www.antiquity.ac.

uk Volume 94 • Number 377 • October 2020

a review of
world archaeology
edited by robert witcher
https://doi.org/10.15184/aqy.2020.181
ISSN 0003 598X Published online by Cambridge University Press
 EDITOR
Robert Witcher
REVIEWS EDITOR EDITORIAL MANAGER
Claire Nesbitt Liz Ryan
ASSOCIATE EDITOR DEPUTY EDITORIAL MANAGER
Robin Skeates Thomas Swindells
EDITORIAL ASSISTANT PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT AND PRESS ADMINISTRATOR
Ross Kendall Adam Benton

EDITORIAL ADDRESS
Antiquity, Department of Archaeology,
Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK
Tel: +44 (0) 191 3341125; Email: editor@antiquity.ac.uk
Antiquity is an international, peer-reviewed journal of archaeological research that aims to communicate the most
significant discoveries, theory, method and cultural resource issues rapidly and in plain language to practising archae-
ologists everywhere.
Antiquity is included in the Cambridge Journals Online service at http://journals.cambridge.org/AQY. Additional and free-
to-access material may be found at http://antiquity.ac.uk
Antiquity was founded in 1927 by O.G.S. Crawford and is owned by the Antiquity Trust, a registered charity. The trustees of
the Antiquity Trust are Graeme Barker, Amy Bogaard, Robin Coningham, Barry Cunliffe, Roberta Gilchrist, Anthony
Harding, Carl Heron, Martin Millett, Nicky Milner, Stephanie Moser and Cameron Petrie.
The Directors of Antiquity Publications Ltd, owned by the Antiquity Trust and responsible for producing Antiquity are Chris
Gosden, Sue Hamilton, Nicky Milner, Cameron Petrie, Mike Pitts, Marie Louise Stig Sørensen and Robert Witcher.

EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD

Peter Bellwood, The Australian National University, Australia Peter Mitchell, University of Oxford, UK
Xingcan Chen, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, Beijing
Eduardo Goés Neves, Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil
Elizabeth Graham, University College London, UK
Charles Higham, University of Otago, New Zealand
Corinne Hofman, Leiden University, the Netherlands
Stephen Houston, Brown University, USA
Timothy Insoll, University of Exeter, UK
Susan Keech McIntosh, Rice University, USA
Ian Kuijt, University of Notre Dame, USA
Kevin Lane, Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina
Akira Matsuda, University of Tokyo, Japan
Barbara Mills, University of Arizona, USA
Timothy Pauketat, University of Illinois, USA
Victor Paz, University of The Philippines, The Philippines
Michael Petraglia, Max Planck Institute for the Science of
Human History, Jena, Germany
Innocent Pikirayi, University of Pretoria, South Africa
Susan Pollock, Freie Universität Berlin, Germany
Natalia Shishlina, State Historical Museum, Moscow, Russia
Benjamin Smith, University of Western Australia, Australia
Claire Smith, Flinders University, Australia
Monica Smith, University of California, Los Angeles, USA
Miriam Stark, University of Hawai‘i-Manoa, USA
Sarah Tarlow, University of Leicester, UK

Antiquity is published six times a year by Cambridge University Press for Antiquity Publications Ltd: February, April, June,
August, October, December.
Advertising enquiries to the publisher at advertising@cambridge.org
©Antiquity Publications 2020. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, in any form or by any means,
electronic, photocopying or otherwise, without permission in writing from Cambridge University Press. Permission to copy
(for users in the USA) is available from Copyright Clearance Center, http://www.copyright.com, email: info@copyright.com.
This journal issue has been printed on FSC™-certified paper and cover board. FSC is an independent, non-governmental,
not-for-profit organisation established to promote the responsible management of the world’s forests. Please see www.fsc.org
for information.
Printed by Bell & Bain Limited, Glasgow, UK.
Cartographic design by Connor J. Sweetwood; inset maps use map data from Mapbox, OpenStreetMap and their data sources.
To learn more, visit https://www.mapbox.com/about/maps/ and http://www.openstreetmap.org/copyright.
Typesetting: Nova Techset Private Limited, Bengaluru & Chennai, India.
Subscriptions can be purchased from Cambridge University Press and online at https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/
antiquity/subscribe
Antiquity remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in maps supplied by authors.
Cover. Results of a terrestrial laser scanning survey of intertidal structures in the Léguer Estuary, Brittany, France. The images show an
axonometric view of the stone-paved trackway leading to the fishweir at Petit Taureau: (top) a terrestrial laser scanning DEM, with
photographic imagery draped over it, and (bottom) with the intensity of return draped over it. The intensity of return shows the sand
(in yellow and red) burying the lower part of the trackway where it enters the tidal frame (image by M. Lobb; for further details, see
the full article by Lobb et al. in this issue on `An estuarine tidescape of production: terrestrial laser scanning of fixed fishing structures
and a tide mill in the Léguer Estuary, Brittany’).

https://doi.org/10.15184/aqy.2020.181 Published online by Cambridge University Press

 Volume 94 Number 377 October 2020

Guest Editorial 1127

Paromita Bose, Sutonuka Bhattacharya, Prachi Joshi, Mokshada Salunke &
Chintan Thakar

Research Articles
Who painted that? The authorship of Schematic rock art at the Los Machos 1133
rockshelter in southern Iberia
Francisco Martínez-Sevilla, Meritxell Arqués, Xavier Jordana, Assumpció
Malgosa, José Antonio Lozano Rodríguez, Margarita Sánchez Romero,
Kate Sharpe & Javier Carrasco Rus
No pottery at the western periphery of Europe: why was the Final Mesolithic 1152
of Britain and Ireland aceramic?
Ben Elliott, Aimée Little, Graeme Warren, Alexandre Lucquin,
Edward Blinkhorn & Oliver E. Craig
Migrations or local interactions? Spheres of interaction in third-millennium 1168
BC Central Europe
Jan Kolář
Death is not the end: radiocarbon and histo-taphonomic evidence for the 1186
curation and excarnation of human remains in Bronze Age Britain
Thomas J. Booth & Joanna Brück
The agroecology of an early state: new results from Hattusha 1204
Charlotte Diffey, Reinder Neef, Jürgen Seeher & Amy Bogaard
Phoenician lime for Phoenician wine: Iron Age plaster from a wine press at Tell 1224
el-Burak, Lebanon
Adriano Orsingher, Silvia Amicone, Jens Kamlah, Hélène Sader &
Christoph Berthold
Make a desert and call it peace: massacre at the Iberian Iron Age village of La 1245
Hoya
Teresa Fernández-Crespo, Javier Ordoño, Armando Llanos & Rick J. Schulting
Summary justice or the King’s will? The first case of formal facial mutilation 1263
from Anglo-Saxon England
Garrard Cole, Peter W. Ditchfield, Katharina Dulias, Ceiridwen J. Edwards,
Andrew Reynolds & Tony Waldron
Constructing and deconstructing the Gokstad mound 1278
Rebecca J.S. Cannell, Jan Bill & Richard Macphail

https://doi.org/10.15184/aqy.2020.181 Published online by Cambridge University Press

 An estuarine tidescape of production: terrestrial laser scanning of fixed fishing 1296
structures and a tide mill in the Léguer Estuary, Brittany
Michael Lobb, Tony Brown, Jules Leyland, Vincent Bernard, Marie-Yvane Daire
& Loïc Langouët
What’s that smell? New directions for materials studies 1314
Sarah Newstead & Tânia Manuel Casimiro
Sherds as archaeobotanical assemblages: Gua Sireh reconsidered 1325
Aleese Barron, Ipoi Datan, Peter Bellwood, Rachel Wood, Dorian Q Fuller &
Tim Denham
The future of archaeology, interdisciplinarity and global challenges 1337
Sarah Kerr

Debate Article
Pathways to past ways: a positive approach to routeways and mobility 1349
Martin Bell & Jim Leary

Reviews

Review Articles

An ode to conference proceedings from the U.S. Southwest 1360

SCOTT G. ORTMAN
Life beyond the boundaries: constructing identity in edge regions of the North
American Southwest
Karen G. Harry & Sarah Herr
Interaction and connectivity in the greater Southwest
Karen G. Harry & Barbara J. Roth
Communities and households in the greater American Southwest: new perspectives
and case studies
Robert J. Stokes

Archaeologies of dispossession: removal, resettlement, community formations 1363

THERESA A. SINGLETON
The archaeology of northern slavery and freedom
James A. Delle
The archaeology of removal in North America
Terrance Weik

Book Reviews

David Miles The land of the White Horse: visions of England 1367
RICHARD BRADLEY

https://doi.org/10.15184/aqy.2020.181 Published online by Cambridge University Press

 Greg Woolf The life and death of ancient cities: a natural history 1369
MICHAEL E. SMITH
María Cecilia Lozada & Henry Tantaleán Andean ontologies: new 1371
archaeological perspectives
LAURA PEY
Mark Gillings, Piraye Hacıgüzeller & Gary Lock Archaeological spatial 1373
analysis: a methodological guide
EVAN I. LEVINE
Caroline Wickham-Jones Landscape beneath the waves: the archaeological 1375
investigation of underwater landscapes
ASHLEY LEMKE
R.N.E. Barton, Abdeljalil Bouzouggar, Simon N. Collcutt & 1378
Louise T. Humphries Cemeteries and sedentism in the later Stone Age of
NW Africa: excavations at Grotte des Pigeons, Taforalt, Morocco
TIM REYNOLDS
Brais X. Currás & Inés Sastre Alternative Iron Ages: social theory from 1380
archaeological analysis
TOM MOORE
Clairy Palyvou Daidalos at work: a phenomenological approach to the study of 1382
Minoan architecture
QUENTIN LETESSON
Kathryn Weedman Arthur The lives of stone tools: crafting the status, skill, and 1385
identity of flintknappers
ANDERS HÖGBERG
New Book Chronicle 1387
CLAIRE NESBITT

Corrigenda
Early commensal interaction between humans and hares in Neolithic northern 1395
China—CORRIGENDUM
Pengfei Sheng, Yaowu Hu, Zhouyong Sun, Liping Yang, Songmei Hu,
Benjamin T. Fuller & Xue Shang
From pack animals to polo: donkeys from the ninth-century Tang tomb of an 1396
elite lady in Xi’an, China—CORRIGENDUM
Songmei Hu, Yaowu Hu, Junkai Yang, Miaomiao Yang, Pianpian Wei, Yemao
Hou & Fiona B. Marshall
Archaeological evidence of early settlement in Venice: a comment on 1397
Ammerman et al. (2017)—CORRIGENDUM
John Meadows, Nicoletta Martinelli & Luigi Fozzati

https://doi.org/10.15184/aqy.2020.181 Published online by Cambridge University Press

 Project Gallery on the website (http://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/antiquity/
project-gallery)
The Palaeolithic stone assemblage of Kota Tampan, West Malaysia
Hsiao Mei Goh, Noridayu Bakry, Mokhtar Saidin, Shaiful Shahidan,
Darren Curnoe, Chaw Yeh Saw, Zainal bin Ariffin & Yeng Meng Kiew
The Early Upper Palaeolithic bone industry of the Central Altai, Russia: new
evidence from the Kara-Bom site
Natalia E. Belousova, Alexander Yu. Fedorchenko, Evgeny P. Rybin,
Maxim V. Seletskiy, Samantha Brown, Katerina Douka & Tom Higham
The Early Upper Palaeolithic in the south Judean Desert, Israel: preliminary
excavation results from Nahal Rahaf 2 rockshelter
Omry Barzilai, Emil Aladjem, Maayan Shemer, Rami Zituni,
Noam Greenbaum, Elisabetta Boaretto & Nimrod Marom
Early agricultural colonisation of peripheral areas of loess uplands: new data
from Sandomierz Upland, Poland
Marcin Szeliga, Radosław Dobrowolski, Przemysław Mroczek, Jacek
Chodorowski, Mirosław Furmanek, Irena Agnieszka Pidek, Maria Lityńska-
Zajac̨ , Daniel Makowiecki, Katarzyna Gawryjołek-Szeliga, Piotr Bartmiński,
Marcin Siłuch & Piotr Demczuk
More Bronze Age less bronze: copper axes in the late Bronze Age hoard from
Karmin, Poland
Justyna Baron, Marcin Maciejewski, Beata Miazga, Kamil Nowak & Dawid Sych
The origins of low-fire polychrome glazed pottery in China
Yulai Chen, Rui Wen & Tianyi Wang

https://doi.org/10.15184/aqy.2020.181 Published online by Cambridge University Press