Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Machinability of Powder Metallurgy Steels Using PCBN Inserts
Machinability of Powder Metallurgy Steels Using PCBN Inserts
com
ScienceDirect
Procedia CIRP 14 (2014) 83 – 88
Abstract
Primary manufacturing of steels by powder metallurgy (PM) is of increasing interest for a wide range of industrial applications. Especially in
automotive parts and tools, PM materials are utilized, as they show advantageous behavior regarding chemical, mechanical and functional
properties as well as resource efficiency. Consequently, machining of these materials is an emerging topic for both, industry and science. This
paper addresses the machinability of PM steels. Two PM high speed steels (HSS) were characterized and machined varying the machining
parameters and edge preparation (PcBN inserts) in longitudinal and orthogonal hard turning. Furthermore, the influence of manganese sulfides
(MnS) in the PM material was analyzed by comparing experiments applying alloys with defined content of MnS. Besides tool life and
achievable surface roughness, the surface integrity was assessed. The results reveal that the amount and shape of carbides as well as the
porosity of the PM steels play an important role in the wear mechanism when machining this kind of materials. As expected, addition of MnS
leads to a decrease of cutting forces and allows for significantly higher tool life. The influence of machining parameters and the tool edge
geometry is discussed. Based on the results, suitable cutting conditions for machining of PM steels can be derived.
© 2014
© 2014 The Authors.
Published byPublished by Elsevier
Elsevier B.V. B.V. under CC BY-NC-ND license.
Open access
Selection and
Selection andpeer-review
peer-reviewunder
underresponsibility of of
responsibility thethe
International Scientific
International Committee
Scientific of theof6th
Committee theCIRP International
6th CIRP Conference
International on High
Conference
Performance
on Cutting. Cutting
High Performance
2212-8271 © 2014 Published by Elsevier B.V. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the International Scientific Committee of the 6th CIRP International Conference
on High Performance Cutting
doi:10.1016/j.procir.2014.03.094
84 Rachid M’Saoubi et al. / Procedia CIRP 14 (2014) 83 – 88
Hence, the main focus of the investigations presented in 3. Results and Discussion
this paper is to analyze the effects of defined variations of the
materials composition on the machinability and the surface 3.1. Longitudinal Turning
integrity.
The results of the tool wear test in longitudinal turning
2. Experimental Setup (Fig. 1) indicate higher tool life when cutting the workpiece
material M2 compared to OB1 independently from the
Two different PM high speed steels were pressed, sintered, content of MnS.
and subsequently analyzed regarding their chemical 200
composition (Table 1). Additionally, samples made of the M2+MnS
same materials with 1 wt% of manganese sulfide (MnS) 100
additive were sintered to allow for investigation of the effects
of the content of sulfides on machinability. The geometry of
40 OB1+MnS
Composition in wt%
2
Material C Mn Si Cr V W Mo Insert: S10-01030
M2 0.83 0.27 0.32 3.13 1.97 5.12 5.00 1
100 150 200 250 300
OB1 1.50 - 0.50 16.00 1.00 1.50 1.50 Cutting speed vc in m/min
Fig. 1: Tool wear test with insert S10-01030 (chamfer angle Jf = 30°, edge
Machining experiments with varied edge preparation of radius rE = 10 μm)
PcBN inserts and cutting parameters have been performed in
longitudinal (vc = 150, 200, 250 m/min; f = 0.1 mm/rev and Independent from the tool geometry, higher wear rates
ap = 0.1 mm) and orthogonal (vc = 150, 200, 250 m/min; were caused by the OB1 material as shown in Fig. 2
f = 0.050, 0.075, 0.100 mm/rev and ap = 1.75 mm) hard comparing typical SEM views of the worn cutting edges of
turning using a Swedturn 300 CNC lathe. For both processes, identical inserts (chamfer angle Jf = 15°, edge radius rE = 10
the cutting tools consisted of PcBN Seco grade CBN200. The μm) after 25 m path length. The figure also indicates a built-
effect of the tool geometry was considered to reveal the wear up-edge generated in the cutting experiments using OB1 as a
mechanisms and to identify the decisive factors allowing for workpiece material.
high performance cutting of PM steels. Tool geometry was
varied regarding the chamfer angle (Jf = 15, 20, 30°) and edge Insert: S10-01015 Insert: S10-01015
radius (rE = 10, 25, 40 μm). All experiments were run under Material: M2 Material: OB1
Distinct crater and flank wear patterns were observed for as shown in Fig. 4 and summarized in Table 4. The results
all inserts. The formation of a distinct layer of MnS on top of clearly indicate that the best surface finish can be achieved
the crater of the inserts was observed when machining the PM using M2 and OB1+MnS workmaterials, whereas the worst
variants containing MnS additives. On the other hand, the surface finish is measured using OB1. The content of MnS
presence of fine grooves, typical of abrasive wear on the seems to have a slightly negative effect on surface finish for
flank, and adhesion of the work material were observed on the M2. In contrast, manganese sulfides in OB1 appear to
inserts machining the standard PM variants. improve the surface roughness.
Insert: S10-01030 Insert: S10-01030
Material: M2 Material: OB1
vc = 250 m/min vc = 250 m/min
Built-up edge
Fig. 4: Machined surface of M2 - measured with Alicona
50 µm 50 µm
Table 4: Surface finish of all materials cut by S10-01030 (chamfer angle
Insert: S10-01030 Insert: S10-01030
Jf = 30°, edge radius rE = 10 μm) at different speeds
Material: M2+MnS Material: OB1+MnS M2 OB1 M2+MnS OB1+MnS
vc = 250 m/min vc = 250 m/min
vc
[m/min] 150 250 150 250 150 250 150 250
M2+MnS 10875 20.1 2.9*10-³ 271873 2.5*109 Insert: S25-01020 Insert: S25-01020
Material: M2+MnS Material: OB1+MnS
OB1+MnS 8700 50.8 9.6*10-³ 677602 7.8*109 vc = 200 m/min vc = 200 m/min
Table 3: Crater wear analysis at vc = 250 m/min, chamfer angle Jf = 30°,
edge radius rE = 10 μm
Material Path length Crater Crater Crater Volume 5 µm 5 µm
lc [m] depth ratio volume ratio V’
KT KT’ V [μm3] [μm³/m³]
[μm] [μm/m] Fig. 5: Machined surface of a) M2, b) OB1, c) M2 MnS, and b) OB1 MnS
(chamfer angle Jf = 20°, edge radius rE = 25 μm)
M2 3625 44.6 12.3*10 ³ -
488108 13.5*10 9
OB1 1450 41.6 28.7*10-³ 478849 33.0*109 A further investigation of the longitudinal cross section of
M2+MnS 18126 67.0 3.7*10 ³ -
995374 5.5*109 the machined surfaces in Fig. 6 demonstrates that in contrast
OB1+MnS 5075 48.6 9.6*10-³ 649638 12.8*109 to OB1, cracks in M2 are observed in the subsurface but do
not emerge from the surface of the deformed top layer.
The forces in longitudinal turning decrease due to the
The corresponding surface topography resulting from the
presence of MnS in the microstructure. Fig. 7 and Fig. 8 show
cutting experiments with varied cutting speeds was measured
86 Rachid M’Saoubi et al. / Procedia CIRP 14 (2014) 83 – 88
the results from the thrust and feed force measurement at process. Similar results were observed for different tool
cutting speed vc = 200 m/min and tool geometry (chamfer geometries. This may be due to the chosen finishing
angle Jf = 20°, edge radius rE = 25 μm). parameters of a cutting depth of ap = 0.1 mm and a feed rate
of f = 0.1 mm/rev. Higher cutting speeds reduce the thrust
forces when cutting materials without additional MnS.
Insert: S25-01020
Insert: S25-01020
3.2. Orthogonal Turning
Material: M2
Material: OB1
vc = 200 m/min
vc = 200 m/min
Orthogonal turning experiments were performed to assess
the influence of feed rate on the cutting forces (Fig. 9 and
Fig. 10). The specific cutting force kc was calculated for all
5 µm 5 µm four materials at three different speeds.
Insert: S25-01020 The highest cutting and feed forces are measured when
Insert: S25-01020
Material: OB1+MnS
vc = 200 m/min
machining M2 work material. Moreover, the forces decrease
Material: M2+MnS if MnS is added to the PM steels. For the presence of
vc = 200 m/min
manganese sulfides, the forces decrease more intensively in
MnS
M2.
500
Insert: S10 standard deviation from five measurements
5 µm 5 µm 450 vc = 150 m/min
Fig. 6: a) M2, b) OB1, c) M2+MnS, and d) OB1 MnS cross-sections
(chamfer angle Jf = 20°, edge radius rE = 25 μm) 400
Feed force Ff in N
350
300 OB1
M2
standard deviation from five measurements
300
250
Insert: S25-01020 250
vc = 200 m/min
Thrust Force Fr in N
200 200
OB1+MnS
M2+MnS
150
150 0,04
0.04 0,05
0.05 0,06
0.06 0,07
0.07 0,08
0.08 0,09
0.09 0,1
0.10 0,11
0.11
M2+MnS OB1+MnS
Feed rate f in mm/rev
100 M2 OB1 Fig. 9: Feed forces at vc = 150 m/min (chamfer angle Jf = 10°)
500
standard deviation from five measurements
50 Insert: S10
450 vc = 150 m/min
M2
Cutting force Fc in N
0 400
new worn
350
Fig. 7: Measured thrust forces on new and worn tools vc = 200 m/min
(chamfer angle Jf = 20°, edge radius rE = 25 μm) 300
M2+MnS
OB1+MnS
250
300 OB1
200
standard deviation from five measurements
250 150
Insert: S25-01020 0,04
0.04 0,05
0.05 0,06
0.06 0,07
0.07 0,08
0.08 0,09
0.09 0,10
0.10 0,11
0.11
Feed Force Fa in N
by the prevention of adhesion rather than by a reduction of Temperature measurements were performed by thermal
friction at the tool-chip contact. imaging to analyze the thermal loads during hard turning of
OB1
M2+MnS standard deviation from five measurements PM steels with varied chemical composition. Fig. 14 shows
OB1+MnS
the temperatures in the contact zone for orthogonal turning at
M2
0,40
0.40 vc = 200 m/min. The PcBN-inserts are exposed to high
Insert: S10
0.35
0,35 vc = 150 m/min temperatures up to 860°C. The highest maximum
temperatures (mean value of 30 thermal images) occur in
Friction coefficient µ
0.30
0,30
0.25 cutting experiments using M2 workpiece material
0,25
0.20 (TM2 = 860±6°C). For OB1, the temperature is slightly lower
0,20
0.15
(TOB1 = 800±10°C). This result is in good accordance to the
0,15 specific cutting forces: the highest specific cutting forces are
0.10
0,10
obtained on M2, which leads to higher cutting temperatures.
0.05
The presence of manganese sulfides has a remarkable effect
0,05
0.00
on the cutting temperatures. For M2, the addition of MnS
0,00
0,05 0,075 0,1
leads to a decrease of the maximum temperature to
0.050 0.075 0.100
Feed rate f in mm/rev TM2+MnS = 750±5 °C. In OB1 with higher amounts of MnS, the
maximum temperature is decreased by 15°C to
Fig. 11: Calculated friction coefficients at vc = 150 m/min TOB1+MnS = 785±9°C. As for the tool wear (see Fig. 1), the
(chamfer angle Jf = 10°) effect of adding manganese sulfides to the material is more
pronounced in M2 than in OB1.
The analysis of the specific cutting forces (Fig. 12) reveals
500
525
5
0
500
5
5 900
52
550
500
625 650 5
0
52
M2 OB1
675
550
the highest values for the PM steels without an additional
500
50
52
625
650
5
5 500 500
500
52
600
55 5
5
6575
6062
500
67
6
0 75
500
550
55
525
0
0 5
50
600
550
575
525
amount of MnS. A decrease of kc is apparently achieved by
575
675
0 50
0
700
72 550 525 0 5
5 550 0 0
575
550 52 850
5
50
525
575
the presence of manganese sulfides. This effect is independent
70
700 725
75 52
550
0
50
625650
0
0 60 55
625
550 5 0
650
667
0 0
600
550 7
600 57
500
575
52
5
77
52
5
62 25
72 70 65 5
700675
from the applied cutting speed, as in Fig. 13 similar
575
5
5 0 0
75 67 625 0 52
80 500
725750
55
0
550
77 0 52 5
0
0
57 50
60
65 5
70
575
5
75 0 5 0
800
775
80
55
5
575
60
625
82 67
0
0 727
0
52
700 5 625
500
550
55
62
57
625
5
5
600
Surface temperature in °C
650
0
5
85
800
5
65
500
0
decrease with higher cutting speeds.
600
500 500
575
75
650
55
725
700
0
6775
5
62
650
60
575
52
75
775
625
0
675 72575
0
67
725
55
575
675
600
5
825
700
750
65
625
5
77
780
77
52
0
600
0
0
57
50 0
67
600
55
550
500
5
5
5
625
72
575
5
62 7550 650 700 550525
4000 5 650 7050 67 525
600
0 500 5
65
57
5 600 6205 575 5552
60 5 500 72650 625 575 550 5
0
550 525
55 675 600 575 5
700 500
500
0 575 52 500
Insert: S10 550 525 625
Specific cutting force kc in N/mm²
0
550 5
00
55
55
5
700
vc = 150 m/min
0
500
0
575
25
25
50 525 600
525
675
650
500
700
625
675
M2+MnS OB1+MnS
575
675
OB1 M2
500
600
575650 625
575
700
0
625
70
500
600
650
725
675
550
50
5
525
500
700 675
0
57
675
650
600
575
0
50
75
575
550
50
600
575
575
52
0
50 750
600
52
3000
5
625
0
725
600
5
650
750
650
550
575
725 675 70
625
50
50
775 800
700 675
0
600
52
775
600
625
750
650
500
700
52
5
OB1+MnS
57
55
575
5
5
725
55
0
600 650
50
500
0
625
0
0
550
7275
52
57
600
550
57
5
575
750
60
5
50
0
625
675
7 0 52 500 0 52
0
55
65 00 60 5 5 5 500
5
0 500
0 5 550 525
M2+MnS 625 50 65062 500
57
57
55 600 00
5
500 5
5
0 60
500
5
525
0
57
500
25
5
0
2000
0,04
0.04 0,08
0.08 0,12
0.12
Fig. 14: Thermal measurement PM-PcBN at vc = 200 m/min
Feed rate f in mm/rev
Fig. 12: Specific cutting force at vc = 150 m/min (chamfer angle Jf = 10°) 4. Summary and Outlook
vc = 200 m/min
inserts have been investigated to analyze the machinability of
OB1 PM steels. The results confirm that the addition of MnS
M2
additives in the PM steels consistently improves tool life of
the PcBN inserts and have positive effects on the mechanical
3000
and thermal loads during the cutting process. However, the
addition of higher amounts of MnS inclusions affects the
M2+MnS
process differently in M2 and OB1. A higher increase of tool
life is observed for PcBN inserts cutting M2+MnS compared
OB1+MnS
to OB1+MnS.
2000 Differences in the microstructure clearly affect the wear
0.04
0,04 0.08
0,08
Feed rate f in mm/rev
0.12
0,12
rate in cutting of PM steels. M2 consists of small and fine
dispersed carbides and shows less porosity. High abrasive
Fig. 13: Specific cutting force at vc = 200 m/min (chamfer angle Jf = 10°) wear rates when cutting OB1 as a workpiece material are
mainly caused by big and hard chromium carbides, a higher
88 Rachid M’Saoubi et al. / Procedia CIRP 14 (2014) 83 – 88