Professional Documents
Culture Documents
WEF Global Lighthouse Network Adopting AI at Speed and Scale 2023
WEF Global Lighthouse Network Adopting AI at Speed and Scale 2023
Network:
Adopting AI at
Speed and Scale
WHITE PAPER
DECEMBER 2023
Images: Getty Images, Unsplash
Contents
Executive summary 3
Contributors 39
Endnotes 41
Disclaimer
This document is published by the World Economic Forum as a contribution
to a project, insight area or interaction. The findings, interpretations and
conclusions expressed herein are a result of a collaborative process facilitated
and endorsed by the World Economic Forum but whose results do not
necessarily represent the views of the World Economic Forum, nor the entirety
of its Members, Partners or other stakeholders.
© 2023 World Economic Forum. All rights reserved. No part of this publication
may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, including
photocopying and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system.
Executive summary
The World Economic Forum’s Global
Lighthouse Network has grown nearly
tenfold since its founding, with each cohort
defining manufacturing’s leading edge.
Each of the first three industrial revolutions now networks. Then they power the engine with
had a defining breakthrough: steam-powered delivery capabilities – talent, agile,1 technology
mechanization, electricity-powered mass production and data – and keep it well-oiled with ecosystem
and computer-powered automation. It is now collaborations that support learning and innovation.
clear that machine intelligence, powered by Steering requires effective change management;
unprecedented access to terabytes of data, defines for this, Lighthouses often deploy a strong
the Fourth. With newfound capabilities to automate transformation office.
and optimize critical trade-off decisions, AI is rising
into the role of conductor, orchestrating an ensemble Early AI pilots were often developed at the process
of Fourth Industrial Revolution technologies to a step level, where scope was smallest, risks
symphony of unprecedented results. were lowest and iterations were fastest. Today,
Lighthouses’ capabilities have accelerated AI well past
Five years into the Global Lighthouse Network, pilots: the 200-plus mature AI use cases implemented
more than 700 proven Fourth Industrial Revolution by Lighthouses span every process step.
use cases – 200 of which involve advanced AI
techniques – prove Lighthouses are past pilots. Lighthouses are also democratizing AI with
The new focus is tackling the “Scaling Slump”, the “assetization”, the art and science of packaging
natural adoption slowdown beyond the learning use cases for speed and scale of deployment.
curve’s “false peak”, when some companies balk Some have used toolkits to fully deploy AI use
at the potential costs of replicating single-site cases in just days and weeks, not months and
approaches across entire networks. years. These include modular code packages to
ensure interoperability with existing technology,
Lighthouses, though, are pushing through. Some productivity tools such as no-code platforms
82% are focused on designing for scale from day to accelerate deployment and digital upskilling
one, with immediate aspirations for dozens, even materials to ensure adoption.
hundreds, of implementations. They are treating
entire factories, not individual use cases, as the new AI “command centre” approaches – which connect,
“pilot”, seeking tenfold the transformation impact control and respond to disruption across collections
and nearly double the return on investment of of individual processes – are increasingly common
single-site approaches. in Lighthouses. They are powered by “cognitive
automation”: the ability to automate complex
The capabilities Lighthouses have built to speed trade-off decisions, bringing them a step closer
past pilots are the same ones they are extending to human on the loop instead of in it. The job of
as they drive towards scale. First, they set tomorrow’s operator will be to do the tasks of
the GPS: designing an effective strategy and today’s technician.
roadmap for value capture across factories and
Today, the GLN is a globally recognized community Factories at the Fourth Industrial
transforming factory and value chain operations
with Fourth Industrial Revolution technologies.
Revolution’s leading edge
Each member is indisputably a leader in its
respective industry. To reflect this, the GLN has The GLN is proud to welcome its 2023 cohort
assembled an advisory board to help steer the of 21 Lighthouses, 16 of which are Factory
network’s future direction. Lighthouses, and five of which are E2E Value
Chain Lighthouses (see Appendix). In addition, four
The latest cohort represents the leading edge of the Sustainability Lighthouses have been recognized
Fourth Industrial Revolution; this paper introduces for their outstanding use of technology to reduce
these vanguard Lighthouses and explores how their environmental footprint on top of their prior
they have progressed beyond pilot purgatory and Lighthouse designations (see Appendix). These
embarked on the steep journey of scaling. latest additions offer a glimpse into the future
of advanced manufacturing and value chains;
together, they comprise the leading edge of the
The Global Lighthouse Network Fourth Industrial Revolution. The main trends
among them include an unprecedented level of
today: 153 lighthouses digital maturity, the rapid proliferation of machine
intelligence and transformation programmes that
The GLN has grown almost tenfold since its execute at-scale deployments from the outset.
inception, from 16 to 153 Lighthouses. Each is
recognized for its leadership in using advanced
technologies and approaches to drive growth,
improve resilience and deliver environmental
sustainability. Ninety-nine are Factory Lighthouses,
driving transformations within the four walls of a
particular production site, while 54 are End-to-
End (E2E) Lighthouses, deploying technologies
for impact across their value chains; 17 are
also Sustainability Lighthouses, demonstrating
exemplary use of technology for emissions, waste
and water reductions.
14
2
12
6 3
3
2 5
9 4
10 31
1
3 13 32
16 8
1
1 7 11
30 33
2 5 41
34 35
3 15 29 36 40
3
4 23 24 1 2 37 38
39 23 24
1
25
26
27
28
4
Previous Lighthouse
5 New Factory Lighthouse New End-to-End4(E2E) Lighthouse New Sustainability Lighthouse
5
2 10 2 2
Agilent Technologies Hengtong Alpha Haier Schneider Electric
Waldbronn, Germany Suzhou, China Qingdao, China Hyderabad, India
Medical equipment Optoelectronics Home appliances Electrical components
3 11 3 3
AMOREPACIFIC Ingrasys Johnson & Johnson Siemens
Osan, South Korea Taoyuan, Taiwan, China Xi'an, China Chengdu, China
Cosmetics Electronics Pharmaceuticals Industrial automation
4 12 4
Aramco K-water Kenvue
Yanbu, Saudi Arabia Hwaseong, South Korea Shanghai, China
Oil and gas Water Self-care products
5 13 5
CATL LONGi Unilever
Liyang, China Jiaxing, China Sonepat, India
Electronics Renewable energy Food products
6 14
CITIC Pacific Special Mondelēz
Steel Jiangyin, China Beijing, China
Steel products Food products
7 15
CR Building Materials ReNew
Tech Tianyang, China Ratlam, India
Cement Renewable energy
8 16
GAC AION New Energy VitrA Karo
Guangzhou, China Bozüyük, Turkey
Automotive Building materials
Source: Global Lighthouse Network Global Lighthouse Network: Adopting AI at Speed and Scale 6
1 The Fourth
Industrial Revolution
inflection point
Manufacturers face a new narrative
as rapid technology breakthroughs,
changing people dynamics, escalating
geopolitical tensions and accelerating
climate change have uncovered global
supply-chain vulnerabilities.
To be ready for future disruptions and withstand Geopolitical changes have enabled advanced
shocks, manufacturers are boosting investment manufacturing to flourish in markets where, only
in artificial intelligence (AI) technology, sustainable 30 years ago, stagnation was the norm. Growth
energy and other technological innovations. Some in the United States’ manufacturing sector, for
90% of senior executives report that increasing example, had been languishing in a 1.4% growth
supply-chain resilience is a priority, and annual rate over the past two decades.4 Now, AI, digital
AI investments have reached around $150 billion technologies, sustainable features and higher skill
– all while supply-chain leaders have invested sets among advanced manufacturing and supply
in advanced analytics to connect data more chains have reinvigorated the market: in the past
effectively.2 Preparation for uncertainty has become five years, industrials in the USA have generated
an industry norm, with executives expecting the total shareholder returns about 400 basis points
impact of disruption to increase by between 15 and higher than in the previous 15 years.5
25% over the next five years.3
Source: McGrath, Rita, “The Pace of Technology Adoption Is Speeding Up, Harvard
Business Review, adapted by the Global Lighthouse Network; World Economic Forum,
Unlocking Business Model Innovation through Advanced Manufacturing, January 2022
Machine intelligence is to the Fourth Industrial But to serve this function, AI requires petabytes
Revolution what the steam engine was to the (PB) of data generated and collected from
first: the defining breakthrough that enables – and enterprise systems, machine sensors, connectivity
is enabled by –numerous other technological infrastructure and the workers themselves. AI’s
advances. Much as steam enabled the impact of meteoric rise in manufacturing has in part been
new piston and condenser designs, intelligence enabled by manufacturers’ newfound capabilities
is empowering flexible robotics and autonomous to generate and connect data at an unprecedented
vehicles. A rapid changeover, for example, requires scale. For some Lighthouses, terabytes – or even
a symphony of solutions: flexible robotics to handle petabytes – of new data can be generated weekly,
different products; automated guided vehicles and sometimes more. Section 3 of this paper will
(AGVs) to reload material; 3D printing to customize explore the reach and impact of mature AI across
line fixtures; and wearables to give critical alerts today’s Lighthouses.
to managers and technicians. In this symphony
As Lighthouses prove impact with an increasing new use cases, including AI use cases, with
number of advanced use cases, they have a scale in mind from day one.7 They are past the
decreasing need for pilots and proofs of concept “learning curve”, and are no longer experimenting
(POCs) of advanced technologies. Take AI, for with individual use cases. Instead, they are using
instance. It has enabled over half of all “top” factories as pilots – showing greater ambitions,
use cases from the past three Lighthouse scaling the Fourth Industrial Revolution across
cohorts, up from just 10% across the first three. entire production networks and, in some cases,
Correspondingly, 82% of Lighthouses design entire organizations.
“Scaling Slump”
Pilot purgatory
The adoption of transformative technologies is Implementation is getting faster, too. The last three
accelerating, with Lighthouses focusing not just Lighthouse cohorts implemented use cases 26%
75%
of Lighthouses can
on one factory but on 10 to 50 at a time. And the
business impacts of scaled transformation will
shape manufacturing’s competitive landscape, with
faster than the first three, and 75% of Lighthouses
report they can now deploy a new advanced
use case in less than six months. Even more
now deploy a new companies experiencing improvements in cost, impressively, 30% said they can do so in less
advanced use case
in less than six quality, service, agility and sustainability that are than three months. When compared with the
months orders of magnitude beyond what can be expected 10–20 months it took Lighthouses to implement
from single-site transformations, driving a maturity their first few use cases, it becomes clear that
chasm between those doing and those still learning. technology adoption is self-perpetuating – the more
that companies do it, the faster they get. With this
This maturity chasm is evident in the wake of recent comes an increased agility to respond to disruption,
disruption and volatility. Consider that 85% of which is one reason for the increasing performance
Lighthouses saw revenue reductions of less than gap between leaders and laggards.11
10% during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic;
this was true for only 14% of other manufacturers.
Lighthouses could react quicker: though they faced Choose a way forward: innovate,
the same supply-chain risks, 65% of Lighthouses
were already dual-sourcing and increasing inventory
accelerate or follow fast – but don’t lag
by 2022, while only 24% of other companies were.10
There is one fatal response to industry acceleration:
doing nothing. As Lighthouses and an increasing
The foundations for speed number of their peers achieve network-level
impacts to make better products more efficiently, a
and scale: strategy, capabilities strategic response becomes increasingly important.
and adoption Laggards don’t often survive.
Lighthouses have crossed the maturity chasm An effective response can take many forms. When it
with clear business strategy, a capability- comes to choosing a network-level digital strategy, a
centric approach to people and technology and company can choose to be an innovator – an industry
effective change management. They rarely invest groundbreaker that bets on and proves at the factory
in technology for its own sake, ensuring clear level the next big technology, catapulting past today’s
business value from every use case. They are also leaders. Lighthouses have historically taken this role.
patient in the formative years of transformation – Alternatively, a company might take the path of an
typically anticipating between 10 and 20 months industry accelerator – concentrating on network-level
for use case implementation, with a payback period impact, raising the bar for the whole industry. Many
of around two and a half years. It is a long time Lighthouses are increasingly focused on becoming
horizon, but the returns are worth it – Lighthouses’ accelerators. Finally, there are fast followers,
Fourth Industrial Revolution use cases have which use the playbook written by innovators and
averaged between two and three times return accelerators, capturing sufficient value with few of the
on investment within three years and between learning curve’s costs. All 10 million-plus of the world’s
four and five times return on investment within factories, large and small, can learn from Lighthouses
five years. to become Beacons for the Fourth industrial Revolution.
Source: Global Lighthouse Network Global Lighthouse Network: Adopting AI at Speed and Scale 11
2 Capabilities power
Lighthouses up the
adoption curve
When technologies reach a certain
maturity, the next challenge becomes
speed and scale – when factories and
entire supply networks, not use cases,
become the pilots.
With scale, the concept of a use case no longer nearly two times that of single-site transformations,
involves one implementation but rather dozens driven by cost and scale synergies and the
– or even hundreds. The transformation impacts comparative reduction – or even elimination – of the
increase tenfold, and return on investment grows to need to pilot new technologies.
Lighthouses, like digital leaders in other industries,12 with a clear, scalable and distributed architecture
have driven themselves up the adoption curve for easy provision of digital services and solutions;
with a six-part approach to site transformation: and (5) a data architecture and governance to
first they (1) set the strategy. Then they build enable critical decisions and ensure quality, easy
delivery capabilities across (2) talent, (3) agile, (4) consumption and reuse. And no less critical to its
technology and (5) data. Finally, they (6) implement function is the motor oil: ecosystem collaborations
change management. keep the engine purring as universities, technology
providers, innovation incubators, public entities
They are now adapting this approach for network and many others shape best-in-class capabilities.
and organizational scale (see Figure 5). It can be Each Lighthouse in this recent cohort has listed
likened to driving a car. an ecosystem collaboration as a key enabler of its
Fourth Industrial Revolution journey.
They first set the (1) strategic roadmap: the GPS
guides the transformation towards an organization But capabilities alone are not enough. Whether
reimagined with technology, and the route set at the site or network level, adoption and
prioritizes and sequences the value at stake – scaling is ensured through (6) effective change
including across use cases (at the site level) and management: the steering wheel. This often
factories (at the network level). includes a transformation office, which nearly 70%
of Lighthouses cite as the most critical of the six
They then build the delivery capability, which is the (see Figure 5).
engine that powers transformation. The engine
parts – its pistons, crankshafts, drivetrain and These six enablers are tried and true for digital and
timing belt – are: (2) programmes to hire, train and analytics transformations across industries.13 And
retain digital talent; (3) an agile operating model Lighthouses’ early approaches to scale demonstrate
that fosters speed, quality and collaboration, often that they are true for manufacturers, too.
including digital studios; (4) a technology backbone
Strategic roadmap: to align the senior leadership team on the transformation vision, value and roadmap and reimagining
1 business domains to deliver outstanding customer experiences and create competitive distance
Strategy
Identify desired value to be captured from transformation Create strategy to scale value, identifying whether
to sequence deployment as technology-led,
Prioritize and plan which use cases will deliver said value
capability-led or one-at-a-time
Talent: to ensure you have the right skills and Agile operating model: to increase the metabolic rate of the
2 capabilities to execute and innovate
3 organization by bringing business and technology together
Perform gap analysis Create enterprise-wide Create agile squads aligned Implement matrix
to identify additional talent strategy, including to use cases organization structure
skills required plan to systematically
hire/train new profiles Source talent from the right Align internal (e.g. P&L
Train colleagues in digital sources (e.g. corporate, performance) and
roles to perform Provide performance vendor, site) to staff external (e.g. supplier
capability-building activities incentives to ensure cross-functional teams delivery) organizational
morale and motivation and roles (e.g. business, IT, incentives
engineering)
Technology: to allow your organization to more easily Data: to enrich and make data easy to consume across
4 use technology to innovate with pace 5 the organization to improve customer experiences and
business performance
Design to integrate within Develop vendor Drive strategy for master Build reusable data
existing systems ecosystem strategy data identification and products and IT/OT
integration across service models for scale
Strategize to minimize Standardize reference corporate IT, OT and
migration downtime and architecture for vendor systems Host master data in cloud
major redeployments interoperability to accelerate analytics
Embed3 data/analytics and deployment
DevSecOps for critical using integration platforms
software projects
Adoption and scaling: to maximize value capture by ensuring the adoption and scaling of digital and analytics solutions, by
6 building new skills and leadership characteristics and by tightly managing the transformation progress and risks
Change mgmt.
Enact site-level transformation office with corporate Implement enterprise transformation office led by
sponsorship chief experience officer (CxO)
Administer role modelling, following top-down Create strategy to disseminate change story
strategy, beginning with site leadership throughout organization
Notes: 1. “Factory to network” enablers are typically built on top of “pilot to factory” enablers; 2. Featured company case examples are from the 11th Lighthouse
cohort; 3. Embed within the platforms in which data/analytics are used.
Source: Framework developed in Rewired: A McKinsey Guide to Outcompeting in the Age of Digital and AI; manufacturing-specific insights curated by Global
Lighthouse Network
Set the strategy hundreds of examples, three have stood out as
Companies must first understand why, what particularly effective: technology-led approaches
and how to transform before taking action to focus on deploying one technology or use case at
accelerate. This comes in the business strategy a time across numerous factories simultaneously;
and road-mapping phase: identifying, prioritizing capability-led approaches are often driven by a
and capturing pockets of value that support overall capability-focused centre of excellence (CoE) that
business priorities. Leaders must understand how proactively identifies and pushes digital innovations
the product will produce meaningful value; what from one site to another; and “build and replicate”
key performance indicators (KPIs) are explicitly to approaches involve the deployment of people
be improved; if the plan sufficiently accounts for and capabilities to one site at a time. In this most
network-wide capabilities; what the time frame is; recent wave, new CATL and Johnson & Johnson
and how change management will be incorporated. Lighthouses were propelled by their organization’s
broader digitalization strategies. Tata Steel, with
This requires careful consideration of the industry, Lighthouses from past cohorts, is the network’s
the size and diversity of the production network prime case study for the “build and replicate” scaling
and the available IT infrastructure. While these strategy. All powered their respective strategies with
tailored approaches have taken many forms across talent, agile, technology and data capabilities.
CoE
Deploys single use cases across hundreds CoE proactively identifies, packages and Champions site transforms first then
of production lines simultaneously scales use cases across sites (e.g. replicated one at a time (Netherlands site
(e.g. AI for energy optimization) energy optimization use case at 32 sites) led two India sites – all are now Lighthouses)
Roll-out from central technical organization CoE holds key digital capabilities and Chosen because all plants are large and
(e.g. “Intelligent Manufacturing Department”) resources – a first call for sites to share best operate similarly – today ~80% of total
practices and receive implementation support production comes from a Lighthouse site
Standardized approach enabled by strong
central IT network and similarity of Sites “pull” from CoE for specific use case
production lines across factories customizations and missing site capabilities
Build deployment capabilities: talent, agile, universities, innovation centres and technology
technology and data partners – to lubricate and maintain the engine for
If the strategy is the GPS and change management sustainable performance.
is the steering wheel, then deployment capabilities
are the engine that powers the transformation: Though no manufacturers have yet achieved full
a high-quality talent bench; an agile operating network or organizational scale with Fourth Industrial
model that fosters speed and customer-centricity; Revolution technologies, multiple Lighthouses have
technology platforms that enable distributed made early but important advances, with best practices
innovation; and data that is high quality and in line with those in other sectors. The remainder of this
consumable. Like a good car engine, the best- section explores these early glimmers – a starting point,
performing capabilities are not built alone; it takes but not yet a playbook, for manufacturers aspiring to
an ecosystem of strategic partnerships – with scale impact to network level in the coming years.
New technologies,
Impacts behavioural science advances
30+
certified for lean and
digital proficiencies
Value-based certifications
Certifications
Mobile learning
980+
trained
Forums Workshops Toolboxes and microlearning
to LEARN
Measurement and 80-150%
Feedback behavioural nudges improvement on
Coaching Boards Groups assessments
to GROW
Fieldwork Reflection
Growth-
planning
Learning
projects
Personalization 1,500+
evaluated
to APPLY
The ReNew Digital (ReD) Team was key to accelerating and scaling digital transformation Use cases from
ReNew Ratlam
30+ data scientists
and engineers 5 or 6 agile squads
simultaneously active
cluster deployed
rapidly and at scale
34% 75%
Ratlam site
Clear unplanned major field
Senior Cross-
ownership maintenance failure rate
leadership functional
and decrease decrease
engagement teams
incentives
70+ 1,500+
Scale
wind farms turbines
Reports to chief digital Involves multidisciplinary Operates with separate
officer for sponsorship site team during every P&L, funded based on
and alignment stage of digital value delivered from
transformation digital projects
Technology: Ingrasys sets the Ingrasys demonstrates the benefits of starting small
but with a clear plan for growth. Manufacturing
stage for vendor collaboration servers require a significant number of black-box
vendor technologies, and Ingrasys addresses this
A technology backbone equips organizations with clear design principles and requirements for
with the infrastructure to deploy new use cases vendors that enable security and scale. This requires
and capture business value. Often leaders believe most, if not all, of their vendors to open up firmware
a single tech change is the best start to Fourth for data and controls accessibility, to design
Industrial Revolution transformation. However, data outputs to mesh with Ingrasys technology
starting small works only with an integrated plan infrastructure and to collaborate for customized
for growth from day one, because fragmentation developments and win-win solutions. In one case,
often stunts growth. That’s why, even as AI an automated optical inspection (AOI) vendor
and other technologies continue to evolve, collaborated on a new, physical IT / OT plug-in or
Lighthouses emphasize accessible and adaptable “media link” on the machine, enabling Ingrasys to
data environments with decoupled architecture deploy an in-house-developed AI inspection model,
solutions (e.g. microservices) for flexibility and augmenting the pre-existing vendor solution. That
scalability alongside high-productivity development vendor is now offering this “bring-your-own AI” as a
environments and tools. service solution to customers.
94%
root cause analysis
time reduction
Active approach to Accelerate AI maturity In-house, custom AI models
moving AI to full through strong developed by on-site analytics teams,
automation in-house capabilities ensuring data security and rapid
training iterations
48%
labour productivity in
quality testing
FIGURE 10 The four service layers underpinning CR Building Material Tech’s data platform
Impact
24/7
continuous highly reliable
35
sites and multiple business
50%
improvement in digital
operating environment for units with standardized, use-case deployment
critical functions (e.g. energy accessible, secure data speed
management, PM planning)
Having explored how Lighthouses have achieved all Revolution – has been infused into Lighthouses’
that they have, it’s time to focus on what lies ahead. operations and how it will supercharge existing
The next section of this paper will examine how technologies to unlock previously unattainable
AI – the defining element of the Fourth Industrial advancements for the entire manufacturing sector.
Machine
intelligence robots, AGVs and drones, and 3D printing
ac
t
These technologies are maturing rapidly as AI is advancing to impact quickly, and is only
companies improve the “confidence intervals” on speeding up. Manufacturers no longer need
AI’s predictions and recommendations. In some to ponder whether it’s possible or impactful.
cases, confidence in these models exceeds the Lighthouses have already proved that. Instead,
confidence in planners or operators, demonstrating they need to focus on the risks, regulations and
that true decision automation is imminent. complexities of responsible AI implementation
Mondelēz’s baking facility and K-water’s sanitation – a critical topic worthy of its own publication.
process provide two glimpses of what this can look Lighthouses are not immune to these risks, and
like, where front-line workers are more technicians they have not been cavalierly bullish. They have
than machine operators, engaged on the loop taken measured approaches, ensuring they have
instead of in it. the expertise, systems and leadership to reap the
benefits of AI responsibly.
If the rapid adoption of GenAI in banking and
technology is anything to learn from, it’s likely that
– for Lighthouses, at least – impact at a factory
Early applied AI pilots were developed at the planning: Ingrasys deployed an AI-demand
process-step level, where the scope was smallest, forecasting model that uses past data to train the
risks were lowest and iterations were fastest. model; this has delivered 27% more accuracy in
As such, it is only natural now that over 80% of just three years. Or process optimization, where
Lighthouse use cases involving AI are likewise Hengtong Alpha Optic-Electric automatically
executed at the process step level. What’s notable, optimizes preform and drawing parameters with
though, is that AI is having significant impact a model trained on past strategies. Or quality,
at every supply-chain process step – including where VitrA Karo deployed computer vision in its
planning, asset management, quality and delivery. kiln, which decreased the scrap rate by 68%. Or
delivery, where CR Building Materials Tech has
The most recent cohort of Lighthouses adaptively optimized heavy transport equipment
demonstrates this breadth and diversity. Consider routes to decrease pickup lead times by 39%.
Supply-chain planning
Agilent uses supplier information to predict material availability, enabling
10–20%
proactive response to SC risks
Ingrasys uses order history and market data to predict orders more
inventory decrease accurately than provided forecasts
Supply-chain management
Unilever automated inventory replenishments based on the previous
10–20%
day's sales, stock targets, capacity constraints, etc
Johnson & Johnson identifies and mitigates SLOB1 risks by using AI to
supplier service automate data analysis and recommend actions
level increase
Production scheduling
ACG Capsules optimizes its production schedule with a novel
10–20%
on-time-in-full
colour-matching AI and validates it with a digital twin
GAC AION achieves automatic scheduling across 100K+ configurations,
enabling plan-driven resource distribution
increase
Process optimization
CITIC Pacific Special Steel deploys AI across furnace, rolling and
40–140%
throughput increase
cooling steps for special high-mix, small-batch products
Hengtong Alpha uses past strategies to inform parameter optimization
of preform and drawing processes
Asset management
10–30%
OEE increase
Aramco predicts the remaining useful life of reactors to minimize
corrosion and optimize maintenance
CATL implemented factory-wide predictive maintenance to optimize
maintenance plans based on real-time data
Assembly
30–40%
labour productivity
Haier optimizes the allocation of production capacity and resources with
AI to match personnel skills with processes, equipment and materials
increase
Delivery
Notes: 1. Slow-moving and obsolete; 2. Root cause analysis; impacts are averages across all Lighthouses in the 11th cohort.
Achieving the impacts the new Lighthouses did approach: high AI performers are now 1.6 times
– with 20%, 40% or even 60% improvements more likely than other organizations to create AI
across critical KPIs such as throughput, quality applications using emerging low-code or no-code
and delivery performance – has required them to programs, allowing them to speed up the process
scale past pilots and POCs to full implementation of development even further.14
of use cases across every machine and production
line. Some undertook their own four- or five-year Agilent, a life science equipment manufacturer
journeys to pilot, learn and scale new technologies in Waldbronn, Germany, not only developed a
and use cases. Others – such as CATL in Liyang, computer vision use case that achieved a 40–50%
China, Unilever in Sonepat, India, and Johnson & defect rate reduction but also assetized it. It built
Johnson in Xi’an, China – were able to draw on the an in-house, ready-to-deploy AI solution library for
experiences of their company’s other Lighthouse detecting anomalies and responding to process
sites to design for scale from day one. They deviations, bundling computer vision tools with
applied advanced AI and other technologies across plug-in connectors to MES and test software and
numerous processes, skipping the steep learning packaging with SOPs, user documentation and
curve that the earliest Lighthouses had no choice training guides for operators. This democratization
but to overcome. of computer vision technology empowers
technicians – not just engineers – to identify, deploy
One of the ways in which today’s Lighthouses and test new camera and vision applications
have sped past pilots is with a strategic focus end to end. This enabled Agilent to deploy five
on “assetization”: that is, the art and science new applications across 57 work centres and 16
of packaging use cases for speed and scale of product lines in less than four months.
deployment. Other industries are also taking this
+49%
defect rate reduction
5–10 days
average time
Solution library User guides Training to implement
Product variation detection Model self-training instructions Retrofitting for production engineers
5 use cases
deployed in 4 months
using 10 camera arrays
Agilent’s computer vision toolkit enables speed and scale through democratized access
to advanced vision capabilities
Autonomous Operations
AutonomousCommand
operationsCenter ‘Lights-out’ Baking baking
“Lights-out”
command centre workshop
Workshop
Three tiers
to decision
autonomy
Process step Local AI models for optimal pump and peak power control across Local AI models across all 9 dough-making process steps to ensure
optimization 14 process steps ( e.g. chemical, mixing) consistent texture (e.g. mixing, fermentation)
E2E operations AI autonomous operation across all water treatment steps Digital lean manufacturing management system oversees all dough-
command centre making steps
Intelligent Autonomous analysis of sensor data to schedule optimal PM Self-adjustment of 50+ critical parameters related to 20 defect types
troubleshooting (e.g. filtration, disinfection) (e.g. biscuit inspection)
Generative AI is expected to add between $2.6 and domains. First, enabling people productivity in
$4.4 trillion in annual value to the global economy16 manufacturing and supply chains – these pilots
– nearly a quarter of which could be productivity include GenAI-powered technician advisers and
improvements of up to two times and task SOP-instructing chatbots. Second, accelerating
automations of nearly 70% across manufacturing digital capability-building – including through
and supply chain-related activities, primarily driven innovations in data management and software
by new capabilities in content generation, insights development co-pilots, personalized trainers and
extraction and user interaction.17 assessors for operators, and team assistants for
agile squads. These kinds of use cases could
What could these groundbreaking capabilities enable robust digital transformations to happen
mean for manufacturing operations? Consider faster than the two-or three-year sweet spot
the hypothetical wind turbine engineer case maintained by conventional wisdom.
(see below). This is the vision that Ni Jun, Chief
Manufacturing Officer of CATL, laid out in this year’s The greater the quantity and quality of data across
Lighthouses Live. the value chain, the more effectively an organization
can tune its GenAI models to be useful. And for
Lighthouses have realized this potential and companies willing to be creative, this data can
are bringing GenAI to areas where data is most take many forms – such as potential transcripts of
unstructured. This includes product development conversations between technicians and operators,
and procurement-related activities (such as which contain valuable insights.
the turbine example), along with two additional
GenAI and engineering design: a hypothetical improvement and one compliance issue. The
engineer engages a “design adviser”, which
A first-year engineer asks GenAI to mock up a 3D references past company designs and even web-
model showing some changes to his company’s scraped customer reviews, to generate iterations.
newest wind turbine blades. He then uses After a few hours of back and forth, the engineer
the platform to coordinate dozens of analytic has a high-quality, cost-optimized and fully
simulations employing applied AI models. The simulated design that is as good as, if not better
platform generates a report of potential product than, those produced by his more seasoned peers.
performance, documenting two areas for design
“Discover” new products Pre-screen, summarize Provide insights into “Technician adviser” to
(e.g. new chemicals, and extract clauses of inventory health and troubleshoot
circuit designs) interest drivers of ageing
Automate process failure
Accelerate/simulate Generate category Automate supplier risk analysis
testing phases strategies with external analyses
sources Co-pilot for SOPs,
Predict product market Chatbot for real-time performance reports,
fit with consumer Role-play negotiations supply-risk action training aids
insights and prepare scenarios planning
Optimize traditional part Automate document
+3 +2
designs (e.g. component generation (RFPs,
weight) contracts) additional additional
Create supplier
performance reports
+4 additional
+4 additional
Analyse and screen Personalized and Data and technology Talent and organization
carrier shipment terms to interactive e-commerce Accelerate software Self-serve HR (e.g.
enhance negotiation pages generation (co-pilot) automated onboarding)
Generate and verify Synthesize info for Dynamic security scans Recruiting co-pilot (e.g.
required documents for pricing decisions (e.g. to stabilize and develop job descriptions)
transportation competitors' prices) accelerate code
maintenance Generate one-off/
Interactive virtual Review transcripts and customized learning
assistant to augment coach call-centre agents scenarios
driver services (e.g. voice
Provide step-by-step
+2
navigation)
instructions to customer
+1
to self-diagnose issues additional
additional
+1 additional
+4 additional
Enablers
The Global Lighthouse Network aspires to represent Applications to join the 12th cohort of Lighthouses will
leading companies that choose to chart their close on 26 January 2024. Details can be found on
course following one of these strategic responses. the Global Lighthouse Network website.
Enthusiastic, forward-thinking innovators,
accelerators and fast followers are invited to learn
more by emailing LighthouseNetwork@weforum.org.
ACG Capsules To stay ahead of the curve in an intensely Real-time quality batch
39% Batch lead time
competitive market, pharmaceutical supplier ACG insights
Pithampur, India
Capsules prioritized manufacturing superior-
quality products, improving responsiveness, ML-powered first-time-
35% First-pass yield
increasing production yields and enhancing right optimization
workforce productivity. To achieve this, ACG
Capsules implemented 25+ Fourth Industrial Digital twin-powered
Revolution use cases powered by the industrial On-time delivery
production planning and 13%
internet of things (IIoT), machine learning (ML), in full
scheduling
deep learning (DL), digital twins, extended reality
and generative AI. Effective adoption of these Virtual reality (VR)-based
use cases has resulted in a reduction in critical Worker onboarding
workforce augmentation 39%
defects of 98%, a shortening of production lead time
and skill management
times of 39%, a drop in total losses of 51% and a
44% rise in workforce productivity. Deep learning-driven
Safety incident
safety management and 53%
rate
behaviour detection
AI-powered fault
Packaging line
detection in packaging 344%
productivity
lines
CITIC Pacific Special To meet the fast-growing global demand for Big data-powered
New product
Steel customized steel products while navigating customized design 57%
design time
volatile raw material and energy-supply issues, process
Jiangyin, China CITIC Special Steel’s Jiangyin Xingcheng plant
deployed 40+ Fourth Industrial Revolution use Blast furnace “black box
Operation
cases such as advanced analytics-powered transparentizing” with 85%
downtime
process simulation and optimization, as well as multimodal data
AI-enabled energy management. As a result, the
plant has been able to increase customized orders Intelligent closed-
by 35.3%, reduce its non-qualified product rate by Increased field
loop control-enabled
47.3% and cut its energy consumption by 10.5% 240% performance of
continuous quality
per tonne of steel. steel
improvement
Advanced analytics-
Average energy
powered sustainability 11%
consumption
optimization
CR Building To address the requirements of green and low- Smart mining operations
CO2 emissions
Materials Tech carbon development, higher quality expectations with AI and autonomous 68%
from mine trucks
and cost pressures, Tianyang site, a cement driving
Tianyang, China factory under China Resources Building
Materials Technology Holdings, has deployed AI control and
Coal consumption
30+ Fourth Industrial Revolution use cases with optimization for key
11% per tonne of
advanced analytics, autonomous driving and cement production
product
IIoT to improve energy, labour and equipment processes
efficiency and quality performance. As a result,
the site has reduced carbon emissions by 24%, Intelligent equipment
increased labour productivity by 105%, reduced Unplanned
maintenance and 56%
unplanned downtime by 56% and improved quality downtime
scheduling
consistency by 25%.
AI-enabled closed-loop Customer reject
87%
quality control rate
Smart microgrid
Energy
for sustainable 48%
consumption
manufacturing
Knowledge graph-
Mean time to
enabled expert system for 67%
repair (MTTR)
performance inspection
Hengtong Alpha Facing higher cost pressures as well as quality ML for product quality
61%
Optical parameter
Optic-Electric and green production expectations from prediction defect rate
the international market, Hengtong Alpha
Suzhou, China accelerated the large-scale application of AI- and vision-based
advanced analytics, machine vision and AI preform outer diameter 35% Processing speed
technology across 27 advanced use cases optimization
covering the whole production value chain. As a
result, unit manufacturing costs have decreased Ultra-high speed drawing
by 21%, the defect rate has reduced by 52% 67% Operators per line
control model
and unit power consumption has fallen by 33%.
ML-powered fibre
Fibre breakage
breaking prediction 26%
frequency
model
Optimized testing
Units per person
with AI-based data 39%
per hour (UPPH)
inheritance
AI-powered automated
Overall equipment
assembly and testing 42%
effectiveness (OEE)
workshop
Digital lean
Unplanned
manufacturing 49%
downtime
management system
Intelligent production
19% OEE
control tower
Haier In order to stay ahead of the industry on cost and One-click should costing
21%
Material cost per
address common problems of unprofessional and optimization unit
Qingdao, China
and delayed services in the home-appliance
industry, Haier deployed 136 Fourth Industrial 5.5G-enabled intelligent Material shortage-
80%
Revolution use cases for procurement cost in-plant logistics based downtime
savings and improvements in productivity and
quality of services, using technologies including IIoT-based optimization of
5.5G, advanced algorithms and ready-to-use 33% Labour productivity
final assembly efficiency
digital twins. This initiative has resulted in product
cost being optimized by 32%, labour productivity Intelligent repair
increasing by 36% and the service complaint rate request matching and 88% Speed to repair
being cut by 85%. autonomous dispatching
Johnson & Johnson To improve agility and responsiveness, raise quality Digital twin-enabled
34% Cycle time
standards and enhance competitiveness, Johnson smart technical transfer
Xi’an, China
& Johnson Xi’an replaced its manual facility
with a Fourth Industrial Revolution-enabled new Intelligent automation-
Batch non-
factory in 2019. This facility includes digital twins powered batch execution 60%
conformance
for technology transfer and material handling, excellence
intelligent automation of continued process
verification (CPV) and batch execution processes. Autonomous continuous Time to detect
This has shortened the product transfer time by 92%
process verification variation
64% during site relocation and has enabled a 60%
decrease in non-conformance, while improving Digital twin-powered Finished goods
productivity by 40%, operating costs by 24% and 100%
material handling inventory footprint
GHG emissions by 26%.
Intelligent supply chain Slow-moving
81%
control tower Inventory
Unilever To improve agility and cater to diverse product Digital twin for green fuel
88%
Boiler GHG
segments, reduce costs in an inflationary flexibility in boiler emissions
Sonepat, India
environment and improve sustainability, Unilever
Sonepat implemented 30+ Fourth Industrial IIoT-enabled spray dryer Process labour
93%
Revolution use cases in its E2E supply chain. Top digital twin productivity
use cases included boiler and spray dryer process
twins, as well as customer data-informed no-touch Cognitive automation for
production planning and inventory optimization. 18% Service levels
supply resilience
This improved service by 18%, forecast accuracy
by 53%, conversion cost by 40% and Scope AI-powered real-time Finished goods
1 carbon footprint by 88%. The use of biofuels 23%
inventory optimization inventory
enabled by a boiler process twin also supports
livelihoods for local farmers. Predictive asset
56% Maintenance cost
maintenance
Sustainability Lighthouses
Johnson & Johnson To address growing energy demands while Digital twin-enabled
32% GHG emissions
reducing its environmental impact, Johnson & adaptive process control
Xi’an, China
Johnson Xi’an constructed a state-of-the-art
manufacturing site. To meet and surpass its LEED Detergent
Intelligent cleaning 72%
Gold® certification, it implemented a series of consumption
Fourth Industrial Revolution technologies, including
AI algorithms for process control, IIoT-based
intelligent cleaning and digital twins. This has Advanced analytics-
resulted in a 47% reduction in material waste, powered batch release 63% Hazardous waste
a 26% decrease in GHG emissions and a 23% for waste reduction
reduction in energy consumption.
Enno de Boer
Senior Partner and Global Head Operations
Technology, McKinsey & Company
Federico Torti
Initiatives Lead, Advanced Manufacturing
and Supply Chains, World Economic Forum
Acknowledgements
Global Lighthouse Network Project Team Petra Monn
Head International Operations – Manufacturing,
Siemens; Project Fellow, Centre for Advanced
Veronique Adenis Manufacturing and Supply Chains,
Director, E2E Performance Design and Deployment, World Economic Forum
Johnson & Johnson; Project Fellow, Centre for
Advanced Manufacturing and Supply Chains, Amy Mun
World Economic Forum Digital Transformation Manager, Henkel; Project
Fellow, Centre for Advanced Manufacturing and
Henry Bristol Supply Chains,World Economic Forum
Engagement Manager, McKinsey & Company;
Project Fellow, Centre for Advanced Manufacturing Benjamin Schönfuß
and Supply Chains, World Economic Forum Initiatives Specialist, Centre for Advanced
Manufacturing and Supply Chains,
Eric Enselme World Economic Forum
Executive Fellow, World Economic Forum
Jagadeesh Tambi
Baoyang Jiang Smart Operations & Innovation Director, Schneider
Director, Industrial Artificial Intelligence Products Electric; Project Fellow, Centre for Advanced
Technology Services Group, Foxconn Industrial Manufacturing and Supply Chains,
Internet; Project Fellow, Centre for Advanced World Economic Forum
Manufacturing and Supply Chains,
World Economic Forum Federico Torti
Initiatives Lead, Centre for Advanced Manufacturing
and Supply Chains, World Economic Forum
Production
Bianca Gay-Fulconis
Designer, 1-Pact Edition
Alison Moore
Editor, Astra Content
The team would like to thank Paul Cumbo of PJC Editorial, external writer and editorial consultant,
for drafting this paper.