Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dr. Farukh Habeeb and Dr. Moutaz Abojeib
Dr. Farukh Habeeb and Dr. Moutaz Abojeib
"When a man dies, his deeds come to an end except for three things: continuous
charity (sadaqah jariyah); a knowledge which is beneficial, or a virtuous descendant
who prays for him (for the deceased)." (Muslim, Book 13, hadith # 1383)
That is why, Islam encourages people to get involved in charity and altruistic acts, no
matter big or small. And Shariah provides a complete eco-system for Islamic
philanthropy to ensure that wealth does not revolve among only the rich of a society.
There are various Islamic social institutions, like zakat, waqf, sadaqat and qardh
hasan which are proposed by Islam. These institutions always played a pivotal role
of sustainable economic development in a Muslim society throughout the history of
Islam. The whole social ecosystem was an integral element of the financial
empowerment program of the people which actively contributed in the financial
inclusion, poverty alleviation and fruitful mutual community initiatives. However,
recently, these important institutions have been generally failed to produce
substantial impact within the Muslim society. There is an array of issues and
challenges facing such institutions in the contemporary world, this paper explains
how Blockchain and smart contract technologies can help these institutions for better
governance, lower transaction cost, more transparency and higher trust; hence,
enhancing the business flexibility and market accessibility. It also presents some
related cases that are currently under development as an evidence for the
practicality of these technologies in the Islamic social finance arena.
2. What is blockchain?
It is pertinent to understand a technology, its benefits and limitations in order to truly
appreciate and explore its full potential and efficient implementation in any field.
Similarly, this section will explore what blockchain is, and what it is not to offer an in -
depth discussion regarding its implementation for Islamic social finance.
2.1. Definition
Blockchain is a distributed ledger technology which allows transactions to be
recorded without the need for a central authority or any intermediary. In other words,
it allows users to verify and store transactions/data, not on a certain server operated
by a centralised body as usual, but on servers/computers (known as nodes)
operated by various participants of the network. The challenge of having such a
decentralized system through traditional technology was extremely difficult;
blockchain technology found a way to synchronise the data/records among the users
and to ensure that it is not manipulated.
In order to add a transaction within a block, and the block into the chain, a
consensus is required from the majority of the full nodes. Moreover, once a block is
completed, it is verified by other full nodes, and subsequently, added to the chain.
Once a block is added to the chain, all full nodes immediately update the copy of
their ledger. With this setup, historical information cannot be altered or manipulated.
This is why it is largely argued that blockchain offers higher degree of integrity
without the need of a trusted intermediary or central authority.
2.2. Inception
Payment systems, or cryptocurrencies, are often cited as the primary product or use
case for blockchain technology. It is due to the fact that blockchain was first
introduced to the world by the introduction of the famous cryptocurrency - ‘Bitcoin’.
Bitcoin was introduced as a peer-to-peer digital payment system; while the
technology underneath was - what is now known as blockchain. Blockchain was
used by Bitcoin as a platform to enable peer-to-peer transactions. Surely, Bitcoin is not
the only cryptocurrency, there are a 1993 different cryptocurrencies exist as of September
25, 2018 (Coinmarketcap.com). [MA2] The differences between these cryptocurrencies
lie mainly due to their different objectives, underlying technology, protocols and
features.
3.1. Definition
Blockchain platform can also run smart contracts. Smart contracts are simply self-
executing contracts. ‘In other words, smart contract is a term used to describe a
computer program code that is capable of facilitating, executing, and enforcing the
negotiation or performance of an agreement (i.e. a contract) using blockchain
technology. The entire process is automated and can act as a complement or
substitute for legal contracts where the terms of the smart contract are recorded in a
computer language as a set of instructions’ (Kasri, 2017).
The idea behind them is to convert terms and conditions of a transaction into codes;
if the conditions are met, the contract is immediately concluded. Previously, the
challenge was to automatically ensure that conditions are met, and that this event
automatically triggers the conclusion of the contract, and perhaps its execution. With
blockchain, conditions - being written into lines of code – could exist across a
distributed, decentralized blockchain network in which it could be verified against the
pre-set conditions by anonymous parties without the need for a central authority,
legal system, or external enforcement mechanism. This renders transactions
traceable, transparent, and irreversible (Investopedia, n.d).
Smart contracts can revolutionize trading. Such structure could provide an
alternative to the traditional legal system. Being a new tool for solving the problem of
trust between parties, trading can be made automatic. Furthermore, it enables
machine to machine commerce without enforcement by legal entities (Stark, 2018).
‘The main feature of smart contract technology is that it can reduce costs for financial
transactions by circumventing regulatory infrastructures while simultaneously
reducing risk through non-discriminatory execution. Greater efficiency is predicted in
servicing markets on account of a lack of a central counterparty agent’ (Khan, 2017).
3.2. Inception
Though the concept and idea of smart contract was not always attached to
blockchain, its application in reality was facing technical challenges which could be
solved today by blockchain. It is reported that in 1994, Nick Szabo, a legal scholar,
and cryptographer, realized that the decentralized ledger could be used for smart
contracts (Blockgeeks, n.d). He was referring to a simple use for sale and purchase
of securities. ‘However, smart contracts went through a long gestation period of
inactivity and disinterest due to the non-availability of platform to enforce them. This
changed when blockchain technology was introduced in 2009. Smart contracts then
began to gain traction, which are now becoming a basic tenet of overall blockchain’s
power’ (Kasri, 2017).
Smart contracts can help in creating endless scenarios in which organizations can
collaborate to encourage charitable donations (Gengler, 2017). UNICEF is already
working on this concept with a blockchain solution to digitize donations and create
transparency in global aid (UNICEF, 2017).
4.1.1. Traceability:
From qardh hasan to sadaqat, waqf and zakat, all social financing instruments
require traceability. Be it lenders or donors, they insist on receiving complete
information about the utilization of their loan or charity. With limited capability of
centralized governing bodies, there is always an issue of maintaining full records of
all the transactions performed. Once the funds are received and commingled, it is
almost impossible to track each and every amount of fund to be disbursed.
Consequently, tracking mechanisms for funds have become a huge cost,
contributing to further inefficiencies of such products. With built-in feature of
distributed and decentralized ledger, blockchain provides an end-to-end tracking
mechanism and complete history of a transaction.
4.1.4. Security
Centralized databases are prone to security threats due to the fact that they have
single point of failure. On the contrary, blockchain ledger system is distributed in a
decentralized manner. The whole network depends on a huge number of
anonymous nodes which are sufficient to maintain the ledger, even in the situation
where the security of a few nodes has been compromised. This added security
feature reinsures safe working and viability of such products or institutions through
digital channels.
4.1.5. Scalability
Although blockchain systems are currently facing the issue of further scalability, but
even then they are still comparatively more efficient than traditional databases in
terms of scalability. Some blockchain systems have already achieved the equivalent
speed of ‘visa’ for transaction processing. Moreover, they are less affected by the
number of nodes as compared to the number of clients in usual databases. This
factor of scalability has several advantages for such products and institutions as their
users are individuals, who are large in numbers as well.
5.5. Inflexibility
Immutability is another strong feature of blockchain and smart contracts, however, it
has appeared to be a double-edge sword. It makes this technology somewhat
inflexible too. For example, if there are any bugs, they are not only visible to all the
users, including hackers, due to open source code of smart contracts, but also they
cannot be immediately and easily fixed due to the requirement of majority consensus
and distributed nature of the blockchain ledger.
This is purely a technical issue; and blockchain experts are working on it. The main
concern is that there is a trade-off between flexibility and trust. It is possible for some
market players to have customized blockchain solutions where there is a good mix of
both.
5.6. Interoperability
Another major concern is integration of blockchain system with the current existing
systems. Particularly, the financial institutions have already invested a huge amount
of capital into their legacy systems. Moreover, the legacy systems are well-tested
and widely used for the financial products; they have been considered as reliable
technology for the financial sector. On the other hand, blockchain technology is not
only unique, but also immature. Therefore, the blockchain technology cannot be
adopted all at once.
Blockchain provides a completely independent eco-system and technology
framework. This is not only unique, but also more advanced than other technologies.
For this reason, a gradual approach is more appropriate which can be broken down
into stages. At the first stage, the blockchain technology needs to be integrated with
the current systems in order to further improve their efficiency. At the second stage,
other technology infrastructure and supportive mechanisms should be devised and
implemented. At the third stage, the whole blockchain framework should be tested
and checked for any errors. At the fourth stage, an overall migration from the current
system to the blockchain system should take place.
6. Conclusion
The blockchain, though still in its infancy stage, has already proved itself as a game
changing breakthrough for the global financial sphere. In fact, its utilisation is not
limited to only the financial sector but it also affords promising features and usage for
non-financial sectors.
Similarly, the islamic social financing institutions could be invigorated with the
innovative and efficient use of the blockchain and smart contracts. The blockchain
technology and such institutions can indeed have a perfect natural match because,
interestingly, the blockchain addresses many, if not all, of the issues and problems
currently facing such institutions in the contemporary world.
It is strongly believed that with the firm fiqhi foundations of such institutions, an
innovative approach consisting of technological advancements, like blockchain and
smart contracts, towards their reinforcement will ensure that they could dynamically
participate in the societal and economic development of the whole Muslim world.
Such remarkable initiatives will also crystalise the ethical and social dimensions of
Islamic finance in a robust manner.
References
Bayram, A. S. (2018). Here Are Three Ways Blockchain Can Change Refugees' Lives.
World Economic Forum. Available at: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/06/three-ways-
blockchain-change-refugees-lives/
Blockgeeks. (n.d). Smart Contracts: The Blockchain Technology That Will Replace Lawyers.
Available at: https://blockgeeks.com/guides/smart-contracts/
Juskalian, R. (2018). Inside the Jordan Refugee Camp That Runs on Blockchain. MIT
Technology Review. Available at: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/610806/inside-the-
jordan-refugee-camp-that-runs-on-blockchain/
Khan. N. (2017). Smart Contracts - The Future of Islamic Banking. Available at: Smart
Contracts - The Future of Islamic Banking
Marr, B. (2018). A Very Brief History of Blockchain Technology Everyone Should Read.
Forebs. Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2018/02/16/a-very-brief-
history-of-blockchain-technology-everyone-should-read/#5462f7f37bc4
PwC. (2017). Blockchain, A Catalyst for New Approaches in Insurance. Available at:
https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/insurance/assets/blockchain-a-catalyst.pdf
Kasri, N. S. (2017). Shariah Compliance via Blockchain and Smart Contract – The Case for
Islamic Credit Card. Wahed Invest. Available at: https://journal.wahedinvest.com/shariah-
compliance-via-blockchain-and-smart-contract-the-case-for-islamic-credit-card/
Stark, J. (2018). Presentation at IIFM Seminar – Fintech, Smart Contracts and Blockchain,
Kuala Lumpur. Available at: http://www.iifm.net/sites/default/files/Session%206%20-
%20Fintech%2C%20Smart%20Contracts%20and%20Blockchain%20-
%20Nicholas%20Edmondes%20%28Trowers%20%26%20Hamlins%29.pdf