Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Critical Analysis of Tradebook
Critical Analysis of Tradebook
2. Based on this book, the standard that relates to it is the kindergarten standard of motion,
SKP2. Obtain, evaluate, and communicate information to compare and describe different
types of motion. The book could also relate to the Science and English Language Arts
terms of the materials they are made of and their physical attributes and ELAGSEKW2:
texts in which they name what they are writing about and supply some information about
the topic. The ELA standards can relate to students being able to use the vocabulary to
draw or write about the different vocabulary words of motion discussed in the book. This
book relates to my SLP topic of motion. The beginning of the book discusses the
different things that can be pushed or pulled by animals. The book then discusses how
wheels can roll and make objects easier to move. It discusses how it can be hard to start
the wheels to turn but once a big force occurs on them it is easier for the wheels to move.
The book also talks about how when more people are pushing/pulling on an object it is
easier for it to move. The animals in the book discuss how it is harder to go uphill
pulling/pushing an object and once you are downhill it can be harder to stop and you
3. I can use this book in my class for teaching science to introduce the concepts of motion,
force, push, and pull. I believe that this is a good book to get students interested in what
motion is and how push and pull can work. Based on the pictures, words, and
engagement of the book I think this would be a great choice for a book for my
kindergarten students. The main concept that is discussed in this book is motion. Since it
does not discuss all of the vocabulary required for this standard this would be a good
starting point for the children to get an idea of what motion is. Including this book in my
instruction could build conceptual understanding for my students by allowing them to get
the basic vocabulary of motion. It would also allow them to get visuals of going up and
down a hill and how the force is different with both. As the facilitator of learning, I could
guide the students to this conceptual understanding by emphasizing the pushing and
pulling discussed in the book. I could also guide them by doing a quick vocabulary
4. In the book, there are different genders in the pictures. The rest of the characters are
different animals based on a farm. This could be a good book for students who have an
interest in animals, farms, or markets. The animal's genders are not discussed. However,
there is a mother and baby horse that communicate back and forth in the book. The
mother and baby horse are doing the pulling of the cart while the other animals are doing
some pulling and pushing on the back of the cart. I think this would be appropriate for
diversity to show that it takes teamwork to be able to get something done and that all of
5. I think this book is an accurate and good book to introduce motion to kindergarten
students. As I mentioned before, it does not discuss all of the vocabulary needed for the
standard of motion. However, it is a good starting point for students to get visuals and
basic vocabulary. I believe that the pictures allow the students to get a better
understanding of pushing and pulling. They can see the different facial expressions on the
horses when they are struggling to go uphill versus the speed of going downhill.
6. The last thing that stood out to me in this book is how the animals are doing all of the
work. There are a few human characters that are shown in the book. However, these
characters do not talk or have any roles in the story. I think this will be more engaging for
young learners.