Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 11

Substance Use & Misuse, 46:1690–1699, 2011

Copyright 
C 2011 Informa Healthcare USA, Inc.
ISSN: 1082-6084 print / 1532-2491 online
DOI: 10.3109/10826084.2011.605414

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Substance Use/Abuse and Suicidal Behavior in Young Adult Women:


A Population-Based Study

Maud Sundin1 , Fredrik Spak2 , Lena Spak2 , Valter Sundh3 and Margda Waern1
1
Department of Psychiatry, Institute of Neuroscience and Physiology, The Sahlgrenska Academy, University of
Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden; 2 Department of Social Medicine, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden;
3
Department of Public Health and Community Medicine, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden

use is also increasing (CAN, 2007). There is evidence


Associations between substance use variables and sui-
that increasing rates of alcohol/intoxicant consumption
cidal behavior were analyzed in an urban population
are paralleled by increasing rates of attempted (Rossow,
sample from (“the Women and Alcohol in Gothen-
Groholt, & Wichstrom, 2005) and completed (Mann, Zal-
burg” study). In Phase I, 20-year-old women (n =
cman, Smart, Rush, & Suurvali, 2006) suicide. Female
2,069) completed a screening questionnaire. Interviews
suicidal behavior is growing more similar to that of males,
were carried out with a stratified sample (n = 560).
with increasing use of violent suicide methods (Beautrais,
Data, collected in 1995 and 2000, were analyzed us-
2003). In a recent European study (Värnik et al., 2009),
ing logistic regression to generate odds ratios. Drug
hanging was the main method among young women in all
use, but not risky alcohol consumption, was associated
participating countries. Rates of hanging were observed
with suicidal thoughts after adjusting for current de-
to be particularly high in both genders in northern Eu-
pression. Study limitations and implications for suicide
rope, and the authors suggested that this might indicate
prevention are discussed. The study was funded by the
converging gender behavior.
Swedish Research Council and the Alcohol Research
While the relationship between alcohol use disorder
Council of Sweden.
(AUD) and suicidal behavior is well documented (Sher,
Keywords alcohol, substance use, suicidal thoughts, suicide 2006; Wilcox, Conner, & Caine, 2004), most of the evi-
attempt, young women dence stems from studies based on clinical cohorts. A re-
cent mixed-age population-based study carried out by the
Office of Applied Studies, Substance Abuse and Mental
INTRODUCTION
Health Services Administration (2009) revealed that per-
Sweden has seen a dramatic drop in the overall suicide sons who fulfilled criteria for a substance use disorder had
rate during the past two and a half decades (National Pre- a more than three-fold increase in odds of having seriously
vention of Suicide and Mental Ill-Health, 2010). How- considered suicide. Population studies with diagnostic in-
ever, the trend has not been as favorable for young women. formation focusing specifically on young women who are
There was no reduction in suicide rates for women aged transitioning into young adulthood are lacking. This age
15–24 years during this time period, and a dramatic in- group is of interest as this is the stage of life at which al-
crease in suicide attempts was observed in this age group cohol consumption peaks (CAN, 2007). Alcohol is often
(Karolinska Institute’s Public Health Academy, 2009). consumed prior to attempted suicide in teens and young
One explanation for this distressing development may be adults (Hawton & Harris, 2007), and risks associated with
the increase in alcohol use observed in young women problematic alcohol consumption need to be clarified us-
during this time period. Over the last 10 years, young ing operationalized measures.
girls/women have increased their consumption more than There is increasing evidence for a link between drug
boys/men. Also, women’s share of alcohol-consumption- use and suicidal behavior in adolescents (Wilcox, 2004).
related inpatient care and alcohol-consumption-related However, results of population studies regarding cannabis
deaths is on the rise in Sweden (CAN, 2007). Illicit drug use and suicidal behavior are mixed (Borges, Walters,

The study was funded by grants from the Alcohol Research Council of Sweden and the Swedish Research Council grant number
K2004-21PD-15102-01A. This is a FAS-Epilife collaboration.
Address correspondence to Margda Waern, Department of Psychiatry, Institute of Neuroscience and Physiology, The Sahlgrenska Academy,
University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg SE 413 45, Sweden; E-mail: margda.waern@neuro.gu.se

1690
SUBSTANCE USE AND SUICIDALITY IN YOUNG WOMEN 1691

& Kessler, 2000; Bovasso, 2001; Hallfors, 2004; Kung, costs by interviewing a selected subsample rather than the
Pearsson, & Liu, 2003; Macleod et al., 2004). Population- entire Phase 1 sample. The fractions were chosen to yield
based studies that examine suicidal behavior in young sufficient numbers of women with AUD and still keep the
adult women with problematic use of substances other total number of interviews manageable. In order to better
than alcohol are needed. understand the effect of Phase 1 attrition, a random 25%
We wanted to investigate relationships between alcohol of those who did not respond to the original screening
and other substances, and suicidal thoughts and attempts questionnaire (n = 100) were also sent an invitation.
in a population-based sample of 20-year-old women who After the initial mailed invitation to the face-to-face
participated in the “Women and Alcohol in Gothenburg” interview, nonresponders were sent up to two written re-
study. We hypothesized that we would find associations minders, and if necessary, they were also telephoned. The
between AUD/high alcohol consumption (HAC)/heavy response rate for Phase 2 was 65.2% for those who had
episodic drinking (HED) and suicidal behavior. We also taken part in Phase 1 and 40% for nonparticipants in Phase
wanted to test associations between intake of illicit drugs 1. Respondents who did not accept full interviews were of-
and suicidal behavior in these young women. Relation- fered short interviews (n = 104), but this article is based
ships between nonprescription use of licit drugs and sui- on data for those who took part in the full face-to-face in-
cidal behavior were also examined. terview (278 women born in 1975 and 284 women born
in 1980).
METHOD
Assessments
Design and Sample Almost all of the interviews took place in the homes
The study is a part of a larger longitudinal population- of the participants. A few women requested alternative
based study, “Women and Alcohol in Gothenburg” (Spak settings (our office at the Department of Social Medicine
& Hällström, 1995), that was initiated in 1985 in Gothen- or the participant’s workplace). The structured inter-
burg, Sweden’s second largest city. The current study view covered sociodemographic, psychological, and
population included all 20-year-old women born in 1975 behavioral parameters, including drug use/abuse (Spak
and in 1980 living in western and central Gothenburg. & Hällström, 1995). The interviewers (n = 11) had
According to the Gothenburg City Office, the study area several years of clinical experience and were trained in
had 200,803 inhabitants in 1995 (104,704 women) and DSM-III-R (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
205,553 inhabitants in 2000 (106,323 women). There Disorders) diagnostics for substance use disorders. This
were no exclusion criteria. DSM version was employed as the current study is part
In Phase 1, which took place in 1995 for those born in of a larger longitudinal study and because it was the
1975 and in 2000 for those born in 1980, all women in the version in use at the time of project initiation. We chose
study population (total N = 2,069) were sent a 13-item to employ this version in later waves for comparability.
self-report instrument, SWAG (Screening Women in Clinical examinations were performed until sufficient
Gothenburg). This instrument, which contains a modified interrater reliability was achieved, which was defined as
version of CAGE (Ewing, 1984), has been shown to complete diagnostic agreement to the unit digit (i.e., 30x,
have good psychometric properties in both clinical and where x is the unit digit). The structured diagnostic instru-
epidemiological settings (Spak & Hällström, 1996). In- ment CIDI-SAM (Composite International Diagnostic
trascale reliability, measured with Cronbach’s alpha, was Interview-Substance Abuse Module; Robins, Cottler, &
0.90. Each endorsed item gave one point (maximum pos- Babor, 1986) was included in the protocol. For cases in
sible score 13 points). There were no questions on suici- which interview diagnoses and CIDI-SAM diagnoses
dality in this phase. The response rate for the initial postal differed, all available information was weighted together
questionnaire was 75.5% for both birth cohorts combined. to form a final diagnosis, which was used in the analyses
There was no formal attrition analysis. However, for a (Spak & Hällström, 1995). Interviewers were also trained
previous study wave, analysis of case record data did in the use of the MINI (Mini-International Neuropsy-
not show any significant difference in the prevalence of chiatric Interview; Sheehan et al., 1998), which was
alcohol-consumption-related diagnoses in participants utilized to diagnose other (nonsubstance use) psychiatric
and nonparticipants (Spak & Hällström, 1995). disorders. Personality disorders were not diagnosed in
A stratified random sample of Phase 1 respondents was the current study, as time was a limiting factor.
invited to participate in face-to-face interviews in Phase In order to enhance statistical power, diagnoses of alco-
2 (n = 901). The stratified random sample included three hol abuse and alcohol dependence were merged into one
groups: 100% of the women who received a score of at category, AUD. HAC was defined as an average daily use
least 5 points on the screening instrument (n = 372), a ran- of more than 20 g of ethanol measured over the last month
dom 22.5% of those scoring between 1 and 4 points (n = of drinking during the past year, and HED denoted use of
201), and a random 77.8% of those who scored 0 points (n 60 g of ethanol (five drinks) on one drinking occasion.
= 228). Female AUD is a low prevalent condition, and the HED frequency measures were: (1) at least once a month,
stratification was made for two reasons: firstly, to collect and (2) at least once a week during the past year.
a large enough sample of women with alcohol problems The young women were asked whether they had
to enable statistical analyses, and secondly, to reduce used illicit drugs and/or prescription drugs in a
1692 M. SUNDIN ET AL.

TABLE 1. Prevalence of suicidal thoughts and attempts in two cohorts of 20-year-old women

Suicidal thoughts Suicide attempts

Past year Lifetime Past year Lifetime

na (%)b na (%)b na (%)b na (%)b

Total (N = 560) 98 (15.4) 282 (49.7) 13 (2.2) 44 (8.1)


Cohort 1 (n = 278) 20 years old in 1995 41 (10.4) 141 (48.3) 4 (0.6) 25 (8.9)
Cohort 2 (n = 282) 20 years old in 2000 57 (22.4) 141 (51.5) 9 (4.4) 19 (7.1)
a
Unweighted numbers.
b
Weighted percentages.

non-prescribed manner. For substances other than regression for both cohort and major depression (single or
alcohol (see Appendix), the frequency measures were: recurrent episode) in accordance with DSM-III-R (296.2x
(1) more than once during the past year, and (2) more or 296.3x). In the final set of analyses, binary logistic
than five times during lifetime. Use/abuse of benzodi- regression models were employed to analyze trend
azepines and opiates also comprised legally prescribed associations with number of different substances used.
medication, as it is often difficult to distinguish between
use and misuse of such drugs in persons with problematic Ethics
drug-use-related behaviors. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee for
Suicidal ideation and suicide attempts were assessed Medical Research at the University of Gothenburg.
according to Meehan, Lamb, Salzman, and O’Carrol
(1992), using the following questions: Suicidal ideation:
Have you EVER had thoughts of taking your life, even if RESULTS
you would not really do it? Have you EVER thought about
specific ways to take your life even if you would not really Half of the young women in this population-based study
do it? A woman was considered to have lifetime suicidal had suicidal thoughts at some point during their lives,
ideation if she answered affirmatively to either question. and 8% had made at least one suicide attempt (Table
The women were also asked whether they had had such 1). Fewer reported past-year ideation and attempts. There
thoughts during the PAST 12 MONTHS, and those with a were significant differences between the two birth co-
positive response were considered to have past-year suici- horts regarding past-year suicidal thoughts and attempts.
dal thoughts. Lifetime suicide attempt was recorded when Twenty-year-olds who were interviewed in the year 2000
a woman answered “yes” to the following question: Have were more likely to report past-year suicidal thoughts (OR
you EVER made an attempt to take your own life? And a = 2.5, 95% CI = 1.4–4.4, p = .002) and attempts (OR =
woman was considered to have a past-year suicide attempt 7.5, 95% CI = 2.1–16.4, p = .03) than their counterparts
if she gave an affirmative response to the question: Dur- who were interviewed in 1995.
ing the PAST 12 MONTHS, have you made an attempt to The two cohorts were combined for further analyses,
take your own life? and regression models were therefore controlled for birth
cohort. One fifth of the women who fulfilled criteria
for AUD during the past year reported having suicidal
Statistical Analysis thoughts (Table 2). Similar proportions were noted in
As the material was oversampled with individuals those with risky alcohol consumption patterns (HAC or
who indicated possible alcohol problems on the postal HED at least once a month during the past year). None
screening questionnaire, all prevalence rates, p-values, of the abovementioned variables conferred increased risk
and odds ratios (ORs) with confidence intervals (CIs) are for past-year suicidal thoughts, however. One third of
weighted based on the sampling fractions in the different those with illicit drug use during the past year reported
SWAG-score classes (see above). SUDAAN 9.0 software past-year suicidal thoughts. A similar proportion was
(Research Triangle Institute, 1997) was used, with observed among women who used cannabis, which was
chi-square test for data analyzed in 2 × 2 tables and the the illicit drug most commonly used. Past-year illicit
logistic procedure for data analyzed in k × 2 tables, where drug use in general, and cannabis use in specific, was
k > 2. No imputation procedure was used for missing associated with a more than three-fold risk for past-year
values. Missing values are reflected in the n’s of each suicidal thoughts. A third of those with nonprescription
analysis. Subgroups with a specific alcohol or drug vari- benzodiazepine use during the past year reported suicidal
able were compared with all others. As suicidal thoughts thoughts; this was associated with a four-fold risk for
and attempts were more common in the later-born cohort, past-year suicidal thoughts. Nonprescription opiate use
this cohort was introduced as a control variable in all of during the past year conferred a near four-fold risk
the regression analyses (Model 1). In Model 2, associa- for suicidal thoughts during this time period. Risk was
tions were statistically controlled with multiple logistic elevated in women who reported use of any illegal drug
SUBSTANCE USE AND SUICIDALITY IN YOUNG WOMEN 1693

TABLE 2. Associations between different types of substance use and past-year suicidal thoughts in 20-year-old women (N = 560)

Model 1a Model 2b

n (%)c OR (95% CI) LRCd (df) R2e OR (95% CI) LRCd (df) R2e

Past year
AUDf 19 (20.5) 1.2 (0.5–2.8) 31.47 (2) 0.0547 0.8 (0.3–2.0) 74.16 (3) 0.1242
HEDg 46 (20.2) 0.9 (0.4–1.9) 31.41 (2) 0.0546 0.8 (0.3–1.8) 74.65 (3) 0.1250
HACh 23 (22.0) 1.5 (0.8–3.0) 35.02 (2) 0.0607 1.6 (0.8–3.1) 77.62 (3) 0.1296
Any illegal drug 35 (33.7) 2.9 (1.5–5.5) 57.22 (2) 0.0973 2.5 (1.2–5.0) 91.40 (3) 0.1508
Cannabis 28 (34.9) 3.0 (1.5–5.9) 53.44 (2) 0.0912 2.6 (1.3–5.5) 90.38 (3) 0.1493
Benzodiazepine 9 (35.0) 4.2 (1.5–11.7) 36.95 (2) 0.0640 4.0 (1.5–10.8) 78.57 (3) 0.1311
Opiates 15 (27.6) 4.1 (1.7–10.1) 53.79 (2) 0.0917 3.8 (1.3–11.5) 92.99 (3) 0.1532
Lifetimei
Any illegal drug 20 (33.0) 2.1 ( >1.0–4.3) 39.71 (2) 0.0687 1.8 (0.8–3.9) 78.67 (3) 0.1315
Cannabis 17 (32.9) 2.1 ( <1.0–4.4) 37.85 (2) 0.0656 1.8 (0.8–3.8) 77.21 (3) 0.1292
Benzodiazepines 10 (33.0) 4.2 (1.6–11.0) 47.02 (2) 0.0808 2.9 ( <1.0–8.6) 81.94 (3) 0.1366
Opiates 17 (26.9) 2.0 (0.9–4.3) 39.10 (2) 0.0677 1.8 (0.7–4.4) 78.81 (3) 0.1317
a
Model 1 adjusted for birth cohort.
b
Model 2 adjusted for birth cohort and depression.
c
Weighted percentages.
d
LRC = Model’s likelihood ratio chi-square.
R = Cox–Snell R2 for binary logistic models.
e 2
f
Alcohol use disorder.
g
Heavy episodic drinking.
h
High alcohol consumption.
i
Use of specified substance five times or more during lifetime.

at least five times during lifetime and in those who used association with any illegal drug remained significant af-
benzodiazepines at least five times during lifetime. ter adjustment for depression.
As subgroups with a specific alcohol/drug variable One quarter of the young women with AUD had made
were compared with all others, there was a risk for a suicide attempt at some point (Table 4). The disorder
confounding comparisons as the reference group could was associated with a more than four-fold increase in risk
include women with other types of substance use. We for lifetime suicide attempt. Neither HAC nor HED was
therefore investigated the effects of an alternative contrast associated with attempted suicide. An association was ob-
category free from any form of substance use problem served between past-year nonprescription use of benzodi-
(no lifetime diagnosis of AUD, no lifetime illicit drug azepines and lifetime suicide attempts, and a six-fold in-
use, and no use of benzodiazepines or opiates more crease in odds of attempted suicide was observed after the
than five times during lifetime). This procedure did not models were adjusted for depression.
change the above associations in any substantial manner We examined whether risk for suicidal thoughts and
(results not shown). When depression was included in the attempts increased with increasing number of substances
logistic models, past-year illicit drug use in general and used during the past year. We found associations between
cannabis use in specific as well as nonprescription use of numbers of different substances and both past-year and
benzodiazepines and opiates, all remained independently lifetime suicidal thoughts (Table 5). The models showed
associated with past-year suicidal thoughts. that the odds for suicidal thoughts approximately doubled
Table 3 shows that over three quarters of all of the 20- for each additional substance used. Results remained sig-
year-olds who fulfilled criteria for AUD during the past nificant also after adjustment for depression. An indepen-
year reported that they had had suicidal thoughts at some dent association between number of substances and sui-
point during lifetime. A three-fold increased risk for life- cide attempt could not be shown.
time suicidal thoughts was observed in young women with
AUD. The association was no longer significant, however,
DISCUSSION
after depression was taken into consideration. Neither
HED nor HAC was related to lifetime suicidal thoughts. Risk of lifetime suicidal thoughts was increased more than
Over two thirds of the women who had used cannabis dur- threefold and risk of lifetime suicide attempts more than
ing the past year reported suicidal thoughts at some point fourfold in 20-year-olds with AUD. Illicit drug use and
during lifetime, and past-year cannabis use was associated nonprescribed use of bensodiazepines and opiate drugs,
with lifetime suicidal thoughts even after depression was but neither AUD nor risky drinking, were associated
taken into consideration. Lifetime use of any illegal drug with suicidal thoughts after current depression was taken
was associated with lifetime suicidal thoughts, as was life- into account. Before results are discussed in detail, some
time use of cannabis and of benzodiazepines, but only the methodological considerations require attention.
1694 M. SUNDIN ET AL.

TABLE 3. Associations between different types of substance use and lifetime suicidal thoughts in 20-year-old women (N = 560)

Model 1a Model 2b

n (%)c OR (95% CI) LRCd (df) R2e OR (95% CI) LRCd (df) R2e

Past year
AUDf 58 (78.3) 3.4 (1.5–7.7) 24.64 (2) 0.0430 2.5 (<1.0–6.4) 107.18 (3) 0.1742
HEDg 119 (54.0) 1.0 (0.6–1.7) 1.44 (2) 0.0026 0.9 (0.5–1.6) 96.65 (3) 0.1585
HACh 53 (45.8) 0.8 (0.5–1.4) 3.09 (2) 0.0055 0.8 (0.4–1.4) 98.16 (3) 0.1608
Any illegal drug 74 (67.2) 2.2 (1.2–4.0) 20.28 (2) 0.0356 1.8 (<1.0–3.5) 106.32 (3) 0.1729
Cannabis 61 (68.6) 2.3 (1.2–4.3) 17.66 (2) 0.0310 2.0 (>1.0–4.0) 106.70 (3) 0.1735
Benzodiazepine 18 (74.8) 1.8 (0.6–5.5) 2.64 (2) 0.0047 1.7 (0.6–5.1) 97.00 (3) 0.1590
Opiates 33 (64.1) 2.1 (0.8–5.6) 8.84 (2) 0.0157 1.8 (0.6–5.5) 100.77 (3) 0.1647
Lifetimei
Any illegal drug 47 (68.1) 2.4 (1.2–4.7) 18.06 (2) 0.0318 2.1 (>1.0–4.4) 107.48 (3) 0.1749
Cannabis 41 (64.5) 2.1 (>1.0–4.4) 11.87 (2) 0.0210 1.8 (0.8–4.1) 102.40 (3) 0.1674
Benzodiazepines 17 (56.1) 3.1 (1.1–8.5) 13.77 (2) 0.0243 2.1 (0.6–6.9) 100.73 (3) 0.1649
Opiates 32 (55.7) 1.5 (0.7–3.1) 6.41 (2) 0.0114 1.3 (0.6–2.9) 98.62 (3) 0.1617
a
Model 1 adjusted for birth cohort.
b
Model 2 adjusted for birth cohort and depression.
c
Weighted percentages.
d
LRC = Model’s likelihood ratio chi-square.
R = Cox–Snell R2 for binary logistic models.
e 2
f
Alcohol use disorder.
g
Heavy episodic drinking.
h
High alcohol consumption.
i
Use of specified substance five times or more during lifetime.

A main strength of this study is its two-stage design. tify young women who fulfilled criteria for AUDs who
Participants are diagnostically well characterized on the had not yet been diagnosed within the health care system.
basis of structured face-to-face interviews carried out by One shortcoming is the cross-sectional nature of the data;
trained clinicians. This approach made it possible to iden- specific time points are lacking for substance exposure

TABLE 4. Associations between different types of substance use and lifetime suicide attempts in 20-year-old women (N = 560)

Model 1a Model 2b

n (%)c OR (95% CI) LRCd (df) R2e OR (95% CI) LRCd (df) R2e

Past year
AUDf 15 (25.3) 4.7 (1.7–13.1) 24.26 (2) 0.0426 3.2 (0.9–11.0) 56.68 (3) 0.0968
HEDg 20 (9.9) 0.7 (0.3–2.0) 2.30 (2) 0.0041 0.6 (0.2–1.7) 47.60 (3) 0.0819
HACh 10 (10.0) 1.3 (0.4–3.7) 1.58 (2) 0.0028 1.2 (0.4–3.9) 44.36 (3) 0.0766
Any illegal drug 12 (8.3) 1.0 (0.5–2.3) 0.91 (2) 0.0016 0.7 (0.3–1.7) 44.72 (3) 0.0771
Cannabis 8 (7.4) 0.9 (0.4–2.1) 1.00 (2) 0.0018 0.7 (0.3–1.7) 45.06 (3) 0.0777
Benzodiazepine 5 (15.0) 6.8 (2.1–22.7) 9.72 (2) 0.0173 6.9 (2.1–22.2) 52.35 (3) 0.0897
Opiates 3 (2.7) 0.4 (0.1–1.6) 3.61 (2) 0.0065 0.2 (0.1–1.3) 49.45 (3) 0.0849
Lifetimei
Any illegal drug 7 (8.2) 2.4 (0.8–6.9) 7.91 (2) 0.0141 1.9 (0.5–6.6) 47.62 (3) 0.0821
Cannabis 6 (8.8) 2.8 (0.9–8.4) 9.76 (2) 0.0174 2.2 (0.6–8.0) 49.12 (3) 0.0846
Benzodiazepines 7 (23.1) 2.1 (0.7–6.1) 3.48 (2) 0.0062 1.2 (0.4–3.8) 43.96 (3) 0.0760
Opiates 4 (6.3) 2.3 (0.8–6.6) 8.55 (2) 0.0153 1.9 (0.6–6.3) 48.30 (3) 0.0832
a
Model 1 adjusted for birth cohort.
b
Model 2 adjusted for birth cohort and depression.
c
Weighted percentages.
d
LRC = Model’s likelihood ratio chi-square.
R = Cox–Snell R2 for binary logistic models.
e 2
f
Alcohol use disorder.
g
Heavy episodic drinking.
h
High alcohol consumption.
i
Use of specified substance five times or more during lifetime.
SUBSTANCE USE AND SUICIDALITY IN YOUNG WOMEN 1695

TABLE 5. Associations between number of substances used during the past year, and suicidal thoughts and attempts in 20-year-old women
(N = 560). Unweighted numbers and weighted percentages

Suicidal thoughts (past year) Suicidal thoughts (lifetime) Suicide attempts (lifetime)

Number of substances n (%) n (%) n (%)

0 (n = 414) 55 (12.6) 181 (45.3) 22 (6.8)


1 (n = 91) 22 (18.2) 58 (62.7) 14 (15.0)
2 (n = 44) 15 (38.8) 33 (70.9) 4 (6.1)
≥3 (n = 11) 6 (54.6) 10 (90.9) 4 (36.4)
Model 1a
ORb (95% CI) 1.9 (1.3–2.6) 1.8 (1.3–2.6) 1.5 (>1.0–2.3)
LRCc (df) 60.65 (2) 38.16 (2) 8.54 (2)
R2d 0.1028 0.0659 0.0152
Model 2e
ORb (95% CI) 1.7 (1.2–2.4) 1.6 (1.1–2.3) 1.3 (0.8–2.0)
LRCc (df) 92.14 (3) 116.57 (3) 45.88 (3)
R2d 0.1520 0.1879 0.0791
a
Model 1 adjusted for birth cohort.
b
Odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) showing risk associated with each additional substance used during the past year (including
past-year alcohol use disorder).
c
Model’s likelihood ratio chi-square.
d
Cox–Snell R2 for binary logistic models.
e
Model 2 adjusted for birth cohort and depression.

and suicidal behavior. These phenomena may or may pointed out that these young women were born only five
not have coexisted simultaneously. MINI (Sheehan et al., years apart and resided in the same geographical area.
1998) does not distinguish between substance-induced Major differences in associations between substance use
and substance-independent depression. Conclusions variables and suicidal behavior would not be expected,
regarding causality cannot be drawn. Another limitation as there were no major societal changes during that short
is that alcohol abuse and dependence are combined into a period that would be expected to affect associations.
single category. This procedure, necessitated by the sam- Some analyses in the current study yielded large ORs
ple size, may affect results, as the literature suggests that but CIs were wide. Examples include the observations of
associations with suicidal behavior may differ in abuse nonsignificant trends despite robust point estimates when
and dependence (Wilcox, 2004). Another methodological the models for AUD and lifetime suicidal ideation and at-
consideration is that substance use categories also include tempts were adjusted for depression.
those with occasional substance misuse and those who
used prescription drugs in a nonprescribed manner. It is Findings
difficult to delineate the latter type of behavior from abuse, In the current study, one fifth of the 20-year-old women
especially in the context of a population-based study. with AUD reported past-year suicidal thoughts. The pro-
Some persons acquire prescriptions for benzodiazepines portion was strikingly similar to that previously observed
or opiates from several different doctors simultaneously in an older population sample of adult women aged 25–65
and others mix legally and illegally acquired substances. years residing in the same study area (Waern, Spak, &
Regarding diagnostics, the lack of information regarding Sundh, 2002). While the risk of lifetime suicidal thoughts
personality disorders is clearly a limitation. The identi- was increased more than threefold and the risk of lifetime
fication of women diagnosed with borderline personality suicide attempts more than fourfold in the 20-year-olds
disorder would be particularly relevant in this context, as with AUD, we could not show an independent associa-
both self-harm and substance use are included in criteria tion after adjustment for depression. This might in part be
for this disorder. However, personality disorder diagnos- attributed to low study power, or may reflect that the as-
tics were deemed to be beyond the scope of this study due sociation between AUD and suicidal ideation is mediated
to time constraints and difficulties in obtaining reliable via depression. It is possible that depressed young women
data in the context of a single interview with a nonclinical in the current study were more likely to remember and re-
sample. Another limitation is the sample size, which port lifetime suicidal ideation than those who were not de-
necessitated the merging of data from two birth cohorts pressed (Goldney, Winefield, Winefield, & Saebel, 2009),
of 20-year-old women. This approach is not optimal as and this might affect results.
proportions with suicidal ideation and attempts differed Our data do not support the hypothesized association
between the two cohorts. We therefore controlled for birth between risky alcohol consumption patterns and suicidal-
cohort in all regression analyses. Further, it should be ity. One reason for this might be related to the fact that
1696 M. SUNDIN ET AL.

intensive consumption has increased in Sweden with in- women who present with self-harm, even in those who do
creasing total consumption (CAN, 2007) and the defini- not appear depressed.
tions of HAC and HED employed here may actually de- The etiology of suicidal behavior is complex and mul-
fine drinking patterns within the norm rather than deviant tidetermined. Interactions among substance use, depres-
behaviors. As suggested by Rossow et al. (2005), the im- sion, personality disorders, and suicidal behavior are
pact of a specific substance on self-harm might be related demonstrated in psychiatric patients (Corbitt, Malone,
to how marginal or widespread its use is. Haas, & Mann, 1996). Larger studies would be neces-
Cannabis use was associated with a threefold risk sary to elucidate possible interactions in population-based
of past-year suicidal thoughts in these young women. samples. Recurrent self-destructive behaviors have ad-
The association was independent of depression. While dictive characteristics, and the relationship between sub-
it is difficult to make direct comparisons with studies stance use and suicidal behavior is probably bidirectional
employing other categories for frequency of substance (Goldston, 2004). It is possible that some individuals may
use, we note that Hallfors (2004) reported an almost nine- have a genetic predisposition toward both substance use
fold increase in risk for suicidal ideation in adolescent and suicidal behavior that is independent of depression.
boys and girls with frequent marijuana use, and Bovasso Behavioral disinhibition appears to be highly heritable
(2001) observed a five-fold risk associated with cannabis (Young, Stallings, Corley, & Krauter, 2000). Both genetic
abuse in adults. Borges and colleagues (2000) found that and early life experience impact on neurobiological mat-
marijuana use without abuse and dependence was asso- uration (Tarter, Kirisci, Reynolds, & Mezzich, 2004), and
ciated with a more than two-fold risk of suicide attempts neurobehavioral disinhibition has a direct effect on both
in 15- to 24-year-old men and women. A recent clinical substance use and suicidal behavior.
study showed that suicidal ideation and behavior were
common among adolescent and young adult patients Generalizability
with cannabis dependence (Arendt, Sher, Fjordback, The study was conducted in western and central Gothen-
Brandholt, & Munk-Jorgensen, 2007). However, not all burg, corresponding to the geographical area served by
studies point to an association between cannabis and Sahlgrenska University Hospital. The hospital delivers
suicidal behavior (Macleod et al., 2004), and a number both in- and outpatient specialized care to all persons liv-
of related factors need to be taken into consideration ing in the uptake area. Thus, study participants identi-
(Beautrais, Joyce, & Mulder, 1999). These include both fied with problematic alcohol use could be easily referred
precursors and consequences of substance use disorder for treatment. According to the Statistical Yearbook for
that are known to be associated with suicidal behavior, Gothenburg for the years 1996 and 2001–2002, rates of
including childhood factors, physical ill-health, comorbid morbidity and suicidal behavior in the study area were
psychiatric conditions, and interpersonal conflict and similar to those of the city at large, suggesting that results
separation. A larger sample size would be required to from our study can be generalized to the city of Gothen-
tease out the independent contributions of these variables. burg as a whole. Findings might not be representative
In the current study, nonprescription use of benzodi- for the country as a whole as rates of alcohol consump-
azepines was associated with increased risk of suicidal tion, illicit drug use (CAN, 2007), and attempted suicide
thoughts and attempts, and these associations were inde- (National Prevention of Suicide and Mental Ill-Health,
pendent of depression. Findings concerning suicide at- 2010) are higher in young women residing in urban ar-
tempts pointed in the same direction. Benzodiazepines eas. The study focuses on young adult women only and
might have disinhibiting effects similar to that of alco- results cannot be extrapolated to other age groups or to
hol (Gillet, Polard, Maudit, & Allain, 2001). Both short- males. The literature suggests gender differences regard-
(Gardner & Cowdry, 1985) and long-acting (Ben-Porath ing alcohol/suicide-related outcomes (Wilcox, 2004), and
& Taylor, 2002) benzodiazepines appear to be related the role of depression might be stronger in women than in
to aggressive behaviors, even in clinically relevant doses men in this age group (Kung et al., 2003).
(Berman, Jones, & McCloskey, 2005). There may be po- A stronger association between alcohol consumption
tential risks of prescribing benzodiazepines for depressed and suicide rates has been observed in countries where
patients (Youssef & Rich, 2008). drinking to intoxication is more common, just as there
The risk of suicidal ideation in these young women seems to be a stronger association between alcohol and
doubled for each additional intoxicant used. An associ- violence in these countries (Rossow, 2000). Concerning
ation was also observed between number of substances consumption of illegal drugs, our results cannot be di-
used and lifetime suicide attempt. A “dose–response” rectly extrapolated to other settings. Rates of illicit drug
relation between number of substances used and suici- use are relatively low in Sweden in comparison with other
dal behavior has been demonstrated in a general popu- western countries.
lation sample aged 15–54 years even in the absence of
abuse/dependence (Borges et al., 2000). In the current
study, we observed that the association between number Implications for Suicide Prevention
of substances and risk of suicidal ideation was indepen- A consultation-liaison psychiatrist in emergency medical
dent of depression, which underlines the importance of a services often meets young women who have attempted
thorough examination of substance use history in young suicide in connection with intake of alcohol, sleeping
SUBSTANCE USE AND SUICIDALITY IN YOUNG WOMEN 1697

pills (prescribed or not), analgesics, and/or illicit drugs. depresion fuera incluida en el modelo. Limitaciones e im-
Our results underline the need for new strategies to re- plicaciones del estudio relacionadas con la prevención del
duce suicidal behavior in young women problematic use suicidio son discutidas. El estudio fue financiado por el
of illicit drugs and nonprescription use of sedatives and Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones y por el Consejo de
analgesics. Social connectedness, confidence in problem- Investigaciones sobre Alcohol en Suecia.
solving, and an internal locus of control constitute protec-
tive factors1 for serious suicide attempts in young adults
(Donald, Dower, Correa-Velez, & Jones, 2006). Examples RESUMEN
of promising treatments include dialectic behavioral ther-
apy (Linehan et al., 1999), cognitive behavioral treatment L’usage de drogues et de comportements suicidaires
(Esposito-Smythers, Spirito, Uth, & Lachance, 2006), and chez les jeunes femmes adultes: Une étude de
motivational interviewing, which can be applied both for population
substance use (Miller & Rollnick, 1991) and suicidal be- Le lien entre les variables de substances consommées
havior (Britton, Williams, & Conner, 2008). The latter et les comportements suicidaires a été analysé dans un
treatment approach is well suited to the primary care set- échantillon de population urbaine provenant de l’étude
ting. General practitioners must be prepared to talk about sur les femmes et l’alcooleffectuée à Göteborg (Suède).
substance use and suicidality with their young patients, Lors de la Phase I, des femmes de 20 ans (n = 2,069)
and also in the absence of a diagnosis of substance use ont rempli un questionnaire de filtrage. Des entretiens ont
disorder. Training programs can provide strategies for the été effectués avec un échantillon stratifié (n = 560). Les
identification and treatment of substance use disorders and données collectées en 1995 et en 2000 ont été analysées
can increase awareness of the need for assessments of avec une régression logistique permettant de générer
suicidal ideation and past history of attempts, which can des ratios inattendus. Après un ajustement correspon-
signal future risk of suicidal behavior. Primary preven- dant aux dépressions courantes, c’est la consommation de
tive techniques such as interventions designed to limit the stupéfiants qui est associée aux pensées suicidaires, et non
availability of substances are also called for. la consommation d’alcool à risque. Les limites d’étude
et les implications dans la prévention des suicides y sont
Declaration of Interest commentées. Cette étude est financée par le Conseil na-
The authors report no conflicts of interest. The authors tional suédois pour la recherche scientifique et le Conseil
alone are responsible for the content and writing of the suédois de recherche sur l’alcoolisme.
article.

THE AUTHORS
RÉSUMÉ
Maud Sundin, MD, is a Senior
Uso de drogas y conductas suicidas en mujeres jóvenes Consultant in psychiatry at
adultas: Un estudio poblacional the Substance Use Clinic at
Sahlgrenska University Hospital
La asociación entre el uso de drogas y conductas suici- in Gothenburg. Her areas of
das fueron analizadas en una muestra poblacional del es- interest include substance use
tudio Mujeres y Alcohol en Gotemburgo, Suecia. En la disorders, liaison psychiatry,
fase I, mujeres de 20 años de edad (n = 2,069) comple- personality disorders, and
taron una encuesta de sondeo. Posteriormente, se procedió suicidal behavior.
a entrevistar una muestra estratificada (n = 560). Los odd
ratios fueron calculados usando regresión logı́stica de la
información, recolectada entre 1995 y 2000. El consumo
de drogas, pero no el consumo de riesgo de alcohol, fue
asociado con tendencias suicidas aún después de que la Fredrik Spak, MD, Ph.D.,
is an Associate Professor at
1
The reader is reminded that the concept of “risk” and “protective” the unit of Social Medicine
factors is often noted in the literature without adequately noting their at the Sahlgrenska Academy,
dimensions (linear, nonlinear), their “demands,” the critical necessary University of Gothenburg.
conditions (endogenously as well as exogenously, from a micro to a His research interests include
macro level), which are necessary for either of these posited processes the epidemiology of alcohol
to operate (begin, continue, become anchored and integrate, change as use disorders, with a special
de facto realities change, cease, etc.) or not to, and whether their under-
focus on women, and the
pinnings are theory driven; empirically based; individual and/or sys-
temic stake holder bound; based upon “principles of faith”; historical
implementation of secondary
observation, precedents, and traditions that accumulate over time; per- prevention programs. He is a
ceptual and judgmental constraints; “transient public opinion”; or what. Senior Consultant in psychiatry
This is necessary to clarify whether these terms are not to remain as yet and social medicine and is
additional shibboleths in a field of many stereotypes. Editor’s note. involved in prevention programs in primary care.
1698 M. SUNDIN ET AL.

Lena Spak, MD, Ph.D., Beautrais, A. L. (2003). Suicide and serious suicide attempts in
is a Child and Adolescent youth: A multiple group comparison study. American Journal
Psychiatrist at Queen Silvia of Psychiatry, 160, 1093–1099.
Children’s Hospital in Beautrais, A. L., Joyce, P. R., & Mulder, R. T. (1999). Cannabis
Gothenburg, and a Guest abuse and serious suicide attempts. Addiction, 94, 1155–1164.
Teacher and Researcher at Ben-Porath, D. D., & Taylor, S. P. (2002). The effects of diazepam
the unit of Social Medicine (valium) and aggressive disposition on human aggression: An
at the Sahlgrenska Academy, experimental investigation. Addictive Behaviour, 27, 167–177.
University of Gothenburg. Her Berman, M. E., Jones, G. D., & McCloskey, M. S. (2005). The
research focus is on women effects of diazepam on human self-aggressive behaviour. Psy-
and alcohol, and especially on chopharmacology, 178, 100–106.
the association between early Borges, G., Walters, E. E., & Kessler, R. (2000). Associations of
background factors and later substance use, abuse and dependence with subsequent suicidal
alcohol abuse and dependence among women. behavior. American Journal of Epidemiology, 151, 781–789.
Bovasso, G. B. (2001). Cannabis abuse as a risk factor for depressive
symptoms. American Journal of Psychiatry, 158, 2033–2037.
Valter Sundh, M.Sc., is a Senior Britton, P. C., Williams, G. C., & Conner, K. R. (2008). Self-
Biostatistician at the Department determination theory, motivational interviewing and the treat-
of Social Medicine and Public ment of clients with acute suicidal ideation. Journal of Clinical
Health at Sahlgrenska Academy, Psychology, 64, 52–66.
University of Gothenburg, with a CAN (The Swedish Council for Information on Alcohol and
special emphasis on longitudinal Drugs). (2007). Development of drug use in Sweden 2007 (Re-
population studies. port No. 105). Stockholm: Author. pp. 17, 23, 24, 62, 68–70,
110, 113.
Corbitt, E., Malone, K., Haas, G. L., & Mann, J. J. (1996). Suicidal
behavior in patients with major depression and comorbid per-
sonality disorders. Journal of Affective Disorders, 39, 61–72.
Donald, M., Dower, J., Correa-Velez, I., & Jones, M. (2006). Risk
and protective factors for medically serious suicide attempts: A
Margda Waern, MD, Ph.D., comparison of hospital-based with population-based samples of
is a Professor of psychiatry young adults. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychia-
at the Section for Psychiatry try, 40, 87–96.
and Neurochemistry at the Esposito-Smythers, C., Spirito, A., Uth, R., & Lachance, H. (2006).
Sahlgrenska Academy, Cognitive behavioral treatment for suicidal alcohol abusing ado-
University of Gothenburg. Her lescents: Development and pilot testing. American Journal on
research focus is on suicidology. Addiction, 15(Suppl. 1), 126–130.
She is also a senior consultant Ewing, J. A. (1984). Detecting alcoholism: The CAGE ques-
in psychiatry at Sahlgrenska tionnaire. Journal of the American Medical Association, 252,
University Hospital. 1905–1907.
Gardner, D. L., & Cowdry, R. W. (1985). Alprazolam-induced
dyscontrol in borderline personality disorder. American Journal
of Psychiatry, 142, 98–100.
Gillet, C., Polard, E., Maudit, N., & Allain, H. (2001). Acting out
GLOSSARY psychoactive substances: Alcohol, drugs, illicit substances. En-
Alcohol use disorder (AUD): It comprises the diagnosis cephale, 27, 351–359.
Alcohol Dependence and Alcohol Abuse according to Goldney, R. D., Winefield, A. H., Winefield, H. R., & Saebel, J.
(2009). The benefit of forgetting suicidal ideation. Suicide and
the DSM-IV definitions.
Life-Threatening Behavior, 39, 33–37.
HAC: It is defined as the average weekly alcohol intake Goldston, D. B. (2004). Conceptual issues in understanding the re-
exceeding 20 glasses per day. The frequency was mea- lationship between suicidal behaviour and substance use dur-
sured over the last 30 days. ing adolescence. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 76(Suppl.),
HED: It is defined as an alcohol intake at “one occasion” S79–S91.
of at least five glasses containing 12 glasses of ethanol Hallfors, D. D. (2004). Adolescent depression and suicide risk: As-
in one day. Frequency was measured over the last sociation with sex and drug behaviour. American Journal of Pre-
12 months. ventive Medicine, 27, 224–231.
Hawton, K., & Harris, L. (2007). Deliberate self-harm in young peo-
ple: Characteristics and subsequent mortality in 20-year cohort
of patients presenting to hospital. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry,
REFERENCES
68, 1574–1583.
Arendt, M., Sher, L., Fjordback, L., Brandholt, J., & Munk- Karolinska Institute’s Public Health Academy. (2009). Attempted
Jorgensen, P. (2007). Parental alcoholism predicts suicidal be- suicide in Stockholm County and in Sweden 1987–2007. Stock-
havior in adolescents and young adults with cannabis depen- holm: Public Health Academy, Karolinska Institute.
dence. International Journal of Adolescent Med Health, 19, Kung, H.-C., Pearsson, J., & Liu, X. (2003). Risk factors for male
67–77. and female suicide decedents ages 15–64 in the United States:
SUBSTANCE USE AND SUICIDALITY IN YOUNG WOMEN 1699

Results from the 1993 National Mortality Followback Survey. Spak, F., & Hällström, T. (1996). Screening for alcohol dependence
Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 38, 419–426. and abuse in women: Description, validation and psychometric
Linehan, M., Schmidt, H., Dimeff, L., Craft, Ch., Kanter, J., & Com- properties of a new screening instrument, SWAG, in a popula-
tois, K. (1999). Dialectical behavior therapy for patients with tion study. Alcoholism Clinical and Experimental Research, 20,
borderline personality disorder and drug dependence. American 723–732.
Journal on Addictions, 8, 279–292. Tarter, R. E., Kirisci, L., Reynolds, M., & Mezzich, A. (2004). Neu-
Macleod, J., Oakes, R., Copello, A., Crome, I., Egger, M., Hickman, robehavior disinhibition in childhood predicts suicide potential
M., et al. (2004). Psychological and social sequelae of cannabis and substance use disorder by young adulthood. Drug and Al-
and other illicit drug use by young people: A systematic re- cohol Dependence, 76(Suppl.), S45–S52.
view of longitudinal, general population studies. Lancet, 363, Värnik, A., Kölves, K., Allik, J., Arensman, E., Aroma, E., Van Au-
1579–1588. denhove, C., et al. (2009). Gender issues in suicide rates, trends
Mann, R. E., Zalcman, R. F., Smart, R. G., Rush, B. R, & Suurvali, and methods among youths aged 15–24 in 15 European coun-
H. (2006). Alcohol consumption, alcoholics anonymous mem- tries. Journal of Affective Disorders, 113, 216–226.
bership, and suicide rates, Ontario 1968–1991. Journal of Stud- Waern, M., Spak, F., & Sundh, V. (2002). Suicidal ideation in a fe-
ies on Alcohol, 6, 445–453. male population sample. European Archives of Psychiatry and
Meehan, P. J., Lamb, J. A., Salzman, L. E., & O’Carrol, P. W. Clinical Neuroscience, 252, 81–85.
(1992). Attempted suicide among young adults: Progress toward Wilcox, H. (2004). Epidemiological evidence on the link between
a meaningful estimate of prevalence. American Journal of Psy- drug use and suicidal behaviours among adolescents. Canadian
chiatry, 149, 41–44. Child and Adolescent Review, 13, 27–30.
Miller, W., & Rollnick, S. (1991). Motivational interviewing. Lon- Wilcox, H., Conner, K., & Caine, E. D. (2004). Association of al-
don: Guilford Press. cohol and drug use disorders and completed suicide: An empir-
National Prevention of Suicide and Mental Ill-Health. ical review of cohort studies. Drug and Alcohol Dependence,
(2010). Suicide statistics. Retrieved May 3, 2010, from 76(Suppl.), S11–S19.
http://ki.se/ki/jsp/polopoly.jsp?d=37160&l=en Young, S. E., Stallings, M. C., Corley, R. P., Krauter, K. S., & He-
Office of Applied Studies, Substance Abuse and Mental Health witt, J. H. (2000). Genetic and environmental influences on be-
Services Administration. (2009). The NSDUH report: Suicidal havioural disinhibition. American Journal of Medical Genetics,
thoughts and behaviors among adults. Rockville, MD: Author. 96, 684–695.
Research Triangle Institute. (1997). SUDAAN user’s manual. Re- Youssef, N. A., & Rich, C. L. (2008). Does acute treatment with
search Triangle Park, NC: Research Triangle Institute. sedatives/hypnotics for anxiety in depressed patients affect sui-
Robins, L. N., Cottler, L. B., & Babor, T. F. (1986). The cide risk? A literature review. Annals of Clinical Psychiatry, 20,
WHO/ADA/ADAMHA CIDI-SAM interview (revised 1987). St. 157–169.
Louis, MO.
Rossow, I. (2000). Suicide, violence and child abuse: A review of
APPENDIX
the impact of alcohol consumption on social problems. Contem-
porary Drug Problems, 27, 397–433. Use/abuse of illicit drug was defined in our 1995 in-
Rossow, I., Groholt, B., & Wichstrom, L. (2005). Intoxicants and terview as intake of marijuana/cannabis, cocaine, am-
suicidal behaviour among adolescents: Changes in levels and as- phetamine, khat, other stimulants, heroin, LSD, ecstasy,
sociations from 1992 to 2002. Addiction, 100, 79–88. other psychedelic drugs and/or inhalants. In 2000 this def-
Sheehan, D. V., Lecrubier, Y., Sheehan, K. H., Amorim, P., Janavs, inition was extended to GHB and/or anabolic steroids at
J., Weiller, E., et al. (1998). The Mini-International Neuropsy-
least once during the last year. Barbiturates and inhalants
chiatric Interview (M.I.N.I.): The development and validation of
were omitted as specified alternatives but could be added
a structured diagnostic psychiatric interview for DSM-IV and
ICD-10. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 59(Suppl. 20), 22–33. and specified under the heading “other drugs”. Use/abuse
Sher, L. (2006). Alcoholism and suicidal behaviour: A clinical of cannabis was intake of any cannabinoid preparation
overview. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 113, 13–22. and use/abuse of benzodiazepines, intake of benzodi-
Spak, F., & Hällström, T. (1995). Prevalence of female alcohol de- azepines and/or related drugs, zopiclone and zolpidem and
pendence and abuse in Sweden. Addiction, 90, 1077–1088. use/abuse of opiates, intake of opiates.
Copyright of Substance Use & Misuse is the property of Taylor & Francis Ltd and its content may not be copied
or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission.
However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.

You might also like