Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PD1CJVPML
PD1CJVPML
https://doi.org/10.1007/s13365-023-01180-w
Abstract
The aim of this study is to analyze the clinical characteristics and outcomes of Chinese patients with progressive multifocal
leukoencephalopathy (PML) who were treated with programmed cell death protein 1 (PD1) blockade therapies. We retro-
spectively analyzed patients who were admitted to our hospital between October 1, 2020, and October 1, 2022, diagnosed
with PML and treated with PD1 blockade therapies. Four patients with PML who were treated with PD1 blockade therapies
were identified. All patients were male, and their ages ranged from 19 to 54 years old. One patient (Case 2) exhibited mild
pleocytosis, while three patients (Cases 2–4) had markedly reduced T lymphocyte cell counts prior to treatment. The time
interval between symptom onset and treatment initiation ranged from six to 54 weeks. All patients received pembrolizumab
treatment, with a total of two to four doses administered. Three patients who responded to pembrolizumab treatment showed
clinical improvement starting around 8 weeks after the initiation of therapy. Although one patient did not show clinical
improvement, they ultimately survived until the last follow-up. None of the patients in this study exhibited immune-related
adverse events or immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome. PD1 blockade appears to be a promising novel therapeutic
option for PML; additional prospective studies are necessary to confirm its efficacy.
13
Vol.:(0123456789)
Journal of NeuroVirology
13
Journal of NeuroVirology
Table 1 Clinical features of the four patients treated with pembroli- specific reads), and CSF JCV PCR revealed a viral load of
zumab 1.68 × 102 copies/mL. He was diagnosed with PML. The
Case 1 Case 2 Case 3 Case 4 patient received pembrolizumab, with a dosage of 200 mg
intravenously every 4 weeks for three doses. The symptoms
Age 19 31 51 54
improved gradually, and he was able to walk without assis-
Sex M M M M
tance about 6 months after the first admission. The brain
Immunodeficiencies X-HIGM CIDa CIDb CIDc
MRI indicated the stabilization of the lesions (Fig. 1M–P).
Time from Sx to Tx (w) 6 40 16 54
He remained stable during the follow-up period.
Total doses of PEM 2 3 4 4
mRS prior to Tx 5 4 5 5
Case 3 A 51-year-old man with consanguineous parents
mRS at last F/U 5 2 4 3
presented with a 3-month history of dizziness, dysarthria,
Time from Tx to CI (w) NA 8 8 8
and unsteady gait. Brain MRI with contrast revealed T2
Doses of PEM before CI NA 2 2 2
hyperintensities in the right cerebellum and brachium pon-
IRIS None None None None
tis without enhancement, suggesting CNS demyelination
irAEs None None None None
(Fig. 1Q–X). Pulse corticosteroid was administered, but
F/U time (w) 81 77 54 26
his symptoms worsened after treatment. Brain biopsy was
CI continuous improvement, F/U follow-up, irAEs immune-related performed, which showed a demyelinating pattern with
adverse events, IRIS immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome, foam cells, bizarre-looking glial cells, and scattered lym-
mRS modified Rankin Scale, NA not applicable, PEM pembroli- phocytes (Fig. 2). On admission, the patient had bilateral
zumab, CID combined immunodeficiency, Sx symptoms, Tx treatment
a
ataxia, with the right upper limbs more affected, and was
Screening for HIV infection, cancers, autoimmune diseases, and
hereditary disorders (whole exome sequencing) did not reveal any
bedridden due to severe dizziness and vomiting aggravated
positive results by head movements. Laboratory tests revealed decreased T
b
T cell counts and IgG levels remained persistently low. However, and B cell counts. Repeat brain MRI showed enlargement of
screening for HIV infection, cancers, and autoimmune diseases all the previous lesion. The CSF JCV PCR returned a negative
came back negative. Whole exome sequencing showed a copy num- result, whereas JCV was detected in both the CSF (with 25
ber variation in the region chr19:53,792,911–54,327,464, including
NLRP12, DPRX, and other genes
specific reads) and brain tissue (with 19,894 specific reads)
c obtained from the previous biopsy using mNGS. Therefore,
The count of naïve CD4+ T cells was 5/μL. Screening for HIV infec-
tion, cancers, autoimmune diseases, and hereditary disorders through immunostaining for JCV capsid proteins was conducted
whole exome sequencing did not yield any positive results on the prior brain biopsy tissue, uncovering SV40-positive
inclusions within infected oligodendrocytes, affirming
JCV infection (Fig. 2B). The patient was diagnosed with
mL. He was diagnosed with PML and X-linked hyper-IgM PML and treated with pembrolizumab at a dose of 200 mg
syndrome (X-HIGM). Treatment with pembrolizumab was intravenously every 3 weeks for four doses. Gradual symp-
initiated at a dose of 200 mg intravenously every 4 weeks tom improvement was observed, with the lesions showing
for two doses. IVIG and mirtazapine were also administered. improvement (Fig. 1A7–A10) after the initial aggravation
However, the patient’s condition did not improve, and brain (Fig. 1A3–A6) within the first 6 weeks of treatment, and the
MRI showed progression of the lesions (Fig. 1E–H). He patient regained the ability to stand and eat without assis-
remained unconscious and required mechanical ventilation tance approximately 3 months after discharge. Follow-up
during follow-up. assessments showed stable neurological symptoms.
Case 2 A 31-year-old man presented with a 9-month history Case 4 A 54-year-old man with a 10-year history of scle-
of unsteady gait and 4 months of ataxia in the upper limbs. rosing glomerulonephritis presented with blurred vision
He had a past medical history of hepatitis B and several for 12 months, weakness of the lower limbs for 2 months,
infections, including pulmonary infection and infectious and cognitive decline for 1 month. He was maintained on
colitis, in the last few years. Despite receiving antitubercu- low-dose corticosteroids. MRI of the brain performed by
losis drugs and glucocorticoids, his symptoms worsened. On a local hospital revealed choroid plexus papilloma and T2
admission, the neurological examination revealed intention hyperintensity in several brain regions without enhancement
tremor in the finger-to-nose test, limb ataxia, and a promi- (Fig. 1A11–A14). On admission, the patient was unable to
nent wide-based gait. He required assistance to walk. Labo- stand and self-feed. Lumbar puncture was performed; the
ratory tests revealed low levels of serum IgM and IgA and CSF JCV PCR yielded a negative result, while JCV was
decreased T and B cell counts. Brain MRI showed FLAIR detected in the CSF using mNGS (75 specific reads). He was
hyperintensities in the right frontal lobe and cerebellum diagnosed with PML and treated with pembrolizumab at a
(Fig. 1I–L). JCV was detected in the CSF by mNGS (16 dose of 200 mg intravenously every three to 4 weeks for four
13
Journal of NeuroVirology
13
Journal of NeuroVirology
Fig. 2 Histopathology of the brain biopsy in Case 3. A Hematoxy- immunostains, showing slight infiltration of T lymphocytes in the
lin–eosin (H&E) stain of brain biopsy, showing numerous foam cells lesion (× 200). D CD68 immunostains, showing extensive infiltration
and scattered lymphocytes (× 100). B Immunostaining for JCV capsid of mononuclear phagocytes in the lesion (× 200)
proteins reveals the presence of infected glial cells (× 200). C CD3
prior to treatment (Fig. 1A15–A18). Although the brain lesions 2020; Sanjo et al. 2019). Recovery of anti-JCV C D4+ and
+
in Case 1 and Case 3 had increased in size, they did not show CD8 T cell responses corresponds to PML patients’ sur-
any contrast enhancement, which suggests that IRIS is an vival (Gheuens et al. 2011). PD1 blockade led to increased
unlikely explanation. In Case 4, a contrast brain MRI was not JCV-specific CD8+ interferon γ response in T cells from a
feasible due to renal failure. subset of healthy volunteers and one patient with active PML
(Beck and Cortese 2020).
Several cases of PML treated with PD1 blockade have
Discussion been reported, primarily through case reports, case series,
and retrospective studies (Beudel et al. 2021; Cortese et al.
We report the use of PD1 blockade in the treatment of PML at 2019; Darcy et al. 2022; Grassl et al. 2020; Lambert et al.
an encephalitis center in China. Among four patients treated 2022; Mahler et al. 2020; Möhn et al. 2021; Pinnetti et al.
with pembrolizumab, three showed improvement, and one sur- 2022; Roos-Weil et al. 2021; Volk et al. 2021; Walter et al.
vived. In patients who respond to PD1 blockade, symptoms 2019). Among these patients, pembrolizumab is the most
typically stabilize around 2 months after treatment. commonly used drug, followed by nivolumab. The patients
T cell exhaustion, which is associated with the expression in these studies had various immunodeficiencies, including
of inhibitory molecules such as PD1 and its receptor PD1 hematological malignancies, primary immunodeficiency,
ligand 1 (PDL1), plays a role in PML (Wherry and Kurachi autoimmune diseases, solid organ transplants, AIDS, and
2015). Previous studies demonstrated that the expression of neoplasms, with hematological malignancies being the most
PD1 is elevated on C D4+ and C
D8+ T cells in patients with common underlying disease. Approximately half of these
+
PML; besides, P D1 lymphocytes and P DL1+ CD68+ cells patients showed improvement or stabilization with treat-
have been observed in PML brain lesions (Beck and Cortese ment. According to a retrospective study, immune-related
13
Journal of NeuroVirology
adverse events (irAEs) occurred in about 30% of patients, peripheral blood T cell counts appeared to benefit from
and immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome (IRIS) PD1 blockade treatment, which primarily enhances T cell
was observed in 20% of patients (Boumaza et al. 2023). effector function.
Notably, two patients developed PML after treatment with There are some limitations for this retrospective study.
nivolumab (Hoang et al. 2019; Martinot et al. 2018), and First, brain MRI was not regularly performed during the
one patient developed PML after treatment with durvalumab treatment in some patients. Second, PD1 expression on
(Vinatier et al. 2022). In the present study, three out of four C D4 + and C D8 + T lymphocytes was not tested. Third,
patients showed improvement after treatment, and no cases regular follow-up visits were difficult to maintain during
of irAEs or IRIS were observed. the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic.
PD1 blockade appears to require some time to become
effective. According to the current study, symptoms usually
become stable around 2 months after receiving two doses of
pembrolizumab. The neuroimaging results of Case 3 were Conclusion
consistent with this phenomenon, in which the brain lesions
initially increased in size in the MRI performed 1 week and In conclusion, immune checkpoint inhibitors targeting
6 weeks after treatment. However, as symptoms improved, PD1 show promise as a novel therapeutic option for PML.
the lesions stopped growing in the brain MRI conducted 3 However, further prospective studies are needed to con-
months after treatment. firm their efficacy.
Previous studies have shown that achieving an unde-
tectable viral load in the CSF and a decrease in lesions
Funding This study was funded by the National High Level Hospi-
visualized on T2-weighted MRI after ICI administration tal Clinical Research Funding (Grant No. 2022-PUMCH-B-120) and
is associated with a good clinical response (Lambert et al. CAMS Innovation Fund for Medical Sciences (Grant No. CIFMS:
2021). However, primary immunodeficiency leading to 2021-I2M-C&T-A-002).
low CD4 + T cells may not be effective, especially when
given late in the disease course (Küpper et al. 2019). In Declarations
the current study, it was observed that three patients who Conflict of interest The authors declare no competing interests.
responded to PD1 blockade were negative for CSF JCV
PCR after treatment. Moreover, patients with decreased
13
Journal of NeuroVirology
13