Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Aeroplane - Vol 31 #08 - 2020-05 - Catch A Falling Star, RAF Canberras On The Falklands-82-91
Aeroplane - Vol 31 #08 - 2020-05 - Catch A Falling Star, RAF Canberras On The Falklands-82-91
FACT
OR
FOLKLORE? The question has gone unanswered for years: did RAF Canberra
PR9s fly from Chilean bases during the Falklands War? Operation
‘Folklore’ was the codename given to a planned deployment —
but, despite its eventual cancellation, rumours still abound. For his
new book Harrier 809, author Rowland White talked to some of
those involved, and researched in official archives, to investigate
one of British military aviation’s most enduring mysteries
WORDS: ROWLAND WHITE
Ever since the appearance of the boss Colin Adams’s time in the Edwards around his headquarters,
New Statesman piece, speculation, cockpit of the remarkable Canberra sharing up-to-date intelligence on
rumour and debate has raged PR9 was also coming to an end. Argentine dispositions, encouraging
about what No 39 Squadron’s Just 23 PR9s were built, all by him to ask whatever he wanted
Canberras might really have got Short Brothers. Their capabilities of his staff and explaining that, as
up to in 1982. While researching were outstanding. Adams himself chairman of the country’s Joint
my new book about the Falklands had flown one as high as 68,000ft. Intelligence Committee, he could
campaign, Harrier 809, I came The System III camera capsule it guarantee the assistance of all
across a letter in the National had inherited from the American Chile’s armed forces. With the carrot
Archives titled ‘Operation Corporate Lockheed U-2 meant it could see dangled, Edwards was invited to a
— Innovations’. Copied across the time on Big Ben while flying meeting with Gen Fernando Matthei,
several naval departments, the letter at over 40,000ft above the Isle of the FACh commander-in-chief.
included an annex containing three Wight. By 1982, those that remained, “Nothing specific to discuss”,
lines that caught my eye: “Canberra carefully nurtured to preserve the Matthei told him. “I just want to
PR9 fitted with Westinghouse 101-10 dwindling fatigue life of their old make sure you’re getting all the help
ECM jammer pods (and 1 aircraft airframes, were under the care of you needed”. Edwards assured him
with additional internal he was. He had good
fuel tank)”. And with news for Matthei in
that, my simple plan As the engineers looked to return: confirmation
to tell the story of 809
Naval Air Squadron, a
reinstate underwing pylons, they that six surplus RAF
Hunters would be
Sea Harrier unit hastily used lengths of metal pipe they air-freighted to Chile
recommissioned a week within the week.
after the invasion and found behind the Wyton NAAFI Another seven would
then sent south to fight follow as soon as they
less than three weeks later, suddenly Colin Adams at Wyton. But, when were ready. Also now given priority
got a little more complicated. the No 39 Squadron boss was first treatment were Chilean requests for
asked to consider the possibility of Blowpipe anti-aircraft missiles. With
a Canberra deployment in support the balance of the conversation so
After nearly a quarter of a of Operation ‘Corporate’, the British far working largely in Chile’s favour,
BELOW:
century as a dedicated photo- effort to retake the Falklands, the Edwards made a request of his own.
Many of the RAF’s reconnaissance unit, No 39 plan was to leave them all at home. “Would you”, he asked, “allow
ever-diminishing fleet Squadron’s time was nearly up. Instead, attention focused on the us to base some RAF photo-
of PR9s underwent With just five aircraft to its name, older, but longer-ranged, Canberra reconnaissance Canberras in
a major update from 39 was due to lose its status as a full PR7. These were to be borrowed Chile?” He outlined the need for
1976 with the fitting squadron at the end of May 1982. from 39’s Wyton neighbours, No up-to-date intelligence and the
of Decca TANS and
the AN/ARI 18228
Redesignated as No 1 Photographic 100 Squadron. While three carefully exceptional imagery the PR9s
passive warning Reconnaissance Unit, it wasn’t chosen No 39 Squadron crews would bring back while flying, he
receiver. going to need a full-blown wing underwent a rapid conversion explained, “at very high altitude in
DENIS J. CALVERT commander to run it, so squadron course, No 100 Squadron engineers Chilean and international airspace.”
prepared their aircraft. The latter’s “I’m familiar with the Canberra’s
operations record book noted with qualities”, Matthei told him. And
impressive disingenuousness, he really was. Chile had wanted to
“Easter was marked by feverish add the PR9 to the FACh inventory
activity to prepare 3 of the PR7s to help with ‘land survey tasks’
for possible deployment to for some time. Previously denied
Chile as part of a potential sales the opportunity to do so for either
demonstration”. Their intended financial or political reasons, the
customer, however, had other ideas. general saw his opening. He let
Gp Capt Sidney Edwards arrived Edwards finish making his case and
in Chile on 14 April 1982. A former then turned him down.
Hunter pilot, Edwards was a “The Canberra is such a distinctive
Spanish speaker with a background aircraft”, he said, “that we would
in military intelligence. His covert not be able to keep its presence in
mission was to liaise with the Chile a secret”. Before Edwards had
Chilean military over support for a chance to absorb the bad news,
the British campaign in the South Matthei proposed an alternative
Atlantic. The recent lifting of a five- arrangement. “If you were prepared
year-old ban on arms exports and to sell some to Chile at an acceptable
the normalisation of diplomatic price, the sale could be portrayed as
relations between Britain and Gen part of Chile’s defence procurement.
Pinochet’s regime was proving to be Obviously, some RAF air and
exceptionally well-timed. groundcrews would be needed
A day after his arrival in Santiago, initially to train their Chilean Air
Edwards met Gen Vicente Force counterparts.”
Rodríguez, the head of Chilean Air Edwards listened, hope rising.
Force (Fuerza Aérea de Chile, FACh) “There could be no better way of
intelligence. Rodríguez showed carrying out this training than to
ABOVE: prompted by any direct route need either to tow the jets out to the In Chile, Peter Robbie boarded
Never before between Belize and Chile had been end of the runway before starting a disguised RAF Hercules and flew
published, this image constant. To have any chance of the engines, or to taxi out and then north to Arica Province. Arriving just
shows Canberra PR9
reaching their destination they hot-refuel at the threshold to top after dawn the transport settled onto
serial 341 in Fuerza
Aérea de Chile were going to have to cruise-climb up the tanks before an immediate the highway on soft tyres. On board
markings, and with on a south-easterly track across departure. Adams and his crews was another RAF Hercules crew and,
tip tanks attached, Honduras, Nicaragua and Costa were no less concerned about the as ever, their Chilean minders. The
taxiing out at Wyton Rica. Clearance to do so would fine detail of their arrival in Chile. C-130 crew was impressed with the
on 15 October 1982, neither be requested nor given. But The squadron boss had already slickness of the FACh operation to
ready to embark
intelligence suggested it was unlikely signalled No 1 Group HQ back in the close the road to traffic and prepare
on the delivery
flight to its new any of them had the capability to do UK to say the MoD demand that they it for the arrival of the Canberras,
operator. It was in the anything about it. Beyond, though, land in the dark was a non-starter. a procedure that appeared to be
hands of a Chilean lay Colombia, Ecuador and Peru. Plainly unacceptable, Cole had practised regularly. And the dress
crew, comprising Such a cavalier attitude to entering thought. They’d not only be very rehearsal proved the validity of the
— according to their airspace was likely to end low on fuel, but would have to No 39 Squadron plan. When the
author Santiago
badly. All three possessed modern, make a visual approach to land on PR9s arrived through the soft glow of
Rivas in British
Combat Aircraft well-equipped air forces operating a totally unfamiliar stretch of road. the new day, they would cross-refuel
in Latin America squadrons of supersonic Mirages. And landing anywhere except a from the C-130’s own tanks before
(Hikoki, 2019) — Col And Peru, more than any other runway was in no way part of No immediately taking to the air again
González and Capt country in Latin America, was vocal 39 Squadron’s normal repertoire. from the road for the final leg of the
Canales. This, as in its support of Argentina. On top of that there’d be no up-to- journey south to Punta Arenas.
XH166, was one of
Adams suggested skirting around date weather information, nor any From there it was Robbie and his
the two PR9s that,
still in service with Peru’s 1,500-mile coastline at a radar control. A compromise was navigator, rather than the two crews
No 39 Squadron, distance of 100 miles. His navigator reached. After descending to low who’d just staged south over 7,000
had got as far Brian Cole argued that tucking level at first light, the PR9 crews miles from Belize, who were tasked
as Belize on the in closer at 50 miles would shave were to radio ahead with 15 miles to to fly the first ‘Folklore’ photo-
Operation ‘Folklore’ the overall distance to Chile and run to their Pan-American Highway reconnaissance mission out over
deployment before it
usefully increase their fuel margin. landing strip. At that point a series the South Atlantic. They were all set.
was cancelled.
FARLINGTON PHOTO COLLECTION
Crucially, being 50 miles offshore of Verey cartridges would be fired
meant the RAF jets would still be to light a flare path to the makeshift
flying way beyond the limits of runway. Unlikely to have the fuel Generally speaking, the Daily
Peru’s sovereign airspace. While to go around again, they’d get one Star’s diet of pin-ups, prurience,
Argentina’s ally might not welcome shot at it. celebrity news and outrage was of
the puzzling presence nearby of If anything went wrong during little interest to readers in Chile. But
a pair of Canberra PR9s dressed this last, critical phase of the flight as the red-top covered the events in
in FACh markings, it could not — and running out of fuel was a the South Atlantic with screaming
legitimately hinder their progress. real possibility — they were, Adams 100-point headlines, there was one
It would buy the RAF flyers a little briefed, “to point the aircraft out to report that prompted deep concern
more leeway, but they would still sea and eject while still over land.” in Santiago.
home hard information was shared hours’ flying time spread out over
on a need-to-know basis. “Those two weeks. And even that was
who were involved in operations did pushing it. The leg between Tahiti
not talk about them”, said a former and Easter Island would need both
Wyton station commander, “and the new internal fuel tank and tip
those directly involved did not ask.” tanks. Once again, modifying the
As tantalising as the prospect Canberras for air-to-air refuelling
of covert PR9 operations in 1982 was mooted, at an estimated cost of
remains, hard evidence points in £25,000 per aircraft. Finally, there
the other direction. ‘Corporate’ was the idea of dismantling the jets,
air component commander Air shipping them to the islands by
Marshal Sir John Curtiss was sea, and then reassembling them
sufficiently exercised by the absence at Stanley. This was acknowledged
of adequate reconnaissance that to be a one-way trip and suggested
he drafted a paper during the using aircraft “destined for the
war giving voice to his concerns. scrap heap”. But Canberra PR9s and
Alongside him at Northwood, No British aircrew did eventually make
18 Group commander AVM George it to Chile.
Chesworth, in whose office the
‘Folklore’ planning cell was located,
was also to reflect on the absence of At the controls of the PR9 that
PR9 imagery. “We had good satellite flew across the flightline at the 29
coverage”, he said, but what was May reunion was Sqn Ldr Dave
required was “real-time recce”. Even Watson. While Watson didn’t
if No 39 Squadron had been able deploy to Central America with the
to provide that, he noted, “it would ‘Folklore’ operation, he had been
have been hard to get products active in support of it, flying trials
of the recce back”. It was all very with the jammer pod and chaff
well developing photographs in dispenser and to assess the aircraft’s
Chile using the RIC, but getting the stability with the new flare bay fuel
‘take’ into the hands of Task Force tank fitted. His involvement with
commanders was another matter, Chile became rather more direct
although Colin Adams proposed to with the arrival of three FACh crews
air-drop it to the Task Force at sea at Wyton in August.
ABOVE: Such has been the official from the Canberra’s flare bay. The six Chilean airmen had
Two of the Fuerza sensitivity over both Chile’s support No-one had thought to inform already undergone the Canberra
Aérea de Chile’s and its willingness to let the British the Prime Minister of all this. Well- conversion course at RAF Marham
three ex-RAF
Canberra PR9s over
mount operations from inside its briefed on the PR9’s capability after before arriving at No 1 PRU to learn
the Andes. Serial 341 borders that inconsistencies and No 39 Squadron had been put on to fly the PR9 in its intended role.
had been XH166, tantalising loose threads remain. stand-by earlier in the year when her Dave Watson was their instructor.
and 343, leading The Hercules that the No 30 son, Mark, went astray during the While he shepherded the six pilots
this formation, was Squadron ORB records supporting Paris-Dakar rally, she asked to see — three of whom had been required
formerly XH173. The Operation ‘Folklore’ from 25 April the imagery from ‘Folklore’. Furious to train as navigators — through
other aircraft, 342,
had XH167 as its RAF
was photographed on the apron at to learn that the operation had been nearly two months of training, the
identity — it was lost Easter Island the day before. scrubbed, a handbagging followed. station engineers prepared three
in an accident during A few years after the war, an Even after PR9s for their
a mission near Punta aviation journalist visiting No 1 PRU the war the transfer to the
Arenas on 25 May at Wyton was shown around a PR9 challenges Furious to learn FACh.
1983. The last active
survivor was 343,
by one of the aircrew. Pointing at a
series of holes in the underside of
of operating
Canberras in the
the operation had The aircraft
were formally
after 341 sustained
minor damage in a the wing just inboard of the wingtips,
the pilot told him, “This was where
South Atlantic been scrubbed, a handed over to
runway excursion in remained. When the Chilean air
1988. Much the same the tip tanks were attached. We used in September handbagging from attaché, Gen
thing happened with them over the islands. We were at 1982 there was Ramón Vega,
343 during April maximum radius without them, a request for an Thatcher ensued at a ceremony
1994, at Santiago’s
main Arturo Merino but if we dropped the tanks we had aerial survey of at Wyton on 14
Benítez International 15 to 30 minutes over the islands”. the Falklands and South Georgia, October. The next day, the three
Airport, following Asked to elaborate, it seemed to the MoD said, “initially this looks a Canberras left Wyton for Santiago,
which it too was suddenly dawn on him that perhaps ‘no go’ project because of numerous staging through the Canary Islands,
retired. Both are he’d already said too much. And yet, problems”, before going on to Senegal, Cape Verde, Brazil and
today preserved by so long after the fighting, it seems consider the options for getting Paraguay. Supporting them during
the Museo Nacional
Aeronáutico y del entirely plausible for an exaggerated PR9s into theatre. You could fly the long journey to their new
Espacio at Los narrative about 39’s involvement to east. Once the Foreign Office had home at Los Cerrillos with Grupo
Cerrillos, Santiago have taken root at Wyton, alluded discounted the possibility of routing de Aviación No 2 was an FACh
— their former to through nods and winks among through Brazil, the alternative, C-130. On board the Hercules,
base with Grupo de those not directly involved. Even as flying via Malaysia, Australia, Fiji, looking forward to a three-month
Aviación No 2. No 39 Squadron personnel prepared Tahiti, Easter Island, Santiago and deployment to South America to
VIA ROWLAND WHITE
‘Folklore’ in Chile and Belize, back Punta Arenas, would require 48 help the Chileans usher their new
809 BOOK
engineer, drafted in from a posting diligently transcribed Adams’s
to Strike Command because of reaction in his notebook before
his expertise in the camera kit. Of asking a few further questions. But
the three PR9s being transferred his heart didn’t seem to be in it. Thanks to publisher Penguin
to the FACh, one, XH166, was the And, after he’d finished scribbling, Books, we have two copies of
aircraft Cole and Adams had flown he closed his notebook and started Rowland White’s new book
no further than Belize during to smile. “I’m sorry”, he said, “but I Harrier 809 — released on
Operation ‘Folklore’. was politically instructed that I had 30 April — to give away.
The RAF training team remained to interview you.” For a chance of winning this
in Chile until December. To “That’s barmy”, Adams told him. book, answer the following
maintain currency during their time On that, they were both agreed. question:
away from Wyton, Watson and Cole So too, it seemed, were more
flew in the PR9 at least once a week. senior figures in the air force. At which RAF base in the
In the company of a FACh crewmate Adams, despite his questioning UK were No 39
who handled the Spanish-language ‘under caution’, was subsequently Squadron’s Canberras
RT, they used their time in the air to promoted to become station
help develop their hosts’ proficiency commander at RAF Akrotiri, and stationed at the time of
in the art of photo-reconnaissance. then defence attaché in Paris. But, the Falklands conflict?
But, conscious of the ongoing after the arrest of civil servant Clive To enter, simply visit www.aeroplanemonthly.com and
political and diplomatic sensitivities Ponting later in 1985 for leaking complete the online competition entry form. Alternatively,
in the region, Watson was only classified details of the sinking of the send your name, postal address and e-mail (if you have the
too aware that “you had to be a bit Belgrano, he imagined something latter) to: Aeroplane Harrier 809 Book Competition,
careful…” similar had happened over ‘Folklore’. Key Publishing, PO Box 100, Stamford, Lincolnshire,
The truth, though, has never
PE9 1XQ, UK.
been confirmed nor denied. Nearly
At Rudloe Manor, Colin Adams 40 years on from the Falklands The winner will be drawn at random on 20 May 2020 and
was flabbergasted. Told he was campaign, details of the No 39 notified by post/e-mail by 27 May 2020.
suspected of having leaked Squadron deployment and other No purchase necessary. There is no cash prize and the editor’s decision
information to the press, the former covert RAF operations that is final. The competition is not open to employees of Key Publishing or
No 39 Squadron boss asked, “Who took place in Latin America their families.
the hell thinks I would possibly during 1982 remain classified.