Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Session 01 - Introduction To PLM and Business Value of PLM PDF
Session 01 - Introduction To PLM and Business Value of PLM PDF
Introduction
Business Value of PLM Course
Dr. Korhan Sevenler & dr. John Stark
1
Objective of the
“Business Value of PLM” Course
This is a reminder about the objective of the Business Value of PLM Course.
As you know, at the conclusion of the course, you'll be able to explain the business
value of PLM and take part in a company's PLM activities.
2
Contents of the
“Business Value of
PLM” Course
Week 1 Introduction to “Business Value of PLM”
Week 2 The Environment of Product Companies
Week 3 Product-related Business Processes
Week 4 Product-related PLM Applications
Week 5 Product Data
Week 6 PDM and ALM Systems
Week 7 Product-related Methods
Week 8 Mid-Course Review and Midterm Exam
Week 9 Internet of Things (IoT)
Week 10 Industry 4.0
Week 11 PLM and Executives – Top Down and Bottom Up
Week 12 The PLM Initiative
Week 13 Organisational Change Management and the PLM
Initiative
Week 14 PLM in Practice
Week 15 End-of-Course Review
Restricted © Siemens 2020
Page 3 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
Here's an outline of the content of the course. As you know it's a 15-week course. As I
mentioned, this week is an introductory week. Next week the subject will be the
environment of product companies. The following week I'll look at business
processes. And then PLM applications. Followed by product data. The subject of week
6 is PDM and ALM systems. After that, I'll address methods and techniques. The
following week we'll have a mid-course review and the midterm exam. When that's
out of the way, I'll address the Internet of Things. And then Industry 4.0. Week 11
looks at executives in the context of PLM. That's followed by the PLM Initiative and
Organisational Change Management. The penultimate week looks at PLM in practice.
And in the last week, we'll have an end-of-course review.
3
Week 1:
Let's get started with this week's subject, an introduction to Business Value of PLM.
4
Week 1: Objective
By the end of today's session, you should be able to describe why and how PLM
emerged. You should be able to outline the environment of products, describe the
traditional management approach to products, and the issues and the pressure for
change. You should be able to summarise new approaches and the emergence of PLM.
5
Contents of Week 1
6
Start of Lesson 1
So let's get started with Lesson 1 of Week 1 of the course - looking at activities and
challenges of developing and supporting products.
7
Developing and
Supporting Products -
Content
A. Products
B. Developing, Manufacturing and Supporting
Products is Hard
C. Complexity of Managing Products
8
A. Products
Ø Importance of Products
Ø Examples of Products
Ø A Busy and Complex Product Environment
Let's start by looking at products. There are three main topics here. First, I'll address
the overall importance of products. Then I'll give some examples of products. And
then third I'll look at the typically busy and complex environment around products.
9
Importance of Products
I'll start by underlining that the product is very important. It's what the customer
wants, and it's the source of company revenues. Company revenues come from its
portfolio of products. Great products make the company the leader in its sector. Great
products lead to great company profitability. So, to put it mildly, products are very
important.
10
Examples of Products (1)
When you think about it, there's a very wide range of products. There are all sorts of
products.
Some of these products are tangible. These are products you can touch, products such
as a smart phone and a machine.
And some of these products are intangible. These are products you can't touch, such as
software.
And there's a diverse range of products. There are products as diverse as a soft drink
and a tractor.
11
Examples of Products (2)
Products come in all sorts of shapes and sizes. For example, a dollar bill is a rectangle,
about a tenth of a millimetre thick and 15 cm long. A lot of products are much larger.
For example, an aircraft may be over 70 metres long and weigh over 400 tons. And
again, there's a diversity of products. A product may actually be a service. Or a
package of services, or a bundle of products and services.
12
Examples of Products (3)
Ø Different forms
The product is often more than what may seem, at first glance, to be the product. For
example, product packaging is often part of the product. Similarly with product
labelling. Another example, the product may include product literature. It may also
include wires and plugs that connect it to the outside world. A product's delivery
mechanism may be part of the product. The product may come in single or multiple
form, for example, soft drinks.
13
A Busy Product Environment - Parts
Most companies have many products. Each of these may be made up of very many
assemblies and very many parts or ingredients, depending on the type of product. An
assembly may also be made up of very many parts. Many products contain a lot of
parts or ingredients. At one extreme, a shampoo may only contain a few ingredients.
At the other extreme, an aircraft may contain a few hundreds of thousands of parts.
14
A. Busy Product Environment - People
There's a busy environment around products. There are many people in that busy
environment, with many titles. For example, documentation clerk, field engineer,
financial analyst, HR manager, product developer, product manager, programmer, and
project manager.
15
A Busy Product Environment - Activities
There are also many activities in the busy environment around products. For example,
risk management, design control, disposal, document control, service provision,
project management, prototyping, validation, quality assurance, and quality control.
16
A Busy Product Environment - Data
There is a lot of data, and many documents, in the busy environment around products.
For example, project plans, process plans, purchasing data, QA records, recipes,
regulatory rules, results of calculations, scanned part drawings, schedules, and service
lists.
17
A Busy Product Environment - Applications
Many applications are used in the busy environment around products. For example,
CAD, CAM, CAE, simulation, image management, EDA, routing definition, ALM,
and data exchange.
18
A Busy Product Environment - Techniques
Many techniques and methods are used in the busy environment around products.
They often have acronyms, for example, DFA, DFE, DFM, DFSS, EMI, JIT, PDCA,
Pokayoke, QFD, and Six Sigma. The acronyms often have three letters, they're Three
Letter Acronyms, TLAs.
19
B. Developing, Manufacturing and Supporting
Products is Hard
In such a busy environment it's not surprising that developing, manufacturing and
supporting products is hard. Product ideation is hard. Product development is hard, it
can be complex, costly, time-consuming, and inefficient. Product use and support can
be hard. Product use can be dangerous. Product disposal can also be hard and
dangerous.
20
C. Complexity of Managing Products - Identifiers
Ø Many identifiers
Ø Name, number, description
product
part
piece a model number
article a series number
item a type number
component an company-internal number and name
element a code name
module a project name during development
Restricted © Siemens 2020
sub-assembly …
Page 21
assembly © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
Ingredient
The environment…around products is complex. There may be many identifiers for a
product. It may have many names, numbers, and descriptions. For example, a product
could have a model number, a series number, a type number, an company-internal
number and name, a code name, and a project name during development.
21
C. Complexity of Managing Products - Numbers
ØBatch (Lot) number, SKU number
4078 6179
4 078600 156263
ØSerial numbers
5 000158 063815
BN 129 405
Products may also have a batch number or a lot number. They may have a SKU
number, a Stock Keeping Unit number. Sometimes the numbers will follow a serial
numbering scheme. Sometimes the numbers will follow an intelligent numbering
scheme.
22
C. Complexity of Managing Products – Keys, Languages
ØProduct key
XB123-Z456N-CD765-LKJ54-PL1N7-02
ØDescription language
A product may also have another number, a product key such as XB123-Z456N-
CD765-LKJ54-PL1N7-02. The environment around products is complex. The product
description may need to be in several languages.
23
C. Complexity of Managing Products – Meaning
ØNumber of parts
"this product is made up of seventy-seven parts"
Ø standard parts?
Ø new parts?
Ø wiring?
Ø purchased parts?
Ø different parts?
24
C. Complexity of Managing Products – States
ØMany product states
ØUnder development
ØPreliminary
ØPrototype
ØPilot
ØProduction
ØEarly access
ØReleased
ØService
ØDiscontinued
ØObsolete
25
C. Complexity of Managing Products – Versions
ØMany versions of a product
Version 1
Version 2
Release 1
Release 2
HP 2133
HP Mini 2140 Notebook PC
26
C. Complexity of Managing Products – Variants and Options
ØVariants
Variant 1: 8.9-inch WXGA display; 1280 x 768 resolution
Variant 2: 8.9-inch WSVGA display; 1024 x 600 resolution
ØOptions
Carrying Case
Basic Carrying Case
Value Nylon Case
Universal Nylon Case
Executive Leather Case
Restricted © Siemens 2020
Page 27 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
The product may come in many variants. For example, Variant 1 may have a 8.9-inch
WXGA display with 1280 x 768 resolution. Whereas Variant 2 may have a 8.9-inch
WSVGA display with 1024 x 600 resolution. The product may come with many
options, such as a Carrying Case, a Basic Carrying Case, a Value Nylon Case, a
Universal Nylon Case, or an Executive Leather Case.
27
C. Complexity of Managing Products – Structures
ØMany product structures to manage
A list An Array
Bottle Assembly 1 Bottle Front label Back
Liquid shampoo label
Screw cap Assembly 2 Labelled shampoo Liquid
bottle shampoo
Front label
Assembly 3 Filled bottle Screw cap
Back label
The environment around products is complex. There may be many product structures
to define and manage. And a product architecture to define and manage.
28
In Conclusion
In conclusion, products are important, product development and support isn't easy, and
the product environment is complex.
29
Back up
30
C. Complexity of Managing Products – More Numbers
ØUPC, GTIN-12
0 39047 00513 6
1 digit, a space, 5 digits, a space, 5 digits, a space, 1 digit
ØGTIN-13
9 783319 174396
1 digit, a space, 6 digits, a space, 6 digits
ØGTIN-8
4078 6179
Restricted © Siemens 2020
Page 31 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
31
C. Complexity of Managing Products – Other Numbers
3 282799 352390
311 394
ACL 3401398339609
CNK 2917-706
Art. 80653
Art. 80608
80653.210.GA.03
4 005808
4 005808 50599 505999
61518008 HR 61518008 HR
7616 9908
5141.421
Restricted © Siemens 2020
95126-01
Page 32 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
32
C. Complexity of Managing Products – Architecture
ØProduct architecture – what goes where?
33
C. Complexity of Managing Products – Portfolio
ØProduct portfolio – by industry, family, line ?
34
End of Lesson 1
That's the end of Lesson 1 of Week 1 of the course. I'll continue later with Lesson 2,
and look at the environment before PLM.
35
Start of Lesson 2
This is the start of Lesson 2 of Week 1 of the course. The subject of this lesson is the
environment before PLM.
36
The Environment before PLM - Contents
I'll address this subject in 9 parts. I'll start with The Past Environment. Then look at
the Departmental Approach in the Past Environment. I'll move on to Departmental
Border Issues in the Past Environment. Then I'll look at Serial Workflow in the
Departmental Environment. After that we'll review Piecemeal Improvements in the
Past Environment. And then look into Product Data Issues in the Past Environment.
The seventh part will address Engineering Change Management in the Past
Environment. And then I'll look at Product Pains. First, Product Pains In Public. And
then Product Pains In Private.
37
The Past Environment
First, I'll look briefly at the environment for managing products before PLM emerged.
You may wonder why this is an important subject. There are several reasons. One
reason is that understanding how the product environment has changed helps
understand PLM. Another is that many companies still retain characteristics of this
past environment. Another reason is that understanding just how different the past
environment was from today's environment supports the need for a different way of
managing products.
38
The Past Environment
Ø domestic market
Ø an agreed paradigm, departmental, multi-level
hierarchy
Ø paper-based
So what was the past environment like? It was an environment that had changed
relatively little over more than 50 years.It had its roots in the first half of the twentieth
century. After the Second World War a new geopolitical situation had emerged. The
Iron Curtain divided the capitalist West from the communist East. There was little
trade between the West on one hand, and Russia and China on the other hand. In this
environment, most product-related companies were focused on their own, domestic
market. Companies had worked out how to succeed in this environment. They had an
accepted way of thinking, a paradigm, about the way products should be managed.
Companies were organised in functional departments which worked in serial, one
after the other, first Marketing, then Engineering, then Production and finally After-
Sales. There was a multi-level hierarchy of managers. Information was on paper.
39
The Past Environment
Ø lifetime employment
Ø formal, slow, customers waiting patiently
Ø little competition
Ø experience curve
Ø “free electrons”
Male engineers used slide rules for calculations. Female secretaries produced male
managers' memos and technical reports on typewriters. It could take years to develop
a new product, 7 years or more in the automotive industry. People waited weeks, or
months, for delivery of the product that they had ordered. As there was little
competition, and little choice for buyers of a product, manufacturers felt no need to
change.
40
Departmental Approach in the Past
Environment
41
Departmental Approach in the Past
Environment
There are many good reasons for organizing a company in functional departments. For
example, departmental responsibilities can be made very clear. However, in practice,
the departmental paradigm didn't work quite as well as expected. Each Department
focused on its own activities.
42
Departmental Approach in the Past
Environment
R&D’s View
Marketing Service
Marketing VP Service VP
And each Department saw itself as the most important, as the center of the world.
Each Department saw the other departments as less important.
43
Departmental
Approach in the Past
Environment
Service’s View
Marketing
Marketing VP
R&D
R&D VP
From the R&D viewpoint, R&D has to do everything. Marketing can't be relied on to
fix product requirements, Production can't be relied on to make the changes required
by R&D. So it's really important for R&D to make sure that it does as much as
possible to be able to run great projects to develop great new products. And to be sure
it can do this, it needs to be in control of its own data, have its own applications,
control its own people, write its own departmental guidelines, take all the decisions
that affect it, and so on.
44
Departmental Approach: R&D’s World
R&D
• R&D VP
• R&D objectives
• R&D managers
• R&D specialists
• R&D projects
• R&D knowledge
• R&D KPIs
• R&D applications
• R&D data
• R&D guidelines
• R&D training
• R&D jargon
• R&D activities
• R&D equipment
Restricted © Siemens 2020 • R&D methods
Page 45 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
So each department, such as R&D, went its own way. To be sure it was in control, it
ran its own business. Concerning data, each department structured and formatted the
data the way that fit best to its needs. To be sure data was in its preferred format, it
even recreated data that another department had already created. It developed its own
data bases to be sure it had the data it needed. It implemented its own applications, to
meet its specific needs. It used its special jargon because that made it easier for
everyone in the department. It had its own methods, its own performance indicators,
its own guidelines.
45
Departmental Approach: Production’s
World Production
• Production VP
• Production objectives
• Production managers
• Production specialists
• Production projects
• Production knowledge
• Production KPIs
• Production applications
• Production data
• Production guidelines
• Production training
• Production jargon
• Production activities
• Production equipment
Restricted © Siemens 2020 • Production methods
Page 46 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
Each department behaved this way, not only R&D, but for example also Production.
46
Departmental Approach in the Past
Environment R&D Production
• R&D VP • Production VP
• R&D objectives • Production objectives
• R&D managers • Production managers
• R&D specialists • Production specialists
• R&D projects • Production projects
• R&D knowledge • Production knowledge
• R&D KPIs • Production KPIs
• R&D applications • Production applications
• R&D data • Production data
• R&D guidelines • Production guidelines
• R&D training • Production training
• R&D jargon • Production jargon
• R&D activities • Production activities
Ø Departmental information silos
• R&D equipment • Production equipment
Ø Departmental islands of automation • R&D methods • Production methods
Ø Duplication of data between departments,
Ø Duplication of activities between departments
Ø Contradictory versions of data in different departments
Incompatibilities at departmental borders
47
Departmental Approach in the Past
Environment
R&D
ØA Hierarchy of Departments •
•
R&D VP
R&D objectives
48
Departmental Approach in the Past
Environment
The Hierarchical Approach was repeated within each department, adding to the issues.
Within each department, there could be Groups, and then Sections.
49
Departmental Approach in the Past
Environment
Ø Result
Ø Product development cycles got longer and
longer, costs increased
Ø Root Cause
Ø The root cause was the way the company was
organised
Restricted © Siemens 2020
Page 50 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
The end result was that product development cycles got longer and longer, and costs
increased. The root cause was the way that the company was organised.
50
Departmental Border Issues in the Past
Environment (1)
51
Departmental Border Issues in the Past
Environment (2)
Marketing R&D
• Marketing VP • R&D VP
Page 52 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
52
Departmental Border Issues in the Past
Environment (3)
•
R&D
R&D VP
?? •
Marketing
Marketing VP
• R&D objectives • Marketing objectives
????
• R&D managers • Marketing managers
• R&D specialists • Marketing specialists
• R&D projects • Marketing projects Service
• R&D knowledge • Marketing knowledge • Service VP
Page 53 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
53
Departmental Border Issues in the Past Marketing R&D F&A
Environment (4) •
•
Marketing VP
Marketing objectives
•
•
R&D VP
R&D objectives
•
•
CFO
F&A objectives
• Marketing managers • R&D managers • F&A managers
• Marketing specialists • R&D specialists • F&A specialists
• Marketing projects • R&D projects • F&A projects
• Marketing knowledge • R&D knowledge • F&A knowledge
• Marketing KPIs • R&D KPIs • F&A KPIs
• Marketing applications • R&D applications • F&A applications
• Marketing data • R&D data • F&A data
• Marketing guidelines • R&D guidelines • F&A guidelines
• Marketing training • R&D training • F&A training
• Marketing jargon • R&D jargon • F&A jargon
• Marketing activities • R&D activities • F&A activities
• Marketing equipment • R&D equipment • F&A equipment
R&D F&A
• R&D VP • Marketing methods • R&D methods • F&A methods R&D Service
• CFO
• R&D VP • Service VP
• R&D objectives • F&A objectives
• R&D objectives • Service objectives
• R&D managers • F&A managers
• R&D managers • Service managers
• R&D specialists • F&A specialists
• R&D specialists • Service specialists
• R&D projects • F&A projects
• R&D knowledge • R&D projects • Service projects
• F&A knowledge
• R&D knowledge • Service knowledge
• R&D KPIs • F&A KPIs
• R&D KPIs • Service KPIs
• R&D applications • F&A applications
• R&D applications • Service applications
• R&D data • F&A data
• R&D data • Service data
• R&D guidelines • F&A guidelines
• R&D training • R&D guidelines • Service guidelines
• F&A training
• R&D training • Service training
• R&D jargon • F&A jargon
• R&D jargon • Service jargon
• R&D activities • F&A activities
• R&D activities • Service activities
• R&D equipment • F&A equipment
• R&D equipment • Service equipment
• R&D methods • F&A methods
• R&D methods • Service methods
Restricted © Siemens 2020
Page 54 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
54
Serial Workflow in the Departmental
Environment (1)
The serial flow of work was another serious issue in the past environment. First
Marketing worked, then Engineering, then Production and finally After-Sales. As a
result, in the departmental environment, it could take a long time for a new product to
get to market.
55
Serial Workflow in the Departmental
Environment (2)
Marketing
Engineering
Marketing
Engineering
Marketing
Engineering
Manufacturing
Engineering
Marketing
Engineering
Manufacturing
Engineering
Manufacturing
Service
Customer
Service
Engineering
Marketing
Manufacturing
Restricted © Siemens 2020
Page 56 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
I'll give you an example. First, Marketing had an idea for a new product. This didn't
take long. After just 2 weeks, they handed over to the R&D department. But by with
all the to-ing and fro-ing the whole thing stretched out over 37 weeks.
5 weeks in the Marketing Department, 16 weeks in the Engineering Department, 10
weeks in Manufacturing, 2 weeks in Service and 4 weeks with the customer.
Slide 59
56
Serial Workflow in the Departmental
Environment (3)
The end result of the serial workflow between the departments was long product
development times and more development resources than necessary being consumed.
57
Piecemeal Improvements in the Past
Environment (1)
Ø The approach to performance improvement in the departmental
company
Ø Improve performance with departmental improvement projects
Our Department knows best how to improve our
Department
Marketing R&D Production Service
• Marketing VP • R&D VP • Production VP • Service VP
• Marketing objectives • R&D objectives • Production objectives • Service objectives
• Marketing managers • R&D managers • Production managers • Service managers
• Marketing specialists • R&D specialists • Production specialists • Service specialists
• Marketing projects • R&D projects • Production projects • Service projects
• Marketing knowledge • R&D knowledge • Production knowledge • Service knowledge
• Marketing KPIs • R&D KPIs • Production KPIs • Service KPIs
• Marketing applications • R&D applications • Production applications • Service applications
• Marketing data • R&D data • Production data • Service data
• Marketing guidelines • R&D guidelines • Production guidelines • Service guidelines
• Marketing training • R&D training • Production training • Service training
• Marketing jargon • R&D jargon • Production jargon • Service jargon
• Marketing activities • R&D activities • Production activities • Service activities
• Marketing equipment • R&D equipment • Production equipment • Service equipment
• Marketing methods • R&D methods • Production methods • Service methods
58
Piecemeal Improvements in the Past
Environment (2)
Marketing
Database
PDMS
Database
59
Piecemeal Improvements in the Past
Environment (3)
ØExample 2 7.
8.
NPD projects coming in late
product development costs rising
Company Company
4 2
Proposal Proposal
Company
Budget Request:
$M 9.88
60
Product Data Issues in the Past Environment (1)
Another issue that companies had to face was the rapidly growing volume of product
data. Up until the 1990s, most of the product data was on paper. And all but the
smallest companies had thousands, or even millions, of paper drawings and other
documents describing their products. One company calculated that it needed 250,000
pages of paper to describe a new product. And, on average, it found that each of these
was reproduced 30 times. How could all this data be managed?
61
Product Data Issues in the Past Environment
(2)
Copies for
Support
Copies for
Production
Copies for
Engineering
Original
What were the issues in the departmental company in the past environment. For
example, to find specific information, people had to search through lots of paper and
many electronic files. This wasted time. Studies showed design engineers spending up
to 80% of their time on administrative and information retrieval activities. The easiest
way to give all the departments access to data was to make copies for everybody. But
then, once all these copies had been made and distributed, it was difficult to keep
them up-to-date and synchronized. When a change was needed, all the other
department's copies had to be changed, but perhaps some weren't changed. And then
errors could sneak in.
62
Engineering Change Management in the Past
Environment (1)
Engineering
Department
Design Rules
Modus Operandi 7:
Document Release Procedure
Engineering Change
Control
EC Engineering
M Change Database
Syste
m
63
Engineering Change Management in the Past
Environment (2)
Although changing a part may look easier, and be less creative, than creating the part,
it may actually take much more time and effort. This is because the change could have
all sorts of unwanted knock-on effects. The part may be in a product that's already in
production, and already in use. In addition to the part itself, what else is the change
going to affect? It could also affect other part of the product. And, perhaps the change
could also affect something in production, such as a machine. And, perhaps the change
could also affect something in the product's use, such as an activity of the product
user. And what if the part isn't just in one product, but in many?
64
Engineering Change Management in the Past
Environment (3)
Service
Database
65
Engineering Change Management in the Past
Environment (4)
Changes
bypassing
the Various
system consequence
Various
consequences
s for the
on product company
documentation
Various
consequence
s on the
product
Various
consequence
s for the
customer
Restricted © Siemens 2020
Page 66 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
66
Product Pains - In Public (1)
Now I'll look at some of the things that can go wrong with a product across the
lifecycle. The complex, risky, continually changing, uncertain, highly competitive
product environment makes life difficult for companies that develop, produce and
support products. In such an environment, they need to have great products that leave
competitors far behind. They need to be continually in control of their products. If
they aren't in control, and for one reason or another, they take their eye off the ball,
unpleasant consequences can occur.
Airbus 380 initial delays due to harnesses.
Boeing 737 800 Max issues.
67
Product Pains - In Public
(2)
Examples (1)
ØFord
ØSony
ØMerck
ØToyota
ØDeepwater Horizon
In 2004, Merck withdrew VIOXX, an arthritis and acute pain medication. Worldwide
sales in the previous year were $2.5 billion. In late 2009 and early 2010, Toyota
announced recalls of over eight million cars because of concerns over accelerator
pedals and floor mats. The estimated cost was $2bn. In April 2010, an explosion on
the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig led to the death of 11 people. The blowout
preventer had failed to activate correctly. BP agreed to finance a $20bn clean-up and
compensation fund.
68
Product Pains - In Public
(3)
Examples (2)
ØGM
ØLow-profile products
In 1999, NASA's $125 million Mars Climate Orbiter got too close to Mars and burned
up in its atmosphere. An investigation found a contractor's engineering team, in
Colorado, provided information about propulsion manoeuvres, in Imperial units, to the
navigation team, in California, which was using metric units. A similar incident had
occurred in 1983, when a Canadian Boeing 767 ran out of fuel. It had to glide down to
an emergency landing after someone used the wrong metric/Imperial conversion
factor to calculate how much fuel it needed to fly from Montreal to Edmonton.
69
Product Pains - In Public
(4)
Examples (3)
ØHubble Space Telescope
ØChallenger
ØColumbia
ØSR-111
In 1990, after the Hubble Space Telescope was deployed, images it sent back were
unexpectedly hazy. An inquiry was held. It found the telescope suffered from spherical
aberration of the primary mirror. In places, the mirror was 2 microns too flat. The
inquiry found the technical cause. A fault in the null corrector, an instrument used in
the mirror's manufacturing and testing process. There was also an investigation after
Swissair Flight 111 crashed into the Atlantic in 1998. The Canadian Transportation
Safety Board investigation found a technical cause. The accident was probably caused
by an arcing event on an in-flight entertainment network cable, which set alight
nearby flammable material. The investigation also found that aircraft certification
standards for material flammability were inadequate. They allowed use of materials
that could be ignited and propagate fire.
70
Product Pains - In Public (5)
Ø Conclusion/Moral
Ø Not easy to successfully manage products
across the product lifecycle
Ø Usually several causes leading to a problem
Ø Not just technical causes, but also
organisational causes
Ø To successfully manage products, need to
address both organisational and technical
issues
Restricted © Siemens 2020
Page 71 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
In conclusion, it's not easy to successfully manage products across the lifecycle. When
there's a problem, there are usually several causes. There are usually not just technical
causes, but also organisational causes. So, to successfully manage products, a
company needs to address organisation and management issues as well as more
technical subjects.
71
Product Pains - In Private
(1)
Some examples:
ØAir travel
ØHotels
ØOther
I looked at some of the publicly-known things that can go wrong with a product across
the lifecycle. But there are others that we all experience in our private lives. For
example in air travel. Reclining aircraft seats that don't recline? Jetways that don't
extend? And aircraft that, before take-off, hit a vehicle on the ground and have to be
taken out of service? Hotel examples such as electronic keys that don't open hotel
doors?
72
Product Pains - In Private
(2)
people making unauthorised changes
Issues projects coming in late
product release delayed
ØBusiness processes slow engineering changes
data silos reinventing the wheel
ØProduct data inconsistencies between data in R&D and Support
product labelling not corresponding to the product
conflicting lists of a customer's configuration
new products not performing as expected
ØProducts products that suddenly stop working
use of obsolete components in a new design
communication silos
ØOther a departmental mentality
lack of up-front planning
poor scheduling of projects
Restricted © Siemens 2020 poor coordination with suppliers
Page 73 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
Taken one-by-one, Issues don't usually lead to major problems. But, together they can
lead to, at best, unnecessarily long lead times, increased product costs and reduced
product quality. Companies often group the issues in different categories. That helps
to get a better understanding.
Usually there are issues related to business processes. For example, people making
unauthorised changes, projects coming in late, product release delayed snd slow
engineering changes. Then, there are issues related to product data. Such as the "data
silo", in which the data of one department isn't easily available to people in other
departments. Another issue, having many Excel spread-sheets containing a lot of
different information, often conflicting, about a product.
73
Product Pains - In Private (3)
Conclusion/Moral
ØProduct-related issues everywhere
ØImpact performance, costs, revenues
74
End of Lesson 2
That's the end of Lesson 2 of Week 1 of the course. I'll continue later with Lesson 3,
which addresses the emergence of PLM.
75
Start of Lesson 3
This is the start of Lesson 3 of Week 1 of the course. The subject of this lesson is the
emergence of PLM.
76
The Emergence of PLM - Contents
Ø Introduction
Ø Macro-economic Changes
Ø Technological Changes
Ø Increased Product Complexity
Ø Macro-economic Opportunities
Ø Technological Opportunities
Ø Change and Opportunity
Ø New Approaches Proposed
Ø The Emergence of PLM
Restricted © Siemens 2020
Page 77 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
I'll address the emergence of PLM in these nine sections. I'll start with an introduction.
Then look at the macro-economic and technological changes that were going on. Then
I'll look at the effect of increased product complexity. After that I'll address macro-
economic and technological opportunities. I'll finish by looking at some of the new
approaches that were proposed, and then the emergence of PLM.
77
Introduction
78
Pressure on Products
from All Sides
New Technologies
• Mechatronics
• World Wide Web
Market
Regulations • Demanding
• Health Customers
• Environment Product • Customization
• New
• Safety Geographical
Markets
Competition
• New Competitors
• Low-cost Competitors
There was pressure on products from all sides. Pressure from new technologies,
pressure because of new markets, pressure due to new regulations, and pressure from
new competitors. It wasn't just that there were many changes for companies to
respond to. It was also that the changing product environment was difficult to
understand. It wasn't obvious how it would evolve in the future.
Slide 82
79
Companies were squeezed by
Strong Forces
C
AB
R
BP M PDM
CA PPM
E
CA D QFD
CA M SPC
DF A VR
DF M
ED I 6S
EM EA
FM
ISO
Global Economic
Advances in
Forces
Technology
Companies were being squeezed by strong forces. On one side, technologies such as
the Web, the Internet of Things, mobile telephony, RFID, the Cloud, Big Data,
Analytics, and Social Technology. On the other side, by forces such as globalisation,
China, the rise of customisation, traceability, sustainability, and so on. Companies
managing products across the lifecycle were faced with an increasingly complex
changing environment.
80
Companies were in a
complex, changing
Environment
81
Opportunities and Pressure lead to
Change
The changes and the pressure drove companies to change. Meanwhile, the potential
opportunities led them to change. Among the changes that companies faced, some
could be seen as global economy drivers pushing PLM. A company's executives
would look at them and say, "we must do PLM because the world has changed".
Among the changes that companies faced, were others that could be seen as
technological advances pulling PLM. A company's executives would look at them and
say "we should do PLM because the world has changed". The changes and the
pressure drove companies towards PLM. The potential opportunities led them towards
PLM. The pressure acted like a stick forcing them to change. The opportunities acted
like a carrot encouraging them to change.
82
Macro-economic Changes
83
Macro-economic Changes (1)
Globalisation
Ø 1980s
Ø more customers
Ø more competitors
Globalisation started in the 1980s. That's more than a generation ago. Globalisation
affected many companies developing, producing and supporting products. As a result
of globalisation, they could sell their products and services worldwide. They could
find many new customers and increase sales. But, also as a result of globalisation,
they were faced with competitors all over the world.
84
Macro-economic Changes (2)
Geopolitical
Ø Soviet Union, China
Geopolitical changes also affected the product environment. For example those
resulting from the end of the Soviet Union in 1991. The end of the Cold War led many
countries to take different roles in the global economy. Another geopolitical change
was the emergence of China as a major manufacturer.
85
Macro-economic Changes (3)
ØThe Environment
Ø Green politics, Global Warming
ØRegulatory
Ø Traceability, recalls, directives
Other changes affecting products were primarily environmental and social. For
example, moves towards sustainable development, recycling directives, product
traceability and regulatory requirements.
86
Macro-economic Changes (4)
Lean Six
ØManagement theories Six
Sigma
Sigma
for
Lean For
ØLean, Six Sigma Dummie
For
Dummie
Dummie
s
s
s
ØBusiness models
ØLow-cost, leasing, auctions
ØIntellectual Property
ØSource of value
Some of the changes in the product environment were due to changes in the way that
companies were managed and operated. Although all companies are different, they
have many characteristics in common. At any given time, it's considered that there's a
"best way to operate". During the late 20th Century, many companies adopted and
adapted to management theories such as "Lean".
87
Technological Changes
In the middle and late 20th Century, new technologies appeared and caused massive
change. They were considered as revolutionary. Examples from the last few decades
include the Biotechnology Revolution, and the Nanotechnology Revolution, and the
Electronics Revolution. Each of these revolutions led to changes and new products,
and other revolutions. For example, the transistor, which was invented in the late
1940s, led to thousands of electronic products throughout the second half of the 20th
Century. The first electronic quartz watch appeared at the end of the 1960s. Today,
more than 75% of watches are electronic. Less than a quarter are mechanical.
88
Technological Changes need more than
Technology (1)
ØCompany 2
Ø"Before CAD, engineers locked drawings away in a drawer every
evening"
Talk of Revolutions such as the Computer Revolution and the Internet Revolution is
very high-level. In practice, technological change needs more than technology. One
Engineering Manager said he didn't like CAD because he could no longer see the
progress that engineers were making on their projects. Before, when he walked round
the Engineering Office, he could see the progress on the drafting tables. With CAD, he
couldn't make sense of what he saw on a screen.
89
Technological Changes need more than
Technology (2)
Other effects of the change from paper to CAD include the need for training to use the
system, the time taken for getting expert with the system, and avoiding unexpected
side-effects. Full adaptation takes many years.
90
Increased Product Complexity
• more innovation
With so many macro-economic and technological changes, by the end of the 20th
Century, the environment for developing and supporting products was changing
significantly. Companies were faced with all sorts of challenges with products.
Competition was increasing. New competitors appeared around the world.
91
Increased Product Complexity
• more innovation
92
Increased Product Complexity (1)
Another change was that some companies started to develop mechatronic products,
containing mechanical, electrical, electronic and software components. They're more
complex than, for example, purely mechanical products. The mechatronic component
mix was more difficult to manage. Another change was that some companies started
to offer complete solutions, as well as individual products. A solution is made up of
several products, and the interfaces between them. This added a new layer of
challenges
93
Increased Product Complexity (2)
The lifetimes of many products, for example, smart phones and computers, decreased
greatly. This also complicated product development and support.
94
Increased Product Complexity (3)
Meanwhile, the lifetimes for some other products, got longer. Some product lifetimes
approached a hundred years. For example, the B-52 first flew in 1952. Its original
lifetime was extended until it was expected to fly beyond the year 2040. The support
of products with long lifetimes, such as aircraft, power stations and telephone
exchanges, is complex. Many changes occur in the product development and support
environment during the lifetimes of these products.
95
Increased Product Complexity (4)
Even though product development and support was becoming more complex,
customer expectations rose. With so many manufacturers from around the world
proposing great products, customers no longer wanted second-rate, or third-rate,
products. Customer demands implied better products, more customisation, faster
availability, better service, and painless disposal. This further complicated product
development and support.
96
Increased Product Complexity (5)
Business was becoming more complex. Products were becoming more complex.
There was more uncertainty in developing products. There was more and more
legislative pressure about product liability, health, safety and the environment. This
was all putting more and more strain on companies.
All these changes made it difficult for them to develop long-term product plans. The
price of failure was high. Why take the risk?
97
Increased Product Complexity (6)
Increasing risk:
98
Macro-economic Opportunities
5 macro-economic opportunities :
• Globalisation
• Pollution
• Sustainable Development
• Global problems
• Millennials
I'll look now at some macro-economic opportunities in the product environment. I'll
look at the following five macro-economic opportunities, globalisation, pollution,
Sustainable Development, global problems, and Millenials.
99
Macro-economic Opportunities (1)
• Globalisation
100
Macro-economic Opportunities (2)
•Pollution
Overcoming pollution is a huge challenge. For example, in May 2016, the World
Health Organisation announced that air pollution causes more than 3 million
premature deaths worldwide each year. That's a great opportunity for companies that
can significantly reduce pollution.
101
Macro-economic Opportunities (3)
• Sustainable Development
102
Macro-economic Opportunities (4)
• Global problems
There are also great opportunities for products that would help solve the many
problems facing the world. For example, helping solve Global Warming, which
threatens to flood many cities and states. Or providing clean water and electricity to
more than a billion people who live without safe drinking water and electricity.
103
Macro-economic Opportunities (5)
•Millennials
And finally, a human resource opportunity - hiring people from the Millennial
Generation. Unlike previous generations, they've grown up in a digital world of
computers, Internet, the Web, smart phones and other digital technologies. They see
the world differently from previous generations, and can see new opportunities for
products and services.
104
Technological Opportunities
8 technological opportunities :
• Smart/Connected Products; Internet of Things (IoT)
• Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) Technology
• Social Technology
• Mobile Technology
• Big Data and Analytics
• The Cloud
• 3D Printing
• Knowledge Management
New technologies offer the promise of new products. And currently there are many
new technologies that offer opportunities for new products. I'll now look briefly at
eight of them. I'll start with Smart/Connected Products and the Internet of Things.
Then I'll look at Radio-frequency identification, social, mobile, Big Data and
analytics, the cloud, 3D printing, and knowledge management.
105
Technological Opportunities (1)
First, Smart Products. In addition to their primary functionality, these products have
all sorts of "Smart" functionality. As an example, to illustrate what that means, a
washing machine has primary functionality to wash clothes. A smart washing
machine, equipped with a scanner, can read the labels on clothes, and select the most
appropriate washing and drying cycle. When Smart Products are connected to the
Internet, they become "Connected Products". They're the "Things" of the Internet of
Things. Then for example, over the Internet, as you leave work, you can switch on the
heating and run the bath in your home.
106
Technological Opportunities (2)
107
Technological Opportunities (3)
• Social Technology
Social technology can be used across the product lifecycle. For example, in the
ideation phase, it can be used to crowd source for new products, functions and
features. Then, for example, it can be used to co-develop the product with the
members of an external community.
108
Technological Opportunities (3)
• Mobile Technology
Mobile technology can also be used across the product lifecycle. It enables, for
example, designers of fashion goods to travel throughout the world, be creative
anywhere, and deliver new designs within minutes of their creation. Another example,
service workers can connect to their company's central database from the customer
sites where they're working.
109
Technological Opportunities (4)
Next, there are opportunities with Big Data and Analytics. Companies create, receive
and can access huge quantities of Big Data every day. Once all the Big Data has been
organised, analytics offer fact-based insight into activities across the product lifecycle.
The company can use analytics to better understand products, and predict what
customers will want next.
With Cloud technology, the CIO can offer best-in-class applications on a shared Cloud
infrastructure. So users won't have to wait years for their company to provide
applications on corporate infrastructure.
With 3D printing technology, product development can be speeded up as prototypes
are made on 3D printers connected directly to CAD applications.
Another opportunity is with Knowledge Management. One application of this
addresses the knowledge in the heads of a company's employees. Each year, maybe 10
or 15 % of them leave or retire, taking with them the knowledge of why, and how,
many activities in the company are carried out. And why particular decisions were
taken for particular products. Knowledge Management techniques can ensure this
knowledge is captured and not lost.
110
Change and Opportunity
Companies want to seize the opportunities in the product environment. But the
environment isn't an easy one. It's changing, risky, global, uncertain and highly
competitive.
111
Change and
Opportunity (1)
There's pressure from many sides:
Sustainable New
Development Technology
Rising Fluctuating
Customer Exchange
Expectations Rates
The
Consumer
Protection Company’s Trade Barriers
Act
Products
There's pressure on the company and its products from many sides. For example, from
shareholder demands to increase value, from influences of financial markets, from
fluctuating exchange rates, from fluctuating commodity prices, from new technologies
and from deregulation.
112
Change and Opportunity
(2)
Yet there are huge opportunities if a company can develop and support the great
products that customers want
To be able to achieve that, they need a great product deployment capability
Yet there are huge opportunities if a company can develop and support the great
products that customers want. To be able to achieve that, they need a great product
deployment capability. They need to be continually in control of their products. That's
what PLM offers them. That's why PLM is of such great business value.
113
New Approaches Proposed
I've been talking about many changes that have been happening since the early 1980s.
Similarly I've been taliking about many opportunities coming on stream from the early
1980s. In response to the many changes and many opportunities, many new
approaches have been proposed since the early 1980s.
114
New Approaches Proposed (1)
1989 Robert Camp published "Benchmarking: The Search for Industry Best Practices That
Lead to Superior Performance"
1990 The world’s first website and server went live at CERN
1990 James Womack published "The Machine That Changed the World"
For example, as you see here, in 1982 W. Edwards Deming published Out of the
Crisis. The following year, Theodore Levitt wrote an article called Globalization of
Markets. In 1985, Michael Porter published Competitive Advantage. Later, Robert
Cooper published Winning at New Products. The Brundtland Commission reported on
Sustainable Development. The International Organization for Standardization
published ISO 9000. Robert Camp published Benchmarking: The Search for Industry
Best Practices That Lead to Superior Performance. In 1990, the world's first website
and server went live at CERN.
115
New Approaches Proposed (2)
1997 Clayton Christensen published "The Innovator's Dilemma: When New Technologies
Cause Great Firms to Fail"
2000 The European Commission published proposal C365E for the Restriction of
Hazardous Substances (ROHS)
2001 Emergence of PLM
2004 Publication of "Product Lifecycle Management: 21st Century Paradigm for Product
Realisation"
Restricted © Siemens 2020
Page 116 © Dr. Korhan Sevenler & Dr. John Stark Siemens Digital Industries Software
In 1991, the Cold War ended. The following year, saw the publication of Engineering
Information Management Systems: Beyond CAD/CAM to Concurrent Engineering
Support. This was followed by Mass Customization: The New Frontier of Business
Competition, Reengineering the Corporation, and Leading Change. In 1997, Clayton
Christensen published The Innovator's Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause
Great Firms to Fail. 2001 saw the emergence of PLM. And in 2004, the first book
about PLM, Product Lifecycle Management: 21st Century Paradigm for Product
Realisation was published.
116
The Emergence of PLM
117
Emergence of PLM (1)
The 21st Century environment of products differed greatly from that of the latter part
of the 20th Century. There was s greatly changed environment for products. There was
no longer an Iron Curtain. China had become a major manufacturer. India was big in
software. Japan's products were known for high quality. The environment was
globalised. There were female engineers, CFOs and CEOs. There were cross-
functional business processes, such ss Engineering Change Management.
118
Emergence of PLM (2)
The 21st Century environment of products differed greatly from that of the latter part
of the 20th Century. There has been technological revolutions. There was the Internet
and the World Wide Web. Electronics, computers and software were everywhere.
Product development times had been cut. Companies used CAD, CAM and PDM
systems for product development, manufacture and support. A Digital Transformation
was underway.
119
Emergence of PLM (3)
120
End of Lesson 3
121
End of Week 1
And it's also the end of Week 1 of the Business Value of PLM Course.
122