MKH-23014 Peer Review Report-Comments Tracker - ICT-10-01-2023

Project Name: Makkah Entertainment Complex Project No: MKH-23014
Prepared by AMSAD Architectural Associates Peer Review Report - Comments Tracker Location: Makkah
Department Electrical Department Issue Date & Rev: 10-Jan-24 Rev 00
IFC Reference Type: • DWG (Drawings) • CALC (Calculation) • REP (Reports) • SPECS (Specifications) • BIM Models • Others
Comments Level: • (Level 1) Non-Compliance Applicable Codes / Projects Specification/ Design Analysis Report / Municipal regulations • (Level 2) Missing and/or Insufficient information • (Level 3) Drafting and/or Printing Errors
General Notes: This Peer Review Comments Tracker is based on the IFC Package received from MBL on January 10, 2024
AMSAD Comment MBL Response Comments Status
Ser No. Comment IFC Reference Comment Response
Review Comment Response Open Closed
Date (Type - Number) Level Date
-Data of the Electricity power consumption KWH through the digital Power Meters (DPM) to
1 10-Jan.-2024 be collected through the BMS Network and to be available at the central BMS PC General comments Level 1
Workstations/software for billing system.
-Add note with regards to Technology Layout Design with the distance for more than 90 a. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-0010-00
meters, use UTP/FO and FO/UTP converter, power connected to the nearest uninterruptible b. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-0011-00
2 10-Jan.-2024 Level 2, 3
emergency power source. (typical to all) c. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-0013-00
- minor text overlapping over general notes and legend. d. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-0014-00
a. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1000-00
b. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1002-00
c.4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1003-00
d. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1004-00
e. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1005-00
f. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1006-00
g. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1007-00
-Add note with regards to Technology Layout Design with the distance for more than 90 h. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1008-00
3 10-Jan.-2024 meters, use UTP/FO and FO/UTP converter, power connected to the nearest uninterruptible i. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1009-00 Level 3
emergency power source. (typical to all) j. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1010-00
k. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1011-00
l. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1012-00
m. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1013-00
n. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1014-00
o. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1015-00
p. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1017-00
q. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1018-00
c. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1103-00
-Add note with regards to Technology Layout Design with the distance for more than 90 f. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1107-00
4 10-Jan.-2024 meters, use UTP/FO and FO/UTP converter, power connected to the nearest uninterruptible g. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1108-00 Level 3
emergency power source. (typical to all) h. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1109-00
i. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1112-00
j. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1113-00
k. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1114-00
l. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1117-00
m.4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1118-00
-Add note with regards to Technology Layout Design with the distance for more than 90 d. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1204-00
5 10-Jan.-2024 meters, use UTP/FO and FO/UTP converter, power connected to the nearest uninterruptible e. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1207-00 Level 3
emergency power source. (typical to all) f. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1208-00
g. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1209-00
h. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1212-00
i. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1213-00
-Add note with regards to Technology Layout Design with the distance for more than 90
6 10-Jan.-2024 meters, use UTP/FO and FO/UTP converter, power connected to the nearest uninterruptible Level 3
emergency power source. (typical to all)
f. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-TE-DWG-1313-00
-Double Check Master Layouts. Building are sprinkler protected therefore automatic
detections if Heat Detectors requied. One of example is drawing # 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-
DWG-0010-00.
-Double Check Master Layouts if carbon monoxide detector required?
7 10-Jan.-2024 General comments Level 2, 3
-Review the above false ceiling detectors, if more than 80cm provide above false ceiling
8 10-Jan.-2024 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-0011-00 Level 2, 3
detectors, Typical comment.
-Review the distance between detectors, details and other relevant drawings that are
9 10-Jan.-2024 related to this drawing sheet. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-0013-00 Level 3
-Provide heat detector coverage spacing Calcutation, Typical comment
10 10-Jan.-2024 related to this drawing sheet. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-0014-00 Level 3
-Provide heat detector coverage spacing Calcutation, Typical comment
a. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1000-00
b. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1002-00
c. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1003-00
d. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1004-00
e. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1005-00
f. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1006-00
g. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1007-00
-Review the distance between detectors, details and other relevant drawings that are h. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1008-00
11 10-Jan.-2024 related to this drawing sheet. i. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1009-00 Level 3
-Provide heat detector coverage spacing Calcutation, Typical comment j. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1010-00
k. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1011-00
l. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1012-00
m. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1013-00
n. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1014-00
o. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1015-00
p. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1017-00
q. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1018-00
-Review the distance between detectors, details and other relevant drawings that are d. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1104-00
related to this drawing sheet. e. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1106-00 **
-Incorporate detector coverage spacing calculation table on the layouts. Typical comment f. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1107-00
12 10-Jan.-2024 for ground floor. g. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1108-00 Level 2, 3
-in the event of a fire condition the audio system of the Tenant such as amplification h. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1109-00
equipment must be able to be silenced by the fire alarm control module in favor of the i. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1112-00
landlord's pre-recorded emergency evacuation message upon broadcasting it. j. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1113-00
k. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1114-00 **
l. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1117-00 **
m. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1112-00 **
related to this drawing sheet.
-Incorporate detector coverage spacing calculation table on the layouts. Typical comment
13 10-Jan.-2024 for first floor. Level 2, 3
f. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1208-00
-in the event of a fire condition the audio system of the Tenant such as amplification
equipment must be able to be silenced by the fire alarm control module in favor of the
h. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1212-00
landlord's pre-recorded emergency evacuation message upon broadcasting it.
i. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1213-00
j. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1214-00 **
Project Name: Makkah Entertainment Complex Project No: MKH-23014
Prepared by AMSAD Architectural Associates Peer Review Report - Comments Tracker Location: Makkah
Department Electrical Department Issue Date & Rev: 10-Jan-24 Rev 00
IFC Reference Type: • DWG (Drawings) • CALC (Calculation) • REP (Reports) • SPECS (Specifications) • BIM Models • Others
Comments Level: • (Level 1) Non-Compliance Applicable Codes / Projects Specification/ Design Analysis Report / Municipal regulations • (Level 2) Missing and/or Insufficient information • (Level 3) Drafting and/or Printing Errors
General Notes: This Peer Review Comments Tracker is based on the IFC Package received from MBL on January 10, 2024
AMSAD Comment MBL Response Comments Status
Ser No. Comment IFC Reference Comment Response
Review Comment Response Open Closed
Date (Type - Number) Level Date
-Data of the Electricity power consumption KWH through the digital Power Meters (DPM) to a. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1300-00
10-Jan.-2024 be collected through the BMS Network and to be available at the central BMS PC General comments
b. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1302-00 Level 1
Workstations/software for billing system. c. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1303-00
related to this drawing sheet.
14 10-Jan.-2024 f. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1308-00 Level 3
-Incorporate detector coverage spacing calculation table on the layouts. Typical comment
for roof floor.
h. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1312-00
i. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1313-00
j. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1314-00
k. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-1318-00
-Review schematic diagram connection between detectors, details and other relevant
15 10-Jan.-2024 drawings that are related to this drawing sheet. 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-6001-00 Level 2, 3
- provide minimum hours of batteries requirements with battery charger.
Drawings must be consistent with and reference other related drawings.
loudspeakers have two emergency cases must be taken into consideration either"
1. operate as an evacuation system, all speakers shall be fitted with fire dome and with fire
16 10-Jan.-2024 rated cable connection between speakers to increase fire protection. (ceiling loudspeakers 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-FS-DWG-6002-00 Level 3
type 4).
2. it will be switched off to allow PAVA system evacuating the people, a fire alarm control
module unit to be provided to silence the amplification equipment of BGM system.
4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-SS-DWG-0010-00
-Add note with regards to Security Systems Layout with the distance for more than 90
17 10-Jan.-2024 meters, use UTP/FO and FO/UTP converter, power connected to the nearest uninterruptible Level 2, 3
-Add note with regards to Security Systems Layout with the distance for more than 90 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-SS-DWG-1008-00
18 10-Jan.-2024 meters, use UTP/FO and FO/UTP converter, power connected to the nearest uninterruptible 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-SS-DWG-1009-00 Level 3
emergency power source. (typical to all) 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-SS-DWG-1010-00
-Add note with regards to Security Systems Layout with the distance for more than 90 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-SS-DWG-1107-00
19 10-Jan.-2024 meters, use UTP/FO and FO/UTP converter, power connected to the nearest uninterruptible 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-SS-DWG-1108-00 Level 3
emergency power source. (typical to all) 4MAKA08-DAR-FC-100-SS-DWG-1109-00
4MAKA08-TNEC-FC-722-FP-DWG-60502-A-FIRE
'-provide minimum hours requirements of fire rated cable.
23 10-Jan.-2024 DETECTION & ALARM SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM Level 3
-provide minimum hours of batteries requirements with battery charger.
LAYOUT
4MAKA08-TNEC-FC-722-SS-DWG-60801-A-GROUND
LEVEL-CCTV, SECURITY & DOOR ACCESS LAYOUT
4MAKA08-TNEC-FC-722-TE-DWG-60401-A-GROUND
-Add note with regards to Technology Layout Design with the distance for more than 90
LEVEL-DATA LAYOUT
4MAKA08-TNEC-FC-722-TE-DWG-60402-A-IT
SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM LAYOUT

MKH-23014 Peer Review Report-Comments Tracker - ICT-10-01-2023

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

MKH-23014 Peer Review Report-Comments Tracker - ICT-10-01-2023

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Project Name: Makkah Entertainment Complex Project No: MKH-23014

7 10-Jan.-2024 General comments Level 2, 3

Drawings must be consistent with and reference other related drawings.

You might also like