Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Institute of Educational Studies
Institute of Educational Studies
A Thesis
Submitted for the PhD. Degree in Education
(Teaching English as a Foreign Language)
By
Supervised By
Abstract
The main concern of this research was to
examine the effectiveness of a suggested strategy in
developing the listening and speaking skills of the TEFL in
industrial secondary school students.
Sample: The sample, totaling 80, was selected from
Shiblanga industrial Secondary school, in Qualiobia
governorate. Three tools were used; listening and speaking
checklist, pre-post test and teacher’s guide. The results
revealed that using the suggested strategy (graphic
organizers and discussion method) had a positive effect on
developing listening and speaking skills in English
language for first year industrial secondary stage students.
The experimental group was superior to the control group
after applying and using the suggest strategy. It is
recommended that using graphic organizers and discussion
method provides opportunity for discussion between
teacher and students, and students to students.
CONTENTS Page
- Abstract
- Acknowledgements
- Table of contents
І-Chapter one The problem of the study 1-6
Introduction 1
Context of the study 2
- Statement of the problem 4
- Research Questions 4
- Hypotheses of the study 4
- Purpose of the study 4
- Delimitations of the study 5
- Significance of the study 5
- Definition of terms: 5
- Listening skills 9
-The principles of teaching listening skills 11
-Problem of teaching listening 12
-Communicative language teaching (CLT) and speaking: 13
-Communicative activities and speaking 14
-Speaking processes 16
-Importance of developing speaking skills in 17
the classroom
- Developing speaking skills needs good and effectiv 18
instruction
-Difficulties of speaking in the classroom 19
- Techniques of assessing speaking 21
-The importance and purpose of graphic organizers 22
for industrial students
- Construction of graphic organizers 23
-A applications and uses of graphic organizers 25
- Discussion method 25
- Hints for guiding successful classroom discussion 27
-Discussion skills 28
- Types of discussion 29
- Problems with discussion 31
- Conclusion 32
ІІІ- Chapter three Review of related studies 33-44
1- Introduction 33
2- Previous studies related to developing listening 33
and speaking skills
3- Previous studies related to using graphic organizers 36
- Previous studies related to using discussion method 38
IV- Chapter four Method &procedures 45-54
- Introduction 45
- Design of the study 45
- Subjects of the study 45
- Tools of the study 45
The global extending of English users among the world has imposed
some educational implications regarding the foreign language teaching and
learning. One of these implications is the growing prominence towards the
integration of English foreign language (EFL) teaching into the national
educational programs and applications. Another remarkable trend is the
arising shift towards communicative language teaching (CLT) that involves
the use of transactional and problem- solving activities that resemble every
day oral interactions (Warchawer, 2000:p20 &Wallace, 2001:p.27).
˺
Within the framework of the communicative view of EFL teaching
and learning, oral communication has been greatly emphasized. Oral
language is thought to be essential for providing successful language
development (McMaculloch 2005:p.21). Such emphasis highlights
developing the oral interactive skills which constitute the core-dimension of
an oral interaction, i.e., listening and speaking skills. (Miszkiewicz
2005:p.30) confirms that developing the oral competence should be the
fundamental aim of the ELT. The reason for that can be related to the main
purpose underlying EFL learning process which is developing the learner’s
ability to be understood.
˼
That is to say, graphic organizers and discussion method enable
listeners and speakers to use their linguistic knowledge efficiently through
offering them a wide range of alternatives for modifying their utterance to
be more comprehensible and communicative.
Research Questions:
The present study attempted to answer the following main question:
-What is the effectiveness of a suggested strategy in developing the listening
and speaking skills of the EFL industrial secondary school students?
Four questions were derived from this main question:
What are the listening skills needed for industrial secondary school students
in EFL?
2-What are the speaking skills needed for industrial secondary school
students in EFL?
3-What is the effectiveness of using graphic organizers on developing
listening and speaking skills for industrial secondary school students in
EFL?
4- What is the effectiveness of using discussion method on developing
listening and speaking skills for industrial secondary school students in
EFL?
˽
2-Identifying the speaking skills that are needed for industrial secondary
school students in EFL.
3-Developing industrial secondary school students’ listening and speaking
skills in EFL.
4-Measuring the effectiveness of the suggested strategy on developing
industrial secondary school students’ listening and speaking skills.
Definition of terms:
Strategy:
Ghoneim (2001:p226) defined strategy as “a mental operation used to
solve a listening problem”.
Shehata &El Naggar (2003:p39) defined the strategy as “a set of
measures practices that the teacher follows in the classroom to reach outputs
in the light of the aim s/he puts includes collection of techniques, means,
activities and evaluation style.
˾
In this study, strategy means “an organization based on a set of
principles and using various activities to develop first year industrial
secondary stage students’ listening and speaking skills”.
Graphic organizers:
Fishers (1995:p20) defined graphic organizers as “a specific instructional
organization tool available to teachers, this tool have proven to be successful for
all students in inclusive classrooms. Visually displaying key content ideas can
benefit learners who have difficulty organizing information”.
Acheycutts, (2001:p.2) defined graphic organizers as a tool that provides
a visual of facts, ideas, and concepts. This visual allows the mind to see
relationships and patterns.
In this study, graphic organizers mean a visual organizational system
used in classroom to promote thinking and language development.
Discussion method:
Gulley (2002:p.357) defined discussion method as one of the most
widely used and valuable methods. It represents a type of teamwork, based
on the principle that the knowledge, ideas, and feelings of several members
have great merit than those of a single individual.
Wagner(2004:p.4) defined discussion method as a forum in which
students can practice expressing themselves clearly and accurately.
In this study discussion method is one in which the students and the
teacher exchange their ideas in order to get a better understanding of a topic
it can be a whole period or be a part of a lesson.
˿
Chapter two
Review of literature
This chapter is divided into four main sections: The first section deals
with listening skills. The second section deals with speaking skills. The third
section deals with graphic organizers. The fourth section deals with
discussion method.
Listening skills
The word "skill" refers to the way language is used, and is
traditionally conceived as consisting of reading, writing, listening, and
speaking (Richard&Platt: I992 , p.14). Listening skills vary according to the
purpose of listening, the listener and the context. However, one can put one's
hand on the outstanding classifications of these skills. The literature is full of
lists of listening skills that go around and orbit the same core.
(Tinkler,1980:p.33) said that the general comprehension skill is
made up of a number of sub skills:-
a) Distinguishing phonemes,b) Recognizing words,
Identifying stress, intonation, and syntactic rules,
Keeping in mind chosen and summarized parts of what is heard,
Anticipating the development of the speaker's utterances,
Understanding the communicative intentions of the speaker.
(Rixon,1986:p.29) pointed out that in order to understand the message
students may need to be able to do the following:
To hear all the words the speaker says;
Understand the plain sense of the information;
Deduce the meaning of unknown words and phrases by using the context;
Understand what is implied but not stated in so many words;
Recognize a speaker's mood or attitude;
̂
f) Recognize the degree of formality with which the speaker is talking.
(Anderson and Lynch 1988:p.30) showed that there are three main
skills in listening as follows:
1-The skills of recognizing the topic of the conversation.
2-The skills of making predictions about likely developments of the topic to
which he will have to respond.
3-The skills of recognizing and signaling when s/he has not understood
enough of the input to make a prediction or a response.
A according to (Abdel-karem,1995:P.29), there are ten sub- listening
skills, these skills are:
1-Following and understanding instructions and oral directions given by
native speakers in informal situations;
2- Selecting the gist of the spoken language "getting the main idea".
3-Selecting and ignoring information: in other words, to search for
purposeful information
4-Drawing inferences: this can be shown through paraphrasing given
information in the listening text.
5- Guessing information.
6- Identifying the purpose of the speaker.
7- Extracting specific ideas.
8-Understanding the communicative functions of the target language.
9-Predicting outcomes and what might come next;
10- Interpreting given information.
(Cindy,1997:P.40) reported that there are six receptive skills;
A) Predictive skill; the efficient listener predicts what he is going to hear.
Extracting specific information; very often the listener is involved in the use
of receptive skills for the sole purpose of extracting specific information.
Getting the general picture; listeners listen to something because they want to
get the general picture or the main idea.
d) Inferring opinion and attitude; listeners have to be able to work out what
the speaker's opinions and attitudes are, particularly since they are not always
directly stated.
e) Deducing meaning from the context; especially when the listener is
confronted by worked that s/he does not know their meaning.
f) Recognizing patterns and markers; recognizing discourse markers is an
important part of understanding how a text is constructed. It is important to
know which sentence is generalization and be able to recognize devices for
cohesion and understand how a text is coherently organized.
˺˹
(Abdel-latif, 2003:p.28) indicated that critical listening is a mental skill that
includes a number of sub-skills such as:
-Selecting from listening,
-Analyzing and interpreting the speaker's purpose,
-Identifying emotion (students listen to identify the mood of certain
speakers),
-Discriminating between facts, imagination and opinion,
- Recognizing the speaker's view,
- Guessing unknown meanings from the context,
-Being able to generalize, summarize, classify, and arrange ideas
systematically,
-Extracting inferences and similarities,
-Evaluating what the ones listens,
-Inferring information and knowledge,
-Expecting and predicting ideas,
-Discussing and expressing opinion,
-Relating background knowledge to the present,
-Diagnosing weaknesses and strengths of what the ones listens,
-Analyzing the message, adapting listening according to the speaker,
recognizing contrasts, expressing feelings after listening.
According to (Omar, 2008:p.40), listening skills can be divided into
two categories; general listening skills and critical listening skills. The
former includes detecting and remembering significant facts and details,
following a sequence in narrative or argument, following oral directions,
selecting the main idea, summarizing and paraphrasing, understanding
meanings in the context, making inferences and predicting. The critical
listening skills include identifying the purpose of the speaker and the
message, identifying and categorizing facts and opinions and judging validity
and adequacy of ideas and arguments
Finally, good students need to be able to use a combination of all skills
simultaneously when processing the listening text. Using certain skills
depends on the kind of the text they are listening to, and their reasons for
listening to it.
˺˺
- The texts that learners listen to should be authentic to have features of
spontaneous speech
- Texts can be graded in a way that ensures that they are appropriate for the
learners.
- Learners can be given a purpose for listening.
- Learners can be encouraged to make predictions about what they are
going to hear.
- Learners can be given various kinds of support for listening teachers
should actively teach micro-skills or sub skills and strategies.
- Similarly, we should actively encourage learners to employ successful
strategies, ways of coping when they couldn’t understand everything
- Teachers should also be aware themselves of the features of natural
speech such as weak forms and assimilation, elision, redundancy, noise,
colloquial language and be ready to help learners with it.
- Teachers should also be aware of learners' difficulties as opposed to native
speakers' ways of listening.
Student's participation is an important principle in teaching. In the
classroom students should be encouraged to develop their sense of
anticipation and prediction in order to prepare for using the language in the
real world. This can be done by stopping the tape in the mid-flow and
asking the students to guess what is coming next.
˺˻
Sometimes students feel frustrated because they find listening
difficult to acquire (Omar,2008:p.40) provided many reasons for that:
-Students are trying to understand every word.
-Students go back trying to understand what a previous word means.
-Students can’t know the most important words.
-Students can’t recognize the words they know.
-Students have problems with different accents.
-Students get tired.
-Students have mental block.
-Students are distracted.
-Students cannot cope without images.
As Ali claimed, listening is the most difficult linguistic task to
acquire, so teachers has to stress their work on acquiring this task to
face student’s listening problems.
˺˼