GRADE/Section/Group#: DATE Submitted:

Website Design Scoring Sheet

Category Excellent Good Satisfactory Needs Improvement SCORE
Content 15 12 8 4
Learning of Material 15 12 8 4
CSS coding 15 9 6 3
Graphics 12 9 6 3
Layout 12 9 6 3
Navigation 12 9 6 3
Presentation 15 12 9 4
Cooperative Work 9 6 3 2
Color Choices 4 3 2 1
Background design 4 3 2 1
Fonts/Typography 4 3 2 1
Interest 6 4 2 1
Copyright 4 3 2 1
Contact Information 4 3 2 1
Spelling and Grammar 4 3 2 1

Total Points Possible = 135 Your score is ________

Scoring Scale
135 128 121 120 114 108 107 100 94 93 87 81
Excellent Good Satisfactory Needs Improvement
A B C D
CATEGORY Excellent
Content All information provided by the
student on the web site is accurate
and all the requirements of the
assignment have been met. In
other words, there is sufficient
content in this website to learn
about the topic and complete a
research assignment.
Learning of Material The student has an exceptional
understanding of the material
included in the site and where to
find additional information. Can
easily answer questions about the
content and procedures used to
make the web site.
Coding (HTML/CSS) Student uses a style sheet to
define attributes (along with some
inline style), which makes all
pages attractive looking and
consistent.
There are no errors in the HTML,
CSS or other coding on the site as
found by me or an online validator.
Graphics Graphics are related to the
theme/purpose of the site, are
thoughtfully cropped, are of high
quality and enhance reader
interest or understanding. There
are no broken images.
Layout The web site has an exceptionally
attractive and usable layout. It is
easy to locate all important
elements. White space, graphic
elements and/or alignment are
Good
Almost all the information provided
by the student on the web site is
accurate and all requirements of
the assignment have been met. Or
all the information is accurate but
not all of the requirements of the
assignment were met. Information
is not complete.
The student has a good
understanding of the material
included in the site. Can easily
answer questions about the
content and procedures used to
make the web site.
Student uses a style sheet,
however there is some
inconsistencies in relation to the
styles on each page in the web
site.
There are 1-3 coding errors on the
site as found by me or an online
validator.
Graphics are related to the
theme/purpose of the site, are of
good quality and enhance reader
interest or understanding. There
are no broken images.
The web pages have an attractive
and usable layout. It is easy to
locate all important elements.
Satisfactory
Almost all of the information
provided by the student on the web
site is accurate and almost all of
the requirements have been met. If
there is little information on the
website, then it is satisfactory. If
researchers cannot find what they
need on your website, it is
satisfactory.
The student has a fair
understanding of the material
included in the site. Can easily
answer most questions about the
content and procedures used to
make the web site.
Student uses a style sheet,
however, it is not consistent on all
pages, which disrupts consistency
of pages within the web site.
There are 4-5 coding errors on the
site as found by me or an online
validator.
Graphics are related to the
theme/purpose of the site, and are
of good quality. There may be a
few broken images.
The web pages have a usable
layout, but may appear busy or
boring. It is easy to locate most of
the important elements.
Needs Improvement
There are several inaccuracies in
the content provided by the
students OR many of the
requirements were not met. Not
enough content, very incomplete.
Student did not appear to learn
much from this project. Cannot
answer most questions about the
content and the procedures used
to make the web site.
Student fails to use a style sheet
within the pages of the web site.
There are more than 6 coding
errors on the site as found by me
or an online validator.
Graphics seem randomly chosen,
are of low quality, OR distract the
reader. Many images are broken.
The web pages are cluttered
looking or confusing. It is often
difficult to locate important
elements.
 used effectively to organize
material.
Navigation Links for navigation are clearly
labeled, consistently placed, allow
the reader to easily move from a
page to related pages (forward and
back), and take the reader where
s/he expects to go. A user does
not become lost.
Presentation Students presented the project
well. They are familiar with all of
the parts/contents of the site. The
audience easily understands the
purpose of the site and how to
navigate its pages.
Cooperative Work Members show respect for one
another's ideas, divide the work
fairly, and show a commitment to
quality work and support for each
other.
Color Choices Colors of background, fonts,
unvisited and visited links form a
pleasing palette, do not detract
from the content, and are
consistent across pages.
Background Background is exceptionally
attractive, consistent across
pages, adds to the theme or
purpose of the site, and does not
detract from readability.
Fonts The fonts are consistent, easy to
read and point size varies
appropriately for headings and
text. Use of font styles (italic, bold,
underline) is used consistently and
improves readability.
Links for navigation are clearly
labeled, allow the reader to easily
move from a page to related pages
(forward and back), and internal
links take the reader where s/he
expects to go. A user rarely
becomes lost.
Students mostly presented the
project well. They are familiar with
all of the parts/contents of the site.
The audience easily understands
the purpose of the site .
Members show respect for one
another's ideas and divide the
work fairly. There is commitment
by some members toward quality
work and support of one another.
There may have been a few
arguments but they were handled
well.
Colors of background, fonts,
unvisited and visited links do not
detract from the content, and are
consistent across pages.
Background is attractive,
consistent across pages, adds to
the theme or purpose of the site,
and does not detract from
readability.
The fonts are consistent, easy to
read and point size varies
appropriately for headings and
text.
Links for navigation take the
reader where s/he expects to go,
but some needed links seem to be
missing. A user sometimes gets
lost.
Students were able to present the
project. They are mostly familiar
with all of the parts/contents of the
site.
Members show respect for one
another's ideas and divide the
work fairly. There is little evidence
of a commitment toward quality
work in the group or there were
some arguments.
Colors of background, fonts,
unvisited and visited links do not
detract from the content.
Background is consistent across
pages and does not detract from
readability.
The fonts are consistent and point
size varies appropriately for
headings and text.
Some links do not take the reader
to the sites described. A user
typically feels lost.
Students were not able to present
the project well. They are not
familiar with all of the
parts/contents of the site.
Members argue or are
disrespectful of other's ideas and
input. Criticism is not constructive
nor is support offered. The work is
mostly done by one or two people.
Colors of background, fonts,
unvisited and visited links make
the content hard to read or
otherwise distract the reader.
Background detracts from the
readability of the site.
A wide variety of fonts, styles and
point sizes was used.
Interest The author has made an
exceptional attempt to make the
content of this web site interesting
to the people for whom it is
intended.
Copyright Fair use guidelines are followed
with clear, easy-to-locate and
accurate citations for all borrowed
material. No material is included
from websites that state that
permission is required unless
permission has been obtained.
Contact Information Every web page contains a
statement of authorship, school
name, and date of publication/date
last edited.
Spelling and There are either no spelling or
Grammar grammatical errors, but there may
be one or two very minor spelling
and/or grammatical errors in the
entire site.
The author has tried to make the
content of this web site interesting
to the people for whom it is
intended.
Fair use guidelines are followed
with clear, easy-to-locate and
accurate citations for almost all
borrowed material. No material is
included from websites that state
that permission is required unless
permission has been obtained.
Almost all web pages contain a
statement of authorship, school
name, and date of publication/date
last edited.
There are a few spelling and/or
grammatical errors in the entire
site.
The author has put lots of
information in the web site but
there is little evidence that the
person tried to present the
information in an interesting way.
Fair use guidelines are followed
with clear, easy-to-locate and
accurate citations for most
borrowed material. No material is
included from websites that state
that permission is required unless
permission has been obtained.
Most (75-80%) web pages contain
a statement of authorship, school
name, and date of publication/date
last edited.
There are several spelling and/or
grammatical errors in the entire
site.
The author has provided only the
minimum amount of information
and has not transformed the
information to make it more
interesting to the audience (e.g.,
has only provided a list of links to
the content of others).
Borrowed materials are not
properly documented OR material
was borrowed without permission
from a site that requires
permission
Several web pages do not contain
a statement of authorship, school
name, and/or date of
publication/date last edited.
There are maybe many spelling
and/or grammatical errors in the
entire site.