In 1704 Jacquet de La Guerre lost both her husband and her son, by
ner denhal the hppoted eel eh peor erat
wa Becongenet arcs began wa ice
jogo sow be pha
a by Alin-René Lesage. She sop
ciety by establishing san
Inher final years, she composed some shot airs and a choral Te Dum th,
has been ost.
Hers would qualify as a major area
In the Realm of All the Senses: Two Sarabandes by Elisabeth
Claude Jacquet de La Guerre
Susan McClary
‘Music theorists usually restrict the senses used in the
to the auditory and the visual. Although we work to deve
four courses in ear ti
would seem to have
why we have such difficulty with repertories of seventeenth-century France
This music often appears simplistic and banal to the eye and—ifitis mt
ion du Tile, e Paras fons, tans. Susan MeClar (Paris: BC
‘10. ar: Seventeenth and Eighteenth Century Keyboard Music
performed well—als tothe ea, and we tend to write off as unworthy of
deled scrutiny.
"et the problem resides not so much in the musi sel but in our ne
lect of modes of communication that involve much more th
tes: For French music ofthis period appeals to and by means of th
the kinetic. the spatial, and pethaps even albeit through syest
olfactory, all of which passthrough the filter of taste: that es
trated by Francopiles. Qualities such as color and timbre usually pushed
to the sid in the interest of objective analysis, become primary parameters
in these repertores. This essay focuses on two works of Elisabeth-Claude
Jacquet de La Guerre: the sarabandes from her keyboard suites in A minor
and D minor! My comments could apply equaly, however, to many other
French composers of her era and of others as wel.
Like other French composers of this time, Jacquet de La Guerre
grounded much of her music in the social dance so central to life at
court. I have written elsewhere about how this close allegiance to dance
produced a kind of tem ite different from the musics of other
focused the attention on a succession
fering a sense of plenitude. This way
corresponded not only with the physical actions ofthe
dancing body but also with widespread ideological precepts in French
philosophy, theology, and governance? It was within this ideological
pe Rameau developed his freeze-frame approach
is, whereby each vertical collection receives its own
fan and Italianate musics of the seventeenth century
worked to create forward striving trajectories by interrupting and delaying
expected points of arrival, creating qualities of motion antithetical to those
ofthe French. To the very large extent to which musicians today are trained
inthe Italian fashion by way ofthe German composers who made i their
‘own, we often find it hard to locate the content of French dances. Even
_musicologists who claim to specialize in this area sometimes apologize for
the music's thinness. na volume dedicated to Jean-Baptiste Luly for in-
stance, Paul Henry Lang wrote,
‘The music all these [French seventeenth-centuy] composers cultivated
was in the sign of the dance, so congenial to the French, with its neat
egnant rhythms, great surface attraction, andi tone and
tach in harmony with the spirit of the age. This musi,
though slight and short-breathed, was elegant and so different fom any
‘other thatthe whole of Europe became enamored ofit*
iste clude acquet de La Gu, aabanesin& mina (65) m8 Diner (107)
>=.its des Bander ob
rs iui tae tits i o
then acu buck othe guaranteed genes ugh
Piseventeenth-centuty French court dance involved much ma
a le Passe-pied
At $
tee
agate
f him. Those wo
excelled might receive his favor and bounty; those who did not ited
{shment from court and financial ruin. The stakes were high,
Completes in these dances occurred at several
ut from
‘ach other in an arch form, and so on. The choreography of a single dance
might demand a dozen such patterns, each one corresponding to a mee
four or eight bars of music. See, for instance, this period notation fora mere
eight bars ofa passepied (Figure
Second,
producing cross-rhythms with the steps thems
Of these other factors that the king distinguished a si
froma mediocre one, with all the rewards and demotior
entailed. One could go through all the motions, in other words, and stil fil
to execute an aesthetically pleasing result.
ally, the qualities of motion for these dances depended almost
iscule discrepancies of timing in the music—the kinds
\we now might all groove but that can be measured only with the ad of
modem digital technologies If in the words of William Butler Yeats, we
cannot separate the music
0 either succeeds or fils in buoying up the festiviisin
was the way the kids were dancing; they were Put
we'd been one-beataccenters with 2
mn dah,” but here this was a thing that went
veteeth- and Elgheenh-Century Keyboard Muse
a —Cti—Ci il14, Pari Seventeenth and Gightenth Century Keyboard Music
‘modal practice that I find it more productive to examine the ways she
‘expands on an age-old formula. For as far back as we have notated scores to
tive major or even a plagal cadence that returns us to our starting position);
the second strain reaches closure on the final. So automatic was this for
two most common harmonizations of the
iapente, or species of fifh from the fifth sale
and further into the background by
tain the points along the way a bref key
thenker graphs, in part because Schenker
[tens erediscerned this process fom the other end: through increasing stages of,
duction, By contrat, my approach builds from the principal unit of modg,
syntax, the descent through the modal diapente, and examines the meany
by which seventeenth-century composers worked to expand and animate
that pattem in their new practices?”
I will begin with the sarabande from Jacquet de La Guerre's keyboar
suite in A minor, a piece that seems quite transparent at first glance (ee
Example 5.22 @). Its opening strain comprises a mere eight bars, which
‘break down into a + 2 + 4 measures. As is characteristic of the sarabande
genre, each bar features a strong agogic accent on the second beat. And a.
though we pass briefly through C major in mm. 3~4, we return to the tone
in m. 5 and continue through a sealar descent to a half cadence pointing
back toward A atthe bar line.
If were introducing French dance types to a class, 1 could do worse
than to use this sarabande as an example, so precisely does it satisfy the
conventions of the style. Moreover, it could serve as an example for an into.