Based on the information provided, it seems that the contributions of A, B, C, and E to X
and Y are mediated through common ancestors S and D. A can only contribute to X and Y through S, and if A were the ancestor of both S and D, it would need to be included as a common ancestor to account for its contributions through both S and D. This ensures that the genetic contributions from A to X and Y are appropriately accounted for in the lineage.