Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A New Understanding and A Minimalist Approach For.17
A New Understanding and A Minimalist Approach For.17
R
hinoplasty is known as a difficult, complex marginal incisions, and the technique is unique
and unpredictable operation, and the rhi- for this feature. There are two reasons: (1) multi-
noplasty surgeon is advised to be ready to ple incisions disturb the integrity of the nose and
use different techniques for each case.1 In this cause disorientation, and (2) each incision is an
article, a rhinoplasty approach that aims to sim- additional trauma.
plify, make the operation more predictable, and
correct basic primary deformities is presented.
There are 20 basic steps that are used in each A NEW UNDERSTANDING OF BREATH
case, and some complementary maneuvers are PHYSIOLOGY
added when necessary. By definition, respiration describes the
This approach is only for primary cases with- amount of air reaching the alveolar level, and to
out obvious congenital deformities or severe reach the alveolar level air must accelerate and
trauma sequelae. Some steps may be used for gain kinetic energy. According to a rule of physics
clefts or secondary cases, but these cases are more known as the Venturi effect, air flows much faster
a reconstruction rather than an aesthetic proce- through narrower channels than wider ones,
dure with a deformed anatomy, and surgical tech- and the same principle applies to the respiratory
nique must be adapted for each case. physiology. Inspired air is accelerated at the rest-
The technique is published by the author as a ing angle that is formed between lateral crura
self-published textbook2 and has been presented and upper lateral cartilage,8 and have a decisive
at many meetings. Most steps are minor modifica- effect on aesthetics and function. If the lateral
tions of well-known and published techniques3–7; crus of the alar cartilage stays flat facing the dor-
other steps that cover unique and innovative sur- sal surface, the lateral crus will receive the load
gical ideas are as follows. from the side and will stand stable. This nose tip
breathes well and is aesthetically appealing to the
eye (Fig. 1).
INCISIONS One also should note that there is some
The technique can be performed open or amount of deviation and base crest on each
closed. Closed approach is performed only by nose. These are parts of normal human anat-
omy, are not pathologic, and function to accel-
erate airflow. Therefore, it is neither necessary
From the Department of Plastic Surgery, American Hospital. nor correct to clean each crest, to correct each
Received for publication December 9, 2021; accepted August deviation.
11, 2022.
Presented at the Moroccan Society of Aesthetic and Plastic
Surgeons Meeting, in Marrakech, Morocco, November
26 through 27, 2021; the 48th Annual International Disclosure statements are at the end of this article,
Symposium Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, in Puerto Vallarta,
following the correspondence information.
Jalisco, Mexico, November 11 through 14, 2021; and the
44th Annual Meeting of the European Academy of Facial
Plastic Surgery, in Nice, France, September 15 through 18,
2021. Related digital media are available in the full-text
Copyright © 2023 by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons version of the article on www.PRSJournal.com.
DOI: 10.1097/PRS.0000000000010213
www.PRSJournal.com 549
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • September 2023
fQneGesK9K6Qk0G8N7nRL8+9JJHP91hfdAvJxqdG3EtHNkyGLj77I7kixrMW8yuNMgxki+ov2vde+GwuMML6U on 09/21/2023
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by luXVnsbozFPHgbIcrIgUvTDUCbkyUcfhjFfXEdHDDdj
Fig. 1. Resting angle determines aesthetics and function. (Above) When the lateral crus is flat, it is
resistant to collapse during inhalation. This is also the best shape aesthetically. (Below) When the
crus is vertically positioned, it is weak, collapses easily, and is aesthetically poor.
PLANNING AND ANALYSIS legs, with techniques such as medial or lateral cru-
In this technique, no measurement is made, ral struts, will not add to the length of the tripod
and no golden ratio or imaginary polygons are and will be ineffective for the projection.
used. The plan is made simply by shaping the tip Ligament suspension techniques are also
with fingertips and finding the new dome point overrated in terms of their effect on projection.
and correcting the resting angle. The only cri- The Pitanguy ligament originates from the nasal
terion is to create a new nose shape pleasing to dorsum, and this soft tissue cannot have any effect
the eye. on a point above that level.
For this reason, a new strut graft is described.
The strut graft acts like an invisible elastic mono-
PROJECTION BASED ON A MONOPOD pod that will hold the tip in place and still allow
CONCEPT the tip to be mobile (Fig. 2).
Tip drop in the postoperative period occurs
more or less in all cases, and tip projection is still THE “L PROFILE” CONCEPT
an unresolved dilemma after many decades. The In ideal conditions, two medial crura have
suture thread has an active force on the tissues a 90-degree angle in between. This architecture
they hold together. This will typically make the tip gives the two cartilages a shape of an L profile and
stronger at the end of the operation. In contrast, makes the columellar leg of the tripod stronger.
with tissue healing, tension on tip sutures relaxes (Fig. 3).
in days to weeks.
In a natural nose, the tip stands on a tripod,
with left and right lateral crura and two medial NO DISSECTION PUSH-DOWN DORSAL
crura, which together form the third leg. In this REDUCTION
model, tip projection is related to the length of Large dissections cause edema and disturb
the legs of the tripod, and not to the shape or the integrity of the nasal dorsum. If the bony pyr-
strength. amid is infractured during manipulations, there
A short alar cartilage will always result in will be nothing but the skin envelope to hold the
underprojection. Strengthening of the tripod broken bone pieces together. For this reason, the
550
Volume 152, Number 3 • A New, Minimalist Approach for Rhinoplasty
fQneGesK9K6Qk0G8N7nRL8+9JJHP91hfdAvJxqdG3EtHNkyGLj77I7kixrMW8yuNMgxki+ov2vde+GwuMML6U on 09/21/2023
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by luXVnsbozFPHgbIcrIgUvTDUCbkyUcfhjFfXEdHDDdj
2. Injection
skin envelop is not dissected except a 4-mm-wide
dorsal tunnel. The tip and osteotomy lines are infiltrated
with 6 cc of 1:50,000 adrenaline with 2% lido-
caine. The septum is then infiltrated with 6 cc of
NO-CAST APPROACH WITH A NEW 1:200,000 adrenaline and 2% lidocaine.
DORSAL STABILIZATION SUTURE A 27-gauge long (0.4 × 40 mm) needle is used
This is the first and only rhinoplasty tech- for injection. All tip injections are made through
nique where a cast is not used. The idea behind it mucosa. Septal injection should always start at the
is simple. When the bony pyramid is pushed down far back and the highest point, so that the closest
into the nasal antrum, the bony edges of the bony point to the skull base is well infiltrated.
pyramid become trapped and will fix the mobile
bony unit in lateral directions. Then, the bony 3. Incisions
pyramid is fixed to the septum by a new percu- In the closed approach, only marginal inci-
taneous suture technique and immobilized. This sions are used. For the open approach, only a col-
suture also flattens the dorsum. umellar incision is added. To make the dissection
easier, in the next step, a modified intercartilagi-
nous marginal incision that leaves a small segment
SURGICAL STEPS of lateral crural rim on the skin edge is used.
There are 20 steps in this technique, as Medial crura is also incised on the rim level.
follows. Then, both incisions are connected. For the open
551
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • September 2023
fQneGesK9K6Qk0G8N7nRL8+9JJHP91hfdAvJxqdG3EtHNkyGLj77I7kixrMW8yuNMgxki+ov2vde+GwuMML6U on 09/21/2023
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by luXVnsbozFPHgbIcrIgUvTDUCbkyUcfhjFfXEdHDDdj
Fig. 5. Subperichondrial plane is dissected with a fine-tip instru- Fig. 6. In the closed approach, soft tissue between the alar carti-
ment. Leaving a small segment of lateral crural rim on the skin lages is cut for delivery.
edge helps for finding the dissection plane.
7. Opening the Window
approach, an inverted-V incision is added to the The soft tissue that remains intact between
columella. the two alar cartilages is cut to the level of the
methylene blue traces in the soft tissues. In the
4. Tip Dissection open approach, this tissue is cut after columel-
There are two options for the dissection: sub- lar incision. In the closed approach, it is cut by
perichondrial and supraperichondrial. In the stretching the columella skin with the Crile retrac-
author’s experience in the follow-up with the tor (Fig. 6).
patients who had different dissection planes on
the right and left sides, no difference in terms of 8. Dorsal Tunnel and Rasping
edema, shape, or prognosis has been detected. Rasping is done only for weakening the
Although the subperichondrial plane creates a K point. This is done through a dorsal tunnel
cleaner surgical field and allows for more control using a thin rasp designed for this purpose.
over the anatomy, it weakens the alar cartilage; A tiny tunnel is dissected with the periost ele-
this can be a disadvantage in weak cartilages, such vator. The dissection plane is supraperichondrial
as in Latino phenotypes. on upper lateral cartilage, and subperiosteal at
The dissection starts at the level of intercarti- the bony level. The tunnel should only be wide
laginous cut on lateral crura (Fig. 5). [See Video 2 enough to insert the 4-mm rasp. Then, the thin
(online), which demonstrates subperichondrial bony cover at the apex of the dorsal hump is
plane dissection of alar cartilages.] rasped (Fig. 7).
6. Cephalic Resection
Cephalic resection aims to create room for the
hemitransdomal sutures, and to free the lateral
crus from its medial attachments to turn inward
for correction of the resting angle. The incision is
made parallel to the rim. The remaining cartilage
width should be 6 mm at the new dome level in Fig. 7. The dorsal tunnel is dissected and the bony hump is
both sexes. rasped. Rasping is done only to weaken the K area.
552
Volume 152, Number 3 • A New, Minimalist Approach for Rhinoplasty
10. Strip Removal from the Septum there has been no skin dissection, bone segments will
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by luXVnsbozFPHgbIcrIgUvTDUCbkyUcfhjFfXEdHDDdj
553
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • September 2023
fQneGesK9K6Qk0G8N7nRL8+9JJHP91hfdAvJxqdG3EtHNkyGLj77I7kixrMW8yuNMgxki+ov2vde+GwuMML6U on 09/21/2023
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by luXVnsbozFPHgbIcrIgUvTDUCbkyUcfhjFfXEdHDDdj
is harvested from the high strip material. extra loop sutures are necessary for secure fixa-
The graft can be sutured on the left or right tion (Fig. 11).
side, and the surgeon should decide which side
fits better for the facial asymmetry and har- 17. L Profile Reconstruction
mony. As the human face is asymmetric with- Medial crura will be fixed to each other at a
out exception, one side is always better than 90-degree angle. The remnants of the soft tissue
the midline. The angle of the graft determines cut when opening the window in step 7 are sutured
the tip rotation, and the point where the dome with a few 6-0 PDS stitches. A standard medial crural
is fixed on the graft determines the projection overlap may be necessary if there is bowstringing.
(Fig. 10).
A figure-of-eight suture is used for inter- 18. Lateral Crural Excision
domal fixation. The free ends of the figure-of-
At the end of the operation, the lateral crura
eight suture are then wrapped around the strut
are always too long and cause bowstring defor-
and the dome point is fixed to the strut. Two
mity, resulting in bulbosity. The cartilage is cut in
full thickness 2 to 3 mm close to its cephalic end.
The free ends of the cartilage are left free to over-
lap and are fixed when the mucosa is sutured at
this level (Fig. 12).
554
Volume 152, Number 3 • A New, Minimalist Approach for Rhinoplasty
COMPLEMENTARY MANEUVERS
fQneGesK9K6Qk0G8N7nRL8+9JJHP91hfdAvJxqdG3EtHNkyGLj77I7kixrMW8yuNMgxki+ov2vde+GwuMML6U on 09/21/2023
DISCUSSION
The main difference of the technique is its
philosophy, rather than its innovative surgical
maneuvers. The approach is based on the follow-
ing principles, which are the personal opinion of
the author based on experience over the years:
Fig. 13. The nose is only taped, and no cast is used (the frontal 1. Aesthetics and function are related. Human
area is taped for fat injection). beauty perception is related to function, and
555
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • September 2023
fQneGesK9K6Qk0G8N7nRL8+9JJHP91hfdAvJxqdG3EtHNkyGLj77I7kixrMW8yuNMgxki+ov2vde+GwuMML6U on 09/21/2023
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/plasreconsurg by luXVnsbozFPHgbIcrIgUvTDUCbkyUcfhjFfXEdHDDdj
Fig. 14. (Left) Preoperative frontal and side views. (Right) Frontal and side views at 19
months postoperatively.
for this reason beautiful noses breathe well, if necessary. Preserving and leaving the
and a nose that breathes well is beautiful. same anatomy behind gives the advantage
2. The surgeon must trust his or her own eye of being able to use the basic technique
and sense of aesthetics. Sense of beauty is in all cases. This technique is focused
by instincts; it is universal and cannot be on the end result rather than the defor-
taught or be simplified by golden ratios. mity. Overprojection deformity is treated
3. Excellent results can be achieved by pre- exactly like the underprojection defor-
serving the existing anatomy and perform- mity by finding the ideal dome point on
ing a minimalist surgical approach. the strut graft. Similarly, preoperative
4. The basic 20 steps are the same for each rotation will not change the operation
nose and additional steps are added only plans, because rotation is determined by
556
Volume 152, Number 3 • A New, Minimalist Approach for Rhinoplasty
557