.

# & $'& / ! " #$

'
 : $

! " #
$ %& ' $ ( ) ) )% * %
.(2001 " +) +,
+ ,% 0 1 + 2 $ 3
78 +) 4 ( 1+ 2 5 6 %
.(2003
6 +% % 9 5 :
8 ; $+ + 7 3
; 6 0 ) ) 6< < * ':5
? < (1992= > ) : + $
6 " " 6 1$ 3 & @ 1 +
.(2003 78 +)4 1+
& < *7& % + + *$ " $ 9A
" 0 * 3 <5 B " 0 C 1@ 8
*2 * 1 < D;0 + = = C 1+ $ # <
(1984) + & + * + 9 ; 6 " C
< : ) < ;0 %80 1 + E
3 < 0 *6 3 =C 1 + ; ( ; 1+ 0 ;0
.(2002 >3 &0 ) 6 B G:
$ ( 1 + & < < ;0 " = < H &6 1 + 6
; " + &$ <4 0 " 9 7 < ;0 * :
3 " < 6 # 1 4 0 +
" 7 " 2 2 <1 * < #: "6& & 7 4
"+ & 4 ;0 " = < : < *
< A: * : " 0 E9 " " A 9< ':
$ 6 *%0 6* :G * : I 7 $2
0 ) ) 0A B < ;0 " = < D0
.(2002 J ; >

1
 +E K ) * < 6 :
4 0 9 I @ A (294) 1 L3 6 + 1 L" A
.(1994 J 7 G ) " A : " A
# A & 6 39 + ; $ 6
:M " 0 $ N , + 1 (1984)
" 0 46 B9 " #; ':* 3 & , (90 )1 + E
" 0 +6 4 1 ) 0A " * 5 : "6 < ;0
. (2002 >3 &0 ) ; 0 " = & $
" 0 $ A ) E 1 & < <
)%2 : H &$ + A E A 6
E < " 0 "
09 ) B ' " $ 4 I 6+
. (1997
+ ;0 " = 4 ! (
;0 E9 <' 6= ; E ! 8
' 9 1+ 6 I 7 9 &0 +3 ) C
* $ < (1992 = ; )* 7 * O 0 9 D$
: : * "E + ; 0 E9 < 6 + <
$ % D# ;0 3 ,9 *;7 L
. % + G J *# K
+ " ; 1+ 38 1 + % L
. 7 D; * 7I
9 29 + * < D0 : L
. * ;7 1 ) 9
( &L 7L + L= ) ";;0 * 9 <, L
.(1997 = ; ) 6+ 4 & 1+ + ; 0 E9 1+
I <% 4 < < 0 D0 +
: :E * + *%0
. I < " $ G: B # & < L

2
 E 7 " H 1+ + < "0 0 L
. 7
" H 1 =A = 3 ,; 1 + @< L
.= I D0 7
B 1 + I D0 7 " $ *# 0 L
.( 1996 " )B
9 ' % :M < E ;0
.(1997 09 ) < 6 + E E
%10 *2 6 A < " 6 6
600 ) " $ 9 * < ( %80) @ 4$ 9
& 7 E9 " ; # < (1998 Q +) 2000 + (
E ) 9 + ( %4 ) R & 7 4 < 6+
,% 0 1 " < 6+ K 3 < ,% 0 * (2001
3 I + +. 0 4 1+ 9 0 6+ ,
: + 0S 4 S " ( 1+ &0 H C *@ < $ 6 " # ; T
9 C #E " 6 +T 1 T " C " ;T H 6 5 +3 & 7 4
+ 1 2 6 + E <3 : H S , 0
. + : 1 < & @ :M
6 1 0 " " A 2 1&
* < 0 :M ;;0 + 1 + :E7 : ) 9 ) 6 ;0
.* < + < + 7 " 0 * <*
$ 6+ 5 < ; 3 "6+
3 <K 5 9 6+ 5 :5 9 8 ;
* & : .. ; $ ,0 ; ,9 ; 9 7 ;0 '
G *%0 * 9 K ; "%9 1 =A
4 :1 + ; 7 < 6+ H H ); ;0
.(1996 " )
8 ;0 " = < &+ I 1+
* 0 79 + & ) B7 <K 6= +
. (1997 09 ) &8 ; :

3
* ) 97 ! 7 : + 29 6 $ " 0 ;6
4 1 5 E $ " 0 +6 4 1+ + 6
* (2002 >3 &0 ) #% E9 B &&0
6 $ , + < $2 < *@ < * 1+ $ 9 * :M
$ + & 7 46 ;0 : 1& + ;
. ;0 ; H
" $ =C < 9 : : ;0 &
1 =A * * < 1+ # * +!
<* = 4 * ' A $ + 'E
" ; H * M : (2002 " +)
. $ " 8 ! 5 6%+ ( 6 4 * < ;0
: )*
4 < +D 3 6& 1+ 1 @ 8
. (1992 = > C) < = ; 6 + ) ) 2 *2 9
& 7 < *7& 15.567 1 *#
. (1999 & < * 7& ) E 1+ "6+ 29 H
;0 " = < * :M " A + I
' : 8 " E * $ " 0 < + 9 D$ E
=E9 E ) E% & + * D <1 $7 " A E9
. (2002 & 7 ; %
;0 ; & 7 + 7;
" A I ;0 * < ;;0 :A
. (1997 09 ) ; 0 " 4 * <9 3 ;$
6 C4 < 29 * 6 + ; 0 5 9
< 5 1+ 3 $ *$ ( @
, @ + 0 < ; 7 1 70 = ( 2M 1
< 9 : % K " 9 $7 & 9 " 6+
. (1991 = ; )
(Lowrenson and Mckinon,1982) 9 6
" + ;0 $ 3 E

4
= D; 0 , 5 9 < *; " 79 +
1 : (Finmian,1986 <) < + < D$
.7 0 3 ;0 " ;
+ , E+ * 6 $ ) 29 K
! 70 9 L 1 –3 U + < E+ I IB
4 B + ": $ = 9 * $ *0
. (1997 09 ) " 79 ;0 " < ;$ 3 I
< *6 ) 5 : ;;0 0 9 K B
4< 6* +, E E7 ;0 " A E9
" ; 46 * K : * !<
1 + B9 A & < : 9
. 6 46
: 1+ 9 9 $ E
!W + ,
. 1 23 ! 4 $ - ./ 0
:5 6 #7 8
: Y 1+ < B# *A 6
: 6 8 :9
6 4 + < ;0 " ; (
.W < @
: 6 6 : &.
"& ( =0. 05) #; ( + )#; < -1
6 4 + < " ; * ;0 "
B# 0 " *:A : " 8 1 (E
. *+ 7
"& ( = 0. 05) # ; ( + )#; * < -2
# Z )" ;
. 6 4 + < ;0 ( 3

5
"& ( = 0. 05) # ; ( + )#; * < -3
(E 6 4 + < " ; * ;0 "
.( 9 $+ ; ) 6+ H 8 1
: 3
: 9 : 4
< " ; * @ + 0M -1
1 + 6 29 46 :1 3 6 + 1+ 6 %
. %; < : ;0
" & * < < & : 6 H &$ : 2 -2
.
+ < < $ & = @ + 0M -3
< "@ % @ < ' < " @ ;0 ;0
. 6 ;$
E 9 + A , < 9 : : 46 : " -4
. 1+ * " ; 46 ;0 " A
: 3
:1 ':,
5 9 6 4 * < ;0 " ; ( -1
. : 3 $ 3
0 " *:A ) $ " 8 ! 2M ( < -2
5 : 1 +( * 6+ H $ =
." ;
!
: ':
" 9 ;0 " A E9 ! 9 : L1
. & </ 8 7 < 8 4$ 0 9
2 *; 7 < ':" : EL2
. 2005/2004

6
* :A : : $ " 8 ! 1+ ' : " ; 6 L3
$ = B# * 6+ H 0 "
.
< 2 K :+ 9 D# ;0 L4
. ! I " + 2 6;
4 * < ;0 " ; 1+ ' : " ; 6 L5
3 # Z : 2 6
.
: !'
' :" 9 6 4 < *+ M *9:
B $ < : )# , " ;
. 0
,% 0 6 $ " :
" A E9 5 $+ ; 9 " 9 6+
. + A E E 9 " *6 ;0
:+ 3 *2 < 0 < ( 1 *; = 7 : ::
;0 " 0 1 Z 5 : $ 6( < 9 <" &
. 6 $ * 9 1+ * ; 4& 1
D0 H 1 Z " #7 *9 U &; :* : !9 ;
"%9 6, 0 + 7 " 9 +
6 9K ,% 0 " #7 ' : #< *9 + &
. (2003 78 +) 6 7
: $
: 9 6+ , @ $ " +"
K : D 0 *9 + *9 H C , @
* ' & 4 $ " ) +K Z )
J ;0 " 6% 1 , "< : (2002) " + 2 C
, 5 9 ( & <) 8 7 < ;0 " A (
)+E ) (250) 4 9. $ " 8 ! 2 1+

7
 ;0 5E 0 K 0 ;0 " = A (35) 1 +
. M9 (1995 % ) + J
L= & ) ; 0 & 1 @ G# " @
G# " @ 9( E L& & )1 $ * <(*7
" 8 1 (E ;0 ( ;0 & < " <% 0 M
" <% 0 (3 ( 0 " + )
G# " 5 9 A 1+ < 6+ H :" 8 (E : +
+5 9 ;0 ( + *9 J (
( 0 + ) " 8 1 (E ( < " <% 0
H 3 ) " 8 1 (E " ( < " <% 0 (
.( A 1+ < 6+
< ;0 G +< $ 1 (2001) = "
" . ) 0 (93 ) +" . 0 @ G 0
Z 0 %:A 7 9 (%63.4 ) ; (% 36.6 ) G#
;0 G G# " @ 9 ;;0 *
4 * H%& 3 K & 9 <) + ) @ 3 &
" @ "6 B7 ;0 " = $ " 0 & 1+ 0
* ; < 1+ " $ ! 4E : G <" ;$ ! G#
& + # + + 6 : + +
3 1 + E9 : * " 6 + 1 " . 0
" 3%& $ K " ,@ " = @ ) $ &
+ ;0 " = ;;0 " A E9 0 <
." $ ! < @
4 ( 7 ( + , 9 (2001) J 7 "< :
9 &6 < 6% " E9 " A < ;0 " = D0
" 8 ! ,% 0 7 ( ,% 0 < "
0 " ( D;0 B 9: < I
U = @ & $ 1 "< : 9. 6 + H = 3
= D0 4 A + M
+ " 9. 7 9 * < < $ ;0 "

8
 # 1+ 6K # $ & : 0 )9 (122)
. 7 % 3 \% B $ 0
" 9 < ( 9 7 G# " @
K ) 29 ; 0 " = 4 9 &
9 ;0 " = 4 &$ I 9. E
= 3 Z% + < ;;0 . 7 % &$ ) 29
;0 * < ;;0 #< )6 29 ; 0 "
8 ( 8 (E ) # ; < G# @ <.
" @ 9. ; 0 " = 4 7 1+ 0 "
#< 29 "6+ = 4 G#
. 9 $ "6+ 4
" : B $ ; $ (1999) "
(510) 9 + *%0 ;0 " = 3%& G
. ! $& < # B <
: * + $ & 0 * G# "7 9
+ 5 $ , 0 "6+ 6+ G
" #7 G 1 + $< " ( 6 & "6+
, ; , "6+ ' M 9 1 : $ 3
%9 3 ; @ + 6 + 0 )9 & 4
: < 3 @ " #7 .H ;
. $ ) $+ 70 < 79 ; I *
G ": < )#; )6 < 5 : 1 ) ";
6 D;0 *:A 8 4 * ;7 < ;0 " =
. &
B ": 1 , (1998) Q + "
+" . B < 6 & G
" : G# "7 9 ) (22) ) (248)
<) ; ) )9 6 G )+ " 9 B
G K <" 9 6+ G# " 9.
< #; " < + G# " 5 9 ; < 6+

9
 <) ; ) )9 6 G B ":
. *:A 6+ D;0 0 7@ B 1 (E
& 8 ; < (1997) 09 "
4 8 9 & 8 " 9 8 7 < ;0 " A
H ( 0 B 9: $ " 8 2M
B $ " 9 . A 1+ < 1 6+
4 < 1+ &= " B0 9 & 8 (
& 8 * ; * *0 G# " @ . ) (181) : + R
<Z 2 4 " 6% < : 4 " 6% ;0 "
4 " 6% < * 3+ 2 6 4 * , @ + 9
(E % 9 &8 ; ( < )<% 0 5 : G# " 5 9 . %E
L41) + U ; 8 9 U ; B 8
6+ U ; 6+ 8 " (10L5) + 0 8 (50
U ; 9< A 1+ < 8 $ 6+
. 0 " A
#$ *; & 1 , ( 1995) = & "
+R 6 .5 ;0 & 6 * 7& C ;0
. 4 (%31) 2 ) (111) + <
& 0 + + < *6 U , E+ G# " @
" < " <% 0 ! 1 < ;0 < +7 *;
. 7 0 " 8 )$ & ; 7
B = " ( Cook and Boe,1995) 5 9(
;0 " = $ " " 9 < 6 3%&
C " @C ;0 D# ;0 K 3%&
0 *6C : K (%90) T + *9 8;C ; 0
" @C 4 $ 9" " 3%&
I * M C ;0 (%37) C C G#
.: + I ': + $ @C 6 * 7&S ; M ( 0C
; 0 6% " (Martin and others, 1995) 0^ K
* +K ) 9 ': " 7; _ &

10
 $ "9 TB $ C" ; 6 7; _ & C #6
& 6% D < : ' B# , 7; _ *
_ & C #6 & : 2 , ;0 " ,; <= _
. < 0 7;
_ & M $ "+ (106) & +" 4
" @C * + (16) ;0 B $ & E9 B $ 7;
C ;0 " 7; _ & 6%+ 5 : C G#
. 8 7 9< 0 % ;0
& ": 1 ( Siegel 1994 ) "< :
4< 9 ": ' : 1+ 3 * + 2 1+ , "6+ =
" 6+ = & 4 1T + 9 ':
+ A ; @ *6 $ , 7;
*; C E G 9< J C 2 ! 7 K 6 &
New " 9 9 < " C <9 3 1+ @
" ( ( 70) 1 + " 6 . " < "Mexico
1 + ) + * 3 1+ <C *; K <
.* : < ;;0 * 6 H < C 2%2
*$ C 1+ 3 +* ; G# " 6
9< $ @ C I 1+ T 29C " ; : C E 3
, 7 ; < 6 & G 4 ; H ; C G
. E @
" A < # 7 ` & C 1T , (1993) " 2 "
( 420 ) + " 9 ." 6 +_ H & S ' : 6%+ ;0
G# " @C . 9 < ;0 " A <
< : I 1 +C : ; E9 <* $ " ; C
+S , 70 7 ` "; C . < 79 E9
." A ' $ S J 4< &
* 6T + 7 3 S (1993) "
$ < G# 7 I * 7&S B 1+
C ;0 +T G % ; * <C

11
1 S <" + 3 S C G# :C " 9 . IB
"%9 * " ; :C " 9 7 2 3 S
4 * +3 T 6T * + C +
. 6
" $ ; (1992) = C "
' :" 3 5 9 @ &6 < ;0
9 # 6) (64) +" 9. : )$< "
+ *99 < 1 "; (30)
* ): : * 99 < @ " " " 9K
& * ;# ;0 % "%9 D0 * " $ E 0
" K *6 ) : ( 0 " ! " < ( 7
.( 0 4 " 6% & * 7; & * ): : " ':
: 3 D0 " #< 9 7 5 9 G# " @
K 1; G# +" 7 < " "
. :M I % 3 :
(Lessen and Frankiewicz, 1992) E 9 < "
" @ 7 ;0 4 " 7; 1 + ,
< : D# ;0 "; < 5 9 7 & < ;0
.3%& 1 + ; 0 & <B 6 K ;0 <
= %& 9 * 7 ;0 C1 "; 6
& " + + 1+ $ *2 ;0 " 4 47 *;
2T 3% & 4 9 1+ $ 3%& < E
. :
& 8 ; < 1 ( 1990 )= + 7 "
& 8 ; ,% 0 ( < < ;0 "
" 4 4 9. 6+ H ,% 0
; G# "7 9 . 9 ; $ " 6 +% ; 0
D# ; 0 : 4 " 6% : 1+ : 3 " & 8
4 " 6% *# " Z 6 4 * , @

12
 ; 1 + ) &I ' + 9 ( G# @ %E
. D# ;0
": " < 1 "< : (Williams,1986) : <
0 " 8 2 1+ , 1 " 6 G # B <
" )6 < 5 : C G# " ." : ' : 1+ ( B 8
5 9 0 8 1 (E 6 G ": < #;
29 29 : " 9K < 0 *6 U ;
. 0
E% " ! 1 (Scott,1982) " 9 "
$ %0 2 "< : ;0 " = 4 * * C
" 6+ , 0 ;0 " = 3%&
" ! 8 @ B < + 3%&
2 + 0 K @ , 7; & < 3%& E% ;0
G# " @C .B + < 3%& 6 3%&
* <C ; 0 " ( 6C % " 6 * 7& M
" 6 6 ( 6C * ; " ?< @ C : I4 $
:C ; 0 " #< 4 * = E% ;0 " +
. 6 * 7& 4 *; 1+ $ ; A * 1+ $
K 1 ( Bensky and others , 1980 ) 0C 9 "
2M ( 6+ " 9 < 6 142/94 9 $
+ (114) +" 9 . "& 8 1+ 5
C G# " C 5 + + "& 8 H C
0 " 6 U < ( < 9< & 8 9+ 6%+ 6
E D6 : E 9 & 8 ! 70 6%+ 9 :*
3 " 9 $< &I , @ D0 . & 8
B : 4 *+ 7 * 1 % : :C
.
: $ 4 2 :
" < "2 6 $ " 29 @ % -1
( 7 6 ;0 D# ;0

13
 + 6 4 * : 2 & 8
: @ * 7 ` "
H &6 $$ * : % = B < 6 G
1 + @ E9 M < 2 + + 7 3 9 6
6+ 6 4 * " A E9 1+ E9 *78 G +
@ D0 " ': K :
" A ' E9 :M9 ; 0 " ;
.: & 0
C E <" ': K 7 L2
. & < < ;0 46 $ % , : $ =
H *:A 0 " )" 8 < 4& $ -2
J 7 (2002) " + " +4 ( * 6+
.(Williams, 1986) (1997) 09 (1998)Q + (2001)
3 6 4 * " ; 46 " L4
4 " 6% D0 ( 1997) 09 4 4& $ 5 : ;0
D 0 (1995) = & # Z 6
(Martin and others, 1995 ) 0^ 6 4
7 ` ) # D0 (1993) " 2 = D0
# : 4 " 6% D0 (1990) = + 7 (
Bensky and others , ) 0^ 9 %E 4 " 6%
. D0 ( 1980
C " < "2 " : I + "7 0 L5
* (2001) = : ;0 T C :M
.(1992 = C) (Siegel,1994)
< 6 G H "2 " : I + "7 0 L6
5 9 (1998) Q + (1999) :*2 B
" 9 (William,1986) ( Cook and Boe1995)
. (Scott,1982(N
" " " : I + "7 0 L7
0 (1997) 09 (2002) " +: ;# ;0 ;0

14
 (Siegel ,1994 ) * (Martin and others,1995 )
.(Leesen and Frankiewicz,1992 ) E 9 <
" A 6 < "2 " : I4 L8
(2001) J 7 (2001) = (2002) " + :*2 ;0 E9
(Cook and Boe 1995) 5 9 (1995) = & (1997) 09
(1990)= + 7 (1992) = C (1993) (1993)" 2
.(Bensky and others ,1980) 0^ 9
3 : " 8 " ! " L9
D; 0 B (2001) = A 1+ <
& 6 D;0 (2001) J 7 3
09 A 1+ < B (*0 ) 3 (1999)
.(1997)
< 9 =5&
: 6
& *%0 7; G 0 K 6 :2 =5&
. ;0 " A E9 " + 1+
" A E9 " 4 9 :
1 + +E ) (261 ) : + R 6 8 7 " @< , 0 < ;0
.E9 A (33 )
* ; K @ # $ & +" 0 : &
6 3 : 0 2 # 6 1+
+ 4E U * 4 (%41.7) 2 "8
: " 8 3

15
 (1)
- ! & @
2 2 $ ; #7 9 A & B & 38

C A &
&

&

&

&
&

38
#7
7

7
B
& 7
52 57 45 49
)E

&.
68 74 22 24
)

D7
17 18 24 26

& 12
(

–12
& 17
20 22 18 20 33 36
$

)2
32 35
E
3/

)
& 17
.)
) !

11 12 13 14 45 49

#
109 = A 109 = A 109 = A 109 = A

" 4 ! 8 ( ) & K 6 : B
= 3 ! < D < B# *A +
" ; $ $ "
" 6 . 2 ;0 E9 " A ;0
: : $ " 8 ! : * CE
= B# * 6+ H 0 " *:A
1 + +E 9 ( 98) 9 #6 9 <: 2 E $
( + 16) ( +18) : :
3 # ( + 13) ( + 13)Z
0 G 6 ( + 15) 0 ( + 23)
." ; 5 1+ $< ( (" 9 )

16
 :B 9 :
D;0 0 = 9 2 1+ ! +2 :0 ! : D1
9 7 + 6 + :0 "% * "@ % K
.. " $< $< *9 + B 9 %90
* 7 ` 9* 0 " 2 * 3 K 6:B 9 .L2
: % 9 < " 2U
(2)
& , & ) , " H & )
" 2 6
0.74
0.91
0.93 Z
0.85
0.88 3 C #
0.87 _
0.95 9
D 0 9 " 2 * 6 (2) 6 * G# U
: ( 0.95 ) : 6 4 < ;0 " ;
. ! I 7 *+ " 2 *
: -
: Y < *2 : $ " 8 LC
.B 9 9 + 2:" 2%2 = *:A -
29 12L7 29 " 7 *6C:" 0 " -
. 17 29 17 L12
: :" C * 6+ H -
. 9 $+ ;
: : $ = B# -
. :M

17
 " $< 1 + < + *; *2 :4 8 –3
. 1 M9 (98) 1 + 9 (490)
E " 1 (12 / 9 ) B 8 , 6
C " @C ( Cook and Boe,1995 ) 4 – 1T – 7 : (%2)
. ( %4) : ; 0 9 1T K _
: 7 !9
Y 3 1 " *0 #; "
0 K ( SPSS) + #; E G 0
: 3
. ( "< "& -
. 2%2 * -
LSD = 0 -
. * -
.= * -
5* & =7 &
" ; ,% 0 ( < 1T ' : "< :
! 2M ( < 5 9 : 3 6 4 + < ;0
: ,% 0 ( " ; 5 : ( 1+ $ " 8
6+ ,% 0 " ; 5 ,% 0 ( < ) 0C : 2M K
" 7 B# *A 3 T *; G# 6 .
: 3 :
: * & #7 8 =7 & – 9
0 : 1+ *A :D
.I & J& 5 25
(: @ ) : 3 " ; 3 6
; ( $ = , & 0 +;
: * 3 G# " 9

18
 (3)
0 !&9 ! '
5 3 !
0 !&C '
/ B $" 2
; !

: 0.97 1.79 1

7 !" # $ % &$ '

1.10 2.08 2
2
7 "( ) &* +, $ -. %
1.20 2.08 3
2
/ 01 23 45 6 " . 723 "8
B 9 1.04 2.20 4

: 0.97 2.25 9" "0 6 0- : 5

>"? * 1 % @7; < 6 (#5 & =
B 9 1.17 2.25 6
"
7 @ A"= B C D E# -$ 2 ;
1.21 2.28 7
2
2 0.98 2.30 .F G# 0H; 4 8
"J F "% -3 92 D 2 I
2 1.10 2.32 9
45
K ) !" # 0G B F & % 4
2 1.26 2.33 10
%H L"; ; . M

2 1.08 2.36 G F" ; B N E 2 O =3 11

2 0.95 2.38 F " ": 6 H 2 ; 12

: 1.24 2.39 G F@ Q""P 13

: 0.90 2.40 & $ B R S 14

7 # 1G T"HU 2 ;
1.03 2.48 15
2

19
 0 !&C '
/ B $" 2
; !

B 9 1.29 2.48 % . NV; D ) ()B % $ -. G 16

: 1.03 2.50 F@2 G B G * Q@ 17

B 9 1.00 2.50 F@0 ;. ":W :X G 18

7 F . 0Y 9 %(& % "8
1.11 2.51 19
2
.Z F@ " "H;. [ H;
B 9 1.22 2.53 20
\ >": * 1% ] = B 900 ;
7 &Q@-3 3F 6 G 2 ;
1.03 2.55 21
2
7 H2 " . $ -. G
1.23 2.57 22
2
7 * [0 "( D 2" ( ; G
1.27 2.57 23
2
7 T HU 9" 4 6 ^ S. 6 _ I 2 V( ; 4
1.21 2.62 24
2 !" # D [

. 72W G Q -$ 2 ;
B 9 1.12 2.65 25
"` .
B K ' 1.04 2.71 & 3 (c; ? )) a ;3 E . ( ; G 26

: ' 1.20 2.72 9ef . g 3 4 27

B 9 ' 1.17 2.72 F @ cD < $X a %3 & h) 28

B 9 ' 1.14 2.74 .$k D '# i $ % jH2 29

B 9 ' 1.27 2.76 & $l = [ 6 "=# G 30

: ' 1.17 2.78 !" # [% G % B h) $ -. 31

B 9 ' 1.00 2.79 a ;X " '# .$k ( ; 2 ; 32

2 ' 1.00 2.80 G !" # 4 33

20
 0 !&C '
/ B $" 2
; !

7 m " H n o p %F Q") ;
' 1.07 2.83 34
2
7 F H . O "H _p%F q#_ G
' 1.20 2.86 35
2 G H

7 62D 3. E ( ; G
' 1.23 2.91 36
2
7 .r ) ) o p % 6 [" $ -. G
' 1.34 2.93 37
2 G 4S _ .r E @D ]

: ' 1.19 2.94 9YI23 ) I 08 $ -. G 38

7 s"@[ # YI23 G
' 1.24 2.95 39
2
: ' 1.25 2.96 F@ L !" # 6 G %, \2 t 40

B 9 ' 1.15 2.96 9 2 F""H; F u f F v $2 41

7 BD C D B%
' 1.31 2.99 42
2
R. i 9 " % @ + ; < 9 Q I [;
: ' 1.00 3.01 43
G %3
7 " " E j w F G $ -. G
' 1.41 3.01 44
2
]# ) G %l 0= 6 - o & h)
B 9 ' 1.09 3.02 45
"0Y . L"0Y
: ' 1.04 3.04 s5 f 46
@[ e[ < & 3 $ ( G# *
B K ' 1.08 3.04 47

7 X &$ xy $ -. 2 ;
' 1.28 3.04 48
2 " " E

21
 0 !&C '
/ B $" 2
; !

c1 " y: [ z J C H(
L 5& ' 1.15 3.06 49
@" % a 0G B
0 & H j o ( "Y`;) ) 2 ;
L 5& ' 1.31 3.07 50
y: [
T( Y ;< u q 2 @i
: ' 0.97 3.08 51
% -3

B 9 ' 1.22 3.10 " " ;y ^ 6 "2 Q" jH2 52

7 6 H Y; p % ;< y ^ G
' 1.18 3.12 53
2 { | p % Z0

: ' 1.20 3.17 @"( u I 6#= F"7[; G 54

uJ v " _ % @[ G% B & 3 cG
B K ' 1.21 3.17 55
* $ p %6 %1
2 ' 1.26 3.18 \ A"= B F }G. T"+ 56
G y $& . 1 F % [G
2 ' 1.27 3.18 57
9$
7 @0 I;. R :3 & h)
' 0.99 3.18 58
2
_3 ] S 4 4
2 ' 1.40 3.19 59

L [s :V8 3 G# *
B K ' 1.17 3.19 60
9- { cG
& G ; 6 ^ S B ] @[ 9 ~
L 5& ' 1.25 3.20 61

7 "{ 6 5 "$ ( ; %
' 1.12 3.21 62
2
9 > H !" : < =
2 ' 1.13 3.22 63
9 ) I . 9; .
B K ' 1.13 3.22 . 3 *". G# c+ 64

22
 0 !&C '
/ B $" 2
; !

& $ H 6 . B Q • -o
2 ' 1.18 3.23 65
c
L 5& ' 1.16 3.25 " [ p % ] @[ ' ;* 66
p %a o F p %L v0 8
2 ' 1.12 3.26 67
6#DI "` & I
F@; :. G G . B % ] @[
L 5& ' 1.23 3.26 68
F@; G.
L ) $ c G a#` 2 ;
: ' 1.24 3.27 69
G a ; B c 1 :Q[ .
& 3 B Y $ * 0%3 &$ '
B K ' 1.34 3.28 70
@[ 3 L ": 60Y s" 2
L; )F S m$ $.$ 2 ;
2 ' 1.26 3.32 71
(
L 5& ' 1.32 3.32 &$ | 6 p % ] @[ Q") ; 72

L 5& ' 1.22 3.32 F "H ] @[ C ~ v0 8 73

7 € " 723 92. c+

" 1.08 3.32 74
2 ;. B j L

• S C.$ & @ p % Q")J F v0 8

L 5& " 1.09 3.34 75

G 6 G Y; ] @[ c +
L 5& " 1.16 3.34 76
9" " F@;#DI p % L `
6 - o L ‚ ] @[ c ""D; 4
L 5& " 1.25 3.36 77
!" ; D $
:r 6# H * -, • - o & h)
B 9 " 1.17 3.36 78
G
7 " " ; E . ci ( ; 2 ;
" 1.31 3.37 79
2
2 " 1.26 3.38 F .$ $ ~ " $ $ -. "8 80

23
 0 !&C '
/ B $" 2
; !

B K " 1.19 3.39 9"2 $ G & B ƒ 81

45 "J C. "8
2 " 2.20 3.46 82
( 6 ^5 a$ 0;)
2 " 1.23 3.49 .„ 0G B @- H; G 83
6 - o . 6#DI $ • - = $ -.
2 " 1.27 3.52 84
45
L 5& " 1.32 3.54 &J( • 0 [ H Fs= ^) 85

B K " 1.09 3.58 F@E [ " U … :3 : G 86

J y ^ :3 ) I 2 ;
B K " 1.06 3.59 87
45
7 " " _ f3 G
" 4.08 3.61 88
2
B 9 " 1.33 3.61 ci "GJ a Dfr. Q( o G 89

"0Y [ G $ .
L 5& " 0.98 3.63
F? ] @[ 0 [ 4 DI;
90

& 3 K" ; < cG 2 ;. "8

B K " 1.06 3.68 91
@[" "( 6 ^5 a$ 0; G
": ; y 2 & 3 ) I 2 ;
B K " 1.00 3.70 92
yE [ T"HU B H
j o 1 =B % :3 "8
B K " 1.30 3.72 93
" ":W . J
& ?g ;< " [ / `1
B K " 0.92 3.72 94
N$ - s" [)
2 " 1.15 3.82 9" Q( = $ -. G 95
DI G %3 6 > ] @[ $ -. G
L 5& " 1.14 3.85 96
4

24
 0 !&C '
/ B $" 2
; !

† ;• -o .a 23 f
: " 1.04 3.90 97
.‡ˆ
: " 1.08 3.99 0H 4 (p % a = 2 ; 98

' 0.52 3.01 )

9 (25) 5 : (25) # 0 * G# U
9 (48) 5 : (50) # < ;( ,; (98) *;
9 (25) 5 : (75) # @ 0 & ;( ,;
. + <C @ 5 47 ;( ,;
+ < ;0 " ; D0 G#
%36) " ; ': ( %20 ) ( 6 4
( %24 ) _ *2 < 3 C # (
;0 " ; 1 : .( %20)
<5 _ # $ S <5
: : "%9 ':E 6 . Z $
% +C E 4 * < 0 3 ! 0
;0 " @S 3 I <9 T + *;7 <
. " < : T &
$< & ( ;0 " ; D0 <
# ( %23) " ; ': ( %19 ) C
( %16.5 ) ( %14.5 ) _ *2 < 3 C
" ; $ S 4 5 1T ( %14.5 ) Z ( %12.5)
: :" ; ':E 6 .& ( : < 6 4 *
G S <C 6%
( &8 ) 79 G: & $< *# 0
< * & 5 H C! @ G: ! $ D;
. +

25
 $< 47 ( ;0 " ; D0 <
# ( %12) " ; ': ( %8 ) C
( %20 ) ( %8 ) _ *2 < 3 C
" ; $ S 4 5 1T : . ( %24 ) Z ( %28)
: :" ; ':E 6 . 47 ( 3 6 4 *
* 7 *$ < * + ; < 1+ * ;
E< 6 7 0 6 +_ " #7 G: 6 5 R 7 1T
.' 9 C ! 7 & 8
" ; K (3.01) & ( 1 9 9
' : 2M & 1T 5 * 6 4 + < ;0
<3 0 T M =E9 @ <* = 46 1 + " ;
*$ * & : T C < 3 I *@ < ;0 " 6%
4 6 ? < " 6 B7 E 6 4 * 46 "
6, :C $ 8 T 6%0C T" + 7 ! 7 ; ;0
S ' : *+ 7 $ C3 E 1 C) 5 : C1 $
.* + & ' " ; ' ) $ )E & <
: 5* & 4 9 6 " =7 &
+9 0 + & M7 ! : 9: 1+ 7 ':D
+ ! ' ( =0. 05) 7 !9
NB & N 38 : - 4 0@ 25 255
. 5& " N2 #7
B# 0 " *:A 2M $ G# " 9
: 9 6 4 + < " ; ( D0 *+ 7
: * <

(4 )

26
 ; 3/ ) - 4 ( 2x 4x 3 ) .,. ! =7 &
5& .,. " 7 &. , " #& B &

9 ( ) ' A
7 !9 ! !

0.827 0.190 4.51 2 9.03 (E ) 38

*0.048 2.738 0.652 3 1.955 ( )B &

0.859 032. 7.55 1 7.55

B & 38
*0.016 2.796 0.665 6 3.99
( x E)

0.231 1.493 0.355 2 0.710 (L x E ) 38

0.764 0.386 9.17 3 0.275 (L x ) B &

B & x; 3/
0.920 0.286 6.798 5 0.340
(L x x E) x

0.238 68 20.468 /'

109 1018.82 )

. #; * *
:= 8 (E #; * < + * G# U
* < + G# 9( $ = *:A )
" ) ( $ = *:A ): *+ 7 1 (E #;
0 " *:A ) *+ 7 5 9 ( $ = 0
< ;0 " ; ( D0 ( $ =
" 8 (E #; * < G# @ 6 4 +
. 0 " *:A *+ 7 0
7 < *:A 8 (E #; * < + D0
.(2001) J 7 G# "; 4 1
0 0 K 6 0 " 8 D0 7 ;
: * 3 G# " 9 (LSD)=
(5)

27
 B & - & $ (LSD) =7 &

17 ) 17 – 12 12 D7 7 & B 7

0.48* 0.23 0.26* 7

0.22 L0.35 12 D7
0.25 17 – 12
17 )
.(0.05) ( + #; * *
" ; * 7 ; * *%0
: 1 0 " 8 3 ;0
12 *6 – 7 ) (" 7 *6C): 0 #< #; * < -
.(" 7 *6 ) #7 U ; (
( 17 29 ) (" 7 *6C): 0 #< #; * < -
.( 0 " #7 #; * < < (" 7 *6 ) #7 U ;
$ 0 = M 5 7 9 $& ':
$ * $ < 6 4 < 9 " ;
; 0 " 2 H 9" ; ' : E T ;
9 & 0 = +5 < 7 0 * A 1+ * ;
.3 : $< + ;
* :A 0 " *+ 7 1 (E #; * < D0
1 + 6 E 4 #% L L $& ':
" E *:A E 6 4 $ " ;
6 ; U *:A H7 4 5 7 * 2 0
( *:A 3 1 0 E < : "6 <" ; 5 < 9
. :
*+ 7 $ = *:A = 8 2M + D0
" $ = *:A *+ 7 5 9
B $ ;0 " 6 M 5 7 9 2 0
3 4 3 1 :M " E * "%:A 3
+ 6 + ,% 0 6 4 * K $ 6 9 = $ &

28
4 +7 < : 18 0 " 1+ 2 * & : *
9 $ = *:A
$ = + @ !8 E 3 7 4 "
" > 2 E% @ " 0 3 9 %:A
3 7& D6 < 1 " * <
"%:A 9 @ C 5 1+ * = @ + $ & 3
@ ;0 D;0 & 7 0
+ 5: B 9 < 2
0 CH + C B7 + < " ;;0 9 IB 9
& 1+ &&0 E9 " ;;0 : # +
+ 5: 6 G: 3 K ;;0 +E <3 8 = 6 +%
.46 : + 29 2 9( 0 "%:A
"7 9 (Williams,1986 ) "; " ': 7
0 29 29 : " 9 < 0 *6
' : 7 9 &0 $ K " ; ' 29 : 9
7 & 8 " (1997) 09 "; 4
" ; 6%+ * " (10L5) 0 #< ( 29 :
.
(Bensky and others) "; 4 ' : G# , 0
,% 0 : ; * & 8 9+ 6%+ J C1 "
: I & *9 C 9 # +1
$ + 1 (2002) " + $< <
B 1 + 7 3 $ : +1 < & < < ;0
$ 4 7 * 9 + ;7 $ 9 +, 0
.$ * , *6 G & 7 : " E

: 5* & &. 6 " =7 &

7 +!9 + 9 0 & M7 ! : 9: 1+ 7 ':D
N2 ++ :++ ++ ) ++ ++ ++ 9 '++ ++ ( = 0. 05)

29
 + (B 9 N2 7 NB 9 NL 5& N:
. 25
" ; ( * G# " 9 6
: * 3 6 4 + < ;0
(6 )

$ K ./ 0 !&9 !

' : "
( ) " ++++
3 !&9 " ' 9
9

F
b R2 R2 r

0.000 377.74 0.290 0.777 0.777 0.883 :

7
0.000 894.45 239 0.166 0.943 0.972
2 E

0.000 1001.29 0.163 0.22 0.965 0.983 B 9

0.000 1553.35 0.146 0.018 0.983 0.992 B 9

0.000 12354.49 0.156 0.002 0.998 0.999 2

0.01288 a .

2M $ * G# *%0
"& 1+ ( 3 # Z )
6 4 + < " ; : 1+ ;0 "
( 1+ 2M 05 : 0
(0.777) 7 H& K 1 * 6 . (0.05)
IH ! + 1 5 * " ;
& 7 $2 E E : * = 1+ %@ $
C L : : : ;0 " 6 " 6
A ( ) * 7 $ " 1 $ < * <
D; & < 6 * & 5 +

30
 * 9 6+ 0 6 ,6 < 7 2 ,6
.( 0 # + $ 9
( Scott,1982 ) T "; 4 3 : < ' : G# 7
$ ;0 E% ;0 " + 1T " C
. 6 4 *; 1+ $ ; A * 1+
H& 3 # " 9< 2
1+ E I # 1 5 " ; (0.166) 7
7 ` 3 IK * 3 < *# K *2 C
E *: 9 1 + $ + 9 " 0 (
E C *@ < & & & G , 9
< # < 2 2 & 0 1+ +
& &0 C G " S $< ( @ % 9 ) E9 " A ':
. 0 2C * :M 1 + *
(1992) = C T "; 4 ' : G# 7
* " $ E 0 * < " C 1T " C
.*6C ) : _ * < " < 7 & S
(0.022) 7 H& K 2 2 *
5 9 : # C1 5 * " ;
6 46 7 " < ; + :
= ; 1+ : "E &+ " E <
. $ $$ 3; & 7 46 9 : =
(0.018) < * $<
1 + 9 ( $ 1 5 4 6 " ;
*; *; ; < E +
! ,6 3 ) ; E * 9
< 6 9 ; 1+ "E $ + 6 & 8
K 7 $ " ;4 3 1 ; $
, + *; <3; < $2 + ;6 H
= 2 9 G *%0 C E9 C *E < " $

31
" ; C * $ *# < + *@ < $ $ 3; C':
.
" C (1995) = & T "; 4 ' : G# 7
. # & C 0 D0 <C * 6 U , E+ 1T
(0.002) <K > 0 * ) 0C
= K " ; ! 1 5 4 6 " <% 0
' + ,6 ;0 > = 9 $ +* ; 18 =
+ J U 9 +'+ 6 +3; ( 0 64 5
U & 3 & @ $ < " 82 + + … +$ 3
6 #& , + C 0 " 0 E K $$
. " E T &8 < I : $ <R
#; &$ $< Z D0
, 0 #% G: 95 7 9 & ' 2M S
& &0 + & + + E9 ':( < *9 3 "6+
, 0 G: 3 I > B 6+ K &3 <
. & " ; 3 : 64

: 5* & . . 6 " =7 &

+9 0 + +& M 7 +! : 9: 1+ 7 ':D
! ' ( = 0. 05) 7 !9
++ 9 A ++& ++ - 4++ 0@++ ++ ++ 2++5 ++ 25 ++
.( ) !N $ N N )
One-Way ) = S * 0 #; _ * G# " 9 6
8 3 6 4 + < ;0 " ; (Anova
: * < : 9 6 +_ H

32
 (7)
; !K ! =7 &
C A & - !
' A
9 0 " ! " !

0.5 3 1.51
0.137 1.886 0.28 105 28.03
108 29.54 A
" ; * )#; T * < + * G# U
6 +_ H 8 1 T (E 6 4 + < ;0
. 7; 7 ; 1T
6 +T 6 4 < 3 $ 3 ': 7 9
9 C $+ C C" 9 ; 6 +_ 5 H + @ !8
T (*& ) 6 +_ , & ( : = " A E9 ': C
. B < 5 : * $
1 T" C (1997) 09 T "; ' : G# , 0
6 +_ U ; 6 +_ 8 (E ) # ; T * <
C1 T" C (1993) " 2 T "; 4 , 0 9. $ 6 +_
4 * " ; : I 1 +C ; E9 < " ;
_ E $ ,% 0 ,% 0 :3 * . < 79
* 2 * 1+ ; ( " 6 C %0 C & 9
E S + C 6 4 * M :M " T
9C G E7 C* 0 9' # C < 2
* $ 9 ( $& ) %+ E9 6 +_ &3
. ;0 " ;

: " ; K $ "; G# <

3 C G: E9 / ;0 D;0 & 7 " J & L
. 6

33
" 0 " 9 ;0 # 2 :M G 4 L
. 6 4 + < E%
$ # *%0 + 7 ` < L
: < + 6 M ; * "
E E " 0 < + + 7 < *%0 3
. , &C * 9 C
# : 9 @7 ;0 7 @ ,; 4 -
.5 ;0 "E * H &6 <
6 G * < 4 "6+ = E9 L -
$ 9 + + * + Z 0 9 4 4
. 6 + ,% 0 9 ) 6 +
" A ' : 1+ , " E9 + #: *9 1+ * L -
E ;0 9 C 1 +) )< ; 0 E9
. $ : #

34
 7

L: 4 )

+ + !9 ; + K (2002) J ; > 0 0 C L1
. & 7 ; c =E9 E + ; 7; $
( J & ( " 7 6%+ (2001) * + *+ E C L2
I EI H &6 < 7 ; 9 6
. & </B & J
C " (1992) +1 = > = 9 C L3
+ + Q ! @) &6 < ;0 " (
.133L97 D D * S 1 S '
+.) R "'9 ; < S * ( 1996) 5 " C L4
. 9 / 5 (, *^ <. = I ;
; _ E + ; ;0 1T * 7&C (1999) ' "'E L5
.(2) 6 " ; T 6 & 7 =E9
. !9 ; ( 1994 ) J 7 G L6
9 ;0 " A < 7 ` & C " (1993) : T " 2 L7
.224L219 D D 13 46 = "
I * 7& B 1+ * 6 3 C (1993) A + L8
#"& 2 " = ; 4 $ "
.43L34 D D (7) (26)
;0 <B 3 C G: (2002) 1 = >* 3 &0 L9
. / + 4E 1 S &
6 4 0 *; & C (1995) 17&; E E + = & L10
.104L79 D D (7) 1 ;0 *6
J ;0 " 6% (2002) CJ " + L11
I 8 7 < ;0 " A (
. & < /B & J

35
 ": B $ ; (1999) EE + L12
1+ 6% " " 8 ! ;0 " = * 7& G
.99L73 D D 11
& !9 ; (2003) 3 % C 78 +L13
. : $ /4 E 7 1
: S B ": (1998) 1 + + 2+ Q +L14
B / & J I < 6 G
. & <
< ;0 " & 8 ( 1990 ) E < = + 7 L15
. +/ I
" = D0 4 ( 7 (2001) + J 7 L16
K + + ; (28) (2) &6 < ;0
.271L247 D D /
" A & 8 (1997) " #< " 0 09 L17
& J I 8 7 < ;0
. & < /B
6 C ;0 (1991) 17&; = ; L18
(1) / < $2 @ + ;
.165L95 D D (11)
" B < 6 G (1992) 17&; = ; L19
@ + ; (2) (12 ) +
.51L32 D D < $2

36
 : S 4 2

-Bensky, Jeffry M. and others (1980) Public low 94/142 and stress:
Aproblem for educator, exceptional children , v.42.No.1.September.p24-
29.
- Cook, Lynne, and Boe, Erling(1995)”Who is teaching students with
disabilities? “Teaching exceptional children, Vol.28, No.(1), Fall.p.70-
72.
- Finmian, Michanel E (1986) Social support and occupational stress in
special education, exceptional children, V,52 No.5 February, p 436-442.
-Lessen, Elliott, and Frankiewicz, Laura (1992) ” Personal attributes and
characteristics of effective special education teachers”, teacher ERIC
document reproduction service No.( EJ 451545 ).
- Martin, Nancy and others (1995) ”Beliefs regarding classroom
management style: relationships to particular teacher personality
characteristi “ Paper presented at the annual meeting of the
reproduction Service No ED. 387461.
-Siegle, Jannal and others (1994) ”Improving teachers attitude toward
student with disabilities” ( paper presented of the Corference of
council on education for teaching, Istanbul Maixico 1994. International
Turkya, New Eric.
-Scott, Mary (1982) “Identication of some teacher trits needed by
teachers for mainstreaming “ , College student reproduction service No
(EJ 269602).
-William, Jean (1986) “Analysis of teachers Attitude toward
manstreeming by elementary teachers of sescted School”, in Dessirtation
Abstract International.

37