Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Treatise On Northern Ireland Volume 1 Colonialism Brendan Oleary Full Chapter
A Treatise On Northern Ireland Volume 1 Colonialism Brendan Oleary Full Chapter
A Treatise on
Northern Ireland
Volume 1: Colonialism
B R E N D A N O ’ LEARY
1
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
3
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford, OX2 6DP,
United Kingdom
Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford.
It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship,
and education by publishing worldwide. Oxford is a registered trade mark of
Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries
© Brendan O’Leary 2019
The moral rights of the author have been asserted
First Edition published in 2019
Impression: 1
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in
a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the
prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted
by law, by licence or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics
rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the
above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the
address above
You must not circulate this work in any other form
and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer
Published in the United States of America by Oxford University Press
198 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, United States of America
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
Data available
Library of Congress Control Number: 2018966372
ISBN 978–0–19–924334–1
Printed and bound in Great Britain by
Clays Ltd, Elcograf S.p.A.
Links to third party websites are provided by Oxford in good faith and
for information only. Oxford disclaims any responsibility for the materials
contained in any third party website referenced in this work.
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
To Lori Salem
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
Contents: Volume 1
List of Figures xi
List of Maps xiii
List of Tables xv
List of Boxes xvii
Abbreviations and Glossary xix
Terminology xxix
Introduction 1
National and Ethnic Conflict and the Daily Recognition of Identities 9
History and Northern Ireland 17
Plan of the Volumes 21
Concepts and Methods 23
1.1. An Audit of Violence after 1966 27
The Spatial Distribution of Political Death 30
The Comparative Scale of the Conflict: “Troubles” or “War”? 37
The Combatants and their Victims 47
The Combatants: Republicans, Loyalists, and UK Security Forces 52
Forms of Killing 74
Trends in Deaths 1969–1990 versus 1991–2012 75
Victims and Responsibilities for Deaths 82
Injuries, Explosions, Shootings, Robberies, Intimidation, Incarcerations,
and Dirty War 90
Among Other Costs 97
Appendix 1.1.1: Different DataBases on Killings in Northern Ireland 103
1.2. Conceptual Conspectus: Colonialism 106
Definitions and Applications 108
Purposes and Types 118
Godly Matters 121
Internal Colonialism 123
The Dependent Kingdom Thesis: A False Alternative 125
Ruling Indirectly to Contain Nationalism 126
A Normal Ancien Régime? 127
The Union without Union 133
Marxism and Colonialism in Ireland 136
“Postcolonialists” and Colonialism 138
Bonn and Composite Colonialism in Ireland 139
On the Alternative 141
The Persistence and Vicissitudes of Settler Colonial Ideologies in Ulster 142
What was Wrong with Colonialism and how it was Remedied 144
1.3. Wild and Bitter Fruits and Royal Pains: Colonial Triangles
and Trilemmas, 1603–1800 146
Slow and Incomplete Penetration 149
Planting Ulster 156
The Rising of 1641 and the Catholic Confederacy 172
The Confederation of Kilkenny 178
Cromwell’s Moment and its Aftermath 181
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
Acknowledgments 397
Notes 403
Bibliography 435
Index of Names 483
General Index 497
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
VOLUME 1: COLONIALISM
THE SHACKLES OF THE STATE AND
HEREDITARY ANIMOSITIES
List of Figures xi
List of Maps xiii
List of Tables xv
List of Boxes xvii
Abbreviations and Glossary xix
Terminology xxix
Introduction 1
1.1. An Audit of Violence after 1966 27
1.2. Conceptual Conspectus: Colonialism 106
1.3. Wild and Bitter Fruits and Royal Pains: Colonial
Triangles and Trilemmas, 1603–1800 146
1.4. Overlooked by the Tall Kingdom before Dying of Political
Economy: Ireland under the Union, 1801–1857 217
1.5. Crying Aloud for Vengeance and the Power of a Colonial Caste:
Toward Union’s End, 1858–1914 263
1.6. “ ’Twas better to die ’neath an Irish sky, than at Suvla, or
Sud-El-Bar”: Revolution and Counter-Revolution, 1914–1922 311
1.7. Scratches across the Heart: Comparing Ireland’s Partition 370
Acknowledgments 397
Notes 403
Bibliography 435
Index of Names 483
General Index 497
VOLUME 2: CONTROL
THE SECOND PROTESTANT ASCENDANCY
AND THE IRISH STATE
Acknowledgments 197
Notes 203
Bibliography 219
Index of Names 239
General Index 246
Notes 365
Acknowledgments 391
Bibliography 397
Index of Names 429
General Index 439
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
List of Figures
1.1.1. Places people were killed in the region, the Isles and the EU, 1969–2001 30
1.1.2. The distribution of killings in Belfast, 1966–2003 31
1.1.3. Two-way plot of killings (1969–2001) by parliamentary constituencies
as of 1997, and percentage of constituency voting for nationalist parties
in the Westminster elections of 2001 33
1.1.4. The first war: The triangle of ethno-national combat, 1969–1989 48
1.1.5. The second war: The killing of civilians, 1969–1989 49
1.1.6. The two wars, 1969–1989 50
1.1.7. The republican reading of the war, 1969–1989 51
1.1.8. The annual and cumulative death toll from political violence, 1969–1990 75
1.1.9. The annual and cumulative death toll from political violence, 1991–2012 77
1.1.10. The civilian annual death toll from political violence, 1966–2003 77
1.1.11(a). Escalation: Civilians killed, 1966–1976 78
1.1.11(b). Containment: Civilians killed, 1977–1986 78
1.1.11(c). Peace process: Civilians killed, 1987–2003 79
1.1.12. Armed agents responsible for deaths, 1969–1989 (IIP), 1969–2001
(Sutton), and 1966–2003 (Lost Lives) 85
1.1.13. Status of victims, 1969–1989 (IIP) and 1966–2003 (Lost Lives) 85
1.1.14. Estimates of the success of armed agents in killing their intended
targets, and their responsibilities for civilian deaths, 1969–1989 (IIP) 88
1.1.15. Data on related violence, with five-year trend lines, 1969–2011 91
1.1.16. Conflict-related injuries, 1990–2011 92
1.1.17(a). Loyalist and republican paramilitary-style attacks, shootings, 1991–2012 95
1.1.17(b). Loyalist and republican paramilitary-style attacks, assaults, 1991–2012
(assaults) 95
1.1.18. Northern Ireland prison population, 1967–2012 97
1.3.1. Two centuries of colonial land confiscation 186
1.4.1. Population growth and decline in the Isles, 1801–1921 220
1.4.1.A. Distribution of Americans who identify as “Irish,” by religion and
region, 1990–2000 260
1.5.1. The underrepresentation of Catholics in the secular professions
in Ireland, 1861–1911 273
1.5.2(a). Timeline of franchise reform in the four nations, 1793–1884 284
1.5.2(b). Timeline of franchise reform in Great Britain and Ireland, 1898–1969 284
1.5.3. Borough enfranchisement rates, four nations of the UK, 1868 288
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
List of Maps
List of Tables
List of Boxes
CnP Clann na Poblachta, party formed by Sean McBride in the belief that FF
had ceased to be a proper republican party
cess originally any local tax, but in Ireland also the levying of soldiers and
provisions, or the billeting of soldiers
CLRNI Campaign for Labour Representation in Northern Ireland.
condominium political entity over which two or more states share sovereignty
confederation states unified by treaty for certain public functions, but that retain their
sovereignty, international identity, and usually rights of secession and
veto
consociation political system used to share governmental power proportionally
between divided peoples—in the executive, the legislature, and public
employment, including security forces; each community enjoys cultural
autonomy, and public expenditure may be allocated on a proportional
basis; in strong consociations the organized communities enjoy veto
rights over major legislation
Continuity IRA breakaway organization from the IRA
covenanters Scottish Presbyterians who wanted the Scottish system of church
government applied throughout Scotland, England, and Ireland; in 1643
a treaty with the English parliament appeared to give them what they
wanted (The Solemn League and Covenant)
CRC Community Relations Council
CRF Catholic Reaction Force—see INLA
CSJ Campaign for Social Justice, founded in 1960s; became part of NICRA
Cumann (Irish) Irish women’s republican organization
na mBan
Cumann na (Irish) pro-treaty party formed from Sinn Féin, which led governments
nGaedhael of the Irish Free State from 1922 until 1932; later dissolved into Fine
Gael; sometimes spelled Cumman na nGaedheal
DAAD Direct Action Against Drugs (IRA front)
Dáil Éireann (Irish) “trans. Assembly of Ireland,” the official name for the lower
house of the Irish parliament (Oireachtas)
devolution act of creating a subcentral government with executive and legislative
powers inside a state; the institutions are constituted by a delegated (and
revocable) act of the political center
DEA Department of External Affairs of the IFS, later the DFA of Ireland
DFA Department of Foreign Affairs (Ireland), today the Department of
Foreign Affairs and Trade
DFM Deputy First Minister
DL Democratic Left, a party formed in 1992 from a split in the Workers’
Party, now absorbed by the Irish Labour Party–some say it was a takeover
dominions originally the partly self-governing (white) settlement colonies of the
British Empire; evolved in the 1920s into sovereign states of the British
Commonwealth of Nations
DPPB District Policing Partnership Boards
DRs Dissident Republicans, expression and abbreviation used by the PSNI
and MI5 to refer to post-IRA republican organizations that remain
actively engaged in what they define as armed struggle
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
PR proportional representation
PRONI Public Records Office Northern Ireland
PSF Provisional Sinn Féin
PSI Policy Studies Institute (London)
PSNI Police Service of Northern Ireland
PTA Prevention of Terrorism Act
PUP Progressive Unionist Party, political wing of the UVF
QUB Queen’s University Belfast
R&D research and development
Republican an advocate of a unified Ireland in a republic free of the British Crown;
an advocate of the thesis that there should be one Irish nation—
composed of its diverse multiple components—in which all share a
common citizenship
Republican see OIRA
Clubs
RHC Red Hand Commandos, name used by the UVF
RHD Red Hand Defenders, name used by the LVF and the UDA after 1998
RHI Renewable Heating Initiative
RIC Royal Irish Constabulary
RIR Royal Irish Regiment (regiment of the British Army created from the
merger of the UDR with the Royal Irish Rangers)
R-IRA Real IRA, breakaway from the IRA in 1997, which does not recognize
either Ireland’s or Northern Ireland’s legitimacy
RLP Republican Labour Party
RSF Republican Sinn Féin, breakaway from Sinn Féin in 1986, which does
not recognize either Ireland’s or Northern Ireland’s legitimacy
RTÉ Raidió Teilifís Éireann (Ireland’s public broadcaster, of both radio and
television)
RUC Royal Ulster Constabulary
SE Saor Éire, left-wing republican grouping of the 1930s, revived briefly in
1969–71
Saorstát Éireann (Irish) Irish Free State, name of dominion status for Ireland agreed in
the Anglo-Irish Treaty and named as such in the first Constitution of
Ireland established under that Treaty
SAA Saint Andrews Agreement, reached in Scotland in October 2006
between the Governments of Ireland and the United Kingdom of Great
Britain and Northern Ireland, and tacitly agreed by Northern Ireland’s
major political parties. Key elements included a change in the method of
electing the First and Deputy First Ministers, the full acceptance of the
Police Service of Northern Ireland by Sinn Féin, the restoration of the
Northern Ireland Assembly and a promise to abolish its Suspension Act
by the British government, and a commitment by the DUP to power-
sharing with republicans and nationalists in the Northern Ireland
Executive. The plan envisaged the devolution of policing and justice
powers within two years of the restoration of the executive
SACHR Standing Advisory Commission on Human Rights
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
SDLP Social Democratic and Labour Party of Northern Ireland, party formed
in 1970 from the merger of civil-rights activists, labor activists, and
former members of the Nationalist Party and the National Democratic
Party
SF Sinn Féin (Irish; lit. “Ourselves”). Irish Republican political party,
though originally formed in 1905 by Arthur Griffith and others to
advocate a common monarchy presiding over independent British and
Irish parliaments (modeled on the dual monarchy of Austro-Hungary).
Radicalized as a republican (anti-monarchical) party in 1917, and after.
It split during the making of the 1921 Treaty and the Irish civil war; and
later after the formation of Fianna Fáil; it split again into Provisional
and Official Sinn Féin in 1969–70; later, Provisional Sinn Féin’s claim to
the title Sinn Féin was uncontested. The party is organized in Northern
Ireland and Ireland
sheriff royal official within a shire (or county)
SHA Stormont House Agreement (2014)
Stormont the site of the Northern Ireland Parliament in a suburb of Belfast from
1932 to 1972, of the Northern Ireland Assembly of 1973–4 and 1982–6,
and of the Northern Ireland Assembly since 1998
STV single transferable vote, a preferential and proportional candidate-based
voting system, in which more than one candidate is elected in a district,
and in which the winners normally have to achieve a quota
Tánaiste (Irish) literally successor to the chief, whence the title of Ireland’s
Deputy Prime Minister
Taoiseach (Irish) Chief, whence the title of the prime minister in Ireland’s
constitution of 1937
TCD Trinity College, Dublin University
TD Teachta Dála (Irish), deputy elected to Dáil Éireann, equivalent to
MP in the UK or Member of Congress in the USA
TRNC Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (so-called)
TUV Traditional Unionist Voice, a party formed by James Allister that
broke from the DUP after the DUP formed a government with
Sinn Féin 2007
UCC University College Cork
UCD University College Dublin
UCG University College Galway
UDF Ulster Defence Force
UFF Ulster Freedom Fighters
Ulster Clubs Loyalist organization formed in response to the AIA of 1985
UCDC Ulster Constitution Defence Committee (see also UPV)
UDA Ulster Defence Association, largest loyalist paramilitary organization
UDI unilateral declaration of independence
UDP Ulster Democratic Party, political party of the UDA
UDR Ulster Defence Regiment, formed in 1970, dissolved into the RIR in
1992
UFF Ulster Freedom Fighters, killing component of the UDA
OUP CORRECTED PROOF – FINAL, 21/3/2019, SPi
Several Boxes will Appear the Same as a Set of Books and will Preserve the
Magazines
The Wire on the Creaser Presses the Paper into the Space between the Two
Wood Pieces
The Furnace Made of Fire Brick is Connected to the Condenser and Washers
with Ordinary Iron Pipe through Which the Gases Pass After being Purified
Before They Enter the Storage Tank
In connecting the first and second cans, use a piece of 1-in. pipe.
This may be bent or connected with ells to form a U-shaped piece. In
either case, one end should be longer than the other so that one will
just pass into the first can, where it is sealed with asbestos cement,
while the other end passes through the second-can top, where it is
sealed, and extends to the bottom of the can. For the connection to
the third can, make a hole in the top of the second can, but do not
seal it up to the connection until the can is first filled with water to
within 2 or 3 in. of the top. Also put powdered coke into the water,
about halfway of the can’s height.
The connection from the second and third cans should be made of
glass so that the gas can be observed passing through it between
the cans. This is not absolutely necessary, however, and a piece of
¹⁄₂-in. iron pipe can be used instead. This pipe is connected in the
same manner as that between the first and second, extending to the
bottom of the third can and being sealed where it passes through the
tops. The third can is filled with water to within 2 or 3 in. of the top.
The gas coming from the third can or washer, is ready for use, but
as the pressure would not be uniform, a storage tank must be
provided. To make a storage tank suitable for the needs of this small
plant, procure two pans from 10 to 12 in. in diameter and from 3 to 4
in. deep. One pan should be a trifle smaller, so that it may be
inverted in the larger pan, as shown. Make a connection from the
third can with a rubber hose to the bottom of the larger pan, near the
center, and use this pan as the bottom part of the storage tank. Pour
into this pan enough water to make it 2 in. deep, invert the other pan
and set it into the water. Attach a gas hose to the bottom of the
inverted pan and fasten a gas jet into the rubber-hose end. This will
make the gas plant complete and ready to operate.
To start the furnace, bore a hole in one side of the brick walls,
about the size of an ordinary lead pencil, and insert a lighted taper to
set fire to the kindling. There may be some difficulty in getting the fire
to burn at first, and it may be necessary to force considerable air in;
however, when the fire is fairly started, it will burn freely and the
gases will soon find their way through the first pipe to the condenser,
which is the first can. There they will mingle and deposit some tar
and ammonia, then flow out through the second pipe, up through the
coke and water in the second can and through the glass tube, where
they may be observed passing into the can of water, where some
more tar and ammonia will be deposited. After leaving this can the
gas will find its way through the rubber tube into the storage tank. It
passes from this tank to the burner, where it can be lighted and will
burn with a bright flame.
If it is possible to force steam into the furnace when the fire is at its
height, a much better quality and a larger volume of gas will be
made. This is accomplished by placing a closed can of water over a
fire near the furnace and connecting it to the latter with a piece of 1-
in. gas pipe. The water in this can must be boiling hot at the time the
fire in the furnace is lighted. The steam entering the furnace is
decomposed, the hydrogen being released as a gas. The pipe
connecting the boiler with the furnace should be fitted in the furnace
wall so that the steam will pass in at the top of the fire; about halfway
up the side of the furnace being about right. The steam will start the
gases more rapidly and force them through the pipes.
Make sure that all connections are carefully sealed to prevent the
escape of gases, as they will always follow the lines of least
resistance and pass out through a very small crevice. The only
danger with a plant of this size is from fire, wherefore it should be
built away from inflammable materials. It will not make sufficient gas
to be of injury to any living being.
Webfoot Attachments for Swimmers
In order to make the feet more effective in swimming, webfoot
devices are frequently used. A simple arrangement for this purpose
is shown in the illustration. It consists of three thin sections of metal,
or wood, fastened together on the back side with spring hinges,
which tend to remain open, thereby keeping all the sections spread
out in one straight surface. The center section should be cut to
conform closely to the shape of the foot, or it will produce
considerable resistance during the onward stroke of the foot, and
tend to stop the forward movement of the swimmer. Straps should be
provided for attaching the device to the foot; one to fit across the
toes, and the other adjusted around the ankle by a buckle.
Device for Attaching to the Feet to Work Like Webfeet
When using the device, the upward or forward stroke of the legs
will cause the wings to brush against the water, creating sufficient
resistance to overcome the slight force of the springs, thereby
pushing the wings parallel with the direction of the stroke. During the
opposite, or pushing, stroke, the resistance of the water combined
with the opening tendency of the hinges will quickly spread the wings
out flat, greatly increasing the effectiveness of the feet.—Contributed
by J. B. Laplace, New York City.
Repairing Sectional Spun-Metal Candlesticks
In repairing hollow, spun-brass candlesticks I find that frequently
the metal rod holding the sections together becomes loosened from
the pitch composition designed to hold it in the base. By tinning the
outer edges of the sections that fit into the other portions, which are
also tinned on the inner surfaces, and then using an iron, or an
alcohol torch, to run the solder together at these points, I secure a
very firm job. Paper can be placed at points necessary to keep the
solder from running out of bounds. When the rod is firm and the nut
only gives trouble, solder can be used to fasten the nut permanently
to the grease cup at the top.—Contributed by James M. Kane,
Doylestown, Pa.
Alcohol Blowtorch for Difficult Soldering
Clamps for Holding the Alcohol Receptacle on the End of the Blowpipe
To light a match in a stiff wind is very easy if the wood part back of
the prepared end is cut and turned up about it before striking the
match. The curled-up shavings about the striker will catch fire easily
and hold a flame, where in the ordinary way it is easily blown out
when the composition of the striker has burned up.—Contributed by
E. K. Marshall, Oak Park, Ill.
A Miniature Cement Plant
By MORTON SOUTHARD
Formolded
many years geologists searched for a substance which could be
into any size and form, and would have the hardness of
rock. As a matter of fact it was found that limestone was composed
of carbonic-acid gas, clay, and lime, and that when great heat was
applied the sealing bond was disrupted and the rock was reduced to
a powder. When this powder was placed in water the gas was set
free so fast that it made the water boil. The powder, or calcined rock,
is now known as lime. This action demonstrated that nature used
heat and moisture in forming these materials into rock. Knowing that
clay contained silica, and that silica furnished the sealing quality of
rocks, experiments were made to reverse the order of this rock
formation, and a cement was produced. Equal portions of lime and
clay were mixed together and stirred until all parts were thoroughly
mingled, and then the mixture was subjected to a very high heat,
after which the resulting mass was ground to a powder. When this
powder was mixed with water, instead of the gases passing off as
they did in the case of the lime, they penetrated the clay and the
mixture became hard. This was first called Portland cement, as it
was made from Portland limestone.
The Furnace is Built Up of Ordinary Brick and Used for Calcining the Lime