Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Forms of Law
Forms of Law
Sources of Law
STRUCTURE
Overview
Learning Objectives
1.1 Common Law
1.2 Legislation
1.2.1 Legislation procedures
1.2.2 Subordinate/delegated legislation
1.2.3 The constitution
1.2.4 Statutory interpretation
1.3 International Treaties
Summary
OVERVIEW
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
In a situation like the one given above, a judge must look carefully
into the competing claims, determine what the justice of the case
requires, and, accordingly, develop a rule of law to govern the
situation. In this particular case, common law judges decided that:
2
Unit 1: Sources of Law
These are just two of the types of disputes which the courts have
been called upon to resolve over the years. There are, of course,
countless others which develop between people every day, in a
variety of circumstances and in all walks of life and most of which,
at times, have to be resolved by the courts. We cannot possibly
capture all the types of disputes here. However, the following list
should illustrate the point:
3
Law, Governance, Economy and Society
You can find this body of rules in the thousands of volumes of law
reports which contain the written judgments of common law
judges. Practically, every country in the common law world has its
own collection. It is, therefore, not easy for anyone to discover
from this huge volume of materials what the common law is on
any particular subject. Fortunately, however, there are many
academics who devote considerable periods of time to researching
these materials and summarising the law for easy consumption.
There are also now books available on a variety of aspects of law.
The proliferation of books, or materials, on law is such that no
lawyer or judge can claim to know what the law is on any subject,
without first engaging in some quick research.
Equity
4
Unit 1: Sources of Law
Having looked into the historical sources of law, i.e., the common
law and equity, let us now move on to study the legal sources of
law. But first, complete the activity given below.
Note:
a) Space is given below for your answer.
b) Check the answer with your tutor.
1.2 LEGISLATION
5
Law, Governance, Economy and Society
The legislative process begins with introducing the Bill before the
Houses of Parliament, first in the lower house, and then,
subsequently, in the upper house. After debate, members of both
houses cast their votes. If it receives the requisite majority, the
Bill, with amendments if any, which may have been successfully
moved during debate, is then submitted to the Head of State
(President or Governor General), for his or her As s ent . Once the
Bill gets the Assent, the Bill becomes law, and is thereafter
referred to as an Act o f Par li am ent . Note that the passing of a
Bill (to become an Act of Parliament) is not so easy as it sounds.
There are quite a number of government procedures to be
followed. We will not, at this stage, go into the details of these.
But, we should know that it is a long drawn process.
6
Unit 1: Sources of Law
Note:
a) Space is given below for your answer.
b) Check the answer with your tutor.
A parent Act, for example, may provide for the payment of certain
benefits to an employee who is injured on the job, and may permit
an employee to make an application to the court of law when the
employer refuses to pay, or when there is a dispute over the
amount to be paid. Regulations made by a minister or any other
authority will then set out in detail the procedure which is to be
followed in order to gain access to the court and to prosecute the
employee's claim. Or, a Road Traffic Act may make general
provisions for the regulation of traffic and leave the designated
authority to flesh out the general purposes of the Act. Thus, a
Traffic Commissioner might, from time to time, identify
regulations such as which streets are to be one way streets, or
7
Law, Governance, Economy and Society
8
Unit 1: Sources of Law
Note:
a) Space is given below for your answer.
b) Check the answer with your tutor.
9
Law, Governance, Economy and Society
• rules governing entry into the upper and lower houses by way
of either appointment or election;
• the power which Parliaments possesses to make laws, including
laws which might amend the Constitution;
• the procedure which must be followed to enact such laws.
(For example, generally speaking, in order to validly pass a law
which is inconsistent with the Constitution, Parliament is
usually required to obtain a special majority, sometimes two-
thirds, other times three-quarters, of the members of the
houses, and in some cases, the legislation must be approved in
a referendum. Where a law is consistent with the Constitution,
and is not passed in accordance with the prescribed procedure,
it is liable to be struck down by the courts of law.)
10
Unit 1: Sources of Law
11
Law, Governance, Economy and Society
Over time, in order to keep faith with their mandate to uphold the
will of Parliament, judges have developed rules of statutory
interpretation to assist them in their task. The rules of statutory
interpretation include:
12
Unit 1: Sources of Law
Some of you may be wondering, why could not the judges simply
ask the legislators what their intention was, or consult the records
of the debates in Parliament when the Act was being considered in
order to determine what Parliament intended?
You are indeed correct. Yes, this may be one of the ways of
interpreting the Statutes when the judges are in doubt. However,
you should also note that in many cases the need for
interpretation might arise long after the actual legislators are
available to permit their intentions to be probed. And even if they
are available, there may be a temptation to so express the
legislator's intention as to be consistent with a policy which the
existing government wishes to pursue in the present, but was not
in contemplation when the Act was passed. And even if that
temptation can be resisted, there is no guarantee that each
legislator would have had the identical meaning in mind,
particularly where the fact situation to which the Act is now to be
applied was not present in the minds of the legislators at the time.
13
Law, Governance, Economy and Society
Point to note
Note:
a) Space is given below for your answer.
b) Check the answer with your tutor.
Let us look at the third source of law next – that is, international
treaties.
14
Unit 1: Sources of Law
15
Law, Governance, Economy and Society
SUMMARY
RECOMMENDED READING
16