ENG 7057 Assignment 1: Draft Argument Map for a Paragraph S1 2024

Task: Refer to the set sources and the sustainability and ethics sources allowed for Assignment
1 and complete the argument map below in response to the following topic:

With reference only to the sources provided and within the context of the assignment scenario,
EITHER: Discuss one water technology in terms of the challenges in using it to contribute to
sustainable water supply.
OR: Discuss one challenge in the use of water technologies in contributing to sustainable
water supply.

Template: Use the template on page 2. Follow the blue template instructions and then delete the
instructions. Convert your text to black.
• Set up at least two sub-issues and provide evidence.
• For each sub-issue you set up, provide at least three dot points (three pieces of
evidence).
• Each sub-issue must use evidence from at least two set sources, in addition to
any sustainability or ethics source used.

Submission: Submit the following two files by 11.45pm Sunday 17 March:

1. this document with your completed Draft Argument Map, including the
completed page header
2. a zip file containing the set source file with highlights and annotations made to all
pieces of information cited.

Ensure the two files are uploaded independently in one submission (that is, as two
separate attachments, with your Assignment 1 document outside the zip file).

Sign: The following Academic Integrity Acknowledgement must be signed and dated.

I have read, understood and agreed to the Academic Integrity Statement as

published in the ENG 7057 Semester 1 2024 MyUni course.

Name: Shivalingaswamy Holeaverimatt Basavarajaiah ID: a1916369

1
NAME: Shivalingaswamy Holeaverimatt Basavarajaiah ID: 1916369

Draft Argument Map

function content
Water technology in terms of the challenges in using it to contribute
Topic
to sustainable water supply.
The issue Challenges in utilizing water technology for sustainable water supply.
Sub-issue 1 Perceived risk and community acceptance of stormwater reuse.
• Community endorsement plays a pivotal role in the efficacy of water
recycling programs. However, backing diminishes when recycled water is
employed for purposes requiring intimate personal interaction, highlighting
a perceived risk linked with water reutilization (Wu, McKay & Keremane
2012, p. 839).
• Distrust in water authorities and inadequate communication exacerbate the
perceived risks associated with the utilization of recycled water (Wu, McKay &
Evidence Keremane 2012, p. 839).
(paraphrased and • The limited understanding of the microbial and chemical contaminants
referenced, including present in stormwater, along with their associated risks, poses a significant
page numbers) impediment to its broad acceptance as an alternative water source. This
informational deficit significantly influences public perceptions regarding
microbial risks, particularly in the context of water recycling and reuse
initiatives (Ahmed et al. 2019, p. 1305).
• In professional endeavours, prioritize the public interest above personal or
group interests. Safeguard the concerns of immediate stakeholders, ensuring
alignment with obligations to public welfare, encompassing health, safety, and
environmental considerations (Australian Computer Society 2014, p.6).
TBL element/s People.

Viewpoint for sub- Perceived risks and community acceptance of stormwater reuse are pivotal.
issue 1 Addressing concerns about water quality and transparent communication are
key to building trust and ensuring sustainable water recycling programs.
Sub-issue 2 Operational challenges in implementing storm water harvesting systems.
• Detecting sewage in stormwater is challenging due to dilution, infiltration, and
limited sensitive detection methods, complicating identification of pathogens
associated with sewage contamination (Ahmed et al. 2019, p. 1306).
• Stormwater harvesting systems often necessitate treatment to mitigate
operational risks. Enhanced treatment may be essential for high-exposure
Evidence
applications to address health and environmental concerns (Ahmed et al.
(paraphrased and 2019, p. 1317).
referenced, including
• The implementation of Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS) and Best
page numbers)
Management Practices (BMPs) requires both structural and non-structural
approaches to manage stormwater effectively (Charlesworth 2019, p. 20).
• Promote community and environmental health, safety, and welfare by
integrating social, cultural, health, safety, environmental, and economic
aspects into engineering projects (Engineers Australia 2022, p. 4).

TBL element/s Environment and Health.

Viewpoint for sub- Operational challenges in Stormwater Harvesting Systems include detecting
issue 2 sewage contamination and the need for treatment to mitigate risks, requiring a
balanced approach for sustainable water technology adoption.

2
NAME: Shivalingaswamy Holeaverimatt Basavarajaiah ID: 1916369

Challenges in utilizing water technology for sustainable water supply, fostering

Viewpoint that covers community engagement and providing access for vulnerable groups are essential.
all the sub-issues Perceived risk and community acceptance of stormwater reuse, coupled with
identified operational challenges in implementing stormwater harvesting systems,
necessitate inclusive strategies. Ultimately, equitable access to smart technologies
is crucial for promoting sustainable water use.

Acknowledgements
I acknowledge the use of ChatGPT [https://chat.openai.com/] to generate ideas and material for background
research and project planning in the drafting of this assignment.