Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Caprioglioetall - 2-2007-Guidederuptionofpalatally
Caprioglioetall - 2-2007-Guidederuptionofpalatally
109
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/17/07 10:39 AM Page 113
diately obvious that the crown of the max- canine was then moved by distally directed
illary left canine is in close vestibular palatal traction, to move it away from the
contact with the root of the lateral incisor, roots of both central and lateral incisors.
while the root of the impacted tooth is In case 4 (Fig 4), both canines are
close to the apex of the first premolar. palatally impacted, but they do not inter-
After reviewing these images, it is clear fere with each other. Case 5 (Fig 5)
that poorly executed traction could pro- shows both canines are palatally
duce iatrogenic damages to the lateral impacted, but the apicocoronal axes are
incisor, especially if the traction was exe- more inclined in a mesial direction. Thus,
cuted palatally, and to the first premolar, the authors proceeded to debride the left
if the traction was vestibularly executed canine before the right, because the left
in a vertical direction. canine required traction toward the con-
Analysis of Fig 2 demonstrates the tralateral side and space to move.
importance of the 3-dimensional CT In other cases, both canines may be
scan. From a medicolegal standpoint, the impacted on the vestibular side; in this
views define damage that has occurred situation, it is less important to decide
at the root level of adjacent teeth before which of the 2 to treat first. However, it is
application of any kind of traction. more important to visualize their position
Finally, as seen above in bilateral with the proximal teeth, especially the lat-
impactions, the clinician can also obtain a eral incisors on the same side, as shown
great amount of information on the in cases 6 (Fig 6) and 7 (Fig 7). Proximity
debridement priority according to tooth may also involve other teeth, such as the
location, to avoid iatrogenic damage and homolateral central incisors, as seen in
delay during therapy. Case 3 (Fig 3) shows case 8 (Fig 8).
the importance of correct debridement From the 3-dimensional CT diagnostic
and traction of the maxillary right canine in technique, it is possible to deduce more
the palatodistal direction first; the left information about the optimal surgical
113
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 110
of allowing unwanted rotations and poor rolled around a steel tube that contained
directional control. In addition, the recip- the main archwire, but this appeared to
rocal torque these rotations apply to the be less stable than similar systems.
molar segment needs to be compensated Ross11 looked to solve the problem of the
through the use of a palatal bar that rein- decay of the applied force by using a
forces the available anchorage, often nickel-titanium (NiTi) coil spring of a Jones
requiring an extension to the premolars. jig (American Orthodontics, Sheboygan,
Several different approaches to solve WI, USA), made shorter and rolled around
this problem have been proposed. In the rectangular main archwire.
1979, Jacoby 2 presented the Ballista Some systems, while biomechanically
Spring, a vestibular attachment device favorable due to the maintenance of the
that could apply a palatally directed extru- anchorage and control of side effects,
sion force to the tooth through a crossover are penalized by the complexity required
lever analogous to a medieval “ballista”. for their planning and/or execution. Such
Over time, different authors have pro- is the case with the statically defined
posed changes to this original concept, appliance proposed by Patel et al12 and
looking to improve its effectiveness, elimi- the cantilever palatal lever proposed by
nate undesired side effects, simplify the Fischer et al.13
procedures, and optimize the results. More recent proposals by Kalra14 (K-9
Lazzati et al 3 proposed a device spring) and Bowman and Carano15 (Kilroy
intended to resist the reaction force at spring) do not overcome the mechanical
the level of the molars by screwing the problems previously identified. For
ballista directly to the basic rectangular instance, the K-9 spring 14 does not
steel archwire for anchorage. Kornhauser exploit the anchorage provided by the
et al4 took advantage of the crossover continuous archwire, and the lever rota-
lever concept by bending a vertical loop tion problem is only partially solved by
directly on a round continuous archwire, replacing a rectangular wire with a round
as an auxiliary to the main arch, but this one and -titanium alloy (TMA) for stain-
did not solve the problem linked to the less steel. The Kilroy spring15 is a spring
rotation of the auxiliary arch. Crescini5 bent according to whether the impaction
chose to use a double archwire with a is palatal or vestibular, using a rectangu-
full-size main arch and a second arch lar main arch as anchorage. It needs fre-
bent to accept the elastic traction with quent inspections because of its large
directional flexibility. size and it runs the risk of applying a pro-
Others have proposed using remov- gressive coronopalatal torque to the adja-
able appliances as anchorage. For exam- cent dental units on which the reaction
ple, McDonald and Yap 6 and Daren- force is shared.
deliler and Friedli 7 chose to exploit a Finally, Oppenhuizen 16 proposed a
maxillary plate, the former for traction lever composed of a steel 0.018-inch
with elastics, and the latter used mag- round arch inserted into the slot of the
nets for the same purpose. Orton et al8 brackets bonded to the incisor group
proposed the use of a mandibular plate with a NiTi or TMA stabilization rectangu-
to hook to the chain emerging from the lar arch. In this case, the problem con-
maxillary impacted tooth. cerning side effects is moved from the
Magnusson9 chose to solder a 0.016- back to the front, always in terms of
inch -titanium spring to a 0.016 ⫻ coronopalatal torque.
0.022-inch stainless steel sectional arch- Thus, all the designs and modifica-
wire to fit into the 0.018-inch slot of the tions have been inspired by the desire to
brackets of the homolateral premolars. solve similar problems linked to an origi-
However, this anchorage was not suffi- nal lever concept. Based on these opin-
cient in cases where a significant move- ions and the authors’ own experience, it
ment of the impacted tooth was needed, is suggested that an ideal device for the
and the support of a palatal bar was nec- extrusion of palatal impacted canines
essary. Terry and Thomson10 proposed a should have:
lever arm composed of a resilient wire
110
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 111
Fig 1 Case 1. Three-dimensional CT scans show labial impaction of maxillary left canine.
• Rigid and extended anchorage for con- Thus, a 3-dimensional CT would not be
trol of side effects necessary if the position of the impacted
• Spatially concentrated and temporally canine could be defined (1) by the pres-
continuous elasticity ence of the canine eminence or ability to
• Force with vector flexibility able to palpate the crown palatally; (2) according
avoid obstacles along the way to the position of the maxillary lateral
• Adequate control of force intensity, incisor crown (when the lateral incisor is
ideally equal to 4 to 5 ounces retroclined, the canine will be palatal,
• Planning and execution simplicity and when the lateral incisor is proclined,
the canine will be vestibular); and (3)
This article introduces a technique of through conventional radiographic tech-
disimpaction through a new device (Easy niques (panoral, occlusal, intraoral exe-
Cuspid), conceived not only to simplify cuted according to Clark’s rule, and lat-
the fabrication procedures and avoid eral cephalogram).
some of the identified problems, but also A 3-dimensional CT scan is necessary
to couple it to the new diagnostic technol- if (1) none or only 1 of the previous con-
ogy of the 3-dimensional computerized ditions is fulfilled; (2) the information
tomography (CT) scan. derived from the previous conditions is
discordant; (3) the clinician suspects
radicular resorption of teeth adjoining
3-DIMENSIONAL CT SCAN the impacted tooth (a 3-dimensional CT
scan can be used to visualize the extent
The use of the 3-dimensional CT scan for of the damage); and (4) there is bilateral
diagnostic purposes in orthodontics rep- canine impaction and priority for debride-
resents a new and controversial topic. ment needs to be established.
According to data collected by the In short, acknowledging the further
authors,1 the main examination to local- exposure to x-rays, the cost-advantage
ize the crown of an impacted canine is ratio for each case has to be estab-
the panoral radiograph in combination lished. It is preferable to submit the
with the execution of good intraoral radi- patient to greater exposure to x-rays than
ographs. This technique is reliable in to the iatrogenic risks of an incorrect
about 60% of cases; it does not require orthodontic-surgical treatment.1
the patient to be exposed to further radi- The authors can asser t that the
ation and it is the one most commonly images from a 3-dimensional CT scan are
used by dentists. Moreover, in the numerous and extremely clear, for both
remaining 40% of cases, this method the absolute position of the impacted
suggests the position of the impacted canine and the apices of adjacent teeth
tooth and indicates if fur ther radi- that could be at risk from the impaction.
ographic inquiries are necessary. For instance, in case 1 (Fig 1), it is imme-
111
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 112
Fig 2 Case 2. Three-dimensional CT scans show palatal impaction of maxillary Fig 3 Case 3. Three-dimensional CT
right canine. Note the root resorption of the maxillary right lateral incisor. scan shows palatal impaction of the
maxillary right and left canines.
Fig 7 Case 7. Three-dimensional CT scans show labial impaction of the maxillary right canine and palatal impaction of the left
canine.
112
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 113
diately obvious that the crown of the max- canine was then moved by distally directed
illary left canine is in close vestibular palatal traction, to move it away from the
contact with the root of the lateral incisor, roots of both central and lateral incisors.
while the root of the impacted tooth is In case 4 (Fig 4), both canines are
close to the apex of the first premolar. palatally impacted, but they do not inter-
After reviewing these images, it is clear fere with each other. Case 5 (Fig 5)
that poorly executed traction could pro- shows both canines are palatally
duce iatrogenic damages to the lateral impacted, but the apicocoronal axes are
incisor, especially if the traction was exe- more inclined in a mesial direction. Thus,
cuted palatally, and to the first premolar, the authors proceeded to debride the left
if the traction was vestibularly executed canine before the right, because the left
in a vertical direction. canine required traction toward the con-
Analysis of Fig 2 demonstrates the tralateral side and space to move.
importance of the 3-dimensional CT In other cases, both canines may be
scan. From a medicolegal standpoint, the impacted on the vestibular side; in this
views define damage that has occurred situation, it is less important to decide
at the root level of adjacent teeth before which of the 2 to treat first. However, it is
application of any kind of traction. more important to visualize their position
Finally, as seen above in bilateral with the proximal teeth, especially the lat-
impactions, the clinician can also obtain a eral incisors on the same side, as shown
great amount of information on the in cases 6 (Fig 6) and 7 (Fig 7). Proximity
debridement priority according to tooth may also involve other teeth, such as the
location, to avoid iatrogenic damage and homolateral central incisors, as seen in
delay during therapy. Case 3 (Fig 3) shows case 8 (Fig 8).
the importance of correct debridement From the 3-dimensional CT diagnostic
and traction of the maxillary right canine in technique, it is possible to deduce more
the palatodistal direction first; the left information about the optimal surgical
113
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 114
Fig 15 Model of a molar band with 3 Fig 16 Easy Cuspid after the welding Fig 17 Easy Cuspid, with modified
vestibular tubes. phase. terminal, inserted into the tubes of the
molar band.
114
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 115
approach since radiologists can localize ity to the system, and to keep adequate
the blood vessels, as shown in Fig 9. The tension on the ligature between the chain
clinician can also obtain other types of emerging from the impacted canine and
images with dedicated software, such the Easy Cuspid.17 Further, based on the
as the SimPlant (Materialize, Leuven, literature and on the fact that the length of
Belgium). the active arm is 15 to 20 mm, and
On the basis of standardized files assuming the corner angle formed by the
(.DICOM), the clinician can evaluate dif- ballista is 30 degrees, a traction force of 4
ferent cuts and perspectives, and have a to 5 ounces should be applied (Figs 13
3-dimensional vision for each. The 3- and 14). However, to obtain that force, it is
dimensional model can be turned in necessary to have a system in which the
every direction to better see the proxim- maxillary first molar bands are prepared
ity between the anatomic structures. with triple tubes. The triple tubes permit
Moreover, it is possible to put different insertion of the main arch into the princi-
tissues in view (mucosa, bone, erupted pal tube, and the Easy Cuspid in the
and impacted teeth), identifying them accessory tube and the tube prepared to
with different colors and freezing the contain the extraoral traction terminal
most important cuts, as shown in Fig 10. (Figs 15 to 17).
In the most complex cases, activations
are carried out at intervals of 2 to 3
MATERIAL AND METHODS weeks over a 3- to 4-month period. This
modular system is suitable for unilateral
For the case shown here, the authors as well as bilateral impactions. In the
chose to obtain anchorage from banding case of bilateral impaction, a compen-
the entire maxillary arch, tied together by satory bend to the removable transpalatal
a 0.018-inch round stainless steel arch- bar at both terminals will act at the molar
wire and by a removable palatal bar. The level (Fig 18). Additional attention has to
palatal bar is bent to give coronovestibu- be given to the bend of the first helix for
lar torque to resist the coronopalatal the palatal crossover. This bend must cor-
forces, following occlusal traction of the respond with the mandibular interproxi-
homolateral canine (Figs 11 and 12). mal space for the patient’s comfort and
The appliance used was the Jones jig, for easier clinical management (Fig 19).
which was originally conceived for distaliza- In an impaction case that also
tion of the maxillary molars. The Jones jig requires extractions, traditional methods
was modified by removing the spring, cut- are followed to prepare space for the
ting the steel arm in the middle of its canine and to close remaining extraction
length, and soldering a 0.017 ⫻ 0.025-inch sites; however, additional modifications
rectangular steel wire on this arm. This new to the Easy Cuspid will be necessary
device has been named Easy Cuspid.17 because the vestibular arm will need a
The helices were bent to give elasticity reduced size to fit the length of the max-
to the system, to obtain the crossover from illary arch, about half of the original
vestibular to palatal, to give greater stabil- length (Fig 20).
115
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 116
116
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 117
Fig 23 Patient PM, 12 years 1 months of age. Pretreatment panoral radiograph. Fig 24 Patient PM, 12 years 1 month
of age. Pretreatment lateral cephalo-
gram.
c d e
debridement, and to aid the surgical and maxillary right canine. The occlusodistal
mechanical planning of the case. The direction of traction was used to remove
scan provided significant images (Fig 25) the crowns from the roots of both perma-
that show the palatal impaction of both nent lateral incisors.
permanent maxillary canines. In April 2002, the authors bonded the
The optimal surgical access to both maxillary arch and inserted a palatal bar
teeth was from the palatal. The maxillary on the maxillary first molars; space was
left canine was debrided first, then the then prepared for the permanent
117
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 118
a b c
b c
canines (Fig 26). After aligning and level- to increase the possibilities for modifica-
ing the maxillary arch, the authors pro- tion and the patient’s comfort (Fig 27). In
ceeded with the surgical debridement of October 2002, the left canine erupted;
the left canine. The point chosen for the the disimpaction of the right canine (Fig
crossover was connected to the inter- 28) was carried out in December 2002,
proximal space between the antagonist while the left canine was left alone until
teeth, and not connected to the canine, the eruption of the right canine (Fig 29).
118
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 119
In March 2003, the right canine fulcrum (maxillary first molar). Moreover,
erupted and the authors bonded 2 but- because the auxiliary insertion is vestibu-
tons to obtain alignment in the arch lar, the appliance provides excellent
through the use of elastic tractions. Dur- anchorage, both rigid and extended; rigid
ing this phase, space maintenance for the anchorage is provided by the main arch-
maxillary canines was obtained through wire that ties together the entire arch, and
passive coil springs (Fig 30). Meanwhile, extended anchorage is represented by a
the mandibular arch was banded and, in removable palatal bar.
May 2003, the authors bonded the brack- The bending of the helices, which are
ets on the vestibular surfaces of both simple to manage, provides adequate elas-
maxillary canines (Fig 31). ticity to the system. The bends allow the
After obtaining the coordination of the operator to move the lever arm to the most
arch, the patient was debanded and the suitable point and to guide the emerging
authors splinted the 6 mandibular ante- tooth away from anatomic obstacles.
rior teeth (Figs 32 to 35). Later, the The Easy Cuspid is fabricated of stain-
authors completed restorative treatment less steel, which allows for easy welding of
and bleaching therapies of the teeth the active arm to the terminals. However,
showing enamel hypoplasia. because of its nature, stainless steel is
subject to a decline of the applied force
levels. Consequently, it is necessary to
DISCUSSION reactivate the appliance every 2 to 3
weeks. These maneuvers are simple to
The main problem with the use of biome- manage and require little operator time.
chanically active systems to extrude Nevertheless, the authors are studying pro-
palatally impacted teeth concerns the totypes built with different materials,
rotation of the auxiliary itself. The Easy including TMA or NiTi—not to eliminate the
Cuspid provides a solution to this prob- necessity of intermediate checks, but to
lem, as it is inserted in a double tube at keep the applied force level as constant as
the level of the dental element acting as a possible during each adjustment period.
119
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 120
120
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER
Caprioglio 5/7/07 4:29 PM Page 121
121
COPYRIGHT © 2007 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS
ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER