Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 s2.0 S0021929008001917 Main
1 s2.0 S0021929008001917 Main
Abstract
Coordinated rheological and biochemical measurements provide the linear and nonlinear mechanical properties of the vitreous and
demonstrate the structural role of hyaluronic acid. ‘‘Cleated’’ tools are used to overcome wall slip and avoid tissue compression during
measurements of the dynamic moduli of fresh porcine and bovine vitreous. Shear moduli decreased five-fold from initial to steady-state
values in the first hour after dissection. Steady-state values (porcine: G0 ¼ 2.870.9 Pa, n ¼ 9; bovine: G0 ¼ 7.072.0 Pa, n ¼ 17) are
significantly greater than previously reported. The decrease in modulus after removal from the eye correlates with a decrease in mass:
even in the absence of external driving forces, porcine vitreous expels 5% of its mass within 5 min and continues to decay to a steady-
state mass 10% lower than its initial mass. The expelled fluid has a substantial hyaluronan concentration, but very low protein content.
These results indicate that the vitreous network is under tension at its native volume and its high initial modulus results from this state of
tension. We hypothesize that hyaluronan plays a role in sustaining the ‘‘internal tension’’ by Donnan swelling.
r 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0021-9290/$ - see front matter r 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jbiomech.2008.04.015
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.S. Nickerson et al. / Journal of Biomechanics 41 (2008) 1840–1846 1841
made reliable measurements extremely difficult. A number ing direct, quantitative, time-resolved rheological charac-
of creative methods have been devised to quantify the gel terization of the vitreous using a fluids rheometer
character of the vitreous including bulk measurements (Nickerson and Kornfield, 2005). The cleat geometry
(Bettelheim and Wang, 1976; Pfeiffer, 1963; Tokita et al., suppresses wall slip while causing minimal disturbance to
1984), magnetic microrheology (Lee et al., 1992, 1994a, b), tissue structure and properties during measurement (see
in vivo visual tracking for humans (Zimmerman, 1980), and Section 2). We have used this method to track the softening
more recently, acoustic techniques (Walton et al., 2002). that occurs after the vitreous is extracted from the eye.
These techniques allow for comparative analyses in terms Prior literature makes no mention of time-dependence of
of phenomenological parameters, but not for quantitative the modulus of the vitreous post-dissection; and our results
measurements. indicated that the literature values of the modulus are
We have recently described a rheological tool—the systematically low for bovine and porcine vitreous—even
‘‘cleat geometry’’—designed to address the difficulties when compared to the relatively low steady-state values
mentioned above (Nickerson and Kornfield, 2005), allow- (Nickerson et al., 2005).
We also apply the cleat geometry to examine vitreous
failure characteristics under high strain, pertinent to certain
injuries and surgical procedures. During severe head
trauma, the vitreous gel can be detached and, in turn,
cause retinal tears. During vitrectomy procedures per-
formed to treat diabetic retinopathy, among other diseases,
surgeons destroy the vitreous in order to remove it from the
eye. However, to our knowledge, there have been no
published studies that demonstrate the maximum stress the
vitreous can bear or the behavior of the tissue as it fails.
Rheological results, together with observations of mass
changes and analytical biochemistry, give insight into the
molecular mechanisms responsible for the bulk behavior.
In contrast to prior literature, we find that hyaluronan does
contribute significantly to the elastic character of the
vitreous. In particular, the swelling pressure of hyaluronan
drives the network of rope-like collagen fibrils into a state
of tension (in accord with their appearance in the presence
of hyaluronan), increasing the rigidity of the network.
Fresh bovine and porcine eyes were acquired through Sierra for
Medical Science (Santa Fe Springs, CA, USA). All specimens were tested
Fig. 1. Schematic depiction of the network structure of the vitreous. The between 3 and 48 h postmortem; storage as an intact globe for up to 60 h
vitreous is composed of a highly swollen double network of heterotypic postmortem did not affect rheological results as observed previously
collagen fibrils (primarily type II) and hyaluronic acid. (Weber et al., 1982). Eyes were gently dissected to remove the vitreous
Fig. 2. Typical time sweep of fresh bovine (A) and porcine (B) vitreous samples showing the rapid modulus decay to a steady state after removal from the
eye (g ¼ 3%, o ¼ 10 rad/s). The loss tangent reached steady state more rapidly, often in as little as 20 min in bovine (tan d ¼ 0.3170.03) and 2 min in
porcine (tan d ¼ 0.2470.09) specimens.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
1842 C.S. Nickerson et al. / Journal of Biomechanics 41 (2008) 1840–1846
with minimal disruption. Intact vitreous was either used directly or a disc- reflect rapid initial changes, making the observed moduli
like section (typically 1.5–2.5 g) was cut with the axis of the disc coinciding
sensitive to the precise time from dissection to loading.
with the anterior-to-posterior axis of the eye. Some of the vitreous discs
were loaded into a cleated 25 mm parallel disc geometry for mechanical Smaller standard deviations for porcine samples were
characterization and the remainder were used for network stability studies. achieved by using a consistent loading time of approxi-
Cone-and-plate geometries are inappropriate for crosslinked gels because mately 1 min from removal of the dissected globe to
high compression near the center of the tool induces a non-uniform inception of measurement. The average steady-state moduli
normal force profile and destroys the vitreous network. The initial for bovine vitreous were G0 fin ¼ 7.072.0 Pa and
modulus values are very sensitive to the time that elapses between
dissection and rheological testing. Therefore, dissection time was kept as G00 fin ¼ 2.270.6 Pa and for porcine vitreous
uniform as possible (2–3 min) and tissue was transferred to the instrument G0 fin ¼ 2.870.9 Pa and G00 fin ¼ 0.770.4 Pa.
immediately after dissection was completed.
Mechanical measurements were made on an ARES-RFS fluids
rheometer from TA Instruments, Inc. (New Castle, DE, USA) using the
3.2. Frequency and strain dependence
‘‘cleat geometry’’ to overcome slip (Nickerson and Kornfield, 2005).
Measurement using previously reported methods for overcoming wall slip, The strain amplitude (3%) and frequency (10 rad/s) for
such as roughened plates or sandpaper, failed because the upper boundary vitreous analysis were optimized to achieve gentle defor-
of the vitreous develops a lubricating layer. Cleated tools succeed by mations close to the linear viscoelastic regime. At 10 rad/s,
penetrating the lubricating boundary layer to achieve an effective no-slip
boundary condition. All measurements were made in a closed, humid
the porcine vitreous responds linearly at or below 3%
atmosphere at 20 1C and with zero normal force on the samples. Shear strain (Fig. 3). To optimize the signal-to-noise ratio,
moduli were monitored as samples were subjected to oscillatory strain oscillatory shear experiments were conducted near the
(g ¼ 3%) at a fixed frequency (o ¼ 10 rad/s) for up to 90 min. Longer upper limit of the linear regime at g ¼ 3%. The broad
experimental times were precluded by drying of the sample edges, which plateau modulus region expected for gels (Ferry, 1980)
artificially raised the apparent modulus of the samples. The conditions for
these experiments were chosen based on the observed dynamic moduli as
appears below 5 rad/s with storage modulus rising
functions of frequency (g ¼ 3%, o ¼ 1–50 rad/s) and strain (o ¼ 10 rad/s, significantly as frequency increases (Fig. 4). To generate
g ¼ 0.5–100%). sufficiently large torques for the instrument specifications
In addition to oscillatory tests, steady shear rate tests were conducted to while operating at small strain amplitudes, a frequency of
determine the minimum shear stress and strain required to destroy the 10 rad/s was required. Thus, the moduli we report may be
tissue. These ‘‘failure’’ tests were conducted after the moduli reach steady
state in oscillatory shear (Fig. 2). A steady shear rate (_g ¼ 0:1 s1 ) was
somewhat higher than the gel’s plateau modulus. The
applied for 150 s while continuously monitoring the resulting shear stress. strain and frequency dependencies of bovine vitreous are
Higher and lower shear rates (_g ¼ 0:3 and 0:01 s1 ) were also probed similar to the porcine data shown.
separately, to demonstrate the rate-dependence of the transient shear stress.
The discovery that vitreous loses elasticity and exudes fluid after
dissection motivated us to measure the time-dependent mass loss and the 3.3. Failure tests
composition of the exuded fluid. Post-dissection weight loss was measured
in four different environments denoted A–D: (A) an intact vitreous body Shear stress rises sharply at the onset of steady shear,
was placed in a dry Petri dish and covered; (B–D) central discs of vitreous rapidly reaches a rate-dependent maximum, and then
were placed in covered Petri dishes that were either (B) dry, (C) filled with
isotonic saline or (D) filled with mechanically liquefied vitreous from other
eyes. Liquefied vitreous was obtained by removing the vitreous of three to
six fresh eyes of the same species immediately prior to the experiment and
slicing them into small fragments, which caused much of the sacrificial
vitreous tissue to liquefy. The mass of each vitreous sample was measured
immediately after removal from the eye (Mo) and only once at the end of
the treatment period (Mf)—excess handling damages the vitreous and
artificially accelerates weight loss. The treatment periods ranged from 5 to
120 min. One specimen was subjected to condition A and photographed at
1, 10, 30, and 90 min from the moment it was placed in the Petri dish.
Using condition C, the components exuded into the saline solution were
analyzed for hyaluronic acid (Hyaluronic Acid Test Kit; Corgenix, Inc.,
Denver, CO, USA) and the presence of protein (ninhydrin assay).
3. Results
4. Discussion
Fig. 6. This sequence of photographs illustrates the state of a whole vitreous gently removed from a fresh porcine eye, 1, 10, 30, and 90 min after
dissection. The vitreous was kept in a dry, covered Petri dish during the course of the experiment.
that expel fluid from the vitreous (Fig. 7). Two obvious
driving forces in conditions A and B are gravity and
diffusion, with gravity playing a smaller role in B due to its
flatter shape.
Conditions C and D are significantly different from
A and B because gravity and concentration gradient-driven
diffusion have been eliminated. In C, the saline bath
allows the vitreous to float at neutral buoyancy in a
solution that is isotonic with the primary soluble compo-
nent of the vitreous—NaCl. In D, the vitreous is
completely surrounded by other vitreous material—thereby
completely eliminating the concentration gradient for all
components, including hyaluronic acid. Despite these
changes there is still a mass loss on the order of 7% in
the first 5–10 min. The unexpected observation that mass
loss proceeds in the absence of hydrostatic pressure
gradients or composition gradients suggests that hyalur-
onan is not simply diffusing out of the vitreous but, rather,
Fig. 7. Changes in porcine vitreous sample mass monitored over time
that it is driven out.
under the following conditions: whole vitreous placed in covered Petri dish
(A), central section of vitreous placed in covered Petri dish that is dry (B), It is well accepted that hyaluronan draws water into the
contains isotonic saline (C), or contains mechanically liquefied vitreous fibril network to achieve Donnan equilibrium, adds
(D) (n ¼ 4). chemical stability to the collagen, and separates the fibrils
(Bishop, 2000; Bos et al., 2001; Sebag and Balazs, 1989).
deformations (beyond the peak stress). This is in agreement Polyelectrolytes, such as HA, are swollen by the hydration
with the accepted view that the vitreous network contains a spheres of their associated counter ions (Flory, 1953). The
distribution of fibril sizes that randomly associate along counter ions also greatly increase the entropic cost of
their lengths (Bishop, 2000; Sebag, 1989). The rate- molecular overlap because a single overlap event between
dependence of failure stress and strain show that the two polymers results in the doubling of the local
vitreous stiffens considerably against rapid deformations— concentration of many counter ions. Based upon its
possibly a protective mechanism against head trauma. In approximate concentration (which is not completely
the context of vitreous surgery, it may be advantageous to homogeneous) (Ansari et al., 2001; Bishop, 2000), mole-
remove the vitreous slowly due to the observed failure cular weight (Bishop, 2000), and radius of gyration
characteristics: during vitrectomy, the vitreous may con- (Mendichi et al., 2003) in the vitreous, HA is at or beyond
tinue to transfer a substantial fraction of its maximum its overlap concentration under physiological conditions.
stress to the retina long after yielding (Fig. 5). Thus, HA is well suited to drawing water into the vitreous
and separating fibrils, as proposed by previous authors
4.2. Mass loss (Bishop, 2000; Bos et al., 2001; Sebag and Balazs, 1989).
We suggest that the swelling pressure and resistance to
The qualitative and quantitative differences observed overlap also play a direct role in stiffening the vitreous in
under conditions A–D provide insight into the mechanisms vivo and driving fluid out after dissection.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
C.S. Nickerson et al. / Journal of Biomechanics 41 (2008) 1840–1846 1845
4.3. Network tension hypothesis throughout the network. The validity of this ‘‘homoge-
neous properties’’ prediction can be verified by comparing
We hypothesize that hyaluronan increases the moduli of the weight-loss behavior of conditions A and B: early
the vitreous by placing the collagen network under internal weight loss driven by the network is nearly identical even
tension as it swells to its Donnan equilibrium hydration though different portions of the vitreous are being
state (Fig. 8A vs. B) (Nickerson et al., 2005). Tension on examined. In both mechanisms, fluid loss should also
individual collagen fibrils would reduce their ability to soften the vitreous (Figs. 2 and 5). Finally, both mechan-
deform and, thereby, increase the modulus. isms are in accord with Bos’s microscopic observation that
We offer two plausible mechanisms by which hyaluronan the collagen network appears to ‘‘relax’’ after removal of
could induce network tension. Flexible and semiflexible hyaluronan (Bos et al., 2001).
macromolecules can be visualized as entropic springs that While this is the first evidence that network tension
exert an entropically driven elastic force when their end-to- stiffens the vitreous, the concept of hydrostatic structures
end distance is increased beyond its equilibrium value (‘‘hydrostats’’) is well known in the biomechanics literature
(Ferry, 1980). Thus, vitreous collagen fibrils are loosely (Vogel, 2003). One notable example of hydrostatic pressure
analogous to a stretched web of ropes; the semiflexible contributing to mechanical strength is cartilage (Hasler
fibers resist stretching to their fully extended length due to et al., 1999; Vogel, 2003). Like the vitreous, cartilage consists
the loss of entropy as they are restricted from undulating of a hydrated network of collagen II containing fibrils filled
(bending). It is known that hyaluronan is essentially with highly charged HA. Cartilage has a much greater
trapped in the vitreous, and so can be regarded as being modulus than the vitreous due to its higher protein content,
enveloped in a semipermeable membrane. The hydrostatic but the underlying mechanism appears to be the same—
pressure (due to hyaluronan-induced Donnan swelling), Donnan swelling due to the high fixed charge density stiffens
exerts an outward force on the semipermeable periphery of the tissue by extending the collagen fibrils of the network.
the vitreous network, which may stretch it until the collagen Our internal tension model suggests that the initial value
fibrils are pulled taut. A second possible tension mechanism of the modulus, measured within minutes of dissection may
arises if the hyaluronan is bound to the network strands, as resemble the mechanical properties of tissue in vivo, where
suggested by Scott (2001). The affinity of hyaluronan for the collagen fibrils are stretched. While it appears that our
water would drive the attachment points to separate. The steady-state moduli are systematically lower than in vivo,
fibril would extend until the chemical potential of swelling they are also useful for several reasons. First, while they
was balanced by the conformational entropic loss. Just as in represent minimum values for the native moduli, they are
the first case, swelling would induce internal tension that higher than any previous estimates found in the literature
would be distributed throughout the network. These two (Bettelheim and Wang, 1976; Lee et al., 1994a; Tokita
mechanisms are not mutually exclusive, so both mechan- et al., 1984; Zimmerman, 1980). Second, they provide
isms may contribute. If the collagen fibrils of the vitreous in useful target values for those striving to create synthetic
vivo are viewed as extended ropes, then upon removal from vitreous replacements (Chirila et al., 1998; Dalton et al.,
the eye the entropically favored reduction in fibril end-to- 1995; Soman and Banerjee, 2003). Third, the steady-state
end length could provide a thermodynamic driving force for network properties are quantitative and reproducible,
loss of hyaluronan-rich fluid. suitable for quantifying the effects of pharmacological
Both scenarios are similar and consistent with all of our vitrectomy agents and examining natural and pathologic
observations. In both cases, tension would be distributed vitreous liquefaction.
Fig. 8. Schematic depiction of the collagen fibrils (heavy lines) of the vitreous network under tension and after relaxation. (A) Native state of the vitreous
in the eye and (B) after relaxation by release of hyaluronan (thin coils) after removal from the eye.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
1846 C.S. Nickerson et al. / Journal of Biomechanics 41 (2008) 1840–1846