Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Catalytic Hydrogenation by Noble Metals Nanocrystals
Catalytic Hydrogenation by Noble Metals Nanocrystals
Science &
Technology
View Article Online
MINIREVIEW
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
Recent studies with better catalytic models show the structure sensitivity of noble-metals for catalytic
hydrogenation. The size and shape of noble-metal nanocrystals have a great impact on their reaction
performance in hydrogenation. Essentially, the exposed crystal planes, which primarily determine the mor-
phology of a nanocrystal, tremendously affect its catalytic behavior. Therefore, many new methods involv-
Received 6th December 2014, ing controllable nucleation and growth processes have been developed to prepare uniform noble-metal
Accepted 1st March 2015
nanocrystals with tunable sizes and shapes for catalytic hydrogenation. This paper presents a brief overview
DOI: 10.1039/c4cy01619j
of the activity and selectivity of noble-metal nanocrystals with well-defined facets in the field of catalytic
hydrogenation. High activity and controllable selectivity in hydrogenation have been achieved based on the
www.rsc.org/catalysis shaped noble-metal nanocatalysts.
2532 | Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015
View Article Online
way of optimizing their performances and recyclability must For sub-10 nm NCs, the smaller the size the higher the sur-
be discerned because of their low abundance in nature. face to volume ratio will be. This means that the active site
Firstly, bulk single crystals of noble-metal catalysts with will be enhanced sharply as the particle size decreases.
certain facets exposed had been studied for surface chemical In essence, the arrangement of surface atoms and the
reactions (e.g., hydrogenation). For a molecular understand- exposed type of crystallographic planes play an important
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
ing of the catalytic process, extending reaction studies to role in the activity and selectivity of catalytic hydrogenation.
structure-sensitive reactions for which activity and selectivity In the following, we will focus on published examples of cata-
change with facets was carried out.3 Benzene hydrogenation lytic hydrogenation on shaped noble-metal nanocatalysts.
is an ideal reaction for such studies for its facet sensitivity, Many nanomaterials have been prepared and used in cata-
which has been investigated on single-crystalline Pt sur- lytic hydrogenation, not all of them can be evaluated as suit-
faces.1,4,5 Moreover, both experimental6–8 and theoretical9 able catalysts for hydrogenation. Recent studies of the synthe-
studies on the selective catalytic hydrogenation of CO sis of shaped noble-metal NCs and their use for catalytic
bonds in unsaturated aldehydes have suggested that such hydrogenation are summarized in Table 1.
reactions may be promoted by close-packed (111) surfaces.
The results provide the reference state needed to probe and 2. The synthesis of noble-metal NCs
compare more complex nanocrystal surfaces which are more
closely related to what is used industrially.
with well-defined facets for
The research mentioned above highlights the separate hydrogenation
roles that particle size and particle shape may play in defin-
It is generally recognized that the wet-chemical approach is a
ing the activity and selectivity in those catalytic processes.
practical strategy to synthesize uniform noble-metal NCs.
Accordingly, independent control of particle size and shape
There are two major stages (nucleation and growth) and four
(exposed facets) during catalyst manufacture may offer ave-
related components referring to: metal ion precursor, capping
nues for the design of good nanocatalysts. A lot of effort has
agent, solvent, and reducing agent, as described in Scheme 1.
been put into investigating the size effects of nano-sized
noble-metal catalysts. Recently, with the development of
nanotechnology, noble-metal nanocatalysts with well-defined 2.1 Precursor
facets have been prepared. In this way, the facet effects Metal salts, e.g., metal acetylacetonate, nitrate, halide
of these nanocatalysts on reaction activity and selectivity have (Cl−, Br−, I−), and acetate, are usually chosen to provide the
been investigated. For example, Somorjai’s group10 has stud- source of the corresponding noble metals. Of course potas-
ied much about the molecular factors affecting turnover sium chloroplatinate IJK2PtCl6) can be substituted by chloro-
rates and catalytic selectivity including surface structure, platinic acid IJH2PtCl6) in the synthesis, but the state of the
adsorbate-induced restructuring, reaction intermediates, sur- metal ion will affect the shape of the obtained metal nano-
face composition and so on. crystal. For instance, using K2PtCl4 as the precursor can pro-
Virtual progress in size/shape control of noble-metal NCs duce Pt nanocubes, while tetrahedral Pt NCs will be obtained
has been made by numerous scientific workers.11–14 But the from H2PtCl6.20,22,24 A complex of the metal precursor will
use of these shaped NCs as catalysts is still under way.11,15–17 form under some conditions. As in the presence of ijPdCl4]2−
It is considered that the size of the noble-metal NCs affects and C14TABr, it has been reported that ijPdCl4]2− ions interact
the activity while the multiple shapes, especially the well- with C14TABr to form the stoichiometric metal-surfactant
defined facets, make a contribution to the reaction selectivity. complex IJC14TA)2PdBr4. The complex of IJC14TA)2PtBr4 is
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 | 2533
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
Reducing Noble
Minireview
Precursor Capping agent Solvent agent metal Facets Effects Hydrogenation of Reference
K2PtCl4 TTABa Water NaBH4, H2 Pt (111) Both cyclohexane and cyclohexene were formed Benzene 2
on (111)
NaBH4 (100) Only cyclohexane was produced on (100)
IJNH4)2PtIJIV)Cl6 and PVPb and TTABa Ethylene Ethylene Pt (100) Ethylene hydrogenation rates were facet Ethylene 18
IJNH4)2PtIJII)Cl4) glycol glycol, PVPb independent
(111) For pyrrole hydrogenation, the (100) facets Pyrrole
enhanced ring-opening ability and showed a
higher selectivity to n-butylamine as compared to
(111) facets.
H2PtCl6 3-HBc Water Ascorbic acid, Pt (100) Free-standing Pt NPs with (111) facets are more 4-Nitrophenol 19
NaBH4 active than those with (100) facets.
Table 1 (continued)
Reducing Noble
Precursor Capping agent Solvent agent metal Facets Effects Hydrogenation of Reference
HAuCl4· ODA j Au, Pd, Pt (111) In toluene Activity: Pt nanorod aggregates (89%) > Citral 30
4H2OPdCl2H2PtCl6· AuPt alloy NPs (55%) > Pt NPs (111) (44%)
6H2O Selectivity to unsaturated alcohols: AuPt alloy NPs
35% > Pt nanorods 4% = Pt (111) monometallic
NPs 4%
In scCO2 Activity: Pt NPs (111) (82%) > Pt
nanorod aggregates (79%) > AuPt alloy NPs (46%)
Catalysis Science & Technology
Minireview
Table 1 (continued)
Reducing Noble
Minireview
Precursor Capping agent Solvent agent metal Facets Effects Hydrogenation of Reference
PtIJacac)2 and PVPb, Water, benzyl Benzylalcohol, Pt3Ni@M (111) The catalytic performance can be significantly Nitrobenzene 41
NiIJacac)2 dimethylglyoxime, alcohol solvothermal M = Au, Ag, improved by sophisticated decoration with the
HAuCl4Ĵ4H2O acetic acid, 150 °C Cu, Rh third metal.
RhIJacac)3, CuIJacac)2, benzoic acid
AgNO3, and FeIJacac)3
PtIJacac)2 and OAmk OAmk CO Pt3Co (111) (100) Amine-capped truncated octahedral Pt3Co-alloy α, β-Unsaturated 42
CoIJacac)2 NPs can be used as efficient catalysts for selective aldehydes (cinnam-
hydrogenation of α, β-unsaturated aldehydes aldehyde and citral)
Na2PdCl4, K2PtCl4 NaI, PVPb DMFi PVPb PtxPd1−x (100) Effect of shape and composition IJPt51Pd49 Nitrobenzene 43
Na2PdCl4, K2PtCl4 NaCl, PVPb DMFi PVPb PtxPd1−x (111) highest) the (100)-facet-enclosed PtPd NCs
demonstrate higher activity than those with (111)
facets.
l m
. THF - tetrahydrofuran.
View Article Online
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 | 2537
View Article Online
of Pd NCs and PtPd NCs with well-defined facets by Xia’s Other polymers, such as sodium polyacrylate (SPA), were
group29 and Huang’s group.43 Zaera’s group used a very large also usually used in the synthesis of uniform noble-metal
PVP polymer with a molecular weight of 360 000 for the prep- NCs. For example, Zaera’s lab employed SPA of MW 2100 for
aration of tetrahedral Pt NCs.20 the synthesis of cubic Pt NCs,20 and Miyake et al. used MW
The binding of surface capping agents (e.g., PVP) usually 8000 SPA to prepare various shaped Pt NCs for olefin hydro-
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
decreases the activity of a catalyst because of the coverage on genation.22 Besides, small molecules, such as I−,22,43 Br−,48
the active sites. Previous studies showed that the coverage of Cl−,43,48 oleylamine (OAM),35,42,44,45,47 oleic acid,35,44,45 benzoic
metal surfaces by large PVP polymers will decrease their acid,41 diphenyl ether,44 TTAB,2 bromurede cetyltrimethyl-
activity due to the fact that the capping or stabilizing agents ammonium (CTAB)23,32 and C14TABr21 were also introduced for
on the surfaces of the NPs hinder contact between the reac- the preparation of shaped metal NCs for hydrogenation.
tants and active sites of the noble metal. Similar results OAM proved to be an efficient functional molecule since it can
were obtained for catalytic hydrogenation. Based on the well- act as both the solvent and the capping agent at the same
defined Pd NCs prepared by Xia’s group using PVP as the time.30,42,47 Li’s group52 compiled the noble-metal-induced
stabilizer,48 Kiwi-Minsker’s group studied their catalytic reduction strategy with octadecylamine (ODA) to generate vari-
properties for acetylene hydrogenation.29 They found that ous bimetallic NCs.
PVP indeed affected the catalytic performance of Pd NCs. The Medlin’s and Schwartz’s groups have finished systematic
removal of PVP by UV-ozone showed a 4-fold increase in their research on the modification of traditional catalytic materials
activity. Therefore, some methods such as UV-ozone, calcina- using self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) to create a more
tion, plasma and electrochemical imposition at high voltages, favorable surface environment for specific product forma-
have been adopted to gain a clean surface of metal tion.53 They tuned the monolayer structure to improve the
NPs.20,29,49–51 However, there is an exception. Li’s group re- catalytic performance for hydrogenation reactions on palla-
ported that PVP as the capping agent does not affect the solu- dium and platinum catalysts. Each approach serves to direct
bility, activity, and recyclability of PtNi nanoalloy catalysts for selectivity by tuning a particular aspect of the system includ-
the hydrogenation of benzalacetone, styrene, and nitro- ing the availability of specific active sites (active-site selec-
benzene.40 Besides, different capping agents have their own tion), intermolecular interactions between the reactants and
effects on the catalytic activity. Somorjai’s group21 proved modifiers (molecular recognition), and general steric or
that the activity is higher for ethylene hydrogenation using crowding effects. On the uniform truncated nanooctahedral
tetradecyltrimethylammonium bromide (TTAB) as the cap- Pt3Co with (111) and (100) facets, Zheng’s and Fu’s groups
ping agent than for that using PVP. studied the selectivity of cinnamaldehyde hydrogenation
Fig. 2 Typical TEM images and size distribution of Pt NPs controlled by TA (a, b) and 3-HB (c, d). Reproduced from ref. 19.
2538 | Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015
View Article Online
directed by oleylamine.42 Capping the Pt3Co (100) surface catalytic activity for the hydrogenation of styrene and α,
with amines that contain long carbon chains results in an β-unsaturated aldehydes, respectively.44,45 In Huang's work,43
ordered surface “array”, in which high selectivity towards nearly 100% conversion of nitrobenzene was achieved for
CO hydrogenation can be achieved because the CC bond the nanocubic Pt51Pd49 capped by I− and PVP under 1 atm
in cinnamaldehyde does not interact with the surface. hydrogen gas in 120 min at room temperature. But in other
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
A review of Zheng’s group12 has clearly demonstrated that cases, before the removal of strong adsorbates on their sur-
strong adsorption of several small adsorbates, like I− and CO, face, the as-prepared NPs typically lack good catalytic activ-
could serve as an effective factor to enrich not only the sur- ity.54 Overall, the influence of these small adsorbates in
face structure but also the shape of Pd and Pt NCs. Small hydrogenation is still not clear. Deep insight into the behav-
adsorbates on the surface will affect the catalytic activity of ior of the small capping agents in catalytic hydrogenation
the as-prepared NCs. In some cases, the small adsorbates should be carried out in the future.
does not largely suppress the catalytic activity of noble-metals In addition to the functional molecules mentioned above,
during hydrogenation. With the presence of small adsorbates biomolecules were also introduced for the controllable prepa-
on the surface of noble-metal nanocatalysts, outstanding ration of noble-metal NCs. Programmable biomolecules, such
activity for catalytic hydrogenation was still achieved. For as peptides, DNA and proteins, have been employed to
instance, CO-capped Pd nanosheets showed superior activity achieve controllable nanostructures of noble-metals. It has
to PVP-capped Pd nanosheets for the conversion of styrene to been reported that some of the bio-inspired NCs can be used
ethylbenzene.28 Moreover, Pt3Co concave nanocubes and as catalysts for hydrogenation. Knecht’s lab27 succeeded in
shaped Pt3Ni NPs capped by oleylamine and CO exhibit good producing Pt and Pd NCs of varying morphologies via a
Fig. 3 (a) TEM, (b) HRTEM (top-right and top-middle insets show the corresponding FFT pattern and the ideal structure model), and (c) HAADF-
STEM images of PtNi2 octahedrons, corresponding element maps showing the distribution of Pt (yellow) and Ni (red). (d) Size distribution of octa-
hedral particles (average size: 11.8 ± 1.2 nm, 95% octahedrons and 5% irregular shapes). (e) TEM, (f) HRTEM, and (g) HAADF-STEM images of PtNi2
truncated octahedrons. (h) Size distribution of truncated octahedral particles (average size: 12.5 ± 1.1 nm, 90% truncated octahedrons and 10%
irregular shapes). (i) TEM, (j) HRTEM, and (k) HAADF-STEM images of PtNi2 cubes. (l) Size distribution of cubic particles (average size: 16.1 ± 1.7 nm,
95% octahedrons and 5% irregular shapes).40 Reprinted with permission from the American Chemical Society.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 | 2539
View Article Online
peptide-template-based approach. With the changed metal/ spherical dendritic polymers by Crooks et al.56,57 The results
peptide ratio employed during the synthesis, it is intriguing of high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM)
to discover that the Pd nanomaterials exhibited various mor- showed that the mean particle sizes of the obtained forty-atom
phologies while the Pt NCs remained spherical at all times. Pt and Pd DENs which were nearly monodisperse were 1.4 and
The NCs of Pt or Pd directed by R5 peptide 1.5 nm, respectively, but the shape of the NPs cannot be well-
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
(SSKKSGSYSGSKGSKRRIL) were further used for olefin hydro- controlled due to such small sizes.
genation with good activity. Moreover, Pt-{100} and Pt-{111}
binding peptides were developed to synthesize uniform plati- 2.3 Reducing agent
num nanocubes and nanotetrahedra by Huang’s group.55 The reducing agent plays a key role in controlling the nucle-
Investigation of this process indicates the origin of the pep- ation and growth of NCs by way of the reduction kinetics.
tide recognition toward Pt (111) and Pt (100) surfaces. When reduction is at a sufficiently high rate, the final prod-
3-hydroxybutyric acid (3-HB) and tropic acid (TA) were identi- uct will have no choice but to take the thermodynamically
fied as the dominant motif to specific binding of Pt {100} favored shapes. When reduction becomes substantially slow,
and Pt {111} facets, respectively.13 Therefore, uniform cubic however, the nucleation and growth will be under kinetic
and tetrahedral NCs of Pt were prepared, directed by 3-HB control and the final product can take a range of shapes devi-
and TA, respectively (Fig. 2). Li et al. investigated the catalytic ating from the thermodynamic ones (e.g., a structure with
performance of these bio-inspired Pt NCs with uniform facets high-index facets).14 By controlling the reaction kinetics of
for the hydrogenation of 4-nitrophenol (4-NP).19 seed-mediated growth, various NCs have been successfully
In addition, dendrimers were also applied in the synthesis prepared with a wide variety of structures.
of noble-metal NPs. For instance, platinum and palladium NaBH4 is the most widely used strong reducing agent
dendrimer-encapsulated NPs (DENs) were prepared within in metal salt solutions which directs the noble-metal ion
Fig. 4 (a–c) SA-corrected HRTEM images of (a) Pt3Ni@Au0.5, (b) Pt3Ni@Au2, and (c) Pt3Ni@Au8. (d–f) Elemental maps of (d) Pt3Ni@Au0.5,
(e) Pt3Ni@Au2, and (f) Pt3Ni@Au8. (g) Schematic illustration of the evolution from octahedral PtNi3 to Pt3Ni@M8 (M = Rh, Au, Ag, Cu). (h) Schematic
illustration of the growth of Au on the Pt surface.41 Reprinted with permission from the American Chemical Society.
2540 | Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015
View Article Online
growth to obtain metal NCs for hydrogenation applica- ODA is a useful all-in-one additive as a capping agent,
tions.2,19,21,23,24,27,32,57 Besides, alkanols and polyols are also solvent and reducing agent in the synthesis of NCs. Both Li’s
widely used in the synthesis of noble-metal NCs as a kind group47 and Zhang’s group30 used ODA for the direct thermal
of weak reducing agent. For example, benzylalcohol was decomposition of a noble-metal salt to fabricate various
used in the synthesis of shaped alloy NCs by Li’s group noble-metal NCs. A metal carbonyl, such as tungsten
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
(Fig. 3 and 4).40,41 Without the extra reducing agent, the alco- hexacarbonyl ijWIJCO)6], was used as the shape-directing
hol plays the roles of both reducing agent and solvent. agent and reducing agent.45 As discussed by Fang’s group,
Hou’s group58 found that highly dispersed Pt NCs could it was believed that tungsten decomposed from tungsten
be fabricated on the surface of graphene oxide (RGO) by a hexacarbonyl ijWIJCO)6] played a partial role in the formation
direct ethylene glycol reduction of PtCl62− without any addi- of the concave structure of Pt-based NCs. In addition, CO
tives in aqueous solution. Pt/RGO exhibited higher catalytic decomposed from metallic carbonyl will act as both reducing
properties for the selective hydrogenation of CO in cinnam- agent and capping agent absorbing on the surfaces of noble-
aldehyde than support-free Pt colloidal NCs. Studies found metal NCs.28,59
that the reducing power of an alcohol decreases as its alkyl
chain becomes longer. In a water-based system, the differ- 3. Activity and selectivity of faceted
ence in reducing power for these reagents enables one to
control the reduction kinetics, and thus the shape of noble-
noble-metal nanocrystals for
metal NCs. Moreover, PVP can also act like a long-chain alco- hydrogenation
hol and serve as a class of weak reducing agent.34,48
19,21,32,34 Size, morphology, and the residue of the additives on the sur-
L-Ascorbic acid (or sodium ascorbate) and citric
34,48 face of metallic NCs have been proven to be of immense
acid were also employed as reducing agents. L-Ascorbic
importance to their catalytic functionalities. Generation of
acid, which is commonly known as vitamin C, can serve as a
NCs with precise morphology and surface structure provides
strong reducing agent for the fast reduction of a noble-metal
a way to modify the proportion of different facets and the
precursor, while citric acid works as a reducing agent in a
number of atoms on the corners and edges. Then the activity
manner similar to the mechanism for a conventional citrate-
and selectivity of catalytic hydrogenation can be tuned, which
based synthesis of noble-metal NCs.
has been proven by many studies.32,60,61
Moreover, H2 (ref. 2,20,22–24 and 35) and CO28,42,44 were
employed as gaseous reducing agents for the synthesis of
noble-metal NCs for hydrogenation. With the introduction of 3.1 Pt nanocrystals
these gases, noble-metal NCs with clean surfaces can be Over the last decade, platinum has been widely studied due
easily obtained and the H2 or CO molecules adsorbed on the to its versatile and efficient catalytic properties. In this sec-
surface can be easily removed by applying a high temperature tion, we will briefly highlight recent important reports
or an electrochemical oxidation potential. concerning well-defined Pt NCs used in hydrogenation.
Fig. 5 TEM image of TTAB-stabilized (a) cubic particles (average size: 12.3 ± 1.4 nm, 79% cubes, 3% triangles, and 18% irregular shapes) and (c)
cuboctahedral particles (average size: 13.5 ± 1.5 nm, 90% cuboctahedra and 10% irregular shapes). TEM images of (b) cubic and (d) cuboctahedral
Pt NPs after reaction at 400 K for 10 Torr C6H6, 100 Torr H2, and 650 Torr Ar.2 Reprinted with permission from the American Chemical Society.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 | 2541
View Article Online
In 2006, Somorjai’s group and Yang’s group62 prepared Pt while only cyclohexane was produced on cubic Pt NPs cov-
NCs (cuboctahedra, cubes, and porous particles) capped with ered by only (100) facets. These results are consistent with a
alkylammonium ions by manipulating the reduction kinetics. previous study for single-crystal bulk Pt surfaces.1 The appar-
They found that the catalytic activity of these NPs for ethyl- ent activation energies for cyclohexane and cyclohexene for-
ene hydrogenation is superior to that of NCs whose shape mation on cuboctahedral NCs in the temperature ranges of
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
was controlled with a polymeric capping agent and foreign 310–340 K and 330–360 K are respectively equal to 8.3 ± 0.2
metal ions. Then, Somorjai’s group2 successfully confirmed and 12.2 ± 0.4 kcal mol−1. For cubic NPs, the apparent activa-
that the catalytic selectivity is significantly affected by the tion energy for cyclohexane formation in the temperature
shape of the NCs with the noted example of benzene hydro- range of 330–370 K is equal to 10.9 ± 0.4 kcal mol−1. The sig-
genation. The Pt NCs used in their study are shown in nificantly lower apparent activation energies and higher turn-
Fig. 5a and c. After hydrogenation, the shape of the NCs was over rates obtained with Pt NCs compared to Pt single crys-
only changed slightly as shown in Fig. 5b and d. Fig. 6 shows tals may be attributed to the decreased size or changes in the
a comparison between the kinetic data of TTAB-stabilized electronic structure of the NCs compared to the Pt single
cubic and cuboctahedral Pt NCs in the temperature range of crystals, rather than the corner and edge sites on the NCs
310–400 K. Both cyclohexene and cyclohexane were obtained available for catalysis, because Miyake et al. found that cor-
on Pt cuboctahedral NCs with both (111) and (100) facets ners and edges have a minor influence on the olefin hydroge-
nation activity of Pt NPs.22
The subsequent work of Somorjai’s group and Yang’s
group further confirmed that the morphology of the noble-
metal is really important for the chemoselectivity of hydroge-
nation. They studied the hydrogenation of ethylene and pyr-
role catalyzed by sub-10 nm Pt NCs with well-defined facets.18
In the examination of catalytic properties, the NCs were
supported in MCF-17 mesoporous silica. In ethylene hydroge-
nation, they found that smaller Pt NCs with more active sites
showed higher activity. For the hydrogenation of pyrrole, the
results showed that the shape of the NCs led to clear selectiv-
ity differences. n-Butylamine was the dominant product for 5
and 9 nm Pt nanocubes, while for the 5 nm Pt nano-
polyhedra, pyrrolidine (up to 30%) and n-butylamine were
both formed at lower temperatures (<400 K).
Furthermore, Somorjai’s group63 studied the hydrogena-
tion of furan over Pt (111) and Pt (100) to elucidate the cata-
lyst structure effect. Furan is a kind of five-membered ring
molecule which is of particular importance in the chemical
industry for both fuel reforming and environmental con-
cerns. The catalytic study of furan hydrogenation was first
carried out in 1949 by Smith and Fuzek over Adams platinum
(platinum dioxide reduced in hydrogen).64 The reaction path-
way for furan hydrogenation is shown in Scheme 2. In the
study by Kliewer et al.,63 the reaction was carried out on Pt
NCs of 1 nm, 3.5 nm, 7 nm to help determine the effect of
catalyst size. A powerful surface analysis technique - sum fre-
quency generation vibrational spectroscopy (SFG-VS) was
applied to systematically study the surface adsorped species
2542 | Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015
View Article Online
present on Pt (111) and Pt (100) during the selective hydroge- catalysts in a H2 atmosphere. Their investigation indicates
nation. As a result, in the spectra on Pt (111) the furan ring potential application to the hydrogenation of many unsatu-
is lying parallel to the metal surface upon the coadsorption rated hydrocarbons (olefins, aldehydes, ketones, organic
of furan and hydrogen. acids, imines, etc.).
Somorjai’s group in collaboration with Yang’s group pre- Pham Minh et al.23 prepared well-defined Pt NCs which
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
pared Pt nanocubes, nanocuboctahedra, and nanooctahedra were deposited on alumina for the selective hydrogenation of
by the addition of silver ions which enhanced the crystal buta-1,3-diene. In their synthesis, the morphology of the Pt
growth rate along <100>.65 They encapsulated the Pt NCs in NCs was dependent on the synthesis conditions such as tem-
mesoporous silica (SBA-15) by in situ hydrothermal growth. perature, atmosphere and the ratio of cationic surfactant and
The catalysts are active for ethylene hydrogenation.62 Then, a Pt. The Pt nanocatalyst (polyhedric morphologies) exposed
procedure was developed for the selective etching of silver mainly the (111) crystallographic plane and had the highest
from these shaped Pt NCs, resulting in the formation of selectivity for the hydrogenation of buta-1,3-diene to butenes
nearly elementally pure Pt nanocubes, nanocuboctahedra, or with a drastic decrease of further hydrogenation to n-butane.
nanooctahedra, with a largest vertex-to-vertex distance of Sepúlveda-Escribano and co-workers24 evaluated the effect
~9.5 nm from the Ag-modified Pt NCs. Subsequently, they of uniform Pt NCs with (100) or (111) crystal faces on the cat-
found that the activity of these Pt NCs for ethylene hydrogena- alytic hydrogenation of crotonaldehyde and cinnamaldehyde,
tion increased exponentially with a decreasing Ag/Pts ratio.66 respectively (Scheme 4). They found that Pt(100)/C showed
Their results confirmed that Ag used in the synthesis of the best catalytic activity among the Pt/C and Pt(111)/C cata-
shaped Pt NCs is confined to the surface and could be selec- lysts for crotonaldehyde hydrogenation at 333 K, as shown in
tively removed to produce highly active surface-clean Pt nano- Fig. 7. The conversion of cinnamaldehyde hydrogenation
catalysts for hydrocarbon conversion. followed the trend Pt/C > Pt(100)/C > Pt(111)/C.
Then, Somorjai and Yang67 discussed the catalytic proper- The effects of shape and support on the catalytic activity
ties of uniform Pt NCs which were deposited on the surface of Pt NCs for 4-nitrophenol (4-NP) hydrogenation were stud-
of capping-agent-free CeO2 nanooctahedra and nanorods ied by our group by comparing kinetic results. The catalytic
using an electron beam (e-beam) evaporation strategy. Cover-
age of the Pt nanocluster layer can be controlled by adjusting
the e-beam evaporation time. Finally, the results of hydroge-
nation of ethylene and cyclohexene clearly showed similar
activation energies for both Pt/CeO2 nanooctahedra and
Pt/CeO2 nanorods, but their results are not conclusive enough
to determine the dominant crystal facets of the Pt NCs.
Additionally, their groups reported the preparation of
Pt/mesoporous silica core–shell (Pt@mSiO2) NPs with ther-
mal stability at high temperatures (Scheme 3). The synthe-
sized Pt@mSiO2 nanopartices that consist of 14 nm Pt cores
and 17 nm-thick mesoporous silica shells have high thermal
stability and are as catalytically active as bare Pt metal for
ethylene hydrogenation.26
Zaera’s group used colloidal and sol–gel procedures to
prepare platinum NCs with narrow size distributions and well
defined shapes dispersed on high-surface-area silica sup- Scheme 4 Reaction pathways for cinnamaldehyde hydrogenation.24
ports.20 Double-bond isomerizations were studied on the Pt Reprinted with permission from Elsevier.
Scheme 3 Schematic representation of the synthesis of t@mSiO2 NPs. Pt NPs were synthesized using TTAB surfactant as the capping agent, and
used as the core particle. Second, as-synthesized Pt@SiO2 particles were prepared by polymerizing TEOS around the TTAB-capped Pt cores. RT:
room temperature. The as-synthesized Pt@SiO2 particles were subsequently converted to Pt@mSiO2 particles by calcination.26 Reprinted with per-
mission from the Nature Publishing Group.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 | 2543
View Article Online
Table 2 Parameters of the L–H model obtained at 25 °C, 40 °C and 70 °C under 0.4 MPa and corresponding apparent activation energy for cubic
Pt(3-HB) NCs and pseudo-tetrahedral Pt(TA) NCs.19
dC A k1K A K B3CACB3
r1
1 K ACA 1 K B1/ 2CB1/ 2
6
dt
2544 | Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015
View Article Online
Fig. 9 TEM images and (inset) selected area electron diffraction (SAED) of (A, B) FePt and (C, D) Pt nanowires and (E) XRD patterns of the as-
synthesized (—) FePt and (—) Pt nanowires.25 Reprinted with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry.
Scheme 5 Asymmetric hydrogenation of ethylbenzoyl formate over alkaloid-modified Pt nanowires.25 Reprinted with permission from the Royal
Society of Chemistry.
Fig. 10 (a) Schematic illustrations of the shaped Pd NPs and their two types of active sites involved in the hydrogenation of MBY. Atoms on
the planes, regardless of their crystallographic orientations, constitute the first type of active site, σ1. Low-coordination atoms, or atoms at the
edges, represent the second type of active site, σ2. (b) Modified reaction network for the hydrogenation of MBY, showing the active sites involved
in each path. (c) Optimization of Pd nanocrystal size and shape based on productivity of MBE.34 Reprinted with permission from the American
Chemical Society.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 | 2545
View Article Online
in this research area should be continued, and then noble- Recently, Knecht’s lab27 succeeded in producing Pt and
metal nanocatalysts with superior performance in hydrogena- Pd NCs of varying morphologies using R5 peptide which were
tion will be fabricated. highly reactive for allyl alcohol hydrogenation. They found
that peptides do not inhibit the reactivity of Pt and Pd NCs.
In addition, the material templates are efficient tools
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
3.2 Pd nanocrystals exploited to overcome the issue that the stabilizing agents
Pd NCs have been employed as catalysts for a variety of reac- prejudice the reagent diffusion. Actually a variety of material
tions including the hydrogenation of 4-nitrophenol, olefin, templates such as resins and polyelectrolytes were used to
and so on. As early as 2004, Chaudhari’s group33 reported maintain an open/porous structure of metal nanocatalysts to
that much higher turnover frequencies were found for the facilitate the catalytic reactivity.
hydrogenation of 2-butyne-1,4-diol with Pd nanocubes (5–7 nm) Tilley’s group synthesized highly branched palladium
than nanospheres (1–7 nm). They showed that both catalytic nanostructures in toluene solution with organic surfactant at
activity and selectivity was affected by the shape of Pd NCs for room temperature.35 As shown in Fig. 11, high index (113)
the hydrogenation of 2-butyne-1, 4-diol into 2-butene-1,4-diol.
Crooks’ lab69 studied the particle size effect for hydroge-
nation over unsupported Pd NPs in the size range of 1.3–1.9 nm.
They demonstrated that the rate of hydrogenation of allyl
alcohol is a function of the diameter of the Pd NPs. The
hydrogenation kinetics are dominated by electronic effects
for the smallest particles (<1.5 nm diameter) and by geomet-
ric effects for larger particles (1.5–1.9 nm diameter).
Previous studies showed that the hydrogenation of buta-
1,3-diene is a structure-sensitive reaction. Berhault’s group31
synthesized uniform Pd NCs by a “seeding-mediated” meth-
odology and applied them to the selective hydrogenation of
buta-1,3-diene. CTAB was exploited as both a capping and
structure-directing agent in the process, which induced the
anisotropic Pd nanorods to expose (100) facets preferentially.
The results showed that Pd (100) surfaces are particularly
selective for the hydrogenation of dienes to alkenes without
further hydrogenation to alkanes. In comparison, previous
studies on bulk Pd surfaces indicated that Pd (110) exhibits a
higher selectivity for butene formation than Pd (111) facets.70
It can be deduced that the facet effect may be totally different
between nanocrystals and bulk material in hydrogenation.
Kiwi-Minsker’s group and Xia’s group34 prepared Pd NCs
with well-defined shapes and used them in the selective
hydrogenation of 2-methyl-3-butyn-2-ol (MBY). In their work,
semihydrogenation of MBY to 2-methyl-3-buten-2-ol (MBE)
occurred preferentially at the plane sites regardless of the
crystallographic orientation, while overhydrogenation to
2-methyl-3-butan-2-ol (MBA) occurred mainly at the edge
sites, as displayed in Fig. 10. Obviously, the selectivity was
then associated to the fraction of edge sites on each type
of NC. Coupled with the kinetic simulations, 3–5 nm cubic
Pd NCs were an optimal catalyst for the highest production
of MBE.
Zheng’s group28 mixed a Pd carbonyl complex, ijPd2IJμ-
CO)2Cl4]2−, and H2O without any organic capping agents to
fabricate ultrathin Pd nanosheets (1.8nm). The surface-clean
Pd nanosheets supported on carbon nanotubes (CNT) Fig. 11 Analysis of the surface of one of the highly branched
showed higher activities for the hydrogenation of styrene in nanostructures. (a) HRTEM image of one of the particle branches; (b)
HRTEM image of the particle branch showing clear atomic packing. The
comparison to the PVP-capped Pd nanosheets. Further experi-
black arrows point to atomic vacancies on the particle surface.
ments proved that PVP partially blocks the active sites, which (c) Schematic showing how the atomic vacancies lead to high index
is consistent with the results of Kiwi-Minsker and co-workers29 (113) facets.35 Reprinted with permission from the American Chemical
reported in 2010. Society.
2546 | Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015
View Article Online
Table 3 Comparison of catalytic activity and selectivity of Rh on charcoal for the hydrogenation of anthracenea
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
Fig. 12 TEM and (a) HRTEM (b–e) images of 13.5 nm Rh NCs.39 Reprinted with permission from the American Chemical Society.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 | 2547
View Article Online
2548 | Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015
View Article Online
heterostructures exhibit extraordinarily high selectivities for NCs demonstrated a higher activity than the {111}-facet-
carbonyl reduction in α,β-unsaturated aldehydes (such as bounded PtPd NCs. In comparison, {111}-facet-covered
cinnamaldehyde and citral). The results showed that terminal PtxNi1−x(0 < x < 1) showed higher activity than that with
CO hydrogenation can be achieved with high activity, while {100} facets in the hydrogenation of benzalacetone.40 More-
the undesirable hydrogenation of the CC group can be over, tetrahedral Pt NCs with (111) facets were more active
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
totally suppressed by certain Co decoration on Pt NPs. Later, than cubic Pt NCs with (100) facets in the hydrogenation of
amine-capped truncated octahedral Pt3Co nanocatalysts were 4-nitrophenol.19 Therefore, it can be deduced that the active
synthesized and used by the groups of Zheng and Fu.42 facets are totally different for various compositions of noble-
Capping a Pt3Co (100) surface with amines that contain long metal NCs in different hydrogenation reactions.
carbon chains results in an ordered surface “array” (see Furthermore, Fang and colleagues reported the synthesis
Scheme 8), in which high selectivity towards CO hydroge- of high-quality Pt3Co concave nanocubes terminated with
nation can be achieved because the CC bond in cinnam- high-index crystal facets (Fig. 16).45 These Pt3Co concave
aldehyde does not interact with the surface. The results nanocubes as a new class of nanocatalysts exhibited enhanced
showed the longer the carbon chains in the amine, the catalytic activity in comparison with low-indexed surface
higher the selectivity.
Huang and co-workers43 prepared single-crystalline PtPd
NCs with controllable shapes (namely {111}-terminated and
cubic shapes) and tunable compositions. The obtained PtPd
NCs exhibited high activity in the hydrogenation of nitroben-
zene, and their performance is highly shape- and composition-
dependent with Pt in ∼50% showing the optimum activity
(Fig. 15). It is interesting that the {100}-facet-enclosed PtPd
Fig. 15 Catalytic results of nitrobenzene hydrogenation using various PtPd NCs.43 Reprinted with permission from the American Chemical
Society.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 | 2549
View Article Online
2550 | Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015
View Article Online
Benzene Hydrogenation, J. Phys. Chem. B, 2006, 110, 23 D. Pham Minh, Y. Oudart, B. Baubet, C. Verdon and C.
10051–10057. Thomazeau, Nanostructured heterogeneous catalysts: well
6 J. Oudar, Hydrogenation reactions on platinum single defined platinum nanoparticles supported on alumina.
crystals, Z. Phys. Chem., 1996, 197, 125–136. preparation, characterization and application to the selective
7 M. Englisch, A. Jentys and J. A. Lercher, Structure sensitivity hydrogenation of buta-1, 3-diene, Oil Gas Sci. Technol.,
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 | 2551
View Article Online
35 J. Watt, S. Cheong, M. F. Toney, B. Ingham, J. Cookson, P. T. 49 J. Solla-Gullon, V. Montiel, A. Aldaz and J. Clavilier,
Bishop and R. D. Tilley, Ultrafast growth of highly branched Electrochemical characterisation of platinum nanoparticles
palladium nanostructures for catalysis, ACS Nano, 2009, 4, prepared by microemulsion: how to clean them without loss
396–402. of crystalline surface structure, J. Electroanal. Chem.,
36 J. Silvestre-Albero, G. Rupprechter and H.-J. Freund, 2000, 491, 69–77.
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
2552 | Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015
View Article Online
sum frequency generation vibrational spectroscopy study, catalyzed selective hydrogenation of o-chloronitrobenzene,
J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2010, 132, 13088–13095. J. Catal., 2007, 250, 25–32.
64 H. A. Smith and J. F. Fuzek, Catalytic hydrogenation of furan 69 O. M. Wilson, M. R. Knecht, J. C. Garcia-Martinez and R. M.
and substituted furans on platinum, J. Am. Chem. Soc., Crooks, Effect of Pd nanoparticle size on the catalytic
1949, 71, 415–419. hydrogenation of allyl alcohol, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2006, 128,
Published on 11 March 2015. Downloaded by Hindustan Petroleum Green R&D Centre on 6/18/2020 9:00:35 AM.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 Catal. Sci. Technol., 2015, 5, 2532–2553 | 2553