4 3 2 1 Identification of Students properly Students Identified Students require The topic identified is 25% main issues -- Identified main issues main issues around prompt to Identify irrelevant to the including that all around the topic the Topic main issues around main issues questions have been the topic addressed Depth and scope of Balanced Information provides Information supports Central purpose or 20% analysis presentation of reasonable support a central purpose or argument is not relevant and for a central purpose argument at times. clearly identified. No legitimate or argument most of Analysis is vague or analysis is provided information that the time but is not too general. clearly supports a able to central purpose or display evidence argument and of a basic analysis of displays evidence of a the thoughtful, Significance of the In-depth analysis of a topic. significant topic. Solutions and Several detailed Some detailed Detailed conclusions No detailed 20% strategies as conclusions are conclusions are are reached from the conclusion is made appropriate to the reached from the reached from the evidence offered from the evidence questions evidence offered evidence offered offered. Connections to Information showed Information showed Information showed Information showed 15% course readings and good connection to some connection to little connection to no connection to other research course readings and course readings and course readings and course readings and other research other research research other research APA Formatting Presentation is easy Presentation is easy Presentation is Does not adhere to 10% to read and adheres to read and adheres difficult to read. APA format to APA format with to APA format but Several errors in APA no errors lacks 1 or 2 elements formatting exist Organization & The ideas on the The slides are The slides are The slides are not 10% Clarity slides are arranged arranged logically to presented in a logically organized. logically to support support the central somewhat logical Most of the time, the purpose or purpose or order. Need a little ideas fail to make argument. They argument. They are bit more efforts in sense together. flow smoothly from usually clearly linked putting the ideas to one to another and to each other. make sense are clearly linked to together. each other.