Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gregor 1957
Gregor 1957
INTRODUCTION
While the titratioii behavior of low molecular weight acids and bases is
independent of the nature of the base or acid used as a titrant, this is not
the case with polymeric acids and bases. Here specific effects have been
found t o occur where difl'erent counterions are present. Some of these
specific effects have been observed by Steinhardtl and by Tanford2, who
observed that the titration behavior of proteins was dependent in part 011
the specific acid or base used. Differences in the viscometric behavior of
polyacrylic acid when neutralized with sodium hydroxide aiid with po tas-
sium hydroxide were noted by K a t ~ h a l s k y . ~
A note by Gregor, Luttinger, and Loeb14described the tihalion of poly-
acrylic acid with quaternary ammonium bases, and showed that pK,,, the
negative logarithm of the average ionization constant, was 6.43 with
potassium hydroxide and 6.85 with tetrabutylammonium hydroxide. This
decrease in acid strength with increasing size of the counterion was also
observed with crosslinked polyacrylic and polymethacrylic acids by Gregor,
Hamilton, Becher, and Bern ~ tein .~Swelling measurements of these cross-
linked gels showed that the entropy of the polymer chain decreased with
increasing size of the counterion, a t the same degree of neutralization.
This contribution presents detailed data on the titration of polyacrylic
and polymethacrylic acids with lithium, sodium, potassium, ammonium
tetramethylammonium, tetraethylammonium, tetra-n-propylammonium,
and tetra-n-butylammonium hydroxides in the presence of varyiiig con-
ceiitratioiis of neutral salts of the same cation, aiid also in llie presence of
mixed salts. Following papers in this series will presciit data on the
conductivity aiid the viscosity of polymcthacrylic acid when neutralized
with the same series of bases. A theoretical trcatmeiit of tlicse syslems also
follows.
* This investigation was supported in part by Research Grant, 1ZG 294(C2) from tlic
Division of Research Grants of the National Institutes of Health, U. S. Public Health
Service.
t The Discussion of this paper will be found 011 page 483.
1Newark College of Engineering, Newark, N. J.
451
452 H. P. GREGOR AND M. FREDERICK
EXPERIMENTAL
Samples of polyacrylic and polymethacrylic acids were obtained through
the courtesy of Rohm and Haas Company; these were purified further by
precipitation and by dialysis using cellophane tubing. All of the chemicals
used were of reagent grade. The bases were prepared to be carbonate free
and the systems were kept under nitrogen a t all times.
Contamination of the solutions by potassium chloride diffusing from the
tips of calomel electrodes was kept a t a minimum by carrying out the
titrations using a Beckman p H meter, laboratory model G, with fiber tip
calomel electrodes. A number of these electrodes were tested for leak
of potassium chloride by immersion in distilled water and measurement over
a period of time. Only those tips which showed a leak of salt less than lop5
M in a half-hour period were used. In the previous study4 certain drifts
in the measured p H readings were found to occur. In the work reported
here it was observed that this drift was due either to bubble formation or
t o a skin of adsorbed polymer on the surface of the electrodes. This drift
in pH was eliminated by using a magnetic stirrer and passing nitrogen gas
over the surface of the solutions during the titrations, the stirrer being
stopped for each reading. It was found that no drift in p H took place; the
pH readings obtained almost instantaneously after the addition of base
were constant over a period of hours or days. Each titration was there-
fore performed directly, with a period of about five minutes between suc-
cessive readings. The temperature was compensated in each case to 25°C.
In order to avoid contamination from sodium in glass, polyethylene
beakers were used wherever this problem might have been serious, partic-
ularly with the quaternary ammonium bases. Repeated titration curves
were identical to within *0.02 pH unit.
Measurements of the hydrogen ion activity of polyelectrolyte solutions in
the presence of various salts contain two errors. The first is the so-called
suspension effect, which is primarily due to the presence of the polyelectro-
lyte; discussion of errors of this type is contained in the work of Loojes.G
These corrections are usually minor and since comparisons were made in
most cases between polyelectrolytes of the same conceiitration and type
no correction was deemed necessary.
A somewhat larger error might arise from differences ill the liquid junc-
tion potential be tween solutions of varying salt coiiceiitratioiis arid salt
TABLE I
EFFECT OF SALT
ON p H METERHEADINGS
WITH 0.05 M POTASSIUM BIPHTHALATE
BUFFER
Standard
Salt (no salt) 0.01 M 0.2 M 1M
types and the saturated potassium chloride solution of the calomel electrode.
A discussion of various procedures for the minimization of these errors is
found in Harned and Owen.’ Since in this paper most comparisons were
made between solutions of equal ionic strength but varying in ionic com-
position, the effects of such variations could be corrected for by measuring
the pH of the same buffer in the presence of different salts of the same ionic
strength; these differences could then be applied as a correction. This
experimental method is similar to that used by Harned and Robinson,8and
by others.
Table I presents data on the pH of a potassium biphthalate b d e r
(0.05 M ) in solutions of lithium, sodium, and potassium chlorides a t vary-
ing concentrations.
Titrations of 0.01 M (base moles) polyacrylic acid (PAA) by lithium,
sodium, and potassium hydroxides in the presence of no salt and of 0.01,
0.1,0.2, and 1.0 Msolutions of the corresponding chlorides were carried out.
The experimental results for each titration curve could be expressed in terms
of the modified Henderson-Hasselbalch equation, pH = pK,, - n log (1-
a ) / a ,where a is the degree of neutralization or equivalents of base added
per equivalent of acid present, n is a constant, and KaDis the average ioniza-
tion constant. In each case an appreciable shift in the titration curves to
lower pH values was observed on going from potassium to sodium to lithium.
log .+
- 0.5 -QZS 0 a23 a5
I I I
c G
ry
Fig. 1. Titration of 0.01 M polyacrylic acid with potassium hydroxide ( 0 ) .
sodium hydroxide (A), and lithium hydroxide (0)in the presence of 0.2 M solutions of
the corresponding chlorides.
PARAMETERS
TABLE 11. HENDERSON-HASSELBALCH FOR TITRATIONS
OF POLYACRYLIC
AND POLYMETHACRYLIC
ACIDSWITH
VARIOUS
BASESAT DIFFERENT
IONICSTRENGTHS
Tetramethyl Tetraethyl Tetraprppyl Tetrabutyl
Salt ammomum ammonium ammonium ammomum
added, Lithium Sodium Potassium
Polyacid M pK.. n pK.. n pK.. n pK.. n pK.. n PK.. n pK.. n
PAA(O.O1 M) ........... 0 6.70 1.96 6.79 2.13 6.79 2.26 6.75 2.72 6.95 2.93 7.12 3.38 7.24 3.62
0.01 5.85 2.13 6.14 2.20 6.14 2.31 6.27 2.57 6.43 2.98 6.55 3.15 6.18 3.98
0.1 5.31 1.87 5.29 1.95 5.35 2.07 5.68 2.51 5.73 2.88 5.96 3.10
0.2 5.08 1.64 5.20 1.87 5.30 1.98
I 4.48 1.48 4.68 1.60 4.67 1.65
PMA(O.O1 M) . . . . . . . . . . 0 7.15 2.05 7.25 2.40 7.34 2.74 7.61 3.12 7.73 3.62
PMA(O.OO1 M) . . . . . . . . . 0 7.90 2.44 7.95 2.66 8.39 3.78
Potassium-tetrabutylammonium Mixture
XE = 1 XK = 0.54 XK = 0.33 X K = 0.12 X K = 0.012 X K = 0.0012 XP = 0
PAA(O.01 M ) .......... . 0 6.79 2.26 6.78 2.74 6.91 3.01 7.11 3.40 7.05 3.50 7.19 3.42 7.24 3.62
Lithium-tetrabutylammoniummixtureas'
XLi = 1 X L i = 0.10 X L i = 0.01 XLi = 0
PAA (0.01 M)..... . . . . . . 0 6.70 1.96 7.10 3.26 7.17 3.44 7.24 3.62
a X = mole fraction.
POLYACRYLIC AND POLYMETHACRYLIC ACIDS 43.55
This effect was perceptible but rather small in the absence of salt, steadily
increasing with the ionic strength due to added salt. Figure 1 shows a
plot of titration curves for 0.01 M PAA with lithium, sodium, and potassium
hydroxides in the presence of 0.2 M solutions of the corresponding chlorides.
The Henderson-Hasselbalch plots for these titrations are also shown.
Table I1 presents calculated values of the average ionization constants
PH
I I I I I I
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2.
CX
Fig. 2. Titrations of 0.01 M plyacrylic acid with potassium and tetraalkylam-
monium hydroxides in the absence of salt, and in the presence of 0.01 M and 0.1 M solu-
tions of the corresponding halides. Note that the ordinate has been displaced for each
curve. The symbols are as follows: potassium (n),tetramethylammonium (V), tetra-
ethylammonirim ()., tetrapropylarnmonium (A),tetrabutylammonium ().
456 H. P. GREGOR AND M. FREDERICK
pK,, and n for other titrations of polyacrylic acid with various bases in the
presence of varying concentrations of salt, and of 0.01 M and 0.001 M solu-
tions of polymethacrylic acid (PMA) with different bases in the absence of
added salt. In all cases Henderson-Hasselbalch plots of the data gave
straight lines with an excellent fit in the range 0.7 > CY > 0.3, where the
equation is considered to have maximum validity.
Figure 2 shows titration curves of 0.01 M PAA with potassium and the
quaternary ammonium bases in the absence of salt, in 0.01 M and 0.1
M salt solutions. The curves have been moved on the ordinate axis to
show the three sets in a single figure. Titration curves and Henderson-
Hasselbalch plots of 0.01 M PMA are shown in Figure 3 for titrations with
sodium and the quaternary ammonium bases in the absence of salt. Titra-
I-=
‘09 a
-a5 -92’1 0 0.25
12
10
II
10
d
PH
3
0 0.2 0.4 -0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4
o(
Fig. 3. Titration of 0.01 M polymethacrylic acid with sodium and the tetra-
alkylammonium hydroxides: sodium (A), tetramethylammonium (V), tetraethylam
moniurn ( O ) ,tetrapropylammonium (A),tetrabutylammonium (m).
POLYACRYLIC AND POLYMETIIACRYLIC ACIDS 457
tion curves with sodium and potassium were nearly identical under these
conditions. Figure 4 presents titration curves for 0.001 M PMA with
potassium, tetramethyl, and tetrabutyl ammonium hydroxides in the
absence of salt.
The polymeric acids were also titrated with mixtures of bases. Figure
5 shows titration curves for 0.01 M PAA titrated with mixtures of potassium
and tetrabutylammonium hydroxide in the absence of neutral salt. The
mole fraction of potassium hydroxide in the mixed bases varied from 0.0012
to 0.54. Figure 6 shows a titration curve for 0.01 M PAA with mixtures
of lithium and tetrabutylammonium hydroxide in the absence of salt.
Figure 7 shows titration curves of 0.01 M PAA with potassium hydroxide
in 1 M potassium chloride, in mixtures of potassium and lithium chlorides
having a total ionic strength of 1.0 and in 1 M lithium chloride employing
lithium hydroxide.
Titrations with potassium and tetrabutylammonium hydroxide in the
absence of salt of an analogous low molecular weight acid, 0.01 N glutaric
acid, are shown in Figure 8. It is seen that the curves are virtually identi-
cal.
DISCUSSION
The discussion contained herein will concern itself primarily with the
I I I I I I I
a
Fig. 4. Titration of 0.001 M polymethacrylic acid with potassium (O), tetramethyl-
ammonium (V ) and tetrabutylammonium (m) hydroxides.
458 H. P. GREGOR AND M. FREDERICK
P”
a
Fig. 5. Titration of 0.01 M polyacrylic acid with potassium-
tetrabutylammonium hydroxide mixtures where the mole
fraction of potassium hydroxide is XK.
oc
Fig. 6. Titration of 0.01 M polyacrylic acid with lithium-
tetrabutylammonium hydroxide mixtures where the mole
fraction of lithium hydroxide is XLI.
a
Fig. 7. Titration of 0.01 M polyacrylic acid with base in 1.0 M lithium
chloride (0), 1.0 M potassium chloride ( 0 ) . and in 0.2 M lithium chloride and
0.8 M potassium chloride or XK = 0.8 (A).
Kf = [LiA]/[Li+] [A-]
was fouiid t o be approximately 1.94 f 0.15 for 0.4 < a < 0.9.
Figure 2, which shows titrations of polyacrylic acid with potassium and
various quaternary ammonium bases a t different salt concentrations,
demonstrates the pronounced increase in the slope and the average ioniza-
tion constant of the polyacid with increasing couiiterion size. Since this
point is treated theoretically in detail in a subsequent paperg all that is
required here is to point out that increasing counterion size and the con-
sequent increasing distance of closest approach of the counterion to the
chain makes for an increased chain potential. The electrical free energy
required t o remove a proton from the chain accordingly increases.
- 0
2.0 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3.0
P 1x1
G c
These data also show direct evidence that a significant fractioii of the
counterioiis of polyelectrolytes of high charge have equilibrium positions
in close proximity to the chain, the distance of iiearest approach being
approximately the sum of the ionic radii.
From Figure 2 it is observed that the upward shift in p H with illcreasing
couiiterioii size is approximately the same in the absence as in presence of
salt. This effect appears to be due in large part to the cxclusioii of neutral
salt from the polyanion coil by the high Donnan concentration present there.
It would be expected that the ionic strength effect would be signifcant
only a t high ionic strengths.
Figures 2 and 3 also show that the curves for titrations with the quater-
POLYACIIYLIC AND POLYMEl’IIACRYLIC ACIDS 463
When the mole fraction of lithium was increased tb 0.1 the effect was
significantly greater than that observed with potassium. It would appear
that the specific binding of lithium is enhanced by the high chain potential
of tetrabutylammonium polyacrylate.
When low molecular weight acids are titrated with cations of m e r e n t
sizes, 110 significant differences appear. Figure 8 shows that, even when the
counterions are as different as potassium and tetrabutylammonium, the
titration curves for glutaric acid were identical.
Refcrenccs
1. J. Steinhardt, Ann. N. Y. Acud. Sci., 41,287 (1941).
2. C. Tanford, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 72, $41 (1950).
3. A. Katchalsky, J. Polymer Sci., 7, 393 (1951).
4. H. P. Gregor, L. B. Luttinger, and E. M. Loebl, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 76, 5879
(1954).
5. H. P. Gregor, M. J. Hamilton, J. Becher, and 17. Bernstein, J. Pliys. Chem., 59,
874 (1955).
6. R. Loosjes, Thesis, Utrecht, 1942.
7. H. S. Harned and B. B. Owen, Physical Cliernistry of Electrolytic Solutions, Rein-
hold, New York, 1943, p. 316.
8. €1. S. Harned and R. A. Robinson, J. Am. Cliem. Soc., 50,3157 (1928).
9. I. Kagawa and H. P. Gregor, J. Polymer Sci., 23,477 (1957).
10. H. P. Gregor, L. Luttinger, and E. M. Loebl, J. Phys. Chem., 59,34 (1955).
Synopsis
Lithium ions, and, t o a lesser extent, the sodium ions are bound by polyacrylic acid,
as evidenced by pII titrations of polyacrylic acid in dilute (0.01 M ) solutions of the
alkali metal bases and solutions of their corresponding salts. The formation constant
for the binding of lithium to polyacrylic acid was found t o be 1.9. When dilute solutions
of pol yacrylic and polymethacrylic acids were titrated with quaternary ammonium
bases, the polyacids became progressively weaker with increasing size of the counterion.
These phenomena suggest that the counterions are largely held in close proximity t o the
polyanion chain, with distances of approach comparable t o the sum of the ionic radii.
Titrations of these acids with a mixture of a large and small cation also served t o point
up the increased chain potential in the presence of large cations. All of these effects are
absent with the analogous low molecular weight acids.
RCsumi:
Ides ions lithiques, e t en rnoindre irnportaiice lcs ions sodium, sorit l i b par I’acide poly
acrylique, ainsi que le montrent les titrations au pfI de I’acide polyacrylique en solutions
diluCes (0,Ol M) au moyen de bases des mCtaux alcalins e t de solutions de leurs sels
correspondants. La constante de forinaticn de liaison de lithium P I’acide polyacrylique
a 6th trouvCe Cgale P 1.9. Lorsque des solutions diluCes d’acides polyacrylique e t poly-
mCthacrylique Ctaient titrCes par des bases ammoniques quaternaires, les polyacides
deviennent progressivement plus faibles suivant la grandeur croissante de I’ion de signe
contraire. Ces phCnom&nessuggerent que les ions de signe contraire sont gardCs dans
le voisinage immCdiat de la chaine polyanionique des distances comparables P celles de
la somme des rayons inoiques. Les titrations de ces acides avec un melange de cations
grands et petits ont Cgalement CtC utilisCs pour dCmontrer le potentiel de chaPne croissant
avec la presence de larges cations. Tous ces effets sont absents avec les acides analo-
gues de faible poids molCculaire.
POLYACRYLIC AND POLYMETHACRYLIC ACIDS 465
Zusammenfassung
Lithiumionen und in geringerem Ausmasse Natriumionen werden durch Polyacryl-
saure gebunden, wie durch pH-Titrationen von Polyacrylsaure in verdunnten (0, 01 M)
Lijsungen der Alkaliinetalbasen und Lijsungen ihrer entsprechenden Salze gezeigt wird.
Es wurde gefunden, dass die Bildungskonstante fiir die Bindung von Lithium an Poly-
acrylslure 1,9 ist. Wenn verdiinnte Losungen von Polyacryl- und Polymethacryl-
sluren mit quaternaren Ammoniumbasen titriert werden, wurden die Polysauren mit
zunehmender Grosse des Gegeniom fortschreitend schwacher. Dime Vorgarige lassen
annehmen, dass die Gegenionen in der Hauptsache sehr nahe der Polyanion-Kette gehal-
ten werden, wobei die AnnEherungsabstande der Summe der Ionenradien vergleichbar
sind. Titrationen dieser Sluren mit einer Mischung eines grossen und kleinen Kations
dienten auch dam, das erhijhte Kettenpotential in Gegenwart grosser Kationen zu
zeigen. Alle diese Wirkungen bestehen mit den analogen Sluren von niedrigem Mole-
kulargewicht nicht.