COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET (CRS)

CONTRACT NUMBER LC19103100

CONTRACT TITLE: ECS FOR NEW LABORATORY BUILDING AT QP REFINERY, MESAIEED

QP EXTERNAL TRANSMITTAL REFERENCE, DATED: PID/LC19103100/EXT/TN/0169

DOCUMENT NUMBER, REV & TITLE: 4154-0-TQ-0004, REV. 2, TECHNICAL QUERY #4 - GENERATOR LOAD LAST REVISION STATUS: 2

PREVIOUS ISSUED DRAWING NUMBER MADE VOID (IF ANY) N/A

SR. QP COMMENTS CONTRACTOR'S RESPONSE REMARKS
NO
QP Engineer Section Comments
Ref id.
EGEC is advised to check the following suggested configuration and
1
provide the details for QP review.
New LV Switchgear (3) to be provided taking one feeder from LV
1.1 Switchgear 1 and second feeder form LV Switchgear 2. Bus coupler to
be provided with ATS system.
All HVAC loads to be fed from LV Switchgear(3), not in Emergency
1.2
switchboard
Kindly note that as per discussion with Lab. Specialist and QP Mechanical Engr.,
New Emergency Switchboard to be provided taking one feeder from the layout considered remains conceptually the same except for all chillers to
the new LV Switchgear 3 and second feeder from a Generator be connected under "non-essential loads" and a separate LV Emergency
1.3
(Remove the Generators from LV Switchgear 1 & LV Switchgear 2 as Switchgear with only one (1) EDG set rated at 1250kVA. Refer to Rev. S2 Key
shown in the key SLD) Single-Line Diagram, drawing no. 4154-25-16-32-001 for details.

1.4 The emergency switchboard to feed all the essential loads and UPS.

1.5 HVAC will be removed from the generator

By this configuration, generator size will be drastically reduced and
1.6 the spare capacity and margins shall be followed as mentioned in
Shell DEP.
The Generator load shall be estimated after finalization of Key Single Noted. Refer to Electrical Utility Data, Rev. S2 with the document no. 4154-25-
1.7
Line Diagram 16-30-111-S2 for details on loads under generator supply.

Please submit list of electrical loads to be fed from generator with

Noted. Refer to Electrical Utility Data, Rev. S2 with document no. 4154-25-16-
2 OAE/31R this TQ. It seems huge load is connected to Generator. QP PTE to
30-111-S2 for details on loads under generator supply.
verify and review the need of electrical loads fed from Generator.

Kindly note that as per discussion with Lab. Specialist and QP Mechanical Engr.,
Why HVAC loads are considered on Generator as Kahramaa supply is HVAC loads considered remains conceptually the same to be connected to
2.1 very reliable. There is no Generator supply in existing chemical Generator except for all chillers which will be connected under "non-essential
laboratory. loads". Refer to Rev. S2 Key Single-Line Diagram, drawing no. 4154-25-16-32-
001 for details.

Doc. No.: 4154-0-TQ-0004 Page 1 of 2

 Kindly note that UPS is connected in Generator supply and vital laboratory
Please consider Telecom equipment loads wherever UPS is provided/
3 equipment and telecom loads are under UPS connection, therefore also with
connected too.
generator support. Refer to attachment 1 for details.

Noted that it is mentioned in the TQ, as per the Laboratory specialist

requirement, HVAC loads are to be connected to Emergency Kindly note that as per discussion with Lab. Specialist and QP Mechanical Engr.,
Generator. But could not find any appropriate justification is given. HVAC loads considered remains conceptually the same to be connected to
4 QP will not be convinced for such large capital investment consultant Generator except for all chillers which will be connected under "non-essential
is not able to justify the requirement based on a proper risk loads". Refer to Rev. S2 Key Single-Line Diagram, drawing no. 4154-25-16-32-
assessment. Consultant shall the following while the following 001 for details.
points.

Kindly note that as per Shell DEP, it requires to provide power supply with
1. The power supply from kahramaa is highly reliable. Consultant is
provision for redundancy (ie. N+1) as well as back-up for UPS loads and standby
well aware of the redundancy they are considering in their design.
generator is mandatory when critical loads require power for extended time
QP do not have record of any such power failures in MIC/Refinery.
period. Refer to attachment 2 for details.

2 What is the impact of power failure? whether impact can be Kindly note that as per discussion with Lab. Specialist and QP Mechanical Engr.,
mitigated by any emergency repose plan such as evacuating from the HVAC loads considered remains conceptually the same to be connected to
laboratory or by connecting the exhaust fans to Emergency Generator except for all chillers which will be connected under "non-essential
generator, instead of connecting HVAC load to the emergency loads". Refer to Rev. S2 Key Single-Line Diagram, drawing no. 4154-25-16-32-
generator 001 for details.

Kindly note that according to the power capacity required for Admin zone
HVAC, it was only foreseen with 2-Nos. 5.06kW rated AHUs (eg. 25‐04‐HAH‐A,
Duty & 25‐04‐HAH‐B, Standby) under MCC-2 Panel. Therefore it was considered
to connect the same along with MCC Panel supplying Lab HVAC as it is
impractical to make a separate MCC Panel just to supply the two (2) Admin zone
3. Clarify if lab zone HVAC only is proposed to connect or Both Lab & AHUs. Moreover, in reference to Electrical Utility Data, Rev. S2 with the
Admin zone HVAC included? document no. 4154-25-16-30-111-S2, it can be noted that the Admin HVAC load
is only less than 1% compared to the total loads foreseen connected to the
generator, and with that small percentage of power contribution to emergency
load, it doesn't affect the total power requirement to size an indicative
generator rating. Furthermore, all the sizing and emergency load rating shall be
verified and updated in the detailed design stage.

Doc. No.: 4154-0-TQ-0004 Page 2 of 2