Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 16

Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Applied Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/apenergy

Mechanical compressor-driven thermochemical storage for cooling T


applications in tropical insular regions. Concept and efficiency analysis

Franco Ferruccia, , Driss Stitoub, Pascal Ortegaa, Franck Lucasa
a
GEPASUD Laboratory, University of French Polynesia, BP 6570, 98702 Tahiti, French Polynesia
b
CNRS-PROMES Laboratory, Tecnosud, Rambla de la thermodynamique, 66100 Perpignan, France

H I GH L IG H T S

• Combination of a thermochemical reactor and a mechanical vapor compression unit.


• The system can provide cooling and energy storage in the context of smart microgrids.
• Thermochemical method presents no self-discharge and long charge/discharge life cycle.
• The compressor aids the desorption and compensates for a low heat source temperature.
• With a waste heat source it attains a cooling capacity of 4 kWh /day/m of PV panel.
cold
2

A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T

Keywords: The energy situation in tropical insular regions, as is found in French Polynesia, presents a number of challenges,
Solar cooling including heavy dependence on imported fuel, high transport costs from the mainland and weak electricity grids.
Solid/gas sorption By contrast, these regions possess a variety of renewable energy resources, which are favorable for the ex-
Thermochemical ploitation of smart micro grids and energy storage technologies. With regards to electrical energy demand, the
Chemical adsorption
high temperatures commonly seen in these regions throughout the entire year implies that a large proportion of
Tropical and insular regions
electricity consumption (∼40%) is used for space cooling, even during evening hours. Framed within this
Microgrid
context, this paper presents an air conditioning system driven by photovoltaic electricity that combines a me-
chanical vapor refrigeration system and a thermochemical storage unit. Thermochemical processes enable the
storage of energy in the form of chemical potential with virtually no losses, which can be used to produce cold
during the evening hours without running a compressor. These processes are implemented using thermo-
chemical reactors, in which a reversible chemical reaction between a solid compound and a gas takes place. The
solid/gas pair used in this study is barium chloride salt (BaCl2) reacting with ammonia (NH3), which is also the
coolant fluid in the refrigeration circuit.
In the proposed system, the photovoltaic-driven electric compressor is used during the day either to run the
refrigeration circuit when a cooling demand occurs or to decompose the ammonia-charged salt and to remove
the gas from the thermochemical reactor when there is no cooling requirement. During the evening, when there
is no electricity from solar sources, the system changes its configuration and the reactor reabsorbs the ammonia
gas from the evaporator to produce cold. The efficiency of this hybrid system is evaluated in this work and
compared with alternative processes which utilize either electrochemical (lead-acid, lithium-ion batteries) or
thermal storage (ice, chilled water) for cold production.

1. Introduction electricity grids, which make them prone to frequency and voltage
perturbation [1]. These regions typically exhibit climate patterns of
The energy situation in tropical insular regions is complex and year-round high temperatures and humidity. Additional challenges in
presents both challenges and opportunities. In such environments, there certain tropical insular regions include geographic remoteness, high
is a strong dependence on foreign energy, mainly fossil fuels. transport costs from the mainland, low population density and the fact
Furthermore, these regions often present weak or poorly interconnected that large-scale energy projects are not typically considered viable.


Corresponding author.
E-mail address: franco.ferrucci@doctorant.upf.pf (F. Ferrucci).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2018.03.049
Received 31 December 2017; Received in revised form 7 March 2018; Accepted 18 March 2018
Available online 24 March 2018
0306-2619/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

Nomenclature Greek letters

PV photovoltaic Δ difference
S/G solid/gas υ stoichiometric coefficient
TR thermochemical reactor η efficiency
MVC mechanical vapor compression τ mixture mass ratio
COP coefficient of performance ρ effective density
DOD depth of discharge θ Carnot coefficient
CFCs chlorofluorocarbons
HCFCs hydrofluorocarbons Subscripts
HP high pressure
LP low pressure 0 reference
BaCl2 barium chloride salt 1 operating point 1
ENG expanded natural graphite 2–3 operating mode 2 combined with mode 3
T temperature amb ambient
P pressure cold cold (heat source)
Ex exergy cond condenser
Q heat (J) comp composite
I solar irradiation (kWh/m2/day) des desorption
W compressor work (J) disch discharge
M molar mass (kg/mol) eq equilibrium
N number of moles evap evaporator
n number of moles per m3 ex exergy
Vswept compressor’s swept volume rate (m3/h) g gas (superheated)
X reaction global advancement (0…1) gas gas
qV,cold cooling capacity per volume of storage (Whcold/L) init initial
qS,cold cooling capacity per surface of solar collector (Whcold/m2/ is isentropic
day) liq-vap liquid-vapor
S0 anhydrous salt max maximum
S1 ammonia-charged salt r reactor
Pref reference pressure, 1 Pa ref reference
R universal gas constant, 8.3144 J/K/mol room room (heat source)
ΔHV0 NH3, standard enthalpy of vaporization, 23,366 J/mol s source (during desorption)
ΔSV0 NH3, standard entropy of vaporization, 193.3 J/K/mol sat saturated
ΔHR0 BaCl2–NH3, standard enthalpy of transformation, synt synthesis
38,250 J/mol vol volumetric
ΔSR0 BaCl2–NH3, standard entropy of transformation, 232.38 J/
K/mol Superscripts
cp0 heat capacity of the anhydrous salt, 75.1 J/K/mol
cp1 heat capacity of the ammonia-charged salt, 390 J/K/mol 0 standard (25 °C, 1 atm)
is isentropic

French Polynesia, the region of relevance to this work, is faced with just energy in French Polynesia an interesting proposition. This is especially
such challenges. the case for photovoltaic technology due to its maturity, declining costs
French Polynesia is comprised of more than one hundred islands and adaptability for use in both large and small-scale energy projects.
and atolls that are distributed in a region approximately the size of Notwithstanding the foregoing, electricity produced by solar energy
Western Europe [2]. Nearly half of these islands are uninhabited and presents some difficulties. For instance, due to its stochastic nature,
many others have a very low population (see Table 6 in Appendix A). solar energy is non-dispatchable–that is, its production cannot be
The ratio between primary energy imports and total energy consump- regulated in order to meet electricity needs. Moreover, photovoltaic
tion in French Polynesia is above 85% [3], which puts the region in a technology, the most commonly employed electricity production
vulnerable position due to the unpredictability of oil prices. What is method using solar energy, does not possess an inherent energy reserve
more, the price of electricity for a small household (3000 kWh/year) is (normally called inertia or spinning reserve), meaning that sudden var-
about 0.30 USD/kWh [4], between two and three times the price found iations of solar irradiation are not attenuated at the output and strongly
in North America [5] and Europe [6]. A study conducted in 2011 on the perturb the electricity grid. These characteristics make the supply of
use and trends of electro-domestic equipment, including air condi- electricity using solar energy challenging, especially where the pro-
tioners, in Tahiti and Moorea, French Polynesia’s most populated is- portion of its use over total electricity production is high [1]. To
lands, showed that there was a steady rise in energy usage in the home, overcome these difficulties, the combination of smart electricity grids
notably of air conditioning units, representing 36% of usage [7]. with energy storage systems has proven to be an effective solution [8].
On the positive side, French Polynesia is rich in renewable re- The term smart grid refers to an electricity network that performs
sources, particularly solar energy. For instance, the average global solar intelligent management of resources, including production and storage,
horizontal irradiation (a key parameter that assesses solar energy po- in order to deliver a reliable and sustainable electricity supply.
tential) for fifteen of the most inhabited islands of French Polynesia and Currently, there is a great deal of research in the field of control and
accounting for 94% of its total population (see Table 6 in Appendix A), optimization strategies applied to smart grids. For instance, Iqbal et al.
is 5.8 kWh/m2/day. Such a high value makes the exploitation of solar [9] present a comprehensive review of publications concerning

241
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

optimization algorithms and tools used in the context of renewable This paper is organized as follows: Section 2 introduces the principle
energy sources. Kyriakarakos et al. [10] propose an intelligent man- of the solid/gas thermochemical sorption process. Section 3 presents
agement algorithm with prediction capabilities applied to autonomous the system architecture that combines a thermochemical reactor with a
micro grids with multiple energy generating sources. In another review, conventional mechanical vapor compression cooling system. The sec-
Guerrero et al. [11,12] present advanced control techniques used in tion also explains the various operating modes. Section 4 outlines the
order to optimize the management of micro grids. system’s operating conditions and admissible range of operation. Sec-
Smart grids don’t necessarily have a size restriction, which makes tion 5 assesses the system performance by analyzing relevant efficiency
their application potentially widespread: from a grid in a small village indicators. Section 6 discusses the results. Section 7 provides detail
of a few kW (also called smart micro grid) to an electricity network that regarding a conceptualized prototype which is planned to soon be
manages hundreds of MW. For instance, Salas et al. [13] present a re- under development. Finally, Section 8 presents the conclusions of the
view of smart hybrid systems combining diesel generators, photovoltaic article.
panels and batteries for application in remote villages and isolated is- This work elaborates upon the paper presented at ICAE2017, Aug
lands. They also describe several examples of such existing systems. On 21–24, Cardiff, UK by (a) further developing the equations related to
a larger scale, Colak et al. [14] discuss the status of existing smart grid the operating conditions of the proposed system, (b) performing a
projects across Europe while Hatziargyriou et al. [15] present examples parametric analysis in order to ascertain the system’s admissible oper-
of research and development smart grid projects around the world. ating range, (c) conducting a study of the compressor’s operating point,
Energy storage systems are key assets in smart electricity grids that (d) expanding upon the system’s performance by adding an exergy
use stochastic renewable energy sources. They have two fundamental analysis and (e) providing detail regarding the prototype under devel-
roles: (a) ensuring power quality by providing voltage and frequency opment.
stabilization and (b) equalizing the overall daily electricity production
with consumption- for instance, by returning the surplus electricity 2. Principle of solid–gas thermochemical sorption process
produced during the day to the grid at night. The most common energy
storage systems fall into one of the following categories: electro- The principle of solid/gas (S/G) thermochemical sorption processes
chemical (e.g. lead-acid, lithium-ion batteries), electrical (e.g. super- is based on the thermal effect of a reversible reaction between a solid
capacitors, superconducting magnetics), chemical (e.g. fuel cells, elec- (S) and a reactive gas (G). The reaction follows the general equation:
trolyzers), mechanical (e.g. pumped hydro, compressed air, flywheels) Synthesis(cold production)
and thermal (e.g. sensible, latent or sorption heat). Palizban [16] and {S0} + υ ·G ⇄ {S1} + υ ·ΔHr
desorption(energy storage) (1)
Luo [17] review many of the energy storage systems found in modern
electricity grids and give a comprehensive list of the services that they where S1 is salt rich in gas, S0 is salt poor in gas, υ is the stoichiometric
provide. coefficient and ΔHr is the enthalpy of the reaction per mole of gas [18].
Within the category of thermal storage systems resides what is re- The strong chemical bonding involved in these reactions translates into
ferred to as thermochemical sorption, a phenomenon that allows for the high values of ΔHr. The solid/gas reaction from (1) can be coupled with
storage of energy in the form of chemical potential which can later be a liquid/gas phase change process of the same working gas in order to
utilized to produce a cooling effect. A sorption process exploits the implement a cold production machine:
physical or chemical bonds between a sorbent material (liquid or solid) evaporation
that has the ability to absorb an active gas in order to produce a thermal G (liq. ) + ΔHliq − vap ⇄ G (gas)
condensation (2)
or cooling effect. When the sorbent is liquid, the process is referred to as
liquid/gas absorption. When solid, the process is called physical or where ΔHliq-vap corresponds to the enthalpy of vaporization.
chemical solid/gas adsorption–this latter is also known as thermo- A cold production process that is based on thermochemical reac-
chemical sorption [18]. Compared with sensible and latent heat sto- tions needs three components for its most basic implementation: a re-
rage, an advantage of thermochemical sorption is that it has virtually actor that contains the salt, a two-phase heat exchanger in which eva-
no energy losses. Moreover, compared with electrochemical storage poration or condensation of the reactive fluid occurs and a reservoir to
technologies, thermochemical sorption has a longer charge/discharge contain the condensed fluid. The process has two distinct phases: energy
life cycle. Sorption technology has found its footing in solar cooling storage and cold production, which are related to the direction of the
applications, where it is mainly utilized in conjunction with solar processes in (1) and (2).
thermal collectors. Kim [19] and Ferreira [20] present comprehensive From right to left, the reaction (1) is called desorption. In this phase,
reviews of such systems. thermal energy is transformed into chemical potential for a deferred
Given the importance of energy storage in modern electricity grids cold production. The solid S1, charged with gas, absorbs an amount of
in tropical insular regions like French Polynesia, where a significant heat (i.e. endothermic process), releases the gas and transforms into S0.
proportion of energy is used for space cooling, the present work pro- The gas flows out of the reactor to the heat exchanger, where it con-
poses and analyzes a system that integrates an energy storage method densates and continues to the reservoir, where it is stored in liquid
based on a thermochemical sorption process that is coupled with a con- form. This phase corresponds to the right-to-left process in (2).
ventional mechanical vapor compression cooling machine powered by From left to right, the reaction (1) is called synthesis and it is when
photovoltaic electricity. The combination of these elements presents an cold is produced. The solid S0 absorbs and reacts in an exothermic
innovative solution that offers energy storage capabilities for cooling manner with the gas coming from the heat exchanger, which acts as an
applications. Additionally, whereas existing systems using sorption evaporator, forming the salt S1 and releasing the heat of reaction to the
technology for cooling applications require the use of heating sources environment. This phase corresponds to the left-to-right process in (2).
with temperatures higher than 55 °C, such as the thermochemical The S/G pair used in this study is barium chloride salt, BaCl2, which
cooling systems experimented by Stitou [18] and Wang [21], the pro- reacts with eight moles of ammonia (NH3) to form BaCl2·8NH3. This salt
posed system can operate with much lower heating source tempera- has been successfully used for solar ice-making and solar air con-
ture–as low as 35 °C. This allows for the revalorization of a wider range ditioning processes using simple flat plate solar collectors [18]. This S/
of low-grade heat sources that are currently not exploited due to their G pair is suitable for such an application as it can operate (i.e. react)
low exergy value. The compressor–driven method for energy storage with relatively low temperatures and moderate pressure. The use of
and deferred cooling has not yet been explored in literature and re- ammonia has the advantage that it is readily available, inexpensive, not
presents an innovative concept, which is described and developed in a contributor to ozone depletion, greenhouse effect or global warming
this work. and is biodegradable [22]. However, its toxicity requires taking unique

242
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

safety measures. Since ammonia reacts with copper in the presence of which also corresponds to the reactive gas of the TR.
common contaminants such as air and water, ammonia systems are Both the PV installation and the grid are used to meet electricity
constructed using aluminum, carbon-steel and stainless-steel compo- requirements of the building and, in particular, to power the com-
nents [23]. pressor of the MVC cycle for cold production. In addition, each time
The two processes, i.e. the chemical reaction (1) and the phase- that there is a surplus of energy from the PV panels and no cooling
change (2), are mono-variant and their thermodynamic equilibrium needs, the system switches its configuration mode and the extra power
conditions follow the Clausius–Clapeyron relation. The equilibrium is used to run the compressor in order to drive the desorption of the TR,
conditions for the two processes are determined by only one variable, thus storing electricity in the form of chemical potential energy. The
either pressure or temperature: stored energy is later used to produce a cooling effect for the building,
without the need for the compressor.
ΔHi0 ΔSi0
ln ( )=−
Pi,eq
Pref R·Ti,eq
+ R
, The system has three operating modes: (a) Mode 1, conventional
MVC cycle, (b) Mode 2, storage phase (desorption) and (c) Mode 3,
r :reaction
with i = ⎧ discharge phase (synthesis).
⎩ liq-vap : liquid−vapor
⎨ (3) Fig. 3 depicts the three operating modes and includes a schema of
each system configuration with the flow of NH3 through the circuit
where Peq and Teq correspond to the equilibrium pressure and tem-
(inactive elements are greyed out), and its corresponding Clausiu-
perature of each process, ΔH0 and ΔS0 are the standard enthalpies and
s–Clapeyron and P–h charts. The Clausius–Clapeyron diagram shows
entropies of the two processes and Pref is a reference pressure [18]. The
the mono–variant equilibriums of the liquid/gas phase–change of NH3
nomenclature section provides the numerical values of all the men-
and the solid/gas reaction occurring in the TR. The P–h chart gives a
tioned parameters. Fig. 1 depicts the Clausius–Clapeyron diagram of the
graphical representation of the path of the refrigerant and allows for
processes, which is a graphical representation of (3).
direct measurement of the evaporator’s cold production and com-
pressor-consumed work. Table 1 gives a description of the operating
2.1. Reaction global advancement X
points indicated on the Clausius–Clapeyron and P-h charts for mode 2
(desorption) and mode 3 (synthesis).
At any given moment of time and in any reaction phase (i.e.
The paragraphs below further describe the three operating modes.
synthesis, desorption or no reaction), there will be elements of both
Mode 1: Conventional MVC cycle
sides of (1) in the reactor- that is, salt rich in reacting gas S1 as well as
This operating mode is shown in Fig. 3(a), in which a cooling de-
anhydrous salt S0. The reaction global advancement X expresses the
mand is occurring. The reactor is isolated from the rest of the circuit
fraction of S1 with respect to the total quantity of salt:
(the reactor's valve is closed) and the system behaves as a conventional
NS1 NS1 MVC refrigeration circuit with the following elements in closed-loop:
X= =
NS NS1 + NS0 (4) evaporator–compressor–condenser–reservoir–throttling valve or capil-
lary tube. The electrical energy necessary to run the compressor and
In (4), NS1 and NS0 represent the number of moles of the rich and produce the cooling effect comes either from the solar panels and/or
anhydrous salt, respectively, while NS is the total number of moles of from the electric grid. The isolated reactor is at ambient temperature
salt contained in the reactor. The reaction global advancement goes and its pressure is fixed by the S/G equilibrium condition (see Fig. 1).
from X ≈ 0 to X ≈ 1 during synthesis and from X ≈ 1 to X ≈ 0 during Mode 2: Energy storage (desorption)
desorption. Note that, unlike physical adsorption, the reaction equili- In this mode, shown in Fig. 3(b), it is assumed that there is no
brium condition does not depend on X for chemical adsorption pro- cooling demand and there is a surplus of energy from the PV installa-
cesses (i.e. the variable X does not appear in (3)). tion. This extra energy is therefore used to power the compressor and
desorb the TR. The evaporator is disconnected from the circuit and the
3. System overview remaining elements are connected in the following order: re-
actor–compressor–condenser–reservoir. The compressor pumps the gas
The architecture of the proposed hybrid system, shown in Fig. 2, out of the TR, decomposing the ammonia–charged salt, thus storing
comprises the elements of a typical mechanical vapor compression re- chemical potential energy for later use. The heat of desorption is pro-
frigeration cycle (MVC) (i.e. evaporator, compressor, condenser, re- vided either by the environment at ambient temperature or by a low-
servoir and throttling valve), a grid-connected photovoltaic (PV) in- grade waste heat source, resulting in reduced power consumption by
stallation (i.e. solar panels and inverter) and a thermochemical reactor the compressor.
(TR) for energy storage. The MVC cycle uses ammonia as refrigerant, Fig. 3(b) shows two distinct cases- one in which the heat source is

id is
liqu es ium
led nth ibr
coo Sy uil
Sub rium eq
quil
ib
S/G ion
e rpt
G/L gas so
ted De
erhea
Sup

(a) (b)
Fig. 1. Clausius–Clapeyron diagram of the BaCl2–NH3 thermochemical sorption process (dashed) and the NH3 phase-change process (solid); (a) pressure and temperature in linear scale;
(b) pressure in log scale and abscissa linear in −1/T (-K−1) (a second x axis shows the corresponding values in °C).

243
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

INVERTER

CONDENSER SOLAR
PANELS
HEAT
RELEASED
TO THE CONTROLLER
AMBIENT
COMPRESSOR
MICRO
GRID
TO SUPPLY
ELECTRICITY
REFRIGERANT REQUIREMENTS

HEAT
RESERVOIR EXTRACTED
FROM THE
BUILDING
HEAT EXCHANGED WITH
THE AMBIENT OR WITH A EVAPORATOR
LOW-GRADE HEAT SOURCE

THERMO-CHEMICAL
REACTOR

Fig. 2. System architecture combining a thermochemical storage unit (thermochemical reactor) and a typical mechanical vapor compression refrigeration cycle powered by photovoltaic
electricity.

the external environment (solid curve) and another with a heat source environment at ambient temperature. As will be shown later in this
of 50 °C (dashed curve). The two cases consider a 10 K temperature Section, in this scenario the compressor work per mole of gas is max-
difference between the reactor and the heat source. imal. In the second scenario, Fig. 4(b), the heat of desorption is pro-
The system can alternate between mode 1 and mode 2 until the re- vided at a temperature higher than ambient temperature T0, which
actor is completely discharged of gas (i.e. the reaction global ad- reduces the compressor work with respect to the previous scenario.
vancement X ≈ 0). At that point, the maximum amount of energy has Finally, in Fig. 4(c), the heat source temperature has risen sufficiently
been stored. so that desorption is produced with no mechanical work required. This
Mode 3: Cold production by using stored energy (synthesis) situation occurs when the desorption temperature is such that the
In this operating mode, Fig. 3(c), the potential energy stored in the thermochemical reactor pressure is equal to that of the condenser.
reactor is expended to produce cold. This process does not require the Fig. 5 shows the Clausius–Clapeyron diagram of the system during
electric compressor and by consequence is well suited for cold pro- the synthesis phase, where the reactor is at temperature Tsynt, pressure
duction during the evening hours, when there is no solar energy Psynt and exchanges heat with the environment that is at ambient
available but ambient temperature is still high. The compressor and temperature T0. The difference between these two temperatures is
condenser are disconnected from the circuit and the remaining ele- ΔTsynt. The evaporator is at temperature Tevap and pressure Pevap, coin-
ments are arranged in the following order: reservoir–evapor- ciding with the TR pressure Psynt, and exchanges heat with a cold source
ator–reactor. The liquid ammonia flows from the reservoir to the eva- that is at temperature Tcold, with a temperature difference ΔTevap. This
porator, where it evaporates –producing a cooling effect– and continues cold source corresponds, for example, with the temperature of the room
to the TR, where the synthesis reaction occurs. Given that synthesis is to be cooled.
an exothermic process, the reactor rejects heat to the external en- Next, the formulas associated with the operating modes of the
vironment, which acts as a heat sink. This operating mode can continue system will be described.
until the TR is completely charged with gas (i.e. the reaction global Desorption process (mode 2):
advancement is close to 1). The reactor and condenser temperatures and pressures are:
The system is managed by a smart controller that decides which
Tdes = Ts−ΔTdes (5)
operating mode to activate based on criteria such as user input (e.g.
room temperature setting), energy produced by the photovoltaic pa- Pdes = Pr ,eq (Tdes ) (6)
nels, electricity consumed by the building and energy stored in the
thermochemical reactor. Tcond = T0 + ΔTcond (7)

Pcond = Pliq − vap,eq (Tcond ) (8)


4. Operating conditions
Eq. (6) and (8) correspond to the S/G and L/G Clausius–Clapeyron re-
This section describes the equations corresponding to the desorption lation, respectively, shown in (3).
(storage) and synthesis (cold production) processes, which will be later The compressor intake and discharge pressures coincide, respec-
applied to a performance analysis of the system. Prior to introducing tively, with the reactor and condenser pressures. The specific enthalpy
the equations, it is necessary to first outline Figs. 4 and 5. and entropy of the gas at the suction and discharge lines are given by:
Fig. 4 shows the Clausius–Clapeyron diagram of the system during
hsuct = h gas (Tdes,Pdes ) (9)
desorption phase, in three distinct scenarios. In each case, the TR is at
temperature Tdes, pressure Pdes and exchanges heat with a source that
ssuct = sgas (Tdes,Pdes ) (10)
has a temperature of Ts. The difference between these two temperatures
is ΔTdes. The condenser is at temperature Tcond, pressure Pcond and ex- is
hdisch = hgas (ssuct ,Pcond ) (11)
changes heat with the environment that is at a temperature of T0, with a
temperature difference of ΔTcond. The value of hisdisch
refers to the isentropic specific gas enthalpy at the
In the first scenario, Fig. 4(a), the heat source for desorption is the discharge line, which, together with the compressor isentropic

244
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

Fig. 3. Operating modes of the hybrid system; (a) conventional MVC cycle; (b) storage phase; (c) discharge phase and cold production. The figure shows the system configuration for each
mode together with the Clausius–Clapeyron and P–h charts.

Table 1
Description of the operating points indicated on the Clausius–Clapeyron and P–h charts for mode 2 (desorption) and mode 3 (synthesis), corresponding to Fig. 3b and Fig. 3c.

Mode 1: compressor–driven desorption process Mode 2: synthesis process and cold production
➀ → ➁ → ➂ → ➃ (Fig. 3b) ➄ → ➅ → ➆ → ⑧ (Fig. 3c)

Point Description Point Description

➀ Reactor operating point during gas desorption. ➄ Reservoir; fluid in saturated liquid state.
➁ Compressor’s discharge line. ➅ Liquid-vapor mixture after an isenthalpic throttling in the evaporator.
➂ Condenser; vapor fully condensed. ➆ Evaporator. Fluid fully evaporated.
➃ Liquid reservoir; subcooled liquid is stored at ambient temperature. ⑧ Reactor operating point during synthesis process.
➀→➁ Mechanical compression process. Gas is pumped from the reactor to the ➄→➅ Isenthalpic throttling in the evaporator.
condenser. The enthalpy difference between the two points is equal to the ➅→➆ Constant-pressure evaporation process. Heat is absorbed from the room
compression mechanical work per mole of gas. An isentropic efficiency is taken enabling the cold production. The enthalpy difference between the two points
into account. is equal to the evaporator cooling effect per mole of fluid.
➁→➂ Constant pressure condensation process. Heat of condensation is released to
the environment.
➂→➃ Sub-cooling process. The fluid is in the reservoir and heat is released until it ➆→⑧ Constant-pressure superheating of the fluid which is heated and absorbed by
reaches ambient temperature. the reactor in synthesis phase.

245
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

Compressor‐driven reactor desorption (storage phase) – Clausius–Clapeyron chart


gas
Qcond Qcond Qcond Qdes
Pcond Tcond Pcond Tcond Pcond Tcond
=Pdes W=0 Tdes
W=Wmax 0<W<Wmax
gas gas
Qdes
Pdes Tdes

Qdes
Ts,max
Pdes Tdes

T0 = T s T0 Ts T0 Ts
Heat of desorption provided at Heat of desorption provided at a Purely thermal desorption
ambient temperature temp. higher than ambient temp. (no compressor work)

(a ) (b) (c)
Fig. 4. Clausius–Clapeyron diagram of the system during desorption phase (i.e. mode 2) for three different cases (a) Qdes provided at ambient temperature T0, (b) Qdes provided at Ts > T0,
(c) purely thermal desorption process (no compressor work).

Reactor synthesis (cold production) necessary energy (sensible heat) to bring the initial fractions of salt S0
Clausius–Clapeyron chart and S1 (given by the initial reaction global advancement Xdes,init) from
their initial state at ambient temperature T0 to desorption temperature
Tdes.
Now that the equations corresponding to the desorption phase have
been introduced, it is possible to clarify why the compressor work is
maximal when the TR is desorbed at ambient temperature, as shown in
Fig. 4(a), and why it diminishes with the increase of the TR heat source
temperature, as in Fig. 4(b), until becoming zero, as seen in Fig. 4(c).
Qevap gas Qsynt
One way to explain this phenomenon is with the help of a pressure-
Pevap
=Psynt Tsynt enthalpy (P-h) chart corresponding to the processes of Fig. 4. Although
Tevap such a chart is not available in Fig. 4, there is one shown in Fig. 3(b),
which refers to the same desorption process. In the P-h chart of
Fig. 3(b), paths 1 → 2 and 1′→2′ each describes compression processes
(explained in Table 1). Fig. 3(b) shows that the enthalpy difference
between the compressor discharge and suction lines (hisdisch − hsuct) in-
Tcold T0 creases (abscissa of P-h chart in Fig. 3b), when the pressure difference
augments (ordinate of P-h chart in Fig. 3b). Additionally, since (12)
Fig. 5. Clausius–Clapeyron diagram of the system during synthesis phase (i.e. mode 3). states that this enthalpy difference is proportional to the compressor
work, it can be seen that, the greater the pressure difference, the greater
efficiency ηis, serves to compute the compressor specific irreversible the compression work. At the limit, when the desorption temperature is
work: sufficiently high, both the pressure difference and compression work
is become zero. In the P-h chart of Fig. 3(b), this would happen if point ➀
hdisch −hsuct
Wdes = rose and point ➁ moved to the left until they overlap each other.
ηis (12) Synthesis process (mode 3):
The maximum desorption temperature is defined as the temperature The reactor and evaporator temperatures and pressures are given
at which the TR reaches the same pressure as the condenser. At that by:
point, as shown in Fig. 4(c), the compressor work becomes zero: Tsynt = T0 + ΔTsynt (16)
Tdes,max = Tr ,eq (Pliq − vap,eq (Tcond )) (13)
Psynt = Pr ,eq (Tsynt ) (17)
Ts,max = Tdes,max + ΔTdes (14)
Tevap = Tliq − vap,eq (Pevap) = Tcold−ΔTevap (18)
Eq. (13) involves both the S/G and the L/G Clausius–Clapeyron rela-
tions from (3). Pevap = Psynt (19)
The heat of desorption Qdes is equal to the enthalpy of reaction, plus
As shown in (17) and (19), during synthesis, the evaporator and
the necessary energy required for the reactants to reach the operating
reactor have the same pressure, corresponding to the S/G equilibrium
conditions of desorption, that is, Tdes and Pdes. The value of Qdes, ex-
pressure at temperature Tsynt.
pressed per mole of gas and considered positive when heat flows toward
The heat of synthesis per mole of reacting gas, Qsynt, is given in (20)
the reactor, is given by:
and is considered positive when heat leaves the reactor.
1
Qdes = ΔHr0 + (cP,s1 Xdes,init + cP,s0 (1−Xdes,init ))(Tdes−T0 ) 1
υ (15) Qsynt = |ΔHr0 |−(hg (Tsynt ,Psynt )−h vap,sat (Tevap))− (c PS1 Xsynt ,init
υ
The first term of the second member in (15) accounts for the en- + c PS 0 (1−Xsynt ,init ))(Tsynt −T0) (20)
thalpy of reaction (endothermic). The second term represents the

246
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

The first term on the right side of (20) refers to the enthalpy of This formula of COP1 will be utilized in the section below, which
reaction. The absolute value bars are necessary as the reaction is, in this compares the system being studied with other energy storage methods.
case, exothermic, so ΔHr0 is negative. The second term refers to the Although this COP will not be further elaborated upon in this work, it
necessary energy to bring the input gas to reacting conditions. This gas should be noted that ammonia has a high latent heat of vaporization
leaves the evaporator as 100% saturated vapor with temperature Tevap (eight times greater than R-12 and six times greater than R-134a, per
and enthalpy hvap,sat(Tevap), and reacts at (Tsynt,Psynt) with a specific mass of refrigerant) and operates with pressure levels comparable to
enthalpy of hg(Tsynt,Pr). The last term in (20) represents the necessary those of other refrigerants. These characteristics result in a highly en-
energy (sensible heat) to bring the initial proportions of salt S0 and S1 ergy-efficient MVC cycle with minimal environmental impact [22].
from ambient temperature T0 to synthesis temperature. The value The second, COP2–3, relates the compressor work during desorption
Xsynt,init represents the reactor global advancement at the start of the phase in mode 2 to the amount of cold produced during synthesis phase
synthesis process. in mode 3:
The cold production per mole of gas is given by:
cold production in mode 2 Qevap
Qevap = h vap (Tevap)−hliq (T0) COP2 − 3 = =
(21) compressor work for reactor desorption in mode 3 Wdes
with hvap and hliq as the specific enthalpy of the fluid fully evaporated (23)
and condensed, respectively. By inserting (12) and (15) into (23), the function of COP2–3 is ob-
tained, which is a function of the following list of arguments:
5. System performance
COP2 − 3 = COP2 − 3 (T0,Ts,ηis ,ΔTdes,ΔTsynt ,ΔTcond,ΔTevap) (24)
This section presents the mathematical formulation of three per-
In the results and discussion section, a parametric study of this equation
formance indicators that are normally used in storage and cold pro-
is performed.
duction systems. These are:

(a) Coefficient of performance, COP. In the context of the system 5.2. Exergy efficiency
analyzed here, this parameter indicates the relationship between
cold production and the electric consumption of the compressor. Fig. 6 shows heat and exergy flows of the system during the storage
(b) Exergy efficiency, ηex. This parameter not only considers the com- and cold production phases. An amount of exergy Exs flows towards the
pressor work, but also takes into account the heat used to desorb the system during the storage phase and another quantity, Excold, flows out
TR. It can be said that ηex assigns an economic value (cost) to the of the system during the cold production phase. The heat of con-
heat of desorption. densation and synthesis are rejected at the dead-state temperature T0,
(c) Cooling capacity, which will be evaluated by two parameters: i) the and thus do not contribute to the exergy flow.
capacity of cold production per unit of volume and mass of the TR The exergy efficiency is defined in general terms as the ratio be-
and ii) the daily cold production per area of solar panel. The eva- tween the useful exergy and the exergy expended (or paying exergy). In
luation of the second parameter is relevant due to the fact that the the system under study, the useful exergy corresponds to the exergy
system is intended to store energy coming from PV panels. |Excold| of the heat transferred from the low-temperature medium at
Tcold to the system (which occurs in the evaporator). The absolute value
Below, further detail is given with regards to each indicator men- is needed as the exergy is negative (i.e. it leaves the system). The exergy
tioned above. expended is the sum of the compressor work Wdes (100% exergy) and
the exergy Exs of the heat transferred from the source at Ts to the system
(which happens in the reactor). This is expressed in the following eq.:
5.1. Coefficient of performance (COP)
useful exergy |Ex cold | |Qevap θcold |
For the system presented in this study, two distinct coefficients of ηex = = =
exergy expended Wdes + Exs Wdes + Qdes θs (25)
performance need to be defined. The first, COP1, is associated with
operating mode 1, when the system works as a traditional ammonia The Carnot coefficients for desorption phase θs and for cold pro-
MVC cycle and there is no energy storage: duction θcold are defined as follows:
cold production in mode 1 T0
COP1 = θs = 1−
compressor work in mode 1 (22) Ts (26)

: exergy
Qdes : heat
Ts Reactor
Exs COLD
PRODUCTION
Compressor (SYNTHESIS)
Wdes
Qcond Qsynt
T0 Condenser Reactor
Excond=0 Exsynt=0
ENERGY
STORAGE
(DESORPTION)
Qevap
Tcold Evaporator
Excold
Fig. 6. Heat and exergy flow of the storage/cold production system. The light gray blocks represent the system during storage phase or mode 2 (left), and cold production or mode 3
(right).

247
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

T0 materials of its walls, allows for the computation of the reactor’s mass
θcold = 1−
Tcold (27) energy density, resulting in an approximate value of 200 kJ per kg of
reactor.
The expression of ηex is derived by combining (12), (15), (21), (25), (26)
Keeping in mind that the system being studied is intended to store
and (27). Its value is a function of several parameters, namely:
energy coming from PV panels, another criterion worth analyzing is the
ηex = ηex (T0,Ts,ηis ,ΔTdes,ΔTsynt ,ΔTcond,ΔTevap) (28) cooling capacity per surface of solar collector, namely qS,cold, which
assesses how efficiently the system takes advantage of the surface ex-
As in the case of the COP2–3, the results and discussion section shows
posed to sunlight. The parameter qS,cold specifies the daily cold pro-
a parametric study of this equation.
duction per square meter of solar panel, using the following formula:
5.3. Cooling capacity qS,cold = Isolar ·ηPV + conv ·COP2 − 3, (31)

The cooling capacity of a thermochemical reactor, that is, the cold with Isolar as the solar irradiation (typically given in units of kWh/m2/
production per volume or mass of TR, depends on the nature and the day) and ηPV+conv as the solar efficiency of the PV panels and
amount of salt in the reactor. Generally, the salt is mixed with an inert converter.The results and discussion section compares the values of
binder (expanded natural graphite) to enhance heat and mass transfers qV,cold and qS,cold with other energy storage methods.
in the reactor. The mixture, characterized by a mass ratio τ (generally
0.8 kg of salt per kg of mixture), is compressed in situ to form a con-
solidated reactive medium with high thermal conductivity, high por- 6. Results and discussion
osity and mechanical elasticity [24]. The consolidation of the salt-
graphite mixture is carried out in the reactor until a given effective This section presents and analyzes the results of the equations for-
composite density ρcomp of reactive medium is obtained. Practical den- mulated thus far, in order to draw conclusions about the system being
sities range from 300 to 500 kg/m3 of reactor in order to obtain ac- studied. These results include: compressor operating condition, tem-
ceptable gas permeability. perature levels of cold production, coefficient of performance, exergy
These characteristic parameters of the reactive salt implementation efficiency and a comparison with other energy storage technologies.For
allow for the evaluation of the number of moles of reactive gas (am- the study of the coefficient of performance and exergy efficiency, the
monia) per m3 of reactor, namely ngas, which is absorbed by the reactor following parameters have been chosen:
connected to the evaporator during the synthesis phase:
τ . ρcomp (i) COP2 − 3 = COP2 − 3 (arg), with arg
ngas = υ|ΔX |
Msalt (29) =( T0 , Ts , ηis ,ΔTdes,ΔTsynt ,ΔTcond,ΔTevap )
⏟ °C T …⏟ 
In (29), Msalt is the molar mass of the anhydrous salt (208.23 g/mol) 25,30,35 T 0⏟ s,max 0.7 … 0.8 5K,10K
and |ΔX| is the reaction global advancement difference between the (ii) ηex = ηex (arg) (32)
start and the end of the synthesis process.
Multiplying the value of ngas with the cold production per mole of The selected values of ambient temperature are in accordance with
gas shown in (21), the cold production per volume of reactor (or vo- typical weather patterns in French Polynesia. The temperature differ-
lumetric cooling capacity) is obtained: ences of 5 K and 10 K permit reasonable rates of heat transfer. The
qV ,cold = Qevap Ngas source temperature Ts varies continuously in most of the cases ana-
(30)
lyzed, ranging from ambient temperature to Ts,max. The compressor
Considering a value of Qevap of 20 kJ/mol for ammonia, a composite isentropic efficiency varies continuously from 0.7 to 0.8.
effective density ρcomp of 400 kg/m3, Msalt of 0.208 kg/mol and ΔX of All of the computations were performed with MATLABTM Software
0.9, the reactor volumetric energy density for cooling production qV,cold and the CoolProp library [25], the latter of which was used to retrieve
equals 220 kJ per liter of reactor (or 60 Whcold/L approximately). This the thermodynamic properties of ammonia.
last value, plus the information regarding the reactor’s shape and the

(a) (b)
Fig. 7. Compressor pressure ratio during desorption process (mode 2) as a function of source temperature Ts, for three scenarios of ambient temperature T0. (a) ΔTdes and ΔTcond of 5 K; (b)
ΔTdes and ΔTcond of 10 K.

248
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

6.1. Compressor operating conditions

During the desorption process, in mode 2, the compressor does not


work at an operating point normally found in a MVC refrigeration cycle,
since the compressor’s intake line is not connected to an evaporator, but
rather to a thermochemical reactor. For this reason, it is important to
ensure that the compressor’s recommended operating range is respected
while the reactor is desorbed. To that effect, this section analyzes two
key parameters: the compression ratio and the gas temperature at the
compressor discharge line (also called ‘discharge temperature’).
With regards to the compression ratio, defined as the quotient be-
tween the discharge and intake pressures, there is a maximum value
that should be respected. This value varies depending on the type of
compressor technology utilized. For example, for reciprocating com-
pressors, the maximum allowable compression ratios are usually be-
tween 5 and 6 [26].
With reference to gas temperature at the discharge line, manu-
facturers recommend that it stay below 185 °C so as to not degrade the
Fig. 9. Compressor-driven TR, regions of admissible desorption temperatures Tdes, as a
oil that lubricates the compressor’s internal mechanisms [26].
function of the condenser temperature Tcond, that allow the compressor to operate within
In this study, it will be considered that the maximum allowable the recommended operating range (i.e. compression ratio inferior to 5 and discharge gas
compression ratio is 5 and that the maximum permissible discharge temperature less than 180 °C). Striped area: ηis = 0.7, Solid & striped area: ηis = 0.8.
temperature is 180 °C.
Figs. 7 and 8 show the compression ratio and discharge tempera-
discharge temperature of 180 °C, the source temperature Ts must be
ture, respectively, of the system being studied, as a function of the
greater than 30–45 °C (depending on the values of ΔTdes, ΔTcond, ηis and
source temperature Ts, for scenarios of the parameters T0, ΔTdes, ΔTcond
T0). This restricts the circumstances under which the system can op-
and ηis.
erate with only one heat source at ambient temperature.
For the analysis of the compression ratio, Fig. 7 shows that low
To continue with the discussion, one might ask the following
values of Ts result in high compression ratios. This means that the
question: for a given condenser temperature Tcond, what is the range of
maximum compression ratio permitted imposes a lower limit on the
desorption temperature Tdes that ensures the operation of the com-
source temperature Ts. Additionally, by comparing graphs (a) and (b) of
pressor within recommended limits? This question is answered in
Fig. 7, it can be seen that, by reducing the temperature differences ΔTdes
Fig. 9, which shows the admissible range of Tdes as a function of con-
and ΔTcond from 10 K to 5 K, the compressor pressure ratio is reduced by
denser temperature, for two scenarios (namely 0.7 and 0.8) of com-
a factor of up to 1.5, especially for lower values of Ts. The reduction of
pressor isentropic efficiency ηis.
these temperature differences can be achieved, for instance, by im-
The two areas shown in Fig. 9, one for each value of ηis, have the
proving the thermal transfer of the TR and condenser.
same upper limit, corresponding to the value Tdes,max (see (13)), where
With regards to discharge temperature, Fig. 8 shows the same be-
the compressor work is zero. The lower limit, on the other hand, is
havior as seen in the analysis of the compression ratio (that is, the lower
different for each scenario. When ηis = 0.8 (region shown in grey), the
the Ts, the higher the discharge temperature). Again, this effect imposes
lower limit is defined by two curves. The first defines the desorption
a different lower limit on the source temperature Ts. Fig. 8(a) and (b)
temperature where the compressor discharge temperature is equal to
also shows that a reduction in ΔTdes and ΔTcond from 10 K to 5 K pro-
180 °C: values of Tdes above this curve indicate a lower discharge tem-
duces a drop in discharge temperature of approximately 40 °C, which is
perature. The second represents the curve of desorption temperature
a considerable amount.
which produces a compression ratio of 5; values of Tdes above this curve
An important point derived from the analysis of Figs. 7 and 8 is that,
indicate a compression ratio inferior to 5.
in order to respect the maximal allowable pressure ratio of 5 and gas

(a) (b)
Fig. 8. Gas temperature at the compressor discharge line during desorption process (mode 2), as a function of source temperature Ts, for three scenarios of ambient temperature T0. (a)
ΔTdes and ΔTcond of 5 K; (b) ΔTdes and ΔTcond of 10 K. The shaded areas represent the variation of ηis from 0.7 to 0.8 (note that a higher ηis results in a lower Tdisch).

249
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

The region that refers to ηis = 0.7 (with a diagonal stripe pattern) 6.4. Exergy efficiency
has a lower limit marked by a single curve, corresponding to the dis-
charge temperature of 180 °C. The analysis of the exergy efficiency, formulated in (25), is sum-
Note that the values of temperature Ts and T0 can be derived from marized in Fig. 12, and shows ηex as a function of the source tem-
Tdes and Tcond by adding and subtracting ΔTdes and ΔTcond, respectively. perature Ts, with the rest of the parameters varying according to (32).
The figure shows a monotonous growth of ηex with Ts, which implies
that the maximum exergy efficiency is reached when the reactor is
6.2. Cold production, temperature levels desorbed without the assistance of the compressor. However, this last
situation can only take place if the temperature Ts of the heat source is
An interesting aspect to analyze is the relationship between eva- sufficiently high (otherwise the desorption process will not occur).
porator temperature Tevap and the temperature T0 of the TR heat sink It must be noted that this result is not inherently obvious. Before
during cold production (synthesis process, mode 3). Fig. 10 shows this performing the analysis, the authors supposed that the maximum value
relationship, which indicates a linear growth of Tevap with T0. Put an- of ηex might be attained for an intermediate temperature Ts, between
other way, the system will produce cold at lower temperatures when ambient temperature T0 and maximum temperature Ts,max. In fact, that
the ambient temperature is low. This means that the system is well situation is indeed the case, but only with higher compressor isentropic
suited for cold production during the evening hours, when no solar efficiencies and smaller temperature differences of ΔTdes, ΔTcond, ΔTsynt
energy is available, ambient temperature is no longer at its maximum and ΔTevap, which is technologically unattainable.
and the building still has a cooling demand. As seen thus far, a main advantage of the system being studied lies
This does not mean, however, that the system becomes ineffective at in its capability to take advantage of a heat source to desorb the TR,
higher ambient temperature levels. For instance, even for a value of when the temperature of the given heat source is insufficient to produce
ambient temperature as high as 35 °C, Tevap will be 8 °C (with ΔTsynt = a purely thermic desorption (alternatively said, when the TR pressure is
5 K). This value of evaporating temperature is sufficient to provide cold lower than the condenser pressure). When such a scenario takes place,
to a room at Tcold of 24 °C through an air-chiller unit connected to the the compressor will assist the desorption process by providing the ne-
evaporator (thus Troom − Tevap = 16 °C). cessary pressure lift.
For moderate values of ambient temperature, the system can ef-
fectively produce water at 0–5 °C in a chilled water loop in contact with 6.5. Comparison with other energy storage methods
the evaporator and then provide cold to the building through a fan-coil
unit. See [18] for experimental results of this scheme. This section compares the following systems, as shown in Table 2:
Pb and Li-ion batteries, ice and chilled water thermal storage and
thermochemical storage. The criteria for the comparison are: cold
6.3. Coefficient of performance production per volume of storage qV,cold, daily cold production per
surface of solar collector qS,cold and life span of the storage technology.
Fig. 11 summarizes the analysis of the coefficient of performance Table 2 and Fig. 13 show the results of the comparison. For the
expressed in (23) and (24). The input parameters are set according to system studied in this work, the values of qV,cold and qS,cold are computed
(32). The figure shows the COP2–3 as a function of source temperature according to (30) and (31). The comparison assumes a daily solar ra-
Ts, for three scenarios of ambient temperature T0. The shaded areas diation of 5.8 kWh/m2/day (see Table 6), a solar efficiency of 14% for
represent the variations of the compressor isentropic efficiency from 0.7 PV panels/inverters and 60% for thermal flat-plate solar collectors.
to 0.8. The graphs (a) and (b) differ in their values of ΔT mentioned in Note that for the batteries, qV,cold is computed by multiplying their net
(32) (that is, 5 K and 10 K). energy densities by the COP of the corresponding MVC cycle and qS,cold
The rising trend of the COP2–3 is due to the fact that, as Ts rises, the is computed according to (31), though applying the COP definition (22)
compressor work decreases. These curves show a vertical asymptote at of a traditional MVC cycle.
Ts = Ts,max, where the compressor work approaches zero. Additionally, As indicated in Table 2 and Fig. 13, the electrochemical technolo-
the higher the isentropic efficiency, the higher the COP2–3. In Fig. 11, gies have a considerably shorter life span with respect to the other
the values of ηis = 0.7 and ηis = 0.8 correspond, respectively, to the
lower and upper limits of each shaded area.
Based on Fig. 11, it can also be surmised that, for a given source
temperature Ts, the COP2–3 decreases when ambient temperature rises.
This is because, with increases of T0, the condenser pressure also aug-
ments, which elevates the compression ratio and results in an increase
of the compressor work.
It should be reiterated, nevertheless, that since the heat of deso-
rption is not included in the definition of COP2–3, it is not considered as
a cost- this can only be true if either the heat is taken from the en-
vironment at ambient temperature, or it is a waste heat from another
process.
The comparison of graphs (a) and (b) of Fig. 11 shows that a re-
duction in the heat transfer temperature differences ΔTdes, ΔTcond and
ΔTsynt from 10 K to 5 K causes an important increase in the coefficient of
performance- by 30% approximately for the lower range of Ts and
larger for higher values of Ts. For example, for values of Ts of 50 °C and
T0 of 25 °C, the increase of COP2–3 due to the reduction of the afore-
mentioned parameters, is of approximately 100%. This sensitivity
analysis plays an important role in the economic study of the system. Fig. 10. Evaporator temperature during cold production in mode 3, as a function of
Section 6.5 will use these results to compare the system under study ambient temperature T0 (which acts as the heat sink of the TR), for two different values of
with other energy storage methods. ΔTsynt: 5 K and 10 K. By reducing ΔTsynt from 10 K to 5 K, the evaporator temperature
drops by approximately 6.5 K.

250
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

(a) (b)
Fig. 11. Coefficient of performance COP2–3 of the compressor-driven thermochemical storage for cold production as a function of source temperature Ts, for three scenarios of ambient
temperature T0. (a) ΔTdes, ΔTcond and ΔTsynt of 5 K; (b) ΔTdes, ΔTcond and ΔTsynt of 10 K. The shaded areas represent the variation of the compressor isentropic efficiency ηis from 0.7 to 0.8.

storage methods. The life span of thermal and thermo-chemical storage 6.5.1. Techno-economic consideration
is limited to the life span of the installation (usually considered to be Any attempt of an economic analysis of the system presented in this
20 years), and not the storage itself. At PROMES Laboratory, France, work would be incomplete for two main reasons: first, there are no
thermo-chemical reactors with more than 10 × 103 cycles have been known commercially available thermochemical reactors, since most of
tested, without showing a decrease in performance. the developments using such technology were conducted in research
By analyzing Fig. 13, some interesting observations can be made laboratories. However, once the technique to produce the composite is
about the system under study: mastered, the cost to obtain the raw materials should be reasonable.
This assumption is based on estimated costs of the raw materials
• It has a cooling capacity six times larger than chilled water systems, (barium chloride, expanded natural graphite). Other auxiliary compo-
and a cooling capacity comparable to that of ice storage systems. nents of the reactor (e.g. heat exchanger in contact with the reactor)
Moreover, while thermal energy storage methods have important would also need to be considered in the economic analysis.
self-discharge rates (sensible heat losses), thermochemical tech- Second, since ammonia refrigeration machines are currently em-
nology has virtually no losses (provided that the valve that separates ployed almost exclusively in large systems (ranging from hundreds to
the thermochemical reactor from the rest of the system has no thousands of kW of refrigerating power), it is difficult to find compo-
leakage). nents for small size implementations. However, with the continuous
• Although the systems with electrochemical batteries present higher ban or phasing-out of current refrigerants (i.e. CFCs and HCFCs) and
cooling capacity values, they suffer from much shorter life spans. with no definitive environmental assessment on the latest generation of
• By revalorizing the wasted heat rejected by another process, the refrigerants, natural refrigerants offer an interesting alternative. It is
studied system can reach important values of daily cold production expected that ammonia will be established in the market for small and
per surface of solar panel, up to 4kWhcold/day/m2. medium refrigeration systems [23]. This situation would lead to an
increased availability of ammonia-compatible components with

(a) (b)
Fig. 12. Exergy efficiency of the compressor-driven thermochemical storage for cold production as a function of source temperature Ts, for three scenarios of ambient temperature T0. (a)
ΔTdes, ΔTcond, ΔTsynt and ΔTevap of 5 K; (b) ΔTdes, ΔTcond, ΔTsynt and ΔTevap of 10 K. The shaded areas represent the variation of ηis from 0.7 to 0.8.

251
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

Table 2
Comparison of storage technologies for cold production.

Storage technology Energy density DOD allowed Net energy Round-trip COP qV,cold (Whcold/ qS,cold (Whcold/ Storage cycle
(Wh/L) (%) density (Wh/L) efficiency (%) L) m2/day) life

Pb battery & MVC cycle [27–29] 90 50 45 75 4.21 190 2600 1500


Li-ion battery & MVC cycle [30] 100 100 100 90 4.21 420 3100 3500
MVC cycle & ice [31] 50 100 50 95 2.52 50 1900 Very long
MVC cycle & chilled water [31,32] 10 100 10 95 4.21 10 3200 Very long
TC + PV + heat source at 67 90 605 100 3.23 60 2600 Very long
Ts = 40 °C
TC + PV + heat source at 67 90 605 100 4.83 60 3900 Very long
Ts = 50 °C
TC + thermal solar collector, 67 90 605 100 0.44 60 1400 Very long
Ts = 73 °C [18]

1
Tcond = 40 °C, Tevap = 0°C, ηis = 0.75.
2
Tcond = 40 °C, Tevap = −15 °C, ηis = 0.70.
3
Tcond = 40 °C, Fig. 11b.
4
Thermal COP.
5
See Section 5.3.

scale projects. Nonetheless, a few manufacturers offer compressors with


small capacities (e.g. for a few kW of cooling capacity). Table 3 lists the
smallest commercially available ammonia-compatible reciprocating
compressors for cooling applications identified by the authors of this
work. Oil-less and diaphragm reciprocating compressors have also been
considered for the prototype. In particular, diaphragm compressors
were initially good contenders, since they have a flexible membrane in
place of a piston which ensures that the compressed gas does not come
into contact with the compressor’s lubricant. However, these types of
compressors were cost-prohibitive for the project.
The compressor bought for the construction of the prototype in this
study corresponds to the model O121DK100/NH3 from German man-
ufacturer HKT Huber-Kälte-Technik, as it presents the lowest swept
volume rate of all the models analyzed (see Table 3). The compressor
has a nominal swept volume rate of 6 m3/h and is equipped with a 3 kW
motor and a frequency converter that allows for speed control to a
minimum of 60% of its nominal value, which produces a swept volume
Fig. 13. Comparison of storage technologies for cold production. Graphical representa- rate of 3.6 m3/h. This limit is imposed by the manufacturer in order to
tion of Table 2. avoid lubrication problems. The compressor also includes a water-
cooled cylinder head that will only be utilized if the gas at the discharge
competitive prices, which, in turn, has the potential to make the system line surpasses 165 °C (manufacturer recommendation [26]). For lu-
analyzed in this work a viable solution from an economic perspective. brication, the compressor utilizes a synthetic type of oil that is im-
miscible with ammonia, so an oil-return circuit (i.e. oil separator and
additional filters) will be installed. Other filters will be mounted in
7. Prototype development
order to minimize the presence of oil in the thermochemical reactor.
The heat source at temperature Ts for the desorption process will be
A prototype of the system presented in this study is currently being
implemented with an electrical heater in direct contact with the TR,
developed at GEPASUD Laboratory (French Polynesia), which will
which will allow for a straightforward regulation of the thermo-
allow for a comparison and contrast of the results presented in this
chemical reactor operating point. During the synthesis process, the TR
study with experimental data.
will be cooled-down using forced air convection.
A critical component of the prototype is the electrical compressor,
Fig. 14 shows a diagram of the prototype under development and
since its swept volume rate directly influences the size of the reactor.
Table 4 specifies the relationship between the operating mode (i.e.
This can be explained from (33) and (34), which show that for a given
mode 1: conventional MVC cycle, mode 2: desorption, mode 3:
desorption time Δtdesorp, the number of moles of salt Nsalt (and, by
consequence, the reactor size) is proportional to the gas flow rate, as
well as to the compressor swept volume rate. In (34), ηvol is the com-
Table 3
pressor’s volumetric efficiency and vgas is the gas’s specific volume. Examples of small-capacity, ammonia-compatible reciprocating compressors available in
Δtdesorp the market.
Nsalt ≈ ̇ (desorption)
Ngas
υ ·ΔXdesorp (33) Brand Model Vswept min (m3/h)

ηvol Frigopol TYP 14PI-DLRC-3 10 @ 35 Hz*


̇ =
Ngas ̇
·Vswept HKT O 121 DK100/NH3 3.6 @ 30 Hz*,x
vgas (T ,P ) (34) GEA F2 NH3 6.95 @ 960 rpm**
Bitzer W2TA-S190 15.7 @ 1450 rmp
With this consideration, and with the idea of obtaining a small-scale
prototype, an investigation into the availability of small ammonia- * Nominal frequency: 50 Hz.
compatible compressors in the market was conducted. As mentioned in ** Nominal speed: 1450 rpm.
x
Section 6.5.1, ammonia-based refrigeration systems are used for large- Purchased for the prototype implementation.

252
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

Needle valve
T
(for capacity control)

V2
Thermochemical
Reactor Compressor Oil
T,P T Pre-cooler T,P T,P De-superheater T T T
V1 V4 separator
M
Condenser
Filter
Fan T T T
Electric V5
cylinder
heater
V3 head cooler

L
T
T
Pump
Liquid
T Thermocouple prove
Municipal water ammonia
P Pressure meter (15-20°C) reservoir

L Level meter V6

T T Expansion
valve
Evaporator Ammonia
charge/drain

Cold chamber

Fig. 14. Diagram of the prototype under development at GEPASUD Laboratory, University of French Polynesia.

Table 4 control method’ in order to reduce the ammonia flow rate coming out of
Correspondence between position of valves from Fig. 14 and operating mode of proto- the reactor during desorption phase. This is necessary since the com-
type. O: open, C: closed.
pressor minimum swept volume rate of 3.6 m3/h would still be too high
Operating mode Valve Heater Fan for the size of reactor in consideration. The implementation of such
capacity control consists of a feedback loop that connects the com-
V1 V2 V3 V4 V5 V6 pressor discharge line with the intake line, a ten-turn needle valve to
regulate the fraction of gas that returns to the intake line and two heat
Mode 1 C O O O O O OFF OFF
Mode 2 O O C O O C ON OFF exchangers- namely ‘pre-cooler’ and ‘de-superheater’, which avoid any
Mode 3 O C O C C O OFF ON gas temperature build-up effects. Although this type of capacity control
is energy inefficient, it allows for a simple flow rate control.
Table 5 shows a list of relevant design parameters and operating
Table 5 points of the prototype. The parameters that were imposed by design
Prototype: selected design parameters (marked with an asterisk) and simulated oper-
are shown with an asterisk. They were selected in order to keep the size
ating conditions.
of the reactor reasonably small, while maintaining the compressor
Reactor, general within safe operating conditions. The other information contained in
Effective length (m) 1.5* Table 5 was obtained by simulating the system shown in Fig. 14 em-
External diameter (m) 0.11* ploying MATLABTM Software and the CoolProp library [25].
ρENG (kg/m3) 120*
The thermochemical reactor under consideration consists of a
τsalt (0…1) 0.75*
Composite (BaCl2/ENG) mass (kg) 6.3 stainless steel tube filled with 6.3 kg of BaCl2/ENG composite. When
Ammonia mass (kg) 2.5 fully charged, it will contain about 2.5 kg of ammonia. This mass of
Reactor, desorption phase refrigerant can produce 0.82 kWh of cooling effect during synthesis.
Heat source temperature (°C) 45*
Another important parameter selected by design was a desorption time
Reactor gas temperature (°C) 33
Reactor pressure (bar) 4.1
of two hours. This value allows for a sufficiently slow desorption phase,
Heat of desorption (from electric heater) (W) 800 which, in turns reduces the power requirements of the heat exchangers.
Outward gas flow rate (kg/h) 1.23 As a final note, it should be pointed out that the compressor ac-
ΔX, global advancement difference (0…1) 0.8 quired for the construction of the prototype allows for a production of
Desorption time (minute) 120*
up to 7 kW of refrigerating power, which is sufficient to cool a space of
Compressor, desorption phase
Swept volume rate (m3/h) 3.6* 45 m2 (considering a cooling load of 150 W/m2). This means that, by
Temperature at intake line (°C) 26 properly resizing the thermochemical reactor and its auxiliary compo-
Pressure at intake line (bar) 4.1 nents, a real-scale system using the same compressor could be im-
Temperature at discharge line (°C) 170
plemented, for example, in order to provide cooling to a room and not
Condensing temperature (°C) 40
Condensing pressure (bar) 15.8
only to a small cold chamber (as in the case of the prototype).
Pressure ratio (HP/LP) 3.9
Isentropic efficiency (0…1) [26] 0.7*
Control capacity, mass return fraction (%) 87
8. Conclusions
Reactor, synthesis phase
Total cooling capacity (kWh) 0.82 This study demonstrates that a thermochemical reactor coupled
with a photovoltaic-driven mechanical compressor is an innovative
solution that offers energy storage capabilities for deferred cooling
synthesis) and the position of the valves, the state of the fan and the applications. Normally, the analysis and application of thermochemical
electric heater. reactors is limited to solar cooling contexts. The present work shows
The prototype will implement what is referred to as ‘capacity that such technology can provide energy storage services in modern

253
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

Table 6
List of the fifteen most inhabited islands in French Polynesia [33] (which account for 94% of the total population), with their corresponding areas and average global horizontal
irradiation (GHI) [34].

Index Island Population (2017) Area (km2) Solar GHI (kWh/m2/day)

1 Tahiti 189,517 1045 5.73


2 Moorea 17,816 134 5.73
3 Raiatea 12,249 175 5.74
4 Bora bora 10,549 38 5.74
5 Huahine 6075 74 5.13
6 Tahaa 5234 88 5.74
7 Nuku Hiva 2951 387 6.61
8 Rangiroa 2709 79 5.93
9 Rurutu 2466 33 5.21
10 Hiva Oa 2243 316 6.57
11 Tubuai 2217 45 5.13
12 Ua Pou 2213 106 6.55
13 Mangareva 1384 16 5.34
14 Maupiti 1286 14 5.71
15 Raivavae 903 16 5.14

electricity grids and is particularly interesting for regions with rising driven thermochemical systems).
energy demands for space cooling. Thermochemical technology has An additional significant point of this work relates to the com-
important features which are sought out in any storage system: com- pressor operating conditions. The study shows that during the energy
petitive storage capacity, no self-discharge and long charge/discharge storage phase, the compressor can work within a normal working
life cycle. range, maintaining parameters such as the pressure ratio and discharge
In contrast with 100%-solar-heat-driven thermochemical systems, gas temperature under safe limits. This means that the system can use a
in which desorption process cannot occur if the heat source tempera- standard ammonia reciprocating compressor designed for operating a
ture is not sufficiently high, the system presented in this work utilizes mechanical vapor compression refrigeration cycle.
an electrical compressor to aid the process and compensates for a lower From a techno-economic perspective, it is expected that ammonia
heat source temperature. More concretely, this study shows that for the will be established in the market for small and medium refrigeration
pair barium chloride/ammonia (BaCl2/NH3), with the use of a com- systems [23]. This situation would lead to an increased availability of
pressor, the thermochemical reactor can reduce the reacting tempera- ammonia-compatible components with competitive prices, which, in
ture by up to 20 K (allowing, for instance, a desorption process with a turn, would have the potential to make the system analyzed in this
heat source at 35 °C). work a viable solution from an economic perspective. Moreover, the use
The reduction in the reacting temperature permits the revaloriza- of the natural refrigerant ammonia reduces the environmental impact
tion of a wider variety of low-grade heat sources that are currently not [23], an increasingly important factor in any energy related system.
exploited due to their low exergy content; these include waste heat
from photovoltaic installations, low-temperature fuel cell stacks and
even from within the system itself (i.e. by being able to recover the heat Acknowledgements
of condensation).
Another important result is that the system can reach a cooling The corresponding author would like to acknowledge the Service de
capacity value of 4 kWhcold/day per m2 of photovoltaic panel, which is l'énergie du gouvernement de la Polynésie française (SDE) for the financial
higher than the values of the other systems analyzed in this work (i.e. support of his PhD thesis and Miss Colleen Eleanor Leminski, for
electrochemical batteries, chilled water, ice and 100%-solar-heat- proofreading the article.

Appendix A

Table 6 shows a list of the fifteen most inhabited islands in French Polynesia, which account for 94% of the total population. The table includes
population, surface area and solar global horizontal irradiation (GHI), this last being an important parameter used in solar energy potential as-
sessments. The average GHI for these fifteen islands of French Polynesia is 5.8 kWh/m2/day.
Table 6 was included in this work to combine three points (i.e. population, area, GHI) that were not found together in literature. Besides, it
emphasizes the fact that the islands found in French Polynesia range in population from nearly 200,000 inhabitants to a few hundred (and even
fewer inhabitants in the islands not shown on this table). This diversity, in conjunction with the high values of solar energy resources, could be
exploited for the development of smart electricity grids of the future.

References polynesie-francaise.html [accessed December 2017].


[4] Électricité de Tahiti (EDT). “Les tarifs”. Available online at: https://agence.edt.pf/
faq.
[1] Erdinc Ozan, Paterakis Nikolaos G, Catalão João PS. Overview of insular power [5] Energy Information Administration, U.S. Department of Energy, Electric Power
systems under increasing penetration of renewable energy sources: opportunities Monthly with Data for December 2017, Table 5.3. Average price of electricity to
and challenges. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2015;52:333–46. http://dx.doi.org/10. ultimate customers. Available online at: https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/
1016/j.rser.2015.07.104. current_month/epm.pdf [accessed February 2018].
[2] Institut de la statistique de la Polynésie française, La Polynésie en bref 2016 (French [6] Statistical office of the European Union, Eurostat, Electricity price statistics, Table 1:
Polynesia at a glance 2016). [in French and English]. Available online at: http:// Electricity prices, first half of year, 2015-2017. Available online at: http://ec.
www.ispf.pf/docs/default-source/publi-pr/polybref-2016.pd [accessed December europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/images/6/6e/Electricity_prices_2017s1_
2017]. update_28_11_2017-final.xlsx [accessed February 2018].
[3] “Les enjeux énergétiques de la Polynésie française”, presentation given by the [7] Agence de l'Environnement et de la Maîtrise de l'Énergie de la Polynésie française,
“Service de l’énergie et des mines” of French Polynesia in 2012 [in French]. Plan climat-énergie; 2015, p. 106 [in French]. Available online at: http://www.
Available online at: http://docplayer.fr/19043030-Les-enjeux-energetiques-de-la- polynesie-francaise.ademe.fr/sites/default/files/files/mediatheque/maquette_pce_

254
F. Ferrucci et al. Applied Energy 219 (2018) 240–255

2015-bdef_dble_page.pdf [accessed December 2017]. refrigeration systems corresponding to various heating source temperatures. Appl
[8] Clastres Cédric. Smart grids: Another step towards competition, energy security and Energy 2016;169:846–56. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2016.02.049.
climate change objectives. Energy Policy 2011;39(9):5399–408. http://dx.doi.org/ [22] ASHRAE Position Document on Ammonia as a Refrigerant; February 1, 2017.
10.1016/j.enpol.2011.05.024. Available online at: https://www.ashrae.org/File%20Library/About/Position
[9] Iqbal M, Azam M, Naeem M, Khwaja AS, Anpalagan A. Optimization classification, %20Documents/Ammonia-as-a-Refrigerant-PD-2017.pdf [accessed February 25,
algorithms and tools for renewable energy: a review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2018].
2014;39:640–54. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2014.07.120. [23] Ciconkov Risto. Refrigerants: There is still no vision for sustainable solutions. Int J
[10] Kyriakarakos George, Piromalis Dimitrios D, Dounis Anastasios I, Arvanitis Refrig 2018;86:441–8. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijrefrig.2017.12.006.
Konstantinos G, Papadakis George. Intelligent demand side energy management [24] Mauran S, Prades P, L’Haridon F. Heat and mass transfer in consolidated reacting
system for autonomous polygeneration microgrids. Appl Energy 2013;103:39–51. beds for thermochemical systems. Heat Recov Syst CHP 1993;13(4):315–9.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2012.10.011. [25] Bell Ian H, Wronski Jorrit, Quoilin Sylvain, Lemort Vincent. Pure and pseudo-pure
[11] Guerrero JM, Chandorkar M, Lee TL, Loh PC. Advanced control architectures for fluid thermophysical property evaluation and the open-source thermophysical
intelligent microgrids—Part I: Decentralized and hierarchical control. IEEE Trans property library cool-prop. Ind Eng Chem Res 2014;53(6):2498–508.
Ind Electron April 2013;60(4):1254–62. http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TIE.2012. [26] HKT Huber-Kälte-Technik software package, version 9/2009. Available online at:
2194969. http://www.hkt-goeldner.de/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/HKTSoftware09_
[12] Guerrero JM, Loh PC, Lee TL, Chandorkar M. Advanced control architectures for 2009.exe [accessed December 2017].
intelligent microgrids—Part II: Power quality, energy storage, and AC/DC micro- [27] Rand David AJ, Moseley Patrick T. Chapter 13 – energy storage with lead–acid
grids. IEEE Trans Ind Electron April 2013;60(4):1263–70. http://dx.doi.org/10. batteries. In: Electrochemical energy storage for renewable sources and grid bal-
1109/TIE.2012.2196889. ancing, Elsevier, Amsterdam; 2015. p. 201–22. ISBN 9780444626165. http://doi.
[13] Salas V, Suponthana W, Salas RA. Overview of the off-grid photovoltaic diesel org/10.1016/B978-0-444-62616-5.00013-9.
batteries systems with AC loads. Appl Energy 2015;157:195–216. http://dx.doi. [28] ROLLSTM Pb flooded deep cycle batteries, renewable energy line. Datasheet
org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2015.07.073. available online at http://rollsbattery.com/wp-content/plugins/rollsbatteries/
[14] Colak Ilhami, Fulli Gianluca, Sagiroglu Seref, Yesilbudak Mehmet, Covrig Catalin- pdfs/Renewable.pdf [accessed December 22, 2017].
Felix. Smart grid projects in Europe: Current status, maturity and future scenarios. [29] TROJANTM Pb deep-cycle flooded battery. Model J200RE with bayonet cap.
Appl Energy 2015;152:58–70. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2015.04.098. Datasheet version J200-RE DS 2016_0921, available online at http://www.
[15] Hatziargyriou N, Asano H, Iravani R, Marnay C. Microgrids. IEEE Power Energ Mag trojanbattery.com/pdf/J200-RE_Trojan_Data_Sheets.pdf [accessed December 22,
2007;5(4):78–94. http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/MPAE.2007.376583. 2017].
[16] Palizban Omid, Kauhaniemi Kimmo. Energy storage systems in modern [30] TESLA PowerWall 2 AC, 13.2 kWh. Datasheet available online at http://www.
grids—Matrix of technologies and applications. J Storage Mater 2016;6:248–59. energymatters.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/tesla-powerwall-2-datasheet.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.est.2016.02.001. pdf [accessed December 22, 2017].
[17] Luo Xing, Wang Jihong, Dooner Mark, Clarke Jonathan. Overview of current de- [31] Bruno Arcuri, Catalina Spataru, Mark Barrett, Evaluation of ice thermal energy
velopment in electrical energy storage technologies and the application potential in storage (ITES) for commercial buildings in cities in Brazil, Sustainable Cities and
power system operation. Appl Energy 2015;137:511–36. http://dx.doi.org/10. Society, vol. 29; February 2017. p. 178–92. ISSN 2210-6707. http://doi.org/10.
1016/j.apenergy.2014.09.081. 1016/j.scs.2016.12.011.
[18] Stitou Driss, Mazet Nathalie, Mauran Sylvain. Experimental investigation of a solid/ [32] Sebzali MJ, Rubini PA. The impact of using chilled water storage systems on the
gas thermochemical storage process for solar air-conditioning. Energy performance of air cooled chillers in Kuwait. Energy Build 2007;39(8):975–84.
2012;41(1):261–70. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2011.07.029. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2006.11.004.
[19] Kim DS, Infante Ferreira CA. Solar refrigeration options – a state-of-the-art review. [33] Institut de la statistique de la Polynésie française, Répartition de la population par
Int J Refrig 2008;31(1):3–15. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijrefrig.2007.07.011. île; 2017 [in French]. Available online at: http://www.ispf.pf/docs/default-source/
[20] Ferreira Infante, Kim Dong-Seon. Techno-economic review of solar cooling tech- rp2017/repart_poplegale_iles_2017_v3.pdf [accessed December 2017].
nologies based on location-specific data. Int J Refrig 2014;39:23–37. http://dx.doi. [34] NASA Atmospheric science data center. Surface meteorology and solar energy.
org/10.1016/j.ijrefrig.2013.09.033. HOMER data access. Insolation on horizontal surface; Jul 1983–Jun 2005. https://
[21] Wang RZ, Xu ZY, Pan QW, Du S, Xia ZZ. Solar driven air conditioning and eosweb.larc.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/sse/homer.cgi [accessed December 2017].

255

You might also like