Professional Documents
Culture Documents
USE OF Project Management Methodologies AND Project Risk Management IN THE Light OF Empirical Research
USE OF Project Management Methodologies AND Project Risk Management IN THE Light OF Empirical Research
Maciej Brzozowski
1 Poland, Poznań University of Economics and Business, Institute of Management
m.brzozowski@ue.poznan.pl; ORCID: 0000-0002-9651-2611
Abstract: The main purpose of the paper is to examine, on the basis of empirical research, the perceived manner
of project management in organizations, as well as to determine the frequency of application of selected project
management methodologies, in addition to the assessment of their usefulness for project risk management. The
first part of the paper presents - identified on the basis of literature studies - types and examples of project
management methodologies along with basic assumptions of the project risk management process, and in the
second part - the results of empirical research conducted by recourse to a questionnaire among the participants
of projects implemented in various types of organizations. The study showed that in organizations employing
respondents, the methodical manner of project management is most often used, while the most popular project
management methodologies were PMBoK, Agile and PRINCE2, wherein respondents highly rated the
usefulness of selected methodologies for effective project risk management.
Keywords: project management, project risk management, project management methodology
© UPH 2020 13
Brzozowski M., THE USE OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT METHODOLOGIES AND PROJECT RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE LIGHT
OF EMPIRICAL RESEARCH, Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Przyrodniczo-Humanistycznego w Siedlcach Nr 127,
Seria: Administracja i Zarządzanie (54) 2020
14
Brzozowski M., THE USE OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT METHODOLOGIES AND PROJECT RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE LIGHT
OF EMPIRICAL RESEARCH, Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Przyrodniczo-Humanistycznego w Siedlcach Nr 127,
Seria: Administracja i Zarządzanie (54) 2020
15
Brzozowski M., THE USE OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT METHODOLOGIES AND PROJECT RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE LIGHT
OF EMPIRICAL RESEARCH, Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Przyrodniczo-Humanistycznego w Siedlcach Nr 127,
Seria: Administracja i Zarządzanie (54) 2020
Fifthly, in most of the proposed procedures management in the organization, (2) identifying the
there is a lack of a separated implementation stage types of project management methodologies used,
of reaction to risk (i.e. it is not present in PMI (3) assessing the suitability of the applied project
standard). It may cause that the reaction to the management methodologies for effective project
evaluated risk will not be proper enough; it will lack risk management. Measurement of the analyzed
the determination and knowledge to implement it phenomena was carried out taking into account
in practice. The authors, whose procedures don’t the differences due to the financial sector. The
include the implementation stage probably source of the evaluation are the results of empirical
assume that the proposed reactions to risk will be research carried out with the use of the survey
implemented as a part of a general project questionnaire in 2016-2018. The scope of
management process (Hilson, 2009). empirical research included people declaring
The lack of serious reflections on the matter professional involvement in projects (subjective
of reaction to risk brings us to the sixth conclusion; scope of the study), conditions related to project
in the majority of the available literature on that management in organizations (factual scope of the
issue there are no guidelines as to how risk study), Wielkopolskie Voivodeship in Poland
management roles, tasks and responsibilities (territorial research scope) and the years 2016-
should be identified and divided among project 2018 (temporal scope of research). The size of the
team members. research sample was 384 observations, while the
selection of the sample was deliberate - the
Methodology selection criterion was the respondent's
declaration regarding professional work in
In order to achieve the research goal, three areas projects. The structure of the research sample is
of empirical research have been identified: (1) presented in Figure 1.
determining the perceived way of project
gender age
2016 34,9%
less than a year 15,7%
2017 32,6%
1 - 5 years 48,6%
16
Brzozowski M., THE USE OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT METHODOLOGIES AND PROJECT RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE LIGHT
OF EMPIRICAL RESEARCH, Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Przyrodniczo-Humanistycznego w Siedlcach Nr 127,
Seria: Administracja i Zarządzanie (54) 2020
Differences in the analyzed area can also be surveyed organizations from the IT sector, the
observed in terms of the sector of activity of the respondents declared that they did not use any
surveyed organizations (Table 1). The analysis of project management methodology. The sectors
the obtained results clearly indicates the IT sector where the application of methodological methods
as the one in which the use of project management of project management is the least frequent are
methodologies in the organization occurs most trade and services (respectively over 36% and
often - over 27% of respondents declared the use over 32% of indications for the random method of
of a comprehensive approach, over 30% of a project management). On the other hand, in the
differentiated methodological approach, and less production sector, the frequency of applied
than 41% of a partially methodical approach. This methodological methods of project management
means that in only slightly more than 1% of the should be assessed as average.
Table 1. Ways of managing projects in the organization in terms of the sector of the organization's operation
17
Brzozowski M., THE USE OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT METHODOLOGIES AND PROJECT RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE LIGHT
OF EMPIRICAL RESEARCH, Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Przyrodniczo-Humanistycznego w Siedlcach Nr 127,
Seria: Administracja i Zarządzanie (54) 2020
The second area of the research procedure results presented in Figure 3 indicate a clear
concerned the identification of examples of project dominance of three methodologies - PMBOK
management methodologies used in the (36.4% of indications), Agile (36% of indications)
organizations employing the respondents. The and PRINCE2 (35% of indications).
PRINCE 39,0%
35,0% 31,5% 34,0%
2
The final area of the research procedure which on the one hand confirms the growing
concerned the assessment of the usefulness of popularity of agile methodologies observed over
project management methodologies in the project the last 20 years and the still high rating of
risk management process (Fig. 4). The highest traditional methodologies (e.g. PMBOK).
average values were recorded for Agile Nevertheless, attention should be paid to the
methodologies (M = 3.34) and PMBOK (M = 3.08), relatively stable assessment of the usefulness of
18
Brzozowski M., THE USE OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT METHODOLOGIES AND PROJECT RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE LIGHT
OF EMPIRICAL RESEARCH, Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Przyrodniczo-Humanistycznego w Siedlcach Nr 127,
Seria: Administracja i Zarządzanie (54) 2020
agile methodologies in 2016-2018 and the 2018). The assessment of the usefulness of the
decreasing assessment of the usefulness of other project management methodologies
traditional methodologies, especially PMBOK (PRINCE2 and IPMA) in the project risk
(from M = 3.49 in 2016 to M = 3.10 in 2018) and management process is relatively stable (on
TenStep (from M = 3.16 in 2016 to M = 2.91 in average 3.00).
TenStep
3,00 2,91 2,90 3,16
Agile
3,34 3,29 3,29 3,45
5-point Likert-type scale: ① useless ② of little use ③ rather useful ④ perfectly matched ⓪ I don't know / hard to say
Figure 4. Assessment of the usefulness of project management methodologies in the project risk management process
Source: own calculation on the basis of research results.
The research results indicated that the management methodology is PMBOK (M = 3.46),
assessment of the usefulness of project in the manufacturing sector also the PMI
management methodologies in the process of methodology (M = 3.28), in the commercial sector
project risk management is different in terms of the the PMI methodology (M = 3.25) and Agile
sector of the organization's operation (Table 3). In (M = 3.27), while in the IT sector it is decidedly
the service sector, the most useful project agile methodologies (M = 4.22).
Table 3. Assessment of the usefulness of project management methodologies in terms of the sector
of the organization's operation
19
Brzozowski M., THE USE OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT METHODOLOGIES AND PROJECT RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE LIGHT
OF EMPIRICAL RESEARCH, Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Przyrodniczo-Humanistycznego w Siedlcach Nr 127,
Seria: Administracja i Zarządzanie (54) 2020
20
Brzozowski M., THE USE OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT METHODOLOGIES AND PROJECT RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE LIGHT
OF EMPIRICAL RESEARCH, Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Przyrodniczo-Humanistycznego w Siedlcach Nr 127,
Seria: Administracja i Zarządzanie (54) 2020
21