Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Alberto Castellanos Project
Alberto Castellanos Project
Athabasca University
Page 1 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Executive Summary:
The applied project analyzed the short-term strategies to forecast future demand
and new potential customers. The City of Oaxaca in the south of Mexico has
been selected as a starting point. The project includes company value
proposition, values, business goals, and objectives to be achieved. Products and
services to be provided are described as well.
Environmental scanning was developed in order to identify trends and events that
can influence the project. The Marketing strategy includes:
• Typical buyers
• Market segmentation
• Psychological and sociological factors
• Target market
• Size of the market
The Marketing plan focuses in the target niche market and product offerings to
attract buyers. The Marketing plan includes:
• Price strategy
• Price structure
• Advertising
The Production and operation plan was developed to take advantage of the
critical success factors – order winner and qualifiers.
Page 2 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
• Limited partnership
• Financing
• Taxation
• Insurance program
Time frame and expected costs are described under the implementation
schedule. The Implementation schedule spans over two years.
• Sources of capital
• Expected profit in the first year of operations
• Financial projections and ratios
• Break-even analysis
• Divestiture/ harvest strategy
Risk types are identified under a specific risk analysis framework. Description,
scope, and management of the risk are described under four different categories.
Major findings includes the identification of a growing market for vacation homes
in sunny Mexico, but mostly in coastal development and established expatriate
communities. This type of business is capital intensive and financial forecasts do
not demonstrate high return on investment in the first year of operation, making it
difficult to obtain sources of capital for the short-term. Other findings include
risks associated with political and security concerns for potential buyers and tax
implications for investors. Coastal developments offer a better outlook and
growth opportunities than inland communities. A Strategic decision concerning
where to invest is now required to be made if the project should go forward.
Page 3 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
TABLE OF CONTENTS
13.0 CONCLUSION...............................................................................................46
15.0 BIBLIOGRAPHY............................................................................................51
16.0 APPENDICES................................................................................................52
Page 4 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Property management and related services are the focus of this business plan.
Related services complement the value proposition. The starting point of the
business is the City of Oaxaca and the concept of strong community ties is at the
centre of the business model. The growing community of expatriates and high
demand for residential real estate gave rise to the idea.
Page 5 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
The marketing plan identifies the unique features, the target niche market, and
the reasons for the attractiveness of the services provided. Price structure and
strategy are described. Advertising through the Internet would be used with
potential links to various sites. The proposed promotional slogan is included and
significant advertising efforts would be required to build awareness. Public
relations and communication strategies are described, as well as distribution
channels.
Production and operation plans identify critical success factors and operational
priorities for this type of business: safe investment, communication, location,
dependability, and flexibility. Also included are growth opportunity, delivery
speed, and price.
Factors affecting organizational form are evaluated in order to select the best
alternative. Advantages and disadvantages of limited partnerships are explained
for both Canada and Mexico. Taxation affects the way foreign operations are
financed. Debt financing was selected in order to avoid double taxation. An
insurance program is presented for basic protection of the new venture.
The implementation schedule for the venture has been broken down into four
distinct phases: conceptual, preliminary, development, and growth. Each of
these phases includes the time frame and expected costs.
The financial plan includes arranging financing from several sources to raise the
required capital. Business is expected to generate $9,300 after taxes in the first
year of operation. Ramp-up is planned for the second year of operation. Start-up
financial requirements are also laid out. Financial projections include cash flow,
income statement, balance sheet, and financial ratios. Break-even analysis is
included as well as divestiture/harvest strategy with four options.
Risk type is identified using Hartman’s basic steps for risk analysis. Description,
scope, and management of risk are covered. Categories of risk include business
related, environment related, and project related.
Page 6 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Page 7 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Destinations include not only coastal locations, but inland communities, such as
San Miguel de Allende and Lake Chapala (Cooper, 2006).7 These two
communities have attracted Canadians looking for pockets of foreigners where
English is widely spoken. San Miguel, an artist’s haven, alone has an expatriate
community of 10,000 Americans and Canadians. An estimated 20,000 North
Americans now live in the lakeside community of Ajijic, an hour southeast of
Guadalajara (Huang, 2005).8
Another tourist destination is the City of Oaxaca de Juárez (Oaxaca); the capital
of the State of Oaxaca in the south of Mexico. ("Oaxaca", pronounced wa-HA-
ka, comes from the Nahuatl word "Huaxacac”, meaning "in the nose of the
Page 8 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
squash.") The city, with its 256,848 inhabitants, is located in the centre of the
state just four hours drive from Mexico City. The state is bounded to the north by
the states of Veracruz and Puebla, to the east by Chiapas, to the west by
Guerrero, and to the south by the Pacific Ocean.
Tourism is one of the principal sources of income for the residents of Oaxaca
(“Municipio de Oaxaca,” 2004).9 One of the first cities established by the Spanish
conquistadores, Oaxaca is also steeped in the Mixtec and Zapotec indigenous
cultures, and offers a unique combination of colonial architecture and pre-
Hispanic ruins. Oaxaca also has a growing community of expatriates located in
the north of the city that has been well-received by the city’s local population.
They enjoy the city’s year round spring-like climate, the scenery, architecture,
cuisine, and a multitude of cultural and artistic centres and events.
Page 9 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
The company’s vision is to create a property management entity that sells, rents,
or manages private vacation or second home real estate in unique locations that
offer a variety of activities and cultural experiences.
• Secure Investment
• Responsibility towards the community
• Unique experiences
• Accessible destinations
• Ease of airlift potential
• Competent partners
• Safe surroundings
• Environmental sustainability
• Superior quality.
Page 10 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
The following criteria will be used to measure the ability to achieve the company
mission:
Page 11 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
These services would be provided primarily in the north of the city where the
American and Canadian expatriate community is currently located, but other
locations within the city would also be investigated. Existing as well as potential
members of the expatriate community would be targeted.
The concept of strong community ties is at the centre of the business model.
Page 12 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Page 13 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Fred R. David (2001) argues that no organization can plan in detail every aspect
of its current or future actions, but all organizations can benefit from knowing the
general direction in which they are headed and the ways to get there.13 It is a
fact that changes in external forces translate into changes in consumer demand
for both products and services. External forces affect the type of products
developed, the nature of positioning and market segmentation strategies, the
type of services offered and businesses’ decisions to acquire or sell. Identifying
and evaluating external opportunities and threats enable organizations to
develop clear strategies and to achieve long term objectives. A framework to
develop an external audit is a vital part of the strategic management process.
Information to be reviewed includes:
• Economic;
• Social, cultural, demographic, and environmental;
• Political, governmental and legal;
• Technological; and
• Competitive forces.
Environmental scanning helps to identify and evaluate the trends and events
beyond the control of the organization.
Real estate for second home and property vacation homes demand in Mexico is
being fueled by U.S. residents flush with cash from rising stocks and five-year
surge in home value, according to Mitch Creekmore, director of International
Development for Steward Title Guaranty, which insures $3 billion of property in
Mexico. (Black, 2006)14
Page 14 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Lenders know there is a huge niche south of the border and have begun to
jockey for position in some of the more attractive markets. Lenders now offer
fixed rate and adjustable rate mortgage programs for primary and secondary
home buyers under its “Mexico: my dream” campaign, which debuted last year.
(Kelly, 2006)17
As a reference, baby boomers are now nearing retirement age and are
increasing the demand for second homes. It is likely that second-home sales will
remain historically high over the next decade. The National Association of
Realtors (NAR) reported 43.8 million second homes, out of which 37.2 million
were found to be investment homes and 6.6 million vacation homes. 23 percent
of all homes purchased in 2004 were for investment purposes, and another 13
percent were vacation homes. In 2003, second home sales went up by 16
percent, investment homes up by 14 percent and vacation homes up by 20
percent. (Reeves, 2005)18 Last year, vacation homes and investment properties
made up about 36 percent of all real estate sales, or about $560 billion. (Neville,
2005)19 Property management has been beneficed because homeowners pay
about 25% commission on all rental income to property management companies.
In exchange property management companies are on duty 24/7, to book guests
and check them in and out, to see that the small details such as windows are
washed or snow removed, and to call in a repairman when the roof leaks or the
dishwasher breaks. (Bennett, 2005)20
A little more than a decade ago, Mexico underwent a currency crisis that saw the
Peso collapse, followed by an economic downturn. Since that time, however, the
Mexican economy has seen a steady economic growth of 5 percent in 2005 with
inflation rarely reaching more than 5 percent. Much of this success can be
attributed to the North American Free Trade Agreement, as Mexico is one of the
largest trading partners of the United States and Canada. Still, should another
Page 15 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
devaluation of the peso occur, an investor in Mexico will likely emerge from it
unscathed. (Smith, 2006)21
According to Mexico’s National Trust Fund for Tourism Development, the five
largest projects geared for U.S. customers should yield $5 billion in investment by
developers and homebuyers over the next 15 years. A Mexican real estate
investment can provide a hedge against rising prices. (Young, 2006)22
The state of Oaxaca offers great retirement opportunities with a reasonable cost
of living, low property taxes and minimal need for climate control.
Baby boomers, the 76 million Americans born from 1946 to 1964 who make up
29 percent of the U.S. population, stand to inherit more than $70 billion from their
parents, and much of that will be spent on real estate. Baby boomers are using
their savings or equity from rising U.S. home prices to buy across the border.
Mexico has relaxed its foreign investment laws and U.S. companies have begun
offering escrow services and title insurance reducing risk. This change in
Mexico’s real estate climate is drawing U.S. developers including Donald Trump,
David Butterfield, and John Fair to build communities on the Baja peninsula.
(Black, 2006) 23
During the last five years, the Mexican government under President Vicente Fox
Page 16 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
has cracked down on corruption and real estate bribes. This has created a safer
environment for real estate business. Recently, for the second time since 1910, a
conservative President was elected and he is probably going to continue the
same policies.
Overall, however, lending in Mexico has become much more attractive to lenders
and safer for consumers.
Page 17 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Baja California has the largest population of expatriates at 62,829. The Federal
District (Mexico City) is the second largest with 56,187 expatriates followed by
Jalisco with 48,989 and Chihuahua with 44,436. Oaxaca only registered 4,591
expatriates or 1% of all the expatriate residents in Mexico. The expatriate
population has seen a steady growth of 0.04% since 1990. In 2000, the
expatriate population grew by 0.1% and is expected to continue growing,
especially in established locations such as Baja California, Jalisco, Mexico City
and Chihuahua. Typical real estate buyers are baby boomers that are near
retirement and looking for second homes or vacations homes, or for investment
opportunities.
• International developments
• Communities
• New developments
• Florida-styles retirement communities
• Fonatur
Page 18 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
The principal market is located in the City of Oaxaca in the first phase of the
project. Actual total market size is about 4,591 based on the number of
expatriates living in Oaxaca in 2000. The market is scattered throughout the city
and surroundings without a typical pattern of specific location. Market size has
grown at 1% per year from 1990 to 2000. Therefore there are 50 potential
customers for properties in the city in the coming year. Total market size in US
dollars is $15,000,000 using an average price of $325,000 per residence.
The key direct competitor in the area is URBIC Constructions – Joaquin Solis
Altamirano.28 The estimated market share is unknown. Products or services
offered include:
• Investment management
• Property acquisition
• Sales and promotion
• Property management
• Surveying
• Property appraisal
Page 19 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
• Land for sale in the area surrounding the city - $6.50 per m2
• Land for sale in coastal areas - $300 per m2
• Land and property within the city - $286 per m2
Its profit margin is approximately between 30 to 50% and it does not emphasize a
low selling price. Expected retaliation could include price lowering and increased
promotion and advertising.
Page 20 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Kotler (2003) states that the traditional view of the business process will not work
in more competitive economies where people face abundant choices. The mass-
market is actually splintering into numerous micro markets, each with its own
wants, perceptions, preferences and buying criteria.32 The marketing strategy
could be defined as follows:
The concept is unique because it strives to tailor the second home buying
experience to the individual's taste and preference. Its focus is on international
buyers that are looking for a potential investment in either an emerging or
established location. The concept is strengthened by forming long standing
partnerships with communities and employees with the obligation to protect the
environment. It is distinctive from other concepts because it caters to a market
niche with individual clients and individual experience. The primary customers
are baby boomers who enjoy new cultural experiences and at the same time
want a good return on their investment. The concept combines two ideas into
one opportunity. On the one hand, it provides a winter destination, and on the
other captures the growing market of expatriates willing to purchase second
homes in sunny Mexico. If the idea is technically feasible, a property residence
would be built as a first step to demonstrate quality standards and unique design.
Page 21 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Warranties would be subject to local laws, but additional services free of charge
would include free translation and consulting regarding references and
networking.
The products and services are unique because of the following features:
Page 22 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
The target customers are baby boomers near retirement age with a median age
of 50 that have sufficient income and net worth to acquire a second home and
have an interest in diversifying their investments.
The following is a list of reasons why customers will buy company products and
services:
Page 23 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
New properties based on design specification and needs are unique services that
should be priced as value-based instead of competition-based.
Value-based pricing is the perceived value the customer places on services. The
price is determined by analysing customer needs and value perceptions that
involve availability, image, and warranty considerations. Differentiating factors
include availability, location, image, quality and reliability.
Pricing strategy will include the cost of the land and the cost of construction. The
average cost of land is US$150 per m2 and US$300 per m2 for construction.
The price includes 5 percent for project management services and 10 percent for
architectural design and engineering.
7.3 Advertising
• Domain name
• File registration request
• Reliable web server to house the site
• Links leading to the site by listing with directories and hotlines
There are different sites that promote living in Mexico and offer financial, legal, or
cooperative advertising programs. A direct link to the company's website would
be preferred. Cooperative advertising websites include:
Page 24 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
7.4 Promotion
Page 25 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Distribution of the products will be directly to the consumers. The company will
use its own sales force in the beginning and start using agents and brokers once
more products are available.
Page 26 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Critical success factors include those activities that must be performed if the
organization wishes to achieve its long term objectives. Critical success factors
or performance objectives are designed to satisfy the market they attempt to
serve. Nigel Slack, Stuart Chambers and Robert Johnston (2001) classify critical
success factors into two categories:38
Identifying and classifying the critical success factors would enable the
organization to gain a competitive advantage.
Page 27 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
The Speed Advantage means providing the services promptly and without delay
– minimizing the time between a customer asking for services and receiving them
in full. Internally, speed reduces risk by delaying resources commitment.
Dependability Advantage means delivering the services when and as they were
promised. In other words, it means keeping the delivery promises you have
made to your customers. Internally, dependability increases operational
reliability, thus saving the time and money that would otherwise be taken up in
solving reliability problems, and also provides stability to the operation.
Page 28 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
The Flexibility Advantage means the ability to vary or adapt the operational
activities to cope with unexpected circumstances or to give customers individual
attention. Hence, the range of goods and services that you produce has to be
wide enough to deal with all possible customer preferences. Change far enough
and fast enough to meet customer requirements. Internally, flexibility can help
speed up the response time by saving time that would otherwise be wasted in
changeovers and maintaining dependability.
• Highly skilled personnel that are able to resolve problems. The ability to train
highly skilled personnel.
Cost Advantage – means minimizing costs, that is to produce goods and services
at a cost that enables them to be priced appropriately for the market while still
asking for a return to the organization. Internally, cost advantage is helped by
good performance in the other performance objectives.
• Price – the total charge to the customer. The lower the cost of producing the
goods and services, the lower they can be priced to the customers.
Page 29 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Order Less
Qualifiers
Competitive factors winners important
Safe Investment
Growth Opportunity
Communications
Documentation
Delivery Speed
Location
Dependability
Flexibility
High Skilled Personnel
Price
To address the owner order winner qualifiers, it is important to separate them into
two categories. The first category can be achieved through planning and
searching for the best options on the market (safe investment and location). The
second category can be achieved through training and project team
development. A review of the internal process is required in order to increase
communication, flexibility, and dependability.
Charles R. Greer (2000) states that human resources strategies are essentially
plans and programs that address and resolve fundamental strategic issues
related to human resources management. Human resource strategy focuses on
the alignment of the organization’s human resources practices, policies, and
programs with corporate and strategic business plans. Increasingly, it is being
recognized that competitive advantage can be obtained with a high-quality
workforce, which enables organizations to compete on the basis of market
responsiveness, products and service quality, differentiated products, and
technological innovation, instead of reliance on low costs.40 A comprehensive
theoretical framework can be used in order for human resource strategy to help
Page 30 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
align personnel practices, policies, and programs with the human resource
strategy so that the desired employee roles and characteristics will support
company strategy (Hartman, 2006).41
Ownership of your work – having control of your work and balancing the needs
of an individual against those of the team.
Creativity – it attracts the best people to the organization and keeps them
motivated. Creativity needs encouragement, focus, and natural leaders as well
as general awareness within the company.
Fun – it starts with open communication and creativity. Team members having
fun are much more productive and motivated.
Tribalism – people feel good when they belong to a tribe. Each tribe has its own
language, culture, dress code, hierarchy, taboos, and traditions. It is part of our
heritage and it is a powerful tool in bringing people together.
Trust – it is the glue that binds us into more effective teams. It is a necessary
condition for meeting targets, collaboration, improvements, and competence.
Page 31 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Anthony A. Atkinson, Robert S. Kaplan, and S. Mark Young (2000) contend that
in response to today’s increasing competitive pressures, organizations are
changing the way they are organized and the way they do business.42 This is
necessary because they must be able to change quickly in a world where
technology, customer tastes, and competitors’ strategies are constantly
changing. Being adaptive generally requires that the organization’s senior
management delegate or decentralize decision-making responsibility to people in
the organization. Decentralization allows motivated and well-trained organization
members to identify changing customer needs quickly and gives frontline
employees the authority and responsibility to develop plans to react to these
changes.
The legal form of organization involves several factors to be considered, such as:
Page 32 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
• The need for capital and operating funds from different sources – funds to be
considered after start up costs.
After considering all these factors, the most appropriate form of partnership in
Canada is a limited partnership. The liability of a partner in a limited partnership
is limited to the partner’s own contribution to the capital of the business. Also,
limited partners are limited in their participation in the day-to-day management of
the business or they will lose their limited-liability status, but they have the ability
to remove the general partners.
Page 33 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
The existence of bilateral tax treaties and the subsequent application of tax rules
can significantly enhance the overall net funds available to multinational
companies from the invested country. International taxation is one of the
variables that multinational corporations should take into consideration when
financing overseas projects. In determining the total taxes to be paid by a
multinational company, the level of taxable income must be calculated.
Page 34 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
foreign income as interest in the year it is generated. The home country tax rate
will likely apply because interest payments may make it possible to reduce the
foreign operation’s taxable income to zero.
9.3 Insurance
Page 35 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Page 36 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
There are relatively few sources of seed capital for ventures that are just starting
and do not have a track record. Combining financing from several sources to
raise capital is required.
Banks can provide debt financing in the form of self-liquidating, short-term loans
to cover small business working capital requirements in the form of a line of
credit. With an operating loan, credit is extended up to a prearranged limit on an
ongoing basis to cover day-to-day expenses due to cyclical incomes.
Furthermore, a line of credit can give you the advantage of a discount for prompt
payment.
Page 37 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Personal funds will be used in the business. The first land acquisition will be
financed through a combination of personal and family funds. All of the terms
and conditions of the investment will have to be set out in a formal legal
agreement. The legal agreement will include the nature of the business, detailed
implementation plans, and risks associated with the venture.
Family business orientation has the advantage of obtaining funds from family
sources with the understanding of limited liability, limited participation in the day-
to day management of the business, and mutual agreement of all partners.
Moreover, family members located in different countries can take advantage of
tax laws.
• Price – value of the business, value prepared to accept, and value prepared
to consider.
• Control – managing the risk by putting some controls in place to protect their
investment, such as ability to make financial decisions, representation on the
board of directors, equity to give up based on predetermined performance
based targets, first opportunity to participate in the sale of equity, and ban on
the sale of future shares without limited partnership agreement
• Establishment of performance expectations – specific milestones and
objectives and performance measures
• Exit strategy – available option to cash in their investment such as:
acquisition by a third party, sale of the investor interest to third party investors,
buy-back agreement, and management of employee buyout.
Page 38 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Calculating funds available to launch the start up phase of the business includes:
Page 39 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
One time expenditures – expenditures must be made before the business can
open its doors. These include capital expenditures and soft costs as disclosed in
Table 12.1
ITEM
1. Owner's Salary -1,667 3 -5,000
2. Employees' Wages and Salaries -3,750 3 -11,250
3. Rent -376 3 -1,127
4. Advertising and Promotion -524 3 -1,572
5. Delivery Expense -215 3 -644
6. Supplies and Postage -270 3 -810
7. Telephone -939 3 -2,818
8. Utilities (Heat, Light, Power) -671 3 -2,013
9. Insurance -537 3 -1,610
10. Taxes including employment insurance -2,147 4 -8,587
11. Interest -1,342 3 -4,025
12. Professional, Legal and Accounting Fees -1,878 3 -5,635
13. Maintenance Expense -617 3 -1,852
14. Other Fixed Expenses -1,020 3 -3,059
A. TOTAL CASH REQUIRED FOR MONTHLY -15,951 -50,000
RECURRING EXPENSES
*Expenses and other payments should be entered as negative (-) numbers.
Page 40 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Detailed financial projections are provided under Exhibit No.1 and No.2. As
indicated, Property Management Services are expected to require $350,000 in
the first year of operations, primarily due to land acquisition, construction fees,
and professional services, such as architectural and engineering. The business
Page 41 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Break-Even Analysis
As indicated in the Cash Flow projection under Exhibit No.2, the initial bank loan
and the $27,000 investment give operations more than adequate cash flow. This
gives the business the advantage of paying debt more aggressively and the
possibility of launching additional properties. Equity will not be paid to the owner
initially in order to maximize funds available for growth. The current and debt
ratio provide evidence that there should not be problems meeting financial
obligations going forward. If cash is drawn down due to equity distribution, it will
be done under the condition that the current ratio be maintained at a minimum of
2:1.
Real options are opportunities that are embedded in capital projects that enable
managers to alter their cash flow and risk in a way that affects project
acceptability (NPV). These options are described below and they will be used to
assess the feasibility of the business plan:
Page 42 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
the end of its planned life will be considered prior to initiating the construction
phase where the bulk of resources would be committed. Land could be sold
and proceeds of the sale will be used to pay off the debt obligations of the
business and any remaining funds will be used to pay the owners
• Flexibility option – Flexibility is incorporated into the organization’s
operations by virtue of the different services provided by the company.
Flexibility would allow the company to focus on the more profitable niches.
• Growth option – The option to develop follow-on projects, expand markets,
and so on includes property developments in the coastal areas after year two
of the implementation schedule. Project feasibility indicates that the growth
option should be pursued.
• Timing option – The timing option recognizes the organization’s opportunity
to delay acceptance of a project for one or more periods, to accelerate or slow
the process of implementing a project in response to new information or to
shut down a project temporarily in response to changing product market
conditions or competition. Funding is the principal obstacle to delaying the
project and to use the timing option.
Page 43 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Francis T. Hartman (1999) defines risk as the event or factor that leads to a
different than planned outcome. Risk analysis helps to identify the elements that
can increase the uncertainty of the outcome of a project. The goal is to avoid or
reduce the chance of failure, and risk analysis involves finding the most volatile
parts of the project and stabilizing them by mitigating the risk. (Hartman, 2006)44
Using Hartman’s basic steps for risk analysis will help to layout a plan to
moderate the things than can go wrong. The three steps to review are as
follows:
• Identifying risks
• Assessing risks
• Managing risks
Page 44 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Page 45 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
13.0 CONCLUSION
Major findings includes the identification of a growing market for vacation homes
in sunny Mexico, but mostly in coastal development and established expatriated
communities. This type of business is capital intensive and financial forecasts do
not demonstrate high return on investment in the first year of operation, making it
difficult to obtain sources of capital for the short-term. Other findings include
risks associated with political and security concerns for potential buyers, and tax
implications for partners. Coastal developments offer better outlook and growth
opportunities than inland communities. The strategic decision about “where” to
invest must be made if the project should go forward after the first phase.
Page 46 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
1
Young, Linda. (2006, October 13). U.S. Retirees Buying Homes in Baja
California, Mexico. AII Headline News. Retrieved October 30, 2006 from the
World Wide Web: http://www.allheadlinenews.com/articles/7005171350
2
Owens, Wesley. “They Are Boomers. And They Are Doing It.” The Globe
and Mail 25 February 2006: LUX1.
3
Choose Mexico: Retirement in Mexico, Health and Safety Travel Guide.
Retrieved on October 14, 2006 from MedToGo Web Site on the World Wide
Web: http://medtogo.com/t/health-travel-store/retirement-in-mexico.html
4
Mang, Anthony Randall. “Join the Club.” The Globe and Mail 25
February 2006: LUX2.
5
Supra No.2.
6
Huang Renee. “Destination Mexico.” The Globe and Mail 8 July 2005:
G12
7
Cooper, Douglas Anthony. “Barbarians at the Gate.” En Route Monthly
March 2006: 51-58.
8
Supra No.6.
9
Municipio de Oaxaca, Oaxaca Fiesta de Arte y Color, retrieved on
October 14th, 2004 on the World Wide Web:
http://www.oaxacainfo.gob.mx/?mod=topic&topic=poblacion.
10
Ponder, Stephanie E. “Staying Healthy in Mexico.” The Costco
Connection Bi-monthly May/June 2005: 51.
11
Vieira, Donna S. “Pure Escapism.” Dream Escapes Bi-monthly
January/February. 2005: 24-28.
12
Sansom, Maggie. “Dream Big” The Globe and Mail 25 February 2006:
LUX2.
13
Fred R. David (2001). Strategic Management Concepts and Cases. (8th
ed). Upper Saddle River, NY.: Prentice Hall.
14
Black, Thomas. (2006, October). News. Mexico’s Baja Tempts U.S.
Page 47 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Page 48 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Page 49 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
37
Supra No.13
38
Nigel Slack, Stuart Chambers and Robert Johnston (2001). Operation
Management. (3rd ed.) Essex England, Pearson Education.
39
Supra No.38
40
Charles R. Greer (2000). Strategic Human Resource Management. (2nd
ed.) Upper Saddle River, NY.: Prentice Hall.
41
Francis T. Hartman (1999). Don’t Park Your Brain: A Practical Guide To
Improving Shareholder Value with SMART Management. Newton Square,
Pennsylvania. Project Management Institute, Inc.
42
Anthony A. Atkinson, Robert S. Kaplan, and S. Mark Young (2000).
Management Accounting. (4th ed.) Upper Saddle River, NY.: Prentice Hall.
43
Lawrence J. Gitman and Sean M. Hennessey (2005). (Canadian ed).
Principles of Corporate Finance. Toronto, Ontario. Pearson Education Canada
Inc.
44
Supra No.41
Page 50 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
15.0 BIBLIOGRAPHY
Kezsbom, D., & Edward, K. (2001). The New Dynamic Project Management:
Winning Through Competitive Advantage.,p.94, New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Page 51 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
16.0 APPENDICES
Page 52 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Exhibit No.1
P R O F O R M A IN C O M E S T A T E M E N T
F O R T H E P E R IO D E N D IN G : Y e a r - M o nt h - D a y
M ONTH
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 T OT A L
1. Gro ss Sales 1,200 1,500 1,500 301,600 2,700 2,700 2,700 2,700 2,700 2,700 322,000
2. Less: Cash Disco unts 0
A . N E T S A LE S 0 0 1,2 0 0 1,5 0 0 1,5 0 0 3 0 1,6 0 0 2 ,7 0 0 2 ,7 0 0 2 ,7 0 0 2 ,7 0 0 2 ,7 0 0 2 ,7 0 0 322,000
Co st o f Go o ds So ld:
3. B eginning Invento ry 21,981 21,981 21,981 21,981 21,981 21,981 21,981 21,981 21,981 21,981 21,981 21,981 263,770
4. P lus Net P urchases 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 150,000
5. To tal A vailable fo r Sale 3 1,9 0 5 3 1,9 0 5 3 1,9 0 5 3 1,9 0 5 3 1,9 0 5 3 1,9 0 5 3 1,9 0 5 3 1,9 0 5 3 1,9 0 5 3 1,9 0 5 3 1,9 0 5 3 1,9 0 5 3 8 2 ,8 5 8
6. Less Ending Invento ry 26,833 26,833 26,833 26,833 26,833 26,833 26,833 26,833 26,833 26,833 26,833 26,833 3 2 2 ,0 0 0
B . C O S T O F G O O D S S O LD 5 ,0 7 2 5 ,0 7 2 5 ,0 7 2 5 ,0 7 2 5 ,0 7 2 5 ,0 7 2 5 ,0 7 2 5 ,0 7 2 5 ,0 7 2 5 ,0 7 2 5 ,0 7 2 5 ,0 7 2 6 0 ,8 5 8
C . G R O S S M A R G IN ( C =A -B ) - 5 ,0 7 2 - 5 ,0 7 2 - 3 ,8 7 2 - 3 ,5 7 2 -3 ,5 7 2 2 9 6 ,5 2 9 - 2 ,3 7 2 - 2 ,3 7 2 -2 ,3 7 2 -2 ,3 7 2 - 2 ,3 7 2 - 2 ,3 7 2 2 6 1,14 2
Less Variable Expenses*
7. Owner Salary -1,667 -1,667 -1,667 -1,667 -1,667 -1,667 -1,667 -1,667 -1,667 -1,667 -1,667 -1,667 -20,000
8. Emplo yees' Wages and Salaries -3,750 -3,750 -3,750 -3,750 -3,750 -3,750 -3,750 -3,750 -3,750 -3,750 -3,750 -3,750 -45,000
9. Supplies and P o stage -268 -268 -268 -268 -268 -268 -268 -268 -268 -268 -268 -268 -3,220
10. A dvertising and P ro mo tio n -429 -429 -429 -429 -429 -429 -429 -429 -429 -429 -429 -429 -5,152
11. Delivery Expense -215 -215 -215 -215 -215 -215 -215 -215 -215 -215 -215 -215 -2,576
12. B ad Debt Expense 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
13. Travel -805 -805 -805 -805 -805 -805 -805 -805 -805 -805 -805 -805 -9,660
14. Co nstructio n, P ro fessio nal, and Legal Fees -1,878 -1,878 -1,878 -1,878 -1,878 -1,878 -1,878 -1,878 -1,878 -1,878 -1,878 -1,878 -22,540
15. Vehicle Expense -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -6,440
16. M aintenance Expense -617 -617 -617 -617 -617 -617 -617 -617 -617 -617 -617 -617 -7,406
17. Other Co nstructio n Expenses -1,073 -1,073 -1,073 -1,073 -1,073 -1,073 -1,073 -1,073 -1,073 -1,073 -1,073 -1,073 -12,880
D . T O T A L V A R IA B LE E X P E N S E S - 11,2 4 0 - 11,2 4 0 -11,2 4 0 - 11,2 4 0 - 11,2 4 0 - 11,2 4 0 -11,2 4 0 -11,2 4 0 - 11,2 4 0 - 11,2 4 0 - 11,2 4 0 - 11,2 4 0 - 13 4 ,8 7 4
Less Fixed Expenses*
18. Rent -376 -376 -376 -376 -376 -376 -376 -376 -376 -376 -376 -376 -4,508
19. Utilities (Heat, Light, P o wer) -671 -671 -671 -671 -671 -671 -671 -671 -671 -671 -671 -671 -8,050
20. Telepho ne -939 -939 -939 -939 -939 -939 -939 -939 -939 -939 -939 -939 -11,270
21. Taxes and Licences -2,147 -2,147 -2,147 -2,147 -2,147 -2,147 -2,147 -2,147 -2,147 -2,147 -2,147 -2,147 -25,760
22. Depreciatio n -2,200 -2,200 -2,200 -2,200 -2,200 -2,200 -2,200 -2,200 -2,200 -2,200 -2,200 -2,200 -26,404
23. Interest -1,342 -1,342 -1,342 -1,342 -1,342 -1,342 -1,342 -1,342 -1,342 -1,342 -1,342 -1,342 -16,100
24. Insurance -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -537 -6,440
25. Other Fixed Expenses -1,020 -1,020 -1,020 -1,020 -1,020 -1,020 -1,020 -1,020 -1,020 -1,020 -1,020 -1,020 -12,236
E . T O T A L F IX E D E X P E N S E S -9 ,2 3 1 -9 ,2 3 1 - 9 ,2 3 1 - 9 ,2 3 1 - 9 ,2 3 1 - 9 ,2 3 1 - 9 ,2 3 1 - 9 ,2 3 1 - 9 ,2 3 1 - 9 ,2 3 1 -9 ,2 3 1 -9 ,2 3 1 -110 ,7 6 8
F . T O T A L O P E R A T IN G E X P E N S E S ( F =D +E ) - 2 0 ,4 7 0 - 2 0 ,4 7 0 - 2 0 ,4 7 0 -2 0 ,4 7 0 -2 0 ,4 7 0 -2 0 ,4 7 0 - 2 0 ,4 7 0 - 2 0 ,4 7 0 -2 0 ,4 7 0 -2 0 ,4 7 0 - 2 0 ,4 7 0 - 2 0 ,4 7 0 - 2 4 5 ,6 4 2
G . N E T O P E R A T IN G P R O F IT ( LO S S ) ( G =C - F ) - 2 5 ,5 4 2 - 2 5 ,5 4 2 - 2 4 ,3 4 2 -2 4 ,0 4 2 -2 4 ,0 4 2 2 7 6 ,0 5 8 - 2 2 ,8 4 2 - 2 2 ,8 4 2 -2 2 ,8 4 2 -2 2 ,8 4 2 - 2 2 ,8 4 2 - 2 2 ,8 4 2 15,500
H . IN C O M E T A X E S (e s t ima t e d) -10,217 -10,217 -9,737 -9,617 -9,617 110,423 -9,137 -9,137 -9,137 -9,137 -9,137 -9,137 6,200
I. N E T P R O F IT ( LO S S ) A F T E R IN C O M E T A X (I=G -15,325 -15,325 -14,605 -14,425 -14,425 165,635 -13,705 -13,705 -13,705 -13,705 -13,705 -13,705 9 ,3 0 0
*Expenses and o ther payments sho uld be entered as negative (-) numbers.
Page 53 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Exhibit No.2
T W ELV E- M O N T H C A SH F LOW PR O JEC T I ON S
M o nt h 1 M o nt h 2 M o nt h 3 M o nt h 4 M o nt h 5 M o nt h 6 M o nt h 7 M o nt h 8 M o nt h 9 M o nt h 10 M o nt h 11 M o nt h 12 TOTAL
Cash Flow f rom Operat ions (during month) 0
1. Cash Sales 300 300 300,400 1,500 1,500 1,500 1,500 1,500 1,500 310,000
2. Payments f or Credit Sales 0
3. Investment Income 1,200 1,200 1,200 1,200 1,200 1,200 1,200 1,200 1,200 1,200 12,000
4. Other Cash Income 0
Capit al
Purchase of Fixed Asset s 100,000 100,000
Sale of Fixed assets 0
C . C HA N GE I N C A SH F R OM PU R C HA S E OR
SA LE OF A SSET S 0 0 0 0 0 - 10 0 ,0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 - 10 0 ,0 0 0
Financing 0
Payment of Principal of Loan -77,500 -77,500
Inf low of Cash from Bank Loan 5,500 12,500 11,000 18,000 30,500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 77,500
Issuance of Equit y Positions 0
Repurchase of Out standing Equity 0
Page 54 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Exhibit No.3
PRO FORMA BALANCE SHEET
End of year 1
ASSETS
Current Assets:
1. Cash 56,670
2. Account Receivable 0
3. Inventory 0
4. Other Current Assets 100,000
A. Total Current Assets 156,670
Fixed Assets
5. Land and Buildings 0
less depreciation 0
6. Furniture and Fixtures 10,000
less depreciation -2,000
7. Equipment 7,500
less depreciation -1,500
8. Truck and Automobiles 5,000
less depreciation -1,000
9. Other Fixed Assests 5,000
less depreciation -1,000
B. Total Fixed Assests 22,000
C. Total Assets (C=A + B) 178,670
LIABILITIES
Current Liabilities (due w ithin 12 months) 27,500
10. Account Payable 35,670
11. Bank Loans/Other Loans 0
12. Taxes Ow ed 0
D. Total Current Liabilities 63,170
Long-Term Liabilities
13. Notes Payable (due after one year) 0
14. Other Long-Term Liabilities 100,000
E. Total Long Term Liabilities 100,000
Page 55 of 56
Applied Project Alberto Castellanos
Exhibit No.4
FINANCIAL RATIOS
Page 56 of 56