Register

Sign In
Home
News
Sport
Business
Innovation
Culture
Travel
Earth
Video
Live

Boom times for US green energy as federal cash flows in

8 April 2024
By Zoe Corbyn,
San Francisco

Share
Getty Images US President Joe Biden signs into law the Inflation Reduction Act of
2022 in the State Dining Room of the White House on Tuesday August 16, 2022.Getty
Images
President Biden signed the Inflation Reduction Act into law in August 2022
In February US company LanzaJet, which produces sustainable aviation fuel (SAF)
from ethanol, announced that it intended to build a second, larger plant on US
soil.

The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) was a "big influence", says Jimmy Samartzis, its
chief executive.

The second plant would add to its facility in Soperton, Georgia - the world's first
commercial scale ethanol-to-SAF plant.

"We have a global landscape that we are pursuing…[but] we have doubled down on
building here in the United States because of the tax credits in the IRA, and
because of the overall support system that the US government has put in place."

Signed into law by President Biden in August 2022, the IRA, along with the so-
called Bipartisan Infrastructure Law (BIL) enacted in November 2021, are intended,
amongst other things, to funnel billions of federal dollars into developing clean
energy.

The aim is to lower greenhouse gas emissions, and incentivise private investment,
to encourage the growth of green industries and jobs: a new foundation for the US
economy.

With a 10-year lifespan, and a cost originally estimated at $391bn (£310bn) but now
predicted to reach over $1tn - the final figure is unknown - the IRA offers new and
juicer tax credits, as well as loans and loan guarantees for the deployment of
emissions reducing technology.

The tax credits are available to companies for either domestically producing clean
energy, or domestically manufacturing the equipment needed for the energy
transition, including electric vehicles (EVs) and batteries.

Consumers can also receive tax credits, for example for buying an EV or installing
a heat pump. The tax credit for SAF producers like LanzaJet is new in the IRA and,
offers between $1.25 to $1.75 per gallon of SAF (though it only lasts five years).
Complementary is the BIL, which runs for five years and provides direct investment
largely in the form of government grants for research and development and capital
projects. Under the BIL, about $77bn (£61bn) will go to clean energy technology
projects, according to the Brookings Institution which monitors the law.

Ascend Elements EV battery recycling company Ascend Elements.Ascend Elements

Ascend Elements extracts useful materials from old batteries
One company to benefit so far is EV battery recycling company Ascend Elements.

It has won BIL grants totalling $480m (£380m), which it is matching a similar
amount in private investment to build its second commercial facility in
Hopkinsville, Kentucky.

"[The IRA and BIL] are massive investments… larger than the infrastructure related
provisions in the New Deal," says Adie Tromer from the Brookings. "There is a clear
sense that America has become more serious about transitioning to a cleaner
economy."

While rules for some tax credits are still being finalized, tens of billions in
actual public spending is flowing into the economy, says Trevor Houser at the
Rhodium Group, an independent research provider. Rhodium, together with the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, runs the Clean Investment Monitor (CIM) to
track US clean technology investments.

According to recently updated CIM data, in the 2023 fiscal year, the federal
government invested approximately $34bn (£27bn) into clean energy, the vast
majority through tax credits.

The extent to which the policy instruments are so far spurring not just
announcements - of which there are plenty - but real extra private investment is
harder to know: clean energy investment has been on a general upward trend anyway
and the IRA hasn't been around long. But experts believe it is rising.

Total clean energy investment in the US in the 2023 calendar year including from
both private and government sources reached a record $239bn (£190bn), up 38% from
2022 according to the CIM data.

Clean energy investment in the US, as a share of total private investment, rose
from 3.7% in the fourth quarter of 2022 to 5% in the fourth quarter of 2023.

The IRA has had two main positive effects thus far, says Mr Houser.

It has "supercharged" private investment in more mature technologies which were

already growing very rapidly like solar, EVs and batteries.

Getty Images An engineer works on a hybrid direct air carbon capture technology
pilot site in Bakersfield, California, UGetty Images
Emerging technologies like CO2 capture have seen "dramatic" growth in investment
It has also, combined with the BIL, led to a "dramatic growth" in investment in
emerging climate technologies like clean hydrogen, carbon dioxide capture and
removal and SAF. While the total magnitude of those investments are still
relatively small compared to the more mature technologies, "the IRA fundamentally
changed the economics" says Mr Houser.

But the IRA is failing to reach some parts of the green economy: so far it hasn't
lifted investment in more mature technologies which have been falling like wind and
heat pumps, though Mr Houser notes things may have fallen further without the IRA.
On the industry's mind is the fate of the laws, particularly the longer-to-run IRA,
should there be a change of government in the US November elections.

Repealing or amending the IRA (or BIL) would require Republican control of the
Presidency, Senate and House - though wholesale repeal would likely face meaningful
opposition from within. The rub is many of the projects that the IRA is
incentivising are being or will be built in Republican states or counties.

Yet a Republican president alone could potentially frustrate things for example by
slowing or deferring loans or grants, or amending the rules which serve the laws.
"A Trump presidency would definitely chill the atmosphere and possibly more," says
Ashur Nissan of Kaya Partners, a climate policy advice firm.

The Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank and purveyor of hard-right ideas
for the next conservative President, advocates repeal for both the IRA and BIL. For
the organization's Diana Furchtgott-Roth, a former Trump administration official,
it is fiscally irresponsible for the US, with its vast deficit and debt, to be
spending like this.

It is also time, she says, that renewable energy such as solar and wind, into which
subsidies have been poured for years, stood on their own feet.

Yet others argue the US can't afford not to take this path. And the point of the
loans program is to take risks to help unlock new solutions that scale. "It would
be failing if there weren't any so called 'failures' within it," says Richard
Youngman, of Cleantech Group, a research and consulting firm.

Presentational grey line

More technology of business

The rise of magnets – from surgery to outer space

Why there's a revolution on the way in glass making
Could AI take the grind out of accountancy?
‘I want to help people fly – and keep them safe’
How Temu is shaking-up the world of online shopping
Presentational grey line
Meanwhile, the US's approach is putting competitive pressure on Europe to do more.

Some European clean energy manufacturing companies are now building facilities in
the US to take advantage of the tax credits that otherwise would have been built in
Europe including solar panel maker Meyer Burger and electrolyser manufacturers Nel
and John Cockerill.

"The US wasn't a market for some of these companies in the past because Europe was
more active," says Brandon Hurlbut, of Boundary Stone Partners, a clean energy
advisory firm.

The EU's Net Zero Industrial Act (NZIA) is expected to enter into force this year.
It doesn't involve new money, but seeks to coordinate existing financing and
introduces domestic favourability for the first time - putting in place a non-
binding target for the bloc to locally manufacture 40% of its clean energy
equipment needs by 2030.

In the UK, chancellor Jeremy Hunt has made clear he isn't interested, nor can the
UK afford to copy the IRA's approach in some "distortive global subsidy race" and
will stick to other ways of helping. The Labour party recently scrapped its $28bn
green investment plan seen as a stab at leaning into an IRA style policy.

A global audience will be watching as the US's clean energy juggernaut unfolds. And
if it leads others to ask what more they can do to produce clean energy products -
even if just for reasons of economic opportunity - it will be good for humanity's
sake, says Mr Hurlbut.

Technology of Business
Joe Biden
Related
The challenge of upgrading iconic steel windows
2 days ago
Business
Even in peaceful countries be ready for a siren blast
6 days ago
Business
The rise of magnets – from surgery to outer space
4 Apr 2024
Business
More
4 hrs ago
US President Joe Biden speaks at Mill 19, a former steel mill being developed into
a robotics research facility, on the campus of Carnegie Mellon University on
January 28, 2022 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Biden calls for tripling tariffs on Chinese metals
It is the latest protectionist policy to be embraced by the White House in an
election year.

Business
23 hrs ago
File image of Joe Biden with his hand to his mouth as he listens to another speaker
Biden treads diplomatic tightrope on Israel-Iran
Iran's unprecedented weekend attack on Israel has changed the US political calculus
in the region.

US & Canada
1 day ago
Beau Biden and Joe Biden
Joe Biden and a life dogged by tragedy
The rise of the 81-year-old to the highest office came despite a series of
tragedies in his personal life.

US & Canada
2 days ago
Prime Minister Rishi Sunak speaking in the House of Commons
Sunak urges restraint after Iran attack on Israel
The prime minister will speak to Israel's Benjamin Netanyahu to discuss how to
prevent escalation.

UK
2 days ago
Split image of Donald Trump and Joe Biden
Where Biden and Trump stand on key issues
How the two candidates' policies compare on the economy, immigration, abortion and
other big issues.

US & Canada
Home
News
Sport
Business
Innovation
Culture
Travel
Earth
Video
Live
Audio
Weather
BBC Shop
BBC in other languages
Terms of Use
About the BBC
Privacy Policy
Cookies
Accessibility Help
Contact the BBC
Advertise with us
Do not share or sell my info
Contact technical support
Copyright 2024 BBC. All rights reserved. The BBC is not responsible for the
content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.

Search news, topics and more

Home

News

Sport

Business

Innovation

Culture

Travel

Earth

Video

Live

Audio

Weather