Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Catalogue of Ancient and Naked-Eye Comets
Catalogue of Ancient and Naked-Eye Comets
1. INTRODUCTION
One of the most complete surveys of the older records of comets and novae seems to be the
work by Pingr~ (1783). As to Chinese records, Pingr~ has used the texts translated by Jesuit
priests, Couplet, Gaubil and de Mailla. These texts are not free from mistakes in translations
The Chinese records of comets have also been collected and translated into European languages
by Biot (1846) and Williams (1871). Williams has collected records mainly from W~n Hsien
Thug K ~ o by Ma Tuan-Lin (1254), but Ma has made some mistakes in his compilation and
Williams himself has sometimes misunderstood Ma's texts. Baldet (1949) has compiled a
general list of comets from the works mentioned above. Recently, Hsi Ts~-Tsung (1955) and
Ho Peng Yoke (1962) have published new catalogues of Chinese comets and novae older than A.D.
1600, but they are also not quite complete.
The Korean observations of comets and novae from the ancient times to the 19th century have
been collected by R. Sekiguchi (1917). Ho (1962) has also collected Korean records
independently of Sekiguchi.
S. Kanda (1935, 1948 and 1960) has compiled Japanese astronomical records, and Kanda and Ohsaki
(1932) have collected some records in Ryukyu. Though Ho (1962) has translated some Japanese
records collected by Kanda briefly in his catalogue, the vast majority of almost all Japanese
records have not yet been translated into European languages.
Because it is rather difficult, when detailed descriptions are absent, to distinguish between
a star (nova) and a comet recorded from the ancient records, we do not reject the records of
the new stars from our catalogue.
For the use of statistical investigations of comets, we have compiled and added naked-eye
comets observed from A.D.1700 to our catalogue of ancient comets. The "naked-eye comet" here
means the comet which has become brighter than the sixth magnitude. When these so-called
naked-eye comets were treated with the ancient comets (observed by the naked eye), this
definition is to be discussed and examined more carefully.
59
60 I. Hasegawa
2. SOURCES
Chinese comet records before Ch'ing dynasty (early in the 17th century) have been compiled in
the Ku Chin Thu Shu Chi Chh~ng (1728). These records have been compared with Ho's catalogue
(1962) and checked with Ma Tuan-Lin's W@n Hsien Thung Khao (1254), Williams' catalogue (1871),
and the Chinese records collected by Pingr~ in his Com@tographie (1783). Records of comets
observed between A.D.1607 and 1771 in Ch'ing dynasty have been taken from the Ch'ing Shih Kao
(1928). Hsi Ts&-Tsung (1955) has compiled a new catalogue of novae and in his catalogue, as
Ho has already indicated (1962), some records of comets rather than novae are included.
Chinese records not included in Williams' and Ho's catalogues are translated into English and
given in the Notes of the Table I. Some remarks and revisions to Pingr~'s and Baldet's
catalogues and to Ho's catalogue are given in the Table 2 and Table 3 respectively.
The Chinese comet in 1231 given only by Gaubil is doubtful. Its orbital elements have been
calculated by Pingr&. This record seems to be constructed by the mixture of some different
comet records or meteors. As to the other doubtful records, the causes of misinterpretations
are assumed and given in the Notes of the Table I.
Dr. R. Sekiguchi, former director of the Tokyo Astronomical Observatory, has collected Korean
records of comets and novae dated from B.C.49 to A.D.1884 and published them in the Annals
of the Government Observatory of Korea (1917, 1918), and in the Astronomical Herald of the
Astronomical Society of Japan. Ho Peng Yoke also gives Korean records in his catalogue (1962)
In ancient times, some Korean records seem to be taken from the Chinese official chronicles.
Though they give almost the same texts as each other, we give these records in our catalogue
as the different observations recorded independently in China and Korea. There have to be
further investigations on these records.
S. Kanda (1935) has collected astronomical records in Japan from B.C.15 to A.D.1600 and
compiled (1960) a general list of comets observed in Japan from A.D.634 to 1862. Some comet
records not included in Kanda's collection (1935) have been found later by Kanda (1947). In
addition, we have collected a few comet records from Shiryo Sohran (The General Materials in
Japanese History)j compiled by the Historiographical Institute, Tokyo University.
Astronomical records in Ryukyu have been collected by Kanda and Ohsaki (1932) and fifteen
comets from A.D.1664 to 1862 have been included.
Most of the European records have been collected by Pingr~ in his Com~tographie (1783), and
some other records are found in Chamber's catalogues (1889, 1890 and 1909) and in Baldet's
Catalogue of Ancient and Naked-Eye Comets 61
Liste G~n~rale (1949). Although the identification of comet records in Europe with those
recorded in Asia mentioned above are rather difficult, all of the records have been inspected
and checked, and then the identifications have been decided as shown in Table |.
The comets which have become brighter than the sixth magnitude have been taken from Vsekhsvy-
atskij's catalogue (1958), and from the report on comets for the Quarterly Journal of the
Royal Astronomical Society. Those comets observed from A.D.1701 to 1970 are given under the
other headings in Table I, which are expected to be useful for the surveys of the bright comets
observed from the early times to the present.
Comets and novae recorded from the year B.C.2314 to A.D.1700 are given in the first part of
the Table | under the following headings:
No: The reference number of the object in the Table |. The asterisk attached indicates
that the Notes are given at the end of the Table ].
Date of discovery: The first date of the observation. The dates before A.D.1583 are given in
the Old Style.
Region of apparition: The constellation, the direction, etc. where the object was seen for
the first time. If necessary, the location of the moon or a planet related to the
object are taken from Tuckerman's ephemerides (1962, 1964).
Country: The country or the district where the object has been recorded. The following
abbreviations are used:
C, China; E, Europe; J, Japan; K, Korea; R, Ryukyu.
References: The bibliographic reference in which the detailed records are given. The
abbreviations are as follows:
B, Baldet (1949); CI, Chambers (1889); C2, Chambers (1909); C3, Chambers (|890);
CS, Chin Shu (Histo~ of the Chin Dynasty); CSK, Ch'ing Shih Kao (History of the
Ch'ing Dynasty); H, Ho Peng Yoke (|964); HHS, Hou Han Shu (History of the Later
Han Dynasty); Hsi, Hsi Tsa-Tsung (|955); K, Kanda (1935); K2, Kanda (1947);
K3, Kanda (1960); KO, Kanda and Ohsaki (1932); MN, Monthly Notice8 of the Royal
Astronomical Society (the number i~dicates the volume); P, Pingr~ (1783);
S, Sekiguchi (1917); T, Ku Chin Thu Shu Chi Chheng (The Great Imperial Encyclopaedia);
W, Williams (|871).
The number following the abbreviation refers to the page and the one in parentheses
refers to the number of the record in the references. The volume number of Pingr~'s
Com~tog~/phi~ is omitted, and pages greater than 245 refer to the pages in the first
62 I. Hasegawa
Remarks: To the record which gives the details on the tail, the duration of apparition etc.,
the letter A is given. The classification of the object, such as nova, the name
of the periodic comet, etc. are also given.
No: The continuous number from the first part of the Table I. Number, Designation and
Date of the comet observed only in the southern hemisphere, not observed by the
naked eye in the northern hemisphere, are parenthesized.
Designation: The definitive Roman numeral is taken from Porter's (1961) and Marsden's (1966)
catalogue of cometary orbits. The preliminary number is given in the order of the
discovery.
Date of max. brightness: The estimated date of the maximum brightness is given.
Maximum brightness: The observed length of the tail from Vsekhsvyatskij's catalogue (;958)
is given.
Reference and remarks: These are the same as in the first part of the Table I.
3.3. Table 2
Remarks or revisions of Pingr~ (1783) and of Baldet (1949) are given. Date is the entry of
the record, and the other headings are self-explanatory.
3.4. Table 3
Table l (continued)
Table I (continued)
Table I (continued)
Table 1 (continued)
Table ] (continued)
Table l (continued)
Table I (continued)
Table 1 (continued)
Table | (continued)
J.P.v.^.24/1 E
72 I. Hasegawa
Table I (continued)
Table I (continued)
Table I (continued)
Table l (continued)
Table 1 (continued>
Table l (continued)
Table I (continued)
Table I (continued)
Table 1 (continued)
Table 1 (continued)
Table 1 (continued)
Table I (continued)
Table 1 (continued)
Table I (continued)
Table 1 (continued)
From No. 950 on Table 1 onwards, narrower linespacing has been used. This will also show up
any repetitions with the work of Pingr~, Baldet and Ho. In several cases the remarks will
supplement the notes of the preceding part of Table I. The following lists in narrow llne-
spacing therefore comprise: the remainder of Table 1 (which summarizes mainly the naked-eye
comets, which are today considered of no special importance), and the whole of Table 2 (p. 97)
and Table 3 (p. I01).
Perhaps on another occasion the author might provide a complete English translation of
Chinese and Japanese records on comets observed in the period 1601-1884.
Table 1 (continued)
Table I (continued)
Table l (continued)
Table I (continued)
Table 1 (continued)
Notes on Table I
2 Or in -2197 or -2284.
5 Or in -2284 or -2269 or -2225.
6 Or in -2024.
7 Or in -1920 or -1949.
8 Or in -1841.
I0 Jupiter was at Sgr in -1718.
12 Or in -1515.
16 Or in -1175.
i8 Probably in -1054.
24 Or in -618.
42 Pingr~ estimated very small q, perihelion to be in Vir and Lib, and i nearly 150 ° .
54 Single comet or two.
92 I. Hasegawa
Notes (continued)
Notes (continued)
529 The month misprinted in H(343). A Japanese record says, "A guest star was seen from SW
to NE". It seems likely to be a meteor.
535,536 A Japanese record says, "At 8 p.m., two comets were seen in NE and in SE (K491)".
575 A Korean record says. "Five comets each measuring 5 to 6 ft were seen".
586 The Korean says, "During thel llth month of the tenth year of Munjong a comet was seen
at the Chen (the 28th lunar mansion)".
587 Or in 1059.
590 The Korean says, "On a keng-hsu day in the fifth month of the 16th year of Munjong, a
comet appeared at the Ta-Chio and located at the Ti (the third lunar mansion)".
591 The Korean says, "On a i-chhou day in the seventh month of the 17th year of Munjong, a
comet was seen at the Ti (the third lunar mansion). Its tail was several ft in length".
592 The Korean says, "On a chi-ssu day in the tenth month of the 17th year of Munjong, a
comet appeared in the Thien-Shih, then moved to the Wei and the Chi (the sixth and t h e
seventh lunar mansions). Its size was like a measure (bowl)". The chi-ssu day was not
in the tenth month.
601 The Korean says, "On a ping-wu day in the ninth month of the 26th year of Munjong, a star
appeared. It was like fire, trespassed the Ying-Shih (the 13th lunar mansion)",
602 Ho gives an incorrect d a t e .
607 A Korean record says, ,'In the night of a ping-tzu day in the first month of the 34th
year of Munjong (1080 Feb. 5) a white vapour ran through from the Mao to the I and Chen
(the 18th, 27th, and 28th lunar mansions)".
609 Or in III0-II|I?
610 A Japanese record gives three comets.
623 The Korean gives a comet in Aug., and Pingre gives one in May.
625 A Chinese comet recorded by De Mailla (Viii 377, P391). is doubtful and likely to be
comet No.635.
626 A Japanese record says, "On the first day in the fourth month of the sixth year of the
Eikyu reign-period a comet was seen only on one night".
651 Or in 11677
656 A Japanese record gives the Chang (the 26th lunar mansion) for a location of the comet.
659 The Japanese says, "On the 30th day in the third month of the fifth year of the Bunji
reign-period a white vapour appeared in the sky and pierced the Big Dipper. Its length
was about 5 ft".
660 A Japanese record says, "On the 18th day in the tenth month of the third year of the
Kenkyu reign-period there were invocations for a comet".
662 Pingr~ gives a comet appearing in Sco in this year.
668 Pingr~ gives a comet appearing in May, 1211. A Korean record says, "In the evening of
a ting-ssu day in the fifth month of the seventh year of Hsi-jong (1211 June 18) a
white vapour appeared in the Hsing, Chang, I, Chen (25th, 26th, 27th and 28th lunar
mansions), Thai-Wei and Pei-Tou, then disappeared".
673 A comet of March 21 recorded in Korea is it seems another one, not the same as No. 672.
675 A Chinese record says, "On a keng-yin day in the third month of the 14th year of the
Chia-Ting reign-period (1221 Mar. 30) a comet was seen".
680 A Japanese record says, "On the 19th, 21st and 23rd day in the third month of the first
year of the Karoku reign-period (11225 Mar. 29, 31 and Apr. 2) a comet was seen".
685 Ho gives an incorrect date. Pingr~ gives a European record of June 3.
705 A Japanese record says, "On the 23rd day in the third month of the tenth year of Bun-el
reign-period (1273 Apr. 12) a guest star was seen in the NW". This star seems to be
not the same as comet No.704.
712 Pingr~ gives three comet records in 1294.
719 Ho gives no Japanese records. A Japanese record says, "In the morning of the 13th day
in the eighth month of the third year of the Shyoan reign-period (1301 Sept. 15) a
comet appeared at the E. Its rays was 3 ft over in length, becoming brighter and
extended to I0 ft in length".
722 A Japanese record says, "On the 13th day in the sixth month of the first year of the
Kagen reign-period (1303 July 27) a comet was seen in the NE. It was about 1 ft in
length, white in colour". Pingr~ gives a European record of a comet in autumn which is
uncertain.
723 A Japanese record says, "On the 28th day in the 12th month of the first year of the
Kagen reign-period (1304 Feb. 4) a comet appeared. At 8 p.m. on the first day in the
first month of the second year the comet appeared in the SW measuring about 2 ft in
length" (K552).
724 A Japanese record says, "In the evening of the 27th day in the llth month of the second
year of Kagen reign-period (1304 Dec. 26) a comet was seen in W, located at the south
of a south star of the HsU (the llth lunar mansion). Its vapour was about 1 ft in
length, pointing eastward, white in colour".
726 A Japanese record says, "At 4 a.m., on the 27th day in the 5th month of the third year
of the Kagen reign-period a comet was seen in NE. After the ninth day of the sixth month
(1305 Ju!y I) it was not seen".
727 A Japanese record says, "On the 16th day in the second month of the second year of the
Tokuji reign-period there were invocations for a evil star. The star disappeared on the
third day of the praying".
94 I. Hasegawa
Notes (continued)
736 A Japanese record says, "In the evening on the 19th day in the third month of the second
year of Gentoku reign-period a comet was seen in the NW. On the 23th day (1330 Apr. 12)
it was seen".
738, 739 Ho gives a wrong year of 13]9 to the Korean record of H(452). The Korean record
says, "In the sixth year of the second reign-period of Ch'ungsuk Wang (1337)". Ho
regards that all the records are for one comet. According to Chinese records of comets
in 1337, we regard these Korean records as two comets.
741 A Japan6se record says, "On the fourth day in the fourth month of the third year of the
Engen reign-period (1338 Apr. 24), the invocations for a guest star were held".
742 Ho gives a wrong year of 1331 in the Korean record of H(453). Korean says, "In the first
year of the second reign-period of Ch'unghye Wang (1340)". A Japanese record says, "A
comet was in the Thai-Wei Enclosure on the fourth day in the third month of the third
year of Rekio reign-period (1340 Apr. 1)".
745 A Japanese record says, "On the |4th day in the eighth month of the third year of the
Shuohei reign-period a comet appeared in the evening".
755 A Japanese record says, "In the eighth month of the 17th year of the Shyohei reign-
period (1362 Aug., Sept.) the invocations for a comet were held".
757 Four comets?
758 A Japanese record says, "On a hsin-chhou day, or the 22nd day in the ninth month of the
Shyohei reign-period (1366 Oct. 26) a guest star appeared at night. It was like the moon
in size". This comet is supposed to be identical with P/Temple-Tuttle.
759 A Korean record says, "On a wu-hsU day in the first month of the 16th year of Kongnim
Wong (1367 Feb. 20) a comet was seen in the horizon".
760, 761 A Japanese record says, "On a Jen-chhen day or the 22nd day in the third month of the
23rd year of the Shyohei reign-period (1368 Mar. 8) a comet appeared in the NW, its ray
was very long". "On the third day in the fourth month (1368 Apr. 20) a comet was seen".
Another Japanese record says, "On the third day of the fifth month of the 23rd year of
the Shyohei reign-period (1368 May 19) a red star appeared".
764 Three comets? Ho considers a comet entered the Tzu-Wei three times.
765 Kanda gives the date of 1374 Mar. I].
766 A Chinese record says, "During the tenth month of the eighth year of the Hung-Wu reign-
period a comet appeared at the Man-Tou". A European record given by Pingr~ is doubtful.
768 The Korean says, "On a chi-mao day in the ninth month of the fourth year of the Sin-u
r e i g n - p e r i o d (1378 Oct. I) a comet appeared at the west side of the Tzu-Wei Enclosure,
trespassed against the Ssu-Fu, went out from the east side of the Tzu-Wei, trespassed
the Thien-Phou and the Thien-Chi". A Japanese record says, "On a chi-mao day or ninth
day in the ninth month of the fourth year of Tenju reign-period (1378 Sept. 30) a comet
appeared in the N. last night".
769 The Japanese records a comet in the E°
770 A Japanese record says, "On the ]2th day in the eight month of the fifth year of the Tenju
reign-period a comet appeared".
771 A Japanese record says "From the 22nd day in the tenth month of the first year of the
Kowa reign-period (1381 Nov. 8) a comet appeared in the E, its ray extended about 15
or 16 ft. It disappeared nearly on the 15th day in the ]Ith month (Dec. II)".
775 A Chinese record says, "In the ninth month of the ;7th year of the Hung-Wu reign-period
a comet swept the I (the 27th lunar mansion) at night".
776 The Japanese records a comet in the second year of the Gen chyu reign-period (1385).
777 Or in 1385.
779 A Chinese record says, "On a hsin-ssu day in the sixth month of the 22nd year of the
Hung-Wu reign-period a comet was seen at the side of the Tzu-Wei. It was in the 90
minutes (in longitude) of the Niu (the ninth lunar mansion). It was white in colour
and one chang (10 ft) or more in length".
786 A Korean record says, "On a k~ng-tzu day in the ]Ith month of the seventh year of Thai-
Ti a guest star trespassed against the moon". The moon was in Sgr on the date.
787 The Japanese records, "From the eighth day in the ninth month of the sixth year of the
Oh-ei reign-period (1399 Oct. 7) a guest star was seen in the southern sky". Pingr@
gives a French record, "In November an extraordinary bright star was seen, its tall was
turned towards the W., it lasted only a week".
799 The Korean says, "On a k~ng-yin day in the ;Ith month of the tenth year of T'aejong
(1410 Dec. 23) a guest star appeared". Pingr~ gives a comet seen in 1410-1411.
800 The Korean says, "On a chi-hai day in the seventh month of the 13th year of T'aejong
(1413 Aug. 18) a comet appeared".
804 A Korean record says, "On a ting-hai day in the third month of the 17th year of
T'aejong (1417 Mar. 18) a comet was seen at the E".
814 Probably two comets appeared in ;432, one was seen on Feb. 2 at the E. (No.813), and
the other on Feb. 29 at the W.
844 A Chinese record says, "In winter of the seventh year of the Chh~ng-Hua reign-period
a comet was seen in the E". Another says, "In the third month a comet appeared at
Thien-tian". Gaubil's record of a comet seen in Vir in the year of 1463 (Pingr@
tom. l, p.466) seems to be identical with this comet.
855 The month is misprinted in H(532).
Catalogue of Ancient and Naked-Eye Comets 95
Notes (continued)
857 A Chinese record says, "In the second year of the Hung-Chih reign-period a comet was
seen".
888 A Chinese record says, "On a hen-wu day in the third month of the sixth year of Chia-
Ching reign-period a guest star entered into the moon". The moon was in Tau on the
date.
913 A Chinese record says, "In the tenth month of the 34th year of the Chia-Ching reign-
period a comet appeared at Pleiades. It moved north to Pei-Tou (the great bear)".
Pingr~ gives a European record of a comet seen in 1555.
915 A Chinese record says,, "In the seventh month of the 35th year of the Chia-Ching reign-
period a comet appeared. It was some ft in length, and disappeared at the end of the
month".
928 A Chinese record says, "During the sixth month of the first year of the Wan-Li reign-
period a comet was seen".
929 The Korean says, "On a k~ng-wu day in the eighth month of the ninth year of S~njo (1576
Sept. 2) a comet was seen". Ho gives a Chinese record of a comet in July-Aug. H(566).
932 A Chinese record says, "In autumn of the sixth year of the Wan-Li reign-period a comet
was seen in the E. Its tail was 50-60 ft in length, a white vapour stretched across
the sky. It disappeared in the end of the l|th month". A Chinese star given by Ho
H(569), seems to be a fire-ball.
933 A Chinese record says, "During the seventh year of the Wan-Li reign-period a comet was
seen".
935 A Chinese record says, "During the eighth month of the ninth year of the Wan-Li reign-
period a comet was seen in the W. Its light shone the earth. After more than 30 days
it went out of sight".
938 A Chinese record says, "During the ninth month of the tenth year of the Wan-Li reign-
period a comet was seen. It stretched across the heavens. Its colour was blue,
pointing to the NW. After about 49 days it disappeared".
939 A Chinese record says, "During the llth year of Wan-Li reign-period a comet was seen".
944 A Chinese record says, "During the 18th year of Wan-Li relgn-period a comet was seen in
the SE. After more than 10 days it disappeared". This is Comet 1590 discovered by
Tycho Brahe on Mar. 5, 1590.
946 A Chinese record says, "During the 20th year of the Wan-Li reign-period a comet was
seen" .
951 A Korean record says, "On the 26th day in the llth month of the 34th year of S6njo a
comet was seen in the NE. Its tail was long".
952 A Korean record says, "On a i-ssu (probably chi-ssu) day in the seventh month of the
35th year of S6njo a comet was seen between San-Thai and the north pole. It moved below
Lang-Wai. Its tail was 7-8 ft in length, and lasted for a long time".
955 A Chinese record says, "On a ping-shen day in the ninth month of the ting-wei year of
Thai-Zu of Chin a comet was seen in the E".
956 A Korean record says, "During the tenth month of the 40th year of S~njo a comet was
seen at San-Thai". A Chinese record says, "During the llth month of the 35th year of
Wan-Li reign-period a comet was seen in the W. Its tail was red, pointing to the E".
959 A Chinese record says, "During the eighth month of the 43rd year of Wan-Li reign-period
a comet was seen in the morning, its shape was like a broom".
960 A Chinese record says, "During the eiRhth month of the 46th year of Wan-Li reign-period
a comet appeared in the SE, its ray was very long". A Korean record says, "On a i-wei
day in the seventh month of the tenth year of Kwang-haegun (1618 Aug. 28) a comet was
seen below the Chung-Thai, its tail was I0 ft more in length, blue-white in colour".
This comet is 1618 I.
961 A Korean record says, "In the morning of a K~ng-yin day in the ninth month of the
tenth year of Kwang-haegun (1618 Oct. 22) a white vapour, like a comet appeared, its
was 4-5 ft in length". A Chinese record says, "On a kuei-chhou day in the ninth month
of the 46th year of Wan-Li reign-period (1618 Nov. 14) a comet appeared in the Chio and
the Khang (The first and second lunar mansions), its tail pointing to the Khuei, the hou
and the Pi (The 15th, 16th and 14th lunar mansions)".
962 Discovered in Europe on 1618 Nov. I0. A Korean record says, "On a i-mao day in the
ninth month of the tenth year of Kwang-haegun (1618 Nov. 16), a white vapour appeared
in E horizon, pierced Chhang-Ho pointing to the I (the 27th lunar mansion). It was l~ke
a comet and 6-7 ft in length". Williams gives a wrong date of 1618 Nov. 24 instead of
1618 Nov. 16.
963 Discovered in Europe on 1618 Nov. 16. A Korean record says, "On a chi-ssu day in the tenth
month of the tenth year of Kwang-haegun (1618 Nov. 30) a comet was seen in the E, its
length was several ft and one inch in width". This comet is 1618 II. Williams gives a
wrong date of 1618 Nov. 16 instead of 1618 Nov. 26.
964 A Korean record says, "On a ping-tzu day in the tenth month of the tenth year of Kwang-
haegun (1618 Dec. 7) a blue-white vapour appeared, superposed Thai-tsun, trespassed
Shang-Thai and passed through Wu-Chu-Hou". Williams gives a wrong date of 1618 Dec. 5
instead of 1618 Nov. 27.
966 A Korean record says, "On a kuei-yu day in the 12th month of the ]2th year of Kwang-
baegun (1621 Jan. 22) a comet was seen".
96 I. Hasegawa
Notes (continued)
967 A Korean record says, "On a keng-yin day in the first month of the 13th year of Kwang-
haegun (1621 Feb. 8) a comet appeared".
968 Uncertain object. Williams seems to give a Julian calendar date.
969 A Japanese record says, "On the third day in the tenth month of the ninth year of the
Gen-na reign-period a comet was seen in the W".
970 A Chinese record says, "During the sixth month of the fourth year of the Thien-Chhi
reign-period a c h i n g hsing (a large star) entered the moon". A Japanese record says,
"During the sixth month of the first year of the Kan-ei reign-period a comet appeared in
the S".
972 A Korean record says, "In the summer of the fifth year of Injo a comet appeared with the
moon".
973 A Japanese record says, "On the 14th day in the seventh month of the fifth year of the
Kan-ei reign-period a comet was seen in the SE".
974 A Korean record says, "On a k~ng-hsU day in the ninth month of the seventh year of Injo
a comet appeared".
975 A Japanese record says, "During the 12th month of the sixth year of the Kan-ei reign-
period a comet was seen in the NW".
977 A Korean record says, "During the fifth month of the 16th year of Injo a comet appeared.
Its light was very red, lasting for a month".
978 A Korean record says, "On a chia-shen day in the tenth month of the 17th year of Injo a
guest star appeared in the E of the Shen (the 2ist lunar mansion), on a i-yu day (1639
Oct. 27) moved to the lower part of the Shen, and covered an unknown star".
982 A Korean record says, "On a jen-hsu day in the seventh month of the fourth year of
Hyojong a comet appeared outside of the western boundary of Tzu-Wei, became small at the
Pei-Ho, then moved to below the Pa-Kuh. Its tail pointed to the SW, 7-8 inches in
length, blue-white in colour, on the 25th day in the eighth month (1653 Sept. 15)
disappeared". Pa-Kuh, 31 Cam, 37 Lyn (Cam), 6, ~ Aur, 7, 9, 2 and 235B Cam.
983 A Korean record says, "On a k~ng-shen day in the sixth (probably seventh) month of the
seventh year of Hyojong a comet was seen in the Ching (the 22nd lunar mansion), it was
like the great star of the Wu-chh~ (~ Aur), its tail was 2-3 inches in length, blue-
white in colour. It disappeared on the 29th day of the seventh month (1656 Sept. 17)".
985 A Korean record says, "On a hsin-wei day in the tenth month of the second year of Hy~n-
jong a guest star was at the five degree of Nu (the tenth lunar mansion), at 102 degrees
from the pole. On a i-hal day (1661 Dec. 20) the star was at the first degree of
Hs~ (the llth lunar mansion), at 97 degrees from the pole". Another Korean record says,
"The star disappeared on a ting-hai day of the llth month (1662 Jan. I)".
988 A Korean record says, "A comet was seen in winter of the seventh year of Hy~njong".
991 A Chinese record says, "On a kuei-ssu day in the second month of the 12th year of the
K'ang-Hsi reign-period a strange star appeared at the Lou (the 16th lunar mansion). It
was like a peach in size, white in colour. Its tail was one inch more in length, pointing
to the E. On a chia-wu day (1673 Mar. II) it was seen".
999 A Chinese record says, "On a k~ng-yin day in the seventh month of the 25th year of the
K'ang-Hsi reign-period (1686 Aug. 26) a strange star appeared in the E, near horizon,
white in colour, moved to the E slowly. On a ting-yu day (1686 Sept. 2) it moved 16
degrees to the Liu (the 24th lunar mansion). It had a very faint tail. On a jen-yin
day (1686 Sept. 7) it arrived at the Chhi-Hsing (the 25th lunar mansion) then
disappeared'!.
A Korean record says, "On a chi-yu day (1686 Sept. 14) a comet appeared at the Chang
(the 26th lunar mansion)".
1000 Hsi regards this a nova, but probably it is a comet.
1002 Hsi regards this a nova, but probably it is a comet. Hsi gives a wrong date.
1007 A Korean record says, "On a ting-chhou day in the second month of the 27th year of
Sukjong (1701 Mar. 28) a comet was seen in the Wei and Ying-Shih (the 12th and 13th lunar
mansions). Its tail was 2 ft more in length. It was like the great star of the Wu-chh~
(~ Aur), white in colour and moved to the Khuei (the 15th lunar mansion). It
disappeared on the fourth day of the third month (1701 Apr. II)".
1025 A Korean record says, "In the evening of a ting-ssu day of the tenth month of the 20th
year of Young-jo a guest star was seen in the longitudes of the Chio (the first lunar mansion)
It had a tail".
1031 A Chinese record says, "On a chia-yin day in the fifth month of the 14th year of the
Chhien-Lung reign-period (1749 June 21) a felicitous star was seen in the E. it was
like an egg in size, oval in shape, yellow-white in colour. It was brilliant. It
moved slowly and went out from the Thien-Chin to the Tsoo Kaou (E, ~, o, 0 Cet)".
Catalogue of Ancient and Naked-Eye Comets 97
Table 2. Remarks on Pinata' s Com~to~r~ohie and Baldet's Liste G~n~rale des Commies
Table 2 (continued)
Table 2 (continued)
Table 2 (continued)
1266 Aug. 413 659 A comet recorded in China and Japan in 1266 is
the same comet in 1266 Jan.
1273 Dec. 5 415 662 Should be 1273 Apr. 9.
1275 416 664 Doubtful record. Conjunction of stars?
1283 416 667 Probably the same comet in 1298.
1297 417 Doubtful record.
1300 Sept. 420 674 Probably the same comet in 1301, P/Halley.
1314 May 426 685 Probably the same comet in 1314 Oct.
1315 Nov. 28 426 686 Better 1315 Oct. 29.
1318 428 Meteor?
1334 Aug. 429 690 Probably the same comet in 1340 Mar.
1352 Oct. 15 437 699 Should be 1352 Oct. 12.
1360 Mar. 12 438 702 Should be 1360 Mar. 18.
1260 Apr. II - 703 Probably the same comet in 1360 Mar.
1375 442 712 Doubtful object.
1380 442 Should be 1379.
1399 Nov. 445 726 Probably the same comet in 1399 Oct.
1400 Feb. 446 727 Probably the same comet in 1402 Feb.
1401 Feb. 446 728 Probably the same comet in 1402 Feb.
1407 At the 452 733 Probably the same comet in 1406.
beginning
1407 Dec. 14 - 734 Should be 1407 Dec. 15.
1431 Jan. 3 - 742 Should be 1431 Jan. 4.
1432 Feb. 3 453 744 Should be 1432 Feb. 2.
1450 Jan. 19 455 754 Probably the same comet in 1449 Dec.
1458 June 466 762 Recorded only in Europe, not in China.
1461 June 29 466 765 Should be 1461 July 30.
1463 466 768 Probably the same comet in 1471Mar.-Apr.
1464 Spring 466 769 Doubtful record.
1468 Feb. 467 772 Probably the same comet in 1472.
1468 Oct. 468 774 Probably the same comet in 1468 Sept.
1469 Oct. 16 469 775 Probably the same comet in 1469 Sept.
1470 Jan. 13 469 776 Probably the same comet in 1472.
1505 Aug. 480 795 Doubtful object.
1506 Apr. 481 796 Doubtful object.
1506 Aug. lO - 798 Probably the same comet in 1506 July.
1513 483 8O2 Meteor?
1520 May 17 484 809 Meteor?
1527 Aug. II 485 818 Meteor?
1529 Feb. 5 - 820 Should be 1529 Feb. 9.
1529 July 486 821 Probably the same comet in 1529 Aug.
1530 June? 486 822 Should be 1530 Nov. 30.
1542 501 835 Doubtful object.
1568 Aug. 30 509 849 Meteor?
1578 Feb. 22 - 854 Meteor?
1578 Oct. 520 855 Probably the same comet in 1578 recorded in China and
Korea.
1584-1621 The Dates of Nos 861, 862, 866, 867, 868, 869 and
878 in Baldet's L~8te are referred to the Julian
Calendar.
1618 Dec. 5 - 876 Better 1618 Nov. 27.
1640 Dec. 12 - 884 Should be 1640 Dec. 21.
Catalogue of Ancient and Naked-Eye Comets ]01
REFERENCES
Baldet, F. (1949) Liste g~n~rale des com~tes de l'origine ~ 1948, Annuaire Bur. Long., (1950)
BI.
Blot, E. (1846) Catalogue des com~tes observ~es en Chine depuis l'an 1230 jusqu'~ l'an 1640
de notre ~re, Connais. Temps, Additions, p.44.
Chambers, G. F. (1889) A Handbook of Descriptive and Practical Astronomy, 4th ed., Vol.l,
p.511, London.
Chambers, G. F. (1890) A Handbook of Descriptive a ~ Practical Astronomy, 4th ed., Vol.lll,
p.332, London.
Chambers, G. F. (1909) The Story of the Comets, London.
Ho Peng Yoke (1962) Ancient and mediaeval observations of comets and novae in Chinese sources I
vistas in Astronomy, ~, 127.
Hsi Ts~-Tsung (1955) A new catalogue of ancient novae, Acta Astr. Sinica, ~, 183 = Smithsonian
Contr. to Astrophys., ~, 109 (1958).
Kanda, S. (1935) Nihon Temmon Shiryo (Astronomical Materials in Japanese History), Tokyo (in
Japanese).
Kanda, S. (1947) Nihon no Temmon Kishyo Shiryo (Astronomical and Meteorological Materials in
Japanese History), Tokyo (in Japanese).
Kanda, S. (1960) Japanese History of Astronomy before Meiji, p.447, Tokyo (in Japanese).
Kanda, S. and Ohsaki, M. (1932) The Astronomical Herald, 25, 221 (in Japanese).
Ma Tuan-Lin (1254) W~n Hsien Thung Khao (Historical Investigation of Public Affairs).
Marsden, B. G. (1966) Mem. Br. Astr. Assoc., 40, No. 2.
Pingr& (1783) Com~tographie ou Trait~ historique et th@orique des Cometes, tome I (1783)
tome II (1784) Paris.
Porter, J. G. (;96;) Mem. Br. Astr. Assoc. 39, No. 3.
Sekiguchi, R. (1971) Report on Ancient Astro-nomical Observations in Korea (in Japanese).
Sekiguchi, R. 1917) The Astronomical Herald, I0, Nos 8 and 9 (in Japanese).
Tuckerman , B. 1962) Planetary, Lunar and Solar Positions, B.C.601 to A.D.I, Mem. Am. Phil.
Soc. 56.
Tuckerman, B. 1964) Planetary, Lunar and Solar Positions, A.D.2 to A.D.1649, Mem. Am. Phil.
Soc. 59.
Vsekhsvyatskij, S. K. (1958) Fizicheskie Kharakteristiki Komet, Moscow = Physical Characteris-
tics of Comets, (1964) Jerusalem.
Williams, J. (1871) Observations of Comets, from B.C. 611 to A.D. 1640, extracted from the
Chinese Annals, London.