Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1998IJSE Shrimp
1998IJSE Shrimp
net/publication/235261380
CITATIONS READS
20 654
2 authors, including:
Mohammad Alauddin
The University of Queensland
66 PUBLICATIONS 1,050 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Mohammad Alauddin on 03 August 2015.
1. Introduction
The fisheries sub-sector plays a crucial role in the predominantly rural
economy of Bangladesh. This sector contributes 4 per cent of GDP and 12 per
cent of export earnings. About 1.2 million economically active people are
employed on a full-time basis in the fishing industry. It also provides another
ten million part-time jobs (DOF, 1995). Fish is an important source of protein
and constitutes about 80 per cent of the animal protein intake. The 1980s has
seen considerable expansion of the aquaculture sector in many countries of the
world, more particularly in the Asian region. There is ample scope for the global
expansion of aquaculture provided it cares for the environment and natural
resources, and becomes part of the primary production systems (Pullin, 1995).
The introduction of modern technology-based intensive commercial
aquaculture is called the “Blue Revolution”, which is the counterpart of the
“Green Revolution” in the agricultural sector (Khor, 1996) in the 1960s. Most
developing countries in the world, with the aquaculture industry, have
introduced the “Blue Revolution”, technology in the 1980s to boost their
economy. As a result, the term “Blue Revolution” has become a part of popular
vocabulary of the Third World development experts and planners.
Shrimp farming spearheads Bangladesh’s aquaculture industry. Both coastal
and inland waterbodies in Bangladesh are suitable for shrimp culture.
Apparently shrimp aquaculture has attracted the highest attention from
government and international development/donor agencies among other
fisheries. In the mid-1990s shrimp contributed about 11 per cent of total exports,
while in the early 1970s, at the advent of commercial shrimp farming, its
contribution to total exports was less than 1 per cent (DOF, 1995; EPBB, 1995).
Subsequently it enjoyed the most phenomenal growth among other primary
industry sectors in post-independence Bangladesh.
In the past rice-based farming systems dominated the agricultural sector in the
coastal areas. The limitations of cropping encouraged farmers in the coastal areas
International Journal of Social
Economics, Vol. 25 No. 2/3/4, 1998,
pp. 314-337, © MCB University This research is financially supported by the Australian Centre for International Agriculture
Press, 0306-8293 Research (ACIAR) Project No. S10039
of the country to switch to shrimp aquaculture. In recent years, shrimp farming Coming out
has expanded at a fast pace. Both the area under shrimp culture and its production of their
have increased significantly since the 1970s. Strong international market demands homesteads?
for shrimp, increased costs of shrimp capturing, favourable environmental
conditions for shrimp production, coupled with private profitability of farmers in
the coastal areas have accelerated the expansion of shrimp aquaculture.
Consequently, shrimp-based farming systems on a commercial scale have emerged 315
in the coastal belt as a highly profitable enterprise.
Shrimp farming itself requires less labour than rice cultivation. The labour
requirement is much less in the extensive method of production which is
commonly practised in Bangladesh. In that sense it has reduced on-farm
employment opportunities for rural landless and wage labourers. However,
shrimp production entails a substantial volume of labour in off-farm ancillary
activities. Therefore, shrimp culture, through a network of backward and forward
linkages, created a significant volume of employment in shrimp farms as well as
ancillary activities, namely trade/commerce, processing and packaging, and
marketing. It was estimated that both on- and off-farm labour requirements for
1983 and 1990 were 10.2 and 22.6 million person days. According to a Master Plan
Organisation (MPO) estimate the employment generation from the shrimp
industry in 2005 is expected to be 59.4 million person days (MPO, 1986).
Most of the off-farm works of the shrimp industry are performed by rural
women. This has led to a major shift in rural employment and occupational
pattern in the shrimp belt. This process has forced rural women to come out of
their homesteads and to stay for longer hours out of home. They have become
more active income-earning members of the rural households. Nevertheless, the
whole process has limited women’s contribution to household duties, particularly
looking after children, performing household chores, and carrying out backyard-
based agricultural works. All these factors together have implications for the
social and economic changes in the rural society of coastal Bangladesh.
This paper addresses the question of whether this process is empowering
rural women of coastal Bangladesh, and the extent to which they have
extricated themselves from various forms of discrimination and exploitation. It
also explores the relationship involving the process of shrimp production and
the status of rural women in Bangladesh. Finally, it examines whether the terms
and conditions of employment and working environment conflict with the local
norms and value systems.
Shrimp
Fry
Collectors
Shrimp Hatcheries
Shrimp
Nurseries Farming Communities
Exporting/Shipping
Backyard Feed Agents
Manufacturers
International Markets
Figure 1.
Sectoral linkages of
Sub-sectors of the shrimp industry
Bangladesh’s shrimp
industry Ancillary activities of the adjacent sub-sector
2.3.1. Shrimp hatcheries. The very first component of shrimp farming Coming out
technological package that was adopted by the farmers in Bangladesh in the of their
early 1980s was supplemental stocking of shrimp fries. This adequately homesteads?
underscores the importance of this subsector. The increased production to date
has been possible due largely to increased stocking densities. Shrimp fries from
wild catch account for about 95 per cent of seed stocking in shrimp farms
(Ahmed, 1996). There is an acute shortage of shrimp fries in Bangladesh 319
(Karim, 1995). Both further expansion of shrimp area and increase in
production would greatly depend on the establishment of shrimp hatcheries.
Currently only ten hatcheries are in operation (DOF, 1995) with very limited fry
production capacity. Consequently, farmers rely mostly on shrimp seeds from
wild collection, and partly on imported shrimp fries from overseas and local
hatchery-bred shrimp post-larvae.
It is important to mention here that only one of the existing hatcheries
produces black tiger fries, the most preferred shrimp species. The present fry
outputs from local hatcheries are far from adequate for the total requirements for
the country’s expanding shrimp aquaculture (Hussain, 1994; Karim, 1995).
Karim (1995) reveals that fry producing capacity of local hatcheries is 20 million
against the total requirement of 2,600 million (Cf. Rahman and Pal, 1995).
Rahman and Pal (1995) note that Bangladesh’s shrimp hatchery sector produces
30 million post-larvae. Construction of 12 private sector hatcheries is in progress
(Haque, 1995) that would significantly ease the shrimp fry crisis in Bangladesh.
2.3.2. Shrimp feed mill. Although shrimp feed is a key component of modern
shrimp technologies, there is a huge shortage of shrimp feed (Hossain, 1995;
Hussain, 1994; Karim, 1995). Application of supplemental feed in shrimp farms
is apparently a recent trend. There are only two feed mills in Bangladesh, with
a production capacity of 6,000 metric tonnes while the total requirement is
100,000 metric tonnes (Hussain, 1994). In addition, there are a few small-scale
fish feed manufacturers. Most shrimp feeds are imported from foreign
countries, which significantly increases costs of shrimp production.
Furthermore, owing to delay in shipment and government customs procedures,
these imported feeds often arrive with a marginal period approaching their
expiry dates. Use of such stale feed has many adverse effects on shrimp farms
(Karim and Aftabuzzaman, 1995), and on the surrounding ecology as well.
Lately, a few private sector feed manufacturing plants have been established.
Lack of any updated statistics makes it impossible to furnish the exact number
of plants that are in operation in Bangladesh.
2.3.3. Shrimp processing plants. Processing plants have experienced such a
rapid growth which is more than in concert with the expansion of shrimp
farming and its total production. This has culminated in a big discrepancy
between the quantity of farm produce required for optimum efficiency of those
plants and the total amount of harvested shrimp crops. As of 1993-94, there
were 115 processing plants with a daily capacity of 800 metric tonnes (Hussain
and Uddin, 1995). In 1994 there was a mere 13 per cent capacity utilisation of
these plants (Haque, 1994). In that period most of the plants were idle because
International of the raw material shortage. Recently Bangladesh Frozen Foods Exporters
Journal of Social Association (BFFEA) has formulated a quota system that would help all the
Economics plants to stay in operation (Economic News, 1995) until shrimp production
matches the requirements of existing processing facilities.
25,2/3/4 It is evident from the above discussion that while shrimp farms and
processing plants have registered substantial growth, the other two sub-sectors
320 have lagged behind. As discussed earlier, sustained growth and development of
the shrimp industry require parallel and compatible development of all its sub-
sectors. In this connection, shrimp hatcheries and feed mills deserve both public
and private sector interventions immediately.
Labour requirement
(000 person-days)
Category of 1983 1990 2005
employment (for 51,000ha) (for 108,000ha) (for 135,000ha)
30,000
20,000
10,000
Figure 2. 0
Projected employment 1983 1990 2005
trend of the shrimp Year
industry
Sources: DOF (1990, 1994); MPO (1986)
• The MPO estimate has not included all avenues for employment
opportunities within the industry. Some other ancillary activities of the
industry have generated substantial volume of off-farm works, namely
delivery of ice to shrimp depots, manufacturing and supply of packaging
materials, production and supply of raw materials for farm construction
and maintenance, trading shrimp feeds and other agri-business
products, shrimp fry and harvested shrimp crop trading, shrimp feed
(e.g. snails) collection, specialised transportation of shrimp crops, and
working in shrimp hatcheries and feed mills. If we add up the labour
requirements for these activities, total employment generation of the
shrimp industry would be much higher.
• The MPO estimate of labour requirement is based on the shrimp farms
in the greater Khulna and Cox’s Bazaar regions. In recent years, shrimp
aquaculture has expanded to other parts of the country particularly the
south-central part of Bangladesh. In addition, fresh water shrimp culture
is gaining increasing popularity in inland waterbodies because of its
high profit potential. In this connection, any valid estimate of labour
requirement for shrimp aquaculture must take into account all shrimp
farming areas.
• Finally, it is evident from Figure 2 that shrimp fry collection is the most Coming out
significant contributing activity to the total employment implication of of their
the shrimp industry followed by on-farm works. Establishment of homesteads?
private sector hatcheries, declining fry availability in brackish water
mainly due to rapid destruction of mangroves, non-discriminatory wild
catch of shrimp larvae and decreasing standing shrimp stock in deep
sea, and importation of shrimp fries from overseas in recent years may 327
have adverse effects on employment prospects for wild shrimp fry
collection.
There are 227 ice plants in Bangladesh (Hussain and Uddin, 1995). In addition,
about 200 firms are involved in the shrimp export trade (Begum and Banik,
1995). All these have employment implications for the shrimp industry.
As stated earlier, about half of the total shrimp farming area is controlled by
multiple ownership. Another 43 per cent of shrimp area is occupied by
outsiders. In the multiple ownership pattern farmers who own some lands are
included in shrimp farming, while some local land owners and influentials may
also join outsiders in the later pattern of shrimp farming. Thus landless farmers
are not encouraged in shrimp farming other than just selling their labour. By
the same token, local landless rural labourers are sometimes not even favoured
for work in shrimp farms. Existing literature portrays various reasons for these
situations, which include:
• mistrust of outsiders towards local people;
• negative attitudes of locals towards outsiders;
• outsiders think that if they hire labour from outside areas it is less likely
they would be able to unite against outsider shrimp growers;
• practices, (e.g. poaching shrimp crops) that are believed to be done by
local labourers, who can also act as part-time security staff etc. (for
details see Rahman et al., 1995).
Outsider shrimp producers prefer hiring labourers from outside areas. The
process they believe would increase profitability from shrimp farms. The
opponents of shrimp farming in coastal areas argue that outsiders hire
labourers from outside areas only to consolidate their power and strength so
that they can keep on producing shrimps without owning lands in those areas
and stay as lead stockholders in the shrimp industry. In sum, the outsiders’
control of large shrimp farms is the prime cause for social imbalance and
deteriorating law and order situations in rural coastal areas. This supports the
argument that although coastal shrimp culture has seen a rapid and unplanned
growth, it has suffered from conflicts that have stemmed from, among other
factors, increased negative social impacts and social unrest (FRI, 1994a; Pullin,
1995). This has serious implications for coastal employment structure leading
to two-way migration flow of landless labourers. Figure 3 sets out the two-way
labour migration in the shrimp belt of Bangladesh.
International Dhaka City - The National Capital
Journal of Social
Economics
25,2/3/4
328
District Town
District Town
Other Coastal
Khulna City
District Town
Bagerhat
Cox’s Bazar
Satkhira
Chittagong
Districts
City
Figure 3.
Labour mitigation flow
in the shrimp belt of
Bangladesh Shrimp Farms in the Coastal Belt
References
Ahmad, N. (1956), “Paddy-cum-fish culture”, Agriculture Pakistan, Vol. 7 No. 1, Department of
Agriculture, Karachi.
Ahmed, A.T.A. (1996), “Policy guidelines for management of coastal shrimp culture Coming out
development”, paper presented at the World Aquaculture ’96 Conference, Bangkok, 29
January-2 February. of their
Ahmed, M.U. and Imam, S.M.H. (1988), “A fisheries information system of Bangladesh”, Naga, homesteads?
Vol. 11 No. 2, p. 12.
Alauddin, M. and Tisdell, C. (1996), Bangladesh’s Shrimp Industry and Sustainable Development:
Resource-Use Conflict and the Environment, Working Paper No. 1, Shrimp-Rice Farming
Systems in Bangladesh Working Paper Series, Department of Economics, The University of 335
Queensland, Brisbane.
Ali, M.Y. (1991), Towards Sustainable Development: Fisheries Resources of Bangladesh,
Bangladesh Ministry of Environment and Forest and National Conservation Strategy
Secretariat, Dhaka.
Begum, M. and Banik, R.C.K. (1995), “Begata panchabarshiki parikalpanakale matshya
utpadaner gatidhara”, in Fisheries Fortnight ’95 Bulletin: Karbo Mora Macher Chash Thakbo
Sukhe Baro Mas (in Bengali), Department of Fisheries, Dhaka.
BFFEA (1995), Leaflet, Bangladesh Frozen Foods Exporters Association, Dhaka.
BFRSS (1986), Water Area Statistics of Bangladesh, Fisheries Information Bulletin No.1,
Bangladesh Fisheries Resources Survey System, Department of Fisheries, Dhaka.
Chowdhury, M.A.M. (1988), “Socio-economic consequences of shrimp cultivation in Bangladesh: a
case study of Satkhira, Chakaria and Maheshkhali”, Bangladesh Journal of Publ ic
Administration, Vol. 2 No. 2, pp. 49-76.
Daily Star (1996), “Garments sector has incurred Tk7,111cr loss in 2 years”, 24 April.
DANIDA (1989), Identification of the Socioeconomic Feasibility of Freshwater Shrimp Culture in
Old Noakhali District, Bangladesh: Final Report, Danish International Development
Agency/Department of Fisheries, Copenhagen.
Das, R.K. (1992), “A study on social and economic aspects of shrimp prawn cultivation in
Bangladesh”, unpublished Master of Agricultural Science thesis, Department of Agricultural
Economics, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh.
DDP (1985a), Shrimp Culture in the Semi-saline Zone of the Delta: Final Report, Vol. 1, Delta
Development Project, The Hague.
DDP (1985b), Shrimp Culture in the Semi-saline Zone of the Delta: Final Report, Vol. 2, Delta
Development Project, The Hague.
DOF (1994), Districtwise Area and Number of Shrimp Farms, DOF Document, Department of
Fisheries, Dhaka.
DOF (1995), Fish Fortnight ’95: Leaflet, Department of Fisheries, Dhaka.
Economics News (1995), “Bangladesh Economics News”, April-July, 1995, http://www.tradeport.
org/ts/countries/bangladesh.
EPBB (1995), Exports from Bangladesh 1972-73 to 1993-94, Export Promotion Bureau,
Bangladesh, Dhaka.
ESCAP (1988), Coastal Environmental Management Plan for Bangladesh, Volume II: Final
Report, United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific, Bangkok.
FRI (1994a), Chingri Chasher Artha-samajik Mullayan (in Bengali), Extension Leaflet No. 16.
Brackishwater Station, Fisheries Research Institute, Khulna.
FRI (1994b), Prakritik utshay hate bagda chingrir pona sangraha o paribesh pratikria (in Bengali),
Extension Leaflet No. 15. Brackishwater Station, Fisheries Research Institute, Khulna.
Guimaraes, J.P.D.C. (1989), “Shrimp culture and market incorporation: a study of shrimp culture
in paddy fields in southwest Bangladesh”, HSD Working Paper 30, Asian Institute of
Technology, Bangkok.
International Haque, M.M. (1995), “Bangladesh’s fisheries sector at a glance”, in Fisheries Fortnight ’95
Bulletin: Karbo Mora Macher Chash Thakbo Sukhe Baro Mas (in Bengali), Department of
Journal of Social Fisheries, Dhaka.
Economics Haque, S.M. (1994), “Annual report of Bangladesh Frozen Foods Exporters Associations
25,2/3/4 (BFFEA)”, in BFFEA Special Bulletin, January 1994, Bangladesh Frozen Foods Exporters
Associations, Dhaka.
Hossain, M.A. (1995), “Lagsai projucti proege upakulya chingri chash unnayan”, in Fisheries
336 Fortnight ’95 Bulletin: Karbo Mora Macher Chash Thakbo Sukhe Baro Mas (in Bengali),
Department of Fisheries, Dhaka.
Hussain, M.M. (1994), “Status of development of the fishery and seafood processing industry in
Bangladesh”, in Sustainable Development of Marine Fisheries Resources in Bangladesh,
Fisheries Research Institute, Mymensingh.
Hussain, M.M. and Uddin, M.H. (1995), “Quality control and marketing of fish and fish products:
needs for infra-structure and legal support”, paper presented at the National Workshop on
Fisheries Resources, Development and Management, Dhaka, 29 October-1 November.
Islam, A. (1983), “A report on aquatic culture in Bangladesh”, Fisheries Information Bulletin,
Vol. 1 No. 2, Bangladesh Fisheries Resource Survey System, Dhaka.
Islam, M. (1996), Personal Communication, Brackish Water Station, Fisheries Research Institute,
Khulna.
Karim, M. (1986), Brackishwater Shrimp Culture Demonstration in Bangladesh, Bay of Bengal
Programme for Fisheries Development, FAO, Madras.
Karim, M. (1995), “Some aspects of shrimp culture development and management”, paper
presented at a seminar on the occasion of Fish Fortnight 1995, Dhaka, August 29 1995.
Karim, M. and Aftabuzzaman (1995), “Brackish and marine water aquaculture: potential,
constraints and management needs for sustainable development”, paper presented at the
National Workshop on Fisheries Resources, Development and Management, Dhaka,
29 October-1 November 1995.
Karim, M. and Ahsan, A.K.M. (1989), Policy Recommendation on Fisheries Development in
Bangladesh, Bangladesh Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock, Dhaka.
Kashem, A. (1996), “Chingri chashe biplabattak utpadan abang raptani aye” (in Bengali), The
Ittefaq, 25 February.
Khor, M. (1996), “Asian shrimp farms at crossroads”, AquaNet: Asian Shrimp Farms, http://
aquanet.com/aquanet/news/item8-4.htm.
Lightfoot, C., Gupta, M.V. and Ahmed, M. (1992), “Low external input sustainable aquaculture for
Bangladesh: an operational framework, Naga”, July, pp. 9-12.
Mozid, M.A. (1994), “Environmental issues and aquaculture development in Bangladesh”,
Country paper, presented at the Final Workshop, FAO Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific,
February.
MPO (1986), Final Report (Vols I-III), Master Plan Organisation, Dhaka.
MPO (1987), Coastal Shrimp Aquaculture Resources, Technical Report No. 18, Master Plan
Organisation, Dhaka.
ODA (1990), Report and Recommendations of the ODA Fisheries Project Identification Mission to
Bangladesh, Overseas Development Administration of UK, London
Pullin, R.S.V. (1995), “Third-world aquaculture and the environment”, Naga, Vol. 12 No. 1, pp. 10-13.
Rahman, A., Islam, M.A., Roy, I, Azad, L. and Islam, K.S. (1995), Shrimp Culture and Environment
in the Coastal Region, Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies, Dhaka.
Rahman, M. and Pal, S.C. (1995), “Bagda chingri hatchery babasthapana”, in Fisheries Fortnight
’95 Bulletin: Karbo Mora Macher Chash Thakbo Sukhe Baro Mas (in Bengali), Department of
Fisheries, Dhaka.
Rosenberry, B. (1995), World Shrimp Farming 1995: Annual Report, Shrimp News International, Coming out
San Diego, CA.
Rutherford, S. (1994), CARE and Gher: Financing the Small Fry, Bangladesh Aquaculture and
of their
Fisheries Resource Unit, ODA, Dhaka. homesteads?
Skagerstam, E. and Brattstrom, T. (1991), “Small-scale fisherfolk’s perceptions and practices
concerning fisheries resources and their conservation: report from a minor field survey”,
Working Paper No. 19, Department of Social Anthropology, Stockholm University, Stockholm.
World Bank (1989), Bangladesh Action Plan for Flood Control, World Bank, Washington, DC. 337
World Bank (1995), The World Bank Atlas, World Bank, Washington, DC.