Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nursing Research Final
Nursing Research Final
Nursing Research Final
McKenzie Morgan, Stacey Pezzenti, Emily Russell, Kailee Shumaker, John Slike
Introduction
Cancer has been a chronic disease that impacts our society tremendously and is seen
throughout various healthcare settings. One important type of cancer that affects individuals the
most especially in childhood cancer patients is acute lymphoblastic leukemia, which is also
known as ALL. ALL is a type of leukemia that affects the white blood cells and creates errors in
the DNA of the bone marrow. It is one thing to understand what the specific type of cancer is and
how it affects the body, but it is another to understand how it is treated and how that treatment
may affect the individuals during the treatment and possibly later on in life. Treatment and
adverse effects of different types of treatments often go hand in hand. We know that acute
lymphoblastic leukemia is treated with either chemotherapy agents or immunotherapy agents and
both play a significant role in helping cure this cancer. Unfortunately, with any cure there are
consequences; childhood ALL patients are at an increased risk of mortality and morbidity related
understand what chemotherapy and immunotherapy treatment is related to ALL, and the various
cardio-toxic effects chemotherapy and immunotherapy have on ALL patients, along with success
rates to the prevention of these cardio-toxic effects to help determine if chemotherapy causes an
increased risk of these patients developing severe cardiovascular disorders over immunotherapy.
PICOT
This literature review was conducted to identify if there was an increased risk of
or immunotherapy. The following PICOT question was developed: “Are acute lymphoblastic
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 3
Search Strategy
We used PubMed as our search engine to find resources and literary works associated
with our research question. We used the following terms: cardiovascular disease, acute,
search yielded fifty-six results until we extended our population size to obtain more results with
their abstracts being adequate to our question. Our initial population size was originally focused
only on pediatric leukemia survivors developing cardiac issues later on as a result of either
inclusive to acquire more resources. We also narrowed down our terms, created a new search,
and selected peer-reviewed journal articles written in the English language. We limited the
literature from 2018 to 2023. The databases used in this search include PubMed and Medline.
Our final search yielded 589 results varying from journal articles, clinical trials, meta-analyses,
and systematic reviews. We strived to establish four to five themes out of the ten articles we
curated. We met our goal of generating five themes from our ten articles to support our research
question.
The human body is composed of millions and millions of cells that work together to form
our organs and tissues. Each individual cell has its own DNA, and a nucleus in the center that
tells the cell what to do, how to work, and eventually die. A normal healthy cell follows these
instructions with no issues. However, when the DNA inside our cells is disrupted or changed in
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 4
some way, it may lead to gene mutation. When gene mutation occurs, these healthy cells are no
longer able to follow instructions due to the change in DNA. When this happens, cells become
dysfunctional and can grow out of control, thus leading to cancer. The out-of-control cells begin
to grow rapidly, and when this occurs, they form a lump of cells, otherwise what we call a tumor.
In leukemia, this out-of-control cell growth comes from blood cells. The blood cells themselves
do not form a tumor, instead, they are built up in the blood or can build up in our bone marrow.
The cells also can ‘metastasis’ which is when they invade other tissues and lymphatic vessels
which carries them into the rest of the body (Mandal, 2019). So how exactly does chemotherapy
different drugs used that strike against these rapidly growing cancer cells and try to prevent
further abnormal growth and cause cell death. Chemotherapy contains cytotoxic agents that have
the ability to disrupt rapid cell growth and prevent division (Mandal, 2019). Other cytotoxic
agents work not to prevent further division but instead kill the cells altogether. This is known as
apoptosis, or programmed cell death (Mandal, 2019). In leukemia, the cells are very fast
growing, meaning that they have the factor of growing and dividing more rapidly than other
forms of cancer. The rapid division factor makes it more susceptible to chemotherapy agents,
hence more likely to see a positive outcome versus other forms of slow-growing cancers that are
There are a number of different chemotherapy drugs that work in different ways. A few
examples of these drugs are Alkylating agents, Antimetabolites, Topoisomerase inhibitors, and
Antitumor antibiotics. These drugs work to achieve the same thing, to prevent cancer cells from
growing and multiplying. However, they have different therapeutic actions. For example,
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 5
Alkylating agents attack DNA within a cell that prevents the cell from dividing. Some examples
of these agents are Altretamine and Cyclophosphamide (Cleveland Clinic, 2022). Alkylating
agents are also the most common type of chemotherapy for cancer patients. Antimetabolites
change the genetic material of cancer cells that are used to grow and divide. Examples of this
group include Floxuridine and Methotrexate (Cleveland Clinic, 2022). Topoisomerase inhibitors
target an enzyme called “topoisomerase” which allows DNA to replicate. A few examples are
Teniposide and Topotecan. Similar to other agents, targeting this DNA can prevent growth and
division, as well as the destruction of the DNA (Cleveland Clinic, 2022). Lastly, antitumor
antibiotics also attack the DNA inside of the cell not allowing it to reproduce. Some examples of
these are Doxorubicin and Daunorubicin (Cleveland Clinic, 2022). These are just a few of the
many categories of chemotherapy agents. As stated before, all chemotherapies have one goal: to
While chemotherapy works to overall get rid of cancer, it has the ability to cause some
harsh side effects that the patient must endure. For reference, a handful of side effects include
fatigue, nausea, and vomiting, as well as hair loss, which is the most common. Other side effects
include bowel issues such as diarrhea or constipation, sores in the mouth, and a loss of appetite
(Cleveland Clinic, 2022). Another major adverse effect of chemotherapy is the effect it has on
certain blood cells, specifically neutrophils. It lowers the blood cell count of these cells causing
what we call neutropenia. Neutropenia is an abnormally low neutrophil count in the blood, which
causes a patient to become more prone to infection. Most patients you see in the hospital setting
who are doing rounds of chemotherapy will be placed on neutropenic precautions. This means
anyone who enters the patient’s room whether it is staff or visitors, must take extra precautions
to prevent the spread of any bacteria to the patient. Handwashing, and the absence of fresh
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 6
flowers, fruits, or vegetables in the room are all examples of measures taken to ensure these
know that the overall goal is to eliminate the process of rapid growth and division of aggressive
cancerous cells. However, it is just as important to understand the adverse effects chemotherapy
has on the body, mainly the destruction of healthy cells in addition to the cancer ones.
Chemotherapy use in pediatric cancer patients has become a concern related to cardiac
cardiovascular issues later on in life after receiving treatment. A specific type of childhood
diseases. During this treatment, anthracycline is still the first–line chemotherapy drug used that
has significant efficacy in increasing the survival rate of these children. Cardiotoxicity is
recognized to be a side effect during any treatment with the use of anthracycline which causes
concern for its use. With consistent use of anthracycline drugs, there may be an effect on
individuals’ quality of life along with the survival rate of patients after beating cancer (Jin et al.,
three types such as sub-acute, acute, and chronic based on the onset it occurs. The use of
anthracycline has increased the possibility of getting cardiotoxicity during treatment or years
later on.
A study done by Jin et.al (2021) was conducted by using a retrospective case study that
looked at children who had acute lymphoblastic leukemia and before each course of
uncovered with the induction of daunorubicin (DNR) on days 5 and 12 of treatment and the use
of vincristine (VCR) on days 5, 12, 16, and 26 that several of the participants or cases have
developed cardiac disorders after the administrations. According to their results, one of the cases
developed palpitations and chest distress and their ECGs showed sinus tachycardia and abnormal
T-waves. Although most patients developed cardiac arrhythmias from the DNR administration,
about 14 cases were shown to have a small amount of pericardial effusion, 11 cases with left
ventricular hypertrophy, and 5 with valve disorders (Jin et.al, 2021). Most of the anthracycline–
induced cardiotoxicity was originally found to cause a decline in the left ventricle ejection
fraction (LVEF) which is the volume of fluid ejected from the left ventricle with the contraction
of the heart. This decline can be presented by either arrhythmias, pericarditis, congestive heart
With ALL, there have been other studies done to determine whether or not chemotherapy
has developed cardiovascular issues in these patients. One study done by the Swiss Medical
Weekly (2019) looks at how the treatment of chemotherapy affects acute lymphoblastic leukemia
survivors. According to the study, survivors have an increased risk of cardiovascular mortality
and morbidity which has been seen to be caused by chemotherapy treatment such as
anthracycline or even by chest radiotherapy (Hau et al., 2019). In their study, they used a
questionnaire that was sent to survivors that survived at least five years after their diagnosis
along with their siblings for comparison. Through the questionnaire, there was a section
specifically for cardiovascular problems that they were asked to explain if they had developed
any of the ones listed. There was a total of 511 ALL survivors that participated out of 707.
Survivors revealed that they had an increased risk or likelihood of developing cardiovascular
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 8
problems. Also, about fourteen percent of the 511 have reported at least developing one
cardiovascular problem. This has been evident as well, with the majority reporting development
of heart failure. The risk is seen high with chemotherapy drugs such as anthracycline, but it is
even higher if the patient had experienced both the anthracycline and chest radiotherapy together
(Hau et al., 2019). Overall, between the two studies, there is shown to be an increased risk from
chemotherapy for these patients whether they develop cardiac diseases during treatment or later
on in life.
The immune system is a vital part of our body- it protects us from various diseases and
illnesses. When the body notices harmful substances that don’t belong- also known as pathogens
such as bacteria, viruses, and even cancer they stimulate an immune response in which the
immune system starts producing antibodies to fight off the antigens. Antibodies are proteins
made by a form of white blood cell, the B-cell, also known as B-Lymphocytes. Lymphocytes are
part of the lymphatic system, and the two major lymphocytes are B-lymphocytes and T-
lymphocytes. Cytotoxic T-cells (killer T-cells) protect us by killing the infected cells and helper
T-cells help the B-cells gather surrounding cells to help kill the infected cells, through the release
of cytokines from the T-cells which aid in the body's immune response through a communication
system between cells (Markman, 2022 & Carter, 2021). The B-cells and T-cells work together in
lymphoblasts (leukemic white blood cells) which are produced by the bone marrow. The
lymphoblasts divide rapidly, do not function correctly, and push out healthy cells.
Immunotherapy agents are used in the treatment of cancer by activating or suppressing the
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 9
person's own immune system. Immunotherapy for the treatment of ALL can be used as a first
line of treatment or combined with other treatments. In most cases, immunotherapy is used when
other treatments in a treatment regimen have not been effective or when someone in remission
relapses (Seladi-Schulman Ph.D., 2021). In ALL, there are different forms of immunotherapy
Drug Conjugates (ADC), and Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T-cell therapy. Monoclonal
produce the same action as natural antibodies we make in our body. In ALL, the mAbs work by
targeting specific proteins on the Lymphoblasts to help the immune system destroy them.
Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) can also be placed in the category of targeted immunotherapy
due to their action to target (Seladi-Schulman Ph.D., 2021). Conjugated Monoclonal Antibodies
are Monoclonal Antibodies that are combined with a chemotherapy drug. When the mAb targets
the specific protein on the cancer cell, the chemotherapy drug will then destroy that cell. In this
case, the Conjugated mAb of choice is Inotuzumab Ozogamicin (Besponsa) which is used in the
treatment of someone with B-cell ALL that has relapsed or is resistant to other treatments. The
mAb is the pathway to the cancer cell for the chemotherapy drug to destroy that cell
(Chemocare, n.d.). Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T-cell immunotherapy uses the body's
naturally produced T-cells in part of the treatment of ALL. Before starting CAR T-cell therapy,
you will usually be given a different form of treatment such as chemotherapy for a couple of
days leading up to a procedure called Leukapheresis. During Leukapheresis, all of the T-cells (a
form of white blood cell) are taken out of the bloodstream. The T-cells are then altered in a
laboratory to have receptors on them so they can find and attach to certain cancer cells once
infused back into the body. For the treatment of ALL, the type of CAR T-cell immunotherapy
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 10
used is- Tisagenlecleucel (Kymriah). There are many different subgroups of ALL- the most
common being B-cell ALL and T-cell ALL, and many different factors that play into which kind
of immunotherapy a patient will receive. The overall effectiveness in the treatment of ALL with
immunotherapy also depends on many factors such as the type of ALL a person has, the stage
they are in with their ALL, the type of immunotherapy used, the types of other treatments they
have received, their age, and most of all: their overall health (Seladi-Schulman Ph.D., 2021).
With ALL, the five-year survival rate continues at a low rate due to relapses being at such
a high percentage. It is hoped that immunotherapy increases the rate of relapsed and resistant
blood cell cancers due to immunotherapy not having to depend on mechanisms that are so toxic
to healthy cells. An article by Shang et.al (2019) explained the different immunotherapies and
their mechanisms of action. Conventional cancer treatments such as Chemotherapy have been
around and used for many years now. Most patients will end up in remission but that does not
stop them from relapsing, gaining resistance to the treatments, and leading to the progression of
the disease and mortality. For ALL, immunotherapy targets for treatment are CD19, CD20,
CD22, and CD52 which are tumor markers. In the article Shang et.al (2019) explained that an
Anti-CD22 agent that produces higher remission rates in patients with either a high or low
number of cancer cells. Blinatumomab- a Monoclonal Antibody that targets CD19 has a higher
remission rate in patients with only a low number of cancer cells. Another immunotherapy used
is Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T-cell therapy. The (CAR) T-cell therapy focuses on tumor
marker CD19 and produces high remission rates greater than 70% without added treatments and
continuous remission. In order to improve the remission rates, it was noted in the article that
instead of using the patient's own T-cells, modifying them in the laboratory then inserting them
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 11
back into the patient, they would focus on redesigning the Chimeric Antigen Receptor and use
healthy donor cells to implant into the patient (Shang et.al, 2019). Concluding the article, Shang
et.al expressed, “The use of immunotherapy in the treatment of Acute Leukemia has greatly
improved the choice of treatment” (2019, para. 48). With immunotherapy agents used in the
treatment of ALL, there is still further research needed due to toxic side effects on healthy cells.
There have been many theories and studies implying that immunotherapies used to treat
cancer led to cardiovascular problems later on in life. Although some studies may lead you to
believe that immunotherapy agents may be safer than chemotherapy and radiation therapy, the
fact of the unknown is what may be the frightening factor. Immunotherapy agents are broken
down into two main groups, Active and Passive Immunotherapy. Immune Checkpoint Inhibitors
are immunotherapy agents that have recently been introduced in cancer therapy (Lobenwein et
al., 2020). Where the fear comes into play is the factor that the cardiotoxic risks of most
immunotherapies are unknown, since they are all so relatively new to the world. There have been
many studies that have been done on patients receiving immunotherapy. The main
cardiovascular side effect that has been brought to the table from these Immune Checkpoint
Inhibitors has been myocarditis. According to Lobenwein et al., “Patients diagnosed with
autoimmune myocarditis present with clinical signs of heart failure such as dyspnea, edema, and
fatigue. Angina pectoris, myocardial infarction, cardiac arrest, and cardiac shock due to
arrhythmias have also been described” (2020, p. 181). With the symptoms of adverse
cardiovascular effects coming about in these patients, the fear of the unknown becomes a big
scare in immunotherapy.
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 12
immune system in a different way. This is a newer class of monoclonal antibodies. With this type
of immunotherapy, T-cells are activated, cytokines are produced, and the cancer is looked to be
killed off. Although they try to use a different approach, many cardiovascular side effects are
still in the picture. Just a couple of acute symptoms are tachycardia and hypotension. Looking at
some long-term effects of this type of immunotherapy are fatal heart failure, myocarditis, and
myocardial infarction. This specific type of immunotherapy poses risks for severe side effects
Another big treatment for cancers that pose risks is cytokine therapy. What this treatment
does is activates white blood cells to fight off infections, classified as a non-specific humoral
immunity (Lobenwein et al., 2020). Cytokine therapy is used for other cancer treatments as well
as Leukemia. One of the biggest side effects of this type of treatment is dilatative
cardiomyopathy. This is a condition that occurs when the left ventricle of the heart is enlarged.
This poses a big problem because it affects the heart’s ability to pump oxygenated blood to the
rest of the body. Autoimmune pericarditis, pericardial effusion with cardiac tamponade,
arrhythmias, and ischemic heart disease are all possible effects stemming from this specific type
of immunotherapy.
When these immunotherapies work to activate T-cells to treat these cancers, the
cardiovascular side effects mainly come from cytokine release syndrome. This is when large
amounts of cytokines get released causing severe or life-threatening effects. Trouble breathing,
tachycardia, and hypotension are a few key indicators of this happening. With all the different
immunotherapies out there, it is very interesting how well they can work. The fear comes into
play due to the factor of not knowing just how safe these therapies can be. Immunotherapy for
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 13
the most part is still relatively new to the cancer treatment world. Many negative cardiovascular
side effects are already known, and there are still many more studies going on to show how much
Two studies were conducted to implement monitoring signs for cardiotoxicity early on
for ALL survivors whether they received chemotherapy or immunotherapy from the data they
collected. These studies were assessed by using different methods. The first study had different
comprehensive test that assesses a variety of cardiac and pulmonary conditions to determine
whether the heart, lungs, or skeletal muscles limit exercise capacity. Serum biomarkers are taken
via blood tests to indicate the presence, risk, or stage of the disease. Echocardiography is an
imaging test that is also known as a heart ultrasound. Tissue Doppler is a method used that
measures myocardial velocity. Speckle tracking is utilized to assess the function of left
The second study utilized methods varying from 2D echo, TDI, TTE, and 3D echo. 2D
echo is an ultrasound examination that uses very high-frequency sounds to make real-time
pictures and videos of your heart. TTE is a transthoracic echocardiogram test involving sound
waves to create images of the heart and is used to determine how well the heart is functioning
and identify causes of cardiac-related symptoms. The 3D echo technique is used to improve
image quality and reader confidence and assess structure and functionality. The goals of each
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 14
study are aligned with the intention to prevent future ALL patients from developing cardiac
diseases.
The first study had a sample size of seventy-nine pediatric cancer survivors ranging from
the ages of zero to eighteen years. The sample size was compared to a group of forty genders and
age matched with HCM or hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. The results from the first study are that
all patients were asymptomatic during the follow-up. Some abnormalities that were detected
capacity on CPED and evidence of diastolic dysfunction when using the tissue Doppler
echocardiography. The significance behind these results is that they have discovered a
correlation between the increased dosage of anthracycline during treatment and cardiac
compared to the remaining patients. Twenty-six patients, most of them with Hodgkin lymphomas
and relapse ALL, also received mediastinal irradiation with heart exposure. All patients with
relapse ALL and one patient with ALL received mediastinal irradiation in the setting of total
body irradiation for preparation to bone marrow transplant” (Wolf et al., 2020, para. 16). These
results were obtained from cardiac serum biomarkers, decreased exercise capacity on CPET,
along with any abnormalities that were identified with speckle tracking and TDI.
The results from the second study conducted did not have any significant major
differences in 2D LVEF (left ventricle ejection fraction), diastolic parameters, & speckle
tracking derived myocardial strain were monitored between patients receiving treatment with
anthracyclines and controls. The findings from this study indicate that long-term CCS who have
However, further research studies need to be conducted to perform the validity of new imaging
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 15
techniques. For example, the TTE and 3D Echo, to identify patients that may potentially be at
risk for cardiomyopathy in the long-term follow-up of CCS. “Novel imaging techniques,
including ST imaging and 3D echo, have been investigated, but further longitudinal studies are
necessary to clarify and optimize their role in routine clinical practice. The challenge with these
predictive of subsequent overt LV dysfunction, which might allow the identification of patients
at risk and undertaking early preventive strategies” (Sofia et al., 2021, para. 43). More research is
Conclusion
Overall, by looking at all of the studies it was shown that the use of chemotherapy agents
such as AC and DNR increased the risk of cardiotoxicity in acute lymphoblastic leukemia
patients during their treatment regimens. As for immunotherapy, more patients were shown to
have cardiovascular issues years after their initial treatment when they would be considered
"survivors" of ALL. Therefore, with the rise in the incidence of cardiovascular effects from
cancer treatments the need for early detection and prevention has been examined. Through
echocardiography and other invasive equipment, patients may have features of myocardial dial
dysfunction. Moving forward there needs to be more research into the cardiac effects of both
potential risks.
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 16
References
Carter, D. (2021, November 10). T cells, B cells and the immune system. MD Anderson
immune-system.h00-159465579.html
Chemotherapy drugs: Types, how they work & side effects. (n.d). Cleveland Clinic.
Chemotherapy Drugs: Types, How They Work & Side Effects (clevelandclinic.org)
Hau, E. M., Caccia, J. N., Kasteler, R., Spycher , B., Suter , T., Ammann , R. A., Von der
Weid X, N., & Kuehni, C. E. (2019). Cardiovascular disease after childhood acute
https://doi.org/10.4414/smw.2019.20012
info/inotuzumab-ozogamicin.aspx#:~:text=Drug%20Type%3A%20Inotuzumab
%20ozogamicin%20is,Inotuzumab%20Ozogamicin%20Works%22%20below
Lobenwein, D., Kocher, F., Dobner, S., Gollmann-Tepekoylu, C., & Holfeld, J. (2020).
Mandal, D.A. (2019, February 26). Chemotherapy principles. News Medical & Life
Sciences. https://www.news-medical.net/health/Chemotherapy-Principles.aspx
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 17
Markman, M. (2022, July 12). B-cells vs. T-cells: What are helper, killer and cytotoxic T
are-b-cells-vs-t-cells
https://www.healthline.com/health/leukemia/immunotherapy-for-leukemia#takeaway
Shang, Y., & Zhou, F. (2019). Current advances in immunotherapy for acute leukemia: An
Sofia, R., Melita, V., De Vita, A., Ruggiero, A., Romano, A., Attinà, G., Birritella, L.,
Lamendola, P., Lombardo, A., Lanza, G. A., & Delogu, A. B. (2021). Cardiac
https://doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2021.624057
Wolf, C. M., Reiner, B., Kühn, A., Hager, A., Müller, J., Meierhofer, C., Oberhoffer, R.,
Ewert, P., Schmid, I., & Weil, J. (2020). Subclinical cardiac dysfunction in childhood
in Pediatrics, 8. https://doi.org/10.3389/fped.2020.00123
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE IN ALL PATIENTS 18
Yu, H., Qiu, Y., Wang, Z., Xu, J., Peng, Y., Wan, X., Wu, X., Jin, R., & Zhou, F. (2021).
https://doi.org/10.3389/fphar.2021.598708