Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ed 3601 Unit Plan Assignment
Ed 3601 Unit Plan Assignment
Ian Snyder
Through an examination of Spanish and Aztec societies, students will demonstrate an understanding and appreciation of how intercultural contact affects
the worldviews of societies.
To what end does the differing worldviews result in the eventual domination of one group over the other?
Colonialism
Contact
Worldview
Expansion
Knowledge:
8.3.4: assess, critically, how the Aztecs were affected by the Spanish worldview by exploring and reflecting upon the following questions and
issues:
o What were the key elements of the worldview of the Aztec civilization prior to contact with the Spanish? (TCC, I, CC)
o How did the Aztec civilization’s worldview influence the Aztecs’ choices, decisions and customs? (TCC, CC, PADM)
o What key elements of Spain’s worldview led to the desire to expand the Spanish empire? (TCC, I, PADM)
o In what ways did factors such as technology and disease contribute to the dominance of the Spanish over the Aztec civilization?
(ER, LPP)
o To what extent were the divergent worldviews of the Spanish and Aztecs factors in the dominance of one nation over the other?
Attitude:
8.3.1: appreciate how a society’s worldview influences the society’s choices, decisions and interactions with other societies.
8.3.2: appreciate how Aztec and Spanish identities and worldviews were affected by intercultural contact.
8.3.3: appreciate and recognize how rapid adaptation can radically change a society’s beliefs, values and knowledge.
of a topic or an issue.
o evaluate ideas, information and positions from multiple perspectives.
1
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
o determine how information serves a variety of purposes and that the accuracy or relevance of information may need verification.
o organize and synthesize researched information • formulate new questions as research progresses.
o demonstrate the advanced search skills necessary to limit the number of hits desired for online and offline databases; for
example, the use of “and” or “or” between search topics and the choice of appropriate search engines for the topic.
o develop a process to manage volumes of information that can be made available through electronic sources.
o elicit, clarify and respond appropriately to questions, ideas and multiple points of view presented in discussions.
Rationale:
This unit is taught because it gets students to think about the worldviews and perspectives of relatively unfamiliar people and understand why their views,
beliefs, traditions, and way of life are different from what they consider “normal.” Moreover, students will view the contrast between Spanish and Aztec ideals and then
realize how the difference in cultures can change, mold, adapt, or transform entirely after the point of contact to create new cultures and identities. Whether that is a
positive or negative consequence is something for the students to discuss, but that is one piece/question that can be asked that can assess their ability to think critically
Social studies at the grade eight level addresses the themes of citizenship and identity through the study of ancient cultures, how they interacted with each
other, and how they interacted with foreign worldviews. The latter is emphasized in the Aztec section of the course. Furthermore, the core concepts are interwoven
throughout the units as they aim to inspire students to consider what influences both an individual and a societal worldview through the common thread of intercultural
contact and the unfortunate results of expansionist cultures in some cases. The Aztec unit allows students to study what it means to be a citizen and have an identity in a
non-colonial society and then see how those systems flourished, were challenged by, and ultimately undermined by Spanish encroachment. The unit asks students to
consider Aztec perspectives through studying their worldviews and their reactions to the events that unfolded. Moreover, the debates through an Aztec lens allow
2
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
students to begin to inquire what the Aztecs might have thought either after the sighting of a comet or the contact with the Spanish, and how to proceed. Additionally,
with our connection to the Indigenous peoples of Canada, students can also reflect on how similar colonization efforts the Aztecs experienced were also experienced by
Our inquiry question revolves around the idea of colonization and the legacy it leaves. A notion we thought about was the fact that first-world or
“developed” nations look down upon third world/undeveloped” nations frequently. With this in mind, we asked “Is this treatment justified? If so, why?” in order to
assess why the Spanish Conquistadors wanted to expand into modern-day Mexico and subsequently infringe on another culture, and if so, why they justified in doing so
or why aren’t they? To do this, we built lessons from the perspective of the Spaniards and the Aztecs to understand both of their cultures and the differences existing
between them. The more in-depth we went, the more differences arose, and so did the conflict and the need for there to be a conqueror/a victor of said conflict.
The two main skills we are looking to develop in this unit are that of critical/creative thinking and the research process. In regard to critical/creative
thinking, we are invoking these skills by taking students through various formative assessments such as KWL charts, Exit slips, and an ongoing timeline assignment
which also works as an assessment AS learning. Some summative assessments attending to these skills include a Compare and Contrast activity and a summative
performance task. The skills of the research process are being developed all throughout the unit through various assessments where we ask students to investigate
certain aspects of Spanish and Aztec perspectives. In our intro lesson, we provide them with resources to use that will help them form concepts about each group and
then give them a basis of their knowledge to move off of. Various resources are still going to be included in the assessment to be used such as the Timeline assignment,
the C&C, and the performance task, and the summative tasks also give room for students to find their own resources and materials in addition to the ones provided for
them.
We are assuming that students already have knowledge of the various Indigenous interactions with colonial perspectives and the circumstances that
resulted from those encounters. If there are any Hispanic students in the class, repeatedly calling on them would be an easy way to single them out, rather we could
approach the topic of cultural perspectives and norms as a broad invitation to have everyone talk about the norms of their cultures. Similarly, another consideration
would be if there are any Indigenous students in this class to also not single them out in our conflict lessons when comparing the experiences of the Aztecs to those of
One example of a formative task we have in this unit would be to have a “Monopoly” day. Based on the board game and the idea that Aztecs were very
driven by accumulating wealth and crops through market trading similar to a farmers’ market, we would have a day where students participate in a class market by
trying to sell/trade/profit off of a certain item that would be assigned to them. Prior to this, the idea of this market would be taught to them so there is an understanding
3
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
of participating in this beforehand. This idea ties in Math ideas as well as Financial Literacy as Math deals heavily with the monetary values of products (and is a real-
world skill to hone) and having Financial Literacy be a background piece to a formative piece such as this would be a great way to teach students how to be smart with
their money (even if it is just a simulated way to go about it) and not simply spend it without thinking. Since the two main chapters of the unit closely resemble the
factions of the British/French exploration into Canada, many connections can and will be made to the Canadian treatment of Indigenous peoples.
4
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
Learning Assessments
Outcomes
Title Debate Timeline KWL Chart Exit Slips Mind Map Indigenous Peoples Compare “Would it Fly?” “In-class Monopoly”
and Contrast
5
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
This formative assessment activity can be used in the beginning of a new topic to gauge where students are at in
their knowledge. Additionally, it provides the teacher avenues with which they can move their lessons in based on
KWL Chart about the Aztecs FOR
what their students would like to know. Before beginning the unit with the Aztecs, students can make their own
KWL chart. The chart will be revisited throughout the unit, and again at the end.
Students will fill in their own timelines with important dates (i.e., Spanish Contact, Fall of Tenochtitlan) throughout
Timeline of events the unit to create a comprehensive timeline of events from the late 1400s to the 1520s. This can become a tool to AS
help plan for summative assessments. Students will hand the timeline in at the end of the unit.
The exit passes will be used throughout the unit to gauge where students are at in their learning. Passes could range
Exit Slip from material retention to asking a question they have after a lesson. Surveys at the bottom of the pass will be used FOR
to indicate to the teacher how the student feels about their understanding of the given material.
This will be an activity done fairly early in the unit where students will be presented with what constitutes a
“worldview” and then will be asked to (either on blank paper or a laptop/tablet) make a mind map with what their
Mind Map worldview comprises. This is a good way to get the students thinking of how worldviews influence what people FOR
believe and how they behave and get them to consider that people have different worldviews from their own which
influence what they believe, do, and value.
For this topic, we will ask students to use the information they know, as well as do research, to compare and
contrast the situations of the Aztec people in modern-day Mexico to that of the Indigenous peoples of Canada, and
how each of their treatments was similar or different. This assessment will start with them utilizing their prior
knowledge in each case, and then they will be given time to research more knowledge of both occurrences, whether
Compare and Contrast OF
that be going through past materials or doing online research. This assessment will look similar to a Venn Diagram
where students list the similarities in the middle of the page/assessment and list the differences under each unique
event. Students should be able to analyze how each situation was different due to geography, the opposing forces in
Monopoly/Trade activity Since Aztec culture was largely based around market trading, we will do an activity where students take on the role FOR/AS
of traders, attempting to trade and distribute whatever resource or good(s) they have been assigned. The goal of this
is to get them to become traders in the classroom and to accumulate as much wealth through monetary value/goods
collected throughout the activity. To do so, they will be trying to accumulate wealth by buying resources that will
help to get them rich and sell their own so that they can combine the wealth to become “richer” than others. Getting
students involved in this activity demonstrates how easy it is for some people to lose all their resources quickly,
whereas some people emerge as those who are savvy and succeed mighty and shows how some people were
6
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
This will be used as a primer for the final performance task as well as seeing how an Aztec society would come
together to solve pressing issues, like the encroachment of the Spanish. Each pod of desks could symbolize a city
Debate state and they could produce their position as a pod and present it to either the other city-states or the absolute ruler FOR/AS
(Montezuma II and his council of nobles). The ruler and his constituency could either be several students randomly
drawn from a hat or the ruler could be the teacher as an easier way of assessing the information and arguments
forwarded by the students.
This unit project is meant to assess the student understanding of the unit. The project itself serves as an opinion
piece but requires careful research and relevant information to be provided in whatever format the student chooses
to state their opinion. Several planning sheets, like the “Cause and Effect” sheet below would be included, relevant
Would it Fly? OF
websites students could look at, and examples that emphasize the differing importance of events we want students
to decipher while simultaneously justifying their placements. Differentiation may look like students going with an
EA and having the EA record their answers (if the student has difficulty writing) as an example. Another example
Would it Fly?
The History Channel is developing a new DVD documentary series Would it Fly? One of the episodes examines the Spanish conquest of the Aztecs. The series seeks to
examine the question: “Would what happen with the Spanish and the Aztecs “fly” today?” As in, would the actions committed be acceptable today?
In order to feature a number of different perspectives, they have sent out a call for proposals to various history classes. As a social studies student, you have been asked
to prepare a submission on behalf of your class.
To complete your submission, you will need to do the following.
Access and Retrieve Information
Create a graphic organizer that will assist you in gathering information answering the question, “would it fly?”
●
As you conduct your research, be sure to cite the sources you are using.
●
Choose your events and fill out the “Cause & Effect” sheet below.
●
7
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
9. The Spanish begin to rebuild Tenochtitlan, but rename it Mexico City, the capital of New Spain (1522)
●
10. The Twelve Apostles arrive to convert the natives to Christianity (1524)
●
Be sure to include reasons for each that clearly state your position. This should include the following:
●
A rationale for why you chose each event and the cause and effect of each one (on the cause-and-effect sheet provided below).
●
Answer the question of “Would It Fly?” and why or why not. To answer this question, list your provided events on a chart and assign a score to each event.
●
If you feel as though the event will “fly,” give it a positive score out of 5. If you feel it would not “fly,” give it a negative score out of 5. See the “Would It Fly?” chart
below to view how to approach this part of the assignment.
Communicate Information
Share your findings in a way that will appeal to the producers. Your submission may take the form of a storyboard planner, a written script, an oral
●
presentation, or a multimedia presentation. If you have any other forms you would like to present it with, let the instructor know.
Your submission needs to inspire the History Channel producer to select your work for the streaming series. They have given you 2 weeks from today (and 2 class
periods) to work on this project. Your name will appear in the credits, so be sure to do your best work!
The Event, the Cause, and the Effect (Would it Fly? Planning)
This blueprint sheet will help with your planning process for you Would it Fly? project. It will help you solidify your argument as well as let you know if you are on the
right track so you can start your research. You will give this completed sheet to a peer for feedback and eventually your instructor at the end of the corresponding work
period for approval. The first row is filled out as an example of what to do.
Smallpox Outbreak (1520) Spanish men unintentionally bring Death of many Aztecs because their The textbook.
diseases from Spain they are immune immune systems could not counter
to because they have had time to the effects of the disease.
adapt.
8
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
Criteria
Access and retrieve Accesses and retrieves in- Accesses and retrieves Accesses and retrieves Accesses and retrieves No score is awarded because
information. depth and pertinent substantial and relevant cursory and basic incomplete and superficial there is insufficient evidence of
student performance based on the
(8.S.7) information. information. information. information.
requirements of the assessment
task.
State and defend a position. Provides compelling Provides convincing Provides predictable Provides inconclusive
(8.3.1, 8.3.4) evidence to defend selected evidence to defend selected evidence to defend selected evidence to defend selected
positions and oppose the positions and oppose the positions and oppose the positions and oppose the
other positions. other positions. other positions. other positions.
Communicate information. Communicates information Communicates information Communicates information Communicates information
(8.3.2, 8.S.8) in a convincing manner. in a persuasive manner. in a simplistic manner. in an ineffective manner.
9
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
Through an examination of Spanish and Aztec societies, students will demonstrate an understanding and
appreciation of how intercultural contact affects the worldviews of societies.
8.3.1 Students will: Compare the differing views that may have led to conflict.
appreciate how a society’s worldview influences the society’s choices, decisions and
interactions with other societies
8.3.2 Students will: Evaluate the factors that led to the dominion of the Spanish over the
appreciate how Aztec and Spanish identities and worldviews were affected by Aztecs.
intercultural contact.
8.3.3 Students will: Analyze how the intercultural contact between the Spanish and the
appreciate and recognize how rapid adaptation can radically change a society’s beliefs, Aztec contributed to differing beliefs, values and worldviews.
8.3.4 assess, critically, how the Aztecs were affected by the Spanish Evaluate important events that led to the dominion over the Aztecs.
and issues:
o What were the key elements of the worldview of the Aztec
8.S.1: Students will: Analyze the actions of the Spaniards and the choices made by the
develop skills of critical thinking and creative thinking: Aztecs to interact with the Spanish. Additionally,
10
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
an issue.
evaluate ideas, information and positions from multiple perspectives.
issue.
generate creative ideas and strategies in individual and group activities ¾
8.S.7: Students will: Retrieve and incorporate visual, and electronic sources to support their
apply the research process: position.
integrate and synthesize concepts to provide an informed point of view on a
research.
draw conclusions based upon research and evidence.
demonstrate the advanced search skills necessary to limit the number of hits
desired for online and offline databases; for example, the use of “and” or
“or” between search topics and the choice of appropriate search engines for
the topic.
develop a process to manage volumes of information that can be made
topic.
make connections among related, organized data, and assemble various
regarding an issue.
Lesson Overviews
11
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
Objectives
This takes us to the body of the lesson, where we give a brief description of the Spaniards and the
Aztecs, displaying some similarities and differences between them. After this brief description, we will
guide the students through how to conduct research and give them resources on where/how to find
more information on the Spanish and Aztecs. In doing this, we will also prepare them for the next
activity, which is the compare and contrast concept formation, where we will give the students
artifacts from both groups and ask them to identify which group, they think each image belongs to. We
will first use a pop culture example using props from Star Wars to get them to think about how they
can approach this, what kind of questions they can ask and how they can potentially identify the group
that each item belongs to.
To wrap the lesson up, we will go over the artifacts as a class, and ask the students their reasoning for
grouping all the items together the way they did. When providing the answers, we will give them
details that show to us why each item belongs in each category and how that can inform us when
looking at historical artifacts of these two groups. After going through that, we will ask students to
complete the Wonder (W) and Learned (L) section of their KWL charts to display what they knew
before, what they wonder going forward and what they have learned in this lesson.
12
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
Activity
This activity will involve the students taking some time to fill out a worldview map. An example
worldview map will be on the board courtesy of the instructor, and students will then be given time to
consider what comprises their worldviews, make their map, and then we will do a “stack and pack”
where students will all get up, wander the classroom hopefully to find some people they have not
talked to very much, and then discuss what they came up with on their worldview maps. This is to
introduce the idea that even the people next to them have different views of the world and that it is
okay. People value different things, and it should be cherished. After they have discussed their
worldviews to each other, we can either come together as a class to discuss each person’s worldview
map or just discuss some common elements or unique features of worldviews students might be
willing to share.
13
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
take on the role of traders, attempting to trade and distribute whatever resource or good(s) they have
been assigned. The goal of this is to get them to become traders in the classroom and to accumulate as
much wealth through monetary value/goods collected throughout the activity. To do so, they will be
trying to accumulate wealth by buying resources that will help to get them rich and sell their own so
that they can combine the wealth to become “richer” than others. Getting students involved in this
activity demonstrates how easy it is for some people to lose all their resources quickly, whereas some
people emerge as those who are savvy and succeed mighty and shows how some people were affected
14
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
the desire to expand was further expansion and the allure of treasures, we continue to take on a Spanish perspective of these ● laptops
the Spanish empire? events. While trying not to become too sympathetic with the colonial perspective, this is still a way to
(8.3.4.3) scaffold into our activity where students would think and analyze what people on this voyage would
need and why exactly they would take what they did.
compare and contrast the situations of the Aztec people in modern-day Mexico to that of the
Indigenous peoples of Canada, and how each of their treatments was similar or different. This
assessment will start with them utilizing their prior knowledge in each case, and then they will be
given time to research more knowledge of both occurrences, whether that be going through past
materials or doing online research. This assessment will look similar to a Venn Diagram where
students list the similarities in the middle of the page/assessment and list the differences under each
unique event. Students should be able to analyze how each situation was different due to geography,
the opposing forces in each situation, the peoples of each occurrence and notable figures.
15
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
list of reasons the empire collapsed as a class (e.g., military struggles, disease, economic/political
weakness, etc.). Students will then be assigned one of the categories, do their own
investigations/research online or in the textbook, and then be placed into different groups for a total of
two rounds, then those students will become “experts” in their categories and then will be able to teach
the different categories what they researched and what arguments they have. Then we will bring it all
together as a class at the end.
In this performance task we are asking students to take on the role of a researcher trying to find
information for the History Channel and whether or not significant events that transpired between the
Spanish and the Aztecs would “fly” today (i.e., be acceptable).
Resources:
Books:
16
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
Hall, Eleanor J. Life Among the Aztecs. Thomson Gale, San Diego, Calif, 2004.
o Many of the chapters in this book provide foundational information on the formation and structures of Aztec civilization. Along with the
information, it also has several pictures that help to visualize Aztec religion and customs. This would be a supplemental resource for teachers
to inform their teaching.
of pictures both from the current day and the past (mostly recreated by artists). This will help students to further visualize Aztec society as
well as the effects of Spanish colonization as many pictures of ruins are included.
Websites:
it should encourage students to find events they consider important and put it on their own timelines.
consider what a conquistador in the 14th century would bring to a destination they knew extraordinarily little about.
eventual downfall to the situations the Indigenous peoples of Canada have gone through.
will be encouraged to conduct their own investigations into the events that happened and become “masters” of their own learning by teaching
what they found to their peers.
conflict is about. This resource references a different activity, but it, much like other resources on this site, is useful for planning activities.
Videos:
and use the land as theirs is misplaced. This also serves as a jumping off point for the comparison between the Aztecs and Indigenous peoples
of Canada.
EAxW6FzQIHWSiBuwQtwJ6BAgXEAI&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv
%3DQRU8pucTvpw&usg=AOvVaw3RKzBxB97N95End37e8ugN&opi=89978449
o This video is a summarized version of the Aztec creation story where students can get a glimpse of Aztec culture and origin.
EAxXeHTQIHdQ4CVgQFnoECBMQAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.learnalberta.ca%2Fcontent%2Faswt
%2F&usg=AOvVaw3ghKKonOv5ZPj6H6DBPMwb&opi=89978449
o This website is an interactive website students can use to learn about Canadian indigenous stories and culture. This will be useful for our
connection classes.
Articles:
Smith, M. E. (1997). Life in the Provinces of the Aztec Empire. Scientific American, 277(3), 76–83.
o This article, and many of the other articles used provide supplemental information for the instructor to include. A recurring issue with the
Grade 8 textbook is the lack of information it has, so outside research is almost required. This article provides insight into the geographical
17
ED 3601 Unit Plan Dante Gentile
Ian Snyder
Burhenn, H. (2004). Understanding Aztec Cannibalism. Archive Für Religionspsychologie / Archive for the Psychology of Religion, 26, 1–14.
o This article delves into the complexities of Aztec religion, namely the ritual and importance of human sacrifice/cannibalism. This is a key
identifier of Aztec culture that is unfortunately not given much attention in the textbook.
Evans, Susan T. “The Productivity of Maguey Terrace Agriculture in Central Mexico during the Aztec Period.” Latin American Antiquity, vol. 1, no. 2,
Daniel, D. A. (1992). Tactical Factors in the Spanish Conquest of the Aztecs. Anthropological Quarterly, 65(4), 187–194.
o This is an article in which Daniel asserts some key contributions to the defeat of the Aztecs. It delves into more than a surface level understanding of why
they lost, with the article attributing some of the factors dating back to the time of contact.
18