Power System Protection 2Nd Edition Paul M Anderson All Chapter

Power System Protection, 2nd Edition
Paul M. Anderson
Visit to download the full and correct content document:
https://ebookmass.com/product/power-system-protection-2nd-edition-paul-m-anderso
n/
Power System Protection
IEEE Press
445 Hoes Lane
Piscataway, NJ 08854
IEEE Press Editorial Board

Ekram Hossain, Editor in Chief
Jón Atli Benediktsson Xiaoou Li Jeffrey Reed

Anjan Bose Lian Yong Diomidis Spinellis
David Alan Grier Andreas Molisch Sarah Spurgeon
Elya B. Joffe Saeid Nahavandi Ahmet Murat Tekalp
Technical Reviewers
Vijay Vittal, Arizona State University
Ralph Barone, Consultant
Power System Protection
Second Edition
Paul M. Anderson†
Charles Henville
Henville Consulting Inc.
Rasheek Rifaat
Rifaat Engineering Inc.
Brian Johnson
University of Idaho
Sakis Meliopoulos
Georgia Institute of Technology
†
Deceased.
Copyright © 2022 by The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. All rights reserved.
Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey.

Published simultaneously in Canada.
No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any
means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section
107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or
authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222
Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 750-4470, or on the web at www.copyright.com.
Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons,
Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, (201) 748-6011, fax (201) 748-6008, or online at http://www.wiley.com/
go/permission.
Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing
this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents
of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose.
No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies
contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate.
Further, readers should be aware that websites listed in this work may have changed or disappeared between when
this work was written and when it is read. Neither the publisher nor authors shall be liable for any loss of profit or
any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages.
For general information on our other products and services or for technical support, please contact our Customer
Care Department within the United States at (800) 762-2974, outside the United States at (317) 572-3993 or fax (317)
572-4002.
Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be
available in electronic formats. For more information about Wiley products, visit our web site at www.wiley.com.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data applied for:

ISBN: 9781119513148
Cover design by Wiley

Cover image: © INTERMOUNTAIN AC SWITCHYARD BY A.P “SAKIS” MELIOPOULOS
Set in 9.5/12.5pt STIXTwoText by Straive, Chennai, India
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
v
Contents
Author Biographies xxv

Preface to the Second Edition xxvii
List of Symbols xxix
Part I Protective Devices and Controls 1
1 Introduction 3
1.1 Power System Protection 3
1.2 Prevention and Control of System Failure 3
1.2.1 Reactionary Devices 4
1.2.2 Safeguard Devices 5
1.2.3 Protective Device Operation 6
1.3 Protective System Design Considerations 8
1.4 Definitions Used in System Protection 9
1.5 System Disturbances 11
1.6 Book Contents 12
Problems 14
References 15
2 Protection Measurements and Controls 17

2.1 Graphic Symbols and Device Identification 17
2.2 Typical Relay Connections 19
2.3 Circuit Breaker Control Circuits 22
2.4 Instrument Transformers 23
2.4.1 Instrument Transformer Selection 24
2.4.2 Instrument Transformer Types and Connections 30
2.5 Relay Control Configurations 37
2.6 Optical Communications 38
Problems 42
References 44
3 Protective Device Characteristics 47

3.1 Introduction 47
3.2 Fuse Characteristics 48
vi Contents
3.2.1 Distribution Fuse Cutouts 48

3.2.2 Fuse Types 50
3.2.3 Fuse Time–Current Characteristics 53
3.2.4 Fuse Coordination Charts 56
3.3 Relay Characteristics 61
3.3.1 Relay Types 62
3.3.2 Electromechanical Relay Characteristics 66
3.3.3 Static Analog Relays 74
3.3.4 Differential Relays 74
3.3.5 Digital Relays 76
3.3.6 Digital Overcurrent Relays 84
3.4 Power Circuit Breakers 87
3.4.1 Circuit Breaker Definitions 87
3.4.2 Circuit Breaker Ratings 88
3.4.3 Circuit Breaker Design 91
3.5 Automatic Circuit Reclosers 93
3.5.1 Recloser Ratings 94
3.5.2 Recloser Time–Current Characteristics 95
3.6 Automatic Line Sectionalizers 98
3.7 Circuit Switchers 100
3.8 Digital Fault Recorders 101
Problems 103
References 103
4 Relay Logic 109

4.1 Introduction 109
4.2 Electromechanical Relay Logic 110
4.2.1 The Overcurrent Relay 110
4.2.2 The Distance Relay 110
4.3 Electronic Logic Circuits 111
4.3.1 Analog Logic Circuits 111
4.3.2 Digital Logic Circuits 116
4.4 Analog Relay Logic 125
4.4.1 An Instantaneous Overcurrent Relay 125
4.4.2 Phase Comparison Distance Relay 126
4.4.3 A Directional Comparison Pilot Relay 127
4.4.4 Conclusions Regarding Solid-State Analog Logic 128
4.5 Digital Relay Logic 128
4.5.1 Digital Signal Processing 129
4.5.2 The Data Window Method 133
4.5.3 The Phasor Method 134
4.5.4 Digital Relaying Applications 136
4.5.5 Example of a Digital Relay System 138
4.6 Hybrid Relay Logic 139
4.7 Relays as Comparators 140
4.7.1 Relay Design 140
4.7.2 Phase and Amplitude Comparison 141
Contents vii
4.7.3 The Alpha and Beta Planes 142

4.7.4 The General Comparator Equations 142
4.7.5 The Amplitude Comparator 146
4.7.6 The Phase Comparator 147
4.7.7 Distance Relays as Comparators 149
4.7.8 General Beta Plane Characteristics 151
Problems 153
References 157
5 System Characteristics 163

5.1 Power System Faults 163
5.1.1 System Fault Characteristics 164
5.1.2 Fault Currents Near Synchronous Machines 167
5.1.3 Saturation of Current Transformers 175
5.2 Station Arrangements 176
5.2.1 Single Bus, Single Breaker Arrangement 176
5.2.2 Main and Transfer Arrangement 177
5.2.3 Double Bus, Single Breaker Arrangement 178
5.2.4 Double Bus, Double Breaker Arrangement 179
5.2.5 Ring Bus Arrangement 179
5.2.6 Breaker-and-a-Half Arrangement 180
5.2.7 Other Switching Arrangements 180
5.3 Overhead Line Impedances 182
5.4 Computation of Available Fault Current 184
5.4.1 Three-Phase (3PH) Faults 186
5.4.2 Double Line-to-Ground (2LG) Faults 186
5.4.3 Line-to-Line (LL) Fault 186
5.4.4 One-Line-to-Ground (1LG) Fault 187
5.4.5 Summary of Fault Currents 188
5.5 System Equivalent for Protection Studies 188
5.5.1 The Open-Circuit Impedance Matrix 189
5.5.2 Computation of the Two-Port Representation 190
5.5.3 A Simple Two-Port Equivalent 192
5.5.4 Tests of the Equivalent Circuit 193
5.5.5 System Equivalent from Two-Port Parameters 193
5.5.6 Equivalent of a Line with Shunt Faults 194
5.5.7 Applications of the Equivalent to Series Faults 195
5.5.8 Conclusions Regarding Two-Port Equivalents 198
5.5.9 Multiport Equivalents 199
5.6 The Compensation Theorem 202
5.6.1 Network Solution Before Changing Y 3 203
5.6.2 Network Solution After Changing Y 3 203
5.6.3 The Incremental Change in Current and Voltage 204
5.6.4 The Compensation Theorem in Fault Studies 205
5.7 Compensation Applications in Fault Studies 205
5.7.1 Prefault Conditions 205
5.7.2 The Faulted Network Condition 206
viii Contents
5.7.3 The Fault Conditions Without Load Currents 208

5.7.4 Summary of Load and Fault Conditions 208
Problems 210
References 214
Part II Protection Concepts 215
6 Fault Protection of Radial Lines 217

6.1 Radial Distribution Systems 217
6.2 Radial Distribution Coordination 219
6.2.1 Supply System Information 219
6.2.2 Distribution Substation Information 220
6.2.3 Distribution System Information 220
6.2.4 Protective Equipment Information 221
6.2.5 Step-by-Step Study Procedure 221
6.3 Radial Line Fault Current Calculations 222
6.3.1 General Considerations for Radial Faults 222
6.3.2 Main Line Feeder Faults 223
6.3.3 Branch Line Faults 230
6.4 Radial System Protective Strategy 233
6.4.1 Clearing Temporary Faults 234
6.4.2 Isolating Permanent Faults 235
6.5 Coordination of Protective Devices 236
6.5.1 Recloser–Fuse Coordination 236
6.5.2 Recloser–Relay Coordination 239
6.6 Relay Coordination on Radial Lines 241
6.6.1 Coordination Procedure 242
6.6.2 Procedure for Phase and Ground Relays 245
6.6.3 Procedure for Instantaneous Relay Settings 252
6.7 Coordinating Protective Devices Measuring Different Parameters 258
6.7.1 Combined Time–Current Characteristics 259
6.7.2 Coordinating Time–Current Characteristics Across Transformers 265
6.7.3 Coordinating Two Overcurrent Relays Not Measuring the Same Currents 268
Problems 269
6.7.4 Time–Current Characteristics for Problem Solving 275
References 276
7 Introduction to Transmission Protection 277

7.2 Protection with Overcurrent Relays 278
7.2.1 Loops with One Current Source 280
7.2.2 Loops with Multiple Current Sources 282
7.3 Distance Protection of Lines 285
7.3.1 Distance Relay Characteristics 285
7.3.2 Zoned Distance Relays 291
7.3.3 Effect of Fault Resistance 293
Contents ix
7.3.4 Summary of Distance Relay Concepts 299

7.4 Unit Protection 299
7.5 Ground Fault Protection 301
7.5.1 Importance of Ground Fault Protection 301
7.5.2 Unique Characteristics of Ground Faults 302
7.5.3 Polarization of Ground Relays 303
7.5.4 Types of Ground Relays 309
7.6 Summary 310
Problems 311
References 315
8 Complex Loci in the Z and Y Planes 317

8.1 The Inverse Z Transformation 317
8.2 Line and Circle Mapping 320
8.2.1 The Half Z Plane: a = c = 0 321
8.2.2 The Half Z Plane: R ≤ − k2 323
8.2.3 The Half Plane: a = b = 0 323
8.2.4 The Half Plane: a = 0 324
8.2.5 The Half Plane: d = 0 325
8.3 The Complex Equation of a Line 327
8.4 The Complex Equation of a Circle 328
8.5 Inversion of an Arbitrary Admittance 330
8.5.1 Inversion of Y with |Y K | Constant and 𝜓 Variable 331
8.5.2 Inversion of Y with 𝜓 Constant and |Y K | Variable 332
8.5.3 Summary of Y Inversion Equations 332
8.6 Inversion of a Straight Line Through (1, 0) 333
8.7 Inversion of an Arbitrary Straight Line 335
8.8 Inversion of a Circle with Center at (1, 0) 336
8.9 Inversion of an Arbitrary Circle 338
8.10 Summary of Line and Circle Inversions 340
8.11 Angle Preservation in Conformal Mapping 341
8.12 Orthogonal Trajectories 342
8.13 Impedance at the Relay 346
Problems 348
References 350
9 Impedance at the Relay 351

9.1 The Relay Apparent Impedance, Z R 351
9.2 Protection Equivalent M Parameters 353
9.2.1 Network Test with EU Shorted 354
9.2.2 Network Test with ES Shorted 355
9.3 The Circle Loci Z = P/(1 ± Y K ) 356
9.4 Z R Loci Construction 357
9.4.1 k Circles 359
9.4.2 𝜓 Circles 360
9.5 Relay Apparent Impedance 363
9.5.1 The Unfaulted System 365
x Contents
9.5.2 ABCD Parameters for a Faulted System 367

9.6 Relay Impedance for a Special Case 371
9.7 Construction of M Circles 375
9.7.1 Short-Circuit Test with EU Shorted 375
9.7.2 Short-Circuit Test with ES Shorted 376
9.7.3 Summary of Short-Circuit Test Results 378
9.8 Phase Comparison Apparent Impedance 378
Problems 384
References 388
10 Admittance at the Relay 391

10.1 Admittance Diagrams 391
10.2 Input Admittance Loci 392
10.2.1 Y I Loci For Constant m 393
10.2.2 Y I Loci for Constant 𝜓 393
10.3 The Relay Admittance Characteristic 395
10.4 Parallel Transmission Lines 400
10.5 Typical Admittance Plane Characteristics 404
10.6 Summary of Admittance Characteristics 407
Problems 408
Reference 411
Part III Transmission Protection 413
11 Analysis of Distance Protection 415

11.2 Analysis of Transmission Line Faults 415
11.2.1 Sequence Network Reduction 417
11.2.2 Phase Faults at F 418
11.2.3 Ground Faults at F 424
11.3 Impedance at the Relay 429
11.3.1 Relay Impedances when C1 = C2 430
11.3.2 Apparent Relay Impedance Plots 434
11.4 Distance Relay Settings 439
11.5 Ground Distance Protection 447
11.6 Distance Relay Coordination 449
Problems 452
References 454
12 Transmission Line Mutual Induction 457

12.2 Line Impedances 458
12.2.1 Self- and Mutual Impedance 458
12.2.2 Estimation of Mutually Coupled Voltages 461
12.2.3 Example of Transmission Line Impedances 462
12.3 Effect of Mutual Coupling 469
Contents xi
12.3.1 Selecting a Reference Phasor 469

12.3.2 Transmission System Without Mutual Coupling 471
12.3.3 Transmission System with Mutual Coupling 472
12.3.4 Other Examples of Mutual Coupling 474
12.4 Short Transmission Line Equivalents 476
12.4.1 General Network Equivalents for Short Lines 476
12.4.2 Type 1 Networks 478
12.4.5 Lines with Appreciable Susceptance 482
12.4.6 Other Network Equivalents 483
12.5 Long Transmission Lines 484
12.5.1 The Isolated Long Transmission Line 484
12.5.2 Mutually Coupled Long Transmission Lines 486
12.6 Long Transmission Line Equivalents 493
12.6.1 Reciprocity and the Admittance Matrix 493
12.6.2 The Long-line Type 3 Network Equivalent 497
12.6.3 Long-line Type 1 Network Equivalents 498
12.6.4 Long-line Type 2 Network Equivalents 499
12.7 Solution of the Long-line Case 501
12.7.1 Determination of the Sequence Impedances 502
12.7.2 Computation of Sequence Voltages and Currents 504
Problems 504
References 507
13 Pilot Protection Systems 509

13.2 Physical Systems for Pilot Protection 512
13.2.1 General Concepts of Pilot Communications 513
13.2.2 Wire Pilot Systems 516
13.2.3 Power-Line Carrier Pilot Systems 517
13.2.4 Microwave Pilot Systems 518
13.2.5 Fiber-Optic Pilot Systems 520
13.2.6 Relay-to-Relay (Peer-to-Peer) Communications Systems 521
13.2.7 Guidelines for Pilot Communications Selection 521
13.2.8 Pilot Communications Problems 522
13.2.9 Pilot Protection Classifications 522
13.3 Non-unit Pilot Protection Schemes 523
13.3.1 Directional Comparison Schemes 523
13.3.2 Distance Schemes 523
13.3.3 Transfer Trip Pilot Protection 525
13.3.4 Blocking and Unblocking Pilot Protection 529
13.3.5 Selectivity in Directional Comparison Systems 532
13.3.6 Other Features of Directional Comparison 532
13.3.7 Hybrid Schemes 534
13.4 Unit Protection Pilot Schemes 536
13.4.1 Phase Comparison Schemes 536
xii Contents
13.4.2 Line Current Differential Schemes 544

13.5 An Example of EHV Line Protection 548
13.5.1 Considerations in EHV Protection 548
13.5.2 Description of the EHV Pilot Protection 549
13.6 Pilot Protection Settings 554
13.6.1 Instrument Transformer Settings 554
13.6.2 Characteristic (Maximum Torque) Angle 555
13.6.3 Distance Element Reach and Time Delay 555
13.6.4 Phase Overcurrent Element Settings 557
13.6.5 Residual Overcurrent Element Settings 558
13.6.6 Switch-onto-Fault Logic 559
13.6.7 Current Reversal Logic and Timers 559
13.6.8 Echo Keying 560
13.6.9 Weak Infeed Logic and Settings 560
13.6.10 Loss of Potential Logic 561
13.6.11 Conclusions Regarding Pilot Protection Settings 561
13.7 Traveling Wave Relays 561
13.8 Monitoring of Pilot Performance 567
Problems 567
References 569
14 Complex Transmission Protection 573

14.2 Single-phase Switching of Extra-high-voltage Lines 573
14.2.1 Control of Secondary Arcs in Transposed Lines 574
14.2.2 Secondary Arcs in Untransposed EHV Lines 578
14.3 Protection of Multiterminal Lines 581
14.3.1 Distance Protection for a Three-terminal Line 584
14.3.2 Pilot Protection for a Three-terminal Line 587
14.4 Protection of Mutually Coupled Lines 590
14.4.1 Mutual Coupling of Parallel Lines 590
14.4.2 Ground Distance Protection of Type 1 Networks 591
14.4.3 Distance Protection of Type 2 Networks 612
14.4.4 Distance Protection of Type 3 Networks 612
Problems 613
References 617
15 Series Compensated Line Protection 619

15.1.1 The Degree of Compensation 620
15.1.2 Voltage Profile on Series Compensated Lines 620
15.2 Faults with Unbypassed Series Capacitors 621
15.2.1 End-of-Line Capacitors – Bus Side Voltage 622
15.2.2 End-of-Line Capacitors – Line Side Voltage 628
15.2.3 Capacitors at the Center of the Line 629
15.2.4 Conclusions on Series Compensation Effects 633
15.3 Series Capacitor Bank Protection 634
Contents xiii
15.3.1 Series Capacitor Bypass Systems 635

15.3.2 A Fundamental Frequency Varistor Model 641
15.3.3 Relay Quantities Including Varistor Bypass 644
15.3.4 Effect of System Parameters 647
15.4 Relay Problems Due to Compensation 653
15.4.1 The Effect of Transient Phenomena 654
15.4.2 The Effect of Phase Impedance Unbalance 655
15.4.3 Subsynchronous Resonance Effects 656
15.4.4 Voltage and Current Inversions 656
15.4.5 Problems Due to Voltage Inversions 665
15.4.6 Problems Due to Mutual Induction 667
15.4.7 Problems in Reach Measurement 668
15.5 Protection of Series Compensated Lines 674
15.5.1 Line Current Differential and/or Current Phase Comparison 674
15.5.2 Directional Comparison Schemes 675
15.5.3 Directional Overcurrent Ground Protection 677
15.6 Line Protection Experience 678
15.6.1 The Effect of Transient Phenomena on Protection 678
15.6.2 The Effect of Phase Impedance Unbalance 678
15.6.3 The Effect of Voltage and Current Inversions 678
15.6.4 The Effect of Fault Locator Error 679
15.6.5 The Effect of Transducer Error 679
15.6.6 Autoreclosing of Transmission Lines 679
15.6.7 Requirements for Protection System Studies 679
15.6.8 General Experience with Line Protection 680
Problems 680
References 683
Part IV Apparatus Protection 685
16 Bus Protection 687

16.2 Bus Configurations and Faults 688
16.3 Bus Protection Requirements 689
16.4 Bus Protection by Backup Line Relays 691
16.5 Bus Differential Protection 692
16.5.1 Current Transformers for Bus Protection 692
16.5.2 Differential Protection Concepts and Problems 694
16.5.3 Differential Protection with Overcurrent Relays 696
16.5.4 Bus Protection with Percent Differential Relays 698
16.5.5 Bus Differential Protection with Linear Couplers 699
16.5.6 High-Impedance Bus Differential Protection 701
16.6 Other Types of Bus Protection 708
16.6.1 Zone-Interlocking/Blocking Bus Protection 708
16.6.2 Time-Coordinated Overcurrent or Distance Protection 709
16.6.3 Fault Bus Protection 709
xiv Contents
16.6.4 Combined Bus and Transformer Protection 710

16.6.5 Optical Arc Flash Bus Protection 711
16.6.6 Bus Protection Using Auxiliary CTs 711
16.6.7 Directional Comparison Bus Protection 716
16.7 Auxiliary Tripping Relays 716
16.7.1 Lockout Relays (Function 86) 716
16.7.2 Nonlockout Relays (Function 94) 716
16.8 Summary 717
Problems 717
References 719
17 Transformer and Reactor Protection 721

17.2 Transformer Faults 722
17.2.1 External Faults 722
17.2.2 Internal Faults 723
17.2.3 Fault Protection Philosophy 729
17.3 Magnetizing Inrush 729
17.3.1 Magnetizing Current Magnitude 730
17.3.2 Magnetizing Inrush Current Harmonics 732
17.3.3 Sympathetic Inrush in Parallel Banks 732
17.4 Protection Against Incipient Faults 732
17.4.1 Protection Against External Incipient Faults 733
17.4.2 Protection Against Internal Incipient Faults 734
17.5 Protection Against Active Faults 735
17.5.1 Connections for Differential Protection 736
17.5.2 Differential Protection of Transformers 739
17.5.3 Overcurrent Protection of Transformers 744
17.5.4 Ground Fault Protection of Transformers 745
17.5.5 Transformer Protection Using Digital Multifunction Relays 746
17.6 Combined Line and Transformer Schemes 748
17.6.1 Nonunit Protection Schemes 749
17.6.2 Line and Transformer Unit Protection 749
17.7 Regulating Transformer Protection 750
17.8 Shunt Reactor Protection 752
17.8.1 Dry Type Reactors 752
17.8.2 Oil-Immersed Reactors 753
17.9 Static Var Compensator Protection 755
17.9.1 A Typical SVC System 756
17.9.2 SVC Protection Requirements 757
Problems 759
References 761
18 Generator Protection 763

18.2 Generator System Configurations and Types of Protection 764
18.3 Stator Protection 766
Contents xv
18.3.1 Phase Fault Protection 766

18.3.2 Ground Fault Protection 769
18.3.3 Turn-to-Turn Fault Protection 777
18.3.4 Stator Open Circuit Protection 777
18.3.5 Overheating Protection 778
18.3.6 Overvoltage Protection 778
18.3.7 Unbalanced Current Protection 778
18.3.8 Backup Protection 781
18.4 Rotor Protection 781
18.4.1 Shorted Field Winding Protection 781
18.4.2 Grounded Field Winding 782
18.4.3 Open Field Winding 784
18.4.4 Overheating of the Field Winding 784
18.5 Loss of Excitation Protection 785
18.5.1 Operation as an Induction Generator 785
18.5.2 Loss of Field Protection 786
18.6 Other Generator Protection Systems 789
18.6.1 Overspeed Protection 790
18.6.2 Generator Motoring Protection 791
18.6.3 Vibration Protection 791
18.6.4 Bearing Failure Protection 792
18.6.5 Coolant Failure Protection 792
18.6.6 Fire Protection 792
18.6.7 Generator Voltage Transformer Fuse Blowing 792
18.6.8 Inadvertent Energizing 793
18.6.9 Protection of Power Plant Auxiliaries 793
18.7 Summary of Generator Protection 794
18.7.1 Unit Generator-Transformer Protection 794
18.7.2 Unit Generator-Transformer Trip Modes 797
18.7.3 Breaker Failure Protection of the Generator 797
Problems 800
References 803
19 Motor Protection 805

19.2 Induction Motor Analysis 806
19.2.1 Normalization of the Basic Equations 806
19.2.2 Induction Motor Equivalent Circuits 810
19.2.3 The Net Accelerating Torque 815
19.2.4 Motor Electrical and Mechanical Performance 817
19.3 Induction Motor Heating 824
19.3.1 Heat Transfer Fundamentals 824
19.3.2 A Motor Thermal Model 828
19.4 Motor Problems 837
19.4.1 Motor Problems Due to Internal Hazards 838
19.4.2 Motor Problems Due to External Hazards 839
19.5 Classifications of Motors 843
xvi Contents
19.5.1 Motors Classified by Service 843

19.5.2 Motors Classified by Location 844
19.5.3 Summary of Motor Classifications 845
19.6 Stator Protection 845
19.6.1 Phase Fault Protection 845
19.6.2 Ground Fault Protection 846
19.6.3 Locked Rotor Protection 846
19.6.4 Overload Protection 848
19.6.5 Undervoltage Protection 848
19.6.6 Reverse Phase Rotation Protection 849
19.6.7 Unbalanced Supply Voltage Protection 849
19.6.8 Loss of Synchronism in Synchronous Motors 850
19.6.9 Loss of Excitation in Synchronous Motors 850
19.6.10 Sudden Supply Restoration Protection 850
19.7 Rotor Protection 851
19.7.1 Rotor Heating 851
19.7.2 Rotor Protection Problems 851
19.8 Other Motor Protections 852
19.8.1 Bearing Protection 852
19.8.2 Complete Motor Protection 852
19.9 Summary of Large Motor Protections 853
Problems 854
References 858
Part V System Aspects of Protection 861
20 Protection Against Abnormal System Frequency 863

20.1 Abnormal Frequency Operation 863
20.2 Effects of Frequency on the Generator 864
20.2.1 Overfrequency Effects 864
20.2.2 Underfrequency Effects 864
20.3 Frequency Effects on the Turbine 866
20.3.1 Overfrequency Effects 869
20.3.2 Underfrequency Effects 869
20.4 A System Frequency Response Model 869
20.4.1 Effect of Disturbance Size, Pstep 874
20.4.2 Normalization 875
20.4.3 Slope of the Frequency Response 876
20.4.4 The Effect of Governor Droop, R 877
20.4.5 The Effect of Inertia, H 878
20.4.6 The Effect of Reheat Time Constant, T R 879
20.4.7 The Effect of High-Pressure Fraction, F H 880
20.4.8 The Effect of Damping, D 880
20.4.9 System Performance Analysis 881
20.4.10 Use of the SFR Model 882
20.4.11 Refinements in the SFR Model 883
Contents xvii
20.4.12 Other Frequency Response Models 885

20.4.13 Conclusions Regarding Frequency Behavior 886
20.5 Off Normal Frequency Protection 886
20.6 Steam Turbine Frequency Protection 887
20.7 Underfrequency Protection 889
20.7.1 A Typical Turbine Protection Characteristic 890
20.7.2 Load Shedding Traditional Relay Characteristics 890
20.7.3 Load Shedding Relay Connections 902
Problems 903
References 905
21 Protective Schemes for Stability Enhancement 909

21.2 Review of Stability Fundamentals 909
21.2.1 Definition of Stability 909
21.2.2 Power Flow Through an Impedance 910
21.2.3 Two-Port Network Representation 911
21.2.4 The Swing Equation 913
21.3 System Transient Behavior 918
21.3.1 Stability Test System 918
21.3.2 Effect of Power Transfer 919
21.3.3 Effect of Circuit Breaker Speed 923
21.3.4 Effect of Reclosing 924
21.3.5 Relay Measurements During Transients 924
21.4 Automatic Reclosing 929
21.4.1 The Need for Fast (High Speed) Reclosing 930
21.4.2 Disturbance Considerations in Reclosing 931
21.4.3 Reclosing Considerations 933
21.4.4 Reclosing Relays 937
21.4.5 Reclosing Switching Options 943
21.4.6 Reclosing at Generator Buses 945
21.5 Loss of Synchronism Protection 949
21.5.1 System Out-of-Step Performance 949
21.5.2 Out-of-Step Detection 952
21.5.3 Out-of-Step Blocking and Tripping 953
21.5.4 Circuit Breaker Considerations 956
21.5.5 Pilot Relaying Considerations 956
21.5.6 Out-of-step Relaying Practice 957
21.6 Voltage Stability and Voltage Collapse 957
21.7 System Integrity Protection Schemes (SIPS) 960
21.7.1 SIPS Characteristics 961
21.7.2 Disturbance Events 962
21.7.3 SIPS Design Procedure 963
21.7.4 Example of a System Integrity Protection Scheme 965
21.8 Summary 968
Problems 968
References 970
xviii Contents
22 Line Commutated Converter HVDC Protection 973

22.2 LCC Dc Conversion Fundamentals 974
22.2.1 Rectifier Operation 974
22.2.2 Inverter Operation 981
22.2.3 Multibridge Converters 984
22.2.4 Characteristic LCC Converter Harmonics 988
22.2.5 Basic HVDC Control 989
22.3 Converter Station Design 992
22.3.1 A Typical Converter Station 992
22.3.2 HVDC Control Hierarchical Structure 993
22.3.3 General Philosophy of HVDC Protection 997
22.3.4 General Categories of HVDC Protection 998
22.4 Ac Side Protection 999
22.4.1 Ac Line Protection 999
22.4.2 Ac Bus Protection 1000
22.4.3 Converter Transformer Protection 1000
22.4.4 Filters and Reactive Support Protection 1001
22.4.5 Generator Protection 1001
22.5 Dc Side Protection Overview 1002
22.5.1 Valve Protection 1002
22.5.2 Other Dc Side Protective Functions 1007
22.6 Special HVDC Protections 1012
22.6.1 General Description 1012
22.6.2 Reverse Power Protection 1012
22.6.3 Torsional Interaction Protection 1013
22.6.4 Self-Excitation Protection 1014
22.6.5 Dynamic Overvoltage Protection 1014
22.7 HVDC Protection Settings 1015
22.8 Summary 1016
Problems 1016
References 1018
23 Voltage Source Converter HVDC Protection 1021

23.2 VSC HVDC Fundamentals 1022
23.2.1 Voltage Source Converter Topologies 1022
23.2.2 VSC HVDC System Topologies 1027
23.3 Converter Control Systems 1028
23.3.1 Synchronization 1029
23.3.2 Current Controllers 1029
23.3.3 Outer Controllers 1030
23.4 HVDC Response to Ac System Faults 1030
23.5 Ac System Protection 1031
23.5.1 Converter Station Ac Protection 1031
23.5.2 Ac Line Protection 1034
23.6 Dc Faults 1035
Contents xix
23.6.1 Ac System Response to Dc Faults 1035

23.6.2 Dc Protection Schemes 1036
23.7 Multiterminal Systems 1037
23.8 Hybrid LCC–VSC Systems 1037
23.9 Summary 1038
Problems 1038
References 1039
24 Protection of Independent Power Producer Interconnections 1041

24.2 Renewable Resources 1042
24.3 Transmission Interconnections 1042
24.3.1 Interconnection Substations 1043
24.3.2 Transmission Tapped Interconnections 1045
24.3.3 Transmission Interconnection Protection 1052
24.4 Distribution Interconnections 1053
24.4.1 Distributed Resource Size 1054
24.4.2 Dedicated Interconnection Feeders 1055
24.4.3 Shared Interconnection Feeders 1056
24.5 Summary 1060
Problems 1061
References 1061
25 SSR and SSCI Protection 1063

25.2 SSR Overview 1063
25.2.1 Types of SSR Interactions 1068
25.2.2 A Brief History of SSR Phenomena 1070
25.3 SSR and SSCI System Countermeasures 1073
25.3.1 Network and Source Controls 1073
25.3.2 Generator and System Modifications 1078
25.4 SSR Source Countermeasures 1079
25.4.1 Filtering and Damping 1079
25.4.2 Relay Protection and Monitoring 1084
25.5 Summary 1093
Problems 1093
References 1095
Part VI Reliability of Protective Systems 1101
26 Basic Reliability Concepts 1103

26.2 Probability Fundamentals 1103
26.2.1 The Probability Axioms 1104
26.2.2 Events and Experiments 1104
26.2.3 Venn Diagrams 1105
xx Contents
26.2.4 Classes and Partitions 1106

26.2.5 Rules for Combining Probabilities 1107
26.3 Random Variables 1110
26.3.1 Definition of a Random Variable 1110
26.3.2 The Cumulative Probability Distribution Function 1111
26.3.3 The Probability Density Function 1111
26.3.4 Discrete Distributions 1112
26.3.5 Continuous Distributions 1113
26.3.6 Moments 1114
26.3.7 Common Probability Distribution Functions 1115
26.3.8 Random Vectors 1123
26.3.9 Stochastic Processes 1124
26.3.10 Power System Disturbances 1126
26.4 Failure Definitions and Failure Modes 1127
26.4.1 Failure Definitions 1127
26.4.2 Modes of Failure 1128
26.5 Reliability Models 1129
26.5.1 Definition of Reliability 1129
26.5.2 The Repair Process 1132
26.5.3 The Whole Process 1134
26.5.4 Constant Failure and Repair Rate Model 1138
Problems 1141
References 1143
27 Reliability Analysis 1145

27.1 Reliability Block Diagrams 1145
27.1.1 Series Systems 1146
27.1.2 Parallel Systems 1147
27.1.3 Series–Parallel and Parallel–Series Systems 1148
27.1.4 Standby Systems 1149
27.1.5 Bridge Networks 1151
27.1.6 Cut Sets 1152
27.2 Fault Trees 1154
27.2.1 Fault Tree Conventions 1154
27.2.2 System Analysis Methods 1155
27.2.3 System Components 1156
27.2.4 Component Failures 1157
27.2.5 Basic Fault Tree Construction 1158
27.2.6 Decision Tables 1162
27.2.7 Signal Flow Graphs 1165
27.3 Reliability Evaluation 1166
27.3.1 Qualitative Analysis 1166
27.3.2 Quantitative Analysis 1170
27.4 Other Analytical Methods 1174
27.4.1 Reliability Block Diagrams 1174
27.4.2 Success Trees 1176
27.4.3 Truth Tables 1176
Contents xxi
27.4.4 Structure Functions 1179

27.4.5 Minimal Cut Sets 1181
27.4.6 Minimal Path Sets 1182
27.5 State Space and Markov Processes 1182
27.5.1 The Markov Process 1182
27.5.2 Stationary State Probabilities 1185
27.5.3 General Algorithm for Markov Analysis 1185
27.5.4 Model of Two Repairable Components 1187
27.5.5 Markov Models with Special Failure Modes 1188
27.5.6 Failure Frequency and Duration 1189
Problems 1190
References 1195
28 Reliability Concepts in System Protection 1197

28.2 System Disturbance Models 1197
28.2.1 A Probabilistic Disturbance Model 1197
28.2.2 Disturbance Distribution 1200
28.2.3 Disturbance Classifications 1202
28.2.4 Probabilistic Model of Disturbances 1203
28.2.5 Disturbance Joint Probability Density 1208
28.3 Time-Independent Reliability Models 1208
28.3.1 The Protection and the Protected Component 1209
28.3.2 System Reliability Concepts 1210
28.3.3 Coherent Protection Logic 1217
28.3.4 Protective System Analysis 1229
28.3.5 Specifications for Transmission Protection 1242
28.4 Time-Dependent Reliability Models 1246
28.4.1 Failure Distributions of Random Variables 1246
28.4.2 Composite Protection System 1252
Problems 1256
References 1259
29 Fault Tree Analysis of Protective Systems 1261

29.2 Fault Tree Analysis 1262
29.2.1 System Nomenclature 1262
29.2.2 Calculation of Component Parameters 1263
29.2.3 Computation of Minimal Cut Set Parameters 1267
29.2.4 Computation of System Parameters 1269
29.3 Analysis of Transmission Protection 1273
29.3.1 Functional Specification for the Protective System 1273
29.3.2 The Top Event 1278
29.3.3 Failure of the Circuit Breakers 1279
29.3.4 Protective System Failure 1284
29.4 Fault Tree Evaluation 1297
29.4.1 Breaker Failure Evaluation 1298
xxii Contents
29.4.2 Protective System Failure Evaluation 1300

29.4.3 Determination of Minimal Cut Sets 1302
29.4.4 Constant Failure Rate-Special Cases 1304
Problems 1306
References 1310
30 Markov Modeling of Protective Systems 1311

30.2 Testing of Protective Systems 1312
30.2.1 The Need for Testing 1314
30.2.2 Reliability Modeling of Inspection 1316
30.3 Modeling of Inspected Systems 1317
30.3.1 Optimal Inspection Interval 1317
30.3.2 Optimization for Redundant Systems 1323
30.3.3 Optimal Design of k-out-of-n:G Systems 1325
30.4 Monitoring and Self-testing 1331
30.4.1 Monitoring Techniques 1332
30.4.2 Self-Checking Techniques 1332
30.4.3 Monitoring and Self-Checking Systems 1333
30.4.4 Automated Testing 1335
30.4.5 Intelligent Monitoring and Testing 1336
30.5 The Unreadiness Probability 1337
30.6 Protection Abnormal Unavailability 1341
30.6.1 Assumptions 1342
30.7 Evaluation of Safeguard Systems 1350
30.7.1 Definitions and Assumptions 1351
30.7.2 The Unconditional Hazard Rate 1352
30.7.3 Expected Number of Failures 1352
Problems 1354
References 1356
Appendix A Protection Terminology 1359

A.1 Protection Terms and Definitions 1359
A.2 Relay Terms and Definitions 1361
A.3 Classification of Relay Systems 1363
A.4 Circuit Breaker Terms and Definitions 1366
References 1368
Appendix B Protective Device Classification 1371

B.1 Device Function Numbers 1371
B.2 Devices Performing More than One Function 1371
B.2.1 Suffix Numbers 1373
B.2.2 Suffix Letters 1373
B.2.3 Representation of Device Contacts on Electrical Diagrams 1374
Appendix C Overhead Line Impedances 1375

References 1387
Contents xxiii
Appendix D Transformer Data 1389
Appendix E 500 kV Transmission Line Data 1393

E.1 Tower Design 1393
E.2 Unit Length Electrical Characteristics 1393
E.3 Total Line Impedance and Admittance 1394
E.4 Nominal Pi 1395
E.5 ABCD Parameters 1395
E.6 Equivalent Pi 1395
E.7 Surge Impedance Loading 1397
E.8 Normalization 1399
E.9 Line Ratings and Operating Limits 1399
References 1400
Index 1401
xxv
Author Biographies
Charles Henville has more than 50 years of experience as a power system engineer, including
40 years as a protection engineer. He worked for 30 years as a commissioning engineer and protec-
tion engineer for a large Canadian utility before starting his own consulting engineering company.
He has been an active participant in the IEEE Power and Energy Society, Power System Relaying
and Control Committee (PSRCC). This committee is responsible for creating numerous IEEE stan-
dards and technical papers dealing with power system protection. Charles was the Chairman of
that Committee and one of its subcommittees and of several of its working groups.
He is also actively involved in teaching and training working engineers. He has presented several
short courses for continuing professional development and has served as an instructor at Gon-
zaga University, the University of Wisconsin, and the University of British Columbia. As a trainer
for utility engineers, he has had broad exposure to protection practices in North America and
worldwide.
Rasheek Rifaat (P.Eng., IEEE Life Fellow) graduated from Cairo University (Egypt), 1972, BSc
and McGill University, (Montreal, QC, Canada), 1979, Master Engineering. He has over 45 years
of experience with industrial and utility electrical power systems in Canada, North America, and
overseas. His experience extends to renewable and traditional power generation, cogeneration,
industrial plants, power transmission, sub-transmission and distribution systems, and large system
interconnections. His long time experience encompasses power system protection design, coordi-
nation and settings, and power system studies including transient studies, insulation coordination,
surge protection, power system reliability, and operational requirements.
He authored and presented over 40 peer-reviewed technical papers and publications and pre-
sented many tutorials on power system protection and transient studies. He is also the current Chair
of the Work Group looking after the IEEE Standards for Protection and Coordination of Industrial
and Commercial Power Systems (formerly known as the Buff Book, Reproduced as Standards Series
3004). He has been involved with the Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers Inc. (IEEE)
for over 40 years and became a Life Fellow Member since 2016. He has been awarded the year 2020,
R. H. Tanner Award for industry leadership for the Canadian Region (Region 7).
He is presently registered as a P.Eng. in Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Ontario and is a member of
the Energy Industry Electrical Engineering Association.
Brian Johnson is a University Distinguished Professor and the Schweitzer Engineering Labora-
tories Endowed Chair in Power Engineering in the University of Idaho Department of Electrical
and Computer Engineering. He received BS, MS, and PhD degrees in electrical engineering from
the University of Wisconsin-Madison. He has worked at the University of Idaho for over 25 years,
where he was chair of the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering from 2006 to 2012.
xxvi Author Biographies
His teaching and research interests include power system protection, HVDC transmission, power
electronic applications in power systems, and resilience controls for critical infrastructure systems.
He is active with the IEEE Power and Energy Society, where he was the chair of the Power and
Energy Education Committee from 2014 to 2015 and of the IEEE HVDC and FACTS subcommit-
tee in 2018–2020. He is currently a member of the editorial board for IEEE Power and Energy
Magazine. He is a registered professional engineer in the State of Idaho.
Sakis Meliopoulos obtained a Diploma in Electrical and Mechanical Engineering from the
National Technical University in Athens, Greece, in 1972 and a Master in EE (1974) and a PhD
degree (1976) from the Georgia Institute of Technology in Atlanta, Georgia, USA. He joined the
faculty of the Georgia Institute of Technology as an Assistant Professor (1976), Associate Professor
(1982–1988) and full professor (1989 to present). In 2006 he was named the Georgia Power
Distinguished Professor. He is actively involved in education and research for improved safety
and electromagnetic compatibility of electric power installations, protection, and control of power
systems and the application of new technology in these areas. Since 1999 he is the Georgia Tech
Site Director of PSERC, an NSF I/URC. Since 2016 he is the associate director for cyber-physical
security of the Georgia Tech Institute for Information Security and Privacy (IISP). He has pioneered
several new analysis and design techniques for bulk power reliability analysis, safety, protection,
and electromagnetic compatibility of electric power systems. Most well-known is the EPRI trans-
mission reliability program TRELLS (now renamed TransCARE), the GPS-synchronized harmonic
state measurement system for transmission systems (first [1993] wide area measurement system
on NYPA), the distributed dynamic state estimation method (SuperCalibrator), the setting-less
relay, the CYMSA software (Cyber-Physical Modeling and Simulation for Situational Awareness),
his invention of the Smart Ground Multimeter, the EPRI grounding analysis programs, and the
WinIGS (Integrated Grounding System analysis and design). He has modernized many power
system courses at Georgia Tech, initiated the power system certificate program for practicing
engineers, and he co-developed the Master of Science Cybersecurity, Energy Systems degree. He
is a Fellow of the IEEE. He holds three patents, and he has published three books, and over 430
technical papers. He has received a number of awards, including the Sigma Xi Young Faculty
award (1981), the outstanding Continuing Education Award, Georgia Institute of Technology
(twice 2002 and 2014), the 2017 D. Scott Wills ECE Distinguished Mentor Award, the 2020 ECE
Distinguished Faculty Achievement Award, he received the 2005 IEEE Richard Kaufman Award
and the 2010 George Montefiore international award. In 2019 he received the Doctor Honoris
Causa from his alma matter, NTUA.
xxvii
Preface to the Second Edition
In the First Edition, Paul Anderson built a solid foundation of analytical study of electric power
system protection. Most of the analytical techniques are still applicable. During the 23 years since
the first publication, there have been many advances in the technology that are now incorporated
in the second publication. Such advances included two fronts. The first front has been associated
with the gradual reformatting of the overall system with more renewable generation, high efficiency
components, and increased interests in safe and secure operations of the power system. The sec-
ond front has been associated with the applications of numeric multifunction relays with further
intelligence and abilities in recognizing fault occurrence, and in developing protection operational
decisions. With the continuation of such advances, protection engineers and specialist need a solid
understanding of the correlated concepts discussed in the book.
The first edition was a massive work for a single author. This second edition needed the combined
efforts of four the authors to bring the book up to date.
Most of the review work was provided by internal review between various authors other than
the initial author/updater. However, we gratefully acknowledge additional thoughtful and helpful
reviews by Vijay Vittal and Ralph Barone.
In addition to updating references and standards and correcting a few typographical errors, the
second edition now includes the following:
In Part 1, Protective Devices and Controls, issues such as power quality and regulatory require-
ments are updated. New technologies such as phasor measurements and proliferation of precise
time applications are noted. The impact of IEC standards on fuse ratings and peer-to-peer commu-
nications is discussed. Six generations of protective relays are now noted in Chapter 3 instead of the
four in the First Edition. These additional generations are discussed in appropriate later chapters.
The standardization of digital overcurrent relays is described, together with migration from using
graphical time current characteristics to calculated ones. Inverter based resources now have an
impact on network faults.
In Part 2, Protection Concepts, we add discussion of different measuring principles such as
negative sequence overcurrent, new methods of polarizing directional ground overcurrent relays,
coordinating overcurrent relays measuring currents at different voltages, and transmission line
protection using quadrilateral distance relays. Analytical techniques for distance relays in Chapters
8–10 remain largely unchanged.
In Part 3, Transmission Protection, we add discussion of issues that have arisen since the first
edition. These include the following:
● A detailed settings example for a three zone quadrilateral distance relay
● Impact of frequency changes on the security of distance relays
● New definitions of short and long lines

xxviii Preface to the Second Edition
● New techniques of line differential protection

● New teleprotection applications
● Detection of secondary arc extinction facilitating single phase tripping and reclosing
In Part 4, Apparatus Protection, the scope is expanded to include industrial protection systems.
Modern differential protection systems using advance digital relays are discussed. We discuss
issues related to reliability of multifunction systems such as “putting all eggs in one basket.”
With increased concerns linked to excessive arc flash incident energy in industrial system, bus
protection aspects and applications have been considered, and associated descriptions added.
In Part 5, System Aspects of Protection, we explore the meaning of system integrity protection
schemes (SIPS) as a development following special protection systems (SPS). System stability issues
are expanded to include voltage stability concerns. In addition, two new chapters are added to
address modern developments. New chapters are
● Voltage Sourced Converter Protection, which addresses the application and protection of modular
multi-level converters. These converters are commonly used for interconnecting wind genera-
tion, photovoltaic sources, and batteries.
● Protection of Independent Power Producer Interconnections, which addresses the issues facing
interconnection of market energy sources to transmission and distribution systems.
In Part 6, Reliability of Protective Systems, there are relatively few changes as the analytical con-
cepts have not changed significantly since the first edition.
Charles Henville
Vancouver, BC, Canada
Rasheek Rifaat
Calgary AB, Canada
Brian Johnson
Moscow, ID
Sakis Meliopoulos
Atlanta, GA
xxix
List of Symbols
The general rules used for symbols in this book are as follows. Letter symbols for units of physical
quantities (unit symbol abbreviations) are given in Roman or Greek typeface, e.g. A for amperes, VA
for voltamperes, or Ω for ohms. Mathematical variables are always given in italic typeface, and may
be either Roman or Greek, e.g. v for instantaneous voltage, V for rms phasor voltage magnitude,
or 𝜆 for failure rate of a component. Complex numbers, such as phasors, are given in bold italic
typeface, e.g. I for current and V for voltage. Matrices are specified by bold Roman typeface, e.g.
Z for an impedance matrix. The following tabulations give specific examples of symbols used in
this book.
1. Capitals
A ampere; unit symbol abbreviation for current
A complex two port network transmission parameter
B = Im Y , susceptance
B complex two-port transmission parameter
C capacitance
CTI coordination time interval
C complex two-port transmission parameter
D damping constant
D complex two-port transmission parameter
E source emf; voltage
ES source voltage, relay equivalent circuit
EU source voltage, relay equivalent circuit
F failure probability
F farad; unit symbol abbreviation for capacitance
G = Re Y , conductance
H inertia constant
H henry, unit symbol abbreviation for inductance
Hz hertz, unit symbol abbreviation for frequency
I rms current magnitude
I rms phasor current
K spring constant; controller gain
L inductance
LL line-to-line
xxx List of Symbols
LN line-to-neutral
M = 106 , mega, a prefix
M matrix defining relay voltage and current
MOC minimum operating current, overcurrent relay
N newton, unit symbol abbreviation for force
P average real power
Pn natural power of a transmission line, SIL
Q average reactive power, unavailability
R = Re Z, resistance
S = P + jQ, complex apparent power
SB base complex or apparent power, VA
SIL surge impedance loading of a transmission line
T time constant
V rms voltage magnitude
V rms phasor voltage
V volt, unit symbol abbreviation for voltage
VA volt-ampere, unit symbol abbreviation for apparent power
VAR volt-ampere, reactive, unit symbol abbreviation for var
W number of failures in a specified time period
W watt, unit symbol abbreviation for active power
X = Im Z, reactance
Y = G + jB, complex admittance
YC characteristic admittance of a transmission line +1/Z C
Y admittance magnitude
Y admittance matrix
Z = R + jX, complex impedance
ZR impedance seen at the relay at R
ZE external system impedance of a network equivalent
ZS source impedance of a network equivalent
ZU source impedance of a network equivalent
ZF fault impedance
Z impedance magnitude
Z impedance matrix
2. Lowercase
ac alternating current
a–b–c phase designation of three phase currents or voltages
b = 𝜔c, line susceptance per unit length
c capacitance per unit length
dc direct current
det determinant of a matrix
e base for natural logarithms
f frequency
h distance measurement parameter
i instantaneous current designation
List of Symbols xxxi
√
j −1, a 90∘ operator
k = 103 , kilo, an mks prefix
k degree of series compensation
l inductance per unit length
𝓁 length of a transmission line
In, log natural (base e) logarithm, base 10 logarithm
m = 10−3 , milli…, an mks prefix
m mutual inductance per unit length
pu per unit
p instantaneous power; Maxwell’s coefficient
r apparatus resistance
s distance along a transmission line
t time
v instantaneous voltage
var voltampere reactive, when used as a noun or adjective
w frequency of failure
x line reactance per unit length; apparatus reactance
y line shunt admittance per unit length
z line impedance per unit length
3. Uppercase Greek
Δ delta connection; determinant (of a matrix)
Σ summation notation
Ω ohm, unit symbol abbreviation for impedance
4. Lowercase Greek
𝛾 propagation constant of a transmission line
𝛿 voltage phase angle
𝜁 magnitude of impedance
𝜃 phase angle of voltage or current, angle of impedance
𝜆 item failure in reliability calculations
𝜇 = 10−6 , micro, an mks prefix
𝜋 pi
𝜌 resistivity, magnitude of admittance
𝜏 time constant
𝜙 phase angle of voltage or current, angle of admittance
𝜔 radian frequency
5. Subscripts
a phase a
A phase a
xxxii List of Symbols
b phase b
B phase b
B base quantity
c phase c
C phase c
LN line-to-neutral
LL line-to-line
max maximum
min minimum
R receiving end, of a transmission line
S sending end, of a transmission line
u per unit, sometimes used for clarity
6. Superscripts and Overbars
( )t transpose (of a matrix)

( )−1 inverse (of a matrix)
Ã tilde, distinguishing mark for various quantities
Â circumflex, distinguishing mark for various quantities
( )* conjugate, of a phasor or matrix
1
Part I
Protective Devices and Controls

3
Introduction
1.1 Power System Protection
The purpose of this book is to present an introductory treatment of power system protection. This
includes a study of common types of abnormal occurrences, such as faults, that can lead to power
system failure, and the methods for detecting and clearing these abnormalities to restore normal
operation. The method of detecting and clearing faults requires the use of special hardware, which
is designed for this purpose. This book does not emphasize the hardware, as this requires timely
information concerning the products marketed by various manufacturers. Instead, the emphasis
will be on analytical techniques that are needed to compute the system conditions at the point of
detection and the methods of making detection fast and effective. Most of these techniques are
applicable to protective devices of any manufacturer and, therefore, constitute general methods for
protective system analysis.
The treatment of the subject of system protection is intended primarily for the engineer or student
who is learning the subject. This does not mean, however, that the presentation is elementary. It is
presumed that the reader has mastered the usual requirements of the bachelors degree in electrical
engineering and is familiar with the use of digital computers. It is also presumed that the reader
has a working knowledge of symmetrical components, as presented in [1].
System protection has evolved, over the years, from relatively primitive devices with limited capa-
bility to complex systems that involve extensive hardware. These modern protective systems are
more selective in their detection and operation and often require greater analytical effort in their
application. This book is concerned with this analytical effort. We begin with a review of the basic
equipment arrangements that provide the protective equipment with its raw data. We then progress
to the computation of protective system quantities, beginning with simple circuit arrangements and
progressing to more complex situations. This involves a treatment of the Thevenin impedance seen
by the protective device at the point of application. This concept is examined in settings designed to
protect lines, generators, transformers, and bus structures. Finally, we examine some special topics,
including system aspects of protection, and protective system reliability.
1.2 Prevention and Control of System Failure

Most of the failure modes in a power system can be controlled to limit damage and thereby, enhance
reliability. Mechanical failures are controlled by designing the system to withstand all but the
unusually severe mechanical loads such as extensive ice buildup, hurricanes, and tornadoes. This
Power System Protection, Second Edition. Paul M. Anderson, Charles Henville, Rasheek Rifaat, Brian Johnson,
and Sakis Meliopoulos.
© 2022 The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. Published 2022 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
4 1 Introduction
is done in a way that tends to minimize the total transport cost of energy, which requires a balance
between initial cost and maintenance. Insulation design is coordinated to minimize damage to
expensive equipment due to electrical surges. Since it is not economical to design a system to with-
stand all possible system failures, the alternative is to design a protective system that can quickly
detect abnormal conditions and take appropriate action. The type of action taken depends on the
protective device and on the environmental condition that is observed by that device. The two basic
types of protective systems are defined in this book as follows:
1. Reactionary devices. These devices are designed to recognize a certain hazard in the power sys-
tem environment and to take predetermined action to remove that hazard. In most cases, the
hazard is related to an abnormal system operating condition that would eventually cause failure
of one or more system components. Therefore, the action is usually to isolate that portion of the
system experiencing the hazard so that the rest of the system can operate normally.
2. Safeguard devices. These devices are designed to recognize a certain hazard in the power system
environment and to take predetermined action to change that environment to a less hazardous
condition.
Each type of device will be discussed briefly.
1.2.1 Reactionary Devices

Reactionary devices are designed to detect a specific system hazard, such as a short circuit, on a
system component and to remove that hazard. The power system is not designed to operate con-
tinually in the presence of hazards such as short circuits. The protective system action restores the
system to the best possible operating condition under the circumstances. In many cases, after test-
ing or inspection, the failed component can often be restored to operation. This may not be true,
however, if the failed component were to continue to operate for a long time under the influence
of the hazard.
The protection of the system against total failure must be adaptive in the sense that it must operate
in an acceptable manner for any kind of abnormal occurrence in a reliable manner. The protective
system is required to make decisions quickly, typically in a few milliseconds, and usually on the
basis of limited information as to the history and state of the system at a given point of observation.
The condition of the electrical system as it experiences and recovers from a major fault or failure
may be characterized in terms of a set of unique system states. Thus, we say that the system is
in the normal state when all items of equipment that should be in operation are actually working
and are operating within normal design limits. When an event occurs that causes the operation of
any system component to exceed its normal operating limits, we say that the system has entered
an abnormal state, which implies that something must be done to relieve the abnormality before
a serious failure occurs. Abnormalities can be transient in nature, and, depending on the nature
of the condition, it may be prudent to wait a bit before taking any action to see if the abnormality
clears itself. If not, we enter an action state, in which certain prescribed actions must be taken,
usually without further intentional delay. Following this action, the system is in an outage state,
in which the faulted device is removed from service. Since this state is not the desired operating
condition, the system is usually caused to enter a restorative state, wherein any required inspections
or other repair actions are taken in order to again reach the normal state. This process is depicted
in Figure 1.1.
From Figure 1.1, it is apparent that two conditions must be met in order to remove a component
from normal service.
Figure 1.1 Operative states of a protection

system. Normal state
x > Xm Inequality
constraint x < Xm
Abnormal Restorative
state state
t>0
t < Tm t > Tm
Action Outage
state state
Time
constraint
To trip the device:

1. Violate the inequality constraint, x > X m and
2. Violate the time constraint, t > T m .
It is also convenient to think of this process in terms of a decision flow chart, which might be
implemented in a computer control system. Such a flow chart is shown in Figure 1.2. Usually, the
system is in the normal state, and the protective device is set to assume that the normal state pre-
vails at startup. As time is incremented, the protective device checks the observed system variables,
represented by x in the flow chart, to determine if any variable exceeds its threshold value. If not,
time is incremented to observe the next measured value. If the threshold is exceeded, the time
threshold is checked and tripping action is withheld until the time threshold expires. When both
the quantity and time thresholds are exceeded, the circuit is tripped. This type of logic is designed to
prevent tripping for short, temporary disturbances that might be observed. Such disturbances are
often a part of the normal operating condition of the network, and tripping should not be initiated
for such events.
In some protective systems, automatic restoration is begun following a preset time delay. This
concept has proven valuable since most power system disturbances are temporary, including short
circuits. Once the circuit is de-energized, the abnormal condition clears itself and the circuit can
be successfully restored. If this is not a part of the programmed response of the device, the circuit
is “locked out” and remains in the outage state until repair personnel can determine the cause of
the outage and take appropriate action. This state is shown at the bottom of the flow chart, where
the system is in the outage state with no automatic escape.
1.2.2 Safeguard Devices

Safeguard devices are different from reactionary devices since safeguards are designed to change
the environmental conditions that are the cause of the emergency. Examples of safeguard devices
are fire sprinkler systems, apparatus supplementary cooling systems, and detectors that monitor
unbalanced currents or voltages in equipment. These systems are designed to change the operat-
ing environment when protective sensors detect a specified hazardous condition. Thus, the fire
sprinkler puts out the fire, and the apparatus supplementary cooling system withdraws additional
heat from the operating machine to restore a normal working environment. Some safeguards are
designed to alarm the operator, who makes a decision as to the severity of the hazard and may
take preemptive action, such as shutting down a facility that is experiencing a hazardous condition.
6 1 Introduction
Normal Figure 1.2 Flow chart of the tripping

state decision process.
Increment
time
N
x > Xm ?
N
t > Tm ? Restore
circuit
Y
Trip
circuit Time
delay
Y
Restore ?
N
Outage
state
Other safeguards are designed to take action, which may include removing equipment from service
if other remedial actions are not effective.
Some safeguard devices are extremely important in power systems. A good example is the emer-
gency core cooling system of a nuclear reactor, which has the capability of preventing core melt-
down following a dangerous reactor failure or accident. Such safeguards must be carefully designed
for very high reliability and security because of the high cost of failure.
For the most part, this book deals with reactionary protective systems, although many features
of these systems are shared by safeguards as well.
1.2.3 Protective Device Operation

The protective device usually consists of several elements that are arranged to test the system con-
dition, make decisions regarding the normality of observed variables, and take action as required.
These elements are depicted graphically in Figure 1.3.
The protective system always measures certain system quantities, such as voltages and currents,
and compares these system quantities, or some combination of these quantities, against a threshold
setting that is computed by the protection engineer and is set into the device. If this comparison
indicates an alert condition, a decision element is triggered. This may involve a timing element,
to determine the permanence of the condition, and may require other checks on the system at
Threshold
quantity
Metered Comparison Decision Action

quantity element element element
Figure 1.3 Protective device functional elements.
other points in the network. Finally, if all checks are satisfied, an action element is released to
operate, which usually means that circuit breakers are instructed to open and isolate a section of
the network.
The time required to take any necessary corrective action is called the clearing time and is defined
as follows:
Tc = Tp + Td + Ta (1.1)
where
T c = clearing time
T p = comparison time
T d = decision time
T a = action time, including circuit breaker operating time
The clearing time is very important for a variety of reasons. These reasons are elaborated on in
the following paragraphs.
Timing is important to facilitate coordination with other devices. Since other protective systems
in the network may be time-coordinated with this protective device in order to ensure that only the
necessary portions of the network are interrupted. There is an important message here, namely,
that many protective devices will observe a given disturbance and many of them will find that
disturbance to exceed their threshold settings. Each device should have some kind of restraint to
allow those closest to the disturbance to trip first. Time is one kind of restraint that is often used.
Other restraint mechanisms will be discussed later.
Fast clearing time is also important because some disturbances, such as short circuits, must be
cleared promptly in order to preserve system stability. This depends on many factors, including the
location and type of disturbance. However, it is a general rule that abnormal system conditions
must be corrected, and speed of correction is always important.
Power quality is affected by short circuits. The voltage on faulted phases often drops below accept-
able minimum values for good power quality. In some cases, the voltage on unfaulted phases may
also rise above unacceptable maximum values. Therefore, short clearing times are required to min-
imize the negative impact of short circuits on power quality.
Short circuits also cause problems to power system equipment and expose adjacent personnel and
property to hazards. Damage to faulted equipment will often be reduced if a short circuit is cleared
promptly. Such prompt clearing may make the difference between repairable and unrepairable
equipment. The high current flowing into the short circuit may also cause damage to unfaulted
equipment supplying the fault current. Damage could be caused if the short time overload capa-
bility of the unfaulted equipment is exceeded. Further there is often arcing associated with short
8 1 Introduction
circuits. In many cases, the energy released by the arc is very high. The arc energy exposes nearby
property and personnel to hazards. Injury due to arc flash is a well-recognized hazard to person-
nel working around electric power equipment. This arc flash energy is directly proportional to the
duration of the short circuit.
Finally, high values of short circuit current flowing through the ground may cause significant
voltage drops across short portions of grounded equipment. These voltage drops also expose per-
sonnel to hazards, commonly referred to as step and touch potential hazards. Substation equipment
grounding is usually designed to maintain acceptable maximum values of step and touch poten-
tials. However, for short circuits to ground in public areas, excessive step and touch potentials are
possible. Therefore, minimizing the short circuit duration for short circuits in publicly accessible
locations will minimize step and touch potential hazards to the public.
1.3 Protective System Design Considerations

A protective system should be designed to recognize certain system abnormalities which, if unde-
tected, could lead to damage of equipment or extended loss of service. The design and specification
of the system components is an important part of the protective strategy, and power systems are
designed to withstand the usual operating contingencies that accompany load changes and line
switching operation. The coordination of insulation is an important design consideration, and pro-
tective devices are commonly installed to protect expensive apparatus from damaging overvoltages.
These problems, although a part of the overall system protection, are outside the scope of this book.
Our concern here is the detection, clearing, and restoration of circuits from damaging abnormal
conditions, which we usually call faults. This requires knowledge of the types of faults that are likely
to be experienced and the kinds of protective devices that can be used to recognize faults and initi-
ate action to clear the fault from the system. The protective system designer must develop a strategy
to accomplish this within the framework of available protective equipment while optimizing the
restoration of the system to the normal state.
There are several design considerations that must be weighed against cost in devising a pro-
tection strategy. We have mentioned an optimum restoration, but this does not necessarily imply
the fastest possible restoration. For example, if the protective system intelligence determines that a
fault is permanent, there is no point in repeating the reclosing of the circuit before a repair crew has
located and repaired the difficulty. Only then can the circuit be restored to its normal state. Thus,
every occurrence has a unique optimum pattern for returning to normal following a disturbance
and this may involve human intervention, such as a physical repair. Normally, there is no human
intervention in the protective system action, however, as this would cause the abnormal condi-
tion to persist for an extended time. In cases where this is feasible, the protective system issues an
alarm, following which the operator can analyze the situation and manually take any action that
is required.
The protective system should also be designed for minimum loss of load. There is no need, usu-
ally, to de-energize the entire system because of an isolated fault. The system should have selectivity
to isolate the fault such that the minimum interruption occurs. Often this requires automatic reclos-
ing following a circuit opening since experience has shown that the large majority of faults are
temporary and that reclosures are very often successful. Minimum loss of load may also require
that alternate circuits be available to serve important loads. For example, bulk transmission sys-
tems usually have the capability of serving all loads with one or more major circuit components
out of service.
1.4 Definitions Used in System Protection 9
The protective system should also be designed with due regard for its own unreliability. This
means that backup protective systems should be installed to operate in case of primary protective
equipment failure so that system damage can be minimized and restoration of normal service can
be achieved quickly.
It is also important that the protective system be designed such that the system can perform
under normal operating conditions. The protective equipment senses system voltages and currents
and, from these measurements, computes a relaying quantity which is compared to a threshold
or trip value. This threshold must not be set too low or the protected circuit may be interrupted
unnecessarily. Furthermore, threshold values must be periodically reviewed to make certain that
these settings are satisfactory for current system loading conditions. This is an operating as well as
a design problem.
The operation of protective equipment must be accurate and fast. Bulk power system reliability
standards require that systems survive severe fault conditions without causing a system collapse.
This in turn requires fast and reliable protective system operation. Thus, there is a direct depen-
dency upon the protective system to achieve a given level of system reliability. This adds to the
challenge of designing an effective protective system and a reliable power delivery system.
1.4 Definitions Used in System Protection
In this section, we define certain terms which are used in system protection engineering. Other,
more specific terms, will be introduced later, as required.
Protective relaying is the term used to signify the science as well as the operation of protective
devices, within a controlled strategy, to maximize service continuity and minimize damage to
property and personnel due to the systems abnormal behavior. The strategy is not so much that
of protecting the equipment from faults, as this is a design function, but rather, it is for protecting
the normal system and environment from the effect of a system component which has become
faulted.
Reliability of a protective system is defined as the probability that the system will function cor-
rectly when required to act. This reliability has two aspects: first, the system must operate in
the presence of a fault that is within its zone of protection (Dependability), and second, it must
refrain from operating unnecessarily for faults outside its protective zone or in the absence of a
fault (Security) [2].
Security in protective systems is a term sometimes used to indicate the ability of a system or device
to refrain from unnecessary operations. Often we use security as a generic term to indicate that
the system is operating correctly.
Dependability in protective systems is a term used to indicate the degree of certainty that the
system or the device will operate when necessary.
Sensitivity in protective systems is the ability of the system to identify an abnormal condition that
exceeds a nominal “pickup” or detection threshold value and which initiates protective action
when the sensed quantities exceed that threshold.
Selectivity in a protective system refers to the overall design of a protective strategy, wherein only
those protective devices closest to a fault will operate to remove the faulted component. This
implies a grading of protective device threshold, timing, or operating characteristics to obtain
the desired selective operation. This restricts interruptions to only those components that are
faulted.
10 1 Introduction
Station A
Length of Station B
transmission line
Rest of zone
not to scale
6 not shown
5
Rest of zone
1
3
not shown
Rest of zone
Line 1 not shown
4
2 Rest of zone
not shown
Protection zone
boundaries
Figure 1.4 One-line diagram of a system showing primary protection zones.
Protection zones (primary protection zones) are regions of primary sensitivity. Figure 1.4 shows
a small segment of a power system. The primary system is shown in heavy lines, and protection
zones are enclosed by thinner lines with various styles.
Coordination of protective devices is the determination of graded settings to achieve selectivity.
Primary relays (primary sensitivity) are relays within a given protection zone that should operate
for prescribed abnormalities within that zone. In Figure 1.4, for example, consider a fault on
Line 1 from Station A to Station B. For this condition, relays supervising breakers 1, 2, 3, and 4
should trip before any others and these relays are called primary relays.
Backup relays are relays outside a given primary protection zone, located in an adjacent zone,
which are set to operate for prescribed abnormalities within the given primary protection zone
and independently of the primary relays. For example, suppose a fault on Line 1 of Figure 1.4
cannot be cleared by breaker 1 due to relay or breaker 1 malfunction. Assume that breakers 2, 3,
and 4 operate normally leaving the fault connected to the equipment terminated by breakers 1,
5, and 6. Backup relays at locations 5 and 6 should be set to operate for the fault on Line 1, but
only after a suitable delay that would allow breaker 1 to open first, if possible.
Local backup relays are an alternate set of relays in a primary protection zone that operate under
prescribed conditions in that protection zone. Often such local backup relays are a duplicate set
of primary relays set to operate independently for the same conditions as the primary set. This
constitutes an OR logic trip scheme and is an effective safeguard against relay failures.
Undesired tripping (false tripping) results when a relay trips unnecessarily for a fault outside its
protection zone or when there is no fault at all. This can occur when the protective system is set
with too high a sensitivity. Such operation may cause an unnecessary load outage, for example,
on a radial circuit, or may cause overloading of adjacent lines of a network. Thus, in some cases,
unnecessary tripping is merely an inconvenience, which, although undesirable, may not cause
serious damage or overloading. In other cases, where an important line is falsely tripped, it can
lead to cascading outages and very serious consequences.
Failure to trip is a protective system malfunction in which the protective system fails to take appro-
priate action when a condition exists for which action is required. This type of failure may result
in extensive damage to the faulted component if not rectified by backup protection.
1.5 System Disturbances 11
Other definitions used in system protection are given in [3], which is a standard for such defini-
tions in the United States. Many of these definitions will be introduced as needed for clarity and
precision.
A summary of several important terms and definitions is also given in Appendix A.
1.5 System Disturbances

The disturbances that occur on electric networks are varied in both magnitude and character. In
this section, we examine the nature of disturbances and attempt to identify those disturbances for
which protective system deployment is feasible and/or necessary.
A disturbance is defined as follows by the IEEE [3].
Disturbance (General). An undesired variable applied to a system that tends to affect adversely the
value of a controlled variable.
Clearly, what appears as a disturbance to one kind of apparatus may be of little consequence
to another type, irrespective of the magnitude of the disturbance. Our classification is general, to
begin with, and from this general classification, we shall consider which disturbance classes may
require special protective system applications.
There are many possible ways to categorize disturbance types and characteristics. One reference
divides disturbances into two major categories: load disturbances and event disturbances [4]. These
are defined as follows:
Load disturbances: Small random fluctuations superimposed on slowly varying loads.
Event disturbances:
(a) Faults on transmission lines due to equipment malfunctions or natural phenomena such as
lightning.
(b) Cascading events due to protective relay action following severe overloads or violation of
operating limits.
(c) Generation outages due to loss of synchronism or malfunction.
As defined in [4], load disturbances are a part of the systems normal operating conditions. In an
operating power system, frequency and voltage are always in a state of change due to load distur-
bances. Any departure from normal frequency and voltage, due to a load disturbance, is usually
small and requires no explicit power plant or protective system response. Occasionally, however,
major load disturbances do occur. These major disturbances are usually caused by important trans-
mission or generation outages and are characterized by low, high, or widely varying frequency and
voltage on the power system.
Small event disturbances are also a part of the normal power system operating environment.
Event disturbances, however, imply a need for rapid response by the protective systems and can
lead to larger upsets if this action fails or is delayed. Large event disturbances always require fast
protective system action and may lead to complete system failure if this action is not correct and fast.
Disturbances, both large and small, may be classified as shown in Table 1.1 [5]. Usually, the sys-
tem protection engineer is interested in small disturbances from the standpoint that the protective
system should not act for this type of disturbance since such action would usually make the situ-
ation worse. Indeed, for this type of disturbance, the removal of additional system components is
likely to make the situation worse.
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
What has caused this jubilation?
Days ago the coronation
Went with jewelled pomp and splendour to the country of the
past.
Is the land some Saint’s Day hailing?
Or has some tall ship gone sailing
Through the hostile fleet to triumph, with the Union at her mast?
Nay, it is no warlike glory,

Nor pale saint, of ancient story,
That has made the island blossom into beauty rare and new.
We in this sea-severed nation,
Share with England our elation,
As we keep this feast, your birthday, and are glad with love for
you!
* * * * *
“White Horse” of Kilburn

To A. K. K. on Her Birthday, 1912
Last night the beat of hoofs was heard upon the shaded street,
It broke the silent brooding of the peaceful countryside;
I looked and saw a horse that stamped its terrible white feet,
A giant horse, as white as flame, long maned and starry-
eyed.
“Who is this monstrous visitant?” said I, “Bucephalus?

Or Rosinante, looking for another crazy Knight?
Or (not to be conceited) may it not be Pegasus?
This mighty horse, this glowing horse, so beautiful and white.”
He proudly tossed his noble head, and neighed, “Across the

foam
My stable lies, with clouds for roof, and mountainous green
walls;
I come to take your message unto Her, who near my home
Will hold her Birthday feast before another evening falls.”
“Go back, O Horse,” I said, “and seek your pleasant dwelling-

place,
And here’s a gift for you to take, I trust it to your care;
Support this heavy load of love until you see her face,
Then humbly kneel before her feet and lay my homage
there.”
Having English blood in her veins, Mrs. Kilburn Kilmer

considers herself something of a Yorkshire woman. The famous
White Horse she has climbed many times.
* * * * *
Valentine Written for My Mother, 1913
I will send my heart to England, and will make it learn to act

Like a vacant minded vicar, or a curate full of tea;
I will make my heart talk Cambridgese, or Yorkshirish, in fact;
I will make it be as British as a human heart can be;
I will dress my heart in roses, roses red and ever gay;
I will steep my heart in scarletest of wine;
I will teach my heart to bow, and smile, and sing, and dance,
and play—
Just to make you take it for a Valentine.
* * * * *
Birthday Poem—1913
England! England! put your veil of mist away,

Dress in green, with poppies in your hair.
England! England! let your birds sing “Holiday,”
Let your lanes be jubilant and fair.
She is made of singing, therefore hail her with a song;
Strew her path with loveliness, and crown her with delight.
Golden hours of joy and beauty should to her belong.
Everything that lives to-day must own her gentle might.
England! England! now the jocund feast is here.
Now is time for frolicking and mirth.
England! England! now another turning year,
Brings the day that celebrates her birth.
* * * * *
Valentine to My Mother, 1914
The English meadows call her, and the streets of London Town,
And the pleasant little villages under the Yorkshire Hills.
She can see the roads, like ribbons white, that stretch across
the down,
And the great slow turning sails of sleepy mills.
She longs for stately mansions, in whose eaves the pigeons
coo,
And she longs for yellow corn fields, where the scarlet
poppies shine,
She loves the folk of England, and, of course, they love her too,
But she lingers in America to be my Valentine.
Set to music by Mrs. Kilburn Kilmer and published in London in

the Spring of 1914.
* * * * *
To An Adventurous Infant
On Her Birthday, August, 1915
“England,” she said, “is surely England yet;

Therefore it is the place where I should be.
In spite of war, I know that tea is tea,
A cigarette is still a cigarette.
“Why should I worry over Wilhelm’s threat?”

And thereupon she said goodbye to me,
And gaily sailed across the dangerous sea,
To where, among the Zeppelins, tea was set.
What if the sea foam mountainously high

With waves that had in Hell their fiery birth?
What if black peril hover in the sky,
And bursting shell wound deep the trembling earth?
All evil things must harmlessly pass by
Her who doth bear the Talisman of Mirth.
* * * * *
Birthday Poem, 1915

To My Mother Singing
Out of the golden valleys of old years,

You have recalled so many a lovely thing.
Forgotten splendours glimmer when you sing,
With their long vanished light of mirth and tears.
Gay lovers flout their love’s delicious fears.
The proud swords clash for Charles, the rightful King,
A woman weeps, and turns her “Silver Ring.”
The “Men of Harlech” charge with level spears.
Yet, I crowned with my crown of vanity,
Have been more happy when you sang and played
The songs wherein your art had succoured me.
As starry note on starry note was laid,
Then my chained rhymes, by your designs set free,
Flew Heavenward on the radiant wings you made.
* * * * *
To My Mother, October, 1915
There fell a flood of devastating flame

On half the world, and all its joy was dead.
The sky was black, the troubled sea was red,
And from all mouths a lamentation came.
But you, in calm and hurricane the same,
Went with gay lips, brave heart and unbowed head.
What was the charm, from which all danger fled?
What did you say, what cabalistic name?
It was my love that sent its quickening breath

On all the waves that bore your ship along.
My love held out, against the flying death,
That clove the sea, a shield than steel more strong,
Bringing you back, where no war harrieth,
Stars in your eyes, and in your heart a song.
* * * * *
August Fourth, Nineteen Sixteen

The Berkshire Hills are gay
With a gladder tint to-day,
And Mount Graylock rears his mighty head in pride.
For the lady that they knew
Long ago, to them is true,
And has come within their shadow to reside.
And across the troubled sea,

Yorkshire hill and Cambridge lea,
Send their love to you by every wind that blows.
And a greater love than these
Hurries Northward on the breeze
From the little hills they call the Ramapos.
* * * * *
Valentine for My Mother, 1917
If some day, as you idly turn the pages,

Whereon my verses are,
You find a flower where angry winter rages,
On the black earth a star;
If in dead words you come on something living,
Some fair and vibrant line—
It is the message that my heart is giving,
It is your Valentine.
* * * * *
March, 1918.
Dear Mother:
The sweater arrived, and it certainly is a magnificent specimen of
knitting, and the wristlets are wonderfully purled—whatever purling
may be. Probably I shall need both sweater and wristlets for many
weeks, for although it is Spring now, it often is cold.
Under separate cover I am sending you my warrant as Sergeant. I
thought you might like to have it framed to hang in the Old-Fashioned
Room. The “drafted” in the corner means that the regiment was drafted
into Federal Service; that is, made a part of the United States Army
instead of a part of the New York State National Guard.
I suppose that you have read in the newspapers of the Regiment’s
recent activities. Now we are taking it easy in a very pleasant little
town. I hope we may stay here at least a month, as it is hard to work
when the Regiment is moving about the country. I had a week’s respite
from office work some time ago and spent it doing what is called
“observation” work for the Regimental Intelligence Section. It was most
interesting.
Did Aline tell you of Kenton’s success in school? It seems that he
won a gold medal for being the best pupil in the school. I was delighted
to learn it. So nearly as I can remember, I was not an especially keen
student when I was his age, although I became one later.
There is practically no chance of my rising any higher in the
Regiment than Sergeant, and I am perfectly content. To become an
officer I would have to go to school away from the Regiment for
several months, then if I failed to pass my examinations and win a
commission, I would be sent to some other Regiment than this, and if I
succeeded I would be sent as an officer, not back to the 69th, but to
some other outfit, and I want very much to stay with the Regiment. I
have many good friends here, and I would feel lost in any other military
organization.
I am looking forward to receiving the photographs you have had
taken. By this time you must have received the one I sent you. I hope
you like it.
Your letters are very gratefully received, and I am looking forward
specially to receiving the cake and the candy you sent me. Everything
else you have written of in your letters has arrived in good condition,
and a day or two ago I got five big jars of excellent tobacco from the
Dickens Fellowship ... a most intelligent gift.
Affectionately yours,
Joyce.
* * * * *
May 15th, 1918.

Dear Mother:
As to your “War Mother” poem, I hesitate to tell you how much I
like it, because I am afraid you may think I am trying to flatter you. It
certainly is the best poem you ever wrote—beautiful, original and well
sustained. I have seen no recent war verse I like so well. There is no
question but what you will sell it to some good magazine. I certainly
congratulate you, and congratulate the magazine fortunate enough to
print your poem.
I am very glad to hear of the deserved success your songs made
at Lakewood, and in general of your triumphs at the Dickens
Fellowship, and elsewhere. I wish I could have witnessed them, but I
will be seeing more of the same sort next winter. That is what we like
to hear about over here—triumphs and celebrations, and in general the
pleasant and prosperous course of civilian life.
Of course we soldiers are undergoing hardships and privations—
we expect to, but we don’t spend our time advertising them. But in the
States when you find they must do without quite as much wheat, or
meat, or something of the sort, instead of just going without and
keeping their mouths shut, they advertise their remarkable abstention
by having “wheatless days” and “meatless days,” and all that sort of
hysterical rubbish, and fill the papers with the news, thereby disgusting
us soldiers and undoubtedly comforting the enemy. I think I will start a
“strawberryless, ice creamless, sodaless day” for the army. It would be
as sensible as what the people at home have been doing. If you (I
don’t mean you personally, of course) have to eat hardtack instead of
butter-raised biscuits, why eat the hardtack and shut up about it, but
don’t be such an ass as to have a “butter-raised biscuitless Monday,”
and don’t shut down on theatres and amusements; and don’t deprive
people of their honest drink. Merely making stay-at-homes dismal does
not help the soldiers a bit. England’s early “Business as Usual”
scheme was more practicable, and this is something of a concession
for me to make. There is quite a sermon on economics for you! Kindly
read it to my father, whom it will edify and instruct. A recent letter from
him shows that he utterly misunderstands my point of view on this
subject, the result of lamentably careless reading by him of one of my
letters in which I contrasted the gaiety and common-sense of the
French, through years of starvation and ruin, with the wail which a little
self-denial brought from the States.
Send your picture soon.
Joyce.
* * * * *
May 27th, 1918.

Dear Mother,
I presume by this time you have received the humorous
photographs of myself I sent you.
I am delighted to know of the Kilburn Hall project. By all means buy
the Hall; it will be an excellent investment. Property is now very cheap
in England, and prices will rise as soon as the war is over. I hope to be
able to spend my summers in France after the war, and I have the
place in mind—only about a day’s run from London. I am absolutely in
love with France, its people, its villages, its mountains, everything
about it. America would do well to copy its attitude in the war. It has
suffered tremendous hardships with dignity and humour and kept its
sanity and faith. America, to judge by the papers, grows hysterical over
a little self-denial; can’t do without an extra lump of sugar in its tea
without a band and speeches and “sugarless” Sundays. It is funny and
rather pathetic to us soldiers. But I honestly think, although it may
seem conceited to say so, that when we soldiers get back from the war
we will do the spiritual and intellectual life of the States a lot of good.
France has taught us lessons of infinite value.
I am having an absolutely Heavenly time since I joined the
Intelligence Section. I wouldn’t change places with any soldier of any
rank in any outfit. This suits me better than any job I ever had in civil
life.
The cake is not yet here. I will soak it in wine all right, don’t worry
about that. Speaking of wine, enclosed find some flowers given me by
a very nice wine-shop girl in a city near here. “Madelon” is a perfectly
respectable song, but “Madelon” is not a gun or anything else of the
sort; it is the name of the girl who serves wine to the soldiers, as the
song clearly states.
Yours affectionately,
Joyce.
* * * * *
June 14th, 1918.

Dear Mother:
There is a chance that I will be able to get to England on a seven
days’ leave in a few weeks. In that case I shall probably spend most of
my time in London, with a possible visit to Oxfordshire, where my
friend Mrs. Denis Eden lives. I wish there was something I could do for
you to expedite the purchase of Kilburn Hall, but since the Archbishop
of Yorkshire is in the States you should, yourself, be able to make a
deal with him. English real estate is a wise investment these days; it
will go up fifty per cent in a year’s time. I wish I could afford to buy
some property in this country. I certainly would like to live here. If the
States go “dry” I honestly think I will move my family over here. I can
write for American papers without living in America. Then if you move
to Kilburn Hall I will be only a day’s trip away from you, and you will
love rural France almost as much as you love rural England.
Learn to sing “Madelon.”
Joyce.
* * * * *
June 28, 1918.

Dear Mother:
I received three letters from you yesterday and to-day, the first I
have had from you in a long time. Your letters always come in bunches
like that. And this morning I received two admirable boxes of Mirror
Candy, in perfect condition. I certainly was delighted to get it, as it is a
long time since I have had any candy. My gratitude is so great that I
even will refer to it as “Sweets.”
I was also glad to get your picture, taken on shipboard. You must
send to Larchmont another copy of the picture of yourself looking at
my photograph, which you sent me some weeks ago, as I had to
remove it from its mount and cut it down to make it fit into my wallet. All
the rest of the fellows in the Intelligence Section (there are nine of us,
nearly all college graduates, and men of some standing—editors,
brokers, etc.), have pictures of their mothers, but none of them so
good looking as mine.
You would be amused at some of the scenes when your picture is
exhibited. Tired from a long hike from a stay in the trenches, I am
having an omelet, and some fried potatoes, and some vin rouge, beau
coup, le vin rouge in some French peasant’s little kitchen. It is a
cottage such as you and I often visited in Derbyshire and
Cambridgeshire; a low grey stone building with rose trees against the
wall, a tiny garden, and a geometrically neat path. The kitchen floor is
of stone, the table without a cloth, but shining from much polishing.
The only thing to distinguish it from the typical English rural cottage is
the crucifix on the wall, and the wooden shoes at the door. (People
wear sabots out of doors, cloth slippers in the house, leather shoes on
Sunday). Well, after such a repast as I have described, I take out my
wallet to pay my bill, and the sharp eyes of little Marie, or little Pierre,
intently watching this strange soldat Americaine espy the picture. At
once an inquisitive, but delighted, infant is on my knee demanding a
closer inspection of the picture; the Maman must see it, and
Grandpere, and Veuve Vatre from across the street (the man of the
house can’t see it; he is away from home on the errand that brought
me across the sea). Well, they all say “Elle est jolie, ma foi, et jeune
aussi.” These comments have been made on your picture many times
in many towns, which I will one day show you on a map of France.
I have not much anxiety for my father, for I look on his condition as
a state of rest really necessary to a mind so constantly busy. But I am
glad that from you I have inherited the power of readily escaping from
worry and work; of entering with enthusiasm into whatever mirth I find
around me; in finding good and true and merry friends everywhere. I
think that some of this quality would have helped my father very much,
and increased his bodily and mental health. I worried grievously about
you for a while, and wished I could have been with you when my father
was taken ill, but I don’t worry now—you are too spirited and
courageous for anybody to worry about. I certainly admire you more
than ever, and look forward eagerly to regular banquets at Henri’s and
Rector’s with you.
I want you to meet all the Regimental Intelligence Section—a fine
bunch of brave men, and good comrades. We have taken big chances
together, and it has made us the best of friends. You will like them all
and they will like you.
Joyce.
* * * * *
To Kenton Kilmer
Headquarters Co.,
165th Infantry,
A. E. F.
Nov. 28, 1917.
My dear Kenton:
I hope that by this time you have entirely recovered from your
illness. I remember that I had whooping-cough when I was about your
age. If you are back in school, send me some of your monthly reports.
The address you must put on letters to me is just what you see at the
top of this sheet, except that you must put before it “Private Joyce
Kilmer.”
There is a school in the building where I work, much like the school
you attend, except that there are no nuns here for teachers. When the
weather is wet, the children wear wooden shoes instead of rubbers.
They go to school at eight in the morning and don’t leave until five. You
wouldn’t like that, would you?
This letter ought to reach you about Christmas time. I am not
sending you anything at once, but I will later. And I know that your
mother and all your grandparents will give you things, and so will Saint
Nicholas.
Be a good boy, and pray to St. Francis and Our Lady to help you.
You ought to go to Mass every morning, since you live so near the
church. Take care of Deborah and Christopher and Michael, and do all
you can to make things easy for your Mother.
From Your affectionate Dad.
* * * * *
To Kenton Kilmer
January 10, 1918.
My dear Kenton:
Your plan for ending the war is very good. I showed your letter to
Sergeant Russell, who fought in the Spanish-American war, long
before you were born, and he said that your plan was the one that the
American Army would adopt.
I am glad to see that you can write and typewrite so well. I hope
that you will get Fr. Morris to teach you how to serve Mass, we live so
near the church that you can easily serve his Mass and get your
breakfast and get to school on time, and if you are a priest when you
grow up you will be glad you had such practice when you were young.
Take care of Deborah and Michael and Christopher and your
mother and don’t forget to pray for
Your affectionate Dad.
* * * * *
To Deborah Kilmer
Headquarters Co.,
165th Inf.,
A. E. F., France.
May 27th, 1918.
My dear Deborah:
About a month ago, I sent you a rubber doll. If you didn’t get it, let
me know and I’ll send you another one.
Yesterday morning about six o’clock I climbed down the mountain
to go to Mass. And just outside the village where the church is, I met a
young lady and walking beside her was a pleasant young pig with a
pink nose.
“Bonjour, M’sieur!” said the young lady.
“Bonjour, Mam’selle!” I replied.
“Bonjour, M’sieur!” said the pig.
“Bonjour, M’sieur!” I replied.
And the young lady and the pig threw back their heads and
laughed heartily and went on to breakfast. And I went on to Mass.
Remember me to young Michael and young Christopher, and
believe me
Your respectful Dad.
* * * * *
To Mrs. Joyce Kilmer

Nov. 11, 1917.
This is what is technically known as a hurried scrawl. It is to the
effect that I have arrived, in excellent health and spirits. I have recently
read the Censorship Regulations, and am in doubt about what I can
say—God help the people who have to interpret them! I mailed a
postcard two weeks ago, which you should now receive. Also I’ll try to
cable you soon, if it is allowed. I have not yet consulted the adjutant on
the subject, but so far as I have been able to find from a diligent study
of the censorship regulations, I am allowed to say that I love you.
Accordingly, I state it, with considerable enthusiasm. Also, I have a
certain regard for Kenton, Deborah, Michael and even Christopher. I
hope to write you again very soon. You know my address—same as
before, only American Expeditionary Forces. I enclose some verses
which may entertain you. The brief one is a memory of the days when I
used to drill. I don’t feel that way about a typewriter—which instrument
I now use with accuracy and speed. Send me some magazines now
and then, and Times Review of Books. And love me exceedingly.
* * * * *
Headquarters Co.,
165th Infantry,
A. E. F.
Nov. 24, 1917.
I am having a delightful time out here—absolutely beautiful country
and very nice people. I am short of money, but I believe we’ll be paid
soon and I’ve borrowed 80 francs from Fr. Duffy. That isn’t as much as
it sounds—you get 5 francs and 70 centimes for a dollar at the
Y. M. C. A. I enclose a bill I received for two enormous boxes of cakes I
hired an old lady to make for me. I furnished the sugar—you know
there was a bag of it in the box of groceries my mother sent me just
before I left. I meant the cakes for dessert for Thanksgiving dinner, but
with the help of my friends I’ve already eaten most of it. There is a
rumour to the effect that we are to have duck for dinner to-morrow, and
the Regiment is much more excited about it than about the good news
of the War in yesterday’s paper. We get the Paris editions of the
London Daily Mail, New York Herald and Chicago Tribune, and before
long I suppose we’ll see the magazines when the Y. M. C. A. opens up
its local tent. I never thought I’d regard the Y. M. C. A. with such
esteem—I wish the Knights of Columbus had a chance to do as much
work for us.
I haven’t written anything in prose or verse since I got here—
except statistics—but I’ve stored up a lot of memories to turn into copy
when I get a chance. The Colonel occasionally speaks of my historical
work, but I doubt if it will be feasible to publish any part of it except
some very general stuff until the war is over. I asked Thomas Hughes
Kelley to send me a history of the 69th published some years ago, and
another copy to you, to make sure. I think it will be useful in preparing
the introductory chapters.
I love you very much indeed and see you clearly always and have
a conviction that I will be with you soon—sooner than you expect.
* * * * *
Dec. 9th, 1917.
I was delighted to receive the other day (December 7th, the day
after my birthday) a batch of letters, including two from you. I am glad
Kenton is getting along well; I was worried about his illness. It is
fortunate you were able to get a good nurse.
You ought to be receiving some money from the government soon.
I made over half my pay to you, and the government is supposed to
add to it so much for you and so much for each youngster. The whole
thing will come to about $57 a month, I believe! I personally am not in
need of money—I am getting a book of traveller’s cheques from my
father and before I heard he was sending it I wrote to John Timpson
Co., and asked them to open an account for me in some Paris bank.
Also we are paid in francs, which makes us feel wealthy, as there are
5.70 of them in a dollar. And I could live comfortably without any
spending money—all there is to buy is candy and canned stuff and
wine and an occasional meal when the business of my department
takes me to a nearby town.
Fr. Garesché’s poem certainly is beautiful; by far the best thing he
has done. I am enclosing a letter from Sister —— which I think you will
enjoy. Delightful old person, nearly blind, but tremendously energetic.
Harriet Monroe was one of her pupils. Probably you remember her
book on Fr. Tabb.
Your Christmas presents probably will reach you in time for Easter.
I hope to get a pair of wooden shoes for Deborah.
I am having a fine time. My statistical work occupies me in the
evening as well as all day, but it’s interesting, and will be increasingly
important, since the Statistical Department really is the only link
between the soldier and his family.
I hope as soon as we get settled I’ll be able to do some writing, I’ve
been too busy so far. I love you very much, and always think of you.
In your letters you spoke of sending me some stuff. Send anything
you think of as soon as you think of it—don’t wait to find out if I want it,
because the mails take too long. Just now I want snap-shots of you
and the children, especially Deborah, and tobacco. I love you.
* * * * *
December 17.
I hope you are getting the letters I send you from time to time. I got
one admirable batch of letters from you by way of birthday present—
they came on the day after my birthday. Perhaps I’ll get another batch
for Christmas—it’s December 17th now, and we should receive
another mail soon. I hope to send you a photograph soon. I believe
personal pictures may be sent through the mail. It will be a beautiful
sight. I got a Sing Sing haircut recently and am growing a corsair
moustache. This is the pleasantest war I ever attended—nothing to do
but fall in, fall out, pound a typewriter 13 hours a day and occasionally
hike across France and back carrying a piano. However, I do really
enjoy it, and the work is different in kind from newspaper work, and so
a rest from it. By the way, I sent you some time ago a poem called
“Militis Meditatio.” Please send a copy of it to a magazine and tell them
to send the check for it to you. I hope to be able to do some writing as
soon as we get settled and I get some of my statistical work out of the
way. You ought to get your allotment this month, with additions from
the Government (I hope you and the children are not yet in the
poorhouse, or at any rate that you have struck a comfortable
poorhouse). Send me pictures of yourself and the children, especially
Deborah. I have made a nuisance of myself telling my bored friends
about her intelligence in naming her doll “Hugh and Mrs. Leamy.” Also
send me some tobacco, enough to fill a bedsack (also love me as
intensely as possible; I love you more than ever before and think of
you all the while)....
* * * * *
Christmas Eve.
The enclosed clippings may amuse you—after you read them
you’d better send them to Bob Holliday. They came with a raft of letters
a couple of days ago. It’s very nice the way feasts seem to be marked
—I last heard from you just before my birthday, and I got three letters
from you by way of Christmas present. There must be a lot of parcels
awaiting me, judging from information in your letters and those of my
father and mother. We may get the packages to-night, in which case I’ll
have some hours hard work, for all the Adjutant’s office helps in
assorting mail. But I don’t think the packages will come until after
Christmas. I suppose that you and the children are in New Brunswick
now, and will go to Midnight Mass at St. Peter’s and pray for a vagrant
verse-maker who is trying to be a soldier. We may have a Midnight
Mass in the church here to-night. Fr. Duffy has had a choir practising
for it, and we possess a tenor soloist. He is an Italian, a barber when
not singing or soldiering.
I have allotted half my pay to you, and the Government’s addition
to that will bring it, I believe, up to about $60—enough to pay the rent.
But don’t worry if there is delay in receiving it. It takes a long time,
usually, to set things like that in motion. I recently read that a veteran
of the Civil War had just received a check for $12 from Washington,
representing his pay for his last month of service.
I am glad you are sending me some tobacco—I suppose it’s in the
five truck loads of Christmas packages said to be awaiting us at a town
some miles away. I have been able to get American tobacco, I am glad
to say, but not my favourite brand. Also I’ll be glad to get the cigars my
father has sent me—I have smoked all of Fr. Duffy’s. But be sure that
tobacco or anything else you send me, such as Michael and Deborah,
is very securely wrapped and tied, as the journey is hard on packages
and many of them go to pieces.
I am hoping to get more letters from you soon—write as often as
you can. I’d rather get a letter from you than anything else now
possible. (I love you more than ever before).
* * * * *
Jan. 18, 1918.

Virginia is an excellent State. One evening last week I met by
chance a Sergeant Interpreter named Nicholson Barney Adams. And
he didn’t know my name and I didn’t know his—he is not connected
with the 69th. And he said, “I see by the Times that Joyce Kilmer has
enlisted.” And furthermore, thereafter, he put me up in his place—he
and two other fellows have a room together—and I had admirable
things to eat and drink, and slept in a bed, for the first time in over
three months. And he came from Lynchburg, Virginia.
You will find with this letter $50 in American Express checks. Put
the place and date in the upper right-hand corner when you cash them.
You see, I had written to John Timpson for some money before I got a
book of checks from my father, so I find myself having more money
than I need.
I wrote this letter—the first part of it—this afternoon. Now it is
evening, and five ambulance-loads of mail have arrived and I have
helped distribute it. I got a November Harpers from my father and a
copy of Frances Huard’s “My Home In the Field of Mercy” from Doran.
To-morrow we get 14 more ambulance loads, they say—I hope I get
some packages, but I especially desire letters from you. My last letter
from you—dated Dec. 12—contained a very noble poem by you
—“High Heart.” I was delighted to get it, I felt admitted to a realer
intimacy than I had known since I crossed the ocean. Please send me
all your poems, sad or spirited. I cannot write verse, but enjoy reading
it more than ever before. And you happen to be my favourite poet.
I bought a copy of Conan Doyle’s new “Sherlock Holmes” book in a
nearby town recently, in the Conrad edition. A French publisher named
Conrad has taken over the Tauchnitz business—you remember the
Tauchnitz books, don’t you? Also I’ve been reading Harry Leon
Wilson’s, “The Spenders”—an entertaining imitation of Mr. Howells,
and rereading “The Cardinal’s Snuff Box”—most delightful.
I love you very much, and I am very sorry for you—you aren’t
having the amusing adventures I am having—but you’re able to write
nice things, and that’s a consolation. I hope to see you and your
admirable babies soon.
Joyce Kilmer.
* * * * *

Power System Protection 2Nd Edition Paul M Anderson All Chapter

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Power System Protection 2Nd Edition Paul M Anderson All Chapter

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Power System Protection, 2nd Edition

IEEE Press Editorial Board

Jón Atli Benediktsson Xiaoou Li Jeffrey Reed

Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey.

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data applied for:

Cover design by Wiley

Set in 9.5/12.5pt STIXTwoText by Straive, Chennai, India

Author Biographies xxv

Part I Protective Devices and Controls 1

2 Protection Measurements and Controls 17

3 Protective Device Characteristics 47

3.2.1 Distribution Fuse Cutouts 48

4 Relay Logic 109

4.7.3 The Alpha and Beta Planes 142

5 System Characteristics 163

5.7.3 The Fault Conditions Without Load Currents 208

Part II Protection Concepts 215

6 Fault Protection of Radial Lines 217

7 Introduction to Transmission Protection 277

7.3.4 Summary of Distance Relay Concepts 299

8 Complex Loci in the Z and Y Planes 317

9 Impedance at the Relay 351

9.5.2 ABCD Parameters for a Faulted System 367

10 Admittance at the Relay 391

Part III Transmission Protection 413

11 Analysis of Distance Protection 415

12 Transmission Line Mutual Induction 457

12.3.1 Selecting a Reference Phasor 469

13 Pilot Protection Systems 509

13.4.2 Line Current Differential Schemes 544

14 Complex Transmission Protection 573

15 Series Compensated Line Protection 619

15.3.1 Series Capacitor Bypass Systems 635

Part IV Apparatus Protection 685

16 Bus Protection 687

16.6.4 Combined Bus and Transformer Protection 710

17 Transformer and Reactor Protection 721

18 Generator Protection 763

18.3.1 Phase Fault Protection 766

19 Motor Protection 805

19.5.1 Motors Classified by Service 843

Part V System Aspects of Protection 861

20 Protection Against Abnormal System Frequency 863

20.4.12 Other Frequency Response Models 885

21 Protective Schemes for Stability Enhancement 909

22 Line Commutated Converter HVDC Protection 973

23 Voltage Source Converter HVDC Protection 1021

23.6.1 Ac System Response to Dc Faults 1035

24 Protection of Independent Power Producer Interconnections 1041

25 SSR and SSCI Protection 1063

Part VI Reliability of Protective Systems 1101

26 Basic Reliability Concepts 1103

26.2.4 Classes and Partitions 1106

27 Reliability Analysis 1145

27.4.4 Structure Functions 1179

28 Reliability Concepts in System Protection 1197

29 Fault Tree Analysis of Protective Systems 1261

29.4.2 Protective System Failure Evaluation 1300

30 Markov Modeling of Protective Systems 1311

Appendix A Protection Terminology 1359

Appendix B Protective Device Classiﬁcation 1371

Appendix C Overhead Line Impedances 1375

Appendix D Transformer Data 1389