Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gender Equality in The Indian Workforce: A Legal Examination of Women's Rights Under Labor Laws
Gender Equality in The Indian Workforce: A Legal Examination of Women's Rights Under Labor Laws
1
Richard Mitchell, Petra Mahy & Peter G. Gahan, The Evolution of Labour Law in India: An Overview and
Commentary on Regulatory Objectives and Development, 1(02) (Jan. 2013),
https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2297160.
However, gender gaps persist in the workforce, with women often concentrated in low-
paying and informal employment, facing barriers to career advancement, equal pay, and
work-life balance. Deep-rooted cultural norms, patriarchal attitudes, and structural
inequalities continue to hinder women's full participation in the labor market, particularly
in rural and marginalized communities. 2
Efforts to promote women's economic empowerment and gender equality have been
undertaken by the government, civil society organizations, and the private sector.
Initiatives such as the Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao campaign, the National Rural Employment
Guarantee Act, and skill development programs aim to enhance women's access to
education, vocational training, and income-generating opportunities. 3
3
Sony Kulshrestha, Provisions Of Labour Law To Safeguard The Interest Of Female Workers To Ensure
Equality In India, (2019), available at: [URL of the document]; Author(s), "Title of the Article," Volume-8
Issue-2S4, International Journal of Recent Technology and Engineering (IJRTE) (July 2019).
4
Shraddha Chigater, Labour Law Reforms and Women's Work in India: Assessing the New Labour Codes
from a Gender Lens, Independent (Oct. 21, 2021).
In the decades following, India enacted several labor laws, including the Indian Factories
Act (1922), Indian Mines Act (1923), Indian Worksmen Compensation Act (1923), Indian
Trade Union Act (1926), and Trade Dispute Act (1929). These laws stemmed from
recommendations by the Royal Commission on Labour (Whitley Commission), established
in 1929 to address workplace issues. Aligned with ILO conventions, the Commission's
suggestions influenced subsequent Indian labor legislation. Pre-independence, the Interim
National Government devised a comprehensive labor program, later integrated into the
Indian Constitution's Directive Principles of State Policy. This laid the foundation for a
progressive post-colonial labor framework, underscoring India's commitment to social
justice and fair labor practices.
There's also Article 46, which tells the government to take extra care to help weaker
sections of society, including women, with education and jobs. To follow these rules,
various labor laws have special sections to safeguard the rights and well-being of women
working in places like factories, mines, and plantations.
Apart from what is written in the Constitution, different government groups like the
Committee on the Status of Women in India and the National Commission for Women
have made suggestions to improve the situation of women in India. These suggestions have
influenced the making or changing of labor laws to better protect women workers.
In India, there exists an array of laws safeguarding the rights of laborers, with some
legislation specifically targeting women's welfare and protection. Acts such as the Equal
Remuneration Act and the Maternity Benefit Act are explicitly tailored to address women's
rights in the workforce. Additionally, several other laws contain provisions specifically
addressing women's concerns. While not every law exclusively focuses on women's
welfare, a closer examination of major legislation unveils provisions intended to benefit
women workers. Through these legal frameworks, the Indian government aims to ensure
gender equality and safeguard the rights of women in the labor force.
5
Sunaina Kumar, The female workforce of India: Emerging trends and insights, March 7, 2024.
Recognizing women's unique needs, the Act mandates creche facilities in factories with
over thirty female employees, supporting working mothers in balancing job duties and
childcare.
Overall, the Act reflects India's commitment to prioritize women workers' welfare and
safety, promoting gender equality and workplace security in factories nationwide.
The Act empowers the central government to regulate women's employment in hazardous
mine classes, ensuring their safety. It also mandates separate facilities for women,
including toilets and washing areas, maintaining privacy and hygiene.
Similar to the Factories Act, both laws empower governments to set limits on the weight
women can handle at work. States can also restrict women's employment in operations
posing serious health risks, safeguarding female workers' well-being across various
industries.
Through amendments in 1973, 1975, 1989, and 1996, the Act has evolved to broaden its
provisions, reflecting ongoing efforts to better serve women's needs in the workforce. This
underscores its pivotal role in promoting gender equality and supporting working mothers.
The Act mandates the payment of gratuity at a rate equivalent to 15 days' wages for each
completed year of service, with a maximum cap set at Rs. 3,50,000. This provision ensures
that employees receive a measure of financial security and recognition for their dedicated
service to the organization.
Despite the abolition of the bonded labour system, instances of its persistence in certain
areas have been reported periodically. The Supreme Court has intervened in such cases,
suggesting the involvement of the National Human Rights Commission in overseeing the
implementation of laws concerning bonded labour.
vii. Building and Other Construction Workers (Regulation of Employment and Conditions
of Service) Act, 1996
The Building and Other Construction Workers (Regulation of Employment and Conditions
of Service) Act oversees the employment and working conditions of construction workers,
prioritizing safety, health, and welfare measures. It includes provisions for crèches and
medical benefits for women workers, reflecting its commitment to worker well-being.
These labor laws collectively aim to prevent discrimination and exploitation in the
workforce. Notable among them is the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923, providing
compensation for industrial accidents resulting in disability or death. The Payment of
Wages Act, 1936 ensures timely wage payment without unauthorized deductions. The
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 addresses conflicts, striving for peace and social justice. The
Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act, 1986 prohibits child employment in
hazardous occupations, regulating their working conditions.
In 1978, the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development established a working group
to address rural women's needs, aiming to enhance their economic status and encourage
women's organizations. Government schemes like DWCRA, NREP, and RLEGP focus on
creating jobs and supporting women's welfare, with provisions to boost their participation
in the workforce and improve their socio-economic status.
6
Sunaina Kumar & Ambar Kumar Ghosh, "Lessons from 30 years of women’s reservation in panchayats,"
Expert Speak Raisina Debates (Dec. 7, 2023).
Then, in 1999, the Second Commission on Labour was created. Their goal was to make
labor laws simpler and create a single law to protect workers in the unorganized sector.
They looked at how factories were growing, the effects of globalization, and reviewed
current laws. They also talked about improving conditions for women and stopping child
labor. They wanted to make sure that all workers, especially those in the unorganized
sector, were recognized and protected. They also emphasized the importance of social
security, helping workers develop new skills, and improving relations between workers
and their employers.
However, without concrete research evidence, these claims cannot be fully verified.
Studies conducted by organizations like the International Labour Organisation (ILO) and
the National Commission on Labour have refuted the notion that the implementation of
protective laws leads to lower participation levels or layoffs of women. For example, the
ban on night work is believed to affect only industries with multiple shifts, and restrictions
on hazardous work, such as lifting weights, are said to impact women's employment in
specific industries like jute to a limited extent.
Similarly, the argument that maternity benefits deter women's employment lacks strong
evidence. The expenditure on maternity benefits under the Maternity Benefits Act is
minimal, amounting to less than 1% of total expenditure. Other provisions like crèches and
sanitary facilities also incur negligible costs, which cannot explain the declining trend in
women's employment.
The Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1971, provides some protection to
workers, including women, but it has loopholes that unscrupulous employers exploit. For
instance, while the Act prohibits hiring contract labor for permanent work, employers often
fire workers who complain, replacing them with new hires when jobs become permanent.
This discourages workers from reporting violations.
Even in the organized sector, where laws like the Employees State Insurance Act,
Maternity Benefit Act, and Equal Remuneration Act exist, enforcement is lax. Wage
disparities persist, with women earning only 60% of male wages for similar work. Despite
government and NGO efforts to advocate for women's rights, there's often a lack of
coordination between them. Sometimes, women's programs are solely associated with
voluntary efforts, indicating a lack of government initiative. Alignment between the
government and voluntary sector is lacking, hindering progress in improving conditions
for women workers.
This exclusion from security provisions allows employers to exploit loopholes, often
employing contract workers without officially recognizing them. Some workers, like rag
pickers, lack specific laws safeguarding their wages and working conditions. The industrial
labor framework doesn't cover workers without a clear employer-employee relationship,
making it challenging for enforcement agencies to protect them.
Home-based workers face similar challenges, as their status and rights are unclear, leaving
them without employment terms, social security, or medical benefits. Domestic work under
this sector also lacks clear definitions, further complicating matters for these workers.
8. RECOMMENDATIONS
Any discussion about the economic contribution of women must consider the stage of
development of the society they live in and the cultural beliefs about women's roles in both
the family and community. The conversation around women's economic roles and the push
for equal rights and opportunities often revolves around a few key points.
Firstly, some argue that when women are economically dependent, it can lead to
exploitation and goes against principles of social justice and human rights.
Secondly, many believe that for a society to progress, everyone must have the chance to
participate fully, including women, who should have opportunities to realize their full
potential.
Lastly, as society changes, including shifts in demographics and social norms, it affects
women's lives as well. Considering these factors, there are various ways to work towards
improving the situation of women in the labor force.
8.1 Amendment in Legal Enactments
Making existing labor laws more relevant and protective for women's labor often involves
amending them to address specific needs. For instance, the Inter-state Migrant Workers
(Regulation of Employment and Conditions of Service) Act, 1979 could be updated to
ensure that contractors and migrant laborers are directly accountable to the principal
employer. This change would empower workers and third parties to file complaints more
easily.
Regarding the Maternity Benefit Act, recommendations from the Shramshakti Report of
1988 propose financing maternity benefits through industry-wide taxes, rather than solely
relying on individual employers. Expanding the coverage of the Maternity Benefit Act to
all industries and including agricultural laborers is suggested, alongside establishing a
Central Fund funded by employer contributions to ensure maternity relief. 7 Furthermore,
extending the scope of the Employees' State Insurance Scheme to all sectors is advised for
broader coverage of women workers.
In line with the National Policy for the Empowerment of Women (NPPW), rural
development programs should acknowledge seasonal migrant laborers as a special group,
with particular attention to women's access to productive resources like land and credit.
Establishing credit societies exclusively for women and providing institutional credit at
preferential rates for women in the informal sector are recommended. Additionally, efforts
should focus on implementing recommendations from various commissions and
committees to enhance workplace facilities such as, retiring rooms, canteens, and hostels,
catering to the specific needs of women.
7
Sony Kulshrestha, Provisions Of Labour Law To Safeguard The Interest Of Female Workers To Ensure
Equality In India, (2019), available at: [URL of the document]; Author(s), "Title of the Article," Volume-8
Issue-2S4, International Journal of Recent Technology and Engineering (IJRTE) (July 2019).
8.3 Strengthening Civil Society Organizations
Non-governmental Organizations (NGOs), Social Action Groups, and other Civil Society
Organizations (CSOs) have a crucial role in advancing labor welfare policies for women.
They can establish traditional and mobile crèches and schools for children of female
migrant workers, provide affordable yet high-quality tents for migrant workers, and
construct hostels to offer better living conditions. Additionally, they can operate mobile
canteens, organize health camps at work sites, and undertake awareness programs to
educate women about their legal rights and compensation regulations.
These organizations can also conduct literacy programs, publicize labor Acts, and
collaborate with the media, research institutions, and political parties to ensure the
enforcement of labor laws. Social Action Groups can highlight occupational hazards and
advocate for workplace safety measures. Their main aim should be to amplify the voices
of workers and address their concerns by engaging with government officials, bureaucrats,
politicians, and trade union leaders.
Public Interest Litigation (PIL) can be a powerful tool for addressing enforcement issues.
Through PIL, CSOs can advocate for women workers' rights and represent their interests
in legal proceedings.
9. CONCLUSION
In conclusion, the legislative efforts and institutional mechanisms aimed at regulating
employer-labor relations in India have undergone a significant transformation over the
years, reflecting the nation's commitment to ensuring fair labor practices and promoting
social justice. From the colonial era to the present day, India has witnessed the enactment
of various labor laws and the establishment of institutional frameworks to protect the rights
and welfare of workers, particularly women.
The journey began with laws primarily focused on preventing laborers from leaving their
jobs under British colonial rule. However, with the emergence of labor movements and
international influences like the establishment of the International Labour Organization
(ILO), there was a notable shift towards enhancing employment and working conditions,
marked by the enactment of several labor laws post-independence.
The Indian Constitution provides a robust framework for protecting women workers, with
specific provisions in the Directive Principles of State Policy and articles like 39, 42, and
46. Moreover, various labor laws tailored for women's welfare, including the Factories Act,
Mines Act, and Maternity Benefit Act, address specific concerns of women workers in
different industries. These laws encompass provisions for maternity benefits, creche
facilities, and equal remuneration for equal work, reflecting India's commitment to gender
equality in the workforce.
Despite these legislative strides, challenges persist. Discrimination against women labor,
lopsided enforcement of laws, lack of security for informal sector workers, and non-
conducive work environments remain prevalent issues. To address these challenges, the
paper proposes several recommendations.
Firstly, there is a need for amendments in existing legal enactments to address specific
needs of women workers. Recommendations include updating laws to ensure
accountability of contractors, expanding the scope of maternity benefits, and extending
social security schemes to all sectors. Additionally, provisions should be made to enhance
workplace safety and ensure a conducive work environment for women.
Secondly, efforts should focus on providing workplace and social security provisions for
women workers, especially in the informal sector. This includes implementing
recommendations from various commissions and committees to enhance workplace
facilities and extending social security schemes to cover all sectors.
In conclusion, while significant progress has been made in safeguarding the rights and
welfare of women workers in India, there is still much work to be done. By implementing
the proposed recommendations and fostering collaboration between stakeholders, India can
further enhance its labor framework and create a more inclusive and equitable workforce
for all.