21/4/24, 0:07 A new look for the canonization process under Pope Francis?

| National Catholic Reporter

Free Newsletters TRANSLATE

SIGN UP NOW

☰ Menu Donate Renew SUBSCRIBE

A new look for the canonization process under

Pope Francis?
BY NICHOLAS COLLURA

View Author Profile

Join the Conversation

Send your thoughts to Letters to the Editor. Learn more

September 30, 2014Pope John Paul II has always had a reputation for

being the pope who canonized people most liberally: reducing

the number of miracles required for beatification and sainthood, abbreviating the
wait time after a candidate's death, and naming more saints than all his
predecessors combined.

I am beginning to wonder, however, whether Pope Francis is going to outdo him in

saint-making bravado, if not in numbers.

Take a look at a list of the saints Francis has canonized since the beginning of his
pontificate. As of this printing, there are 10. What is striking is that six of them --
more than half -- were canonized without the two requisite miracles.

Moreover, the Vatican has just announced that another saint, Giuseppe Vaz of Sri
Lanka, will also have his second miracle waived.

The pope is using an 18th-century process known as "equivalent canonization." It

allows people to become saints not on the basis of miracles, but because of a long-
standing cult, of the "constant and common attestation" of a virtuous life, and of an
"uninterrupted reputation for wonders."

https://www.ncronline.org/blogs/ncr-today/new-look-canonization-process-under-pope-francis 1/6
21/4/24, 0:07 A new look for the canonization process under Pope Francis? | National Catholic Reporter

According to Cardinal Angelo Amato of the Congregation for the Causes of Saints,
the process, "though not frequent, is not rare." It had been used most recently by
Pope Benedict XVI in the case of Hildegard of Bingen, whom he also made a doctor of
the church. Yet it is increasingly in vogue under Pope Francis, who may soon hold
the honor of making more saints by equivalent canonization than all of his
predecessors combined.

This is fitting for a pope who has insisted that the church be of the poor. The saint-
making process -- with its drawn-out inquiries and trials -- is notoriously
expensive, and usually only dioceses and religious orders with some financial means
are capable of launching these protracted canonization campaigns. This has resulted
in an underrepresentation of saints among the laity and in some less traditionally
Catholic countries around the world.

This discrepancy has caught the pope's attention. Meeting a Cambodian woman in
South Korea, for instance, he reportedly promised to speak to "my friend Angelo"
about the dearth of native Cambodian saints.

Acting on executive order like this could help to democratize the process for smaller
churches eager to see their local blesseds recognized. Along these lines, it is worth
noting that the soon-to-be-canonized Vaz will be Sri Lanka's first native-born
saint.

Naturally, diminishing the role of the saint-making bureaucracy gives greater

consequence to the subjective feelings of the pope. There have been rumblings that
Francis' choice of saints (Peter Faber, José de Anchieta) has shown favoritism
toward the Jesuits. Likewise, much ink has been spilled over the theological
significance of the canonization of John XXIII, just as more will be spilled if Francis
canonizes Archbishop Oscar Romero.

But saint-making is just one way among many that a pope can set the church's tone.
Perhaps the greater stakes here involve traditional pieties concerning the
supernatural.

Whatever the pope's personal theological opinion of miracles, equivalent

canonization could be seen as more befitting 21st-century ideas about science.

The church's centuries-old insistence on ascertainable miracles was actually an

attempt to apply greater rigor to a tradition rooted in the spontaneous acclamations
of local cults. Yet many today will wonder whether popular veneration, if seemingly
more subjective, isn't ultimately a more sober criterion of people's holiness than
miracles are.

https://www.ncronline.org/blogs/ncr-today/new-look-canonization-process-under-pope-francis 2/6