Professional Documents
Culture Documents
01 - Trauma, Gender and Art. The Confessional Work of The Reluctant Feminist Artists
01 - Trauma, Gender and Art. The Confessional Work of The Reluctant Feminist Artists
Industrial Investigation
Contemporary Creative Practice
Hanoi, Vietnam
Introduction
separated from the emotions of the producer, they still can be a tool for self-expression
and a lens through which analyses the art. While Roland Barthes proclaimed the “death
of the author” and this seems to suggest that the author isn’t always in control of their
(Barthes, 1977, p142). In other words, as modern art became popular it also became
popular to think of art only "for art's sake." Clearly, though, art, even in its most abstract
forms, can be considered to express the emotions of the artist. It is this kind of self-
expression of trauma that women artists have continued to engage with even after
Barthes’ proclamation.
However, emotions and curiosity can still be aroused, which navigates the viewers
towards the stories, either biographical or fictional, behind the works. While this may
seem "naive", it could be relevant to the work of female artists and an important
component to analysis of their work. Female artists are often mistaken as "outsider
artists" or considered too emotional for the relationship between their art and their
3
personal lives, yet this essay argues that both are integral to the analysis of female
artwork.
The focus of this essay is to explore how gendered trauma is reflected in the
work of women artists and to consider the effects of this art. Many studies have looked
at trauma and femininity independently when analyzing art, however there is a lack of
studies or analysis which links these two notions. While some theorists, such as
Griselda Pollock, do link these notions, the focus of this research paper is to more
strongly link these two ideas, particularly the relation to the biographies and some of the
stated aims of the artists. The investigation into gendered trauma in the works of Louise
Bourgeois and Tracey Emin can serve as the foundation for a potential theoretical lens
for future art analysis. Specifically, it uses the idea posited by Pollock in analysis of
female artwork as a lens through which both fictional and biographies of gendered
Theoretical Background
psychic injury (Kulesakara, 2016). For instance, incidents such as war, terrorism or
natural disasters are associated with physical and psychological wounding that later
become the unseen trauma and could be projected onto the future as an "intrinsic
nature" (Kulesakara, 2016, p36). Taking a look at the "Garden of Fugitives" (figure 1)
4
and the artwork "Body at Rest'' by Atony Gormely (figure 2), it can be seen that there is
a vague connection between a historical trauma and the visual sense of the
contemporary piece with a more aesthetic touch (Kulesakara, 2016, p37). Art historian
Griselda Pollock, in considering the long history of western art, describes “five defining
carries an impossible history within them or becomes the symptom of a history that they
cannot entirely possess” (Kulesakara, 2016). The artist affected by trauma, then, feels
like the injury or trauma is always present, that there is something always missing inside
them, that they can’t quite represent that trauma, that the feelings of injury come later
and seep into other aspects of their lives and art. (Pollock, 2013)
Figure 2. Gormely, A. (2000-2010). Body at Rest. Ball Works. Antony Gormely website.
Some studies have said that trauma is not in the realm of the amateur but is an
the notion of serious art. In doing so, he suggests that some might say that “some
serious art” (Napier, 2014, p50). He argues that such art allows both artists and viewers
to work through such trauma (p52). This may be very relevant to the study of the artists
in this paper. (Thus not only does the presence of trauma define and accredit the
artwork, but is a medium through which both artist and those experiencing the art and
Other studies have noted the relationship between art and trauma. Some
consider the connection between the expression of trauma in art (or the use of art to
“outsider” artists, Daniel Wojcik has suggested that taking a “behavioral perspective”
6
from folklore studies offers useful insights into artistic expression (Wojcik, 2008, p180).
He notes that outsider artists have long “created art in response to adversity, suffering
and personal crisis” (p187). Perhaps the same could be said for female artists who,
though not technically “outsider” artists, have essentially been pushed to the outside.
Without diving too deep into the field of psychology, it is worth noting that an
entire therapeutic area is dedicated to the use of art in healing from trauma. Schouten
et. al, for example, in a systematic review, have concluded that there is at least some
evidence for the value of different types of art therapy in reducing depression and
lessening the effects of trauma (Schouten, et al., 2015, p226). Dori Laub and Daniel
important connection between expression of trauma and art. For Laub and Poddell,
some traumas actually take away the ability to express trauma and that victims “cannot
articulate trauma even to themselves” (Laub and Poddell, 1995,p992). They say that
trauma may destroy memory or may exist only as a kind of haunting memory. In their
opinion, “only a special kind of art, which we shall designate ‘the art of trauma’, can
begin to achieve a representation of that which defies representation in both inner and
outer experience” (p992). Theorists in this field seem to agree that communication in art
has the ability to express trauma that is almost inexpressible. Laub and Poddell
conclude with the discussion of a female poet/patient that “it is through her art that she
begins to own and negotiate her own separate voice” (p1003). Therefore, artwork
provides female artists the agency to communicate and identify with their own trauma.
clear that trauma could be an important theoretical lens for the examination of art. Art
7
may be a means to heal trauma. More importantly for this paper, trauma could possibly
be an important concern for audience and critics to observe artists who are said to be
on the “outside.”
Feminist Perspective
While the focus of this paper is not strictly about “feminism", the artists explored
are female artists and their traumas are often related to their positions as women.
Important early feminist work establishes the idea that the creativity of women comes
from or at least deserves a special space. Helene Cixous’ call for a feminine writing is
very relevant to this discussion. Writing in creating is something that women have had
to fight for. It has traditionally been the woman’s body that has been represented in art
by men. This itself is one kind of trauma. While the women artists mentioned are not
necessarily making feminist statements, they are working in a world that suppresses
female creativity. Helene Cixous writes that “woman must put herself into the text”
(Cixous, 1976, p875). She calls for what these female artists now do: writing based on a
personal history of trauma against the female body and identity. Cixous sees women as
outsiders to culture who must “return from afar, from always: from “without,” from the
heath where witches are kept alive; from below, from beyond culture”; from their
childhood which men have been trying desperately to make them forget…”(p877).
Women’s writing and art, then, regardless of topic, is a creative act that incorporates or
8
deals with a cultural gendered trauma and, often, a personal gendered trauma. Cixous
says that “by writing herself, a woman will return to the body which has been more than
confiscated from her,” and so Cixous calls on the woman artist: “Write yourself. Your
Important feminist critic Judith Butler, who introduced the notion of the
“performativity” of gender (the idea that there is no “gender” until we perform acts that
are gendered) is also important background for this summary (Butler, 2009, i). First, all
artists are “performing” in a way and the subject of their pieces, as shown below, can
performativity and adds the idea of “precarity” to gender. For Butler, precarity as a part
of gender focuses on “conditions that threaten life in ways that appear to be outside of
one’s control” (Butler, 2009, i). While Butler focuses her attention on those who are
seen to be outside of social norms (queer, transgender, sex workers), the key idea in
relation to the women artists I will consider is that while the artists perform, society
decides “who counts as a life, who can be read or understood as a living being” (Butler,
2009, iv). While an artist might perform gender and identity, the artist is also constrained
to act in certain ways. Butler asks an important question that could be asked throughout
this paper: “how does the unspeakable population speak and make its claim” (Butler,
2009, xiii). Or, in other words, how do artists who have experienced gendered trauma,
performance of gender--is a concern that falls under a feminist lens. Gendered trauma
might also create an experience that is closely related to the experience of being a
9
woman. As Cixous suggests, women need to find a voice. Trauma victims also search
for a means of expression. There is likely an overlap between the lens of “trauma” and
and Silvia Pellicer-Ortin (2013) look into the representation of trauma in both literature
and art, stressing the importance of re-presenting trauma in a woman’s voice. They are
concerned with broadening trauma studies to include “more individual forms of trauma
produced by marginalisation, racial or sexual abuse” (Andermarh, 2013, p2). They note
that “cultural texts have increasingly become privileged spaces for the representation of
individual and collective traumas in our contemporary age, arguably providing a means
of transforming traumatic memories into narrative memories” (p2). They add that
literature and art that deals with gendered trauma has the potential to “disclose silenced
accounts of history, experiment with the ways in which trauma can be represented, and
attempt to deal with these experiences of human suffering” (p3). Their work explores the
ways the “representation process of suffering and pain contribute to the subject’s
Reina Van der Wiel, in discussing the work of novelist Jeanette Winterson and
the painting of Frida Kahlo, has raised the questions of the relationship between an
artist's “story” and her art mentioned in the introduction. Van der Wiel has states that
personal stories or looking at self portraiture--as she quotes Winterson who says that
“the focus is on the woman, rather than the work” (Winterson, as quoted in Van der
Wiel, 2009, p7). Winterson’s real concern, Van der Wiel suggests, is that the female
artist’s biography is often used by men, by the patriarchal art community, to interpret
and control women’s art that in itself often tries to speak to experience (p10). Van der
Wiel concludes that “the temporary ‘freedom’ gained by (re)creating one’s traumatic
past or personal life within one’s art may come at a price. Rather than seeing it as an
suggests that it is not so much “truth” that we are looking for in this art, but the blending
of the truth of trauma, autobiography and creativity that can make the work not just for
Figure 3. Abramson, T (2017). I'm Screaming Inside. Photo source: BREATH website
11
anguish: a feminist take on art and trauma” when she simply writes “severe trauma
informs artistic visions no less than aesthetic evaluations of the work itself” (Abramson,
2019, p190). She goes on to say that while male artists certainly are affected by or
engage with trauma in their work, there is a feeling when looking at the art of many
women that raises the question: “how did severe trauma ‘select’ women? (In this case,
women who eventually became artists.) And was it random or targeted?” (Abramson,
2019, p192). For Abramson it comes down partly to the targeting of female victims in
sexual violence. It is this “theft,” as Abramson calls it, of sexuality that so prominently
affects women and so prominently appears as an issue in art (Abramson, 2019, p193).
“Is it any wonder then,” Abramson asks, “that Kara Walker conflates racism, sexuality
and gender into her artwork or that Luzene Hill, a Native American artist, formulates the
traces of a brutal rape within the context of sexual violence against Native American
brushed away out of concern and artworks themselves cannot be observed without the
Artwork Analysis
interpreted through the lenses of trauma and feminism. In order to look at specific
examples of gendered trauma, the following section will look at two female artists in the
12
Louise Bourgeois
Louise Bourgeois was a French - American artist, born in Paris in a family with a
seemed to grow up with certain privileges being exposed to a lot of opportunities in the
creative fields, little did anyone know about the domestic drama happening in her
adolescence. Despite being remarkably close with her mother Josephine, who passed
away due to the Spanish flu when Louise was only twenty-one, there was always some
tension going on in the relationship between the artist and her father, due to his affair
with her British au pair, Sadie (The Easton Foundation, unknown). It is to be believed
that these occurrences later led to the process of forming Bourgeois's autobiographical
domesticity, family, the human body, sexuality, fidelity, abandonment and death (Tate,
The Art Story, unknown). Bourgeois, throughout her life, has explored these topics with
art experimentation using diverse media, producing artworks that are most often large-
scale with an abstract look. In many ways, Bourgeois work stands on its own as
Her work is not necessarily about anything but is an exercise in form. At the same time,
there is a darkness and shattered quality in her work that hint at raw emotions and
13
trauma that will be discussed below. Her personal experience is also important to
Figure 4. Bourgeois, L (1943). Untitled. [Ink on colored paper]. New York: MoMa.
long artistic career, most of them are black and white sketches, made with simple lines
and with minimal details but enough to deliver the stories. Very child-like drawing
techniques with a dark touch is an impression one could have about the Untitled piece
(figure 02) from1943 by Bourgeois. The sketch implies a woman crying, and her tears
are being hung on by other human-figure-like objects, a face, a child's body. These
The work demonstrates Pollock's notions of trauma in many ways. First, the
"presentness", There is absence, in this case,it is the absence of the body, often the
sign of trauma. Second, there is clearly "irrepresentability" in the sketch that makes it
hard to identify trauma. It looks sad but where does this sadness originate? It is in the
Figure 5. Bourgeois, L (1999). Maman. [bronze, stainless steel, marble]. Women's Art
Blog
Maman is perhaps one of the most recognizable works by Louise Bourgeois and
shows both her aesthetic principles as well as some of the trauma that may underlie the
work she has done throughout her career. Even a glance at the statue shows a touch of
eeriness. A giant spider with her legs which are considered abnormal compared to
eggs. This is a mother spider who is both terrifying and protective (Guggenheim,
caregiver and a protector, who was taken by sickness before she could reach
adulthood, leaving behind the void in young Louise's life. Understanding "Maman"
through Pollock's analysis of trauma, there are undeniable marks of "belatedness" and
"transmissibility". The sculpture, in visual form, represents love, loss and sufferings of
Bourgeois after the death of her mother that she had carried through years.
Figure 6. Bourgeois, L (1974). Destruction of The Father. [plaster, latex, wood, fabric,
explicitly and symbolically represents the trauma of the artist’s upbringing. This piece of
work was once described as “nasty” by critiques. The eerie red colors and the
16
composition give out the claustrophobic effect that overall seems like the artwork took
place in a cave- like area/or a theater (Tate, unkown). With the use of mixed mediums
including plaster, latex, wood, fabric and light, the self-enclosed installation was
regarded as Bourgeois celebration of "a childhood fantasy of slaying and consuming her
dictatorial father at the supper table” (Tate, unknown). Similar to "Maman'', however in a
visual presentation as result of after years feeling abandoned and betrayed by her
father.
Understandably, Louise Bourgeois is a female artist who is engaged with the raw
aesthetic and formal possibilities of art. But these choices of medium, style, and
representation are deeply linked to internal trauma. Her art is a voice that has been
audience, with a strong statement about the feminine perspective in the matters of
mistreatment and abandonment in her works, Bourgeois was never officially aligned
with a specific movement in art history. Though the world often speaks of her as an
important figure in the Feminist Movement, the artist, on the other hand was once
referred to a "reluctant hero of feminist art" on The Guardian (Ferrier, 2016). This
affirmation was likely based on a truth which was not acknowledged enough that
17
herself from the traumatic childhood events and their long-lasting influences.
Tracey Emin
British born artist, Tracey Emin, is one of those art figures/celebrities whose
name could arouse a lot of opinions and controversy when being spoken of. The artist
hardly received any recognition before the early 1990s and was often misunderstood by
the art world (Tate, unknown). Even after getting famous worldwide, critiques and
collectors remained on two sides of the bridge when it came to the criticism of her work.
The 90s was Emin’s most sensational period. She had a hard-partying lifestyle, a
drunken appearance on the television show about her nomination for the Turner Prize
and teared down the stage with her expletive language. This adds to her "shocking"
works that are considered to contain "stains and impurities.” (The Art Story, unknown).
She was dubbed as "the bad girl of British art" by the art press, and even the lowest
tabloids took an interest in their coverage of the artist. (The Art Story, unknown)
It was Emin’s honesty that created her art, as honest as her life was, and it was a
series of unfortunate events that shaped her as a woman she has become. The artist
had a good start in childhood, until her father left with all the money, which forced the
remaining three members of the family to live in poverty. (The Art Story, unknown). At
13, Emin was raped, an event which certainly affected the rest of her life. Then, as she
reached 24 and was pursuing an MA in painting at Royal College of Art, Emin went
18
through two abortions which led to the self-sabotage of her work (The Art Story,
unknown). Being physically and emotionally wounded and having to suffer many
traumas at such a young age, Emin was exposed to a dark side of life way before she
could mature, which might be the reason why she went through some sort of identity
crisis and explored this in her art. This is not necessarily a negative thing, since in a
way, it influenced Emin to explore womanhood and sexuality through a unique artistic
Figure 7. Emin, T. (1998). My Bed. [Box frame, mattress, linens, pillows and various
“My Bed”, 1998 (figure 6) is a later work by Emin that is clearly related to identity.
Even if we didn’t know that this work reflects Emin’s own struggles, it is apparent that
the work is related to trauma, psychological despair and sexuality. The very fact that the
work is a bed indicates the personal and perhaps sexual nature of the piece. Of course,
the rumpled sheets and the stockings tangled in the sheets further indicate both unease
19
and sexuality: unrest in the bed, the quick discarding of clothes. Upon closer inspection,
the items in the room also reflect gender identity and trauma. Ranging from the “cute”
stuffed animal that could belong to a child to the empty birth control boxes, the items
indicate both innocence and experience. This could be a loss of innocence because of
various experiences. Discarded tampons along with the birth control remind us of the
realities of gender while empty alcohol bottles add to the sense of abuse. The travel
bags on one side of the bed are perhaps suggesting the desire to escape or meant to
presentness" stands out as the strongest character compared to the other fours. There
is always space for trauma to lurk around behind Emin's works, being disguised under
different forms and means, but always noticeable. In Emin's circumstances, it could be
herself/her past trauma who borrows art as a voice for visual expression of her pain
(transmisibility).
Figure 8. Emin, T. (1997). Terribly Wrong. [Monoprint on paper]. London: Tate Museum
20
standard modern and postmodern history of art. The figure of the woman is
expressionistic and is similar to depictions of the woman’s body by the artist Egon
Schiele. The use of language is similar to more postmodern work ranging from Renee
Magritte (“Ceci n’est pas une pipe” written on “The Treachery of Images” (1929) to
contemporary feminist work by Barbara Kruger. These elements, though, are re-figured
by Emin and point to gendered trauma. The words themselves are written in a way that
appears both personal (someone’s own handwriting) and troubled (the letter ‘N’ written
in the wrong direction). And though we have a Schiele-like nude woman, this nude
woman, presumably, is not only the subject of the painting but quite possibly the
artist/creator. This woman also appears to be the victim of sexual trauma. The head of
the figure is barely visible and hidden due to her lying position, suggesting
unconsciousness or even being strangled. The legs are splayed and there is discharge
coming from her private part. The effect is, in fact, “wrong” or disturbing.
for creating artworks that carry a strong theme of sexuality, relationships and trauma,
and often including disturbing details, Tracey Emin never pretended to fit in or please art
critiques to calm the waves of criticism (Artsy, unknown). She once explained, in an
interview featured by Tate Gallery, "I realized I was my work, I was the essence of my
21
work - I always say that after I'm dead my work isn't going to be half as good" ((Emin,
"Is she a great artist?" a question raised by Melanie McGrath in a Tate article,
can not really be answered. While critics continue to criticize and dissect Emin's work,
putting a “narcissistic” tag on her personality as ever, Emin just does her thing, which is
experimenting. Her identity has been formed by physical and spiritual anguish and the
practice of its expression, and these traumas, as well as her art, are clearly related to
gender, especially the precarious nature of the feminine. By exposing her vulnerability,
her mundane minutiae in fear, neediness, powerlessness, illness, Emin found a way to
communicate with her audience, especially the female audience, reflecting the basic
needs of human socializing in the world we live in. (McGrath, 1997, np.). Perhaps
because of that, like Bourgeois, Emin tried to avoid tightening her ideology with a
particular movement and became another reluctant hero of feminist art, as she once
stated :"I'm not happy being a feminist. It should all be over by now." (The Art Story,
unknown).
22
Conclusion
Bourgeois and Emin, two female artists who were born in different times with
different approaches in their art practice, by fair means or foul, speak a similar artistic
through their self-confessional lenses. Both artists deliver a new definition to what a
"liberated woman" can be by focusing on the taboo aspects in the lives of women in
and family damage. They also deal with the stigma that can come from society but often
come from within. In dissimilar ways, both Bourgeois’ and Emin’s artworks can shift
from lonely, furious, raw, frankly disturbing, heavily provocative to genuine, calm, or
even loving. The emotions that are communicated in their art are clearly related to the
effects of trauma. The simple line drawings of Bourgeois can show sadness and loss.
The splattered paintings of Emin, or the disturbed bed, can show the anger, depression
Importantly, though, the lens of “trauma” is not the only lens for viewing these
works. The trauma itself that these artists suffered is related to gender, to their
“precarity” as Butler puts it, and the expression of this trauma is a clear demonstration
of Cixous’ expression of the feminine. Together, the lens of “gendered trauma” can be a
useful tool to consider the work of contemporary female artists, to reconsider classic
References
Abrams, A. (2021). How Tracey Emin's Emotive Works Became Must - Have for
February, 2021].
Abramson, T. (2019). Unchain my anguish: a feminist take on art and trauma. Feminist
Barthes, R. (1977). The Death of The Author. Image, music, text. London: Fontana
Publication, pp.142-148.
Bourgeois, L (1943). Untitled. [Ink on colored paper]. New York: MoMa. Available at:
https://www.moma.org/collection/works/35046?artist_id=710&page=1&sov_referr
Bourgeois, L (1974). Destruction of The Father. [plaster, latex, wood, fabric, red light].
modern/exhibition/louise-bourgeois/room-guide/louise-bourgeois-room-6.
Bourgeois, L (1999). Maman. [bronze, stainless steel, marble]. Women's Art Blog.
Butler, J., (2009). Performativity, Precarity and Sexual Politics. AIBR. Revista de
Cixous, H., Cohen, K., Cohen, P. (1976). The Laugh of Medusa. Signs, Vol. 1, No. 4,
2021]
Emin, T. (1997). Terribly Wrong. [Monoprint on paper]. London: Tate Museum. Available
Emin, T. (1998). My Bed. [Box frame, mattress, linens, pillows and various objects]
https://luciawardblog.wordpress.com/2017/04/21/my-bed-tracey-emin/.
Ferrier, M. (2016). Louise Bourgeois - the reluctant hero of feminist art. Women.
https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2016/mar/14/louise-bourgeois-feminist-
https://www.amusingplanet.com/2011/04/garden-of-fugitives-fossilized-
Gormely, A. (2000-2010). Body at Rest. Ball Works. Antony Gormely website. Available
Lin, M. (unknown). Trauma Studies and the Traumas and Art Practice in the Post-
Traumatic Era. AICA Taiwan and Professor of Department of Arts and Design,
https://www.academia.edu/34616052/Trauma_Studies_and_the_Traumas_and_
of Serious Art. The Journal of Aesthetic Education, Vol. 48, No. 1, pp45 - 53,
2021].
Pollock, G. (2013). After Affect - After Image: trauma and aesthetic transformation in the
Schouten, K., Niet, G., Knipscheer, J., Kleber, R. and Hutschemaerker, G. (2015). The
Violence & Abuse. Sage Publications, Inc, Vol. 16, No. 2, pp. 220-228. Available
2021].
Tate (unknown). Introduction to Tracey Emin: A closer look at the life and work of the
January, 2021].
The Art Story (unknown). Biography of Tracey Emin. Tracey Emin. Artists. Available at:
January, 2021].
Van der Wiel, R. (2009). Trauma as Site of Identity: The case of Jeanette Winterson
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09574040903000795. [Accessed
Wojcik, D (2008). Outsider Art, Vernacular Traditions, Trauma and Creativity. Western
Folklore, Spring - Summer 2008, Vol.67, No.⅔, Special Issue in Honor of Michael