Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Media and The Government of Populations Communication Technology Power 1St Ed Edition Philip Dearman Full Chapter
Media and The Government of Populations Communication Technology Power 1St Ed Edition Philip Dearman Full Chapter
Media and The Government of Populations Communication Technology Power 1St Ed Edition Philip Dearman Full Chapter
Populations: Communication,
Technology, Power 1st ed. Edition
Philip Dearman
Visit to download the full and correct content document:
https://ebookmass.com/product/media-and-the-government-of-populations-communic
ation-technology-power-1st-ed-edition-philip-dearman/
Palgrave Studies in the History of the Media
Series Editors
Bill Bell
Cardiff University, UK
Chandrika Kaul
University of St Andrews, UK
Alexander S. Wilkinson
University College Dublin, Ireland
Palgrave Studies in the History of the Media publishes original, high
quality research into the cultures of communication from the middle
ages to the present day. The series explores the variety of subjects and
disciplinary approaches that characterize this vibrant field of enquiry. The
series will help shape current interpretations not only of the media, in all
its forms, but also of the powerful relationship between the media and
politics, society, and the economy.
Advisory Board:
Prof. Carlos Barrera, University of Navarra, Spain
Prof. Peter Burke, Emmanuel College, Cambridge
Prof. Nicholas Cull, Center on Public Diplomacy, University of Southern
California
Prof. Bridget Griffen-Foley, Macquarie University, Australia
Prof. Tom O’Malley, Centre for Media History, University of Wales,
Aberystwyth
Prof. Chester Pach, Ohio University.
Cathy Greenfield
RMIT University
Melbourne, VIC, Australia
Much writing concerned with the social, cultural, and especially political
significance of media is focused on the public sphere and publics. In this
book, we argue for shifting attention to populations. In providing multi-
ple examples of populations of various kinds and scales using and caught
up in media and communication technologies, we trace connections
between individuals, groups, and media that are not of the sort confined
to the public sphere framework of consciousness or rationality. Making
populations of various kinds and scales our vantage point for consid-
ering media and communication technologies helps us to assess claims
made about the role of new media in change, and it helps us remember
the status of individuals and populations as historically curious and novel
figures and as thoroughly political inventions.
The book is primarily a work of synthesis and is crafted for readers not
already versed in the governmental school. It aims to bring the insights
of this school to those readers whose concern is chiefly with media and
communication; readers whose interest lies with politics will find a pro-
ject to enlarge how we understand that term, without sacrificing interest
in politics as ordinarily understood. Past and current scholarship is drawn
on and drawn together to focus on the ways particular populations are
rendered literate, productive, accountable, skilled, connected, patriotic,
fit, surveilled, marginalized, enterprising, entertained, informed, and
creative—and how this is achieved in relation to widely variant govern-
mental programs and projects undertaken within and across diverse insti-
tutions and organizations. Our aim is to make it difficult, after reading
vii
viii Preface
*******
When we started there were three of us. We lost one along the way. Peter
Williams died in November of 2015, but his determined intellect and
his inspiring teaching are embedded in all that is here. In many ways,
this book began with the Honours and Masters courses Peter taught for
many years at RMIT. Blind through this period, Peter’s teaching was
made possible by the love and labors of Mick Counihan and Deborah
Kessler, who were his weekly readers throughout these years. These
courses were important for many students, for what was taught and
Preface ix
learnt, and also for Peter to continue a vocation. One of Peter’s students,
Sharanjeev (Terry) Johal, has written this about him:
I have been lucky in life to have many good teachers, a few great ones, and
fewer still inspirational ones. Even fewer are those, who as a teacher myself
now, I aspire to be. Peter Williams was one of those … Peter was the first
teacher I had who thanked us for letting him teach us, and making it a
pleasure for him. Thanked us - his students! He said that he learned from
us. A man whom we all thought was a genius and a truly remarkable man
had learned from us.
xi
xii Contents
Broadcasting 70
Mobile Privatization 72
A Socioeconomic Literacy 78
Conclusion 83
References 88
Index 225
CHAPTER 1
Introduction: Communication,
Government, Populations
It deals with how these technologies have been and are now used to
change the ways people are governed, and indeed brought to partic-
ipate in their own government. To do this, it provides multiple histo-
ries of the uses of different media that help us to understand their role
in pervasive modern forms of power. Thus, the book is concerned with
both the communication and media of politics and power and the poli-
tics and power of communication media. It focuses on how politics and
power rely on communication media to operate, and how communica-
tion media are integrated with different scales of politics and power.
Such an investigation responds to where we find ourselves in the
twenty-first century, surrounded with claims about the all-determining
importance of communication, especially new forms of communication.
The latest social media revolution grabs the headlines and is said to be
transforming how people learn, become informed, earn, and play. Such
claims occupy public discussion, are repeated with increasing regularity,
and then suffer the fate of either becoming clichés or dismissed as over-
blown, with counterclaims about the eternal verities of human psychol-
ogy, human biology, plain old human nature, or simply common sense
being the real key to understanding current events and forms of life.
Communication fades to a surface expression of these deeper verities and
explanations.
Caught up in a seesaw of hyperbole and relegation, just how the sig-
nificance of communication can be plausibly grasped is perplexing. The
accelerated development and spread of diverse applications of new media
and communication technology both contributes to this situation and
provides one reason for seeking to remedy it. In this sense, the book
responds to the current phenomena of communicative abundance—of
broadband, of digital economies, of ubiquitous computing and organiza-
tional surveillance, of mobile media and social media—locating them in a
history of the present and the role of communication in it.
But looking at the proliferation of new communication devices does
not answer the question of how and in what ways communication mat-
ters. Instead, we make a case for taking note of the connections, often
unlikely, between communication media practices and the ways in which
the dispositions, capacities, and activities of various populations are
formed, shaped, and regulated. In so doing we describe such connec-
tions as they exist now but also in different times and places, revisiting
episodes in earlier histories of print, broadcast, telegraphic, and other
media.
1 INTRODUCTION: COMMUNICATION, GOVERNMENT, POPULATIONS 3
Communication
This book is centrally interested in “communication,” which we under-
stand to be the production, distribution, exchange, and uses of mean-
ings, as well as of accompanying pleasures and pains. Communication
helps to shape and constitute social relations, identities, and situations
rather than to simply express or represent them. The argument here
is that rather than, say, a national community existing first as “dumb”
fact then expressing itself—for example, in a national cinema—
certain kinds of film-making and viewing help generate a national
identity; rather than a masculine identity existing innately, then being
represented say in advertising and popular music, automobile ads and rap
1 INTRODUCTION: COMMUNICATION, GOVERNMENT, POPULATIONS 9
Government
“Government” names the formative shaping of the possible field of
actions of individuals and groups—this is using the word in its older
sense. Government—or governing—is a pervasive, productive and het-
erogeneous exercise of power (or, more precisely, of power relations)
which attends to the work of governing as extending beyond the State
and thus beyond elected governments directing the State, although
by no means ignoring these elected bodies and their tasks. The more
recent, now dominant use of the term “government” is conceptually nar-
rower, and it is this now broadly liberal and common sense usage that
encourages a more or less exclusive focus on the State and its armory
of laws and agencies to control and coerce people’s behavior through
the authority to take away from the people within a particular territory
their liberty, property, and in some cases, life. Battles against, and for, the
power of government as the State, are familiar in the late twentieth–early
twenty-first century period.
In the broad sense of government, by contrast, governing occurs in
and across all organizations and institutions, operates at different lev-
els, and on local, regional, national and global scales. Rather than being
characterized only by the imposition of obedience and the control of
unwanted conduct, it also involves a governmental power to persuade,
train, and form those who are governed. Thus, to speak of popula-
tions being governed is to describe something beyond people coming
under direct purview of the representatives of elected governments. This
broader sense of government and governing requires a little more discern-
ment to appreciate the different perspective it brings to our understanding
of a whole array of things: political life, pressures, and possibilities; the
social relations within which people live; economic activities and calcula-
tions; and cultural practices and patterns.
If governing is pervasive, it means that to understand how things are
arranged in a particular society, and how they might be arranged dif-
ferently, does not depend on locating some center of power (such as,
traditionally, “the State”). Other institutions, for example, medicine,
education, finance, television, and business, are as involved in the exer-
cise of governmental power as the State, and it is the loose alliances
among institutions and their actors that repay scrutiny rather than a
simple pursuit of the source of sovereign power, that is, of who has the
“right” to exercise power, a right traditionally attributed to the State.
14 P. DEARMAN ET AL.
Populations
In this book we focus on populations. People are governed as mem-
bers of populations, and we wish to align description and analysis with
what actually happens to people. People are constituted as populations
and shaped by virtue of action directed at those populations understood
in different ways—as consumers, as audiences, as publics, as citizens,
as peoples. A population is an aggregate of socially formed individ
uals, of individuals gathered into a grouping in some definite way, that
is, by some governing body or other, which utilizes definite techniques
of aggregation and means of making those who are aggregated visible
to and knowable by the governing body. This grouping may be at the
level of the nation, or of the city, or of a region or neighborhood—but it
may also be at the level of an institution (for example, the population of
patients in the institution of health and medicine) or of an organization
(the population of employees at Google or Facebook).
Historically, governing bodies have focused on populations guided
by objectives involving health, education, productivity, and security. A
concern with national populations accompanied the formation of nation-
states, hungry for knowledge of the fertility, the literacy, the working
abilities of a nation’s population. As the geographer Thrift puts it, ‘the
notion of population is caught up with the rise of states and their need
to both circumscribe and enlarge their capacities through synoptic [com-
prehensive] facts’ (2008, p. 94).5 He is working here with the knowl-
edge that “population” is not a natural accompaniment of the existence
of human beings on the planet but a relatively recent notion and way of
seeing and knowing human beings that dates from around the start of
the seventeenth century in Germany.6 Rather than the medieval view
of persons as organic elements of indivisible groupings of various hierar-
chical kinds (orders, estates, Stände), fixed by natural law, that is, God’s
18 P. DEARMAN ET AL.
Rhetoric
Rhetoric is the strategic use of linguistic and other materials to persuade
particular audiences to some aimed-for social outcome. We investigate
media in terms of rhetoric as part of an approach to media as embedded
within the government of populations. Focusing on rhetoric, or rather
on particular rhetorics, helps us describe one key element of the action at
a distance that government entails.
22 P. DEARMAN ET AL.
History
This book contributes to histories of the present. We are interested
in multiplying the ways we can understand, and thus act in, our pres-
ent circumstances, and how they have come to be. This stance assumes
1 INTRODUCTION: COMMUNICATION, GOVERNMENT, POPULATIONS 23
Notes
1. Others are doing similar work: see Isin and Ruppert (2015), Dean (2013),
Amin and Thrift (2013), and Bennett and Joyce (2010).
2. See also the ESRC-funded research by Curran et al. on gender gaps in
political knowledge from a ten-nation comparative study, reported in
Pollack (2013).
24 P. DEARMAN ET AL.
References
Alasuutari, Pertti. 1995. Researching Culture: Qualitative Method and Cultural
Studies. London: Sage.
Amin, Ash, and Nigel Thrift. 2013. Arts of the Political: New Openings for the
Left. Durham and London: Duke University Press.
Bennett, Tony and Patrick Joyce (eds.). 2010. Material Powers: Cultural Studies,
History and the Material Turn. New York and Oxon: Routledge.
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1979. “Public Opinion Does Not Exist.” In Communication
and Class Struggle, Volume 1: Capitalism, Imperialism, edited by Armand
Mattelart, and Seth Siegelaub, 124–130. New York: International General.
Chaterjee, Partha. 2004. The Politics of the Governed: Reflections on Popular
Politics in Most of the World. Delhi: Permanent Black.
1 INTRODUCTION: COMMUNICATION, GOVERNMENT, POPULATIONS 25
We opened this book with some of the matters occupying people’s lives
in a time of broadband communication technology. But if broadband
seems to us now to take the government of populations into pathbreak-
ing digital dimensions, it is worth remembering that, to some degree,
we have been here before. Another digital technology, the telegraph,
was the focus of technical inventiveness and problem solving, economic
ambitions, political negotiations, and a wide variety of social and cultural
uses and consequences in the nineteenth century, which just as relent-
lessly patterned and embedded populations in relations of power as the
currently remarkable phenomenon of broadband.1
Digital is not quite so new as we like to think. The historian of new
media Carolyn Marvin (1989, p. 3) reminds us of this by describing
computers as simply the telegraph with a prodigious memory. Saying
this is not an attempt to wash away the particularity of computerized
and Internet-enabled communication technology, but to get us to see its
“newness” in connection with the persistent and to some degree familiar
work, negotiation, and day-to-day tussle around how any communica-
tion technology is brought into people’s lives and the social and other
relations they comprise, and what changes are thereby fashioned.
These are the history lessons that help us understand the actual signif-
icance of what is often unhelpfully dramatized, singularized, and over-
blown as a revolution—in our times, a revolution going by the name of
broadband, or a few years earlier, the Internet. In this chapter of history
EGYPT: A. D. 1898-1901.
The Barrage and Reservoir works on the Nile.
"At Assiut the great regulating dam across the Nile approaches
completion, the foundations being practically all in position,
leaving a portion of the superstructure to be completed. The
sluice openings here number 119, all 16 feet wide. This dam is
somewhat similar in principle to the well-known barrage near
Cairo, but the details of construction are entirely different,
as the foundations are guarded against undermining by a
complete line of cast iron and steel-piling above and below
the work. The barrage itself is constructed of high-class
masonry instead of brickwork as at the old barrage. Although
the Assiut barrage is overshadowed by the greater magnitude of
the Assuan dam, it will, doubtless, rank second as the
monumental work of Egypt."
ARTICLE I.
The word "Sudan" in this Agreement means all the territories
South of the 22nd parallel of latitude, which:
2.
Which, having before the late rebellion in the Sudan been
administered by the Government of His Highness the Khedive,
were temporarily lost to Egypt, and have been reconquered by
Her Majesty's Government and the Egyptian Government acting in
concert; or
ARTICLE II.
The British and Egyptian flags shall be used together, both on
land and water, throughout the Sudan, except in the town of
Suákin, in which locality the Egyptian flag alone shall be
used.
ARTICLE III.
The supreme military and civil command in the Sudan shall be
vested in one officer, termed the "Governor-General of the
Sudan." He shall be appointed by Khedivial Decree on the
recommendation of Her Britannic Majesty's Government, and
shall be removed only by Khedivial Decree, with the consent of
Her Britannic Majesty's Government.
{202}
ARTICLE IV.
Laws, as also Orders and Regulations with the full force of
law, for the good government of the Sudan, and for regulating
the holding, disposal, and devolution of property of every
kind therein situate, may from time to time be made, altered,
or abrogated by Proclamation of the Governor-General. Such
Laws, Orders, and Regulations may apply to the whole of any
named part of the Sudan, and may, either explicitly or by
necessary implication, alter or abrogate any existing Law or
Regulation. All such Proclamations shall be forthwith notified
to Her Britannic Majesty's Agent and Consul-General in Cairo, and
to the President of the Council of Ministers of His Highness
the Khedive.
ARTICLE V.
No Egyptian Law, Decree, Ministerial Arrêté, or other
enactment hereafter to be made or promulgated shall apply to
the Sudan or any part thereof, save in so far as the same
shall be applied by Proclamation of the Governor-General in
manner hereinbefore provided.
ARTICLE VI.
In the definition by Proclamation of the conditions under
which Europeans, of whatever nationality, shall be at liberty
to trade with or reside in the Sudan, or to hold property
within its limits, no special privileges shall be accorded to
the subjects of anyone or more Power.
ARTICLE VII.
Import duties on entering the Sudan shall not be payable on
goods coming from Egyptian territory. Such duties may,
however, be levied on goods coming from elsewhere than
Egyptian territory, but in the case of goods entering the
Sudan at Suákin, or any other port on the Red Sea Littoral,
they shall not exceed the corresponding duties for the time
being leviable on goods entering Egypt from abroad. Duties may
be levied on goods leaving the Sudan at such rates as may from
time to time be prescribed by Proclamation.
ARTICLE VIII.
The jurisdiction of the Mixed Tribunals shall not extend, nor
be recognized for any purpose whatsoever, in any part of the
Sudan, except in the town of Suákin.
ARTICLE IX.
Until, and save so far as it shall be otherwise determined, by
Proclamation, the Sudan, with the exception of the town of
Suákin, shall be and remain under martial law.
ARTICLE X.
No Consuls, Vice-Consuls, or Consular Agents shall be
accredited in respect of nor allowed to reside in the Sudan,
without the previous consent of Her Britannic Majesty's
Government.
ARTICLE XI.
The importation of slaves into the Sudan, as also their
exportation, is absolutely prohibited. Provision shall be made
by Proclamation for the enforcement of this Regulation.
ARTICLE XII.
It is agreed between the two Governments that special
attention shall be paid to the enforcement of the Brussels Act
of the 2nd July 1890, in respect to the import, sale, and
manufacture of fire-arms and their munitions, and distilled or
spirituous liquors.
EGYPT: A. D. 1899-1900.
Final defeat and death of the Khalifa.
Capture of Osman Digna.
Condition of the Sudan.
----------EGYPT: End--------
{203}
ELAM.
(in volume 4)
SEMITES;
ENGLAND: A. D. 1894.
The commandeering question with the South African Republic.
ENGLAND: A. D. 1894-1895.
Retirement of Mr. Gladstone from public life.
Earl of Rosebery Prime Minister.
His speech on the "predominant member" and Home Rule.
Weakening and overthrow of the Liberal Government.
Dissolution of Parliament.
Conservative and Unionist triumph.
Third Ministry of Lord Salisbury.
Mr. Gladstone, who had passed his 84th year, whose health was
failing, and who might justly consider that his public work
was done, resigned his post as Prime Minister, on the 2d of
March, 1894, and the Earl of Rosebery, on his recommendation,
was called by the Queen to take his place. Slight changes,
otherwise, were made in the cabinet, but the spirit in the
Liberal government was no longer the same. The new Premier
soon signified that his disposition in the matter of Home Rule
for Ireland was not quite what Mr. Gladstone's had been, by
using the following language in a speech (March 13) in the
House of Lords:
{204}
ENGLAND: A. D. 1895.
Enforcement of claims against Nicaragua.
See (in this volume)
CENTRAL AMERICA (NICARAGUA): A. D. 1894-1895.
ENGLAND: A. D. 1895.
The question of Chitral.
ENGLAND: A. D. 1896.
Establishment of the Sierra Leone Protectorate.
ENGLAND: A. D. 1896.
Report on Old-Age Pensions.