Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1951 Replay 05-21
1951 Replay 05-21
1951 Replay 05-21
VOL. 1, No. 36
G 26 28 26 18 28 25 20 26 24 27
R 17 25 16 19 22 20 17 13 17 24
H 36 42 39 24 37 35 25 31 30 35
AVG. .400 .382 .379 .375 .366 .343 .342 .341 .337 .337
G 31 27 31 30 32 26 32 28 34 34
R 40 23 21 10 23 20 20 15 26 22
H 56 40 42 42 42 32 40 35 40 40
AVG. .421 .381 .341 .336 .331 .327 .325 .324 .313 .313
The Sportlight
By Grantland Rice
More About the Dodgers A rabid Brooklyn fanatic is there any other brand of Brooklyn fanatic? doesnt think your correspondent has given the Dodgers a fair deal for 1951. Why not admit they outclass the league? one of them writes. Why not admit they also outclass the American League, including the Yankees, Indians and Red Sox? The Dodgers are undoubtedly an odd outfit. They have the best catcher in the National League and next to Yogi Berra, the most valuable catcher in baseball. They have the best first baseman in baseball in the stalwart Gil Hodges, one of the games top stars. Jackie Robinson is the best second baseman in the game, and but for his somewhat unsteady temperament, his constant feeling of persecution (which doesnt exist), he could be even more valuable to his club. He is a great ballplayer for all that, both on the offensive and defensive side. Pee Wee Reese at short is one of the infield greats. Pee Wee is close to Phil Rizzuto, but not
RICE, Page 2
Sisler, Phi. Slaughter, St.L Gordon, Bos. Hemus, St.L Irvin, N.Y. Thomson, N.Y.
HR: Mantle (N.Y.) 12; Robinson (Chi.) 8; Doby (Cle.) 8; Yost (Was.) 6, Dropo (Bos.) 6. RBI: Mantle (N.Y.) 26; Williams (Bos.) 25; Zarilla (Chi.) 25; Doby (Cle.) 23; Robinson (Chi.) 23. Wins: Scheib (Phi.) 5-1; Feller (Cle.) 4-0; Lopat (N.Y.) 4-1; Pierce (Chi.) 4-2; Trout (Det.) 4-2. Strikeouts: Raschi (N.Y.) 38; Trout (Det.) 26; Garcia (Cle.) 25; Feller (Cle.) 25; Wynn (Cle.) 24; Gray (Det.) 24. ERA: Morgan (N.Y.) 1.65; Feller (Cle.) 1.66; Wight (Bos.) 1.83; Lopat (N.Y.) 1.89; Stobbs (Bos.) 2.08.
HR: Thomson (N.Y.) 10; Pafko (Chi.) 10; Jethroe (Bos.) 10; Sauer (Chi.) 10; Campanella (Bro.) 8. RBI: Sauer (Chi.) 34; Jones (Phi.) 31; Pafko (Chi.) 31; Thomson (N.Y.) 30; Gordon (Bos.) 29. Wins: Roe (Bro.) 5-0; Hearn (N.Y.) 5-1; Maglie (N.Y.) 5-1; Konstanty (Phi.) 4-1; Sain (Bos.) 4-1; Brecheen (St.L) 4-1. Strikeouts: Blackwell (Cin.) 38; Queen (Pit.) 35; Maglie (N.Y.) 30; Newcombe (Bro.) 30; several tied with 28. ERA: Roe (Bro.) 1.52; Jansen (N.Y.) 1.53; Heintzelman (Phi.) 2.16; Newcombe (Bro.) 2.41; Brecheen (St.L) 3.08.
Page 2
RICE
From Page 1
quite the whirling dervish amazing Phil is around short. But Reese will do plus. The Dodger outfield is one of the best. Certainly there is no better outfielder in baseball than Duke Snider. You can move him up immediately with Stan Musial, Ted Williams or Joe DiMaggio. Last year Duke hit .321, including 31 home runs, 10 triples and 31 doubles. He cracked in 106 runs. This season he is much better than he was a year ago. Carl Furillo is another fine outfielder. This gives the Dodgers more top men than any other team carries. It gives them the National League tops at catcher, first base, second base, center field and at least a draw at short The Dodger Weakness But I still think the main Dodger weakness is set at the most vital spot. I mean pitching. The Dodgers have one outstanding pitcher Preacher Roe. Don Newcombe is a star as long as his arm holds up. But here is a physical giant who has trouble finishing a game. Picked as a 30 or 35game winner last season, he wasnt able to make the 20-game mark. He has terrific stuff while it lasts. Newcombe says his arm frequently is too sore to lift a glass of water. The answer is that New-
combe should actually be a 30-game winner. But he cant finish enough games. Outside of Roe and Newcombe, you have some trouble locating another dependable Dodger starter. Palica will be around for only a limited period. Ralph Branca has his full share of stuff on his good days. But last year Branca won seven games and dropped nine with a fine ball club. King, Van Cuyk and others have their in-andout days and moments. But even with a team as able as the Dodgers are, they have only one pitcher who now looks good enough to win 20 games but Roe has never won 20 games. Neither has Newcombe. And Roe is 33 years old. It should be easy to win 20 games with Brooklyn just as it should be easy to win 20 games with the Red Sox. You can average four earned runs a game and still win most of them. You cant give pitchers working for the Dodgers and Red Sox in past years too much credit. They have all the runs needed to work with. On form and on copy paper, the Dodgers and Red Sox should win the two pennants. But the Dodgers lack pitching and the Red Sox lack soul or spirit. The certainly lack flame. There is nothing yellow about any ball club. But there can be a big difference in spirit and hustle, which can easily make the difference between winning or losing a pennant. All the Dodgers lack is consistent pitching.