Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hrynyk Et Al 2012 Thermal Properties of Aluminized and Non Aluminized Basalt Fabrics
Hrynyk Et Al 2012 Thermal Properties of Aluminized and Non Aluminized Basalt Fabrics
Abstract
The aim of this study was to characterize modified basalt fabrics as semi-finished articles for application in personal
protective equipment (PPE), i.e. protective gloves. Resistance to the thermal properties for three fabrics made of basalt
fibers differed in the aspect of mass per square meter and thickness as well as for the aluminized modifications presented.
The modifications were obtained by gluing aluminum foil to the fabric with two kinds of glue. The results of the
measurements are presented in the form of tables and figures. The study focused on the elaboration of the optimal
textile modification designed for use in protective gloves against thermal and mechanical risks. According to the spe-
cifications of related European standards, only one way of proposed modification meets the requirements and can be
successfully used for manufacturing the final product.
Keywords
basalt, fiber, aluminization, thermal factor, protective gloves
Perspectives of the application of basalt fibers related to comparison with other fabrics. Moreover, basalt fabrics
their physicochemical properties arouse the interest of are characterized by their resistance to extremely high
industry as well as research centers. Basalt fibers are temperature. After exposure to high temperatures, they
called man-made mineral fibers (MMMF) and are pro- reveal flexibility and retain resistance to mechanical and
duced by melting basalt aggregate derived from previ- chemical factors. They are also clean and nontoxic,
ously studied basalt deposits, in terms of chemical which is their next useful advantage. Basalt fibers do
composition, at temperatures above 1400 C. The chem- not pollute the water and air; therefore, their storage
ical content of basalt rock applied for manufacturing of and processing is safe. Taking into account the influ-
the fiber include approximately: SiO2 (52.8 %), Al2O3 ence of basalt fibers on the human body, no negative
(17.5 %), Fe2O3 (10.3 %), CaO (8.59 %), MgO (4.63 effect has been recognized thus far. It should be pointed
%), Na2O (3.34 %), K2O (1.46 %), TiO2 (1.38 %), out that basalt does not cause a cancer risk in contrast
P2O5 (0.28 %), MnO (0.16 %) and Cr2O3 (0.06 %). to the asbestos responsible for malignant mesotheli-
Basalt fibers show low moisture absorption, low oma.9 Basalt fabrics are classified as safe for human
thermal conductivity and low elongation at break health in agreement with US and EU standards.
with a limiting oxygen index (LOI) > 70 but high tensile Today, basalt fiber research, production and market-
strength and modulus, very good chemical resistance ing efforts are based in European and North American
and more extended operating temperature range than countries. There are several companies using basalt as a
regular E glass fibers, approaching that of carbon fiber
and high-strength glass, but beating them price wise.1–7
Because of their specific properties, they can be used as 1
Central Institute for Labour Protection – National Research Institute,
a substitute for special glass fiber threads for heat- Poland
2
resistant elastic structures for technical purposes. A Technical University of Lodz, Poland
comparison of properties of basalt fiber with other
Corresponding author:
fibers used in high temperatures is given in Table 1.8 Rafał Hrynyk, Central Institute for Labour Protection – National
Incombustible properties allow basalt fabrics to Research Institute, Wierzbowa 48, Łódź 90-133, Poland.
resist fire for a significantly long time period in Email: rahry@ciop.lodz.pl
Hrynyk et al. 1861
Type of fiber
Table 3. Symbols of basalt fabrics, their aluminized variants and the mean values of measured basic fabric parameters
and 4-ter-butylphenol (dry matter content is 25%). exception of fabric 5, the increase of mass per square
Bonatex PU85 is a dispersion adhesive based on acrylic meter was proportional to its initial value.
acid-ester polymers modified with dispersions of resins Analyzing the thickness change after aluminization
and other modifying agents that do not include any with the Bonatex PU85 glue, there were observed
solvents. It is intended for self-adhesive manufacturing increases of about 0.05, 0.15 and 0.17 mm, successively,
(dry matter content is 42%). The use of two glues for fabrics of nominal mass per square meter: 170, 420
applied for finishing of the basalt fabrics was related and 730 g/m2. For the variants using the Butacoll A+
to an optimization of the aluminization techniques. The glue, the following thickness changes were noted: an
best combination of the fabrics covered by double-sided increase of 0.13 mm for fabric 4 from the initial nom-
aluminized foil including durability, homogeneity as inal mass per square meter 170 g/m2, an increase of
well as repeatability of the structures was achieved 0.06 mm for fabric 5 from the initial nominal mass
by adjusting the thickness of the glue layer, speed of per square meter 420 g/m2 and a decrease of 0.10 mm
rolling and temperature of drying. The main param- from the initial nominal mass per square meter 730 mg/
eters of both aluminization techniques are presented m2 after the aluminization process.
in Figure 1. The thickness of all aluminized fabrics produced and
assessed within the study included values from 0.37 mm
to 0.80 mm for the Butacoll A+ glue and from 0.29 mm
Aluminized basalt fabrics up to 1.07 mm for Bonatex PU85. The thickness of the
During the aluminization process the increase of mass material is a crucial parameter characterizing the flexi-
per square meter value was observed (on average about bility of the gloves and dexterity related to their use.
69 g/m2). The highest mass increase was observed for Values of thickness for aluminized basalt textiles cor-
the basalt fabric designated by the symbol 6, i.e. from respond to other aluminized textiles applied to the pro-
the value 730.0 g/m2 before the aluminization to tective gloves. For example, the thickness of aluminized
840.7 g/m2 after combining with the aluminum foil. Nomex fabric characterized by the weight 302 g/m2 is
The lowest increase of mass per square meter on the about 0.4 mm, whereas the thickness of aluminized
level 56.1 g/m2 was for the fabric of symbol 4. With the Kevlar fabric at 346 g/m2 is about 0.5 mm.16
Hrynyk et al. 1863
Table 4. Flame resistance performance levels according to EN Table 6. Performance levels related to convection
407:2004 heat resistance according to EN 407:2004
copper (Cu) calorimeter in direct contact with the Table 8. Performance levels related
sample. The registered heat transmission index to resistance to small molten metal
(HTI24) is the time of colorimeter temperature increase splashes according to EN 407:2004
of 24 C. The result for each fabric was calculated as a Performance Number of
mean value of three specimens. The level of perform- level droplets
ance for the property is given in Table 6 according to
EN 407:2004. 1 10
The radiation heat resistance was determined 2 15
according to EN ISO 6942:2002.23 Within the tests, 3 25
the time of temperature increase of about 24 C was 4 35
registered after exposing the fabric sample to the heat
radiation of the flux density equal to 20 kW/m2. It is
expressed as a radiation heat transmission index
(RHTI24). The performance levels for the radiation
heat resistance are defined in EN 407:2004 and pre- Additionally, heat resistance was determined accord-
sented in Table 7. ing to EN 659:2003+A1:2008 and ISO 17493:2000.
The resistance to small molten metal splashes was The test relies on examining the fabric samples and
determined according to EN 348:1992,24 taking into ready gloves at an air temperature of 180 C for 5 min-
account requirements defined in EN 407:2004 utes, and next checking the sample size and appearance
(Table 8). The test relies on the reaction of molten changes after such an exposure. The requirement of
metal droplets on the vertically placed fabric samples. heat resistance is written in the standard for the fire-
As a result of measurement, the number of droplets fighters’ gloves, EN 659:2003+A1:2008. According to
acting on the sample was registered. The mean values this standard, after the exposure in the above-described
from the samples cut in the warp and weft directions conditions the fabric should not be melted, dropped or
were calculated and then the lower value was taken into burned, and the shrinkage of gloves should not be
account as a final result. higher than 5%. The measurements were carried out
Hrynyk et al. 1865
Flammability:
time of
further burning
(s)/time of Contact heat Contact heat Convective Radiant
Fabric further resistance at resistance heat resistance heat resistance
symbol glowing (s) 100 C (s) at 250 C (s) HTI24 (s) RHTI24 (s)
for six specimens cut in the warp and weft direction, Assessment of the resistance to contact
respectively.
Two mechanical properties of basalt fabric variants
and convective heat
were assessed, i.e. abrasion resistance according to EN Contact heat resistance was examined first for all
388:200325 and fatigue bending resistance according to the fabrics by measurement with a contact tempera-
EN ISO 7854:1997.26 Because the methodologies of ture equal to 250 C. Results showed that none of the
those measurements are commonly known, a detailed fabricsachieved the required threshold time equal to
description of the procedures is not included here. 15 seconds. For this reason, further measurements
were carried out at a contact temperature equal to
100 C. In this case only one variant of aluminized
fabric designated by the symbol 4 did not fulfill the
Results and discussion requirement.
Thermal properties of non-aluminized and The non-aluminized thin fabric I also did not ful-
fill the requirement. In both cases the expected
aluminized basalt fabrics
time was shorter by about 1 second for fabric 4
The results of thermal measurements of basalt fabric and 2 seconds for fabric I. It should be emphasized
variants are presented in Table 9. The measurement that the application of Butacoll A+ glue for covering
procedures are described in the appropriate standards the fabric with the aluminum foil is responsible for
mentioned above. achieving the first performance level regarding contact
heat resistance. The first performance level in that case
is not so high, but is enough to fulfill the basic require-
Flammability assessment
ment of the standard. Threshold times for fabrics,
The analysis of the flammability of particular basalt which were combined with the aluminum foil using
fabric variants confirms that only two fabrics did not the Bonatex PU85, is lower than for non-aluminized
fulfill the requirements in the range of this parameter, fabrics and indicate a negative influence of the glue
i.e. variant 4 – basalt fabric of nominal mass per square on the protective properties in contact with the hot
meter 170 g/m2, aluminized with the use of Bonatex item.
PU85 glue, and variant 5 – basalt fabric of mass per Analysis of results concerning the convective heat
square meter 420 g/m2, aluminized in the same way. In resistance confirmed fulfilling the EN 407:2004 stand-
the rest of the aluminized and non-aluminized variants, ard requirements in each case. For fabrics of symbols
the after-flame and after-glove time corresponded to III, 3 and 6, i.e. variants of the highest mass per square
the highest value, meaning the fourth performance meter equal to or higher than 730 g/m2, the second per-
level according to EN 407:2004. formance level was obtained. For other variants the
1866 Textile Research Journal 83(17)
Figure 2. Results of the resistance to the contact and convective heat for particular basalt fabric variants.
first performance level of the convective heat was the rest of the aluminized fabrics over-crossed the value
confirmed. of 200 seconds and is significantly higher than the value
On the basis of the results of measurement of resist- described in the standard, i.e. 95 seconds. The graphical
ance to convective heat, it can be concluded that the representation of the results concerning the radiant
mass per square meter and covering the fabric with the heat resistance for the particular basalt fabric variants
aluminum foil layer influence this property. The higher is shown in Figure 3.
the fabric mass per square meter, the higher the value of
HTI24 – the parameter characterizing the convective Assessment of the resistance to small splashes
heat. The graphical form of the results concerning the of molten metal and size change after exposure
resistance to the contact and convective heat is pre-
to hot air
sented in Figure 2.
Two successive parameters, i.e. the resistance to small
splashes of molten metal and the size change after
Assessment of the resistance to radiant heat exposure to hot air were examined for all the basalt
Concerning the resistance to radiation heat, all the fabric variants. Both parameters were assessed, taking
examined basalt fabric variants fulfilled the require- into account a possible application of basalt gloves by
ments of the EN 407:2004 standard. Non-aluminized welders as well as other activities concerning the metal-
basalt fabrics achieved no more than the second per- lurgy industry. The results as well as confirmation of
formance level, whereas aluminized variants achieved the fulfillment (or not) of the standard requirements are
the highest – the fourth performance level. Such a presented in Table 10.
result was expected because the aluminization of the The resistance to small molten metal splashes in the
fabrics is recognized as one of the most effective modi- case of non-aluminized fabrics did not fulfill the
fications enhancing their ability to reflect heat. requirements of the EN 407:2004 standard. The
The highest value of the heat transmission coefficient number of drops for all the aluminized fabric variants
RHTI24 equal to 560 seconds was registered for the seems to confirm the standard requirements. However,
variant designated by the symbol 2, i.e. basalt fabric even with an acceptable number of drops allowed to
(420 g/m2) combined with the aluminum foil with the pass the test in the case of fabrics of symbol 4, 5 and
Butacoll A+ glue. The heat transmission coefficient for 6, the final test result for them is negative because of the
Hrynyk et al. 1867
Figure 3. The set of result of the resistance to radiant heat for the basalt fabrics and their aluminized variants.
Table 10. The results of resistance to small splashes of molten fabrics of symbols 1, 2 and 3. The changes in the fabric
metal and of heat resistance for the particular variants of basalt appearance after the treatment of the samples by small
fabrics molten metal splashes are presented in Figures 5–7.
Resistance to small Size change after The measurement of the small molten metal splashes
splashes of exposure to hot air activity showed that for all non-aluminized basalt
Fabric molten metal (%) warp direction fabric variants aluminized with the use of the Bonatex
symbol (number of drops) X/weft direction Y PU85 glue, metal drops caused holes in the fabrics
(Figures 5 and 7). A significantly better effect and
I 3 (—) — higher performance level was obtained for the fabrics
II 5 (—) — aluminized with the Butacoll A+ glue (Figure 6).
III 5 (—) — The heat resistance measurements were carried out
1 34 (3) 0.7/ 0.7 only for aluminized fabrics, because in the case of non-
2 >37 (4) 0.2/0.0 aluminized fabrics the fabric thread displacement dis-
3 >37 (4) 0.2/0.0 abled the measurement. All the aluminized basalt fab-
4 30 (—) 1.4/ 0.2 rics fulfilled the EN 659:2003+A1:2008+AC:2009
5 23 (—) 2.6/0 standard requirements at an air temperature of
6 26 (—) 2.6/ 0.9 180 C. This standard concerns the gloves for fire-
fighters. The size changes in the X and Y directions
Values in parentheses describe the performance levels related to protect- are presented in Figure 8.
ive properties; dash means fabric variant does not fulfil requirement of
the standard.
Mechanical properties of non-aluminized
changes that occurred in the tested samples. Therefore,
and aluminized basalt fabrics
these fabric variants cannot be used to ensure hand Assessment of the abrasion resistance. From the point of
protection against small molten metal splashes. abrasion, the best were two variants of aluminized fab-
The graphic form of the results including resistance rics of symbols 3 and 6 made of the same basalt fabric
to small molten metal splashes is shown in Figure 4. characterized by the highest mass per square meter
In the case of this parameter, as in the previous (Figure 9). In both cases the second performance level
cases, a better performance level was obtained for the was achieved. For the rest of the aluminized fabrics as
aluminized fabrics with the Butacoll A+ glue, i.e. the well as for non-aluminized variant III, the first
1868 Textile Research Journal 83(17)
Figure 4. The results of the resistance to the small molten metal splashes for the basalt fabrics and their aluminized variants.
Figure 5. Effect of treatment by small molten metal splashes of non-aluminized basalt fabrics: A 170 g/m2, B 420 g/m2,
C 730 g/m2.
Figure 6. Effect of treatment by small molten metal splashes of basalt fabrics aluminized with Butacoll A+ glue: A 170 g/m2,
B 420 g/m2, C 730 g/m2.
performance level was achieved. It should be pointed Assessment of the fatigue bending resistance. In the range of
out that the raw basalt fabrics of symbols I and II do fabric strength properties of aluminized basalt fabrics,
not fulfill the requirements of the standard in the range the fatigue bending resistance according to the EN ISO
of abrasion. It confirms that in this case the aluminiza- 7854:1997 standard was tested. This parameter was also
tion modification of the fabrics improves the protective applied for checking the bonding durability of alumi-
properties. num foil with basalt fabric as an aluminization process
Hrynyk et al. 1869
Figure 7. Effect of treatment by small molten metal splashes of basalt fabrics aluminized with Bonatex PU85 glue: A 170 g/m2,
B 420 g/m2, C 730 g/m2.
Figure 8. The results of assessment of fabric size changes after exposure to hot air for the aluminized basalt fabrics.
Figure 9. Results of abrasion resistance for aluminized and non-aluminized basalt fabrics.
1870 Textile Research Journal 83(17)
Figure 10. Aluminized fabrics after testing of the fatigue bending resistance. Symbols of fabrics correspond to the description in
Table 3.
quality assessment. The appearance of aluminized Tests on the resistance to contact heat failed at a
basalt fabrics after fatigue bending is presented in temperature of 250 C; therefore, 100 C was used in
Figure 10. the next step. The lower range of the contact heat con-
The results of fatigue bending resistance according firmed that only the aluminized basalt fabric of symbol
to EN ISO 7854:1997 was assessed with the use of a 4 and non-aluminized fabric of symbol I are not enough
four-grade scale describing the worsening of appear- to meet the requirements.
ance (from 0 up to 3). All the examined aluminized The use of three different values of mass per square
basalt fabric variants showed changes of surface meter basalt fabrics within the study was related to the
appearance due to the fatigue bending cycles. The regis- flexibility of the fabrics and their modified variants
tered failures included small wrinkles, cracks and fabric designed for final products. The higher mass per
surface wrinkling. The observed worsening of appear- square meter can affect manual functionality and dex-
ance of measured fabric variants in comparison to non- terity of the gloves. However, aluminized with Butacoll
bent fabric was equal to one in the case of each variant. A+ glue, fabrics meet the requirements in terms of all
Registered changes do not affect the protective proper- tested parameters. The second performance level con-
ties of fabrics. cerning convective heat resistance was observed for
variants III, 3 and 6, characterized by the mass per
square meter higher than 730 g/m2. Lower values regis-
tered within the study for other variants are related to
Summing up the experiments the first performance level for this parameter.
According to the parameters defined in the standards Taking into account the radiant heat resistance of
concerning protective gloves designed for use in ther- the fabrics, the aluminization finishing was responsible
mal risks, only basalt fabrics aluminized with Butacoll for a significant increase in protective performance
A+ glue fulfill all requirements, i.e. flammability, level, achieving the highest level for all aluminized
resistance to contact, convective and radiant heat as variants.
well as resistance to small splashes of molten metal Distinguishing between both aluminization tech-
and size change after exposure to hot air. niques is important with relation to protecting fabrics
Flammability tests confirmed that only two variants against small molten metal splashes. A significant
of basalt fabrics did not fulfill the requirements, i.e. 170 advantage again was revealed for Butacoll A+ glue.
and 420 g/m2 aluminized with the use of Bonatex PU85 Because fabrics of symbols 4 and 5 did not pass the
glue. In the case of other variants, the after-flame and flammability tests, they cannot be applied for use in
after-glove times reached the highest performance level gloves protecting against small molten metal splashes
according to EN 407:2004. designed for metallurgic purpose, e.g. welders.
Hrynyk et al. 1871
20. EN ISO 15025:2002. Protective clothing. Protection 23. EN ISO 6942:2002. Protective clothing. Protection
against heat and flame. Method of test for limited against heat and fire. Method of test: Evaluation of
flame spread. materials and material assemblies when exposed to a
21. EN 702:1994. Protective clothing. Protection against heat source of radiant heat.
and flame. Test method. Determination of the contact 24. EN 348:1992. Protective clothing. Determination of
heat transmission through protective clothing or its behaviour of materials on impact of small splashes of
materials. molten metal.
22. EN 367:1992. Protective clothing. Protection against heat 25. EN 388:2003. Protective gloves against mechanical risks.
and fire. Method for determining heat transmission on 26. EN ISO 7854:1997. Rubber- or plastic-coated fabrics.
exposure to flame. Determination of resistance to damage by flexing.