$I=B 6?CN>?L)?HM=BB?

CN
<S.O>IF@&IBH#ILMF?<?H

 

0;<F?I@IHN?HNM

,;LN+H?
, QGH[RI3LFW XUHV;, ,
3UHIDFH;9, ,

, 2QO\W KDW LVZ RUW KNQRZ LQJZ KLFKEULQJVXVZ LVGRP 

    :KDW  LV .DKOD"  7UDGLW LRQV  6HFUHW  6FLHQFHV  .QRZOHGJH LV LQKHULW HG P HP RU\  ³ 7KH
)LYH6HQVHV´ , QLW LDW LRQV7KHKXP DQEHLQJLVDUDGLRDSSDUDW XV7KHVRFLHW \RIW KHVLOHQW
RQHV8QFRQGLW LRQDOVFLHQFH2EM HFW LYLW \DQGVXEM HFW LYLW \³ 1HZ/LIH´

, ,  5DW D 5DFH
:KDW LVUDFH"3URFUHDW LRQE\SUR[\*HUP LQDW LQJHQHUJ\, P SUHJQDW LRQRIW KHZRP DQ
-XV SULP DH QRFW LV  *RG DQG UDFH DUH RQH  +HURHV DQG W UDGHUV  $U \DQGRP  &KULVW LDQLW \
DQG%XGGKLVP 7KHQHZ VL[W KUDFHLVEHLQJERUQ5DFH FDXVDOLW \5DW KHQDXDQGUDFH
5DFHFUHDW LRQ&KLQDDQG6Z HGHQ

, , ,  %UHHGLQJRU, QGHFHQF\
5DFHFRQGLW LRQVDFHUW DLQVSLULW 5DFLDOFRQVFLRXVQHVVDQGFKRLFHRIEUHHG6FKRODU
ZDUULRU DQG SHDVDQW  FODVVHV  6HP  +DP  DQG -DSKHW   7KH XJO\ DQG W KH VW URQJ KXP DQ
EHLQJ7KHW KUHHOLIHJRDOV -XVW LFH*DLQ3OHDVXUH7KH.QLJKW VRI(W W DO3DUVLIDODQGW KH
NQLJKW V¶RUGHUV6SLULW XDOUHGHP SW LRQVW DQGVDERYHSK\VLFDOUHOHDVH

, 9 ³ 6DFUHG6SULQJ´ 
=HXVSURFUHDW RULVW KHJRGRIHVVHQFH7KHFKLOGUHQV¶RXW LQJ7KHIRXQGLQJRIFLW LHV
DQG W KH EOHVVHG VSULQJ  0LJUDW LRQV IURP  W KH SROH  7KH +\SHUERUHDQV  .LQJ .UHQRV RI
$W ODQW LV$SROORDQG'HOSKL$U\DQP LJUDW LRQVDOORYHUW KHHDUW K$U\DQ&RVVDFNSHRSOHV

9+XP DQ&UHDW LRQDQG+XP DQ6DFULILFH

     :DOSXUJLV FXOW  DQG W KH 9DON\ULHV  7KH DUW  RI FKRRVLQJ RQHV P DW H  7KH SULP DO FXOW LF
LQVW LW XW LRQVRIW KHDQFLHQW *HUP DQV6RODUUK\W KP VDQGVRODUU LW H.RW LQJVDQG*RW LQJVDV
W ULEDO RIIVSULQJ RI W KH JRGV  7KH ³ JROGHQ´  IOHHFH DQG W KH JULIILQV  *HUP DQLF P \VW HULHV
7KHFXOW LFDVVRFLDW LRQRIW KH6XHEHV7KH³ OD\LQJ LQW R W KH FRIILQ´ , VDDF¶VDQG, SKLJHQLH¶V
VDFULILFH7KHZDQGHUHUV -XLIHV7KH*RW KV W KHJRGV¶IRON7KHVZ DQVDQGW KHODE\ULQW K
7URM DQFDVW OHV/HGDDQGW KHVZ DQ
 

9,  7KH%UHDNW KURXJKRIW KH$U\DQ6SLULW 

$ULVW KHVXQ7KH1RUGLFUHELUW K3OHGJHLQVW HDGRIEHOLHI> *HOREHQVW DW W *ODXEHQ@ 
5H OL JLR UHFRQQHFW LRQ

9, ,  :KDW LVW KH(GGD"

        (GGD  H[LVW LQJ VLQFH W KH EHJLQQLQJ > YRQ HKH GD@   :LGXN LQG DQG .DUO W KH :RUVW 
*RW KLF JRGO\ DQG JRHW LF P DQ  $OOIDW KHU VW DQGV DERYH DOO RW KHU  JRGV  $OO P \W KRORJ\ LV
VXEP HUJHGUHDOL]DW LRQ7KH/DW LQJXHVW 

9, , ,  7KH'HFHSW LRQRIW KH*RGV

7KHJUHDW QHVVRI*HUP DQLFQRQGRJP DW LFFRP SUHKHQVLRQRIW KHGLYLQH+|UELJHU ¶V
GLVFRYHU\DQGW KH(GGLFFUHDW LRQP \W K7KHW ULDGRIJRGV7KHZ RUOGLVFUHDW HGIURP KHDW
DQGFROG:RW DQ:LOLDQG:HK7KHFUHDW LRQRIW KHZ RUOG&KHP LVW U\DQGSK\VLFVLQW KH
(GGD7KHILYH SRLQW HGVW DUDQG9DOKDOOD7KHVHFUHW VRIW KH(GGLFQXP EHUV7KHQH[XVRI
FRVP RVDQGKXP DQEHLQJ

, ; 7KH+LJKDQG+RO\7KUHH
%HFRP LQJEHLQJSDVVLQJ*RG IDW KHUVRQKRO\JKRVW 8UGD :HUGDQGL 6NXOG'HHG
> 7DW @ 7KHRDQG=HR-XKXDQG-X 0DQ=H ED RW )D0D )DW KHUP RW KHU

;2I%RRNVW KDW NLOO%RG\DQG6SLULW 

*RW KV9DQGDOVDQG5RP DQV³ 'HOXVLRQVRIKHDW KHQLGRODW U\´ 7KH2OG7HVW DP HQW 6W 
$XJXVW LQH  7KH W HDFKLQJV RI W KH KHUHW LFV  7KH 2UGHU RI W KH 7HP SODUV  7KH UXOH RI W KH
FKXUFK

;,  7KH6RQRIW KH6XQ
+HZKRVHHNVVKDOOILQGW KHVSLULW 7KHVHYHQJUHDW GHHGVRI-HVXV7KH&KULVW LVW KH
IUDP HZRUNRIW KHZKROHZRUOG7KHGHYLOVSRVVHVVW KHSLJV0D\W KHZKLVSHULQJVRIM XVW
UXQHVVDYHXV

;, ,  3ULP DO9LVLRQ
1RUHOLJLRQVW DQGVKLJKHUW KDQW KHW UXW K7KHQDP HVRI:RW DQ7KHP \VW LFGZHOOVDW
W KHFDUGLQDOSRLQW RIW KHZ RUOG7KUHHSDW KVW KDW OHDGW RW KH1RUW K-HVXVW KH$HVXVIURP
*DOOLFD7KH'UXLGVDQGW KHVRQRIW KHVXQ7KH\HDULVERU QZLW KLQXVDW HYHU\P RP HQW 

;, , ,  7KHROGHU$W ODQW HDQ&KULVW LDQ&KXUFK

7KHKLVW RULFDO$W ODQW LV7KHRULJLQRI&KULVW LDQLW \LQ$W ODQW LV7KHSRSHDQGW KHJUHDW
/DP D  7KH DJH RI W KH FURVV  $VV\ULDQ NLQJV ZLW K W KH ³ , URQ &URVV´   7KH .URGR DOW DU LQ
*RVODU  7KH +DU] ³ KHDUW ´  > KHU]@  RI W KH ZRUOG  ³ 7KHUH OD\ W KH FDVW OH 5RP D W KDW  ZH FDOO
7UR\´ &XOW DQG.XOGHHU³ :KLW H6W HHG´ .QRZ OHGJHDQGM XVW LFH

;, 9 7KH(W HUQDO5HFXUUHQFH
:KDW P HQVDZLQ&KULVW $OO³ VRQVRI*RG´ DUHERUQRQW KHW KRI'HFHP EHU7KH
SRODUP LGQLJKW IDOOVRQW KHW KRI'HFHP EHU7KHVRQDSSHDUVLQW KHVLJQRI9LUJR7KH
5RP DQFUHGRLQLW V, QGLDQZ RUGLQJ7KH(DVW HUEOHVVLQJLVRI*HUP DQLFRULJLQ7KHODP E
DQGW KHODP SRI*RG
 

,;LN0QI
;9 7KH5HYHODW LRQRI*RGLQ1XP EHUV
       7KH JRGV¶ P DQLIHVW DW LRQ LQ VSDFH DQG W LP H  7KH GHYLDW LRQ RI W KH ZRUOG IURP  W KH
VSLULW XDOYHUW LFDO7KHQXP EHU(LJKW FLUFXP VFULEHVDFRVP LFIRUFHILHOG, QW KHEHJLQQLQJ
W KHUHZ DVW KH2QHLHW KHVSLULW 7KH+DJDOODVVSDW LDOVLJQ3OXVDQGP LQXV

;9,  7KH&RVP LF2ULJLQRIW KH5XQHV

7KH³ 0DQGO´ 7KHGDQFHVRI*RGLQW KHOLJKW 7KH5XQHDOSKDEHW RIW KH(GGD7HQ
W KRXVDQG \HDU ROG SDLQW HG SHEEOHV  7KH KRXVH XUQH RI $OED /RQJD  7KH DUFKDHRORJLVW V
DQG W KH U XQHV   7KH FU HDW LY H LP SXOVH DQG W KH DU W  RI W KH EUDFW HDW HV   7KH U XQHV  D
P DW KHP DW LFDOIRUP XOD7KHUXQHLP DJHFRQW HP SODW HGRQW KHHDUW KO\SODQH7KHUXQHVFXW
RXW RIW KHFHOHVW LDOYDXOW 7KHGHYHORSP HQW RIW KHODW LQDOSKDEHW IURP W KHUXQHV*HUP DQ
RUODW LQVFULSW "7KHVL[ SRLQW HGVW DURIUHELUW K7KH&KHRSVS\UDP LGDQGW KHFRQVW UXFW LRQ
RIW KHXQLYHUVH

;9, ,  7KH5XQHVDV6XEW OH(QHUJ\&XUUHQW VLQ6SDFH

&RDUVH P DW W HU DQG VXEW OH P DW W HU  0XVLF DQG DQG W KH VFLHQFH RI W KH IXW XUH  7KH
P HGLHYDO FDW KHGUDOV DQG W KHLU FRORUHG JODVV Z LQGRZ V  6XEW OH P DW W HU HQHUJ\ FXUUHQW
SK\VLFV  0DW HULDOLVP  DQG VSLULW XDOLVP   7KH HIIHFW  RI W KH VXEW OH HQHUJ\ FXUUHQW V RQ W KH
KXP DQERG\

;9, , ,  )URP &U\VW DO> .ULVW  DOO@ W RW KH&RVP LF&KULVW > $OO .ULVW @ 
7KH³ SODW RQLF´ ERGLHV&XEHDQG+DJDOOUXQH&U\VW DOIRUP DW LRQDQGW UDQVIRUP DW LRQ
$OOP DW W HULVFU\VW DOOL]HGVSLULW 7KHJUHHNW HDFKLQJVRIW KHDW RP V7KHFU\VW DOOL]DW LRQ ODZ
RI$OO QDW XUH7KH$OOUDXQH> µ$OUDXQH¶ 0DQGUDNH@  $OO 5XQH

;, ; 7KH5XQHVLQW KH=RGLDF
        7KH FHOHVW LDO YDXOW   :RW DQ LQ W KH SLFW XUH  5XQHKRXVHV  (YHU\ VKDSH LV D UXQH
$VW URORJ\  DV XQHU U LQJ  P DW KHP DW LFV RI W KH KHDYHQV  7Z HOYH $HVLU  RI GLYLQH QDW XU H  7KH
KRRN FURVV> VZDVW LND@ DVFRVP LFEDFNERQH)LQLW HVLJQVDQGLQILQLW HVLJQV7KH³ IRXU IROG´
QDW XUHRIOLIH7KHKXP DQVKDSHDP LUURULP DJHRIW KH]RGLDF 7KHIRXUHOHP HQW V ILUH
DLUZDW HUHDUW K

;; 6W RQH&LUFOHDQG6W RQH&DOHQGDU

       6W DU P DQ DQG VW HHUVP DQ  7KH ([ W HUQVW HLQH  7KH *LHU NHQ 0DQRU DV ³$VW RUQ KROW HU´
LH³ VW DUNHHSHU ´2OGDVW URQRP LFDOVLW HV7KH³ 6W RQHGDQFHRI%W ]RZ´ &DOHQGDUVW RQHV
 DJR  7KH DQFLHQW  +DQQRYHUDQ SHUFK > P HDVXULQJ XQLW @   7KH HQJOLVK ³ TXDUW HU ´  DV
ROGHVW P HDVXULQJXQLW 7KHVW RQHFDOHQGDUDW 2GU\W KHVW RQHFLUFOHVRI6W RQHKHQJHDQG
$YHEXU\2VW HQGRUI:HVW HQGRUI1RUGHQGRUI

;;,  3ULP DO/DQJXDJH

/DQJXDJH DV VSLULW XDO DFW  RI ELUW K  /DQJXDJH LQ W KH 7ULDG  &UHDW LRQ DFW LRQ DQG
SDVVLQJ*HUP DQDVNH\W RW KHSULP DOURRW ODQJXDJH7KHW ULSDUW LW HVW UXFW XUHRIW KHURRW
ZRUGV7KHODZRISRODULW \LQODQJXDJH7KHEXLOGLQJRI%DE\ORQ¶VW RZHU5RP HW KHVSDFH
DQGIUDP HRIW KHROGFLW \RIW KHJRGV
 

;;, ,  5XQH %OHVVLQJ

7KHUXQHVDVDP HDQVRIUHYHODW LRQ7KHUXQHVDVFHOOVRISULP DOW KRXJKW 7KHUXQHV
DVSRZHUVKDSHVRIFRVP LFFXUUHQW V7KHQXP HURORJLFDODQGUXQLFJUDVSLQJRIW KHODZVRI
QDW XUH(GGD&DEDODDQG7DURW 

;;, , ,  7KH5XQH)XW KRUNLQ, QGLYLGXDO3UHVHQW DW LRQV

)D IH IHRUXQHOHW W HU)QXP HULFDOYDOXH8UUXQHOHW W HU8QXP HULFDOYDOXH
7KRUQ W KXUV UXQH OHW W HU 7K ' QXP HULFDO YDOXH   2V DV DVN UXQH DQG 2W KLO 2GDO $GHO
> $GHO DULVW RFUDF\RIDQFLHQW VW RFN@ OHW W HU2QXP HULFDOYDOXH/XUV2VDQG2W KLOUXQH
OHW W HU 2 QXP HULFDO YDOXH   5LW  UHLW K UDG URG UXQH OHW W HU 5 QXP EHU   .DXQ NRQ NXQ
NRQD NLHQUXQHOHW W HU.QXP EHU1RW  QLW  QDXW UXQHOHW W HU1QXP EHU, V LFH> (LV@ 
LURQ> (LVHQ@  , > , FK@ UXQHOHW W HU, QXP EHU7KHQLQHZ RRGV+YLO +Z HHOUXQH+YLO
DQG+HLO +DQG6DYLRU> +HLODQG@ 7KH, UP LQVXO6NDODDQG6NDOLQJV7KH=LHJHQKDLQ
FDQHV$U RU HU UDUXQHOHW W HU$QXP EHU$UP DQQ +HUP DQQ$U , $U$U EHXW H²$U
EHLW²$U EHW HQ> DUEHLW Z RUNEHW HQ W RSUD\@ 6RO VDO VXO VLJUXQHOHW W HU6QXP EHU
7\U W XU W RU W UL W UH W HU ]HUUXQHOHW W HU7QXP EHU8U 6DO +HLP DQFLHQW KHDOLQJSODFH
7KHKDP P HURI7KRU%DU ELUN EM |UN ERUUXQHOHW W HU%QXP EHU3DLULQJDQGW KH%DU
UXQH EDU EDU EDU  7KH W KRXJKW  RI UHELUW K  /DI ODJX O|J ODXJ UXQH OHW W HU / QXP EHU 
'R OLYH  7ZR OLYHV > 7XH /HEHQ  =ZHL /HEHQ@   2UORJ  RULJLQDO FLUFXP VW DQFH > 8U /DJH@ 
7KH/LRQFRDW RIDUP VDFRDW RIDUP VVLJQLI\LQJOLIH0DQ P RQ P DUXQHOHW W HU0QXP EHU
0RRQDQGP DQ<U (UU> , UU@  HXU <HZ > (LEH@  : \EHUXQHOHW W HU<QXP EHU(K HKH
HKXUXQHOHW W HU(QXP EHU0DUULDJH> (KH@ DP RQJW KHDQFLHQW *HUP DQV*LERU JL JH
JLID JHD JHRUXQHOHW W HU*QXP EHU7KH7RZHU> 'ROGHU@ RI5HLFKHQZHLHU

;;, 9 +DJ$OO $OO +DJ

+DJDO UXQH RI KHDOLQJ DQG VDOYDW LRQ  +DOJD KRO\  *DOJD *LOJ OLO\  OHW W HU +
QXP EHU   7KH P DVW HUV RI ZRUOGV DQG ZRUNV  :RRG FKXUFKHV DQG W KH DJH RI ZRRG
7HP SHUDQG7HP SODUV.ULVW FUHDW HGW KHDQFLHQW ZRUOG$UD +DU L+DUL +DULVW RV &KDULVW RV
&DO 9D 5L  -HVXV RI 1D]DUHW K  (O (OL RU HO 6KDGGDL  7LH   $JDO +DJDOO  7KH W ULXQH
3\W KDJRUDV  , FKW K\V  $UL 8VW H 1]DUHW K  5DW D UDFH  *RW KV DQG -RW KV  *DOJD +DOJD
&KULVP RQ &KLURQ.LQJ$UW XV¶URXQGW DEOH7KHP DW KHP DW LFDOJUDLO, QUL , QGUL , QGUD+DJ
$OODQGW KHFURVVRIUD\V7KHDOOP XUP XULQJ> $OO 5DXQH@ 7KHFDW DFRP EVH[LVW ORQJEHIRUH
W KHDGYHQW RI&KULVW LDQLW \1UQEHUJ¶V:HLE$DUFRDW RIDUP V5XQLFGLYLQDW LRQ

3DUW 7KUHH

;;9 5XQH0DJLFLQW KH(GGD

:RW DQ¶V  SDUW  UXQH URZ LV W KH RULJLQDO RQH  7KH UXQH URZ HP HUJHV IURP  W KH
SULP RUGLDOVLJQRIW KH+DJ $OO7KH6JUGULIXP DO.QRZ HVW W KRXKRZ W RZ ULW HNQRZ HVW KRZ
W R UHDG"  )URP  W KH ³ 6NLUQLVP DO´   5XQH P DJLF LQ W KH *XGUXQDUNYLW KD , ,  (W ]HO¶V LQYLW DW LRQ
Z LW K ³ Z URQJO\ FDUYHG´  UXQHV  5XQHV DV UHP HGLHV DJDLQVW  LOOQHVV  7KH UXQHV DV W KH ODVW
LQLW LDW LRQIRUW KH\RXQJ³ .|QQLQJ´ > NLQJ@ *UHW W LU ¶VIDOOW KU RXJKUXQHP DJLF

;;9,  7KH$%&
7KHILYHYRZHOVDQGW KHILYH SRLQW HGVW DUULJKW DQGOHIW 
 

;;9, ,  7KH³ 2XU)DW KHU:KR$UW LQ+HDYHQ´ 3UD\HUD5XQH5RZ :KLVSHU

7KH³ 2XU)DW KHU ´ LQW KHUXQHURZV7KH³ 0RQRJUDP RI&KULVW ´ RQW KHW KUHHUXQH
I LQ GV   7K H Q DP HV RI  W K H    U X Q HV JLY H W K H N H\  Z RU GV RI  W K H ³ 2X U  )DW K HU ´   7K H
FRUUHVSRQGHQFHV RI W KH LQGLYLGXDO HQW UHDW LHV W R RXU ERG\ SDUW V   7KH ILUVW  VHYHQ UXQHV
P DUNW KHVHYHQGD\VRIFUHDW LRQ7KHQH[W VHYHQUXQHVVLJQLI\W KH³$UW LFOHV´ RIIDLW K7KH
UXQHVDUH7\UDQG7RUGRRUDQGJDW H> ³ 7UXQG7RU ´ @ W RDOOUHDOL]DW LRQ

;;9, , ,  ³ +DQV+HJHOOLQ´ DP \VW HULRXVLQVFULSW LRQ 'LQNHOVEKO

7KH³ *HUP DQ0DQ´ LQW KHODQJXDJHRIW KHFDUSHQW HUV¶JXLOGV5RODQG¶VEURW KHUV
DQG W KHLU FRQFHDOP HQW   $  FRXQW  > 0DQGHO@  RI HJJV DQG W KH 0DQ UXQH  7KH P DJLF
VTXDUHDQGW KHQXP EHU³ ILIW HHQ´ +DQV+HJHOOLQEHFRP HV+DQV+DJDOO

;;, ; $&RDW RI$UP V5HDGLQJXVLQJW KHH[DP SOHRI'LQNHOVEKO 

'LQNHOV EKORU'LQNHO VSLHO"7KHW ULSOH%DUUXQH7KH'LQNHO %DXHU> IDUP HU@ LQ
W KH7KLQJ %DXH

;;; $OEUHFKW 'UHUW KH$UP DQH

9DOXHRUQRQYDOXHRILQW HQW LRQLVDOVRDGHFLGLQJIDFW RULQW KHDUW V7KHIXQGDP HQW DO
N QRZ OHGJH W KDW  Z DV JXDU GHG LQ W KH VHFU HW  VRFLHW LHV  0HOHQFROLD  .LQJ RI W KH EHOOV
SXULILFDW LRQZ KRLVW KHDQJHO"3ULP DU\NQRZ OHGJHUHW XUQVLW VSULP RUGLDOM XGJHP HQW > 8U
7HLO@ ULJKW DQGOHIW 7KHULJKW IRRW DQGW KHODVW IRRW 6\ULQJHDQGP HW DEROLVP 7KHEORFN
RIVW RQHW UDQVIRUP VLQW RDGRXEOHSULVP DW LFEORFNZ LW KW KHQXP HULFDOYDOXHRIW KHJUDLO1R
LP P HGLDW HW UDQVLW LRQIURP DQLP DOW RP DQ7KHM XGJHP HQW RIW KHDUW VFKRODUV7KHNH\W R
XQGHUVW DQGLQJDZ KROHFXOW XUHDQGLW VW LP H

;;;,  $)HZ([DP SOHVRI$UP DQLF5XQH.QRZOHGJH

7KHUXQHVRI*RVODU, FHODQGLFUXQHVW DYHFDOHQGDU7KH6W RUNV7RZHU> 6W RUFKHQW XUP @
LQ*HUQVEDFK$ERDUVKHDGRQW KHJDW HRI6W 0DU\¶VFKXUFKLQ1HXEUDQGHQEXUJ5XQ|
W KHUXQHLVODQG$ERXW W KHLQKDELW DQW VRIW KHUXQHLVODQG
 

0B?*OG?LC=/SMN?GCHNBCM0L;HMF;NCIH
7KHQXP EHULQJRIW KH(QJOLVKSDJHVLVHVVHQW LDOO\W KHVDP HDVW KHQXP EHULQJRIW KH
*HUP DQSDJHV+RZHYHUDVDQLQFHQW LYHIRUW KHVW XGHQW W RLP P HUVHKLP  RUKHUVHOI
LQW R W KH FUHDW LYH GLP HQVLRQV RI W KH $UP DQHQ )XW KRUN W KH QXP EHU V DUH W UDQVODW HG
LQW R W KHLU 5XQH HTXLYDOHQW V RI D QXP HULF V\VW HP  ZLW K W KH EDVH  QXP EHU RI W KH
)XW KRUN

([DPSOHV

   HW F       ³ ´

 ³ ´  [  LQW KHGHFLP DOV\VW HP

 ³ ´  [[ 

 ³   ´  [[ [  [ [  

 

.O>IF@&IBH#ILMF?<?H
     
0B?AL?;NFCABNCMMNCFFMBCHCHA@ILOM
H>;NHCABNNB?MN;LM;L?ACPCHA=IHMIF;NCIH
3?Q;H>?LDIS@OFFS;H>Q?Q;H>?LB;JJCFS
0B?MJF?H>ILI@NB?OHCP?LM?CHIOL@;=?M

$IHZP RQW KVEHIRUH5XGROI-RKQ*RUVOHEHQZURW HGRZQW KHVHOLQHV

KHKDGLQTXLUHGRQDVLP SOHSRVW FDUGLQDYHU\IHZOLQHVZKHW KHUP \
SXEOLVKLQJ KRXVH ZRXOG EH LQW HUHVW HG LQ D EDVLF ZRUN DERXW  UXQHV
W KDW ZRXOGHTXDOO\GHDOZLW KFXOW XUDODQGUHOLJLRXVTXHVW LRQVDVZHOO
DVW RSURSRVHDVROXW LRQIRUW KHP $IW HUDQDQVZHULQW KHDIILUP DW LYH
D YLVLW  LQ 'LQNHOVEKO IROORZHG VRRQ ZKHUH ,  EHFDP H DFTXDLQW HG
ZLW K KLV ZRUN DQG ,  JRW  W R NQRZ D SHUVRQ RI VXFK D GHSW K DQG
H[SDQVHRIW KRXJKW VW KDW , GHFLGHGW RSXEOLVKKLVERRNRQZKLFKKH
KDG ZRUNHG GXULQJ W KH SUHYLRXV W ZHQW \ \HDUV  0RUH W KDQ D \HDU
KDYHSDVVHGVLQFHDQGGXULQJW KLVW LP H*RUVOHEHQSXW DOOKLVKHDUW
EORRGLQW RSXW W LQJW KHODVW SHUIHFW LRQVLQW RKLVOLIH¶VZRUN6LQFHW KH
ZDU*RUVOHEHQVXIIHUHGDQLOOQHVVRIW KHKHDUW EXW KLVP LQGVHHP HG
W RHQW LUHO\GRP LQDW HKLVERG\, QGHIDW LJDEO\KHVXSSOHP HQW HGDQG
LP SURYHGKLVZRUNXQW LOW KHODVW VKHHW ZDVP DLOHGW RXVUHDG\ W REH
SULQW HG7KHQKLVKHDUW VW RSSHGXQH[SHFW HGO\ SHUKDSVDUHVXOW RI
H[HUW LRQRURIEHLQJRYHUM R\HGDERXW KDYLQJILQLVKHGKLVZRUN":KR
KDGW KHRSSRUW XQLW \W RNQRZ*RUVOHEHQLVDZDUHW KDW DVSHFLDOSHUVRQ
KDVOHIW XVZKRP ZHP RXUQEXW ZKRP ZHJLYHRXUGHHSHVW W KDQNV
IRU W KH OLW HUDU\ P RQXP HQW  W KDW  KH KDG HVW DEOLVKHG IRU KLP VHOI Z LW K
KLV ZRUN  D ZRUN W KDW  KH GLG QRW  KDYH W KH RSSRUW XQLW \ W R VHH LQ LW V
FRP SOHW HGIRUP 
'U+HUP DQQYRQ+DVH
L )D.RHKOHU $P HODQJ*P E+
 

,L?@;=?
2QHW KLQJLVFOHDU 7REHD*UHHNRQHKDGW REHDFTXDLQW HGZLW KW KH
VSLULW DQGLQW HOOHFW RIKLVIRONRQHKDGW RNQRZW KHKLVW RU\RIW KHJRGV
DQG RI W KH KHU RHV W KDW  OLYHG LQ W LP HV RI \RU H DQG RQH KDG W R EH
DFTXDLQW HG ZLW K W KH DQFLHQW  ODQJXDJH RI +RP HU  7KLV ZDV HVSHFLDOO\
LP SRUW DQW  IRU DQ\ IRUHLJQHU ZKR ZDV QRW  ERUQ LQW R W KH *UHHN SHRSOH
P RUHVRW KDQIRUW KHQDW LYH*UHHN7KH*UHHNVZHUHDIRONW KDW GRHV
QRW H[LVW DQ\P RUHW RGD\VLQFHLW VEORRGKDVUXQGU\ORQJW LP HDJR$V
IRUHLJQHUV W KH *HUP DQ  +XP DQLVW V DW W HP SW HG W R DGDSW  W R DQG OLYH
W KH DQFLHQW  *UHHN ORUH QRW  NQRZLQJ HYHQ QRW  KDYLQJ W KH VOLJKW HVW
LGHDW KDW W KH*UHHNZHUHEXW DQRIIVKRRW RIW KHJUHDW 8U W ULEH  RIW KH
$U\DQVLQIDFW W KDW W KHEORVVRP RIW KLVFRXQW U\ *UHHFH ZDV1RUGLF
EOXH H\HGDQGEORQG1LHW ]VFKHZDVW KHILUVW SHUVRQZKRKDVSHUFHLYHG
*UHHNORUHZLW KDFOHDUYLVLRQDV*UHHNZLW KRXW SUH FRQFHLYHGSUHM XGLFHV
RIXQLYHUVLW \ SKLORORJLVW V, QIDFW ZKHUHYHUW KLQJVZHUHQRW FRP SOHW HO\
FOHDUW RKLP KLVLQW XLW LRQJRW W KHULJKW LGHDZLW KRXW IDLO

$FFRUGLQJ W R RXU LQVLJKW  W R VHHN W KH FRXQW U\ RI W KH *UHHNV ZLW K W KH
VRXO P HDQV W KHUHIRUH IRU W KH *HUP DQ  W R VHDUFK IRU KLV RZQ 6HOI KLV
W UXHLQGLYLGXDOLW \DQGW RXQFRQVFLRXVO\ORRNIRULW LQW KH*UHHFHRIW KH
SDVW   7KLV LV VR EHFDXVH RXU ORQJLQJ ZRXOG QHYHU KDYH IRFXVHG RQ
VRP HW KLQJ HOVH VRP HW KLQJ W UXO\ IRUHLJQ  LW  QHYHU ZRXOG KDYH IDOOHQ
YLFW LP W RVXFKGHFHSW LRQ2XW RIW KLVLQVLJKW DQGIDFW VKRXOGDULVHW KH
FRP SHOOLQJFRQFOXVLRQW RVHHNW KHRULJLQDOFRXQW U\RIW KH*UHHN VLQW KH
$U\DQ1RUW K7KLVLVW KHFRXQW U\RIW KH*UHHNJRG$SROORW KHJRG3RO
W KH+\SHUERUHDQ  LQW KHYLFLQLW \RIW KHSROHHVSHFLDOO\VLQFHLW LVFHUW DLQO\
W KH8U KRP HODQG  KLVKRP HODQGDQGLQDGGLW LRQW RW KDW W KHFUDGOHRI
W KH$U\DQUDFH, QYLHZRIW KHVHIDFW VVKRXOGW KHUHQRW EHSXW P RUH
HP SKDVLVLQRXUVFKRROVDQGXQLYHUVLW LHVW KDW LQRUGHUW ROHDU QDQGW R
XQGHUVW DQG W UXH *UHHN QHVV EDVHG RQ RXU RZQ GHHSHVW  NLQVKLS ZH
VKRXOG ILUVW  LP P HUVH RXUVHOYHV LQW R RXU FRP P RQ $U\DQ 1RUGLF SDVW "
7KDW ZHVKRXOGLP P HUVHRXUVHOYHVLQW RRXUDQFLHQW *HUP DQLFODQJXDJHV
LQW R RXU DQFLHQW  UHOLJLRQ ZKLFK LV 8U UHOLJLRQ VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V DQG W R
NQRZW KH(GGDDW OHDVW DVZHOODV+RP HU ¶VZRUN"


8U W ULEH RULJLQDOW ULEHURRW  W ULEHW ULEHDW W KHURRW  RIDOO$U\DQIRONV , DP 
XVLQJW KHZ RUG³ XU´ Z KHQHYHUVXFKP HDQLQJLVLQGLFDW HG

3HRSOHOLYLQJLQW KH1RUW K

VHH  DERYH RULJLQDOKRP HODQGURRW  KRP HODQG
 

7KHURRW RIHDFKHGXFDW LRQP XVW EHW KHDGYDQFHP HQW RIW KHLQGLY LGXDOW RDZKROH
KXP DQ EHLQJ DQG )RON FRP SDQLRQ   DQG ZLW K W KLV W KH HGXFDW LRQ RI DOO W RZDUGV D
IRONLVKZKROH7RHGXFDW HDQGW RIRUP D\RXQJSHUVRQP HDQVW RSURYLGHKLP ZLW K
W KHKHOSW KDW DOORZVKLP W RXVHHIIHFW LYHO\KLVRUKHULQQDW HFDSDELOLW LHVDQGW DOHQW V
:H P HDVXUH W KH H[FHOOHQFH RI W KDW  ZKLFK ZDV DFTXLUHG E\ W KH H[FHOOHQFH RI W KH
UHVXOW VDFKLHYHGE\W KHSHUVRQ KRZKHFRXOGXVHLW IRUKLVRZ QEHQHILW DQGIRUW KH
ZHOO EHLQJ RI W KH IRON  2QO\ W KDW  ZKLFK LV W UXO\ RXU RZQ FDQ EH RI EHQHILW  W R XV
2XU RZQ SDVW  LQ KLVW RU\ RXU UHOLJLRQ ODQJXDJH DUW V DQG FXOW XUH QHHG W R EH W KH
P DLQ HP SKDVLV RI RXU HGXFDW LRQ  1RERG\ EHFRP HV ULFKHU ZKHQ ERU URZLQJ IURP
W KHQHLJKERU1RKXP DQEHLQJFDQLJQRUHKLVRUKHURULJLQDQGZKRFDQQRW GUDZ
HQHUJ\ DQG QRXULVKP HQW  IURP  W KLV RULJLQ DQG LW V URRW V ZLOO UHP DLQ D VSLULW XDO
SUROHW DULDQIRUJRRG:KRHYHULVLJQRUDQW RIZKHUHKHFRP HVIU RP LVLJQRUDQW RI
ZKHUHKHLVDQGHYHQP RUHLJQRUDQW RIZKHUHKHLVJRLQJ

7KH SULQFLSOHV RI HGXFDW LRQ RXJKW  W R EH RIIHUHG W R W KH SHRSOH XQLIRUP O\  7KH
SLHFHZRUNRIRXUSUHVHQW LVUHVXOW RIW KHHQW LUHO\GLIIHUHQW VRP HW LP HVFRQW UDGLFW LQJ
SULQFLSOHV RI HGXFDW LRQ RI W KH YDULRXV FODVVHV ZKLFK GR QRW  DOORZ VRFLDO EULGJHV
EHW ZHHQHDFKRW KHU2QO\FRP P RQNQRZOHGJHFRP P RQZLVGRP FUHDW HVRQHQHVV
RI W KH IRON  8QLILHG :HOW DQVFKDXXQJ DQG XQLILHG YLHZ RI W KH 'LYLQH LV ZKDW  W KH
*HUP DQLVP LVVLQJLQRUGHUW RKDYHDOLIHILOOHGZLW KVW UHQJW KZHOO EHLQJDQG8QLW \
7KHGLIIHUHQFHRIW KHQDW XUHRIVNLOOVLW VHOIFDQEHGHQRP LQDW RUIRUGLIIHUHQFHVLQ
VRFLDODQGP HQW DOVW UDW DRIW KHSRSXODW LRQ

)URP W KHVHEDVLFSULQFLSOHVZHFDQGHULYHQDW XUDOO\DQGHIIRUW OHVVO\W KHRXW OLQHIRU

DFRP LQJLW LQHUDU\RIOLIH

6KRXOGZHQRZEHFDXVHRIRXUHP SKDVLVRQW KHKRP HODQGFRQVLGHUIRUQXOODQG

YRLGHYHU\W KLQJW KDW KDYHJLYHQXV*UHHFH$VLDDQG5RP HDQGVW LOOZLOOJLYHXV"
&HUW DLQO\QRW EXW ZHKDYHW ROHDUQDERXW RXURZQSDVW :HKDYHW ROHDUQDERXW
W KHFXOW XUHUHOLJLRQDQGODQJXDJHRIRXUDQFHVW RUVDQGZHVKRXOGEHP RUHIDP LOLDU
ZLW KW KDW W KDQZLW KIRUHLJQW KLQJVIURP IDUDZD\FRXQW ULHV(YHQLIRXURZQIRONLVK
EDFNJURXQGZDVDQXQLP SRUW DQW DQGSRRURQHZKLFKLW FHUW DLQO\LVQRW VLQFHRXU
KRP HODQGDQGRXUUDFHDUHW KHFUDGOHRIDOOFXOW XUHHYHQW KHQ ZHVKRXOGORYHLW
DQG JLYH LW  SUHIHUHQFH RYHU HYHU\W KLQJ W KDW  LV IRUHLJQ VLP SO\ EHFDXVH LW  LV RXU
YHU\RZQ $QGDVORQJDVZHFDQQRW P XVW HURXUZLOOW RVXFKFRXUDJHRIRXUVRXO
DQGRIRXUEORRGDZLOOZKLFKW UXO\NQLJKW VXVDQGFRXOGP DNHXVW REHW KHP RVW
QREOHIRONRIW KH(DUW KW KLVORQJZHZLOOUHP DLQXSVW DUW VLQRXURZQH\HVDQGDOVR
LQW KHH\HVRIRW KHUV


, DP UHIUDLQLQJIURP W KH³ FRUUHFW ´ W UDQVODW LRQRI³ 9RONVJHQRVVH´ ZKLFKZRXOGP HDQ³ IRON
FRP UDGH´ 
 

:HDOOFDQJRRQO\RQHURDG W KHURDGEDFNW RRXUVHOYHV:HVW HSRXW RIW KHGRRU

RI RXU IDW KHU KRXVH DQG ZH EHOLHYH W R JR D VW UDLJKW  DQG LQILQLW H URDG  , Q IDFW 
GHSHQGLQJRQRXUFDSDELOLW LHVZHJRRQO\DODUJHURUVP DOOHUFLUFOHLQRXUM RXUQH\
DQG RQH GD\ ZH ZLOO UHW XUQ W R RXU RULJLQ ZLW KRXW  DFW XDOO\ ZDQW LQJ W R GR VR  :H
EHFDP HVW UDQJHUVLQRXURZQZRUOG7KHUHDVRQIRUW KDW LVW KDW ZHGRQRW NQRZ
DQ\W KLQJ DQ\P RUH RI W KDW  ZKLFK LV RXU YHU\ RZQ RI RXU RULJLQ DQG RXU VSHFLDO
EHLQJ 7KLV LV VR EHFDXVH IRU DERXW  D W KRXVDQG \HDUV SRVVLEO\  HYHQ ORQJHU ZH
KDYHQRORQJHUIHGW KHVW UHDP  EHGRIRXUOLIHZLW KRXURZQVSLU LW XDODQGSK\VLFDO
VRXUFHV DQGDVDFRQVHTXHQFHLW GULHGXSYHU\P XFKOLNHDULYHUW KDW LVFDXJKW
DQGGHYLDW HGFORVHW RLW VVRXUFH5HW XUQLQJKRP HUHW XUQLQJW RZLW KLQW KHUHIRUH
VKRXOGEHRXUVORJDQ 7REHP DVW HUZKRLVLQXQGLVSXW DEOHFRQW URORIW KDW ZKLFKLV
RXURZQLVW KHUHTXLUHP HQW  7KLVERRNZLOOFRQW ULEXW HW RSURYLGHDYLHZEDFNW R
ZKDW  LV EHORQJLQJ W R XV W R RXU RZQ SHFXOLDU FKDUDFW HULVW LFV  7KLV VLJQLILHV RXU
SRVLW LRQW KDW ZHKXP DQVRIW RGD\GHVFHQGHQW VW KDW ZHDUHKDYHW RW DNHUHJDUGLQJ
W KH(GGDDQGLW VW UDGLW LRQV

(DFKRIXVZKRVW LOOKDVDGHVLUHIRULQVLJKW VDQGNQRZOHGJHDQGZKRLVKRP HVLFN

IRUW KHEHVW RIKLVQDW XUHKDVDKRO\GXW \W RLP P HUVHKLP VHOILQW RW KHZRUOGRIRXU
DQFHVW RUV, W LVD:HOW DQVFKDXXQJZKLFKIROORZLQJW KHODZRIOLIHLW VHOILVQHFHVVDULO\
DOVRRXURZQ

7KHQ W RR DUH IXOILOOHG W KH W ZR ³ TXDW UDLQV´  RI W KH VHHU 0LFKHO 1RVW UDGDP XV OLNH
DOUHDG\DJRRGKXQGUHGRIKLVSUHGLFW LRQVW KDW KHVW DUW HGZLW KW KH\HDU

, Q*HUP DQ\GLIIHUHQW JURXSVZLOOHP HUJH

:KRDUHDSSURDFKLQJW KHM R\IXOSDJDQUHOLJLRQ
'XULQJW KLVW LP HW KHVW DW HZLOOEHSUHVVHG
7RLQFUHDVHW D[HVW RW KHW HQW KSDUW RIW KHLQFRP H

$QHZUHOLJLRXVP RYHP HQW ZLOOVKLQH

W KDW GHVSLVHVJROGKRQRUVZHDOW KDQGGHDW K
, W ZLOOUHDFKEH\RQGW KH*HUP DQP RXQW DLQV
ILQGVXSSRUW P HDQVRISUHVVXUHDQGIROORZLQJDIDU

7KH8U ZRUGLW VHOIZLOOP RYHW KHVXEVW DQFH

7KDW HQFRP SDVVHVVN\DQGHDUW K2FFXOW JROGIORZVIURP P \VW LFDOP LON
%RG\VRXODQGVSLULW IHHOW KHEOHVVLQJRIRP QLSRW HQFH
7KDW LVDVYDOLGRQ(DUW KDVLW LVLQKHDYHQ

7KH P RYHP HQW  ZLOO FRP H RYHU XV OLNH D UDYDJLQJ P RXQW DLQ VW UHDP  DQG LW  ZLOO
HQJXOIKXP DQLW \ZLW KKRUURUDQGHQW KXVLDVP $FW LQJLQW KHGHSW KLW ZLOOGHFLVLYHO\
GHW HUP LQHIXW XUHGHYHORSP HQW 
 

7KHW KRXJKW VSXW IRUZDUGLQW KLVERRNDUHW KHUHVXOW RIP \ZRUN LQJZLW KW KHEDVLF
TXHVW LRQVRIOLIHW KDW ODVW HGIRU\HDUVQDP HO\ZLW KUDFHDQGUHOLJLRQE\ZKLFK
H[SHULHQFHVW KHVSLULW XDODQGSK\VLFDOOLYHVRIKXP DQNLQGDUHLQIOXHQFHGGHFLVLYHO\

, W VHHP HGW RP HW KDW W KHUXQ RII W KHP LOOZRUOG YLHZDOP RVW W RW DOO\LJQRUHVW KHVH
W ZREDVLFIDFW RUV HVSHFLDOO\W KHSDVW RIW KHUDFHW KDW ZDVOHDGLQJW KH(DUW KVLQFH
W LP HLP P HP RULDO

, JRW W RNQRZW KH(GGDUHODW LYHO\ODW HEHFDXVHXSW RTXLW HUHFHQW O\LQRXUVFKRROV

W KHUHZDVQRP HQW LRQRILW DW DOO, W VFRQW HQW W KDW LVEUHDW KLQJW KHDLURIW LP HVORQJ
SDVW  DQG RI W KH 8U VSLULW  ZKLFK ,  KDG D KXQFK H[LVW HG EHKLQG W KH ZRUGLQJ RI
LQVXIILFLHQW DQGERW FKHG XSW UDQVODW LRQVFDXVHGDEXUQLQJGHVLUHZLW KLQP \VHOIW R
JHW W RNQRZW KH8U W H[W P \VHOIDQG, EHJDQW RW UDQVODW HRQP \RZQW KLVP \VW HULRXV
ZRUNIURP W KH2OG1RUVHLQW R*HUP DQDOW KRXJKZLW KRXW ³ H[SHUW ´ SUHSDUDW LRQ,
UHDG W KLV ODQJXDJH W KDW  LV VR FORVH NLQ W R W KH *HUP DQ ODQJXDJH DQG ,  W KHUHIRUH
SHQHW UDW HGLW VP HDQLQJZLW KHDVH6RRQ, UHFRJQL]HGW KDW W KHDJHRIW KLVODQJXDJH
RQH RI ZKRVH FKDUDFW HULVW LFV LV GRXEOH HYHQ W ULSOH DQG P XOW LSOH P HDQLQJ RI W KDW
ZKLFK LV H[SUHVVHG E\ LW  SXW  W KH (GGD LQ W KH IRUHIURQW  EHVLGHV W KH 9HGDV W KH
ZULW LQJV RI W KH 0D\DV W KH ']\DQ DQG VRP H SDUW V RI W KH 2OG 7HVW DP HQW  P RVW O\
EHFDXVHRIW KHYDOXHRILW VW UDGLW LRQVDQGP HP RULHVRIGD\VRI \RUH+RZHYHU,
ZDVDOVRDZDUHW KDW W KHW LP HIRUP HW RP DVW HUW KLVZRUNZLW KLW VP DQ\DQGYDULHG
ZD\VRILGLRP DW LFIRUP VKDVQRW DUULYHG\HW , ZDVVDW LVILHGW RJLYHDW UDQVODW LRQRI
WKHP RUHREYLRXVP HDQLQJVDVGLGDOOP \SUHGHFHVVRUVZLWKWKHGLIIHUHQFHKRZHYHU
W KDW  ,  LQW HQGHG W R FUHDW H D UHDGDEOH W UDQVODW LRQ ZLW KRXW  SKLORORJLFDO DGGHQGD
:LW KRXW  NQRZOHGJH RI W KH VHFUHW  ODQJXDJH RI W KH (GGD VXFK DGGHQGD DUH E\
QHFHVVLW \LQVXIILFLHQW HYHQP LVOHDGLQJ%\QRP HDQVGR, QRW DFNQRZOHGJHRUW KH
HIIRUW V RI W ZR G\QDVW LHV RI VFLHQW LVW V VLQFH *ULP P  ZKR ZHUH GHGLFDW HG W R W KH
(GGD+RZHYHUW KHLUHIIRUW VZHUHLQYDLQP RVW RIW KHW LP HVLQFHW KH\ZDQW HGW R
P HDVXU H W KH FRVP LF P HDQLQJ HVRW HU LF DQG H[RW HU LF Z LW KLQ W KHLU  SKLORORJLFDO
EDFNJURXQGDQGW KHUHIRUHW KH\QDW XUDOO\P DQDJHGW RJUDVSRQO\DVP DOOVHFW LRQRI
W KHZKROHSLFW XUH

, QW KLVFRQW H[W , P HQW LRQW KH(GGDZLW KVXFKHP SKDVLVEHFDXVHLW SURYLGHGP H
ZLW KW KHEDVLVIRUW KHYLHZVW KDW , DP W U\LQJW RLP SDUW W RDODUJHUSXEOLFZLW KW KLV
ERRN7KH(GGDLVW KHZD\DQGW KHJRDOIRUDQ\SHUVRQZKRZDQW VW RHVW DEOLVKW KH
VKRUW HVW GLVW DQFHLHW KHVW UDLJKW OLQHRIVRXODQGVSLULW EHW ZHHQSDVW DQGIXW XUH
:KRHYHU OLP LW V KLP VHOI W R D YLHZ RI D QDUURZ HQYLURQP HQW  RI KLV SUHVHQW  VHHV
LQGHHGYHU\OLW W OH+HLVOLNHDW LUHGDQGZRUQ RXW KRUVHW KDW RQP DUNHW GD\W XUQV
DW LQ\P HUU\ JR URXQGIRUFKLOGUHQLQH[W UHP HO\QDUURZFLUFOHV

6W LOODOOUHVHDUFKHUVRIW KHSDVW RIRXUUDFHZHUHFDXJKW XSLQW KHHUURQHRXVYLHZ

RI LW V ULVH LQ W KH (DVW  W KH VXSSRVHG SODFH RI DOO KXP DQ HYROXW LRQ  6W LOO QRERG\
GDUHGW RFRP HW RUHDFKW KHFRQFOXVLRQIURP W KHVXSHULRULW \RIW RGD\¶V1RUW KDQG
FRQVHTXHQW O\W KHVXSHULRULW \RILW VDQFLHQW LQKDELW DQW V QDP HO\ W RGHULYHW KHRULJLQ
RIDOOFXOW XUHIURP W KH³ FRXQW U\RIW KH+\SHUERUHDQV´  UHJDUGOHVVRIW KHIDFW W KDW
W KH W KUHDG RI W KHVH W UDGLW LRQV ZDV QHYHU FRP SOHW HO\ LQW HUUXSW HG  7KHUH KDYH
DOZD\VEHHQEDVLFSULQFLSOHVW KHNQRZOHGJHRIZKLFKLVILUVW DQGIRUHP RVW QHFHVVDU\
 

LI RQH ZDQW V W R ZULW H DERXW  KLVW RU\ RI KXP DQLW \  %HORZ \RX ILQG W KHVH SRLQW V LQ
EULHIDQGFRQFLVHGHVFULSW LRQV

 7KHP HDVXUHRIYDOXHRIW KHFXOW XUHRIDUDFHLHW KHKHLJKW RILW V8U FXOW LV

QRW W KHOHYHORILW VFLYLOL]DW LRQ QDP HO\LW VW HFKQLFDODFKLHYHP HQW VDQGSHUIHFW LRQV
ZKLFKDUHW KHFDXVHRIVRP HP HUFDQW LOH SDUDVLW LF³ W LP HVRIEORRP ´7KHP HDVXUH
RIYDOXHLVW KHFRQVLGHUDW LRQRIVSLULW XDO SK\VLFDO VRXO UHODW HGYDOXHVW KHFRQVFLRXV
UHVSRQVLELOLW \RIW KHLQGLYLGXDOIRUW KHFROOHFW LYHZKLFKLVH[SUHVVHGLQKLVFDUHIRU
UDFHDQGUHOLJLRQLQFOXGLQJW KHFDXVLQJRISK\VLFDODQGVSLULW XDOZHOO EHLQJ

7KH FRQQHFW LRQ RI UDFH DQG UHOLJLRQ ZKHQ LW  RFFXUV KDSSHQV QRW  DV D UHVXOW  RI
VRP HFRLQFLGHQFHEXW W KH\DUHP XW XDOO\LQW HUDFW LYH

 7KHKLJKHUDUDFHLVSRVLW LRQHGW KHKLJKHULVLW V:HOW DQVFKDXXQJ'HFD\RIW KH

UDFHEHFDXVHRIXQIRUW XQDW HP L[LQJRIUDFHVDOVRGHFRP SRVHVDQGFRQIXVHVUHOLJLRQ
DQG:HOW DQVFKDXXQJ

³ (TXDOFDQRQO\EHXQGHUVW RRGE\(TXDO´
:H OLYH LQ W KH P LGGOH RI D UDFLDO DQG UHOLJLRXV FROODSVH D SURFHVV W KDW  SURYLGHV
FRQW HP SRUDULHV ZKR DUH DZDUH RI W KH VLW XDW LRQ ZLW K D SRLQW  RI Y LHZ W KDW  FDXVHV
YHU\VRP EHUHP RW LRQV

 $OOFXOW XUHVRIW KH(DUW KZHUHDOUHDG\DW DOHYHORIGHFD\DQGFROODSVHZKHQW KH\

HQW HUHG W KH DUHD RI NQRZQ KLVW RU\ UHJDUGOHVV KRZ KLJK VRP H RI W KHP  P D\ EH
UHJDUGHGZKHQFRP SDUHGW RRXUVW XOW LI\LQJZDYHRIFLYLOL]DW LRQRIW KHSDVW FHQW XULHV
$OORIW KHP DUHVW LOOGUDZLQJIURP W KHLQKHULW DQFHRIDP LOOHQQLDROGKXP DQKLJK
FXOW XUHZKLFKVORZO\H[KDXVW HGLW VHOI

 7KHKLVW RU\RIW KHSODQHW NQRZVRIDUDGLDW LQJFHQW HURIDODVW JUHDW DQGW UXH8U

FXOW XUH QDP HO\RQW KH, VOHRI$W ODQW LVW KDW VDQNEFHLQW RW KH$W ODQW LFDQG
ZKLFK ZDV W KH ODVW  UHP DLQGHU RI D VORZO\ VLQNLQJ FRQW LQHQW   7KH UHP DLQGHUV RI
W KLV FXOW XUH UDFH ZKLFK ZHUH LQ W KH P DLQ VW LOO UHSUHVHQW HG LQ W KHLU FRORQLHV RI
ZKLFKQRZDGD\VZHP HQW LRQRQO\DQFLHQW (J\SW DQGDQFLHQW 0H[LFR7KHUHW KH\
FDXVHGLQW KHP LOOHQQLDW KDW IROORZHGDULVHRILQIHULRUUDFHVRQW KHZKROHSODQHW E\
P L[LQJ LQ W KHLU P RUH QREOH EORRG W KDW  ZDV FDSDEOH RI FXOW XUH  +HUH OHW  XV DOVR
P HQW LRQ DV H[DP SOHV W KH ROG $U\DQ , QGLD DQG W KH ROG $P HULFDQ HP SLUHV W KDW
H[LVW HGEHIRUHW KH$]W HFVDQGW KH, QFDV

6W LOOW RGD\ZHDUHOLYLQJLQW KLVSURFHVVRIK\EULGL]DW LRQDQGGHFRP SRVLW LRQZKLFK

LV DLP OHVV DQG ODFNV LQW HQW LRQ RI D JRDO W RZDUGV D QHZ ULVH DQG EUHHGLQJ RI W KH
KLJKHUKXP DQLW \

 :HVW LOOFDQILQGDQLP P HQVHZHDOW KRIV\P EROVSHUW DLQLQJW RDQ8U VFULSW W KDW

EHORQJLQW KHP DLQW RW KHVR FDOOHG1RUGLF5XQH )XW KDUNZKLFK UHP DLQHGLQXVH
VW LOOLQW RW KHP RGHUQDJHLQ*HUP DQLFFRXQW ULHV7KHVHKDYHEHHQIRXQGDOORYHU
W KHSODQHW DQGW KH\JREDFNW RW LP HVW KDW DUHHUURQHRXVO\DVVLJQHGW RW KH3DOHROLW KLF
 

FXOW XUHDVLIZLW KW KDW ODEHOW KHROGHVW KXP DQFXOW XUHZDVGHVFULEHGKLVW RULFDOO\
7KH KLVW RULDQ IRUJHW V W KDW  W KH 6W RQH $JH 3DOHROLW KLF  ZDV SUHFHGHG E\ D ZRRG
DJHZKLFKLVQRW H[W LQFW \HW HYHQLQRXUGD\V6W RQH$JH%URQ]H$JHDQG, URQ
$JHDUHUXQQLQJSDUDOOHOVW LOOLQRXUSUHVHQW W LP H

, IZHHVW LP DW HW KHROGHVW VW RQH DJHZD\W RRVKRUW ZKHQDVVXP LQJLW \HDUV
LQW KHSDVW W KHQRXUDW W HQW LRQDQGUHVHDUFKVKRXOGIRFXVRQVFULSW V\P EROVW KDW
KDYHEHHQVFULEHGRQZRRG7KLVM XVW LILHVW KHFRQFOXVLRQW KDW  W KH5XQHVFULSW LV
P XFKROGHUW KDQHYHQW KHHDUOLHVW DUFKDHRORJLFDOILQGVZRXOGDOORZXVW RDVVXP H
5XQHVDQGUXQH OLNHV\P EROVROGHVWZLWQHVVHVDQGSUH FRQGLWLRQVRIKXP DQVSLULWXDO
FXOW XUH FDQ RQO\ EHHQ IRXQG LQ FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K W KH UHP DLQGHUV RI W KH 1RUGLF
$U\DQUDFH7KLVW KHUHIRUHLVSURRIRIW KH$U\DQUDFHKDYLQJEHHQW KHILUVW ERUQ
RQH

 7KHVH UXQHV DQG UHSUHVHQW DW LYH V\P EROV DUH LQ LUUHIXW DEOH FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K
H[W HQVLYH DVW URQRP LFDO NQRZOHGJH ZKLFK HYROYHG HIIRUW OHVVO\ LQ W KH HDUOLHVW  HUD
RI KXP DQNLQG IURP  D GLUHFW  H[SHULHQFH RI DVW URORJLFDO FRQW H[W V  (DUO\ LQGHHG
EDFNLQW KHW LP HVRILW VHDUOLHVW SURYDEOHXVHW KHVHV\P EROVDQQRXQFHGW KH6RQRI
W KH6XQLHW KHELUW KRIW KH\RXQJJRGW KH6XQZKLFKHP HUJHVHYHU\\HDUIURP
W KH'LYLQHYLUJLQW KHLP P DFXODW H0RW KHU1DW XUH

6HHQ XQGHU W KLV DVSHFW  ZH P D\ UHJDUG DOO UHOLJLRQV RI W KH (DUW K LQFOXGLQJ W KH
&KULVW LDQFRQIHVVLRQVDVKHLUVRIDQROGUHOLJLRXVSDUDEOHRIW KHXOW LP DW H*RRG D
SDUDEOH W KDW  W KH\ FRXOG QRW  XQGHUVW DQG DQ\ P RUH HYHQ DW  W KH W LP H ZKHQ W KH\
DVVLP LODW HGW KHVHDQFLHQW W UXW KV

 :KHQHYHUW KHHTXLQRFW LDOSRLQW W KDW IROORZVW KH*UHDW 6RODU<HDULQLW VFRQW LQXRXV

SDW K W KURXJK W KH HFOLSW LF HQW HUV D QHZ VLJQ   W KLV KDSSHQV DSSU R[LP DW HO\ HYHU\
\HDUVW KHV\P ERORIW KHFRVP LFW KHP HRIW KDW HUDLVFKDQJLQJ:HDUHVW LOO
UHP HP EHULQJ W KH FXOW V RI W KH ³ EXOO´  7DXUXV  RI W KH ³ UDP ´  $ULHV  DQG RI W KH
³ ILVKHV´  3LVFHVW KH&KULVW +XP DQVRIW KHSUHVHQW DUHM XVW OHDYLQJW KH3LVFHDQ
DJHLQRUGHUW RHQW HUW KHGRP DLQRI$TXDULXVLQDIHZGHFDGHVZKLFKZLOOVW DUW D
QHZ HUD RI  \HDUV  , QVW UXFW LRQV W R FXOW XUDO FKDQJHV LQ W KH FRXUVH RI W KH
VDFUHG]RGLDFDOVHTXHQFHZHUHJLYHQLQW KHHDUOLHUHUDVRI$W ODQW LV

 )URP $W ODQW LVIRXUEUDQFKHVRIFXOW XUHVP LJUDW HGLQW RW KHIRXUGLUHFW LRQVRIW KH
FRP SDVV$1RUW KHUQEUDQFKP LJUDW HGW R1RUW KZHVW HUQ(XURSHW KHP DLQODQGRI
ZKLFKLVEHQHDW KW KH1RUW K6HDDQG%DOW LF6HDEXW ZKLFKUHDFKHG&HQW UDO(XURSH
DQGIURP W KHUHLW HVW DEOLVKHGDEULGJHW R$VLDZKLFKZDVXVHGE\ODW HUP LJUDW RU\
W ULEHV ZKHQ W KH\ P RYHG W R 1RUW K (DVW  $VLD  7KHUH ZDV D VRXW KHUQ EUDQFK W KDW
EURXJKW  IRUW K IUXLW  LQ W KH VXQNHQ 6RXW KHUQ $W ODQW LV DQG DOO RI :HVW HUQ $IULFD  $
:HVW HUQEUDQFKVHW W OHGLQERW K$P HULFDV)LQDOO\W KHUHZDVW KH(DVW HUQEUDQFK
ZKLFK H[SDQGHG W KURXJK 6SDLQ 7DUW HVVRV  DQG DFURVV W KH $W ODV 0RXQW DLQV D
FRORQ\RI$W ODQW LV DORQJERW KVLGHVRIW KH0HGLW HUUDQHDQDQGW KHQDIW HUFURVVLQJ
W KH 'DUGDQHOOHV EHW ZHHQ $VLD DQG (XURSH DQG W KH LVW KP XV EHW ZHHQ $IULFD DQG
$VLD 6XH] W R6RXW KHUQ$VLDDOOW KHZD\W RW KHIDU(DVW )URP W KHUHW KH\VHW W OHG
 

LQ W KH 6RXW K 6HD DV W KH JLJDQW LF $W ODQW HDQ P RQXP HQW V RQ (DVW HU  , VODQG SURYH
ZKLFKDIRUW XQDW HFRLQFLGHQFHNHSW IRUSRVW HULW \

 7KH SUHFRQGLW LRQ RI W KH $W ODQW HDQ FXOW XUH ZDV W KH IDFW  RI W KH RULJLQ RI DOO OLIH
DP RQJRW KHUVDOVRRIKXP DQVLQW KHFRXQW ULHVDURXQGW KH1RUW KHUQSROH$VW KH
KLVW RU\RIW KH(DUW KVKRZVW KHUHZDVLQHDUOLHVW W LP HVRIW KHHYROXW LRQRIW KH(DUW K
DQHDU W URSLFDOFOLP DW HZKLFKZDVSUHFRQGLW LRQIRUW KHEHFRP LQJDQGW KULYLQJRI
KXP DQNLQG XQGHU QDW XUDO FRQGLW LRQV  7KH VORZ SURFHVV RI W KH SRODU FRXQW ULHV
FRROLQJ GRZQ IRUFHG KXP DQV W R W KH 6RXW K ZKHUH W KH\ UHDFKHG RQ $W ODQW LV W KH
SRVW SRODU ³ SDUDGLVH´ LH D VW DW H RI KLJK EOLVV EDVHG RQ D OLIH URRW HG LQ 'LYLQH
UHDVRQDQGZLVGRP 

 , QW KHVHTXHQFHRIKXP DQHYROXW LRQW KH$W ODQW HDQVZHUHW KHIRXUW KURRW UDFH
DQGW KH\FUHDW HGW KH$W ODQW HDQFXOW XUHW KHUHP DLQGHUVRIZKLFKDUHKXJHHDUW KHQ
VW UXFW XUHV W KDW  FDQ EH IRXQG RQ DOO FRQW LQHQW V  7KHLU P DLQ FKDUDFW HULVW LF ZDV D
KLJKO\  HY ROYHG W HFKQLFDO FXOW XU H  Z KLFK  KRZ HY HU  Z DV U RRW HG P DLQO\  LQ W KH
NQRZOHGJHRIW KHP DJLFNDOSRZHUVRIW KHKXP DQEHLQJ7KLVZDVTXLW HW KHFRQW UDU\
W RRXUP RGHUQW HFKQLFDOFLYLOL]DW LRQZKLFKDW W HP SW VW RFRQW UROW KHHQYLURQP HQW E\
P HFKDQLFDOP HDQV

 7KHKHLUVRIW KLVFLYLOL]DW LRQZDVW KHILIW KP DLQ RUURRW UDFHW KH$U\DQVZKLFK
GLGQRW H[SHULHQFHDQ\P RUHW KHVLQNLQJRIW KHFRQW LQHQW RI$W ODQW LVEXW ZKREXLOW
W KH$U\DQFXOW XUHERW KIURP W KHUHP DLQGHUVRI$W ODQW HDQW UDGLW LRQVDQGW KHLURZQ
FUHDW LYHHQHUJLHV

 7KH UXQ GRZQ UHP DLQGHUV RI W KH W KLUG DQG IRXUW K URRW  UDFHV W KH ILUVW  DQG
VHFRQG RQHV ZHUH HOLP LQDW HG E\ GUDVW LF (DUW K FKDQJHV ORQJ DJR  W KDW  ZHUH DW  D
VW DQGVW LOOLQW KHLUHYROXW LRQHQGHGXSEHLQJW KHP DLQERG\RIW KHQRQ$U\DQJURXSV
RIKXP DQNLQGRQW KH(DUW K7KH$U\DQURRW UDFHKDVIRUP HGW KHKLJKHVW HYROYHG
KXP DQEHLQJVZLW KFRQVFLRXVEUHHGLQJXQGHU'LYLQHJXLGDQFH7KLVKLJKO\HYROYHG
KXP DQEHLQJHVW DEOLVKHGDQHP SLUHRISHDFHRQ(DUW KW KDW ODVW HGIRUW KRXVDQGVRI
\HDUV7KHP HP RULHVRIW KLVJROGHQDJHQHYHUYDQLVKHGIURP KXP DQV7KH(GGD
DQG P DQ\ RW KHU KXP DQ GRFXP HQW V W HOO W KH VHHNHU DERXW  W KLV DJH  7KH ³ *ROGHQ
$JH´ UHFHLYHGLW VQDP HEHFDXVHW KH$U\DQKDVKLVQDP HIURP W KHJROGLHW KH
VRODUJROGRIW KH$DUW KHDQFLHQW ZRUGIRUW KH(DJOHZKLFKLVV\P ERORIW KH6XQ
$UDQGLW VUHYHUVDO5DP HDQV6XQLQDOOODQJXDJHVDQGKXQGUHGVRIW KHLUGLDOHFW V
RI W KH (DUW K LW  P HDQV OLJKW  DQG ILJXUDW LYHO\ DOVR *RG  7KHUHIRUH W KH $U\DQV DUH
W KH6RQVRIW KH6XQRUW KH6RQVRIW KH*RGVDQGW KHLUFXOW LFSUDFW LFHZDVHVVHQW LDOO\
D FXOW  RI W KH OLJKW   $V VXFK LW  ZDV QRW  D ZRUVKLS RI W KH P DW HULDO ILUH EXW  LW  ZDV
ZLW KLQW KHFRQVFLRXVQHVVRIVSLULW XDOLQVLJKW RIDVSLULW XDOLQZDUGUHDFKLQJZKHUH
DOO'LYLQHDQGVSLULW XDOHQHUJLHVH[SHULHQFHGW KHLUYLVLEOHHP DQDW LRQLQW KH/LJKW 

7KHVHEDVLFLGHDVDUHQRW QHZ7KH\ZHUHDFFHSW HGE\P DQ\FUHDW LYHSHUVRQV

DQGFRQYLQFLQJO\W DXJKW E\W KHP ZLW KP RUHDQGOHVVJRRGUHVXOW V
 

5HFHQW O\ +HUP DQ :LUW K D JLIW HG VFKRODU KDV SXEOLVKHG D FRP SUHKHQVLYH ERRN
³ 'HU$XIJDQJGHU0HQVFKKHLW ´LQZKLFKXVLQJKLVDFXLW \LQW KLQNLQJKHKDVSXW DOO
W KHVHSRLQW VDQGFRQQHFW LRQVRQDQHZVFLHQW LILFEDVLV

+LVVW DW HP HQW VDQGSURRIVFRQFXULQSULQFLSOHZLW KW KDW ZKLFKW KHUHSUHVHQW DW LYHV

RI W KH $U\DQ UDFLDO ZRUOGYLHZ KDYH FODLP HG DOO DORQJ  QDP HO\ W KH UHFRJQLW LRQ RI
W KHRULJLQRIDOOP RUDOLW \DQGFXOW XUHLQW KH1RUW K

+HHVSHFLDOO\SURYHVW KHIXQGDP HQW DOLP SRUW DQFHRIW KHUXQHVIRUKXP DQKLVW RU\

DV V\P EROV RI W KH 8U VFULSW  RI W KH 8U ODQJXDJH  7KH IDFW  W KDW  KLV IRFXV LV LQ W KH
P DLQRQDVXSHUILFLDOH[SODQDW LRQRIW KHUXQHVP DLQO\DVVFULSW DQGV\P EROVRIW KH
FRXUVHRIW KH\HDULQQRZD\UHGXFHVW KHZRUW KRIKLVZRUN3HUKDSVW KLVDSSURDFK
P DN HV KLV Z RU N  HDVLHU  W R XQGHU VW DQG DQG DFFHSW  E\  FLU FOHV RI VFKRODU V DQG
NQRZOHGJHDEOHOD\SHRSOHZKRW RW KLVSRLQW GLVW DQFHGW KHP VHOYHVIURP VXFKW UXO\
U HY ROXW LRQDU \  LGHDV HLW KHU  EHFDXVH RI DQ DW W LW XGH RI P LVW U XVW  RU  EHFDXVH RI
LQGLIIHUHQFH7KHFRQW HQW VRIP \SUHVHQW ERRNZHUHDOUHDG\LQSULQW ZKHQ, JRW W R
VHH :LUW K¶V ERRN  7KLV LV HVSHFLDOO\ LP SRUW DQW  W R QRW H EHFDXVH LQFRQW HVW DEOH
DJU HHP HQW V LQ SU LQFLSOH EHW Z HHQ ERW K SXEOLFDW LRQV Z KLFK KDYH EHHQ Z U LW W HQ
LQGHSHQGHQW O\IURP HDFKRW KHULVREYLRXVSURRIRIW KHFRUUHFW QHVVRIW KDW ZKLFK
ZHSRLQW RXW KHUH

-XVW LFHDQG6FLHQW LILFW UXW KUHTXLUHKRZHYHUW KDW ZHH[SODLQW KDW :LUW K¶VLQVLJKW V
DV ZHOO DV W KRVH W KDW  ,  RXW  IRUW K LQ W KLV ERRN DUH QRW  QHZ DOW KRXJK W KHUH ZDV D
GHILQLW H QHHG W R SUHVHQW  W KHP  LQ D QHZ IRUP   , Q IDFW  VLQFH W LP H LP P HP RULDO
W KHVHLQVLJKW VFRQFHUQLQJW KH$W ODQW HDQRULJLQRIDOO(XURSHDQ $P HULFDQ$IULFDQ
DQG $VLDW LF FXOW XUHV ZHUH W DXJKW  E\ P XFK P DOLJQHG DQG P XFK VODQGHUHG VHFUHW
GRFW ULQHV6LQFH3ODW R¶VUHSRUW RQ$W ODQW LVW KHW KUHDGRIW UDGLW LRQVKDVQHYHUEHHQ
LQW HUUXSW HG EXW  DOVR W KH YR\DJH RI &ROXP EXV ZDV EDVHG RQ VHFUHW  NQRZOHGJH
FRQFHUQLQJ$W ODQW LVDQGW KHFRQW LQHQW EH\RQGLW +LVGHFLVLRQSRVVLEO\ZDVIXUW KHUHG
DV D UHVXOW  RI KLV SHUVRQDO LQTXLULHV LQ , UHODQG DQG , FHODQG Z KHUH W KH\ VW LOO NHSW
W KHFRQQHFW LRQZLW KW KH$P HULFDQFRQW LQHQW  LQIDFW W KH\KDGFRORQLHVW KHUH7KLV
FRQQHFW LRQ ZDV D ZHOO JXDUGHG LQKHULW DQFH RI W KH DQFLHQW  UHODW LRQV W R $W ODQW LV
DOW KRXJKW KHVHFXODUDQGFOHULFDOVFLHQFHVRIW KHP LGGOHDJHVGLGQRW NQRZRILW RU
GLGQRW UHYHDOLW :HVKRXOGQHYHUEHOLHYHW KDW VXFKIDFW VVLP SO\GLVDSSHDUZLW KRXW
WUDFHIURP W KHFROOHFW LYHP HP RU\RIQDW LRQVDQGSHRSOHVUHJDUGOHVVRIW KHDUW LILFLDOO\
SURP RW HGULJLGORRNLQJW RZDUGVW KH(DVW ZKHUHIRUJHUVFODLP HGW KHRULJLQRIKXP DQ
KLVW RU\ZDV

7KH P DLQ VRXU FHV RI W KLV Z LVGRP  DU H W KH %DVTXH , U LVK 6FRW W LVK DQG .HOW LF
W UDGLW LRQVVDJDVDQGP \W KVZKLFKVFDUFHO\JRW DW W HQW LRQRIW KHVFLHQFHRIKLVW RU\
0D\HVW DEOLVKHGH[SHUW VW DNHSDUW VRIP \ZRUNDQGW HDUW KHP DSDUW SHUKDSVHYHQ
ZLW K VRP H M XVW LILFDW LRQ EXW  W KH\ ZLOO QRW  EH DEOH W R VKDW W HU W KH EDVLF LGHDV W KH
 

JUHDW SODQRIDOORILW ZLW KW KHP HDQVW KDW W KH\KDYHDYDLODEOH7KLVLVVREHFDXVH

W KLVEDVLFLGHDDFW VDOUHDG\DVDQLQYLQFLEOHSRZHULQW KHP LGVW RIVSLULW XDOW UHQGV
RIDQHZW LP HZKLFKEULQJVIRUW KDQHZEUHHGRIKXP DQVZLW KFU HDW LYHEHJLQQLQJV
DQGOHDQLQJV

,  KDYH GRQH W KH 6W HS  7KLV ZRUN ZLOO SUHSDUH W KH JURXQG IRU W KH FRP LQJ $U\DQ
:HOW DQVFKDXXQJDQGZD\RIOLIHZKLFKRULJLQDW HVHTXDOO\LQ8U DQFLHQW DVZHOODV
LQ8U P RGHUQVSLULW XDODQGFXOW XUDOKHULW DJHV, W GRHVVRW REHQHILW QRW DKXP DQLW \
W KDW  LV LQIOXHQFHG E\ W KH IRJ OLNH DSSHDUDQFH RI DQ LP DJH W KDW  VD\V ³ KRZ IDU ZH
P DQDJHGW RDGYDQFH´EXW DKXP DQLW \W KDW IHHOVLW VHOIDJDLQP XW XDOO\UHVSRQVLEOH
DQGZKLFKQHYHUW KHOHVVSHUFHLYHVLW VHOIDVGLIIHUHQW IROORZLQJDQXQDOW HUDEOHFRVP LF
SODQ  7KH W KLQJV W R ZKLFK ,  DOOXGHG LQ W KH SDVW   \HDUV LQ RIW HQ FRQW LQXRXV
SXEOLFDW LRQV RI SHULRGLFDOV IRU ZKLFK ,  VDFULILFHG VR P XFK ,  QRZ SURIHVV W KHP
VROHP QO\ DQG ORXGO\ IRU DOO W R KHDU DQG IRU W KH EHQHILW  RI DOO ZKR KDYH JRRG
LQW HQW LRQV

7KHDFFHVVW RW KHLQQHUVDQFW XP RIW KHLQVLJKW VLQRXUW LP HOLHVW KHFRQVHFUDW LRQRI

W KHVHFUHW FRQW HQW VRIW KH(GGDW KH9HGDVDQGW KH%LEOHLQFRQQHFW LRQZLW KP DQ\
RW KHUIUDJP HQW VRIKXP DQGRFXP HQW VW KDW QHYHUFDQEHORVW %\QRP HDQVKDYH
ZHRXW JURZQ\HW W KHVHGRFXP HQW V, QIDFW ZHDUHM XVW EHJLQQLQJW RXQGHUVW DQG
W KHP  LQ W KHLU W UXH P HDQLQJ  5HW URVSHFW LRQ LV QRW  D UHW XUQ W R W KDW  ZKLFK LV SDVW 
EXW LW RSHQVXSW KHHQM R\P HQW RIW KHSUHVHQW DQGW KHEOLVVRIDP HDQLQJIXOIXW XUH
8U VFULSW 8U ODQJXDJHDQG8U P HDQLQJRIW KH5XQHVKDYHEHHQORVW DQGEHIRUH
P DQKDVQRW XQGHUVW RRGW KHP DJDLQLQW KHLUP RVW LQW LP DW HFRUUHODW LRQVKHKDVQR
ZD\ W R DQ H[SODQDW LRQ RI P HDQLQJ DQG UHDVRQ IRU KLV SDVVLQJ SUHVHQFH RQ W KLV
URXQG(DUW KW KDW VDW LVILHVUHDVRQDQGKHDUW DOLNH

$QGZKDW ZHXOW LP DW HO\ZHUHZRUW K

5HVXOW VIURP ZLOODQGGHHGV
:HFKDQJHVLOHQW O\RQO\W KHDSSHDUDQFHV
2QW KH7UHHRIW KH:RUOGDJUHHQOHDI

5XGROI-RKQ*RUVOHEHQ
 

, 0IG? IHFSQB;NG;E?MG?QCM?CM
QILNBEHIQCHA

3XVKIURP \RXUVKRXOGHUW KDW ZKLFKDSSHDUVHYLO

$QGRULHQW \RXUVHOIHQW LUHO\DFFRUGLQJW R\RXUVHOI
(GGD

:KRHYHUREVHUYHVW KHSUHVHQW HYROXW LRQRIW KLQJVZLW KRSHQH\HVDQG

ZKRGRHVQRW DOORZEHLQJVW XOW LILHGE\W KHQRLV\VXSHUILFLDOLW \ RIGDLO\
OLIHEXW ZKRHP SDW KLFDOO\SUREHVW KDW ZKLFKVORZO\JURZVDQGP DW XUHV
EHQHDW K W KH VXUIDFH KH EHFRP HV DZDUH W KDW  W KLQJV VW DUW  VSURXW LQJ
DQGJURZLQJHYHU\ZKHUHW KDW VRXUFHVDUHEHJLQQLQJW RIORZDJDLQLQ
W KH *HUP DQ )RON W KDW  ZHUH KLGGHQ IRU FHQW XULHV  2XU ROG DQG W UXH
VSLULW XDOKHULW DJHW KHKLJKHVW NQRZOHGJHRIRXUDQFHVW RUVFRP HVEDFN
W R OLIH DJDLQ  :LW K DP D]HP HQW  VRP H RI XV EHFRP H DZDU H RI W KH
W UHDVXUHVW KDW DUHZDLW LQJW REHUHFRYHUHGHYHU\ZKHUHDQGZKLFKZDQW
W RUHYHDOW KHP VHOYHVW RXV$QGZKHQP DQSHQHW UDW HVGHHSHULQW KLV
UHDOP RIP LUDFOHVDQGIDLU\W DOHVKHILQGVRXW W RKLVJUHDW HVW DP D]HP HQW
W KDW KHILQGVHYHU\ZKHUHSHUVRQVZKRVKDUHKLVRSLQLRQVDQGLQVLJKW V
, QIDFW KXP DQVUHYHDOW KHP VHOYHVW RKLP ZKRKDYHNHSW W UXHDQFLHQW
NQRZOHGJH DV IDP LO\ W UDGLW LRQ ZKR DOORZ RQO\ W UXVW ZRUW K\ SHUVRQV
LQVLJKW  LQ W KHLU W UHDVXU\  7KH W \SH RI SUHFLRXV W KLQJV W KDW  KDYH EHHQ
VOXP EHULQJ LQ ³ .DKOD´ XQQRW LFHG DQG KLGGHQ W R W KLV SRLQW  DJDLQ DQG
DJDLQDP D]HVW KHVHHNHU

:KDW  LV ³ .DKOD´ "  .DKOD GHULYHG IURP  W KH ZRUG ³ YHUNDKOHQ´ KDV W KH
P HDQLQJ RI KLGLQJ DQG NHHSLQJ VRP HW KLQJ D VHFU HW   , Q W KH Z RU G
³ .DODXHU ´ZKLFKLVGHULYHGIURP W KHZRUG³ .DKOD´W KHROGP HDQLQJKDV
EHHQ UHW DLQHG DOVR LQ W KH ZRUG ³ YHUNRKOHQ´    7R W U\ W R FRQYLQFH D
SHUVRQW KDW DQ³ ;´ LVD³ 8´W RP DNHD³ .DODXHU´  7KH$U\DQSLFW RJUDSKLF
VFULSW DQGW KHP HW KRGVRILW VXVHDUH.DKODDQGW KH\DUHXVHGIRUW KH
SXUSRVHW RSURW HFW DJDLQVW P LVXVHDQGW UHVSDVVHUVDSUDFW LFHW KDW ZDV
VW ULFW O\REVHUYHGLQDOOP \VW HU\VFKRROVRIW KH$U\DQZRUOG


DSXQ
 

2XUIDLU\W DOHVVDJDVW KH(GGDRXUROG*HUP DQDQG0LGGOH+LJK*HUP DQHSLFV

W KH JRVSHOV DUH ZULW W HQ LQ .DKOD  )XUW KHUP RUH W KHUH LV QR GRXEW  W KDW  W KH 2OG
7HVW DP HQW W KH9HGDVDQGDOO, QGR$U\DQSRHW U\VDJDVDQGP \W KVFRQW DLQVP RUH
.DKODW KDQZHZRXOGKDYHGDUHGW RGUHDP W RW KLVSRLQW , QDQ\FDVHLQIXW XUHZH
FDQQRW GRZLW KRXW XVHRIW KHVHODZVRIW KH.DKODW KDW KDYHEHHQUHGLVFRYHUHGE\
/LVW DQGRW KHUVZKHQZHZDQW W RH[SODLQVXFKP \VW HULRXVZULW LQJV, QIDFW RQO\
ZKHQZHIROORZW KHVHSULQFLSOHVZLOOW KHVHZULW LQJVUHYHDOW RXVW KHLUW UXHP HDQLQJ
$P RQJ W KH VHFUHW LYH IDUP HUV RI W KH 2GHQZDOG ZH ILQG P DQ\ ILUVW  QDP HV RI W KH
VDJD RI W KH 1LEHOXQJHQ HYHQ W KRXJK W KHVH IDUP HUV KDYH QR NQRZOHGJH RI W KH
P HGLHYDO1LEHOXQJHQOLHGDQGW KH\KDYHQRW EHHQLQIOXHQFHGE\W KHP XVLFDOGUDP DV
RI:DJQHU$QROGSUHDFKHUDGP LW W HGW KDW KHZDVDSUHDFKHULQW KH2GHQZDOGIRU
\HDUVEHIRUHW KHIDUP HUVHQW UXVW HGKLP W KHLUVHFUHW V7KURXJKRXW W KHFHQW XULHV
IURP IDW KHUW RVRQW KH\UXQHG  ROGZLVGRP IURP %DOGHUDQG6LHJIULHGW RHDFKRW KHU
DQG W KH\ UHYHDOHG LW  LQ W KH QDP HV RI W KHLU FKLOGUHQ  7KH IDUP HU LQ W KH UHP RW H
DUHDVLVZHOODZDUHRIW KHW UDGLW LRQVRIW KHSODFHVLQW KHZRRGVDQGLQW KHILHOGV
W KDW VW LOOKDYHROGP HDQLQJZKLFKKHP D\QRW HQW LUHO\XQGHUVW DQGDQ\P RUHEXW
ZKLFKKHLVUHOXFW DQW W RVKRZW KHRXW VLGHURUW RW DONZLW KKLP DERXW W KDW 0LVW UXVW
LVLQKLVEORRGDQGIRUFHQW XULHVKHKDVW KHFHUW DLQIHHOLQJW KDW W KHQHZW LP HVKDYH
UREEHGKLP RIVRP HW KLQJHVVHQW LDO2QW KHRQHKDQGW KH\DUHDVKDP HGRINQRZLQJ
W KLQJV W KDW  W KH\ FDQ QHLW KHU H[SODLQ QRU GHIHQG EXW  W KH\ DUH DOVR VDW LVILHG W KDW
W KH\NHSW W KLVZD\HP RW LRQDOYDOXHVW KDW VHUYHW KHP DVDVXSSRU W VW LOOLQRXUGD\V
EHFDXVH W KHVH W KLQJV UDGLDW H P \VW HULRXV SRZHUV W R W KRVH ZKR NQRZ RI W KHP 
7KHVH SURFHVVHV DUH XQFRQVFLRXV  6W LOO ZH DUH GHHSHU LQYROYHG LQ ³ SDJDQLVP ´
³ KHDW KHQGRP ´  W KDQ ³ FLYLOL]HG´  SHUVRQV DURXQG XV P D\ DVVXP H DQG W KDW  LV D
YHU\JRRGW KLQJ

0XFKRIZKDW , P \VHOIKDYHP HQW LRQHGDERXW W KHVHROGW UDGLW LRQVLQW KHFLUFOHVRI

IULHQGVDQGDFTXDLQW DQFHVIURP W LP HW RW LP HUHYHDOVLW VHOIDQDQFLHQW W UHDVXUHRI
W UDGLW LRQV RZQHG E\ FHUW DLQ IDP LOLHV ZKHUH W KHQ W KH VRQV ILQG HYHQW XDOO\ W KH
FRXUDJH Z LW KLQ W KHP VHOY HV W R W HOO W R W KHLU  RIIVSU LQJ W KDW  Z KLFK W KHLU  IDW KHU V
EHTXHDW KHG W R W KHP   0RVW  RI W KH W LP H LW  LV W KH SHRSOH LQ :HVW SKDOLD ZKR JXDUG
VXFK VHFUHW V  7KH ZRUGV W KDW  W KH DQFLHQW  %DE\ORQLDQV FRLQHG IRU W KH P \VW LF LV
YDOLGIRUW KH1RUW KVW LOOLQRXUGD\V ³ 2QO\W KHRQHZKRNQRZVVKDOOILQGRXW DERXW
LW W KHRQHZKRGRHVQRW NQRZVKDOOQRW ILQGRXW 7KHKHUGVP DQVKRXOGW HOOLW W R
W KHKHUGVP HQ ER\DQGW KHIDW KHU VKRXOGW HOOLW W RW KHVRQ´

, Q RXU  GD\ V D W LP H LV FRP LQJ Z KHQ  DFFRU GLQJ W R W KH SU RSKHF\  RI W KH VHHU
1RVW UDGDP XV SUHFLRXV JHP V ZLOO UDLQ GRZQ W KH ROG W UHDVXULHV DUH RSHQLQJ W KH
W UHDVXUHRIW KH1LEHOXQJHQULVHVDQGW KHUHGEHDUG (P SHURU)ULHGULFK%DUEDURVVD
LQ W KH .\IIKlXVHU 0RXQW DLQ ZLOO UHW XUQ LQ RUGHU W R EHJLQ W KH U XOH RI W KH ³ 7KLUG
5HLFK´     7KRVH ZKR E\ LQKHULW DQFH RU LQQHU FDOOLQJ DUH LQ SRVVHVVLRQ RI W KH
DQFLHQW ZLVGRP DUHSUHSDULQJW RVSHDNDJDLQW RW KH*HUP DQSHRSOHW RFRQYH\W R
W KHP W KHVSLULW XDOW UHDVXUHVRIW KHLUDQFHVW RUV7KLVW DVNLVDGLIILFXOW RQHEHFDXVH

 ,  DP  JRLQJ W R XVH W KLV Z RUG IRU ³ UDXQHQ´  D GHULYDW LYH RI ³ UXQH´  $ IRUP  RI P XUP XULQJ Z KLFK
FRQYH\VQRW M XVW OLW HUDOEXW DOVRV\P EROLFDQGHYRFDW LYHP HDQLQJV

6HHP VW KDW KHKDVZ ULW W HQW KDW \HDUVEHIRUHW KH³ 7KLUG5HLFK´ HP HUJHG
 

ILUVW W KHSUHFRQGLW LRQVIRULW KDYHW REHFUHDW HG7KHVLJQRIRXUW LP HVLVP DW HULDOLVP 

LHW KHXQFRQGLW LRQDOEHOLHILQDZRUOGW KDW LVP DW HULDOVXEVW DQFHRQO\ W KHUHIRUH
LW LVQRW KLQJEXW DGRJP DW KDW DFFHSW VRQO\W KDW ZKLFKRXUILYHVHQVHVFDQSHUFHLYH 
7KH NQRZOHGJH RI RXU DQFHVW RUV RQ W KH RW KHU KDQG LV URRW HG LQ D VSLULW XDOLVW LF
RXW ORRN LQ LW V KLJKHVW  VW DJH RI HYROXW LRQ DQ LQW HOOHFW XDO VSLU LW XDO   VFLHQFH W KH
NQRZOHGJHRIW KHVSLULW EHLQJ³ ILUVW ERUQ´&RQVHTXHQW O\W KLVSRLQW RIYLHZKDVW R
EHSUHVHQW HGW RW KHUXOLQJP DW HULDOLVW LFZD\RIW KLQNLQJ7KLVLVLQGHHGDGLIILFXOW
W DVN VLQFH P DQ\ H[LVW LQJ  H[SHULP HQW V RI VSLULW XDOLVP  DUH VW XFN LQ D P D]H RI
HUURUVW KDW JLYHVW KHP DW HULDOLVW VHDV\ZD\VW RDW W DFNW KHP +HUHRIFRXUVHZH
KDYHW RSRLQW RXW W KDW W KHUHZHUHJRRGDQGEDGDUW LVW VDW DOOW LP HVDVZHOODVZH
KDYHJRRGDQGEDGDVW URORJHUVLQRXUGD\VW KDW DUW LVW VDUHSDLQW LQJSRUW UDLW VDQG
FDQYDVVHVIRUP RQH\DQGW KDW DVW URORJHUVFDVW KRURVFRSHVIRUILYH0DUNVDSLHFH
2QW KHRW KHUKDQGZHKDGDOVR'UHUDQG.HSOHUZKRSDLQW HGDQGZKRLQW HUSUHW HG
W KH VW DUV  6KRXOG EH EHOLHYH W KDW  IRU W KDW  UHDVRQ D IHZ EDG P RQH\ P DNHUV RI
W KHLUSURIHVVLRQ SHRSOHOLNH7\FKRGH%UDKH*RHW KH3\W KDJRUDVDQGKXQGUHGV
RIRW KHUVZHUHIUDXGV"

:LW KVLP LODUW KLQNLQJZHFRXOGQRZZRUNW RZDUGVGHYHORSLQJDQLQVLJKW LQW RFHUW DLQ

W KLQJVVW HSE\VW HS7KHQLW ZRXOGVW LOOW DNHDORQJW LP HXQW LOW KHZLVGRP RIRXU
DQFHVW RUVZRXOGFRP HW RW DONW RXVDQGW KRVHZKRDUHHDJHUW RDFFHSW LW ZRXOG
VW LOO QHHG W R UHP DLQ LQ W KH RXW HU FRXUW V IRU TXLW H D ZKLOH  1RZDGD\V KRZHYHU
W KHUHLVQRW P XFKW LP HW RORVHDQ\P RUH(YHU\W KLQJLVXUJLQJXVW RZDUGVDXQLRQ
RIW KHRQHVZKRNQRZDQGW KHRQHVZKRZDQW W RNQRZDQGW REHFRP H+RZHYHU
DQROGH[SHULHQFHW HOOVXVW KDW ZHFDQOHDUQW RVZLP RQO\LIZHKDYHW KHFRXUDJHW R
JRLQW RGHHSZDW HUV

2XU W LP H VSHDNV DQ HQW LUHO\ GLIIHUHQW  ODQJXDJH W KDQ W KH W LP H RI W KHVH VHFUHW
VFLHQFHV6HFUHW VFLHQFH :KHQM XVW KHDULQJW KHZRUGFHUW DLQSHRSOHJHW DQJU\
:KDW  ³ VHFU HW ´  LV W KHU H"  , VQ¶W  DOO N QRZ OHGJH FOHDU  DQG RSHQ  DFFHVVLEOH W R
HYHU\ERG\" 7KDW LVRQO\W UXHLQDYHU\OLP LW HGVHQVH&HUW DLQO\ZLVGRP FDQEH
IRXQGLQW KHVW UHHW DQG\HW IHZRQO\NQRZW RJUDVSLW  <RXFDQSXUFKDVHLW RQDOO
XQLYHUVLW LHVLQDOOERRNVW RUHVHYHQERUURZLW LQOLEUDULHVDQG\HW RQO\IHZVHHP W R
RZQLW :LVGRP LVOLNHP RQH\ZKLFKW RRFDQEHIRXQGLQW KHVW UHHW DQG\HW YHU\
IHZILQGLW HYHQW KRXJKLW ¶VVRQHFHVVDU\W ROLYHLQRXUGD\V%XW W KHUHKDYHEHHQ
W LP HVZKHQQRERG\KDGDQLQW HUHVW LQSLFNLQJXSW KDW P RQH\HYHQZKHQKHIRXQG
LW   7KH (GGD W HOOV XV W KDW  GXULQJ W KH W LP HV RI W KH DQFLHQW  ZLVH P HQ D JROG ULQJ
FRXOG OLH RQ W KH VW UHHW  IRU W KUHH \HDUV DQG QRERG\ ZRXOG SLFN LW  XS  3HRSOH RI
W KHVHW LP HVREYLRXVO\ZHUHVRZLVHW KDW W KH\GLGQRW QHHGP RQH\ DQGJROGW ROLYH
6KRXOGLW QRW EHYHU\YDOXDEOHW RILQGRXW KRZW KHVHSHRSOHXVHGW ROLYHDFFRUGLQJ
W R Z KLFK JXLGHOLQHV W KH\  VW U XFW XU HG W KHLU  VRFLHW \  LQ RU GHU  W R EH VR XW W HU O\
LQGHSHQGHQW  IURP  W KDW  ZKLFK DSSHDUV W R EH DEVROXW HO\ QHFHVVDU\ VXFK DV JROG"
:KHQ DIW HU W KH LQW URGXFW LRQ RI &KULVW HQGRP  LQ 6ZHGHQ W KH\ VW DUW HG W R FROOHFW

 2PLWWHG

:HGRQRW KDYHDQH[DFW W UDQVODW LRQRI³ *HLVW HVZLVVHQVFKDIW ´ VLP LODUW RW KH(QJOLVKZRUG³ P LQG´ 
W KDW GRHVQRW KDYHD*HUP DQFRUUHODW H ³ LQW HOOHFW XDOVFLHQFHV´ LVW RROLW W OHZKLOH³ VSLULW XDOVFLHQFHV´ 
JRHVW RRIDULQW RW KHUHDOP VRIW KHVSLULW XDO, W LP SOLHVERW K
 

DOP VDFFRUGLQJW RW KHUXOHVRIW KHFKXUFKW KH\KDGW RVHQGW KHP RQH\IURP W KH

LQKRVSLW DEOH 1RUW K W R W KH IHUW LOH , W DO\ EHFDXVH W KH *HUP DQLF IRONV KDG QR SRRU
SHRSOH  :KDW ZRXOGW RGD\¶VIRONVIURP W KH6RXW KGRLIW KH\ZHUHW UDQVIHUUHGW R
W KH 1RUW K"  7KH\ ZRXOG VW DUYH EHFDXVH W KH\ ZRXOG EH LQFDSDEOH RI P DLQW DLQLQJ
W KHP VHOYHV ZLW KRXW  W KH VXSSRUW  RI D ULFKHU QDW XUDO HQYLURQP HQW   :KLFK IRON
W KHQ KDV W KH KLJKHU VNLOOV"  7KH *HUP DQV W RR KDG P DGH W KH H[SHULHQFH RI JROG
DQGLW VFXUVHDW DODW HUW LP H:KHQW KH\EHFDP HVXIILFLHQW O\XQZLVHW RW KLQNW KDW
W KH\QHHGHGLW W KHQSRYHUW \FDP H

:K\"+HUHZHKDYHW RGHDOZLW KDVHFUHW W KDW ZHFDQILQGRSHQO\³ LQW KHVW UHHW ´

DQG\HW ZKLFKP LOOLRQVRISHRSOHFDQQRW VHHEHFDXVHW KH\UHSODFHGZLVGRP ZLW K
³ IDLW K´  DQG W KH ³ ORYH W K\ QHLJKERU ´ HYHQ LI KH LV W KH ZRUVW  RI KLV NLQG   , I W KHUH
ZHUH UHDOO\ QR VHFUHW  NQRZOHGJH ZK\ W KHQ DUH KXP DQV VR XQVSHDN DEO\ VW XSLG
W KDW W KH\DOORZEHLQJUXOHGDQGH[SORLW HGIRUFHQW XULHVE\IUDXGVRUE\GHIUDXGHG
RQHV"(DFKFRXQW U\HDFKFRQW LQHQW W KHZKROHZRUOGKDVHQRXJKVSDFHDQGIRRG
IRU DOO W R OLYH LQ SDUDGLVH LI W KH\ DYRLGHG ³ W KH GHW RXU DURXQG W KH DQLP DO´    7KLV
VHFUHW W RROLHVRSHQO\LQW KHVW UHHW VUHFRJQL]HGE\DIHZRQO\SLFNHGXSE\HYHQ
IHZHUSHRSOH

7KHUHZRXOGQHYHUKDYHH[LVW HGLQLW LDW HVDQGVHFUHW W HDFKLQJVLIDOOKXP DQVZHUH

VW LOOVRQVRIJRGVEHFDXVHLQVXFKDFDVHDOOKXP DQVZRXOGQHFHVVDULO\XQGHUVW DQG
W KHP RVW LP SRUW DQW W KLQJVLQOLIHDVVRP HW KLQJW KDW ¶VVLP SO\P DW W HURIIDFW 7KH
IDFW  W KDW  VHFUHW  GRFW ULQH EHFDP H QHFHVVDU\ DQG ZKLFK LQGHHG LV YDOLG VW LOO LQ RXU
GD\V HYHQW KRXJKW KHXOW LP DW HVHFUHW VVKRXOGEHREYLRXVW RDOOEXW HVSHFLDOO\W KH
VFKRODUV DUH GHQ\LQJ LW V H[LVW HQFH  LV SURRI IRU W KH W ULSOLFLW \  RI ³ *|W W HU ´  JRGV 
³ *RW HQ´ XQG³ .|W HU ´  , W ¶VVW LOOYDOLGLQRXUGD\V2QO\W KH*RW KVKDYHLQKHULW HG
P HP RULHVRIIRUP HUVW DW HVRIW KH(DUW KVDJDVRIIORRGVLFHDJHVHW F7KRVHZKR
ORVW W KHLU$U\DQVRXOZKRDUHW RRKXP DQHLW KHULQP LQGRUERG\VXE KXP DQVW KDW
DUHGHFD\HGZLW KW KHEORRGRIDSHVNQRZRIQRLQKHULW HGP HP RULHVDQGW KHUHIRUH
W KH\ GHQ\ LW V H[LVW HQFH  &RQVHTXHQW O\ HYHU\ W KLUW \ \HDUV W KH\ QHHG W R FOLQJ W R
HYHU QHZW KHRULHVZKHQW U\LQJW R³ VFLHQW LILFDOO\´ SUREHW KHSDVW 

%\ W KH ZD\ ZKRHYHU ZDQW V W R JR W R W KH URRW V RI DOO VHFUHW  GRFW ULQHV QHHGV W R
XQGHUVW DQG *HUP DQ DQG XQGHUVW DQG LW  YHU\ ZHOO EHFDXVH W KH NH\  W R DOO VHFUHW
W HDFKLQJV OLHV LQ W KH $U\DQ 8U ODQJXDJH ZKLFK UHP DLQHG VHFUHW  ODQJXDJH RI W KH
$U\DQSULHVW KRRGIRUDORQJW LP HW RZKRP W KH*HUP DQODQJXDJHLVFORVHVW VLQFH
LW LVLW VROGHVW GDXJKW HU

, W LVHDV\W RGHQ\LQW XLW LRQLQVSLUDW LRQKHULW DJH P HP RULHVRIZKLFKFRQVLVW VDOORI

RXUNQRZOHGJHZKLFKDFW XDOO\LVUH GLVFRYHU\DQGFRQW LQXRXVUH GLVFRYHU\LIRQH
GRHV QRW  KDYH W KHVH JLIW V RU KDV W KHP  RQO\ P LQLP DOO\ ZKLFK W KH VFKRRO DQG RXU
SODLQLQW HOOHFW XDOW KLQNLQJVXSSUHVVHVHQW LUHO\RUGXOOVLW (YHQW KHIDFW W KDW [

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

  ZDV QRW  ³ FDOFXODW HG´  IRU W KH ILUVW  W LP H EXW  LW  ZDV DFTXLUHG DV D UHVXOW  RI
LQVLJKW 

7RGD\¶VVFKRODUVFODLP WKDWWKHILYHVHQVHVDUHVXIILFLHQWIRUUHVHDUFKDQGH[SHULHQFH
7KLVLVDJUDYHP LVW DNH, QVXFKDFDVHDOODQLP DOVZRXOGEHDKHDGRIXVZLW KRXW
H[FHSW LRQ7RRXUFRQVRODW LRQZHFDQUHP HP EHUW KDW HYHQW KHP LQXW HVW UHVXOW RI
RXUW KLQNLQJFDQEHJDLQHGRQO\ZLW KW KHKHOSRIDFKDUDFW HULVW LFRIW KHVRXORURI
W KHVSLULW VXFKDVLOOXP LQDW LRQKXQFKHVLQVLJKW VRUUHYHODW LRQ

6RW KHUHDUHVW LOOP DQ\VHFUHW VZKLFKW RVHHRQHKDVW RKDYHH\HVZKLFKW RKHDU

RQH KDV W R KDYH HDUV DQG D JRRG ZLOO W RZDUGV ERW K RI W KRVH DQG W KH JLIW  RI
P HP RU\ 7KRXJKW VDUHQRW P DW HULDOW KHVDP HZD\DVHOHFW ULFLW \W KHH[LVW HQFHRI
ZKLFK, UHFRJQL]HLQLW VHIIHFW VEXW ZKLFK, GRQRW VHH6KRXOGW KHW KRXJKW VRIP \
IRUHIDW KHUVFRP HW ROLIHZLW KLQP \VHOIEHW KHUH"6KRXOGW KH\QRW JHQHUDW HZDYHV
LQ W KH VSDFH IRU HYHU\ SHUVRQ P H LQFOXGHG DQG UHDG\ W R EH XQGHUVW RRG E\ P H
ZKHQ, DP DW W XQLQJP \VSLULW XDOUHFHLYHUP \VRXORQW RW KHLUZDYHOHQJW K":KR
XQQDW XUDOO\ FRQYLQFHV KLP VHOI W KDW  VXFK D W KLQJ GRHV QRW  H[LVW  ZLOO QHYHU FDW FK
W KRXJKW ZDYHV$OONQRZOHGJHLVLQKHULW HGP HP RULHVVD\V3ODW R

7KLVKDSSHQVW RP RVW SHRSOHDQGW KDW LVW KHUHDVRQZK\W KH\DU HVRSRRUZKHQLW

FRP HV W R LQVLJKW V  0DQ\ SHUVRQV KDYH \HDU ORQJ VXEVFULSW LRQV W R W KH UDGLR
OLVW HQLQJW RLW EXW KRZIHZRIW KHP UHDOO\DUHRQW KHORRNRXW IRUDIXOOGD\HYHQ
M XVW KDOIDGD\DQGOLVW HQW KRXJKW VIURP W KH&RVP RV"/HW XVQRW IRUJHW W KDW RXU
RZQ W KRXJKW V DUH EXW  EURDGFDVW  IUHTXHQFLHV RI FRVP LF W KRXJKW V   , VQ¶W  LW  VW XSLG
W KHQ ZKHQ VRP H FDOO XV ORDIHUV DQG OLDUV LI ZH DUH FDSDEOH RI EULQJLQJ LQ P RUH
H[SHULHQFH W KDQ P DQ\ RW KHUV ZLW K W KHLU ³ ILYH VHQVHV´ "  7KHVH ³ ILYH VHQVHV´  DUH
KDUGO\IXQFW LRQLQJSURSHUO\DQ\P RUHLQSUDFW LFDOO\DOORIRXU RSSRQHQW V, VQ¶W LW
DP D]LQJ W KDW  D ³ VDYDJH´  ZKR OLYHV LQ W KH VW HSSHV ZKHQ VW DQGLQJ LQ D FHUW DLQ
ORFDW LRQFDQUHFRJQL]HKRXUVHYHQGD\VDIW HUW KHIDFW LIDVW UDQJHURUP HP EHURI
KLV W ULEH KDG SDVVHG E\ W KHUH  ZKLOH W KH LJQRUDQW  ³ FXOW XUDO´  KXP DQ RI RXU GD\V
FDQQRW SHUFHLYHZLW KQRVHRUHDUOHVVHYHQZLW KH\HJODVVHVRU P DJQLI\LQJJODVV
ZKHW KHU RU QRW  D VW HDP  UROOHU GURYH W KURXJK W KH ZRRGV W ZR P LQXW HV DJR"  , W
FHUW DLQO\ LV W UXH W KDW  W KH ³ OHDVW  FXOW XUDO´  P HGLFLQH P HQ RI DOO FRQW LQHQW V SHUIRUP
P LUDFXORXVW KLQJVRQDGDLO\EDVLVRIZKLFKH[SORUHUVP LVVLRQDULHVDQGP HUFKDQW V
UHSRUW HYHQIURP W KHIDUDZD\M XQJOHV$UHQ¶W W KHUH, QGLDQVZKRDUHEXULHGDOLYH
DQGULVHDJDLQIRXUP RQW KVODW HU":HOOHQRXJKQRZRIDOOW KHVHVHFUHW VW KDW DUH
REYLRXV DOO RYHU W KH ZRUOG  3HRSOH DGP LW  W KDW  W KH , QFDV DQG $]W HFV KDG VHFUHW
NQRZOHGJH DQG SRZHUV W KDW  W KH SULHVW V LQ 7LEHW  FDQ GR D ORW  P RUH W KDQ M XVW  HDW
EUHDG DQG GULQN ZLQH W KDW  DFFRUGLQJ W R 7KRP DVLXV D W HDFKHU RI ODZ VLQFH W KH
SRSH *UHJRU\ W KH *UHDW    QLQH DQG D KDOI P LOOLRQ KHUHW LFV ZHUH W RUW XUHG
SHRSOHZKRZHUHRXUVHHUVDQGZLVHZRP HQ$FFRUGLQJW RRW KHUVRXUFHVXSW R
P LOOLRQ SHRSOH VXIIHUHG W KDW  IDW H ZKLFK QXP EHU GLG QRW  LQFOXGH W KRVH ZKR GLHG
EHFDXVH RI W RUW XUH  0RUHRYHU W KH\ ZHUH W UHDW HG W KLV ZD\ EHFDXVH W KH\ NQHZ
5XQH ZLVGRP  DQG UXQH SRZHUV DQG \HW  W KH FKXUFK ZDV XQDEOH W R H[W HUP LQDW H
RFFXOW SRZHUVDP RQJSHRSOHRIW KH1RUGLFUDFHHQW LUHO\DOW KRXJKDW W KRVHW LP HVLW
ZDVVXIILFLHQW RIDFULP HW RIDOOYLFW LP RIW KHLQTXLVLW LRQLIRQHZDVYHU\EORQGDQG
YHU\ EOXH H\HG  +XP DQV DUH UDYDJLQJ ZRUVH W KDQ W KH HOHP HQW V  &RP SDUHG W R
 

W KHVHQXP EHUVDQGDFW VHDUW KTXDNHVDQGLQXQGDW LRQVDUHQRW KLQJ (YHQW KRXJK

LW  VKRXOG EH REYLRXV W KDW  RXU GDLO\ OLIH DQG DFW LRQV KDSSHQ LQ W KH P LGVW  RI P DQ\
P LUDFOHVP DQ\GHQ\W KHH[LVW HQFHRIVHFUHW NQRZOHGJHDQGW KLQJVXQH[SODLQHG
GHQ\ FRQW HP SRUDU\ W KLQJV DQG KLVW RULFDO HYHQW V M XVW  EHFDXVH VFLHQFH KDV QRW
EHFRP HDZDUHRIW KHP \HW 

³ +RUDW LRW KHUHDUHW KLQJVEHW ZHHQKHDYHQDQGHDUW K

2IZKLFKRXUVFKRROZLVGRP ZRXOGQRW GUHDP ´ 6KDNHVSHDUH

3HRSOHNQRZKRZW RW DONRIW KHLQLW LDW LRQVRIW KH*UHHNVW KH(J\SW LDQVW KH5RP DQV
QDW XUDOO\ RI W KH DQFLHQW  RQHV EXW  W KH\ JULQ DUURJDQW O\ ZKHQ P HQW LRQLQJ W KHP 
$QG\HW DQFLHQW EXLOGLQJJXLOGVFDOFXODW HGGLIIHUHQW O\W KDQW RGD\DQGW KHLUGRP HV
VKRXOGFROODSVHDFFRUGLQJW RRXUNQRZOHGJHRIVW DW LFVFLHQFHP RUHVRDFFRUGLQJ
W R RXU EXLOGLQJ FRGHV W KH\ ZRXOG EH SURKLELW HG IURP  EHLQJ HUHFW HG EHFDXVH
DFFRUGLQJW RW KHVHDVVXP SW LRQVW KH\VKRXOGFROODSVH3HRSOHDU HVSHDNLQJRIW KH
IDFW  RI W KH )HP H M XVW LFH LQ :HVW SKDOLD W KDW  ZDV SUDFW LFHG VW LOO D KXQGUHG \HDUV
DJR  7KH\ VSHDN DERXW  W KH ³ +DEHUIHOGW UHLEHQ´   DERXW  VHFUHW V DQG LQLW LDW LRQV RI
W KH)UHH0DVRQVEXW W KH\GRQRW ZDQW W RDGP LW W KDW DQG\HDUV
DJRHYHQVW LOO\HDUVDJRH[W UDRUGLQDU\NQRZOHGJHRIVHFUHW ZLVGRP RIZKROH
FODQVDQGJURXSVZHUHEORVVRP LQJLQ*HUP DQ\7UXHZLVGRP FRP HVQRW E\ZD\RI
ZRUGVIURP W KHRXW VLGHEXW E\ZD\RILQQHULOOXP LQDW LRQ/LJKW LQJ XSOLJKW HQLQJ
XSOLJKW HQLQJZKLFKLVDQH[SODQDW LRQDFOHDULQJDQGZKLFKEHFRP HVDODGGHUD
OHDGHUZKLFKLQW XUQLVD³ OLJKW HU ´  VRP HW KLQJW KDW JLYHVOLJKW RXW RILQQHUSXULW \ 

/HW  XV DVVXP H D KXP DQ EHLQJ KDV EHHQ W UDQVIRUP HG LQW R D UDGLR EXW  KH ZRXOG
DOVR KDYH H\HV QRVH HDUV W RQJXH DQG IHHOHUV DQG KH FRXOG VHH VP HOO KHDU
W DVW H DQG IHHO W KH VP DOO ZRUOG DURXQG KLV SODFH RQ W KH ZLQGRZ RU RQ W RS RI W KH
W DEOHRUDQ\ZKHUHHOVH+HP D\HYHQJRRQW ULSVZLW KKLVRZQHU DQGZRXOGW KLV
ZD\ H[SDQG KLV KRUL]RQ KH ZRXOG DOVR VORZO\ OHDUQ DERXW  DOO W KLQJV W KDW  SHRSOH
DURXQGKLP GLGW KRXJKW DQGVDLG:RXOGQ¶W LW EHVW XSLGW RFODLP DERXW KLP W KDW
W KHUHGLGQRW H[LVW DQ\W KLQJEHVLGHVW KDW ZKLFKKDSSHQHGDURXQGKLP M XVW EHFDXVH
QRERG\\HW KDVFRQQHFW HGKLVLQW HUQDOUDGLRUHFHLYHUZLW KW KHZDYHVRIIUHTXHQFLHV
LQ W KH ZKROH ZLGH ZRUOG"  7KLV ZD\ KH ZRXOG EH VLP LODU W R D KXP DQ ZKR FODLP V
W KDW  W KHUH DUH QR UHDOLW LHV EH\RQG W KH ILYH VHQVHV M XVW  EHFDXVH KH KLP VHOI ZDV
LQFDSDEOH RU XQZLOOLQJ W R W KLV SRLQW  W R JHW  D FRQQHFW LRQ D FRQQHFW LRQ EDFN ZLW K
W KHZRUOGVRIIUHTXHQFLHVRIQDW XUHW KDW VXUURXQGVKLP 4XLW HW RW KHFRQW UDU\KH
ZRXOG RSSRVH VXFK H[LVW HQFH RI D YLEUDW LQJ FRVP LF SRZHU M XVW  EHFDXVH KH ZDV
ODFNLQJW KHFUHDW LYHZLOOW RHVW DEOLVKDFRQQHFW LRQ-XVW OLNHDUDGLRHDFKKXP DQ
SRVVHVVHV ³ UDGLR DFW LYH´  RUJDQV KH LV D VW DW LRQ ZLW K W UDQVP LW W HU DQG UHFHLYHU
ZKLFKFRQQHFW VKLP ZLW KRW KHUVW DW LRQVDQGNHHSVW KLVFRQQHFW LRQZLW KW KHLQYLVLEOH
DQG HYHQ P RUH UHDO VRXO VSLULW XDO DQG P HQW DO ZRUOGV RI W KH LQQHUP RVW  FRUH RI

$FW LYLW LHVLQW KHRDW ILHOGVW KDW KDYHSDJDQURRW V

:DKUH:HLVKHLW NRP P W QLFKW GXUFK:RUW HYRQDX‰HQKHUVRQGHUQGXUFKLQQHUH(UOHXFKW XQJ
(U OLFKW XQJ (U OHLFKW XQJ (UOHLFKW HUXQJ GLH HLQH (UOlXW HUXQJ  HLQH /lXW HUXQJ LVW  XQG ]XU /HLW HU
Z LUG ]XP  /HLW HU GHU Z LHGHUXP  HLQ /LFKW HU ´  LVW  DXV /DXW HUNHLW    *RUVOHEHQ DUW IXOO\ ³ SDLQW HG´
P HDQLQJZ LW KVRXQGVZ KLFKLQLW VW UXHP HDQLQJFDQRQO\EHJUDVSHGE\DSHUVRQZ KRLVIDP LOLDU
Z LW KW KHJHUP DQODQJXDJH³ Z HOOIDP LOLDUZ LW KLW ´DV*RUVOHEHQSRLQW HGRXW HDUOLHU , DP VRUU\W R
VD\W KDW DP HUHW UDQVODW LRQFDQE\QRP HDQVFRQYH\W KHIXOOP HDQLQJRIW KHVHZRUGV
 

QDW XUH ZKLFK LV FDOOHG OLIH ZKLFK FRQW DLQV DOO W KLQJV DQG LV SDVW  SUHVHQW  DQG
IXW XUHVLP XOW DQHRXVO\DQGZHDUHFHUW DLQDQGDZDUHRIW KLVLOOXP LQDW LRQDQGLQVLJKW
LQW KHVDP HZD\DV  SURYLGHGW KDW ZHFDQDQGZDQW W RW XQHLQW RW KHVH
YHU\ UHDO VSLULW XDO ZDYH OHQJW KV  , I W KH KXP DQ GHQLHV W KHVH SRVVLELOLW LHV ZKLFK
EHFRP HUHDOLW \IRUHYHU\RQHZKRZDQW VVRW KHQKHZLOOQHYHUDFKLHYHE\KLP VHOI
FRQQHFW LRQZLW KW KLVH[W UD RYHU LQQHU DQGXQGHU VHQVRU\ZRUOGZKLFKLVHQW LUHO\
VSLULW XDODQGQR³ VW XGLHV´QRNQRZOHGJHW KDW KHJHW VIURP RXW VLGHKLP FDQKHOS
KLP W KHUH:KRHYHULVUHDG\KRZHYHUZKRHYHULVLQW HOOLJHQW Z KRKDV³ RLO´ZKLFK
P HDQV³ bO´  VSLULW  RQKLVODP SKHW XQHVLQW RW KHVSLULW XDOW UXW KVRIW KHFRVP RV
ZLW K W KH KHOS RI KLV VRXO DQW HQQD DQG KH W KXV EHFRP HV UHFHLYHU RI DOO W KRXJKW V
DQGHIIHFW VRIW KHZRUOG+HLVFDSDEOHRIUHFRJQL]LQJLQW XLW LYHO\ VRXOZLVH VSLULW XDOO\
DOOW KDW UHP DLQVW RW DOO\XQUHDFKDEOHW RW KHEDUHILYHVHQVHVW KDW DUH³ H[DFW ´ DQG
HTXDOO\LQFDSDEOHW RGRVR+XP DQEHLQJVEHFDP HP \RSLFZLW KW KHLUERRNVKDOI
GHDI IURP  W KH QRLVH RI W KH ELJ FLW LHV ORVW  W KH FDSDELOLW \ W R VP HOO LQ W KH FKHP LFDO
VW HQFK RI W KH DXGLW RU LXP V RI XQLYHU VLW LHV ORVW  W KHLU  W DVW H GXH W R P L[HG DQG
RYHU FRRN HG IRRG ORVW  W KHLU  IHHOLQJ GXH W R W KLFN  FORW KLQJ DQG \HW  W KH\  W U XVW
H[FOXVLY HO\  W KHVH Z HDN HQHG VHQVHV DQG EXLOG RQ W KHP   7KHLU  N QRZ OHGJH LV
DFFRUGLQJO\

7KHKXP DQEHLQJZKRLVQRW VDW LVILHGZLW KM XVW KLVDQLP DOLVW LFVHQVHVW KDW VHUYH
W KHVSLULW XDOO\RULHQW HGKXP DQP XFKP RUHSURQRXQFHGO\DFW VLQDGLIIHUHQW ZD\
+HLVFDSDEOHW RUHFRJQL]HUHDOLW \LQW XLW LYHO\DQGURRW HGLQKLVVRXORXW RIDQLQW HUQDO
JUDVS RI W UXW K    $V DQ HYROYHG SRZHU FHQW HU RI DOO FRVP LF VW UHDP V KH LV HYHQ
FDSDEOH W R VKDUH VORZO\ VRP H RI W KH DEXQGDQFH W KDW  KH FROOHFW HG  :LW K W KLV KH
EHFRP HV D P LJKW \ VXSHU W UDQVP LW W HU RI FUHDW LYH W KRXJKW V W KDW  FRQW ULEXW H W R W KH
FUHDW LRQ RI W KH ZRUOGV ZKLFK W KRXJKW V KH SDVVHV RQ W R DOO ZKR KDYH JRRG ZLOO
JRRGGHVLUHJRRGUHFHSW LRQDQGJRRGFDSDELOLW LHVW RVKDUHW KHLUDEXQGDQFH+H
FRQQHFW V LQ FROODERUDW LRQ ZLW K W KH ³ LQW HOOLJHQFHV´ ZLW K W KH P HQW DO SRZHUV RI W KH
HQW LUHVSLULW XDOZRUOGW KDW EHFDP HUHDOLW \DQGW KXVKHEHFRP HVDP HP EHURIW KDW
³ VRFLHW \RIW KHVDLQW V´ ZLW KRXW UXOHVDQG³ E\ODZV´ZKLFKH[LVW HGDW DOOW LP HVDQG
ZKLFK DUH XQLW HG LQ FROOHFW LYH SRZHUIXO FUHDW LRQ DQG JLYLQJ  7KH\ GR VR ZLW KRXW
FRQJUHJDW LRQVDQGFRXQFLOVHYHQZLW KRXW SK\VLFDOW RXFKEHFDXVHLQGHHGW KH\DUH
FORVHUFRQQHFW HGZLW KHDFKRW KHUEHFDXVHRIW KHLUSK\VLFDO VSLU LW XDODOO SUHVHQFH
7KH\DUHW KHVRFLHW \RIW KH6HFUHW 6LOHQW 2QHVLQDOOODQGVDQGRQO\ZKRFDQW XQH
LQW RW KHLUFRVP LFZDYHOHQJW KZKRVW LOOLVFDSDEOHW ROLVW HQZLW KKHDUW DQGHP RW LRQV
LQW HOOHFW  DQG EORRG W R W KH P XUP XU RI W KH VRXQGV RI W KH ZRUOG 5XQHV KH ZLOO
SDUW LFLSDW HLQW KHLUFRXQVHOVDQGGHHGV

7KH FODLP  W KDW  HYHU\W KLQJ FDQ EH OHDUQHG LV W KH RSLQLRQ RI ORZ OLIH  )RU W KH
P LUDFXORXV P RVW  KXP DQV DUH ODFNLQJ LQQHU VNLOOV  7KHUHIRUH W KH\ DUH IRUFHG W R
ILQGVDWLVIDFWLRQLQ³ VFLHQFH´6FLHQFHQHHGVWREHFRP H³ SRHWU\´LH³ LQWHQVLILFDWLRQ´
DJDLQ  


$UHIHUHQFHW R³ DOH´ RLO *HUP DQ³ gO´ DJDLQKHSOD\VZLW KVRXQGVW RFRQYH\D³ GHHSHUP HDQLQJ
EHKLQG´ W KDW Z KLFKKHVD\V

:LVVHQVFKDIW P X‰Z LHGHUÄ 'LFKW XQJ´GK9HUGLFKW XQJZ HUGHQ
 

7KHVSLULW ZRUOGLVQRW FORVHGW R\RX

<RXUKHDUW LVFORVHG\RXUVHQVHVDUHGHDG
&RP HRQVW XGHQW EDW KHW LUHOHVVO\
7KHHDUW K ERXQGFKHVW LQW KHDXURUDRIW KHP RUQLQJ
*RHW KH

(YHU\ W KRXJKW  LQ W KH ZRUOG LV D W UXW K D OLYLQJ HQW LW \ RW KHUZLVH LW  FRXOG QHLW KHU
FRP H QRU H[LVW   , W  OLYHV HW HUQDOO\ DQG LW  FDQ QHYHU GLH EHFDXVH VLQFH LW  LV LW
H[LVW HGIURP W KHEHJLQQLQJRIDOOH[LVW HQFH$OOW KLQJVYDOXHVDQGW KRXJKW VHYHQ
LIW KHP RVW FRQW UDGLFW RU\RQHVSURGXFHW KHZRUOGYLHZ7KHUHIRUHQRQHRIW KHP
LVZURQJEXW DOORIW KHP DUHHTXDOO\W UXHLQDKLJKHUVHQVH$OOW KLQJVKDYHVHYHQ
VLGHVW LP HVVHYHQW LP HVVHYHQW \0RUHRYHUW KHLUP XOW LSOLFLW \JHQHUDW HVDXQLW \RU
2QHQHVV:HNQRZRIRQO\W ZRW UXHRSSRVLW HVW KDW HYHULUUHFRQFLODEOHDUHP XW XDOO\
H[FOXVLYH W KHZRUOGVRIW KH<HV DQGW KHZRUOGVRIW KH1R +RZHYHUW KHZRUOGV
RI W KH 1R GR QRW  H[LVW   7KH\ H[LVW  RQO\ LQ W KH GHOXVLRQ RI KXP DQV  7KLV LV VR
EHFDXVHZKDW HYHUQHJDW HVLW VHOIGRHVQRW H[LVW HYHQLILW VREM HFW ZDVODUJHHQRXJK
W RHQFRP SDVVW KHZRUOG<RXDUHFUHDW RUEHFDXVH\RXVD\<(6 W RDOODQGHYHU\
W KLQJ  <RX DUH GHVW UR\HU \RX DUH QRW KLQJ EHFDXVH \RX VD\ 1R   1HYHU VD\ 1R
%XW  ULVH \RXUVHOI W R W KH <HV  DQG W KHQ \RX DUH W KH ZRUOG DQG *RG   <RXU VSHHFK
VKRXOGEH <HV<HV :KDW ¶VEHORZW KLVW KDW ¶VHYLO:LW KRXUNQRZOHGJHZHDUH
DOZD\V VW DQGLQJ RQ W KH VKRXOGHUV RI W KRVH ZKR W KRXJKW  W KLQJV RYHU EHIRUH XV
(YHU\W KLQJ W KRXJKW  RXW  DUH W KLQJV W KDW  H[LVW  IRU D ORQJ W LP H  , Q W KLV UHVSHFW 
LQGHHGW KHUHLVQRW KLQJQHZLQW KLVZRUOG1RW M XVW KDVHYHU\W KLQJDOUHDG\H[LVW HG
EXW HYHU\W KLQJW KHUHLVH[LVW V:HUHFHLYHRXUW KRXJKW VRXUJLIW VDQGW KHW ULJJHUV
W RRXUGHHGVIURP W KHLP P HQVHFRVP LFVW RUHKRXVHRIHYHU\W KLQJW KDW LVKDSSHQLQJ
DQGRIHYHU\W KLQJW KDW LVEHFRP LQJ:HQHHGW RRSHQXSRQO\W RW KHVHLQIOXHQFHV
W RW KLVLQIOX[W KHQZHZLOOEHILOOHGZLW KZLVGRP DQGNQRZOHGJH:KDW LVGLIILFXOW
LV QRW  W KH UHFHLYLQJ LW VHOI EXW  W R JHVW DW H W KDW  ZDV UHFHLYHG DQG W R DOORZ LW  W R EH
ERUQLQW RW KHZRUOG

$W W KHW LP HRIW KHGHHSHVW DQGP RVW VW UHQXRXVW KLQNLQJZHP DNHW KHP RVW LGLRW LF
IDFHV$OOOLIHZDVUHP RYHGIURP RXUIDFHVDQGUHW UDFW HGLW VHOILQZDUGVW RFRRSHUDW H
:KDW UHP DLQVDVDQH[SUHVVLRQRIW KHIDFHKDVP XFKVLP LODULW \Z LW KDGHDW KP DVN
)URP W KLVZHFRP HW KHQW RDFRQFOXVLRQW KDW LW VQRW XVZKRDUHW KLQNLQJEXW W KDW
LW W KLQNVZLW KLQXV 7RW KLVSRLQW QRVFKRODURUVFLHQW LILFJU RXSQRXQLYHUVLW \QR
QHZVSDSHURUP DJD]LQHKDGW KHFRXUDJHRUW KHLQVLJKW W RVXSSRUW W KLVUHVHDUFK
ZKLFK LQ IDFW  W KUHDW HQ W R RYHUW KURZ W KH H[LVW LQJ ZRUOGYLHZ  +RZHYHU VORZO\ LW
ZRQ¶W EHDYRLGDEOHDQ\P RUHVFLHQFHW RRHVSHFLDOO\*HUP DQLVW LFVFLHQFHZKLFKW R
W KLVSRLQW ZDVW RRP XFK³ DFDGHP LFGLVFLSOLQH´ DQGW KHUHIRUHUHQRXQFHGDOOLQQHU
DQGRYHUYLHZLQLW VUHVHDUFKEHFRP HVDZDUHRIW KHIDFW W KDW LW ZDVRYHUW DNHQ, W
ZLOOUHFRJQL]HW KDW LW LVW LP HW RGURSW KHRQH VLGHGSXUVXLW RIVFLHQFHLQDOOILHOGVRI
KLVW RULFOLQJXLVW LFUDFLDODQGUHOLJLRXVUHVHDUFKW KDW KDSSHQVRQO\IRUW KHSXUSRVH
RIVLP SOHNQRZOHGJHDQGH[W HQGHGEXUHDXFUDF\W KDW LW LVW LP HW RSXW UHVHDUFKLQ
W KHVHUYLFHRIDZRUOGYLHZDQGLGHDRI*RGW KDW VXSSRUW RXUOLYHVW KDW FDQGHP DQG
SURYDELOLW \DQGHYLGHQFHLQW KHLUHOHYDW HGKLJKHUFKDUDFW HULVW LFV3URYDELOLW \W KDW
LV QRW  EDVHG RQ W KH GHFHLYLQJ ILYH VHQVHV EXW  ZKLFK LQ DGGLW LRQ LQFOXGHV W KH
LP P HGLDW HSRZHUVRILQVLJKW DQGLQVSLUDW LRQ7KH\KDYHW RW HOOW KHSHUVRQVZKR
 

DUHQRW \HW FRP SOHW HO\ZLW KRXW KRSHW KDW LW LVQRW FUHDW LYHW RDOORZNQRZOHGJHW R
EH LP SDUW HG NQRZOHGJH W KDW  ZLOO QHYHU FRP H W R OLIH XQOHVV LW  LV ³ VHHQ´  IURP  D
SRVLW LRQ RI FR FUHDW LYLW \  , W ¶V QR ORQJHU D FKRLFH W R GHQ\ W KHVH SXUH DQG FOHDU
VRXUFHVRINQRZOHGJHW KDW DUHP XFKULFKHUM XVW EHFDXVHW KHSHUVRQGHQ\LQJW KHP
GRHVQRW KDYHW KHVHTXDOLW LHV6KRXOGZHEHEODP HGEHFDXVHZHW DNHLW XSRQXV
W RW HDFKP RUHRIW KHZRUOGDQGW KHW KLQJVW KHUHLQW KDQW KHVHHW HUQDOVW XGHQW VZKR
GR QRW  ULVN DQ\W KLQJ W KHLU QDP H P D\ EH ³ :DJQHU ´   EXW  ZKR ZDQW  W R ZHLJK DOO
W KDW ZKLFKLVQRW ZHLJKDEOH"

2QW KHVHW KLQJV, UHFRJQL]H\RXVFKRODUV

:KDW \RXGRQ¶W IHHOLVP LOHVDZD\IURP \RX
:KDW \RXGRQ¶W JUDVSW KLV\RXDUHODFNLQJHQW LUHO\
:KDW \RXGRQ¶W FDOFXODW H\RXEHOLHYHLVQRW W UXH
:KDW \RXGRQ¶W ZHLJKKDVQRZHLJKW IRU\RX
:KDW \RXGRQ¶W FRLQ\RXW KLQNKDVQRYDOXH
*RHW KH

/HW XVQRW GHFHLYHRXUVHOYHV ³ 6FLHQFH´ LVP HUFKDQGLVHW KDW DQ\EHJJLQJEXP FDQ
SXUFKDVHQRZDGD\VRQW KHXQLYHUVLW LHVZLW KP RQH\DQGW LP H+RZHYHURXUZLVGRP
DQGLQVLJKW DUHRQO\DFFHVVLEOHW RW KH*RRGRQHW RW KH³ *RW K´QRW W RW KH³ ZRUOG´
EHFDXVH W KH *RW K GRHV QRW  H[LVW  ZLW KRXW  SUHFRQGLW LRQV VXFK DV U XQ RII W KH P LOO
VFLHQFHEXW KHKDVW KHFRQGLW LRQRIEHLQJW KHVRQRIJRGKHLVW LHGW RW KHFRQGLW LRQ
RIVRQRI*RW K$OO³ ZRUOG´ FRQVFLRXVO\DQGQRQ FRQVFLRXVO\IDOVLILHVRUSUHYHQW V
W UXHZLVGRP DQGW UXHVFLHQFHE\DVNLQJVFLHQFHW REHRQO\³ REM HFW LYH´  DQG³ H[DFW ´
W KDW LW JLYHVXSDOOLQVLJKW DQGUHYHODW LRQ6XFKVFLHQFHLV³ REM HFW LYH´ DQG³ H[DFW ´
DFFRUGLQJW RW KHZRUW KOHVVP HDQLQJW KDW W KLVZRUGKDVUHFHLYHGZKHUHDOOKLJKHU
LQVLJKW  DQG KLJKHU YLHZ LV GHQLHG  7KH\ DUH URSHV W KDW  W LH W KH ZLQJV SUHYHQW LQJ
W KHP IURP RXUKLJKHVW IOLJKW VRIRXUP LQGV:HULGRXUVHOYHVRIW KHVHVKDFNOHV
ZHEUHDNW KHP LIW KH\ZLOOQRW RSHQHIIRUW OHVVO\³ ([DFW ´ VFLHQFHLHVFLHQFHW KDW
LVSUHFLVHVKDUSFDUHIXOFDULQJFRQVFLHQW LRXVSURYDEOHVW ULFW ZRQ¶W ORVHDQ\W KLQJ
LI LW  LV JXLGHG ³ LQW XLW LYHO\´  E\ LQQHU LQIDOOLEOH 'LYLQH YLVLRQDU\ SRZHUV KXQFKHV
DQGLQVSLUDW LRQV7KLVLVVREHFDXVHW KHVHODW W HUTXDOLW LHVFRP HIURP W KH8U URRW V
RI DOO W KLQJV ZKLOH W KH SRRU ILYH VHQVHV DOORZ XV RQO\ W R EHFRP H DZDUH RI EXW  D
VP DOOSDUW RIW KHZRUOG4XLW HW RW KHFRQW UDU\W KH'LYLQHLQW HOOLJHQFHZLOOSUHYHQW
W KH ³ KXP DQ´  HUULQJ LQW HOOHFW  LH W KH ³ RQO\ ORJRV´ W KH ORJLFDO RQH W KH /RNL W KH
/RJHRIW KH(GGDIURP GHYLDW LRQV:HKDYHW KHFRXUDJHW RGHULYHIURP W KLVW KH
QHFHVVDU\GHP DQGVW RRXUVHOYHVDQGW RW KRVHZKRZRUNZLW KXV(YHQW KHQRQ
W KLQNLQJDQGLUUHVSRQVLEOHSHUVRQLVDOUHDG\DZDUHRIW KHIDFW W KDW VFLHQFHFDQQRW
EHVHSDUDW HGIURP LQW XLW LRQDQGZLW KLW IURP VSHFLDOIDYRUDW W LW XGHDQGFRQQHFW LRQ
ZLW K*RG RW KHUZLVHZLVGRP ZLOOW XUQLW VEDFNRQXV, QW UXW KDOOLV2QHQHVVDQG
W KH VSOLW  EHW ZHHQ REM HFW  DQG VXEM HFW  EHW ZHHQ W KLQJ DQG SHUVRQ  LV DQ HUURU D
GHFHSW LRQZKLFKLVDGLVHDVHRUZHDNQHVVRIRXULQW HOOHFW XDOLQVLJKW 


:DJQHUDFKDUDFW HULQ*RHW KH¶V)DXVW 

2PLWWHG
 

0DW HULDOLVP  KDV W KURZQ W KLV RSLQLRQ LQW R RXU W KLQNLQJ EHFDXVH P DW HULDOLVP  ZLW K
KLV LQQHU GLVFRUG KLV SK\VLFDO DQG VSLULW XDO EDVW DUG QHVV W KDW  FDQQRW  JUDVS RU
XQGHUVW DQGDQ\FRQFHSW RI2QHQHVVRIDOOEHLQJFRQVFLRXVQHVVRIW KHGLYLQHDQG
KLJKHVW SXULW \7KHUHIRUHP DW HULDOLVP P DGHDQLGRORI³ REM HFW LYLW \´W KDW ZKLFKLV
LP SHUVRQDO LQ VFLHQFH DQG UHVHDUFK DQG DOO ZKR KDYH EHHQ DOLHQDW HG IURP  W KH
'LYLQHVXFFXP EHGW RLW VOXUH

, QW KLVP XUN\VRXSRINQRZOHGJHW KRVHZKRZHUHVHHLQJKDW W RILVKW RJHW KHUZLW K

W KRVH ZKR ZHUH EOLQG XQGHU HTXDO FRQGLW LRQV  7KH P DW HULDOLVW  LV LQFDSDEOH RI
EHLQJ VXEM HFW LYH LQ W KH VDP H LQW HQVLW \ DV W KH VSLULW XDOO\ RULHQW HG KXP DQ EHLQJ
EHFDXVHKHLVODFNLQJW KHSHUVRQDOLW \RIKLVEORRGW KHKLJKHVW EOLVVRIW KHFKLOGUHQ
RIW KH(DUW K7KLVZD\KHUREEHGW KHSXUHRQHVRIW KHLUSUHIHUHQFHRIW KDW ZKLFK
ZDVLP P HGLDW HDQGLQW URGXFHG³ REM HFW LYLW \´LHW KHUHQXQFLDW LRQRIW KDW ZKLFKLV
HVVHQW LDO LQ LQVLJKW   7KH KRQHVW  LQW HOOHFW  GRHV QRW  QHHG VXFK VKDFN OHV LH
REM HFW LYLW \  EHFDXVH LW  FDQ HQFRP SDVV DQG P DS RXW  VXEM HFW LYHO\  KLV ZRUOG RQ D
VP DOOVFDOH KLVP LFURFRVP DQGW KHZRUOGRQDODUJHVFDOHKLVP DFURFRVP 

6FLHQFHZLW KRXW VHOHFW LRQRIUHVHDUFKHUVOHDGVW KDW ZKLFKLVSXUHLQW RW KDW ZKLFKLV

LP SXUH  :H $U\DQV DUH FDSDEOH RI W KLQN RXUVHOYHV LQW R DQ\ W KLQJ DQG LQW R DOO
SHRSOHEHFDXVHRXU'LYLQH%ORRGIORZVLQDOORIW KHP 

7KH -RW H W KH ³ GRJ LQW HOOHFW XDO´ W KH -RW H RI W KH (GGD ZKR NQRZ V KXQGUHGV RI
W KLQJV W KH RQH IXOO RI QRW LRQV IXOO RI W ZLVW V KDV LQW HOOHFW  P RVW  RI W KH W LP H W RR
P XFKLQW HOOHFW EXW QRUHDVRQEHFDXVHUHDVRQLVXVHRIW KHLQW HOOHFW LQH[SHULHQFH
W KDW LVJDLQHGLQW KHSK\VLFDOEXW ZKLFKKDVW RKDYHVSLULW XDODQG'LYLQHSXUSRVHV
DVLW VJRDO, QW KLVUHVSHFW W KH-RW HLVP LVVLQJRXW HQW LUHO\DVGRHVHYHU\ERG\HOVH
ZKRW LHGXSLQW KHP DW HULDOODFNV*RW KLFORQJLQJ/LNHW KH-RW H:DEHUHUKHZLOO
ORVHKLVKHDGW R:RGDQW RW KH³ EUHDW K´W RW KHVSLULW ZKHQKHLVDVNHGDERXW W KH
LP SRUW DQW W KLQJVLQOLIH+HW KLQNVZLW KIRFXVW RZDUGVW KH(DUW KQRW XSZDUGV2XU
P DW HULDOLVW LFVFLHQFHVW DUHVW RW KHJURXQGLW KDVQR³ SUH FRQGLW LRQV´LW FDQQRW VHH
W KHZKROHRUW KHKLJKHUVW UXFW XUH6W UDLJKW IRUZDUGZHVSHDNRXW W KHW KRXJKW RI
ZKLFK&KDP EHUODLQKDGDKXQFKZKHQKHVDLG
 

6FLHQFH ZLW KRXW  SUH FRQGLW LRQV   W KDW  LV D FKDUDFW HULVW LF SKUDVH RI W KH GHP RQ RI
GHVW UXFW LRQ, QW ZRZRUGVDW RW DOFRQIXVLRQRIW KHZRUOG%HFDXVHZKDW P DW W HUV
LVQRW VFLHQFHEXW FXOW XUH$VFLHQFHW KDW LVQRULQW KHVHUYLFHRIFXOW XUHW KDW KDV
QRW DVSHFLILFFXOW XUHDVDSUH FRQGLW LRQLVW KHP DGGHVW P RQVW URVLW \W KDW DUDELG
KXP DQ EUDLQ FRXOG HYHU KDYH KDW FKHG   DOO VR FDOOHG VFLHQFH E\ LW VHOI LV W RW DOO\
LUUHOHYDQW LQIDFW ZHFRXOGGHILQHVFLHQFHDVNQRZOHGJHRIW KDW ZKLFKLVLUUHOHYDQW 
7KH SHRSOH ZKR P DNH W KH EDW W OH FU\ RI VFLHQFH ZLW KRXW  SUH FRQGLW LRQV UHIHU W R
NQRZOHGJH DQG DW  W KH VDP H W LP H LJQRUH W KH ILUVW  ODZ RI DOO QDW XUH  2Q W KLV \RX
P D\UHFRJQL]HW KHHQHP \DQGEHZDW FKIXO´

:KHQZLOOW KH³ H[DFW RQHV´ ZKLVW OHEDFNW KHLU³ LQIHUQDOGRJV´ZKLFKKHOGRQW KH

VKRUW FKDLQRIW KHLUVDODULHVEDUNDW HYHU\+HUP RGLHHYHU\SHUVRQZLW KDKLJK
ZLOODQGFRXUDJHZKRLVERXQGW RSDVVW KHP RQKLVULGHW RW KHXOW LP DW HTXHVW LRQV
RIOLIH"

, W  LV D FKDUDFW HULVW LF RI DOO ZKR DUH LQ FKDLQV W KDW  W KH\ SRVVLEOH EHFDXVH RI W KHLU
ODFNRIIUHHGRP EDUNDW DQ\RQHZKRDSSURDFKHVW KHP QRP DW W HU ZKHW KHULW ¶VD
IULHQGRUDQHQHP \RIW KHKRXVH

:HGLIIHUIURP W KRVHZKRDUHW LHGXSE\W KHLUGHVW LQ\W KDW ZHFDQFRQW LQXHW RILQG

W KLQJVZKHUHW KH\GHFLGHGW RVW RSVHHNLQJ:HKRSHW KDW LQW LP HVRIDVHULRXVZLOO
RI U HQHZDO W KH *RW KLF SRZ HU V SU RYH W R EH VW U RQJHU  W KDQ W KH ³ KXP DQ´  RQHV
RW KHUZLVHRXU³ QHZOLIH´ ZRXOGEHLQDEDGVW DW H

+DLOKLP ZKRFUHDW HVQHZGDQFHV

/HW ¶VGDQFHW RDW KRXVDQGW XQHV
2XUDUW VKRXOGEHIUHH
$QGM R\IXORXUVFLHQFH
1LHW ]VFKH
 

, , .;N; .;=?

³$QGDJDLQP LUDFXORXVO\ZHILQG
, QH[XEHUDQW O\JURZLQJJUDVVW KHGLFHVRIJROG
7KDW RQFHLQW KH8U W LP HVZHUHSRVVHVVLRQRIW KH$HVLU
7KHQD*UHDW RQHULGHVW RW KHFLUFOHRIW KHFRXQVHOV
7KH6W URQJRQHIURP DERYHW RHQGW KHGLVSXW H
:LW KDVHW W OLQJM XGJP HQW KHGHFLGHVLW DOO
$QGHW HUQDOO\VKRXOGODVW W KDW ZKLFKKHFRQVHFUDW HG´
(GGD

7KHFHQW HURIOLIHRIKLVW RU\LVW KHKXP DQEHLQJ, QVSLW HRIDOOVFLHQFH

RI DQW KURSRORJ\ ZH NQRZ YHU\ OLW W OH DERXW  KLP   :KDW  W KH DQDW RP LVW
FXW VXSIURP DFRUSVHRQDFROGW DEOHLVQRW KLQJEXW W KHVKDEE\ OHIW RYHU
RI D EORRP LQJ KXOO W KDW  ZDV ILOOHG ZLW K OLIH DQG ZLW K W KH 'LYLQH  :KDW
W KHQ LV W KH GLIIHUHQFH EHW ZHHQ ERG\ VRXO DQG VSLULW "  :KDW  LV W KH
P HDQLQJRIW KHP XFKGLVSXW HG\HW YHU\FOHDUQRW LRQRIW KHUDFH"7KLV
LVDZRUGW KDW LQLW VVRXQGDOUHDG\FOHDUO\UHIHUVW RVRP HW KLQJRULJLQDO
EDVLFURRW OLNHHYHQZKHQLW LVXVHGLQFRUUHFW O\

:H FDQ RQO\  W KHQ Y LHZ  DQG GLVVROYH W KH LQFRKHU HQW  OXP S RI UDFH
TXHVW LRQVZKHQZHQRW RQO\ILQGRXW DERXW UDFHRIZKROHQDW LRQVEXW
DOVRKDYHDFOHDUXQGHUVW DQGLQJRIUDFHDQGUDFH QHVVRIW KHLQGLYLGXDO
KXP DQEHLQJ

:KDW LVUDFH":KHQUHIHUULQJW RGRJVDQGKRUVHVZHDUHFHUW DLQO\LQ

DJUHHP HQW  DERXW  W KLV SRLQW   :KHQ LW  FRP HV W R KXP DQV W KHUH ZHUH
GRXEW V DERXW  XVHIXOQHVV RI VXFK D TXHVW LRQ IRU D ORQJ W LP H  'RXEW V
ZKLFKZHUHW KHUHVXOW RIW KHLQIOXHQFHRIORZUDFHV1RZDGD\VRQO\D
IHZZKRDUHLQFDSDEOHRIWDNLQJDQ\DGYLFHDUHOHIWZKRGHQ\WKHGLIIHUHQW
W UDLW VSK\VLFDODQGP HQW DORQHVRIW KHYDULRXVKXP DQUDFHV:LW KRXW
GRXEW  W KRVH DUH ULJKW  ZKLFK VD\ W KDW  QR QDW LRQ LQ (XURSH XQLIRUP O\
EHORQJVW RRQHVLQJOHUDFH3HUKDSVZHVKRXOGDVNLIZHKDGKHUHVW LOO
VW ULFW O\ORZ UDFHSRSXODW LRQVLQW KHSDVW \HDUV$OOSHRSOHVLQRXU
WLP HVKDYHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIUDFLDOP L[LQJDQGGHSHQGLQJRQWKHSHRSOH
W KHUHVXOW VRIVXFKP L[LQJDUHP RUHRUOHVVSURQRXQFHG
 

, QVSLW HRIDOOW KDW ZHFDQDQGP XVW VSHDNRIDSHRSOHEHORQJLQJW RDVSHFLILFUDFH

EHFDXVHW KHSURSRUW LRQLQZKLFKRQHUDFLDOFRP SRQHQW UHODW HVW RDQRW KHUZHDNHU
RQH GHW HUP LQHV ZKDW  W KDW  SRSXODW LRQ LV LQ D UDFLDO VHQVH  :H *HUP DQV DUH
DFFRUGLQJW RRXUSK\VLFDOVRXODQGVSLULW XDOOD\HULQJDQ$U\DQSHRSOHLQVSLW HRI
H[W HQVLYHUDFLDOP L[LQJ&RQVLGHULQJW KHVLW XDW LRQLQW KHZRUOGEHLQJ$U\DQVZH
DUHFDOOHGXSRQW RGHIHQGRXUSK\VLFDOVRXODQGVSLULW XDOKHULW DJHDJDLQVW W KHUHVW
RIW KHZRUOGLQIDFHHYHQDJDLQVW SDUW RIRXURZQEORRG:HDUHDZDUHW KDW W KH
*HUP DQIRONGRHVQRW OLYHDQ\P RUHLQDSHUIHFW UDFLDOXQLW \, QP DQ\UHVSHFW VLW
KDV DVVLP LODW HG IRUHLJQ UDFLDO FRP SRQHQW V W KH SURSHUW LHV RI ZKLFK LW  HOLP LQDW HV
P RUH RU OHVV VXFFHVVIXOO\  'XULQJ JRRG W LP HV W KHUHIRUH W KH VSLULW XDO EDVLV DQG
SK\VLFDO OHDGHUVKLS RI RXU IRONLVKQHVV LV VW LOO W KH $U\DQ EORQG DQG W DOO KXP DQ
$OW KRXJKZHGRQRW KDYHUDFLDOXQLW \DVDIRONW KHUDFHUHP DLQVLQH[LVW HQFHLQW KH
LQGLYLGXDOSHUVRQ%\W KLVZHP HDQW KDW W KHLQGLYLGXDOSHUVRQKDVUDFHLQLW VSXUH
IRUP  RU KH KDV VRP H P L[W XUH LQ JUHDW HU RU OHVVHU GHJUHH  , Q W KH FRXUVH RI W KH
P LOOHQQLD ZH ZRXOG KDYH ORQJ DJR W XUQHG RXW  W R EH D FKDUDFW HU OHVV P DVV RI
SHRSOH ZLW KRXW  GLIIHUHQFHV EHW ZHHQ HDFK RW KHU LI W KHUH ZDV QRW  W KH ODZ RI GH
K\EULGL]DW LRQDV0HQGHOKDVSURYHQZLW KKLVH[SHULP HQW VRQSODQW V7KHUHIRUH
W KHUH LV QR UHDVRQ QRW  W R DFFHSW  W KH IDFW  RI W KH VDP H HIIHFW V RQ KXP DQV DQG
DQLP DOV  (YHU\ RQH RI XV FDQ HDVLO\ W HVW  W KLV IDFW  ZKHQ KH M XVW  FRP SDUHV DQG
DQDO\]HVDOOLQGLYLGXDOVRIW KHSDVW W ZRJHQHUDW LRQVLQKLVRZQIDP LO\

*UHDW W LP HVDQGJUHDW SHRSOHUHFRJQL]HGW KDW QRW DOOUDFLDOK\EULGL]DW LRQLVKDUP OHVV

+\EULGL]DW LRQZLW KORZHUUDFHVHYHQLQDOP RVW HTXDORULQRYHUZKHOP LQJSURSRUW LRQV
P XVW EHDOZD\VGHW ULP HQW DOIRUW KHKLJKHUUDFH  , QHYHU\FDVHW KH\ZLOOEHSXVKHG
GRZQDIHZVW HSVIURP W KHLUSXUHKHLJKW RIW HQW KH\ZLOOVXIIHUW KHHQW LUHGHFOLQHRI
W KHLU XQLTXHQHVV DV W KH KLVW RU\ RI W KH SHRSOHV VKRZV XV  8SRQ H[DP LQDW LRQ RI
W KHLUW UXHRULJLQVVXFKKLVW RU\W XUQVRXW W REHQRW KLQJHOVHEXW DKLVW RU\RIW KHLU
UDFHV

:HGHP RQVW UDW HKHUHRQW KHH[DP SOHRI³ EHJHW W LQJDW DGLVW DQFH´ W KHHIIHFW W KDW
UDFHP L[LQJKDVRQDQLQGLYLGXDOSDLURIKXP DQV7KHSRZHURIW KHP DQW UDQVIHUV
W RW KHZRP DQZLW KKHUSUHJQDQF\&RQVHTXHQW O\KLVEORRGFLUFXODW HVLQW KHEORRG
RIW KHZRP DQDQGFKDQJHVLW W RVRP HH[W HQW DFFRUGLQJW RVRP HFKHP LFDODQDO\VHV
$OVRHP RW LRQDODQGRGLFW UDQVIHUVDQGLP SUHVVLRQVSOD\KHUHDU ROHW KDW W KHZRP DQ
ZLOO QHYHU ORVH HVSHFLDOO\ LI W KH FRQW DFW  ZDV D SURORQJHG RQH DQG LI P XW XDO ORYH
GHHSHQHGW KHUHODW LRQVSLULW XDOO\7KHVHIDFW VDUHDOUHDG\VXIILFLHQW O\NQRZQW KDW
W KH\FDQQRW EHGHQLHGDQ\P RUH$ZRP DQLVHVVHQW LDOO\LQIOXHQFHGE\W KHP DQW R
ZKRP VKHJDYHKHUVHOIDVDYLUJLQ7KLVSK\VLFDOHP RW LRQDODQGVSLULW XDOP HUJLQJ
KDV W KH FRQVHTXHQFH W KDW  FKLOGUHQ W KDW  UHVXOW  IURP  W KH XQLRQ W KDW  D ZRP DQ KDV
ZLW KDVHFRQGP DQZLOOKDYHW UDLW VRIW KHILUVW P DQHYHQLIQRFRQFHSW LRQKDSSHQHG
GXULQJW KDW W LP H7KLVLVVREHFDXVHDOUHDG\W KHP DOHVHHGFDXVHVDFKDQJHDVD
UHVXOW RIM XVW EHLQJDFFHSW HG3K\VLFDOO\DQGHP RW LRQDOO\VXFKFKLOGUHQRIVHFRQG
P DUULDJHDUHGHW HUP LQHGLP SUHJQDW HGDQGIRUP HGE\W KHILUVW P DQ6FLHQW LILFDOO\


2PLWWHG
 

Z H FDOO W K LV I DFW  ³ SK \ VLRORJLFDO LP SU HJQ DW LRQ ´  RU  ³ W HOHJRQ\ ´  Z K LFK  P HDQ V

LP SUHJQDW LRQDW DGLVW DQFH%\W KLVZHXQGHUVW DQGW KHDIW HUHIIHFW VRIW KHVSHUP
W KDW W KHZRP DQDFFHSW HGZKLFKLVDFRQW LQXRXVLQIOXHQFHXSRQDOOODW HURIIVSULQJ
E\W KHILUVW VXFFHVVIXOLQW HUFRXUVHZLW KDP DOH

7KH DQLP DO EUHHGHU LV DZDUH RI W KHVH W KLQJV IRU D ORQJ W LP H DQG KH DGM XVW V W R
W KHP ZKHQKHGHVLUHVSXUHEUHHGV 

7KH LP SUHJQDW LRQ RI W KH ZRP DQ LH W KH SHUP DQHQW  LP SUHJQDW LRQ E\ W KH ILUVW
P DQ ZKR SRVVHVVHG KHU FDQ EH H[SODLQHG E\ W KH IDFW  W KDW  P ROHFXODU FRP SOH[HV
DUH JHW W LQJ ORRVH IURP  W KH FHOOV RI W KH IUXLW  ZKLFK HQW HU W KH EORRG VW UHDP  DQG
DGKHUHW RW KHFHOOVRIW KHP RW KHUSUHIHUDEO\W KHVH[XDOFHOOVZKHUHW KH\DUHXVHG
LQW KHEXLOGXSRIDQHZJHUP W KDW KDVEHHQRULJLQDW HGE\DQRW KHUVSHUP :HFDQ
UHIHU W R W KLV DV D KRVW LOLW \ RI W KH P DOH VSHUP  W KDW  HQW HUHG ILUVW  DJDLQVW  DOO ODW HU
LQW UXGHUV+HUHZHKDYHW RGRZLW KDP HW D FKHP LVW U\RIZKLFKZHVW LOONQRZYHU\
OLW W OH 

)URP W KHNQRZOHGJHRIW KHVHIDFW VVW HP VW KHROGFXVW RP RIW KH³ LXVSULP DHQRFW LV´
W KHULJKW RIW KHILUVW QLJKW E\W KHODQGORUGRUSULHVW ZKLFKHQYLVLRQHGW KHEUHHGLQJ
RIDSRSXODW LRQDQGQRW DQDEXVHRISRZHU 

$UHVXOW RIW KLV³ LQVW LW XW LRQ´ ZDVW KDW LQP DQ\DUHDVW KHKXP DQW \SHZDVHQQREOHG
E\ D UDFLDOO\ DQG VSLULW XDOO\ P RUH DGYDQFHG DULVW RFUDF\  7KH U HOLJLRXV EHOLHIV RI
P DQ\SHRSOHVZKHUHW KHILUVW QLJKW ZDVUHVHUYHGIRUW KHJRGVDQGGHP RQVDUHD
P HP RU\ RI W KLV FXVW RP  ZKLFK ZDV D FRP P DQGP HQW  W KDW  ZDV LQVW LW XW HG E\ W KH
$U\DQV ZKHQ W KH\ VHW W OHG LQ D ZRUOG W R EUHHG DQ LQIHULRU KXP DQLW \ W R JUHDW HU
KHLJKW V6W LOOLQRXUGD\VW KHUHLVDFXVW RP LQVRP HLQIHULRUUDFHVW RFHGHW KLVULJKW
W RDIRUHLJQHUEHFDXVHW KH\SHUFHLYHLW EDGODFNLIW KH\GHP DQGLW IRUW KHP VHOYHV 
'XULQJP HGLHYDOW LP HVLW ZDVVW LOOW KHULJKW RIW KHSURSHUW \RZQHUW RSDVVW KHILUVW
QLJKW DIW HUDZHGGLQJRIRQHRIW KHLUVODYHVZLW KW KHEULGH&OHULFVW RRP DGHXVH
RI W KLV LQVW LW XW LRQ DV P DQ\ GRFXP HQW V IURP  W KLV HUD DUH SURYLQJ  (YHQ ZKHQ
LP VHP LQDW LRQ GRHV QRW  KDSSHQ W KH RGLF W UDQVIHU ZLOO EH DFW LYH  LH W KH RGLF


 $FW XDOO\  QHZ  SXU H EU HHGV U HVXOW  IU RP  P XW DW LRQV  DQG RU  P HW KRGV RI VSHFLILFDOO\  RU LHQW HG
K\EULGL]DW LRQV Z LW K HP SKDVLV RQ QHZ  W UDLW V DQG IROORZ LQJ P HW KRGV RI LQFHVW  W R JDLQ YHU\ SXUH
VW UDLQV DQG W R HOLP LQDW H OHW KDO JHQHW LF IDFW RUV DV P XFK DV SRVVLEOH  7KLV P HW KRG RI Z KLFK *
REYLRXVO\Z DVQRW TXLW HDZ DUHLVFDOOHGW KHP HW KRGRI³ LQFHVW  K\EULGL]DW LRQ´

VLF  /DW LQIRU³ LQGHHG´

, QGHHGW KLVZ DVEODW DQW DEXVHRISRZ HUDQGLQVW LW XW LRQDOL]HGUDSH , FDQQRW LP DJLQHKRZ LQW KH
KHOO W KH ZRUW KOHVV DULVW RFUDF\ ZKLFK DV D UHVXOW  RI ³ SROLW LFDO P DUULDJHV´  ZDV W UDGLW LRQDOO\ P XFK
P RUH K\EULGL]HG W KDQ W KH IRON FRXOG HYHU KDYH KDG D EHQHILFLDO LQIOXHQFH XSRQ LW V SXULW \   7KH
KDELW  RI W KLV EXQFK RI SRZHU KXQJU\ DQG VOHD]\ FUHHSV W R IRUFH W KH ILUVW  IXFN IRU W KHP  LW  ZDV
QHYHU DQ\W KLQJ P RUH W KDQ W KDW   FHUW DLQO\ FRQW ULEXW HG P RUH W R EDVW DUGL]DW LRQ RI DQ HVVHQW LDOO\
SXUHIRONW KDQW RDQ\W KLQJHOVH , I*RUVOHEHQ¶VFODLP VRIW HOH LP SUHJQDW LRQDUHUHDOO\W UXHZKLFK,
VHULRXVO\GRXEW W KHQW KHHIIHFW VRIW KLVOHJDOL]HGUDSHE\LQIHULRU\HW P RUHSRZHUIXOLQGLYLGXDOV
ZDVP RUHGHVW UXFW LYHW KDQDQ\RQHRIXVFRXOGHYHQGDUHW RLP DJLQH )HZYHU\IHZRIW KHROG
DULVW RFUDF\ DP RXQW HG W R DQ\W KLQJ DIW HU W KHLU SRZ HU DQG W KHLU Z HDOW K W KDW  W KH\ V\VW HP DW LFDOO\
DQGOHJDOO\ULSSHGRIIIURP W KHIRONZHUHW DNHQDZD\
 

H[FKDQJHW KDW KDSSHQVXQGHUKLJKHVW HURW LFH[FLW DW LRQDFW VDVDQLP SURYLQJRUDV

DGHJUDGLQJIDFW RUGHSHQGLQJRQW KHFODVV YDOXHRIW KHP DQLQTXHVW LRQ 

7KLV ZD\ Z H FDQ XQGHU VW DQG W KH P DQ\ RW KHU Z LVH LQFRP SU HKHQVLEOH FDVHV RI
VLP LODULW LHVDQGGLVVLP LODULW LHVEHW ZHHQFKLOGUHQRIGLIIHUHQW SDUHQW V DVZHOODVW KH
GHFOLQHRIW KHLQW ULQVLFDQGRXW HUYDOXHVRIW KHUDFH

, QRXUGD\VLP SUHJQDW LRQSURGXFHVP RUHOLNHO\DVHOHFW LRQGRZQZDUGUDW KHUW KDQ

LQ  W K H X S Z DU G  G LU HFW LRQ   E HFDX VH W K H 7VFK DQ G DO  W K H VX E K X P DQ   FRQ W U ROV
HFRQRP LFDOO\FLW \DQGODQGLQRXUGD\V+HXVHVW KLVRSSRUW XQLW \W RP DNHXVHRI
KLV SRZHU ZLW K FUXGHQHVV DQG UXW KOHVVQHVV  +HUH RQO\ W KH LQVLJKW  FDQ KHOS W KDW
RXUZRP HQDQGJLUOVKDYHDERXW W KHVHW KLQJVDQGW KHKHDOW K\W DVW HZKLFKJHQHUDOO\
LVVW LOODFKDUDFW HULVW LFRIW KHZRP DQ QDP HO\W KDW VKHSUHIHUVW KHP DQRIKLJKHU
FKDUDFW HUDQGUDFHRYHUW KHVXEKXP DQEHFDXVHRQO\W KLVKLJKHUP DQFDQJLYHKHU
SHUP DQHQW EOLVVLQP DUULDJHIRUZKLFKW KHZRP DQLVORQJLQJ

7KHP DQRIW KHVXSHULRUUDFHW KHUHIRUHFDQDIIRUGW RGRP RUHZLW KRXW UHDOO\FDXVLQJ

DQ\ GDP DJH  , I KH LP SUHJQDW HV D YLUJLQ RI $U\DQ EORRGOLQH KH GRHV QRW  RQO\
SURFUHDW H IXUW KHU EXW  XSZDUGV  , I KH LP SUHJQDW HV D JLUO RI DQ LQIHULRU UDFH KH
P D\ QRW  DFW  ZLVHO\ EXW  KH GRHV QRW  GLVKRQRU W KH JLUO  +H P RUH OLNHO\ GLVKRQRUV
KLP VHOI LQ DQ ³ XQHTXDO´  SU RJHQ\   , I W KH JLU O Z DV XQW RXFKHG  W K HQ VKH ZDV
LP SUHJQDW HGE\DKLJKHUUDFHDQGW KHSURJHQ\RIODW HUOLDLVRQVZLW KP HQRILQIHULRU
UDFHVHOHYDW HVW KHLUSURJHQ\DERYHW KHLUSDUHQW V7KLVREVHUYDW LRQGRHVQRW SXW
LQW RDFFRXQW W KH0HQGHOLDQODZRIVSOLW W LQJRIFKDUDFW HULVW LFV:KDW ZHKDYHKHUH
LV D P RUDO M XVW LILFDW LRQ RI W KH LGHD RI KLJK EUHHGLQJ  'LVFLSOLQH OHDGV W R KLJKHU
P RUDOVODFNRIGLVFLSOLQHOHDGVW RSK\VLFDODQGW KHUHIRUHP RUDOFROODSVH 

7KHUHIRUH W KH SXUH $U\DQ LV DFFRUGLQJ W R KLV FKDUDFW HULVW LFV W KH RQO\ RQH ZKR
QHYHU DEXVHV ZHDOW K DQG SRZHU  %HLQJ W KH KLJKHU KXP DQ KH QDW XUDOO\ KDV W KLV
SUHIHUHQFHV ZKLOH W KH VXEKXP DQ DOZD\V DEXVHG VXFK DGYDQW DJHV DJDLQVW  W KH
KLJKHU KXP DQLW \  7KHUHIRUH SURSHUW \ DOVR SURSHUW \ RI W KH KLJKHU ZRP DQ LQ W KH
KDQGVRIW KHVXE UDFH HTXDODP LVIRUW XQHIRUDOORIZKLFKIDFW RXUSUHVHQW W LP HV
DUHZLW QHVV7KHUHIRUHZHKDYHW RSDYHW KHZD\W RSRZHUDQGZ HDOW KFRQVFLRXVO\
IRUW KH$U\DQEHFDXVHKHLVW KHEHQHYROHQW W KHJHQHURXVDQGW KHERUQP DVW HU
ZKRLVSUHGHVW LQHGW RVKDUHKLVVXUSOXVRIZRUOGO\DQGVSLULW XDOJRRGV

 <RX ILQG ³ JXHVW  SURVW LW XW LRQ´  P RVW O\ Z LW K SHRSOHV Z KR DUH W KLQO\ VSUHDG RXW  RYHU ODUJH DUHDV
VXFK DV LQ W KH SRODU UHJLRQV  7KH W ULEHV Z KR SUDFW LFHG LW  DVVXUHG DQ LQIOX[ RI QHZ  JHQHV DQG
W KHUHIRUHKDGDQHYROXW LRQDU\DGYDQW DJHRYHURW KHUVZKRVRRQVXIIHUHGW KHGLUHFRQVHTXHQFHVRI
LQEUHHGLQJRQHRIZ KLFKLVW KHHP HUJHQFHRIOHW KDOJHQHW LFIDFW RUV KHP RSKLOLDHW F
 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG


, W UDQVODW HG³ =XFKW ´ Z LW KGLVFLSOLQHDQG³ 1LFKW  =XFKW ´ Z LW KODFNRIGLVFLSOLQH=XFKW P HDQVDOVR
³ EUHHG´ RU³ EUHHGLQJ´ DQG1LFKW  =XFKW  8Q =XFKW LQW KHIROORZ LQJFKDSW HU P HDQV³ QRQ EUHHGLQJ´ 
RU³ Z URQJEUHHGLQJ´ *RUVOHEHQREYLRXVO\SOD\HGZ LW KW KHVHZ RU GVW RFRQYH\P XOW LSOHP HDQLQJV
VLP XOW DQHRXVO\
 

6FKRODUVKDYHGHW HUP LQHGW KDW W KHZRUG³ UDFH´ RULJLQDW HGLQ/DW LQODQJXDJH7KLV

LVQRW FRUUHFW 7KHP LVFRQFHSW LRQRULJLQDW HGLQW KHIDFW W KDW ZHGRQRW NQRZRXU
*HUP DQLFODQJXDJHVDVW KRURXJKO\DV/DW LQDQG*UHHN6LQFHERW KODQJXDJHJURXSV
W KH 5RP DQ DQG *HUP DQ RQHV DUH ERW K URRW HG LQ W KH $U\DQ ODQJXDJH  ERW K
FRQW DLQHVVHQW LDOO\W KHVDP HW \SHVRIZRUGVFRQFHSW VDQGFRQFHSW LRQV, QIDFW 
W KH 1RUVH ODQJXDJHV EHLQJ FORVHU W R W KH RULJLQDO ODQJXDJH DQG W KHUHIRUH OHVV
FKDQJHG KDYH SUHVHUYHG W KH P RUH RULJLQDO IRUP V LQ P DQ\ FDVHV  , QGHHG W KH
ZRUG³ 5DVVH´ LVQRW DORQHSURSHUW \RI/DW LQDVVRP HVFKRODUV IRUZKRP HYHU\W KLQJ
FRP HVW RDQHQGZKHQW KH\FDQQRW H[SUHVVLW DQ\P RUHLQ/DW LQODQJXDJH  SUHIHU
W RFODLP EXW LW LVDQRULJLQDO*HUP DQLFZRUGW KDW FRP HVIURP W KHDQFLHQW 1RUGLF
ODQJXDJHDQGZLW KW KLVLW KDVDOVRLW V*HUP DQURRW LH³ 5DW D´ZKLFKFHUW DLQO\LV
ROGHU W KDW  W KH ZRUG RI D \RXQJHU ODQJXDJH W KDW  KDV VSOLW  RII IU RP  W KH 8U$U\DQ
ODQJXDJH QDP HO\W KH/DW LQZRUG³ UDGL[´  URRW 

, Q ROG 1RUGLF ODQJXDJH LQ W KH ODQJXDJH RI W KH (GGD DQG LQ *HUP DQLF *HUP DQ
5DW DP HDQVURRW +HUHZHVW LOOKDYHLQGHHGW KHZRUG³ 5HW W LFKDQG³ 5DGL´  UDGLVK 
ZKLFKP HDQV³ URRW ´ DQGZKLFKGRHVQRW QHHGW RJREDFNW RW KH/DW LQ³ UDGL[´(DFK
ZRUG KRZHYHU KDV W R FRQFHSW V RI RSSRVLW H SRODULW \ QDP HO\ D P DW HULDO DQG D
VSLULW XDORQHVRP HW KLQJSRVLW LYHDQGVRP HW KLQJQHJDW LYH, QW KHROG1RUGLF5$7$
W KHVSLULW XDO8U QRW LRQLVVW LOOLQKHUHQW 

5DW K DQG 5DW KHU DUH W KH QDP HV RI JRGV LQ W KH (GGD  *RG W KHUHIRUH LV W KH 5DW D
LH W KH URRW  RI DOO W KLQJV   ³ KHUH D JUHDW  RQH ULGHV W R W KH FLUFOH RI W KH µUDW HU ¶´
5DW KD LQ ROG 1RUGLF P HDQV DOVR FRXQFLO SURFUHDW LRQ +HL 5DW  :HGGLQJ   +LJK
&RXQFLO +LJK 5DFH    , Q DQRW KHU P \W K RI W KH (GGD 2GLQ SXOOV KLV ³ GULOO´  5DW L
+HUHW RRLW LVW KH³ URRW ´ W KDW JURZVIURP W KH8U EDVLVRIDOOH[LVW HQFHZKLFKOHDGV
XVEDFNDJDLQW RW KH8U FDXVHVRIDOOH[LVW HQFH:LW KW KLVURRW ³ 5DW L´2GLQGULOOV
W KURXJKW KH³ P RXQW DLQUDQJHW KDW VHSDUDW HV´ W RIHW FKIURP *XQODGH W KLVP HDQV
M R\  RI ILJKW LQJ  M R\  RI IU HQ]\  W KH ³ GU LQN  RI OLIH´  RI H[ FLW HP HQW   SRHW U \  DQG
LQW HQVLILFDW LRQ  $Q 8U SURFUHDW LRQ P \W K RSHQV XS ZKHQ ZH DQDO\ ]H W KH ZRUG
³ UDW L´ZKLFKW HOOVXVW KHQW KHGHFLVLYHSURFHVVHVLQYROYHG5DFH5DVVH UDW DFDQ
EHVSOLW LQW RW KH$U\DQ8U V\OODEOHV DURUUDP HDQVDVZHNQRZDOUHDG\E\QRW 
6XQDQGW KHV\OODEOHW DP HDQVGHHGSURFUHDW LRQ5D W DW KHUHIRUHLVW KDW ZKLFK
KDV EHHQ SUR  FUHDW HG E\ W KH 6XQ LQ LW V UHYHUVDO DU W D W KH DUW V W KH FDSDELOLW \
W KH³ DULD´7KH$U\DQVW KHUHIRUHDUHW KHVRQVRIW KH6XQW KHVRQVRIW KHJRGV
OLIHLQP DQLQLW VKLJKHVW UHYHODW LRQLQW KH*RW KLQW KH*RRGRQHLQW KHJRGVLQ
ZKRVH FRXQFLO UDW  VSLULW XDOO\ LQ W KHLU UDFH UDVVH UDW D  SK\VLFDOO\ LQ W KH 5DW D
:KRHYHULVLQFDSDEOHRIIROORZLQJKHUHZKRHYHUW KLQNVW KDW VXFKGHGXFW LRQVDUH
DEQRUP DOKHKDVQRW \HW GLVFRYHUHGW KHODQJXDJHRIW KHVSLULW KHEHORQJVW RW KH
OHYHOVRIrot t ing,RI%HW UD\DO 9HU rat - XQJ 7KH5$7$ZLW KLQKLP W KH5DW  FRXQFLO 
LQRW KHUZRUGVW KHJRGZLW KLQKLP EHFRP HVW KH5DW W H W KHUDW 7KHUDW KDVLW V
QDP HIURP W KHIDFW W KDW KHOLYHVLQW KHUHDOP RIURW )ROORZLQJW KHDGYLFH 5DW RI
W KHJRGVP DQW KHODQJXDJHJDYHW KLQJVW KHLUQDP HQRW DUELW UDULO\HYHQZKHQ
ZHGRQRW NQRZW KHRULJLQDQGUHDVRQEXW DFFRUGLQJW RDSODQDFFRUGLQJW RD³ UDW ´
DGYLFH RIW KH³ UDW HU ´  W KRVHZKRJLYHFRXQFLO 7KHHUDRIW KH$U\DQVW KHUHIRUH


$FW XDOO\DQXQW UDQVODW DEOHLGLRP DW LFIRUP 
 

LVW KHURRW W KH³ UDW D´W KH³ UDVVH´ RIKXP DQNLQG6LQFHDOORW KHUUDFHVKDYHQRW
HYROYHG\HW W RW KH5DW DLW LVRXUW DVNW RDGYDQFHW KLVHYROXW LRQ

1RRQHLVW KHVDP HDVW KHRW KHUEXW HTXDOVKRXOGHYHU\ERG\EHZLW KW KH+LJKHVW 

+RZW RDFKLHYHW KLV"(YHU\ERG\VKRXOGEHSHUIHFW HGZLW KLQKLP VHOI

*RGDQGUDFHW KHUHIRUHDUHD2QHQHVV5DVVH 5DW D  ROG1RUGLF 5DW 5DW HU

W KHJRGV UDGL[W KHURRW RIDOOH[LVW HQFH7KHUHIRUH*RGDQG5DW DRU5DFHDUH
2QH7KLV2QHQHVVFDQQRW EHEURNHQDSDUW DQGW KHTXHVW LRQDERXW 5DVVH UDFH 
DERXW  5DW D DERXW  W KH URRW V LV D EDVLF TXHVW LRQ RI KXP DQ H[LVW HQFH D 'LYLQH
TXHVW LRQ DQ XW W HUO\ UHOLJLRXV P DW W HU  7KHUH LV QR QHHG W R W UHDW  W KH TXHVW LRQ
FRQFHUQLQJUDFHLQDVSLW HIXOP DQQHU5DFHLVD'LYLQHUHDOLW \ DQGRQDQ\OHYHOLW LV
D'LYLQHP DW W HUDVW DW HRIZRUG HYROXW LRQZKLFKLVP RUHRUOHVVZLW QHVVRIKXP DQ
HYROXW LRQ7KHUHLVQRGRXEW ZKDW VRHYHUW KDW QDW XUHW KH'LYLQHZLW KLQRXUVHOYHV
ZLOODOVRFDXVHW KHXSOLIW LQJRILQIHULRUUDFHVRYHUH[W HQGHGSHULRGVRIW LP H7KH
NLQGVW KDW DUHUHSUHVHQW DW LYHRIW KHKLJKHUUDFHVZLOOQHYHUDEXVHW KLVDGYDQW DJH
W RW KHSRLQW W KDW W KH\KDYHFRQW HP SW DERXW W KHORZHUUDFHVEXW W KH\ZLOOVW ULYHW R
KHOS W KHP   7KLV P HDQV RI FRXUVH W KDW  W KH\ KDYH D FHUW DLQ LQIOXHQFH RYHU W KHLU
\RXQJHUEURW KHUV

*RG DQG UDFH DUH D XQLW \   7R XQGHUVW DQG W KLV VW DW HP HQW  EHW W HU ZH KDYH KHUH D
GLDJUDP RIDW KRXJKW 

+HUHZHKDYHW KHV\P ERORIW KH³ HW HUQDOXQLRQ´RIW KHXQLRQRIW KHDERYHZLW KW KH

EHORZ W KH KH[ DJUDP  VL[ SRLQW HG VW DU VH[ XDO VW DU V\ P ERO RI OLIH LQ LW V GXDO
H[SUHVVLRQLQSRODUL]HGXQLRQ

7KLVFRQVLGHUDW LRQSURYLGHVXVZLW KW KHEDVLFSULQFLSOHVRIDW UXHSHUFHSW LRQRI*RG

DQGW KHZRUOGZLW KVSHFLDOHP SKDVLVRQUDFLDOTXHVW LRQV$OOW KLQJVRQW KLV(DUW K
DUH XOW LP DW HO\ DOZD\V LQW HUGHSHQGHQW  DQG EHORQJ W R W KH SK\VLFDO DQG P HQW DO
HYROXW LRQRIP DQNLQGQRP DW W HUKRZRSSRVLQJHYHQKRVW LOHW RZDUGVHDFKRW KHU
W KHVHW KLQJVP D\DSSHDURQW KHVXUIDFH

7KHUHLVQRGRXEW W KDW ZHDUHOLYLQJLQDW LP HRIUDFLDOFROODSVHDQGGHJUDGDW LRQ

HVSHFLDOO\ZKHQZHFRQVLGHUW KHOHDGLQJ$U\DQUDFH1RERG\FDQGHQ\W KDW W KLV
UDFHZDVDOHDGLQJRQHDQGVW LOOLVLQZKDW UHP DLQVRILW 'XU LQJDW LP HVSDQRIDW
OHDVW   \HDUV DOO FXOW XUHV RQ (DUW K KDYH EHHQ FUHDW HG E\ FODVVHV RI $U\DQ
 

OHDGHUVKLS  7KLVLVDIDFW RI(DUW KKLVW RU\DQGW KHW UXW KVKRXOGEHDFFHSW DEOHW R

HYHU\ERG\HYHQZKHQKLVHW HUQDOO\UHW XUQLQJHJR QHVVVHHP VQRW UHSUHVHQW HGLQ
W KLVUDFHGXULQJKLVSUHVHQW OLIHW LP H3HUKDSVZHFDQUHFRJQL]HDVDUHDVRQIRUW KH
UDFLDOFROODSVHW KDW W KHP DLQUHOLJLRQVKDYHEHHQVXSSRUW LQJW KLVUDFLDOGHW HULRUDW LRQ
GXULQJW KHSDVW P LOOHQQLD

*2'

0$/( )(0$/(
SRODUL]HG EDODQFH
326, 7, 9( 1(*$7, 9(

([SDQVLRQ ([KDOH
)RUZDUG <$1*

:+, 7(5$&(<(//2:5$&(%/$&.5$&(

&RQW UDFW LRQ , QKDOH

%DFNZDUG <, 1*

0$1 :, )(
0$55, $*(
+86%$1'   :20$1
352&5($7, 21

$QG LW  LV IRU W KLV UHDVRQ W KDW  ZH FODLP  ULJKW IXOO\ W KH FRQFHSW  RI D UHOLJLRQ IRU RXU
:HOW DQVFKDXXQJZKLFKZHFDOOW KH$U\DQRQH

+HURLQDQH[SDQGHGP HDQLQJRIW KHZRUGLVQRW M XVW W KHZDUULRURUW KHVROGLHURQ

W KHEDW W OHILHOGEXW HYHU\ERG\ZKRSHUFHLYHVKLVSUHVHQW OLIHDVDW HP SRUDU\SUHVHQW
W KDW DOORZVKLP W RP XOW LSO\DQGLQFUHDVHKLVVRXODQGKLVHJRXQGHUW KHDVSHFW RI
HW HUQDOUHW XUQV+HURLVZKRGRHVQRW M XVW LP P HUVHKLP VHOILQW KHVW ULYLQJIRUW KDW
ZKLFKLVW DQJLEOHEXW ZKRNQRZVW KDW W KHKXP DQEHLQJGRHVQRW OLYHIURP EUHDG
DORQH ZKRNQRZVW KDW W KHKXP DQEHLQJOLYHVIURP HYHU\ZRUGRI*RGW KDW FRP HV

 7KDW  LQ IDFW  FRQW UDGLFW V W KH IRXUW K URRW  UDFH P \W K RI DQ $W ODQW LV W KDW  VDQN VRP H 
\HDUVDJR
 

IURP  KLV P RXW K  , Q RW KHU ZRUGV KH OLYHV W KURXJK HYHU\ GHHG DQG W KRXJKW  W KDW
HOHYDW HV W KH KXP DQ H[LVW HQFH EH\RQG W KH EDUH QHFHVVLW LHV DQG P RQH\P DNLQJ
+HUR LV HYHU\ W UXH DUW LVW  SRHW  DQG P DQ RI *RG  KHUR LV W KH IDUP HU ZKR NQRZV
W KDW LW LVQRW M XVW KLVW DVNW RIHHGKLP VHOIDQGKLVIDP LO\EXW W KDW KHLVUHVSRQVLEOH
IRUW KHGDLO\EUHDGRIW KHHQW LUHIRON KHURLVW KHEXLOGHUZKREXLOGVW KHKRXVHQRW
M XVW  EHFDXVH VRP HRQH RUGHUHG LW  IURP  KLP  EXW  ZKR FDXVHV W KH GHDG VW RQHV W R
UHYLYHDEUHDW KRIW KH'LYLQHVSLULW DQGRIW KHVSLULW RIP DQ KHURLVW KHP HUFKDQW
ZKREH\RQGEDUHSURILW VW LOOKDVDFRQFHSW RIUHVSRQVLELOLW \ W REHW KHQHFHVVDU\
P LGGOHP DQEHW ZHHQP DQXIDFW XUHUDQGFRQVXP HU KHURLVW KHJRYHU QP HQW FOHUN
ZKRVHHVKLP VHOIDVKHDGRUKDQGRIW KHOLYLQJIRONSHUP HDW HGE\KLVSURIHVVLRQ
W KDW  UHTXLUHV DVVLVW DQFH IRU W KH SK\VLFDO DQG HP RW LRQDO ZHOO EHLQJ RI W KH IRON
DOZD\VREH\LQJDQGIROORZLQJW KHSXOVHRIW KHIRONDVDZKROH KHURLVW KHFUDIW VP DQ
ZKR HQQREOHV LQ IHVW LYH ZRUNVKRS KLV H[LVW HQFH ZLW K W KH TXDOLW \  RI KLV ZRUN DQG
SURGXFW V KHUR LV W KH ZRUNHU ZKR RQ W KH ORZHVW  UXQJ RI VRFLHW \ HDUQV KLV GDLO\
VDODU\ZLW KW KHFRQVFLRXVQHVVRIEHLQJW KHORZHVW EXW P RVW IDLW KIXOVRQRIKLVIRON
DQGZKRORRNVDW KLVFKLOGUHQZLW KH[SHFW DW LRQDQGZLW KSULGHW KDW VRP HW LP HW KH\
ZLOOJUHHW W KHLUIDW KHUW RZDUGW KHHQGRIKLVOLIHIURP KLJKHUVW UDW DDQGZRUN KHUR
LV W KH HGXFDW RU ZKR OHDGV DQG SURW HFW V W KH \RXW K DQG JLYHV W KH \RXQJ SHRSOH D
KLJKJRDOEHFDXVHKHNQRZVW KDW ZLW KW KH\RXQJSHRSOHKHKDVW KHIXW XUHRIKLV
IRONLQKLVKDQGV KHURLVW KHIDFW RU\RZQHUZKRNQRZVW KHUHVSRQVLELOLW \W KDW W KH
ZHOO EHLQJ RI W KRXVDQGV RI SHRSOH LV GHSHQGLQJ RQ KLP  DQG ZKR W KHUHIRUH GRHV
QRW  SXW  KLV ZKLP V DERYH W KH ZHOO EHLQJ RI W KH P DVVHV  KHUR LV W KH P LQLVW HU RI
JRYHUQP HQW ZKRKDVFRXUDJHLQKLVKHDUW DQGZKRNQRZVW UXHGHVLUHW RGRW KH
ULJKW W KLQJVDOZD\VDQGHYHU\ZKHUHHYHQLIKHKDGW RVDFULILFHKLVSRZHUDQGKLV
KRQRUHGRIILFH DOORIW KHP DUHKHURHVDQGW KHUHLVQRERG\ZKRZRXOGEHW RRORZ
W REHDFFHSW HGLQW RW KLVKHURLFVRFLHW \SURYLGHGKHKDVW KHZLOOW RJLYHP RUHW KDQ
ZKDW HYHUP D\EHKLVSUHVHQW GXW \DQGREOLJDW LRQ+RZHYHUZKRLVQRW FDSDEOHW R
GRW KDW ZKRIHHOVQRQHHGZLW KLQKLP VHOIW RGRP RUHW KDQZKDW VHUYHVKLVJRDOV
DQGKLVRZQSXUSRVHVKHLVQRW KLQJEXW DZKHHOHU GHDOHUEHFDXVHKHOLYHVXQGHU
W KH HUURQHRXV LGHD W KDW  OLIH LV D P HUFKDQGLVH W KDW  KDV LW V SULFH DQG ZKHUHYHU
P DQ\ JRDOV DUH UHDFKHG W KHUH OLIH KDV D KLJKHU YDOXH  7KLV LV D JUDYH P LVW DNH
DQGW KHZRUOGZLOORQO\W KHQEHDGZHOOLQJIRUKDSS\KXP DQVZKHQW KHKHURHVZLOO
KDYHEHHQYLFW RULRXVRYHUW KHZKHHOHU GHDOHUV

7KH :HOW DQVFKDXXQJ RI W KH $U\DQV LV DQG ZDV KHURLF  +HURLF :HOW DQVFKDXXQJ
IRFXVHV LW V HIIRUW V QRW  RQ W KH VW ULYLQJ IRU W KH P DLQW HQDQFH RI W KDW  ZKLFK LV RQH¶V
RZQSURSHUW \EXW LW GHP DQGVVDFULILFHHYHQVHOI VDFULILFHRIW KHLQGLYLGXDORIW KH
IDP LO\RIW KHIRONRIW KHUDFHIRUW KHZHOO EHLQJRIW KHZRUOG7KLVLVW KHKLJKHVW
P DUNRIW KH$U\DQVSLULW XDOFRQGLW LRQDVW KHKLVW RU\RIW KLVUDFHLVW HDFKLQJXV
 

7KHFRQTXHVW DQGFRORQL]DW LRQRIW KHHQW LUHSODQHW ZDVW KHLUZRUNDQGW KH\EOHG

GHDW K IURP  W KLV W DVN  :KHW KHU W KH\ GLG VR NQRZLQJO\ RU QRW  NQRZLQJ ZH ZRQ¶W
M XGJHKHUH'XULQJW KLVW DVNW KLVUDFHKDVHOHYDW HGDJUHDW VHFW LRQRIW KHORZHU
KXP DQLW \ DOO W KH ZD\ W R D OHYHO RI LQGHSHQGHQFH  1RZ W KH ORZHU UDFHV W XUQ
DJDLQVW W KHKLJKHURQHW RZKRP W KH\RZHW KHLUHOHYDW LRQ$U\DQLQVLJKW DFFHSW V
W KLV IDFW  DV D ODZ RI HYROXW LRQ DQG VHHNV IURP  W KLV D SRVVLELOLW \ W R DVVLVW  W KLV
SURFHVV RI EHFRP LQJ DQG HYROYLQJ  7KLV LV SDUW  RI W KH KHURLF Z RUOGYLHZ ZKLFK
QHLW KHUVKLHVDZD\IURP DQ\VDFULILFHQRUUHJUHW VDQ\VDFULILFH

&KULVW LDQLW \W RRZKLFKZHFDQYLHZDVVHFRQGZRUOGUHOLJLRQDIW HUW KH$U\DQRQH

FRQW DLQVDKHURLF:HOW DQVFKDXXQJLQLW VFRUHGHP DQGVIXOOGHYRW LRQW RW KH'LYLQH
XQGHUQHJOHFW RIW KDW ZKLFKLVRIW KLV(DUW KW KHVDFULILFHRIVHOIRIW KHIDP LO\RI
W KHIRONDQGW KH³ ZRUOGV´LHDOVRRIW KHUDFH 

7KLVSUHFLRXVFRQW HQW RIW KH&KULVW LDQUHOLJLRQLVNLQW RW KH$U\DQ:HOW DQVFKDXXQJ

DQGLQGHHGKDVRQO\W KH$U\DQUDFLDOLQSXW DP RQJW KHSHRSOHVDFFHSW HG&KULVW LDQLW \
XQGHUP RUHRUOHVVSHUIHFW VKDSHDFFHSW HGW KLVLGHDRI&KULVW LDQLW \W KDW LVVRNLQ
W RLW VRZQSDJDQ:HOW DQVFKDXXQJKDVFDUHGIRULW DQGVXIIHUHGXQGHULW &RQW UDU\
W RW KLVW KHP DVVHVHVSHFLDOO\LQ6RXW KHUQFRXQW ULHVDUHZRUVKLSSLQJDJULP DFHD
IHW LVKXQGHUW KHQDP HRI&KULVW LDQLW \

:HFDQP DNHW KHVDP HVW DW HP HQW DVIDUDV%XGGKLVP W KHW KLUGZRUOGUHOLJLRQDV

ZHVHHLW , W GHP DQGVFRP SOHW HUHVLJQLQJIURP HYHU\W KLQJZRUOGO\DOOW KHZD\W R
W RW DOVHOI VDFULILFH%XGGKLVP W RRHYROYHGIURP W KH$U\DQUDFLDOLGHDORIW KHDQFLHQW
, QGLDQVDQGLW LVVW LOOOLYLQJLW W KLVZD\

$OOW KUHH:HOW DQVFKDXXQJVYLHZVUHOLJLRQVDUHKHURLFLQRW KHUZRUGVW KH\DUH

VHOI VDFULILFLQJ'XULQJW KHFRXUVHRIW KHSDVW W KRXVDQG\HDUVW KH$U\DQKXP DQ
XQGHU W KH EDQQHU RI W KHVH W KUHH UHOLJLRQV KDV SHUIHFW HG W KH VHOI VDFULILFH RI KLV
GLVVROYLQJZLW KLQW KHORZHUUDFHV+HLVW KHELUG3HOLFDQZKRUDLVHVW KH\RXQJLQ
W KHFDVHRIW KH$U\DQW KH\RXQJHUEURW KHUVZLW KKLVRZQEORRG, W LVSUHFLVHO\IRU
W KLVUHDVRQZK\W KURXJKRXW W KHP LGGOHDJHVW KLVV\P EROW KDW UHIHUVHVSHFLDOO\W R
W KH&KULVW KDGLW VSUHIHUUHGSRVLW LRQ

:HUHJUHW W KHGHFOLQHRIW KHUDFHZKLFKLVREYLRXVEXW LQRXU GD\VW KHNQRZOHGJH

RI W KH QHFHVVLW \ RI SUHVHUYLQJ RI UDFH HVSHFLDOO\ RI W KH KLJKHU UDFH LV REYLRXV
7KH QRZ JURZQ UDFHV FDQ P HDQZKLOH KHOS W KHP VHOYHV ZLW K W KHLU LQKHULW DQFH RI
KLJKHU EORRG ZKLFK W KH\ KDYH QRW  \HW  FRP SOHW HO\ LQFRUSRUDW HG  )RU W KH P DLQ
UDFHWKHQREOHUDFHDWLP HRIIRUEHDUDQFHLVQHFHVVDU\7KHSURFHVVRIK\EULGL]DWLRQ
LVFRP SOHW HG, QIDFW LW KDVW REHHQGHGXQOHVVW KHFUHDW RUHQGVXSH[KDXVW LQJ
KLP VHOIRQW KHFUHDW HG, W KHFRQW LQXHGW KLVODW W HUZD\KHZRXOGW DNHDZD\IURP
KLVZRUNOLIHRQW KHKLJKHUSODQHZKLFKKHM XVW JDYHLW 


 2PLWWHG
 

7KHSURFHVVRIDLP OHVVP L[LQJDQGK\EULGL]DW LRQDVLW W KUHDW HQVW RFRQW LQXHLQRXU

GD\V KDV W R FRP H W R DQ HQG  2W KHUZLVH ³ SURJUHVV´ ZKLFK IDOVHO\ LV VR P XFK
W DONHGDERXW ZRXOGEHHQGDQJHUHG:KDW LVQHFHVVDU\LVEUHHGLQJLQDQXSZDUG
GLUHFW LRQ LQ W KH VDP H P DQQHU DV ZH KDYH EURXJKW  K\EULGL]DW LRQ E\ IROORZLQJ D
KLJKHU SODQ IRU W KH ZRUOG  7KLV LV VR EHFDXVH W KH UDFHV DUH QRW  D SHUP DQHQW
SKHQRP HQRQ  7KH\ P D\ DSSHDU VR IRU P DQ\ P LOOHQQLD EXW  W KH\ DU H QRW  ZKHQ
P HDVXUHGE\W KHKXJHW LP HVSDQVRIW KHKLVW RU\RIW KH(DUW K

3UHVHQW O\DQHZUDFHLVHP HUJLQJIURP W KHUHP DLQGHUVRIW KH$U\DQURRW UDFHDVD

UHVXOW RIDQHZVSLULW XDOUHRUJDQL]DW LRQ7KLVGHYHORSP HQW LVYLVLEOHIRUW KRVHZKR
KDYHW KHH\HVW RVHH

3UHVHQW O\ LW  LV QRW  DV P XFK P DW HULDO UHVXOW V DQG QHZ IRUP V W KDW  VSHDN D GHILQLW H
ODQJXDJH EXW  ZH KDYH W R GR ZLW K VSLULW XDO IRUFHV W KDW  SXW  W KHLU HQHUJ\ LQW R W KH
QHZUDFH7KLVLVKDSSHQLQJRQDVFRSHW KDW LW FDQEHFOHDUO\SHUFHLYHGKRZW KLV
QHZUDFLDOVSLULW JHQHUDW HVW KHVKDSHW KDW LVVSHFLILFIRULW 

7KH HIIRUW V W KDW  VHUYH W KH SUHVHUYDW LRQ DQG W KH IXW XUH RI W KH QREOH UDFH SUHIHU
H[W HUQDOP HDVXUHVW KDW RIFRXUVHDUHSUHW W \P XFKXVHOHVV7KLVLVVREHFDXVH
QRGRXEW W KH$U\DQUDFHLVH[KDXVW HGW RDFHUW DLQGHJUHHQRW M XVW SK\VLFDOO\EXW
DOVR VSLULW XDOO\ P HQW DOO\  7KHUHIRUH W KH HIIRUW V W R LW V SUHVHUYDW LRQ KDYH W R EH
GLUHFW HG DW  VKRXOG DQG VSLULW  RI W KH UDFH DW  ILUVW   7R DFKLHYH W KLV JRDO VSLULW XDO
SHUVRQVFDQFRQW ULEXW HZKRGRQRW FRUUHVSRQGW RW KHSK\VLFDOLGHDORIW KH$U\DQ
UDFH   , W  LV W KH VSLULW  ZKR FUHDW HV W KH ERG\ DQG W KHUHIRUH ZH ZLOO REVHUYH DQ
HYROXW LRQURRW HGLQW KHSK\VLFDODQGVSLULW XDOEDVLVRIW KH$U\DQUDFHW KDW ZLOOOHDG
HIIRUW OHVVO\W RW KHVL[W KQHZURRW UDFH$VZHNQRZW KH$U\DQUDFHZDVW KHILIW K
RQHLQW KHDUUD\RI+XP DQP DLQUDFHVZKLFKDUHSRSXODW LQJW KHSODQHW IRUP LOOLRQV
RI \HDUV DQG ZKLFK DGDSW  W KHP VHOYHV W R W KH UHVSHFW LYH FRQGLW LRQV RQ W KH (DUW K
$VVXFKW KHVHP DLQUDFHVVKRZHGYHU\GLIIHUHQW H[W HULRUFKDUDFW HULVW LFVDQGVSLULW XDO
YDOXHV

:HFDQDVVXP HW KDW W KHQHZUDFHZLOOEXLOGLQHVVHQFHXSRQW KH$U\DQRQHDVIDU

DVORRNVDQGLQQHUFRQGLW LRQVDUHFRQFHUQHG%HFDXVHW KDW ZKLFKW KH$U\DQUDFH
KDV DFKLHYHV ZDV D SHDN QRW  M XVW  VSLULW XDO P HQW DOO\ EXW  DOVR SK\VLFDOO\  %OXH
JROGZKLW HQDP HO\EOXHH\HVEORQGKDLUDQGZKLW HVNLQDUHH[W HUQDOFKDUDFW HULVW LFV
RI D OLJKW EHLQJ DQG W KH EULJKW  DSSHDUDQFH LV D P LUURU RI W KH LQW HULRU EULJKW QHVV
DQGSXULW \RIW KHUHSUHVHQW DW LYHRIW KLVUDFHDV\P ERORIKLVSUR[LP LW \DQGNLQVKLS
W R*RG  7KHUHLVQRGRXEW W KDW GDUNVNLQDQGGDUNH\HVDUHVW LOOLP SHUIHFW UHVXOW V
RIQDW XUH2QW KHRW KHUKDQGFRQVLGHULQJW KHIDFW RIUDFLDOP L[LQJW KDW RFFXUUHG
W KURXJKRXW  VHYHUDO P LOOHQQLD ZH KDYH W R HP SKDVL]H W KDW  DJDLQ DQG DJDLQ W KDW
H[W HULRUDSSHDUDQFHLVQRW FUXFLDODVIDUDVVSLULW XDODQGHP RW LRQDOFRQGLW LRQRID

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

KXP DQLVFRQFHUQHG7KHVSLULW XDODQGSK\VLFDOFKDUDFW HULVW LFVUHP DLQGLIIHUHQW O\

GLVW ULEXW HG LQ KXP DQNLQG XQW LO D EDODQFH LV DFKLHYHG LQ W KH VXE UDFHV W KDW  DUH
QRZ RQ D QHZ OHYHO , Q D QHZ LQFDUQDW LRQ HYHU\ RQH KDV D FODLP  IRU D EHW W HU
OLJKW HU H[W HULRU ³ KXOO´ LI W KLV LV FRP P HQVXUDEOH ZLW K KLV LQQHU HYROXW LRQ DQG W KH
VHTXHQFH RI KLV (DUW KO\ W DVNV LQ OLIH  7KH QHZ VL[W K UDFH ZLOO P DW HULDOL]H UDFLDO
RUGHU DQG P RUDO LQ W KH VHQVH RI XQGHUVW DQGLQJ ORYH  7KHUHIRUH W KHUH ZLOO QR
ORQJHU EH DQ\ ZDUV EXW  FRP SOHW H DQG XQGHUVW DQGLQJ DGDSW DW LRQ RQ DOO OHYHOV RI
KXP DQHYROXW LRQ7KHZD\ZHVHHW KHP W RGD\HDFKVXE UDFHZLOOKDYHDVVLJQHG
LW VVSKHUHRIDFW LRQZKHUHLW M R\IXOO\IXOILOOVLW VW DVNKRQRULQJW KHUHDOLW LHVRIGHVW LQ\
DQGIDW H:KHQHYHUW KHSHRSOHVZLW KP RUH$U\DQFKDUDFW HULVW LFVZKRLQRXUGD\V
GRP LQDW HW KHZRUOGDUHQRORQJHUH[SORLW LQJW KHLUOHVVGHYHORSHGEUHW KUHQW KHQ
ZLOO W KHVH UDFHV UHFRJQL]H ZLOOLQJO\ D OHDGHU LQ W KH $U\DQ  6LP LODU GHYHORSP HQW V
ZLOO KDSSHQ LQ FRXQW ULHV ZLW K SUHGRP LQDQW O\ $U\DQ LQIOXHQFHV RI OHDGHUVKLS DV
W RGD\¶V(XURSHDQG1RUW K$P HULFD$UDFLDOVSOLW ZLOOQHYHUKDSSHQW KHUHQHLW KHU
SROLW LFDOO\ QRU HFRQRP LFDOO\ EXW  HDV\ DQG QDW XUDO DGDSW DW LRQ RI W KH UDFLDO VW UDW D
DFFRUGLQJ W KHLU ZRUN DQG W KH UHVSHFW LYH VLW XDW LRQ LQ W KH FRXQW U \ IROORZLQJ W KH
FRVP LF 'LYLQHSODQ, QGLYLGXDOJURXSVKDYHW KHQDVW KH\GRW RGD\W KHSRVVLELOLW \
W RVHSDUDW HDQGW RVHW W OHLQQHZW HUULW RULHVDVHFRQRP LFDOO\DQGVRFLDOO\LQGHSHQGHQW
JURXSV(YHU\KXP DQEHLQJZLOOW KHQJDLQW KHGHHSHVW LQVLJKW W KDW LW LVIDW HDQG
W KH SDW K W KDW  ZH GHFLGHG W R W DNH XSRQ RXUVHOYHV LQ W KLV OLIH DQG W KDW  QRERG\
VKRXOGHQY\RUGHVSLVHDIHOORZKXP DQEHLQJVLQFHKHNQRZVW KDW DOORIP DQNLQG
KDVLW VRULJLQLQ*RGW KDW DOORIXVDUHEUHW KUHQZKRDUHZLOOLQJW RNHHSDQDW XUDO
UDQNLQJVSLULW XDOO\DQGSK\VLFDOO\

)RULP SRUW DQW P HQNQRZLQJRIW KHYDOXHRIUDFHZDVDOZD\VDVLJQRIJUHDW QHVVRI

RXW ORRNDQGRIW KHP DJQLW XGHRID:HOW DQVFKDXXQJHYHQLIW KH\FDXVHGDFW VW KDW
ZHUHDW RGGVZLW KW KHLULQQHUW DOHQW VDQGDFW XDOGHHGV:DOW KHU5DW KHQDXDERUQ
-HZ KDG DQ XQXVXDO LQVLJKW  LQ W KH YDOXH RI W KH 1RUGLF UDFH KH NQHZ ZHOO LW V
VLJQLILFDW LRQIRUFXOW XUHDQGP RUDOVDQGSRVW XODW HGDQHZEUHHGLQJIRUDKDSSLHU
IXW XUHRIKXP DQNLQG, W LVDP D]LQJKRZHDUO\KHLHH[SUHVVHGKLVW KRXJKW V
DERXW W KDW FRQFLVHO\ZKLOHLP SRUW DQW UHSUHVHQW DW LYHVRIRXURZQIRONVKRUW VLJKW HGO\
FORVHW KHLUH\HVZKHQLW FRP HVW RUDFLDOTXHVW LRQVW KHVROXW LRQRIZKLFKFDQP DNH
W KHGLIIHUHQFHEHW ZHHQDVFHQW DQGGHFOLQH2QW KHRW KHUKDQGZ HFDQEHHTXDOO\
DP D]HGKRZOLW W OH5DW KHQDXIROORZHGKLVLQVLJKW VDVORQJDVKHZDVLQIOXHQW LDODQG
SRZHUIXO0D\W KHRSSRQHQW VRIDUDFLDOO\RULHQW HG:HOW DQVFKDXXQJDQGOLIHVW \OH
OHDUQ RQ W KH H[DP SOH RI 5DW KHQDX W KDW  D QDW XUDO IDFW  VXFK DV UDFLDO GLIIHUHQFHV
QHHGV QRW  W R EH GHQLHG  , W  P D\ EH GLIILFXOW  W R DFNQRZOHGJH W KH DGYDQW DJHV RI
DQRW KHUUDFHEXW FRP LQJW RW KLVSRLQW FDQEULQJRQHVSLULW XDOO\FORVHUW RW KLVLGRO
5DW KHQDX DQGRQHFDQW KHQYLHZKXP DQVLW XDW LRQVQRW DVLQM XVW LFHEXW W DVNVLQ
W KLVOLIHW KDW DUHJLYHQW RXVE\IDW HW DVNVW KDW DUHQRW XQUHDVRQDEOHRUXQGHVHUYHG
7KH SHUVRQ ZLW K LQVLJKW  ZLOO EDVHG RQ W HP SRUDU\ ODFN RU ³ SHUVRQDO P LVIRUW XQH´
FRP HP XFKHDVLHUW RW KHFRQFOXVLRQRIDJHQHUDOQHHGW RDQXSZDUGHYROXW LRQRI
ERG\DQGVSLULW 7KLVVKRXOGQRW JHQHUDW HKDW HEXW W UXHORYHW RKXP DQLW \

7KH UDW LRQDOLVW  DQG P DW HULDOLVW  5DW KHQDX RYHUORRNV LQ HVVHQFH W KH VSLULW XDO DQG
HP RW LRQDOFRQGLW LRQVW KDW DUHQHFHVVDU\IRUW KHHYROYLQJRIDUDFHRIVXFKSHUIHFW LRQ
7KH FOLP DW LF FRQGLW LRQV DORQH FDQQRW  GR LW  IRU LI LW  ZHUH VR W KH (VNLP RV ZRXOG
 

KDYHHYROYHGW RW KHKLJKHVW UDFHW KHEORQGHVW RQHDQGW KHVW URQJHVW RQH7RW KH

FRQW UDU\ W KH $U\DQ UDFH HYROYHG LQ D UHODW LYHO\ P LOG FOLP DW H W KDW  SURYLGHG W KLV
KXP DQEHLQJZLW KW KHZHDOW KRIQDW XUHW RKHOSKLVDVFHQW 'LVW UHVVFDXVHVP LVHU\
LQW KHORQJUXQDQGKLQGHUVW RSSHUIRUP DQFHHYHQW KRXJKDW W LP HVW KHSRZHURI
W KHZKLSRIODFNVKRXOGQRW EHXQGHUHVW LP DW HG

)URP  7KHRJQLV RI 0HJDUD ZKR OLYHG DURXQG  EFH ZH UHFHLYHG D VP DOO EXW
VLJQLILFDQW VD\LQJ
2QO\P RQH\LVKRQRUHGLQRXUGD\V
1REOHP HQP DUU\W KHGDXJKW HURIUDJJHGSHRSOH
$QGW KHFURRNP DUULHVW KHQREOHP DQ¶VGDXJKW HU
7LOOW KHUDFHVDUHP L[HG

+HUHZHFDQVHHKRZLQW KH³ KDSSLHU ´ W ULEHVW KDW LQKDELW W KHVRXW KDQGZKRDUH

³ FLYLOL]HG´  KDG W R FRSH ZLW K SUREOHP V W KDW  UHVXOW  IURP  FLYLOL]DW LRQ TXLW H HDUO\ LQ
³ FODVVLFDO´ *UHHFH +HUHZHFDQQRW VHHDQ\SURJUHVVEXW DGHFOLQHW KDW ODVW HGDOO
W KHZD\W RRXUGD\VZKHUHW KHUH LQW RGD\¶V*UHHFH LVDEVROXW HO\QRW UDFHOHIW RI
W KH1RUGLFQREOHP HQRIW KHSDVW 6XFKDGRFXP HQW FRP LQJIURP W KHP RXW KRID
P DQ ZKR NQHZ KLV W LP H DQG W KH IDW H RI KLV SHRSOH JLYHV XV D FOHDUHU SLFW XUH RI
*UHHN GRP  DQG LW V GHFOLQH DQG RXU RZQ GHFOLQH W KDQ D W KRXVDQG YROXP LQRXV
ERRNVW KDW KDYHDOUHDG\EHHQZULW W HQDERXW *UHHFH

1RERG\VKRXOGVW D\DVLGHRUZLOOLQJO\FORVHKLP VHOIRIIIURP VXFKLQVLJKW VEHFDXVH

KHLVDIUDLGRUEHFDXVHKLVH[W HULRUORRNVGRHVQRW VDW LVI\W KHFRQGLW LRQVW KDW P D\
EHFRQVLGHUHGQHFHVVDU\IRUEHLQJSDUW RIW KH$U\DQJURXSRIUDFHV7KHUHLVDOVR
DVSLULW XDOP HP EHUVKLSW RDUDFH  &RQVLGHULQJW KHH[W HQVLYHUDFLDOK\EULGL]DW LRQ
P DQ\RIW KH$U\DQFKDUDFW HULVW LFVFDQEHIRXQGLQQRQ $U\DQERGLHV&RQYHUVHO\
QRW  HYHU\ EORQG DQG EOXH H\HG P DVN JXDUDQW HHV DQ $U\DQ VSLULW  DQG DQ $U\DQ
VRXO  :H N QRZ  DOO W RR Z HOO KRZ  P XFK SODW LW XGH XW LOLW DU LDQLVP   P DW HU LDOLVP 
FRP P HUFLDOLVP DQGLQVXOW LQJVW DOHQHVVRIW KHVRXOFRQIURQW XVLQDQ³ DFFHSW DEOH´
S K\ VLFDO VK HOO  K RZ HY HU  Z K R N Q RZ V P D\  Q RW  EH GHFHLY HG E\  W K LV H[ W HU LRU
DSSHDUDQFH2QW KHRW KHUKDQGZHFDQVHHVSLULW XDOQRELOLW \HOHYDW HGW KRXJKW V
ZLOOLQJ W R VDFULILFH  FUHDW LYH SRZHU DQG $U\DQ FRQQHFW LRQ W R *RG LQ DQ SK\VLFDO
DSSHDUDQFHZKHUHZHP D\OHDVWH[SHFWLW7KRVHIHZNQRZDOVRW KDWVXFKXQSODQQHG
P L[LQJ VKRXOG EH VW RSSHG EHFDXVH W KH\ IHHO FOHDUO\ D VSLULW XDO DQG HP RW LRQDO
GDP QDW LRQ RI XQFOHDQ ERGLHV UHVXOW LQJ IURP  W KH VLQV IRU W KHLU IRUHIDW KHUV ZKLFK
FDXVHG W KH K\EULGL]DW LRQ RI DOO RI KXP DQNLQG XQGHU ZKLFK LW  LV VW LOO VXIIHULQJ 
7KHERGLHVDQGVSLULW VKDYHW RVHSDUDW HDJDLQLISHDFHDQGTXLHW VKRXOGUHW XUQW R
KXP DQVDQGIURP W KHUHW RW KH(DUW K:KDW ³ *RG´ VHSDUDW HGVKRXOGQRW EHP L[HG
E\KXP DQVDLP OHVVO\DQGFULP LQDOO\$QGW KLVZD\ZHVKRXOGDOVRXQGHUVW DQGW KH
VD\LQJ W KDW  KXP DQV VKRXOG QRW  VHSDUDW H W KDW  ZKLFK *RG XQLW HG  6HSDUDW LRQ LV
FUHDW HG ZLW K HYHU\ M RLQLQJ RI LQHTXDOV P LOOLRQV RI G\QDVW LHV DUH W KURZQ LQW R W KH

*RUVOHEHQZ DQW VW RSRLQW RXW W KHIDFW W KDW DOORIXVFDUU\HOHP HQW VRIDOOUDFHVZ LW KLQ
RXUVHOYHV
 2PLWWHG

 

KHOORIVHSDUDW LRQZKLFKQHYHUFRP HVW RUHVW HYHQQRW LQW KHKXQGUHGW KJHQHUDW LRQ

XQW LO QDW XUH GLVVROYHV LW  KHOSLQJ LW VHOI E\ VHSDUDW LQJ W KH FOHDQ IURP  W KH XQFOHDQ
DFFRUGLQJ W R 'LYLQH ODZ W KDW  0HQGHO IRXQG DJDLQ DV DOVR RW KHUV GLG  +RZHYHU
ZKDW  FRQIXVLRQ LV FDXVHG E\ P HDQQHVV DQG LJQRUDQFH DJDLQVW  W KH RQH 8U ODZ
5DFH &DXVH (IIHFW  1RFDXVHZLW KRXW KRUULEOHRUIHUW LOHHIIHFW   1HYHUW KHOHVV
W KH ODVW  M XGJP HQW  W KDW  LQ UHDOLW \ LV KDSSHQLQJ RQ (DUW K LQ HW HU QLW \ DW  DOO W LP HV
HW HUQDOO\VHSDUDW HVW KH³ EXFNV´ IURP W KH³ VKHHS´:KRHYHUZDQW VW KH$U\DQHP SLUH
W KHNLQJGRP RIJRGW KHHP SLUHRIW KHJRGVW KHHP SLUHRIW KH*RW KVW KHHP SLUH
RIW KHJRRGRQHVRQ(DUW KKHVKDOOFRP HW RW KHULJKW RQRXUVLGHIRUZHDFW DQG
OLYH ZLW KLQ W KH HW HUQDO ODZ LQ HW HUQDO ³ P DUULDJH´ LH LQ W KH 8U ODZ DQG QDW XUDO
ODZ

+HUHIROORZVQRZDVHFW LRQIURP 5DW KHQDX¶V³ UHIOHFW LRQV´ 

³ 7KHUHIRUH KHOO FDQQRW  W HUULI\ XV QR P DW W HU KRZ ZLGH RSHQ LW V JDW HV DUH LQ RXU
GD\V2QO\W KHIHDUIXOLVGHYRXUHGE\IHDU)HDUFRQFHGHVYLFW RU\W RW KHEUDYHDQG
W KHEUDYHJDLQVQHZHQHUJ\IURP HDFKFKDOOHQJHW KDW KHRYHUFRP HV´

<HV 5DW KHQDXFHUW DLQO\NQHZLW OLNH%HQM DP LQ'LVUDHOL(DUORI%HDFRQVILHOGDQG

KLVUDFLDOFROOHDJXHZKRXVHGKLVSROLW LFDOVNLOOVLQW KHVW ULYLQJRIW KH$QJOR 6D[RQV
W RZRUOGGRP LQLRQLQW KHVHUYLFHW RKLP VHOIDQGKLVIRON DQGKHH[SUHVVHGLW W KLV
ZD\

³ 7KHUDFLDOTXHVW LRQLVW KHNH\W RZRUOGKLVW RU\´

, QW KLVFDVHW KHQZRUOGKLVW RU\FDQRQO\OHGW RDZRUW KZKLOHJRDOZLW KW KHKHOSRI

W KHOHDGLQJ$U\DQUDFH


.HLQH8UVDFKHRKQHIXUFKW EDUHRGHUIUXFKW EDUH:LUNXQJ $QLFHSOD\RIVLP LODUVRXQGLQJZ RUGV
W KDW HIIRUW OHVVO\RSHQVXSVHYHUDOOD\HUVRIXQGHUVW DQGLQJDQGFRP SUHKHQVLRQ

³ :KHQZHDVVXP HW KH1RUGLFRULJLQRIW KH$U\DQ
UDFH W KHQ W KLV SURYHV W R EH D UHVXOW  RI W KH P RVW
U LJ RU RX V VHOHFW LRQ  RI  E U HHG LQ J  E \  Z D\  RI
HOLP LQDW LRQ  %HFDXVH LW  KDG W R JHW  XVHG W R W KH
FOLP DW LFDOO\  I DX Q DO DQ G Y HJHW DW LRQ  Z LVH P RVW
GDQJHURXVDQGFKDOOHQJLQJODQGVFDSHZKHUHLW KDG
W RVXUYLYHDQGP DLQW DLQLW VRZQXQW LOLW FRQW UROOHG
W KLVHQYLURQP HQW DQGP RGLILHGLW W REHEHDUDEOH
:HDNHU8U LQKDELW DQW VZHUHGHFLP DW HGDQGGULYHQ
DZ D\  E HFD X VH W K H\  FR X O G  Q R W  P D Q D J H W K H
RSSRVLW LRQRIQDW XUH7KHUHIRUHW KH\P DLQW DLQHG
W KHLUSUH KLVW RULFH[LVW HQFHW RW KLVGD\
$IW HU W KH KDSSLHU W ULEHV LQ W KH 6RXW K DQG 6RXW K
(DVW  KDG EHHQ DIIOLFW HG E\ W KHLU FLYLOL]DW LRQ W KH
$U \DQV U HP DLQHG LQ W KLV +HU FXOHDQ LQIDQF\  IRU
DQRW KHUW ZRW KRXVDQG\HDUV
7KLVZD\RQDODUJHVW VFDOHKDSSHQHGW KDW ZKLFK
UHSHDW HGLW VHOIODW HURQDODUJHVFDOHLQLQGLYLGXDO
FDVHV   VXFK DV W KH 5RP DQV DQG W KH 3UXVVLDQV
7KRVHSHRSOHUXOHZKROHDUQHGW RH[LVW DQGW RUXOH
LQW KHURXJKHVW RIW HUULW RULHV
7KH W DVN RI FRP LQJ W LP HV ZLOO EH W R EUHHG DQHZ
W KH GHFOLQLQJ QREOH UDFHV W KDW  DUH DERXW  W R EH
H[W LQFW EXW ZKLFKDUHQHHGHGLQW KHZRUOG2QH
ZLOOKDYHW RJRW KHZD\W KDW QDW XUHLW VHOIKDVJRQH
LQW KHSDVW W KHSDW KRI³ QRUGLILFDW LRQ´$SK\VLFDO
DQGH[KDXVW LQJZD\RIOLIHURXJKFOLP DW HFRP EDW
DQGVROLW XGH
$QHZURP DQW LFLVP ZLOOFRP HW KHURP DQW LFLVP RI
UDFH, W ZLOOJORULI\W KHSXUHEORRGRIW KH1RUW KHUQ
ODQGVDQGFUHDW HQHZP HDQLQJVRIYLUW XHDQGYLFH
7KLVURP DQW LFLVP ZLOOEORFNW KHW UDLQRIP DW HULDOLVP
IRU D ZKLOH  7KHQ W KLV UDFH ZLOO YDQLVK EHFDXVH
W KHZRUOGLVLQQHHGRIW KHEODFNVSLULW EHVLGHVW KH
EORQGDW W LW XGHDQGEHFDXVHW KDW ZKLFKLVGHP RQLF
Z DQ W V K LV U LJ K W    %X W  W K H W U DFHV RI  W K LV ODVW
URP DQW LFLVP ZLOOQHYHUYDQLVK

 ³ :LUW VFKDIW  VW DW W  +HUUVFKDIW ´

5DW KHQDX XVHG W KH Z RU G ³ DIIOLFW HG´
W KHQU HIHU U LQJW RW KHKDSSLHU W U LEHVLQ
W KH 6RXW K Z KLFK W DNHV W KH P HDQLQJ
RI GLVHDVH OHSU RV\ RU  LQIHU LRU LW \ LQ
DQ\FDVHZ LW KDGLVDGYDQW DJH, QW KLV
FDVH W KHVH W U LEHV FDQQRW  EH FRXQW HG
W R EH ³ KDSSLHU ´ W KLV LV D P LVW DNH LQ
KLV7KLQNLQJ&RXOGEHW KDW EHFDXVH
RI KLV EORRG KH ZDV QRW  FDSDEOH W R
P DNHFRQVHTXHQW FRQFOXVLRQVIURP KLV
L Q VL J K W    6R  K H Y L HZ HG  O DW HU  D
SRVVLELOLW \  W R U HDOL]H W KLV FLY LOL]DW LRQ
Z LW K  W RW DO HQ VODY HP HQ W  DQ G
P HFKDQL]DW LRQ RI Z RU N Z KLFK Z RXOG
P HDQW KHGHDW KRIW KH1RU GLFUDFH
7KLVKRZ HYHUZDVQRW W KHFDVHZ LW K
W KH 5RP DQV DQG W KH 3U XVVLDQV KDYH
VW LOOW RFU HDW HW KHLU Z RU OGHP SLU H
6XU H  W KH GHP RQLF LV W KH RSSRVLQJ
SROHRIW KHW KHRQLFLHW KH8U 'LYLQH
RIW KH'LYLQH%XW D³ EODFNVSLULW ´ GRHV
QRW H[LVW LW Z LOODOZD\VEHXQP DVNHG
DV³ QRQ VSLULW ´DV/RNL7KHVSLULW ZKR
LV EU LJKW  DQG Z KR VKLQHV P XVW  U XOH
R W K HU Z L VH Z H K DY H ³ HFR Q R P \ ´ 
LQVW HDGRI³ GRP LQLRQ´ RQ(DU W K$QG
5DW K HQ DX ¶V Z R U G  Z DV ³ HFR Q R P \ ´
7K H U H I R U H  K H  FR Q VL G H U H G  K L P VH O I
GHP RQLF
 

2XUHUDSXW V³ SHUVRQDOLW \´ RQW KHKLJKHVW SHGHVW DO

W KLVLVFRUUHFW EHFDXVHDEDVLFFKDUDFW HULVW LFRIRXU
W LP HLVUDFLDOK\EULGL]DW LRQDQGZLW KLW W KHULQVLQJ
RXW  W KLQQLQJRXW RIFKDUDFW HU:HJLYHDSUHP LXP
W R W KDW  IRUP  RI DW DYLVP  W KDW  UHFRQVW UXFW V RQH RI
W KH FRQVW LW XHQW  RI K\EULGL]DW LRQ RI W KH P DVVHV RI
RXUSRSXODW LRQLQUHODW LYHO\SXUHIRUP 

, I ZH FDP H EDFN DJDLQ W R W KH SXUHU UDFHV W KHUH
Z RX OG  Q RW  E H W K H U HT X LU HP HQ W  W R DE ROLVK  W K H
SHUVRQDOLW \DQGUHSODFHLW ZLW KW KHUDFLDOLGHDO7KLV
ZDVW KHVLW XDW LRQLQW KH*UHHNDULVW RFUDF\DQGW KH
VDP HKDSSHQVLQW RGD\¶VDULVW RFUDF\
:U RQJ FRQFOXVLRQ  6HHQ D JRRG LGHD
W KHRW KHU Z D\DU RXQG7KHP RU HSXU H
UDFH W KH P RU H SHU VRQDOLW \  &KDRW LF
ODU J H FLW LHV G R Q RW  DOORZ  W K H
GHYHORSP HQW  RI SHU VRQDOLW LHV

7KLV FDQ EH XQGHUVW RRG E\ W KH SHUVRQ ZKR UHDGV
W K H VRX OV I U RP  K X P DQ  FK DU DFW HU V   +HU H LV D &RP P LW W HHVDIW HU ::
QREOHP DQ Z KR VHU Y HV FRP P RQ VODY HV  W KHU H D
EX Q FK  RI  VODY HV  Z K R DFFX VHV DQ G H[ HFX W HV D
QREOHP DQDQGW KHUHDEXQFKRIVHUIVZKRLQW KHLU
ZULW LQJ SUHW HQG W UXH QRELOLW \ DQG LQ UHDOLW \ JORULI\
YLUW XHVRIVODYHVLQRUGHUW RW DNHDZD\W KHODVW ULJKW V
IURP W KHQREOHP HQ

$W UDJLFRP LFDOSOD\RIW KHVSLULW LVW KHVXEM HFW LRQRI
3ODW RXQGHUW KHLQIOXHQFHRI6RFUDW HV7KHNQLJKW
OLNHEORQGLGHDOLVW OHDUQVP RUDOLW \DQGSXUSRVHIURP
W KH GDUNLVK QDW LYH ZKR VXFFHHGHG W R P DVW HU KLV
E D G  L Q VW L Q FW V Z L W K  X Q VS H D N D E O H  H Q H U J \  D Q G
LQW HOOLJHQFH  6LHJIULHG LV FRQYHUW HG E\ 0LP H ZKR
³ JRW UHOLJLRQ´
6HHQXQGHUW KLVDVSHFW +HOODVZDVFRP SDUDEOHZLW K
W KH SUH UHYROXW LRQDU\ )UDQFH ZKLFK P HDQV W KDW  D
UHODW LYHO\VP DOOQXP EHURIEORQGQREOHP HQNHSW W KH
EDODQFH 
7KLVLVDEROGLQYHU VLRQW RQDP H3ODW R
DQLGHDOLVW LQFRP SDU LVRQW R6RFUDW HV
, W  REYLRXVO\ RI W KH LQKHU LW DQFH RI W KH
³ EODFN  VSLU LW ´  W KDW  KH FRQVLGHU V W KH
*U HHN  DQ  S K DQ W DVL]HU  E HFDX VH K H
FRQVLGHU VW KDW Z KLFKLVJRRGDVDVHOI
HY LGHQ W  SU HFRQ GLW LRQ   DQ G W K LV Z DV
FRP LQJ IU RP  Z LW KLQ  5DW KHQDX ZDV
QHYHUFDSDEOHRIUHDOL]LQJW KDW RQO\W KH
XQFRQGLW LRQDO LGHDOLVW  LV W KH W U XH DQG
SUDFW LFDO SHU VRQ   Q RW  W K H LGHRORJLVW
Z KRLVXQFOHDQLQP RVW FDVHV7KLVLV
VR EHFDXVH LQ W KH ORQJ U XQ YLU W XH LV
W KHEHVW EXVLQHVVW KHP RVW SU RILW DEOH
³ HFRQRP \ ´

, P HQW LRQHGDOUHDG\W KDW W KHDULVW RFUDF\LVW KHP RVW K\EULGL]HGEXQFKW KHUHLV, QIDFW 


KLVW RULFDOO\VSHDNLQJW KH\VW DUW HGRXW DVIRUHLJQHUVW KDW UXOHUVZKRIHOW LQVHFXUHDERXW W KHLU
SRVLW LRQSXW LQFKDUJHRIGRP LQDW LQJW KHIRON
 

7KHSHRSOHORYHGW KHP DVW HUVHQM R\HGW KHLUFXOW XUHDQG

GHIHQGHG LW VHOI DJDLQVW  W RR P XFK SRZ HU  E\  P HDQV RI
2VW UDNLVP  W KH M XGJP HQW  E\ VKDUGV   7KLV H[SODLQV W KH
GRXEOHVRXORI*UHHN GRP  LW VK\VW HULFVW DQFHLW VZDIIOLQJ
DQGLW VP HODQFKRO\ZDVZLW KW KHP DVVHVLW VIUHHGRP DQG
JUHDW QHVVZLW KW KHXSSHUW HQ

7KH SHRSOH FDUULHG VDW \U OLNH W UDLW V W KH DULVW RFUDF\ KDG
DSROORQLFW UDLW V:LW K6RORQZKRKDGVW XGLHGW KH6HP LW LF
FRQVW LW XW LRQW KHORZHUHOHP HQW ZDVHP SKDVL]HGDQGZLW K
W KH5RP DQVW KHXSSHUHOHP HQW ZDVGHVW UR\HG

7KLV H[SODLQV W KH XQLP DJLQDEOH   W KDW  W KLV SHRSOH W KH

EORVVRP RI0HGLW HUUDQHDQFXOW XUHHQGHGDOORIDVXGGHQ
DQGW KDW W KH*UDHFXOL ³ OLW W OH*UHHNV´ ZHUHW KHREM HFW RI
GHVSLVHDQGP RFNHU\RIW KH5RP DQV

7KHIUHHDQGLQVW LQFW LYHUHVSHFW LVHQW LUHO\EDVHGRQUDFLDO

IHHOLQJV  7KH\ SUHIHU W R REH\ D QREOH ZKLW H KDQG UDW KHU
W KDQLQW HOOLJHQW DUJXP HQW V´

7KLV DOO LV ZHOO H[SUHVVHG FOHDUO\ SHUFHLYHG DQG QRW  W R H[FHO  7KLV ZD\ RQO\ W KH
H\HRIFUHDW LYHORYHRURIDE\VP DOKDW HFDQVHH, W LVXQW KLQNDEOHIRUW KH$U\DQRU
DQ\KXP DQW UXHW RKLP VHOIW RXVHKLVLQIOXHQFHIRUW KHIXUW KHULQJRIW KHRSSRVLW H
LIKHKDVLGHDOVRIW KLVNLQG

%XW 5DW KHQDXLVFRUUHFW DQGKHZLOOUHP DLQFRUUHFW QRP DW W HUZ KHW KHUKHKLP VHOI
DFW HGDFFRUGLQJO\RUQRW 1RW RQO\DW UDFHRIW KHODVW URP DQW LFLVP LVKHUHW RVW D\
W KLV KH FRXOG QRW  DGP LW  DV Z H XQGHU VW DQG IXOO\ EXW  W KH VSLU LW  RI *HU P DQLF
URP DQW LFLVP  ³ *HUP DQW LN´ ZLOODZDNHQIURP KLVGUHDP LQW KDW LQVW DQW ZKHQKH
VKRXOG EH VW DEEHG GXULQJ KLV VOHHS  1R P DW W HU KRZ GLP  RXU SUHVHQW  P D\ ORRN
W KLV(DUW KZRXOGKDYHW KH$U\DQKXP DQUH ERUQLIKHZDVORVW EHFDXVHKHFDUULHV
W KH(DUW KRQKLVVKRXOGHUVDQGEHFDXVHW KH(DUW KLVOLYLQJEHFDXVHRIKLP DQGQRW
W KHRW KHUZD\DURXQG7KHVHZRUGVRQO\KHFDQXQGHUVW DQGZKRNQRZVW KDW P DQ
LVP RUHW KDQDKLJKHU HYROYHGP DP P DO QDP HO\W KDW KHLVW KH(DU W K VSLULW KLP VHOI
 

$ UHYLYDO RI UDFH P DLQW HQDQFH RI UDFH DQG D QHZ FUHDW LRQ RI UDFH ZLOO RQO\ EH
SRVVLEOHRQDUHOLJLRXVEDVLV1RHFRQRP LFRUSROLW LFDOP HDVXU HVZLOO\LHOGDUHVXOW 
EHFDXVH UDFH DV D QDW XUDO SKHQRP HQRQ VXEM HFW V LW VHOI RQO\ W R FRVP LF GLUHFW LYHV
DQGFRVP LFODZV

$OD\HULQJDW \SHRIFDVW HVW UXFW XUHZKLFKZRXOGQRW EHFUXHOEXW ZHOOP HDQLQJ

ZKLFK LW  XVHG W R EH ZKHQ LW  ZDV VW LOO OHG LQ 'LYLQH RUGHU VKRXOG EH W KH H[W HUQDO
IRUP  RI D SHDFHIXO FRRSHUDW LRQ  :LW K W KLV ZH GR QRW  SUHDFK FODVV KDW H RU UDFLDO
KDW H EXW  D VDW LVIDFW LRQ RI W KH RSSRVLW HV Z KLFK DU H QRW  P DW W HU V RI M XVW  RQH
JHQHUDW LRQEXW VXFKVROXW LRQVFDQQHYHUFRP HZLW KW HP SRUDU\UXOHV7KLVLVVR
EHFDXVH UDFHV ODVW  IRU P LOOHQQLD  :H DUH DOVR DZDUH W KDW  W KLV W DVN FDQQRW  EH
VROYHGE\P HDQVRIP XW XDOH[W HUP LQDW LRQQHLW KHUE\P HDQVRIP XW XDOOHJDOL]DW LRQ
DV LV DW W HP SW HG QRZDGD\V LQ P DQ\ DUHDV DOVR QRW  E\ P HDQV RI GHQ\LQJ RI W KH
H[LVW HQFH RI UDFHV EHFDXVH W KLV ZRXOG EH W KH ELJJHVW  OLH DQG FRQVHTXHQW O\ W KH
ELJJHVW LQM XVW LFHEXW E\P HDQVRIIXOOUHFRJQLW LRQRIW KHGLIIHUHQFHV7KHQKXP DQV
ZLOODFW P XW XDOO\ZLW KUHVSHFW DQGZLW KUHDVRQEHFDXVHW KHOLHZRQ¶W EHEHW ZHHQ
W KHP DQ\P RUHDQGLW FDQQRW EOLQGW KHP DQ\P RUH

:DUVW RRZLOOSURYHW REHDQLQDGHTXDW HP HDQVHYHQW KRXJKW KHIULHQGVRISHDFH

VW LOOFRXOGQRW FRP HW RDUHFRJQLW LRQRIW KHVLW XDW LRQDQGSXW P RUHGLVFRUGLQW RW KH
ZRUOG W KDQ EHIRUH ZLW K W KH TXHVW LRQ ZKHW KHU RU QRW  ZDU  7KH\ ZLOO QRW  SUHYHQW
ZDUVEXW W ULJJHUW KHP %HFDXVHW KH\GHQ\UHDVRQVIRUZDUZKLFKDUHUHVXOW RIW KH
GLIIHUHQFHV RI UDFHV DQG SHRSOHV  7RGD\ W KH REQR[LRXV SDFLILVP  D ZRUG W KDW
QHYHU VKRXOG EH FRQIXVHG ZLW K *HUP DQ ZLOO W R SHDFH  LV RSSRVHG E\ DOO QREOH
P LQ GV Z K R K DY H W K H VHFX U H I HHOLQ J DERX W  VX FK  W K LQ JV  EHFDX VH DOO K HU RLF
:HOW DQVFKDXXQJZRXOGEHGHVW UR\HGZLW KVXFKDW W LW XGH

7KHUH LV VRP H REYLRXV NLQVKLS EHW ZHHQ SDFLILVP  DQG &KLQHVH SKLORVRSK\  7KH
W HDFKLQJV RI &RQIXFLXV UHFRP P HQG HTXDOO\ DV W KH $U\DQ LGHDO DQG W KH FUHDW HG
UHOLJLRQVRI&KULVW LDQLW \DQG%XGGKLVP VDQFW LW \RIP DUULDJHRIW KHIDP LO\RIUDFH
DQGHVSHFLDOO\RIZRUVKLSRIW KHDQFHVW RUVZLW KRXW KDYLQJDKHURLFDW W LW XGH7KH
VXFFHVV RI W KLV LV SUHVHUYDW LRQ RI UDFH IRU VHYHUDO W KRXVDQG \HDUV  :LW K W KHP 
KRZHYHUW KHUHLVUDFHXQLW \DQGUDFHSHUP DQHQFHZKLOHW KHSDFLILVW VRYHUORRNW KH
UDFLDOTXHVW LRQDQGW KXVW U\W RP DNHDJUHDW P LVW DNHLQW KHLUW KLQNLQJ

%RW KOLQHVW KHFROOHFW LYH $U\DQZRUOGYLHZRIVDFULILFHDQGW KH&RQIXFLDQYLHZRI

SUHVHUYDW LRQRIUDFHFRXOGP XW XDOO\VXSSRUW LQJHDFKRW KHUKHOSIXUW KHUW KHSDW K
RIKXP DQLW\WRZDUGVSHUIHFWLRQ)URP WKLVHP HUJHVQDWXUDOO\WKHSODQRIFRRSHUDWLRQ
DQGRIFRH[LVW HQFHW KDW KDVDVLW VREM HFW LYHDUDFLDOOD\HULQJQRW DUDQGRP UDFLDO
K\EULGL]DW LRQZLW KRXW SODQZKLFKFDXVHVSUREOHP VIRUW KHSURJHQ\VSOLW VOLIHDQG
FDXVHV GLVFRUG + DU P RQ\ W KHUHIRUH $U P DQ¶V DUW  LV W KH EDVLV RI 'LYLQH DQG
ZRUOGO\OLIH
 

8QDYRLGDEOHFRP EDW VKRXOGRQO\VHUYHW RGHVW UR\DOOW KDW ZKLFKLVGHW ULP HQW DODQG
QRW FRQVW UXFW LYH, W VKRXOGGHVW UR\DOOW KDW LVKDOI RQO\FRP SURP LVHDOOW KDW ZKLFK
RSSRVHV GHFLVLRQ DQG 'LYLQH VHSDUDW LRQ  :KR ZDQW V SHDFH 'LYLQH SHDFH DQG
ZRUOGO\SHDFH KHP XVW DFFHSW UDFLDOVHSDUDW LRQLQW RQDW LRQVRU LQW RFDVW HVZLW KLQ
QDW LRQV5DFLDOP L[LQJP HDQVZDUDQGW KLVIDFW W KHSHDFH ORYHUVVKRXOGFRQVLGHU

)RUP LOOHQQLD&KLQDKDVQRW FRQW ULEXW HGDQ\W KLQJW RW KHSHUIHFW LRQRILW VUHOLJLRQ
LW V HFRQRP \ LW V VRFLHW \ LW  ZDV VHOI VDW LVILHG  , W V HVVHQFH JRW  H[KDXVW HG LQ LW V
UDFH  &KLQD QHHGHG QR ORQJHU DQ\ HIIRUW  LW  ZDV VHOI VDW LVILHG  7KH FRP EDW V LQ
&KLQDW RGD\DQGRI\HVW HU\HDUKDYHEHHQFDUULHGLQIURP DEURDGDQGKDYHEHHQ
OHG E\ UHVXOW V RI P L[LQJ RI VSLULW XDO DQG SK\VLFDO W \SHV  7KLV LV QRW  D VXFFHVV
+RZHYHUZLW KLQDSHRSOHDQGDUDFHVXFFHVVLVQRW W KHLVVXHEXW W KHGHJUHHRILW V
KDSSLQHVVVDW LVIDFW LRQDQGIXOILOOP HQW 7KHUHIRUH(XURSHLVVRP XFKLQXSURDU, W
VLP SO\LVGLVVDW LVILHG, W KDVW RSHUIRUP QRORQJHUOLYHVLW LQW KHVW DW HRIH[LVW HQFH
RIDUDFH, QIDFW LW KDVQRORQJHUDQ\VW DW HRIH[LVW HQFH$VDUHVXOW RILQILQLW H
P L[LQJRIEORRGHIIRUW VDUHKHLJKW HQHGE\P HDQVRIXQKHDOW K\VW LP XODW LRQRIW KH
QHUYHVW KDW IROORZVHYHU\K\EULGL]DW LRQRIW KHEORRG$OOSXUHUDFHVRUW ULEHVDUH
EDODQFHVLQW KHLUVW DW HRIH[LVW HQFH7KHSRZHUVW RSHUIRUP DU HGRUP DQW 

6ZHGHQDQG&KLQDDUHRSSRVLW HVEXW ERW KRIW KHP HQM R\W KHDGYDQW DJHRIUDFLDO

XQLW \DQGSXULW \  7KLVSLFW XUHKRZHYHULVLQFRP SOHW HEHFDXVH6ZHGHQZLW KLW V
P LOOLRQSHRSOHFRQVW LW XW HVRQO\DIUDFW LRQRIW KH$U\DQUDFH%RW KSHRSOHKRZHYHU
HQM R\DVW DW HRIVDW LVIDFW LRQ$JDLQW KHFRP SDULVRQLVDELW SUREOHP DW LFEHFDXVH
W KH6ZHGHVDVP HP EHUVRIW KH$U\DQUDFHDUHFUHDW LYHO\DFW LYHDQGZLW KRQO\
P LOOLRQSHRSOHKDYHE\SHUFHQW DJHDKLJKHULQIOXHQFHRQFXOW XU HW KDQRW KHUP RUH
VRXW KHUQ QDW LRQV RI (XURSH ZLW K  P LOOLRQ LQKDELW DQW V DQG P RUH  2Q W KH RW KHU
KDQG DIW HU KDYLQJ DEVRUEHG W KHLU $U\DQ OHDGHUVKLS DUH M XVW  YHJHW DW LQJ  7KLV LV
W KH UHDVRQ IRU W KHLU TXLHW  FRQW HQW P HQW  DQG LQW HOOHFW XDO VW HULOLW \ IRU P RUH W KDQ
RRR \HDUV  6R ZH FDQ FRP SDUH RQO\ LP SHUIHFW O\ EHFDXVH W KH $U\DQ UDFH W KH
ILIW KURRW UDFHLVRQDQRW KHUHYROXW LRQDU\OHYHOW KDQW KH0RQJROLDQUDFHZKLFKLV


 2PLWWHG
 

W KHHQGUHVXOW IURP DQHDUOLHUHUDRIW KHSODQHW DQGLVGHVFHQGLQJIURP W KHIRXUW K

URRW UDFH

*RG DQG UDFH DUH RQH  2U H[SUHVVLQJ P \VHOI LQ VFLHQW LILF W HUP V   UDFH LV W KH
SULQFLSOHRIFDXVHDQGHIIHFW %HOLHILQUDFHLVEHOLHILQ*RGLVEHOLHILQW KH5DW D
W KH5DW HU DGYLVRU W KH5DW  FRXQFLO RIW KH³ JRGV´ DVW KH(GGDLVW HDFKLQJOLW HUDOO\

7KHUHFRYHU\RIRXUUDFHRIRXUOLIHZLOORQO\EHSRVVLEOHE\P HDQVRIVDQFW LILFDW LRQ

RISURFUHDW LRQRIP DUULDJHRIW KHEORRGDZRUGZKHQUHIHUULQJW RW KHIDP LO\LQ
*HUP DQ   D ZRUG W KDW  LV P XFK P RUH DFFXUDW H E\ P HDQV RI VDQFW LILFDW LRQ RI W KH
IRON DQG RI W KH UDFH  3XULW \ RQ D UDFLDO OHYHO LV UHOLJLRQ  LP SXULW \ RI W KH UDFH
K\EULGL]DW LRQRIDQ\NLQGLVLP SXULW \DQGODFNRIXQLW \RIUHOLJLRQ

7KHKHURLF:HOW DQVFKDXXQJW KHFDSDELOLW \RIVDFULILFHVKRXOGDOVRKDYHDQHIIHFW

W RW KHZHOO EHLQJDQGSHUP DQHQFHRQ(DUW KLQW KHIXW XUH
 

, , ,  L??>CHA IL %H>?=?H=S

7KLVLVZKDW P \JUHDW ORYHW RW KRVHZKRDUHIDUW KHVW DZD\GHP DQGV
'RQRW VSDUHW K\QHLJKERU 0DQLVVRP HW KLQJW KDW KDVW REHRYHUFRP H
1LHW ]VFK H

:KDW P DQNLQG :HDUHQRW DKXP DQNLQGRUKXP DQNLQGVLQW KHP HDQLQJ

RIDQRSSRVLQJSULQFLSOHW R*RG NLQG JRG QHVV RU*RG NLQGV JRGV 
EXW ZHDUH*RGRUW KHJRGVRXUVHOYHV7KHDQFLHQW SHRSOHNQHZW KLV
VW LOO IURP  W KHLU ODQJXDJH EHFDXVH P DQ ZDV QRW  RQO\ P DQ EXW  DOVR
JRG DQG DOO OLYLQJ EHLQJV  7KLV FDXVHG W KH ZRUG P DQ LVN  JURZQ
IU RP  W KH P DQ Z KLFK LV P HU JHG W RGD\  W R ³ 0HQVLFR´   ³ 0HQVFK´  
0DQDVN 0HQVFKDFW XDOO\P HDQV³ W KHRQHZKRJUHZIURP *RG´W KH
RQHZKRLVERUQIURP *RG7KLVZD\ODQJXDJHW HDFKHVXVW RSURIHVV
DOO W UXW K  'LG QRW  W KH $SRVW OH -RKQ VD\  ³ 'R \RX QRW  NQRZ W KDW  \RX
DUHJRGV´ "  2XUOLP LW HGKXP DQOLIHLVEXW DW DVNDVW DW HRIH[LVW HQFH
W KDW LVJRLQJW RSDVVVRRQ:HFDQQRW KHOSEXW XVHW KHP LVXQGHUVW RRG
ZRUG³ KXP DQNLQG´ IXUW KHUEXW ZHXQGHUVW DQGZLW KLW W KHVXP W RW DORI
W KH JRGV DQG KXP DQV W KDW  OLYH LQ W KH KXP DQ FRQVFLRXVQHVV

6KRXOG ZH QRW  ORYH KXP DQLW \"  1R  %HFDXVH ZH ORYH W KH KXP DQ
EHLQJ W KH LQGLYLGXDO W KH XQLTXH RQH W KH EHDXW LIXO RQH W KH VW URQJ
RQH W KH *RW K  7R ORYH DOO KXP DQ EHLQJV KXP DQNLQG DV D ZKROH
GRHVQRW KRQRUW KHKXP DQEHLQJEHFDXVH³ KXP DQNLQG´ LVVRP HW KLQJ
YHU\XQUHDODQGZHKDYHW REHDZDUHRIDOORILW VVKRUW FRP LQJV7KLV
VW ULYLQJ DQG SXVKLQJ W RZDUGV DQ XQLP DJLQDEOH GHSW K W RZDUGV W KH
VKDOORZH[SUHVVLRQ³ KXP DQNLQG´ LV³ KXP DQDOOW RRKXP DQ´:KHU HYHU
W KH -RW H   VHHV W KH *RW K GLJJLQJ LQW R W KH GHSW K KH EXULHV KLP  LQ KLV
SLW  LI KH FDQ GR VR

7KH DU JXLQJ RY HU  P HDQLQJV QHY HU  HQGV  EHFDXVH KXP DQV DU H VR

GLIIHUHQW 7KLVRSLQLRQLVFRUUHFW DQGKDVGHHSUHDVRQVDQGLW H[SRVHV
W KH HUURQHRXV W HDFKLQJ RI HTXDOLW \ RI DOO W KDW  KDV D KXP DQ IDFH DV D
ELJOLH+RZHYHUIURP W KLVSHRSOHFRQFOXGHW KDW DXQLYHUVDOO\ SRVVLEOH

7KH*HUP DQZRUGIRU+XP DQ

 $FW XDOO\ -HVXV UHIHUV W R W KH 2OG 7HVW DP HQW   ³ , V LW  QRW  ZULW W HQ W KDW  \RX DOO DUH
JRGV"´

 +HUH *RUVOHEHQ P HDQV  DSSDUHQW O\ W KH 1RQ $U\DQ VSHFLILFDOO\ W KH -HZ  DW  W KH
VDP HW LP HDOVRDOOXGLQJW RW KHGXP EDQGDJJUHVVLYHJLDQW VRI-RW XQKHLP /DW HUKH
LQFUHDVLQJO\XVHVW KLVZ RUGV\QRQ\P RXVO\Z LW K*RW HRU*RW K
 

RSLQLRQ LH DQ RSLQLRQ W KDW  LV DOVR W UXW K ZRXOG QHYHU EH SRVVLEOH  7KDW  LV QRW
W KH FDVH  7KHUH DUH LQVLJKW V W KDW  DUH QRW  DFFHVVLEOH W R HYHU\ERG\ HYHQ ZKHQ
W KH\DUHW DXJKW ZLW KH[W UHP HHIIRUW DQGZKHQW KH\KDYHEHHQDFFHSW HGZLW KW KH
EHVW ZLOO0DQ\W KLQJVUHP DLQLQFRQFHLYDEOHW RP RVW KXP DQV6XFK LQFRQFHLYDEOH
LV D ODVW  $U\DQ ZLVGRP  FRQFHUQLQJ W KH IDW KHUKRRG RI *RG DERXW  2QH QHVV ZLW K
W KH IDW KHU DERXW  EHLQJ *RG DQG W KH 6RQ RI *RG DERXW  *RG LQ (YHU\W KLQJ DQG
(Y HU \ W KLQJ LQ *RG    $W  DOO W LP HV W KH FKXU FKHV GLG W KU LY H DV D U HVXOW  RI W KH
LQFDSDELOLW \ RI W KH P DVVHV W R OLYH DFFRUGLQJ W R VXFK D FRQFHSW LRQ  7LP H DQG
DJDLQ

*UHHN 9DVH GHVLJQ IURP  *DUH DERXW   EFH

$Q $U\DQ ZKR LV VHW  XS IRU VDFULILFH IUHHV KLP VHOI 

+XP DQV RI KLJKHVW  UDQN RI W KH UDFH KDG W R SD\ ZLW K W KHLU GHDW K W KDW  W KH\ KDG
VXFK NQRZOHGJH DQG W KH\ GLG QRW  NHHS W KLV NQRZOHGJH W R W KHP VHOYHV DQG W KHLU
UDFLDO HTXDOV  $V DUURJDQW  DV LW  P D\ VRXQG   7KH 'LYLQH VSDUN KDV D YHU\ ZHDN
OLIHZLW KLQW KHORZHUSDUW RIKXP DQNLQGDVLILW KDGW REUHDNXSVRP HW LP HLQW KH
SDVW 6RP HW LP HZHZLOOILQGRXW W KDW W KHORZHUUDFHVDUHEDVW DUGVEHW ZHHQW KH
'LYLQH UDFHV DQG DQLP DOV   7KH QDW XUH RI ³ *RG´  KDV FUHDW HG RQO\ RQH W \SH RI
³ *RGV´RU*RW KV 7KH$VLDQ$U\DQP DQDVDOO³ VDFUHGW H[W V´ W HOOXV7KH³ JRGV´
FUHDW HG KXP DQV E\ 6RGRP \   DQG W KH\ ³ UHJUHW W HG LW ´ DV LV ZULW W HQ LQ *HQHVLV
*RG W KH )DW KHU KRZHYHU FDQQRW  KDYH UHJUHW V DERXW  KLV ³ JRGV´ W KDW  RQH KDV W R
XQGHUVW DQG

2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG


2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

7KH IRUFHV RI GDUNQHVV KRSH W R GLVVROYH DOO KLJKHU KXP DQLW \ LQW R DQ ³ DOO HTXDO´
W \SH RI P HGLRFULW \ DQG ORZQHVV LQ D VSLULW XDO DQG SK\VLFDO VHQVH  7KH\ KRSH W R
GRVRE\P HDQVRIIXUW KHUK\EULGL]DW LRQRIW KHUDFHV7KLV³ JUDQGLRVHJRDO´ W KDW
DFRQVFLRXVOHDGHUVKLSRILQIHULRUUDFHV LW P D\EHGRQHQRQ FRQVFLRXVEXW W KHUH
LV VXIILFLHQW  SURRI SRLQW LQJ W R D FRQVFLRXV VHW W LQJ RI W KLV JRDO  LV VHW W LQJ TXLW H
RSHQO\ DQG \HW  QRW  UHFRJQL]HG DV VXFK ZLOO QHYHU EH DFKLHYHG KRZHYHU  QR
P DW W HU KRZ P XFK W KH SUHVHQW  VLW XDW LRQ P D\ FRQW UDGLFW  W KLV LGHD  7KLV LV VR
EHFDXVHQDW XUHVLP SO\GRHVQRW ZDQW UDFLDOGHJUDGDW LRQEXW LW LVVW ULYLQJW RZDUGV
D EUHHGLQJ LQ DQ XSZDUG GLUHFW LRQ RI KXP DQV DW  DOO FRVW   $W  W KH W LP H ZKHQ W KH
ZRUOG %DVW DUG EHOLHYHV W KDW  KH KDV DFKLHYHG KLV JRDO W KH W HUULEOH SUHVVXUH W KDW
W KH EHDVW  RI K\EULGL]DW LRQ H[HUW V ZLOO XQOHDVK W KH IRUFHV RI 'LYLQH *RW KLF *RG
OLNHQDW XUHZKLFKHQIRUFHIRUW KHP VHOYHVW KHSDW KXSZDUGVRIQDW XUHDQGRIW KH
'LYLQHDQGW KHVHIRUFHVDUHDOUHDG\DFW LYHW RGD\LQW KH*OREDO$U\DQP RYHP HQW 

1RELOLW \DQGJRRGUDFHDUHVLP LODULQW KHDW W LW XGHW KDW W KH\SU HIHUW RUHP DLQNLQJV
ZLW KLQW KHLURZQVP DOODUHDUDW KHUW KDQEHFRP LQJVHUIVLQW KHIRUHLJQODUJHDUHD
7KHUHIRUHW KH\RIW HQFHGHZLW KRXW ILJKW W KHUXOHDW ODUJHW RW KHVP DOODQGFRP P RQ
SHRSOH ZKR DUH QRW  SLFN\ DERXW  VXFK W KLQJV  , Q RXU GD\V W KH W UXO\ QREOH DQG
JUHDW  KXP DQV OLYH VHFUHW O\ LQ VP DOO SODFHV ZKLFK KRZHYHU DUH TXLW H RIW HQ YHU\
HQYLDEOHVP DOOSODFHVDOOW KHZKLOHDOOKXP DQYHUP LQRIW KH³ G\QDVW \RIM HDORXV\´
DW  EHVW  DQ LJQRUDQW  P HGLRFULW \ LV DW  W KH KHOP   7KHVH QXLVDQFHV W KDW  OHDG W R D
JHQHUDO SUROHW DUL]DW LRQ FDQ RQO\ EH UHP RYHG E\ D ODZ W KDW  JLYHV DQ DULVW RFUDF\
ULJKW V W R OHDGHUVKLS ZKLFK DULVW RFUDF\ KRZHYHU VKRXOG EH RI W KH UDFH  

5DFH GHW HUP LQHV D VSHFLDO P LQG VHW   7KRXJKW V RI W KH VXE KXP DQ E\ QHFHVVLW \
DUH KRVW LOH W RZDUGV P \ W KRXJKW V  7KH $U\DQ SHUFHLYHV KLV W KLQN LQJ KLV ZDQW V
KLV GHVLUHV DV KRVW LOH SDLQIXO SK\VLFDOO\ DQG UHM HFW V W KHP  ZLW KRXW  W KH QHHG W R
M XGJH W KHP   7KH\ DUH QDW XUDOO\ GDP DJLQJ W R KLP   W KHUHIRUH KH GLVOLNHV W KHP 
7KHQKHFDQHDVLO\W HVW KLVIHHOLQJVZLW KKLVP LQGDQGKHZLOODOZD\VILQGRXW W KDW
ZKDW KHKDVFRQVLGHUHGDQGM XGJHGW XUQVRXW W REHFRUUHFW $QHUURULVRXW RIW KH
TXHVW LRQ IRU W KH SHUVRQ ZKR GUDZV IURP  KLV UDFLDO KHULW DJH  3U HFRQGLW LRQ LV D
VRXO DQG P HQW DO FRQGLW LRQ W KDW  LV QRW  LQIOXHQFHG E\ DQ\W KLQJ IRUHLJQ  7KLV ZD\
W KHZRUOGZLGHIUDXGW KDW NHHSVFRP LQJEDFNHYHU\\HDULQDQRW KHUVKDSHZLOOQRW
W RXFK W KH $U\DQ ZKR LV URRW HG LQ KLV GHHS UDFLDO VHFXULW \  7KH VXEKXP DQ W DNHV
FDUH W KDW  W KH KLJK JRDO LV VXIIHULQJ XQGHU W KDW  ZKLFK H[FLW HV DOO W KH K\EULGL]HG
SHRSOH

, Q RXU GD\V W KHUH LV D W KUHDW  W KDW  RXU VSLULW XDO JRRGV DUH VLQNLQJ LQ W KH VZDP S
RI W RGD\¶V ZRUOG P L[  7KH IUHHO\ DQG P HQW DOO\ ZRUNLQJ $U\DQ DV DUW LVW  VFKRODU
RUSRHW RIRXUGD\VRIW HQHDUQVEDUHO\GXULQJDZKROHZHHNW KDW ZKLFKDFDEEDJH
SUHSDUHU HDUQV LQ DQ KRXU  7KH P RVW  QREOH SURGXFW V IRU W KH ZHOO EHLQJ RI D IRON
 

KDYHQRYDOXHDQ\P RUHGXULQJW KHW LP HRIUDFLDOGHFOLQHW KHUHIRUHQRERG\SD\V

IRUW KHP %XW LW LVFOHDUW KDW QRQHRIW KHHFRQRP LF³ P HDVXUHV´ ZLOOVDYHXVEXW
RQO\ LQFUHDVHG HIIRUW V RI RXU P RUDO DQG VSLULW XDO VW ULYLQJ FDQ EULQJ D UHODW LYHO\
FRQVROLQJ IXW XUH  +RZ FDQ W KH LQGLYLGXDO KHOS W R LP SURYH W KH GLUH IDW H RI RXU
SRHW V VFKRODUV DQG DUW LVW V"  , I HDFK ODQG RZQHU IDFW RU\ RZQHU P HUFKDQW  LI DOO
RW KHUV ZKR KDYH VRP H IUHH VSDFH LQ KLV KRXVH LQ W KH FLW \ RU LQ W KH FRXQW U\VLGH
LQYLW HVRQHRIW KHVHVSLULW XDOSHRSOHRIRXUIRONIRUDIHZGD\ VZHHNVRUP RQW KV
DQGW KHQUHFRP P HQGVKLP W RKLVIULHQGVDQGDFTXDLQW DQFHV1LQHW \ QLQHRIDOO
P DU U LDJHV DU H XQKDSS\ EHFDXVH W KH\  DU H QRW  RI HTXDO UDFH EXW  KHU H HY HQ
P LQLP DOGLIIHUHQFHVSOD\DGHFLVLYHUROH:KHQDFFRUGLQJW R*UHHNOHJHQGP DQ
DQG ZRP DQ DUH SDUW V IURP  D ZKROH W KDW  H[LVW HG LQ D IRUP HU HYROXW LRQDU\ HUD
ZKLFKZKROHZDVVW LOORIRQHVH[LHP DQ ZRP DQDQGW KDW LW LVORYHW KDW IRUFHV
W KHKXP DQEHLQJVW RVHDUFKIRUW KLVVHSDUDW HGSDUW W KHQZHKDY HW RDGP LW KRZ
Q HFHVVDU \  LW  LV W K H HT X DO FRP HV DJ DLQ  E DFN  W R HT X DO  RU  W K H U HDVRQ V I RU
LQFRQVLVW HQFLHV DU H JLY HQ D SU LRU L  'XU LQJ W KH W LP HV RI SXU H U DFHGQHVV W KH
P DUULDJHVZHUHDORW KDSSLHUW KHVHDUFKLQJDQGILQGLQJZDVHDVLHU7KLVH[SODLQV
W KH FXVW RP  W R JLYH DZD\ W KH ZRP DQ EHFDXVH LW  ZDV GLIILFXOW  W R ILQG DQ XQHTXDO
KXVEDQG DP RQJ UDFLDOO\ HTXDOV VLQFH DOO ZHUH EURW KHUV DQG VLVW HUV LQ D P XFK
W UXHUVHQVHW KDQDUHW RGD\W KHFKLOGUHQRIDIDP LO\ZKRRIW HQJRLQW RDOOGLIIHUHQW
GLU HFW LRQV  

7KHUHIRUH W KH (GGD VLQJV

7KH RQH VKRXOG LW  EH ZKR LV LQ P \ DUP V
$V ZLIH DQG DV VLVW HU

7KH VHHP LQJ FROGQHVV RI IHHOLQJV LQ DQW LTXLW \ W KDW  VW LOO H[LVW HG ZLW K SHRSOHV RI
SXUH UDFH FDQ EH H[SODLQHG DV D UHVXOW  RI FORVH UDFLDO NLQVKLS RI W KH LQGLYLGXDO
KXP DQV P HQ DQG ZRP HQ  6DP H UDFH FDXVHV XQLVRQ RI W KH HP RW LRQV RI P LQG
RINLQGRILQFOLQDW LRQVRIW KHEHLQJDQGLW DZDNHQVORYHZLW KRXW W KHW UDJLFRP LFDO
HUXSW LRQVRIXQHTXDOKXP DQVZKREHOLHYHW REHXQLILHGEH\RQGDOOW KHLUGLIIHUHQFHV
LQW HUQDO DV ZHOO DV H[W HUQDO RQHV QR P DW W HU KRZ W KHLU LQQHUP RVW  ZDUQV W KHP
DERXW  VXFK DFW LRQ  (TXDO FDQ RQO\ EH XQGHUVW RRG E\ HTXDO VD\V 3\W KDJRUDV 
ZKR P DUULHG DJDLQ LQ KLV  W K  \HDU RI OLIH

3XUFKDVHRIW KHEULGHUXQIRUW KHEULGHUREELQJW KHEULGHFRQW UDFW VEHW ZHHQW KH

SDUHQW V FRQFHUQLQJ FKLOGUHQ RI HTXDO UDFH DUH QRW  DV KDUG DQG U XW KOHVV DV W KH\
P D\ DSSHDU W R XV LQ RXU GD\V  , Q P DUULDJHV W KDW  DUH EDVHG RQ W KLV W \SH UDFLDO
P RUDOV DFFXP XODW H P RUH P DW HULDO W RZDUGV W UXH ORYH W KDQ LV W KH FDVH ZLW K RXU


 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

P DUULDJHVRIW KHSUHVHQW ZKLFKDUHP LV P DUULDJHV DOVR ³ P L[´  P DUULDJHV VHHQ
LQW KHOLJKW RIDUDFLDODQGW KHUHIRUHDOVRP RUDOSRLQW RIYLHZ7KHIDFW W KDW W KH
LQGLYLGXDO KDV EHHQ W RUQ DSDUW  LQVLGH DV D UHVXOW  RI XQHQGLQJ P L[LQJ FDXVHV KLP
RU  KHU  W R EH LQFDSDEOH RI D KDSS\ FKRLFH RI D VSRXVH D SU LRU L  7KH QDW XU DO
VHOHFW LRQ W KDW  IROORZV GHVLUH LV DOP RVW  FRP SOHW HO\ VXSSUHVVHG LQ W RGD\¶V OLYLQJ
FRQGLW LRQV DQG GXH W R W KH LQHTXDOLW \ RI W KRVH ZKR VHDUFK IRU VSRXVHV DQG W KH
ODFN RI HTXDO UDFLDO SHUVRQV W KH VHOHFW LRQ LV W KH P RVW  GLIILFXOW  RQH IRU W KH KLJK
UDFLDOSHUVRQ7KHJHQHUDOW UHQGRIW XUQLQJW KHSRSXODW LRQLQFUHDVLQJO\LQW RP REV
DQG ORZ OLIH W KDW  LV SHUSHW UDW HG E\ SUHVV FKXUFK DQG VFKRRO IDYRUV W KH OLH RI
HTXDOLW \RIDOOKXP DQEHLQJVDQGLQFUHDVHVW KHQXP EHURIXQKDSS\K\EULGVZLW K
DOO W KHLU LQW HUQDO GLVFRUGV DQG LQW HUQDO FDFRSKRQLHV LQW R W KH P LOOLRQV

:LW KLQW KHSXUHUDFHHYHU\ERG\KDVW KHVDP HIHHOLQJV7KHP DQSRVVHVVHVZLW K

KLVRQHZLIHDOVRDOOW KHRW KHUZRP HQRIKLVUDFH/XVW DULVHVDIW HUK\EULGL]DW LRQ
EHFDXVH QR P DQ DQG QR ZRP DQ UHSUHVHQW V KLV JHQGHU DQG KLV UDFH SHUIHFW O\
ZLW KLQ  3XUH UDFH ORYHV QDW XUDOO\ ZLW KRXW  LQFHQW LYH IURP  W KH RXW VLGH  7KHUH DUH
KDUGO\ DQ\ LQGLYLGXDO GLIIHUHQFHV  7KLV LV W KH VW DW H RI KDSSLQHVV W KH ³ SDUDGLVH
RQ(DUW K´6DW XUQDOLDP RUDORIW KH.RW LQJVW KH³ VSURXW VRIW KHJRGV´E\W KHROG
*HUP DQV%DFFKDQDOLDDUHEXW ZHDNUHP LQGHUVRIDJHQHUDO+LJK W LP HW KDW LVIDU
DZD\

$V VRRQ DV FRQVFLRXVQHVV RI UDFH DZDNHQV DQG ZKHUH LW  LV VW LOO LQ H[LVW HQFH W KH
IRON ZLOO SUDFW LFH VHOHFW LRQ IRU EUHHGLQJ  $ULVW RFUDF\ ZDV DOZ D\V V\QRQ\P RXV
ZLW KKLJKHUDQGSXUHUUDFHZKLFKZDVEUHGV\VW HP DW LFDOO\7KLVLGHDGRP LQDW HG
W KH HDUO\ KLVW RU\ RI W KH $U\DQV OLNH D QDW XUDO ODZ  7KH UDFLDO DULVW RFUDF\ ZDV
GHVW UR\HG E\ FKXUFK DQG VW DW H UHODW LYHO\ HDUO\  :KDW  W KH ³ JUHDW ´  .DUO   OHIW  KH
UHSODFHGLW ZLW KEDVW DUGL]HGSHRSOHIURP W KHSURYLQFHVRI*DXO/DW HUP LQLVW HULDOV
UHSODFHG DULVW RFUDF\ IUHTXHQW O\

7KH IDUP HU ZDV IRUFHG LQW R VHUIGRP  DIW HU KLV VRLO ZKLFK ZDV D ORDQ IURP  *RG
ZDVW DNHQDZD\IURP KLP %XW W KHIDUP HULVW KHRULJLQDOYRUW H[RIW KH$U\DQUDFH
6W LOO LQ RXU  GD\ V KH P DLQW DLQV FLW \  DQG FRXQW U \ VLGH Z LW K KLV EORRG  Z LW K KLV
SURJHQ\  +H FHUW DLQO\ LV VLFN LQIHFW HG E\ W KH JHQHUDO FROODSVH RI UDFH DQG VRXO
%XW  ZH KDYH W R DW W HP SW  RXU UHFRYHU\ ZLW K KLP  DQG W KURXJK KLP   )URP  KLP
UHGHP SW LRQ ZLOO FRP H  +H P XVW  EH OHG W R W KH VSULQJV RI ZLVGRP  NQRZOHGJH
FXOW XUH DQG UHOLJLRQ  $JDLQ W KH IDUP HU KDV W R EHFRP H JXDUGLDQ DQG DUFKLYLVW 
EHFDXVH RQO\ KH FDQ ZDUQ RXU HYROXW LRQ DERXW  GHHS DQG GLVDVW URXV HUURUV W R
ZKLFK DOO SDUW V RI W KH IRON DUH H[SRVHG ZKLFK DOUHDG\ DOORZHG W R EH UHP RYHG
IURP W KHVRLO:HDUHORVLQJRXUSRZHULIZHKDYHQRORQJHUDQ\FRQW DFW ZLW KW KH
VRLO M XVW  OLNH $QW DHRV W KH JLDQW  LQ W KH *UHHN OHJHQG ORVW  KLV SRZHU ZKHQ W KLV
KDSSHQHG W R KLP 

:H DUH EHIRUH D FKDQJHLQ W KH Z RUOGV +LVW RU\ FDQQRW  EH XQGHUVW RRG ZLW KLQ W KH
IU DP HZ RU N  RI HY HQW V RI D KXQGU HG RU  W Z R KXQGU HG \ HDU V DQG OLP LW HG W R W KH
H[SHULHQFHVRIDFRXSOHRIQDW LRQVEXW KLVW RU\FDQRQO\EHXQGHUVW RRGZLW KLQW KH
IUDP HZRUN RI ZLGH FRQQHFW LRQV ZLW KLQ W KH OLYHV RI LW V UDFHV FRQQHFW LRQV W KDW

&KDUOHP DJQH &DUROXV0DJQXV
 

VSDQ P LOOHQQLD  7ZR P LOOHQQLD LQ W KH OLIH RI SHRSOHV DUH FRP SDUDEOH W R D FRXSOH
RI \HDUV ZHHNV HYHQ M XVW  D GD\

7KH JHQLDO FUHDW LYH SHUVRQ LV QRW  W KH ILQDO UHVXOW  RI D ORQJ HY ROXW LRQ RI VSHFLILF
EORRGOLQHV DQG QRW  W KH ILQDO SURGXFW  RI SHUIHFW LRQ RI KXP DQLW \ EXW  EDVLF VHOI
HYLGHQFHZLW KHYHU\RQHZKROLYHV7KLVLVREYLRXVZKHQZHREVHUYHW KHFUHDW LYLW \
RI W KH FKLOG LW V GRXEW OHVVO\ ³ JHQLDO´  IUHHGRP   7KH VR FDOOHG ³ QRUP DO SHUVRQ´
ZKR UXOHV LQ RXU GD\V W KH DYHUDJH SHUVRQ P RVW  RI W KH W LP H EHORZ DYHUDJH
SHUVRQDUHXQHTXLYRFDOVLJQVW KDW GHJHQHUDW LRQKDSSHQHGDOUHDG\6LQFHDIHZ
P LOOLRQ \HDUV VLQFH W KH SUHVHQFH RI W KH $U\DQ *RW K , I \RX ZDQW  D ³ VFLHQW LILF´
FUXW FK, DP W DONLQJDERXW W KH$XULJQDF UDFH W KHUHKDVQRW EHHQDQ\HYROXW LRQ
RI D SU H GHW HU P LQHG GRXEW IXO ³ KXP DQLW \ ´ EXW  RQO\  GH HY ROXW LRQ  GRZ QZDU G
GHJHQHUDW LRQ RI W KH *RW K EHFDXVH RI KLV K\EULGL]DW LRQ ZLW K DQLP DOV DQG DSHV 

7KH HDU OLHVW  LQVW LW XW LRQV RI W KH $U \ DQV  E\  Z KLFK P HDQV W KH\  RU JDQL]HG OLIH
EHW ZHHQ HDFK RW KHU W KHLU ZD\ RI OLIH W KHLU NQRZOHGJH RI *RG DQG H[SHULHQFH RI
W KH ZRUOG KRZ W KH\ SHUFHLYHG ZRUVKLS FRUUHFW O\ QDP HO\ W R H[SU HVV W KH ZLOO RI
W KH'LYLQHW KURXJKW KHLUFKDUDFW HUDQGW KURXJKW KHFKDUDFW HURIQDW XUHDOORIW KDW
UHTXLUHV KLJKHVW  HYROYHG VRXOV VSLULW V DQG ERGLHV  6R LW  LV IDFW  W KDW  W KH P RVW
GHJHQHUDW HG SHRSOH RI RXU GD\V W KH P RVW  DQLP DO OLNH RQHV LQ FLYLOL]DW LRQ JHW
W KHLUELJJHVW HQM R\P HQW RXW RIOLYLQJLQW KHKHOORIDP HW URSROLVRXW RI³ :HVW HUQ´
HGXFDW LRQ LQ IRUFHG VFKRROLQJ LQ W KH JRYHUQP HQW  RI EXUHDXFUDW V LQ ³ W UDIILF´
ZLW KLQW KHSLW LIXOLP SRVHG³ RUGHU ´7KH*RW KRQW KHRW KHUKDQGW KHUDFLDOO\SXUH
RQH RU W KH ³ FORVH W R UDFLDOO\ SXUH´  SHUVRQ ZLOO DOZD\V FKRRVH RQH RI W KH P RVW
KRQRUDEOHSURIHVVLRQV 7HDFKLQJGHIHQVHDQGIHHGLQJ  7RW KHFODVVRIW HDFKHUV
EHORQJ   W KH W UXH SULHVW  W KH W HDFKHU W KH DUW LVW  W KH GLVFRYHUHU W KH LQYHQW RU W KH
P HGLFDO GRFW RU ZKR LV DQ DUW LVW  LQ KLV VNLOO W KH VFKRODU W KH P DQ RI *RG ZLW KRXW
HP SKDVLV RI W KHLU FRQFHUQV XSRQ UHW LUHP HQW  EHQHILW V DQG W KHLU ³ GDLO\ EUHDG´ RU
VDODU\  7R W KH FODVV RI GHIHQVH EHORQJ W KH ZDUULRUV RI HYHU\ GHVFULSW LRQ  7R W KH
QRXULVKLQJ FODVV EHORQJV W KH IDUP HU ZKR ZRUNV RQ KLV RZQ IUHH ODQG QRW  XQGHU
W HUULEOHSUHVVXUHW RIHHGFRP SHW HQW O\KLP VHOIDQGKLVKHOS$W EHVW ZHFDQDGG
KHUH W KH FUDIW VP DQ  $OO RW KHU SURIHVVLRQV DUH LP P RUDO LQ W KH GHHSHVW  RI W KH
P HDQLQJ RI W KH ZRUG  7KH\ RULJLQDW HG LQ W KH GHJHQHUDW LRQV RI HFRQRP LF DQG
JRYHUQP HQW  VW UXFW XUHV DQG W KH\ FRQVW LW XW H DQ HQVODYHP HQW  W KDW  LV FRYHUHG XS
RQO\ VXSHUILFLDOO\

, Q ERW K FXOW XUH DQG FLYLOL]DW LRQ W KHUH LV D UHODW LRQVKLS EHW Z HHQ W KRVH ZKR UXOH
DQGW KRVHZKRVHUYHEHW ZHHQP DVW HUVDQGVODYHV:HFDQP DNHW KHREVHUYDW LRQ
DQGW KLVREVHUYDW LRQLVLQIDOOLEOHW KDW LQW UXHFXOW XUHVW KHU DFLDOO\KLJKHURQHVDUH
W KHUXOHUVRIW KHSRSXODW LRQZKLOHLQFLYLOL]DW LRQVRIROGDQGQHZHUDVW KHKXP DQ
EHDVW  LV UXOLQJ DQG W KH SDUW  W KDW  EHORQJV W R W KH QREOH UDFHV LV VXIIHULQJ


, W P D\EHLQGLFDW HGW RGLYLGHW KH³ P LOOLRQVRI\HDUV´ ZKLFKKHFODLP VE\URXJKO\

2PLWWHG

/HKU :HKU XQG1lKUVW DQG
 

7KH ³ FDVW HV´  DUH FOHDUO\ SUHVHQW  VW LOO LQ RXU HUD  $OUHDG\ DP RQJ P RVW  RI W KH
$U\DQVW KHUHZDVDVHSDUDW LRQRIW KHQREOHRQHVW KHFRP P RQIUHHRQHVDQGW KH
IUHHG RQHV  W KH SULHVW  W KH ZDUULRU W KH FUDIW VP DQ DQG W KH P HUFKDQW   7R W KH
³ P HUFKDQW ´ ZHFDQDOVRDGGW KHP DVVRIW KH³ 7VFKDQGDOHQ´DOO³ GD\ODERUHUV´EH
W KH\LQRIILFHDQGKRQRURULQW KHIDFW RU\W KHJ\SVLHVDQGFULP LQDOV7KHGLIIHUHQFH
W KHUH LV W KDW  P RVW  RI W KHVH ³ FDVW HV´  DUH QR ORQJHU SUDFW LFLQJ W KH SURIHVVLRQ LQW R
ZKLFKW KH\ZHUHERUQEHFDXVHDOOUDFLDORUGHULQVW DW HDQGSHRSOHLVHOLP LQDW HG
DQGKDUGO\DQ\RQHFDQSUDFW LFHKLVSURIHVVLRQW KDW LVKLVULJKW DFFRUGLQJW RIDW H
, W ZDVQRW RQO\W KHSURIHVVLRQZDVGHW HUP LQHGLQW KHSDVW E\W KHSRVLW LRQRIW KH
VW DUVDW W KHW LP HRIELUW KEXW FKLOGUHQZHUHFRQFHLYHGXQGHUGLUHFW LRQDQGDGYLFH
RISULHVW VW KDW ZHUHNQRZOHGJHDEOHLQDVW URORJ\7KH\FKRVHW KHSDUHQW VIRUW KH
FKLOG DQG W KH FKLOG IRU W KH SDUHQW V

3DFW V ZLW K 0HSKLVW R DQG DOO GHYLOV KDYH W R EH VLJQHG ZLW K EORRG ZKHQ W KH VRXO
LVW REHVROG7KLVP HDQVFOHDUO\W KDW ZLW KJLYLQJDZD\RXUEORRGE\P L[LQJZLW K
ZH DUH DOVR VHOOLQJ RXU VRXO W R W KH GHP RQLVP  RI ORZ UDFHV

7R ZLVK W R EH ZKDW  ZH DUH DQG QRW  GLIIHUHQW O\ SURYHV LQVLJKW  LQ W KH 'LYLQH DQG
KDSSLQHVV7KH³ -RW H´ FDQQHYHUIHHOW KLVVHOI VDW LVIDFW LRQDQGVHOI FRQW HQW P HQW 
, I W KLV ZDV QRW  W KH FDVH W KH &KXUFK  DQG ORZ UDFH W HDFKLQJV ZRXOG QRW  W U\ W R
FRQYLQFH XV W KDW  *RG LV RXW VLGH RI XV  7KH\ GR VR VLP SO\ EHFDXVH *RG LV QRW
ZLW KLQW KHP 7KH\UHSURDFKXVIRUW DONLQJLQVXFKDQ³ XQ &KULVW LDQZD\´ VRP XFK
DERXW  UDFH DQG UHOLJLRQ DW  W KH VDP H W LP H  %XW  Z H GR VR ULJKW IXOO\ EHFDXVH
QRZKHUH RQH IORZV IURP  W KH RW KHU DUH REYLRXVO\ DV UDFH IORZV IU RP  UHOLJLRQ DQG
UHOLJLRQV IORZV IURP  UDFH  (YHU\RQH VKDSHV DQG XQGHUVW DQGV KLV *RG DFFRUGLQJ
W R KLV LP DJH  7KH -RW H VKDSHV *RG DV D -RW H W KH *RW K D *RW K ZKDW HYHU LV LQ
EHW ZHHQ LV DOVR HYLO

7KHP RUH$U\DQDIDFHRUDERG\LVW KHP RUHEHDXW LIXOLW LV$0RQJROFRXOGQHYHU

KDYHEHHQDEOHW RP RGHOIRUDQ$SROORRI%HOYHGHUH7KHW KRXJKW RIP DQVRQRI
*RG$U\DQZDVW KRXJKW RXW DQGZDQW HGE\FUHDW LRQRQO\RQFHDQGKHEHFDP H
IRUP LQW KH*RW K$OORW KHUUDFHVDUHW KHUHVXOW RIUHSHDW HGP L[LQJRIW KH*RW KV
ZLW K ³ DQLP DOV´  DQG W KH P L[LQJ RI W KHVH EDVW DUGV ZLW K *RW KV DQLP DOV DQG KDOI
DQLP DOV7KH0RQJROVW KHQHJURHVW KH$XVW UDOLDQVDUHDVOLW W OHDQRULJLQDOUDFH
DVOLW W OHDVW KH\DUHRULJLQDO³ KXP DQ´$OORIW KHP EHFDP HULJLGLILHGEDVW DUGL]DW LRQV
³ UDFHV´  RI W KH UDFH OHVV RI ZKLFK W KH $XVW UDOLDQV W KH SHRSOHV LQ 1HZ =HDODQG
DQGP RVW RIW KHSHRSOHVLQW KH6RXW K6HDDUHH[DP SOHVRIP RUHU HFHQW IRUP DW LRQ
ZKLOH W KH 1HJURHV DQG W KH 0RQJROV FRQVW LW XW H ROG EDVW DUGL]DW LRQV

+XP DQ DQW L VHUXP  ZDV GHYHORSHG IURP  SXUH $U\DQ EORRG DQG XVHG IRU VHYHUDO
H[SHULP HQW V:KHQP L[HGZLW KW KHEORRGRIW KH0RQJROLW ZDVDOP RVW LQHIIHFW LYH
ZLW K W KH 1HJUR LW  JRW  FORXG\ DQG ZLW K W KH 0HGLW HUUDQHDQ W KHUH ZDV D FRYHU OLNH
D YHLO DQG ZLW K W KH $U\DQ LW  ZDV OLNH D ELJ FORXG W HQ W LP HV DV VW URQJ DV LQ DOO
RW KHU H[SHULP HQW V  $ VLP LODU HIIHFW  LV VW LOO W KHUH ZLW K DQ (J\SW LDQ P XP P \ W KDW
ZDV  \HDUV ROG  7KHUHIRUH W KLV FRUSVH ZDV DQ $U\DQ ZLW KRXW  GRXEW  


1RW VRDFFRUGLQJW RUHFHQW JHQHW LFH[DP LQDW LRQ
 

$OO P DP P DOV DUH IRXU OHJJHG  7KH $U\DQ LV W ZR KDQGHG LQ D YH\ VSHFLDO ZD\
7KHUHIRUH ³ 0DQQ´  P DQ   0$1 ROG 1RUGLF   P DQQXV  0HQVFK DQG P DQXV
KDQG LQ /DW LQ   +H LV RQH ³ ZKR JHW V D JULS´  RQ VRP HW KLQJ SK\ VLFDOO\ EXW  DOVR
P HQW DOO\ P DQDV  UHDVLQ LQW HOOHFW  6DQVFULW  P HQV  LQW HOOHFW  /DW LQ  P DQQD
 'LY LQH IRRG  $OO ORZ  U DFHV ORY H W R XVH W KH IHHW  DW  W LP HV Z KHQ SU DFW LFLQJ
FU DIW VP DQVKLS

7KH DSH LQ SRSXODU YLHZ LV IRXU KDQGHG EXW  DQDW RP LFDOO\ W KH EDFN KDQGV DUH
DFW XDOO\ W ZR W UXH IHHW   :H FRXOG EH M XVW LILHG LQ DVVXP LQJ W KDW  W KH DSH LV D P L[
EHW ZHHQ KXP DQ DQG DQLP DO DV P RVW  UHVHDUFKHUV ZRXOG DOVR DFFHSW    D K\EULG
EHW ZHHQ D KLJKO\ HYROYHG KXP DQ D SUH $U\DQ DQG VRP H P DP P DO SU HFXUVRU  
7KHORZKXP DQUDFHVW KHQFDQEHYLHZHGDVUHSHDW HGP L[HVEHW ZHHQW KH$U\DQ
DQG EDVW DUG W \SHV EHW ZHHQ DSH DQG KXP DQ W KDW  HYROYHG ODW HU

7R P H LW  VHHP V W KDW  LQ W KH ZRUG ³ KRP R´ FRQW UDU\ W R W KH ZRUG ³ P DQ´   KDQG
VSLULW  LQW HOOHFW  DU P DQ  VSLULW  P DQ 6XQ P DQ $UP DQH  LV VW LOO W KH QRW LRQ RI D
P L[W XUH6HP +DP DQG-DSKHW  VLP LD+lP  OLQJDQGDSH7KH\DUHSURJHQ\
RI 1RDK ZKR KLP VHOI ZDV ILUVW  P DGH E\ W KH ³ JRGV´  DQG ZKR W KHUHIRUH LV SDUW
DQLP DO  , Q W KH ZRUG +DP  W KHUH DUH FOHDUO\ W KH QRW LRQV RI EORFNDJH DQG P L[LQJ
³ EOHQGLQJ´  RI ZLQH  +lP  OLQJ +lP LVFK GHURJDW LYHO\  +lP P HU OLQJ  GHYLO
+DP  SHOP DQQ KDOIP DQ KDP SD 6SDQLVK  ORZOLIH+DP P HO FDVW UDW HGUDP 
+DP D G\UDV  D VSHFLHV RI P RQNH\V  6HP  FOHDUO\ LV ³ VLP LD´   DSH DOVR ³ KDOI
VHP L W KH LQYHUVLRQ RI ZKLFK LV P LV DQG P H]  W R P L[
-DSKHW  $IIH DSH SRVVLEOHGHULYDW LRQV -DSDQ-DSV$I JKDQLVW DQZKHUHW KH
(DVW HUQ W ULEH LV FDOOHG $I ULGL

)RUW KHFRQFHSW RIP L[LQJZHKDYHVLP LODURUHTXDOO\VRXQGLQJZ RUGVHYHU\ZKHUH

LQ W ULEDO QDP HV DQG QDP HV RI SHRSOHV  , Q HQJOLVK W KH ZRUG P RQJUHO LV XVHG IRU
FURVVEUHHGRUEDVW DUG7KLVLVW KHVDP HZRUGDV0RQJRO6SDQLVK P RQR DSH
P DQ  P RQHVNR  DSH OLNH GHVFHQGLQJ IURP  W KH DSH

(QJOLVK ³ P RQNH\´  LV DSH   LQGLFDW LQJ D P L[ HYHU\ZKHUH  , W  LV HQW LUHO\ FOHDU W KDW
DOVR W KH ZRUG IRU HDW LQJ ³ P DQJHU´  LQ )UHQFK DQG ³ P DQJLDUH´  LQ , W DOLDQ LV UHODW HG
W R P L[LQJ EHFDXVH LQ FRSXODW LRQ W KH JHQGHUV P L[ HDFK RW KHU  ³ (DW ´  ZDV DOZD\V
W KHVHFUHW ZRUGIRUSURFUHDW LRQDQGFRSXODW LRQP HUJLQJZLW KHDFKRW KHU$VVXFK
LW  LV DOVR YDOLG LQ W KH %LEOH DERYH DOO LQ W KH FUHDW LRQ P \W K  ³ 0DQJHU´  )UHQFK
P DQM DU6SDQLVKLVW KH*HUP DQ³ 0DQVFKHQ´³ 0LVFKHQ´  ERW KIRUP L[LQJ 0HVW L]R
6SDQLVK  LV P L[HG EUHHG EDVW DUG  7KH DQFLHQW  3HUXYLDQ EDUHO\  GLVW LQJXLVKHV
W KH ZRUGV RI P DQ DQG DSH   P XLVFR DQG P XLVFD  W KH QDP HV RI W ZR VSHFLHV RI
DSHV  DUH DOVR ULQJLQJ D EHOO   0DQJ DEHQ DQG 0DN DNHQ  )UHQFK ³ P HVTXLQ´ 

2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 

P HDQ6SDQLVK³ P H]´  KDOI LQYHUW HGVLP  0H]FODU W RP L[, QW KLVFRQQHFW LQ
ZHP HQW LRQDOVRW KHZRUGV³ P DXVHQ´  KDYLQJVH[ DQG³ 0lXVFKHQ´  OLW W OHP RXVH
LQ W KHLU P HDQLQJV LQ W KH GLDOHFW  LQ UHIHUHQFH W R ³ P L[LQJ´  :LW K ³ 0DQVFKHQ´  W KH
³ &DYDOLHU´  .QLJKW  UHIHUV W R D UHODW LRQVKLS EHW ZHHQ GLIIHUHQW  FODVVHV

7KURXJK W KH SUDFW LFH RI P L[LQJ Z H LQFUHDVH W KH FKDRV W KH SDLQ  W KH HW HUQDO
GLVFRUGW KHUHVW OHVVQHVVW KHGLVFRUGLQW KHFRQW UDU\W RXQLRQ7KHVDW LVIDFW LRQ
RI KXP DQNLQG LV RQO\ SRVVLEOH E\ P HDQV RI OHDGLQJ LW  W R W KH SXU H UDFH LQ P \
RSLQLRQ DOVR W R SXUH UDFHV HYHQ W KRXJK ZKHQ H[DP LQLQJ W KH P HDQLQJ RI W KH
ZRUGFORVHUW KHUHLVRQO\RQHSXUHUDFHUDW DLQROG1RUGLFRQHUDGL[RQHURRW 
1DW XUH DFW XDOO\ RSSRVHV HYHU\ K\EULGL]DW LRQ  , I LW  LV QRW  IRUFHG DUW LILFLDOO\ W R
FRQW LQXLQJ P L[LQJ LW  GH P L[HV LW VHOI QDW XUDOO\ VSOLW V LW V FRP SRQHQW V EDFN LQW R
LW V RU LJLQDO SDU W V DQG LQGLFDW HV Z LW K LW  W KDW  LW  GRHV QRW  Z DQW  P L[ LQJ  W KDW  LW
UHM HFW V³ P DQVFKHQ´ DQG³ 9HUN|W HUXQJ´  VRP HZD\W UDQVODW HGLQW R³ GRJ LILFDW LRQ´  

5DW D   5DW D LQ ROG 1RU GLF ODQJXDJH LV W KH U RRW  W KH 8U  6SU LQJ 5RRW  W KH $OO
UDXQH   ZLW K ZKLFK :RGDQ GULOOV W KH P HDG RI SRHW U\ ZKLFK P HDQV W KDW  KH JHW V
LQVLJKW  RI OLIH ZKLFK VROYHV DOO VHFUHW V RI H[LVW HQFH

7RGD\¶V KXP DQV DUH QRW  JHW W LQJ P RUH VLP LODU LQ FHUW DLQ UHVSHFW V E\ EHFRP LQJ
EHW W HU EXW  EHFDXVH DOVR W KH EHW W HU RQHV EHFRP H XJOLHU ZRUVH DV D UHVXOW  RI
JHQHUDOP L[LQJDQGK\EULGL]DW LRQLQZKLFKSURFHVVW KH\ORVHDOOW KHLUDGYDQW DJHV

&DQQRW  ZH VHH KRZ KRUULI\LQJO\ KXP DQV EHFRP H LQFUHDVLQJO\"  -XVW  ORRN LQ W KH
W UDP ZD\V LQ W KH W KHDW HUV LQ W KH FLQHP D RQ W KH VW UHHW V LQ EULHI HYHU\ZKHUH
SHRSOH FRQJU HJDW H  7KH EHFRP H LQFU HDVLQJO\  GLVW DQFHV IU RP  KXP DQ QDW XU H
P RUH VLP LODU W R DSHV  7KH GH VSLULW XDOL]DW LRQ DQG GH GLYLQLVDW LRQ RI W KH P DVVHV
P DNHV YHU\ UDSLG SURJUHVV  +HUH D FLUFXODW LQJ FKDRV DW W UDFW V DOO VFXP   7KH
³ -RW H´ VXFFHHGHGHDUO\W REDEEOHRXW RIW KHP LQGVRIW KHDYHUDJHSHUVRQW KHLGHD
RI D UDFLDO XS EUHHGLQJ  :KHUH DUH EHDXW LIXOO\ JURZQ SHRSOH VXSSRUW HG RU HYHQ
EUHG"

7KH P DVVHV IHHO M XVW  ILQH  SLJ DP RQJ SLJV   7KH DQJHU W KH H[FLW DW LRQ LQFUHDVHV
VR KRUULEO\ LQ RXU GD\V EHFDXVH LW ¶V YHU\ UDUH W KDW  W ZR SHRSOH OHW  DORQH P RUH
W KDQ W ZR SHRSOH RI W KH RI VDP H UDFH P HHW  ZKR ZRXOG KDYH RQH RSLQLRQ   7KH
GLVVRQDQFHVRIW KHP LQGV6RXOVVSLULW VDQGSK\VLFDOERGLHVDUHVRKDUGW KDW D
JHQHUDO EDG VRXQG FDFRSKRQ\  KXUW V W KH UHODW LRQV RI KXP DQV DP RQJVW  HDFK
RW KHU


2PLWWHG

$OO P XUP XUDOO UXQHEXW $OUDXQHLVDOVRDP HGLFLQDOKHUEDFXUH DOO
 

%XW  P DQ\ ZDQW  W R EH XJO\  , Q IDFW  W KH\ SULGH W KHP VHOYHV RI W KDW   :H VKRXOG
QHY HU  IRU JHW  W KDW   %HFDXVH VHFU HW O\ LQ W KHLU  VXEFRQVFLRXV W KH\  IHHO KDSS\
DERXW  W KLV VW DW H RI DIIDLUV  7KH\ HQM R\ EHLQJ SHRSOH ZKR GR W RR OLW W OH ZKR ORVW
W KHLU  U LJKW V  Z LW KRXW  W KH ORDG RI D W DVN    )U RP  W KLV VLW XDW LRQ W KH\  IRU JH IRU
W KHP VHOYHV D VW DW H RI KDSSLQHVV  7KH\ P DNH D YLUW XH RXW  RI W KHLU SUREOHP V
:KDW GRHVW KDW P HDQ"7KLVP HDQVW KDW W KH\DUHQRW M XVW ODFNLQJW KHZLOO W KHLU
DSSDUHQW  ZLOO LV IUXLW OHVV FRP SODLQLQJ   W R EH W KH VW URQJHU RQHV W KH P RUH QREOH
RQHV  EXW  DOVR W KH SK\VLFDO FDSDELOLW \ LV ODFNLQJ  )URP  DOO SK\VLFDO LQFDSDELOLW \
KRZHYHU W KLV FRQFHSW  KDV W R EH P HDVXUHG YHU\ EURDGO\  UHVXOW V DQ HP SLUH RI
HTXDOLW \ W KDW  W KH SRRU RQHV W KH LGLRW LF RQHV W KH ZHDN RQHV ZDQW  W R HUHFW  DV D
UHIXJH

7KH FKDLU W KH W KURQH LV D V\P ERO RI 'LYLQH SRZHU DQG ZRUOGO\ UXOHUVKLS  %HLQJ
FDSDEOHW RVLW LVDV\P ERORIW KH*RW KLFUDFH$OOLQIHULRUUDFHVDQGDSHVFURVVW KH
OHJVHYHQLI\RXSXW W KHP RQFKDLUV, P SHULDOFKDLUVM XGLFLDOFKDLUVW KHFKDLURI
W KH KLJK SULHVW V DUH VW LOO UHP LQGHUV RI W KH IRUP HU JHQHUDO YDOXH RI W KH FKDLU DV D
SULYLOHJH RI W KH M XGJH DQG UXOHU  +RZ P DQ\ SHRSOH FDQ VLW  FRUU HFW O\ RQ FKDLUV LQ
RXU W LP HV"  3HRSOH SUHIHU W R VLW  RQ W KH IORRU EHFDXVH W KDW  DSSHDUV W R EH P RUH
FRP IRUW DEOH7KHSHUVRQZKRKDVJURZQXSULJKW VKRXOGFKHFNW KDW RXW IRUKLP VHOI
KH VKRXOG QRW  DOORZ W R EH VHGXFHG E\ KLV HQW KXVLDVP  IRU W KLQJV IURP  W KH (DVW 
IRU%XGGKLVP W RW KLQJVW KDW DUHGHW ULP HQW DOIRUKLP EHFDXVHW KH\GRQRW P DW FK
KLP   :H FDQ DSSURDFK W KH VSLULW XDO JRRGV RI W KH (DVW  TXLFNHU Z LW K P HW KRGV
RW KHU W KDQ VLW W LQJ LQ XQFRP IRUW DEOH SRVLW LRQV  :H DUH JLYHQ W KDW  ZKLFK LV RXU
$U\DQ LQKHULW DQFH DQG ZH VKRXOG DFFHSW  LW  ZLW K W KDQNV DQG XVH LW 

7KH*HUP DQKDVDVSHFLDOSRVLW LRQLQ(XURSH+HLVW KHFHQW HURI(XURSHDQGIURP

RXUHYROXW LRQQRW M XVW RXUIDW HLVGHSHQGHQW EXW DOVRW KHIDW HRI(XURSH+LVW RU\
KDVW REHYLHZHGUDFH UHODW HG:KDW HYHUZDVDFKLHYHGLQ(XURSH$IULFD$P HULFD
DQG $VLD FDP H IURP  $U\DQ VRXUFHV

<RX VKRXOG NQRZ W KDW  \RXU ERG\ LV W KH W HP SOH RI *RG DQG *RG OLYHV LQVLGH \RX
<RX GLG QRW  EHFRP H ZKDW  \RX DUH RXW  RI \RXU RZQ HIIRUW   7KHUHIRUH SUDLVH W KH
/RUG LQ \RXU ERG\  +LV VSLULW  HQOLYHQV LW   <RX DUH RI *RG

7R EH $U\DQ P HDQV W R KDYH W KH LQQHU FHUW DLQW \ RI RQH¶V P HQW DO DQG SK\VLFDO
VXSHULRULW \DVFRP SDUHGZLW KHYHU\W KLQJ³ KXP DQ´EHFDXVHW KDW Z KLFKVXUURXQGV
XVLQRXUGDLO\OLIHLVM XVW DGLVW RUW HGP DVNRIW UXHKXP DQLW \, W LVW KHVSLULW ZKR
JLYHV OLIH W R W KH VKDSH DQG ZKHUH W KH VSLULW  LV ODFNLQJ W KH VKDSH ZLW KHUV

7KH *HUP DQV EHFDP H W LP LG SHRSOH EHFDXVH DOUHDG\ LQ HDUO\ W LP HV W KH\ JRW
UREEHG RI W KHLU VSLULW XDO IRXQGDW LRQ  $W  DOO W LP HV W KH\ DUH DIUDLG W KDW  W KH\ IDOO
W KURXJK W KH IHZ SODQNV W KDW  OHIW  VW LOO KROGLQJ W KH EDVLF VW UXFW XUH  7KH VKRXOG
DOORZW RIDOO7KHDE\VVUHFHLYHVW KHP VRIW O\RQW KHJURXQGRIW KHLURZQVRXODQG
W KHUHLVDQH[LW W RW KHEORRP LQJDQGM R\IXOILHOGVRIW KHLURZQVSLULW XDOLW \DOW KRXJK
LW  LV D QDUURZ H[LW 
 

7KH VW URQJ EHQHYROHQW  W KH VHOI XQGHUVW DQGLQJ RQH VXFFXP EV RIW HQ SDUW  RXW  RI
EHLQJ JURVVHG RXW  SDUW  EHFDXVH RI LQGLIIHUHQFH EHFDXVH KH JRHV LQ W KH VW UHHW V
ZLW KRXW ZHDSRQVW UXVW LQJKLVVW UHQJW KZLW KRXW ZRUULHVDQGFRQFHUQV%XW W KHUH
DUH UREEHUV RI P DQ\ NLQGV DQG RIW HQ KH KDV EDUHO\ W KH W LP H W R FDW FK W KH VSHDU
W KDW  LV DLP HG DW  KLV KHDUW  ZLW K W KH EDUH KDQG DQG HYHQ W KHQ KH LV M XVW  VDW LVILHG
Z LW K KDY LQJ GLVDU P HG W KH RSSRQHQW   +H GRHV QRW  W KU RZ  W KH VSHDU  EDFN  W R
GHVW UR\ LW V RZQHU ODXJKLQJO\ KH FRQW LQXHV W R ZDON  7KH RSSRQHQW V EHOLHYH W KDW
KHIHDUVW KHFRP EDW DQGVRRQW KH\FRP HLQP DVVHVW RNLOOKLP (YHQW XDOO\DURFN
IURP W KHVOLQJVKRW RIVRP H'DYLGKLW VW KHIRUHKHDGRIW KHFDUHOHVVSHUVRQ, QP \
RSLQLRQ LW  LV P RUH QREOH W R EH D *ROLDW K W KDQ D 'DYLG  +HUH ,  KDYH W R SRLQW  RXW
W KDW LW LVDOLHZKHQW KH-HZVFODLP W KDW *ROLDW KVFUHDP HGLQIURQW RIW KHLUW HQW V
*LDQW V GR QRW  VFUHDP   7KH\ VOHHS XVXDOO\ RYHU W KHLU KHDY\ W KRXJKW V DQG W KHLU
KXJH IRUFH

+RQHVW FRP EDW LVW KHURRW :HFDQQRW JHW DQKRQHVW FRP EDW DQ\ZKHUHDVIDUDV
ZHDQGW KHRSSRQHQW DUHFRQFHUQHGW KDW ¶VZK\ZHVXFFXP E6W HSRQW KHKHDG
RIW KHSRLVRQRXVVQDNHW KDW W HDFKHVDQGDGYLVHV ³ ORYHW K\QHLJKERU´ DQGP HDQV
ZLW KW KDW W KHORZOLHVW W KHRQHW KDW LVIDUW KHVW DZD\ 1HYHU\HW DZRUGKDVEHHQ
GLVW RUW HG DV P XFK DQG FRQYHUW HG LQW R LW V RSSRVLW H DV W KLV ZRUG RI $U\DQ 8U
NQRZOHGJH *RGORYHVRQO\SXUHORYH*RGVW D\VZLW KLQ\RXLQVRIDUDV\RXORYH
LQSXUHORYHLH\RXUQHLJKERU(YHU\W KLQJHOVHLVOHZGQHVVRIW KHOHZGDQLP DO
ZKLFKW KURXJKRXW W KHP LOOHQQLDSUHYHQW VW KHNLQJGRP RI*RGW KHNLQJGRP RIW KH
*RW KV W KH NLQJGRP  RI W KH *RRG RQHV RQ (DUW K

7KH RUGHUV  DUH ROGHVW  $U\DQ LQVW LW XW LRQV DQG VHUYHG IRUP HUO\ W KH XS EUHHGLQJ
EXW  DOVR DV D UHSRVH IRU W KH KXP DQ ZKR VHDUFKHG SHDFH P HGLW DW LRQ DQG LQQHU
YLHZ DIW HU D EOHVVHG OLIH LQ ORYH DQG ZRUN  7KH P RQDVW HULHV DQG RUGHUV ZHUH DV
KHLUV RI W KH DQFLHQW  SULHVW  VFKRROV W KH SODFHV RI VFLHQFH DUW  DQG W KH UHDOL]DW LRQ
RI W KH 'LYLQH  2QO\ GXULQJ W KH ODW HU P LGGOH DJHV P RQDVW LFLVP  GHJHQHUDW HG IRU
LQVW DQFHLQW RW KHEHJJLQJRUGHUV7KHDQFLHQW GHP DQGIRUFKDVW LW \SRYHUW \DQG
REHGLHQFHKDVUHFHLYHGDQHQW LUHO\GLIIHUHQW P HDQLQJZKHQP RQDVW LFLVP GHFOLQHG
2ULJLQDOO\ FKDVW LW \ P HDQW  SURFUHDW LRQ ZLW KLQ W KH UDFH FDUH IRU  UDFH DQG JHQGHU
:LW K SRYHUW \ QRW  ODFN RI SRVVHVVLRQ ZDV P HDQW  EXW  UHQXQFLDW LRQ RI LQFRP H E\
P HDQV RI FRP P HUFH RU LQM XVW LILDEOH HDUQLQJV  $U P XW  SRYHUW \  LV DQ DW W LW XGH
W KDW LVEURXJKW E\W KH$DU HDJOH  $U JHP W 6RQQHQ JHP W  $U P XW  FRXUDJH
RI W KH (DJOH  7KLV DORQJ ZRUN FDQ GR QDP HO\ ³$DU EHXW H   VSRLQV RI W KH $DU
RIIHUHGE\W KH$DURIIHUHGE\W KH6XQ $U VSRLOVIURP W KH6XQ2QO\W KDW ZKLFK
LV GXH W KH 6XQ  2QO\ LQ LW  LV VDOYDW LRQ DQG EOHVVLQJ EHFDXVH HYHU\W KLQJ HOVH
EULQJV P LVIRUW XQH


5HOLJLRXVRUGHUVDQGP HW DSK\VLFDORUGHUV
 

2EHGLHQFHZDVW KHYROXQW DU\RQHZKLFKZDVDFRP P LW P HQW LQW KHFRP SDQLRQVKLS

IRUOLIHW RW KH³ SULP XVLQW HUSDUHV´W KH³ ILUVW RQHDP RQJHTXDOV´SOXVW KHREHGLHQFH
RI W KH QDW XUDO 8U ODZ W R ZKLFK W KH HOHFW HG OHDGHU ZDV HVSHFLDOO\ FRP P LW W HG

7RUHQHZVXFKRUGHUVRI$U\DQUXOHVIRUOLIHLVDKLJKJRDODQGZRUW KW KHVDFULILFH

RIW KHEHVW , QFRQQHFW LRQZLW KVHW W OLQJLVP D\SHUKDSVUHP DLQW KHRQO\SRVVLELOLW \
W R UHQHZ $U\DQ FRP P LW P HQW  LQ OLIH DQHZ LQ LQGHSHQGHQW  XQLW V

7KDW  W KH LGHD RI EUHHGLQJ ZDV QRW  FRP SOHW HO\ GHDG LQ W KH P RQDVW LFLVP  RI W KH
P LGGOH DJHV VKRZV W KH IRXQGDW LRQ RI D NQLJKW O\ RUGHU E\ (P SHURU  /XGZLJ W KH
%DYDULDQ LQ W KH \HDU  W RJHW KHU ZLW K W KH HVW DEOLVKP HQW  RI W KH P RQDVW HU\
(W W DX LQ W KH 2EHU DP P HU JDX  , Q W KLV XQLTXH FDVH Z H KDY H D KLVW RU \  RI W KH
IRXQGLQJ IURP  W KH \HDU  ZKLFK QR GRXEW  LV D W UXH LP SHULDO GRFXP HQW  W KDW
KDV EHHQ IRXQG LQ W KH %DYDULDQ DUFKLYHV RI 6W DW H GDW HG $XJXVW     7KLV
P HDQV W KDW  ZH KDYH P RUH NQRZOHGJH RI W KH IRXQGLQJ EXLOGLQJ DQG LQVW LW XW LRQV
RIW KLVRUGHURIFKLYDOU\W KDQDERXW P DQ\RW KHURUGHUV:KDW LVREYLRXVLP P HGLDW HO\
LV W KH UXOH W KDW  W KH NQLJKW V VKRXOG OLYH LQ (W W DO W RJHW KHU ZLW K W KHLU ZRP HQ  :H
KDYH W KH KDELW  RI VHHLQJ W KH RUGHUV RI FKLYDOU\ DV P RQDVW LF LQVW LW XW LRQV ZKHUH
FHOLEDF\ZDVW KHUXOH1RZZHNQRZKRZHYHUW KDW W KHVHYRZVFRXQW HGRQO\DV
ORQJ DV RQH ZDV P HP EHU  RI W KH RU GHU  LW VHOI  0DQ\  HQW HU HG W KH RU GHU  DIW HU
W HUP LQDW LRQ RI W KH P DUULDJH DIW HU W KH GHDW K RI W KH ZLIH RW KHUV OHIW  W KH RUGHU
XVXDOO\ D VRFLHW \ RI W ZHOYH ZKHQ W KH\ LQW HQGHG W R P DUU\  0HP EHUVKLS RI W KH
RUGHU ZDV QR OLIH ORQJ GDP QDW LRQ W R FHOLEDF\ DQ LQVW LW XW LRQ W KDW  LV DJDLQVW  DQ\
KXP DQ DQG GLYLQH ODZ

, Q RXU GD\V P RQDVW LFLVP  EHFDP H W RW DOO\ VW HULOH LH LW V HIIHFW  GHSRSXODW HV DQG
KDV QHJDW LY H LQIOXHQFH RQ W KH U DFH  7KLV LV VR EHFDXVH RIW HQ W KH EHVW  DU H
GHW HUP LQHGW RJRW RW KHP RQDVW HU\DOUHDG\LQW KHLU\RXW KDQGP DQ\RW KHUVFORVH
W KHP VHOY HV RII DIW HU  P DQ\  GLVDSSRLQW P HQW V LQ OLIH   , Q ROG W LP HV OLIH LQ W KH
P RQDVW HU\ ZDV RIW HQ W KH FRQFOXVLRQ RI D ULFK DQG DFW LYH OLIH EHVLGHV W KH IDFW
W KDW  W KH P RQDVW HU LHV KDG P DQ\ VRFLDO DQG HGXFDW LRQDO W DVNV VW LOO LQ W KH ODW H
P LGGOH DJHV  1RZDGD\V W KH P RQDVW HULHV DUH W KH W RP EV RI DUW LILFLDOO\ NLOOHG OLIH
7KHP RQDVW HULHVFRXOGIXOILOOLP SRUW DQW W DVNVDJDLQLIW KH\EHFDP HDJDLQDSODFH
RIUHFRYHU\DQGTXLHW SDVVLQJIRUSHUVRQVRIDOOFODVVHVZKRJRW VW UXFNDQGZRUQ
RXW  E\ OLIH IRU W KH ROG SHRSOH IRU W KH VLFN DQG IRU W KRVH ZKR DUH W LUHG
 

7KH KHDOW K\ KXP DQ EHLQJ KDV W KUHH JRDOV LQ OLIH ZKHQ JRLQJ KLV QRUP DO SDW K
GXULQJW KHZRUNRIW KHGD\DVORQJDVKHGRHVQRW ZDQW UHGHP SW LRQIURP W KHW LHV
RI W KLV ZRUOG  QDP HO\ ULJKW HRXVQHVV DFTXLVLW LRQ DQG HQM R\P HQW 

7KH HUURU RI DOO W KHRVRSK\ LQ UHODW LRQ W R W KH DQFLHQW  , QGLDQ ZLVGRP  RI W KH 9HGDV
LV W KDW  W KH\ VXSSRVHGO\ W HDFK W R DYRLG D SULRUL W KH ³ GHFHSW LRQV´  W KDW  VXUURXQG
XV7KLVLVQRW W UXH $FFRUGLQJW RW KHZRUGV, QGR $U\DQZLVHP HQSURYLGHGZH
XQGHUVW DQG W KHP  FRUUHFW O\ ZH KDYH UHFHLYHG RXU \RXW K EHDXW \ IRUFH DQG RXU
ZLOO IRU RXU SDW K RQ (DUW K LQ RUGHU W R H[SHULHQFH W KHVH IHDW XUHV  , W  LV LP SRUW DQW
W KDW  ZH GR QRW  VW XP EOH EHIRUH UHDFKLQJ W KH JRDO W KDW  DV DQ XOW LP DW H ZLVGRP  LV
LQ RXU YLHZ

5LJKW HRXVQHVV DFFRUGLQJ W R P DQ\ LV D VHHP LQJ VW ULYLQJ ZLW KRXW  VXFFHVV LI ZH
FRQVLGHU ZKDW ¶V KDSSHQLQJ RQ (DUW K  %XW    GRQ¶W  ZH W KURZ W KH VHHGV LQW R W KH
ZLQG LH W KURZ D VHFXUH SRVVHVVLRQ DZD\ LQ RUGHU W R JHW  W KH IXW XUH JUDLQ"

7KH H[LVW HQFH RI KXP DQ VRFLHW \ LQ LW V VHFXUH VW DW XV DQG JHQHUDO ZHOIDUH FDQ EH
VHFXU HG Z KHQ KXP DQV DU U DQJH W KHP VHOY HV Z LW KLQ VRFLHW \  DFFRU GLQJ W R W KHLU
FDSDELOLW LHVDQGNQRZOHGJHLIW KH\NHHSP RUDOVLQKLJKUHJDUG DVW KHZLVGRP RI
DOO SHRSOHV DQG RI DOO W LP HV LV W HDFKLQJ  2QO\ W KLV ZD\ FDQ ZH SXW  XS D EDUULHU
DJDLQVW  DOO DUELW UDULQHVV DQG LP P RUDOLW \ RI DOO W KRVH ZKR KDYH QHLW KHU LQW HOOHFW
QRU*RGDQGW KLVZD\ZHFDQDYRLGW KDW W KHDQLP DOZLW KLQW KHKXP DQEHLQJW HDUV
GRZQ FHUW DLQ JDW HV RI JHQHUDO ZHOIDUH  :KR NQRZV W KH DFW LYLW LHV RI W KH ZRUOG
DQG GRHV QRW  VHW  KLV VW ULYLQJ W RZDUGV ULJKW HRXVQHVV DQG FRUUHFW QHVV LQ DFW LRQ
FRP P LW V D ELJ IROO\  DQG GDP DJHV KLP VHOI  %XW  Z H VKRXOG QRW  M XVW  H[HU FLVH
ULJKW HRXVQHVV ZKLFK LV XS W R XV EXW  ZH VKRXOG DOVR QRW  W ROHUDW H DQ\ LQM XVW LFH
QR P DW W HU ZKHUH LW  FRP HV IURP   )URP  W KLV ZH FDQ FRQFOXGH ZLW K FHUW DLQW \ W KDW
W KH JRRG ROG UHTXHVW  IRU ULJKW HRXVQHVV LV QRW  ZLW KRXW  P HULW  DQG W KDW  DOO W KRVH
DUHGRLQJZHOOZKRDFFRUGLQJW RW KHLUFKDUDFW HUDQGEHLQJKDYHW KHLQFOLQDW LRQW R
GR VR

:KHQ ZH W DON DERXW  DFTXLVLW LRQ ZH P HDQ W KH DFTXLVLW LRQ RI NQRZ OHGJH ODQG
KRXVH P RQH\ DQLP DOV IULHQGV DQG W KH LQFUHDVH RI W KHVH DFTXLVLW LRQV  :LW K
W KLV W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ DFTXLUHV ZHDOW K DQG SRZHU  , GOH DQG LQGLIIHUHQW  SHRSOH
P RVW RIW KHW LP HDOVRVXFKSHUVRQVZKRDUHGHUDQJHGLQW KHLUUDFLDOGULYHVGHQ\
W KH QHFHVVLW \ RI DFTXLVLW LRQ DQG EHOLHYH W KDW  OXFN LV RQ W KH VLGH RI W KH SHUVRQ
ZKR GRHVQRW GHVHUYHV LW  RUHYHQ W KH SHUVRQZKRLV QRW  VHHNLQJ LW   7KH\ FODLP
W KDW  FRLQFLGHQFH EULQJV ZHDOW K DQG SRYHUW \ YLFW RU\ DQG GHIHDW  JRRG DQG EDG
OXFNW RKXP DQV:HKDYHW RUHVSRQGW KDW W KHDSSDUHQW FRLQFLGHQFHFDQZHOOEH
DP HULW &RLQFLGHQFHLVIDYRURIGHVW LQ\EXW GHVW LQ\LVP RVW O\LQRXUKDQGVDQG
ZKRXQGHUVW DQGVKRZW RXVHGHVW LQ\W RKLP LW LVDP HDQVW RDFTXLVLW LRQOLNHDQ\
RW KHU  P HDQV   &DSDELOLW \  RSSRU W XQLW \  DQG LP SOHP HQW DW LRQ DU H  OLN H GHVW LQ\
P HDQV W R LW  SHUKDSV HYHQ 8U SDUW V RI GHVW LQ\  (YHU\ SHUVRQ LV W KH VP LW K RI KLV
OXFNDQGDQLGOHSHUVRQNQRZVQRW UXHOXFN7KLVSHUKDSVLVRQHRIW KHGHHSHVW
VD\LQJV RI ZLVGRP  W KHUH H[LVW V  :H VKRXOG QHYHU IRUJHW  W KDW  HYHU\W KLQJ W KDW
KDSSHQVRQ(DUW KLVP RVW O\RXUDFW LYLW \DQGRQW KHRW KHUKDQGW KHZRUNRI*RG
EHFDXVH*RGGRHVQRW ZDQW RW KHUZLVHW KDQZKDW ULJKW HRXVKXP DQVZDQW 7KHUHIRUH
 

*RGKHOSVW KHSHUVRQZKRKHOSVKLP VHOI:HKDYHRIW KH'LYLQH LQW KHZRUOGDQ

HTXDO SDUW  DV ZKDW  ZH KDYH RI W KH KXP DQ DQG ZH ZRXOG EH FDSDEOH RI VKDSLQJ
W KHZRUOGDFFRUGLQJW RRXULP DJHLQD'LYLQHP DQQHUEXW W KHP DM RULW \RIKXP DQV
QRQ 'LYLQH KRVW LOH W R *RG

:HH[SHULHQFHHQM R\P HQW ZLW KRXUVHQVHV YLVLRQKHDULQJW DFW LOHVHQVHW DVW H

DQG VP HOO   , Q RXU  VRXO W KH IHHOLQJV RI HQM R\ P HQW  DQG QRQ HQM R\ P HQW  DU H
DFFXP XODW LQJ RI M R\ DQG SDLQ RI KDW H DQG ORYH RI ZDQW LQJ DQG GHQ\LQJ  'R
GHVLUHDQGZLVKLQJKDUP XV", QP DQ\FDVHVW KH\GR EXW QHYHUW KHOHVVHQM R\P HQW
LV QRW  QHFHVVDULO\ GHVSLFDEOH RU VLQIXO  :H DUH ERUQ W R HQM R\ W KLQJV W KDW  W KH
ZRUOG RIIHUV EXW  RQO\ DV P XFK DV P DNHV VHQVH DQG LI LW  GRHV QRW  KLQGHU W KH
VW ULYLQJIRUULJKW HRXVQHVVDQGDFTXLVLW LRQ:KDW HYHUZDVVHW DJDLQVW HQM R\P HQW
E\ SRZHUIXO FOHULFV DQG VHFXODU UXOHUV LV HUURU M HDORXV\ DQG IUDXG LV XQJRGO\
VHUYLW XGHRIVRXOVDQGERGLHV:HKDYHEHHQERUQIRUHQM R\P HQW DVP XFKDVZH
KDYH EHHQ ERUQ IRU VXIIHULQJ  7KH LQW HUDFW LRQ RI HQM R\P HQW  DQGSDLQ DOORZVRXU
VRXOV W R JURZ DQG LW  P DNHV W KHP  JUHDW  RU SLW LIXO GHSHQGLQJ RQ RXU IUHHGRP  RU
VHUIGRP  LQ IDFH RI W KHVH W KLQJV

5LJKW HRXVQHVV DFTXLVLW LRQ DQG HQM R\P HQW  DUH W KH W KUHH JRDOV RI OLIH

7KH DUW  RI OLYLQJ LV W R VW ULYH IRU W KHVH JRDOV HTXDOO\ DQG W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ QHHGV
W RXVHKLVJRRGLQW HOOHFW DQGKLV'LYLQHZLOOIRUW KLVSXUSRVH 7KHKXP DQVKRXOG
DVVLJQ KLV W LP H DFFRU GLQJ W R W KH W U LSOLFLW \  RI KLV JRDOV LQ OLIH DQG KH VKRXOG
DW W HP SW W RFRQQHFW W KHP W RHDFKRW KHUW RDFKLHYHW KHLUFRQJUXHQFHVRW KDW W KH\
DUH QRW  RSSRVLQJ HDFK RW KHU  :H DUH GRLQJ EHVW  LI ZH P HHW  RXU  REOLJDW LRQV DW
W KHVDP HW LP H W KHUHIRUHZHVKRXOGH[HUFLVHULJKW HRXVQHVVDOUHDG\LQ\RXW KDQG
ZKHQJURZQXSW RIROORZW KHREOLJDW LRQVRIULJKW HRXVQHVVDQGDFTXLVLW LRQEHVLGHV
HQM R\P HQW  DQG DOVR ORYH  2W KHUZLVH LW  P D\ KDSSHQ W KDW  ZKHQ ZH DUH ROG ZH
ZRXOGQRW KDYHDFKLHYHGW KHVHW KUHHJRDOVLQOLIH2QO\W KHSHUVRQZKRFDUHVIRU
ULJKW HRXVQHVV DFTXLVLW LRQ DQG HQM R\P HQW  DFKLHYHV W KH KDSSLQHVV W KDW  HVFDSHV
P RVW  SHRSOH  $Q XQM XVW  SHUVRQ HYHQ LI KH KDG DFTXLUHG JRRG W KLQJV DQG ORYHG
D ORW  DQ LGOH SHUVRQ HYHQ LI KH KDG EHHQ ULJKW HRXV DQG ORYLQJ DQG D SHUVRQ
ZLW KRXW  ORYH HYHQ LI KH KDG DFTXLUHG P XFK DQG KDG EHHQ ULJKW HRXV W KH\ DOO
ZRXOGKDYHOLYHGDQXQ JRGO\ZD\EHFDXVHDFW LQJLP SHUIHFW O\W KH\ZRXOGKDYH
LJQRUHG RQH LP SRUW DQW  JRDO LQ OLIH

1RZ W KHUH LV IRU D IHZ D IRXUW K JRDO LQ OLIH  7R W KHVH IHZ EHORQJ W KHVH ZKR
ZKHQROGFDQVD\W KDW W KH\KDYHUHDFKHGW KHW KUHHJRDOVLQOLIH7KHVHDUHW KH
KDSS\RQHVZKRKDYHVXIIHUHGW KLVZRUOGDQGZKRKDYHHQM R\HGLW OLNHZLVHDQG
DOO W KH\ KDYH W R GR QRZ LV W R LP P HUVH W KHP VHOYHV LQW R W KH P HDQLQJ RI OLIH RI
H[LVW HQFH DQG RI W KH Z RU OG  7KH\ Z LOO GLU HFW  W KHLU  W KRXJKW V XSRQ W KH 'LYLQH
ZLW KRXW  DQ\ FRQVLGHUDW LRQ RI SXUSRVH  $ IHZ RI W KHP  ZLOO DFKLHYH W KH VW DW H RI
P HGLW DW LRQ LQ ZKLFK W KH SHUIHFW HG EHLQJ FDQ VD\ RI KLP VHOI ZLW KRXW  EODVSKHP \
ZKHUH ZRXOG *RG EH LI KH ZDV QRW  ZLW KLQ P \VHOI

7KLV ZDV W KH SHUIHFW HG RQH ZKR M RLQHG W KH RUGHU
 

7KH QXP EHU RI W KH NQLJKW V LQ (W W DO ZDV OLP LW HG W R W ZHOYH ZKR ZHUH XQGHU D
W KLUW HHQW K RQH ZKR ZDV W KH P DVW HU RI W KH RUGHU DQG D P LVW UHVV RI W KH RUGHU IRU
W KHW ZHOYHVSRXVHVRIW KHNQLJKW VDSSDUHQW O\XQGHUW KHVDP HUXOHVRIW KHRUGHU
'XULQJW KRVHW LP HVW KHUHZDVQRW KLQJXQXVXDOW RVXFKDQDUUDQJHP HQW EHFDXVH
W KHUHLVQRLQGLFDW LRQDERXW W KDW 7RW KHFRQW UDU\DOOW KDW VHHP HGTXLW HQRUP DO
+RZ VHOI HYLGHQW  W KH IRXQGLQJ RI W KH NQLJKW O\ RUGHU LQ (W W DO ZDV YLHZHG FDQ EH
VHHQ LQ W KH IDFW  W KDW  HFFOHVLDVW LF RSSRQHQW V RI /XGZLJ ZHUH QRW  ERW KHUHG E\
W K DW 

+HUH LW  LV W KH ROG URXQG W DEOH RI .LQJ $UW KXU W KDW  ZDV UHYLYHG KHUH ZLW K JRDOV RI
EUHHGLQJ  7KLV LQW HQW LRQ RI (P SHURU /XGZLJ LV DQ H[FHOOHQW  UHIHUHQFH IRU KLP 
+LV SURJHQ\ KRZHYHU KDG QR XQGHUVW DQGLQJ IRU W KH IDU UHDFKLQJ LQFOLQDW LRQ RI
W KH %DYDULDQ RQ W KH LP SHULDO W KURQH DQG W KH\ FRQILVFDW HG W KH ILQDQFHV RI W KH
P RQDVW HU\ DIW HU /XGZLJ¶V GHDW K  $V D FRQVHTXHQFH W KH RUGHU GLVVROYHG DJDLQ
SHUKDSV XQGHU VOLJKW  SUHVVXUH RI W KH FKXUFK ZKLFK GLG QRW  VXSSRUW  VXFK W KLQJV
EHQHY ROHQW O\

7KHSURW RW \SHRIW KHUXOHVRIW KHRUGHUIRUW KHNQLJKW VRI(W W DOZHUHSRVVLEO\W KH

E\ODZVRIW KH.QLJKW V7HP SODURUW KH*HUP DQ2UGHURI.QLJKW VZKLFKKDGEHVLGHV
W KH DFW XDO NQLJKW V RI W KH RUGHU QXP HURXV EURW KHU  DQG VLVW HUKRRGV ZKR ZHUH
OLYLQJ LQ P DUULDJH IURP  ZKLFK W KH RUGHU FRXOG GUDZ QHZ P HP EHUV FRQW LQXRXVO\
7KHVH JURXSV RIW HQ OLYHG QH[W  W R W KH VHDW V RI W KH RUGHUV DQG KHOSHG W KHP  LQ
P DQ\ZD\V

7KHIDFW RIP DUULHGEURW KHUVRIW KHRUGHUZDVQRW DVVHOGRP DVJHQHUDOO\DVVXP HG

:H N QRZ  RI 6SDQLVK N QLJKW O\  RU GHU V W R W KH FRQW UDU \  RI W KH -RKDQQLW HV DQG
*HUP DQ.QLJKW VW KDW W KH\ZHUHDOORZHGW RP DUU\³ SXUHYLUJLQV´$SSDUHQW O\W KH
³ YRZRIFHOLEDF\´ ZDVLQW HUSUHW HGLQUDFH K\JLHQLFDQGUDFH HW KLFDOZD\V, QGHHG
W KH6SDQLVKNQLJKW O\RUGHUVDW W KHW LP HRIW KHIRXQGLQJRIW KHP RQDVW HU\RI(W W DO
LQ  FRQVLVW HG LQ W KH P DLQ RI RIIVSULQJ RI W KH 9LVLJRW KV LQ 6SDLQ ZKR IRU
FHQW XULHVP DGHW KHDW W HP SW W RVHSDUDW HW KHP VHOYHVIURP W KH0RRULVK-HZVDQG
QDW LYH , EHULDQV   2EYLRXVO\ ZH NQRZ IDU W RR OLW W OH DERXW  W KH P HDQLQJ RI HDUO\

 2PLWWHG
 

P HGLHY DO P RQDVW LF RU GHU V  Z KLFK KDG DOVR VRLO U HIRU P  LQ P LQG VX FK DV W KH
=LVW HU ]LHQVHU V   DQG LQ RXU  GD\ V Z H P D\  W DON  RI W KHP  DV FRU SRU DW LRQV Z KR
IROORZHU D SROLW LFV RI VHW W OHP HQW V EHVLGHV W KHLU UHOLJLRXV DQG VFLHQW LILF DFW LYLW LHV
7KHUHIRUH ZH VKRXOG QRW  EH VXUSULVHG ZKHQ ZH ILQG W KDW  VXFK NQLJKW O\ RUGHUV
ZKLFK DOZD\V KDG W KHLU HP SKDVLV RQ EUHHGLQJ DQG VHOHFW LRQ DV Z H NQRZ IURP
VW ULFW W HVW LQJRIDQFHVW U\W KDW P DNHVRQO\VHQVHZKHQVXFKEUHHGLQJDQGVHOHFW LRQ
ZHUHSUDFW LFHGZHUHDOVRLQYROYHGLQSUDFW LFDOVHW W OHP HQW DFW LYLW \7KH\GLGW KDW
E\IRXQGLQJRUGHUVW KHNQLJKW VRIZKLFKVKRXOGSURFUHDW HSXUHFKLOGUHQZLW KSXUH
YLUJLQV7KHUHIRUHW KHUXOHVRIW KHRUGHULQ(W W DOVKRXOGEHFRQVLGHUHGDVVRP HW KLQJ
TXLW H LP SRUW DQW   7KH SUDFW LFH ZDV W R IRXQG VHW W OHP HQW V LQ UHP RW H DUHDV DQG
FUHDW HDW W KHVDP HW LP HW KHEDVLVIRUDSRSXODW LRQZKLFKVKRXOGOLYHLQW KHDUHD
DQ G I DU P  LW     $W  W K DW  W LP H I DU  VLJK W HG SROLW LFV Z DV SU DFW LFHG   1RZ DGD\ V
VHW W OHP HQW V DUH HQW HUSULVHV W R UHOLHYH FLW LHV RI D SRSXODW LRQ W KDW  KDV JURZQ W RR
P XFK ZKLOH EDFN W KHQ W KH FRXQW U\VLGH ZDV QRW  VHW W OHG DV P XFK DQG W KHUH ZDV
D ODFN RI SHRSOH

7KH DW W HP SW  RI W KH (P SHURU /XGZLJ W KH %DYDULDQ W R IRXQG D NQLJKW O\ RUGHU ZLW K
W KH JRDO RI KXP DQ EUHHGLQJ DQG KXP DQ VHW W OLQJ LQ D UHP RW H EXW  QHYHUW KHOHVV
SROLW LFDOO\LP SRUW DQW DUHD  SURYHVKLVRXW VW DQGLQJLP SRUW DQFH7KLVLP SRUW DQFH
KRZHYHUZDVQRORQJHUKRQRUHGE\KLVIROORZHUV 7KHIRXQGLQJRIW KLVNQLJKW O\
RUGHU W KDW  GLG QRW  IRUELG P DUULDJH W R KLV P HP EHUV EXW  TXLW H W R W KH FRQW UDU\
GHP DQGHG LW  LV W KHU HIRU H QRW  M XVW  SXU H Z KLP   7KH IDFW  W KDW  W KH GRFXP HQW
P HQW LRQHG W KH FLUFXP VW DQFH RI P DUULHG NQLJKW V UDW KHU P DW W HU RI IDFW O\ VKRZV
W KDW  VXFK W KLQJV ZHUH VHOI HYLGHQW  LQ W KRVH W LP HV  7KH W LP H RI IRXQGLQJ IDOOV LQ
W KH EORRP  RI W KH RUGHU DIW HU W KH GHFOLQH RI W KH .QLJKW V 7HP SODU  7KH .QLJKW V
7HP SODUZHUHP DUULHGP RVW RIW KHW LP HDQGW KH\KDGVHFUHW DQGSXEOLFP HP EHUV
DOORYHUZKRZHUHRXW VLGHRIW KHVW ULFW UXOHVRIW KHRUGHU, QJHQHUDOZHP D\QRW
Y LHZ  W KH N QLJKW O\  RU GHU V DV LVRODW HG FRQVW U XFW V EXW  DV W RS RU JDQL]DW LRQV RI
VW UDW DRIW KHVRFLHW \LQRXUFDVHRIW KHDULVW RFUDF\ZKLFKFRQILUP HGLW VLQIOXHQFH
RQW KHVW DW HDQGFKXUFKLQW KHP DLQZLW KW KRVHRUGHUV7KHRUGHURIW KH.QLJKW V
7HP SODU ZDV GLVVROYHG RQ 0DUFK   P RVW O\ E\ IRUFH LQ )UDQFH ZKHUH
 .QLJKW V 7HP SODU SDLG W KHLU KLJKHU NQRZOHGJH DQG VW ULYLQJ IRU *RG DQG
UDFHZLW KW KHLUOLYHV, Q6SDLQDQG*HUP DQ\W KHP HP EHUVRIW KH.QLJKW V7HP SODU
HQW HUHGW KHIROORZ XSRUGHUVRUW KH\M RLQHGH[LVW LQJRUGHUVW KDW ZHUHNLQW RW KHLU
LGHDOV  &ORVHO\ UHODW HG ZHUH W KH =LVW HUW ]LHQVHUV DQG W KH *HUP DQ RUGHU ERW K RI
ZKLFKKDGDOVRDJULFXOW XUHDQGVHW W OHP HQW VIRUIDUP HUVLQW KHLU UXOHV7KHUHIRUH
ZH KDYH W R VHH LQ W KH IRXQGLQJ RI (W W DO DQ HQW HUSULVH W KDW  ZDV ILW W LQJ LW V W LP H
7RR EDG LW  ZHQW  GRZQ DIW HU W KH GHDW K RI LW V IRXQGHU  (W W DO KDV UHP DLQHG DQ

$&DW KROLF0RQNV2UGHU

 2PLWWHG

 7KH DUHD ZDV FHUW DLQO\ SROLW LFDOO\ LP SRUW DQW    , W  Z DV RQH RI W KH P DLQ URXW HV W KDW  W KH *HUP DQ
NLQJV DQG 5RP DQ HP SHURUV W KH RIILFLDO W LW OH RI W KRVH UXOHUV  Z KHQ W KH\ LQYDGHG , W DO\  7KHVH
LQYDVLRQVZHUHDUHJXODUYHQW XUHW KDW HQGHGP RVW RIW KHW LP HZLW KDFRURQDW LRQW R5RP DQHP SHURU
E\W KHSRSHLQ5RP H7KHUHDUHP DQ\YHU\ROGFLW LHVDORQJW KLVURXW HZKLFKDOUHDG\W KH5RP DQV
KDYHXVHG
 2PLWWHG

 

RUGLQDU\ P RQDVW HU\ IRU P RQNV W R W KLV GD\  3RVVLEO\ W KH QDP H (W W DO JLYHV D KLQW
DERXW  W KH NQLJKW O\ RUGHU ,  GR QRW  NQRZ W KH GHULYDW LRQ RI W KH Z RUG   QRU LW V
QDP H EXW  LQ W KH ( RI (W W DO FRXOG EH W KH ³ (KH´  LV P DUULDJH DQG ³ 7DO´  IRU YDOOH\
YDOOH\ RI P DUULDJH  (+(7$/ (W W DO LQ QHZHU *HUP DQ  ³ (K´  RU ³ (KH´  ZDV LQ
P HGLHYDO W LP HV QRW  RQO\ W KH W HUP  IRU P DUULDJH EHW ZHHQ P DQ DQG Z RP DQ EXW
EH\RQG W KDW  LW  KDG DOVR D P HDQLQJ W KDW  UHODW HG W R ODZ LH W KH ODZ RI P DUULDJH
W KDW  LV YDOLG E\ P HDQV RI P DUULDJH DQG P RUDOLW \ EUHHGLQJ  W KH QDW XUH 8U ODZ

7KDW RXUFRQFOXVLRQVKDYHW KHLUKLVW RULFEDFNJURXQGLQW KHW UHQGVRIW KHW LP HFDQ

DOVR W KH GRXEW IXO H[SHULHQFH LI KH UHDOL]HV W KDW  KHUH LQIOXHQFHV RI W KH OHJHQG RI
W KH+RO\*UDLODOHJHQGW KDW SXW VDQFLHQW URRW VLQW RW KH*HUP DQVRLORIOHJHQGV
SOD\HG W KHLU SDUW   :H FDQ VHH P RUH FOHDUO\ P RUH DERXW  W KH EDFNJURXQG RI W KH
IRXQGLQJRIW KHRUGHURI(W W DOLIZHDVN:ROIUDP YRQ(VFKHQEDFKZKRP DGHW KH
OHJHQG RI W KH *UDLO W R W KH P DLQ W KHP H RI KLV JUHDW  HSRV ³ 3DU]LYDO´    7KHUH W KH
SRHW  JLYHV XV D SLFW XUH RI W KH RUGHU RI W KH .QLJKW V7HP SODU DQG LW V DFW LYLW LHV
IURP ZKLFKZHFDQFOHDUO\UHDGW KHVHW W OLQJDQGEUHHGLQJLQW HQW 7KHSDVVDJHLV
DV IROORZ V

7KH KLJK QDW XUH RI W KH *UDLO GHP DQGHG

7KDW  ZKR W DNHV FDUH RI LW  LQ GLJQLILHG P DQQHU
6KH VKRXOG EH RI FKDVW H KHDUW 
)UHH RI DOO IDOVHKRRG DQG SXUH

$QG W KHQ IXUW KHU

<RX VKRXOG UHQHZ W KH FXVW RP 

(P XODW LQJ KLV W LHV IRU OLIH
/RYH \RXU ZLIH IURP  W KH ERW W RP  RI \RXU KHDUW 

7KLV UK\P H FDQ RQO\ EH XQGHUVW RRG ZKHQ ³ \RXU ZLIH´  P HDQV W KH ZRP DQ RI W KH
VDP HNLQGRINQLJKW O\RUKLJKH[W UDFW LRQ7KLVEHFRP HVFOHDUHULQW KHIROORZLQJ
OLQHV

)ROORZLQJ W KH ZLOO RI *RG

7KH VW RQH VKRXOG EH FDUHG IRU E\ D SXUH YLUJLQ
:KLFK OLYH LQ VHUYLFH RI W KH *UDLO
+H VKRXOG RQO\ FKRRVH KLJK FKRLFH
$OVR NQLJKW V VKRXOG FRP EDW  IRU LW 
:KR FRQVHFUDW HG W KHLU OLIH W R VW ULFW  FKDVW LW \
$QG VRRQ W KH FURZQ UHFHLYHV EHQHILW
$QG VRRQ W KH\ JLYH LW  DZD\ DJDLQ
7KH\ IHW FK FKLOGUHQ ZHOO VHOHFW HG

, GRNQRZKRZHYHUEHFDXVH, DP IURP W KDW JHQHUDODUHD7KH³ (´ LVIRU³ HEHQ´RUIODW DYHU\
FRP P RQ SUHIL[ LQ P DQ\ QDP HV IRU ORFDW LRQV DQG W RZQV LQ W KLV DUHD RI 6RXW KHUQ *HUP DQ\ DQG
$XVW ULD  2I FRXUVH W KH DULVW RFUDW LF EDVW DUGV VHOHFW HG W KH IODW  ERW W RP  RI D YDOOH\ ZLW K VXIILFLHQW
ODQGDQGW \SLFDOO\VXIILFLHQW IRON W KHLUVODYHODERU DOUHDG\OLYLQJW KHUH

7KHRULJLQRIW KLVOHJHQGZDV)UHQFKQRW *HUP DQ7KHQDP HVRIW KHKHURHVZHUH5RP DQ]R ROG
)UHQFK *RUVOHEHQFRQYHQLHQW O\LJQRUHVW KLVFUXFLDOIDFW 
 

2I QREOH NLQG DQG EHDXW LIXO

, I D ODQG EHFRP HV ZLW KRXW  ORUG
:KLFK W UXVW LQJ W KH KDQG RI *RG
'HVLUHV D P DQ DV ORUG
7KLV FURZG W RR W KLV VKRXOG EH JLYHQ
7KH\ VKRXOG W DNH FDUH RI KLP  W KDQNIXOO\
%HFDXVH W KH EOHVVLQJ RI *RG SURW HFW V KLP 
7KH YLUJLQ LV JLYHQ DZD\ RSHQO\
%XW  KHU RIIVSULQJ P XVW  UHW XUQ
7R LQFUHDVH W KH FURZG RI W KH *UDLO LQ VHUYLFH
7KRVH KRZHYHU ZKR FDUU\ VXFK ZHDSRQV
7KH\ P XVW  UHQRXQFH W KH ORYH RI ZRP HQ
/LYH LQ SXUH P DUULDJH
$QG W KRVH VHQW  E\ *RG
$V UXOHUV LQW R D FRXQW U\ ZLW KRXW  ORUG

7KH *UDLO LV W KH V\P ERO RI SXUH ORYH LQ VHFUHW  DV ZHOO DV RSHQO\  $OO W KLQJV LQ
KHDYHQ KDYH W KHLU FRUUHODW HV RQ (DUW K  7KLV ZDV W KH *UDLO ZDV XQGHUVW RRG DV
KHDYHQO\ DQG HDUW KO\ SXUH ORYH  $P IRUW DV DJDLQVW  W KH FRP P DQGP HQW  RI SXUH
UDFLDOORYHKDGLQW HUFRXUVHZLW KW KHDQLP DO KXP DQ.XQGU\7KU RXJKLP SXUHORYH
KXP DQNLQGUHFHLYHGVLQDQGGHDW K%RW KSDUDEOHVDUHYDOLGKHUHW KHSDUDEOHRI
KHDYHQO\ ORYH  DQG W KH SDUDEOH RI SXUH ZRUOGO\ ORYH W KH ORYH W R ³ \RXU ZLIH´
³ 6DP H ZLW K VDP H FUHDW HV P RUH
8QHTXDO ZLW K 8QHTXDO FUHDW HV GHVW UXFW LRQ´

, Q W KH (GGD DV ZHOO DV LQ W KH 2OG 7HVW DP HQW  W KHUH LV W KH KRSH IRU W KH UHGHHP HU
ZKRZLOOFRP H$W HDFKLQJW KDW LVFRP P RQW RW KH*RW KVW KH*RRGRQHVDQGW KH
-HZV+HLVW KHJUHDW UHGHHP HUZKRVXUSDVVHVDOOIRUP HUUHGHHP HUVDIDFW W KDW
LV HYLGHQW  LQ DOO KRSHV RI KXP DQLW \  7KLV UHGHHP HU VKRXOG UHGHHP  VSLULW XDOO\
DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH KRSH RI W KH JRRG RQHV DQG DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH -HZV KH VKRXOG
UHGHHP KXP DQLW \SK\VLFDOO\ $P L[W XUHRIW KLVW HDFKLQJUHP DLQHGLQW KH&KULVW LDQ
GRJP D

3K\VLFDO VDFULILFH LV QRW  VXIILFLHQW  LW  LV D XVHOHVV DQG ZURQJ GHHG  :H DOO KDYH
OHDUQHG W R VDFULILFH RXUVHOYHV SK\VLFDOO\ ZH GLG ³ SUDFW LFH´  W KLV W KURXJKRXW  W KH
FHQW XULHV DOO GRZQ W R W KH P RVW  XQLP SRUW DQW  RQH  QDP HO\ W R VDFU LILFH RXUVHOYHV
ZLW KRXW  RSSRVLW LRQ IRU DQ ³ LGHD´ QR P DW W HU ZKLFK RQH EHFDXVH W KDW  GHW DLO LV
LUUHOHYDQW DVIDUDVW KHYDOXHRIW KHVDFULILFHLVFRQFHUQHG7KHODVW H[DP SOHZDV
KXP DQLW \W KDW VDFULILFHGLW VHOILQW KHSDVW ZDU :: :KRHYHUGHFLGHG³ QRW W R
SDUW LFLSDW H´  H[SHOOHG KLP VHOI IURP  W KH NLQJGRP  RI KXP DQLW \  :KRHYHU GHFLGHG
QRW W RSDUW LFLSDW HLQW KLVZDUZKLFKXOW LP DW HO\ZDVDQHFRQRP LFZDUDQGRIZKLFK
QRERG\NQHZZKDW LW VUHDOUHDVRQVKDYHEHHQZDVZHLJKHGDQGZDVIRXQGW REH
W RR OLJKW   7KH IHZ ZKR UHFRJQL]HG W KH P HDQLQJ RI W KLV ZDU W KDW  LW  ZDV QRW
P HDQLQJOHVV EXW  D W KRURXJK W HVW  ZHUH W KHUHIRUH FRQYLQFHG W KDW  W KH\ FRXOG QRW
³ EDLORXW ´7KH\FRXOGQRW DQW LFLSDW HLIW KH\ZHUH³ QHHGHG´ DIW HUW KHZDUIRUW KH
W LP H DIW HUZDUGV   1RERG\ VKRXOG EHOLHYH W KDW  D SHUVRQ JHW V NLOOHG LQ ZDU E\
FRLQFLGHQFH  :KR GLG QRW  KDYH W KH FRXUDJH W R DW  OHDVW  RIIHU W KH VDFULILFH DW
 

OHDVW  W R SDUW LFLSDW H TXLHW O\ DQG DFFHSW LQJO\ EXW  ³ EDLOHG RXW ´  RI ZKR ZURW H SLW LIXO
OHW W HUV W R W KRVH LQ SRZHU KLJKHU XS EHJJLQJ W KDW  W KH\ ³ NHHS KLP  IRU W KH ZRUOG
DQG IRU KXP DQLW \´  ZDV DOUHDG\ P DUNHG DV VRP HRQH VXSHUIOXRXV  $OO ZKR ZHUH
QHHGHG ZKR ZHUH IRU W KH FKDQJH LQ QHHG W KH\ XQGHUZHQW  W KH W HVW  DQG W KH\
SDVVHGW KHW HVW :KRHYHUZDVDFFHSW HGDVDVDFULILFHKHKDGW KHFHUW DLQW \W KDW
KLV W HP SRUDO P LVVLRQ ZDV DOUHDG\ IXOILOOHG IRU W KLV W LP H  )DW H NHHSV D W KULIW \
EXGJHW  DQG GRHV QRW  DOORZ W KDW  LW V DSSOLFDQW V ZDLW  IRU W KDW  ZKLFK LV DVVLJQHG W R
W KHP 7KHUHLVDGLIIHUHQFHZKHW KHUZHH[SHFW W KHUHW XUQRIW KHVW URQJRQHIURP
DERYH DV W KH FUHDW RU RI W KH ³ HW HUQDO SHDFH DQG M XVW LFH´  RU LI ZH H[SHFW  W KH
0HVVLDK DV W KH UHGHHP HU RI VRP H ³ SHRSOH´  IURP  D VHUYLW XGH LQW R ZKLFK LW  VHQW
LW VHOI

7KH UHGHP SW LRQ LQ VSLULW  KDV W R EH SUHFHGHG E\ D UHGHP SW LRQ LQ W KH SK\VLFDO  $
UHGHP SW LRQ IURP  SK\VLFDO VXEP LVVLRQ LV P HDQLQJOHVV RI LW  GRHV QRW  FRQFHUQ W KH
ERG\ LW VHOI  :H UHGHHP  RXUVHOYHV IURP  W KH ERG\ E\ P HDQV RI KLJKHVW  SK\VLFDO
FKDVW LW \DQGGLVFLSOLQHZKLFKDJDLQLVFRP LQJIURP W KHKLJKHVW VSLULW XDOFKDVW LW \
DQG GLVFLSOLQH  :KDW  ZLOO EHFRP H RI D KXP DQLW \ W KDW  ZDLW V RQO\  IRU W KH VW URQJ
RQH IU RP  DERY H RU  W KH Z HDN  RQH IU RP  EHORZ Z LW KRXW  FRQW U LEXW LQJ DQ\ W KLQJ
W KHP VHOYHV"  +XP DQNLQG KDV W R FRQW LQXH VW ULGLQJ W KH SUHGHW HUP LQHG SDW K RI
KLJK EUHHGLQJLQERG\DQGVSLULW EHFDXVHW KHUHLVQRSRLQW RIUHVW LQW KHDOO W RR
KXP DQ ZKLUOZLQG RI SKHQRP HQD RQ W KH VSLUDO RI DOO DVFHQW 

+XP DQNLQGVKRXOGQRW DOORZEHLQJIRROHGFRQFHUQLQJW KLVODVW UHTXLUHP HQW EHFDXVH

W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ ZRQ¶W  FHDVH W R H[LVW  RQ W KLV (DUW K XQW LO KH KDV JRQH W KLV SDW K
W RSHUIHFW LRQDQGW R*RG$Q\DW W HP SW W RFLUFXP YHQW W KLVJRDORUW RJHW ULGRILW
ZLOOHYHQW XDOO\LQFUHDVHW KHUHTXLUHGW LP HW RJHW W RW KHW RS1RW ³ HTXDOLW \´ LVW KH
JRDODQGKXP DQVDUHQRW HTXDO$OOKXP DQVZLOOEHHTXDOZKHQW KH\UHDFKHGW KH
XOW LP DW H JRDO EXW  HYHU\RQH ZLOO JHW  W KHUH LQ ³ KLV W LP H´

:H DUH QRW  VXUSULVHG W KDW  W KH LQIHULRU RQH ZDQW V W R KDYH DQG P DNH HYHU\W KLQJ
³ HTXDO´  DQG OLNHZLVH ZH DUH QRW  VXUSULVHG W KDW  W KH EHW W HU RQH GHIHQGV KLP VHOI
DJDLQVW  W KDW  EHFDXVH ERW K RI W KHP  DUH QRW  RQO\ HQHP LHV RI W KDW  ZKLFK LV JRRG
EXW VW LOOP RUHRIW KDW ZKLFKLVEDG+RZHYHUW KLVKRVW LOLW \LVHTXDOO\ELJZLW KW KH
LQIHULRURQHW KHUHIRUHKHP HDQVZLW K³ HTXDO´  GRZQZLW KKLP   :KLOHW KHEHW W HU
RQH P HDQV ZLW K ³ HTXDO´   ³ XS ZLW K KLP ´
 

, 9 /;=L?> /JLCHA
2QFH W KUHH IRU W KH UDFH RI W KH JRGV
6W URQJ DQG 0LOG ZDONHG W KH EHDFK RI W KH VHD
7KH\ IRXQG RQ W KH VKRUH ORVW  SRZHUOHVV
7KH $VN DQG W KH (P EOD VW LOO ZLW KRXW  SXUSRVH
7KH\ GLG QRW  KDYH VHQVHV QRU GLG W KH\ KDYH VRXO
1R OLIH DQG ZDUP W K QRU 'LYLQH VW DW XUH
%UHDW K :RGDQ JDYH W KHP  , QQHU P HDQLQJ +|QHU
*ORZ RI ZDUP W K JDYH /RJH DQG VKLQLQJ EORRG

(GGD

7R W KH ROG *HUP DQLF SHRSOHV W KH JRG RI W KH KHDYHQO\ DUP LHV DQG RI
W KHDUP \RQ(DUW KZDV=LX7LXLQ/RZHU*HUP DQ1RUVH7\RU7\U2Q
KLV GD\ W KH =LX GD\ RU 7XHVGD\ W KH GD\ RI W KH 7KLQJ M XVW LFH  W KH
=LFKW DJ (QJOLVK   7XHVGD\ /RZHU *HUP DQ 7LHVW DJ 6ZHGLVK 7LVGDJ
6ZLW ]HUODQG6XHELDDQG$OVDFHLQGLDOHFW =LVKW LJ =LX GD\W KH7KLQJ
SHRSOH DVVHP EOHG W R W KH 7KLQJ ZKLFK ZRUG DJDLQ DV D FRP P RQ URRW
ZLW K7LX=LXDQG=XJ, QDQFLHQW 5RP HW KH7XHVGD\ZDVFRQVHFUDW HG
W R0DUVW KHJRGRIZDU P DUW HGLP DUGLHW F 7KLVDQFLHQW JRGRIW KH
DUP LHV=LXRU7LXZDVD'LHV SLW HU -XSLW HU IRUW KH5RP DQVD'M DXV
SLW DU IRU W KH , QGLDQV DQG D ³ =HXV´  IRU W KH *UHHN

7KH LGHQW LW \ RI W KH *HUP DQLF JRG RI W KH KHDYHQV =LX ZLW K =HXV LV
P DW W HU RI IDFW  IRU D ORQJ W LP H DQG LW  EHFRP HV REYLRXV W R W KH UHDGHU
HYHQ ZLW KRXW  P XFK H[SODQDW LRQ  =HXV W RR ZDV D JRG RI ³ P RYLQJ
RXW ´  DVKLVQDP HLQGLFW HV ³ 3URFUHDW RU ´KDQG RIDFORFN 0DW HULDO
SXOO DUH 8U *HUP DQ ZRUGV W KDW  KDYH W KH VDP H P HDQLQJ  7KHUHIRUH
W KH³ =HXJ KDXV´  DUP RU\ W KDW GRHVQRW KDYHW RGRZLW KW KH³ W KLQJV´
=HXJ W KDW ¶VVW RUHGW KHUHLQEXW SULP DULO\IURP W RP RYH =XJ W KHUH
ZKHUHSHRSOHDVVHP EOHGDQGJRW W KHZHDSRQVIRUW KHFDP SDLJQ =XJ 
IRU W KH ³ =HXJ´

³ 7HH W R 7KLQJ´  ZDV W KH FDOO LQ )ULHVODQG RI W KRVH ZKR P RYHG W R W KH
FRXUW W RW KH7KLQJ ³ JRW RW KH7KLQJ´ 7KHW UHHRIM XGJP HQW W KHUHLV
VW LOO QDP HG   ³ 7HH %RRP ´

, Q 7KXULQJLD 3URIHVVRU 6W XKO P HQW LRQV W KH ³ 7KJH´   RU ³ 7´  FRXUW 
ZKHUHVXUURXQGHGE\ZRRGRUVW RQHW KRVHZKRKDGW KHULJKW W R W KH
7KLQJDVVHP EOHGW RFRXUW RIM XVW LFHRUW RFRXQFLO, Q1RUW KHUQ*HUP DQ\
W KH ROG SODFHV RI DVVHP EO\ DUH FDOOHG 7LH 7K 7HH DQG W KHLU QDP HV


2IW KHDUP \RIFRXUVH
 

UHP DLQHG LQ H[LVW HQFH W R W KLV GD\ RQ P DUNHW  SODFHV DQG VW UHHW V RI W KH FLW LHV
, Q7\UROW KHZRUGIRUD\RXQJP DQZKRUHDFKHGW KHDJHRIFRP SXOVDU\P LOLW DU\
VHU Y LFH LV FDOOHG D ³ =RFK´ DOVR RQH Z KR EHORQJV W R W KH ³$XV ]X J´ Z KLFK LQ
6ZLW ]HUODQG LV W KH ZRUG IRU W KH DUP \ UHVHUYHV

7KH FLW \  RI $XJVEXU J Z DV FDOOHG ³ =LHVEXU J´  LQ ROG W LP HV LH =LXVEXU J W KH
6ZDELVK SHRSOH W KHP VHOYHV ZHUH ³ =LX W UDYHOHUV´ ZKR ZHUH QRW  D W ULEH DV VXFK
EXW  D VKRUW HU RU ORQJHU ZDYH RI P LJUDW LRQ W R D VHW W OHP HQW  ZKLFK ZDV SHDFHIXO
DQGRULJLQDW HGIURP W KH*HUP DQLFOHDGHUVKLS$XJVEXUJ  W KHUHIRUHZDVD³ SODFH
RI P LJUDW LRQ´  =LHK VW lW W H  DQG W KH ³ ]LX Z DUHQ´  DU H W KH P HQ Z KR JR W R W KH
³ SODFH RI P RYLQJ´ W R W KH SODFH RI W KH 7KLQJ W R W KH 7KLQJ DV VRQV RI 7LX RU =LX
7KH9LNLQJVRIW KH W K FHQW XU\FDOOHGW KHLUZDUYR\DJHV³ 7\ZHUN´LHZRUNVRI7\
ZKLFKLVW KH1RUGLFQDP HIRU]LX7\RU7\ULVW KH1RUGLF0DUVDQGW KHV\P ERORI
0DUV LQ DVW URORJ\ LV W KH V\P ERO RI 7\U LQ W KH 1RUGLF 5XQHV LH W KH 8U V\P EROV
RI ZULW LQJ RI DOO SHRSOHV RI W KH (DUW K

, Q W KHVH VRXQGV LH 7LX =LX 7\U 'LH 'HXV /DW LQ  'HRV *UHHN  7KLRG ROG
6D[ RQ  7KLRGD *RW KLF  'LRW D 'LHW  2OG +LJK *HU P DQ  'HXW  0LGGOH +LJK
*HU P DQ  Z KHU HIU RP  FRP HV DOVR W KH QDP H 'HXW VFK LQ W KHVH VRXQGV LV W KH
P HDQLQJ RI W KH ZRUG ³ *RG´  LQ DOO $U\DQ SHRSOHV DQG LQ SHRSOHV Z KR DUH VW LOO
VSHDNLQJDQ$U\DQODQJXDJHW RGD\7KHVDP HZRUGIRU'LRW RU'HXW  *RW LVDOVR
D ZRUG IRU 'HXW VFK DV W KH ZRUG *RG LV DOVR IRU W KH *RW KV KLV JRRG SHRSOH
7KHUHIRUHW KH*HUP DQLFSHRSOHLVW KHSHRSOHRI*RGZKLFKP HDQVW KHSHRSOHRI
W KH *RRG 2QHV

8QGHUW KHSURW HFW LRQRIW KH$OO *RGW KLVJRGRIW KHDUP LHVW KH*HUP DQLFFURZGV
P RYHGLQW RW KHZRUOGLQW KH6DFUHG6SULQJ7KHLUOHDGHUVZHUHW KH³ 7KLRGDQV´ RU
³ 7HXW RQL´  /DW LQ W KH=LX RU7HXW  DQFHVW RUV  W KLVZD\DFFRUGLQJ3URIHVVRU6W XKO
W KH\ Z HU H VW LOO QDP HG E\ W KH *RW KV  7KH QDP H LV RQ D ERU GHU VW RQH RQ W KH
*UHLQEHUJE\0LOW HQEHUJ)URP W KHZRUG7LRW RU7HXIIRU*RGQDW XUDOO\W KHZRUG
IRUW KHZKROHRILW HP HUJHG 7KH$U\DQ *HUP DQLFZRUG³ 7RW  /DW LQ W RW XV ZKLFK
VHHP VW RKDYHEHHQDFFHSW HGE\DOOODQJXDJHVDQGZKLFKFDQHYHQEHUHFRJQL]HG
LQ W KH &KLQHVH 7DR DQG LQ W KH (J\SW LDQ 7RW  RU 7HO  7KDW ¶V LW  Z KDW  *RHW KH P HDQW
ZKHQ KH ZURW H

³ , Q W KH EHJLQQLQJ ZDV W KH ³ 7DW ´  DFW LRQ    7KLV LV W KH JUHDW  ³ 'DW ´ VW LOO XVHG LQ
GLDOHFW W KH³ , W ´  'DV  7KH7DW DQG7RW RIW KH(J\SW LDQVW KH7DRRIW KH&KLQHVH
W KHUHIRUH DOO RI LW   ³ W RXW ´   )UHQFK

:LW KW KHZRUG³ =HXJ´ FRQQHFW HGLVDOVRW KHZRUGDQGLGHDRI³ =HFKH´7KLVZRUG

KDV QRW KLQJ W R GR Z LW K ³ ]HFKHQ´  LQ W RGD\ ¶V P HDQLQJ LH W R GU LQN  DOFRKROLF


2PLWWHG
 

EHYHUDJHV LQ D ³ =HFKH´   W DYHUQ   7KLV P HDQLQJ ZDV DGGHG P XFK ODW HU  7KH
ZRUG³ =HFKH´ FRP HVIURP ³ =XJ´  W UHN P RYHLQORZHU*HUP DQW LHW RJJHW RJHQ
=XJ  =HXFK  =HFKH  , Q W KLV P HDQLQJ LW  UHP LQGV XV RI W KH ³ =XJ´  P RYH  LH
W KHOHDYLQJRIW KH\RXQJSHRSOHDW W KHW LP HRIH[LW 7KHUHZRXOGEHDFRQW UDGLFW LRQ
LI³ ]HFKHQ´  JHW LQJGUXQN ZDVW KHP DLQSXUSRVHDQGQRW W KHW UHN7KHH[FXUVLRQ
LQ W KH P RQW K RI 0D\ DV SUDFW LFHG LQ SUDFW LFDOO\ DOO VFKRROV FRP HV IURP  W KLV
W UDGLW LRQ ZKLFK ZDV FRP P RQSODFH

7KLVFXVW RP KDVW KHIROORZLQJRULJLQ $OUHDG\LQDQW LTXLW \SHRSOHUHFRJQL]HGW KH

1RUW K DV W KH FUDGOH RI KXP DQNLQG DW  OHDVW  W KH FUDGOH RI W KH KXP DQNLQG W KDW
FUHDW HG W KHVH ROG FXOW XUHV ZKLFK KLVW RULFDOO\ ZH ODEHO ³ DQW LTXLW \´  , QGHHG IURP
W KH1RUW KLHW KHRULJLQDOVHW W OHP HQW VRIW KH$U\DQVZKLFK VRP HZKDW FRLQFLGH
Z LW K W KH ERU GHU V RI W RGD\ ¶V *HU P DQLF QDW LRQV  HP DQDW HG Z DY HV RI  SHRSOHV¶
P LJUDW LRQVIRUW HQVRIW KRXVDQGVRI\HDUVZKLFKVORZO\VHW W OHGW KHZKROHZRUOG
$ P RGH RI VHW W OLQJ DQG SRSXODW LQJ W RJHW KHU ZLW K ODUJH VFDOH EUHHGLQJ DUUDQJHG
LQ HYHU\ VSULQJ W KH ³ FRQVHFUDW HG VSULQJ´ RU W KH ³ YHU VDFUXP ´  'XULQJ W KDW  W LP H
W KHJURZQ XS\RXW KRIW KLVRXU8U IRONZDVVHW XSW REHQHZOHDGHUVDP RQJQHZ
SRSXODW LRQV7KHVDP HZDVDVEHHVVZDUP LQVSULQJW RILQGDQHZSODFHW ROLYH
W KH \RXQJ DVVHP EOHG LQ W KHLU KRP HODQG XQGHU W KH VDP H LQQHU GULY H  7KLV ZDV
QRW  DLP OHVV DFW LRQ EXW  DFFRUGLQJ W R ORQJ SODQQHG EOXHSULQW V RI VHW W OHP HQW V W KDW
K DG W K H SX U SRVH W R U HVK DSH W K H Z RU OG  W R GLU HFW  LQ W R RU GHU O\  SX U SRVH W K H
FRQW LQXRXVO\IORZLQJIRXQW DLQRIUDFLDOIHUW LOLW \7KHSXUSRVHZDVQRW W RDOORZW KH
SRSXODW LRQLQW KHKRP HODQGW REHFRP HW RRGHQVHVRW KDW W KHSK\ VLFDODQGVRXO
DULVW RFUDF\ RI W KH IRON ZRXOG QRW  VXIIHU  :H DOOXGHG DOUHDG\ W R W KH IDFW  W KDW  W KH
VHW W OLQJ RI W KH KRP HODQG Z DV QRW  OHIW  W R DU ELW U DU \  GHFLVLRQV EXW  W KDW  LW  Z DV
VDQFW LILHGE\'LYLQHODZ6XFKZLVHUXOHVSUHYHQW HGW KHKRUULEOHLQM XVW LFHRQW KH
VRLOZKLFKZDVDORDQIURP W KH6XQ7KHODFNRIREVHUYDW LRQRIW KLVODZEURXJKW
W KH VODYH FKDLQV W R KXP DQNLQG XQGHU ZKLFK W KH\ DUH VXIIHULQJ LQ RXU GD\V

(YHU\ ROG VHW W OHP HQW  RQ *HUP DQ VRLO ZDV RULJLQDOO\ M XVW  RQH IDU P  P RUH RU OHVV
FORVH W R W KH QHLJKERU GHSHQGLQJ RQ ORFDW LRQ IHUW LOLW \ DQG FOLP DW H  6W LOO W RGD\
UHVHDUFKRIQDP HVRIW RZQVKLSVDQGORFDW LRQVFDQQRW LFHW KH8U IDUP VZKHUHLQ
IXOOQHVV RI OLIH W KH $U\DQ ZDV DFW LYH LQ W KH P LGVW  RI KLV QXP HU RXV DQG KHDOW K\
RIIVSULQJ RQ D OHYHO RI FXOW XUH ZKLFK LV YHU\ REYLRXV W R DQ\ SHUVRQ DEOH W R 8U
&XOW ZKHQORRNLQJDW DQ\XQHDUW KHGLP SOHP HQW RIW KRVHW LP HVVXFKDVZHDSRQU\
M HZHOU\ RU GRP HVW LF W RROV

7KHP LJUDW LRQVOHIW LQZDYHVRIGLIIHUHQW W LP HVSDQVDQGVL]HVW KHLUKRP HVW HDGV

VR W KDW  W KH\ FRXOG P RYH LQW R SUHSDUHG VHW W OHP HQW V RI SUHYLRXVO\  VHW W OHG IRONV
VHHGV RU W R FRQTXHU QHZ W HUULW RULHV W KDW  DUH IDU DZD\  -XVW  KRZ W KHVH ODUJHU
P LJUDW LRQV ZHUH SODQQHG VKRZV W KH IDFW  W KDW  LQ FDVH RI IDLOXUH W R DFKLHYH W KH
IRDOV W KH\ VHFXUHG W KH ULJKW  W R UHW XUQ LQW R W KHLU KRP HODQG IRU   \HDUV  , Q W KLV
OLJKW LW LVHDVLHUIRUXVW RVHHIRULQVW DQFHW KH&LP EULDQG7HXW RQVQRW DVGHVSHUDW H
SHRSOHVZKRUHP RYHGW KHP VHOYHVIURP W KHLURZQVRLOEXW DVDQRUGHUHGP LJUDW LRQ
RQDODUJHVFDOH%HIRUHW KHP ZHUHW KH*DOOLFSHRSOHVDIW HUW KHP W KH*RW KVDQG


W KH*HUP DQZ RUG³$KQHQ´ P HDQVDQFHVW RUV
 

*HUP DQ %URQ]H DUW LIDFW V  %&

DE VZRUGVF EURFKHG JRUJHW H QHFNULQJI VXVSHQGHGYHVVHOK O QHHGOHV
 

W KH/DQJREDUGV, QDQRW KHUDSSHDUDQFHDQGXQGHUGLIIHUHQW FLUFXP VW DQFHVVXFK

P LJUDW LRQVKDSSHQVW LOOLQRXUGD\V$P HULFD$IULFDDQG$XVW U DOLDKDYHEHHQIHG
IURP W KLVVRXUFHRIW KHIRONLQP RGHUQW LP HVDVIDUDVW KHZKLW HUDFHLVFRQFHUQHG

7KLV ZDV W KH ILUVW  $U\R *HUP DQV FDP H W R , QGLD DQG ODLG W KHUH W KH EDVLV RI W KH
, QGR *HUP DQLFUDFH7KURXJKRXW W KHP LOOHQQLDROGHUP LJUDW LRQVLQW KHLUVHDUFK
IRU QHZ VHW W OHP HQW V FDP H W R 3HUVLD 3DOHVW LQH (J\SW  $VLD 0LQRU *UHHFH DQG
6SDLQHYHQW R1RUW K$IULFDDQGW KH\SXW W KH³ VW DP SRIW KHLUFKDUDFW HULVW LFV´ RQ
W KH ORFDO UDFHV E\ P L[LQJ W KH EORRG

7KLV GHYLDW LRQ LQW R W KH ELJ SLFW XUH RI W KH VHW W OHP HQW  RI W KH SODQHW  E\ W KH $U\DQV
ZDVQHFHVVDU\W RXQGHUVW DQGW KHVP DOOHUSLFW XUHRIW KHVHW W OLQJRIW KHKRP HODQG
LQW KHSDVW :HFRXOGQHYHUJHW DSLFW XUHRIW KHSDVW RIRXUKRP HODQGLIZHZHUH
QRW  FDSDEOH RI XQFRYHULQJ W KH ELJ SLFW XUH ZKLFK ZDV W KH RULJLQ RI W KH KRP H
UHODW HG KLVW RULF SUHVHQW   7KXV W KH SUHFRQGLW LRQ RI W KH ZRUOG P LJUDW LRQV RI RXU
DQFHVW RUV LV QHHGHG W R H[SODLQ W KH FXVW RP  DQG W KH ZRUG ³ =HFKH´  FRUUHFW O\

+HUH ZH KDYH W R H[SODLQ   VR W KDW  W KH OD\P DQ DV ZHOO DV W KH SKLORORJLVW  FDQ
XQGHUVW DQG W KLQJV EHW W HU   W KDW  LQ DOO ODQJXDJHV YRZHOV P D\ EH UHSODFHG ZLW K
RW KHU YRZHOV  , Q D FHUW DLQ UHVSHFW  YRZHOV KDUH OHVV SHUP DQHQW  W R W KH SRLQW  RI
EHLQJ LQVLJQLILFDQW   )RU W KLV UHDVRQ YRZHOV DUH QRW  ZULW W HQ LQ P DQ\ ODQJXDJHV
M XVW  LQGLFDW HG  )RU LQVW DQFH LQ *HUP DQ GLDOHFW V \RX KDYH P DQ\ IRUP V IRU W KH
Z RU G ³ N DXIHQ´  W R SXU FKDVH  Z LW K GLIIHU HQW  Y RZ HOV DQG GLSKW KRQJV   .DIHQ
.HIHQ .LIHQ .XIHQ .HLIHQ DQG .lXIHQ

³ =HFK´  LV D ZRUG ZLW K W KH P HDQLQJ ³ =XJ´   DV ZH NQRZ  7KH +HU]RJ GXNH 
ORZHU*HUP DQ+HU W RJLVDP DQZKRW UHNVLQIURQW RIW KH³ KHU´  DUP \ 6XFKD
JURXS W KDW  W UHNNHG M RLQW O\ ZDV FDOOHG ³ =XJ´ =XFK =RFK =DFK =HFK =HXFK RU
=HXJH

7KH ³ ]HFKH´  RI W KH P LQH ZDV RULJLQDOO\ W KH VRFLHW \ RI W KH SHRSOH ZKR ³ ]HFK´  HG
LH W KH SHRSOH ZKR ZHQW  W KHUH QRW  W KH P LQH LW VHOI  , Q 6ZDELD FHUW DLQ JURXSV
RIIDUP HUVDUHFDOOHG³ =LHK´ RU³ =HFK´EXW DOVRW KHORZHU*HUP DQIRUP RI7LHRU
7XH LV NQRZQ W KHUH D SURRI IRU LQW HUQDO P LJUDW LRQV RI W KH *HUP DQLF P LJUDW LRQV
9HU\ P XFK XVHG LV VW LOO W KH H[SUHVVLRQ W KDW  D FRP P XQLW \ RU IDU P  KDV W KH ³ =XJ´
W R W RZQ ; LH W KH FRXUW  RI M XVW LFH W R ZKLFK LW  EHORQJV LV LQ W KH W RZQ ; ZKLFK
LQ P RVW  FDVHV LV EDVHG RQ W KH ROG GLYLVLRQ LQ 7KLQJV  $ 5HSUHVHQW DW LYH RI VXFK
DFRP P XQLW \ZDVD³ 7JH´RUD³ =JH´EHFDXVHKH³ P RYHG´ W RKLVSODFHRIFRXUW 
 

LQQHZ*HUP DQ³ =HXJH´KRZHYHUZLW KDFKDQJHLQP HDQLQJDVLQRXUGD\VW KH

³ =HXJH´  ZLW QHVV LV³ SXOOHG´ W RFRXUW VRW KDW KHFDQJLYHW HVW LP RQ\ZKLOHLQROG
W LP HV KH ZDV ZLW QHVV FUHDW RU FUHDW HG IRU KLV FODQ ³ ZLW QHVVHG´  DW  DQ DVVHP EO\
RI W KH DEOH ERGLHG P HQ

$VZHP HQW LRQHGDOUHDG\EHIRUHW KHP LJUDW LRQVGHFOLQHGJUDGXDOO\DFFRUGLQJW R

FKDQJLQJFLUFXP VW DQFHVW KH\EHFDP HUDUHUDQGVP DOOHUDQGW KH\KDSSHQHGP RUH
DV DQ LQYLVLEOH HP LJUDW LRQ DV LQ RXU GD\V  2Q W KHLU SODFH FDP H SLOJULP DJHV
SURFHVVLRQV \HDU P DUNHW V IRONORULVW LF IHVW LYDOV IHVW LYLW LHV RI DOO NLQGV GD\V RI
DVVHP EO\  DQG RI FRXU W  VHVVLRQV   7KLV KDSSHQHG LQLW LDOO\  W R U HP HP EHU  W KH
P LJUDW LRQV ODW HU DV ROG KDELW V DQG HYHQW XDOO\ DOO W KLV W KH RU LJLQ RI ZKLFK ZDV
ORQJIRUJRW W HQZDVW UDQVIHUUHGW RW KH\RXW KW RW KRVHZKROHDUQHGW RVW XGHQW V
W R FKLOGUHQ LQ JHQHUDO  7KH IRXQW DLQ IHVW LYDOV H[FXUVLRQV LQ W KH P RQW K RI 0D\
DQG VLP LODU IRON IHVW LYDOV DUH P HP RULHV RI W KH JUHDW  VSULQJ P LJUDW LRQ W KH YHU
VDFUXP 

7KLVLVW KHUHDVRQZK\LQW KH&KXUFKDUFKLYHVRI'LQNHOVEKOW KH\UHSRUW HG

RI D IHVW LYDO W KDW  DOUHDG\ W KHQ ZDV UHIHUUHG W R DV ³ ROG FXVW RP ´ ZKHQ VFKRRO
FKLOGUHQ RQFH LQ W KH EHDXW LIXO W LP H RI W KH \HDU ZHQW  W R ³ ]HFKHQ´ W UHN ZLW K W KHLU
W HDFKHU LH ZKHQ W KH\ P DGH DQ H[FXUVLRQ

3HUKDSVLQVXEFRQVFLRXVUHP HP EUDQFHRIW KHZDU OLNHVHULRXVQHVVRIW KHRULJLQDO

³ =HFKH´ W KH DQFLHQW  VDFUHG P LJUDW LRQ W KH FKLOGUHQ ZHUH FORW KHG LQ W KH P LOLW DU\
XQLIRUP RIFHQW XULHVSDVW DQGHYHU\\HDUW KH\JRLQDVROHP QSURFHVVLRQW RW KH
DUHDV RI W DUJHW  SUDFW LFH ZKLOH W KH ER\V EDQG LV SOD\LQJ ROG /DQGVNQHFKW  W XQHV
DQG W KH OLW W OH P DM RU  U LGHV KLV KRU VH DW  W KH EHJLQQLQJ RI W KH SU RFHVVLRQ  +H
SHUIRUP VNLQGRIDQDUP \VKRZRIW KHP RGHUQ\RXW KZKLFKZLW KEULJKW H\HVDQG
HQW KXVLDVW LFDOO\ UHSHDW V W KH VHULRXV JDP H RI DQFLHQW  W LP HV LQ KDUP OHVV M R\ RI D
I HVW LY DO

6XQGD\0RQGD\DQG7XHVGD\DUHW KHGD\VRIW KH&KLOGUHQV ´ ]HFKH´UHIHUULQJW R

W KH KRO\ W ULQLW \ EXW  RQ W KH W KLUG GD\ RQO\ W KH ³ ]LHK´  GD\ SU RFHVVLRQ GD\  W KH
7KLQJ GD\ Z KLFK DOU HDG\ Z DV FRQVHFUDW HG W R W KH JRG RI ZDU  E\ W KH DQFLHQW
SHRSOHV W KH ³ .LQGHU]HFKH´  KDSSHQV DV LQ ROG W LP HV W KH P LJUDW LRQ LQW R D GDUN
IXW XU H

, Q W KLV FRQW H[W  LW  P D\ EH GHVLUDEOH W R JHW  D OLW W OH JHQHUDO YLHZ RI W KH VHW W OHP HQW
P HW KRGV LQ ROG W LP HV LQ W KH RZQ FRXQW U\ DQG W KH GLVW ULEXW LRQ RI W KH VXUSOXV RI
ELUW KV EHFDXVH LQ W LP HV RI FRQVFLRXV FDUH RI UDFH DQG IRON SHRSOH GLG QRW  DOORZ
W KLQJVM XVW W RKDSSHQDVW KH\GRLQRXUGD\V4XLW HW RW KHFRQW UDU\W KH\DGDSW HG
VW ULFW O\ W R W KH VLW XDW LRQV W KDW  UHVXOW HG IURP  W KH QXP EHU RI W KH SRSXODW LRQ W KH
JURZW K RI W KH SRSXODW LRQ DQG W KH OLYLQJ VSDFH /HEHQVUDXP  RI W KH SHRSOH  $
P \ RSLF OHDGHU VKLS RI W KH IRON  W KDW  H[ LVW V DOU HDG\  IRU  FHQW XU LHV P DGH RI W KH
*HUP DQV D SHRSOH Z LW KRXW  VSDFH DQG QRW  RQO\ RI W KH *HUP DQ\ LQ D VW ULFW HU
SROLW LFDOVHQVHEXW DOVRW KHSHRSOHVZKRDUHNLQW RRXUIRONRQW KHERUGHUVRIRXU
HP SLUH  :H VKRXOG QRW  IRUJHW  W KDW  RXU IRONLVK ERUGHUV LQ W KH SDVW  UHDFKHG IURP
W KH 0HGLW HUUDQHDQ W R W KH 1RUW K &DSH DQG IURP  W KH 3\UHQHHV W R W KH %ODFN 6HD
 

7KH³ IRXQGDW LRQVRIFLW LHV´ XQGHU+HQU\W KH9RJOHUZHUHDOZD\VDUELW UDULO\M XVW LILHG

ZLW K W KH LQYDVLRQ RI W KH +XQJDULDQV DQG JHQHUDO LQVHFXULW \ HYHQ W KRXJK ZH FDQ
SURYH W KDW  LQ W KRVH W LP HV W KHUH ZDV QR ODFN RI IRUW LILHG  SODFHV VRP H RI W KHP
YHU\H[W HQVLYHLQDQ\*DXGLVW ULFW RUFRXQW \RIW KH*HUP DQOLYLQJVSDFH5DW KHU
LW ZDVFKDQJLQJFLUFXP VW DQFHVW KDW IRUFHGW KHIDUP HUVW RP RYHLQW RW KHIRUW LILHG
ORFDW LRQVZKLFKW RW KLVSRLQW ZHUHRQO\FXOW LFORFDW LRQVDQGKDYHQVGXULQJKRVW LOH
LQYDVLRQV:HDVVXP HW KDW W KHIODW ODQGW KHQZDVQRORQJHUFDSDEOHRIDEVRUELQJ
W KHVXUSOXVRIW KHSRSXODW LRQ%HFDXVHW KHUHZDVQRVSOLW W LQJRIW KHVKDUHFURSSHU
IDUP VLQW KHYLOODJHW KH\RXQJHUVRQVKDGW ROHDYHW KHVRLODQGHQW HUW KHVHUYLFH
RIW KHJUHDW HUORUGVW KHFRXQW VDQGGXNHV%HFDXVHRIRYHUSRSXODW LRQDZDUULRU
FODVV HP HUJHG W KDW  ZDV QR ORQJHU ERXQG W R W KH ODQG DQG W KHQ DOVR FUDIW VP HQ
DQG P HUFKDQW V ZKLFK W KHQ ZHUH W KH ILUVW  LQKDELW DQW V RI W KHVH IRUW LILHG SODFHV
W KDW  VLQFH W LP H LP P HP RULDO KDYH EHHQ FHQW HUV RI *HUP DQLF OLIH DV SODFHV RI
VDFULILFH SDLQW LQJ GDQFLQJ DQG W KH 7KLQJ FRXUW  RI M XVW LFH DQG DVVHP EO\   7KH
LQYDVLRQVRIW KH+XQJDULDQVDQGW KHLP SRVVLELOLW \RIIXUW KHUH[ SDQVLRQP D\KDYH
VW RSSHG W KH P LJUDW LRQ KDELW V RI W KH \RXQJ IRON IRU VRP H W LP H DOUHDG\ VR W KDW
W KH\ FKDQJHG RYHU W R D QHZ P HW KRG RI LQW HUQDO VHW W OHP HQW V ZLW KRXW  \HW  JLYLQJ
XS W KH W R W KDW  GD\ JHQHURXV GLVW ULEXW LRQ RI W KH ODQG

(GP XQGRI:HFXVKDVVKRZQFRQYLQFLQJO\LQKLVERRN³ W KHP HDQLQJRIQDP HVRI

W RZQVKLSVIRUW KHSUH KLVW RU\´ W KDW W KHHVW DEOLVKP HQW RIRXUFLW LHVSRLQW VW RVXFK
RULJLQV  7KH ROG IRUW LILHG VDQFW XDULHV DQG 7KLQJ ORFDW LRQV W KDW  RULJLQDOO\ ZHUH
LQKDELW HGM XVW E\DIHZJXDUGLDQVZHUHUH EXLOW DFFRUGLQJW RW KHQHZUHTXLUHP HQW V
DQG LQ SDUW  HQODUJHG  7KLV ZDV W KH FLW LHV HYROYHG  7KH\ ZHUH QRW  DUELW UDU\
³ IRXQGDW LRQV´ QRU ³ LP SURYHP HQW V´  RU ³ DFKLHYHP HQW V EXW  FRQVHTXHQFHV RI DQ
XQGHVLUDEOH³ HYROXW LRQ´VLQFHIRUTXLW HDZKLOHW KHP LJUDW LRQRIW KH\RXQJSHRSOH
LQ W KH VDFUHG VSULQJ DQG W KH VHW W OHP HQW  RI IRUHLJQ ODQGV W KDW  KDV EHHQ W KH W DVN
RIRXUUDFHIRUFHQW XULHVDQGP LOOHQQLDKDGFRP HW RDVW RS  7KHJUHDW P LJUDW LRQ
ZDV DQ DW W HP SW  W R IRUFLEO\ P DNH W KH P LJUDW LRQ IURP  W KH 8U VRXUFH LQ W KH 1RUW K
KDSSHQ DJDLQ

, Q W KH FOHDU DQG REYLRXV OLJKW  RI KLVW RU\ W KH KRP HODQG RI W KH $U\DQ P DQ ZDV
1RUW KHUQ(XURSHP RUHSUHFLVHO\1RUW KZHVW HUQ(XURSHZHORJLFDOO\KDYHW RDVVXP H
LW  W KHUH ZKHUH VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V DUH W KH URRW V RI KLV UDFH  , W  LV FHUW DLQ W KDW  W KH
KLJKO\HYROYHGP DQLVOLYLQJIRUP LOOHQQLDLQIDFW IRUKXQGUHGVRIP LOOHQQLD7KH
W UDFHV RI KLV ODQJXDJH UHDFK LQW R YHU\ DQFLHQW  W LP HV ZKLFK ZH XVXDOO\ FDQQRW
LP DJLQH VLQFH ZH DUH XVHG W R VTXHH]LQJ ZRUOG KLVW RU\ LQW R D IHZ FHQW XULHV

/LYDEOH ODQG LQ RXU DUHDV ZDV DOZD\V LQKDELW HG DV ORQJ DV W KHU H ZHUH KXP DQV
DQG HYHQ GXULQJ W KH JUHDW  P LJUDW LRQ SHRSOH GLG QRW  M XVW  OHDYH W KHLU KRP HODQG
1R IDUP HUV LQ RXU GD\V GR W KDW  QRU GLG W KH\ GR LW  W KHQ  7KH W ULEDO P DLQ IRON
QDW XUDOO\ VW D\HG EXW  W KH \RXQJ IRON W KH ELUW K RYHUIORZ ZKR FRXOG QRW  UHFHLYH

W UHN

 2PLWWHG
 

ODQG RU ZDV QRW  DOORZHG W R UHFHLYH LW  VLQFH W KH\ GLG QRW  ZDQW  W R GHVW UR\ W KH ROG
VHW W OLQJ RUGHU W KH \RXQJ IRON P LJUDW HG OLNH D VZDUP  RI EHHV VW UXFW XUHG LQW R D
ZKROHQHVV RI W KH IRON P LJUDW HG W R VHDUFK IRU QHZ OLYLQJ VSDFH FORVH E\ RU IDU
DZD\, QIDFW DW W LP HVW KH\VHFXUHGW KHULJKW RIUHW XUQIRUDSHULRGRI\HDUV
LQ FDVH W KH\ RU  W KHLU  FKLOGU HQ KDG W R JLYH XS DJDLQ W KH QHZ  VHW W OHP HQW V IRU
ZKDW HYHUUHDVRQV7KHUHIRUHLW LVHUURQHRXVW RYLHZLQW KH*HU P DQLFSHRSOHVDQ
XQVHW W OHG DQG P LJUDW LQJ P DVV RI SHRSOH ZLW KRXW  XQLILHG OHDGHUVKLS ZKLFK RQO\
VORZ O\  XQGHU  LQIOXHQFH RI W KHLU  QHLJKERU V  HQGHG XS Z LW K FXOW X U H DQG IL[HG
VHW W OHP HQW V  $V P RW KHU RI DOO SHRSOHV W KH $U\DQ 1RUW K KDV VW LOO VHQW  RXW  KLV
VZ DU P V LQ W KH W LP HV W KDW  IROORZ HG VXFK DV W KH FU XVDGHV W KH FDP SDLJQV W R
5RP HE\W KHHP SHURUVDVW UDYHOLQJJURXSVDVP HUFHQDULHVDVW KH6ZDELDQVLQ
+XQJDU\DQGW KH6D[RQVLQ7UDQV\OYDQLDDQGDVW KHP DQ\QRQ UHJXODW HGHP LJUDW LRQV
GXU LQJ W KH SDVW  FHQW XU LHV  $OO W KHVH P LJU DW LRQV VHU YHG W R SDVV RQ W KH ELU W K
RYHUIORZEXW QRORQJHULQDSODQQHGDQGJUDQGLRVHRUGHURIW KH$U\DQ *HUP DQLF
P LJUDW LRQVZLW KW KHLUVHHGVRIQDW LRQIRXQGLQJZLW KLQW KHLUOLY LQJVW UXFW XUHRIW KH
IRON, QVRIDUW KHZRUG³ FXOW XUDOIHUW LOL]HU´ RI*HUP DQP LJUDW LRQKDVEHHQP HDQLQJIXO
IRUP LOOHQQLD7KHHDUO\FXOW XUHVRI6RXW KHUQ(XURSH:HVW HUQ$VLD1RUW K$IULFD
DQG , QGLD VSUXQJ IURP  1RUGLF EORRG

7KLV H[SODLQV ZK\ W KH QDP HV RI W KH P RXQW DLQV ULYHUV ODNHV DQG VHDV VHHP  W R
EHUHSHDW HGDOORYHUW KHZRUOGEHFDXVH<RXU$QFHVW RUKDVJLYHQLW W RW KHP RQKLV
P LJUDW LRQV DFURVV W KH (DUW K

7KHVH DUH KLVW RULFDO IDFW V DQG LW  LV QHFHVVDU\ W R SRLQW  DW  W KRVH IDFW V HVSHFLDOO\
LQ FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K W KH UHFHQW  ³ 0LOOHQQLD´  2W KHUZLVH RXU IRON LQ LW V P RGHVW \
P D\ EH LQFOLQHG W R EHOLHYH W KDW  RXU KLVW RU\ LV QRW  ROGHU W KDQ D W KRXVDQG \HDUV
7KH FURZGV DFFHSW V VORJDQV DQG HVSHFLDOO\ LQ ORFDO KLVW RU\ SHRSOH DUH QRW  W RR
IRQGRIJRLQJEH\RQGW KH³ W KRXVDQG\HDUV´EHFDXVHW KHQ\RXILQGP DQ\GLIIHUHQW
QDP HV )UDQNV$ODP DQQL6XHEL5RP DQV.HOW V6ODYV:HQGHV+DOOVW DW W SHRSOH
SHRSOHRIW KHVW RQHDJHDQGRIW KHEURQ]HDJH+RZHYHUZHDYRLGSDLQVW DNLQJO\
W DONLQJ DERXW  RXUVHOYHV ZKHQ W DONLQJ DERXW  W KH *HUP DQLF SHRSOH   $QG \HW  DOO
W KHVH SHRSOHV ZHUH RXU DQFHVW RUV DQG RI RQH EORRG DQG RI RQH UDFH W KLV W KH
*HUP DQ SHUVRQ RI *HUP DQLF GHVFHQW  VKRXOG UHP HP EHU RQFH DQG IRU DOO  $QG
ZKHQ W KH\ W DON KHUH DERXW  W KH .HOW V RU *DOOLF SHRSOH RQ \RXU JU RXQG W KHQ \RX
VKRXOG NQRZ W KDW  W KH\ W RR ZHUH RI W KH VDP H EORRG DQG W KH VDP H ODQJXDJH DV
\RXDQGW KDW W RW KHP .HOW VP HDQW KHURHV<RXVKRXOGNQRZW KDW DOORIW KLVKDV
GLIIHUHQW  ZRUGV RULJLQDW LQJ LQ GLIIHUHQW  W LP HV RI RQH DQG W KH VDP H 8U UDFH RI
ZKLFK\RXW RRDUHGHVFHQGLQJHYHQW KRXJK\RXUEORRGKDVEHHQP L[HGODW HUE\
IRUHLJQ LQIOX[ RI EORRG
2XURZQROGHVW W UDGLW LRQVDQGW KHW HVW LP RQ\RILP SRUW DQW FRQW HP SRUDULHVRIRXU
DQFHVW RUV SURYH W R W KH SHUVRQ ZKRVH LQKHULW HG P HP RULHV W KHP VHOYHV FDQQRW
W HOO W KLV W KDW  Z H DUH D QDW LYH IRON RQ W KH VRLO Z KHUH Z H DUH OLYLQJ VDP H W R
RXUVHOYHVRQO\VDP HVL]HRIERG\P LQGDQGVRXODQGKDYLQJP RUDOVOLNHQRRW KHU
SHRSOH LQ DQW LTXLW \ UHFRJQL]HG DV EHLQJ W KH 8U VRXUFH RI KXP DQLW \ VLQFH W LP HV
LP P HP RULDO ZKLFK RQO\ QRZDGD\V VHHP V W R H[KDXVW  LW VHOI
 

, W  LV HY LGHQ W  W K DW  VX FK  DQ  8U  IRON  FDQ Q RW  VW DQ G EHK LQ G RW K HU  SHRSOHV Z K R

W KHP VHOYHVHYROYHGIURP W KLV8U VRXUFH-XVW EHFDXVHZHVW D\HGFORVHW RQDW XUH
RXUKRP HODQGIRUDIHZP LOOHQQLDORQJHUW KDQRXUEUDQFKHVZHFDQQRW EHODEHOHG
DV EHLQ J ³ EDFN  Z RRGHG´  LQ  FRP SDU LVRQ  Z LW K  W K H FLY LOL]DW LRQ V RI  DQ W LTX LW \
0HDQZKLOHKRZHYHUW KHRSLQLRQJDLQVJURXQGW KDW ZHGUHZORQJHUIURP W KH8U
IRXQW DLQ W KDQ RXU EUDQFKHV DQG W KDW  ZH UHP DLQHG W KHUHIRUH SXUHU P RUH FORVHG
DQGP RUHFORVHGRIIZKLOHW KRVHZKRZHQW DIDUP L[HGDOUHDG\HDUO\ZLW KLQIHULRU
UDFHV DQG W KXV ODLG W KH JURXQG IRU KXP DQ DQG P RUDO GHJHQHUDW LRQ

(YHU\W KLQJSRLQW VW RW KHIDFW W KDW DOOOLIHRQ(DUW KDVIDUDVZHFDQM XGJHRQHRI

LW V HUDV RULJLQDW HG RQ W KH 1RUW K 3ROH   DQG ZLW K W KDW  DOVR W KH KXP DQV  :KHQ
W KH 1RUW K 3RODU 5HJLRQ EHFDP H XQLQKDELW DEOH EHFDXVH RI FRROLQJ GRZQ KXP DQV
H[SDQGHGRYHUW KHZKROH(DUW KOLNHW KHUD\VRIW KH6XQ, QGHHGW KHVHW W OLQJRI
W KH SODQHW  E\ KXP DQV LH KLJKHU HYROYHG KXP DQV GHFUHDVHV SU RSRUW LRQDO W R
W KHGLVW DQFHIURP W KHSROH$IW HUKXP DQVP LJUDW HGIURP W KHSROHW KHP HDQZKLOH
VXQNHQFRQW LQHQW RI$W ODQW LVEHFDP HFHQW HURIW KHSRVW SRODUKXP DQLW \ZKLFKLV
VDLG W R EH W KH IRXU W K U RRW  U DFH RI W KH $W ODQW HDQV DFFRU GLQJ W R ³ 7KH 6HFU HW
'RFW ULQH´    7KH ILIW K URRW  UDFH W KDW  IROORZHG W KH IRXUW K EHFDP H W KH P DLQ KHLU RI
W KH IRXUW K $W ODQW HDQ URRW  UDFH W KDW  VORZO\ JRW  H[W LQFW   7KH EHVW  DQDO\VW V RI W KH
*UHHNJRGVDQGKHURHVUHDOL]HGIRUDORQJW LP HDOUHDG\M XVW KRZGDUNW KHRULJLQ
RI *UHHN P \W KRORJ\ DFW XDOO\ LV   3UHOOHU DQG 5REHUW  FRQILUP  W KDW  W KH ODQGVFDSH
RI W KH 0HGLW HUUDQHDQ GRHV QRW  FRUUHVSRQG W R W KH ORFDW LRQV JLYHQ LQ W KH P \W KV 
LQIDFW W KDW QRW HYHQW KHQDP HVRIW KHJRGVDUHRI*UHHNRULJLQ, QIDFW ZHFDQ
VD\W KDW LW LVHYLGHQW W KDW W KHQDP HVRIW KH*UHHNJRGVFDQEH GHULYHGIURP W KH
*HUP DQODQJXDJHIRUW KHVLP SOHUHDVRQW KDW W KH*UHNVFDP HIURP W KH1RUW KDQG
EURXJKW ZLW KW KHP W KH$U\DQ8U UHOLJLRQDQGODQJXDJH7KH*UHHNODQJXDJHVW LOO
LQRXUGD\VVKRZVIRUW KHH[SHUW W KLVNLQVKLSW RVXFKDQH[W HQW W KDW VRP HGD\ZH
Z LOO QRW  ILQG LW  DQ H[DJJHU DW LRQ Z KHQ W KRVH H[SHU W V Z LOO FODLP  VRP HGD\ W KDW
*UHHN LV D *HUP DQ GLDOHFW  W KDW  VSOLW  RII D IHZ W KRXVDQG \HDUV DJR  3URIHVVRU
6W XKOKDVFRQGXFW HGGHFLVLYHDQGFRQYLQFLQJUHVHDUFKLQW KLVUHVSHFW W KDW GHVHUYHV
W R EH VKRZQ W R DOO    7KHUHIRUH LW  LV D M XVW LILDEOH FRQFOXVLRQ W R ORRN LQ W KH :HVW
DQG 1RUW KZHVW  IRU W KH DFW XDO LVODQG RI +HOLRV W KH FRXQW U\ RI W KH $UJRQDXW V DQG
W KHSODFHRI6F\OODDQG&KDU\EGLV7KHDQFLHQW *UHHNVW KHP VHOYHVNQHZRIW KHLU
RULJLQLQW KH1RUW KLQW KHFRXQW U\RIW KH+\SHUERUHDQV)URP  W KLVFRXQW U\W KH\
EURXJKW  ZLW K W KHP  W KH GHYRW LRQ W R W KH +\SHUERUHDQ $ 3RO ORQ W KH JRG RI W KH
³ SROH´W KH³ 3RKO´ RIW KH*HUP DQVDQGW KH%DO GHURIW KH(GGDDOOW RJHW KHUOLJKW 


 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 

DQG 6XQ JRGV RI RQH DQG W KH VDP H RULJLQ  6R ZH DUH QRW  VXUSULVHG W KDW  W KH
5RP DQVIRULQVW DQFH&DHVDUDQG7DFLW XVJDYHW KH*HUP DQLFJRGVVLP SO\*UHHN
DQ G 5RP DQ  Q DP HV  EHFDX VH DW  W K HVH W LP HV SHRSOH U HFRJQ L]HG FOHDU O\  W K H
FRUUHVSRQGHQFHV  7KLV ZDV FRQVLGHUHG VHOI HYLGHQW  GXH W R W KH FORVH NLQVKLS RI
W KH/DW LQDQG*HUP DQLFDW W KHW LP HRIW KHELUW KRI&KULVW %HFDXVHRIW KDW W KRVH
DXW KRUVGLGQRW ERW KHUW RJLYHP RUHH[SODQDW LRQV 7KHFRP P RQDQFHVW U\RIDOO
$U\DQ P \W KRORJ\ IURP  W KH $U\DQ 8U UHOLJLRQ ZDV SHUFHLYHG DV FRP P RQ YLHZ W R
VXFK DQ H[W HQW  W KDW  W KHUH ZDV QR QHHG W R P HQW LRQ P XFK DERXW  LW   , I LW  UHDOO\
KDSSHQHG W KHQ ZLW K ZRUGV DQG FRQFHSW V RI ZKLFK ZH GR QRW  NQRZ DQ\P RUH LQ
RXU GD\V

7KH*UHHNVW KRXJKW RIW KH+\SHUERUHDQVDVEHLQJW KHP RVW SLRXV DQGULJKW HRXV

KXP DQVW KHIDYRULW HVRIW KHJRGV ZKHUHHOVHVKRXOGZHORRNIRUW KHJDUGHQVRI
W KH+HVSHULGLQVW KDQLQW KHJDUGHQRI, GXQDZKRJXDUGHGW KHDSSOHIURP ZKLFK
W KH *RGV DUH W R EH LP P RUW DO  :H FDQQRW  GR ZLW KRXW  DVVXP LQJ DQ RULJLQ RI W KH
$U\DQFXOW XUHDQGZLW KLW RIDOO0HGLW HUUDQHDQP \W KRORJLHV$W ODQW LVZRXOGKDYH
QHHGHGW REHLQYHQW HGLILW ZDVQRW DOUHDG\IDFW 7KH(GGDLVP XFKROGHUW KDQZH
DVVXP H  2G\VVH\ DQG , OLDG H[LVW HG DOUHDG\ LQ D 3UH +RP HULDQ YHUVLRQ VDP H
DERXW  W KH KHURLF W DOHV RI W KH (GGD DERXW  6LHJIULHG W KH :lOVXQJV W KH 1LEOXQJV
DQG DERXW  $W W OLD  *ULP P  VD\V  ³ W R GHQ\ W KH UHDOLW \ RI W KLV P \W KRORJ\ P HDQV
URXJKO\W RGHQ\W KHKLJKDJHDQGSHUP DQHQFHRIRXUODQJXDJH´ +HVSHDNVKHUH
DERXW  W KH 1RUGLF (GGD ³ W KH FRQW HQW  VW UXFW XUH DQG OD\RXW  RI ZKLFK EUHDW KHV
HDU OLHVW  W LP HV´

:H KDYH W R ORRN IRU W KHLU RULJLQ LQ $W ODQW LV  , W  KDV W R EH W KH SRLQW  RI GHSDUW XUH
RI DOO UHVHDUFK RI P \W KV  )RU RXU RZQ SUH KLVW RU\ W KH $W ODQW HDQ FXOW XUH LV W KH
2QH FXOW XUHW KH8U FXOW XUH&DUULHURIW KLVFXOW XUHZDVW KH$U\DQP DLQUDFHW KDW
OLYHV LQ LW V RULJLQDO VW DW H VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V   7KH VSOLW  RI W KH $U\DQ KXP DQLW \ LQW R
P DQ\ SHRSOHV KDSSHQHG ODW HU DIW HU W KH VLQNLQJ RI $W ODQW LV ZKHQ W KH $W ODQW HDQ
FRORQLHVLQ(XURSH$VLD$P HULFDDQG$IULFDIROORZHGGLIIHUHQW HYROXW LRQDU\SDW KV

$V ZH NQRZ W KH (J\SW LDQ SULHVW V JDYH W KH *UHHN ZLVH P DQ 6RORQ D GHVFULSW LRQ
RI W KH $W ODQW LV W KDW  KDV VXQN HQ   \ HDU V DJR   3ODW R Z U RW H DERXW  LW  LQ
³ .U LW LDV´

1RW DEOH FKXUFK IDW KHUV RI W KH ILUVW  &KULVW LDQ FHQW XULHV EHOLHYHG LQ W KH VXQNHQ
$W ODQW LV  7KH\ ZHUH FRQYLQFHG RI W KH VFLHQW LILF UHOLDELOLW \ RI W KH *UHHN VFKRODUV
DQG W KH W UDGLW LRQ ZDV VW LOO FRP P RQ NQRZOHGJH  7KHQ HIIRUW V EHJDQ W R VXSSUHVV
DOO LQIRUP DW LRQ FRQFHUQLQJ $W ODQW LV DQG W R UHOHJDW H W KHP  LQW R W KH UHDOP  RI IDLU\
W DOHV


*UHHN³ NDOHHP HUD´  *HUP DQ³ JXW HQ7DJ´ 

 2PLWWHG
 

2QO\  LQ W KH SDVW  FHQW XU LHV VHU LRXV VFKRODU V EHJDQ W R H[ DP LQH W KH $W ODQW HDQ
TXHVW LRQDJDLQ:LGHFLUFOHVZRUNHGDJDLQVW VXFKUHVHDUFKDQGFDOOHGDOOUHSRUW V
FRQFHUQLQJ $W ODQW LV IDLU\ W DOHV

7KHQ XSRQ LW V GLVFRYHU\ RI W KH W UHDVXU\ RI 3ULDP XV LQ W KH UXLQV RI Z KDW  KH
VXSSRVHGW REH7UR\W KHDUFKHRORJLVW +HLQULFK6FKOLHP DQQIRXQGDODUJHEURQ]H
YHVVHOLQZKLFKZHUHFRLQVRIDUDUHP HW DODOOR\ FRSSHUSODW LQXP DQG$OXP LQXP 
DQG ZKLFK FDUULHG DQ LQVFULSW LRQ ³ LQ 3KRHQLFLDQ OHW W HUV

³ )URP  NLQJ .UHQRV RI $W ODQW LV´

:HVXUHFDQLP DJLQHKRZ6FKOLHP DQQZDVVXUSULVHGZKHQKHUHDGW KHVHZRUGV

W KLV ILQG ZDV SURRI W KDW  $W ODQW LV H[LVW HG LQ W KH SDVW 

6FKOLHP DQQ GLHG LQ  ZLW KRXW  KDYLQJ EHHQ DEOH W R SXEOLVK W KH UHVXOW V RI KLV
UHVHDUFK ZKLFK KH OHIW  VHDOHG

+LVJUDQGVRQ3DXO6FKOLHP DQQUHSRUW HGLQW KH³ 1HZ<RUN$P HULFDQ´ EULHIO\

DERXW W KHILQGVRIKLVJUDQGIDW KHUDQGSURP LVHGSXEOLFDW LRQRIDERRNFRQFHUQLQJ
$W ODQW LV W KDW  VKRXOG IROORZ VRRQ  7KH ERRN W KDW  ZDV H[SHFW HG Z LW K DQW LFLSDW LRQ
KDVQRW EHHQSXEOLVKHGW RW KLVGD\'U3DXO6FKOLHP DQQGLVDSSHDUHGLQDQG
ZLW KKLP W KHUHVXOW VRIKLVJUDQGIDW KHU ¶VUHVHDUFK:HP D\FRUUHFW O\DVVXP HW KDW
HYHU\W KLQJ LV GRQH W R VXSSUHVV W KH W UXW K FRQFHUQLQJ $W ODQW LV DQG W KHUHIRUH RI
ZRUOG KLVW RU\

, QW KHP LGGOHRIW KHULQJV\VW HP ZDVDP RXQW DLQ³ W KHKRO\P RXQW DLQRI*RG´ RI
W KH%LEOHZKLFKZDVW UDQVIRUP HGW RDEXLOGLQJRIJLJDQW LFH[SDQVHVSOHQGRUDQG
RI XQXVXDO VKDSH  $U RXQG W KH P RXQW DLQ Z HU H VR 3ODW R VHY HU DO ODU JHU  DQG
VP DOOHU ULQJV W ZR RI HDUW K DQG W KUHH RI ZDW HU  7KH ZLGHVW  RI W KH ULQJ VKDSHG
FDQDOV P HDVXUHG  IHHW  DFURVV  7KH HDUW KHQ UDP SDUW  W KDW  IROORZHG KDG W KH
VDP H ZLGW K  7KH QH[W  ULQJ FDQDO ZDV  IHHW  ZLGH DQG W KH UDP SDUW  LQVLGH LW
ZDV HTXDOO\ ZLGH  )LQDOO\ W KH LQQHUP RVW  FDQDO W KDW  VXUURXQGHG W KH LVODQG LW VHOI
ZDVIHHW ZLGHDQGW KHDUW LILFLDOLVODQGKDGDGLDP HW HURIIHHW , VODQG
DQG UDP SDUW V KDG ODUJH VW RQH ZDOOV W KDW  ZHUH FRYHUHG ZLW K EURQ]H VKHHW V  2Q
W KH SHDN ZDV D SURXG .LQJ¶V FDVW OH W KDW  ZDV VKLQLQJ LQ W KH VSOHQGRU RI JROG
VLOYHU SUHFLRXV VW RQHV DQG EURQ]H
 

7KH ZLGH FDQDOV ZHUH XVHG W R EXLOG D ODUJH FRP P HUFLDO FLW \ W KDW  KDG GHHS DQG
ZLGH FDQDOV  2Q W KH ZDOOV RI LW V KDUERU ZHUH KXJH VW RUDJH KRXVHV ZKHUH RQH
FRXOGILQGJRRGVIURP DOOFRXQW ULHV7KHVKLSVFDQDOVKDGDJLJDQW LFFRP P HUFLDO
DQGZDUIOHHW QHYHUVHHQRQW KLVSODQHW EHIRUH$FDQDOW KDW ZDVNP ORQJ
IHHW  Z LGH DQG  IHHW  GHHS FRQQHFW HG W KH VHD Z LW K W KH FDQDO U LQJV  +LJK
EULGJHG XQGHU ZKLFK W KH W DOOHVW  ZDU VKLSV FRXOG SDVV VSDQQHG W KH FDQDOV  $
EULGJHDFURVVW KHFDQDOVW KDW ZDVIHHW ZLGHDQGW KDW ZDVEXLOW RIZKLW HUHG
DQG EODFN VW RQHV FRQQHFW HG W KH FLW \ ZLW K W KH NLQJV FDVW OH  6W LOO LQ RXU GD\V UHG
DQGZKLW HVW RQHVDVZHOODVEODFNODYDEORFNVFDQEHIRXQGRQW KHLVODQGVRIW KH
$]RUHV ZKLFK DUH UHP DLQGHUV RI $W ODQW LV  7KHVH VW RQHV DUH XVHG IRU EXLOGLQJV

3ODW RGRHVQRW P HQW LRQW KHQDP HRIW KHFLW \7RFRQFOXGHDIW HUW KHUHYHODW LRQRI
-RKQ FKDSW HU  YHUVH  LW  KDG W KH QDP H RI ³ 3DSLORQ´ W KH %DEHO RI W KH %LEOH
7KH %DE\ORQ RQ W KH (XSKUDW HV ZDV D FLW \ IRXQGHG E\ $W ODQW HDQV DQG LW  KDG W KH
QDP H RI W KH P RW KHU FLW \    3DSLORQ OLW HUDOO\ P HDQV )DW KHUODQG QDP H\ SDSD 
SRSH IDW KHU DQG LRQ  FRXQW U\ ODQG  :H ZLOO EULQJ KHUH SURRI RI W KLV

$FFRUGLQJW R0H[LFDQVRXUFHVW KHP HW URSROLVRQ$W ODQW LVZDVQDP HG³ 7KXOD´W KH

³ ODVW  7KXOH´  RI W KH *HUP DQLF DQG *UHHN W UDGLW LRQV  7KH ZRUG ³ 7KXOH´  P HDQV
YDOOH\ ³ 7DO´ DQGP RXQW DLQHTXDOO\DFFRUGLQJW RW KHODZRISRODULW \ZKLFKFRXQW V
IRU DOO OLQJXLVW LF FRQFHSW V  , Q W KLV FDVH YDOOH\ LV W KH VHSDU DW LRQ EHW ZHHQ W ZR
KHLJKW VLQ*HUP DQGLDOHFW VW LOO³ 7XO´ RU³ 7RO´DORZSODFHZ KLOH³ 7HLO´$UDELFKLOO
'DOOH KXP S EXP S  VLJQLILHV W KH RSSRVLW H W KH P RXQW DLQ RU KLJK SODFH  7KH
QDP H RI W KH ³ +RHK 7ZLHO´  P D\ ILQG DQ H[SODQDW LRQ KHUH DV EHLQJ DQ DQFLHQW
FXOW LVK SODFH RI W KDW  GDW HV EDFN W R W KH W LP H RI $W ODQW LV  (QJOLVK ³ W R GZHOO´  OLNHO\
LVDOVRFRQQHFW HGZLW KW KHZRUGIRUP RXQW DLQDQGYDOOH\EHFDXVHHYHU\IRUW LILHG
GZHOOLQJ FRQVLVW HG RI W UHQFK DQG W KH DUW LILFLDO ³ P RXQW DLQ´  W KDW  ZDV P DGH RI W KH
(DUW K RI W KH W UHQFK  ³ %HUJ´  P RXQW DLQ  LV W KH UHYHUVHG RI ³ *UDE´  W RP E 


2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

7KH FLW \ 7KXOD LQ 0H[LFR LV W R YLHZ DV D FRORQ\ RI W KH ³ 8OW LP D 7KXOH´  W KH VDP H
ZD\DVW KH%DE\ORQRQW KHULYHU(XSKUDW HVLVDFRORQ\RI3DSLORQW KHUHIRUHRIW KH
7KXOH  :H FDQ DVVXP H IRU VXUH W KDW  W KH P HW URSROLV KDG P DQ\ QDP HV DP RQJ
W KRVH FHU W DLQO\  W KH QDP H RI 7U RM D EHFDXVH RI W KH W KU HHIROG DU U DQJHP HQW  RI
ZDW HU DQG(DUW KULQJV, QW KLVP HW URSROLVZHILQGW KHP RW KHU FLW \RIW KH$W ODQW HDQ
$U\DQ FXOW XUH W KDW  KDV VSUHDG DOO RYHU W KH (DUW K

$W ODQW LV W RR OLW HUDOO\ P HDQV IDW KHUODQG  7KH ZRUG IRUP DW LRQV ZLW K ³ DW O´  LQ W KH
DQFLHQW $P HULFDSRLQW W RZDUGVW KHIDW KHUW KH³ ROGRQH´  $W W DLVDZRUGVLJQLI\LLQJ
IDW KHU  W KDW  FDQ EH IRXQG LQ DOP RVW  DOO ODQJXDJHV  :LW K ³$W W D XQVDU ´  :XOILOD
EHJLQVKLVW UDQVODW LRQRIW KH³ RXU)DW KHU ´  W KH/RUG¶VSUD\HU LQW R*RW KLFODQJXDJH
7KH Z RU GV ³$W W D ODQG´  DQG 3DSL ORQ W  $W ODQW LV DQG 3DSLORQ P HDQ W KHU HIRU H
ERW K W KH ³ IDW KHUODQG´  DQG GHW HUP LQH FOHDUO\ W KDW  W KLV IDW KHUODQG LV W KH ODQG RI
RULJLQRIDZLGHVSUHDGUDFLDOFXOW XUH7KH*UHHNDXW KRUVFDOOW KH%DE\ORQRQW KH
(XSKUDW HV RIW HQ DOVR &KDOGHD  7KLV ZRXOG EH XQLP SRUW DQW  LI W KLV IDFW  GLG QRW
EULQJW KLV%DE\ORQLQGHSHQGHQF\RIW KH$W ODQW HDQ%HFDXVHW KH&KDOGHDQVKDYH
W KHLU QDP H IURP  W KH &DOHGRQLDQV W KH ROG QDP H RI W KH 6FRW W LVK W KH 6NRW KV W KH
*RW KV  , Q W KH FRXQW U\ RI W KH &DOHGRQLDQV ZH VHH VSUHDG W KH ILU VW  &KULVW LDQLW \ RI
W KH &KDOGHDQV DFURVV 0LGGOH (XURSH VW LOO EHIRUH W KH 5RP DQ &KULVW LDQ P LVVLRQ

&XOGHHU V P HDQV W KH RQHV W KDW  DU H FRQQHFW HG Z LW K *RG FRQQHFW HG Z LW K W KDW
ZKLFK LV HW HUQDO E\ P HDQV RI W KH FXOW   , Q W KH ZRUG ³ &XOGHHU´  DQG ³ &DOHGRQ´  RU
³ &KDOGHD´ W KHURRW IRUW KHZRUGDQGFRQFHSW RIFXOW XUH6R$W ODQW LVZDVW UXO\W KH
³ IDW KHU ODQG´  W KH RU LJLQ RI W KH FDU U LHU V RI ³ FXOW XU H  W KH $W ODQW HDQ &XOGHDQV
&DOHGRQLDOV &KDOGHDQV

7KH UHYHODW LRQV W KDW  P D\ KDYH DQ LP P HGLDW H HIIHFW  KHUH ZLOO EH FRQQHFW HG ZLW K
RW KHU IDFW V LQ W KH FRXUVH RI RXU IXUW KHU REVHUYDW LRQV DQG DQDO\VHV

, W LVTXLW HVW UDQJHW KDW QRERG\\HW W RRNW KHSDLQW RH[DP LQHP RUHW KRURXJKO\W KH
SDVVDJHV LQ W KH %LEOH LQ UHIHUHQFH W R W KH ³ KRO\ FLW \ RI JRG´  7KH\ ZRXOG KDYH
IRXQG RXW  W KDW  W KH ³ KRO\ FLW \ LQ W KH P LGVW  RI W KH VHD´  +HV      ³ RQ
P DQ\ ZDW HUV´  5HY -RKQ   ³ EHW ZHHQ W ZR VHDV´  'DQ    ³ QH[W  W R W KH
P DQ\LVODQGVLQW KHVHD´³ LQW KHJDUGHQRIM R\RI*RG´³ ZLW KW KHIRXQW DLQRI*RG´
+HV  3V    ³ ZLW K W KH YDOXHG KRO\ P RXQW DLQ RI *RG EHW Z HHQ W ZR VHDV´
'DQ ³ ZLW KW KHERUGHUVLQW KHVHD´  +HV FDQQHYHUEH-HUXVDOHP LQ
&DQDDQEHFDXVHW KHLUIRXQW DLQJDUGHQRIM R\LVODQGVZDW HUDQGVHDDUHP LVVLQJ
3HRSOH VKRXOG KDYH QRW LFHG LP P HGLDW HO\ W KDW  W KH GHVFULSW LRQ RI W KH KLJK ³ KRO\
P RXQW DLQ RI *RG´  ³ LQ W KH P LGGOH RI W KH VHD DQG RQ W KH P DQ\ ZDW HUV´  FDQQRW  EH
ILW  W R W KH P RXQW DLQ RI =LRQ EXW  P RUH VR UHODW H W R W KH FDSLW DO RI $W ODQW LV


2OG*HUP DQ³ DOW ´
 

7KLVIDUZHIROORZHGW KH$W ODQW HDQW UDGLW LRQ, VQ¶W LW FRQVSLFXRXVW KDW W KH*UHHNV
EHOLHYH W KDW  W KH GZHOOLQJ RI W KH 6XQ JRG LV LQ W KH :HVW "  %UDYH SUH 9LNLQJV W KH
EXLOGHUV RI W KH 'ROP HQ P RYHG DORQJ W KH $W ODQW LF DQG 0HGLW HUUDQHDQ FRDVW V
RW KHUV P RYHG W R *UHHFH IURP  *HUP DQLD  2USKHXV $SROOR DQG W KH 0XVHV FRP H
W R W KHP  ZLW K W KH 7KUDFLDQV  7KH QLQH 0XVHV RI $SROOR FRUUHVSRQG W R W KH QLQH
P RW KHUVZKRDUHVLVW HUVRIW KH1RUGLF+HLP GDOOW KHZKLW HVW RQHRIW KH$HVLUZKR
FOHDUO\ LV W KH JRG RI OLJKW  DQG ILUH DV ZKLFK $SROOR SUHVHQW V KLP VHOI  7KH ROGHVW
FXOW  LV W KH ZRUVKLS RI W KH 6XQ DV D V\P ERO RI 'LYLQH RP QLSRW HQFH  )URP  QLQH
W \SHV RI ZRRG W KH VDFUHG ILUH ZDV OLW  W KUHH W LP HV W KUHH W KH M RLQHG IODP H JDYH
ELU W K W R +HLP GDOO  W KH W U HH W KDW  JDY H ELU W K W R W KH ILU H DU H VLVW HU V  W KH QLQH
P RW KHU V

%RUQ ZDV LQ W KH EHJLQQLQJ RI W LP HV

)URP 8U SRZHUDQGGLYLQHRULJLQ
1LQH JLDQW  JLUOV DQ W KH HGJH RI W KH (DUW K
*DYH ELUW K W R W KH P DQ ZKR ZDV IDP RXV IRU KLV DUP V
'UXQNHQQHVV JDYH ELUW K W R KLP  UREEHU\ JDYH ELUW K W R KLP 
+XUU\ JDYH ELUW K W R KLP  'HSW K JDYH ELUW K W R KLP 
3DLQ JDYH ELUW K W R KLP  /XVW  JDYH ELUW K W R KLP 
:DYH :ROI DQG W KH , F\ IORRG
7KH (DUW K QXUVHG KLP  ZLW K KHU RZQ SRZHU
7KH LFH FROG VHD DQG W KH UD\V RI W KH 6XQ
7KH 2QH ZDV ERUQ KLJKHU W KDQ DOO
$V UXOHU VR W KH\ VDLG KH ZRXOG EH W KH KLJKHVW
$QG NLQ W R DOO IRON DV FODQ
%XW  W KHQ ZKHQ DQRW KHU RQH FRP HV VW LOO JUHDW HU W KDQ KLP 
1HYHU ZRXOG ,  GDUH W R QDP H KLV QDP H
)HZ RQO\ DUH FDSDEOH W R VHH IXUW KHU
7KDQ ZKHQ :RGDQ¶V FRP EDW  ZLW K W KH ZRUOG ZXOI VW DUW V 
7KHQ W R W KH VN\ W KH VHD ULVHV LQ D VW RUP 
7KH ODQGV ZLOO VLQN W KH DLU ZLOO YDQLVK
2QO\ P DVVHV RI VQRZ ZKLUO LQ W KH VKDUS ZLQG
%XW  W KH ZHDW KHU HQGV DFFRUGLQJ W R HW HUQDO FRXQFLO (GGD

'DUN P HP RULHV RI W KH +\SHUERUHDQV DQG W KHLU KDSS\ GD\V NHSW  RQ OLYLQJ IRU D
ORQJW LP H7KHW ULSRI+HUFXOHVW RW KHJDUGHQVRIW KH+HVSHULGLQVJRHV1RUW KZHVW
DFFRUGLQJ W R $LVFK\ORV DQG $SROORGRU  7KH OLHV RI W KH 3KRHQLFLDQV DV ZHOO DV W KH
ODW HUOLHVRIW KHFKXUFKFRQW ULEXW HGW RFRQIXVLRQLQW KHVFLHQFHRIKLVW RU\$FFRUGLQJ
W R +HURGRW XV W KH +\SHUERUHDQV VHQW  ILYH EHDXW LIXO \RXQJVW HUV DQG W ZR YLUJLQV
ZLW K JLIW V W R 'HORV EHFDXVH $SROOR P RYHG DZD\ IURP  W KHP  W R W KH 6RXW KHDVW  LQ
ROG W LP HV  7KH\ RULJLQDW HG IURP  W KH ROGHVW  EORRG RI DOO SHRSOHV DQG W KH\ KDYH
IRXQGHG W KH FXOW V RI 'HOKL DQG 'HORV  7KDW  W KH\ DOVR IRXQGHG W KH FXOW  RI 'HOKL
LQ, QGLDLVP HQW LRQHGKHUHRQW KHVLGHLQRUGHUW RVKRZW KHODUJHFRQW H[W 7KH\
ZRUVKLSSHG W KH HP EDVVLHV W KH RQH H\HG JRG  7KH\ EURXJKW  GLUHFW LYHV DERXW
W KHRUDFOHDQGW KHVHUYLFHW R*RGDQGZLW KW KDW W KH\VKRZW KDW DW W KDW W LP HW KHUH
ZDV VW LOO D ZRUOG JRYHUQP HQW  RI D VSLULW XDO QDW XUH LQ W KH 1RUW K LH D W \SH RI
$U\DQ SDSDF\
 

7KH *HUP DQLF SHRSOHV DFFRUGLQJ W R 7DFLW XV W KLQN RI W KHP VHOYHV DV DQ 8U IRON
+HW KLQNVRIW KHP DVHTXDOVW RKLP VHOIDQRW KHUSRLQW HUW RW KHVRXUFHRISHRSOHV
LQW KH1RUW K7KH*HUP DQVNQRZRIW KHLUDUULYDORQVKLSVIURP W KH:HVW HUQVHD
6W DW HP HQW VOLNHW KDW RQHVKRXOGEHDFFHSW HGLQLW VP HDQLQJQRW VXSSUHVVHGDQG
LJQRUHG VLQFH VXFK VW DW HP HQW V VKRZ W KH IDFW  W KDW  HYHU\W KLQJ FRP HV IURP  W KH
:HVW IURP W KHLVODQGRI+HOLRVW KHLVODQGRI$W ODQW LV7KLVZDVFRP HVW KHW ULDV
W KH W ULQLW \ W KH W KUHH ULQJV RI ZDW HU DURXQG W KH FDSLW DO RI $W ODQW LV W KH W KUHH
VW HSSHG 7LDUD FURZQ RI W KH SRSH W KH 7URM D W KH 0LW UD IURP  $W ODQW LV DQG QRW
IURP  W KH (DVW  ZKHUH QHYHU W KH ³ W KUHH´  ZDV ERUQ    7KHUHIRUH ³ &KULVW LDQLW \´
FRP HVIURP W KH1RUW KDQGDIW HUW KH1RUW KLW FDP HIURP W KH:HVW IURP $W ODQW LV
6W LOOW RGD\W KHUHDUHZRRGHQFKXUFKHVZLW KW KUHHQDYHVLQ6FDQGLQDYLDZKLFKDUH
8U LP DJHVRIW KH³ &KULVW LDQ´ KRXVHRIJRGDQGODW HURIW KHURP DQVW RQHEXLOGLQJV
W KDW  ULJKW IXOO\ DUH 1RUGLF VW \OH DQG VKRXOG DOVR EH FDOOHG W KDW  ZD\  

*HRORJLVW V SXW  ZRUOG KLVW RU\ IXUW KHU DQG IXUW KHU LQW R W KH SDVW  FRXQW LQJ ELOOLRQV
RI \HDUV ZKLOH W KH SKLORORJLVW V DQG P \W KRORJLVW  JR W KH RW KHU ZD\ W KH SXW  W KH
RULJLQRIP \W KVOHJHQGVDQGUHOLJLRQVODW HUDQGODW HU7KH\DUHODFNLQJDIHHOLQJ
IRUW LP HW KH\ODFNLQKHULW HGP HP RU\DQGW KH\KDYHDEVROXW HO\QRUHVSHFW IRUW KH
8U ODQJXDJHRIW KHSLFW XUHVRIP \W KV7KHUHYHODW LRQRI1RUGLF *HUP DQLFP \VW HULHV
W XU QV W R W KH Y LVLRQ RI W KH VHHU W RZDU GV W KH ³ VDFU HG FKLOGU HQ´  RI W KH FODQ RI
+HLP GDOO´:KRLVLQFDSDEOHRIXQGHUVW DQGLQJKHUODQJXDJHFDQQRW M XGJHKHUROG
DJH  7KH :DOD W KH ZLVGRP  RI ZKLFK UHDFKHV EDFN LQW R W KH HUD RI W KH JLDQW V
W UDQVIHUV W R XV W KH P \VW HU\ RI W KH ZRUG RI W KH 8U W LP HV  :KDW  VKH VD\V SURYHV
W R EH FDUULHU RI W KH ZRUOG P HP RU\

7KH $U\DQ ZDV LQ D IRUELGGLQJ QDW XUH GULYHQ DZD\ IURP  KLV RULJLQDO SDUDGLVH LQ
W KHODQGRIW KHSROHW KH$ SRO ORVRIW KH+\SHERUHDQ³ LQZKLFKW KHVXQGLGQRW
VHW W OH´ ZKHUH KH ZDV H[SRVHG W R P DQ\ GDQJHUV  )URP  W KLV VLW XDW LRQ KH KDV
W DNHQ W KH ILUVW  VW HS W R ZKDW  ZH VHH HYROYH W R FXOW XUH  , Q W KLV W DVN KH ZDV
VXSSRU W HG E\  KLV RXW VW DQGLQJ U DFLDO TXDOLW LHV   :KHQ KLV EORRG EHJDQ W R EH
DEVRUEHG E\ W KH ORZHU UDFHV FXOW XUH GHJHQHUDW HG W R FLYLOL]DW LRQ

$W  W KH HQG RI W KH LFH DJH W KH YDULRXV SDUW V RI W KH IRON OHIW  W KH VHW W OHP HQW V W KDW
KDYHEHFRP HW RRRYHUFURZGHGDQGP RYHGLQDOOGLUHFW LRQVW RW KH6RXW K(DVW DQG
:HVW  LQW R LFH IUHH DUHDV  'XULQJ W KLV W LP H GHILQLW HO\ QRW  P XFK ODW HU W KH ILUVW
$U\DQVFDP HRQW KHLUP LJUDW LRQVW R, QGLD7KHUHW KH\KDYHODLGW KHJURXQGW RW KH
, QGR $U\DQUDFHEUDQFKDQGFRQVHTXHQW O\W RDKLJKDQGUHP DUNDEOHFXOW XUH2Q
W KHLU  VHDU FK IRU  QHZ  OLY LQJ VSDFHV RW KHU  SDU W V RI W KH IRON  DU U LY HG LQ 3HU VLD

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

3DOHVW LQH 0HVRSRW DP LD $VLD 0LQRU *UHHFH , W DO\ 6SDLQ DQG HYHQ 1RUW K $IULFD
DQG W KH\ SXW  W KH VW DP S RI W KHLU EHLQJ DQG W KHLU RXW VW DQGLQJ FXOW XUH XSRQ W KH
VXEM XJDW HGQDW LYHSRSXODW LRQV(YHQZKHUHW KHW UDFHVRIW KHLU UDFHDQGRIW KHLU
ZRUNKDYHYDQLVKHGRYHUW LP HW KHLUODQJXDJHZDVNHSW DOLYHW KU RXJKRXW P LOOHQQLD
LQ SRSXODW LRQV ZKR ZHUH IRUHLJQ W R W KHLU UDFH

, QQHU DQG (DVW HUQ $VLD W RR KDG P LJUDW LRQV RI $U\DQV LQ HDUOLHVW  W LP HV

7R W K H $U \ DQ  P LJU DW LRQ V W K DW  DU H N Q RZ Q  I U RP  K LVW RU LF W LP HV EHORQ JHG W K H

LP P LJUDW LRQRIHDUO\*UHHNVLQW R*UHHFHDQGODW HUW KH'RULDQVZ KRZHUHIROORZHUV
VR W R VD\ RI W KH W ULEHV ZKR VHW W OHG W KHUH EHIRUH W KHP   7KH\ ZHUH W KHUH DV D
FRQTXHURUVFODVVRYHUW KHQRQ $U\DQRULJLQDOQDW LYHVW KHUHQDP HO\W KH3HODVJLDQV
7KLV IDFW  UHP DLQHG LQ W KH P HP RU\ RI W KH DQFLHQW  *UHHNV DV P DQ\ W HVW LP RQLDOV
IU RP  W KDW  W LP H SU RY H  7KH JU HDW  P LJU DW LRQ Z DV W KH ODVW  RI W KHVH U HSHDW LQJ
P LJUDW LRQVRISHRSOHVZLW KZKLFKW KH$U\DQUDFHFRQFOXGHGW KHLUH[SDQVLRQLQW R
(XURSH DQG :HVW HUQ $VLD

&DQ ZH UHJDUG DOO SHRSOHV ZKR VSHDN DQ $U\DQ ODQJXDJH DV $U\DQV"  1R   %XW
IURP  W KLV ZH FDQ VHH W KDW  $U\DQV ZHUH W KH FRQTXHULQJ FODVV LQ DQ\ RQH RI W KH
FRXQW ULHV ZKHUH W KH\ VSHDN DQ $U\DQ ODQJXDJH LQ RXU GD\V RI KDY H VSRNHQ RQH
LQ W KH SDVW  VXFK DV LQ 3HUVLD $UP HQLD RU *UHHFH  0RVW  RI W KH W LP H W KHUH LV QR
$U\DQ)RONIUDJP HQW OHIW DQ\P RUH%HFDXVHRIW KHLUVP DOOQXP EHUVW KH\YDQLVKHG
LQ  W K H Q DW LY H S RS X ODW LRQ   Z K HU H W K HU H Z HU H Q R VW U LFW  ODZ V DJ DLQ VW  U DFLDO
K\EULGL]DW LRQVVXFKDVLQ, QGLD(YHQQRW W KHUHW KHVORZEOHHGLQJW RGHDW KRIW KH
$U\DQ FRQTXHURUV FRXOG EH SUHVHQW HG LI QRW  QHZ P LJUDW LRQV KDSSHQHG IURP  W KH
W U LEDO VHDW V

:LW K W KH VLQNLQJ RI W KH $U\DQ EORRG KDSSHQHG DOVR D FXOW XUDO UHJUHVVLRQ DOO W KH
Z D\  W R W RW DO FROODS VH RI  Z K ROH Q DW LRQ V DQ G  I RU P HU O\  S RZ HU I X O DQ G  I HU W LOH
SRSXODW LRQV  7KLV UHJUHVVLRQ KDSSHQHG DOUHDG\ HDUO\ LQ 0HVRSRW DP LD *UHHFH
$VLD 0LQRU 3HUVLD DQG 6\ULD D ELW  ODW HU LQ W KH $U\DQ LQIOXHQFHG SHRSOHV RI , W DO\
DQG6SDLQ7KLVH[SODLQVW KDW VLQFHW KHHQGRIDQW LTXLW \W KHFXOW XUDODQGVSLULW XDO
FHQW HUP RYHGIURP W KH0HGLW HUUDQHDQW R0LGGOHDQG1RUW KHUQ(XURSHW KHSUHVHQW
P DLQ ODQG RI W KH $U\DQ UDFH

7KLV ZD\ ZH FDQ DOVR H[SODLQ VRP H UHP DUNDEOH UHP DLQGHUV RI W KH $U\DQ UDFH LQ
UHP RW H DUHDV W KDW  DUH GLIILFXOW  W R DFFHVV IRU LQVW DQFH LQ W KH %DONDQ DQG DOVR LQ
 

DUHDVZKHUHW KH$U\DQODQJXDJHKDGW RFHGHDQRW KHUODQJXDJHORQJDJRVXFKDV

LQ $QDW ROLD , QGLD &KLQD HYHQ LQ $P HULFD

)URP  W KH IRXU H[SHGLW LRQV RI *UQZHGHO DQG /H &RJ LQ (DVW HUQ 7XUNLVW DQ LQ W KH
RDVLV FLW LHV RI .XW VFKD DQG 7XUIDQ ZH IRXQG RXW  DERXW  D ELW  RI $U\DQ *HUP DQLF
IRON KLVW RU\ LQ W KH FHQW UDO $VLDW LF W KHDW HU RI DFW LRQ  7KH DULVW RFUDW LF IRXQGHUV
W K DW  DU H RQ  W K H Z DOO SDLQ W LQ JV DU H $U \DQ V EHORQ JLQ J W R W K H 7RFK DU HV  Z K R
LP P LJUDW HG IURP  W KH 1RUW K  7KHLU ODQJXDJH SXW V W KHP  LQW R W KH FDW HJRU\ RI W KH
(XURSHDQ , QGR *HUP DQLF W ULEHV  7KH\ KDYH UHG EORQG KDLU EOXH H\HV DQG IXOO\
*HUP DQLF IDFLDO IHDW XUHV  7R W KLV FRP H RW KHU GHW DLOV W KDW  DUH RXW ULJKW  DP D]LQJ
DW  W KH ILU VW  JOLP SVH   7KHVH GXN HV DQG DU LVW RFU DW V U HP LQG XV Y LY LGO\  RI W KH
(XURSHDQDUHDRINQLJKW V7KHP HQDSSHDULQJUDQGDUP V FRDW VW KHFROODUEDFN
W KH FUHVW  RI W KH KHOP HW  RQ W KH KHDG W KH VFDOHG DUP RU RQ W KH ERG\ W KH OHJV LQ
W KH DUP RU RU ORQJ ERRW V W KH ORQJ VW UDLJKW  VZRUGV ZLW K FURVV VKDSHG KDQGOHV LQ
W KHP HW DOEHOW 2QW KHKRUVHW KH\KDYHERZDQGDUURZVDQGW KHORQJODQFHZLW K
W KH IODJ RQ LW   %HVLGHV W KHP  DUH GDP HV LQ H[SHQVLYH FORW KLQJ ZLW K FRUVHW V W KDW
KDYHOLW W OHEHOOVDW W DFKHGDQGDORQJUREH)URP ZKHUHGRW KHVH, QGR *HUP DQLF
W ULEHV W KDW  ZHUH DW  W KH EHJLQQLQJ RI &KULVW LDQ W LP HV LQ W KH 1RU W K LQ W KH VW HSSHV
RIW RGD\¶V5XVVLDKDYHW KHLUFXOW XUHDQGW KHLUVFULSW ":KHUHLVW KHOLQNEHW ZHHQ
DUP VDQGFORW KLQJRIW KH*HUP DQLFUXOHUVLQ.XW VFKDDQGW KHNQLJKW VRI&KULVW LDQ
(XURSH"  7KHUH LV D KXJH DP RXQW  RI HQLJP DV W KDW  W KH ILQGLQJV RI W KH *HUP DQ
7XUID H[SHGLW LRQ SRVH W R W KH UHVHDUFK RI FXOW XUDO KLVW RU\  

7KH QDP HV 7XUDQ 7XUNLVW DQ $UDO DQG $OW DL VW LOO VKRZ FOHDUO\ W KH $U\DQ RULJLQ
)URP W KH$UDOW RW KHODNH%DLNDODQGIXUW KHURYHUW KH0DQFKXULDDQG.RUHDZDYHV
RI$U\DQP LJUDW LRQFDP HDOOW KHZD\W R-DSDQ7KHUHW RRZHFDQILQGUHP DLQGHUV
LQ W KH W DOOHU DQG KLJKHU G\QDVW LHV RI OHDGHUV  3HRSOH ZRXOG QRW  DVN DV P XFK DV
W KH\GRLIW KH\NQHZP RUHDERXW W KHGLVW ULEXW LRQRI$U\DQEORRGLQW KHSDVW DQG
HYHQ VW LOO GXULQJ W KH SUHVHQW  W LP HV  , QGHHG W KHUH LV VW LOO D ORW  P RUH $U\DQ EORRG
RQ (DUW K W KDQ ZKDW  VFKRODUV RI W KLV GLVFLSOLQH ZRXOG DVVXP H  $OO RI $VLD ZDV
VHW W OHGDQGFRQTXHUHGE\$U\DQVDOUHDG\LQSUHKLVW RULFW LP HV$OORIW KHFXOW XUHV
LQ W KH (DVW  GHVFHQG IU RP  $U \DQ OHDGHU V  7KH 0DQFKX P HDQV W KH RQHV Z KR
GHVFHQG IURP  W KH P HQ $U\DQ RQHV RI FRXUVH   , QGHHG W KH 0DQFKX DUH W DOOHU
DQGOLJKW HUW KDQW KH&KLQHVHVW LOOLQRXUGD\V , Q)XUKP DQQ¶V³ /DQGGHU0LW W H´
,  KDYH VHHQ SLFW XUHV RI W HP SOH VW DW XHV W KDW  UHSUHVHQW  OHDGHUV DQG SULHVW V RI
HDUO\ W LP HV ZKLFK VKRZ  $U\DQ EXLOG Z LW KRXW  H[FHSW LRQ DQG Z KLFK FDQQRW  EH
GLVW LQJXLVKHG IU RP  W KH EHVW  *HU P DQLF QREOH VW DW XU HV  $FFRU GLQJ W R &KLQHVH
$QQDOV VW LOO DERXW   EFH ZHUH SHRSOH ZLW K EORQG KDLU DQG RI W DOO VW DW XUH RQ
W KH :HVW HUQ ERUGHUV RI W KH HP SLUH    , Q W KH KLJKODQGV RI &KLQD DQG , QGLD DUH
UHP DLQGHUV RI EORQG SHRSOH VW LOO W RGD\ DV ZHOO DV LQ W KH &DXFDVXV 0RXQW DLQV
7KH.XUGVKDYHVW LOODVLJQLILFDQW $U\DQHOHP HQW DP RQJW KHLUSHRSOH'XULQJW KH


2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG

9HU\UHFHQW H[FDYDW LRQVSURYHW KDW  SRLQW 
 

ZDU LQ W KH $UDELDQ GHVHUW  VRXW K RI W KH 0DDQ ,  KDYH QHJRW LDW HG Z LW K D %HGRXLQ
ZKR KDG D UHG IXOO EHDUG DQG ZKR KDG EOXH H\HV D UDFH OHIW  RYHU RI IRUP HU
FRQTXHU RU V DP RQJ W KRVH SU HVHQW  GD\ 6HP LW LF %HGRXLQV Z LW KRXW  FXOW XU H Z KR
QHYHU EXLOW  D KRXVH W KHP VHOYHV DQG ZKR QHYHU IRUJHG D ZHDSRQ  

, Q W KH \HDU  ,  SDUW LFLSDW HG LQ W KH FDSW XUH RI URXJKO\  &RVVDFNV RI W KH
7XVHP D\D GLYLVLRQ  $OO RI W KHP  ORRNHG OLNH EURW KHUV VDP H EHDXW \ QRELOLW \ DQG
KHLJKW ZLW KORQJQDUURZIDFHVDVZHILQGW KHP UDW KHUVHOGRP DP RQJW KHRIILFHUV
RIW KH*HUP DQDUP \EORQGEOXHH\HGW DOOHUW KDQFP W KHUHIRUHLGHDO$U\DQ
UDFH LGROV  ,  KDG W KH RSSRUW XQLW \ W R W DON H[W HQVLYHO\ ZLW K W KH OHDGLQJ RIILFHU LQ
W KH FKLYDOHUHVTXH ZD\ DV XVXDO DP RQJ $U\DQ SHRSOH HYHQ LQ ZDU DQG KH FRXOG
DVVXUHP H W KDW LQ KLV KRP HEHW ZHHQ8UDO DQG &DVSLDQ 6HD DUH P DQ\ SHRSOHV RI
W KHLU W \SH

7KH8UDO&RVVDFNVDUHHTXDOO\RIW DOOVW DW XUHZLW KEDODQFHGVKDSHORQJIDFHDQG

GXULQJW KHVXP P HURIOLJKW UHG EURZQFRORURIVNLQ:HGRQRW QHHGW RZRUU\W KDW
VXFK UDFH UHP DLQGHUV DV W KH P DQ\ &RVVDFN W ULEHV JR XQGHU LQ W KH ZRUOG RI W KH
ORZHU UDFHV DV ORQJ DV W KH\ ZLOO QRW  EH YLFW LP V RI ³ FLYLOL]DW LRQ´ EXW  DV ULGHU DQG
IDUP HU SHRSOH NHHS W KHLU KHDOW K\ VNLOOV DQG GULYHV

$Q$U\DQFRRSHUDW LRQDOORYHUW KHZRUOGLQRUGHUW RNHHSW KHLQKHULW HGW UDLW VLVD

JUHDW  JRDO   +HUH ZH FDQ VW LOO FRXQW  RQ XQVXVSHFW HG KHOS  , W  Z DV DOZD\V GXP E
W R W DON DERXW  D W RW DO GHFOLQH RI W KH :HVW  RU RI W KH 0LGGOH (DVW   7KH JHQHUDO
URW W LQJDZD\LQORZHUUDFHVFDQQRW GHFHLYHW KHSHUVRQZLW KLQVLJKW W KDW W KHVSLULW
RIW KHFUHDW RUUDFHZLOODZDNHQDJDLQW RRUGHULQJGHHGV$QGLQW KLVW LP HZHDUH
OLY LQJ  2XU  ³ QHLJKERU ´  LV QRW  DQ\  VXEKXP DQ LQ W KH SDLQIXO QDU U RZ QHVV RI D
³ IDW KHUODQG´EXW LQW KLVFDVHHYHQDIRUHLJQ&RVVDFNZKROLYHVIDUDZD\EHFDXVH
KHP HDQVP RUHIRUW KHP DLQW DLQLQJRIP RUDOVLQW KHIXW XUHW KHQW KHJRGOHVVGDUN
³ *HUP DQ´  P DVVHV LQ W KH ELJ FLW LHV

:H DUH OLYLQJ XQGHU W KH LOOXVLRQ W KDW  HYHU\W KLQJ ZDV GLVFRYHUHG LQ W KH P RGHUQ
W LP HV  , Q W UXW K DOO W HFKQLFDO DFKLHYHP HQW V Z HUH GLVFRYHUHG RQ W KLV SODQHW  D
VHFRQGW LP HDQHZSRVVLEO\HYHQP RUHRIW HQ7KH(J\SW LDQVZHUHIDUW KHUDKHDG
LQ$VW URQRP \DQGP DW KHP DW LFVW KDQZHDUHW KH\NQHZHOHFW ULFLW \DQGW KH\XVHG
LW , QW KHLUW RP EVFRQGXFW RUVRIFRSSHUZLUHZHUHGLVFRYHUHGW KDW FRXOGRQO\KDYH
KDG VHUYHG SUDFW LFDO SXUSRVHV RI W KDW  NLQG  7KH URFN SDLQW LQJV RI %RKXVOlQ W HOO
XV XQHTXLYRFDOO\ DERXW  DQ $U\DQ QDYLJDW LRQ FXOW XUH W KDW  UHDFKHG DURXQG W KH


2PLWWHG
 

(DUW KDW OHDVW \HDUVDJRSRVVLEO\HYHQ\HDUVDJR7KHS\UDP LGV

LQ(J\SW RQ-DYDDQGLQ0H[LFRHYROYHGIURP W KHVDP HVW \OHDQGDW DSSUR[LP DW HO\
W KH VDP H W LP H   VKRZ FXOW XUDO DQG UDFLDO FRQQHFW LRQV EHW ZHHQ W KHVH FRQW LQHQW V
W KDW ODW HUVHSDUDW HGDJDLQDVIDUDVZRUOGW UDYHORUW KHODFNW KHUHRILVFRQFHUQHG
7KH (DVW HU , VODQG LQ W KH 3DFLILF 2FHDQ KDV VW RQH LQVFULSW LRQV W KDW  DUH DP D]LQJO\
VLP LODU W R W KH 1RUGLF 5XQHV DQG ZKLFK KDYH QR GRXEW  W KH VDP H U DFH DV W KHLU
RULJLQQRW W KHSLW LIXOLQKDELW DQW VRIW RGD\¶V6RXW K6HD2QH UDFHGRP LQDW HGW KH
(DUW K VLQFH W KH ROGHVW  W LP HV DQG KDV GRP LQDW HG LW  LQ W LP HV EHW Z HHQ RYHU DQG
RYHU DJDLQ  , W  LV FOHDU W KDW  W KHVH UXOHUV LQYHQW RUV FRQTXHURUV ZHUH DOZD\V RI
W KH VDP H NLQG  7KH\ ZHUH P HP EHUV RI W KH UDFH RI JRGV ZKLFK VW LOO W RGD\ UXOHV
W KHZRUOGE\P HDQVRILW VJHQLXVHYHQW KRXJKW KHRUGHUZDVRYHUW KURZQE\ORZ
UDFHV  , W  LV W KH VDP H LQ W KH QDW LRQV ZKHUH LW  VW LOO LV P RUH RU OHVV GHFLVLYH DERXW
W KHLU IDW H   W KLV LV W KH 1RUGLF W KH $HVLU W KH $U\DQ UDFH ZKLFK DFFXP XODW HG LQ
W KH 1RUW K RI (XURSH DQG $P HULFD DUH VW LOO W KH RQO\ FDUULHUV RI DOO SRVVLELOLW LHV RI
³ KXP DQ´  GHYHORSP HQW 

7KH (DVW  $VLDW LF FXOW XUHV DUH QR H[FHSW LRQ W R W KLV UXOH  7KH\ DUH FUHDW LRQV RI
$U\DQ FRQTXHURUV DQG LP P LJUDQW V DQG W KH\ P DQDJHG W R NHHS W KHP VHOYHV RQ
URXJKO\W KHVDP HOHYHOIRU\HDUVEHFDXVHW KH0RQJROLDQKHLUVRIW KH$U\DQ
FXOW XUH KDG W LP H DQG SHDFH W R DGDSW  W KLV LQKHULW DQFH W R W KHLU U DFLDO QHHGV  1RW
RQO\DJLJDQW LFVW RQHZDOOSURW HFW HGW KHP IURP IRUHLJQFRQQHFW LRQDQGGHVW UXFW LRQ
IRU FHQW XULHV EXW  DOVR W KH ZDOO RI HTXDO ERGLHV DQG VRXOV   +RZHYHU W KLV UDFH
ZDU QRQ FUHDW LYH LQ W KH GHHSHVW  JURXQG RI W KHLU VRXO  7KH\ KDY H QRW  DGGHG W KH
OHDVW  RI W KHLU RZQ GXULQJ W KLV ORQJ W LP H  


2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 

9
&5($7, 212)+80$16
$1'6$&5, ), &(2)+80$16
<RX  VK RX OG  Q RW  S U R FU HDW H  E X W  X S  FU HDW H FU HDW H LQ  X S Z DU G
GLUHFW LRQ 
1LHW ]VFK H

7KHUHLVQRGRXEW W KDW GXULQJW KH6DFUHG6SULQJW KHUHZHUHFRP EDW V

RI VHOHFW LRQ DP RQJ W KH P DOH DQG IHP DOH \RXW K RI W KH $U\DQV  7KH
³ UXQ IRU W KH EULGH´  RULJLQDOO\ KDSSHQHG QRW  LQ SDLUV EXW  LQ FU RZGV
7KH IDVW HVW  DQG P RVW  VNLOOHG RQHV M RLQHG DV W KH ILUVW  RQHV DW  W KH
JRDO W KDW  Z DV GHP DQGHG Z KLFK Z DV SHU KDSV D VDQFW XDU \  RQ D
P RXQW DLQ  7KH RW KHU SDUW LFLSDQW V SDLUHG XS GHSHQGLQJ RQ W KHLU
DUULYDO DW  W KH JRDO DQG W KHLU VNLOO LQ RYHUFRP LQJ W KH REVW DFOHV

7RGD\¶V KXP DQ KDV D KDUG W LP H W R LP DJLQH W KDW  W KHUH ZDV D W LP H

ZKHQFRQVFLRXVXS EUHHGLQJRIW KHKXP DQEHLQJZDVW KHP DLQJRDO
RI D OHDGHUVKLS  7KURXJKRXW  P DQ\ P LOOHQQLD W KHUH H[LVW HG XQGHU
$U\DQZRUOGJRYHUQP HQW LQVW LW XW LRQVIRUM XVW W KDW SXUSRVHZKLFKLQ
VW ULFW O\RXW OLQHGULW XDOVVHUYHGW KHEUHHGLQJRIW KHKXP DQUDFH:H
KDYHDORW RIFRQFHLW W KDW VXFKFRP SXOVRU\LQVW LW XW LRQVGRQRW H[LVW
DQ\P RUHW KDW IUHHFKRLFHRIVSRXVHVLVRQHRIW KHP RVW LP SRUW DQW
DFK LHY HP HQ W V  DQ G  W K HU HE \  Z H I RU J HW  W K DW  DP RQ J  D K X Q G U HG
P DU U LDJHV W KHU H LV KDU GO\  RQH W KDW  IXOILOOV LW V SXU SRVH SHU IHFW O\
QDP HO\ W KH DFKLHYHP HQW  RI D KHDOW K\ RIIVSULQJ  7KH SHUVRQ ZKR
NQRZVJURVVHVRXW ZKHQVHHLQJW KHFRQW LQXRXVSK\VLFDODQGP RUDO
GHJHQHUDW LRQRIKXP DQNLQGZKLFKDOORZVDOOFULSSOHVVLFNSHU VRQV
LQIHULRUV FULP LQDOV DQG RW KHUZ LVH KDQGLFDSSHG SHRSOH P DUULDJH
DQG XQLQKLELW HG SURFUHDW LRQ

7KHUHVXOW LQLW VKRUUHQGRXVVFRSHLVREYLRXVIRUDQ\SHUVRQZKRLV

FDSDEOH RI M XGJLQJ D VLW XDW LRQ  7KH DSSURDFK RI W KH VXEKXP DQ LV
W KH FRQVHTXHQFH RI VXFK DQW L FXOW XUH

, Q DOO DU HDV RI W KH (DU W K  LQ (XU RSH  $VLD  $IU LFD DQG $P HU LFD
HY HU \ Z K HU H DU H VX FK  VDFU HG  S ODFHV RI  K X P DQ  E U HHG LQ J   VW LOO
UHFRJQL]DEOHLQLW VVKDSHXQOHVVW KH\KDYHEHHQGHVW UR\HGRUZ HUH
EXLOW  RYHU E\ FLW LHV FDVW OHV DQG FKXUFKHV  1DP HV OLNH 3DUDGLVH
 

%DELORQZKLFKP HDQVIDW KHUODQGRUSODFHRIW KHIDW KHUODE\ULQW K7ULEHUJ:DOEXUJ

7URM D QDP HV+DJ SODFHV%DQQ ZRRGV6ZHGLVKHQW UHQFKP HQW VZKLFKDUHDFW XDOO\
6XHELFHQW UHQFKP HQW VLQP RVW FDVHVDQGVKRXOGEHQDP HGDFFRUGLQJO\DOOW KHVH
SRLQW  W RZDUGV ROG JDUGHQV RI EUHHGLQJ  , W  ZDV W KH JUHDW  W LP H RI $U\DQ GRP  RQ
(DUW KDERXW \HDUVDJRZKHQW KHVHLQVW LW XW LRQVZHUHLQKLJKEORRP ZKLFK
EUHG D G\QDVW \ RI KHURHV W KH OLYLQJ ZLW QHVVHV RI ZKLFK DUH VW LOO W KH EHVW  DQG
P RVW EHDXW LIXOKXP DQVRIRXUUDFHHYHQLIW KHUHLVKDUGO\DQ\KXP DQOHIW DP RQJ
XVZKRZRXOGKDYHDOOW KHVHFKDUDFW HULVW LFVLQKLP ZKLFKZHUHFRP P RQSODFHLQ
W KRVH W LP HV

, Q W KH (GGD W KHUH LV VW LOO D P HP RU\ RQ DQ H[DP SOH RI W KLV XS EU HHGLQJ  QDP HO\
W KH SODFH ZKHUH LQ W KH KLVW RU\ RI W KH :lOVXQJLDQV W KH VW DW XUH RI 6LHJIULHG LV
GHVFULEHG

³ +LVKDLUZDVRIUHGEORQGFRORUDQGIDQW DVW LFW RORRNDW W KHEHDUGZDVVKRUW DQG

GHQVHDQGRIW KHVDP HFRORU+HKDGDKLJKQRVHDQGDIXOOVW URQJO\ERQHGIDFH
KLV H\HV ZHUH VR VKDUS W KDW  IHZ RQO\ ULVNHG W R ORRN XQGHU KLV H\HEURZV  +LV
VKRXOGHUV ZHUH VR EURDG DV LI RQH VDZ W KH VKRXOGHUV RI W ZR P HQ  KLV VW DW XUH
ZDV ZHOO P DW FKHG W R KLP  LQ KHLJKW  DQG IXOOQHVV DQG LW  ZDV LQ D ZD\ VR W KDW  LW
KDGDJUHDW HIIHFW RQW KHSHUVRQDVDZKROH$QGW KDW LVDP DUNRIW KHOHQJW KRI
KLVOLIH :KHQKHJLUGHGKLP VHOIZLW KDVZRUGW KDW KDVW KHOHQJW KRIVHYHQVSDQV
DQGKHZDONHGW KURXJKDIXOO\JURZQU\HILHOGW KHERW W RP RIW KHVZRUGW RXFKHG
W KH XSULJKW  HDUV  +LV SRZHU ZDV VW LOO JUHDW HU W KDQ KLV VW DW XUH  +H ZDV VXFK DV
ZLVH P DQ W KDW  KH NQHZ DKHDG W KLQJV W KDW  VW LOO GLG QRW  KDSSHQ  +H ZDV ZHOO
VSRNHQDQGTXLFN ZLW W HGDQGQHYHUEHJDQW RVSHDNDERXW VRP HW KLQJQRUGLGKH
VW RSVSHDNLQJXQW LOHYHU\ERG\ZDVFRQYLQFHGW KDW LW FRXOGQRW EHRW KHUZLVHW KDQ
W KH ZD\ KH W DONHG DERXW  LW   +H ZDV KDSS\ ZKHQ KH FRXOG KHOS KLV SHRSOH DQG
ZKHQ KH SHUIRUP HG JUHDW  GHHGV  1HYHU KH ODFNHG FRXUDJH DQG QHY HU ZDV KH
DIUDLG´

:H XQGHUVW DQG W KDW  DQ\ZKHUH ZKHUH VXFK KXP DQV DUH LGROV W KH P DVV RI W KH
SHRSOH DSSU RDFK KLV LQW HU QDO DQG H[ W HU QDO Y DOXHV  +LJK FXOW XU H DQG KXP DQ
H[LVW HQFH LQ GLJQLW \ LV DQ XQUHDFKDEOH JRDO ZLW KRXW  EUHHGLQJ XS RI KXP DQNLQG
W KDW  \RX VKRXOG NQRZ

)URP W KHVDFUHG³ :DKO %XUJ 1DFKW ´  RIRXULP P HGLDW HDQFHVW RUVZLW KW KH³ :DKO
%XUJ &XOW ZKLFKW KHJRGOLNHG\QDVW LHVRIW KH$U\DQVSLULW XDODQGEORRGDULVW RFUDF\
FUHDW HG EHFDP H W KH VSRRNLQJ RI W KH ³ :DOSXUJLV QLJKW ´ IURP  W KH QREOH ³ +DJH
'LVHQ´ W KH JRGGHVVHV OLYLQJ LQ W KH SODFH RI FDULQJ SURW HFW HG DUHD RI ZRRGV 
'LYLQHORRNLQJKLJKO\GHVLUDEOHVW DW XUHVRIP RVW VDFUHGZRP DQKRRGEHFDP HW KH
³ +D[HQ´ RU³ +H[HQ´  ZLW FKHV RXW RI&KULVW LDQVW XOW LILFDW LRQDQGW KHLUFRQFHDOP HQW
RIW UXW K7KHVH+DJH 'LVHQW KHZLW FKHVZHUHW KRVHW KDW ZHUHH[W HUP LQDW HGE\


 $ U HIHU HQFH W R W KH ³ :DOSXU JLVQDFKW ´  QLJKW  RI :DOSXU JLV  RI W KH Z LW FKHV  Z LW K W KH VHFRQG
P HDQLQJRI³ VHOHFW LRQ FDVW OH QLJKW ´
 

W KH VXEKXP DQ SRZ HU V RI W KH FKXU FK LQ W KH VKDP H RI W KH Z LW FK KXQW V  7KH
³ Z LW FKHV´  Z HU H Z RP HQ Z LW K JU HDW  DELOLW LHV Z LW K W KH JLIW  RI FODLU YR\DQFH DQG
LQGHSHQGHQW VSLULW ZKLFKZDVW KHJUHDW HVW REVW DFOHRIW KHFKXU FKLQW KHLUDW W HP SW V
W R JDJ W KH P LQGV DQG W KH ERGLHV

7KH\ZHUHW KHIROORZHUVRIW KH:DO N\ULHV DZRUGZKLFKW RRLVFRQQHFW HGZLW K

W KH:DO %XJ &XOW 7KH:DON\ULHVEHORQJHGW RW KHVHOHFW HGKLJKEUHGZRP HQRI
W KH*HUP DQVZKRKDGW KHULJKW W RVHOI GHW HUP LQHGFKRLFHRIDVSRXVHDUHP DLQGHU
IURP  W KH W LP H RI P DW ULDUFK\ ZKLFK LQ W KH $U\DQ FXOW XUDO ZRUOG UHP DLQHG DOZD\V
LQIRUFHDQGZKLFKZDVLQW KHVHUYLFHRIDQXS EUHHGLQJ, QGHHGVW LOOLQRXUGD\V
W KHKLJK SRVLW LRQHGZRP DQFKRRVHVKHUVSRXVHE\VHOHFW LQJRQHDP RQJDODUJH
FURZG RI VXLW RUV  0DW ULDUFKDO DQG SDW ULDUFKDO LQVW LW XW LRQV KDG HTXDO VW DQGLQJ LQ
ROG $U\DQ FXOW XUHV  2QO\ ZKHUH W KH EDODQFH RI W KLV UHODW LRQ ZDV GHVW UR\HG E\
UDFLDO W ZLOLJKW  SDW ULDUFK\ RU P DW ULDUFK\ EHFDP H RQH VLGHG

:H FDQ UHDG W KH ZRUG ³ :DO N\ULH´  LQ W ZR ZD\V  )LUVW  DV ³ P LVW UHVV RI FKRLFH´
ZKHQZHUHDG³ .\U ´ RU³ N\UU ´ DVP DVW HURUP LVW UHVV *UHHN.\ULRV ZKLFKZHDUH
FHUW DLQO\ DOORZHG W R GR  .\ULH HOHLVRQ   %XW  ZH FDQ DOVR UHFRJQL]H W KH ZRUG
³ FRP EDW ´  DQG W KHQ UHDG IURP  W KLV W HUP  ³ VHOHFW LRQ E\ P HDQV RI FRP EDW ´  RU ³ W KH
RQHZKRVHOHFW VE\FRP EDW ´EHFDXVH:DOLVROG1RUGLF³ FRP EDW ´  DQGW KH*HUP DQ
.\UHQP HDQVW RVHOHFW VW LOOW RGD\, Q³ .DUHQ´³ NLUUHQ´ LVVW LOOFOHDUO\DQDVSHFW RI
VHOHFW LRQ IRU EUHHGLQJ ZKLFK VKRZV W KDW  W KH :DON\ULH ZD\ W KH Z RP DQ RI KLJK
EUHHG ZKR JDYH W KHLU FKLOGUHQ W R W KH P RVW  EHDXW LIXO LQW HOOLJHQW  DQG VW URQJHVW
KHURHV ³ ZKR FRXOG QRW  NQRZ IHDU ´

7ZR SDVVDJHV LQ W KH (GGD DUH SURRI KHUH RQH IURP  W KH ZRQGHUIXO ³ +HOJH VRQJ´
ZKHUHW KH:DON\ULH6LJUXQFRP HVW KURXJKW KHDLUW RKHOS+HOJHDQGVHOHFW VKLP
W RW KHQEHKHUKXVEDQG:HLP P HGLDW HO\W KLQNKHUHDERXW W KHW UDGLW LRQFRQFHUQLQJ
ZLW FKHV ZKR W RR KDYH W KH VNLOO W R IO\ W KURXJK W KH DLU RQ W KH %URRP  ³ %HVHQ´
ZKLFKP HDQV³ NDOLVK´  KLGGHQP HDQLQJ ZLW KW KHKHOSRIW KHZLFN HGRQH ³ %|VHQ´ 

7KHQ W KH GHFLVLRQ FDP H  7R FRP EDW

$W  W KH )LUH 0RXQW DLQ W KH UXOHUV LQYLW HG HDFK RW KHU
7KHUH SHDFH EHW ZHHQ HQHP LHV ZDU W RUQ
$QG KXQJU\ ZROYHV VQHDN DURXQG W KH SODFH RI FRP EDW 
:RUQ IURP  FRP EDW  +HOJH VDW  RQ W KH $GOHUVW HLQ (DJOH VW RQH
6ODLQ ZDV W KH ZKROH FODQ RI +XQGLQJ
7KHUH OLNH VKLQLQJ RI IODP HV EURNH W KURXJK
$QG IODVKLQJ OLJKW QLQJ VKRQH IURP  FORXGV
7KHUH KHOP HW V VSDUNOHG LQ W KH VNLHV
*LOGHG FUHVW V UHGGHQHG E\ EORRG
$QG JORZLQJ VSDUNV RQ W KH W LS RI W KH VSHDU
7KHUH ZDV 6LUJXQ ZKR VHDUFKHG IRU +HOJH


.\UHQNUHQLVDQROG*HUP DQZ RUGIRUVHOHFW LQJFKRRVLQJRU HOHFW LQJ

$OVR*HUP DQVXFKDVW KHZ RUG³ :DOOVW DW W ´SODFHRIFRP EDW EDW W OHILHOG
 

7KH OHDGHU DVNHG W KH GLYLQH ZRP HQ W KHQ

, I KRP H W KH\ ZRXOG ULGH ZLW K W KH KHURHV
, Q W KH VDP H QLJKW   7KHUH DQHZ W KH\ DW W HP SW HG
7R EHJLQ EDW W OH  $OUHDG\ W KH ERZV FUHDNHG
EXW  +DJHQ¶V GDXJKW HU IURP  KHU KRUVH FDOP HG
7KH QRLVH RI W KH VKLHOGV DQG W KHQ VSRNH W R W KH RQH ZKR DVNHG
³ :KDW  HOVH ,  P HDQ LV IRU P H W R H[SHFW
,  ORYHG \RX IRU D ORQJ W LP H ZLW K DOO RI P \ KHDUW
%HIRUH ,  KDYH VHHQ \RX VRQ RI W KH :lOVXQJV´

7KH EDVLV RI W KHVH LP DJHV LV W KH IDFW  W KDW  LQ ROG W LP HV W KH FDSDELOLW \ W R VSOLW  W KH
SHUVRQDOLW \ZDVVW LOOP RUHZLGHVSUHDGW KDQW RGD\DVDUHVXOW RIVSLULW XDOH[HUFLVHV
7KHVH SHRSOH FRXOG HDVLO\ DSSHDU W R RW KHUV RQ DQRW KHU SODFH W KDW  LV IDU DZD\
ZKLOH VOHHSLQJ RU ZKLOH EHLQJ LQ GHHS P HGLW DW LRQ    7KLV LV DQ DUW  W KDW  LV VW LOO
SUDFW LFHG E\ W KRVH ZKR NQRZ ZRUOG ZLGH  , W  LV NQRZQ W R P DQ\ QDW XUDO SHRSOHV
ZKLOH W KH LQW HOOHFW  RULHQW HG SHRSOH RI (XURSH KDYH ORVW  W KRVH FDSDELOLW LHV DQG
NQRZOHGJH DOP RVW  HQW LUHO\

, W  LV W KH ³ SRZHU W R ZLVK´  E\ W KH VRQV ZKR ZLVK DQG W KH P DLGHQ Z KR ZLVKHV DV
W KH (GGD FDOOV W KHP  ZKLFK FKDQJHV W KHP  W R VHP L JRGV DQG VHP L JRGGHVVHV
KDOI JRGV DQG KDOI JRGGHVVHV   , Q RW KHU ZRUGV LW  LV W KH VNLOO RI W KH P DJLFDO
SRZHUV ZLW KLQ W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ  +HUH ZH GHDO ZLW K IDFW V DQG ZLW K FDSDELOLW LHV
W KDW  SHRSOH XVXDOO\ UHM HFW  DUURJDQW O\  ZLW K W KH FRQVHTXHQFH W KDW  VXFK D SHUVRQ
ZDV UHM HFW HG KLP VHOI IURP  D GHHSHU SURELQJ LQW R W KH LQH[KDXVW LEOH DQG RIW HQ
LQFRP SUHKHQVLEOH KXP DQ QDW XUH

7KH VHFRQG SDVVDJH LV LQ W KH ³ 5LJVP DO´ W KH VRQJ DERXW  W KH RU LJLQ RI VRFLDO
FODVVHVDV, KDYHFDOOHGLW LQP \W UDQVODW LRQZKHUHW KH\W DONHGDERXW W KH\RXQJ
5LJUW KH\RXQJNLQJW KHRQHZKRZDVFDSDEOH+HZDVW DXJKW W KH³ IRJODN\UUD´
Z K LFK  OLW HU DOO\  Z RX OG  P HDQ  W R VHOHFW  DQ G  W R FDW FK  E LU G V   +RZ HY HU  Z K R
FRP SUHKHQGHG W KH VHFUHW  ODQJXDJH RI W KH ROG P \W KV FDQQRW  EH VDW LVILHG ZLW K
VXFK VXSHUILFLDO H[SODQDW LRQV RI W KH ORZHVW  OHYHO  )RJOD N\UUD ZLW KRXW  GRXEW  LV
KHUH W KH VHOHFW LRQ RI W KH VSRXVH IRU EUHHGLQJ  ³ )RJOD´  KDV LQ P D\ ODQJXDJHV D
FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K ORYH P DNLQJ VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V DQG DSSHDUV LQ GLDOHFW V HVSHFLDOO\
LQ *HUP DQ    6XFK UHP DLQGHUV RI DQFLHQW  ZRUG P HDQLQJV GR QRW  FRP H RXW  RI
FRLQFLGHQFHEXW W KH\ZHUHNHSW DOLYHZRQGHUIXOO\LQW KHOLQJXLVW LFW UHDVXUHRIW KH
IRON 

7KH ³ DU W  RI VHOHFW LQJ D VSRXVH´  Z DV W DXJKW  E\  W KH OHDGHU V DQG SU DFW LFHG E\
P HQW LRQLQJW RZKLFKKXP DQW \SHW KHSHRSOHZKRDUHZLOOLQJW RP DUU\EHORQJHG
LH W R ZKLFK ]RGLDFDO VLJQ W KH\ EHORQJHG DV D UHVXOW  RI W KH W LP H RI W KHLU ELUW K
7KHDQFLHQW ³ UR\DODUW ´ RIDVW URORJ\ZDVW KHEDVLVRIW KHIRUP DW LRQRIW KHOHDGHU
FODVV LQ ROGHU W LP HV DQG LW  ZDV RQ D KLJK OHYHO RI H[SHULHQFH DQG VNLOO  7KLV


2PLWWHG

Y|JHOQ(QJOLVK W RFRSXODWH
 

N QRZ OHGJH GLG QRW  RQO\  DOORZ  W R GHW HU P LQH Z KLFK VSRXVHV EHORQJHG W R HDFK
RW KHU DFFRUGLQJ W R FRVP LF H[SHULHQW LDO GDW D EXW  DOVR W KH W LP H RI IHUW LOL]DW LRQ
7KLVZD\GHVLUDEOHKXP DQFKDUDFW HULVW LFVRIW KHRIIVSULQJFRXOGEHGHW HUP LQHGE\
W KH VW DUV ZKHQ W KH W LP H RI IHUW LOL]DW LRQ DQG ZLW K W KLV RI W KH W LP H RI ELUW K DQG
LW V SODQHW DU\ SRVLW LRQV ZDV FDOFXODW HG

7KHUHIRUHVSHFLDOW LP HVRIIHUW LOL]DW LRQDW VSHFLILFIHVW LYDOVZHUHSUHIHUUHG7KHVH

IHVW LYDOV ZHUH LQ D JRRG VHDVRQ IRU W KH ELUW K RU SUHIHUUHG KXP DQ W \SHV  )RU
LQVW DQFHIHUW LOL]DW LRQGXULQJW KH6XP P HUVROVW LFHSURGXFHGXVHIXO$ULHV SHUVRQV
ILJKW HUV DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH SRVLW LRQ DW  W KH HQG RI 0DUFK  7KH IHW LOL]DW LRQ DW  W KH
W LP H RI W KH :DOSXU JLV QLJKW  Z KLFK P D\ KDYH EHHQ D ELW  HDU OLHU  SU RGXFHG D
VSLULW XDOO\ P RUH GHW HUP LQHG KXP DQ XQGHU W KH VLJQ RI $TXDULXV 

(YHQLQRXUGD\VZHZRXOGEHFDSDEOHW RGHW HUP LQHW KHW \SHRIRIIVSULQJDFFRUGLQJ

W R W KH LQIOXHQFHV RI W KH VW DUV LI ZH XVHG W KH H[SHULHQFHV RI DQ DVW URORJ\ W KDW  LV
EXLOW  XSRQ VW ULFW O\ VFLHQW LILF SULQFLSOHV DV W KH DQFLHQW  SHRSOHV GLG ZKLFK ZH FDQ
VHH RQ P DQ\ DQFLHQW  UHSRUW V

, Q DQ\ FDVH W KH\ QHYHU OHIW  FRQFHSW LRQ DQG ELUW K W R SXUH FRLQFLGHQFH RU ZDQW RQ
DFW LRQUHVXOW LQJRIP RUHRUOHVVDOFRKROLQGXFHGP RRGVZKLFKZ DVDW W KHEHJLQQLQJ
RI W KH H[LVW HQFH RI P RVW  RI RXU FRQW HP SRUDULHV  7KLV LV W KH UHDVRQ W KDW  ZH URW
LQRQHRIW KHP RVW KRUULEOHQRQ FXOW XUHVRIFRLQFLGHQW DODFW LYLW LHVIURP ZKLFKZH
FDQRQO\EHUHGHHP HGE\P HDQVRIDIDW H FRQQHFW HGKLJKHULQVLJKW RIW KHFRVP LF
FRQQHFW LRQV  5HJDUGOHVV RI DOO ³ LQW HOOLJHQFH´  W KDW  ZH KDYH ZKHQ LW  FRP HV W R
W DNHDGYDQW DJHRIRXUIHOORZKXP DQVZHDUHIULJKW HQLQJO\XQZLVHEHFDXVHZLW K
VXFK DFW LRQ ZH ORVH VLJKW  RI W KH W UXH DGYDQW DJHV DQG FRQVHTXHQW O\ OLYH D OLIH RI
ODFNE\W KHP LOOLRQVLQFDSDEOHW ROLYHLW ZLW KGLJQLW \HYHQIRUDQLQVW DQW :HEHDW
HDFK RW KHU RXW  ZLW K UHFRUGV RI VSHHG DQG P RYHP HQW  FDQQRW  JHW  W KH DGYDQW DJH
IRUP LW IRUZKLFKLW ZRXOGEHZRUW KW RUDFHDURXQGW KH(DUW KVHYHUDOW LP HVDGD\
QDP HO\W RVDYHW LP H4XLW HW RW KHFRQW UDU\ W KHIDVW HUZHP DQDJH³ W UDIILF´W KH
ZRUVHLVW KHUHVXOW EHFDXVHHYHU\GD\W KHSRRUKXP DQVKDYHOHVVW LP HDYDLODEOH
IRU W KHP VHOYHV  7KH\ HQVODYH W KHP VHOYHV KRSHOHVVO\ EHFDXVH RI DQ LQVDW LDEOH
ODFN RI W LP H

%XW W RKDYHW LP HLVHYHU\W KLQJ :KRHYHUKDVW LP HKDVP RQH\ 7KLVP HDQVKH
QHHGVQRP RQH\ 7KLVKRZHYHULVDFRQW UDGLFW LRQW KDW LVLQVROYDEOH:KRW DNHV
KLV W LP H KDV DOUHDG\ P RQH\ DQG ZKR QHHGV W R W DNH P RQH\ KDV QR W LP H OLNH DOO
W KRVH SHRSOH ZKR KDYH D ORW  RI P RQH\ EXW  QR W LP H

(YHQIRUSURFUHDW LRQW KHVHSHRSOHKDYHQRORQJHUW LP HDQGW KH\ZLOOVRRQFKDQJH


 2PLWWHG
 

RYHU W R DUW LILFLDO LQVHP LQDW LRQ LQ LQVW LW XW LRQV W KDW  DUH OHG E\  GRFW RUV LI RQH GRHV
P RW  VW D\ ZLW K W KH ROGHU YHUVLRQ RI EHLQJ UHSUHVHQW HG E\ D SRRU ³ KRXVH IULHQG´
ZKR KDV W KH W LP H

7KHGLIIHUHQFHLQDW W LW XGHW RW KHVHKXP DQTXHVW LRQVFDQEHVLJQLILHGE\DSUD\HU

W KDW \RXILQGLQW KH8SDQLVKDGVRIW KH$U\DQ, QGLDQVZKLFKLVVSRNHQDW W KHW LP H
RI FRQFHSW LRQ RI D FKLOG

³ 1RZ OHW  XV JR W R ZRUN

3XW  W KH VHHG LQW R HDFK RW KHU
&UHDW H D P DOH FKLOG´

7KH P DQ XQFRYHUV W KH ODS RI W KH ZRP DQ

³ RSHQ KHDYHQ DQG (DUW K´

$IW HU FRSXODW LRQ DQG FRQQHFW LQJ P RXW K ZLW K P RXW K W KH W RXFKHV KHUSXELF KDLU
W KUHH W LP HV DQG VD\V

³ 9LVKQX VKDOO EXLOG XSRQ \RXU ODS

:DVKW DU VKRXOG EXLOG W KH VKDSHV ZHOO
3UDM DSDW L VKDOO ZDW H W KHP
'KDW DU SXW  W KH VHHG RI IUXLW  LQW R \RX
5HLFK JRGGHVV ZLW K W KH ZLGH EUDLGV
5HLFK 6LQLYDOL IUXLW  IRU KHU
)UXLW  VKDOO FUHDW H IRU \RX W KH $VYLQL
/RW XV FURZQHG SDLU RI JRGV´

7KH W ZLQ FRXSOH RI W KH $VYLQL VRQV RI W KH 'M DXV 3LW DU RI W KH -XSLW HU W KH =HXV
IDW KHU DUH W KH P RVW  EHDXW LIXO RI W KH JRGV

7KH ZDV W KH FRQVFLRXV EUHHGLQJ FKRLFH RI W KH $ULR , QGLDQV ZKLFK FORVHG LW VHOI
VW ULFW O\ LQW R FDVW V VR W KDW  W KH OLJKW  EORRG UHP DLQHG ZLW K W KH OHDGLQJ FDVW V RI W KH
SULHVW V DQG ZDUULRUV  7KH VLW XDW LRQ ZDV W KH VDP H LQ *HUP DQLD DW  W KH EHJLQQLQJ
RI W KH &KULVW LDQ HUD  7KH 5RP DQ 7DFLW XV NQRZ V QRW KLQJ W R UHSRU W  DERXW  W KH
SULQFLSOHVRIKXP DQEUHHGLQJEXW KHFOHDUO\UHSRUW VW KHUHVXOW VLQFKDSW HURI
KLV ³ *HUP DQLD´

³ :LW KRXW H[FHSW LRQLQW KHKRXVHQDNHGDQGQHHG\W KH\RXW KJURZVW RW KHVKDSH

RI OLIH W KDW  ZH DGP LUH´

³ /DW H W KH \RXW K FRP HV W R HQM R\ ORYH W KHUHIRUH KLV LQH[KDXVW LEOH YLULOLW \  :LW K
W KHYLUJLQVW RRW KHUHLVQRKXUU\W KHLU\RXW KLVW KHVDP HW KHLUKHLJKW W KHVDP H
7KLVZD\LQW KHIXOOQHVVRIW KHLUKHDOW K\RXW KDQGYLUJLQSDLUXSDQGW KHFKLOGUHQ
DUH ZLW QHVV RI W KH IXOO SRZHU RI W KH SDUHQW V  7KH ODUJHU W KH QXP EHU RI NLQVKLS
W KH P RUH DJUHDEOH ROG DJH ZLOO EH  &KLOGOHVVQHVV KDV QR SUHIHU HQFH´
 

7KHSUDFW LFHRIW KLVDQFLHQW FKRLFHRIP DUULDJHDQGRIP RUDOODZVZDVSDUW RIW KH

³ ULW D´  ODZ ULJKW V 

$FFRUGLQJW RROGFRQYHQW LRQVW KHLQVLJKW VFRQFHUQLQJKXP DQEUHHGLQJZHUHLQKHULW HG

IURP JHQHUDW LRQW RJHQHUDW LRRQE\ZRUGRIP RXW K7KH6NDOGVDQGVDFUHGZRP HQ
ZHUHHGXFDW HGW RW KLVVHUYLFHRIW KHIRONH[W HQVLYHO\DQGIRUDORQJSHULRGRIW LP H
LQ SULHVW  VFKRROV W KDW  ZHUH ORFDW HG LQ SODFHV ZKHUH \RX ILQG P RQDVW HULHV DQG
FKXUFKHV P RVW  RI W KH W LP H LQ RXU GD\V

7KH*HUP DQLFSHRSOHVZHUHW KHODVW FDUULHUVRIW KHVHSUHFLRXVW UDGLW LRQVDQGZH

ZLOOGRZHOOW RERZGRZQLQW KHIDFHRIVXFKKXP DQZLVGRP EHFDXVHW KHUHLVQR
KLJKHU P RUH QREOH ZRUN W KDQ W R FRQFHLYH QREOH EHDXW LIXO DQG VW URQJ KXP DQ
EHLQJV W KHQZHKDYHFUHDW HGIRURXUVHOYHVW KHSDUDGLVHRQ(DU W K7KHKLJKHVW
ZLVK SXUH ZLVGRP  DQG UHOLJLRQ FDQ RQO\ EH UHDFKHG RYHU W KH ³ hEHU 0HQVFK´
6XSHUP DQ  DOO RW KHU DW W HP SW V DUH IUXLW OHVV EHFDXVH W KH QREOH KXP DQ EHLQJ
DORQHFDQEHFDUULHURIQREOHVW ULYLQJVIRUDQ\H[W HQGHGW LP H, W LVDP D]LQJW KDW
VXFK NQRZOHGJH DQG VNLOO ZHUH ORVW  W R KXP DQNLQG  7KLV ORVV ZDV RQO\ SRVVLEOH
EHFDXVH RI W KH VORZ  U LVLQJ RI W KH VXEKXP DQ Z KHQ W KH EU HHGLQJ JRDO RI W KH
EXLOGLQJ XS RI W KH ORZ KXP DQLW \ E\ P HDQV RI P L[LQJ LQ W KH 'LYLQH KXP DQ ZDV
RYHUGRQHDQGW KHDLP OHVVP L[LQJFRQIXVLRQFDP HW REHRQ(DUW K+XP DQVFRXOG
QR ORQJHU XQGHUVW DQG HDFK RW KHU EHFDXVH W KHLU ODQJXDJH DOVR GHJHQHUDW HG ZLW K
D JUHDW HU RU VP DOOHU SDUW  RI W KH 'LYLQH EORRG  7KH ODQJXDJH LV SDUW  RI W KH UDFH
HY HQ  W K RX JK  LQ  RX U  GD\ V ODQ JX DJH DQ G U DFH DSSHDU  K RSHOHVVO\  P L[ HG DQ G
LQW HUFKDQJHG  :LW KLQ OLP LW V W KH UDFH LV VW LOO DFW LYH LQ W KH FKDQJLQJ RI ODQJXDJH
HLW KHU E\ P DLQW DLQLQJ D KLJKHU OLQJXLVW LF IRUP  RU E\ LQFUHDVHG QHJOHFW  W KHUHRI

 7KH *HUP DQV VW LOO SUDFW LFHG W KHVH ZKROHVRP H FXVW RP V DQG P RUDOV DW  D W LP H
ZKHQW KH5RP DQVKDGDOUHDG\GHJHQHUDW HGXQGHUEDGODZVIRUDORQJW LP H7KH
5RP DQVGLGW HOOXVVROLW W OHDERXW W KH*HUP DQVEHFDXVHW KHLUXQGHUVW DQGLQJZDV
QR ORQJHU VXIILFLHQW  W R XQGHUVW DQG W KH GHSW K RI W KH 8U FXOW LF LQVW LW XW LRQV RI W KH
*HUP DQV LH W KHLU LQVW LW XW LRQV W KDW  FUHDW HG FXOW XUH  7KH\ KDG DOUHDG\ ORVW  DOO
FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K DQ 8U P RW KHUO\ ZRUOG URRW  EHFDXVH RI W KH GHFOLQH RI FXOW XUH DV
D UHVXOW  RI FLYLOL]DW LRQ  7KH *HUP DQV KDG VW LOO DQ 8U FXOW XUH W KDW  DOORZHG QR
³ ZKHHOLQJDQGGHDOLQJ´QRSXEOLFZULW LQJQRW XUQLQJLQW R³ FLW L]HQU\´ZKLFKDOZD\V
OHDGVW RGLVLQW HJUDW LRQ7KH\VW LOOKDGW KHVDFUHGFRQQHFW LRQRIW KHIRONZLW KUDFH
DQG UHOLJLRQ W KDW  GHP DQGHG VHFUHW LYH VLOHQFH ZKHQ GHDOLQJ ZLW K W KH ³ RXW VLGH´
ZRUOG  7KHUHIRUH W KHUH VHHP V W R EH DQ HP SW LQHVV ZKLFK HP SW LQHVV DFW XDOO\ LV
RXULJQRUDQFHFRQFHUQLQJW KHW UXHVLW XDW LRQRIW KHILUVW SHRSOHRIW KH(DUW KZKLFK
LJQRUDQFH W KH 5RP DQV KDG DV ZHOO  , I (XURSH ZDV LQXQGDW HG LQ RXU GD\V E\
JLJDQW LF DUP LHV RI 1HJUR   DQG 0RQJRO DUP LHV W KHQ W KH RIIVSULQJ ZRXOG KDYH
UHODW LYHO\ OLW W OH LGHDV DERXW  W KH KLJK OHYHO RI W HFKQRORJ\ DQG W UDIILF W KDW  LV W KH
KDOOP DUN RI RXU W LP HV OHW  DORQH RI OLW HUDW XUH DQG DOO RW KHU LQW HOOHFW XDO FUHDW LRQV

7KLVZD\ZHFDQH[SODLQZK\ZHNQRZVROLW W OHDERXW RXUSDVW $VRFLHW \RQHLQ

LW VHOI DQG 8U FXOW LF Z LW K YHU\ VSHFLILF LGHDV P RUDOV DQG FXVW RP V Z DV VORZ O\
FK RN HG X Q GHU  W K H LP SHW X V RI  D GHVHFU DW LQ J FLY LOL]DW LRQ   Z K LFK  E HFDP H DQ
 

LQW HOOHFW XDO DQG SK\VLFDO V\SKLOLVDW LRQ  

, Q W KH FXOW  RI W KH :DUEXUJV \RXQJ P HQ DQG JLUOV IRXQG HDFK RW KHU W R P DUULDJH
DIW HU ORQJ \HDUV RI VFKRROLQJ DQG GLIILFXOW  W HVW V RI VRXO DQG ERG\  7KH\ GLG VR LQ
RU GHU  W R FRQFHLY H EHDXW LIXO DQG U DFLDOO\  SXU H RIIVSU LQJ  LQ Z KLFK W KH U DFLDO
FKDUDFW HULVW LFV RI W KH SDUHQW V VKRXOG VW LOO EH LQFUHDVHG  %DVHG RQ W KLV P DUULDJH
EHW ZHHQVLEOLQJVZDVDOORZHGHYHQUHFRP P HQGHGZKHQDVSHFLDOO\KLJKEUHHGLQJ
JRDO ZDV W R EH DFKLHYHG

7KHUHIRUH 6LJUXQ RI W KH :lOVXQJ OHJHQG P DUULHG KHU EURW KHU EHFDXVH VKH FRXOG
QRW JHW VRQVW KDW ZHUHFDSDEOHRIUHYHQJHIURP KHUKXVEDQG! )URP W KHP DUULDJH
RI EURW KHU DQG VLVW HU RI W KH :RGDQ G\QDVW \ RI W KH :lOVXQJV VXFK DEOH RIIVSULQJ
ZRXOG FHUW DLQO\ HP HUJH  

, QEUHHGLQJQHYHUP HDQVZHDNHQLQJRIH[FHOOHQW LQKHULW HGW UDLW VEXW W KHLULQFUHDVH

DV ZH NQRZ IURP  P HW KRGV RI EUHHGLQJ DQLP DOV  $ GDQJHU RFFXUV RQO\ ZKHQ DQ
LQFUHDVHVHHP VQRORQJHUSRVVLEOHRUZKHQP RUELGDQGIDXOW \JHQHVDUHLQKHULW HG  
:KHQW KHEUHHGLVRIDKLJKOHYHOVXFKFRQVLGHUDW LRQVDUHLUUHOHYDQW DQGZHILQG
LQW KHOHDGLQJG\QDVW LHVRIW KHZKROHZRUOGP DUULDJHRIVLEOLQJVDVDQLQVW LW XW LRQ  
, W EHFDP HLP P RUDOXQGHUW KHUXOHRIQRQ EUHHGLQJDQGW KHUHIRUHOHZGSRZHUV, Q
W KHSUHVHQW VW DW HRIKXP DQLW \LW ZRXOGQRW EHDQ\W KLQJW REHUHFRP P HQGHGDQG
ZRXOG QHHG W R EH OLP LW HG W R H[FHSW LRQV

7KHEUHHGLQJVHOHFW LRQW KDW ZDVIROORZLQJW KHUK\W KP RIW KH6XQW KHULW XDORIW KH

6XQ P DGH W KH $U \DQV W KH P DVW HU  SHRSOH RI W KH (DU W K  3XU LW \ IDLW KIXOQHVV
LQW HOOHFW W UXW KIXOQHVVLQQHUYLHZDQGKHDOW KDUHHIIHFW VRIW KHEUHHGLQJRIQREOH
DQGSXUHEORRG, IVXFKSHRSOHZHUHJLYHQW KHSRZHULQW RW KHLU KDQGVW KHQW KH\
Z RXOG OHDG DOO SHRSOHV DQG QDW LRQV LQW R SHDFH DQG Z HOO EHLQJ Z LW KLQ D VKRU W
W LP H  :HVKRXOGFRP SDUHW KHSRW HQW DW HVLQW RGD\¶V(XURSHZLW KW KH H[DP SOHV
W KDW  ZH DUH GHVFULELQJ KHUH DQG ZH ZLOO EH FRQYLQFHG W KDW  LW  LV W KH UHVXOW V RI
³ EUHHGLQJ´ RU³ XQ EUHHGLQJ´  W KDW FRXQW 7KLVLVW KHP DLQUHDVRQDQGQRW RW KHU
U HDVRQV W KDW  DU H P HQW LRQHG DOO W RR RIW HQ Z KHQ W KH H[ LVW LQJ EDG VLW XDW LRQ LV
³ H[FXVHG´


 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG


2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG


7KHP DLQP HDQLQJRI8Q ]XFKW LVOHZGQHVV
 

2QVW HHSFOLIIVVXUURXQGHGE\UDP SDUW VDQGLP SHQHW UDEOHKHGJHVLQVZDP SDQG

SHDW  GHSHQGLQJ RQ W KH VLW XDW LRQ RI W KH ODQG ZHUH EXLOW  W KH :DOEXUJV DQG W KH
GDQFLQJ SODFHV  5RVH W KRUQV ZHUH SUHIHUUHG DV ZH DUH VW LOO QRW LFLQJ LQ W KH IDLU\
W DOHRI6OHHSLQJ%HDXW \0DQ\D³ NQLJKW ´ ZDVVW XFNLQW KHW KRU QVEHIRUHKHFRXOG
VHHW KHYLUJLQW KDW KHZDVGHVW LQHGW RUHGHHP W RJHW KHUZLW KKHUFRP SDQLRQVLQ
W KH IUHH VSDFH EHKLQG W KH SURW HFW LYH ULQJ  :KHQ W KH ZRP HQ ZHUH HVSHFLDOO\
Q REOH  W K H FRQ GLW LRQ V Z HU H LQ FU HDVLQ JO\  GLI I LFX OW  W R P DVW HU   $ EX U Q LQ J I LU H
VXUURXQGHGW KHEULGHDVZHNQRZIURP W KHULGHRI6LHJIULHGW KU RXJK W KH ULQJ RI
ILUH ZKHQ KH FKRVH %UXQKLOGH W KH :DON\ULH DV KLV VSRXVH  7KLV OHJHQG DOVR
SURYHVW KDW W KHP DQ\SHQHW UDW LQJVXLW RUVGLGQRW IRUFHDW DOOEXW W KDW W KHZRP HQ
ZHUH W KH RQHV ZKR P DGH D FKRLFH W R UHM HFW  DQ\ RQH RI W KH VXLW RU V

:H KDYH W R LP DJLQH W KH SUDFW LFH RI W KH FKRLFH RI W KH VSRXVH DV IROORZV   ! )URP
D VP DOOHU JURXS RI W KH IRON RU VFKRRO W KH \RXQJVW HUV DQG YLUJLQV DVVHP EOHG W R D
ODUJH ZHGGLQJ FHUHP RQ\ EXW  W KDW  W KH\ KDG DOUHDG\ P RUH RU OHVV P DGH W KHLU
FKRLFH  +RZHYHU W KH ZRP DQ VW LOO KDG W KH RSSRUW XQLW \ W R UHFRQVLGHU ZKHQ W KH
HQY LVLRQHG P DQ SU RY HG W R IDLO W KH ODVW  W HVW   W KH VW RU P LQJ RI W K H ³ Z RP HQ¶V
P RXQW DLQ´ LH LI KH SURYHG W R EH LQHSW  RI FRZDUGO\

$VZHNQRZIURP W KH, FHODQGLFVDJDVW KHZRP DQHVSHFLDOO\YDOXHGW KHIHDUOHVVQHVV

RI D SRW HQW LDO P DW H EHFDXVH IHDUOHVVQHVV FRQQHFW HG DOVR ZLW K DOO RW KHU QREOH
FKDUDFW HU LVW LFV  EXW  FRZ DU GLFH LV W KH P DLQ Y LFH RI KXP DQLW \  DV W KH SU HVHQW
VKRZ V

2XUW LP HVXIIHUVFRZDUGLFHLQDOOVLW XDW LRQVDQGTXHVW LRQVRIOLIH0RUDOFRZDUGLFH

DQG FRZDUGLFH RI W KH DYHUDJH FLW L]HQ LV W KH GLVHDVH W KH SODJXH W KH SHVW  RI W KH
SUHVHQW 7UXO\KHDOW K\KXP DQEHLQJVDUHQHYHUFRZDUGVW KHUHIRUHZHDUHURW W HQ
DQGVLFNW RW KHFRUH7KHFRZDUGLFHRIRXUVRFLHW \LQDOOQHFHVVLW LHVRIOLIHLVW KH
UHDVRQ RI DOO RXU ZHDNQHVV  , I ZH KDG W KH FRXUDJH W R W KH W UXW K W KHQ DOO RI XV
ZRXOGEHKHDOW K\DJDLQLQKHDOW K\FLUFXP VW DQFHVZKLFKEULQJE\ W KHP VHOYHVW KH
FRXUDJH W R W UXW K

$ ORRN DW  W KH ODQGVFDSH RI RXU KRP HODQG RSHQV W KH H\HV RI W KH HDJHU VW XGHQW 
(YHU\ZKHUH \RX ILQG EDVLFDOO\ W KH VDP H QDP HV W KDW  DUH UHSHDW HG LQ ZRRGV DQG
SDVW XUHV+HUHDQ³ (DVW HU ZRRG´W KHUHD³ 5RVH UHVHUYH´KHUHD³ 7ULEHUJ´W KHUH
D ³ )LHUHQVW RQH´   ILUH VW RQH  D ³ KDUH JDUGHQ´ D ³ W KRUQ P RXQW DLQ´ D ³ GDQFH
SODFH´P RVW O\DZLW FKHVGDQFHSODFHW KHP DQ\³ ZDO ´ DQG³ ZDKO´  EXUJHQ FDVW OHV 
ZLW KDQGZLW KRXW SLOJULP DJHV ³ :DOOIDKUW HQ´ D³ %DQQ:DOG´  EDQLVKLQJZRRGV 
D ³ SDUDGLVH´ D ³ 6DDO´  EXUJ D ³ 0lJGH EXUJ´  P DLGHQV¶ FDVW OH  D ³ )UDXHQEXUJ´
ZRP HQV¶FDVW OH D³ +HLOEURQQ´  IRXQW DLQRIKHDOLQJ ³ :LFKW HO /XLW HQ´ DQG³ 6LJ
P RXQW DLQ´+HUHZHM XVW VKRZDVP DOOVHOHFW LRQ(YHU\RQHFDQQDP HQHZQDP HV
RI SODFHV LQ KLV FORVHU KRP HODQG W KDW  UHIHU W R W KH :DOEXUJ FXOW  RI W KH DQFLHQW V
SURYLGHG W KDW  KH OHDUQV W R OLVW HQ DQG W R ORRN

(YHU\ZKHUH \RX ILQG JURW W RV VSULQJV FKDSHOV W R ZKLFK VSULQJW LP H SLOJULP DJHV
DUH RUJDQL]HG   :DKO IDKUW HQ DUH VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V W KH :DOO IDKUW HQ SLOJULP DJHV
RI W KH FDW KROLF FKXUFK
 

7KHVHDUHW KHROGFXVW RP VDQGKDELW VZKLFKZHVKRXOGH[DP LQHFORVHUDQGDVN

QRW  W R EH IRUJRW W HQ FRP SOHW HO\

1RZ  Z H P D\  DVN   Z KHU H FRXOG W KH ROG *HU P DQLF SHRSOHV KDY H JDLQHG VXFK
NQRZOHGJH"  7KH\ KDG QR VFKRROV DQG QR KLJKHU HGXFDW LRQ  2K KRZ OLW W OH ZH
NQRZDERXW RXURZQVLW XDW LRQ:HGRQ¶W HYHQNQRZW KDW RXUW KUHH VL[ DQGQLQH
OHYHO VFKRROV KDG W KHLU RULJLQ LQ W KH VFKRROV RI RXU IRUHIDW KHU V ZKLFK ZHUH YDOLG
LQ W KH 0\VW HU\ FXOW  VFKRROV DOO RYHU W KH (DUW K

, W  ZRXOG JR W RR IDU W R GHVFULEH W KHVH W KLQJV KHUH LQ P RUH GHW DLO  /HW ¶V SRLQW  DW
DSDVVDJHRI&HVDU ¶V³ :DURI*DXO´ZKHUHKHJDYHDVSDUVHUHSRUW FRQFHUQLQJW KH
GUXLGV DQG W KHLU VFKRROV

³ 0DQ\ *DXOV .HOW V  GHYRW H W KHP VHOYHV W R W KLV FODVV RXW  RI W KHLU RZQ YROLW LRQ RU
W KHLUSDUHQW VRUNLQIRONVW HOOW KHP W RM RLQ+HUHW KH\OHDUQE\KHDUW P DQ\YHUVHV
IRU ZKLFK UHDVRQ P DQ\ UHP DLQ LQ W KLV VFKRRO IRU W ZHQW \ \HDUV  7KH\ DUH QRW
DOORZHG W R ZULW H W KHVH W KLQJV GRZQ HYHQ W KRXJK W KH\ XVH W KH *U HHN VFULSW  LQ
W KHLU  SU LYDW H GHDOLQJV DQG JRYHU QP HQW ´   7KLV LV D JU RVV P LVXQGHU VW DQGLQJ
EHFDXVHKRZFRXOGW KH'UXLGVKDYHUHFHLYHGW KH*UHHNDOSKDEHW " 7KLV³ *UHHN
VFULSW ´  LV W KH 5XQH VFULSW  W KDW  ZDV P RUH RU OHVV XQNQRZQ W R W KH 5RP DQV DQG
ZKLFK LV P RUH VLP LODU W R W KH *UHHN VFULSW  W KDQ W R W KH /DW LQ RQH    ³ :LW K W KLV DV
, VXVSHFW W KH\KDYHDGXDOSXUSRVH)LUVW W KH\GRQRW ZDQW W KDW W KHLUW HDFKLQJ
EHFRP HVNQRZQW RW KHFRP P RQSHRSOHVHFRQGW RSUHYHQW W KHLUGLVFLSOHVW RW UXVW
W KHZULW W HQZRUGP RUHW KDQW KHLUP HP RU\ZKLFKW KH\W KHQXVHOHVV, IW KLVLVW KH
FDVH W KH FDUH JLYHQ W R W KH P HP RU\ DQG W R OHDUQLQJ LQ JHQHUDO LV GLP LQLVKHG
7KHLU P DLQ W HDFKLQJ LV   W KH VRXO LV LP P RUW DO DQG DIW HU GHDW K JRHV IURP  ERG\ W R
ERG\´  2I3\W KDJRUDVW KH\UHSRUW W KDW KHIRXQGRXW IURP W KHP \VW HU\VFKRROVLQ
W KH 1RUW K ZKDW  KH W DXJKW  RI UHLQFDUQDW LRQ RU W KDW  KH IRXQG W KHU H SURRI RI LW 
³ 7KLV W KH\ FRQVLGHU  W KH VW U RQJHVW  LQFHQW LYH W R EHLQJ EU DYH Z KHQ RQH LV QRW
DIUDLG RI GHDW K  %HVLGHV W KDW  W KH\ W HDFK DOVR P DQ\ W KLQJV DERXW  W KH FHOHVW LDO
ERGLHV W KHLU FRXUVHV W KH VL]H RI W KH ZRUOG DQG G RI W KH FRXQW ULHV W KH HVVHQFH

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 

RI W KLQJV W KH SRZHU DQG P LJKW  RI W KH LP P RUW DO JRGV DQG W KH\ W HDFK DOO W KDW  W R
W KH \RXW K´

$V ZH FDQ VHH   +H GLG QRW  NQRZ P XFK DERXW  DOO W KDW  EHFDXVH W KHUH ZHUH QR
SXEOLF VFKRROV DV LQ RXU GD\V  7KH LQVW LW XW LRQV LQ *DXO FRUUHVSRQGHG HQW LUHO\ W R
W KRVH LQ *HUP DQLD ZKLFK ZDV NLQ E\ UDFH FXOW  DQG ODQJXDJH  7KHUHIRUH W KLV
UHSRUW FDQDOVREHXVHGW RGHVFULEHW KH*HUP DQLFSHRSOHVVLQFHW KH5RP DQVGLG
QRW QRW LFHDQ\GLIIHUHQFHEHW ZHHQW KHW ZRSHRSOHVW KH*DXOVDQGW KH*HUP DQV
LQODQJXDJHORRNVDQGP RUDOV$W P RVW W KH\VDZP RUHRULJLQDOLW \LQDOOZLW KW KH
*HUP DQV D KLQW  W KDW  M XVW LILHV XV W R DVVXP H W KDW  W KH FXOW LF LQVW LW XW LRQV RI W KH
*HUP DQV DUH DW  OHDVW  DV ROG DQG XQLTXH DV W KRVH RI W KH *DOOLF SHRSOH

:HVD\W KHW UXW KLIZHFODLP W KDW W KH$U\DQW ULEHVRIW KH1RUW KZHUHW KHOHDGHUV
RI KXP DQLW \ VLQFH W LP HV LP P HP RULDO DQG W KDW  KDSSHQHG VLQFH W LP HV W KDW  ZH
W KLQNZDVLP SUREDEOHEHFDXVHZHULJLGO\ORRNW RZDUGVW KH(DVW DQGDUHUHDG\W R
LJQRUH ZKDW  W KH DQFLHQW  SHRSOHV W KHP VHOYHV VDLG DERXW  W KHLU RULJLQ DERXW  W KH
FUDGOH RI KXP DQLW \ DERXW  W KH ZRUOG JRYHUQP HQW 

, Q W KH 1RU W K W KH\ EU HG W KH ³ .RW LQJV´ JRW KV´ ³ JRGV¶ RIIVSU LQJ´ W KH ³ 6RQV RI
:RGDQ´ RI 'RQDU RI 2GLQ DQG RI 7KRU  7KLV EUHHGLQJ KDSSHQHG LQ W KH JXLVH RI
VROHP Q P \ VW HU \  SOD\ V  DQG W KH RIIVSU LQJ Z HU H FKLOGU HQ RI KLJK SU LHVW V DQG
SULHVW HVVHVZKLFKZHUHFRQVHFUDW HGW R2GLQRU7KRUDQGZKRUHSUHVHQW HGW KHVH
GHLW LHV DV W KHLU  HP ERGLP HQW  RQ (DU W K LQ W KH FRQFHSW LRQ SOD\ V  :H FDQ DOVR
DVVXP H W KDW  W KH\  HVW DEOLVKHG HP EDVVLHV W KDW  W KH\  VHQW  IRU  P LOOHQQLD W R W KH
SHRSOHV W KDW  KDYH P LJUDW HG LQW R W KH IDU :HVW  DQG 6RXW K LQ RUGHU W R UHQHZ W KH
EORRG DQG W KH VSLULW 

+HU RGRW XV Z KR KDV U HFHLY HG W KH VDFU HG LQLW LDW LRQV LQ W KH W HP SOHV RI (J\ SW 
LQLW LDW LRQVW KDW ZHUHW KHVDP HRQHVDVW KRVHRIW KH'UXLGVW HOOVDERXW EFH
DERXW  W KH 6NDOGV DQG W KH 6F\W KLDQV LH W KH 6FRW V 6FRW W LVK W KDW  W KH\ KDG W KH
VDP H RULJLQ DQG W KDW  W KH\ OLYHG LQ W KH 1RUW K

³ )RUP LOOHQQLD´KHZURW H³ FDP HIURP W KLVH[FHOOHQW FRXQW U\W KHG\QDVW \RIW KRVH
ZKRZHUH³ NLQJVRIW KHNLQJV´ZKLFKP HDQVNLQJVRIW KHVHFXODU JRYHUQP HQW VDV
ZHOO DV NLQJV RI W KH DULVW RFUDF\ RI W KH VSLULW  DQG VRXO´

+HURGRW XV FRQILUP V W KDW  W KLV QREOH UDFH KDV VSUHDG DOO RYHU W KH (DUW K DQG W KDW
LW  UXOHG HYHU\ZKHUH W KH VDP H ZD\ DV VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V ZKHUH *HUP DQ G\QDVW LHV
DUH RQ W KH W KURQHV ZKLFK KRZHYHU ORVW  UXOHUVKLS DV D UHVXOW  RI W KHLU RZQ JXLOW
DQG GHJHQHUDW LRQ  , W  ZRXOG EH EHW W HU LI RXU KLVW RU\ ZULW HUV KDG FRSLHG IURP  W KH
KLVW RU\ZULW HUVRIDQW LTXLW \ZKLFKDUHDW OHDVW DVUHOLDEOHDVRXUQHZRQHV7KHQ
W KH\ ZRXOG KDYH UHFRJQL]HG P XFK HDUOLHU W KH W HUULEOH FRQIXVLRQ W KDW  RULJLQDW HG
ZLW K W KH DVVXP SW LRQ W KDW  ³ W KH FUDGOH RI DOO FXOW XUH LV LQ W KH (DVW ´

7KHP RVW QRW DEOHJHRJUDSKHURIKLVW LP HW KH*UHHN6W UDERP HQW LRQVDERXW W KH

6F\W KLDQV LQ W KH \HDU  EFH   ³ :H W KLQN RI W KH 6F\W KLDQV  W KH 6FRW HV W KH
JRW KVEHFDXVHXQGHUW KH7HUP ³ 6F\W KLDQV´ ZHVW LOOVHHD³ OHJHQGDU\´ SHRSOHZLW K
 

ZKLFK ZH DSSDUHQW O\ KDYH QRW KLQJ W R GR HYHQ W KRXJK ZH DUH W KHLU LP P HGLDW H
GHVFHQGDQW V  DV W KH P RVW  KRQHVW  DQG OHDVW  FXQQLQJ SHRSOH´

+HURGRW XV W HOOV DERXW  W KH VDP H 6F\W KLDQV DV EHLQJ W KH 1RUW KHUQ +\SHUERUHDQV
LQW KH³ EORQG$ULP DVSLDQ FRXQW U\´W KHROGHVW SHRSOHRIW KH(DU W KDV.DOLP DFKRV
VD\V  (YHU\ \HDU W KH\ VHQW  DP EDVVDGRUV W R W KH LVODQG RI 'HORV LQ W KH $HJHDQ
6HD ZKHUH W KH VDQFW XDU\ RI W KH *UHHN SHRSOH ZDV ORFDW HG LH W KH VHDW  RI W KH
*UHHN ³ +LJK$UP DQ´ +LJK SULHVW  W KH FOHULFDO DQG VSLULW XDO W RS OHDGHUVKLS

, I W KH VHDW V RI W KH 6F\W KLDQV KDG EHHQ H[FOXVLYHO\ RQ W KH 1RUW KHUQ FRDVW  RI W KH
%ODFN 6HD W KLV ZRXOG FRQW UDGLFW  W KH VSHFLILF P HQW LRQ RI +HURGRW XV RI ³ , Q W KH
ODQGV RI W KH +\SHUERUHDQV LQ W KH QRUW KHUQ FRXQW U\ RI W KH 6F\W KLDQV´

7KH 6F\W KLDQV RQ W KH EODFN VHD DUH M XVW  W KH IDUW KHVW  JURXS RI W KH DFW XDO 0DLQ
6F\W KLDQVW KH6FRW W VRQW KH1RUW K6HD:HKDYHW KHVDP HVLW XDW LRQDVW KHRQH
RI W KH *RW KV RQ W KH %ODFN 6HD DQG W KH %DOW LF 6HD  , Q IDFW  *RW KV 6NRW V *HOHV
DQG 6F\W KLDQV DUH DOO W KH VDP H SHRSOH W KDW  VSUHDG RXW  ZLGHO\ W R W KH 6RXW K DQG
(DVW   6W LOO LQ W KH 0LGGOH $JHV W KH 1RU P DQV FDOOHG W KHP VHOY HV *RW KV Z KLFK
SURYHV W KH FRUUHODW LRQV W KDW  ZH VKRZHG KHUH  :H VKRXOG OLIW  RXU H\HV IURP  W KH
P DSDQGORRNIDUDZD\LQDOOGLUHFW LRQVRW KHUZLVHZHRYHUORRNW KHKLVW RU\RIW KH
SHRSOHV ZKLFK LQ W KH SDVW  HQFRP SDVVHG W HUULW RULHV RI W KH VDP H VL]H DV W RGD\

7KDW  RXU DVVXP SW LRQ RI DQ $U\DQ OHDGHUVKLS RI W KH 6F\W KLDQV W KH 6FRW V LQ W KH
1RUW KHUQODQGRI³$ULP DVSLDQV´ LVDFRUUHFW RQHW HOOVXVW KHGLUHFW LRQIURP ZKLFK
W KH *HUP DQLF FXOW  OHDGHUVKLS UHFHLYHG W KHLU LQVW UXFW LRQV   QDP HO\ IURP  W KH VHHG
SODFH RI W KH VXQNHQ $W ODQW LV -HQD D VP DOO LVODQG FORVH W R 6FRW ODQG

, I+HURGRW XVVD\VQRZW KDW ³ W KH$ULP DVSLDQVDUHRQH H\HGDQGOLYHLQFRQW LQXRXV

FRP EDW  ZLW K W KH JROG SURW HFW LQJ JULIIRQV ZKRP  W KH\ DW W HP SW  W R URE´ KH VSHDNV
DVDQLQLW LDW HRI6DLVLQ.DODW KHVHFUHW ODQJXDJH $OORZP HW KHTXHVW LRQW RDVN
ZKR LV P RUH VW XSLG +HURGRW XV W KH KLVW RU\ ZULW HU RI W KH DQFLHQW V ZKR ZURW H
VXFKW KLQJVRUW KHVXEVHTXHQW KLVW RU\ZULW HUVZKREHOLHYHGW KDW +HURGRW XVW RRN
W KDW ZKLFKKHZURW HOLW HUDOO\, QRXUGD\VDVZHOODVLQW KHSDVW LW FHUW DLQO\ZRXOG
EHVRP HDVVXP SW LRQW RW KLQNRIDQLQW HOOLJHQW P DQW KDW KHW DNHVVW RULHVOLNHW KDW
OLW HU DOO\

:HFDQILQGW KHNH\W RVXFKUHSRUW VRQO\W KHQLIZHDUHQRW W KDW VW XSLGW REHOLHYH

W KDW SHRSOHRIDQW LTXLW \VXFKDV+HURGRW XVZHUHDVVW XSLGDVVRP HP D\DVVXP H
7KLV ODQJXDJH EHFRP HV P XFK FOHDUHU DV ZHOO DV ZLOO KXQGUHGV RI RW KHU UHSRUW V
W KDW  DUH VLP LODU LI ZH NQRZ W KDW  W KRVH ZKR ZHUH LQLW LDW HG  ZKR ZHUH VFKRODUV
EHVLGHV EHLQJ SULHVW V RU KDG RW KHU OHDGLQJ IXQFW LRQV ZHUH IRUELGGHQ W R VD\ LQ
RSHQ ODQJXDJH P RUH W KLQJV W KDQ W KH UXOLQJ OHDGHU FDVW H GHHP HG DFFHSW DEOH
7KHUHIRUHW KH\VDLGW KDW ZKLFKZDVQRW IRUHYHU\SHUVRQLQDVSHFLDOODQJXDJHDV
ZHW RRXVHLQP DQ\GLVFLSOLQHV7KHGLIIHUHQFHW KHUHZDVW KDW  SHRSOHRIDQFLHQW
W LP HV KDG W R KLGH ZLW K FU\SW LF ZRUGV P RUH LP SRUW DQW  W KLQJV W KDQ LV GRQH LQ W KH
VW \OH RI VFKRODUV RI RXU GD\V D VW \OH W KDW  LV URRW HG LQ W KHLU LQHSW QHVV W R D EHW W HU
 

*HUP DQ    7KH ³ RQH H\HG EORQG $ULP DVSLDQV´  DUH FOHDU UHIHUHQFH W R W KH 6XQ
VHUYLFH RI W KH +\SHUERUHDQ $ 3RO ORQ ZKR DFFRUGLQJ W R *UHHN W U DGLW LRQ OLYHG LQ
W KH 1RUW K  %XW  KHUH ZH VHH DJDLQ W KH FRQQHFW LRQ EHW ZHHQ W KH DSROOR VHUYLFH
ZLW K W KH :RGDQ 2GLQ VHUYLFH W KH RQH H\HG KHDYHQO\ IDW KHU DQG IDW KHU RI W KH
SHRSOHV ZKRVH VRQ 3RKO RU %DO GHU LV W KH \RXQJ VRQ JRG  7KH ³ JULIIRQV´ ZKLFK
ZH VHH DV DQ DQLP DO RI OHJHQGV W KDW  KDG P DQ\ VKDSHV W KHVH ³ JROG SURW HFW LQJ´
JULIIRQV KDG W KH RIILFH RI DGP LQLVW UDW LRQ RI W KH SDUDGLVH LH RI SUDFW LFDO UDFH
EUHHGLQJVLP LODUW RW KHGUDJRQVW KHGUXLGVLQW KHKLJKHVW $UP DQLVP 7KH³ JROG´
W KDW  W KH\ JXDUGHG LV W KH JROGHQ 9OLHV W KH JROGHQ IXU W KH JROGHQ KDLU RI W KH
$U\DQ JRG P DQ DQG KHUH LQ W KH UHSRUW  RI +HURGRW XV DUH SRVVLEO\ KLQW V DERXW
FRP EDW V ZLW KLQ W KH $U\DQ ZRUOG JRYHUQP HQW  DERXW  XVHIXOQHVV RI ODFN W KHUHRI RI
IXUW KHU P LVVLRQV W R W KH VRXW K ZKLFK DV ZH NQRZ FRQVLVW HG RI QREOHVW  \RXQJ
P HQ DQG YLUJLQV ZKLFK W KH\ VHQW  W R W KH VXERUGLQDW H VDQFW XDULHV ZKHUH W KH\
W RRNRYHUW KHVHUYLFHLQW KHP \VW HU\FXOW VDVRQO\ FDSDEOHRQHVDQGSRVVLEO\DOVR
KDG W R W DNH FDUH RI YDOXDEOH RIIVSULQJ

6R W KH UHSRUW V RI +HURGRW XV  +H VKRXOG EH W DNHQ P XFK P RUH VHULRXVO\ W KDQ DOO
XQVXVSHFW LQJ KLVW RU\ ZULW HUV ZKR QHYHU ZHUH LQLW LDW HG LQ W KH VHFUHW  GRFW ULQH
:LW KRXW  N QRZ OHGJH RI W KHVH EDVLFV W KH\  DU H QRW  FDSDEOH W R U HDG W KHVH ROG
VRXUFHV DQG XVH W KHP  IRU W KH VHFUHW  VFLHQFHV

:H KDYH W R OLP LW  RXUVHOYHV KHUH ZLW K W KHVH UHODW LYHO\ VKRUW  KLQW V DQG SURP LVH W R
SXEOLVKDERRNW KDW FODULILHVW KHLVVXHVP RUHIRUW KHIXW XUH+RZHYHUZHEHOLHYH
W KDW  ZH JDYH \RX VXIILFLHQW  LQVLJKW V LQW R W KHVH FRP LQJ TXHVW LRQV DV IDU DV W KH\
UHODW H W R W KLV UHSRUW  VR W KDW  ZH FDQ FRQW LQXH KHUH

7KH W HP SOH RI 'HORV ZDV FRQVHFUDW HG W R $SROOR DQG $UW HP LV  7KH $SROO  3RO 
3DO *RG ZH DOZD\V UHFRJQL]HG DV EHLQJ W KH SROH SKDOOXV JRG W KH EHJHW W HU RI
W KH P RVW  EHDXW LIXO KXP DQV  7KH $UW  HP LV LQ W KH QDP H RI ZKLFK ZH FDQ HDVLO\
UHFRJQL]H W KH $U 6XQ DQG $UW  V\OODEOHV W KHUHIRUH W KH JRGGHVV RI $UW  XQJ   LV
W KHUHIRUHDOVRZLW KW KH*UHHNVDJRGGHVVRIIHUW LOLW \7KHJLUOVZKRDUHUHDG\IRU
P DUULDJHFRQVHFUDW HW RKHUW KHLUW R\VDQGJLUOV¶FORW KHV W KH\RXQJP HQEHW ZHHQ
 DQG  \HDUV RI DJH ZKR DUH W UDLQHG IRU ZDU FRQVHFUDW H KHU W KHLU ORQJ KDLU

&DU XV 6W HU QH LV Z U LW LQJ LQ KLV ERRN  ³ &DVW OHV RI 7U R\ ´  DERXW  W KLV ROGHVW  VW LOO
VW DQ G LQ J  W HP S OH RI  $S ROOR LQ  'HORV  ³ LQ G HHG   E HLQ J  E X LOW  I U RP  K X J H Q RQ 
VP RRW KHQHG ERXOGHUV LW  ORRNV P RUH OLNH D 'DQLVK P RXQG W RP E W KDQ D *UHHN
W HP S OH   

$W  W KH W LP H RI +HURGRW XV W KH DP EDVVDGRUV W KDW  FDP H W R 'HORV ZHU H QR ORQJHU
IU RP  W KH 1RU W K W KH ³ JU LIIRQV´  KDY H OLN HO\  FDU U LHG W KH Y LFW RU \  EXW  W KH FOXW 
OHDGHUVKLSRUGHUHGW KHQHLJKERULQJSHRSOHVW RSDVVRQDP EDVVDGRUVIURP SHRSOH

2PLWWHG

$UW  W \SHUDFHLQP RGHUQ*HUP DQ

$UHFHQW ILQGLQJDERXW W KH³ UHGFOD\´ FXOW XUHRI/DEUDGRU W KH\ZHUHVHDIDULQJDQGW KHUHDUHW KH
VDP HW \SHVRIP RXQGVM XVW VHYHUDOFHQW XULHVROGHUW KDQW KH'DQLVKRQHV
 

W RSHRSOHDOOW KHZD\W R'HORV6XFKDP EDVVDGRUVZHUHXQOLNHO\ VHQW M XVW RXW RI

SXUH SROLW HQHVV  6XFK P HVVDJHV KDG FHUW DLQO\ D ORW  RI FRQW HQW  DQG UHODW HG W R
LQVW UXFW LRQVRIDFXOW LFNLQGDQGW KHH[FKDQJHRIRSLQLRQFRQFHUQLQJTXHVW LRQVRI
KXP DQNLQG

, W LVRXULQW HQW LRQW RW XUQW KHIDFHRIW KHZHOO P HDQLQJW RW KH1RUW KHDVW EHFDXVH
IRU QRZ KH FDQ VHH W KHUH P RUH W KDW  LOOXP LQDW HV KLP  DERXW  W KH FRXUVH RI DIIDLUV
LQ W KH ZRUOG W KDQ ZKDW  KH FDQ VHH ZLW K D ULJLGLILHG ORRN W RZDUGV W KH (DVW   :H
KDYH W R GR D FRP SOHW H W XUQDURXQG P HQW DOO\  W KHQ DJDLQ ZH DUH DW  W KH FRUUHFW
IURQW   7R W KLV SRLQW  ZH DOO KDYH EHHQ LQ W KH ZURQJ SRVLW LRQ

2QW KHLVODQGRI*RW ODQGW KHP HP RULHVVW D\HGDZDNHW KDW GXULQJW LP HVRIDKXJH

LQFUHDVH RI W KH SRSXODW LRQ ³ W KH W KLUG SDUW  RI W KH SRSXODW LRQ P RYHG W R *UHHFH´
7KLV LV TXLW H FRUUHFW  DQG VLJQLILFDQW  IRU W KH LVODQG W KDW  FDUULHV W KH QDP H RI W KH
*RW KVW KHOHDGLQJIRONRIW KH*HUP DQV7KHRIIVSULQJRIW KHVH*RW KVVXSSRVHGO\
DUH VSHDNLQJ ZRUGV RI W KH ROG 1RUGLF ODQJXDJH VW LOO LQ RXU W LP HV  7KLV W RR LV
FRUUHFW DV3URI6W XKO¶VLQW HOOLJHQW ZRUNFRQFHUQLQJW KHRULJLQRIW KH*UHHNODQJXDJH
FDQ SURYH  

, IZHP DNHW KHVDP HGLVFRYHU\ZLW KW KH+HEUHZDQGP RUHVRZLW KDOOODQJXDJHV

W KHQ W KH FRP SOHW H SURRI LV DW  KDQG W KDW  GHW HUP LQHV W KDW  W KH $U\DQ ODQJXDJH LV
W KH P RW KHU RI DOO RW KHU ODQJXDJHV  :LW K W KLV ZH ZLOO ZLQ D GHFLVLYH EDW W OH IRU D
QHZ IRUP XODW LRQ RI KXP DQ KLVW RU\ DQG W KH $U\DQ UDFH ZLOO EH FRQVLGHUHG DJDLQ
DV EHLQJ W KH ILUVW  ERUQ D SRVLW LRQ W KDW  LW  KHOG IRU HYHU DQG Z KLFK W KHUHIRUH LV
M X VW LI LHG

(YHQ W KH HW HUQDO ³ 4XDUW DLQLDQ´  DSSDUHQW O\ D UHIHUHQFH W R 1RVW U DGDP XV  KHDUG
DOU HDG\ RI W KH (OHXVLDQ P \VW HU LHV DQG P DQ\ W KHRVRSKLFDO VFKRROV P DNH W KH
DW W HP SW W RLQW URGXFHSHRSOHLQW RW KH, QGLDQVHFUHW GRFW ULQHW KHHVVHQW LDOFRQW HQW
RI W KH (J\SW LDQ P \VW HULHV ZDV SUHVHUYHG LQ W KH  DUFDQD RI W KH 7DURW   7KLV DOO
LVHDVLO\DFFHSW HG+RZHYHUVKRXOGDQ\RQHKDYHW KHDXGDFLW \W RW DONDERXW W KH
SRVVLELOLW \RID*HUP DQLFLQLW LDW LRQW KHQLP P HGLDW HO\HQUDJHG KRZOLQJZLOOVW DUW 
7KLV P DNHV DQ\ ORJLFDO GLVFXVVLRQ YHU\ GLIILFXOW   :K\"  %HFDXVH ZH EHOLHYH LQ
W KH OHW W HU ZKR ZDQW  W R KDYH HYHU\W KLQJ ZULW W HQ GRZQ ZLW KRXW  FRQVLGHULQJ W KDW
W KHUH DUH W KLQJV W KDW  FDQQRW  EH SURYHQ VLP SOH EHFDXVH W KH\ DUH D VHFUHW  RU
P \VW HU\ZLW KZKLFKW KH\ZHUHVXUURXQGHGLQRUGHUW RSUHYHQW GHVHFUDW LRQ7KDW
Z H KDYH KDUGO\ DQ\ OLW HUDU\ GRFXP HQW V RI W KH *HUP DQLF VHFUHW  W HDFKLQJV LV
HYLGHQW  LI ZH W KLQN ORJLFDOO\ IRU D IHZ P LQXW HV  7R GHQ\ W KH H[LVW HQFH W KHUHRI D
SULRUL LV W KH P DUN RI W KH W \SLFDO NQRZ LW  DOO ZKR ZDV VR EHDXW LIXOO\ H[SRVHG LQ
W KH VHFRQG SDUW  RI *RHW KH¶V )DXVW  LQ W KH VFHQH RQ W KH LP SHULDO SDODW LXP   :KR
LV FDSDEOH RI UHDGLQJ EHW ZHHQ W KH OLQHV FDQ ILQG D GHVFULSW LRQ RI W KH *HUP DQLF
LQLW LDW LRQ ULW XDO VW LOO LQ 7DFLW XV¶ ZRUN  )RU W KH UHVW  ZH KDYH W R ORRN DW  LQIHUHQW LDO
SURRI  , I ,  ILQG DQ ROG NH\ W KDW  RSHQV D KLGGHQ GRRU LQ D ZDOO W KHQ ,  NQRZ W KDW

2PLWWHG
 

LW  LV W KH FRUUHFW  NH\  &RDW V RI DUP V IDLU\ W DOHV ROG LQVFULSW LRQV HYHQ ODQJXDJH
FDQUHYHDOW KHLUKLGGHQP HDQLQJ 1RYDOLVFDOOVW KLV³ JHQHUDOHW \P RORJ\´  ZKHQ
W RXFKHG E\ W KH 5XQLF GRZVLQJ URG  7KLV VKRXOG EH SURRI IRU DQ\  SHUVRQ ZKR LV
VW LOO FDSDEOH W R SHUFHLYH DQG DQDO\]H QDW XUDOO\ DQG IUHH IURP  EHLQJ FRHUFHG E\
GHDG DQG ULJLGLILHG FRQFHSW V

7KHSDVVDJHLQ7DFLW XV¶*HUP DQLD&DSZKHUHDQLQLW LDW LRQU LW XDOLVGHVFULEHG

IROORZV KHUH LQ LW V /DW LQ ZRUGLQJ

Vet ust issim os nobilissim osque Sueborum Sem nones m em orant : fides ant iquit at is
religione firm at ur. st at o t em pore in silvam auguriis pat rum et prisca form idine
sacram om nes eiusdem sanguinis populi legat ionibus coeunt caesoque publice
hom ine celebrant barbari rit us horrenda prim ordia. est et alia luco reverent ia:
nem o nisi vinculo ligat us ingredit ur, ut m inor et pot est at em num inis prae se
f er en s, si f or t e pr olapsu est . at t oli et in su r ger e h au d licit u m : per h u m u m
evolvunt ur. eoque om nis superst it io respicit , t am quarn inde init ia gent is, ibi
regnat or om nium deus, cet era subict a at que parent ia. adicit auct orit at em fort una
Sem nonum : cent um pagi iis habit ant ur, m agnoque corpore efficit ur ut se Sueborum
caput credant .

7KH5HFODP W UDQVODW LRQRI'U0D[2EHUEXUJHULVDVIROORZV ³ 7KH6HP QRP LFODLP

W R EH W KH ROGHVW  DQG P RVW  QREOH W ULEH RI W KH 6XHEL  7KHLU FODLP  W R KDYH ROG DJH
ILQGV SU RRI LQ U HOLJLRQ  $W  D SU HGHW HU P LQHG W LP H W KH DP EDVVDGRU V RI DOO NLQ
SHRSOHV FRQJUHJDW H LQ D VDFUHG IRUHVW  W KDW  GHP DQGV GHYRW LRQ EHFDXVH LW  ZDV
FRQVHFUDW HGE\W KHDQFHVW RUVDQGKDVROGDJHDQGW KH\EHJLQW KHUHZLW KKXP DQ
VDFULILFH D KRUUHQGRXV FHOHEUDW LRQ RI W KHLU EDUEDULF VHUYLFH W R W KH JRGV  7KLV
SODFH KDV DOVR DQRW KHU IRUP  RI ZRUVKLS  (YHU\ERG\ KDV W R HQW HU  LW  W LHG XS DV D
V\P ERO RI VXEP LVVLRQ RI W KH RP QLSRW HQFH RI W KH JRG  , I VRP HRQH IDOOV W R W KH
JURXQG KH LV QRW  DOORZHG W R VW DQG XS RU EH OLIW HG XS KH KDV W R UROO KLP VHOI RXW
RI W KH IRUHVW   7KHVH FXVW RP V KDYH DV W KHLU EDVLV D EHOLHI W KDW  KHUH ZDV W KH
FUDGOHRIW KHSHRSOHW KDW KHUHLVW KHJRGZKRUXOHVHYHU\W KLQJDQGW KDW HYHU\W KLQJ
HOVHLVGHSHQGHQW DQGVXEM HFW 7KLVEHOLHILVVXSSRUW LQJW KHOXFNRIW KH6HP QRQL
W KH\  OLY H LQ  FRXQW LHV  DQG EHFDXVH W KLV ODU JH SRSXODW LRQ W K H\  FRQVLGHU
W KHP VHOYHV W R EH W KH UXOHUV RI W KH 6XHEL´

:HLVKDDU W UDQVODW HV DV IROORZV   ³ 7KH\ W HOO XV W KDW  W KH 6HP QRQL DUH W KH P RVW
QREOH DQG KRQRUDEOH W KH ROGHVW  DULVW RFUDW V"  RI W KH 6XHEL   W KLV DVVXP SW LRQ LV
VROLGLILHGE\DUHOLJLRXVFXVW RP IURP ROGW LP HV$W DVSHFLILFW LP HFRQJUHJDW HW KH
GHOHJDW HVRIDOOIRONZLW KW KHVDP HEORRGLQDIRUHVW ZKLFKLVVDFUHGDQGZRUVKLSSHG
VLQFH DQFLHQW  W LP HV DQG DOVR EHFDXVH W KHU H W KHLU  DQFHVW RU V SU DFW LFHG W KHU H
DOUHDG\UHOLJLRXVDFW LYLW LHVDQGGLYLQDW RU\FXVW RP V+HUHW KH\ EULQJE\NLOOLQJD
P DQLQIURQW RIDOO RUXQGHUGLUHFW LYHVRIW KHVXSHULRUV W KHKRUUHQGRXVRULJLQRI
 

W KHURXJKDQGIRUHLJQDFW RIFRQVHFUDW LRQW RDFHOHEUDW LRQ$OVRDQRW KHUZRUVKLS

LV JLYHQ W R W KH IRUHVW    1RERG\ FDQ HQW HU ZLW KRXW  EHLQJ W LHG XS W KLV ZD\ W KH
SRZHU RI W KH GLYLQLW \ LV DFNQRZOHGJHG DV EHLQJ VXSHULRU  , I VRP HRQH IDOOV KH LV
QRW  DOORZHG W R ULVH RU W R EH OLIW HG E\ RW KHUV EXW  W KH\ DUH UROOHG DZD\ RQ W KH
JURXQGDQGW KLVVDFUHGFXVW RP LVW RVKRZW KDW W KHIRONDVDZKROHKDGLW VRULJLQ
W KHUHDQGW KHUHZDVW KHKLJKHVW RIJRGVDQGHYHU\W KLQJHOVHZDVGHSHQGHQW DQG
VXEM HFW $OVRW KHSRZHURIW KH6HP QLRQLLQFUHDVHVW KHLUUHSXW DW LRQ FRXQW LHV
DU H LQKDELW HG E\ W KHP  DQG IU RP  W KDW  ODU JH SRSXODW LRQ U HVXOW V W KDW  W KH\ DU H
FRQVLGHUHG W KH OHDGHU RI W KH 6XHEL

7KLV LV W KH IDP RXV SDVVDJH LQ W KH *HUP DQLD RI 7DFLW XV  7DFLW XV LV DOZD\V XVHG
ZKHQ LW  FRP HV W R SXW  XV GRZQ  7DFLW XV LV XVHG E\ SUHM XGLFHG VFKRODUV DQG E\
W KRVH ZKR KDYH HYLO DW W LW XGHV DJDLQVW  XV W R ³ SURYH´  W KDW  W KH DQFLHQW  *HUP DQV
ZHUHM XVW DQRW KHUW \SHRIVDYDJHV$VVRRQDVDFOHDUO\VHHLQJ*HUP DQVXFKDV
*XLGR /LVW  'U :LOVHU YRQ :HFXV DQG RW KHUV JLYHV DQ DGHTXDW H GHVFULSW LRQ RI
RXU DQFHVW RUV W KHUH LV LP P HGLDW HO\ VRP H ³ ([SHUW ´  ZKR JULQQLQJO\ DFFXVHV RI
³ KXP DQ VDFULILFH´

7KLV SDVVDJH LV HQW LUHO\ P LVXQGHUVW RRG EHFDXVH XQGHU W KH NQRZQ VXJJHVW LRQ
W KH\ ZDQW  W R VHH EDUEDULVP  DW  DQ\ FRVW  EHFDXVH W KRVH SHRSOH KDYH QR LGHD RI
W KHW UXHFXOW XUHRIW KH*HUP DQLFSHRSOHVDQGEHFDXVHW KRVHSHRSOHDUHJHQHUDOO\
W KRXJKW OHVV(YHQLIW KHLQW HUSUHW DW LRQZDVFRUUHFW W KH*HUP DQVZRXOGQRW KDYH
EHHQ GLIIHUHQW  W KDQ W KH SHRSOHV RI DOO DQFLHQW  FXOW XUHV ZKHUH KXP DQ VDFULILFH
ZDV QRW  VHOGRP   %XW  HYHQ LI W KH\ ZHUH SUDFW LFHG E\ RXU DQFHVW RUV W KH\ ZRXOG
EH VRP HW KLQJ HQW LUHO\ GLIIHUHQW   3UHM XGLFHV DQG FRQFHLW  LJQRU DQFH EXW  RIW HQ
DOVR ZLOOIXOQHVV FDXVH VXFK IDOVH DQG LQDFFXUDW H W UDQVODW LRQV  7KH W UDQVODW LRQ RI
:HLVKDDU VRXQGV GLIIHUHQW  LQ LP SRUW DQW  VHFW LRQV DQG ZH OHDYH LW  XS W R KLP  W R
H[DP LQH W KH P DLQ SDVVDJHV EHW W HU DQG W R M XVW LI\ KLV W UDQVODW LRQ

+HUHZHILQGOLW HUDOO\ ³ caesoque publice hom ine celebrant barbari rit us horrenda
prim ordia.”  'U 2EHUP H\HU W UDQVODW HV   DQG KHUH W KH\ EHJLQ ZLW K SXEOLF KXP DQ
VDFULILFH W KH KRUUHQGRXV FHOHEUDW LRQ RI W KHLU EDUEDULF VHUYLFH W R W KH JRGV  7KH
FRUUHFW  ZRUG E\ ZRUG W UDQVODW LRQ LV   7KHUH W KH\ EULQJ E\ IHOOLQJ D P DQ LQ W KH
SUHVHQFH RI DOO RU  E\ RUGHU RI W KH VXSHULRUV  W KH KRUUHQGLI\LQJ ILUVW  RULJLQ RI
DVW UDQJHDQGURXJKFRQVHFUDW LRQW RDIHVW LYHVKRZ7KHUZRUG³ FDHGHUH´ P HDQV
W R W KURZ GRZQ W R IHOO  &HUW DLQO\ W KH URP DQ FRQQHFW V ZLW K W KLV TXLW H RIW HQ W KH
IHOOLQJ LQ W KH P HDQLQJ RI N LOOLQJ  +RZ HY HU LI VRP HRQH LV W KU RZ Q GRZ Q W KH
SHUVRQ GRHV QRW  QHFHVVDULO\ QHHG W R GLH  +DG 7DFLW XV ZDQW HG W R VD\ W KDW  KH
ZRXOG KDYH XVHG ³ QHFDUH LQW HUP LQHUH LQW HUILHFHUH RFFLGHUH  ´


3XOELFHXVXDOO\P HDQV³ LQSXEOLF´ QRW ³ E\RUGHURIW KHVXSHULRUV´

 2PLWWHG
 

3XEOLFHFRXOGQRW M XVW EHW UDQVODW HGZLW K³ LQSXEOLF´ 0RUHSUHFLVHO\LW KDVW KH

P HDQLQJ³ ZLW KDOOSUHVHQW DQGIROORZLQJRUGHUVRISXEOLFSRZHUVUXOHUVOHDGHUV
HW F  3ULP RUGLXP  P HDQV   7KH ILUVW  EHJLQQLQJ W KH ILUVW  RULJLQ  +RUUHQGXV LV
VRP HW KLQJ W KDW  LQVSLUHV DZH RU FRQQHFW HG ZLW K DZH  5LW XV LV D FXOW LF DFW LRQ D
FRQVHFUDW LRQDULW XDODFHUHP RQLDO³ %DUEDULDQV´ W KH5RP DQV DQG*UHHNFDOOHG
DOOSHRSOHZKRZHUHQRW *UHHNVRU5RP DQVEXW ZLW KRXW GHVSLVLQJVLGH P HDQLQJ
ZKLFK FDP H P XFK ODW HU DQG RULJLQDW HG ZLW K XV  7KH 5HFODP  W UDQVODW LRQ W RR LV
LP SHUIHFW  DQG VW LOO LQIOXHQFHG E\ W KH VXJJHVW LRQ RI KXP DQ VDFULILFH

%XW  OHW ¶V FRQW LQXH   'U 2EHUP H\HU W UDQVODW HV  1R RQH HQW HUV LW  W KH IRUHVW  EXW
W LHG XS  7KHUH LV ZULW W HQ   nem o nisi vinculo ligat us ingredit ur.  7DFLW XV SXW V QR
REM HFW  ZLW K LQJUHGLW XU  7KHUHIRUH D EHW W HU W UDQVODW LRQ   QRERG\ HQW HUV RU  KDV
HQW UDQFH YLQFXOROLJDW XVP HDQVOLW HUDOO\ ZLW KDULEERQW LHG ZRXQGDURXQG , W
GRHV QRW  P HDQ W LHG XS  7KDW  OLJDU H P HDQV ³ Z RXQG DU RXQG´  LV LQ W KH /DW LQ
*HU P DQ GLFW LRQQDU \  E\  6FKHOOHU   7KHU H LV SU RRI W KDW  W KH 6XHEL KDG D FXOW 
RUJDQL]DW LRQ DQG FDUULHG HP EOHP V DP RQJ ZKLFK W KH\ KDG DOVR ULEERQV ZKLFK
DUHSUHFXUVRUVRIW RGD\¶VULEERQVFDUULHGE\RUGHUVRIVW XGHQW JURXSV7KHUHIRUH
9LQFXOR OLRJDW XV UHDGV EHW W HU DV ³ ZLW K DQ RUGHU ULEERQ ZRXQG DU RXQG 2U EHW W HU
³ DFFHSW HG LQW R P HP EHUVKLS DQG FRQQHFW HG E\ D VSLULW XDO FRQQHFW LRQ´

1RZ W KH QH[W  VHQW HQFH LV LP SRUW DQW   si fort e prolapsu est  LV W UDQVODW HG UDW KHU
LP SUHFLVHO\ZLW K³ LIVRP HRQHIDOOVW RW KHJURXQG´)RUW HP HDQV E\FRLQFLGHQFH
7KH RULJLQDO P HDQLQJ RI IRUV LV VW LOO LQ W KH )UHQFK ZRUG RI ³ IRUFH´ ZKLFK P HDQV
IRUFH SRZHU  7KH DFW XDO P HDQLQJ RI ³ IRUW H´  LV ³ E\ XVH RI IRUFH´  7KLV VHQW HQFH
LV FRQQHFW HG ZLW K ³ FDHVR KRP LQH´ DQG ZH ZLOO VHH LP P HGLDW HO\ Z KDW  LV P HDQW
ZLW K LW   , I W KH SHUVRQ OHW ¶V VD\ KDV FROODSVHG XQVXVSHFW LQJO\ ZLW K OLJKW HQLQJ
VSHHG KH LV QRW  DOORZHG W R EH OLIW HG XS E\ RW KHUV DQG KH LV DOVR QRW  DOORZHG W R
JHW XSKLP VHOI7KHQDJDLQFRP HVDP LVW UDQVODW LRQ per hum um evolvunt ur GRHV
QRW P HDQKHKDVW RUROORXW RQW KHVRLOEXW  W KH\DUHUROOHGRXW RQW KHVRLO IURP
W KH FLUFOH RI W KRVH W KDW  DUH DURXQG   7KH ZKROH SDVVDJH ORRNV TXLW H GLIIHUHQW O\
ZKHQ W KH W UDQVODW LRQ KDSSHQV ZLW KRXW  SUHM XGLFH DQG FRUUHFW O\  $QG ZKDW  GRHV
W KH QDUUDW LRQ FRQYH\"  :HOO W KLV P HDQV W KDW  W KRVH ZHUH FXVW RP V W KDW  DUH DOVR
LQXVHLQRXUGD\VRIW KH³ P DVRQLF´ W \SHLHDFFHSW DQFHLQW RW KHP DVW HUGHJUHH
VXFK DV W RGD\¶V ³ OD\LQJ D SHUVRQ LQW R W KH FRIILQ´    7KH SDVVDJH VKRZV W KDW  W KLV
³ 0DVRQLF´ ULW XDOLVYHU\DQFLHQW  DQGLQKHULW HGIURP W KH6XHELDQGW KDW LW GLGQRW
RULJLQDW H RQ IRUHLJQ UDFLDO -HZLVK VRLO  , W  LV 8U *HUP DQ DQG DW  EHVW  SDUW LDOO\


2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

M XGDL]HGLQRXUGD\V, W VKRZVW KDW )UHH0DVRQU\LVURRW HGRQYHU\DQFLHQW $ULR

*HUP DQFRQFHSW VDQGFXVW RP VHYHQW KRXJKLW KDVIRUJRW W HQW KLVIDFW FRP SOHW HO\
LQ RXU GD\V DQG GRHV QRW  NQRZ DQ\ P RUH DW  DOO W KH P DLQ SXUSRVH RI W KH DQFLHQW
RUGHU RI W KH 6XHEL  

$QG QRZ ,  DP  JRLQJ W R W HOO W KH P HDQLQJ RI W KH 0DVRQLF ³ OD\LQJ LQW R W KH FRIILQ´
(YHU\RQH FDQ W KHQ VHH YHU\ FOHDUO\ W R ZKDW  7DFLW XV DOOXGHV LQ KLV  W K  FKDSW HU
HYHQ W KRXJK ,  GRXEW  LI KH ZDV FRQVFLRXVO\ DZDUH RI ZKDW  KH DFW XDOO\ GHVFULEHG
7KH GHVFULSW LRQ LV D ELW  FRQIXVHG DQG LW  FDQ ZHOO EH W KDW  W KH SHUVRQ W HOOLQJ KLP
ZDV QRW  D SHUVRQ ZKR NQHZ DQG W KDW  KH KDG RQO\ D SRRU FRQFHSW  RI W KH ULW XDO
6XFK FXVW RP V RI W KH RUGHUV RI DOO W LP HV ZHUH VXUURXQGHG E\ P \VW HU\ DQG W KH\
ZHUH W KH RULJLQ RI P DQ\ IDLU\ W DOHV IRU W KH RUGLQDU\ QRQ LQLW LDW HG SHRSOH  

$W W KHLQLW LDW LRQW RP DVW HUVKLSLQW R)UHH0DVRQU\W KHM RXUQH\P DQLVSXW LQIURQW
RI D FRIILQ RU W KH FRS\ RI D W RP E  7KHUH KH LV W ROG W KH KLVW RU\ RI +LUDP  W KH
IRXQGHU RI W KH RUGHU RI )UHH 0DVRQU\ DV IROORZV   6RORP RQ ZDQW HG W R EXLOG W KH
W HP SOH LQ -HUXVDOHP  DQG IRU W KDW  KH FDOOHG XSRQ ZRUNHUV IURP  DOO FRXQW ULHV DQG
P DGH W KH DUW LVW  +LUDP  W KHLU OHDGHU  +H VHSDUDW HG W KH ZRUNHUV LQ W KUHH FODVVHV
LQRUGHUW RDYRLGFRQIXVLRQLQVXFKDODUJHQXP EHURIZRUNHUV LQW RDSSUHQW LFHV
M RXU QH\ P HQ DQG P DVW HU V  7KU HH DP ELW LRXV M RXU QH\ P HQ Z DQW HG W R EHFRP H
P DVW HUV EHIRUH W KHLU M RXUQH\P DQ \HDUV ZHUH XS  7KH\ ZDQW HG W R ILQG RXW  W KH
VHFUHW  RI P DVW HU\ E\ IRUFH DQG ZD\ODLG +LUDP  ZKHQ KH OHIW  W KH W HP SOH DQG RQH
RI W KHP  NLOOHG KLP  ZLW K D VW ULNH DW  KLV IRUHKHDG EHFDXVH KH GLG QRW  ZDQW  W R W HOO
W KH VHFUHW   7KHQ W KH\ EXULHG KLP 

$W W KHLQLW LDW LRQW REHDP DVW HUW KHLQLW LDW HLVW ROGW KDW +HUHFHLYHVW KHQDVW ULNH
XSRQKLVIRUHKHDGIDOOVLQW RW KHFRIILQRURQW RW KHW RP EDQGU HP DLQVW KHUHXQW LO
KH LV OLIW HG XS DQG DFFHSW HG LQW R W KH P DVW HU GHJUHH ZLW K W KH DSSURSULDW H ZRUGV
7KH VHHP LQJ NLOOLQJ LV GHVLJQHG W R JLYH W KH LQLW LDW H VHYHUDO VHFUHW V  +HUH ,  JLYH
RQO\DELW RIDQH[SODQDW LRQ7KHFDQGLGDW HLVVKRZQW KDW OLN H+LUDP KHVKRXOG
SUHIHU GHDW K W R EHW UD\LQJ W KH VHFUHW V RI W KH P DVW HU GHJUHH

7KLV V\P EROLF SXW W LQJ LQW R W KH FRIILQ W KH ³ G\LQJ´  RI W KH ³ ROG´  SHUVRQ W KH $GDP 
DQGW KHUHVXUUHFW LRQW KHUH ELUW KRIKH³ QHZ´ SHUVRQW KH³ &KULVW ´W KH³ DQRLQW HG
RQH´ LQLW LDW HG QHZ P DVW HU ZDV D ULW XDO FXVW RP  RI W KH DQFLHQW  P \VW HULHV ZKLFK
LV DOVR IRXQG LQ W KH (J\SW LDQ SULHVW  VFKRROV 


2PLWWHG

7KLVVHFUHF\W RRLVVRP HW KLQJW KDW KDVEHHQREVHUYHGZLW KP RVW ³ SULP LW LYH´ FXOW XUHVLQ
UHIHUHQFHW RW KHLULQLW LDW LRQULW XDOV

2PLWWHG
 

7KLVLVW KHSURFHVVRILQLW LDW LRQRIZKLFK7DFLW XVW HOOVXV 2QDFRQVHFUDW HGSODFH

GHOHJDW HVRIDOO³ ORGJHV´ FRQJUHJDW H$FFHVVKDYHRQO\W KRVHZ KRKDYHDULEERQ
RI W KH RUGHU RU ZKR RW KHUZLVH FDQ GHP RQVW UDW H W KDW  W KH\ EHORQJ LH W KDW  W KH\
DUH SHRSOH ZKR NQRZ RU EUHW KUHQ RI W KH RUGHU  7KH KRUULI\LQJ SURFHVV RI W KH
P XUGHU RI +LUDP  LV VKRZQ RQ D FDQGLGDW H W R P DVW HUVKLS  +H LV VW UXFN GRZQ LV
QRW DOORZHGW RULDVHW LOOW KHHQGRIW KHFHUHP RQ\DQGLVUHP RYHGIRUDVKRUW W LP H
IURP  W KH FLUFOH DV DQ DSSDUHQW  FRUSVH

(YHQ D QDLYH SHUVRQ P D\ KDYH UHFRJQL]HG E\ QRZ ZKDW  W KH VXSSRVHG ³ KXP DQ
VDFULILFH´  RI RXU DQFHVW RUV LQ W KH *HUP DQLD RI 7DFLW XV ZDV LQ UHDOLW \  , P SRUW DQW
LVDOVRW KHH[SUHVVLRQRI7DFLW XV³ P DJQRTXHFRUSRUH´ZKLFKKDVQRW P XFKW RGR
ZLW K D ODUJH SRSXODW LRQ EXW  D ODUJH JURXS  +HUH ZH DOVR P HQW LRQ W KH NQLJKW LQJ
FHUHP RQ\ DQG W KH VR FDOOHG GHSRVLW LRQ RI W KH VW XGHQW V W LOO   XSRQ EHLQJ
DFFHSW HG LQ W KH XQLYHUVLW \

+HU H Z H JLY H W Z R H[ DP SOHV RI -XGDL]DW LRQ  L H  KLGLQJ W KH FXVW RP V EHKLQG
-XGHR &KULVW LDQV\P EROLVP VLQRUGHUW RSUHYHQW SURVHFXW LRQDQGH[HFXW LRQ7KLV
SURFHVVZDVODW HUIRUJRW W HQZKHQSHRSOHEHJDQW RFRQVLGHUW KH³ ELEOLFDOFRYHU XS ´
DV W KH RULJLQDOO\ $U\DQ RULJLQ  7KH *HUP DQLF VRZHU ;DOSLDQQ  KDLO KHDOLQJ  
P DQEHFDXVH³ VDO´ LV+HLO /DW LQVDOXV EHFRP HVW KHHQW LUHO\QRQ KLVW RULFDONLQJ
³ 6DORP RQ´)URP , UP LQ+HUP DQQ$UP DQW KHEXLOGHURIW KHZRUOGDQGKLVSULHVW V
ZKRHUHFW HGW KH, UP LQVXOFROXP QVV\P EROVRIW KHXQLYHUVHW KH\P DGH+LUDP RU
+LUP RQ W KH EXLOGHU RI W KH ³ W HP SOH RI -HUXVDOHP ´ ZKLFK QHYHU ZDV EXLOW  LQ W KH
IDVKLRQW KDW W KHERRNRI6DORP RQW HOOVXVW KHP HDVXUHP HQW VRIZKLFKKRZHYHU
DUHFRVP LFQXP HULFUHODW LRQVE\ZKLFKW KH³ W HP SOHEHFRP HVDJDLQDV\P ERORI
W KHXQLYHUVH-HUXVDOHP ZKHW KHUW KHFLW \LQ3DOHVW LQHRUD³ KHDYHQO\-HUXVDOHP ´
LV LQ RXU ODQJXDJH   ³ +HUH 8U 6DOHP ´   +LHU LV KHUH ³ KLHUR´ KRO\ LQ *HUP DQ VW LOO
³ KHKU ´  LQ W KH P HDQLQJ RI KRO\ VDFU HG  8U  LV VHOI H[ SODQDW RU \  DQG VDOHP  LV
VDOKHLP   6R W KLV W HP SOH LV LQ W KH VDFUHG 8U 6DOKHLP  LQ W KH FHOHVW LDO -HUXVDOHP
DQGLVFDOOHGW KHFDVW OHRI=LRQRI=HXV :KHQ7LW XVFRQTXHUHG-HUXVDOHP KH
GHVW UR\HGZLW KW KHW HP SOHW KHP RUW JDJHEDQNRIW KH5RP HRIW KH&HVDUVZKLFK
FRXOGP DNHLW VZDUVIRUDORQJW LP HZLW KP RQHW DU\KHOSRIW KH-HZV 7LW XVIUHHG
W KH 5RP DQ HP SLUH E\ GHVW UXFW LRQ RI W KLV ZRUOG EDQN DQG E\ W DNLQJ RYHU LW V JROG
U HVHU Y HV   &LW LHV Z LW K W KH QDP H RI 6DOVW lW W HQ H[ LVW  E\  W KH KXQGU HGV LQ W KH
*HUP DQLFDUHDEXW HVSHFLDOO\LQ*HUP DQ\DQGKHUHW KHZRUG³ VDO´ P HDQVDOZD\V
³ +HLO´  6DO DQG YLFW RU\   7KDW  LV W KH +HDO 5XQH RI W KH OLJKW QLQJ RI =HXV DQG W KH
7HXW 


2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

1RZLW LVXSW RW KHUHDGHUW RGLVFHUQEHW ZHHQOHJHQGDQGKLVW RU \W UXW KDQGSRHW LF

FU HDW LRQ    , W V Q RW  VX U SU LVLQ J W K HU H W K DW  W K HVH FRX Q W U LHV DOZ D\ V K DG $U \ DQ
VHW W OHP HQW V DQG W KDW  W KH FUXVDGHUV IRXQG LQ /HEDQRQ VW LOO EORQG QRQ 6HP LW LF
W ULEHV ZLW K ZKRP  W KH\ FRXOG FRP P XQLFDW H LQ *HUP DQ  

, IW KH*HUP DQVSUDFW LFHGKXP DQVDFULILFHRUQRW W KLVTXHVW LRQKDVQRW KLQJW RGR
ZLW K W KH KHLJKW  RI W KHLU P RUDOLW \    ,  KRSH LQ IDFW  ,  NQRZ W KDW  W KH *HUP DQLF
SHRSOHV SU DFW LFHG KXP DQ VDFU LILFH DOVR LQ LW V KLJKHVW  IRU P  DV VHOI VDFU LILFH
:KDW HYHU+lP OLQJV ZRXOGVD\DJDLQVW W KDW ZRXOGEHK\SRFULV\2QDYHU\KLJK
OHYHO RI LQVLJKW  W KLV W RR ZLOO EH XQQHFHVVDU\  7RGD\ ZH GR QRW  NQRZ DQ\P RUH
XQGHU ZKLFK VKRZHUV RI VDQFW LILFDW LRQ W KHVH SHRSOH FRQGXFW HG VXFK DFW LRQV  7R
W KLQN  DERXW  EORRGOXVW  Z RXOG U DLVH W KH VXVSLFLRQ W KDW  RQH KDV VXFK SU REOHP V
KLP VHOI  $ SHRSOH ZKR ZLOOLQJO\ IROORZV W KH OHDGHU LQW R GHDW K LV P RUDOO\ KLJKHU
W KDQ W KH VDP H SHRSOH LQ DQRW KHU W LP H LQ ZKLFK LW  SUHIHUV W R EH VODYH W R EHLQJ
GHDG LQ D W LP H ZKHUH FRZDUGLFH EHFDP H ODZ  7KH DQFLHQW  SHRSOH SUHIHUUHG
GHDW KW REHLQJDOLYLQJFRUSVH2QRXUVRLOZHH[SHULHQFHGKXQGUHGVRIW KRXVDQGV
RI VW DNHV DQG KXP DQ VODXJKW HU KRXVHV LQ 5XVVLD DIW HU W KH ZRUOG ZDU ³ IRU W KH
VDNH RI IDLW K´  , Q ERW K FDVHV W KH VXEKXP DQ KDV VHL]HG SRZHU RYHU KLV QDW XUDO
P DVW HU V

6W LOOLQRXUGD\VZHDUHNLOOLQJKXP DQVEDVHGRQVRP HSDUDJUDSKVZKLOHZHDUH

UHDGLQJW KHP W KHLUGHDW KVHQW HQFHVF\OLQGHURQW KHKHDGDQGLQFRDW VDQGW DLOV
7KLVLVNLOOLQJRIKXP DQVZLW KRXW UHFRQFLOLDW LRQZLW KRXW FRQVRODW LRQZKLFKKXP DQ
VDFULILFH DOZD\V ILQGV LQ W KH XQLTXH SUHIHUHQFH W KDW  LW  LV DJUHHDEOH W R W KH JRGV
7KHVDFUHGDFW LVDFFRP SDQLHGZLW KRXW IHHOLQJVRIKDW HSXQLVKP HQW RUUHYHQJH
, Q IDFW  ,  DP  FRQYLQFHG W KDW  GHHSHVW  ORYH IRU OLIH DQG W R W KH YLFW LP  ILOOHG W KH
KHDUW V EHFDXVH EHLQJ VDFULILFHG ZDV DOZD\V D SULYLOHJH DQG UHFRQFLOLDW HG YLFW LP
DQG VDFULILFLQJ SHRSOH LQ W KHLU EHOLHI RI D GHDW K W KDW  EULQJV Z HOOQHVV

7KH VDFULILFH RI , VDDF E\ $EUDKDP  W R W KH FRQW UDU\ KDV QR UHDVRQDEOH LQQHU DQG
RXW HUP HDQLQJ$KRUULEOHW HVW DFUXHOXVHOHVV³ M RNH´ RIDVW LOOP RUHFUXHO³ JRG´
ZLW KDZHDNDQGGXP EIDW KHUZKRVHREHGLHQFHVHHP VLQKXP DQW RXV7KLVVW RU\
ZRXOG EH UHDOO\ VW XSLG LI ZH KDG W R W DNH LW  OLW HUDOO\  $JDLQ LW  LV .DKOD VHFUHW
ODQJXDJHDQGSRLQW VW RVRP HW KLQJTXLW HGLIIHUHQW ZKLFKZHZLOOQRW FRQW LQXHW R
H[DP LQHKHUHEXW ZKLFKVKRXOGEHW DVNRIUHVHDUFKEDVHGRQW KHVHFUHW GRFW ULQH

2PLWWHG


3HUKDSVDQHP XODW LRQRIW KHFUHDW LRQRIW KHZRUOGIURP W KHSDU W VRIW KHVODLQJLDQW <P LU7KLV


VHHP VOLNHO\DW OHDVW LQYHU\HDUO\*HUP DQLFW LP HV


 K\EULGV
 

7KHVDFULILFHRI, SKLJHQLDRQ$XOLVE\W KHKLJKSULHVW .DOFKDVZKLFKQDP HKDVD

VW ULNLQJ VLP LODULW \ W R W KH +LJK SULHVW  .DLSKDV  ZKR ZDQW V W KH VDFULILFH RI -HVXV
KDV VRP H GHHSHU UHDVRQV  1R P DW W HU KRZ ZH M XGJH W KHVH OHJHQGV DW  OHDVW  ZH
VKRXOG QRW  XVH D GRXEOH VW DQGDUG RQ VXFK W KLQJV  :KDW  LV ULJKW  IRU W KH DQFLHQW
-HZV DQG *UHHNV VKRXOG EH OLNHZLVH ULJKW  IRU W KH DQFLHQW  *HUP DQV

7KH GHDW K RI -HVXV RI 1D]DUHW K W KH ZD\ LW  LV W ROG LQ W KH JRVSHOV DV D IDFW  LV
QRW KLQJHOVHEXW VXFKDVDFULILFHRIDW RQHP HQW , W LVQRW HYHQDW KLVIUHHZLOO, I
KH KDG EHHQ FDSDEOH GXH W R KLV GLYLQH SHUIHFW  SRZHU W R DYRLG KLV GHDW K RQ W KH
VXSSRVHG FURVV KH VKRXOG KDYH GRQH VR DQG W KDW  IRU W ZR UHDVRQV   )LUVW  LQ
RUGHU QRW  W R P DNH KXP DQV JXLOW \ IRU KLV GHDW K EHFDXVH KH *RG OHQW  KLV ERG\
DV D GHFR\ VR W R VD\ W KHQ VHFRQGO\ EHFDXVH ³ *RG´  FDQQRW  EH VDFULILFHG E\
KXP DQV*RGRUP DQERW KKDYHW RVDFULILFHW KHP VHOYHVDQGW KHVDFULILFHRIERW K
FDQQRW  UHGHHP  DQ\RQH HOVH EXW  W KHP VHOYHV

$V IDU DV QRZ W KH TXHVW LRQ RI KXP DQ VDFULILFH E\ W KH *HUP DQV LV FRQFHUQHG
7DFLW XVFRUUHFW O\UHSRUW VW KDW W KH6HP QRQLZHUHW KHP RVW YHQHUDEOHDQGQREOHRI
W KH6XHEL7KH5RP DQVRIW KHQDQGW KH5RP DQLFVRIW RGD\ZHUHDOZD\VJRRGLQ
W ZLVW LQJ QDP HV EHFDXVH W KHLU W RQJXHV GLG QR ORQJHU P DQDJH W KH P RUH RULJLQDO
VRXQGVRIW KHROGHU*HUP DQLFODQJXDJHRXW RIZKLFKW KH\GHJHQHUDW HG7KHUHIRUH
7DFLW XV VSHDNV RI 6HP QLRQL LQVW HDG RI 6DP  0DQHQ 6DHP DQHQ RU 6DOP DQHQ  , Q
W KLVZRUGLVKLGGHQW KHFRQFHSW RIVHHGW RVRZEXW DOVRVSLULW XDOVHHGNQZROHGJH
IURP  ZKLFK ZHOOQHVV LV FRP LQJ   8U $U\DQ URRW  Vl VDP  VDO  7KH 6DP DQHQ RU
6DOP DQHQ EHORQJ W KHU HIRU H W R W KH KLJKHVW  LQW HOOHFW XDO DU LVW RFU DF\  DQG EORRG
DULVW RFUDF\

:H KDYH W R ORRN IRU W KH ORFDW LRQ RI W KH 6XHEL ZLW K W KHLU P DLQ KRO\ SODFH LQ W KH
1RUW K7KH%DOW LF6HDKDGW KHQDP H³ 6XHELF6HD´ LQROGW LP HV6FKZLHEXVLVVW LOO
D QDP H RI D W RZQ ZKLFK OLNH P DQ\ RW KHUV UHIHUV W R W KH 6XHEL

:H KDYH DOVR W R FKHFN RXW  DQG ORRN FORVHU DW  W KH QDP H RI W KH 6XHEL  , W  LV W KH
QDP HRIW KHODW HU6ZHGHV6FKZDEHQHYHQ6ZLVVW KHLP P LJUDW LRQRIZKLFKIURP
6ZHGHQ LV HYLGHQW  DV ZHOO DV RI W KH 6FKZDEHQ IURP  W KH 1RUW K  , Q W KH 6XHYLVK
ZRUG 6FKZHGHQ 1RUGLF 6YHQ 6FKZDEHQ LV DOVR W KH *HUP DQ ZRUG ³ VFKZHLIHQ´
ZDQGHUDURXQG ³ VFKZHEHQ´  IORDW LQW KHDLU , W LVW KRVHZKRZDQGHUDURXQG


 2PLWWHG
 

W KRVH ZKR IORDW  DERYH W KH IRON W KRVH ZKR DUH DW W DFKHG QRZKHUH  EHFDXVH W KH\
DUH W KH SULHVW O\ W ULEH RI W KH JUHDW  IRON RI W KH *RW KV DV LV UHSRUW HG W R XV IURP
DQRW KHU VRXUFH  7KH\ DUH EHVW  W R FRP SDUH ZLW K W KH GUXLGV W R Z KLFK W KH\ QR
GRXEW  EHORQJHG LQ D ODUJHU FRQQHFW LRQ D SULHVW KRRG W KDW  HQFRP SDVVHV DOO VXFK
DV W KH RQH IURP  5RP H ZKLFK W RR GLG QRW  NQRZ DQ\ ERDUGHUV DV DQ RUGHU W KDW
VSUHDG RXW  RYHU P DQ\ FRXQW ULHV

6R ZH KDYH DQ H[FHOOHQW  FRP SDULVRQ W KDW  VKRZV KRZ W KH RUJDQL]DW LRQ RI W KH
URP DQ FKXUFK LV FRSLHG IURP  DQ $U\DQ VDP SOH
 

:HGRQRW NQRZH[DFW O\KRZZHVKRXOGUHODW HW RW KH6XHYHV6XHEHV6FKZDEHQ

6ZHGLVK7KH³ 6FKZHGH´  6FKDQ]H\DVDFW XDO6XHYHQ VFKDQ]HQZLW KDIHZREYLRXV
H[FHSW LRQV DUH DQFLHQW  FXOW LF ORFDW LRQV P RVW  RI W KH W LP H  :LW K W KH 6XHYHV ZH
KDYH W R GR ZLW K D W ULEH DV ZHOO DV ZLW K D FODVV W KH FODVV RI SULHVW V DQG W ULEH RI
SULHVW VW KHVDP HZD\DVW KH/HYLW HVRIW KH-HZVFDP HIRUW KHSULHVW V¶W ULEHDQG
W KHUHIRUH W KH\ P DGH XS W KH SULHVW O\ FODVV  %\ W KH ZD\ ,  VHH LQ W KH ZRUG ³ /HYL´
W KH $U\DQ URRW  OHFK OD\ ODY\ OHYL *URP OHFK /RUHOH\  IRU W KDW  ZKLFK KDV ODLG
GRZQ W KH ODZ W KDW  ZDV ODLG GRZQ LQ W KH VW RQH FLUFOHV  7KH  8U W ULEHV RI W KH
*RW KV W KH JRRG RQHV ZLOO EH IRXQG DJDLQ  7KH\ JDYH W KH VDP SOH IRU W KH 
W ULEHVRIW KH-HZV DQGW KH\FRUUHVSRQGW RW KHW \SHVRIKXP DQVLQW KH]RGLDF

7KH 6XHEL DUH W KH P RYLQJ RQHV W KRVH ZKR IORDW  EHFDXVH RI W KHLU SRQ\ W DLO W KDW
W KH\FDUULHGRQW KHULJKW VLGH  DVVKRZQLQW KHSLFW XUH , VHHKHUHDFRQQHFW LRQ
ZLW KW KH)UHQFKM XLIVW KH³ ZDQGHULQJ´  SRQ\ W DLOHG -HZVVXSSRVHGO\³ W KHSHRSOH
RI*RG´ZKLFKW KH6YHGHV 6XHELZHUHLQUHDOLW \ZKLFKKDGW KHLUQDP HQRW IURP
ZDU OLNH ZDQGHULQJ DURXQG EXW  EHFDXVH W KHLU VSUHDGLQJ W KURXJKRXW  DOO RI W KH
IRONDVDFODVVRISULHVW V:KDW ZHNQRZDERXW W KH-HZVKLVW RULFDOO\FDQQRW OHDG
W R D W UXH LP DJH  +HUH DOO W KLQJV DUH VW LOO LQ GDUNQHVV  7KDW  W KH *RW KV ZHUH W KH
SHRSOHRIJRGDQGQRW W KH-HZVW KHUHLVQRW P XFKLQW HUSUHW LQJDURXQGDQ\P RUH
LQIXW XUHUDQGDOOW KHVR FDOOHGKLVW RULFDO³ SURRIV´ LQW KHROGW HVW DP HQW DUHSLRXV
ZLVKIXO W KLQNLQJ DW  EHVW 

*RW KV *RW HQ  DQG -RW HQ DUH RSSRVLW HV  +RZ ZDV UHDOLW \ P DQ\ W KRXVDQGV RI
\HDUVDJR"7KHUHDIRONRIJRGH[LVW HG7KH\ZHUHW KH*RW KVW KHJRRGRQHV GLH
*XW HQ  YHU\ FHUW DLQO\ QRW  W KH -RW HQ RI -HZV -XGHQ   7KHUHIRUH DQ LP P HQVH
IDOVLILFDW LRQKDGW RKDSSHQZLW KW KHW UDGLW LRQVW KHFRP SOHW HXQFRYHULQJRIZKLFK
VKRXOG EH W KH P RVW  LP SRUW DQW  W KLQJ W KDW  VKRXOG EH XQGHUW DNHQ LQ W KH QDP H RI
FXOW XUHDQGP RUDOV7KLVVKRXOGEHGRQHZLW KRXW SODLQW LIIVDQGDFFXVHGEHFDXVH
HYHQW KRVHZKRW RRNDGYDQW DJHRIW KLVIUDXGFHUW DLQO\GRQRW NQRZDQ\P RUHZKR
W KHIRUJHUVZHUH7KHUHLVQRGRXEW W KDW ZHKDYHW RH[DP LQHW KLV*RW K -HZVW RU\
LQ *HUP DQ\ RU LQ ³ *HUP DQLD´  7R FODLP  3DOHVW LQH DV W KH KRP H RI W KH -HZV LV D
FODLP ZLW KGLUHFRQVHTXHQFHV7KHUHZHUH³ -RW HQ´ DOORYHUW KHZRUOGVLQFHW LP HV
LP P HP RULDOW KHVDP HDVW KHUHZHUH*RW KVLQW KHZKROHZRUOG, QW KHFRXUVHRI
W KH P LOOHQQLD ROG KLVW RU\ RI D SDULD SRHSOH W KH -HZV ZHUH H[SHOOHG IURP  , QGLD
IURP  (J\SW  IURP  P RVW  RI W KH FRXQW ULHV DW  ILUVW  IURP  &HQW UDO (XURSH

$VK LV W KH +HEUHZ QDP H RI W KH FRQVW HOODW LRQ RI W KH JUHDW  GLSSHU  %XW  LW  LV RXU
ZRUOG DVK W KH ZRUOG D[LV ZKLFK LV EHKLQG W KLV ZRUG  7KHUH DU H P DQ\ +HEUHZ
ZRUGV W KH $U\DQ RULJLQ RI ZKLFK LV HDV\ W R UHFRJQL]H   .RVKHU  ³ NHXVFK´ 0LHV
 P LVV


0RUHFRUUHFW O\ RI, VUDHO7KHW ULEH-XGDZDVM XVW RQHRIW KHW ZHOYH

+HXVHVW KHGRXEOHP HDQLQJRI³ VFKZ HLIHQ´ Z KLFKP HDQVW RZDQGHUDURXQGDQG³ VFKZ HLI´
ZKLFKLVW KHW DLORIDKRUVH
 2PLWWHG

 

$W DFLW FRQYHQW LRQGHULYHV$VKNHQDVLP IURP $VKDVIURP W KHGLSSHURU3ROHVW DU

FRP LQJ SRVVLEO\ DOVR DV ³ FRP LQJ IURP  W KH $HVLU ´  7KLV ZD\ W KH (GGD LV DOVR
LQW HUSUHW HG DV (OOD 8U P RW KHU  , Q W KH 5LJVP DO ³ (GGD´  LV W KH P RW KHU RI W KH ILUVW
GDUNUDFHIURP W KHK\EULGL]DW LRQRI+HLP GROOZLW KW KH(W W D7KHGZDUIUDFHRIW KH
:HGGDLQ, QGLDVW LOOFDOOW KHP VHOYHV³ (W W D´ZKLFKW KHDQW KURSRORJLVW VFRQVLGHUW R
EH W KH P RVW  SLW LIXO UDFH  +HUH ZH XQFRYHU W KH VHFUHW  RI W KH ³ SHRSOH RI *RG´  RI
ZKLFK W KH %LEOH W DONV  7KH 6XHEL W KH 6FKZDEHQ DUH W KH ZDQGHU LQJ RQHV W KH
³ M X LI V´  )U HQ FK  N HOW LF W K H ³ 6FK Z LHI ´   HQ GV  LI  Z H X VH *HU P DQ  2U W K RJU DSK \
SKRQHW LFV 

-HZ -HZ HL DUH W KH -X SHRSOH RI W KH -XUD W KH -X KX JRGV W KH +X P DQHQ W KH
+X JRGVW KDW ZHUHZRUVKLSSHGLQW KHSUH .HOW LF(XURSHVW LOOLQW KH.HOW LFHUDRW
HK , ULVK DQG 6FRW W LVK

7KDW W KH)UHQFKZRUG³ -XLI´  6FKZLHI6FKZHLILQGHHGDOLW HUDOW UDQVIHUIURP W KH

*HUP DQLVFOHDUIRUHYHU\RQHZKRNQRZVW KDW W KHODQJXDJHVRIW KH*DXOVDQGRI
W KH*HUP DQLFSHRSOHVDUHDOP RVW W KHVDP HDFFRUGLQJW RW KHW HVW LP RQ\RI6W UDER
VRP HZD\OLNHW ZRGLDOHFW V SOXVW KDW W KH)UDQNV%XUJXQGLDQV)ODP LVK9LVLJRW KV
DQG 1RU P DQV EU RXJKW  *HU P DQLF ODQJXDJHV LQW R W KH FRXQW U \  W KDW  Z HU H N LQ
:KDW HYHU LQ W KH )UHQFK ODQJXDJH LV QRW  GHULYHG IURP  /DW LQ ZKLFK LV UHODW LFHO\
OLW W OH LV QHFHVVDULO\ RI *HUP DQLF RULJLQ ZKHUH W KH .HOW LF W RR KDV W R EH LQFOXGHG
)RUW KLVW KHQRW HGOLQJXLVW (UQVW )XKUP DQQEURXJKW FRQYLQFLQJSURRILQKLVLQJHQLRXV
H[SHULP HQW  ³ 7KH )UHQFK ODQJXDJH D *HUP DQ GLDOHFW ´

7KH6XHEL6FKZDEHQKDGW KHLUKDLULQDNQRW RQW KHVLGHLHW KH6FKZHLI W DLO 

1RZLW ZRXOGEHDP LVW DNHZKLFKLVP DGHUHSHDW HGO\E\UHVHDUFKHUVW RFRQFOXGH
LQ VXFK VLW XDW LRQV W KDW  W KH 6XHEL QDP HG W KHP VHOYHV DIW HU W KH ORQJ KDLU  1R ZH
KDYH W R FRQFOXGH W KH RW KHU ZD\  7KH\ VRXJKW  W R P DNH D YLVLEOH V\P ERO RI W KDW
ZKLFKW KH\ZHUHDQGZKDW W KH\ZHUHFDOOHGLQRUGHUW RH[SUHVVERW K7KHUHIRUH
W KHORQJJURZQKDLUZDVDUUDQJHGLQDNQRW RQW KHVLGHDQGKXQJGRZQLQDORQJ
W DLO 7KH KDLU W KDW  UHP LQGV RI W KH $DU W R W KH 6XQ DOUHDG\ EHFDXVH RI LW V JROGHQ
FRORU EXW  DOVR RQ W KH +DDU W KH KLJK RQH KDG P XFK YDOXH IRU RXU DQFHVW RUV DQG
RIIHU HG P DQ\  P DU N V RI GLVW LQFW LRQ   )XU W KHU P RU H W KH KDLU  KDG DQRW KHU  Y HU \
LP SRU W DQW  IXQFW LRQ DV DQ DQW HQQD IRU  VW U HDP V RI VXEW OH HQHU JLHV  7KLV LV D
SXUSRVH W KDW  QRZDGD\V LV QHJOHFW HG HYHQ P LVW UHDW HG


2PLWWHG
 

7KHVH³ -XLIV´E\ZKLFKZRUGVW KH)UHQFKP HDQW KH-HZVDUHQRW W KH-HZVIURP

QRZDGD\VQRUW KH³ -HZV´ RIZKLFKW KHIUDXGXOHQW 2OG7HVW DP HQW LVVSHDNLQJEXW
W KHVH ³ -XLIV´ -HZ V LQ U HDOLW \  DU H W KH ³ -XW HV´  W KH JRRG RQHV  W KH *RW KV  W KH
*W HQ W KH*RW HQ W KH*RG )RONRIZKLFKW KH%LEOHLVW DONLQJDQGRIFRXUVHQRW
W KH %LEOH DV LW  ZDV SXW  W RJHW KHU E\ (VUD DQG 1HKHP LD IRU W KH SXUSRVHV RI W KDW
SDULDK SHRSOH W KDW  QDP HG LW VHOI +HEUHZV  7KLV ODW W HU ZDV SXW  W RJHW KHU IURP
DQFLHQW  $U\DQ W UDGLW LRQV DV W KH\ IRXQG GXULQJ W KHLU FDSW LYLW \ LQ %DE\ORQ DQG
ZKLFK W KH\ W KHQ P DGH W KH EDVLV RI W KHLU KLVW RU\  ,  DP  W DONLQJ DERXW  W KDW  8U
%LEOH W R Z KLFK DOO DU FKDHRORJLFDO ILQGV DQG W KH W U DGLW LRQV RI DOO SHRSOHV DU H
SRLQW LQJW KHH[LVW HQFHRIZKLFKZDVUHFRJQL]HGORQJDJRE\FRP SDULQJUHVHDUFK
RI KLVW RU\

1RZ  Z H KDY H GHW HU P LQHG W KH *RW KV DV W KH IRON  RI JRG  Z KLFK KDV EHFRP H
XQHTXLYRFDOIURP W KHZRUG HTXDW LRQEHFDXVHODQJXDJHFDQQHYHUEHIDOVLILHGIRU
W KH HDU RI KLP  ZKR FDQ OLVW HQ  :LW K W KLV W UXW K ZH KDYH UHP RYHG D IUDXGXOHQW O\
EDVHG -HZLVK 5RP DQ &KULVW LDQLW \ ZLW K DOO LW V RIIVKRRW V IURP  W KH JDUGHQ RI IDFW V
:KDW  RW KHU P HDQLQJ VKRXOG W KLV GHHS ZRUG KDYH LI ZH FDQ RQO\ VD\ VRP HW KLQJ
W KDW  LV HYLGHQW   :H ZDQW  W R VFUHDP  LW  LQW R W KH HDUV RI DOO KXP DQV VR W KDW  W KH\
OLVW HQ , W LVZURQJZKDW \RXKDYHKHDUGW RW KLVGD\, W LVDOOZURQJ 7KLVLVW KH
ILUVW  VW HS W R \RXU NQRZOHGJH RI VHOI DQG LW  ZLOO EH W KH ILUVW  VW HS W R \RXU JHW W LQJ
EHW W HU E\ ZKHQ UHFRJQL]LQJ \RXUVHOI \RX DOVR UHFRJQL]H W KRVH ZKR VHGXFHG
\RX  'R QRW  EHOLHYH JODXEW  QLFKW  EXW  YRZ JHOREW  DV W KH Z RUG ³ *ODXEHQ´
EHOLHI LQLW VW UXHXQIDOVLILHGP HDQLQJ*HUP DQZKLFKP HDQVFOHDUO\*HUP DQ  
P HDQV  9RZ W KDW  \RX ZDQW  W R JHW  HYLGHQFH \RXUVHOI ILUVW  RI ZKDW  W KH\ KDYH
GHFHSW LYHO\SUHVHQW HG\RXDVW UXW KDQGW KHQEHOLHYHW KDW ZKLFK\RXNQRZ2QO\
W KHQ W KH ZRUG ³ EHOLHYH´  LV QRW  D ZRUG UHIHUULQJ W R D OLH EXW  LW  H[SUHVVHV W KDW
ZKLFK LW  VKRXOG P HDQ DFFRUGLQJ W R LW V 8U P HDQLQJ W KLV P HDQV W R YRZ ZKDW  \RX
NQRZ QRW  W R ³ EHOLHYH´  VRP HW KLQJ

*UHHN SULHVW  RI $SROOR +RP HU +HVLRG $ULVW HDV 2OHQRV DQG RW KHUV UHSRUW  W KDW
$SROOR KLV VLVW HU $UW HP LV DQG KLV P RW KHU /DW RQLD FDP H IURP  W KH ODQG RI W KH
+\SHUERUHDQVW KHRYHU QRUW KHUQODQGVDQGW KDW W KH\KDYHIRXQGHGW KHW HP SOHV
RI 'HORV DQG 'HOSKL  7KHUH LV QR P RUH LQW HUSUHW LQJ DURXQG RQ W KH IDFW  W KDW  W KH
OLJKW  FXOW  DOO RYHU W KH (DUW K FDP H IURP  W KH 1RUW K  7KH , QGLDQ 'HOKL LV W KH VDP H
ZRUG DQG DOVR D SODFH RI VDP H RULJLQ DV W KH 'HOSKL LH IURP  W KH 1RUW K  ,  ZLOO
VKRZ KHUH W KDW  P \ DVVXP SW LRQ EHFRP HV D FHUW DLQW \ DV VRRQ DV LW  LV VSRNHQ  , Q
'HO 'DO 7HLO 7XO 7DO 7ZLHO   DQG P DQ\ RW KHU YDULDW LRQ ZH KDYH IRXQG D NH\
ZRUGIRUW KHVDQFW XDU\IRUW KHODVW ³ 7KXOH´W KHIDUW KHVW P RVW W KHKROLHVW FLW \RI
W KH (DUW K


*ODXEHQ JHOREHQVLP LODUVRXQGLQJZ RUGV7REHOLHYH W RYRZ'HXW OLFK FOHDUO\GHXW
VFK OLFK DFW XDOO\DZ RUGSOD\P RUHW KDQDFRQQHFW LRQ
 2PLWWHG
 

$YDOOH\ 7DO LVW KHUHYHUVDORIW KH'DOOHQDP HO\DEXP SDKLOODP RXQW DLQW KH

UHYHUVHGRIZKLFKLVDJDLQDGLW FKDW RP E, EULQJKHUH'HORV'HOKL'HOSKLDQG
P DQ\ RW KHU 'HOO  DQG 7HOO ZRUGV LQ FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K 7KXOH 7KXOD 7ROHGR DOVR
7ZLHOZKLFK/DW LQZDVGXHOOXP DQGUHFRJQL]HW KHQW KHGHVFULSW LRQRIDVDQFW XDU\
RQ D 7HLO $UDELF  RQ D 'DOOH RQ D KHLJKW   7KH ZRUG 7HLO KDV DOVR D UHODW LRQ W R
³ P DNLQJ W Z R =Z HLXQJ  7Z LHO 7Z LH =Z LH =LHK DQG 7LH W R =Z HLIHO GRXEW 
=Z HL IDOO  =Z LHIDOO  

7KH 3DLULQJ LV W KH FRQVHTXHQFH RI W KH =ZHLXQJ VSOLW  RI W KH JHQGHUV  ,  VHH LQ
W KHVH 7HLO VDQFW XDULHV DERYH DOO DOVR EUHHGLQJ SODFHV LQ W KH VHUYLFH RI W KH OLJKW 
JRG RI $SROO ZKLFK LV FHUW DLQO\ W KH P RVW  EHDXW LIXO RI W KH JRGV OLNH KLV 1RUGLF
FRUUHODW H %DO GHU   ZKLFK OLNH KLP  LV D VRQ RI W KH =HXV RI =LX    ,  EULQJ W KHVH
W KRXJKW V LQ FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K W KH QDP H DQG W KH W DVNV RI W KH VXHEL ZKLFK ZH JRW
W RNQRZDVW KHSULHVW FODVVRIW KH*HUP DQLFSHRSOHV:HKDYHDOUHDG\IRXQGW KH
VLJQLILFDW LRQ RI W KHLU QDP H DQG ZLW K W KDW  ZH DUH QRZ FDSDEOH RI H[SDQGLQJ LW 
7KH GHULYDW LYHV RI 6XHYHQ 6ZHQ 6FKZDEHQ 6FKZHGHQ DQG 6ZLW ]HU ODQG LV W RR
RIW HQ SURYHQ W KDW  LW  FDQQRW  EH GHQLHG DQ\ P RUH  )URP  W KH   W RGD\ YDOLG   6YHQ
 6ZHGH DQG 6XHYH -XLI DQG 6FKZHEHQ W R IORDW  LW  LV QRW  W RR EROG D M XP S W R
6ZDQ *HUP DQ 6FKZDQ  ZKLFKEHLQJDW \SLFDOO\1RUGLFELUGEHORQJVW RW KRVH
ZKR³ ZDQGHUDURXQG´, W LVDELUGW KDW ZDQGHUV6RXW KOLNHW KH6YHQH6YlQHW KH
6XHEL W KH ZDQGHULQJ $U\DQV RI W KH 1RUW K    D ZRQGHUIXO SDUDEOH W KDW  LV HYHQ
P RUHVHOI HYLGHQW EHFDXVHW KHVZDQSOD\VDQLP SRUW DQW UROHLQOHJHQGDQGP \W K
RI W KH 1RUW K  :H NQRZ RI W KH VZDQ YLUJLQV  RI W KH 9DON\ULHV ZLW K W KH 6ZDQ
VKLUW VDQGZHEHJLQW RJHW DKXQFKRIVRP HW KLQJLQFRQQHFW LRQZ LW KW KH6FKZDQHQ
6YlQHQ DQG W KH 6XHYL W KH ZDQGHULQJ SULHVW V RI $SROOR RI W KH 3ROH  $SROOR LQ
*UHHNP \W KRORJ\LVUHIHUUHGW RDV³ P DVW HURIW KHVZDQV´ DQG'HOSKLDV³ VHDW RI
W KH P DVW HU RI W KH VZDQV´

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG


2PLWWHG
 

$IW HUZKDW ZDVVDLGKHUHZHP DGHLW FOHDUW KDW IRUW KHSULHVW O\W ULEHRIW KH6XHYL
W KH VHUYLFH RQ $SROOR ZDV D VSHFLDO W DVN  7KH OHJHQGV DQG VW RU LHV RI VZDQV DUH
HVSHFLDOO\  QXP HU RXV DU RXQG W KH VDQFW XDU LHV RI 'HOSKL DQG 'HORV  VR W KDW  LV
VHHP V FRUUHFW  W R VHH DV W KH FRUH RI W KH FXOW  RI $SROOR W KH FRQFHSW LRQ W KH +LJK
EU HHGLQJ

+HUH SHUKDSV LV W KH RSSRUW XQLW \ W R W DON DERXW  W KH ODE\ULQW K  7KH ODE\ULQW K FDQ
EHUHFRJQL]HGDVV\P ERORIW KHYDJLQDW KHZRP EDQGQRZLW EHFRP HVFOHDUZK\
W KH \RXQJ P HQ DQG YLUJLQV DUH VDFULILFHG LQ W KH ODE\ULQW K RI W KH 0LQRW DXU W KH
P DOH DQLP DO W KH 0DQ 6DW \U W KH EHJHW W HU  RI KXP DQV DV Z H FRXOG W UDQVODW H
5XQLFDOO\7KH\ZHUHW KHOXFN\YLFW LP VRIUDFLDOXS EUHHGLQJ7KHVHQREOH\RXQJ
P HQ DQG YLUJLQV GLVDSSHDUHG IRU W KH ZRUOG LQ W KH ODE\ULQW KV LQ W KH VHUYLFH RI D
6RODU EUHHGLQJ UHOLJLRQ DQG ZLW K W KLV ZH FDQQRW  GHQ\ DQ\P RUH W KH FKDUDFW HU RI
W KHV\P EROVRI&KULVW DVKDYLQJRULJLQDW HLQDSXUHUDFLDOUHOLJLRQ7KHFKXUFKKDV
W ZLVW HG DOO KLJK EUHHGLQJ LQW R QRQ EUHHGLQJ  :LW K W KH SK\VLFDO XS EUHHGLQJ LW
KDV DOVR EORFN HG DQG HY HQW XDOO\  GHVW U R\ HG W KH VSLU LW XDO DQG LQW HOOHFW XDO XS
EUHHGLQJ  7KH SLFW XUH VW LOO VKRZV W KH QXP EHU ILYH W KH QXP EHU RI 9HQXV W KH
³ 'UXLG IRRW ´  7KH QXP EHU IRXU LV JLYHQ E\ W KH FURVV W KH IRXU IRRW  W KH ³ ILUH´ 
IRRW %XW IRRW  IRV EHJHW W LQJEUHHGLQJ7KHILYH IHP  6FDQGLQDYLDQIRU 
)HKP H M XVW LFH  DQG W KH    9LHUXQJ IRXU SDUW  )KU XQJ   OHDGHUVKLS  JLYH
W RJHW KHU W KH  FRP SOHW LRQ

7KHGHVLJQVRQW KHYHVVHOOHDYHQRGRXEW FRQFHUQLQJW KH

ODE\ULQW KIRUW KHVHUYLFHRIKXP DQEUHHGLQJ7KHODE\ULQW K
KDV W KH 5XQLF LQVFULSW LRQ   RI ³ 7URLD´  DQG VKRZV W KDW  W KH
VLW HV RI W KH W HP SOHV W KH VW RQH FLUFOHV DUH DOVR SODFHV
IRUEHJHW W LQJ7KHW UDGLW LRQRIW KH6W RQHGDQFHVZLW KW KH
ZHGGLQJV EHVSHDNV D P LOOHQQLD ROG ODQJXDJH  5LJKW  RI
W KH ODE\ULQW K DUH GHVLJQV RI VH[XDO XQLRQ  2Q W KH OHIW
VLGHW KH³ SURGXFW V´VRW RVD\H[LW $W W KHYDJLQDRIW KH
ODE\ULQW KLVW KHFURVVV\P ERORIFUXFLIL[LRQRIXQLILFDW LRQ
RI W KDW  ZKLFK LV RI W KH KHDYHQ ZLW K W KDW  ZKLFK LV RI W KH
(DUW K DOVR LQ LW V &KULVW LDQ P HDQLQJ

&URFN RI 7DJOLDW HOOD

3DUW LDO GHVLJQ RQ W KH FURFN  ULGHUV RQ KRUVHEDFN OHDYH W KH ODE\ ULQW K

2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

/DE\ULQW KV RQ FRLQV IURP  .QRVVRV &UHW H  EFH

7UR\D FDVW OH E\ :LVE\ RQ W KH LVODQG RI *RW ODQG

7KH SUHYLRXV GHVLJQV VKRZ ODE\ULQW KV RQ FRLQV RI .QRVVRV RQ &UHW H W KH W KLUG
ODU JH SLFW XU H VKRZ V D VHW W LQJ RI VW RQHV  D ³ 7U RM D FDVW OH´  FORVH W R :LVE\  RQ
*RW ODQG  $ ODE\ULQW K LV DOVR IRXQG RQ W KH 6ZHGLVK URFN SDLQW LQJV RI %RKXVOlQ
7KLV VSLUDO W KDW  UHIHUV W R W KH VRXUVH RI W KH 6XQ DV LW  LV REVHUYHG LQ 1RUW KHUQ
ODW LW XGHV ILQGV LW V V\P EROLF H[SUHVVLRQ LQ W KH 7URM D FDVW OHV LQ W KHVH ODE\ULQW KV
:H ILQG W KHVH UHSUHVHQW DW LRQV DOVR LQ HDUO\ )UHQFK DQG , W DOLDQ FKXUFKHV DOO RI
ZKLFK ZHUH VW LOO XQGH W KH LQIOXHQFH RI W KH LP P LJUDQW V IURP  W KH 1RUW K  $V W KH
LVODQGRI'HORVZDVDSODFHLQVHUYLFHRIW KH1RUGLF3RKO%DOGXU$SROORW KLVZD\
W KH ODE\ULQW KV LQ W KH VRXW K HVSHFLDOO\ &UHW H DSSHDU DV EHLQJ IRXQGHG E\ 7URM D
FDVW OHV W KDW  FDP HIURP W KH1RUW K7KHUHIRUH DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH (GGD 5RP H ZDV
D 7URSM D FDVW OH EHFDXVH W KHUH LV VW LOO ZULW W HQ
 

7KDW  ZKLFK LV FDOOHG 5RP D QRZ ZDV FDOOHG 7URM D IRUP HUO\

7KLV LV RQH RI W KH P RVW  YDOXDEOH UHIHUHQFHV W R W KH UHODW LRQV RI W KH 1RUW K W R W KH
6RXW K ZKLFK UHP DLQHG P RUH FRQVFLRXV LQ W KH 1RUW K W KDQ LQ W KH 6RXW K EHFDXVH
W KH 1RUW K ZDV W KH JLYLQJ DUHD

6ZHGLVKURFNFDUYLQJVIURP /HRQDUGVEHUJ
&DUYLQJV W KDW  ZHUH FRYHUHG ZLW K EXUQW  URFNV DQG P DUNHG ZLW K FKDON

9HU\LP SRUW DQW LVW KHUHW KHGHVLJQRIDODE\ULQW KRQW KHVHURFNFDUYLQJVDFFRUGLQJ

W RZKLFKODE\ULQW KLQW KH1RUW KDUHSURYHQW RKDYHEHHQLQH[LVW HQFHHDUOLHUW KDQ
LQ &UHW H  7KH SLFW XUH LV D JRRG H[DP SOH RI W KH W KRXVDQGV RI UHSUHVHQW DW LRQV RQ
6ZHGLVKURFNFDUYLQJV

7KHUHDOODE\ULQW KVFRQVLVW HGRIDM XP S W UDFNRIVW RQHEORFNV$P RQJW KHODE\ULQW KV

LV W KH RQH RI &UHW H P RVW  NQRZQ EHFDXVH RI W KH OHJHQG RI W KH 0LQRW DXU  , Q
(XURSHW KHUHLVDJUHDW QXP EHURIVXFKDUUDQJHP HQW VLQP DQ\GLIIHUHQW VHW W LQJV
7KHODE\ULQW KVW KDW DUHVW LOOLQH[LVW HQFHLQ6ZHGHQDUHODUJH FLUFOHVW KDW DUHODLG
RXW  ZLW K UHODW LYHO\ VP DOO VW RQH EORFNV  8VXDOO\ W KH\ DUH FDOOHG ³ 7URM D FDVW OHV´
7KLV ZRUG LV QRW  D ORDQ IURP  DQRW KHU ODQJXDJH EXW  LW  LV RULJLQDOO\ 1RUGLF DQG LW
KDV D FKDUDFW HULVW LF DV D 'URM D 'UHLHU W KUHH  ZRUG  $ P RXQW DLQ FORVH W R W KH

 2PLWWHG
 

JUHDW  URFN SDLQW LQJV RI +LP P HOVW DGOXQG LQ 6ZHGHQ KDV RQ W KH P DSV RI W KH  W K
FHQW XU\W KHQDP H³ 7URM DEXUJEHUJ´ DQGLW ZDVXVHGE\W KHFLW \IRUW KHDW HUSOD\V
ILUHZRUNV DQG SURFHVVLRQV

/HW ¶VQHYHUIRUJHW W KDW DOOW UXHUHOLJLRQKDVDVLW VLQQHUP RVW GULYLQJIRUFHW KHXS

EUHHGLQJ RI KXP DQV  :KHUH W KLV JRDO KDV EHHQ ORVW  W KH VSULW  U RW V LQVLGH W KH
ERG\ DV RXU SUHVHQW  VKRZV

, Q 2GLQ¶V FRP SDQLRQVKLS ZH ILQG W KH VZDQYLUJLQV W KH UDYHQV DQG W KH ZROYHV
7KH DQLP DOV RI $SROOR DUH OLNHZLVH W KH VZDQ W KH UDYHQ DQG W KH ZROI  +HUH ZH
Z DQW  W R HP SKDVL]H RQO\  W KH U DY HQ Z KR  Z KHQHY HU  KH DSSHDU V LQ W K H (GGD
³ DOZ D\ V N QRZ V VRP HW KLQJ´  7KH W Z R UDYHQ RI :RGDQ DU H +XJLQ DQG 0XQLQ
³ W KRXJKW DQGW KLQNLQJ´:HW DONHGRQDQRW KHUSRUW LQRIW KHERRNDERXW ³ 5DYHQV´
DQG³ (DJOHV´ DVW KHZLVHRQHVDQGW KHSXVKHUVLQW KHDQFLHQW ZRUOGJRYHUQP HQW 
:LW K W KH UDYHQ RI $SROOR Z H ILQG W R RXU VXUSULVH W KDW  W KLV VHFU HW  W UDGLW LRQ LV
FRUUHFW   7KH $SROOR SULHVW  $ULVW HDV UHSRUW V DFFRUGLQJ W R +HURGRW  RI D OHJHQGDU\
P DQRQW KHLVODQGRI0DUP DUDZKRGXULQJDIRUP HUOLIHW KHSHUP DQHQW FRP SDQLRQ
RI $SROOR LQ W KH VKDSH RI D UDYHQ ZKR KDV DOVR ZULW W HQ DQ (SRSHH IRU W KH EORQG
IRONRIW KH$ULP DVSHQLQW KH1RUW K6HYHUDOHYHQW VFRQFHUQLQJKLVDUHQDUUUDW HG
ZKLFK VKRZ W KDW  KH ZDV D JUHDW  P DJLFLDQ  +H KDV FHUW DLQO\ EHHQ DQ LQLW LDW H RI
$SROOR ZKLFK P HDQV W KDW  KH FRQVHFUHDW HG KLP VHOI W R W KH HVVHQFH RI $SROOR  , Q
DQ\ FDVH ZH VHH W KH FRQFHSW  RI W KH UDYHQ VHYHUDO W LP HV LQ W KH VHQVH RI W KH
GHULYHG³ +HEUHZ´ UDEELZKLFKKRZHYHUZDVRQO\DEHQHILFLDU\RIDGHDGDQGQRQ
XQGHUVW RRG VFULEH NQRZOHGJH

1RZ ZH FDQ DOVR XQGHUVW DQG DQG FODULI\ W KH P \W K RI /HGD ZLW K W KH VZDQ  , W  LV
DOZD\V GXELRXV W R FRQVLGHU RW KHU SHRSOH HYHQ RI W KH SDVW  DV VW XSLG W KDW  W KH\
W DNHW KHVHVW RULHVP \W KVDQGIDLU\W DOHVIRUW UXHM XVW EHFDXVHRXUVFKRODUVW DNH
W KHP  IRU W UXH ZKHQ W KLQNLQJ W KDW  W KH DQFLHQW  SHRSOHV EHOLHYHG LQ LW  OLW HUDOO\
EHFDXVH W KH\ KDYH EHHQ W KDW  ³ EDFNZRRGHG´    7KHUH LV P RUH LQVLJKW  LQW R W KH
IDFW V LI ZH NQRZ W KDW  W KHVH OHJHQGV IDLU\ W DOHV DQG P \W KV DV IDU DV W KH\ DUH
W UXHDQGROGFDUU\ZLW KW KHP DVHFUHW W UDGLW LRQW KDW DUHW ROGLQV\P EROLFODQJXDJH
ZKLFK UHYHDOV LW VHOI W R W KH SHUVRQ ZKR NQRZV DQG IRU ZKRP  W KH\ DUH D UHOLDEOH
VRXUFH RI KLVW RU\

:KR W R W KLV SRLQW  KDV DW W HP SW HG D UDW LRQDO DQG VDW LVI\LQJ H[SODQDW LRQ RI W KH
P \W K RI /HGD DQG W KH 6ZDQ" =HXV ZKR LV W UDQVIRUP HG LQW R D VZDQ YLVLW V /HGD
W KHZLIHRINLQJ7\QGDUHRVDQGEHJHW VW ZRGDXJKW HUV+HOHQDDQG.O\W DLP QHVW UD


2PLWWHG
 

DQG W ZR VRQV .DVW RU DQG 3ROOX[  7KLV LV EHVW LDOLW \ LI W DNHQ OLW HUDOO\ DQG FUD]\
LI ZH ZRXOG EHOLHYH LW   'RHV UHVHDUFK RI P \W KRORJ\ KDV D VDW LVI\LQJ DQVZHU W R
W KLV DQG KXQGU HGV RI VLP LODU  V\ P EROV"  1R   :H JLYH W KH N H\  Z LW K W KH 8U 
ODQJXDJH

=HXV LV W KH EHJHW W LQJ IDW KHU  =HXJH   IDW KHU  W KH IDW KHU  RI $SROOR Z KR Z DV
³ P DVW HU RI W KH VZDQV RI W KH ZDQGHULQJ RQHV RI W KH 6XHEL RI W KH SULHVW V RI W KH
UDFH FXOW  RI W KH $OO$U\DQV´ RI W KH ³ P RVW  EHDXW LIXO´  RI W KH JRGV RI W KH 2O\P SXV

:KHQ=HXVVOHHSVZLW K/HGDDVDVZDQW KH*UHHNKLVW RU\P HDQVW KHXS EUHHGLQJ

RI D UR\DO G\QDVW \ W KH 1RUGLF LQIXVLRQ RI EORRG E\ W KH ³ VZDQV´ ³ 6ZlQH 6YHQH
VXHYL´ LQW KHFORW KLQJRIDP \W KZKLFKLQVXFKLP DJHU\ODVW VW KURXJKW KHP LOOHQQLD
ZKLOH D GU\ ZULW W HQ UHSRUW  ZRXOG ORQJ DJR KDYH EHHQ IRUJRW W HQ GLVW RUW HG DQG
GHVW UR\HG7KLVH[DP SOHVKRZVIRUW KRXVDQGRW KHUVW RULHVW KDW W KHRUDOW UDGLW LRQ
ZKHQFRQFHDOHGLQW KHVHFUHW LP DJHU\RIDP \W KOHJHQGRUIDLU\ W DOHUHP DLQVIRU
D ORQJHU W LP H W KDQ DQ\ LQVFULSW LRQ LQ VW RQH RU EUDVV  7KH OLYLQJ W KRXJKW  LP DJH
SURYHVW REHVXSHULRUW RDQ\LP DJHLQZULW LQJDQDQ\DSSOLFDW LRQ)URP W KDW W KH
DQFLHQW VKDGW KHZLVGRP DQGKDELW QRW W RHQW UXVW W KHLUNQRZOHGJHW RW KHW UDQVLHQW
VFULSW  EXW  W R P HP RU\ W KH LQQHU DQG RXW HU HDU


=HXJHLVDOVRP RGHUQ*HUP DQ
 

9, 
7+(%5($.7+528*+
2) 7+( $5<$1 63, 5, 7

:KDW  ZRXOG EH D JRG ZKR SXVKHG RQO\ IURP  RXW ZDUG
:KR ZRXOG OHW  W KH XQLYHUVH UXQ LQ D FLUFOH RQ KLV ILQJHU
, W  EHKRRYHV KLP  W R P RYH W KH ZRUOG LQ LW V LQVLGH
7R SXW  QDW XUH LQ RQHVHOI W R QXUVH RQHVHOI LQ QDW XUH
6R W KDW  ZKDW  OLYHV DQG ZHDYHV DQG LV ZLW KLQ KLP 
1HYHU P LVVHV KLV SRZHU QHYHU P LVVHV KLV VSLULW 
*RHW KH

:HFDUU\DKLJKQDP H $U\DQV 7KLVZRUGLVDVDQFW XDU\

D W HP SOH IRU XV  :KHQ ZH XVH W KLV ZRUG W KLV LV QRW  LQ
DRQH VLGHGUDFH SROLW LFDOIDVKLRQLQZKLFKZHP HHW W KLV
ZRUGRIW HQLQRXUGD\VEXW LW LVLQDSXUHO\ELRORJLFDODQG
KLVW RU LFDO P HDQLQJ Z KLFK HQDEOHV XV W R VKRZ  FHU W DLQ
FRQQHFW LRQV RI OLQJXLVW LF UHOLJLRXV UDFLDO DQG KLVW RULFDO
NLQG DV FDQQRW  EHHQ DFKLHYHG ZLW K DQ\ RW KHU FRQFHSW 

7KH 8U $U\DQV RXU DQFHVW RUV FDOOHG W KHP VHOYHV W KLV DV OLQJXLVW LF
UHVHDUFK SURYHV W R XV DQG W KHUH LV QR SDUW  RI W KH (DUW K ZKLFK W KH\
ZRXOGQRW KDYHDOUHDG\UHDFKHGLQW KHP RVW UHP RW HSDVW $ULD 6XQ
P HQW KH\FDOOHGW KHP VHOYHVDQGW KH\KDYHEHHQ6XQ P HQVKLQLQJLQ
EHDXW \RIW KHERG\SRZHURIW KHP LQGZDUP W KRIIHHOLQJDQGGHSW K
RI W KH VRXO  $U LV DQ 8U V\OODEOH VDQFW LILHG E\ W KH FHQW XULHV HYHQ
P LOOHQQLD VLQFH LW  ZDV VSRNHQ  , Q P RVW  ODQJXDJHV LW  P HDQV 6XQ VW LOO
LQRXUGD\VRULW VV\P EROW KH(DJOHW KH³$DU ´ZKLFKVW LOOLQRXUGD\V
LVDV\P ERORIW KH6XQRIW KHGLYLQHLW VHOIDSSHDUVLQW KHFRDW RIDUP V
RI W KH *HUP DQ HP SLUH DQ RIIVSULQJ IRON RI W KH $U\DQV  :H KDYH DOO
UHDVRQW RKRQRUW KLV8U ZRUGW KDW W KHJRG P DQXVHGW RUHIHUW RKLP VHOI
DQG W R P DNH LW  DJDLQ RXUV DV RXU 8U QDP H DQG QDP H RI KRQRU  $OO
RW KHUQDP HVDQGFRQFHSW VDSSHDUEHVLGHVW KLVRQHM XVW DV³ LQYHQW HG´
QRP DW W HUKRZLQW HOOLJHQW O\W KHUHDVRQIRUW KHP KDVEHHQHVW DEOLVKHG
7KH ZRUG LW VHOI JLYHV XV LQVLJKW  DV W R ZKHUH ZH FRP H IURP  ZKDW  LV
W KHULJKW W \SHRIRXUP LQGRXUERG\DQGRXUVRXOZKDW RXUIXW XUHFDQ
EH LI ZH ERZ GRZQ W R LW V LP SORULQJ VRXQG  7KH LP P HUVLRQ LQW R RXU
 

³$U \DQ  GRP ´  Z LOO FRQ Q HFW  X V EDFN  DJDLQ  Z LW K  RX U  SDVW   DQ G Z LW K  W K LV VHOI
FRQVFLRXVQHVVDQGVHFXULW \RIVHOIZKLFKKDVEHHQUREEHGIURP XVZLW KVHGXFW LYH
VXE KXP DQ ZKLVSHULQJ

:KR GRHV QRW  NQRZ IURP  ZKHUH KH FRP HV OLNHZLVH GRHV QRW  NQRZ ZKHUH KH LV
VW DQGLQJ DQG P XFK OHVV ZKHUH KH LV JRLQJ

$DU LV W KH HDJOH DQG V\P ERO RI W KH 6XQ W KH $U   5D LV W KH UHYHUVDO RI W KLV ZRUG
LW VP LUURU, QW KHNLQJW KHUHLVW KHIXOOQHVVRISRZHUDQGW KHVSOHQGRURIW KH6XQ
W KHUHIRUH W KH V\OODEOH 5$ 5L 5R 5H P HDQV NLQJ  /DW LQ UH[ ROG 1RUGLF 5HTLQ
, QGLDQ 5LJYHGD 2OG , ULVK ULJ (J\SW LDQ UD $E\VVLQLDQ UDV , QGLDQ UDM D  )D UD R
FRQVLVW VRIW KHVW HP V\OODEOHV)DIRUEHJHW W LQJVHHW KH)D5XQHUDIRU6XQLQLW V
UHYHUVDO P LUURU  LQ W KH NLQJ DQG R IRU W KH VKDSH RI DSSHDUDQFH RQ (DUW K

:HKDYHP HQW LRQHGW KHROG, ULVKULJZKLFKP HDQVDVP XFKDVNLQJDQGZHUHIHU

KHUH W R W KH 5LJV P DO W KH ULJV VRQJ LQ W KH (GGD ZKLFK LV RQH RI W KH ROGHVW  RQHV
DQGZKLFKGHYHORSVKXP DQKLVW RU\LQW KUHHW ULEHVRUFODVVHV, UHODQGW KHUHIRUH
W KH ODQG RI W KH $U\DQV ZDV FORVHVW  W R W KH VXQNHQ $W ODQW LV W KH RULJLQ RI W KH
$U\DQVDFFRUGLQJW RW KHROGHVW W UDGLW LRQV7KLVLVDKLQW W KDW ZHGRQRW IROORZXS
ZLW KLQW KHIUDP HZRUNRIW KLVERRNEXW ZHKDYHW RP HQW LRQLW EHFDXVHLW ZLGHQV
RXU ORRN DW  W KH (GGD LQ D GLUHFW LRQ W KDW  FDQ EH IHUW LOH IRU ODW HU REVHUYDW LRQV  $
EU LHI ORRN  DW  W KH P DS RI W KH $U \ DQ , U H ODQG EU LQJV DQ DU U D\  RI $U  ORFDW LRQV
(UULJDO $UDQ LVODQG (UQVODQG $FKLOO LVODQG  :H DUH QRW  DOORZHG W R GHW HUP LQH
W KH EHJLQQLQJV RI W KH UHYHODW LRQV LQ W KH (GGD RQ KLVW RULFDO HYHQW V DORQH   W KLV
ZRXOG OHDG XV DVW UD\  2I ZKDW  DUH ZH FHW DLQ LQ W KLV DVSHFW "  1RW KLQJ  :H KDYH
W R NHHS RSHQ DOO SDW KV W R W KH DQFLHQW  W LP HV EHFDXVH RXU OLP LW DW LRQV LQ KLVW RU\
GRHV QRW  VW RS KLVW RU\

:H DUH QRW  DOORZHG W R DUW LILFLDOO\ OLP LW  RXU KRUL]RQ E\ VD\LQJ ³ KHUH HQGV ZRUOG
KLVW RU\´ M XVW  EHFDXVH W KHUH LV QRW KLQJ OHIW  RI LW  LQ ZULW LQJ  $ IXW XUH UHVHDUFK RI
KLVW RU\ZLOOILQGQHZZD\VRIUHVHDUFKE\P HDQVRIZKLFKZHZLOODFKLHYHQHYHU
H[SHFW HG UHVXOW V

:H DUH OLYLQJ LQ DQ HUD ZKHUH W KH ULJKW V RI UDFHV DQG SHRSOHV DV IDU DV W KHLU
FKDUDFW HULVW LFVDQGLQGLYLGXDOLW \DUHSURJUHVVLYHO\W DNHQDZD\7KH*HUP DQIRON
W RR KDV D FRP EDW  IRUFHG XSRQ LW  DV IDU DV P DLQW DLQLQJ LW V VSHFLDO FKDUDFW HU LV
FRQFHUQHG LW V FXOW XUH LW V LQERUQ P RUDOV DQG YLHZV   3HRSOH VSHDN OLJKW O\ DERXW
³ SURJUHVV´ RIKXP DQNLQG7KLVSURJUHVVLVFHUW DLQO\DQHUURU LIQRW DIUDXGLVLW
VKRXOG RQO\  FRQVLVW  LQ W HFKQLFDO DFKLHY HP HQW V DQG W KH HP RW LRQDO U DFLDO DQG


2PLWWHG
 

VSLULW XDO QHHGV DUH VXIIHULQJ XQGHU W KLV RQVODXJKW   7KH KLJKHVW  JRDO RI KXP DQ
DFW LYLW \ VKRXOG EH W KH VW ULYLQJ W R DFKLHYH W KH KLJKHVW  LQVLJKW V RI W KDW  ZKDW  LV
RXW VLGH W KH (DUW K DQG DW  W KH VDP H W LP H UHJDUGOHVV RI W KDW  W R P DNH W KLV (DUW K
D KRP H IRU W KH EHVW  RI P DQNLQG DJDLQ  $UH ZH VW LOO IHHOLQJ DW  KRP H LQ W KLV RXU
OLIH RQ W KLV RXU (DUW K"  0RVW  ZLOO KDYH W R DGP LW  DVKDP HGO\ ZLW K VRP H VHFUHW
DQ[LHW \ W KDW  W KLV LV QRW  W KH FDVH  %XW  W KHUH LV DQRW KHU ZD\ DQG RQH RQO\ ZKLFK
FDQ JLYH XV EDFN W KH KDSSLQHVV RI RXU KRP H RQ (DUW K DQG W KLV LV W KH SDW K W KDW
OHDGV XV IURP  VW RQ\ GHVHUW V RI W KRXJKW V EDFN W R RXUVHOYHV  LW  LV W KH ZD\ W KDW
OHDGV W R LQVLJKW  DQG W R W KLQNLQJ RI W KDW  ZKLFK LV RXU RZQ  7KHUH DUH P DQ\ ZD\V
W R RXUVHOYHV  7KH EHVW  RI W KHP  LV W R JHW  W R NQRZ RXUVHOYHV  7KH OLP LW DW LRQV
XQGHU ZKLFK W KH *HUP DQ SHRSOH RI W RGD\ KDYH W R OLYH SV\VLFDOO\  DQG VSLULW XDOO\
ZLOOP DNHLW QHFHVVDU\W RW XUQLQZDUGDQGW RW KLQNRIRXURZQW KLVP RUHVRVLQFH
W KH DFW LYLW \ DIDU EHFDP H GLIILFXOW   :H FDQQRW  EXUVW  W KH ULQJ W KDW  ULJLGLILHV RXU
FKHVW  XQOHVV Z H LQKDOH W KH EU HDW K RI RXU  SDVW  Z LW K LQW HQVLW \ DQG FORVHQHVV
! )URP  SDVW  DQG SUHVHQW  W KH IXW XUH HP HUJHV ZLW K P DW KHP DW LFDO SUHFLVLRQ DQG
FHUW DLQW \QHYHUIURP W KHSUHVHQW DORQHDOVRQRW IURP DSDVW W KDW LVQRW RXUVEXW
RI RW KHU VSLULW  DQG RULJLQ

:H ZLOO QRW  EH DVKDP HG RI RXU SDVW  LW  LV W KH P RVW  YDOXDEOH RQH W KDW  D UDFH DQG
D IRON HYHU FRXOG VKRZ

7KH ZRUOG ZDU GLG QRW  EULQJ EURW KHUKRRG RI W KH QDW LRQV EXW  DQ HP SKDVLV RI W KH
IRONLVK LQ DOO QDW LRQV DQG W KLV LV JRRG VR EHFDXVH ZH FDQ RQO\ EHFRP H D W UXH
FLW L]HQ RI W KH Z RU OG Z KHQ DV D IRON LVK LQGLY LGXDO Z LW KLQ DQG H[ W HU QDOO\ Z H
NQRZLQJO\ VHHN W R M RLQ XS ZLW K HTXDOO\ ZHOO IRXQGHG IRON XQLW V

6W LOO ZH DUH IDU DZD\ IURP  W KLV  ZH DUH QRW  HYHQ FOHDU DERXW  RXU RZQ SRLQW  RI
GHSDUW XUH:HDUHVW LOOORRNLQJIRUW KHEHVW IRUXVRXW VLGHRIRXUVHOYHVHYHQIRU
W KH LQQHUP RVW  RI W KLQJV   IRU *RG   $ FRP SOHW H UHVHDUFK LQ W KH DQFHVW U\ W KDW
FUHDW HGRXUIRONRXUUDFHZLOOJLYHXVEDFNRXUVHOI FRQILGHQFHW KDW ZHKDYHORVW
ORQJ DJR  7KH DFW XDO UHDVRQ IRU W KH P LVIRUW XQH RI RXU RXU ODFN RI RXU RZ Q
HP RW LRQDODQGP RUDOVW UXFW XUHLVW KDW ZHJHW RXULGROVIURP W KH*UHHNV5RP DQV
DQG -HZV LQVW HDG W R ORRN LQ W KH P XFK ROGHU VRXUFHV RI RXU RZQ SUHKLVW RU\ W KH
ORFDW LRQ DQG HYHQ H[LVW HQFH RI ZKLFK ZH KDYH IRUJRW W HQ  :KDW ¶V IRUJRW W HQ LV E\
QR P HDQV ZKDW ¶V QRQ H[LVW HQW 

1RZDJDLQRXUORQJVXSSUHVVHGORQJLQJLVGLUHFW HGW RZDUGVW KHLQKHULW DQFHIURP

RXUDQFHVW RUV$UH ELUW KIURP W KHGHSW KVRIRXURZQVRXOHP HUJHVFRP SDUHGW R
ZKLFKW KHUH ELUW KRIFODVVLFDO*UHHFHLQW KH W K FHQW XU\ZDVM XVW DZHDNJOLP P HU
 

2XU  U HELU W K LV QRW  GU DZ LQJ IU RP  VHFRQG DQG W KLU G KDQG LGHDV RI DQ DOU HDG\
VRXW KHUQL]HG *UHHN GRP  EXW  GLUHFW O\ IURP  W KH 1RUGLF KRP HODQG RI DOO $U\DQ
GRP 7KHUHIRUHLW ZLOOJURZW RSRZHUIXOHIIHFW V7KH1RUGLFVRXUFHVRIW KH(GGD
DQG LW V P \W KRORJLHV DUH IORZLQJ SXUHU DQG FOHDUHU W KDQ W KH HQW LUHO\ KXP DQL]HG
*UHHN DQG 5RP DQ RQHV  2QO\ W KH , QGLDQ 9HGDV FDQ FRP SDUH W R W KDW  DQG D IHZ
VHFW LRQV RI W KH 2OG 7HVW DP HQW  W KDW  DUH RI $U\DQ RULJLQ DQG ZKLFK KDYH VXIIHUHG
D IHZ P XW LODW LRQV  , Q W KH 9HGDV DQG W KH (GGD ZH KDYH W R VHH W KH ROGHVW  DQG
SXUHVW VRXUFHVRI$U\DQOLIHDQGW KLQNLQJ$GGW RW KLVW KHDP D]LQJGRFXP HQW VRI
W KH KDQJLQJ URFNV LQ %RKXVOlQ 6ZHGHQ W KH FRQW HQW  RI ZKLFK FRXOG QRW  \HW  EH
HVW DEOLVKHG ZLW K FRP SOHW H FHUW DLQW \  7KHUH FDQQRW  EH DQ\ GRXEW  DERXW  W KHLU
XQXVXDOO\KLJKDQW LTXLW \HYHQW KRXJKW KHUHDUHVHYHUDOHVW LP DW HV, QDQ\FDVH
KHUHZHKDYHW RGRZLW KHQRUP RXVW LP HVSDQVDVRXUKLVW RU\GLGQRW VXVSHFW \HW 
W LP HVSDQVW KDW ORVHW KHP VHOYHVLQW KHGLVW DQFHVRIIDLU\W DOHVDQGOHJHQGV7KH
FRQVW HOODW LRQRIW KHELJGLSSHUKDVEHHQGUDZQVHYHUDOW LP HVDQGOLNHO\DW GLIIHUHQW
W LP HVRQW RW KHVHHQRUP RXVVXUIDFHVP HDVXULQJVHYHUDOVTXDUHNLORP HW HUV7KLV
JLYHV XV LGHDV DERXW  W KH FDOFXODW LRQ RI W LP H ZKHQ ZH FRQVLGHU W KH VKLIW  RI W KH
LQGLYLGXDO VW DUVRIW KHFRQVW HOODW LRQDP RQJ HDFK RW KHU W KURXJKRXW  W KH P LOOHQQLD

+RZ  Z DV LW  SRVVLEOH W KDW  W KHVH XQLTXH GRFXP HQW V RI W KH HDU OLHVW  KLVW RU \  RI
KXP DQNLQG ZKLFK SURYH W KH IDFW  W KDW  W KH $U\DQ P DQ ZDV ILUVW ERU Q KDYH QRW
EHHQFRQVLGHUHGZKLOH*HUP DQHDJHUQHVVRIVFKRODUVVHDUFKHVDOOFRUQHUVRIW KH
ZRUOGIRUW KHP RVW LP SUREDEOHW UDFHVRIKXP DQDFW LYLW \ LQSUHKLVW RU\ 5HVHDUFK
NHHSVFRP SOHW HO\VLOHQW DERXW W KLVFROOHFW LRQRIGRFXP HQW VLQVW RQHRQ*HUP DQLF
VRLO RQ W KH ERUGHUV RI *HUP DQ\ W KDW  KDV D OHJHQGDU\ DJH  2QO\ RXW VLGHUV OLNH
%DO]HU )XKUP DQQ DQG :HQGULQ XVH W KHLU VSLULW  RI GLVFRYHU\ W R H[DP LQH W KHVH
VDFUHGP RQXP HQW VRIRXUUDFH, QIDFW W KHVHURFNVRI%RKXVOlQZHUHXQFRP IRUW DEOH
W RDFDGHP LFUHVHDUFK7KH\GLVW XUEHGW KHSDLQIXOO\HUHFW HGDVVXP SW LRQVRIKRZ
SUHKLVW RU\ZDVVXSSRVHGW REH+RZFRXOGZHILQGDQ\W KLQJLQ6FDQGLQDYLDLIDOO
OLJKW  DOO P RU DOV FDP H IU RP  W KH (DVW "  7KH W KHVLV RI (; 25, (17( /8; Z DV
P DLQW DLQHG Z LW K DOO P HDQV DY DLODEOH  TXLW H RIW HQ XQGHU  QHJOHFW  RI VFLHQW LILF
W UXW K7KHIDFW RIW KHRULJLQRIDOOFXOW XUHIURP W KHKLJK1RUW KKDVW REHVLOHQFHG
RW KHUZLVH W KH\ ZRXOG KDYH QHHGHG W R UHFRJQL]H W KH VXSHULRULW \ RI W KH $U\DQ
UDFH EHFDXVH W KHUH ZH FDQ ILQG SURRI
 

7KLV ZDV QRW  VXSSRVHG W R KDSSHQ  , W  VHHP HG LP SHUDW LYH W R NHHS W KH *HUP DQV
ZLW K D SUHM XGLFH W KDW  W KHLU P RUDOV DQG FXOW XUH FDP H IURP  ³ ROGHU ´  DQG ³ P RUH
VNLOOHG´ SHRSOHV, IW KDW ZHUHQRW VRW KHQDFFRUGLQJW RDVW DW HP HQW RI*LRUGDQR
%UXQR W KH\ ZRXOG ORQJ KDYH QRW LFHG W KDW  W KH\ DUH QRW  KXP DQV EXW  ³ JRGV´ LI
W KH\ FDP H W R NQRZ W KHLU H[TXLVLW H RULJLQ DQG W KHLU LQH[KDXVW LEOH HQHUJ\  2XU
DQFHVW RUV KDG VW LOO W KH FRQVFLRXVQHVV RI W KHLU H[W UDRUGLQDU\ RU LJLQ DQG W KH VROH
SRVVHVVLRQ RI DOO KXP DQQHVV EHFDXVH ZKHQ W KH VXQ OLNH $U\DQ FU RZGV HQW HUHG
W KH YDOOH\ RI W KH *DQJHV  \HDUV DJR   W KH\ FDOOHG W KH QDW LYHV W KDW  W KH\
IRXQGW KHUHVLP SO\³ P RQNH\V´&RP SDUHGZLW KW KHLUQREOHERGLHVDQGW KHLUKLJK
IO\LQJ VSLULW  W KDW  LV NLQ W R *RG W KH\ QDW XUDOO\ SHUFHLYHG W KDW  IRU ZKLFK ZH ZKR
DUHOLYLQJDKXP DQSRUULGJHZLW KRXW GLVW LQFW LRQVKDYHQRORQJHUDQ\XQGHUVW DQGLQJ
RU IHHOLQJ

7KH P LQG OHVVQHVV RI DQ HDUO\ GXVN RI W KH UDFH P DGH LW  DOVR SRVVLEOH W R ILUVW
GHVW UR\RXUROG*HUP DQOLW HUDW XUHDQGW KHQDOVRH[W HUP LQDW HW KHP HP RULHVRIRXU
VSLULW XDO FXOW XUH DQG SDVW   7KH ROG EHOLHI W KH ROG ZLVGRP  OLYHV LQ W KH OHJHQGV
DQG IDLU\ W DOHV LQ P RUDOV FXVW RP V QDP HV RI ILHOGV DQG FLW LHV LQ SUHKLVW RULF
JLJDQW LF EXLOGLQJV W KDW  RIW HQ DUH QRW  UHFRJQL]HG DV VXFK DV ZHOO DV LQ RXU $U\DQ
VHHNHUV RIJRG)URP  W KLVEHOLHI DQG ZLVGRP ZH KDYHW R EHUH ERUQLI ZHZDQW
W RZLQEDFNRXURZQHW HUQDOOLIHIURP W KHKHULW DJHRIRXUUDFH7KH(GGDDQGW KH
DQFLHQW  1RUGLF ZULW LQJV KDYH EHFRP H D KHULW DJH W KDW  LV DV P XFK RXUV DV W KDW  RI
RXU 1RUGLF EUHW KUHQ  7KDW  ZKLFK RULJLQDW HG LQ DQFLHQW  *HUP DQLD ZDV SUHVHUYHG
LQW KHVLVW HUODQJXDJHRIW KHDQFLHQW 6FDQGLQDYLDQV7KLVZD\W KH\FRXOGUREW KH
RXW HU IRUP  RI RXU DQFLHQW  W HDFKLQJV EXW  QRW  W KH FRQW HQW V    $QG IURP  W KLV
NQRZOHGJH ZH FDQ UHEXLOG RXU ZRUOG YLHZ DOW KRXJK VORZO\ DQG ODERULRXVO\  :H
GR W KLV IURP  RXU P LQG DQG IURP  RXU EORRG EHFDXVH W KH W UXH KDSSLQHVV RI DOO
FKLOGUHQ RI W KH (DUW K LV RQO\ W KH IRONLVK SHUVRQDOLW \  , W  JURZ V DQG W KULYHV RQ W KH
8U JURXQGRIRXURZQHVVHQFH(YHU\W KLQJHOVHUHJDUGOHVVRIW KHKLJKVRXQGLQJ
QDP HV LW  P D\ KDYH QR P DW W HU E\ ZKLFK ERDVW LQJ LW  JDLQHG LP SRUW DQFH  QDP HV
DUH VRXQG DQG VP RNH DQG ERDVW LQJ JHQHUDW HV VHOI SRLVRQLQJ DQG W KH XQW UXW K
DQGLQQHUKROORZQHVVRIRXUZKROH³ FXOW XUH´ZLOOJRW KHSDW KRIDOOOLHVW KHSDW K
RI VSLULW XDO GHDW K  2XU HGXFDW LRQ DQG ZRUOG YLHZ W KDW  KDYH EHHQ EXLOW  XSRQ
P HQGDFLRXV IRXQGDW LRQV FROODSVHV  :KRHYHU LV QRW  RI W KH FRP P RQ W UDVK VDYHV
KLP VHOI LQW R W KH VSLULW XDO W UHDVXUHV RI RXU SDVW  LQ RUGHU W R ILQG RXW  ZKHUH W KH
SDW KLQW RHUURUVZDVW DNHQ EHFDXVHW RW KLVSRLQW W KH*HUP DQKDVW RUHW XUQLIKH
ZDQW V W R HQYLVLRQ D IXW XUH RI KLV RZQ SRZHU DQG ZLW K KLV RZQ JRDOV

2PLWWHG


*RUVOHEHQUHIHUVW RW KHP DQ\ERRNEXUQLQJVRI*HUP DQLF³ KHUHW LF´ Z ULW LQJVVW DUW LQJZ LW K


&KDUOHP DJQHDQGW KHQHVSHFLDOO\KLVVRQ/RXLVW KH3LXVDQGRW KHUVDIW HUW KHP 

 

6RP HZLOOVD\QRZ (YHU\W KLQJVHHP VULJKW , DP IDUIURP LJQRULQJW KHVHW KLQJV
EXW  ZKDW  GR W KHVH ROG JRGV P HDQ W R XV"  +DYH ZH QRW  RXW JURZQ VXFK LGHDV RI
JRGV ORQJ DJR"  +RZ VKRXOG W KH (GGD EHFRP H EDVLV RI RXU :HOW DQVFKDXXQJ RU
HYHQRIRXUUHOLJLRXVSRVLW LRQ":RXOGW KDW QRW P HDQUHJUHVVLRQW RLGHDVW KDW ZH
KDYHRYHUFRP HORQJW LP HDJRZLW K&KULVW LDQLW \DQGDKLJKO\HYROYHGLQW HOOHFW XDO
UDW LRQDO DQG VFLHQW LILF FXOW XUH"

7KLVLW VHHP VW REHLQGHHGLIZHDGKHUHW RW KHM XGJP HQW RIW KHFRP P RQSHRSOH
, IZHSHQHW UDW HW KLVTXHVW LRQDELW GHHSHUZHFDQHDVLO\UHFRJQL]HW KHVXSHUILFLDOLW \
RIVXFKDYLHZ7RGD\¶VZRUOGLVURRW HGLQ³ IDLW K´ ZKHW KHUFKXUFKRUVFLHQFHGRHV
QRW  P DW W HU KHUH  7KH DQFLHQW  ZRUOG GLG QRW  NQRZ W KH FRQFHSW  RI ³ IDLW K´  7KHUH
ZDVQRZRUGIRULW 7KH\W UXVW HGVRP HW KLQJRUW KH\P LVW UXVW HGLW 7KDW ZKLFKLW
W U XVW HG LW  FDOOHG ³ W UDXW H´   W KH 7U RM D W KH IDLW KIXOQHVV *HU P DQ   7U HXH  W KH
W KUHH P RGHUQ *HUP DQ   'UHL  W KH KLJK   ZLW K ZKLFK W KH ROG ZRUOG DQQRXQFHG
LW VNQRZOHGJHRIW KHHW HUQDOUHW XUQRIDOOW KLQJVLQFOXGLQJKXP DQVLQW KHULQJRI
EHLQJ RI EHFRP LQJ EHLQJ DQG SDVVLQJ DZD\

³ *HOREDQ´   W R YRZ W KH\ FDOOHG W KH ULW XDO 5LW D LQ ZKLFK W KH 5L W DHU W KH 5LW W HU
NQLJKW RQKLVNQHHVSXW KLVIROGHGKDQGVLQW RW KHODSRIW KH OHDGHUW KDW KHKDV
FKRVHQDQGVZRUHOR\DOW \W RW KHGHDW K+HGLGQRW ³ EHOLHYH´ W KHUHEXW KHNQHZ
ZKDW KHZDQW HGDQGGLG$OVRW KHOHDGHUGLGQRW ³ EHOLHYH´ DQ\W KLQJEXW UHFHLYHG
W KH YRZV DFFHSW HG W KH ³ ORE´  ODE   ODI  OLIH RI W KH RQH ZKR YRZHG KLP  KLV OLIH
7KH SHUVRQ ZKR ORYHV W UXW K GRHV QRW  YRZ GRHV QRW  EHOLHYH W KH ZRUG ³ JODXEHQ
 EHOLHYH RULJLQDOO\ P HDQW  W R YRZ QRW  W R EHOLHYH  ZKDW  KH KDV QRW  UHFRJQL]HG
LQLW VW UXHQDW XUHRQO\W KHQKHUHFRJQL]HVYRZVW KLVLQVLJKW KHEHOLHYHVKLVRZQ
LQVLJKW   $Q\  RW KHU  ³ EHOLHY LQJ´  IDLW K  LV LP P RU DO EHFDXVH LW  U REV XV RI RXU
UHVSRQVLELOLW \ IRU RXUVHOYHV LW  UREV XV RI RXU VHOI GHW HUP LQDW LRQ

:KDW LVDKXP DQ¶VKLJKHVW RIILFHRQ(DUW K"7KHKXP DQEHLQJLVW KHFRQVFLRXVQHVV

RI*RG5HFRJQLW LRQRIJRGW KHUHIRUHLVDW W KHEHJLQQLQJRIKXP DQKLVW RU\7KH
KXP DQ EHLQJ LV W KH YHVVHO RI HYHU\W KLQJ 'LYLQH RQ (DUW K VLQFH 8U EHJLQQLQJV
7KHUHIRUH W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ KDV QRW  ³ HYROYHG´  IURP  DQ\ RI W KH OLY LQJ RU H[W LQFW
VSHFLHV RI DQLP DOV  EXW  KLV 8U  VKDSH Z DV DOU HDG\  ³ *RG´  RQ LW ¶V Z D\  W R W KH
FRQVFLRXVQHVV RI *RG  7KH KXP DQ EHLQJ KDV DOVR QRW  HYROYHG XSZ DUGV LQ W KH
SDVW P LOOHQQLDEXW DVZHFDQVHHZLW KFHUW DLQW \KHHYROYHGGRZQZDUGEHFDXVH
RI KLV P L[LQJ RI KLV 'LYLQLW \ ZLW K ³ DQLP DOLW LHV´  $ORQH W KDW  LV W KH RULJLQDO VLQ
7KHUHIRUHLW LVHQW LUHO\XQM XVW LILHGW RVSHDNRIDQHYROXW LRQRIW KHFRQFHSW RI*RG


 2PLWWHG

³ 7UDXHQ´ LQP RGHUQJHUP DQLVW RW UXVW 
 

IU RP  ³ SU LP LW LY H EHJLQQLQJV XS W R W KH KHLJKW V RI QHZ HU  LQVLJKW V   +HU H W KH\

KDUQHVVHG W KH KRUVH VW DUW LQJ ZLW K W KH W DLO HQG    , Q W KH EHJLQQLQJ KXQGUHGV RI
W KRXVDQGV RI \HDUV DJR SRVVLEO\ P LOOLRQV RI \HDUV DJR ZDV W KH UHYHODW LRQ RI
*RG W KURXJK JHW W LQJ FRQVFLRXV RI W KH NQRZOHGJH RI EHLQJ W KH 6RQ RI JRG LQ W KH
³ *RW K´  6LQFH W KH P L[LQJ RI W KH *RG UDFHV ZLW K W KH DQLP DOV  W KH UHOLJLRXV 8U
Z LVGRP  VDQN  LQW R W KH P DQLIROG K\ EU LG EORRG RI W KH ORZ HU  KXP DQ U DFHV W KDW
RULJLQDW H W KURXJK VXFK DFW LRQ  7KHUHIRUH W KH ZRUG ³ 0HQVFK´  IRU KXP DQ  W KH
P L[HG RQHP DQ LVNR7KLVZD\W RW HP LVP DQGIHW LVKLVP W ULEDOJRGDQGSHUVRQDO
JRG EHFDP H GHJHQHUDW LRQV RI ROGHU KLJKHU W HDFKLQJV RI ZLVGRP  DQG QRW  W KHLU
EHJLQQLQJV DV EHFRP HV REYLRXV W R W KH LQLW LDW H ZKHQ ORRNLQJ DW  W KH P \W KRORJLHV
RIW KHZKROHZRUOG7KH³ *RW K´ FRP HVW RJHW KHUZLW K*RGDQGKLVFRQVFLRXVQHVV
LQW R W KH ZRUOG  7KLV RULJLQDO FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K *RG LV W KH 8U UH OLJLRQ UH OLJLR
³ FRQQHFW LRQ EDFN LQ /DW LQ DQ LQVXUDQFH DJDLQVW  EDFNODVKHV  ZKLFK ZDV W DXJKW
E\ DOO JRG VRQV RI W KH $U\DQ UDFH DOO W KH ZD\ W R P HQ OLNH (NNHKDUW  %|KP H DQG
/DJDUGH  2Q W KH RW KHU KDQG W KH FKXUFKHV UDQ RQ W KH VLGH DQG LQFUHDVLQJO\
GDUNHQHG W KH *RG LQ W KH *RW K HYHQ P DGH KLP  KXP DQ P L[HG XS DFFRUGLQJ W R
W KHLURZQLP DJH6DP HLVRQO\XQGHUVW RRGE\VDP H 7RW KHGXOOSHUVRQHYHU\W KLQJ
LVKLODULRXVW KDW KHFDQQRW XQGHUVW DQGRUOLW HUDOO\³ JUDVS´³ , I\RXFDQQRW IHHOLW
\RX QHYHU FDQ JHW  LW ´

2QO\W KHKXP DQEHLQJKDVW KHDUW W KHODQJXDJHW KHYLHZRI*RG +HVW ULYHVW R

UHSUHVHQW  D FRP SOHW LRQ D KLJKHVW  RI W KLQJV DURXQG KLP VHOI DQG DOVR IRU KLP VHOI
EHFDXVHW KHKXP DQLVW KHHW HUQDOO\LP SHUIHFW XQILQLVKHGFRQW U DU\W RW KHDQLP DO
7KH DQLP DO LV SHUIHFW  EHFDXVH LW  KDV QR HYROXW LRQ DQG QR VHOI FRQVFLRXVQHVV
+XP DQ DQG DQLP DO DUH SKHQRP HQD RI D W KRXJKW  RI *RG W R P DW HULDOL]DW LRQ EXW
RQO\LQW KHKXP DQW KHBGLYLQHEHFDP HFRQVFLRXV%HFDXVH*RGOLYHVW KURXJKW KH
KXP DQ FRQVFLRXVO\ LQ W KLV ZRUOG KH VW ULYHV W R UHGHP SW LRQ W R SHUIHFW LRQ W KDW
OHDGVKLP EDFNZLW K*RGLQW RW KHQRQ FRQVFLRXV7KHDQLP DOW KDW LVQRW FRQVFLRXV
RI *RG LV QRW  VW ULYLQJ

+LJKHVW ZLVGRP VRIDUHOLJLRXVNLQGDUHDW W KHEHJLQQLQJRIKXP DQKLVW RU\7KH

FRQ W LQ X LQ J GHJHQ HU DW LRQ  RI  W K H U DFHV  W K HLU  U HP RY DO I U RP  Q DW X U H W K U RX JK
FLYLOL]DW LRQ W KH H[W HUQDOL]DW LRQ W KURXJK W UDIILF DQG W KH RYHUZ KHOP LQJ ZHLJKW  RI
W KH ³ HFRQRP \´  DV FRP SDUHG W R DOO RW KHU TXHVW LRQV RI OLIH KDV UREEHG W KH KXP DQ
EHLQJ RI LW V FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K W KH 'LYLQH  :H VHH KRZ W KH JUHDW  KXP DQ ZRUNV RI
ZLVGRP RI*RGDQGW KHZRUOGRULJLQDW HGLQW KHHDUO\GD\VRIW KH$U\DQKXP DQLW \
7KH9HGDVW KHW UXHSDUW VRIW KH2OG7HVW DP HQW W KH(GGDDQGW KHP \W KVRI$U\DQ
ZRUOG YLHZV W KDW  DUH VSUHDG DOO RYHU W KH (DUW K

(YHU\ZKHUH ZH VHH LQ W KH RULJLQDO W LP HV D KLJKHU OHYHO RI ZLVGRP  IURP  ZKLFK

$*HUP DQLGLRP DW LFH[SUHVVLRQW HOOLQJW KDW W KLQJVKDYHEHHQGRQHW KHZ URQJZ D\DURXQG

2PLWWHG
 

RFFXUV D GHVFHQW  RI W KH SHRSOHV W R W KHLU GHFOLQH DQG GHVW UXFW LRQ  7KH JUHDW HVW
P LVIRUW XQH RI RXU W LP H LV W KH DEXVH RI OLW HUDF\ LQ W KH VHUYLFH RI D VXE KXP DQLW \
W KDW  KDV IRUJRW W HQ W KH VDFUHGQHVV RI LW V UHVSRQVLELOLW \ IRU HYHU\ ZRUG W KDW  LV
XW W HUHG E\ LW V P HGLD ORQJ DJR  7KH\ SULQW  DQG LQGHHG W KH\ SXVK KXP DQLW \ LQW R
D P LVIRUW XQH W KDW  FDQ RQO\ EH EDQLVKHG ZKHQ W KH OHDGHUVKLS LV U HP RYHG IURP
W KRVH ZKR ZDQW  W R HDUQ DOZD\V E\ W KRVH ZKR ZDQW  W R VHUYH DW  DOO W LP HV

7KHUHLVQRZLVGRP W KDW W UDQVFHQGVW KH, QGLDQZLVGRP RI%UDKP DQVW KDW RULJLQDW HG

LQ$U\DQUDFLDOW UHDVXUHV ³ :KRUHFRJQL]HV*RGZLW KLQRQHVHOIDQGLQHYHU\W KLQJ
HOVH KH LV W KH W UXH VHHU´  %KDJDYDG *LW D ;, , ,  

$OO UHOLJLRQV RI W KH (DUW K W KDW  RULJLQDW HG LQ W KLV ZLVGRP  DUH GULHG XS LQ RXU GD\V
LQ H[W HUQDO IRUP V  2Q W KH SODFH RI LP P HGLDW H H[SHULHQFH RI W KH GLYLQH W KH\ SXW
W KH ³ SHUVRQDO *RG´  7KHUHIRUH W KH IDOVLILHG 5RP DQ &KULVW LDQLW \ GLG QRW  EULQJ
FXOW XUH UHOLJLRQ DQG P RUDOV W R W KH ROG *HUP DQV RXU DQFHVW RUV  1R GRXEW  W KH
DQFLHQW  *HU P DQV VW RRG P XFK KLJKHU  LQ W KHLU  N QRZ OHGJH RI D 'LY LQ LW \ Z KLFK
DSSHDUHG W R W KHP  W RR JUHDW  W R EH ZRUVKLSSHG LQ FORVHG URRP V EHORZ SLFW XUHV
(QW LUHO\ DJDLQVW  W KHLU SULQFLSOHV W KH W HDFKLQJV RI &KULVW  ZHUH IRUFHG XSRQ W KHP
ZLW K ILUH VZRUG EUXW DOLW \ DQG IUDXG LQ LW VHOI DOUHDG\ P HQGDFLRXV DQG W ZLVW HG
GHJHQHUDW HG DQG ULJLGLILHG  , W  ZDV IRUFHG XSRQ D KLJKHU IRON E\ VSLULW XDOO\ DQG
LQ W HOOHFW X DOO\  ORZ HU  S HRS OH   7K LV LV W K H G HHS HU  U HDVRQ  I RU  DOO  RW K HU Z LVH
XQH[SODLQDEOH VW HULOLW \ RI W KH HIIRUW V RI W KH FKXUFKHV RQ W KH EHVW  VRLO IRU W UXH
ZLVGRP RIJRGZKLFKLVW KH*HUP DQLFVRLO:LW KDOOUHYROW DJDLQVW W KHXQ GLYLQH
FRHUFLRQ LQ IDLW K DQG W HDFKLQJV KHUH &KULVW LDQLW \ KDG W KH HIIHFW  W R W KH P RVW
EHDXW LIXO EORRP  LQ JUHDW  ZRUNV RI DUW  DQG SRHW U\

, QW KH(GGDLVW KHW HVW LP RQLDORIDOOW LP HVW KDW QRKLJKHUP RUDOVRU:HOW DQVFKDXXQJ
FDP HIURP W KH(DVW W RXV4XLW HW RW KHFRQW UDU\ZHZHUHQRW RQO\EORFNHGEXW
W KURZQ EDFN D P LOOHQQLXP  E\ D IUDXGXOHQW  &KULVW LDQLW \ LQ FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K DQ
LQFUHDVLQJO\JURZLQJZRUVHQLQJRIW KHUDFH7RGD\ZHKDYHW RVW DUW DJDLQZKHUH
ZH VW RSSHG ZH KDYH W R IROORZ RXU SURW HFW LYH VSLULW   &KORGZLJ FRP P LW W HG W KH
ILUVW  VLQ DJDLQVW  RXU RZQ KRO\ JKRVW  DQG DJDLQVW  RXU RZQ KRO\ EORRG ZKHQ KH
DFFHSW HG &KULVW LDQLW \ RXW  RI P LVJXLGHG SROLW LFDO FRQVLGHUDW LRQV  +H GLG W KDW  RQ
W KHVXUIDFHVRKHW KRXJKW EXW DVDFRQVHTXHQFHRIW KLVHYLOGHHGFRXQW OHVVHYLO
GHHGV ZHUH SHUSHW UDW HG DJDLQVW  W KH *HUP DQ )RON  7KH *HUP DQ *RG VRQV W KH
³ *RW KV´ Z HU H KDQGHG RYHU  W KH GLVVROYLQJ ORZ VSLU LW  W KDW  OHG W R D FRQW LQXRXV
UHP RYDO RI W KH 'LYLQH  7KH KLVW RU\ RI W KH *HUP DQV FDQ RQO\ EH XQGHUVW RRG DQG
GHVFULEHG FRUUHFW O\ LQ W KLV OLJKW  DQG LW  LV W LP H W KDW  UHVHDUFK UHP RYHV W KH OLH
ZKLFK KDV EHHQ ³ W DXJKW ´  DERXW  RXU SDVW  DQG W KH GHHSHU UHDVRQV IRU RXU IDLOXUHV
GXULQJ P RUH W KDQ W KRXVDQG \HDUV
 

7KH*HUP DQVKDG8U FXOW XUHZKHQW KH\KDGFRQW DFW ZLW KW KH5RP DQVZKLOHRXU
³ EUDQFKHV´  KDYH DOUHDG\ VXQNHQ GRZQ W R FLYLOL]DW LRQ  7KHUHIRUH LW  FRQW UDGLFW V
ZLVHORJLFLIZHDUHORRNLQJIRUIRUHLJQEULQJHUVRIFXOW XUHRQRXURZQVRLOZKLOH
UHVHDUFK W KURXJKRXW  DOO HUDV RI VW RQH EURQ]H DQG LURQ ILQG W KH EHVW  DQG P RVW
DGYDQFHGREM HFW VRQRXUVRLODVIDUDVVKDSHDQGXVHDUHFRQFHUQHG2QDGDLO\
EDVLV ZH ILQG LQ RXU RZQ VRLO W RROV ZHDSRQV DQG XW HQVLOV RI EU RQ]H JROG DQG
LURQW KHEHDXW \DQGQRELOLW \RIZKLFKDOORZVXVW RP DNHFRQFOXVLRQVDERXW W KHLU
P DQXIDFW XU HU V DV EHLQJ KXP DQV RI W KH KLJKHVW  W DVW H DQG HGXFDW LRQ  7KHVH
REM HFW V RI DU W  DQG FU DIW VP DQVKLS FRP SDU H W R W KH REM HFW V RI RXU  ³ FRQVXP HU 
LQGXVW ULHV´ OLNHZLVHDQGVDLQW VFRP SDUHW RIRROVDQGXQKRO\SHRSOH$OOZHQHHG
W R GR LV JHW  W KH QHFHVVDU\ GLVW DQFH VR W KDW  ZH FDQ P DNH D M XGJP HQW  ZLW KRXW
SU HM XGLFH

, Q RXU GD\V W KH\ IRXQG D 6XQ VDQFW XDU\ FORVH W R 'HW P ROG  7KH UHP DLQGHUV RI LW
DOORZ XV W R FDOFXODW H W KH W LP H RI LW V HUHFW LRQ W R W KH GD\ P LOOHQQLD DZD\  7KLV
SUHFLVHO\ LW V P HDVXUHP HQW V ZHUH DOUHDG\ W KHQ IDVKLRQHG DIW HU W KH FRXUVH RI W KH
VW DUV  , Q W KH P LGGOH DJHV W KH *HUP DQ IDUP HU ZDV FDSDEOH RI P DNLQJ KLV RZQ
FDOHQGDUDQGW KH6ZHGLVKIDUP HUNQHZW KDW VW LOODKXQGUHG\HDUVDJR7RGD\W KLV
NQRZOHGJH LV ORVW   7KLV P XFK W KH ³ SURJUHVVLYH´  FLYLOL]DW LRQ KDG GDP DJHG W KH
*HUP DQLFSHUVRQ

3HRSOHZLW KLQVLJKW W KHUHIRUHDUHRIW KHRSLQLRQW KDW W KHFKXUFKDQGDQDEVROXW H

NLQJGRP EURXJKW W KHGHFOLQHRIRXUQDW LYHKLJKHUFXOW XUH7KHFKXUFKGLGVRZLW K
IXOO LQW HQW  DV W KH UHSUHVHQW DW LYH RI W KH ORZ VSLULW  RI W KLV HDUW K W KH P RQDUFK\ DV
W KH FURZQ UREEHU RI *HUP DQLF IUHHGRP  ZLW KRXW  NQRZOHGJH DQG SRVVLEO\ ZLW KRXW
LQW HQW  W R W KLV W UHDVRQ RI UDFH DQG IRON ZKLFK GHOLYHUHG W KH IRON W R W KH IDOVLILHG
&KULVW LDQLW \ W KDW  ZDV LP SRUW HG Z LW K ILUH DQG LURQ XQGHU W KH JXLVH RI EHLQJ D
UHOLJLRQ RI ORYH  .DUO W KH *UHDW  &KDUOHP DJQH   JUHDW  IRU W KH FKXUFK  LQ W KH
HP SLUHRIW KH)UDQNV+DUDOG³ EHDXW LIXOKDLU´ LQ1RUZD\KDYHEHFRP HW KRVHZKR
EURNHW KHVRXORIW KHLUIRONZKLFKVW RRGP XFKKLJKHULQP RUDOVDQGZHOW DQVFKDXXQJ
W KDQ W KH SDSDF\ W KDW  JUHZ RQ W KH P DQXUH RI SHRSOHV LQ W KH GHFOLQHG 5RP H
7KHUHDUHW KHUHDVRQVIRURXUGHFOLQHLQW KHSDVW \HDUVZKLFKQRVFUHDP LQJ
DERXW  W KH SURJUHVV RI FLYLOL]DW LRQ FDQ GHQ\  7RGD\ ZH FRQW ULEXW H W R W KH JXLOW  E\
W DNLQJRYHUVHFXODUDQGFOHULFVW UXFW XUHVW KDW DUHIRUHLJQW RRXUNLQGDQGW KDW ZLOO
UHP DLQIRUHLJQDQGZKLFKW KHUHIRUHFDXVHGLVHDVHW KDW QRW KLQJFDQH[SHOH[FHSW
D UHW XUQ W R RXU RZQ VRXUFHV

:LW KRXW  W KLV LQVLJKW  DQG W KH SRVVLELOLW \ W R DFW  DFFRUGLQJO\ ZH ZLOO QHYHU JR W KH
SDW K W R UHFRYHU\  :H KDYH W R OHDYH W KH IDOVH VLGH URDG RQW R ZKLFK ZH ZHUH
SXVKHG RII EHFDXVH RQO\ W KH P DLQ SDW K OHDGV W R W KH IDW KHU KRXVH RI RXU VRXO
 

9, , 

: + $7, 67+ ((''$"

,  NQRZ RI DQ DVK W UHH ZKLFK LV FDOOHG W UHH RI W KH
Z RU OGV
$ ZKLW LVK IRJ P RLVW HQV LW V W RS
)U RP  W KHU H W KH GHZ  LV IDOOLQJ W KDW  IHU W LOL]HV W KH
GHSW KV
(YHUJUHHQ LW  VW DQGV RQ W KH ZHOO RI 8UG
(YLO GHHGV P RUH W KDQ KXP DQV W KLQN
$QG GLVFRP IRUW  W KH DVK W UHH VXIIHUV
, Q KHU W RS W KH GHHU LQ W KH W UXQN W KH URW 
, Q W KH URRW V W KH ZRUP  RI M HDORXV\ LV JQDZLQJ
$QG P RUH ZRUP V DUH W HHP LQJ EHORZ W KH W UHH
7KDQ GXP E P RQNH\ SHRSOH VXVSHFW 
(GGD

, IZHZDQW W RJHW W RW KHUXQHVLW LVLP SRVVLEOHW RSDVVDSKHQRP HQRQ

OLNHW KH(GGDZKLFKLVVKLQLQJLQW RW KHSUHVHQW IURP W KHJUD\SDVW RI
RXUUDFH

%HIRUH ZH H[DP LQH FORVHU W KH (GGD DQG LW V VLJQLILFDQFH ZH KDYH W R
ILQG RXW  ZKR DUH W KH FUHDW RUV DQG W KH JXDUGLDQV RI LW V W KRXJKW V DQG
GHHGVRUIURP ZKLFKP LQGIURP ZKLFK'LYLQHKHDGFDP HLQW REHLQJ
W KLV VSLULW XDO P LUDFOH RI W KH ZRUOG   $V W KH VLW XDW LRQ LV LQ RXU GD\V
W KH(GGDLVW KHSXUHVW IRXQW DLQRI$U\DQVSLULW XDOKLVW RU\EHVLGHVW KH
$U\R, QGLDQ9HGDV.DUO6LP URFNZKRZDVW KHILUVW SHUVRQW RDW W HP SW V
D FRP SOHW H W UDQVODW LRQ RI W KH (GGD ZURW H LQ KLV LQW URGXFW LRQ LQ W KH
\HDU  VW DW HP HQW V W KDW  DUH VW LOO YDOLG LQ RXU GD\V

³ 7KHUH LV QR ORQJHU DQ\ GRXEW  W KDW  W KH JRGV RI W KH 1RUW K ZHUH DOVR
RXU JRGV W KDW  ERW K EURW KHU W ULEHV W KH 1RUGLF DQG W KH *HUP DQ RQH
KDG EHVLGHV ODQJXDJH M XVW LFH DQG P RUDOV HVVHQW LDOO\ DOVR W KHLU  IDLW K
LQFRP P RQ 2GLQLV:RGDQ7KRULV'RQDU W KH$OIVDQG(LEHV6LJXUG
DQG6LHJIULHGDUHEXW RW KHUIRUP VRIW KHVDP HP \W KLFDOQDP HV+RZ
LVLW SRVVLEOHW KHQW KDW ZHDUHVW LOOLQGLIIHUHQW W RZDUGV1RUVHP \W KRORJ\
DVLIZHKDGDEVROXW HO\QRW KLQJW RGRZLW KLW ", W P D\EHSRVVLEOHW KDW
ZH GR QRW  ZDQW  W R NQRZ DQ\W KLQJ RI W KH 1RUGLF JRGV EHFDXVH W KH\
DUH RXUV  , Q W KLV FDVH W KHQ LW  LV W KH DOO W RR *HUP DQ ZD\ W R VHDUFK
HYHU\FRUQHUHYHU\ZKHUHLQW KHZRUOGLQ5RP H*UHHFH(QJODQGDQG
6SDLQLQ$UDELD&KLQDDQG, QGLDW RUXQLQW RHYHU\GHDGHQGSRVVLEOH
DQGDW W KHVDP HW LP HW RIXP EOHDURXQGLQRXURZQKRXVHOLNHDEOLQG
SHUVRQ´
 

7KHDQJHUDQGW KHFRQW HP SW W KDW LVVSHDNLQJIURP W KHZRUGVRIW KLVJUHDW SHUVRQ

ZKR SUREHV RXU SDVW  LV M XVW LILHG VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V  6LQFH  \HDUV W KH (GGD KDV
EHHQ SXOOHG LQW R GD\OLJKW  DJDLQ IURP  LW V KLGLQJ SODFH  0HDQZKLOH W KH *HUP DQ
SHRSOH KDYH DFFHSW HG HYHU\W KLQJ SRVVLEOH LP SRVVLEOH ZRUW KOHVV DQG IRUHLJQ
EXW  W KH\ DUH VW LOO LJQRUDQW  DERXW  W KHLU (GGD EHFDXVH W KH W HDFKHUV RI LW V \RXW K
KDYH ORVW  DOO FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K W KH RULJLQ RI W KHLU IRON

6LP URFN DGGV W R W KLV

³ , W ¶V QRW  M XVW  HQRXJK W R H[SORUH RXU DQFLHQW  W KLQJV  7KH\ VKRXOG EHFRP H QHZ
W KLQJV W KHLQKHULW DQFHRIRXUIRUHIDW KHUVZDQW VW REHRIXVHIRUW KHJUDQGFKLOGUHQ
W KHVXQNHQW UHDVXUHVRIRXUGD\VRI\RUHFDQQRW IDOOYLFW LP W RDVHFRQGFXUVH ZH
KDYH W R UH FRLQ LW  DQG SXW  LW  LQW R FLUFXODW LRQ DQHZ IUHHG IURP  UXVW ´

, OOXP LQDW HGP LQGVRIRXUIRONKDYHUHFRJQL]HGHDUO\W KHXQLTXHDQGLQFRP SDUDEOH

W UHDVXUHV W KDW  KDYH EHHQ KDQGHG GRZQ W R XV LQ W KH DQFLHQW  ERRNV RI RXU UDFH
$OUHDG\ LQ  :LHODQG IURP  ZKLFK ZH P D\ QRW  KDYH H[SHFW HG LW  DW  DOO W KH
I ROORZ LQ J  Z RU G V   ³ :H K DY H W R DG P LW  W K DW   LI  W K H FOLP DW H RI  W K H DQ FLHQ W
6FDQGLQDYLDQV ZDV FROG W KHLU LP DJLQDW LRQ FHUW DLQO\ ZDV QRW   :KDW  DUH DOO IDLU\
W DOHV RI W KH *UHHN SRHW V FRP SDUHG ZLW K W KDW "´

7KDW  :LHODQG ZDV QRW  RQO\ ZD\ DKHDG RI KLV RZQ JHQHUDW LRQ ZLW K W KLV LGHD EXW
HYHQ DKHDG RI EHJLQQLQJ 5RP DQW LF P RYHP HQW  LV SURYHQ E\ W KH REM HFW LRQ RI
:DFNHQURGHU     ³ , I ZH ORRNHG FRQW LQXRXVO\ DW  W KH IXU FRYHUHG JRGV RI
6FDQGLQDYLD ZH ZRXOG ORVH DOO LGHDV RI D JHQW OH *UHHN SURILOH´   7KH JUHDW QHVV
RIW KH(GGDLVVW LOOD KXQFK LW LVVW LOOQRW DSHUFHSW LRQ)LUVW W KHSHRSOHKDYHW R
VKRZ XS ZKR NQRZ W KH 2OG 1RUGLF ODQJXDJH  7R W KH LP P RUW DO DFKLHYHP HQW V RI
W KLV\RXQJVFLHQFHW KDW HQYLVLRQHGW KHJDLQLQJRIW KHFRP SOHW H*HUP DQLFHVVHQFH
EHORQJV W KH DZH ZLW K ZKLFK LW  ERZV W R W KH UR\DO JUHDW QHVV RI RXU ROG OHJHQGV RI
JRGV DQG KHURHV  :LOKHOP  *ULP P  VD\V    ³ 7KLV SHUIRUP DQFH VHHP V W R P H
VR GLJQLILHG DQG JUDQGLRVH W KDW  ,  FRXQW  W KHVH VRQJV W R W KH ILU VW  RQHV LQ SRHW U\
:LW KGDULQJW UDQVLW LRQVDQGRP LVVLRQVDOORILW LVVRVLP SOHIRUFHIXODQGH[DOW HG
W KDW  ,  DP  UHP LQGHG RI W KH W UDJHGLHV RI $HVFK\OXV´   , W  ZDV QRW  M XVW  W KH DQFLHQW
6FDQGLQDYLDQV ZKLFK W KH\ DSSURDFKHG EXW  W KH QDP H RI $HVFK\OXV VD\V LW  W KH\
DSSURDFKHGDVZHOOW KHDQFLHQW *UHHNV W KH\GLVFRYHUHGW KDW EHVLGHVW KH³ JHQW OH
SURILOH´  W KHUH ZDV DQ HQW LUHO\ RW KHU RQH FHUW DLQO\ QRW  OHVV *U HHN W KDQ W KDW  RQH
EXW RIDQDQFLHQW VHYHULW \D³ EDUEDULDQ´ H[DOW DW LRQZKLFKP DW FKHGYHU\ZHOOW KDW
RIW KH(GGD, VQ¶W LW OLNHDIRUHERGLQJRIW KH³ 5LQJRIW KH1LEHOXQJHQ´LI)ULHGULFK
6FKOHJHOZULW HVW KHIROORZLQJVW DW HP HQW VD\HDUODW HU ³ DOORILW LVOLNHDFRP SOHW H
 

SRHP  D FRQW LQXRXVO\ EORZLQJ W UDJHG\´ "  7KDW  LQ W KH RDN RI W KH (GGD LV VW XFN D
VZRUG DV LI SXVKHG LQ E\ D JRG¶V KDQG :LOKHOP  *ULP P  QRW LFHV ZKHQ KH UHW XUQV
DJDLQ W R KLV 1RUGLF VW XGLHV  ³ :KHUHYHU W KLV SRHW U\ EHJLQV W R XQIROG TXLHW O\ DQG
W REDODQFHGHSLFSURJUHVVLQJLW LVGLVW XUEHGE\DQLQFOLQDW LRQW RYLYDFLRXVGUDP DW LF
SUHVHQW DW LRQ W KDW  EUHDNV W KURXJK HYHU\ZKHUH   W KH P RVW  EHDXW LIXO VRQJV W XUQ
VRRQ LQW R FRQYHUVDW LRQV RU W KH\ DUH SUHVHQW HG DV FRQYHUVDW LRQV  W KH QDUUDW LQJ
UK\P HV NHHS W KH FRQW H[W  DV D ZKROH  (YHU\W KLQJ RI W KH P LGGOH LV RP LW W HG  7KH
DFW LRQVDUHVW DQGLQJVW ULFW O\VLGH E\ VLGHOLNHP RXQW DLQVRIZKLFKRQO\W KHSHDNV
DUH LOOXP LQDW HG  , I ZH ORRN DW  W KLV KDUGQHVV LQ W KLV JUDQGHXU DQG W KH DGYDQFLQJ
GU DP DW LF W U HQG LQ W KHVH VRQJV W KHQ D U HP LQGHU  W R W KH DQFLHQW  VSLU LW  RI W KH
W UDJHG\ LV QRW  W RR IDU IHW FKHG

:KDW GRHV(GGDP HDQ"7KHZRUGLVLQW HUSUHW HGLQGLIIHUHQW ZD\V6RP HW UDQVODW H

LW  ZLW K SRHW U\ RW KHUV ZLW K DQFHVW RU  ,  DP  M RLQLQJ W KH H[SODQDW LRQ RI *XLGR YRQ
/LVW  DFFRUGLQJ W R ZKLFK W KH (GGD ZDV W R LQW HUSUHW  DV ³ YRQ HKH GD´ LH ³ EHLQJ
VLQFH HYHU ´ VLP LODU W R W KH QDP H RI W KH ILUVW  1RUQ 8UGD ZKLFK LV H[SODLQHG DV
EHLQJ ³ VLQFH W KH 8U W KHUH´ LH VLQFH GD\V RI ROG  :LW K W KLV W UDQVODW LRQ RI W KH
ZRUG (GGD ZH DUH QRW  W RR IDU UHP RYHG IURP  W KH RW KHU H[SODQDW LRQV LI ZH W DNH
W KHDQFHVW RUVLQW KHP HDQLQJ³ KHUHVLQFH8U W LP HV´ DQGSRHW U\DVODZFDXVHDQG
RULJLQ  7KDW  W KH ³ 9HGD´  RI W KH , QGLDQV DQG W KH ³ (GGD´  RI W KH 1RUGLF $U\DQV DUH
RI FRP P RQ RULJLQ LV DOP RVW  VHOI HYLGHQW  LQ RXU GD\V  5HJDUGOHVV RI W KDW  W KH
FRQQHFW LRQ ZDV QRW  UHFRJQL]HG W R W KLV GD\

:KDW  LV W KH (GGD"  :KDW  LV LW V FRQW HQW  DQG LW V P HDQLQJ"  2ULJLQDOO\ (GGD VW RRG
IRUDKDQGERRNRI'LYLQHW HDFKLQJV'LYLQHKLVW RU\DQGW KHSRHW U\W KDW W KHJUHDW
, FHODQGLFSRHW DQGKLVW RULDQ6QRUUL6W XUOXVRQOHIW XV+HOLYHGDURXQGFH
+LVZRUNLVNQRZQW RW KHKLVW RU\RIOLW HUDW XUHXQGHUW KHQDP HV RI3URVH (GGDRU
6QRUUL (GGD%LVKRS%U\QM ROI6YHLQVVRQRI, VODQGFRQFOXGHGIURP W KHLQW HUVSHUVHG
YHUVHVLQW KLVP DQXDO W KH6QRUUL (GGD W RW KHH[LVW HQFHRIDFROOHFW LRQRIDQFLHQW
VRQJVW KDW P D\KDYHEHHQW KHEDVLVRIW KLV(GGD, QGHHGLQKHVXFFHHGHG
W R ILQG W KH DVVXP HG FROOHFW LRQ RQ D SDUFKP HQW  W KDW  ZDV IRXQG RQ DQ , FHODQGLF
IDUP   %LVKRS %U\QM ROI FRQVLGHUHG W KDW  FROOHFW LRQ EHLQJ W KH ZRU N RI DQ , FHODQGLF
SRHW DQGVFKRODU6lP XQG6LJIXVVRQZKROLYHGDURXQGFH +HFDOOHGW KLV
FROOHFW LRQ RI VRQJV W KH ³ 6lP XQGDU (GGD´  7KH OLQJXLVW LF VFLHQFH RI RXU GD\V
UHIHUV W R LW  P RVW O\ DV ³ ROGHU (GGD´  RU ³ VRQJ (GGD´  /LHGHU (GGD 

3RVVLEO\  DV D FROOHFW RU  6lP XQG P D\  EH DFFHSW HG  EXW  QRW  DV SRHW    7KHVH
RXW VW DQGLQJ W HVW LP RQLHV RI $U\DQ *HUP DQLF OLW HUDW XUH IURP  W KH W LP HV RI KHURHV
DQGJRGVDUHP XFKROGHU:HDUHQRW ZURQJLIZHJLYHW KH\RXQJHVW SDUW VRIW KH
 

(GGD DW  OHDVW  DQ DJH RI D W KRXVDQG \ HDU V  W KH P LGGOH SDU W  RQH DQG D KDOI
W KRXVDQG \HDUV DQG W KDW  ZH DVVXP H RI LW V URRW V W KDW  W KH\ UHDFK EDFN LQ ROGHVW
W LP HV RI \RUH W KDW  W KH\ DUH W KH ROGHVW  W UDGLW LRQ RI DQ ROGHU $U\DQ FXOW XUH DQG
UHOLJLRQ, W VKLJKHVW LQVLJKW VSURYHVXFKDKHLJKW RIFUHDW LYHKXP DQLW \W KDW W KH\
EHOLW W OH ZKDW  ZH FDQ ³ SURJUHVV´  RI KXP DQNLQG HVSHFLDOO\ LQ RXU  GD\V

, Q 8U GD\V LW  ZDV ZKHQ HDJOHV VFUHDP HG

$QG KRO\ ZDW HUV IORZHG IURP  W KH KHLJKW V RI W KH KHDYHQV
7KHQ +HOJH W KH P DJQDQLP RXV LQ KHDUW
:DV ERUQ W R %RUJKLOG LQ %UDJHZDOG¶V FDVW OH
, Q W KH QLJKW  ZDV W KH IDUP  ZKHQ W KH 1RUQV FDP H
$QG FUHDW HG GHVW LQ\ DQG DJH IRU W KH QREOHP DQ
3URP LVHG KLP  KRQRUV RI GXFK\ LQ DEXQGDQFH
$QG W KH P RVW  QREOH RI UHSXW DW LRQ RI DOO
7KXV ZLW K SRZHU W KH\ VSXQ W KH W KUHDGV RI GHVW LQ\
7KDW  W KH VW RUP V P RDQHG LQ W KH EUHDNLQJ ZRRGV
7KH\ VHQW  DQG W LHG W KH URSHV RI JROG
$QG W LJKW HQHG W KHP  LQ W KH P LGGOH RI W KH KDOO RI W KH 0RRQ
$QG W KH\ KLG W KH HQGV LQ W KH (DVW  DQG :HVW 
7KDW  LQ W KH P LGGOH RI W KH QHW  ZDV W KH ODQG RI W KH JORULRXV RQH
2QO\ 6NXOG W KUHZ DW  ODVW  RQH D URSH W R W KH QRUW K
$QG RUGHUHG LW  W R KROG IRUHYHU DQG HYHU

, W  LV DOP RVW  HYLGHQW  W KDW  W KH FRQW HQW  RI W KH (GGD LV QRW  RI , FHODQGLF RULJLQ EXW
FRP P RQ $U\DQ SRVVHVVLRQ HVSHFLDOO\ *HUP DQ  , W  LV P DW W HU RI IDFW  W R FRQFOXGH
DQG ZH KDYH FRQYLQFLQJ SURRI W KDW  W KLV SRHW U\ RI KHURHV JRGV DQG VRQJV ZDV
LQ JUHDW HU EORRP  LQ W KH $U\DQ *HUP DQLF 0LGGOH ODQG W KDQ LQ W KH DOZD\V W KLQQHU
SRSXODW HG 6FDQGLQDYLD  +RZ LV LW  SRVVLEOH W KDW  W KHVH VRQJV DUH RQO\ LQ , FHODQG
E\QRZ", W LVJRRGIDW HW KH\EHHQSUHVHUYHGW KHUHRQDUHP RW HLVODQGZKLOHLQ
W KH RW KHU *HUP DQLF FRXQW ULHV W KH SHUVHFXW LRQ DQG GHVW UXFW LRQ RI DOO SDJDQ DQG
UDFLDOFXOW XUHKDGEHJDQ7KLVLVVW LOOW KHFDVHLQRXUGD\VZ KHQW KH*HUP DQVSLULW
LVVW LOOUHSODFHGE\DIRUHLJQRQHM XVW ZLW KRW KHUP HDQV7KLVDOP RVW FODLUYR\DQW
KDW H DJDLQVW  $U \DQ *HU P DQLF DU W  DQG :HOW DQVFKDXXQJ KDV U REEHG X V RI W KH
LQKHULW DQFHRIRXUHDUOLHVW OLW HUDW XUHH[FHSW IRUDIHZOHIW RYHUVW KHP RVW LP SRUW DQW
RI ZKLFK ZDV W KH (GGD 7KH LQW HOOHFW XDO DQG LGHDOLVW LF FXOW XUH RI W KHVH W LP HV KDV
W R EH DVVXP HG W R EH RI D YHU\ KLJK OHYHO EHFDXVH W KH IRUFHV RI GDUNQHVV IRXQG
LW ZRUW KZKLOHW RFRP EDW LW DOUHDG\LQHDUOLHVW W LP HV7KHKLVW RU\RIW KHVXSSUHVVLRQ
DQG RSSUHVVLRQ RI RXU UDFLDO $U\DQ FXOW XUH DUW  DQG UHOLJLRQ KDV QRW  \HW  LQ RXU
GD\V $OO QRQ $U\DQ DQG QRQ *HUP DQLF UHSUHVHQW DW LYHV RI ZRUOG GRP LQDW LRQ DUH
 

EHQW  W R W LH XS RXU LQKHULW HG ERGLHV DQG RXU QDW LYH VRXO  2QO\ ZKHQ VHHQ XQGHU
W KLV DVSHFW  Z H FDQ M XGJH RXU  U HODW LRQ W R W KH (GGD FRU U HFW O\   7KH IDFW  W KDW
LQW HOOHFW XDOIRONLQFUHDVLQJO\ORRNVDW W KH(GGDDQGLW VZLVGRP LVSURRIW KDW DIW HU
JUHDW  HUURUV ZH KDYH HQW HUHG DJDLQ W KH VROLG JURXQG RI D JRDO RULHQW HG URDG
:KR KDV SHQHW UDW HG W KH VSLULW  RI W KH (GGD FDQ XQGHUVW DQG KRZ HDV\ LW  ZDV W KDW
RXUDQFHVW RUVZKRKDYHEHHQVFKRROHGLQW KHVSLULW RIW KH(GGDFRXOGDFFHSW W KH
W KRXJKW RIVDOYDW LRQRIW KHW UXHW HDFKLQJVRI&KULVW 8SRQDFFHSW LQJFKULVW LDQLW \
W K H\  U HP DLQ HG  Z LW K LQ  W K H U LQ J  RI  W K HLU  RZ Q  Z HOW DQ VFK DX X Q J   D U L Q J  W K DQ
HQFRP SDVVHV, QGLDQLQVLJKW VRI*RG&KULVW LDQORYHIRUKXP DQVDQGZRUOGZLVGRP
RI W KH (GGD

:KDW  W KH *HUP DQLF ZRUOG GHIHQGHG LW VHOI DJDLQVW  ZDV W KH H[W HUQDO FRHUFLRQ RI
VW DW H DQ G  FK X U FK  W K DW  Z DV S HU S HW U DW HG  DJ DLQ VW  W K H *HU P DQ LF I RON  X Q G HU
&KDUOHP DJQH LQ *HUP DQ\ DQG +DUROG ³ W KH %HDXW LIXO +DLU ´  LQ 1RUZD\  $P RQJ
RW KHUW KLQJVLW OHDGW RW KHEXW FKHU\RIW KRXVDQGVRIQREOH6D[RQVE\&KDUOHP DJQH 
:LGXN LQG   Z DV DERXW  W R EH EDSW L]HG   :KHQ KH DVN HG W KH SU LHVW  Z KHU H KLV
IRUHIDW KHUV DUH LI LQ KHOO RU KHDYHQ W KH SULHVW ¶V DQVZHU ZDV ³ DV SDJDQV LQ KHOO
RIFRXUVH´ +HW KHQOHIW EDSW LVP ZLW KW KHZRUGV ³ W KHQ, W RRZDQW W RJRW RKHOO´
:KR FDQQRW  UHDOL]H VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V KRZ P XFK P RUH ³ &KULVW LDQ´  :LGXNLQG ZDV
KDVQRW W KHVOLJKW HVW LGHDRIW KHGHFLVLYHW XUQDURXQGLQRXUFXOW XUDODQGVSLULW XDO
KLVW RU\  :H VKRXOG QRW  VHH W KH GHFLVLRQ RI :LGXNLQG DV QDLYH KHURLVP  ZKHW KHU
LW  LV IDFW  RU M XVW  OHJHQG  , W  ZDV EORRG\ GHVSLVH RI D YLHZ RI SLW LOHVV ORZQHVV
ZKLFKOHDYHVW KHLQQRFHQW W RHW HUQDOSDLQDVSXQLVKP HQW IRUQRW NQRZLQJ6XFK
YLHZLVIRUHLJQW RW KH*HUP DQLFVRXO*RW KLFVW \OHDQGP \VW LFLVP %UXQR%DFRQ
W KH)UDQNIXUW HU'HXW VFKKHUU(NNHKDUW /XW KHU%|KP H$QJHOXV6LOHVLXV*RHW KH
.DQW 6FKRSHQKDXHUW KRVHDUHVW HSSLQJ VW RQHVLQW KHFRP EDW RI(GGLFLQW HOOHFW XDO
IUHHGRP  DJDLQVW  W KH FRHUFLRQ RI XQFKULVW LDQ DQG XQ *HUP DQLF IRU FHV

7KHP RUHW ROHUDQW 1RUW KUHP DLQHGSXUHULQVSLULW DQGUDFHIRUDORQJW LP H7KHUH

SHRSOH Z HU H DEOH W R FROOHFW  W K HVH VRQ JV VW LOO LQ       F H  LQ  VSLW H RI W K HLU
³ &KULVW LDQLW \´  W KDW  HQW HUHG DOVR , FHODQG DURXQG  FH  $URXQG  W KH RUDO
W UDGLW LRQ RI SRHW V DQG VLQJHUV YDQLVKHG VORZO\

:HKDYHW REHKDSS\LQRXUKHDUW VIRUW KLVEHFDXVHW KDW ZKLFKFDP HW RXVLQW KH

(GGD LV ZLW QHVV RI JUHDW QHVV DQG KLJKHVW  DULVW RFUDF\ RI KXP DQLW \  7KHVH ZRUNV
RISRHW U\EHORQJW RW KHILUVW LQZRUOGOLW HUDW XUHDQGW KH\KDYHQRW DFKLHYHGE\DQ\
RW KHUSHRSOHDVIDUDVW KHLUXQLTXHQHVVLVFRQFHUQHG7KHVHKXP DQEHLQJVKDYH
DVW URQJEHOLHILQOLIHW KDW LVERXQGE\GHVW LQ\DQGW KH\KDYHDGHHSORYHIRUW KH


6D[RQVZHUHEXW FKHUHGE\&KDUOHP DJQHLQ9HUGHQRQW KHU LYHU$OOHU

7KHGXNHRIW KH6D[RQV
 

W UXW KLQDOOW KDW OLYHVDVLW FRXOGRQO\EHIHOW DQGH[SHULHQFHGLQDUDFHW KDW ZDV

KHURLF7KLVEHOLHILQOLIHRYHUFRP HVHYHQGHDW KW KHVDP HZD\ DVORYHRYHUFRP HV
GHDW K LQ W KH LP DJLQDW LRQ EHW W HU LQ W KH NQRZOHGJH RI W KHVH KXP DQ EHLQJV  7KH
KXP DQEHLQJOLYHVQRW M XVW RQFHEXW KLVKLJKHUHJRLVHW HUQDO 1DP HDQGVKDSH
DUH FKDQJLQJ RI FRXUVH EXW  LW  LV HQFORVHG LQ W KH ULQJ RI H[LVW HQFH ZLW K HW HUQDO
UHW XUQ LQW R W KH HW HUQDO VHTXHQFH RI W KLQJV RI W KH H[LVW HQFH W R ZDQLQJ DQG ZLW K
W KLV W R QHZ RULJLQV

6KRUW O\EHIRUHKLVGHDW K)UHGHULFNW KH*UHDW H[SUHVVHGW KLVFRQYLFW LRQZLW KW KH

ZRUGV , IHHOQRZW KDW P \OLIHRQ(DUW KZLOOVRRQEHRYHU6LQFH, NQRZQRW KLQJ
W KDW H[LVW VLQQDW XUHFDQEHGHVW UR\HG, NQRZIRUVXUHW KDW W KHP RUHQREOHSDUW
RIP \VHOIZLOOQRW VW RSOLYLQJ, ZLOOQRW EHNLQJLQP \IXW XUHOLIHEXW W KDW ¶VHYHQ
EHW W HU   ,  ZLOO OHDG DQ DFW LYH OLIH DQG ZLW K W KDW  RQH W KDW  LV FRQQHFW HG ZLW K OHVV
LQJUDW LW XGH  7KRVH ZKR DUH FRQGHP QHG W R ³ HW HUQDO GHDW K´  ,  VD\ W KH IROORZLQJ
W KH\ DFFHSW  HW HUQDO GHDW K LQ IDFW  W KH\ SUDLVH LW  EXW  W KH\ GHQ\ W KH HW HUQDO OLIH
W KH HW HU QDO U HW XU Q   $ ELW  RI W KLQN LQJ VKRXOG W HOO W KHP  W KDW  HW HU QDO G\ LQJ LV
XQW KLQNDEOH ZLW KRXW  HW HUQDO OLYLQJ EHFDXVH RQH FDXVHV W KH RW KHU

6FKRSHQKDXHU SRLQW HG DOUHDG\ RXW  W KDW  UHLQFDUQDW LRQ LQ W KH P HDQLQJ RI DQ HJR
W KDW  HW HUQDOO\ JRHV W R SHUIHFW LRQ LV DQ XQGHQLDEOH IDFW  IRU W KH UDFLDOO\ VW HDGIDVW
$U\DQZKRLVQRW P LVOHDGE\W KH&KXUFK+HGRHVQRW NQRZRIDQ\JRGRIVRP H
W \SHRXW VLGHRIKLP VHOIDQGKHKDVXQVKDNDEOHDOP RVW SK\VLFDOFHUW DLQW \RIW KH
LP P RUW DOLW \ RI KLV HJR

2I W KLV W KH (GGD VSHDNV FOHDUO\ LQ DQ HSLORJ W R W KH +HOJH VRQJ  7KH LP SUHVVLRQ
RI W KLV P DJQLILFHQW  SRHW U\ ZLOO W HOO P RUH W KDQ ZRUGV W R W KH SHU VRQ ZKR KDV W KH
LQQHU YRLFH DQG FHUW DLQW \

³ 7KLV ZDV W KH EHOLHI RI W KH ROG W LP H W KDW  KXP DQV DUH UH ERUQ EXW  W KDW  LV QRZ
FDOOHG W KH VXSHUVW LW LRQ RI ROG ZRP HQ´

7KH 'LYLQH QDW XUH RI KLV RULJLQ VSLULW  DQG VRXO JLYHV KLP  DW W LW XGH DQG GLUHFW LRQ
LQ DOO RI ZKDW  KH GRHV DQG GRHV QRW  GR  2QFH KH IUHHG KLV W KLQNLQJ DQG IHHOLQJ
IU RP  XQFOHDQ EXU GHQV RI 0LG (DVW HU Q   U HOLJLRXV DQG M XGLFLDO  FRQFHSW V W KH\
SURYLGH KLP  ZLW K D M R\IXO XQELDVHG QHVV W RZDUG ZRUOG DQG GHVW LQ\ ZKLFK RQO\
W KHIDFW RIHW HUQDOM R\LQGHDW KDQGOLIHFDQVHFXUHIRUW KH³ *RW K´W KH*RW KLFW KH
GLY LQH W KH ³ JRHW KLF´  LW  DOO P HDQV W KH VDP H  KXP DQ EHLQJ  7KH *RW K W KH
*RW KLFW KH'LYLQHRQHLVW KH³ VRQRIP HQ´ZKLFKLVW KHVDP HDVW KHVRQRI*RG
7KH*HUP DQLFVRXOKDVUHDOO\VRXJKW JRGQRZKHUHHOVHEXW ZLW KLQLW VHOI7KHUHIRUH
\RX ZLOO ORRN LQ YDLQ LQ W KH (GGD ZKHQ \RX ZDQW  W R KHDU KLV QDP H EHLQJ FDOOHG


2ULHQW LQ*HUP DQLVW KH0LGGOH(DVW
 

DQG ZKHUH W KH $OO IDW KHU :RGDQ LV FDOOHG ³ W KH KLJKHVW  SRHW ´  DQG ZLW K KXQGUHG
RW KHU QDP HV W KLV LV DOZD\V RQO\ P HDQW  LQ D FRP SDULVRQ ZLW K D P \W KLFDO P LQG
1RZKHUH LV KH ³ /RUG´ ³ W KH´  *RG W KH ³ UXOHU RI W KH ZRUOG´  RXW VLGH RU DERYH XV LQ
D KRSHOHVV FRQFHSW  RI D SHUVRQLILHG UHDOLW \

+DLO \RX GD\  $QG +DLO \RX \RX VRQV RI W KH GD\
+DLO 1LJKW    $QG \RX GDXJKW HUV RI W KH QLJKW V
2 ORRN GRZQ ZLW K P DJQDQLP RXV H\HV
$QG JLYH XV 6LW W LQJ 9LFW RU\
+DLO \RX \RX $HVLU   7R $HVLUHVVHV +DLO
$QG +DLO \RX P XOW L XVHIXO (DUW K
*LYH VSHHFK UHDVRQ W R DOO RI XV DQG JORU\
$QG OLIH ORQJ KHDOLQJ KDQGV

7KHU HIRU H  \ RX Z LOO QRW  ILQG RQH Z RU G DERXW  *RG DQG KLV Z LOO LQ  W KH VDJDV
EHFDXVH VW LOO W KH ROG , FHODQGHU IHOW  KLP VHOI W R EH IXOILOOP HQW  RI GHVW LQ\ LQ HYHU\
VLQJOH FDVH  +H IHOW  KLP VHOI DV *RG DOW KRXJK KH QHYHU VSRNH DERXW  W KLV HYHQ
P D\ QRW  KDYH EHHQ FRQVFLRXV RI W KLV FRP SOHW HO\  (DFK $U\DQ IHHOV KLP VHOI DV
EHLQJ W KH FHQW HU RI W KH ZRUOG  ,  DP  W KH EHJLQQLQJ DQG W KH OLIH   6R ZKHUH FRXOG
*RG EH LI KH ZDV QRW  SDUW  RI KLP  DQG GLYLQLW \ LI LW  GLG QRW  OLYH LQ KLP VHOI "

7KH LQQHU FHUW DLQW \ RI W KH GLYLQLW \ DQG HW HUQLW \ RI W KH RZQ HJR ILQGV LW V H[W HUQDO
H[ SU HVVLRQ LQ W KH EHOLHI RI U HLQFDU QDW LRQ  D EHOLHI  Z KLFK VW LOO LQ RXU  GD\ V LV
FHU W DLQO\  RI H[ SHU LHQFH IRU  HY HU \ ERG\  Z KR KDV U HFHLY HG VXIILFLHQW  LQKHU LW HG
P HP RULHVIURP SXUHUDFHRQKLVSDW KRIOLIH6FKRSHQKDXHUVD\VW KDW ³ QHYHUGLG
QRU ZLOO D P \W K EH FORVHU W R SKLORVRSKLFDO W UXW K W KDQ UHLQFDUQDW LRQ  7KLV LV W KH
³ QRQSOXV XOW UD´  QRW KLQJ P RUH EH\RQG  RI P \W KLFDO UHSUHVHQW DW LRQ  LW  LV DQ
DQFLHQW  ZLVGRP  W KDW  \RX ILQG ZLW K DOO SHRSOHV ZLW K H[FHSW LRQ RI W KH -HZV 

, Q DQRW KHU  SDVVDJH KH VD\ V   ³ 7KH (GGD W RR  QDP HO\  W KH 9ROXVSD  W HDFKHV
UHLQFDUQDW LRQ´ 7KLVW KRXJKW FRP HVUHSHDW HGO\VXFKDVLQW KHVRQJRI6LHJIULHG¶V
GHDW KDQGLQW KHVRQJRI+HOJHZKRNLOOHG+XQGLQJ%XW W KRVHDUHIHZH[DP SOHV
RIW KHW KRXVDQGIROGFRQVRQDQFHZLW KRXUVHDUFKLQJDQGORQJLQJ ZKLFKW KH(GGD
I LOOV

,  ZLOO P DNH D VKRUW  FRQFOXVLRQ   7KH (GGD DQG ZLW K LW  W KH FRP SOHW H NQRZOHGJH
RI W KH 5XQHV DV IDU DV LW  LV VW LOO LQ H[LVW HQFH KDYH W R EH DW  W KH EHJLQQLQJ RI DOO
HGXFDW LRQ DQG RI DOO LQVW UXFW LRQ EHFDXVH W KLV LV RXU RZQ  2QO\ DIW HU ,  KDYH
DVVLP LODW HG W KDW  ZKLFK LV FORVH W R P \ EHLQJ FRP SOHW HO\ FDQ ,  DFFHSW  IRUHLJQ
LGHDVDGYDQW DJHRXVO\:KDW ¶VW KHXVHW REHJLQLQFKXUFKDQGVFKRROZLW KW KH2OG
7HVW DP HQW "  :H VKRXOG OHDYH W KDW  XS W R LW V FROOHFW RUV DQG HGLW RUV DV IDU DV
LQVW UXFW LRQLQUHOLJLRQDQGZHOW DQVFKDXXQJDUHFRQFHUQHG)URP DSXUHO\KLVW RULFDO


2PLWWHG
 

SRLQW RIYLHZLW VURRW VUHDFKEDFNW R$U\DQVRXUFHV, EHOLHYHW KDW ZHKDGW RSD\

DOUHDG\GHDUO\IRUW KLVODFNRIRXURZQSRLQW VRIGHSDUW XUHDQGZHP D\EHLQFOLQHG
W REHW W HULQVLJKW V1RKXP DQEHLQJRQW KH(DUW KFDQJHW DURXQGKLVRULJLQ7KLV
FRXQW V DOVR IRU HYHU\ RQH ZKR FKDVHV DIW HU D KXP DQLVW LF HGXFDW LRQDO LGHDO W KDW
JLYHVSUHIHUHQFHW RHYHU\W KLQJIURP DIDURYHURXUFORVHVW KHULW DJHDQGNQRZOHGJH

7R FRQVLGHU W KH KHDYHQ RI W KH JRGV RI RXU DQFHVW RUV DV DQ LQIHU LRU ZRUOGYLHZ LV
DW DVW HOHVVQHVVW KDW ODFNVLQW HOOHFW XDOVNLOOVRIM XGJP HQW 7KH&KULVW LDQUHOLJLRQV
RIW RGD\ZLW KW KHLUSHUVRQDORQH JRGP DNHRXW H[W UHP HO\SRRUO\ZKHQFRP SDUHG
W R W KH GHSW K RI W KLV DQFLHQW  ZLVGRP  W KDW  LV P LVXQGHUVW RRG RQO\ E\ XV LQ IDFW 
ZKLFKLVVXSSRVHGW REHP LVXQGHUVW RRG1RGRXEW W KHUHOLJLRQVRIW KHDQFHVW RUV
ZHUH RQ D P XFK KLJKHU EDVLV RI ZLVGRP  DQG LQVLJKW  W KDW  W KH &KULVW LDQ RQHV
ZKLFK KDYH ERUURZHG IURP  W KHP  HYHU\W KLQJ RI YDOXH  7KH DQFHVW RUV H[FHOOHG
ZLW K D ZRQGHUIXO ZHDOW K RI IRUP V DQG LGHDV ZKLFK W LP H DQG DJDLQ SRLQW HG W R D
8QLW \ EHKLQG DOO RI W KDW 

³$ERYH DOO JRGV LV W KH DOO IDW KHU KH OLYHV W KURXJKRXW  DOO HUDV´

7KH DOO IDW KHU  DOIRW KXU ZKLFK LQ W KH 1RUGLF ODQJXDJH RI W KH (GGD P HDQV W KH
EHJHW W HU RI W KH XQLYHUVH LV W KHUHIRUH QRW  :RGDQ DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH XVXDO FRQFHSW
DQGDFFRUGLQJW RRW KHUW HVW LP RQLDOLQW KH(GGD0RVW RIW KHW LP H:RGDQLVW KHUH
D IDW KHU  RI W KH JRGV Z LW K DOO KLV Z HDN QHVVHV DQG VW U HQJW KV  +H VXFFXP EV
HYHQW XDOO\ W R W KH JXLOW  RI W KH ZRUOG ZLW K DOO RI KLV $HVLU  D JXLOW  W KDW  KH FRQM XUHG
XS KLP VHOI E\ KLV RZQ GHHGV  7KHUHIRUH W KHUH P XVW  EH DQRW KHU  DOO IDW KHU DQ
DOO EHJHW W HU DQG LQGHHG DOVR W KH (GGD W HDFKHV XV LQ W KH ³ LOOXVLRQ RI W KH JRGV´
*\OIDJLQQLQJ RI³ 'LYLQHSRZHUVW RZKRP W KH$HVLUJDYHVDFULILFHV´ZKLFKP HDQV
W KDW  W KH ³ JRGV´  VDFULILFHG W R VW LOO KLJKHU SRZHUV

:LW K W KLV LV H[SUHVVHG FOHDUO\ W KDW  W KH FLUFOH RI W KH W ZHOYH $HVLU DP RQJ W KHP
:RGDQ DV W KH W KLUW HHQW K VW RRG EHQHDW K D KLJKHU GLYLQH SRZHU  7KLV ZDV W KH
FHOHVW LDO=RGLDFRIW ZHOYHSDUW VW KH³ 7\U ´  FLUFOH UHYROYLQJFLUFOHDVDUHYHODW LRQ
RIW KHRQHZKRVKRZVHYHU\W KLQJ7KHJRGVW KH$HVLUDUHQRW KLQJEXW SLFW XUHV
FRSLHV RI W KLV DOO SRZHU ZKLFK W KH\ FDOOHG ³ DOIRW KXU ´   DOO EHJHW W HU  $ERXW  W KLV
DOO IDW KHU W KH\ W ROG LQ W KH VDP H VRXUFH *\OIDJLQQLQJ  W KDW  KH ZDV ZLW K W KH ³ LFH
JLDQW V´ W KH -RW XQV ³ EHIRUH W KHUH ZDV KHDYHQ DQG HDUW K´  7KLV DOO IDW KHU DOO
EHJHW W HU LV W KH VSLULW XDO SULFLSOH RI FUHDW LRQ LW  LV W KH P DQ VSLULW   :LW K W KH LFH
JLDQW V W KH HOHP HQW V DUH P HDQW  W KH 8U P DW W HU P DW W HU P DW HU /DW LQ  P RW KHU 
7KH-RW XQVDOVRFDOOHG³ 7XUVHV´ZKLFKP HDQVHDW HUVRUW KLUVW \RQHVDUHKHUHDV
Z HOO DV HY HU \ Z KHU H HOVH LQ W KH (GGD W KDW  Z KLFK LV QRW  VSLU LW XDO W KH HW HU QDO
P HW DEROLVP  DQG W KH HW HU QDO FKDQJH RI P DW W HU  Z LW KLQ DQ 8U  HOHP HQW  XQGHU
GLUHFW LRQRIW KHVSLULW XDO7KHZRUG³ -RW XQ´ LVW KHRSSRVLW HRI³ *RW H´*RW K*RG
DQG W KH *RRG
 

7KHUHDOL]DW LRQW KDW OLIHH[LVW VDQGRULJLQDW HVIURP DSRODULW \LHIURP RSSRVLW HV
Z DV P RU H FOHDU O\  LQ W KH FRQVFLRXVQHVV RI W KH DQFLHQW  *HU P DQV W KDQ LQ RXU V
W RGD\  7KH\ NQHZ   %HIRUH W KH (DUW K W KHUH ZDV QRW KLQJ EXW  ³ IRJ KRP H´  DQG
³ IODP H KRP H´  Z KLFK LQ DFW XDOLW \  U HIHU V W R W Z R VW DW HV  QDP HO\  FROGQHVV DQG
ZDUP W K IURP  ZKLFK W KH\ VHH HP HUJH W KH ZRUOG DQG OLIH  7KLV LV DQ HQW LUHO\
P RGHUQ VFLHQW LILF FRQFHSW   :H KDYH W R EH FOHDU RI W KH IDFW  W KDW  W KH KXP DQ ZKR
LV FRQQHFW HG ZLW K *RG KDV DQ 8U YLHZ RI DOO 8U RULJLQV ZKLFK W RGD\¶V KXP DQLW \
IUXLW OHVVO\ W ULHV W R JUDVS ZLW K W KH LQW HOOHFW  DORQH  7KHUHIRUH LW  KDSSHQV W KDW  ZH
ILQG W KH NQRZOHGJH RI RXU DQFHVW RUV LQ DP D]LQJ SHUIHFW LRQ EXW  ZH FDQQRW  ILQG
ORJLFDO SDW K V DQ G FRQ FOX VLRQ V W K DW  OHDG W R W K HP    7K HU HI RU H  Z H FRQ FOX GH
HUURQHRXVO\ W KDW  W KH\ KDG ³ FRLQFLGHQW DO KXQFKHV´  &HUW DLQO\ W KHKXQFKLHW KH
W KRXJKW  UHVXOW V RI W KH DUUD\ RI DQFHVW RUV IURP  W KH FHOO W R *RG SOD\V D UROH
EHFDXVH VLQFH 8U W LP HV ZH DUH W KH HYROXW LRQDU\ OLQH EHW ZHHQ W KHVH W ZR SRLQW V
1R LQGLYLGXDO NQRZ OHGJH Z LOO HYHU EH FDSDEOH RI UHSODFLQJ W KH P \W K W KH 8U
LQVLJKW   7KLV ZLOO KDSSHQ DV XQOLNHO\ DV D KHDS RI EULFNV ZLOO DUUDQJH LW VHOI W R EH
DQ DUW IXO EXLOGLQJ

, QW KH(GGD<P LULVW KHJLDQW IURP ZKRP W KH$HVLUEXLOGW KHP VHOYHVW KHIRUP HG
(DUW K  ,  KDYH W KH ZRUG W UDQVODW HG ZLW K ³ LP P HU´    ³ , P P HU´  LV IHG E\ W KH ZRUOG
FRZ$XGXP ELDZKLFKP HDQVDEXQGDQFH%RW KDUHDV\P ERORIW KHLQH[KDXVW LEOH
QDW XUHW KHDOO QXUVLQJP RW KHU$XGXP ELDOLFNVW KH³ VDOW ´ IURP W KH³ EORFNVRILFH´
OLFNVOLIHIRUW KIURP W KHP )URP W KH³ VDOW RIW KH(DUW K´ W KHJRG P DQHYROYHVW KDW
ZKLFK LV VSLULW XDO W KDW  ZKLFK LV KXP DQ DQG VW ULYHV W R FRP SOHW LRQ W R SHUIHFW LRQ
7KLV'LYLQH VSLULW XDOSULQFLSOHLQHW HUQLW \FRQQHFW HGZLW KW KHJLJDQW LFZLW KP DW W HU
ZLW KP DW HULDOW LP HDQGDJDLQUHYLYHVW KHFRP EDW EHW ZHHQJRRGDQGHYLOEHW ZHHQ
ZDUP W KDQGFROGQHVVEHW ZHHQ\HVDQGQREHW ZHHQP RLVW DQGGU\EHW ZHHQORZ
DQG KLJK EHW ZHHQ OLJKW  DQG GDUNQHVV  7KDW  ZKLFK LV VSLULW XDO SHQHW UDW HV W KH
P DW HULDO DQG GLVVROYHV LW  E\ HQOLYHQLQJ LW  E\ VSLULW XDOL]LQJ LW  EXW  LW  GRHV QRW  VR
FRP SOHW HO\ EHFDXVH W KDW  ZKLFK LV RI W KH GULYHV FR UXOHV LW  VW LOO P XGGLHV W KDW
ZKLFK LV VSLULW XDO DQG W KLV LV W KH FXUVH RI W KLV ZRUOG

:RUOG RI W KH JRGV"  , GRODW U\"  (YHU\ LQVLJKW IXO SHUVRQ FDQ VHH FOHDUO\ W KDW  DOO
W KHVHLP DJHVDUHGHHSLQW HUSUHW DW LRQVDQGP HDQLQJVRID'LYLQH8U SRZHUZKLFK
LV D XQLW \  2XU  DQFHVW RU V FHU W DLQO\  GLG QRW  KDY H W KH LQW HOOHFW XDO SRYHU W \ RU
VW XSLGLW \ W KDW  RW KHUV QHHGHG W R ³ SROLVK XS´  D ³ SHUVRQ´  W KDW  DOZD\V SOD\V TXLW H
DQ XQEHOLHYDEOH \HW  XQIRUW XQDW H UROH EH LW  LQ W KH KRXVH RI DQ XQFOHDU HW HUQLW \
RU ZLW KLQ W KH ULJLG FRQILQHP HQW V RI VSDFH DQG W LP H

7KHILUVW VFKRODUZKRUHFRJQL]HGLQW KH(GGDDW UXHW UDGLW LRQRIP \VW HULHVZDV7

/ 6W XGDFK ZKLFK SXEOLVKHG LQ  D W UDQVODW LRQ RI W KH 6lP XQGDU (GGD ZKLFK
FRQW DLQHG W KH GHHSHVW  DQG EHVW  RI W KH (GGD LQ FRP P HQW DULHV DQG W KDW  ZDV D
ORQJW LP HEHIRUH*ULP P +LVZRUNLVIRUJRW W HQDQGKLVQDP HDQGW UDQVODW LRQDUH
P HQW LRQHG QRZKHUH  $OO RI W KH VFLHQFH RI *HUP DQLVP  SDVVHG KLP  E\ ZLW KRXW


, P P HU P RGHUQ*HUP DQ  DOZD\V
 

XQGHUVW DQGLQJ KLP  DQG KLV ZRUN  , QGHHG KH KDV IRXQG W KH NH\ W R W KH (GGD E\
GLVFRY HU LQJ W KDW  LW  LV D W U DGLW LRQ RI DQFLHQW  P \ VW HU LHV RI LQLW LDW LRQ DQG W KH\
FDQQRW DSSHDUFOHDQHULQDQ\RW KHU³ %LEOH´6RP HGD\W KLVZLOOEHDQXQH[SHFW HG
HIIHFW  RI W KH (GGD  9ROXVSD LV W UDQVODW HG ZLW K ³ W KH :DOD VSHDNV´ ,  ZRXOG UDW KHU
VHH LQ ³ VSD´  W KH 8U ZRUG IRU ORRNLQJ VHHLQJ ZDQW LQJ W R JHW  W KH LQVLJKW    7KH
9ROD ORRNV RXW  LH W KH VHHU ORRNV EDFN LQW R W KH SDVW  DQG DKHDG LQW R W KH IXW XUH
ZLW KKHUVSLULW XDOH\H7KHUHIRUH, W UDQVODW HGW KHKHDGOLQHRIW KHSRHP ZLW K³ W KH
YLVLRQ RI W KH VHHU ´

7KXV ,  GHP DQG W KH HDU RI VDFUHG G\QDVW \

2I KLJK DQG ORZ RIIVSULQJ RI +HLP GROG
)ROORZLQJ W KH ZLOO RI :DO IDW KHU ,  DP  JRLQJ W R W HOO \RX
:KDW  W DOHV RI KXP DQV IURP  W LP HV RI \RUH ,  NQRZ
,  VW LOO KDYH KXQFKHV RI W KH JLDQW V W KH 8U W KHQ ERUQ RQHV
:KR HYHQ P H KDYH EHJRW W HQ EHIRUH W LP HV
1LQH FLUFOHV RI W KH ZRUOGV W KHUH KDYH EHHQ QLQH VSDFHV ,  NQRZ RI
2I W KH HW HUQDO ZRUOG W UHH JURZQ IURP  W KH HDUW K
, Q W KH ROG DJH LW  VW LOO ZDV DV 8U URDU RI ZLQGV OLYHG
1R VDQG ZDV QRU VHD QRU FRROLQJ ELOORZV
1R HDUW K W KHUH ZDV QRU W KH VN\ DERYH
2QO\ \DZQLQJ DE\VV DQG QRZKHUH D EODGH RI JUDVV

7KH EDVLV RI DOO P \W KRORJ\ LV D VXQNHQ NQRZOHGJH

0\W KV DUH QRW  IRONV\ SRHW U\ DV RQO\ D ELJ P LVXQGHUVW DQGLQJ FRXOG FODLP  EXW
DOZD\VLP DJHVRILQVLJKW VDQGZLVGRP W KDW FDQFUHDW HW KHP \W K:RUOGSHUFHSW LRQ
DERYHW KHVHQVHVKDVEHHQW DXJKW DQGFXOW LYDW HGLQW KRVHW LP HVDQGVFKRROV, Q
W KH SUH ZRUOG P \W K W KH *HUP DQLF SHUVRQ ULVHV W RZDUGV KLV FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K W KH
$OO IDW KHU  LP P HGLDW HO\  DV W KH VRQ DV W KH VRQ RI *RG IU RP  W KH IDW KHU   DQG
P RW KHU JURXQGRIW KHZRUOG2QO\DQ$U\DQQHYHUDQ2ULHQW DO FRXOGUHFRJQL]H
W KH 8U &KULVW LDQ )DW KHU *RG  2QO\ D FKXUFK W KDW  LV W RW DOO\ IRUHLJQ W R KLP  FRXOG
GLVW DQFH LW VHOI W KDW  IDU IURP  W KLV 8U SHUFHSW LRQ DV LW  GLG

7KH +DJ $OO W KH ZRUOG DVK W UHH <JJGUDVLO W KH FDUULHU RI W KH HJR LI W UDQVODW HG
OLW HUDOO\ LV VHHQ FRVP LFDOO\ DV W KH ERG\ RI *RG W KH FRVP LF ERG\ RI W KH KXP DQ
7KH FUHDW LRQ RI P DQ IURP  D W UHH DV W KH (GGD W HDFKHV SURYHV LW VHOI DV D KLJKHU
VSLULW XDO UHDOLW \  7KH (GGD KDV VW LOO P DLQW DLQHG LQ SXUH VHFUHW  ODQJXDJH W KLV W UHH
RI OLIH DQG LW V P HDQLQJ OLNH QR RW KHU W UDGLW LRQ GLG  :LW K W KLV LW  VKRZV W KDW  LW
UHP DLQHG FORVHVW  W R W KH RULJLQ RI W KLV FRQFHSW  W KDW  LW V UHYHODW LRQ LV W KH ROGHU
RQHW KHSXUHURQH2QLW VIRRW RQW KHW UHHURRW VDUHOLYLQJW KHW KUHHZRP HQRI
IDW H 8UGD 9HUGDQGL DQG 6NXOG   3DVW  SUHVHQW  DQG IXW XUH
 

 )URP  LW V URRW V VSULQJ W KH IRXU VW UHDP V RI VSLULW  DQG 0LP LU W KH FRVP LF ZLVGRP 
LV VLW W LQJ DW  W KH IRXQW DLQ RI P HP RULHV  +H LV D OLYLQJ 8U EHLQJ    $V DOLYH DV W KH
P HP RU\ VW D\V ZLW K XV W KXV DOLYH LV 0LP LU ZKLFK P HDQV W KH ³ P H W R P H´ W KH
P HP RU\ RI VHOI

 )URP  W KH W ULEDOO\ NLQ ODQG RI W KH $U\R , QGLDQV D P HP RU\ FDOOV W R XV W KH ZRUOG
W UHH IURP  W KH 8SDQLVKDGV RI W KH 9HGDV

5RRW V RQ W RS W ZLJV KDQJLQJ GRZQ

7KHVH KDV W KLV HW HUQDO ILJ W UHH
7KLV LV W KH SXUH RQH LV W KH %UDKP DQ
7KLV LV FDOOHG W KDW  ZKLFK LV LP P RUW DO
, Q LW  DUH UHVW LQJ DOO W KH XQLYHUVHV
1R RQH VW HSV EH\RQG LW 

, I Z H FRP SDU H W KH P LJKW \  LP DJHV RI W KH Z LVGRP  RI P \ W K Z LW K W KH VKDOORZ
VD\LQJV RI RXU P DVVHV W KHQ ZH FDQ IDW KRP  ZLW K GHHSHVW  HP RW LRQ W KH KRUULEOH
KLVW RU\ RI RXU VSLULW XDO FROODSVH

:RUOG 7UHH 6L[ SRLQW HG VW DU +DJ $OO 5XQH

ZLW K +DJ $OO 5XQH RU :RUOG 7UHH
7KH H[ SODQDW LRQ RI W KH KRU U LEOH VSLU LW XDO FROODSVH RI W KH Z RU OG  HVSHFLDOO\  RI
*HUP DQ\ W R W KH EDVLF HYLO RI W KH ZURQJ ZHOW DQVFKDXXQJ ILQGV DQ LP P HGLDW H
UHSUHVHQW DW LRQLQ7KRP DVLQYRQ=LUFODHUHV¶³ 'HU:HOVFKH*DVW ´  7KH:HOVK*XHVW 
ZKLFK 0DUW LQ %UFKHU SRLQW HG RXW  ILUVW 

7KLV LV RI LQYDOXDEOH LP SRUW DQFH EHFDXVH DW  W KH W LP H RI =LUFODHUHV   W KH
VSLULW XDOURRW  HYLOZDVLQIXOOHVW EORRP LQLW VP HDQHVW GHJHQHU DW LRQZKLOHRQW KH
RW KHU KDQG W KH NQRZOHGJH UHODW HG W UDGLW LRQV RI SXUH DQG XQIDOVLILHG *HUP DQ
QHVV ZHUH VW LOO UHODW LYHO\ IUHVK HYHQ W KRXJK FROODSVLQJ

7KH ³ :HOVK JXHVW ´  LV D JU HDW  ³ HGXFDW LRQDO SRHP ´ Z KLFK DV W KH QDP H VD\V
FOHDU O\  EUDFHV LW VHOI RII DJDLQVW  W KH LQFU HDVLQJO\  VW U HQJW KHQLQJ RI FKU LVW LDQ
³ :HOVKLQJ´  RI *HUP DQ GRP 

, Q RXW VW DQGLQJ FOHDUQHVV RI W KRXJKW  W KH LP DJH RI W KDW  SDJH VKRZ V W KH P DLQ
UHDVRQ RI RXU FROODSVH

, DP LQFOLQHGW RW UDQVODW HW KLVZ LW K³ 8U EHLQJ QHVV´  SOD\Z LW KERW KZ RUGV

1RW ³ :HOVK´ UHODW LQJW R:DOHVEXW W R/DW LQVSHDNLQJSHRSOHP DLQO\, W DOLDQ
 

$V =LUFODHUH VD\V FRUUHFW O\ LQ KLV VHFRQG OLQH W KH P DLQ HYLO LV LJQRUDQFH ZKLFK
EHFDXVH RI ODFN RI D VSLU LW XDO OHDGHU  FDQQRW  XQW DQJOH DQ\  P RU H W KH VSLU LW XDO
HUULQJ W KDW  ZDV FDXVHG E\ SHUSOH[LW \  7R KLV W H[W  =LUFODHUH DGGV LP P HGLDW HO\ D
JURXS RI ILJXUHV ZKLFK VXSSRUW V W KDW  ZKLFK LV VDLG LQ VLP SOLFLW \ DQG ZLW K GHHS
LQW HUSUHW DW LRQ RI W KH P HDQLQJ

, Q W KH EDFN RQ W KH ULJKW  VLGH LV ³ W KH ROG RQH´ OHIW  LQ IURQW  RI KLP  ³ W KH \RXQJ
RQH´ W KH OHIW  W KH ³ ODVW  RQH´

, W  LV W KH ROG DQG W KH QHZ W HDFKLQJ RU GRFW ULQH

, Q REQR[LRXV VSLULW  W KH ULEERQ RI W KH ³ \RXQJ RQH´  VD\V   ³ OHW  P H JR DKHDG ROG
IRRO´
2Q W KH ULEERQ RI W KH ³ ROG RQH´  ZH UHDG W KH SDLQIXO ZRUGV  ³ VR W KLV LV W KH ZD\
W KLQJV DUH QRZ ZLW K W KH ZRUOG´
2Q W KH OHIW  LV VLW W LQJ ³ W KH ORUG´ *RG ZKR W XUQV W R W KH KXP DQ DQG DVNV KLP 
³ :KRP  GR \RX ZDQW  DV DQ LQW HUFHVVRU´
7KHRQHZKRLVW DONHGW RVKRZVDUDP ZLW KW KHDQVZHURQW KHULEERQ ³ , W DNHW KH
UDP  RI FRXUVH´  :LW K W KLV W KH RQH ZKR ZDV DVNHG W XUQV EDFN W R W KH SHUVRQ
EHKLQG KLP  ZKR FRQILUP V RQ KLV ULEERQ  ³ \RX KDYH GRQH ULJKW ´
:LW KW KHUDP $ULHVLVP HDQW W KH$U\DQW KH$HVLUW KH:LGDUZKLFKFRP HVDJDLQ
DIW HU W KH ³ *|W W HUGlP P HUXQJ´  DQG W KH GXVN RI W KH KXP DQV

, Q U LJKW  LQVLJKW  =LU FODHU H W XU QV DJDLQVW  W KH QHZ O\  LQYDGLQJ :HOVK GDQJHU E\
EHJLQQLQJ
7KH XQZLVH KDV D ZLVH P DQ¶V W RQJXH
7KH ZLVH RQH FDQQRW  JLYH DGYLFH

7KLV P HDQV W KDW  W KH ³ \RXQJ RQH´  ZKR SXVKHV KLP VHOI LQ IURQW  FODLP V IRU KLP VHOI
W KH W RQJXH RI ZLVGRP  RI W KH DQFLHQW  NQRZOHGJH  , Q GHHSHVW  SDLQ IROORZV W KH
DQVZHUEHFDXVHW KH³ ROGRQH´  2GLQ =HXV FDQQRW JLYHDQ\P RUHDGYLFHEHFDXVH
W KH ROG ODZ RI LQVLJKW  KDV EHHQ ORVW  DQG QR RQH LV KHUH ZKR FDQ SRLQW  RXW  W KH
HUURU DQG SURYH W KDW  QR RQH LV KHUH ZKR LV QRW  DIUDLG

, Q IURQW  RI W KH ROG RQH SXVKHV W KH \RXQJ RQH VR W KLV RQH VSHDNV W KH IORJJLQJ
ZRUGV
7KH DQLP DO KDV D KXP DQ¶V W RQJXH
5HFHLYHG DQG P HDQV W R VSHDN ZHOO
(YHU\P DQVKRXOG
, Q W XUQ NHHS KLV W RQJXH TXLHW
$QG VKRXOG OHW  W KH DQLP DO GR W KH W DONLQJ
7KLV ZD\ QHZ  ODZV FDP H LQW R EHLQJ

:KLFK P HDQV   ZKDW  ZDV DW  W KH ERW W RP  KDV EHHQ SXW  RQW R W KH W RS

7KH P DVW HU VKRXOG QRZ KRQRU W KH VHUI

$QG NQLJKW V VKRXOG ZDON

 

5LJKW IXOO\ W KH ³ /RW W HU´   KDYH W R ULGH

7KH KRO\ VHHU VDLG
:KHQ KH VDZ W KH VHUIV ULGLQJ
:KLOH W KH P DVW HUV KDG W R ZDON
7KLV LV W R XQGHUVW DQG DV IROORZV
7KDW  W KH HYLO RQHV KDYH KRQRU
7KH JRRG RQHV DUH YHU\ KXP LOLDW HG
7KLV DOO EHFDP H QRZ LOOXVLRQ
:K\ GRHV LW  QHHG W R EH W KDW  ZD\"

$Q LQVLJQLILFDQW  ³ &KULVW LDQ´  SDOOLDW LRQ IROORZV

%HFDXVH W KRVH ZLW KRXW  YLUW XH
+DYH P DVW HU\ RI W KH ZRUOG

:LW K LQGLJQDW LRQ KH UHVSRQGV W KHUHIRUH

+RZ"  'LG \RX QRW  XQGHUVW DQG P H"
7KDW  P RXQW DLQ W UHHV KDYH
6XQNHQ GRZQ W R W KH P RUDVV"

%HFDXVHRQO\RQHZKRNQRZVVD\VKRZRXUKLJKHVW YDOXHGNQRZOHGJHDQGZLVGRP
KDYH VXQNHQ GRZQ W R W KH GHHSHVW  SLW  RI W KH P RUDVV  +HUH LV RI QR XVH ZKHQ
KHOSOHVV ³ VFKRODUV´  FRQILUP  W KH DEQRUP DOLW \ RI W KH VLW XDW LRQ EHFDXVH HYHQ W KH
LJQRUDQW  SHUVRQ IHHOV LW  RQ KLV RQ ERG\

:KHQ ZH W HOO W KH ³ VFKRODU´  W KH UHDVRQ IRU W KDW  ZKROH SODJXH KH IDLOV IRU W KH
VDP HUHDVRQDVW KHLJQRUDQW SHUVRQ RQW KHKRUULEOHLQFDSDELOLW \RILQQHUVSLULW XDO
LQ VLJK W V

)LQDOO\ W KH ³ ROG RQH´  VD\V

:KHQ W KH JUDVV RI W KH VZDP S
:DV GRZQ LQ W KH VZDP S
$QG W KH VW RROV OD\ GRZQ W KH VHUI ZDV VHUI
$QG ZKHQ ZH W RRN FDUH RI KLJK W DEOHV
$QG ORZ SHRSOH NQRZ W KDW
7KDW  W KHQ W KH ZRUOG ZDV D EHW W HU SODFH
7KHQ W KH P DVW HU DQG W KH VHUI
'LG W KDW  ZKLFK W KH\ ULJKW IXOO\ VKRXOG GR

7ZR SRLQW V ZH VKRXOG SRLQW  RXW  DV W KH P RVW  LP SRUW DQW  RQHV
7KH VHFRQG OLQH ³ 7KH ZLVH RQH LV QRW  DOORZHG W R DGYLVH´    W KLV P HDQV W KH OLH
FDQQRW  EH UHFRJQL]HG DQG UHM HFW HG

7KHQW KHGUDZLQJRIW KH³ \RXQJRQH´ZKLFKZLW KUD\SRZHUDQGGLVGDLQFRQVFLRXVO\

SODQV W R IHOO W KH W UHH RI NQRZOHGJH


*RUVOHEHQZULW HV³ /GHULJHQ´  ³ /RW W HU´ LVD\RXQJJURZQ XSP DQRUD\RXW KZKRLVFORVHW REH
JURZ QXSW KHZ RUGVW LOOH[LVW VLQW KHXSSHU *HUP DQDUHD
 

%RW K IULHQGV KRZHYHU VKDNH KDQGV  W KH\ VKRZ ORYH DQG LQVLJKW  W KH\ NQRZ RI
W KH :LGDU   ZKLFK ZLOO FRP H DJDLQ  7KLV ZD\ LW  LV ZLW K W KH ZRUOG W RGD\

7KH UH JDLQLQJ RI SXUH LQVLJKW  DQG ZLVGRP  LV W LHG W R P DW KHP DW LFDO ODZV ZKLFK
KDV W R IXOILOO LW VHOI DJDLQ DQG DJDLQ LQ W KH VSLULW XDO UHDOP  LQ VSLW H RI DOO KXP DQ
LJQRUDQFH DQG URW W HQQHVV

$QG VKRXOG W KH M HDORXV\ RI DOO SHRSOHV DQG RXU RZQ GHJHQHUDW HG K\EULG EORRG
JQDZOLNHW KH³ ZRUP RIM HDORXV\´ RQW KHURRW VRIW KHW UHHRI*HUP DQZLVGRP W KH
ZRUOGDVK<JJGUDVLOZLVKUXLQDQGGLVDVW HUW KLVLVLQYDLQEHFDXVH2GLQGHW HUP LQHG
LW  RW KHU Z LVH

7KLV RQO\ VHHV W KH EULJKW  H\H RI W KH VHHU ZKLFK NQRZV W KDW  D ³ ILQDO UXLQ´  FDQQRW
H[ LVW 

7KH ³ ROG RQH´  DGYLVHV DJDLQ


2PLWWHG
 

9, , , 
7+ (, //86, 21 2)7+ (*2'6
:RGDQ VSHDNV
8S KLJK ,  VHH D KRO\ ODQG
&ORVH W R W KH $HVLU DQG $OEHV
2QEUDYHFDVWOHXSKLJK'RQDUVLWVRQKLVWKURQHWRWKHGD\
2I W KH W ZLOLJKW  RI W KH JRGV LQ W KH IXW XUH
)LYH KXQGUHG URRP V DQG IRXU W LP HV W HQ
,  W KLQN KDV 'RQDU ¶V EXLOGLQJ
2I DOO W KH GZHOOLQJV RI W KH JRGV ,  NQRZ
0\ VRQ RZQV W KH ODUJHVW 

, W LVDQHUURUDQHUURUW KDW LVVSUHDGSXUSRVHO\LQP DQ\VLW XDW LRQVLI

SHRSOHP HDQVW LOOQRZDGD\VW KDW RXUDQFHVW RUV³ SUD\HG´ W RW KHY DULRXV
JRGVM XVW EHFDXVHVXFKSUDFW LFHLVFRP P RQSODFHLQW RGD\¶V³ &KU LVW LDQ´
(XURSH  1R W KH\ W KHP VHOYHV FDOOHG LW  DQ ³ LOOXVLRQ´ RU D P LUDJH RI
W KH JRGV RU ³ OLHV RI W KH H[DOW HG RQH´ W KHLU :DOKDOOD W KHLU ³ KDOO RI
M R\´  DQG W KHLU ³ KDOO RI ORYH´   DQG W KDW  ZDV ZKDW  W KH\ FDOOHG DOO W KH
JRRG DQG HY LO IRU FHV  Z LW K Z KLFK W KH\  SRSXODW HG W KHLU  Z RU OGV RI
W KRXJKW V   DQG UHDOLW \  , Q W KHLU LQQHUP RVW  KHDUW V W KH\ UHFRJQL]HG
ZLW KXOW LP DW HFHUW DLQW \W KHRQO\*RGW KH³ IDW KHURIDOOJRGVDQGP HQ
W KHFUHDW RURIKHDYHQDQGHDUW K´  DQGW KDW LQQRGLIIHUHQW ZD\DVRXU
JUHDW HVW  P LQGV KDYH UHFRJQL]HG W KH HVVHQFH RI W KH 'LYLQH EHLQJ   , Q
DOO W LP HV P RU H RIW HQ IRU  VXU H LQ HDU OLHU  W LP HV LOOXP LQDW HG SHRSOH
KDYHW DXJKW KXP DQVW KLVZD\, QIDFW W KHP DM RULW \RIW KHSHRSOHIHOW
D ³ NLQVKLS´  W R W KH JRGV  7KH\ IHOW  W KHP VHOYHV DV EHLQJ W KH VRQV RI
*RG EHFDXVH W KH\ ZHUH FORVH W R *RG FORVHU W R *RG W KDQ DUH SHRSOH
RI W RGD\

7KH ZRUOG RI W KH $HVLU LV EXW  D V\P ERO RI W KH LQILQLW H LQYLVLEOH SRZHU
RI *RG  ³$ERYH DOO W KH JRGV LV W KH $OO IDW KHU ´ ZKLFK KRZHYHU LV QRW
:RGDQDVOHJHQGNQRZVKLP DVOLW W OHDVW KHLP DJHRIW KH³ JRRG*RG´
LQ W KH SHRSOH RI W RGD\ UHSUHVHQW V KLJKHU FRQVFLRXVQHVV RI *RG  7KH
³ JRGV´  SHU LVK LQ W KH W Z LOLJKW  RI W KH JRGV W KH 'LY LQLW \ W KH 'LY LQH
SULQFLSOHUHP DLQV, QQRZD\VGRZHZDQW W RUHW XUQW RW KHROG³ IDLW K´
7KLV LV VR EHFDXVH HDFK HUD KDV W R FRLQ LW V RZQ VSHFLILF H[SUHVVLRQ
+RZHYHUZHZDQW W RGHVFHQGW RW KHVDP HVRXUFHVRISRZHURXUVHOYHV
IURP  ZKLFK RXU DQFHVW RUV GUHZ W KHLU SRZHU  7KHQ ZH ZLOO QRW  JR
DVW UD\ DQ\ P RUH
7KH LOOXVLRQ  RU  P LU DJH  RI W KH JRGV  LQ DQFLHQW  1RU GLF ODQJXDJ H
*\OIDJLQQLQJ DFW XDOO\ *\OILV EHGD]]OHP HQW  LV W KDW  SDUW  RI W KH VR
 

FDOOHG SURVH  RU \RXQJHU (GGD ZKLFK GHVFULEHV W KH YR\DJH RI DQ LQLW LDW H ZKR
Y LVLW V W KH JRGV KLP VHOI  7KH IDFW  W KDW  W R W KLV GD\  W KHU H H[ LVW V QR FRP SOHW H
W UDQVODW LRQLQW RW KH*HUP DQODQJXDJHZLOODOZD\VEHDP DW W HURIDP D]HP HQW DQG
DV\P SW RP RIXW W HULJQRUDQFHDQGODFNRILQW HUHVW DVIDUDVRXW VSLULW XDOKHULW DJH
LV FRQFHUQHG  6LP URFN¶V W UDQVODW LRQ ZKLFK LV RXW  RI SULQW  IRU  D ORQJ W LP H ZDV D
VFKRODUO\ ZRUN IRU VFKRODUV W KDW  ZLW K DOO SUHFLVLRQ RIIHUHG FRXOG QRW  VDW LVI\ W KH
UHDGHU*HULQJEURXJKW RQO\DQH[W UDFW LRQW KDW RIW HQRYHUORRNHGW KDW ZKLFKZDV
HVVHQW LDODQGLP SRUW DQW 7KH³ EHGD]]OHP HQW RIW KHJRGV´ JLYHVXVLQW KHVKDSH
RIDQDUUDW LRQZLW KVW \OHDJRRGSLFW XUHRIW KH*HUP DQLFZRUOGRIW KHKXP DQVDQG
JRGVDQGRIW KHJUHDW QHVVRI*HUP DQLFSRVLW LRQLQW KHZRUOGDQGLQGHSHQGHQFH
, Q W KH ZKROH ZRUOG OLW HUDW XUH ZH KDYH QR RW KHU H[DP SOH RI D ZRU OGYLHZ W KDW  LV
QDUUDW HGZLW KVSLULW LQQHUIHHOLQJDQGVW \OHDV\RXILQGLQW KLVOLW HUDU\ZRUN+HUH
ZHKDYHDW HVW LP RQ\RIW KDW ZKLFKZDVEHDXW LIXODQGHOHYDW HGLQROGW LP HVZKDW
SHRSOH W KRXJKW  DQG EHOLHYHG EXW  QRW  QHFHVVDULO\ ZHUH ³ IRUFHG W R EHOLHYH´ ZKDW
W KH\ FRQVLGHUHG W R EH DQ HTXDW LRQ RI W KH ZRUOG RI W KH GLYLQLW \ RI OLIH

1R RQH FDQ VD\ LQ RXU GD\V W KDW  KH NQHZ RI KLV VSLULW XDO RULJLQ LI KH GRHV QRW
NQRZ W KHVH DP D]LQJ FUHDW LRQV RI $U\DQ H[XEHUDQFH LQ IRUP 

, QW KH³ LOOXVLRQRIW KHJRGV´ W KHJUDQGHXUDQGP DJQLILFHQFHRI W KLVSHUFHSW LRQRI

*RG ZLW KRXW  GRJP DW LF FRHUFLRQ VKRZV LW VHOI KLGGHQ LQ D SOD\IXO  HYHQ JURW HVTXH
FORW KLQJ7KLVKDVSRVVLEO\EHHQGRQHW RKLGHW KLVXQLTXHP RQXP HQW RI*HUP DQLF
NQRZOHGJHRIW KHJRGVDQGW KHZRUOGIURP W KHLJQRUDQFHRIXQDXW KRUL]HGSHUVRQV
DQGW RUHP RYHLW IURP W KHFRP SXOVRU\GHVLUHW RSURVHFXW HRISRZ HUVW KDW GLGQRW
DOZD\V DFW  W KH ³ &KULVW LDQ´  ZD\    7R DVVXP H W KDW  W KHVH FUHDW LRQ P \W KV DUH LQ
SDUW EDVHGXSRQW UDGLW LRQVW KDW ZHUHLQKHULW HGE\KXP DQNLQGW KU RXJKP LOOLRQVRI
\HDUVLVLQQRZD\W RRIDU IHW FKHGDQGW KLVFDQEHIRXQGLQW KHIDFW VW KHP VHOYHV
W KDW  ZHUH W UDQVP LW W HG

:KDW ZHKDYHORVW LQW KHZRUOG DQGKHDYHQV YLHZRIW KH*HUP DQLFSHRSOHVZH

FDQUHDGZLW K5HXW HU ³ 7KHHQLJP DRIW KH(GGD´E\6LP URFNLQ³ 0\W KRORJ\´ZLW K
8HKOL  ³ 1RUGLF *HUP DQLF P \W KRORJ\ DQG KLVW RU\ RI P \VW HULHV´ +HUP DQQ :LUW K´
DVFHQW RIKXP DQNLQG´)XKUP DQQ ³ 7KH*HUP DQV´ DQG:LOVHUHTXDOO\³ 7KH*HUP DQLF
SHRSOH´

)RUW KHILUVW W LP HLW LVLQW KH(GGDW KDW VDOYDW LRQLVSURFODLP HGW RXVIURP RXURZQ
EORRG  7KH (GGD LV JRLQJ W R EULQJ XV W KH EDVLV IRU HGXFDW LRQ DQG LQVLJKW V IRU D
QHZ IRONLVK FRP P XQLW \ ZKLFK W UDQVFHQGV E\ IDU W KLQJV W KDW  P D\ EH GLVSXW HG
EHFDXVHLW HQFRP SDVVHVSXUHJRG KXP DQ KRRG:HDUHUHSHDW LQJW KLVEHFDXVH
LW  LV ZD\ W RR LP SRUW DQW  W R DOORZ LW  EHLQJ IRUJRW W HQ  7KH ZRUOG RI W KH $HVLU LV
V\P ERO RI W KH SRZHU RI *RG  LW  LV QRW  W KRXJKW  D UHDOLW \  $ERYH DOO JRGV LW ¶V W KH
$OO IDW KHUZKRLVQRW :RGDQZKRLVERUQDQGZKRZLOOSHULVKLQW KHW ZLOLJKW RIW KH
JRGV
 

0L[LQJ RI W KH VSLULW XDO ZLW K W KH P DW HULDO RI W KDW  ZKLFK LV RI W KH $HVLU ZLW K W KDW
ZKLFK LV RI W KH JLDQW V FDXVHV W KH W ZLOLJKW  RI W KH JRGV W KH GLVVROYLQJ RI W KH
ZRUOG ZKLFK EULQJV W KHQ QHZ FUHDW LRQ LQ HW HUQDO GDQFH RI OLIH IURP  EHJLQQLQJ
RYHUEHLQJW RHQGLQJ2QO\P DOLFLRXVQHVVDQGSXQLVKDEOHLJQRUDQFHFRXOGW DONRI
RXUDQFHVW RUVDVEHLQJVDYDJHV, W FHUW DLQO\LVDV\P SW RP RIW KHFRQIXVLRQW KDW
H[LVW VLQRW KHUZLVHLQW HOOLJHQW P LQGVZKHQ2VZDOG6SHQJOHUFRXOGXVHW KHIROORZLQJ
ZRUGV  ³ VRP H IDFW RU\ EUDQGV IURP  %DE\ORQLDQ W RROV P D\ KDYH EHHQ ZRUVKLSSHG
E\W KH*HUP DQLFVDYDJHVDVP DJLFDOV\P ERODQGLW P D\KDYHEHFRP HW KHRULJLQ
RIHQ³ RULJLQDO´ *HUP DQLFRUQDP HQW ´ +HP D\EHDVKDP HGRIKLVZRUGVW RGD\+H
W RR P D\ UHFRJQL]H W KDW  W KH ³ VDYDJHV´    W KHQ DV W RGD\   ZHUH W KH ³ %DE\ORQLDQV´
7KHQ KH ZLOO EH FRQVFLRXV RI W KH IDFW  W KDW  EORRG DQG VSLULW  FUHDW H FXOW XUHV  :LW K
DW UXHZRUG W KH³ P DQXIDFW XUHUV¶EUDQGV´ W KDW ZHUHXVHGLQ%DE\ORQZHUHFUHDW LRQV
DQGZLW QHVVHVRIW KHVH³ VDYDJH´ *HUP DQLFSHRSOHVZKRKDYHLP P LJUDW HGW KHUH
P LOOHQQLD DJR DQG ZKR ODLG W KH IRXQGDW LRQ W R W KH JUHDW  0LG (DVW HUQ FXOW XUHV

%DFN RI D .HOW , EHULDQ FRLQ   EFH 

7KH 7ULSRG W UL IRV  DV $U\DQ 8U V\P ERO RI W KH 7ULQLW \ LV SURYHQ ORQJ EHIRUH W KH
XVH LQ &KULVW LDQ FKXUFKHV E\ W KH FRQVW UXFW LRQ JXLOGV

/XW KHUKDVXQLILHGW KH*HUP DQODQJXDJHZLW KKLVZRUNEXW ZLW KKLVELEOHKHKDV

VSOLW W KH*HUP DQVRXO7KH(GGDLVJRLQJW RDZDNHQFUHDW LYHO\LQXVRXULQKHULW HG
SRZHU W R HP SDW K\ DQG RXU LQQHUP RVW  NQRZOHGJH DERXW  RXUVHOYHV

, W  LV ZHOO NQRZQ W KDW  ZH FDQ ILQG LQ W KH YDULRXV FUHDW LRQ P \W KV RI W KH DQFLHQW
$U\DQ FXOW XUDO SHRSOHV KLJKHVW  VFLHQW LILF LQVLJKW V EHKLQG VHHP LQJO\ GDUN ZRUGV
DQG LP DJHV  :H M XVW  QHHG W R NQRZ KRZ W R UHDG FRUUHFW O\ W KHVH GRFXP HQW V RI D
P LOOHQQLDROGH[SORUDW LRQRIW KHZRUOG7KHDQFLHQW ZLVHP HQN QHZW KDW LQVLJKW V
DQGW HDFKLQJVFDQJHW ORVW LQW KHFRXUVHRIW KHFHQW XULHV3HUKDSVW KH\W KRXJKW
W KDW  LW  ZDV QR ORQJHU QHFHVVDU\ W R W HDFK VFLHQFHV W R W KH FRP P RQ SHRSOH P RVW
RI ZKLFK ZRXOG P LVXQGHUVW DQG LW  DQ\ZD\  , Q DQ\ FDVH DW  DOO W LP HV DQG DW  DOO
SHRSOHV W KH\ FORW KHG W KHLU LQVLJKW V LQW R P \W KRORJLFDO SLFW XUHV LQ ZKLFK VKDSH
W KH\ FDP H W R RXU GD\V UDUHO\ XQW RXFKHG DQG RIW HQ GDP DJHG  :KRHYHU W KLQNV
W KDW  W KH OHJHQGV RI W LP HV RI \RUH W UDGLW LRQV RI W KH 2OG 7HVW DP HQW  RI W KH 9HGDV
DQGRIW KH(GGDDERXW W KHRULJLQRIW KHZRUOGDQGW KHFUHDW LRQRIKXP DQVDUHM XVW


 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

EDEEOLQJIRULJQRUDQW FKLOGUHQLVGHDGZURQJ:HKDYHQREHW W HUVRXUFHVIRUW KH

H[SORUDW LRQ RI HDUO\ W LP HV W KDQ W KHVH GRFXP HQW V RI VFLHQW LILF DFW LYLW \ DV LW  ZDV
ZULW W HQ LQ W KH P \W KV

6W LOOOHDVW NQRZQDQGHYDOXDW HGW RW KLVSRLQW ZHUHW KHW UDGLW LRQVRI$U\DQZLVGRP

DV ZH ILQG LW  LQ W KH (GGD W KRVH VDFUHG ERRNV RI W KH *HUP DQV W KDW  W R W KLV SRLQW
KDUGO\ SOD\HG D SDUW  LQ RXU VSLULW XDO OLIH  +RZHYHU W KH SDUW LFLSDW LRQ LQ W KHVH
RXW VW DQGLQJZRNVRIRXUSDVW LQFUHDVHGGXULQJW KHSDVW \HDUVDQGW KDW M XVW LILDEO\
EHFDXVHKHUHW KHVW UHDP VRIRXUXQLTXHVW UHQJW KIORZSRZHUIXOO\IURP W KHGDUNQHVV
RI W KH SDVW  LQW R W KH GD\OLJKW   +HUH ,  EULQJ DV DQ H[DP SOH D SDUW  RI W KH FUHDW LRQ
P \W KW KDW LVLQP \W UDQVODW LRQRIW KH*\OIDJLQQLQJRIW KH(GGD, W LVFDVW LQW RW KH
IRUP RIDQDUUDW LRQDERXW W KHW UDYHORIDQLQLW LDW HZKRYLVLW VW KHGZHOOLQJVRIW KH
JRGV7KHUHKHILQGVRXW IURP W KHP W KDW DERYHDOOJRGVDQGKXP DQVLVW KHDOO
IDW KHU W KH FUHDW RU RI DOO W KDW  OLYHV

9HU\ VXUSULVLQJ DSSHDUV KHUH W KH IDFW  W KDW  W KLV FUHDW LRQ P \W K SUHGDW HV Z LW K
VXUSULVLQJ FOHDUQHVV W KH :RUOG , FH W KHRU\ RI +|UELJHU    ,  ZRXOG OLNH W R VHH LQ
W KDW  D FRQILUP DW LRQ DQG SURRI RI W KH VFLHQW LILF GLVFRYHULHV RI +|UELJHU EHFDXVH
W KHVHP \W KVDUHLQJHQLRXVVXP P DULHVDQGLQVLJKW VGDW LQJEDFNW RW LP HVZKHQD
VW LOOSXUHUUDFHREVHUYHGW KLQJVZLW KDYLVLRQW KDW LVLP P HGLDW HO\FRQQHFW HGZLW K
*RG

+HUH LV W KH EHJLQQLQJ RI W KH VW RU\

*ROI *\OIL ZDVW KHQDP HRIDP DQ KHZDVNLQJYHU\ZLVHDQGDP DQRIVHFUHW

ZLVGRP   +H ZDV ZRQGHULQJ IRU VXFK D ORQJ W LP H ZK\ W KH IRON RI W KH $HVLU ZDV
DVFDSDEOHEHFDXVHDOOW KLQJVKDSSHQHGDFFRUGLQJW RW KHLUZLOO+HZDVZRQGHULQJ
LI W KH\ RXW JUHZ W KHLU RZQ SRZHU RU LI 'LYLQH SRZHUV ZHUH DW  ZRU N W R ZKRP  W KH
$HVLU VDFULILFHG  7KHUHIRUH KH ZHQW  RQ D W ULS W R $VJDUG RQH GD\  +RZHYHU KH
W UDYHOHGLQFRJQLW R KHW RRNW KHVKDSHRIDQROGP DQDQGKHKLGKLP VHOILQLW %XW
W KH$HVLUZHUHDZDUHRIW KDW EHFDXVHW KH\KDGW KHJLIW RIYLVLRQDQGW KH\NQHZ
RI KLV YR\DJH EHIRUH KH FDP H  6R W KH\ P HW  KLP  ZLW K D P LUDJH IRU W KH H\HV

2PLWWHG
 

ZKHQ KH FDP H W R D KLOO KH VDZ DOO RI D VXGGHQ D KDOO VR KLJK W KDW  KH FRXOG QRW
VHH DERYH LW   , W V URRI ZDV FRYHUHG ZLW K JROGHQ VKLHOGV OLNH DQ RUGLQDU\ URRI LV
FRYHUHGZLW KVKLQJOHVW KHVDP HZD\DVDFFRUGLQJW RW KHVRQJVRIW KHSRHW W KH
:DOKDOOD LV FRYHUHG ZLW K VKLHOGV

)URP  W KH ULGJH IODP HG

7R GHIHQG DJDLQVW  VW RQHV W KURZQ
6OHHSHU ¶V VKLQJOHV
)RUP V RI W KLQNLQJ DUW LVW V

, QW KHJDW HRIW KHKDOO*ROIP HW DP DQZKRM XJJOHGZLW KKDQGNQLYHVDQGKHKDG

VHYHQRIW KHP LQW KHDLUDW RQHW LP H7KLVP DQDVNHGKLP KLVQDP H*ROIFDOOHG
KLP VHOI ³ FRXUDJH W R ZDQGHU ´  ³ :DQGHUP XW ´    +H FDP H IURP  ZLOG U RDGV DQG KH
FDP HW RDVNIRUDSODFHW RVOHHSDW QLJKW 7KHQKHDVNHGZKRW KHRZQHUZDVRI
W KDW KDOO7KHP DQDQVZHUHGW KDW LW EHORQJHGW RW KHNLQJ DQG, ZLOOOHDG\RXW R
KLP  VR W KDW  \RX FDQ VHH KLP   W KHUH \RX FDQ DVN KLP  KLV QDP H \RXUVHOI

7KHP DQZHQW DKHDGLQW RW KHKDOODQGZKHQ*ROIIROORZHGW KHJDW HIHOOKDUGLQW R

LW VORFNEHKLQGKLVEDFN7KHQKHORRNHGLQW RP DQ\KDOOVDQGVDZDODUJHFURZG
6RP H RI W KH P HQ ZHUH JDP EOLQJ RW KHUV GUDQN DQG VW LOO RW KHUV H[ HUFLVHG ZLW K
W KHLU ZHDSRQV  +H ORRNHG DURXQG KLP VHOI  0XFK RI ZKDW  KH VDZ VHHP HG QRW
ULJKW  W R KLP  DQG KH VSRNH W KRVH ZRUGV W R KLP VHOI

/RRN DW  GRRUV DQG JDW HV

%H FDUHIXO EHIRUH \RX HQW HU
:KR NQRZV LI QRW    IRU D ORQJ W LP H   LV LQ DP EXVK"
<RXU HQHP \ LQ W KH KDOOZD\ RI W KH KRXVH

1RZ KH QRW LFHG W KUHH KLJK VHDW V RQH DERYH W KH RW KHU DQG RQ HDFK D P DQ ZDV
VLW W LQJ*ROIDVNHGZKDW W KHQDP HVZHUHRIW KHVHOHDGHUV7KHP DQZKRZDVKLV
JXLGHDQVZHUHG 7KHRQHRQW KHORZHVW VHDW LVDNLQJDQGKLVQDP HLV³ W KH+LJK
RQH´W KHRQHRQW KHQH[W VHDW LVFDOOHG³ W KHHTXDOKLJKRQH´ DQGW KHRQHRQW KH
KLJKHVW  VHDW  LV FDOOHG ³ W KH W KLUG RQH´

1RZW KHRQHZKRVHQDP HZDV³ W KH+LJKRQH´ DVNHGW KHQHZFRP HUZ KDW EXVLQHVV

OHG KLP  W KHUH  W KDW  KH KDV D ULJKW  W R IRRG DQG GULQN DV DOO KHU H LQ W KH KDOO

%XW  :DQGHU P XW  VDLG W KDW  KH Z DQW HG ILU VW  W R ILQG RXW  LI D N QRZ LQJ RQH DQ
LQLW LDW H  ZDV SUHVHQW  KHUH  7KH +LJK RQH UHVSRQGHG W KDW  QR RQH ZRXOG OHDYH
ZKR GLG QRW  NQRZ P RUH W KDQ W KH\ GLG DQG KH VDLG

6W D\ SXW  W KHUH VW UDQJHU DV ORQJ DV \RX DVN

:KR DQVZHUV W KRXJK VKRXOG EH VHDW HG

1RZ :DQGHUP XW  VW DUW HG W R DVN   ZKR LV W KH KLJKHVW  DQG ROGHVW  RI DOO JRGV"
 

7KH +LJK 2QH DQVZHUHG   +LV QDP H LV $OO IDW KHU LQ RXU ODQJXDJH  LQ W KH ROG
$VJDUG KRZHYHU KH KDG W ZHOYH P RUH QDP HV

:DQGHUP XW  EHIRUH W KH 'LYLQH W ULQLW \

$FFRUGLQJ W R D GUDZLQJ RI 2ODI 5XW EHFN ³$W ODQG HOOHU 0DQKHLP ´ 8SVDOD 
7KLV GUDZLQJ LV HVVHQW LDO EHFDXVH LW  KDV D ZRP DQ IROORZLQJ W KH ROG FRQFHSW
RI GLYLQH W ULQLW \ W KHUHIRUH D W ULQLW \ RI IDW KHU P RW KHU DQG VRQ LQ W KLV FDVH
2GKLQ 7KRU DQG )ULJJD
 

7KHQ :DQGHUP XW  DVNHG   :KHUH LV W KLV *RG"  $QG ZKDW  LV KH FDSDEOH RI "  2U
ZKDW  JUHDW  GHHGV KDV KH SHUIRUP HG"

7KH+LJKRQHDQVZHUHG +HLVOLYLQJW KURXJKRXW DOODJHVDQGKHUXOHVDOOZRUOGV

DQG FRQW UROV DOO W KLQJV ODUJH DQG VP DOO

(TXDOKLJ DGGHG   +H FU HDW HG W KH KHDY HQ DQG (DU W K DQG W KH DLU  DQG DOO W KDW
EHORQJV W R W KHP 

$QGW KH7KLUGRQHFRQFOXGHG %XW W KDW LVW KHJUHDW HVW W KDW KHFUHDW HGP DQDQG
JDYH KLP  W KH VSLULW  ZKLFK VKDOO OLYH DQG QHYHU H[W LQJXLVK HYHQ LI W KH ERG\ URW V
RUEXUQVW RDVKHV$QGVXFKOLIHDOOKXP DQVVKRXOGKDYHZKRZ HUHFUHDW HGULJKW 
DQG W KH\ ZLOO EH ZLW K KLP  RQ W KH SODFH W KDW  LV FDOOHG *RRG 'HHG RU 0RXQW DLQ RI
6DOYDW LRQ %HUJ GHV +HLOV   %XW  W KH ORZHU KXP DQV JR W R +HO DQG IURP  W KHUH W R
1LIHOKHLP  IRJ KRP H  ZKLFK LV EHORZ LQ W KH QLQW K ZRUOG

7ULQLW \   UHOLHI   IURP  W KH &KXUFK LQ 3ODX 0HFNOHQEXUJ

:DQGHUP XW FRQW LQXHGW RDVN :KDW GLG$OO IDW KHUEHIRUH+HDYHQDQG(DUW KZHUH

FU HDW HG"

7KH +LJK RQH DQVZHUHG   +H ZDV ZLW K W KH LFH JLDQW V

:DQGHUP XW  DVNHG   %XW  ZKDW  ZDV VW LOO EHIRUH W KH EHJLQQLQJ"  2U KRZ EHJDQ LW
DOO"  2U ZKDW  ZDV HDUOLHVW "

7KH +LJK RQH DQVZHUHG   7KLV ZD\ LW  ZDV ZDV VDLG LQ W KH VRQJ RI W KH YLVLRQ RI
W KH VHHUHVV
, Q ROG W LP HV LW  ZDV DV DOO ZDV QRW 
1RW  VDQG ZDV QRU VHD QRU FRROLQJ ELOORZV
1RW  (DUW K ZDV QRU KHDYHQV DERYH
2QO\ \DZQLQJ DE\VV DQG QRZKHUH D EODGH RI JUDVV
 

(TXDO +LJK DGGHG   7KURXJKRXW  VRP H HUDV EHIRUH W KH (DUW K ZDV FUHDW HG W KHUH
ZDVDOUHDG\1LIHOKM HP P H, QLW VP LGVW LVDIRXQW DLQFDOOHGVSULQJ FDXOGURQDQG
IURP  KLP  IORZ DOO W KH VW UHDP V ZLW K KRO\ QDP HV

7KH 7KLUG RQH FRQFOXGHG   6W LOO EHIRUH 1LIHOKHLP  ZDV D ZRUOG W KDW  ZDV FDOOHG
IODP H K RP H  W K DW  RQ H LV EU LJK W  DQ G K RW   LW  JORZ V DQ G EX U Q V  DQ G U HP DLQ V
XQDSSURDFKDEOH W R DOO W KRVH ZKR DUH QRW  DW  KRP H W KHUH  %ODFN KH FDOOV KLP VHOI
DQGW KHUHKHVLW VRQW KHERDUGHUVRIKLVHP SLUH KHKROGVDIODP LQJVZRUGLQKLV
KDQG DQG DW  W KH HQG RI W KH ZRUOG KH ZLOO FRP H DQG GHYDVW DW H DQG YDQTXLVK DOO
JRGVDQGEXUQDOOW KHZRUOGVZLW KILUH7KLVZD\LVVDLGLQW KHVRQJRIW KHYLVLRQ
RI W KH VHHUHVV

)URP  W KH 6RXW K W KH EODFN RQH FRP HV ZLW K VLQJLQJ IODP HV
+LV VZRUG VKLQHV OLNH W KH VXQ LQ W KH EDW W OHV
&OLIIV W HDU DSDUW  OLNH IDOOLQJ JLDQW V
+HO GHYRXUV W KH KXP DQV W KH KHDYHQ LV ZLGH RSHQ

:DQGHUP XW  DVNHG IXUW KHU   :KR FDP H DQG ZHQW  EHIRUH W KHUH ZHUH EHLQJV DQG
KXP DQ IRON P XOW LSOLHG"

7KH+LJKRQHDQVZHUHG 7KRVHVW UHDP VW KDW ZHFDOOZDYHVRISRZHUDQGEULJKW QHVV

FDP HVRIDUDZD\IURP W KHLURULJLQW KDW W KHFROGW KDW UROOHGDZ D\ZLW KLW KDUGHQHG
OLN H VLQW HU  Z KLFK IDOOV RXW  RI W KH ILU H   7KHU H W KH VW U HDP V EHFDP H LFH  DQG
EHFDXVH W KLV LFH ZDV ULJLG DQG GLG QRW  P RYH DQ\ P RUH W KH VW UHDP V IUR]H RQH
DERYHW KHRW KHU7KHP RLVW XUHKRZHYHUZKLFKRULJLQDW HGIURP W KLVFROGW XUQHG
W R LFH OLNHZLVH DQG W KXV LFH DIW HU LFH UROOHG RYHU W KH DE\VV W KDW  ZDV \DZQLQJ
RSHQQHVV W KH QRW KLQJ

(TXDO +LJK DGGHG   7KH SDUW  RI W KH ZRUOG DE\VV W R W KH 1RUW K ILOOHG XS ZLW K W KH
P DVVHVDQGKHDYLQHVVLILFHDQGIURVW DQGW KHUHLQLW P RYHGIURP ELOORZW RELOORZ
W KHSDUW RIW KHDE\VVLQW KHVRXW KKRZHYHUEHFDP HZDUP HUIURP W KHVSDUNVDQG
IODP HV W KDW  IOHZ RYHU IURP  IODP H KRP H

7KH W KLUG RQH FORVHG   $V W KH FROG FRP HV IURP  1LIHOKHLP  DQG ZLW K LW  DOO W KH ZLOG
DQG VW URQJ W KLQJV VR ZDV W KH SDUW  RI IODP H KRP H P LOG DQG EULJKW  DV ZDUP  DV
ZLQG VW LOO DLU  :KHQ W KH IURVW  P HW  W KH EUHDW K RI ZDUP W K VR W KDW  LW  P HOW HG DQG
GULSSHG W KH IDOOLQJ GURSV JDLQHG SRZHU W KURXJK W KH IRUFH RI W KH RQH ZKR VHQW
KHDW  DQG FROG DQG EHFDP H W KH VKDSH RI D P DQ DQG FDOOHG KLP VHOI ³ , P P HU´
<P LU 

7KLV GHHS DQG IDU UHDFKLQJ UHSRUW  RI W KH (GGD DERXW  W KH FUHDW LRQ RI W KH ZRUOG
DFFRUGLQJW RZKLFKIURP 1LIHOKHLP FDP H, FHVW UHDP VDQGJRW FDXJKW LQW KHZDUP
VSDUNV RI 0XVSHOKHLP  LV D V\P ERO RI FRVP LF JUHDW QHVV
 

7KH HW HUQDO 8U JURXQG RI DOO H[LVW HQFH LV W KH 8U SRZHU ZKLFK LV XQLP DJLQDEOH
HW HUQDO XQOLP LW HG  , W  ZDQW HG W R DFW   $ IRUFH FDQ RQO\ DFW  LI LW  KDV D SRLQW  RQ
ZKLFKW RDFW W KHSRLQW LQW KHXQLYHUVHZLW KW KHKHOSRIZKLFK$UFKLP HGHVW DONHG
DERXW  P RYLQJ W KH (DUW K RXW  RI LW V KLQJHV  7KHUHIRUH W KH IRUFH FUHDW HG IRU LW VHOI
W KH ODZ  RI HIIHFW V DQG RI SRODU LW \  W KH IRU P V RI P DQLIHVW DW LRQ RI Z KLFK DU H
1LIHOKHLP  DQG 0XVSHOKHLP   %RW K DUH QDP HV IRU W ZR VW DW HV

0XVSHOKHLP    ZDUP  DQG EULJKW

1LIHOKHLP    FROG DQG GDUN

%RW K FROOLGH LQ W KH P LGGOH DQG ³ FURVV HDFK RW KHU ´ W KH RSSRVLW HV HP HUJH

*HLVW    ZDUP  XQG KHOO

6W RII   NDOW  XQG GXQNHO

6SLULW
:DUP  DQG EULJKW

)RJ KRP H
)LUH KRP H
 1LIOKM HP
0XVSLOKM HP
FROGDQGGDUN
ZDUP DQGEULJKW
LQ W HOOHFW
HP RW LRQV
P DOH
IHP DOH

&ROG DQG GDUN

P DW W HU

7KLV ³ FURVVLQJ´  FDQ EH HYDOXDW HG LQ GLIIHUHQW  Z D\V DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH OHYHO RI
REVHUYDW LRQ RI W KH SHUVRQ ZKR H[DP LQHV

7RH[SODLQ, ZDQW HGW RDGGEULHIO\ *ROIKLP VHOIDQLQLW LDW HYLVLW VW KHJRGVW KH
$HVLU7KH\NQRZW KDW DKHDGDQGW KH\VKRZKLP DP LUDJHLHW KH\DQVZHUKLV
TXHVW LRQV ZLW K DQ DUUD\ RI SLFW XUHV  :LW K W KH KDOO ZH FDQ HDVLO\ XQGHUVW DQG
:DOKDOOD P RUH D SODFH LQ W KH LP DJLQDW LRQ W KDQ D UHDO RQH D VW DW H RI EOLVV DIW HU
D KHURLF OLIH  7KH W ULQLW \ RI W KH +LJK RQH W KH HTXDO KLJK RQH DQG W KH W KLUG RQH
LV DQ DQFLHQW  $U\DQ FRQFHSW  W KDW  ZDV W DNHQ RYHU LQW R W KH &KULVW LDQ GRFW ULQH E\
W KH FKXUFK DW  D ODW HU W LP H  :H ILQG W KH VDP H FRQFHSW  LQ :RGDQ :LOL DQG :HK
LQW R ZKLFK W KH 8U VSLULW  VSOLW V  :RGDQ LV EUHDW K W KH , QGLDQ $W P DQ :LOL LV ZLOO
LQ W KH ZRUOG YLHZ W KDW  6FKRSHQKDXHU JDYH LW  DV EHLQJ ZLOO DQG FRQFHSW   :HK LV
 

W KHFRQVHFUDW HGRQH:HRU'RQDUDVW KHRQHZKRFRQVHFUDW HVEXW DOVRW KHSDW K

RIVXIIHULQJZKLFKOHDGVXVIURP RULJLQRYHUH[LVW HQFHW RZDQLQJ 8UGD9HUGDQGL
DQG 6NXOG W KH W KUHH 1RUQV ZKLFK UHSUHVHQW  DQRW KHU W ULQLW \ RI W KH KLJKHVW  ODZ
RIW KHGLYLQHSHUVH8UGD W KHDOZD\VW KHUH9HUGDQGL W KHRQHZKREHFRP HV
FRUUHODW LQJ ZLW K :LOL W KH VRQ W KH SUHVHQW  W KH H[LVW HQW  W KDW  UHP DLQV  6NXOG 
GHEW  W KDW  ZKLFK ZDV GRQH W KDW  ZKLFK JRHV W R DQ HQG W R QHZ H[LVW HQFH  6KH
FXW VW KHW UHDGW KHGHVW LQ\DQGKHUIDFHLVW KRXJKW W REHEODFNW KDW ZKLFKOHDGV
LQW R GDUNQHVV  7KHUH DUH D IHZ KXQGUHG RI VXFK W ULQLW LHV ZKLFK JR W KURXJK W KH
P \W KV RI W KH (GGD DQG RXU ROG OHJHQGV

7KH VHYHQ ³ KDQG NQLYHV´  W KDW  VLP XOW DQHRXVO\ IORDW HG LQ W KH DLU DUH OLNHO\ W KH
VHYHQVKDUSFXW W LQJDQGGLVFHUQLQJOHYHOVRILQVLJKW DQGZLVGRP RIW KHSODQHW DU\
OHYHOV DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH DQFLHQW  W HDFKLQJV

:DQGHUP XW FRQW LQXHVW RDVN ³ :KDW GLG$OO IDW KHUEHIRUHKHDYHQDQGHDUW KZHUH

P DGH"´

7KH +LJK RQH DQVZHUHG   ³ +H ZDV W KHQ ZLW K W KH , FH *LDQW V´

:KDW  DUH W KH LFH JLDQW V"

, W LVLQDQLP DW HP DW W HULQFRQW UDVW W RDQLP DW HVSLULW 7KH(GGDZDQW VW RVD\KHUH

W KDW  *RG ZDV W KDW  VSLULW  LV EHIRUH W KH ZRUOG ZDV  *RW  KDV QRW  \HW  P DQLIHVW HG
QRW EHFRP HP DW W HUVRP HZD\LQW KHZRUOG1LIHOKHLP DQGIODP H KRP HFROGDQG
ZDUP  DUH DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH (GGD W KH RULJLQV RI DOO OLIH ³ W KURXJKRXW  VHYHUDO HUDV
EHIRUH W KH ZRUOG ZDV FUHDW HG´  2EYLRXVO\ W KH\ W KRXJKW  KHUH RI D SRODULW \ DQ
LQW HUDFW LRQ  $Q HQHUJ\ LV FUHDW HG W KDW  ZDV DW  W KH EHJLQQLQJ RI DOO EHFRP LQJ

2XW  RI ZDUP W K DQG FROGQHVV P RLVW XUH GHYHORSV  7KLV P RLVW XUH KDUGHQV W R LFH
DQG LW  ILOOV W KH \DZQLQJ QRW KLQJ JLQQXJD JDS W KH \DZQLQJ JDS W KH ³ W \SH´  2Q
W KH EHJLQQLQJ W KLV ILUVW  GD\ RI FUHDW LRQ LV W KH JLDQW  <P LU   ZKRVH G\QDVW \ FDOOV
KLP 8U SRZHU, QW KLVJLDQW , P P HUZHKDYHW RVHHW KDW ZKLFKLVW DQJLEOHP DW W HU
)URP LW W KH³ JRRGJRGV´ EXLOGW KHZRUOG7KLVP HDQVW KH\NLOOW KHJLDQW <P LU W KH
VSLULW  FRQW UROV P DW W HU DV LV QDUUDW HG IXUW KHU LQ W KH ³ LOOXVLRQ´


*RUVOHEHQXVHVW KHP RGHUQ*HUP DQZRUG³ , P P HU ´  DOZD\V IRU<P LU
 

:DQGHUP XW  DVNHG   ³ DQG ZKDW  W KHQ GLG W KH VRQV RI W KH UH ERUQ DV \RX EHOLHYH
W KH\ DUH *RG"´

7KH +LJK RQH DQVZHUV   7KHUH LV OLW W OH W R VD\ DERXW  W KLV  7KH\ W RRN KLP  DQG
FDUULHGKLP LQW KHP LGGOHRIW KH1RW KLQJW KH\DZQLQJXQLYHUVH DQGW KH\IRUP HG
IURP  KLP  W KH ZRUOG   IURP  KLV EORRG W KH VHD DQG W KH ZDW HUV W KH HDUW K IURP  KLV
IOHVK W KH P RXQW DLQV IURP  KLV ERQHV URFNV DQG ERXOGHUV IURP  W KH W HHW K M DZ
ERQHV DQG EURNHQ ERQHV

(TXDO +LJK DGGHG  IURP  W KH EORRG W KDW  UDQ IURP  KLV ZRXQGV DQG VHHSHG DZD\
W KH\JLUGOHGDQGIDVW HQHGW KH(DUW KDQGSXW W KH6HDLQDFLUFOHDURXQGLW VRW KDW
LW  VHHP V LP SRVVLEOH W R KXP DQV W R FRP H RYHU

7KH 7KLUG RQH FRQFOXGHG   /DVW  W KH\ W RRN KLV VNXOO URXQGHG IURP  LW  W KH VN\ DQG
SXW LW ZLW KLW VIRXUFRUQHUVRQW RW KHHDUW KXQGHUHDFKKRUQ SURFHVV W KH\VDW D
GZDUIZKLFKDUHFDOOHG 2VW HU:HVW HU1RUGHUDQG6GHU7KHQW KH\FDXJKW W KH
VSDUNVDQGHP EHUVW KDW IOHZRYHUIURP 0XVSHOKHLP DQGW KH\W KUHZ W KHP LQW RW KH
RSHQ\DZQLQJW ROLJKW XSW KHKHDYHQDVZHOODVW KHHDUW K7KH\JDYHSODFHVW R
W KH VW DUV  VRP H VROLG RQ W KH VN\ RW KHUV ORRVH RQ W KH VN\ DV DQFLHQW  ZLVGRP
W HDFKHVW KDW DFFRUGLQJW RW KRVHW KHGD\VDUHP HDVXUHGDQGW KH\HDULVFRXQW HG
2I W KLV W KH VRQJ RI W KH VHHUHVV¶V YLVLRQ W HOOV

7KH 6XQ GLG QRW  NQRZ ZKHUH LW  GZHOOHG

7KH 0RRQ GLG QRW  NQRZ RI W KH SRZHU KH KDG
7KH VW DUV GLG QRW  NQRZ ZKLFK SODFH W KH\ KDG
7KLV ZD\ LW  ZDV EHIRUH W KH JRGV ZHUH

7KHQ :DQGHUP XW  VSRNH   7KHVH DUH JUHDW  W KLQJV IURP  ZKLFK ,  DP  KHDULQJ D
P LJKW \ ZRUN VR ZRQGHUIXOO\ FRQVW UXFW HG   +RZ W KHQ LV W KH VKDSH RI W KH (DUW K"

7KH +LJK RQH DQVZHUHG   , W  LV URXQG DQG DURXQG LW  LV W KH GHHS VHD  7KH ODQG
DORQJW KHFRDVW VW KHJRGVJDYHW RW KHJLDQW VRU-RW HVZKLFKP HDQVW RW KHHDW HUV
IRU FXOW LYDW LRQ EXW  DURXQG W KH ODQG LQ W KH P LGGOH RI W KH HDUW K W KH\ EXLOG D ULQJ
VKDSHG UDP SDUW  DV D SURW HFW LRQ DJDLQVW  W KH JLDQW V DQG W R EXLOG W KLV FDVW OH W KH\
XVHGW KHH\HEURZVRI<P LUDQGW KH\FDOOHGLW )RUW 0LGJDUG+LVEUDLQW KH\W KUHZ
LQW R W KH DLU DQG P DGH FORXGV RI LW  DV LV VDLG LQ W KH VRQJ

)URP  8U SRZHU ¶V IOHVK W KH (DUW K ZDV FUHDW HG
)URP  KLV EORRG W KH ELOORZLQJ VHD
)URP  W KH ERQHV W KH P RXQW DLQV W KH W UHHV IURP  KLV KDLU
)URP  KLV VNXOO W KH FOHDU VN\
)URP  W KH H\HEURZV W KH JRRG JRGV EXLOW
0LGJDUG W R W KH UDFH RI KXP DQV
7KH FORXGV EHFDP H W KH VW RUP  ULGGHQ RQHV
)URP  W KH FRQYROXW HG EUDLQ RI W KH JLDQW ¶V KHDG
 

:DQGHUP XW  VDLG   *UHDW  W KLQJV ,  W KLQN W KH JRGV KDYH EURXJKW  W R FRP SOHW LRQ
ZKHQ W KH\ FUHDW HG KHDYHQ DQG W KH (DUW K VHW  6XQ DQG VW DUV DQG VHSDUDW HG W KH
GD\ IURP  W KH QLJKW   %XW  IURP  ZKHUH FDP H KXP DQV W KDW  LQKDELW  W KLV HDUW K"

7KHUH LV QR GRXEW  W KDW  IODVKHV RI W KRXJKW V IURP  W KH 8U W LP HV ILUHG W R +|UELJHU
EHFDXVH LQ W KH ZRUOG W KHUH LV RQO\ RQH W UXW K , W  FRXOG EH DIW HU W KRXVDQGV RI
\HDUV W KDW  LI W KURXJK QHZ GHJHQHUDW LRQ RI W KH LQW HOOHFW  RI KXP DQNLQG KLV ZRUN
ZRXOGEHIRUJRW W HQDJDLQ  DQHZP \W KZRXOGW DNHSRVVHVVLRQRIKLVW KHRU\W KDW
SDVVHG RQ W KH FRUH RI KLV LQVLJKW V W R IDU DZD\ RIIVSULQJ W R ZKRP  W KHLU FDUHIXOO\
SUHVHUYHG EORRG ZRXOG JLYH DJDLQ W KH DQFLHQW  LOOXP LQDW LRQ  +|U ELJHU ¶V W KHRU\ RI
W KH ZRUOG LFH KDV VXFK DQ XQVKDNDEOH VXSSRUW  DP RQJ W KH EHVW  RI RXU SUHVHQW 
EHFDXVH KLV W KLQNLQJ GRHV QRW  HP HUJH IURP  VW HULOH EURRGLQJV EXW  LV OLYLQJ ZLW K
LW V URRW V LQ W KH EHJLQQLQJ RI DOO H[LVW HQFH  

:H VKRXOG QRW  EH VXUSULVHG DW  DOO ZKHQ ZH GLVFRYHU LQ W KH (GGD SXUH QDW XUDO
VFLHQW LILFGLVFRYHULHVRIRXUGD\VDQGZKHQZHIROORZW KHVHZLW KDP D]HP HQW , Q
W KH 'LYLQH KXP DQ VSLULW  DOO SRW HQW LDOV RI HYROXW LRQ DUH SUHVHQW  ULJKW  IURP  W KH
EHJLQQLQJ  +H GRHV QRW  VW ULGH KLJKHU DQG RQ EHFDXVH KH SHUIRU P V W HFKQLFDO
P LUDFOHV QRZDGD\V EXW  KH GRHV W KDW  RXW  RI D QHHG EHFDXVH KH KDV W R OHDUQ W R
FRQW URO W KH ZRUOG RI KLV W HFKQRORJ\ ZKLFK RW KHUZLVH ZRXOG GHYRXU KLP   +H LV
LQJHQLRXVRXW RIDQHHGEXW QRW P RUHLQJHQLRXVW KDQDQ\RIRXU IRUHIDW KHUVZKR
QHHGHG W R P DNH D VW RQH KDP P HU W R VXUYLYH DIW HU KH OHIW  RU KDG W R OHDYH  W KH
SDW K RI QDW XUDO QRXULVKP HQW 

:HKDYHW RJHW ULGRQFHDQGIRUDOORIRXUDUURJDQW RSLQLRQW KDW RXUSUHVHQW LVVR

P XFK IXUW KHU W KDQ IRUP HU W LP HV  :H VKRXOG P XFK P RUH DVVXP H W KDW  KXP DQ
LQVLJKW V DQG KXP DQ GULYH IRU UHVHDUFK ZDV QRW  OHVV W KDQ RXU HIIRUW V DOUHDG\ IRU
P LOOHQQLD , Q IDFW  W KH\ P D\ HYHQ KDYH EHHQ VXSHULRU LQ P DQ\ UHVSHFW V  , I ZH
FDQQRW  U HFRJQL]H W KDW  DW  D ILU VW  JOLP SVH W KHQ Z H VKRXOG QRW  IRU JHW  W KDW  DOO
QDW XU DO VFLHQW LILF DV Z HOO DV SKLORVRSKLFDO DFKLHY HP HQW V DU H W LHG W R VSHFLILF
H[SUHVVLRQV  $W  GLIIHUHQW  W LP HV W KHUH ZHUH GLIIHUHQW  ZRUGV V\P EROV FRQFHSW V
YDOLGIRUW KHVDP HW KLQJVW KHUHIRUHLW LVQHFHVVDU\W REHVXUHRIW KHODQJXDJHRI
DUW  W KDW  EHORQJV W R D VSHFLILF W LP H RU P DW HULDO  , Q P RVW  FDVHV W KLV ZDV D VHFUHW
ODQJXDJH VLP LODU  DV HDFK VFLHQFH W U DGH RU  W HFKQRORJ\ KDV VXFK D ODQJXDJH
Z KLFK LV LW V RZ Q  7KH (GGD EHLQJ D Z RU OG Z RU N  RI P RU H W KDQ M XVW  OLW HU DU \


 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

LP SRUW DQFHHQFRP SDVVHVDNQRZOHGJHRIW KHZRUOGRIYHU\XQXVXDOGLP HQVLRQV

DQG LW  ZLOO EH W KH ORQJLQJ RI W KH QH[W  JHQHUDW LRQV W R OLIW  W KHVH W UHDVXUHV

, Q  7UDXW ZHW W HU KDV DOUHDG\ P DGH W KH DW W HP SW  LQ D ZRUN ³ W KH NH\ W R W KH
(GGD´  W R H[SODLQ W KH 1RUGLF P \W KRORJ\ RI W KH (GGD DV ³ D FKHP LVW U\ W KDW  ZDV
SUHVHQW HGLQSDUDEOHV´*ROW KHULQKLV³ +DQGERRNRI*HUP DQLFP \W KRORJ\´UHIHUV
W R W KHVH ZULW LQJV RI 7UDXW ZHW W HU DQG W KH RSLQLRQV KH XW W HUV DV W KH ³ KHLJKW  RI
QRQVHQVH´  7R XV 7UDXW ZHW W HUV DVVXP SW LRQ VHHP V ZHOO IRXQGHG XSRQ D GHHSHU
LQVLJKW  LQW R W KH HVVHQFH RI W KH (GGD  , W  JLYHV W KH LQW XLW LRQ RI 7UDXW ZHW W HU W KH
KRQRU LW  GHVHUYHV  1R GRXEW  GLG KH DSSURDFK KLV W DVN ZLW K FRQVLGHUDEO\ P RUH
LQQHULQW HUHVW W KDQP RVW RIW KHODW HUUHVHDUFKHUVZKRRIW HQRYHUORRNHGW KHP RVW
LP SRUW DQW W KLQJVGXHW RSHHUSUHVVXUHV, W LVOLNHO\W KDW FRQVLGHULQJW KHLQW HUQDO
Z LGHQHVV RI W KH VHW W LQJ RI W KH (GGD  LW V W H[ W  Z LOO VKRZ  GLIIHU HQW  U HVXOW V RQ
GLIIHUHQW  OHYHOV  (YHU\ JUHDW  LQW HOOHFW XDO Z RUN RSHQV XS RQ VHYHUDO OHYHOV RI
LQW HUSUHW DW LRQ8VXDOO\ZHH[SUHVVW KLVH[SHULHQFHLQVLP SOHUZRUGVIRULQVW DQFH
LIZHUHDGW KH)DXVW DQHZIURP W LP HW RW LP HDQG³ HDFKW LP HZHUHDGLW DQHZZH
JHW  P RUH LQVLJKW V IURP  LW ´  :LW K RXU SURJUHVVLQJ DJH ZH QDW XUDOO\ DUH JLYHQ
HYHU QHZOHYHOVRILQVLJKW VEXW ³ W KHVHYHQVHDOV´RU³ W KHVHYHQSODQHW DU\OHYHOV´
OLIH GRHV QRW  JLYH XV HDVLO\  7KHVH KDYH W R EH W DXJKW  W UDQVP LW W HG H[SODLQHG
DFKLHYHG DQG DFFHSW HG IURP  SUHYLRXV JHQHUDW LRQV  , W  LV YHU\ LP SRUW DQW  W R VW DW H
W KDW  W KH VR FDOOHG ³ QRQVHQVH´  RI 7UDXW ZHW W HU LV QRW  DV ODUJH DV *ROW HU P HDQV
, QGHHG  W KH Z RU N V RI 'U  , QJ  )U  7HOW VFKHU   JDY H XV LP SRU W DQW  LQIRU P DW LRQ
HVSHFLDOO\DVIDUDVW KDW DVSHFW RIW KH(GGDLVFRQFHUQHG7KHVHZHUHGHVFULEHG
LQ P RUH GHW DLO LQ DQ HVVD\ E\ $ 5GLJHU LQ µ RI W KH ³ 'HXW VFKH )UHLKHLW ´  RI W KH
\HDU  ZKHUH KH ZURW H DERXW  W KH ³ )ORGVW RII ´  +H GHDOW  ZLW K W KH TXHVW LRQ RU
DVVXP SW LRQRIDFRQQHFW LQJ8U P DW W HUZKLFKKDGW KHQDP HRI³ (W KHU ´ LQ(XURSH
VLQFH ROGHVW  W LP HV LQ , QGLD LW  ZDV $SDV 7DW W ZD DQG ZKLFK REYLRXVO\ ZDV DOVR RI
LP SRUW DQFH LQ W KH ZRUOG YLHZ RI W KH LQLW LDW HV RI W KH (GGD

5GLJHU ZULW HV

³ )RU W KLV W KH \RXQJHU (GGD VKRZV DQ LQVW UXFW LYH SDVVDJH ZKLFK UHJDUGOHVV RI
W KH H[W UHP HO\ EULHI VW \OH LQ ZKLFK LW  LV ZULW W HQ W KURZV D GD\ EULJKW  OLJKW  RQ W KH
YHU\ KLJK NQRZOHGJH RI QDW XUH RI W KH ROG 1RUVHP HQ  7KLV SDVVDJH LV ZULW W HQ LQ
W KH6NDOGVNDSDUP DO6HFW LRQYHUVH6HFW LRQGHDOVZLW KW KH6DHYDUV
ZKLFK DUH VSLULW XDO EHLQJV W KDW  UXOH HYHU\W KLQJ W KDW  KDV W R GR ZLW K W KH HOHP HQW
RI ZDW HU  9HUVH  VSHDNV RI D VSHFLDO FKDUDFW HULVW LF RI W KLV HOHP HQW  D ODZ

7KH YHUVH LV LQ 2OG , FHODQGLF

/|JU W KYDHU IODXVW  HQ IDJULU

IORGV YDNDU KULP  VW RGXP
W KDU HV VDHU D KOLG KYDUD
K\OP UYHGUYLW DUJO\P LD


8QLYHUVLW \RI, QQVEUXFNKHGLVFRYHUHGW KH³ LQW HOOHFW XDO´ ELRU K\W KP RIGD\V
 

, Q*HUP DQ
³ , W  LV ODZ W KDW  DFURVV W KH GLUHFW LRQ RI W KH P DLQ YLEUDW LRQ W R ZKLFK DGM XVW P HQW
)ORG QHW V  VXUURXQG W KH W UDFNV LQ ZKLFK W KH SRZHU VW UHDP V DUH VXUJLQJ´
6RP H ZLOO VD\ W KDW  W KLV LV DQ HQW LUHO\ DUELW UDU\ W UDQVODW LRQ  W KH SDVVDJH ZRXOG
UHDGHQW LUHO\GLIIHUHQW DFFRUGLQJW RFRP P RQO\NQRZQP HDQLQJRIW KHZRUGV:KR
W KHQLVULJKW "%RW K(DFKRQHZKRP DNHVDQHIIRUW KDVW RDGP LW W KDW W KHZRUGLQJ
RI W KH OLQH FDQ EH W UDQVODW HG ERW K ZD\V ZLW KRXW  EHLQJ LQFRUUHFW   +HUH ZH KDYH
DQH[DP SOHRIGXDOH[SUHVVLRQLQW KHZRUGLQJRIW KH(GGDZKLFKLQVRP HVW DJHV
FDQDOVREHFRP HDW KUHH DQGP DQ\ IROGH[SUHVVLRQLQVRP HSDVVDJHVGHSHQGLQJ
RQ W KH P HDQLQJ W KDW  Z H DU H FDSDEOH W R DW W U LEXW H W R LQGLY LGXDO Z RU GV DQ 8U 
OLQJXLVW LF ZD\ RU E\ XVLQJ W KH UXQH NH\  , Q IDFW  ZH KDYH W R GR VR LI ZH GR QRW
ZDQW  W R OLP LW  RXUVHOYHV W R W KH ORZHVW  OHYHO RI LQW HUSUHW DW LRQ U HVXOW LQJ IURP  W KH
VHHP LQJO\ VLQJXODU P HDQLQJ

7KH6DHU 6DHYDUDUHW KHEHLQJVW KDW FRQW UROW KH³ IORG´ DQGZKRZHDYHW KHIORG
QHW V DQG W KH\ DUH DOZD\V DFW LYH ZKHUH VW UHDP V RI SRZHU ERXQFH DJDLQVW  HDFK
RW KHU  7KH\ FRXQW HUDFW  DQ\ ZDVW H RI HQHUJ\  7KLV DP D]LQJO\ FOHDU SLFW XUH RI
QDW XUDO SURFHVVHV GHVFULEHV D SURW HFW LYH P DW HULDO DQG LVRODW LQJ P DW HULDO ZKLFK
VXUURXQGVW KHW UDFNVRIHQHUJ\VW UHDP VDQGZKLFKUHJXODW HVW KHVHVW UHDP VZLW K
LW  DV ³ IORG´  )URP  W KH YRFDEXODU\ RI P RGHUQ ODQJXDJH ZH ZRXOG XVH W KH ZRUG
³ IOXLGXP ´ IRUW KLV)ORGW KDW OLHVDFURVVW KHW UDFNVRIW KHHQHUJ\VW UHDP ³ YDNDU ´
LHZDW FKLQJRYHUW KHVHVW UHDP VLVW KHLP DJHRILVRODW LQJDQHOHFW ULFFRQGXFW RU
ZLW KDVLONHQW KUHDG QHW  , QDQRW KHU(GGDP DQXVFULSW ZHILQGFOHDUO\³ YDVNDU´
LQVW HDGRI³ YDNDU ´ZKLFKP HDQVW RZDVKW RULQVHDURXQGVRP HW KLQJ7KLVZRUG
W RR JLYHV W KH VDP H LP DJH   )ORG IORRG IOXLG ULQVHV DURXQG W KH W UDFNV W KH VXUIV
%\  P DN LQJ D KXOO DU RXQG W KH HW KHU LF W XU EXOHQFHV W KH SRZ HU  VXU JHV LW  DOVR
VKDSHV W KH SRZ HU  W XU EXOHQFHV W R SRZ HU  VW U HDP V RI SRZ HU  VW RU DJHV     7KH
P XOW LW XGH RI VXFK IORG W KUHDGV LV D SURW HFW LYH RU LVRODW LQJ QHW  DV LQ W KH FDVH
ZKHUHLW LVLP SRUW DQW W RJXDUDQW HHW KHFKHP LFDOVW DELOLW \RIDQHOHP HQW DU\DW RP  

:H DUH QRW  VXUSULVHG DW  DOO W KDW  W KH DQFLHQW  1RUVHP HQ OLNH DOO DQFLHQW  $U\DQV
VDZHYHU\P DW W HUFRQW UROOHGE\VSLULW XDOEHLQJV , QW KHVDP HZD\LW DSSHDUVW R
XV DV TXLW H QDW XUDO W KDW  W KHVH VSLULW XDO EHLQJV XVH W KHLU IORRG SURW HFW LRQ QHW  W R
³ Y HGU Y LW DU  JOM P M D´  W R FRXQW HUDFW  DOO VXU JHV  DOO ZDVW H RI HQHU J\  Z KHU H RQH
HQHU J\  VW U HDP  FROOLGHV Z LW K DQRW KHU 7KH\  FDW FK W KH HIIHFW V RI W Z R FROOLGLQJ


2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

SRZHUVW UHDP VLP P HGLDW HO\ZLW KW KHLUIORG QHW , QGHHGDQLP DJHW KDW LVHTXDOO\
SHU IHFW HG SRHW LFDOO\  DV Z HOO DV VFLHQW LILFDOO\  FRU U HFW  DQG SRZ HU IXO LP DJH  IRU
LQVW DQFH W KH FRP ELQDW LRQ RI W ZR HOHP HQW DU\ DW RP V W R D P ROHFXOH  

:K\GLGW KHVNDOGVW KHSRHW VDQGSULHVW VRIW KH1RUGLF(GGDDQG6DJDOLW HUDW XUH

XVHVRIUHTXHQW O\W KHGHVFULSW LRQP HW KRGRIW KH³ .HQQLJDU ´ "7KHP HDQLQJRIW KH
ZRUG.HQQLJDUVUHIHUVW RKLGGHQGHVFULSW LRQVW KDW RQO\W KHSHUVRQFDQXQGHUVW DQG
Z KR KDV W KH N QRZ OHGJH    $W  DOO W LP HV SKLORORJHU V ORRNDG DW  NHQQLJDU V Z LW K
GLVGDLQ  &RQVHTXHQW O\ W KH\ UHOHJDUH W KHVH NHQQLJDUV LH W KHVH JURW HVTXH DQG
RIW HQ FOXP V\ GHVFULSW LRQV W R W KH GHFOLQH RI W KH HUD RI W KH VNDOGV DW  W KH HQG RI
W KH VR FDOOHG ³ KHU RLF HUD´  7KLV RI FRXU VH Z RXOG EH DQ DFFXVDW LRQ DJDLQVW
&KULVW LDQLW \RIZKLFKSHRSOHRIW HQFODLP W KDW RQO\ZLW KLW V³ LQW URGXFW LRQ´ LQW RRXU
KRP HODQG W KLQJV OLNH W KH DUW V P RUDOV DQG VFLHQFHV ZHUH SURP RW HG  

7KH .HQQLQJH W KHQ IXOILOO D XQLTXH VHUYLFH LQ W KH OLQJXLVW LF DQG SLFW RUDO P DW HULDO
RI W KH (GGD DQG W KH 6DJDV  &HUW DLQO\ W KHUH DUH DOVR H[DJJHUDW LRQV DQG VRP H
FRQIXVLRQ RI D G\QDVW \ RI 6NDOGV ZKLFK GLG QRW  KDYH HQW LUH P DVW HU\ RI W KHVH
.HQQLQJH DQ\ P RUH  2Q W KH RW KHU KDQG D JUHDW  QXP EHU RI VXFK SDUDSKUDVLQJ
DSSHDUV W R XV DV EHLQJ ULGLFXORXV FOXP V\ RU RXW ULJKW  ZURQJ DUH SXUSRVHIXOO\
KLGGHQODQJXDJHRIW KHSRHW VDQGVLQJHUVW RJLYHXVKLGGHQNQRZ OHGJHXQGHUW KH
JXLVH RI .HQQLQJV  7KLV ZDV LP SRUW DQW  LQ D W LP H ZKHQ FKXUFK DQG VW DW H KDYH
EDQQHG VXFK NQRZOHGJH IRU D ORQJ W LP H  6XFK LQW HOOHFW XDO SUHVVXUH LV VW LOO XSRQ
XVUHJDUGOHVVRIDOOSXEOLFO\SURIHVVHGIUHHGRP RIRSLQLRQ)HZKXP DQVRQO\DUH
IUHH IURP  W KLV FRHUFLRQ W KDW  LV GRP LQDW LQJ W KH LQW HOOHFW XDO VRFLDO HFRQRP LF DQG
SU RI HVVLRQ DO OLI H      )RU  P RU H W K DQ  D W K RX VDQ G \ HDU V FRP P DQ GP HQ W V DQ G
SURKLELW LRQV W KDW  RULJLQDW HG LQ IRUHLJQ VW XSLGLW \ NHHS XV P RUH RU OHVV DW  ED\
7KH\ GR QRW  DOORZ IRU DQ\W KLQJ W R FRP H W R EORRP  OHW  DORQH W R IUXLW LRQ W KDW  KDV
W R GR ZLW K W KH FUHDW LYH SRW HQW LDO RI RXU LQGHSHQGHQFH

4XLW H D IHZ VHFUHW V RI W KH (GGD FDQ VW LOO EH VROYHG  /LYLQJ DQG
\HW  LP SHQHW UDEOH LP DJHV DUH VKLQLQJ W R W KH 6HHNHU IURP  W KLV ROG
DQGP DJQLILFHQW GRFXP HQW $W W LP HVW KHERRNLVSXW DVLGHZKHQ
W KH VROXW LRQ RI DQ HQLJP D P RYHV IDUW KHU DZD\ W KH P RUH HIIRUW  LV
SXW  LQW R UHVHDUFK

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 

6\P ERO DQG QXP EHU SURYLGH XV ZLW K D EULGJH W R W KH ROGHVW  ZLVGRP  DQG W KH\
FRQFHDO VHFU HW V W KDW  DU H EDU HO\  LP DJLQDEOH W R XV EHFDXVH Z H KDY H ORVW  W KH
NQRZOHGJH RI W KH 8U RULJLQDO IURP  ZKLFK HYHQW XDOO\ DOO VHFUHW  W HDFKLQJV KDYH
VSUXQJ

, I ZH ORRN DW  W KH SHQW DJUDP  LQ LW V JHRP HW ULF FRP SRVLW LRQ W KH P DJLFDO V\P ERO
Z LW K P DQ\ LQW HU SU HW DW LRQV W KDW  LV XVHG W R HYRNH DQG EDQLVK VSLU LW V W KHQ Z H
GLVFRYHU W KDW  LW V ILYH OLQHV FURVV HDFK RW KHU P XW XDOO\ ILYH W LP HV LQ W KH JROGHQ
UDW LR ZKLFK LV D P LUDFOH RI UHODW LRQV LQ W KH ILYH IROG SDUW LW LRQHG FLUFOH  :KR LV
DZDUH RI W KH YDOXH W KDW  ZDV DW W ULEXW HG W R W KH JROGHQ UDW LRQ W LOO ODW H LQW R W KH
P LGGOH DJHV ZLOO EH DEOH W R M XGJH W KH LP SRUW DQFH RI VXFK D FOHDU DQG VLP SOH
ILJXUH ZKLFK FRQW DLQV W KLV JROGHQ UDW LRQ ILYH W LP HV

7KH DQFLHQW  $U\DQ ILYH VW DU W KDW  KDV ZLW KLQ LW VHOI W KH JROGHQ U DW LRQ ILYH W LP HV
DQG Z KLFK Z H Z LOO H[ DP LQH VHY HU DO W LP HV LQ RXU  U HVHDU FK  LV W KH V\ P ERO RI
:DOKDOOD  , I ZH FDOFXODW H W KH DQJOHV RI W KH SHQW DJUDP  ZH KDYH ILYH DQJOHV RI
 GHJUHHV HDFK

(DFK H[W HUQDO DQJOH RI W KH SHQW DJUDP  KDV  GHJUHHV  )LYH W LP HV  LV 
DQG  [  LV    7KH (GGD VD\V QRZ    LQKDELW DQW V ULGH GDLO\
W KURXJK W KHVH  JDW HV  7KH ³  +HULHUV´    7KLV ZH KDYH W R U HDG LW  DQG W R
ZULW H LW    LV W KH LQYHUVLRQ RI  D KLGGHQ P HDQLQJ W KDW  U HIHUV W R W KH 
GHJUHHV RI W KH ³ JDW HV´  W KDW  P DNH XS W KH FLUFOH DURXQG W KH SHQW DJRQ  :DOJULQG
LV W KH W U HOOLV JDW H RI W KH :DOKDOOD W KDW  VXU U RXQGV W KH LQQHU P RVW  ³ EXLOGLQJ´  RI
:DOKDOODW KHVHDUHW KHGHJUHH JDW HV(LQKHULHUVDUHW KHKLGGHQUHYHUVDO
RI W KH  DQG ZKDW  GRHV W KH VRQJ RI *ULP P LU VD\"

 JDW HV DQG  ZLW K LW

DUH LQ :DOKDOOD¶V ODUJH EXLOGLQJ
 (LQKHULHUV OHDYH RQH JDW H
ZKHQ W KH\ OHDYH W R GHIHQG DJDLQVW  W KH ZROI

[ 

 LV W KH P RVW  ZRQGHUIXO FRVP LF QXP EHU W KDW  ZH NQRZ  $FFRUGLQJ W R 26
5HXW HU ¶V³ (QLJP DRIW KH(GGD´ LW LVW KHHQGQXP EHURIW KH\HDUVRIW KHZRUOG
DQGLVEDVHGRQW KHVDQFW LW \RIW KHW KHEDVLFQXP EHURIW KHVW DUP RQW KZKLFK
W KH 7HXW RQV W KH , QGLDQV DQG W KH 3HUVLDQV DOZD\V ZRUVKLSSHG

[DUH7KLVLVW KHQXP EHURI\HDUVW KDW W KHHTXLQRFW LDOSRLQW QHHGV

W R ZDQGHU W KURXJK W KH ]RGLDF  \HDUV DFFRUGLQJ W R *XLGR Y RQ /LVW 

%XW  ZH GR QRW  HYHQ QHHG W R VHDUFK IRU P LOOHQQLD DQG W KH W LP H FDOFXODW LRQ RI W KH
8U $U\DQV  'DLO\ ZH KDYH W ZR W LP HV  VHFRQGV LQ W KH  KRXUV RI W KH GD\
DQG QLJKW 
 

, QW KHLVFRQW DLQHGW KHRUELW RIW KHFRVP RVW KHUHIRUHW KHLVW KHQXP EHU
RI W KH XQLYHUVH   :DOKDOOD   DQG LW  LV P HQW LRQHG LQ W KH *ULP P VP DO RI W KH (GGD

 (LQKHULHU P RYH RXW  RI :DOKDOO W R ILJKW  W KH )HQULU ZROI W KH GHVW UR\HU RI W KH
OLJK W 

&UHVW  EXP S RI LURQ ZLW K EURQ]H

2EYLRXVKHUHLVW KH:DOKDOODQXP HULFV\P EROZLW KW KHLQW KHJDUQHW EDOOVW KHQW KHFURVVW KH
IRXU V\P ERO RI W KH OHDGHU GRXEOHG W R W KH VDFUHG   7KURXJK W KH EODQN KDOI FLUFOHV DQG LQ W KH
P LGGOHW KHW ULQLW \GRXEOHGW RW KHVL[Z LW KDVHYHQLQW KHFHQW HU7KHVHDUHQRW M XVW FRLQFLGHQW DO
UHVXOW VRIJHRP HW ULFGUDZLQJEXW P DGHZLW KIXOOSXUSRVHW KDW QRERG\ZLOOGHQ\ZKRFDQVHHLQW KH
ZRUOGW KHHW HUQDOSDUDEOHVRIQXP EHUVRIOLIH

, I ZH SXW  W KH OHW W HUV RI W KH (GGLF ZRUG ³ :DOKROO´  LQ W KH QXP HULF YDOXHV RI W KH
UXQHV FRUUHVSRQGLQJ W R W KH VHTXHQFH RI W KH )XW KRUN ZH JHW 
: RU 8 ZKLFK FDQ EH LQW HUFKDQJHG  
$  2  
/  / 
+  / 
7KH VXP  RI W KLV LV 
   W LP HV 

 LV W KH V\P ERO RI :DOKDOOD  W KH QXP EHU RI W KH ZROI )HQULU RU RI GDUNQHVV RU
RI GHDW K LQ (J\SW  DV ZHOO


:RUG JDP H +HZ ULW HV³ :HOW DOO´Z KLFKLVXQLYHUVHLQ0RGHUQ*HUP DQDQGFRQQHFW VW KDW Z LW K
:DOKDOO D 
 

7KH QXP HULF V\P EROLVP  LV QRW  XQLTXH IRU W KH &DEEDOD RU RI W KH DQFLHQW  RULHQW DO
ODQJXDJHV  , Q W KH $U\DQ DQW LTXLW \ LW  LV FRP P RQ NQRZOHGJH

, Q *\OIL¶V LP DJHU\ ZH ILQG VW LOO DQRW KHU LP SRUW DQW  V\P ERO RI W KH (GGD HP EHGGHG
LQ XQH[SODLQDEOH QDUUDW LRQ   ³ 7KH W UDYHOLQJ ZRP DQ *HIM RQ W RRN IRXU R[HQ KHU
RZQ VRQV W R ZKRP  VKH JDYH ELUW K IDU DZD\ LQ W KH QRUW K DQG KDUQHVVHG W KHP  LQ
IURQW RIW KHSORXJK7KHSORXJKKRZHYHUZDVVRVKDUSDQGGHHSW KDW LW W RUHRXW
W KH ODQG´

7KH P DLQ LGHD FRQVLVW HG RI W KH IRXU IXUURZV RI W KH
W HDULQJR[HQ$FFRUGLQJW RW KHZRUGLQJW KHVHIRXU
IXUURZV SRLQW  W RZDUGV W KH 6RXW K 7KHUHIRUH ZH SXW
IRXU YHUW LFDO OLQHV RQW R W KH SDSHU  7KH R[HQ P RYH
W KHSORXJKDOVRIURP (DVW W R:HVW 7KHUHIRUHW UDFH
IRXUKRUL]RQW DOOLQHV7KHVHOLQHVJLYHQLQHVTXDUHV
IRXU W LP HV W ZR LQW HUVHFW LRQV DQG IRXU FRUQHUV IRU
ZKLFK UHDVRQ W KH SRHW U\ VD\V
³ , Q W KH IRUHKHDG W KH VW HHUV KDG HLJKW  VW DUV DQG IRXU KHDGV´

+HUH ZH KDYH W KH P DJLFDO VTXDUH RI W KH QLQH W KH  [  W KH VTXDUH RI 6DW XUQ
IURP  ZKLFK HP HUJHV W KH FURVV DV ZHOO

7KH SDVVDJH LQ W KH *\OIDJLQQLQJ FRQW LQXHV   ³ W KHUH DUH W KH ED\V LQ W KH ORJ OLNH
W KH IRRW KLOOV LQ 6HHOXQG´  7KLV P HDQV OLNH LQ D FKHFNHUERDUG ZKLFK UHSUHVHQW V
W KH DOW DU ERDUG RI W KH DQFLHQW  *HUP DQV

1RW  HQRXJK \HW   /HW  W KH QXP EHU VSHDN

*HIM RQ KDV W KH YDOXHV  * RU .  
( 
) 
,  
2  
1 
7KH VXP  LV 
  

$FFRUGLQJW R*ROW HU +DQGEXFKGHU*HUP DQLVFKHQ0\W KRORJLHSDJH 

)UH\DLVKLGGHQ)UH\DOLYHVLQW KHW KKRXVHRI2GLQLQW KH)RONZDQJ)RONZDQJ
LVFRP ELQHGDFFRUGLQJW RW KHQXP HULFYDOXHRILW V5XQHVDQGOHW W HUVW R  
                   7KLV     DJDLQ LV 

1LQH QLJKW V 2GLQ KDQJHG RQ W KH ZRUOG W UHH XQW LO KH DFKLHYHG W KH FRQVFLRXVQHVV
RI FUHDW LRQ DQG FRXOG EHJLQ W KH FUHDW LRQ RI W KH ZRUOG  , Q W KH P \VW LFLVP  W KH
 

QXP EHU   FRQW DLQV W KH  LQYLVLEOH FRVP LF HQHU JLHV W KDW  DU H W KH EDVLV RI W KH
SULQFLSOHV RI W KH VW UXFW XUH RI W KH YLVLEOH ZRUOG   IDW KHU DQG P RW KHU VSLULW  DQG
P DW W HU RI W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ  7KH V\P EROLF QXP EHU LV  DOSKD   DQG 2P HJD
   ³ 1LQH LV RQH´  7KH VSLULW  LV HYHU\W KLQJ   DQG ³  LV QRW KLQJ´    P DW W HU LV
QRW KLQJ  

, Q W KH ZLVGRP  RI W KH $U\DQV RI DOO ODQGV W KH QXP EHU  SOD\V DQ RXW VW DQGLQJ
UROH)RUW KH, QGLDQVLW LVW KHQXP EHURIW KHJUHDW ZRUOGF\FOHRI\HDUV
W KH&KDOGHDQV &DOHGRQLDQV W RRFDOFXODW HGZLW KD³ ZRUOG\HDU´ RI\HDUV
7KH(GGDDVZHILQGRXW E\5HXW HU (QLJP DRIW KH(GGD DVZHOODV.HSOHULQKLV
ZRUN³ &RQVRQDQFHVRIW KHZRUOGV´FRP HW RW KHVDP HP \VW HULRXVQXP EHU, Q
W KH&DEEDODLW LVW KHQXP HULFYDOXHRI7HEHOZKLFKP HDQVXQLYHUVH7KHGLDP HW HU
RI W KH RUELW  RI W KH (DUW K LV  UDGLXVHV RI W KH 6XQ    W KH GLDP HW HU RI W KH OXQDU
RUELW  LV  UDGLXVHV RI W KH (DUW K 

  [    LV D QXP EHU W KDW  FRUUHODW HV ZLW K W KH 3ODW RQLF \HDU ZKLFK
P HDQVW KHW LP HRIDQRUELW RIW KHHTXLQRFW LDOSRLQW DURXQGW KH]RGLDF$FFRUGLQJ
W RDQFLHQW W HDFKLQJVDKXP DQUDFHHYROYHVEORRP VDQGGHFOLQHV 7KLVDVVXP SW LRQ
LV QRW  DUELW UDU\ LI ZH NQRZ W KDW  W KH ]RGLDF UHSUHVHQW V W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ ZLW K LW V
OLP EVDQGW KDW W KH]RGLDFDOVLJQVUHSUHVHQW W KH³ W ULEHV´RUW \SHVRI
KXP DQV

$KHDOW K\KXP DQEHLQJP DNHVDSSUR[LP DW HO\EUHDW KVSHUP LQXW HDUHW KH

 [  RU  [  8U 5XQHV RU 8U IRUP V  'XULQJ W KH GD\ ZH KDYH W KHQ 
EUHDW KV7KHKXP DQEHLQJLVOLYLQJ7KH³ ELEOLFDODJH´ RI\HDUVDSSUR[LP DW HO\
GD\V)URP W KHVHP DW KHP DW LFDOIDFW VZHFDQVHHDFRQQHFW LRQRIFRVP RV
DQG KXP DQ EHLQJ DQG LW  LV D M XVW LILFDW LRQ RI W KH DVVXP SW LRQ W KDW  DFFRUGLQJ W R
DVW URORJ\ HDFK GD\ DIW HU ELUW K FRUUHVSRQGV W R RQH \HDU RI OLIH LH W KH  GD\V
DIW HU ELUW K DUH D P LUURU RI W KH ZKROH KXP DQ OLIH LQ LW V VP DOOHU  IRUP   7KLV LV DOVR
M XVW LILFDW LRQIRUW KHIDFW W KDW W KHOLIHRIDUDFHODVW VXQLW VRIW LP H:KRHYHU
KDV U HFRJQL]HG W KH P HDQLQJ RI VXFK FRQQHFW LRQV LQ OLIH DQG Z RU OG W R Z KRP
VORZO\ W KH JDW HV RI LOOXP LQDW LRQ RSHQ DQG KH JLYHV XS W KH ULJLGLILFDW LRQ RI KLV
KHDUW &DSDEOHRIDFFHSW LQJW KHW KLQNLQJRIW KHKHDUW KHZLOOEHJLYHQW KHJUHDW HU
UHYHODW LRQ W KDQ W KLQNLQJ ZLW K W KH KHDG FRXOG JLYH

$QRW KHUUHODW LRQ 7KHSRVLW LRQRIW KHKXP DQKHDUW RQW KHVLGHFRUUHVSRQGVW RW KH
GHYLDW LRQ RI W KH (DUW K¶V D[LV IURP  W KH YHUW LFDO SRVLW LRQ ZKLFK LV    GHJUHHV
7KHKXP DQKHDUW LVW RW KHERG\D[LVRIW KHKXP DQEHLQJDP LUURU RIW KHZRUOGD[LV


$UHIHUHQFHW RW KH³ ZLW FKHV[´ LQ*RHW KH¶V)DXVW ZKLFKJLYHVDGHVLJQRIW KHP DJLFDO
VTXDUHRIW KHW KDW LVGLIIHUHQW IURP W KHVTXDUHRI6DW XUQ

2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

LQDQDYHUDJHDQJOHRI GHJUHHV7KLVFRUUHVSRQGVDVZHOOW RW KHDQJOHRI

W KHHFOLSW LFRIW KH6XQDQGDJDLQLW SURYHVKRZFORVHO\FRQQHFW HGFRUUHODW LRQVDUH
E HW Z HHQ  W K H K X P DQ  E HLQ J  DQ G  W K H FRVP RV  K RZ  G HHS O\  I RX Q G HG  DU H W K H
DVVXP SW LRQV RI DVW URORJ\  2QH RI W KHP  FRUUHODW HV W KH KHDUW  W R W KH VXQ DV W KH
OLRQ LQ W KH ]RGLDF ZKLFK DJDLQ LV NDOD VLQFH ³ OLRQ´  P HDQV ³ OHZH´  LQ *HUP DQ
GLDOHFW V +LJK *HUP DQ /HEHQ OLIH    7KH KHDUW  LV UXOHG E\ W KH ³ /|ZHQ´ OLIH
7KLV W RR LV DJDLQ RQH RI W KH W KRXVDQGV RI SURRIV LQ RXU ODQJXDJH W KDW  *HUP DQ
KDV VW LOO FRQW DLQHG W KH 8U ODQJXDJH LQ VRP H UHVSHFW   6XFK ZRUG  JDP HV DQG
JDP HV ZLW K P HDQLQJV DUH RQO\ SRVVLEOH LQ *HUP DQ DQG LQ W KH RW KHU *HUP DQLF
ODQJXDJHV ZKLFK ZLOO JLYH XV DJDLQ W KH VHFUHW V W KDW  VKLQH IURP  W KH ZRUG IURP
W KH SODFH 2UW  IURP  W KH 8UG W KH 8U 'D W KH 8U 'D 6HLQ 8U H[LVW HQFH 


0RGHUQ*HUP DQGLDOHFW VP RGHUQ*HUP DQODQJXDJH

 

, ;
7+ (+ , *+ $1 '+ 2/<7+ 5((

7RDULVHW REHW RSDVVDZD\

7R W XUQ LQ W KH IOLJKW  RI W KH
Z RU OGV
7LP H QHYHU FKDQJHV
(YHQ QRW  LQ HW HUQLW \

:KHUH D IRON W KDW  LV VW LOO D XQLW \ LQ UDFH DQG UHOLJLRQ VKDSHV LW V OLIH
W KHUH W KH FXOW LF LQVW LW XW LRQV LQ W KH VHUYLFH RI ZRUVKLS RI W KH DOO DFW LYH
'LYLQLW \ DUH W KH P RVW  KRQRUHG RQHV  7KH SXUHU W KH UDFH VW LOO LV W KH
VLP SOHU  DQG W KHU HIRU H GHHSHU  W KH FXOW XU H W KH P RU H GRP LQDQW  W KH
SRVLW LRQ W KDW  LV JLYHQ W R W KH 'LYLQH VSLULW XDO SRZHUV  7KLV ZD\ ZH
FOHDUO\ UHFRJQL]H LQ W KH SDVW  RI RXU IRON HP SKDVLV RQ D FRQFHSW  RI
HW HUQLW \W KH+RO\W ULQLW \RURQHQHVVRIW KUHH  7KLV$U\DQSHUFHSW LRQ
RI W KH W ULQLW \ DQG W KUHH VDQFW LW \ RI DOO HYHQW V IURP  EHFRP LQJ W R EHLQJ
W R SDVVLQJ DZD\ LQ EULHI W KH W KUHHIROG QHVV RI W KH FUHDW LRQ DQG ZLW K
LW  DOO OLIH RQ (DUW K IURP  W KH SDVW  RYHU W KH SUHVHQW  W R W KH IXW XUH  ZDV
W KH U HDVRQ W KDW  RXU  DQFHVW RU V KDY LQJ EHHQ FRQQHFW HG W R QDW XU H
DGDSW HG DOO FRUUHODW LRQV DQG LQVW LW XW LRQV RQ (DUW K W R W KLV W ULQLW \  $Q
H[DP SOHLVW KHVXEGLYLVLRQRIW KHIRONLQW RDFODVVRIW HDFKLQJDFODVV
RI GHIHQGLQJ DQG D FODVV RI QRXULVKLQJ

 2PLWWHG
 

2EYLRXVO\ W KLV JHQHUDW HV D JUDQGLRVH V\P ERO RI W KH W ULQLW \ RI JRGV ZKLFK W KHQ
EHFRP HVW KHREM HFW RIZRUVKLSDVDQRXW SRXULQJRI'LYLQHUHDVRQDQGLW VYLEUDW LRQ
2XU DQFHVW RUV KRZHYHU ZHUH QRW  W KDW  VLP SOH P LQGHG W KDW  W KH\ W RRN VXFK D
V\P ERO DV D SHUVRQ LH OLW HUDOO\ EXW  W KH\ VDZ LQ LW  D P DW KHP DW LFDO IRUP XOD VR
W R VD\ RI W KH HW HUQDO ODZ RI HYROXW LRQ  7KLV ILQGV LW V H[SUHVVLRQ LQ W KH P DQ\
KXQGU HGV RI W U LQLW LHV W KDW  W KH\  FRQFHLY HG RI LQ DQ DOP RVW  Z DVW HIXO Z HDOW K RI
FUHDW LYLW \ RU FRSLHG IURP  OLIH LW VHOI  :H GR QRW  QHHG DQ\ FOXP V\ SURRI W KDW  W KH
FRQFHSW  RI W KH W ULQLW \ LV QRW  RI &KULVW LDQ RULJLQ EHFDXVH W KH FKXUFK DFFHSW HG DV
ODW HDVW KHW KFHQW XU\FHW KHILUVW LQGLFDW LRQVRIW KLVW ULQLW \XQW LOILQDOO\LQW KH
W K FHQW XU\ LW  ZDV FRP P RQO\ DFFHSW HG E\ W KH FKXUFK  7KLV KDSSHQHG P DLQO\
E HFDX VH W K H *HU P DQ LF W U DG LW LRQ  Z DV W RR S RZ HU I X O W R E H S X VK HG  LQ W R W K H
EDFNJURXQG   6HH0ROVGRUI ³ &KULVW LDQV\P EROLVP ´ $URXQGW KDW W LP HW KHVDFUHG
W ULQLW LHVDUHOLNHO\W RKDYHEHHQW UDQVIHUUHGLQW R&KULVW LDQLW \7KLVLVW KH8U$U\DQ
7KU HH W KDW  U HSHDW V LW VHOI LQ DOO P \ W KRORJLHV   :RGDQ  :LOL  DQG :HK  Z KLFK
FKULVW LDQLW \ W RRN RYHU DV
*RG )D W K H U 6RQ +RO\*KRVW

7KLVKRO\W ULQLW \LVQRW KLQJEXW DV\P EROLFW KRXJKW IRUP XODIRU W KHXQGHUVW DQGLQJ
RI W KH FRQFHSW  UHJDUGLQJ DOO HYHQW V LQ
$ULVLQJ2ULJLQDWLQJ %HLQJ 3D VVLQJD Z D \

2ULQ
3D VW 3U H VH QW )XW XUH

2U LQ ODW HU KLGGHQ IRUP  E\ W KH FKXUFK

.D VSD U 0HOFKLRU %DOW KDVDU
&  0  %

)URP  W KLV ZH FRQFOXGH W KDW  DOO $U\DQ W KLQNLQJ ZDV ILUVW  ERUQ  :H DVN QRW  W R EH
VXUSULVHG DW  W KHVH HTXDW LRQV EHFDXVH DFFRUGLQJ W R W KHLU RULJLQ W KH\ DUH VW LOO
FOHDU FRQFHSW V FRQFHUQLQJ QDW XUDO HYHQW V W KDW  RULJLQDW HG IURP  H[DFW  UHDVRQLQJ
VXFK DV FKHP LFDO SK\VLFDO EDVLF ODZV

7KH $U\DQ , QGLDQV XQGHUVW RRG W KLV W ULQLW \ DV W KH W KUHH IROG %UDKP DQ
&U H D W RU 0DLQW DLQHU ' H VW U R\H U
%UD KP D 9LVKQX 6KLYD
$ULVLQJ %HLQJ 3D VVLQJD Z D \


 2PLWWHG
 

3RVVLEO\ ZH P D\ JXHVV VRP HW KLQJ IURP  W KH QDP HV RI W KH &KULVW LDQ W ULQLW \ DQG
W KH RQH W KDW  ZDV ODW HU VXSHULP SRVHG  $SSDUHQW O\ W KH\ GLG QRW  N QRZ TXLW H ZHOO
KRZ W R VSHDN VRP HW KLQJ RXW  DQG VW LOO KLGH LW 
&D VSD U 0HOFKLRU %DOW KDVDU

,  DP  UHDGLQJ 8U OLQJXLVW LFDOO\ DV IROORZV

&DV VSDU FKDVW HSXUHELUW K&DVW D&DVW  SXUHEDU ELUW K7KHUHIRUH $ULVLQJ
0HOFKLRUFDQEHVHHQLQW KHSDUW VRI 0HOP DO0DKO P XOW LSOLFDW LRQFKLLQW KH
LQYHUVLRQ RI LFK ,  DQG RU  6XQ RU (DUW K   0XOW LSOLFDW LRQ RI W KH HJR LQ W KH 6XQ
³ RQ (DUW K´  7KHUHIRUH   %HLQJ
%DOW KDVDU ZKR LV D 0DXU D GDUN SHUVRQ ZKR SRLQW V W R W KH GDUN W R W KH IXW XUH
QHHGV QR IXUW KHU H[SODQDW LRQ  7KHUHIRUH
)D W KH U 6RQ 3D VVLQJD Z D \+ RO\*KRVW

$UH W KH FKDUDFW HULVW LFV RI W KH 'LYLQH LQ

2P QLSRW HQFH $OO ORYH 2P QLVFLHQFH

, I, P D\P DNHDGDULQJJUDVSLQW KHZRUOGRIW KHZRUGRIW KH

ODQJXDJH W KHQ ,  GDUH W R GLVFRYHU W KH P HDQLQJ RI W KH ZRUG
%DOW KDVDU   7KH SDOLQJ %DO GHU VDU   %DO  6XQ 6DU  YHU
´VHKUW ´  YHUVHKUW   KDUP HG  E\ W KH P LVW OHW RH W KH 0LV W DO
W KH 0L‰ W HLO EDG SDU W  W KH 0L‰ JH]HXJW H FU HDW HG EDG 
7KH 6XQ EDOO ZKLFK +|GXU +DGHU FRQIOLFW  +D‰ KDW H LQ
P RGHUQ*HUP DQ W KHHW HUQDOLQFLW HUW KURZVLQW RW KHGDUNQHVV
 W RQHZDULVLQJ7KLVLVW KHP LUDFOHRI$U\DQ6XQ EOLVVLQDOO
LW V W UDJLF H[SUHVVLRQ W KDW  LW  QHYHU LV KRSHOHVV QHYHU OLIH
QHJDW LQJDOZD\VDIILUP DW LYHEHFDXVHZLW KRXW HW HUQDOGHDW K
W KHUH LV QR HW HUQDO OLIH  7KLV LV W KH ODQJXDJH RI W KH ELUGV
ZKLFKHDFK³ 6LHJIULHG´HDFK³ NLOOHURI'UDJRQV´ XQGHUVW DQGV
ZKHQ KH GLSSHG W KH LQGH[ ILQJHU W KH ILQJHU RI EHJHW W LQJ
LQW R W KH GUDJRQV EORRG DQG SXW V RQW R KLV OLSV

9RJHO FDQ EH FRP SRVHG RI YRJ  EHJHW W LQJ DQG HO  VSLULW 
:DUULRUZLW KW KHW UL 7R XQGHU VW DQG W KH ODQJXDJH RI W KH ELU GV P HDQV DOVR W R
IRV W KH W KUHH IRRW  XQGHUVW DQG W KH ODQJXDJH RI VSLULW XDO EHJHW W LQJ W KH ZRUOG
V\P ERORIW ULQLW \RQ
ODZ RI OLIH ZKLFK UHYHDOV LW VHOI LQ W KH GUDJRQ¶V EORRG  7KH
D*UHHNFXSRIW KH
W K FHQW XU\ EFH GUDJRQLVW KHW ULJRQ W ULDQJOH  $ULVLQJEHLQJSDVVLQJDZD\

:H NLOO W KH GUDJRQ ZLW KLQ RXUVHOYHV W KHQ ZH P DVW HU W KH ODZ RI OLIH

:KDW  LV W KH YDOXH RI W KHVH LQVLJKW V DQG IRU ZKDW  SXUSRVH GR ZH FRQVLGHU W KHVH
W KLQJV"

%HFDXVH ZLW K LW  ZH JHW  DQ DQVZHU W R W KH TXHVW LRQ RI ZKDW  ZH DU H

$ ZRUG LQ W KH ELEOH VD\V ³ 7KH KXP DQ EHLQJ GRHV QRW  OLYH IURP  EU HDG DORQH EXW
IURP HDFKZRUGRI*RGW KDW FRP HVW KURXJKKLVP RXW K´ 2XU$U\DQERG\GHW HUP LQHV
DOVRRXU$U\DQVSLULW W KHVSHFLDOVSLULW XDOLW \RIRXUUDFHZKLFKP HDQVW KDW LQRXU
 

W KLQNLQJDQGIHHOLQJZHDUHGLIIHUHQW IURP RW KHUUDFHV, QRW KHUZRUGV 1RERG\

FDQ JHW  DURXQG KLV RULJLQ  $V IDU DV ERG\ DQG P LQG DUH FRQFHUQHG ZH DUH W KH
UHVXOW RIDORQJDQGXQLQW HUUXSW HGOLQHRIRXUDQFHVW RUV7KLVZD\W KHVXP RIDOO
LQGLYLGXDOO\ W KH IRON LV W KH UHVXOW  RI LW VHOI

7KH VSHFLDO VROLGLW \ RI D UDFH LV P DQLIHVW  LQ D ZD\ RI OLIH W KDW  LV VSHFLILF W R LW VHOI
RQO\ DQG LQ DOO W KDW  ZH HQFRP SDVV LQ W KH FRQFHSW V RI FXOW XUH DQG P RUDOV  $UW 
UHOLJLRQ DQG VFLHQFH JURZ RQ W KH IRXQGDW LRQV RI RXU LQQDW H EHLQJ DQG W KH\ JLYH
W KH VW U XFW XU H RI RXU  :HOW DQVFKDXXQJ VKDSH DQG GLU HFW LRQ DOO W KH ZD\  W R W KH
KLJKHVW  HP DQDW LRQV RI W KH KXP DQ P LQG   W KH FRQFHSW  RI *RG W KDW  RULJLQDW HV LQ
LW 

, IZHFDQVSHDNRISURJUHVVZKHQZHFRQVLGHUW KHDGYDQFHP HQW RIW KHW HFKQLFDO

ZRUOGW KHQZHDOVRDFFHSW W KHIDOVHEHOLHILQDQDGYDQFHP HQW LQVSLULW XDOP DW W HUV
+RZ HYHU W R W KH FRQW UDU\ LW  VHHP V W KDW  Z H KDYH DFKLHYHG UHOLJLRXV P D[LP DO
HYROXW LRQ P LOOHQQLD DJR

$OO$U\DQUHOLJLRQVDQGW KHFKXUFKHVW KDW HP HUJHGIURP W KHP DUHFXOP LQDW LQJLQ

W KHSURFODP DW LRQRIW KHUHVXUUHFW LRQRIOLIHSURYLGHGW KDW W KHVHFKXUFKHVGLGQRW
UHSODFH EDVLF ODZV ZLW K GRJP DV  7KLV NQRZOHGJH LV DQFKRUHG LQ W KH W ULQLW \ RU
W KUHH IROG QDP H RI ³ *RG´ QDP HO\ DV ZH VDZ
*RG)D W K H U 6RQ +RO\*KRVW
: RGD Q :LOL : HK

2Q W KH SODFH RI ZKLFK ZH FDQ DOVR SXW 

$ULVLQJ %HLQJ 3DVVLQJ
W RQH Z D U LVLQJ

7K H + RO\7U LQ LW \ 7K H 7K U H H  + ROLQ H VV

 

7KLV P HDQV W KDW  ZH KDYH W R EHFRP H VSLULW  DJDLQ DQG W R GXVW  LQ RUGHU W R FRP H
W R W KH IDW KHU DQG W KXV W R FRQFOXGH W KH HW HUQDO F\FOH RI OLIH

7KLVIDUZHUHFRJQL]HRXUVHOYHVDJDLQLQW KHW HDFKLQJVRIW KH(GGDRI%UDKP DQ

RI%XGGKD=RURDVW HUDQG&KULVW DVIDUDVW KHVHW HDFKLQJVKDYHQRW EHHQIDOVLILHG
:H UHFRJQL]H W KH UHYHODW LRQV RI W KHVH W HDFKLQJV DV VSLULW  EHIRU H RXU VSLULW 

7KH ZRUOG UHYHDOV LW VHOI W R XV LQ W KH VDFUHG F\FOH RI OLIH IURP  DULVLQJ RYHU EHLQJ
W R SDVVLQJ DZD\  7KH *RW K DV W KH FURZQ RI FUHDW LRQ LV HQFORVHG LQ W KH P LGGOH
RI W KLV HW HUQDO P DQLIHVW DW LRQ  $OO RI KLV HIIRUW V W R LQW HUSUHW  W KH ZRUOG DQG W KH
H[LVW HQFHGLIIHUHQW O\W RZUHVW OHIURP LW DQRW KHULQVLJKW KDYHEHHQLQYDLQW RW KLV
SRLQW  DQG W KH\ ZLOO UHP DLQ LQ YDLQ  (YHQ W KH VW ULFW  P DW HULDOLVP  UHP DLQHG VW XFN
LQW KHEDUEHGZLUHRIW KLVERUGHUOLQHZLW KKLVODVW W KRXJKW VLHZKHQLW SRVW XODW HG
W K H ODZ  RI  W K H FRQ VHU Y DW LRQ  RI  P DW W HU  DQ G LW V FRQ W LQ X RX V FK DQ JH  Z LW K RX W
UHFRJQL]LQJ KRZHYHU W KDW  ZLW K W KLV LW  P DGH W KH VW HS EDFN W R DQFLHQW  NQRZOHGJH
DQG LQVLJKW V W KDW  KDYH EHHQ DFKLHYHG ORQJ DJR

:H KDYH VHHQ W KDW  W KH W ULQLW \ LV D V\P ERO RI W KH ZRUOG DQG LW V HW HUQDO F\FOH RI
EHFRP LQJ RYHU EHLQJ W R SDVVLQJ DZD\  2XU $U\DQ DQFHVW RUV SXW  IRU W KLV W KH
ZRUGV
8U GD 9HUGDQGL 6NXOG

7KHVH DUH W KH QDP HV RI W KH W KUHH 1RUQV RI W KH (GGD  7KH\ DUH H[SODLQHG DV
IROORZ V
6LQFHW KHQ 7K H EH FRP LQ JRQ H W K D W Z KLFK Z D VGRQ H
8U  K H U H W KH EH LQJRQH W KD W Z KLFKKD VEH FRP H

³ 6FKXOG´  P RGHUQ*HUP DQ GHEW JXLOW LVRIW KHW ULQLW \W KDW ZKLFKHQGVW KHHQG
ZKLFK ZH KDYH RZHG RU VKRXOG KDYH GRQH ZKDW  ZH RZH W R IDW H DQG RXUVHOYHV

7KH 1RUQV DUH VLW W LQJ XQGHU W KH ZRUOG W UHH W KH ZRUOG DVK W KH D[LV RI W KH ZRUOG
<JJ GUD VLOZKLFKP HDQVLQ*HUP DQ , DP FDUU\LQJW KHJRDO 7KHUHW KH\VSLQW KH
W KUHDGRIGHVW LQ\7KHZRUOG DVKKDVW KUHHEUDQFKHVDQGW KUHHURRW VDFFRUGLQJ
W R W KH H[LVW HQFH RQ (DU W K DQG DERYH (DU W K  7KH QXP EHU  W KU HH V\ P EROLFDOO\
SRLQW V W RZDUGV W KH W ULQLW \ W R W KH W KUHH SDUW V RI OLIH  , W  LV VLJQLILFDQW  W KDW  W KH
W KLUG EUDQFK ZDV W KRXJKW  W R EH LQ D VW DW H RI GU\LQJ XS  7KH DVK W UHH DV VDFUHG
ZRUOGW UHHDJDLQLV.DODZKLFKP HDQVKLGLQJRIW KHP HDQLQJ, Q$U\DQODQJXDJH
$VKLVDVNZKLFKP HDQVD[LVEXW DOVRW RJURZW RFRP HIRUW K7KHUHIRUHW KHILUVW
KXP DQ LQ W KH (GGD LV QDP HG DVN DVK W UHH W KH RQH ZKR JURZV W KHUHIRUH W KH
FRUUHODW LRQ RI W KH ZRUOG W UHH LQ W KH P LFURFRVP 

, QKHUDOGLFP HDQLQJVDVZHOODVGHVLJQDQGV\P EROVRIW KH5XQHVW KHDVKW UHHDV

V\P ERORIW KHXQLYHUVHZLW KRXW KDYLQJEHHQUHFRJQL]HGDVVXFKXSW RQRZ, DP
SRLQW LQJ W RZDUGV W KH +DJ $OO 5XQH DQG LW V FU\SW LF UHSUHVHQW DW LRQ VXFK DV W KH
KHUDOGLFOLO\RIW KH)UHQFKLH)UDQNLVKNLQJVDQGRIP DQ\RW KHUG\QDVW LHVW KDW
ZHUH OHDGLQJ LQ W KH SDVW 
 

, Q W KLV V\P ERO DUH KLGGHQ GHHSHVW  VFLHQW LILF DQG GLYLQH NQRZOHGJH DQG ZLVGRP 
DQFLHQW SURSHUW \RIRXU$U\DQUDFHZKLFKZHDUHDERXW W RGLVFRYHUDJDLQODERULRXVO\
DIW HU ORQJ ODVW LQJ HUURUV DQG P LVW DNHV

6NXOGGHEW KHUHGRHVQRW P HDQ³ VLQ´ LQW KHP HDQLQJRI-XGHR &KULVW LDQFRQFHSW V

7KH $U\DQ *RW KLF KXP DQ GRHV QRW  NQRZ DQ RULJLQDO VLQ QR RULJLQDO YLRODW LRQ RI
'LYLQH ODZ    7R KLP  VLQ LV RQO\ W KH LQGLVFULP LQDW H P L[LQJ DQG SRXULQJ RXW  RI KLV
SXUH EORRG ZLW K W KH VXE UDFHV ZLW K ZKLFK DFW  VLQ FDP H LQW R W KH ZRUOG DV W KH
JHQHVLV RI DQ HDUOLHU SHULRG RI (DUW K KLVW RU\ W HOOV XV   7KH VRQV RI KHDYHQ OLNHG
W KHGDXJKW HUVRI(DUW K W KHDQLP DOIHP DOHV DQGFRSXODW HGZLW KW KHP 7KHVDP H
LV W ROG XV LQ W KH (GGD LQ W KH ³ 5LJVP DO´ ZKHUH W KH VRQ RI W KH JRGV W KH $HVLU
+HLP GROG W KH ZLVHVW  RQH P L[HV ZLW K W KH VXE UDFHV LQ RUGHU W R XSOLIW  W KHP  W R
EUHHGW KHP XS+RZHYHUZKHQVXFKP L[LQJFRP HVIURP FRP P RQOXVW DVLQRXU
GD\VIURP ODFNRIP RUDOVQRW DFFRUGLQJW RDFRVP LFSODQRIDQXS EUHHGLQJRIDOO

+DJ $OO5XQH +HUDOGLF³ /LO\´  ZRUOGW UHH 7KH+DJ$OOW KH:RUOG7UHH

W KDW  OLYHV IURP  EHORZ W R KLJKHU OHYHOV W KHQ W KLV LV VLQ  7KLV ZD\ ZH FDQ DOVR
XQGHU VW DQG W KH ODZ  RI 0RVHV        ³ %HFDXVH W KH KXP DQV KDOI DQLP DO
VXEKXP DQV W KH K\EULGV  EHJDQ W R P XOW LSO\ W KHP VHOYHV RQ (DUW K DQG W KH\ KDG
GDXJKW HUVW KHFKLOGUHQRIJRG VXFKDVKDOI JRGV VDZW KHGDXJKW HUVRIKXP DQV
DQG KRZ EHDXW LIXO W KH\ ZHUH KXP DQ OLNH  DQG W RRN W KHP  DV P DW HV ZKLFKHYHU
W KH\GHVLUHG´ 7KLVZDVQRW ZKDW W KH\VKRXOGKDYHGRQHDFFRUGLQJW RW KHLUOHYHO
RI HYROXW LRQ DQG W KH 'LYLQH SODQ EXW  W KH\ IROORZHG W KHLU GHVLU HV DQG OXVW 

, Q W KH LP DJH RU LGHD RI W KH RULJLQDO VLQ RI W KH ILUVW  KXP DQV ZH ILQG W KH VDP H
W KRXJKW  RQ DQRW KHU  OHYHO  :H KDY H W R XQGHU VW DQG W KDW  Z H GR QRW  ORVH W KH
SDUDGLVH M XVW  E\ HDW LQJ DSSOHV EXW  LI ZH W RRN W KLV VHFUHW  ODQJXDJH OLW HUDOO\ LI
KXP DQV DW H DSSOHV LQVW HDG RI URDVW V W KH\ ZRXOG KDYH VHFXUHG DGYDQW DJHV RI
W KH SDUDGLVH W R W KLV GD\  , Q W KLV P \W K ZH ILQG W KH FURVVURDGV RI VHYHUDO P DLQ
FRQFHSW V RI KXP DQ KLVW RU\ W KDW  ZH KDYH W R VROYH

 2PLWWHG
 

7KUHH P DLQ FRQFHSW V W KUHH P DLQ ZRUGV W KUHH P DLQ W KRXJKW V ZHUH FRQQHFW HG
FOHDUO\ ZLW KLQ D W ULQLW \ VLQFH W LP H LP P HP RULDO

)DW KHU 6RQ +RO\ *KRVW

7KH W KRXJKW  RI W KH IDW KHU W KH DOO IDW KHU W KH DOIRW KXU DV W KH (GGD QDP HV KLP 
W KH DOO FUHDW RUV W KH DOO EHJHW W HUV W KH DOO VKRZHU LV W KH ILUVW  W KH P RVW  QREOH
RQH W KH KLJKHVW  RQH  , W  LV VSHFLILF W R W KH $U\DQ FRQFHSW  RI GLYLQLW \ DQG LW  SDOHV
LQ DOO (DVW HU Q DQG :HVW HU Q U HOLJLRQV SDU W LDOO\ VRP HW LP HV W R W KH SRLQW  RI QRW
EHLQJ U HFRJQL]HG DQ\  P RU H  7KHU HIRU H LW  LV QRW  VXU SU LVLQJ W KDW  Z H ILQG W KLV
FRQFHSW LQDQRW KHU$U\DQZRUGIRUJRGRUFRQFHSW IRUJRGLHW KH8U UXQHRUW KH
8U ZRUG
7$7 '$6 '$7 '(7 GLDOHFW  7+$7 (QJOLVK

7KH *RG W KH DQFLHQW V VDLG LQ EULHI  'DV   , QGLDQ   7KDW   W KLV DQG W KDW    'DV
7KDW 'LHV(QJOLVKDQGORZHU*HUP DQ7KDW 7KDW LVDOOZKLFKZ DVLVDQGZLOOEH
, W LVW KHZKROHVXFKDVW KH)UHQFK³ W RXW ´/DW LQW RW XVGHXW VFKW HXW  7HXW W KDW
LV *RG W KH ZKROH DQG LW V IRON W KH 7HXW  RQV W KH 7HXW$KQHQ P RGHUQ *HUP DQ
IRUDQFHVW RUV QDP HO\ W KH7HXW VFKHQW KH7HXW OL VFKHQW KH'HXW OLFKHQ7KH
ZKROH RI LW  FDQ DOVR EH VSOLW  HYHU\ ZKROH KDV W ZR SRODULW LHV VR ZH VKDOO QRW  EH
VXUSULVHG ZKHQ W KH 7HXW  W KH ZKROH EHFRP HV W KH 7YLVW  W KH =ZLVW  DUJXP HQW V
FRP EDW  W KH =ZHL W ZR LQ 0RGHUQ *HUP DQ  ZKLFK W KH W KH URRW  RI W KH ³ 'X´
*HUP DQ ZRUG IRU 7KRX \RX    , W  LV W KH ³ W KRX´  W KDW  LQGLFDW HV D VSOLW   ,  DQG \RX
DU H D RQHQHVV  D Z KROH  HVSHFLDOO\  LI W KHU H DU H SRODU  HJR QHVVHV DQG W KRX
QHVVHV DV LV W KH FDVH ZLW K P DQ DQG ZRP DQ

*HUP DQLF 7KHXGD *RW KLF 7KLXGD $QJOHVD[RQ 7KHRG 2OG +LJK *HUP DQ 'LRW 
0LGGOH +LJK *HUP DQ 7LHI /LW KXDQLDQ 7DXW D /DW LQ 7RW XV  $OO UHIHUV W R *RG

7KH V\OODEOHV 'L 7L 'D 'R 7L 7H P HDQ LQ W KH $U\DQ ODQJXDJHV *RG DQG DOVR
'D\, IZHW DNHW KHLQYHUVLRQRI7DJ7RJ *DW *RW ZHJHW *RGW KH*RRGW KH
/LJKW 

³ 7$7´  LV OLW HUDOO\  W KLV DQG W KDW  EXW  DOVR W KH 7DW  DFW LRQ  LQ D FRVP LF VHQVH
EHFDXVHW KHSUHVHQFHRIW KHZKROHUHVXOW VIURP W KH'LYLQHDFW LRQ7KHZRUGZDV
SUHVHUYHGDVDGHVFULSW LRQRIW KHZKROHLQDOOODQJXDJHVRIW KHZRUOGW RW KLVGD\
7DW  OLIHDQGGHDW K W RW  GHDGLQ0RGHUQ*HUP DQ 7RW DO HYHU\W KLQJ(J\SW LDQ
7HW ZKLFKP HDQVOLIHHW HUQLW \HYHU\W KLQJ7RW R HYHU\W KLQJW KHXQLYHUVHDQG
LQLW VXQLRQW RW  QRW KLQJ 7KHUHIRUHZHFDQGHGXFHIURP W KLVW KH'LYLQHQDP H
RI W KH 7HXW VFKHQ W KH 7HXW  LVFKHQ
7HXW  7LX =HXV 'HXV '\DQV 7KHRV
, Q *HUP DQ *UHHN /DW LQ DQG , QGLDQ SURQXQFLDW LRQ
7KHR DQG =HR
, Q 0H[LFDQ SURQXQFLDW LRQ

$VOLJKW RYHUVLJKW  *RUVOHEHQW RRNW KH*HUP DQW UDQVFULSW LRQRIW KH+HEUHZZRUG³ =LRQ´ IRULW V
SURQXQFLDW LRQ, QIDFW W KHFRUUHFW SURQXQFLDW LRQRIW KHZ RUGLQ+HEUHZ DQ³ HP SKDW LFV´ Z KLFK
LVDIDUIURP W KH³ W ]´  VRXQGRIW KH³ =LX´ 
 

7KH VDP H ZRUG =LX ZKLFK DSSHDUV LQ 3DOHVW LQH DV =LRQ 

)XUW KHU GHGXFW HG W KLV ZRUG DSSHDUV DV

-LX VSRNHQ DV 'M X  DQG -X EXW  DOVR +X
LQ W KH P HDQLQJ RI *RG VSLULW  ILUH

-XO DQG +XO DUH W KH W XUQLQJ SRLQW V LQ W KH F\FOH RI W KH 6XQ   OLJKW  DQG GDUNQHVV
*RGDQGGHYLO7KH\SXW W KLV-XW KLV³ -8+8´ LQW KHFDOORIW KH$OSLQHSHRSOHVLQ
IURQW  RII W KH ZRUG IRU IDW KHU SDW HU SLW HU DQG W KLV EHFDP H W KHQ
-X SLW HU  IDW KHU RI VSLULW
:LW K W KH 5RP DQV DQG
'\ DXV SLW HU 
:LW K W KH , QGLDQV  :H ILQG DOVR -X  *RG DQG 'HXV 'M DXV  *RG DQG 3LW HU
YDW KHU W KHUHIRUH -X 3LW HU  *RG )DW KHU  7KH , QGLDQ VHFUHW  ERRN ']\DQ LV W KH
ERRN RI =HXV RI 7HXW 

6LOYHURUQDP HQW VRIW KH6F\W KLDQVW ZRW KUHH SDVVHVDVW KH\ZHUHXVHG

ODW HU LQ JRW KLF GRP HV DQG ZLW K W KH VDP H LQW HQW LRQ RI VDQFW LILFDW LRQ RI
W KH W ULQLW \ LQ W KH FRXUVH RI OLIH IURP  EHFRP LQJ RYHU EHLQJ W R SDVVLQJ
+HUH W KH ILHU\ W ULSOLFLW \ LV YLEUDW LQJ ZKLFK LV W KH P \VW HU\ RI W KH OLJKW 
W KHFUHDW LRQRXW RIURW DW LRQW KH7KUHHW KHIDLW KIXOQHVV P RGHUQ*HUP DQ
³ 7UHXH´ W KH7URM D )URP W KLVRQHW ULSOLFLW \DUHGULSSLQJGRZ QW KHW KUHH
W LP HV W KUHH  QLQH ULQJV RI 'UDXSQLU DQG W KH\ FRP SOHW H W KH ILJXUH W R
W KHW ZHOYHW RW KH7\UW RW KH7UHW RW KHURW DW LRQDOFLUFOH3HRSOHGLGQRW
GHVLJQ XVHOHVV ³ M HZHOU\´ EXW  W KH W KRXJKW FRQW HQW  RI D ZKROH YLHZ RI
OLIH DZDNHQHG 8U LP DJHV LQ W KH DQFHVW RUV ZKLFK JDYH W KH LP SHW XV W R
DQLQH[KDXVW LEOHZHDOW KRIVKDSHV7KLVZDVQRW ZDVW HIXOOX[XU \EHFDXVH
RI W KH SUHFLRXVQHVV RI W KH P DW HULDO RI ZKLFK W KH\ KDG DOZD\V HQRXJK
UHJDUGOHVV EXW  ULFK P HQW DO IUXLW IXOQHVV  6XFK DUW  W KDW  ZDV NHSW  DQG
P DLQW DLQHG LQ LW V 8U FXOW LF VW DW H FRXOG QHYHU GHJHQHUDW H   EFH

FRQFOXVLRQVDQGW KH³ OLQJXLVW LF´ EDVLVRIW KHP Z KLFKZ RXOGFRY HUDZ KROHERRN, M XVW OLP LW
P \VHOIW RSRLQW LQJRXW W KHP RVW EODW DQW HUURUV

7KH6DQVFULW ZRUGIRUIDW KHULV³ SLW DU ´ RUP RUHFRUUHFW O\³ SLW DKD´GHILQLW HO\QRW ³ SLW HU ´
 

7KH *HQLW LYH ³ VHFRQG FDVH´  RI -XSLW HU LV -RYLV DV ZH DOO NQRZ  7KLV LV HQW LUHO\
XQH[SODLQDEOH ZKLFK VW UHVVHG W KH P LQGV RI W KH SKLORORJLVW V    6XFK W KLQJV FDQ
RQO\ EH VROYHG LI ZH DUH DZDUH RI W KH XQLW \ RI DOO ODQJXDJHV DQG LI ZH DUH QRW
DIUDLGW RSXOODQH[SODQDW LRQIURP W KH%DYDULDQGLDOHFW RUIURP W KH, ULVKODQJXDJH
LI LW  RIIHUV LW VHOI IURP  W KHUH  

:KHQ ZH FDQ QRZ SURYH W KH H[LVW HQFH RI D QDP H RI D JRG RI -8 RU  -2 W KH
JHQLW LYH-XLV-RLVRU-RYLV , IVRP HRQHVW XGLHV³ -XV´ LQRXUGD\V DFW XDOO\-XUD
RU ODZ  KH P D\ NQRZ W KDW  KH KDV W KH REOLJDW LRQ E\ W KH SRZHU RI W KH 'LYLQH
QDP H RI -86 W R VW XG\ *RG ZLW K ³ M X UD´  W KDW  ODZV RI W KH JRGV EHFDXVH UD RU DU
LV W KH $DU HTXDOV 6XQ DQG ODZ W KHUHIRUH ODZ RI W KH 6XQ

:KHQ-X *RGW KHQ-X W  *RGRIDFW LRQLQW KHSKHQRP HQRQZKLFKLVSURYHQ

E\W KHHVRW HULFFRQW HQW RIW KH7RURIW KHUXQH7\UW KH5XQHRI*RGZKLFKP HDQV
DFW LRQ

)URP  -XW  -XW W  W R *XW  JRRG  *XW W   DQG *RW W  *RG LQ P RGHUQ *HUP DQ  LV M XVW  D
VP DOOOLQJXLVW LFVW HSZLW KZKLFKZHKDYHSURYHQW KH'LYLQHSURSHUW \RIW KHZRUG
-X%XW VW LOODQRW KHUZRUGRSHQVKHUHKLVW RQJXH7KLVLVW KH(QJOLVK-HZ -XGH 
RXU -X LQ -XGH  -XGH DQG *XW H *RW H *RW K  ZH FRQQHFW HG HOVHZKHUH  , W  LV W KH
QDP HIRUW KH-X *X *RW KV *RW HQ RU*RW W HV YRON IRONRI*RG , IW KH+HEUDLF
-XGD P HDQV ³ *RW W OLHE´  D *HUP DQ QDP H  W KHQ ZH KDYH DJDLQ LQ W KLV ³ +HEUHZ´
ZRUG W KH *HUP DQ ³ *XW H´  W KH *RRG  *RW H DQG *RW W 

7KHDQFLHQW 'LYLQHQDP H-8FDQVW LOOEHW UDFHGLQOLQJXLVW LFUHP DLQGHUVW KDW KDYH

QRW  EHHQ FKHFNHG IRU W KHLU FRQW HQW V LQ JROG W R W KLV GD\  , Q W KH ³ \RG OHUV´  DQG
³ \FK ]HUQ´  DSSHDUV W KLV ZRUG LQ FXOW LF VXUURXQGLQJV   %HFDXVH W KH <RGHOHUV
DQG-XFK]HUVDUHSUH KLVW RULFFXOW LFVRQJV ZKLFKVW LOOW RGD\DUHVXQJLQVSHFLILF
DQG GHW HU P LQHG VHTXHQFH RI W RQH DQG Z RU G IU RP  Z KLFK GHY LDW LRQV DU H QRW
DOORZHG ZKLFK W KHUHIRUH DUH QRW  DUELW UDU\  7KH YDULRXV YDOOH\ V DQG DUHDV DUH
ZHOO GLVW LQJXLVKHG IRU W KHLU VSHFLILF \RGHOHUV

:RUVKLS RI *RG ZDV DQG VKRXOG DOZD\V EH W KH KLJKHVW  DIILUP DW LRQ RI OLIH  , W
VKRXOGQRW EHDP LUURULQJRIRQH¶VVLQIXOQHVVQRW KLQJQHVVDQGXQZRUW KLQHVVW R
ZKLFK ZRUVKLS ZDV HOHYDW HG E\ D VLQIXO YDLQ DQG XQZRUW K\ VXE KXP DQLW \  7KLV
ZD\M X ELODW HVLQKLJKHVW OLIHDIILUP DW LRQW KH\R GHOHUW KH*RW W OHUDQGW KH-XFK

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG


2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

]HU RI W KH $OSLQH SHRSOHV LQ W KHVH VRQJV RI SUDLVH  +H M XELODW HV KLV M H EHO -X
EDOW KHJRG%DDO  RXW RIW KHP RXQW DLQVDVDOUHDG\P LOOHQQLDDJRIURP W KH%DO
%HODQG%HOFKHQ P RXQW DLQV7KH-X UDP RXQW DLQW KDW JRHVDFFURVVDOORI6RXW KHUQ
*HUP DQ\  LVW KHFHQW HURIW KHIRUP HUFXOW LFP HDQLQJRIW KH-X *RG7KHUHLVDQ
DEXQGDQFH DQG ZHDOW K RI ROG ³ M XULF´  FXOW  ORFDW LRQV

2XU *HUP DQ ZRUG -D  7KH DIILUP DW LRQ W KH ³ %H -DKXQJ´  W KH ³ %H -D ZH KXQJ´
ZHQW RXW ZLW KW KH$U\DQZDYHVRIFRQTXHVW DQGW KLVEHFDP HW KH'LYLQHQDP HRI
-DK ZH-HKR YD-R-D-H-XK7KHZRUG-X +XLQZKLFKERW K'LYLQHQDP HVDUH
FRQQHFW HG FRQW DLQV W KH H[SUHVVLRQ RI W KH KLJKHVW  XQFRQGLW LRQDO DIILUP DW LRQ RI
OLIHZKLFKLVLQW KH'LYLQH7KHV\OODEOH-R *RH[SUHVVHVDOVROLIHDQGP RYHP HQW
DQG LW  EHFDP H W KH SULHVW O\ QDP H RI W KH , RQLDQV W KH RQHV ZKR ZDONHG (QJOLVK
W RJR 7KHRQHVZKRZDONW KH6RODUZDONLQW KH6DFUHVVW RQHFLUFOHVRIW KHLVODQG
RQ -R QD DQ $W ODQW HDQ FRORQ\ LQ 6FRW ODQG  , Q W KH .HOW LF FRXQW LHV RI , UHODQG DQG
6FRW ODQG W KH +X P DQ ZDV P RVW O\ ZRUVKLSSHG

0DQ *RGW KHUHIRUH+X P DQLVW KH+X *RGDQGKLVVHUYDQW VW KH+X P DQV+X

P DQ LV VW LOO (QJOLVK KXP DQ W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ  KXP DQNLQG W KH *RG P DQ FKLOG  
KXP DQNLQG+XP DQKDP RQDP P RQ +HUHW RRW KH-XSLW HU$P P RQUHFHLYHVDUD\
RI P HP RU\ IURP  KLV 1RUW KHUQ KRP HODQG

7KH QDP H RI W KH +LJKHVW  RQH ZKLFK LV H[SUHVVHG LQ W KH V\OODEOH RI +X +R +R
FKLVVW LOOYHU\FOHDUO\FRQW DLQHGLQW KH(QJOLVKZRUGRI³ KXJH´ZKLFKP HDQVYHU\
ODUJHDQG³ KXJHQHVV´7KH*HUP DQFODQQDP HVRI³ +XFK´ DQGW KH(QJOLVK³ +XJK´
³ +XJKHV´ HW F UHIHU W R W KH ³ +XJ HVW ´ W KH KLJKHVW  RQH  

³ -X JHQG´  FDQQRZEHHDVLO\H[SODLQHGIURP W KHZRUG-XDQGJHQW NHQW JHQLW XV

IURP W KH.D 5XQHW KHUHIRUHW KDW ZKLFK³ NXQQW ´ LP P HGLDW HO\IURP *RG³ .XQQW ´
LVDGLDOHFW ZRUGIRU³ NRP P W ´LHFRP HV, QW KH(QJOLVKODQJXDJHW KHP HDQLQJ
RI ³ \RXW K´  SRLQW V LQ W KH VDP H GLUHFW LRQ , W  LV FORVHO\ NLQ W R -XW K -XG -XGD ZKLFK
P HDQV³ GHVFHQGLQJIURP *RG´-XGDDVZHOOW KHUHIRUHW KH*RGDW KH*RW HZKR
LV ³ JRW W LJ´  JRG OLNH   :H NHHS FRP LQJ EDFN W R W KH VDP H OLQJXLVW LF URRW V DQG
W KHUHIRUH SURYH RXU ILQGLQJV W R EH M XVW  DQG ULJKW 

$FK +HU U  -H  , V D U HP DLQGHU  RI DQ ROG FDOO RI ³ -D´  \ HV   QRW  D VXSSU HVVHG
H[FODP DW LRQ   ³$FK KHUU -HVXV´

, Q W KH ³ +ROGULR´  RI W KH \RGHOHU LV W KH FDOO RI W KH +RO W ULR W KH KRO\ W KUHH VW LOO
FRQW DLQHGW RZKLFKW ULQLW \DOVRW KH³ KRO XQGHU´  W KHHOGHUEHUU \ ZDVFRQVHFUDW HG

7KH ILUVW  UHYHODW LRQ RI *RG LQ LW V W ULQLW \ ZDV W KH IDW KHU
7+ (2 =(2

%D DO W KH*RGLQ3KRHQLFLDQHYLGHQW O\W KHVDP H³ HO´  +HEUHZ 

 2PLWWHG

.LQGLQP RGHUQ*HUP DQP HDQVFKLOGIURP ZKHUHKHP DGHW KHGHGXFW LRQ

2PLWWHG

<RXW KLQ0RGHUQ*HUP DQ
 

7KH VHFRQG UHYHODW LRQ RI *RG LQ W KH W ULQLW \ LV W KH VRQ
%$/ ' 85

3RKOLQ*HUP DQ\$ 3RO ORLQ*UHHFH:LW KW KH$U\DQVZKRP LJUDW HGW RW KH(DVW 
W KH 6RXW K (DVW  DQG W R W KH 6RXW K W KH ZRUG %DO ZHQW  W R W KH 0LGGOH (DVW    %DDO
%HHO%HO%HHO ]H %XE:KHQDW DODW HUW LP HLQW KH(DVW W KH%DOGHU FKDUDFW HURI
ORYHEHDXW \DQGW UXW KEHFDP HW KHJULP DFHRIW KHVHUYLFHRI%DDOZLW KLW VKXP DQ
VDFU LILFHV W KHQ Z H KDY H W R EODP H IRU  LW  W KH LQFU HDVLQJ SK\ VLFDO DQG P HQW DO
P L[LQJ RI UDFHV DQG GHJHQHUDW LRQ RI UDFH LQ W KRVH SHRSOHV  7KH SXULW \ RI W KH
FRQFHSW  RI *RG DQG RI W KH UHYHODW LRQ RI *RG W R D SHRSOH DV D ZKROH GHSHQGV RQ
W KHLQIOXHQFHRUVW UHQJW KRILW VEHVW UDFLDOSDUW )URP W KLVZHP D\FRQFOXGHW RRXU
SUHVHQW   7KH %DO RQ W KH SK\VLFDO OHYHO LV W KH EDOO W KH OLJKW  EDOO RI W KH 6XQ DQG
ZHJHW LP P HGLDW HSURRIZKHQZHLQYHUW W KHZRUG /DEZKLFKOHDGVW R/DE XQJ
/HE HQ OLIH /LHEH ORYH 7KHP HDQLQJRIW KH5XQH/DIRU/DEIXUQLVKHVXVZLW K
P RUH SURRI RI RXU RSLQLRQ  7KH %DO  %HO FKHQ 0RXQW DLQV LQ W KH ROG .HOW LF DUHDV
RIW KH%ODFN)RUHVW DQGRIW KH:DVJDXDUHW KH6XQ0RXQW DLQVZKHUH/LJKW DQG
6XQ ZRUVKLS ZDV SUDFW LFHG E\ W KH 'UXLGV W KH 7URLGV W KH ³ 7UHXHQ´  W KH IDLW KIXO
RQHV 

$Q H[DP SOH RI W KH 0HW DW KHVLV W KH YDOLGLW \ RI W KH UHYHUVDO LQ W KH 8U ODQJXDJH LV
W KH ZRUG %DO ZKLFK P HDQV W KH 6XQ W KH EDOO DQG ZLW K W KLV DOO NLQGV RI 'LYLQH
QDP HVVXFKDV%HL%DDO%DO GHU)RKO $  3RO OR 7KHP DQ\%HOFKHQ0RXQW DLQV
DUH %DOO 6XQ 0RXQW DLQV  %DO ROG 1RUGLF   W KH S\UH LV DQRW KHU  GHGXFW LRQ  7KH
RSSRVLW H W R %DO  6XQ LV KRO ROG 1RUGLF  W KH HYLO  , I %DO DQG %DOO DUH *RG DQG
W KH6XQW KHQW KHLQYHUVLRQODEODILVW KHEDVLFZRUGRIRXUOHDYHVDQGOLIH7KH
FRUUHVSRQGLQJ UXQH LV /DI DQG W KLV LV W KH 5XQH RI OLIH  7KDW  QRZ DJDLQ /DI LV
FRQQHFW HG Z LW K ERG\  P RGHU Q *HU P DQ   ³ /HLE´  DQG ORY H QHHGV QR IXU W KHU
H[SODQDW LRQ  %RW K FRQVRQDQW V % DQG / DV W KH VW UXFW XUH RI W KH ZRUG %DO ZULW W HQ
LQUXQHVW HDFKXVW KDW W KHEDVLFP HDQLQJRIW KHZRUGLVW KHQ%DUDQG/DIZKLFK
P HDQV W KH ELUW K DQG OLIH

:KHQ W KH VRXQG % LV UHP RYHG ZKLFK H[SUHVVHV W KH SK\VLFDO DFFXP XODW LRQ %
DOO XQJ  RI W KH OLJKW  FRUUHVSRQGLQJ W R W KH 5XQH % LV ELUW K W KHQ W KH ZRUG DQG
FRQFHSW RIW KH$OOUHP DLQV XQLYHUVHLQ0RGHUQ*HUP DQ , QW KHZRUGV(ObO$O
IRUVSLULW LW LQGLFDW HVP RUHW KHVSLULW XDOFKDUDFW HULVW LFRIW KH6XQRIW KH/LJKW 7R
W KLV FRUUHVSRQGV W KH LQW HUSUHW DW LRQ RI bO DQG gO LQ W KH P \W KRORJLHV DV VSLULW XDO
HW KHULF OLTXLGV ZLW K ZKLFK W KH NLQJV DQG SULHVW V ZHUH DQRLQW HG DQG ZKLFK W KH\
ZHUH JLYHQ W R GULQN LH ZLW K W KH SRZHU RI W KH 6XQ  7KH GHJHQHUDW HG UHOLJLRQV
RI W KH ZKROH (DUW K DERYH DOO W KH RQH W KDW  FDOOV LW VHOI &KULVW LDQ KDYH W R UHW UHDW
IURP  W KLV VSLULW XDOL]HG W HDFKLQJ DERXW  W KH 6XQ VR W KH\ FDQ JHW  EDFN W R W KHLU
RULJLQ EHFDXVH RQO\ W KHUH ZLOO W KHLU URRW V ILQG W KH IHUW LOH VRLO IURP  ZKLFK W KH\
ZHUH W RUQ E\ VDFULOHJLRXV KDQGV

7KH 6HP LW LF SHRSOHV P DGH W KH ZRUG %DOO $OO W R $OODK DV DQ LQKHULW DQFH IURP  W KH
$U\DQ W ULEHV ZKLFK OHIW  LW  W R W KHP  DV DOVR W KH VXSSRVHG -HVXV LQ 3DOHVW LQH GLG
QRW  W DON +HEUHZ RU DQRW KHU 6HP LW LF ODQJXDJH EXW  KLV REYLRXVO\ W UXW K W KDW  KH
 

LQKHULW HG LQ KLV EORRG RI W KH *RRG RQH  , Q KLV XW W HUP RVW  QHHG KH FDOOHG KLV
IDW KHUZLW KW KHZRUG³ (O´LHW KHUHIRUHFDOOV(OLW KHJRGRIOLJKW RIW KH$U\DQV 

7KH-HZVKRZHYHUDQGW KHSHRSOHW KDW ZHUHHGXFDW HGLQ-HZLVKY LHZVW KDW ZHUH

QRW  UDFLDOO\ -HZLVK DVN QRW  XQGHUVW DQGLQJ   :KRP  GRHV KH FDOO"  'RHV KH FDOO
(OLM DK RU RQH RI W KH SURSKHW V"  +HUH D VOLJKW  JOLP P HU VKLQHV W KURXJK W KH YHLO RI
IUDXG ZKLFK ZDV SHUSHW UDW HG ZLW K IDOVLILHG JRVSHOV W KURXJKRXW  W KH FHQW XULHV
-HVXV ZDV QRW  D -HZLVK NLQJ EXW  D * RW KLF NLQJ  KH ZDV $VXV  ZKR KDV P DGH
KLV FRYHQDQW  ZLW K W KH JRG RI OLJKW  (O  +H GLG W KDW  FRQW UDU\ W R ZKDW  W KH ³ -HZLVK´
IRUHIDW KHU $EUDKDP  GLG  $EUDKDP  LV D ZRUG W KDW  ZDV GLVW RUW HG IURP  W KH $U\DQ
%UDKP DQ%DUP DQ$UP DQ+HFRP HVIURP W KH³ 8U´  UDW KHUW KDQDFLW \RI³ 8U´ LQ
&KDOGHD$FFRUGLQJW RW KH-HZLVKIDOVLILFDW LRQKHP DGHKLVFRYHQDQW ZLW K6KDGDL
ZKLFK P HDQV 6KHLW DQ 6DW DQ VKDGRZ 6FKDGHQ GDP DJH LQ P RGHUQ *HUP DQ 
W KHUHIRUH W KH RSSRVLW H RI W KH OLJKW   RI (O

, QW KHVH³ 6DFUHGW H[W V´ HYHU\W KLQJLVVRW ZLVW HGIUDXGXOHQW DQGFURRNHGW KDW QR
RQH FDQ GLVW LQJXLVK DQ\ P RUH EHW ZHHQ EHJLQQLQJ DQG HQG P \W K DQG KLVW RU\
W UXW K DQG OLH    7KHUHIRUH W KHVH ³ VDFUHG W H[W V´  DUH EDG QHZV W KDW  EULQJV RQO\
P LVIRU W XQH SK\ VLFDO DQG VSLU LW XDO GHDW K W R W KRVH Z KR EXLOG W KHLU  IDLW K XSRQ
W KHP 7KHW LP HLVFRP LQJZKHUHZHVXFFHHGW RFODULI\W KHXQEHOLHYDEOHHUURUDQG
IUDXG FRP SOHW HO\  7LOO W KHQ U HDVRQ ORYH RI W U XW K DQG IHHOLQJ RI FOHDQOLQHVV
VKRXOG SUHYHQW  W KH EHOLHYHUV LQ W KH FKXUFKHV W R EXLOG DOO RI W KHLU H[LVW HQFH DQG
ZRUOGO\KDSSLQHVVXSRQVXFKDKHDSRIVSLULW XDOLQM XVW LFH W KH RULJLQRIZKLFKQR
VHUYDQW  RI W KH FKXUFK FDQ GHVFULEH ZLW K D ZRUG RI W UXW K

7KHW KLUGUHYHODW LRQRI*RGLQLW VW ULQLW \LVW KH³ +RO\VSLULW ´DFFRUGLQJW R&KULVW LDQ
YLHZV W KH W KLUG ³ ORJRV´ W KH SDVVLQJ W KH
2' W KH 2G LQQH QW KH VSLU LW  

2GKLQW KHLQQHU2GKW KHLQQHU2GHP  SRHW LF EUHDW K , QQHU%U HDW KW KH, QGLDQ
$OO VSLULW  W KH $W P DQ W KH $GDP  W R ZKRP  *RG JDYH W KH EUHDW K RI OLIH DOO VSLULW
2GKLQ ZKLFK LQ 1RUGLF P \W KRORJ\ LV KXP DQL]HG W R :XRW DQ SDOHG LQ W KH *UHHN
P \W KRORJ\ W R $GRQLV GDUNHQHG W R $GRQDL IRU W KH -HZV W KH QDP H RI JRG W KH
/RU G Z KLFK Z DV XVHG LQVW HDG RI W KH QDP H RI -DKZ HK W KDW  W KH\  Z HU H QHY HU
DOORZHG W R VSHDN

2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG

7KLVLVD*HUP DQL]HGIRUP RI8UXN
 2PLWWHG


2PLWWHG

, QQHQ P RGHUQ*HUP DQIRULQVLGH
 

, IZHSXW W RJHW KHUW KHW KUHHZRUG UHYHODW LRQVRI*RG=HXV %DO 2GZHFRP H

W R W KU HH DU U D\V RI Z RU GV DQG FRQFHSW V DQG D P XOW L VKDSHG DQG DOO SRZ HU IXO
W ULQLW \ HP HUJHV LQ EHIRUH RXU H\HV
7D W 7H O7K LX 7H X W =H X V=LX ' H X V' M D X V' \D Q V' ]\D Q
%D O GXU %D D O%H H O%H O: D O: H O$O(OD OVR%D U
2G2GK 2GK LQ 2GH P $W H P $W P D Q $GD P $GRQ D L

, I ZH FRQW UDFW  W KH ZRUGV RI HDFK DUUD\ ZKLFK DUH NLQ LQ VRXQG DQG P HDQLQJ W R
DP LGGOHDVIDUDVVRXQGLVFRQFHUQHGZHJHW ZKHQRP LW W LQJHQGFRQVRQDQW VIRU
W KH ILUVW  URZ D ZRUG W KDW  ZRXOG EH 7( 7$ =(

)RU W KH VHFRQG URZ ZH ZRXOG UHFHLYH D ZRUG OLNH %$ %$/ DQG IRU W KH W KLUG URZ
D ZRUG OLNH 2'

7KHVHW KUHHV\OODEOHVW KDW ZHIRXQGW KLVZD\FDQEHFRQW UDFW HGW RRQHZRUGDQG

FRQQHFW HG
=( %$ 2'
7R RXU DP D]HP HQW  ZH UHFRJQL]H KHUH W KH %LEOLFDO QDP H RI *RG ³ /RUG =H %D
2W K´  2XU GHGXFW LRQ FDP H ZLW KRXW  HIIRUW  IURP  W KH W ULQLW \ RI W KH $U\DQ QDP HV RI
*RG  DQGZHDUULYHDW DVXSSRVHGO\+HEUHZQDP HRI*RGZKLFKLVQRW DFFHVVLEOH
W R DQ H[SODQDW LRQ RQ EDVLV RI W KDW  ODQJXDJH KDV QR P HDQLQJ DQG DOORZ V QR
P HDQLQJ EHFDXVH W KH GHGXFW LRQ RI W KH ZRUG ³ =HEDRW K´  DV D SOXUDO RI 6DED
DUP \ VDW LVILHV XV DV OLW W OH   DV RW KHU GHGXFW LRQV IURP  +HEUHZ ZRUGV DOO RI ZKLFK
ZHUHW DNHQIURP W KH$U\DQ8U ODQJXDJH  7KHRW KLQ=HEDRW KLVW KH2GLW V'LV
W KH 5XQLF 7KRUQ W KDW  FRUUHVSRQGV HQW LUHO\ W R W KH VRXQG 7K

$OO Z H QHHG W R GR LV W R DGDSW  W KH U RRW  RI W KH $OU XQH W KH $OO 5XQH DQG W KH
FRUUHVSRQGLQJ UXQHV W KDW  ZH KDYH DOUHDG\ JLYHQ IRU W KH W KUHH XQLW V RI W KH 8U
XQLW \  7K\ ZLOO W HOO XV W KDW  ZH KDYH GHGXFW HG FRUUHFW O\ DQG W KDW  W KH\ UHYHDO W R
XV W KH 8U P HDQLQJ RI W KH ZRUGV W KDW  ZH KDYH IRXQG
)D W KH U 6RQ +RO\*KRVW
5XQH RIEH JH W W LQJ 5XQH RIELU W K 5XQH RIW KH 6SLU LW
3KDOOXV %D U  5X Q H RIW K H 6RQ 2G LO5XQH
7\ U %D U 2WKLO
%HFRP LQJ %HLQJ 3DVVLQJ
: RGD Q :LOL : HK

 2PLWWHG

$UP LHVRIW KHKHDYHQ
 2PLWWHG

 

8U GD 9HUGDQGL 6NXOG
3D VW 3U H VH QW )XW XUH

)RU W KH W ZLVW HG =HEDRW K   ZH KDYH IRXQG W KH IRUP XOD
7\U  %D U  2W K LO

:ULW W HQ LQ 5XQHV  7KLV JLYHV XV DV ZHOO W KH NH\ W R W KDW  8U W ULQLW \ RI IDW KHU VRQ
DQG P RW KHU DQG LQGHHG IRU D ORQJ W LP H W KH W KLUG SHUVRQ RI W KH +RO\ W ULQLW \ ZDV
UHSUHVHQW HG DV D IHP DOH HYHQ LQ &KULVW LDQ SUDFW LFH

:H GHGXFW  IURP  W KH TXRW H ³ ,  DP  W KH $ DQG 2 *UHHN $OSKD DQG 2P HJD´

, Q W KH $O SKD ZH UHDG W KH $OO )D 5XQH W KH $OO )DW KHU 5XQH W KH $OO EHJHW W HU
5XQH  2V W KH 5XQH 2V LV LW V SHUIHFW  FRUUHODW H RU LQYHUVLRQ

5XQHVWRQHIURP6QROGHOHJ6HHODQGZLWKVZDVWLNDDQGV\PERORIWKH7ULIRVFUHDWLRQJRIWKH+RO\7ULQLW\

%XW  DOVR LQ W KH 2W KLO 5XQH ZH UHFRJQL]H HDVLO\ W KH ODS RI W KH P RW KHU VW LOO EHW W HU
LQW KH*UHHN2P HJD$DQG2$OSKDDQG2P HJDIDW KHUDQGP RW KHU, Q+HEUHZ
W KH ILUVW  OHW W HU LV DOHSK ZKLFK P HDQV EXOO ZKHUH ZH FDQ VHH W KH *UHHN DOSKD
ZLW KRXW  DQ\ GLIILFXOW \ EXW  DOVR W KH $O 3KD 5XQH RI W KH IXW KDU  W KH $OO )DW KHU
5RZ RI 5XQHV
)$ 26
)$ 0 $ RV W K H P RX W K
)D W KH U D QG 0 RW KH U
<H V D QG 1R
$ERYH D QG %HORZ
6SLULW D QG 0 D W W H U

7KH EXOO W KH 6D7\U ³$OHSK´  $OSKD´  LV KHUH DJDLQ D V\P ERO RI EHJHW W LQJ ZKLFK
EHJLQV RQ W KH VSLULW XDO OHYHO ZLW K W KH $OSKD %HW 


 2PLWWHG
 

%HJLQQLQJ DQG HQG VSLULW  DQG P DW W HU P DQ DQG ZRP DQ LV W KH P HDQLQJ RI W KH $
DQG 2 RI W KH )$ DQG 2V RU 2G

1RZZHDUHVW LOOODFNLQJW KHW KLUGW KLQJEHW ZHHQERW KW KHVRQDQGZHW DNHKLP

IURP  W KH 5XQH W ULQLW \ W KDW  ZH NQRZ QRZ DQG ZH DGG %$5 W KH VRQ W R LW 
7 < 5 RU )$ %$5 2' RU 26
)D W KH U 6RQ 0 RW KH U
0DQ &KLOG : RP DQ

7R W KH 6RQ RI *RG ZKR LQ $UDP DLF ODQJXDJH FDOOV KLP VHOI %DU KYDP  W KH VRQ RI
P HQ W KLV %DU 5XQH KDV EHHQ LQGHHG ³ SXW  LQW R KLV P RXW K´

7KHZRUG%DU KYDP FDQZHGLVVROYHLQW R%DU VRQDQG+YDP KRP KRP P H KXP

P DQDQG*RGDVZHIRXQGLQW KH, ULVKKXP DQVRW KDW W KHZKROHUHDGVDVW KH
³ KXP DQ¶VVRQ´ RU³ VRQRIJRG´2QZKLFKOHYHORIREVHUYDW LRQZ HZDQW W RUHP DLQ
LV XS W R XV

:KHUHYHU ZH XVH W KH 5XQLF NH\ LW  RSHQV W KH VSLULW XDO W UHDVXUHV W KDW  KDYH EHHQ
FORVHG VSHOOERXQG FXUVHG E\ GDUN IRUFHV  7KHVH VSLULW XDO W UHDVXUHV DUH KLGGHQ
LQ ODQJXDJH LQ ILQGLQJ W KH P HDQLQJ RI ZRUGV LQ IDLU\ W DOHV LQ P \W KRORJLHV DQG
OHJHQGV   , Q W KH OLJKW  RI $U \ DQ 8U  ODQJXDJH  W KHVH W U HDVXU HV DU H U HY HDOLQJ
W KHP VHOYHV W R XV IUHHO\ W DONLQJ DQG QR ORQJHU FKDVHG DZD\ DQG LQW LP LGDW HG E\
W KUHDW VW RERG\DQGOLIHQRORQJHUKLGGHQE\OLHVDQGIUDXGEXW LQW KHUDGLDW LQJ
FRDW  RI W UXW K  7KH *HUP DQ W KH $U\DQ W KH JRRG JRW W H W KH (XURSHDQ IDFHV QR
ORQJHU  HDVW   EDQLVKHG E\  KRU U LEOH GHFHSW LRQ  EXW  KH ORRN V QRU W K   LQ W KH ROG
SRVLW LRQRISUD\HUW RW KH3ROHLQW KHSRVLW LRQRIW KH0$1DQGVSHDNVW KHZRUGV
IROORZLQJ W KH $UP DQH *RHW KH W KH *RW K

³ 2I *RG LV W KH 2ULHQW

2I *RG LV W KH RFFLGHQW
1RUW KHUQ DQG VRXW KHUQ W HUULW RULHV
$UH LQ W KH SHDFH RI +LV KDQGV´
 

;
2)%22.67+ $7., //
7+ (0 , 1 '$1 '7+ (%2'<
0HGLFLQHP DNHVVLFNSHRSOH
0DW KHP DW LFVP DNHVVDGSHRSOH
$QG7KHRORJ\P DNHVVLQQLQJSHRSOH
/XWKHU

1RUHOLJLRQLVKLJKHUW KDQW UXW K7KH%LEOHLVDQXQXVXDOIDOVLILFDW LRQ

7KDW  HYHU\ERG\ KDV W R NQRZ EHIRUH KH W DNHV LW  DV W KH EDVLV IRU D
IDQDW LFIDLW K(DFKRQHKDVW RGHDOZLW KW KHKLVW RU\RIW KLVERRNLIKH
GRHVQRW NQRZLW DOUHDG\$KXP DQZKRZDQW HGW REHOLHYHOLW HUDOO\DOO
W KDW  LV W ROG LQ W KH FUHDW LRQ P \W K KH ZRXOG QRW  KDYH DQ\ LGHD RI W KH
W UXHZRUOGYLHZ7KHVHSDVVDJHVKDYHW REHUHDGYHU\FDUHIXOO\7RGR
W KLV RQH QHHGV P DQ\ \HDUV RI UHVHDUFK RU RQH KDV DW  OHDVW  W R NQRZ
W KHUHVHDUFKRIRW KHUVLQRUGHUW RFRP HW RDFRQFOXVLRQRUM XGJP HQW 

7KLV LQGHHG ZRXOG EH D SLW LIXO *RG ZKR KDG UHYHOHG KLP VHOI W R W KH
ZRUOG M XVW  VLQFH DERXW   \HDUV  *RG KDV UHYHDOHG KLP VHOI LQ DOO
JUHDW  P HQ IRU DV ORQJ DV W KH (DUW K KDV H[LVW HG  <RX FDQ JUDVS DQG
XQGHUVW DQG *RG RQO\ E\ \RXUVHOI DQG QRW  E\ P HDQV RI D ERRN QRW
HYHQ W KH P RVW  SUHFLRXV ERRN  :KDW  W KH %LEOH W HOOV W KH 9HGDV RI W KH
, QGLDQV DQG W KH (GGD VDLG P XFK HDUOLHU DQG LQ SDUW  P XFK EHW W HU RU
W KH\NHSW LW P XFKEHW W HU1RW HYHU\ERG\FDQFKHFNW KDW RXW EXW ZKR
KHDUVW KHW UXW KZLOOXQGHUVW DQGLW XQOHVVKLVKHDUW DQGLQW HOOHFW KDYH
E HHQ  E OX U U HG  DQ G  VDG G HQ HG  E \  FRP P DQ G P HQ W  DQ G  S U RK LE LW LRQ 
:KRHY HU  LV RI ³ &KU LVW ¶V´  N LQG  Z KR LV RI *RG  KH QHHGV QRW  VXFK
FUXW FKHV, FRQVLGHUP \VHOIFORVHUW R*RGDQGW RW KHVSLULW RI³ &KULVW ´
EHFDXVH ,  DP  QRW  RI VXIILFLHQW  OLW W OH IDLW K W R W DNH DOO W KHVH V\P EROV
OLW HUDOO\DQGIRUW UXH:KRFRXOGQRW DGYDQFHW RW KDW OHYHOW RUHFRJQL]H
W KDW  *RG LV VSLULW  DQG W KH FRQW HQW  RI W KLV ZKROH ZRUOG LQ LW V JRRG DQG
EDG DVSHFW V KH LV VW LOO IDU DZD\ IURP  W KH LQVLJKW  KH LV VW LOO URRW HG LQ
W KH GHFHSW LY H EHOLHI LQ Z RU GV W KDW  W DN HV HY HU \ W KLQJ DV W U XH IDFW 
 

7KHUH LV QR SHUVRQDO *RG ZLW K EHJLQQLQJ DQG HQG ODUJH RU VP DOO EXW  *RG LV
ZLW KLQ\RXRUP HODUJHRUVP DOODVSHUVRQDORUQRQ SHUVRQDODV, FDQSHUFHLYH
:KDW  GR ,  W KLQN RI W KH &KULVW ¶V 'LYLQLW \ RU *RG OLNHQHVV"  +XQGUHGV RI KLV NLQG
OLYHG DQG DUH OLYLQJ LQ ZKRP  *RG LV GZHOOLQJ H[FOXVLYHO\ DQG Z DV GZHOOLQJ  7R
FDOO KLP  ³ *RG´  LV EODVSKHP \ RI W KRVH ZKR JLYH W KH OHW W HU W KH SRZHU RI EHLQJ
VSLU LW 

$ERXW  W KH ³ GHDW K RI &KULVW  RQ W KH FURVV´ ,  VD\ W KDW  ZKHQ KH GLHG RQ W KH ZRRG
KHGLHVOLNHHYHU\RQHRIXVW RJRW KHSDW KW RQHZLQFDUQDW LRQDVZHGR*RHW KH
W RR NQHZ W KDW  KH KDG OLYHG W KRXVDQGV RI W LP HV  , W  FRXOG EH W KDW  ³ &KULVW ´  ZDV D
SHUIHFW HG RQH ZKR HQW HUHG *RG ZKR ZDV DW  W KH HQG RI KLV IRUP DW LRQV

$ERXW W KHUHVXUUHFW LRQRI&KULVW DQGW KHDVFHQVLRQ, VD\W KDW DOORIXV³ UHVXUUHFW ´

W RDQRW KHUOLIHDIW HUW KLVGHDW KW KDW ZHW UDYHOW RW KHKHDYHQVZKLFKP HDQVW KDW
ZH EHFRP H VSLULW  DJDLQ DQG W KLV ZD\ ZH UHW XUQ DJDLQ VRP H GD\  &KULVW  W RR
UHW XUQVDV³ W KHSRZHUIXORQHIURP DERYH´DERXW ZKRP W KH(GGDVSHDNVKHZKR
ZLOO ILQDOO\ P DNH SHDFH LQ HYHU\ FRP EDW    ZLW KLQ RXUVHOYHV DQG HYHU\ GD\

7KH +RO\ 6SLULW  LV QRW  M XVW  SRXUHG RXW  DW  3HQW HFRVW  EXW  DW  DOO KRXUV RQW R W KH
SHRSOH ZKR DUH UHDG\ IRU LW   3HRSOH ZKR VHH *RG LQ W KHLU VSLULW  EXW  QRW  W KRVH
ZKR ZRUVKLS GHDG OHW W HUV EHFDXVH W KHVH DUH W KH QRQ VSLULW 

, KDYHDEVROXW HO\QRUHVSHFW IRUW KHVLQ7KHW UXHKXP DQW KHJRG KXP DQZLW KLQ
XVLVJRRG(YLOLVW KHSHUVRQZKRIROORZVKLVGHVLUHV7KLVHYLOLVKXJHDQGW KLV
SHU VRQ Z DV P HDQ LQ DOO KLV SODQQLQJ DQG LQW HQW V  7KH ³ VRQ RI *RG´  KDV QR
RULJLQDOVLQ W KDW VLQLV³ LQKHULW HG´ RQO\E\W KRVHZKRGRQRW FRP HW RW KHUHFRJQLW LRQ
RI*RGEHFDXVHW KH\ODFNW KHFRQVFLRXVQHVVRI*RGDVP XFKDVW KH\DUHVXEM HFW
W R W KHLU DQLP DOLVW LF GULYHV

7KHODVW M XGJP HQW KDSSHQVLQHYHU\P RP HQW E\ORRNLQJLQW R\RXU LQQHUP RVW DQG
DVNLQJ\RXUFRQVFLHQFH$OORIW KHEOLQGQHVVDQGLGLRF\RIW KHKXP DQVVKRZVLW V
DQLP DOLVW LFIHDURIW KLVM XGJP HQW ZKLFKW KH\SURM HFW IDUDZD\ LQVSDFHDQGW LP H
IURP  W KHP VHOYHV LQVW HDG LQW R W KHLU LQQHUP RVW  LQW R W KHLU RZQ VRXO

$ IDOVH &KULVW LDQLW \ W KDW  ZDV EURXJKW  E\ W KH ³ -HZ´  IURP  W KH (DVW  DQG EURXJKW  LQ
D IDOVLILHG YHUVLRQ UREEHG W KH $U\DQ RI DOO KLV LQERUQ SUXGHQFH  7KHUHIRUH KH
GRHVQRW VHHDQ\P RUHW RGD\KRZKHLVFKHDW HGE\DQXJO\W ULQLW \ RI%LEOH%DEHO
DQG ORZ OLIH SHRSOH

+RZ KDSS\ LQGHSHQGHQW  DQG KHDOW K\ P XVW  RXU DQFHVW RUV KDYH IHOW  DQG VRP H
SHRSOH VW LOO GR LQ RXU GD\V   :KHQ *\OIL YLVLW HG W KH $HVLU KH ORRNHG DURXQG LQ
:DOKDOO DQG ³ P XFK RI ZKDW  KH VDZ KH FRQVLGHUHG LQFUHGLEOH´  +H VW LOO KDG W KH
QRELOLW \ W R EH FDUHIXO  7KH *HUP DQ RI RXU GD\V LV JXOOLEOH DQG W KHUHIRUH QRW
QREOH ZLW KRXW  SRVW XUH UHVW UDLQW V DQG DW W LW XGH
 

*\OIL VSRNH
/RRN IRU W KH GRRUV DQG JDW HV
%H FDUHIXO EHIRUH \RX HQW HU
)RU D ORQJ W LP H DOUHDG\ SRVVLEO\
<RXU HQHP \ P D\ EH LQ DP EXVK LQ W KH KDOOZD\ RI W KH KRXVH

$QG W KH\ W UXO\ KDG D UHODW LRQVKLS RI W UXVW  RXU DQFHVW RUV DQG W KHLU JRGV   7KH
UHDVRQ EHLQJ DQG W KDW  LV D VHFUHW  W KDW  H[SODLQV LW  DOO W KDW  W KH\ ZHUH W KHLU JRGV
W KHP VHOYHV   +RZ  VD\V (NNHKDU G DQG *RHW KH DQG W KH &KHU XELQLF Z DQGHU HU "
5RXJKO\W KDW  ³ , I*RGZDVQRW ZLW KLQP \VHOIZKHUHHOVHFRXOGKHEH"´ &DQDW UXH
³ FKLOG RI *RG´  IHHO RW KHUZLVH"  'RHV KH QRW  KDYH KLV IDW KHU ¶V EORRG DQG VSLULW "
7KH W LP H LQ ZKLFK ZH DUH OLYLQJ LV D SLW LIXO RQH  , W  LV GHHSO\  EHORZ DOO IHW LVKLVP
DQG KRUULEOH LGRODW U\  LW  KDV D EXUHDXFUDW LF 'LYLQLW \ ZKLFK KDV DQ XQEHOLHYDEOH
VXSHUYLVLRQ RYHU DOO KRXVHV RI *RG RI DUP V RI M DLOV RI W KH SRRU RI M R\ KRXVHV
RI M R\   EURW KHOV  RI UHQW  RI ZDVK RI ILUH W UXFNV

7KH P HDQ VRXO RI W KH SUHVHQW  W KH ZKROH SK\VLFDO HP RW LRQDO DQG VSLULW XDO UDFH
RI VXEKXP DQV LV W KULYLQJ ZHOO XQGHU SURW HFW LRQ RI D &KULVW LDQ P RUDOLW \ RI VRXO
FRP P HUFH, W DOORZVW KHP W RIROORZXQVFUXSXORXVO\W KHLUP HDQHVW GULYHVSURW HFW HG
E\DKROORZJHVW XUHRIKXP DQHQHVV7KHEHW W HUEXW YHU\VP DOOUHP DLQGHURIRXU
VRFLHW \ Z KR U HIXVHV W R FRYHU  XS KLV DFW LRQV Z LW K W KH Z RU Q RXW  FRDW  RI VXFK
SULQFLSOHVKDVDKDUGW LP HXQGHUW KHSUHVVXUHRIW KHUXOLQJLP P RUDOLW \2QO\YHU\
IHZ W KH YHU\ VW URQJ RQHV DUH FDSDEOH RI W DNLQJ W KH FRQVHTXHQFHV DQG KDYH DOO
W KHLU DFW LRQV EDVHG RQ D FOHDU :HOW DQVFKDXXQJ

:H KDYH DOO RI RXU VRXO¶V VHDUFKLQJ DQG ILQGLQJ DOO RI RXU LQERUQ $U\DQ P RUDOV
W DFW  DQG QRELOLW \ W UDQVIHUUHG LQW R D VXSSRVHG ³ &KULVW LDQLW \´  DQG ZH EHOLHYH QRZ
W KDW  RXU VSLULW XDO DULVW RFUDF\ HYROYHG IURP  W KHUH HYHQ W KRXJK LW  LV P XFK ROGHU
:H ZHUH DOUHDG\ JRRG ³ &KULVW LDQV EHIRUH W KH FKXUFK P DGH XV W KH SUHVHQW  RI
&KULVW LDQLW \  4XLW H W KH FRQW UDU\ LV W UXH  7KH DQFLHQW  KLJKO\ QREOH SHRSOHV RI
(XURSH ORVW  W KHLU P RUDOV DV D UHVXOW  RI W KLV ³ &KULVW LDQLW \´

7KH &DW KROLF ELVKRS 6DOYDQLXV RI 0DU VHLOOHV D FRQW HP SRUDU \  RI W KH 9DQGDOV
ZULW HVLQKLVERRN³ 'H*XEHUQDW LRQH'HLOLE9, , ´  ³ 7KHUHLVQRYLUW XHLQZKLFKZH
5RP DQVDUHVXSHULRUW RW KH9DQGDOV:HORRNGRZQRQW KHP DVKHUHW LFVDQG\HW
W KH\ DUH VXSHULRU W R XV DV FRQFHUQV W KHLU IHDU RI *RG  *RW  SXW  W KH 9DQGDOV RYHU
XV LQ RUGHU W R SXQLVK W R W KH P RVW  LP P RUDO SHRSOHV E\ W KH P RVW  P RUDO RQHV
:KHUH W KH *RW KV DUH UXOLQJ QRERG\ LV LP P RUDO EHVLGHV W KH 5RP DQV EXW  ZKHUH
W KH 9DQGDOV DUH UXOLQJ HYHQ W KH 5RP DQV EHFDP H FKDVW H´

)DLW K LV QHYHU LP SRUW DQW  EXW  W KH KXP DQ EHLQJV DUH LP SRUW DQW   $ M XGJP HQW
DOZD\V VW DW HG ZLW K DP D]HP HQW  KRZ P XFK P RUH SLRXV DQG P RUDO W KH DQFLHQW
SHRSOHV Z HU H Z LW KRXW  W KH EOHVVLQJV RI &KU LVW LDQLW \ LV U HSHDW HG YHU \ RIW HQ LQ
KLVW RU\  6R RIW HQ LQ IDFW  W KDW  ZH FDQ FRQFOXGH W KDW  W KHVH SHRSOHV KDG VXFK D
 

KLJKOHYHORIDW W LW XGHDQGSRVW XUHEHFDXVHW KH\ZHUHQRW \HW FXUVHGE\&KULVW LDQ

ORY H   

$URXQG  W KH 1RUGLF &KURQLFOHU $GDP  YRQ %UHP HQ UHSRUW HG DP D]LQJ W KLQJV
FRQFHUQLQJW KHFRP P HUFLDOFLW \RI-XP QHRQW KHP RXW KRIW KH2GHU5LYHU+HDOVR
P DNHV D M XGJP HQW  FRQFHUQLQJ W KH JUHDW  YLUW XHV RI LW V LQKDELW DQW V W KDW  ZHUH QRW
\HW  FRQYHUW HG W R W KH &KULVW LDQ IDLW K

³ , QGHHGLW LVW KHODUJHVW RIDOOFLW LHVW KDW LVVXUURXQGHGE\(XURSH, QLW 6ODYVDUH

OLYLQJDQGRW KHUQDW LRQVDVZHOODV*UHHNVDQG%DUEDULDQV7KHDUULYLQJ6D[RQV
W RR DUH DOORZHG W R OLYH W KHUH DQG KDYH W KH VDP H ULJKW V DV W KH RW KHU SHRSOHV
SURYLGHGKRZHYHUW KDW W KH\GRQRW SXEOLFO\VKRZRIIW KHLU&KULVW LDQIDLW KDVORQJ
DV W KH\ DUH OLYLQJ W KHUH  %HFDXVH DOO SHRSOHV W KHUH DUH VW LOO FDXJKW  LQ W KH HUURU
RI SDJDQ LGRODW U\  2Q W KH RW KHU KDQG \RX ZLOO QRW  ILQG DQRW KHU SHRSOH W KDW  LV
P RUHQREOHDQGVHUYLFHDEOHDVIDUDVP RUDOVDQGKRVSLW DOLW \DU HFRQFHUQHG7KLV
FLW \ ZKLFK LV ULFK EHFDXVH RI LW V P HUFKDQGLVH IURP  DOO 1RUGLF SHRSOHV RIIHUV DOO
SRVVLEOH DP HQLW LHV DQG UDULW LHV´

7KLV VKRUW  UHSRUW  W HDFKHV XV D ORW  QDP HO\ W KDW  W KH ³ HUURU RI SDJDQ LGRODW U\´
NHHSVKXP DQVREYLRXVO\P RUHP RUDOW KDQ&KULVW LDQLW \&RQVHTXHQW O\W KDW LGRODW U\
VHHP VQRW W REHDVEDGDVW KHFRQYHUW HGDQGZURQJO\W KLQNLQJP DQIURP %UHP HQ
P HDQV  :H FDQ DOVR VHH W KDW  ZLW K &KULVW LDQLW \ W KH FRQYHUW HG SHUVRQ DVVXP HV
LP P HGLDW HO\ W KH DUURJDQFH RI D SHUVRQ ZKR W KLQNV W KDW  KH LV EHW W HU DQG NQRZV
EHW W HU LJQRULQJ W KH IDFW  RI KRZ TXHVW LRQDEOH DQ HIIHFW  &KULVW LDQLW \ KDG RQ LW V
IROORZ HU V

7KHQ W KH U HSRU W  VKRZ V W KDW  HY HQ Z LW KRXW  &KU LVW LDQ ³ FXOW XU H´  W KH 1RU W K KDG
VLJQLILFDQW  W UDIILF ZHDOW K FRP IRUW  DQG ODUJH FLW LHV  , W  DOVR VKRZV W KDW  D ODUJH
FLW \GRHVQRW QHFHVVDULO\OHDGW RFRUUXSW LRQRIKXP DQVDVZHVHHLQW KLVH[DP SOH
HYHQ W KRXJK ³ *UHHNV  DQG %DUEDULDQV´  OLYHG W KHUH DOW KRXJK LQ VP DOO QXP EHUV
P DLQO\ W R W UDGH LQ IXUV DQG DP EHU

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

(OHYDW LQJ LW  LV W R KHDU RI W KH W ROHUDQFH RI W KRVH ZKR ³ OLYHG LQ HUURU ´  $V ORQJ DV
W KH&KULVW LDQVGLGQRW KXUW W KHIHHOLQJVRIW KHVH³ KHDW KHQV´ E\ REYLRXVHP SKDVLV
RQ W KHLU  KDELW V DQG W KH U HTXLU HP HQW V RI W KHLU  IDLW K QRERG\  ERW KHU HG W KHP 
7KHUHIRUHW KHSHRSOHW KHUHVW RRGRQDKLJKHUOHYHOW KDQW KH&KU LVW LDQVZKRODW HU
³ IUHHG´ W KHW HUULW RU\IURP LW V³ HUURUV´ XVLQJILUHDQGP XUGHU'HVW UR\HGW KHVDQFW XDU\
RI $UNRQD RQ W KH LVODQG RI 5JHQ EXUQHG W KH ³ VDFUHG ERRNV´  DQG EURNH W KH
³ LGROV´ SXW W LQJ W KHLU RZQ W KHUH LQVW HDG

7RGHW HUP LQHLQVLJKW VDVEHLQJW KHVDP HIRUDOOKXP DQVDVXQFKDQJHDEOHDQGRI

HTXDO YDOXH KDV DOZD\V EHHQ D V\P SW RP  RI KXP DQ LGLRF\ DQG LW  VW LOO LV  ³ 6DP H
LV XQGHUVW RRG RQO\ E\ VDP H´    $OO FRQYHUVLRQ LV HUURQHRXV DOO ZLOO W R FRQYHUW  LV
ZHDNQHVV DOO IRUFHG FRQYHUVLRQ LV FULP H  &RQYHUVLRQ LV VW LOO DW W HP SW HG LQ RXU
GD\V  7KH W UDGLW LRQDO FUXHOW \ RI W KH SURFHVV LV ³ VSLULW XDOL]HG´  LQ RXU GD\V  <RX
KDYH W R VD\V W KHVXE KXP DQ \RXFDQVD\V W KH 0DQ  &HUW DLQO\ RQO\RQH¶VRZQ
ILQGLQJ OHDGV W R *RG  &KULVW LDQLW \ KDV QRW  SUHYHQW HG W KH 'DQHV ODW HU W R SOXQGHU
W KDW  FLW \ VHYHUDO W LP HV DQG W R GHVW UR\ LW  HYHQW XDOO\  :KHQ W KH &KULVW LDQ .LQJ
+DUROG %OXHW RRW K IRXJKW  KLV UHEHOOLRXV VRQ LQ D VHD EDW W OH FORVH W R W KH FLW \ RI
+HOHJQHV KH ZDV ZRXQGHG P RUW DOO\ DQG VRXJKW  UHIXJH IURP  LW V LQKDELW DQW V

$GDP YRQ%UHP HQUHSRUW VDERXW W KDW  ³$JDLQVW KLVH[SHFW DW LRQVVLQFHW KH\ZHUH

SDJDQV KH ZDV UHFHLYHG E\ W KHP  ZLW K D ORW  RI FRP SDVVLRQ´   7KH &KURQLFOHU ¶V
³ DJDLQVW  H[SHFW DW LRQV´  ZDV QRW  ZLW KRXW  UHDVRQ EHFDXVH W KH ORZHU RQH M XGJHV
W KHKLJKHURQHDFFRUGLQJW RKLP VHOIDQGGUDZVW KHZURQJFRQFOXVLRQVDVDUHVXOW 
$ SDJDQ NLQJ FHUW DLQO\ ZRXOG QRW  KDYH EHHQ FDUHG IRU LQ D &KULVW LDQ FLW \ EXW  KH
ZRXOGKDYHEHHQW RUW XUHGDQGEXUQHG&KULVW LDQLW \ZLOOEHFRP H ³ &KULVW LDQLW \´ LQ
W KH P HDQLQJ W KDW  ZH *RRG RQHV *RW KV JLYH LW  RQ W KH GD\ ZKHQ LW  VHHV LW VHOI
DV RQH RI W KH W KRXVDQGV RI SRVVLEOH ZRUOG YLHZV W KDW  FDQ EH HVW DEOLVKHG DQG
W KDW  LW  LQ QR ZD\ DW  W KH SHDN RI W KRVH W KRXVDQGV RI SRVVLELOLW LHV  2QO\ W KLV W \SH
RI KXP EOHQHVV ZKLFK LW  VR VW URQJO\ UHFRP P HQGV W R LW V IROORZHUV FDQ P DNH LW
ZRUW K\ RI KLV QDP H W KDW  LW  EOHP LVKHG E\ LW V RZQ JXLOW 

$ W UXH &KULVW LDQLW \ LV QHLW KHU E\ FKXUFK QRU E\ VW DW H  7KHUHIRUH LW  QHYHU ZDV
SUDFW LFHGDQ\ZKHUH$IHZKLJKO\JLIW HGP HQRI*RGKDYHXQGHUVW RRGDQGJUDVSHG
LW V W HDFKLQJV  $ IHZ SLRXV JRRG DQG EUDYH KXP DQ EHLQJV OLYH D ³ VXFFHVVLRQ RI
&KULVW ´  VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V  1DW XUDOO\ W KH\ FDQQRW  EH IRXQG DP RQJ W KH IROORZHUV RI
W KH YDULRXV &KULVW LDQ FRQIHVVLRQV  7KH -XGHR &DW KROLFLVP  DQG IROORZLQJ LW  W KH
-XGHR 3URW HVW DQW LVP KDVGHYRXUHGHYHU\W KLQJW KDW ZDVHVVHQW LDOW RW KHW HDFKLQJV
DQG VKRZ QRW KLQJ EXW  DQ HP SW \ KXOO

7KH\ DUH W KRVH ZKR DUH DORQH GRRP HG   7KH $U\DQ JRGV DQG W KHLU VRQV RI JRG
KDGQRUHDVRQIRULQW ROHUDQFH:KRLVIXOORIW KHVSLULW RI*RGZKRLVDQLP P RUW DO
*RW K KDV W R OHDYH LW  W R W KH P RUW DO KXP DQ W R ORRN XS W R KLP   2QO\ W KH UHOLJLRQV
RI -XGDLVP  &KU LVW LDQLW \  DQG , VODP  DU H LQW ROHU DQW  SU RVHO\ W L]LQ J VQRRSLQJ RI
KHUHW LFV DQG GUDJ GRZQ DOO W KDW  LV 'LYLQH LQW R W KHLU KXP DQL]DW LRQ RI W KH KLJKHVW
VHFUHW V E\ P HDQV RI IRUFHG GRJP DV LQ W KHLU P DNLQJ XQ EOHVVHG DORQH
 

, IFKXUFK&KULVW LDQLW \ZDVW KHUHDORQHDQGW KDW LVW KHHUURUXQGHUZKLFKSDVW RUV

DQGFKDSODLQVDUHVXIIHULQJW KHQW KHZRUOGDURXQGXVZRXOGORRNGLIIHUHQW LQRXU
GD\V  &KULVW LDQLW \ REYLRXVO\ ZDV LQFDSDEOH W R P DNH D EHW W HU ZRUOG EHFDXVH
ZRUOGDQGKXP DQVDUHP XFKZRUVHRIIUHJDUGOHVVRILW VOHDGHUVKLS7KHFKXUFKHV
KDGDW KRXVDQG\HDUVW LP H$W KRXVDQG\HDUVZHUHILOOHGZLW KZ DUDQGEORRGVKHG
W KDW  ZHUH FDXVHG E\ UHOLJLRXV ZDUV LQ W KH QDP H RI &KULVW    0DQ\ P DQ\ P LOOLRQV
RI ³ ZLW FKHV´  DQG ³ KHUHW LFV´ W KH P RVW  SXUH DQG SLRXV KXP DQV RI W KHLU W LP H W KH
FKXUFKKDVEXUQHGDORQHLQ*HUP DQ\³$W KHRORJLDQLVDQDQLP DOZLW KRXW UHDVRQ´
VDLG )U HGHU LFN W KH *U HDW  Z LW K Z DU QLQJ VFRU Q  6LQFH W KH FKXU FK LV QR ORQJHU
DOORZHGW REXUQW KH\XVHRW KHUP HDQVW RVXSSUHVVIUHHGRP RIFRQVFLHQFH7KH
VDOYDW LRQRIKXP DQNLQGKRZHYHUGRHVQRW GHSHQGRQW KHW KHRORJLDQVDQGFOHULFV
EXW  RQ W KH SXULW \ RI RXU VW ULYLQJ RU RXU VSLULW  DQG RI RXU EORRG  :KR LV VLW W LQJ
LQ W KH JODVV KRXVH RI W KH FKXUFK VKRXOG DYRLG W KURZLQJ URFNV DW  RW KHUV

7KHUHDUHP DQ\³ P HQRQW KHVW UHHW ´ ZKRKDYHP RUHUHOLJLRQLQW KHLUVP DOOILQJHU

W KDQ D FKDSODLQ RI D GRP H RQ KLV ZKROH ERG\  3ROLW LFV VSRLOV W KH FKDUDFW HU DQG
W KH FKXUFKHV GR HYHQ P RUH VR  2XU LQW HQW LRQV HP HUJH IURP  W KH SXUHVW  ZLOO DQG
W KH\DORQHDUH³ &KULVW LDQ´ DFFRUGLQJW RW KHXQIDOVLILHGW HDFKLQJVRIW KH³ +HOLDQG´
W KH6DYLRU  7KHFKXUFKHVVRZZLQGDQGW KH\ZDQW W RKDUYHVW VW RUP V:HKDYH
EHHQERUQEH\RQGW KDW DQGZHKDYHRXW JURZQLW 2XULQVLJKW VDERXW *RGDQGW KH
ZRUOGDUHEH\RQGW KHFKXUFKHVZKLFKDUHGDQJHURXVO\LP SHUIHFW P DFKLQDW LRQVRI
KXP DQV(YHU\\HDUW KHFKXUFKHVJHW HP SW LHU  6RP HUXQDZD\EHFDXVHW KH\
FDQQRW  ILQG VDW LVIDFW LRQ LQ W KHLU VHDUFK IRU *RG  2W KHUV UXQ DZD\ EHFDXVH W KH
FKXUFKHV FDQQRW  RIIHU VW DELOLW \ DQ\ P RUH QRW  HYHQ W R W KH SRRUHVW  LQ LQW HOOHFW 

7KH RSLQLRQ W KDW  *RG LV QRW  LQ W KRVH ZKR VHDUFK IRU KLP  RXW VLGH W KHP VHOYHV LV
TXLW H FRU U HFW    7KH Z KROH XQLY HU VH  L H  DOO W KDW  Z KLFK LV DQG Z KLFK VW LOO LV
HP HUJLQJ DQG W KDW  ZKLFK ZLOO EH LV *RG W KH ZRUP  DV ZHOO DV ³ &KULVW ´  +RZ FDQ
\RX &KULVW LDQV RU $GYHQW LVW V RU ZKDW HYHU \RX FDOO \RXUVHOYHV EH RI VXFK VP DOO
IDLW K W KDW  \RX DUH VDW LVILHG ZLW K D ³ ZRUOG´  RI D SXQ\  \HDU V RI KLVW RU\ RI
NQRZOHGJH RI *RG  7KHUHIRUH LQ RXU GD\V W KLV ³ ZRUOG´  DQG LW V KXP DQV DUH VR
SLW LIXO W KH\GRQRW KDYHW KHFRXUDJHW RHW HUQLW \P XFKOHVVW RHW HUQLW LHV$ERRN
W KDW  FRQVLVW V RI KRQHVW  DQG GLVKRQHVW  FRQW HQW V FROOHFW HG E\ W KH DQFLHQW  0LG
(DVW HUQ SHRSOHV IURP  W KH UXLQV RI QREOH ZLVGRP  RI 'LYLQH DQG $U \DQ EULQJHUV RI
W KH /LJKW  D ERRN W KDW  ZDV GLVW RUW HG DQG IDOVLILHG E\ (]UD DQG 1HKHP LDK ODW HU
SDW FKHG DJDLQ DOO W RJHW KHU D P XOW LFRORUHG JOLW W HU RI D W LP H W KDW  Z DV DOUHDG\
P DGHXQKRO\´  W KDW ERRN\RXFDOO³ W KHZRUGRI*RG´ DQG\RXGDUHW RH[SODLQZLW K
LW DOOW KHW KLQJVLQKHDYHQDQGRQ(DUW K  7R\RX\RXZKRDUHVW DQGLQJVSHHFKOHVV
DQGGXP EIDFLQJW KHVHOHW W HUVW KLVOLHEHFDP HDSUREOHP 7KHU HLVQRW KLQJW KDW
KDVEURXJKW DVP XFKFULP HDQGGHDW KRYHUW KH(DUW KW KDQW KHUHOLJLRQVW KDW ZHUH
EDVHGRQW KLVERRNRIZKLFKRQHFDOOVLW VHOIW KHUHOLJLRQRIU HYHQJHDQGW KHRW KHU
FDOOV LW VHOI W KH UHOLJLRQ RI ORYH


7KH³ +HOLDQG´  P RGHUQ*HUP DQ +HLODQG VDYLRU ZDVDQHSLFLQROG*HUP DQGHVFULELQJW KH
OLIHRIW KH³ VDYLRU´ JORULILHGDVLIKHZDVD*HUP DQLFP LOLW DU \OHDGHU
 2PLWWHG

 

7KH NQRZOHGJHDEOH SHUVRQ ZKR IUHHG KLP VHOI HQW LUHO\ IURP  W KDW  ERRN LV FDSDEOH
W R GLVFHUQ LQ W KLV ERRN W KH JRRG P DW HULDO IURP  W KH SRLVRQ ZLW K W KH VSLULW  RI W KH
SXUHVW W UXW K, QW KHKDQGVRIW KHJXOOLEOHW KLVERRNLVDP XUGHURXVZHDSRQW KDW
FDXVHV SK\VLFDO DQG LQW HOOHFW XDO GHDW K W R KXP DQV DV W KH KLVW RU \ RI W KH SDVW
\HDUVKDVSURYHQ+XP DQLW \LVRQLW VEHVW ZD\W RW RW DOO\W XUQLQW RDQLP DOV
EHFDXVH W KH UHSUHVHQW DW LYHV RI VXE KXP DQLW \ FODLP  W KDW  W KH\ KDY H IRXQG W KH
W UXW K RI DOO W LP HV DQG IRU DOO W LP HV LQ D ERRN LQ D SLW LIXO ZRUN RI KXP DQV  6XFK
D KRU U LEOH P LVW DN H KDV EU RXJKW  P HQW DO GLVHDVH W R KXP DQV DQG LQGHHG W KH\
GHVW UR\ HDFK RW KHU LQ W KH QDP H RI W KLV LGRO

7KH ³ 2OG 7HVW DP HQW ´  LV D IRUJHU\ VLQFH LW  LV QRW  W KH ³ UHYHODW LRQ RI *RG´  IRU W KH
VDFUHG SHRSOH EXW  D FROOHFW LRQ RI P DQ\ VHFW LRQV RI JRRG DQG EDG ROG DQG QHZ
ZURQJ DQG FRUUHFW  W UDGLW LRQV DQG KLVW RU\    , Q SDUW  LW  FRQW DLQV GRFXP HQW V W KDW
UHDFKEDFNW RW LP HVZKLFKZHFDQEDUHO\LP DJLQH7KH2OG7HVW DP HQW LVHYHU\W KLQJ
EXW VSLULW XDOSURSHUW \RIW KH³ -HZV´+HUHZHP HDQE\³ -HZV´ QRW ³ W KH-HZV´EXW
W KRVH -HZV *RRG RQHV *RW KV IRU W KH ORFDW LRQ RI ZKRVH RULJLQDO KRP HV LQ W KH
1RUW KZHKDYHSRLQW HUVLQW KHQDP HVRI-XW ODQGDQG*RW ODQG+HUHZHDOVRKDYH
W R LJQRU H W KH LQVHU W LRQV DQG U H Z RU N HG SDVVDJHV W KDW  W KH ERU U RZ LQJ VFU LEHV
SHUIRUP HG DOUHDG\ D ORQJ W LP H EHIRUH ³ &KULVW ´ LQ RUGHU W R JLYH W KH ZKROH W KH
DSSHDUDQFH RI D XQLIRUP  ³ -HZLVK´  W UDGLW LRQ

7KH 2OG 7HVW DP HQW  LV D ZRUN RI SKLORVRSKLFDO LQVLJKW JLYLQJ DQG D KLVW RULFDO
YDOXH W KDW  LV FULW LFDO RI LQVLJKW V  , W  EHORQJV LQ W KH KDQGV RI W KH VFKRODU W KH W UXH
ERUQ SULHVW  RU NLQJ DQG QRW  LQ W KH KDQGV RI FKXUFK VHUYDQW V DQG FKXUFK JRHUV
EHOLHYHUV DQG QRQ EHOLHYHUV RI RXU W LP HV  :LW K W KH H[FHSW LRQ RI SXQ\ OHIW RYHUV
RI VLP SOH DQG VHOI HYLGHQW  FRQW HQW  LW  LV D VHFUHW  ERRN D ERRN RI SUH P HGLW DW HG
.DOD &DEEDOD LH ZKHUH W KH DFW XDO FRQW HQW  ZDV KLGGHQ EHQHDW K W KH FRYHU RI
LP DJ HV DQ G  Z RU G V   2I  FRX U VH Z H K DY H DOVR W R FRQ VLG HU  LQ W HQ W LRQ DO DQ G
XQLQW HQW LRQDO GHVW UXFW LRQ  7KHUHIRUH QRERG\ ZLW K UHDVRQ LV FDSDEOH W R UHDG LW 
XQOHVV KH KDV W KH VNLOO RI LQW XLW LRQ DQG KH LV LQLW LDW HG LQW R P DQ\ EUDQFKHV RI
NQRZOHGJH VXFK DV ODQJXDJH KLVW RU\ SKLORVRSK\ W KHRVRSK\ V\P EROLVP V DQG
P \W KRORJ\  )RUFHQW XULHVW KLVERRNLVW KHFXUVHRIW KH(XURSHDQKXP DQLW \W KDW
FDOOV LW VHOI HLW KHU &KULVW LDQ RU -HZLVK DQG QRW  W KH EOHVVLQJ  7KH -HZV DUH VW LOO
P RUH OLNHO\ W R KDYH DQ LGHD RI LW V HVVHQFH  (YHQ LI W KH\ VKRXOG QRW  IHHO HQW LUHO\
LQQRFHQW DVW RW KHIRUJHU\RILW  W KH5DEELVDW OHDVW NQRZVW LOOLQSDUW KRZW RXVH

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

LW VUHDGLQJLW VVROXW LRQ RIW KHHQLJP D  %XW ³ &KULVW LDQV´ ZLW KW KHLU³ &KULVW LDQLW \´
IDLOHG ZLW K W KLV ERRN LW V ROG SDUW  W KDW  W KH\ FRXOG QRW  XQGHUVW DQG DQG W KH QHZ
RQH  7KH\ ³ VKLSZUHFNHG´  ZLW K LW  DQG SHULVKHG  $ UHOLJLRQ W KDW  LV EXLOW  LQ SDUW
XSRQIRUJHULHVDQGLQSDUW XSRQFRQW HQW VW KDW DUHQRW \HW XQGHU VW RRGRUFRQVFLRXV
LV ERXQG W R GLVW XUE W KH RULJLQDO DQG LP P HGLDW H LQVLJKW V LQW R W KH 'LYLQH LW  LV
ERXQG W R GLVW XUE DQ\ FHUW DLQW \ DV IDU DV IDLW K NQRZOHGJH DFW LRQ DQG DYRLGDQFH
DUH FRQFHUQHG  7KH (XURSHDQ RI RXU GD\V LV W KH P RVW  FDVW  RXW  VRQ RI RXU (DUW K
U HJDU GOHVV RI KLV RXW VW DQGLQJ W DOHQW V DQG REY LRXV FDOOLQJ IRU  OHDGHU VKLS  $Q
HQRUP RXV JXLOW  LV JURZLQJ IRU KLP  W KDW  RSSUHVVHV W KH IDW H RI (XURSH DV D ZKROH
DQG RI HYHU\ LQGLYLGXDO SHUVRQ EHFDXVH KLV RYHUZKHOP LQJ GLVW DQFH IURP  *RG LV
DW  RGGV ZLW K KLV GLYLQH ELUW K DQG KLV GLYLQH *RW KLF FDOOLQJ

/XW KHU ¶V W UDQVODW LRQ LQFUHDVHG W KLV ZURQJ ORRN ZLW KRXW  KLV LQW HQW LRQ EHFDXVH KH
XVHG D FRXSOH RI FROOHFW LY H QDP HV VXFK DV ³ *RG W KH /RU G´  RU  ³ -HKRY DK´  W R
W UDQVODW H W KH P DQ\ GLIIHUHQW  JRRG DQG EDG JRGV DQG ZRUGV W KDW  GHVFULEH *RG
2EYLRXVO\KHZDVQRW DZDUHW KDW KHKDGW RGRZLW KP RUHW KDQDGR]HQRIYDULRXV
FRQFHSW V RI *RG DQG JRGV W KDW  RULJLQDW HG LQ GLIIHUHQW  W LP HV DQG SHRSOHV  +H
P HDQW  W R GR W KH EHVW  EXW  XOW LP DW HO\ KH VROLGLILHG OLH DQG FRQIXVLRQ  7KLV ZDV
W KH FDVH EHFDXVH LW  ZDV /XW KHU ¶V ZRUN W KDW  EURXJKW  W KLV ERRN W R W KH FRP P RQ
SHRSOH7KHLJQRUDQFHRILW VHVVHQFHGHVW UR\HGHYHQIXUW KHUW KHVRXOVRIKXP DQV
LQ D GDUN IDLW K LQ W KH %LEOH  7KLV KDSSHQHG HVSHFLDOO\ LQ 3URW HVW DQW LVP  W KDW  SXW
W KH ³ ERRN RI ERRNV´  DERYH HYHU\W KLQJ DQG EHOLHYHG W R EH FDSDEOH RI H[SODLQLQJ
HYHU\W KLQJ ZLW K W KLV ERRN  , Q W KH YDULRXV SURW HVW DQW  VHFW V LW  GHJHQHUDW HG LQW R
%LEOH EHOLHYLQJ OXQDF\  2QH RI W KH W KUHH M XJJOLQJ SRZHUV KDV P DGH XVH RI W KDW
LOOQHVV RI KHDOW K\  FRP P RQVHQVH DQG W KH N LOOLQJ RI DOO W U XH H[ SHU LHQFH RI W KH
GLYLQH  $V ³ %LEOH UHVHDUFK´  VRFLHW LHV  W KH\ SXUSRVHO\ FRQW LQXHG W KH GHVW UXFW LYH
ZRUNRIZKLFKW KHFOHULFDOZRUG SLFNHUVGLGQRW FRQVFLHQW LRXVO\ P RVW RIW KHW LP H
DQGP XFKOHVVVNLOOIXOO\³ 3URSKHFLHV´ DUHFRQW DLQHGLQW KH³ +RO\VFULSW XUHV´EXW
W KH\GRQRW IRUHVHHW KHQHZHUDRIW KH³ -HZV´EXW RIW KH³ -XW HV´W KHJRRGRQHV
W KH *RW KV W KH *RG HP SLUH RQ (DUW K ZKHUH W KH EHVW  DUH UXOLQJ QRW  W KH EHDVW V

+HUHRQO\W KHRQHJUHDW ZRUGRIZLVGRP KHOSVJHW ULGRIVXFKGHYLO¶VVSRRNZLW K

RQH VHQW HQFH   *RG LV VSLULW  DQG W KRVH ZKR ZRUVKLS KLP  VKRXOG ZRUVKLS KLP  LQ
VSLULW  DQG LQ W UXW K

7KH JRVSHOV W RR DUH IRUJHG DQG LW  LV XQW UXW KIXO W R FODLP  W KDW  W KH\ FRQW DLQHG W KH
SXUHW HDFKLQJVRID6DYLRURU³ -HVXV&KULVW ´:HKDYHP RUHW KDQP DQXVFULSW V

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

/HVXQJXQG/|VXQJVLP LODUVRXQGLQJZRUGV

, DP QRW VRVXUHLIKHUHIHUVKHUHW RW KH³ ZLW QHVVHVRI-HKRYDK´ ZKRFDOOW KHP VHOYHVW KH
³ %LEHOIRUVFKHU´ LQ*HUP DQ
 

RIJRVSHOVIURP DERXW W KHW KFHQW XU\$', IZHDGGW RW KLVW KHIUDJP HQW VDQG
VLQJOH W UDGLW LRQV ZH JHW  W KH KLJK QXP EHU RI RYHU     1RW  W ZR RI W KHVH
P DQXVFULSW V DUH LQ DJUHHP HQW  ZLW K HDFK RW KHU  $ FODULILFDW LRQ RI W KHVH ZLOGO\
FRQIXVHG W H[ W V LV W KHU HIRU H M XVW  D W KLQJ RI LQVLJKW  DQG W U XVW    1RW  D VLQJOH
H\HZLW QHVVUHSRUW VDERXW W KHDVVXP HGOLIHDQGW HDFKLQJVRIW KHVDYLRULQ3DOHVW LQH
7KH ILUVW  ZULW W HQ UHSRUW V DSSHDU DW  OHDVW   \HDUV ODW HU  $IW HU  \HDUV LI ZH
DFFHSW  W KH W LP LQJ RI D ³ ELUW K´  DW  DOO D ORW  RI W KLQJV FDQ EH DGGHG HLW KHU ZHOO
P HDQLQJ RU ZLW K W KH LQW HQW  W R IDOVLI\  , I ZH ZDQW  W R EH KRQHVW  ZH KDYH W R VD\
W KDW  W KH JRVSHOV DUH SLHFHP HDO DQG KXP DQ GRLQJ HVSHFLDOO\ LI P HDVXUHG RQ W KH
SXUHW UXW KDQGJUHDW QHVVRIW KHLGHDRIW KH³ &KULVW ´2QO\DGP LW W LQJW KDW FDQJLYH
W R KRQHVW  VW ULYLQJ W R H[DP LQH W KH RULJLQV RI W KHVH W H[W V W KH SRZHU FRXUDJH DQG
LQVLJKW V   W H[W V ZKRVH RULJLQV ZH FDQQRW  VHDUFK LQ 3DOHVW LQH  6RP H ³$SRVW OH
3DXO´  KDV W ZLVW HG DURXQG FRP SOHW HO\ W KH SXUH P HVVDJH RI W KH ³ &KULVW ´  :LW K
W KLVW KH3URW HVW DQW FKXUFKW KDW LVHQW LUHO\EDVHGRQKLVDFW LYLW \DQGLQW HUSUHW DW LRQ
LVVOLGLQJGRZQDVORSHZLW KRXW KRSHIRUVDOYDW LRQ(YHU\KXP DQFDQXQGHUVW DQG
W KLQJV RQO\ W R W KH H[W HQW  DV KH LV FORVH W R *RG

)LQDOO\ D ZRUG DERXW  W KH YHU\ GDQJHURXV GRJP D RI D ³ SHUVRQDO *RG´ W KH ³ JRRG
*RGLQW KH+HDYHQ´DQLQFRP SOHW HFRQFHSW W KDW LVLQFRQW UDGLFW LRQZLW KW KHJUDYH
ZRUGVRIW KHDQRLQW HGRQH ³ *RGLVVSLULW DQGZKRZRUVKLSVKLP VKRXOGGRVRLQ
VSLULW  DQG LQ W UXW K´   %XW  LI *RG  VSLULW  KDV FUHDW HG W KH ZRUOG ³ 'DV´  *RW W  VDLG
W KH *RW KV ZKRVH QDP H LV GHULYHG IURP  *RG DQG ZKR W KHUHIRUH NQRZV EHW W HU
W KDQ W KH ³ KXP DQV´  LQ DQ XQKHDUG RI FODULW \ RI UHYHDOHG LQVLJKW  DQG ZLVGRP  LI
*RG  VSLULW KDVFUHDW HGW KHZRUOGW KHQW KLV ZRUOG LVSDUW  RI *RG DQG HYHQ W KH
1RW KLQJZRXOGEH*RGDQGKHKDVFUHDW HGW KHZRUOGRXW RIW KHQRW KLQJEHFDXVH
W KHUH LV DQG ZDV QRW KLQJ EHVLGHV *RG  W KHUHIRUH LI *RG  VSLULW  W KHQ VSLULW  DQG
P DW W HU DUH RQH W KH\ DUH W KH ZRUOG W KDW  LV DQ RXW SRXULQJ D VW UHDP  IURP  *RG
6W LOO W KH DQFLHQW  FKXUFK IDW KHUV NQHZ RI W KLV EXW  W KH FKDSODLQV RI RXU GD\V DUH
LJQRUDQW  RI LW 

6W LOO W KH &KXUFK IDW KHU 7HUW XOOLDQ NQHZ RI W KH RULJLQ RI W KH 8U UHOLJLRQ IURP  W KH
$U\DQ V\P EROLVP V ZKHQ KH ZURW H  ³ 0DQ\ EHOLHYH W KDW  RXU ZRUVKLS LV D ZRUVKLS
RI W KH 6XQ´  

6DLQW  $XJXVW LQH DGP LW W HG VW LOO DURXQG W KH \HDU 

³ 7KDW ZKLFKLVFDOOHG³ &KULVW LDQUHOLJLRQ´ E\QRZH[LVW HGDOU HDG\ZLW KW KHDQFLHQW V

DQGLW ZDVDOZD\VSUHVHQW IURP W KHEHJLQQLQJRIKXP DQNLQGXQW LO-HVXVEHFDP H
IOHVK LQ W KH VHFUHW  ODQJXDJH W KDW  P HDQV ³ XQW LO KH ZDV UHLQFDU QDW HG´   7KHQ
SHRSOHEHJDQW RFDOOW KHW UXHUHOLJLRQW KDW H[LVW HGDOUHDG\DW DOOW LP HV³ &KULVW LDQ´  

+HUH ZH KDYH SURRI RI RXU FODLP  W KDW  W KH &KULVW LDQ FKXUFKHV GHY LDW HG IURP  W KLV
KLJK ZLVGRP  XQGHU W KH LQIOX[ RI GHDGO\ VXE KXP DQ FRQFHSW V IURP  W KH P RXW K RI

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

W KH P RVW  LP SRUW DQW  FKXUFK IDW KHU RQ W KH W HDFKLQJV RI ZKLFK W KH W KUHH &KULVW LDQ
FKXUFKHV DUH EDVHG    -XVW LILDEO\ ZH UHM HFW  D &KULVW LDQLW \ RI W KH FKXUFKHV W KDW
ZDV UHYHUVHG LQW R LW V RSSRVLW H  :H IHHO W KDW  LW  LV RXU GXW \ W R LQW HUYHQH LQ D
KHDOLQJ DQG LP SURYLQJ P DQQHU  :H GR VR EHLQJ SHQHW UDW HG E\ W KH GHHSHVW
FRQVFLRXVQHVV W KDW  RXU LQVLJKW  SURYLGHV XV  QDP HO\ W KDW  ³ QR FKXUFK LV KLJKHU
W KDQ W UXW K´  

7KH KXP DQ EHLQJ JHUP LQDW HV IURP  *RG LQ W KH P DQQHU DV KH LV RI 'LYLQH NLQG
KLP VHOI  7KH $U\DQ UHFRJQL]HV *RG DV W KH P HDQLQJ RI W KH Z RUOG  *RG W R KLP  LV
QHFHVVLW \ KLJKHVW  VW ULYLQJ EHQHYROHQW  IDW KHU RI DOO VSLULW V DQG KXP DQV IXOILOOHU
RIIDW HHQFRP SDVVLQJW KDW ZKLFKLVKLJKHUDQGORZHULQFOXGLQJ W KHZRUOGDFW LQJ
EDFN XSRQ W KH ZRUOG IURP  KLP VHOI  7KH $U\DQ KDV QR OLP LW DW LRQ LQ KLV IDLW K
EHFDXVHKHUHFRJQL]HV*RGLQKLP VHOIDQGKLP VHOIEHLQJRI'LYLQHVKDSH*RGLV
W KHP HDVXUHRIKLVEHLQJ+HNQRZVZLW KXQVKDNHDEOHFHUW DLQW \RIKLVEHLQJW KH
6RQRI*RGDQGVP LOHVDW W KHW KRXJKW W KDW *RG³ &KULVW ´EHFDP HKXP DQDP RQJ
W KH -HZV ZKLFK W R KLP  LV D FRQFHSW  W KDW  RULJLQDW HG LQ IRROLVK DQG HUURQHRXV
W KLQNLQJ  +HUH SHRSOH KDYH KHDUG ZURQJ XQGHUVW RRG ZURQJO\ KDQGHG GRZQ
LQFRUUHFW O\  $ -HVXV &KLOG DQ $VXV &KLOG   EHFRP HV NLQJ HYHU\ GD\ DP RQJ W KH
³ JRRGRQHV´W KH*RW KV+HFDUULHVDQLQYLVLEOHFURZQW KDW UDGLDW HGDKDOR7KH
SHU VRQ Z KR IROORZ V KLV LQY LVLEOH IRRW VW HSV RQO\  VHHV FU RZ Q DQG KDOR  7R DOO
RW KHUV KH DSSHDUV RQO\ DV D EHJJDU D YDJDERQG D VHGLW LRQLVW  D EODVSKHP RXV
SHUVRQ HVSHFLDOO\W KHODW W HURQH 7KH\³ FUXFLI\´ KLP IRUHYHUDQGHYHULIKHZDQW V
W R VHUYH W KHP 

7KHFKXUFKHVRIRXUGD\VKDYHW RDOORZVSDFHIRUW KHNLQJGRP RIW KH*RRGRQHV

RI W KH *RW KV IRU W KH NLQJGRP  RI *RG RQ (DUW K ZKLFK FDQ RQO\ P DW HULDOL]H E\
P HDQV RI W KH NLQJGRP  RI KLV ³ ZLVKHG VRQV´ E\ W KH $U\DQ OHDGHUVKLS

7KHUHIRUH OHW  W KH FKXUFK VLQN

/LNH D VKLS ZLW K P DQ DQG P RXVH
:KDW  LV QRW  VSLULW  LQ LW  P XVW  GURZQ
1HZ LQ W KH *RW K *RG EXLOGV KLV KRXVH

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 

5DU HO\  FDQ Z H ILQG DQ DSSU RSU LDW H FRQFHSW  RI W KH KLJK VSLU LW XDOLW \  DQG GHHS
LQVLJKW V DERXW  *RG RI W KH VR FDOOHG KHU HW LFV DIW HU  W KH IRU JLQJ U HSRU W V RI W KH
FKXUFKZKLFKDOZD\VDW W HP SW HGW RGHVFULEHW KHP DVXQLQW HOOLJHQW DQGJRG OHVV
7KHFRQW UDU\LVW KHFDVH7KHFRQIHVVLRQVRIW KRVHSHRSOHZKRZHUHFRQGHP QHG
W R D SDLQIXO GHDW K DV ZHOO DV W KH W HDFKLQJV RI W KHVH JURXSV RI GLYLQHO\ LQVSLUHG
VHHNHUV RI W UXW K W R ZKRP  W KH\ EHORQJHG ZKLFK ZHUH ZLGH VSUHDG DQG QHYHU
FRXOG EH VXSSUHVVHG HQW LUHO\ VSHDN D FOHDU ODQJXDJH  :H VHH KHUH W KDW  LQ RXU
DUHDW KHW UDGLW LRQDONQRZOHGJHRIVRP HW KLQJKLJKHUW KDQZKDW W KHH[LVW LQJGRJP DV
Z HU H FDSDEOH RI W HDFKLQJ ZDV QHYHU  LQW HU U XSW HG HQW LU HO\  :H P DNH DQRW KHU
FRQFOXVLRQ IURP  W KH P DQLIHVW DW LRQV RI W KHVH W UXH P DUW \UV IRU D W UXH &KULVW LDQLW \
LQW KHP HDQLQJRI$U\DQFRQFHSW V7KH\DOVRVW RRGXSIRUSXUH EUHHGLQJDQGXS
EU HHGLQ J RI W K H U DFH DW  W K H VDP H W LP H   7K HU HIRU H W K H\  IRX Q G HY HQ  P RU H
XQFRP SURP LVLQJ RSSRQHQW V LQ D UHOLJLRQ W KDW  SURP RW HV RXW  EUHHGLQJ DQG QRQ
EUHHGLQJE\UHQRXQFLQJOLIH0LVOHDGHP SHURUVDQGNLQJVZKRVHKHDOW K\LQVW LQFW V
EHFDP H LP SRYHULVKHG ERDVW HG W KDW  W KH\ KDYH ³ IUHHG´  W KHLU FRXQW ULHV IURP  W KH
³ SODJXH´  RI W KH ³ KHUHW LFV´  E\ P HDQV RI LQQXP HUDEOH P XUGHUV DQG DOO W KDW  E\
RUGHU RI W KH FKXUFK  , Q W KHLU EOLQGQHVV W KH\ IUHHG W KHP VHOYHV IURP  W KH RQO\
KHOSHUV W KDW  FRXOG KDYH SURW HFW HG W KHP  IURP  W KH UXVHV RI W KRVH SRZHUV W KDW
Z HU H KRVW LOH W R DOO OLIH  7KHU HIRU H OLN H W KHLU  QDW XU DO DOOLHV W KDW  W KH\  KHOSHG
GHVW UR\ EHIRUH W KH\ VXFFXP EHG DV VRRQ DV W KH\ ZHUH H[SRVHG W R W KHVH SRZHUV
ZLW KRXW  DQ\ SURW HFW LRQ OHIW 

/HW ¶VORRNDW DQH[DP SOHEULHIO\, QDFRQW HP SRUDU\FOHULFDOUHSRUW DERXW W KHVHFW

RI W KH :DOGHQVLDQV ZKLFK ZDV D UHP DLQGHU RI *HUP DQLF FORVHQHVV W R *RG RI
%XUJXQGLDQ EORRG RQ W KH VRLO RI )UDQFH ZH DUH UHDGLQJ W KH IROORZLQJ

³ 7KHU H DU H VW LOO RW KHU  KHU HW LFV LQ RXU  FRXQW U \  W KDW  GLIIHU  IU RP  W KRVH HQW LU HO\
%HFDXVH RI W KHLU SROHP LFV Z H GLVFRYHUHG ERW K GLUHFW LRQV  7KH\ FRQGHP Q DOO
VDFUDP HQW V EHVLGHV EDSW LVP 

7KLVLVW \SLFDOIRUW KH*HUP DQLFDW W LW XGHEHFDXVHEDSW LVP LVD*HUP DQLFFXVW RP 

)XUW KHU ³$OOP DUULDJHW KH\FRQVLGHUZKRULQJH[FHSW EHW ZHHQDQXQW RXFKHGP DQ

DQG D YLUJLQ´

7KH\DSSDUHQW O\FRQW LQXHZLW KW KHEUHHGLQJJRDOVRIYDULRXVNQLJKW O\RUGHUVDQG

W KH\ ZHUH NQRZOHGJHDEOH RI W KH UDFLDO ODZ RI LP SUHJQDW LRQ  

³ )DVW LQJ DQG RW KHU SUDFW LFHV RI UHSHQW DQFH IRU W KH SXUSRVH LI DW RQHP HQW  W KH\
FRQVLGHU  XQQHFHVVDU \  IRU  U LJKW HRXV RQHV     /LN HZ LVH  W KH\  FRQVLGHU  LW  DOVR
XQQHFHVVDU\IRUVLQQHUVEHFDXVHW KHVLQQHUP RDQVDQ\ZD\HYHU\ GD\EHFDXVH
KLV VLQV IDOO EDFN W R KLP ´   7KH UHFRJQLW LRQ RI W KH ODZ RI NDUP D JDYH W KHQ VXFK
HOHY DW HG M XGJP HQW  DQG LW  LV VRP HZ KDW  VXU SU LVLQJ EXW  DOVR W \ SLFDO W KDW  W KH


2PLWWHG
 

FKXUFKEXUQHGVXFKSRW HQW LDOSLOODUVLQVW HDGRIJLYLQJW KHP ELVKRS VHDW V 7KHQ

ZH ZRXOG EH D FRP P XQLW \ RI VDLQW V W RGD\ DQG D VSOLW  RI EHOLHIV ZRXOG QRW  KDYH
KDSSHQHG

³ 7KH\ UHM HFW  W KH SRSH LQ 5RP H EXW  W KH\ GR QRW  DGP LW  W R KDYH DQRW KHU RQH´

+DYLQJ QR SRSH VHHP V LP SRVVLEOH W R W KH UHSRUW HU EHFDXVH KH LV XQDEOH W R W KLQN
KLP VHOILQW RW KH³ IUHHGRP RID&KULVW LDQ´ DFFRUGLQJW R*HUP DQLFLGHDOV+HDGGV
W KDW W KH\DUHVSUHDGLQJUHDW QXP EHUVW KURXJKRXW DOOFRXQW ULHVDQGW KDW QXP HURXV
P RQNV DQG FOHULFV ZHUH DP RQJ W KHP   :H VW LOO NQRZ UHODW LYHO\ OLW W OH DERXW  W KH
UHOLJLRXVVLW XDW LRQGXULQJW KHP LGGOHDJHV2QHVLGHRIW KHP LGGOHDJHVZDVQRW
DV GDUN DV XVXDOO\ SDLQW HG  7KH ELVKRS RI 6W UDVERXUJ -RKDQQ Y RQ 2FKVHQVW HLQ
UHSHDW V LQ RQH RI KLV OHW W HUV D IHZ VHQW HQFHV IURP  W KH W HDFKLQJV RI W KH KHUHW LFV
RQ W KH XSSHU 5KLQH 5LYHU  5HDGLQJ W KRVH ZH DUH DP D]HG W KDW  VXFK LGHDV FRXOG
EH SURVHFXW HG LQ W KH QDP H RI &KULVW LDQLW \   ³ &KULVW  KDV QRW  VXIIHUHG IRU XV EXW
IRU KLP VHOI´   $Q XQXVXDO KHLJKW  RI NQRZOHGJH   :H FDQ UHGHHP  RXUVHOYHV

³ (DFK KXP DQ EHLQJ FDQ VXUSDVV &KULVW  LQ P HULW ´   7KH\ KDYH SURY HQ LW  E\ W KH
P LVVLRQVZLW KW KHLUDFW LRQVW KDW W KH\DOORZHGW REHFUXFLILHGVDFULILFHGIRUW KHLU
NQRZOHGJHQRW M XVW IRUW KHLUIDLW K, QIDFW W KH\KDGW RVXIIHUP XFKZRUVHKRUURUV
DW  W KH KDQGV RI W KHLU  SLRXV H[ HFXW LRQHU V   ³ 1RW KLQJ VKRXOG EH GRQH IRU  W KH
SXUSRVH RI UHZDUG QRW  HYHQ IRU W KH SXUSRVH RI HW HUQDO EOLVV´

³ 7KH\EHOLHYHW KDW W KH&DW KROLF&KXUFKLVDIRROLVKW KLQJ´ ³$OOP DULW DOLQW HUFRXUVH

LV VLQ ZLW K W KH H[FHSW LRQ RI W KDW  ZKLFK VHUYHV SURFUHDW LRQ´   +HUH W RR W KH\ EUHG
IRU UDFH     7KXV W KLV ³ KHUHV\´  SURYHV W R EH DQ KHLU RI W KH DQFLHQW  GRFW ULQH RI
EUHHGLQJLQLW VIXOOHVW , W LVW KHKHLURIDFRUUHFW O\XQGHUVW RRGUHOLJLRQRIW KHVRODU
VSLULW ZKLFKLVDVZHOOW KHSXUHW HDFKLQJRIW KH6RQRI*RG ³ 7KHUHLVQRKHOORI
SXUJDW RU\´  LQDQ\RW KHUSODFHW KDQZLW KLQRQHVHOIW KHELVKRSFRXOGKDYHDGGHG
LI KH KDG EHHQ ZHOO LQVW UXFW HG DERXW  W KH H[DOW HG GRFW ULQH RI W KHVH KHUHW LFV

³ +XP DQV KDYH W R IROORZ P RUH W KH LQVLJKW V RI W KHLU KHDUW V W KDQ W KH W HDFKLQJV RI
W KH JRVSHOV´   $ P RUDO SULQFLSOH RI KLJKHVW  ZLVGRP  EHFDXVH W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ
GRHV QRW  EHFRP H D VDLQW  E\ ERRNV DQG IDLW K EXW  E\ LQVLJKW V DQG DFW LRQ


 6HQNUHFKW H JH UHFKW VHQN UHFKW Z RUGSOD\Z LW KP RGHUQ*HUP DQZ RUGVE\SXW W LQJW KLVLQ
SDUDQW KHVHVQH[W W RW KH³ ULJKW HRXV´ RQHV6HQNUHFKW P HDQVYHUW LFDOVRKHFRQVLGHUVW KH
ULJKW HRXVSHUVRQ³ YHUW LFDO´ 
 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG


2PLWWHG
 

³ 6RP HDP RQJW KHP FDQZULW HEHW W HUERRNVW KDQDOORIW KHVFULSW XUHVRIW KHFKXUFK
W DNHQW RJHW KHUHYHQLIW KH\ZHUHGHVW UR\HG´ $FRQFHVVLRQW RW KHKHUHW LFVW KDW
W KH\ RZH W KHLU KLJKHU LQVLJKW V W R W KHLU RZQ YHUEDO DQG ZULW W HQ W UDGLW LRQV  , W  LV
FOHDUW KDW W KHNQRZOHGJHRIW KHROGEXLOGLQJJXLOGVDQGRIRW KHUVRFLHW LHVW ULFNOHV
GRZQ ZKLFK TXLHW O\ W RRN W KH SXUH W HDFKLQJ LQW R W KH KLJK VHFUHW  DW W HQW LRQ  2XW
RI W KLV VSLULW  W KH P DJQLILFHQW  FDW KHGUDOV HP HUJHG W KH P XVLF W KH SRHW U\ W KH
P \VW LFLVP  RI W KH P HGLHYDO W LP HV  $OO W KHVH W KLQJV FHUW DLQO\ ZHUH QRW  DFKLHYHG
E\ W KH FRZDUGV DQG E\ W KH GDUN RQHV ZKRVH LQW HQW LRQ LW  ZDV W R W RUW XUH DQG NLOO
W KH VSLULW  RI W KH OLJKW  RXW  RI W KH ERGLHV RI W KH EHVW  RQHV ZLW K DQ\ P HDQV W KH\
FRXOG W KLQN RI  ³ 7KH ZRUOG LV RI HW HUQLW \´  FRQIHVVHV +HUP DQQ YRQ %\VZ\N VW LOO
EHIRU H KH Z DV EXU QHG DQG Z LW K W KLV KH U HM HFW HG W KH OLW HU DO P HDQLQJ RI W KH
FUHDW LRQ P \W K RI W KH ³ IRROLVK´  0RVHV

7KHHP HUJHQFHRIP DQ\RUGHUVHVSHFLDOO\RIW KHNQLJKW O\RUGHUVKDVW KHLURULJLQ

LQKHUHW LFV3HRSOHIHOW P RUHVHFXUHZLW KLQW KHIUDP HZRUNRIVXFKRUJDQL]DW LRQV
ZKLFKZHUHXQGHUSURW HFW LRQRIKLJKFOHULFVDQGDULVW RFUDW V7KLVZD\W KH\FRXOG
NHHS VHUYLQJ W KH ULW XDOV FXVW RP V DQG V\P EROLF DFW LRQV RI W KH DQFLHQW  W HDFKLQJV
DQG W R VSUHDG W KHP  LQ W KHLU RZQ FLUFOHV RI OHDGHUVKLS LH W KH RUGHU  7KLV ZDV
VREHFDXVHW KHVHRUGHUVRQO\DFFHSW HGP HP EHUVZKRFRXOGSURYHW KHLU³ FKLYDOULF
ELUW K´ LH W KHLU $U\DQ GHVFHQW 

8QGHU W KH LQIOXHQFH RI W KH FKXUFK W KH SXEOLF RSLQLRQ FDP H LQFU HDVLQJO\ W R W KH
RSLQLRQ W KDW  W KH .QLJKW V 7HP SODU FDXVHG W KHLU GHP LVH E\ GHJHQHUDW LRQ  %XW
HYHQ W KH ZRUVW  GHJHQHUDW LRQ ZRXOG QRW  KDYH M XVW LILHG W KH FUXHOW \ RI W KH FKXUFK
RQ LW V YLFW LP V  %XW  W KH ZRUOG LV OLW W OH FRQFHUQHG ZLW K W KDW  ZKLFK LV LQ W KH SDVW 
QHYHU OHDUQV IURP  LW  DQG HYHU\ JHQHUDW LRQ W KDW  IROORZV LV VODXJKW HUHG ZLW KRXW
DQ\ RQH EHLQJ DEOH W R W KLQN DERXW  ZKHUH W KH SUHYLRXV JHQHUDW LRQV HQGHG XS

7KH P RUH UHFHQW  ZRUNV RI KLVW RU\ UHSUHVHQW  W KH RSSRVLW H SRLQW  RI YLHZ  , Q W KLV
UHVSHFW  LW  LV YDOXDEOH W R KHDU W KH RSLQLRQ RI '|OOLQJHU W KH LP SRUW DQW  ZULW HU RI
KLVW RU\DQGW KHRORJLDQ+HXW W HUHGLW LQKLVODVW DFDGHP LFVSHHFKRQW KHW KRI
1RYHP EHU   ³ , W  LV FRQVSLFXRXV W KDW  LQ W KH P RUH UHFHQW  OLW HUDW XUH ZH ILQG
JHQHUDOO\W KHRSLQLRQW KDW W KH.QLJKW V7HP SODUZHUHDGHJHQHUDW HGRUJDQL]DW LRQ
ZKLFKGLGQRW OLYHXSDQ\P RUHW RW KHLUUXOHVEXW OLYHGLQGHEDXFKHU\DOUHDG\IRU
TXLW H D ZKLOH  3HRSOH W UXVW LQJO\ FRSLHG W KLV IURP  W KHLU SUHGHFHVVRUV  +RZHYHU
LI ZH H[DP LQH W KH VLW XDW LRQ P RUH W KRURXJKO\ ZH ILQG HYHU\ZKHUH LQGLFDW LRQV RI
W KH RSSRVLW H HYHQ LQ W KH RSLQLRQ RI W KH HQHP LHV DQG GHVW UR\HUV RI W KH RUGHU
%HIRUHW KHW KRI2FW REHUW KHGD\RIW KHJUHDW VW ULNHDJDLQVW W KHRUGHU RQ
VHFUHW  RUGHUV RI 3KLOLS W KH %HDXW LIXO DOO .QLJKW V 7HP SODU LQ )UDQFH ZHUH DUUHVW HG
RQW KLVGD\ QRERG\VSRNHDERXW VXFKVXSSRVHGFRUUXSW LRQDQGGHJHQHUDW LRQRI
W KHRUGHU, KDYHIRXQGW KHFRQW UDU\LQW KHOLW HUDW XUHSUHFHGLQJW KLVHYHQW DW W KH
VDP HW LP HDQGVW LOOLQW KHILUVW \HDUVRIW KHW KFHQW XU\$XW KRUVZKRRW KHUZLVH
DUHYHU\SUHFLVHLQM XGJLQJW KHW KHQUDP SDQW GHJHQHUDW LRQVDQGDEXVHVRIVSLULW XDO
JURXSV JLYH D UHFRP P HQGDW LRQ IRU W KH RUGHU HLW KHU QHJDW LYHO\ E\ LJQRULQJ LW
ZKHQP DNLQJW KHLUOLVW VRIFRUUXSW RUGHUVRUP RQDVW HULHVRUSRVLW LYHO\E\QDP LQJ
W KH RUGHU DV D P RGHO IRU W KH RW KHU RUGHUV
 

7KH W UXO\ FRUUXSW  RUGHUV DSSDUHQW O\ FRUUHVSRQGHG W R W KH LQW HQW LRQ DQG GHP DQGV
RI W KH SRSH  +H ZDQW HG W R GHVW UR\ W KH RUGHU RI W KH .QLJKW V 7HP SODU ZKLFK ZDV
KLJKO\ UDFLDO DQG RI $U\DQ P HQW DOLW \ ZLW K W KH IXOO LQW HQW  W R FXW  RII W KH OLQNV W KDW
W KLV RU GHU  KDG Z LW K W KH Z LVGRP  RI W KH SDVW   '|OOLQJHU  H[ SODLQHG W KDW  P RU H
SUHFLVHO\ E\ DGGLQJ   ³ 1RERG\ FRXOG EH OXUHG LQW R W KH RUGHU ZLW K W KH ZLVK W R
FRQGXFW  D OLIH LQ GHEDXFKHU\  4XLW H W R W KH FRQW UDU\ W KH DVFHW LF VHYHULW \ RI W KH
RUGHU P XVW  KDYH KDG D GHW HUULQJ HIIHFW   7KH IRRG ZDV EODQG DQG ORQJ W LP HV RI
IDVW LQJKDGW REHREVHUYHG7KHEHGRIW KH.QLJKW 7HP SODUFRQVLVW HGRIDVW UDZ
EDJDQGDEODQNHW +HUH, ZDQW W RP HQW LRQRQFHDQGIRUHYHUW KDW QRZKHUHHYHU
D .QLJKW  7HP SODU P DGH D FRQIHVVLRQ XQOHVV IRUFHG W R LW  E\ W RUW XUH RU IHDU  7KH
UHSRUW VRIKRZW KH\SURFHHGHGW RJHW FRQIHVVLRQVZHUHKRUULI\LQJ7KHVHUHSRUW V
GLG QRW  M XVW  FRP H IURP  W KH .QLJKW V 7HP SODU EXW  IURP  RW KHU FRQW HP SRUDULHV  , Q
3DU LV DORQH  .QLJKW V 7HP SODU  GLHG RI W RU W XU H  1HZ O\ LQYHQW HG P HW KRGV RI
LQIOLFW LQJ KRUULEOH SDLQ   ZHUH XVHG  7KH (QJOLVK KLVW RULDQ /HD VD\V DERXW  W KDW 
³ , W  LV QRW HZRUW K\ W KDW  LQ SODFHV ZKHUH W KH LQTXLVLW LRQ KDG IUHH KDQG VXFK DV LQ
)UDQFH DQG , W DO\ LW  ZDV QRW  GLIILFXOW  W R JHW  W KH GHVLUHG FRQIHVVLRQV  , Q &DVW LOH
DQG LQ *HU P DQ\  LW  IDLOHG  LQ (QJODQG W KH\  FRXOG QRW  GR DQ\ W KLQJ  XQW LO W KH
LQTXLVLW LRQ ZDV W HP SRUDULO\ HP SRZHUHG IRU W KLV SXUSRVH´

7R W KH W KLQNLQJ SHUVRQ LW  VHHP V LQFUHGLEOH KRZ VXFK KLJK NQRZOHGJH FRXOG JHW
ORVW KHUHDQGZLW KRXULP P HGLDW HDQFHVW RUV&HUW DLQO\QRW QDW XUDOO\E\IRUJHW W LQJ
:H FRXOG H[SODLQ LW V GLVDSSHDUDQFH E\ SRLQW LQJ RXW  W KDW  W KLV ZLVGRP  ZDV QRW
FRP P RQEXW W KDW LW ZDVZHOOSURW HFW HGE\DIHZFKRVHQRQHVRIHDFKJHQHUDW LRQ
, W  GLVDSSHDU HG W KHQ DV W KH LQLW LDW HV GLVDSSHDU HG  Z KHQ W KHLU  H[ LVW HQFH Z DV
W KUHDW HQHG  7KLV KDSSHQHG ZLW K W KH FRQW LQXRXVO\ LQFUHDVLQJ GRP LQDQFH RI W KH
FKXUFK LQ FRQM XQFW LRQ ZLW K W KH SROLW LFDO SRZHUV ZKR GLG QRW  NQRZ DQ\ P RUH
ZKHUHW KHDGYDQW DJHRIW KHIRONZDVLQIDFW W KH\ZRUNHGDJDLQVW W KLVDGYDQW DJH
IRU VHOILVK UHDVRQV  $OUHDG\ XQGHU &KDUOHP DJQH W KH VRLO W KDW  ZDV M RLQW  DQG
LQGLYLVLEOH SURSHUW \ RI W KH FODQ W KH EORRG DQG W KH IDP LO\ ZDV GHFODUHG UR\DO
SURSHUW \  , W  ZDV UREEHG XQGHU DQ H[FXVH  7KLV ZD\ W KH NLQJV IROORZLQJ W KHP
VRRQDOVRW KHGXNHVFRXOGGRQDW HW KHUREEHGSURSHUW \W RW KHFKXUFK7KLVZD\
W KHGRQDW LRQVW RP RQDVW HULHVFKXUFKHVDQGELVKRSVFRXOGEHFRP HLP P HDVXUDEO\
HQRUP RXV7KHROGQREOHEORRGW KDW GHIHQGHGLW VHOIDJDLQVW LW ZDVH[W HUP LQDW HG
DQG W KH RSSRVLW LRQ ZDV HYHQW XDOO\ EURNHQ  7KLV ZDV D W RW DO H[SURSULDW LRQ LQ
IDYRU RI W KH RYHUO\ SRZHUIXO UR\DOW \ DQG W KH FKXUFK  LW  ZDV W KH UHVXOW  RI W KH
³ EOHVVLQJV´  W KDW  W KH QHZ IDLW K VXSSRVHGO\ EURXJKW  LQW R W KH FRXQW U\  'XULQJ LW V
VR FDOOHG W LP H RI EORRP  IRU LQVW DQFH W KH $EEH\ RQ W KH LVODQG RI 5HLFKHQDX LQ
W KH ODNH RI &RQVW DQFH ³ RZ QHG´   Y LOODJHV W KH IDU P HU V RI Z KLFK Z HU H VW LOO
P DVW HUV RI W KHLU RZQ ODQG GXULQJ W KH ³ HYLO HUD RI KHDW KHQGRP ´  )RXU GXNHV 
SDODW LDOFRXQW VFRXQW VDQGEDURQVKDGW RSD\W ULEXW H:DVLW W KHW DVNRIW KH
&KXU FK W R FROOHFW  W KH JRRGV RI W KH QHZ O\  ³ FRQY HU W HG´  &KU LVW LDQV VR W KDW  W KH
VDOYDW LRQ RI W KHLU VRXOV ZRXOG QRW  VXIIHU DQ\ GDP DJHV"

7KHFKXUFKKDVFOHDQHGXSW KRURXJKO\, W KDVUHP RYHGW KHP RUDODQGHFRQRP LF

EDVLV RI W KH YDQTXLVKHG  , W  P DGH W KHP  SRRUHU LQ VSLULW  DQG LQ SURSHUW \ DQG LW


2PLWWHG
 

NHSW W KLVFXQQLQJDQGXQIRUW XQDW HP HW KRGW RW KLVGD\HYHQW KRXJKZLW KGLIIHUHQW

P HDQV DQG XQGHU GLIIHUHQW  FLUFXP VW DQFHV

:H FRXOG DVN W LP H DQG DJDLQ KRZ GLIIHUHQW O\ W KH IDW H RI W KH 2FFLGHQW  P D\ KDYH
EHHQ KDG LW  EHHQ FDSDEOH RI P DLQW DLQLQJ W KH HYROXW LRQ RI LW V RZQ FKDUDFW HU
ZLW KRXW  W KH KRUULEOH VSLULW XDO SODJXH ZKLFK FDP H RYHU W KH *HUP DQLF SHRSOHV
ZLW K D IRUJHG &KULVW LDQLW \  :H P D\ EH DEOH W R FRQVROH RXUVHOYHV LI ZH DVVXP H
W KDW  W KH *RW K ZLW KLQ W KH *HUP DQ KDG W R VDFULILFH KLP VHOI IRU D IHZ FHQW XULHV W R
HQW HU KHOO LW VHOI LQ W KH FRP EDW  ZLW K W KHVH GHYLOLVK SRZHUV LQ RUGHU W R RYHUFRP H
W KHP ILQDOO\VRW KDW W KH\FRXOGQRW SRVHDQ\P RUHDGDQJHULQW KHFRP LQJW LP HV

:HVKRXOGFRQFOXGHIURP ZKDW KDSSHQHGW KDW OLP LW LQJW KHKLJKHVW DQGXOW LP DW H

NQRZOHGJH DQG ZLVGRP  W R M XVW  D IHZ LV XQIRUW XQDW H  2Q W KH RW KHU KDQG W RR
EURDG D VSUHDG RI NQRZOHGJH ZKLFK KDSSHQV DW  SUHVHQW  XQGHU W KH JXLVH RI D
VXSSRVHGO\ XVHIXO JHQHUDO EURDGHQLQJ RI HGXFDW LRQ OHDGV W R D GHFHLYLQJ SRS
VFLHQFH KDOI NQRZOHGJH DQG VKDOORZ LQW HOOHFW  W R ZKLFK W KH VSLULW  LV HQVODYHG LQ
RXU GD\V DQG ZKLFK FDXVHV W KH P RVW  FRUUXSW  UHVXOW V RQ D GDLO\ EDVLV

7KHUH LV QR GRXEW  W KDW  W KH W LP H RI W KH UXOH RI W KH FKXUFK XQGHU W KH QDP H RI
&KULVW LDQLW \ IURP  W KH \HDU  XQW LO DERXW  W KH \HDU  ZDV D W HUULEOH VHFUHW
DQGRSHQFRP EDW IRUW KHIUHHGRP RIVSLULW DQGFRQVFLHQFHRIW KH*HUP DQLFKXP DQ
EHLQJ6LQFHW KHQW KHFRP EDW ZDVGHFLGHGLQRXUIDYRU:HEDQGDJHRXUZRXQGV
DQG ZDVK RII IURP  RXUVHOYHV W KH GLVJXVW  ZKLFK W KH FRP EDW  ERG\ W R ERG\ ZLW K
DQ XQFOHDQ RSSRQHQW  KDV FDXVHG LQ XV
 

;, 
7+ (621 2)7+ (681
6ZLQJ\RXUFXSZLW KZDW HUDOOSXUH
<RXZDQW W RILOOLW Z LW KJROGHQZ LQH
(P SW \\RXUVRXORIP XGDQGRISDLQ
6KRXOG\RXZ DQW W RILOOLW Z LW KEOLVV
7KHUHIRUHW KHKXP DQRXJKW W REHIUHHIURP W KHKXP DQ
7KHQRQO\*RGHQW HUVLQW RW KHKXP DQ

:KR VHHNV KH VKDOO ILQG   :KR GRHV QRW  VHHN W KH OHW W HU KH ILQGV W KH
VSLULW , QW KHJRVSHORI-RKQHYHU\W KLQJLVVDLGDVLW LVP HDQW LQW UXW K
7KLVLVW KHVXQQLHVW RIW KHJRVSHOVW KHP RVW 1RUGLFRQHRIW KHEORQG
W KLVLVRQO\³ VHHQ´ LQYLVLRQ \RXW K-RKDQQHVW KHP RVW *HUP DQRQH
W K H +DQ VHQ   W K H ³ +DQ Q HV´    DV K H LV I RX Q G  DJ DLQ  LQ  W K H P RVW
VLP SOHP LQGHG JRRG VROGLHU RI W KH ZRUOG ZDU DV D ORZHVW  UHIOHFW LRQ RI
W KH VXFFHVVLRQ RI &KULVW  LQ W KH ZLOO W R VDFULILFH DQG W KH FDSDELOLW \ W R
VDFULILFH  :DV KLV VDFULILFH QRW  HTXDOO\ JUHDW  DQG W UXH DV W KDW  RI W KH
³ /RUG´  RQ W KH FURVV"

, W  LV VDLG HYHU\ZKHUH LQ W KH ZKROH %LEOH IRU W KH SHUVRQ ZKR N QRZV
LW VVHFUHW P HDQLQJ  , W LVDOVRLQDOOW KHRW KHUERRNVRIVDOYDW LRQW KDW
H[LVW  RQ (DUW K  7KHVH VFULSW XUHV EULQJ VR P XFK HYLO EHFDXVH Z H GR
QRW XQGHUVW DQGW KHP DQ\P RUHDQGEHFDXVHZHGRQRW UHFRJQL]HDQ\
P RU H W KH FKDQJHV W KDW  RU LJLQDW HG LQ Z HOO P HDQLQJ RU  HY LO LQW HQW 
VRP HW LP HVLQLJQRUDQFH:HDUHODFNLQJW KHNH\W RLW  7UXO\KRQHVW
DQ G K DU G Z RU N LQ J W K HRORJLDQ V DW W HP SW  W R JDLQ  LQ VLJK W V LQ W R W K H
FRQW HQW VIRUW ZRJHQHUDW LRQV7KH\W RRFDQRQO\ILQGYDULRXVGLIIHUHQW
HGLW LRQVEXW W KH\GRQRW FRQFOXGHIURP W KHP 7KH\DUHDIUDLGW RVD\
W KDW VXFKSLHFHP HDOW UDGLW LRQFDQQRW EHDUHYHODW LRQ7KH\DUHDW W KH
W KUHVKROG RI DQ LQVLJKW  EXW  HLW KHU W KHLU OHYHO RI UHOLJLRXV LOOXP LQDW LRQ
LV W RR ZHDN DQG W KHLU ³ IDLW K´  W RR VW URQJ RU W KHLU IHDU RI *RG LV W RR
VP DOODQGW KHLUIHDURIKXP DQVLVW RRJUHDW 2W KHUZLVHW KH\ZRXOGEH
Z LW Q HVV W R W K H I DFW V W K DW  W K H\  I RX Q G   Q DP HO\  W K DW  W K HVH ³ K RO\
VFULSW XUHV´ DUHW KHZRUNRIKXP DQVHYHQW KRXJKW KH\FRQW DLQLQSDUW
UHYHODW LRQV RI W KH 'LYLQH VSLULW  W KDW  FRP HV W KURXJK W KH KXP DQ VSLULW 

$VIDUDVW KHJRVSHORI-RKQLVFRQFHUQHGZKLFKZHP HQW LRQHGLQLW LDOO\

LW  LV FORVHVW  W R P DQ\ RI XV EHFDXVH LW  P HQW LRQV ZLW K P RUH RSHQQHVV

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG

0RGHUQ*HUP DQ
 

FHUW DLQ W KLQJV W KDW  DUH P RUH FRYHUHG XS RU KLGGHQ LQ RW KHU %LEOLFDO VFULSW XUHV
(VSHFLDOO\W KHP RUH³ GRZQW RHDUW K´VXSSRVHGO\FOHDUHUJRVSHOVRI0DUN0DW W KHZ
DQG /XNH DUH ZULW W HQ LQ P RUH GLIILFXOW  P HW KRGV RI KLGLQJ W KH P HDQLQJ W KDQ W KH
DSSDUHQW O\ GDUNHU JRVSHO RI -RKQ

7KH ODQJXDJH RI SDUDEOHV DQG LP DJHV LV XVHG P RUH SHUIHFW O\ W KDQ LQ W KH JRVSHO
RI -RKQ  7KH ODW W HU RIW HQ JRHV EH\RQG W KH VHFUHW  ODQJXDJH RI LP DJHV DQG W XUQV
W RDSKLORVRSKLFDOOHFW XUH7KHDFW XDOP \VW LFDOZULW LQJRILP DJHV SDUDEOHV UXQHV
LV SXUHU DQG VW ULFW HU LQ W KH W KUHH RW KHU JRVSHOV  7KHUHIRUH W RGD\¶V W KHRORJLDQV
SHRSOH ZKR W DNH HYHU\W KLQJ OLW HUDOO\ DQG W KRVH ZKR GR QRW  EHOLHYH LQ W KH ZRUG
KDYHDKDUGHUW LP HW RXQGHUVW DQGW KRVHEHFDXVHW KH\VHHP W REH³ HDVLHU ´7KLV
LVVREHFDXVHZHW DNHW KHP \VW LFDODQGV\P EROLFODQJXDJHRILP DJHVDVKLVW RULFDO
P DW HULDOLHDVDFW XDOHYHQW V&RQVHTXHQW O\ZHUREW KLVODQJXDJHRILW VKLGGHQ
W UXH P HDQLQJ

7KH 5HYHODW LRQ RI -RKQ W RR DV GDUN DQG FRQIXVLQJ LW  VHHP V LV D UHYHODW LRQ RI
W KDW ZKLFKLVVDLGLQDP RUHFRQFHDOHGP DQQHULQW KHRW KHUERRN V, W ZRXOGQRW
EHFDOOHGUHYHODW LRQLILW UHYHDOHGOHVVW KDQW KHRW KHUJRVSHOV:KDW LVGHVFULEHG
W KHUHDVKDYLQJKDSSHQHGLVW REHXQGHUVW RRGLQDV\P EROLFZD\ QHYHUOLW HUDOO\
7KHZKROHOLIHRI³ &KULVW ´ LVW KRXJKW DQGYLHZHGV\P EROLFDOO\, W LVW KHH[SHULHQFH
RI HYHU\ 6RQ RI *RG LI Z H Z DQW  W R GHVFULEH Z LW K W KLV Z RUG W KH SHUVRQ Z KR
VHDUFKHV *RG DQG ZKR GRHV QRW  JR W KH ZLGH URDG EXW  ZKR W DONV DERXW  KLV JRG
ZKR QHYHU ZDV W KH JRG RI W KH 6FULEHV DQG 3KDULVHHV W KHQ DQG W RGD\

, Q RXU GD\V VFLHQFH DQG FKXUFK DUH YHU\ IDU IURP  W KH H[SHULHQFH RI *RG RI
³ &KULVW ´  &KULVW  P HDQV DQ LQLW LDW H ZKR LV DQRLQW HG ZLW K W KH VDFUHG RLO W KH ³$OH´
 W KH VSLULW   $V ORQJ DV ZH DUH VW ULYLQJ LQ W KLV ZRUOG W KDW  LV UXOHG E\ W KH VXE
KXP DQ DOO RI XV VW ULGH W KH SDW K RI 3DVVLRQ RI W KH  VW DW LRQV  7KHVH VW DW LRQV
FDP HIURP W KHVFKRROVRIP \VW HULHVZKHUHW KH\ZHUHDFW XDOW HVW VRIW KHGLVFLSOHV
W R DGM XVW  W KHP  W R W KH DFFXVDW LRQV DQG KRVW LOLW LHV W R ZKLFK KH Z LOO EH H[SRVHG DW
DODW HUW LP HZKHQKHVW ULGHVW KHSDW KRIW KH³ /RUG´:KRHYHUIROORZHGW KHSDW K
RIW KH³ /RUG´HYHQLIRQO\DVKRUW GLVW DQFHNQRZVW KDW W KHP HDQLQJRIW KH³ GHDW K
RI W KH VDY LRU ´  LV DQ HW HU QDO SU RFHVV Z LW KLQ RXU VHOY HV DQG DU RXQ G RXU VHOY HV
7KHUHIRUH LW  ZRXOG EH HDV\ W R ILQG KXQGUHGV RI VDYLRUV ZKR KDYH VXIIHUHG P RUH
W KDQW KH6RQRI*RGRQW KHVXSSRVHGFURVV, QIDFW KHFRXOGKDYHOHIW LW DW DQ\
W LP H EHFDXVH RI KLV SHUIHFW  SRZHU DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH HUURQHRXV RSLQLRQ RI W KH
FKXUFKHV$FW XDOO\QRJRGRUKXP DQFDQHVFDSHKLVLQW HUQDOFU XFLIL[LRQQRUGRHV
KHZDQW W RGRVREHFDXVHLQW KLVHQRUP RXVSRZHURIGHVLUHW RW KH³ FURVV´ LVKLV
VDOYDW LRQ KLV JRDO  <JJ GUD VLO  ³ , FK W UDJH ]XP  =LHO´    ,  FDUU\ W R W KH JRDO
W KHUHIRUH W KH ZRUOG DVK W UHH LV QDP HG ZKLFK LV W KH FURVV RI W KH ZRUOG RI W KH
*HUP DQLF SHRSOHV

/LNH OHJHQGV DQG IDLU\ W DOHV W KH UHOLJLRXV P \W K LV XVLQJ H[W HU QDO VHTXHQFHV RI
HYHQW VRIUHDOOLIHLHDVW RU\ZKHQGHVFULELQJVSLULW XDOSURFHVVHV 7KHUHIRUH
ZHZDQW W RXQGHUVW DQGW KHVHUHOLJLRXVP \W KVFRUUHFW O\, P P HGLDW HYLVLRQRI*RG
DOZD\V LV H[SUHVVHG LQ P \W KV  /LNH LQ W KH IDLU\ W DOH ZH KDYH W R XQGHUVW DQG

³ 7KHDQFLHQW SHRSOHVXVHGW KHP \W KRORJLFDOP HW KRGZ KHQGHVFULELQJVSLULW XDOSURFHVVHV´ 
3LREE )RUP XODLUHGH+DXW H0DJLH
 

SHUVRQVDQGHYHQW VV\P EROLFDOO\, IZHXQGHUVW DQGP \W KDVKLVW RU\DVKDSSHQHG

Z LW K  W K H &K U LVW LDQ  P \ W K   W K HQ  P HDQ LQ J EHFRP HV Q RQ VHQ VH  I DLW K  E HFRP HV
VXSHUVW LW LRQ DQG YLVLRQ RI *RG EHFRP HV OLHV DQG IUDXG

2XU W DVN DP RQJ KXP DQV RI W RGD\ LV W R GLVW XUE DQG W R GHVW UR\ W KLV JHQHUDOO\
H[LVW LQJ UHOLJLRXV IUDXG DQG W R W HDFK DJDLQ W KH W UXH DQG IDLW KIXO W UXW K  ILUVW  W R
RXUVHOYHVDQGW KHQW RKXP DQLW \DVDZKROH7KLVLVVREHFDXVHEHLQJW KHROGHU
DQGP RUHP DW XUHEURW KHUVLW LVRXUFDOOLQJ7KHHQW LUHZRUOGLVZDLW LQJIRUW KDW 
, W ZRXOGEHDJUHDW GHHGRIVDOYDW LRQLIW KH*HUP DQVRXORI$U\DQVSLULW VXFFHHGHG
W R SHUIRUP  W KLV JUHDW  ZRUN RI UHQHZDO W KDW  ZDV DW W HP SW HG  \HDUV DJR EXW
ZKLFKFDP HW RDKDOW KDOIZD\  7RGD\ZHDUHXVLQJW KHVZRUGRIW KHP LQGP RUH
SROLVKHG DQG VKDUSHU DQG YLFW RU\ LV P RUH FHUW DLQ W KDQ HYHU

/HW  XV OLVW HQ KRZ W KH P \W K W DONV W R XV ZKHQ ZH DUH OHDYLQJ W KH OHYHO RI SODLQ
P DW HU LDO RU LHQW DW LRQ

, QRXUJRVSHORI-RKQW KHVHYHQP LUDFOHVRI³ -HVXV&KULVW ´ ZHUHGHVFULEHG7KHVH

DUHW KHGDLO\P LUDFOHVRIW KH'LYLQH/LJKW W KH6XQZKLFKLW W KHUHSUHVHQW DW LYHRI
*RG LQ 0DW W HU RI W KH VRQ EHKLQG ZKRP  W KH XQLYHUVDOLW \ GRHV QRW  IHHO W KH VSLULW
DQG P RUH W KH V\P ERO  +H &KULVW  W KH 6XQ W XUQV ZDW HU LQW R ZLQH OLNH W KH 6XQ
ULSHQV W KH ZDW HU LQ W KH JUDSH W R ZLQH  +H KHDOV W KH VRQ RI W KH FRP P DQGHU OLNH
W KH6XQKHDOVLQLW VGDLO\UXQRIYLFW RU\DQGVDOYDW LRQRYHUW KH(DUW K+HFOHDQVHV
SHUVRQZKRZDVVLFNIRUVRP H\HDUVE\W KHSRZHURIUDGLDW LRQRIKLVVDQFW LW \
OLNH W KH VXQ DORQH FOHDQVHV W R JH VXQG KHLW  E\ P HDQV RI JH VRQQW  KHLW  W KH 6XQ
FOHDQVHVW RKHDOW KE\P HDQVRIEHLQJLUUDGLDW HGE\W KH6XQ +HIHHGVW KH
RQW KHP RXQW DLQZLW KW KHIRRGRIOLIHOLNHRXU6XQLVHW HUQDO IRRGRIOLIHDQGW KH
JRGV QHYHU DJH LQ W KH IDFH RI W KH FRVP LF VRXUFH RI OLJKW   +H Z DONV DFURVV W KH
ELOORZ LQJ Z DY HV RI W KH VHD RI OLIH DQG VP RRW KHV W KH VRXO DQG EDQLVKHV W KH
VW RU P V OLNH W KH OLJKW  W KH 6XQ VFDW W HU V W KH FORXGV DQG SXW V LQW R SHDFH DQG
VOXP EHU W KH ZDYHV  +H UHVW RUHV W KH LQQHU YLVLRQ IRU W KH VSLULW XDOO\ EOLQG DV W KH
6XQJLYHVXVW KHVHQVHRIYLVLRQVRW KDW W KHH\HZKLFKLV6XQ OLNHFDQDOVRVHH
W KH6XQ

³ , I W KH H\H ZDV QRW  6XQ OLNH

7KH 6XQ LW  FRXOG QHYHU VHH
+DG ZH QRW  *RG¶V RZQ SRZHU
+RZ FRXOG W KH 'LYLQH H[FLW H XV"´

+HDZDNHQVW KHVSLULW XDOO\GHDGIURP KLVW RP EOLNHW KH6XQDZDNHQVDOOOLIHIURP

W KHW RP ERIZLQW HU, W LVW KHVRXQGLQJ6XQW KDW FDOOVZLW KW URP ERQHVRIOLJKW W KH
OLIH LQ VSLULW  DQG LQ P DW W HU W R JURZW K LQ W KH OLJKW 

+RZ  FDQ Z H VW LOO W DN H W KH VFU LSW XU HV OLW HU DOO\  LQ Y LHZ  RI W KLV EU LJKW  DQG ORXG
ODQJXDJH RI W KH 6XQ
 

7KHVHYHQJUHDW GHHGVRI-HVXVRI$VXVDUHW KHGHHGVRIW KHVHYHQFRORUVRIW KH

UDGLDW LQJ6XQDERYHW KH(DUW K+RZFRXOGW KH6RQRI*RGW KH6XQRI*RGZDON
W KH(DUW KGLIIHUHQW O\W KDQKHDOLQJFRQVROLQJDZDNHQLQJDQGZRUNLQJ"+RZOLW W OH
DQG FUXGH LW  LV W R P DNH D KXP DQ D P DQ IURP  W KLV ZKHUH W KH SDUDEOH LV KLJKHU
W KDQ DOO VQXJ UHDOLW \ GHHSHU W KDQ DOO KXP DQ EURRGLQJ FRQVLGHULQJ D RQH W LP H
ULGLFXORXV LQFDUQDW LRQ RI *RG RQ (DUW K  0RUH VR VLQFH HYHU\ LOOXP LQDW HG SHUVRQ
IHHOVDQGNQRZVKLP W REHW KHVRQRI*RGZKRLVP LUURULQJW KHVSLULW XDOFODULW \RI
KLV 'LYLQH EHLQJ LQ W KH OLJKW  RI W KH 6XQ

³ ,  DP  W KH OLJKW  RI W KH ZRUOG´ VD\V W KH &KULVW  EXW  W KH GDUNQHVV FRXOG QRW  \HW
FRP SUHKHQG LW 

, DP  6D\VW KH6XQZLW KLQRXUVHOYHVDQGEHXQGHUVW DQG , DP LW KHUH $QGW KXV
VD\V W KH FRVP LF &KULVW  ZLW KLQ RXUVHOYHV   ,  DP  W KH /LJKW   ,  DP  W KH UHVXUUHFW LRQ
DQG W KH OLIH  ,  DP  W KH JUDSHYLQH DQG ,  DP  W KH EUHDG  ,  DP  W KH $ DQG 2 W KH
EHJLQQLQJ DQG W KH HQG  'RHV D KXP DQ VSHDN W KLV D P DQ"  1R DQG LI D P DQ
VSHDNV LW  W KHQ KH VSHDNV LW  OLNH DOO RI XV ZKR DUH IHHOLQJ RXUVHOYHV EHLQJ W KH
VRQV RI *RG  , Q HDFK RI XV EXUQV W KH P DLQ VHQW HQFH   ,  DP  W KH /LJKW  ,  DP  W KH
ZRUG, DP ORYH 7RILQGRXW DQGW RSURYHW KDW ZLW KLQRXUFRQVFLHQFHZHGRQRW
QHHG W R DVVXP H *RG HQW HULQJ OLIH RQ (DUW K DV D KLVW RULF DQG P DOH SHUVRQ  :H
NQRZ W KDW  ZH DUH HYHU\W KLQJ RXUVHOYHV LQ W KH VSOHQGRU RI W KH VSLULW XDO 6XQ RI
³ &KULVW ´RIW KH³ 6RQRI*RG´ZKRUHYHDOVKLP VHOILQHYHU\RQHRIXVIRUZKRP W KH
OLJKW  DOUHDG\ KDV ULVHQ LQ W KH (DVW  RI KLV LQQHUP RVW 

(YHU\KXP DQOLYHVLQ&KULVW DQG&KULVW OLYHVLQHYHU\KXP DQ7KHUHDUHRQO\IHZ

ZKR KDYH EHFRP H DZDUH RI W KLV DQG DOO RW KHUV VHDUFK IRU *RG LQ D ERGLO\ VKDSH
RQ D ZRRGHQ FURVV RQ W KH JDOORZV RI D SODFH RI H[HFXW LRQ LQVW HDG RI RQ W KH
FURVVRIW KHZRUOGZKLFKKDVLW VFHQW HULQW KHKHDUW RIHYHU\KXP DQEHLQJ7RGD\
DOUHDG\ W KHUH DUH SHRSOH ZKR SUHDFK W KH FRVP LF &KULVW  EXW  W KH\  VW LOO DW W DFK
W KHP VHOY HV Z LW K GHVSHU DW H VRXO W R W KH ODVW  VW LOO P LVXQGHU VW RRG GRJP D DQG
³ EHOLHI´  UHJDUGOHVV RI DOO W KDW  LQ W KH HP ERGLP HQW  RI *RG LQ D KLVW RULF P DQ ZLW K
W KHQDP HRI-HVXV&KULVW +HZDVVXSSRVHGW REHERUQVRP H\HDUVDJRE\
D KXP DQ ZRP DQ EXW  EHJRW W HQ E\ W KH +RO\ 6SLULW 

7KH\ ZDQW  DQG W KH\ EHOLHYH W KDW  W KH FRVP RV UHYHDOHG LW VHOI LQ D P LFURFRVP  VR
W R VD\  'XH W R EOLQGQHVV LQ VRXO DQG ERG\ W KH\ GR QRW  VHH W KDW  W KLV KDSSHQV
HYHU\ LQVW DQW  LQ HYHU\ SDUW LFOH RI GXVW  RI W KH 6XQ DQG P RUH VR LQ HYHU\ KXP DQ
EHLQJZKLFKLVD³ OLYLQJUHYHODW LRQ´ RI*RG7KLVW KH+LJK-RKDQQHVNQRZV ³ <RX
DUH JRGV´
 

7UHHRI/LIHLQW KHDUFKHGILHOGRIW KH&KXUFKRI(OVW HUVW UHEQLW ]W KFHQW XU\

7KHW UHHRIOLIHLVUHSUHVHQW HGE\W KHGRXEOHOLQHRQW KHOHIW DQGVHW RQHTXDO

IRRW LQJ ZLW K W KH FURVV RQ W KH ULJKW   7KH FURVV JURZV RXW  RI W KH JURXQG  $W
W KH OHIW  DUH W KH V\P EROV RI W KH ROG IDLW K ZKHHO DQG ZRUOG DVK <JJGUDVLO LQ
EHW ZHHQ 0DU\ DV 1RUQ W R W KH ULJKW  SHUKDSV -RKQ W KH %DSW LVW  W KH SLJHRQ
NHHSHU ZLW KW KHSLJHRQZKLFKKDVDP XFKGHHSHUP HDQLQJW KDQEHLQJM XVW
W KH VSLULW  RI JRG W KH ODW W HU EHLQJ EXW  DQ DOOHJRULF LP DJH  , W  LV QRW HZRUW K\
IRUW KLVFRQFHSW W KDW W RW KHULJKW ZHKDYHW KHDQFLHQW W HDFKLQJRI$UP DQHQ
VHHQ DV D FRDW  RI DUP V  $OO RI LW  LV D W ULQLW \ ZLW K D VSHFLDO HP SKDVLV RQ W KH
*HUP DQLF FRQW HQW   +HUH &KULVW  LV W KH FRVP RV LW VHOI KLJKHU W KDQ IDW KHU DQG
P RW KHU$ERYHKLVFKHVW W KH, V 5XQHFRQQHFW VZLW KW KHFURVVRI6W $QGUHZ
:KHQ ZH HORQJDW H W KH KHDG ZH UHFHLYH W KH +DJDO 5XQH  )RXU VW HSV VKRZ
W KHW UDQVLHQW IRXURIW KHKXP DQEHLQJERG\FKHVW DQGKHDGVKRZW KHQRQ
W UDQVLHQW  W KUHH RI W KH VHYHQ IROG KXP DQ

&KULVW KLP VHOILVW KHFRVP RVW KHXQLYHUVHW KH+DJ $OOW KH&U \VW  $OODVZHKDYH
DOUHDG\SURYHQDQGW KHW ZHOYHGLVFLSOHVDUHKLVW ZHOYHFUHDW LY HFUHDW LQJSRZHUV
RI W KH ZRUOG ZKLFK KXP DQV UHFRJQL]HG LQ W KH 7\U &LUFOH ]RGLDF  DOUHDG\ VLQFH
8U W LP HV ZKHUH W KH EUHDW K RI *RG EORZV DQG W XUQV ZKLFK DUH DOVR W KH SDUW V RI
W KH ERG\ RI &KULVW   7KURXJK W KHP  W KH JUHDW  EDVLF HQHUJ\ RI W KH XQLYHUVH DFW V
XSRQXVXSRQHYHU\ERG\LQLW VW ZHOYHFRUUHVSRQGLQJSDUW VRIW KHERG\7KLVZD\
&KULVW  OLYHV LQ XV W KH .ULVW  W KH ³ *ULVW ´ W KH VFDIIROG RI W KH ZRUOG DQG ZH DUH
OLYLQJLQKLP :HDUHKLVYLVLEOHERG\7KHUHIRUHW KHFKXUFKDVVRFLHW \RIVDLQW V
LV W KH FRP P XQLW \ RI &KULVW  RI W KH ERG\ RI &KULVW 
 

7KH =RGLDF LV W KH JULQGLQJ VW RQH W KH P LOOVW RQH RI W KH VN\ ZKLFK URW DW HV DURXQG
LW VD[LVP LOOLQJP DUU\LQJIORXUP DNLQJ, W LVW KLV³ ODVW VXSSHU´  ZKHUH+HEUHDNV
W KH EUHDG LQ W KH IRRG FRXUVH JULQGLQJ FRXUVH  RI W KH W LP HV DQG HW HUQLW LHV  +H
RIIHUV W KLV EUHDG W R KLV W ZHOYH ³ GLVFLSOHV´ LH W KH W ZHOYH SDUW V RI KLV ERG\ DQG
VSLU LW    +HDG  KHDU W   ERG\  DQG IHHW    7KHVH W Z HOY H GLVFLSOHV DU H W KH W Z HOY H
KHOSHUV RI W KH ZRUOGV W DNHQ IURP  W KH 8U LP DJH RI W KH KHDYHQO\ W ZHOYH ZKHHO  
W KH'LYLQHFRXQFLORIW ZHOYH+HKLP VHOILVW KHEUHDGW KDW KHEUHDNVIRUW KHP +H
LV W KH EUHDG RI OLIH W KH %DU 2G W KH VSLULW  RI OLIH DV W KH HVRW HULF P HDQLQJ RI W KH
ZRUG HP HUJHV E\ LW VHOI IURP  W KH 5XQHV DQG UHGHHP V XV IURP  W KH FODZV RI DQ
XQKRO\  HU U RU  RI OHW W HU V DQG VXSHU VW LW LRQ DV W KH Z RU OG KDV QHY HU  VHHQ HY HQ
W KRXJK LW  LV DOU HDG\  IXOO RI KRU U LEOH DW U RFLW LHV  7KH FRVP LF &KU LVW  Z KLFK Z H
UHFRJQL]H DQG FRQIHVV KHUH LV DV ROG DV ³ &KULVW LDQLW \´  LW VHOI DQG ZKRHYHU W DNHV
W KH VDFU HG VFU LSW XU HV DV U HY HODW LRQV QHHGV RQO\  XQGHU VW DQG W KH ODQJXDJH RI
UHYHODW LRQ DV LW  LV SUHVHQW HG  7KLV W LP H RQO\ LW  VKRXOG EH W DNHQ OLW HUDOO\ QDP HO\
W KDW  &KU LVW  ZDV QRW  D P DQ EXW  ³ W KH KXP DQ´ *RG KLP VHOI W KH FRVP RV W KH
XQLYHUVH LQ D SDUDEOH LQ DQ LP DJH  (FFH KRP R   6HH W KH KXP DQ

 2PLWWHG


7KHSUHFHGLQJSOD\RQZ RUGVLVDOP RVW XQW UDQVODW DEOH 7KH³ VXSSHU´ UHIHUVW RW KH³ ODVW 


VXSSHU´ 

5DGLQP RGHUQ*HUP DQ ZKHHO5DW  FRXQFLORUFRXQFLOP DQ
 

7KH 2OG DQG W KH 1HZ 7HVW DP HQW V DOO RI W KH GRJP DV DOO ULW XDOV DQG VDFUDP HQW V
DOO V\P EROV RI W KH FKXUFKHV QR P DW W HU ZKDW  QDP HV W KHVH FKXUFKHV KDYH JLYHQ
W KHP VHOYHV VSHDN FOHDUO\ RI W KH FRVP LF &KULVW   ³ <RX DUH P \ EHORYHG VRQ ZKR
SOHDVHV P H´   :KR GDUHG W R W DNH VXFK D ZRUG OLW HUDOO\"  :H DOO DUH W KHVH VRQV
XSRQ ZKLFK W KH VSLULW  RI *RG GHVFHQGV LQ W KH VKDSH RI D GRYH EHFDXVH DOO RI XV
DUH W KH FDUULHUV RI W KH 'LYLQH VSLULW  LQ KXP DQLW \

7KHUHIRUH LI W KH W KHRORJLDQV VD\ W KDW  W KH FRVP LF &KULVW  LV QRW  W KH &KULVW  RI W KH
2OG RU 1HZ 7HVW DP HQW  W KHQ W KH\ DUH LQGHHG GHP RQRORJLVW V DQG W KH\ SURYH XV
ZLW KW KLVDFW LRQW KDW W KH\KDYHQHYHUOHDUQHGKRZW RUHDGFRUUHFW O\RUW KDW W KH\
FDQQRW  XQGHUVW DQG W KDW  ZKLFK W KH\ DUH UHDGLQJ HYHQ LI W KH\ GR QRW  NQRZ W KH
V\ P EROLF ODQJXDJH RI W KH VFU LSW XU HV QRU  W KH VHFU HW  ODQJXDJH LQ Z KLFK W KHVH
W HVW DP HQW V KDYH EHHQ ZULW W HQ OLNH DOO VDFUHG ERRNV  7KH\ DUH QRW  HYHQ FDSDEOH
RI JU DVSLQJ W KH REY LRXV Z RU GV DQG W KH\ DU H VR JRG IRU VDNHQ W KDW  W KH\ W DNH
OLW HUDOO\ W KDW  Z KLFK LV Z ULW W HQ LQ D ODQJXDJH RI LP DJHV DQG W KH\ GR QRW  W DNH
OLW HUDOO\ W KDW  ZKLFK SUHVHQW V LW VHOI FOHDUO\ W R W KHP  ZLW KRXW  FRQFHDOP HQW   7KH
XQJRGOLQHVV RI DOO FKXUFKHV LV DOUHDG\ HYLGHQW  LI ZH W DNH D ORRN DW  W KH VLW XDW LRQ
RI W KH Z RU OG DQG LW V KXP DQLW \ IRU  Z KLFK EHLQJ ³ JRYHU QRU V RI &KU LVW ´ W KHVH
P LOOHQQLD ORQJ OHDVH KROGHUV DQG W HQDQW V RI W KH NLQJGRP  RI KHDY HQ RQ (DUW K
VKRXOG EH UHVSRQVLEOH

%XW  Z KDW  DU H DOO ERRN V DQG DOO W U DGLW LRQV"  7KH H[ SHU LHQFH RI &KU LVW  LV QRW
GHSHQGHQW  RI W KHLU  H[ LVW HQFH RU  DYDLODELOLW \  &KU LVW  LV P LU U RU HG DV D FRVP LF
H[SHULHQFH LQ HYHU\ KXP DQ EHLQJ W KDW  LV DZDNH  :H ZRXOG KHDU DJDLQ DOO 8U
5XQHV DV W KH\ DUH P XUP XULQJ W KHLU VRQJV LQ W KH XQLYHUVH HYHQ LI QRW  RQH OHW W HU
DERXW  ³ &KULVW ´  KDG EHHQ KDQGHG GRZQ W R XV

7R EHOLHY H W KDW  W KH VDOYDW LRQ RI W KH Z RU OG DQG W KH DFN QRZ OHGJHP HQW  RI LW V
FUHDW RU ZDV GHSHQGHQW  RQ W KH NHHSLQJ RI D FRXSOH RI FRRNV RU M XVW  RI D VLQJOH
OHW W HU LV LQ LW VHOI D KXJH EODVSKHP \  , Q IDFW  ZH DUH QRW LFLQJ W KH GHHSHVW  EOLVV
W KH GHHSHVW  GHYRXW QHVV W KH GHHSHVW  SHDFH ZKHUHYHU SHRSOH NQRZ  QRW KLQJ RI
W KH OHW W HU  ZKHUH SHRSOH UHO\ VROHO\ RQ W KH JUDFH RI LOOXP LQDW LRQ E\ W KH OLJKW 
VDQFW LILHG E\ W KH VSLULW  W KH FORVHQHVV W R QDW XUH DQG W KH ZDUP W K RI OLIH  2Q W KH
RW KHUKDQGZKHUHW KHGLVW RUW HGDQGIDOVLILHG³ ZRUGRI*RG´ VRXQGVIURP W KRXVDQGV
RI FKXUFKHV DQG VFKRROV W KH ZRUOG LV UHVRXQGLQJ RI NLGQDSSLQJ DQG P XUGHU RI
VRXOV7KHUHW KHS\UHVDUHIOLFNHULQJ7KHVHS\UHVP D\QRORQJHUEHIHGE\ZHOO
GULHGEHHFKORJV7KH\DUHGHYRXUHGE\GULHG XSOHW W HU ORJV E\KHOOLVKIODP HV
RI KDW U HG M HDORXV\ ORZ OLQHVV GRP LQDQFH VW XSLGLW \  DQG P HDQQHVV RI W DN LQJ
W KLQJV OLW HUDOO\  :KRHYHU W DNHV W KH QDUUDW LRQV RI W KH JRVSHOV OLW HUDOO\ DQG ZKR
W KHQ GRHV QRW  FRQGHP Q W KH DFW LRQV DQG GHHGV W KHU H KDV ORVW  DOO RI KLV RZ Q
W KLQNLQJ+LVFRQVFLHQFHEHFDP HP XW HDQGKHKDVEHFRP HYLFW LP RIW KHP RUDOLW \
ORZHULQJ LQIOXHQFH RI ³ IDLW K´  ZLW KRXW  NQRZOHGJH  2IW HQ W KHUH DUH W KLQJV ZKLFK
W R EHOLHYH ZH DUH IRUFHG W R  7KHVH W KLQJV FDQ RQO\ EH EHDUDEOH LI ZH VW ULYH W R
UHFRJQL]H W KHP  DV V\P EROV DQG W R GH FRGH W KHLU W UXH P HDQLQJ


%XFKHQ VFKHLW HU EHHFK ORJV%XFK VW DEHQ VFKHLW HU OHW W HU ORJV%XFKVW DEH OHW W HU
OLW HUDOO\ ³ EHHFK VW DYH´ ZKLFK UHIHUV W R W KH SUDFW LFH RI FDVW LQJ UXQHV
 

+HUH ZH JLYH RQO\ RQH H[DP SOH W KDW  VKRZV KRZ ZH FDQ EH W HP SW HG W R W DNH W KH
SDUDEOHVRUP LUDFOHVRI-HVXVRI1D]DUHW KOLW HUDOO\DVW KHFKXUFKFRP P DQGVXVW R
GR

:H DUH UHDGLQJ LQ /XNH  KRZ &KULVW  KHDOV D SRVVHVVHG SHUVRQ  7KH GHYLOV
W KDW  SRVVHVVHG W KH SRRU SHUVRQ DVNHG &KULVW  W R EH DOORZHG W R HQW HU D IORFN RI
SLJV VR W KDW  W KH\ ZRXOG QRW  EH ³ FDVW  LQ W KH GHSW KV´  &KULVW  DOORZV W KHP  W R GR
VR³ W KHUHW KHGHYLOVOHIW W KHKXP DQDQGHQW HUHGW KHSLJV DQGW KHKHUGUDQGRZQ
W KH VORSH LQW R W KH ODNH DQG GURZQHG´   :H GR QRW  QHHG W R P HQW LRQ W KDW  VXFK D
VW RU\ LV QRW  P XFK UHDVRQ IRU M R\ XQOHVV ZH ILQG LW  IXQQ\ W KDW  W KH SLJV W KUHZ
W KHP VHOYHV LQW R W KH ODNH DQG W KH GHYLOV ZHUH ³ FDVW  LQW R W KH GHSW K´  HYHQ W KRXJK
&KULVW  KDG SURP LVHG W KH FRQW UDU\  *RG RU KLV VRQ DQG KHLU ZRXOG DFW  GLIIHUHQW O\
XSRQ KLV FUHDW XUHV HYHQ RI W KH\ ZHUH GHYLOV

%DGH[DP SOHVVSRLOJRRGP RUDOV6W LOOLQRXUGD\VFRQM XUHUVW KURZGLVHDVHVRQW R

RW KHU SHRSOH DQLP DOV RU SODQW V  )RU W KLV W KH FKXUFK URXW LQHO\  EXUQHG W KHP  DV
ZL]DUGV RI KHUHW LFV HYHQ W KRXJK W KH\ M XVW  IROORZHG W KH H[DP SOH RI &KULVW   :H
ZLOO DFFHSW  KHUH W KH SRVVLELOLW \ RI VSLULW V EHLQJ H[RUFLVHG E\ D P DJLFLDQ EXW  ZH
VW LOOKDYHW RFRQVLGHUW KHGDP DJHW KDW W KHRZQHURIW KHKHUGRISLJVVXIIHUHGE\
W KLV EODFN P DJLFDO DFW   +HUH ZH FHUW DLQO\ FDQQRW  VSHDN RI ZKLW H P DJLF DV OLW W OH
DV ZH FDQ GR VR LQ W KH FDVH ZKHQ &KULVW  FDXVHG DQ LQQRFHQW  ILJ W UHH W R GU\ XS

$OP RVW  HYHU\ SDJH RI W KH 1HZ 7HVW DP HQW  KDV VXFK GXELRXV SDVVDJHV DQG W KH
EHOLHYLQJ &KULVW LDQ VKRXOG DFW XDOO\ EH KDSS\ LI ZH VXFFHHGHG LQ FRQYLQFLQJ KLP
W KDW  W KHVH GXELRXV SDVVDJHV DU H QRW  W R EH W DNHQ OLW HUDOO\ DW  OHDVW  QRW  DOO RI
W KHP   7KHUH DUH QXP HURXV VW RULHV LQ W KH 2OG 7HVW DP HQW  W KDW  VKRXOG EH W DNHQ
OLW HUDOO\ DQG W KHVH KDYH W R EH M XGJHG LP P RUDO LQ HYHU\ FDVH  +HUH ZH QHHG QR
ORQJHU EULQJ H[DP SOHV EXW  ZH DUH DP D]HG ZLW K ZKDW  OHYHO RI LQGLIIHUHQFH W KH
VHUYDQW VRIW KH&KXUFKRYHUORRNVXFKLQH[FXVDEOHDQGLQHIIDFHDEOHHUURUV$VIDU
DVW KHFKXUFKLVFRQFHUQHGW KDW W KH\KDYHW RUHSUHVHQW W KH\KDYHORVW DOOIHHOLQJ
RIW KDW ZKLFKLVW UXHKRQRUDEOHDQGP RUDOZKLOHLQSULYDW HOLIHW KH\ZRXOGUHM HFW
VLP LODUW KLQJVZLW KXW W HULQGLJQDW LRQ+HUHZHKDYHW RGRZLW KDFDVHRIK\SQRW LFDOO\
LQGXFHG GHOXVLRQ DQG FRUSRUDW LRQ LQGXFHG UHP RYDO RI P RUDOLW \ RQ D KXJH VFDOH
1DW XUDOO\ LW  VKRZHG LW V HIIHFW V LQ W KH FRP P RQ GHFOLQH RI SXEOLF P RUDOLW \ P RUDOV
LQ VW DW H FKXUFK DQG SHRSOH
 

7R W K H $U \ R *HU P DQ LF VSLU LW  Z LW K  K LV LQ GHSHQ GHQ FH RI  M X GJP HQ W  LQ  Z K LFK
LQGHSHQGHQFHDORQHKXP DQGLJQLW \W KULYHVDQGW UXHZRUVKLSRI*RGLVSRVVLEOH 
VXFKLP SXGHQFHZKLFKW KHJRVSHOVGHP DQGDFFRUGLQJW RW KHUHTXLUHP HQW E\W KH
FKXUFKHV RI XQFRQGLW LRQDO IDLW K DUH DQ DERP LQDW LRQ

7KHGHFOLQHRIKXP DQLW \XQGHUVXFKFRQGLW LRQVLVXQDYRLGDEOH, IP HQW DOKRVSLW DOV

M DLOV DQG KRVSLW DOV DUH ILOOLQJ XS LQFUHDVLQJO\ W KH FKXUFKHV DORQH DUH W R EODP H
IRUW KDW ZKLFKKDYHLQIHVW HGKXP DQLW \ZLW KDQLQFXUDEOHP RUDOLQVDQLW \EHFDXVH
RI W KHLU OLW HUDO IDLW K  <RX ZLOO UHFRJQL]H W KHP  E\ W KHLU IUXLW V

7R UHFRJQL]H DQG XQGHUVW DQG W KH 'LYLQH VHFUHW V ZH GR QRW  QHHG Z ULW W HQ RU RUDO
W U DGLW LRQ V W K DW  U HODW H W R D RQ H W LP H K LVW RU LFDO U HY HODW LRQ    7K H OLY LQ J  DOO
HQFRP SDVVLQJ$OO +DJ +DJ $OO*RGOLYHVLQXVW RRDVD'LYLQHSDUW LFLSDW LRQRQ
W KH ZKROH  +H DQQRXQFHV KLP VHOI ZLW K HW HUQDOO\ \RXQJ OLYLQJ HYHU QHZ DQG
HW HUQDOO\ DQFLHQW  UHYHODW LRQ  $V ORQJ DV ZH OLYH ZH DUH W KH OLYLQJ UHYHODW LRQ RI
W KH OLYLQJ *RG  7KH OLYLQJ *RG KDV SXW  KLV +DJ $OO ODZ LQW R RXU KHDUW V LQW R RXU
FRQVFLHQFH7KHFRQVFLHQFHLVQDP HGVREHFDXVHLW LVW KHP RVW VHFXUHH[SHULHQFH
RI JRG DW  DQ\ VHFRQG  7KHUH ZLW KLQ RXUVHOYHV ZH ILQG W KH W UDGLW LRQ RI W KH W UXH
UHYHODW LRQ W KDW  LV VFULEHG LQW R VSLULW XDO 5XQHV  , W  LV QRW  ZULW W HQ LQ GHDG OHW W HUV
E\ KXP DQ KDQGV LQW R SULQW HG DQG ZULW W HQ ERRNV  7KHVH ERRNV KDY H EHFRP H
HUURQHRXV DQG FRQIXVLQJ W KURXJKRXW  W KH FHQW XULHV ZKHQ W UDQVODW HG IURP  RQH
O D Q J X D J H  L Q W R  W K H  Q H [ W   S D VVL Q J  W K U R X J K  P D Q \  K H D G V D Q G  P H D Q L Q J V 
P LVXQGHUVW RRG DQG W KHLU P HDQLQJV W ZLVW HG

:H KDYH W R W HVW  DQG P HDVXUH W KH W UDGLW LRQ RQ W KH OLYLQJ UHYHODW LRQ RI W RGD\ LQ
W KH HW HUQDO QRZ ZKLFK ZH DUH  , W  VKRXOG QHYHU EH GRQH W KH RW KHU ZD\ DURXQG
7KHOLYLQJSHUVRQW KHSHUVRQDOLYHDORQHLVULJKW DOVREHIRU H*RG:HP XVW QRW
EHFRP H VODYHV RI D ORQJ GHDG SDVW  RI D IRUJHG SDVW  ZKLFK QHYHU H[LVW HG LQ W KH
P DQQHU LQ ZKLFK LW  LV SUHVHQW HG W R XV  /LYLQJ LQ D GHDG SDVW  P DNHV XV GHDG LW
P DNHVXVFDUULRQLW FDXVHVXVW RVW LQN*RGLVQRW DJRGRIW KHGHDGEXW D*RG
RIW KHOLYLQJ7KH*RGZKLFKZHUHFRJQL]HDQGFRQIHVVLVW KHOLYLQJ*RGRIW KH
SUHVHQW ZKRZRUNVKLVP LUDFOHVW KURXJKXVW RGD\DVKHGLGLQW KHSDVW DQGLQW KH
IXW XUH  7KH OLYLQJ DQG RQO\ W UXH *RG GRHV QRW KLQJ ZLW KRXW  XV DQG LI ZH GR QRW
SHUIRUP  KLV ZRUN LW  ZLOO UHP DLQ XQGRQH LQ HW HUQLW \   7KLV W KH FKXUFKHV SURYH W R
XV  W KH\ KDYH QRW  GRQH W KH ZRUN

:KDW  LP P HQVH UHVSRQVLELOLW \   %XW  DOVR Z KDW  UHGHHP LQJ FHUW DLQW \  RI W KH DOO
SUHVHQFH RI *RG LQ XV   :KDW  D VW LP XODW LQJ W KRXJKW  W R DFW LRQ
 

:H KDYH W R UH FUHDW H W KH ZRUOG DQG RXUVHOYHV ZH KDYH W R QHZ FU HDW H W R W KH
ZRUNRIJRGW RW KHKHDOLQJZRUNRIVDOYDW LRQZKLFKFDQRQO\EHDFW HGDQGGRQH
E\ XV  2QO\ E\ RXUVHOYHV

7KH P XUP XULQJ 5XQHV RI W KH XQLYHUVH W KH VDFUHG V\P EROV RI VDOY DW LRQ RI W KH
&RVP RV DUH GHHSO\ EXULHG ZLW KLQ RXUVHOYHV LQ RXU VRXO DV LQKHULW HG P HP RULHV
7KH\FDOOP XUP XUDQGUXVKZLW KLQXVDQGZHFRXOGQRW JHW W KHP RXW VLGHXVE\
LP LW DW LRQ LI W KH\ ZHUH QRW  EXLOW LQW R XV VLQFH HW HUQLW \

0D\ W KH P XUP XU RI W UXH 5XQHV VDYH XV W R DFW LRQ

$JDLQLQRXUGD\VDP XUP XURI5XQHVSHQHW UDW HVW KHZRUOGDQRXW SRXULQJRIW KH

P XUP XULQJSRZHURI5XQHVLQDOOODQJXDJHVDQGW RQJXHV7KURXJKW KHP W KH+RO\
6SLULW VSHDNVW RW KHZRUOGHVSHFLDOO\W RGD\W RW KH*HUP DQSHRSOHDQGLW DZDNHQV
W KHVSLULW RI3HQW HFRVW RIUHQHZDORIUHFRQVW LW XW LRQRIUH VKDSLQJRIQHZVKDSLQJ
RI DOO W KDW ¶V ZRUW KOHVV W R YDOXHV DQG RI DOO QRQ W KLQJV W R UHDO W KLQJV
 

;, ,
85 9, 6, 21
:K LFK  U HOLJ LRQ  ,
SURIHVV"
1RQ H RI  DQ \  W K DW
\RXP D\QDP H
$QGZ K\QRQH"
)R U  U H D V R Q V  R I
UHOLJLRQ
6FKLOOHU

7KH KXP DQ EHLQJ GRHV QRW  OLYH IURP  EUHDG DORQH EXW  KH OLYHV IU RP
HYHU\VLQJOHZRUGRI*RGW KDW FRP HVW KURXJKKLVP RXW K7KLVP HDQV
W KDW  KH ZKR GRHV QRW  FRQFHUQ KLP VHOI ZLW K TXHVW LRQV RI KLV KLJKHU
EHLQJDQGEHFRP LQJLVGRRP HGW RVSLULW XDOGHDW K2QO\HUURULJQRUDQFH
RU ZRUW KOHVVQHVV P DNH LW  SRVVLEOH W R DVVXP H W KDW  W KH $U\DQ KXP DQ
ZKR KDV EHHQ RULHQW HG W RZDUGV *RG VLQFH KLV 8U RULJLQ ZRXOG QRW
KDYH KDG KLJKHVW  NQRZOHGJH DQG ZLVGRP  LQ UHODW LRQ W R *RG DQG W KH
ZRUOG IURP  W LP H LP P HP RULDO  6KRXOG ZH UHDOO\ EHOLHYH W KDW  KH W KH
FUHDW RURIDOOFXOW XUHDUW UHOLJLRQVFLHQFHDQGW HFKQRORJ\ QHHGHGW R
W DNHRYHUW KHW UXHFRQFHSW RI*RGIURP W KHGHJHQHUDW HG(DVW ", W W RRN
FHQW XULHV RI XQLQW HUUXSW HG GLVW RUW LRQV W R FDXVH W KH *HUP DQ W R ERZ
XQGHU  W KH \ RN H RI D IRU HLJQ LGHD W KDW  VLFN  RI D EU RN HQ VRXO KH
KLP VHOI W RRN RYHU W KH OLH DQG UHSHDW HG LW 

7KH FKXUFKHV EURXJKW  W KH HUURQHRXV LGHD LQW R W KH ZRUOG W KDW  W KH\
ZHUH W KH RQHV ZKR ILUVW  EURXJKW  P RUDOV DQG RUGHU W R KXP DQV  4XLW H
W KH FRQW UDU\ LV W KH W UXW K  $OO ROG UHOLJLRQV W KDW  EXLOW  XSRQ W KH 8U
U HOLJ LRQ  RI  W K H *RG  FRQ Q HFW HG  $U \ DQ  K X P DQ   W DX J K W  DE RX W  W K H
RP QLSUHVHQW  *RG DERXW  W KH IDW KHU RI DOO JRGV DQG KXP DQV DQG W KH\
SUHDFKHG W KH UHVXUUHFW LRQ RI OLIH QRW  RI W KH ERG\  ³$ERYH DOO JRGV LV
$OO IDW KHU KH OLY HV W KU RXJKRXW  DOO DJHV´ W HOOV XV W KH *\ OIDJLQQLQJ
7KLV $OO IDW KHU LV QRW  :RGDQ ZKR SHULVKHV LQ W KH W ZLOLJKW  RI W KH JRGV
$OO IDW KHUGRHVQRW NQRZDQ\W ZLOLJKW RIW KHJRGV+HOLYHVW KURXJKRXW
W KH DJHV  7KH JRGV RI W KH *HUP DQV ZHUH DOZD\V IRUP V RI VSHFLILF
GLYLQH HQHUJLHV RU SHUVRQLILFDW LRQV RI QDW XUDO IRUFHV   7KHLU LQLW LDW HV
QHYHU³ ZRUVKLSSHG´ :RGDQ'RQDURU)UH\D, W ZDVDIRON UHOLJLRQRU
YHU\EURDGLQW HUSUHW DW LRQEHW W HU\HW D)RONVDQVFKDXXQJ  ZKLFKZDV
QHYHUGRFW ULQHRIIDLW KRUVDFUDP HQW :KHQW KHVHW KLQJVZHUHEHOLHYHG
W KHQ QHY HU  Z LW K W KH VW U LFW QHVV DQG RQH VLGHGQHVV Z LW K Z KLFK W KH
DUP \RIVDLQW VDUHZRUVKLSSHGLQRXUGD\V7KLVDUP \RIVDLQW VE\W KH
ZD\ KDSSHQHG EHFDXVH RI D QHHG IRU W KH ROG *HUP DQV W R HQOLYHQ W KH

 2PLWWHG

/LNHZ HOW DQVFKDXXQJ Z RUOGYLHZ RUSKLORVRSK\DERXW W KHZ RUOG, W UDQVODW HKHUH
GLUHFW W RIRONVDQVFKDXXQJ SKLORVRSK\RIW KHIRON
 

KHDYHQ DQG W KH HDUW K ZLW K SLFW XUHVTXH UHSUHVHQW DW LRQV   :H KDYH W R FRQVLGHU
W KDW  ZKHQ ZH HUURQHRXVO\ W DNH W KH (GGD DQG RW KHU VHFUHW  W UDGLW LRQV OLW HUDOO\
7DNHQOLW HUDOO\VXFKVFULSW XUHVDUHQRQVHQVHRUGRJP DGHSHQGLQJRQRXUDW W LW XGH
1HLW KHUKRZHYHULVFRUUHFW :KDW ZHHYHQW XDOO\P DQDJHGW RGRLQW KHILJKW RYHU
VRXOV DQG ERGLHV ZDV W KH VROLGLILFDW LRQ RI W KH SXUH W HDFKLQJV RI W KH &KULVW  IRU
W KH EHW W HU RQHV W KH JRRG RQHV W KH *RW KV  %HFDXVH QRZKHUH GRHV W KH VSLULW  RI
W KHSXUHVW NQRZOHGJHRI*RGDQGUHOLJLRQYDQLVKDVIDVW DVLW GRHVLQW KHKHDGV
DQG KHDUW V RI W KH QRQ JRRG RQHV W KH QRQ *RW KV

(YHU\ XQSUHM XGLFHG REVHUYHU VKRXOG JHW  W KH FOHDU LQVLJKW  W KDW  W KH JRGV KHURHV
DQGP RQVW HUVRIW KHROGLP DJLQDU\ZRUOGDUHEXW V\P EROVRIDQLQILQLW HGLYHUVLW \
RIW KH'LYLQH8U SRZHU7KH$U\DQZKRLVSXUHLQP LQGRUERG\ ERW KDUHVHSDUDEOH
DQG SRVVLEOH LQGHSHQGHQW O\ EHFDXVH RI W KH XQLQW HUUXSW HG K\EULGL]DW LRQ  KDV
UHFRJQL]HG*RGRUW KH'LYLQHRQO\ZLW KLQKLP VHOIDW DOOW LP HVDQGDOOSODFHV7KLV
ZD\ KH VKDSHG KLV VRXO W R D KRXVH RI W KH 'LYLQH W R W KH KLJKHVW  H[W HQW  DV RQO\
KH FRXOG GR

7KH VP DOO DQG W KH ORZO\ RQH LQ VSLULW  KDV D VP DOO DQG ORZO\ JRG DQG KH FDQ
P HDVXUH KLP  LQ OHQJW K DQG LQ ZLGW K LQ DQ LP DJLQHG RU P HQW DOO\ FRQVW UXFW HG
UHDOLW \  7KH VRXO RI W KH *UHDW  DQG +LJK 2QH KDV D JUHDW  DQG DOO HQFRP SDVVLQJ
*RG   Z KHU H Z RXOG EH W KHU H U RRP  IRU  U XOHV FRQIHVVLRQV GRJP DV  W HP SRU DO
SXQLVKP HQW DQGHW HUQDOSDLQ"1RUHOLJLRQLVKLJKHUW KDQW UXW K 7KLVLVDSULQFLSOH
W KDW DOO³ FRQIHVVLRQV´ DUHIRUFHGW RW UDP SOHZLW KW KHLUIHHW 6RW KH\ZDQW W RW DNH
W KH FUHDW LRQ P \W KV RI W KH %LEOH OLW HUDOO\  (VSHFLDOO\ W KRVH FU HDW LRQ P \W KV ZKHQ
UHDG DQG HYDOXDW HG FRUUHFW O\ FDQ UHYHDO W R XV VHFUHW V RI KXP DQ HYROXW LRQ DQG
KXP DQ FUHDW LRQ ZKLFK ZRXOG SXOO DZD\ W KH JURXQG XQGHU W KH OLW HUDOLVW V RI DOO
NLQG  %HFDXVH W KRVH W RR DUH QRW  ULJKW  ZKR ZRXOG QRW  JLYH DQ\ VFLHQW LILF RU
KLVW RULFDO VLJQLILFDQFH W R W KH FUHDW LRQ P \W KV RI DOO UDFHV DQG SHRSOHV  , W  LV VW LOO
XSW RXVW RGHILQHW KH$U\DQFRQFHSW RI*RGDVW KH(GGDW HDFKHVLW :HZLOOP LVV
VFLHQW LILFGLVFXVVLRQVDERXW W KDW LQW KH1RUGLFW UDGLW LRQV:KDW ZHH[SHULHQFHRI
LW  ZH KDYH W R UHDG IURP  W KH P HDQLQJ RI W KH LGHDV DQG P \W KV SUHVHQW HG  2QO\
LI ZH UHDFK D IXOO LP SUHVVLRQ DQG LQVLJKW  IURP  W KH :HOW DQVFKDXXQJ RI W KH ROG
*HUP DQV ZH DUH M XVW LILHG W R M XGJH W KLV TXHVW LRQ   , Q DQ\ FDVH LW  LV FHUW DLQ W KDW
ZH FDQQRW  ILQG W KH VOLJKW HVW  DOOXVLRQ RI DQ\ GRJP D RU UXOH RI IDLW K LQ W KH VRQJV
DQG QDUUDW LRQV  7KHVH KDYH EHHQ KDSS\ KXP DQV W KDW  ZHUH SHUP HDW HG E\ W KHLU
FRQVFLRXVQHVV RI *RG LQ VXFK D ZD\ W KDW  W KH\ KDG QHLW KHU ZRUG QRU GHVFULSW LRQ
RI LW 


2PLWWHG
 

7KLVLVQRW D*RGLQSHUVRQZLW KEHJLQQLQJDQGHQGODUJHRUVP DOOVL]HEXW *RG

ZLW KLQP \VHOIZLW KLQ\RXDQGZLW KLQDQRW KHUSHUVRQDVVP DOORUODUJHDVZHDUH
VP DOORUODUJHRXUVHOYHVDVVHOIRUQRQ VHOIDV, DP VHOIRUQRQ VHOIP \VHOI)URP
W KHUH FRP HV W KDW  P HQW LRQ LQ W KH (GGD LQ W KH ³ GD]]OH RI W KH JRGV´  W KDW  *RG KDV
P DQ\ QDP HV DP RQJ W KH KXP DQV DQG SHRSOHV DOO RI W KHP  ODFNLQJ SHUIHFW LRQ
HYHQ LI W KH\ VHDUFKHG DQG UHVHDUFKHG ZLW KRXW  HQG W R ILQG W KH SHUIHFW  QDP H IRU
*RG

7+( 1$0(6 2) :2'$1

:DQGHUHU, DP FDOOHGKHOSIXODQGZLVK
6NLOOHGLQP DQ\W KLQJVZLW KP DQ\VKDSHVILOOHU
(YLOGRHU, DP FDOOHGEURDG KDW DQGEURDG EHDUG
'HFHLYHUIUDXGUHYHDOHU

&KDQJLQJZHDW KHULQJIORZHUFRQVHUYHU
%XUQHUEOLQGHUFULP LQDO
(P EHU H\HVKLQLQJH\HVOHHSHUVKDNHU
0DVW HU RI IORRGV SURW HFW RU RI FDUJRHV

&DUULHURIKHOP HW , DP FDOOHGDVZHOOUXOHUDQGVKLHOGRIW KHDUP \

7LHRIW KHDUP \GHVLUHRIW KHDUP \H[DOW HU
&DOOHUVSHDNHUDQGULGHULQW KHEDW W OH
:LVHRQHDQGSRHW DQGW KLQNHU

=HDORXV LQ FRXQVHO RZQHU DW  KRP H

:L]DUGDQGJUD\ EHDUGZLW KW KHJRGV
7KHKLJKRQHHTXDOKLJKDQGW KLUGRQH, DP 
&UHDW RUDQGVKLSSHURIW KHGHDG

$OO IDW KHUEDW W OHIDW KHUUHW XUQZDW FKHU

)DW KHU RI YLFW RU\ JRG RI DOO JRGV
1RZ, DP FDOOHG:RGDQDQG, EHFDP HDKRUULI\HUW R\RX
'RQDU, ZDVFDOOHGORQJEHIRUHW KLV

:LW KP DQ\QDP HVDOUHDG\, QDP HGP \VHOI

6LQFH, P LQJOHGZLW KKXP DQV
)URP  DOO W KRVH :RGDQ EHFDP H W KH 2QH
³ *ULP P HU´ , DP FDOOHGE\*HURG

*HURG\RXGUXQNDUGZKDW IRUGLG\RXGULQN\RXUILOO"
7KH P HDG EHFDP H \RXU P DVW HU
$QG JUHDW  W KLQJV \RX P LVVHG W KDQNV W R ³ *ULP P HU´ 
7KH IDYRURIW KHDUP LHV DQG :RGDQ

, W HOO\RXP DQ\W KLQJV\RXUP LQGFDQQRW JUDVSDQ\W KLQJ

7KHUHIRUHEHLQJIDLW KIXOW R\RX, KDYHW RGHFHLYH\RX
, W KLQN, VHHDOUHDG\IXOORIEORRG
7KH VZRUG RI P \ SURW pJp O\LQJ W KHUH
(GGD
 

:H VHH KHUH W KDW  W KH DQFLHQW  RQHV ZHUH ZLVH W KH\ GLG QRW  FOLQJ W R W KH OHW W HUV
DQG QDP HV  *RG IRU W KHP  ZDV HYHU\W KLQJ W KH JRRG DQG W KH HYLO DOLNH DV W KH
ZKROHFRQW HQW RIW KHH[LVW HQFHRIW KHZRUOG$FFRUGLQJW RW KHVRQJZKRFDQQRW
UHFRJQL]H W KDW  *RG KDV W R FDUU\ KLP  EHFDXVH RI IDLW KIXOQHVV LH IROORZLQJ W KH
ODZ RI W KH 7+5(( RI W KH 752-$ EHFDXVH W KH QDP H ZLOO QHYHU EH HQRXJK  *RG
ZLOODOZD\VEHGLIIHUHQW IRU\RXDVZHOODVIRUHYHU\ERG\HOVH, W ZLOOEHDFFRUGLQJ
W R KRZ \RX RU DQRW KHU FDQ FRQFHLYH RI LW   ³ <RX ORRN HTXDO W R W KH VSLULW  RI ZKRP
\RX KDYH D FRQFHSW  QRW  P H´  LV D GHHS ZRUG ZULW W HQ E\ W KH VRQ RI W KH JRGV
*RHW KH ZKR HYHQ LQ KLV QDP H LQGLFDW HV RULJLQ LQ W KH 'LYLQH DQG IURP  W KUHH
W KRXVDQG\HDUVDJRKLVEURW KHULQ*RGDQGW KH³ 5DW D´3\W KDJRUDVDQVZHUVKLP 
(TXDO LV RQO\ XQGHUVW RRG E\ HTXDO

$ VW RQH LV VXIILFLHQW  IRU W KH 1HJUR   IRU W KH ³ &KULVW LDQ´    LQ GHILDQFH RI KLV GHHS
QDP HDJRG³ LQKHDYHQ´ LVVXIILFLHQW ZKRP KHSHVW HUVZLW KKLVSHW W \SDLQVDQG
ZLVKHV DQG ZKR SXQLVKHV RU SUDLVHV KLP  LQ UHW XUQ

7RP DQ\VP DOO VRXOVW KLVRUW KDW ERRNEHFDP H*RG7KRVHDUHW KHEOLQGHVW RQHV
RIDOO7KH\VDFULILFHW KLV0RORFKW KHLU'LYLQHUHDVRQDQGW KHEOLVVIXOQHVVRIW KHLU
KHDUW V DQG LQ KLV VHUYLFH W KH\ EHFRP H W KH P RVW  M HDORXV RQHV ZKR ODFN DQ\ DQG
DOO M R\  7KH\ W U\ W R JLYH OLIH W R W KH GHDG OHW W HUV ZLW K DOO P HDQV SRVVLEOH EXW
GDUNQHVV UHP DLQV XQP RYHG DERYH W KHLU KHDGV

*RG LV IRU XV W KH $ DQG 2 W KH EHJLQQLQJ DQG W KH HQG ZLW KRXW  EHJLQQLQJ DQG
ZLW KRXW  HQG KH OLYHV W KURXJK XV DQG ZH OLYH W KURXJK KLP   +H LV JUHDW  LQ W KH
JUHDW HVW W KLQJVDQGVP DOOLQW KHVP DOOHVW W KLQJVKHLVP DW W HUDQGHQHUJ\ZKLFK
ILOO W KH Z RU OG DQG Z KLFK ILOO DQG HQOLYHQ VSLU LW  DQG VRXO  *RG LV DOO DQG LW  LV
QRW KLQJ DV DOVR VLQJV W KH ³ &KHUXE ZDQGHUHU´ 

*RGLVW UXO\QRW KLQJDQGLIKHLVVRP HW KLQJ

+HLVLW RQO\ZLW KLQP HDVKHFKRRVHVP HIRUKLP 

, Q*RGQRW KLQJLVUHFRJQL]HG KHLVDQHW HUQDO2QH

:KDW RQHUHFRJQL]HVLQKLP W KDW RQHKDVW REHKLP VHOI

, Q*RGHYHU\W KLQJLV*RG $VLQJOHVP DOOZRUP

, VLQ*RGDVP XFKDVW KRXVDQGJRGV

2IZKDW VKDSHLVP \*RG"*RORRNDW \RXUVHOI

:KRORRNVDW KLP VHOILQ*RGORRNVW UXO\DW *RG

*RGGZ HOOVLQDOLJKW W RZ KLFKZ HKDYHQRW UDFN

:KRGRHVQRW EHFRP HLW KLP VHOIZ LOOQRW VHHKLP LQHW HUQLW \

*RGGZ HOOVZ LW KLQKLP VHOIKLVHVVHQFHLVKLVKRXVH

7KHUHIRUHKHGRHVQRW OHDYHKLV'LYLQLW \

, QW UXW KJRGLVGHHSZ LGHLQP HUFLIXOQHVV

+LJKLQDOO P LJKW DQGORQJLQHW HUQLW \

 2PLWWHG
 

7R DOO VRQV RI *RG  *RG Z DV W KH FHQW HU  RI W KHLU  H[ LVW HQFH  LQW R Z KLFK W KH\
HQFORVHG W KHP VHOYHV RU *RG ZDV W KHLU FLUFXP IHUHQFH LQW R ZKLFK W KH\ VSUHDG
1RW KLQJ HOVH LV W R VHH LQ ³ &KULVW ´ W KH VRQ RI W KH JRGV DQG HYHU\ &KULVW  FKDVHV
W KH ZRUG FKDQJHUV ZKR IDOVHO\ XVH KLV QDP H RXW  RI DOO W HP SOHV VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V

7KHUHIRUH LW  LV W KH IXOILOOP HQW  RI W KH ODZ DQG LW  LV M XVW  LI *RG LV QRW  LQ W KRVH DQG
QHYHUFDQEHLQW KRVHZKRVHDUFKKLP RXW VLGHRIW KHP VHOYHVLQDGUHDU\UHDOLW \  
, Q DOO W KDW  LV W KDW  KDV EHHQ DQG W KDW  ZLOO EH *RG P DQLIHVW V W KH VSLULW  RI *RG
EHFRP HV VKDSH LQ W KH ZRUP  DV ZHOO DV LQ KLV ³ VRQV´  &KULVW  3\W KDJRUDV DQG
KXQGUHG RW KHU JUHDW  VSLULW V ZKR OLYHG DOUHDG\ P LOOLRQV RI \HDUV DJR DQG ZLOO OLYH
DJDLQ DQG DJDLQ VW LOO DIW HU P LOOLRQV RI \HDUV

)URP  W KH $U\DQ SULHVW  VFKRROV W KH GHYHORSP HQW  RI W KHVH W KRXJKW V ZDV VSUHDG
RYHU W KH ZKROH SODQHW  W KRXVDQGV RI \HDUV DJR

7KLV NQRZOHGJH ZDV W UDQVIHUUHG W R W KH KHLUV RI W KH ROG $U\DQ SU LHVW  P \VW HU\
VFKRROV W R RUGHUV DQG VFKRROV RI SULHVW V W R W KH )UHH 0DVRQV W R W KH .QLJKW V
7HP SODU (J\SW LDQV *UHHNV *HUP DQV , QGLDQV W R W KH FKXUFKHV 5RP H &KXUFK
&XOGHDQ FKXUFKDVZHOODV7LEHW  FKXUFK W RW KH5RVLFUXFLDQVDQGJURXSVFKXUFKHV
DQG FOXEV RI DQ\ GHVFULSW LRQ DQG QDP H

'R \RX NQRZ W KH XOW LP DW H VHFUHW "

7KH XOW LP DW H VHFUHW  LV  (W HUQDO UHW XUQ  (ZLJH :LHGUHNHKU

7KLV LV W KH ZRUG W KDW  :RGDQ ZKLVSHUHG LQW R W KH HDU RI KLV GHDG VRQ  , W  LV 7+(
:25'W KHP DVW HU ZRUGW KDW ZDVORVW  ZKLFKHYHU\RQHKDVW RILQGDJDLQKLP VHOI
E\ P HDQV RI KLV RZQ LQLW LDW LRQ  , W  LV W KH ZRUG W KDW  FDXVHG W KH LQLW LDW HV RI 6LOV
0DULD GDQFH LQ W KH HFVW DV\ RI KLJKHVW  LQVLJKW  DQG NQRZOHGJH

6XFK NQRZOHGJH H[SDQGV  LW  JURZV DQG W KULYHV DURXQG LW VHOI LQ W KH KHDUW  RI W KH
KXP DQZKHUHKHKDVIRXQGW KHRQHURRW RUEDVLVLQ2GKLQW KHHW HUQDOEUHDW K  
2QFH IRXQG DOO VRXUFHV RI NQRZOHGJH VW UHDP  W KHLU ZLVGRP  W R KLP  HIIRUW OHVVO\

:KR H[SHU LHQFHV KLV KLJKHU  6HOI LQ GHHSHVW  FRQVFLRXVQHVV DV VRP HW KLQJ 8U 
EDVLF LQGHSHQGHQW  DQG LP P RUW DO KH FDQ FDOP O\ DOORZ DOO ³ UHODW LYLW \´  RI VSDFH


 2PLWWHG

2GHP  *HUP DQZRUGIRUEUHDW K7KLVZRUGLVXVHGLQSRHW U\RQO\
 

DQG W LP H SDVV RYHU KLP  LW  W RXFKHV KLP  DV P XFK DV RW KHU W KLQJV W KDW  FDQ EH
W DNHQ DV VRP HW KLQJ RI OLW W OH LP SRUW DQFH  $OO NQRZOHGJH FRQFHUQLQJ P DW W HU LV
³ UHODW LYH´6LQFHW KH³ *UHDW 6W RRSHG2QH  ´ FDQQRW UHFRJQL]HW KHDEVROXW HEHKLQG
LW  ZKLFK ZH FDOO HW HUQLW \ RU JRG RU DOO VRXO EHFDXVH KH KDV QR SDUW  RI LW  KH
VFUHDP V ZLW K FKLOGLVK IHDU EXW  ZLW K LP SXGHQFH  ³ 'RQ¶W  W UXVW  \RXU H\HV OHVV \HW
\RXU KHDUW V DOO LV UHODW LYH LQGHILQLW H DQG VW UHW FKDEOH  'RQ¶W  P DNH DQ\ HIIRUW 
\RX ZLOO QRW  ILQG DQ\W KLQJ ZKHUH ,  W RR GLG QRW  ILQG DQ\W KLQJ´

7KH P \VW LF LV W KH SHUIHFW  KXP DQ EHLQJ  KH VHHV FOHDUHVW  DQG SXUHVW  KH VHHV VR
ZHOO W KH LOOXVLRQ RI W KLV ZRUOG W KDW  ZH FDOO UHDOLW \ ZLW K KLV ILYH VHQVHV  0RVW  RI
W KH W LP H KH VHHV LW  P XFK EHW W HU W KDQ W KH SRRU ³ P DQ RI UHDOLW \´ EXW  KH GRHV QRW
UHO\ DORQH RQ KLV ILYH VHQVHV EHFDXVH KH KDV W HQ P RUH VHQVHV RI ZKLFK W KH
³ UHDOLVW ´ KDVQRRSLQLRQDQGZKLFKKHW KHUHIRUHUHQRXQFHV7KHW UXW KLVEHKLQG
W KLV ZRUOG RI SKHQRP HQD  2QO\ ZKR LV FDSDEOH RI W KLQNLQJ LGHDOLVW LFDOO\ KDV D
UHDOLVW LF M XGJP HQW   7KH VR FDOOHG LQW HOOHFW XDO ZLOO DOZD\V P LVFDOFXODW H EHFDXVH
RQO\ W KH LGHDOLVW LF YLHZ FDQ SUHYHQW  KLP  IURP  P DNLQJ W KH ZURQJ FRQFOXVLRQV

2QO\W KHP XFK P DOLJQHGLGHDOLVW KDVDFRUUHFW M XGJP HQW FRQFHUQLQJW KHSUDFW LFDO
QHFHVVLW LHVIRUVW DW HVFLHQFHDQGM XVW LFHDVZHOODVLQDOORW KHUTXHVW LRQVRIOLIH
7KLV LV VR EHFDXVH KLV RULHQW DW LRQ LV LGHDOLVW LF ZKLFK P HDQV ZKLFK KLJK VSLULW 
DQG W KLQNLQJ ZLW KLQ D ODUJH IUDP H RI UHIHUHQFH  +H GRHV QRW  M XGJH HYHU\W KLQJ
VP DOO VFDOH DQ G ORRN LQ J I RU  DGY DQ W DJHV  K H LV Q RW  LQ I OX HQ FHG E\  SU DFW LFDO
FRQVLGHUDW LRQV1HYHUW KHOHVVKHLVRYHUZKHOP LQJO\W KH³ SUDFW LFDO´ DQG³ UHDOLVW LF´
RQH EHFDXVH KH LV W KH LGHDOLVW LF SHUIHFW  DQG OHDGLQJ DVVHVVRU  , Q RXU GD\V DQG
SRVVLEO\  DOU HDG\  IRU  D ORQJ W LP H EHIRU H W KH Z RU OG LV U XOHG VR P XFK Z LW KRXW
UHDVRQ DQG GLVRUGHUO\ EHFDXVH LW  LV DW  W KH P HUF\ RI W KH ³ SUDFW LFDO´  SHRSOH DQG
W KH ³ UHDOLVW V´ W KH H[SHUW V

+DQG RYHU W KH OHDGHUVKLS RI \RXU GHVW LQLHV W R W KH LGHDOLVW V DJDLQ ZKLFK P HDQV
W R W KH RQO\ KRQRUDEOH SHRSOH DP RQJ ZKLFK DUH DOZD\V W KH FUHDW LYHO\ VNLOOHG
RQHV1HYHUDJDLQKDQGLW RYHUW RW KH³ SUDFW LFDO´ SHUVRQZKRLVQHYHUFDSDEOHRI
W KLQN LQJ RU  DFW LQJ P DW W HU  RI IDFW O\  EHFDXVH KH KDV DOZ D\ V W KH P RP HQW DU \
DGYDQW DJH LQ P LQG  Z KHW KHU  SHU VRQDO RU  IRU  W KH ³ JHQHUDO SXEOLF´   :LW K W KH
LGHDOLVW W KHVSLULW XDODW W LW XGHLVYLFW RULRXVRYHUW KHHFRQRP LFEHOO\RIW KH³ SUDFW LFDO
RQH´ DQG W KH IUDXGXOHQW  RU GHIUDXGHG ³ H[SHUW ´  GLVDSSHDUV LQ W KH DE\VV


 2PLWWHG
 

7KH P \VW LF OLYHV LQ W KH KLQJH RI W KH ZRUOG

/HW ¶V DVVXP H \RX DQG ,  DUH W KH W ZR ERDUGV RI D GRRU W KDW  DUH VLGH E\ VLGH  <RX
DUHW KHERDUGFORVHUW RW KHORFNZKLOH, DP W KHRW KHUSODQNEDFNDW W KHKLQJH$P
, GRLQJOHVVW RRSHQDQGFORVHW KHGRRUM XVW EHFDXVH, UXQDURXQGOHVVW KDQ\RX
LH ,  DP  P DNLQJ D FLUFOH ZLW K D VKRUW HU UDGLXV"  $ ZLVH RQH W ROG KLV \RXQJHU
IULHQG W KDW  W KLV ZD\ ,  DSSHDU W R EH OHVV P RYLQJ W KDW  \RX  , I \RX DV LW  VHHP V
P DNH W KH ODUJHVW  P RYHP HQW  ,  LQ UHW XUQ DP  FORVHU W R W KH KLQJH W KH FHQW HU RI
W XUQLQJ   RI W KUHH LQJ     DQG ,  KHOS FDUU\LQJ \RX

³ :KDW  ZRXOG D JRG EH ZKR SXVKHG RQO\ IURP  W KH RXW VLGH
LIKHOHW UXQW KHXQLYHUVHLQDFLUFXODUP RW LRQRQKLVILQJHU
, W EHKRRYHVKLP W RP RYHW KHZRUOGLQLW VLQW HULRU
7RFDUHRIQDW XUHZLW KLQW RFDUHIRUKLP VHOILQQDW XUH
6RW KDW ZKDW OLYHVLQKLP ZKDW ZHDYHVDQGLVLQKLP 
1HYHUP LVVHVKLVSRZHUDQGKLVVSLULW ´
*RHW K H
<HVZHFODLP DQGZHFDQSURYHLW  7KH&KULVW LDQ&KXUFKRUEHW W HUW KH&KULVW LDQ
W HDFKLQJ GLG QRW  RU LJLQDW H LQ 3DOHVW LQH EXW  LV DQ 8U  FU HDW LRQ RI W KH VXQN HQ
$W ODQW HDQFXOW XUH)URP W KHUHP DLQGHUVRIW KLVFRQW LQHQW $W ODQW LVLW FDP HILUVW W R
, UHODQG DQG 6FRW ODQG W KDQ IXUW KHU W R W KH (DVW  DQG VLP XOW DQHRXVO\ :HVW  W R W KH
$P HULFDQ FRQW LQHQW   7KH DQFLHQW  (J\SW LDQ FXOW XUH RQ W KH RQH KDQG DQG W KH
DQFLHQW $P HULFDQFXOW XUHVRIW KH, QFDVW KH0D\DQVDQGW KH$]W HFVRQW KHRW KHU
DUH FRUQHUVW RQHV W KDW  UHP DLQHG IURP  W KH IRUP HU $W ODQW HDQ EXLOGLQJ RI D ZRUOG
FXOW XUH

7KH DQFLHQW  SHRSOHV VW LOO NQHZ DERXW  W KDW  KRZ HOVH FRXOG ZH LQW HUSUHW  W KH IDFW
W KDW  ZKHQ 0H[LFR ZDV GLVFRYHUHG ZH IRXQG W KHUH W KH ZKROH &KULVW LDQ W UDGLW LRQ
DV LW  UHP DLQHG LQ W KH &DW KROLF &KXUFK DQG DOVR LQ 7LEHW  W R W KLV GD\  7KRVH DUH
W KLQJV RI ZKLFK SHRSOH GR QRW  OLNH W R W DON EHFDXVH W KH\ W KUHDW HQ W R XQGHUP LQH
W KH VW UXFW XUHV RI OLHV W KDW  P HQW LRQV W KH RULJLQ RI &KULVW LDQLW \ LQ W KH 1HDU (DVW
OHVV W KDQ  \HDUV DJR

&KULVW LDQLW \ DQG LW V P \W K DUH DV DQFLHQW  DV KXP DQV RI GLYLQH EU HDW K FRXOG W KLQN
DQG OLY H  0DQ\  KXQGU HGV RI W KRXVDQGV RI \ HDU V DU H QRW  VXIILFLHQW  IRU  W KDW 
EHFDXVH W KLV DQFLHQW  LV W KH IDFW  RI KXP DQLW \ EHLQJ FKDUDFW HUL]HG E\ EHLQJ VRQV
RI *RG  7KH 8U $U\DQ $W ODQW HDQ FRQFHSW  RI *RG ZDV NHSW  DOLYH IRU W KH ORQJHVW
W LP HLQW KH1RUW KRI(XURSHZKHUHW KHVSURXW VRI$W ODQW LVZHUHEORRP LQJDOOW KH
ZD\ W R RXU W LP HV RQ , RQD DQG W KH , VOH RI 0DQ  6W UDQJH HQRXJK IURP  W KHUH W KH
VXSSRVHGO\ILUVW ³ &KULVW LDQ´ P LVVLRQDULHVFDP HDQGW KH\IRXQGHGW KHILUVW &KULVW LDQ
&KXUFKW KH&KXUFKRIW KH&XOGHDQV/DW HURQO\LQW KHW KDQGW KFHQW XULHVW KH
5RP DQ FKXUFK FRXOG GHVW UR\ W KH EOHVVHG ZRUN RI W KHVH W UXH &KULVW LDQV LQ VSLULW 
DW W LW XGHDQGW HDFKLQJV7KHFKXUFKRIW KH1RUW KZKRZHQW GRZQW RRNW KHVHFUHW
RILW VRULJLQZLW KLW LQW RW KHJUDYHW KDW W KH5RP DQ3RZHU&KXUFKGXJIRULW %XW 
W RGD\ W KH 2FFLGHQW DO GLVW RUW LRQ RI W KH W HDFKLQJV RI &KULVW  H[SHULHQFHV W KH W UXW K
W KDW LW P D\EHDEOHW RNLOOW KHERG\EXW QRW W KHVSLULW 7KLVVDFUHGVSLULW RIW UXW K
'UHKXQJ W XUQLQJ'UHLXQJ W KUHH LQJ*RUVOHEHQM RLQVW KHVHW Z RZ RUGVDVDUHIHUHQFHW RW KH


+RO\7ULQLW \
 

ULVHVW RGD\DVW KHP DVW HUDQGORUGRIW KLVFKXUFKDQGKHZLOORYHUFRP HLW DQGLW V

W KLQNLQJ LQ ZRUGV
³$QGLI&KULVW KDGEHHQERUQLQ%HW KOHKHP DW KRXVDQGW LP HV
$QGQRW ZLW KLQ\RXUVHOI\RXUVRXOZRXOGJHW ORVW KHUHUHJDUGOHVV
<RX ORRN LQ YDLQ W R W KH FURVV LQ *ROJRW KD
LI\RXGLGQRW HUHFW LW ZLW KLQ\RXUVHOIDOUHDG\´
$QJHOXV6LOHVLXV

)URP  W KH ODQG RI ³ :DOHV´ W KUHH SDW KV OHDG W R 1RUW K (DVW  DQG 6RXW K ZKLFK DUH
P DUNHG E\ W KH JUDQGLRVH VHW W LQJV RI VW RQHV RI W KH P HJDOLW KLF W RP EV  7KH ILUVW
RQH OHDGV DORQJ W KH FRDVW V RI W KH 1RUW K 6HD DQG %DOW LF 6HD FURVVHV RYHU W R
6ZHGHQ DQG 1RUZD\ W KHQ P RYHV DORQJ W KH 9ROJD ULYHU 6RXW KHDVW  W R , QGLD  7KH
VHFRQGSDW KJRHV6RXW KDORQJW KHFRDVW RI)UDQFHVW DUW LQJIURP DP DLQFURVVLQJ
SRLQW  LQ W KH %UHW DJQH  , W  OHDGV W KURXJK 6SDLQ 3RUW XJDO *UHHFH DQG $VLD 0LQRU
DOZD\V FORVH W R W KH FRDVW   7KH W KLUG SDW K OHDGV M RLQW O\ ZLW K W KH VHFRQG RQH W R
6SDLQ EXW  W KHQ FURVVHV RYHU W R $IULFD JRHV DORQJ LW V 1RUW KHUQ FRDVW  HYHQW XDOO\
ZLW KW KHVDP HJRDOLQW RW KH)DU(DVW 7KLVZDVW KHSDW KRIFXOW XUHIURP :HVW W R
(DVW  ZKLFK IROORZHG W KH $U\DQ P LJUDW LRQ  7KH ZRUG ³ H[ RULHQW H OX[´  LV LQVRIDU
M XVW LILHG DV ZH KDYH W R GR KHUH ZLW K D SDUW LDO UHIOX[ RI D FXOW XUDO ZDYH LQ W KH
P LOOHQQLD W KDW  IROORZHG  7KLV KRZHYHU LV QRW  GLIIHUHQW  W KDQ W KH VLW XDW LRQ W KDW
P DQ\ W KLQJV FRP H EDFN W R XV IURP  $P HULFD ZKLFK ZH FDUULHG W KHU H LQ W KH ILUVW
SODFH  2ODI .ULW ]LQJHU JDYH D ZHDOW K RI VW LP XODW LQJ W KRXJKW V LQ DQ LQW HOOLJHQW
HVVD\FRQFHUQLQJW KH5XQHVLQYROXP H RIW KH³ 6RQQH´+HP HQW LRQVW KHUH
DVZHOOW KHLVODQGRI-RQDDQGLW VVLJQLILFDQFHDVDVW DUW LQJSRLQW RIW KH$W ODQW HDQ
$U\DQ NQRZOHGJH DIW HU W KH VLQNLQJ RI W KH ODVW  UHP DLQGHUV RI $W ODQW LV W KH , VODQG
3RVHLGRQLV DV 3ODW R FDOOHG LW 

-RQDLVW KHP RW KHUODQGRIW KH-DRQHVW KH-RDQHVW KH, RQLDQVZKLFKDOVRDSSHDU

XQGHUW KHQDP H-DZRQHV-XQLRU-XQR'LRQH'LRQ=LRQ, RQDQGGHULYDW LYHVRI
W KLV ZRUG ZKLFK P HDQV W KH ³ ZDONLQJ RQHV´ GLH ³ M HKHQGHQ´  LQ GLDOHFW  

7KH³ ZDONLQJRQHV´  JHKHQM HKHQW RJR DUHW KHHDUW K ERUQVRQVRIW KHFHOHVW LDO
SDW K P DNHUV  7ZHQW \ W ZR NLQJV RI W KHVH VRQV RI JRGV ZKR DW  W LP HV KDYH W KH
QDP H RI VW DUV DUH EXULHG LQ W KH VRLO RI -HQD  7KLV OHJHQG RI W KH DQFLHQW  .HOW LF
SRHW U\LVW RXQGHUVW DQGDVIROORZV W KHNQRZOHGJHRINLQJVLVEXULHGLHW KH
$U NDQDZKLFKP HDQV6RODU.KDQVVRODUNLQJV7KH*UHDW $UNDQDDUHW KH
 FDUGV RI W KH (J\SW LDQ 7DURW  ZKLFK LV W KH FDUG JDP H W KDW  LQ LW V  FDUGV KDV
FRQFHDOHGW KHEDVLFLGHDVRIW KHZRUOG  :LW KW KH*\SVLHVW KHKDQGVRIXQZRUW K\
SHRSOH KDYH EURXJKW  LW  W R XV  7KH\ FRXOG DW  OHDVW  FRQQHFW  ZLW K LW  H[W UDRUGLQDU\
NQRZOHGJH LQ VRRW K VD\LQJ DQG RW KHU P DJLF  2XU 5XQH URZ RI  LV FRQVLGHUHG
W R EH W KH DFW XDO 8U7DURW  DQG W KH TXHVW LRQ UHP DLQV LI W KH  RU W KH  LV W KH
RULJLQDO QXP EHU    7KH DQFLHQW  *UHHN $OSKDEHW  W RR KDV  OHW W HUV DQG LW  FORVHV
ZLW KW KH7DXW KHVDP HZDVDVW KH7DURW HQGVZLW KW KH7DX 7 W KHJDOORZVW KH
HQG W KH 7DX W KH 7HO 'HDW K W KH 7RW XP  W KH ZKROH

-HKHQ LQP RGHUQGD\GLDOHFW VRIVRP HDUHDVLQ1RUW KHUQ*HUP DQ\

7KLVP D\EHDP LVSULQW LQJ7KHUHDUHFDUGVRIW KH7DURW 

7KH6HSKHU-HW ]LUD ³ %RRNRI&UHDW LRQ´Z ULW W HQE\W KH5DEELRI/HRQ6SDLQ VSHDNVRI³ 7KUHH
0RW KHUV6HYHQ'RXEOHRQHVDQG7ZHOYHVLP SOHRQHV´UHIHUULQJW RW KUHHHOHP HQW VVHYHQ
 

6RDOVRW KH7\U &KULVW  W KHW ZHOIW KUXQHRIW KH7\U7LHU  &LUFOH W KH]RGLDF RI
OLI H

7KLV DOSKDEHW  ZDV W DNHQ RYHU E\ W KH 6HP LW HV DQG IROORZLQJ W KHP  DOO SHRSOHV RI
W KH (DUW K

, QW KH1RUGLFKRP HODQGLW VHOIW KHNQRZOHGJHRIW KHNLQJVW KH$U NDQDRI-RQD

YDQLVKHGRQO\W KHOHJHQGRIEXULHGNLQJVSRLQW VW RW KHRULJLQRIW KLVDUUD\RI
RQW KLVVSRW RIVDFUHGVRLO  %XW W KHNQRZOHGJHRIW KH'UXLGDW KH7URM DW KH
7RUW D W KH 7RUW OD DV W KH SULHVW  VFKRRO ZDV FDOOHG UHP DLQHG DOLYH IDU DZD\ LQ W KH
ZRUOG DERYH DOO LQ W KH (OHXVLDQ P \VW HULHV  'RUW OD GRUGD W XU W XU LV W KH 7XUW HO
7DXEH W XUW OHGRYH  DV W KH V\P ERO RI W KH +RO\ *KRVW   :H DVVXP H W KDW  W KH ZRUG
³ W XUW HO´  LV DQ H[SUHVVLRQ RI W KH W XUQLQJ P RYHP HQW  RI W KH FRXUW LQJ P DOH GRYH
7KLVZD\ZHFDQH[SODLQW KDW W KH³ +RO\*KRVW ´EHLQJW KHW KLUGRQHW KHRQHW KDW
W XUQVIDW HW KHW XUQLQJRQH GHU'UHKHQGH W KHRQHP DNLQJW KLU GVRIW KLQJV GHU
'ULW W HOQGH  W KH NLFNLQJ RQH GHU 7ULW W HOQGH  DQQRXQFHV YHU N QGHW  GH FKLOGV
YHU NLQGHW  W R W KH ³ SXUH YLUJLQ´  0DU\ W KH FRQFHSW LRQ RI W KH 6RQ RI *RG DV W KH
5XQH..XQ.HLP  VSURXW JHUP .LQG FKLOG FOHDUO\VKRZV8QGHUW KH6\P ERO
RIW KHGRYHW KH\RXQJGLVFLSOHZDVSXW LQW RW KHW DEHUQDFOHRIKLVRZQDVW UDOERG\
RUKLV$XUD7KHUHKHZDVW ROHDUQW RIHHOW KHFRVP LFKHDOLQJVW UHDP VW KDW FDP H
GRZQ LQW R KLP  OLNH W KH +RO\ *KRVW  GHVFHQGV RQ W KH \RXQJ -HVXV ZKHQ KH ZDV
LQLW LDW HG E\  D -RQD +DQHV 3U LHVW    &ROXP ED  GRY H SRLQW V W R W KH VDP H 8U 
P HDQLQJ, W LVQRW FRLQFLGHQFHW KDW RQHRIW KHILUVW P LVVLRQDULHVLQ*HUP DQ\ZDV
&ROXP EDQ ZKR FDP H IURP  W KH VDQFW XDU\ RI W KH , VODQG RI -RQD  &RO FXO SRLQW V
W R W KH EHJHW W LQJ Z LVGRP  RI W KH 5XQH .XQ DQG W KH ³ gO´    RLO RI Z LVGRP   RI
LQLW LDW LRQ RI W KH DQRLQW HG RQH IURP  ZKLFK W KH DQFLHQW  SODFHV RI FXOW  JRW  W KHLU
QDP HVVXFKDV&RORJQH .|OQ &XOP 8OP  ZLW KRXW ³ .´EXW ZHDVVXP HRULJLQDOO\
ZLW K W KH +   .|OOH GD &XOOH GHL ZKLFK ZDV ³ IRXQGHG´  E\ W KH , ULVKP DQ .LOLDQ
1RZ ZH NQRZ DV ZHOO ZK\ LQ W KH W KLUG ERRN RI W KH NLQJV W KH P \W KLFDO NLQJ
6RORP RQ W KH 6DOP DQ ZKLFK ZDV P L[HG XS RIW HQ ZLW K W KH KLVW RULFDO IDW KHU RI
SODQHW VDQGW Z HOYHVLJQV7KHQXP EHURIGHJUHHVLQW KHFLUFOHRU URXJKO\ GD\VLQW KH
\HDUFDQEHGLYLGHGE\QXP EHUVZ LW KRXW UHP DLQGHU  HW F
7Z RRIW KHVHQXP EHUVDUHQRW ILJXUDW LYHVLH\RXFDQQRW P DNHSRO\ JRQV LQ(XFOLGHDQ
*HRP HW U\RIVW UDLJKW OLQHV *DXVVLDQFRRUGLQDW HVZ HUHHQW LUHO\ XQNQRZ QLQDQFLHQW W LP HV Z LW K
RQHRUW ZRFRUQHUV7KHILUVW SRO\JRQW KDW \RXFDQLQVFULEHLQW KLVFLUFOHLVW KHW ULDQJOHW KHQ
W KHVTXDUHW KHQW KHSHQW DJUDP HW F6RZ HKDYHSRO\JRQVLQW KHFLUFOHW KDW UHSUHVHQW 
VSHFLILFHQHUJHW LFVW DW HV+HEUHZOHW W HUVP DM RU$UFDQDRIW KH7DURW 7KUHHRIW KHVH
SRO\JRQVUHSUHVHQW W KHW KUHHEDVLFQXP EHUVRU³ P RW KHUV´ RIZKLFKDOORW KHUQXP EHUVDUH
FRP SRVHG DQGRUW KHW ULDQJOHVTXDUHDQGSHQW DJRQ SHQW DJUDP 7KH\FRQQHFW Z LW K
W KHHOHP HQW V7KH³ VHYHQGRXEOHQXP EHUV´ DUHW KRVHW KDW FDQEHGLYLGHGE\ ³ W KHGRXEOH
W KUHH´ DQGW KH\VW DQGIRUW KHSODQHW , W LVLQW HUHVW LQJW RQRW HW KDW W KHVHQXP EHUVDUHDOVR
UHSUHVHQW LQJW KHQXP EHURI³ JHQLL´RUVSLULW VRIHDFKSODQHW DU\VSKHUH IRU6DW XUQIRU
-XSLW HUIRU0DUVIRUW KHVXQIRU0HUFXU\HW F$QH[FHSW LRQLVW KHZKLFK
VLJQLILHVW KH³ W RW DOLW \´7KHRW KHUSRO\JRQVUHIHUW RW KHW ZHOYHVLJQV7KH$UFDQDRIW KH
7DURW DUHGHULYHGIURP W KHRUELW RIW KH(DUW KDQGW KHVLW XDW LRQLQRXUSODQHW DU\V\VW HP 
7KHUHIRUHW KHVHHQHUJLHVDUHZHOO GHILQHGDVDUHW KH³ SODQHW DU\JRGV´ RIW KH³ VHYHQGRXEOH
RQHV´ 
 

'DYLG  ZDV³ ZLVHUW KDQW KHVRQVRI0DFKRODQG'RUGOD´7KLVZLVGRP 6DORP RQ

DFKLHYHG E\ P HGLW DW LQJ XSRQ W KH VL[ SRLQW HG VW DU W KH VR FDOOHG ³ 0RJQ 'DYLG´
ZKLFK DV ZH NQRZ LV W KH FLUFXP VFULEHG +DJDO 5XQH  :LW K LW  KH EHFDP H ³ W KH
ZLVHVW RQHRIW KHKXP DQV´DFKLHYHGNQRZOHGJHRIKLJKHUZRUOGVDQGW KHP DJLFDO
SRZHU DQG P DVW HU\ RYHU W KHLU LQKDELW DQW V  +RZ W KHP  FDP H 6RORP RQ ZKLFK
P HDQV W KH $U\DQ 6DOP DQ LQ SRVVHVVLRQ RI W KH VL[ SRLQW HG VW DU"

³ +HW RRNLW IURP W KHQHVW RIDQHDJOH ³$GOHUKRUVW ´ ´7KH³$GOHUKRUVW  QHVW RIDQ

HDJOH  SRLQW V W RZDU GV ³$DU KRU VW ´  $DU   W KH SRHW LF IRU P  RI (DJOH  GZ HOOLQJ
KRUVW RI$U\DQV $DUEHFRP HV$U\DQKHUH W KHGZHOOLQJRIW KH6XQLQW KH1RUW K
Z KLFK FHU W DLQO\ DOVR KDG DQ RIIVKRRW  LQ 3DOHVW LQH LQ W KH +HU P RQ P RXQW DLQV
+DUP DQ P RXQW DLQV $UP DQQ P RXQW DLQV ZKHUH VW LOO LQ W KH P LGGOH DJHV EORQG
SHRSOHGZHOOHGZLW KZKRP W KHFUXVDGHUVFRXOG³ W DON*HUP DQ´0\W KDQGKLVW RU\
DUH OD\HUHG KHUH RQ W RS RI HDFK RW KHU ZKLFK OD\HUV DUH GLIILFXOW  W R VHSDUDW H
+RZHYHU DOO ZH QHHG DUH W KHVH SRLQW HUV LQ RUGHU W R UHFRJQL]H W KDW  HYHU\W KLQJ
W KDW  KDSSHQV RQ (DUW K JRHV EDFK W R W KH $U\DQ GZHOOLQJ LQ VSLULW 

$ JUHDW  1RUGLF &KULVW LDQ &KXUFK FRQQHFW HG FRQQHFW HG QRW  ³ UXOHG´  DV GLG W KH
5RP DQ FKXUFK  DOUHDG\ LQ W KH W K FHQW XU\ ZLGH W HUULW RULHV IURP  W KH 1RUW KHUQ
VORSH RI W KH $OSV DOO W KH Z D\  W R , U HODQG , FHODQG DQG *U HHQODQG   IU RP  W KH
3\UHQHHV³ W RW KHODQGRIW KH7KXULQJLDQV´ DQGEH\RQG  7KLVIDFW XQYHLOVVHYHUDO
VHFUHW V7KH:RGDQ VDFULILFHRQW KHFURVVRIW KHZRUOG DVKW UHH  E\KLVVRQ7LX
7LX7\VW KH³ , FKW K\V´  W KH, FK W \V7KH, FK =HXV RIW KH1RUW KDQGW KH$HVLU

7LHU P RG*HUP DQ$QLP DO

2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG


$QDOOXVLRQW RW KH*UHHN³ , FKW K\V´ IRUILVKGHULYHGDVDSDU W LDODQDJUDP RIW KHZRUGV³ -HVXV´ 
³ &KULVW ´ 
7KH*HUP DQ³ , FK´ IRU, LVDUHODW LYHO\UHFHQW GHYHORSP HQW 1RW VRORQJDJRLW ZDV³ HN´


0LGGOH+LJK*HUQDP 
 

VDFULILFH RI W KH bVXV  RI W KH *DXOV W KH .HOW V .HOW HQ  ZKLFK EHLQJ D EUDQFK RI
W KH *HUP DQV ZH VLP SO\ UHIHU W R DV ³ +HOGHQ´  KHURHV    7KLV bVXV IURP  *DXO
W KHUHIRUH IURP  *DOLOHH GLHG RQ W KH FURVV ORQJ EHIRUH W KLV P \W K ZDV W UDQVIHUUHG
W R 3DOHVW LQH IRU UHDVRQV RI IDOVLILFDW LRQ W R D SHRSOH RI W KH -HZV ZKLFK ZLW K LW V
ERUURZHG QDP H XQM XVW LILDEO\ FODLP V DQ RULJLQ LQ W KH *RRG RQHV W KH *RW KV   , Q
W KLV FDVH W KH FDVH RI W KH -HZV RU W KH JRRG RQHV ZH KDYH W R GR ZLW K D VSLULW XDO
SHRSOH D VDFUHG SHRSOH ZH KDYH W R GR ZLW K W KH VRFLHW \ RI W KRVH VDLQW V ZKLFK
QHHG QR E\ODZV DQG QR FKXUFK  , W  LV W KH ³ FKRVHQ´  SHRSOH RI W KH SXUHVW  DQG
KLJKHVW  DQG P RVW  VDFUHG SRZHUV RI W KH VRXO W KH NLQJ RI ZKLFK REYLRXVO\ LV W KH
³ -HVXV&KULVW ´W KH$U\DQW KH$DU KHLW  ³ EHLQJW KH(DJOH´ W KH:DKU KHLW  P RGHUQ
*HUP DQZRUGIRUW UXW K 

7KHFOHUJ\RIW KH*HUP DQLFZKLFKP HDQVDOVRRIW KH.HOW LFLQKDELW DQW VRI0LGGOH

(XURSH DQG RI W KH 1RUW K :HVW  EHFDXVH W KHUH W KH $U\DQ 8U IRON OLYHG DIW HU W KH
VLQNLQJ RI $W ODQW LV ZHUH W KH 'UXLGV W KH 7URM DLGHV W KH ³ 7UHXHQ´  IDLW KIXO RQHV 
7KH\ W DXJKW  7UHXH IDLW KIXOQHVV  W KH 'UHLH W KH 7KUHH  W KH *UHDW  'UHL 7KUHH 
W KH 7UDXHQ W R W UXVW  W KH 9HUW UDXHQ W UXVW LQJ  LQ W KH 'LYLQH W KH SURFHVVHV RI
RULJLQDW LQJRYHUEHLQJW RSDVVLQJZKLFKZHOHDUQHGLQDOO+RO\ 7ULQLW LHV 7DFLW XV
W RR FDOOV W KH EDVLF FRQVW LW XW LRQ RI W KH VRXO RI W KH *HUP DQV 7URM D  , Q W KH (QJOLVK
ZRUGVRIW UXVW W UXW KZKLFKP HDQVW UXW KEHOLHIDQGW UXVW W KHQDP HRIW KH$U\DQ
.HOW LF SULHVW KRRG NHHSV EHLQJ DOLYH   RI W KH 7UXLGV 'UXLGV   ³ 7UXW H´  DOVR P HDQV
³ ZLW FK´ W KH7UHXHQ IDLW KIXORQHV W KH7URLHQ DJDLQDOOXGLQJW RW KHFLW \RI7UR\ 
ZKLFKW DXJKW W KH'URLW  P RGHUQ)UHQFK ODZ W KHODZRIW KH7URLV P RGHUQ)UHQFK
IRU 7KUHH  W KH ³ +LJKHVW  +RO\ 7KUHH´ DOVR W KH 3RZHU RI 'UHL 7KUHH  RI 'UHK
W XU QLQJ  RI 'U RK W KU HDW HQLQJ  DQG 7U XJ LOOXVLRQ  EXW  DOVR W KH FRQW HQW  RI
LOOXVLRQ RI W KH &HOHVW LDO 7\U  7UL  7UR  DQG 7KRU FLUFOH

$W  W KH EHJLQQLQJ RI W KH W K FHQW XU\ 2W IULHG YRQ :HL‰HQEXUJ XVHV VW LOO W KH ZRUG
³ W UXW KLQ´ IRUW KHQDP HRI*RGLQKLVERRNRIJRVSHOV7KLVP HDQV³ RIW KHIDLW KIXO
RQH´ZKLFKVKRXOGP HDQ³ W KH7KUHH´W KHW KUHH IROG*RG, W LVHYLGHQW W KHQW KDW
W KH *HUP DQLF SULHVW  ZDV W KHQ W KH 7UXW KLQ DV ZHOO OLNH KLV P DVW HU DV LV LQ W KH
1RUW K W KH *RGH W KH SULHVW  OLNH W KH *RG

³ )DLW KIXOQHVV´ LVW KH8U QDP HRIDOO$U\DQ*HUP DQLFDQGZLW KLW *HUP DQUHOLJLRQ
, Q *HUP DQ ZH KDG QRW  UHDOO\ D W UDQVODW LRQ IRU W KLV IRUHLJQ ZRUG ZH KDYH QRQH
DQGZHZLOOQRW KDYHRQHEHFDXVHZHQHHGQRQH%DFN FRQQHFW LRQ UH OLJLRQ
P HDQVW KHZRUG:KRZRXOGEHP RUHEDFN FRQQHFW HGW KDW W KHW UXHFOHDU6RODU
KXP DQ"


 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

$JDLQ ZH ZLOO UHDZDNHQ ZLW KLQ RXUVHOYHV W KH IDLW KIXOQHVV W KH 7UR\ W KH 7KUHH
W KH NQRZOHGJH RI W KH HW HUQDO ZRUNLQJ RI 'LYLQH /DZ ZKLFK UXOHV W KH .ULVW$OO
³ &U\VW DO &KULVW 8QLYHUVH LQ)DW KHU6RQDQG+RO\*KRVW ZKLFKP HDQVLQSDVW 
SUHVHQW  DQG IXW XUH DQG DV W KHVH W KUHH DUH RQO\ 2QH LQ 8QLW \ D ODZ IXOQHVV
3UHVHQW  SDVW  DQG IXW XUH HQFRP SDVVLQJ  ³ 7KHUH LV QR SDVW  W KDW  SDVVHG DQG QR
IXW XU H LQ W KH IXW XU H EXW  RQO\  D SU HVHQW  SDVW  DQG D SU HVHQW  IXW XU H´  W HDFKHV
$XJXVW LQH W KH FKXUFK IDW KHU LQ KLV FRQIHVVLRQV

:HNQRZRIW KH'UXLGVW KHVRQVRI7\URU'U\W KDW W KH\W DXJKW DVRODUUHOLJLRQ

DQGQRUHOLJLRQRQ(DUW KFDQW HDFKDQ\W KLQJHOVHW KDW DZLVGRP RIW KH6XQ7KLV
LV W KH JRDO RI DOO U HOLJLRXV V\ P EROV P \ W KV DU W LFOHV RI IDLW K DQG IRU P XODV RI
FRQIHVVLRQV  :H DUH JRLQJ W R VKRZ ODW HU W KDW  W KH 6XQ LV DOVR W KH 8U FRQW HQW V RI
W KH &KU LVW  U HOLJLRQ   :H DOO VHH W KH 6XQ DQG Z H IHHO OLJKW  DQG ZDU P W K W KDW
HP DQDW H IURP  LW   %XW  W KDW  LV QRW  DOO  7KH 6XQ DOVR VHQGV RXW  HQHUJLHV W KDW  DUH
EH\RQG W KDW  ZKLFK SK\VLFV FDQ H[SORUH ZKLFK VSHDNV RI XOW UDYLROHW  UD\V  )URP
W KH LQQHU 6XQ ZKLFK LV W KH LQQHU VW DU W KH LP DJH DQG V\P ERO RI ZKLFK LV W KH
H[W HULRU 6XQ DQG VW DU W KH VDP H ZDV DV W KH ERG\ DORQH LV QRW  W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ
SRXUVGRZQW RXVORYHDQGZLVGRP :KRHYHUFRXOGVXFFHHGW RSHU FHLYHZLW KKLV
FRQVFLRXVQHVVW KHRYHU VHQVRU\SRZHUVDQGVW UHDP VRIW KH6XQKHZRXOGEHFRP H
D ZLVH RQH DQG OHDGHU RI W KLV (DUW K

7KH'UXLGVZHUHW KHUH7KH\UHFRJQL]HGW KHDERYH VHQVRU\TXDOLW LHVRIW KH6XQ

W KDW  KDV HIIHFW  ZKHQ W KH VHQVRU\ FKDUDFW HULVW LFV RI W KH 6XQ DUH DEVW UDFW HG  , Q
W KH6XQW KH, QQHU6XQW KH\UHFRJQL]HGW KH6RQRI*RGLQVSLULW , QW KHLUZLVGRP
W KHDQFLHQW P \W KRIW KH6XQ 6RQRIW KH.ULVW  $OO 6RQZDVSUHVHUYHGIURP $W ODQW HDQ
W LP HV  , W  ZDV LQKHULW HG E\ W KH LQLW LDW HV RI W KH ZKROH ZRUOG Z KLFK IHUW LOL]HG W KH
(DUW K GXULQJ W KH W LP H RI W KH $U\DQ ZDYH RI SHRSOHV 

, W  LV VXIILFLHQW  W R SRLQW  RXW  W KH IROORZ LQJ   $FFRU GLQJ W R W KH W U DGLW LRQ RI W KH
5RP DQ&KXUFKW KH'UXLGVH[SHULHQFHGLQYLVLRQVW KHVXSSRVHGHY HQW VLQ3DOHVW LQH
GXULQJ W KH W LP H RI W KH ELUW K RI &KULVW   :LW K W KLV W KH\ W ULHG W R H[SODLQ W KDW  W KH
'UXLGV NQHZ RI W KLV P \VW HU\ DOUHDG\ EHIRUH LW  VXSSRVHGO\ KDSSHQHG LQ 3DOHVW LQH
DQG W KH\ W DXJKW  LW   7KH ILUVW  5RP DQ P LVVLRQDULHV VXSSRVHGO\ IRXQG DOUHDG\ LQ
W KH %UHW DJQH &KULVW LDQV  7KH %UHW DJQH ZDV RQH RI W KH P DLQ DUHDV RI 'UXLGLVP 
SURRI RI ZKLFK DUH W KH JUHDW  VW RQH DOOH\V RI FURP OHFKV DQG RI W KH ³ DOLJQP HQW V´
&HUW DLQO\W KH\IRXQG&KULVW LDQVDOORYHUW KH1RUW KEHFDXVHW KH.ULVW  $OO W KRXJKW
RI  W K H J RG  RQ  W K H FU RVV RI  W K H Z RU OG  LV P X FK  ROG HU  W K DQ  W K H FRP S OHW HO\
P LVX Q GHU VW RRG  EHFDX VH LW  Z DV SX W  LQ W R D W LP H I U DP H  W K RX JK W  RI  D 1HZ 
W HVW DP HQW DU\ GHDW K RQ W KH JDOORZV RI *ROJRW KD  , Q W KH VDFULILFH RI 2GKLQ bVXV
DQG .ULVKQD W KLV P \VW HU\ KDV IRXQG DOUHDG\ D P LOOHQQLD ROG FKDUDFW HU

%\P HDQVRIDJURVVIDOVLILFDW LRQ³ KLVW RULFDO´ HYHQW VLQ3DOHVW LQHHP HUJHGZKLFK

FDQQRW  EH SURYHQ DQ\ZKHUH  :H VKRZHG DOUHDG\ HDUOLHU W KDW  W KHVH ZHUH QR
KLVW RULFDO HYHQW V DW  DOO  7KH VRRW K VD\LQJ RI W KH 'UXLGV NQHZ DOO DORQJ ORQJ
EHIRUH &KULVW ¶V VXSSRVHG DUULYDO RQ (DUW K RI W KLV YLUJLQ W KH 0DW HU /DW  0RW KHU 
W KH 0D W H ULD ZKLFK VKRXOG JLYH ELUW K W R W KH 6XQ W R W KH 6RQ EHJRW W HQ E\ W KH

:LW KW KLVKHP HDQVW KHDVVXP HGZ DYHRIP LJUDW LRQ
 

IDW KHU RI W KH ZRUOGV ZKLFK DW  W KH VDP H W LP H LV ³ +RO\ VSLULW ´ ERW K LQ RQH SHUVRQ
DQG LQ HVVHQFH W KH VDP H DV W KH 6RQ  6XQ  6RQ DQG 6XQ  6XQ DUH W KH VDP H
ZRUGV VW LOO LQ W KH ROG *HUP DQ ODQJXDJH ZKLFK W KHQ SURYHV W KH LGHQW LW \ RI W KH
HVVHQFHRIW KHQDP HRIW KH6XQDQGW KHQDP HRIW KH6RQ7KLVLVW RSHUFHLYHDV
SDUDEOH DQG QRW  LQ GHYDVW DW LQJ DQG VSLULW FKRNLQJ OLW HUDOLW \  7KHUHIRUH W KH 8U
&KULVW LDQP \W KVGRQRW FRP HIURP 6\ULDEXW IURP W KHP RUQLQJ ODQGRIRXUVRXO
W KH 2ULHQW  ZLW KLQ  7KH\ IRXQG LQ W KH ODQG RI W KH *DXOV RI W KH .HOW V .HOW HQ  RI
W KH +HURHV +HOGHQ  W KH ODQG RI W KH +HOLDQG 2OG *HUP DQ IRU +HLODQG  VDYLRU
W KH KHDYHQO\ FKDOLFH W KDW  HQFRP SDVVHV W KH XQLYHUVH OLNH DOO W KRVH $U\DQ W DOHV
DQGOHJHQGVRIW KHURXQGW DEOHRIW ZHOYHRI.LQJ$UW KXURI3HU FLYDORI7ULVW DQDQG
, VROGH RI , ZHLQ DQG *DZHLQ RI W KH *UDLO RI W KH .DUDO

7KH 'UXLGV W KH ³ GUDJRQV´  DOZD\V ZRUVKLSSHG W KH FHOHVW LDO YLUJLQ  7KH\ VDZ LW
ZLW KLQ D FLUFOH RI W KH VW DUV W KH 0RRQ DW  KHU IHHW  DQG W KH 6RQ W KH 6XQ RQ KHU
EUHDVW 1RZZHNQRZZK\W KHYLUJLQFXOW VRULJLQDW HGLQW KH1RU W K W KHHDUO\RQH
DERXW )UH\DRIW KH*HUP DQVZKLFKKDVDVM HZHOU\W KHVW DU QHFNODFHW KH%ULVLQJHQ
M HZHOV W KH.HOW LFYLUJLQRIW KHKHDYHQZKLFKZDVZRUVKLSSHGLQW KHSUH &KULVW LDQ
VDQFW XDU\ RI &DUQXQW XP  QRZDGD\V &KDUW UHV  7KLV KDSSHQHG ORQJ EHIRUH W KH
VW RU\ RI W KH &KULVW LDQ ³ 0RW KHU RI *RG´ W R ZKLFK W KH\ HUHFW HG RQH RI W KH P RVW
P DJQLILFLHQW  1RUGLF *HUP DQLF FDW KHGUDOV Z KLFK Z DV W KHQ W UDQVIRUP HG LQW R D
*RW KLFFDW KHGUDO&HVDUZKLFKLQKLVP RUHELOHRXVW KDW *DOOLFZDUUHSRUW VGHVFULEHV
&DU QXQW XP  DQG LW V FXOW V P HQW LRQV W KDW  W KH RU LJLQ RI W KHVH FXOW V Z DV LQ W KH
1RUW K LQ %ULW DLQ

7KH ORRN QRUW KZDUG ZLOO EH RI GHFLVLYH LP SRUW DQFH IRU W KH ZKROH FKDUDFW HU RI
&KULVW  DQG ZLW K LW  W KH UHOLJLRXV TXHVW LRQ RI W KH ZRUOG  3UH &KULVW LDQ LGHDV DUH
UHIOHFW HGLQW KHV\P EROLFW \SHVRIW KHIRXUHYDQJHOLVW V%HVLGHVRW KHUH[SODQDW LRQV
W KH RQH RI W KH IRXU GLUHFW LRQV KDV D ORW  RI P HDQLQJ  7KH IDFW  W KDW  LQ FOXP V\
FKXUFKFRXQFLOVW KH\VHOHFW HGSUHFLVHO\IRXUJRVSHOVRXW RIDERXW W H[W VZDV
FHUW DLQO\ QRW  UHDOLVW LF QHFHVVLW \ EXW  LW  KDSSHQHG DFFRUGLQJ W R V\P EROLF SRLQW V RI
YLHZ

, Q W KH (DVW  LV W KH +HDYHQO\ /LRQ RI 0DUN RI W KH YLJRURXV JRVSHO W KDW  EULQJV OLIH
ZKLFK DSSHDUV DV W KH ³ (DVW HUQ RQH´ W KH ³ (DVW HUQ´ LQ W KH ROG OLVW V RI W KH GHFDQV
RIW KH]RGLDF, QW KH6RXW KLVW KHW DXUXVRIW KHJRVSHORI/XNHW KHVW DURI/XFDV
RI W KH ³ /X[´ RI W KH OLJKW  RI W KH VRXW K RI W KH 0LOGQHVV RI P RW KHUOLQHVV DQG
IHUW LOLW \  7KDW  W DXUXV 1RUGLF 6W M RUQ  W KH VW DU  UHSUHVHQW V W KH 6XQ QDP HO\ W KH
FRQVW HOODW LRQ RI 7DXUXV LQ W KH ]RGLDF GXULQJ W KH *UHDW  6RODU <HDU VKRZV W KH EXOO
LQ W KH (J\SW LDQ FXOW  RI W KH EXOO  , Q W KH :HVW  LV W KH ODQG RI GHVFHQW  W KH ODQG RI
W KHDQJHOV(QJODQGW KHKLQJHRIW KHZRUOG  ZKHUHW KH6XQVHW VZKHUHP DQLV
EORZQ DZD\ E\ W KH ZLQG W KHUH W KH DQJHO RI 0DW W KHZ VW DQGV RI ³ 0D7KHXV´ W KH
P DQ *RG ZKLFK W HDFKHV W KH JRVSHO RI W KH 6RQ RI 0DQ W KH +X 0DQ  )URP  W KH
1RUW K KRZHYHU W KH HDJOH LV ULVLQJ W KH $DU RI W KH *RVSHO RI -RKQ RI W KH $U\DQ
JRVSHORIW KHP RVW *HUP DQRQHLQW KH1RUW KZKHUHGXULQJW KH\HDUO\P LGQLJKW
RI W KH 6XQ W KH $DU  U LVHV DQHZ  7KH JRVSHO RI -RKQ W HDFKHV U HLQFDU QDW LRQ
UHVXUUHFW LRQW KHELUW KRIW KHZRUGLQW KHIOHVKW KHZRUGW KH'LYLQHW KHEUHDW K

$QJHO KLQJH
 

ZKLFK ZDV DW  W KH EHJLQQLQJ DQG W KHUHIRUH W KH JRVSHO RI -RKQ EHORQJV DW  W KH
EHJLQQLQJRIW KHOLVW VRIW KHJRVSHOV , W VEHJLQQLQJFRUUHODW HVZLW KW KHEHJLQQLQJ
RI*HQHVLVW KHFUHDW LRQP \W KRIW KH³ ROG´ W HVW DP HQW RIZKLFKQRRQHLVFDSDEOH
RI SURYLQJ W KDW  LW  LV LQGHHG ROGHU HDUOLHU W KDQ W KH ³ QHZ´  W HVW DP HQW   :KHQ ERW K
RIW KHP KDYHEHHQZULW W HQGRZQUHP DLQVLUUHOHYDQW 2OGHULVW KH³ .ULVW ´  &KULVW 
W KH ³ *HUVW ´  P RGHUQ *HUP DQ ZRUG IRU VFDIIROG RU VW UXFW XUH RU VNHOHW RQ    -R
KDQQHVZKRLVD-R DQVHD-D HLQV \HV RQH D-DQVD+DQVD+LJKRQHLVW KH
³ SURSKHW ´ -RQDKRIW KHROGW HVW DP HQW ZKRKDGW REHLQW KHEHOO\RIW KHZKDOHIRU
W KUHHGD\V$VRODU0\W K &KULVW W KH6RQW KH6XQRI*RGW RROLHVLQKLVW RP E
IRU W KUHH GD\V OLNHZLVH W KH SK\VLFDO 6XQ ZKLFK LV W KUHH /XQDU GD\V LQ W KH W RP E
RIW KHZLQW HU7KHVXQZKLFKZDVLQHDUOLHU*HUP DQODQJXDJHW KH6RQQW KH6RQ
W KHUHIRUH LW  ZDV RI P DOH JHQGHU  , Q DVW URORJ\ W RR LW  KDV W KLV FKDUDFW HULVW LF LH
LW LVP DOH6DLQW 3DW ULFNZKRZDVERUQDURXQGW KH\HDULQ, UHODQGW HOOVW KH
DQFLHQW  ZLVGRP    ³ 7KH 6XQ LV &KULVW ´    , W  LV W KH VDP H FRQIHVVLRQ W KDW  2ULJLQHV
VW LOO SURIHVVHV FOHDUO\ DQG ZLW KRXW  DOORZLQJ DQ\ GRXEW V

7KHUHLVDOHJHQGW KDW W KHDQFHVW RURIW KH'UXLGVZDV1RDKZKRFDP HRXW RIW KH

ZDW HURXW RIW KHIORRGVDQGZDVVDYHG, QW KLV1RDKZHUHFRJQL]HW KHSHUVRQDOLW \
RI-RQDKLQW KHUHYHUVDORI1RDK  DOVRRI2 $QQHV+HLVW KHVKLS P DQRUILVK
P DQ ZKR ULVHV IURP  W KH VHD DQG ZKR JHW V W KH SHRSOHV XVHG DJDLQ W R P RUDOV
RUGHU M XVW LFH DQG 'LYLQLW \ DIW HU W KH JUHDW  IORRG  +H UHP DLQHG DIW HU W KH VLQNLQJ
RI $W ODQW LV DQG KH EHFDP H W KH DQFHVW RU RI W KH $U\DQV

7KH ³$ULDQ´  &KULVW LDQ W KH *RW K :XOILOD LV W KH ILUVW  RQH W R W UDQVODW H W KH %LEOH
7KH, ULVKDUHLQSRVVHVVLRQRIDQ8U %LEOHRIZKLFKZHVW LOON QRZYHU\OLW W OH7KDW
OLW W OH ZH DUH FRQFHUQHG ZLW K W KH P RVW  LP SRUW DQW  GRFXP HQW V  2QH ZDV W RUQ XS
DQGLW LVRQO\DYDLODEOHLQSUHFLRXVIUDJP HQW V7KHH[LVW HQFH RIW KHRW KHURQHLV
GHQLHGDW SUHVHQW , QW KLVUHVSHFW ZHDUHVW LOODW W KHEHJLQQLQJRIDW UXO\UHOLDEOH
UHVHDUFK ZLW KRXW  VHW  SUHFRQGLW LRQV  7KH SUREOHP  RI W KLV W \SH VFLHQFH LV W KDW  LW
KDVQRSUHFRQGLW LRQVW KHUHIRUHLW KDVQRW KLQJW RDGG1RP DW W HUZKHUHZHKDYH
W KH &KULVW LDQLW \ HP HUJH LQ SODFH DQG W LP H ZH GR QRW  ZDQW  W R IDOO YLFW LP  W R W KH
VDP H HUURU DJDLQ QDP HO\ W R W DNH W KLQJV W RR OLW HUDOO\  :H DUH VDW LVILHG ZKHQ ZH
GHP RQVW UDW H W KDW  3DOHVW LQH LV QRW  QHFHVVDULO\ W KH SODFH DQG W KDW  W KH \HDU ³ 2QH´
RI RXU HUD LV QRW  DW  DOO W KH W LP H RI W KH ELUW K RI D ³ &KULVW ´ ZKR DV DQ LGHD KDV
EHHQSURYHQLQH[LVW HQFHDOUHDG\W KRXVDQGVRI\HDUVHDUOLHUFKDUDFW HUDVZHOODV
QDP H  7KH &KULVW LDQ FKURQRORJ\ EHFDP H FRP P RQ SUDFW LFH QRW  HDU OLHU W KDQ W KH
W K FHQW XU\ DIW HU SHRSOH KDYH HQGHG XS W DNLQJ W KH P \W K RI &KU LVW  OLW HUDOO\

2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

0RUH SUHFLVHO\ ZH ZRXOG QHHG W R VD\ W KDW  &KULVW  ZDV ERUQ LQ W KH \HDU =HUR  
RW KHUZLVH ZH FRXOG QRW  FRXQW   EHIRUH DQG  DIW HU &KULVW 
7KHUHLQLVW UXW K 6LQFH&KULVW ZDVERUQLQW KH\HDUQDP HO\QHYHUDQGDOZD\V 

:H FDQ ILQG W KH QDP H , RQD DJDLQ ZLW K W KH , RQLDQV DQG W KH , RQLDQ , VODQGV  , Q
SDUW  9 ZH SRLQW HG RXW  W KDW  'HORV ZDV IRXQGHG E\ W KH 1RUGLF +\ SHUERUHDQ FXOW
OHDGHUVKLS ZKLFK P D\ KDYH KDG LW V VHDW  RQ W KH LVODQG RI , RQD  7KH LVODQG RI
'HORV ZDV W KH VDQFW XDU\ RI W KH DOOLDQFH RI W KH , RQLDQ W ULEHV  7KLV IDFW  FRQQHFW V
FORVHO\ W KH QDP HV RI W KH LVODQG RI , RQDO DQG W KH , RQLDQ , VODQGV

7KH \HDU  W KHUHIRUH LV HW HUQDOO\ SUHVHQW  EHFDXVH LQ HYHU\ LQVW DQW  D QHZ HUD
EHJLQV DQG DQ ROG RQH SDVVHV DZD\  7KH ³ &KULVW ´  LV ERUQ ZLW KLQ XV LQ HYHU\
LQVW DQW LQW KH\HDU :HDUHFRQW LQXLQJIDUW KHUDQGZHKDYHUHFRJQL]HGLQKLP
W KH :RUOG .ULVW$OO W KH ³ SKLORVRSKHUV¶ VW RQH´ W KH QDW XUDO ODZ  RI FU\VW DOOL]DW LRQ
ZKLFK DFKLHYHG 'LYLQH ZRUVKLS LQ W KH P \W K DQG ZKLFK GHJHQHUDW HG LQFUHDVLQJO\
W R D KRUULEOH W ZLVW LQJ RI ZRUGV

, W LVQRW DFRLQFLGHQFHW KDW W KHSODFHZKLFKKRVW HGW KHVDQFW XDU\RIW KH&KULVW LDQLW \

RI -RKQ W KH %HORYHG LQ W KH H[W UHP H 1RUW K W KH VP DOO , VODQG 6RXW K RI 6FRW ODQG
KDGW KHQDP H, RQDRI-RKQW KH%HORYHG7KLVZDVVLQFHDQFLHQW W LP HVDQGQRW
DIW HU W KH &KULVW LDQ SULHVW V KDG W DNHQ RYHU W KH W HP SOHV DQG VHUY LFHV W KHUH  , RQD
Z DV W KH P DLQ ORFDW LRQ RI W KH 'U XLGLF P \ VW HU LHV  D P LOOHQQLD ROG RIIVKRRW  RI
$W ODQW LV+HUHW KH'UXLGLFLGHDRIW KHDQFLHQW FXOW P HUJHGZLW KW KHQHZ&KULVW LDQ
ZDYH , RQD EHFDP H W KH SRLQW  RI RULJLQ RI W KH &XOGHDQ &KXUFK  )URP  KHUH W KH
P LVVLRQDULHVZKLFKZHFDOO$SRVW OHVSULHVW VZLW KQHZFORW KLQJIRUDQFLHQW FRQW HQW V
ZHQW  W R W KH 6RXW K DV GLG DOUHDG\ W KHLU SUHGHFHVVRUV IRU P DQ\ FHQW XULHV LQ IDFW 
P LOOHQQLD7KH\W DXJKW DERXW W KH&KULVW W KH6RQRI*RGLQDUHDVZKHUHKHZDV
W KU HDW HQHG W R VXFFXP E W R P LVXQGHU VW DQGLQJ DU LVLQJ IU RP  W KLQJV EHLQJ W DNHQ
OLW HUDOO\ DIW HU KLV P \VW HU\ HP HUJHG IURP  KLGLQJ DQG UHDFKHG W KH JHQHUDO SXEOLF
, Q DQ ROG , U LVK VRQJ DERXW  W KH /DVW  6XSSHU  Z H VW LOO KHDU  FOHDU O\    7KH /RU G
VDFULILFHV KLP VHOI IRU W KH FRVP RV   $QG &ROXP ED RQH RI W KH ILUVW  KLJK SULHVW V RI
W KH VDQFW XDU\ W KDW  KLVW RU\ QRZ GHVFULEHV DV &KULVW LDQ VD\V   ³ 'R QRW  P L[ XS W KH
W RU FK Z LW K W KH W RU FK EHDU HU  7KH VXQ LV W KH ODP S RI W KH Z RU OG´   7KH ODP S
KRZHYHU LV W KH ODP E DV ZH DOUHDG\ OHDUQHG W R XQGHUVW DQG  ZKLFK FDUULHV W KH
VLQV RI W KH ZRUOG LW  LV 0DVW HU /DP SH   W KH (DVW HU %XQQ\ W KH 2VW DU$VH $HVLU 
W KH:LGDU 2OG*HUP DQIRUUDP W KH:LGGHU P RGHUQ*HUP DQIRUUDP W KH$ULHV
W KH $U L $U LQ W KH 5XQHV  $5   , 6   $5 W KH &KULVW  W KH $ULVW RV W KH +DULVW RV W KH
³ +HKUVW H´  P RGHUQ *HUP DQ SRHW LF H[SUHVVLRQ IRU W KH ³ +ROLHVW  2QH  W KH ³ (UVW H´
P RGHUQ*HUP DQIRUW KHILUVW RQH W KH6XQDVW KHUHSUHVHQW DW LYHRIW KHVSLULW XDO
6XQ ZKLFK LV EHKLQG LW  RI W KH VSLULW XDO .ULVW  $OO   7KH\ ZHUH ZRUVKLSSHUV RI W KH
6SLULW 6XQW KHVHVRQVRI$DUW KH³$UV´IURP ZKLFK  FRP HVW KHDUW W KH³ .|QQHQ´

 2PLWWHG

$*HUP DQZRUGIRUW KH(DVW HU%XQQ\

$UV/DW LQIRUDUW
 

FDSDELOLW \  W KH ³ .|QLJ´  NLQJ  RI W KLV (DUW K W KH ³ .|QLJOLFKH´  W KH UR\DO RQH 
3URRI RI W KLV DUH W KH P DVVLYH OD\HUV RI ERXOGHUV W KH FLUFOHV RI FRXOGHUV LQ W KH
ODQGRIW KHDQJHOVLQW KH%UHW DJQHLQ1RUW KHUQ*HUP DQ\ZKHUHZHNHHSILQGLQJ
QHZ  RQHV  1RW  W LP H GHVW UR\HG W KHP  EXW  W KH EDG FRQVFLHQFH RI W KH 5RP DQ
FKXUFK GLG VR ZKHUHYHU W KH\ FRXOG  7KHUHIRUH RQO\ IHZ UHP DLQHG LQW DFW  LQ W KH
VRXW K RI *HUP DQ\  6RP H ZHUH EXLOW  LQW R W KH FKXUFKHV RU P RQDVW HULHV ZKHUH
W KH\EHFDP HDJDLQIRXQGDW LRQVW RQHVRIVDFUHGSODFHVRIDQFLHQW 8U NQRZOHGJH
ZKLFKQHYHUVDQNGRZQEXW RQO\VXEP HUVHGXQW LOW KHJUHHQLVODQGRIW KH%OHVVHG
2QHV ULVHV LW VHOI DJDLQ IURP  W KH IORRGV RI W KH W ZLOLJKW  RI W KH KXP DQV DQG W KH
DQFLHQW  W DEOHV RI W KH 6XQ ZLOO EH IRXQG DJDLQ

7KHDUUDQJHP HQW VRIERXOGHUVKDYHEHHQEXLOGDFFRUGLQJW RW KHODZVRIW KH6RODU

UHYROXW LRQW KURXJKGD\DQG\HDU:KHUHW KH\FDQEHGHFLSKHUHGDQGFDOFXODW HG
W KH\ VSHDN DQ XQHTXLYRFDO ODQJXDJH  , Q W KH P DLQ W KH\ GHW HUP LQH W KH KLJK
SRLQW RIW KH6XQDW W KHVROVW LFHRIW KH6XP P HURIW KHQLJKW RI6W -RKQRIW KH-R
$QVHQ  W KH -R $VHQ $HVLU   W KH <D $VHQ <HV $HVLU   W KH -D YDW HU  W KH <HV
IDW KHU  W KH -X SLW HU  %XW  -R M X LV W KH SUHIL[ RI W KH QDP H RI W KH VSLULW XDO IDW KHU
RI W KH VSLULW XDO ILUH  $ P HUH +DQV LV EXW  D ³ +DQQHV´  $ -R KDQV LV D -R +DQQHV
D+LJKRQHLQ6SLULW DILUH +DKQ P RGHUQ*HUP DQIRUURRVW HU DILUH $HVLU 'RHV
QRW  RQH KHDU W KH YRLFH RI W KH ODQJXDJH DQG LW V P HDQLQJ LQ VXFK SDUDEOHV"

;, , , 
7+ (2/'(5$7/$1 7($1 &+ 5, 67, $1 &+ 85&+
³ 7KLV JRHV W RR IDU´
1RW KLQJ JRHV W RR IDU
ZKDW  \RX DUH UHDG\
W R DFFHSW 
2QO\ZKDW VSOLW V\RXLQW ZR
7KDW  JRHV W RR IDU
<RXP XVW FDOOLW HQHP \
, QW LP HDQGHW HUQLW \

, W ZRXOGEHZRUW KW KHHIIRUW W RFROOHFW HYHU\ZKHUHW KHVFDW W HUHGUHSRUW VRUIDFW V

W KDW  VSHDN  LQ IDY RU  RI RXU  RSLQLRQ W KDW  W KH FKDU DFW HU  RI W KH -HVXV &KU LVW  RI
1D]DU HW K Z DV QRW  D KLVW RU LFDO SHU VRQ  EXW  W KDW  Z H KDY H W R GR KHU H Z LW K D
P \W KRORJLFDO SKHQRP HQRQ  +HUH IROORZ D IHZ SRLQW HUV W KDW  VKRXOG EULQJ OLJKW
LQW R W KH P DW W HU VR W R VD\ DQG W R LQFUHDVH W KH EULJKW QHVV W KDW  RXU ZRUN KDV
EURXJKW  LQW R W KH GDUNQHVV RI W KH DIIDLUV RI W KH ZRUOG  7KH FRUUHVSRQGHQFHV DUH
REYLRXV  -HVXV LV NQRZQ DV D NLQJ ³ EHIRUH W KH HQG RI W KH ZRUOG´ RI ZKLFK KH
ZDUQHG7KLVZDVLQDQROG*HUP DQW UDGLW LRQLQ7KXULQJLDZKHU HW KHIRONLVVW LOO
SUHVHUYLQJ W KLQJV W KDW  LW  GRHV QRW  XW W HU LQ IURQW  RI FOHULFV DQG SURIHVVRUV  W KHVH
FDUULHUVRIOHJHQGVIHDUW KHFOHULFVDQGW KH\DUHDVKDP HGZKHQLQSUHVHQFHRIW KH
 

SURIHVVRUV EXW  W KH\ DUH VXSHULRU W R ERW K JURXSV ZLW K W KHLU VHFXUH IHHOLQJ IRU
W UXW K  , Q *HUP DQ\ W KLV W DOH RI W KH VDYLRU LV P L[HG ZLW K W KH JUHDW  IORRG DQG LW
FRQW DLQV $W ODQW HDQ W UDGLW LRQV ZKLFK SRLQW  W RZDUGV W KH NLQJ¶V VRQ -HVXV $VRV
DV GR W KH 'UXLGLF UHP DLQGHUV RI OHJHQGV  2Q DQ ROG 6ODYLF ILJXUH RI 7LVOERJ W KH
ZRUG ³ .ULFFL´  &KULVW  LV ZULW W HQ DQG W KLV UHP LQGV XV RI W KH 1DW LYH $P HULFDQ
³ .ULVW LQRV´  HQJOLVK &UHHNVRU.UHHNV $OVRW KHVLP LODULW \RIW KHZRUG³ &KULVW XV´
Z LW K W KH ³ *U HHN V´  VKRXOG VW LP XODW H RXU  W KRXJKW V HVSHFLDOO\  VLQFH W KH Z KROH
HFFOHVLDVW LF &KULVW LDQLW \ IORZV IURP  *UHHN VRXUFHV DQG *UHHN ODQJXDJH  

7KHOHJHQGVZLW KHTXDOFRQW HQW W KLVVLGHDQGW KHRW KHUVLGHRIW KH2FHDQZKLFK

ZH FDOO W KH ³$W ODQW HDQ RQH´ EHFDXVH $W ODQW LV VXQN W KHUH DUH D FOHDU LQGLFDW LRQ
W KDW  W KH ODQG W KDW  ZH FDOO $P HULFD QRZDGD\V ZDV YLVLW HG DQG UXOHG E\ ZKLW H
SHRSOH ORQJ EHIRU H &ROXP EXV GLVFRYHUHG LW   $FFRUGLQJ W R W KH UHSRU W V RI W KH
6SDQLVK FRQTXLVW DGRUV DOO G\QDVW LHV RI W KHLU W LP H VW LOO EHORQJHG P RUH RU OHVV W R
W KH ZKLW H UDFH ZKLFK ZDV SUHVHUYHG IRU D ORQJ W LP H E\ VW ULFW  P DULW DO ODZV DQG
P DUULDJH RI VLEOLQJV   7KH FRQTXLVW DGRUV DOUHDG\ VDZ ZKLW H , QGLDQ W ULEHV W KHLU
SUHVHQFHZDVDOZD\VFODLP HGDQGRIQHZSURYHQDJDLQ0RQW H]XP DVSRNHW RW KH
6SDQLDU GV DERXW  W KH RU LJLQDO N LQVKLS RI W KH $]W HFV Z LW K W KH 6SDQLDU GV DQG
3RUW XJXHVH  7KLV ZDV VR EHFDXVH W KHUH LQ 0H[LFR QRERG\ KDG D QHHG W R GHQ\
W KHVHROGUHODW LRQVRUW RHUDVHW KHP 7KLVZDVFRQW UDU\W RW KHFKXUFKZKLFKKDG
W R P DNH DQ HIIRU W  W R HU DVH HYHU \W KLQJ LQ W KHVH FRXQW U LHV Z KLFK Z RXOG KDYH
DOORZHG W KH FRQFOXVLRQ W R 8U &KULVW LDQ LQ W KLV FDVH SUH &KULVW LDQ UHODW LRQV DQG
FRP P RQ W UDLW V   0DQ\ , QGLDQV P D\ KDYH EHHQ VHHQ DV 5RP DQLF SHRSOHV IRU
)UHQFK 6SDQLVK , W DOLDQV P DQ\ HYHQ 1RUGLF DV P DQ\ W UDYHOHUV DUH UHSRUW LQJ
DERXW , QGLDQW ULEHVVW LOOLQW KHW KFHQW XU\  %XW DOOW KHZRP HQVHHQW REHW UXHU


 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

, QGLDQ ZKLFK P D\ SHUKDSV SRLQW  W RZDUGV W R ZKLW H W ULEDO IDW KHUV DQG FRORUHG
W ULEDO P RW KHUV IURP  D ZKLW H LP P LJUDW LRQ RI ZDUULRUV LQ HDUOLHU  W LP HV 

'HFLVLYHIRUXVUHP DLQVW KHSURRIW KDW DOVRW KHDQFLHQW $P HULFDQDQG(DVW $VLDW LF

FXOW XUHV DUH UDGLDW LRQV RI W KH $W ODQW HDQ FXOW XUH  $OO ODQJXDJH DOO UHOLJLRQ DUH
2OG $U\DQ  (VSHFLDOO\ W KH H[SHUW V RI W KH SUH &ROXP ELDQ  $P HULFDV KDYH P DGH
GLVFRYHULHV W KDW  ERUGHU W KH P LUDFXORXV  7KH DQFLHQW  0H[LFDQV DQG 3HUXYLDQV
ZHUH LQ SRVVHVVLRQ RI W KH $ULR &KULVW LDQ UHOLJLRQ  7KH\ KDG W KH V\P ERO RI W KH
FURVVW KH/DVW 6XSSHUDQGW KH&KULVW LDQULW XDOVDOUHDG\%& , W LVW KHP HULW
RI 'U $OEUHFKW  :LUW K W R KDYH SURYHQ W KDW  W KH (DVW HUQ $VLDW LF FXOW XUHV W RR DUH
IDLUO\ ODW H EUDQFKHV RI W KH $ULR$W ODQW HDQ FXOW XUH  7KH UHVHDU FK E\ 3HQND * Y
/LVW .LH‰OLQJ'RQHOOLVKRZHYHUFOHDUHULQW RW KHP RVW P LQXW HGHW DLOVW KHFRQQHFW LRQ
RI DOO P \ W KRORJLHV DQG U HOLJLRQ HY HQ RI DOO ODQJXDJHV  6W XFN HQ SU RY HV W KDW
FHUW DLQZRUGVLQW KHDQFLHQW 0H[LFDQDQGDQFLHQW 3HUXYLDQODQJXDJHVDUHFORVHO\
FRQQHFW HG ZLW K W KH ODQJXDJH RI W KH 0DRUL DQG RI W KH 6XP HULDQV

7KHVH IDFW V ZHUH W UHDW HG KHUH D ELW  P RUH H[W HQVLYHO\ EHFDXVH W KH\ HDVH DQ
H[SODQDW LRQRIW KHVXUSULVLQJGLVFRYHU\W KDW &KULVW LDQFXVW RP V&KULVW LDQW HDFKLQJ
DQGV\P EROLVP VHHP HGW REHSUDFW LFHGLQDOORI$P HULFDVLQFHW LP HVLP P HP RULDO
W RW KHJUHDW DP D]HP HQW RIW KH(XURSHDQ³ &KULVW LDQV´ W KDW SOXQGHUHGDQGP XUGHUHG
W KHUH  :KRHYHU LQW HOOLJHQW O\ GRHV QRW  GHQ\ W KH KLVW RULFLW \ RI $W ODQW LV IRU KLP
W KH SUH &ROXP ELDQ FRQQHFW LRQ EHW ZHHQ W KH ROG DQG W KH QHZ ZRUOGV LV QRW  DQ
HQLJP D  7KH 9LNLQJV KDG DOZD\V VHW W OHG RQ W KH $P HULFDQ FRQW LQHQW  QRW  M XVW
DIW HU(ULFW KH5HGDQG/HLI(ULFVRQLQW KH\HDU/HLIW RRUHSRUW VRIW ULSVDQG
VHW W OHP HQW V RI KLV W ULEDO EUHW KUHQ EHIRUH KLV W LP H DQG OLNHZLVH KLVW RULFDO DUH
, ULVK VHW W OHP HQW V DQG W ULSV W R W KH IDU :HVW HUQ ODQGV  :LW QHVV RI W KH W LP H RI W KH
1RU P DQV LQ $P HU LFD DU H W KH 5XQH LQVFU LSW LRQV W KDW  KDY H EHHQ IRXQG RQ W KH
³ :ULW LQJ5RFN´ LQ7DXQW RQ0DVVDFKXVHW W V 6RXW KRI%RVW RQ LQ'ULIW JRRGV
W KDW  DUULYHG RQ W KH FRDVW V RI W KH %ULW LVK , VOHV  FRQYLQFHG W KHLU LQKDELW DQW V ORQJ
DJ R RI  W K H H[ LVW HQ FH RI  I RU HLJ Q  ODQ G V LQ  W K H :HVW  DQ G  RI  I RU HLJ Q  U DFHV
UHSUHVHQW DW LYHVRIZKLFKRQW KHLUOLJKW FUDIW VZHUHVRP HW LP HVGULYHQE\VW RUP V
W R W KH (DVW   7KLV DFFRUGLQJ W R ROG UHSRUW V VW LOO IURP  W KH W LP HV RI W KH 9LNLQJV
3URI 'U +HQQLQJ W HOOV DERXW  W KDW    ³ 7KH , FHODQGLF VDJDV W HOO XV W KDW  W KH 1RUP DQ
/HLIOHIW *UHHQODQGZKHUHKLVIDW KHU(ULFW KH5HGVHW W OHG\HDUVHDUOLHULQW KH
\HDU)URP W KHUHKHZHQW 6RXW KZHVW W RILQGQHZODQG7KHUHKHGLVFRYHUHG
ILUVW  D VW RQH ODQG +HOOXODQG  W KHQ D ZRRG ODQG 0DUNODQG  1HZIRXQGODQG RU
P RUHOLNHO\1HZ%UXQVZLFN  DQGHYHQW XDOO\W KHEOHVVHG9LQODQG /DQGRI:LQH 
ZKLFK P RVW  UHVHDUFKHUV W RGD\ ORFDW H DW  W KH FRDVW  RI 0DVVDFKXVHW W V  , FHODQGHUV
W KHP VHOYHV DP RQJ W KHP  6LJXUG 6W HIDQVVRQ LQ W KH \HDU  KDYH DVVXP HG
W KDW ORFDW LRQRIW KHVHW KUHHFRXQW ULHVUHODW LYHW RHDFKRW KHUZKLFKZHUHGLVFRYHUHG
E\ W KHLU DQFHVW RUV  %HFDXVH RI W KDW  ZH KDYH HYHU\ UHDVRQ W R DVVXP H W KDW  W KH

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

7KHUHP DLQGHUVRI/HLI¶VEDVHFDP SKDYHEHHQIRXQGDIHZ\HDUVDJR, W ZDVVLW XDW HGDW W KH
1RUW KHQGRI1HZIRXQGODQG
 

YR\DJHV RI /HLI DQG KLV YDULRXV VXFFHVVRUV UHDFKHG DOO W KH ZD\ W R W KH &DSH &RG
SHQ LQ VX OD   

%H\RQG W KDW  D Z KROH DU U D\ RI IDFW V Z HU H GLVFRYHU HG LQ 0DVVDFKXVHW W V Z KLFK
ZRXOG EH XQLP DJLQDEOH ZLW KRXW  DVVXP LQJ DQ HDUO\ LQIOXHQFH RI (XURSHDQV  , Q
ROG EXULDO VLW HV RI W KH , QGLDQV W KH HDUW K KLOOV RU ³ P RXQGV´  W KH\ IRXQG VW UDQJH
GHY LFHV DQG W RROV Z KLFK LQ QR Z D\  FDQ KDY H RU LJLQDW HG IU RP  W KH $P HU LFDQ
QDW LYHV DQG ZKLFK KDYH W \SLFDO 1RUGLF FKDUDFW HULVW LFV  6LQFH P DQ\ RI W KHVH
³ P RXQGV´  KDYH EHHQ EXLOW  EHIRU H W KH GLVFRYHU \ RI $P HU LFD E\ &ROXP EXV DOO
GRXEW V VKRXOG GLVDSSHDU W KDW  W KH 1RUP DQV KDYH EURXJKW  W KLV P HUFKDQGLVH W R
0DVVDFKXVHW W V)URP W KHUHW KH\ZHQW LQW R, QGLDQSRVVHVVLRQE\W UDGHVZDSSLQJ
W KHIW  RU UREEHU\

/LW HUDU\ P RQXP HQW V W RR VSHDN DJDLQVW  W KH DVVXP SW LRQ W KDW  W KH 9LQODQG UHSRUW V
ZHUHLQYHQW HG  , W ¶VQRW RQO\W KH, FHODQGLFVDJDVW KDW VSHDNRI9LQODQGEXW VW LOO
HDUOLHU URXJKO\  W KH*HUP DQFKURQLFOHU$GDP YRQ%U HP HQKDVZULW W HQ
RI D 9LQODQG LQ W KH RFHDQ LQ ZKLFK ZLOG ZLQH DQG ZLOG JUDLQV Z HUH IRXQG LQ
DEXQGDQFH

3RVVLEO\\HDUVROGHULVD5XQHVW RQHLQ'HQP DUNRQZKLFK9LQODQGLVP HQW LRQHG

7KH VW RQH LW VHOI GLVDSSHDU HG Z LW KRXW  W U DFH  EXW  Z H N QRZ  RI D SLFW XU H RI LW V
LQVFULSW LRQ W KDW  ZDV P DGH LQ W KH \HDU   7KH VW RQH VW RRG QH[W  W R W KH IDUP
+RQHQFORVHW R5LQJHULNH1RUZD\2EYLRXVO\D\RXQJVDLORURIDQREOHG\QDVW \
VHW LW XS7KHEHJLQQLQJRIW KHW H[W JRW ORVW 7KHUHP DLQLQJW H[W ZDVW UDQVODW HG
DVIROORZV ³ W KH\ZHQW RXW IDUDZD\DQGW KH\QHHGHGP DW HULDOW RGU\W KHP VHOYHV
DQGIRRG7KH\ZHQW RQW R9LQODQGDQGLQW RW XQGUDDQGVKHHW VRILFH%DGW KLQJV
OXFN FDQ FKDVH DZD\ VR W KDW  RQH GLHV HDUO\´   $OVR LQ DQ DQFLHQW  HSRV IURP  W KH
)lU|HU, VODQGVW KH\VSHDNP XFKRI9LQODQG7KLVP DNHVLP SRVVLEOHW KHDVVXP SW LRQ
W KDW  9LQODQG ZDV QRW KLQJ P RUH W KDQ DQ REM HFW  RI W KH LP DJLQDW LRQ

$VW KHUHLVKDUGO\DQ\GRXEW SRVVLEOHDVIDUDVW KHW UDGLW LRQVFRQFHUQLQJ9LQODQG

DU H FRQFHU QHG  W KHQ W KH U HSRU W  RI DQRW KHU  FRXQW U \  RQ $P HU LFDQ VRLO W KDW  LV
P HQW LRQHGLQW KHVDJDVEHFRP HFUHGLEOH7KLVLVW KHUHSRUW RI +YLW UDP DQQDODQG
ODQG RI ZKLW H P HQ  ZKLFK LV P HQW LRQHG LQ W KH , FHODQGLF 9LQODQG VDJDV  7KH
1RUP DQVRI*UHHQODQGZKRFDP HW R9LQODQGKHDUGW KH, QGLDQVVSHDNRIDFRXQW U\
P RUH LQ W KH 6RXW K ZKHUH ZKLW H P HQ LQ ZKLW H UREHV P RYH DURXQG VLQJLQJ DQG
ZLW KEDQQHUVW KHUHIRUHREYLRXVO\&KULVW LDQV3URFHVVLRQVDUHQRW M XVW D&KULVW LDQ
FXVW RP  EXW  LW  LV DOVR D W DNHQ RYHU FXVW RP   7KH 1RUP DQV FDOOHG W KLV FRXQW U\
ZKLFKW KH\GLGQRW YLVLW *UHDW , UHODQGRUODQGRIW KHZKLW HP HQ:KLOH9LQODQG
DV ZH NQRZ ZDV VHW W OHG W HP SRUDULO\ RQO\ +YLW UDP DQQDODQG VXSSRVHGO\ ZDV D
W UXH FRORQ\ RI D (XURSHDQ SHRSOH SRVVLEO\ , ULVK W KDW  Z DV REYLRXVO\ DOUHDG\
IRXQGHG LQ  $'  7KH , FHODQGLF VDJDV VSHDN RI W KUHH FDVHV LQ ZKLFK 1RUP DQ
VDLORUV ZHUH GULYHQ W KHUH E\ VW RUP V QDP HO\ LQ W KH \HDUV   DQG 

2PLWWHG


0HDQZKLOHDUFKDHRORJLFDOHYLGHQFHVKRZVW KDW W KHVHUHSRUW VZHU HFRUUHFW RIW HQHYHQ



XQGHUVW DW HGVLQFHQRW HYHU\W KLQJZ HQW EDFNW R, FHODQG

 

:KDW  H[DFW O\ W KH VLW XDW LRQ ZDV ZLW K W KLV +YLW UDP DQQDODQG LV VW LOO DQ XQVROYHG
HQLJP D, W VHHP VW KDW LW UHDFKHGIURP W KH&KHVDSHDNH%D\VRXW KDOOW KHZD\W R
)ORU LGD 5XQHVW RQHV LQ )ORU LGD  5-*  DQG W KDW  LW  Z DV D (XU RSHDQ &KU LVW LDQ
&RORQ\RQ$P HULFDQVRLOW KDW ODVW HGIRUDW OHDVW W R\HDUV:HNQRZRQO\
YHU \  OLW W OH DERXW  W KH IDW H RI W KLV FRORQ\  :KHQ DQG KRZ  LW  HQGHG DQG Z KDW
KDSSHQHGW RLW VZKLW HLQKDELW DQW VLVHQW LUHO\XQNQRZQ6W LOOLQW KH6KDZDQV
6KDZQHHV" ZKROLYHGRQW KH2KLR5LYHUP HQW LRQHGW KDW )ORULGDZDVRQFHLQKDELW HG
E\ ZKLW H SHRSOH ZKR KDG LURQ W RROV  7KH FXOW XUDO SHRSOHV RI 0H[LFR W KH 7ROW HFV
DQGW KH0D\DQVNHSW W HOOLQJW KDW W KHLUFXOW XUHFDP HW RW KHP IURP W KH1RUW K7KH
EULQJHU RI FXOW XUH RI W KH 0D\DV 4XHW ]DFRDW O W KH ³ ZKLW H VDYLRU´   DQG LQILQLW HO\
EHQHYROHQW  JRG KDV W UDLW V RI &KULVW  LQ IDFW  KH LV HYHQ GHVFULEHG DV W KH 'LYLQH
VRQ RI D YLUJLQ P RW KHU  7KHUH LV DOVR W KH FXVW RP  RI ZRUVKLSSLQJ W KH FURVV LQ
DQFLHQW  0H[LFR ZKLFK DP D]HG DOUHDG\ &RUW H]  7KHQ W KHUH ZDV FHOLEDF\ RI W KH
SULHVW V UHOLJLRXV FXVW RP V W KDW  DUH VLP LODU W R RXU EDSW LVP  DQG FRP P XQLRQ  $OO
W KLV OHDGV XV W R FRQFOXGH W KDW  W KHU H LV D KLJK SU REDELOLW \ RI VW U RQJ &KU LVW LDQ
LQIOXHQFHVORQJEHIRUHW KHDUULYDORI&ROXP EXV &RQVLGHULQJW KHFLUFXP VW DQFHV
GHVFULEHGDERYHVXFKLQIOXHQFHVFRXOGRQO\KDYHFRP HIURP W KH&KULVW LDQ, ULVKP HQ
RI+YULW DP DQQDODQGLQ)ORULGD, Q<XFDW DQW KH\GLVFRYHUHGHYHQDVSHFLDO³ W HP SOH
RI W KH FURVV´  RI W KH 0D\DV LQ ZKLFK W KH ZRUVKLS RI W KH FURVV LV LQ D SLFW RULDO
UHSUHVHQW DW LRQ  7KLV ZDV LQ W KH P \VW HULRXV FLW \ RI UXLQV RI 3DOHQTXH W KDW  ZDV
IRXQG DJDLQ DIW HU LW  ZDV FRP SOHW HO\ RYHUJURZQ E\ W KH M XQJOH IRU  FHQW XULHV

7KHU H LV QR HQG W R W KH VHFU HW V  Z KHQ Z H

LP P HUVH RXUVHOYHV LQW R W KH P LUDFOHV RI W KH
DQFLHQW $P HULFDQFXOW XUHV1RGRXEW ZHKDYH
K HU H RQ H RI  W K H P RVW  U HZ DU GLQ J I LHOGV RI
DFW LYLW \ IRU IXW XUH UHVHDUFK  :H KDYH ZHOO
IRXQGHG U HDVRQV W R FRQFOXGH P XFK P RU H ³ &K U L VW L DQ
Q DP HO\  W K DW  ³ &K U LVW LDQ LW \ ´  RU LJ LQ DW HG  LQ &URVV´
$Q FLHQ W  $P HU L
$W ODQW LV&RP LQJIURP W KH:HVW IURP , UHODQG 6XQ :KHHO
FDQ6RODU6ZDV
6FRW ODQG , RQD LW  UHYLYHV DQHZ  DQ DQFLHQW I U RP  1RU W K
W LN D I RX Q G LQ  D
GRFW ULQH ZKLOH LW  H[SHULHQFHG LW V IUDXGXOHQW $P HU LFD I U RP
P RX Q G  LQ  7HQ 
IDOVLILFDW LRQ LQ 5RP H E HI RU H LW V U H
Q HVVHH
GLVFRYHU\
7KH 0H[LFDQ S\UDP LGV LQ W KH :HVW  DQG W KH (J\SW LDQ S\UDP LGV LQ W KH (DVW  GR
P RUH W KDQ OHDG W R DQ DVVXP SW LRQ RI $W ODQW LV W KHLU P RW KHUODQG  , Q IDFW  VXFK D
FRQFOXVLRQ EHFRP HV XQDYRLGDEOH HYHQ W R SHUVRQV ZKR ZRXOG QRW  N QRZ RU W DNH
VHULRXVO\ W KH UHSRUW  RI 3ODW R ZKLFK KH UHFHLYHG IURP  (J\SW LDQ VRXUFHV  7R DGG
W R RXU FODLP  RI DQ $W ODQW HDQ RULJLQ &KULVW LDQLW \ ZH P HQW LRQ W KH UHSRUW  RI 6YHQ
+HGLQ DQG W KDW  ZKLFK &DSXFKLQ P LVVLRQDULHV UHSRUW HG EHIRUH KLP    7KDW  7LEHW DQ
/DP DLVP  LV D SHUIHFW  FRUUHODW LRQ ZLW K W KH &DW KROLF &KXUFK  +HU H QRW KLQJ FDQ EH


2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 
KLGGHQDQGFRQFHDOHGEHFDXVHLQW KHOLJKW RIQHZKLVW RU\W KHUHLVQRSRVVLELOLW \
W RFODLP DFRQQHFW LRQRI7LEHW ZLW KW KH:HVW VLQFHW KHUH HP HUJLQJRI&KULVW LDQLW \  

7LEHW  UHP DLQHG XQW RXFKHG W R RXU GD\V DQG LW  ZLOO VW LOO UHYHDO P DQ\ VHFUHW V W KDW
DUHQRW DW W KHOLNLQJRI5RP H+RZFDQW KHHTXDOLW \RIFXOW  RI5RP HDQG/KDVD
EH H[SODLQHG RU ³ H[FXVHG´ "  :K\ LV 5RP H DQG ZLW K LW  W KHRORJ\ DV D ZKROH
VLOHQW DERXW W KHVHLP SRUW DQW DQGHQLJP DW LFFRQQHFW LRQV"7KH\DUHP RUHFRQFHUQHG
ZLW KW UXO\OHVVSURP LVLQJTXHVW LRQV:K\GRHV7LEHW UHP DLQLQDSSURDFKDEOHDQG
FORVHG"   7KH UHDVRQ LV FHUW DLQO\ QRW  W KH LQKRVSLW DEOH FKDUDFW HU RI W KH ODQG DQG
LW V FOLP DW H   7KU HH EDW W DOLRQV RI (QJOLVK LQIDQW U \  Z RXOG IRU FH HQW U \  LQW R W KH
FRX Q W U \  DQ G  X Q G HU  W K HLU  S U RW HFW LRQ   VFLHQ W LVW V FRX OG  W K HQ  J LY H Y DOX DE OH
LQIRU P DW LRQ  

7KH 5RP DQ FKXUFK VSHDNV RI ³ XQH[SODLQDEOH´  P \VW HULHV RI LW V FXOW  DQG ZLW K W KLV
LW  SXW V LW VHOI DW  RGGV ZLW K W KH RIILFLDO W HDFKLQJ RI LW V GRFW ULQH W R W KH ³ SDJDQV´
ZKR ZLOO XQGHUVW DQG W KHVH P \VW HULHV HYHQ OHVV W KDQ W KH FKXUFK LW VHOI

, Q W KH P \VW HULRXV 7LEHW  FXOW  DQG GRFW ULQH DUH KLGGHQ EHKLQG D YHLO W KDW  VHHP V
LP SHQHW UDEOH  , W  DOP RVW  VHHP V W KDW  7LEHW  P D\ QRW  KDYH W KH NH\ W R W KH VHFUHW 
EXW  W KDW  LW  NQRZV W KH VHFUHW  QHYHUW KHOHVV ZKLOH 5RP H KDV ORVW  W KH VSLULW XDO NH\
ORQJ DJR

, IW KH*HUP DQLFSHRSOHVDQGDQFLHQW $P HULFDQ, QGLDQVNQHZRIEDSW LVP DQG/DVW

6XSSHU FXVW RP V W KDW  ZH ILQG DV ZHOO ZLW K W KH 7LEHW DQ /DP DV  Z H KDYH W R DVN
)URP ZKHUHGRW KHVHV\P EROVFRP HRULJLQDOO\"1RW IURP 5RP HEHFDXVH$P HULFD
DQG 7LEHW  KDY H REY LRXVO\  XVHG RW KHU  VRXU FHV   7KDW  LV FOHDU   :H FRQFOXGH
HIIRUW OHVVO\W KHFRP P RQRULJLQRIW KHW KUHHSURYLQFHVRIFXOW V7LEHW 0H[LFRDQG
5RP HIURP DP RW KHU FXOW ZKLFKZHFDQDVVXP HHIIRUW OHVVO\DVFRP LQJIURP W KH
VXQNHQ $W ODQW LV

7KH*UHDW /DP DVDFULILFHVEUHDGDQGZLQHHDW VDQGGULQNVIURP W KHP DQGVKDUHV

LW  W KHQ  /LNH W KH 3RSH KH FDUULHV W KH 7LDUD W KH ³ W UR\´ W KH 'UHL W KH W KUHH  W KH
7URLHW KH³ 7UHXH´  P RG*HUP DQIRUIDLW KIXOQHVV RIW KH$W ODQW HDQNLQJV7KHVH
DUH QRW  M XVW  VLP LODULW LHV EXW  FRP SOHW H LGHQW LW \  7KLV OHDGV W R D FRP P RQ RULJLQ
Z KLFK Z H ILQG RQO\ LQ $W ODQW LV  7KH 5RP DQ FXOW  LV EHW Z HHQ W KH 7LEHW DQ DQG
$P HULFDQRQHRQO\E\VSDFHEXW LW LVQRW W KHLURULJLQ$OOW KUHHKDYHW KHLURULJLQ
LQ W KH 8U FXOW  RI W KH $U\DQ $W ODQW HDQ SULHVW KRRG ZKLFK W DXJKW  W KLV 8U UHOLJLRQ
Z KLFK VW LOO LV YDOLG Z LW K DOO SHRSOHV RI W KH (DU W K  KRZ HY HU  Z LW K LW V FRQW HQW V
W KLQQHGGRZQW RW KHH[W UHP H7RUHDOL]HW KLVZHKDYHW RNHHS RXUIRFXVRQW KH
DFW X DO HVRW HU LF HVVHQ FH RI  GRJP DV  P \ W K V DQ G W HDFK LQ JV  Z K LOH E \ SDVVLQ J


 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 

HY HU \ W K LQ J  W K DW  K DV E HHQ  G LVW RU W HG  E \  G HJ HQ HU DW LRQ   I DOVLI LFDW L RQ 

P LVXQGHUVW DQGLQJ DQG IUDXG  

7KLVHVVHQFHW KHQRULJLQDW HGLQ$W ODQW LVIURP EHIRUHW KHW LP HRILW VRZQUHSRUW HG

VSLULW XDO DQG SK\VLFDO GH UDFLDOL]DW LRQ  :H FDQ DFFHSW  W KLV DVVXP SW LRQ ZLW KRXW
GRXEW V DV ORQJ DV ZH FDQQRW  ILQG DQ\ EHW W HU H[SODQDW LRQ  7KLV LGHD KHOSV XV DW
OHDVW W RHVW DEOLVKDVROLGEDVLVW RZKLFKZHFDQILQGEDFNDIW HUDOOIDLOHGDW W HP SW V
RI RW KHU H[SODQDW LRQV

7KH %LVKRSV VW DII EHOO YHVSHU P DVV DQG NH\ DUH SUHVHQW  LQ 7LEHW  DV ZHOO  , Q
/KDVD LQIDOOLEOH DQG LQDSSURDFKDEOH LV W KH 'DODL /DP D DV UHSUHVHQW DW LYH RI *RG
OLNHW KH3RSHLQ5RP H$³ &KULVW LDQ´ KHDGLQ(XURSHDQG³ 3DJDQRQHV´ LQ$P HULFD
DQG $VLD ZKLFK ZRXOG W HDU XS HDFK RW KHU LI W KH\ FRXOG JHW  DJDLQVW  HDFK RW KHU
7KH EORRG W KLU VW LHVW  RQH LV W KH RQH Z LW K W KH QDP H RI 5RP H   , W  KDU GO\  OHIW
DQ\W KLQJ RI LW V EU RW KHU  LQ $P HU LFD GHYRXU HG KLP  Z LW K KDLU VNLQ DQG ERQHV
EHFDXVH LW  ZDV W HUULILHG W R UHFRJQL]H LW V EURW KHU ZKHQ LW  IRXQG KLP  DJDLQ DQG LW
GLG VR XQGHU W KH JXLVH RI EURW KHUO\ &KULVW LDQ ORYH   7KHUH LV QR GRXEW  W KDW  LW
ZRXOGDOVRHP EUDFHW KH7LEHW DQEURW KHUZLW KFODZHGDUP VRIORYHLILW FRXOGJHW
KROG RI KLP   %XW  W KLV GHDGO\ IUDW HUQL]DW LRQ ZRXOG W KHQ DSSHDU LQ D ZRUOG W KDW  LV
P RUH DZDNH  7KHQ W KH W LP H ZRXOG KDYH DUULYHG ZKHQ W KH W LDUD W KH ³ 7URM D´
7U R\   W K H W U LSOH FU RZ Q   W K H DQ FLHQ W  ³ 'U HLH´  Q X P EHU  W K U HH   W K H ³ 7U HX H´
IDLW KIXOQHVV  W KH ROG ³ *ODXEH´  IDLW K  W KH ³ *HOREXQJ´  SURP LVH  ZRXOG IDOO RII
W KH ORZ IRUHKHDG

7KH-HVXVW KH$VXVW KHVRQRI*RGW KH&KULVW W KH$ULVW XVW KH+DULVW RVLVRQO\

D OLJKW  W KDW  ZDV ERUURZHG E\ W KH 5RP DQ &KXUFK ZKLFK VKLQHV W R LW  LQ YDLQ
EHFDXVH LW  QHYHU LOOXP LQDW HG LW   7KLV FKXUFK KDV EDQLVKHG DQG EXUQHG DOO W UXH
GLVFLSOHV  L H  W KH IROORZ HU V RI -HVXV Z KR EHFDP H \ RXQJ EHFDXVH RI 'LY LQH
N QRZ OHGJH

(YHU\RQHZKRP DGHDP LVW DNHRUDQHUURUDFFRUGLQJW RW KHRSLQLRQRIW KHFKXUFK

ZDV H[W HUP LQDW HG LQVW HDG RI LP SURYHG  %XW  5RP H KDG QHYHU W KH SRZHU RI W KH
$ULVW RV &KULVW RV EHFDXVH LW  DOZD\V ODFNHG W KH ORYH RI W KH RIIVSULQJ RI W KH $HVLU
:LW KRXW  ORYH W KHUH LV QR SRZHU DQG W KH OHDGLQJ UDFHV KDYH W R DFFHSW  W KLV  2QO\
DIW HU W KH DFFHSW  D GXW \ W RJHW KHU ZLW K W KHLU FODLP  RI EHLQJ W KH ILUVW  ERUQ RI *RG
DQGW KH(DUW KDQGW RUXOHRYHUW KHLU\RXQJHUEURW KHUVDVZHOODVRYHUDQLP DODQG
SODQW V ZLOO W KH\ JHW  W KHLU SRZHU DJDLQ  7KLV GXW \ P HDQV W R W DNH FDUH RI W KHLU
\RXQJHUEURW KHUVDQLP DOVDQGSODQW VLQVW HDGRIH[SORLW LQJW KHP DQGH[W HUP LQDW LQJ
W KHP  DV W KH\ DUH GRLQJ QRZDGD\V LQ W KHLU EOLQGQHVV  2QO\ ZKR W UXO\ ZDQW V W R
EH UHSUHVHQW DW LYH RI *RG RQ (DUW K DQG ZKR FRQQHFW V ORYH DQG JRRGQHVV ZLW K
SRZHU ZLOO NHHS W KH OHDGHUVKLS  :H GR QRW  SXULI\ W KH ZRUOG Z H W RUW XUH LW  E\
H[W HUP LQDW LQJ W KRVH ZKR DUH QRW  \HW  HYROYHG  :H P DNH W KH ZRUOG EHW W HU LI ZH
OHDG W KH OHVV HYROYHG XS KLJKHU LI ZH EUHHG W KHP  KLJKHU LQ VSLULW  DQG ERG\
, Q3DOHQTXHW KH\IRXQGD/DW LQFURVVZLW KURRVW HU ³ +DKQ´ DQGFDS7KHURRVW HU
SRLQW V W RZDUGV W KH +LJK 2QH LQ *HUP DQ GLDOHFW  LW  LV ³ KDKQ´ DQG LW  SURYHV DQHZ
, QUHDO(QJOLVK , IDERXW KDOIDSHUFHQW RIW KHW HDFKLQJVFRUU HVSRQGW KHW HDFKLQJVDUH


HVVHQW LDOO\W KHVDP HKDYHW KHVDP HRULJLQ, GRQ¶W W KLQNVR

 

&URVV LQ W KH URFN VXUIDFHV RI

/DJR GHOOH 0HUXYLJOLH
%&

&URVVHV RQ D IODW  URFN LQ 5HQRQJDUG

3UH &KULVW LDQ M DVSHU F\OLQGHU IURP

&\SUXV RDW K VFHQH ZLW K FURVV
1RW H LQW HUSUHW LQJW ZROLIW HGDUP VDVDQ
RDW K" XQEHOLHYDEOH

9HVVHO ZLW K FURVV

ZKHHO FURVV IURP  3HW UHQ\
3UH KLVW RULF ZKHHO FURVVHV IRXQG LQ (QJODQG
URFNFDUYLQJVLQ6ZHGHQ

W KDW  W KH V\P EROLF ODQJXDJH W KHUH ZDV $U\DQ W R ZKLFK W KH *HUP DQ ODQJXDJH LV
VW LOO FORVHVW  EHFDXVH RI W KH $U\DQ DQG *HUP DQ W KHVH V\P EROV DU H VW LOO OHJLEOH
2Q W KH RW KHU KDQG W KH ³ &KULVW LDQ´  FURVV DSSHDUV DOVR RQ UHP DLQGHUV IURP  W KH
VW RQHDJHDOVRRQDSUH &KULVW LDQDQFLHQW XUQIURP /RZHU6D[RQ\W RJHW KHUZLW K
W KH VZ DVW LN D

7K H S OX Q G HU HU V RI  W K H DQ FLHQ W  $P HU LFDQ  Q DW LRQ V DQ G  FX OW X U HV W K H Z RU G

³ FRQTXLVW DGRU´ LVW RRKRQRUDEOHIRUW KHVHFULP LQDOV ORRNHGLQDP D]HP HQW DW W KH
EDSW L]HU V Z RU VKLSSHU V RI W KH FU RVV DW  W KH GRY H DW  W KH FU XFLILHG RQH  7KH
P \VW HU\ RI FUXFLIL[LRQ KDV UHDFKHG $P HULFD DOUHDG\ P LOOHQQLD DJR DQG W KHUH W RR
LV ZDV P LVXQGHUVW RRG DQG IRUJHG W R D UHDO SK\VLFDO GHDW K RQ D Z RRGHQ FURVV
UDW KHUW KDQW KHV\P EROLFGHDW KRIW KHVHHNHURQW KHFURVVRIW KHZRUOGW KDW OHDGV
KLP  W R VSLULW XDO UHELUW K

7KH &DW KROLF SULHVW V DQG P RQNV VDZ LQ W KHLU RZQ ULW XDOV DQG GRFW ULQHV ZKLFK
W KH\IRXQGRQQHZO\GLVFRYHUHGVRLORQO\GHYLOVZRUNDQGKHOOLVKFRHUFLRQ, QVW HDG
RI LOOXP LQDW LQJ W KLV VHFUHW  ZLW K W KH SHDFHIXO W RUFK RI VFLHQFH W KH\ LOOXP LQDW HG LW
ZLW K W KH IODP LQJ ORJV RI W KH S\UH  7KH\ EXUQHG VDFUHG W H[W V DQG HYHU\W KLQJ
 

YDOXDEOH W KDW  W KH\ FRXOG JHW  W KHLU KDQGV RQ  :KHW KHU P HDQQHVV RU VW XSLGLW \
ZKRNQRZV, QDQ\FDVHRXW RIFRP SOHW HJRGIRUVDNHQQHVV$IHZP DQXVFULSW V
DQG W H[W V ZHUH VDYHG DQG W KH\ ZLOO JLYH XV YDOXDEOH UHYHODW LRQV  (YHQ LI W KH
³ &KULVW LDQ´  P RQVW HU KDG VXFFHHGHG W R GHYRXU DQG H[W HUP LQDW H HYHU\W KLQJ LQ LW V
ILHU\ W KURDW  W KH W UXW K LV OLYLQJ DQG FDQQRW  EH GDUNHQHG LQ W KH UK\W KP V RI W KH
ZRUOGV LW V VSOHQGRU SHQHW UDW HV DOO SULVRQ ZDOOV  7KH P HVVDJH RI W KH FUXFLIL[LRQ
W KH P \VW LFDO GHDW K RQ W KH FURVV UHDFKHG $P HULFD EHIRUH W KH VLQNLQJ RI $W ODQW LV
7KHQRQO\DIW HUW KHVXSSRVHGELUW KRI&KULVW DORQJLQW HUUXSW LRQRIW KHFRQQHFW LRQ
RIERW KSDUW VRIW KHZRUOG(XURSHDQG$P HULFDEHJDQDW OHDVW DFFRUGLQJW RW KH
XVXDOKLVW RULFDOUHFRUGVW RZKLFKZHKDYHDFFHVV, QGHHGW KHFRQQHFW LRQEHW ZHHQ
3RUW XJDO, UHODQGW KH&DQDU\, VODQGDQG$]RUHVRQW KHRQHHQG DQG$P HULFDRQ
W KH RW KHU ZDV QHYHU LQW HUUXSW HG  1RZ ZH FDQ DOVR XQGHUVW DQG EHW W HU ZK\ W KH
GRFW ULQHRI-HVXVW KHVDYLRUVW KH³ +HOLDQG´W KHVRQRIJRGW KH+LJKHVW RQHW KH
+DULVW RV W KH ³ +HKUVW HQ´  W KH P RVW  VDFUHG RQH  W KH ³ HUVW HQ´  ILUVW  RQH  ZDV
DOUHDG\ LQ , UHODQG (QJODQG W KH %UHW DJQH DQG LQ 1RUW KHUQ *HUP DQ\ ZKHQ W KH
5RP DQ P LVVLRQDULHV DUULYHG DQG DOZ D\V XQGHU RUGHUV RI W KH 5RP DQ FKXUFK
SHUSHW UDW HG W KHLU IDOVLILFDW LRQ W KHUH DV ZHOO  7KHUH ZDV VRP H RSSRVLW LRQ W R W KLV
GD\

1RZZHKDYHW RW HOOZKRW KLV-HVXVZDVHYHQW KRXJKZHJLYHKHU HRQO\KLQW V+H

LV D JRG bVXV $VXV -DVXV -HVXV SURYHQ E\ W KH .HOW V D ZRUG ZKLFK ZH HTXDO
W KH*HUP DQKHURHVDQGW KHUHIRUHFHUW DLQO\ZLW KW KH*DXOV*DOLOHDQV*DODW LDQV
&KDOGHDQV &DOHGRQLDQV DQG ZKDW HYHU QDP HV W KHLU VSURXW V KDYH DOO RYHU W KH
ZRUOG7KHQDP H-HVXVbVXV$VXVLVDOVRUHIHUUHGEDFNW RDNLQJRIW KHW ULEHRI
, VVD-HVVHW KH(VVHUW KH(VVDHDQW KH$HVLU:HFDQDVVXP HW KDW ERW KFKDUDFW HUV
P HUJHG H[FKDQJHG DQG XQLILHG

*RG(VXVRIW KH.HOW VRIW KH*DXOLVKRIW KH\HOORZVRIW KHEORQGVRIW KH*DHOLF

EHFDP H D W RW DOO\ W Z LVW HG SDURG\ RI W KH %LEOLFDO *DOLOHDQ -HVXV   +HUH LQ W KH
³ *DOLOHDQ´  D W UXH P HP RU\ ZDV SUHVHUYHG W KH IRUJHU\ GLG QRW  VXFFHHG HQW LUHO\
HVSHFLDOO\ EHFDXVH ZH NQRZ DOVR SUHFLVHO\ W KDW  W KH 'UXLGLF W UDGLW LRQV RI $VXV DV
ZHOO DV W KH VHFUHW  W H[W V RI W KH JRVSHOV FRQW DLQ W KH FRVP LF &KULVW   7KLV FRVP LF
&KULVW DQGW KHUR\DOFKDUDFW HURI-HVXVZHUHW KHQLQFUHDVLQJO\P L[HGXSZLW KHDFK
RW KHU RQ D ORZHU OHYHO LQ W KH LP DJLQDW LRQ DQG W UDGLW LRQV RI OLVW OHVV SRZHUV

7KH .HOW V KHU RHV DV W KH ROGHU  N LQIRON V DV W KH IDW KHU V DQG EU RW KHU V RI W KH
*HUP DQLFSHRSOHVZKLFKW KH\DUHW KHP VHOYHVDQG\HW DJDLQRW KHU VHYHQW KRXJK
RI W KH VDP H NLQG KDYH VSUHDG RXW  DOO RYHU W KH (DUW K LQ W KHLU P LJUDW LRQV ZKLFK
ZHUH QRW  P LJUDW LRQV W KDW  ZHUH IRUFHG E\ KXQJHU EXW  SODQQHG VHW W OLQJ RI W KH
(DUW K  , Q &DO\GRQ ZKLFK QRZ LV FDOOHG *UHHFH W KH\ ZHUH W KH +HOOHQHV W KH
³ +HOOHQ´    7KH &KDOGHDQV GHVFHQGHG IURP  W KH .HOW V  W KH &DOHGRQLDQV  7KH

2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

QDP H RI 6FRW ODQG ZDV &DOHGRQLD  :KHUH ZH FDQ VW LOO W UDFH .HOW LF ODQJXDJHV
W KHUH ZH ILQG DOVR W KH ODUJHVW  DQG ROGHVW  P RQXP HQW V RI DVW URORJLFDO NQRZOHGJH
DVW KHVW RQHFLUFOHVDQGVW RQHVHW W LQJVLQW KH1RUW KHUQSDUW RI(XURSHSURYH$OO

$VV\ULDQ NLQJ W K FHQW XU\ %& ZLW K FURVV VLP LODU W R W KH , URQ &URVV

2U LHQW DO 0LG (DVW HU Q  ³ &KDOGHDQ´  DVW U RORJ\  GHVFHQGV IU RP  W KLV RIIVKRRW  RI
DQFLHQW  $W ODQW LV  :KDW  RW KHU H[SODQDW LRQ FRXOG W KHUH EH RI W KH SKHQRP HQRQ
W KDW LQW KHVXSSRVHGELUW K ODQGRI$VW URORJ\6XP HULDLW VSUHVHQW GD\LQKDELW DQW V
DUH RQ VXFK D ORZ OHYHO RI HGXFDW LRQ W KDW  ZH HYHQ FDQ QRW  HYHQ ILQG D SXUHO\
VXSHU ILFLDO SUDFW LFH RI DVW U RORJ\  7KLV SHU LRG RI EORRP  ZDV FU HDW HG E\ RW KHU
KXP DQVZKRGHVFHQGHGIURP W KHRULJLQDOFRXQW U\RIDOOFXOW XUH$W ODQW LVDQGIURP
W KHU H &DOHGRQLD 

³$5RVHVSURXW HGW KHNLQGZDVRI-HVVH´ VLQJVW KHSRHW DFFRUGLQJW RYHU\DQFLHQW

W UDGLW LRQ  )URP  W KH SHGLJUHH LH W KH VW HP  URRW  RI -HVVH -HVXV $VXV , VVD
, VDL FDP H D EUDQFK , VVD , VDL EXW  DOVR W KH VW DU DQG SODFH RI RXU UH ELUW K IURP
W KH FRVP RV DFFRUGLQJ W R D ODVW  DQG KLJKHVW  OHYHO RI ZLVGRP 

 2PLWWHG
 

7KH.HOW *HUP DQVW KHKHUR +HUP DQVRFFXSLHG

RQFHDW KLUGRI(XURSHDQG:HVW HUQ$VLD&HVDU
UHSRUW VW KDW W KH.HOW VXVHG*UHHNOHW W HUV6XFK
OHW W HU V Z HU H DOVR IRXQG LQ +HOYHW LD  %XW  W KH
R S S R V L W H  L V  W K H  W U X W K    7K H  *U H H N V   W K H
³ &DO\GRQV´  KDG W KHLU OHW W HUV IURP  W KHLU IDW KHUV
W K H .HOW V  Z K LFK  VK DS HG  W K HVH 5X Q HV I U RP
$W ODQW HDQ8U 5XQHV³ -HVXV´ W RRW DXJKW W KH 1HFN DGRUQP HQW  RI $VV\ULDQ
8U 5XQHV ZKLFK ZHUH H[SDQGHG W R  DQG  NLQJV ZLW K 6XQ ZKHHO W KH
DW  D ODW HU GDW H 0RRQ DQG W KH ZLQG URVH
$FFRUGLQJ W R $ULVW RW OH 3OLQ\ DQG 7DFLW XV W KHUH ZHUH  OHW W HUV  , Q 3DUW   ZH
H[SODLQW KH³ /RUG¶V3UD\HU ´ DVDQDUUD\RI5XQHV7KH$VXVW KH(VXVW KH$HVLU
-HVXV ZDV VNLOOHG LQ 5XQHV RI FRXUVH ZKHW KHU KH ZDV D P \VW LFDO RU KLVW RULFDO
FKDUDFW HU7KLVLVVREHFDXVHW KH³ )XW KDUN´W KH)XW KDUW KH)DW KHU SUD\HUDVZH
W UDQVODW H W KH ZRUG FRUUHFW O\ EHFDXVH 8U NQRZOHGJHDEOH RI ODQJXDJH LV QRW  DQ
HP SW \DUUD\RIFRXQW LQJRIOHW W HUVDVDKDOI GH VRXOHG(XURSHDQ$OSKDEHW RIRXU
GD\VEXW DZLQG ZRUOG 5RVH SRZHUFLUFOH  RIW KHKHDYHQZKLFKLQW KH]RGLDF
UHYROYHV DURXQG RXU KHDG LQ W KH HW HUQDO SUD\HU RI W KH W LP HV  9HUHOLXV DOUHDG\
VDLGW KDW W KH5XQHVDUHGUDZQDQGFXW W KHSXUHUW KHROGHUW KH\ DUH, QGHHGZH
VHH W KH RULJLQ RI DOO (XURSHDQ ZULW LQJ LQ IDFW  DOO ZULW LQJ RI W KH (DUW K FOHDUO\ LQ
W KH FU\VW DO VHDO RI W KH +DJDO ZKLFK FRQW DLQV W KH VDFUHG 8U 5XQHV  1R VFULSW  RI
W KH (DUW K FDQ EH UHGXFHG W R RQH P HDVXUH DQG RQH QXP EHU DV W KH 1RUGLF .HOW
*HUP DQLF +HOG +HUP DQLF ROG $UP DQLF 5XQHV  1RW H W KHVH ZRUG GHULYDW LYHV RI
$W ODQW HDQ RULJLQ

7KH +HOLDQG  W KH 3HU FHYDO  W KH OHJHQG RI $U W KXU  W KH $GGDP V
P DQXVFULSW W KHW UDQVODW LRQRI:XOILODDVW KHROGHVW RIW KHJRVSHOV
W KHROG6D[RQ*HQHVLVDUHQRW FRSLHVEXW W UXHUUHP DLQGHUVRIDQ
8U %LEOH W KDQ W KH &KULVW LDQ-HZLVK RQHV LI ZH ZDQW  W R FDOO W KH
VXSSRVHG 8U VRXUFH RI DOO 6DFUHG ERRNV W KLV ZD\  $OO RYHU W KH
:HVW  OLW HUDU\ IUDJP HQW V ZHUH P DGH ZKLFK UHSRUW  P DQ\ W KLQJV
GLIIHUHQW O\ DQG ZKLFK DOVR UHSRUW  GLIIHUHQW  W KLQJV W KDQ W KH 2OG
DQG1HZ7HVW DP HQW V7KH\DUHQRW OHVVSUREDEOHEXW GHFLVLYHO\
P RUH KRQHVW  DQG ZLW K OHVV LQW HQW 

, Q$P HULFDW KHFUXFLILHGRQHLVDW W DFNHGE\IRXUYXOW XUHVZKLFKFRUUHODW HW RW KH

IRXU ZRUOG HQGV RI W KH FURVV   W KH IRXU HOHP HQW V RI ILUH DLU HDUW K DQG ZDW HU


5RVHQ URVH NUDQ] FLUFOH  URVDU\5RVH SRZHU FLUFOHP D\EHXQGHUVW RRGDVSRZHUURVDU\
 

ZKLFK HDFK SHUVRQ W R LQLW LDW HG LQ W KH DQFLHQW  P \VW HULHV KDG W R RYHUFRP H XQGHU
D W HUULI\LQJ W HVW  RI KLV SRZHUV RI UHVLVW DQFH DIW HU KH VW UHW FKHG RQ W KH (DUW K LQ
FU RVV SRVLW LRQ  W LHG W R W KH FU RVV  KDV GLHV W KH P \ VW LFDO GHDW K  DIW HU  D GHHS
P HGLW DW LRQLQVROLW XGH³ EXULHG´LQRUGHUW RUHVXUUHFW W RDQHZVSLULW XDOOLIHDVD
W Z LFH ERUQ RU UH ERUQ RQH  7KLV SDUDEOH Z DV QHYHU SRLQW HG RXW  VXIILFLHQW O\
EHFDXVH W KH HUURU W KH ODW HUDOL]DW LRQ FUHDW LQJ KLVW RU\ RI D V\P ERO NHHSV VW LOO W KH
QRQVHQVH RI ZKROH HUDV LQ LW V VODYLVK VKDFNOHV
, QW KHP \VW HULRXV*RVODUZKLFKKDVVW LOOXQNQRZQ*HUP DQLFVDQFW XDULHVDP RQJ
RW KHUVW KH.URGR$OW DUW KH\IRXQGIDGHGSDLQW LQJVEHKLQGW KHODUJHFKHVW VLQW KH
FLW \KDOORQZKLFK³ -HVXV´ LVSDLQW HGRQW KHW RUW XUHSROHDQGFRYHUHGZLW KDUURZ
ZRXQGVW KUHHOLOLHVDERYHW KHKHDGEHW ZHHQW ZR6LE\OV7KHVH DUHUDW KHUROGHU
FRQFHSW VW KDQ\RXQJHURQHV, W LVW KH%DOGHU &KULVW DIW HUZKLFKW KHEOLQG+|GXU
+DGHU   W KH P LVGLUHFW HG RQH VW LOO VKRRW V LQ RXU GD\V  7KH W ZR ³ VLE\OV´  DUH
P RW KHU )ULJJD W KH VSRXVH RI :RGDQ DQG P HDQ /RNL ZKR LV GLVJXLVHG DV DQ ROG
ZRP DQ HYLO 6HYHQ 6LE\OOLQ  W KH 0HSKLVW RSKHOHV RI W KH 1RUGLF FDVW  RI JRGV
+HOLDQG DQG 2OG (QJOLVK SRHW V VHH LQ -HVXV W KH P DVFXOLQH \RXQJ NLQJ DQG KHUR
W KH DSRVW OHV DUH KLV ZDUULRUV  $V W KH ZDUULRUV RI .ULVKQD LQ , QGLD ILJKW  DJDLQVW
HYLO³ VSLULW V´VRGRW KH.HOW LF *HUP DQLF+HOG +HUP DQLFZDUULRUVDJDLQVW P RQVW HUV
, Q , UHODQG W KH (LUODQG W KH $U\DQODQG KH ZDV FDOOHG ³ *LOOLFKU LVW ´ ZKLFK P HDQV
.HOW LF&KULVW 7KHUH-HVXVZDVDNLQJDVRQRI*RGIURP DQFLHQW VXQNHQW LP HV
+HUH RQ W KH SODFH RI RULJLQ EHW W HU \HW  W KH SODFH RI W UDQVIHU RI W KH P \W K IURP
$W ODQW LV ZDV W KH P HP RU\ VW LOO P RUH DZDNH  7KLV UR\DO FKDUDFW HU VHHP V P RUH
SUREDEOHDQGW UXHUDVDVRQRI*RGRIFRVP LFELUW KW KDQW KHZDQGHULQJSUHDFKHU
RI *DOLOHH ZKLFK LV ³ *DXO´  LQ ³ 3DOHVW LQH´

7KHUHIRUH W KH FKXUFK FRQVLGHUHG LW  QHFHVVDU\ W R SURYH IRU -HVXV W KH UR\DO EORRG
RI 'DYLG DV OLW W OH FRQYLQFLQJ W KLV DW W HP SW  ZDV 

:H ILQG =HXV W KH IDW KHU RI 7\U RI &KULVW  DV 7XV 7LHV &HVDU P HQW LRQV ³ 'LV´
Z KLFK W KH *DXOV FDOO W KHLU  DQFHVW RU  7KLH‰ 7KXU V 7U XV 7U XW  W KHU HIU RP  W KH
'UXLGV ZKLFKGLGQRW RQO\LQ*DXOEXW DOVRLQ*HUP DQLDKRQRU HGW KH7URM DW KH
IDLW KIXOQHVV 7UHXH  ZRUVKLSSHG DV DQFHVW RUV E\ .HOW V 6F\W KLDQV W KH 6FRW V RI
VFRW W LVK *RW KV *HOHV

7KHUH DUH DW W HP SW V QRW  W R DFFHSW  W KH XQLW \ IRON RI W KH 1RUW K DV D UDFLDO DQG
FXOW XUDOXQLW \DQGW KHUHIRUHDOOUHVHDUFKZLOOEHJRLQJZURQJVW LOOIRUDORQJW LP H
7KH QDP H RI W KH -HZV W RR W KH *RRG RQHV W KH *RW KV EHORQJV LQW R W KLV DUUD\ RI
SHRSOHVDQGZRUGGHULYDW LYHVDQGW KHUHLVSURRIIRUDORQJW LP HDOUHDG\W KDW LQ
W KHFDVHRIW KH³ ELEOLFDO´ DQGKLVW RULF-HZVZHKDYHW RGRZLW KDP L[ XSEHW W HU
D IUDXG EHFDXVH W KH ERRN W KDW  ZH FDOO W KH 2OG 7HVW DP HQW  RULJLQDW HG LQ $U\DQ
VRXUFHV ZKLFK ZHUH GHULYHG DQG P XGGLHG E\ (VUD DQG 1HKHP LD  7KH RDN W UHH


+DGHU DUJXP HQW LQP RGHUQ*HUP DQ

 2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 

ZDV W KH 7LVERRP  W KH W UHH RI =HXV LQ W KH 1RUW K DV LQ W KH VRXW K ZLW K W KH .HOW V
W KHKHURHVW KHOLJKW RQHVW KH*lOLFVW KH\HOORZRQHVW KHEORQGRQHV 7KDW W KH
7URM DW KH7UHXH IDLW KIXOQHVV DVNLQGDQGSODFHKDVW REHORRNHGIRULQW KH1RUW K
SU RYHV QRW  RQO\  W KH 5RP DQ 7DFLW XV EXW  KXQGU HGV HYHQ W KRXVDQGV RI 7U R\
S ODFHV   7U LE HU J   7U HX E HU J   7U RE HU J   7U X G HU LQ J   7U HX FK W OLQ J HQ   7U  G LQ J HQ
7URM DW KLQJHQ  7ULHU   HW F

7KH JORULRXV FRVP LF IUDJP HQW V RI W KH -HVXV &KULVW  LP DJH DUH VFDW W HUHG DOO RYHU
W KH ZRUOG  0DQ\ W KLQJV W KDW  DUH QRW  FRQW DLQHG LQ W KH JRVSHOV Z DV NHSW  RXW VLGH
RI W KDW  W UDGLW LRQ DQG LW  LV QRW  VXUSULVLQJ W KDW  RI KXQGUHGV RI W H[W V RQO\ IRXU
³ DSSURYHG´ DQG³ FOHDQVHG´ RQHVFRXOGUHP DLQZKLOHHYHU\W KLQJHOVHZDVW KURZQ
RXW  DV XQILW  IRU W KH SXUSRVHV RI GHFHSW LRQ DQG IUDXG

6R³ -HVXV´ KDVVDLGDFFRUGLQJW RDQRW KHUUHSRUW  ³ <RXDUHP XFKEHW W HUW KDQW KH
OLOLHV RQ W KH ILHOGV´

$FFRUGLQJ W R (SKDUQLDV -HVXV W DXJKW    ³ ,  FDP H W R GHVW UR\ W KH VDFULILFHV DQG LI
\RXGRQRW TXLW VDFULILFLQJW KHQW KHLUHZLOOQRW TXLW IURP \RXHLW KHU´ 5HJDUGOHVV
RI W KDW  W KH &KXUFK SHUIRUP V GDLO\ VDFULILFHV   RIIHULQJV ZKLFK LV VW LOO D EORRG
VDFULILFHHYHQW KRXJKLQZHDNFRQFHDOP HQW DIW HUW KHGRJP DDFFRUGLQJW RZKLFK
ZLQH DQG EUHDG DUH W UDQVIRUP HG LQW R EORRG DQG IOHVK

7KLVVDFULILFHLQVXFKDVKDSHDQGDW W LW XGHLVEODFNP DJLFN, W VW UXHP HDQLQJLV

7KH³ 6RQRI*RG´W KHKLJKHUKXP DQLW \KDVVDFULILFHGKLP VHOIE\P L[LQJKLVEORRG
ZLW KW KHORZHUUDFHVZLW KW KH³ \RXQJHUEURW KHUV´:LW KW KLVKHORZHUHGKLP VHOI
EHIRUH*RGDQGEHIRUHW KHKXP DQV$QHZFLUFOHRIW LP HKRZHYHUZLOOEULQJDOO
RI KXP DQLW \ RQ D KLJKHU OHYHO DJDLQ

2Q W RS RI DQ DUFK LQ , QGLD LV VW LOO D IRUJRW W HQ ZRUG   ³ -HVXV XSRQ ZKLFK SHDFH
VKDOOEHKDVVDLG 7KLVZRUOGLVEXW DEULGJH JRDFURVVLW DQGGRQRW UHP DLQRQ
LW  W RR P XFK´

7KLVLVZRUW KW KHVSHHFKRIDQ$U\DQZLVHP DQRIDQLQLW LDW H ZKRNQRZVRIW KH

HW HUQLW \ RI W KH VSLULW XDO HJR EHFDXVH RI KLV P DQ\ LQFDUQDW LRQV RQ KLV ZD\ W R
SHU IHFW LRQ

$FFRUGLQJ W R W KH JRVSHOV -HVXV FDOOHG KLP VHOI D VRQ RI 7KHRV ZKLFK LV W KH .HOW
*HUP DQLF+HOG +HUP DQLF2OG$UP DQLF7KLXV7KLRG7HXW =HXV , W DOOGHSHQGV
RQW KHW UXHNQRZOHGJHRI=HXVHVSHFLDOO\IRUW KHUHDGHUW RUH W KLQN(YHU\ERG\
VW DUHVDVLIK\SQRW L]HGE\DZURQJQRW LRQRIW LP HDW W KHELUW KRID³ -HVXV&KULVW ´
 \HDUV DJR  &HUW DLQO\ W KH HTXLYDOHQFH RI W KH FKDUDFW HUV RI W KH %XGGKD DQG
RI &KULVW  FDQ VKDNH XS P DQ\ FRQYLFW LRQV ZKLFK LQ IDFW  DUH UHVXOW V RI EHLQJ
W DNHQIRUIRROV%XW W KLVLVQRW HQRXJKW RH[W HUP LQDW HW KHGHHSURRW HGSUHM XGLFH
RI W KH 3DOHVW LQLDQ -XGHR &KULVW LDQLW \ EHLQJ ILUVW  ERUQ  7KH .HOW LF -HVXV $VXV DV
ZH FDOO KLP  IRU QRZ LV LQ DQ\ FDVH ROGHU W KDQ W KH , QGLDQ .ULVKQD DQG %XGGKD
 

)URP W KHRQFHZDUP 1RUW KW KHODQGRIRULJLQRIW KH3ROHRI$SROHRI$SROORRI

W KH +\SHUERUHDQ VSUHDG W KH KLVW RU\ RI W KH ELUW K RI D ZRUOG VDY LRU  7KH %LEOH LV
D KRGJH SRGJH FROOHFW LRQ RI IUDJP HQW V RI OLW HUDW XUH RI GLIIHUHQW  YDOXHV  7R VHH
LW  DV D P HQW DO FUHDW LRQ RI W KH -HZV ZKLFK ZHUH W KHUH SDLQW HG VR Oj Oj P HDQV W R
NLFNW KHW UXW KLQW KHIDFHZLW KGLUW \ERRW V:HFRQQHFW HGDOUHDG\W KHVLE\OVZLW K
W KH³ -HVXV&KULVW ´W KHFRP LQJRIZKRP W KH\KDYHDOZD\VSUHGLFW HGDVD³ KHDYHQO\´
ELUW K6RLVDOVRW KHXQLFRUQDV\P ERORI&KULVW ZKRLVW KH³ (LQ KRUHQ´W KH³ (LQ
JHERU QHQ´ W KH ³ (LQ EHJRW W HQ´ W KH RQO\ EHJRW W HQ RQH   HLQ KRU HQ  +RU HQ LV
EHJHW W LQJ DQG W KH KRUQ LV W KH V\P ERO RI W KH SHQLV  7KH XQLFRU Q LV DOVR W KH
DQLP DO P RGHUQ*HUP DQ 7LHU EXW DOVRW KH7\UW KHP DVW HURIW KHVLE\OVZKLFK
W KH\ ULGH UK\P H ZKLFK DFFRUGLQJ W R FKXUFK OHJHQG NHHSV KLV ³ KRUQ´  LQ 0DU\¶V
ODS

7KLV ODS LV DOZD\V W KH ODS RI D SXUH YLUJLQ VR W KDW  W KH SXUH EHJHW W LQJ LQ VSLULW
DQG ERG\ LV JXDUDQW HHG  7KLV =HXJH ZLW QHVV  =HXJHU EHJHW W HU  RI DOO LV W KH
=HXV =LRQ =LX 6RKQ 6RQ  W KH -HVXV W KH $VXV W KH &KULVW XV W KH +DULVW RV W KH
KROLHVW  GHU +HKUVW H  W KH ILUVW  RQH GHU (UVW H   P RG *HUP DQ  RQ W KH SODQH RI
W KH(DUW KDVZHOODVRQW KHVSLULW XDOKHDYHQO\SODQHEHFDXVHRQHKDVW RFRUUHODW H
W R W KH RW KHU LQ UHDOLW \  (IIRUW OHVVO\ ZH UHFRJQL]H KHUH W KH 8U  EDVLFV DQG 8U
LQGLFDW RUV RI W KH 8U UHOLJLRQ ZKLFK P XVW  KDYH EHHQ D UDFH UHOLJLRQ D %UHHGLQJ
U HOLJLRQ =XFKW   D %HJHW W LQJ U HOLJLRQ =HXJXQJV  D =HXV U HOLJLRQ EHFDXVH
UHOLJLRQ LV ORYH LV ORYH W R *RG DQG ORYH W R KXP DQV LV VHUYLFH RI ORYH RQ W KH
SK\VLFDO ERG\ HYHQ LI LW  LV DW  W KH ORZHVW  OHYHO RI W HP SOH SURVW LW XW LRQ DV D UHVXOW
RI P LVXQGHUVW DQGLQJ DQG GHJHQHUDW LRQ

$V D ORYH VHUYLFH IRU W KH SXUSRVH RI KLJK EUHHGLQJ LW  ZDV W KRXJKW  XS RQO\ LQ LW V
KRP HODQGW KH1RUW K  $OUHDG\W KHGHJHQHUDW LRQRIW KLVVHUYLFHLQW KH2ULHQW W R
FRYHU XS IRU LQGHFHQF\ VKRZV W KDW  LW V RULJLQ QHFHVVDULO\ DURVH IURP  W KH DQFLHQW
UHOLJLRQ RI UDFH DQG KLJKHU UDFH    $FFRUGLQJ W R OHJHQG W KH XQLFRUQ OLYHG RQO\ LQ
W KH ³ +DU]´  P RXQW DLQV

7KLVLVQRW W REHW DNHQHQW LUHO\OLW HUDOO\HYHQW KRXJKP DQ\W KLQJVLQ*RVODUSRLQW

W RZDUGV LW  KDYLQJ EHHQ D FHQW HU RI W KH -HVXV UHOLJLRQ  :LW K W KH +DU] W KH +HU]
P RGHUQ *HUP DQ IRU KHDUW  LV P HDQW  DQG OLQJXLVW LFDOO\ +DU] LV DOVR +HU] W KH
KHDUW RI*HUP DQ\RIW KH7HXW  ODQGRIW KH=HXV ODQGRIW KHZRUOG%XW IURP W KH
KHDUW  DORQH W KH XQLFRUQ LV HP HUJLQJ ZKLFK P HDQV W KH GHVLUH W R P DW H DQG W R
SURFUHDW H7KLVGHVLUHFRP HVIURP W KH2QHIURP W KH'LYLQHIURP W KH+LJK2QH
, QW KLVUHVSHFW LW LVLP SRUW DQW W RP HQW LRQW KDW \RXFDQH[SODLQW KHP HDQLQJRIW KH
V\P ERO RI W KH XQLFRUQ RQO\ ZLW K W KH KHOS RI *HUP DQLF RU *HUP DQ ODQJXDJH

&KULVW  LV 7<5  :H KDYH GHP RQVW UDW HG P \W KRORJLFDOO\ W KDW  KLV ODQG RI RULJLQ LV
W KH ODQG RI 7\U UHJDUGOHVV RI KLV FRVP LF RULJLQ  7KLV LV W KH ODQG LQ ZKLFK W KH


2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

7KXULQJLDQV  DUH VW LOO FDUU\LQJ KLV QDP H DQG ZKHUH W KH 7KUHH (TXDO 2QHV W KH
7KUHH (TXDO +LJK 2QHV W KH 7ULQLW \ W KH 7URM D W KH 7ULDV RI W KH +LJK 2QH RI W KH
(TXDO+LJK2QHDQGRIW KH7KLUG2QHDSSHDUDVDQFLHQW QDP HVRIFDVW OHVDQGRI
VDFUHG ORFDW LRQV W KDW  DUH VW LOO YDOLG LQ W KH SUHVHQW 

&KULVW LVW KHXQLFRUQZKLFKP DNHVSRVVLEOHDSXUHSURFUHDW LRQZLW KDSXUHYLUJLQ

EXW  KH LV DV ZHOO W KH SHOLFDQ ZKR UDLVHV KLV \RXQJ ZLW K KLV RZ Q EORRG DQG KH
UDLVHVW KHP LQVSLULW DQGERG\7KLVRW KHUV\P ERORIEORRGDQGRIEUHHGLQJVSRNH
LQKXQGUHGVRILP DJHVFDUYLQJVDQGFRORUVW RW KHNQRZOHGJHDEOHLQLW LDW HVRIW KH
P LGGOH DJHV W KDW  ZHUH QRW  W KDW  GDUN DW  DOO   P LGGOH DJHV W KDW  DUH UHIOHFW HG DV
GDUNRQO\LQGDUNKHDGV7KHV\P EROVKDYHEHHQVSHDNLQJDQGVW LOODUHVSHDNLQJ
D ODQJXDJH W KDW  FRQW DLQV P RU H Z LVGRP  W KDQ W KH QRQ SDODW DEOH VW \ OH RI W KH
VFKRODUV RI RXU GD\V D VW \OH W KDW  LV XQJRGO\ DQG P LQGOHVV DQG W KHUHIRUH RQO\
LQW HOOLJLEOH E\ HTXDOO\ XQJRGO\ DQG P LQGOHVV FROOHDJXHV RI W KH IDFXOW \  ³ 3HOLFDQ´
DV VHFUHW  ZRUG LV W KH ³ 3DO .DQ´ W KH %HO %DDO 3RO 3RKO D SROOR %DO GHU    .DKQ
.DKQP HDQVNLQJ.|QLJ *HUP DQ .|QQLQJ.|QQHU W KHSHUVLRQZ KRLVFDSDEOH 
.RQU  %DL %HL %DOO  6XQ  .DQ LV W KH 5XQH . W KH 5XQH RI SURFUHDW LRQ DQG RI
GHVFHQW  W KH 5XQH RI W KH VH[HV  2QO\ W KLV ZD\ W KH LP DJH RU V\P ERO RI W KH
3HOLFDQ ZKR UDLVHV ³ EUHHGV´  KLV \RXQJ ZLW K KLV EORRG LV P HDQLQJIXO

7KH /DW LQ ZRUG IRU FKXUFK ZKLFK LW VHOI P HDQV FLUFOH .LUNH ³ HFFOHVLD´  P HDQV
VHOHFW LRQ  1RW KLQJ FDQ W HOO P RUH FOHDUO\ ZKDW  W KH DQFLHQW  &KXU FK .HUNH .LUNH
.ULV .UHLV FLUFOH  ZDV LQ UHDOLW \   LW  ZDV W KH FLUFOH RI W KRVH ZKR ZHUH FKRVHQ
DFFRU GLQJ W R W KHLU  ERGLHV DQG VRXOV W KHU HIRU H D U DFLDO VSLU LW X DO DQG SK\ VLFDO
EU HHGLQ J LQ VW LW X W LRQ   Z K LFK  LQ  RX U  GD\ V EHFDP H LW V W RW DO RSSRVLW H  Q DP HO\
&DW KROLFLVP  W KH DOO FRP P RQ DV W KH ZRUG FDQ EH W UDQVODW HG OLW HUDOO\ ZKHUH W KH
$OO ZKLFK LV *RG GLHG DQG W KH FRP P RQ   W KLQJ UHP DLQHG

7KH.RUDQW RREULQJVDQLP SRUW DQW KLQW ZKHUHW KHUHLVP HQW LRQRI0DU\ 0LUM DP
DQG W KH ³ FDUSHQW HU ´  7KDLDV  , Q W KH 1HZ 7HVW DP HQW  W KLV ³ FDUSHQW HU ´  LV FDOOHG
-RVHSK%XW W KH.RUDQJRW W KHUHDOQDP HP XFKEHW W HU&KULVW QHYHUFDOOVKLP VHOI
W KH VRQ RI -RVHSK EXW  W KH VRQ RI *RG ZKLFK LV W R XQGHUVW DQG LQ D P \VW LFDO
P HDQLQJ:KHW KHU*UHHN$UDP DLFRU*UHHNKHFDOOVKLP VHOIHTXDOO\W KH6RQRI
7KHRV RI 7HXD RI =HXD RI 7HXI 7KDLDV LQ W KH .RUDQ  %XW  7HXW  LQ *HUP DQ DQG
7KHRVLQW KH1HZ7HVW DP HQW DUHRQHDQGW KHVDP HZRUG, W VLJQLILHVW KHEXLOGHU
RI W KH ZRUOGV W KH FDUSHQW HU *RG 7RW   W KH ZKROH  7KHR DQG =HR DUH 0H[LFDQ
ZRUGVIRUW KH6XQ:KHUHYHUZHOLVW HQZKHUHYHUZHUHDFKRXW W RZKHUHYHUZH
OLVW HQ ZH ILQG DOZD\V W KH VDP H ZRUG DQG W KH VDP H P HDQLQJ IRU W KDW  ZKLFK LV
KLJK H[DOW HG W KH XOW LP DW H W KH IDW KHU W KH =HXV W KH KDQG RI W KH FORFN   W KH
SURFUHDW RU DQG KLV VRQ W KH 6XQ

, Q 5DYHQQD Z H ILQG W KH ³ 0RQRJUDP  RI &KU LVW ´ LH RXU  +DJDO Y HU \ RIW HQ LQ
P RVDLFV RQ VW RQH FRIILQV HW F DQG Z H ILQG LW  OLN HZ LVH LQ W KH &DW DFRP EV RI
5RP H  , W  LV LQW HUHVW LQJO\ QRW HZRUW K\ W KDW  W KLV 0RQRJUDP  W KLV +DJDO LV DOVR
JLYHQW KHQDP H³ *DXORLV´*DOOXV W KHURRVW HUDVDV\P ERO:KHQW KH+DJDOLV

³ *HP HLQ´ LQ*HUP DQP HDQVFRP P RQDVZHOODVP HDQ*RUVOHEHQUHIHUVW RERW KP HDQLQJV

=HLJHULVW KHKDQGRIDFORFN
 

FDOOHG³ *DXORLV´  W KH*DXOJDOOXV /DW LQ EXW JDOOXVLVW KHURRVW HUW KH+DQW KH

+LJK2QHW KHQZHDUHEOHVVHGZLW KDQDGGLW LRQDOFRQILUP DW LRQZKLFKDW ILUVW ZH
P D\ KDYH FRQVLGHUHG DV EHLQJ D ELW  W RR EROG  %XW  RXU FRQFOXVLRQV DUH QRW  W KDW
EROG DW  DOO W KH\ DUH M XVW  VXUSULVLQJ EHFDXVH SHRSOH GLG QRW  KDYH DQ\ QRW LRQ
DERXW  W KRVH W KLQJV W R W KLV SRLQW  LQ W LP H  7KH UHVXOW V DUH VLP SO\ VHOI HYLGHQW  QR
P DW W HU KRZ DP D]LQJ W KH\ P D\ DSSHDU W R W KH QRYLFH LQ W KLV ILHOG RI NQRZOHGJH
7KH *DXOV LQ )UDQFH W KH .HOW V DUH W KH VXSSRVHG ³ *DOLOHDQV´  LQ 3DOHVW LQH ZKHUH
W KHU H LV QRW  W KH OHDVW  KLVW RU LFDO U HDVRQ RIIHU HG IRU  W KH HYHQW V W KDW  W KH ³ 1HZ
7HVW DP HQW ´  UHORFDW HV W R W KDW  DUHD
, Q  I D FW   W K HU H L V Q R  U HD VR Q  D W  D O O 
EHFDXVHW KHQDP HVRIW KHORFDW LRQVDQG
P RX Q W DLQ V Q HY HU  K DG  W K RVH Q DP HV
W KHUHZLW KDYHU\IHZH[FHSW LRQVZKLFK
FDQ EH H[SODLQHG ZLW K FRLQFLGHQFH DQG
W K H I DFW  W K DW  W K H Q DP HV R I  U L Y HU V
P RXQW DLQVFLW LHVDQGDUHDVDOORYHUW KH
ZRUOG DUH UHSHDW HG DV D UHVXOW  RI W KH
ZDQGHULQJVRIW KH$U\DQVZKLFKJLYHQ
W KHP  W KHVH QDP HV   (Y HU \ W KLQJ KDV
³ 0RQRJUDP ´ RI ³ 0RQRJUDP ´
EHHQ W U DQVIHU U HG ODW HU  LQW R W KH (DVW 
&KULVW  DV LW  ZDV RI &KULVW
DQ G W K LV Z DV GRQ H I RU  VSHFLI LF VX E
GHULYHG IURP  W KH
KXP DQUHDVRQVLQRUGHUW RGHFHLYHDQG
+DJ $OO 5XQH
W R FRQFHDO

7KH.HOW *HUP DQLFSHRSOHVRULJLQDW HGLQW KHKHDUW RIW KH$U\DQ8U GZHOOLQJVW KH

ODQG W KDW  LQ RXU GD\V LV FRYHUHG E\ W KH 1RUW K 6HD DQG DOO ³ *DOOLDQV´  *DW DW LDQV
*DOLFLDQV *DOLOHDQV &KDOGHDQV *DODW LDQV  DUH RIIVSULQJ RU VSURXW V P LJUDW LRQV
DQG W KHLU EUDQFKHV RQ W KH ROG SDW K W RZDUGV W KH (DVW  6RXW K DQG :HVW  LQ RUGHU
W R UHOLHYH W KH KRP HODQG IURP  DQ H[FHHGLQJO\ ULFK RIIVSULQJ RI D IHUW LOH 8U )RON
:KHQ QRZ DQ (VXV RI -HVXV ZDV D JRG RU NLQJ RI W KH .HOW V RU *DXOV W KHQ KLV
FUDGOH KLV P DQJHU ZDV LQ W KH 1RUW K LQ W KH KRP HODQG RI W KH .HOW V .DOW V DQG
*DXOVDQGQRW LQW KH6RXW KHDVW $OUHDG\ZKHQZHH[DP LQHGW KHDVW UDOP HDQLQJ
RIW KHP \W KRI&KULVW ZHSRLQW HGRXW W KDW LW FRXOGRQO\KDYHRULJLQDW HGXQGHUW KH
1RUW KHUQ 3RODU VN\  $OVR RQ W KLV GHW RXU W KH +DJDO W KH .DJDOO W KH &DXOGLD LV


$OVRFDOOHG³ :HW W HUKDKQ´  ZHDW KHUURRVW HU+DYLQJDODUJHUW DLOW KDQKHDGDQGEHLQJW KHELUG
W KDW FURZVDW VXQULVHLW ZDVLGHDOW REHDQLQGLFDW RURIW KHGLUHFW LRQRIW KHZLQG<RXILQGLW
P RUHRQW KHW LSRIFKLP QH\VW KDQRQW KHW RSRIFKXUFKW RZHUVZ KLFKW UDGLW LRQDOO\KDYHFURVVHV
 

UHFRJQL]HGDVDV\P ERORIW KHURRVW HURIW KH+LJK2QHW KHURRVW HUEHLQJRQW KH

SHDNV RI FKXUFK W RZHUV DV D V\P ERO RI W KH ³ +LJK 2QH´  VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V 

$W  W KH W LP H RI &KULVW  , W DO\ ZDV FDOOHG ³ 7\UUKHQXV´  7KLV QDP H VW LOO H[LVW V LQ W KH
QDP H RI W KH , W DOLDQ VHD W KH 7\UUKHQLDQ 6HD  , W DO\ VR W R VD\ EHORQJV W R W KH
LQQHU³ 7\U FLUFOH´VRW RVD\, W LVD7\U FRORQ\RIW KH1RUW KDQGLW UHP DLQHGVRIRU
P LOOHQQLD  , W  Z DV LW  ORQJ EHIRU H W KH *DXOV LQYDGHG W KLV FRXQW U \ Z KLFK M XVW
ZDQW HGW RNHHSW KHLUSURSHUW \LQW KHIDFHRIUHQHJDGHRIIVSULQJRIW KH1RUW KW KDW
EHFDP H LQGHSHQGHQW   , W  ZDV LW  GXULQJ W KH LQYDVLRQV RI W KH &LP EUL DQG 7HXW RQV
W KH *RW KV DQG W KH /RP EDU GV W KH *HU P DQ HP SHU RU V RI 5RP DQ QDW LRQ XQW LO
W RGD\EHFDXVHZHZKRKDYHP RUHKXQFKHVNQRZZK\W KHGHVLUHIRUW KLV6RXW K
FRQVXP HV XV  , W  LV W KLV 6RXW K W KDW  KDV EHHQ IHU W LOL]HG DQG P DLQW DLQHG RQO\
W KURXJK RXU EORRG  7KH (GGD ZKLFK FRQW DLQV VW LOO XQGLVFORVHG KLVW RU\ NQRZV
VW LOO W KH W UXW K W KDW  ZH GR QRW  ILQG DQ\P RUH LQ W KH %LEOH DQG W KH , OLDG

6QRUULZURW HLQW KH)RUP DOL ³ 7KDW YDUVHW W 5RP DEXUJHUYHUNDOOXP 7URM D´7KLV
LVW KHROG1RUGLFODQJXDJHRIW KH(GGDDQGLW W UDQVODW HVLQW R*HUP DQ ³ 7KHUHZDV
5RP DEXUJ ZKLFK ZH FDOO 7URM D´   7KHUHIRUH ZKDW  ZDV RQH RI W KH P DQ\ 7URM D
FDVW OHV EHIRUH ZDV QRZ FDOOHG 5RP H  7KH , OLDG W RR NQRZV VW LOO W KDW  5RP H ZDV
IRXQGHG DV DQ RIIVSULQJ RI ³ 7URM D´   E\ ZKLFK RI FRXUVH LV QRW  P HDQW  W KH 7UR\
LQ $VLD 0LQRU W KH QDP H RI ZKLFK LV DQ DVVXP SW LRQ EXW  DQ 8U P RW KHU 7UR\ RQ
$W ODQW LV 7KLVLVYHU\LP SRUW DQW  $JDLQZHJHW EDFNW R7UR\ 7URM D W KH7KUHH
'UHLH  W KH IDLW KIXOQHVV *HUP DQ  7UHXH  W KH 7ULDV  7ULQLW \ 

$FFRUGLQJW RDFRLQIRXQGE\6FKOLHP DQQLQ+LVVDUOLNW KHVXSSRVHG³ 7UR\´3ULDP RV

W KH NLQJ RI ³ 7UR\´  ZDV HVW DEOLVKHG DV EHLQJ W KH ³ .LQJ RI $W ODQW LV´     +LV VRQ LQ
ODZZDV0HQRQW KHVRQRIZKRP ZDVFDOOHG7UR7KLV7URUHP LQGVXVRI7KRUDQG
LQGHHG KH LV EURXJKW  LQW R FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K 6LI ZLIH RI 7KRU  7KLV P HDQV W KH 7UR
LV 7KRU DFFRUGLQJ W R ODW HU GLVW RUW LRQ RI OHJHQG  7KRU 7\U DQG 7UR DUH QDP HV RI
EU RW KHU V  7U R YDQTXLVKHV Z LOG DQLP DOV DQG GUDJRQV DQG W KH GHHGV RI D 6W 
*HRUJH DQG $UFKDQJHO 0LFKDHO DUH DVFULEHG W R KLP   7KH JRVSHO RI /XNH SOD\V LQ
5RP H  , W  UHIHUV W R HP SHURUV $XJXVW XV DQG 7LEHULXV 


 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG


2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG


, UHIUDLQIURP XVLQJW KH)UHQFKODQJXDJHDVDSRLQW RIUHIHUHQFHIRUW KLV³ ZRUGHW K\P RORJ\´ 
7KH³ W ´ DSSDUHQW O\UHSODFHVW KHRULJLQDO)UHQFK³ H´ LQW KLVFDVH
 

7KH ODW H ³ 5RP DQ´  &KU LVW LDQLW \  RU LJLQDW HG LQ 5RP H  VW U DQJHO\  HQRXJK QRW  LQ
3DOHVW LQH Z KHU H LW  VKRXOG KDYH KDG P RU H LP SDFW    $OO UHDVRQV IRU W UDQVIHU
DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH DFW V DQG RW KHU VRXUFHV DUH XQKLVW RULFDO XQW UXVW ZRUW K\  2QO\
ZKHQZHDSSO\RXUGRFW ULQHRIW KH1RUGLF $W ODQW HDQRULJLQRIW KHW HDFKLQJRIW KH
6DYLRU 5RP H JDLQV KLVW RULFDO SUREDELOLW \ DV ZHOO DV LP SRUW DQFH DV RQH RI W KH
UDGLDW LQJ SRLQW V RI D SUH &KULVW LDQ &KULVW LDQLW \  $V ZH KDYH DOUHDG\ VHHQ 5RP H
ZDV RQH RI W KH 7UR\ RIIVKRRW V  %XW  FRQW UDU\ W R W KH 7UR\ RIIVSULQJ LQ W KH 1RUW K
LW  KDV IDOVLILHG W KH DQFLHQW  7URM D W KH W ULQLW \ W KH IDLW K DW  DQ HDUO\ W LP H  2QH RI
W KHVH 1RUW KHUQ RIIVKRRW V LV W KH , ULVK 6FRW W LVK &KULVW LDQ &KXUFK RI W KH &XOGHDQV

$FFRUGLQJ W R W KH XVXDO H[SODQDW LRQ &XOGHDQ P HDQV ³ W KH RQHV FRQQHFW HG ZLW K
*RG´   FXO GHD DQG ZLW K W KDW  LW V P HDQLQJ LV P HW  FRUUHFW O\  7KH ³ FXOW ´   LV W KH
P HDQV RI W KH FRQQHFW LRQ W KH XQLRQ ZLW K *RG  :KHQ ZH ZULW H W KH V\OODEOH &XO
LQ5XQHVW KHQZHFRP HHYHQFORVHUW RLW VP HDQLQJ&RRU.FRU UHVSRQGVZLW KW KH
.   .DQQ  RU SULHVW NLQJV 5XQH W KHUHIRUH LW  FRQW DLQV W KH FDSDELOLW \ W KH DUW  DQG
DOVR W KH IDYRU RI W KH RQHV LQ +HDYHQ DQG RQ (DUW K
7KH 8O FDQ EH VHSDUDW HG LQW R W KH 8U 5XQH DQG W KH /DI 5XQH  W KHU HIRUH 8U /DI
M RLQHGW RJHW KHUDZRUGW KDW UHIHUVW R8U OLIHDQG8U ORYH$FFRUGLQJW RLW VZRUG
P HDQLQJW KHUHIRUH&XOLVW KHSRZHURI8U ORYH1RZLW LVQRW HZRUW K\W KDW P DQ\
DQFLHQW VDFUHG&XOW  SODFHVKDYHP DLQW DLQHGW KLVRULJLQLQW KHLU QDP HVVW LOOLQRXU
GD\V VXFK DV .|OQ &RORJQH  .XOP  . 8OP   %\ W KH ZD\ W KH ILUVW  &XOOH 'HHU
FDP HW R.|OOHGDLQ7KXULQJLDLQW KHW KFHQW XU\, IODW HU5RP HFHGHGDQGRIIHUHG
W KH , P SHULXP  5RP DQXP  W R W KH NLQJV RI W KH 1RUW K W KHQ W KLV ZDV QRW  ZLW KRXW
JRRGUHDVRQDQGDQFLHQW ULJKW V, W JDYHW RW KHKHLUVRIW KHDQFLHQW 8U7UR\LQW KH
1RUW KW KDW ZKLFKZDVGXHW RW KHP , W GLGVRQRW RILW VRZQZLOOLQGLVFULP LQDW HO\
EXW XQGHUVRP HSUHVVXUHRUFRHUFLRQZKLFKZHFDQQRW JUDVSFRP SOHW HO\DQ\P RUH
LQ RXU GD\V

&KU LVW LDQLW \ DV D U HOLJLRQ RI P \VW HU LHV FDP H IU RP  W KH 1RU W K DQG H[SDQGHG
EHLQJNHSW VHFUHW VORZO\DFURVVW KHZKROHFRQW LQHQW HQW LUHO\RQW KHSDW KVRIW KH
DQFLHQW  $U\DQ P LJUDW RU\ URXW HV

)URP W KHVH$U\DQ $W ODQW HDQP \VW HULHVDOOW KHSHRSOHVRIW KH(DU W KUHFHLYHGW KHLU
UHOLJLRQVDQGW KH\NHSW W KHP P RUHRUOHVVGLVW RUW HGZLW KRXW W KHLURULJLQDO³ VRXO´
'XULQJ W KH SURJUHVVLQJ P L[LQJ RI W KH UDFHV W KHVH P \VW HULHV W ULFNOHG GRZQ IURP
ZHOO JXDUGHG YHVVHOV RI W KH *UDLOV RI P \VW HU\ VFKRROV W KDW  H[LVW HG DOO RYHU W KH


 2PLWWHG
 

(DUW K W R W KH RQO\ SDUW LDOO\ P DW XUHG P DVVHV  7KLV SURFHVV SXW  W KHVH UHOLJLRQV RQ
DQ LUUHYHUVLEOH SDW K RI GHFDGHQFH DOUHDG\ DIW HU W KH\ EDUHO\ EHFDP H NQRZQ

7KHFDW DFRP EVLQ5RP HW KDW VXSSRVHGO\ZHUHEXLOW E\W KHHDUO\&KULVW LDQVLQGHHG

ZHUH DQFLHQW  SUH &KULVW LDQ FXOW  SODFHV RI W KHVH P \VW HU\ UHOLJLRQV  :LW K W KHLU
H[W HQW W KH\QHYHUFRXOGKDYHEHHQNHSW VHFUHW   7KH\ZHUHW KHLP P HQVHORGJH
EXLOGLQJ RI W KH H[LVW LQJ JXLOGV RI W KH W LP H IURP  W KH GRFW ULQHV RI ZKLFK W KDW  SDUW
RI W KH P \VW HULHV HP HUJHG W KDW  ZDV FDOOHG ³ &KULVW LDQLW \´  $OO UHOLJLRQV SUHVHUYH
W KH RULJLQDO V\P EROV DQG W KH\ W KLQN LQ V\P EROLF W HUP V RQO\  7KHUHIRUH ZH FDQ
ILQG LQ W KH FDW DFRP EV RI 5RP H DV ZHOO DV LQ DOO DQFLHQW  FXOW  SODFHV HYHU\ZKHUH
W KHVXSSRVHGO\HDUO\&KULVW LDQV\P EROVRIW KH+DJ $OOW KHVZDVW LNDW KHFURVVLQ
W KH ZKHHO DQG W KH FURVV RI OLIH ZKLFK LQGHHG DUH DOO SUH &KULVW LDQ

7KLVZD\RQO\W KHSHUVRQZKRSRQGHUVW KHVHW KLQJVFDQXQGHUVW DQGDQGH[SODLQ

W KDW  LQ , U HODQG DQG *DXO W KH LGHD RI -HVXV LV D IHZ  P LOOHQQLD ROGHU  W KDQ LQ
3DOHVW LQHDQGW KDW , ULVK 6FRW W LVKP LVVLRQDULHVZKRZHUHP HVVHQJHUVRID1RUGLF
FXOW  OHDGHUVKLS ZRUNHG LQ *HUP DQ\ DOUHDG\  \HDUV EHIRUH 5RP H  2Q D ILUVW
JOLP SVH VXFK UHYHUVDO RI W KLQJV P D\ EH XQEHOLHYDEOH W R W KH SHU VRQ ZKR LV QRW
SUHSDUHG IRU LW  EXW  W KH GRFXP HQW V ZLOO LQFUHDVH LQ IXW XUH W KDW  LQFUHDVLQJO\ ZLOO
VXSSRUW W KHUHVXOW RIRXUUHP DUNV, QW KH9DW LFDQLW VHOIW KH\ZLOOILQGERRNV5XQLF
ZRUNVKLVW RU\ERRNVDQGW KHOLNHVXFKDVDOO5RP DQRQHVFRQVLGHULQJW KH*HUP DQLF
SHRSOHV Z KLFK W R W KLV GD\ DUH RQO\ NQRZ Q LQ IUDJP HQW V  )RU W KH VSLULW XDOO\
RULHQW HG³ )UDQN´ W KHUHLVDQXQHTXLYRFDOLQGLFDW RUIRUW KHW UXW KRIRXUFODLP V W KLV
LV W KH IDFW  W KDW  &KU LVW LDQLW \  LQ D KLJKHU  SHU FHSW LRQ  LGHD DQG LP DJLQDW LRQ LV
H[FOXVLYHSURSHUW \RIW KH*HUP DQLFSHRSOHV, QW KH1RQ $ULDQ6RXW KLW GHJHQHUDW HG
SURSRUW LRQDOO\ W R W KH SURJUHVVLQJ SURFHVV RI GHFUHDVH RI 1RUGLF LQIOXHQFH DQG
LGHDOV W KDW  ZDV W KH FKDUDFW HULVW LF RI W KH

+DJDO 5XQH     ³ 0RQRJUDP ´  RI &KULVW      6ZDVW LND IURP  W KH &DW DFRP EV LQ 5RP H

P L[HGSHRSOHVW KDW OLYHGW KHUHDQGW KDW LW EDUHO\FDQH[LVW LQLW VVXSSRVHGSODFH

RI RULJLQ QDP HO\ 3DOHVW LQH DQG LW  LV W KHUH RQO\ DV D UHVXOW  RI W KH VXSSRUW  RI W KH
2FFLGHQW  VLQFH W KH FUXVDGHV  7KH FUXVDGHV W KHP VHOYHV KDG W KH SXUSRVH RI UH
GLUHFW LQJ W KH DW W HQW LRQ RI W KH SHRSOH RI W KH 2FFLGHQW  IURP  W KHLU 1RUW KZHVW HUQ
VSLU LW XDO KRP HODQG 

$ VW UDQJH W UDGLW LRQ UHIHUV W R W KH KRXVH RI 0DU\ LQ /RUHW R , W DO\  7KH SHRSOH
DOZD\V FODLP HG W KDW  /RUHW R ZDV 1D]DUHW K  6XFK IDFW V VKRXOG QRW  EH E\SDVVHG
OLJKW O\ EXW  W KH\  VKRXOG EH M XGJHG DFFRU GLQJ W R W KHLU  Z RU W K  7R U HQGHU  W KLV

 2PLWWHG
 

XQFRP IRUW DEOH P HP RU\ KDUP OHVV W KH H[FXVH ZDV LQYHQW HG W KDW  DQJHOV FDUULHG
W KH KRXVH RI 0DU\ IURP  3DOHVW LQH W R , W DO\  :LW K W KLV ZH GR QRW  FODLP  D ³ ELUW K´
RI &KULVW  RU RI D -HVXV LQ /RUHW R   ZLW K W KLV ZH ZRXOG FRP P LW  W KH VDP H P LVW DNH
DJDLQVW ZKLFKZHSUHDFK EXW VXFKFODLP VSRLQW XVLQDQ\FDVHLQW RW KHGLUHFW LRQ
ZKLFK ZH KDYH W R W DNH LQ RUGHU W R VHH FOHDUO\ FRQFHUQLQJ TXHVW LRQV DQG W KLQJV
W KDW  FRQFHUQ D ODUJH SRUW LRQ RI KXP DQNLQG FRQVFLRXVO\ DQG XQFRQVFLRXVO\  , W  LV
QRW LQFRQVHTXHQW LDOIRUW KHSK\VLFDOHP RW LRQDODQGVSLULW XDOVLW XDW LRQVRIKXP DQLW \
ZKHW KHU RU QRW  LV LW  IRU W ZR P LOOHQQLD XQGHU W KH GHYDVW DW LQJ IRUFHG LP DJHU\ RI D
P HQGDFLRXVW UDGLW LRQ7KHREYLRXVGHFOLQHRIW KH$U\DQ (XURSHDQKXP DQLW \FDQ
EH DW W ULEXW HG W R W KLV VSLULW XDO GHFD\

6LP LODUOHJHQGVDVW KHRQHRI/RUHW RDUHVSUHDGDOORYHU(XURSHQRZDV&KULVW LDQ

OHJHQGVDQGLQDOORIW KHP W KH³ DSSHDUDQFHRIW KH/RUG´ LQW KHODQGRIW KH1RUW K
LV DFFHSW HG IDFW   6RP H FDOO W KLV ³ QDwYH´  DQG ZLW K W KDW  W KH\ DUH FRUUHFW  ZLW KRXW
KDYLQJ W KH LQW HQW LRQ EH VR E\ SURYLQJ ZLW K W KDW  W KH W UXH FKLOG FKDUDFW HU RI W KDW
LGHD7KHFUXFLILHGRQHDSSHDUVDOVRRQDYDVHRI&XP DHW KHSODFHRIW KH6LE\O
LQ SUH &KULVW LDQ W LP HV  %HVLGHV KLP  DQJHOV DUH VW DQGLQJ DQG EHORZ KLP  D P DQ
ZLW KW KHFDGXFHXVDZRP DQZLW KZLQJVDQGDW RUFKDQGDP DQZLW KDFURVVDQG
D KDP P HU LQ KLV KDQG  , Q 8SSVDOD W RR W KH 6LE\OV DUH VW LOO SDUW  RI W KH W UDGLW LRQ
ZKHUH LW  KDV W KH QDP H RI D KRO\ FRZ  7KH 6LE\OOLQH %RRNV FRXOG DQVZHU RXU
TXHVW LRQV  %XW  HYHU\W KLQJ KDV EHHQ GHVW UR\HG ZKLFK FRXOG KDYH VKRZQ W KH
IUDXG DQG IDOVLILFDW LRQ  %|UDQVVRQ W HOOV XV W KDW  ZKHQ $UFRQD W KLV ZRUG P HDQV
DOVR 6XQ ZRP DQ RU DOVR NQRZOHGJH RI W KH 6XQ  ZDV GHVW UR\HG DOVR W KH W KUHH
³ KROLHVW ERRNV´ ZHUHGHVW UR\HG+XP DQVDQGERRNVZHUHEXUQHGE\W KH5RP DQ
&KXUFKE\W KHP LOOLRQ7KH\W KRXJKW W KDW ZLW KW KHERG\DQGSDU FKP HQW W KHVSLULW
W RR ZRXOG EH EXUQHG EXW  HYHU\W KLQJ ZLOO EH IRXQG DJDLQ IURP  W KH VSLULW  DQG W KH
W LP H Z LOO FRP H Z KHQ W KH W U XW K Z LOO FRP H W R W KH OLJKW  DJDLQ QR P DW W HU  KRZ
GLOLJHQW O\ LW  P D\ KDYH KDG EHHQ EXUQHG DQG LW V DVKHV VSUHDG LQW R DOO ZLQGV

6ZDVW LNDV IURP  DQFLHQW  $P HULFD

7KH FUXFLIL[LRQ LV \RXQJHU W KDQ W KH V\P ERO RI W KH FURVV  W KHUHIRUH W KH FURVV
FDQQRW FRP HIURP W KHFURVVRQ*ROJRW KD7KHV\P ERORIW KHFURVVOLNHQRRW KHU
VKRZV W KH GLVW RUW LRQ RI D FRVP LF LGHD LQW R D VFHQH RI H[HFXW LRQ DQG DOO ZKR
H[SHFW HG DQG VW LOO H[SHFW  U HGHP SW LRQ DV D U HVXOW  RI W KLV VDFU LILFLDO GHDW K DU H
IRROHG7KLVLVVREHFDXVHILUVW O\LW LVDOLHRQW RZKLFKW KH\KLQJHW KHLUODVW KRSH
DQG VHFRQGO\ EHFDXVH W KH\ DUH VR JRGIRUVDNHQ W R EHOLHYH W KDW  VRP HRQH FRXOG
UHGHHP  W KHP  E\ W DNLQJ W KHLU SODFH DQG GRLQJ P RUH VR E\ P HDQV RI D SK\VLFDO
GHDW K DV LI W KDW  ZKLFK LV VSLULW XDO FRXOG EH UHGHHP HG E\ P HDQV RI D SK\VLFDO

, ULVFK $ULVFK $U\DQ
 

VDFULILFH6LQFHW KHQELOOLRQVRILQGLYLGXDOOLYHVRIKXP DQNLQGOLYHGLQHUURU2QO\

D IHZ LQLW LDW HG SHRSOH ZKR DOZD\V H[LVW HG FRXOG VHH W KH IUDXG EXW  QR P DW W HU
KRZORXGO\W KH\FDOOHGIHZRQO\KHDUGW KHP W RW KLVSRLQW %XW W KHW LP HLVKHUH
ZKHQ QRW  RQO\ W KH RQHV DZDNH DUH UHDG\ EXW  W KH VOHHSLQJ RQHV W RR DUH ZDNLQJ
XS

:H ILQG W KH V\P ERO RI W KH FURVV LQ W KH GROP HQ RI , UHODQG ORQJ EHIRUH W KH VR
FDOOHG³ LQW URGXFW LRQ´ RIW KH(DVW HUQ&KULVW LDQLW \LQW KH1RUW K, W LVSURYHQW RKDYH
VSUHDGDOORYHUW KH(DUW KFRP LQJIURP W KH1RUW KW HQVRIW KRXVDQGVRI\HDUVDJR
7KHU H W RR ³ -HVXV &KU LVW ´  H[SODLQV W KH  OHW W HU V RI W KH , U LVK RI W KH $U \DQ  
$OSKDEHW  LQ RW KHU  Z RU GV W KH 5XQH U RZ  RI  SDU W V W KH 5XQH )XW KDU N  W KH
)XW KHU W KH)DW KHU SUD\HUEHFDXVHW KHUHZRXOGQRW KLQJW REHH[SODLQHGZLW KDQ
³ DOSKDEHW ´    RU GLG KH UHDOO\ ZDQW  W R W HDFK KLV GLVFLSOHV KRZ W R ZULW H"  7KH YHU\
DQFLHQW  , ULVK DOSKDEHW  KDV  V\P EROV DQG VKRZV D JUHDW  VLP LODU LW \ ZLW K W KH
5XQHV DV ZH ZRXOG H[SHFW 

7KHUH DUH DQFLHQW  .HOW LF W H[W V DQG LQVFULSW LRQV ZKLFK DUH QRW  \HW  GHFLSKHUHG
7KH W HQXUHG DQG SDLG UHSUHVHQW DW LYHV RI VFLHQFH P DNH HIIRUW V FRQFHUQLQJ W KLQJV
W KDW DUHIDUW KHVW DZD\ZLW KFRP P HQGDEOHGLOLJHQFHEXW W KHDUHNHSW DZD\E\DQ
LQYLVLEOH IRUFH IURP  W KH SODFHV W KDW  FRXOG EULQJ YDOXDEOH LQVLJKW V  7KH ZKROH
1RUW KFRQW DLQVP RUHLP SRUW DQW ILQGVW KDW QHHGW REHHYDOXDW HGW KDQW KHHQW LUHO\
ZRUNHG RYHU 0LGGOH (DVW  ZKHUH W KH UXEEOH KDV EHHQ UH GXJ IRU W KH W KLUG DQG
IRXUW KW LP HVLQRUGHUW RILQGKDOIDEULFN1RRQHVHULRXVO\ZRUNHGZLW KW KHURFN
GU DZ LQJV LQ %RKXVOlQ RU  FRXOG HYHQ GR VR HYHQ LI KH Z DQW HG EHFDXVH W KH
JRYHUQP HQW VRIW KH1RUW KHUQ(XURSHDQQDW LRQVKDYHQRP RQH\IRUVXFKORVH W R
K RP H Z RU N    %X W  W K H SU REOHP  LV Z LW K  W K H JRY HU Q P HQ W  W HQ X U HG SU RI HVVRU V
W KHP VHOYHV  , I W KH\ DVNHG IRU W KH P HDQV W R GR VXFK ZRUN W KH\ ZRXOG UHFHLYH
W KHP %XW ZLW KGLIILFXOW W KLQJVOLNHW KDW QRIDP HFDQEHDFKLHYHGM XVW H[SRVXUH
LI W KH\ FDQQRW  NQRZ ZKDW  W R GR ZLW K W KRVH W KLQJV

, Q.HOW LFORUH-HVXVURGHRQDZKLW HKRUVH7KLVLVW KHDQLP DORIW KHFRDW RIDUP V

RI W KH Z KLW H U DFH DV VXFK DQG LW  VW LOO VKRZ V XS LQ DQFLHQW  OHJHQGV   , Q W KH
KHDUW ODQGRIW KHZKLW H$U\DQUDFHLQW KHROG6D[RQ\ZKHUHW KH³ 6DVVL´ DUHW KH
8UHLSSHQ´ VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V W KH M XP SLQJ KRUVH LV OLYLQJ LQ W KH FRDW  RI DUP V RI
+DQQRYHU  ³ :KLW H´  KRUVH LW  ³ :LW ´  DQG ³ 5RW ´  7KLV P HDQV LQ KLGGHQ ODQJXDJH
³ NQRZOHGJH´ DQG³ ULJKW ´ LQW KHODQGRIW KHZKLW HKRUVHLQW KHROG6D[RQ\LQW KH
ODQGRI:LGXNLQGZKLFKGHIHQGHGLW VHOIDJDLQVW W KHIUDW ULFLGHRI.DUOW KHEXW FKHU
RI W KH 6D[RQV ORQJHU W KDQ DQ\RQH HOVH

:LGXNLQG DQG :LW W HONLQG DUH JHQHUDOO\ W UDQVODW HG DV ³ FKLOG RI W KH ZLGRZ´  DQG
W KLVW UDQVODW LRQP DNHVVHQVHLQW KHOLJKW RIDVSHFLILFOHYHORINQRZOHGJHEHFDXVH
ZLW K³ ZLGRZ´ LVDOVRP HDQVW RHROG³ ZLW W XP ´RU³ ZLVGRP ´7KHU HIRUHW KHP DVW HUV
RI W KH FRQVW UXFW LRQ ORGJHV W RR   DV ZHOO DV W KHLU VXFFHVVRUV W KH )UHH 0DVRQV 
OLNHGW RFDOOW KHP VHOYHV³ FKLOGUHQRIW KHZLGRZ´%XW ³ :LG´ RU ³ :LW W H´ LVDOVRRXU
³ Z LVGRP ´ DQG D ³ :LGX ´  RU  ³ :LW W H ´  .LQG LV W KHU HIRU H RQ D KLJKHU  OHY HO RI
LQW HUSUHW DW LRQ D SHUVRQ ZKR W HDFKHV ZLVGRP  EXW  DOVR ZKLW HQHVV EHFDXVH LW
RZHG KLV NQRZOHGJH KLV ZLVGRP  W R W KH ROG ³ ZLGRZ´
 

;, 9
(7(51 $/5(7851
7KDW  \RX FDQQRW  HQG W KLV P DNHV \RX JUHDW 
$QG W KDW  \RX QHYHU EHJLQ W KDW  LV \RXU GHVW LQ\
<RXU VXIIHULQJ LV W XUQLQJ URXQG DQG URXQG OLNH W KH YDXOW  RI W KH VW DUV
%HJLQQLQJ DQG HQG FRQW LQXRXVO\ W KH VDP H

7KH DU JXP HQW  FRQFHU QLQJ W KH VXSSRVHG ³ SHU VRQ´  RI W KH VXSSRVHG
IRXQGHU  RI W KH VXSSRVHG &KU LVW LDQ FKXU FK KDV QHYHU  TXLHW HG GRZ Q
VLQFHW KHGD\VRIW KHVXSSRVHG³ ELUW K´ RI&KULVW (YHU\SHUVRQVHHVLQ
W KDW  SHU VRQ  RU  LQ W KH LGHDV W KDW  KH U HSU HVHQW V  W KDW  Z KLFK KH LV
KLP VHOI  ³ <RX DUH HTXDO W R W KH VSLULW  RI ZKRP  \RX KDYH D FRQFHSW ´
FRXQW V IRU KHUH DV ZHOO  .DQW  VDZ LQ W KH W KRXJKW  RI &KULVW  LQ ³ -HVXV
&KULVW ´ DQ LP DJH RI KXP DQ SHUIHFW LRQ RU ³ W KH SHUIHFW  KXP DQ EHLQJ´
W KHUHIRUHQRVLQJXODUKXP DQSHUVRQQRKLVW RULFDOUHDOLW \QRHDUW KERXQG
KXP DQ EHLQJ   )LFKW H XQGHU VW RRG KLP  DV EHLQJ W KH ILU VW  RQH Z KR
SURFODLP HG W KH P \VW HU\ RI W KH XQLR P \VW LFD ZLW K *RG ZKLFK E\ W KH
ZD\ LV QRW  W KH FDVH   DV DQ LQFDUQDW LRQ RI W KH 'LYLQH ZRUG RI W KH
/RJRVRUW KH'LYLQHUHDVRQW KHUHIRUHDOVRQRW DVDKXP DQEHLQJRUDV
*RG  )UDQ] +DUW P DQQ UHFRJQL]HG KLP  DV DQ LGRO DQG V\P ERO RI W KH
VSLULW XDO UH ELUW K RI W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ 5HQDQ FRQVLGHUHG KLP  W R EH D
EXP  ZKR XVHG P DJLF DQG W KH W KHRORJLDQV RI W RGD\ EHOLHYH LQ KLP  DV
EHLQJ DQ ± ZHOO ZKR FRXOG W HOO W KDW  SUHFLVHO\" ± RQH W LP H DV *RG
KLP VHOIDQGW KHQDJDLQDVDKXP DQEHLQJZKRZDVKLVVRQLQW KHW UXH
P HDQLQJ RI W KH ZRUG LH LQ W KH KXP DQ VHQVH ZKR KDV HQM R\HG W KH
ULJKW VRI'LYLQHSRZHUDQG\HW ZKRSZDVVXEM HFW HGW RW KHJHQHUDOIDW H
RI KXP DQV

7KHUHIRUHW KH\QHYHUFDP HW RDQDJUHHP HQW FRQFHUQLQJW KHSHUVRQRI

&KULVW ZKHW KHUKHZDVQRZKXP DQRU'LYLQH7KHW KHRORJLDQVRIW KH
&KULVW LDQDQW LTXLW \RQW KHRW KHUKDQGNQHZH[DFW O\DERXW W KHP \ W KLFDO
FKDUDFW HURIW KHJRVSHOVDQGRIW KHLUKHUR-HVXV&KULVW 7KHUHIRUHW KH\
DW W ULEXW HG W R KLP  QRW  W KH FKDUDFW HULVW LFV RI D KXP DQ SHUVRQ EXW  RQO\
W KHKXP DQQDW XUHDQGZLW KW KDW W KH\JDYHLQW KHGRJP DRIW KHGXDO
QDW XUH LQ -HVXV &KULVW  W KH SKLORVRSKLFDOO\ FRUUHFW  GHVFULSW LRQ RI W KH
P \ W K LFDO P DW W HU  RI  I DFW   Z K LFK  LV Q R ORQ J HU  X Q G HU VW RRG  E \  W K H
W KHRORJLDQV RI RXU GD\V DQG ZKLFK W KHUHIRUH LV QR ORQJHU DFFHSW HG E\
W KHP 7KLVKDVEHHQGHVFULEHGH[FHOOHQW O\E\$GDP $EHOLQKLVUHOLJLRXV
ZRUNV RI LQQRYDW LRQ

7KH -HZV VHH LQ KLP  D -HZ W KHUHIRUH D W UDLW RU RI W KHLU RZQ UDFH DQG
VW LOO W RGD\ W KH\ DUH KDSS\ DERXW  KDYLQJ KLP  NLOOHG  7KH\ QHYHU  JRW
W LUHG RI W KHLU KDW UHG DQG GHULVLRQ LQ QHDUO\  \HDUV  7KLV FRXOG
HYHQ OHDG W R M XVW LI\ W KRVH ZKR VHH LQ KLP  W KH DQW L-HZ W KH $U\DQ
7RGD\¶VFKXUFKHVNQRZQRORQJHUDW DOOZKDW W KH\VKRXOGW HDFKDQGVD\
 

DQG W KHUHIRUH W KH\ JHW  LQYROYHG LQ H[FXVHV DQG UHDVRQLQJ EHVLGH W KH SRLQW   )RU
W KHP KHLVVRW RVD\³ W KHJLUOIRUHYHU\W KLQJ´   *RGP DQJRG P DQP DQ JRG
VRQRI*RGDQGVRQRIP DQ$U\DQ-HZ&KULVW VRQRIW KHP RW KHURI*RGDQGRI
W KH KXP DQ ZRP HQ 0DU\ RI W KH +RO\ VSLULW  RI -RVHSK W KH &DUSHQW HU DQG RI JRG
LQSHUVRQW KHUHIRUH*RGDQGP DQEXW \HW QRW SHUVRQEXW *RGDQGP DQRQO\ZLW K
KXP DQ QDW XUH

)RU'UHZVW KHSURRIKDVEHHQIXUQLVKHGXQHTXLYRFDOO\W KDW -HVXV&KULVW FDQQHYHU

KDYHOLYHGDVDKXP DQSHUVRQDW OHDVW QRW DW ILUVW LQ3DOHVW LQHEHFDXVHLQ, QGLD
*DXO 6FDQGLQDYLD &KLQD DQG LQ $P HULFD HYHU\ZKHUH KDYH W KH ³ 6RQV RI *RG´
EHHQ FUXFLILHG DFFRUGLQJ W R OHJHQG KLVW RU\ RU GRFW ULQH P DQ\ KXQGUHGV HYHQ
W KRXVDQGV RI \HDUV EHIRUH W KH DSSHDULQJ RI ³ -HVXV RI 1D]DUHW K´  'UHZV VHHP V
W KHUHIRUHW RKDYHFRP HFORVHVW W RW KHVROXW LRQ0DQ\VHHLQW KHLP DJHRI&KULVW
DQDVW UDOP \W KDQGRW KHUVKDYHVKRZQW KHFOHDUHVW SURRIVIURP W KHDQFLHQW $U\DQ
W H[W VEHLW W KH9HGDVW KH%LEOHDQGW KH(GGD VRP HVHHLQW KHFRP LQJRI&KULVW
DRQH W LP HHYHQW ZKLFKZLOOQHYHUEHUHSHDW HGRW KHUVDJDLQH[ SHFW KLVFRP LQJ
KLVUH DSSHDUDQFHLQHYHU\KRXU7KHW UXW KLVW KH$DU KHLW  $DU EHLQJ EHFDXVH
W UXW KW KH$DULVW KHVXQLW VHOIW KHVSLULW XDOSRZHUZKLFKLVDFW LQJEHKLQGLW W KH
VSLULW XDOOLJKW RIW KHZRUOG 7KHW UXW KLVW KDW &KULVW LVDW KRXJKW RIW KHXQLYHUVH
W LP H OHVV DQG HW HUQDO ZKLFKHYHU ZD\ ZH ZDQW  W R DFFHSW  W KLV  7UXW K LV W KDW  W KH
³ &KULVW ´  OLYHV ZLW KLQ DOO RI XV W KDW  KH LV W KH ³ &KULVW$OO´ W KH $OO &KULVW  DV ZH
GLVFRY HU  KLP  Z LW KLQ RXU VHOY HV DV Z H RSHQ XS RXU VHOY HV W R KLP   +H LV W KH
VSLULW XDO ODZ RI &KULVW$OO L]DW LRQ LQ W KH :HOW $OO XQLYHUVH   DQG W KHUHIRUH W KH
.U\VW DOO LW VHOI W KH $OO .ULVW  W KH $OO *HUVW   RI W KH VSLULW XDO DQG FRQVHTXHQW O\
DOVR RI W KH SK\VLFDO ZRUOG

:LW K W KH ³ -HVXV´ W KH $VXV W KH $HVLU W KHUH LV DQRW KHU FRUUHODW LRQ DJDLQ  7KLV
QDP HKDVDOVRKLVW RULFDOEDFNJURXQGVDQGW KLVOHJHQGDU\DQGP \VW LFDOILJXUHZDV
FRQQHFW HG HDUO\ ZLW K W KH ILJXUH RI W KH &KULVW   %RW K ZRUGV -HVXV DQG &KULVW
VLJQLI\ OHVV D QDP H EXW  DQ RIILFH D SURSHUW \ D VW DW H ERW K LQ W KHLU P HDQLQJ RI
W KH ZRUGV DUH W KH ILUVW  W KH KLJKHVW  RQH W KH KROLHVW  RQH

(YHU\ZKHUHDQGVLQFHW LP HVLP P HP RULDOW KH³ 6RQRIW KH*RG´ KDVEHHQFRQFHLYHG

E\DSXUHYLUJLQE\W KH+RO\*KRVW RUE\DJRG6RW KH, QGLDQ.ULVKQDKDVEHHQ
FRQFHLYHGE\W KHYLUJLQ0DM DE\W KH+RO\*KRVW M XVW DV&KULVW E\W KH9LUJLQ0DU\
E\ W KH +RO\ JKRVW  LQ W KH VKDSH RI D GRYH  -XSLW HU W RR P DGH W KH YLUJLQ 3\W KLD W R
D P RW KHU LQ W KH VKDSH RI GRYH  7KH *UHHNV FRQVLGHUHG 3ODW R W R EH W KH VRQ RI
$SROOR ERUQ E\ D YLUJLQ RQ (DUW K %DFFKXV DQG 0LW KUD ZHUH FRQFHLYHG W KH VDP H
ZD\ LQ FKLQD LW  ZDV )RKO LQ .RUHD $UFKHU LQ 0H[LFR LW  ZDV +XLW ]OLSXW ]OL    DOVR LQ
%DE\ORQ LQ (J\SW  DQG ODVW  QRW  OHDVW  LQ W KH *HUP DQLF P \W K W KH YLUJLQ JRGGHVV
ZKLFK JLYHV ELUW K W R W KH VDYLRU LV EURXJKW  W R XV E\ W UDGLW LRQ  $FFRUGLQJ W R D
1RUGLFP \W K:RGDQW DNHVKXP DQVKDSHLVERUQE\D UDFLDOO\SXU H VHUYDQW P DLG
DQG KDV W R H[SHULHQFH HDUW K ZLW K LW V VXIIHULQJ  , I LQW HUSUHW LQJ W KH P HDQLQJV RI


7KHVHUYDQW  P DLGZ KRLVFDSDEOHRIGRLQJDOOW KLQJVDQGDQ\W KLQJDVNHGIURP KHU

*HUVW  P RGHUQ*HUP DQZRUGIRUVFDIIROGLQJRUVW UXFW XUH

+XL]LORSRFKW QL
 

DOOW KHVHDQFLHQW P \W KVLW EHFRP HVFOHDUW RXVDOVRW KDW LW LVLQGHHGDEODVSKHP \

RI W KH ³ +RO\ *KRVW ´  LI ZH W DNH VXFK VW DW HP HQW V DERXW  KLP  OLW HUDOO\

&RP SDULQJW KHW ZRFKDUDFW HUVEHW W HULP DJHVRIW KH%XGGKDDQGRIW KH-HVXVRI

1D]DUHW KDVKHZDVZLW KDOOSUHFLVLRQZRUNHGLQW KH, QGLDQDQG&KULVW LDQW UDGLW LRQV
VKRZ V KRZ  ERW K LP DJHV KDY H HP HU JHG IU RP  RQH 8U  W KRXJKW   RQO\  Z LW K W KH
GLIIHUHQFHW KDW W KHP \W KRI&KULVW HP HUJHGIURP W KHP \W KRI%XGGKDZKLFKZDV
/272/'(5 $1'7+(17+$77+(%XGGKDP \W KDJDLQJRHVEDFNW RDFRVP LF8U
LP DJH ZKLFK LQ W KLV ZRUN ZH DW W HP SW HG W R H[SRXQG RQ

-HVXV DV ZHOO DV %XGGKD GHVFHQG IURP  W KH UR\DO G\QDVW \ RI W KHLU  SHRSOHV %RW K
KDYH YLUJLQV DV W KHLU P RW KHU -HVXV KDV 0DU\ DQG %XGGKD KDV 0DM D ZKLFK KDYH
EHHQ SUHSDUHG E\ DQJHOV LQ W KHLU SURIHVVLRQ DV ELUW K P RW KHUV RI VRQV RI *RG
%RW K RI W KHP  UHFHLYH W KH IUXLW  RI W KHLU ZRP E E\ W KH ³ +RO\ 6SLULW ´  7KH ELUW K LV
DQQRXQFHG E\  DQJHOV   .LQJV  JRGV DQG SU LHVW V DSSHDU   DW  W KH ELU W K RI W KH
%XGGKD DV DW  W KH ELUW K RI &KULVW  W KH ³ ZLVH IURP  W KH 2ULHQW ´  DUH VKRZLQJ XS  , Q
ERW K VW RULHV W KH\ GRQDW H LQFHQVH DQG RW KHU SUHFLRXV W KLQJV DQG ERW K \RXQJ
VDYLRUVDUHW KUHDW HQHGE\P HDQUXOHUVZKLFKZDUQHGE\GUHDP VDQGSURSKHFLHV
ORRNIRUW KHIXW XUHNLQJDOORYHUW KHFRXQW U\  $QGDVW KHVH+HURGVFDQQRW JUDVS
W KH LGHD W KDW  W KH HP SLU H RI W KHVH N LQJV Z RXOG QRW  EH RI W KLV Z RU OG  DV W KH
&KULVW LDQKXP DQLW \XQGHUOHDGHUVKLSRIW KHLUFKXUFKHVKDVQRW XQGHUVW RRGW RW KLV
GD\

/LNH -HVXV %XGGKD LV EURXJKW  LQW R W KH W HP SOH

<RXQJ%XGGKDDP D]HVW KHVFULEHVZLW KKLVZLVGRP  %HIRUHKLVSXEOLFDSSHDUDQFH

KH UHM HFW V 0DUD W KH W HP SW HU ZKLFK VKRZV KLP  DOO W KH ZHDOW K RI W KH ZRUOG    +H
KHDOV W KH VLFN P DNHV EOLQGV VHH ZDONV RQ W KH ZDW HU ZLW K GU\ IHHW   IHHGV KLV
GLVFLSOHV P LU DFX ORX VO\  OLN H -HVX V K H Z DV EHW U D\ HG E\  RQ H RI K LV GLVFLSOHV
'HYDGDW W DDQGKHVKRZVKLP VHOIW RKLVGLVFLSOHVLQEULJKW LOOXP LQDW HGDSSHDUDQFH
DIW HU KLV GHDW K

2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 

7KHHTXDOFRXUVHVRIW KHOLYHVDQGRIW KHW HDFKLQJVRIERW KLGROVRIKXP DQLW \JR

DOO W KH ZD\ W R W KH LGHQW LW \ RI FHUW DLQ VW DW HP HQW V W KDW  W KH\ P DGH  +HUH LW  ZRXOG
JR W RR IDU W R P HQW LRQ HYHU\W KLQJ  7KLV KDV EHHQ GRQH E\ RW KHUV ZLW K VXIILFLHQW
FOHDUQHVV DQG W UXW K E\ RW KHUV VXFK DV 7KLHGH LQ KLV ERRN ³ 'DV HQW VFKOHLHUW H
&KULVW XVJHKHLP QLV´  7KH 8QYHLOHG 6HFUHW  RI &KULVW 

7KH V\P EROLF FKDU DFW HU LVW LF RI W KH &KU LVW  LV D FHU W DLQW \ RI W KH SHU VRQ Z KR LV
FRQQHFW HG W R *RG ZKLFK FDQQRW  EH ORVW   )RU KLP  W KHVH SURRIV Z RXOG QRW  EH
QHHGHG EXW  ZH ZDQW  W R JLYH FUXW FKHV W R W KH ZHDN DQG VLFN RQHV ZKLFK DUH VW LOO
DIUDLG W R VW ULGH W KH SDW K W R W KH W UXW K ZLW K W KHLU RZQ SRZHUV RI FRQILGHQFH  

7KHELUW KRI&KULVW DVVRQRIW KHIDW KHURIW KHZRUOGLQW KHQLJKW RIW KHW KH W K
RI'HFHP EHUE\D³ ZRP DQRIW KH(DUW K´DYLUJLQILQGVDZHDOW KRIHTXDOW UDGLW LRQV
Z LW K W KH DQFLHQW  SHRSOHV   $JQL LQ , QGLD  0LW KU DV LQ 3HU VLD  2VLU LV LQ (J\ SW 
$GRP LV%DFFKXV$SROORLQ6\ULD3KHQLFLDDQG*UHHFH 0DQXDV ZHOODV%XGGKD
DQG P DQ\ RW KHU ³ VRQV RI JRGV´  KDYH EHHQ ERUQ LQ W KH QLJKW  RI W KH W KH  W K  RI
'HFHP EHU

(YHU \ \HDU  RQ W KH  W K  RI 'HFHP EHU  W KH SU LHVW V DQG IU DW HU QLW LHV RI %DFFKXV
0LW KUDV 9HQXV DQG , VLV FHOHEUDW HG W KH ELUW K RI W KH \RXQJ JRG RI W KH 6XQ  $OVR
HYHU\ZKHUHLQDOOSURYLQFHVRIW KHHP SLUHW KH\FDUULHGDURXQGW KHFUDGOHRIW KH
QHZO\ ERUQ DURXQG LQ IHVW LYH SURFHVVLRQ ZLW K W KH M XELODQW  FDOO ³ (YRH %DFFKXV´
&HUHVW KHKDSS\P RW KHURIW KH%DFFKXVZDVZRUVKLSSHGDVW KH³ KRO\YLUJLQ´2Q
DQ DQFLHQW  W HUUDFRW W D YDVH D GHSLFW LRQ RI W KLV SURFHVV UHP DLQHG IRU SRVW HULW \
7KH SULHVW V RI +RUXV DFFRUGLQJ W R ROG W UDGLW LRQ KDG W KHLU KDLU VKDYHG DW  W KH
FHQW HU RI W KH W RS RI W KH KHDG  )URP  W KHP  W KH 5LRP DQ FKXUFK W RRN RYHU W KLV
FXVW RP   , V ZDV D ZD\ W R KDYH W KH KDLU DUUDQJHG VR W KDW  W KHUH ZDV DQ HDVLHU
DFFHVV IRU W KH FRVP LF ZLOO

$OO W KHVH VRQV RI W KH JRGV KHDOHG W KH VLFN   DZ DN HQHG W KH GHDG  SHU IRU P HG
P LUDFOHV DQG HYHQW XDOO\ KDG W R GLH DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH UHTXLUHP HQW  RI W KH DQFLHQW
P \W K RI HW HUQDO FKDQJH RI OLIH RYHU ELUW K W R GHDW K ZKLFK LV H[SHULHQFHG LQ W KH
FRXUVH RI W KH 6XQ DURXQG W KH ]RGLDF HYHU\ \HDU

7KH 9LUJLQ 0DU\ ZLW K OLW W OH -HVXV RQ KHU DUP  LV QRW  D \RXQJHU LP DJH LW  GRHV QRW
FRP H IURP  ³ &KULVW LDQLW \´ EXW  LW  LV LQKHULW DQFH RI W KH JHQHUDO KXP DQ ZRUVKLS RI
W KH P LUDFOH RI P RW KHUKRRG RI EHFRP LQJ D P RW KHU RI W KH HDUW K LQ JHQHUDO  :H
NQRZ RI W KH JRGGHVV -XQR ZLW K W KH FKLOG RQ KHU DUP  ZH NQRZ W KH $UW HP LV RI
(SKHVXV W KH ³ LP P DFXODW H´  YLUJLQ W KH $UW HP LV IURP  &KU\VRV W KH 'HP HW HU W KH
³ 'HD0DW HU ´W KH0RW KHU*RGGHVVLQ*HUP DQVLP SO\³ W KHP RW KHU ´  GHP HW HUW KH
V\P ERO RI IHUW LOLW \

7KH KXP DQ ORQJLQJ IRU W KH JRG ERUQ SXUH FKLOG W KH VKLQLQJ VRQ RI W KH KHDYHQ
ZKLFKLVW KHOLJKW DQGW KHORYHDQGW KHM R\RIW KHZRUOGLVQRW DQLQYHQW LRQRIW KH
UHFHQW SDVW ZKLFKRQO\DUURJDQFHDQGVW XSLGLW \ZRXOGFODLP DQGEHOLHYHEXW W KLV

 2PLWWHG
 

LV DQ XQLYHUVDO LQKHULW DQFH D XQLYHUVDO ZLVK D XQLYHUVDO VHDU FK RI W KH SXUH
SURFUHDW HG UDFLDOO\ SXUH URRW  OLNH DQG 'LYLQH KXP DQ EHLQJ

7KH FKXUFK IDW KHU $XJXVW LQH VW LOO NQHZ RI W KHVH FRQQHFW LRQV EXW  W KH FKXUFKHV
KDYH GHVHUW HG W KH SDW K RI NQRZOHGJH RI W KHLU IRXQGHUV DQG W KHUHIRUH W KH\ ZHQW
RQ HUURQHRXV SDW KV  $XJXVW LQH SURIHVVHV   ³ 7RGD\ RQ W KH  W K  RI -XQH  ZKHQ
W KHOHQJW KRIW KHGD\EHJLQVW RGHFUHDVH-RKQKDVEHHQERUQVRW KDW W KHKXP DQ
EHLQJLVP DGHORZO\ RQW KDW GD\ W KH W K RI'HFHP EHU ZKHQW KHOHQJW KRIW KH
GD\LQFUHDVHV&KULVW LVERUQVRW KDW *RGLVHOHYDW HG´ 7KLVLVDJUHDW VHFUHW DQG
P \VW HU\

7KLV ZD\ RQO\ W KH &KULVW  LV W R EH YLHZHG DV W KH VKLQLQJ VRQ RI *RG DV VRP H
P LOOHQQLD EHIRUH DOUHDG\ W KH +HVDYD -HVKXD -HVXV  .ULVKQD W KH Ä ZKLW H RQH´
W KHÄ VSOHQGRURXVRQH´W KHÄ OLJKW ERUQ´QRW W KHÄ EODFNRQH´DVSHUKDSVSXUSRVHO\
W KH QDP H &KULVKW QDV LV W UDQVODW HG  7KH .ULVKQD FKLOGUHQ ZHUH FRQVLGHUHG W R EH
EHJRW W HQE\W KH6XQ7KHUHIRUHW KHGHULYDW LRQ³ W KHEODFNRQH´ EHFRP HVXQW HQDEOH
LQDGGLW LRQW RZKLFKZHFDQUHDGIURP W KHV\OODEOH³ &KULV´ W KH³ &KULVW DOO´  FU\VW DO 
W KH FROOHFW RU RI OLJKW  DQG W KH GLVW ULEXW RU RI OLJKW   %HFDXVH Z H KDYH W R GR KHUH
ZLW K D SHUIHFW  FRUUHODW LRQ W R W KH ODW HU ³ -HVXV &KULVW  RI 1D]DUHW K´ ZH ZRXOG W KHQ
QHHG W R H[SODLQ W KDW  &KULVW  DV ZHOO DV ³ W KH EODFN RQH´ ZKLFK KRZHYHU SHRSOH
UHIUDLQ IURP  ZHOO NQRZLQJO\

+HUHZHKDYHW KHUHP DLQGHUVRIDFOHDUUDFHUHOLJLRQZKLFKVSHDNVRIW KHORQJLQJ

R I  K X P DQ L W \  W R  K L J K  E U HHG   HY HQ  L Q  W K H Z R U VW  G HY HO R S P HQ W  R I  ³ P X W W V´
³ 9HUN|W HUXQJ´ DQGW KLVKDSSHQHGVXEFRQVFLRXVO\7KHW UXO\U HDOLVW LFGHVFULSW LRQ
RI 0DGRQQD¶V DQG -HVXV &KLOGUHQ DV EORQG VW DW XUHV Z LW K OLJKW  VN LQ DQG EOXH H\HV
DOVR LQ FRXQW ULHV ZKHUH W KH $ULR *HUP DQLF P DQ LV EDUHO\ OHIW  RYHU LQ RXU GD\V
VXFKDVLQ6RXW KHUQ, W DO\6LFLO\6SDLQDQGW KHHQW LUH0LGGOH (DVW ZKHUHYHUW KH
&KULVW LDQFKXUFKHVKDYHW DNHQDKROG7KLVVKRZVW KDW W KH$U\DQ *RW KLFP DQLV
U HFRJ Q L]HG  DV 'LY LQ H DOVR I U RP  W K H VX E K X P DQ  U DFHV   7K HVH DU H HQ W LU HO\
VXEFRQVFLRXV IHHOLQJV DQG LQVLJKW V W KDW  W KH P RW KHU RI *RG DQG W KH VRQ RI *RG
FDQQRW  EH GDUN FDQQRW  EH RI ORZ YDOXH FDQQRW  EH RI LQIHULRU U DFH

, W LVW KHHQW LUHO\QDW XUDOVW ULYLQJRIOLIHIURP DQLQERUQZLOODQGZLVKRIKXP DQNLQG

W KDW  LW  VW ULYHV IURP  W KH GDUN LQW R W KH OLJKW   ³ %\ ZD\ RI W KH FURVV LQW R W KH OLJKW ´
W KLVLVFRUUHFW LQHYHU\DVSHFW QDP HO\W KDW ZLW KW KHOLJKW QHVVRIW KHDSSHDUDQFH
DKLJKHUOHYHORIHYROXW LRQLVUHDFKHGZKLFKDW DOOW LP HVLVVXSSRUW HGE\W KHZLOO
RI W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ LQ LW V LQW HQW LRQ RI EUHHGLQJ  2QH FDQ RQO\ DUJXH W KDW  W KHUH
LV DOVR D OLJKW OLNH VSLULW  DQG VRXO LQ RUGHU W R DFKLHYH W KH KXP DQ SHDN JRDO  :H
FDQRQO\DJUHHZLW KW KLVDGGHQGXP QDP HO\W KDW W RW KHOLJKW ERG\FRP HVDVZHOO
 

P XFK HDVLHU W KH OLJKW  VRXO DQG W KH OLJKW  VSLULW  LQ IDFW  W KDW  OLJKW  DQG VKDGRZ
VKRZ W KH LQW HQW  LQ JHQHUDO W R GHFLGH DQG W KDW  W KLV ODZ JHW V LQW R DFW LRQ RQ DQ\
OHYHO RI REVHUYDW LRQ

, W  LV VHOI HYLGHQW  W KDW  W KH *HUP DQLF SHRSOH W RR FHOHEUDW HG W KH  W K  RI 'HFHP EHU
EXW QRW W KH³ ELUW K´ RIW KH³ VRQRI*RG´EXW W KHELUW KRIW KHOLJKW LW VHOI)URP W KLV
IDFW  LV SURYHQ W KH 1RUGLF RULJLQ RI W KLV P \W K ZKLFK LV VW LOO IORZLQJ SXUHVW  DQG
FOHDUHVW  KHUH LQ W KH 1RUW K ZKHUH LW  GLG QRW  GHJHQHUDW H \HW  W R W KH SODW LW XGHV RI
P DNLQJ LW  HQW LUHO\ KXP DQ EXW  LW  UHP DLQHG LP P HGLDW H 8U NQRZOHGJH RI QDW XUH
DQGVSLULW 7KLVIDFW RIW KHSXUHUW UDGLW LRQRIW KHP \W KRIW KH6XQ VRQLQW KH1RUW K
SURYHVLW DVW KHVRXUFHRIW KHP \W KRI&KULVW DVEHLQJDQ$U\DQP \W KLHD6XQ
P \W K7KH³ 6RQ´ LVKHUHQRW P DGHKXP DQW RW KHSRLQW RIEHLQJXQUHFRJQL]DEOH
EXW  W KLV W LP H LW  LV W KH ³ 6RQ´ QDP HO\ W KH 6XQ LW VHOI ZKLFK UHFHLYHG W KH IHP DOH
FKDUDFW HU LVW LF LQ RXU  ODQJXDJH P XFK ODW HU Z KLOH LQ $U \DQ P \ W KRORJ\ LW  VW LOO
V\P EROL]HV HYHU\W KLQJ P DOH

, W  LV W KH ³ 6RQ´ W RGD\ LQ RXU ODQJXDJH W KH ³ 6RQQH´  W KH 6XQ  Z KLFK RQ W KH  W K
RI 'HFHP EHU LQ W KH VLJQ RI W KH &DSULFRUQ DZDNHQV IURP  W KH QLJKW  RI W KH ZLQW HU
DQG DULVHV W R QHZ OLIH RQ W KH VN\ RI KXP DQNLQG

8QGHUVW RRG W KLV ZD\ W KH ³ &KULVW ´  LV LQGHHG W KH OLJKW  RI W KH ZRUOG  7KLV OLJKW
DULVHVGXULQJW KHP LGQLJKW RIW KH(DUW KZKHQW KHVLJQRI9LUJR W KHYLUJLQ ZKLFK
³ JLYHVELUW KW RKLP ´ DVFHQGVLQW KH(DVW RIW KHVN\, W LVW KHVRQRI*RGZKRZDV
ERUQ LQ W KH QLJKW  RI FRQVHFUDW LRQ RI ZKLFK W KH JRVSHO RI 0DW W KHZ UHSRUW V ³ W KDW
KLV IDFH VKLQHG OLNH W KH 6XQ´

, QVXP P HUW KH6XQVW DQGVKLJKHVW RYHUW KHKRUL]RQDERYHRXUKHDGRQW KHVN\

, Q ZLQW HU LW  LV IDU LQ W KH 6RXW K  7KH P RUH ZH FRP H W R W KH 1RUW K W KH FORVHU W KH
6XQ LV RQ W KH KRUL]RQ DQG W KH IODW W HU LW V W UDFN DSSHDUV  8S W KHUH LQ W KH 1RUW K
ZKHUHW KHELUW KRIW KHKXP DQVW RRNSODFHLQW KHHP SLUHRIW KH+\SHUERUHDQVLQ
W KHHP SLUHRIW KH$SROOR³ ZKHUHW KH6XQQHYHUVHW W OHG´DFFRUGLQJW RW KHDQFLHQW
W UDGLW LRQV RI W KH *UHHNV W KHUH W KH 6XQ VKLQHV VL[ P RQW KV RI W KH \HDU VW LOO W RGD\
DQG GXULQJ W KLV W LP H LW  GRHV QRW  GLVDSSHDU EHQHDW K W KH KRUL]RQ DW  QLJKW 

7KHUHIRUH LQ D SDVW  W LP H ZKHQ W KHUH ZDV QHDUO\ D W URSLFDO FOLP DW H LQ W KH 3RODU
5HJLRQV W KH LQKDELW DQW V RI W KH 3RODU ODQGV JUHHW HG W KH VXQ M R\ IXOO\ DQG ZLW K
KDSSLQHVV DIW HU W KH KDOI \HDU RI W KH ZLQW HU GXULQJ ZKLFK W KH\ KDG QLJKW   7KH
OLJKW  W KH ³ 6RQ´ W KH VRQ RI *RG W KH 6XQ ZDV ERUQ DQHZ  7KH P LGQLJKW  RI W KLV
ORQJ QLJKW  RQ W KH SROH ZKLFK ODVW V KDOI D \HDU ZDV W KH  W K  RI 'HFHP EHU  7KLV
GD\VLJQLILHGW KHORZHVW SRVLW LRQRIW KH6XQXQGHUW KHKRUL]RQ$W W KHVDP HW LP H
RI W KLV GHHSHVW  SRVLW LRQ RI W KH 6XQ DQG W KH EHJLQQLQJ UH DVFHQVLRQ W KH VLJQ RI
9LUJR DSSHDUHG LQ W KH (DVW  DV ULVLQJ FRQVW HOODW LRQ  

, QDVW URORJ\W KHUR\DODUW RIW KHDQFLHQW VW KH(DVW HUQSRLQW ZKLFKZDVW KHVLJQ
W KDW URVHDERYHW KHKRUL]RQLVW KHFHOHVW LDOSODFHRIELUW KRIW KHSHUVRQZKRZDV
ERUQDW W KDW W LP H7KHFHOHVW LDOVLJQZKLFKLVRQW KH(DVW HUQKRUL]RQDW W KHW LP H

 2PLWWHG
 

RI W KH ³ UHELUW K´ LH RI W KH UH DVFHQVLRQ RI W KH 6XQ LV W KH KRXVH ZLW K W KH VLJQ
RI9LUJR7KHVRQRI*RGW KH\RXQJVXQW KH³ VRQ´ LQW KHROGODQJXDJHZKRZDV
ERUQLQW KHSRODUP LGQLJKW RIW KH$U\DQVRIW KH$ULDURIW KHVRQVRIW KH6XQ DV
W KHLQKDELW DQW VRIW KHVH1RUW KHUQDUHDVODW HURIW KH1RUW KHUQKHP LVSKHUHFDOOHG
W KHP VHOYHV ZDVLQGHHGERUQE\DQLP P DFXODW HSXUHFHOHVW LDOYLUJLQDQGFRQFHLYHG
E\ W KH +RO\ *KRVW  ZKLFK EORZV W KURXJK W KLV URW DW LQJ FRVP RV

2Q W KLV FKRVHQ H[DP SOH ZH UHFRJQL]H W KH FRQJUXHQFH RI QDW XUDO V\P ERO DQG
VSLULW XDO V\P ERO  (YHU\W KLQJ LV UHODW HG W R P DQ DV W KH P HDVXUH RI DOO W KLQJV  $V
RXW VLGH VR LQVLGH  DV DERYH VR EHORZ   DV *RG VR P DQ  9DOXDEOH GHFLVLYH
UHP DLQV DORQH W KH LQQHU VSLULW XDO UH  DQG QHZ ELUW K RI W KH VSLU LW XDO 6XQ RI W UXW K
W KH VSLULW XDO VRQ RI W KH W UXW K  7KLV HW HUQDO DORQH UHGHHP LQJ QHZ ELUW K RI VSLULW 
ZKLFK ZH QHHG EHIRUH DQ\ DQG DOO IDLW K LV GHSLFW HG KHUH LQ W KH LP DJH RI W KH
H[W HUQDOQDW XUDOKDSSHQLQJW KHUHIRUHV\P EROLFDOO\7KHSURFHVVHVRQW KHH[W HUQDO
VN\ DUH FOHDU W R HYHU\ VLP SOH REVHUYHU ZLW KRXW  DQ\ SUREOHP  DQG GLIILFXOW LHV EXW
QRW  LQ W KH VDP H ZD\ W KH LQW HUQDO VSLULW XDO VRXO DQG P RUDO SURFHVVHV ZKLFK W R
XQGHUVW DQG UHTXLUHV D VSHFLDO VSLULW XDO VFKRROLQJ LQW URGXFW LRQ DQG LQLW LDW LRQ

:KDW ZDVVSLULW XDOLQVLJKW DQGFOHDUNQRZOHGJHFRQFHUQLQJQDW XU DOSURFHVVHVIRU

W KH$U\DQVZKLFKW KH\SXW LQW RLP DJHVRIGHHSV\P EROLFVLJQLILFDQFHLQRUGHUW R
GHVFULEHW KHVSLULW XDOELUW KRIW KHW UXHDQGSHUIHFW KXP DQEHLQJW KLVGHJHQHUDW HG
VORZO\ LQ W KH LP P DW XUH ³ IDLW K´  RI QRQ VSLULW XDO W LP HV DQG UDFHV  0LVXQGHUVW RRG
LQGHDGO\OLW HUDOEHOLHYLQJLW EHFDP HW KHW RP ERIDOOW UXHDQGOLYLQJLQVLJKW RIIDLW K
DQGLW EHFDP HW RDZKLSRIDKXP DQLW \W KDW ZDVHQVODYHGLQDQLOOXVLRQRIP DW W HU
DQG EHOLHI LQ OLW HUDO XQGHUVW DQGLQJ

, Q DOO UHOLJLRXV P \W KV DQG OHJHQGV W KH SURFHVVHV RI W KH H[W HUQDO QDW XUH DUH
DOZD\V SDUDEOH LP DJH DQG V\P ERO IRU LQW HUQDO VSLULW XDO VRXO U HODW HG DQG P RUDO
LVVXHV  $V OLJKW  HP HUJHV H[W HUQDOO\ LQ W KH GHQVH P DW HULDO ZRUOG LQ W KH VDP H
P DQQHU LW  KDV W R EHFRP H DOVR DQ LQW HUQDO OLJKW   7KH LQW HUQDO OLJKW  RI W KH VDFUHG
6XQ RI VDOYDW LRQ RI W U XW K P XVW  U LVH LQ \RXU  KHDU W  DQG W KDW  HVSHFLDOO\ LQ W KH
GHHSHVW  DQG ORQJHVW  QLJKW  RI \RXU GHDGO\ GHVSDLU DERXW  HYHU\W KLQJ HYHQ DERXW
\ RXU VHOI   :KHQ HY HU \ W KLQJ EHFDP H GDU N HVW  DQG XW W HU O\  KRSHOHVV QRQVHQVH
ZKHQ ZH FDQ QHLW KHU GLH QRU OLYH ZKHQ W KH VDG W RUW XUH RI RXU H[LVW HQFH KDV
W UDQVJUHVVHGHYHU\P HDVXUHW KDW LVEHDUDEOHZKHQW KHGDUNQHVVLVP RVW LQW HQVH
W KH*RGLVFORVHVW W KHQRQO\W KHUHW XUQW RW KHOLJKW DQGW KHUH ELUW KFDQKDSSHQ
$IW HU ZH KDYH W DVW HG W KH GHDW K W KH VSLULW XDO GHDW K DOO W KH ZD\ W R GHVSDLU W KHQ
RQO\ GR ZH NQRZ W R DSSUHFLDW H OLIH LQ W KH OLJKW  RI W UXW K :DKUKDIW LJNHLW  RI $DU
KDIW LJNHLW  RI 6XQ W UXW K 6RQQHQZDKUKHLW  RI 6RQQHQ $DU KHLW 

7KLVLVW KHUHELUW KRIW KHLQW HUQDOVSLULW XDOKXP DQEHLQJW KHUHVXUUHFW LRQIURP W KH

W RP E RI W KH VSLULW XDO GHDW K  7KH ELUW K RI W KH 6XQ V\P EROL]HV W KH ELUW K RI W KH
&KULVW  6XQRIW UXW KLQW KHKHDUW RIW KHVSLULW XDODQGP RUDOW UXW KZKLFKOLNHDQ\
ELUW K KDSSHQV QRW  ZLW KRXW  FRQW UDFW LRQV DQG JUHDW  SDLQ  7KH ELUW K RI W KH W UXH


 

W KH FKLOG RQW R W KH VW UDZ RQ ZKLFK LW  LJQLW HV LW VHOI W R W KH IODP H  2Q LW V VLGH W KH
FRZLVSXW ZKLFKGHOLYHUVW KHEXW W HUZLW KZKLFKW KHIODP HLVIHGIXUW KHUDQGW KH
GRQNH\ZKLFKKDVFDUULHGW KH6RP DLHW KHGULQNRIW KHJRGVZKLFKVHUYHVW KH
$JQLDVQRXULVKP HQW ODW HU ³ 6W HHUDQGGRQNH\´ ZHUHIDLW KIXOO\ W DNHQRYHULQW KH
&KULVW P DVFXVW RP V $SULHVW XVHVDOLW W OHIODJW RIDQVRP HDLULQRUGHUW RSUHYHQW
W KHH[W LQJXLVKLQJRIKLVOLIH7KHQ$JQLZDVSXW RQW RW ZLJVZ KLFKZHUHVW DFNHG
XSRQW KHDOW DUDQGDQRW KHUSULHVW SRXUHGW KH6RP DRYHULW $W KLUGRQHDQRLQW HG
$JQLDIW HUZKLFKKHZDVQDP HG³$NW D´W KHDQRLQW HGRQH *UHHN &KULVW RV 7KH
ILUH ZKLFK ZDV W KXV OLW  DVFHQGHG W R W KH KHDYHQ DV EULJKW  IODP H E\ ZKLFK W KH\
EHOLHYHG W KDW  $JQL UHFRQQHFW HG ZLW K W KH KHDYHQO\ IDW KHU  %UHDG DQG ZLQH ZHUH
VDFULILFHG W R W KH VDFUHG ILUH  $JQL FRQVXP HV ERW K DQG FDUULHV LW  W R W KH KHDYHQ
ZLW KW KHVP RNH7KLVZD\KHEHFRP HVP HGLDW RURIW KHVDFULILFHLH$JQLZKLFK
RIIHUV KLP VHOI DV VDFULILFH  7KH SULHVW V UHFHLYH D SDUW  RI W KH VDFULILFH W KH KRO\
ZDIHU DQG W KH\ FRQVXP H LW  DV W KH ERG\ DQG EORRG LQ ZKLFK $JQL LV GZHOOLQJ´

8OW LP DW HO\ W KLV LV W KHUHIRUH DOVR D P \W K RI SURFUHDW LRQ

, QW KLVFRQQHFW LRQZHSRLQW RXW $JQXVW KHODP EDVZKLFK&KULVW DSSHDUVDOUHDG\

LQ DQ DQFLHQW  SUH &KULVW LDQ P \W K DQG LW  UHP DLQHG DV W KH ³ ODP E RI *RG´  W KH
³ KHUDOGLFDQLP DO´ RI&KULVW W RW KLVGD\, QLW VRULJLQDOIRUP ³ &KULVW RV´ VRXQGVDV
³ +DULVW RV´  $ULVW RV W KH KLJKHVW  RQH QDP HO\ W KH ILUVW  RQH (UVW H  W KH KROLHVW
RQH +HKUVW H   7KLV ³ (UVW H´  ILUVW  RQH  +DULVW RV W KHUHIRUH DULVW RV *UHHN  W KH
QREOH RQH W KH ³$U LVFKVW H´  W KH P RVW  $U \DQ RQH  W KH ILU VW  HQW LU HO\  *HU P DQ
VSRNHQLQGLDOHFW W KH³ DULVFKVW H´DQGDOVR)LUVW  URRIULGJH LQP RGHUQ*HUP DQ 
)UVW  GXNH KDVKHUHLW VRULJLQLVW KHUHIRUHW KHKLJKHVW OLQHW KHURRIULGJHW KH
GXNH RQ W KH VN\ W KH DULHV LQ W KH 7LHUNUHLV ]RGLDF ± *HUP DQ   FLUFOH RI DQLP DOV
± 7\U NUHLV ZLW K ZKLFK W KH OLJKW  W KH ODP E W KH ODP S DSSHDUV DJDLQ DIW HU W KH
QLJKW RIW KHZLQW HU+HUHZHILQGFOHDUUHODW LRQVRIW KH&KULVW FXOW DVD6RODUFXOW 
ZKLFK LW  ZDV DQG RI ZKLFK VW LOO W KH FKXUFK IDW KHU $XJXVW LQH VSRNH DV VRP HW KLQJ
VHOIHYLGHQW 7KLVODP SW KLVILUH³$JQL´, QGLDQDQGDJQXV ODP E/DW LQLVDOVR
DJDLQ W KH VDP H LP DJH DV W KDW  RI ³ 0DVW HU /DP SH´ W KH KDUH LQ W KH IDEOHV  W KH
³ +DVH´  KDUH LQ P RGHUQ *HUP DQ  W KH $VH $HVLU   +H LV W KHUHIRUH W KH (DVW HU
%XQQ\ 2VW HUKDVH  W KH 2VW HU$VH W KH 0HLVW HU /DP SH 0DVW HU /DP SH LH W KH
QDP H RI W KH KDUH LQ W KH IDEOHV  W KH 2VW HU /DP SH (DVW HU +DUH RU (DVW HU /DP S
VDP HZRUGGLIIHUHQW P HDQLQJVLQP RGHUQ*HUP DQ W KH/LJKW RI(DVW HUW KH*RG
RI 6SULQJ RU W KH *RGGHVV RI 6SULQJ 2VW DUD ZKLFK ZDV ZRUVKLSSHG DW  W KH W LP H
ZKHQ W KH 6XQ ZDV LQ $ULHV ZKLFK LV D ODP E LQ W KH ODP S LQ W KH 0DVW HU /DP SH
LQW KH(DVW HU%XQQ\LQW KHODP ERI(DVW HULQW KH$HVLURI(DVW HU$W W KLVW LP HW KH
HJJW KH(DVW HUHJJZDVLQFXEDW HGE\W KH(DVW HU$HVLUDQGW KHUHIRUHDFFRUGLQJ
W R IRONORUH ZKLFK DJDLQ W UDQVP LW W HG W KH FRUUHFW  W KLQJV IDOVHO\ W KH (DVW HU %XQQ\
KDV W R EULQJ HJJV ZKLFK RW KHUZLVH ZRXOG QRW  EH KLV EXVLQHVV EXW  W KH EXVLQHVV
RIW KHFKLFNHQRURIW KHURRVW HU%XW +DKQ URRVW HU LV³ W KHKLJKRQH´ DQG³ KDUH´
(QJOLVK W KHKDUHZKLFKLVNLQZLW K³ KDU ´ZKLFKLQROG1RUGLFLVKLJKRUW KHKLJK
RQH
 

7KHKDUHDVV\P ERORIW KH$HVLULVIRXQGIUHTXHQW O\LQW KHDQFLHQW DUW RIFKXUFKHV

HVSHFLDOO\ LQ W KH DUW  RI EXLOGLQJ LQ HDUO\ 5RP DQLF VW UXFW XUHV  7R P HQW LRQ EXW  D
I HZ  HVVHQ W LDO RQ HV  VX FK  LP DJ HV DU H I RX Q G  RI  W K H I U LHV RI  W K H FK X U FK  RI
6FKZHUW VORFNFORVHW R7ELQJHQRQW KHEDSW LVP VW RQHRI2VVHNHQ+LQW HUSRP P HUQ
ZKHUH VXUHO\ W KH QDP H RI W KH $HVLU VRXQGV VW LOO IURP  W KH 2VVH RI 2VVHNHQ DQG
VSHFLDOO\FOHDURQW KHIULHVLQW KHFKXUFKRI.|QLJVOXW W HUFORVHW R:ROIHQEW W HO, Q
(QJOLVKODQJXDJHW KHP HDQLQJUHP DLQHGFOHDUHUEHFDXVHW KHUHW KHKDUHLVUHODW HG
W R W KH ROG 1RUGLF KDU W KH KLJK RQH

7KH/DP ERI*RGLVFDUU\LQJW KHFURVVW KHZRUOGDVKW UHHRQKLVVKRXOGHU7KLV

LV W KH ZRRG W KH FROXP Q RI W KH ZRUOG RQ ZKLFK DJDLQ LV VKLQLQJ W KH ³ ODP E´ W KH
³ ODP S´ W KH UDP  W KH QHZ 6XQ  , W  LV DOVR W KH :LGDU RI W KH (GGD ZKLFK ³ ZLHGHU
HUVFKHLQW ´  P RG *HUP DQ IRU ³ DSSHDUV DJDLQ´  DIW HU D JUHDW  \HDU  RI W KH ZRUOG
DIW HUDP DQW DYDUDQDDVW KH$U\DQ, QGLDQVFDOOLW :LGDUZKLFKLVZKRHW HUQDOO\
³ ZLGDU ZLHGHU NHKUW ´  ³ ZLHGHUNHKUW ´  P RG*HUP DQIRU³ UHW XUQV´ZKLOH³ ZLGDU ´
LV W KH IRUP  IRU ³ ZLHGHU´  LQ D IHZ *HUP DQ GLDOHFW V  LQ W KH FRXUVH RI W LP HV

$JQXV W KH ODP E &KULVW  DV W KH 6XQ W KLV LV DJDLQ FORVHO\ UHODW HG W R W KH HTXDOO\
VRXQGLQJ ³ LJQLV´  /DW LQ  W KH ILUH DQG $JQL   , QGLDQ  W KH VDFUHG ILUH RI OLIH
ZKLFK IODP HV IURP  W KH ZRRG W KDW  V\P EROL]HV W KH ZRUOG  $QG W KLV ZRRG DJDLQ LV
W KH ZRUOG DVK W UHH ZKLFK LV V\P EROL]HG E\ W KH DOO HQFRP SDVVLQJ +DJ $OO 5XQH
ZKLFKLVW KHFURVVRQ*ROJRW KDRQZKLFKW KHVXQRI*RGLVKDQJLQJOLNH:RGDQ
7\UKDQJVRQW KHFURVVRIW KHZRUOGIURP ZKLFKKHIDOOVGRZQDIW HUKHDFKLHYHG
ZLVGRP  DQG NQRZOHGJH E\ P HDQV RI W KH 5XQHV VLP LODU DV ³ &KULVW ´  JDLQV W KH
XOW LP DW H NQRZ OHGJH LQ KLV GHDW K  3HRSOH W U LHG W KHLU  ELJJHVW  HIIRU W V W R P DNH
(DVW HU  D &KU LVW LDQ IHVW LY DO  EXW  W KH\  FRXOG QRW  HY HQ H[ W HU P LQDW H LW V QDP H
RW KHUZLVH ZH ZRXOG KDYH D 3DVVDK LQ LW V SODFH

7KH 2OG (QJOLVK &KXU FK FKU RQLFOHU  Z U RW H DU RXQG  $' RI W KH $QJOR 6D[RQ
QDP HV RI W KH P RQW KV DQG DGGV W R W KH ³ (DVW HU P RQDG´  W KH H[SODQDW LRQ W KDW  LW
ZDV FRQVHFUDW HG W R W KH JRGGHVV ³ (RVW DHU ´  , Q D W KRXVDQG \HDUV ROG P DQXVFULSW
RI W KH P RQDVW HU\ RI *RUYH\ LQ :HVW SKDOLD W KH QDP H RI W KLV JRGGHVV UHP DLQHG
DOVR RQ *HUP DQ VRLO  7KLV LV D SUD\HU DQ (DVW HU EOHVVLQJ DV LW  ZDV VW LOO LQ XVH
Z LW K W KH 6D[RQV DQG W KH :HVW SKDOLDQV  EHFDXVH W KH FKXU FK VXFFHHGHG RQO\
VORZO\ W R FRYHU W KH KHDYHQO\ ZLQGRZ ZKLFK ZDV VW LOO RSHQ EDFN W KHQ ZLW K LW V
GLUW \ YHLO  6KH ZDV FDOOHG 2VW DUD LQ ROG *HUP DQ DQG VKH JDYH KHU QDP H W R W KH
VORZO\ &KULVW LDQL]HG (DVW HU IHVW LYDO KHU QDP H 2VW HUQ LQ *HUP DQ   , Q *HUP DQLF
P \W KRORJ\W KHP LOG P DQQHUHGJRGGHVVZDVW KHVLVW HURI'RQDUDQGVKHZDVW KH
V\P ERORIW KHULVLQJOLJKW LQW KHVSULQJ7KH0D\IORZHUVZHUHEOHVVHGE\KHUDQG
VR ZDV W KH FRORU RI W KH JROG DQG RI W KH OLJKW  \HOORZ  6KH ZDV W KH JRGGHVV RI
ORYH  7R KRQRU KHU W KH ILUHV RI (DVW HU ZHUH EXUQLQJ

+HU ZRUVKLS ZDV ODW HU W DNHQ RYHU E\ W KH ³ &KULVW LDQ´  :DOSXUJD Z KLFK RQO\ ZLW K
GLIILFXOW \FDQKLGHKHURULJLQIURP W KH:DO RU:DKO %XUJHQ FDVW OHVRIVHOHFW LQJ 

2PLWWHG
 

RQZKLFKW KHILUHVRI(DVW HUEXUQHGDQGW KHP DUULDJHVRIVSULQJZHUHSHUIRUP HG

IROORZLQJDQFLHQW UDFHULW XDO9HU KD‰ OLFKW DQGYHU Kl‰ OLFKW  W KLVQREOHFXVW RP
OLYHVVW LOORQLQW KH:DOSXUJLV1LJKW 2YHUW KHKLJKEUHHGLQJ RIW KHDQFLHQW RQHV
DQ LQGHFHQF\ DQG OHZGQHVV JDLQHG SRZHU  )URP  D ZHOO RUGHUHG DQG SURW HFW HG
LQEUHHGLQJ ZKLFK HDFK KLJK EUHHGLQJ P XVW  EH DQ RXW  EUHHGLQJ HYROYHG ZKLFK
FDQ RQO\ EH LQGHFHQF\    )URP  W KH +DJH 'LVHQ W KH JRGGHVVHV RI W KH ZRRGV
KHOSLQJ QREOH ZRP HQ EHFDP H KRUULEOH ZLW FKHV   EXW  W KH ZLW FKHV VSRRN RI W KH
:DOSXUJLV1LJKW GLVVROYHVLQW RQRW KLQJZLW KW KHOLJKW RIW KHGD\ZKLFKW RRDJDLQ
EHFRP HVDFOHDUP RUQLQJLQRXUZRUOGRI*RG, Q2OG6D[RQODQJXDJHW KH(DVW HU
SRHP  LV DV IROORZV

2VW DU 2VW DUD(DUW K 0RW KHU (RVW DU (RVW DUHRUGKDQ P RGRU
$OORZ  W KLV JHQQH W KHVH
)LHOG W R JURZ DFHUDYHD[HQGUD
$QG W R EHFRP H XQGZLUGKHQGUD
7R EORRP  HDHUQHQGUD
7R EULQJ IUXLW  HLQLHQGU D
3HDFH W R KLP  IULGKD KLP 
7KDW  W KHUH ZDV SHDFH ZLW K W KH HDUW K W KDW  ELV \UGK VL JHIULGKRG
7KDW  LW  LV SURW HFW HG DQG KHR VL JHERUJDQ
$V W KH VDLQW V lV KLV KDLLJH
« W LEIL QQ KIW QIGIW QQUQ DLQUL

:LW K W KH VDLQW V W KH\ GLG QRW  P HDQ W KH VDLQW V RI W KH FKXUFK ZKLFK ZHUH QRW  UH
ZRUNHG \HW  DW  W KDW  W LP H EXW  W KH VDFUHG SRZHUV RI W KH KHDYHQO\ +LJK RQHV

:KHQ 2W LULHG LQ KLV JRVSHO ERRN FDOOV W KH IHVW LYDO 2VW HURQ ZLW KRXW  EHLQJ DIUDLG
RI GRLQJ VR W KHQ W KH FRQQHFW LRQ RI W KH $HVLU FKULVW  ZLW K W KH IHVW LYDO RI VSULQJ
P XVW KDYHEHHQFOHDU 7KH³ +HOLDQG7KH%RRNRI*RVSHOV´ DQG:XOILODVW UDQVODW LRQ
RIW KH%LEOHW KDW ZDVODW HUW RUQDSDUW RQSXUSRVHZLOOEULQJVXUSULVLQJUHYHODW LRQV
ZKHQ W UDQVODW HG   LOOXP LQDW HGO\ ZLW K W KH NQRZOHGJH RI W KH RULJLQ RI &KULVW LDQLW \
LQW KH1RUW K7KHODVW ZRUGVFRQFHUQHGW KRVHW KLQJVKDYHVW LOOQRW EHHQVSRNHQ
EDUHO\ W KH ILUVW  RQH DQG QR W UXH RQH W R W KLV SRLQW 


9HU KD‰ OLFKW  W XUQHGLQW RKDW H KD‰ ±YHUKl‰OLFKW  P DGHXJO\ Kl‰OLFK

 2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG


(QJOLVKHGLW LRQW UDQVODW HGDV THE HELI AND: THE SAXON GOSPELS.%\*5RQDOG0XUSK\6-
SXEOLVKHGE\2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW \3UHVV, VW URQJO\VXJJHVW W RW KHVHULRXVUHDGHUW RJHW W KLV
ERRNDVZHOODV0XUSK\¶VFRP P HQW DU\RQW KH+HOLDQG THE SAXON SAVI OR: THE GERMANI C
TRANSFORMATI ON OF THE GOSPEL I N THE NI NTH- CENTURY HELI ANDSXEOLVKHGE\2[IRUG
8QLYHUVLW \3UHVV
 

$OOZHQHHGW RGRLVW RSRLQW RXW RQO\RQFHW KDW W KH(DVW HUQEXW OLW W OH*HUP DQLF
(DVW HUQ$VW DUW HRULJLQDW HGLQW KH1RUW KEXW EHFDP HDZKRUHZLW KW KHGHFOLQHRI
W KH EORRGOLQH RI W KH RULHQW DOL]HG $U\DQ SHRSOHV  7KH DQFLHQW  , QGLDQ 8VUD LV NLQ
W RW KH2VW DUDDOVRW KH*UHHN(RVDQGW KH/DW LQ$XURUD7KHZRUGVW HP LV³ XVW ´
2VW  (DVW ZLW KW KHP HDQLQJRI³ RULJLQDW LQJ´7KHUHLQLVDOVRW KHFRQFHSW RIW KH
ZLVK W KH 8VW  2VW  HU ZLVK 2VW HUQ  (DVW HU LQ P RG *HUP DQ  W KH ZLVK ZKLFK
OHDGVW RDQGEULQJVIRUW KDOORULJLQDW LQJ7KHZRUG³ 8VW H´ ZHKHDUGDOUHDG\RQFH
LQW KHP LOOHQQLDROGQDP HRIW KHW KUHHILUHVLJQVRIW KHFHOHVW LDOFLUFOH &KUL XVW H
Q]DUHW K  8VW H LV W KH VLJQ RI W KH FHQW HU RI W KH ZLVK IRU OLIH RI W KH OLRQ

+HUHLVW KHRULJLQDOJURXQGRIW KHP \W KRI&KULVW ZKLFKLVDFRVP LFV\P EROIURP

ZKLFK W KH , QGLDQ W UDGLW LRQ W RR LV EXW  D ZHDN UHIOHFW LRQ EXW  DOVR D IHZ W KRXVDQG
\ HDU V ROGHU  W KDQ W KH RQH W KDW  Z DV FDOOHG ³ &KU LVW LDQ´  DW  D ODW HU  W LP H   $N W D
, QGLDQ  W KH DQRLQW HG RQH LV DFKW D W KH DUW D W KH  DFKW  LQ P RG *HUP DQ  W KH
LQILQLW H W KH KLJK RQH W KH VDFUHG (LJKW  DQG W KLV KDV LW V URRW  LQ W KH 8U V\OODEOHV
IRUW KH6XQ $U±UD

2QO\LQW KH1RUW KW KLVW UDGLW LRQUHP DLQHGSXUHDQGFOHDUIDYRU HGE\W KHSUR[LP LW \

RIW KHEORRGRIW KHVSLULW DQGRIW KHSODFH+HUHDOVRRW KHUV\P EROVZHUHDGGHG
W R W KH OHJHQG E\ KDYLQJ W KH VW HHU DQG W KH GRQNH\ SUHVHQW  DW  W KH ELUW K RI W KH
6XQ FKLOG  2FKV VW HHU  DQG (VHO GRQNH\  DUH $[H DQG $VHQ DVLQXV DVXV
$VXV 7KHUHIRUH:RUOG$[LVDQGW KH$HVLUJRGVVW DQGE\QDP HO\W KH]RGLDFW KH
7LHU  W KH 7\UNUHLV ZKLFK W XUQV VLFK GUHKW  URW DW HV NUHLVW  NUHL‰W   W R P DNH
SRVVLEOH W KH ELUW K RI W KH FKLOG RI W KH 6XQ RI W KH 6DYLRU 2I 7KH :RUOG  , Q W KH
HTXLQRFW LDO SRLQW  LW  LV W KH :LGGHU   $ULHV  W KH :LGDU RI W KH (GGD ZKLFK DIW HU
W KH7ZLOLJKW RIW KH*RGVZKLFKP HDQVDIW HUD\HDURIW KHZRUOG W KHSODW RQLF\HDU
RI\HDUV UHW XUQVZKRW KHQLQW URGXFHVW KDW 'LYLQHFLUFOHRIW KHJRGVW KH
ULQJ RI W KH $HVLU W KH ODP E RI JRG W KH ODP S RI *RG W KH OLJKW  RI W KH ZRUOG ZLW K
ZKLFK W KH 2VW HQ (DVW  W KH 2VW HUQ (DVW HU  W KH $XV 6W UDKO RXW  UD\  UD\ RI
HP DQDW LRQ  EHFDXVH W KDW  LV W KH P HDQLQJ RI W KH ZRUG DQG RQ RXU W HUUHVW ULDO
SODQH W KH RXW SRXULQJ RI OLIH EHJLQV DQHZ  , W  LV W KH KDSS\ HDUO\ VSULQJ W LP H RI
W KH(DVW HU %XQQ\RIW KH(DVW HU$HVLU 2VW HU +DVH2VW HU$VH ZKRKDVKDW FKHG
W KH HJJ RI W KH ZRUOG ZKLFK LV QRZ IRXQG EHKLQG DOO KHGJHV LQ W KH JUDVV DQG
EHORZIORZHUVE\W KHFKLOGUHQRIW KH6XQW KHFKLOGUHQRIW KH$U\DQVDOORYHUW KH
ZRUOG

:KDW  P HDQLQJIXO JDP H RI SDUDEOHV IURP  W KH ZLVH JLYLQJ KDQGV RI W KH DQFLHQW
LQ LW LDW HV


.UHLVHQ URW DW H NUHL‰HQ DZRUGQRORQJHUXVHGDVDYHUE
 

+RZ SLW LIXO FRP SDUHG W R W KDW  DUH W KHLU VXFFHVVRUV LQ RIILFH LQ W KHLU UREH DQG
W DOHQW V   7KH\ NQRZ QRW KLQJ DERXW  W KDW  DQG W KH\ FDQQRW  VD\ DQ\W KLQJ DJDLQVW
W KDW    7KH\ QDLO D &KU LVW  LGRO SK\VLFDOO\ RQW R D Z RRGHQ FU RVV DQG P DNH KLP
UHVXUUHFW  DJDLQ DIW HU W KUHH GD\V SK\VLFDOO\ W KH &KULVW  ZKLFK LV W KH $ULVW  W KH
+DULVW  W KH +HKUVW H W KH KROLHVW  RQH  W KH (KUVW H D W ZLVW HG ZRUG P HDQLQJ W KH
P RVW KRQRUDEOHRQH±(KUH KRQRU W KHKLJKHVW RQHRQW KHKHDY HQRIW KHZRUOG
W KH$ULHV/DW LQ W KHUDP DJQXVW KHODP E$JQLW KHILUHW KHILUHRIW KHKHDYHQ
, JQLV W KH ILUH RI W KH (DUW K W KHUHIRUH W KH ILUH W KH OLJKW  LQ ERW K DSSHDUDQFHV
ZKLFK ZDUP V W KH (DUW K SK\VLFDOO\ DQG VSLULW XDOO\ HQOLYHQV LW  LOOXP LQDW HV LW  DQG
VKLQHV RQ LW 
 

3$577: 2

 

;9
7+ (5(9(/$7, 21 2)*2', 1 7+ (1 80 %(5

, Q IORRGV RI OLIH LQ W KH W RZHU RI GHHGV

2 DP  IORZLQJ XS DQG GRZQ
,  DP  ZHDYLQJ EDFN DQG IRUW K
%LUW K DQG W RP E
$Q HW HUQDO VHD
$ FKDQJLQJ ZHDYLQJ
$ JORZLQJ OLIH
7KLV ZD\ ,  DP  ZRUNLQJ RQ W KH UXQQLQJ ORRP  RI W KH W LP H
$QG ,  DP  SHUIHFW LQJ W KH OLYLQJ UREH RI W KH 'LYLQLW \

*RHW KH

+RZ GLG W KH $U\DQV RXU DQFHVW RUV LP DJLQH W KH ZRUOG DQG LW V RU LJLQ"
%HIRU H VSDFH DQG W LP H H[ LVW HG *RG ZDV DOU HDG\  7KLV VW DW H ZDV
 

EHLQJW RRDVDW KLQNLQJHJRDVW KHHJRW KDW W KLQNVLW VHOILVDOZD\VLQW KHP LGGOH

RI W KH ZRUOG  , Q W KH LP P RYDEOH FLUFOH W KH QRQ P RYLQJ 8U LQ W KH 8KU P RG
*HUP DQ IRU &ORFN  VR W R VD\ UHVW V *RG DV W KH QRQ GLYLGHG W KH $OO 2QH DOZD\V
EH\RQG RI VSDFH DQG W LP H  6W LOO LQ RXU GD\V W KLV FLUFOH ZLW K W KH SRLQW  LV W KH
DVW URORJLFDO DQG DVW URQRP LFDO V\P ERO RI W KH 6XQ DV W KH H[W HULRU  UHSUHVHQW DW LYH
RI*RGDVDV\P ERORIW KHSRZHURI*RGLQDQH[W HQGHGP HDQLQJDOVRRIW KHJROG
W KDW  LV SURSHUW \ RI W KH 6XQ RU  6XQ DU  HDJOH $DU  V\P ERO RI W KH 6XQ
W KHUHIRUH$U\DQ 7KHSRLQW LVW KHILUVW UHYHODW LRQRIW KHH[LVW HQFHRI*RGLQW KH
GHSW KLQW KHLQILQLW \LQW KHHW HUQLW \+HLV2GKLQW KHRQH H\HG6XQW KHRQHH\H
RI JRG :RGDQ  8RW DQ  GHU $W HP  W KH EUHDW K  W KH :HK EUHH]H  W KH 8U
EU HDW K  , I W KH SRLQW  P RYHV W KHQ LW  EHFRP HV W KH OLQH LW  EHFRP HV W KH KDQG
=HLJHU RIW KLV³ FORFN´W KHSURFUHDW RU =HXJHU  $SRZHUHQW HUVW KHFLUFOHDZLOO
W KH ZLOO RI W KH IDW KHU QDP HO\ :LOL W KH ³ 6RQ´ W KH VHFRQG RQH LQ W KH +RO\ 7ULQLW \
:RGDQ:LOLDQG:HK, W LVW KH6RODU5D\IURP W KH$OO )DW KHUVHQGIURP W KHSRLQW
RIW KHGHSW KIURP HW HUQLW \8SDQGGRZQVKRZLQJW KDW ZKLFKLVSDVW DQGIXW XUH
DQG LW  LV ZLW K KLP  W KH VHFRQG UHYHODW LRQ RI *RG LQ W KH W LP H   7KLV YHUW LFDO OLQH
ZKLFK LV D ZLOO D :LOL D ZKHHO  (QJOLVK D ZKHHO LW  LV D VSU LQJ 4XHOOH  D ZDYH
:HOOH  ZKLFK URW DW HV DURXQG LW VHOI D 'LYLQH W KRXJKW  W KDW  URW DW HV DURXQG LW VHOI
W R EHLQJ FRQVFLRXV  , W  LV W KH ZLOO ZKLFK FUHDW HV LW VHOI W KH Z RUOG W KH +YLO W KH
:KHHO W KH :HOO 3RZHU LQ W KH SK\VLFDO SODQH W KH SRZHU RI ZLOO LQ W KH VSLULW XDO
+XO-XODUHW KHZDYHVW KH\DUHD[OHVZKLFKJLYHELUW KW RW KH ZLOO7KHZRUOGDV
ZLOO DQG LP DJLQDW LRQ

, W LVW KH, V 5XQHLQW KHFLUFOHRIW KHZRUOG, 

W KH HJR W KH FRQVFLRXVQHVV  7KH ³ , V´ W KH
³ , ´ W KH 2QH LV LQ W KH FLUFOH   )URP  2QH DQG
=HUR    DFFRUGLQJW RW KH.DODLH
W KHKLGGHQODQJXDJHLQW KH:LW FKHV¶RQH E\
*RG UHYHDOHG *RG UHYHDOHG
RQH ZLW FKHV¶ P XOW LSOLFDW LRQ W DEOH  EHFRP HV
LQ VSDFH LQ W LP H
W KHW HQ)URP W KH$OO 2QHIURP W KH6SLULW XDO
IURP  W KDW  ZKLFK LV HW HUQDO LV HP DQDW LQJ W KH
OLP LW DW LRQ RI W KDW  Z KLFK LV W HP SRU DO W LP H
7KH YHUW LFDO OLQH LV W KH DFW LYH P DOH SRVLW LYH
SU LQFLSOH
³ &UXFLIL[LRQ´  RI VSDFH DQG W LP H
7KHURW DW LQJZLOOLQW LP HFUHDW HVVSDFHIRULW VHOIDQGZLW KW KLVW KHW KLUGUHYHODW LRQ
RI *RG LV DFW LY H EU LQJV W R ELU W K W KH IHP DOH P HGLXP LVW LF SDVVLY H QHJDW LY H
SU LQFLSOH LQ VSDFH V\P EROL]HG E\ D KRU L]RQW DO OLQH LQ W KH FLU FOH  7KLV LV W KH
 

W LSSHG RYHUKRUL]RQW DO, V 5XQH W KH6LH 5XQHLQUHYHUVDOW KH, VLV5XQH7KUHH

GLP HQVLRQV LQ VSDFH DUH QRZ JLYHQ   OHQJW K ZLGW K DQG GHSW K

2I W KLV W HOOV XV D YHUVH RI W KH DQFLHQW  , QGLDQ ³$W KDUYHGD´ 

+H ZKR NQRZV W ZR UXEELQJ VW LFNV

%\ ZKLFK ZLW KLQ XV W KH HP EHUV DUH LJQLW HG
+H VKRXOG EH DZDUH W KDW  KH NQRZV D +LJKHVW  W KLQJV
+H NQRZV W KH JUHDW  SRZHU RI %UDKP DQ

, Q W KH QDYHO LQ W KH SRLQW  RI W KH ILUVW  UHYHODW LRQ RI W KH 'LYLQLW \ LQ HW HUQLW \ DQG
LQILQLW \ DUH KDSSHQLQJ W KH XQLRQ W KH FUXFLIL[LRQ RI W KH $FW LYH ZLW K W KH 3DVVLYH
W KH FUXFLIL[LRQ RI VSDFH DQG W LP H ZKLFK LV HYHU\ ELUW K  7KDW  ZKLFK UHVW V ZLW KLQ
LW VHOIW KH5XKH UHVW W KH8U UHYHUVHG8U 5XK *HUP DQVKRUW IRUP IRU5XKH
 U HVW   W KH DEVROXW H  W KH VSLU LW XDO  W KH QHFHVVDU \  ³ *RG´  EHFRP HV ±  Z LW K
P RYHP HQW    W R EH W LP H DQG VSDFH DQG FDXVHG E\ W KDW  GHSHQGHQFH FRQGLW LRQ
QRQ JRG  (DU W K  P HDVXU H  FRQW U DU \  W R W KH LP P HDVXU DEOH  W KH W KLQ J Z LW KRXW
P HDVXUHVW KHW KLQJZLW KRXW OLP LW VDQGERUGHUV7KH*RGDSSHDU VDVP DQRQW KH
FURVV RI W KH P DW HULDO ZRUOG  &KULVW:RGDQ   *RG LV LQ W KH W HUUHVW ULDO LQ W KDW
ZKLFK SDVVHV LW  FDP H W R P DQLIHVW DW LRQ DQG DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH HW HUQDO ODZ RI OLIH

6ZHGLVKURFNLP DJHVIURP (DVW HUQ*RW ODQG

%RW KZLQGURVHVDSSHDUKHUHDVW KHROGHVW ZLW QHVVHVRIW KLVV\P EROEHFDXVHW KH

URFN SDLQW LQJV DUH SUH LFH DJH FRQVLGHULQJ W KH HURVLRQV ZKLFK DIIHFW HG W KH IODW
URFNV%HVLGHVW KLVLVDZKHHOZLW KIRXUVSRNHVZKLFKLVDZKHHOZLW KDFURVVW KHQ
D VKLS Z KLFK P D\ EH LQW HUSUHW HG DV FDSVL]HG W Z R OXUHV D VZ RU G Z KLFK FOHDUO\
VKRZVP DUNVRIW KHVR FDOOHGEURQ]HDJH, QIDFW IRUDORQJW LP HZHVKRXOGFKHFN
W KH FODVVLILFDW LRQ RI HUDV DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH SUHYDOHQFH RI FHUW DLQ P HW DOV ZKHW KHU
VXFK D FODVVLILFDW LRQ LV FRUUHFW   , Q DQ\ FDVH LW  LV QRW  FRUUHFW  LQ LW V SRVW XODW HG
H[FOXVLYLW \, URQH[LVW HGDOUHDG\EHIRUHEURQ]H$JULGZLW KW KUHHSDUW LW LRQVVKRZV
W ZLFHDQGRQFHOLQHV3HUKDSVDFDOHQGDURIGD\V7KHSRLQW VW RRP D\KDYH
VRP H FRQQHFW LRQ W R W KH W LP H LQGLFDW RUV Z KLFK VHHP  FRQQHFW HG Z LW K W KH HLJKW
VSRNHGZKHHOV
 

KH JRHV EDFN RQ W KH F\FOH W R W KH VSLULW  IURP  RULJLQDW LQJ RYHU EHLQJ W R SDVVLQJ
*RG IDW KHU VRQ DQG +RO\ *KRVW  RU :RGDQ :LOL DQG :HK

, IZHSXW W KHP XOW LSOLFDW LRQV\P ERO W KHFURVVRIP DUULDJH±W KH³ RW KHUFURVV´RU
FURVV RI $QGUHZ RU W KH ZDQGHULQJ FURVV  DERYH W KH SOXV V\P ERO RI W KH FURVV
W KHQ ZH JHW  W KH :RUOG 5XQH W KH &DQRQ W KH NH\ W R W KH VDFUHG URZ RI W KH 
5XQHV ZKLFK LV W KH URXQG RI W KH KHDYHQ W KH VKLHOG URQG  VKLHOG LQ DQFLHQW
1RUGLF  RI W KH KHDYHQ ZKLFK V\P EROL]HV W KH ZRUOG   [     7ZR FHQW HU
SRLQW V LQYLVLEOH LQ DGGLW LRQ W R LW  P DNHV 

7KLVZKHHORIHLJKW VSRNHVW KDW ZHUHFHLYHGIURP W KH FURVVDQGW KHP XOW LSOLFDW LRQ
FURVVLVW KHHLJKW IRRW HGZLQGKRUVH6OHLSQLURI:RGDQW KH*UHDW %UHDW K $W HP 
$W P DQ 2GKLQ :RGDQ  RI W KH ZRUOG W KH ZLQG URVH DV LW  ZDV FDOOHG LQ VHFUHW
V\P EROLVP W KHHLJKW  OHDIHGRQHZKLFKZDVLQVW DOOHGLQDOOGRP HV ELVKRSVHDW V 
Z K LFK  Z HU H EX LOW  E\  W K H LQ LW LDW HV  RU  :LK LQ HL  RI  W K H DQ FLHQ W  W HDFK LQ J  W K H
5RVLFUXFLDQV KRUVH FURVV ± 5RVHQNUHX] ± 5R‰NUHX]± 5R‰ LV KRUVH LQ P RGHUQ
*HUP DQXVHGW REHRUVLQROG*HUP DQ DVHYHU\NQRZOHGJHDEOHSHUVRQLVDZDUH
RI  7KLV ZDV W KH VLJQ W KDW  VRP HW KLQJ LQ W KHVH &KULVW LDQ $U\DQ KRXVHV RI *RG
ZDVW REHW DNHQLQW RW KH+LJK6HFUHW (LJKW W KHVDFUHGSURW HFW LRQ +XW ±SURW HFW LRQ
± KXLW  LQ )UHQFK LV    7KHUHIRUH DOVR W KH QDP H RI W KH ([W HUQVW HLQH   DV (JJ
HLJKW  HLJKW  VW DUVW RQHVLQW KHUHFHQW O\GLVFRYHUHGROG*HUP DQLFVRODUDQG6W DU
VDQFW XDU\ IURP  DERXW   \HDUV DJR  7KLV ORQJ DQG P XFK ORQJHU W KH VW DU
SHRSOH W KH KHOP VP HQ P HDVXUHG W KH VW DUV

%HIRUHZHFRQW LQXHZHZDQW W RHYRNHDQRW KHUSLFW XUHIURP W KHZDUGUREHRIRXU

LQQHUYLVLRQDQGZHFDQVD\ 7KHGLYLQLW \LVW KDW ZKLFKLVP DW KHP DW LFDOO\VW UDLJKW 
W KHRQHW KDW ZKLFKLVXQGDP DJHGZKLFKLVEDODQFHGZLW KLQLW VHOIW KHVSLULW W KH
XQLW \ RQHQHVV W KDW  ZKLFK LV YHUW LFDO  0DW HULDO P DW HULDO P DW HU P RW KHU P DW W HU
W KH0DULD *HUP DQQDP HIRU0DU\ W KDW ZKLFKLVP RW KHUO\ZKLFKFDQEHVHSDUDW HG
W KLVLVW KHZRUOGW KHP DM DW KHGHYLDW LRQIURP W KHVW UDLJKW OLQHIURP W KH2QHQHVV
IURP  W KH XQ GDP DJHG IURP  W KDW  ZKLFK LV YHUW LFDO IURP  W KH 'LYLQH

7KH DEVROXW H VSLULW XDO EHLQJ 7KHGHYLDW LRQRIW KHZRUOGRIP DW W HUIURP W KH

VSLULW XDOVW UDLJKW OLQHDQGYHUW LFDOOLQHE\ƒ
7KH LQYLVLEOH D[LV RI W KH GLYLQH W KH VSLULW XDO , UP LQVXO LV YHUW LFDO EXW  W KDW  ZKLFK
LVP DW HULDOLVDGHYLDW LRQIURP W KDW ZKLFKLVVSLULW XDOIURP W KDW ZKLFKLVYHUW LFDO
:HJHW DYHU\VLP LODUSLFW XUHLIZHW KLQNW KHXQLYHUVHDVDFLU FOH, IZHLQVFULEHG
W KH D[LV RI W KH (DUW K LW  ZRXOG GHYLDW H IURP  W KH YHUW LFDO OLQH E\  GHJUHHV LI
GUDZQW KURXJKW KHFLUFOH%XW W KLVLVW KHIRXUW KSDUW RIDTXDUW HUFLUFOHDFFRUGLQJ
W R W KH SLFW XUH KHUH

IW W DOOVW RQHVLQ:HVW SKDOLDW KDW DUHKLJKO\UHYHUHGHVSHFLDOO\E\$UP DQLVW V
 

:KHQ SXW W LQJ LQ W KH YHUW LFDO OLQH RI W LP H LQ W KH FLUFOH ZH JHW  D EHIRUH DQG DIW HU
SDVW  DQG IXW XUH D SRVLW LYH DQG D QHJDW LYH  :LW K W KH KRUL]RQW DO OLQH LQ W KH FLUFOH
ZH UHFHLYH DQ DERYH DQG D EHORZ  7KLV ZD\ ZH UHFHLYH DOVR  TXDUW HUV RI W KH
FLU FOH Z KLFK U HODW H W R HDFK RW KHU  P XW XDOO\ DQG Z KLFK Z H VSOLW  IROORZ LQJ W KH
P HDVXUHRIW KHGHYLDW LRQRIW KHD[LVRIW KH(DUW KLQIRXUVHFW RUVRIHDFKTXDUW HU
RIW KHFLUFOHVRW KDW ZHHQGXSZLW KVHFW RUVRIW KHFLUFOHRUW ZRHDFKRIHLJKW
KDOI FLUFOHDUFKHVZKLFKUHODW HW RHDFKRW KHUDVDERYHDQGEHORZULJKW DQGOHIW 
SRVLW LYH DQG QHJDW LYH

%HFDXVH W KH HDUW K D[LV VSOLW V W KH KDOI FLUFOH DUFKHV LQW R W ZR XQHTXDO KDOYHV GXH
W R LW V LQFOLQH RI  GHJUHHV LQW R D VP DOOHU RQH W R W KH ULJKW  ZLW K W KUHH SRVLW LYH
VHFW RUVDQGDODUJHURQHZLW KILYHQHJDW LYHSDUW LW LRQVRUVHFW RUV, QW KLVUHODW LRQ
LV KLGGHQ W KH P DW KHP DW LFDO P LUDFOH RI W KH JROGHQ UDW LR LQ ZKLFK W KH VP DOOHU

UHODW HVW RW KHODUJHUDVW KHODUJHUSDUW W RW KHZKROH, QQXP HULFH[SUHVVLRQW KLV
LV DJDLQ D UHODW LRQ LQ FUHDW LRQ QDP HO\ W KDW  W KH W KUHH UHODW HV W R W KH ILYH DV W KH
ILYHW RW KHHLJKW ±RUW RW KHZKROH+HUHDJDLQW KH(LJKW DSSHDUVDVP HDQLQJW KH
ZKROH ZKLFK VKRXOG EH W DNHQ LQ W KH KLJK DQG VDFUHG HLJKW  DW  DOO FUHDW LQJ DQG
FUHDW LRQ6LQFHW LP HLP P HP RULDOW KHFUHDW LYHKXP DQLW \VDZLQW KHJROGHQUDW LR
 

W KHUHODW LRQRIDQDEVROXW HKDUP RQ\DQGW KLVODZP D\UHP DLQYDOLGIRUW KHILQLW H

IRUW KDW ZKLFKLVP DW HULDO%XW EHFDXVHW KHSURSRUW LRQRIW KHJROGHQUDW LRQLVD
UHVXOW  RI W KH P DW KHP DW LFDO 'LYLQH VW UDLJKW  OLQH DQG YHUW LFDO OLQH W KLV SURYHV W KH
LQFRQVLVW HQF\ RI HYHU\W KLQJ W KDW  LV RI W KLV (DUW K P DW HULDO DV D FRQGLW LRQ W KDW
DVNV IRU LW V GLVVROXW LRQ LQW R W KDW  ZKLFK LV VSLULW XDO DQG *RG  7KLV LV VR EHFDXVH
LQ W KLV KRU U LEOH GLVFRYHU \ RI W KH GHYLDW LRQ RI W KH (DU W KHQ  P DW HU LDO IU RP  W KH
VSLULW XDOUHDOLW \V\P EROL]HGE\W KHYHUW LFDOOLQHZHGLVFRYHU W KHW HUULEOHP HDQLQJ
RIVXFKDZURQJXQEDODQFHGKDUP RQ\ZKLFKDFW XDOO\VKRXOGEH DQGZKLFK
LQW KHGLYLQHLVLQGHHG RUDEVROXW H&RQVHTXHQW O\ZHFDQDVVXP HW KDW W KH
D[LV RI W KH ZRUOG LW VHOI LV D GHYLDW LRQ IURP  W KH 'LYLQH VSLULW XDO YHUW LFDO OLQH DQG
W KDW  LV YDOLG IRU DOO P DW W HU E\ QDW XUDO ODZ

)U RP  W KLV GHY LDW LRQ IU RP  W KH 'LY LQH Y HU W LFDO OLQH DJDLQ DOO SKHQRP HQD DQG
FUHDW LRQV LQ W KH XQLYHUVH UHFHLYH W KHLU SRODU RSSRVLW HV LQ W KH VSLULW XDO SRVLW LYH
D Q G  P D W HU L D O  Q HJ D W L Y H   , I  W K H :R U O G  $[ L V VW R R G  Y HU W L FD O O \  X Q G HU VW R R G
V\P EROLFDOO\ W KHQDOOSKHQRP HQDZRXOGEHLQH[LVW HQW QRW KLQJZRXOGEHSRVVLEOH
QRW KLQJ FUHDW HG ZRXOG H[LVW   7KH UHVXOW  RI W KLV GHYLDW LRQ IURP  W KDW  ZKLFK LV
'LYLQH VSLULW XDO DQG DEVROXW H LV ZKDW  ZH FDOO OLIH  

7KLV LV W KH ³ TXDUW HU ´  RI ZKLFK VLQFH D IHZ W KRXVDQG \HDUV W KH 5LJ 9HGGD 5LJ
(GGD  LV VLQJLQJ

7KDW  JUHDW  LV KLV P DM HVW \ RI 3XUXVKD 

EXW  KH LV VW LOO JUHDW HU W KDQ W R ZKDW  W KH\ HOHYDW HG KLP 
³$ TXDUW HU ´  RI KLP  DUH DOO W KH EHLQJV
³ 7KUHH TXDUW HUV´  RI KLP  LP P RUW DOO\ DUH DERYH
³ 7KUHH TXDUW HUV´  RI KLP  HOHYDW HG W KHP VHOYHV LQW R W KH KHLJKW V
³ 2QH TXDUW HU´  JUHZ XS LQ W KLV ZRUOG
7R VSUHDG RYHU LW  DV ³ HYHU\W KLQJ´
7KDW  ZKLFK P DLQW DLQV LW VHOI ZLW KRXW  DQG ZLW K IRRG

/HW ¶VORRNEULHIO\DW W KHW ZRRUQDP HQW VIURP +DOOVW DW W ZKLFKZ HUHIRXQGRQVKHHW

P HW DOV RI EHOW V DSSUR[LP DW HO\ GDW HG  %&

2QW KHILUVW EHOW DSSHDUVW REHDQXP HULFUDW LRRIW RW KHUHIRUHRIW KHJROGHQ
UDW LR  :H QRW LFH W KUHH EDOOV FRQQHFW HG E\ D ULEERQ ZKLFK DUH RSSRVHG E\ ILYH
EDOOV W KDW  Z HU H FRQQHFW HG E\  D U LEERQ   7KH W U LQLW \  Z LW K W Z R VP DOOHU  EDOOV
EHFRP HVDILYHW KHILYHRIW KHODUJHEDOOVEHFRP HVDQ(LJKW ZLW KW KHDGGLW LRQRI
W KUHH VP DOOHU EDOOV $FKW  XQJ     7KH UHODW LRQ RI W KH QXP EHUV  DQG  W R W KH
JROGHQUDW LRLVNQRZQEHVLGHVW KDW ERW KQXP EHUVDGGXSW RW KHFXOW LFQXP EHURI

 2PLWWHG

0RG*HUP DQIRU³ $W W HQW LRQ´
 

 7KRVHDUHQXP EHUVDQGUHODW LRQVZKLFKZDQW W RH[SUHVVVRP HW KLQJ, QW KH

SDUW RIDEHOW EHVLGHVW KDW RQHZHUHFRJQL]HVNLW W OHSLQVZLW KW KH³ NLQJ´ LQW KH
P LGGOH  (DFK SDLU RI EDOOV KDV W KUHH VP DOOHU RQHV ZKLFK DJDLQ DUH   7KDW
W RJHW KHU  Z LW K W KH      [     )LY H U RRVW HU V  DV W KH ILJXU LQHV DSSHDU
DFFRP SDQ\ W KH EDOOV W ZR RQ RQH VLGH DQG W KUHH RQ W KH RW KHU DQG W KH EDOOV DUH
KHOG W RJHW KHU E\ FRQQHFW LQJ OLQHV VLP LODU W R IOLJKW  OLQHV  :KDW  DOO RI W KLV VKRXOG
P HDQ LQ GHW DLO W KDW  ZRXOG UHTXLUH D ORW  RI HIIRUW V  7KH VFLHQFH RI SUHKLVW RU\
VHHP V W R U HIXVH RI GHDOLQJ Z LW K VXFK TXHVW LRQV RQ SXU SRVH :H DW W HP SW  W R
SURYLGH W KDW  VFLHQFH ZLW K VRP H KHOS LQ W KDW  GLUHFW LRQ ZKLFK FRXOG IDFLOLW DW H LW V
W DVNYHU\P XFKEXW ZKLFKZRXOGDOVRSURYHW KDW FRQFHUQLQJW KHVHDUFKDHRORJLFDO
REM HFW VZHKDYHW RGRZLW KDP LOOHQQLDROGXQLIRUP FXOW XUHRIDP DLQUDFHZKLFK
P D\KDYHGLYLGHGLQVW \OHVDQGIDVKLRQVEXW W KH'LYLQH8U JURXQGDQGEDVLVFDQ

EH GHP RQVW UDW HG HDVLO\ LQ DOO W KHVH REM HFW V SURYLGHG KRZHYHU  W KDW  ZH FHGH W R
YLHZ LQ DOO VXFK REM HFW V RI KXP DQNLQG M XVW  DQ HYROXW LRQ LQ W KH SRRU P HDQLQJ RI
³ SURJUHVV´

%XW  ZHDUHQRW DVVXP LQJZURQJO\ LIZH VHH LQW KHVHREM HFW V ZKLFK DUH FRYHUHG
Z LW K JROG VKHHW V U HSU HVHQW LQJ DVW U RQRP LFDO V\ P EROLVP  W KRVH P DJLFDO SRZ HU
EHOW V ZKLFK ZHUH SDUW  RI W KH SULHVW O\ UREHV HYHU\ZKHUH

7KH (LJKW  DQG W KH ZKHHO ZLW K HLJKW  VSRNHV FRQW DLQV LQ QXP EHU DQG LP DJH W KH
ODZRIW KHZRUOGZKLFKZHFRXOGQDP HZLW KW KHODEHO³$FKW XQJ´  P RGHUQ*HUP DQ
IRU  ³$W W HQW LRQ´  EHFDXVH LW  LV D GLY LVLRQ RI W KH Z RU OG LQW R HLJKW  SDU W V DQG LW
UHTXLUHVDW W HQW LRQIURP XV³ 2EM HFW LYHRIW KHDW W HQW LRQ $FKW XQJ LVRQO\W KHODZ
DQGLW LVW KDW ODZW KDW ZHP DNHIRURXUVHOYHVDQG\HW ZKLFKLVQHFHVVDU\LQLW VHOI´
VD\V .DQW 

7KH HVVHQFH RI W KH 2QHQHVV 8QLW \ SHUP HDW HV W KH (LJKW  OLNH QR RW KHU QXP EHU
7KLV RW KHU SURSHUW \ P DNHV W KH (LJKW  W R D SHUIHFW  QXP EHU  $V VXFK LW  P XVW  EH D
P XOW LFLSOLW \ W KH UHODW LRQ RI ZKLFK FDQ EH QRW LFHG LQ D QDW XUDO VHTXHQFH RI LW V
LQGLYLGXDO SDUW V ZLW KRXW  JDSV  $ UHODW LRQ W KDW  FDQ DOUHDG\ VHHQ LQ W KH QXP EHUV
 RU  P XVW  EH FDOOHG SHUIHFW  EHFDXVH LW V SDUW V IROORZ HDFK RW KHU LQ
QDW XUDO DUUD\V
$ FDOFXODW LRQ ZLW K W KH (LJKW  FDQ VKRZ ZKDW  ZH P HDQ
 

O[ O [  

[  
[  
[  
[  
[  
[  
[  

7KRVH DUH QRW  JDP HV  W KLV LV KHDYHQO\ P DW KHP DW LFV ZKLFK GHVHUY HV ³ %H $FKW 
W XQJ´  P RG*HUP DQIRUDW W HQW LRQ EHFDXVHLQLW VFRQQHFW LRQVDQGHIIHFW VDFFRUGLQJ
W R QDW XUDO ODZ LW  OHDGV W R NQRZOHGJH RI W KH ZRUOG DQG RI *RG DQG ZLW K W KDW  LW
OHDGV W R W KH W UXH HVVHQFH RI RXU H[LVW HQFH

$V ZH KDYH VHHQ W KH VDFUHG QXP EHU SRLQW V W R W KH ZKROH DQG LQGHHG W KH (LJKW
KDV QRW DEOH P DW KHP DW LFDO SURSHUW LHV OLNH QR RW KHU QXP EHU KDV  , W  KDV SHUIHFW
SDUW LW LRQ EHFDXVH ZLW KRXW  GLIILFXOW \ LW  FDQ EH UHGXFHG W R RQH   W KH 2QH W KH
'LYLQH       7KHVH SURSHUW LHV FDXVH W KH HLJKW  W R EH D SHU IHFW  QXP EHU IRU
W KH DQFLHQW  DQG ZLVH RQHV  , W  EHFDP H V\P ERO RI W KH ZKROH DQG DOVR RI W KH
(LJKW K ZKLFK FRP HV IURP  ³$FKW ´   DV ZHOO DV $UW   DQG $UW XQJ   $UW   DUW V 
$U\DQ $VZHZLOOVHHODW HUW KH5XQH+DJDOW RRFRQW DLQVW KH(LJKW LQLW 7KLVZDV
ZH FDQ H[SODLQ W KDW  W KH KLJKHVW  P \VW HU\ ZKLFK LV FRQFHDOHG LQ W KH QXP EHUV 
W KURXJK  KDV EHHQ W DNHQ LQW R W KH +LJK DQG 6DFUHG   $ERYH W KH HLJKW  VW DQGV
W KH2QHEHFDXVH  HLJKW VNLW W OLQJSLQVDQGRQH³ NLQJ´W KHVDFUHG1LQH
W KHSHUIHFW LRQRIW KDW ZKLFKLVP DW HULDOKDVEHHQUHDFKHGEHFDXVHW KHW HQDJDLQ
LV HTXDO ZLW K W KH RQH  7KLV ZD\ W KH ZKHHO ZLW K HLJKW  VSRNHV W KH ZLQG URVH RU
W KH Z LQG KRU VH   Z LW K W KH HLJKW  OHJV DQG W KH RQH FHQW HU *RG Z LW K W KH KXE
1DEH  W KH QDYHO 1DEHO  W KH V\P ERO RI W KH XQLYHUVH

7KH (LJKW  LV D V\P ERO RI D FRVP LF IRUFH ILHOG

7KHW KDW LVO\LQJGRZQLVW KHV\P ERORILQILQLW \VLQFHW LP HVLP P HP RULDO  7KH

VW UHDP V RI OLIH FLUFOH DURXQG XV LQ D YLEUDW LRQ RI HLJKW  LQ IDFW  W KH DOO OLIH LW VHOI
FLUFOHVLQDZKHHORIHLJKW VSRNHVLQDQ³$W W HQW LRQW RW KHDGY LFH´   ³ +DEW $FKW ´
ZDVW KHFRP P DQGIRU³ VW DQGVW LOO´ LQW KH$XVW ULDQDUP \DQGW KHVROGLHUSHUFHLYHG
LQW KLVSRVLW LRQRIDW W HQW LRQW KH³ (LJKW ´ZKLFKVXUURXQGHGKLVERG\LQW ZRFLUFOHV
Z KLFK W RXFKHG HDFK RW KHU  LQ W KH DU HD RI W KH KLSV  , Q ROG W LP HV RI W KH VW LOO

 DW W HQW LRQ Z DW FKIXOQHVV

 W \SH UDFH

UDFHP RUHZLW KW KHP HDQLQJRI³ UDFLDOLW \´

*HUP DQ5RVH URVH5R‰ KRUVH±:LQGURVH FRP SDVV:LQGUR‰ ZLQGKRUVH
 2PLWWHG


5DG±ZKHHO+HUHKHZULW HVÄ $FKW DXIGHQ5DW ´ ZKHUH5DW  DGYLFHFRXQFLO
 

XQEURNHQ ODZ W KH FULP LQDO ZDV EDQLVKHG RXW  RI W KH RVW UDFL]DW LRQ   7KH\ GLG QRW
RVW UDFL]HDQ\P RUHKHZDVQRORQJHUZRUW KDQ\DW W HQW LRQEXW KHZDVGHVSLVHG
EHFDXVH KH QR ORQJHU KDG ³$FKW ´   KH QR ORQJHU ZDV ZRUW K DQ\ DW W HQW LRQ 

:LW K W KH FRQVW HOODW LRQ RI 2ULRQ D FRVP LF  VZLQJV DURXQG W KH SROH RI W KH VN\
2ULRQ $ULRQ W KH JUHDW  $U W KH JUHDW  DUF W KH JUHDW  $FKW  (LJKW  FLUFOHV RQ W KH
QLJKW O\ VN\ DERYH RXU KHDGV gU YDQGLO W KH FRQVW HOODW LRQ LV FDOOHG LQ W KH (GGD
ZKLFKP HDQV8U FKDQJH:KDW DVDFUHGZRUGDQGLP DJHIRUW KHFLUFOLQJXQLYHUVH
EXW IRUJRW W HQW RGD\DQGFRYHUHGXSE\DJURVVKHDSRIXQJRGO\DVVXP SW LRQVDQG
LP DJLQDW LRQV  , W  LV QR VXUSULVH W KDW  ZH ZLOO QHHG VHYHUDO FHQW XULHV W R OLIW  DOO W KH
W UHDVXUHV W KDW  JRW  ORVW  GXULQJ W KH P LOOHQQLD RI KXP DQ GHFOLQH

$OO OLIH RULJLQDW HV IURP  W KH VSOLW W LQJ RI W KH 2QH LQW R W KH 7ZR W KH GLVFRUG W KH
SRODULW \W KHRSSRVLW HV$QDERYHDQGDEHORZDULJKW W XUQRIW KHQRUW KHUQZRUOG
SROH DQG D OHIW  W XUQ RI W KH VRXW KHUQ Z RUOG SROH   SURYH DP RQJ RW KHU W KLQJV
EHVLGHV IDFW V W KDW  ZH ZLOO GHVFULEH ODW HU W KH GRXEOLQJ RI W KH 1LQH ZKLFK P HDQV
[ W KHQXP EHURIW KH5XQH 5RZ 0XUP XU 5XQHQ 5HLKHQ 5DXQHQ 

7KH UXQH DUUD\ RI  SDUW V FRQW DLQV W KH V\P EROV RI W KH VHFUHW V RI W KH XQLYHUVH
:KR KDV JUDVSHG W KHLU P HDQLQJ XQGHUVW DQGV DQG FRQW UROV OLIH  7KH 5XQHV DUH
QRW  M XVW  W KH VW UXFW XUDO EHDP V RI W KH XQLYHUVH EXW  DOVR DQ LP DJH RI KXP DQ
SK\ VLFDO VW U XFW XU H DQG W KH\  DFKLHY H LQ W KHLU  U K\ W KP LF J\ P QDVW LF P RY HP HQW
P DJLFDO VSLULW XDO HIIHFW V  7KH\ DUH VRXQGLQJ FRVP RV ZLW KLQ W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ
DQG W KH\ JLYH LP P HGLDW H H[SHULHQFH RI W KH 'LYLQH

, Q W KH EHJLQQLQJ ZDV W KH 2QH ZKLFK P HDQV *RG 6SLULW   $FFRUGLQJ W R W KLV W KH
QXP EHUV DUH LQ W KH UHDOP  RI W KDW  ZKLFK LV SRVVLEOH HYHQ LQ W KH UHDOP  RI W KDW
ZKLFK LV IDFW  LQ W KH VSLULW XDO UHDOP  EHIRUH W KH FUHDW LRQ RI W KH ZRUOG EHIRUH W KH
RULJLQRIW KHP DW HULDOZRUOG W KHDUUD\RIQXP EHUVIURP W KH W RW KHZKLFK
VHHQ QRW  LQ D FDOFXODW LRQ ZD\ EXW  LQ D SKLORVRSKLFDO RQH HTXDOV W KH VHQW HQFH 
ZKLFKP HDQVW KH2QHLVW KHEHJLQQLQJDQGW KHHQG7KLVHTXDW LRQW HDFKHV
XV

7KHUH LV QR HYROXW LRQ W KDW  GLG QRW  KDYH LW V EHJLQQLQJ LQ W KH 2QH LQ *RG  $OO
QXP EHUV ZKLFK P HDQV W KH DUUD\ IURP   W R  KDYH EHHQ ERUQ IURP  W KH 2QH
IU RP  *RG IU RP  W KH VSLU LW   1R QXP EHU  KDV U HDOLW \ YDOXH DQG P HDVXU HP HQW
ZLW KRXW  W KH 2QH W KH XQLW  IURP  ZKLFK LW  RULJLQDW HV  %XW  W KH RQH W KH XQLW  *RG
VSLULW  FDQ H[LVW  ZLW KRXW  W KH QXP EHU

)URP  W KH 2QH ODZ DQG RUGHU RI W KH QXP EHU HYROYH

)URP W KLVZHFRQFOXGHW KHSULQFLSOHRIZLVGRP FRQFHUQLQJW KHRQHQHVVRIQDW XUH

RI W KH ZRUOG ZKLFK E\ P HDQV RI LW V HYROXW LRQ JHQHUDW HV W KH QXP EHU DQG LW V
VHTXHQFHZKLFKUHYHDOVW KH2QHLQHDFKQXP EHUZLW KRXW KRZHYHUFKDQJHLQLW V
YDOLGLW \ DQG HVVHQFH M XVW  OLNH W KH QXP EHU


2PLWWHG
 

, Q W KLV DUUD\ ZH UHFRJQL]H W KH ODZ RI W KH RULJLQ ZRUN DQG FRQVHTXHQFH W KH
KLJK KRO\ W KUHH ZKLFK LQ W KH HTXLODW HUDO W ULDQJOH LV DEVROXW H 2QHQHVV DJDLQ
7KH 2QH W KH XQLW \ LV W KH FDXVH  W KH HYROXW LRQ W KH HIIHFW  DQG W KH QXP EHU DUH
W KH HIIHFW   7KUHH EHLQJV LQ RQH W KH 7KUHH LQ W KH 2QH  2QH HTXDOV 
 

, I ZH ELVHFW  W KH DQJOH RI W KH HTXLODW HUDO W ULDQJOH DQG GUDZ W KH OLQHV RI ELVHFW LRQ
W KHVH OLQHV LQW HU VHFW  LQ W KH P LG SRLQW  RI W KH W U LDQJOH Z KLFK GHW HU P LQHV W KH
HTXLOLEULXP VSLULW XDODQGP DW HULDORIW KHW ULDQJOH, IZHVXVSHQGW KHW ULDQJOHRQ
W KLV SRLQW  RQ D W KUHDG W KH W ULDQJOH LV LQ HTXLOLEULXP 

7KH W ULDQJOH FRQW DLQV QRZ DOO QXP EHUV DOO VKDSHV DQG DOO P HDVXUHP HQW V  , I ZH
SXW  W KH 2QH LQW R W KH FHQW HU W KDW  ZH IRXQG DQG XVLQJ W KH VSDFH ZH HQW HU W KH
YDOXHRIW KHQXP HULFDUUD\RI±LQW RDQHTXDODP RXQW RIXQLW VZHUHFHLYHW KH
IROORZLQJ ILJXUH

3RLQ W
6W UDLJKW  /LQH
7U LDQJOH
6TXDUH

7KHU H Z H FDQ VHH W KH HY ROXW LRQDU \  ODZ  RI W KH QXP EHU V 0HDVXU HP HQW V DQG
ERGLHVIURP W KHSRLQW RYHUW KHOLQHW RW KHW ULDQJOHIURP W KHUHW RW KHTXDGUDQJOH
DQGIURP W KHRQHW RW KHW ZRRYHUW KHW KUHHW RW KHIRXUZKLFKDUUD\UHVXOW VLQW KH
W HQW KHUHIRUH      

, I ZH VXUURXQG W KH QXP EHUV W KDW  ZH IRXQG DQG ZKLFK EHFDP H
VKDSH Z LW K D FLU FOH W KHQ Z H U HFHLY H VHHQ DV D VXU IDFH D
V\P ERORIW KHFRP SOHW HFUHDW LRQW KHFLUFOHW KH]HURVXUURXQGV
W KH2QH6HHQP DW HULDOO\W KH2QHLVW KHLQYLVLEOHFHQW HURIW KH
W HQVLRQ HQHUJLHV ZKLFK DFW  LQ D VSKHUH

, IZHGRXEOHW KHW KUHHW KHW ULDQJOHLQW KHFLUFOHW KHQZHJHW W KHVXEGLYLVLRQRI

W KH FLUFOH LQW R  VHFW RUV W KH OHQJW K RI ZKLFK LV HTXDO W KH UDGLXV RI W KH KH[DJRQ
W KDW LVVXUURXQGHGE\W KHFLUFOHZKLFKZHKDYHFUHDW HGZLW KW KLVRSHUDW LRQ7KLV
LV W KH W ULDQJXODU 8U IXQFW LRQ RI W KH FLUFOH RU W KH ZLVGRP  W KDW  IURP  W KH VSLULW XDO
7KUHHZKLFKLV2QH*RGW KHXQLYHUVHHP HUJHVW KHV\P ERORIZ KLFKLVFRQFHDOHG
LQ W KLV VKDSH DV W KH V\P ERO RI W KH ZRUOG DVK W KH :RUOG 7UHH ZKLFK LV W KH $OO
5XQH W KH $OUDXQH W KH +DJ $OO W KH $OO +DJ

*RGLVW KH2QHW KHDQVHW KHDFH  W KHKDW H  $FHDQGKDW H $‰XQG+D‰ DUH

RSSRVLW HV   8QLW \  DQG GXDOLW \    ORY H DQG KDW H  ORY H XQLILHV  KDW H VHSDU DW HV
'LVFRUG KRZHYHU KDW H LV W KH RULJLQ RI DOO W KLQJV QRW  ORYH ZKLFK ZDQW V XQLW \

0RGHUQ*HUP DQ $‰

0RGHUQ*HUP DQ +D‰
 

+DW H LV W HQVLRQ VSOLW W LQJ GLYRUFH GH XQLILFDW LRQ GXDOLVP  GLVFRUG UHSXOVLRQ LW
LVIOHHLQJFHQW ULIXJDO+DW HW KHUHIRUHLVOLIHKDW HFUHDW HG W KHZRUOG  /RYHZLOO
GHVW UR\LW DJDLQEHFDXVHORYHVHHNVRXW W KH8UW KHFDOP W KHXQLW \W KHRQHQHVV
W KH XQLILFDW LRQ LW  LV FHQW ULSHW DO LW  IOHHV W KH ZRUOG  7KHUHIRUH ORYH LV QRW  W KH
EHJLQQLQJ EXW  W KH HQG RI W KH FUHDW HG ZRUOG  /RYH VLQNV EDFN LQW R W KH 8U EXW
IURP  W KH 85 IURP  W KH FDOP  D QHZ $DU HDJOH  ULVHV D QHZ -DKU \HDU  ULVHV D
QHZ :HOW HQM DKU ZRUOG \HDU  ULVHV

6SDFH   LV W KUHH GLP HQVLRQDO  7KH +DJ $OO LV SUHIHUDEO\ D V\P ERO RI VSDFH  7KH
SHJ W RS LV D UHYHDOLQJ H[DP SOH RI W KDW   %HFDXVH IURP  LW  ZH FDQ UHFRJQL]H W KH
RULJLQ RI W KH VZDVW LND DV ZHOO DV W KH RULJLQ RI W KH +DJ $OO 5XQH

7KH +DJ $OO KDV W KH FORVHVW  FRQQHFW LRQ W R W KH FXEH EHFDXVH LW  UHSUHVHQW V LW V
W KHFXEH¶V W KUHHD[HVDQGW KHW KUHHGLUHFW LRQVLQW KHVSDFH/LNHZLVHW KLV5XQH
KDV D U HODW LRQ RI N LQVKLS W R W KH VSKHU H DV Z HOO DV W R HY HU \ W KLQJ ERGLO\  DQG
P DW HULDOEHFDXVHLW LVDV\P ERORIW KHVSDFHDQGJHQHUDOO\W RW KHFRVP RV2QH
GLUHFW LRQDOZD\VVLJQLILHVW KHD[LVDURXQGZKLFK³ HYHU\W KLQJ´ ZKLFKP HDQVW KH
$OO XQLYHUVH  URW DW HV  $V ZH VKRZHG EHIRUH 'UHKHQ W R W XUQ  DQG 'UHL W KUHH
DUH NLQ DFFRUGLQJ W R ZRUG VW HP   %XW  LI ZH GUDZ D FXEH DV VHHQ LQFOLQHG IURP
DERYH W KHQ W KH +DJ $OO HP HUJHV IURP  VXFK D SURM HFW LRQ IURP  W KH ± VHHQ ZLW K
W KH H\HV RI W KH SHUVRQ ZKR GUDZV ³ LQQHU´  VL[ HGJHV RI W KH FXEH W KH RW KHU VL[
HGJHV ZKLFK OLP LW  W KH FXEH¶V RXW VLGH DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH GUDZLQJ  IRUP  DQ H[DFW
KH[DJRQ ZKLFK QDW XUDOO\ HP HUJHV E\ VSDFLQJ W KH SHULSKHU\ RI D FLUFOH ZLW K LW V
U DGLXV

7KLVZD\ZHUHFHLYHJUDSKLFDOO\W KHUHODW LRQVEHW ZHHQW KHFXEHDQGW KHKH[DJRQ

7KH UHVXOW  RI W KLV W KHQ LV W KDW  7+( +DJ $OO 5XQH FDQ QDW XUDOO\ HP HUJH IURP  QR
RW KHU JHRP HW ULF VKDSH W KDQ W KH KH[DJRQ EHFDXVH RQO\ W KDW  GRHV QRW  KDYH W KH
KRUL]RQW DO OLQH DV LV DOVR W KH FDVH ZLW K W KH +DJ $OO  7KLV KRUL]RQW DO OLQH LV W KH
7HO 7HLO  7HOOXV  RU (DUW K 5XQH  :LW K W KLV ODFNLQJ W KH +DJ $OO 5XQH SURYHV LW V
XQ (DUW KO\FRVP LFFKDUDFW HU7KHUHIRUHW KHKH[DJRQZDVVLQFHW LP HVLP P HP RULDO
 [  P DOH DQG IHP DOH    W KH V\P ERO RI W KH P DFURFRVP 


 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG

, UUW XP  P RG*HUP DQIRUHUURU
 

7KHKH[DJUDP ZLW KLW VW ZRW ULDQJOHVLVKRZHYHUDVZHNQRZQRW KLQJEXW W KHW ZR

GLP HQVLRQDOUHSUHVHQW DW LRQRIW ZROLQNHGW KUHHGLP HQVLRQDOS\UDP LGV, IZHSXOO

%XFNOHIRXQGRQW KHLVODQGRI$P UXQZKLFKVKRZV

W KH +DJ $OO 5XQH W KH $OO 5XQH LQ W KH VKDSH RI D
KH[DJRQ Z LW K SXUSRVHG RP LVVLRQ RI D KRUL]RQW DO
OLQH DFU RVV  Z KLFK LV W \ SLFDO RQO\  LQ W KH U HODW HG
FRP SDVV EXW  IRU ZKLFK W KH FRUQHU SRLQW V DSSHDU
DOUHDG\  7KH SDW W HUQ LV ZRQGHUIXOO\ W LHG LQW R W KH
IUDP HZRUN RI W KH +DJ $OO  %&

DSDU W  W K H S\ U DP LGV DQ G SX W  W K HP  W RJHW K HU  RQ  W K HLU  EDVHV  Z K LFK  DU H W Z R

GLP HQVLRQDOVTXDUHVW KHQZHJHW DQRFW DKHGURQ7KH&KHRSV3\U DP LGLVVRW R
VD\W KHXSSHUKDOIRIDQRFW DKHGURQW KHRW KHUKDOIRIZKLFKLW VP LUURULP DJHLV
EHQHDW K W KH JU RXQG    2QO\ IURP  W KH YLHZ  IURP  W RS GRQH E\ W KH Z LVH W KH
IROORZLQJ FDQ EH VHHQ   KH VHHV IURP  DERYH W KH VTXDUH ZLW K LW V GLDJRQDOV KH
VHHV W KH FURVV FUXFLIL[LRQ  DQG KH NQRZV W KDW  D S\UDP LG LV DOZD\V D KDOI LH
RQH SDUW  RI W KH RFW DKHGURQ RU RI W KH +RO\ (LJKW 

)URP W LSW RW LSRIW KHRFW DKHGURQKRZHYHUW KHUHLVW KH7KLUGRQHYHUW LFDOW RW KH
GXDO W ZR GLP HQVLRQDO VXUIDFH  7KLV 7KLUG HP HUJHV IURP  W KH GXDOLW \ DQG LW  LV
VRP HW KLQJ HOVH DQG LW  LV P RUH W KDQ W KH W ZR W KH VXUIDFH QDP HO\ LW  LV W KH D[LV
W KH FKLOG W KDW  ZKLFK LV QHZ ³ DURXQG ZKLFK HYHU\W KLQJ LV W XUQLQJ´ DQG W R ZKLFK
HYHU\W KLQJ FRP HV LQ W KH IXW XUH QDP HO\ DOO W KDW  ZKLFK FRP HV W R XV

, W  LV W KH UD\ RI W KH P LGGOH W KH SRVLW LYH W R W KH W ZR QHJDW LYHV DFH DQG KDW H
FRP LQJ LQILQLW HO\ IURP  W KH GHSW KV DQG ULVLQJ LQILQLW HO\ W R W KH KHLJKW V

7KLVSRVLW LYHYHUW LFDOUD\LVW KH, 65XQH, W KH(JR 5XQHW KHD[LVRIW KHZRUOGDQG
RIW KHVRXOW KHVSLQHRIW KHKXP DQEHLQJDQGRIW KHFRVP RV7KLVUD\LVW KH, 6
W KH RQO\ W KLQJ ZKLFK LV VHFXUH W KH ³ , ´  ± HJR  :KDW  RUELW V DURXQG LW  EXW  QHYHU
UHDFKHV LW  LV W KH ,  UU W XP    7KH UD\ W KH ZDYH RI ³ , ´ LV W KDW  ZKLFK LV SRVLW LYH
YHUW LFDO P DOH W KH SOXV W KH S KDO OXV EXW  W KH GLVN RI W KH SHJ W RS ZKLFK RUELW V
DURXQG LW  LV W KDW  ZKLFK LV IHP DOH W KH P LQXV V\P ERO ZKHQ VHHQ RQ D VXUIDFH

3/86DQG0, 186±W KLVVXUHVRXQGVGU\W RRXUHDUDQGZHFDQUHP HP EHUKRZZH

KDYH EHHQ W RUW XUHG LQ VFKRRO ZLW K W KHVH W ZR V\P EROV  %XW  KRZ IXOO RI OLIH DUH
W KHVHZRUGVLIZHXQYHLOW KHLUP HDQLQJ7KHQZHVHHW KDW P DW KHP DW LFVRULJLQDW HG

0LGGOH+LJK*HUP DQ *HUP DQRIW KH0LGGOH$JHV IRUORYH
 

IURP  W KH SOXV  IURP  W KH SXOVDW LQJ OLIH  $OO LV QRW KLQJ EXW  D FRP SDULVRQ DQ
DGM XVW P HQW    7KH SOXV LV W KH SXOVH  W KDW  Z KLFK LV ³ SXOVLW LY H´  W KDW  Z KLFK LV
SRVLW LYH SOXVLVW KHS KDO OXVW KDW ZKLFKLVP DOH0LQXVLVW KDW ZKLFKLVIHP DOH
W KH ³ 0LQQH´   W KH ³ 0LQ G HUH´   W KDW  ZKLFK LV VP DOOHU QHJDW LYH W KH ³ 0LQQD´  
W KH 0LQHW W H  

+HUH ZH KDYH W KH LP DJH   W KH ³ GHYLO¶V ZKHHO´  RI W KH IRONORULVW LF IHVW LYDOV RI W KH
2NW REHUIHVW   7KH ³ (DUW K´  DV D GLVN QHJDW LYH URW DW HV DURXQG LW V D[LV SRVLW LYH
:KHQ W KH GLVN URW DW HV W KH KXP DQV Z LW KRXW  FDSDELOLW \ W R JUDVS DUH SXVKHG
DZD\IURP W KHP LGGOHIURP W KHD[LVIURP W KHDVKW UHHIURP W KH:RUOG7UHHDQG
W KH\  DU H FDVW  LQW R HP SW LQHVV W LOO W KH\  U HFRJQL]H W KDW  VW DELOLW \  LV RQO\  LQ W KH

P LGGOH%XW RQO\W KDW SHUVRQILQGVVW DELOLW \RQW KH:RUOG7UHHRQ, UP LQVXOZKR

KDV UHFRJQL]HG W KH IROORZLQJ   KDW H W KDW  LV QHFHVVDU\ IRU OLIH DV ZHOO DV HUULQJ
DQG EHLQJ SXVKHG LQW R HU U RU  KDYH W R EH FRXQW HU HG Z LW K GHDW K GHVLU LQJ DQG
VDFULILFLQJORYHZKLFKRYHUFRP HVW KHFHQW ULIXJDOH[W HUQDOSRZHUZLW KFRQFHQW UDW LQJ
LQQHUSRZHU7KHQLW FDQHQW HUW KHUD\RI*RGDQGRIW KHHJRZKHUHDORQHFDOP
LV H[LVW LQJ  +HUH LV W KH HP SLUH RI W KH P LGGOH RI RXU VRXO   FROXP Q   IURP  ZKLFK
W KH ZRUOG FDQ EH OLIW HG RXW  RI LW V KLQJHV  +HUH HJR QHVV LV UXOLQJ QRW  HUURU  
+HU H W KH Z LOO LV U XOLQJ W KH U RW DW LQJ HJR D[ LV LFK Z DFKVH   W KH Z DY H W KH
ZKHHOW KHZKHHORIZLOOW KH+YLO 5XQHDQGLQGHHGLIZHZULW HW KH,  ZDYHZLW K
W KH GRW  RI W KH OHW W HU ³ , ´ ZH UHDFK W KH P \VW HU\ RI W KH P DW KHP DW LFDO SRLQW  ZKLFK
LV QRW  W R SHUFHLYH EHFDXVH LW  KDV QR GLP HQVLRQ D QRW KLQJ DV IDU W KH VHQVXDO

(JR ZDYH VHHQ IURP  W KH VLGH (JR ZDYH VHHQ IURP  W RS  :KHOO 5XQH
SHUFHSW LRQV DUH FRQFHUQHG DQG DOVR LQ W KDW  ZKLFK LV DERYH VHQVXDO SHUFHSW LRQ
*RG 7KHVP DOOHVW YLVLEOHSRLQW LVDOUHDG\DFLUFOHZLW KRXW EHJLQQLQJDQGZLW KRXW
HQG ZKLFK P HDQV W KDW  EHJLQQLQJ DQG HQG DUH RQH HYHU\ZKHUH RQ W KH FLUFOH LQ
HYHU\RQHRILW VSRLQW V, IZHLP DJLQHW KHSRLQW DERYHDZDYHDVDFLUFOHRIVRP H
H[SDQVLRQ DQG ORRN DW  LW  IURP  DERYH SK\VLFDOV VHHQ DV D OHW W HU RQ W KLV UXQH


GDV0LQGHUH W KDW ZKLFKLVLQIHULRULQW KHP HDQLQJRIQHDU Z RUW KOHVV

0LQQD DFROOHFW LYHÄ QDP H´ IRUDKRXVHP DLG±DIHP DOH³ )UHQFK´

2PLWWHG

6HHOH VRXO6lXOH FROXP Q
 2PLWWHG


, FK $FKVH D[LVRIHJR±LFKZ DFKVH VRXQGVVLP LODUZ LW KW KHH[FHSW LRQRIW KHVRXQGRIÄ Z ´ 
, JURZ
 

W KHQW KHZDYHW KH, W KH, 6W KHHJR , FK EHFRP HVDSRLQW LQVLGHDFLUFOH*RG
UHYHDOHGKLP VHOILQW KHKXP DQEHLQJLQW KHHJREHFDXVHVXFKP HDQLQJKDVW KLV
V\P ERODVZHKDYHDOUHDG\OHDUQHG%XW LW LVDW W KHVDP HW LP HW KH5XQH:KHHO
DQG IURP  W KDW  ZH FDQ FRQFOXGH W KDW  W KH DQFLHQW  RQHV KDG W KRVH W KRXJKW V ZKHQ
Z RUNLQJ Z LW K W KHLU 5XQHV EHFDXVH RW KHUZ LVH W KH\ FRXOG QRW  KDYH DUULYHG DW
W KHVH V\P EROV   7KH ZDYH W KH ZLOO   LQ W KH FHQW HU QRZ LV *RG RU W KH (JR EXW
W KH FLUFOH LV W KH ³ ZRUOG´ W KH RW KHU KXP DQV DOO FUHDW XUHV DQG DOO P DW W HU DURXQG
XVLQEULHIHUURU7KHUHIRUHZHVKRXOGVW ULYHW RRXUVHOYHVW KHQZHDUULYHDW W KH
P LGGOHDW *RG$UHQ¶W VXFKREVHUYDW LRQVDQGFRQFOXVLRQVP RUHP HDQLQJIXOW KDQ
W KH QRQVHQVLFDO DUJXLQJ DERXW  GRJP DV ZKLFK W KURZV KXP DQV RII W KH FHQW HU
DZD\ IURP  *RG RQ W KH FLUFOLQJ W UDFN RI HW HUQDO HUURU"  , Q W KH HP SLUH RI W KH
P LGGOHRQW KHD[LVRQW KHDFHHYHU\W KLQJHQGVZKLFKLVHUURUDQGKDW H ZHDUH
LQ W KH 85 LQ W KH SRLQW  RI UHVW 


2PLWWHG

:HOOH ZDYH:LOOH ZLOO
 

;9, 
7KH&RVP LF2ULJLQRIW KH5XQHV
0\6HOI\RXU<RXDQG*RGDUHDVDP H
)RU*RGKDVZ HGKLP VHOIZ LW KDOOW KDW LVEUHDW KLQJ
)RUW UXO\DOOEHLQJDULVHVIURP RQHVLQJOHHP SLUH¶VURRW V
2IHDUW KHQKHDYLQHVVDQGKHDYHQO\NLQG

7KHVRXOSUHVVHVKRP HZDUGW KURXJKHDUW KO\OD\HUV

7RZ DUGVHYHUQHZ ELUW KVLQW RW KHOLJKW 
7RILQGKHUHYHQW XDOO\DQGQRW \RXUGHHGVZ LOOEHZ KDW \RXZ LOOEHM XGJHGIRU
2XUDFW LRQVFRP P HQGXVEXW VDYHXVW KH\GRQRW 

2QFH*RGDQGVSLULW KDYHP HUJHGLQW RRQH

7KHILQDOW XUQRIHW HUQDOFKDQJHFDQDSSURDFK\RX
:KHQP DQLVGUXQNQRORQJHURIEHLQJP DQEXW RI*RGDORQH
7KHQ\RXUVHOIKDVFRP SOHW HGW KHSDW KRIIXOILOOP HQW V

+DYLQJRULJLQDW HGLQW KHRULJLQDOFRQW H[W RIW KHKXP DQ8U UDFLDOP LQGRIW KH

VRQV RI W KH JRGV ZLW K W KH VSLULW  RI W KH ZRUOGV W KH 5XQHV OHDG W KH VHHNLQJ
KXP DQ EHLQJ EDFN W R KLV FRVP LF KRP HODQG  7KH\ JUDQW  KLP  W KH P \ VW LFDO
H[ SHU LHQFH RI XQLILFDW LRQ Z LW K *RG   7KH\  DU H W KH VXU HVW  Z D\  W R VHOI
GHLILFDW LRQ ZKLFK LV D VHOI ZHGGLQJ   W KH VXUHVW  ZD\ W R LQVLJKW V DERXW  VHOI
DQGZLW KW KDW DOVRW RSK\VLFDODQGSV\FKLFKHDOLQJ

:H FHUW DLQO\ H[SHULHQFH DQ LP P HQVH LQQHU M R\ ZKHQ ZH H[SHULHQFH W KH
VKHHU ZHDOW K RI NQRZOHGJH DQG *QRVLV UH   W KH (QJOLVK ZRUG ³ W R NQRZ´
W KDW  W KHVH VLP SOH ORRNLQJ V\P EROV RI W KH 5XQHV FDQ RIIHU W R W KH LQLW LDW H
HYHQW RW KHEHJLQQHU

:HFDQVDIHO\DGYLVHDJDLQVW DQ\IRUHLJQNLQGRIP \VW LFLVP EHFDXVHDOOW UXH

'LYLQH LQZDUGQHVV IORZV LQW R W KH VHFUHW  RI W KH $OO 5XQH W KH $OO 0XUP XU
ZKLFKFRQW DLQVW KHXOW LP DW HRIDOOP \VW HULHV, QW KLVFRQW H[W W KHKRSHOHVVO\
DEXVHGVD\LQJ³ H[RULHQW HOX[´  W KH/LJKW IURP W KH(DVW ORRNVLQFUHDVLQJO\
QRQVHQVLFDO   &RUUHFW O\ XQGHUVW RRG W KLV VD\LQJ P HDQV W KH ULVLQJ W KH $DU
HDJOH W KH6XQW KH$ULHQW  W KH(DVW  2VW HQ W KH(DVW HU 2VW HUQ ZLW KLQ
RXUVHOYHVZKHUHW KHOLJKW LVVKLQLQJIRUXV7KXVZKHUHZRXOG(DVW EHRQ
W KLVHDUW KIRUDFRVP LFDOO\RULHQW HGKXP DQEHLQJLIQRW RQHYHU\RQHRILW V
SRVVLEOHUHIHUHQFHSRLQW V, FRXOGFLUFOHW KHHDUW KIRUHYHUDQGZRXOGQHYHU


2PLWWHG
 

ILQG W KH DVFHQW  W KH HDUW KO\ (DVW   7KHUHIRUH DOO NQRZOHGJH FRP HV IURP
LQVLGH QHYHU IURP  RXW VLGH QHYHU IURP  W KH LQW HOOHFW XDO P LQG RQO\ IURP  D
I HHOLQ J  RU  K X Q FK   W K H I HHOLQ J RI  HY HU \ W K LQ J DQ G W K H FRQ Q HFW LRQ  Z LW K
HYHU\W KLQJRUW KHXQLYHUVH ´$OOJHIKO´  

7KH5XQHVOHDGXVEDFNRQW KHSDW KW RW KHP RW KHUVDQGW KLVSDW KLVW KHSDW KRIIDLW K, W
LVIDLW KQRW LQW KHP HDQLQJRIGRJP DW LFW KLQNLQJQRW LQW KHP HDQLQJRIDFFHSW LQJDVW UXW K
W KLQJV W KDW  DUH QRQ GHVFULSW  LQGHVFULEDEOH EXW  LQ W KH P HDQLQJ RI W UXVW  W KDW  ZH VKRXOG
IROORZ W KH YRLFH RI RXU FRQVFLHQFH RI RXU EORRG  ZH VKRXOG QRW  IROORZ W KH LQW HOOHFW  W KH
ZRUOGZKLFKW UXO\LVW KHELJLOOXVLRQW KHFRQW LQXRXVGHFHSW LRQW KH0DM DRIW KH, QGLDQV
0DM D W KH6DQVNULW ZRUGIRULOOXVLRQ W KH0DULD  W KH0D7H 5LDW KH0DW W HUW KH0RW KHU
*HU P DQ   ³ 0XW W HU ´  W KDW  Z KLFK LV P DW HU LDO  , Q W KLV XU  KXP DQ Z LVGRP  LV QRW KLQJ
FRLQFLGHQW DODUW LILFLDOFRQVW UXFW HGP DGH$OORILW LVRULJLQDOO\JURZQ

:KHQFRQW HP SODW LQJW KHVHW KLQJVLW LVLP SRUW DQW W KDW \RXULG\ RXUVHOIRIDOOSUHM XGLFHV
DQG OHW  \RXU LQQHU YRLFH DORQH VSHDN  7R M XGJH VRP HW KLQJ EHIRU H \RX KDYH IRXQG D
EULGJHW RDQXQGHUVW DQGLQJLVDV\P SW RP RIP HQW DODQGSK\VLFDOUDFLDOLQIHULRULW \EHFDXVH
ERW K RI W KDW  FDXVHV FDSDELOLW \ W R DFFHSW  W UXW K :DKUKHLW  ZKLFK LV DQ $U QHVV  D 6XQ
QHVVDVXQQ\ QHVV  1RERG\VKRXOGEHDUW KHJXLOW RIXQNQRZLQJO\SUHYHQW LQJW KHY LFW RU\
RI W KH P LOG OLJKW  RI LQVLJKW  DQG NQRZOHGJH ZLW KLQ RQHVHOI RU RW KHUV  7KLV UHW XUQ W R RXU
ZHOO VSULQJV SRUW HQGV D VW UHQJW KHQLQJ DQG D IXW XUH LW  LV QRW  DQ LGOH UXP P DJLQJ LQ W KH
GHDG SDVW  LQ W KDW  ZKLFK KDV EHHQ DV OLW W OH DV W KH ZHOO VSULQJ LV DQ\ KDYH EHHQ IRU W KH
ODUJHIORZLQJULYHUEXW VRP HW KLQJW KDW LVSUHVHQW DQGQHFHVVDU \7KHUHIRUHOHW XVJRW R
W KH VRXUFHV

+RZ GLG W KH 5XQHV FRP H LQW R EHLQJ"  :KR FUHDW HG W KHP  DQG LI W KH\ DUH RI FRVP LF
RULJLQ DQG D P DW KHP DW LFDO UHYHODW LRQ VR W R VD\ W KHQ ZKR KDV UHDG W KHVH VSLULW XDO
FRRUGLQDW HVDQGSRZHUFHQW HUVRIW KHXQLYHUVHIURP W KHFHOHVW LDOYDXOW "

1RERG\  FU HDW HG W KHP   EHFDXVH W KH\  KDYH DOZ D\ V H[ LVW HG  VLQFH µ8U GD¶  7KH\  DU H
XQFRQVFLRXVO\ SUHVHQW  LQ HYHU\RQH DQG W KH\ DUH VLP SO\ W KH SULP DO H[SUHVVLRQ RI RXU
SV\FKR SK\VLFDO FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K W KH FRVP RV  $V DERYH VR EHORZ    RXU QDNHG ERG\ D
P LFURFRVP FORW KHGZLW KLW VVRXOLVP HUHO\DP LUURULP DJHRIW KHP DFURFRVP W KHFRVP RV
ZKLFK LV FORW KHG ZLW K W KH GLYLQH VSLULW   :H FDQ RQO\ SDLQW  DQG FRP SRVH LQ P XVLF DQG
SRHW U\W KDW ZKLFKZHDUHRXUVHOYHV(YHU\FKLOGDOUHDG\KDVW KHXUJHW REHDP LUURURI
LW VHOIZKHQLW W DNHVXSW KHVODW HW DEOHW DQGSDLQW VLW VHOIDVW KHP LUURULP DJHRI*RG

2QFHXSRQDW LP HW KHUHZDVDFKLOGW KDW GUHZDOLQHDQGVKRZHGLW RIIUHM RLFLQJ 7KLVLV

P H , W GUHZW KH, V 5XQHD5XQHRIW KH³ , ´EHFDXVHLW FRXOGQRW GUDZDQ\W KLQJHOVHEXW
LW VHOI  LW V ³ , ´    1RZ  LW  SODFHV D GRW  DERY H W KH ³ , ´   +RZ HY HU  D GRW  V\ P EROL]HV W KH


0\DW W HP SW W RFRQYH\W KHP HDQLQJRIW KHZ RUG³$OOJHIKO´ DV*RUVOHEHQP HDQW LW W RW KH(QJOLVK
VSHDNLQJUHDGHU

 *HUP DQ IRU 0DU\   KHUH *RUVOHEHQ REYLRXVO\ DGGV W KH FRQQRW DW LRQ RI ³ P RW KHU RI *RG´  W R W KH
+HEUHZ³ 0LUM DP ´
 2PLWWHG


$U W KH$U 5XQHRU5XQHRIW KH6XQ

 2PLWWHG
 

FRQVFLRXVQHVV RI *RG DV ZH NQRZ 7KURXJK FLUFXODU P RW LRQV RI W KH VODW H SHQFLO W KH
FKLOGHQODUJHVW KHGRW XQW LOLW EHFRP HVDKHDGW KHVHDW RIFRQVFLRXVQHVVDQGNQRZOHGJH
7KHFKLOGORRNVDW W KHSLFW XUHDVW RQLVKHGDQGUHFRJQL]HVLW VHOILQLW :LW KW KHXUJHRID
VWLOOXQFRQVFLRXVUHFRJQLWLRQRIWKHWUDQVLWRU\QDWXUHRIH[LVWHQFHWKHFKLOGWKHQSODFHV
DERXQGDU\ FURVVRYHULW VHOIRYHUW KHOLQHDQGFURVVHVLW VHOIRXW  DOLQHVODQW LQJIURP OHIW
DERYH W R ULJKW  EHORZ ?  LW  LV W KH EDON  RU GHDW K UXQH  D OLQH VODQW LQJ IURP  OHIW  EHORZ W R
ULJKW DERYH LW LVW KHEDU RUOLIH UXQH

%RW KOLQHVW RJHW KHUIRUP W KHFURVVRILQFUHDVH;DQGOLHRQW RSRIW KH, V RU,  UXQH7KHQ

W KHFKLOGGLVFRY HU VW KDW IU RP W KDW Z KLFKZ DVFU RVVHGRXW W KDW Z KLFKZ DVGHDGDQHZ
DQG P RUH SHUIHFW  KXP DQ EHLQJ FDP H LQW R H[LVW HQFH DQG W KDW
W KHOLW W OHP DQKDGQRZDOVRDUP VDQGOHJV7KHOLW W OHP DQLVU H
ERUQ FRP SOHW H DQG W KH ³ P DQGHO´   LV FU HDW HG  P DQDV P HQV
P HQW XODP DQ0HQVFK *HUP DQIRU³ KXP DQEHLQJP DQ´  $ ³ 0DQGO´ +DJDOO
OLW W OH P DQ 5X Q H
%HIRUHXVLVW KH5XQHRIW KHKHDGRIW KH$HVLU +DJDO W KH5XQHRI*RGDQGW KH:RUOG
DV ZHOO DV RI W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ W KH ³ 0DQGO 5XQH´ EHFDXVH DV DERYH VR DUH W KH W KLQJV
EHORZ LW LVW KHKLJKDQGKRO\5XQHRIW KH+DJ $OOW KHRQHZKLFKLVFDOOHG³$OO +HJHU ´W KH
RQHZKRW DNHVFDUHRIHYHU\W KLQJSURW HFW VHYHU\W KLQJW KH$FKW  $OO HLJKW IROGXQLYHUVH 
W KH .DJ $OO W KH .XJ $OO W KH .XJHO     6SKHUH   EHFDXVH W KH +DJDO KDV W R EH YLHZHG LQ
VSDFH  7KH EUDQFKHV RI W KH +DJDO UHSUHVHQW  W KH IRUFHV RI W HQVLRQ W KDW  DUH LQ HIIHFW
ZLW KLQ W KH VSKHUH  7KLV LV W KH 5XQH RI W KH 5XQHV W KH QDNHG KXP DQ EHLQJ W KH P LUURU
LP DJH RI W KH KHDYHQV W KH KXP DQ LW VHOI GLYLGHG LQW R DERYH DQG EHORZ LQW R P DQ DQG
ZRP DQ LQW R VSLULW  *RG DQG P DW W HU 0D W H  ULD   M RLQHG W RJHW KHU XQLILFDW LRQ FUXFLIL[LRQ
W KHFURVV LQJKHDYHQDQGHDUW K\HVDQGQRGD\DQGQLJKW 

, Q W KH M DUJRQ RI W KH FDUSHQW HUV ZKLFK VW HP V IURP  W KH KDQGHG GRZQ W UDGLW LRQ RI W KH
> P HGLHYDO@  EXLOGLQJ JXLOGV DV GRHV )UHHP DVRQU\ W KH W HUP  ³ *HUP DQ 0DQ´  > 'HXW VFKH
0DQQ@  VW LOO GHQRW HV W KH ZDOO DQFKRU ZKLFK KDV SUHVHUYHG LW V +DJDO VKDSH DQG LV FDOOHG
³ OLW W OHP DQ´ > ³ 0DQGHO´ @ IRUVKRUW 

PDQUXQH 0DQQUXQH \EHUXQH :HLEUXQH +$*$// $//+$*

7KH QXP EHU RI P DQ DV LV ZHOO NQRZQ LV ILIW HHQ DQG LW V GLJLW V W RW DO VL[ W KH VH[XV W KH
VH[7KHP DJLFVTXDUHZLW KLW VQLQHVTXDUHVZKRVHW RW DOGLJLW VW RW DOILIW HHQDOVRIRUP V
W KH+DJDO³ 0DQGHO´ LIRQHH[W UDFW VLW VFURVV OLQHVDQGGLDJRQDOV7KHP DQ UXQHDOVRKDV
W KH QXP HULFDO YDOXH RI ILIW HHQ LQ W KH UXQH URZ  7KHVH FRUUHVSRQGHQFHV DUH QRW  VLP SOH
FRLQFLGHQFHEXW LQVW HDGIRUP SDUW RIW KHROGHVW NQRZOHGJHRIW KHVHFUHW VFLHQFHZKLFK
ZDVDQGW RW KLVGD\KDVUHP DLQHGW KH³ :LKLQHL´


³ P DQGO´DGLP LQXW LYHIRU³ 0DQQ´  P DQXVHGLQGLDOHFW V OLW W OHP DQ

)LQDOO\KHGHULYHGW KHVRXQGVVXIILFLHQW O\W RFRP HIURP W KH5XQH+DJDOW R.XJHO VSKHUH

$JDLQ*RUVOHEHQFRQQHFW VW KH9LUJLQ0DU\ +HEUHZ0LUM DP ZLW KW KH/DW LQZ RUGRIP DW W HU
 

7KH³ *HUP DQP DQ´

+DJ $OO5XQH 7KHP DJLFDOVTXDUHDV
DVP DVRQU\DQFKRU
³ P RW KHU´ RIW KH+DJ $OO5XQH

7KH+DJ $OO 5XQHDV

W HQVLRQ HQHUJLHVLQW KH
KH[DJUDP ZKLFKLVW KH
+HUDOGLFOLO\UHSUHVHQW LQJ :RUOGDVKW UHHDVKHUDOGLF
GLP HQVLRQDOLP DJHRI
W KHZRUOGDVKW UHH LP DJHLQDQFLHQW FRDW RIDUP V
DGRXEOHS\UDP LG

7KHVDP HV\P ERORIFRVP RVDQGP DQDSSHDUVVRP HZKDW KLGGHQLQW KHKHUDOGLFOLO\LQ

W KHVL[ SRLQW HGVW DULQW KHZRUOGDVK<JJGUDVLOW KHZRUOGW UHHRIZKLFKW KH(GGDW HOOVXV
ZLW K LW V W KUHH EUDQFKHV DQG W KUHH URRW V DW  ZKLFK W KH W KUHH 1RU QV W KH SRZHUV RI IDW H
UHVLGH $ULVLQJEHLQJSDVVLQJDZD\(YHQW KHJRGVZKLFKZHUHFRJQL]HDVOLIHIRUFHVLQ
W KHW UL XQLW \:RGDQ:LOLDQG:HKDUHVXEM HFW W RW KHVHIRUFHV:RGDQ:LOLDQG:HKFDQ
EH HTXDW HG ZLW K W KH W KUHH EUDQFKHV RI W KH W UHH RI OLIH ZKLFK DUH DOVR D V\P ERO RI RXU
UDFLDOQDW LRQDOLW \ W KUHHURRW VSHQHW UDW HGHHSO\GHHSLQW RQDW LYHVRLOW KUHHP DLQEUDQFKHV
VW UHW FK LQW R W KH EOXH VN\ RI W KH $U\DQ IXW XUH DQG W KH P LJKW \ W UXQN VSHDNV RI W KH OLIH
IRUFHVRIW KHSUHVHQW +RZHYHUW KHW KUHH1RUQVDUHFDOOHG8UGD9HUGDQGL6NXOG

7UDQVODW HGOLW HUDOO\IURP W KHODQJXDJHRIW KH(GGDW KHZRUGVP HDQ 8UGD W KHUHHYHU

VLQFHW KHRULJLQ> 8U@  9HUGDQGL FRP LQJLQW RH[LVW HQFH ZHUGHQLQ*HUP DQ ODVW LQJ
EHLQJ   6NXOG  W KH GHEW  REOLJDW LRQ W KH KDYLQJ W R HQJO W R VKDOO  VROOHQ  *HUP DQ
6FKXOG 

:HVHHFOHDUO\W KDW W KHUXQHVDUHDQLP DJHRI*RGLQW KHZRUOG7KH\DUHW KHZULW LQJRI

OLIH  2QO\ ODW HU GLG W KH 5XQHV GHJHQHUDW H LQW R W KH ZULW LQJ OHW W HUV RI DOO QDW LRQV  6LQFH
W LP HVLP P HP RULDOW KH\ZHUHSRVHGZDONHGDQGGDQFHG7KH\DUHW KHVSLULW XDO P DW HULDO
H[SUHVVLRQ RI W KH GLYLQH QDW XUH LQ W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ  7KHVH XQZU LW W HQ 5XQHV DUH W KH
DQFLHQW  $U\DQ GDQFHV W KDW  DUH H[SUHVVLRQV RI W KH ERG\ W R KRQRU W KH *RG LQ W KH /LJKW 
 

7KH\ DUH W KH GDQFH RI W KH VW DUV LQ W KH XQLYHUVH  :H FDQ LQIHU IURP  W KH GHVFULSW LRQV RI
7DFLW XVW KDW GDQFHUXQHV³ GDQFHURXQGV´ ZHUHDP RQJW KHROGHVW FXOW LFFXVW RP VRIW KH
$U\R *HUP DQV7KHGDQFHVZHUHGDQFHGLQW KHQXGHVLQFHQXGLW \LVVHOIHYLGHQW  QRUP DO
IRUW KHLQKHUHQW O\QREOHKXP DQEHLQJ*RG¶VH[DFW OLNHQHVV7KHERG\FORW KHGRQO\ZLW K
W KHVRXOLVFKDUP HGDJDLQVW W KHDW W DFNRIDOOORZO\DQGFRP P RQP LVLQW HUSUHW DW LRQV)RU
W KH SXUH DOO LV SXUH IRU W KH VZLQH DOO LV REVFHQH  7UXH VHQVH RI VKDP H LV QRW  ERXQG W R
FORW KLQJRUW RW KHLUUHP RYDO7KHH[SHULHQFHRIEHLQJµFORW KHGZLW KRQH¶VVHOI¶KDVEHHQ
ORVW W RW KHFUHDW XUHVRIW KLVFLYLOL]DW LRQW KDW LVZHDNLQYHUDFLW \%XW W KHSULP DOLQVW LQFW V
RI W KH SXUH $U\DQ VRXO ZKLFK KDV QRW KLQJ W R KLGH M ROW  XV RXW  RI RXU VOHHS DQG KHOS
LQZDUG ORRNLQJ GHFHQW  KXP DQV W R UHJDLQ W KHLU KHDOW K IRU W KHLU  ERGLHV DQG VRXOV \HDUQ
IRU OLEHUDW LRQ IURP  W KH SULVRQ RI FRQFHSW LRQV W KDW  DUH FKDUDFW HULVW LF RI LQIHULRU UDFHV 

, Q W KH $U\DQ UDFLDO SXUHVW  DQG P RUDOO\ KLJKHVW  GLVW ULFW  RI W KH (DUW K LQ 6ZHGHQ   ERW K
VH[HG EDW KH M RLQW O\ HQW LUHO\ LQ W KH QXGH  :KRHYHU JHW V FORW KHG ZLW K D EDW KLQJ VXLW
DP RQJW KHVHSXUHW KLQNLQJKXP DQVLVDVKDP HGRIKLV³ KXOO´ DQGJHW VULGRILW LQVHFUHW LQ
RUGHUW RDSSHDUDJDLQDVDKXP DQEHLQJDP RQJKXP DQEHLQJV

7KHP RUDOVW DQGLQJRIW KHDQFLHQW *HUP DQLFSHRSOHV LVZHOO NQRZ Q6RUHSRUW V&DHVDU
DERXW  W KHP  LQ KLV ³ *DOOLF ZDU´  FRP P HQW DULL GH EHOOXP  JDOOLFXP   ³ ZRP DQL]LQJ EHIRUH
W KHDJHRILVW KHJUHDW HVW VKDP H$QG\HW W KH\KDYHQRVHFUHW DERXW W KHGLIIHUHQFHV
RIW KHVH[HVEHFDXVHERW KVH[HVEDW KHM RLQW O\LQULYHUVDQGW KH\DUHW KHUHP DLQO\LQW KH
QXGH

7KH\SHUIRUP HGW KHLUGDQFHVLQW KHVW RQHDUUDQJHP HQW VLQW KHVW RQH FLUFOH DUUDQJHP HQW V
LQ  W K H &U RP  OHFK V  W K RVH Z K LFK  K DY H D FU RRN HG OD\ RX W   Z K LFK  Z HU H DU U DQ JHG I RU
W XUQDURXQG ZKLFK ZHUH DOVR FDOOHG OD\RXW V RI W KH ZRUP  ZKLFK P HDQW  W KH ZRUP  W KH
JUHDW ZRUP RIZLQW HUZKRFDW FKHVW KH6RODUYLUJLQVORZO\LQKLVVSLUDOORRSVNHHSVKHU
FDSW LYH LQ W KH ODE\ULQW K XQW LO W KH \RXQJ JRG RI VSULQJ W KH KHUR IUHHV KHU DQG NLOOV W KH
ZRUP  /HFK OD\W ROD\W KDW ZKLFKKDVEHHQODLGW KDW ZKLFKKDVEHHQVHW W KDW ZKLFK
ZDVSURW HFW HGLQVW RQHVZKLFKZDVODLGGRZQLQVW RQHVW KHVHW  XSRULJLQDOODZQDW XUDO
ODZZKLFKLVUHIOHFW HGLQW KHFRXUVHRIW KH6XQ +LP D OD\DLVW KHOD\RIW KHKHDYHQW KH
SRVLW LRQRIW KHKHDYHQW KHKHDYHQO\VW RQH FLUFOHOD\RXW  7KHVHORFDW LRQVDUHDOVRW KH
LQQXP HUDEOH 7UR\ FDVW OHV W KH W KUHH W XUQV D ZRUG W KDW  KDV UHODW LRQ ZLW K W KUHH 'UHL 
W XU Q P RG *HU P DQ ³ 'U HKHQ´  VW HS P RG *HU P DQ ³ 7U HW HQ´  GU LY H P RG *HU P DQ
³ 7UHLEHQ´  W R FDUU\ P RG *HUP DQ ³ 7UDJHQ´   7KH GDQFH LQ W KH ORFDW LRQV RI W KH ZRUP
KDVEHHQSHUIRUP HGLQW KHW KUHH VW HS W KUHH W RW XUQ P RG*HUP DQ³ 'UHL 'UHKHQ´ LQ
W KH UK\W KP  RI W KH ZDOW ]    7KH ORFDW LRQV RI W KH GDQFH W KH 7UR\ P RXQW DLQV W KH W KUHH
P RXQW DLQVDUHW KH$U\DQW HP SOHVRUKRXVHVRI*RG$QLQLW LDW HDQ$U\DQD³ &KULVW RV´
W HDFKHVW KDW E\W HOOLQJXV ³ <RXDUHW KHW HP SOHVRIW KHOLYLQJ*RG´DQGKHVSHDNVRIW KH
W HP SOHZKLFKKHFDQW HDUGRZQLQRQHGD\DQGUHEXLOGLQW KUHH DQGHP SKDW LFDOO\DGGV
W R LW  DQ DVVXP SW LRQ W KDW  ZDV QRW  IRXQG LQ W KH ZRUGV RI W KH 6RQ RI *RG  W KDW  KH GRHV
 FI7KH0DVNVRI2GLQ :LVGRP RIW KH$QFLHQW 1RUVHW UDQVODW HG%\(OVD %ULW D7LW FKHQHOO

3DVDGHQD&$ 7KHRVRSKLFDO8QLYHUVLW \3UHVV
 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 

QRW  P HDQ W KH W HP SOH W KDW  ZDV EXLOW  Z LW K KDQGV DQG VW RQHV LQ ³ -HUXVDOHP ´ EXW  W KH
W HP SOH W KH +DJ DOO RI KLV ERG\  :H DOORZHG W KDW  W KH GXVW  RI W KH GHDG OHW W HU IDLW K ZDV
W KURZQXSRQRXUVRXOW KDW ZDVNQRZLQJRIW KHOLJKW LQW KHROGHQW LP HV

, IW KHW HP SOHLVRXUOLYLQJERG\W KHQRXUERG\DQGW KH'LYLQHGDQFH ³ 5HLJHQ´ ZLW KLQLW 

W KLV P RYLQJ ³ 5HJHQ´  W KLV 5K\W KP  W KLV 5LW XDO LV W KH W HP SOH  7KDW  ZKLFK LV VDFUHG
RUGHULQJLW VHOI'LYLQHO\ 2UG 6XQ SRLQW LVUHYHDOLQJLW VHOILQW KHUK\W KP LQW KHULW XDO

³ 2QO\ ZKHQ GDQFLQJ ,  DP  FDSDEOH RI W DONLQJ DERXW  W KH SDUDEOHV RI W KH KLJKHVW  W KLQJV´
1LHW ]VFKH

(LJKW HHQ FRVP LF 5XQHV 'LYLQH RQHV W KH\ DUH FRP LQJ IURP  W KH ³ FKLHI W DONHU´  W KH $OO
)DW KHU ZKR W HDFKHV W KH 8U 5XQHV OLNH HLJKW HHQ W RQHV RI W KH VSKHUHV ZKLFK VRXQG LQ
W KH FRVP RV  $Q DW RP  RI K\GURJHQ RI W KH OLJKW HVW  P DW W HU VR W R VD\ VW DQGLQJ RQ W KH
HGJH RI QDW XUH LV FRP SRVHG RI  P RQDGV    7KHVH  5XQHV RI W KH )XW KDUN LH W KH
DOSKDEHW RIW KH5XQHVDQGDOVRW KHNH\W RW KHNQRZOHGJHRIW KHFKRUHRJUDSKLFGDQFH
UHODW HGFKDUDFW HULVW LFRIW KH5XQLFSRVLW LRQV7KHOHQJW KRIW ZRVW ULQJVRIHTXDOGLDP HW HU
W KHVRXQGRIZKLFKGLIIHUVE\DFKURP DW LFVHP L W RQHLV RIW KHLUOHQJW K2XUDQFHVW RUV
OLNHO\ KDYH NQRZQ W KHVH QXP EHUV RI DFRXVW LF YLEUDW LRQV RI W KH W RQHV EDVHG RQ LQQHU
LP DJLQDW LRQ   6W LOO LQ RXU GD\V HYHU\ SHUVRQ QHHGV W R NQRZ W KDW  ZKR ZDQW V W R W XQH D
KDUS RU D JXLW DU    /DW HU LQ ZULW W HQ GRZQ DQG GDUNHQHG P \VW HULHV W KH KDUS SOD\ LQJ
YLUJLQEHFRP HVDQDVW \GHP RQLFEHLQJRXW RIW KH³ KDUIXLM D´ HP HUJHVW KH+DUS\$P RQJ
W KHVH +DU SLHV DSSHDU V RQH Z LW K W KH QDP H RI 3RGDU JH  Z KLFK LQ *U HHN  P HDQV W KH
³ VSOHQGRU OLTXLG RQH´  3RGDUJH   )XW KDUN LV W KH IRUP  RI W KH ZRUG IRU W KH 1RUGLF 5XQH
$OSKDEHW  W KDW  EHFDP H ³ *UHHN´    W KH ZRUG P HDQLQJ W KH )XW KDUN RI W KH 5XQHV ZKLFK LV
IRUP HG DFFRUGLQJ W KH ILUVW  5XQH V\P EROV

%XW  ZLW K W KLV ZH VHL]HG W KH RSSRUW XQLW \ W R SXW  W KLV ORVW  ZLVGRP  LQ IURQW  RI W KH H\HV RI
W KH VHHNHU DQG W R VW LP XODW H KLP  W R FRRSHUDW H LQ LQFUHDVLQJ W KLV NQRZOHGJH  2XU LQW HQW
VKRXOGEHDQDW W HP SW W RJLYHDQLGHDRIW KHP DJQLW XGHDQGJUHDW QHVVDQGLP P HGLDW HQHVV
RIW KH$U\DQZRUOGYLHZW KH8U YLVLRQW KDW ZHKDYHIURP ELUW KW KH8U YLVLRQW KDW VKRXOG
EHHYHU\UHOLJLRQ%XW ZKHUHFRXOGZHH[SHULHQFHVXFKDUHOLJLRQ"7KHW LP HLVULJKW IRULW 
DQG W KDW  RQO\ IRU D VKRUW  SHULRG RI W LP H W R UHW DNH W KH *RG H[SHULHQFH RI RXU UDFH
ZKHUHYHU LW  ZDV W DNHQ DZD\ IURP  XV E\ ZD\ RI IDVW  W DONLQJ FKHDW LQJ E\ ILUH DQG E\
VZRUG  2XU UHVHDUFK W KHQ ZLOO QRW  P DNH W UXH UHOLJLRQ OHVV LP SRUW DQW  DV IDU DV LW  KDV
W DNHQW KHVKDSHRIFRQIHVVLRQVLQRXUSUHVHQW W LP HEXW LW ZLOOHQULFKLW LQ\HW XQVXVSHFW HG
ZD\V2QO\IURP W KHKLJKHVW ZLVGRP RI$U\DQ8U UHOLJLRQFDQHP HUJHDUHQHZLQJRIDOO

 2PLWWHG
 

VHFW V DQG &KXUFKHV EHFDXVH W KLV 8U UHOLJLRQ DORQH KDV JLYHQ W KHP  FRQW HQW  DQG VKDSH
, W LVW KH8U P RW KHULQW RKHUZRP EDOOFXOW XUHVUHW XUQLQW KHFRXUVHRIW KHW LP H F\FOHVRI
W KHZRUOG1RW KLQJLVFRLQFLGHQFH(YHU\W KLQJLVIDW H

$VP LFURFRVP VZHDUHGHSHQGHQW IURP W KHJUHDW LQILQLW HHYHQW VLQW KHP DFURFRVP EXW
ZH FDQ DGG D ORW  W R W KDW  E\ RXU RZQ YROLW LRQ VR W KDW  ZH FDQ JU DVS W KH P HDQLQJ RI RXU
SU HVHQW   RI RXU  SU HVHQW  OLIH   $ KXP DQ OLIH SDVVHV RIW HQ W RR IDVW  LQ W KH HW HU QDO RI
UHLQFDUQDW LRQVZLW KRXW KDYLQJIRXQGW KHFRQQHFW LRQW RW KHHQHU JLHVRIW KHFRVP LFZLOORI
LW VW LP H

$IW HU ZH KDYH VKRZQ W KH 5XQHV RI W KH EHJLQQLQJ DQG D IHZ KLHURJO\SKV ZH KDYH W R
FRQW LQXHZLW KW KHVHW KLQJVLQRUGHUW RJLYH\RXDFRP SOHW HSLFW XUH

7KH 5XQLF DOSKDEHW  RU W KH 5XQLF )XW KDUN FRQVLVW V RI  RU  ODW HU P RUH V\P EROV
)ROORZLQJ2GLQ¶V5XQHVRQJZHFDQGHW HUP LQHLW DVIROORZV
7KH  $OSKD EH W  RI W KH  5XQH V
RU  W KH  5XQH  )XW KRU N K RI W KH  (GGD
FDOOHG)XW KRUNIROORZLQJW KHQDP HVRIW KHILUVW VHYHQOHW W HUV

1DP H
1XP EHU

1DP H
1XP EHU
/LNH W KH OHW W HUV LQ P DQ\ RW KHU DOSKDEHW V HDFK RQH RI W KH 5XQHV KDV D VSHFLILF QDP H
ZKLFK EHLQJ D ZRUG ZLW K RQH V\OODEOH LV OLNHZLVH D URRW  ZRUG D JHUP  ZRUG RU DQ 8U
ZRUG7KH5XQHQDP HVZLW KW ZRV\OODEOHVDUHQRW UHDOO\DQH[FHSW LRQW RW KLVUXOH

)URP W KHVHQDP HVEHLQJRIRQHV\OODEOHIROORZVW KDW W KHVHOHW W HUUXQHVZHUHRQFHSDUW V

RI D ZRUG  RU V\OODEOH VFULSW  EHIRUH W KH\ EHFDP H D OHW W HU VFULSW  

7KH ROGHVW  5XQHV DUH NQRZQ W R XV IURP  'ROP HQ W RP EV IURP  SRW W HU \ VKDUGV RI W KH
6W RQH $JH DQG IURP  EURQ]H ILQGV  :LW QHVV IRU W KHLU SUHVHQFH VW LOO LQ KLVW RULF W LP HV ZH
ILQGZLW K7DFLW XVDQG&DHVDU7KHODW W HUIRXQGDVFULSW ZLW KW KH+HOYHW LDQVZKLFKP XVW
KDYH EHHQ VLP LODU W R W KH ³ *UHHN´  RQH DQG W KHQ ZH ILQG W KHP  RQ QXP HURXV P HP RULDO
VW RQHVRQREM HFW VDQGRQZULW W HQW KLQJVRIDOONLQGV

$VZ DVW KHFDVHZ LW KW KH3KRHQLFLDQDOSKDEHW IURP Z KLFKW KH*UHHN$OSKDEHW RULJLQDW HG7KH
*UHHN$OSKDEHW NHSW VW LOOP RVW RIW KHRULJLQDO3KRHQLFLDQQDP HV2YHUVRP HGHW RXUVW KHSUH 5XQLF
DOSKDEHW VLQ1RUW KHUQ, W DO\HP HUJHGRIZ KLFKZ HNQRZ VHYHUDODQGZ KLFKKDYHP RUHEDVLVW KDQ
D IHZ VFUDW FKHV DQG FURVVHV RQ 6FDQGLQDYLDQ URFN ZDOOV W KDW  P D\  RU P D\ QRW  EH 5XQHV  7KH
XQHTXLYRFDOKLVW RULFW LP HOLQHRIW UXH5XQHGRFXP HQW VFRP LQJIURP W KHVRXW KW RW KH1RUW KVHHP VW R
SURYH W KLV SRLQW   , Q IDFW  W KH QDP HV RI W KH OHW W HUV SRLQW  W R W KHLU XVHDVLGHRJUDP VSULRUW RW KHLU
XVHDVV\OODEOHV
 5XQH7DEOH DFFRUGLQJW R:HUQHUY%ORZ
2IFRP SOHW HRUDOP RVW FRP SOHW HFRP P RQ*HUP DQLFOLVW 
LQJV RI DOSKDEHW V Z H KDYH KHU H  W KDW  DU H HVSHFLDOO\
LP SRUW DQW ZKLFKKDYHDQDOP RVW FRP SOHW HP XW XDOLGHQ
W LW \ RI W KH V\P EROV DQG ZKLFK DOVR VKRZ W KHLU VXEGLYL
VLRQ LQW R W KUHH SDUW V VRQJ7KH5XQHV\P EROVRIW KLV%DYDULDQDOSKDEHW ZKLFKKDV
   W KH JROGHQ EUDFW HDW  RI 9DGVW HQD LQ 6ZHGHQ
   W KH VLOYHU EXFNOH RI &KDUQD\ LQ %XUJXQG\
   W KH .\OIHU VW RQH LQ 6ZHGHQ
 W KHNQLIHLQW KH7KHP VHZLW KW KH$QJORVD[RQ)XW KDUN
ZKLFK W R ZKLFK YDULRXV V\P EROV IRU YRZHOV KDYH EHHQ
DGGHG
   FRP SOHW HV W KLV $QJORVD[RQ DOSKDEHW  ZKLFK LV FRGL
ILHG LQ W KH DQJORVD[RQ 5XQH VRQJ
   W KH  VW DQ]DV RI W KH 1RUGLF 5XQH VRQJ
   W KH \RXQJHVW  1RUGLF IXW KDUN
2IW KH%DYDULDQ5XQHVRIW KH+UDEDQXV0DXUXVZKRGLHVLQ
, KDYHSXW W KH5XQHQDP HVLQW RW KH5XQHFORFNEHKLQG
W KHSDUW LW LRQOLQHZKLOHDERYHLW DUHW KHQDP HVRIW KH1RUGLF
UXQHVRQJDQGEHORZW KHP DUHW KRVHRIW KH$QJORVD[RQ5XQH
DOUHDG\EHHQDGDSW HGW RW KH5RP DQVHTXHQFHDUHYHU\P XFK
DGRUQHG EXW  W KHLU EDVLF VKDSHV DUH VW LOO YHU\ REYLRXV  %H
VLGHVW KHQDP HVW KDW KDYHEHHQLQVHUW HGLQW RW KH5XQHFORFN
W KHIROORZLQJKDYHEHHQDOVRP HQW LRQHG IRU.JLON OLO\  W KH
.XQ5XQHKDVEHHQHOLP LQDW HGW RP DNHSODFHIRUW KH³ F´SHUF
IRU³ S´FKRQIRU³ J´KDODFKIRU³ [´ DQG]LXIRU³ ]´
7KH9LHQQHVH5XQHDOSKDEHW VKRZVW KHVDP HVKDSHVDVW KH
%DYDULDQLIZHLJJQRUHDIHZVOLJKW FKDQJHV$OVRW KH&RGH[
/DW LQXV  D P DQXVFULSW  LQ 0XQLFK KDV W KH 5RP DQ VH
TXHQFHRIW KH$OSKDEHW DQGDOP RVW HQW LUHO\W KHVKDSHVRIW KH

$QJORVD[RQ 5XQH VRQJ
 

, Q W KH IROORZLQJ ,  VKRZ W KH SLFW XUHV RI D IHZ UXQLF GRFXP HQW V RI W KH ROGHVW  W LP H  7KH
ODVW RQHLVD5XQHULQJRIODW HUW LP HSRVVLEOHW KW RW KFHQW XU\FH7KHVHDUHH[DP SOHV
W KDW JLYHDOLYLQJQRW LRQRIW KHFRKHVLRQRIW KHUXQLFW UDGLW LRQW KURXJKDERXW \HDUV
HYHQLIW KHLQGLYLGXDOV\P EROVZHUHVXEM HFW W RVRP HFKDQJHVVXFKDVZHFDQREVHUYHLQ
RXUV\P EROVW KDW ZHXVHIRUZULW LQJLQYHU\VKRUW SHULRGVRIW LP H

7KHSLFW XUHVEHORZVKRZSHEEOHVIURP W KHFDYH

RI 0DV G¶$]LO RQW R ZKLFK 5XQHV DUH SDLQW HG
DQGVW UDQJHV\P EROVW KDW DUHVLP LODUW ROHW W HUV
7K H U HVHDU FK HU  3L HW W H I R X Q G  W K R VH D I HZ
GHFDGHV DJR LQ W KH 1RUW KHUQ 3\UHQHHV

7K H VFL HQ FH R I  W K H VK R Y HO V FR X Q W V W K HVH

GRFXP HQW V W R W KH ROGHVW  VKRZV RI W KH KXP DQ
VSLULW RQW KH(DUW K%XW LQW KHZRUOGYLHZW KDW
LV SUHVHQW O\ DFFHSW HG E\ VFLHQFH SHRSOH FDQ
G R Q RW K LQ J  Z LW K  W K HVH VW U DQ J H HDU O\
SKHQRP HQD DQG SHRSOH GRXEW  W KH SXUSRVH RU SDLQW HGSHEEHOVRI0DV G$]LO
LQW HQW RIVXFKXQGRXEW HGO\YLVLEOHZLW QHVVHVRI  \HDUVROG
KXP DQ DFW LYLW \  DFFRUGLQJ W R ( 3LHW W H
0RVW KDYHW KHIDOVHRSLQLRQW KDW W RROVDUHDFKLHYHP HQW VRIKXP DQHYROXW LRQW RDKLJKHU
OLIH%XW W KH\IRUJRW W KDW W KHKXP DQRIKLJKVW DQGLQJZKROLYHGLQDSHUIHFW FOLP DW HDQG
ZKRZDVFRQQHFW HGW RQDW XUHODFNHGQRW KLQJW KDW KHQHHGHGIRUP LOOLRQVRI\HDUV7KLV
ZDVVREHFDXVHKHOLYHGLQ³ SDUDGLVH´ZKHUHKHKDGDOOIRRGDQGDOOSURW HFW LRQEHFDXVH
LQSDUDGLVHW KHUHZHUHQRZLOGDQLP DOVW KDW FRXOGEHDGDQJHUIRUKXP DQVEHFDXVHKH
KLP VHOIGLGQRW KXUW W KHP   , W ZDVFRP P RQW UXFHDQG*HQHVLVVW LOOKDVDP HP RU\RILW
DQGVRGRHVW KHROGVHFUHW GRFW ULQH7KHKXP DQEHLQJVW RRGRXW VLGHRIW KHVW UXJJOHIRU
H[LVW HQFH DQG KH KDG P DJLFDO P HDQV RI GHIHQVH W R VW XQ DQG W R EHGD]]OH    :H VKRXOG
UHDG W KH IDLU\ W DOHV GLOLJHQW O\ W R ILQG SURRI IRU W KDW     7KHVH ZHUH ZL]DUGV DQG IDLULHV
ZKLFKZHUHFDSDEOHW RGRHYHU\W KLQJZKRUXOHVRYHUW KHDQLP DOVRIW KHIRUHVW EHFDXVH
W KH\VW LOOGLGQRW HDW W KHP  
2QO\ FROG FOLP DW H VKRUW QHVV RI IRRG DQG ZLW K W KLV W KH KXQW  IRU  DQLP DOV GURYH KXP DQV
IURP W KHSDUDGLVH+XP DQVVDQNGRZQDQGGLGQRW ULVHDJDLQZLW KW KHSHUIHFW LRQRIW KHLU
W HFKQLFDO DLGV W KDW  EHFDP H QHFHVVDU\ W R VXUYLYH W KH VW UXJJOH IRU W KHLU H[LVW HQFH  7KLV

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG

6LF  /DW LQIRU 5LJKW VR
 2PLWWHG

 

ZH KDYH W R FRQVLGHU VR W KDW  ZH GRQ¶W  JHW  W R ZURQJ FRQFOXVLRQV DERXW  W KH VLW XDW LRQ RI
KXP DQNLQG LQ HDUOLHU HUDV    7R EODP H LV W KH LQFDSDELOLW \ RI RXU VFLHQW LILF P HW KRG RI
UHVHDUFK W KDW  GRHV QRW  KDYH NQRZOHGJH RI W KH VHFUHW  GRFW ULQH   W KDW  ZDV KDQGHG GRZQ
W R XV  :KHQHYHU W KH SLOODUV RI VFLHQFH JRW  W R NQRZ W KHVH SUHFRQGLW LRQV W KH\ ZRXOG
H[SHULHQFHDQLQFUHGLEOHXSVZLQJLQW KHLUZRUN5HJDUGOHVVRIDQLQFUHGLEOHLQFUHDVHRI
W HFKQLFDOP HDQVZHDUHRQDUHJUHW W DEO\GHHSVSLULW XDOOHYHORILQVLJKW ZKLFKP DNHVXV
LQFDSDEOHW ROLYH³ DVKXP DQVDP RQJKXP DQV´ LQZD\VW KDW KDYHVRP HKXP DQGLJQLW \

3UHKLVW RULF5XQHLQVFULSW LRQLQ&UHW H

5XQHVRIHTXDOW \SHW KDW DSSHDULQW KH

$V\OLHQ " DVZHOODVLQW KH'ROP HVRI3RUW XJDO
$SSUR[LP DW HO\ \HDUVDJR

5XQHVFULSW RQDURFNLQ6W lUNLQG2VW JRW ODQG6ZHGHQ9HU\DQFLHQW VKDSHV

$FFRUGLQJW RW KHORFDW LRQRIW KHDUW LIDFW ZHFDQHVW LP DW HDQDJHRIVHYHUDOW KRXVDQG\HDUV


 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

6LQFH W LP H LP P HP RU LDO DOO W HFKQLFDO SRW HQW LDO LV FRQW DLQHG Z LW K LQ W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ
EHJLQQLQJ IURP  W KH P RVW  SULP LW LYH VW RQH FKLVHO DOO W KH ZD\ W R W KH ODUJHVW  SRZHU SODQW 
7KHVH DU H QRW  DFKLHYHP HQW V DFFRU GLQJ W R Z KLFK Z H FRXOG M XGJH W KH P RU DOV RI W KH
KXP DQEHLQJVLQFHKHKDGKLJKHVW W HFKQRORJLFDODFKLHYHP HQW VDOUHDG\LQP XFKHDUOLHU
W LP HV7KH5RP DQVVW RRGEHQHDW KW KH*HUP DQLFSHRSOHVEHFDXVHW KHP DM RUSDUW RILW V
SRSXODW LRQKDGW ROLYHLQKRXVHVRIVL[DQGVHYHQVW RULHVDOUHDG\W KHQ7KH*HUP DQZDV
DERYHW KH5RP DQEHFDXVHKHGLGQRW NQRZD³ VRFLDO´ TXHVW LRQDQGEHFDXVHKHZDVVR
SHUIHFW  LQ ERG\ DQG VSLULW  W KDW  KH KDG QR QHHG IRU DQ DUW LVW LF DQG DUW LILFLDO FRS\ RI W KH
KXP DQ EHLQJ VLQFH KH KLP VHOI ZDV D SLHFH RI DUW  RQ VSLULW  VRXO DQG ERG\  &DQ ZH
XQGHUVW DQGW KLV"1DP HO\W KDW W KH*UHHNVFUHDW HG DQGKDGW RFUHDW H W KHP DJQLILFHQW
ERGLHV RI W KHLU  JRGV  EHFDXVH W KHVH ERGLHV Z HU H DOU HDG\  IDGLQJ DZ D\  IU RP  W KHP 
7KHU HIRU H W KH DQFLHQW  *RW KV DQG ³ -HZ V´  *RU VOHEHQ¶V TXRW HV  P DGH QR SLFW XU H DQG
LP DJH RI W KHLU JRGV RI W KH 'LYLQH EHLQJ DQG RI W KHP VHOYHV W KHLU LP DJH EHFDXVH W KH\
W KHP VHOYHVZHUHW KHLP DJHRIW KHLU*RGLQIOHVKEORRGDQGVSLU LW 

+RXVH5XQHLQFOD\VXSSRVHGO\IURP W KHEURQ]HDJHIRXQGLQW KHW RP EFLW \

RI$OED/RQJDQHDU5RP H
 

7KLVGLVFRYHU\LVLP SRUW DQW EHFDXVHRILW VRULJLQ$OED/RQJDLVW KHROGHVW FLW \RI/DW LXP

DQGLVFRQVLGHUHGW REHW KHP RW KHUFLW \RI5RP H, QDQ\FDVHLW ZDVW KHFDSLW DORIW KDW
UHJLRQ /DW LXP EHIRUH5RP H7KHXUQLVFRYHUHGZLW K5XQHV\P EROVZKLFKVHHP LQJO\
LQGLVDUUD\DW DILUVW JOLP SVHVW LOOKDYHDUHFRJQL]DEOHVW UXFW XUH6W UDQJHLVW KHLQGLIIHUHQFH
RI DUFKDHRORJLVW V ZKHQ FRQIURQW HG ZLW K REYLRXV ZULW W HQ GRFXP HQW V RI W KLV W \SH  $W
OHDVW W KH\VKRXOGKDYHZRQGHUHGZKDW UHODW LRQW KHVHV\P EROVKDGW RW KH/DW LQDOSKDEHW 
LQW KHUHDOP RIZKLFKW KHVHVW UDQJHKLHURJO\SKVZHUHIRXQG, QGHHGW KHVHV\P EROVDUH
P XFK ROGHU W KDQ W KH /DW LQ DOSKDEHW   RW KHUZLVH ZH ZRXOG UHFRJQL]H VRP H UHODW LRQ  %XW
W KLVXUQKDVXQP LVW DNDEOH5XQHV\P EROV  ZKLFKFDQRQO\EHUHDGZLW KW KH1RUGLF5XQH
DOSKDEHW 7KHUHZHILQGDOVRDQXP EHURIVR FDOOHGV\P EROVRIVDOYDW LRQZKLFKZHFDQ
VW LOO ILQG LQ *HUP DQ\ LQ W KH 0LGGOH $JHV LQ DSSURSULDW H XVH  7KHUHIRUH ZH FRXOG SURYH
W KDW  FOHDU 5XQH V\P EROV KDYH EHHQ XVHG LQ , W DO\ VHYHUDO W KRXVDQG \HDUV EHIRUH W KH
&RP P RQ (UD DV ZHOO DV HYHU\ZKHUH HOVH RQ W KH (DUW K  , I QRZ W KHVH V\P EROV KDYH
GLVDSSHDUHG HYHU\ZKHUH FRP SOHW HO\ DOO W KH ZD\ W R W KHLU ODW H XVH LQ W KH 1RUGLF RULJLQDO
KRP HODQGRIW KH$U\DQVW KHQZHFDQFRQFOXGHW KDW W KHUHZDVW KHLURULJLQDQGW KHRULJLQ
RIW KHLURULJLQDW RUV

(YHU\ DUFKDHRORJLVW  VKRXOG EH GUDZQ W R LQW HUSUHW  W KLV YHU\ ROG ZULW W HQ GRFXP HQW   %XW
W KLVZLOOEHGLIILFXOW EHFDXVHEHVLGHV5XQHVQRRW KHUVFULSW FDQRIIHUDQ\FOXHVDVW RW KH
P HDQLQJ RI W KLV GRFXP HQW  

%XW  ZKHUH DVK XUQV LQ W KH VKDSH RI KRXVHV KDYH EHHQ P DGH W R ³ W DON´  ZLW K W KH KHOS RI
W KH DQFLHQW  5XQH DUW  W KHUH SHRSOH FHUW DLQO\ GLG QRW  P LVV RXW  RQ SXW W LQJ W KHVH VDFUHG
V\ P EROV DOVR RQ W KH KRXVHV RI W KH OLY LQJ SHRSOH DQG W KDW  LQ D Z D\  W KDW  FRXOG EH
XQGHUVW RRG, IW KDW KDSSHQHGDOUHDG\GXULQJW KHEURQ]HDJHW KHQLW EHFRP HVYHU\FOHDU
W KDW  W KLV 5XQH DU W  Z DV VLP SO\   W DN HQ RY HU  ODW HU  LQ W KH Z RRGHQ I U DP HZ RU N  RI W KH
FRQVW UXFW LRQ P HW KRG RI KDOI W LP EHULQJ DQG W KDW  W KHUH W KH SRVLW LRQV RI W KH EHDP V ZHUH
P DGH LQ VXFK D Z D\ W KDW  W KH\ Z HUH VSHDNLQJ RXW  5XQLF P HVVDJHV

7KH 1RUGLF *HUP DQLF $U\DQRULJLQ RIW KLV 5XQLF VFULSW  W KHUHIRU H LV SU RYHQ DQG DOVR LW V
SURSHUW \RIEHLQJW KHROGHVW VFULSW FDQQRW EHGHQLHGEHFDXVHZHILQGW KHP DOUHDG\RQ
VKDUGVRIW KH6W RQH$JHZKLFKDFFRUGLQJW RW KHSUHYDOHQW RSLQLRQLVW KHROGHVW FXOW XUDO
W LP H RI KXP DQNLQG EXW  ZKLFK ODW W HU DVVXP SW LRQ LV DQ HUURU  %HFDXVH DERYH D VFULSW
ZRXOGEHW KHSRVVLELOLW \RIDFRP P XQLFDW LRQEH\RQGVSDFHDQGW LP HZLW KRXW VFULSW LH
VRP H NLQG RI VSLULW XDO VFULSW  ZKLFK LV TXLW H SRVVLEOH   D NLQG RI UHDGLQJ RI W KRXJKW V LQ
W LP H OHVVDQGVSDFH OHVVLQILQLW \%XW ZHZLOOQRW GHDOZLW KW KLVTXHVW LRQKHUH

:H SUHVXP H W KDW  LI DQ DUW  VXFK DV ZULW LQJ ZLW K 5XQHV RULJLQDW HV LQ D VSHFLILF ORFDW LRQ
W KDW  W KLV DUW  ZLOO HYHQW XDOO\ FRP H EDFN W R W KLV ORFDW LRQ ZKHQ RXW VLGH DQG IDU DZD\ W KH
FDUULHUVRIW KHVHSUDFW LFHVGLHRXW 7KHLGHDVW D\VZLW KW KHKXP DQLQKLVLQYHQW LRQKLV
UDFH DQG KLV QDW LRQ  7KH 5XQH FLUFOH KDV SURYHQ W R EH D FRVP LF FU\VW DO LQ LW V GHVLJQ
P DW KHP DW LFDOO\ VR W R VD\  )URP  W KLV FRVP LF FU\VW DO DOO RW KHU VFULSW V DUH GHGXFW LRQV LI


 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

ZH ZLVK W R DVVXP H D ODZ W KDW  W KH RULJLQDO W KLQJ LV DOZD\V W KH VLP SOH W KLQJ  1R RW KHU
VFULSW  FDQ EH UHGXFHG W R VXFK D JHRP HW ULFDO IRUP XOD  7KH +DJ $OO 5XQH LV DQ 8U JO\SK
W KDW ZDVLQVFULEHGLQW RDKH[DJRQ, W LVDQ8U V\P ERODQ8U VKDSHDQ8U FU\VW DODQGLW
P RFNVW KHFODLP W KDW LW ZRXOGEHDQLQYHQW LRQLQW KHRUGLQDU\VHQVH/LNHODQJXDJHLW LV
UHYHODW LRQ QRW  HYROXW LRQ 

$YHVVHOZLW KXQXVXDOVKDSHZKLFKDUFKDHRORJLVW VUHJDUG

ZLW KRXW  SURRI DV D GUXP  KDV EHHQ IRXQG LQ %HUQEXUJ
DQGLW ZDVFRQVLGHUHGW REHORQJW RW KHODW HU6W RQH$JH
Z KLFK FRQVLGHU HG  %&( E\  RXU  VFKRODU V Z DV
Z D\  W RR ODW H   7KDW  LW  KDV DOVR XQP LVW DN DEOH 5XQLF
V\P EROV GHVHUYHV RXU VSHFLDO DW W HQW LRQ  6FKXFKKDUGW
GRHVQRW P HQW LRQW KHV\P EROVDW DOOEXW LW LVLP SRVVLEOH
QRW  W R QRW LFH W KHP   $FFRUGLQJ W R KLP  6FKXFKKDUGW
W KH5XQHVFRP HIURP W KHUHJLRQRIW KH%ODFN6HDZKHUH
DFFRUGLQJW RKLP W KH*RW KVW RRNW KHP RYHUSDUW O\IURP
W KH VFULSW  RI W KH *UHHNV DQG LQ SDUW  IURP  W KH VFULSW  RI
W K H 5RP DQ V   $VVX P LQ J  VX FK  W K LQ J V  LW  LV HDV\  W R
RYHUORRN 5XQHV HYHQ LI W KH\ DSSHDU P DVVLYHO\ SULQW HG
LQKLVERRNV
$UW LIDFW IURP %HUQEXUJ
, P SRU W DQW  LV W KH W LP H IU DP H   +HU H Z H ILQG EU RQ]H
VZRUGV RQ URFN HQJUDYLQJV ZKLFK ZH KDYH W R W LP H DV
FRP LQJ IU RP  EHIRU H W KH 6W RQH $JH   7KHU HIRU H RXU
GHILQLW LRQV RI W LP HV DQG DJHV ZKLFK LQ JHQHUDO LV ZD\
W RR VKRUW  QHHGV W R EH H[DP LQHG RYHU DQG FRUUHFW HG
HVSHFLDOO\ZKHQZHFRQVLGHUW KH*HUP DQLFFXOW XUHV

&OLIIFDUYLQJVLQ/HRQKDUGEHUJ6ZHGHQ


 2PLWWHG
 

$JROGULQJZLW KXQXVXDOO\EHDXW LIXOHGJHVKDVEHHQIRXQGDW .|VOLQLQ3RP P HUQDQGLW

KDV 5XQHV RQ LW  DOVR D VZDVW LND DQG W KHQ D V\P ERO RI W KH 7ULQLW \ DQG D IHZ DQLP DO
P DVN V

7KH5XQLFLQVFULSW LRQFRQVLVW VRIW ZRSDUW V $6, * KRRNZLW KDGRXEOHORZHUOLQHDQG

W KH5XQHV)$/$)85LQVHTXHQFH

:H FRXOG UHDG LW  )/8 EXW  DOVR UHYHUVHG 8/) EHFDXVH W KH 5XQHV ZHUH ZULW W HQ IURP  W KH
OHIW DVZHOODVIURP W KHULJKW DQGYHUW LFDOO\IURP W RSW RERW W RP 

7KH )$ FRXOG DOVR EH D UHYHUVHG 26 $  , Q DQ\ FDVH LW  LV GLIILFXOW  W R UHFRQVW UXFW  W KH
P HDQLQJ RI W KLV LQVFULSW LRQ EHFDXVH ZH VW LOO NQRZ YHU\ OLW W OH DERXW  W KH KDELW V W KRVH
SHRSOHKDGZKHQZULW LQJ%XW ZLW KW KHFRP ELQHGHIIRUW RIDOOZKRVHHNZHZLOOVXFFHHG
LQ FUHDW LQJ FODULW \ LQ W KLV UHVSHFW  W KHUH LV QR GRXEW  DERXW  W KDW     :H FDQ DVVXP H W KDW
W KHVH5XQHVKDYHQRW M XVW W KHSODLQP HDQLQJRIW KHOHW W HUVEXW W KDW DOVRW KHROGH[SDQGHG
P HDQLQJV RI 5XQHV ZKLFK ZH KDYH  W R FRQVLGHU DV ZHOO ZKHQ ZH DW W HP SW  D VROXW LRQ  
8/) RU 2/8 RU )/8 ZKHQ UHDG GRHV QRW  KDYH DQ\ P HDQLQJ HYHQ QRW  M RLQHG ZLW K W KH
V\P ERO IRU YLFW RU\  

:H KDYH W R JR W KH SDW K W KDW  DW W ULEXW HV W R W KH 5XQHV D GHHSHU P HDQLQJ EDVHG RQ W KHLU
HVRW HULF V\P EROLVP 

7KHQ ZH ZRXOG JHW  W KH LGHD RI YLFW RU\ DQG VDOYDW LRQ IURP  W KH 6DO RU 6LJ 5XQH DQG W KH
LGHDRI)DW KHUIURP W KH)$ 5XQHW KHLGHDRIOLIHIURP W KH/DI 5XQH DQGW KHLGHDRI
FDXVH RI 8U FDXVH IURP  W KH 8U 5XQH

7KH LQW HUSUHW DW LRQV W KDW  ZH DW W HP SW HG W R W KLV SRLQW  DGP LW  DOVR W KDW  ZH FDQQRW  ILQG D
VDW LVI\LQJH[SODQDW LRQIURP W KHSXUHSURSHUW \RIW KH5XQHVRIW KLVLQVFULSW LRQDVOHW W HUV
DQG VRXQGV  , W  LV P XFK P RUH FRUUHFW  W R FRQVLGHU W KH H[SDQGHG P HDQLQJ RI W KH 5XQHV
W KHQZHFDQUHDFKDVROXW LRQRIXQLYHUVDOYDOLGLW \  , QW KRVHW LP HVSHRSOHGLGQRW OLJKW O\
ZULW H P LOOLRQV DQG ELOOLRQV RI ZRUGV GD\ LQ DQG GD\ RXW    7KH DUW  RI ZULW LQJ KDG VW LOO

2PLWWHG

6LF

 2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

P DJLFDOFKDUDFW HUSHRSOHGLGQRW VLP SO\HQW UXVW XQLP SRUW DQW W KLQJVW RW KHP HW DOZRRG
RU URFN    3HRSOH W KRXJKW  LW  RYHU ZHOO ZKDW  W KH\ ZDQW HG W R VD\ DQG W KH\  XVHG OHVV
OHW W HUVW KDQW KH\XVHGZRUGV7KH\KDGDORZRSLQLRQRIP XFKW DONDQGZULW LQJDORW ZDV
VLP SO\XQNQRZQW KHQ7KHUHIRUHW KHOLW W OHKDGW RW HOODORW DQGLW GLG

7KH LP DJH VKRZV RQH RI W KH ROG ³ EUDFW HDW HV´ ZKLFK ZHUH RUQDP HQW DO FRLQV W KDW  ZHUH
FDUULHGDVM HZHOU\

7KH\ ZHUH FDOOHG QHFNODFH VKLOOLQJV  7KH DVVXP SW LRQ W KDW  ZLW K W KHVH GHFRUDW LYH FRLQV
W KDW  ZHUH XVHG DV SHQGDQW V W KH *HUP DQV RULJLQDOO\ FRSLHG FRLQV RI 5RP DQ HP SHURUV
XQW HQDEO\ RULJLQDW HG LQ W KH REVHVVLRQ RI QRW  DVVXP LQJ DQ\ DUW LVW LF FDSDELOLW LHV RI W KH
*HUP DQLF SHRSOHV  +RZHYHU W KHVH FRLQ SHQGDQW V VKRZ FOHDUO\ LQ FRQW HQW  DQG VKDSH
K R Z P X FK HVS HFL DO O \ W K HVHS L HFHVDU HG HW HU P L Q HG E \ W K H1R U G L F *HU P DQ L FVS L U L W 
&RQVLGHULQJW KLVW \SLFDO*HUP DQLFLQW HQW LQW KHLUIRUP W KDW W KHVH
SLHFHV RI DUW  KDYH ZH FDQ GHILQLW HO\ QRW  VSHDN RI LW HP V W KDW
ZHUHFRSLHGIURP 5RP DQFRLQV7RUHFRJQL]HW KDW RQHQHHGV
KRZHYHU VRP H DUW LVW LF LQVLJKW  DQG HGXFDW LRQ ZKLFK P RVW  RI
RXU VFKRODUV DQG VFLHQW LVW V DUH ODFNLQJ P RVW  RI W KH W LP H M XVW
OLNHW KHQRQ DUW LVW LFZD\RIZULW LQJZKLFKVHHP VW REHDSUH
FRQGLW LRQIRUDQDFFHSW HGEXVLQHVVRIVFLHQFH, NQRZKDUGO\
DQ\ERRNRIW KHYROXP LQRXVOLW HUDW XUHFRQFHUQLQJDUFKDHRORJ\
W KDW P HHW VW KHUHTXLUHP HQW VRIDQ\VFKRODUO\VW \OHRIZULW LQJ  
$VFKRODUO\VW \OHKDVDOVRDSUH FRQGLW LRQRIKDYLQJW KHSRZHU
W RM XGJHDUW LVW LFDOO\ZLW KRXW ZKLFKFDSDELOLW \ZHVLP SO\FDQQRW
M XGJH DUFKDHRORJLFDO GLVFRYHULHV LQ DQ\ ZD\   IURP  W KH ODFN
RIZKLFKRULJLQDW HDOVRW KHP DQ\³ EHQW ´ M XGJP HQW VFRQFHUQLQJ
W KH DUFKDHRORJLFDO GLVFRYHULHV IURP  W KH SDVW   :KRHYHU VHHV
RQO\ODFNDQGW KLQJVLQFRP SOHW HEHW UD\VKLVRZQSULP LW LYHQHVV
DQGQDLYHW\$FROGLQW HOOHFW W KDW GHFODUHVDOOQDW XUDOH[SUHVVLRQV
RI FXOW XUHV W KDW  DUH FORVH W R OLIH DV EDFNZDUG XQGHYHORSHG
LP SHUIHFW DQG³ SULP LW LYH´GRHVQRW NQRZKRZGHHSO\KHVHOHFW V
KLV RZQ SRLQW  RI YLHZ DQG DGM XVW V KLV ZRUOG YLHZ 

7KLV FRLQ SHQGDQW  VKRZV D XQLTXH SRZHU RI IRUP  IDU IURP  DQ\ IRUFHG IDLW KIXOQHVV W R
QDW XUH  7KHVH KXP DQV KDG QDW XUH DQG OLYHG LW   &RQVHTXHQW O\ W KH\ DOZD\V W UDQVODW HG
LQW R W KDW  ZKLFK LV V\P EROLF ZKHQHYHU W KH\ DW W HP SW HG W R H[SUHVV W KHLU LGHDV DERXW  W KH
W KLQJVDURXQGW KHP 7KLVZDVW KHRQO\ZD\IRUW KHP W RFRQW UROW KHZHDOW KRIQDW XUHDQG
W R RUJDQL]H LW  IRU W KHP VHOYHV  7RGD\ ZH NQRZ W KDW  QR GUDZLQJ DQG QR SKRW RJUDSK LV
FDSDEOHRIJLYLQJQDW XUHW RXV7UXHDUW DQGW UXHNQRZOHGJHRIW KHZRUOGDOZD\VVW ULYHV
W RZDUGVW KHSDUDEOHDQGQHYHUKDYHKXP DQVEHHQIDUW KHUDZD\IURP W UXHFDSDELOLW \DQG

 2I FRXUVH QRW    6XFK ZULW LQJ W RRN D KHOO RI D ORW  P RUH W LP H  , W  ZRXOG EH D QLFH FXUH IRU
EXUHDXFUDW VRIRXUGD\VW RFKDQJHW KHLUFRP SXW HUVDQGILOHVZLW KURFNVSLHFHVRIZRRGDQGP HW DO
LQJRW VW KDW W KH\KDYHW RKDP P HUIODW Z LW KDVW RQHKDP P HUEHIRUHVFUDW FKLQJW KHLUQRW HVRQW KHP
ZLW KDVKDUSURFN

 +P P P    *RUVOHEHQ VDLG W KDW "   +H KDG D P HW KRG RI Z ULW LQJ LGHDV Z LW KLQ LGHDV Z LW KLQ LGHDV
LQFOXGLQJH[FHSW LRQVDQGW KHQH[FHSW LRQVW KDW DUHH[HP SW IURP W KHH[FHSW LRQVDQGDOOW KDW ER[HG
LQW R D VLQJOH VHQW HQFH W KDW  LV VRP HW LP HV H[W HQGHG RYHU W HQ OLQHV DQG P RUH  +LV VW \OH LV D
P RQVW URVLW \ RI XW W HU FOXP VLQHVV QRW  DQ DUW LVW LF RU ³ VFKRODUO\´  VW \OH  7KLV LV HVSHFLDOO\ W KH FDVH
Z KHQHYHU KH HQGV XS IRUJHW W LQJ W KH P DLQ YHUE LQ KLV P RQVW HU VHQW HQFH  7KLV KDSSHQHG TXLW H
RIW HQSRVVLEO\UHVXOW RIJHW W LQJFRQIXVHGKLP VHOIZ KLOHZ ULW LQJ

+LV³ VW \OH´ P XVW EHH[HP SW IURP W KLVSUH FRQGLW LRQRIFRXUVH

$VGRHV0U*RUVOHEHQZLW KDOOQDW XUDOH[SUHVVLRQVRI³ QRQ$U\ DQ´ FXOW XUHV$QREYLRXVGRXEOH
VW DQGDUGEXW KHZ DVDFKLOGRIKLVW LP HVRIFRXUVH
 

W UXH DUW  W KDQ ZKHQ W KH\ DW W HP SW HG W R H[FHHG W KH W UXW K RI QDW XUH E\ DSLQJ VODYLVKO\
HYHU\W KLQJW RW KHP LQXW HVW GHW DLOV2QO\VHHQIURP W KLVSRLQW RIYLHZFDQZHXQGHUVW DQG
DQG DSSUHFLDW H W KHVH *HUP DQLF ZRUNV RI DUW   :H KDYH W R EH P RGHVW  DQG QRW  VW ULYH W R
H[SORUH   7KDW  W KH DQFLHQW  SHRSOHV ZDQW HG W R DSSHDU DV SXUH DUW LVW LF LQVLJKW  ZLW K W KHVH
VKDSHVW KDW DUHQRW EL]DUUHEXW GHHSO\VHULRXVQRW GLOHW W DQW LVKEXW KLJKO\VNLOOHG7KLV
FRLQ SHQGDQW  LI ZH DEVROXW HO\ ZDQW  W R YLHZ LW  DV D FRLQ LV DUW LVW LFDOO\ VSHDNLQJ IDU
DERYH W KRVH VP RRW K FRLQLQJ RI RXU  GD\V FRQVLGHU LQJ W KHLU  FRQW HQW  H[SU HVVLRQ DQG
IRUP ZKLOHW KHGHVLJQVRIW RGD\¶VFRLQLQJDQ\VW XGHQW RIDUW VDQGFUDIW VFDQSURGXFHLQ
KLV ILUVW  VFKRRO \HDU  7KHVH P RGHUQ FRLQV GR QRW  UHSUHVHQW  DQ HQLJP D DQG W KH\ GR QRW
NQRZ RQH HLW KHU DQG W KH\ DUH M XVW  HQRXJK IRU W KHP VHOYHV DQG W KH JHQHUDO SXEOLF ZLW K
W KHLU SODW LW XGHV RI DQ DOOHJRU\ RI FRUQ HDUV DQG JHDUV  , W  ZLOO EH JRRG W R JHW  ILUVW  ULG RI
RQH¶V DUURJDQFH DQG W R DGP LW  QRW  W R NQRZ ZKDW  W KLV FRLQLQJ ZLW K W KH KHDG DQG W KH
UXQQLQJ DQLP DO P HDQV  :H FDQ EHOLHYH W KHVH SHRSOH W KDW  W KH\ NQHZ YHU\ ZHOO KRZ D
KHDGORRNHGLQQDW XUHDQGKRZDUXQQLQJDQLP DOORRNHGOLNH7KH\GLGQRW OHDUQ]RRORJ\
DQG DQW KURSRORJ\ IURP  ERRNV EXW  W KH\ SHUFHLYHG W KH HP RW LRQDO LP DJH RI D W URW W LQJ
KRUVH EHQHDW K W KHP  ZLW K GUDVW LF FODULW \  7KH\ KDG QR QHHG IRU  VW DW XHV QR ORQJLQJ IRU
W KHEHDXW \RIKXP DQERGLHVP DGHRIP DUEOHEHFDXVHW KH\W KHP VHOYHVZHUHVW LOOEHDXW LIXO
/LNHZLVHP XFKODW HUW KH*UHHNVW RRZHUHGUHDP LQJDERXW W KHLUORVW OLNHQHVVRIW KHJRGV
DQGEDODQFHDQGH[SUHVVHGW KDW LQLQFUHGLEOHYLVLRQVP DGHLQVW RQH7KLVKDSSHQHGZKHQ
W KHLU  RXW HU  DQG LQQHU  OLN HQHVV W KHLU  LQKHU LW DQFH RI W KH 1RU GLF $SROOR U DFH EHFDP H
LQFUHDVLQJO\ SDOHU  , Q QR RW KHU W HUP V GR ZH M XGJH D *HUP DQLF JURXS RI DP EDVVDGRUV
ZKRP  W KH 5RP DQV VKRZHG D VW DW XH RI D KHUGVP DQ LQ W KH &ROLVHXP  ZKLFK OLNHO\ ZDV D
ZRUNRIIODW W HVW IDLW KIXOQHVVW RQDW XUH:KHQW KH\DVNHGW KHLUJXHVW VZKDW W KH\W KRXJKW
DERXW LW W KRVHDQVZHUHGW KDW W KH\ZRXOGQRW JLYHDQLFNHO  IRUDOLYLQJKHUGVP DQDQG
P XFKOHVVIRURQHLQVW RQH3HRSOHDOZD\VW RRNW KDW DVDVSHFLDOSURRIRIODFNRIFXOW XUH
RI W KH *HU P DQLF SHRSOHV DQG VP LU NHG DU U RJDQW O\ EHLQJ FRQVFLRXV RI W RGD\¶V 5RP DQ
FLYLOL]DW LRQDQGVFKRROLQJ7KLVDW W LW XGHRULJLQDW HVLQW KHVDP HVXSHUKXP DQW KLQNLQJW KDW
LV LQFDSDEOH RI P DNLQJ D GHDG SLFW XUH RI W KH GLYLQH DQG ZKLFK DOVR SUHIHUUHG W KH RSHQ
W HP SOH RI W KH IUHH QDW XU H XQGHU W KH U RRI RI W KH VN\ Z LW K LW V VW DUV RYHU EXLOGLQJV RI FROG
VW RQH  6W LOO GXULQJ P HGLHYDO W LP HV FRXUW  ZDV KHOG XQGHU W KH VN \ RU XQGHU W KH EHQGLQJ
EUDQFKHV RI D OLYLQJ W UHH EHFDXVH W KHQ SHRSOH VW LOO KDG DQ LGHD RI W KH YDOXH RI VXFK
FRVP LFFORVHQHVV7KHUXQH/DIZDVHTXDOO\W KH5XQHIRUW KHZRUG³ ODZ´W KDW ZKLFKZDV
ODLG GRZQ JHOHJW  DQG DOVR IRU OLIH  , I ZH UHW XUQ W R W KLV GLVFRYHU\ W KDW  ZH P HQW LRQHG
DERYHZHDUHUHDGLQJW KH5XQHV


3ILIIHUOLQJP HDQVFKDQW HUHOOH, W UDQVODW HGW KDW LQW R³ QLFNHO´
 

=$%$5  :H GR QRW  NQRZ  Z KDW  W KH\ P HDQ  7KH VROXW LRQ RI VXFK W DVNV Z LOO EH W KH
SXUSRVH RI D ODW HU ERRN  3RVVLEO\ ZH KDYH W R UHDG W KH UXQHV QRW  M XVW  DV VRXQGV RI
VSHFLILFOHW W HUVEXW DVFROOHFW LYHLGHDV

7KHVDP HW \SHSLHFHRIDUW LVDOVRW KHFRLQSHQGDQW RIXQNQRZQ

RULJLQW KDW ZHVKRZKHUH7KHUXQQLQJDQLP DOKDVLW VW RQJXH
KDQJLQJIURP LW VP RXW K, QIURQW RIW KHHDUVLW KDVDVW UXFW XUH
W KDW  ORRNV OLNH KRUQV VXFK DV RQH RI W KH QHFN ULQJV W KDW  DUH
P DGH RI EUDVV  7KH EHDXW LIXO DQG URXQGHG FDW HUSLOODU KHOP HW
KDVW ZRURZVRIOHDYHVDQGDVW ULQJRISHDUOVW KDW IDOOVW RW KH
EDFN  %HW ZHHQ KRUVH DQG ULGHU W KHUH LV D TXDGUXSOH V\P ERO
DERYHLVW KHUXQLFLQVFULSW LRQ:$, *$ZKLFKLVDZRUGLQZKLFK
W K H Q RW LRQ  RI  D FDU W   Z DJ RQ   W K H S HU VRQ  Z K R G DU HV  LV
FRQW DLQHGLIZHZDQW W RW DNHW KHUH5XQHVDVVFULSW H[SUHVVLQJ
VRP H FRQW HQW 

$QRW KHU EUDFW HDW H FRLQ SHQGDQW  W KDW  Z DV

GLVFRYHUHG LQ D W RP E P RXQG QHDUE\ +HLGH
LQW KHDUHDRI'LW KP DUKDVW KHVDP HLQVFULSW LRQ
DV W KH ULQJ RI .|VOLQ   )/8 RU 8/)  +HUH W KH
LQ W HQ W  W R U H Z RU N  D K X P DQ  EHLQ J LQ W R DQ
RUQDP HQW DO VKDSH YHU\ FOHDU VR W KDW  LQ QR
ZD\ FDQ ZH DVVXP H ODFN RI VNLOO  4XLW H W R
W K H  F R Q W U D U \  W K H  W D V N  L V  V R O Y H G  Z L W K
LQW HOOLJHQFH DQG DUW LVW LF VNLOO  :KHQ M XGJLQJ
VXFK GHVLJQV ZH KDYH W R DOZD\V EH DZDUH
W KDW W KHFUHDW RUVRIVXFKZRUNVGLGQRW DW DOO
Z DQW  W R JLY H GHVFU LSW LRQV W KDW  DU H W U XH W R
QDW XUH:KHUHYHUVXFKDSRVW XODW HLVP DGH
W K LV LV DOZ D\ V D V\ P S W RP  RI  ODFN  RI
XQGHUVW DQGLQJLQDUW 

$ ILJXUH RI ZKLFK ,  DVVXP H LW  UHSUHVHQW V D KXP DQ EHLQJ LQ DQ HFVW DW LF GDQFH ZKLFK LV
P LUURUHG ZLW K FRQVFLRXV VW \OL]LQJ KDV W ZR IO\LQJ ELUGV W R W KH OHIW  DQG ULJKW  ZKLFK ,
FRQVLGHUEHLQJUDYHQVM XVW OLNHW KHUDYHQRQW KHP HW DOILW W LQJRI:HQGHOLQ8SODQG7ZLFH
W KHV\P ERORIW KH7ULQLW \DSSHDUVDVRQW KHULQJRI.|VOLQDQGLQDGGLW LRQW RW KDW W ZRULQJ
VKDSHGV\P EROVDVSLUDODQGDUP  OLNHVW UXFW XUHVZLW KW KUHHHQGV)RXUVP DOOFLUFOHV
 

DUUDQJHGLQDVTXDUHP DNHW KLVDUUDQJHP HQW FRP SOHW HZKLFKRQO\ ODFNRIXQGHUVW DQGLQJ

FDQFRQVLGHUEHLQJUHVXOW RISOD\LQJDURXQGRIODFNRISXUSRVHRURILQFDSDELOLW \, QVW HDG
RI VXFK W KLQNLQJ ZH VKRXOG VW ULYH W R FRQVLGHU ZKDW  VSHDNV W R XV IURP  W LP HV SDVW  2I
FRXUVH VXFK VHFUHW V ZLOO UHYHDO W KHP VHOYHV W R XV HDVLHU ZKHQHYHU ZH ORRN IRU P HDQLQJ
LQW KHP UDW KHUW KDQGHQ\LQJDQ\SXUSRVHDSULRUL 

7KH 5XQH LQVFULSW LRQ LV EHW ZHHQ W ZR URZV RI YDULRXV V\P EROV W KDW  UHSUHVHQW  RQ W KH
ULJKW VLGHVHYHQVLP SOHHOOLSVHVDQGW RW KHOHIW VLGHW KH\GHY HORSP RUHGLIIHUHQW LDW LRQ,
ZRXOG DVVXP H VRP H UHODW LRQ W R RW KHU QXP HULF XQLW V  &HUW DLQO\ W KHVH KLQW V KDYH DQ
DVW UDO P HDQLQJ DQG LQW HUSUHW DW LRQ  7KH LQVFULSW LRQ LW VHOI P HDQV DV DOUHDG\ P HQW LRQHG
EHIRUH)/8IURP W KHOHIW DQG8/)ZKHQUHDGIURP W KHOHIW RU2/8DQG8/2LIZHGHFLGH
W KH)$IRUDQ26, IZHDFFHSW W KHLQW HUSUHW DW LRQRI(UQVW 7LHGHZHVHHLQ8/W KHZRUG
DQG W KH IRUP XOD IRU ZLVGRP    8/   RZO   g/ 2O (/   OLJKW  VSLULW  DQG RW KHU ZRUGV W KDW
KDYH VLP LODU P HDQLQJ  7KLV Z RXOG EH D P HDQLQJIXO DGGLW LRQ W R :RGDQ Z KR VHHP V
LQGLFDW HGZHOOHQRXJKZLW KW KHW ZRUDYHQV7KH)DJDLQZRXOGEHW KH5XQHRIFUHDW LRQ
RIFUHDW LQJRIP DNLQJRIW KHIDW KHUW KH³ IDFHUH´  ³ W RP DNH´ LQ/DW LQ 

:H FDQQRW  UHM HFW  W KH LGHD W KDW  W KHVH FRLQV W KDW  ZHUH P DGH W R EH ZRUQ RQ D QHFNODFH
ZHUHDFW XDOO\DP XOHW VW KDW KDGV\P EROVRIVDOYDW LRQ5XQHVRQW KHP ZKLFKZHUHW KHQ
W UHDW HG E\ DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH FXOW  E\ SHRSOH ZKR NQHZ EHFDXVH DOO W KHVH REM HFW V ZHUH
W UHDW HGZLW K2G OLIHIRUFH DFFRUGLQJW RW KHFXOW W KH\ZHUH³ EOHVVHG´DVW KH&KXUFKLV
VW LOOGRLQJW KLQJVOLNHW KDW LQRXUGD\V $FW XDOO\ZHVKRXOGW HVW ZLW KW KHVLGHUHDOSHQGXOXP
LIW KHVHREM HFW VKDYHVSHFLILFYLEUDW LRQVZKLFKKDYHQRW KLQJW RGRZLW KW KHLUUHVSHFW LYH
FKDUDFW HU RI W KH P DW HULDOV LQ ZKLFK W KH\ ZHUH P DGH EH LW  URFN ZRRG P HW DO RU ERQH
7KLVZRXOGEHVLP LODUW RXVLQJW KHSHQGXOXP RQDQFLHQW FRDW VRIDUP VDQGLQVFULSW LRQV
HDFK RI ZKLFK W RR VKRZV VSHFLILF GLDJUDP V RI W KH P RYHP HQW V RI W KH SHQGXOXP 

7KH5XQHVDUHV\P EROVRIW KHSXOVDW LQJOLIHW KH\DUHOLIHLW VHOIUHGXFHGW RDP DW KHP DW LFDO

IRUP XOD7KH\DUHLQVRP HP \VW LFDOUHODW LRQW RW KHODZRIW KHQXP EHUVDVW KHEDVLVRIDOO
FRVP LF DQG SKLORVRSKLFDO W KLQNLQJ  $QG LQGHHG LW  VLP SO\ LV QRW  SRVVLEOH W R H[SODLQ W KH
5XQHVZLW KVR FDOOHGSXUHO\DQGSUHFLVHVFLHQW LILFP HW KRGVDQGW ULFNV7KH5XQHVSURYH
P RVW FOHDUO\W KDW W KHUHDUHVW LOOW KLQJVEHW ZHHQKHDYHQDQGHDU W KRIZKLFKW KHDOOSRZHUIXO
VFKRROZLVGRP RIRXUGD\VVLP SO\FDQQRW GUHDP 6FKRODUVSUHW HQGDVLIIURP RQHRIW KH
0LG (DVW HUQ ODQJXDJHV W KDW  ZHUH FKRVHQ IRU VXFK SXUSRVH W KH OHW W HUV RI D VFULSW  KDG
HP HUJHG DOO RI ZKLFK REYLRXVO\ KDG RQH RULJLQ RQO\  ,  P \VHOI FDQQRW  DFFHSW  W KH LGHD
W KDW W KH5XQHVRULJLQDW HGLQSLFW XUHVRULGHRJUDP VDV'U:LOVHUEHOLHYHGW RKDYHSURYHQ
DQG W KDW  W KH\ ZHUH VLP SOLILHG LQ W KH FRXUVH RI W LP H  %XW  ,  P XVW  DGP LW  W KDW  SHRSOH
LQYHQW HGLP DJHVDQGFRQQHFW HGW KHP ZLW KW KH5XQHVDW DODW HUGDW HVRW KDW W KH\ZHUH
HDVLHU W R XQGHUVW DQG  :LW K W KLV DVVXP SW LRQ W KHUH LV QR FRQW UDGLFW LRQ DQG W KHUHIRUH LW
DSSHDUVRIW HQW KDW DUXQHRULJLQDW HGIURP DQLP DJH2QW KHRW KHUKDQGW KH5XQHVDUH
W RRP XFKP DW KHP DW LFDOO\GHILQHGVW UDLJKW OLQHVZKLFKP DNHVVXFKDQDVVXP SW LRQYHU\
XQOLNHO\


2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

+HUHIROORZVQRZDW DEOHRI5XQHVDFFRUGLQJW R:HUQHUYRQ%ORZLQZKLFKW KHUHLVW KH

LP DJH RI W KH P DW HULDO SODQH RI LQVLJKW  QH[W  W R W KH 5XQH ZKLFK W KHQ FRQW DLQV DOVR DQ
H[SODQDW LRQRIW KHQDP HDQGRIW KHV\P ERORQW KHP DW HULDOSODQH


6W *DOOHQLVDIDP RXVROGP RQDVW HU\ZKHUHDOVRW KHFRQW URYHU VLDO9LQODQGP DSVKRZHGXS
 


 2PLWWHG

/DW LQ ODZ
 

7KHRULJLQRIW KH5XQHVLVRQO\W REHXQGHUVW RRGEDVHGRQNQRZOHGJHRIFHUW DLQODZVRI

D FRVP LF P DW KHP DW LFDO QDW XUH  7KH RULJLQDO H[SUHVVLRQ RI W KLV NQRZOHGJH RU LQVLJKW 
ZHFDQUHDG IURP W KHVKDSHRI W KH ROG 1RUGLFDUUD\RIUXQHV

)RU W KH SHUVRQ ZKR LV NQRZOHGJHDEOH RI W KH (GGD W KHUH LV QR GRXEW  RI W KDW   +H FDQ
SURYHW KDW DOUHDG\KXQGUHGVRIW KRXVDQGVRI\HDUVDJRW KH³ JRGV´ KDG8U NQRZOHGJHLQ
DVW U RQRP \  Z KLFK JDYH W KHP  DOVR W KH N H\  RI W KH &DQRQ RI W KH U XQLF VFU LSW   Z KLFK
RULJLQDOO\ ZDV QRW  XVHG IRU W KH SXUSRVH RI ZULW LQJ DQG W KDW  ZDV GRQH VR LQW HQW LRQDOO\
EXW  IRU D ORQJ W LP H W KLV VFULSW  KDG W KH FKDUDFW HU RI DVW URQRP LFDO V\P EROV VXFK DV W KH
VLJQVRIW KH]RGLDFZLW KZKLFKW KH\DUHVW LOOFRQQHFW HGLQQDU URZSDUDOOHOLVP 


/DW LQ OLJKW

 2PLWWHG

/DW LQ KRUVH W KHVW LUUXSW KDW *RUVOHEHQGUHZVRSURXGO\RQW RW KHVDGGOHKDVQRW EHHQLQYHQW HG
\HW Z KHQW KH5XQHVRULJLQDW HG

 

/LW HUDOO\W KHUXQHVKDYHEHHQFDUYHGRXW IURP W KHVN\IURP W KHXQLYHUVHDQGEDVHGRQ

W KLVRULJLQW KHKDYHSURYHQW KHLUVXSHUQDW XUDOSRZHUV3UHVHQW O\LW ¶VRQO\LP SRUW DQW W KDW 
FRQFHU QLQJ W KH P DQ\ LGHDV RI Z KHU HIU RP  W KH U XQHV Z HU H GHU LYHG W KDW  DOO RI W KHVH
GHULYDW LRQV KDYH EHHQ SHUFHLYHG FRUUHFW O\ LQ W KHLU NLQG DQG LQW HQW  EXW  W KDW  ZH KDYH W R
GR ZLW K ODW HU KLVW RULFDO LQW HUSUHW DW LRQ HYHQ W KRXJK W KRVH DUH YHU\ ROG  7KH RULJLQDO
VKDSH DQG W KH HOHP HQW V RI W KH 5XQLF V\P EROV UHSUHVHQW  W KHP VHOYHV DV VHFW LRQV RI D
JHRP HW ULFVKDSHZKLFKZDVV\P ERORIW KHFRVP RVVLQFHYHU\DQFLHQW W LP HV7KLVLVW KH
KH[DJRQW KDW LVLQVFULEHGLQDFLUFOHW KHW LSVRIZKLFKW RXFKW KHHQGVRIW KHUXQH+DJDO
W KH 5XQH ZKLFK DOUHDG\ LQ LW V QDP H UHSUHVHQW V W KH +DJ $OO W KH FDULQJ IRU HYHU\W KLQJ
W KDW  ZKLFK FDULQJO\ VXUURXQGV DQG HP EHGV HYHU\W KLQJ  7KLV LV QR FRLQFLGHQFH DQG QR
SRVW HULRU FRQVW UXFW  RU DVVXP SW LRQ EXW  W KH UHVXOW  RI D ZHOO W KRXJKW  RYHU LQW HQW  W R ILQG
IRUW KHZRUGZKLFKLVUHSHDW LQJFRQYLQFLQJO\W KHGDLO\UHYHODW LRQRI*RGRIW KDW ZKLFKLV
VSLULW XDO DQG RI W KDW  ZKLFK LV 'LYLQH DQ LQFDUQDW LRQ D P DW HU LDOL]DW LRQ D SURM HFW LRQ D
W UDQVIHU LQW R W KH YLVLEOH ZRUOG ZKLFK FRUUHVSRQGV ZLW K W KH VDQFW LW \ ZLW K W KH P LUDFOH RI
W KHZRUGDQGZKLFKNHHSVW KLVZRUGFRQQHFW HGZLW KLW VFRVP LFRU LJLQ

2QH ORRN DW  RXU GHVLJQ VKRZV DOVR W KH QRQ LQLW LDW HG SHUVRQ W KDW  W KH 5XQHV KDYH EHHQ
FXW RXW RIW KLVLP DJHRIW KHXQLYHUVHRULQEHW W HUZRUGVW KHXQLYHUVHKDVEHHQFXW XS
LQW RW KH5XQHVZKLFKDUHLW VFRP SRVLQJSDUW V7KHUHIRUHZHVKRXOGQRW EHVXUSULVHGLI
W KH LQLW LDW HV ZKR NQHZ ZHOO DQG XVHG ZHOO W KH P DJLFDO SRZHU RI W KH 5XQHV XVHG W KHP
IRU RUDFOH DQG IRU GHFLVLRQV  7KH\ GLG QRW  GR W KDW  RXW  RI DQ LGLRW LF EXW W KROH VFLHQFH
*RUVOHEHQ XVHG W KH ZRUG ³$IW HUZLVVHQVFKDIW ´    DIW HU  W KH P HGLFDO W HUP  IRU EXW W KROH
DVVKROH  EXW  RXW  RI H[SHULHQFH ZKLFK VW LOO LQ RXU GD\V DQG SHUVRQ FDQ H[SHULHQFH RQ
ERG\DQGVRXOSURYLGHGW KDW KHVW ULYHVDQGVHHNVKRQHVW O\DQGKHFDQH[SHULHQFHW KHP
 

RQKLP VHOIDQGRQRW KHUVIRUKLVDQGIRURW KHUV¶EHQHILW RUUXLQLQW KHZD\DVFDSDELOLW \

RULQFDSDELOLW \JRRGRUHYLOZLOODUHHP SRZHULQJRUOHDGLQJDVW UD\

:KRHYHU UHIXVHV W R DVFULEH DQ\ VSLULW XDO RULJLQ W R W KH FRVP RV W KH XQLYHUVH W KH VW DUV
W KHP DW W HULQJHQHUDOLQRW KHUZRUGVZKRW HDFKHVP HDQLQJ OHVV QHVVRUQRQVHQVHKH
KLP VHOILVODFNLQJDOOVHQVHP DNHVQRVHQVHLVQRQVHQVLFDODQGLVHQFORVHGLQKRUULEOH
HUURU FRQVFLRXVO\ RU QRQ FRQVFLRXVO\  7KH IDFW  W KDW  VXFK QRQ VSLULW XDO KXP DQV FDQQRW
W LH DQ\ P RUH FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K W KH VSLULW XDO 'LYLQH SRZHUV LV VHOI HYLGHQW   7KHUHIRUH LW
VHHP V W R W KHP  W KDW  W KH Z RU OG LV D P HFKDQLFDO LQVW LW XW LRQ Z LW KRXW  SXU SRVH Z LW KRXW
FDXVHDQGZLW KRXW P HDQLQJDQGW KLVLVVREHFDXVHW KH\UHP RYHW KHP VHOYHVIURP DQ\
VSLULW XDOFR FUHDW LRQ7KHKXP DQERG\EHLQJDZRUOGRIFUHDW LRQRQDVP DOOHUVFDOHDQG
IRUZKLFKW KHUXQH+DJDOLV8U KRO\V\P ERODQGREYLRXVFRS\W KHUHRIW KLVERG\FDQZLW K
W KHP HDQVRIW KHUXQHVLHW KHFXW XSDQGVHSDUDW HGFRVP RVGUDZGRZQW RLW VHOIW KH
VSLULW XDO FRVP LF HQHUJLHV DQG EULQJ W KHP  W R FDXVH HIIHFW V LQ VSDFH DQG W LP H RQ W KH
P DW HULDOSODQH$W DOOW LP HVW KLVDUW KDVEHHQNQRZQDQGKDVEHHQW DXJKW DQGSDVVHGRQ
KRZHYHULQQRHSRFKKDVLW EHHQOHVVNQRZQDQGOHVVSUDFW LFHGW KDQLQW KLVURW W HQQRQ
VSLULW XDOSUHVHQW W KDW LVVZDP SHGDQGEOXUUHGLQW RDQREVHVVLRQIRUW KHP DW HULDOW KLQJV

$IW HUW KLVLQVLJKW LVLW VW LOOQHFHVVDU\W RUHM HFW W KHQDwYHDVVXP SW LRQZKLFKKRZHYHULV
YHU\REVW LQDW HW KDW W KHUXQHVRULJLQDW HGIURP W KHROG5RP DQVFULSW  $OOZHQHHGW RGR
LV UHFRJQL]H W KH NH\ W KH FDQRQ RI VFULSW  RI W KH /DW LQ OHW W HUV DV D VTXDUH LQW R ZKLFK D
VW DQGLQJFURVVDQGDQ;DUHLQVFULEHGW RNQRZW KDW W KH5XQLFNH\ZKLFKLVGHULYHGIURP
D KH[DJRQ DQG LW V W KUHH GLDJRQDOV W KDW  DUH LQVFULEHG LQ D FLUFOH UHSUHVHQW V W KH RULJLQDO
FRVP LF 8U LP DJH LQVW HDG RI W KH FRSLHG QRQ FRVP LF DQG M XVW  GHVLJQ UHODW HG SURSHUW \
RIW KH5RP DQNH\IURP ZKLFKZHFDQGHULYHW KH/DW LQVFULSW ZLW KDOOLW VV\P EROV

7KH *HUP DQ KDG RW KHU Z RUGV IRU W KH V\P ERO RI W KH FLUFOH RI OLIH Z LW K W KH LQVFULEHG
KH[DJRQ W KH V\P ERO RI W KH *HUP DQLF JURXS RI SHRSOHV ZKLFK VW DQGV ZLW KLQ LW VHOI DQG
W DNHV FDUH IRU LW VHOI  7KH GLVW RUW LRQ W KHUHRI LV W KH VTXDUH Z KLFK LV W KH EDVLV RI W KH
5RP DQ OHW W HU VFULSW  DQG ZKLFK LV W KH ³ VTXDULQJ´  RI W KH FLUFOH RI OLIH ZKLFK ZLW K W KLV
 

DFW LRQ DFTXLUHV ³ FRUQHUV´  LQVW HDG RI UHP DLQLQJ URXQG IORZLQJ DQG FLUFOLQJ  , I ZH SXW
ERW KV\P EROVRIRULJLQVLGHE\VLGHZHJHW W KHRSSRVLW HVRI8U ERUQDQGRULJLQDO*HUP DQLF
$U\DQFKDUDFW HUDQGUHYHUVHGVTXDUHDQGGLVW RUW HG5RP DQL]HGFKDUDFW HULVW LFRIDVLFNO\
FLYLOL]DW LRQ    7KH 6XQ FLUFOH W KH +DJ $OO 5XQH VHFXUHG W KH ULJKW  RI W KH VXQ RI DOO ZKR
OLYHG RQ W KH JURXQG  8QGHU W KH V\P ERO RI W KH VTXDUH ZLW K W KH W LHG LQ FURVV D ODZ RI
SURSHUW \ ZKLFK P HDQV UREEHU\ RI W KH VRLO KDG W R EHFRP H W KH ODZ  %XW  VW LOO W RGD\ W KLV
LQM XVW LFHKDVQRW EHHQDFFHSW HGLQW KHKHDUW RIW KHSHRSOHDQGW KHUHW XUQW KHUHVXUUHFW LRQ
RIW KHUXQHVZLOOVROYHDOOW KHVHTXHVW LRQV 8QGHUW KHLUUXOHDOOODFNRIUHDVRQDOOIUDXG
KDV W R FHGH  :KRHYHU NQRZV W KH P HDQLQJ RI V\P EROV W KDW  UHIHU W R W KH ZRUOG KH FDQ
GLVW LQJXLVK W KH 'LYLQH JLIW  RI W KH VDFUHG +DJ $OO 5XQH IURP  W KH W LSSHG RYHU DQG XQKRO\
VTXDUH ZKLFK LV W KH V\P ERO RI P DW HULDOLVP  RI W KDW  ZKLFK LV VFKHP DW LF  8QGHU W KH
VTXDUH¶V UXOH W KH *HUP DQ VHOI JRYHUQP HQW  DQG FROOHFW LYH KHOS W XUQHG LQW R EXUHDXFUDW LF
VLOHQFLQJRIW KHYRLFHRIW KHSHRSOH(Y HU\W KLQJEHFDP HULJLG P RW LRQOHVVFOXP V\DVLV
W KHVTXDUHW KDW OLHVRQRQHRILW VVLGHVW KHVDP HZD\DVW KHFXEHW KDW OLHVRQRQHRILW V
ODUJH VXUIDFHV  &RQYHUVHO\ W KH V\P ERO RI OLIH RI W KH +DJDO IORDW V HDVLO\ VLQFH LW V DUP V
DUHW KHSRZHUVRIW HQVLRQRIDVSKHUHDQGRIW KHXQLYHUVHLW VHOI

, QW KLVFRQW H[W LW LVSRVVLEOHYHU\GHVLUDEOHDQGLOOXP LQDW LQJW RRSHQW KHTXHVW LRQFRQFHUQLQJ
W KHVR FDOOHG*HUP DQVFULSW 1RGRXEW W KH*HUP DQVFULSW RULJLQDW HGXVLQJROG*UHHNDQG
ROG /DW LQ OHW W HUV ZKHUH DOVR D IHZ 5XQHV KDYH EHHQ LQFOXGHG  3XW W LQJ W KHVH XQHTXDO
SDUW VRIDVFULSW W RJHW KHUW RJHW KHUZLW KDIXUW KHULQIOX[RIW KH/DW LQW RGD\¶VEORFNOHW W HUV
HP HU JHG  W KH ³ *RW KLF´  )U DFW XU H )U DN W XU   Z KLFK LV FDOOHG U LJKW IXOO\  VR  EHFDXVH LW
FRQVW LW XW HVDUXSW XUHZLW KW KH8U VFULSW DQGW KLVFRUUHVSRQGVW RDEUHDNLQJDSDUW RIW KH
VRXO DQG RI UDFH ZKLFK W KH *HUP DQ SHRSOH W KH *HUP DQ QHVV VXIIHUHG LQ LW V SDVW 
ZKHUHLW ZDVW RUQIURP LW VRULJLQDQGIURP LW V$U\DQ'LYLQHELU W K

$ *HUP DQ VFULSW  LQ W KH P HDQLQJ RI D QDW LYH LQKHULW HG VFULSW  ZRXOG RQO\ EH SRVVLEOH LQ
FORVHVW  FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K W KH 5XQHV ZKLFK ZHUH W KH 8U VFULSW  RI W KH $U\DQV DQG ZLW K
W KDW W KH8U VFULSW RIKXP DQNLQGEHFDXVHIURP LW DOORW KHUOHW W HUVFULSW VZHUHGHULYHG, I
UHJDUGOHVVRIDOOW KDW ZHDUHVW LOOSUHIHUULQJW KHVR FDOOHG*HUP DQVFULSW DVW KHRQHLQW R
ZKLFK ZH ZHUH ERUQ W KHQ ZH VW LOO FDQQRW  H[FOXGH W KH VR FDOOHG /DW LQ VFULSW   %HFDXVH
W KHUH LV QR GRXEW  W KDW  LQ VRP H UHVSHFW  LW  ZDV IRUP HG IURP  W KH 5XQHV LQ HDUOLHU W LP H
W KHUHIRUH LW  UHP DLQHG LQ P DQ\ RI LW V V\P EROV P RUH 5XQH OLNH W KDQ W KH EURNHQ DQG VR
FDOOHG*RW KLF*HUP DQ)UDFW XUH7KHQDP H³ )UDNW XU ´ LW VHOIUHIHUVW R³ ZUHFN´W RDEUHDN
ZKLFKVHSDUDW HVLW IURP W KH8U VFULSW RIW KH5XQHV


2PLWWHG

2PLWWHG
 

)DQG  ID   DQG IRU%²DUHEXW DIHZH[DP SOHVW RFODULI\W KDW ZKLFKZHVDLG

$Q XQXVXDOO\ KLJK W DVN HP HUJHV KHUH IRU XV DQG W KLV VFULSW  ZLOO HP HUJH E\ LW VHOI VR W R
VD\ DV D UH ELUW K DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH 5XQH VFULSW  DQG LW  ZLOO HP HUJH DV DQ 8U VFULSW  D
JHQXLQHQHZ*HUP DQVFULSW RIEORFNOHW W HUVZKLFKVKRXOGVXUSDVVDOOH[LVW LQJDW W HP SW V
RIFUHDW LQJDVFULSW EHFDXVHRILW VW UXO\5XQLFVLP SOLFLW \DQGFODULW \

3HRSOHZLW KUDFLDOLQVLJKW VHHLQW KLVUHTXHVW VRP HW KLQJW KDW ¶VVHOI HYLGHQW 7KHDUJXP HQW
FRQVLGHULQJ W KH VFULSW V ZRXOG VLOHQFH LW VHOI EHFDXVH LW  ZRXOG QHYHUEHGHFLGHGZLW K W KH
H[LVW LQJDW W HP SW VRISURRIVEHFDXVHW KRVHZKRDUJXHERW KVLGHVFODLP W KLQJVW KDW DUH
LQFRUUHFW DQGQRW JHQXLQH  :HFDQRQO\KDYHRQHUHDVRQRIJLYLQJDJUHDW HUM XVW LILFDW LRQ
IRUW KH*HUP DQ*RW KLFVFULSW LQVRIDUDVLW LVEHW W HUDGDSW HGW RW KH*HUP DQODQJXDJHDQG
VSHOOLQJSK\VLFDOO\DQGE\LP DJHW KDQW KH/DW LQVFULSW W KDW ORRNVOLNHDVFULSW W KDW LVIDOOLQJ
DSDUW  DQG W KHUHIRUH LW  LV HDVLHU DQG IDVW HU W R UHDG  )RU ODUJH VLJQV LQVFULSW LRQV DQG
SLFW XUHVYHU\RIW HQ QRW HYHUW KRXJK W KH/DW LQVFULSW W KHVR FDOOHG$QW LTXDFDQSURGXFH
HIIHFW V ZKLFK W KH JRW KLF FDQQRW  VLQFH W KH *RW KLF VFULSW  KDV ULFKHU DQG P RUH LQGLYLGXDO
DQGSHUVRQDOVW UXFW XUHV$VORQJDVZHGRQRW SRVVHVVW KH5XQHEORFNOHW W HUVFULSW W KDW
LV W UXO\ DGDSW HG W R XV ZH QDW XUDOO\ XVH ERW K VFULSW V DQG ZH ZRXOG UHM HFW  W KH LGHD W KDW
XVH RI W KH DQW LTXD ZDV DQ RIIHQVH DJDLQVW  RXU *HUP DQ QHVV

:H FDQQRW  W DN H W KLV VLW XDW LRQ W RR VXSHU ILFLDOO\  2XU  ROGHVW  GRFXP HQW V VXFK DV W KH
0HUVHEXUJHUVSHOOVW KH+LOGHEUDQGVRQJW KHVRQJRIW KH1LEHOXQJVW KH+HOLDQGQRQHRI
W KHP KDYHEHHQZULW W HQLQW KH*RW KLFVFULSW EXW LQD/DW LQORZ HUFDVHVFULSW 

7KH V\P ERO W KDW  LV NLQ W R W KH +DJDO LQ IDFW  ZKLFK FRUUHVSRQGV W R LW  LV W KH VL[ SRLQW HG
VW DU ZKLFK LQ IDFW  UHSUHVHQW V RULJLQDOO\ W ZR S\UDP LGV W KDW  DUH SHQHW UDW LQJ HDFK RW KHU
+HUHW KHFRQQHFW LRQZLW KW KHERG\KDVW REHDFFRUGLQJW RW KHJROGHQVHFW LRQLIZHZDQW
W KHV\P EROW REHSHUIHFW 7KLVZD\W KHERG\EHFRP HVV\P ERORIW KHHQW LUHFRVP RVDQG
LW VH[W HQVLRQVDVW KH\DUHUHSUHVHQW HGLQW KHVW UXFW XUHRIW KH&KHRSVS\UDP LG


2PLWWHG
 

*HQHUDOO\W KHVL[SRLQW HGVW DULVVHHQDVW KHV\P ERORI-XGDLVP EXW LW KDVEHHQERUURZHG

E\ W KHP  DQG LW  OLNHO\ FDP H W R W KHP  E\ ZD\ RI (J\SW   7KH VL[ SRLQW HG VW DU LW  W KH ZRUOG
DVK W UHH <JJGUDVLO DQG DV VXFK LW  UHSUHVHQW V W KH XQLYHUVH E\ LP DJH DQG VSDFH  7KH

:RUOGW UHH 6L[ SRLQW HGVW DUZLW K 'RXEOHS\UDP LG

LQVFULEHG+DJ $OO 5XQH RU 2FW DKHGURQ
&KHRSVS\UDP LGKDVW KHVDP HHIIHFW 7RFRP SOHW HW KLVV\P ERODQGW RM XVW LI\LW ZHKDYH
W RDGGW RW KHYLVLEOH&KHRSVS\UDP LGDQLP DJLQDU\RQHW KHFXVSRIZKLFKUHDFKHVGRZQ
LQW RW KHVRLODQGW KHEDVLVRIZKLFKLQW HUVHFW VZLW KW KHW DQJLEOH&KHRSVS\UDP LGDFFRUGLQJ
W R W KH JROGHQ UDW LR  7KLV ZD\ D GRXEOH S\UDP LG HP HUJHV DURXQG ZKLFK ZH FDQ SXW  D
VSKHUHW KHVXUIDFHRIZKLFKW RXFKHVW KHFXVSDQGW KHFRUQHUVRIW KHGRXEOHS\UDP LGLQ
RW KHUZRUGVLW FLUFXP VFULEHVLW 

+DJ $OOZLW KLQVFUW LEHG +H[DJRQ ZLW K

KH[ DJRQ LQVFULEHG+DJ $OO
7KHLQW HUODFLQJRIW ZRS\UDP LGVLQW KHJROGHQUDW LRUHSUHVHQW HGLQW ZRGLP HQVLRQV

7KHUH LV QR GRXEW  W KDW  KHUH ZH KDYH W KH P DW KHP DW LFDO 8U LP DJH RI W KH ZRUOG DVK W UHH
DQG LW V W ZR SDUW V   W KH S\UDP LG ZLW K LW V W LS RQ W RS DQG W KH S\UDP LG ZLW K W KH W LS DW  W KH
ERW W RP W KHFRP ELQDW LRQRIZKLFKUHSUHVHQW DQGV\P EROL]HW KHVSLULW XDODQGW KHP DW HULDO
ZRUOGVW KHDVFHQGLQJDQGGHVFHQGLQJOLIHOLJKW DQGGDUNQHVVULVHDQGGHFOLQHJRRGDQG
HYLOW KHFRQVFLRXVDQGW KHXQFRQVFLRXVLQEULHIDOOSRODULW LHVIURP ZKLFKOLIHRULJLQDW HG
 

, Q W KH UHSUHVHQW DW LRQ RI W KH ZRUOG DVK W UHH RQ D SODQH W KH W KU HH W LSV RI W KH XSSHU
W ULDQJOH W KHW ULDQJOHSRLQW LQJXSZDUG UHSUHVHQW W KHW KUHHEUDQFKHVRIW KHZRUOGW UHH
DQGRIW KHXQLYHUVHRIEHFRP LQJEHLQJDQGSDVVLQJDZD\ ZD[LQJEHLQJDQGZDQLQJ 
ZKLOH W KH W KUHH W LSV RI W KH GRZQZDUG SRLQW LQJ W ULDQJOH RQ ZKLFK W KH W KUHH 1RUQV DUH
VLW W LQJ ZKLFK DJDLQ FRQW DLQV W KH VDP H P \VW HU\ DQG ZKLFK UHYHDOV LW VHOI W KURXJK W KH
QDP HVRIW KH1RUQV8UGD:HUGDQGLDQG6NXOG SDVW SUHVHQW DQGIXW XUH:HUHFRJQL]H
FRUUHODW LRQV LQ W KH (GGD LQ W KH 7ULQLW \ RU W KH W KUHH IROG *RG ZKLFK FXOP LQDW HV LQ W KH
HTXDW LRQV

7KH+LJK2QH 7KH(TXDO+LJK2QH 7KH7KLUG2QH

)DW KHU 6RQ +RO\ *KRVW
:RGDQ :LOL :HK
7KH NQRZHU 7KDW ZKLFKLVNQRZ Q .QRZ OHGJH
0DQ 6RQ :RP DQ
)DLW K /RY H +RSH
6SLULW 6RXO %RG\

, W  LV QR FRLQFLGHQFH W KDW  W KH VL[ SRLQW HG VW DU LV DOVR FDOOHG W KH VH[ VW DU W KH VW DU RI W KH
DVFHQGLQJDQGRIW KHGHVFHQGLQJOLIHW KHVW DURIUHLQFDUQDW LRQRIHW HUQDOUHW XUQ$QGIRU
W KLVUHDVRQW KLVV\P EROLVFRP P RQDVDJXHVW KRXVHDQGKRW HOVLJQVW LOOLQRXUGD\V, W LV
VRLQDZRUOGO\P HDQLQJRIDQLQYLW DW LRQW RFRP HKRP HW RFRP H LQW RUHW XUQ

7KH&KHRSVS\UDP LG W KHS\UDP LGRI.KXIX KDVVW LOOP RUHUHODW LRQVW RW KH+DJ $OODQG
W KHVL[SRLQW HGVW DUZKLFKFRQQHFW VLW ZLW KRXU5XQHV

'U )U LW ] 1|W OLQJ KDV Z U LW W HQ DQ DQDO\ VLV FRQFHU QLQJ W KH &KHRSV S\ UDP LG  W KHU H KH
G HVFU LE HV W K H FRVP LF Q X P E HU V W K DW  Z HU H I RX Q G  LQ  W K H &K HRS V S \ U D P LG  DV W K H
P DW KHP DW LFDO NH\ W R W KH ODZV RI 2QH LQ W KH VW UXFW XUH RI W KH XQLYHUVH  6R ZH ILQG W KH
VDP H W KRXJKW V DJDLQ Z LW K D VFKRODU  Z KR RQO\  OLP LW HG KLP VHOI W R VW U LFW O\  VFLHQW LILF
H[DP LQDW LRQV DQG P HDVXUHP HQW V RI W KH S\UDP LG QDP HO\ W KDW  W KLV P \VW HULRXV EXLOGLQJ
UHSUHVHQW VW KHFRVP RVW KHXQLYHUVHDQGW KLVLVHYLGHQW LQFHU W DLQP DW KHP DW LFDOUHODW LRQV
W KDW FDQEHGHP RQVW UDW HG:LW KW KLVW KHFRQQHFW LRQEHW ZHHQW KHEXLOGHUVRIW KH&KHRSV
S\UDP LGVRP H\HDUVDJRDQGW KHLGHDVRIW KH(GGDDQGW KRVHZKRZURW HLW GRZQ
LVSURYHQXQHTXLYRFDOO\ZLW KW KDW IDFW $QGDVLVW KHVLW XDW LRQZLW KW KHUHVHDUFKRIW KH
DQFLHQW W LP HZHKDYHW RDVVXP HW KH(GGDDVW KHSRLQW RIRULJLQRIW KLVNQRZOHGJHDQG
ZLW KW KLVZHKDYHW RFRQVLGHUW KH(J\SW LDQFXOW XUHDVRQHRIW KHP DQ\$U\DQRIIVKRRW V
$QG LQGHHG W KH FUHDW RUV RI W KH DQFLHQW  (J\SW LDQ S\UDP LG KDYH EHHQ RI W KH $U\DQ UDFH
DQG ZLW K W KLV ZH P HDQ W KDW  W KH\ ZHUH RI 1RUGLF RULJLQ DV W KH U HVHDUFK RI W KH EORRG RI
W KH UR\DO P XP P LHV RI ROGHVW  RULJLQ SURYH DV ZHOO DV RW KHU ZLW QHVVHV

$OUHDG\ RQFH IURP  $W ODQW LV RULJLQDW HG DQ $U\DQ ZDYH RI FRQTXHURUV DOO RYHU W KH (DUW K
ZKHQ LQ 0H[LFR LQ (J\SW  DQG LQ VRXW K (DVW  $VLD W KH VDP H S\UDP LGV ZHUH FUHDW HG ZLW K
W KH VDP H KLHURJO\SKV DQG W KH VDP H RUQDP HQW V    0H[LFDQ OLQH SDW W HUQV DUH FORVHVW  W R


 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

W KH 1RUGLF OLQH SDW W HUQV DQG RULJLQDW HG LQ W KH VDP H ZLOO W R FUHDW H  $OO ROG $P HULFDQ
W UDGLW LRQV VSHDN RI ZKLW H P HQ ZKR FDP H RYHU W KH 6HD IURP  W KH (DVW  DQG ZKR EURXJKW
W RW KHP UHOLJLRQFXOW XUHDQGOLW HUDW XUH2IDOOVFULSW V\VW HP VW KHURFNLQVFULSW LRQVLQW KH
IDU RII(DVW HU, VODQGLQW KH6RXW K6HDKDYHW KHJUHDW HVW VLP LODULW \ZLW KW KH1RUGLF5XQHV
DQG LW  VHHP V W KDW  W KH\ KDYH EHHQ GHULYHG IURP  W KHP   , Q 6ZHGHQ W KH URFN LP DJHV RI
%RKXVOlQ DUH ZDLW LQJ W R EH GHFLSKHUHG  7KHVH QR GRXEW  DUH W KH ROGHVW  W UDGLW LRQV RI
ZULW LQJLQLP DJHV%HVLGHVRW KHUVW UDQJHIDFW VW KHYDVW DQGJLJDQW LFHQJUDYLQJVLQKDUG
URFNJLYHZLW QHVVW RW KHYR\DJHVRIDVHDIDUHUSHRSOHRIKLJKFXOW XUHLQW RZDUP HUDUHDV
EHFDXVHHOHSKDQW VJLUDIIHVP RQNH\VDQGRW KHUW URSLFDODQLP DOVZHUHEURXJKW DVVSRLOV
RQW KHLUORQJERDW VDVW KHVHFOHDUHQJUDYLQJVDUHSURYLQJ

7KHVHUHP DUNVVKRXOGVHUYHW RLOOXP LQDW HFXOW XUDOO\RXU5XQHGLVFRYHULHVVRW KDW ZHFDQ

DW W HP SW  W R SURYH W KDW  VXFK KLJK NQRZOHGJH RI W KH ZRUOG DQG RI *RG RULJLQDW HG IURP  D
SHRSOHIURP DUDFHZKLFKKDGDGRP LQDQW SRVLW LRQDOVRHOVHZKHUHLQW KHZRUOG1|W OLQJ
LVZULW LQJLQKLVERRN³ 7KH&KHRSV3\UDP LG´ DERXW W KHP HDVXUHP HQW VRIW KHVW RQHFKHVW
LQW KH.LQJVFKDP EHURIW KLVLP SRUW DQW EXLOGLQJ

³ 7KHODUJHUDQGW KHVP DOOHUSDUW RIW KHFRQW DLQHUUHIOHFW LQW KHLUGLP HQVLRQVW KHJROGHQ
VHFW LRQ, QW KHP HDVXUHP HQW VRIW KHJUHDW S\UDP LGLQ(J\SW LDQ\DUGVDOOFRVP LFUDW LRV
DUHFRQW DLQHGZLW KDP D]LQJSUHFLVLRQVXFKDVW KHW LP HRIW KHRUELW RIW KH(DUW KDURXQG
W KH 6XQ W KH OHQJW K RI LW V W UDFN W KH W LP HV RI RUELW V RI W KH SODQHW V W KH OHQJW KV RI W KHLU
W UDFNVDQGW KHLUP XW XDOGLVW DQFHVDQGW KDW DOODFFRUGLQJW RW KHODZRIW KHJROGHQUDW LR
)XUW KHUP RUH W KHUH DUH W KH UDW LRV RI VL]H RI W KH (DUW K UDGLXV VXUIDFH DQG ZHLJKW   , Q
IDFW  LW  VHHP V W KDW  W KHVH GLVFRYHULHV FDQ EH H[W HQGHG W R W KH DW RP LF ZHLJKW V´

7KHLP SRUW DQFHRIW KHVHGLVFRYHULHVW KDW ZHUHIRXQGE\P DW KHP DW LFDOP HDQVLVW KHIDFW
W KDW  ZH FDQ UHDFK DQ H[SODQDW LRQ RI W KHVH EXLOGLQJV DV ZHOO ZLW KRXW  W KH KHOS RI W KHVH
H[DFW  VFLHQW LILF DLGV DORQH ZLW K W KH KHOS RI W KH 5XQHV DQG W KH P \VW LFLVP  RI W KH (GGD
7KHVHDUHEXLOGLQJVW KDW DUHVSLULW RIRXUVSLULW DQGZKLFKVKRZW KDW W KLVVSLULW FDP HW RD
UHVSHFW HGEORVVRP LQJDOUHDG\\HDUVDJRLQW KHYDOOH\RIW KH1LOH

1|W OLQJ VD\V IXUW KHUP RUH

³ 8S W R QRZ QRERG\ FRXOG KDYH DQ\ XVH IRU W KH P HDVXUHP HQW V RI W KH VW RQH FKHVW   ,
KDYH GHP RQVW UDW HG DQG SURYHQ W KDW  W KHVH YDOXHV FDQ ZLW K HDVH EH UHGXFHG W R W KH
QXP EHU3L  DQGIURP W KLVIROORZVW KDW W KHDVVXP SW LRQW KDW W KHVW RQHFKHVW LVDNLQGRI
P HDVXULQJYHVVHOIRUJUDLQRUHYHQDVDUFRSKDJXVFDQQRW EHFRUU HFW LQDQ\ZD\EHFDXVH


2PLWWHG
 

LQ ERW K FDVHV W KH P HDVXUHP HQW V ZRXOG EH LQ LQW HJHUV DQG QRW  LQ W KH FRP SOLFDW HG IRUP
RI DSSUR[LP DW LRQV W R QXP EHUV ZLW K LQILQLW H P DQ\ GHFLP DOV    7KH GHHSHU P HDQLQJ RI
W KH VW RQH FKHVW  LV LQ W KH REY LRXV LQW HQW  W R H[ SU HVV VSHFLILF DOJHEU DLF Y DOXHV LQ LW V
P HDVXUHP HQW V1RZZHNQRZW KDW LQW KLVVW RQHFKHVW W KHYDOXHSL  =   LVH[SUHVVHG
7KLVYDOXHLVRIW KHJUHDW HVW FRVP LFVLJQLILFDQFHLQVRIDUDVLW LVQRW RQO\DP HDVXUHP HQW
RIW LP HEXW DOVRDP HDVXUHP HQW RIOHQJW KDQGDVVXFKLW UHSUHVHQW VDSULP DU\FRVP LF
YDOXH  9LHZHG DV D FRVP LF P HDVXUH RI W LP H W KH YDOXH SL      LV W KH GXUDW LRQ RI W KH
W URSLFDO\HDULQGD\VKRXUVP LQXW HVDQGVHFRQGVDQGGHFLP DOVRIVHFRQGV6HHQDVD
P HDVXUHRIOHQJW KW KLVYDOXHZLW KW KHFRUUHVSRQGLQJSRZHURIQDP HO\  P XOW LSOLHG
LVW KHDEVROXW HOHQJW KRIDIRXUW KSDUW RIW KH(DUW KRUELW LQ(J\SW LDQ\DUGV%XW P RUHVW LOO
LIZHP XOW LSO\W KLVYDOXHZLW K [  W KHQZHJHW DYDOXHZKLFKUHSUHVHQW VW KHVSHFLILF
Z HLJKW  RI W KH (DU W K Z LW K JU HDW HVW  SU HFLVLRQ  6LQFH W KLV Y DOXH  P XOW LSOLHG Z LW K   
UHSUHVHQW V W KH OHQJW K RI D VLGH RI W KH &KHRSV S\UDP LG LW  VHHP HG XVHIXO W R P H W R
H[DP LQH ILUVW  W KH GLP HQVLRQV RI W KH JUHDW  S\UDP LG  7KH DOJHEUDLF YDOXH RI W KH VHFRQG
P DLQGLP HQVLRQRIW KHJUHDW S\UDP LGLW VKHLJKW FDQEHGHGXFHGVLP SO\IURP W KHDOJHEUDLF
YDOXH RI W KH OHQJW K RI LW V VLGH )URP  W KLV ZH FDQ GHGXFH LUUHIXW DEO\ W KDW  W KH W ZR P DLQ
GLP HQVLRQV RI W KH JUHDW  S\UDP LG FDQ EH GHGXFHG IURP  W KH GLP HQVLRQV RI W KH VW RQH
FKHVW   , I ZH FRQVLGHU W KDW  W KH DOJHEUDLF YDOXH RI W KH KHLJKW  RI W KH &KHRSV S\UDP LG LI
P XOW LSOLHG E\    LV W KH DEVROXW H OHQJW K RI W KH P HDQ GLVW DQFH RI W KH (DUW K IURP  W KH
VXQLQ(J\SW LDQ\DUGV W KHQLW EHFRP HVLP P HGLDW HO\FOHDUW KDW ZLW KW KLVUDW LRZKLFKLV
DOVR W KH UDW LRQ RI W KH VW RQH FKHVW  W KH\ KDYH H[SUHVVHG W KH P RVW  LP SRUW DQW  FRVP LF
SUREOHP V´

1|W OLQJDVNV ³ 7KHP DQ\KXP DQVZKRGHDOZLW KW KLVP \VW HULRXVVKDSHRIW KHVL[SRLQW HG
VW DU W R ZKLFK W KH\ DW W ULEXW H JUHDW  P DJLFDO SRZHUV NQRZ DERXW  W KLV RU GLG W KH\ NQRZ
DERXW W KLV"´

:LW KRXUNQRZOHGJHDERXW W KH$U\DQVHFUHW GRFW ULQHVZHFDQVD\ZLW KJRRGUHDVRQW KDW

P DQ\KXP DQVNQHZDERXW W KLVDQGW KDW W KLVVHFUHW QHYHUYDQLVKHGDP RQJW KHLQLW LDW HG
RQHV  )RU LQVW DQFH 3\W KDJRUDV ZDV VW LOO VXFK D SHUVRQ ZKR NQHZ

'U1|W OLQJW KHVFLHQW LVW W RZKRP W KHVRXUFHVRINQRZOHGJHGLGQRW UHYHDOW KHP VHOYHV
UHJDUGOHVV RI KLV DP D]LQJ NQRZOHGJH DQVZHUV W KLV ZLW K  ³ 1R  1RERG\ NQRZV W KDW  W KH
VLGHV RI W KH W ULDQJOHV RI ZKRVH LQW HUODFLQJ W KH VL[ SRLQW HG VW DU HP HUJHV KDYH W R KDYH
W KHVH P HDVXU HP HQW V VR W KDW  W KHLU  EDVH DQG W RS DQJOHV KDY H W R KDY H SU HFLVHO\  
GHJUHHV  P LQXW HV DQG  VHFRQGV RI DUF EHFDXVH W KH (DUW K LQ D GLVW DQFH RI


2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

0LOOLRQW KRXVDQGDQG(J\SW LDQ\DUGV P LOOLRQW KRXVDQG

 NLORP HW HUV FRP SOHW HV KHU RUELW  DURXQG W KH 6XQ LQ  GD\V  KRXUV  P LQXW HV
DQG  VHFRQGV

, W LVKLJKO\SUREDEOHW KHQW KDW W KHVL[SRLQW HGVW DULVDV\P ERORIW KH6XQ RU/LJKW FXOW 
ZKLFK V\P EROL]HV LQ LW V IRUP  SHUKDSV DOVR W KH SHQHW UDW LRQ RI P DW W HU E\ OLJKW  RU E\ W KH
VSLULW´

:LW KW KLV1|W OLQJH[SUHVVHVW KHDVVXP SW LRQW KDW ZHKDYHDOZD\VUHSUHVHQW HGFRQFHUQLQJ

W KHP HDQLQJRIW KHVH$U\DQV\P EROVZKLFKHP HUJHGIURP W KH5XQH)XW KDUN

7KLV ODZ RI W KH ZRUOG LV H[SUHVVHG P HDQLQJIXOO\ E\ W KH VW UXFW XU H RI W KH JUHDW  S\UDP LG
DQG ZLW K W KLV RQH RI W KH SUREOHP V LV ILQDOO\ VROYHG RYHU ZKLFK SKLORVRSKHUV SRQGHUHG
W KURXJKRXW  W KH P LOOHQQLD QDP HO\ W KH SXUSRVH DQG VLJQLILFDQFH RI W KH JUHDW  S\UDP LG
7KH S\UDP LG RI &KHRSV LV QHLW KHU D P RQXP HQW DO W RP E QRU DQ\ W \SH P RQXP HQW  DV ZH
JHQHUDOO\XQGHUVW DQGLW 7KH&KHRSVS\UDP LGLVQRW KLQJEXW DORJLFDOUHSUHVHQW DW LRQRI
W KHODZW KDW JRYHUQVRXUZKROHXQLYHUVHDQGZKLFKILQGVLW VP DW KHP DW LFDOH[SUHVVLRQLQ
W KHQXP EHU

%XW W KHSDW W HUQDIW HUZKLFKW KH&KHRSVS\UDP LGZDVVKDSHGLVW KH5XQLFV\P ERORIW KH

+DJ $OO LH W KH FURVV W KDW  VXUURXQGV W KH XQLYHUVH W KH ZRUOG DVK W UHH <JJGUDVLO RI W KH
$ULR *HUP DQV IURP  ZKLFK W KH  5XQHV ZHUH FXW  ZKLFK DUH W KH VSLULW XDO P DW HULDO 8U
LP DJHVRIDOOVFULSW V
 

;9, , 
7KH5XQHVDV6W UHDP VRI6XEW OH(QHUJLHV
LQW KH8QLYHUVH
2W KHUV ORRN DW
&RYHULQJZULQNOHV
2YHUW KDW ZKLFKLVROG
6DGDQGVK\
%XW W RXVVKRXOGVKLQH
)ULHQGO\IDLW KIXOQHVV
6HHW KDW ZKLFKLVQHZ
)LQGV XV W R EH QHZ
*RHW KH

7KH LQLW LDW LRQ LQW R W KH Secr et of t he Runes KDV W KH SXU SRVH W R SXW  W KH
SHUVRQZKRLVUHDG\IRULW LQW RDKLJKHUFRVP LFFRQVFLRXVQHVVRIOLIH

7KH QRW LRQ RI ³ IRUFH´  LQ JHQHUDO HQHUJ\  P HDQV W KDW  ZH IRUFH DQ\ NLQG RI
HIIHFW 

:H KDYH W R GLVW LQJXLVK EHW ZHHQ W KUHH W \SHV RI IRUFH
$ 7KH P RYHP HQW  RI D GHQVH P DW HULDO W DQJLEOH ERG\   W KLV LV IRUFH LQ W KH
P HFKDQLFDO VHQVH VXFK DV IRUFH  P DVV [ DFFHOHUDW LRQ 
%7KHP RYHP HQW RIDQLQYLVLEOH³ VRP HW KLQJ´ RIVXEW OHP DW W HU )RULQVW DQFH
W KHFUHDW LRQRIDW HQVLRQVXFKDVHOHFW ULFDOYROW DJH
&  W KH LP SXOVH W R VHW  LQW R P RYHP HQW  IRU LQVW DQFH W KH IRU FH RI RXU ZLOO
$LVW KHILQDOHIIHFW %LVW KHP HGLXP DQG&LVW KHW ULJJHU
0RGHUQSK\VLFVLQLW VH[DFW UHVHDUFKLQFOXGHV$DQG%VXFKDVW KHP HFKDQLFV
RIVROLGDQGOLTXLGP DW W HUHOHFW ULFLW \DQGRSW LFV

%XW LIZHJRGHHSHUZHJDLQW KHNQRZOHGJHW KDW QRW KLQJKDSSHQVZLW KRXW D

W ULJJHU  , I ZH W KURZ D VW RQH W KH W ULJJHU W R W KDW  LV W KH LP SXOVH RI RXU ZLOO
& W KHP HGLXP RIRXUQHUYRXVLP SXOVHV % DQGW KHW KURZLQJP RYHP HQW
LW VHOI ZLW K W KH SRZHU RI RXU P XVFOHV

7KH8U VRXUFHRIHYHU\YLVLEOHP RYHP HQW LVDW ULJJHU

7KHVHSUH KLVW RULFREVHUYDW LRQVOHDGXVW RW KHUHVXOW RULQVLJKW W KDW GHQVH
P DW W HULVW KHHOHP HQW RIIRUP W KHEXLOGLQJP DW HULDOVRW RVD\RIW KHZRUOG
RIERGLHV IRUP V W KDW LVGLUHFW O\DFFHVVLEOHW RRXUILYHVHQVHV W KLVP HDQV
HYHU\W KLQJW KDW ZHFDQVHHKHDUIHHO
 

VP HOORUW DVW HFRQVLVW VRIDW RP V$OUHDG\W KHVHDW RP VEHLQJEDVLFHOHP HQW VRIGHQVH
P DW W HU DUH H[W UHP HO\ VP DOO DV FRP SDUHG W R RXU XVXDO QRW LRQ RI W KH VHQVHV

7KHUHIRUHDVP DOOSDUW LFOHRILURQVW LOOFRQVLVW VRIKXQGUHGVRIW ULOOLRQVRILURQDW RP V7KLV

W KHP RGHUQP ROHFXODUSK\VLFVFRXOGGHW HUP LQHZLW KW KHLUP HDVXULQJW HFKQLTXHV

7KHHOHP HQW DU\SDUW LFOHVRIZKLFKW KHVXEW OHP DW W HULVFRP SRVHGLVDW OHDVW DW KRXVDQG
W LP HVVP DOOHUW KDQW KHDW RP VRIGHQVHP DW W HU6XEW OHP DW W HUW RRLVDQDW RP LFEXLOGLQJ
P DW HULDORIRXUZRUOG7KHDW RP VRIW KH/LJKW  (W KHUZKLFKDUHW KHVP DOOHVW SDUW LFOHVRI
W KHZRUOGFRUUHVSRQGLQW KHLUVL]HW RW KHODUJHVW RIW KHEDVLFSDUW LFOHVRIVXEW OHP DW W HU  
$W  W KH SRLQW  ZKHUH W KH ZRUOG RI GHQVH P DW W HU HQGV EHJLQV W KH ZRUOG RI VXEW OH P DW W HU
%XW VLQFHDOOJDSVEHW ZHHQW KHDW RP VRIGHQVHP DW W HUDUHILOOHGZLW KVXEW OHP DW W HUW KH
ZRUOGRIGHQVHP DW W HU W KHGHQVHP DW HULDOZRUOG FRQW DLQVZLW KLQLW VHOIDOVRDP XFKILQHU
GLIIHUHQW LDW HGZRUOGRIVXEW OHP DW W HUW KHP LUDFOHVRIZKLFKODW HUJHQHUDW LRQVZLOOSHQHW UDW H
HYHQ GHHSHU  

7KH VW UHDP V RI VXEW OH HQHUJ\ DUH P RYLQJ DQG GLUHFW LQJ W KHVH HOHP HQW DU\ SDUW LFOHV RI
VXEW OH P DW W HU   ZKLFK LQ W XUQ W UDQVIHU W KH LP SXOVH W KXV UHFHLYHG XSRQ W KH DW RP V RI
GHQVHP DW W HU(OHFW ULFLW \SOD\VDODUJHUROHLQW KLVSURFHVV  7KHLQQHUP HFKDQLVP VRI
W KHZRUOGRIGHQVHP DW W HUFRXOGEHLP DJLQHVDVIROORZV W KHYLEUDW LRQVRIVXEW OHHQHUJLHV
ZKLFK FRP H IURP  W KH XQLYHUVH RQW R RXU (DUW K LQIOXHQFH W KH VXEW OH VXEVW DQFHV DQG
W KHVH W UDQVIHU W KHLU HIIHFW V IXUW KHU RQW R W KH GHQVH P DW W HU  7KH HIIHFW V RI W KH IORZV RI
VXEW OHHQHUJ\DFFRUGLQJW RW KDW ZRXOGW KHQRQO\EHUHFRJQL]DEOHE\P HDQVRILQW HUP HGLDU\
P HDVXUHP HQW V LH IURP  FKDQJHV RI GHQVH P DW W HU  7KLV LV VR EHFDXVH RXU VHQVRU\
RUJDQVDUHJHQHUDOO\W XQHGW RGHQVHP DW HULDOP DW W HURQO\

, QW KLVFRQW H[W LW ZRXOGSHUKDSVEHJRRGW RP HQW LRQVRP HGUDZLQJVDQGSDLQW LQJVW KDW
KDYHRULJLQDW HGLQP HGLXP LVW LFLQVLJKW VZKHUHXQLTXHVW UXFW XUHVRIJURXSVRIOLQHVDSSHDU
W KDW  DUH ZLQGLQJ DURXQG HDFK RW KHU P HUJLQJ LQW R HDFK RW KHU DQG W KHQ IORZLQJ DSDUW
DJDLQEXW ZKLFKDOVRUDGLDW HRXW VW DUOLNHRIW HQDVJURXSVRISRLQW V 

6LQFH RXU VXEFRQVFLRXV LV FORVHO\ FRQQHFW HG ZLW K SURFHVVHV RI VXEW OH P DW HULDOV VXFK
P HGLXP LVW LF SURGXFW V SHUKDSV FRXOG EH LQW HUSUHW HG DV P DW HULDOL]HG UHSUHVHQW DW LRQV RI
SURFHVVHV RI VXEW OH P DW W HU

2Q W KH RW KHU KDQG W KHUH DUH SHUVRQV ZKR SHUFHLYH D FRORU VW LP XOXV ZKHQ W KH\ KDYH
W KHLUH\HVFORVHGDQGDQRW HLVSOD\HGRQW KHSLDQR

7KHYLEUDW LQJVW ULQJRIW KHSLDQRVHW VW KHP ROHFXOHVRIW KHDLU LQW RUK\W KP LFP RW LRQ7KH
SK\VLFLVW  FDOOV W KRVH ORQJLW XGLQDO YLEUDW LRQV  7KLV VKDNLQJ RI GHQVH P DW W HU KDV DOVR D
VW URQJGLVW XUEDQFHRIW KHEDODQFHRIVXEW OHP DW W HUDVDFRQVHTXHQFHZKLFKLVEHW ZHHQ
W KH GHQVH P ROHFXOHV RI W KH DLU  )URP  W KLV HP HUJHV D GLUHFW  YLEUDW LRQ RI VXEW OH HQHUJ\

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

ZKLFK JLYHV W R W KH H\H RI D P HGLXP LVW LF OLVW HQHU W KH LOOXVLRQ RI D VSHFLILF OLJKW  UHIOH[  ,
H[SUHVVLYHO\VD\³ LOOXVLRQ´EHFDXVHZHDUHXVHGW RUHIHUDVREM HFW LYHDQGDVUHDOLW \RQO\
W R LP SUHVVLRQV RI GHQVH P DW W HU  

7KLV ZD\ OLJKW  HP HUJHV IURP  VRXQG DFFRUGLQJ W R D ODZ ZKLFK ZH FRXOG ODEHO DV ³ ODZ RI
U RW DW LRQ´ DQG Z KLFK ODZ  FRQW U ROV W KH FRQQHFW LRQ EHW Z HHQ GHQVH P DW W HU  DQG VXEW OH
P DW W HU  7KLV ODZ RI URW DW LRQ VW DW HV W KDW  RXU QRUP DO VHQVRU\ RUJDQV W KDW  DUH VHW  IRU
GHQVH P DW HULDOLP SUHVVLRQVDQGRXUP HGLDORUP HGLXP LVW LFKLJKHUVHQVRU\RUJDQVW KDW
DUHVHW IRUSURFHVVHVLQVXEW OHP DW W HUDUHSRODUW RHDFKRW KHU, QW KLVFDVHIRULQVW DQFH
W KHZDUQLQJYRLFHZLW KLQRXUVHOYHVW KDW ZHFDOOFRQVFLHQFHQDP HO\W KDW ZKLFKLVFHUW DLQ
W KDW ZKLFKLVW KHRQO\W KLQJFHUW DLQW KDW ZKLFKZHNQRZRIRXU VHOYHVLQW KLVUHVSHFW W RD
FRQQHFW LRQZLW KW KLQJVFRVP LFLVSURRIRIDQLQW HUQDOFODLUDXGLHQFHQDP HO\SURRIIRUW KH
FDSDELOLW \RIRXUVXEFRQVFLRXVW RSHUFHLYHVW UHDP VRIVXEW OHHQHUJ\IURP W KHXQLYHUVH  
ZKLFK LQ RQH RI W KH W ZR SUHYLRXV H[DP SOHV P DQLIHVW  DV VLJQDOV RI VXEW OH VRXQGV DQG LQ
W KHRW KHUFDVHDVVLJQDOVRIVXEW OHOLJKW ZKLFKZHUHP HGLDW HGE\IORZVRIVXEW OHHQHUJ\
7RGD\ ZH DUH FDSDEOH RI W UDQVP LW W LQJ ZLW K W KH VLP SOH HOHFW ULFDO ZDYHV RI W KH ZLUHOHVV
W HOHJUDSK\V\P EROVVRXQGVDQGZRUGVW RSODFHVW KRXVDQGVRINLORP HW HUVDZD\VRZK\
VKRXOGW KDW QRW EHW KHFDVHDVZHOOZLW KP XFKILQHUW XQHGIORZVRIVXEW OHHQHUJ\LQP XFK
P RUH YROXP H DQG RQ D KLJKHU SODQH RI VXEW OH P DW W HU  "

7KHUHSHDW HGO\P HQW LRQHGFDSDELOLW \W RKHDULQFRORUVE\KXP DQVZKRDUHRQDKLJKOHYHO

RI H[FLW DELOLW \ VKRZ XV DQHZ SURRI RI W KH NLQVKLS RI VRXQG DQG OLJKW  W KDW  ZDV IRUP HUO\
DVVXP HGE\P \VW LFVDQGZKLFKZDVVLQFHW KHQDOVRSURYHQE\VFLHQFH :HP D\W KLQN
RIW KH)DXVW LDQUHYHODW LRQ

³ 7KH6XQVRXQGVLQDQFLHQW W XQH
LQ W KH VLQJLQJ FRQW HVW  RI W KH EURW KHU VSKHUHV´ 

0XVLF LQ LW V LQVW UXP HQW DO SUDFW LFH LV DSSDUHQW O\ RQO\ D GHQVH P DW HULDO SURFHVV  %XW  W KH
VRXQGZDYHVLQFOXGHVXFKSURFHVVHV W KH\JLYHLP SXOVHDQGVW LP XODW HW KHP VHOYHVDJDLQ
7KH VRXQG ZDYHV RI JRRG P XVLF DUH LQW HQVLILHUV RI 2G JHQHUDW RU V RI 2G  8QGHU W KH
LQIOXHQFH RI VXFK P XVLF KXP DQV DQG REM HFW V OLJKW  XS DQG W KH\ U HYLW DOL]H W KHP VHOYHV
DQGDVDUHVXOW RIKHLJKW HQHGFDSDELOLW \W RUDGLDW HW KH\VSUHDGXSOLIW LQJLP SUHVVLRQV7R
IHHODQGW RVHHW KHVHSKHQRP HQDDQGW KHUHFHSW LYHQHVVRIW KHP GHSHQGVRQW KHOHYHORI
GHYHORSP HQW RIRXUP HGLDODQGP HGLXP LVW LFFDSDELOLW LHV

)URP VFLHQW LILFVLGHW KHUHFDQQRW EHVW DW HGDQ\W KLQJW KDW ZRXOGGHQ\VXFKDGLVW LQFW LRQ
RISHUFHSW LRQEHFDXVHRXUDQLP DOILYHVHQVHVDVZHOODUHGHYHORSHGYHU\GLIIHUHQW O\, I
W KH P HGLXP LVW LF KLJKHU VHQVHV RI RXU DYHUDJH VFLHQW LVW V UHVHDU FKHUV DQG VFKRODUV DV
W KH\ DSSHDU LQ RXU GD\V DV EHLQJ W RW DO DUP FKDLU KXP DQV DUH GXOOHQHG DQG ZLW KHUHG W R
VXFKDGHJUHHDVDUHVXOW RIW KHLUGHQ\LQJDQGODFNRIXVHOLN HW KHLUILYHVHQVHVW KHQZH

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG


 2PLWWHG
 

VKRXOG QRW  EH VXUSULVHG W KDW  W KH\ KDYH VXFK D KDUG W LP H W R DFFHSW  W KH GRFW ULQHV RI
VXEW OH P DW W HU DQG RI VXEW OH HQHUJLHV  )RU VXFK LQVLJKW V LQVLJKW  W KH\ DUH VLP SO\ ODFNLQJ
W KHSUH FRQGLW LRQVDVZHOODVDJRRGDQGIUHHZLOOW RDFFHSW W KHP 

$W LP HW KDW LW VHOILVGHQVH P DW HULDOLVW LFRULHQW HGVXFKDVW KHRQHLQZKLFKZHDUHOLYLQJLV

VLP SO\VDW LVILHGZLW KGHQVHP DW HULDODQGH[W HUQDOSKHQRP HQDDQGW KHQHZLQW HUQDODQG
FRVP LF FXOW XUH RI (XURSH EHJLQV ZLW K W KH NQRZOHGJH DQG W KH DGDSW DW LRQ RI W KH KLJKHU
HQHUJLHVRIVXEW OHGHQVLW \ZKLFKDUHODW HQW XQXVHGGRUP DQW Z LW KLQRXUVHOYHVDQGZKLFK
DUHDZDLW LQJEHLQJDZDNHQHG7KHDUW LVW RIW KHIXW XUHZLOOQRORQJHUEHRQHZKRFRSLHV
ULSVRIIDQGIROORZVVW \OHVEXW DJDLQRQHZKRFUHDW HVSRZHUDQGHQHUJ\DQGDUW LVW ZKR
LV P DJLFDO W HFK Q LFDO   +LV DFK LHY HP HQ W V Z LOO EH P DJLFDO W HFK Q LFDO DU W LVW LF FU HDW LY H
VLP XOW DQHRXVO\DQGW KH\ZLOOLQW URGXFHDQHZFXOW XUHDQGW KH\Z LOORSHQSRVVLELOLW LHVW KDW
SUHVHQW O\ DUH IRUHVHHQ RQO\ E\ SRHW LF IDQW DV\

:KRHYHUKDVDQXQGHUVW DQGLQJRIW KHILQHUIRUP DW LYHSRZHUVRIODQJXDJHDQGP XVLFDQG

RIW KHVXEW OHHQHUJ\VW UHDP VLQQDW XUHKHLVDOUHDG\RQW KHSDW KW RDKLJKHULQVLJKW RI
H[LVW HQFH

0XVLFLQFOXGHVLP SXOVHZLW KLQLW VHOILW LVDQLP SXOVHJLYHUDQGW KHUHIRUHW RW KLVGD\LW LV
W KHRQO\NQRZQP HDQVW KDW SXW VXVLQW RW KHSRVLW LRQW REHFDSDEOHRIJHQHUDW LQJSULP DU\
P RYHP HQW V ZLW KLQ RXU ZRUOG  

7KHUHIRUH P XVLF ZLOO SOD\ D JUHDW  UROH LQ W KH W HFKQRORJ\ RI W KH IXW XUH  7KH HQOLYHQLQJ
HIIHFW W KDW DIDVW P DUFKKDVRQW LULQJP DUFKLQJW URRSVLVZHOONQRZQ$OOIXUW KHUSRVVLELOLW LHV
DUHEXW DTXHVW LRQRILQW HQVLILFDW LRQDQGUHILQHP HQW RIHIIHFW V

$ZHOO HVW DEOLVKHGIDFW LVW KDW VLFNSHRSOHIRULQVW DQFHSHRSOHZKRDUHSDUDO\]HGFDQEH

P DGHW RIHHOEHW W HUZLW KP XVLF

/HW ¶VORRNDW W KHDFRXVW LFSURFHVVHVLQQDW XUH QDW XUHVHUYHG DVW KHSULP DU\P RGHOIRU
HYHU\SULP LW LYHW HFKQRORJ\

7KHP RVW EUXW DOVRXQGLVW KHW KXQGHURIW KHOLJKW QLQJ:KDW LVLW VSXUSRVH", W LQW HQGVW R
FOHDQVH 7KHH[W HQW W RZKLFKW KHSXULI\LQJLP SXOVHW KDW LVFRQFHDOHGLQW KHVRXQGRIW KH
W KXQGHULVJHQHUDW LQJR]RQHVKRXOGEHOHIW W RDVRXQG FKHP LVW U\ RIW KHIXW XUH

7KHUHIRUH EUXW DOVXGGHQO\VW RSSLQJVRXQGVFRQW DLQFOHDQVLQJLP SXOVHV

:KDW  LV W KH SXUSRVH RI W KH P XUP XU RI D SHDFHIXOO\ IORZLQJ OLW W OH EURRN"  , W  LQW HQGV W R
HQOLYHQ

$OOVRXQGVW KDW DUHW ULFNOLQJDQGP XUP XULQJFRQW DLQHQOLYHQLQJLP SXOVHV  

, Q IXW XUH P XVLF ZLOO QRW  VHUYH UHFUHDW LRQ DORQH EXW  DV KDSSHQHG DOUHDG\ LQ DQFLHQW
W LP HVLW ZLOODOVRVHUYHZRUN7KHUK\W KP LFVRQJVW KDW LQDQFLHQW W LP HVDFFRP SDQLHGDOO
ZRUNKDYHGLVDSSHDUHGIURP GDLO\SUDFW LFHZLW KW KHH[FHSW LRQRIVRP HP LQXW HOHIW RYHUV
RI W KLV P HW KRG  7KH VRQJ EU RXJKW  W KH EU HDW K LQW R U K\W KP  DQG P DGH LW  FDSDEOH W R
VSHFLILF SHDN DFKLHYHP HQW V HVSHFLDOO\ ZKHQ SHRSOH ZRUNHG W RJHW KHU  0RUH FRP P RQO\

2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

VW LOOLQSUDFW LFHLVW KHKHDYH KRIRULQVW DQFHZKHQSHRSOHM RLQW O\OLIW VRP HW KLQJKHDY\RU

XVHDUDP RUSLOHGULYHU, QDQFLHQW W LP HVSHRSOHNQHZW KDW W KHUK\W KP LFEUHDW KFRXOGEH
XVHGW RHOLP LQDW HJUDYLW \

)URP  W KH Z RUG W R W KH 5XQH W KDW  FRU U HVSRQGV W R LW  LV RQO\ D VP DOO P HQW DO VW HS

7KHUHIRUHW KHJUHDW RUDW RUDQGSULHVW ZDVDOVRW KHJUHDW P DJLFLDQDW DOOW LP HVZKRZDV

FDSDEOHRISXW W LQJSHRSOHXQGHUKLVVSHOODQGE\P HDQVRILP DJHDQGDGDSW HGFUHDW LRQRI
IRUP  KH FRXOG HGXFDW H W KHP  DQG XSOLIW  W KHP  DQG LQ W KLV SURFHVV KH VKRZHG D ZD\
XSZDUG KH DOVR SURFUHDW HG W KHP  XSZDUG DQG EUHG W KHP  LQ DQ XSZDUG GLUHFW LRQ  7KLV
JURXS RI ZRUGV KLQDXI ]HLJHQ KLQDXI ]HXJHQ KLQDXI ]FKW HQ  W R VKRZ XSZDUGV W R
SURFUHDW H XSZDUGV DQG W R EUHHG LQ XSZDUG GLUHFW LRQ  SURYHV W KDW  W KHVH ZRUGV EHORQJ
W RJHW KHUDVDUHVXOW RIW KHNLQVKLSRIW KHLGHDVW KDW W KH\UHSU HVHQW DQGH[SUHVVVRW KDW
RQH FDQ EH GHGXFW HG IU RP  W KH RW KHU  RQH  7KLV LV D OLW W OH H[DP SOH RI W KH P DJLF RI
ODQJXDJH

5XQHV HQJUDYLQJV P XUP XUV 5XQHQ 5DXQXQJHQ 5LW ]XQJHQ  ZKLFK DUH QRW  GHVLJQHG
W RUHSUHVHQW M XVW DVRXQGEXW ZKROHZRUGVVHQW HQFHVZLVKHVH[SUHVVLRQVRIW KHZLOO
RUGHUV FRQM XUDW LRQV LQ EULHI W KH\ VHQW  RXW  VW UHDP V RI HQHUJ\  W KDW  ZHUH GHVLJQHG W R
FUHDW HDYLVLEOHRURW KHUZLVHSHUFHLYDEOHHIIHFW :HNQRZDOVRW KDW W KHHDUOLHVW KLHURJO\SKV
ZLW KW KHVHW ZRW HUP V5XQHVDQGKLHURJO\SKVZHDUHQRW UHIHUU LQJW RKLVW RULFDOOHIW RYHUV
EXW  W R VSHFLILF P DJLFDOO\ DQG FRVP LFDOO\ URRW HG P HW KRGV  KDYH KDG FRORU W KH\ ZHUH
SDLQW HG DQG ZH NQRZ W KDW  W KH YDULRXV FRORUV ZHUH XVHG W R W ULJJHU GLIIHUHQW  P DJLFDO
HIIHFW V DFFRUGLQJ W R W KH ZLOO RI W KHLU RULJLQDW RUV DQG W KH DW W LW XGH RI W KH SHUVRQ W RZDUGV
ZKRP W KHVHHIIHFW VZHUHGLUHFW HG7KHP RGHUQW KHUDSLHVRIOLJKW DQGFRORUDUHEHJLQQLQJV
ZKLFKLQW URGXFHDJDLQDQFLHQW NQRZOHGJHLQW RW KHDUW RIKHDOLQJRIZKLFKW KHP DJLFLDQ
DUW LVW  SK\VLFLDQ DQG SULHVW  VLP XOW DQHRXVO\  ZDV P DVW HU  $QG D P DJLFLDQ LV DOVR D
P DVW HUDP DVW HURIP DJLFZKRKDVSRZHU3RZHUDQGP DJLF 0DFKW XQG0DJLH DUHD
FRP P RQ H[SUHVVLRQ DQG W KHUHIRUH W KH\ RULJLQDW HG IURP  D FRP P RQ U RRW  ZRUG

(YHU\ W UXH SLHFH RI DUW  KDV D VSHFLILF LQQHU YLEUDW LRQ W KDW  SRZ HUIXOO\ H[FLW HV VRXO VSLULW
DQGERG\7KHUHIRUHLW KDVQRW M XVW DQH[W HULRUHIIHFW EXW DOVRDQHIIHFW W KDW EHORQJVW R
W KH ZRUOGV RI IHHOLQJ RI UK\W KP  DQG RI W KH VRXO  ZKLFK HIIHFW  KRZHYHU LV SDVVLYH DQG
XQFKDQJHDEOHLHDIW HUW KHZRUNLVILQLVKHGLW UHP DLQVDOZD\ VW KHVDP H

%\P HDQVRIDQLQFUHDVHRIW KH2GLFLQIOXHQFHVDW ZLOOLHD³ FKDUJLQJ´LVW KHP DJLFDO

DQGVXEW OHHIIHFW RIDZRUNRIDUW P DGHSRVVLEOHDIW HULW VFRP SOHW LRQ6XFKZRUNVRIDUW
FDQ EH W ULJJHUHG E\ W KH 2GLF UK\W KP  RI W KH REVHUYHU W KH FRQGLW LRQ RI KLV VRXO DQG
HP RW LRQVDQGKLVLQQHUFDSDELOLW \W RJHQHUDW HW KHVDP HYLEUDW LRQDQGFRQQHFW LW ZLW KW KH
SLHFH RI DUW   7KHUHIRUH VXFK YLEUDW LRQV DUH QRW  LQGHSHQGHQW  RI W KHLU VXUURXQGLQJV EXW
W KH\DUHFKDQJHDEOHVXEM HFW LYHDQGDFW LYH

:HDUHTXLW HFRUUHFW ZKHQZHVSHDNRIVRXQGVRIFRORUVDQGRIW RQHVRIFRORUVDQGRXU

ODQ JX DJH SRLQ W V W R W K H U HDOLW \  RI  VX FK  SK HQ RP HQ D  RW K HU Z LVH LW  Z RX OG ODFN  VX FK
H[SUHVVLRQV  &HUW DLQ VRXQGV ZH SHUFHLYH DV P DOOHDEOH RW KHUV DV IODW  RW KHUV DJDLQ DV
ZDUP RUVRIW KDUGDQGFROGDQGZLW KRXW P XFKW KRXJKW ZHW UDQVIHUVXFKQRW LRQVXSRQ
 

W KDW ZKLFKKDVEHHQSDLQW HGXSRQDUFKLW HFW XUDOVW UXFW XUHVRUXSRQSRHW LFZRUNV7KLVLV

VR EHFDXVH DOO IRUP V RIDUW RULJLQDW HIURP  RQH VLQJOHFUHDW LYH8U LQW HQW 7KHUHIRUHZH
VKRXOG QRW  EH VXUSULVHG W KDW  FRORUV IRUP V VKDSHV W RQHV DQG Z RUGV KDYH P XW XDOO\
HIIHFW LYHUHODW LRQVRIVXEW OHP DW W HUVRW KDW W KH\P XW XDOO\HQOLYHQVW UHQJW KHQVXSSRUW 
FRP SOHP HQW DQGH[SODLQ)RULQVW DQFHW KHXQLYHUVLW \SURIHVVRU 'U3ROHQVNHKDVIRXQG
RXW W KDW W KHYRZHOVRIDJRRGSLHFHRISRHW U\DUHDUUDQJHGDFFRUGLQJW RDVSHFLILFVFDOH
RIYDOXHVRIW RQHVW KDW KHGLVFRYHUHG:KHQW KLVSRHW U\LVW UDQVODW HGLQW RP XVLFW KHVH
W RQHV JHQHUDW H D KDUP RQLF VHTXHQFH RI VRXQGV D P HORG\  %DG SRHW U\ RQ W KH RW KHU
KDQGFDQJHQHUDW HRQO\DQXQFRRUGLQDW HGDQGDUELW UDULO\DUUD\RIW RQHVW KDW LVLQFRKHUHQW 
W KHUHIRUH QR P XVLFDOO\ FU\VW DOOL]HG P DJLFDO VHTXHQFH RI W RQHV W KDW  LV RUGHUHG ZLW KLQ
LWVHOI

7KDW  VHHP LQJO\ OLIHOHVV VW UXFW XUHV VXFK DV SDLQW LQJV DQG VFXOSW XUHV FDQ EH W ULJJHUHG
ZLW KLQRXUVHOYHVE\P HDQVRIP XVLFKDVEHHQSURYHQP DQ\W LP HV$SDUW RIW KHVXSHULRU
W HFKQRORJ\ RI W KH IXW XUH W KHUHIRUH ZLOO DW W HP SW  W R KHLJKW HQ W KH LQQHU SRZHU RI P XVLF
SDLQW LQJDUFKLW HFW XUHHW FLQEULHIDOODUW 7KLVZLOOQRW KDSSHQE\P HDQVRILQFUHDVHDQG
SHUIHFW LRQRIW KHGHQVHP DW HULDOW HFKQRORJLFDOP HDQVEXW DORQHE\P HDQVRIKHLJKW HQLQJ
W KHVRXO HP RW LRQDODGGLW LRQVW KDW DUHRIVXEW OHP DW W HUDQGZLW KW KLVW KHHIIHFW VRIVXEW OH
P DW W HUDUHLQFUHDVHGDQGVW UHQJW KHQHG

, IZHHQW HUDP HGLHYDOFDW KHGUDOLQZKLFKW KHVW DLQHGJODVVZLQGRZVUHP DLQHGZHKDYH

W KHUH DQ HYLGHQW O\ VSHDNLQJ ZLW QHVV RI W KH OLYLQJ SRZHU RI W KH OLJKW  VSHFW UXP  W KDW  LV
IORZLQJLQLW VVHYHQFRORUV+HUHSHQHW UDW HXVDQGDFW XSRQXVQRW RQO\H[W HUQDORSW LFDO
VHQVRU\SHUFHSW LRQVEXW DOVRIORZVRIVXEW OHHQHUJLHVZKLFKLQGXFHGDQDUW W RXVZKLFK
LV ORVW  QRZ  , W  LV QR FRLQFLGHQFH W KDW  W KH P RGHUQ W LP HV KDYH ORVW  W KLV W HFKQLTXH VLQFH
P DJLFDO NQRZ OHGJH DQG P HW KRGV RI P DJLFDO DUW  Z HUH XVHG Z KHQ W KHVH JODVVHV DQG
FRORUVZHUHP DGH  7KHVHKXP DQEHLQJVKDYHEHHQSHQHW UDW HGE\DUHDOREVHVVLRQIRU
W KH OLYLQJ IORZLQJ DQG UDGLDW LQJ OLJKW  IRU W KH 'LYLQH 6XQ DQG W KH\ VDZ W R LW  W KDW  W KHLU
VRXOVZHUHSHQHW UDW HGE\W KHVHUD\VZKHQW KH\ZHQW W RZRUN7KH\ZHUHEHOLHYHUVLQD
KLJKHUP HDQLQJW KH\NQHZRIW KHP DJLFRIW KHSRZHURIOLIHDQGRILW VSKHQRP HQDDQG
W KHUHIRUH W KH\ FRXOG EH W KH JUHDW  SDLQW HUV RI /LJKW  W KH NQRZOHGJH DQG VNLOOV RI ZKLFK
HYHQ W KH KLJKHVW  VW UXQJ W HFKQRORJLFDO W UDLQLQJ FDQQRW  UHSODFH  7HFKQRORJ\ RI GHQVH
P DW W HURIW KHSUHVHQW QHYHUZLOOEHDEOHW RUHSODFHP DJLFNDQGVSLULW XDOSRZHU7KHUHIRUH
ZH DUH SRRU DV FRP SDUHG W R RXU DQFHVW RUV DQG ³ SULP LW LYH´  SHRSOHV ZKHQ LW  FRP HV W R
W UXH DUW  2QO\ W KHQ FDQ ZH FRP H FORVH W R W KHP  DV IDU DV JHQLXV SRZHU DQG SXULW \ DUH
FRQFHUQHG ZKHQ ZH KDYH FRP P DQG RYHU W KH VSLULW XDO VW UHDP V W KDW  ZH UHFRJQL]HG LQ
W KH5XQHVDVSRLQW VRIFROOHFW LRQRIHQHUJLHVRIVXEW OHHQHUJLHVDQGHIIHFW VDQGZKHQZH
XVHW KHP DJDLQ


2PLWWHG
 

7KHVW DUW LQJSRLQW IRUW KHVHH[SODQDW LRQVRIW KH5XQHVDVVW UHDP VRIVXEW OHHQHUJLHVRI
W KH XQLYHUVH ZDV IRXQG W KH P DJLFDO W HFKQLFDO H[SHULP HQW V LQ W KH SDLQW LQJV DQG LQ W KH
UHVHDUFK RI VXEW OH HQHUJLHV RI W KH SK\VLFLVW  SDLQW HU DQG SKLORVRSKHU 'U , QJ )ULHGULFK
7HOW VFKHU  ZKRVD\VW KHIROORZLQJLQ%RRNOHW RIW KHP RQW KO\SXEOLFDW LRQHag- All= All-
Hag

“ We are living on t he Eart h and we see t he st ars m oving along t heir t racks in t he night
sky. The first basis of t he knowledge of our world im age t herefore is an opt ical one.
Modern ast ronom y is based on t he law of gravit y. This m eans t hat t wo bodies at t ract
each ot her wit h a force t hat is inversely proport ional t o t he square of t heir dist ance
from each ot her. To deepen our underst anding of an exact world view, we have t herefore
t o gain knowledge of energies t hat are blocked, for inst ance, t hat t he eart h would fall
int o t he sun if it had not it s own m ovem ent around it .

Now ast rology assum es an influence of t he posit ion of t he st ars upon t he dest iny of t he
hum an being, and ast ro- m et eorology is based on t he influence of st ellar posit ions upon
t he form at ion of t he weat her. Sim ilarly, we could develop an ast ro- geology. All t hose
influences do not fit int o t he world view of exact science, because neit her t he science of
t he light nor t he science of gravit y can explain such influences.

Therefore we are eit her forced t o rej ect t he ast ro- sciences or t o search for an expansion
of t he basic energies t hat are considered t o be act ive in our m odel of t he world.

Let ’s m ake such an at t em pt , i.e., t o go t his pat h, and let ’s st at e a prelim inary working
hypot hesis of a t hird basic energy besides light and weight ( gravit y) , which are st ream s
of subt le energy.

These st ream s of subt le energy we assum e now as free energies t hat are act ive wit hout
being blocked in any way, and which t he planet s and t he Sun send t owards t he Eart h,
and t hey have t he role of basic energies t hat provide form at ion.

All m ore subt le com posit ions of m inerals, st ones, pert rificat ions, but also of living beings
are, according t o t hat , t he consequences of st ream s of subt le energies, which com e t o
our eart h from t he universe. These flows of subt le energy would even be part of t he
shaping of our m ood, and according t o t hat t hey would have influence upon t he econom ic
and polit ical event s on t he Eart h.

The assum pt ion of st ream s of subt le energy would t hen clarify an array of fact s t hat t o
t his day could not be explained.

I n t he following it is im port ant t hat we bring proof of t he possibilit y of t he exist ence of

energies of a subt le nat ure t hat act in such a way, because a working hypot hesis can
only becom e a science, if it is back ed by sufficient fact s as pr oof, be t hese fact s
hist orical, done by experim ent , and furt herm ore, if t heir pract ical usefulness has been
est ablished.

'U, QJ7HOW VFKHUDGRFW RURIHQJLQHHULQJZ KRW DXJKW DW W KHXQLYHUVLW \RI, QQVEUXFN$XVW ULD


KDGGLVFRYHUHGW KH³ LQW HOOHFW XDOELRUK\W KP ´ RIGD\V

 

Here we will st ill briefly t ouch upon an im port ant quest ion: if st ream s of subt le energy
exist , why have t hey not been discovered long ago and analyzed wit h precision? Wit h
t his quest ion we t ouch upon t he m ost difficult t o overcom e block against t he whole
sit uat ion. Because t hese energies are so subt le, t hey escape our direct observat ion
m ost of t he t im e. I n ot her words, our norm al organs of percept ion, such as t he eye and
t he ear, are not suit ed t o det ect st ream s of subt le energies and our m edial sensory
organs are degenerat ed and wit hered m ost of t he t im e. And not wit hst anding of t hat
t he st ream s of subt le energies can be proven under som e circum st ances.

A possibilit y t o ex plain t he Runes could per haps be in t heir char act er ist ic as being
sym bols for com pounds of st ream s of subt le energies, not unlike chem ical com pounds.

I n ancient t radit ions we can see clearly t hat t he cosm ic feeling of our ancest ors was
already on a high level, in any case on a m uch higher level t han is t he case wit h m ost
people of t he pr esent t im es. We can w ell assum e t hat t his fact could also hav e
m anifest ed in t he sym bols of writ ing, t he Runic alphabet .

Let ’s t ry t o exam ine t he Runic sym bols, especially t he eight een Runes of t he Fut hark,
on t he basis of t his assum pt ion.

For t hat purpose we have t o put t he runes int o t wo classes, nam ely:
A. Runes wit h full lengt h lines, i.e., Runes, t he lines of which are of equal lengt h, and
B. Runes wit h full lengt h and half lengt h lines, i.e., Runes, where we can see lines of full
lengt h and of half lengt h.
Finally t he Group C: Runes, which consist only of half lines. Group A can be regarded as
connect ion of equivalent st ream s of subt le energies; each full lengt h line describes an
individual st ream of subt le energy. The angle of int ersect ion of 60 degrees m eans a
harm onic int eract ion and cooperat ion of t he corresponding st ream s of subt le energies.

According t o t hat we have t hree such connect ions:

A. The I S Rune: Only one full line, t herefore t he only st ream of subt le energy
B. The EH Rune: A harm onic connect ion of t wo st ream s of subt le energy
C. The HAGAL Rune: Harm onic connect ion of t hree st ream s of subt le energy.
Connect ions wit h m ore t han t hree independent st ream s of subt le energy would not
exist in our world according t o t hat  
I n Group B t he short er lines would m ean auxiliary lines of power, or energy, which adapt
t hem selves t o t he basic st ream s of subt le energy, such as is t he case wit h t he LAF
Rune. The vert ical full line is t he support ing m ain flow of subt le energy, while t he
inclined line on t op is t he working auxiliary flow of subt le energy.

As Werner von Bülow has proven, t he runic inscript ions and t rue old coat s of arm s
( which t oo are Runic docum ent s according t o t heir lines and im ages) refer indeed t o
flow s of subt le ener gies t hat t r igger m ovem ent s in t he sider eal pendulum t hat t he
experim ent er holds above t hem .


 2PLWWHG
 

I n ot her words: Runes and coat s of arm s in nat ure or also on phot ographs are not
giving t he usual vibrat ions and figures of t he pendulum t hat t he st one, wood or m et al of
which t hey consist is supposed t o deliver, but t hey produce specific im ages t hat st ill
have t o be int erpret ed. There is m uch hard work st ill t o do in t his respect .

These hint s should suffice for t he m om ent . The ext rem ely im port ant and basic m eanings
of t he Runic sym bols as im ages of connect ion bet w een and com binat ions of subt le
energies is obvious by now.

According t o t hat , t he ancient Runes are sym bols t hat som ewhat correspond t o t he
sym bols of m odern chem ist ry  . To int erpret and recognize t hem would have a significant
expansion of our world view as a consequence.

This conclusion m ay possibly seem a bit t oo early, even t oo bold. A final j udgm ent is
possible only aft er science penet rat es t he field of physics of subt le energies which is
ent irely new for us. But , we are fort unat e enough t o have also a hist orical m onum ent
t hat gives us a few closer hint s and from which t he deeper m eaning of t he Runes as far
as nat ural processes are concerned em erges very clearly. Wit h t his, we m ean t he very
ancient song in t he Edda, “ Wodan’s Rune Song” and som e passages in t he skalds-
Kaparm al of t he narrat ive Edda.

From t his song we can clearly see t hat each rune cont ains a healing power as well as a
defensive power. Here t he Rune is not j ust a pure m eans for com m unicat ion such as
our m odern sym bols of writ ing, but each Rune is m ent ioned here as a m eans t o cause
or force a specific st at e wit hin ourselves or around us. And t hat exact ly is what we
m ean when referring t o t he not ion of connect ions wit h st ream s of subt le energies.

Let ’s t ake t he I S Rune as t he m ost sim ple exam ple. Wodan says about it :

“ This I sing as a nint h, when dist ress at sea forces m e

To prot ect m y ship against t he billowing floods,
The st orm I cause t o calm down and I calm down t he sea as well
And I put t he waves int o slum ber.

I n t he opinion t hat we represent here, t his would refer t o t he following basic law concerning
t he st ream s of subt le energies on our planet :

On one hand, we can re- const it ut e dist urbed balances in t he air wit h t he help of a
sim ple st ream of subt le energy. On t he ot her hand we have t o look at st ream s of subt le
energy when t rying t o explain dist urbances in t he air and t he weat her.

Proof t hat m odern nat ural science has by far not explained everyt hing in t he field of
hydrom echanics are basic waves in ot herwise calm weat her, for inst ance t he so- called
‘sh oot in g’ or ‘r oar in g’ of t h e lak e on t h e Lak e of Con st an ce. Th is appear s m ost
pronouncedly when t he hot wind st art s, i.e., in dist urbances of t he air. This can be
easily explained as an accom panying effect when seen in t he light of sim ple st ream s, or
flows, of subt le energy.
I n any case, several very unique nat ural phenom ena point t o t he fact t hat we by far do
not know our eart h sufficient ly and no doubt will we achieve significant progress in t his
field wit h t he int roduct ion of t he not ion of flows of subt le energies.
2PLWWHG

 

But let ’s go back now t o t he song. From t he int erpret at ion of t his single st anza follows
very clearly t hat wit h t echnology of st ream s of subt le energies we can achieve a m uch
m ore perfect cont rol of nat ural processes t han wit h t he m eans of nowadays m odern
t echnology. Perhaps our ancest ors possessed ext ensive m eans in t his field. People of
our days have t o st art all over again.

And here we find a concise pat h, st art ing wit h a lit t le experim ent in t he laborat ory,
slowly ascending and progressing all t he way t o a cosm ic power plant , very sim ilar as
happened wit h t he developm ent of t he t echnology of elect ricit y t hat st art ed wit h frog
legs and went all t he way t o t he elect ric t rain.

Finally we want t o m ent ion a very im port ant fact : At t he end of t he song, t here is
em phasis t hat Rune t echnology is especially developed for t he Aryan, and t hat in t he
developm ent of t echnology of st ream s of subt le energies t he Aryans will play an im port ant
role. Then it is also necessary t hat especially Aryans acquire basic knowledge in t his
field.

Not acquiring of t reasures of knowledge serves progress, but , quit e t o t he cont rary, t he
int er ior ex per ience, or co- ex per ience of t hem . Ther efor e t he t echnology of subt le
energies will not find any fert ile ground wit h people who m easure t he value of a science
wit h a yardst ick and wit h scales, but wit h t hose who feel st ream s of subt le energies
w it hin t hem selv es.” 

7KHVW UHDP VRIVXEW OHHQHUJLHVDUHW KHP XUP XULQJ5XQHV GLHUDXQHQGHQ5XQHQ LQRXU

H[LVW HQFH7KH\P XUP XUIORZVXUJHZLW KLQRXUVHOYHVDQGLQW KHLUODQJXDJHFRQW LQXRXVO\
W HOOXVZKDW LVJRRGIRUXVZKDW ZHRZQZKDW ZHDUHODFNLQJDQGW KH\EHVW RZXVZLW K
VW URQJSRZHUKHDOW KEXW W KH\DOVREULQJW KHFORVHHQGRIGHQVHP DW W HU

, W LVW RREDGW KDW W KHUHDUHQRW M XVW OLIHJLYLQJDQGJRRGVXEW OHP DW HULDOVEXW FRUUHVSRQGLQJ

W R GHQVH P DW W HU DOVR QR[LRXV VXEW OH P DW W HU DQG VW UHDP V RI VXEW OH HQHUJLHV SRLVRQRXV
VXEW OH P DW W HU  $FFRUGLQJ W R W KDW  ZH FDQ DVFULEH W KH EDG YLEUDW LRQV RI VRP H ORFDW LRQV
SDLQW LQJV 5RRP V SUHFLRXV VW RQHV HW F DVFULEH DW  OHDVW  SDUW LDOO\ W R SRLVRQRXV VXEW OH
P DW W HU

:H EHW W HU VKRXOG OLVW HQ W R W KHP  EHFDXVH W KH\ DUH RXU LQQHU KHOS ZDUQLQJ XV DJDLQVW
DFFLGHQW V DQG GLVHDVH W KH\ DUH W KH JXDUGLDQV RI RXU KHDOW K  :H QHYHU VKRXOG QHJOHFW
VW UHQJW KHQLQJ W KH VW UHDP V RI VXEW OH HQHUJ\ LQ RXU ERG\ E\ P HDQV RI H[HUFLVH VSRUW V
P DVVDJH GHHS EUHDW KLQJ 5XQH SRVW XUHV E\ P HDQV RI M R\ JRRGQHVV DQG ORYH  $V
LP SRUW DQW IRUOLIHDVVW UHDP VRIVXEW OHHQHUJ\DUHLIW KH\DUHIORZLQJZKHUHW KH\VKRXOG
IORZ DV QR[LRXV W KH\ FDQ EHFRP H ZKHQ W KH\ JHW  W R SODFHV ZKHUH W KH\ VKRXOG QRW  EH
$VDZKROHW KH\DUHW KH8U HOHP HQW RIRXULQQHUIHHOLQJVDQG³ W KHIHHOLQJ´ LVHYHU\W KLQJ
VD\V *RHW KH

  7KLV FRP HV W R W KH HQG RI *RUVOHEHQ¶V TXRW H RI 'U 7HOW VFKHU DUW LFOH W KDW  DSSHDUHG LQ +HIW


%RRNOHW RIW KHP RQW KO\SXEOLFDW LRQHag- All= All- Hag5HJUHW W DEO\*RUVOHEHQGRHVQRW W HOOXV
ZKDW \HDUW KHDUW LFOHDSSHDUHG
 

7KHQHZGRFW ULQHRIW KHVXEW OHHQHUJ\LQW URGXFHVDQLP SRUW DQW HUDLHW KHFRQQHFW LRQ
RIP DW HULDOLVP ZLW KVSLULW XDOLVP , W GHOLYHUVW KHEULGJHXSRQZKLFKDQHZFRVP LFFXOW XUH
FDQVW ULGHW KHILUVW VW HSVLQW RDQHZHUD$OOSXUHKXP DQVZKRDUHVW ULYLQJW RJHW DKHDG
DUH QRZ VW DUW LQJ IURP  P DW HULDOLVP  RU VSLULW XDOLVP  DQG W KH\ KDYH W R XQLI\  $V ORQJ DV
W KHUH LV GLVVLSDW LRQ DV LW  LV XS W R QRZ QRW KLQJ JUHDW  FDQ KDSSHQ LQ W KH P HDQLQJ RI D
YDOXDEOH OHDGHU VKLS W RZ DU GV P XW XDO U HFRJQLW LRQ RI KXP DQV RI RQH Z LW K HDFK RW KHU
7KHUHIRUHLW ZLOOEHDGLIILFXOW W DVNEHFDXVHHYHU\SDUW EHOLHYHVW RNQRZDOUHDG\HYHU\W KLQJ
DQGW REHH[FOXVLYHO\FRUUHFW :HGRQRW GHQ\W KHGHQVHP DW HULDOZRUOGEXW ZHFDQQRW
GHQ\W KHZRUOGRIVXEW OHP DW W HUDQGLW VIDFW VHLW KHU2QO\W KLVZD\FDQZHILQGW KHEHVW
RI ERW K ZRUOGV

, I ZH DUH IDP LOLDU RI GHDOLQJ ZLW K W KH VW UHDP V RI VXEW OH HQHUJ\ ZH FDQ OHDUQ W R GLUHFW
W KHVHHQHUJLHVDQGW RXVHW KHP W RW KHZHOO EHLQJRIDOOKXP DQV 7KHP DLQHIIHFW RIW KH
5XQHV OLHV LQ W KH IDFW  W KDW  W KH\ DUH VSLULW XDO P HDQV W R FOHDQVH DQG W R QRXULVK LH W KDW
W KH\KDYHDQHIIHFW RIVSLULW XDOFOHDQVLQJDQGQRXULVKP HQW 

7KHQHZUHDOP RINQRZOHGJHDQGSURRIW KDW W KHGRFW ULQHRIW KHVXEW OHHQHUJLHVRSHQVXS

IRUXVZLOOEHUHYROXW LRQDU\IRUKXP DQNLQGLQLW VP XOW LSOHSRW HQW LDOVRIXVHVLP LODUW RW KH
GLVFRYHU\ RI HOHFW ULFLW \  %XW  W KH VXEW OH P DW HULDOV DUH QRW  RQO\ OLP LW HG W R W KDW  ZKLFK LV
P DW HULDOEXW W KH\UHODW HDERYHDOOW RW KDW ZKLFKLVVSLULW XDODQGHP RW LRQDOUHODW HGW RW KH
VRXO  , I ZH GR QRW  OLP LW  RXUVHOYHV W R W KH ILYH VHQVHV DV VRP HW KLQJ W R SHUFHLYH W KH
HQYLURQP HQW  ZH UHDFK KHUH D W HUULW RU\ RI W KDW  ZKLFK LV DERYH W KH VHQVHV LH W KLQJV
W KDW  W R W KLV SRLQW  LQ W LP H UHP DLQHG FORVHG W R FRQVFLRXV H[SHULHQFH DQG H[SHULP HQW DO
W HVW V  2I FRXUVH W KHUH KDYH EHHQ H[FHSW LRQV W R W KDW  LQ DOO HUDV DQG W KHVH H[FHSW LRQV
KDYH EHHQ GRFXP HQW HG E\ W KH P RVW  DQFLHQW  RI W UDGLW LRQV RI KXP DQNLQG SURYLGHG ZH
XQGHUVW DQGFRUUHFW O\P \W KVDQGOHJHQGVDQGW KHVDFUHGERRNVRIDOOSHRSOHVDQGW LP HV
DQG ZH NQRZ W KDW  W KHUH ZDV RQFH D P DJLFDO HUD ZLW K KXP DQV ZKR FRXOG GR P RUH W KDQ
KXP DQV RI RXU GD\V QR P DW W HU KRZ HYROYHG RXU W HFKQLTXH RI GHQVH P DW W HU P D\ EH
SUHVHQW HG

+HUH ZH P D\ SHU SHUKDSV DOORZHG XQG RI JHQHUDO LP SRUW DQFH LI Z H P HQW LRQ W KH EDVLF
DW W LW XGH W R W KHVH TXHVW LRQV RI SHU KDSV W KH P RVW  LP SRU W DQW  SK\ VLFLVW  RI W KH SU HVHQW
W LP HVW KHVHFUHW FRXQFLO3URI'U/HQDUGRIW KH8QLYHUVLW \RI+HLGHOEHUJZKRVHUHVHDUFK
RIFDW KRGHUD\VDQGDOVRRI;UD\VUDGLRDFW LYLW \OHGW RQHZDQGGHHSHQHGLQVLJKW VLQW KH
H[DFW VFLHQFHVFRQFHUQLQJHOHFW ULFLW \DQGP DW W HUZKRZDVDP DQRIJHQLXVDQGZRUOGZLGH
UHSXW DW LRQ ODXUHDW H RI W KH 1REHO 3ULFH DQG ZKR LV DOVR EH\RQG D VXVSLFLRQ RI EHLQJ D
³ GUHDP HU ´  +H ZURW H W R P H ZKHQ VHQGLQJ P H KLV EDVLF ZRUN FRQFHUQLQJ FDW KRGH UD\V
RQ 'HFHP EHU  
 

“ You have pleased m e several t im es by sending m e your m ost valued m essages, and
when I received som et hing from you, t hen I was pleased, because it was always basic
and it had lot s of new ideas and cont ent . I want t o send you m y best t hanks and, as a
lit t le response, please t ake som et hing t hat I am sending, which com es from a t im e,
when I st ill did not know t hat t he branch, on which I was sit t ing t o pract ice m y t ype of
science was about t o be cut off. To t he out side, of course, m y work seem ed successful.
X rays followed and m uch ot her research, in which m any people are st ill seeing ‘cult ure’.”

$QG RQ $XJXVW    KH DGGV W KHVH ZRUGV

“ I believe t hat bot h of us reach t he sam e goal, nam ely a view t hat is ent irely opposit e
t o m at erialism : Your way proceeding from t he inside out ward, while I am proceeding
from t he out side inward. The lat t er is t he pat h of t he nat ural scient ist . On t his pat h it
becom es increasingly clear t hat m at t er is a special form of t he et her. These insight s
cam e fort h in all m y work, as you can see in t he essay t hat I have m ailed t o you earlier
( about t he Cat hode rays) . This way, I hope, we will not lose each ot her on t his st range
Eart h, regardless of our very different approaches.”

7KHVW UHDP VRIVXEW OHHQHUJ\DUHP XUP XULQJDQGZKLVSHULQJW KH\ DUHUXQQLQJDQGW KH\

DUH UXVKLQJ ZLW KLQ XV  $V D ZKROH W KH\ FRQVW LW XW H W KH P RVW  HVVHQW LDO SDUW  RI RXU LQQHU
IHHOLQJ

$FFRUGLQJW RW KDW ZHFDQDW W ULEXW HW RHDFK5XQHDVSHFLILFIHHOLQJ, IZHDW W HP SW DIHZ

LQW HUSUHW DW LRQVZLW KDQHP SKDVLVRQIHHOLQJVSHUKDSVZHFDQUHDFKLQW RDW HUULW RU\W KDW
LVVW LOOOLW W OHNQRZQDQGOLW W OHDSSUHFLDW HGLHW KHW HUULW RU\RISUDFW LFDO5XQLFZLVGRP DQG
NQRZ OHGJH

³ 7RGD\ ,  DP  IHHOLQJ HVSHFLDOO\ ZHOO´  7KDW  P HDQV LI VHHQ IURP  RXW  SRLQW  RI YLHZ   W KH
VXEW OHHQHUJLHVVW UHQJW KHQP HLQVLGHW KH\DUHVHHNLQJSRZHUIXODFW LYLW \EHLW LQVHULRXV
ZRUN RU LQ VSRUW V

)RUW KLVIHHOLQJRIUDGLDW LQJHQHUJ\ZHKDYHDVDV\P EROW KH5XQH0$1 0DQV\P ERORI

W KH IRUFH RI *RG RI W KH 0DQ KXP DQ  )URP  W KH W LSV RI W KH W RHV W R W KH W RS RI W KH KHDG
W KHVXSSRUW LQJVW UHDP VRIVXEW OHHQHUJ\DUHXQGHUW HQVLRQLQRQHOLQHW KHYHUW LFDOFHQW HU
OLQH7KHJHDURIW KHIORZRIVXEW OHHQHUJ\FRP HVIURP W KHW RSRIW KHKHDGRYHUW KHW ZR
OXQJV W R W KH IHHW   7KH KHDUW  LV FLUFXP YHQW HG LQ W KDW  SURFHVV LW  FDQ GR LW V ZRUN TXLHW O\
DQGIUHHO\EXW W KHW ZROXQJVDUHHDJHUIRUDFW LRQW KHUHIRUHLW LVJRRGW REUHDW KHGHHSO\
7KLVJHQHUDW HVDFRVP LFW ULJJHUDQGHVSHFLDOO\W KHOXQJVDUHYHU\VHQVLW LYHW RVW UHDP VRI
VXEW OH HQHUJ\ DQG UHFHSW LYH LQ D SRVLW LYH ZD\ ZKLFK P HDQV W KDW  W KH\ FDQ GLVW LQJXLVK
ZHOOEHW ZHHQJRRGDQGEDGVW UHDP VRIVXEW OHHQHUJ\7KHKHDUW  RQW KHRW KHUKDQGLV
RULHQW HGP RUHHOHFW ULFDOO\LW LVVXEM HFW P RUHW RW KHHOHFW ULFDOVW UHDP VRIVXEW OHHQHUJ\RI
W KHSODQHW V6W UHDP RIVXEW OHHQHUJ\DQGHOHFW ULFLW \DUHW KHW ZRSROHVW KDW SXW RXUERG\
LQW R LQW HUQDO W HQVLRQ  :H KDYH W R P HQW LRQ KHUH W KDW  ZH GR QRW  P HDQ W KH RUGLQDU\
JDOYDQLFHOHFW ULFDOFXUUHQW 

/HW ¶VORRNDW W KHDUP V 7KH\DUHVOLJKW O\EHQW W HQVHDQGOLIW HGXSZDUG W KHSLFW XUHRI
DQRULJLQDOEDVLFIRUFH
 

, Q W KH KHDOW K\ ERG\ W KH VXSSRUW LYH LQW HUQDO VW UHDP V RI VXEW OH HQHUJ\ DUH DUUDQJHG LQ
GLUHFW LRQRIW KHORQJLW XGLQDOD[LVRIW KHERG\ZKLOHW KHDFW LY HVW UHDP VRIVXEW OHHQHUJ\
UHDFKW RERW KVLGHVLQXSZDUGGLUHFW LRQ7KLVLVW KHROGSUD\HUSRVLW LRQRIW KHP DQZKR
GUDZV GRZQ LQW R KLP VHOI W KH FRVP LF VW UHDP V RI VXEW OH HQHUJ\

1RZ ZH VKRXOG VW LOO VKRZ DQ RSSRVLW H LP DJH RI IORZ RI HQHUJ\

$ SHUVRQ QRW  NQRZOHGJHDEOH RI W KH P RXQW DLQV W KDW  JRW  ORVW  KDV EHHQ VLJKW HG E\ D
UHVFXH VTXDG LQ W KH P RXQW DLQV  &RP SOHW HO\ H[KDXVW HG DQG EURNHQ GRZQ W KH FDUHOHVV
SHUVRQ LV KXQFKHG LQW R W KH VQRZ KLV KHDUW  LV SRXQGLQJ KLV H\HV DUH ORRNLQJ DURXQG
HUUDQW O\DQGKLVKRDUVH P RDQLQJ FRP HV IURP KLVP RXW K

+HUHZHKDYHDQLP DJHRIDEURNHQV\VW HP RIVW UHDP VRIVXEW OHHQHUJ\DVDV\P ERORI

W KH6, * 5XQH$W W KHVDP HW LP HLW V\P EROL]HVW KHGHVW UXFW LYHSRZHURIVXEW OHHQHUJ\RI
W KH OLJKW QLQJ  $OO VXSSRUW LQJ VW UHDP V RI VXEW OH HQHUJ\ DUH EURNHQ  7KH ORZHU VW UHDP
SXOVDW HV LQ W KH IHHW  W KH XSSHU RQH GLVW XUEV W KH KHDG DQG W KH P LGGOH RQH ZKLFK LV
DFURVV SHQHW UDW HV W KH KHDUW 

7KH SHU VRQ Z KR JRW  ORVW  LV U XEEHG RII Z LW K VQRZ W KHQ IHG KLV VW U HDP V RI VXEW OH
HQHUJ\DUHVW UHQJW KHQHGDJDLQDQGVRRQKHUHFRYHUV

2XUKHDUW VKRXOGQRW EHRYHUORDGHGZLW KVW UHDP VRIVXEW OHHQHUJLHVW KDW DUHW RRVW URQJ
0DQ\ GLVHDVHG SHRSOH ZKHQ XQGHU DQHVW KHVLD GLH RI D KHDUW  DW W DFN EHFDXVH XQGHU
DQHVW KHVLD W KH EDODQFLQJ HOHFW ULFDO IXQFW LRQV RI RXU ERG\ DUH LP SDLUHG DQG W KH VW UHDP V
RIVXEW OHHQHUJ\FDQZDQGHUDURXQGLQW KHERG\ZLW KRXW DQ\EORFNDJHV

:Y %ORZ VD\V W KDW  ZH FDQQRW  H[SHFW  ³ VFLHQFH´  W R EHOLHYH VXFK W KLQJV  2XW  HUD LV
JHDUHGW RZDUGVW KDW ZKLFKLVIDFW XDODQGLW JLYHVW KHODEHORIVXSHUVW LW LRQW RHYHU\W KLQJ
W KDW  ZH FDQQRW  SURYH W R KDYH SXUSRVH DQG W KDW  ZH FDQQRW  VROLGLI\ ZLW K H[SHULP HQW V
)RUXQNQRZQW HUULW RU\ZKLFKZKDW ZHDUHGHDOLQJZLW KLVP RVW O\W KLVUHTXLUHP HQW FDQQRW
EH IXOILOOHG HDVLO\ DW  DOO W LP HV  %XW  ZH P D\ SRLQW  RXW  DOUHDG\  QRZ W KDW  W KH 5XQHV DUH
DP RQJRW KHUW KLQJVDOVRV\P EROVIRUYDULRXVVW UHDP VRIHQHUJ\IURP ZKLFKDOORUJDQLF
JURZW K RQ (DUW K LV GHSHQGHQW   , I W KH , FHODQGLF VDJDV DUH ILOOHG ZLW K UHSRUW V RI P DJLFDO
HIIHFW VZKLFKFDQEHDFKLHYHGZLW KW KHKHOSRIW KH5XQHVW KHQW KHIDFW W KDW ZHDUHQR
ORQJHU P DVW HUV RI W KLV W HFKQRORJ\ GRHV QRW  JLYH XV W KH ULJKW  W R FODLP  W KDW  VXFK W KLQJV
DUH VXSHUVW LW LRQ  0RUH VR EHFDXVH RI QHZ GLVFRYHULHV LQ VFLHQFH ZH DUH LQFUHDVLQJO\
IRUFHG W R EH FRQYLQFHG W KDW  P DW W HU LW VHOI LV QRW KLQJ EXW  D FORVHG DQG W LHG XS UK\W KP  RI
P RYHP HQW DSULVRQVRW RVD\RIW LHG XSHQHUJLHVDQGW KDW W KHUHDUHQXP HURXVW \SHV
RI UDGLDW LRQ FRDUVHU RQHV DQG P RUH VXEW OH RQHV RI ZKLFK ZH NQRZ EXW  W KH VP DOOHVW
SDUW 7KHUHIRUHZHVKRXOGFRQFOXGHW KDW EHVLGHVW KHP DW W HUW KDW LVNQRZQW RXVW KHUHLV
D W \SH RI P DW HULDOV W KDW  DUH P XFK P RUH VXEW OH VR W KDW  RXU H[LVW HQFH LV VW UXFW XUHG LQ
VW UDW LILFDW LRQIROORZLQJW KHSULQFLSOHRIGHQVHUDQGP RUHVXEW OH7KLVLVHQW LUHO\LQDFFRUGDQFH
ZLW KW KHDQFLHQW W UDGLW LRQ7KDW ZKLFKLVP RUHVXEW OHLVDOZD\VHQFORVHGLQW KDW ZKLFKLV
GHQVHU
 

;9, , , 
920 .5, 67 $//=80 $// .5, 67
)URP W KH&U\VW DOW RW KH&KULVW  (YHU\W KLQJ 
, QW KH+DJ $OODW RQHRIW KHXQLYHUVHLVVRXQGLQJ
$VRXQGRIW KHVW DUVW KDW SHQHW UDW HVW KHXQLYHUVH
$&U\VW  $OOORRVHQHGLW VHOIIURP W KH³ , VW ´
7KHVRQW KHVRXQGW KH$OO &KULVW RIW KHZRUOG

7KH+DJ $OO5XQHFRQVLVW VRIW KUHHVW DYHVRUOLQHV)URP W KHW ULQLW \RIW KH

1RUQVW KHKXP DQEHLQJDFFHSW VKLVIDW HRQW KHZRUOGW UHH7KUHHSDUW VRI
W KH HJR   6SLULW  VRXO DQG ERG\  7KUHH HJRV W KUHH VW DYHV KDYH W R EUHDN
ZKHQ \RX OHDYH W KLV OLIH  7KUHH VW DYHV ZKLW H RQHV NQRZLQJ RQHV ZLVH
RQHV JXLGLQJ RQHV KDYH EHHQ EURNHQ RYHU W KH FULP LQDO ZKR KDV EURNHQ
W KH ODZ W KH UDW D W KH 'LYLQH DGYLFH  $ FU\VW  DOO EUHDNV LQ HYHU\ KXP DQ
EHLQJZKHQKHLVG\LQJ, W LVOLNHW KH³ OXFNRI(GHQKDOO´   ZKLFK VRXQGV W R
HYHU\KXP DQEHLQJIURP W KHJDUGHQRI(GHQRIW KLVZRUOGDQGW KHD&U\VW 
$OO :LOOLVEUHDNLQJDQGW KHUHDUHKXP DQVZKRFDQYLHZW KHFU\ VW  DOORIW KH
HVVHQFHRIHYHU\KXP DQEHLQJZKRP RUHRUOHVVKDVDVKDSHW KDW LVDUUDQJHG
VLP LODUW RW KH+DJDOO5XQH

&U\VW DO  .ULVW DOO  +RZP XFKW KLV ZRUGFRQW DLQVVD\V , QJ5GLJHU DV IDU
DV LP DJLQDW LRQ LV FRQFHU QHG P HP RU LHV DQG KRZ  P XFK RI SRW HQW LDO RI
VFLHQW LILFLQVLJKW VDQGRIDUW LVW LFYLHZV

(J\SW LDQ SULHVW V *UHHN VFKRROV RI SKLORVRSK\ P HGLHYDO EXLOGLQJ JXLOGV
KXP DQLVW LFVFKRODUVDQGDUW LVW VVHFUHW RUGHUVRIDOOW LP HVDQGFRXQW ULHVDOO
RI W KHP  ORRNHG DW  FU\VW DOV DQG VDQJ DERXW  W KHP  HVSHFLDOO\ FRQFHUQLQJ
W KRVHILYHFU\VW DOVW KDW W RW KLVGD\DUHFDOOHG³ 3ODW RQLFVKDSHV´QDP HO\W KH
W HW U DK HG U RQ   W K H FX E H  W K H RFW DK HG U RQ   W K H G RG HFDK HG U RQ   DQ G  W K H
LFRVDKHGURQ$OOW KHVHILYHVKDSHVFDQEHUHGXFHGW RDVLQJOHEDVLFFU\VW DO
ZKLFK LV W KH VSKHUH  7KLV VKDSH W KHUHIRUH LV FRQVLGHUHG LQ W KH DQFLHQW
GRFW ULQHDVEHLQJW KHVL[W KRUW KH³ SHUIHFW ´ FU\VW DO³ V\P ERORIW KHXQLILHG
EDVLV´RUDV³ P HDQLQJ´ LQJHQHUDO


 , Q W KLV FRQW H[W  LW  LV YHU\ LP SRUW DQW  W R UHDOL]H VRP H RI W KH ZRUG JDP HV W KDW
*RUVOHEHQLVXVLQJKHUH &KULVW  &KULVW  $OO HYHU\W KLQJXQLYHUVHFRVP RV .ULVW DOO
&U\VW DO .ULVW ±*HUVW  6W UXFW XUHVFDIIROGLQJLQW KHEXLOGLQJW UDGH  *ULVW  $OO
VW UXFW XUH RI HYHU\W KLQJ FU\VW DOOLQH VW UXFW XUH RI HYHU\W KLQJ VFDIIROGLQJ W R EXLOG
HYHU\W KLQJ .ULVW  $OO &KULVW  HYHU\W KLQJ DQGRQLW JRHV

*RUVOHEHQUHIHUVW RDEDOODG³ 'DV*OFNYRQ(GHQKDOO´
 

7KHJHRP HW ULFRULJLQRIW KH6FDOGLF)XW KRUN6W DYHV

$OP RVW LQFRQFHLYDEOHLVZKDW W KHDQFLHQW ZLVHP HQFRXOGVHHLQW KHVHVL[FU\VW DOVDQGLW

LV ZRQGHUIXO KRZ LQ W KH FRXUVH RI D VKRUW   \HDUV IURP  W KH YLVLRQ XSRQ W KHVH VL[
FU\VW DOV W KH ZKROH SURXG HGLILFH RI RXU SUHVHQW  GD\ H[DFW  VFLHQFHV HYROYHG XQW LO W KLV
VFLHQFHGXULQJW KH W K DQG W K FHQW XULHVW KRXJKW LW FRXOGHQW LUHO\JHW ULGRIVXFKYLVLRQ
DQGZLW KLW DOVRJHW ULGRIW KHDQFLHQW GRFW ULQHRIW KHFU\VW DOV)ROORZLQJW KLVIOLJKW IURP
VXFKYLVLRQ RULQW XLW LRQ LQRXUGD\VDQRSSRVLQJW UHQGHP HUJHVZKLFKLVW KHW UDLQLQJRI
W KHLQQHUVHQVHV DUHW XUQW RYLVLRQDQGIURP W KLVIROORZVW KHQHFHVVLW \W RHQOLYHQDJDLQ
W KHDQFLHQW GRFW ULQHRIW KHFU\VW DOV
 

7KRXVDQGVRISDLQW HUVVFXOSW RUVDQGDUFKLW HFW VLQRXUGD\VKDY HYLVLRQVRIFU\VW DOVDQG

W KH\ SXW  W KHP  LQW R W KH FHQW HU RI W KHLU TXHVW  IRU W KH DUW V  7KRXVDQGV RI KXP DQV ZLW K
P HGLXP LVW LFVNLOOVQDP HO\W KRVHZKRSUHVHQW O\DUHRID\RXQJHU DJHVHHW KHP IORDW LQJ
LQVSOHQGRUDQGLQVXSHUQDW XUDOFRORUVDQGDOORIW KHP ORRNDW W KRVHFU\VW DOVEHLQJP XW HG
LQDZHRIW KHP 7RW KLVGD\RQO\IHZVSHDNRI³ W KHJROGHQVSKHUHV´ DQG³ FXEHV´RIW KH
³ KHDYHQO\ EOXH´ W KH ³ YLROHW  EOXH´ W KH ³ VXSHUQDW XUDO JUHHQ RI W KH RFHDQ´ W KH ³ UHG RI
SHDFKEORVVRP V´W KH³ 6RODUVSOHQGRU ´LQZKLFKW KHFU\VW DOVDSSHDUW RW KHP 7KHVW LOOGR
QRW  NQRZ W KH P HDQLQJ RI VXFK FU \VW DO YLVLRQ

$QG \HW  W KH DQFLHQW  GRFW ULQH RI W KH FU\VW DOV LV DW  W KH EHJLQQLQJ RI W KH %LEOLFDO FUHDW LRQ
P \W KW KDW LVHYHQLP SDUW HGXSRQW KHOLW W OHFKLOGUHQLQVFKRRODQGFDOFXODW HGFRQW LQXRXVO\
E\ W KRVH ZKR DUH VNLOOHG LQ W KH NQRZOHGJH RI *RG  7KLV KDSSHQV RQ DQ XQFRQVFLRXV
OHYHO KRZHYHU   $GDP  (YH DQG D ZKROH DUUD\ RI QDP HV DOO W KH ZD\ W R 1RDK DOO RI
W KHP  DUH P DVW HU ZRUGV DQG W KH QXP EHUV W KDW  FDQ EH H[W UDFW HG IU RP  W KHVH QDP HV
H[SODLQW KHZKROHGRFW ULQHRIW KHFU\VW DOVZKHQLQW HUSUHW HGFRUUHFW O\7RILQGW KLVFRUUHFW
LQW HUSUHW DW LRQ ZH QHHG RQO\ W R EH DZDUH W KDW  W KH UHSUHVHQW DW LRQ RI QXP HULF UDW LRV LQ
VSDFH ± DQG LW  LV W KLV UDW LR W KDW  W KH VR FDOOHG P DVW HU ZRUGV FRQYH\ W R XV ± KDYH W R EH
FU\VW DOV  :KHQ UHVHDUFKLQJ W KH P DVW HU ZRUGV DQG W KHLU FU\VW DOV W KHUHIRUH HYHU\W KLQJ
KDVW RHP HUJHZKDW DVQXP EHULQLQIDOOLEOHORJLFDFFRUGLQJW RP DW KHP DW LFDOODZVUHIHUV
W R DOO FUHDW LRQ DQG FRQW UROV LW   :LW KLQ W KLV NQRZOHGJH LV KLGGHQ W KDW  LV P XFK JUHDW HU
GHHSHU DQG P RUH SUHFLVH W KDW  FRXOG KDYH DFKLHYHG E\ H[DFW  VFLHQFHV W R W KLV GD\

$P LQXVFXOHVHFW LRQRIW KLVFU\VW DOGRFW ULQHLVHVSHFLDOO\FORVHW RXVKXP DQVQDP HO\W KH

VHFW LRQ W KDW  UHIHUV W R W KH KXP DQ HJR FU\VW DOV RU W R FU\VW DOV RI W KH HVVHQFH RI KXP DQ
EHLQJV7KHVHDUHW KHFU\VW DOVW KDW DUHSHUFHLYHGE\P DQ\SHUVRQVZKRKDYHP HGLXP LVW LF
VNLOOV

%RG\ VRXO DQG VSLULW  IRUP  W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ  $QDW RP \ DQG SK\VLRORJ\ GHDO ZLW K W KH
ERG\ DQG SV\FKRORJ\ GHDOV ZLW K W KH VRXO  :LW K W KH +LJKHVW  ZLW K W KH 'LYLQH ZLW K W KH
VSLULW  LQ W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ LQ RXU GD\V QR VFLHQFH LV GHDOLQJ DQG ZH FDQQRW  VD\ W KDW
W KHRORJ\ GRHV VR  4XLW H W R W KH FRQW UDU\ W KHRORJ\ LV D W RRO RI GDUNQHVV

)RUP HUO\DVFLHQFHGHDOW ZLW KW KHVHTXHVW LRQVZKLFKLQRXUGD\ VLVQRORQJHUSUHVHQW IRU

W KLV ZRUOG   W KH GRFW ULQH RI W KH FU\VW DOV  , I \RX ZDQW  W R UHFRJQL]H W KH VSLULW  ZKR DFW V
ZLW KLQ W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ ORRN DW  KLV FU\VW DOV  , I \RX ZDQW  W R U HFRJQL]H DQG H[SHULHQFH
W KHVSLULW W KDW JRYHUQVW KHKXP DQEHLQJW KHQORRNDW KLVFU\VW DOV:KDW DFW V'LYLQHLQ
W KHKXP DQEHLQJLVW KHEUHDW KRI*RG7KHEUHDW KRI*RGSXW VW KHXQLYHUVHLQW RUK\W KP LF
YLEUDW LRQVDQGZLW KW KLVLW GRHVVRW RW KHKXP DQEHLQJDVZHOO7KLVSXW W LQJLQW RYLEUDW LRQV
KDSSHQV LQ W KH V\VW HP  RI W KH JDOD[\ LQ Z KLFK RXU (DUW K LV ORFDW HG  7KHUHIRUH W KH
P DW KHP DW LFDOQXP EHUIRUW KHEUHDW KRI*RGLVRUDVDQLP DJHW KH+DJDOOW KDW ZKLFK
FDULQJO\ VXUURXQGV W KH 5XQH +DJDOO ZLW K W KH VL[ UD\V W KH QXP EHU   DQG W KH FHQW HU
SRLQW  W KH 'LYLQH 8U IRUFH    7KH QXP EHU VHYHQ KDV D P XOW LSOH P HDQLQJ LQ DQFLHQW
ZLVGRP  RI UHYHODW LRQ   W KH VHYHQ SODQHW V W KH VHYHQ W RQHV W KH VHYHQ FRORUV RI W KH
UDLQERZ W KH VHYHQ IROGQHVV RI W KH KXP DQ P LFURFRVP  W KH V\P ERO RI ZKLFK W KH LP DJH
 

RIZKLFKLVW KH5XQH+DJDOODVZHOODQGW KHUHDUHP RUHJURXSLQJVRIVHYHQZKLFKZHGR

QRW  QHHG W R P HQW LRQ KHUH DQ\ P RUH

)URP W KH+DJDOOW KH5XQHDQGW KDW ZKLFKFDULQJO\VXUURXQGVHY HU\W KLQJW KHXQLYHUVH

W KH VSKHUH ILYH FU\VW DOV HYROYH DV VKRZQ LQ W KH GHVLJQV  W KU RXJK   , P P HGLDW HO\
HYROYLQJIURP W KH+DJDOODUH W KHFXEH DQG DQGW KHGRGHFDKHGURQ  ZHVHHW KH
FXEH DV D FRP ELQDW LRQ RI W ZR W HW UDKHGURQV DQG W KH GRGHFDKHGURQ DV W KH FRP ELQDW LRQ
RIILYHW HW UDKHGURQV7KHFRQQHFW LRQRIW KHLQW HUQDOFRUQHUSRLQW VLQGHVLJQ  UHVXOW VLQ

7KHHYROXW LRQRIW KHFXEHIURP W KH+DJDOO5XQH

W KHRFW DKHGURQLQGHVLJQ  W KHLFRVDKHGURQ7KLVLVW KHP DW KHP DW LFDOHYROXW LRQRIW KH

UK\W KP  RXW  RI W KH EUHDW K RI *RG

7KH REM HFW V W KDW  SHQHW UDW H HDFK RW KHU LQ W KH GHVLJQV  DQG  SOD\ D JUHDW  UROH LQ W KH
NQRZOHGJH RI W KH DQFLHQW  Z LVH P HQ  7KH REM HFW  RQ GHVLJQ  FRQW DLQV DOO LP DJHV RI W KH
5XQHV, W Z DVW KHV\P ERORIW KH³ SKLORVRSKHU ¶VVW RQH6LQFHLW LVYHU\HDV\W RSURGXFH
LW  LW  LV D P DLQ DLG IRU W KH GLVFLSOHV RI W KH DQFLHQW  GRFW ULQH  %HVLGHV W KH ZLVGRP  RI W KH
5XQHV RQ KDQG RI W KLV REM HFW  DOVR W KH ZLVGRP  RI ³$GDP  DQG (YH´  ZDV W DXJKW  LH
W KLQJVW KDW HTXDOO\DVLQW KHILUVW ERRNRI0RVHVFDQDOVREHIRXQGLQQXP HURXVVDJDVRI
DQFLHQW  $U\DQ VSURXW  ORFDW LRQV

7KH ³ ZKLUOLQJ ERG\´  DFFRUGLQJ W R GHVLJQ  SRVVLEO\ ZDV OHVV RIW HQ SURGXFHG EHFDXVH
RILW VFRP SOH[LW \DQGW KHUHDUHQRDQFLHQW GLVFRYHULHVRIW KLVREM HFW NQRZQ7KHUHIRUH
LW  ZDV M XVW  P HQW LRQHG ZLW K QXP EHUV RU ZLW K VRXQGV UHSUHVHQW LQJ QXP EHUV QDP HO\ DV
W KHILYH W LP HV IRXU KHGURQRU RU 6LQFHDFFRUGLQJW RW KHUXOHRIW KHVNDOGVW KH
5XQH26  2DQGW KH5XQH5, 7 5ZHJHW W KHZRUGRUW KHIRUP XOD25

7KH8U ZRUGV25RU$5 W KH(DJOH P HDQW KH'LYLQH/LJKW LQW KH$U\DQ8U ODQJXDJH7KH

+HEUHZODQJXDJHW RRW RRNRU OLJKW IURP W KH$U\DQ -¶KLµ2U ³ OHW W KHUHEHOLJKW ´ 7KH
OHW W HU +H LQ W KH +HEUHZ LV W KH YDOXH RI  W KH OHW W HU 0LP  KDV W KH QXP HULF YDOXH RI 
 

W KHUHIRUHKDP  ZKLFKLVW KLVIDP RXVP DVW HUZRUGW KDW LVW KHEDVLVRIDOODOFKHP LVW LF
ZLVGRP W KH, QGLDQ20DQGW KH$P HQW KDW LVNQRZQW RDOORIXV2QW KLVERG\W KHZLVH
P HQW DXJKW W KHEDVLFZLVGRP RIDOOYLEUDW LRQVDQGW KHZKLUOVRIYLEUDW LRQVDQGW KHUHIRUH
W KH\FDOOHGLW W KHZKLUOLQJERG\

%XW W KHVHZRUGVDQGQRW LRQVRI20DQG$P HQKDYHW KHLURULJLQDJDLQLQW KH(GGLFZRUG

RI 0$1 IRU *RG VSLULW  UHDVRQ DQG ILQDOO\ P DQ IRU W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ DV W KH YLVLEOH
UHSUHVHQW DW LYH RI *RG RQ (DUW K  7KH VHHUV VDZ W KH 'LYLQH UK\W KP V W KDW  KDYH W KXV
RULJLQDW HGLQW KHLUUHODW LRQW RW KHKXP DQEHLQJDVIROORZV
  7HW UDKHGURQ±FDSDELOLW \LP LW DW LRQFRQQHFW HGZLW KKDUGZRUN 
  +H[DKHGUD FDSDELOLW \W RRQH¶VRZQW KRXJKW VDUW LVW LFVNLOOV
  2FW DKHGURQ±FDSDELOLW \W RRQH¶VRZQW KRXJKW VRIDW HFKQLFDOQDW XUHFDSDELOLW \W R
P DQDJH HQHUJ\
  6SKHUH ± FDSDELOLW \ W R RQH¶V RZQ W KRXJKW V RI D UHOLJLRXV SKLORVRSKLFDO QDW XUH LQ
UHODW LRQ W R RQH¶V RZQ EDVLV
  'RGHFDKHGURQ±FDSDELOLW \W RYLVLRQRIJUHDW FRVP LFVW UHDP VRIZLOODQGVXEP LVVLRQ
W R W KHP 
  , FRVDKHGU RQ ± Y LVLRQ RI W KH P HFKDQLVP  RI W KH Z RU OG DQG HP XODW LRQ W KHU HRI
LQYHQW LRQVRQDFRVP LFVFDOH

$FFRUGLQJ W R W KH P HDQLQJ RI W KH FU\VW DO W KH YLVLRQDULHV VDZ W KH ILUVW  KXP DQV ZKR KDG
'LYLQH U K\W KP  DV VNLOOHG Z LW K W HW U DKHGU RQV DQG IU RP  W KHU H W KH\ FRQW LQXHG Z LW K W KH
FU\VW DOV RQH E\ RQH DV W KH\ Z HUH KDQGHG W R W KH KXP DQV LQ W KH VHTXHQFH W KDW  Z H
VKRZHGSUHYLRXVO\'RGHFDKHGURQVDQGLFRVDKHGURQVW RW KLVGD\ZHUHOLP LW HGRQO\W RD
IHZH[FHSW LRQDOLQGLYLGXDOVZKLFKZHUHVRQVRIW KHJRGV

:KDW GLGW KHYLVLRQDULHVRIDOOW LP HVDQGSHRSOHVVHHLQW KLVU HODW LRQRIW KHFU\VW DOVW RW KH
LQGLYLGXDOKXP DQEHLQJV"7KH\VDZW KDW ZKLFKZHFDOOSUHGHVW LQDW LRQ

1R FKLOG FDQ EH SURFUHDW HG E\ SDUHQW V XQOHVV W KH EUHDW K RI *RG KDV JLYHQ W KH JHUP  RI
UK\W KP W RW KHFU\VW DOVRILW VEHLQJ1RFKLOGFDQKDYHRW KHUVNLOOVW KDQW KRVHW KDW DUHSXW
LQW R KLV FU\VW DOV  1RERG\ FDQ SHUIRUP  RW KHU W KLQJV W KDQ W KRVH W R ZKLFK KLV FU\VW DOV
HQDEOH KLP   'HW HUP LQHG SUHGHW HUP LQHG LV HYHU\ERG\¶V P HQW DO W DOHQW  DQG FDSDELOLW \
%XW  HYHU\ERG\ LV IUHH W R OLIW  W KH VSLULW XDO GHHG IURP  KLV FU\VW DOV RU W R OHDYH LW  GRUP DQW
DQGXQGRQH7KLVLVW KHIUHHGRP RIW KHKXP DQZLOORIZKLFKLVP DGHVRYHU\OLW W OHXVH
 

W KDW  RQO\ W KH )RUFH RI GHVW LQ\ LH QHHG OHDGV P RVW  SHRSOH W R DFW XDOO\ XVH W KDW  ZKLFK
W KH\ KDYH EHHQ JLYHQ  1RW KLQJ LQ W KH ZRUOG LV ZLW KRXW  FRQVHTXHQFHV  1R FDXVHV DUH
ZLW KRXW  HIIHFW V

7KLVDUUD\RIFU\VW DOODZVZRXOGEHULJLGLQGHHGLILW ZDVQRW UHSODFHGE\DVHFRQGRQH

LHW KHFU\VW DOODZVRIW KH³ 6XQRIJUDFH´ZKLFKP HDQVODZVRIDKLJKHUSRZHURIZRUOG
RUGHUW KDW LVDFW LQJDERYH+HUHZHW DNHW KHVW HSIURP W KHFU\VW DOW RW KH.ULVW  DOO

7KH³ .ULVW ´ZKLFKZDVGHVFULEHGVRZRQGHUIXOO\LQW KH(GGDDVQRZKHUHHOVHDVDFRVP LF

HQHUJ\LHW KHFRVP LFHQHUJ\RIJUDFHDQGSHUIHFW LRQW KLV.ULVW UHEXLOGVW KHDUUDQJHP HQW
RIFU\VW DOVIRUW KHSHUVRQZKRVW ULYHVLQGHVLUHDQGKHLP SURY HVLW FRP SOHP HQW VLW DQG
W KLV ZD\ SURYLGHV FDSDELOLW LHV W KDW  W KH RQH ZKR ZDV EHVW RZHG ZLW K W KLV JUDFH KDV QRW
KDG EHIRUH KLV W UDQVIRUP DW LRQ RI FU\VW DOV  1XP HURXV DUH W KH H[ DP SOHV RI VXFK FU\VW DO
W UDQVIRUP DW LRQV ZKLFK HVSHFLDOO\ YLVLRQDULHV RI RXU GD\V FDQ SHUFHLYH RQ OLYLQJ KXP DQ
EHLQJV  %XW  QRW  RQO\ FU\VW DO DUUDQJHP HQW V DUH FKDQJHG EXW  DOVR W KH VSOHQGRU RI W KH
FU\VW DOV W KRVH FRORUV LQ ZKLFK W KH FU\VW DOV UDGLDW H LQW HUQDOO\ RQ W KH VXUIDFH DQG LQ W KH
DXUD, QW KHVHFRORUVZHFDQVHHW KHNLQGDQGW KHVW UHQJW KRIW KHEORFNDJHVW KDW ZRUN
DJDLQVW DKXP DQEHLQJLQKLVDW W HP SW W RIXOILOOKLVFU\VW DOGHVW LQ\IURP W KHHQYLURQP HQW
DQGIURP ZLW KLQ5HGLVKRVW LOHGHVW UXFW LYH%OXHLVFROGDQGUHM HFW LQJJUHHQLVDUURJDQW
DQGVSRLOLQJ\HOORZLVIULHQGO\DQGUHGHHP LQJ

&RQVHTXHQW O\ RQO\ \HOORZ FU\VW DO FRORU LV IDYRUDEOH DOO RW KHUV DUH QRW  IDYRUDEOH  $Q
H[FHSW LRQ VHHP V YLROHW  EHFDXVH LW  GRHV QRW  UHODW H W R EORFNDJHV EXW  LW  UHIHUV W R D OHYHO
W KDW  KDV EHHQ UHDFKHG ZKLFK LV W KH OHYHO RI W KH SHUVRQ ZKR KDV OHDUQHG W R P DVW HU W KH
YLROHQFHW KDW LVHP EHGGHGZLW KLQKLP 

7KHUHDUHVRP HKXP DQVDERYHDOOIHP DOHVDSSDUHQW O\ZKLFKZLW KRXW NQRZLQJDQ\W KLQJ

RI W KH GRFW ULQH RI W KH FU\VW DOV RU ZLW KRXW  HYHU KDYLQJ KHDUG RI LW  VHH VLP LODU FRORUV RQ
KXP DQ EHLQJV HVSHFLDOO\ RU VW URQJHU GXULQJ W KH KRXUV RI GXVN RU GDZQ RU GXULQJ W KH
QLJKW , QW RW KLVUHDOP EHORQJVDOVRW KHVHHLQJRIFRORUVLQUHODW LRQW RYRFDOVRUJURXSVRI
ZRUGV  &HUW DLQO\ VRP H RI RXU UHDGHUV ZLOO EH FDSDEOH RI DGGLQJ W KHLU RZQ H[SHULHQFH
DQGREVHUYDW LRQW RZKDW ZHVDLGKHUH, QW RW KLVILHOGEHORQJVDOVRW KHIDFW W KDW ODQJXDJH
LVSDLQW LQJDQGVLQJLQJDQGW KDW KDVDQHVVHQW LDOLP SRUW DQFHDVIDUDVW KHXQLILHGRULJLQRI
DOOW KLQJVLVFRQVLGHUHG, QDGGLW LRQW RW KDW DW RQHKDGDFRORULQJHIIHFW W KHFRORUKDVD
W RQHDQHGLILFHKDVUK\W KP DSLHFHRISRHW U\DQDUFKLW HFW XUDOVW UXFW XUHRUDUUDQJHP HQW 
DQG D VFXOSW XUH RI VW RQH RU EURQ]H VKRZV P RYHP HQW  DQG D VHW  RI ZRUGV LV VRXQGLQJ
7KHUHIRUHW KHUHLVQRW KLQJXQXVXDOLQW KHVHSKHQRP HQDDQGW KH\KDYHEHHQVFLHQW LILFDOO\
H[SORUHGDW DOOW LP HV$OOZHQHHGW RGRLVW KLQNDERXW W KHVW DW HP HQW VP DGHE\5HLFKHQEDFK
LQ KLV W HDFKLQJV FRQFHUQLQJ 2G DQG YLEUDW LRQV    +LV ZRUNV DQG W KHLU LP SRUW DQFH DUH LQ
KLJKHVW HHP DJDLQLQRXUGD\V

6HHW KH(QJOLVKW UDQVODW LRQRI.DUOYRQ5HLFKHQEDFK¶VZ RUNHQW LW OHGThe Odic Force: Let t ers on


Od and Magnet ism . 1HZ+\GH3DUN1< 8QLYHUVLW \%RRNV2W KHUHGLW LRQVP D\EHDYDLODEOH

 

$VORQJDVDKXP DQEHLQJLVDOLYHKHUHP DLQVLQFORVHVW FRQQHFW LRQZLW KKLVFU\VW DOVDQG

W KH\ UDGLDW H LQ FRORUV   $W  W KH P RP HQW  RI GHDW K W KH FU\VW DOV UHP RYH W KHP VHOYHV IURP

6QRZFU\VW DOVDV+DJDOO5XQHV
 

W KHKXP DQEHLQJ7KHLUUHP RYDOP HDQVKLVGHDW K7KHFRORUVIDGHDQGYDQLVKEXW W KH

FU\VW DOV EHLQJ W KH VSLULW XDO FUHDW LRQV RI W KH 'LYLQH EUHDW K UHP DLQ DV P HP RULHV  :LW K
W KRVH FU\VW DOV W KH ZLVH P HQ RI DQFLHQW  W LP HV W DXJKW  W KHLU GLVFLSOHV NQRZOHGJH DERXW
KXP DQV NQRZOHGJH DERXW  W ULEHV FXOW XUDO KLVW RU\ W UDGLW LRQV HYROXW LRQDU\ SODQV RI W KH
FUHDW RU ZLVGRP  DIW HU ZLVGRP   6RP H RI W KLV DQFLHQW  ZLVGRP  P RU H RU OHVV FDUHIXOO\
KDVEHHQLQKHULW HGIURP G\QDVW \W RG\QDVW \W RW KLVGD\VW LOOP RUHZDVIRUJRW W HQDQGKDV
W R EH DFKLHYHG DQHZ LQ RXU GD\V  LW  KDV W R EH FDOOHG EDFN LQW R FRQVFLRXVQHVV EHFDXVH
QRW KLQJ LV ORVW  IRUHYHU  7RGD\¶V QHZO\ JURZLQJ ³ *RW K GRP ´ D QHZ KXP DQLW \ ZKLFK LV
ZRUW K\ RI W KLV QDP H DJDLQ ZKLFK LV ILOOHG ZLW K W KH ORQJLQJ IRU  VSLULW XDO DQG SK\VLFDO
XSZDUG EUHHGLQJ DQG SXUH EUHG EUHHGLQJ ZLOO M R\IXOO\ DQG M XELODW LQJ P DNH W KH DQFLHQW
GRFW ULQHRIW KHFU\VW DOVW KHLURZQDJDLQ

, Q W KH FU\VW DOV DUH W KH P ROHFXOHV LQ UHJXODU YLEUDW LRQ FRQW LQXRXVO\  7KHUHIRUH ZH FDQ
DVVXP HW KDW W KH\DUHXVHIXODVVW RUDJHURRP VIRUVXEW OHP DW W HURIDOONLQGEHFDXVHW KH
RUGHUHG P RYHP HQW  RI W KH FU\VW DO P ROHFXOHV LV FRQVW DQW  DW  FRQVW DQW  W HP SHUDW XUH DQG
GRHV QRW  FKDQJH DQG W KHUHIRUH LW  GRHV QRW  GLVW XUE W KH VXEW OH P DW HULDOV ZKLFK LV TXLW H
RSSRVLW HW RW KHVXGGHQYLEUDW LRQRIDVW ULQJLQDSLDQR6XEW OHP DW HULDOVW KDW DUHSXW LQW R
FU\VW DOVW KHUHIRUHNHHSW KHLUVSHFLILFFRP SRVLW LRQIRUDORQJW LP H

7KHIROORZLQJJHQHUDOL]HGODZRIH[LVW HQFHLVRIIDUUHDFKLQJFRQVHTXHQFHV 7KHFU\VW DO

SURW HFW V LQZDUGV DQG VKLHOGV RXW ZDUG  (YHU\W KLQJ W KDW  LV RXW  LQW R D FU\VW DO DFKLHYHV
P RUH SHUP DQHQFH DV GRHV W KH VXEW OH P DW W HU W KDW  LV SXW  LQW R D FU \VW DO RI GHQVH P DW W HU
%XW  W KLV ODZ FDQ DOVR EH DGDSW HG W R D P XFK KLJKHU SODQH RI H[LVW HQFH   W KH VSLULW XDO
DFKLHYHP HQW V W KDW  KDYH EHHQ SXW  LQW R D FU\VW DO EHFRP H P RUH SHUP DQHQW   7KLV ZD\ D
ZRUNLQJ K\SRW KHVLV EHFRP HV D W KHRU\ ZKHQ LW  FDQ EH DGDSW HG W R W KDW  ZKLFK KDV EHHQ
NQRZQDQGDFKLHYHGW RW KLVGD\7KHUHIRUHZHFDQVHHDVDFU\VW DOHYHU\W KLQJW KDW KDV
EHHQ U HVHDU FKHG DQG RU JDQL]HG SU HFLVHO\ LQ D VSHFLILF ILHOG RI NQRZ OHGJH  %XW  W KLV
VW DW HP HQW  LV YDOLG IRU D IDU KLJKHU OHYHO  , Q VRP H VSHFLILF ZD\ RXU ZKROH ZRUOG LV D
FU \ VW DO  2XU  DFW LRQV DU H IU XLW IXO RQO\  Z KHQ Z H ILW  RXU VHOY HV LQW R W KH Z RU OG FU \ VW DO
HYHU\W KLQJHOVHLVQR[LRXVDQGVHOILVK

7KHP LQHUDOZRUOGLVFU\VW DOOLQH7KLVFU\VW DOZRUOGQHFHVVDULO\H[LVW HGEHIRUHW KHZRUOG

RI W KH SODQW V  %XW  DOO ZRUGV DUH FRQVW UXFW HG RI FU\VW DOV  7KHUHIRUH DOVR W KH KLJKHU
RUJDQLVP VFRQW DLQFU\VW DOIRUP V7KHFU\VW DOFOXVW HULQFDVW LURQRULQURFNVKDVDOZD\V
W KHVKDSHRIDSODQW IRULQVW DQFHW KHVKDSHRIDVSUXFH

6XEVW DQFHVW KDW VW DUW LQJIURP DOLTXLGRIJDVHRXVVW DW HEHFRP HVROLGDQGW KH\VROLGLI\W R
FU\VW DOVZLW KW KLVW KH\UHFHLYHDVKDSHDQGDVKDSHRIOLIHVRW RVD\, W LVDVVXP HGW KDW
IURP W KHFU\VW DOW KHZD\JRHVLP P HGLDW HO\W RW KHOLYLQJFHOO0DQ\RUHVVKRZVW UXFW XUHV
OLNHSODQW V7KHKXP DQH\HLVRIDFU\VW DOOLQHQDW XUH
 

, IW KHH\HZDVQRW RIW KH6XQ

7KH6XQLW FRXOGQHYHUVHH
, I W KHUH ZDV QRW  *RG¶V RZQ SRZHU ZLW KLQ RXUVHOYHV
+RZFRXOGW KDW ZKLFKLV'LYLQHH[FLW HXV"
*RHW K H

, QVHFW V DQG RW KHU ORZ HU DQLP DOV KDYH FU\VW DOV LQVW HDG RI H\HV RIW HQ KXQGUHGV DQG
W KRXVDQGV7KHKXP DQH\HKDVW KHFU\VW DOOHQVZKLFKLVFRP SRVHGRIDJUHDW QXP EHU
RIW UDQVOXFHQW FU\VW DOV7KHH\HLVDFU\VW DOLQZKLFKW KHZKROHZRUOGLVFDXJKW 7KHUH
KDYHEHHQH\HVRIKLJKKXP DQVZKRFDXJKW W KHZKROHZRUOGDQGW KHVSOHQGRURIZKLFK
RW KHUV FRXOG QRW  VW DQG  $ERXW  ³ 6LHJIULHG´  W KH OHJHQG VD\V W KDW  KLV H\HV UDGLDW HG EOXH
OLJKW QLQJVVRIXOORIVSOHQGRUOLNHW KHVXQQ\VN\VRW KDW QRERG\FRXOGUHVLVW KLVORRN7KH
KXP DQEHLQJRIZKRP W KH+DJ DOOUDGLDW HVIURP KLVH[HVLQVXFKDP DQQHUIHHOVKLP VHOI
DVEHLQJW KH$OO +DJKLP VHOI6SDFHH[SDQGVLQW RW KUHHGLUHFW LRQV LQW KUHHGLP HQVLRQVLW
VXUURXQGV W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ  3XW  \RXUVHOI LQ W KH SRVLW LRQ RI W KH +DJ $OO 5XQH LQW R W KH
P LGGOHRIW KHZRUOGZKHUH\RXDUHDOZD\VVW DQGLQJZKHQHYHU\RXIHHO\RXUVHOIFRQVFLRXVO\
DV FHQW HU  6W UHW FK RXW  \RXU DUP V DQG IHHO \RXUVHOI RQ W KH +DJ $OO RQ W KH .ULVW $OO RQ
W KH FURVV RI W KH ZRUOG  <RX IHHO W KH FRVP LF VW UHDP V FRP LQJ GRZ Q XSRQ \RX UXQQLQJ
GRZQ LQW R \RX P XUP XULQJ GRZQ   <RX KROG \RXUVHOI RQ W KH IRXUW K GLP HQVLRQ  

6SLULW LVDW W KHURRW RIDOOW KDW LVP DW HULDOEHFDXVHRQO\DVDUHVXOW RILW VHP DQDW LRQDQG
FRQGHQVDW LRQW KHUHIRUHFU\VW DOOL]DW LRQP DW W HURULJLQDW HG$OOP DW W HULVFU\VW DOOL]HGVSLULW 
7KH QHZ HU  SK\VLFV YLHZ V W KH XQLYHU VH DV D FU \VW DOOL]HG V\VW HP  RI VSDFH FHOOV W R D
VW UXFW XUHRIVSDFHFHOOV 7KHUHIRUHW KHP DW HULDOZRUOGLVOLW HUDOO\DQGDOVRLQDQH[SDQGHG
P HDQLQJ D .ULVW  $OO 6W UXFW XUH D &U\VW  $OO D +DJ $OO  $QG LQGHHG IRU LQVW DQFH W KH LFH
FU\VW DOV DUUDQJH W KHP VHOYHV LQ KXQGUHGV RI YDULRXV GUDZQ +DJDOO 5XQHV RQ W KH VSDFH
FURVV RI VL[ EUDQFKHV  $QG LW  LV QRW  M XVW  W KH LQRUJDQLF P LFURFRVP  EXW  DOVR W KH RUJDQLF
P LFURFRVP  W KH DQLP DO ZRUOG W KDW  DUUDQJHV LW VHOI LQ LW V LQH[KDXVW LEOH ZHDOW K RI GHVLJQ
DQGIRUP DW LRQDURXQGW KHKH[DJRQLHW KHVW UXFW XUHRIW KH+DJ $OO5XQHW KHVW UXFW XUH
RIW KH&U\VW $OO, W LVW KHFRVP LFVH[XVW KH³ .ULVW ´ZKLFKSURFUHDW HVLW VHOIZLW KLQRXUVHOYHV
DQGLQHYHU\W KLQJ6RW KH³ &KULVW ´ LVDVZHSRLQW HGRXW DOUHDG\QRW KLQJEXW W KHODZRI
FU\VW  DOO L]DW LRQRI$OO QDW XUHW KHVSLULW XDOVW UXFW XUH ³ *HUVW ´ RIW KHP DW HULDOZRUOGW KH
FUHDW LRQ LGHDW KDW LVDW LW VEDVLVRUURRW V

7KH FU\VW DO LV VXEM HFW  W R W KH P DW KHP DW LFDO SK\VLFDO ODZV  , Q LW  DOO P DW HULDO IRUP V DUH
FRQW DLQHG IURP  W KH VLP SOHVW  W HW UDKHGURQ DOO W KH ZD\ W R W KH P RVW  SHUIHFW  ERG\ W KH
VSKHUH  7KH ODZ RI P DW W HU RI P HDVXUH DQG QXP EHU LV FRQW DLQHG LQ W KH FU\VW DO EXW  LW V


 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

HVVHQFHDOVRUHDFKHVLQW RW KHVSLULW XDOUHDOP V7KHKXP DQEHLQJLVDFU\VW DOVSLULW XDOO\

DQGP DW HULDOO\KHLVDFU\VW DOOLQHVW UXFW XUH
7KHVW UXFW XUDOEDVLVW KHEXLOGLQJ VW UXFW XUHRUSDW W HUQDQGW KH
EXLOGLQJ LGHD RI W KH 5RP DQLF DQG *RW KLF VW \OHV DQG W KHUHIRUH
DOVRW KHEXLOGLQJVW \OHRIW KHZRRG VW \OHW KDW SUHFHGHGLW ZDV
W KH W ULDQJXODW LRQ RI W KH P DVVHV DQG VXUIDFHV W KH HTXLODW HUDO
W ULDQJOHZKLFKE\P HDQVRIGRXEOLQJDQGFRQQHFW LQJH[SDQGV
LW VHOIW RW KHKH[DJRQW RW KH+DJ $OO7KHHTXLODW HUDOW ULDQJOHLV
DOVRW KHEDVLVRIDOOP HDVXULQJDQGRUQDP HQW DW LRQW KHUDW LRV
RI ZKLFK FRUUHODW H ZLW K W KH JHRP HW ULF ODZV RI FU\VW DOOL]DW LRQ

&RQYHUVHO\ ZH FDQ VD\ W KDW  DOO P DW W HU DOO VXEVW DQFH LV FU\VW DOOL]HG VSLULW    )URP  W KH
FU\VW DO SXULW \RIKLJKHVW UHILQHP HQW RIW KHVSLULW XDODQGSK\VLFDOLQVW LQFW VRULJLQDW HVW KH
QDP H DQG W KH QRW LRQ RI &KULVW  RI W KH +DULVW RV RI W KH DQRLQW HG RQH ZKR H[SHULHQFHG
W KHODVW DQRLQW P HQW W KHXOW LP DW HZLVGRP EHFDXVHRLO ³ |O´ LVVSLULW LQW KH8U ODQJXDJH
HL  W KH OLJKW  DO  W KH XQLYHUVH $OO    7KH *UHHNV FDOOHG UHJXODU FU\VW DOOLQH ERG\ W KH
³ EHDXW LIXO Z RUOG´  7KHUH DUH ILYH RI W KHP    7KH W HW UDKHGURQ D S\UDP LG ZLW K RQO\ W KUHH
VLGHVDFFRUGLQJO\LW KDVDW ULDQJXODUEDVH7KHQW KHKH[DKHGU RQRUW KHFXEHQH[W W KH
RFW DKHGURQ ZKLFK ZH FDQ EHVW  LP DJLQH DV DQ (J\SW LDQ S\UDP LG ZLW K LW V P LUURU LP DJH
W KHUHIRUH D GRXEOH S\UDP LG W KH EDVHV RI ZKLFK W RXFK HDFK RW KHU W KHUHIRUH HOLP LQDW H
HDFKRW KHU1H[W FRP HVW KHGRGHFDKHGURQFRQVLVW LQJRIW ZHOYHUHJXODUSHQW DJRQVDQG
HYHQW XDOO\W KHLFRVDKHGURQFRQVLVW LQJRIW ZHQW \HTXLODW HUDOW U LDQJOHV, I\RXDW W HP SW W R
FRQVW UXFW RW KHUUHJXODUERGLHV\RXZLOOQRW LFHVRRQW KDW W KLVLVLP SRVVLEOHW KDW QRRW KHU
ERGLHV FODQ EH FRQVW UXFW HG IURP  W ULDQJOHV VTXDUHV DQG SHQW DJRQV W KDQ W KH  SHUIHFW
FU\VW DOVW KDW ZHGHVFULEHGKHUH

7KH GRFW ULQH RI W KH $W RP V RI W KH DQFLHQW  *UHHNV W HDFKHV XV W KDW  W KH VP DOOHVW  SDUW LFOHV
RIDOOP DW HULDOERGLHVP XVW EHVLP LODUW RW KHVHUHJXODUVKDSHV DQGVLQFHW KHUHDUHRQO\
ILYHRIW KHVHVKDSHVW KHDQFLHQW RQHVVSHFXODW HGW KHVHIRUP VRIW KHDW RP VDQGDSSOLHG
W KH QRW LRQ RI W KH IRXU HOHP HQW V LQ FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K W KH SHUIHFW  FU\VW DOOLQH ERGLHV  7KH
IOLFNHULQJ ILUH $V DQ 8U LP DJH VKRZ V W KH W HW UDKHGURQ W KH VROLG HDUW K KDV W KH FXEH W KH
IORZLQJ ZDW HU KDV W KH ERG\ W KDW  LV FORVHVW  W R W KH VSKHUH LH W KH LFRVDKHGURQ DQG W KH
DLUKDVW KHRFW DKHGURQDQGLQGHHGW KHZLQGURVHZLW KLW VHLJKW EUDQFKHVLVW KHV\P ERORI
W KHXQLYHUVHVLQFHDQFLHQW W LP HV7KLVXQLYHUVHLVV\P EROL]HGLQW KH*HUP DQLFP \W KDV
W KHHLJKW IRRW HGZLQGKRUVHRI:RGDQ6OHLSQLUDQGLQW KH*RW KLFDQG5RP DQLFFKXUFKHV
DV W KH ZLQG URVH
 

1RZ ZKDW  KDSSHQHG ZLW K W KH GRGHFDKHGURQ"  ³ *RG

X VHG  LW  DV DQ  RU Q DP HQ W  RI  HY HU \ W K LQ J ´   7K HVH
P \ VW HU L R X V Z R U G V R I  3O DW R  K DY H Q R W  E HHQ  I X O O \
XQGHUVW RRG DOUHDG\ LQ DQFLHQW  W LP HV DQG VW LOO ODW HU
W KHUHZDVDORW RIJXHVVZRUNFRQVLGHULQJW KHP :LW K
W KLVKHP HDQW W KHW ZHOYHVLJQVRIW KHFHOHVW LDO]RGLDF
Z K LFK  FRU U HVS RQ G  W R W K H W Z HOY H VX U I DFHV RI  W K H
GRGHFDKHGURQ$QGW KHQW KHUHLVVW LOOW KHHW KHU rW UH
LQ)UHQFKP HDQV³ W REH´ W KHH[LVW HQFHZKLFKNHHSV
W RJHW KHUOLJKW DLUZDW HUDQGHDUW K

<RXU H[LVW HQFH LQ W KH VRQ LQ W KH W KLUG RQH LV W KH ]RGLDF LW VHOI ZKLFK ZLW KRXW  W KH 6XQ
ZLW KRXW W KHVRQZRXOGQRW KDYHDQ\6XQQRVSOHQGRUDQGQRH[LVW HQFH ³ NHLQHQ6FKHLQ
XQGNHLQ6HLQ´ 

7KHFURVVLVQRLQYHQW LRQEXW W KHQDW XUDOO\JLYHQUHYHODW LRQRIW KHV\P ERORIW KHZRUOG

, I ZH VSUHDG RXW  W KH FXEH RQ D VXUIDFH W KHQ ZH JHW  W KH VKDSH RI W KH FURVV ZLW K 
VTXDUHV  7KH VL[ W KH VH[ W KHUHIRUH LV DOUHDG\ 8U FRQQHFW HG Z LW K W KH FURVV ZLW K W KH
FUXFLIL[LRQ

$OOZHQHHGW RGRLVW RSXW W KURXJKW KH+DJDOO5XQHW KH7HO 5XQHW KH7HLO 5XQH SDUW LW LRQ
5XQH  DFURVV DQG ZH KDYH W KH SXV FURVV  7KHQ ZH JHW  W KH SXV FURVV DQG W KH HLJKW 
FURVV RU W KH HLJKW  ZKHHO RI W KH KLJK KRO\ HLJKW  W R ZKLFK FRUU HVSRQGV W KH RFW DKHGURQ
DVW KHDLU\HGLILFHRIW KHZRUOG

7HLO7HO 5XQHDQGW KH+DJDOO5XQHUHVXOW LQW KHHLJKW ZKHHO

2FW DKHGURQ +H[DJRQ +DJDOO 6L[ ZKHHO(LJKW  ZKHHO

+HUH ZH KDYH W R P HQW LRQ DOVR W KDW  W KH W ZR S\UDP LGV RI W KH RFW DKHGURQ DUH LQW HUODFHG
DFFRUGLQJW RW KHODZRIW KHJROGHQUDW LRVRW KDW W KHEDVHVRIW KHS\UDP LGVLQW HUVHFW ZLW K
 

W KHVLGHVXUIDFHVLQW KHVDP HUDW LRDQGFLUFXP VFULEHGZLW KDVSKHUHDQGZHUHFHLYHW KH

W KUHH GLP HQVLRQDO LP DJH RI W KH 0RJHQ 'DYLG ZKLFK RQ D SODQH LV W KH ZHOO NQRZQ
KH[DJUDP  ZKLFK DJDLQ LV DQRW KHU VKDSH RI W KH +DJDOO ZLW K LW V  HQGV  %DVHG RQ W KLV
Z H FDQ FRQFOXGH W KDW  W KH HLJKW  Z KHHO DQG W KH VL[ Z KHHO FDQ P XW XDOO\ UHSODFH HDFK
RW KHU  , Q DOO W KHVH V\P EROLF GHVLJQV ZH UHFRJQL]H W KH FRVP LF U HJXODU  VROLGV RI W KH
*UHHNVW KH³ EHDXW LIXOZRUOG´DVW KHEDVLFVW UXFW XUHRIW KHIRUP DW LRQRIFU\VW DOVLHW KH
FDSDELOLW \W RFU\VW DOOL]HRIW KHP DW HULDOZRUOG%DVLFVW UXFW XUHRIW KHZRUOGLVW KHFU\VW DO
/HW V UHSHDW  KHUH   7KH ³ &KULVW  $OO´  LV QRW KLQJ HOVH EXW  W KH ODZ  RI FU\VW DOOL]DW LRQ RI $OO
QDW XU H W KH VSLU LW XDO VW U XFW XU H RU  SDW W HU Q ³ *HU VW ´  RI W KH P DW HU LDO Z RU OG W KH VRQ
³ 6RKQ´  W KH H[LVW HQFH ³ 6HLQ´  RI *RG

&KU LVRV *U HHN  W KH *ROGHQ RQH W KH 6XQ

6L[VW DULQW KHJROGHQUDW LR

, QW KHSRLQW RIFURVVLQJRIW KHEHDP VRI+DJDOLQW KHLUSRLQW RIW KHFLUFOHLQW KHKXERI

W KH +DJDO ZKHUH W KH XQLYHUVH URW DW HV DURXQG LW V D[LV W KHUH LV VHHLQJ VSLULW XDOO\ DQG
SK\VLFDOO\W KHEDVLVRUURRW RIDOOW KLQJV7KHZLOO ³ :LOOH´ W KHZDYH ³ :HOOH´ RI*RG
W R DFW LRQ W KH 5DG L[ W KH ZKHHO HJR   LV W KH URRW  RI DOO W KLQJV  :LW K DQ 8U ODQJXDJH
EDVHGHTXDW LRQZHDUULYHW RW KHVROXW LRQRIW KHXOW LP DW HVHFUHW V

/DQJXDJHLVUK\W KP DQGQXP EHULVUK\W KP ODQJXDJHLVSDUW LW LRQRIW KDW ZKLFKLV'LYLQH

DQG QXP EHU LV SDUW LW LRQ RI W KDW  ZKLFK LV P DW HULDO  $ OLQJXLVW LF HTXDW LRQ FRP HV W R W KH
VDP HLUUHYHUVLEOHUHVXOW VDVGRHVDP DW KHP DW LFDOHTXDW LRQ  7KHUHVXOW P XVW JHW ULGRI
DOOFRQW UDGLFW LRQ

7KHZRUG³ *HUVW ´  VW UXFW XUHVFDIIROGLQJ LQGLDOHFW ³ *ULVFKW ´³ .ULVW ´LV8U NLQZLW KW KH
³ &KULVW ´ ZKRIXOILOOVW KHXQLYHUVHZKRIRUP VLW VVW UXFW XUHQDP HO\W KH.ULVW  $OO FU\VW DO±
FU\VW  DOO W KHVW UXFW XUH $OO ³ *HUVW ´  $OO W KHDOO VW UXFW XUH $OO *HUVW 7KHUHIRUHHYHU\
&KULVW  RU .ULVKW  QD .UVKQD  LV D VRQ RI D FDUSHQW HU D VRQ RI *RG W KH EXLOGHU RI W KH
VW UXFW XUH ³ *HUVW ´  RI W KH ZRUOGV ZKLFK DOZD\V VKRXOG EH W DNHQ V\P EROLFDOO\  $W  W KH
EDVLVRIHDFKEXLOGLQJLQFOXGLQJW KHEXLOGLQJRIW KHZRUOGLVDEOXHSULQW  *HUP DQ ³ 5L‰´ 
EHFDXVH Z LW K LW V ³ 5L‰´  LW  HP HU JHV IU RP  W KH VSLU LW XDO U HDOP V DQG EHFRP HV SRVVLEOH
EHFRP HVP DW W HU(YHU\*UXQG 5L‰ EOXHSULQW RIW KHEDVLVRIDKRXVH±EDVLV EOXHSULQW 

 5DG  *HUP DQ IRU ZKHHO ± UDGL[  /DW LQ IRU URRW  ± LFK  *HUP DQ IRU HJR

2PLWWHG
 

UHIOHFW VDP HQW DOEDVLFVW UXFW XUH, W RULJLQDW HVIURP GUDZLQJ DQGFLUFOLQJ ³ UHL‰HQ´ XQG
³ NUHLVHQ´  RI OLQHV W KHLU VFUDW FKLQJ ³ *HULW ]H´  DQG VFULEEOLQJ ³ *HNULW ]H´  D VFDIIROG
³ *HUVW H´ DQGD.ULVW H

7KH+DJDOO5XQHW KHUHIRUHLVW KHEOXHSULQW W KHEDVLFVW UXFW XUHRIW KHXQLYHUVHW KH+DJ

$OOLVDQ$OO +DJDQ$OO HQFRP SDVVLQJ $OO +HJ HQGHV , W EHFRP HVLP DJHRIW KHZRUOG
DVK W UHH ZKLFK LV D ZRUOG D[ LV W R W KH ZRUOG W UHH RQ ZKLFK :RGDQ DV LW V VRQ 7\U *RG
DVKLVVRQ&KULVW LVKDQJLQJW RW KHVHOI VDFULILFHRQW KHGRXEOH+DJDOORIW KH]RGLDF 7LHU
NUHLV FLUFOHRIDQLP DOV ZKLFKLVD7\U FLUFOH FLUFOHRI7\ U

³ , NQRZP \VHOIKDQJLQJIURP W KHZLQGFROGW UHH

)RUQLQHLF\QLJKW V
:RXQGHG E\ W KH VSHDU FRQVHFUDW HG W R :RGDQ
,  P \VHOI FRQVHFUDW HG W R P \VHOI
2QW KHP LJKW \W UHHZKLFKFRQFHDOVP DQ
:KHUH KH KDV JURZQ IURP  W KH URRW V´

7KH+DJ$OOLVW KH$OO +DJW KDW ZKLFKLVW DNHQFDUHRIW KDW Z KLFKLVW HQGHGW RW KDW ZKLFK
LVSURW HFW HGXQLYHUVDOO\LW LVW KH$OO KRRN $OO ´ +DNHQ´ W KH$OO FURVVEHFDXVHDKRRNLV
D FURVV LW  LV HYHQ W KH VZDVW LND +DNHQNUHX] ± KRRNHG FURVV  DV W KH 'LYLQH V\P ERO RI
EHFRP LQJ LQ 8U $U\DQ ZRUOG ZLVGRP   7KH &URVV $OO LV W KH FLUFOH $OO FURVV  .UHX]
FLUFOH .UHLV EHFDXVHFURVVDQGFLUFOH±LQGLDOHFW VW KH\VD\³ .UHL]´ IRU³ .UHX]´  FURVV 
DUH RQH DQG W KH VDP H ZRUG DQG W KH\ RULJLQDW H IURP  W KH 8U ZRUG SDUW V  .DU LV ZKLFK
P HDQV D FORVHG LQ HJR DV LQ W KH V\P ERO RI W KH 6XQ  ± VHH W KH V\P ERO RI W KH JRG ZKR
P DQLIHVW HGKLP VHOIDQGW KDW LVDFLUFOHZLW KW KHGRW LQW KHP LGGOHDVDV\P ERORIKLVVHOI
DVVHUW LRQ

7KH FURVV $OO W KH FLUFOH $OO W KH $OO FLUFOH LV W KHQ W KH VDP H DV W KH .ULVW  $OO FU\VW DO 
EHFDXVH W KH FU\VW DO LV W KH EDVLF VW UXFW XUH RI W KH P DW HULDO ZRUOG DV ZH KDYH DOUHDG\
VHHQ7KHP DW HULDOEDVLFVW UXFW XUHW KH&U\VW DOVSURXW HGILUVW IURP W KHVSLULW XDOVW UXFW XUH
³ *HUVW ´  *HUVW  $OO DOO VW UXFW XUH  W KH VSLULW XDO &KULVW  $OO W KH $OO &KULVW   )URP  W KLV
HTXDW LRQHYHU\LOOXP LQDW XVFDQVHHW KHSXUHO\FRVP LFP HQW DOFKDUDFW HULVW LFRIW KHRULJLQ
RI W KH P \W K RI &KULVW  ZKLFK ZDV ODW HU KDV EHHQ W DNHQ YHUEDW LP  DV UHSUHKHQVLEOH DQG
FRYHULQJXSRIW KHVRXOE\XQKRO\SRZHUV P HDQLQJW KH&KXUFK , QW UXW KW KH&KULVW RVLV
DQ $ULVW RV *UHHN ³ DULVW RV´   W KH EHVW  RQH  D KDULVW RV D KLJKHVW  RQH  $ULVW RV DQG
&KULVW RV 7KHP RVW $U\DQP RVW DULVW R FUDW LFRQH 7KH&KRU.LQ&KULVW LVDGLVVROYHG
++DUDQG+DULLQW KH(GGDLV:RGDQRU)XRW DQW KHKLJKRQHZKRSRVLW LYHO\W XUQHGW R
+DULVW RVW KHKLJKHVW RQHZKRZDVERUQLQW RW KHFURVVRIW KHZ RUOGW KHFURVVRIVSDFH
DQGW LP HDV*RGIDW KHUVRQDQGKRO\VSLULW LQRQHSHUVRQ

7KUHH W LP HV VL[ 5XQHV RI IDW KHU VRQ DQG VSLULW  UHVXOW  LQ W KH SHUIHFW HG DQG FRP SOHW H
+DJDO  9HU\ RIW HQ W KH W KUHHIROG +DJDO LV DOVR XVHG DV D KHUDOGLF V\P ERO  W KHQ W KH 
EHDP VDUHFURZQHGZLW KDW KUHHIROGOLO\RQHDFKHQG
 

, W LVW KH$OO 5XQHZLW KSDUW VW KH$OO 5DXQH $OO P XUP XU$OO ZKLVSHU EHFDXVHDVZH
NQRZ W KH DUUD\ RI 5XQHV FRQVLVW V RI  5XQHV  7KH $OO 5XQH W KH $OO 5DXQH W KH $OO
5DXQHURRW RIW KHROG*HUP DQIDLU\W DOHRSHQVDOOORFNVRIW KHVSLULW DQGRINQRZOHGJH

7KH$OO 5DXQHW KH$OO 5XQH

7KH%KDJDYDG *LW DKDVVRQJVDP RQJW KRVH³ HJR´ VRQJV W KH(J\SW LDQW DURW KDV
 FDUGV ZLW K ³ 5XQHV´ DP RQJ W KRVH W KH 5XQH RI W KH HUURU W KH P DQ ZKR VW DQGV RQ KLV
KHDGZKLFKLVDFOHDUKLQW DVW RW KHRULJLQRIW KHRULJLQDOO\$U\DQDUUD\RI5XQHV

7KH$OO 5XQHLVDOVRW KHLP DJHRIW KHW ZRW LP HVQLQHZRUOGVRIW KHQXP EHUVW KURXJK
W KH[LF\QLJKW VDQGGD\VDIW HUZKLFK:RGDQVLQNVGRZQ IURP W KHZRUOGW UHH
 

;, ;
7KH5XQHVLQW KH7\U &LUFOH 
7KHQRLVHRIW KHGD\KDVEHFRP HVLOHQW EORZQDZD\LW VP LOOLQJFURZGV
7KH ULJLG 0RRQ JRHV RQ KLV SRVW  RI D VW HHS ZDW FK
7KH VW DUV DZDNHQ RQ W KH EDOG VN\
7KHERDW RIW KH(DUW KDQFKRUVGXULQJW KHQLJKW 
, W VVKDGRZ\P DVW GULOOVLW VHOIW RZDUGVW KHSROHIDUDZD\
, QFLUFOHVLW VZLQJVDURXQGZLW KW KHYDXOW RIW KHVN\
$QGLW UROOVW KHZUHDW KRIGLDP RQGVW DUV
, QDEOHVVHGGUHDP DURXQGKLP VHOIW KURXJKRXW W KHZKROHZRUOG
, DP VZD\LQJP \VRXQGLQJKHDGLQW KHVRQJRIW KHOLQHV
0\VSLULW VJRQHIURP ORRNLQJLQW RW KHXQLYHUVH, EDUHO\QRW LFH
+RZ 0RRQ DQG 6XQ VOLGH W RZDUGV XV
, QHW HUQDOULGHRIW KHVKLSRIW KH(DUW KW KURXJKVSDFH

5XQD LQ ROG 1RUVH P HDQV W R ZKLVSHU W R P XUP XU W R VXUJH W KDW  ZKLFK
ZKLVSHUVRUP XUP XUVW KDW ZKLFKLVP \VW HULRXV5XQLQ6DQVNULW W KHVDFUHG
ODQJXDJHRIW KHDQFLHQW $U\DQ, QGLDQVP HDQVW RVRXQGEXW DOVRW RVXUJH
W RZKLVSHU%RW KZRUGVDOVRUHIHUW RVRP HW KLQJW KDW LVUXQQLQJW KLQNDERXW
5XQHDQGJXW W HU ³ 5LQQH´ LQ*HUP DQ VRP HW KLQJW KDW UXQV UD VXFKDVW KH
6XQ DU JRHVURXQ 'DQGW KHUHIRUHVRXQGVGRQDU G W KXQGHUV±³ GRQQHUW ´
LVW KH*HUP DQZRUG OLNHW KH³ FRP SHW LW LYHVRQJRIW KHVSKHUHV´, W LVW KH
VRXQGW KHW RQHRIW KHZRUOGVW KH7RQ$URIW KHZRUOGV 7RQ$U ±'RQDU±
'RQQHU ± W KXQGHU  DOVR 7RQ VRXQG  DQG 6RQQH 6XQ  W KH W RQH DQG W KH
VRQ DW  W KH VDP H W LP H EHFDXVH W RQ DUH DQG VRQ DUH ERW K DUH ZRUGV IRU
VRXQGLQJ7XQ DUHW XUQHGDURXQGUD W XQ7RQDUW KHVRQRI:RGDQRI*RG
W KHUHIRUHOLW HUDOO\P HDQVW R³ GRULJKW ´OLNHW KH6XQW KH$URU5DLVGRLQJ
EHFDXVHDOOODZLVODZRIW KH6XQLVVRXQGRIW KH6XQDQGW RQHRIW KH6XQ

5XQ LQ (QJOLVK DOVR P HDQV W R IORZ W R UXQ  7KH 5XQ]H LV D ZDW HU FXUUHQW 
W KH 5XQ]HO *HUP DQ ZRUG IRU ZULQNOH  VLJQLILHV W KH FRXUVH ³ 5LQQVDO´ LQ
*HUP DQ  RIOLIH%XW 5XQ LVDOVR W KDW ZKLFKUXQV DURXQG W KH RUELW  5XQG
ODXI  RI W KH 6XQ W KH FRXUVH RI W KH \HDU W KH URXQG RI W KH VN\ DQG IURP
ZKLFKZDVGHULYHGW KHROG1RUGLFURQG W KHVKLHOGW KHVKLHOGRIW KH6XQLQ
JHQHUDO EHFDXVH RQ W KH VKLHOG SHRSOH GUHZ W KH 5XQHV RI W KH VN\  7KH
VKLHOG ZDV DQ LP DJH RI W KH URXQG RI W KH VN\ W KH ³ URKG´ W KH UXQ ZD\ W KH


 7LHUNUHLV  FLUFOH RI DQLP DOV W KH *HUP DQ ZRUG IRU ]RGLDF *UHHN  W R ]RRQ ± W KH
DQLP DO±]RGLDF
 

URXQG ZD\ RI W KH 6XQ W KH ULQJ RI HYHQW V RI GHVW LQ\  7KHUHIRUH W KH W KH
*HUP DQ W KH VKLHOG LW V SRVVHVVLRQ RU ORVV ZDV GHVW LQ\   KRQRU RU VKDP H

7KLV VKLHOG W KLV ³ URQG´  ROG 1RUGLF IRU

VKLHOG  W KLV U RXQG RI W KH KHDY HQV LV
VW UDQJHLQGHHGZLW KLW VZRQGHUIXOVSLUDO
RUQDP HQW DW LRQ, QGHHGLW LVD6XQ VKLHOG
DQG 2U QD P HQW  ZKLFK P HDQV ERUQ LQ
W K H 6X Q  R U  Q D  DQ G  DO O  R U L J L Q DO
RU QDP HQW V U HIOHFW  VRP H N LQG RI W LP H
S DVVLQ J   W K H\  DU H Z U LW LQ J  DQ G
RU QDP HQW DW LRQ DW  W KH VDP H W LP H EXW
QHYHU RUQDP HQW DW LRQ DORQH QR ³ DUW  IRU
W KH DUW ¶V VDNH´  EXW  DOZD\V ILUVW  ZULW LQJ
P HVVDJ H  FDOFX ODW LRQ    7K LV X Q LW \  RI
X VHI X OQ HVV DQ G EHDX W \  LV RQ H RI  W K H
DGP LU DEOH W KLQJV HY LGHQW  LQ DOO 'LY LQH
FXOW XUHVZLW KZKLFKHYHQW KH³ SULP LW LYH´
SHRSOHV DUH EOHVVHG  7UXO\ SULP LW LYH LQ
U HODW LRQ W R KLJKHU  U HTXLU HP HQW V KDY H
DOZD\VEHHQFLYLOL]DW LRQVLQRXUGD\VDV
ZHOODVEDFNW KHQ

7KH FHQW HU VW DU FRQW DLQV ZKLFK LV D UDUH FDVH W KH 1LQH ZLW K
W KH'LYLQLW \W KHW HQLQW KHFHQW HU7KLVLVIROORZHGE\DQHLJKW
OHDIHG ZLQG URVH W KH ZLQG KRUVH  7KHQ FRP HV W KH QXP EHU
 DV W KH QXP EHU RI P DQ RI ³ P DQQXV´ W KH KXP DQ RI W KH
(DUW KDQGW KHRXW HUULQJLVHQFORVHGZLW KDFLUFOHRI [
 7KH VXP  RI W KH GLJLW V RI  LV  LW  LV W KH QXP EHU RI W KH
'LYLQLW\

6W DW XHRIHP SHURU2W W R
LQW KHGRP HRI0DUEXUJ

5XOHU V\P ERORI2W W RW KH*UHDW

ZLW K5XQHLQVFULSW LRQV
DFFRUGLQJW R5LFKDUGYRQ6LQQLQJ
 

(P SHURU 2W W R FDUULHG W KH URXQG VKLHOG W KH URQG W KH URXQG RI W KH KHDYHQ ZLW K W KH 
LQQHUEXP SVDQGDVHYHQW KRQHDVFHQW HUDQGZLW KLW VRXW HUEXP SVW KHVLJQVRI
W KH]RGLDF:LW KW KLV6LQQLQJKDVGHVLJQHGDQDUUDQJHP HQW RI5XQHVZKLFKZDVGHULYHG
IURP  W KH FRQVW UXFW LRQ RI W KH YDXOW V DQG FXSRODV RI P RVW  RI W KH P HGLHYDO FDW KHGUDOV DV
W KHV\P EROVRIW KHFRVP RV:HFDQVHHW KDW W KH³ P RQRJUDP RI&KULVW ´ FRUUHVSRQGVDV
ZHOOW RW KLV5XQLFHTXDW LRQE\P HDQVRIRP LVVLRQRIW KHVHFRQGRUSRODU3DUG 5XQHRU
5XQHRIW KHVRQ3W KHXQGHUZRUOGVW KHSUHVHQW VRW RVD\³ , QW KLVV\P ERO\RXZLOOEH
YLFW RULRXV´ ±QDP HO\W KHV\P ERORIW KH&KULVW RVRIW KHXSSHUZRUOGZKLFKVKRXOGQRZ
EHJLQW RUXOH, QGHHG&KULVW LDQLW \KDVQHYHUXQGHUVW RRGW KHFRQFHSW RIW KHZRUOGVSLQQLQJ
ZKHHOW KHZKHHORIW KHZRUOGLQLW VSRODULW \7KDW ZKLFKLVDERYHSDOHGEHFDXVHW KHUH
ZDV QR EDODQFLQJ ZHLJKW  IURP  EHORZ

2QW KLVSDJHZHVHHDKRUVHEDFNULGHUHOHYDW HGDV:RGDQNQLJKW ZLW KRXW IHDUDQGIODZ

DV6DLQW *HRUJHDQG6DLQW 0LFKDHO7KLVLP DJHEULQJVEDFNW KHP HP RU\RIW ZRYHUVHV
ZKLFKZHKDYHUHDGLQ³ W KH6D\LQJVRIW KH+LJK2QH´  LQW KH(GGD


+iYDP iO
 

7KLV VKRZ P H :RGDQ \RX ZKR NQRZV ERW K

7KH GHVW LQ\ RI W KH JRGV DQG RI P HQ
, I, JRLQW REDW W OHZKLFKVLJQZLOOSURP LVH
7KDW , DP XQKDUP HGZKHQVZLQJLQJW KHVZRUG"

0DQ\ DUH IDYRUDEOH W R W KH VZLQJLQJ RI W KH VZRUG

:KHQULJKW RQO\ W KH ZDUULRUUHFRJQL]HV W KHP 
7UXVW LQJVKRXOGIROORZW KHP DQDVDILUVW W KLQJ
7KHIOLJKW RIW KHGDUNUDYHQ

:RGDQ FDUULHV W KH URQG W KH VKLHOG LQ ROG 1RUGLF ODQJXDJH W KH URXQG W KH URXQG RI W KH
KHDYHQZKLFKLVV\P EROL]HGE\W KHFLUFOHVW KDW DUHDUUDQJHGLQW KHVKDSHRIDSHQW DJUDP
ZLW K D FHQW HU  7KLV LV W KH V\P ERO RI :DOKDOOD DV ZH KDYH SURYHQ LQ DQRW KHU VHFW LRQ RI
W KLV ERRN  /HIW  RQ W KH HGJH RI W KH VKLHOG LV W KH 7KUHH LQGLFDW HG E\ W KH W KUHH EXP SV
7KH\SRLQW W R:RGDQ:LOLDQG:HK:LW KW KHVL[LQW KHP LGGOHRIW KHVKLHOGW KH\P DNH
QLQH W KH SHUIHFW LRQ W KH QLQH QLJKW V RI :RGDQ RQ W KH ZRUOG W UHH W KH QLQH OHYHOV RI
LQLW LDW LRQRIKLVSULHVW V$V:RGDQW KHKRUVHEDFNULGHULVDFFRP SDQLHGE\W KHW ZRUDYHQ
+XJJLQDQG0XQQLQW KRXJKW DQGP HP RU\RIZKLFKRQHDVDOVRLQW KHUHSHW LW LRQRIW KH
UDYHQLQW KHRUQDP HQW RQW KHKHOP HW VHHP VW RFDUU\DULQJSHU KDSVDQDOOXVLRQW RW KH
ULQJ'UDXSQLURIZKLFKHYHU\QLQHQLJKW VDQRW KHUULQJLVGULSSLQJGRZQ2QW KHSODQHRI
W KH (DUW K W KH FRUUHODW LRQ W R W KH UDYHQ DUH W KH UDYHQ G\QDVW LHV DV W KH RQHV ZKR DUH
VXSSRUW LQJUHQHZLQJZKLFKDUHHTXLOLEULXP W RW KHUXOLQJG\QDVW LHVRIW KHDULVW RFUDF\

7KHOHYHOLVV\P EROL]HGE\W KHKHP LVSKHUHRQW KHULJKW VLGHRIW KHHGJHRIW KHVKLHOG

:HVKRXOGQHYHUEHOLHYHW KDW VXFKW KLQJVDUHDUELW UDU\, QW KHVHW LP HVSHRSOHZHUHVW LOO
IRFXVHGRQW KDW ZKLFKZDVHVVHQW LDOLQDOOW KLQJV

7KH JXLGDQFH LV W KUHHIROG ZKLFK LV H[SUHVVHG LQ EULGOHV ZLW K W KUHH EHOW V DQG DOVR W KH
W ULSOHEUDLGLQJRIW KHKHOP HW LVOLNHO\QRW E\FRLQFLGHQFHREY LRXVO\W KHUHDUHOLQHVRQ
HDFKVLGHFRUUHVSRQGLQJW RW KH5XQHVW KH³ P DLQSRHW ´ RU³ P DLQVSHDNHU´ IRUZKLFK
LV:RGDQ7KHVSHDUW KUHDW HQVW KHVQDNHW KHYHUP LQZKLFKJQDZVRQW KHURRW VRIW KH
ZRUOG DVK W UHH  6KLHOG DQG KHOP HW  VKRZ DOO SDUW V RI KHUDOGLFDOO\ M XVW LILHG UHTXLUHP HQW V
DFFRUGLQJ W R VKDSH DQG QXP EHU DQG W KLV DORQH LV SURRI RI W KH SUHKLVW RULF RULJLQ RI W KH
KHUDOGLFDUW 7KHKHUDOGLF DUW  ZDV QRW  ³ LQW URGXFHG´ IURP  W KH 0LGGOH (DVW  E\ ZD\ RI W KH
&UXVDGHVEXW LW IRXQGW KHQDP RUHLP DJH OLNHDQGP RUHFRQFHDOHGH[SUHVVLRQEHFDXVH
LW ZDVQRORQJHUDFFHSW DEOHW RVKRZW KHDQFLHQW 5XQLFV\P EROVLQSODLQYLHZ, QGLYLGXDO
FRDW V RI DUP V RI RXU GD\V DUH VW LOO FRUUHVSRQGLQJ HQW LUHO\ W R W KH LP DJH RI W KH FRDW V RI
DUP V RI W KLV H[DP SOH W KDW  QR GRXEW  FRP HV IURP  SUH &KULVW LDQ W LP HV

7KH FRDW V RI DUP V KRXVH V\P EROV VSHFLILF RUQDP HQW V DQG VHFUHW  V\P EROV DUH KLGGHQ
5XQHV, QW KLVVKDSHW KH\DSSHDUHGDVODW HDVW KH&UXVDGHVEHFDXVHW KH\ZHUHFRQQHFW HG
 

ZLW KW KH&UXVDGHVDQGFODLP HGW KDW W KH\ZHUHLP SRUW HGIURP W KH(DVW HYHQW KRXJKDQ\
SHUVRQZKRLVVRP HZKDW W DXJKW LQVFKRROVKRXOGNQRZW KDW W KHUHW KH\QHYHUZHUHXVHG
DVP XFKDVLQW KH:HVW :LW KW KLVZHGRQRW ZDQW W RGHQ\W KDW LQW KH(DVW DVZHOOFRDW V
RI DUP V H[LVW  DQG W KDW  W KHLU RULJLQ W RR FDQ EH GHW HUP LQHG DV FRP LQJ IURP  W KH 5XQHV
ZKLFKKDYHEHHQXVHGW KHUHDW DOOW LP HVE\W KH$U\DQVZKRLP P LJUDW HGW KHUH

*DEOHRIW KHZDW HUFDVW OHRI%DOLQJHQ

7KHEHDP VW KDW DUHW UDFHGLQEODFNFOHDUO\LQGLFDW HW KH5XQHV
ZKLFK LQ P RVW  FDVHV ZHUH QRW  HVVHQW LDO HOHP HQW V RI W KH VW UXFW XU H

, W  Z RXOG EH DQ DP D]LQJ W KLQJ LI W KH ODZ  RI W KH W U LQLW \ GLG QRW  GHW HUP LQH W KH ODZV RI W KH
KHUDOGLFDUW VDQGLW VH[SUHVVLRQLQLP DJHVDVLW DOVRUXOHVRY HUW KHZKROHVHW RILGHDVDQG
ILJXUHVLQW KH(GGDDVZHOODVRYHUDOO$U\DQLQVW LW XW LRQV7KHH[DP SOHVVKRXOGH[SODLQ
W KDW  P RUH FOHDUO\

7RZHUV P RQDVW HULHV FKXUFKHV FDW KHGUDOV FLW \ KDOOV FDVW OHV DQG FLYLO EXLOGLQJV VKRZ
5XQHVDQG5XQLFLQVFULSW LRQVLQW KHLURUQDP HQW DW LRQVDKXQGUHGDQGDW KRXVDQGIROG2Q
FROXP QVFROXP QW RSVDERYHURXQGHGDQGSRLQW HGDUFKHVLQORQJRUQDP HQW DOOLQHVW KH
ZLVHP HQDQGP DVW HUVRIW KHEXLOGLQJJXLOGVRIDQFLHQW W LP HVZ KLFK ZHUH JXDUGLDQV RI
ROG*HUP DQLFZLVGRP KDYHFRQYH\HGW RXVVD\LQJVRISURW HFW LRQV\P EROVDQGK\P QV

, QRXU*HUP DQFLW LHVDUHROGKDOI W LP EHUHGKRXVHV&LW LHVDV5RW KHQEXUJ%UDXQVFKZHLJ

+LOGHVKHLP 1UQEHUJDQGW KHP DQ\VP DOOLP SHULDOFLW LHVLQW KH$OVDFHLQ)UDQNLD+HVVLD
 

DQGRQW KH5KLQH5LYHUW KH+DQVHDW LF&LW LHVRQW KH6HDRYHUVHDVDQGLQW KHFRXQW U\VLGH

DUHIXOORIW KHVHKDOIW LP EHUHGKRXVHV7KHKDOIW LP EHULQJRIW KHLUVW UXFW XUHLVXVXDOO\UHG
DQG FOHDUO\ GLVW LQFW  IURP  W KH ZKLW H ZDOO VXUIDFH  , W  VKRZV W KH VKDSH RI 5XQH URZV EXW
W KLVZDVFRQVFLRXVO\XVHGRQO\LQYHU\ROGKRXVHV/DW HUW KHDQFLHQW V\P EROVZHUHVW LOO
FRSLHGLQW KHLUROGV\P EROVDQGLQVLP LODUVKDSHVEXW W KLVZDVGRQHDVSDUW RIW KHFUDIW
DQGW KHV\P EROVZHUHQRORQJHUXQGHUVW RRG7RW KHXQVFKRROHGH\HVW KHEHDP VW UXFW XUH
DSSHDUVSXUHO\XVHRULHQW HGRUFRLQFLGHQW DO%XW ZKRLVDUP HGZLW KRXUEHW W HUNQRZOHGJH
DQG Z KR ORRN V P RU H FDU HIXOO\  Z LOO QRW LFH W KDW  W KHVH P XOW LSOH EHDP V FDQQRW  EH M XVW
RUQDP HQW DW LRQ$QGDOVRZHFDQQRW H[SODLQW KHVHREYLRXVO\DUELW UDU\VHW W LQJVRIEHDP V
ZLW K UHDVRQV RI QHFHVVDU\ VW UXFW XUH VR W KDW  SHRSOH VKRXOG KDYH IRXQG RXW  LQ HDUOLHU
W LP HVW KDW W KRVHW KLQJVZHUHP DGHE\DVSHFLILFLQW HQW 

&KXUFKW RZHURIW KHYLOODJHRI+HQQHEHUJ

$V IDU DV YLVLEOH RQ W KH LP DJH W KH VLGH RI W KH W RZHU W KDW  ZH VHH KHUH KDV W KUHH YHU\
FOHDU +DJDO 5XQHV ZKLFK DUH QRW  ³ M XVW  RUQDP HQW DW LRQ´  DQG ZKLFK DOVR DUH QRW  QHHGHG
IRUUHDVRQVRIVW UXFW XUDOVW DELOLW \DW OHDVW QRW LQVXFKDQREYLRXVDUUDQJHP HQW ZKLFKLV
QRW YHU\XVHIXOHLW KHU(YHQZKHQW KHUHLVDSODLQLQW HQW RIRUQDP HQW DW LRQSHRSOHXVHG
 

RW KHU VKDSHV DV LV SURYHQ E\ P DQ\ EXLOGLQJV RI D ODW HU W LP H  7UXH DQG FRQVFLRXV KDOI
W LP EHULQJ)D DK 5XQH ZRUN +DOIW LP EHULQJLQ*HUP DQLV³ )DFKZHUN´ ±ZKLFKW UDQVODW HV
LQW R ³ EXLOGLQJ LQW R FRP SDUW P HQW V´  DOZD\V EUHDW KHV D VSHFLDO VSLULW  RI VHULRXV DQG \HW
VSHDNLQJUHVHUYH, QW KHJDEOHRIW KHW RZHUDUHDUUDQJHGOR]HQJHVZKLFKLVW KHZHOO
NQRZQ QXP EHU RI W KH FDUSHQW HU RU W KH 0DQ 5XQH

7KH OR]HQJH *HUP DQ   ³ 5DXW H´  LV W KH V\P ERO

RI W KH UDW D  RI W KH 'LY LQLW \  RI W KH U LJKW   DQG
W KHUHIRUHW KHFRXQW VRIW KHVODZ7KHOR]HQJHLQ
W KH FRDW  RI DUP V KDV DOZD\V W KLV P HDQLQJ

1 R Z  L Q G H H G  3K L O L S S  6 W D X I I  V X F F H H G H G  W R
RFFDVLRQDOO\UHDGDQFLHQW 5XQLFLQVFULSW LRQVLQW KH
KDOI W LP EHULQJ VW UXFW XUHV RI DQFLHQW  FDVW OHV FLW \
KDOOVW ROOKRXVHVFORW KVW RUDJHKRXVHVDQGGHIHQVH
W RZHUVRQFLW \JDW HV:LW KW KLVZHKDYHGRXEW OHVV
SURRIW KDW DOOW KHZD\W RW KH W K FHQW XU\W KHROG
W U DGLW LRQDO ODQJXDJH RI LP DJHV Z DV QRW  \ HW  D
IRU JRW W HQ DU W  IRU  W KH P DVW HU  EXLOGHU V RI W KRVH
W LP HV

7K H  &K X U F K  I R U E D G H  W K H  K D O I
W LP EHU LQJ P HW KRG RI FRQVW U XFW LRQ
RFFDVLRQDOO\ EHFDXVH LW  FRQVLGHUHG
W KLVZLVGRP DQDW W DFNDJDLQVW LW 

%XW RQO\5LFKDUG6LQQLQJW KHNQRZQFLW \P DVW HU

EXLOGHU RI +DOEHUVW DGW  KDV SURYLGHG XV ZLW K W KH
NH\ W R DQ XQGHUVW DQGLQJ RI W KH 5XQHV DV IDU DV
W KH\KDYHEHHQXVHGLQW KHEXLOGLQJVW \OHVRIW KH
*HUP DQLFKDOIW LP EHUHGKRXVHV
+H GHP RQVW UDW HV KRZ W KH 5XQHV KDYH EHHQ SUHVHUYHG W R W KLV GD\ LQ *HUP DQLF KDOOV RI
W KHLU GXNHV E\ VSHFLDO DUUDQJHP HQW  RI W KH EHDP V DQG ODW HU LQ VW RQH  +LV ZRUN ³ 'HU
5XQHQVFKOVVHO]XU(GGD´  W HOOVXVDERXW W KLVLQXQXVXDOFODULW \DQGGHSW KRILQW HUSUHW DW LRQ
6W DXIIW RRKDVZULW W HQDERXW W KHUHVXOW VRIKLVUHVHDUFKLQDERRNW LW OHG³ 5XQHQKlXVHU´  
$QGKHLVW KHILUVW RQHZKRP DGHXVDZDUHRIW KHUHJXODUO\XVHG.DKODLQRXUIDLU\W DOHV
DQG OHJHQGV $IW HU KLP  :HUQHU YRQ %ORZ FRXOG JHW  P XFK IDUW KHU LQ SRLQW LQJ RXW  W KH
VHFXUHG UHVXOW V LQ KLV ERRN ³ 0lUFKHQGHXW XQJHQ´ 
:KRLVFODLUDXGLHQW FDQOLVW HQDQGILQGRXW W KHVHFUHW RIVRXQGLQQDW XUHZLW KW KHKHOSRI
W KH 5XQHV KH XQGHUVW DQGV W KH ODQJXDJH RI W KH VW DUV DQG RI W KH ELUGV  7KH UHYHUVDO RI


³ 7KH5XQH.H\W RW KH(GGD´7KLVZRUNKDVQRW \HW EHHQW UDQVODW HGW R(QJOLVK

³ 5XQH+RXVHV´7KLVZRUNKDVQRW \HW EHHQW UDQVODW HGW R(QJOLVK

³ , QW HUSUHW DW LRQRI)DLU\7DOHV´7KLVZ RUNKDVQRW \HW EHHQW UDQVODW HGW R(QJOLVK
 

W KH ZRUG 5XQD UHVXOW V LQ 8U QD ZKDW  FRXOG P HDQ W KH 8U ERUQ RQHV QD  QDW XV /DW LQ
IRUERUQDQGZLW KW KLVLW ZRXOGEHDUHIHUHQFHW RW KH5XQHV, QW KLVZRUGLVDOVRW KHLGHD
RIDQ8U QDDVSLULW XDOYHVVHOW KDW FRQW DLQVW KH85

7KH 5XQHV DUH IRUP DW LYH DQG W UDQVIRUP DW LYH HQHUJLHV DQG W KH\ GLUHFW O\ KDYH LP SDFW
XSRQ W KH ZRUOG RI P DW W HU ZLW K W KHLU VRXQG W KHLU ZRUG  )RU LQVW DQFH YRZHOV KDYH W KH
HIIHFW  RI FRORU W RQHV RI W KH OLJKW  LQ W KH FRVP RV ZKLOH FRQVRQDQW V VKRZ OLP LW DW LRQV DQG
IRUP DW LRQRIVKDSHV(DFK5XQHUHSUHVHQW VDW ULQLW \QDP HO\QXP EHULP DJH KLHURJO\SK
DQG LGHD   7KHU HIRU H W R VSHDN  DQG U HDG 5XQHV P HDQV W R FU HDW LY HO\  DFW  XSRQ W KH
HQYLURQP HQW DQGXSRQW KHFRVP RVLW VHOI7KHUHIRUHHYHU\W KLQJLQODQJXDJHUHIHUVW RW KH
W ULQLW \ RI ³ HP HUJLQJ EHLQJ DQG SDVVLQJ DZD\´ DERYH DOO LQ W KH $U\DQ 8U ODQJXDJH EXW
DOVRLQDOO$U\DQGDXJKW HUODQJXDJHVW RZKLFKEHORQJDOOODQJXDJHVRIW KHZRUOGDQGLW
ZRXOG EH D W DVN RI OLQJXLVW LF UHVHDUFK W R W HVW  W KHVH SRLQW HUV DQG W KH UHODW LRQV LQ DOO
ODQJXDJHVW RW KH$U\DQ8U ODQJXDJHDQGW RGRVRLQLQGLYLGXDOZ RUNV

, QW KHEHJLQQLQJZDVW KHZRUGDQGIURP LW HYHU\W KLQJW KDW LVFU HDW HGKDVEHHQFUHDW HG
W KLV YHU\ DQFLHQW  ZLVGRP  LV W HDFKLQJ XV  7KH ZRUG W KH ODQJXDJH FRQW DLQV HQRUP RXV
SRZHUW RFUHDW HDQGOLIH5XQLFSRZHUVRXUOLQJXLVW LFSRZHUVDUHW UDQVIRUP HGSURFUHDW LYH
HQHUJLHVDVW KHFKDQJHRIYRLFHRIW KHP DOHXSRQP DW XULW \LVVW LOODOOXGLQJW R+HUHZH
FDQ SRLQW  RXW  VW UDQJH FRQQHFW LRQV ZKLFK FRQQHFW  W KH OLQJXLVW LF W RRO RI W KH ODU\Q[ ZLW K
W KH SU RFHVVHV RI SU RFU HDW LRQ  DQG W KRVH DU H TXHVW LRQV RI GHFLVLY H LP SRU W DQFH  EXW
ZKLFK ZRXOG W UDQVFHQG W KH IUDP HZRUN RI RXU LQW HQW LRQV LQ W KLV ERRN

5XQHV SXOO W KH FORXGV W KURXJK W KH VN\ W KH ZLQG DFURVV W KH W UHHV W KH ZDW HU RYHU  VW RQH
DQGHDUW KOLIHZLW KHYHU\ULQJRIJURZW KEHLW RQKXP DQVDQLP DOVRUSODQW V5XQHVDUH
FXW  LQW R \RXU IDFH DQG LQW R \RXU KDQG DQG UHIOHFW  \RXU NLQG \RXU W KLQNLQJ DQG \RXU
IHHOLQJ(YHU\VKDSHLV5XQH7KHUR\DO5XQHKRZHYHULVW KHRQHRIW KHKXP DQEHLQJ
W KH+DJ $OO5XQHZKLFKP HDQVW KHRQHW KDW SUHVHUYHVW HQGVDQGSURW HFW VW KHXQLYHUVH
W KHVDP HZD\DVW KHXQLYHUVHW HQGVSUHVHUYHVDQGSURW HFW VW KHKXP DQEHLQJLHW KH
KXP DQEHLQJDVEHLQJDSDUW RIW KHLQGLYLVLEOHVSLULW RI*RG5XQHVZHVFUDSHLQW RVW RQH
ZLW KW KHFKLVHODVVFXOSW XUHVZHSDLQW W KHP ZLW KFRORURQDVXUIDFHDVDUW ZRUNDQGZH
GUDZW KHP ZLW KVRXQGVLQW RW KHRFHDQRIW KHDLUDVP XVLF5XQHVYLEUDW HLQRXUFKHVW 
5XQHVSXOOW KHVW DUVW KURXJKW KHZRUOGVRQW KHLUW UDFNVDQGW KH\GHW HUP LQHW LP HVSDFH
DQGGHVW LQ\RIDOOW KLQJVDQGEHLQJV5XQHVVKLQHRQW KHQLJKW O\VN\DVFRQVW HOODW LRQVDQG
W KH\KDYHEHHQLQW HUSUHW HGDV'LYLQHZULW LQJDVIDUDVKXP DQVFDQW KLQNEDFNDQGW KH\
KDYHEHHQXVHGDVVXFKDVNHGDVVXFKDQGFDOFXODW HGDVVXFK
 

5XQHVZKLVSHUULJKW DGYLFH 5XQHQUDXQHQUHFKW HQ5DW 

)RUW KHSHUVRQZKRNQRZVW RUHDGW KHP W RVROYHW KHLUHQLJP DVDQGW RSLFNW KHP ULJKW
IRUDVSHFLILFKXP DQEHLQJRUSXUSRVHIURP W KHP XOW LW XGHRIW KHLUDSSHDUDQFHV, QW KLV
SURFHVVW KHUHLVQRW KLQJDUELW UDU\DQGFRLQFLGHQW DOEHFDXVHHYHU\W KLQJLVGHVW LQ\QRW KLQJ
LVFRLQFLGHQFH:KHUHYHUZHDUHW DONLQJRIFRLQFLGHQFHZHRYHUORRNW KHEHJLQQLQJDQG
W KHHQGRIFDXVHDQGHIIHFW W KHVDP HZD\DVRXUHDUVFDQQRW KHDUW KHKDUP RQ\RIW KH
VSKHUHVEHFDXVHW KH\DUHQRW W XQHGW RW KHLUZDYHOHQJW KV

5XQHQUDXQHQUHFKW HQ5DW 

)RUW KHSHUVRQZKRORRNVDIDUOLVW HQVDIDUW KLVLVQRORQJHUDQ\W KLQJW RGLVSXW HW KDW ZH

DUH FR LQFOXGHG DV FRVP LF 8U SDUW LFOHV LQ W KH ODZIXO FRXUVH RI W KH VW DUV DQG W KHLU P RVW
VXEW OHHP DQDW LRQVLQP RYHP HQW P DVVDQGVSLULW 

³$V RQ W KH GD\ W KDW  OHQW  \RX W R W KH ZRUOG

7KH6XQVW RRGVW LOOW RVDOXW HW KHSODQHW V
8QW LO VRRQ \RX KDYH JURZQ P RUH DQG P RUH
$FFRUGLQJ W R W KH ODZ W KDW  \RX IROORZHG
7KLV ZD\ \RX KDYH W R EH DQG \RX FDQQRW  IOHH IURP  \RXUVHOI
7KLVDOUHDG\W KHVLE\OVZHUHVD\LQJDQGW KHSURSKHW V
$QG QR W LP H DQG QR SRZHU VKDW W HUV
7KHSUH VHW VKDSHW KDW HYROYHVDVDOLYLQJEHLQJ´
*RHW K H

)RU W KLV ZH QHHG QR SURRI IRU SHRSOH ZKR FDQQRW  H[SHULHQFH W KLV IDFW  RQ W KHP VHOYHV
EHFDXVHW KHLUYHKLFOHW KHLULQVW UXP HQW ZKLFKZHFDOOERG\LVVW LOOW RRGXOODQGLW LVODFNLQJ
W KHVW ULQJVRIW KLVLQVW UXP HQW SURSHUW REHFDSDEOHRIH[SHULHQFLQJW KLVNLQGRIFRQQHFW LRQ
ZLW KW KHZRUOG6LQFHW KH\FORVHW KHP VHOYHVRIIIURP W KLVW UXW KW KHW UXW KUHP DLQVFORVHG
W R W KHP 

$VW URORJ\ LQ LW V KLJKHVW  P HDQLQJ DQG P HW KRG KDV QRW  EHHQ LQYHQW HG RU FDOFXODW HG DW
VRP H EHJLQQLQJ EXW  GXH W R W KH XQLW \ RI DOO EHLQJV DQG W KLQJV W KHUH FDQ RQO\ EH RQH
VRFLHW \RIGHVW LQ\EHW ZHHQRXW SRXULQJDQG6XQ7KHVW DUVW XGGHGKHDYHQRIW KH5XQHV
DERYHKLVKHDGDQGW KHODZLQKLVFKHVW W KDW KDVEHHQFKLVHOHGLQE\5XQHVRIFRQVFLHQFH
W KH\ SURYLGH W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ ZLW K W KH 8U FRQQHFW LRQ ZLW K HYHU\W KLQJ W KDW  H[LVW V DQG
KDSSHQVLQVSDFHDQGW LP H.DQW KDVH[SUHVVHGW KDW ZKLFKLVFOHDUO\SHUFHLYHGZLW KW KH
LP P RUW DOZRUGV ³ 7ZRW KLQJVILOOW KHHP RW LRQVDJDLQDQGDJDLQZLW KUHQHZHGDGP LUDW LRQ
DQG DZH  W KH VW DU  VW XGGHG VN\ DERYH P \VHOI DQG W KH P RUDO ODZ Z LW KLQ P H´

:KRHYHU NQRZV W KDW  ZLW K KLV KRXU RI ELUW K W KHUH LV QRW  EHJLQQLQJ D RQH W LP H OLIH RQ
(DUW KEXW W KDW ZLW KW KLVDP RUHHVVHQW LDOVSLULW XDOOLIHLVLQW HUUXSW HGIRUDEULHIW LP HVSDQ
W R KLP  LW  GRHV QRW  DSSHDU XQXVXDO W KDW  KLV OLIH RQ (DUW K QRW  RQO\ W KLV RQH EXW  DOO W KH


2PLWWHG
 

RW KHUV EHIRUH DQG DIW HU DUH FRQQHFW HG E\ IDW H ZLW K W KH W KUHDG RI ZKLFK W KH 9HGGD   LV
VSHDNLQJ DQG W KH URSH RI ZKLFK W KH (GGD LV VSHDNLQJ ZLW K ZKLFK W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ LV
W LHGW RW KHFLUFOHRIW KHKHDYHQ

:KR NQRZV W KDW  W KH W KUHDG LV GLVFRQQHFW HG

7RKLP W KHEHLQJVDUHFRQQHFW HG
$QG ZKR NQRZV W KH W KUHDG RI W KUHDGV
+H NQRZV W KH JUHDW  SRZHU RI %UDKP DQ
,  NQRZ W KH W KUHDG GLVFRQQHFW HG
7RZKLFKW KHZLVHRQHVDUHW LHG
, NQRZW KHW KUHDGRIW KUHDGV
,  NQRZ W KH JUHDW  SRZHU RI %UDKP D   9HGGD

7KLVLVQRW DW DOODTXHVW LRQRIDQDUELW UDULO\GLIIHUHQW FRQYLFW LRQRU:HOW DQVFKDXXQJEXW D

IDFW  RI H[SHULHQFH DQG FRQVHTXHQW O\ RQO\ W KH SHUVRQ FDQ P DNH VW DW HP HQW V DERXW  W KLV
Z KR LV LQ SRVVHVVLRQ RI W KLV H[SHULHQFH Z KR KDV W KLV NQRZOHGJH 1RERG\ FDQ FRQYLQFH
D EOLQG SHUVRQ W R VHH FRORUV  +H ZLOO GHQ\ W KHP   :H DUH W KH FUHDW LRQV RI DQ XQHUULQJ
P DW KHP DW LFVRIW KHKHDYHQDQGIURP W KHFUDGOHW RW KHW RP EZHDU HLQW KHKDQGVRIW KH
JUHDW  P DW KHP DW LFLDQ ZKR ³ FDOFXODW HG´  W KH FRVP RV DQG ZKR LV FDSDEOH RI W KLQNLQJ LQ
VW HOODU V\VW HP V

5DDEHDQQRXQFHV ³ 7KHVW DUVW UDYHOLQW KHLUSDW KDQGW KH\ZDW FKRYHUDOOKXP DQEHLQJV

9HU\IHZRIW KHSHRSOHRQW KLV(DUW KSD\DW W HQW LRQW RW KDW 2QHNQLIHLVVKDUSHQLQJW KH
RW KHUNQLIHDQGRQHKXP DQVKDUSHQVW KHRW KHUEXW W KHVW DUVEULQJW RJHW KHUNQLYHVDQG
GHVW LQLHVRIKXP DQV7RORRNDW W KHVW DUVZKHQFRP EDW DQW SXVKDJDLQVW HDFKRW KHUDQG
W KHEODGHVVW ULNHHDFKRW KHULVJRRGDQGXVHIXODQGLW LVDVLJQRIDVSLULW W KDW LVEH\RQG
W KHRUGLQDU\´

³ 7KH EDVLV RI W KH DVW U RORJLFDO Z RU OG Y LHZ ´  VD\ V /RP HU  ³ LV W KDW  UDGLDW LQJ FLU FOH RI
FRQVW HOODW LRQV FDOOHG W KH ]RGLDF Z KHU H W KH 6XQ 0RRQ DQG 3ODQHW V DU H W R ILQG DQG
W KURXJKZKLFKW KH\W DNHW KHLUFRXUVH)URP HDFKRQHRIW KHVHVLJQVRUKRXVHVW KH\DFW
GLIIHUHQW O\IURP RQHVW URQJHUIURP W KHRW KHURQHZHDNHU DQG W KHFDOFXODW LRQRIW KHVH
HIIHFW V DV VHHQ IURP  D VSHFLILF SODFH RQ (DUW K DQG W KH QHZ OLIH W KDW  RULJLQDW HV W KHUH LV
GRQHDFFRUGLQJW RVSHFLILFUXOHVW KDW DUHEDVHGRQH[SHULHQFH7KHVHUXOHVFDQEHW HVW HG
ZLW K HDVH E\ DQ\ SHUVRQ ZKR W DNHV W KH W LP H DQG HIIRUW  W R GR VR

$JDLQ EDVHG RQ SUDFW LFDO H[SHULHQFH W KLV ]RGLDF LV GLYLGHG LQW R W ZHOYH VLJQV RU HQHUJ\
ILHOGV  7KH\ DUH QRW  LGHQW LFDO ZLW K W KH FRQVW HOODW LRQV RI W KH VDP H QDP H EXW  VW LOO LQ RXU
GD\VW KH\DUHW KHEDVLVRXUDVW URQRP LFDOFDOFXODW LRQV$OVRW KH\KDYHQRW EHHQOLP LW HG
W RW KHQXP EHUDW DOOW LP HV

+HUHLQW KHVHP DM HVW LFVSKHUHVRIW KHKHDYHQZKLFKZHKDYHW RUHJDUGDVDFHQW HURI

8U HQHUJ\ W KH SODQHW V RI RXU 6RODU V\VW HP  P RYH DV SRZHUIXO LQGLFDW RUV W KDW  VKRZ XV
W KHIDW HVIRUQDW LRQVDQGIRUKXP DQVDOLNH7KLVLVDGRFW ULQHW KDW FRUUHVSRQGVHQW LUHO\
W RW KHZRQGHUIXOV\P EROLFLGHDVW KDW DUHFRQW DLQHGLQW KH(GGD DFFRUGLQJZKLFKW KHILUVW
URRW RIW KHZRUOGDVKW UHHVSUHDGVDFURVVW KHKHDYHQ, QW KHGD]]OHRIW KHJRGVLW VD\V
 

W KDW  EHQHDW K W KLV URRW  LV W KH Z HOO W KDW  LV W KH P RVW  VDFUHG RI Z HOOV DQG W KH Z HOO RI 8UGD
ZKLFKLVW KHZHOORIEHFRP LQJRURIEHJLQQLQJ7KHUHW KHJRGVKDYHW KHLUSODFHRIFRXUW
DQG HYHU\ GD\ W KH $HVLU ULGH W KHUH DFURVV W KH EULGJH %HEHUDVW  ZKLFK LV DOVR FDOOHG W KH
EULGJH RI W KH $HVLU´ 

$VZHNQRZW KLVEULGJHLVW KHUDLQERZDQGW KHROGJRGVDUHQRW KLQJHOVHEXW W KHFHQW HUV

RIHQHUJ\W KDW DUHFU\VW DOOL]HGLQW KHSODQHW DU\ERGLHVRIRXU6RODUV\VW HP 

7KHUDLQERZLVW KHVXQOLJKW W KDW KDVEHHQVSOLW LQW RLW VVHYHQFRORUVE\W KHFORXGVDQGLQ

IDFW DVW URORJ\W DXJKW W KDW W RHDFKSODQHW DU\HQHUJ\DFRORULVFRUUHVSRQGLQJW KDW UHIOHFW V
LW V VSHFLILF FKDUDFW HU  7KHUHIRUH W KH $HVLU W KDW  ULGH DFURVV W KH OLJKW  EULGJH LV D JUHDW
V\ P EROLF LP DJH RI W KHVH P \ VW HU LRXV LQQHU  U HODW LRQV   7KH SU RFHVV RI ³ U LGLQJ´  LW VHOI
UHSUHVHQW VDVDQLP DJHW KDW UDSLGDQGUK\W KP LF5LW D OLNH.QLJKW  ³ 5LW W HU´ ±OLNHULGHU
OLNHP RYHP HQW LQZKLFKDOOFHOHVW LDOERGLHVDUHFRQW LQXRXVO\$QRW KHUYHU\ZHOO FKRVHQ
GHVFULSW LRQRIW KHOLJKW ILOOHGVRODUUHDOP LVDOVRZKHQW RLW LVUHIHUUHGLQW KH³ W ZLOLJKW RI
W KHJRGV´ DV³ W KHILHOGRIVSOHQGRU ´³ 7KHUHDUHW ZHOYH$HVLURI'LYLQHNLQG´ W KHGD]]OHRI
W KH *RGV W HOOV XV  $JDLQ W KHUH LV DQ H[DFW  FRUUHODW LRQ W R W KH  VLJQV RI W KH ]RGLDF RU
KRXVHV RI KHDYHQ

, W  LV W KH 7\U FLUFOH RI W KH *HUP DQLF JRG 7\U DQG LW V QDP H LV QRW  GHULYHG IURP  ³ 7LHU ´ 
DQLP DO LQ *HUP DQ ODQJXDJH  EHFDXVH QRW  DOO RI LW V VLJQV DUH QDP HG DIW HU DQLP DOV DQG
W KH\KDGRW KHUQDP HVLQW KHSDVW 7KHZRUG7\ULVNLQW R7UL W KUHHW XUQW ZLVW HUDQG
P HDQVKHUHW KHFLUFOHW KDW W XUQV7\ULVW KHW KUHHIROG*RGW KH³ IDLW KIXO´


7KLVLVW KHHQGRIW KHIRRW QRW HE\/RP HU1RLQIRUP DW LRQE\*RUVOHEHQLVJLYHQRILW VRULJLQ
 

³ W UHXH´ LQP RGHUQ*HUP DQ *RGW KH*RGRIW KH³ 'UXLGV´W KHKLJKHVW RQHRIW KHW ULQLW \
+LVVRQVW KH³ W ZHOYHJRGV´ DUHW KHLQGLYLGXDOVLJQVRIW KH]RGLDFW KHILHOGVRIVSOHQGRU
RIW KHKHDYHQLQZKLFKW KHLQGLYLGXDO$HVLUDUHUXOLQJDQGXQIROGW KHLUSRZHUDQGH[HUW
W KHLULQIOXHQFH

7KH7\U FLUFOH ³ 7ZHOYH$HVLURI'LYLQHNLQG´

$JDLQZHILQGW KHODZRISRODULW \W KDW UXOHVODQJXDJHLQW KHZRUGV7\UDQG7LHU/LIHVSDQV

EHW ZHHQ 7\U DQG 7LHU DQG W KLV OLIH LV D 7UL  W XUQ   W KH YRUW H[ W KDW  FUHDW HV OLIH DQG LV LW V
EDVLV RU FRQGLW LRQ ZKLFK HQFRP SDVVHV W KH VP DOOHVW  DQG ODUJHVW  W KLQJV LQ W KH FRVP RV
LHW KHDW RP ZLW KLW VZKLUOLQJHOHFW URQVDQGW KH6XQZLW KLW VZKLUOLQJSODQHW V$QLP DODQG
7\U DQLP DO DQG *RG  7KLV GHGXFW LRQ LV DOVR SURYHQ LQ ³ ]RGLDF´  IURP  *UHHN =RRQ
DQLP DOW KHUHIRUHFLUFOHRIDQLP DOVZKLFKLVDOVRW KHFLUFOHRI=HXV
 

2Q H  R I  W K H  P D Q \
W K RX VDQ G V RI  VS LU DOV
DERXW   \ HDU V E F H
Z KLFK KDV EHHQ IRXQG LQ
W KH VRLO RI *HUP DQLD LH
Z K H U H  *H U P D Q V  O L Y H G 
7KLVLVDJROGHQVSLUDOIURP
6LOHVLD   7KH U HVHDU FKHU V
ZLW KW KHVSDGHV JLYHQRW
P X FK  W K RX J K W  W R W K H
P HDQLQJRIW KHVHVSLUDOV
 DQG W KH\ FRQVLGHU W KHP  W R EH SLHFHV RI M HZHOU\ DV P DQ\ RW KHU SLHFHV
7KH\VLP SO\GRQRW F R Q V L G H U  W K D W  W K L V  F R X O G  E H  D V\P ERORIW KH\HDUO\
FRXUVH RI W KH 6XQ :H VKRXOG FRXQW  W KH QXP EHU RI W KH GRXEOH EDQGV W KDW
IRUP W KHGRXEOHVSLUDODQGZHUHFHLYHSDLUVDJDLQW KHQXP EHU 7KLV
H[SODQDW LRQ LV W RR VLP SOH VR W KDW  W KHU H LV QR QHHG W R U HSHDW  LW   )U RP
W KRXVDQGVRIXQHDUW KHGDUW LIDFW VZHFDQP DNHVXFKGHGXFW LRQV$VSHFLDO
UHVHDUFK HIIRUW  FRXOG ILQG LP SRUW DQW  DVW URQRP LFDO DQG DVW URORJLFDO UHVXOW V
IURP  W KH HDUO\ W LP HV  7KH FRQGLW LRQ W R W KDW  ZRXOG EH NQRZOHGJH RI W KH
ZKROH V\P EROLVP  W KDW  LV QRW  M XVW  VXUIDFH NQRZOHGJH  

7Z R 1RU W K  *HU P DQ  E U RQ ]H Z RU OG V\ P ERO ORQJ EHIRU H

VZRUGVVKRZRQW KHNQREW KH DQ\ERG\ FRXOG LP DJLQH W KH
Q X P E HU     LQ  U LQ J V DQ G 5RP DQ-HZLVK &KULVW LDQLW \
DQRW KHU W LP H W KH QXP EHU  1 R U G L F R U Q D P H Q W V VK R Z
HDFK  W LP H Z LW K  W K H 'LY LQ H VSLU DOV P RVW  RI  W K H W LP H
FHQW HUSRLQW DVW KHW KLUW HHQW K 7K L V  L V  D Q  H V V H Q W L D O
RUQLQW KSDUW 7KHNQRERIW KH FKDU DFW HU LVW LF RI W KH LQQHU
VZRUGVKRZVDUXQQLQJVSLUDO LQVLJKW  FRQFHU QLQJ W KH OLIH
ZLW KW XUQV$OVRDSLQZLW K W K DW  HW HU Q DOO\  U HY ROY HV LQ
DZKHHOW KDW KDVW KUHHFLUFOHV VSLUDOV Z KLFK ERRVW HG E\
RQ W KH ZKHHO FURVV D W ULQLW \ W KHVSLULW VSLUDOVXSZDUGVW R
\HDUVEHIRUH&KULVW W KH W KH KLJKHVW  SHDNV LQ RUGHU
W R VORZO\ UHW XUQ W R LW V SRLQW  RI RULJLQ ZKLFK QHYHU LV H[DFW O\  W KH VDP H
KRZHYHUEXW DOZD\VDIHZVW HSVKLJKHUW KDQW KHSUHFHGLQJRQH


 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

2YHUW KH7\U FLUFOHW KH5XQHVOHDGXVEDFNW RW KHUR\DODUW RILQW HUSUHW LQJW KHVW DUV7KH
]RGLDFZLW KLW V5XQLFVW UXFW XUHLVDQLP DJHRI*RGLQW KLVYLVLEOHZRUOG

)URP W KUHHFURVVHVRQH3OXV V\P ERODQGW ZRP XOW LSOLFDW LRQ[V\P EROV

W KH ]RGLDF RI  SDUW V LV FRP SRVHG [[   [    EHDP V DUH W KH
VSRNHV RI W KH KHDYHQO\ ZKHHO ZLW K W KH  DUP V

7KHP RVW LP SRUW DQW RQHRIW KHVHW KUHHFURVVHVLVW KHYHUW LFDO KRUL]RQW DO
7K H W Z HOY H Z K HHO SOXV FURVVZLW KLW VIRXUFDUGLQDOSRLQW V  

, W  IRUP V W KH FRVP LF EDFNERQH VR W R VD\  7KLV ZKHHO P DLQ FURVV ZLW K W ZHOYH VSRNHV
KDV EHHQ W UDQVP LW W HG W R XV QXP HURXV W LP HV DV VZDVW LND VLQFH W KH ROGHVW  W LP HV DV D
V\P ERO RI W KH 6XQ ZKLFK RQ W KH RW KHU KDQG FRP LQJ IURP  YHU\ DQFLHQW  ZLVGRP  RI W KH
DQFHVW RUVRUZLVGRP RIRXUKHULW DJHLVDVSHDNLQJV\P ERORIW KHUK\W KP RIW KHKHDYHQ
DVDZKROHDQGRIRXULQW HJUDW LRQLQW RW KLVKXJHUK\W KP (YHU\ ZKHUHZKHUHLW DSSHDUV
LQW KLVIRUP LW LVW RW DNHDVDQLUUHIXW DEOHSURRIW KDW W KHKXP DQEHLQJVZKRGHVLJQHGLW
KDYH EHHQ XVLQJ DVW URORJ\    7KH DUFKHG VHJP HQW V RQ W KH HQGV RI
W KHFURVVUHIOHFW SUHFLVHO\W KH³ FDUGLQDOSRLQW V´ZKLFKP HDQVW KHVSDFHV
RI W KH ILUVW  IRXUW K VHYHQW K DQG W HQW K KRXVHV RI W KH ]RGLDF  $OVR
ZKHQ W KLV FURVV LV YLHZHG ZH KDYH W KH LP SUHVVLRQ RI D URW DW LRQ W R
W KH ULJKW  LH IURP  W KH (DVW  W R W KH :HVW  DV LV KDSSHQLQJ ZLW K W KH
]RGLDF7KLVLVW KHULJKW URW DW LRQQDP HO\W KHURW DW LRQW RW KHULJKW , W V
FRUUHODW HLVW KHURW DW LRQW RW KHOHIW , P DJLQHDKXP DQEHLQJVW DQGLQJ
RQW KH1RUW K3ROHLQURW DW LRQW RW KHULJKW ZKLOHLW VQHJDW LYHLVDKXP DQEHLQJVW DQGLQJRQ
W KH6RXW KSROHLQURW DW LRQW RW KHOHIW 7KHUHIRUHERW KFURVVHVLQFOXGHW KHW KHRQLFDQGW KH

GHP RQLFFKDUDFW HULVW LFV XSDQGGRZQJRRGDQGHYLO7KHODQJXDJHRIV\P EROVVSHDNV

W RXVLQSODLQW HUP VZKLFKP HDQVZLW KDOOW KHUHLVW RVD\

7KHVZDVW LNDLVW KHV\P ERORIW KHVRODUSRZHUW RW XUQRQW KHSROH, QP DQ\SODFHVW KHUH
LVVW LOOFRQIXVLRQDERXW W KHGLUHFW LRQRIW KHURW DW LRQRIW KHVZDVW LND, W LVLP SRUW DQW W KDW

7KDW LVRQW KHSLHFHRISDSHUZKHUHKHGUDZVVXFKDGLDJUDP DQGDUELW UDULO\GHW HUP LQHVIRUD
KRUL]RQW DO OLQH W R UHSUHVHQW  W KH OLQH EHW Z HHQ W KH HTXLQRFW LDO SRLQW V  ³ +RUL]RQW DO´  DQG ³ YHUW LFDO´
GRHV QRW  FRXQW  IRU W KH HFOLSW LF SHU VH

7KLVW \SHRIORJLFREYLRXVO\LVW RRDGYDQFHGIRUP H , W VRXQGVYHU\P XFKOLNH*RUVOHEHQ¶VFODLP
W KDW  DQ\  FU RVV W KDW  DSSHDU V DQ\ Z KHU H RQ (DU W K DQG SRVVLEO\  RQ RW KHU  SODQHW V  LV SU RRI RI
&KULVW LDQLW \KDYLQJEHHQSUDFW LFHGW KHUHDQGLW EHLQJDQ³$U\DQRIIVKRRW FXOW XUH´
 

ZH FODULI\ W KLV TXHVW LRQ KHUH DQG W KDW  ZH FRP H W R D FRQFOXVLRQ  7KH ODZ RI SRODULW \ LV
JHQHUDOO\NQRZQDQGZHP HQW LRQHGLW P DQ\W LP HVKHUH+RZHYHU LW LVOHVVNQRZQW KDW

$QFLHQW $P HULFDQFURVVHV

W KHVH SRODU HQHUJLHV RI W KH ZRUOG DFW  LQ W KH IRUP  RI URW DW LRQ DQG RQ RXU (DUW K W KLV
URW DW LRQJRHVW RW KHULJKW RQW KH1RUW K3ROHDQGOHIW RQW KH6RXW K3ROH7KLVLVH[SUHVVHG
LQW KHV\P EROVRIERW KVZDVW LNDV7KHDQFLHQW VKDGDOVRNQRZOHGJHRIW KLVDQGZHDUH
ZRQGHULQJ DERXW  W KH RULJLQ RI W KLV NQRZOHGJH EHFDXVH ZH GR QRW  ZDQW  W R DGP LW  W KDW
W KHVHSHRSOHKDGDVSLULW XDOLQVLJKW LQW KHVHW KLQJVZLW KZKLFKLQVLJKW W KH\VDZIXUW KHU
ZLW K OHVV HIIRUW  DQG EHLQJ VXEM HFW  W R OHVV HUURUV W KDQ FRXOG EH GRQH ZLW K W KH  VHQVHV
DORQHW KDW ZLOOYDOXHW KHP LQGDQGUHDVRQZKLFKDUHVW LOOP RUHGHFHSW LYHDQGHUURQHRXV

3HUKDSVW KHROGHVW VZDVW LND± 3UHKLVW RULFVZDVW LNDZLW KVSLUDOV

RQW KHZ DOOLP DJHVRI%RKXVOlQLQ6Z HGHQ

/DQFHUV ZLW K KHOP HW V LQIDQW U\ ZLW KRXW  KHOP HW V EXW  ZLW K VKLHOGV ZKLFK VKRZ W KH
YHU\DQFLHQW SDW W HUQRIW KHOLOLHVW KHZRUOGDVKW UHH7KHOHDGHUREYLRXVO\LVGLIIHUHQW
W KDQW KHRW KHUW ZRIRRW VROGLHUVZKLFKREYLRXVO\VW DQGIRUZKROHUHJLP HQW VZLW KD
IRXU IROG OLO\ LH  HQGV LQ FRQW UDVW  W R W KH W KUHH IROG OLOLHV ZLW K  HQGV  7KH
QXP EHUV  DQG  DUH FHUW DLQO\ QRW  D FRLQFLGHQFH KHUH  7KH ULGHUV DUH ZHDULQJ
VRP H NLQG RI SODW H DUP RU  7KH\ DQG W KH ³ KHOP VP HQ´  RQ W KH ZKHHOV DUH ZHDULQJ
XQLIRUP V  7KHUHIRUH W KLV VXSSRVHG GLVFRYHU\ XQLIRUP V  LV QRW  SDUW  RI W KH P LGGOH
DJHV7KHIRRW VROGLHUVDUHHTXLSSHGOLJKW O\ REYLRXVO\W KH\Z HDURQO\VDQGDOVDQG
VKRUW  VNLUW V VXFK DV W KH 6FRW W LVK KLJKODQGHUV  7KH RGGHVW  W KLQJ LV W KH 6XQ ZKHHO
EHFDXVH KHU H Z H KDYH W R GR Z LW K VXFK D W KLQJ QDP HO\ D Z LQG U RVH Z LW K HLJKW
VSRNHVW KHUHIRUHDOVRD+DJ $OO7KHW ZRP HQLQW KH³ FRDW V´ DUHREYLRXVO\SHRSOH
NQRZOHGJHDEOHLQW KHVW DUVDQGW KHW LP HVZKRKDYHFDOFXODW HGDIDYRUDEOHW LP HIRU
W KH ZDU  QH[W  SDJH
 

'HVFULSW LRQSUHYLRXVSDJH
 

7KH VZDVW LND FRQVLVW V RI W ZR VW DYHV RQH RQ W RS RI W KH RW KHU W KHQ HQGV RI ZKLFK DUH
EHQW W RW KHULJKW RUW RW KHOHIW 2ULJLQDOO\LW LVDVLP SOHFURVVDQGDVVXFKDVRULJLQDOO\W KH
&KULVW LDQFURVVDVZHOODV\P ERORIUHW XUQ NH UH X] VZHHSRXW  7KHEHQW RYHUHQGV
SRLQW  DW  W KH GLUHFW LRQ LQ W KH FRVP RV W KH 6XQ  7KHUHIRUH W KH VZDVW LND LV W KH V\P ERO RI
W KH6XQ%DVHGRQW KLVZHFDQDOVRH[SODLQW KHRW KHUZRUGIRUW KHVZDVW LNDW KHI\UIRV
ZKLFKZHH[SODLQH[RW HULFDOO\DVILUHIRRW EHFDXVHW KHIRXUDU P VRIW KHFURVVZHUH DQG
W KH *UHHNV GLG W KDW  W RR  UHSUHVHQW HG E\ KXP DQ IHHW   7KH IRRW  LV D P DOH V\P ERO RI
SURFUHDW LRQ FRQW UDU\ W R W KH VKRH ZKLFK LV D IHP DOH V\P ERO  )\U IRV W KHUHIRUH P HDQV
SURFUHDW LRQZLW KW KHILUH2IFRXUVHKHUHLVDFRQQHFW LRQZLW KW KHDUUDQJHP HQW W RP DNH
ILUH W KHILUHGULOOZKLFKJHQHUDW HVILUH I\UIRV

:LW KW KLVZHZDQW W RVD\W KDW DOOOLIHLVZDUP W KILUHFRP EXVW LRQURW DW LRQ6XQ$OVRW KH
GLUHFW LRQVRIURW DW LRQRIW KHVZDVW LNDKDYHW KHLUP HDQLQJ:LW KW KLVW KHW KHRQLF 'LYLQH
SRVLW LYHJRRG DQGGHP RQLFIRUFHVRIW KLVKLHURJO\SKDUHLQGLFDW HG7KHW XUQW RW KHULJKW
V\P EROL]HVDVFHQGLQJOLIHW KHW XUQW RW KHOHIW UHSUHVHQW VGHVFHQGLQJOLIH2IW HQZHILQG

W XUQLQJULJKW W XUQLQJOHIW

W KH VZDVW LND HQFORVHG LQ D FLUFOH EHFDXVH LW  P HDQV W KH UHW XUQ RI OLIH LQ W KH F\FOH RI
HYHQW V$FFRUGLQJW RW KLVZHUHFRJQL]HLQW KHVZDVW LNDDYHU\DQFLHQW V\P ERORIOLIHW KDW
KDV EHHQ XVHG IRU P DQ\ P LOOHQQLD P RUH RU OHVV FRQVFLRXVO\ ZLW KRXW  DQ\ DJJUHVVLYH
P HDQLQJEXW M XVW DQLP DJHDSURW HFW LYHV\P ERORIZHOOEHLQJERUQLQW KHZLVGRP RIW KH
'LYLQHRULJLQRIOLIHDQGDQDGP RQLVKP HQW W RDOOW RP DLQW DLQW KHHW HUQDOODZRIDVFHQGLQJ
OLIH LQ KXP DQNLQG LQ W KH IRON  , W  LV D ZDUQLQJ RQO\ DJDLQVW  DOO GHVW UXFW LYH JRDOV DQG
SRZHUV ZKLFK FRQW UDGLFW  W KH ODZV RI DVFHQGLQJ OLIH  


7KLVFHUW DLQO\KDVW KHSRW HQW LDORIYHU\EURDGLQW HUSUHW DW LRQV
 

7KHRSLQLRQW KDW W KHVZDVW LNDW XUQLQJW RW KHULJKW KDVW REHGHVLJQHGOLNHW KLVLVZURQJ
:H SRLQW  KHUH W R W KH H[SHULP HQW V LQ SK\VLFV ZLW K ZKHHOV RI UHDFW LRQ  7KH P DQ RI W KH
SHRSOH ZKR ZRUNV DV D SXP S P DQ W XUQV W KH ZKHHO ZLW K VSRNHV DOZD\V W R W KH OHIW 

7KH VZDVW LND W UDYHOHG ZLW K W KH $U\DQV DOO DURXQG W KH (DUW K DOUHDG\ W KRXVDQGV RI \HDUV
DJR DQG UHP DLQHG DV D VDFUHG 'LYLQH V\P ERO SDUW  RI W KH ZRUVKLS ZLW K DOO SHRSOHV W KDW
W KH\ IHUW LOL]HG ZLW K W KHLU 'LYLQH EORRG W R DVFHQW  DQG P RUDOV  , W  UHP DLQHG W KHUH W R W KLV
GD\DQGLQFOXGHGLQW KLVLVDOVRW KHVLP SOHFURVVW KDW LVIDOVHO\FDOOHGW KH³ &KULVW LDQ´ RQH
7KLVODW W HUFURVVKDVDOZD\VEHHQDV\P ERORIW KHZRUOGEXW LW ZDVVW ULSSHGE\&KULVW LDQLW \

RILW VGHHSP HDQLQJDQGIXUQLVKHGZLW KDFODLP W KDW LW LVDV\P ERORIW RUW XUHRQZKLFKD
KXP DQEHLQJZDVNLOOHG%XW W KHVZDVW LNDLVQRW DV\P EROIRUW KDW ZKLFKLVILQLW HEXW LW LV
DV\P ERORILQILQLW \

.QRZ W K\VHOI   7KHVH ZRUGV DUH W KH VZDVW LND¶V FDOO W R XV DERYH DOO DV ZHOO   5HGHHP
W K\VHOI $QGDERYHDOOGRQRW FRXQW RQGHDW KDQGUHGHP SW LRQE\ DQRW KHUSHUVRQHYHQ
LILW LVDJRG

7KHVZDVW LNDZLW KRULHQW DW LRQW RW KHULJKW V\P EROL]HVW KH'LYLQHODZRIEHFRP LQJZKLOH
W KH VZDVW LND ZLW K RULHQW DW LRQ W R W KH OHIW  V\P EROL]HV W KH GHVW LQ\ RI HYHU\W KLQJ W KDW  KDV
HYROYHG W R LW V SDVVLQJ DZD\

%RW K FURVVHV FDQ DOVR EH UHSUHVHQW HG E\ W ZR FURVVHV RI W KH ³ &DOYDU\ 0RXQW DLQ´ ZKLFK
H[SUHVV W KH VDP H LGHD LH RI EHFRP LQJ DQG SDVVLQJ DZD\ LH W KH 5XQH (+ ODZ

DVFHQVLRQ DQG W KH 5XQH 12' GRZQIDOO GHVW UXFW LRQ DQG GHDW K  :KHQ SXW  RQ W RS RI
HDFKRW KHUERW K5XQHV FURVVHV UHVXOW LQW KH+DJ $OO 5XQHW KHXQLYHUVHW KHP HDQLQJ
DQGFRQW HQW RIZKLFKLVEHFRP LQJDQGSDVVLQJDZD\

7KH ³ P LOOLQJ SDW K´  RI OLIH KDV EHHQ DW W ULEXW HG D GHHS DQG P XOW LSOH P HDQLQJ VLQFH W LP HV
LP P HP RULDO  7KH ZRUGV W KDW  DUH UHODW HG W R W KH LP DJH RI W KH P LOO DQG RI P LOOLQJ KDYH
EHHQ FRQW HQW  DQG VSHFLDO LP DJHU \  LQ P DQ\  P \ W KV P RVW  RI W KH W LP H LQ D W KU HHIROG
P HDQLQJ QDP HO\W KHSURFHVVRIP LOOLQJW KDW ZKLFKKDVW REHP LOOHGDQGW KDW ZKLFKLV
P LOOHGLHW KHP LOOW KHJUDLQDQGW KHIORXU
 

7KHZRUOGLVDP LOO(DUW KDQGKHDYHQDUHJULQGVW RQHVEHW ZHHQZKLFKDKXP DQEHLQJDQG

KLVGHVW LQ\DUHP LOOHG+HLVJURXQGGRZQW RIORXULQRUGHUW REHFRP HJUDLQDJDLQRQW KH
SDW K RI QDW XUDO W UDQVIRUP DW LRQ RI P DW W HU DQG JUDLQ ZDV DOZD\V D V\P ERO RI HW HUQDO
UHW XUQ  7KLV ODW W HU W KRXJKW  ZDV XVHG E\ W KH &KULVW LDQV LQ W KH ³ 6DFUHG *HUHRQ´  7KH
FURVVRI*HUHRQFOHDUO\SRLQW VW RP LOOLQJDQGW XUQLQJ *HUHRQ .HKUH XP  W XUQDURXQG
DQG LW  LV DJDLQ DQRW KHU QDP H IRU W KH W ULSRG W KH W KUHH IRRW   %XW  W KH JUDLQ LV DOVR W KH
FURZQ   LH W KH ULQJ RI OLIH DURXQG W KH KHDG RI W KH FURZQHG SHUVRQ RI W KH DQRLQW HG
RQH RU W KH LQLW LDW H LQW R W KH VHFUHW  RI W KH HW HUQDO UHW XUQ RI W KDW  ZKLFK KDSSHQV IURP

7KHKHDGRI*HUHRQ

EHFRP LQJ RYHU EHLQJ W R SDVVLQJ DZD\  , Q W KH 5XQH 4XRUQ  W KLV P HQW DO LP DJH KDV
IRXQG D V\P EROLF UHSUHVHQW DW LRQ  7KH ZKHHO RI W LP H W KH P LOO RI *RG ZKLFK JULQGV
VORZO\ EXW  ZLW K FHUW DLQW \ ZH VHH LW  W XUQ RQ W KH QLJKW O\ VN\ DURXQG LW V D[LV  $ERYH RXU
KHDGVW KHZKHHORIW LP HURW DW HVDURXQGW KHSROHDW QLJKW LW LVW KHVZDVW LNDW KHZKHHO
FURVVZKLFKDVDV\P ERORIW KHZRUOG ZHGGLQJW KHZRUOG P LOOLQJLVW KH5XQHRI*RGRI
W KHJLYHU

6W LOO LQ RXU GD\V W KH .URGR DOW DU LQ *RVODU VW DQGV RQ IRXU IHHW  ZKLFK LQGLFDW HV IRXU
IROGHGQHVV OHDGHUVKLS 9LHUXQJ ± )KUXQJ  LQGLFDW LQJ W KH URXQG RI W KH KHDYHQV  , W  LV
FRQVHFUDW HG W R W KH P DVW HU RI W KH P LOO W R W KH *URW W D W KH P LOO *URW W L RI W KH (GGD ZKLFK
HYHQW XDOO\ JULQGV XS W KH ZHOO EHLQJ DQG P LVIRUW XQH RI KXP DQNLQG LQ KRUULI\LQJ P LOOLQJ
DFW LRQDQGW KHQIDOOVLQW RW KHGHSW KVRIHW HUQDVZDW HU:HVKRXOGDOORZW KHP LOO*URW W LW R
EHFRP HDP LOORIOXFNDJDLQDVLW ZDVW KHP LOOJDP H W KHP RGHU Q*HUP DQZRUGIRUW KH
QLQH P HQ¶V 0RUULV *DP H  RI RXU FKLOGKRRG GD\V

7KHREDOG %LHGHU P HQW LRQV D YHU\ P HDQLQJIXO RSLQLRQ FRQFHUQLQJ W KH SRVVLEOH RULJLQ RI
W KH VKDSH RI W KH VZDVW LND DV VHHQ LQ W KH GUDZLQJ  7KH W UXW K DERXW  W KH RULJLQ RI VXFK
V\P EROV LV W KDW  W KH\ DUH UHIOHFW LRQ RI FRVP LF IDFW V ZKLFK KDSSHQV DOVR ZLW KRXW  EHLQJ
LP P HGLDW HO\ FRQVFLRXV W R W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ  7KH KDQG RI W KH DUW LVW  GHVLJQV OLQHV DQG
FLUFOHVW KDW DUHDOUHDG\IDFW RQW KHVN\, QRW KHUZRUGVZHFDQQRW LQYHQW DQ\W KLQJW KDW
GRHVQRW DOUHDG\H[LVW LQQDW XUHDVLGHDLQW KHW UHDVXU\RILW V6KDSHV7KHLP DJHRIW KH


+HUHKHXVHVW KHVLP LODULW \RIW KHP RGHUQ*HUP DQZRUGV³ .URQH´  FURZQ ZLW K³ .RUQ´  JUDLQ ±LQ
(QJOLVKZ HFRXOGXVH±DVKHUH±JUDLQDQG J FURZ Q

 

7KH ZRUOG
5XQHFORFN
DFFRUGLQJ W R :HUQHU Y %ORZ
 

([SODQDW LRQVRIW KH:RUOG5XQH&ORFN

&LUFOH W KHVXLW HVRIW KH*HUP DQFDUGJDP H
&LUFOH    W KH SURFUHDW LYH P HDQLQJ RI W KH ILUVW  IRXU V\P EROV Z KLFK W KH 'LYLQH P DJLFLDQ
KDV LQ IURQW  RI KLP  RQ W KH ILUVW  FDUG RI W KH 7DURW  DQG ZKLFK DUH UHSHDW HG LQ W KLV JDP H
ZKLFK FRQW DLQV W KH ZKROH VHFUHW  GRFW ULQH RI 7KRW  +HUP HV  ZDQGV FXSV VZRUGV DQG
SHQW DFOHV FRLQV 
&LUFOH    W KH 1RUGLF UXQHV LQ W KH VHTXHQFH RI W KH +DYDP DO  $W     DQG  W KH
FRRP RQ*HUP DQLF5XQHVKDSHLVDGGHGDQGP DUNHGZLW KD³ J´, QW KHRXW HUIURQW FRUQHU
W KDW W XUQVULJKW W KHDQFLHQW URP DQVW \OHRIW KHVRXQGLVDGGHG, W VVLP LODULW \W R5XQHVLV
VWULNLQJ
$ERFHW KHOLQHDUHW KHQDP HVRIW KH5XQHVDFFRUGLQJW RW KH1RUGLF5XQHVRQJEHORZW KH
OLQHDUHW KRVHRIW KHDQJORVD[RQ5XQHVRQJRQW KHULJKW W KHUHRIDUHW KRVHRIW KH%DYDU
LDQ5XQHVRQJDFFRUGLQJW R7UREDQXV0DXUXV
&LUFOH UHSUHVHQW VW KH5XQHVLQW KHFRUUHVSRQGLQJVLJQVRIW KH]RGLDF
&LUFOH    QDP HV W KH  UXOHUV RI W KH P RQW KV W KDW  KDYH EHHQ UHYHDOHG E\ :RGDQ LQ W KH
*ULP QLVP DOW KHW KRIZKLFKKDGW RGLHDW W KHW LP HRIW UDQVLW LRQRIW KH6XQ \HDUW RW KH
/XQDU\HDU, QW KLVKRXVHRIW KH%$55XQH, SXW 2HNX7KRUW KHJRGIROLJKW QLQJEHFDXVH
LW LVKHZKRFDUULHVW KHZDQGHUHUW RW KHVW DUV 2HUYDQGLO DFFU RVVW KHLF\ELOORZVRIOLJKW 
IRUZKLFKUHDVRQKHLVDOVRFDOOHG)DUP D7\UZKLFKLVFDUULHU *RG
, QW KHFDUU\LQJVLJQRI%$5W KHVRQ EDUQLQ0LGGOH+LJK*HUP DQ ZKLFKLVW KHKXP DQ
SHUVRQDOLW \ZKLFKFDUULHVLQLW VHOIW KHFRQVFLRXVQHVVRI*RGDQGRIEHLQJDFKLOGRI*RG
&LUFOH W HOOVW KHQXP HULFYDOXHRIW KH5XQHVDQGW KH6NDOGLFQDP HVRIW KHQXP EHUV
&LUFOH VKRZVW KH$U\DQEDVLFODZRIW ULSOHJRYHUQP HQW ZKLFKZLW KDOLW W OHGHYLDW LRQRI
W KH P HDQLQJ LV XVHIXO IRU W KH 1RUGLF 5XQH VRQJ ZKLFK HQGV ZLW K W KH W K 5XQH W KH
W K5XQHLVEHLQJLW VW ZLQV\P EROLVRQO\DQDGGHQGXP W RW KHW K5XQH DQGRIW KH
$%&GDULXP QRUGLFXP  1RUGLF$OSKDEHW RI6W *DOOHQ7KHQW KHOLQHRIVHSDUDW LRQLVDIW HU
DQGDQGHDFKW LP HDV\P ERORIFRXUW RIODZLVDW W KHHQG 5, 7 KXP DQM XGJP HQW 
$5 M XGJP HQW RIW KHGHDG DQG<5 M XVJP HQW RIW KHZRUOG

VDP HLQROG*HUP DQ
 

VZDVW LND LV VXFK D V\P ERO RI OLIH W KDW  ZDV ERUQ LQ W KH FRVP RV Z KLFK QHYHU KDG M XVW  D
FOHDUDQGSODLQP HDQLQJ$VW KHD[LVRIW KHKHDYHQEULQJVW KH YDXOW RIW KHVN\W RJORZ
DQG LV SU RFUHDW LRQ W KLV Z D\ GRHV HYHU\ W XU Q RI DQ D[LV DOVR RQ W KH SODQH RI W KH (DUW K
7R EULQJ W KLV FRQQHFW LRQ RI KHDYHQ DQG HDUW K EDFN DJDLQ LQW R W KH FRQVFLRXVQHVV RI W KH
KXP DQ EHLQJ RI W KH SUHVHQW  EDVHG RQ W KRXVDQGV RI VP DOO DQG ODU JH FRP SDULVRQV DQG
SDUDEOHV W KLV LV W KH W DVN W KDW  ZH KDYH GHFLGHG W R GR  7KHVH RUQDP HQW V RI W KH FXOW  RI
W KHILUHZHUHW KHLQH[KDXVW LEOHSDW W HUQVRIDOORUQDW HRQHTXLSP HQW FORW KLQJDQGKRXVHKROG
DUW LFOHVDQGRQO\ZLW KW KHEHJLQQLQJRIW KHP RGHUQW LP HVEHJLQQLQJZLW KW KHUHQDLVVDQFH
GLVDSSHDUW KHDQFLHQW V\P EROVRIZHOO EHLQJIRULQVW DQFHLQFU DIW VGRQHE\IHP DOHV

7KHVZDVW LNDLQFOXGHVLQLW W KHP \VW HU\RIW KHIRXUIROGQHVVZKLFKLVW KHOHDGHUVKLSLQW KH

VSLULW XDOUHDOP VEXW DOVRRIP DNLQJILUH  EHFDXVHLW LVDV\P ERORIOLJKW DQGOLIHDQGW KH
W RRO RI FUHDW LQJ OLIH DQG ILUH DV VXFK Z LW K LW V W Z R Z RRGHQ VW LFNV W KH EHDP V ³ KDUG´  DQG
³ VRIW ´$VNDQG(P ELDYHUW LFDODQGKRUL]RQW DOW KHVLQNHUDQGW KHVFDOHVZKLFKUHFHLYHV
W KDW ZKLFKLVW REHVXQN³ ZHLJKV´ LW DQGUHW XUQVLW W KHQ

7KH 6ZDVW LND LV DOVR W KH V\P ERO RI W KH IRXU ³ HOHP HQW V´  RI ILUH DLU ZDW HU DQG HDUW K  , I
ZHGUDZW KLVIRXUIROGV\P EROLVP LQW RW KHVZDVW LNDDQGDGGW KHIRXUFDUGLQDOVLJQVRIW KH
]RGLDF ZKLFK FRUUHVSRQG W R W KHVH HOHP HQW V LQ W KH VFLHQFH RI DVW URORJ\ QDP HO\ $ULHV
/LEUD &DQFHU DQG &DSULFRUQ DQG ZLW K W KDW  D W KLUG JURXS RI IRXU   VSLULW  OLIH VRXO DQG

   
6SLULW /LI H 6RXO %RG\

6SLULW %RG\ %RG\ 6SLULW

)LUH (DUW K (DUW K )LUH
$ULHV &DSULFRUQ &DSULFRUQ $ULHV
W XUQLQJ W R W KH OHIW W XUQLQJ W R W KH ULJKW
Q HJ DW LY H SRVLW LY H
/LIH 6RXO 6RXO /LIH
$LU :DW HU :DW HU $LU
/LEUD &DQFHU &DQFHU /LEUD

ERG\ DV FRUUHODW H W R W KH ILUVW  W ZR JURXSV RI IRXU  )LQDOO\ ZH DGG W KH FRUUHVSRQGLQJ
QXP EHU V
7KH  W KH JU RXS RI IRXU W KH OHDGHU VKLS EHORQJV W R W KH VSLU LW   W KH OLIH DV Z H KDYH
REVHUYHG RULJLQDW HV IURP  W KH W KUHH W KH URW DW LRQ ³ 'UHL´  XQG ³ 'UHKXQJ´  W KH  JLYHV
ELUW KW RW KHJURXSRIW ZRW KHGLVFRUGRIRXUH[LVW HQFHRIW KDW ZKLFKLVRIW KH(DUW KDQG
W KDW ZKLFKLVQRW RIW KH(DUW KRIVRXODQGERG\RIW KHVRXO ERG\W KHVRXO VHOIW KHVHOI
W KH HJR W KDW  LV GLYLGHG LQ W ZR  7KH ORZHVW  IRUP  KRZHYHU W KH P RVW  ZRUW KOHVV W KLQJ
W KDW  ZKLFK LV W UDQVLW RU\ SK\VLFDO W KH ERG\ YDQLVKHV DJDLQ LQ W KH 2QH W KDW  ZKLFK LV
'LYLQHDQGVSLULW XDODQGULJKW IXOO\LVKHUHRQW KHORZHVW OHY HORIW KHDUUD\RIQXP EHUV
W KHRQHZLW KZKLFKHYHU\W KLQJEHJLQVDQGHQGV


0RGHUQ*HUP DQ³ 9LHUXQJ´  V\VW HP RIIRXUDQGP RGHUQ*HUP DQ³ )KUXQJ´  OHDGHUVKLSDQG
³ )HXHUXQJ´  P RGHUQ*HUP DQIRUP DNLQJILUHRUDOVRILULQJ IURP DM RE 
 

, IZHDUUDQJHW KHVHW KUHHJURXSVRIIRXUDFFRUGLQJO\LQW RW KHHQHUJ\ILHOGVEHW ZHHQW KH

DUP V RI W KH ZLVH V\P ERO RI W KH VZDVW LND W KHQ ZH DUULYH DW  DQ LQVW UXFW LYH RYHUYLHZ

, QW KHQXP HULFDUUD\ZHKDYHW KHFRVP LFQXP EHUZLW KZKLFKREYLRXVO\DOOUHODW LRQV

LQW KHXQLYHUVHDUHH[SUHVVHG)RULQVW DQFHW KHGLDP HW HURIW KHRUELW RIW KH(DUW KLV
VRODUUDGLLW KHGLDP HW HURIW KHOXQDURUELW LVUDGLLRIW KH0RRQ$OVRLQGHW HUP LQLQJ
W KHHUDVRIW KH, QGLDQVZKLFKDUHFORVHUW RQDW XUDOUHODW LRQVW KDQDQ\RW KHUFDOFXODW LRQRI
W LP HW KHQXP EHUKDVW KHFKDUDFW HULVW LFW REHW KHEDVLVIRU DXQLILHGZKROH

 [  LV W KH QXP EHU RI W KH VHFRQGV RI W KH GD\ DQG RI W KH QLJKW   P DQ\ RW KHU
UHODW LRQVFDQVW LOOEHGHGXFW HGIURP W KLVQXP EHUEXW ZHZRQ¶W P HQW LRQW KRVHKHUH

%XW LIZHH[DP LQHW KHP XW XDOUHODW LRQVKLSVRIW KHVH³ HOHP HQW V´ RIW KHSHUIHFW KXP DQ
EHLQJRIZKLFKQRQHFDQEHP LVVLQJLIKHLQW HQGVW RUHP DLQ³ SHUIHFW ´EHFDXVHVSLULW OLIH
VRXO DQG ERG\ DUH D XQLW \  , I W KH VSLULW  JLYHV RXW  W KHQ ZH KDYH W R GHDO ZLW K D SHUVRQ
ZLW KRXW UHDVRQZLW KRXW P LQG+HP D\ODXJKZKHQDKXP DQEHLQJGURZQVLQIURQW RIKLV
H\HV DQG KH ZLOO QRW  NQRZ DQ\ DQVZHU ZKHQ DVNHG ZK\ KH ODXJKV LQ W KH IDFH RI VXFK
P LVIRUW XQHEHFDXVHKHLVZLW KRXW P LQGZLW KZHDNW KLQNLQJVW XSLGDQGIRROLVK

2QW KHRW KHUKDQGLQW KHJURXSRIIRXUOLIHFDQJLYHRXW EXW VSLULW VRXODQGERG\FDQVW LOO

UHP DLQDFW LYH6XFKDKXP DQEHLQJLVVHHP LQJO\GHDG, IEXULHGDOLYHKHKHDUVDQGVHHV
HYHU\W KLQJ EXW  FDQQRW  FRP P XQLFDW H EHFDXVH OLIH YDQLVKHG IURP  KLP  DQG W KH ³ 7KUHH´
W KHURW DW LRQ ³ 'UHL´ XQG³ 'UHKXQJ´ ZLW KLQKLP LVLQW HUUXSW HG

7KH W KLUG FDVH LV JLYHQ LI W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ KDV VSLULW  P LQG DQG ERG\ EXW  QR VRXO QR
IHHOLQJDQGQRVHQVDW LRQ6XFKDKXP DQEHLQJNQRZVQRIHDUQRJURVVRXW QRFRQVFLHQFH
DQGQRSLW \+HFDQSHUIRUP RQKLP VHOIDQGRW KHUVW KHP RVW FUXHOGHHGVZLW KRXW KDYLQJ
DQ\ SLW \ SDLQ RU VDGQHVV ZKLOH ³ LQW HOOLJHQFH´ ZKLFK P HDQV VSLULW  OLIH DQG ERG\ DUH
GHILQLW HO\W KHUH

7KH IRXUW K FDVH VFHQDULR ZH KDYH ZKHQ W KH KXP DQ EHLQJ ORVHV W KH ERG\  7KHQ KH LV
³ GHDG´ RQW KHSODQHRIW KH(DUW KEXW KHVW LOOKDVVSLULW OLIHDQGVRXOZKLFKQRZFRQQHFW
RW KHUZLVH DQG W UDQVIRUP  SDVV DZD\ DQG H[LVW  DFFRUGLQJ W R W KHLU  RZQ ODZV

:LW K RX W :LW K RX W :LW K RX W :LW K RX W

6SLULW /LI H 6RXO %RG\

/LI H 6RXO %RG\ 6SLULW

6RXO %RG\ 6SLULW /LI H
%RG\ 6SLULW /LI H 6RXO

&UD]\ 6HHP LQJO\ 6RXOOHVV 3K\ VLFDOO\

0HQW DOO\ , OO 'HDG 1R HP RWLRQV 'HDG
 

:HVHHW KDW W KHJURXSLQJRIIRXU ³ 9LHUXQJ´ RUOHDGHUVKLS ³ )KUXQJ´ KDVQRSHUP DQHQFH

RQ W KH SODQH RI W KH (DUW K  2YHU W KH W KUHH DQG W ZR LW  UHW XUQV EDFN W R W KH RQH RYHU
SK\VLFDOGHVW UXFW LRQW RXQLW \LQVSLULW 

7KH ROG W HDFKLQJ RI W KH NQRZOHGJH RI W KH VW DUV VHHV LQ W KH YDXOW  RI W KH KHDYHQ LQ W KH
FRVP RV D KXP DQ EHLQJ RI LP P HQVH GLP HQVLRQV  7KH KXP DQ EHLQJ RQ (DUW K KLP VHOI
KXP DQLW \ DV D ZKROH W KH (DUW K RQ ZKRP  KH OLYHV DUH DQ DW RP  RQ W KH LP P HQVH ERG\
IRU W KLV FRVP LF P DQ ZKRP  DVW URORJ\ FDOOV ³ *RG´

7KH KXP DQ ERG\ KDV DOO W KH FRUUHODW LRQV ZLW K W KH FRVP RV   OLNH  EUDQFKHV  SDLU RI
QHUYHV FRP H RXW  RI KLV EUDLQ  YHUW HEUDV RI W KH QHFN SOXV  YHUW HEUDV RI W KH ORLQV
W RJHW KHUZLW KW KHYHUW HEUDVRIW KHFKHVW DUHYHUW HEUDVKDUP RQLRXVW RQHVW KH
YRLFH GHYHORSV

7KHVLJQRIW KH7\U FLUFOH ]RGLDF DQGW KHLUFRUUHODW LRQVLQW KHKXP DQERG\

 

:H VKRXOG VHH KHUH D FRUUHODW LRQ RI W KH KXP DQ ERG\ ZLW K W KH ³ KRXVHV´  RI W KH ]RGLDF
DQGLW VVLJQV7KHKXP DQVKDSHLVDQH[DFW P LUURULP DJHRIW KH]RGLDFIURP KHDG
W KH$ULHVW RW KHIHHW LQW KH3LVFHV

 +RXVH $ULHV +HDG  +RXVH /LEUD /RLQV

 +RXVH 7DXUXV 1HFN  +RXVH 6FRUSLR *HQLW DOV
 +RXVH *HP LQL $UP V  +RXVH 6DJLW W DULXV 7KLJKV
 +RXVH   &DQFHU  /XQJV  +RXVH   &DSULFRUQ  .QHHV
 +RXVH   /HR  &KHVW  +RXVH $TXDULXV &DOIV
 +RXVH 9LUJR (QW UDLOV  +RXVH   3LVFHV  )HHW

7KHVH DUH QR FKLOGLVK FRP SDULVRQV EXW  OLYLQJ DQG HIIHFW LYH FRU UHODW LRQV W KDW  EHFRP H
IDFW VRIGDLO\H[SHULHQFHIRUW KHDVW URORJLFDOO\W UDLQHGREVHUYHU

, QW ZHOYHIDFHW VW KHFU\VW DOFDOOHG³ KXP DQ´ LVVKLQLQJ, QW ZHOYHP LUURUVW KHKXP DQEHLQJ
FDQVHHKLP VHOILQW KHKHDYHQO\ILUHRIW ZHOYHUD\V

7KH $GDP  .DGP RQ  7KH &RVP LF +XP DQ

:LW K W KH KHDG $ULHV  EHJLQV W KH FRXUVH RI W KH 6XQ ZLW K W KH IHHW  LW  FORVHV  7KH $GDP
.DGP RQ KXP DQ RI W KH ZRUOGV DQG W KH KXP DQ HP EU\R DUH HTXLYDOHQW  W KH VDP H W KLQJ
LH P DFURFRVP  DQG P LFURFRVP   6P DOO ZRUOG DQG ELJ ZRUOG DUH EXW  GLIIHUHQW  IRUP V RI
 

7KH KXP DQ HP EU\R LQ W KH ]RGLDF

DSSHDUDQFHRIDXQLW \RID%HLQJ 2QHRIDZKROH DVDERYHVREHORZ   )URP &KULVW 

W KHVRQRIW KHKHDYHQW KHUHIRUHLVVDLG³ W KDW KHGLVW ULEXW HVKLVOLP EVDP RQJW KHSHRSOHV
RI W KH (DUW K´ Z KLFK P HDQV RI W KH ]RGLDF Z KLFK UHSUHVHQW V W KH W ZHOYH W ULEHV RI ³ -XGD´
³ *XGDV´ W KH ³ -HZV´ ZKLFK P HDQV RI W KH ³ *RRG 2QHV´ RI W KH *RW KV W KH  W \SHV
ZKLFKDUH8U LP DJHVRIW KH*RW KLFZKLFKP HDQVGLYLQHDUW RIEUHHGLQJKXP DQV7KHVH
W \ SHV IROORZ  HDFK RW KHU  FKDQJLQJ IU RP  P DOH W R IHP DOH DQG IXU W KHU P RU H W KH\  DU H
VXEGLYLGHGLQW KUHHSDUW VLQW KHIRXUFRVP LF³ HOHP HQW V´W KHIRUP VRIHQHUJ\DV³ ILHU\´
³ DLU\´ ³ ZDW HU\´ DQG ³ HDUW KHQ´  FKDUDFW HUV

)LUH $LU :DW HU (DUW K

/LJKW *DV /LTXLG 6ROLG

7KH FRVP RV W KH ZKROH ZRUOG W KH $OO ZRUOG LV QRW  D P DW HULDO DQG LQRUJDQLF VW UXFW XUH
EXW  DQ RUJDQ D W RRO RI *RG RUJDQLF LQ *HUP DQ P HDQV ³ 8U JDQJ´  8U ZDON   (YHQ LI D
ZRUG LV ³ *UHHN´ LW  VW LOO QHHGV W R EH UHGXFHG W R LW V $U\DQ URRW  DQG W KHQ LQ *HUP DQ   LW
VLP SO\ LV  8U *DQJ DQG W KH ³ IRUHLJQ ZRUG´  FRXOG JHW  D *HUP DQ W U DQVODW LRQ W KDW  FDQ EH
FRP P RQO\  XQGHU VW RRG

*HRUJ /RP HU VD\V W KDW  ³ LQ W KH P RYLQJ HQHUJ\ V\VW HP  RI W KH KHDYHQV HYHU\ KXP DQ
EHLQJ LV D VSHFLDO W KRXJKW  RI *RG W KDW  KDV EHHQ FRQGHQVHG LQ VSDFH DQG W LP H´   7KH
V\P ERO RI W KH FUXFLILHG RQH JRHV EDFN W R W KLV GHHS DQG P \VW HULRXV URRW   LW  KDV W R EH
XQGHUVW RRG FRUUHFW O\ KRZHYHU  , W  LV QRW  D 'LYLQH KXP DQ EHLQJ W KDW  GLHG IRU KXP DQLW \
 \HDUV DJR  7KHVH DUH FKLOGLVK P LVXQGHUVW DQGLQJV RI LJQRUDQW  HUDV  %XW  LQ HYHU\

 2PLWWHG

 2PLWWHG
 

EHLQJW KDW DSSHDUHGLQHYHU\KXP DQEHLQJW KHHW HUQDO*RGGLHVRQW KHFURVVDQGKDVW R

VHOI UHGHHP E\³ UHFRJQL]LQJ´ KLP VHOI

7KUHHIROGLVW KHFRVP LFFURVVRQZKLFKHDFKRQHRIXVLVKDQJLQJDQGVXIIHULQJ  DQGLW

LV DOZD\V IRXU VLJQV RI W KH ]RGLDF W KDW  FRP H W RJHW KHU W R IRUP  D FURVV D ILHU\ DLU\
ZDW HU\DQGHDUW KHQVLJQ

³ )RXU HOHP HQW V M RLQHG FORVHO\

IRUP OLIHDQGEXLOGW KHZRUOG´

7KUHHW LP HVW KHFRVP LFZLOOW UDFHVW KHFURVVRYHUHYHU\W KLQJZ KLFKLW ZDQW VW RFDOOLQW R
OLIH%DVLFDOO\W KLVLVDVW UDQJHIDFW W KHH[W HUQDOV\P ERORIZKLFKFDP HDVW KHJHVW XUHRI
P DNLQJW KHFURVVIURP $U\DQSUHKLVW RU\DQGZKLFKLVP LUURUHGLQ&DW KROLF0H[LFDQDQG
7LEHW DQ FXVW RP V DV P DNLQJ D FURVV

, QW KHP DM HVW LFW HDP RIIRXURIW KHVHEDVLFHQHUJLHVW KHIRXU³ KRUVHVRIW KH6XQ´ RIW KH
$XURUD ZH VHH DJDLQ W KH QXP EHU IRXU DV D VHUYLQJ QXP EHU  %HFDXVH RQO\ ZKHQ SXW
W RJHW KHU W KUHH W LP HV LW  EHFRP HV W KH FLUFOH RI W ZHOYH

7KH W KUHH OLQHV ZKLFK FRP H W RJHW KHU LQ D FHQW HU SRLQW  ZKHQ LQW HUVHFW LQJ ZH VHH DJDLQ
W KH QXP EHU IRXU DV D VHUYLQJ QXP EHU  %HFDXVH RQO\ ZKHQ SXW  W RJHW KHU W KUHH W LP HV LW
EHFRP HV W KH FLUFOH RI W ZHOYH

7KHW KUHHOLQHVZKLFKFRP HW RJHW KHULQDFHQW HUSRLQW ZKHQLQW HUVHFW LQJW KHW KUHHW HDP V
RIIRXUW KHUHIRUHFDQEHQDP HGDVEHLQJW KHFRVP LFW ULSRGZKLFKLVW KHEDVLVRQZKLFK
W KH P DM HVW LF URW DW LRQ RI W KH ]RGLDF KDSSHQV  %XW  W KLV W ULSRG W RR LV D V\P ERO RI W KH
KHDYHQO\7ULQLW \DIDFW ZKLFKFDQW HOOXVDORW 


  2PLWWHG