Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ipri 36 1499588
Ipri 36 1499588
Ipri 36 1499588
RESEARCH ARTICLE
a
Department of General Practice, Turku University and Turku University Hospital, Turku, Finland; bSalo Health Center, Salo, Finland;
c
Department of Psychiatry, Turku University and Turku University Hospital, Turku, Finland; dDepartment of Psychiatry, Hospital
District of Satakunta, Pori, Finland; eDepartment of Biostatistics, Turku University and Turku University Hospital, Turku, Finland;
f
Central Satakunta Health Federation of Municipalities, Harjavalta, Finland
KEY POINTS
Hypertension and depressive symptoms are known to form a toxic combination contributing
even to all-cause mortality.
Comorbidities or the labelling effect of the diagnosis of hypertension can confound their
association.
Our study shows that depressive symptoms are common in hypertensive persons even with-
out comorbidities, if the person is already aware of his/her hypertension.
Many modifiable, lifestyle-associated factors may contribute to the association of hyperten-
sion and depressive symptoms.
When treating hypertensive patients, consideration of depressive symptoms is important in
order to promote favorable lifestyle and control of hypertension.
Introduction
approximately 10% of patients suffer from depression
Hypertension affects every third adult worldwide [1] and another 10% have depressive symptoms [3]. Based
and it is the most important risk factor for disabili- on a large Swedish population registry, Sandstro €m
ty-adjusted life-years [2]. In primary care setting, et al. recently showed that individuals with the
CONTACT Ansa Talvikki Rantanen atsipp@utu.fi ICT-City, General Practice, Joukahaisenkatu 3-5, 20520 Turku, Finland
ß 2018 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
324 A. T. RANTANEN ET AL.
diagnosis of hypertension are also more commonly cardiovascular risk factor survey, a tape for waist cir-
diagnosed with depression than individuals without cumference measurement, and a type 2 diabetes risk
hypertension [4]. The coexistence of self-reported assessment form (FINDRISC, Finnish Diabetes Risk
hypertension and depressive symptoms was associated Score, available from www.diabetes.fi/english). The
with a 15% higher relative hazard for all-cause mortality participation rate was 74% (4,450/6,013). Those having
than hypertension without depressive symptoms even at least one cardiovascular risk factor (n ¼ 3,072) were
after adjustment for lifestyle factors and comorbid dis- invited for an enrolment examination performed by a
eases; as reported in the US National Health and trained study nurse. Risk factors taken into account
Nutrition Epidemiologic Follow-up Study (NHANES) [5]. were the latest blood pressure measurement 140/
Thus, when present simultaneously, hypertension and 90 mmHg, use of antihypertensive medication, history
depressive symptoms form a toxic combination high- of gestational diabetes or hypertension, family history
lighting the importance of the recognition of depres- of premature CVD, waist circumference at the level of
sive symptoms in hypertensive subjects. the navel 80 cm in women and 94 cm in men in
However, comorbidities such as cardiovascular dis-
Harjavalta, and FINDRISC-score 12 points in
ease (CVD), diabetes, and obesity may have confound-
Harjavalta or 15 points in Kokem€aki. Subjects with
ing effects on the association between hypertension
known CVD, renal disease or diabetes were excluded.
and mental distress. It has also been suggested that
having the diagnosis of hypertension may partly
explain the higher level of psychological distress in Measurements
patients treated for hypertension [6,7]. This awareness
of hypertension may have a labelling effect causing Blood pressure (BP) was measured by a trained nurse
mental distress, as suggested by Hamer et al. [6], or it with a mercury sphygmomanometer with subjects in a
may be the result of increased healthcare utilization of sitting posture, after resting for at least 5 minutes with
depressed persons as proposed by Michal et al. [7], the cuff placed on the arm. If the mean of two read-
who also reported that unawareness of hypertension ings of systolic BP was 140 mmHg or diastolic BP
was inversely associated with depression. In these 90 mmHg and the subjects had no antihypertensive
studies, a substantial proportion of patients had CVD medication, they were taught to use an automatic
validated BP monitor (OmronV M4-1, Japan) which
R
or diabetes, and blood pressure was measured only
on one occasion. We had the opportunity to investi- was lent to them for home BP monitoring. The partici-
gate the association between hypertension awareness pants whose arm circumference was 32 cm used a
and depressive symptoms in subjects who had no larger cuff. The subjects were advised to perform
manifested CVD, renal disease or diabetes. The diag- duplicate BP measurements in a seated position after
nosis of previously unknown hypertension was con- five minutes of rest in the morning and evening for
firmed with home blood pressure measurements and one week. The recorded measurements except those
thus, we could exclude subjects with white coat from the first day were used to calculate the mean
hypertension. We hypothesized that having a diagno- home BP. The subjects were classified according to
sis of hypertension, rather than elevated blood pres- their hypertension status to three categories:
sure per se, is associated with depressive symptoms.
Our secondary aim was to investigate factors predis- 1. aware hypertensives (subjects with antihyperten-
posing subjects with known hypertension to depres- sive medication)
sive symptoms. 2. unaware hypertensives (no antihypertensive medica-
tion, the mean of home BP monitoring 135 mmHg
Methods for systolic or 85 mmHg for diastolic BP)
3. normotensives
Study population
The study population was drawn from the Harmonica Height and weight were measured with subjects in
Project (Harjavalta Risk Monitoring for Cardiovascular a standing position without shoes and outer garments,
Disease), a population survey carried out in Harjavalta and waist circumference at the level midway between
and Kokem€aki (7,646 and 8,217 inhabitants on the lower rib margin and iliac crest. Body mass index
December 31, 2007, respectively) from August 2005 to (BMI) was calculated as weight (kg) divided by the
September 2007. All home-dwelling inhabitants aged square of height (m2). Classification of BMI was as fol-
45–70 years (n ¼ 6,013) were invited, and mailed a lows: normal weight BMI <25.0 kg/m2, overweight BMI
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE 325
25.0–29.9 kg/m2, obese BMI 30.0–34.9 kg/m2, very angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor or angioten-
obese BMI 35.0 kg/m2. sin receptor antagonist, diuretic). Odds ratios (OR) and
Laboratory tests were determined in blood samples their 95% confidence intervals were calculated from
obtained after at least 12 hours of fasting. Glucose val- this logistic regression model. All statistical tests were
ues were measured from capillary blood with performed as 2-sided, with a significance level set at
0.05. The analyses were performed using SASV System,
R
HemoCue Glucose 201þ system (Angelholm, Sweden).
Plasma total cholesterol was measured enzymatically version 9.4 for Windows (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC,
(OlympusV AU640, Japan).
R
USA) and SPSS Statistics (IBM SPSS Statistics for
Windows, Version 22.0. Armonk, NY, USA).
Questionnaires
Results
The study subjects completed self-administrated ques-
tionnaires at the clinic before the enrolment examin- Characteristics of the study population
ation was performed: upper secondary school We evaluated 2,676 cardiovascular risk persons with a
(accomplished/not), cohabiting (yes/no), current smoking mean age of 58 (SD 7) years (55.7% women), who
(yes/no), alcohol consumption (Alcohol Use Disorders had no previously known CVD, diabetes, or renal
Identification Test, AUDIT [8]), leisure-time physical activ- disease. Characteristics and health behaviours of the
ity (LTPA) level, and Beck’s Depression Inventory (BDI) subjects are presented in Table 1. Hypertension was
[9]. AUDIT score 8 was regarded as the cut-off for diagnosed in 1 282 (47.9%) of the subjects, of whom
harmful alcohol use [8]. LTPA was classified as follows: 442 (34.5%) had not previously been detected as
high: LTPA for at least 30 minutes at a time for six or having hypertension and were thus unaware of the
more times a week; moderate: LTPA for at least disease. Normotensive subjects were slightly younger,
30 minutes at a time for four to five times a week; low: more often female, more educated, and less
LTPA for at least 30 minutes at a time for maximum of frequently at-risk users of alcohol than the hyperten-
three times a week. The presence of clinically significant sive subjects. The prevalence of obesity (BMI 30.0 kg/
depressive symptoms was defined as a BDI score 13 m2) was 49.9% (419/840) among aware hypertensive,
[10], indicating at least mild depression. 29.9% (132/442) among unaware hypertensives, and
21.5% (300/1,394) among normotensive subjects
Ethical approval (p < 0.001). The mean of BMI was 29.5 kg/m2 in
female subjects and 28.8 kg/m2 in males.
The ethics committee of Satakunta hospital district
reviewed and approved the study protocol and consent
forms. All participants provided written informed con- Association of hypertension status and depressive
sent for the project and subsequent medical research. symptoms (BDI 13)
Depressive symptoms were reported by 14.1% (116/
Statistical analyses 822) of the aware hypertensives, by 8.7% (38/439) of
the subjects unaware of their hypertension and by
Descriptive statistics are shown as the number of sub- 9.3% (129/1,382) of the normotensive subjects. In the
jects and proportions for categorical variables. For nor- logistic regression analysis, the difference in depressive
mally distributed variables, means with standard symptoms between hypertension status categories
deviations (SD) are presented, and median with inter- remained significant (p ¼ 0.0030) despite common risk
quartile range (IQR) otherwise. Characteristics of factors. When compared to aware hypertensives, both
normotensive, unware hypertensive and aware hyper- the normotensive (OR 0.62, 95% CI 0.45–0.86)
tensive subjects were compared with one-way analysis (p ¼ 0.0038) and the unaware hypertensive subjects
of variance, Kruskal–Wallis test or chi-square test. (OR 0.54, 95% CI 0.35–0.84) (p ¼ 0.0067) had a lower
Predictors for depressive symptoms (BDI 13) were risk for depressive symptoms.
modelled with logistic regression with the following
independent variables: hypertension status, age, gen-
Predictors of depressive symptoms among aware
der, education, cohabiting, smoking, alcohol use, LTPA,
hypertensives
BMI as categorised. In addition, similar model was exe-
cuted to subjects using antihypertensive medication Table 2 shows the predictors of depressive symptoms
including medication (beta-blocker, calcium antagonist, among the aware hypertensives. The strongest
326 A. T. RANTANEN ET AL.
were able to take into account many factors influ- was 26.3% in a sample of hypertensive patients.
encing both depressive symptoms and hypertension, According to Li et al., self-rating scales as measures
it is possible that factors such as other causes of may introduce considerable heterogeneity into the
mental distress and number of health care visits results [12]. The difference in the prevalence of
confound the found association. Our study popula- depression between our study and the meta-analysis
tion only included subjects considered to be at risk is likely due to different methods used.
of a cardiovascular disease, which must be consid- The majority of hypertensive patients attending a
ered when applying our results to the general popu- primary care physicians office have previously been
lation. As only subjects with elevated blood pressure diagnosed and already been prescribed an antihyper-
were instructed to perform home blood pressure tensive medication. Considering the deleterious effects
measurements, we cannot exclude the possibility of of concomitant hypertension and depression, it is
masked hypertension. important to recognise depressive symptoms in hyper-
In keeping with our findings, Hamer et al. tensive subjects. Our results suggest that female gen-
observed an elevated risk of psychological distress in der, harmful alcohol use, obesity, smoking, and low
patients treated for hypertension, but not in unaware level of LTPA are factors predisposing hypertensive
hypertensives, compared to normotensive subjects in patients to depression. Depression and depressive
a large population-based study conducted in England symptoms affect a person’s motivation and ability to
and Scotland [6]. Also Michal et al. [7] found con- lead a healthy life. On the other hand, physical activity
trolled, but not uncontrolled, treated hypertension and other components of a healthy lifestyle promote
being associated with increased risk for depression in psychological well-being. Not surprisingly, an
a German population-based cohort study. In contrast unhealthy lifestyle including low physical activity and
to Hamer’s and our findings, they also found the alcohol intake has been associated with depression
unawareness of hypertension having a buffering [13,14], which is plausible in a bi-directional way.
effect against depressive symptoms. The investigators Alcohol use disorder and depressive disorder have
suggested that these findings are mainly explained been found to double the risk for the other disorder
by increased healthcare utilization of depressed per- [15]. In addition, obesity is linked to unhealthy life-
sons rather than a labelling effect [7]. The reason style. A recent meta-analysis [16] provides evidence
for these somewhat mixed results can be the mis- that depression and obesity are associated bi-direc-
classification of the hypertension status of the tionally: there is a 37% increase in the risk of being
subjects and confounding by comorbidity. In the obese in depressed adults, and obese adults have an
above-mentioned studies, hypertension status was 18% increase in the risk of being depressed. One has
determined by a single measurement and thus the to keep in mind, that these lifestyle-connected factors
possible misclassification of subjects with white coat associated with depressive symptoms are also risk fac-
hypertension to unaware hypertensives may influence tors for hypertension. Hence, contributing to these
the results. We cannot discount the possibility that modifiable risk factors may attenuate the effect of the
depressed individuals use more healthcare services, toxic combination of depressive symptoms and
which enhances the chance of diagnostic recognition hypertension.
of hypertension as suggested by Michal et al. [7]. In In conclusion, depressive symptoms are common in
Finland, anxiety has been associated with increased hypertensive persons even without comorbidities, if
utilization of health care services [11]. Only 5% of the the person is already aware of his/her hypertension.
previously diagnosed hypertensives in our study Thus, discussing a new chronic condition and lifelong
population used antidepressant medication suggest- medication should happen in a delicate, supporting
ing a low level of clinically significant depression or manner. Many modifiable, lifestyle-associated factors
underdiagnosed depression among medicated may contribute to the association of hypertension and
hypertensives. depressive symptoms. Clinicians should consider
In our sample, the total prevalence of depressive depressive symptoms when treating hypertensive sub-
symptoms among aware and unaware hypertensive jects and find ways to enhance their psychological
subjects was 22.8%. In a meta-analysis of 10,194 well-being in order to promote a favourable lifestyle
hypertensive subjects in 27 studies using self-rating and control of hypertension. Future research will
scales Li et al. [12] found even higher prevalence of hopefully clarify whether treatment of the screen-
depression (29.8%). One study had used BDI, and, with detected depression would also lower blood pressure
a cut-off point of 16, the prevalence of depression levels in hypertensive subjects.
328 A. T. RANTANEN ET AL.