Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Precceived eWOM and Students's University Ẻnolment Intention
Precceived eWOM and Students's University Ẻnolment Intention
Precceived eWOM and Students's University Ẻnolment Intention
net/publication/335259577
CITATIONS READS
13 1,144
2 authors:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mahmoud Saleh on 20 August 2019.
Authors’ contributions
This work was carried out by the two authors. They designed the research methodology, managed
and wrote the literature review, collected the primary data, performed the statistical analysis, wrote the
findings and recommendations and approved the final manuscript.
Article Information
DOI: 10.9734/JEMT/2019/v24i130152
Editor(s):
(1) Dr. O. Felix Ayadi, Interim Associate Dean and JP Morgan Chase Professor of Finance, Jesse H. Jones School of
Business, Texas Southern University, TX, USA.
Reviewers:
(1) Dr. Borislav Kolaric, University Union - Nikola Tesla, Serbia.
(2) Gengeswari Krishnapillai, Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman, Malaysia.
(3) Margarita Išoraitė, Vilniaus kolegija/University Applied Sciences, Lithuania.
Complete Peer Review History: http://www.sdiarticle3.com/review-history/49228
ABSTRACT
The advancement of internet technologies and the emergence of social media platforms have made
the influence of electronic word of mouth (eWOM) more pronounced than ever before on
consumers’ purchase decisions, especially young consumers who are more engaged with new
technologies and social networks. Through social media platforms, young consumers nowadays are
always connected to friends, families and organizations on smartphones, tablets or computers and
actively look for eWOM before making purchase decisions. This study is aimed at examining the
effect of perceived eWOM on the university enrolment intentions by the Saudi high school students
mediated by the corporate image of the university. The sample comprised of 133 high school
students studying in Saudi high secondary schools. The findings revealed that electronic word of
mouth (eWOM) had a significant and positive association with the students’ enrolment intentions,
and the corporate image mediates this relationship. This research’s findings and recommendations
can largely help who are in charge of the private and public universities in Saudi Arabia to
understand how eWOM shapes the university choices of students.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Keywords: Electronic word of mouth; eWOM credibility; eWOM quality; eWOM quantity; university
enrolment; purchase intention.
2
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
study finding may help the competitive university school students of Saudi Arabia are mostly
to develop its marketing strategies to improve heavy users of social networking sites and
their corporate image on social media, taking into remain always connected with friends and family
account that the researchers did not find any [18]. As Saudi students use social media, the
similar studies regarding the scope of this effect of electronic word of mouth is appropriate
research. Thus, the main objective of this paper and relevant in this study context. The university
is to examine this relationship in depth by enrolment intention, which means here the
considering the association of perceived eWOM secondary school students’ choices for
factors namely: eWOM credibility, eWOM quality, universities for higher education, represents a
eWOM quantity with choice and university key dependent variable in the study. The
enrolment intentions from student’s perspective. university enrolment intention will help in
This study will also examine the mediating role revealing effectiveness and influence of eWOM
played by corporate image of universities on students’ decision-making process for seeking
between perceived eWOM factors and choice an admission to a university.
and enrolment intentions among Saudi high
school students who are active on social 2.2 Perceived eWOM
networking sites.
In today’s digital era, eWOM plays an influential
2. CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK AND role in shaping purchasing decisions [2]. Hennig-
HYPOTHESES DEVELOPMENT Thurau et al. [4] defined electronic word of mouth
(eWOM) as any positive or negative statements
2.1 Enrolment (Purchase) Intention made by users for prospective users of products
and services on the internet. Previous studies in
As a whole, purchase intention refers to the hospitality, automobile and electronics context
consumer’s willingness to buy a product or a reveal that positive statements lead to favorable
service in future [23]. Purchase intention is a key purchase intentions and harness good corporate
variable in learning and understanding about the image [31,9,32]. Positive ewom is a boon for
effectiveness of promotions undertaken by any companies because it reduces advertising costs
marketing entity [24]. Most of the studies use and increases sales [32]. In some studies,
purchase intention in order to measure negative eWOM proves to be detrimental of the
effectiveness of advertisements [25]. However, in organization’s sales and corporate image [12].
today’s digital and “always connected with According to Nam et al. [11] consumers tend to
friends and families age”, studies also use remember negative eWOMs more than positive
purchase intention to understand and measure eWOMs. However, negative statements about a
the effectiveness of electronic word of mouth product or service doesn’t necessarily always
[25]. Purchase intention is an important variable result in detrimental effects on purchase
in judging the outcome of EWOM [10]. In a study intentions [11]. Similarly, positive statements
conducted by Dehghani & Tumer [26], electronic alone do not always necessarily lead to favorable
word of mouth was found to be of substantial purchase intentions because on the internet
influence in shaping purchasing decisions for anybody is free to write reviews, posts,
products and services. comments on products and services which can
sometimes be biased and of incorrect evaluation
For secondary school students who intend to [33]. Selecting a university for pursuing higher
enroll in a university refers to bearing tuition, education requires high involvement in the
fees, books and general academic expenses of a decision making process by students as it
university [27,21,22,28]. Previous researchers involves paying for tuition, fees, books and
have found links between electronic word of general expenses for academic purposes [22].
mouth (eWOM) and enrolment intention for high Students look for information to be credible, of
school students who aspire for admission in good quality and quantity in electronic word of
universities for higher education [27,29,30]. In a mouth [27,22].
study conducted by Bataineh [27] in Jordan, the
eWOM was significantly found to shape A study conducted on Taiwanese students
intentions of high school students for choosing a through in-depth interviews by Yang & Mutum
university for higher education in Jordan. In [21] suggests that students value quality and
Saudi Arabia the effect of eWOM on how truthfulness of EWOM in shaping their decision
secondary school students make a choice for a of choosing a university. In a study conducted in
university remains largely unexplored. Secondary Jordan by Bataineh [27], a university’s corporate
3
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
image was found to mediate the relationships presumed to be credible electronic word of
between eWOM and university enrolment mouth in Saudi Arabian context. Thus, the first
intention of high school students. If a university hypothesis is proposed as:
has a good corporate image and information
perceived through EWOM is credible, of good H1: There is a statistically positive association of
quality and quantity, it facilitates purchase eWOM credibility with students’ university
decision making of students [27,22]. Previous enrolment intentions
studies [27] have investigated effects of eWOM
from three angles of eWOM on university 2.2.2 eWOM quality and purchase intentions
enrolment intentions of students namely: eWOM
credibility, eWOM quality and eWOM quantity. The quality of electronic word of mouth can be
When talking about eWOM, these three factors understood as how appealing the information
of perceived eWOM and their relationships with that is provided to consumers [30]. In a study on
enrolment (purchase) intention are mostly consumer products, Park et al. [30] reported a
studied by marketing researchers [27,22]. positive association of eWOM quality with
purchase intention. Another study conducted on
2.2.1 eWOM credibility and purchase Taiwanese students through in-depth interviews
intentions by Yang & Mutum [21] suggests that students
value quality and truthfulness of EWOM in
Electronic word of mouth credibility simply refers shaping their decision of choosing a university.
to how much a consumer believes the When consumers are in the pre-purchase stage,
information obtained through eWOM to be true they seek certain type of information or set
and reliable [34]. The internet does not restrict criteria in their minds [38]. Consumers expect the
anyone from posting reviews, comments about information provided through eWOM to be
products and services on social networking sites relevant, helpful, clear and simple to comprehend
[35]. Students also can post comments about [38]. If the eWOM is irrelevant and complex to
their universities in public on social networking understand, it would hardly make any difference
sites, but the question lies in how eWOM is in consumer’s decision making process [28]. As
perceived to be credible [21,22]. Too much high school students make choices of
positive or too much negative reviews posted prospective universities by communicating with
online are not considered credible by consumers students studying in universities, the quality of
because too positive doesn’t talk about the information matters [28]. Hence, for Saudi high
shortcomings and too negative may come from school students to make decisions about higher
prejudice or hidden personal interests [36,11]. education, the information provided through
EWOM credibility is of paramount importance eWOM should be perceived as relevant, clear
only when it is perceived to be credible and leads and easily understood so that it can aid students
to favorable purchase intention [29]. Regarding in the selection of the prospective university.
the factors that affect choosing professors and Thus, the second hypothesis is proposed as:
courses in USA college students, Steffes &
Burgee [15] found that students perceive H2: There is a statistically positive association of
electronic word of mouth more reliable than eWOM quality with students’ university
traditional person to person word of mouth and enrolment intentions
seek primary information actively through eWOM
to shape their service choice and enrolment 2.2.3 eWOM quantity and purchase intentions
decisions.
EWOM quantity simply refers to the scale of
Since, Saudi youth value social ties [19], they will information available on the internet [39]. Park et
consider the information from the nears and al. [30] in a study on consumer products found
dears more credible on social media rather than that the number of reviews of a product positively
open public reviews and opinions. A study correlates with purchase intention. In a study
among college students in USA by Valenzuela et conducted on undergraduate students, Sher and
al. [37] revealed that social trust increases with Lee [40] found that students when exposed to a
time on Facebook when users add contacts who product review website, they looked only at the
are friends of friends. Therefore, posts, reviews, number of product reviews to shape their
and messages from friends and a friend of purchase intention. Park et al. [30] also found
friends on social networking sites of high school that consumers who are less involved in the
students studying in Saudi universities will be decision making process refer to the number of
4
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
positive or negative reviews of a product only. mediating variable between eWOM and students’
However, for high involvement decision making, enrolment intention of universities. Thus, the
consumers looked both for quality as well as fourth hypothesis is proposed as:
quantity of eWOM. Students, during their
decision-making process about higher education, H4: The associations of eWOM credibility,
also seek information on a greater scale through eWOM quality and eWOM quantity with
electronic word of mouth besides checking students’ university enrolment intentions are
university websites [21,22,28]. As universities are mediated by the university’s corporate image
primarily service organizations and their products
being intangible [19], thus, Saudi students will 3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
ask for greater information from the ones who
are consuming educational experience of 3.1 Population and Sample
studying in various universities. Thus, the third
hypothesis is proposed as: The population for this study was all secondary
school students studying in Riyadh city of Saudi
H3: There is a statistically positive association of Arabia. The sample for the study was
eWOM quantity with students’ university convenience non-probability sampling method,
enrolment intentions represented by 133 secondary school students
who responded to the study’s data collection
2.3 Corporate Image as a Mediator questionnaire. Secondary schools in Riyadh
between eWOM and Purchase were selected to be the scope of this study
Intentions because Riyadh city represents about 25% of the
total population in Saudi Arabia, and the
Secondary school students in Riyadh represent
Previous studies in hospitality, automobile and
23% of the total secondary school students in
electronics context reveal that positive
Saudi Arabia’s administrative regions [17].
statements lead to favorable purchase intentions
and harness good corporate image [31,9,32]. 3.2 Measurement
According to Gray [41], corporate image refers to
the general perception of an organization in The survey method was used to collect the
public. The level of knowledge held in the primary data needed to test the study
consumer’s memory of the organization’s image hypotheses. The questionnaire was distributed
helps consumers in reducing risk associated with both manually and electronically. Only students
the purchase [41]. Torlak et al. [10] found that the who were active and used social media were
corporate image mediated relationship between selected. Specifically, students who had an
eWOM and purchase intention in Turkish active account on any one of these social
students when considering purchase of networking sites like Facebook, Twitter, YouTube
cellphones. A university cares about good and Instagram were selected for this study. A
corporate image, so that it can attract students of filtering question was used to reveal if the
great caliber [42]. In a study conducted in respondent had an active account on the above-
Romania by Avram [42], it was found that when mentioned social networking sites. The
students had good experience in their independent variables eWOM credibility, eWOM
universities, their willingness to promote their quality and eWOM quantity were measured by
university through word of mouth was high. adapting Bataineh [27] scales. Corporate image
Promotion of universities through word of mouth and university enrolment intention were
not only helps in enhancing corporate image but measured using scales of Chen et al. [24]. All
also helps in attracting future prospective scales were adapted to suit the Saudi
students [42]. In another study conducted in universities context and culture. The variables
Jordan by Bataineih [27], corporate image was were measured using a 5-pointLikertscaleranging
found to significantly mediate the relationships from strongly disagree (1) to strongly agree (5).
between eWOM and intention to join a university
among Jordanian high school students. 3.3 Procedure
Damayanti and Subriadi [43] revealed a positive
relationship between eWOM and the university The survey responses were coded in the SPSS
image. Since, there is a limited number of studies statistical software for data analysis. The
in Saudi Arabia that examine corporate image’s analysis begins with descriptive analysis of the
mediating effect, this paper will examine sample. Content and face validity was conducted
corporate image of various universities as by some marketing academicians and students
5
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
before distributing the questionnaire to check of the respondents (72.9%) accessed their social
initially whether the scales are measuring the media accounts more than 5 times per day. Only
intended dimensions and in obvious articulation. 3% of the respondents accessed their accounts
A back translation from Arabic to English was once a day, so it can be clearly inferred that the
also done to be sure that the meaning of each young Saudi high school students are active on
item is the same as the original scales. social media sites. The most preferred activities
Exploratory Factor analysis was conducted first of the respondents were posting comments
to test the sample adequacy, and second, with 44.4%, followed by searching for products and
AVE and discriminant validity, on the data services 26.3% and chatting 23.3% on social
collected to test the scales construct validity. The networking sites. Making new friends was the
reliability of the measures is checked by least preferred activity 6% on the social media of
Cronbach Alpha and composite reliability after the respondents. The table clearly shows that the
factor analysis. Lastly, after checking the students engage in reading online reviews and
reliability, the hypothesis of our study was tested comments about products and services. It is also
using multiple regression analysis. evident that 51.9% of the respondents had less
than 5 friends who were studying in various
4. FINDINGS universities in Riyadh. 25.6% of the respondents
had more than 11 friends followed by 22.6%
4.1 Sample Characteristics which had more than 6 but less than 10 friends. It
can be inferred that the respondents of the
From the initial analysis, as shown in Table 1, the secondary school students have friends online
sample exhibited highest users of Twitter 52.6%, elder to them who are studying in various
followed by Instagram 23.3% and YouTube universities in Riyadh. Lastly, the sample
21.1%. Facebook was the least used consisted mostly of male secondary school
representing 3% of the study respondents. Most students 97.7%.
6
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
4.2 Descriptive Statistics (.000<.05) and thus indicates that the data can
be factorized.
The responses of the variables of our study were
coded as “1” for “Strongly Disagree”, “2” for Table 4 shows the factor loadings of each of the
“Disagree”, “3” as “Neutral”, “4” for “Agree” and study five constructs. According to Fornell and
“5” for “Strongly agree”. Table 2 shows the mean Larcker [45], the average variance extracted
values of the respective variables of this study. (AVE) and composite reliability(CR) should be
All the variables for electronic word of mouth above than .5 and .6. For all of the constructs the
have Mean values above 3, which indicates that AVE can be seen above .5 except for corporate
the electronic word of mouth is perceived to be image “.49” and CR well above .6 for all the
credible, of good quality and quantity. Most of the constructs. Fornell & Larcker [45] also suggest if
respondents agree that there is an overwhelming an AVE value is less than .5 it can be accepted
quantity of electronic word of mouth about but with CR higher than .6, in our case the CR for
universities available in the form of reviews, corporate image is “.88” far above .6 and hence
comments and recommendations in the social can be accepted. DeVellis [46] and Kline [47]
media as the Mean is 3.47. Also, presence of suggest the higher the number of Cronbach
perceived corporate images of universities is alpha greater the internal consistency, however
evident from the Table 6 below as it has a mean both are of the opinion .6 can be used as an
value of “3.6” which indicates most of the acceptable threshold. All the variables reported
respondents agree that they have some kind of higher Cronbach alpha greater than .6 which can
overall perception built of universities. Lastly, be seen in the Table 4.
secondary school students do keep an intention To be further sure that construct validity is not
of getting admission to prospective universities violated, check for any possible violation of
which are talked about on the social media as discriminant validity is needed. John and Benet-
their mean is reported “3.30” leaning towards Martinez [48] suggest the criteria for checking
agreement. discriminant validity is that the square root of the
average variance extracted (AVE) should be
4.3 Validity and Reliability greater than the correlations with the other
constructs of a particular construct. Employing
Since the scales are adapted from prior studies, John & Benet-Martinez method [48], Table 5
exploratory factor analysis was employed using shows the respective squared AVE values of
principle component analysis to confirm each construct and their correlations with each
whether the scales are measuring the same other. The square roots of all the AVE values are
dimensions which are intended to be measured. clearly seen well above the individual
The overall Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of correlations of constructs presented in rows and
Sampling Adequacy (KMO) is seen to “.768” from columns. Thus, it could be concluded that the
Table 3 which is greater than the acceptable measures are indeed distinct and well
range of .7suggested by Kaiser [44]. The discriminant. According, the scales can thus be
individual measures for all the five considered as valid and reliable. It is now
variables reported KMO above .7. The p value of possible to proceed to test hypotheses of the
Bartlett’s test of sphericity is less than .05 study using regression analysis.
7
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
8
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
Constructs 1 2 3 4 5
1 eWOM Credibility .74
2 eWOM Quality .292 .78
3 eWOM Quantity .084 .265 .75
4 Corporate Image .215 .429 .575 .70
5 University enrolment Intention .277 .330 .355 .467 .76
Table 7. Regression model for corporate image and university enrolment intention
9
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
10
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
enrolment intention of young Saudi high school trend of the previous studies is a positive
students in the context of acquiring higher association between eWOM and the consumer
education. The study reported that electronic choice, which is also demonstrated by this study.
word of mouth (eWOM) has a significant and In this study, electronic word of mouth was found
positive relationship with the intention of enrolling clearly influencing decisions of Saudi high school
at a university for higher studies among Saudi students in choosing universities for higher
high school students. This research can largely education. This means that the information
help persons in charge of private and public exchanged in social media is of great benefit to
universities to understand how eWOM shapes marketers in enhancing the corporate image.
choices of university among Saudi students. The
information obtained through eWOM was found The genuine grievances of university students
to be credible significantly by Saudi high school can be addressed by scanning and responding to
students and this can be because the Saudis their messages on social media platforms, so
overall value social ties and believe in helping that the possible spread of negative eWOM is
each other by providing their opinions about their kept in check. Active presence of universities
experience of studying in various universities. As needs to be maintained on the social media
previous studies have indicated [30,27], high platforms like Facebook, Instagram, twitter,
involvement decision making demands for both YouTube etc. which are used by students
eWOM quality and quantity, in this study Saudi heavily. Moreover, universities can promote their
students also look for eWOM quality and eWOM achievements, satisfaction of students with
quantity, as it is a life changing event choosing a quality education and much more on social
university for higher education. media platforms, so that efforts are directed
towards genuine positive eWOM of universities
Regarding the mediating role of brand image on on the internet.
the relationship between eWOM and Purchase
intention, previous studies (e.g. Jalilvand) found The universities in Saudi Arabia need to take the
that brand image is a mediator [9]. The current influence of eWOM into cognizance. The
study found that corporate image of universities universities may need to devote an information
did mediate relationships fully between eWOM technology section in university’s marketing
quality and eWOM quantity and partially for departments which scans the social media
eWOM credibility with purchase intention. platforms for negative electronic word of mouth
Corporate image along with eWOM quality and on a regular basis. It is necessary to scan and
eWOM quantity aids in decision making among look for negative electronic word of mouth as
high school students. A good corporate image numerous researches in the past have
corresponded with positive eWOM quality and suggested negative electronic word mouth to be
eWOM quantity will make decision making more dangerous and detrimental for university
simple for high school students, validating a enrolment intentions of students. Social media
study by Damayanti and Subriadi [43] who found provide platforms for grievances, genuine
that eWOM is a path to build the image of the criticisms, and dissatisfaction for students. The
university. The reason why corporate image comments on social media can also help
partially mediated eWOM credibility and universities develop their products and
enrolment intention in this study may be educational environment including: admission
attributed to the student selectivity which makes criteria and procedures, curricula, educational
them not in full agreement with is said about the facilities, extracurricular activities, and any other
universities because comments and reviews dimension of the marketing strategies in
cannot be said to be always free from personal universities as education service providers.
prejudice. Consumer behavior studies looking in social
media sites could be useful for marketing
7. CONCLUSIONS AND MARKETING
strategy planning.
IMPLICATIONS
Social media websites such as Facebook and 8. LIMITATIONS AND FUTURE
Twitter have become a source of information for RESEARCH DIRECTIONS
developing marketing strategy. Consumer stake
information of eWOM more credible than formal One limitation of this study is the less inclusion of
sources. This could be attributed to the female secondary school students in the study
consumer’s belief that this information is more sample, this is attributed to the non-probability
experiential and from non-beneficiaries. The sampling method that adopted in the study.
11
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
12
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
13
Balroo and Saleh; JEMT, 24(1): 1-14, 2019; Article no.JEMT.49228
37. Valenzuela S, Park N, Kee KF. Is there 43. Damayanti, Surbriadi AP. Electronic word
social capital in a social network site: of mouth (E-WOM): A Pathto Buildthe
Facebook use and college students' life Imageof University. Journal of Theoretical
satisfaction, trust, and participation? and Applied Information Technology. 2016;
Journal of Computer-mediated Communi- 94(1)123-132.
cation. 2009;14(4):875-901. Available:http://www.jatit.org/volumes/Vol9
DOI: 10.1111/j.1083-6101.2009.01474.x 4No1/12Vol94No1.pdf
38. Cheung EA. The impact of electronic word- 44. Kaiser HF. An index of factorial simplicity.
of-mouth: The adoption of online opinions Psychometrika. 1974;39:32-36.
in online customer communities. Internet 45. Fornell C, Larcker DF. Evaluating
Research. 2008;18(3):229-247. structural equation models with unob-
DOI: 10.1108/10662240810883290 servable variables and measurement error.
39. Park DH, Lee J. eWOM overload and its Journal of Marketing Research. 1981;
effect on customer behavioral intention 18(1):39-50.
depending on customer involvement. 46. DeVellis RF. Scale development: Theory
nd
Electronic Commerce Research and and applications (2 ed.). Thousand Oaks,
Applications. 2008;7(4):386. CA: Sage Publications; 2003.
DOI: 10.1016/j.elerap.2007.11.004 47. Kline RB. Principles and practice of
nd
40. Sher PJ, Lee SH. Customer skepticism structural equation modeling (2 ed.). New
and online reviews: An elaboration York: Guildford; 2005.
likelihood model perspective. Social 48. John OP, Benet-Martinez V. Measurement:
Behavior and Personality. 2009;37(1):137- Reliability, construct validation, and scale
144. construction. Handbook of research
41. Gray G. Interaction of learner control and methods in social and personality psycho-
prior understanding in computer-assisted logy. Cambridge: Cambridge University
video instruction. Journal of Educational Press; 2000.
Psychology. 1986;78(3):225. 49. Baron RM, Kenny DA. The moderator–
42. Avram EM. The relationship between mediator variable distinction in social
the university image and students' psychological research: Conceptual,
willingness to recommend it. Cross- strategic, and statistical considerations.
Cultural Management Journal. 2016;18(2): Journal of Personality and Social
115-123. Psychology. 1986;51(6):1173.
_________________________________________________________________________________
© 2019 Balroo and Saleh; This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution
License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Peer-review history:
The peer review history for this paper can be accessed here:
http://www.sdiarticle3.com/review-history/49228
14