الجريمة والفساد في المنظمات لماذا تحدث وما الذي يجب فعله بشأنها♦

..
J:!.J.11
cl w. ·J .)..) Li 9J •
u9J II i.! I a gj .lJll .lJ Ig .l! •
.H~ .J '::('J:!11.
ULnDinll ~ .lUnOllg do.f.P.-11
Lm.iL~ al2D '.'?.! Y"ill lag Uni l.lla.J
.J:IJ.:ii
d_w. ·cJ ~U9J
og.•u iJ I ogj .lJII .lJlg.lJ
.H~ .J 'J'}.!l:S
~_µ
':l\,i 1~9,11 Jiu u.a CJ.I all I~ .~
u_s_ar_,a.a_-_~
( ________4"""
__ __. _______)
•.A\ i ,"\ ,LWI D.Jbtll ..1f£..o ©
. ~ I ~Li:il ~.,JI ~ c.illll ~ ~~
. [ .JJ \.jJ.) '~.>=:'

~~ ljU :~\...Jo..al ~ JL.uuill_, 4J~I
~~~ ·[ .JJGJJ I L,.j~ ~ ~ ~.l....JI lAJ
A, in ,u=ol:.J..11 ,..Hfi ~~lS' ~0~JJ .lJIJ.l1
·~ n x \V ~~r'\r
'\'\ "\ · - \ i - no - r :l..il.4.lJ
w.JA~IJ ~~I -Y ~.;btll .l~I -\

D).lU ~ - ~~IJ ~l..Jo.al -r
'Y-fi ·'-:-l c~.)~ u1.;.o) .lJIJ.l1,0~ji. i
.01.,.WI ·[ (~.;Lla..o ulj.o) ~~lS'
Hr"\/ivn
H1"\/iVri :tl..1:?JI ~J
'\'\"\•-\i-Yro-r :·'' 4.l.J
Crime and Corruption
in Organizations
Why It Occurs and What To Do

About It
RONALD J. BURKE,
EDWARD C. TOMLINSON
and
CARYL. COOPER
© Ronald J. Burke, Edward C. Tomlinson and Cary L. Cooper 2011

A ............................................................................................................................. J~~L:,Wti
C\ ............................................................................................................................ JJl~L:, Wti
,. ........................................................................................................................................... ()~'
,, .......................................................................................................................................... wfi.) L!&a.l I
Y• ................................................................................................................................. wls~J_µ
yy .............................................................................................................................. ~.;.:..LI a.o~

Yo ............................................................................................................................... 2...o...L.4.4 :J.J~I ~~I
:ul4laltl '='9 .:.'""'4ltg '""4.J~I -JJ'il ~ I

YV ................................................................. Ronald J. Burke i.!J>.!:I ·[ ..uwJJ :.ll~l
C\, ................................................... ul.JUI '='9 .:.~t, '""4.J~I ~~t :~WI ~~I
:JU.t ~Jl - ~WI ~ I

C\, ................................................................. Ronald J. Burke i.!J>.!:I ·[ ..uWJJ :.ll~l
u~J,L.Jt, '.! 10.;...:Jt "'~4 J,4.alt uLU~ ~ ' - ~WI~'

:;, ..1..4::1.:.lS\'t
Thomas H. Stone -w_;....u ·'->" U"'Loji : .ll~l
I. M. Jawahar JlAIJ~ . r .i
,r, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jennifer L. Kisamore · J ~ .J ~ J
=~,11 ul!..,..., '='9 llilt-".:. - ~t,Jt ~ t
, to .................................... Edward C. Tomlinson w ~ j i ·U"' .l.JIJ.ll : .ll~l
L
, "\O ................................................... u ~ I ~ ~~t, ~~I 1.:-'~l :~WI ~J..:?JI
:~~I~~ ~.,JI li~l~\:i- ~UJI ~ I
Amy Guerber .>J...H?:- ~t : .ll~l

Aparna Rajagoplan u>l:,~~1.; w.;~l
, "\V .............................................................................................. Vikas Anand ..L,jljj '-'""~-'
,Av .......................................... u ~ I ~ J~~t, ~~, ~~ :~WI ~J..:?JI
: u ~ I ~ J~.W ~ I u~t:u, - V"~l.JI ~ '

Canan C. Albrecht,-. ,~.~t ·V" ul,jfi : .ll~l
Matthew L. Sanders j_;..L,jL.u • J ~LA
Daniel V. Holland ..L,j~JA .~ J;,b
, At\ .......................................................................................... Chad Albrecht ,-..~.~t .lLl.
J~~I ~IJ-4 ~ 1.:-'~~I '-"°!.,,cl ~~I o~~J - ~l.JI ~ I

:'-""Jl-'11 ~ ,j Qjt;;;u
Zehava Rosenblatt ~~jJ.J U1\.s.,_j : .ll~l

nv ................................. Orly Shapira-Lishchinsky Y:'' ,i.: ~,;.~,.:l l~Ll. ~_;l_,
rt, .................................................................................. ~IJ~l~~~l-~t,Jl~J..:?JI
:dj 4J~IS~t u~u...t,~ - ~w, ~ '

Alison L. Antes ~t .J u~i : .l1~1
nr ................................................................ Michael D. Mumford .l.J.J4A-"4 . .l ~LA
:4Jy~I ul.4.Jl.all ~L....i.9 :JUt, ~~~I - ~till ~ I

rv o .......................................................................... Joel Lexchin ~~ JJ...?. :.ll~l
,
'1'C\ V ................................ u\.o.laal ~ .ll.u..iltg 4.4.i~I vA ~ I :~12,..ll ~~I
,;-a...,w :J~~I u ~ ~ -ll.u..ill vA -WI 4=¥ - ~Lall ~ I

: ~ ~Wt, ulS~ ¥.)U..~I ~WJI
'1'C\C\ ......•.........•.•.•..•.•.......•....•................ Mark S. Schwartz JJJI~ ·u-u L!JJLA :.ll...u:.1
4.tb. :a..!j.UI ~IJ-4 J,J_,Jo ~ .ll.w.ill ~ l.9-4 - ~ ($-lWI ~ I

-~
·u .
Wesley Cragg ~1.;S' ~ . J • .ll...u:.1
Umafiokun Idemudia l:.).-'"4=~1 wfiJl.91..,_,_,
rn ..................................................................................... Bronwyn Best~ ~ljsJ..HJ
: ~ ~JS W-':!~1- ~ ~WI ~ I

roo ........................................................... L. S. (Al) Rosen wjJJ (Ji) ·u-u .J :.ll...u:.1
('
£. -( -( -< -< -< -< -< -< - - -
-( -< 0 -( -( -( • • > > -< -( {•
.F -< • -( I"' -( -C: < 0 0 -C: < ,J
t. ·i t· I>
;~ It
•Ci; E1
- ft~
s I 't, I> - I>
~ i:[C• ~
tX
·r '\.~
\-
J"[i, ~ f;""
1; ,£: fr: ,r t
t p-• .t'
~
,:: '&,
f.t.C irt irt '~·r. lE
[• '
~
C•
t
~- ~ ~-
~
~
t { ~! l.! f- I;; c..
'\. C• l,
~~ ~ 'f,
'
l 1. l: .~
l,'
~ ~ ·i D v i .t; - r.
t 't t,! ~ q~ .(t 'f ~ ,,.. i:~ r;s
~ - ~ c.. I> - -E
.r r e! &, li-
£' EI - 't~ iI ~: t!
l,
I:. •t' i ~t 'Lf ~ ~ ! [!
t ·\. ~ ft ~ 1
c.. r P-' E:
tr·
t' ~ .. ~~ '&· ~
[;1' fil l> [ fu f ~
t- t- f fi ~ - ~ ~ ~ r
,r~ f.,Cig
J 1 ~ ~ ~~
"° .
~i i;;- E . ~~ -~ F.
~ - Ci
~ E 'tf;_ {·e. r~r i·~
f rt
-(
-- -• >I t t t C. t t t t t t t t i
JlJt~u~Li
• •
\V• ................................................................... ~ J ~ J : ~ I ~L.u_, o-\ JJ~
\ C\ \ .......................................................................................................... J~~I tl_,:,i "\-\ JJ~
, a.. r ........................................................................................................... ~..1.11 ~wL::i 1-r J..,~
rtA ......................................... ~.)~~I~ ~)l;.~I ~l~I, o.:i«oi A-\ JJ~
rot ......................................................... J~I ~~ ~ ~~1~1 A-Y JJ~
rto.. ...................................... ~~1~1~1.,olJ.lllJ~~~ \\-\JJ~

~-,,.,;-._=.==:,.-:~·~.: .-,.-,:,,;p.:·..-,:·.-~·::·-:_::.·:·..=.==jf . . e;·:···,_..·,~·,:··>,==§~. ,,,·.·:~~::y~,-;=ry-.,,;·.·.=,,!l:--_.-,.o.::,!:'j~=:-S:_;(·=;:·\,;;.·(·.·;::z:J
,Ronald J. Broke~~ t ..Ull.JJ
.¥JJ.;fo. l.!l.;~ LA~ J~)U ~~ ~ ~ <::'"Q}o ii JI l.!l_,l.uJI ~ .;_;:,S~ ~ti.....u i

.Schulich School of Business, York University, Toronto, Canada I ~
~~U.o O• • 0-4~i~J 4to,, ~~~l.!l.;LluJ I.J.r'C-4~ ~J
~b?JI r.,_h.U ~J..AS:JI ~ I ~ i ~.:.UI ~ I ~J . ~ a 2 Qtc ~~~
~i .>J~ ~~ ~ ~ \.q$' ,Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences
~~IJ ~ I J ~ I ~WI a 2~~~1 t:Glo'-4:i.AI ~ • ~ ~ Y• 0---4
.isJ ,D)~?JIJ Dl,J.IJ ~\5_;-!JI ~ J ~ I L>luJIJ ~ I J ~~I~ ~L..willJ
~l.;Llu...u~IJ ~.;b?}I .>J~I ~1.J..>-4A ~ ~ ~~ ~ l.!l.iH ...uwJ.; .;_;:,SJ.JI l.!l_;\.~
. ~ I ~).,.ti D.;bl ~~ ~ ~ l.!il~J rWIJ ~\.;JI ~~I~~
,Cary L. Cooper...H.JS .J ~~
~ , . , ':YQ.!t:,. ;;ti ~I~~ Distinguished Professor~ JjjS~ ~ti....ui

.Lancaster University Management School~~~ LA~ D.;b?}I ~ ~
~ I ~ J ~IJ Di.;--llJ , ~ I J o ~ ~ ) y~, ••0--4~l ~j
.;~41.!l.;l-!u..J ~ JLJ..o t • • 0---4 ~ l ~ J (u- Q.!t:,. iiJIJ ~~I
- .,, -
~ ~ ~fi .;_;:,S...ul ~b.......u,~IJ •~A.,JIJ L)_j--1_µ.l:JIJ ~ _ , J I ~ ~ , ~
~ J British Academy of Management D.;b~ ~l.b~I ~~\5~1
3.......A...G.JI D~~ jLl ~J) Academy of Management D.;b?}I ~~\5t
4\.b~I L..J_,bl.>+4)'1 "-.+i.; Dj...J4,. r · · , ~ D~I rw:. .(,°'°'Ar~
(CEB) ...dWI rt-.uJ ~.;...1.:' The Most Excellent Order of the British Empire
~'-&-,'j l.!il~J List Queen's Birthday Honours~ I ~)4..o ~ .Pl.?. Wl:g ~
~"~~.:.Ul~~~l~w~~..,Jl~Wl~J . ~ l ~ I ~
JUI V"i.; w~ UK Government Office for Science r_jh.U D~I ~I~~
r
.isJ • 'r • • A- 'r • • v D~ J)l;. Mental Capital and Well Being L>luJIJ ~~I
-
~~_,11~~,~~.,J~t.;-p,Jlk~~'~r"· ·°'r~~~
~~.., National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence t.j..J-1...;-uJI ~I_,
.«~IJ ~~?JI ~ I ~_»t; J)l;. <JA ~ I ~~It:!"-"!" ,~·i>~ ~ ~
. . r~
a..u:.W>.'}11 ..
· '-'' ;;~I 45:WI ~.)LS'~~ ,.t:: .~t::...ul ~~~I ~....,
..~~~.)yw '--·
. UK's Academy of Social Sciences
aEdward C. Tomlinson ~.JJ ·4"' ~..Jlg~!
J~}U YJ-:1 ~ Mulwich Scholar ~_,J-"'° ~4_, ;;J.l?JI ~ l.!1.)~ ~~i

~ . Boler School of Business at John Caroll University JJ.JLS' 0.P.- d..a-4~
~~..,i d..a-4~ Fisher College of Business~~ 0---4 "'.J~...ul ~.J..l ~
al..l\+UI ~I a.!, 11/!.)-ll ~ I c:Glo~I ~ J ,Ohio State University d..:4~1
.,
~ u';)/~ ~ c.0~ u ~ .~I~~ ~~11.!J~I_, ~~I d.Alj..lJI_,
;;)..l?J~_,...ul~l_,AcademyofManagementReview;;.JIJ?/1~..llS'i~~
'2 a.!: b ;JI ~ I ~ ~ _ , International Journal of Conflict Management tlJ..lll
~ J Journal of Management ;;.Jl..l?JI ~ J Journal of Applied Psychology
~ ~ ~6.. ~ .JAJ .Journal of Management Education t.j.Jb?JI ~ I
.Journal of Trust Research ~I~~~ ~tu:9'}11 J-1~
aChad Albrecht .-'-"'t,~1 ~t..:,
w,k. c.G~fa_;.:i • Utah State University l:i~ 4:'}!_, 4.a.44,. ~ ~~ jl.:i--uj

~) ~t:; ~ l.!J.J~ ..i9_, .4:..>b! ~ ~J <JA ..lL.u.uitl_, y Q.!t:, iill J ~ '}II
J~~I u~)l;.i ~ ~~I ~~J 6-4 ..)~ ~~J J~'}!I o,e. ~
~IJllJ JnternalAuditing ~1...ul ~.J:JI_, Journal of Business Ethics
~ I ..l).,.ll ;;.JIJ?l ~_,...ul ~I_, Corporate Finance Review ulS'.;-s!Jl ~UI
..)~ l.!1.)~ ~ • International Journal of Human Resource Management
Cross Cultural Management An u~la:'JI ~ ;;.JIJ~ ~_,...ul ~ I ..>--J~ ~
J~~I ;;.JIJ1 ~ 6-4 "'.J~...ul ~.J..l w,k. ..)Ll, ~ ..i9_, .International Journal
a.:,_,.1-j,.>:-;t (Escuela Superior de Administraci6n y Direcci6n de Empresas)
.~~~
r.Yr'ri<a;l,•~ur-·.-.":.1'--~,,..-...~.. . , f h . . v - . . . " " a : - : - ' o > - ~ " ° N ' . b ' ~ ~ ._ ___,.-,.4.__:..•;~~,-.:1~~"'·.-.i:.u:.:..-.~e....,,s~Q.V-~>.%"<~/~".,;>bY~:'::~r
,, ~~ 4.ls!I ~ ':f~I LAJ c,~ faU : u ~ I ~ ~lwt.AlL9 4-w~I

aConan Albrecht,-, ,t,:!.,Hl1 ~U.,S
1 --~-
r~..H~J= • ~bu a.u--~<t'l)I
.... '»-""..
J~~, 'r~
· · b ~ ulA·'·t\
~ ~'r ... t:..~ • j~j
~J ~..JL.:.J.I a..Lw ~ u ~ b r..1..-a: ~ .Brigham Young University
~Lla:'ol ~l-..uJ ~ ~~ uis\5 ~ . u ~ I ~..HJ ab.: ,11_,JI u~~I
- -
..>:..iA ~ ~L-..u ~ .~WI a<: Ml~ ~~I u~~.lJ J~'l'I
Director of Programming . LlJj..J..Ji LLO~ ulA.,WI oJbl ~~ ~~I
for the Center for Management of Information for the University of
uLA.,WI L~..,J~'l'I ~~I~ u'l'la.A u.,....:,15~ ...L..l_, .Arizona
~ J ,Journal of Forensic Accounting ~~I ~WI~~
~~I ~l_p,JI ~l..,J u'l'~'l'I ~ J ,Journal of Accounting ~WI
Communications of ACM (The Association for Computing Machinery)
. oJb?}IJ ulA.,W.' ~ J Decision Support Systems ) ~ I ~.l ~ i ~ J
~.l\5~1 ~ I ~L-..uJ 0-4 .;--:i- i .l~ ~J Information and Management
.~1..,
•Vikas Anand ..uU1 "'1'~
Arizona State University~µ, L>Jj..J..Ji~4'-0-40IJ.¢.J.llo.l~~~

0.)4c=J.l i.i..L..4ll ~ ' 0-4 ~_,.J.JI J~~I J ~ ~ J~\', OJl.ll.;.:i rcc:"?"lAJ
~ (.)-A'_jJ..Jy~I o.l~ ~ JAJ .Indian Institute of Foreign Trade ~JWI
J~\'I_, .ll.uuiJI ~ I culA~l ~ -~~I ~~LA o.l~J ~...Li&JI
.lLl.....u~ J~~I u~JW a.I.~ u~jiJ u ~ I ~ a:s..,.._1.1 oJbl, u ~ I ~
u~~t ~ cll~t ,y:>J-.l:-J~ .i9_, .Outsourcing ~JG.. u ~ J~~I
~.l15l ~ l+i,.oJ ~,_, ~ ' ~l-..u_,JI 0-4 .l~ ~ a:s..,.._1.1 oJbl, J~~I
Y! q.:Jo iitl ~~I~~~ ~ J Academy of Management Review oJb?]I
~~I o.Jb?l' ~.li5l ~ J Research in Organizational Behavior
~ ,o-4:.l~' ~ J.isJ .d...n ~ J Academy of Management Executive
-
~,_, J\..bj ~ ~ .i9J ,a.:ce·i=:--JI o.l~ u\5~10-4 ~~ ~~ ~ l..>:..lA -
~_,.st 0-4 ~,?.i ~~l>'-""f'I ,b.:b?-.:JIJ ~~I u~~ ~ o.l..u11.I t91-"4 ~
-~iJ
,Alison Antes ~1 ~ i
a.Jl ••u.HJ ~~I r.,WI ~ ~ a . : Q.:t;., ;;JI ;;.l~I J~ ~ .u.l-A :,~i

~ '-r"'6J North Kentucky University <r5l:us- J ~ L....o~ ~'-'-?JI
l.oj,4~Jf L....o~ o.o Y! Q.!t;., iftlJ ~~I ~ I ~ ~ olJ.,....:0..ul o.l~
~~..H CJI~ (J-"-4> ;;~ ~ 0 ~ l ~w .iaJ . University of Oklahoma
olj.tll ~~i ~ J National Institutes of Health ~_,JI ~ I ...LAWI oA
.~)l;.~l CJ~jtllJ CJl.;ly°ill :,~I~,:., ,--t1J Office of Research Integrity
~..JJJ ~w..H ~ L-4J,4~Ji a.....o~ L:!Wl CJ~IJ..ul ~ t'° ~Jl.t:i l.f.LJ.JS'
l&,.o~l c.;r-J1 ~L.o1 .LA'-=!,JI •b .:~ ~ l:!Wl CJ~IJ..ul y)Lb ~ JA~
~l..l:t)'I J.,b,JIJ a.:Q.:t;.,;1t1 o.l~l 0~~ ~ I CJl.o~~I ~ ,J)l;.~4
.CJ~
,Bronwyn Best~ ~t.Jl.!H
juJjji L....o~ 0..0.) .:' 111'?°" LoJ ..._g~I ~.)A ~ V"_,.,..J_,J~ ~ a.......1.w:,6..
J~~I ;;Jb)' ~~~ oAJ~~l ;;Jbl~~LoJ University of Toronto
\ 8; • ss, ,:j.A Y-JJJ, York
University l.!JJ~ 4£.4~ School of Business Schulich
Heiwa Business International L-=1J.J.ll J~}U I ~ o ~ I ~~~I
oY-.J.A ~ ~ ·L-=1J.J.ll J~~I CJ~)l;.~J CJ~~l ~ oJb?/4 a «oi:d.lJ
Transparency International Canada I ~ "--:lJ.J.ll ¥ ~ I ~ ~.J.:.;;;
~~I ~j.1.1 c4 ~ '~..Jbll I~ J;9J . \ C\W f'~ ~~~ ~

~~I ;;J~l ~_,.c.J Asia Pacific Foundation "?.l4I ,b .:>l I JJ...L-J
~J.J.ll ;;J~IJ ~JL.;JI 0J~I o).)JJ Canadian Chamber of Commerce
;;~I CJ~ .iaJ .Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade
~ ~~ J\..bj c..-,k. ~)l;. ~I CJl_;ly°ill :,~I ~ .l~IJ ;;~.;JI .JJ.l ~ ,-. , 11.:!
.L..,WIJ J~~I CJ~l.Jd9 J;9
,Wesley Gragg~!.,S~
;;~ b~
~
.::.., :. ~
u,u::-1-""" - . ~, ~ ~ ~J
- .. .< .<.:. •
"?~ emeritus
· · ~L:u..,,i
juJJ~ York University l.!JJ~ d..A~ School of Business Schulich J~~I
.,,
~ ~ I .;-J~J ~~ rL:9J ~J..UIJ cl:!.JAll CJ~I ~ I ~ ~ .I~
corporate citizenship u\5~ ~_jl\ _;..9 ..1...l\..9 Jw:. ~1 u~)l;.t u~~JA
,a 2 ;;2_,t,;J1 J~~IJ ~>Ll-~\ ~,.., 4.i+ll u~)l;.t_, .l~IJ ;;~.;JI ~J
."-,Ju..JI
. ~~ uJJ
· 'l.411 ~~ ~~'xi
.. . J ~L.uJI .. .. ~ IJ ,u~~~I
.. J
u~)l;.l 6~~ ~..\..iS:JI ~ I u~~ i-H.\-4 JI~ _;~..ul l:]6.. ~
Canadian Business Ethics Research Network (CBERN) JI 11 c~I
~~?JI_,~, j "?- 'i\ r.,_w...JI o ~ l '-'" , =:= " L....A~t ~,..,
Q
0-4 y,,,. i .l...u:.J Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC)
.1~ ~ ~'Ll, 0-4 t9_;.ll..9 Jw:.~I u~~i o~l ~.lJ ~ ~~ LJ:C.>iJ.1
,Amy Guerber..>J~ ~i
·r r~ ~ o_;l.l?JI J ~ ~ 1Jl_;~.l ~lb ->--'.J-t?:- ~ i ~

'-""~\5_; l ~~ Sam M. Walton College of Business Jw:.)U 0.,:a1_,
::i~I O::J J.;1~1 ~ <.)1 ~~ ~ ~ -L:_Jb.. ~ •University of Arkansas
t~ J:;;11_, ;;~1 ~ ¥~~\ ul_;\~1 ::i~IJ ;;~\ ~~ ~1 ul_;\.~1
~~~ ~ l ~ ~ i J .lA~J~Ll..9..1>.~l~)l;.~l_;l~I
.a 2 11 2t;.,;;JI ul_;l.)---411 u~)l;.i ~ '-""Li.JI a..o~ t ~ I ~ <i"1' JAl~I ~
ul:!S'.,.t.......u ~ ~)L;..~I ~1_;.l?JI u~b a2l:a; ,1111 ~ 1 ~lA~I 0-=11 ,;,;;_,
.ul_;l...,_;.1\ ::i~I ul.,W.. 0-4 U)~J ulA.,W.1 ~ ~1
,Boland Daniel V ..u~~.t..iJ:!ll~
~fi,>JI b..9: ~~ Entrepreneurship 4:;~I o.l~I J~~ ..1.e.~ ::i~i

J)l;. ~IJ 4:;~I o.l~\ ul_;ljs ~lu.o ~ ~~t jSy:; . Utah State University
cu·~
t!. ~,1 cu 6u.JI o.lw· t\ ~
J :.) . :.r' . J-'-1'-'
1'=L.u . ~
:.· LJ-' ~ I.?""" ~
:.· ..ll~ .~~'xi
.. • a..J ,~ ... qJ
.. ~..,.........
o.l~\ 6 ~ ub~ ~ J Entrepreneurship, Theory, and Practice 4..s.u_;W\..9
1Jl_;~..u\ ~ J;ib ~ J Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research~...;~\
'-""y...;_,ns:.t11J Jw:. ~1 ;;.;bl ~LA o.l~J Indiana University w~~l ~4- 0-4
J.o...11 <.)14.4~\ ~ J • Brigham Young University ~J: r~->=' 4.£.44' 0---4
~ J J,J~IJ 4.........u.J..i.fl\5 ~ u'xL=:=,.o ~ ulJ-L--'-" ;;.J.£1 ~I.) Jo.c. ,~.l~~I
.. .. -
. a..o..1A&J.1 a2;;;JI ~~ ~ 4:;b! l)J.li
aUwafiaokun Idemudia ~~~~! &,jJSL:!l't~
~I~ Lancaster University~~~ ~4,. o--A "11~..ul ~ ~
~~~luL..ul.;..ulJ4J..ula .!4iiJIJ~~~~~~i.JAJ .;;~I
~~ African Studies Programme a .!;~~I ul-.ul.;..ul ~Ll..H ~ J
J ~ ~I ~w..H ~ <>"J-4 ~i .JAJ • I ~ .,.....:tiJ.;fo. York University cl.;~
~ ~ ca~i u ~ ..igJ .c.!l.;..9---:! ~~ Business and Society t ai~IJ
ulS'~ ~_,.JI .;J..ul ~ J Journal of Business Ethics J~~I uli9)l;..i
Resource Policy J.;l.,_..1.1 ul-.u~ ~ J Journal of Corporate Citizenship
~ I ~ J Journal oflnternational Development ~J..ul a .!4 IJI ~ J
. Conflict Security and Development tl_µll 0:4bJ
al. M. ,Jim» JawaharJ~~'-?-«tu.""» .,. .i
~~I LAJ,A%Ji L..A4,. 0--4 "11.,....:0..ul ;;J~ c.,---k ~6..

~ I ~llt.lJ ;;.;b~ b~i ~6.. ~ - J Oklahoma State University
4-JLA~I w 4•oii .Illinois State University ~~I 1.§~1 ~~
J:,~IJ a.!:' 111JI ~ I ul:S'..,L-,J ~IJllJ Lll...u.JIJ ~IJ~I ~ a .!~¥1
~~ wlAJ,:!,A Y~J .;J~ J:b ;;~4,. c,.:,k. ~ ~ -~J~':il d....A)l_µIIJ
J.;l.,.._..1.1 ;;1 1Jl a .!. 4=!" u--..o Dale Yoder and Herb Heneman Research Award
w~ ~ ...L....lJ .Human Resource Management Society for ~ I
~ ~ J Academy of Management Review ;;.;IJ~ ~JlS'~I L4d,I ~
~ . , . t i ~ ~ ~ J Journal of Applied Psychology'=' ;.!:bill ~ I
Journal of Labor Research JL....u.ll ~~ ~ J Personnel Psychology
a 4J;,iJIJ ~~I ;;.;b! ~ J Journal of Management ;;.;b)'I ~ J
. Human Relations ~~?JI ~ll)WI ~ J Group and Organization Management
~
-__ .:. ~,, _ ,,.. a..b.A 4..cJo.al
,- . 'J J .
a. . . d.,.o.>o.ll;; bl a..6:.A ~
'J •
... ,_ A -
..>-J..j->t-J
~
-
t -- •
~ ~ 0---:
4:JJ..ul ~ I ~ I ~..>-J~~c.!l.;L.!u-J ,Managerial Psychology 1.§Jb)'I
. Career Development International
,Jennifer L. Kisamore»-4~ . J ~
I.J.....J-1# y ~ cl.....£A4,. u--4 Dl.;.,....:0..ul ;;.l~ c.,---k.) .!Oi.!=:,, ,... \co>
~ I ~~~as'.;~ ;;~tu.ui L;Jb.. j4Li t..:rAJ University of South Florida
... .
-
~ ,:~.. ..... --~
~.....
..
~ -·-~~~
..........~ ..
\o lfj~ ~ ~ ' ? ~ I LA..9 ~..b,,j fall : ~ ~ I '?'9 .:al.wwiJ!g 41~1
.)I-'"° u,uJ-13 ~ University of Oklahoma in Tulsa ~.At lo_,A~Jt L.A~
Organizational Dynamics a.: 4.!t;, ;;ti u~~..ul ~w.J-H ~ I .)Jl..9.l.l DJ bl
~~J a.::' «ull ~ I u~~J d.lbl_,J.I ~ I l&Jlo~I u 4 ,;.,;; -~4
~~ ~ I J~~I u ~ .i9J .~.)\S'~I ~lj.lllJ~WI ~ a .!'!'~
Organizational Research Methods a.!4.!t;,;;JI ~~I ~Ll-4 ~ ~ u ~
J~)U 4J..ul ~IJ Journal of Business Ethics J~~I ul.jg)l;..i ~ J
~ ~ . International Journal of Selection and Assessment f .:.: oiJIJ
~l..>--J~4J..ul~l.r-J~~~~Wlu...-9.,JI~.; .:ai.:=!'
,Joel Lexchin ~~ JJ~
University of Toronto .¥JJJj°J 4.aA4,. L>-4 J~~I DJbl ~Lo~~

...I" 1· L ~ a...a..,~1 -
LA~ ()--l~J
· · · .::. • ti ~
- • :.'l'I J ~ c..,---J
1 - ,.. , \ WV ~
i.;J~ • -· • r
J:~ J-4-L: . University of Health Network 4..:--,. ,o JI ~ I L..A~
l.!lJ~ ~~ oJbtilJ a .: ,. ,o ti uG..u~I a .: I<:: h ~ l 4-]L>-
hb.c..ulJ School of Health Policy and Management at York University
Department of Family and Community ~1J illWI ~ ~ \S').~
J-J-Jl:uJl ~lA.o LG..U \).~Ui.A ~ .i9J . University of TorontO.¥JJJj°J 4.aA~
~WI ~ I ~ LG..UJ ~.)L:..:i'l'I ~~I L ~ ~till u~I L>-4 .)~J
~.,11 ~IJ..u1 ~_;JI L..1.>J l..l.lL_j~ Lfi>.J World Health Organization
~ l.!lJLl.J J..,~ '-4lt LS .Australian National Prescribing Service ~~~I
• II - - <- <-
~ "?.:.U1 ~ 1 u~µu~~-"'°~ ~ ~ 'l'lA.o \• LJ-4~1 ~u
0)lc. ?/IJ «4:J.)~1 ~ llil_,J.1 u1~1~1J «d..J_J.)}U tlfo 'l'I ul~tr., ~~J ,~1J...u1
~
. ~ u~,j,;> ~..)-'Ai ~1 ":J.)t11 ~

,Michael D.Mumford ~~.JA·~~LA
George Lynn Cross u,ujfi 0:3 [J~ o~4,. c.)c. ~W1J~16~1 ~b...c,l
6~1 fa.J-A Y-.J.A ~J University of Oklahoma Lo~)lS'Jl 4.l.44c-:, 6 ~
. a..a..o ~ 4 Center for Applied Social Research a.: o.:: b; JI ~ ~ 'l' 1
~ 1 ~ ~->-4~1 a.:, a ~1 a..JLoj ~ J.....oG. .)J.,._.i-A.)-A J~..W1J
~ ~Ji(, t , o ,r rW)U) Fellow of the American Psychological Association
Society of Industrial and Organizational Psychology '-::"YQ.!t;.. iill..9 ~l..u.o.l\ ~ I
~i ~ .ii..9 .American Psychological Society ~->-4~1 ~ \ ~ ~ J
0-J.J.r'l=A ~ ~J J)l;.. ~l..9 ;;..)~l..9 •b.! b~IJ tl.fo '11..9 ti ...l;')'I ~ yl..aA Y• • 0-4
~l ..)JJAAJAJ~.JJ\~ .TheLeadershipQuarterly;;..)~~\ ~\~
0.4~~~->-4i.;'1..9..)i,~ Yo oA~j ~t~~~~ -~ J ~4 --
~ I .aWl..9 National Science Foundation 4=,i.b.,JI r#l ~jAS' ~~
. Department of Defense t~.JJI ;;.;lj..9..9 National Institutes of Health 4=,i.b.,JI
~ls') 4-...AA~ J~)U 0_,-:Jl..9 ·r r~ ~~.,,.;~..)~lb

~ u---Q .;.,;, .Sam M. Walton School of Business, University of Arkansas
~ J .;;.;~IJ~~~4J\;;..)~l..9J~~l;;.;bl~lA;;..)~a.:Q.:l·itl
~J .J~'il ~~)L;..i..9 a.!4.!J;..iitl ~Wl..9 '=74.!t;,;;JI ..)~I ~ I ~lA~I
• ..)~ a.!4.!J;,iill ~WI ~~I ¥ 1 ~ c....9~1 ~ L:Jb. j.4-t3
aLawrence S. (AL) Rosen~ (Ji) ·4"" ~tl,J
~l.k.J...;-t,11 ~yfi 4.....AA4" ~ ~4'Jl o..)~l c.:,--k. ~

o.;bl.;.!i cu:::,-lA..9 .,1.;~.JJI ~ La.:,..'1 ~~University of British Columbia
, o,. o,. • r~ ~ ~ i •University of Washington ~l..9 "-'-44" 0A J ~ ~I
~..u as'...,.lu ~J Rosen & Associate Limited 0..)..9~1 cd\S'~..9 u.)JJ as'~
-t:-1,-t,
~~
I _.t,
1.>J~.J.J '"" ·-,--
~UA ~ .cf O I • cc Q
,, :.-1 r..l,g- ..l,g- j
~ ~"-'-"-LI.cl
'I
• ~~ C .U ~ IljAj
c1:::,,. It-
~fi..9..9 b~i..9 a.j,l.k.J~l ~.,Jfi ~ b I.LU~~ ~ ;;~\ ~~'1.,Jl..9 ,~ ~
,I.LU.JS' • , ~ L:,Wl a Q<~,a.ll ~ji<..o a;,_,:sls ~b~ r.iiJ l.!l.)J->~J ~_.;bj..9f..9
;;~I ~~'1.,14 ~ W I ~~I 0A ..).U. -
~ I ~ ujJJJ~.JJI ~
~ ~'1LUI ~~J ~I~ ..1:...u.Jl ~b ~ l.!l.;Lc:i,..9 ~i .ii..9 . l~..9 ~l..9
~~,J~'i,~~.;1~4~.jAJ .~1~,.)~,oA~..).U,
~U&.uf ..9i instructor ~JA ~ ~~ ~J ~ ...uAi ...li..9 .Canadian Business
"-'-44"..9 University of British Columbia ~l.k.J...;-t,11 ~.,Jfi "-'-44" ~ ~WI
University of Alberta U~i 4.....A.A4"..9 University of Washington ~ I J
- - - - ~ ~ - ~ ' l ; > ~ ' V * ( ' V . , C ; l l l ~ l l r i l l t ' C ...... :>rs ill.OJ•
W ~~ ~ ~ '?~t LAJ ~...L:,,,ij l~U :u~t '?'9 ~~~ 4.4..a~I

0A a:;)W ~ i.;' .~,i·ce" ~ ,cl.I~ ~1 ~~1
.York University ~J~ a.............4-_,
~ o~ Auditor's General of Canada I ~ ~41 ,11:dl ~~I ~.J.l.l
-
.LA~~
,Zehava Rosenblatt u~jJJ Ull.s:!j
~ UniversityofHaifa~b-""'hi ~~~~l~~_;...Ga~.!"~
. Center for School Evaluation and Administration U"".) I.J.l. I o.; I.llJ f .!.! ;; jS'.)A Y-...G
John M. Olin School ~ I J ~~ J~}U c:r:,J.,t ·r 0~ ~ ~ <.:.c...uJ.l .i9J
~~ ~~I a.....o~ ~ I ~ ~J of Business in Washington University
Ll~...)J . School of Education in the University of Illinois at Chicago
ti
~~~JA ~ I._# ~~J '=""Q.!t;.,iit\ ~.,L-Jl..9 ~ I .lJl_j,1.1 o.;b! ~ a,o,o~

~ ~ ~~...)J .y~~I ~l:!S'_,l-,J ~_,JI 0LA~I rl..u,jlJ ~Uo_,JI f.!Q ,oi<
~J ,Journal of Educational Administration a
.!Q.!l,itl oJl.l?/1 a l~..>--J~
.~I ~I ~WI (.)-'J.) I.J.l.L-~~
.... '..>-'-"&
· --~ ~ I& y L:.~ LJ6...
~
,Matthew L. Sanders.i)..u~ .J ~Lo
.;..w~ J.ll.;.,.._J..,...._< LL-44 0--4 Dl.)~..L...JI O . l ~ c.:,-L.c. ~ L , . .

J~~I ~ i~~ b~t ~6. ~_., University of Colorado at Boulder
. Utah State University ~µ1 ti~~~ Speech Communication ~l.b;JI
d....i.c:.~~I
.. . ~'IJ '-r" ~~I
o.ll.J· · .:.~ti ~LJo.i.tl ~
. ..r::-J .. I
. cu~~I ~
· · ....
~ . leadership communication ~.l~I JL.di~I_, social entrepreneurship
o.l~I (J-'JL.ul uh.Ul..9 a..&IJ-'ll.S' F-1 ~~~~WI ~_,JI~ ca~t fi'jj
~_,JI ~ ~LJo.i.tl t_.!b;,.,; l,&l~ 0A ~I J.>.b.11 ~ ~t JS'.>iJ ,d.kWI
.. - -
~ \+.,oJ~J business discourses J~ ~1 ~4Lb.;.. Jl.>:11 <.r"~~I ~ I .llJ.;J
-~~1 ~I.J.&i ~ ~ ~
,Mark S. SchwartzjJJI~ ·4"' l!l'.)Lo
0~t ~ J~ ~1., 0.,:,w,., ~LS"~I w~ ~~~ ~ ~~ ~b........u,f

.¥JJ.J~ I.!.!.;~~~ Atkinson's Administrative Studies ~b?JI ~Lu.lJ..ill
u!JJ1i, ~ 0A r , \\\ r~ Dl.;_,=6'...ul o.l~ ~JJ.;IJ1i, ~ . York University
~ ·--
~L:i.:a 4.1.as ~ ~.:Lll l.4_, 1!1~ ljU

-11'1'11\ . . ~ ... - - - ~ ,..
:ul.o.l:wl ~ ~L.w.ill ~ '-4J~I

yi; ~.~--=--- \A
~ York University ~.;~ L.aA~ Schulich School of Business J~)U
~\S'_;.1ill ~)\.;..~I ~l~I ~ I 4Jl.o~I ~ .J~~I ~~)l;..l wo·o~
J)l;..~l_,~lS'~I U..P""J J-*-31 i.S...u J~~I ~~)l;..i_, ~ ~ ' i i ~ J ~ J
J ~~,~~)l;..i~bi
- ~(' . ~~L,• _J-J.)
• ~..)A":: :. . )-~<'...ul
·- '_j-A-IJ ~ ~)\.;..~I .) ~ ' i iJ
L •. l_& •."::
~
Research Fellow for the Center for Business Ethics (Bentley College)
- - ~ ~ vu ..L....4ll ~
La:,.. t. ~('~It
- . J ~ ~' ~~)\..;..
- ":} ~ ('
vu ..L....4ll ~..)A . ~J
~
. Jerusalem Center for Business Ethics (Jerusalem College of Technology)
.J~~I ~~)l;..4 Ul..:al ~'i4c,11 ~ ~\S'~I <J-4 .l..U:. i.S...U I.;~~ .ieJ
,Orly Shapira-Lisshchinsky ~ '-" 1.! ,:t,;,:, ...J ~U, ~.J.91
c.:,~! .;L:, L.aA~ cl .!4.!\•ill ;;.;b)ll ~ ~ ~_)..D ~ ~

c1.!4.!t:,;;ll J)l;..~I c1 .!~"'"~' laJL.o~I ~ .J:pl..>--""h, Bar-Ilan University
~.)JJ ( ~ ' ~~ ~., y~1., ~ , ~ r~'il r~) y ~ ' i , ~l#.,i.-.,
~I~ ~'il.....4A ;;.;~I ~~t ··u.q ,;.,; .J.....lJ . ~ I 4i.ll.....aJ ;;\S'~ ~
~ J Educational Administration Quarterly c1 .!4.:!1.;11 ;;.;bµ c1 .!\.oall
~L....;s)l;..i ~ J Qualitative Health Research ~_,lll c1 .!.,. ,o11 ~~I
~ ~J .Sex Roles t~I )J.ll ~ J Journal of Business Ethics ~ I
.Creative Education Journal ~l..1-:1)11 ~I~ J.J~ ~ ~~t <>'°
L_;b)ll c1 .!4 ;;H "---:!:t.;J~I ~j.J.IJ .l'i..J--:!A! 4ij--j~ ~.;Jl ~jLl .J.....lJ
r" r · · ~ r"W European/Foundation for Management Development Emerald
~~)\..;.. ~I c.:,~ .J..:4.11 ol.;jiS'...ul ~ c.ill~J 4i.l~I ~~-ul~lJ ~ I ~
. ~ I i.S...U y~'il ~\.fo'~J cl.!q.!t:,;;JI
,Thomas H. Stone~.~ ""'Lo.,:i
<>'° ol.;~...ul ;;..)~ ~

~..J University of Minnesota l:iJ '11.!i.!4 c1..Lo4-
. University of State University ~ µ 1 Lo~~Ji a.....o~ 4i.;b~ btu..ui ~b
t i ~ c1..Lo4-J University of Iowa IY-T ct.-A4- ~ w-s_;..D ~ ~ ~ .ie_,
~Lo d4 ct.-A4-J York University ~.;Y- L.aA4-J University of Minnesota
a.c.~., 4i.l~IJ ~b~I ~.!.!;; ~ I 4Jl.o~I i:, .McMaster University
Q ,;.,;;
.ieJ .~J\S'~I ~l__µJI_, Ja~IJ c1.!:' ,u11 ~l#.,L-JIJ 4.lbl.,.t.lJ ~1.;l~I

~~ ~ ~ - ~ l e . l ' Y..~~~ ... ~w,,_.......
-.-.wca... ~ ..~
. -.. ~~QMIIA...~-~-··il -· • :oi~
\\ ~~~~~~ILoJ~~fall :u~l~~'-4l!J~~I
Journal of Applied Psychology'-:? ;;.!!b;JI ~ I ~ ~ ~ 4:l~i ~
o.)b~ ~..)lS'~I L.L:_d.lJ The Leadership Quarterly o..)~ ~ I L.L:_d.lJ
Business Ethics ~ I ~L;9)b.i ~ J Academy of Management Review
Canadian Journal of Administrative Studies ~b?ll ~L.ulJ.ill ~~I ~IJ
-
4:l..9...ul ~ I ~I~~ -lS'J~ I~~ -~~I o,,-o LA~J
i~Li~..,µ
~ 0:4WI YJla: LA .J.1.4 ~~I~ ~~4 LA ..l>- ~1 l5~1 <.,-4~1 f~
4'~
-\.! - - ..
c~ei4u.."'°!'Oj ~ ~ I L.4."'°coJI (>A t~.,.ll ~b~~ ~ ~f...L-.;t
i . S ~ ~ o.J-tfi~~IJa.!4.!t;.,;;~~ ..)~IJ ~~I . ..)l.,.t.l 0A ~~I
~.,.ti r~~l 0A ~->11 ~ J . ~ I J ~ I J .)~I ~ ~t:; ~I~ ~J rJWI
~ i , l.:U • ..)L-..ill..9 ~~I ~~I~ J..Li ~IJ~1 l5f l.!JUA ~ ~i ~l \.fl
- ~
.o)~I ~ ..)~IJ ~~I y~I I.J.A y ;;!.! uf
uJ •.,;.!L~_,:; ..).;IJ..)1~ ~~ ~ .~)\.Aj0A~j..J~lr..lli LS

lf,JL.:i ) ~ I u~ ~~I J..)~ '-'S' ~ ul_,JI ~ .J.1.4 Edward Tomlinson
I~ ,Cary Cooper ~fi t.§J:~ ~ ~ LAi .~I 0A ~,.!;.! •• .,;JI ~_,-4 ~
..)~IJ ~~ ~ u~ oJijA ~LA~l r..ll J.s~ ~J JAJ,, ;;.!., uJL.:i J..9l
.y~I I.J.A ~_,J ~ ~t:; ct.A~?i' c:,lS' ..ll..9 -~~ u~ ,,~\.;:JI ~ t.§.:UI LA..9
Jy,, t.§~I ~I~ ~~ti' < >~..9...ul y~I ~)\.Aj..J t.§~ r..lli LS
1
.)I~~ ~.R ~..) York University l.!JJJ: d..-..44" c.::.«A..ll ..ll..9 ·f4l' t~.,.ll I.J.A
- ~
.< -~- .~
i~ . L. ~
. I
. J ~ ..ill~~
. - ll.L.t.A - i~
- ':r.)---'JJ - . LS .~~1
. I.J.fl
·~..>-'-"i ..)'~~
as~ ~l.bJJ Jonathan Norman c:,LAJ~ c:,l:iw~ ~ltJl..9~1 r..lli J..>:P"f
~ i f&9 ..)~J ~ t 0 LJw.?. ~J..)i ...L....4l .Gower Publishing~ J ~
i~1J~J~~l~o->1ol.:t:..ll~~~,~b.lJ~~~,Ja.! ... .;;Jl~b~
• ..)~I ".J.fl
~J>:I • [ ...u WJJ

I~ ·~JJ-'3
Y•
s~...,i.l'tu~~
.~~\ .J-:C- y~I ':?t ~J...ul ybS14 .l~\ (i)
Y\
[.Z~-···,,~,'..:-·'',·,.:.•.. ••.(".·.,1:·.. :-., .. ,,-,.':=.•:,,~-... ,,·.;;JC"l-r:·.·.•
i~ _..,i..tt 4.4.WA
cUd ~ "?~I lAJ ~.J.>.j l~U :ul..Jo.UI ~ -l~IJ ~~I" yl:6' ~
ul..Jo.UI a__t.J-l J~ ~~I~ ~I u~~_jll 0,.4 -l~ w,k "'-fj~
0,.4
~bJ.IJ LWI o.Jb?JIJ a..u.~IJ '=?"24.!t:,;;tt ~ I ~J '=?"24.!t:,;;JI t~"il ~~
-l~IJ ~~I~~ ~ I u~~_jl.11.!.U:i 0-AJ . LA-*J J~~I o.JblJ
.JJ-lJ ~ I uW~ J.t.i:JIJ ~L;JIJ rWI ~lb.aJI u ~ ~ ls:iJ..!>- y~iJ
~~t
. -.:.L-:~ • .ll-i.a.JIJ ~--
~ ~'~l.Jl~~I
1
• - J~..,.... ·~~~I
·--~ 1~.&'lwt!!.)-'-"~
,A c.· - '
~j~~, u"i4'J.1 ~ .ll-i.a.JI .J~J ,vu.;1...LI.I ~ lS...U a.!4.!t:,;;Jt J>l.;.)U ~1
• cLi...o .J..:i.JI a.!:.§J a~: 11,6...l.lJ ~ I J
cGbbJi ~ I a_j~t~I-* rl~"il" ~1 .ll-i.a.JI t-*'4-4~

0,.4
~ uJ.»-iJ Ashforth U.)~t i.!.U~fi~ ~ (.,:rd.~I Ji vo;. .~,JI'.« ,(JI ~t
11
-
~lb.a.JI ~ -l~I c:,yilj..ll JJ~ ,'...4J~I I~ w_, .y~I <.>A JJ~I ~~I
- - - I
F Ji .igJ . LA-* UJ-l LWI u ~ I c..:rk ~)4.6,.:i ~ "iJ ~l,;JIJ rL.JI

.ll-i.a.JI o.JA~ ~1.JJ ~ I y~~I ..!>-l ~ F l c:,i Ronald Burke~~ ...uLlJ.)
rl.is ~1 ~~ lA ..l.lj:3 ~I 0-1:...u.JI ~~I 0-AJ .~..wt ul..Jo.UI ~ ~ ~ I J
ol:>JI ~Ji~ u~ ~I uL..a..t:,.al ~~I ~s·ooi.: "i ~~I ~~~I 0,.4 -l~
- .. - - ~
a bl C .,JIJ JUI w,A ..l.l_j.ll ~ ~ c:,..,:,w,., J>l.;.)U ~Ll.A u~~ "-4~ a 010!
o.JblJ J~ ~IJ ~1=.,JI ~~ ~ ~~ ~ °'i_}A 0-AJ ,illl~ ~J ~~ "ii a,j~IJ
.~bJ.IJ ~-llS'~IJ ~ I u"i4'J.IJ LWI ul..Jo.UI
u. i ~~ . l ~ I ~ ~ ,... ~la:i.ll j-:J:.bl ~~1

•
. ~ ,, ~
"l:JI ~:'..r:""
<,jA <.:r
"!. L-: ~
~ "-l.P.-Y ~)U.JI .)l~~I J)t;.I_, "J-l~ -°'iJl i""4:! ul..Jo.UI ~ . l ~ I ~ b -

u~.al,"!~,~"'·-·• t• • IU
~ d 44'4 ~: 111•• ••tt I • \.) t -
-l~.JU ~~4
?
I -. •••I
d t «ice cl .)J-l i.!.u.l ~ <.rt:
,It• ,t, -~ -
.,C.
0,.4 i»~ "i 1~~ ~ u~ ~ , ~ j ~ ~bl1 ~ ,a.!.'' 11111 U~.)w1

i""4:! <:?4.!t:,;;tt j~,
c:,i llA Ft.,.it 0-AJ .a.!4.!t:,;;tt ~~J 4.:A~' \..sJlbLj,j
• ~.J...a ~ J "~"?.>/ cl,~ d I ,:.;t ~ u~ ~>l,;. w,A 1...9~ ~ ' .l~I wl_J,J.._>+i (.)A
y.AllS' ~.) ~J.>:!:W ~~4 a.!:' 11,JI u~.,.LuJI J-l..J+i ~ I ~ ~ . , w,AJ
. ~ , -l_p,-JJi~t -l.?,-J.)~!J~JJ . ~,~r Ji..H..l.41.J "~>l.;.?JI" a...,...)~
u~~ u~ ~J.A ~ 1 4 : i ~ ~ -lj-4ll ~ u~ "~~"ii a,j_jl_jll" illl~ w,AJ
~.) ~i ~L....i.AJ ·".llZul ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ cGi Ji Jd L4A i_j--1-Ui (Y_?~I
.l~I ~ 0~ "~WI .JJ.l o.;lu.a.ul"J 0.,:,w14.416 .;l£>1J 4Jj..-uJ.4 i...SI~~,
. ~ I .~
__g u--r-' .. ~ ciIJJ ",,,
'--'I ~ ...... ~
-a-;- · ··-~" 1
· c..)AJ....,.......... A··L ~.J.A
'"(to' • -
caLilb
". .< -~'L J -~ ~IJ L4J.
~..r' •
~ti c....a..Jts::i
:.;-:w - 1-Jl:6:JI
. · <.!:.J\:tll ~-;~
(,)A
-'I ~· .J-A-1----'-"
- I ,~.JS'
~~ - ~I u· i
·'--· J\..u:,.. '1 u.,.-,
(.:r'
· · !t:q
.Y" ~
:. ~ J\..u:,..
. u ~ I .~ -
' 1 t d...u.L.,JI
..)'U -·
ul~:.tJI ~
'-
da.!i,oi~J~IJtl~IJ..s_)o~~~0yWluJ~.J~I~
ul.J-l~l w-4J • .ll_~~IJ u ~ I ~ J~I Ji u ~ I ~ r~ J~I d_ji c.:,--k.
0~1,/:1~1,.•: 'ri ")} ~~~0~~jg0Jlb.:,..,ll ~ ~<?' ~~,
~lJ~I ~ u.:W..i ~ 0 ~ <?' ~ I 0i J i ~ i...Sl.ai ul~ ~ i Ji
w~WLlJl~li...S~J.ul~l<JA~~~J~ I ~ l-4A~iw~i,112
1-Jl:6:JI·
• (,)A
<.!:.J\:tll~-;-t\
'..r:""' .)
Llii,cl..4,J-~t\
:.;-:w J .lL-will c.:r.-
.<-:.t~\"d..LAI
.r . - ~ ~1~1"
~ -.
- ti
o.;~4 I ~ . l ~ 0J~ Ji ~l..~1 u~~ 0~.>: ~.J..JI <JA I~ 0i ~1

<)A~~I ~~j ~j 't .:?:collyb~I J:,~l~?JI u ~ I y~io--4
~ ~ <?11 J.ol~l 0-4 .l.U. ~ ~~I ~ I I.JA ~ ~ .~..GllJ ~ I
~ i J ~~ ~ I .;~")JIJ o.l~l .;J.l ~J u ~ I ~ J~")JI <JA ~I
.~.;L.::JI u4~1J a.k.Lill ~b.t.lJ jA...11 ut_;g~i J ~ ~ ~ I J ~_.;...Gll
~ . ~.l~I d.J:.~ .l~J '=7"4=.lts'~I . l ~ I ~ F~ t:ib..ll ~~, ~i

~ I Ll~
- ~I ~. u~~ WI J i I'"(t-1 AA~,J uwWL
-· . ~>l=JI
. ~.lts'~I
- - uLil\..;J.I
'=7"4=.lts'~I .ll.will ~.lJ: . ~ I uLu..;WIJ ~~I c4 J.o~IJ u~l.;JJI :,.!.;;;!
~ .l~")JI M Ls~ ~G... ,ul •cai7"..llJ .ll~~4~1 J.=d:i ~ J ~tr, c..:,-..ll
~ . ~ uLu.l.;.lJ i!:.J~ ~ ~WI uLu.~I ~.JJ ~ I J ~ I ul.;l_..)-4ll
~ J .ul caJ;,i~J ~ I J 4lll .l.;l_,11 ~.J-tfi .;.a ~l ~.lts'~I . l ~ I LPJ:
- - c.- -
~ r~ <?11 u~.;WI <JA b.u. t:tl.>11 ~~I JJL.u ,~.l~I ~~ . l ~ ~

af;lk 'il-'"'°l .;..Li ~.li 4w 0 ~ jL;:J.IJ ~\.Z.j~I ~ I \+i..caJ ~.l~I uts'~
~ t~JJIJ ~ I ~ I u~.l~4 ~)b.U ~ J yl:6:.l ~~IJ uts'~I <.).c.
uts'~ 4J:; ~. ~l oi ,114 r_~.H):. ~.l~ ~~IJ ~.l~I uts'~ u ~
1.
u,J.._P., .) Llil ~IJ . a.u.b.JI
-• A~~
''"(to' •
•
iY. ..1Aill.l ulS:.-")J ,r:~'.r· ti ~~ 4.J~ .l~I
' a.:,..b.ll I.)-'
uts'~ <.).c. ~l:s_.,JI u~I ~.>-°3 ~I u~~I 0i ~1 Joel Lexchin ~~
af;lbJI r_4)14 a,j.;\..a..o r_4.;~I '1li:i aca.!" ~...w ~ ~~J ,~.ll.; ~ ~.l~I ~
• ~lk~ ~ I ~l~I ~~Id~~~ <?I
,,.·->~· s:.:: ..'.":"~ , .., ' ·;:;-.::·:.~.,:.;~~·,,:=:.:·p:::''<.J :.:;:,:· .··.,:.::~:;::"·::y.5:-::=1· :· .:;:::· .:;->:-.;§:';·:;-:~>?f..·.'.'."·. :· : ·:".'.~ -;::;·::.-:.:_~:=:~, ·-~~~~::."·~~=.=.: ,,·.:::.-=;~~-=-~<·: :-.~\,:.:.'?:~Y::: ~ .. :,:~:."<~~~;·:-..;:.=~:~::.":":;·,:~::\<':;.::,:.=.'.-:~=:;:-::·:',';::°;"-::"i-·\'; .,
~~, oA ..L>JI a.!a§ ~ ~~, y~I oA c.>"-4\.;JI ~~, - ..

~ , 1.)-:?-IJ
..L>JI ~ ,Mark Schwartz jJJI~ ~JLA ofi~ U l.dJ . a ~ I ~ .)~IJ -
~~ a:;~ J)l;. w---.o a ~ I ~ ¥)l;. ~I~J ~~WI~ ab ,~,;~1 o-4
'-8JL.u).4AJ '-8:i~J ~ , a l - , ~ [ ~ a.!"'.!~.) a;s)l;.t ~ .l.R-J ~ ~.)
a.14A Ll)l;.~I
- o.lWo4ll
- ,.... : .< .":tl.J.~~-)l;.)U ~ . ) ~ w
.)J.) <.:r-~J-""' ~
~Ll.&jl, ~ . ·ti
... ~ - ~
. ~ I ~ 0~..1.1.IJ oJb?/1 ~ ~ ~ ~ i'11 ~L.u.;JI ~
, I..LiS' ~ J ~'}II a~.!: J ~bJ--'-" oJ~ y~I oA c.>"-4\.;J I ~~ I f-"'""J ~

~J~'}!I ~0t Rosen 0.JJ.J FJl ~ .4:,lUI JIJJ~I a'}!~~ ~L;.
o-4i ~~ ~J ,a.lwJ.I 4:,lUI _J,J_.;l.4Lll t ~ C. '! 111! . ) ~ ~ ~ ~ IJ.jS'
~)UI ~ ~ i oA ,o.).J.L&A y~~ J~~I J~ ~ ~UI o.:-J~
~~, r~l 0i ~~, i.S.>: .4:,lUI JIJJ)LJ ~ J r ~ -l.R-J r.J....&.J ~~WI
~ljg ~~ rll o-4 0i c.;rl! I ~ ~UI ~_,.i.i.11 yb..wol oA 0:,1~1 a,.1.ot ~
~IJ-4 ~~~a~~ a4~1 ~IJ-4J ~UI t.>4'ilJ ~6J.I
~ '}!_µ ~~ r~ ~ ~~WI ~~I U.~ c.;rl! i.S-li w ~UI ~l~I
~ I ~~I ~ I 01 ~ .~l..ulJ ~~I ~b..o old.J-4 oA ~~ ~l.;J.I
~IJ-4 ~ ~~I ~Jk...ul ~.) ~~I oA ~ 1)~ r' \W rk. a.)~j
4:,lUI ~1~10~ ~ 4:,llA alA_,h.A ~ ~..>J_.;~ ,-,,~; ,~,I ~.JJI a4~1
~ ~~I ~~WI r~I ~ ~ .d.AWI a'}!JIJ:JI al~ a~~ ~ I
~bJI ~ I J ~ll.;JI a~~~ oA 0t ~ al~ '}!_,.JIJ ~~I~ YJ~
a4~1 ~1..,-o o-4 ~~I~~ 4:,lUI JIJJ)U ~'}II ~~I a~~
~ I.JJ .~6J.I a~~~~~ a~l o,j,A c.;rll 1Jj4,. ~.JJI ~L.,JI
.~~I a~~I ~ a4~1 ~IJ-4 oA ~~.) ~ ~'}!_µ ~ 0i
r~ 0f ~~I -lJ: ,a.! '".!~.;JI y~I ak.~_,J.~_,J.I u=o.;-aJI 1,j,A ~~ ~J
;;'.) b'}!I. __g ~~: 1t U1 cG~~ ,.... •~ • .":<'...ill 1.-:. ~ti .< :._,,
" ':?'""" 'j"-'J - c;--- ~ ~ .)~ UJJ-':"'6 ~
~ I ~l._>ll ~ o~I ~.)~ ~ d.AWI oJb?JI ~ ~IJ a.c.4bll d.AWI

. y ~ ~ I [l_~'ilJ
~l..ll_,.JI 4.UI~ . .)
.A' tr\ c.;r1.,~1 i.S.l4 rr ~l.bll
J.J"!t~t
C')uL4t.; t..tt ~ ~~~ ~~t
Ronald J. Burke .!J~ ·[ .ltll4" a~,~i
~ .lLuui.ll..9 ~~I ~l:u..9 y4,.-,l ~ ~..l4.4 ~J ~1 ~ I I.J.A ~~

• .ll...c..u..a.JI 0-4 ~ .,4W ~~l..9 ~Wo.lll..9 .ll~~I ~ ~ LA c::l~IJ ~~I
~ ~ ~ ~ ~11.J.A ~ ~ I ~l.a.l.l..9 ~b-\b ,oil ~ I .l~ ~
.~ <:i'11 J ~ I
r'~~ll» d..ll.:t .lLuui.11 (Ashforth et al. 2007, 671) 0J»-IJ ~.J~T ~~
.cc~~l ..9i y •o~I •. c cc,<JI ~ j 0,A '4ibl eccl Jf (.)'°-.:.. ,~,JI a,jlS:J. t ~ I ~
t ~ I ~ ~_,l..uJIJ '~.Jb?JI J~~I ,~lS'~I ~w~ ~~ .ll...c..u..a.JI ~
~..»-t a.fi.Ai ~ ~ LiS' .(Zahra, Priem, and Rasheed, 2005) ~L4t;,;Q.)J
,~~ t ~ I ~~.:..,;.,;JI ,~LA..,.W.I ~~ ~ ~~ ;;~t:ul '(.)"'~~lS'
~ .ll~~I J ~ J '~.J ~LA ~J.>JJ>i ,.l~I ~ J ~ ~J~.;JI ~.l
,~-.1 aS'~ u
c.J-""'
:. · ~14>-I
. ~- . ~ '.iJ . a..JLA
:'-?"'tbJI "='""""~ - U...1 · - t.'-4_o L.il.
_IJ.>J.J..>-J~ ~ti J i JUI
- 'J-""'
0~ ;;--1:~ .J~I ~Jlc..l ,y-"""WI ~ll.J ~~ al~I aS'~I ,Intel Corp.
r'~,0-4~~~~~,.)~J...ul~>l:,~.lJ0-J_,,;..~1~~w1~-.1:~
Jjjl aS'->1u ud.l .i!J • (Diaz, 2009) ~..»-i ~lS'->1u ~ 0-4 ~ I y-"""WI ~ll.J
. 4.JJi ~ LA~ .J~~I ~Jlc..l ~ ~JAt.J~J.l0-*4,, to LA.;l..l4.4 ~I~
~<\s;«uI4 ;;~ li>L:i ~.JW ~ j .i!J J~l 0-41.A• ~ aS'~l.;b.: «cri
.(Associated Press, 2009a) ~..»-i ~~~~..,~.»-~I ~lS'~4J
~lS'~J ~ 0Ll.J-'"4 ~ ~ aS'~ ~1.., ,~T Jli4 ~ J

~ ~JAi .J~J.l 0~ V· • ~...,_:ot ~.l ~ JPMorgan Chase & Co.
~i 0-4 LJ::4~ 6:,J..9~ ~ll~\r ~~ll~ ~4A ~.i! l+>L:i LA~ ~Jlc..l
,0~~1 ~i~~ylY' LiS'J . ~ I ~ I ab\ , ,0-4~~~l~j_,.;JI
.(Gordon, 2009) ~:'.)fi.ri f1J ~w~ ~L:i aS'~I ~ f1
~~I ~~.ll;JI 0-4~ ~JA\rl ~J,All ~ J ,r• •'\ r W ~ . l ~ ~ J

~ ~)ill J~ ~4 ~ US and Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
YV
I. -~--·Ll..sl.a
U':'"'""' -
:. • • ;;La..uJ.I -LJ6. a-J..UI • '~~, aS' :. . -~ . ~ , ~L.uL t\
~.>-'-"-'-'-" j:!J j - ~ :.r-. ~~~ - '.u-
J,J_,.b ~ ~..; Q~; , rel I ~ ~ ~ ~ J • New Century Financial Corp
.(US Securities and Exchange Commission, 2009) ~UI ~~J~ ~~,
. price-fixing Ji.•.,)il «··:.:~; ~ JLu~4 l:l~1 ~ d_jjfa\ ~ J4S° ~I ii>P-t

d_jJ.>Sll ~ o--4 ~~J aL- ~ ~ J...U.O rr · · \ ru:.~,~~ ~
~<J 6; ;.,JI~ LAJ-A--'-" ~ cartel- I.SJ~,~
- l.A I ~ W:?.:ul ~~~I
w~ 'r ~..;-u ~ .i!J 1.Y"'\ ~1 ~ ~
~---:.
&A ..t..,JI «.·: ·::: ~~1 ;;~ ~ J
.(BBC News, 2009a) ~~I ~Lal
·~~!g~~t~cS~l.4
Global Economic Crime Survey ~WI ~.l~~, ~~I~ ~J
Price waterhouse Cooopers ~ § '->"JLIJ:iJJ (.)-"--:1.,H aS'~ ~ ~t9 ~.:UI
J~\'I uo:.«o;....J ~J-'-"» &A~ ~.l~~I ~l~I o--41.A'r ul f' r • • \ rw:.
~~ ~J ,~I~,< J;4 4 al..,......,, ~ I J ~ Ji ,«asset misappropriation
~t ~lS'J . ~ I ~81 LJ:!.:UI ~L..-l!I &A 1.V1J J~.;JI &A 1.o'"\ ~~)~ ~j
Q .~.
. ..:.a~~)'IJ ~ I ulJ.ll ~ u:.~ ~t9JJ-,ll

Association Certified Fraud Examiners LJ:!..14W.I J~ ~I ~ l s ~ ub ~ ~
J~I 0 o.l~ ~UA ul um J~)U W;?.J.4lall ~ ,:.,;,;t I &A 1.oo, t ul (r • • \)
1.t\,, ~i ..\SJ -~UI .)~~I ~ r• •\ ~1 r• •A <.JAO~' J)l;.. ulS'~I
u~ 1.AA &A~~ .o.l~l ..ill:i ~1.)J '.'! 111< 4UI Jo~I ~ ~)U4 ~
~lS'~ ' ~-"4 J~IJ '->")t;.I .ll.) ..1.41 ·r r ·, • ru:. J)l;.. ~ ~-""" J ~ ~1
~ ~J'-4 - c4 (Ryan, 2009) LJ:!l_;.J ~lAA 0J -~.l~~I J~~I J)L;. -I ~
~.,.ti ..:.at9..,.......,, o.l\i) ~1 ~ J~t ~ a.J~ ~1 J~i Martin Kenney
;;~I J)L;. ~ JS' ~_;-ol .)~J.l u~ ~1 ~ <'>white collar theft 0::!-4µ1
.r r
r .. \ <.;)1 r .. , oA
Sales and Marketing Management Magazine ~~IJ J.,~I ;;Jbl ~ ~ ~J
~i '-4< ,~I ..:.aUlS:..o ~ w-"!~ ~J.J.A.A u~ ~~I 1.S.>---:.J.A <.)A 1.t \ ~~I
- - -
1.'r· ~iJ ,~~~IJ~ b.J&-JW-"4~~~1 c.r-J.J.A.A I~~~ t.rt
..:.a'-4..wl Ji ~~I ~1~ ~t <.JA u~~ y1b 0 u ~ ~~ ~..u u~
. (Bucaro, 2006)
YA
&:t\.ola.a I ~ ~l.WMil~ 4.w~I
E%¥iff9¥@#£by·A§&,·k¥W&4%¥'1~2§%~¥§V&-¥f%£8¥?,%£&~··$'L·tv&-1¥§@·¥t-6,.&v~-§f#¥%§¥-¥~@i'),{·;,~iJACdr.z~jtf'·ft;+.¥;t~1aw@~:lM£%,.~w%%!~1
~ -~~~l~c.!l~l..,0~UU'-41l=.J.lc.!l~l~~0i~~~
- -
LI.J.A ~ .J.aj~~~I ~· ~LoaL.tl ~ -~
· ·-Wual····tla..u
_,,__.. ~ ·w1 ~· ~l.oal.
_,,__.... t1 -·
~J o~Ull a..ill=.J.I ~l:_o_,L.uJI ~ c.!lliAJ • .)~I ~~~~~~I~
lfj~ ~_,..J ~ ci'11J ~_,.I.I ~ll~ o.)~4J • 5c.o o~..,JlS' ..b.lJ 0T ~ ~~i
rl~>Ll ~1-'""" ~.,.ti~~ ~I~~~ 4! r~I ~ ~~'}/I»
~ a.bl c.!lliA 0 1 ~ (Greenberg, 1995, p.154) «c:,...-i_,;.)U ~ Ji '-i.)J-411
~l.,HS~ ~ .~6JI "E.)~'}11.J~'}ll J ~ ~l~l 0--4 t-'"'111.J.A o.)Li,
~J+4 .J-AJSergey Aleynikov ~.AAJl if':"J-:-U' ~ ~ J ~ rY·' • rte.~
.JJA.J ~~~'}II~ Goldman Sachs~'--, 0 LA.JJ.?. ~~ 1.S.J.l '-:-'---'-"6.
~ .J.J.aj ci'11J ~WI ~b.l->'11 ~I~ ~~I ~~~4 ~L.;JI y~WI
LJt J~I ~IJ: .J-AJ .(Bray and Bunge, 2010) ~~I llfl ~I.J'}!J.JJI ~~
wfiJLJl~L& .i..otc.(JJ~Ja «114~.J.J.aj~l~~~o~~
. a l ~ ~ ~ ~~\S' ~.)LA ~ I ~~~IJ ~ I ~~I
LlJ.=!:=ill ~...>A\JI ~_,JI L.-.c.jll ~.l.JJl ,~~ ~1 d.....S~}
0 ~ ~Li.iulJ ~~I al.J-"" LJt (Y • • C\) US National Retail Foundation
~.J'}/J.)0~,, V ~~l t4.! LAJ,AJ 'r"· rlc.1.·, • A ~ ~ .ll.)~~I
•A
~".-~ti · ··
~ oJ.>,.:it:.A ~
· \..i.iu'}l c..r--
t("tl r-:-- I,\.& . rle.
---ti:c-:
..1A.J LAlc. · .. t~-: ~ti j:,~I
. ~~ j-J
aJ< Ml o.J.A. 0~ ~~I .J~ t4) ~)Ci~~~ '.J'}/J.) 0~ r\, o rY• •A rte.
~ .;s-t J ~'}/IJ al.;,-JI ~ 0_,.ilo.,.t.l ~ ~ .J;9 '-i~ <J-4 i~~ ps-i u.."'=: col
l&J ~ ~I ~~I o-41.Y'1 ~ a,j.)'-4.,o 1.tr a: ..,;JI~~ ~~1 Ji ~LjJI
, <,~
-
IJ,AllJi~ll~~~~1~~0_,.ilo.,.t.l~t ~ - ~ , . , ~
~ ~
.gift cards l:l~I ~LI~~ ~UI ~ ~~ IJAll ~ ~~I ~~I

Father Tim Jones J.--,j.?. ~ y~I _j-,-AJ ~~->:' u,AlS' ~ i ~Li..o J ~ ~ J
l.!l.JJ: ~ Hilda I ~ ~ ~ I J St. Lawrence ~.J_,J ~~I '-'; •".! ;< ~ b
- ,, -
0~~ LA~ ~b,:,,..ll J;9 &4 '}/~ \S'~ ~ ~~, al.)-'-" 0~ ~Uo A~~
-
~~I o.J.A. ~_,..:; ci'11 o~I ~~I <J-4 '}!} j ~ '}I I.J..i.J -~4 ~ J ~
~1~.J.aj ~J .(Aitchison, 2009) w.i>--="'i ~4..> '&lo~ ~le. .JLL......i..ui J ~ <J-4
~ '"fta.::I
-
~I t• ·•1 1 ~-':.....,Lj
~
ti J~'
~,1 al·~...J - JU' a.,a~
1
~
···'I ~l<:tll
- u· i ~ · " a ~~
-· I~JA
-
a.!ccsli.J J<~ .)~IJ 4.4J~ls .(ACFE, 2008) .J'}!J.) 0.,A, C\C\t .J-A ~->-4~1
-~~,~
J.i:11 J,wMJI
t};;~ L..i:u~I
l...r ..
J~\.J
...
I.:. ..ul a..u
l.!U~~ u-- -~ . [ ~~.~
~ u. b~I
.. .
~ IJ-"
UI "-1.A.J
• ..
~ ~, ILl .l.!U~ c....a~ b ~ ~t ~~Lo~ j>.l <)A ~..u LA JS'
.. .~l~Al_.,S-1 <)A cl:!,k u~ Lo Js:-:1 ~l.b.1.1 ~

~J .. u~ ~jjl ~~.ll.i..JIJ J.ll~I
~
~~I LJA 1., '\ .;L:ui Y• • '\ r~ J.,...Hl ~ ~ ~.r!"i ~J.iS:JI ~ ._»-i ~ I
F Lo~ y ~ ~ :Jlj....u ~ ~4-1 ~ ()~~ ~~ J4-..,JI LJA 1.Y'\J
.;1~?}1 [~~~~LA~ J~b,) l.!U~J ~~ c....a~ b ~ ~i ~~ ~ o_jf
~-'44 ~i ,..,_;..i Jl:l.A ~J .(~\si:~i 0 i t~bi ,ui ~ ..>-'"°~ ~UJb, Ji ~~I
l.!L..J-:P .l.;w..H New York City Police Commissioner c.!l.;~~ ~..lA ak>-2,
<)A~I ~ J ~ ~..>A u\5 LA~~~, ~I~ y~ cG~ Bernard Kerik
~jjl J~~I ..1:,..l l.!L...># 0 \5 ~ ·r r ··tr~ Homeland Security Chief ~.,JI
~w~~ Loy~.;l.:1~i~~<JA~~.l6J1~,..1:,..ipi~ , ~
Yo·••• ~ d.!j.lA ~..>=J W~J J>..ul ~~ [~~ ~ y.All ~J ~l.r!"
-
~ o-k 41~ o-k \.a:il-. ~IJ ~I
..
<)A aJ~ Ji ~1~ .;~J.l
.. ~\5~11.S..1:,..!
,,
.(Bone, 2010) ~ ~,_,.;..u, &J~ cl:!,k ~ c....al.b.1.1 ~~ ~J -r~ t ~
y)lb UIJ:!~ <i'1'J The Insider J~L..ajl ,f~ ~ \si ,<c ~ I o.J.A
o.J.A~l~t,.:,.o~~~~~ -~4-~J~~lo.;bl~~w~4-
t~-"40lS' -iiJ .11~1 r~"~'~ k~-"4 r·, ·Jr··°' Ji;. a 0,!.,.~1
L:!J6. ~ ~~IJ ,John Rigas U"'~...> 0.?. ~ r • • C\ .>:'~t ~ ~~I ~ I
~~ I.At .Adelphia ~.bi ~_,...!W ,.s~l ..>:!..ul l.!U:, ~ c:,lS' ,.s~IJ ~I~
~~ ~ ~ ~ J ~(~~I~ ~t )w:. c:,l.:illl ol..u; WJ) U"'~...>
r'~'
0~..ul ,.:,.o .;"iJ~ 0.-,A, r, r ~Li>lJ as-~1 Jl-"41 ,.:,.o .;"iJ~ 0~ , • •
0~ nJ~~y&L.o~~.;"iJ~0~ ,r
U"'~->J,Ajt .J..a.J .c:,..,~I~
Loi .Jj.i.1.4 ~ I ~I~ ~WI ~t ,.:,.o .;~~I Uh.i.A ~1~ .;"iJ~
JJ.l.o~l ~~, ¥.;~ljaj~l,.:,.o.;"iJ~, ••• ,- iqcoi9,.Sj>~l~Lla.tll
c:,~~~«~r~» lAi .~_,...!Wl~l.;~0-4 \V ~l~J~.;~_,;i~~I
~ ~"i ~ I J>.~lJ ~I ~.:UI Sir Allen Stanford ~.;~lz..........., ~i ~ I
~ ~ ~ u ~ r ~ » l A l .4.4,J...?." n ~~~Jl-"4~1~Jt1~1
~JL.., ~ ~_,...!W J:,L..JI i.S-,.!.;;;JI J:!..UI Richard Scrushy ~~ ~JL:&a:i.,->
.~WI J~"il ~ ~6. c:,~I HealthS-outh Corporation
l.!U~J '~...>At~~;;~YJ~ l..o~I alJ-'-" ~~~ ,Y• •Ar~~

c.:.i:iJLl:i .Miller-McCune.com (Beale, 2009) u~ Lo .;,4A ~~ ~ .lJJ U lliJ
•~ ,.,.. J ~l,..11 al~ J a..u
-~L:;.tl -·~ WI~· ~ti · 1.!U~.~
'j""-' U::'
~ a..o~I ,~1.-,.t1
U"' ,.,..
,.. .
i4 qt; c..tt ~t~ ~~t t.Ja;.c.a,
~1 J;;;2 LA:;.)~ 4lil ~1..b-1..,JI .)yi.110---4 L~ i~ .)~10t ~..,.11 ~
~wi .)..b,. ~ .(Zyglidopoulos and Fleming, 2008, 2009) (j-J...?-i <J.?..>~
4J: ~)lli. al.;-,~~ (r · · o) Joshi ~.?.J Ashforth t.JJ~iJ Anand
~ i ~ u~ ~.LJI ~_,JI~ ,rs ·u,;;~-:;~1 ~u~J-1~ A>-9~1 ~1
~ al..,_,~I o:U ~ .:;~I ~l:P_,L.«, 0,A ~ t?I ~.:.\.HJ r..1lll y : . ~ 0,A
lijl_,.1.IJ , ~ I .)_?.J J\S:jU , ~ 4 ~I~ ~I r~J '~Jj.....uJ.4 ~I~ ~I ~ J
t.J)\:iu.?~ W' .a4~1~.)a:tjlJAJ ,~l alhl....u,~1 s:.~IJ ,~~~I
.. .)~I al:P.,k,,, ~
[J--CJI_., s:-1~~1 ~J .. as°J~ .)l~~I ,, .)~ ~)lli. a ~
as°J~ ~..i:; c.,:JI :;~WI JAl~I 0,A ~ ufa,-4.JI .)..b-, l~l .~_,JI J_,.bJIJ
.. '
J.)~I ~.J.llJ ,~~~I s:.l.b.iJIJ ,~~I ~j~ :~J .)L..will aL:P_,k, ~ .)yi.11
. r .
. ~ I a.at! l ~ I ~t1 ~~1 ~~~I a~.~.;;ll-'<.r·~1 ~bJI . · LA
. . U::t
~_,L.,Jl 0i Ariely ~..JU Ayal J:iJ Gino ~.;-&loi YJ~l 0,-4 at , ,I, ·~J
ab 11:ll ~~I~~~ Jgi ~..>~ ~ A>-9~1 i.S..L! ~)l;.~I ~
r~-'="""~c.r--
'\ ...<-~ ~tl~~~I
.. . .>:!= WI ~
'""o.)~LLl
• .,...., ~~
~ l.a..A~l·-tl ..
. ~ I c.!l1:i j ~ ~J 0-t?-:ll ¥ 1 ~
~ . . , J I ~ ~ ~ ~ .o..b-_jl Bernard Kerilc ~ .)JWJ.:' ~~ f1

.J~~I ~ ct:iS'JLt!J. ~l..o 4li1=, DiPascali Frank ~lS' '-'""~.)~I~~""= i.S.:UI
.. .. ,, .r
JI.J..&.Ol w.J.4.a:J y_,....,bJI ~ .. ~ ·o«o:ul.l ~~j 0,-4 ~~ 1->=""j.o ~ I ~ J W'
,,
• '! --=-~",
~ ~ ·· ~w, · ··· !I!. ~ ~i
(,)A s:.~t~~JA .. ..b,.-~ W" .:;~J.>A
· a..JLA
.. J-1..J La:i
r"· · O . . . ~ ~ ~ ~i ~~J ~~J Madoff ~J.)LA~~ ~JU:..)~J w-
.J~~4 ~ ~ t?l 0-J~I JIJAt 0,A J~J.) 0~ '0...A :;.)L.:...ul J:?.,l 0,-4
~ .~.JS' o..b-_,1 ~~ f1 Sir Allen Stanford .)J~l:l-.c, ~i ~ 0 i W'
:;.)_.,..bJ.I ~UI .)J~l:l-.c, ~~ ~UI .>:..Lt.I James Davis ~ b ~4,- ...,.._li
,.;__µJ:t ,bb:v ~ .)J~u_.. cu~Lua.l. ~l..o 4lil:, Stanford Financial Group Co
.. .. ~
&,,~.J.A a:i)W ~ I ~ J ~ • (Daker, 2009) (T)Ponzi scheme ~..>-41:JI

a.JUI
.. alA..G,JI ,=--
- .t:... :-:t I~ :1r: · ·'."-:e..~ I .):..l.41l'.J d 1..)---'-"
-·j ~ :. ':""" · · i ~.J..a.4.u
. -~ (>J...r"" .... ..
ct.J~ 0:.)i ~.LJI Antigua's Financial Services Regulatory Commission
.a\ o.:o:,uJI ~~1 ~~ .)J~u_.. 0,-4 i.SJLliJ ~
fu?ii~;=='.tffi?iJ@iWd#iit#i¥l#2&?%•1 '~ITNM%W«J,?.@00£iB0£h1-.r?'.n ·Ud~s@%Ryifh&iffi&(1@·,1r@·4&$w0@@eM1A6%&J@&i@§·!¥¥IB·~;w»r·filiWtiW+i&kJJWMfffi·(@@i41@Ad
1 1
~ ~ ~,_., J~I ~ wfi'Ji .lJIJ.ll ~.ll ~

«.·: ·11! Edward Okun
oA ~~ t_., 4=!Ab oA JS' ~J-Abll d bb;.., ~ q$'JLl. ..a_., rk. m ~ 4 ~
I ~ LA~ ~~J •Wachovia Corp ~fil..9 as~_., ~L..JI ~~'-411 4i cc·«1,o
.1031 Tax Group LLC (Larson, 2009) wfi'Jl as~ l:1~
~ ' ~~JJ w~..1.1., ~~ LA~ ~'-* _.,t ~ wt ~>1' oA .l~,

w~..1.1., JA~ wt .;,#l ~J~ ~>1' oAJ .cC,_,lA~ ~ ~)L;..~I .J-t):. c.!J~I
~'~~.is d.!A~ r~ wt wfi'J-1: LA~ ~)L;..~1 ~ c.!l.,L.:JI ~~J..llJ
. (Gino, Moore, and Bazerman 2008a, 2008b)
wLAJjl;,J ~ (j--A JS' ~ J L..J~~, YJ~I (j--A a, 111J.11 ~ J

k_,L.u_;,#l ~J~ .ll->-9~1 ~ wi ~>1,1 oA w~ (Gino and Bazerm~, 2009)
o~ ~.ll:j oA ~t [J~ ~)L;.. ~I~ q$'_,L.u ..u~ LA~ LA~ ~)L;.. t .J-t):.
.<cslippery slope effect» [J~I ~JI.J.:,iw~I ~bl4 ~ LA .JAJ ,.>:!# ~ J
s~WtJ~~t
'r' r · · '\ rk. >-'~t ~ ~ .JUL;,~ J ~ ~, u~6. ~ t wi ~1.,11 oA
insider trading uLA.,WI '-:-'-1..;---:i ~~~;;?.bl.I~ w~..J-4~1 w~I ~J
~ -
..u .a.JUI
-
-1 ~I - . J\ ·~ 1 -WI ~
"'Jj "'-'"'"" I..:'" ~
_..... ~.q ()A
· a:......-J i.k--~'I - .l~• ~ I
..,......... ~
w~~ ~J4=!CA ~ j A .JAJ Raj Rajaratnam rlnlJ~b [IJ ~ I ~~J.A ..b,.i
J~t .i!..9 • ~..>Ai ~~t ~ t ..b,.iJ ~~I ~.l~ .J--:!..1.AJ Galleon Group
'->..b,.1~~,~~,~w~?Jlo.A;;~_.,;;~~~~1~1~0.ll:J~I
J~J.l<J~ ro ":-IJ~ LA~,~~~~, ~~J.Awi w~lfi~ .i!..9 .ulS'~I
~.l~ ..b,.~ ~~~I, o.!i«oilJ ~JAo.Au~ji~ ~~J~~I ~_,Jo~
~J .(Associated Press, 2009b) '->~t ulS'~~~WI ~lboAJi.k~I
~~J.A~wlS' ~<J.J~ ~1 ~_.,~~, .llJS~' .l~ .llJaJ§,t='L...ut
..,li .i!..9 •Wall Street (Reuters, 2009a) ~UI JbJ~I JJ-'-" ~ wJ;L&AJ w.}Ab
~ .<Jj:l~ ~~ uLA~ d.._u~ ~l.A c(,~ Anil McKinsey ~j.i#LA J;,l
.(Glovin, 2010) rlnlJ~IJ ~ o.l~I ~ l~IJJ w~l.A ~L:a w.J»-i ..,li
Baht ul;, w~ \ t • LJ-"~I ~ ~J I...LiS' <)--A 4P-,__>3 ~ as.J-AA ~ J
c.!l~4 ~~ ~l_j.;JI .;1 .~.;,114 .J-AJ Rakesh Saxena ~ l - ~1..,J ':?4l:i
4:lUI LAJ\11 ~ "J~I ~ i ~LllJ Bangkok Bank Commerce ~J~I
4:1~1 ~J>S ~ ~,.,11 ~ ct.J ~ J ,c.!.Uj ~1 as~1 ·r' \\v rLc. ~~'
~<?Jlas'~l~lw,~loA~4l:i~4w~' ,"\0-:1 1 siq.!'J..l.....4i
. (Bangkok Post, 2010)
JSJ-A c.:..,j~ 4:llA akL.uJ as'~ ~J .Optionable Inc J-':'w~i as'~ lAt
- ~ ' oA ~..>Ai J':lJJ w~ Aor-:' o.Rb.ll w~ r"'· ·\ rW 4:1u1 a,..!,oaJI
.,
J~."4 I.A~~ ~L-""11~.,110-4 ~':l ~.ia as-~, wi ~J ..L....GJ
~I.J:iJ ~4JJ)-~ ~~J '-4.1..J~ ~J ,-, iq ,;,; ~ l:!l.a Bank of Montreal
J~."4 w,J-'4A JLi.u.w.l ~ LiS' .o.R\11 ~,J4--J ~b~ ~ I ~ 4 ~lA.,.;.J
~IJ':lJ..ul ~~J ~Llls:Aj ~~_,..:;s- ~ ,o;. ,~.It ~..>Ai J':ljJ w~ Yr ~..u
.~':l~J r~J ~ ~ udJ <?-'' J-'='w~t as-~
,BAE Systems Plc t_Ll..ulJ 0-4\'IJ ~ I ~ ) U ~~I as'~I lAi
~..>Ai J':lJJ w~ to· ~ J ~ ~,J ~ 'LJ::!:'JJ\11 t_Ll..ul ~J..&.w~i ~J
~ ~~ w~ ~jlS Jl.,s~ ~':lJ?/1 ~~ lAJIJll ~ ~...>AlJ ~lb...H ~µ
.(Reuters, 2010a) lSy,,-t JJJ
~~lBankofAmerica ~...>Af w,J-'4A~jirl'·' • rW~l~~~J
~bJ~IJ4:lUIJIJJ)Uo~I ~1:!':l_,JI a~.!,,.~~...>AiJ':lJJw~ ,o• lAJl..l4A
~ "~~ w~ ~lA~ ~ i w,~I w~ ~.,:,ts lS~J c.!.U~ ~ us SEC
~JA\11 a...oµ1 &,A4LA JJl."4~ 4.J~j;iMerrillLynch~ J.HA as'~
~ American Banker ~JA\PI ~~I~ ~J~I ~ .(Reuters, 2010b)
c.!.Uj ~ wlS .iaJ «Banker of the Year rWI ~J-'4A» ~..,.lJ Ken Lewis u----s~
·u".!';,:>JI ~1 ~L,.JI 4-'4'-" J;i ~..>At w,~ ~.J.!an i "'.!~J ecs.,JI
- ~ ~ 4:lUI ~LA..1,:1,JI t_Lk:a~~~I 0-J->:!.J.ll aeq ,11~.J-Li ~
rW ~J~ ~ .(<ab~~~» ~..u l>=.:.UI ~~I~ ~UA ~J
~ ~ ~~ JJJ ~~ ..b-f _,.,,.J ,McGee Hugh t.r-"."4-*"' ~ r r · · \
~L.;J, ~, a___,J..1.4 ~~t ~ ~1 a.JL-.uJ ,rts) ~w oA wfi-4 ~J-A ~
LiS" j~\11 w\P ~,ju .Lw,J.JJ.1 ~ 0-J.F--T ~_jAJ ~_,.JJ.1 ..b-i ~ 4Jl.b..a
- -
.(Quinn, 2009) <c~)G..i w~J» ~i ~ ~~I ~1 JLlit J~
~ ~..\+.I ~JL;. u 4 ~ ~ ~1.JAi w~ <J:.:UI U"°~~I ~'l'i ,.!J\lA
L~
. ~ . - L".L ~ ~IL·<
'+' . - =.>-4
~ti ..J.a.j - ~
,_,__..., J -
~, "l..ilJ . t.:. ..ul a..u
~ . 'T U-"'"
. . .l
-~ ~
~JL;. ~J~ ~ JIJ--A~I ~Li.;.!«.·: «er! j>-.l .lJy.5 J'l'J.l w~ '• • YJ~ LA
~1 15..,_;. l JJ.lJ 1.)-1-"-J-"""' ~ Jo~ I u.l i ..l..4l •15..,_;.~I ~l:tl I u Ib b ;.11 ~ J
~ i ..l!J ·U"°~~I ~Ji~~ ul..A~ ;;~I ul:'l'_,ll JJ..Lll ".j,A ...u_jjJ
Ji ul..,_;...l.A <.>A ~..u LA~,:, .:.,<Jr"·'. rk.. ~ ~ ..b.lJ rk.. ~ ~'l'JA
.Llb ul..A 1 .-:1 ~,,....._,
- . '+' ~.JA
~ ' ~ ' ~ I ~ o-4-4 ~~ V ••• YJl....c: LA r..L..4i °' ~ 'r" .. r~

~~I J..._;....ul a.J~J ~ ~~ J'l'J.l w~, , '"\'"\ ' sici.!e ul~..l.A ~L;.;.bi
- ,,
u 4 ~ <.>A ~..u LAJ u!..,_;....u.1 ~ ~# c:,..,...).)+4 Canada Revenue Agency
~ I ~.)-U&J-.,.uJI ~~I c4 ~~I ~l~I ~.JA ~w ~ ..ill~J ~JL;.
.ll_~~I rJ:JI ·~JL;. u 4 ~ ~ ;;~I ~~I ul..,_;...l.A ~~ USB Bank
cl:l ~1.J-4 <JJ.l JI.JA~I ".j,A ~ Wl~I ~l~IJ ~l~I ~~ ~lilll 1.j,A ~
JAW' ~l~I <)A y...>+"JI ~ LJb w:ulje IJ.iS' 15..u ~J: 'l' .15..,_;.i uL;i~
~.JAw~ul~k...ll i.!ll.i.Ac:,i W-(Wednesday-Night.come,2009) 15..,_;.l JJ.lJ6.
IJ~L.u .i! ~J.iS' a.kl-J ~ j A ~ i ~J RBC Dominion ~ I IJ.iS' ~~
<"">. Liechtenstein (McArthur, 2009) 0:' .~, ii=-=-=1 ~ ~IJP ~L;.;.1 ~ ~~I
i ~ ~ ,-. , ce _,J l4lµa ,~t, i,;A-..,.i$i 4:!JL~:r~~t ~_JJ.al't CcllS t~!

U"°~t ~J~ SEC ubJ-*3IJ 4UI JIJJ~I ~ ~JrY· ·\ r~ ~
J'l'J.l w~ r·~ i:.~>Ll ~JAI:tll ,b.!b.;..::JJ «Ponzi ~.>J~» ~ ~~J
~ . ~la:i.JI d......!.J ~ fA 0:.:UI ~ I J~ <)Ai:,.,_; ci~i «cell JI.JAt <)A ~J-Ai
~ ~~la:i.JI ~~) c4 J~~I J ~ I J ~.)LlA t=! ~ .li_~~I ~'?= c~,i ~
~ J : ~ ~J .(Stempel, 2009) «1.' • • » ~11.W "J~ ~~ ...d~ fA~J
~~ ~JJJ:l ~..l.A c:,lS:......u, ..1.>-i JAJ Wezhen Tang J:,l.:i LJ:A~IJ ~.ll rr · · °' rk..
ul:'l'_,.II ~ 4.1 ~ J ~ .«Chinese Warren Buffet» «y i.!·oll ~ 4 WJJJ»
~ ulJ'l'J..Lll ~ ) L o ~ ~ US SEC ubJ-*31J 4UI JIJJ}U ; ; ~ I
4UI JIJJ~I ~ <Gfi~ U La!J Ponzi Scheme <<~.J--Abll ~.>J~ ,bb;. ci» ;;JJ---&.O
,, -
, ~ I ".j,A ~ ~ ~ l t.;AJ ,Ontario Securities Commission ~-Jt.:,J~
-
--
J.i..;,,b ~ ~ ~~ i ( 1., ) "JI-J.4A -~J ~JA-L:J 1ct b b;.,, ~ i:,.,_; <I~; , ci.U r.i! ..l..4l Cl
IC'~ ,01'~----.. .,.....~--~.i;.rn-~-;.:;~---.::.:...-~-~-: r . . 1 . . ~ " f t . < F ~ ~ - ~ -

Lfj~ Lla.9 ~ 'i.'.1ll '-4J i!l""->J faU : u ~ I ~ J~~ Lw~I rt
u~I ~ l~!J 44.J_r?JI
t··-:-::~-·· -·1~-:-:,··/·-:1··-:~~ .. -,.·,·.• r.··.·.-.:.,•.·:.-•:·.······,.-.:7"~~~:~~~~~~t:7;~·""::~~T,:~~~~~;;m::~~~z:::z:~'.-7.:.:-. '-'"·.:'-E:!:J
0-1~' J.,..;,k ~ JIJAi tl..1:l a.b.ul~ ~J ~~I J.J-'-" ~ a.!4.!0> ul.;~I

c.;rll J~_,.JI J..i.-!J . (Schecter, 2009) ~>4bll ~ I l.l.A) ~ ~ ~.:UI .l~I
Tang ~\.:i ..)~ 4JJ..uJ.4 ~l_~I uJ.l u~.;-*11J 4UI Jl.;J~I ~ ~., ~ J ~
J I·- - - · • i l."4;; ~ ; ; .~.:.t ·- - ·-'It..) i c:La.k .• ;.. .1 I~
U.J lA~ .aJLlS' ~1...~1.c . J ~ ~ '..r--~ ~J - ~ J 1.7"'1
.(Pazzano, 2010) ; ; ~ .JJ~l.:uJ4 4UI Jl.;J~I ~ ~ ~
,
s6'.l' ~ 'J 1.4~ ~~ ~ ~ ..\l_g
u .;~~ ;;..1.uu~..) 15..u 4,L.u )lkA Geraint Anderson W.J-'-".;...G i c,.jl~ ~
4-:1\:6' ~ _fij .0.J.LJ ~J.A l.AJ-4.A ~~I JJl..i:J as-~ ~J Dresdner Kleinwort
lA ~ t ut r r · · A r~ ~ ~.:UIJ Cityboy: Beer and Loathing in the Square
~ ,,
u~.;...wt ulS' ..L9J .,1WkA 4.l ~ 'i r~» ~ o.;~ J-A ' " ~ "j)\A.)J J-A 4.lll
.a.!;.!J~t'I u ~ I <J.A ~'i~I u~ ~ ~J-4 ~ ~ ~ _ , J I c.!.lJj ~
s9r~~t~~t
1...9~1 ~ ~IJAi IJ..w ~.:UI ~~~I J ~ 'ii ~~ <J.A 1..S'i~I u~ c.!lUA
0-A 1..S'i~I u~ ~~ ~ ·~J-AbJI ~.>J~ «bb:i:..4 ~ ~ J i J~'il u ~
~J~lu~~ LsJU:,L!..j,-,;q,o;u~~ l~~.:UI ~~~I ~~I
.ll~~I ~ 'ijA ul ~ I <J.AJ .ulb~I c..ill:i ~ lfi.;~ f1 ~i ~..,JI~ u.;~I
~ ;;~ u4~ uJ~ ~ w
~_,JI~ o.;l,..UI u ~ I ~ ~.J ~
u.;~I <i'1' ;;~I u ~ j l l ~JA .J:?:.! , , ~ .;;...\:~ ~U;J ~ J ~ I
'.~
~J · - ;;~
...<ti u~=t\ .:t.:..
'.r ~~ ~
a:, l.o..A u&-~tl. -~ · .<j uL. ~ Jlu:..
- .,.... ~~ -
'ii ~
. • •
~I~ c.!.LJjJ - Arthur Anderson 0.J-'-".;...Gi .P.;i aS'~J Enron 0-.,.;,1 aS'.;--c!u
~U;J ~ ~4JI .ll~~I ~ ~ . .)~4 J:iJi al~ ~..u ui ~ ~1
o.;l,..UI ~l.uJI ~lS'~ Jy,- ~.,:JI u4,11, ~ t.G_,.J~ ~ I~~ ui 0..1:~
., -
4.;.Jl ~ l.-9.J-'-" ulS'_;--c:cJI c..ill:i ~ ~ I ~~I 0 i ~>1, I <J.A u~ (o...i..-WI )J
~..uJ~f1 .~..b-~~J~r..u:.~~~,~~~J . ~
.a ... .!,ociJI ~ u~?ll ~ ~U;J ~ J ~ I Bernard Madoff ~J.llA .l.Jw.>:'
~4 Eleanor Squillari c.S.;~ .;JLl:11 ~..D ~I 1..SJ.llA o..u:.~ u.;~l ~
- - ,,
J~~~~~~iJ~Ult~,~~J~J~ll~l~f1
1..SJ.llA~ o..u:.~ ~J Elaine Solomon uJA_,.l~ c.J:'1 u.;~i ~ . ~ I
\"O
~ J ~ J ~ I ~ u4~ ~ ~~ ~J.ll..o .l.;W..H ~ Peter Madoff
.(Lucchetti, 2009) «..u:.lZ.11 ~ ~t» ~~ ~J.ll..o ~ ~Jl ~., "->Y"'t
:a..Jbll
.. ~
~b.tll ~.~q
.. '.r J.J
~ ....
CJ-L4J..J
.~,~~u.fiF-
- ~~~
.....u f ~
l. 4 Jlu.:,..'ll
.. I •. '.&
~~~
:. ~t1 ~ I '-:!"""~
__j\ '--'I c.!J!.>J.. 1-
.a_jL.o\J4 c.ill ~ ~.J-4 r~ -
.~I u~~t ~ '->~ ~t ~~ .ll~I ~f ~ ~ -
-0.."'4 ~t ul~ ~ J ~t J~ i ~ ~ -
• -1:!~ LJ-A t~ ~ c.;~ rlJ~ ~ J _,t .lLli.;tll ~ J ~ I ~ fo -
.~WI c.ill)\AjJ c.ill~ o..u:.~ ~ t~I -
·.»-T ~.;~ Jol..!aj _,t ~ c.,11 J~ -
ul..o..bJI L>.JA~w--:!.J.JI ~.,t LJ-A ~\JI L.>~ ~.ll.:d.l L.>f ~..,JI~

-
,Madoff ~J.lU J i l l ~ ~ ) IF-J.o ~ . , b . ~I ~..ul ~~I u.lll ,~UI
~~ y\:6:11 ~ (Norbourg Group [.J-':'.J~ ~~J ,Earl Jones j.j.P.' J~u
~ ~I ~ \ J I ~ ~ ~J -~J.lU ~..b- L o ~ ~ u~j.4ll ~ b j
: ~ .lLl,>"'-"'11
~..Lo~I.J-4 c.ill~LJ-.4 '-l ~ ~ ~ -~-1:! ~.:Ul.;~I ~ ~ j S ' y 'l-
.cG4~
.u~j°JIJ .;lS:s\'I ~ . ; ~ I ~ u.fi JLI -
. .) ~ 1 1~'
··'1 ~'lul..:.---'I
-·
~ ~ ~ c.:r-
,... ~-!.>JU.. _
.as'~! . ; ~ I ~ r ~ <i'11 ~_#I~ o->1u~ ~, JLI -
j ~ ~.:UI L.>\S' I~! ,JUI cGj~ ~.:UI LJ-A ·"~i ~ . ; ~ I ~ u.fi JL.ul -
,~u.o)U ~ ~J: ~ ,.;Llu.ua.ll ys, JUI
.(,~_;.-aA yb JA) . ; ~ I 0~ y_,L,t LJ-A ~ -
,..1.:R'- .;Llu.ua.ll ~J J..ct> :~~I J.,.- ~ o.:JJ~I JLI -
u ~ I ~ ~l.w4l~ 44.l~I
k·'ik ".§4Jh)-.w
. . . .·'§ ~y,,::.;..4§%(-~ .,·¢:··NiYP tw~h ?:'fk :a;, ..... ~(······¥-··->". - -· -r·-- 5¥ ..Y&· 1v,·"=WW <i<A;S i ,··: -W-::fr.,,-... @,·:--,~.~..,..u;,:.a~~«A>1,;.a.:·-·iiSf' ,·~we..;.+f &k=-:>--=~ii!+&b->!,\·,,;.:,..·,.~4
iu.J~L:, J~'it
suUIIMt~ "="3!J.>tt ~ ~ ~ t ~.J

o~l.,~LUI yl,:tll [)WVioxx~~.Jlli.J~I Merck~.J-:!Aas'..,_j, ..w
l,Jllo~Jh:i: ~ l~jA ~1~~1 ~ ~c;JI ~.)~I alS'~~ .)..Le~
r l' • • t.Jr\\\\ r,l.c. ~ lA ~i ~l.>.!..1ZJI a.JLl, l . J.t~IJ o ~ I a 'i~ ~""1
wlS:A?/4 wlS' a i.!v ~.,~a.!:'' abS'-..-J uAJ.J-A 0~ rv ~ ;-ot ~J--Li
J~ .(MSNBC, 2004) ~l.i.o ~~t as'..,_j, [ ~ c..:,,")..,.ll ~'ij.A J_,Lu .,J ~
~.:UI c..:,,")..,.ll ~~ _;,b;.. ~ c.:.J.ls ~.J-:!A as'~ 0 t al~l.c..)I a.JLl,f ,o~I ~ ""1
\.-9.>W ~ r, l' • • V r,l.c. ~J . o~ lA '-4J~ ~ll L,j f J f ~~ .J~ 1.,-..J_,Lu
~.J-4l.J'iJ.l0.J-=4 t. ,Ao ~~.l~~IJ ~JO~ w. ~J~as'~I
il4J .as'~I ..1.&4 uAS...,.:J4 a4Jlhl.1 a a_tl ~.l ~t ~ JJ..1-L.w:) ~ ~J ~
, -
~~~ ~.llS'i 0 ~ ~ ~.:UI ~..):!A as'~ ~.,-0 0i F l ,~I d.J::i
l.d~ c.ill::i~ ~1J ..ill ~~ .A .~u o~~• ~I • l)-AJ '1.J~ Lw..l
• ('tJ'"l:rt I~.a "ghostwrote"
yWJ ~~I a
.!·~I ~~r,l'• •A r,l.c.J.....Hl~~a~~L-ul.Jw\J
~ J .Journal of the American Medical Association (Goldstein, 2008)
o~I ~ ~~i r::oJ ~'-4.A ~4JolJ ~ . l ~ ~1.,-ol ~.J-:!A as'.;-,!u ~.) J~
-
•a.wi..JI ~)L,c.ll
. c-r~~
. . .::. ·.J.ii
~
~It I A - 1.7.
~~as'..,_j,a.>9l r'°' • •\ r,l.c.~~~ . ~ I ~l.c...,.JI J~~ l.i.ljlAJ

~~I 4.4~1 LsJ ~ J 0 l ~ ~.:u4 ,~.l~I a.c.u...o J ~ ~ J ,Pfizer
.J..a.J ·r'i}U ~[~Y'_,Bextra l~[)W~~I ·-·iq ,;,; ~4~lAL,JI
~~ 0~ ~.,~.) ~ ~.J-Al .J'iJ.) 0-*4 r, r t-44 t"9.l ~ as-~1 udlJ
~ C..Lc.L.u ~.l~I i , ~ d4~~ as'~ ~.)I .~l.i.o~ a.a.,~~,.)~\,
.(Thomaselli, 2009) L.,:,~ ~~ ~ J ~ l 0lS:A)'4 ~ ~ <i'11 ~'iWI
r L,.I.)~La.:,
• I.)
'-4.A ~
-·
~
-
..was'·~
-~·'I I~
A°':-A.) ~,, d..41 ·.:. ti • i .lla.i.JI
c.r-- ~ u
· .<::i LS
~~
~ W' . (Angell, 2004) ~ I ~lli.11 db J-1~ ~ ~ ~ c;JI
- c.r
Lw~· t · JLibl c.:r--
•- ~-· , ~- lli.!1 .) L:&;..1
• ~
•• •~
- ~ c.:r-- · ~ as~:.
•- J.):
.(Goos,2007) ~I~~ L.,:,t ~ ~ l ~~lli.11 ~~0J.l
US Food and Drug Administration ~JAf.:JI ~IJ..UIJ ~Lilli~~ ~
~ ~lJ Cephalon u~~J Bayer AG~ <-:?i ~4) ~J ,u\S'~ ~.;i 0-4
'--49J ,Amylin Pharmaceutical Inc. ~..))U ~iJ .Eli Lilly & Co ~lS'~J
_t_,.
J--~
ti 0-4~J - - ·--1.:j
,1 ,~~ I s,o·!r::eLL.l.4.!~'0'L)--=4101
· ·t·tl · ·- 1 ~ •.1:
~11 ·tll
Ill!~ .-:1·,1-1
~u~
. (Reuters, 2010c)
a.a..~ul
• ·
Y---1-"' ~~I
• t ... · -< .. _._~ ~ ~
~ <..»>-1.r-- .)
-L.:. uL:il
• u · ~~l.J
c
· i £>.·'
• u ~
J.4l
~ a..a.t.:J.I uLA.,W.I ~ as'~I [.JI,;.. 0-4 ~4JI ,-1 ,tbi ml:e as'~ ui .,_J
J_,.a.ll ~~~I ~Jml:e as'~ .)~I ~~~I~ .(Steenhuysen, 2009)
~~ J~ ~ 4AWI ulS'.;-c!JI ~~ ~_,-u, ~ uLA.,W.I i.!.U:i ~ ~bl u'-:t
- .LA~~..)f.;J\ -
ulS'~ ui (Spielmans, Biehn, Sawrey, 2010) I.S.)1.,-u,J u~J _j.j~ ..l.JJi
,P C - C lt
~ o.J:~ ul->-1,J ~I~ LI.J..ul 0-4 ~1~10-4 ~t&j ul:?-~I ~ ~ -l.Jji ~.)~I
'r ~ ~ ~ uLA.,W.I ~ ui ~1 LI.J.l~ ~tJ4J .o.>A JS~ ~IJ..ul ~~
.k~i ,1 ~~ ~uLA.,W.I ~ ui ~l ~\:i LI.J..l.J.!'~';LJ? ~ k~i
~ J ~..llS'l u ~ ~..lf.:JI ~~ ~ a!AWI ulS'.;-c!JI u~l ~ '.J~4
-~.JA.>A ~..)\S'l ul.J~ D.)J.>A -\:i~J ~.) ~ ~ -
u>4:J. o.)_i).A l:i~ ~~J -
Elsevier ~ 1 as'.;-c!J ~1-'"°i Merck ~..))U l.!l~ as'~~~ ul~lc.ll l.!l~
,l.!l~ as'~ l&b~.JI ~1 o.JL:u?JI J~l ~ o.)_i).A ~..llS'i u ~ ~ ~ ~
~
~ - J .u~'-4.tll L&:Jl~.#<.S.»-i~ ~ ,, w,k ~t~ LA~J
- -
0-4 ~'-:t ~ as'.;-c!JI ~~ 0-4 <)J_.;~ ui ~1 uLA.,W.I w,k l.!l~ ~~ ~
-~.;JI ~.)WI ~l~I
u~~ u~ ~-'"° Eli ~illy & Co~ ~1 ~~ 15...u u'-:t ul~\..c..)I l.!l~J
O.)~ ~ ,=-:::J ~..)\S'~I ~ I u ~ ~...\Ai~ ul ~ 0--'.J>-)U ~
I
Pfizer ml:eJ Merck l.!l~ ~~ t~4 ul~lc..ll l.!l~ ui ~ .as'~I u ~

. ~~ J.,~ ~~ c.ill~ JS~~ . (Laidlow, 2009) ~ y_,L.a,)U
; ,"";It
c:- -•~-•1 d..J~I as'-~
~ -
-~-tt ~ b -~1:; • ~-
- L9-' !J 0-4 ~ -
~ • :. LJI J..:,,.. ~
u.J-'>" • .J
uLA..)~ <5..lj:i .,;4t=---uJ1 ui u-31 ~ ~ ~ ~J Imperial Tobacco Canada
Ll..J:&A -
d..J~ • L"'..L ~ 0 - -
.-:t.:.q • j · - ~ j • ('t •lb .... t\ ~
~~~~~c ~ u ~ - ~Ju '..r--' •• !J
•• • • ~\
- -
~,~ u-31 u\.: i.:i 11111 .»-IJi 0-4 as'~I u~.Jb °'.:a;; I.SY':" • c.ill~ ~ 1~1 I.J.A
.J-A l.!l.J~ ~ w~ .J1lJ ,u\.:i.:· «uitl ~I..L;t ~ ~l:i_,JI 0-4 ~ I ~J u\.:i.:i'-4:JI
r''\'\A rl&. ~J .(Brunner,2009)~~1 u ~ ~ ~ l ~ t : J I ~
ulAfi.=.,J ~->-4i ./1J~ w~ n "\ ~~ ~ o~I ul:~_,JI ~ ~I u~~ ~IJ
" ,,
L>'°~)U ~ I ~l&.yl ~~~LAL&. w,J~J ~I.SJ.A~ ul:~_,JI
~ af°LA~l ,,.:U, ~ ~I ~ I wl -~...Ltl4 ~~ ~,~ Lo1..>-4i wi,~ c.J:.:.UI
- - ,,
.a..u~, ~ F' ~ ~ ~ ~ Wb F' wi
~I ~tu.JI J~I ~ . J ~~~~IO:! ~Lli .J-AJ J ~ ~I o-4 .»-i tY ~LiAJ
y~~b1.S~l~J~irr· ·'\rL&.>='jiS'i~~ .~,J.l~~4JI Ls,J~..,:;
Hwang Woo-suk ~.,_...,,JJ ~I.J-A ~ ~ I ~J t'° LJ:AW ~~ ~ l:.)fi
rt&.~ . (BBC News, 2009b) ~~I l:)l;.JI w~ "-!J4-J ~ ~tu.J ".J-S..»"J
ScienceFl~~LA~~~JJ'.«: '".'o~l~~.J-A~rr··t
~ 0-4 ~ J ~ I ~ f1WI ~ ,, ~~ ~ JJi ~ ~ 4.ii ~ ~~
u ~ lA..L.u:.~IUJJ~ ~~~l~I~~ .ulJ ·t«cciicccA~~
u~~I ~ w~ ~I~~ w~~~~I ~J~ ~ -w~ ..>--J..»"JI t_§Jl.....:.~
.l.!l.J.:.U oJL:u)i'I wJ-l w,J.Y-)U ~-l~I u4~4 a.;~~I ~J , ~ I
u ~ t'° '-fj.:.WL,,,,,iJ uhA~ i~ o~_,JI ~~)WI w~ ~ ~ l.!ll~
~ ~ ,,~t; '. «: '"! l.!ll~J (Woodhouse, 2009) ~UI ~...l.11 ~ ~ J ~ ~I
-~~~~I ~I~ wl:?-~I
,,
t9,~~4PJ~J..aJ
jljlA ~J 'YJ'-=!:=JI o-4 a,
,11L11 ~ .o...\..4£A ~~~ U~IJ ~IJ y.JS:JI
o~ u ~ l ~ i (.):.:.UI ul-A4,JI y)lb wi (Y· ·'\) Zhong ~.J-AJJJ Mazar
,1....J.JS:JL)
• •
~
-
-'-- ~ ~ ,~~
a.a.,~ ,.~ - -· ~-~)Lo I......U.u&J)
• • •
c~ ,_. _
u)l;.
-
~' d...i>.w,
-
.
<.)A
.~a.a.,~~~, f41 c:..,1;.y..u o~I f41wi wi J~ -(~.;-uJIJ ~IJ
.. .
&4..L..ii u ~
i·h 1 w,,....,..-:::' .
(Rutherford, Buller, and Stebbins, 2009) j i.::i , "J Y-':'J ~J~PJJ ~ ~
i~ ~'-=!:=JI ~Luu..,,j.1. ~J ~I ul: I~I ~ ~~ w ~ c.J:J.J'-=!:=JI -lljj-ll wi
l.!l.J~ ~~J -~~ Ji (.)J~JJA Ji (.)~JA Ji J~iJ Ji t,.,.Jb ~...l.J ~ ~~
!l'.l.f.lt'l'IG.'lc,4#,~k~S..!•Y'-'»'AS!.:..A"®\.;,,.t,;:..A¢1:'<,"1:~~-',.~"ft~•./L.'L~..Dllllll'I,~~- , .,4..,..,~
......,.._-,rJ.v-~~........ ~-,y,;n.
Y'°i ~~ ~ ~ ~.:tll Lo.91!1~ faU : u ~ I ~ ~~!J 4.4w~I

J_j":llJ.wwll
AM · M ff?f5S&H%#±iht4 "'" s
I.J.A ~ -~~I u.,~ ~ o.l~I ¥.;JI ":?t ,cc':r'~ y~» c.:,11 oJ~
, ~ ci'11 o~I ~ J ~~ o~ JfoJ a qJoiJI ~ ~ c.::Jl.o_,ia.o y.A.11
• ~ rlj:tl'il ~ 'i .l~J r':..14iJ ~L..JI ~~I .l~J ,~WI .l~J
c.::JJ~t ..1.o.l .((~ ~ t y~» ~ .)~ ~l.;-11 ~~I c.::Jl-....uj.ll ~
~~ '-4!ji 0 ~ ~ 1->At British Columbia ~lk.J..;+11 ~.,Sfi 4-LblaA ~ b
r'=..1,4jJ '-4il,.U ":!.J.£S' aS'~ ~J Rogers Communications c.::J'i~)U ~J.J
J~~((l..1.iS' ~~.,,!i,-o;.s\'I» ~~ ~~.ll ~J':iil ~_,.,~I c.::J'-4..wl
t.;--':it1~1»~~~J.Jas-~~.llot~..aJ .~)UIJ~'ilc.::J~
,
.
.(Sturgeon, 2009) o)\..c.'il I.J.A ~Ji ~ J ccl.J.£S' ~
,
-
i« lh I(ff' I
. .•
... ..,......._.. \J.lS»
&4.L..ii ~
U .t Alt .
~ ci'11 c.::J~I oA .)~ ~UA .((o.;J.).11» ~4.JI c.::Jb~ \l_,.., ~UA 0 t J~
o~~c.::J~~J(ylfilJJ~':iil o.;bl ~) l,c.l_isi, ;,1;'"C4.' ~4.JI c.::Jb~I
~..u ci'11 Peng Sun (jJ.IJ ~ ~4- ~ .(.,IJ..,:.S'.lJ~l.oJ LJ"'_,.,..J_,J~ c.::Jb~)
o.l~J ~.J:o .;'iJ.l ,. • • ~ ~UA c.::Jb~I t~ ~j~ '-:,WI c.::JLi..._;l..ill o).ll
c.::J~ ~4 ~t d.A.44.JI f.:r'..UJ -~.J:o J'ij.l t ••• ~ a..ow1 o).l?/1 ~ ~UI
. University of Toronto .¥JJ.Jji d.A.44-J York University~.;~ ~4.l c.::Jb~I
, -
~ 1 oA ~~1 ~ ots -~4 ~ ~1 W6 , l+.!11 ~ji ~ cGi ~ ~IJ
~J~c.::Jl~~c.:,ll~)lj ~~oA 'i~c.::Jb~I ~1~ I~~
clJ_.;.l~ ~l..,s' ~..u bl.i.,~ oA o~ c.::J~I .141 .(Brazao, 2008a) ~~ u.a~
~ ~.J.J~ ~,-o oA c.:,lJi ~4- o.l~, I.J:o ~ w~I ~ J ,Quami Frederick
~ .I.J:o~4!,-o.>Aw~~~~~J(~~l)d.:lWla<: ,~.Jl~c.::Jb~I
oA ~~~ ~l.;.loA~~l 4.6.Jll~~\S Lo~ t.,::J6.~I ,·,a ,~,-."-) - c.::Jl.l~I ~ c.)A
· ~ -=-:-~u WWI
-
~ •
I.
.~.;<.! oA JS' ~1 ,~1 o~~ ~1:.u1 ~.>:!-'-" ~ wJ-!~ 0:!:.u1 ~~~1 ol

•0
~~ ,~WI ~.,SI~~~ "-1~ r~ y~i Ji 4:ib~ 0 ~ y~\S cGi
.~1().4.l..,.b\J
~J o..o ~1~)'1 ~..,JI~ Y'J Ali Kordan 0 1.l.;~ ~ ~ ~ ~
"'-'~..)o..)~~'1..1~0~~~~~, ~r't'··Ar~~l.ill.>J.Jfi
~..)I W' . Oxford University (Theodoulou, 2008) .l_;~i 4.&.44', o..o ~
~1~1 ~l£A4,. o..o ~J\11 ~4,JI o.l~IJ~UI o.l~ ~ ~ t.Gi ~ j
.y~ t(,j F' LA ~J
I~ ;._, t!.,
~~9':.r-. t ~lS ,..,,,
Al A t ~ t •. ' ~C,.,. - tt ull
- ~~,..., !>"'
Psychology Today r-'='11 ~I~~~ LA~ ~}ii y_;~ LA~
, ,
~_j "fi~ U ~J .ccul::i.,..Jl ~ I rJ>ll o..o ~_.,:; ;;~I wl:i~I» c:,I~ ~~
wllo4>-l o..o ~.JJ U c:,LWI J)lbl ~1 ~.,.ti wl:i..>---'-" l:?.lY { \ \ V \) Zeitlin
w\S'J: ·fA~JA o.lli, ~1 o_;b}'I ~6. o..o ~ J ~_,JI ~1;;11 "-'"°~ ~ t..l......43J
~ ,l.:U .~tu!
.. . .~('iJ oJb J--
J-- -"'·-· ,A~
-~<'i ~ ~>'-"= u· L. ~.,._...
··· !t!.._tt r ~ , u• L. ~...)
·~'~··
d.lL..u..,JI D.J.A ~ c:,i ~.;-ll ~ o..o ~ J ~ , ~ , ~.,.ti o..o -':!..WI l.!ll.i.A 0i J..!
•~L.wo t1~T ~_,JI I.J.A ~
s ~ ~ t u'i~~ ull~" wi .-s ~ , r t 9,l>,3~t

Ji ~_,JI
.. ~~>-1l..:i 0 ~ i:H.:WI , ~.,_J.I c:,~ LlJi l.!JL.i..A
lS...W.I o..J ~ • ! JI a~ i 6 ti ~1..l....Ai c--4 LA~ ~UoJ ~'~ <>-:!.:WI
wl:i~I ill~ ~ 4 , ~ I a~~.' ~ w W ~ ~~) J.-:gi 0.,_j~
.(Harris and Benson, Benson, 1998; Huiras, Uggen, and McMrris, 2000)
... ~ ~ ~6. ..::.il~l..r!'-1 ~1..=-::i4 ~ ~ljlfi»

~ I o..i.l;i ~ ~l_,JI &oJ ~ ~l_,JI &o c.:,4 ~ljlfi ..Loh ~~~I ~.;JI t.)4! ~ ~
~i r~' ~J · ~ ~ I . l ~ I c.)-4
~b ·rl:!l ~)W ~ , ~.:.UI JL.....i.JI ~~ d~jA
~~.;JI c.:,l ~..,JI~ ~~LP.-JJ~J~~ ~14......J-"4:'JY.lS'~..i.l;i~.;c.:,i:. ~ljl->-5
. JL.....i.JI ~ ul~ ~.;~ ~ 4 4.;i~
* The Onion, December 2, 2009.

Mll1 • 1W ..'Wl!OIINIL100;" =Olli:.Ci"~ :IIQl!,l_ _ _ _ , ,
~~~~'?'.:Lt' LoJ i : , ~ ,~u :ul.J=a.at ~ ~l..i&ia.t!J 4J~I

=~~=~~...---.;."'~~~··__c...;·
.·.·. . :·; ... ·::··: ·,···.·.·=····:·. . ··.·.·::(:""·.·-'·"·.··\:... _ . · : ~ ~...... ·,:·...._.."·.·:.,·:....._::-:-:·:,·.-'--"bl
-; .......
~~I [J.J ~J ''-:?.Jb.JIJ ~ u.a..o~ ~WI ~~4,11 <.>":PYI wi

J >l,;. cu~:. ~
•
i <..;r----
,... ~ ..>=J~ ~ _jJ~ ._)-J_)·ljL• a.J.~:q
1. __ ..1.4l • •.•. 1. ,.,,~, -
~
a..u~LJI
- •
~ ~
. b ..L.L.iJL»
. - . ~~ (.)· \S' Lo~ a...o.< -t\. -~ · -
~ ~ LJ:':-'-" ~ <J:l..r--
... <....._
L:; • -: .~.:.t c:G>.. J.)• ~--
~ I J;...).., .)~1..,J~~, ~ell~.., r'\\'J r'\\· ~~ ~ .«1., •

~~4 ~ ~J
.
.(GlobalSecunty.org, n.d.) -~'}}~I~ ,-.b;; ,ul{ ~ J
.~WI <.>":PYI o.:i~ I~ ~~I ~~I 0-4 -
J:!WI ~JJ-::1 ~.J.;li 'r''t' • • \ f'~.J:cii: , .. ~0-40,,1~IJo-4~I ~
I.SJLi:u.J ~~J ~)-•A w,k. un • ,:::-.::J4 Alberto Fujimori '-:?.J~ ~~ ~.;-.Ji
r'~ ~ ~ ' } J I ~ ~ L ~ I a.......u~_;J ~.;J ~...u ~·ollJ W'.::!--'""4-JJ
~ o~c4 .J.>.I_,~..,~ ~
- ~
~,J-L'-"~~ ~ 4 '4k, ~ .ig.., ·r't'· • •
~
. (Boucaud, 2009) u~?JI J ~ c:G\S'~~ lA~ 0J~.., ~
c4 ~L..u~ '-:?.:UI) Fahrni Shabaneh ~~~ -\:~ 0-4 .J.>.IJ r'~ ~

o~I ~L.u.JWI ~~ o.:i~ ( ...1.......uWI ~~ ~ J J ~ U"'~ . ) ~ L ~
ofi~ a.:i.:bu,l.;JI a.bLJI ~.)J.L.oi ,~~~~~I w,k.i ~ jl~)U
- -
I.Jl.:G! .lL.will ~~ J J ~ ~J ..1.4l .«~IJ--'""1 c4 uJL.:tll)) ~ ~ J~I -
-~~~I ~ u~?JI ~ l ~ o.:ii _,t 0:~I 0:1J.;...-.ll a,g\S' ~ u-"4-J ~~
u.,lo.Jj"&A a.:i.:bu,l.;JI a.bkJI ~ ~_;JI <.J:!Jj.uJ.I 0-4 J:..u.ll ui w,11 ~~ .JLlii
.(Toameh, 2010) ~ ~~ ~.., rWI JUI~.>-'""~~-\:~
~J ·r' \A"\ r'~ jJ~i~o-4 <)-l~IJU"'.ll-uJI ~~~~ ~~~I

G-7 ~ ' d..c~ ~Lo~ w,11 ~~';/4 ~~, L ~ I ~.ig r' \W rl....J:.
~~')/ a.J_,6 ~ iill~J ~LUI ~4-A 0-4 ~ Lo J~')/ JUI Governments
J~.., ·('-:?~.J~J.)u~v, t:44 ,~~.i9,J~I ,~~) .~~')/ly~I
"Lll.LA ,l.ill~o-4 ~~ ·t~' ,~~~'-:?ii~ ~ ·r't'·'. r~..>:,..H-9~
. ~ i ~I..,=;?] JUI I~ w,k. ~~)LI 1_,J~I ~lfi'J~I 0:1Jj.ua.tl u~ .)~\
~ '
um..u\S'~~'.JJ:iWl~_.;tu.i.~1<.>":P.;Jlw,k.~,rr· ·\r~..r.>jiS"1~~
·U"')t;..~I ~~ ~~ ~J o.:ii ~ ~,Y-'-" ~ ~ 4 Rafael Calderon
~
u.ci ILLI~J r't'· • i r~ ~...r4i .)~J~ o • ·, • • • ~ w,k. J ~ 4 0m..u\S' f §11

.(Associated Press, 2009c) ~_.;t°u.ufa. ~~~I u~I r'~ '-:?~ <.>"'.il
I.Ll~ ~WI ~J-4ll ~yl ~Lc.~I ~ r' r • · t\ r'~ J-:lj"oi ~ ~ c.ill~
- ~ -
cl:~~.) 0lS' lAJ..u:. ~I cG~J u,u)b;.':/4 4.4~':/ Jacques Chirac
,, I.Lll~
u-o~':/1 wl~ JIJAi ~..u cl:~ 4UI wl~...ul r-1..J:ki , ·4 ~I ...l4l ·~->4
.(Associated Press, 2009d) ~ J ~~J ~
..>J_jJ .JAJ ,Jesse Chacon 0fiLla:i ~~ J~I 'f" r · · t\ r'~ ~..) ~ ~
·.•: ,11! c.ill~J ,Hugo Chavez~Lj,_ij.Jib~~I ~yl 0A ~t.H~J
~ ...l4l .Lfi.>J4 wl:s~ f-8:...u J~i J~.J ~ ~.Jji ~l.A:i.A ¥ ~ a =-.:·os
.(Reuters, 2009b) ~.J~I ~ J~JJ ~~10,A ...1;?...u.ll ~
~ ~~.J w41...;.:wl I.Ll~ ,r'r·' · ("~..>:IJ-is~ ~~II~~~ J..u:.J
~J'~J.,.,:UI ,Yanukovych~fiy~ WJ0l.a:,l.uu.1.I ~I ..llJ. ~lfiJi
.~1-'""'°~I ~l~J ~4~':/1 ..>J.JlJJ J~':/4 ~ I l4s·o~ Tymoshenko ~~
~I ~Jl-c:uyl ~4! World Bank Institute ~J...ul ~ I
W' ~ .)~
(Rose-Ackerman, 2007) ~JAi.) ':JJ.l 0~~ ~I~~ JS' wlS'_;-1ill ~..D
~I.J~ W' ·rl.....:.JS'~JAi.J':lJ.l0"*4A• ~ .lLuuill 1~~0i ~
~ I u.:}J ~ l 0i The National Audit Office w4~1 ~l._rl w,--i.b,j11
i~~ ~~I ~~JAi.)':lJ.l0"*4 ro YJ~ LA l ~ I J i J ~ I iJjl-.ui
Lfi.>JI ~J~J~~Jl~JJJIJAl ~ c.ill~~ ·r'r· •t\ r~ ~J~I
, , • • • 0,A~i I.Ll~J .0:...LLJI J ~ Ji ~_µI ~I.J~I c!2 Ji ~1~ J)l;. 0A
" -
.(Barboza, 2009) ~yl:s ~~ ~~ ~~ JJ~
~~j ~.Hl a...5~ .ll 4 I , ~La.JI ~La.JI~ I J "~ J
111 CCI 4
'f" r · · AJ r r · · v <:r4\.c. 15?.- ~j..JI Ernst & Young's 1Q h Global Fraud Survey 1
~11.rr .JLlii W' . ..)L,j Ji o.,..:U.) aJ6.. ~~I ~~I 0J...>:...u.l 0A 1.n ,,~,J
~~ 1.,A ..lZ..Jj , ~ ~L.a:,)11 JI ~J~ ~ ~ J ~ o.,..:U.) ~..) ~ y1b cGi
~ ,c.ill~ ~1 ~~! ·~~Ll.4 ~.l ~I ~JL!.yl ~ "'l:)~ ~ - IJ~
. (Ernst & Young, 2008, pp.56) .l~.ljl ~ .l~I 0~ ~~I ..:.J:i 0A ~i
0l~IJ wl 4 Io ;JI~ 0A ~ I 0 4 ,;.,;;~Jo~ .lLuuill ~~ 01
a .::~I .l)...,._J.I ~..DJ a :- ,otlJ ~ .:l•ill ~ ~WI w~I u;, .:a:i-.JJ
~4,ll ~.JL;.JI 1 ~':/1 w ~ ·;, •·oJ ~~I ~~I o.ll..i)J
. (Fisman and Svensson, 2007; Rodriguez, Uhlenbruck, and Eden, 2005)
_...,...-.,-..--.,~~~ _ , 1 o a . · . A ~ V ~ t : . ..,.'il"~r1'1.:.<111'.1..W~~o;.'Q:;o,p: ,---."«.V~~•'.i.)."li,,.itw'\.~,~-x,,,:,y ~~,-.-;.7'~~-;·;,=._.,,...,.;,,.;,.:.:.,·,w•,#,.-,~~.....-. :'(·:,; ~''°'~ ~l",1'
tr lf:t~ ~ ~ (j.'..Lll L4J ~~ fall. : u ~ I ~ JL.w..ciJ!., 44.t~I

~J.J~ laJIJ~ll.-9~1~ Ekea ~1 ~~c..i.kt ,rY· ·4\ r~ ~~~~
~Ls~I ~ oJl:}., ~~I <r'...u -~JLl..;JI ~ ~ I oJ~J J~I t ~ '.·: '"!
Jlis ~ ..1l . ~ , LA>~ r~' ~ ~J~J t=9J l&:k wlS'J o~ oJ~ l&:k
~J~ w ~~ )~I ~\.;:J~ ,.sy,- ~I~ ~I ~~I a~~IJ aLAµI ~1
J~~I ~~J-AA: ..1l ~ -~~I J~~I ~IJ~ ob~ ~JJ ~ o~L....u?JI ~1
. ~ ~ J a ~ ~~I JjjJJ ~UoJ ~~ ~1 ~~ wl ~ ~»JI
J ~ I w~ Dimitri Medvedev ~~..l.:!-4 ~~J ~»JI v":P>111.-9~1 ~
.(Kramer, 2009) 'Ul:,JJl ,.s..\>.14..i..4 ~I ~ J ~J.J ~ ~.P.- ~
~ , J wJlullJ . ) ~ ~ , ~ ~ r t · , · r~ ~ ~~1 ~ ~ ~
lA~J ·r)WI a~~~JLl..;-11 r;:9-l :,:nwt r~~I ~ ~wlS'J ,OECD
~~I~ ~ I ~l..>--""l ~ ~ J ~ wJlullJ -l~~I ~ ~\S'
~ ~ ~ , ~1~ ~i ~ ~->9t tl:9.l..>-J.JY ,.s:,Ll.j ~...u ~1>""1 ~)
.(Globe and Mail, 2010b) ~1>""1
~~~ ~JOL9J~~l~l ~~ .l.yw~'-?Jlwi~.;-11~

~ i ~ w\S' , ~ I J a:J~I 0----'-" ~rt·· 4\ r~ ~~~~Omar Bongo
a.JJJ ~ j ~i alS:.\4A ~_;ot ~_,4 ~ a ~ (U>""i ,.s...u wlS' ~ ~WI ~~t
-
~1.;-11 a ~ I ~ r\J ,oJ~ ,Ar '~..>-'4-4 -4~ 11 ~~,.s...u wlS' ~ ·i.S.»-l
., -
~ t..,t..,j ~J ,~~ w~4JI ~~ ~ o~ ~~l ~_,LlaAJ, ~~ ~
aLl.Ll.~..\>.l ~ 4-A_µI ~IJ.)J ..\>.t J.).Uw~lj.JI ~~ ~ .i.:,o;.~ dJ ~\S'.:U
U I l..&..-..J Ls ~ ,~ • c..4! ~ t I ~ l.J
. I Ll • ·~(' t~ I O~ ~ IJ a...u
O
' ~ ! ,~ 'I I..>'°..r--ti
.,
0 O
..
. ~ ~J u-w .. '.u---' .. !j,J~
A - • ' • a
j ..
~ 0t ~ w~ J~ ~ .((~~ r~» ~ , Jl~t ~li:i - ~ ' ~411

Wl.c.
... LAi - ~ ..1,a.jjl,. ~
LL.:u.. ~.r ,~·. ~':.~,JUL,
';. ti u• ~,.~ 'J-
.l .. <t" .. -~t 4..u..a>,
. ~~ '..r---' ...
. (Nossiter, 2009) r~' ~ ~ y t 0-J...J~J.l ~ w ~ w~'-?JI ~ ~l_,.1.1

~~I~~~ ~.;JI~ o~I a~~_,JI ~ ~..DJ -lL.w;JI Jl~i ulljlAJ
~ ~ ~ ~-lWI 6IJ>.i ~ lAJl..~1 ~ ~IJ Jl~~I ~ ~ a_;,j,WI
~w~~,J.A~~ -~~~i ~...w0--4~~~0i~~~
~ ~.;J ~1.;JI ~JjJIJ ~yl a..tlol~ ~J ,Jennifer Douglas u-u>4'-J-l
~ .o~I a~~_jll ~yiJ~J-lWJ&-0 t.· J~?/ ~Jju..u:.L....c, .ig ,~L.uJI
~t ~ 0..)-'-"~IJj~, ~~YJ ~ y t LJ:,Al:i.J. ~,~~, ~ ~ j <.>:'I~
tt
ul.J:..al ~ ~~I.J 4J~I
j: 'i(hv~'" ,·,··~>-.. _;··.J::.-'Y r;·:-.Y1··.1 . .._,'.' ,_.·.f~~- ,~·-.. ~ · ·.. ~;!!'.;,-~) i /··.?~~7":-"lt'F""~!''.'.~< .·~?::: '?L-~, ... ·.-f, •··~·£s·I>-=\) f · ·." :~ :, . • : - ) ' ' •,.' .· .•. • ·.. ·-~·:-;-. C• ,·~z. ~(-- .. .S-· ·::: .·f" ·-;:_.,........ ·. ~~,-. · ·.•,• ·;.::.-·--:·(\ ,•:-.-.,:,J
~~ ~j..i.A '->~I ~ .;;~I ~l:'i.,JI ~J ~.JAi .)'iJ.l ~~ \ \ • ~ JJ_p.:i

;;~lb ~ l '->~IJ . ~.)~~ Malibu ~'il..o ~...lA ~ ~.JAi .J'iJ-l 0 ~
'->..u 0 i ~ •~->-4 i .J'iJ.l 0 ~ r A , o ~ Gulfstream ru->'-'-" ~ ti, 0--4
~~I ~b_,JI JJ~~~.JAi .J'iJ-l 0~ A, o ~~~ w~4JI ~.J ~ I
~->-4~1 ;;~I ~~'i_,ll JUI I.J.A ~ i LA..ulJ 0~ ,... ~Ji ,igJ ~ ~L.>JI
.(Abrams, 2010) ':""""l..o-'1:i..ul ~-':I ct:,w.u'i4
, ~~~ J~ ~~a~~, J~ ~w, utswitjiW ulf.?,.,

4-4.J~I 0t (Albrecht and Albrecht, 2009a) ~ I J ~.._r.JI ~ 'i
~ .)~,J J ~ 'ii PJ: ~ .0 1.J.4.J1 ~lS' ~J ~~, ~ ~ ~JJ .l~IJ
,igJ .rJWI 0A '->F"-~I s:I~ ~I~ ~Lofo>JIJ 4:;~I J~ ~I~ ~WI 0A s:~
.. ti '/J
International ~~l.a:JI ~ ;;.Jb¥-J d..:!,lJ..ul ~ I 0A ~~ b~ 0~~1 ~

Journal of Cross Cultural Management (Albrecht and Albrecht, 2009a)
L. s:l..u .l~I Jl..u:,..'il . L!&..i :. ... ~ , ~~~, (.). i ~... A
<.:r-- • J - (.) . ..)-:!d hA ~ ~
~
t!.~
..
·
'rJ J~I t- ~~I
<.:r-- .. ~
~b;JI :.~
..>JJ,J.. wuS' ,clu~'il
.. 1 .. " a..u.Ja.11
.. . ·
~
~ ~
'->J.)
~)b!IJ ;;.,._1uyl CJJ~ ~'iLu:,.I ~J .l~I ~ ~JllJ 0-J->:..U.I ~LA4,.:il
.d.J:,~ 01~ ~ 4U1 ~w~4
;;~yl~~J ·<:r4t,.~!~~iw,k.;;~yl~J~WI~~~~
0~~ ;;~->11 . (Eicher, 2009; Hopton, 2009) ~ 01~ ~ ~Ll. ..ill~ ~.J
. ~ ~ , d.A.J.4i l..oj,AJ0.,._1uyl .ll..~~I ~~ ~y,-~IJ~P ~~i
0A ..,:Si 1.§J~yl ~..i:; Ji ~~ ..J,J-'-" ~~ I ,,.J.A 0A ~ 0 i ~->-1, I 0--4J
..>:~l.:,J. I~~ i 0A passive bribes ~ I 1.?JLl.yl r~ .'->?~I~~,
.)~I) 0-J_,.;..~I ~~t:JJ active bribes a.JlMJl "?JL.....:i,.iJI r.J;.; ·u;J ~4~1 Jl
·(~.,s:.:.JI ~l....u~IJ ~1~4 ~ ~ ~6:..o ~I)~~ J ~ I ,.)~4
~I J.:>~4J ~ I ¥ ~~ "?.:UI ~I «br ~ 1.?Jl..lu.;JI '->~ p~ ~
uAJ~~J ~~1~.~tl
.. , ~ ..>J:.i.'-:'""(Martinetal.2007) <..JJ..»
· · iJ t),J.)
... LA~• .,AA-I
~~
..
~ I ~ ~I uLo.,WI ~ 0~411 jAb ·~Jl..luyl ulb~ w,k. ~ I
~~ 'ii
-
u~j.tlJ ¥~I JAly.JI .JJ.l a...__1.J..u I~ Ar ~ ~ rv, 0A
- .. -
~
.J • .r ~ .
\,;J 'J-'
tt f: ..l4A.l ~ , U:-'
u ~ :..~, aqt;,;4" ~
L~tt ~,'..>--'-".,... .. , a.JUI
.. .)A
'.r--'
.-:tfJ
.. '/J
c.JsJ ,~.lyi}I ~I~,~ 01..L4JIJ d..:!,lWI ;;~yl ~~ 6:::-! lbl+i.JI 0~411

_ _ _ _ _ _,..,..._. . , . . , . . . , . . . i : . : . & . : ' 6 W ' ~ ~ . . 1 1 \ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ pm ..... _,.,~~~~.,ilo,~ ~
to ~~ 41.d ~ 'i?.:Lll l.oJ c,~ tjU :ul.J:a..al ~ Jlwwil!, 4.w~I

~J...l:IJ4i ;;.,._i:uyl 0 1~i~.., , ~ ~ ' 4:~J~jj<i'3I ~~JUuyl u'~'
.~i ~~ J~ ~ ~~ <i'3I ul..tltJI ~~i
4....4.J~IJ ulJ.J ;. t t ;;.., ?: i t I f-4 ~I •. •; , o ~ JJL.....wo ..>--1~ ~ j
Q
l..9JLl.i ~~I 0 w~I ~ 0 1 UN Office on Drugs and Crime UNOFC

~~~uh 'r"· · °' r~ J~ r~ u1o.,i ;;~_,..11 r;:9J ~ ,~i ~t c.:,11
iJ~JJ tro _jAJ ~~' j>J.ll JJ.t.A .:G..J:i - ~...>Ai iJ~JJ n· _jA ~JLl.yl
-~ t:9...Li <i'1' ~..9Ll._,JI t ~ J ~., ,ul~~?JI "~ ~ ~~ . ~ ~...>Al
,, ..
~~.., a:;)\j JJ~ LA _jAJ '~...>Ai .)~JJ u-*4 r, o 0 b...u:,wi ~~i a:s\S' ~
u-4 "/.Ar ,.s~ ,c.illj c.:,11 a:s~1 -ub...u:,w~ ~4?1' ~ ' ~\111 u-4 aJUI ~
~4=.Jb~lul~l~?J'~t'.)-'-"~u~~~J~J~'c.?u~~~uw~I
4=...w<JI a.o_µ1 C1.>~I .igJ .(UNODC, 2010, p. 4) J\:W.I ~ J ~ .. ,,~
.:. t' ~'
~~ .. .< . r 1..)-'-" '-':>lkl ~
~ f-l ~ (.):J '...L.cJ.J ~ A ' .. t'
I,.. J:'.:r---'
.. - ~ (..1-"-!'W
L - ": u' .. ' .
~ ~-'"°~
I ~ 0 i 0.,-a~I ~~J.A t;.!b;.,,2 ,~6.. ·d..:1~ ~i white-collar criminals

,,
u-4 I ~ [ ~ I u..P.!biw:!J ~~ U""...Lu, ~~~I_,~ ~I.)-'-" J)lb!
-
~~
<-A~~~ J.£J-·--
0 00
~
.• ... t\
,,
lHfi U""JlA..>3JJ ~I..H as'~ u~J IJ.4 ot ~ as'~ r, • • • ~ ~ ~
~.>-4) J~ ~I u ~ ~~~I 0 1~1 0 i PricewaterhouseCooopers
,~ ~ ~b <?' 01~1.., . I ~ ' ~ '~~i y ~ '~J.) ~ (L:Jjl..i:i
i.S.»-~'
J~~I u ~ LAi .l:,Jl~i ,1..1.LL...)~ ,;;~I ~ I ,~lfi'..9l ,"1.! , ..q\ ~
l..>--'-"-'.J-'-"J l~J ~LAJ.)J IJ..tl_jAJ ~..>3J ~fi ~_jAJ u4l:JI ~~~~~I
~~I ~ i.S~I .;-s~I ~J . (PricewaterhouseCooopers, 2009, P.10)
- .. .,
~J-4 ~J,, t"\ ~.>11 ~ ~J.) ~ J Transparency International ~..9.J.ll
u\S'~I 0-4 "/."\0 4i: .,,., LA c.:.uki ~ .(Tl, 2009) .)JJlfi~llJ I~ ~J-4 ~
~ l>-4 "/.YV dj.' ... •• LA u .)...(9 "·ill~ . rr •• A r~ 4:J~I ~'~ ~ ~..w<JI
~~ JL;o. ~I~ LA__;~ f1WI ,.sjl.,..,.,.A ~~I~ d.)Ll, <i'3I u\S'~I
u-4 "/."\V 4i: ... ; Lo UJ.)Ji .i9J .(Tl, 2009, p. 13) ~....r4i .)~JJ O •• ' ••• t>-4
-
~bJ.I JL;o.~I ~ ~~J~~I tl~i~iS Ls=il.;->--l.o~ ~)bu\S'~I
.. ,,
~J~~I .J~~I ~ i ~ .(Tl, 2009, p.6) 4i~ylJ 4UI 4i.J.A.o.)~4 ~}tll..9
ul.J=..al ~ ~Lwwill..9 4J~I
r::::::r:m:-.,~-.-~:·-·.-.-.f?·1, ..•-.f2~-·~™:.;:rtPa-!:;.t..~~~~~=ti;,,~~~;;..G.£{~·L-:JJJ::.;~~~.:.::.~
~~l0i~_;,llu-4~J .JL;o,'11~~1~)U~IJ..ulJ~~l~jJ~
4.9~1 r'~ ·.·: 111! «.!iljJ ,~WI ~4-) a.slS' ~ ~ i 0 ~ JL;o,)U ~ I
a_j.J~ I~~ 0~...L°LA ~ ~ I ~ I J~ ~ ~L.w.c '11J o_,1u_;JI LAi • 4Jlc.
" -
'141 J~)U 4WI ~'1._w.l ~ LAi -~1 ~ l&:.Jl .JLJw.l ~.?-~101~4
_,,_.... . . .iJ ~lS:Jl~L.,,,j
~l.J.:•tt1..-c..1..1..1. .Lo. : .~<iw'16.. ~
• ~• J-""- 1.- ..- :•~ '"''°'I~."
. .. .)~ .. J
,. t r l.:r-
-
-~1~1 db ~ . ) - 4 ~ ~ a.;.!•rotl
~ (Tl, 2009) 4J..lll ~Li1wl ~ laJ .)L.u,..iJI Wll ~ wlA~I Jgi 01
l~J ~l>'-""iJ l..l.Ll-"4>J l~J l..>-'-"-'J-'""J ..u~IJ o.J~~J ~..>4>1..UIJ l...1.ilJ_j~
0Uu&jwfJ JLA~I ~ F l «.!.Uj ~ ~~ i.)Wj:S~I wlA~I LAi . L,.lL.ca:iJ
.~lAJ 01..HlJ 0Uu&j~.>3J u~4.)JiJ .lLli:ij Jl_;..-JIJ ub~IJ (.J~LA) LA.).j:'J
- "
•.)~I J ~ ~ ~ ul~I j:Si ~J.JJ ~ I ~ts' ..igJ
st:J'~t ':t>Wal
:~tJI ~ J..ob . k~J;S~I J.ib ~~I Y.JL.o:i 01
-~L..o.1.1 ~ LuL.o:i W.l.)Ji ul.b~I ~ O.)~I wl.......ul.)..ul cJ:i Y.Jla: Lo -
4=ll_,JI u-4 ~~[~I~ ~~I~ ~.>3 ~.)~I wlS'~ lA~.>3 ~I~~~
f ' ~ ~J wo.!;. .~,ill ~L.,,,l ..9l screening ~~I ~l..9i~I J..ol_,.c. Ji
~1..9..ul aS'~ r~'14.A~>LoJ:Si ~l:w f'~ ~I ~L.....ul.J...ul ~L&.OJ ~.J~I ~
.(UMHS News, 2009)
~L!~J.>-L4~i i;I~ <J-l?i ~~ w~.iJ(+-'~I J.,._-u~r'~ -
.o_;.bb t.:.ui ~ 0,--S'J..9 .~WI ~~t ~ a =::s:11 Jt;...)?l «.!iljJ "a.L:u~"
aS'~ tl..b.41 ~~.!.;,; ~JJ o.Jbl ~ ~.J Joseph Hirko fi.J-t:A 4-4J...J..P."" uts'
0~i as-~ u-4 t~ ~J Enron Broadband Section ~_,..JI JL!o..i.U u~l
,, -
~ ~ ...1.41 .Internet Division of Enron(~~!) ¥WI a<., .~,11 ~LA...G.J
,
«LU~J ~->-4 i.)'1J.l ~>lo V ~.) cUA y.\bJ I ~ \ "\ ~ 4 ~ 4-4J_j._?.
Jlb.ill u~l as-~ t~ f'6-'-"j ~ o.ll:}J ~ I t;-7' .~,i.. yjlS:JI ~__v:JI ~
~ u~i as"~ ~~I Jlb.ill u'.!; .~,iJI r-~1 0L! fi~ ~i ...1.41 -~-r-JI
- ,, t
~WI ¥WI jJJ-!:A aS'~ ~J . (Fowler, 2009) ell [J.J LA~ 4fA ~
~..J.) ~4-J ~ I ..1>.i ~ ~~ ~~.) ~...(g Hertz Global Holdings
~..ir.~~~«_.,,_-;,r..,.u-.....,~~,~o,:..x.,;,c,_,..,_,_...~...-,__,........_v_.....,_..-___,_ _._ _,..,.,. -~..-~~-.,..,-~._.o;,.._-e._-.,. ..u:.w:.~::.-J:.~~»~ar:i
tV ~~ ~ ~ 'i~I Lo..9 0...1.>,j faU : ~ ~ I ~ ~l.""4l~ 4J~I
__µ~ as'.>1u ~Y .Integrity Inc ~~1 as'~ ~~l.>:!..ul Jack Zwingli
. (Reuters, 2009c) r r ·, · r~ ~ U"")\:9~ ~JoAA o>& as'.>1u 0,J~ ~
as'~~ ~)LI ~ ~ ~.LJI Brain Kennedy~~ 0--:!LH Loi -
~Ji i:,l ~ ct ;.;!t;J i.LJ->3 ~ ~ i ~ Jefferies & Co i:,J.J-->TJ~~
~ r.J..a3 as-..,_.!JI iJ.A LG~ ~..\.A ~ i ~ . CardioNet as-~ ~ i t=-H
uL..o.;_t:JIJ ~UI Jl.;J~I ~ LGLJ d ~ ~ ~~I <J---'-Y-..ul ~
.(SEC) Securities and Exchange Commission (Armstrong, 2009)
~J,;S .J~J-l i:,~ ~ Steve Frustaglio ~ta..-~, ;.,!; ,11 bS'~ ~ -
J~I ~ Vaughn 0~ ~'i untenderedjobs a.,_jl.l.Jl ~~~ ~Uoy
~I~ o~ J-..u:i c.t:i.J.llJ ~l5 '5.:UI ~yl ~ _,:ijj)j:J 0~4-4 '5~\..:,J.I
- - -- -
iJ.A i:,i ~ I.JAJ ,~~ .J~J.l r, · · · LJ--A Jil ~l..b.c <>='~, r.ig -~~ ~..L....4,11
u~ ~1 o.;b} LG..U ~ ~J ,~.>=JI uL.dla ~U.o ~ 0i y_,lb.ll ~
.(Gombu , 2009)~ r~ f -":".i:\c.t:il5'..)-.J.AJ;. 1~-·
r.J4J-- ~~t\J~~I ~ ~ _,,..
.«~fll ~l.;JI .;tµ...I» jJ~ ~ ~I u ~ I ~ J>T J~ I.JA
~...\Ao~ ~J ,Hazel McCallion 0J,:l\S'..o JJ.:A Cr Y·' • 4~) ~b. ~L:...:i -
~L:.:..o ~ ,_,:ijJ.JY ~I~~~ ~I o ~ I Mississauga l:-J "'!'"!4
~ .Municipal ConflictoflnterestAct ~~I '-:-1.J~ t.?..1itll 0.,.....:,~1
~Ll4,. c-~..ill uL.o'J LUI."__j\:· "
• .<~1<' ·;.·· as' LlJ.L 1 - - 1 -·:t ~ ~L:,J.I - I
~ '.) . '"(t-""'"8"' • • • ~j
0-4 :;~ ~Utl World Class Development ¥WI ~ I lli as'~~ ~..14i
~J~ ~I 0l:> ~ ~ ~l:> ef-..1:i ~J ~..ul ~J-4 ~ J~J ~ I ul..b-yl
y ~~ .J~J:; ~~ '. ~ J ~ I <>:'~I i:,\S'..oh, 0l5 ..1.41
.aS'~I i.ill:i ~
41~~lAi:,~d.£bt!a~~l~JlluJ~J -~lcl.J:i,-, ,.~
.(O'Toole, 2010) "o~~ a~» ~i J~ ,~WI
~)t;. ~I ~1..,_c. ?}4» "-'4---'-"i ~ (Moore et al. 2006) i:,J.J-->iJ .JJ_j-4 ~
--blJ ,,I),~,;·,, ,~:;~I ~ ,0~l~0:.:UI u4~1 ~..u«moral seduction
u4~1 ~...\A ~~I :;~ .)ol:.:..o a:;~ IJ:;~ J.41 •~~I y .J~ ~
.)· ~I
.. ,\-o---1
.... ,,t. ..... 'l.\j uL~I
.
. _a.J.1 u ~ I ":"
~
. _'\ ~
· ~
..
I (>J,Y-
· ..ul ~
- ~.. :~
. .&j
u4~1 ~...\A f;!..l.4iJ ,Jly,-~I ~ i ~ uLJo.i.1.1 ~~ ~ u4~1 ~...\A
~ uLJo.i.1.1 r~J -~~, u 4 ~ ~..D :;~ .)j~ ulA..l>J r~~' o.JA
W..S"<" :;ir:;: a;
Lfj~ 4..La9 ~ Ii~' LoJ Q ~ 1:,u :u~1 ~ ~l-4!,J a..w~,

..wi,;w,-~----- tA
~·L ~ 1· c, c, ~ i· ta l. l. ~· l. i ·,~ c,
~ I ~~ t lf f'~· r f;;trc,tr~-t~ -c-L;~·r. E
°" ~ l r[
l~ ·. ~~-l:
,. n c;.: b .
g ~ ~. ~ - .r; ·t.. \.,. ~
t { .r -c ~ ~i. r(· fl ;. r ~ .c-; i= ~;.~ .. tt };f f.r. .:·~ ·i..,
' -r·(.,£: 1:~ r- :~, .f f ~ r [ ; 1· , 1· ~~ ~ · ;[
1\ 1> I C· b .r
J'- e. '°'
l, - I
I f. ~- l ~ iJ
~ir
(~· ~ t~ ~ '°~
"~ C· ~ t ~ [,
N
,. 'fi 8
t :-- 't:,
r;;
,-
s £
Ci ~ :c- 'I ft! .c- .c· t~ ~ 1-;r ~_,. lJ, ,f, ~ ,c;, ~ l
l, [ '° •L" ~' • L ,E [• ~ I
f t C· [ [• [• !: ~. .-
£. _,. t!~f. f '\! .c- ~ .~ t ~ ~. . ~ ,C- [, C•
•
.Fl <et>' ' _ -~ ' • Cc; ,c E
I,[ I.'f.--t · ~·- ··t
r;; ,. • [ ~· ~· - I;- r [ 'f:. [ - '\ ~ ..-· r f, [ d
,.· ~ °1- . C• • .~
•( C P E:_ (;. C..:.
l~,1~I [,w- ~~fl-' •Ci_.es.. - • ·~· t ,- l '\1 ' . fl: l° 'E. h - ~ ~
;z r ~ ,t' ·f; ,r, ;; 1, - \1 l ~ ~ 1
E f-. . t• { 'i.1 '<i,.. 'i:;
·~ t,, - f>"" C• c, t ~. 'Ii>• G' - 'L ~ C• i.
1:-; _,. ,. ~ I> '. Ci. -~ V\~
l, [ ,,........ [
., 1 .. c E£,
.c- c: E: tr t f..t re· -C•
~ ~1- ~ [ f. ~. ~ .E t ·~. !t I•
l, I I)
1' ~ c.' 't.#l-' [ - 0~ : C· ~ ~f. •[C-
't [. ·~ <j, { (: ti '<i,.. I,
[ ~ ·L .r 't!, r- ~ . c o - ~- ~
• - i-,· t .r ~- Et - ~ 1! ~ ·t.· • "· <\.
C· f:!
~ '~. r;; 1·•
a,• b & I - l,
t 1~ l·l ~ l b~ %', 1· ~ [ ~ t' <j, ~ ~ ([!' 1( :f. t J •Ci.
~• fl_· V ,t.' •f. ,~·t' , l lC t~ b ~'l ~: f. ~ ~ ~ V: l! '°, [ ~.
C· r; l~ Ci-: , ·· - c
!.., C- Lr
1t r 1 [' Jf"' i . . ~· L ~ [!: C·
- i ! !t- { - -:- [ b - .,,
E ~ ~ '\ ~ 1 t f 1.: f \ f. 1 c-.f _.~. t
·~. I r
. D l,' ~
l 5· l 1 ~ l } <is- \~ t 1; .r t i' (• 1. i [, f l.t: G, (• t'
r J. - .[T ·~. ~ F>"" ~,.~ - ~ ~
~ ~ ~ Q <r- f>"" ~ G' ~.. C•
rr ·~ t f' [ '°.~ 1. ~ f l ~ [, i. ~· ~
\D 1
I ~.f . - E
~ ,. .~ ~ ~ L I tr I!. ~
- - - f . t ft r~, 1 t ~bfc..1
t7
r- o br £ - 3 Ci"
'°- a fr: 1• [, ~· - ,f f- ~ ~ 1> ~· ~. t C· 1 ~
~ II i.· -.;;.. it C • C: C.. ~ t~ l ~ Ci f;, ·,, & - ~ ~ {
r-
·t s.:en ~~ ("'• ,(;~· ·~I:; "'Ort ~ '-'f,. ~..~• iC·
- I -Cl'J -- I p J:. .[" !~ i. :~; t ( t· .E' ~ rt 1· }~ ~ t
~l.;_,l u.i:~ _w ~ ~IJ J~~I l:~ l~i ~~I uU~I o:JJ ~ I
. (Canadian Press. St Lawrence)
l_;+:u , o ~ retroactive drug ~>Lll _,..j9\..a..Jl .;~I ~ ~l:.; ~ ~ -
J.JL ~ ~ c.ill~ ulS' ~ Beijing Olympics ~ yWt ~ ~ . ; ~ 0-4
~ '~Jl ~I~~ ~WI J.>.i ~~,~~I u4,l.;JJI ~I.; 0---4
'l.:.U ·r". •A rlc. ~ i..S.»-i ~Ll.4 ~ CERA ~b~I j.l_j.A:i ~ .;~I j~I
~J~I ~l~0---4~l ...u~J~.;~0-4~l:_;a ·uq>ulA~~
. (Roadcyling.com, 2010; Wikipedia, 2010)
<i'1' ~ I ~J~I yW~I ~~Lal~ ~lyl ~l:.;JI 0-4 u_,:i)G ~ -
.~la..Jl.;~lj~l~~~(February,12-28)~~~~..\A~u~
,Mark McGwrire..>:l.?.Ac.!l.;lAuic··/; 'f" Y ·' • rlc..>:~..>+=uu-4~<.:?JWI ~-
~.}A~ J~ ~I~~ home run ;;~I '?"4.; ~ ~~I ~yl ~ ":?.:.UI
~ ~ c.ill~ ulS' .steroids ...u.J.H-'·'"b .:.,in ~L.:i .ig 'f"' C\C\A r u ..\.....>IJ
~ ~4- ?JI ~.;J US Congress ~~'ii <>"~~I rlAl ct:iJ~ 0-4 ulJ-U-"
. (Heakes, 2010) ~La..JI r ' ~ ' J_p, J ~ Jlj.u,
ul~I..J..t.JI J ~ Caster Semenya ~ ~ l S ' ~~i y~I ;;~1...u-11 uj~ -
~ aJJi ~~ r.JL 0-4 ~->11 ~J .;;i..>-41 rt~.; Li,t 0 ~1 ~ ~ f1 uS]J
·r" ·' • rl..:. ~ as".;L!J4 ;;i..>-41 ~ ~ ~ t.t:,i 'il c.ill~
J.,~u-4~'i~) uic·«/i .ill .lawn bowling~~! ~~d,:~co9u~-
~i aJ~ ~ match-fixing ;;1_;4,ll a~~ JLi:i'il ~~ 0¥.~ I.JlL_j~
~ ;;1_;4,A ~ ;;_;~I ~.J.4LJ Asia-Pacific Championship ":?J~I ~ I J
.(Associated Press, 2010) ~ i ~llA ~ J.,..J-4ll ~ <,.:)1 ,.,sJi w 4b
~
ulS' ":?.:.UI ,Tim Donaghy ~WJJ ~ rl..>--'-" Jlloi 'f" Y• • C\ rlc. ~__,:, ~ ~ -
c.ill~J ,National Basketball Association ~I;;~ ~_,JI ~lyl ~ ~
u-AI.; J.4l ._;UJ cq~~l J~I ~I~~ ~I~ -l_;+:u H' ~~ - ~
~'-8lJI ~ r.igJ ~j.l.n ~~ Jl_jA~I rJ?:i rlJ ~ cdlA0-4~i ~ ~WJJ I
.~,~~ulA~
~ Richard Pound ~J4 J_;~_.; ":?~I FJi r"·' • rl..:.->=~~ ~ -
JL..will i:,~ ~ cGl International Olympic Committee ~JJ..11 ~J~I ~ I
,._.~.,,,.,..-,-... ~-~.l.l';U.?~,_,,,..,.-,,,....,_flf_....~-~U:a....-.za...//1163..:r..Lt,,~.J'lrl'.:a,~~"'W'.A~W'"-~-----·--~~~~
~~Lla!~'i?~ll.ojQ~faLl :u~l~~~lj4.J~I O•
u ~ I ~ ~l.w.il!J 4.4.J~I
L~~~~~~~~;:;:;~~~~'.'+·-~=:-~;...~~~~~.idi=~
rW ~ I ~~I yW~I ~ .~..>:JI rl:!) ~.!.!;;; J4c,.A ~ aK ,~,o JI~ LA

c.:.,LA)k ~J.>11 ~..>:JI ~lti ~~ ~ l : ! ~ LA~ a,..!,;.,a c.:.,lH ,rr· ·r
i.,-111.Pi w ~L..b;.i ~i 0J~ ~..>:JI ~i ~.J.....11 ~~I ~LtJI ~ ~~ ~~
~ I ~WI c.:.,_;si ..w .~.:UI ~1..1.:ll w,k J ~ I LJA ~...Lis:11 wLA..»-
(y:. L.a>-'1 ~I_;; LJA ~.;JI~ '->"J.>11 ~~Jo~,- •• ,;.,;,~~~~~
~ 4 ,- •• ,;.,;, ~WI 0i i.,-11 ~>LIi c.:.,1;;.!;;?-~I c.:.,.bji ~J -~~I I.L..4,
. (Associated Press, 2012) ~~ ~l:i ~ j 41..l:!-4 ~ ~ ~ Jo~
r~.;: qi: , .. ~~Renault Formula One u, )4.o.J~ J-L-l-.J» J---,..;Jl ~~ -
,, -
~6.. ~ 1..1.......4.C. .:U.)~ r~ 0i .)~..?. CA.J_fi4 0 ~ w----o ~ r r .. °'
~_iJ'li J...G~..>-9 ~jjj-Q: 0i ~i LJA ~L.JI ol:?- .)..1.8:! ~~ ~J '-:?iiq , ..1
Singapore Grand Prix I.)~~ LG~I o~4,JI J ~ Fernando Alonso
. (Formula 1, 2009) r r · · A r~
w ~~ ofill Thierry Henry~~~~ ~~I r..wl ofi ~~ ~'1 ~ -
~ ~~c.:.,jl.9~~Wlu.uls:lllij.l.lc.:.,~l~j~I~~~·.·: ,ce;
. ~..;Jll Y ~ [~lA..?. d..i:J.A ~ r"·, · r~ ~w1 '->"~ l..lll..Hlr...w:i:J
~~~l~ '.Jc.:.,l_;J. ~.)~UJ:!~~~~ ~I ~J.:.7= ,.,; ~J
i ·t ~\S'.":?""""~~
~ · · L- ti·u WI J)L;..,'"(t-:' ~ \ -t ~J cl.......o..JWL.
Ar~ •• ol.).
i .~
t J-J
A.~ - ...
LA -r~l l&b)4 '1 ~ I c.:.,WW4 ~I~ 'll 0~fi: ~1=.;JI c.:.,\.lo~I

ljl ~ ~ i ,~1=.;JI ~lb~ c.:.,l:?I~ ~ y~I i.,-11 ~ <i°'11 aJL.u,_;JI ~
l'.' •• ..:.ti t.!Jo
'l.).:t""""'
t -
IC II I,-.,-, .-,C
- •••
r.is
c.:.,\ ;;.!;;?-.:JJ ~.)Ji ofi ~ '1 r • • Y.J~ LA Fr r • • C\ r~
~_iJ ~ ~ -
r
0::t.JJ.l. lJ ~ IJ ~>LI I 0 ~ .)~ I ,.!H.lA> 0\S' •LG~ i wI.ll;! a;,wJ 1..)-'-"-J..J-'-" ~
L&JI.JA i ~ ~ d..:!-41~1 ~~ a.b-,I~ ~~.) ~ .is LJ:J-.J I.)'°!I w-:JJj..uJ. IJ
~~~~~~I ~i ~ .c.:.,~~I ~bj ~ c.:.,~l.;J.I ~
.(BBC News, 2009c) l..>-'-"-'..J-'-" ~ ~ J ~Ul
LG.li ~.:UI ~ljlfi J.A6.. 0i ~ ~l.u.o ahl ~llA -~4-uJI ~~ ~I jAl:u.l

'
c.:.,4~'11,,J..>..u,nc.:.,l~~o~rr••C\~_iJ~~~.J"=.J~JJl~I
~J -{o~.;JIJ ..l:~IJ tl..~'11 ~.)~ ~~4) J~'ll ~ 45'.)LlJ.I ~_>1o (y:.
~Ll.A wi ~ o.JJ.ill c.:.,4~'11 (y:. JJ~IJ ~ I ""°:..1..&.0 Jl~I <.#.J ~ljlfi
~ ~ c.:.,l_ig ls:!JJ <i"11 ~ ~ JJ.l ,-.b; ,:, ~ .a.o.)l:! o.)L...c.1 c.:.,~~I
o, ... · ~~~~~~IL4Jo~faU :u'4Y,iil~~~!J~~I

"~ ~_;.o ~~ ~1 "pt w .)~, i>A J=14ill ~ <5IJlfi ~ 0 ~ w t
~ ~ c.illjJ ~~, ~\l~t., ~Lib. 0-4 ~ ~ ~ ~ t~ ~ yll.b.ll --
~ ~ ~l.)lfi 0~ ljl LA~.! «,. ci_,JI_, . (Farmer, 2009) r r · · '\ r~ ~_,.l
• .)~I 0-4 ~~~~~I..!~ a.JJ.) ~ .)~, ~~6. ~~
(Mazar,Amir, andAriely, 2008)~..JtJ..>:AiJJIJLAfij 5~~.;-:i;.~~\11 ljU

0 ~ ~ t ~ r s ,11.;·,t~1_µ .)1~\11~~~.;Jl~(lj~~~~
~~~, 0t ~1 ~ J ~ t ...1.4l .~lj..ill r~ ~,.)_,~UA c.!ll.lA0t ~1,~1j..il4
c.;-- '°"'..,..-.-., 1· •~I.A•'
, ....... ,,t •. -~ t :.('-: d,,, ••
c.ill j •'•Ia :. •
<.;--
•
~J-l ~
•L
• ~ . ,_. I..._4
~ ~~
- • L .• ;..4\l.c:tll I"· .t )G.. ·
••t LY La~• ~;.('-: ~

(.) . v -
~ f_. • • •
---+'
l..:i..&.A
..i.a.,
(.)j-A -
U~f+' ~f+'. ~ ~ J - l ~U~~J~ •

A I• • •
•f+'-~~- j-J~J - Ll)l;.~I

- J-td WI v-
1 ... 6u_.. .
1.-S~I J-'b r~>Ll ~ I ~J .~l....o4'JIJ U"')...ul ~ ~ J ~ I c.!lllA
~I 1010;..::JI y)\.b ~.;:o'l ~l....o4,JI ~ 0 ~ J~~I o.Jbl uo·o;..J y)\.b 0l
~.;JI ~J ~J . (McCabe, Trevino, and Butterfield, 2001) I.S..» ~I a.! "'.!~.;JI
· 0 ~ l_,Jl.)LA~ l..,..to 0t ~1 ~)l;.l~ ~ I 0~y)l.bll ~ i .)~I LJ-A
"~~.) 0~ yllbll ~,.)~ J-'b yllbll ~ ~jj 4J)l;. ~ ~ JA~ ~ i 01
~ I c.!l_,1- ~1 ~ , l.:U . (McCabe, Trevino, and Butterfield, 2002) 0 ~
~ ~ ~1 U"')...u.l ~ uLiJI J ~ 0i ~..,..t.l oA 0~ ~ I ~~J . ~ 4_.j~
~l.,µ\l 4,WI J'JI 0i J-'b ~ ~.:s.JI 01 • (Nonis and Swift, 2001) ~ I J ~
~ 0.->=4 ~~ .;:ot.,~t ~~~., .)'~~' 4,J LJS' J~~ o~I a.!,o;. ,~,n.,
.JLAJ o.;+!,J r~J O.H-4 ~,.)J ~ ' ~i ~~~GA ~_,.l\l ~ .,t ¥)l;.i
~ ~l..b.-.u_,_, y>lbJ o.:UL-.ut i>A ~ ~ c.:,k. ~ r".' . r~ ~,~ ~

I.SJLliJ o.)~ ~ . ) ~ I ~ .)~~I~~ Zagreb University y~I.) d..t.44',
,~.) y)l.bll 0t. ;, ~ y)l.bll r ~ 0 ~
1~1~<1 ...1.4l .Jui J:''-4A ~1.)1.+o, ~,
r~ ~_;:; ~' ~1~~, ~ J ~ I ~t ~ JJ~ ~i ~1 ~ LA o.:UL..u)U
.(SETimes.com, 2010)
i ~~!g 4.t~t ":'~i

~ J ~tuJ .)Luui.JIJ 4,~I ~ o.)~ ~I.?.~ ~ I ~1 Jlajj~\ ~
. .)~IJ 4.s~I y'-t,u,i ~ ~ t:,~.), ~ 4:>ll.;JI _,t ~~
oy
u ~ I ~ J~!, 4.4.J~I
j·,L•" \t ,, ..;-. .. ,)'(Av- ... ,·-~· - ..:~·~:: :);-.. i"'tfr- .-·_ .... y·..fu.:,J:-.,'.. -T , ...... •• 2- .. ··rfr:& > h ··H··~::·&1< ·-·(:~·z.,. ,.·hfo r·+P ·§n,t~ +aa:·/·
1 ·.).-v-i .. :i; ·.~.. ·-:-~.,; .r:, .. ~- ·:-·--.) .. ····:·/HP·-M-"i&-7194 <W&r,·ws;J
a4 ..1111;, itt c..ul~

A--tt - \ .
-
.~)l;.~' ~'.)..)~, .;.,b:Jl -
- ..
•~lit.I -
.~l-
Y·~~l-
.~_,JI ~ ;;~l -
.~_,JI ~~.;JI -
a4:!llS..JI ~1.J,,?JI - Y
·(~i Ji pj) t__,lll -

.~1-
· ~ I 15_,1uJ.I -
a{.J.uWttUl:a0~~\tt'4J«aortu~
• I t ~
~~y
M
A - I .~ -
.~l~I~-
. j-:J:.b.JI a..J~I
-
-
. y.; lIJ I .;I .J..a.A -
·~~~, t4?JI -
·.)J~ ~jJI 15...u.l -
.~WI J)l;.~1 ;;_;s -
----"""""'"'-~·-
or .....~--....---·---
l.fj~ ~ ~ ~.:.Lll l.o..9 l.!I~ fall : u ~ I ~ ~L.w..il~ 4-4..J~I
.......~-~
'""'v·:.,:.. :.·jl
s{~-"-"'Wt ~~~t) dt _s.~rla.S:J't 1' ;.! .J't u~

.~)lj..~I tl.UI ,~w~I -
-~J.LJI ~)lj..~I tl.UI -
. ¥)1j.. ~I ~~I -
. <.!l_,kJ I a.;JJ.A -
• a.;J..U' .:, .: .; ji -
antecedents ~~I j.Al.,_.JI "~ 0-4 J-1:& <.J.::' ~)WI ~-.1: Lo 0~4JI ~J
<.!l~ 0 t IJ~J u.!.l..J~ ~1 ~~1 . ¥)1j.. ~I ,.::A#.jL.uJIJ ¥)1j.. ~I l: 1_,.a I LJ:--!J
~ .(~LuJI 6>Gll ~~~I ~\S' ~)~)lj..~l~J~)U ~~J.)~
'* - -
• •.~<ti~';..
(.)A~ •
t_. L L - •
~ ~(.)A
~..1.,LJT
• - J -
Lll.alJ~.L. I -la•tL,~ I ••~
~u--yw u----
LI ~tt ~ ~ll~ 1 .L, ~ '- ·ti cd....J a.lALlJI .-LU..&\..o.1.1 Lot • ~ I - .< :.~q
-:J"*" l::4 - ~...;--~ -· ,..-- J~
&
f"~ J,1b ~...ul_k ~J .ib..wl ~)lj..~I tl.UI ~, Q.:.:ai.' a.;JUA ,¥)1j..~I~

<.!l~ ~J ¥)1j..~I ~ ~l_,.alJ code of ethic <.!l_j-L.uJI J~ <.J.::' ~~ .)_?.J
cl.ti 0-4 ~ u'S11 JAL:ul ·¥)1j..~I ~ l:l_,.alJ <.!l_j-L.uJI a.;JJ.A ~ <.J.::' ~~
.~t ~ ~L.iJI j.Al.,_.JI
i~~ 'it Jtj.aj~~ 4 _1.S~'it 4 _c.QJ-Jt

•(>J.J>-
· · '}}La.;
• ~ UALl)lj..i-:.
- ~~ - L. ~~I ~
· ~~ -u· ~ ~
- .<f ~~~11..!l~
~~<.!l~ul ~J .J.41 5u~>l,;..~I .)\~~I ~~I ¥)1j..~I ~~I~ Lo
WJ ¥)t.;.~I ~Li.JI 0-4 ~1_;1~1 :'.l~4 Jo~JI ~ u,J..;ai .,,4 ~.)~ ~~I
.~>l,;..~I Jlj..Li~IJ ¥)1j..~I ~I~~
u,e. c-..uJI J>.l_;J.I ~ ~ 0-4 ~ J (Kohlberg, 1984) [J~~ r~i

.Ll)lj..~I d...w.ZJI ~ ..1.,\ ·-
- - - _i_J-J
.obedience and punishment orientation ~~IJ a.db.JI~ ~j&JI :~i~ll a.6._;J.1-

.~l~I Ji ~l~I tJA ~~ l.dJ I~~ 0i ~ ~l_,JI 0-4 0l.:t .ll~~I 0-4~
.)\~)LI ~ • individualism and exchange ~.)\.;JIJ ~.)~I :~l:JI ab.._;J.I -
.~L;JI ~~ c..:,k ~~ ~ lS]J ~
-~-c.,;;,wr-.--..:....~~-y~~,_~.o,t;~~--,;,...-~~-----
r:;n-r:'<.'""1...W·-,.._..'l;..~ •......_..J"S.&.-'1&"1...--.,,•
~~ ~~~~I Lo..9 Q..l>,j faU : u ~ I ~ J~~ "4.1~1 ot

u\.o.L:a.al ~ Jl.w...i.t!_g '-4.J~I
~~~:-!:~:7'.~;-:-.·i-t,~·<··,;.~-~~::~~~~97:~-M·.· ··t~:J!..ii.t~..~~~,r7rr-~:s.~:2..:.?x·ra;:.:..~~3Y.2u.~~::t..1.!"~
.good interpersonal relationships o~I a.!«o~I u~>WI :a:Jl:JI a.b...;-11 -

-~b~Lli..o_, O..)-:?- t91.,.) &J 1...9~1 A~~I ~
.maintaining the social order ~~~I r~I ~ ~WI :~\._;JI a.b...;J.1-
r~I ~ ~6:..JJ ~~I ul bl rnJIJ ~IJ-0,ll ~ J .)l~~I ._g~
-~~~,
.social contract and individual rights.)~IJ~.,~~"il~I :d.....""4\..;.~.lla.6...,..11-
~l~~..ulul~l.?.-?Jl~_,~L.uiJ~~~..>:~~0~ .)l~~lo-43:!
.... ~-ti . .. . ·,.~ti ... .:.~t
c-;- ~ J O : > ~ ~
~.)4,A A~~I ~ . universal principles L:,J.WI ~.)l+J.I :a......ui.)WI a.b....,..11 -
- ( ~ aJl.ull Jl:al ~ ~ ) d..:l~
.>l_;J)~l u~ ui ~.;-11 o-4 . l-LA L.)w,., ~l.;JI ~..,..11 ~.)~LAO.)~
~ ~.;Lli..o Jsi a......ui.)WI_, ~\.;.JI~.;-11 ~ ~~I ~I~ 0J.>.)WI
·¥)\.;..~l~ul;.6'~1
l;9)l;.. i 0.,_J~ LA~ a__;g)l;.. i ~ ul.;I~ .)l_;J) ~I ~ u i ~ I <J---A
~j.JIJ ~lj.JI u~~I o-4 .)~I ~)l;.. ~I Jl_j-Lj~I ~ . (Bandura, 1986)
.)~ ~ . ~ IjJ I ¥)\.;..~I ~.>;.I: w '-4ll=d. I &.!J..,.L-.uJ I ~ ~.) L.:;J.1 L:-'-.,. CO.! ~j.J I
ui.bl..:JI ~ ~)l;.. ~I Jlj-Ll>lt a!;.I...LlA u~i ~W (Bandura, 1986) l.;J...G4
,.s...u 0~ .)~"ii ~l ~lj5..>-4 d..L.o_;-SJ ,l.!.L:wl ~ . , ¥~~I ~1.,~1 c4
-~I.:>- ~~,~~I~~ o ~ .)l_;Jl~I
lJWt ~--
:~tJI ~JA'b
~ ~j.!ciii ..>:...U. ~.>A ~i Stephen Schwarzman uLA.).;I~ ~ ~ I . ; ~ -
~ ~...)Ai .;"iJ.> 0~ V• r ~ d 11,0iJ ~,.) .)~ ~j.JI ~J ,o~I ul:"i_,JI
.,.;1.J.aA~I..H Larry Ellison u ~ l ~.;~ ~l:Jl..;5.;-11 ~ ~ J ·r"· ·Ar~
rlsJI r..u. <J---A ~..;JI ~ . (Reuters, 2009d) ~.JA i.;"iJ.) 0 ~ oo"\ , '\
~ -
t9..D <?JI ci Q._;. ,;.,JI 4UI t-ll+J.l u ~ ~ i ~1 Jdg ~ ~~ u~u uLA.).;1~
~i ~i~~~i~u~ll.!.l.;Lli: ~ i - ~ ~ I ulS'~I ~..>:...u.
.«..J-:!AL!J.IJ ~~~I)) ol:>- Jo~i ~ l~J ~WI~ u~I
~ ~ ~ ~ S o ' , ! l ; Y , ,..................._ , _....~.ic'llll7!n-~~ ... lM,·_,.,,.IN~~•.t~•"l'..-.\!'':l'l.:~..A,~~,l[---'\~.~""""•W,C,,."\.-1"~~.-.-M~....'9!1,VCU~.'l:l•.•,~-<IN'A•-"'-"'4">-·,U,,t.~~."J'Wl('l,•,........'l,(~~0X.-.~
00 ~~ 4.ld ~ ($o:LJI Loj o..b.l l~U : u ~ I ~ Jl.w...i.t!_g 42~1

J.i~I J.wwl
,J
t.j.>JY.,, ,bbv o.;bH ~ ~ t.jLll Bernard Madoff ~_,.)Lo .l.J~..H Loi -

~~ ~ lS.:UI_, ~1_;'}1_,.J...JI ~~ 01..w ~1 ~pt lS.:UI lS~bJI <«Ponzi
~
.. - - ..
~ J ~IJ-A.?.AJ 4.;liJ ~_;Ll3 Jjll.o a=i)\:i ~~I~ LA~ , o • ;;.J.1.
--
,t"· .:.._(' • _._ __ m~ •. t- ... lt~)w_ • '--- I(' • • ... t .('t .·.-':t\a..Jo.Al.,
~~~~ ~ ()A~~~~~~., u-- .
o.;Ll3 JjLlAJ ~->-°t _;'}TJJ ~)4 v c:.,..o_;s-t ~ t.j.:UI Jeffery Picower .;J~
~ i.SJ# ~~ ~ l_,b>. ~~ ~'}TY. ~JJ 0-J~J ~ f14J c:,J~LA ~
~~1 ~ t.j.:UI Picower .JJ~ LAi ·t.jJ-Abll ~JJLA ,bb:u 0-4 ~J~I ~,~,
~
...
I'!.· ·t r.1.
~y'
cl.4_; _),J ·J\'-"4't 0-4 t: --II 111J " ~
~..J,J
.ti
LA
·- 1... J - SCI cl.A..,.._......
c.,,--Qft I
- ..<~ti WI-!L
0-J~IJ V"-41..;JI ~ ,..1>-~I r~ l...u__;fo 4:'}IY. dJj-LA ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~Lljj
0t «·,t,., ~ 4 ~->-°-' ~ ~ a.Jb. ~ 0lS' ~ ·rr· ·'\ r~ '..H~i c:.,..o
~ t.j.:UI .;J..u4 ~I~ ~J .(Efrati, 2009) ~J,C, b.)6. ~ts' cuU3..9
.caU3_, ~ 4-4.lWI ~~WI_, J~'.)14 ~LA~'.)11
,J
rY ·' • r~~~~ ~ Earl Jones .>J~ j.l~l t.j~I ~UI _ ; ~ I ~ ~ -

.>J.P.'" ~ . t.j.JJS _;'}IJ.l 0~ O • "~)w. ulS' t.j.:U I t.jJA bl I.>J~ ,b b v ;;_; bh,
~~1 ~~~I a5~1 c:.,..o 4LA ~W.l o.;J-&-O ~ ~)Lo a=i)\:i y_;~ LA~
~ J ,i5~i ~~J dJLibi <.>".JI...U. ~~ t.j~ J'}TJ.l O'\'r, • • • ~ ~l
~l lSJJS J '}IJ.l t '\V , • • • ~ J..? ~ ~114---u ~ I ~ lSJJS _;'}IJ.l '1 '\ , · · ·
- ,J -
v • , • • • ~ ~ i ~J.JJ .>J.P.'" 0 i fi~ ~ . (Canadian Press, 2009b) b '-"4.JY.

~LA LAl -rl....bll ~4Y.J ;;~Lb.l4 ~ ~4:fi.;J ~ ~ ~ t.j.JJS _;'}TJ.)
~ ~JJ0-4 ~~1~1~1~ l:Jb.~~I MaxineJones_j-j.P.'"
~., r~ ~ ~~, ~~ ~ ~iJ ~ts'~, ~1_;'}1_,JJ1 c:.,..o ~'}1511 ~~
Jl'-"4~1 ~J~ ~ ~..>9 ~ ~:·0.:,11 t.j.:UI .>J.P.'"~ JL-.-J f1 J~ ~
~Ll:t ~Ll3j ~~ ~ J~~ JUI rl..1;.; ,,,I~ .J-..a.l .(CBC News, 2009b)
6)\:i_, ~)b. ~ll.o ~,~ ~l1iJ ~.J-LA 6l:ii_, ~ ~,..b.J 6)\:i ~,~., ~Jj.ll
-
,;
Royal Montreal Golf ClubJ~~ul~~I t.jJWl~~_,~I.;'-:!-,

.Boca Raton Resort Club wiJI.; lS'Y. ~ t.j.l~J
~ ~ ~->-°i ~ b J-'bJ ,Scott Rothstein ~ ~ J . J ~ls:...-.,, ~.)i LA~ -
r r • • C\ r~ ~~ ~ ~ t.jJ-Ab.ll Ponzi t.j.>JY. •b b :u ;;.; bh, , I...u__;fo 4-...:.'}I.,
c.:rAJ) ~ 1 U3 o_;'-:!-, 0-J~ i.ill~ ~ .ca~ o_;.)~ 0~.)6.:i'}ll ~~1 rli
_;_,~ 0 ~ '=;il~..Y. o_;~J v.su.JvJ.J c;;.;~J t.jl~ ~11 '-:!-- 6)C; ~
O'\
i:,L.Ja.at ~ .:.L.w..cal~ a.w~t
@¥ff&i$0& f\tW~¥%M--&4iM¥%XM?#A\S-t-iffl~if¥&fi&YJRi%W:r:t8Wift§#f41#tP&#@&ii¥@Wi?Wh&iliNi4%M#Mt¥MAf@f&~f?i&J
1
~~~c.:,:A.Jl)u~lo,.o~a ,,c;J(~..JAt.;~J.)w~~
- # -
~Lui~~~ \S'_J,4-o wlS' South Beach ~~I ~~I Ub.i..o ~ ~

4.J_,.b &- Warrent ~.;IJ t~ o,.o ~ ~J) ~ y .;!jg a=i)\:;J (Gianni Versace
4.J_,.b~y.;llJAquariva "4J_.;lfil t~&.o.;b.ol \ • 4.J_,.b~~iJ n µ
.(Zand, 2010) ~JM ~.;~ ~ ~lyslJ ,(Sea Ray 'iJ ~ t~ o,.o ~ \V
- ~ ~~ ~ c ~ I c.ill:i JS'
'iJ-Ab.JI Ponzi 'i.>J.J-! ,bb'"C4 ~ wfi.;~ ~:.u,
~~\'1 wt ~1 a.bl~ -
J~~I t~ .(LeBor, 2009) ~ta~i o,.o i_,c..)J r_l~I ~ ~U:t ~~ w~
~:.UI ~ta~\'1 o,.o ~ .)~ ,~ta~\'1 D::t J~I ~J ,affinity fraud ~lj&JI
.as'.;~ ~ta~t i_,c..) ~JUI~ I ~
-
cl.;.,_,~ ~~J ~ L..lys ot ~Jr"· ·I\ r~ '41~~ o,.o o-t~IJ ~ c.1~, -
~IJ ~y,:.~ ~~J ~ u..lA ul:~ ~L.uj.; a=i)t:; ~~I~ ,~y,:.~J
~.,.LI o,.o cl_~J .)_,a: clA~b. a , ·u.J ~~_,JI~ ~fi.:,,JI yl_,lll o,.o
~fi.:,,Jl~.,.J.IJ~ul~~.)lcll.i.A .Jl.j,A\'l~J.)~l~~fi.:,,JI
uwJ~lJ ~_.;Lla.A ~ J ~ I ~ ~~~ ~UA i.,-t_.;_,.b.l.1 o,.o 'iJ~yl ~
~1.). ,.., 1 ~1 ~J ~ Jl-"'°\'I ~ J-AbJI ,jj.ol .iaJ .~ J~ \'I ~~J ~Jl
. (Temple-Reston, 2009)
lt - #
.'='4.!t;,;;tl .)~IJ'i.)~I .)~lo,.oaJiG~lc.ill:i<J:! \S'~ ~ t a ~ I ~
.)l~\'I ~ wi ~,JUI~ ,-.14; ,~,I c~WI o,.o ~ I ~WI wi ~~ ~
;;~~ ~ 4:,llA ~UA ~ J ~ I ~J+.I wlS' .)~I ~ as'.;LlJI u~IJ
.;;~~~Jt
Wall Street ~UI Jl.;J\'1 J ~ 4UI c~j.JJ ;;..>:P"'\'1 cl.;~~, ~J--J
uls·b.
!) •
~ -"t · ..u ~
~ ,,,-i.P"
· ~ - I (),J~
· .J.1.1 ,.,...
.• "ts::; c.r .•~,, ~ \ ' LI·
~,, c ~~ -~
i.S:.UI Jeffrey Immelt ~T I.S~ ~~ .(Cohan, 2009; Tett,2009) a.....lo.>4-4
- .-
4.J ylb ~ General Electric cl..,.:;s:Jl J ~ as'..,...1iJ -l:j.:.;;; *~ . ; -l:Jb. ~
~WestPoint(«·,~ Cc......uuJ) ;;~I ul:~.,.U ~< ,uetl ~.)\S'\'I y}lb rlAl
~>>j « ~ I LA.;l.....u.A ~ u'isl<.ll ~~, .J..4l» r 't' • • \ r~.) .n.4 c ".!.) 0,.0 t"-""t.JI
a,.,· al ~ ~J . (lmmelt, 2009, p.6) «~IJ i~w..u4 .;~I J.a.all J l ~ I

~~a: '";! u.)lj .;.?.\'I wi ~ Statistics Canada ~~I cl~~f'I
ov
f;! ~ <i.. ~, t:d '~. ~1· i::-" ~ 1· ~ ~ ~ t C). bl t' ·~.. ~1.:
-< t.. ·~ [ • C• X ~{
£.'~t [·~· (""" ~ f,: ~ ,~ ,r e_. • I f ~ ~ ~
,t" M V J:. rt C· ..~ ~ ~: I ;o., t ~ f;, i I - C: J;!. ti;!; :, El
t =-- ' £ [, ,r.-[, ~.•[ - "'· [, r }; r ,t t
r-11 ·t I!
t ~ ~ ~ f - ~ i ~· f· f c~. ~ :- :"k c;. c, .f ~ 'Ii,· ·i,..• ·i,.. :: I
.ce g: b r. ';: s ~· 1, ~ ~ 1 r. 1 i ~ ·~· rt ~ b f-, C· I! .~ 1::
~ ~ §; ·~ t g V\ t· ~ ,t .e rt ~ b ..~ b ~ c... V\ '!.... ~ 'fu· ~
:(.i I r. r-
:f" r, ~i·i.
\j ge, \ ·1·}·:•:···
£°i ~ r- ~f- ~O \i. -

~[ i= .¥~· t.Y.. 1!f iifi\ ·t~ 1·~ 1·· cC: ~t"" b ·f L~· tr 1,n..E f-;;:- ~·[ <e.V\ c...f ,
b.! I:,- '; - C· N . 1
C•· i ~ ,t,· ;, _,. ~ ~ t· . ,fl-• : ~
t ~. C·~
,L _,.. [, ~. ~· fr.' -.C .:.-·.
0 1 Ii>' [• 1\ - [r ~ I V\ 0 •E" ~c c...I . ;,' C I
tI ·i,..' F '& t ~ 1>- . . .,(i,.· [p, I r;.' t!L' Ii b t } l r. X. g . ~ t ;l

~ '· i L
~ 0
~ <i;- ~[,- • ~. IA - ·~ . ; r.1- 1 f I, - •~ ' Cf.) t..
b
1 !· - t 1-' [
f' t: t ,-._ ~.. [1 • .._,
F> -:" ~ 1 ~ _,. ·t I ~
[., J· ~ ;:. t ·~ 1 ;: :I "P ;. r _: C, :-- L~ ir: - -:- c.. _: · g. ~ I!
fl°_
'\i bf .t' 1:- [ C Ci ~· <i.' - (j ,._ I,~
t ~ ·~ r.~· cr ~ :f ~~ 1 f· .;- .~ i1 ~ t t~ ; lt' t- t- i ~ i~ 1~ &.t .._,1, ~· ~ y '.• ·;
E;-
[ - I• ~II ~' }e" f'• b.! I:. I I:. }; i:-, ~" (_,• •.'·.~
~· tt~ · r 1. 1~ [. g.~ ·re -;-~ l: t::~ ~" £:r ~E: i~ --;;-J I 1:~ .t~ ~- . · t· t· ~[ i e. t;,
"° ~ a- it. , .. - , . e; . g - . -:
- •G:_ c;! ~. I, • ·~. i - ·.'·····.'···.!
IJ>I r;; I, C) C· ~· ...... 1(; 'i

r-· J!. •
i' e f"' 2: ! t..l b -- C· ::s ~. ~ ~ ~ e. i F>
1
t C·
-~ 1
11! (i _
t ~~~ 1
C•
·t I. .e-· G.~ ~ ~~ ~~. 1~ \. ~
• ~ OCI '
I ...
C !- -
11'
- ' ,. ,
[r
, , \ 't,
V\
0 1 ls>·
I>
_,. I C ~ ~ ,._ DC.. Er r[! 1(; I I C f ~• bl
I:. ._.,
A rIJ>• -( '/.·.;•.·
l-I
·
tt;' ~ ry.:
- 1
't ·t a(') i •f' f· - r· ( ~ ~ ::r .b'
~ 1f f i" ~ · , ~.. 11 ,C- { ,L ls>· , ' ·c, C· • '";:"' " :t: •
I ;
T. ·~ ~ ~ £. [· 'E. •f s·
[ t f.._ , I:. ,
C\ .[
~ !~ I - ~ • :·
... • ,.. ,-,
:t cf t ~ ·f 'e°: ~ f l't. 'r,10 1~ r';;7 ]r;; t [ _;. ·;.:·
1
gCf.) r;.
~ _ , . l.D ,b• c ~b• l.D
1-.c r f>" .P" t.:;bl I>r -
\I It- "' V\ - - • V r ~I -~I IJ>•
't. ,--.. I
t 1t -• --:- '~b ;·,
. ": r~ •E ~· t': ·::. ~~.:'·:•1•.· ~·
t > C V\ - C Ir 1.-' /;' C - -~ <.. i.. ,L [ X. .•
l!
't_ fl r~ ~·l ~ •_;;- (;. E ~. ~~ fi:.C ~· f ~ ~. t ~ £ t. f- ~ ~f 1.:
I 1- b i ~ 1 t t 1: t ~ i- s t!· [ f P t ~ [ [ ~ B~ l ~ · .rr : : i t
t
u ~ I ~ ~~lj 44.J~I
~h··=·,·.:,~-7 -.-•,·~·,-:,=·.--'"'r··--·~;12..:h1::i~.fZ.. ·~·~~%.T'~~~:-:-¥q"c~ltiV§k·~+":RT?fe.;7.;(it;~;:~.!;;·S_:;\-.~SSLi-:.:.-~:.;..~..;,.~..:;.,~:]
,,
International Monetary Fund~J...UI ..14.Lll JJ.Jl.c4.J I~j.A ~.i9 ~ UJJ ~J
Fistful of Dollars: «~UI Lj~IJ ~ I uL:.4 :ulJ~J...ul 0-4 ~ » 01~
,Lobbying and the Financial Crisis (lgan, Mishra, and Tressel, 2009)
dol..,l?}I u ~ ~ t <i'1' JI.¥'~!~~ o->1u~ al~ l.!JUA> 0i 0~411 fi~
~ ~JLlJ.IJ ~~ ~_,.!.I lobbying ~~I ~ I ..)~ ~...u ~J~I
ul...J~I 0-4 ~ aJJb ~ JUI I.J.A JL;.jl ~ J.41 •.;Jo~! ~WI dol..~?}1
.~WI .)o~I y ~ i ~l..,l?J ~..)~ ~ <i'11
~1 ~ yjl . lA4Ji oJbl '5...W r~?JI ~ ~~ l.!JL.iA 0i ~ ~ J

.;I~ ~lA ~LA,1 ~ ~ u~~ tf-1-" ~~J.A 0-4 1.Yo ~i u\+i..>-4 ~
0:!.J.JI 0-J~J a 11,Q>J djUI ~~JA 0-4 ..)..>-9 ~i ~ ~ ,dl~ ~1 a,g~l .1.C\ •
J~~I ulJ~ ,~L;.. ul~lk ,Jlit.l ~ ~ ) ¥~1 u~lfi1 ~ 0~~
~ 0~1 ~ J ~ I (c.r-4J_,JI 1.S..)liJI ~ J ~~I ulJ~J limos oJLill
r~?l ~l_ig ~~ r"·'. ~L:. ~..)A~' LµI U.)..U.Oi W' . ~Ji LµI
-~Ult~I
, I~ ,Jlit.l ~ ~ ) ~ 01-":t ~ ~UI uL..ua.u_;J.l 0-4 ..)...u:. JL.....:ui W'
~...ul uL..uJ'-4.A .J.!.!;;! 0.¥'~ ~~ (o~I u~~.,JIJ, L-.j~ ,o~I ~ I
~1 ~ ~ I Jl......:uiJ ,~_,.bJI '5..u.l ~ ya-i.14 ~b~I &J ~...ul ih_,->-' ~UI
.1
~
A-A.)
"*'"" '-r~ti a.JUI
-
-
u~~I ~
· tb..'..>-'-'-"
.. I a..u~l
-
~ 0 i ~JL..::J.I ~ 0Y-~10..i>--:..u.l l5iJ 'tr··°' rL:. ~~ ~ "-4......1.u~' c4

t~l~i_~j.A~~ul.;.,-b:i~~~~~u~~~i l~0l~Lal
Alastair Darling ~Jb~I J ~ I ..)J 0~0~1 ~I~ . ~ I ~UI
JJ~ <i'1' ~J~I u~~ ~ ~ 1.o • ~Jl..lAA o~IJ o_;l ~~ do..>-9 ~
~ .t .. 1cl...i.o.
~j-1-"JJ
· · (.Ttl ~~i '-4.A ~
·,- .1. o~I ~ , 4.l,:.»- ~ .t .. 1cl...i.o. ro · · ·
- -~
,, - • (.:r - j-1-"JJ .. • '
.dll;, I~~ f1 ~J~I tl.Jds 0i ~l_,ll 0-4 .(GAAPweb.com, 2010)
iAJ.u__,l;w~~t
<J:1i Jl:'J.I ~ ~ ) ~ J~I u~b. ~ lfoJji 0:!.:UI ..)l~~l 0-4.J-lS
Y!' ~J4-J Kozlowski ~_,ljfi ~..)J Allen Stanford ..)J~~
'"'!'J..)
~ f:.~~t 0-4~t ~i~~a Q;.«oiaulJ~~...u (Garth Drabinsky
r~,.:-....::S\.=.h<;·h.:@§· . .@J<&L:t·A&£.:.F;fo-::.::~fiiA..f&swA&vr-S.. ~.f&fiiifuf-%41·'"":"::-.:".=·~a~>f··><:-.:j):::.-,,·s=.-::.,t~Aii·'.";:£:·.sr=::=\¥+:i''.'~;:~,·+y·:.:1·s+w::-~::::c\AJ(k,s-XiY-}wi--:..::-.p?.;f§+·;: ... =£~-+<)
-
~ I ~ l:u_,l» wl~ 4l:o ~IJ.l y:.s' ~ I ~~ c.:J~I~ ~ .ol:=-JI o.iA -
Icarus o-vJJ~l ~ ol_,L......u.ll r.Jl ~ ~ ~1.., «( \ '\ '\o) Closer to the Sun - - -
"-:P-~ Jl~I ~ ~.)f.:JI ~ .L; , , ~.J.JI_, J,J_,.i:.}'11.S...U ~_,b-,f.:JI a,:,o;. «~«JI
~,..,~1 ~ ~~ c.:J~ w,o~f.:J, ~'iJA 1.S...U - ~ 1 ~ ~l.;i91 '.«: '"!
~ a.1:.Al dJJUolJ) ~~ ~t ~ 0J·.:bi,.,.? ~~ . ) ~ ' ~ w ~4
~ ' cciJt,-..,!i,l L,Ut:.._j,t» ~ ~ rtzj'il_, c.:Jllll ~..,~, ~ ' ~
· ~ ~ t ~ ~~ 0~ .i9 J~)U ~~10~ ,Ill .(Nocera, 2008
tf llJ~t ~Llw:,
~~t ~ l...b~ ~~4 c.:JlS'~ 0~~10~..u.1 ~1~ ~w,
~ 'ij-A J ~ , I.LJ •(Lanchester, 2010) a......~ll.A L..!I..L....Al J .:;,._jj ~~I
o~ ~~\jj ~
'..r.:,--
'! • -:--:t ·
()-JJ>- • ..1A ~'1 Jo~
· TiY~ a.:.·._ ti o.J.....A uJ--:!
• .J..a.i&.ijJI
_ · ~ ..ul
u
J ,:aN ~ L.....o~_, .(Schweitzer, Ordonez, and Douma, 2004) 1.S.J.......ll
_,ta .:~I~~~ c.:Jl........uJw ~1 w~..ul ~ ..u ,~UI L..!I..L....A'il
~J.HJ c...>-""--'.JLA ~ J .(Swartz and Watkins, 2003) 0~'-4.U ~~
~~ c;..u_, ~I oJbf'I c.:J~jLi 0--4 SlS' 0 l (Harris and Bromiley, 2007)
~U14J -~UI c.:JW~I ~~I~ ..1.J_)Jc.:Jl..a.Uo:lJ4 ~~J~4.!J;,;;JI ~bf.:JI
w-a~..ul J~ ~ ~ J ~\jj ~1 «d......;t_,1.b.11 rllJf.:JI ~J JJ-«,O.,JI ~ ~ I » ~.lJ:
~a:tJl..,:too.ll:LJ~LlA,~ll a~ .«c.:J4~1 ~~)b.U»Jo~I ~ ..1.J-1! w
.«~lk;..t» L..!Ll«:'ol ~ L,:ibl~l ~..,_J;..ltl ~ ci'11 ~WI J.? c.:J~I .ll~t
~ c.:J~~ ~ J ~ I ~~1 ~ ~~~J ~_,1.b.11 rll}il ~1 JJ-«,O.,.UJ

a.a.)•
_ 'J-'
.:.q ~ I (• . ) - A1.1'!":lt •., !t!.a'I ..),~t 014~ •
~~_,... u - . UJ--:! .J..a.iLijjl
- • ~ ..ul t~
U •
1.1-:-:. ~lS'
~..,
- -Loi .l - ,..: .t:... - a:, '-4.A ~ "4 lt
.., ~~ I) c.F ~1 c.r..J--:w ·~ !t!. &'I r..,
':~~ti ~.,... I .l ""tl ~~
&-"L.IJ
. _4 ~ I a...u.JI . Q a.a &.. ".-ti c.:JI ~ ' i i '·- t:u •.. ~·!. &"c.:JL.ol .C'I &---:al.i..1.1
~J - - • I.:" ~.u-- IJ ~ .IJ~.,... - ~u'--
~ ~ ~~I 0-JY-..ul ~ c.:Jl~l~}'l o.iA wl ~ ~->14 .c.:Jb.)Lw,?/1
~ ~.JJI ~~ Jli4J . ~f.:JI 1.SJ......ll ~~~I~ '-fjl 'iJ ~ I 1.S..ul ~
~.lJW c.:J_HJJ c.!L_;:,s:JJ JI~~~ J~IJ J:,l-uJI ~~I Y-..ul J-A lpj.A
.Home Depot c.:J~.l r.J-A ~~ ~~I ~..ul ~ i ~.JJI_, Robert Nardelli
LA~a.u
" '..-U.1.1.«J 1 ~ ~-
••. ~c?"'J-A-' - u· "I ~ I ~~ c.:JI~
I· -:ti ~ · · .:.-:ti o.J.A <.)A~~..,
• I· .:..C' • .J.4l -
-~~l~bt~~'
"\.
ul.Ja.al ~ ~1-..iJ!J "'4J_r?JI
ki,,S§--!hitf4:-<hM4"Nt!\#@··.-.M.§#if4 ¥··ii~&&--,,..,¥&t&ik-if~@r,;.·.t'ift-'"&h3i4:ti•il'MS# -~{R~w·M:::&\@@M Pf(.;:., J ~- ··d5a-4L ·Sr:5~.t}fn;!a'$FH "'P·\:df bz;.,rr::m
14' ..cl~Yt j...att uc. ..~

a\4., w~ <J:!.:UI ~.,.ti 0t (Victor and Cullen, 1988) o.:JfiJ . ; ~ ~J
lt
.a.j9~:1I alJ-4110-4 -~ -b~ -~ t wP>4 ~le a_;g~t ~J"'-:1 ( s'4,C
alc~l~a.j9~~1~1~~~¥~~1~1a\u:.l~ILA~J
~ j i .a.j9~~1 ~~4 U}laJI al~ ~ I al~l~lJ aL-_;w ~ ~.,.ti
~I.?.~~ LJ:&.4 ~J ~ .lyi.11 LA~ <:i'11 a~.,.,oll ~ ~ ' i i a.j9~~1 a~.!:ll
~J ~ .lyi.11 Ls-! r~ 0t ~ ~1 a~... ,011 ~ ~ ' i i ~ j i ~J .a.j9~t
~ ¥~~I al#~I ~ j i ~ I ~I~ ~I.?. wl .a.j9~t .l~l w
~ I al.jg~~IJt~J~I illt~ ~~I ~~I al~l~?]IJ~I J ~
4..&:i~f L- ~ ~1 tl ~ ~ti ~--'I
• c.r·tJ '-:""
.e.l- ... ,l.~tl '-',J ..t.:lll ,:_,A
- ~ -· ~ c.:r - • "i! ~ r-:-- J . ~ -~ J
J~~I 'GJ..1A<JS1J ·'-:-'-'Lal ~~I~ ~~1 ·b.!\ •.,;~lJ (Stevens, 2009)
~U~I ~ ~t ~ as~ rJJ ~ .~~~I al#..,L.,JI .l_?.J LA.J.:,,.J ~ 'i
.;t;i?]I ~c.ill~J Y· ·ArlcJJ~wJAt \ ,o ~~aLAl~~.lSiemensAG
~~ c.!l.J.J5 ·~JLl..;JI ~ ~ 'GJ..l.4 as~I '->..u wl 0A ~.;JI~ .lW aLA~l;,
a ~ , 0-A.PS'l .JA u ~6.. ~UA ,l.:U .a.!,.!'0.;; J~t 'GJ..l.4 0~t as~ '->..u
.J.;_,JI ~
~..1.Lll .l_,.i&Jl;, J.w ;;~~ ~ .-. ,.o> ;;~1 ~ , ~ ~~ ~..l.4 ~

~ <i'1' ~IJ . ~ ~J ~ a ~ ~LA t:,-J~ ~ arcade game
LL....,;;JI J~ylfal)) ~.J.4ll ~I~ ~«Whack a banker ~~I yfal))
~ WJS: ~'.!J ~~ ~t ~~I~ w~~I ~ .«Whack a mole
wJ~ ~t ~ ~.;bll ~ D:--loWl w ~ U"'WI ~ t wl •..' '"! c.ill~J ~ I
.~Ci~)t:;J~~~l0,A.l~~lyfa<)~)UIJJ~ .0J..:4Aa\.!,o;....i:u
CJ-&-0 ~ 'uo·o;....ll ~_,JI~~~~ .l~ yfa ~ ~)LIi r_4,.:, J6.. ~J
.<(4:~\Zll lzi~LAA t:9.l ~ ~l~I ~l..u ~~ I ~ .a~ .J.4l)) :J~ - -
.(BBC News, 2009d) i.!;;.!;;..,., ~~~~~I J.;l.b.ll Jl~I ~ t .J.4J
d •4i~ JJ..LJIJ t_ 4i~tlJ a\ 4J;,;tlJ A~~I ~ . l ~ I ~~

. l ~ I ~ as.;L....i!J.l;, wJ.Jl...u.l .ll~~I ~I~ ..u .(Nofsinger and Kim, 2003)
'\'
J.J'-:/1~1
·~~~=.~·~==~==···,·~'.':·.--""":·•:cc...._···,:•·:...··.·:••·'·•·-••.~·.•,·c:·... ·.·..·.i)
~ c.r'J ;;~I ~ <.)A l..sJ~.J..) ~ u4~J ~ I J ~.:Ul <.)A u4JA

;;.>-'-"~I;;.)~ u~WI ~ ~J ~I~ ;;.J~J a.Q .. ,JI wl~J ~ I
~~l~~u~Wl~~JJUIJa•Q ,11Jlu~l..1.44iLaS' .J~I·.,: '"!
a:,1...ul uL-.u...r..ujl.l ~,~ LaS' . (Clarke, Dean, and Oliver, 2003) a.......L_,Jo ; ; ~
k~
- .r l..u..D
- 1.!.U~ . -~ ~
.._,........--- leai,cell LA~bi
- , y. J ~ . . J l..:T.':'""
:L.4 i...uui
- -'~~-'4 .::"..LLJI v-- ;,,;-- ..)~L•
(Sullivan, Haunschild and Page, 2007) ~~ ~J ~\S'~ ul:g~ ~
P) aS'~ ~ JL.it.l ~ ~ ~ LaS') <>")Ll?JI u~L,.JI ~ ~ J

18;;1 u\ •qi 7 ll ..1-4Ai d...J.:lS' .(e.g.,Arthur Andersen ~ b . J l WJ---'-".J.J,jj
(eu~ JJJ ~ 0:4WIJ ~~I 0-J~..u.1 c--4 i!JJ.>. l..sJL-.u...r..ujA ~ ~)
~bl ~L-JI ~~IJ J~yl <.)A ~ I ..).J..t.ll ~J ,<J:! :;.;;JI <J:!JJ..--..J.I ~J
a.u.
.:J- J
,. . -~
ti ~ I ~ .
~ .(' -~•1
~..r ~
LaS' ,~U;.tL,.J.......A
~
- ";. .~.q -
'-:T"" ~ f"S-l~
- -
~r'~~,J~L4.i.JIJ.J~~I ~~JJJ-11 ..1-4Ai ,i~tJ .(Pirson, 2009)
Ls:c:,~ ~ ~ t.ji ,~i lj~ f1WI ~ ~ l.A.>:!3LJJ ~l_,JI ~J..ul ~ I
ulS'.;----c!JI ~ az.JI Lj~ w~l 4.!Q '".! ¥ JAl_~l ".J.......A ~ .~}l;.~I
. (Child, 2002; Child and Rodrigues, 2003; Kochan, 2002; Gioia, 2002)
as-~ Nortel Networks u~L..::a:i)U J:3.J~ as-~ ~\S' ,ul:gJ~I <.>A ~J ~

'5~1 ·<>"~?JI ;;_)b <.)A[~ w~I ~ c.r'J LJ.4UI ~_,J_µ ~w ~J..o'
rL:. aS'.;----c!J I ~ IJ ;;..>-!fi ~ b a ..,. .! ,;., s 0 \S' ~_,JI I.J.,J u..)l:g ci'11 j..-A l_,..J I
aS'.;----c!JI ;;..)l:g ;;.J..)l..i.A ~J ul..,.11 <.)A ..).J..t.l ~UI ~ ;;..)L:.1 ~1 u..)l ~ r '1' • • t.
~~I ~1 ~L.al - ~ u ~ lA~J ~UI Ul..).JIJA ..)LljJ ~ ~ J
u~J ,J.,-JI ~ J 0-J..; Q~; ,cell • 1
'.!' .~.;J ~ W I a..,..!,;.,.;14 ~..,.11 ~u,
~11.!ll~ JS' '5..)t ..1.4l -w~JA.J-A ;;.Jbl ~ ~~i y ~ ~ d..:>~ ~~ aS'~I
•L&Jo~ LIJ..) J ~ I
i U:c.tt ~ J.a,WtJL.:J; ""~t

~ ~ l ~ J ~ <.)A ~..u LA~ ¥..H <>"WI ~J ~..;tJI ~WI <J-4
wJAWIJ w~~IJ u4~1-'49..1AJ ~..ul J~.J ~ ~U;JJ ~ ~~i
..)~~~I ~.,-JJ .alo.;----c!JI ~~iJ u\S'~ 0Y-~I w~..LI.IJ ~4Jo~IJ
.~I ,,.JA ~ J.oi a.'":!;, <>"WI~~~ <.)A
'\Y
o4=d.J o.J..a.UI L_,J~I 0A IJ..LC. ~ i L_,J~I ~ c.=:.i\.S'~ 0i ~->31 ~
a+,ylJ ~ I ~lzJJ o~l_µ.o u\ ii.!ii?c.'.ll -
ly;..jA ~.)-Li \+,I' ~1 a ::- colt oj).Ll.lJ
~Ul.1 uj.:i.AI ~ · ¥ ~ i ..H)!. c.=:.iL.u). 4.4 ~ (Santoro and Corrie, 2005)
~~I~ ~I ...dl~IJ ~J~I ~ ulS'->1u ~ ~ I . A ~ o~I
L-
- u~
~LUI c4 a.:,~ I~ .. ~I ~· L~L....u
'"(t-1 ~ · -~- 'L, -&'
~ ulS'~ ·. ·t ill lb.JI L Li.~~I ..L.:i ,-
- t w
. ~ , ~~i ~~~I
~ ~~I ~ . . > £ A ~ ~ 0:jjl a.k.;-c!JI ~ 0_,loWIJ 0.,-._.AWI Loi

0fo-)L...u ~ J ~ . , ;;;~t ~l:?- •...' '"! w~i 0~.J.A ~ ~~J ~.;13 Ji - -
I~->-'-" 0:.:.UI ~~I c.i:4WI 0A ~ J.J.A.1 ~I...P." ?JI l.!l.,LuJI (Slayton 2007)
JUI ~..>--'""~~~I 13...LC.l.....uiJ ~UI c.=:.iLl)WI J ~ I IJjl.....uiiJ l_,Jb:,..IJ
~JJ-6l:u ~ -~~ c4 ~ c.=:.i\l~ ~ lfiJL.a!.J c.=:.tlJ~I IJA..1;.; ,crlJ
l.!JJ~I y ,~,iaaJ ~->-4~1 o~I c.=:.i1=~.,JI JJ.J.>. 4:!b ~~ ~ , Y• • °' r~
~~I c.=:.il~I...P.-?Jl .)_,4,-:i ~ ~.!<.! ,u<II c.=:.tlJ~l ':T-* o..LC.LuJ. ~ I J JUI
Luis Alarid J..>:~i ~__,J ~..J ~I~~~ .J.>.i ~ J.41 .oJ~l 4:!JJ~I
0_,.,_). .ilH~ iJ ~w ~ IJJ ~ l.;-c!J \..sA..1;.i crl ~IJ ~->-4 I J ~JJ Y• • , • • • t:4-4
~ ~ '-4 ~~ 01 .,.sy;..i ~~iJ J ~ '-:-«-'6.. .)~J d,:bcu4 c.=:.,La!,~
~ ~ 1 y~ ~ o~->31 0i ~ w r~ JS' v· , · · · y,, l.!lJ~' ~JA
. (Archibold, 2009)
Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP)4:!~l~la.J~la.b~~J-Li..l.41

c;l.,~I ~ I uL.u.J..u.l. \..sAl~I ~ ~ a , q Ill ulLJJ ub~~I ~
0A ~ 0Lli ~L:u ·0~ ~I~~ o~_,JI ~,. ·: , cri Jl~~I L)L...u tj..tl w
, ~\Jdg ~ ~ 4 4:!~I ~ I a.J~I a.k->1u ..:...all ,4:!~I a.k~I c.=:.,~\Jdg
~
.c.=:.iW~ 4:!i ~ ~i ~ l"21Jl~i ~ <?I c.=:.i~I o:U ~ 0i Jb.t..ll <.J---AJ

~ <...djAJ 0~~~ iyJ-4i a.1~1 a.k->1u ~ J , r· · °' r~ ~ i ~ ~ . ,
.~I c.=:.i~b.. ~ ~I o ~ I c.=:.iWL:.:.11 ~ ~~i ~ c.=:.i~ ~I...P.-1
~ 'r r · · °' rW Human Rights Watch 0~~1 J~ ~l..r4 ~ la:sJ

~ ' ' , • • • 0A ~i jJ_j l~I ~ _,JJ4 3L.uJ J.>i,4'- ~J _,.i..J <?=-\A ~ a.k~ I
0A w,,,~J a.:;)\j JS' 0A I.J.>. IJ I. o;. ,~. _9,J..J a.k~ ~ J.41 . u lj-L--'-" ~ ~ - fJ
~~, ,.s~ 0-4-4 nA 0A JS' 0A,- ,o;. ,~. _,J_,4 JL....ui a.1:,~ ~ . , , ~ I -
,,., ~~~~'?.'.ill l.oj l!I...L:,,,.j fall =~~,
~ - ; : ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . - « ' l ~ · , . ~ ~ o : . ; ' ! I I X ~ ~ : : . \ k J V , . . . ~ ~ , . ~ . a . ! i r . : a . 1 ~ ~ ~ - . o r r ~ \ . ' l . ~ ~ u ~ , ~ G l t / ' t r A . . , . . , . ~ r ~ A . ~ 1 . , - , . , . > < , , . y , . - . : ; ~ . , ; , _ . _ , . ," - ¥ V ' L ~ O ~ ~ ~
~ .)~lj 44J~1
~ rv, • • · JS'o-4 -IJ.>.IJ -\,a;. .~.;;~I c~~_,Jl~ak~I~~ ~
c:,..ul cl.ti~ c~_,JI y4,-l J.t_Jl..,.,tll ~ ak~I ~ -·fSilaic I o-4-4 -Wt ~)\jJ
-
-
t ... 1.·.Lcl..J)Atl -~~I - - Lll
- .~J~~l4.......4iJ ~•
~..... - ..,.. (.) • '"'~ • ~ ~~
- . ·
~~
·r'~tl' c ~ .;I.~
r~i ..1.41 •.l~I~ J~~L - ' ! I . - : . ~ ~ : ; ~1
-~ - . . '.) ->- .':('f ~\SJ
- l.!ll..lA ~.:,5
J-AJr'<· ·'\ rL::. ~~~ ~Jbuj~, ~ w~~,
rJ6.. ~~~~ J~t ~.)
~ . .l~I ~ ;;~I c~~_,JI cl:!,Jl ~JJ Citigroup y..!)l ~ ~ ~
ul,:il ·.: • ·: .¥JJJ.iJ ~..1-o cJ-4 JAJ Gil Comblum r#Jfi ~ '="'°6J.I ~ I
.clJ~J.JJI ~~ J~I c ~ ~11.S.ll w cLA.,W.I '-:-1-i~ ~ "~ ;;.r?-tJ.4
_jJ.J~J4 C~J~IJ ~UI JIJJ\'1 ~ c:,)lc.1 o-4 J.>.IJ r'~ J......i9 OJl....:,i::;jl C:,~J
e:4J ~ Jl4i~ clc.oji ~l;. Ontario Securities and Exchange Commission
. (Wallace, 2009) dj~~
~WI ~_,JI~ I~~ 0:46J.I <>-4 -~.J..! ~J'-'4ll ~ c:,_,iAWI ~
~ ~=•.:aiiJI cJ---IJ:!..UI ~~ JJ.l ;;.lLI u..c.:)J ..1.41 .a..tltl c ~ ~.ll ~
..1.41 •tij.i:.ll w~ ~4J ~l~I f s• 0 i.:J w~J W..9---'-U~ ~l;. ~J~I
0
~ J1b:i ~~ <i'1' c~ls.;;~ ~J.J..! ~UI clA.,,;JI t\.Jos ~ ~I ~..u

~ull ~..ul UJ-S ~~ t-4 ~J - ~ ~ I ~ J1b:i c:,~I c...--:·ol c.J:-.o6...l.l
~ » ~ t ~.:UI ~~ J.>.t ~ .¥JJJ.iJ ~ Second City Comedy ~~.,,s1l
.~~~«~I o-41.\ • •J ~\ti~
-
l:JLA -I_;\ :.-
c:,Ut,~ I W:!~ IZ.l
c:n • n cn 4
-- - :. -
I cJ-4 ~ . . -.
~~ c.:.,..i.b;. - - .
t d_9..,.Jo:a.o a.Jb.. ~J
-
~t,.;...1-o o-4 JJ~ c:,~ r, o ~ ~JL.-;.J ~ c:,~ ct:.l ·.·: .,,1 ~~- l..""4llJ
a.J6JI ol.A c:,l fL..,.SI ~ •(Pidd, 2010) ~Jl.aAJI l..u.Jfo J.,.._,, ~ LA.; q~i , ,.I c?JI
~FLA~ ~~J ;;"~' ~ ~ ~ rJ ~t ~.;ll 0'4J ~~' ~ rJ
cJ-4~ .l~ ~~ ~.:UI ~I~ ~t ~1 ·.l~)U ~~I J~~I .;~'it
•~~, 0-l->:!JJ., 04,.:iJ ~u t r ~ t 04,.:i U""w, a..oL::.
;;~t c~~_,Jt ~ Pew Research Center ~~)t.J ~fa.JA I.S.r?-l ~
-- ., ~t ~l~~.JA\rl cL::.~t ~ ~ L~ ·c:4
J-:>-~<ct~»~<i'11 - -
~ ·~ -'-'1 :. (1.At. ~
. .) ~ru . .) (.)"":!"":"~U"'J
-~··-'' L _:._., ,~, \rt --~
ca~,
'-,c..U - "6.. ....-:-tt
• ~
~ (1.'rA ~ ) WJ.!.;,.,oJI "~ •.·.:1):'11 ~.lf ~J .(1.V• a: ,mi:) t-l.ca.WI ~ (1.VV
ul.Jaal ~ JlwMillJ 4+1~1
mz:::w . \ffr'L. ·:·>··::·-<:.:P.s:::i,-''·>:"h=\··:·.t;;-'5777t~::-:~~~?.}'{:,,·: ·};:'/:·+····-X.?.:y/§r:=-..-.'35-}UC .·.r,r,;?~h,··t-;.:.zj.-£,,z/§··Z"Uiti:::.-,. ·-aj.. :,::···pi::·-'.·..f:±.-···1'.ilii.&ZJ
w~~I J~~I ~J.A i~tJ (:l.'n" a: ·ui:) wJ-AWI ~ (:t.r\ a: .. ,;_,) w~lui.JI
.(Pew Research Center, 2009) (:I.Y\ ~ )
,~~ u~ ~t ~~tu~~'-"' ~La:at

4.Ja~t
_,,....
4..c..==>.J\clllA
'..r-
,I.L.J .d_uuJI
-
o·~
_tt 4..c..==>· .:.q ~bLJ
'J-" ~- ~ ..ul (
· >·A ~
.:..~ c.)--A
· ~ I>
u~'i_,JI ~ .~.)~! u~~ Jl ~~IJ ~I..P.-1 ~~i l~JI ~.:UI .ll.>9~1

I.S..»-t o.J-A IJ.)~ w-o~ i ~ ~..b,. a....J:&A t cll-...ub o.J-..:tu.ll a <\ 4 t IJ o ~1
ijJlAJ Michael Milliken~ ~lA ~ J r'6iv re:, ~l:?-J ~ I fAJl-uJ
clllAJ .Sir Jeffrey Archer ~ J i t.§>4t?:" ~ I J Martha Stewart uJJ:P---,
~ 'i Michael Vic ~ ~lA ~J ~La:JI ab.....>-4:' w ~ wJ.»-i w,o~l
y~I cJ:! Jl:i.a.U a..._.,~ d.LJ4S ·.·: '"-' ~ 4 ~ ~ f.§.:UI ._g~I ofi.JI
~~)U ~ ~lA aS'~ 1.S~I ~.;JI Michael McCain ~LA ~lAJ
~.>-4 LJi tA j_.ql.a:JI cCiS'~- ~ -lAljJ wlS' 1.§LllJ Michael McCain Foods
~ ~J ~~, ~ o~J ~1 u.)l ci'1'J a:;_,.u1 r~' '.·: ,. ., listeria l.;Ji , ,i\11
~4 ~~ 1.S~..u ~
·~->-4l J'iJ.) w~ rA a4.!4.'
wlA..u.?.- ._g~ 1.§~l ..>:!.J.1.I ,Lolyd Blankfein ~~ ~_,J r.ia c.i.LJ.:\S'
JJ..U °' rY· · r~~~~w..o~ t:tWI ~oJl~I ,Goldman Sachs ~L.u
0-AJ ·f.§~Ull 1.§J~I oA>.;-11 ~~I~ 4..c..==>~ ~WI 4UI Lj~I ~ ._g~I
r'1'• •Ar~ ~L-.wlA..u.?.'...,g~ l&,l~J,Lici'11 ~ I ub~'il w i ~ I
~T~J'wlA..u.?.-...,g~w~~~_;st ~ -;l~~~..Lo:i~·-·46 «11i
«r-'"'"°~ ~~ ~~f »~ clJL.:u .ia ,rJWI ~ 4=.J~I ¥ ~ as-~ 1.SjglJ
. (Harper and Townsend, 2009)
l.!l.,.LJIJ . l ~ l w..o u~IJ A~~I ~l.a:i D::t aS'~I j.Al~I ~ ~jj

. Al.a:;•LJ::' as-.~
":T ~ .:..q C....:,la~fl
• .,-,:w ~ • • -- ~ ~ I C....:,la~f\
• .,-,:w ~ • l.!lllA1 ~ 0 • I>• ···''
.l.?.-~ ._gl~ 'ii w,Jl ~6..J (as'~J .l..)--4ll) J.,~I uWo..alJ .ll~~I
~ ~ ' i i U~4 0 ~ ~J...1.:1 d.!10.;. .~.JI d•4 rtlpb:i ob~lJ L..b;.JI C
w_,:ulS' ~~~Ji <JAJ cL.J ~-»-'ii~ I.S...L-4J charisma ((LAj.J-JlS'» .l..)--4ll

~I O.)~, ~ ~IJ r..l.ll4 .)~' ulS'~I~ .ll_~~I ~ . (VBill Clinton
.I
clJJJ~ ~J.A ~~Eliot Spitzer~ u~l <>"J..i: ,Jul.I~~ -~
---·-~---------~~.,. • ..-.a ~ .s r,;~~"'#ll'lie~O.o."ill.::::ic ...,...,7 nwww....-....-.io-~~o,
'\O l.fj~ ~ ~ Li~I LAJ o...bJ ,~u : u ~ I ~ Jlw..slt, 4-s~I

t:4-4 J.,U.O LW\ L..u~\J 0 j,WI ;;.)LA City College of New York
.igJ ,~J
I,
~ ,u~~I ~~J .uL.uA_,J.I ~...\>1c44 .... .1,0" ~ ~.JJ-S_,;, ~'}l_,J '-4S'6.. u~

~ u~.;-!JI t.1bi,11i . ~ i ('Y ~ J., t)-J_y,,.)U r~l "-:R-ji .)\~~I .)J.l44:'
~ . L ~ -~la:tlla.6. ·- .)I.._~~\ .t •.. !t~.q
~ ~ I..:"° 'J-4 ~
• - <LJ-""J
' t .• .. !t~.f\~\
~..,... L- JA~J '..r- f"~J ~ r
.u~~IJ A~~I 0-4 Js:i
.. ,,
~ L&:i~~J ud.u,~~1~.:Ul~_,ll~~la:tllu~lt.1b;,11iJA,~
~J~yl l.JAJJ4'Jtbi «11irJu~I~ ~~l~...U~J.>-AA~~~I
~J .Arthur Andersen~~ U_j-1-".)...wi .P.JTJ Enron u~l ~~ ~ ~
,,., ~ ~ C.
(Pfarrer et al.: 2008) 0 ~,J~-.JLl:i .J~ ...l4l • ~ \..>-4t u ~ I UJA ...LJ: '}l
.. I,
<>"\..al .)~I.)~ ~ ~ I ~W J~IJ ~.J-'-" ;;..)l:u-J J>.l..>-4 t:t.Jl 0-4 4,-~-'4'

~~yµ~ .~>l:.i~~~~~~~lyb.i.oi~_.,_.J~Ji
:4\.:i.JI ul_,b;JI
t.J.:,~ ,LJ)UI ulb~'}ll .:G.i ,~b ~ ~l.?.-l) ..)L.will ~~ ~W:01-,

·(rWI ~~I ~t 0-4 uJla:tll ~ ~.JLlJ.\ ,~\fo uLA.,W.I ~ ~ I
~I~ '}ll 'f"J.......lll .) l&1:,1,~ lb. ~4 ~ I~ '}ll) ..)Luui.U '-:-4---'-"Ll.4 ~ ~...\.4i -Y
.()~'}ll f=J.4i ,~~I ~~_,JI~~~ ,4Jj.uJ.4
'~~1~.,~~'~IJ~)d..bWl~~I.J.1ciiJJ~Jlb.;Jl~~1-r
.(y~I a.JI~ ~l~'}ll
u~~I JS'~J u-0~~1 ~ ) ~.)l:,..J ~ b "-:P-~l ul_;.1.1;; ~I...L...>1-t
4.1 Q.!t;, ii aJL_u,.J ~L«!c:sl '<:r."".JWI ~~I~ ;;...l:!~ ;;.J-'""'° J\...H1 ,~l...ul
.(;;...l:!~
u_,.\A~ LA~ c'""IJ Jl.b:J ~ ~ I ..)L.will jJ4'J u~IJ Ar"~' t.!b; 11J C
u ~ l ~ ! lAi .aJ.,j.....ucAa..a..i~u~~~~~J[~-":'ULiJ~I~
.~ti ul~ ..u:i ~ ~lb.J4 ~~IJ ~J.4JI LW\ ul:9)WI
i~~ti),A~t
~ t ~ _u~ ~ (Simons, 2009) r4.J~I ~>l:. ~I u ~ I ~ ,J.,l.411 ~
.(Schwarz, 2009; Torres, 2009) ~ I J ..)~I 0-4 ~ ~>l:.~I ~µ,
~ . . : ~ ~ ' W : o o ~ . . . _ _ , . _ - - . , ~ ~ . . . . . - = ~ ~ ~ ~ . Y ~ • ~ ~ ~ ~ ...~ = - = - • - - ~ s . o 1 L L ~ ~ u s . - = - . m " ' V 4 ~ ¥ ~ ~ " - ~
~~~~~.'.ill l.oJ Q.J.>,l fall : u ~ I ~ .)L.ii..illj '-4J~I ii

ul.J=a.at ~ Jlw.il!_g 4-4.J~I
,,,.:<<F:, .. n,r.=:=,f:":.11: "·.f·.-:<vl-f, +c~ ·,, .-....-~.i..: ·z;.t.•/.l":·~~-~---;q,H,·:;; .. h··\·",~../'/···c~--·~···.~c····.;·. :, ·{:/,,;;;, "u·::·.:. -·-···i'·N· . . .~~-,f&ffiif-.2•:- ... ~· ·S·y-~ .. ...-.·jiJJ
.~~...,.;it, ulll~lf u!JL:.C:~~,

~ <JS''-4i ~ .lL.wil\ ~ c.:,ll '-:?.)Jj <.?l' u~~\ J~\ .)\~~I t_.!bi , ,.:
~..u ~ r~?Jl wy.!b•((f.: ~ (Beenen and Pinto, 2009; Watkins, 2003)
0:.J.JI jA..JI ~~j J,::.. i (:A '-:--'-"Li.A~ cG f 0 J ~ ..r4 i '-:? i J.? u~)\A ~
~ .~~ (:A u~)\A c)A ~...u '-4 ~llA 0J'.!bc ·11.: l.!1.1.JS'J .~ 0~
whistleblowers uWlid.l ~ <J:i4.ll c)A lj,fi: wl J~l l.!lJj ~ WJ'.!bi ,er.:
j)UI I.Ai .~'-4~1 c)A~...U '-4F-ji1 ~WI ~L&JI as'~I ~ rl...1;.c ,,.4
[J\.;. c)A lS~i oJ~l '-:?i Ji ~j,~ oJ~I ~ J ~ I ~ 0~ ~.>:P"-~I
u~l4A c.:,ll t.?.>14J .~Ll.)4.U ~ b rl...Joj ~i.,t:,;4 ~ ~ rJ lj! a .,t:,;JI
rl~I ~ 0~1 ~~ ~ ~ ~~ <.?l' Sherron Watkins ~I_., 0 ~
Jlo ~ .l...,..a.ll c.!l~ 0i ~1_,JI c)A .«~D»J «~111 «~111 «~"}11, ~ l ~ I
~~ lS..U ~i ~ 1...9~1 I.J41 ~~I ~~I 0i ~ d........>.\:J.I ~IJ~I
-~>WI ulj 1...91.)..b~I
iJ~~t ~Jt~! J~ ~..,._-:. 111 ?"Wt~

~'-4~"}/lj.Jj.LJ ~ ~ ~ ~ J J . ) J ~ ~ I oJbl ~~ 0§.: J....l
. (Adler, 2002; Gioia, 2003) . ) ~ a.!'::;, ,c:11 u ~ \ ~ ~till ~~ ~I
u\;9~ t J4c,..o ~ o.)'-4 ~WI c.cl_,JI ~ r..laJ J ~ ~I u~ ~~ 0i ~.;-LI~
•o.)LA ~ o.J,:..J Ji jA..JI
(McCabe, Trevino, and Butterfield, 1999; McCabe ~~JJ ~~ ~J

t=9~ <.?11 u~I ~ ~ I ~'}lb~ I.;--& ~...G c.!.JUA 0i and Trevino, - 1993) - -
~~ c)A o~l>'-4 bl ..1.....d ~...G ~ . ~ I 81...9~ a:,J..1.A ~ ~ y ~ I
uis~ ~~~~~.,:ill ~..u ~I ~~Jl..ul y)Uo rJWI J.? J ~ ~I
u.J~L;tub..i» :J~I ~ ,y~I J,::..i_;S~ ~ -~~ ~¥)l;.iUJ..;-b:,
~4l.b.;.. ~i.:i lS..LA ~l_,JI c)A ~ ~J .«Bernie Madoff '-9J.l'-4 ~~ ~ i
~..>£A c)A ~>11 ~ ~ I rJW ~.?.) ~ "=1-,JI u~IJ._ul ~~~~I
~IJ.l .ll..9-4~ J ~ I ~l.!lJjJ LA~JJ~ a~-.:,oJI ~~)U~l_,J\
~0i9.J-'4J~\'loJbly)Uo~~J -~l~~jiJJ)l;.~I~
J ~ ~ "=1-JI a~l.)..ul y)Uo t_.!bi«uJ u.J J:!..l4i Jgi ~ ._,.;..i t~.JA ¥ ~ i
al;g)l;..f ~ .ll.J-4 a.__\J.) ~ ¥)l;.i~ ~ois.J-'40:lJIJJ~~I oJbl
'\V
lt·;.,1···r-ibtef~~u~·a,d·}~.,!~01:-&MJ@•e).:J@-.J@M>-&i&·8®1r~,@>;-f£1r1tr£4fyJi\Z§f§§410 4&41wJPH'~ff%Jb.-i:Vw§J··'fliffwi2%(@~·tt«~l}~!®J:Wfu.rirXJi&%~i6%·~4,U@riii&¥&M·~0HfC l\ 0'1
1 1 1
~~ w-4 ~ i ~ I JA\'I ~J . ~)l;.i ~ ~ ~~ 64 ~ I ~~.ll ~ I

yJlkU ¥)l;.\'I a.:,o,.!'iJI ~ ~.;-ti w-4-;~)l;.~I l.!l_,611 ~ ~ JA ~
c.::.....-:,oi ,~.J.J a-:-_w .J~~I oJbl J ~ ~ l:!,WI ~L....,IJ...ul rt4l:t..r.t 4.J_,;...l J.t9
.J~ ~I oJbl y)lbl ~)l;. ~I ~ I a 4.!" J~ ~IJ:i-4 ~ ~
~ J~ \JI~~~ ~ I ~~)l;.i ~-J..13 wi ~~)UL!,~~ ~J
u,k J~\11 oJbl ~~ ~ j jS._,:i .J~\11 oJbl rt4l..r.t ~ i ~ µLA i~.P.'"
~
wi ~1 ~ ~IJ ~ _ , J I ~ ~ LAJ .l~~I ~~ ..,.tu ~J w-4 tS~I
-
~ \ ' J..19 ~t u,k J ~ JJA---'-"-4 ~~ ~ w~ ~iJ w~wt ~~~,
u,k ~lb)Lo ~~ ,~~ ~1 ~~1 . (Sutton, Ferraro, and Pfeffer, 2005)
~ t wl:- .lWJI ~~Ji~ ~..i.-iul.>1J ~ ' ~~)l;.i o.lLA O""'-J..u ~Ls
.~ I ~ ~ ~~IJ w~I w~ LA~ ~ J)l;. ~I ~ ~ JAL..:ill ciJ
~t ~J J~~I oJbl ~~ 6--A ~~I y)lbll c,k. ~~)Lo l.!lUA
~J~J ~ 6 ~ a.:;Io j4 .>tJ;. ~ldJ'.iJ a~.:.. ,:o;., ~,J~ f+.!...UJ 6~~
~,.,:;i.i.:u, r~'~J ,i~.JA~<:?J.llAA ~~~ . ~ 6 ~ LA ~l.:- .,,,o. .
~~tl' ~~I~ .l~J '~J~I o..,..Jl 4AA4'JI c,k. 6JJ7=i ,ull ~ ~
f~~Wlu,k o_;b.: 11111»~_;,All ~4J ~ ~ J J i u,ky:.s'~IJo~I
.J~\11 ~~ ~ o).ltll O""'-J..u ~IJ:! i.i.J.JI i.i~I u,k ~~I 1.lA ~ .«llA
.(Mintzberg, 2004) llA ~~ct.ii J6. ~ ~L:tl4 l.lA
(Dincer, Gregory-Allen, <:fJLliJD:li ~J.P.-J~.l ~ rts ~..1>- a..c.ulJ.l~
a.:Q ,.,;JI'~ i.i.J.JI ~UI <)JJ:!..U.I wl:- J~I ~ i.S.J.A ~ Shawky: 2010)
Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) .1 Q;,11 ~UI J.6,JI o.)~ ~J ¥1..,.ll
l.!.l.l.:i u,k J ~ I ()J.l J ~ \JI o).ll ~b~ u,k ~WI ~ J i w-4 ~ i
~b\11 ~ i.i.>A.P.- ~t; ~ ~ ¥1..,JI a.:Q ec,iJI l.!.l.l.:i wi w~'-tJI ~J .o.l~I
al~..1.;t ~j~ Jgt l~\S' .., 4i•ll ~UI J.6,JI o.l~ u,k ~WI <J-s.J:!..U.I ~J
oJLl! ~b~ u,k ~WI <J-s...>:!..u.4 4.lJ~ 4UI ~WI J ~ ~ L.J-A.P.-
~ c.:....s.>'-'-" JJJ ~IJ ~I ~4~1 ~ :i,.;.T Sl.o~ ~~ ~ ~ .J~\JI
;Jbl ~~ ~-»
w-4 aJJs i.ll.J.d l.!lllA wi r~)U~I w-4J .o~~I ~l_,1-uJI
~ i ~J ~jlll ~..u ~ ~ ~ l.lAJ l.!lllA ~I~ ~'-tJI J ~ ~I
-~.>'-'-" JJJ ~ ~ I ~lA4,.:i~I
:: 1 c, .s· ·~. tr' 1>. ; ~ 1- e; t;! <i- ·1. ~ t· ·i ~ C• •f'C•~\·e..c.~1· ·.£
~ 1, .h ~! CD (r • ~ ~ ~• ~ ,t" ~
r f. f
.
~ [ l, <c ,c; 'T.I ~ ~ f C>I L .• c:·~t-·f. & t E f :t: if:
E
- ~ ~, •L ~· n1 t• i•.£ }::. -~ t- i} g ,·(
11. C· C..
•ts., ft.' " C.. C
<i" r.., _:
·r ~ t g. .~ ~ r . . ~ ~. . ~ r·t;:'° ~·\.::
,c; •
r.~·.f.t~1~1· el'. •
I'
-~~ '5c,· ·f\ f ~ r t ~ I r(i..
I, • -,C 1r" J:.
- ~ \o
-: t-
~ - C>I
(p, ~·
-
Ii\ '
t~'k-t~· .:trr~
~ - [ f ~ 't ~. ~. ~. .• c.. - ~ tt-'
i.: ~.
;
1 ~ e:o'i: ~r ~ u [ t r-·<i,.. t'
i . !· . r. l 7 ·~. !·
l.o 1..• \
,I:s- ~', ~ ~
.·t~
£ .- g t. 1c· 1 ~ t· ~ <t <i" ~ [
.f. e:. ~ ·~. ·~ ~ ~,.~ •. 1 '
fl:. :r.b _ ~. .!)·
. . .f ~ l ~. ~ ~ - t! ~ ·~· ,E
~ .e-· - I: ~ J e· 1 s. _ i ~· ,(; ~ r -~ ·~ ~ .ti c, f. l ce. <r ~ r·
~. !;i [• C• ~ f (;"" ~ ~ t> - \' .c- Ci C• { ~ [• ~ •\. t: ' '' l
·t ~ E\ ~ ·~ ·i. ~ s· ·~. ~ t .1: ·~. t! f' i l ' • • ·~ • •~ -
~·~r·i~-. (r
:l Al -[' 1
r ,C°;_ ~ : 'f. 1~• . ~
u.. '-4
,c;;
~- f;:
~ f.• \" ',C~. •:=tr .f-'
!;i f> r C 1> ~
1
1
f. «>·.
• ' , ~ [ ~·
I;; ~ f-1 d ~ i ; L { ~
£ ·~ ·ir-. _ . l ~. t ~
}, ~ ~ • ~ ,i b ~ - •(i..
- 'E.. 8 • I> - -f ,L - C O>
J° 'r ~ CD •f' fi_ p.• ~· < ~. { 8 :r ·f. .,. ~t t:: -: 1· c.. 1::
r,.i .-~~ --0 CD
~yr>-~ f :1 ~ l!.- ,r,
r ~ t r ~ ·- t s ~. ~ i .,. ·= 1- -; 1:. r :;, : ~ ,e' {: fi:-- ~. Ii' l: ~ ~ ·t
d, C• .;-
O b f- 'J-: r- ·~. ~. rr-:.1 ,I:
\D ,i - ;· .. C)I ·V - C
,:
~t,: - '° ·t e. ,t' --
·t .
{. fi... ~[ ~ (ii '°le; ti '°b t~ -f. ~:l ..( ~·C"' ~E:,
e, ~. 1: t! r tr. d· ~~t·r~ ~
-1 · ~ ,(; 't, C ~. 0.
?.~ •'f..• .Ii,.S --= t !'• ~-; f-. . ~t tf ·~ ff~ ~
E • f ,[ I> t> I> rt ~ I CD, 'ti\~{ 1- - r ·~ b gc..c; -:-
f>" f,c., \- ~ f ~ 1 ~. ~· C•
~. ·i. ~
Al • Ts>·
'C....
I,
'°b
•
-i
•I..
t
•
l
v-
~ ~ f.
•
•G ~ -~· ~ ~
~ t>·
I! ,c; ~... • 0
Ils>· -CD, •
1 t. ! ~< (b.--.i I
-~ C.. e• (. ~ " C• [
r c, ~ re t .- _ _ r- $. 1--. ~ c~ :::i • ~·
"" l:. r e! .. ,r. .r \ . -< 1> ~
'°~" ·~ c...- - . c_U>' - ~· t" ~ • e.. r £:: b
1{ ~ tr l-' 'i-. '.t f.~ ·f.t ·iE" ~ :[l
E •(j ~ • I t; .. :1· ~ 1 ·r !· t fl' ~
.r ~ ~ .,. 5=: 1= f>" ~. E _ E'. C"' ' E. c- I:;
l·~ cr-Jls.· t~ t ·~ 'f ~ ect.~. ·r·· . i _f - ._ - •L ' -
' ' ~1-::::·-,···' ·.-.:.,,:...::.;·.·~::·,.,:-:·;·:~;::,.•::·::.::.-.:::i--::. ;:::.~::·;_:=;,~d:J
~ ~~I u ~ I J)G.. uA o~ ~~ ~l.b-1 ~..># r~ t ~ I ljl

-
-~.;~r~1
<:rQ.!t:, ;;JI ..)~I w,k ~t9.;ll ..)~~I ..)~ i.;~ (Lange, 2007) ~"'i r~
"-..91..1.A~I w,kj.#~I (') :~'"~..)~I w,k ~t9..rlJ[j~~.;i ..).b-~
Lo! ~J ,~ljtll ul_,a w,k j.#~I (Y) , u 4 ~ J i u ~ ufi::i ul LA! ~ J
u~_,1....-JI ~4,- L..91..1.Ats' u ~ I w,k j.#~I JJ~ ·¥1..a:i/~~I Ji ~bl
'"~ u4~1 Jl uLl~I ~4,- L..91..1.Ats' u4,.~I w,k J--.#~I JJL.zu_, ~.l~I
~L-.~IJ ~ y l ~~I w,k ~.;b?/1 ~ljtll ul_,a ~j:i LS .u~_,.LuJI w,k
~j:iJ .u4~IJ uts~I rlJ;.i (114 ~jJ ~~1 ...\.Li c.?!IJ ~~IJ a .:i_:i_j)-11
.~ WIJ ul~I <..:r- ,... Ll~l/a""d
- - ..4~"'il
• 1.-1.~,1
u--- _,.... ul~
.r-
(Albrecht, Albrecht, and Albrecht, 2004; Albrecht, clels.;J ,- ••~,.u-tli r~I

uA ~ .lLwill uA ~ L..ulJ u~\..~1 ~~ Albrecht, and Dolan, 2007)
~ I L..91~?/I J)\j.. uA ..)~I~~ uA ~ I : u..)~I c.:..r..liA» ~ ~.;UA
rt9.;~I t-"4 J:?,.t uA ~ ..)l~~I ~ c.?11 ~~I uA ~ I .~llylJ ~G!IJ
.J)\j.. ~I ~Jj uA ~_,.I.I ~lb~~ ,<)~ ~ ~~ ~_,J.b.t.l
J_,.b (Anand,Ashforth and Joshi, 2005) ~y:,:.J ~.;~iJ .,ij\.jf ~ J
.o..)_y:,:.ysc.:.,,j~ ljl ~ ~IJ~~"'il a~ ,~,iillJa;i~4~..,..11 ..)~I ~
~_;...Lill u ~ J u~Lal J)G.. uA u ~ I ~ ~_,JI o..)l:!j ~1 I~..) ~~J
""':!J.:,,,j ~ ~~I ~Lt:,_,J ~.,.LI '"bl~ u~ ':?lj.JI J.ob..11 w,k t=""!" ,~,illJ
~.:.:;;;~~ul~l ~ t I~..) LS .J:6:=JI I.J.AuA~~)lj..iu~~t
~ ~Ll&.ll uA ~ L..9-'""" u ~ I u~ t,~~IJ ~ «r-ll.;~I» uA ..u.;,i .J-1b U '"b~I
-~~ 4,-j~ 41,a.11 o.;b?/1 ufi::i 0t yy:,:.J ~1 IJ.;Ll.t ,i..>:P""tJ -¥~i a.:Q.:t:,;;
..)\.jj r~I o..)_y:,:._,.1.1 ~~'"ii a~ ·~riillJ a;i~I ~~I uA ~ 4 ~ ~J
~~I~ a.:t:.1..o ~6.. L&J~l ~ J ~~I ".J.A ~ ~Jl, a r~r<ll ~ u'4 ~ls.)J
(J~~I ~ ~ uJ·.:bi,rr_~JG,.. '"I~ a,jl.:u.u"'i4 ~jJ ~J.ol..:ill ~~
. ~ °DJ;!~ UJ_;,lo ~ ~.;G... ~J ~
Association of Certified Fraud Examiners ~..14&.Lll J~' " i i ~ ~ ~ ~fij

~...r4~I o~I u~"'i.,JI ~J~"'il ~41 uA ;or t4u~I J ~ I '°-'"""ul
~ y s u ~ r-W-A4 u~I..>: ~j.JI ~ I y4.;{ .l..u:. ~ o..)l:!j ~Li.AJ r' Y• •Ar'~
u ~ t '?9 J~!., 4.4.J~t
r:::~2==-:i.:::~~~~~11Z:.::1.u~--=-~::::..~~s:::-.:;~.:.:z::~:•.. : :.:rdl
.
y4) 0.JA~ a.! 4.!J;, iiJI u ~ I c(glS° ~ ~_,.I.I wi ~ ~ . ~~~ <?11

L)-l_;~I uk.\l L ~ u ~ t:9.lJ u'-4.illl ~ j i l ~..u w~ L>-:.JJI ~ I
~ I ~4 ~,~ ul~.lJ ~I.J..:,J4 ct:l1£11_., c(gl.J;,.lJI_., JL1b ~I ul , ".!'"?"J ~l:;JI
~~i y ~ LG.?-i u~., ~1_;.1.1., uu~I ~l:J U""J.J.lJ ~~' ~ . ,
.a;.!.~,ll ulfi'_,iuJI l.!ll:i.l ~~I 4L.o~I L>-4~ ..)~ 1-!l~ -~~k. <JA L>-l?i
~ l...w_;fo w ~ ..1.>-i ~ ~6.. L>J-:= ,11ll Conrad Black l.!l)4 .ll~fi .;l.li ~
~ J,lbi Lo Hollinger r>L:.~ ~~as-~~ wlS' Lo~ J ~ '}14 ct:ub!
~~ as'~ 1-!l>l:, ~ ~ .<<Corporate kleptocracy u,c~I as'~~»
a:i~ ~JAi .;'}]J..) '\•,··._.,«a .!.;.!,o u 4 ~ » ~ ~ i i.;'}]J..) n, '\o·
.. ~
U ~ J uL.u~_, ~l:J L)-l_;W ul...u..l. W ul.; '}1..9...ul wa'}]i_., (Yl:1.;j.1J..>-11 CU.)~

~.jlJjfi ~..) Loi .(Kirby, 2009) L&,o..1;.; "'.! <?11 c\S'~I ;;~lhf ~
· ... ,A , , c-:-'""
u..,:,- ; 1." 4 '.>---4-":. ~ Tyco ~
.< ·l.:i.t <.S~I
- .. ~. 'I Dennis Konlowski
~..)-'
l...u_;fo ~'}]J ~ ~ I ~l+JI 4-J_j..U u~J>AAJ ~ j ~ W ~_)Ai .)'}]J.l

<?11 ; ; ~ I ~ ~ ~.;~I"..)~~~ ~JAi .;'}]J..) w~ ~..91-!l.;.,_,_,;,_,
~ I ~ t ~ I o.;~~JAj.)'}]J.l "\, • • • ~JcU4JJ ~ ~'-«>:•of
.(Maremont and Cohen, 2002) .;lAJ~4 c(g.?-j.11
~J .u~I y ~ rl~I ~y.,., ~ ~.,..Jl ;;~I~ ..)_;Jo u'}]b..1-!J~
i
rl..1;.; cul ~.J---'-" L)~ ~_,.I.I~ FY wl 'i_., uLJo.al ~ ~
<a C f$
...\..Li u~I
• ~~.;I~ Fol~ u~ ~ aJ..)i f=..14i-' ~Uo_., <JA ~ c.:,11 ~..)_µ a ~
~lfo- ~ ~I.; ~ll.&.o Cdforensic accounting ~~I a+u,l>..1.1 u:-:.rc<>i ~
u~j.ll .ll~i ~~ ~lj.:i 1-!l~_, ,~_,.I.I u ~ ~ ~.J---'-"6.. ~I...H w'll
f$ ..
ul.b~ ~ \l_;Jo ~ wi u ~ I ~ ~ ~J .ulo...l>JI "~ r~ ~I

.JLib~I _.,t <J:1.A~lS' ~~ ~~ wi 0J.l ~_,.I.I
~ w~ .ll~i ..).P."-J ~ <?11 ~~I~ y.;~I u'}]b.. <JA ~...Lt.111.!l~
House of Commons r~' ~ ~J) !..LAS'~ ~ I ~4d.l..9 0...u.l ~~
~ ~~ls:.11 '-'"".;l...u.l ~Li.Ai~ ~l..9 ~ ·(LG.?-i t-9l_j-4J ;;~I as:LJ.I ~
~I ~~t c--4 1=~1 "~ Catholic School Board in Toronto ~J..)Y
u~I ~ wal..>-'-"lJ ~ r~
~ r::9l.i..A..9 ~b.A ~.;W ~..u ~.JJI_, ~ I
-~_;~ ~~I u)G..,>ll..9 4.:,1~1 u4~1_., ,~l..ul ~L.-lll u~~
<JA L>-l~IJ ..1.>-lyl ~ ..1.>-l..9 r~ ~ ~_;..1:i d..4.6.. ~L...iA':JI ~ ..J-A.C ~
~.J.IM;,~~--..-~f'. ~~~.. , ., ._.; '_. .
~t~... . , . . , . _ ~ . , . . , . J O . ' : l . . ~ ~ ~ 9 V l . , ; • , L , o ; , . . L ~ o r . ~....... ~-:..:.."Ca>.--1.Q::it'-~·~--.....~
V\ ~~ 4.1.a.9 ~ ':f~I Lo.9 Q ~ faU :ul.J::a.at ~ J~!., 4.4.J~t

j ·I .;__;.,) .-;-:; ; , ·-:·< , .. ·=· z,·,:: .. .- ;=h-f;"=;:-.1 i'·;.:: · ··:·:,• l.i :(,·· i/,;:==: ~ 1.JJ(·:··. ..- ~ v=-1 ·. -~.:. ,:: · _-.....-,·= ... ·1'.,·.··:·:=.1 ·.,.,)· ·=.-.:[ .-, _;: .. ··::: · '".::-··;: ·=.:_::., (. ,._. ....._.. (:·.-.·: ·, 1',M 0'· :.- .. ,,.-; ;:~ .,. 1·, 1'/ ,;t' ·/r "=.:·=:=... ::~ ·'::.-.· ., •-r ::. ,, ( ·.. ·,··= =-·{·:'.....::.===.-(,·. ··1 · ·-> ···., ....., ·.·..) l \·1·.,,···;D··"/"=·y.:,-:. j
,~Wt ~~t i,>A ~ t

.)_;~tz.........., oJl.., Bernie Madoff ~J..)l-4 ~.J-:H Jl:Loi 0-4 ..)l~~I ~ t ~
~~~I 0-4 ~ ~ ~i .)~J Earl Jones~.?.- J.J--:!lJ Allen Stanford
,.-::~
~...- tl.J~I..Lw·l ·
- u C~-':IJ '"' -~~
~~la.d.l.~ ~ - ~'UI _; ~~I
:~bll u~~I t~I W::PUI ~~I ~J
- ~ J <.>.!~ 1.,...... :,0.!J ~~I ub~IJ ~I~ J ~ I -
-~~ ub~0-4~..u Lo~_,:;-
~ J ~ I C.:.,J..) ~UI ul_;~~I ul..o..1>- C.:.,JA~ W:!.:UI ~~'}II ~_;la.A-
- ~ l ub~I
.J~~ ~~ tJS.,JI <J-4 ~~~~I~..) q~j sutl ~ ~ ~jS'

:~~W ~ ~bll ul~IF.-t'IJ
.a..-.,,1_, ~~ ul~J a.a.,_y:. as'~~ ~ I -
.4:il..o..1>-J 4:i~J ~UI _;~I u b ~ ~ ~ ..1.1_j.ll ~ ~ I -
.~L.u ~>W- c.:.,..o u~ji ~ r~ c.:.,i c;lUI _;Llu..uJI c.:.,..o ~ I -
. ~tl..o .)~ .(>A~
-~('j.(.)::I l.!.\:il.) ~ , ~ ,-
-- d -
,~,..rt ul:i>"' i.>A ~ t

~Jll ~ll.J--"" w,.o ~ I ulS:A14 G~ (Rosenbaum, 1976) ('Jl..+sJ..i> ~~t
~1~1..r?-1 ~ weighted application black ~b.i.U tJ-4ll ~I'-""~ ~4,-.;J rl...Gt::i.u,4
- -~ (.)..,....-:,
-~I-,_.:. •,.II:- •• .JJI ~-'I . ~LLJJ Lll
~ - :r U::' . ~ aJJ .,l:,c.J • .• ~,~.q l.u;.I
..J ~.,... .) ..
swhistleblowing uWu....tt iJ,1:, ~1t
«~_,j 5w, ~ I J_,.i ~ ,J.,LlJI tl..J.>.11 ()Aj ~»

Gorge Orwel JJJ).J f ~..JY.-
VY
u ~ I ~ .:ilw.4J~ 4.4.J~I
c::--,-~r-.'·=J}.-, .. · .. -r-, . ·:.--·.·..... ,·,.· .. -·:-.-.-.· .. · .-:.··. ~.-·-:,:.7•.0~~"-70;7,;-~:---~~;: .. -···h?:' .. · ..~····>( .·.-.. ·,1-:{J.':: -::zr2E7WPi~-"-~'!-'."~~:-'.":z:::::::::rJ:1
whistleblowers uWL:.:.11 ~ ~?14 ~ w,4.4 ~~ c!J~ Time ~b ~ u.;lD.I

u:JfiJ Worldcom r~ ~.JJJ ~~~~<?I Cynthia Cooper ..Hfi ~ ~J
u~J FBI ~.lL:i..:i'il c.:.,I ii.:ii:,c.jjl ~ ~ ~ < ? I Coleen Rowley <:r-1J.J
·rr· · r r~c.:.,1.:,o;.,~.<Enron u~i~~~~<?I Sherron Watkins~!_,
~ ~?JI (Miceli, Near, and Dworkin, 2009: 379) ~.JJ.lJ~J ~ ~y:.
J:,L..u _,i ~6.. ulo.,-o ~ Lo~ uWWI ~ ~?JI c!J~» :~tJ4 c.:.,WWI
~ ~1.)o~ ~~~ ..,t ¥>bi~ ..,i c.:,j,Ull L.4l~ a.:4.:Jon c.:.,Uo~
c.:.,Wo.iJ.I c.:.,WWI ~ t_)4?JI ..u:.~ '-¥ y~I FJi ·<<~~! c.JJ·.:bi«,2 ~i
~ <?I JLAS~I .lJ.l.J t-'-4-' ~.,11 ~L.a.; o.l4.)J ~ I J JUI~ JoLb.JI ~
c.:.,WWI ~ t.~?JI ~J.>: ~ .a.:4.:loiiJI ~l_jlll <JA~ J;.....Gll ~ ~ µ I
j-J_,b:'11_, c_:,Jl.:.UI ~'"e roi\tJ '=' 4.!J;, iiJI ~ ~.JJ.>--'A J-'bJ d..4.&,ll c.:.,l.o..,W4 4lo..UI
~ i~ ~ uWo.i..tl ~ i r...Lii:i ':J ~J .(Armenakis, 2004; Martin, 2009)
u4~J «o~tw.l» c.:.,t:g_,~I ~ c.:.,4~ ~lji ~~ i~ '="4.:Jo;;JI ~ I J ~
c.:,f y ~ I c.J.A ~ , l.:.U .c.:.,W\..;.,11 ~ ~?JI ~J J-'bJ ««~I c.:.,t:gJi» ~ ~f
~ .uW\..;.,11 ~ ~ I u--4 I ~ ui ~ ~.,-o <)J~...u.l c.J.A ill t:7= /·,2
~ (Miceli, Near, and Dworkin, 2009, 2008) ~.JJ.lJ.J--:-lJ yl.: «·.:" r..i9
: ~ ~J ~LUI ~_,JI~ c.:.,WWI ~ e_)4?JI c.:,~ c.:.,\ 4Joi~ ~~I
-WoL;. -I .. i · Lo~ c.:.,WWI ...
· . >Ll t _-:_ • • ~ - r lii:lj'il t:--'-4
·
J-A uJJ--: ~ ~ . ~ u-" - :J-J..,
~I.~ r..:-~··· '-WI ~r• ,... -t lii:lj'il ~..,~
· -~ ~I a,j~ ..l.4J. a.b.u · 'I c.:.,L..ul.u.u
.r.r · -
- ~_,.,..,
~ ~_jl.l ~U rlii:ljl c.JJ~ c.:.,~)UI c4 J.ol.ull a.:,;f ~ <)J~...u.1 '-:-U_.;..DJ
_µl~I ~...Lii:iJ ~~~I~ t.>4~ ul~ ~~u ~I~ ~J c.J.A ~~~I
.4.Ab 4.JLl.a.J .e ~I~~._'::\ -= .-:--:ti c.:.,~~ t..u ·- t
- . "'?J r..:- ~ J . '-:?" - IJ""
Richard Colvin~_,S'~.;Lli:i.;~~l~Lo-'"4...ulr..i9«r '1' • • °'r~~_,:,.#,~

Canadian House of Commons ~~I r~I ~ c.:,4,J lS.J.>.! rL.oi o.l~
J~ ~ ' J a..oµ, o..)l:g c.J.A ~..u.JI w,,11 r r · · v r~ ~L..u.;b, rl:g c.:.,lfi.JA c.:,~
c.:,w~I . l ~ f-84.!I «rri ~ ~.:.UIJ ~~I ul-.,.all ~ <)A c.:,wi J ~ u~L&:ul
u-" , - ~ ~ ':r"' 0:
.~c-t u· 1 .'--«.).J.Lill
. ~ _,, .,,.. _._.~ti -:.,t . .:.u1 u· w~I J-1- .- ~'i ~ .~c-i · -
\ J-1- ~.J-A-1 f--1:. __J
~ ~ .c.:,~Uo ~.l~ c.J.A l~J ~.;l_j.J.IJ o.?.-~I c.:.,I.;~ ~Lc.u c.J.A ~...u.1
··-'' r .,1.ajl~·-t"
u.,.- . --~d...l~1a...,.c-_,,
~..,~~Jr..:- - ~ ~ ~ ~~
·-1~:j t ... ·~!t~;;~t~:. -
l.(t-UI.)~
<?' a.o~I ~ Ci.4Jl ,~~ ~ ~->1JJ .4.<'~I ~ r~ ~.;WI ylj.>.~

.. ~ ~ ~ ~ ' 1 : ' , - . r :..•v.-..-...·.,:"l;y:I.-A,·/#J/).\.-..-,v;:"'l,-."7.l,Tf.'•'•4·~~~.;\11Ar4'\&.'l"~'-'.IO~'l,,~....w«it.Q',.-;.-.-L"...'!'r·?:;.~~'n,......:-.•-'...:-..........~~~~~.....~~
V'(' ~~ 4.1.aa ~ i.i~I l..oJ l!I~ fall : u ~ I ~ ~'""'4J~ 4.4J~I

~ J~4 41~ ~LA~~~
o.:i.l~ 0~ - y_,kJI 0-4 -Ub ~LA~~
~ . l ~ 0-4 0-4\:ill ~J . (Brennan and Woods, 2009) ..:.,\~I 0-4 _.# ~
-
~ L ~ I JAW ...U.:O[~' a..J~.) ,~~ ... ~, y~ LAt9JrY· •\ r~
;;.)1.)., ~ ~WJ ~ a.JL..u.) r~ 4£.A JA~I y..,lu,i 0i c.)1 ,_,.)La:ut ~ ~lS'
rY· •\i.~~.l~<JA~tJl~J .W~l..:.,l~~l..:.,~!c.)l~..1:i~.J~I
Walter Natynczyk l.!L~w fallJ Canadian Forces ~...LAS:JI ..:.,l~I ~[g ~.lt
~ " ' ~ c.:Jl_jLA r r ·, · r~ J..iY.l ~ ~., .~lS' ..:.,\~~.), ~JJ ..:.,b~
~...LAS:JI ~ I ak~4 ':?-'~I ~ ls,J~ t ~ I ..:.,~ 0.J~ ~ ; ; ~
.)~ 0---A ~ . ; J I ~ Canadian Military Police Complaints Commission
..u: .(Voltairenet. org, 2010) cG:l.iH -l~,u.aio ~lS' JI..H ~ ~ , ~ L..,WI
~Jll y~I 0-4 ; ; ~ 4':.~ ~ cib.. ~L:, .i9_, ..:.,W~ l~w ~lS' -
~WI ~I~ .~lS'J.L9 LJ:&.o i o\bo l ~ u , l ~ ~ ~ ~ i f i ~ ~ ~ I
~ <1~l....A»~ ~ i J ~ ..:.,I.J~ ..:.,W~I ~ ~ I 0-4 ~LuJI
k:.,~I ~ ':?~ L A ~ ~ ~j.A ~ I~ . (Martin, 2003) J.>.b.11
rJ 0:.JJI ~lS' ~~_j Jwi .lJ.l.J JA ~LlA~ ~.JJ .,~>lJ~ JA LA_,

)L_,b ~J ~~ ~ ~.J.>JI 0-4 ~ I i.J3~ .~""":' l-'94~ _,t ~ l~I~
0~~ ~i .,i ~~\.Z.tl ~IJ.)J ~Uoj 0\...w 0-4 u~b_., L..,WI ~J.)i ~
4 i L . . .cJ\ •. t\a..u...GA~Uo
·~!'lS'
~
,,..
i.r- ~ \--V---r
·-,,tl~~i~,t.;;,., :.- "
~ u-' ., • »- - ., <.r~ti,--:.~,,
u----w
~~ ~...LAS:JI ~,~, r~ ~ .':?...LAS:J1 0~l4l1 ~ ~~ J~ .l~J r~.,
..:.,i:~_,llS' ~..»i ~I.Ai~ ~l~I ~ JL>JI JA ~ ..:.,W~I ~ ~ o.>---!fi
. J.pl..r'""lJ ;;~I
'i'< I II i ,~,!.P." U.P." ;;ts~~ .;;~ ~~ ..:.iW~I ~ ~ ' ~~ ~ J

,Pfizer ~.l)U ~~ as'~ ~J.l ~~ ..:.,~ wilo-'94 JAJ ,John Kopchinski
.as'~I ~ ..:.,W~ . , ~ ~~~~.)a~ ~JAi .J~J.l 0~ o, , o ~
Bextra I ~ [ ~ J,J~ ~~~as'~ U.t_)o ~ 'i'< ,,. ;,:.,!.P." ~ ~
...u.:o ~~ ~~..1:1 r..\.Ai, 1.JJ . ~~,~~~.;JI Fas-~, u~ ~ ~
i.r-1,.. ci:ik.J JA .,~ l La.A ~
1 -· 11 • ~ • ~ as' :. ~[g JWI
(>A • »: 'J-'-" '-r· J .as'·~
.:..t\
~~I~ o.J.A ~J ..:.,IJ-L'-1' eu.u o..u. J:,LuJI ~I.J c.:.J:; Y.J~ LA~ .l~~I
~LA~\ ~~~~J,J~I ~-'94 0,A cl 1110;,_J'i'(,11ic~•i!.P." ..i.u.........ul . ~ I
u ~ t ~ ,)l.w.,.U!J 4 , ~ I
~ ~ - ,.•.;:••.•: , . S 0 " 2 < 4 ~ . . . ; 4 . ; . : . . ~ 2 L L : . ~ ~ & i ~ ? " ' ; . ? ~..;-..Z1k:Z.ZJ;.:..:..~:~.;;,*~~-.:..0...:....•..:.........·. .·-,.:": ··.~]
~i ~.:.ut., US False Claims Act ~lj.JI al~~.l>Ll o~I a~~_,JI w~l:! c.;r--11
.w~~I aW~ r'+..,.,:os ~ w~~ ~ J ~ I ~~1 -ll~~I
.>:!:b 0A ( J ~ ~,.,., d..:t~ ~.) ~J» ~~'

J>l,;. "~, LlJJ.A 1...9_)-JJ~
.(Schwartz, 2004: 324)«l.A ~ J i a~~l_,i~.,.tl c.!l_,k,~jLJr'~
.>:!:w1., J ~ ~ JA LA_, J ~ JA LA ~t ~ , ~ ~, J>l,;. ~, aw_,J.A r.;-!J
ti .. "
L. ..u I._-: 'I ·. .< -"':" I · r~•.-. • •·· ! t ._ • 'I
~ - '..J- ~ _ ; - - , ~ ~ . , . . . ~
w Ll~- c.\..:,..• :JJ- cJ• I '-',;t:.J -: t I -
• • - ~ \---=- J
,:: tI
aS'~ '• • ~i iJ.4 "/.oA ~ Ja: ~ LA LG...U ~ i ,w~I ~ ~>l,;.~I c.!l.,.LuJI
.(Kapstein, 2004) d..:t~ J>l,;.i awJJ.A ~~
a~~ aw.,...u.l r'..L4i .J>l,;. ~I wWJJ.A ~..L4i ~I ~l.Ji:,_,JI 0A ..l~ c.!l~

a.J~I ~ aLl~I ~~ F..,:; ~.J..u:. l.!.U~J ,11.;·, u,c l;_u~ll ~ls..l 'a ti ti
..ll~~I e l s ~ ~ wi ~ ~I ~IJ al;g>l,;.~I~ ~ . (Stevens, 2009)

~i ~ . .ll-.will 0-4 J14i 0i ~ ~i '.'! 0i ~ .aS"~l '=7'9 '".' ~ l,g.J
Jb:i~I J>l,;. iJ.4 J>l,;. ~I a..iJ.J.4:' ~.,JIJ ~>l,;. ~I o.l~I a..;J...L41.J ~...ul .J-l~
Wb ~1~ aS'~I ~ .l~ ~I ~till!_, r~~.>:!:WI J .!.,.,.;;_,.; Q; ,1111
~J ~.)w~<::9 a..iJ...u.l ~ ~~a~'-4j ~., ct.AWi ~>l,;.~I ~..l4J.1
'?'4~1 aS'~I r'~ <::9 J>l,;.~I a..iJJ.A i.>"~J J>l,;.~I a..iJJ.A ~j.J.J.aJJ ~ . J
. (Mays, 2009; Weaver, Trevino, and Agle, 2005)
u,c al~» o~I a~~_,JI ~ a.! ,,..!~.) .)Lu l,g.J ~~ ~ ~.).) ...1......4l
tj!J .J..u:. l.!.U~_., o..l~ ~ w~b. ~ l.!.U~J ~ . , . t i ~ ((~I a~>l,;.i
r'll LA.J..u:. ~~.,i ,«~-llJ>-» ~)Ci wl~I LG~l afi~ - ~ J ~~1 ~..lly,-
':?.:.UIJ aS'~I a ~ ~~J .b.l at:,,; .... cs~ ~l..1.4>1 alllk:i ~~ ~411 ~t
uJ-:1.) .)~j ~ • ~1..1.6,11 "4,.:i ~ I al......u~ ~411 fi~J ~1..1.4>?}1 al:!lk:i ..l~i
~.) LAJ,A_.,cll a.JJ-4-C ~.J.AiJ.,l..u~I w ~ ~1~~.Jt;.,;.! ,,.cGi~
~~Jw~J-4-Cw~ILG.b.!~w~~Jylb~i .w~IJJ~
~ ~ ~ 1.!.U~ 0-4 ~ ~ ~I '-'""J.J..UIJ . c.!l.,.LuJI l.:ui , .• : ... _, ~ iJ.4
--~-~.-..._......,.."'<."·"'.' •~··"'._.Q-...,...... <.--..w:·~f,J'.,..,.,._..~.u.v...-~- ... ,;a.. , . , : - · . , , . z ' ; , ; . N ~ ~ - : r . - « ~ ~ ' : ' t " : : ' . x . - x ~ ~ - · . : J•.,,._--;,-·-~=-'"v'M··-.·~2,,··:"Lv,i
vo ~~ 4..Lt.9 ~ 1$~1 LA..9 c,~ l~U : u ~ I ~ ~~!J 4.4.J~t
J ~ I ~~t <JAJ , J ~ I ~ t.Hlll4Jl J~I ulo.,.t.l l.!l~~ lA ,JLJJ.I
.,~ ~ , L.d_jA ~ J , 4.,lk..o
c.ill::i 0lS' 1::i1 'Y! Q.:t;, ;;11 ~)l;. ~' 1.:-U_,...L&J1 ~
~ ul.b~I J_p, u~)Lo 0-4 ~..u lA JAj 0~.,.t.l uloi , "- ~ J ~IJ.fll
¥)l;.~I ~ ul#~I .,~ ~ I ~J '"~1 ~1 ul~I ~ ~~ -~~WI
-
• ~.>AJ 0 ~ -IJ-"llo
idi _c.i~~t o~L:.~t

~wt y.;•i ,cell 0-4~ ,l.:U . u ~ I ~ L:!,WI u ~ I LJA~I J~:"
..>L:ui .Jl:---,uJI I.J.A ~ Lo~I '"Li.A~I ~ '"~iJ ~~I <J->->:..ul ..>~ .JJ.l
~ l.!lllA wL:t ,(Schwartz, Dunfee and Kline, 2005) ~%J ~J.lJ _j.j.JI~
rl.i=J'il '"Li.A~I w-J~ '"~lJ ~~I 0-J->:..ul ..>l..# ~ ~ ~..> ~
wl.4J~ lAi .Llbl.,llJ a.tlJ.AllJ 4J~IJ ~)l;.~IJ ~lj..i.JIJ a.:sLA~I ~ J ~
o ~ IJ.l~ (Freeman, Moriarty, and Stewart, 2009) u..>l~J c;;)..>-'"4J
a.J~ 1.!JllA ·(S 11,0·,t o.lWI '"'ij.A~ ~ J 0-4 c..tlJjJ ~)l;.~I o.lWl ~'.?.
~JG~~ .lyill ~I.J-4:> c..tlJj t~ ~ ~)l;.i ._dtg ~1 J_p::&.11 ~ a.:: ,u·,
t \_j,J·f u:,--,
·.:.Hq .<'::i
y. ~
.·~!t-:.:.._q_t~\w~lo\.:...:i
~ C"" • • ~ .:\.Jwio\.:...:ia..J.~
• ·--t\~~
- '.j..,..-......
~ ~ ,(,j ~1 IJ..>La:uiJ (S cc,:.·.~ U)~~ 0t o.lWI ~~~I a..lLi.u~I
~J ,\s cc,:.;t ~ J ~ I ~ 4 ~lj:JI lSJ.A..>~'i ~&iqJ;,;4 ~~~.,.t.l
wJl..r.'J w~..>U)J J.:i.:a.uJ r.,1g ,~t .(Kochan, 2003) 0L:ufi U)..u~ ~I ~ I
lfj)l;. 0-4 t.:bi '"- ~I ul~;ll ~ (Trevino, Hartman, Brown, 2000)
. ~)l;. i o.l~ ~ si, Q.c.11 '"Li.:, 0JJ:..U I
r · · i ,Grohean et al. 0J.>-->-iJ ~..>.?. ,Jl:J.I ~ ~ ) 0~T ..>La:ui lAS'

~l..>J r · · o ,Moore ..>-'"4J, r · ·, ,Meddonca ~_,:,JJ.AJ, r · ·V ,Gowri ~..>~J
~ i '"'..>J ~ <>"L.ui .l.P.-J ~1 (Wright and '1'· ·V ,Goodstein ~~.l.P.-J
~I ~~I 0-4~ .l...u:. ~~~J ·¥)l;.i ~~ '"~~¥)l;.~I o.l~I.JJ.l
·<Y°l~'il I.J.A ~ lSJ.A ~
0::' ~)\..all ~..D a....;,1..l-:A a.bl (Neubert et al., 2009) wJ.>-->-iJ u.;.!:.:; r~
r1-:~t'l'IJ ~
'J-""
\ '"W,~J Ll)l;.~I
- · t~ - ~-·I ~
· u~Lb:t'il
. J Ll)l;.~I
- o.l~I
-
- -
ulS'~ ~ ~ ~~ ~-'"4 ro · 0-4 ulA_,1.A w~J.l.l ~ .~WI '='"Q.:t;.;;JI
uL41:t.Ut ~ J~~ 44.J~I
,~,:<.vh/,r' :)....-,:..-i§'"/l"i:''·:·.?;·_;·:;f...:·.-.+-..-. ··r·. ,.,.,:"·''ff'._··..• :;·-~-. M;n<· ,.!7~· ·.··u··-~ ··...~-, . ?' ·.;.,-JbrF•»:.;-j,j'tfr'" -.z· AA I)'# ~~.;.;1. :~~.;:1-.~r..-:-r':Ii·k~ 5.f"•{•'-. ..;=.• ;:V•v: . -'•fr·=··e=· A-/,'4
iy~ra 4t,;;~t
~ 1 ~µ1 c.:..--A~i ru~_,-j~u,,o0-J~1.,t=t1>11 ~ rr· ·°'
~ l.!.U~J ~ ~ ~p,,~IJ ~ I [bj)' ~JJ-4 ~~ w..1,:i,.i ~
~ I J~0:4'1l:ll 4i.llo 0)4..>,ll ~~i -~.,.UI JLi!o~I ~ t#~ W.;J.l
l.!.U~ 1..Pi .4UI ~lS:A D.ll:j ~i 0-41.!.U~J~~I i.S~ t:9.; ~1 ,.,S.li L4.A
~,~ ~~ ~ ~ J 0-J.J>i r• •, • · • W:0>4J ~~I~ JLUoi ~ ~ ~1
-~~~~r~i~.;~~ -~~15.,1$'Jl~l_,i~I -
, -
~4~~ w..1,:i,.i .<J:4...>,110-4J:gia.;,~r~i~ 1 ~ ~ p , , i
~ ~., r'~i ~ LJ::1 r.,1) ~ 4 r~i ~ wJ?i ~., ;;4>J1 ,.,s.J.A
~i .~I~~ L~i ~ rlS:.>.~l tt.JA .(BBC News, 2009e) Lk.
~ ~ ; ; ~ I ~1_;--b)U JUI ~.,s:.:..JIJ a:s>WI ~I~ ~lS~I u,,o ~ ~..LS
~\:!as'·
.
.:..t - WI
'J-' ~
':. ti rl~I, f"'- , ~ ;o.l6.. <.r-'
O"':P..J"' · .Ll~I
- t.?-' k....ul ~.)
·
F- t.?JL..1u.; .u~ ~~ ~J 0i ~ Li Peiying [ ;.!.!! ~ J-AJ ~.,s:.:..JI \ 8<\;4;
~...>Ai .;'iJ.l 0 ~ , , , r u-"~1., ~...>Ai .;'iJ.l 0 ~ r, v y.;~ L A ~
.(Guardian, 2009)
"?~ .;'iJ.l 0~ ,rA , A ~ ~UI ~~I ~Luu.uj..ll u,,o .)~ f->_;.i:i ~ ~

Jl.;J~4 ~~..u.1 J~~l .;~I ~ ~\.+--.ul ~ ~wL=c.o w~ CGJk..l ~
f"~ ~i . (Yew, 2009) f" 't' • • v rk. <t>asset-backed commercial paper ~~I
Toronto Dominion Bank ~J.J-'3 0J:-LAJ.l ~.l-'4-4 t~ ~~I ~.;~IF
a..,1:g. tt <-t-JL.ui ~~I . ~;; · -<~ .. ~\:!'-4;.I .l
• 'J-' •• J I.:'"~ · t L.w
'~.,.. --~- 1L~~
·~- · }\.A V u• .J.lL.
P"'j ~ .igJ .(FSA,2009) D.)~l 4UI ~~I.).!• c,jJ '-6,AJ;.j cer,:~I
• ~ .?.L:; ~I 4UI Jl.;J~I ~ 0~ 0-J...?."tJ.1 ..1,:i,.j y~ ~~I ~ll'-4;. 'ii
- lt
0-4 'i~ I~~ l.!.U~ ~ 0i w ~:ll ~ LA.r.C-4 ~ 0t ~.>: 0--4
t$
DJ.ALJA -I~ J....l i I~ ~~I r~I' DJ.A <)I' 1.·: "'.' l.!.U~J ,;;~I ~L:'i.,JI
-----"",4-........-."""•.,!lo'\;~.,Xt'>A.:.w....,;;;-.,,"".#- ~~~~~I'..1~ ,,.....,_~.,._"l.!W',•.:J(.....-.11'_,..~,~.~-----
vv ~~ 4.La.9 ~ '?.:ill LA.9 c,..l>J faU : u ~ t ~ ~l.wwil!9 ~~t

R~·0.-.~.-.. . ~~·-~;·' · : , 1 : · · · ' ) ~ ' ' .. i::.;.( 1. •.'·.',"',·:· •. ·.-·i·:,, . ._.:-·/ :_., ·.-'·.~.r, ~;·.·,, (· ··.,·,. ·.":\·.-··.·,·:r:.,( ... ~_./ . ." ·;·,, ... ,.. , ~ ,,,, ' 'I ~ '/ L '.,·.~,(-' r.,,.,, . . . . -,.•,:.:y1.:.;·,',",·.,,.,:·;··,·.•:-.-•.>'//';,•;-:,~r:.-[.j
,,
David Radler >bl,; ~ . . l ~ ~ :~tJI ~JA'b .o~I ~l:~.,.tl ~~I
[ ~ ~ ~ ,;~ o~ ~J o.J.>.IJ J~I ~ ~ ~ w,J~J ~
- - - -
~ ~ ~ J u l i u s Melnetizer .>J..J'.!;.!lia <>".,:l.P." lAi . ~ I 0A ~~
J~J..l 0~ '\V ~ ~ J J~I ~ ~)J ~)tj ·.·: "'!~I~ ~1..9-'-'-"
~T ~ ~ J - ~ J <J:A~ ~ ~ I 0A ~~ [J.»- ~ ~ J '-?JJS
J~J..l 0j:l.o lA,;l...1.4.A 4-Al~J ~ I ~ , ; ~ ~W:i Alan Eagleson UJ "'.!''?C:l
~ I 0A JA~ ~~ [~ ~ ~ J J~I ~~6.. ~ ·.·: "'! l.!.U~J '-?JJS
~ ~1_,.i-.u ~~ Harold Ballard J,;~4 ..UJ,;lA ~ ~ J - J ~ ~ ~
c.:,k~J .~l~o.J.>.IJ~~JJ~IJ~..>-"~~)J~·.·: '"!
J-AJ J~I ~ ~ ~ ~1_,.i-.u ~ Garth Drabinsky Y!~ '" i!l,;J ~,;4-,
ui~l~~l_,.;-,~cyk~_,lJ . ~ l ~ ~ I ~~l[,;~u~I
,,
l:Jb.. ~J ~ ~~4 ~l.;..l r..l.ii -llJ · J.>.IJ r~ J>L;. ~ 1 iJA [ ~
~ 1 J>-J: 0 t ~10A ~ ,1.:u .aJ~ ~ 1 [J~ (r ~~ ~.Jb:i) r·, ·
, I..J..iS' ~ ~l,;J ~ ~ I iJA J.>.IJ r~ ~ ,J.,Li.ll ~ ·'-:-'->~I J:iii ,ull ~
- - - -,,
~l:~_,.11 ~ ~..J \"'.!;;.! '-?JJS ~IJA ~J ,Edward Okun ufiJl J,;IJ..ll c.;,1:. ~
~~lJ~IJ.J-Ab~w,J~J~)Ci~~~J~l~r~~~,o~I
~J -~..;,Ai .;~JJ 0j:l.o , n ~..>-"J .;.i) o..l~J '-:-'-1...>+iJ JIJAi ~ J wire fraud
0~~ t ~ r..l.ii ~J-'-'-' ~i <.)1 ~~1 4-4..,s:.:..JI ~.;Ll.i r r · · °' r~ .r.>.,::&t ~
. white-collar criminals ~..,s:.:..JI ~.,.ti 0A ()._\A~I ~4~ oJ~
~b.;~IJ ~UI Jl.;J}U o~I ~~~_,JI~ ~1 ~l..>:~I iJA ..l~ ~ J
~J..llA J.;w.r.> ~lbLla:J u~ US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
o~l~..D ~L.......u -~__,.il4~~'-?i~~ ~JBemardMadoff
a~.!"' <>".J..D ,~.:u ~~IJ ·1..?.J-Abll ~J.llA ~ ~1 r~ ~ o~LlS:.ll ~ J
~_,.I.I '-:-'-1.J...cJ «J~~ ~ » ~Lc:i,jl ~b.;~IJ ~UI Jl.;J}U o~I ~'=~_,JI
~JA 0A, • . ~1 ~.).l r" .. °' ~ ~ .J.i..oJ ,J~~1 ~ ~~, ~
~~ ~~ o~ LA4Ji o.;bl ~~i 'tr· · C\ r~ ~~ ~ ~J -~~ ~
.~UI J~~I ~ 4-A.;b ~1~1~1 ~~IJ a..,..,\.;..u
~~I d.J:.~ ~ J:...l.!. ~~ ~~ .15...u.l o ~ ofil.:UI 0l J~ ,u.c.u~I ~
~ l A ~t:; "4] 0~ ~.,-..u, ~l.;.l ~ <i'1' ~l~l ui ~ '-?.:UIJ J:~I
u~I ~ ~lw.il!J ~~I
r~rm&-~~2:r::r;~-23s:r>.:,,;~;;~l.:7IJ~11:'il:.=~~,2to ~:. ."}~~·/L.~'t.!Ji:);.~~~--~,~~;~tr~'"~i:..;~~~..~. .::~~1.:2~-;: .-~,·. ;.-.. ;$~·~z~::~~:n:lE'l!ill
1
~.,JI ~1.l~ Wall Street e u ~ J . H 0i . J A ~ ~.J....J\..g .(Rosen,2009)

• .l~l~WI
LAJ-l-.)-43 Transparency International ~J..ul ¥ ~ 1 a qJ;,;o w ~

dJJ.l ~ J ~LA LJA _;oi ~ rWI t ~ I ~ . l ~ I w ~ u-c, ~~I
~~ » <Gl:, . l ~ I ¥ ~ I ~ ~~ . ( de Sousa and Larmour, 2009)
~~I ~J~I o~_; ,Jl:J.1 ~ ~ .((a.!«obu:u t-9La rWI ~ I r l ~ I

~.;J ~IJ d.AWI -l_;l.,.._11 LJ"")l:G..IJ ,w~LalJ wl~l..b.£11 ~ w'i~I f:>.J.AiJ
¥LL:&Jl~~j.A~~ .a~ .. :.,JI .l~,~~w~~~_;~I~
i.l~ w w~ I .,.:u. r.J.Ai . Jg~ I ~ _;.ll.&.o.A 4:i>G LJA ~ I ~I 1.Sl,J o.)..LL&A w6..J-'-"A
.,.:u.~ -~J..UIJ~l .l~l~~iLJ.Al.!.U~Jo~l~l~~lo--4
.. ? ..,, - ~
ww_;l.a.ll:, ~ l:.)~ l~j.A r.J.AiJ dJJ..ul ~ .l~I w ~ wL.u~ ~I~ ~I
~1 ~~1 ·LJ.AjJI !SJ.A~ dJJ..ul p-b Ji r.J.Ai ~_,:; ~ I LJA ~..J JJ..ul ~
.4WI ~.)L.u:9 w ~ ~ dJJ~ JJ..ul ~ ,l.!.U~
~rJ Lll:, ~ I a .!ql•JI w'iL4LIJ WL.-.:,oJI w'iL.;J.~l..>-4~

~ ~..H w ~ ~ w ~ dJl..a..o u:uWJ ~LI. I S ~ ~ J~ LJA •L.J.4i
1-!.LuJljJ .,G~ LJA JS'~ rJ Forbes ..H..>~J Fortune ~..>~J Business Week
~l--4 ~ o~I ~l¥JI ~~I ui ~ a.....bf ~i (Hannah and Zatzick 2008)
~ LJA wWo..al o.ll4l ~ I > ' ~ ~ ~b l,&l ulS u-,~IJ ...1:l,..1.,JI 0.;,-ill
~~I LJA wlJ-L'-" ~ ~ l.!.U~J ~Lc.o i.S.J.A Ji ~_;J.l Ji J~ ~I 0-4 o.l\..g?/I
JS'~ ~->-11 f:>.J.Ai w ~ I o.lll ~ ui ~ ~.:.UIJ . ~ wlJ-'--'-" ~ ~J
•., I.J-'-1' LA
1-H-'-"~ ,Jl:J.I ~ ~ ) w ~ I ~ .l~IJ ~~I w~.li ~w~?JI LAi

d_;.li ..lAl -~ ~4 4.:tw.J o~ d..:i~ ~ J ~~I~ ,('f • · A ,Nocera
-
-w~I ~ ~r..1.4iJl_.~l ~ J ~J.:L'i=JI w4~J .)~I~~~ -lp-j.A
~..u w~I ~ .l.!11..lAJ llA dJ.ll-:J.I ~J o ~ I r..1.Z.11 wlA~ ~ l.!11..lA ~J
,.,.._,,._."""":w:;.,,,·~"""-~.._.._-.~~-~~-.. ..,.,,...__, .,~r-.-......"'... .___.....,...,,..~•xo....-N~-_......,.,......,., .....-...,.,..~ •.,....,.,...·,,.....:.·~·<-:.."-",4"\:.•~·-Y,Y.,,i.•,L'-~._'ltl;,,'r'_..q.,::,,.•~~~~ ~
v~ ~~ 4..1.d ~ ~~I LA..9 c,,..L,,,j faU : u ~ I ~ ~~lj 4J.._r?JI

J~~l~I
~ ~ ~ = = = · ~ . ' . " ' . 0 . " 7 ...-,--
.... ~:::;:=====-=="=--:·
. :.:·:. . ._.·:.· :.· CJ__,,.,.
~ l:!Jb. ~J: ~ • (Lefkowitz, 2009) J~IJ 4J~I y~~ ~i O..>£A

c.!ll.i.AJ,~JU' 4t;,;t\~J~\J4J~I ~~a,o,o~~i~~l
((a.!4.!0'.>-)) J)l.;..i ulsj..1.4 ;;st ul o t;, io UJ..,loJ ,<JJ~..UIJ y)lbil ~)l.;..i c ;.. .!;~;
*
uL.u~ ~~1 ~ ~\..i.ll JJ..ul ;;~w~, b ~ c.!ll.i.A 01 ~ ,c.!l_,L.sJ\ ~w
C. C. -
~i~ ~..u ,~.JS .J~\J;;~_;JI~~ ~i~->-1,\~~~jA ~ljgJ

_psi~ J~\ "~J .(Tomlinson, 2009) ~.,.t\ u~..>-'-" ~~I~
~Lor.~~J~,"~t~~J-A:0i~j.At~J .~~'~'~
u\J4> uLJo.a\ ~lji .(Friedland,2009) I~~ 051\ l.!l~I ~ l~UJ 41d
~
· 51\ ~
-~·-t\.0-4 a..u~b.
-· . ..)-'- A.·--· J~IJ 4J.~t\
.=:<j,~ ·, A~L~L• ~
~ J-'IW ~ • •
-:I.~.~
-
. (Anand et al., 2009)
~ .a~IJ uo .!"-=-oil1 ~k-.ul_;J\ ~_;Li ,~U\ ~ \ ul_,.L-uJI ~

\· ~ -
~LU\ ~ jA....JI ~ U"'\..i.ll ~ l LA...1.ls:. ~UI ~ \ u~ J.,l ~~ ~.J...->
; ; ~ \ ~~ ~ ~~J ~JI..>··~ jA....J\ ~ J ~ ~ \ ~ ~~ ~L~lJJ -
~ u..>-4JJ u ~ J ulS'~I u ~ ...L..-41 .(Allaie and Firsirotu, 2009)
ciL.uJ ~ Pope Benedict d ~ 4431 J...G ,l.:U .(Bown, 2009) ~WI ~l~i
- --
l..1.;po,J l:s..1A ~ ~..;J4 Charity in Truth (July 2009) ~ » a:tlDJI «~~,
~~ ~~ J~f.:J1 J ~ ~J ~4-uJI J;s ~ 0yWI WL.=t:..oJ J ~ l 0biJ
0i ~UI ~ \ u\~I u~l ...Lal -¥~l a.!,o;...i.:u J~>Ll 0~ 0i ~
.(Patel, 2010; Yaziji, 2008) <<~ ~4-,» L&J ~ I .}-t):.J ~4,JI 4~i_;JI
~~~by\:ai 111A~lJl&Jua!.! 111ub\..a:u~\1>~0~J~\~\~j
LJ\.;.. ~lS' LA~ <JJ~ ~ t ~WI 4k--i..ui_;JI ~ ...Lal .~k--i..ui_;JI
J4,JI ~IJ ~ ~->-1-1 yfa 0i ~ . ~ ; ; ~ ~ ~J 0~?/1 u4,.W
~ ~
~~.JS.~~\'-'"''"; '".! l..>-41 ~ J~I "~ ~WuL...:9~~JJ ,o.,d,J
- -
l&l JU\ 0~...u-J 0..t»-511 ~ Y--C-..>: L..1>- f:'~ u~lS:.1.1 ~ ~ ~ b .
. (Anderson, 2009; Crawford, 2009)
- 1-,,~, ,-,, ,.~ ... t\
• c.\.AJ u2J ~ u :,--u,,, ":r• L>-'""'-'"--, , , II J.JA t,, LJI ...L.&C.
JJ 0 '-!
- I":I'-""'
l":I ·- •• ~ :..1"1-:. -· ~
L4.&.A ~ ~ .)'U u, F L.u
·¥)l.;..f.:J\ d..:>-l.i.l\ ~ ~l.u.o u....-:,ol ulS'~\ 01 ~1~ ,~W\ ~_,JI Loi

L~\
-
~UA c..r- · U\ ~ I J ~ c--
,... '-r'"° • .. t...t\J "-:
. ~~f.:JI ~
· ·--~~t\ ~:. ...Lal
~_psi~ ~~4 ul.o~\J u ~ \ J Jl~t.:i, ~ Jl.)J ¥~t.:i, r'~'
.u~, ~~tu~~~ Jwt.:i, 0~ Wb Jla: ~J ·~Jj.-AJ ¥ ~ J
~J'~~--
~~~..,.~~,.___----~~=-='Y'-S-~-,-=>---..,,.,.,..~~-..~·~--...:-s_11._;,,... .-=.,.--1-,-~·-""~-,_~ .... -...... ~~-=.:.-~-~.:;~
'-6=>~ ~ ~ 'i.:.Lll Loj \!,.,L>J ,~u :u~I ~ ~Lw..illJ 44..t.._r?JI A•

l":'~tt~~
uL~tb,oll~~L.lWIJ~~l:,~,y~l0-4JJ~l~~l~Ll.A
-._,_. ·6:.JLu~I.'-r~.l~IJ ~--"~-t\
~J-0&-..) ... ,. ~ .... '.)-' ~
~~IJ.
~lu.u~I
. J uL-'~~,1
~J
~..LaJ yj~ ~1 . l ~ l...4J_,...:i ~~ i..i.:,L.u .y~I r~ ?JI 0-4 ; ; ~ u")}~
u~~IJ .ll.>9~1 "---'-"..;~ ~.:UI . l ~ I tl~i ~ u!,'-4:J t.!JJ~ ~ .al:iA~I ~
~ .l~l..;~4~..>-llJAl~I J : ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ I J u \ qf;,;tlJ
4:--~.:co.,:tll a.1:£A~I .ll~h, t.!JJ~J ~ u#J <:r1UI J ~ ")JI JJLA:iL.u ~ .u\ qlo ;t I
i..s..u .LµIJ ~.llS'~I ~ I J ~.l~I ~~ o.l..b:.A u~l.Y ~ . l ~ I ~
~- '-~t\ ~
~ - Lo I.JA~ .lL..c...a.llJ JL:"o.")11
.. Jl.9-)l;..~IJb~
.. -,~··u'~J u ~.I
~ A-
~~I y4'°"iJ ~LlJI ~~I ul:,..;~ ..1:~ ~ i.J3y,u ·<:r1l=Lll ~~I ~ 41

~I ~..u ~1 ~I~ i.J3~ ~.:U a~ .u~IJ .ll.>9~10-4 ~ i..s..u .lL..c...a.llJ
~~IJ .lL..c...a.ll l~..;Lo ~.:UI u ~ I J .ll.>9~1 Loi .~b~I ~ J .l..;l__,.t.l ..;.J.AJ
~..l.a:iF-~~~l~ui ~u~~l(G4i•q "' IJ '.!·i «11.?<Ji~
~---ti
~ ~~
t.t-:~ '- -~I t._.:.q ... J!i.J3
• ~~ ~ ~
- - .. d...L4.0
.t.!JJ~ ~ ·LlaJub..'..J-'-dA
- .. '-' •
--
~ t_>4?JIJ a.!q.!t;,;;JI ~ll_r11J ~ I J ~.)~I u~~I ~ ~J .l~IJ
~bAJ ~~I ~~IJ ulS'~ J)l;..~I ul)J..lAJ whistleblowing uWl..=c..t.l
-~J..UIJ ~ I .lL..c...a.ll u ~
;;~ ~Ll.A . u ~ I ~ .l~IJ ~~I y4--u,i ~ ~t&JI ~~I JJ~

.ll~~I ~ u.)-1>- i;.jA ~..1>. ci'11 d.....:,lWI 4UI Lj~I ;,4--,u,t J.P- ul..;~I
~t&Jl~I~ -~..J~4Ulul.o.J.>Jlu~l.YJi.J3J~l~0~~.:UI
.u~l~.l~IJ~I.P.-?Jlu~~l~i~l..)J~Flui~lu~i
~I .)~I u~~ j:oi ~I.JJ ~jS'Jll ~ I _jJb JUI 0i ~ j i a.1:£Ai c.«.A.i! ~
~ I ~ ~I JIJA~I .ll~~I 1-!illJi r'J:ti rcrl ~ . u ~ I ~ iy.jA ~..L>.
~~q «cruWl..=c..t.l".JAJ -t~lo~w,kJW?Jl~i<J.A~~~~
.._~~I ~.) Ll, ~ . r" IIJ-'>"
.ll:..r- - ")JIJ ~ b '.jA r-o-:- - "'·-- ~ ~ . I a..,~j
.. ti r" ~")}L.
1..7"'
- 'A:f ,... - ~ ..) '.t::.")}
~....>J ~ (..:r'- f.fJ "'(t-lQ'
.l~I ul..o·'- -. ~ u ~ I .'-r~ l.£A (..)..,...-..:
- ,.,...... '-r
·.. L-. ~ · .:UI
. ~ ~ l.: ,
'-r '···L
~ .
uLJo.al ".JA ..)"'(t-lQ,
1 .t::.\ ti t.!JJ.:U ~
1..7", •- .r.)i
~
~W
- -- - ~ J-'-
~
-~<i
~ I I.JA~ui~ .JUIJ~~4~..;biw,k ~ i ~ J J ~ I
'-?"'t~i.~ti ~
...~-ti '-r
. -~ ~_,........,
..... --~t\ .l~ .)_).A.J
. . .. •1..7"L~
'-'I ..1..JI
..
cl.JJ ~ IJ L9.. \..b.j (..:r'-
,... :.-·
~
" ' ' = ' ~ ~ . l , - - ~ ~ l ' ~ - . C : , ~ , : . • ~ l . 1 . 1 . " ' - ~ r , > J , . ~ ' ~ ~ ~ ) , ~ ~ ~ 1 ' ; ; - ~ . . , . , ' ( X ( ; . " J " ! l , ~ . ~ . _ - ~..........-~~ ... _.,-~.~,l,.~<.,'.,...o • , < d . • . ' Q I , ~ ~ ~
A\ ~~~~'-:?~ILAJ~~l~U :u~l~.:i~IJ4J~I
. ~ ~J ~ ~~i I ~ 0~ ~1.JJI ~ ..)l~~I ~..) ~ l.:U .JUI c)l ~WI
~J . ulS'..A JS'~ (.)>conspicuous consumption ~.»-Lull ~~'}JI ~ I J.a.l
0-4 ~~"''.::I;~~ £>I~ i:t..l JUI .o..)\.....uJI ..)..P."J ~'}]JUI ,u.u.~I c4
~J Ji 0-JJ>-'511 ~ c\l\..ijl ~ LA~ o..)\.....uJI 0-4 ~ 4 ..u...>:! _jAJ ~IJ a4,.WI
·":..)ill o~_,JI 0-4 ~b_;_;6'i ~_,JI o~J ..\.Li 0-J~I LG...U ~J .~l_,ll y_;~I
~ ~ ~
~10-4 ~ ' aWo.i.t.lJ ..)1~'.)11 ub•
"'.! ~ J~ aG-1~4 ~ ' ~ F'
o..)1=.} u,-o J,l4i ~~-"=' 4i~i_>11 _;.:.:·; 0i '}]!,I.LU~~~ 0-4 ~_;JI~ .JUI
~
. ~_;~J a ~ \ J;.b ..)~IJ ~~I~~ ~i ..u: o..)UIJ ~ I

JimJawahar _;lAI.P.-~J Thomas Stoneuj"u.uLJ"'lAjiJJ~~\:JI ~ I ~J
¥~~I~ a~~ ~ I al:IJ..t,11 Jennifer Kisamore ..>JA~ ~ J
~~~~l~~.,.LuJIJ~l6~ ·l>")..ul~j.#..>=J4~yWl~Ji
~~I~ ...1:IJJ ~~ .rJWI ~~i ~ al£A4-JIJ a~IJ L_i,\:JI LJ"'_;IJ......1.1
i ,;.,2i o_;Lli?}I ~ J.a.l .o~I i-"'""i ~ J~ ~I o_;bl Y~J ~I aL.ul_;...ul al:,lS'
"T·a_u·tg
- ~ ~· J ja_.:g~j
- ~
"wlo·' - ~ . ~ . . ~ ~..ul
···ul.S::iLJo...:i ~ "T· ~
_:._:.tl·i
(.) '-7'~ti
~yWl~J¥~~1~a~.,.LuJl.;JAWJ_;iAI.P.-J0~~_;~~1
a.tlol_,J.la~~~~J~_,ll ~b~I ~ ~~_;6'i wl_;-c!,j.1.yjl~~I ~
~ I J...u..ll a~_jL.uJ organizational citizenship behavior (OCB) a.:Q.:Ioiill
~ c4 ~ ~_;:; ~i ~ <i'1'J counterproductive work behavior (CWB)
~\ r~ ~i) olj..&JIJ c1.:,o.;.~10~4JI LJ"'.J..) ~ .c:,>negatively related ~ I
~ ~ I a~~J a.:Q.:loiill cl..£bl_,J.I ~_jL.u 0-4 ~ ~L..u JAi~ {~_;..ul ~
..>-"°~_)~'}JI ~ ~ I J ~WI y)lbll 0-4 nv 0-4 ~fi,A ~ ~ i.!.U~J D~~,
~J .~..)lS'~I olj.lll ~ J Big Five personality factors ~ I a.:,o~I
~ I a~~ _µ.LI JAl_j&- ~ L_;..ul ~ ~ I c)l o_;Llu?}IJ ~ I ui 0~4JI
r'~' ~ u~Jl.' ~b ,l..r.?-iJ . ~ ~b a.:,o.;.~1 ~Lal uts'J o~l..i.tl' ..)-!):.
1$ - -
• « ...l.uiLill rLl::JI ,, ~ji ~ ~I_; ~~JA ~~ l.>":!:l.a.A
~_,J.1 al:9.J-'-U 0i ~1 t:il_;JI ~I~ Ed Tomlinson 0~1.:i . )1 _;Llii ~

u~.,11 J:i: rJ 1~1 -~_,l.l al:9.J-'-U J ~ ~ a..a:JI _;J..) LJ"'.J..) J.a.l • ..)l:..)JI ~ J~
.~l:9.J-'-Uw'}/~I ..)l..)JJ0i~_;J.l~~l0~...1:0:.:Ul~~l0-J~..ul~
w~l_;...ulJ [~~I l.:U ~~_;~a.: Q.:lo ;;JI a ;;~tt J.;4 [~.J4> ~I~ '--4lj.1.I i~
u ~ t ~ ~lw.aJ!J ""4J~I
mJ.l'.·~~··=l-·,:~,_.,.-~.-.,·,·-=1e~r@~~-B!a2.~rnJ::~~t.=-~~~;}-<§*-~··~..,:;s .•.. *.~-·......~~--r.wm~X-';";~fi~~nqj.~~r-~?'"{73E:Y7JGVifl
4->3 ,t~.,ll llA ~ ~>11 ~ ~ J ~ -b~I .~_,.ti ul:9~ ~ I

JAi~ .l.P.-J ~>11 <.>-4 ,~~ t:r11 ~~1 -~.,.ti ul:9~ ~~1 Ji ~I 41--
,Jlil.l ~~ 1.. , ... , ·~ :t!..• q ul:9
~r ~
~I J::u.l_)-Jc.r
• -:q ~~1-~ l..b..a.__ -I J ~
J.\ -
- ~ '.JJ .
.r...:-"•u~
.!t!-.fl
r ~ .:. lo~~- ... ti 1-:-:.
~ U"'"' u ~ 0-4
j 1.-:_ t\ · .~- !ti
'J-"
J ~JJ
uJo.q
'.r
4:,..b
.
w,J.Y-..U.I~~ .L_;b)'lu~l~uJ ... j\4\:;F~ .~,~~

-~.,.ti ~ ~l..)lJI i.:..il).~u>.' ~ o...d~ ~~J .~, J-....; "'.! ~ 1~ 0i
~ i ~ ~J . L&.>-.,.a:iJ ~ljlll ~ ~L,..:; ~ ~ J.--1:i.. 0J..>:..U.1 t_.!bi •".!
~_,.ti~ d..:tliylJ ~ , 0::> a:sjl_,.tl 0J..>:..U.I t_.!biccr_! ~ .J>L;.~I ~ '"':-'-1..)...LJI
·d..:tliylJ ~l41.l Hi '.)J.l r'J;.; ... , i.SJ.A ~.JS'J ~ c4'°J ~ ~.J4'=-l' ~ J
~ .~,
Y-..u., ~ 0~.,.t1 ~ 0t ~'.)~' iJA J.>:?-tJ ~.:u,
u~~I ~ ~ ~J .dJ ~ ~J . l ~ I ~ ~I}~ u~~I ~
J.c,l~I ~ Lo .dJ.,.;s ~..J ol...:>-yjL.ui t:r11 ~Lb.ll ~~ ~ . ) ~ \ J~
'b-;.t\ I A.,, bu •-=-ti .>J...r:-w
-:q . ) ~ ~ ...-:t\ Jo~i.'-?"'"
~ :.~- -:q .... :;q i Ll~I
'..;--' "'(:t:-1 ~ • - c.r j-Jy c.r r=- J -
0~4.P.-4-1.; Ll.;4iJ Amy Guerber ~..H?:- ~ i JJlz: 'LJ""AL;J\ ~I~
~ ~ ~_jll ~~, ..>:Pb Vikas Anand J,jt:,f '->"¥J Apama Rajagopalan
. .)~\ u~~~ ~ ~ ~L.u_jl .lyill
tlyi -.1:J.:,,.j ~~.JS'~ ..u:; ~~ ,.lyill ~ ~~, ~ t:r11 ~~1

.aJ~ - ~· J ja.....J~ I,.. .l·;.t\ L.tl. t~~. -:t\i.:.,il
- L"'(t-'.j c.;,-- ...-:f\ i.:..iLS'-1 ... t\
'..;--' "'(t:' ..r----: c.r
0
l_)--J~ J - ~
~_jl (Schwartz, 2006) j:i.;I~ 4-4~1 ~.:UI ~~I .;Lb)'\ u~J.ll r ~ I
~,~~I ul.>J~l 0-=-Q·oi; . .;l~~IJul.>J~I ~ l~.;JJ ~_jll ~~I
~,~ ~, .;l.:U:. ~' ~ J a.!!t ... ul.J-:Pb dJ ui ~.) c4 ~~, ~ 4JJ..---.14
~y.;l~~,..9 ul_J-J~I ~l.;Jui ~ -~ 4JJ..---.ll ~.)c4~~1 a.!:' I'!
.;l.:U:.~I ~YJ ~ I .l.P.-J .;~u
~l ulbi....u t:r11 ~~I WJ ul..c.~I 0-4
~J ~ .;I~ i 4:i>UJ ~~ ~I a:sjl.,llJ ~ I J.P.-J .;~! WJ ~~ ~I
--~i .<J)'-:-U-"b..f.l .;J.l o.;W-.ulJ uyWI W~.;~u 4JJ..---.14 ~l~~I ~.;
'-::7"4-WI [.;..LJI / o\..9Wl..9 ,tJ-'-"_,JI / 4~'}}\j:i.;I~ ~~, .)~~I ,-.;Q,o;
L. "I ~'}JI
ti ~--It\~ Lll.aj
<..T~ ~ -
.ll...Ji
•
...w··
-!)-J
'--4-0 •,.;.Hq U2.w::)
- u.r--r J~:. .o.
~ J r.
t:r11 ~.lj:j ~..9 ~ ~ J+_.,, ~ I l.:U. ~ .ul.>J~I 0-4 ~ tl~i
.LA~ J
·- ~)L;.~luLS'·'--·tl
- -~ ~
1,.. Ll~lu~~~I
- :.i.:J •~-AA·
j-:J ~~
•
~~'1';>":JQ?T,...,,*~•~.!_--OA,~.J<'J•'i'r~l!lo....,,,...,,(.,_e.-,,,1.!".~.r,,,.,..--.J...• ~ - . l - X - ~ ' r . . - . : A « - ~ ...~ \ Q..'l,~~.,."!J/!'t..c,( ~-.·.r....~---.~;~-,w.~\..XC.,,-.t.'>~1."~™~'C'4'.l~.-:I
AY' ~~ '-1d ~ (j~I Loj ~~ fall : u ~ I '='"9 Jl.ww:a.l!J 4.4..1~1
~I~ . a ~ I ~ .)~IJ~~I ~~~~~cJ~l "~I Lol
Mathew Sanders jJ..ijlu.u l~l.oJ Conan Albrecht ~._r.Jt 0wfi .;Llil '<.>".)~I
~~~1 ul ~1 Chad Albrecht ,-,,~.:_r.Jt .)l-:uJ David Holland .J.ll~ ~.)J
Jl.b:s~ ~ I J~'il a'i6..J ~~1.)1..u:.l ~o~o.)~~1 u.)i ~~I
~.,.ti aL..u)t;..I J u l . I ~ ~ ~J J ~ 'ii JoWl u~j.1.1 ~I.; ·t---"'IJ
~ J.4l ., 1 1\si cull J~IJ ~.;b?JI J~'ilJ ~ I J~IJ ~4]1 J~IJ
~ .~l.;.)~6..rl.J..;.; ,114a~l~J~'il~i.J~~0~jll
~J-LA ~~I o-4 ul l.,_7=iii ,crlJ J~I ~I~ ~lfo4 ~J>L4 o4 l.,_JJlu
a.:;;:< lA ~ ~1 u ~ ~~ ~1~11.!LI:i y~) ~ ~ c..e~I ~ ~
as'.;..ul Jo~4 rationalizations a ;t;;,JI ~ lA~ J~'il ~~ .<>"LJI
~ 4 ' ~ ul . perceived opportunities a....<.;..ul U'°.J-4l4J perceived pressures
~J-4ll ~ J ~ I a~IJ t ,~,~I Jo~I ~ . J ~' i i ~ c..el..,__bi
~ .~l.:U D~~ uJ.) J~'i4 .).;-all ~~I al.>J~I ~ J ~ll_;JI ~ ~
"~4 J ~'ii<>'°~ .)'~~I<>'° u~4 ~~ ,~u r~ ~ u~j.1.1 ~ ,
l~IJ ,Raven ~l.;J French ~J-4l ~ I ab! cull ..u:-1..,.;J ~I[~~
~1-tld..J.)L...a.llo·
~ - -
-~ttub..-~-:tt..ill:i
'..r.-' ~
· · -- .Jl..u>.'il
~ -
· 1.1·:.-~1tu6..:.)-L4A
()A~
-- .)I~~-L
~ll.;JIJ d..411__µ11 ul .;.:.:;;;J ~_.;...cJIJ ~ I J ~jAJI ub~J Lr-~)'1 ~ I J
-
cl.4.;~I ul ;;.:;;..,..::JIJ ,J~)U -L....uo u4~1 ~..LiJ ~t&.l.lJ t.)4)'1 ul"l~lJ
J ul.I ~
I.. ...
c,- , ... , .~. Jl..u>.)U ~ , . I
~J _ U'°~ )LI u~r ':. L-: ~ .Lt.Jt&J.I
.. !t!t\ ~ . J
~L..ui po
-
'ii c..e~I
0~ 0i uJ.) .)~1 <>'° ~~ uw~I ~ ~ ~ ~..u ufi3 uiJ J ~ 'ii
• .)~I .)_?.J J~I ~ abl ~..u
'='<II i.: c~ei c~c.:l I>='~ '-:?"'.;JiJ Zehava Rosenblatt u~jJJ lsl,.,_j ~J-C ~
ci.: .;.:lo ;;JI uL;g>b ~I <.J::t ~)WJ t:tWI ~ I ~ Orly Shapira-Lisshchinsky
<>"JIJ.1.1 o.JJL..ui '5..U {o.;.)Lal ~ ~_y.llJ y~IJ .;,>-bll) y ~ ' i l u ~ ~ J
-
..ill:i~ -~.;l..1.A~i,~y~'ilu~~~pj:i - .~IJ--'-"?JI
ci.: .;.:lo ;;JI Lll..u.JIJ ethical climate~~ ~I tlill dj>UJI ~~ ~I ~Ll.1.1
. ; ~ .tendency to misbehave c..e~I o"L...u)' J.:I.IJ organizational justice
y)lb.ll 0A JS'.;.: •i.: ~ dj>UJI y ~ 'ii uls.)-&Ai o-4 c..e_)-'Ai JS' ~ uL;g>b ~I
~---u.J..J~~-- .g.a:;;:...;....,..«_.~-------.,.,.._._«<_~_.,..~-At
~~ c'"1aS ~ '?.'.1lt Lo.9 l!I~ ljU :u\.J:a.al ~ l~IJ 4.4.J~t
~J t' '~, [• ~ .y'(f1' '\ ~1' C·
't C· ~. [• G. ,f-' ~ 'l_ J L,;
~ t- (X <;, £
I f. ~ r;. ,.
,t:S- ~· f. '° fil l· : t t ~ ~ •t c;;· ~ f ~. 1 f'. '[,. V, -~ .~; ~C•
I - ~· 'f R· , ·~ e. ~ c, - ·E ~ ~ f L V\ o i' ~ c· .c . ~
't f
1 ~ c;V,, _..;- ' \ .[ . ·[ ; .,: Ll .cfr, i ~ ,C· ~ : •i
t> I ~ lo •G ~, I • I,
~.~ r~ ~ '°·~ '[[, .~·f> i. ,(; [, >i .
~· E•· 4..p ~. • lo ,. • • - b. .. •G. ls>· P,.I - i
f 1:5 ls>• r.
1- t'~ t
a~ - ~
[! C & h • I
'°_: I . e; c.- I I • CI l:! ls> ls)I
t:.1..! E r- <; !: I- -;di )<! } <;, !

I - (1)
,i f/:E ~ ~·~ t ! ';,~ -r~ C,c; "" ri ir '[ fi•L .,: f-q 't· 1i ,t' f;-" C ~ & t I: E•· ~ t-'
i IL, ~ .E! - - 1:r :E ~
r· f l ~ :E '.;;- !i.. -:~ b t· . .: f t :: 1 -:: f ~ ~
r! [.
t·_
(1)
,:. ~
i
r..
,:: ~
~~
ls)• I
~ 1,. ~r i-r f'. ,. C.b'~ tr• V' t-' -~ . '°f>- ~~ ~. ~ l c- lc '°J-·i
(1)
~
-
V\
~ -
\) &
~ 1 1· -. , ~}.
'--, '-"- ' •• ~ t:S
.Fl ~ c, 't 1 c .~ 'r ·1· ~ , ; i t· ,~ c;· <f e. g ·- ; , ~ E'<i., . ~ r ~ lo'
~l t -~ . r- ~ ~. =.
<i· -cf. ~ <i· ~ ~ t:
L,·
/.r I ~E.. c;~·f;-" ·r[ <i.:t g-- t-~e-. •f~.e [;;b ·E.c-e-· ·tt- 1·., ~.e~. ~t~ ~.r;::E ~le- ~x~ ~~c, _: .r~~" c.t,t· ~ <i· • ·1:. r
i rd~ <: 'f c, i E ~: ·i i ·. . ~ -; .;' ·<is,. ~ l: ,i ~ _§ c, • . §; -:
t '( r f: ,. ; . f
[o-
i r=- ,..
_i ,r- 'r-:. ·t-
I I I V\ \J>I
[· ,tf t
L , , Cl\ c~ .rl f_
i ~f;-" l.f te. ~r i- . tr;. (.. hr-: \~ ~r· '°t .r·~ <r5: _ ·i·i. ~,1: ::r~(") Ir_ (;!
I - I I C. -i> _,a. L, I I ~ I •
J
t t ~- (• > f .;;- ;:" ~ \: ~ V\ lo '1, 1,• ,_.
I.;· L,
~ ~ 't.. : . c; ~ ~ ·~ 1 tr '° ~ ~ ~ ~
l ,I: -i,\ ~ G.f !!.~ r~- '<is,. f-~ t<i· l~ ,c-. 1 e 1I
" ~ ~ ~· 1 - ,~' lit f:' '~ ~ ~ f. cr r (; 1 ls>, ' ~ f ;:..~ (1 - .C I:! C C: .C
[a [s 1 I t f;-" I~
i f;. C- · - •L C-' C::- [.
i Ci·~ 1' t )!~ • ~t t: ~~ tr;. •~ t- 'L,.f': '°~ 'l'. t=• ~g, <i'}. l- ~·• ~~ t' t •[ (:r/.) ,r-[• t~'
t~ IA - ~ ~ • ls>• .,: ,t' '"l1' • ..
L ~ I I - ; 0. • c_ Cl\ I
- ! $,..: [ I t' - I - I - ~ I I "[ L, I I C- l]\ - -·
r,: .~ '° ~ t1> -G.
,1;' t
.& ~ ~ .t f;-" t>
·~Irt ~~ ;;:c, .f~ [;~ l'° fl.- fc..e ~~~ 1· .;°';_· ft ~·- ci~. .f:.· $- ~- <; ·i.f t ~,t' 'r .rE, tf'~. .i C~ ·~f 1:'i~
~Jf
~ '° rt '°E,
1
'° ~
~· -
<i:-
'E._ f 1
'°E, '°C- p,., }
ls)I oc...· - ~ - LI L"' - t:_
t- ,-.. • C C• ~
- ·~ E
(") ~ . t-
' ('i
t' - I ~ I I i= I I I ~ b I ~I G. \., ~ e: ~:
f' ~ ~ ~- ~· l t ;; '°~ ft ~
f ~ t ~ [ f &; ·~ ~ ~ 1f l f [ i t ~ f i t t t [ l t ! !'1J
J.J'-il~I
JJ-?. ~I~ ~b.ll ~I~

~ ~ .l~I ul::i.ll Loel Lexchin ~~
~ a........c.~
~~ Jol~I ~1 ~ a.k:wJ o.l~ ~I.J.l u~b.. -'-4..!4.4 ~.l~I
uL.u.JWI o.JA l..!'~,i ,u..u,~I c° . . l ~ uL.u.Jw Jl <<4A~» ~Lw,~ ~.l~I
o ~ I u~~~IJ ci§'.!;.!\<)'I bb.:,~1 ~ _;.::;t:JI ~ ~J ~IJ J~ ~
;;'..) l:i.:it:.A ~I·~ i ~:. ·J L)LuJI l.JL.;dg
- •_, - ,._~'IJ cu:J .l~I ulS''.)---1-":. "-'--;"
"""-~J,J. WI ~
(..)• Ll..,. ,·~ ,·..u
ul:9~ ..1.:!:t:J ghostwriters ~ J y~ ~jiJ 6~~1 ~b.tl ci.A~ Ji

~ r~~ u~~~ u ~ J.,~j ~.l~I ulS'~ U~.) ~ J ulS'~I
ul..c.~IJA~~l~r~IJ~~r'~~'1JjjL.ujj~ly)\.b«s;ly:.l11J
t~JA~~u~LlAJ al.li ~~ r..La: . ~L.u.JwJ~.l~I ~~ ..ioiii~I
~ <.?-4 d_jj ~ . u ~ I ~ J_j,6. .l..P.""J ~ Js;~ ~ ul..c.~.,11 ~ 0A
~~ 0A ~ ~ L~I ul.Aly:. ~J <):ul~I JJ~ ~ ~.l~I ulS'~ 0~ '1.Jjg
- - -
l&JJ ~ l..c..ll.J u4~1 ~ ~ , I.J.J .~lS'~I ~ r4Ji 0A Jgi ..1..J ~~I
~1<-Alj.ll l..c..l .ulS'~I ~~ ~_;.::;tJ l&l~ ~iJi~~ul~LJ
~.l~I ~lS'~ ~~I ~IJ.l4ll ~ ufi:i ui ~LA"~ G.>.JJ.l ~I~
- ~ J aL_,Jo ul.,W... ~J
.l~IJ 4l~I 0A ~ I J;,b a.........ul.J..1.:t ~~I o.JA (.)-YAWi s;~I ~

~)\.;..~I ~\Z.Jly~ ~ Mark Schwartiz._µ).,._1u~JLAJS.J -~~I ~
ul:9\Z.JI ~ ~ -~~I ~ .l~I 0A ~ U,.._# ~ ~WIJ ulS'->1ill
- ,,
~J .«..1.ul:9 rLl:i» ~LiA Wb 0 ~ ~ u=,o.;-ill I.JA ~ ~J.:.-J ~)\.;..~I
-
• LJ •- I :. • .... !t._ • fl a..u.Jl.c. c.:r-
(..) . y.) J---'-" ~~ ~Y" - •
,. . Ll)\..;..
- ,._ ~!J---'-"
~I d-I 4 -,J;, jjJI ~\Z.JI y :.J,J
F-10A ~~ ~ J ~)l;..~I ~~ a.! «rr.!1.J ulfi:i..>-4 Ll>l=J ~6.. ~Li.A
,.... , ·)l;_}U t:, s;~I ~ I s;I· i ~lS'. -~ :.- ~ti Ll)l;..~I
c.:r-'"' ~j~ t..H u ~ ~~<:?""" -
J)l;. ~I J J ~ J ~4,ll ~'-&JI Jo.;JIJ ~_.;...cJIJ J)l;. ~I a_jJ...LA ,Jut.I ~
WW u=,o~ .~~ ~ .~)l;.~I o.l~I . l ~ J ) ~ I ~ O>((ethic officer11
,Jut.I*-""~ . ~ I s;4',) ~ ~ ~~ ci.!o§ r~IJ a.! '11.!t~JI F-' (J-4
~ 4 JJ~ ~J.:.- ~ ~ I J .uL.u.JWIJ uls;I?. ?JIJ ~Lw,~I J)l;. 0A
.J~ 0A ;;.,1jWI f:>...l4i ,J)l;..i a_jJ...LA ,Jut.I~~ ,~)l;.~I ~~,~~
~ lt
~~.}3.)1_,..;, F l ' ..r.P"'' .~,J~~~I ~_j...cJI ,~Ll-4~1 ~J<)J~.J.l.l
,, C.
~.J.ll 0::~I 0,J~.J.l.l .J~ d.L.Ai r...\l ~ ~)l;.~I o.l~I .JJ.lJ-1~ ~~

. ~ j 0 ~ ~ 0-l...»-iJ ~_,kJI I.JA 0 ~
-.,'!;:IS~--=.o"ll~~-.....-.-..<s,:,._'9.J"_r;p>-:•.,,T~--. $'-"'~~.:r~--__:,.,,1,,v.·u1a:,-s _-, -·-:..·""""'""~-~~~lf"'.,,,,.4~J"'l...~rtk'¥--.M......-.. •• ~ ..-..:..:;..ll"".A.~~::,...,..~~"~..a.~-,v;.:-c.i.~~"I
~~ '-1.d ~ <.j~l l.A.J ~~ falt : u ~ I ~ J~~ Lw~I ,\'\

l:..)~..)l 0fi'~'J-J-' Wesley Gragg ['..r?" ~_, ~ ~.)WI ~ I ~ r~
~J ~..u LA ~ i Bronwayn Best,-, ,,,.!.' ~JJJ.HJ Uwafiaokun ldemudia
~I~ wJ-41_;11 i..1.:t . ~ ~ I t ~ ~ .lL.wi.11 0-4 ~ ~l.).l a..16..
4~i lj>-~IJ o~.;-11 ~ ~ , J ~ l lJA~J ~WI J~I ~ .ll.uuiJIJ o~.;-11
~..) l~«fJI ..)~I 0-4 ~~ ~ J ~J .o..)..w.1.1 L&J~Luf , ,IJ ~ ~j,L'-4
J-AJ Integrity Pact ~lj-Lll J ~ 0~411 r~ ,..)l.uuill 0-4 J.:.J,Zll ~1 ~~ ~I
Transparency International d.:lJ..ul ~Ll.1;JI ~ ".>J~ Cc.All ~jJI ~ I
~ .ll.uuill ~lS:.t ~ ~ ~..ul ~ I J J~ ~I t.l.h9J wLAµI o..le.LuJ.
~
w~l.h9 ~ JJ..ul 0-4 ~..u.JI J;s 0-4 l:J6.. rJ;.; '".! <>"~ .JAJ , ~ µ I .)~I
4.4_µ! ~ ~Li:il ~~1 ~1 ~~ wl~I...P.-1 ~ o.)\+c .JA ~l~I J ~ . ~
~1 ~Li:i~I D.:U ~ t ~fi.>JI .)~It~ ~ ~~4 ~ ~ I J «<>:t:.J_J
l&J~6.. ~ i ~ wfi:i LA~ clAl_j.lll ~IJA 0.,..._.;.Jj.1.I ~ J .c.!:Jl:i ~..,Jo a..__;st..>-4
~J ,~l.)..ul a.Jb.U t.?.>14J •~llll L&J~ 0-4 ~.lLl:&......c.ulJ a .!la .JI
[I ~
· - IJ b . L~ '. r· ~,~:J-'""~t\ ~-1..:uA
. 'r· .ll.uuill WW .• ,_-: - <....a..0
- .J-l~f-l
• :. LJI
- (.)j-0- •
~J ~ -
. _A - ~•• 1.11.:U j-J...:,--
I.?""" .. L-:
-:ti ~ I '- I - _It I ·
<.r"" '..;-- ~~ ~ ~
:. . - -~tt tJJ.'-:""
i . .IL-:
~
~ ~I
~Ll,l,~ .----"1. '-l·flD~·,.....l>-1 . ~ a.L·'-wl·L:.

LL..:J.J c.rtJ j ..)4J-~JA i.r-
- ~ u- <.r"" '..r I,;, ~ - .tJ ~ _,-.-
~ I.S.»-t.:/1 wl~I ~~ ~ ~ ·rLA~I ~ wl~l l.!.UJ r~ ~~ ~J
~ ~
J ~ ~ .ll.uuill ~w I ~ 4-~~ ~l.).J..11 aJWI Cc.A..lS -r~I ~ ~...l>.

. ~llll JJ.J.ll ~ cL&.o\.;.. ,~fi.>JI .)~I
0i ~ ~ ~~~ i..l,4j Al Rosen wJJ.) JT r~ ~ ~\:ill ~ I ~ J

~ ~ ~ -
~~1 wl uilj.1.1 ~~ .4U.I Jl.)J~I J-"""~w~~>Ll ~ I ~ ..u:i I~
~J ,~~..), rl....1,.j _,i ~ J ~ll.) ~ ~.JJ ~,~,a ,;.!.,:, J~~, ..1.-J.a
0-4 ~~ ~_,.;.. ~ J ~ ~I ~ w~>l:, ~~~I J:!.l~I ..9.>:..1.A r~

~ ~l..r?" )'I w~WI ~.J..iS'JI ~ll.;JI w~I t:tl:u ~ ~ ,cll~ . L&.!~ ~ I
~ I~ 1.5.JJ .~1~11.!.UJ ~~ ;;~UA ~ ;;~I wl:~_,.11 L~ 0-4 ~.;JI
.w4~1 ~ J . A wlAl__µJI ~ ~1 i.S.li ~ ~LI.I r~IJ ~~WI ..le.l_ig ~
~>lo ~J ,~~WI wLAlj:J~l 0-4 ~ ~..GS:JI wlS'~I ~..>:.J.A 1.5..u 0i L6
wJJ.) r~ -~ ~_; ,~,i wl_;.!.!·i~ ~..GS:JI ci.!q.!t:,;;JI wLi.u.)WI ~ wl~
~~ ~...l>. ~ i JJ~ I~~ L-..>-4l:Lll <1Ponzi ~y~» w\ bb-.d ~l..>-4
W"""--.,.~~JN\"ll!:•,.:.4....-,.,n.. ....,..'\,"Wf'X.-:>.......,,v.u.-,.,,,.-..u".•.~J.~·.~tc~ -~~~r ~ - , ,WJ;..-.y X:JA<.,,""'b-~·~!L••,·c,~- v.-#~<'3.-:.-..:i..•, •..,-:ia:.. vJU1r..-.-~.··~~v..",=.~.-~,,;;ir
AV \.,s:,~ L t d ~ 'i~I l.oj i ! , ~ fall : u ~ I ~ ~l.w.a.l!., ~~I

' .. ·.;-:::=.';_: .;. ~... ,,:.~:~·~:. ·:::;,··;::~::";·j ~ ·---: ·.. -:.;·: ~:·:.,·.J
u~L.o:i)U J:;.;.,:, as'~ (:4 ~...\>. ~ ~ u4~ ~ ( J ~ ~->-4b.l.l wi

w.)J.) ~ J ~ .i.b'-4, L>-4 ~..ll LA '-4lj.ll ,-.:~!. wl ~t L>-4 c.ill~J Nortel Networks
u~la:;.JIJ u;l~IJ ul:!JJ~I ~~! J\:'J.I ~ ~ ~J a...:;Lc!JI «~I»
·r~.;)U o~ o.;~ ~ lfj! .a.:«o;.~I
L.>A ~.;JI~ ~~1 ~ cPJJ ~ wiJ aJ~ wfi:i wl u\S'~ ~ ' L.>A
(Kanter, 2009) ~\S' ~ . ~WI ~LzJI ~ I ul~ Jw:. ~I ~ i.b~
<?'J «a.:·.:'btl u\S'~I» ~ i <?IJ ~WI u\S'~I L>-4 ..)~ u ~ ~
0_v.;.i_, ~.,.J "?..) LAt .'->..u.1 o ~ I ~u1 ik~t rJl.a:iJ ~1 '->..u.1 ~ ~.;J
~I~ ~~l~->=..l.l.l.;~H.iJwi ,_,~~ (De Luque et al. 2008)
.)~ J.t.5.;J ~Y- ~ ~ a.:b'. uiJI O.l~I ~ t4J~I ul.c.~4 ~Y- ~..)~~I
ul~ o.l~I ~ ~~ ~I ul.c.~4 ~~I y ~ l ~~~~I 0J->:..l.l.l
<?'J ~~?JI ~_jll ..)~ ~~ ul~ LA.;J..l:' ~J ,~l:&.11 a.:1:ai «11114A,JI
.~l~b~~
u..21.t}4.tt u~~
. ~ I I.J.A .ll~l ~i L>-4 ~~ k..) ~.JJ-1_,;, a....o4,. ~.i9 (')

~LA.J.4l ~..l:' ..)~' <)J~I Jl~i r ' ~ ' t.?.J-AI:JI t.?~Y. ,bbv ~ (Y)
r..J;.; •".! t.?.J-AI:Jt ~ , D.JA t~ 0 i .;~~, ~ l......>-~, (:4 0J_; Q ~; '",,
..,t ~u, .;~~, aJ~ ..ill~~ . ~4,-6. ..,t ~4,-6. ~~ o.l.;l.,.JI JI~~'
· ~ .)~, t.?t .l_?.J r~
~~ -
, 1~Ll .,..t
. · - 'l.u>.I ~~ · ·w,."?"""~~~
<. ~' c.JJ-1
~ .r-~->-4
,L~ ~ ·... --:<1~1 Jl.u>.~t (,)
..
w! .J~~I u l ~ L>-4 o~ "?I J ~ ~~?JI J~~I tl.,:,t L>-4 t~ "?i
"?..)~ J~~, tl.,:,i 0---A tY "?~ .ll~?l' ~ ~~?1' u~L.o:i~I r'J?:i cul
u ~L.o:i~I r'J;.; , ul (JJ.l ~~ "?.:UI J ~ ~4 d.,j.)'-4A ~~ ~i O..)~ ~!
-~~?1'
s~...,i.tt u~~
~l~Jl ~ll>'"" ~ cc white collar theft or crime» r'b ,oJ WL-:iJI ~.>=JI (f)
~ ~~I ~ll~I ~J.!~ 0:.J..JI j~I y ~ t ~J ,~~I ~ll~I ~Jj
~Jj ~ WL,j, ~ll~I 4.!lJ:i ..u:; ~ ,~WI ~ ~ LAi •~.i! '-:-1~1
<>'° JJl ~ (wikipedia.org) ~~..J ~~.,.l W)JJ -~~ ~ j ~ I
Edwin ~'1.JJjJ-'-" 0J..J~1 ~.JA~I t~~I f1~ ~ r'b,oll I.J.A r..i;.; • ,I
':i'1' ~~I» o.,j~ ~~I<>'° t_,111 I.J.A ~~ ~ , °'"'°' r~ Sutherland
.cc~ cdbt J)U. ~~I a:slSAJ r,l..~4 ~ ~ ~..>:
:. - :. t t
er~
#
• -- .,, • I
~J-l W: I-•cccccc11.!
• .,, t
~L..1..1.1~ J W: 1-...:.,,.- ....
• t I • ~. - .• I I-... (
-:-1» 'i:~..J ~~..,.... L.a.!='J Y )
~ I J y~IJ y~I <.;)! l~-J-'-1' LA~ ,~_,JI 4J.JJi ~ yl~I J4

# # #
~~ -l~.J..14.1..J l.&Jy I.fa-a#,,.~~~~ ..u.JJ . ~ I ~

.«~Y'O,••• ~
~':i'11 ~ I 1.!:J~I rl..i;.; , ,I «meta-analysis»~! ~ I ~ ( ~ )

·LJ:AA ~ Jlj.- ~ ~4'-?}I c....a~ ~b.al ~l.>-4J l.>"°~'1 LA~
.)'..}-""-
· :.11 ob- i.r· Wlo..11 ~I
. ~.~11 ~t c.r11 u----w
· .. .:.~11 ,
... 1...
- er -- -
• «~lS:..J.I» - :. (1.!:J)
~ Jo:!-'-":
~ ci.:\.:e\4LIJ .a
.:i4..>-t11J ~IJ.lJ'14 o~I ~ ~.,L..u,i ~ ~.J..JI
I.J.A~ LA 4J~J ·0J~~4 ~~ J:ilJ o..dWI ~~~~I~ Jl~'11
~IJ-l~ 0J_y,-)U -l~I rl..i;.; ,crlJ ~\.:,~I<.;)! ~I~ ~4-li ~~I
.(wikipedia.org) l:~..J ~J-'-"JA~I .~l..1.Al ~
~ J:tWI ~.JA~I ~.;JI l&J u=o..,..:; ':i'11 a.: ... j'?'"JI 4:,-.:•oolJ LiA <-41j.1.I .;.: .~•.! ([)
.Monica Lewinsky ~.,.t ~JA ~..DJ ~L;uill lS~l ~ 0.,:u.lS'
~L:.Jl~l~l~~Jo~~forensicaccounting~~l~L:.Jl(r)
~.J.a:i ~ L.bi Ji ulo_,.tl ~~LA~~ J ~ I c....a~ ~j,WIJ
-'"l:i·ll~I
~,.,.. • ~Jj-l_.)
\.ZJI ~~
I.L": 1.... ~
-~
bJo~.~
_.11_i:\,I.J..J .W'b.Jl
.~_i,l:9 c....al..1.A~
ti>~ «asset-backed commercial paper» 4:u~I JI.JJ~4 L~..u.l J~~I (t)
~~j.1.1 <>'° ~ J ~.J~I LA.J~ ':i'11 ~UI 4:u~I JI.JJ~I tl_i>i <>'°
- J~ L. ~~ f"':
. lS.?· t a.JLA - ~ ~11J a.JUI
-
JJ~l~I
[.;;~~~---·.=.::;.:·: .. ·:·.=:.:=· . .... ,·:.:-,.·~:.·.·....:.. ·.:·:.· ..·..~~ ~·.·.·,.t .. ;:v>· ,,·,-,, ..~-, ·.. ·.<>·,·,...~...... ,,.:.·.,:: ... ,,,:.. ,-.,,,,., . . ,..,,:,:: ·.,.Yr.,r:2::........,.·..•· .,.,.. ·,::J
J~IJ JUI JU,j! .J-A conspicuous consumption ~.J>-Lull ~~~I (J)

u4'"~I ~ ~ J I.J-lJ>-}U ~l~I D_;~I _;~~ u'-4..wlJ ~I~
f1~ ak.-,1~~ {:-'""till ~ I ~t_\b,oll I.J.A~ .JlJ .~J....J ~
l:~-., a.......u-'"4 ~t) Thorstein Veblen~ 0:tL..u.;~ J~~IJ t~ ~I
. (wikipedia.org)
Jlj LcJS' c:Gt ~t «negatively related ~ I \ s,;.,.! c4 ~ ~._>:i» ~ (j)
.;;~~1 ~ ~ I u~_jl.u, ~...li a_Lq.!t;,;;JI ~l_jll ~~
~ JAJ «metaphor of the ledger» .J-A ~~I ~I~ .l_;J ~.:UI ~I(_;)
~~>'11rl.J:-i ,ul .JlJ .cc~~~l~.l»Jiccul:,~l~.l»;;_;~I
4.1~~ w~j.11 ~ ~.:UI ~ I c4 ~lb:;J c i ~ cc~WI _;J.l D_;~I»
•l)_)WJ
~~ r~ j5~ ~~ t ~J-4 .JA «ethic officer» J ~ ~I J J ~ (j)

.A'\1·~,t '--'I~. J~ ~ I ul-.u WI '-...1.Li
.aqt;,iq\J Ll)l..;.~I ~LZ.JI
c4 1..7""-~ ~ -· ~ -· ~ I.);!
y. ~~tL --
L.,-., · ~~
~ti ~L;.
U.0
WI yl..b..4JI
L
. 4\ '- -'I ul:i.u. 4\ LJ'-':. ..1>-o...1 ,..___&
'-:"""~ -· '-:""" · . .J;~J
-
-~LZ.ll
~ .... ~-~---=-~--....-p~-e. .=::c-=------.:--,,c ~.......,,-~ . _ , , _ - - - · - - - ~ - ~ ~ ~
~~ 4.1.aa ~ '-$~1 LA.J ~~ faU : u ~ I ~ ~~~ 4-w~I \•

~Wt~t
<'>JWt~Ji
Ronald J. Burke i.!J~ ·~ ..AtUJJ a.it~!
i4A.wA
.Cassell's Concise Dictionary (1997) «oJJ~ ~ o~ Jl ¥J .)A ~ I Jl ~II)
01~ ~L-JI ~ JJfoJ asL.o} .jAJ . ~ I J JUI ~ 1 1:a JJ~
Research Companion to Corruption in «al 1 t:,; I I ~ J ~ I ~~ J--~b,,
a~Ul.1 t ~ ~l.1:1 ~ ~ I 1.L.A ~L:! .Organizations (Burke, 2009)
J~IJ 41~1 C~_)-'Ai ~ t i;IJJ ~ ~ 1 0t ~ , ~~ ~ 1 J J ~
.-
J.;L.u _jAJ Willie Sutton 0jiL.u ~J ~ a;,l!&JI ;;..,_JJ ~ Lo~ . a ~ I ~
-
"Jl~I ~ ~ '~J-'AA ~T ~ " ~ ~ , ~ ..LiJ '.J~ ~...>At ~.J~
41~1 01 ~ , Ill .«~JUI J_?.JI> c.ill~ ~ 04 y4'-i..e ~J~I al>""~
.«~ JUI J_?.JI> ~ r~~I ":a a ~ I ~J-AJjJ J~IJ
,, ~
Anthony Marshall Jl....j,.J\.o ~.¥J i ~ ~ 'r' r · · \ r~ ..>-:'jAS't ~ ~

~\.,;JI ~1 0A t:Jltll ~~I ~1 ~.J Brooke Astor Jj&........u,i c.!lJ..H <.>.JI .jAJ
aj\.o 41.!a!~JJ~I ~ I l:a.J~ o.JIJl i;.,__.,,~ ~ b ~ J ,~~IJ
i;~ ~ "..ul_,J J~.Jlo <.>.JI ~J 0t ~ cG.cSb ~ ·~...>Ai J"'iJJ 0~ ~WJ
~ J l ..LiJ .Alzheimer «~I.Aj.11,, Jf ~~I ~..>-4 ~L..:i ci'1' c:G~ LlAl&A
~..\.Li~ '->..r':° t~"'i Jj&........u,i ~I~~ I I J~.Jl..o (J~ Jj&........u,i c.!lJ..H ~j-4,A
.(Leonard, 2009) 4:.;lall l+i\S:.14A ~ i ~Fl~~ ~J
,,
J~I ~ cl:k ~ J~ ~ JJj.....-A ~f _jA Ao Man-Long ~_,J 0Lo Ji
r" ··Ar~~~~ 0A ~)WI 0A -li;.1:1~1 ~ Lo~ ~~J ~ ~~ -
J ~ I ~ ~.J.A cGi ,-,/; LiS' .al~~f'I a.d..,.l.oQ ~ J ~ a~~ J;s ..LiJ
o..u:.U ~ I J ~ I ~~J JI.JA~I ~ J ~J~yl 0A al.J"'iJ.J.11 ~~ ~
c u ~ ~ ~I~ ..1.-.l_, .~,~~?JI .)~ ~ J ~ I J.:?.,l 0-4 0-,-J_;.,,-b.11
.o~.J 0-4 ~J-At .J~J.l u~ ~)Ci_, .J>-IJ t::44_,
'=' ,~.,;; ~ ~J.J ~ LA-.J~I ~t.,:,! r r · · '\ r~ Ikea ~1 as-.;-1u u.J.>9

~~..l:A ~Y-:f:A.l '-:?"'""»JI ~.;JI _;gt .llJ -~J~.;JI y1b ~ rW?JIJ . l ~ I
cUl~t .J>-l .JA ~ ~ 1 uiJ ~ J a1< .~,o .l~1 u~ Dimitri Medvedev
. (Kramer, 2009)
~~,,, ~ , ~ ~l.110-4 J ~ ~~ ~ y1il ~t 0-4 ~w ui LS

..u~ .J~ r1J;.i CCl4 ;(g~ f41 r, '\'\Ar~ f-'""-'"° ~ «home runs a.Lo~\
ulj~?JI ol.s,l i.S..1.1.1 o~J i.S..1.1.1 o ~ ..di~ l.!ll....lA • (NPR, 2009) C'>steroid
J4,,.;JI ~~J.A ~ ~ .ll .ab ,~.;JI ~I.all ~~1 uJ~ \s;;.!;;~ ~ 1~1 a.a.ol>.
.)'-4All rl.J;.i ,I a~ Hall of Fame .>:!-"~I ~ f41y-.l a.a.o~ S,i :oi cssO
C
-~'
~.J .JAJ Michael Misick ~ ~Lo J~1 r r · · '\ r~ O"'.JLo ~ ~..,
uts' .J.o.1 • .)~4 ct.Al+il «.·: "'! Turks and Caicos V"~lS'_, ~.JJ°J ~ ~1.).)J
~ Lo 's ,,,:\t ~ '-,:,~ ~JJ ~JJJ ·ti¥1 ol:?, ~ ~i ·''.! ,,,.!o
l,fl e:9.) Tourism Board 4>-~1 ~ 0 1..,~ JS' ~J-At .J~J.l u.H ~Lo
ul LS -~~.) u~l ~ 4>-4---uJI (.)"'LA,.)~ ~ y l .)~J.l wJi ~W)t:i ~
o~Uo~f1W1 J.P"ul->9~ Wj.)~J.l~>l.A~W~ i~~JjJ1 i.S..U
,
~~~~~I ~LUI ~_jjJ ~ ;(g.J~ V"~lS'J ~JJ°J ~ ul ~ .a.a.ol>.
a,;.,,;;.., Jb~ ~~1 c.J.:,~J ~~~1.., patronage ~j>J1J ~~1 ~ 1
.J1~1 ~ LS .~I ol.s,l ~ ..di~ c.J.:,.i),411 ~..l.4iJ ~_,..;.;JI 0~1.l 0-4 ~~
u~~ ~ ~~ ~U.o ~~ d..t.4i->-° ~~ .lJ~ 0 ~1 ut9~
. (The Independent, 2009) ~~1
J~l J~.,-o ~~ ~u1 ~1.)~~1 ~ ~ 1 r · · '\ r~ 4~~ ~..,

J1.,-ol 0-4 ~..,.:is .)~J.l u~ ~ snq.>J ~)Ci O::I CJ1.A t::44 CUAJ Earl Jones~.?.
(-..,>Bernard Madoff ~J.ll.o .l.JW~ 1J:i5 d..:t~I ~J . o.l~1 o J ~ I J:!.llu..o
~ ~ J~ ~1 ~ ~ ~J
~ , -
J~_,11.>:? i .l~ ~ . (National Post, 2009)
·rr·' · r~~~
'\t
Jlll~..)l
f~~·~:;w-~~::i!!~~w;,-..::£:0£~7.:'!!2JJE"~~·~7._:~~-~"."~-~~;--~Tlir~~~.f.'9F~lilti:~a.2"u:i~~~~~i'Z:'7$i
~ ~J ~ Merck ":JJ)U clJ->:!-4 ~.>1u ~1_., r • ·A rk.->=I~~ ~J r

.;bi~ \+Lil~~ ~Jk-J ~ ~...>At .;'y.JJ w~ ~ J ~1.,_., ~~
u1 .;.,.!';;..J Ci.A~J Medicaid ~1_~4 ~ I ~LWI ~l:i~ ~~ ":JJi U>l:i
~ I i:,l ~1 clJJ:!A ~.;Ll,i .~y:wl u ~ r l ~ 4 I~~ ~4Jo)U ~I.J.AJ
.(Johnson, 2008) ~ 4 Ji ~JJ..a.l4 ~~I 0-4 i.;1;s1 ~ 'y.
~.JJI (Reshma Jagri and Colleagues, 2010) ~~.;J ~..>---=?'-4-- ~_.; LA i
a...ul.;J, on ~l..>-4:' I.JAw University of Michigan~ ~4,- ~ w~
dtil.!:..J:iw-4~i .Jk., a.!i,oiulj~u~~W~~wl.b~I~
~ - -
~ J ":JJ~I ulS'_>1u ~ 0-4 ~..ul) ~~I~ y.;L..o3 J.P.--J u~i ~G.ul.)..ul
., -
y.;L..o3 J.P.--J~ ~I uG.ul.;..ul i:,i ~..,.I.I w-4 wl .(ulS'~I db~ ~jll
db ~ ·~·-' a.JUI
.. ..dla=-tl · w ~
:y- ~ ~ ~ .. 4J~ Ji L-
~ll.o ~ -t~I."T"
· ~- C "
·":JJ~I
ub~I ~ ~I ~~I 0-4 .J:!...WI ~UI i:,.,~I ul~I J)l;. u ~
,~...>Ai .;'y.JJ ~ i c.;,--11 u1 i 6::i LA oJk. wfi.: LJ:LA ~.; ~ 1..a..o o.;Jj.1.1 ~ 4-J 1
~Jl>.:i'y.l J.!a ....~I ~ .;~ .~4,JI ub~I w-4 t~ ~iJ J~ ~i ~ ~ ~J
JUI~ u ~ l o2l4, ~ ·ru ~ ~...r4i .;'y.JJ w.*- o.;~l o ~ (FBI)
~..,.ti ub~l o~ ~ w ~ ~.JJI .>9J: ~ . ~ 4:.)~I J.;I.JA ~L'i..o
y ~ i ..u..i: , ~ j ~1 ~~1 -~4,. oJ~ ~ J ~ I ~i 0-4 y_,1.bJ.I JUIJ
- ~ ~ I ~~LA~UI ~Jw,AJ~I ~sl:ai • eQJ~i w-40.;Jj.l.l ~ b ~ I
J~ ~ ~ ~ J ~ O.)jj,A OJ~ ~..u o~I ~ wi ~;. 11,lt _;,;J.I <JAJ
~1 ~~1 .lub~I ~ w,1:. alJ~I ~ ~~ 15~1 ~lS'J u~l 15~6,
~IJ (.)AJ~I ~ l~J o.;.1>-4 ub~ w,1:. I ~ ~.JJI Jl_~~I i:,i ~ , ~ j
-~ ~ ·~ .~A'I ~ . 2l4, c.:r'I.. ~
•.• t"!_ ti 0: :.• LlAiJ ,,~
- A.d I~. ~
I ~~~jt ~ AUt _J~ !>.:u" 4 J!j L4 J~ ~~

t
i.b..h:d. .:G.;bh, Bernard Madoff ~JJl..-o J.;LJ..H ~Irr· • A r u .;->IJi ~
.)'y.JJ w..*4 ~ cc,P. ~ i:,.,..; Q~; ,111' t...G,.. ~.JJl..9 Ponzi scheme ~J-Abll ~.>J-"='
j ~ d.,j~ o..L:R- ~..>£A ~JJLA 15..u wi .l--! 'y. ·<.J:4~1 ~...\..4.t.ll J)l;. ~...>Aj
., -~
i:,\S' ~JJLA ~~LA~ .NASDAQ «.!lbjl:i ~.J-":' ~u.oi ~ ~ ~G.u
~ ~ ~ . - - . . . . . . . . . . , . ,_ _ . _ _ , . _ - . , " " ' ~ · " - , . . _ . , - -- - - ~ ~ ~ .... : - . . ~ - ~ ~ - - . . . - - - • ~ ' " ' - " - • ,;: K 'loQ:111
~o ~~ ~ ~ cSo:Lll LoJ ~~ fall : u ~ I ~ ->~t, 4.4..1~1

~
w,k J_j..LAJ ~ ~J I.J.J_;fo ~~J ~ Palm Beach~ f34 ~ J_µo 4-..:!..u

~I.) a~_,~.,
ti
~i ~ ~~ ~ 0ti~Uo_, Long Island ...G~i ~_,J ~~
~.)w ~ I ~ 0lS' ~ . al.;~_,..111 ~~ .;..l.4i ~I~J ~..,.sJ I.J.J_;fo <)A JS'~
l.!J~~I ~ Jlio ~J (Balm Beach~ f34) al~I lS..1>1 ~ ~l&. ~_;
.)~i ~ 0~1» ybS' ~Leamer~ .;~l ·t~4ll ¥..>=JIJ ~..>->-~I
Madness under the Royal Palms: «a41¥.I ~bJ <)A aJllJ y:,,JI : ~ I ~ I
0iJ JUI~~ ~4 0t Love and Death behind the Gates (Leamer, 2009)
~ Ji.A <)A ~..u LA~~ LA~ .JWl cu.)~~ l...9J.l~ y ~ ~I~
1...9.)L.o.LIJ ~ I a~IJ ~~~I l...9J.)LAt...G.. ~ . ~ ~~~I ~.)~I w,k
~.,t., ~ ~.,a 4;.~ ~LAab~<)A;;.)Ll?il J,At w,k~l-'"4i ~ w~
. (Arvedlund, 2009; Kirtzman, 2009; Oppenheimer, 2009) J-A~I ~l..1.:1 ~
aWo..i..t~ .f-f11-'"4i0.i)q~i ,,,t1~.,t~,.,s.r4bll~41...9~I LA~J
~ -
w,k '.i)-P." t 0,-J_; q~i cc t I .)l..,.s~ I ~ J L,:;LA...G.. f:1..l.4i w,k ;;.).)Li ..I.Li f1 ~ I
I
~~I~ l...9J.lLA ~ I J .JLA ~t ~.JJ ~~ ~ ~t lfi.).)i LA~ ~.)UA t#

~I~ .;~I ~ ~...r4l .)~J.) ~)t.o ~~~~I oJ'-"wLA ~ ~
rl&.. ~l_,t ~J .~;;.~. y4J l-'"4.i9 ~:.UI 0J.!.;,.,oJI ~~~I a4,.l&.J~I ~
- ti - ~
. LAL&.~., cdLA ;;..u. ~ 4 ~ ~ ,r r • • °'

~J ,Salah Ezzedine ~.JJI ~ r~ ~~I~ 'r" r • • °' rl&. .»-IJl ~
ti~ ~I~ YouseffFaour .)~~ ~~ ~->--1uJ ,0~ < ) A ~ ~ . )
~ .~...r4l .)~J.) 0.,A, t43 ..l9 al.;~J.J.ll ~)t.o w,k ~~ clJ~J 0-J~I
~ .~l-'"4i w,k ..dWI <)A 1.t • ~1 ~ ~ 0-J~I ~.JJI ~ aS'J-iu a~_,
Jw. ~I J ~ ~ ~ 0lS' ~ ~Ll.t,UI ~..ill ~ I .;J.) ~i ..1>t ~.JJI ~
~ ~.J,:,JIJ ~ , ~ ~4,.:i alJoLl&j ~.JJ 0lS'J ( ~~, ~~) 0'-'-tl ~ ~ I
~l).a."""iJo~c.,: ,.,!al.;~~L,~~rr• •Arl&.~J •4.)Jiy~
Jl-'"4t w,k J ~ 4 ~~I"~~ <J4J_,..:JI JJ~ ~.JJI ~ 0l ~ I 0-4J
. (Nahamet, 2009) 0-J~I
.)~J.) ~~ ~W 0-4~~ ~UI J~~I ~..>-:!I~~~ ~ J ~

~ ~ .Sir Allen Stanford .).)~~ ~i ~ I ~fill a+-J ~ ~...r4i
~t vu.)LA .i9J r r · · 1 rl&. rL-.,JI Antigua and Barbuda b~.)4J 1_,;_:i·,t a.i.,.)
~.)~J.)0~~~F,r"··ArL&.~ ·~_)~,~~..,J'"~~
JU1~.Jl
li¥ri®N&i4ihffi-&?§i@k£4~?t1w~@w@¥f:iiifaikifrA~«fr§&w,~~¥¥+i4¥B¥f&tii¥¥iW~·YiiWAN@W4¥%4£+.§~{.fr-cl&J&£iit§%P&i.ce·,~-~@-:rf?@Writ·?J
J.P.' <J-4 ~ I ~l..:i&A <J-4 i}J->9J ~l.b...H ~ ~..,s:JI ~ ~ ~~

,, - - "°"-' J:?.. J
4-4 .< -" Ll-l..1.4 .l •• b...-u • lS' ,ell Jl.u> ~, ~ ,.,J°: ~ • lii t • ~ •4-u • :. tt
~ - w -
~J,42 ---0-0 • • J,Jf:. ~J -~ ~
~ ~ ,,
I
r"· ·A_,rr· ·v <.::4w~L.u~~~J~JAt.;~J.lcJ~ nr ~~JA\11

. (Huffington Post, 2009)
.;~J.l l:JJA, :~I ~1 ~ J LA~ ~bll ~l.»-..u.1 .l_;~b...-u \S..U c.:,lS' ..141
c.:,~ , • • a q.:a! ~,~Uo ~ <JA J.,bl , '-4.a , r • cll_,b &- ~ ,i..14, ~JAt
iiJ.iS ~L..u ~ ~j ~ '--4:' ~_.;~I J.P.'~~~,.)~ ,F '~-.)At .)~J.l
Wackenhut Castle ~lS' ~'-f.i:S'IJ ~ JJ.lAJ Antigua l~fJ St Croix
o.;4---J ~L....u ~ ~., .(as~ ov ii~--' r~ ,A··· G>.~)
c.:,_µ.
r~' ~ ~L..u oJ~J t!J\'J t~\11 rl:!i a!:b JLilo\11 ~~ ~ .;Ji.:a.:,t:J
l:!L\.~ ~JAf .)~J.l VO' ••• ~i ~T ~~,~ '-4S' ·c.>"~..>-4 l:i.;~J
cl.JLilo i ~ l:!14 '\ • • • &4J 4:->l:!-JI ~)lb.all J ~J .l~I ~ ~ JLilo)U
~_.;~I J.P.'~ a.:;;.:; ....JI ~J-4ll J~4 ~WI c.:,1 . (Financial Times, 2009)
•(.:.)Johnny Depp ~.l ~.?. ~ J .l_;_,.ijU..U J-A
,,
~ 4 Edward Okun c.:,§Ji .l_;IJ.ll ~ ~ , Y• •'\ rl.c. wub ,ucl~ ~
~~' 4:t~» w-41+,t5_, f:.~, Jl~t r.J>i 1111 ~ . l ~ , «.·: ,11! r1.c. ~u
0...1:~I ~jjJ ~1.,,.-A~ f:.l~J ~IJ.)~L.:if ~ ~~ c.!l..JjJ«u«o;. s~,fl
,,
J ~ ~ ~ , ~ .cGll~\' ~ ' ~41, f:.~, ul~.l ~~ <.)1
-
,, ,, as~1
.(Larson, 2009) 4-41__p- ;;~Uo_, a.:,o~ ;;~Uo_, .;~I 0A b~J LA~ n. ,
~bll ~ I~ cu.)~~ Gary Sorenson c.:,~.;~ 'i.>P.- ~~I~ '-4S'

'iJA'bll 'ij:J~ ,bb;. a ;;_;I.lb, ~1 'i.,;o J-AJ 'r r • • '\ rl.c. ~ J+1 <JA oJ~,.,
·'i.,:o J~J.l c.:,~, • • ~ cJ,J~I ~ J ~ ~I <.)1 lS.li '-:?.J.11 Ponzi ,, scheme
~~ ~ J ul.;~J..Lll ~~ ~ ~~ ~ '-""l.;J...L.....i.A ~ ~ c.:,lS' ~J
~~T ~ Milowe Brost~~ iiP- ~-.,lu ~~I~~ .l.,.ol>. ;;~Uo
. (Seskus, Cryderman, and Massinon, 2009) 'i.>P.- ~ ~ I ~_.;ti w-4
~~'~y>l..oy'bJ,HafizMalik~'-4~6...illrY·' • rl.c.ct.;,~.;+1~J
~ ~~I l&!~f w-4 t.5.JJ5.; ~J.l c.:,~ o, t ~ ~l:! U.;J ~ f:.~~I
- -
aq.:a:~f:.'~JUl~LAr~' .;;~,.,~~4~~J'rr··tr1.c.
,,
. (Torstar Network, 2010) c.>"~..>-4 o_;~J ~J.J..lJ~ o_;~J 'i.,:o J~J.l c.:,~
l
d..4l;..9-4 ~J ,Melissa King~~ ~ I 'r" r · · \ r,k. ~J~ ~J
.~_,.tlwl~~JJ~0A~.J-Ai.J~JJ0~ H w,u~4,~_j,Lld..:tl.dj~
-
1-~":J ·
, - -
~j ~ • ·-~- ~ 1·~'1
,· '"JUI·o-4 1--~('-:<~~l~i
.:r-6 ~ ~ c..:,------ ~ ~--
~ J ?:i cc·IJ ,J~I w~ ~ . ) A ~lS:6' ~.J-Ai .J~JJ ~>Li cd)G 0-A~i
a;,~~, '-""~10~.J-Ai u~ y ~ J.i..;-b ~ ~.J-Ai .J~J.) 0~ v, r t4-4
w~~~.J-Ai.J~JJ ,. ·, • • • 0-,A~i ~iJ,American Express
~...>At .J~JJ V'1, • • • t--44J (.:.>Neiman Marcus w,u.,_5.)lA 0 ~ a5.;--.!. 0-4
i;ll~)U l:IJAJ ~>Li~ wl.)~J.J.ll 1...9~jJ ~.)~~ wl~~ ~ ~
. (Buettner, 2010)
~ U. j \ 4.....,jl.J>-u
. I • .u ~_ a5'..)--'-'J:. ~
. ____j\ u.H
• ~
_ I .u ~ ..ul ~
I ·-- ~
0-*4 r , o t4-4 ~ Bear Steams~~ .H! a5->1uJ Lehman Brothers Holdings

~JwL.u4",u0i~_rtl0-40i~l~ '-4.-4,r, Y• •Ar,k-~Jr,Y· • • r,k-0-A.J~JJ
~J ~jJ ~~!'-pl w ;;_;Jo~I ~ ~ ..\l ~~I~~~ w4:i_rll
JJ-9.J~ ~ ~~ ~IJ The Wages of Failure lliWI .J..?. ~I 01~ ~ U.J_,J
.J.41 • Harvard Law School (Bebchuk, Cohen, and Spamann, 2010) 0~WJ
~ ~>Ul ~ ~ j ~\j 0~ a5~ ~ .)~I cl scs~\ ~Jj-uJ.I .)_?.i ~
wlJ~ ;;.)~ ~ ~~ ~ ~.J-Ai .)~JJ 0-*4,, •r r,Y· ·A r,k..J-!-qi: , · ~
0-,>~..ul .Jl# wl~k. ~ J . ;;_;.:wl 1.!1.1:i J>l,;.. ~~I w~ 0-4 wl~k.J 4:~
~~lwl~l~~.J-Ai.J~JJ0..*4, ,t1~~.H!a5.;--.!.~~~I
a5~ i;I~ ~ .JP Morgan Chase & Co "~->1uJ ~.JJ-4 ~ ~ a5->1u llil..9-4
0~~10~..u.1 i;~_j.A l&.J ~~ ..\l~~ ~l 0~ ,l.:U ·r,Y· •A r,k. ~ 0~
J>l,;.. ~
- I~ ~ ~ti a.JUI
- ww..ul 1.!1.1:i o-4
• ~:j-'J- ~- ..\l ~-~1..)-4"
:. ~ "--1..LUU
• • •
. ~WI ~~I wl~I
,Cui .jib~~~~~
a5->1uJ UnitedAirlines ..w:\.j~0l..;-:b a5~~.J-A~I w~~l 0-A~~J
.J~JJ0~ ro · ~~I 0,,>~..Ll.l.J~'5..»-i w~->1uJ USAirwaysw,ul~0I~
~tzll wLlilLo ..kb~ ~I~ ~.)41,-,;;: «,, ~I ~ I wl~I ~
_jAJ .)~JJ 0 ~ \V\ t4-4 ~ . l ~ 01..>-=1:JI w~~ '5~1 w ~ ~ . ~_jl
ur........-~v... ~.~-:--===--~---~~..:..a.:...J.~~~....,._-::.:~::!LA·.ax. c;.....•c.-=.----=..~.-...,.,,.,.,..,,._.=-a=...:A....-.'N--.~-"- -..:;,-.e,,c,.
~~ ~ ~ ~.'.l.!1 l.o.J ~~ faU :ul.J:a.al '?9 ~~lj ~~1 ~"

JU.I '?'JI
~)\j ~ ~.J.ll ~.,JI~ ~_,1.b.ll ~tzll wLlilLo ~ J~)U y_,1.bJ.I t4-ll

.wW:u~ ~yi J'"xJJ 0~ o, o ~~~~I as'~I ~...>:J.A J~ 0-4
J '"xJJ 0J,&,A , r · t:4-4 0:--:~I ~."4 J~ 0-4 ~J ~ i.S.»-i as'~ ~ J ~
a,o,o;.J.\ ~ L a l ~ ~ .i9J .as'~I U"'~l wl~ ~ ~~ J)l;. ~yi
~ ~ . , J I ~ ~ .:Gi U? ~ ~ I ~1 w'"xWI ~ ~ ~ ~ L>=~'-4Wl
'f,&--'-"j ~ J ~ I wlJ~J w~.;-ll ~ wb~ ~~I ~..>:..LI.I Jl:6' DLl~
. (Rosenkrantz, 2009) k>retention bonuses ~~I wTh~J
~J ,Nortel Networks w'"x~)U LPJis as'~ ~>-3 , ~ ~ J...-;sJ

r~ ~ i ~ ~ w~Ji ~~,~WI a!;;;}I wl~ ~~I w\S'~I i.S..1>.l
c.!.U~ulS'JwTh~I ~ J ~ I ~0~~1 u~...\.1.1~1 ~J ·r't'• •'\
~
J,o..,..!'" .as'~lwl.b~JPJ~J~~~~'il~¥yl«.·: «·:~~

wTh~ ~yi J'"xJJ c.:,~ V, o t:4-4 ~ LPJis as'~ ~J~ 0-4 C.:,~J c.:,l.jl
L>:.J.ll ~i ,C.:,J~la:UI ~ ui ~ ~ . , J I ~ ~_;-ll w-4J .~IJJ ~! ~~
.. _(' . - .,~-: ,_ ,al~ '"xi~
~~<;- ~
L -'I ,_ D ...l4.ll ~ ..u U""'="~
• • • u-- <;- '.)
.... t • .J.llJ ~-~U;j 'J ~
~~' V"':PYI ~JI -~~ ~i ~ I ~ 01 ~i Ji ~~tzll ~I COCOtA ~
J'"xJJ 0~, r, r t:4-4 0i Mike Zafirovski ~ J J ~ l j ~LA as'~ J:t~I
' , • • • ~Gl ~ r'r • • '\ U"'JLA ~ ~J ,D.»-L:iA w~~J «-;,JIJJ ~\S' ~yi
wTh~ ~yi J'"xJJ 0~ to t:4-4 ~ DJ'-flll as'~I ~ ~~I 0-J.->:..U.I 0-4
. (Evans, 2009a, 2009b; Reuters, 2009) retention bonuses ~~I
~y~I ~l~I ~ b 0-4 Goldman Sachs ~L.u 0LA..u.?. ~~ ~

c.:,~ ,v t:4-4~J~~,~~ ,J.,L'Ul~J ·J'"xJJ~>4 '. ~Ll~~
i~ ~iJ ~~I~~ rWI ~~ wTh~ ~~ ~~I C.:,........,.->:..1.4.U J '"xJJ
-
;;.J~ ~ ~yi .J'"xJJ0~ r · ~~ 0-4 "i~~ t:9J ~ U"'L..iJI w4~"i
LA~ ~_µIDJ~l~oi:s~~J,wlJ-L'-"~;;._u. ~Jo~"il~~j
a.d.b:u..ul.J. JI.J LA c..>--'J
. ('t .aJ~~
..
- LLl.:...o ..~ \ .I~ J .ig ~ · ti . i ,La:,.."}/ ...
. ul.~ c.r _,.,- - 'r u ~
;;_J-& ~~ uTh~ ~ J ~ I ~b'il ~I~~~ ~I .rt):. 0-4 0-3~b.l.l J~
0i ~ j i aJJi J_?.J f'...L-C. Ji~~.;. , .. \t~I L>--"'J .(Johansmeyer, 2009)
01 ,t9l.,JI ~ .~.,_JI ~b~I 0-4 Jul4 ...u..]J ~.,JI ~b~I ~ ~~ uTh~ ~
Jo~I u ~ 0-4 ...u...H w ~b~I ul.dji 0-4 ...u.._H .i9 o_;-& ;;ts~ J_?.J J~I
~bi a.!:..!'~ _µ1 ~ uTh~l 0~~ Jl~~I ~ i J.a.l . ~b~I 0-4 J.,..ilJ..J
Jl ~ i~t.:; ulsts:..Jl 0~ (S ,ua·,t ~~I (>'Y-...u.1 _;l.p c)AJ:! LS -~.,JI
- ~ ~ I (>'Y-...u.l Ji ulS'.;,1WI ~Llt ~ ~ 4 i ~b ~ ~ cGl
~ <?I uls~IJ , ~ ~ I (>'Y-J.41.J ~ tf4,ll ~l»JI ~ ~ I .lJ 1.Pl

J ~ ~ I "?.J.JI c.rl_,JI ~ ~~La:.J.I u\ ,o,o.:.:,, ~ ~JJ ,~Ll'i4 U)k ~
~ al.AWi 15~1 .ll..L....C.i ~ ILLI~J ~ ul.9~ c.).c. ~~I 0--..JY-...u.l
d..J~
• -!Jc.:r''1
ul.o..i.;.. D.lL.,·
·'-l.Jo~u~.
· ~ I u~ ~· ...u.l ~
• ~I ~ .eLll c.rl·'I
,_,.,
ul~..LSJ~~4-J ~ ~~I (>'Y-...u.l Jjl.i..o~..,-.J ...\.al - ~ ~ I (>'Y-...u.l
~~ <)Al ~-"4 ulS'~I ~ , ~ I ul~~I "~ ~~lS'J -~4
Jul.I ~c.).c.) u.WI ~~<fil.olJ~)\j~J~~I (>'Y-...u.l ~~~
<>4 ~~ ILLI~J , 1 1.!'u<II ~..1.4 ~~~bl c.rlJ ~ ~~I ul.o..i.;.. f=.J.a:i
.~b_;.J.&4.o ul~ ul~~I c.Lll:i c)A~l ul ~WI c.rl_,JI ~ ~JJ ('--9\.b:o.~I
~14:lUI ul.o...GJI tl..bs ~, a .!abtl ~I~ ,a.JlhtJI tLl:iJI c)A ~~4J

0::' 0 ~~I a.J6. .J.J...)':! l4A d.:l~ c.Jljl.o ~~J-AJ ~~I (>'Y-...u.1 uLl~ ul
·vuWI L~J J~'il tl..bs
0l (Mintzberg, Simons, and Basu, 2002) J--4J u ~ I J [.>-:JJ:u.4 ,.;~
r~I ~ a.!,o~I a,-\.04\t i ~ I ~ ~..>At JW ~ ~UI ~..1.4£11
'.·: cull 0~~ l.cSJFI ~ ...\.al .ILLJ~u.w,_,l«~w'il»DJ~0~J.ll
.~'ii l.!I)U ~W.1 f=.J.a:i JA u ~ I ~~ ~ ..L.:P--.,ll
• • Jt y,A
I""=! CO~
•
"?.J.JIJ ~ ~ ~ ~.J.JI ~~IJ J4,.~I c)A i..)~ "?~ W\l l.!IUA ul ~

0J.H..1AJ 0.J¥'fi::.. 0~-"4J 0 ~ u.,lJ~ ~ J ~l.JoJ J ~ I IJjL.ut
:~bll d.L.o~I j.Ab.i.J .~\.;.JI t ~ I c,;s c.:,~ \:aii
~li9~.ill ~~I ~ I ~ J Jean-Louis Roy "?JJ (.)-"-l..,l ~ ~.ll -

~.ll.:,..j":JI Lfi>JI <>4 4-...A~...u.1 Canadian Rights and Democracy J ~ I J
~ I ul ~~I~ ~.J4 c,;s ~ t'\ ~~ ul_,.i...- ~)lj J ~ uLll:, .l_?.J
JJLl:iJ a.!,o;. .~,JI u'-9~1 ~~ u ~ ~J,j "iJ 1.!JllA ~w..r., "?i ~ f1
. (National Post, 2009b) ~l~I ~ b yL..u..:... c.).c. ~.,I.I~ ~l...wl
' ..
JUl~Jt
c;:;:;;7'Sr~-,. .~,-·.:·.-~ .,p,a::.,·., ' @ ~ r A · =-?W---~-----·V ·.Q-¥:W-&ffPA w -~.,---~.....f,<-·:r·-.Y:· ·-·f. ;:..,....?.::J'rS".taEZ··-··~ · A =-·Y ..0.37~:?b ·· fdAi®:> *..-;-a
~ t:9J ~ ,J:,L."11 ~\.b~I ~1J.J_,11 ~.; Gordon Brown wJI..H c)J_;~ ~IJ -
(Winnett ' 2009) <J:l~J
· ·- UJ~
- J~iJ ~ - ~
1.~ lu..J - IL-~- \'1' u o
- - ~.. ~ '
~hJ.,JI ~ J u ~ Daily .Telegraph~,~ ~.JJI ~ ~ ~ \.!U~J
YJ~ Lo k.,k:ic:,~1 yl~ (.)A wo t:9J '>4~,M~~, ~J ·rY· ., rw:.
IJA ~ o..,.;J.I ul~w:.J'il IJAJ . (Stratton, 2009) ~>'-""1 ~ r · · ,···
,~ o.;,:bJ ~Lo J.J..i.>.,;, .:loiiJ ,~l+--w, w,o_p-, a.:lofi1 ~ , c.!ll:; r~'il
..Hf!- Jj.ll ':?J~ w-A..>1 ~l~J ,r..l.411 ofi ul:u~ o~~ ~~ ul)-:!--""J
f-"'""' f'I.J;.j sc·4 \.!U~J ol_,.c.J cjJ 4.J ~' ~ ~ ~ ' j cl:llA u\ co co;. OJ ,J~J,A
Lo LJ:4:IL....uJI ylj,lll u 4 ~ ~IJ-4 ~J . (Telegraph.co.uk, 2009) ~ J
ub.;T Sir Thomas Legg~ u,uLoji ~I~ IJA rY· ·A ~ J rY· •t 6::'
~ .>-Pi c:,lS' -~~! ~ c)~ ' , '' ~~ Lo t:9J oJ~ ?/ yl_,.al u4,Uo
~~ l.;4.;4 ~ I yj.>. a;w IJA \.:i.:l>'-""l ~ t Y, toA .tA .GJ~I ~ - -
,~litl L,.lj.lA '->.JJ a.ta.i:UI ~~I ui:uJ.JJI u ~ ~ c.r-AJ Barbara Follet
~ 0:4b.tl , ~ I c:,~I ~ 0:4b.JIJ ~L,.11 c.b_,k>JI J~ ~ Jol_~?/IJ
..\SJ -~litl L,.lj.lA .,-A~ r:9JA ~ u l ~ ~lS°.AJ '~..>-4 ~ t:9J ~ w~
~ t • ~ Ilford South c!JJL-u J_;_,.il~ a;l.i.JI ~ IJA t~..LA ~ ~i c:,lS'
..w ~ o~ u~~..LA f-8:.JJ c.c:,lS' ~lJI ylj,lll Lot .(BBC News, 2010)
yl_,.tll 1JA J~ ~ly..J r' Y•, • rW LWI u4l.:.::.:lj'il ~ ~ ~ r.J.A J i ~
.J~'il ~ ~4 ul..Al+il -L:Jb..
Lo~ ':?.J..£1Y-~I c:,~I f"'""4 c!.t~I John O'Donoghue ~~JJl c:,~ ~ -
~~JJi ~i -~_;\.;JI .G~_;Ja.;.~4JI .G~U:!J~u~LWtu~
\.!U~ ~ ~ ,~>'-""1 ~ 1 • • , • • • (.)A ~l r r · ·A r~J r r · · r r~ 6::' Lo
~ J ' ~ ~_.;4J J y ~ ~ J~ ~ l.41~ ~ Js:.J ~ , • • c:,.....o ~i
.(Sharrock, 2009) ...b,.IJ .;LkA ~ ~~ 6::' o.;~4 4.Jlajjl o.r?-l ~ tvr
~l:JIJ yW)U y_.;bjJf as-.;--1u ~.; ~ ~ r r · ·' r~ ~ ~ ~ -
~ ~ll.o~I ~ ~~i ~lS' Jla:l.....,..ulJ Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corp
y_.;bjf L ~ y ~ ~ Jl->9~1 ~ 'ij..4, ~ .ule~I w~ u'ijL,.J o_;l:i}
1JA ~JA ~ J IJ.J_.;fo ~~~I c:,y..;-aJIJ ~ I r~i ~JA oJ~! ~
.(CBC News, 2009) o.;4,u, ~ J ul~W . ; ~ ~ ~i
'.'
~l:Jl~I
r.= .· -=~·~=--~-~ ...·. ·.-. __.:=__._-::· ....:_. _:_. . : -_..._-::_. < -::;.·._ ..~.. ::_:- . ---~~-=~--.. u ~ - .• · . ·=··~_. . >.-... v:::2 . .- ..~
~J ,eHealth ~~)'I ~ I o.J.>.J~.J~~f"'r• •'\ rk. ~~~~ -

<l=t:..L.4 l.!.Uj ~ ~~ . JJ_)~J l:, ~ I ulA_,i....t. I ~_p,- u£- aJJj.....uJ I o.b._jll
.a..ok. ~Ll..o uJ~~~.J':JJ~~~ o ~ ~~I uLd!Ll..o~l_u, ~~~
~.;JI~ t:9~ ~l~I ~ b JAi~ ~ ~i ,~ 4k. ~~ .J~i t:9~ ~~J
.(Dearing, 2009) o~I ~~IJ ~~?JI ..u.._>+}I ~l_u,.J ~
~~I 0A Jgi i.SJi J~~I o~Ll f.!.!;; ~ ,~WI c.:-g_jll ~
·er~
~~.Ju. d.£.4~ a..o~ ~JJ.# ~ cu.r?"i rWI ~l_;-U ~ I ~ l .0:4WIJ

~JA~10-41., • ulKennedy School of Government at Harvard University
· · ,~(1.oY)a.....£~1
u~.r-- •. LAi ....
~ ~-ti~·u·'--·J~~lo~l.9
~ · ~~
u·L. uJ ..
,·~-~,~j.:.~,
"""-- i..r , -.. '" t< _:._.
c-- ~.J ~ u.r--: ··'--·u~· _:._u, .....
~ '-"..":' ..
~ 1 -0-l...>: .J LS'·L
..u.1 . u .
~bA ~ ~ I 0A o ~ ~~ ~ u~ ~i ~JA~I 0-41.,, ->5j
~ , ~ I ~ ~J 0---4 . (Center for Public Leadership, 2009) a........w:,L;JI
. (Colvin, 2004) o~l.9 u4lL ~ o~l.9 ~I.>:>~ i~l.9 6..LlJ J~ ~I o~ll
a~i:,_1.d.t"J't ~~..WtJ4$ ~~
~U;.tl ~-~ti t .... o· ..<ti
1.~~ -- tWI ~L....uS:.JI ul~:.t:; (,>A
· ~· J-'
.ti <.:r-
t ....
~ ~J
- ~ <.:r- ~ ':r"
r k. ~ . ~~ ~t:~JI ~ ulljlA ~~10-J...>:..U.I .J~ u\+i.J-4 u~ '.J~ ~IJ

0A o.J-4 Wt w,ki ~~I ~l_u,»JI J\.# 0-4 , • •ll ~~..u.l ~l»JI U:,~ 'f" 'r • •A
I~~ .r?"~I i.h.u.j£A .J..49 f" r .. Ark.J f"' '\'\Ark. ~J . I~~.)~ ~I i.h.u.j£A
· ~
~ · ..u.l .)~ i u·~J 6.:i
.. I 0-l...>: . ~ . ~ ,.:ll \
· '-T - ~
-.:...:...~ti . ~~1 ~ l.!.Uj~ 1.1
. (CBC News, 2010) 1.V • -! ~ I J..u.A

,StephenHester~~_;st~ -~i,0-40..u~~~l~~I~
~ I ul.:i ,Royal Bank of Scotland ~ I ~~~I~~ ~~I ..H..u.l
~ l.:.U .(Prynn and Duncan, 2010) I ~ ~J-4 ~IJ ul:i um i,IJJIJ ~
(o~I ul:':J_jll ,o~I ~ I ,l.u.i,j~) JJJJI 0-4 ~~ uLA~ ui y.;ti «11110-4
u=o~ Ji~\ ,o rov ~ ub~IJ ~~I ~...):...U.I ~IJ.) 0-4 .J.>JI ~ ~_JJ
.4k. u\+i.J-4 w,k u ~ ~.:.UI w,k ¥~1 ~I~
uLlJ .J-:l...: ~ W J ..,._:,~ i,->---5j L...A yl.; ; i , ,~ ~ I u--4J
~ ~~ ~I ul.Jb)'I ~~ ui 0-4 (Guner, Malmendier and Tate, 2008)
~~ 4.1d ~ L?~I LA.9 ~..\>,j I~ :uW:a.al ~ . > \ , ~ ~ I - - - = ~ • \'

JUl~Jt
1f7Jt7z77.-..,.5....-.
· ,·. . . , ·,·i,.~. , ,.· ., ;,A.,.,. . ...>:·,~5*~-~7~·~:cIT:f~.~-~dJ'.?·,·; .•-:-·-:·.~-.·,.-&··:-· .=~-~-•:.,.rn::::::.E4"°~;.~~7\.i:,~.~.~:::~zr~~j-~~~!Jl
u ~ .)\~~I ~~J..e u~ 4~ u~..>-4 ~ u~ 0-4-4 ~ I ~~i

ulS'~I J.>:..1.A ~ ,dJj o-11 a_g~l .u~.;-ll ~ ubl:j.ll_.9 u~.;-ll 0-4 4~
~ J ~4=,.ll u~JI..L.A ~ ~bll J:?.,i 0-4 ,b; ,;.,It 4LA ul..>-?- f4:!.J.l 0:!~I
·~~I i.LJ~ J..,.Lot dJj u§.: ui ;;.;~4
•.»-?-~t i.>A ~ t 74 ~'-Lhi>Jt.»-?-i ~ ..\l
white-collar criminals j~I ~J°-> i.>A 6:-4_r.e-1.I ;;~ U a· o, o;.io ~~ u lH

u~LuJI 0.JA~I r~ . ~ I ; ; ~ o-11 ~I~.)\.;.. ;;~I 0-4 J.,...,.:JI ~
. ~ I ; ; ~ J~ ~~~~LA_,~~ U ~ j i ul~L.u..o
~ o.;~l.t..u.u u..F.-'-" ~t 0-4 Nick Leeson u ~ ~ r'..>---'-" J>lbl ~ ...L4l

~....>-4i .)~J.) u-*4 't' ~ ~.;~I J:6:JI '.'.'
ulJ-L--'-" &Ji~ ui Ill!~
~ul~b~t:,'il.j-AJ .BaringsBank~.;4~.J-'4A.;~I~~~,..,
LA..Li.c. 'U..4 4.!..:...wl t)bi CCC.! 0-4 ~..u t:,lS' ui ~ ) a:;.)WI 0-4 o.)~I LA L)-l?'il
4LA u~i i.LJUA t:,lS'..9 ,~lS' 4LA ~ll.; ~.,: ~) ~ J ~ J ( ~ "~~ ~lS'
;;~l_,JI ;;~WI ~~..91.; ...L4l .(~u-"Llll i.>A~t_bi , ,2f3 ;;~
·~~! ~ '·, · · · <.)l '"\,···~LA
~l.;-ll uLA...G.. .)l~)U r..l4i ~I a.: q.:t:, iit\..9 ~.)~I uw..G.JI u_)A.)jl ~
-~~I JI.JA~I ;;.)~~'-fl~~ ~I .)~l..9 .)L..u..o..ll ~LluS'l..9 4UI
~J:,5 .j-AJ ,Martin Kenney~ uJ.;LA ul.b~ (Ryan, 2009) u~ ~
~ ~ I ~.., ,~Li.a.JI . ) ~ ~~ ~ d ..Lq t; j Q ~ fa~ -~...;~I~~
.Jlu>-~I
- . i .:w
JI.JA i ~ .. ~......
° " .:r~I L-~
~.q ct.j~
~_)
~
i« ~ ~ t i>4 ~ t » al~" ~t.jhN'tJ~t ~ ...\l

~I.;.) ~.;4,. CdBroadway ~IJ.)..H ~ L>i ,... .,:., ,f" '1' • • ~ f"~ u-".JLA ~ ~
~1~4 ~J.Jji ~ L>~.J.A Myron Gottlieb~..?. u»:LAJ Garth Drabinsky
~I ~WI a ,cc\=?'" ~J .Levent ,.. i.:ci.:l c4 ~~I i.>A . ) ~ J~I cl.....4.l...r!"
y~I.., ~~I u l ~ 0-4 4$.F ~Lu,.) ~ b r..ll ~1.;1~1, ... ;., I
1,0"\ .Y'~~:.~1:.--0:-:..."\:~·~"'-'U,7;,.•.,..•,.:,,,.,_Vll',•-=-",.•"~ L/',U7J'~--·~---· ''J,C,,31~--.;r--"l,.,_~A.~0"11,•a,.•..,. . °'..-_

.._-. .. •#-,._V._'<:-. i , , - r - •" " " " " · _....... . . . ., . ~
\ •Y' ~~ 4.la! ~ 1$~1 l.oj ~...L>,j faU :&:l~I ~ ~~lj 4-,~I
~UJtJ,wM.Jt
f§-l+Jl..Z.@\\\t&4f¥&@1¥¥itfktko1N&ifhki4@ik¥@t~\r~~irtw@i4i§4@@+ii1i&i&PWlw&#&•~iY&V®@A%iiW fr@®i94ffl1Tfu·1@f§VMW~-.~ilra,;r~\%&i&i#%M&ii?&%#ili0@,&yi#J
1
ljjLl,f ~ .ylj.?.J '-:?< eui:I.J~ ~~ 0,A ~~I~ l~l <J:!.:.UI <J:!..uj.llJ

-LA~ ~ l j ~~?JI "'='1j..ill 4All?JI ~ ~ c.:,k yl:i.?.J 0 ."i!IJ.> J ~ ~1
~..l.4i 0,A o~I o~ J~ ~ w ~1>1,1 o-4 c l ~ ~)t:tl ~~ ~
. (Acharya and Yew, 2009) ~ I c ~ ~ i ~ 4.AA~I y ~ cl~b..o
~ ct,."'6:..o "Wht Bernard Madoff c..SJ.>LA .>Jw.;-tl r ~ ~~ I~ ~ f
t_.!bi«u.: ~ J , ~ ~6.J.IJ Ponzi scheme ':?.)Aiill ':?j:J.J,! .JoJo~ ~-¥1 a.!,;§
J~~l 4.41~ l~Ji <J:!.:.UI .>!_~~I t_.!bicuJ ~ J ' ~ _,.b-JI c..Sj~I ~~
.At". -~·'I ~ ~1
~.:u-- --r -
,, A
1~\tt iJA ..u_j.A~! i-lJQt('t.M:,.J 4 \!ha.Jt~1 ,S~jl ..Li

American International Group, Inc. (AIG) ~.J-A ~I ~J..UI ~~I as'->1u ~lS'
c.:,J,A.;JIJ~J.>41J ~.>J '&'.!'?" ,~,;~c.>"')u?/1 ~Jc.:,ko~~.J-Alas'~~J
~WI ~.,JI ~J ~ ~ta.,JI c.JJ'.!b; "'.! ~ .>l~i ~ ~ <i°'11 ~ I ~~I
.c.:,_,:<..,.J-A~I ~l~I ..,_.slJ L,41 ct.A..il ~.:.UI JUI«.·: '"! u,u)u?JI 0,A as'..,_.!JI ~
o ~ Robert Benmosche ~~ c~JJ --':?~I ~~I ~ J ~ ..ilJ
~lj;S' ~L-, c.:,k Jk:i <i°'11 ~ ~Li.JI ~ I o-4 as'..,_.!JI c4 ~I~ JJ~I
c.:,k c...a~ ~l1i~I o~ ~ c.:,lS' ~ ~..J-41 J~JJ c.:,~ ~ ~ J ~l:LJ.>?JI
~~4c.:,i~1J~i ..ilJ .Dubrovnik~~J.>J~d.lh~~I~
~~~I J~~I ~.,J~ J~ o-4 (AIG) ~ ':?i 4:?l J~i c4 ~ljtll
~ 1 A._1 .(Clark 2009) cl
- J "(to' '
~!!fl.-~ -~e LlJ.l.,• a..w
~ . , . . . ":T ~ j -
1 ·'I c'iLAi'il ~ -·')11
I.ft-' J ~ J 5
.1~ r~ c.:,i ~..b-i c.:,k ~ ~J ~

1~1iU:.c».J~J,~•4:'~~!•\!hN't~1'.5~jl .\l
4,jly,.lJ c.:,~ as-~ c.:,)lc.1 (>-4 r~ ~Jr"··°' rw. ~J:iS'l ~ ~
D:lb~ ~~I as'~I i..S~J.A JI.# 0,A ~ JIJLA 'c.>"')u?/1 Lehman Brothers
- ..
l~J.A ~ ~4JI c.:,~ LA~ J>i ~ c.:,k J ~ I ~~I o-4 .J.4All ~
, ....... I. - - .
c.,..-u~~ ~~I~'i~.r-U
· lS' J.4l •~
. . J~I
-
~
..
.. as'.~
& ~J-'A -~-' L.J..ui.D
- ..
~~ o-4 Jsi C~.)A t_--A ~Lull c.:,~I ~ J ~lS'~ ~ ~ ~~ C~.)A
:rY··°'r~~~~~ ~~.,11~.J,!c.Jl::t~ ~J -~
JUI ~Jl
,-~·> (v9ft§ -&-\ftAi{f#tY l'·-t+· r.;.;.: -<~<$-· . ..jO.•'f·:. k·v:.A:-f&@··~~%*4 x ff.=>4}ih>~:if:vLfiffi>2f<t iB k.'. .": . . ·::.! :,~.1v.;@.. 3@wvpk.=.v=··4··.:JH•±§}: ~-.. ,. :®T'"\" hi~kH
.~I ~ ~ k JI..H LA Richard Fuld ..u-"9 .l) «~«'.!) ~~I ~.;JI -

.~I ~ ~ k JI..H LA Joseph Gregory ~.)~-.r':- u.J_j_?. ~.;JI -
o-s~ ~ c.S.?-l ;;..>-4 ~I~ )lbl.c. ~ f Bart McDade .ll.JS'..A u.;4 ~.;JI -
.Barclays ~.;4 aS'_;.-1;, 0-4
.:iJ4-1 ~ ~ J ulo-"° d_jj ~ I &4 Erin Callan 0~lS' oJ...>:l JUI ~~I ~->31-
~.; American Securitized Products 4UI Jl.;J)U ~\JI aS'~I ~.; -
• ~.JA JIJLA Rich McKinney ~LA
~.;L....a...JI LJ---A.;-\l 4~i.;JI aS'~I ~ . ; Ted Janulis ~~4,- ~ -
. ..u:.LZ.o Mortgage Capital
,~4:.J'Wt .\lt~t
, ~ I c.S.l.1.1 ~ . ~ i ~ J ~ I ~~h, ~..)~~ ~ .ll->9\'I ~
c..:,ll .lJ4i ...w ~ I c.S.l.1.1 ~ LAi ,J~4 I.;~ .l.J-41J ul~l i,.J....-A t~ ~
~ .(Callahan, 2004) ~1>'11J ;;~I ;;.ll:j c..:,ll ~~I~~~ ~.l~~l r~
ulLo4J J_,;...ul ~i <J-4 ~4,-.;.l ~.;J ~J~I '-'"".;l..u.1 ~~ ~ ~ y)L..b.tl
~i<JA~iu4,..;.l~J~ulLo4Jl~~y~I ~ . ~ i
~~ o-4~i ~ 0J~ J~~I ;;.;bl ul:JS' ~J ,~i ~Uo_, ~ J ~ I
o-4 ;;.;Jj.A u b ~ u.o~\11 ~~ ~ ·c.S_;.;..~1 ~JlS'\11 ~l~I y>l,b <J-4
Jl->9\'I ~ ~ .~i ~LA ...dl.c. ul~ ~Uo_, ~ J ~ I ~i 0-4 ~ J ulLo4,.
u4~ c.;a ~I.JAi u.o~~I F..J .J;...ul ~I~ c.;a_, u~I u 4 ~ ~
IJ-..,. ! « o.!J ~l:.,JI J ~ ~ u.o~ ~I~ ~ . J;...ul ~I~~.)~~.;~
,, -
Jl..u:.i~ ~ljJ ~i~L.L.4> .u~luw~lo-4JUI~ l~..J0-l..J~
- ,,
••. _=:~ ... q . i .. '\ I.:,..~ .::~j, ~:j I ~t!.~ a.JUI,~- L, i ~ - ..LLLi ~,, u ~ I
<.)-,1.....r--- ~ ~
,, - • J""'- '"&-' .) ~ . - "(p'- .!.) • - !..>-J - (;'"'
-
~~ 'C~ l:.;~ ~ I ~ . (Albercht, Albrecht and Dolan, 2007)
.(Frank, Cook, 1995) ~~ JS'jjWI F <?' a~.!!JI ~ ~~J ,4UI ~LU4
I~~~
, ~ ~ I o-s~.411 ~...w ~I ~1..v,JI L.JIJI JJ...L...JI ~ u~l_,J.I y.7 ,~·.!
~~ c.?JI ulS'~I u~WI ~ ~J ~ I ~b\11 ul~ ulS'~I ~ ~~
~ ~ ~ . . . . . , _ a , c , e ~ " • . c ' o : . = . ' 1 1 ' ,... o ' " A ~ - . . - . ~ • . - e , : . r - , i ; : , - , ; , t ? " " ~ - · ~ Y C : O " ~ ~ I I M ( . ~ ~ ~ > " . . C V . ~ ~ · . o , · . i : , n . . . s . • 1 1 ; . ~ V ~ " l o N D . ' ° ~
'• 0 lfj~ 4J.a.9 ~ "?'.:UI l.oj ~i.bJ ,~u : u ~ I ~ Jl.w..illj 4.4,J~I

~UJl~I
L·~5..L.L;;;.·~:·... ,.t;... ·'.:.·-~;·i.~:~:i~~~-,.-.·c_· ..; · · · - = ' 4 : · · ~ ~ - ~ ,·,· .-.·1.._,,m4~-~. .~.~--::-rrZZJ
1-!·.-.'·.,'.··~.-.-:;-·,·.-.,·.· .
ul.J~I ~ ulS'_,._j, <JA ~~ 0..9:?~I c.:,~..ul rJh-i ,11\ ljU ·I.Y'~¥l

~i l~U 5~1_,J ~ ~ I a..lo.A4J1 as'~I ul__;Uo c.,~..) ~ ;;.Jl+iJ.I
~ . . ) ~ ~ ~ I ~UI u ~ J.JJ u~j.A i..SJ.>.'# ~~I ~->:..ul J.>.i
~ lA ~ I I.J..A ~ ,~lS:l.10:JyJ ~->-°i .J'1J.l, • ·, • • • <JA ,PS'i '-?"4~
~ <jJI ulS'~ ~~I ~->:..ul ~l.,_,J ~i, ;,,; "' I.JA~ lA4Ji ~.;JI
.J~'il 0A ~.;JI ~J ~J -~->-4i .J'iJ.l o • ·, • • • .)J4u: 'i '-?"4~ ~.l ~
u~~ ~ ~.Jbll ~~ 0A o, • • • <JA ,PS'i ~ r '1' • •Ar~~ ~.l~'il
aJLua_;JI c.:,1 .(Story and Dash, 2009) rWI ..ill~~ ~->-°i .J'1J.l c.:,~ 0A ps-i
lA~J ~1.)~j ~ ..tlJj ~ J,o,:i 1119 j ~ ~~1 ~bi c.:,lS' 1~} ~ d...Jj ~l.)J
J,o,-i ,11s~l~l~bJl~i0A~..ul~_,j~ ~~~l~bic.:,~
~~, as"_,._j, ~~ .l~i 'r"· ·~ r~ .~,.)~i ~ ..tlJj ~
l..).IJ.)LA~ ~
~ 4 ~ . ) ~ '.·: ,11., lA:,.J ~ I ~ ~I u~lS:l.1 AIG ~->-°~I 4J..ul
.(McCool and Zuill, 2009) '-?"4~'#1 r~'il 4 ~
~2:•calt4.l4j~t~~~A.lttj~~,jlb~ a~~t~~i':7'~U
~ ~~1 y ~ l ~ ~.l~'il .lfi'.;JI ~b c.:,ll uw~I ~..1>-i, ;, ,~,-4~1.J'iJ...u4) ~6.. ~>4,11 yW:t:..L.oi
i.5..u ~~ '}I c.:,lS' c.:,i ~ ~..)~ ~~ ~ ,;;..u::al ul:'i_,JI ~;;~~~\:ill
~ .l.P.""J c.:,ll~ <jJI u ~ I ~ <.!.J~J ·>:PJ:-4 ~i r"· ., r~ ~ I
,..illj c.:,ll ~~1 .c.:,~1 ~ ~--1:..l>J M ~ 0:.JJIJ ~ 1 ~ ~>4,11 yW:t:..L.oi
- -
y ~ i .ll~ i ~ ~ J:lj.:j <.!.J~ .J..ifllJ ~I~ .1.;,;,J:-4 t ~ ..L-41 i.5...L...l
~ ~l_j,JI JAJ , LAji.JJ 0:.JJI iillJJi ~~ (' s "'a·, L:i ~IJP 1 ~ 0:.JJ I ~>4,11
JAJ ,Deng Xiaoping ~..9:?IJ ~.lp~ ..141 .;;~1 ul:'i_,llJ ;;~1 ~ I
J~ .((~1.JJ-Ai ~IPJI ~ J~I» c.:,i ,~~1 ~ 1 yj.>JI ~ &.Lu, .l!,tg
.ll~i ..tlJj ~ J~ ~ ~ c.:,~ ~J ~ 1 ~1 ~ J ..i9 aJLua_;JI c.:,i
~ ~1.;JI u ~ I .;I~~ <jJI I.Y'~Y.IJ BMWs ~..) rl ~I ul.J~
-~~~~
.,.-_-,65,,!.·~..r..~-_,,,_ .......,.,_.___ ~ ~ ~ , . . , . . . ~ - ~. .~ - ~ : , ; , , v , - , _ . . . . . - , , , , , _ , _ ~ ~ - . ; , ' , R ~ . : . : , . . . - .
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . : i l l l.oJ i!I~ faU : u ~ I ~ .,Li.a4llj 41~1 \ •"\

Jlll~Jl
G~0- .-:· . · ~·:::r:::2<· : : .. · ::;,-.·~.- ..~:.;6·•. -:,u .. ·=···· · ··--:-.: .·>(;,··-~...~.:..;.......L.~ . - ·.· ··· ·.·· . ;.,\.,··~:~,:c-.;.-·:'_·~· ·· ._,.~·-·,.._.:. ·...--~..... -:;--.,.:.:.· •. ·-_:..... ·.·. ·_-:·.·~ · .-:-<~<···'-:·· . .,.· -...... ~---:-.J
Ll,j .~~~l~Jl.:,... ~ -~ 0 1.1-:~q ... ,,.,,.. ~~~~, "

• -4 •<t
.) ~~ ~ , ~ . ·- - ~~J
~1 National Post (March 27, 2008, FP3) ~~ Jw~w ~ ~~J-?-
c.:.iL:.~ Bear Stearns~~J-td d5~ ~ ~~I .;l# 0-4 ~ I ~4-Jj ~w1
~ I 0-4 ~ i ~ .~~I .;~I y~ 0-4 <J:A.,:! ~ ~jllA W:J_µl ~ I ~L:.
c.:.il:J.I ~I~~ ...l4l .ao.!S.l...P""i ~ ~l_>-11 ~lb..1.1 ~~ ~ J ~ I
rL:. ~ ·r"· •A rL:. 0-4 4:i)Gll ~~I~ ~U;J ~UI c.:.iLA...GJI ~.JA 0-4
~l.;Ji ~ ~ ' i i c.:.,\S'~I c.:.,~ ~~I 0,J~..U.I 0-4 1. tr ~ r r .. A
..l:IJ.J.l.)J ~IJ ~~l_,.J ~J l.!.U~J ~~I ~u~IJ ~~I c.:.iulS:AJ ~UI
~ ~_,.JI ~l...J:. ~ J •Watson Wyatt Worldwide (Towers Watson, 2009)
.i...P""JA «!J~ ~.J.11 ~I~ ~L..u ~l
,G~c.~ ,-~T ft.,.0 ~

~l rJ ~ ~J · ~ ' wi ~ ~L...,~I ab.WI oJL...JIJ .:.,l~I ~t,,
~4(,1 .o.;JJ~J~~J~L.o.J-Ai~lw! -~.J-At,~.,i.t~~i
F' ~ .J.aJ • U>_JA_P.- ~ J ~ ~ Ji.l.:J4 ~.,-b:J' rJ.>--!' .l-4.P.-
J ~ ~ dJl.)-'-ll ~J ~ I ~J JUI ~J o~I ~ ~ l S ~ , o.;~
.,
.;I~ as'~~~~~~~_,...., ,t?I.;~ ljjS~J ,~IJ ,~L....:i)'I
o~l .:.i~"}J_,.JI ~..w '5?t ~as'~~~~ ~J Teldar Paper~
.cc~~I
Michael Douglasu-")4,.JJ~LA~I 1...2>1.llGordonGecko ~0.l.;.P.-.:.,1.;~

Oliver wJL..u ~Ji ~?iJ ~ (' C\AV) Wall Street c...i->'-JJJ ~ ~
.Stone
oJP "-='~ ~ .t41JI 4'=-:= ~.;t Adam Smith ,:.,.:Q ,u r~T ~ I r'i ..l.......4l
~IJ r.J..o:JI s:-1.;J ~I.J.ll ~i ~ 11~w~I» c.,---11...,_Jo.j Wealth of Nations f-4~1
JUI l.:.U. 0~ ~~I~ ~1 JUI 0-4 J.JjA ~ J ~ I ~ ~_;JI ~~ ~
1.S.J.l 0~ ~ r~T 0-4..§: ,LL:.~ •.PS"i c.:.i~J ~U;J ~ ~1 ~.)J: ~WI
~ i ~ J ~ ~~ ~ J ~ I ~ o_;...l.4ll ~ I ~~~I
~~~I a.... Lotl ~_,_;:; -0~ LA~~~j;;~~~~a:,_;1.AA i~
~ L.....,, i ...l4l •~~I t ~~~ ~ i 4..4.,~ .).;I_,.!. I t='..Jj:JJ ;;~ LAJI f"~ 0-4 ~ I c.,---11
~ i l.!.l.JjS ~ 1.>----t:i:- t41JI 0 iJ ~ ~ I 0 ~ '-:r'~ cU.4C ~ ~ I
-.,.-.~-
~w,~,
... ·. -.. -..c.=...:::.:::::::~-,,.,·--·,·., . . . . . . . . . . .:·.·:·!
~..,...\>. l.fl ~..1.4i Jgi c.:,k. ..,t ~1.JJ1 ~1_;g l.fl 11a.;,w\'1» c.:.,i ,.. ,.! Q , "I.>~~.., •4.i.A
¥)l;.\'1 ..,.c.Llall ~ cGl~J o~ Jg\'I J_,\'1 ~~ ~ ~ r~T fa~ . ~
~1~\'1 c.:.,i ~\JI o.,_,.:i 1..:-1~ ~ ~ ~LllJ The Theory of Moral Sentiments
.,,~ ~ » c.:,k. ~ r~1 ~ ~ ·~~ ~~Yo r~I ~...u
a;~La.Jt JWt '-:~ ~

u~.>: ')I ~~i w,-k d,j~; ,.: ')I ~.J......JI JUI U"'L...i.JI &A .>---/:iS ~ »
. Will Smith~ JJJ . « ~ ~ ')I U"'Llt ~ ~bll ~~ l.!l...J~J ~
~1 ~~~ ~4JI ~ I c.:.,'-:, ~~I ~Li.A ~Li.JI_, ~~I J_,...ul ~~ ~

~ <t>Horatio Alger ~ l ~hJA ~ ~ "~ LA I.St 'U""Li.JI cl:>, ~
~W4 Wb JA a.JWI o:U, ~ t~J\'1 ~ J .«rag; to riches»~ _;-WI
~.., .~1.JJ1c.:,k.J~1~J_,...u1~~t~F~ .~u,..,d.....:!~~"l',
.L:J6. ~ ~ c.;-JI t.:J~I ~ .Joi 4:~LA t.:J~ i~t ~Li.A
~I~~ 4:IJ.J '--4ljA F. Scott Fizgerald ...ul.J-:R-~ t.:J\L..,, .~ ~
~0~~1 .i~ ~~\JI ~~~l~~~>> SLlllTheGreatGatsby
c.:.,1 .~»1..:-14'-ld,.__jl:ifa~EmestHemingwayl.S~lA,-, '".!;.Jl LAl .11~J
~~l:>, ~i'.!;C:~I ~t ~~ ~J~ D.JJ-'"Or.i!J .11.Jol ~LA~...u
U""Li.JI ~ . (Leamer, 2009) (t.:Jl~I ~ Jg\'1 c.:,k.) l...u_.;~ f14 ~L.:u
_jj.JJ ~.?.J ~ ~ L& .~...u ~.JJI JUI .JIJ...Al. -~J ~~~I~~~~~
c.:.,~ ~~ . ~J,&:11 .;-:i:.J ~J-&:ll ~ .iJ.JJJ ~ ~~IJ ~l:,;~I ~ ~LA~I U:--:1
~Lhll ~l ~ <*4Wo c.:.,_,J_,Lzu_.., ~I ~4JI ~->314=..u~4 l...u_.;fo ~L.:u
- -
~ ~c.:.,t~~.., ·r~~~~~1 t.:J~La1 t.:Jl~~c.Jfi.J~--'
t.:Jll)\..c. ~...u ..,t ~t ~ Wb ~Li.A~~' 1.S...U , ~ \ ' , e:4 .a..:a1 ~..,
·<YJA\'1 )tS _,t ~ ~ t ~~I
i.S.»-la:JI ~~~I_, 3-..:~UI .)~I c.:,k. J..w ~I t.:Jl~j.1.1 ~ ~

; -
~~ _;ot ~Ll.A c.:,k. u,lb)U) t-'""'-' Jlhj c.:,k. conspicuous consumption
.(Burke, 2009 :~I
:0--ffol-.~~-- - ~----...........~·""'°"·-·-:"··----"""·-=~----~~,6""1--...=··=-:.i1-_,..._t
l,i.j~ AW~ '=?~1 Lo_,~~ ,~u :u~' '=79 .:i~IJ 4.4,.1~1 , •A
JUl~.;I
rs::::,--.·~ . zv:z:z::.:::2 --=-.·;._ . ~ .. :-:~!,.=L:! -.:- .. -, ..- --::::-lo . -=~·-:~~~:!-....-<·.·.....Jt~"!r"~G-- -··:;,:....;.;...;..:"='1[::-;?:=-·-··.,:-.-·.·~· . =···:t.«-:-.x~·-\~;...;'::,;, ~:,~-:::.:·.:a!·.ll:iL;.J
~ ..
u ~ i!J.l>.i \s ,u<,; <i'1'-' <<..)-:!AL.!J.I ;;L:?,.,, ~ ~ 4]6.. JLib'l'I ~..H
(Chaplin and John, 2007)w~JLJ:415vu.J..) ·IJ"":'>UlulQ.!Q'o;_,aJ~l~IJ-&ll
ul-'""'"" ~W LJ::I ~.J~ i CJl..>3 ~.JJI ~l_;ll_, JLib~I lS...u ul.JJI rl~IJ ~..)UI
0~~1_,.JJ uoa:t..LArl~I ~...u ~.JJI JLib~l ui ,~_,_, ~ ; ; ~ ~w_,
..H.J.4i ~...u ~.JJI JL.....ib ~I ~ ~ ul.J-A~IJ JUI_, ul.J~ 4k ~
c.:.c,j\SJ .~l:.,JI ul.b~I_, ul:!IJ-&llJ ~~.J..&.::,~IJ ;;>'-")U 4k ~ ~l_,.JJ yk
~l:JI u--'-" LJ::I LA JLib ~I LJ::I ~ ul.:ill ~ I~..i.a=JI_, 4:..)U I ~ L:s)WI
0i uJ~ JLib~t 0i (Schor, 2004) .)~ ~~ ~ .;;~ ~l->-11 ~_, ; ; ~
.~~~I ~l<A ..)~J ~ 0-4 ~ u\5.JUI_, IJ"":')UI
~ \.t "
1~01 UJ'.!bi«u.:~.JJI ~~'l'I~ rl:!.il t1.lAvuWI 0-4 ;;...1:!lj.:&.4 ..)l...u:.t ~LlA
C,
u\5.JLA ~ b i ~ <.i'11 ;;.illJ.I ~~ ;;~ ~bJ-'-" JJ--'-" ~l.l,4) • ~~ i ~ts_,

~L..u~_, Guess ~ J Nike ~w_, Louis Vuitton wfo.J-9 (..)-'U_,.J ~ o . ) ~
~ .(Phillips, 2005) Parada bl.J4J Rolex ~J.JJ Annani ~LA)_, Versace
~~I ~~I J~ ..~I~ -~ _;;_µ 4.4J~ ;;.illJ,I u\5.)UI t1.lA- J..,~J t~l
~1~J~l 0-40i vuWI 0-4~ ~,~_,.(Nunes andMulani,2008)
.JUI ~. u
. -.4.. t~~
A. • .. t~lt ~ ~~ L.1u L - -: ~ti ;;.illJ,I ~L.:o..JI
.)~ - • .) u---'~ ~ •
:~~t~t.J,A
;;.)-'-U~I ~ J;....ul 0 ~ LA ~_,.I.I i:,i (George, 1997) t.J~ ~ ~ 41~
w.r.!bi, ,2 ~~1 )l.;...)~ r...La: t.lA_, .Jfoi uk~ 0~~.JJ_, ,t_lyilk:~_,..,
u)l .!< ,~·iJIJ ulA)WI_, t_lj,~I ul~ uLA..,.,;JI_, ul.:_.::uJ.I ~ J ~ I ct.J>l> 0--4
a.L_.,b.ll ~ I uk.Lu. uLJo..&.t.l_, wm...u.1 rJ;.; "'.! ul:?-~I ~ ~ .~JZll
~tu! 4.!.!;;; <.;)! ..)~ l.lA_, -~4 rl_µJ~I ~ u l ~ ~ 11~.,.JI ~I~,~
~ ~ <.;)! D.)J~ ~..)J:! l.lA_,~i uTh~ J_,.bi uk.L.u 0 ~ ~.JJI ~~
.(Landers, Rebitzer, and Taylor, 1996) <1~ ~i 0J..) ~l_j41 J4-uJ411
u. "9-c..it aw~t ~.J.JJ ~ t
.)~ ~ ~ ..W .cc<)l~I ~l-"4» l)A y.-ull JUj)'IJ ~ I u::--JJ.J ~l:

u~~ 0 ~ ~ JUj)'IJ ~ I ~IJJ ~ 0 ~ ~.,.t.l 0t (Schor, 1991)
-r~4 I~~ u ~ I uA ..lJ_j-4 ~ J ~ I ~i uA ~ J ;;J~ J_,.bi
.Rick Warren 0./, i.!L-> . , , ~ I ~ ~ ~L&.::JI ~ I J ul.:UI ~ "

:~4 4:J\lt uS...,l
~ ~ u")/L:... ~ ~~~JO.O~~I ul.;~ ~ j i ~ •••
_,jj:iu.!l~")/4~ ~ . d i ~ ~ ; ; ~ ~ l+i,S'.JJ~~lu")/~
~_)jj ~ 4:!.lUl~j:i di~ ui;._, .ol~I ~~I U~j ~_,j ~ a-,pUI
~ I ~.pUI wl..,..j'tll .;~ ~ ,Jl:JI ~ w,k .ci_,JI di~~~ .l.;1_,J.I ~
ulkLlJ.11 ~ ci_,JI di~ r l ~ I ~~-'-!JUI~ ..u_j..o ~ J.,bl uL:.L....J
.(Richins and Dawson, 1992, p. 307) a.:s.:sy.ll
~~ ~JWJ L"=4-o (Richins and Dawson, 1992) 0-"""JbJ ~...J .;_,.b .J.dl
;;JL..uJI ~~I~ ~l~~IJ ,~l~~I ~..>-4 ~J~Ll.c. a:i)l:i c..:,,k.
-
~JJ j>.J.U ~..>-4 ~~ ~WI u4,..;...ul ~ ·r~ J ~ ~l~~IJ
-
~~ a.bl;J.I a.!,o;. ,~,11 u\l>WI ~ Jgi_,~lll 0--4~1 c..:,,k.~i~~
u~_,kJI uA Jgi ..)~ ~ ~LA...G~IJ <.>-'-?~I c..:,,k. Jgt_, rs ,11.;·,j ~ ;;~ JUj)'I
Jgt l~lS' ~ (~fi.11 I.J.A ~ ab.! "'! u ~ 1-!l~ a.t_,b) ab , ,:11 ~.,.b:JI
~WI ~~I uly..-JI J ~ 4:Jlll ~LlJ ~ a.tJi 1-!l~J ,~l;p.. ~ ~.J
. (Belkand Pollay, 1985)
..lJ_j.11 ~ ~~I ~ I wi (Whybrow, 2005) Jl~IJ ~ ~ ~~

;;..1:!l..>=J.la.....b~4Js 1~1i11,l~J .;;..)~1.,a ,:,o1l~~ul~t:iw
: ~ i ~ I ) J~I ~t:g.J0-4~f-' ~Jlll ~l.>=JI o..)w_jui~l~~I
'-:r-"~ J.;Ji ~ .(Csikszentmihalyi, 1999; Diener and Seligman, 2004
r~..>-4~1 ~ ~ 0.w.--lJ: ~Jlll ~~~I 0i ~ ~ d.:j.; (Sirgy, 1998)
..):-'-"\S' ~ j j ~ -~Jlll ~ ~~~4 a:i.;L4A ~l:?, ~~ ~ J#i ~~.)
0i ~l ,;;JL.......uJI_, ~Jlll ~ ~)l.11 ~ I Ct.b)U ~l..>-4 ~ (Kasser, 2002)
k:V;,..•~,;.,C:r"ICl'·-=~··:-1-~~""·"'-·~.~.. v r : : ' l • ~ e 1• .-...L ......' l . ~ , C : ~ • · < r , ~ ~ - , , , . ~ ~ - ~ r ~ , . , " ~ ~ . x ~ . . , . ' l l W " : l l
~~A.Wt~ 1$.:.Lll Lo..91!1~ tj\l : u ~ t ~ Jlw..al~ ~~I \\•

JUl~Jl
~";:;x,·-i·:··-~---:·..y._..,.,""·---?f-.;e.;.~:r~~a-~~-~~~~~;13.~
1~ : ~.. ~~"'v,.r;:0~~~~;.z~~s::::ri";.;~£..m:-:-.-,?:i~~-~:a
u,uWI 0-4 i_# ~ ~ i 4.-iSJJ ~ o.ll.LuJI ~1 J~_,31 ~ f1 ~IPJI ~ ~ I

.(Easterbrook, 2004; Frank, 1999) ~~i l ~ i ~i ~->11 ~ o..)b Jgi
~ ~.,11 ~ ~ '-9J-'-" .4:!.llA.U ~~f'I ~l~I ~ ~L..lA ~J

o..)1=.)~1 ~WI 4:!.lUI ~~I l?.ljJ ,l.:U -~.llo~~w-4~..u lAD..)~~i
tl..1:tf'I J ~ ~ ~i ~ . ; ~ ' i i o..)l.DJ .;lA.lJ"il:, l,fl ~ w ~~, r4)
i:9.; ~1 L..9l.b.tl 4:!~ ~ l?..).H w ~t ~bjl ~ J oJ:~ ~~ ~LL...>·u
. ~ ".i_, J..ii ~ ~.?-i .;J.AiJ ~I~~
iJWt ~
· 4-i!)&I_
· 1.S .:.Ut L4
~» ~1>1,1 ~..1>.l ~ Sophie Tucker .;5jj ~~ ~~I ~IJ ~ I cJll
0i ~->11 c.;,k. ~.., .11~~1 ~ ~ I ~ i l: ~jl.J.J.a .o~ ~.., a.:;<- ~
.~'·'=··- <.9.)
- Li.JI U·i ~11 ~1.'.:.:.tt.Ja:, ·~"i 1_JJ·'"<.
..r-- • ~ '-4Ao..)b J-'-
C
-~···"~·~~~I
.:r'": u U~ -
~LlA.J~t~J.AJUl0! -~~~JWly ,11aiJl~4JI~~

JUI~ ~~~l.;J.A~I~~ ~ J .(FumhamandArgyle, 1998)
: (Diener et al., 1999)
0 ~ l?.:UI w,o~ ~I 0-4 o..)b psi ~ I 014,11 ~ 0 ~ 0:!.:UI ~~ ~I -

.o~I 014,11 ~
~UI ~_;-a.JI .)~I ~ L~I 0Lu..JI ~ ~_,JI ~IPJI ~ o..)l:j.11 ~~ f1 -

.o..)l.A.uJI ~ o..)~4
JUI~ ~l..>=JJ ..)J~ '=:T.'~1.>:Pb ~ll.4> 01~1 l?'-b ~~)b;.. 'ii J ~ ~ J -
P).o.llt..iJIJ
.o.llt..iJI ~ o.ll:!) ~1 y ,o~I ~IPJI o..)1=.) l?..)~ "i o..)~ -
~ a:,.)~ o..)~ Jgi ~ JUI_, ~l..>=JI ~ ~4,- ¥.; ~..u 0:!.:UI w,o~~I -
~Jo..)~ ~WI ~~I LJ::1 Jot+i.;I ~~, l.:U .oJP _,i JLA ~..u ~
.;;j_;:JL:, al~ l,fl ~ L..9Ll~i w,k.J,#~IJ l?j:, ~ ~ ~ I J ~ I ~
~~·~'
f 1;.· ..· 'i""'"'~,,i;>.;~~-*e ··~:.fr?.+&--·WY.,1-~'~·-··~n§h+«~·,;·-~ w?~!~'v'ifN-P~A!if.'..~,..." . . .;.,:hafit",)4·,,;=p-'f~>~Joe~·-.@·=·$<f'.rvw·:+w~t=v:n:t1=·!R.~/·4H"r:1:i:Pi··.- ~-·fo.,P...:-:@A,r,qi:.i·:-:z,,pLtt,%~ 'fWiitvfr%W~-@N4AAVL . .et
11 1 1 1
.o~ ~~ ~u, J=--..ul ~ ~~ ~ :~I -

.c.!l.l.o ~ l ~ Wb ~\1A :d_j.)'-41.I -
tJ~I ~J) c.S~~I ~~~I J~ JUI 0A ...u_j.4 ~~LA~ :J...jl~l -

illWI ~J ,JUI ..HJ;. o~~ ~ .J~~ ~'1A . 4.i-4 ~ ~t (a.....r;Wl..9
.~1.., e:.'.~,.., ~ts~~,..,
..HJ;. c.S.»l ~~t ~~~I ~..u ~ J U I ~ ~ LA~ :JUJI -
~UI J,j>-..ul y~l c.SJ.l ;;~l...,_Jl..9 J>..ul 6::t ~ ~ly ~'1A uf ~J .JUI
. ~L)~~..9llf:llu.?.~~1~~~1~,~~~L,~JUI~ .a ,;.,,;.:...1.t.\
o~t...,_J\ ~ ~ ~Jll J>..ul u ~ uf ~ a.b~I ILll:i ~1.JJ ~.;JI ;;~1

f""j-J-"t c4 ~ts~ 0A ~~.;JI~ ~~~I~,~~ 0A ~~ ·vc~>Ll
a.!"";. .~. ~ i~ 0~~1 ~ .~..ul..9 ul:!l.,,s.Jl..9 uLAJ.>JI 0AJ ~\l~t..,
<.),J...>-4~ b~f ~ c,S.JJI ~_,JI~ Wb L)J-4 rsci:o ~l,;.,_j,~I ~ ,~~I
0A o~~~j ~.)~..UIJ LJ:.:!...Ll~I ul ~ ~_,JI ~LZJI ~Li.A.., . ~ b

- - -
.~lk:?Jl..9 0u~1.., ~yill 0A o~L...upsi ~~J.AJ ~...r4~1
L~ ~ f"".J~l ~ i co;. ,~. no c4 u)4U.O (Izzo, 2005) ~i c.Sr?-i
.J~» 0A ~i ~ ~~?JI "...uY. ~ vuWI u~ ~ 0A ~1 o.JLli?JI ~J ~Th
~411 ~ji ·~JA ~ ~ uJ~J: <?I ~~~I~ ~L ~ «~~I ~ I
~J ~~I o4>JI u ~ ~ J 4..9i ~I~ a.owl ~LUI IJA ~ ~~ ~1
~ ' .)~» 0A "-4>-L..iJI ~ W I ~ f1 ~J . ~ I J>b 0A <iit:; o~~I wi
~~~I~~~ y ~ ..9l Ls:i.Jl:J ~ ~I ~LA~I ~ y~ o~l.>9 c.,,11 ,,~~I
r.J.,aj ~;;~~I).>-'-" f ~ '~ ~ ,i.!lJj
- -
0A ~~ .u_,J.I ~~~~I
.«,".:i.;..i ul ~ t ~.JJI LA» ~ J cc,c.\..o.igl wl ~ t ~.JJI LA»~ ~ I
J~ «~_,JI ~till.~ "~i LA Y'J ,~_,JI 0A ...u_j.A _;.elji 0~ uJ~J J-'-U~ i.S~
"~i LA Y'J JU~ a:,.Ju.o ~t9..,JI ..,t ;;~t...,_JI ~ ~ r~?JI ~~t ~ i
o~..9.J.:t:.A ~.JIJA JUl..9 ~_,JI . (Kasser and Sheldon, 2009) «~~LIi _Hbll>l.:'
~I~ ~_}o u~4 ...141 • l.A.J..1.A ..9i \..&,AIJ;.i ,ul ..9l ~ Jol.,i:,,JI ~
~y.l ul:,Jl.ull..9 ulk~I ~~.)~~.,JI ~.?.J 0A ~~ :c.)b.ll ~ I <.)c.
~ I u ~ 0A ~t I.J.......A..9- . (Lyubomirsky, Sheldon, and S~hkade, 2005)
·"'tlll,~~~~~.---~~.c,.-~-~._...-~~~.-3'..
~~ ~ ~ t$.:ill LoJ ..:,~ lj\l. : u ~ I ~ ~l.w.4llj 4.4.J~I
~~
\\Y
Jllt ~.)1
Pi?Hfof:•;;z;.Z&M$W@+@kW~ftt:=·frR>\Y·:"·.•wr::.\~r:'"~-v+t¥§BAf~--&s=-:~;g.1w+1x .§tb·.-)2 ··-'.LYM+~-£- -~.@@lidhSYA#·="6%4--~~-.wf.,K-.~-1'f·~~. .,:;..\····y@#t=·M?3 vffiAlh¥i'-=~ "§
9
LAS' •(Kasser, 2002) ~..u.1 ~ 1 ~ r~?/1J a.!,o;.~1 c.::Jl:i)W1J ':? ,o;. .~,JI
~ 1 <JAJ (Csikszcentmihalyi, 1999) YJ~1 ~l..~I LJA ~_,JI.)~~
.o.)\.....uJI ~ ~ ~ ~ JA1~ ~J (Brown and Ryan, 2003) ~lll
j:!:ibllJ ~_,JI 0::t U)WI (Kasser and Sheldon, 2009) <JJ~J J-""'\S' JJL.i:i
'~J~I a..ulJ..u1 ~ .c.::JL....u,IJ.l i!J~ ~ ~..J--*"~1 s:.~.;JIJ ~_,JI ~laAJ ~.)UI
..La.I
.~ ''=WIJ ~~.:..t.:..f1 ~~. •L L~~,1 ~.•1
'J-. ~
'"b J)l;. <
~ .)-!:J
· )·A~ ~
-. .(,f (.)· •
.J......:i,..41
•J
~w,
,~Gll a..u1J..ul ~J .J;....ul a..b.--..,I-'=' ~l.;9 ~ ~lJIJ ~.)U1 JAWI j:!:ib 4>-1J1
. "«.:JI~- · .:.~tL. .) ..ecool1.~r..ul ~ t ... ..hJ3 .. ~tu.JI. ~~"«.:JI.· .:.~ti · l · ~WI .J......:i,..
'-T -~~ ~ ~(.)(.) . .J
..La.I (l...\>.I I :. ·
'"bl1.
.)-!:J '-T"«.:JI ... :.~ti
~ .)-!:J
r.t:; 4>-1 ·
.),
I •
·~ti
J ~ ~J- c..9.).. WI c-:= -~ ) ~~
; 1., L .... ·t1
c.::J4-,W1 t~lJ ~lll ~ 1 0 l 0 ~4JI, ;, .~;i<I ,,.,;_;.;.i L...ulJ.l ~J .~.)u1
J'~.. -- ., ~ 'Ill .4..i.4)U,.
.. 'J-J ti ~ . ,~, .)-!:J'"ti ~
. U)WI.'-T
-~ (J)LI·
.. ~
Jo........u!j-U
....
JUI LJA ~_j.A c.:,k J ~ 4 LlJlaA o.l~I ~;;~~_,JI <)A ..u_j...o ~
. ~ I i.::i4-,~~I ~ ~ l..lAJ .(Kasser and Sheldon, 2009)
i ~ t ~ 1.4A" ols:J J:ii ~~, ~~, ~ ..(i

~J-'-" ~ wiJ o.)bp <JA) ~ 4Lo c.::Jbl~l ~..u 0-4-4 - u ~ t. rt\
J;...) c.::J~ &Ji.ill~~ ~I~~.)~~~ '--9..1,8:1 (~_;-oi .)~J.) u.Ji
JU10::t U)WI J:...\.4i ~ 0_,..J~ ~~~I wi <J~4JI ~J .a..wj-AJ a .;,,;;....LA
~ 4UI i.::ibl..>:)14 o.l~I U)W Jgi ~ t <:>~~I ~ j LJ:>- ~ o.l~IJ
<:>y~ '-9J-'-" 4WI 4UI c.::Jbl..>:?JI y~l <:>L:t r~ IJ~ ...1.4l .c.::J~I ~
~~~I ,.,;..u ~\..a..a.j L.!ll..lA .a..b..-~I ~bl..>:?JI y~L:, ~.;laA o.)~p:?JI y ~ i ~ ~ ~J .o.)~ Jgi
~~i ~b~ l19J~'"~Ji ~ ~ ~ & J ~JJsi ~IJ.;c.::Jl~~&J~..u
~J-A~ J,J...)o ~ .)~I .;!~I JUI c.:,k J ~ I ~ ¥ . ; J I ~ ~ .,.,;_;.;.i
... ;;L>,.~ t ... ~b <t
~ - ~ .. e,r
i ~ Li""""'~t '-::~ ~ ~.J o~l.a.&Jt JWt '-::~ .\l
y_,J~ L.ua..u.j.A 0,-o ~ ~ wLl~ ~ (Diener, 2009) ~ . l rLi
~J .i..1.y H"1' 0---4 ,r"\, · ·· ~~1.l~~~Gallups:-1.J~I~~
~ o.l~I w,-o Jlc i..S~ ~1 IJ.JL..c:ui ~WI ~UI wblY-?JI y ~ i 0i ~4JI
- -
. J ~ Ji~ ~~I w~~ .l_?.JJ ~..ul 0::t al~ i.!lLlAI v"='1 ~J ~~
·r_j: JS' ~~?JI ~LlJ.1.)~?1 Ji rl~~4
u.::,~t ":'Lt.u.:iSt ~ ~i t~! o~l.a.&Jt JWt,. ~~ .\l
0~ L>:!...L....a:ul_;JI 0,-o , o t a...__1.J.l <,? (Howell and Hill, 2009) ~J JJ..J-A fi~
~ Les~ .wl~I ~ c(gLi,jl o.lb Ji~ o.ll....uJ ~.lJ: ~ s:.~~I ~ JUI JLi,jl
J i ~ a+-J o.JALlJ. yl.A.JJI ~.lJ: (~_j-11 ,rl£hl1 '1..>JUI) ~L.ut w4,.b. a.::'i
· ~ Y . ~ wl~ L)j-1.._µ\J alc,\.:u s:-1~ ~.)~~i o.lb~l ~~ Ji r ~
o.llc wl~I ~ .~~ L)j-l_µtJI alc,\.:u ~,~ ~ ~>°'11 D.l~I ~ ) b j
W.J~Y. ~J-'2Al.A J~ LaS°J .a :·a> w~~ t...l..a:iJ (<r"~~I ~lfa!I) <J--J....>->~I
Casablanca l£,)4j\S' ~~Lauren Bacall J.,S-4 0--J-.J.,.U Humphrey Bogart
.o.ll....uJI 0,-o i~ ~.lUI ~~~I~~ .«Wl.l w~ o.l.?..¥' ~-.J4»
~->-4~1 ;;~I wl:~_,11 <,? L>:!~1.;JI 0,-o, r, · · · 0,-o~~ ~ J ~ <,?J
~.lb o.ll:.} ~~ ~ 1-""'~ ~.llcs ~~ ~1~ ~~ ~_;J ~~I JI~~
.)~~I ~ 0i ~~I ~i->--5~ .(Van Boven and Gilovich, 2003)
Jd).J~~ly.)~~ ,~u .~.lu1.)~~10,-o~lo.l~4~~i
0~ .)1.:u, . ~cs:.~1 ~ J ~ ' ) LPu, i.!1~~4 ~.)'-4.4 ~i D.l~ c~~,
- C. - ... "' -
wl.;.: ,111i\t~~~ly.)~I :~JI .w~~~lw,-o.l~~!~.?.J~Y.

~ ~J<..PUli.!l~~I~~~ .l.JA,ll ~~ l.b~.)l~it.;AJ~~?JI
- - - - -
Y.J~I wl:~ ~ 0-J....>->~I as'.)~ .l~I t.:bi '"- ,~l:i .a.:,o;. ,~.JI ~I~
-
,~\j .~.lUI w~4 - ~.)~ ~ ~...L>JI ~ a.:\ cccA '-8,j~J ~~ ~
~~I -41~ '-:-).)~I ~ ,~I.) - .~~~I w~~I a.::\i ~'-:-).)~I~
e:4 y .J~I dl:i ~ ~~_;-o .J_,Jo:i:i ~ ~.)~ ~ ~i '-'""Llll J.o~ .j~?JIJ
0i ~1 ~ '-8,jl W' a.::I ,1111 ww.JWI e:4 ~.)Lui Y.J~I 0l ~ .~_,JI .)J.>A
(Nicolao, Irwin, and Goodman, 2009; Solnick and ~ i ~~I~ L> Q ,;.,;;
. Hemenway, 1998; Van Boven, 2005)

r:..WV-"J'--~~~. -..---~-·......-=~_,......,:-i::,,111.-··.~--0. ~~~.=--...=--.;-··. . .
~~·-·.,cc1.··.. 1p-._);?T ..~i.:.:..~ ....... . > - - . ~ ~
lfj~ 4.La9 ~ Ii~' LAj o..L>,j faU : u ~ 1 ~ .:a~!J 4.4.J~I \ \t

JUl~.Jt
G!,;,"§:"'~.~~~;..S:.,.;;..-; .•-!;."5~:t:~tU::!...Y••b~~~(; ..;,:.£·:1:h.i&;.;.i~:;j;~~~~s21.;.::L.!t~~:,Z·:~~!3~~~;.A.~~~x;:..~i~Z::_.1~~£:~-1~:..iJl.i.?.,,..~'.::~;...~~~.;~1}
s~ LA~~;~~tJWtf~
-u)J l.!.L.i-> «L_; ~~ ui .J-A ~.:u1 ~ ~~ ~1_;-i11 ui ~ i '}]»
.Rick Warren (Sydney Morning Herald, July 4, 2006)
Warren Buffett~~ u)JJ Paul Allen ~i J~J Bill Gates~ J...-:!:'

~...u lA~i l~ui~>4Jly~io-4~J~'}!J.A~ ~-~I~
.. ,, .. - ts
~ I~ u'i I...L...:?-- ~l:P'il 0--A.?-I b~ I~.) ~I~~ .L.1AJ ,JI.JAi 0--A
03.Jj,J i.J:WiJ ub .JL-:ui ,~~ ~1 ~~! . (Nichols, 2010) d.J~ ~l-"4i
<.)! (Norton and Dunn, 2008) ubJ 03.Jj,J (Dunn, Aknin and Norton, 2008)
-ti
c-- ."-1-,,<~l~i
\-0- .. .) ~ ~ .. \-er"
_A,O..)~IJLJJ ~ ~'}JI 1..9-Ll:,l~'--4-0
.. • • .. ..
O.l~I ~ ~jl)J '=:T.'~1~t:;"-10,Jy•.'511 ~ JUI JLl:,l ui <.)1 u~4JI ~ '}]_j.A
-~ ..)~~ID~ ~~J .J..41 .o..)b o-4 cul~ ..l:,.. ~ JUI JLl:,l ~ ~ a:,.JL.a..o
o.l~I ~ ~jil ~ly l.!Jl..iA ulS' ,w,-1}ii L.ul.)...ul ~ . o ~ ~ ~ l . ) . l l!J)\.:; o-4
~I~ ~-'¥1 ~...u cul~ ~ J U I ~ ~ a:,.JL.a..o 0-1...»- ~I~ JLl:>?JIJ
..l:.-
f.!.!;;! 0.,.LoWI ~~1J J4-->11 rll ,a_;,l:"JI Luil.)...ul ~J .~1 ~ ~ 1

~rsbb;,J~l>4-4~~~~~~~~Jj;g~.l~~jl.......u.A
,(g Li:, ..I u-4
· -
'}] .J.J. (.>J...»-
• • '}] I ~ - .. Jo.b ~ ...u 0:
' ,.. JU I 1..9.. Li:,'}] · .:U I uJ-l~
· :.. · - ·'I .) Ll. i •,(g Li:,..I
~ ,a::Jl:"JI L..ul.J...ul ~J .o..)~I o-4 ~ i ~~ ~ <.)! (S .,,,;·,i ~
~I.J'}]J.l ~ ~ ~~ J;g ~.ll.a....-.u . . : J ~ ~ ~~ ~ ufi.J~I
ts ts -
~ Ji ~ i ~ JUI JLi:Jh, ~.J'-?-1 ~ .igJ ~ i I.J'}]J.l 0-1~ Ji ~.J-Ai
~~~I fi~ '~.?°i o..>-4 -~.lb ~jl.......u.A <,)} ljil.# r~l 4:!l-s:, ~J 'LJ-1.J>-~1
Jo~.)'}]lo-4~~\.611 u i ~ .~io.lb~~LJ-1.j>-~1 ~JUI l~i ~.:UI
ui (Norton and Dunn, 2008) ubJ u--J.Jj, r ~ I , ~ J ~ I ~J .4:!.lU4
·0->-»-~1 ~...uJ ~...u ~ ' rJ.>11 o.ll:}J ~~~ ~ ~ u~J-1.11.!..1) ,~.;_
.,
~~->-14 J..-+u.U ~ ~~ ~_;; l~LiJ ~ ~_;; LA 4
1.!.1.,_JJ \,; '~" "~->=""" JJLu • (Carvr, and Baird, 1998; Kasser et al., 2004)
U>.l.J~ ~I y~~I ~t:; ~J.A (Strivastava, Locke, and Bartol, 2001) JJJ.J4J
-L..ula..a..A
..
- . , r - . ).t-.J..41.~I~~
'•- ':.~LJI~'}]~ ~ .. ,-----.. ..- '"'JUI ~
~~ t ... J···--tt
~~ ~~I
~lill~I
~;.;;.._c,;;·.·..'·... .: ,.,.,, . . ,.·.··.>.:•·••· .. ··....,,.,,·,.,.· ·. ··,·•,··.,.<''.''>'.""'.'.""",·,.,··.·,,,.::··,,·.,. :. ·. ·,,. ·.. ··.:.,,,.· .. ,,:·.,:.,··-.·.:···.',•'' :... ,. ' ,:: .. ,,.,.:....... ·,· .. •··.•·ca.;··.'.:•.,,,·,,. ;.;·"'······ ..~·:c:7·.· ... , ,,,·.·:·:J
:~ ~IJ.l ;;~ ljg.# ~JUI~ J ~ I ~l.;J 0-4 w,o~~I ~IJ.l --':~

a.!:I; ~ o.;..1.4ll , ~ I ,tJ>-'111 c..lJ '.?"Li:JI ,~~I ~ I ,;;.J-'""~1 ~.l ,0-4~1
.ul.:.UI ~~I~ ~ I J ,~~~I uw.;Ul.1,~..i..w::JI ,~4,JI u~.;-11
ui u~4.JI ~J cJ:t..Jl:_.::JI .lljjllJ ~....>:J.l.lJ ~ I 0-4 ~~ I 48.!; ,ul.;.l ~J
ill WI u~.; ~ i.S? tL-91..a~ a:,.;l.4.A JLJJ .;,#l i.;~ Iu~ t.S.:.UI w,o~ ~I
\LU~J ,~1.:.UI ~l,g.;JI 0-4 ~ ,.sjl-A .;l&,lo'j ~ _;oi l~\S' F j.4C. ~bi .,t - -
<):.:.UI .ll_;,S~I ..b.d ~ i ~ . ~ I ~.JJIJ (gender) t~I ul~b a.:,..IJ1 ~
~~ ~I uw.;Ul.lS' ,~ ~ - I ~l.;J ~ ~IJ.l ~..u ~lS'J -l.;~I JLJJ 1_,k.i
<):.:.UI w,o~~I Loi .~l,g.;Jl 0-4 i ,;.,,;;....&.4 ,.s~ ,ul.:.UI ~~I~ ~ I J
,.s~ ~..u u~ ,~ ~.J-'""i ~~ ,~~1 Y~~ Jui~ J ~ u~
~l.;.l~ ~l,g.;JI ~JJJ ~.lUI ~I ~~l..>=JI J:pji ~~-~~.;JI 0-4~i
. (Kasser and Ahuvia, 2002; Vansteenkiste et al., 2006) J~ ~I y)Lbl
,~ti_,,A~t
t.!bi11,·, LA ~ i ~J ~~'~I ..H):. 0-4J uJ>9 l-LA ~I.; ..l.4l F'
clL4jAl..:Jl~Flu-4~J -~'~'..P.'"LJ-4JD1~0-4~l_jA>ctw
l.iA. ~ I 0-4J . ~ I J ~ IJ ;;.J-'""~IJ .l_;-.a.JI ,.sjl-A ~J o.l.J.L&A u ~ ~
~Lal_, ~..i..a:u, ul--L4ll .l~, ~ ~11.u ~1.;J 0-4 L..9J+ll u~ ~j&.11 ~ i - -
~ ~ ~)U ~~I u ~ l 0-4 ~~i.;-11 ~ . J .J.41 -~~l.;-11 .l~I _.,t
unbridled capitalism ~4,JI ~~i.;-1.J ,~_, .~WI ~6:,jj ~\S' ~ u-"Llll 0-4
• • L:,,. ~ I · . -" a.uL..u ~ tu
""- ~ " T -· ~
'~~~~~~, ~~t
~.?Li:JI ~~I U L , ~ l.>-'° ~ I ~ ~ l J .ll->--9~1 ~
.(Segal, 1999) ab.!'"-'JI ;;~I ~L.u~ r,1~~4 conspicuous consumption
c..l_,ll ~ J ~ ;;~ ~ f-8-A ~ LA c.:,.h J-.:!.5~1 I~~
~ ~j--:iJ I~~ ~ I ~~~I~ JJ ,o > J I ~ ~
- - - C
;;~~i., ~u~~, 1..§~ .(Kasser and Kanner, 2003; Needleman, 1991)

~ .(Izzo, 2005) ul-.u_j~ ~4,>JI y.;4-:L}I ~L..::..J..>-.llJ ~_,..:LllJ
.lj~ ~_j-ll u~ ~~..,_u ~,,;. j ccrl ~l..>-4 ~1 ..ll~~I [ ~
. (de Graaf, 2003; Honore, 2004; Needleman, 1998)
... __ ~~- ~-.-.~~-=-~-=-~~!c"-,~!•,..,...•~~-~~-al..,..._...,,r.--~
Lfj~ 41aS ~ c,i.:.Lll Lo.9 ~.bJ ljU : u ~ I ~ JL.w..al!_, 4.4.J~I , ,i
:::: I 1 1
< ~ r- 1· C fr: r- ~ -P 1 (,. c· C ~ <r- ~ ;..... -Cl)
,',::;
.; -
t i.[ r;.' ~ ~· J; 'ti ~ ~'. r;.• I ~ ~ !:: ~ l'J c..
r l. .
IA f:. 1>1 1/\ ·~ - t::S
~ ,. !:: - p C- r:- : I : i> - • C• ~· N 1.·l
c-· . (• ce.. y
f it • I 1, l/\ce.,. O"
r. J 1. ·t
C• N ·.
.r;- • fl_ r;.• ~- ·<j.. <::. tf1 1.° f:: [ h O J
o i1
tC:
r=
i~ ~f. t~ .~ ..
IA t fi
!:: ~ f
t. 1 ~. (1 l'- "'
~
.t~' t..· r
1p;J Cf.l .,:::..
'-' t),it·J·
''I - I l)(,'f I I
,J-~
; 0§' t- { j
l- ,· r- l r- c, - .t [ c: - i;l fi
p
'lE ~~ ,t:~ ~fr: 1"' r- .. ~ ~ ~· , r;.' ~.
f E .,. - re
1
~ l.'k
~ ,. rJ
cf.. •L C" -i 1· le C· r !f r ~·. ~'
~ - (j
J> \.D \.D \.D
.F ~ 't, C·
E: C·~.. .
h [,(;i ~.
,b. t:.. ·~ C· (;! S-
~• 'Lr= s.t::P
l,
C,
-
•, r:- 1
C· ·r
t')
·
i
'
• • r
,-. ti '&\
r 1s1·
'
.c-" [, .rt r>
. (•
~
r:n
~t ~
f. C\ I r;.• F
-
~ Ci_ fJ
t-' ~ v ~..
~ l 't
·[.I ~ ~ ~I
'I r;. p
~i -:- . ,f t 11·L
~ ~ l (;i I !::
~
lr : -
1l . Y' N c... i
:l I !:. '<i. ...:
:e ..;- ~ .. . P !: ~ ,.i ..... i L 1 c, ~ ~ §
1
t, t. r I
t:1
L1
1 fi
1
·rf t~
Ci·
~~ ]~ ~'t, r; ·L~ t~
l,
~
• ~
l,'
i
..
..
t
I
[ 't.. 1>1 •
~
rf. (~. ~ ~i-. {t ~-. [ ~ !:~ !, { fr ,e-~, ~it
uc:.
-
C·
I°)
-
~
N ,...,. I
-
r
~ I
• _,.
'
(r ~ ,f-'
I, i;"' L. b !;.' C.. ~'
~
I~\. I
1
l,
l- •• ,L. ,L
t ,' 1
• •
'b ~ [, p<e.. ~, ~ • r:r~ ~S • l;r • l- - •t. 0 c; ~ ~E n t1M
~~
- i '-D
i~' - ~f { c_ L • N
r· 1(;: \o · L.•
;-· ft [•
1
.. ~
~...~ ~.• ~~ i
• ~ .. ~
~E.~ ' ~ . 1
~- f f ~. 'l .['"" ~r ~ ocl~ t;.t
~ ~. ~ ~ "' ft: 1:.:.
~ 1,· ~
f-1 '° ~ ~ .. 0 N -
- C. C ij
t ~}, ~
1:1
ti f· ~ :1; r ~! .t.. ~ ~ t ·~rf: .~
t IL - - C·
r: t _,. t,- ·~ t \ 1 ·~~. lc.. 1~.- -c:t, !E'~ ~.fr cf §fl' j ·<j..·~ ·"·t: B
ii1
~ r= _:_ (:'f C. i l> ID•
C·
,t "1 ~ • ~t ~
l,"
'~ f f txj .r: l- _:, r.
b j L. G' '(.
• ~
t 1... - ~ .~ £' ' J
~ 1' 1C. ~ ~" l,t t ~.~ l.~
I, I . ~ ' ,._ ~ ~ r;- · ~ ~ ,. i ; [• .~
[ i
,c ~ ~ [ ,Z: 1:. <.':. ~ C· - ·
- C•
~ ~· 0 b !V - -
1 i1C '~
1: l f'.E'· ~.~ ~ 1· ~1- tf.i Df f"' ~ t- [•, - -
t (;.1- a,
·t ~e..E ~m
<o, - t.
•· 1--~ ·~ I
r C· "ti.! •
r·t ·~r·· i t ·Lr= 1= \'~ ~ :t~ ~.c.. r·· rit r ~f:. t. ~~- .~~ i-~· ~ . i- ~•t
- i , - I
3~ tI r.I - ;E , _,. Y' - "° - . 1 , - ,C-' ~
~Ull~I
r._~-.:;.·:--.fu:·S .·:_:._-.,<~- .._=· . .:-~,~-.-..;_~·0-~- · c'I .--i~z:r:.:._·~-~ .. -:~~~:._.1LJ::.>··_...·' '--"· .._. _.::;.rz_:-~~-:--.·•···.. ·,.-:.·.·· . -.·~
:~~~,~~,
~~I~ .ili ~I~ ~ I Y:,4JI ~ w)! ~~I[~ ·t l~I~
..,1~~1 ~_,~'ii ..,fi.;JI ~ i .(Jackson, 2009) .,~'ii I.J.A> ~ ~l_,b;JI ~

,~i ~ Jjl.UI ~~ ~ ~ ,<1~U1JLij?/10-4 J:lZJI» w,k ~LJ:ill.lJ ~)ljW1J
~LJ:ill.lJ ~)ljWIJ _,1~~1 J-¥- U~ . '-8:i4J ~ J l..41.Jt.........ut ~lb.t.l ,·cc;.,.;,_,
.(~ r:roi,11 ~ I i.S~ w,k ~1~1 w~ ,~1 w,k o ~ ..,~1
w,k.J ..)~I ~~0-4 ~'i uS'J ' ~ ~ ~ , ~ ~ ~ 0 i « · , . ~~ Ill
~ I w~ f'~'i4~~ _,~1 J~wi ,- ...~~·crJ ,...\>.IJ~J~J~~I ~lS'

.~LJ:ul.l ~ ..,~IJ 4..4-J~ a.!'".!~.;JI y\.+u,~I ..\>.LS'~
,~}..ttu~~
. ~ I I.J.A> ..,1.u-1 ~t 0-4 ~?. k.., York University l.!l.JJ: (U.44,. Ci.A..,:g (,)
,_....n.:;,a.~ .. , , . . . . _ , ~ ... , v ~ ...-..-~,,,....,....,,u-·...,;,or~..r,.~t,~•·~- ..~ U - « ' ~ ' - - ...- ~ . -,u1:~...:,._,..,,....., ~l.ll.o::;.~~.,,.-..:,i,....-~·...-~~w...o - " \ ~ : ,
~~ ~ ~ ($.'..L!I l.oJ !!I~ fall : u ~ I ~ JL-.i.tlj 4-4.J~t , '"

JUl~.Jt
!~;,f;,;fi':;._.,Z;r~:S.W.Hlf.2'.ifa~r;:~:;'.K@!E,""illit'?f,~~{!*.~;'™:~w~w~Z§.:iWZlli:~2,:'lr,,);.;S'{(:£,ii~?fr~'i't£;'\1fi:T;r'~~l
,~...,.:t.rtu~~
w,k ~I~~ J.4-it: ~ <->~ ~J-4 ¥' «steroid» ...u~ .)~ (i)
- fl!
o.ll:J ~1 ~.lJ: ~ u~?l' ~ ab..........ul~ ~ F c.i'1' u\.j-'"4._r&JI [tu!

4-41~1_, .~L..u.ll4 cG.)~J4-,..>1J~i~F-¥'J .a.:Qc11,:--JI a.:;:JI ~
J...u:. ~L;.. ~ , ~ "~t; '.c., CII! o~I ul:'}J_,11 ~ w~L4.U WJ.....J~
ul~ ~ ul.)~I ~l~i~ ..i9J ,a.L_,.b o~J o.J-tfi u ~ 4-4\._1;.; cul
(lhttp://steroidshq.net~I ul.A.,.WI 0A ...u_j..l) .4-41~1 ~.., 0A
Jl-'"4i ~->-'-"~Earl Jones~~ j.J~! ~~, a.lb.. i:.,i ~ o.)~4 .l~I (y)
..!:J~ ~.JJI_, Bernard Madoff 1..9J.:ilA .:i.)w~ ~->-4~1 ~ 0A 0-J..J Q~; cull
~ I I.:u, ~ "-l.c. ~..L:>J I ~ 1.-9J-'-"J y l:iS:.J I 0A JJ ~ I ~ I ~ c...1J_µ I "-l.c.
• ~ '}I c.5y,,-i J~J
~,_;g ~ ~ i:.,L.o~I .)J~ rl:g ~->-4i ~ Johnny Depp '-:-':.:i ~~ (u)
.«Pirates of the Caribbean)) ~_.)~I
-~1 ··· d.JA~IJ ~l:.J~I ~~a ,o,o;.~ '->"fi°JLA w~ as'~ Neiman Marcus(~)
~l~?J o).l?JI '-6,A~ uLl~ ~ retention bonuses ~~'}JI uLllS:.1.1 ([)
. ~ , ~ ~~4 ~.,rt
\J.A .l~IJ ~->-4~1 l.!l.)J-J~ ~..\..Q t.)1.,.._:u ~ i ...\>.i Broadway ~IJ.:i.>:' (d
.l.!l
.)J,J~
.
- [ \:u'}/1
c.:r~~, ~ -
a.u..\..Q
t-'""l:JI 0.)-o-11 ~ ~->-4~1 ~IJ.J,11 w.i 0A HorationAlger ~ i ~I.)~ (t)

t ~ J ~I r..:r-,-cr.-
L .. - ".,;~ 4-ui.o ·
- - ~ ..!:J~ ~ ~t\ JLl.b~I.~ ~,_,....4' u..Jb., - :.1 • :.
- -~ ~
.aw:,Li.JI ""-)l.;..~IJ.:iWI
. ~- -
'--'L ~ I ~ I
--
~ . ) ~ 0A ~\:JI~ u..UJ ~->-4i ~ Britney Spears~~.>:' (.l)
c...1J_µ, '-fl J.>.lo:i ..l9.., wl:.J-i__,l ~'}I.., ~ u ~.., '=': c 11.: c 11.: 4 ~'}I.., ~ r, Oi.AA rlc.
.a.Lib ~\S' i:.,i .J.i4 ~la.JI ui~ ~i ~ \J.A
.o.:il......JI u.:ilj JUI .:ilj WS' cGi yt, <:r.~?JI Jo~.)'}14 .:i~I (j)
j.AWI 0::i ~>WI ~PJ:c.Jl:i j.Alc. .l~J~l «mediate)) <1~jAJ»o.)4c.J.:c~,; (.))
t~l»J 11~.J.ll ~I» cJ\:JI JAWI ~ ,J~I l.:U, ~J ·t:il:JI_, ~ I
~I ~>WI~ o~~ ~ UJ..;-b:, PJ: _,i ~ ~ «~_iL:» ~ «u4-,WI
.«~~.>-11» ~i t:il:JI JAWI_, <<~_,ll ~b» ~i ~ I JAWI 0::t ~_;;
~Wt~t
~~IS~t
.. .. ul.&S AL. tta 4 ..110> ;}.,t ,-
.. ,.,,..,..'.j . l ..... tt uW~.~
•t.~1",~. ~ ~ .~~tt
Thomas H. Stone~.~ ""w.Jl a~•~!
I. M. JawabarJIA!f~ .,,. •T
Jennifer L. Kisamore~ . J ~
~~4~~1~,~~~,()AJ ·r~?l'~~LS'~1~,~J-J..;~~Ll.~
~l:iJ Enron w~u Adelphia l:!..i.bl Jlitl ~ ~ c.!11.lA ~ ~LS'~I ~l~J
Parmalat ~~LA.;4J Northern Rock c.!1.J.J ~.;_,-jJ WorldCom rLS'.l.;JJ Tyco
a.b~I ~ ~ o--':?~ o->-"llo ~ ~LS'~I ~'~ wl •Halliburtion wji~lAJ
c.!11.lA ui 4:!.l~I ~,.! ;.!'! cceJI <, •oii., <>4 ~w~ ~
C =~
~ . l . ) ~ L,.o~ c.,:tll
--
o~I ~LS'~I ct..w,G., ,~LS'~I ~.;I ~I o ~ I ~l~I <>4 -L>&' l.l~
~ JJ~ ~~I a<!
Ml ~ ~.JA c.!JL...lAJ • (Clinard and Yeager, 2006)
.http://corporatecrimereporter.com :J,AJ ~LS'~I ~I~ .;l.......!u:,I ~.J.AJ a...ll<:iJ
":a y4,-i LA :Jlitl ~ ~ ~J ,~~j~I <>4 i..)..u-:. ~lS'~I ~I~~
~.J.A ~ ~~I >9lji cJA ~>11 ~ '>l,s~l Ji ~ .l>JI ~ '-¥J '2~1~1
~ ~,J ~4~1 ~~ ~ d_jf ~1,~.,z.o ~L.u~ ~,~,J
L~ ~)lj cJA ~i
J:.bull r ' ~ 4 Lt.;J ~ " ~ 0~1 ~ ~1~1 ~ t ..J.:,..iJ .J_;Lui:tlt 1:a
.(Kish-Gephart et al., 2010) w.1»TJ~l).a~~~ ~4,U meta-analysis ~ I
~~~I) ~ ) b ~I yjl~IJ ( apples rLi:tll) 4:!.l.J-411 ~~I ~b a.......,,t.;..ul cJJl.u
:~ LA 0.,..;Jj.ll ~ I .isJ .(barrels J.!.c,l~I) ~~I ~~J (cases
. .U)l:i-~I . ~, L;.ll a.JL::. 4:,.. .) ~ b j .
~ - ~ ~ - 'r. ,.Lwj,JI
- .
C.:,---0 - .'.) •
Al!..~ •••
~
~L::. Jl ~~.) b.: JAW t.P.--Y4 ~1.;~1 0 ~ ~ ~ "i ,tjf ill]~
Q
~IS'.)~,~ O.l....w.A JAi~ ~,.)~11.Lllj ~ PJ:i ,ill]~ &4 ~~ -~k.. <>'~

~)l;.~I ~ I ~ J ~ I .)~Io.Pb~~ c-lJ J~ ~ ~
.(Kish-Gephart et al., 2010, p.17) a.:1.:loiitl 41 ~bi..J
~~~t tii ,«~w1 rLi:tll» 0t <),J_,.;..TJ ~ ~,..>~ ~,

J:.bull ~ i
c,;a~~I ~.,>£11 ~~ ~..u ~~~ J--':? ~a.!,o;. Ml a,.1,otl ~.l~0:!.:UI
~ I jS..>-4J Machiavellianism ~l,:aj~I ~~ tl..i:i)J ,(Kohlberg, 1969)
\Y\
l:l_,.;.ll ~~~~I~ (Rotter, 1966) P)extemal locus of control ~.)WI
~L;wl;> ~ I t~J~I ..9l «u'l'L>JI» ~ ~ ~ J -~~~I ~ ul#_,1.....-Jl..9
j.#~ ~ I ..)~~I 0-4 ~.J ~ ~ b a.bf a.......u1.JJJI u~..9 ul.Jl~I
~)t.;. ~I
..i:~~J .(Jones, 1991) _j.j..?. Ui.l.JJi ~ I six moral intensity dimensions
~~~I~ l:1_,.;JI ..hi_;J c.ftll ~)Wl ~..?. aJ'l'..) ul~ a.!:' , , a:s~ ..LJUA c:,lS
a..a.J~I ~J.A ..9i y~l..9 .>:Pt:JI u'l'~l..9 ~ I j.#y ~ ~ I ~.J~I ..)~~4
'~.J~I JAl~I " ~ 0-4..9 .(a.fi_,1.....-JI ~WI) ~~'l'I ~l..9 ~I~
~~~1->:Pt:JI w~I.LJ~¥~i r~ JJ>-~~'l'I ~ I c:,f ~ j
a.!Q.!J;,;;JI a~.!:JI u ~ u~l 1.§.:UI ~_,JI ~J -¥~~I ~ l:l_,.A.110-4 J.......>JI
~~.. ~ti ~...I u
~.>-J~ ·i ~
· .. I.,Ll~~I
. ~
· ul.6'·'-··'1
.. ~~~~ :. .. « •• ··,, ~... u• i
ul#_,1.....-JI ~1.§.:UI J~'l'I ~..9~\0-4~ '.!,;; ,scll~4:,At_g.J~
ul.JL:>JI ~ \~>:PD.AP ..LJ~ ~JJ.A ~_;g,,~..9 aJ~l~..9 Ll~I
~b:, ~..D r~I ~ J .(Kish-Gephart et al., 2010,p. 21) <<~~~\~
(McCabe, Butterfield, ~~~I~ ..LJ~ ~L«.,, u ~ ~ I ~ I
. and Trevino, 1996; Trevino, 1986; Trevino and Youngblood, 1990)
J-:!:o J:,~.JI ~ J ~J.A c1~ wJ»-iJ ul.J~ ~ ~'l' ,1.!L..J~ ~1 a__g~l
~.)la.A ..LJ_,1.....-JI ~ ~jgi ~ antecedents ..LJ_,1.....-JI ~ c.ftll JAl~I w---4
~~ ~Li.A c1 =:=f iJI " ~ ~lS ~ J .(Kish-Gephart et al., 2010) ~l_,.A.14
¥>l> ~I ul.Jl~I ~~ ~ _ ) [~~ ~ c.ftll ~~I [~WI <...a..JLlt:J
LLJ~I Rest's model of ethical decision-making (Rest, 1986)
L~J
Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) (Ajzen, 1991) cJ-t?.~ w ,b b;....11
wJ»-iJ ul.)~ ~ ~i J~t ...LJ~I ~ l:l_,.A.11 c:,i ~1 u.)L«:ui ~l..9
~ <,ethical impulse perspective ~>L> ~I t~'l'I . J ~ ' ' 0-4 ~ ~1
~~I L~i» ~~~\~~!~..Li ci'1'J (Reynold, 2006) ..u.,_i.J..) ~
llil~ ~~~I t~J~I ~ ~~ [~~ rlJ;.; cc,4 «reflexive judgments
.(Kish-Gephart et al., 2010: 22) <1ut.g~I ~
~~Wl~..9 ~)l;..~I~ u~_,1.....-JI <JA.# ¥~1.§.:UI ~_,JI~

~ ul~ ~."'41.§f ~ J ~ ~ J ~ JIJ.-.u ~ , J ~ ~I J.....a.>- ~
~)l;.. ~I~ u~_,l.uJl..9 ~ I .)~I ~l ~ o_# aJ..)i L!lllA..9 , u ~ ~ I
l';;"--.-·-~;A"'.;.--~.....-..
..,...u,.,::.._~.,r:,..---.-.--=-tt-~~·-~~._._~.._._....--.........,T-~~--~=~~~._.at.-~__,.-~-·-
~~ ~ ~ ~~, Lo..9 o..b,j faU : u ~ I ~ ~~!.9 4.4.J~I 'H
(Joesphson Institute of Ethics, 2010; Williams, 2011) ~\:JI o,uJI..L...1.1 ~
,- ~ i .Lb...>,ll ".LA~ ui~ .J.....l uLl~I "LA 0i ~ I 0---0J -
4-..Al_j..LJI ~~IJ ~)l;..~I ~ ~_,LuJI .l~J ~ o ~ Lbi ~L....i.A
~JA~I o ~ I u~'}]_,JI ~ uWA4'JIJ u ~ I ~ ~.llS~I
~ J ,(Davis et al., 1992; McCabe and Trevino, 1993, 1997; Whitley, 1998)
,(Christensen-Hughes and McCabe, 2006; Genereux and McLeod, 1995) 1..1.AS'
o~I ~ I ~ J ,{Brimble and Stevenson-Clarke, 2005) l:.Jl~l ~ J
,(Newstead, Franklyn-Stokes, and Armstead, 1996; Magnus et al., 2002)
(Crimes, 2004, Koljatic, Silva, and Ardiles, 2003; '5~i o~~ 01~ ~J
o-4 ~ J ~ I ~ ~I uw~I ~ ,I.LU~ <.)1 ~~1 .Magnus et al., 2002)
ul:g.;-uJIJ ~I~ 0i l..1.AS'_, o~I ul:!~_,JI ~ Lu.J...LA 1, ~ ~lb ,A,···
uw~I "~~ .(McCabe,2005) 1..1.AS' ~ 1.V·_, ~JAi 1.v, ~l ~ ~ I
y>LbJI o,uJ~_J - ~ ~ I ~J o-k J~~I o.Jbl rt-41..>:' ~ ~ I J ~ I ~ j
~\_).:A.A .l...W o.l~ ~I~~ ~.llS~I ~~ o-4 ;;~ ul~ ~ ~ I
~ 4i·o~ ,-. ".!J l:,WI u~IJ...ul rt-41..>:' 0l ~.J>. Lu.lJ.l u ~ i ~J - ~
~ ~IJ.l ~ F' ,Jl:J.I ~ o-k -~.llS~I ol_j..LJI uW~ ~ ($_p-~I
0ts°J y>lbll ~ ~j.A (5...U ~.llS~I uWWI .ll:!.lJI l:1-JI uL.ul.J...ul y)lb o-4 or,,
uL.u~ ~l:d.l i~i (5_p-i o..>-4 ~ J~ ~I J~ ~ l:,WI u~IJ...ul y)\..b
. (McCabe, Butterfield and Trevino, 2006) ~.llS~I ol_j..LJI
~ c4 ~.llS~I uL.....1ll:d.l Lu.JlAA Jo~.)I <.)1 6~1 ~ UJ~j I.LU~

(Harding et al., ~ I J~ ~ ~)l;..~I ~ ul#.,LuJI y~)J ~b u---o
2004; McCabe, Trevino and Butterfield, 1996; Nonis and Swift, 2001;
uL.ul.J...ul "~ r~ f1 ~J .Sims, 1993; Trevifio,Weaver, and Reynolds)
b
J . <r - . Ll)l;..~I . i a..u ·w, ~. ul.o-'
~ J -~
- t\ WJ I •. ~ -
- ~ 0-U - ~ ~~
l4A
~~J ~~'}14 al~ ul~ ~J>L4 6 ~ J u ~ u---o ~ '}] ~J ~ I
~ ~I ~IJ...ul LAi .counterproductive work behavior (CWB) ~ I ~ I
- ~ -
:~I) ~.llS~I uW~I o,u~ I~ ~J>L4 ~UA r...,;.; cc,is ~ l,&l J..>.b:tll
~UA r..J.?:i '"; l.!.LI~J (McCabe, 2005; McCabe and Trevino, 1993, 1997
.(Spector et al., 2006) ~ I - ~ I ~ I ~.,-Li V " ~ i~ ~JJ-L4
1-. ·:. i:;..) ( .' ··~·.•:,:·,•.',;'"( .,·.,...;.;.,,.;:::.-;_·1/)~-:;.·).:i'=r::.•: .•· .\1.~~,..'("·fr··.{'':'.~ d, . ,=...•...=y;.. ,·,1·;•·;::·.. ~ '··=~ ·:./-:):;·.: 1.)-,'.,''.· .'"'.J:/( ,,, ...,_..• ,,., •:·-··\( .' ··:·,.,. ·,"./""· ... ~- ... ::• .. -~.,1· , 1.. 1·-&:,:1. ,··1')!, ·, .• : "/(( ·.. : ... ;=: '1.~f ·:&"i',{l)'.-!,•'"·r''" ··Lr.. •''"(.,:,.,-::."(., .. '····I
.>-!):. ~ I ul:_6'~ I J ~ ~LWJ a .!QI.JI ~~I ~..191.,,_.;.jAJ - -

u\ Q.! ccsoi a=i)\:i 0-4 0..1>-IJ Lg:,~ U.l.)Jt ~ ~~Lo.JI ~ J a....;s~~I 4'?'".,.,_
'="Q.!J;,iiJI ~l_,J.14.!l..,.l-uJ rL,.11 ~bt w Q,;,i; ~ J ~_,JI ~l.l}LJ a.....otc.
~ I ~ I 4.!l.,.L,J organizational citizenship behavior (OCB)
wA ~_,JI ~b~I 0t ~ j ~ • (Rotundo and Sackett, 2002; Sackett, 2002)
-
LAl -~4::lJ ~ ~ I.,. ? . ~ I.J:!~~t 4#.,.L,JIJ.llJo..)~ 4#.,.L,JIJ..)t 0-4
- -
~ Jo Li>J I» ~ ~ <?JI ~lk LlajJ ulo_,J. I 4.!l.,.L, ~ '-:11 Q.! t:, ii JI ~ 1_,J. I 4.!l..,.l-u
~ .(Organ, 1997: 91)«a.4,fll ~1..)t~--1:! ~ojj.a:iJ~IJc.r-~'llJ~I
ulJ ~ ul~~ ?JIJ ~l~I ~ e,jslfo.J a.! Q.!J;, ii JI ~1..1.A~I ~--':! LA ulk~I o~
'i'Q.!J;,iiJI ~l.,.llr~~lu~JJt~~"-:'\ ,~,i;~.:is" .~UA~~~JdulS'
(Borman and Motowidlo, 1997) _,l.llJjiJAJ ulAJ~ wu.J-Li r:::--4 (Organ, 1997)
~ u l ~ <J:A~I )tS' 0~ ~~J performance contextual ~~I ~l.l}U
0t i..S.>J ·a......-,IJ.J.ll o.JA ~..l.A ~ J -~_,ll ~ o,o~?}IJ ~l.:UI u'l~I
~ ' 4.!l.,.L, 0A ,,.;~ ~' 0-4J . '="'""L.ut ~ w\.g.ll..~ <J:A~ ' ~~ ~w,
~.:UI ~I~~~ c.r-#14.£.J~I 0-4«~1 J~~~l~'ll»Jl ~ I
. ~ I Jl ~~t Jl a Qt:,;tl ~Lg.J ..)~~~I a.!Q.!J;,;iJI ..>=!WI"' 6;;.!
yl:i}IJ U~I ~ ul:_6'µ1 o~ ~ • (Robinson and Bennett, 1995:556)
~~IJ production of deviance ~1~'11 [Lljl ~ J aL_,Jo u l ~
~ ~ I J ~ ~ ~1~'11 ~ 'lJ ~l~I ~~J '-:11 ,o;. Ml ~l~'tllJ
~ uW\..;J.I ill.b ~ ~ J •(Miles et al., 2002; Spector et al., 2006) ~j
~L.u~I L,:iwfi-4J ~Lg.J ~,>tJJ a.!Q.!t:, iill .J-:!:!WI u ~ I u~ ~ ~J..1>-

.(Gruys and Sackett, 2003; Robinson and Bennett, 1995) ~
~.J.ll ul:_6'..,.l-uJ 4#~1 uW\..;J.I ~~ ,o)lc.l ~ 7=..JI A>:1 ~ ~ J

ulA)lc. 4.£.JUA 0~ .i9J ~..)\S'~I u~I ~ pro-social behaviors c.r-~ '11
~ t.)4?}1 ~L.u ,Jlil.l ~ ~ .~I~~ ~ 4+.>~ u\.g~ 4#..,.L-u
a.!Q.!\,iJI ~ I ~IJ:, ~ JoLi>JI ~~...»-Ty~~ 0-4 ~ I uLl~
'="Q.!J;,iiJI ~l_,J.14.!l~ "-='~~~I l~J (McCabe and Trevino, 1993)
~ ~IJ ~.)~I uW\..;J.I ..l.-Li ,15~ ~I ~WI 0-4J .~I u ~ ~
~ I ~J-CJ.J - d..t.4~1 uLu'-:!-u, ~ -l.lJ-L4,0-4 lS..,.l-u ~ I U~IJ ~- I -
J:tl.b:i~~k~JL~I~ -~1 ~ I 4.!l.,.L,4:·\?~ ,l.:U .a.!Q.!\,;JI
~~\S-Jt ul:!,S_,J....J!J C,.:, o;.,,,.:JI rl~\.:i J4&}1 uUl~ ~ I
ma::::z:::::1~·'t y~ · ,:+ .-,·. ·~t-·1-·-".·=·:,·.t.~·,XOM fa· .....·,·&n·= 0 ·.•.t?.1;f:'!fs1}·-v·1. ·
1-·· . .,;:.·....,..---:-,... ==;,~·,,._. . 4 . {f-J.-J-K1"··i22···rm::::I~~~~~
ul ~1 CJ.;L:ui ~~4J ,~I ~ ~ c.!l~I ~ ~.l~~, a~.!:11 ~ c.!l~I

..H):. ~ I CJl$~ U.J-'-".J~ L-9.J-'-" CJ~I ~ ~ I U.J-'-"J~ ~jjl ul ~J~I <JA
Harding et al., 2004; McCabe, Trevino and J Jul.I~~ ~I)~~ ~I
Butterfield, 1996; Nonis and Swift, 2001; Sim, 1993; Trevino, Weaver, and
. (Reynolds, 2006
JA~~~Ja.!,o;....!Jlt~-'"°1!:J~l<JA~JtlJdgJJlz:ljjJl~.,JI~
c.!l~J u 1.!lo iiJI d.llol.,.tl c.!l~ ~ u=a1 JAl~IJ CJ~4k:s"11J CJl.A4,.j'l'~ 15..»-t
- -
~~~,~I I~~ ~"1 ~l.>-4 F'-" <i'111!:J~I ~J , ~ I ~ I
.. -
behavior samples ~_,.LJI CJ~I y_,l-.ut r.Jh:i ICI; c.;JI 1!:J~I <JA ~ .l~
a.!· o;.~I ~l4A ~ . ~ I ~ I c.!l~ J ':' 1.!lo ;;ti d.llol.,.t I c.!l~ J.t.c:ill
~ ~ JAl~I <JA .l~ ~~J a.!,o;.....c!JI CJl~j.o ~ a..l:Loi CJIJ.J.411 ~l4AJ
(.;r ~
-
'1 · t!.. ~.,• ~ •a...o
- ~
•I ···ti CJl.l.a.JI
-
I,.. aJ:Lo j lJd ~ j c.!J • I · ·· t\ L,...
c.:r- - -- J ~ U:-. ui ~ I~ --
- 1
~ ':?"1.!lo ii JI d.llol.,.tl c.!l_,l-.u ~ JUA cGi ~~~~I Ji! &4 ~I~ ~?JI
~ I c.!l~ ~ ~i ~ ~ I ~ I c.!l~ U)WI CJI~ ~ I ~1 ~ ~
- ti
~ CJ~IJ a.!· o;....!JI <JA )ts' r ~ ,~l.;...ul "~ ~ . ~.l~~I CJ~I ~

• . I. .. tI L - 'I c.!l . I. .. q • t;., ii JI d.llo I• q c.!l . I. .. . I - . ~ - ·~ ~ L:; I L.i..6' . J~
'r----' u-- ~ J '=?" - ~ ~ ~ CJ-1 • ~ - - I.:
J.? 1!:J~I ~1.)-4:' r ' ~ '~Jl ·':'"'ttll ~ I u--k ~ , ,~ f'I.! ICI;;; ~

~~ ~ J.:p'_;tl4 counterproductive work behavior ~ I ~ I c.!l_,l-.u
ti -
~.l~I ulj.iJI ~~ ~'.>-4:'r~ ,~l:i .antecedents c1;;: '"; u=a1 JAl~I

ti -
r~ ,~l:i .~.l~~I CJLiJ\h:..JJ ~L.u JAl.,.s' a.!,o~I JAi~ ~ CJjS.; <i'11

~ I , ~ I ~J 4.:·o;. .~.JI JAi~ u~ oA~ ~ ~ I ~l»JI "~ ~-1-!
a~.!:11 J ~ ~ u,L.ill c.!l_,l-.uJ ~1 ~ ~?JI CJl$_,l-.uJ ~1 ~ Jd4'11J ~-»-
_;-;..i J ~ ~ ~ I ~ I c.!l~ ~ D ~ CJl~J-4 ti
ufi:i L-9~ ~.l~I
.clb \..Lil~~ CJ..r?" a.__1.;.l u.w::tJJJ~L-9~ ,~IJ .~I ~J~~J
y a...11biJIJ '-:~
.e · t!.. ~,, J6:.J.I . -~ a..-1 ...ul ~b:J t,.. 4..a:i · ~tt l:i~I. ~~Llj L-9
. I.: J ('tJ c.:r- . '..r"' .) v- ~ ~
J ·l
.d.: -- ti c:.,.-.It
- I :01111 ' I ..-,ti · -·
. . ; ; J ~ CJL:iJ,,.~,I ~ f'...L.oJJ
*v~r,; c:c.rt 4.lbt.,..tt ~~., ~ t J..att ~~ ~ as~t

ul "11,~t ~1 uJ_,l-.u ~ u ~ ~ t 1~ ~ ->=P>'11 ui ~.;JI~
ul_,l...u ~ a.!:' '" ~~ uu ~.?. a..t'l'.l CJI~ U)W ,.. , """i 1!:J~IJ CJ~I
\YO
Bennett and J Jl:&11 ~~~I) (.;rq.!t;, iill ~1.,11 ~..,.L..u,J ~ I ~ I
Stamper, 2001; Dalal, 2005; Miles et-al., 2002; Sackett and DeVore, 2001;
~_,JI~ .(Sackett et al., 2006; Salgado, 2002; and Spector and Fox, 2002
~~ ~UA ui ~l ,0:4~10::U 0:! ~ U)lc. lA~ c.:.>L.u\J..ul c.:.>~i ':?.:.UI
- - 1$
(Bennett and a.......,~ U)lc. ~ ~JIJ ~ c.:.>Lc.ulJ..ul i.!ll:i ~ U)WI o~ ~

Stamper, 2001; Berry, Ones and Sackett, 2007; Sackett and DeVore, 2001)
. (Dalal, 2005; Kellaway et al., 2002; Sackett et al., 2006) a :..!. ,¢ ~)lc.J
~ J~b LIJ.) 4-;> Cc.All ':?.:.JI meta-analysis ~ I J:k::J4J ,Jl:&11 ~ ~
sample-size- ~I~ ~l..>=J ~.,rll ~.,:J.I ui ~J LIJ.) ,A~~ t\
~ I ~ I ~..,.L..u, u-4 ~ c4 ¥1~4 ~ ~ ..b~) J~ weighted mean
. ·, rr- ) ~ '='q.!t;,;;JI ~1.,.i.1 ~~J
i4:r~~i ..Jt~t_,..tt~jl.M,J~tJ..att~µ ~~JAlaS4jta~t

~yq.!t;,;;Jl~l_,J.1~.,bJ~l~l~.,b~<i'11JAl_~J;-b:JI~~
(Berry, .Ones, and Sackett, 2007; Cohen-Charash u-i~ I0::Uc.JJLA3 c.:.> ~IJ.)
'5..»-i c.:.>~I.J.)~i.!.UjS' andSpector,2001; Colquittetal.,2001; Dalal,2005)
~ y q.!t;, ;;JI ~1.,.i.1 ~.,b c.JJLA3 <i'1' c.:.>Lc.ulJ..ul ~ .0..1>- ~ ~ ~ ~
LIJ.)J (LePine, Erez, and Johnson, 2002) u~.?.J j..,~lJ 0:4:1 LI.J.) ~
(Organ and Ryan 1995)u~Ju4-JJiLIJ.)J(Meyeretal., 2002)u-i...»-iJ>:4J
~ I ~I~_,b ~ ~ ci'1' c.:.>~I.J..u\ 0-4J . (Riketta, 2002) Li:_.S:~ L\J.)J
a......u\.J.)J (Barrick and Mount, 1991) ~JlAJ ~..;4 a......u,1_;.) ~~ ~ 0..1>- ~
u~J.J a......utJ.)J (Mount, Hies, and Johnson, 2006) u~.?.J ~u
~JLA
. (Salgado, 2002) J.)4J~LI.J.)J (Robinson and Greenberg, 1998) [J-t-W~J
U)lc. <r'.,.u ui (Dalal, 2005) J~b a......u,1.).) ~ ':?.:.UI ~ I J:.6:::JI ~ i J.....lJ
y-q.!t;,;;tl ~1.,.i.1 ~~ ci)lc. o~~~~~c--40~1 ~ ~~
~ ~ . J .(r= • ,,1-)~1~,~~ci~o~~J(r= • ,,t)
d.,j.J\..a.o (r = ·, t,) ~ I ~I~~~~ u~ meta-analysis ~ I
~'b..11 ~bj ~lS' ..llJ .(r = • , , ·-) ~ ~, Y q.!t;,;;JI ~1.,.i., ~~ ci~
y-q.!t;,;;JI ~1.,11 ~~ ~ ~ ~~1 ~i ~..,JI~ c,6..~J Jsin ':r-4c:'?/I
.(Dalal,2005,p.1248) ~ I ~I~~~~ ~ J
~-Qc - ~ -s:::;--~~·~----=:s:a-.J.~~~~-
~~ A.1aS ~ c.i.:.L?I Lo..9 i:,..L:,,,J fall : u ~ l '?9 ~L.w.4ltg 4.J~I
rt~~
;,_..~~\S\tl ul:S~!J i1.;co;....!JI J,4.all ul.iiJ~~I
c:a::::..:~=._..-_~"".'"w.;z::::::r.:..:rz:~--rii:'.7W.-wn;?"'----- rw,.g~~~.::r:wI:l:~:tJml:J
~l_,J.11.!l~ J~i ~JLlJJ uLuil.)..ul dti ,-,;: '" ~ u ~ l.!l~J

(Cohen- ->Ji§: 11:j ~->Ll,J ~fi a........u.1->J ~J 4a., ,cc; ~I j.Al_,..Jl..9 '="Q.!J;,;;JI
,(Colquitt et al., 2001) <>'Y""TJ ~fi a........u.1->JJ Charash and Spector, 2001)
J-t:A a..u.1->JJ (LePine, Erez, and Johnson, 2002) 0~.?.J .J-l...H!J ~~ a..u.l.)JJ
(Organ and Ryan, 1995) ~1->JJ 04-->Ji a........u.1->JJ (Meyer et al., 2002) <>'Y""TJ
~~ "-8:1~ ~tu~! uLuil.)...ul D.J.A ~ j i .(Riketta, 2002) ~I.) a........u.l.)JJ
r · IJJ~ (Borman et al., 2001) 0.1)-->-i..9 0LAJ.J,! wi .('1' • • o ,Dalal) J'}!IJ
'QS1.!1 ...~ (Organ and Ryan, 1995) 0L..s-JJ 04->Ji r~ 0i .L..iA c.:....,~i a........u.1->J
. a.! , o;. MI JA l.,_c_, '="' 4 .! Jo ii JI ~ 1.,.t.1 l.!l~ LJ.::1 Jo.J->3 ~ 1~>W.l '="' • ~ 1
&,~.)'}II u>l-oW. ~.?. ~ ~~1 a...J'}!J ulj ~)k. 0.,_b..LtJI ~J ~
'="' Q.!J;, iitl a..tlol.,.t.l l.!l_,k, ~)k. ~ ~I uncorrected correlation coefficients
~_,Jl..9 (r = ·, '1'A) <>'Y""~I ~ ubl-:JI ~ ~I ".!·o;. ,~,JI ~Ll.A 0-4 J~
~ I ~b.Jl..9 (PA; r = ·, \A) ':r-~t'I ~tJl..9 (r = ·, '1"1') 0_,..JIJ (r = ·,rt)
0~~ ~ J~IJ ~_,JI 0i ~_;JI~ .(r = ·, \') J~IJ (NA; r = ·, \ t)
&,~)~Big Five Personality Factors ~ I a.!,o;. ,~.JI..>-"°~ 0-4 ~
.J~I ~ 0_,..JI ~~)J ~WI u'-?JI ~ <>'Y""~I ~ ubl-:JI
..>-"°~ ~J ~ I ~11.!l~ ".:·o:,....!J\ ~)W 0~.;JI 0~1.;.ll ~
JAl_,..JI ~ i 0-4 ...LLi J~IJ ~WI u'-?Jl..9 ~_,JI 0i ~1 a ICIQ;JI ".1·0;. ,~,JI
Barrick and Mount, :Jt'J.I ~~~I) .~1~11.!l~ i:ii;~I
1991; Berry, Ones, and Sackett, 2007; Cullen and Sackett, 2003; Ones,
JJ4JL.u ~J ~ .(Viswesvaran, and Schmidt, 1993, 2003; Salgado, 2002
..>-"°l.W4 ~ I l,&l)l;.. 0-4 ~ ~I j.Al_,..JI ~ i JA ~_,JI 0i (Salgado, 2002)
'-""'~ JAJ ~ I ~11.!l~ composite measure ~.;.ll '-""'~ Ll~I
JS'~J ,~l4.JI ~l..:i 9-~J ~~I uW~_, U~~ u\.#~ ~
ulS:b.cJ.4 ~ I JW!J ,&,~'}II
~~ ..ll..9 ,a.I..9j..uJ.I ~ u~~I 0-4 4.!J.lj ~J
·, n- (mean corrected correlation) ~~·oiJI &,~->'}II j.AhA Jo-,_,:A.A a~
~_,J~ a cc,~I a.!,o;. ,:.,JI..>-"°~~ JJ-':' rl...1;.i ,114J .(Salgado, 2002)
- 'II'
Reliability Scale ~I~ L.u~ ~JAJ ~JA .)_,lo ,J~IJ ~WI u'-?JIJ
Hogan Personality Inventory (HPI) ".!«o;. ,:.,u ~~I ~JA '-""'~ JJ-':' 0--4
'II' -
ol__µJI ->~4 41~ ~ ~~I <>"~I I.J.A i :ii2 .(Hogan and Hogan, 1989)
9"~J U~~ ul:S'~ ~ ~IJ ((a.!«l.!J;, iill u~l~'}il» ~ integrity test
~ . ~ I ~I~~~~ ..s~i uW~J w~IJ ~u...JI '=""°l.:i
.a cu1;.Jla.!«O;. c~eJl~~<J-"~[~w~a.!10;. c~slfc;~,~~(..)-"~
J ~ t.b.u~ 0t u ~ J 0b~~Jj.jJ ~J ,4Alj.tll V"":!:!~ ~ LIJ.l ~.,
~ ' ~ ' ~_,J-,J a.! Io.:.. ,~,It c;~,
~~ O"':!~ ~ u4',J..UI Lt'-:' ¥1.J..,~,
I~ 01 J~'l ~~., .(Ones, Viswesvaran, and Schmidt, 1993) ·, t.o ~
~~ ~ 0 ~ Joi~ .J.Li a.! Io.;.u."JI Joi~ 0 i u-11 L~~ (j&a.e.&lt ~ ' J~I
· ~ ' ~ ' ~~J '='4.!t;.. ;;JI ~1.,11
1uW~~ ~~LS~t~t;..at
wl ~1 ·~.llS~I c\.......Alj.tll J ~ ~ I uL,,IJ..ul o~J <.>A ~.;JI~
a....__1J.l ~ .l~~4 ~.l~I ul-AJWI t~JA ~ ~ \.s.i,A ~ ~
~lcA 0 i uL,,IJ..ul <.>A .l.JL ~Ji~ .uLilu.J.I "~ J:,L,, Jo~ a.!«o;. ,~,ti
~.l~I u~I ~ ~ I ~~J locus of control ~ I FJA ~ a.....l)l.c.
.(Houston, 1983; Karabenick and Srul, 1978; Forsyth, Poe, and McMillan, 1985)
~s'.!'>~ ~ (Kish-Gephart et al., 2010) wJ..>->'iJ u l ) ~ ~ ~ J ~
o J ~ uL,,IJ.l ~W ~ .l~~4 ~~~I .J-t):. ~..,L«.aJI V"":!:!Lil 'ii ·~::--JI
Machiavellianism ~~~I uµj.l. uL.ulJ.l U-'-" ~J ~ I FJA c.:JJLA:i
~ ~ I uL.ulJ..ill • , , 't'J ~~I uL,,IJ..ill • , , r ~ ulb~J ~I ~~ 0 l
- ~
0 l:i.........ulJ.lu~I ~ .~.l\5~14Alj.tll ~f1 ~~I c.illi~l0l~.;JI

~.l~I c\.......Alj.tl4 ~ a « ,q;JI a.:,o;. .~,JI~~ U""~ ~ cfo~I ~
,(Stone, Kisamore, and Jawahar, 2008; Stone, Jawahar and Kisamore, 2010)
wi JlAl.?.JJJ-4 cufJ wS,,---,-u ~J J~~, y)lb (>A 4Jlb nv ~ ~ ~
~ ' ~I~~~ HPIReliability a.:10.:.. MJ ~~I ~ ~ U " " ~ a..._;il..L&AA
• , ,A JI~ ~I~ t.)41' ~~4 ~J-1.J ·, n- J I ~ u~I ~
~~ U""~ ¥1..1.&.oll J ~ 0 ~ . (Stone, Kisamore, and Jawahar), 2008
o.l~ r-';.; « ,; .l~ 0-4 ~~ 0--4 HPI Reliability Scale a.:,o.:.. ,~,IJ ~~I
.(Hogan and Hogan, 1995, 1989) 0-J?~I ~ ~\..a:;.JI_, ~,.., ~ I U""~
~~J~I U>l-JI wi JJAL.u4S°JJ-"IJ4-J 0S,,---,-u ~J J~~I y)lb <.>A~ ~J
~f1 ~ J ·, ,t.-~~lul:P~~adjustmentcorrelated~ljtll
• , 't' o- ~ 4 ~ I a.....l)l.c. )..L4A ~J ~ I ~I~ a.....l>l-J4 ~.?. a....J~ .l ul~
• • , , C\- (Stone, Jawahar, and Kisamore, 2010) ~ I ~l~J
\ YA
iy::':.tla.ntt ~t_,.Jt d ~J ~ t j.4att d~J 4..1.~~lS\tt 4A!j.tt~ 4.! ca'>..aJt
U4)1lS~WI pro-social behaviors~~ '11 ~...ul ~L:.o~ ".:·o~I ~Y
Jul.I~~ ~I) ~ I U~IJ ~ts ~jts~I ~W~4J 0-J..?-'511 ~ ~
.(Stone, Kisamore, and Jawahar, 2008; Stone, Kisamore, and Jawahar, 2010
-
~ ~ ' ) ~~1 0
- ts
i i ~ I J a .: ,o ;. ,~, JI J-A~ ~..,...:; LA...5
Q
-
.;,
(Berry, Ones and Sackett, 2007 )UA~I) J~IJ (Borman et al., 2001; Dalal, 2005
ul.J~ ~ UJ_J-tJ 0-4 ~yl ~ ~ I ~ I c.LJ.jl.u,-., ':rQ.:loiiJI a.tlol_,.1.1 c.LJ~
~lL.J.t ~ I ~~i l>"° ~ ~i ~~I» cG~ ~}Lli..~I ~ c.LJ_,-bll c:.,..,~T-.,
(Kish-Gephart et al., 2010: 2) «t"""IJ J\..bj ~ a.J~I (~~'11) ¥~~I
-
~ I ~_jl.u, cJ-.,LlJ ~I ~~I l>"° I~ -t~~ jA4,.:i ~ I fS'.:'>~ ui '11
- • :.u --,,_ • . 1. .. ,,
.ct.:10 ....~L:' cl:"&.9~ ~ ~
(Berry, Ones, and Sackett, 2007)~~JYJJJI.G~~~c.J_,lrii;.:Uk:.~_,JI~

- ~ -
0-4 % meta-analyses ~ I u ~ I 0-4 ~~ ~J (Dalal, 2005) J'1b-.,
-
-
rl__µ.1'11-., ~_,JI ~~y\S' ~ I Y.J4,.:i ~ u~4,.:i'11-., uldt~'11J a.:,o;.~I
' ="'ca.: lo;; JI a..J.b l_,.1.1 ~_j1.u,J ~ I ~ I ~_j1.u, l>"° ~ ~ L.u Jo I~ 'i' Q.: lo ii ll
u¥, c4 cl.:10;. ,~,It ~l-JI J.ol~I a,j.)l..u ~ ~l.)J.ll i,.jA ~ .lJ-4Li LA uf '1}
~ uld.~.bj '11-., ul..A~'11 0-4 ~"'-! t;\_j i c.ill~ ~ • ~.llS'i ~ ~ ~_,J..u,
j->_.;LAi ~l.)JJI j).jA c.::.J-.,LlJ '(.:rQ.!lo iiJI rl__µ.1'11-., ~_,JI ~~ylS a.::..:t;_,ll Y.J~I
-
- ~ I ~ I c.LJ_jl.u, ~ ~>'14 ~.,-bll ~I~
~1 -~ y Q.:lo iill a.tlol_,.1.1 c.LJ.jl.u,-.,
•0-JJ> 1-LuJI
• • '5]\ c4 ~ J ~
l'!-~t\
.., ~- I ~
l..u (::A ~
• •
~ I c.LJ_,.L.u ~ ~u~'1\....:i Jo..+:i.;-J ~.ll.S~I ~WUt:....1.1 ui J.J....H

~ ~ I ~ J - 4 ui '11 ~~I ~ ~ ,~W\....:i ·u : I ,cs JI
- - - ..
~ I a ~.:., J.._;.. b a .: s>L.;.. ~I ~ u45.,.LJI L..&,.J~ ~ ..,...:...S-i V".JI ..L...11
. (McCabe, Trevino, and Butterfield, 1996; Nonis and Swift, 2001; Sims, 1993)
~-·.~-~ Ll~~I
-
~ ulo'·'-··'1
..r..- - '.r--'
~~ ~• .J.J.l.J- i'J-1-U:. .JA
" <J-".J 1..ul.~~ <..>---'
-~.!ti· .• <. ~
u~
- ts -
~~4 ~~ 4l lS'_jl.u, ~~I~~~ 0i ~1 J:]JJ4~ liA ~ J -~1
•<->-
'--'I~ -· · ~
.1. .. t\ c.Ll·'--·t\
<.r
~J ~
-~~IJ uJ-l
· .La.U 4.4Jl.;J.I utg."-r--w
--~tt.,•
~..)\S'~I u~l.;J.I Jo~) ~._rll 0--4 0i ~1 ~~IJ u ~ I ~

(Gottfredson and Hirsch, 1990; Marcus ~ I J ~ ~ ~.re-UI c.LJ~4
~_,f ,Jlit.l ~ ~ .and Schuler, 2004, Sackett and De Vore, 2001)
_ _ _...,,._,_ _ _ _
, -- ~~ •• ; a u . - ~ . ~.. ~~~~JV4EEZC5,iL'Cli.C!
\ Y~ l,6l~ LI.as~ ':?~I l.oJ ~~ lj\l : u ~ I ~ ~~~ 4.4.J~I

~ ' jA.all c.!.l~ ~ a.!, o.:..~, J.olJ-Al a:,.)L'U I o~' .;J~J o-ufi.)U a..-.u,.).)
~ , ~.)~~, ~~w, 0-A ~~ ~ .H.Jt:J1 ~~J~~,~,DLA
self- ~l.:UI ~l:s.;JI ~Li.o ~I.).)~~, ...L4l • (Marcus and Schuler, 2004)
4-lj,• iiJI ~,'.)-1-'J:..~,
r I w-4
· <.)J_,--
· ~J a=i)liJ. I~.)
_J A"".·. ~. u.,_-,
• ...w:.>4J
·-6,.
•J ~ ..J-:!'&' control
:._.·A,
~l#..,L.u 0-A c'""IJ J\.b:, ~ 16 ;.!:b;! ~~J ~_#1 ~l~J a.!,o;. ,~.IJ 1.S.?-~1
~ a..ow1 ~~ ~ ~~J .(Hirschi and Gottfredson, 1994) a.!:' •.,JI j.4.t.ll
~l.:UI ~l:s.;JI ui uJ-'-"...w~4,J ~J-:A fi~ General Theory of Crime ~~I
('r)ccLl~I I~
A-:\· ...Lu.JI. r.J.l.l ~I,.. I A"". :I('-: - ·- ~,,~~ .. -~ti~ I ·'1». ,..j
- ~ - • ~
I,;, '?'"'"'
'-'~ '..r---' . . u--:-"' ~
~~i ~J -~~l~J---Ay,:-c.,---lb (Hirschi and Gottfredson, 1994:4)
- - ,,
~~ ~Lj~ ~~ <?' ~l.:UI ~l:s_;l.J ~ ~.) Y~J o-ufi.)LA La.ulJ.) ~bj
~~ a:s).4A emotional stability ~WI ~~IJ conscientiousness ~_,ll
~_,JI ~~>14J F .)y,:-J J ~ a..b+i.;J.1 triggers~,~,~~~ ~ I.S.?-i
IA-:1
~ J~J
-•~-A
~~,
. ~~ ~ .I ... ,, '--'lc.!.JAI ... L
u-- ~ ~ ..-: i-.<-: ~,, .. .:.t\J
J c-:-- I.?*' ~J-"'
. (Marcus and Schuler, 2004)
~l.,J.I c.!.l~,_, ~.)~~I ~~I~ ~)WI o..l:...u:. ~L.ulJ.) c.J..9Ll:i ~

(Harding et al., 2004; ~ Ji j.4.t.ll ~~~~~I~ c.!.l_,l.uJI Ji <:?"q.!J;,iiJI
.McCabe, Trevino, and Butterfield, 1996; Nonis and Swift, 2001; Sims, 1993)
~J ~ I j.4.t.ll c.!.J~ ~~I ~L'UI ~L.ulJJ.ll D.iA w,A ~j f"J;.j 11,i ~ ~J
~l.,J.I c.!.l_,l.u, ..9i ~ I j.4.t.ll c.!.l_,hu ~ ~L..u Jo~ a.!,o;. ,~,JI ~ i.Si JJ~
-Lb4i_;I ~ ~J- J ~ ~~I oJbl .;.!; 11,:::,-LA y>l,b 0,A "\ • 0,A ~
-
~J .<:?"q.!t:, iiJI
~\SJ:i..cJ.I ~~ jA.AJI ~l#~J ~ ' ~ ~ ' Jlfo ~':J.J.A.A ~ • 'tA DJIJ.o.A
uA.1-J-'-"J ~jl ~J 4Jl.b , ·o, & ~i a..i.. t.e ~J . (Sims, 1993) y.All..9 ~_,llJ
~4JI y)Lb.JI 0-A JS] j.4.t.ll ~J ~'~~'.;IP~~ ~\.+i.;I ~)le.
...L4l .(Nonis and Swift, 2001) (r = ·, "\,) l:,WI ~L.ulJJ.ll y>lbJ (r = ·, "\"\)
~I ~l#.,1.uJI ~ uA>.J-'-"J ~jl a..-.ulJ.) ~~~~I ~L#~I u:,~
<?J1 LIJJ.ll LAi .y.Ail i.S.?-i ~~iJ~~I ~L.:i ~-"'"" ~~1 t-4~ l&JJlr;
'--'I c.!.J.I.
u-- ~..J 4...c.4.l.)~~I
.. - ~Li.l~I.LJ::I ~)l.JI J:J Lu:; I.?*'
~" (.;r'tJ ~'.~"" LiA I A.·-
~~ .
c.!.l_,l.u,..9 ~ ' c.!.l_,l.u, o-u~ ~J.>£A ~~ rL.,;.; • ·41..ill~J a.!,o;. ,:.,JIJ ~ '
- ~ ' j.4.t.ll
.-•. _ , . . . _ . ~ = - - - e - = - -· - ·~ · ~ ~ ~ - - · -
lfj~ 4.La.h ~ ':f~I '-4J o ~ faU : u ~ I ~ .>lw..aJ!J ~~I
·-~-~-. -•z=---------= \l"•
'"""°"·
~ b i ~ ~i ~ ~.,.ti ~bi ~1 µ1 ~ , ~L....u, o.-1~1 ~ ~..,
(Rotundo and Sackett, ~ I jA.a.11 l.!l~..9 Y! 4.!t;, ;;JI 4.Lbl.,.tl l.!l~..9 rl+ll
~ ~Lal 0-4 , l.:.U . 2002; Sackett, 2002; Viswesvaran and Ones, 2000)
ul~WI uld~ ~ ~ I jA.a.11 l.!l_,J-,..9 Y!q.!J;,;;JI 4.Lbl_,.tl l.!J~ ul~j..o
~WI a.! 4.!t;, c;JI u~I ~ uWl=i:..1.1 ~ ~ cGL:i JS'jj ~ J .J....JI J ~ J
(Gruys and Sackett, 2003; ~ ~~~i..9 uLJo..al ~~.J ~~J a.!4.!J;,;;JI
u~L=i:..t.10µ ,Robinson and Bennett, 1995; Sackett and DeVore, 2001)
4-aAWI
•
uL.ub -
.<.:.ti~·~Ju--"-'
"-41~ 4.J~ ... ti _:._:.t\S uW~ ~~
· · -- ~ti ~.)\S~I
- -
0-A~ ~ ,Jil4J .~11.!l~I tl.,:Si -b.i c.ill~ ~J a.!4.!l•iJI ~ I ~~J
~I._µ~ ~ W I ~ J . & . ~ y~I Jig 0-4 ~ I u'ib.. ~ t_)4?Jl 0i ~
t.)4?11 ~~ ~ ,~w..14 .(McCabe and Trevino, 1993) a.!4.!\.;JI a .!lo.JI
(Van Dyne and LePine, 1998) ¥~?JI ¥.,.LuJI .JIJ.l~I 0-4 D.J~4 ~I~
,whistleblowing (Miceli and Near, 1988) uWWI ~ t_)4?JI .JJ.l ~ ~ 4 J
<i'3I ~ I ~G.. , ~ I ~ 1.-S~ yllbll .)J.l u\ :lbio .)..9~ l.!.LJ~ 01 ~1
4.Lbl_,.tl l.!l~ tl.,:Si 0-4 k_,:, ~I~ t_)4?JI ~ , l.:.U .~I._µ ulj..9..LA ~..1.1 U"':P
l.!l.,.LuJI ll.4» Jio 0i .)~'ii ~ F Lo~ c.ill~..9 ~.)\S~I u~I ~ Y!ca.!Ioc;JI
((rl+l' ~bi ~..1.1 D.}J..Li.J '-:' •• .;,11.., <r~'il J4----u.JI ~ & , ~ I » ~ ~
al~l..9 ~I~ 0 ~ 0:.:.UI y~I 0i 0-A~ ~ , l.:.U . (Organ, 1997: 91)
J....JI J ~ ~ Y!"q.! Io ;;JI 4lb l.,.tl l.!l_,1-, .J~?J ~ _;&~I ~ 4-L44'JI ~ ~ I
. ~ I j....JI l.!l_,1-, a..u.JW ~ Jg~l..9
i~~t~t,..ut
J....JI l.!l_,l-,..9c..,q.!J;,ijJI 4.Lbl.,.tl l.!l_,1-,J.?- ~WI ~~I La..ul.)..1.11 D~~
-
a.!,o;.__jJI ~~ (..)-"~ .)~t ~w ~ ~I-SJ-'-" ,'i..,i - .;;.).J..u.o ~ ~ 1
~ t_)4?Jl..9 ~.)\S~I ~ I c.ill~..9 ~ I ~11.!l_,J-, ~~~a 111q;JI
~ 1.-SJ-'-" ,~l:i .structural equation model ~ I a.bWI [~~~~I
L~~"4-L4WI
~
· _;_:.t1 ~t
• Y!"9u--""" · ·)L~L.i..11
•c •
_:._:.tl!.!J·'
J~ ~ •
---a..Jw~a.bWI
• [~~·
Y!q.!t;,;;JI 4.Lbl_,.tl l.!l_,1-, J._p, ~~I ~ i u ~ I ..l.4l . ~ I j....JI l.!l~
~ (Berry, Ones, and Sackett, 2007; Dalal, 2005) ~ I ~ I l.!l~..9
~l.a.1.1 ..9i a.!,o.:,. .~.JI J._p, ~~I ..9i ~~JJI u4~1..9 a.jil.:.UI u4~'il
H"'\
-------·----==-----~... ~
~~ 4.1.a.9 ~ ~.:.LSI LoJ Q..L>,j faU : u ~ I ~ JlwAJ!., 4.4..t~I
r t, ll-• ~· C· ~' • C... . {j;- .. • 'f' 1 r" C· [• ~, • T° ~ ~ ·~
,:. - •L .eJ- & Ci\ & 'L ·,~·
.F . ~ ,r. r-- c I.D c b ~ r p
e. l. ·~ { t:: I:. . I:. L. ~ . ~ ,C- h .[ - Pi E..
t ~ .~ l 11: -{El1!. !C ~·~ ~l 1. f ~·~ .,t! '[:
i. ~ [·· "· ~.· ,c; . 6 ' V •V •~.
'>
~.
- t "'t t ~ ,r.1. • -;. ~
C 3 ,.•
·[ ~· .~· lS> C lS> & t,
1 ·~ ~· t·£ ~·
:i Cj; • (g.i - Ci-- E: ~ t ~- i.. f '[ ~
L. •• C I - .
·~
f [I:. L ~ ~ [. ~ cI:. ·Y - - h ~. Pi ~
S"- Pi~
~ ~- 1: 'i: ~· ._. -; ~- ~ E g· ·._. . ~ i
s t -:- 1:. [. E ~ f'\. ~- t ..
~~ I
t 'y t '( c... ~ [, - L
f .~: ~ <t ~ ~ r ·~. ~ ·fi ~ 1 .l·· - . t. t l,: Ci- -
~· ' \- .y C ~•, I C:,..
J· :< fr ,~: i• .& ,r, r • • 8 1.r& --~ lc... E. }
~ I ~~··1st! p.: k~~ c.' c, ~ •
~- l--rr:I-l ~ . ~Nl,ifr:i !!. <;z &. ~
J: [• r. - - - - ~· ~ (s j ~I I '\ t' I>
.. .f i.. x~ }e C• ·~ ~. i:"' Ci\ 1,. •r. r ~
l ~:t• [.::. ·~-.
I VI ~.,.
C• lc f - f "~ l'I' t.. ~ ·L
1L C·
IJ'\ -
L ~.,. i-' V\ ~
~ ~ '-' .t
f •
t~ ·t. • 8
(:'('• 1. I '-" 'c.. •
t .~ l [ . fr: ~ - 'd f rr l:.<r: 1··1 't:l:~. r· l-t't :
·~. ~ <(t: ?.q.1 -: 1 t. ·n: t t~~
~ ·v C•
if: t- r[ t l~-
'i.. 1.
J:~ :(· ~ 1 .t:~ ~t: ~rt--
[ 'f-.El.~fcit._1. ~r he.er . -
.("" .. t. ~ ~ f~ tt h ._ ~· r. ·
J;9 - I \.
~~• ~
'[ ~- - tl t •
~il,' ~ £
C· ,C- r! e_ ~• C• ~• ~1 ~ t -t· .h _
1. _
~.~ .~ Ci_t [t ~r .~:f. t- ·f... [• 1.r ·1·'t
, £ L c
(•- 'S c... e.
·~ C C - .f .. .h •!j.. !t· 'Ii,. ,f; I:.
V\
~. : ~
'f;. - [• I:. ,c;lS>· ~ { E Pi - 'D L .r' c= L ,c- .1> ~
't- - f.= .r..:.1:, - ~ t l ~; ~ ;~ 'f :i ~ ~f1 ';, t'
:~ tr [· i- ~ f. 'i . ~ r-i
·l,·
1~ . 1L _, L - •
~ r·~- f . f •t '~. .f •t r r.S ~·
£:. ~~ c ~ '~~~· ,c;t·
~I. C i ~ = 1 ·C =r - ~ :!:: Ii>• ...: - e. Y - e: ~ lS>· j.
, 1.
• 'D •
~. f.,. ·t { - 'l! ~ t (• Cj; l·i_i_ E:
t ~ f: i . . . .l· c- 1 ~ 1 e
t- 'FL _rl· t- ~-~ g.= t·• 'E-. <;:-E. ·t• ~~
- '[ I:.
~ 1fl, l·['. 'f..r r"·
f \- i 1.° [ [
C ti • h l'I' - f I • rr=. . C, ;. ;_. :_ i
C:· \!'. ~ .c; • L
:i I I:. E F.- f ;H~ '!j.. } -
r:t ·!j._[ .E:1-: l,~ 't: 'f re. F(·..[, rq· tt
- - ~ c;- \ C •
t ,r; l.,. .~~
f; - . ~ - c:.. ,I: .[ -
{t
a.:,o;..~,lt ~~I ~J---A o , u ~ <J-A ~ w.,....SJL.!a.....1.1 ~ i
«Online» ~WI ~I~ olj.lll ~ J Hogan Personality Inventory (HPI)
~1 as~1 ~.)~ ..)-1-U ~ . . , J.,;...) ~>-' ~.J.J..JiJ ~ ..ll_, . ~ l ~ b Jl4A [Jl;..
·~ wfi:i 1.-9~ ~44-1 w~ ~bJI
:t.t.r.., 4,,j4i1.'1'\ LAL:. y._, ,A~~J~irJl..)-JLJ-4ALJ.?JLjJ,I~~
ti ti ~
LS . ~ lAL:. n a.:a:JI J~i ~ts"_, lAL:. n.., n <>-"" ~ ~J~T r..,1) 044
-~~ ~~ -4)lb LJ.?JL!a.11 <JA :t.vo wts°J ,:t.t '\ ~I~ J.,S-.JJI ~ ~
~ I aL:.L.u 0-4 LIJ.) ~L.u '\• ~ l@'JWI 0-41.t.'\ ~ - ..ll_, .LIJ..ill LA\:i -
~ a.:a:JI ~ J o..l.)--,411 ~ I aL:.L- 0-4 ~L- '\ ·.., "\ • ~ LA :t.r,.., o..l),4ll
~ ~ ,c.ill~ ~1 as~1 .~b~ ~ o..l),4ll aL:.WI o-o ~L- "\ • 0-4 ~i
~.JJI ~ ~ J ,:t.r, "\ t~~I ~ aL:.L..u , • 0-4 ~t w~ ~.JJI ~>lbll
n
r·.., ~ LA0~~.JJI ~..,,:t.r·, r t-*""~,~~L.u ~ LA0~y._,"
~ ~ . . , ,:t.,A ~-*""i ~L..u t·.., n ~ LAw~~jJI ~ J ,1.YA,A ~L..u
·~JLlJI t ~ o-o :t., '\, t t-*""~I ~ ~L..u t • o-o ps'i w~ ~.JJI
'~~t
self-report» ~I~ <..>-":!:l4.o ~ oJ~ ~ L.-IJ..ul t 8;; 4 , ;.,; ~I <..>-":!:WI ~
.«Online» ~WI ~ I J.,_,.b ~ ~~«measures
,Hogan Personality Inventory (HPl)4.!s2'>:,7,U ~~t~.,i.()"~

~ ~ ~ ' - ' : , ~ I 4.:•o;. ,~.It o,u~ j-4 4.:•o;. .~,It ~~I ~j-4 o,u~
..ct.:•o"'C•..uLJ
:.ti ~~O"'~~~J,.,....L!d
I•_ I.. .,.~ti .... • .. • • tt• I .. _ ,t1· .. t~~t,
4.!4'0'f-& ~Jci.:•o,:,'(, ~~~ ~
'-'""~ w.A . Big Five personality factor (Hogan and Hogan, 1995) ~ I
,adjustment ~ I ~J a.:,o;. .~,\1 <..>-":!:l4.o ~ 0-4 a.:,o;. .~,\J ~~I ~J-4
,intellectance ~ts".JJI ,success in school ~I~ r~' ,ambition r ~ I
r~._g~,LIJ..ul"lA~J .sociability 0-'....>~..'5ll~J.c.l4'.JIJPrudenceJ.o,a:JI
r~ -0-1~~1 ~ J.c.Li:JI_, J.o.a:JIJ ~ I o,u~ a.:«o;. ~.IJ ~~I~-""'-'""~
·,A'\.~
":r-' ~)WI <..>-":!: WI ~ LW ~ 1.:..1..ul '"'·Lu.:;)\J Lll..L«.4l.l
- ~
,..- ~I (.):'
O"'.. t.t.)
.(Hogan and Hogan, 1995) 0-1....P"~I ~ J.c.Li:ill ·, v,_, , ~ ·, VA_, ,~ljill

,,.,..
1.-·!~, -r.> ..-· •.. ·· .. >_.«:-··0;:--·:· .... · .·_··.::c··~;;:;,;···.--:·.,.' ,::::::-:>:vz:::::.-.= ··.. :.:··_5C..._.. -~...-:". ... :J
~ ~ ~ ; : = : : t : / » ~ ..
(r= • ,V·)~4~~.J~~Wlu~~l->-'"°l.Wlr:4~l~~W'
r:4 0->?~I r:4 Jd~I ~..>-1-' (r = . 'rq ~ ~.)~ <:r'.,.ti r:4 J.a..=JI ~..>-1-'
.(Hogan and Hogan, 1995) (r = ·, o"\) ~ ~.J~ r:4 agreeableness J~I
i~t~~
~~(a=· ,A°')~~;;~r1_.,;.; 1114~.3\S~luW\..;J.lu-"~~
Ji ~L:t ul.J~ '}II~ ~ I J:iA 1)-4 u~_,b L.Jw i.SJ.A ~ ~~I JI~
~1a:s_;-uJ1_,t"-44-4~~~~UJ~0_,L.:J1_,1~1~u,,,_,.;.~1;;~~
~~'}II ~~I~ 4-4J;.i 11111 ~~I r:4 ~~I"~ c_i,~ .l.!.ll~ ~J
~J;.i 11,I <i'1'-' ~.3\S~I uW\..;J.I J..? ~~IJ ~..J-4~1 surveys~~ 11111
.(McCabe, 2005; McCabe and Trevino, 1993, 1997 ~ I ) "j)\AJJ ~\S'-4
~» l.>-4 i~ ul.J~ ~ ~La.;JI u ~ u-"~ ~ u44-, ?JI ~.! 111ai ~ .i9J
1)-4 4~ u ~ .3_?.J w,ll 4WI u4-,.J...ul .J.!1~1i .«;;~~ ul.J-A» w,11 «l~i ~~
u l.fo'_,b u-" ~ ->-'"° ~ ~J ~ W' . ct;,J:J. I u 4-,.J...u4 a:,J L1A ~.3\S~I u W\..;J. I
~ ~ I ~ I u~.,bJ a.!Q.!loiiJI ~1.,11 u~jL.uJ ~I~ ~?JIJ ~ I
.J.:d.1.11)-4 JJ~I .3~1
i · .~.
u-- • •~41t
.:.tt ~t: ..
u-"~ ~~I ~ J .(a= · ,Ao).>-'"°~ t:t) a..b........u,IJ-:' ~ I l:I~ u-"~ ~
u-"~ ~ u44-,?JI ~ ~ .i9J .u,,,_,.;.~I ~ 1)-4 ~I~ ~?JI J ~ l i.SJ.A
,, ,, ~ ~
.«I~~,, w,ll «1~1 ~I~ 1)-4>> 1)-4 I~ ul.J~ ~ ~La,;JI ufi:J

~ 1)-4 4=,~.3\S~I uW\..;J.I ~ ~~ 4~ l:I~ .3_?.J w,ll ~.;-11 u4-,.J...ul .J.!1~1i
,, -
~11.!l_,b ~ ~?/1.Jlfo 1)-4 '}I~ ~I~ ~?JI l:I~ u-"~ ~ .i9J .u,,,_,.;. '}II
LI.J...ul ~ eu..r?"i <i'11 L..A'-=!,JI ~ ~ J.3W 1.!.t_,L.«JI I~~ u~ j~ ~ I
«!..:~~)Donald McCabe <:r.'\S'-4 ...UWJ.3fi'~ ·I.SJ>~\ ul..A'-=!,JI l.>-4 LA.~ ~J
<i'11 ~ ' ul~~';)!I ~ ~~ ~i 1)-4 J.,~, ~ 4£A ':?,o;. Cr"·,·~,~ l~I
:r · · r r~ ~ ~..J-A~' ul..A'-=!-JI ~ u-"J-1_.,.,.t~ d..6..>A y>Lb ~ ~ rl:s

u=ol~"i4J -~ l~T ~t ~} 1.\ ~JLl.t (~I l..9..LA1Lli)~.'.1.111.H &A
i.!ll:i~(J&- l~~..9o~l..9~a.J6.0-4~l l..9..l.Al~~ti.,~\.!JW-Ac:.,l
- ~ ..ill~ 0-4 Jgt ~~~I~ ~I ~ I ~"ii.:,.~ c:.,.,s::; .il ,~ww,
~~ ~~ ~~· Lo.9 ~~ ® :;, QY,UI ~ ~l.w1llj 4-w..,r?JI ,,,_ . \Y't

~1 L!l~ Wl:9 0-4 ~~ r-1~4 a.!:' ,11JI ~1 ~l#.,-L.u, <.>"~ ~ ..1.4l
Wl:9 ~ J Counterproductive Work Behavior Checklist (CWB-C) ~ 1
~ c..r-'-"~ <.>"~ c.)c.J .(Specter et al., 2006) 0~iJ .J.f': , 0 LA~t
.. ts
~11 .J~4 1~...1.-..:' a.!:' •.,JI ~l#_,L.uJI 0-4 a.c.~ ~.)La.A i..S.J.A c.;,-!10~~1
ts
~ <i°'11 a.!:\ ,.. JI ~l#_,L.uJI ~~ .isJ ·«r-J: JS' ~~n.J~I ~l «WhA e,:.,~
production deviance ~l~~I [b:,1J (a= • , "\ 't') sabotage ~~I~~~
.(a= ·,A,) theft ~~IJ (a= ·, V·) withdrawal y~~IJ (a= ·, "\ ·)
s~l.lat
. Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CPA) ~~I JAl.c. ~
~)J ~ 1 ~ ~?/IJ ~ I L!l_,-l-u, <.>"~ ~' «oai • ,1 ~1~1 ~ ..L..41
.J~IJ wl...:~ ~~J 0J--'-".J...Gt ~ J t - ~ 1 L!l_,L.uJI tlyt 0-4 tl~l
.(AndersonandGerbing,1988) [::i~I ~ J.-;s <.>"~1 [::i~
cc,4 ~L..;JI j..--41.c. ~ ~ ~ '[~~I ~ .J~~
r-1...1;.;
~4?~ ~ cG~~I ~ ~ .LISREL8.5 (Joreskog and Sorbm, 1993)
~ ~~~I ~.JW.I r-1...G::C..-I ~ l.!.\JjS'
.LISREL ~\q.:.:iii ~~ co-variances
~ I .J~~ ~~I y..,_l.u,~I ~~\~maximum likelihood approach c.)c. ~1
. (Anderson and Gerbing, 1988; Joreskog and World, 1982) LIJ.J_,b:jJ
d.-4~~ ~ 0 ~ (Hu and Bentler, 1999) ~ J ~ ~ J i ~ J
th3dl ~..;:JI t.b;.JI ~ ~..;:JI . ) ~ I ~ ~ r-1...1;.; ccel ~ '[::i~I
0.J~I d,...__Q~.)WI ~j....AJ (RMSEA) root mean square error square
~..,.t.l ~_;tll . J ~ ~411 ~j°J.IJ comparative fit index (CPI)
. standardized root mean square residual
'-WI [
(.)-"" ::i!_9-4-)"JJ ~1~·":tl . .. 'J-'"' ~ ~ ~.. ..L..41
'~-·. t ::i~a:;~~Wl~l-"":tlcG
. .. 'J-'"' ~ ..
[::i~I I.JAJ . ~ I ~WI <.>"l.;9 ~~ ~~ ~ J-AJ (JJ~I [::i~I) ..l.>.l_,JI
:~Ll~I tA r-~~ ~
[ x2(349,N =207)= 3495J2,RMSEA=011, RMSEA 90 percent confidence interval (0.20,0.21),CR =0.44,and SRMR =0.29].
· · ... r.:iJI ( ~"\:JI [::i-~

~~ - ~ti) "T~\.jjl ~ ::i- - ~ti " "" '\:JI r~
'-WI [~~~ ::i- - :q ~i
~~I ~ ~ f ' l 0J~1 L!l_,-l-u,<.>"~0 ~...1;.; ,.,tl~u.JI ~
'"'o
&S%rs..t.oZ 'l.~.:,,0.,....,-4,r.44~"::"'C',\ ,.,!a·,,.w~~··:,,p-,,~~;;,.••,:,.:.wu,1o~:i."v.·,.10,~-l:l:lol',f.:io,,~~.rw,.~·~~~ ~ c,:, l!A.J:J,,)':>~~¥n10·· •• Y.~ .• .-1W"1.'.,.~·i ~ ~ ~ , t Y ' i . ' C " , ~ ' Q ' l i ~ N '..\.'O:.i\~
~~ ~ ~ ($.'..lll LA.9 ~..L:,,,J faU : u ~ I ~ .:i~IJ 44.1~1

r::r;-:7 ·.···.i.:', '· ,·._,•;·.- -~-.-...:.. ~-..-.... -~ .•··-~"/-~:.''-:'<.;_:::.:·. ~ :•.' ,, , ~- ... ; :.· ;! ; ~ .,·,-~ '. : ..... ',''. -~.;.-.~-):···,'·-'.((~///;;_, ·. , / , ··' ,-' •:·...~;:•,( ",'., !.1',•.,'.·.• 1•:-~~,-· ;,• <
lt , ,
~ \ u\#_,L.ut>A ~J'}]\ tl.,:S~I <.>"~~ a...o~l~Ll.a.JI ~\S'J 1~1_, I ~
~1 fit statistics W~I ul~~'i' U.)Ll,l ..L!J -~l:i.l\ ~I~ a.!:' cull
:[~~, I~~ poor f i t ~ a.a~~ .l.?.J
[ x2(348,N =207) = 1780.84, RMSEA=0.14, RMSEA 90 percent confidence interval (0.14,0.15),CFI =0.80,SRMR =0.14).
L~\~Ll.a.JI J:~~~\~l[~~~c.:Jl:i.J\[~~4~ ~J
.i!J . f-*4-4 ~ o.l..i>J.1 ~I Jl+lol ~ i t>A a:L....c..,J\ ~LU I t>A t-*4-4 ~ <.>"~
~1 fit statistics L..o~~t ul~~l uJL«!,i ~ k.l ~\~'}JI[~~, ~ J
:[~J-4-ill a..J~ a.a~~ .l_?.J
[x2(334, N=207) =93635, RMSEA =0.09, RMSEA 90 percent confidence interval (0.087, 0.10), CFI =0.91, and SRMR =0.09].
ul~ ":.l.;-aJI ul~j.l. latent construct~~, ~LUI ulJ~ ~ ~\S' .i!J

~~' l+iJ~~~J-AilJ;;~_,1.,~t~Ll.a.Jt~_,1_;.:;.,,(p<0.5)~.?.a..J'}].l
r~l ~ .i!J • , C\ t ~1 · ,r, 0--4 completely standardized factor loadings
standardized deviations ~~\ u~~IJ ulk..-..s.ji.o t>A d.......&..ulJ..111 u l ~
.(r-,) JJ~ ~ correlations ulb.:,\..>3J
~ · J:M.._g:at ~~.,..:a- ~~,4?~\.alt ~~.,..a~ul er-,) ~ . J ~
~
~p=-M••
~
P=:n~~
··..··..
.....
...
··..
~.U.m
....
...··
II':=-~ •••••••••••••••••••••••
}::
....·· ·•·...
8,m •••• ••••
~::.:::-::................ ···...
.· · · · · · ·
P=M.m
... ····•
®
p=- .19, ;;;···
•••··•·••·•·
I
..,_,..ol..WI .:.il~j.o Lot .~~1..,.;:.. a.J":a'.JJl .:.,I:, .:.,~)WI ~I a.b.a.al ~~I~ •*p < .05, **p < .01 :~)Lo
• li.A ~_,....,.;:.. '="1'J J:d.ll i,;s 1+-Jl o)..!,?JI ~ ~ ~lS:JI .:.ii~ ~lf.ill ~J,-....:t ~ ~~IJ 0..1.>Jll
~~ -•• ao
l.,6l~ 4.la.9 ~ "?~I UJ Q ~ 1:,u :u~t ~ J~lj 4-4,J~I

l~~,[~.,...at
~ I ~jLJI [j-'4l k4i~i ,~j-'4l~ ~ J~~ ~m ~ J i ~
0~01.)~Li:J.J,~1~y11crj~~~ .~~1~y11crj~~~1..,
~! sociability 0-J...»-'JI~ ~Ll:ill..9 prudence ~ I J adjustment ~ I 0---4
,J.,WI ~J . report cheating ~I~ t_)4?/IJ cheating behavior ~11..!l~
":-U~I ~J a.ul ceJI wl#~I ~ 0-J~~ u,J_.)~ ul..~I ul~ ~.):
C
withdrawal y~'il..9 production of deviance ~l~'il [l...ij!J sabotage

[ j ~ "?.:UI ~ I ~_;.ti~ ~ I ~jLJI [j-'4l ~ J . theft ~~IJ
[j-'4lt~ {\"-\ )~~~.,-o.,-A ~J .ww4-tJI ~ "~~ u~J<Y'~I
:_,-A..9 ww~ a.I~ Ls:.~ ~ I ~jLJI
[ x2(413,N =207) =1008.74,RMSEA =0.084, RMSEA 90 percent confidence interval (0.077,0.090), CA =0.90,and SRMR =0.089).
0-4 4 i ~ ~ wl.J~ ~ ~J IJ.!.!;; Jgl ~l:i [j-'4l .J~I ~ i ~ ...1....SJ - " <$
~ I wl:.o.,L...u, tl~i 0-4 tl~i ~ ) ~10-J...»-~I ~ ~~IJ ~IJ, a .!<;ti

:wwl:.JI ~ "~ I" ~~ ~~I ~jLJI [j-'4lJ . ~ I
[x2(401,N =207) =993.13,RMSEA=0.085,RMSEA 90 percent confidence interval (0.078,0.092),CA =0.90,andSRMR =0.088).
~ I ~jLJI [j-'4l ~~~~chi-square &>11 "?~ .J~I s:.I~! ~ ~..,

&Jll "?~.J~'i ~~'ii alco·uu~ ...1....SJ .~~I ~jLJI [j-'4l~~IJ
~ I 0-4 Jgi ~J degrees of freedom ~ I w4--.J.) 0-4 \ r J<J \ o, "\ \ ~
Jg~I ~~I ~jLJI [j-'4l ~.J Y.P."J ~ l4.A \\,Vo ~J "?~ &Jl 4'.uWI
. I...l...u.4i . i:<'l' IJL~
~(" 'I ~ .~ 'I j ',.. s:, u.,...
'i IJ I...l...u.4i
<$ .. -
.... J--1 .
,.,..., [~c.r- ....
~l..9((3=-46,p<0.01), <, .!<;ll ~ ) , ~ I ~jLJI [j.J4l~J

~11..!l~~~~l 1.\A u l ~ l£A ki,,..9~11..!l~ ,((3 = -28,p <0.05)
~11..!l_,l.-...ui ~ ,((3 = 0.44, ns) ~...»-~I~ Jd. a:JI .;J: ~J . ~4JI ~
((3 = - 0.08, ns) ~4J ,((3 = -0.12, ns), <, §;t4 ~ ~J . ~.P." i~b
0-41..!l_,l.-...ui ~
t)4?14 ~>le. u<3 ~ ((3 = -0.19, ns) ~...»-~I~ ~Ll:il4J
~ I ~__.>J ~.P." ~~1 a.......l~ l..!l~ u~J ·~.P." aJ'i.) wlj 0-J...»-'xl ~
((3 =0.31,p <0.05) ":-U~I ~ ci'11 a.!:I ,cell ~ I wl:.o~ d..L44JI ~
~.;-uJl..9 (f3 = 0.41, p < 0.01) y~'il..9 (f3 = 0.46, p < 0.01) ~l~'il [bj!J
0-J...»-'xl J;go-4~1 ~ t_)4?/I al~~~ ,~4JI ~J .((3 = 0.29, p < 0.05)
~~.::A..~tt'1f" ~ '.~:.7,,~~,.::-.,:ll.L.u...-~·,pc;1.,;,c.._.-.,. .-.,,.~,;i...- •.;. ••. ,:.i.!.'~~~.n,:.-,j- ~Y,.;,.,.•.11;,_;,~ ..:&·\.'~~~.;-,..-~'l\J,J..,·~,.,.._, "¢:~~~ T . ' ~
\Y'V ~~ ~ ~ 1.?°.:.Ltl l.oJ ~~ l~ll : u ~ I ~ ~~!., 4-,~I

cf.~ ~ &~ f>-.. e-! {~· [,[•{ti
•l \. C
c·.
Fl . r r • "b.! ,t• t' f>"" ~ "b.! ~ { .c; H
r r· 1.~ ·t y ~ ~~· l.t t· r <r y <r
~ \ ~ I I~ G. ~ (1 - [. ~ ; v1
r;: [. 1''.j
- t·.·1··1
b.! . 'E • ,,
t - X b.! L·.
t, l
.·~ •t,. ... - Cl) b.!" ~
~l
,(; =- -
·ti ·1.f 'f ~t l~ t·t {.r~ a~ \-.
Cc •I• l:! I:; \I> I('; - [:
,f,;l
.I l ·
r
f ,rt•'(' er
I
r;"
~ Cl)_,.
'D
~·\fir.~ l:ft~·~·L
'~ ; 1-
~
b.!
r. ~· ~. l ·~ - •
~· - •
'D
c:;.: -.
n 'i:P
t·.1
LI
L•l b ('t> ••
.:;,.q C· ~
• n, L , III tt·l..l.
- i P ,t' -• - C· 0.1 ~· t· 1e..b
n ft t. t t.t: c;.: - o r -I:!. - ; .O tlj j
C· C· I~ N 1:f
~. I I:. _,.
~ ~ Cc C• -
~· ,r'
't- f.. -
l_ S ~
- 1;'"
·~. ~ Ci:-- (, ~
~ f l ~- 1: ~~ .f.1,· .r.t~ .~t· ~
- F.. I!.. t ,(' t' t
G.-
i;;
-~
r
c_
b
r .
h
X
t> :-.. - . ..v,)
(:'('• 'i:P 'i:P
'I>
~
j;'\
,·1
f,
l, I •l b C· C• '(...
.'f II II A
'D I I O
&.
> "be! [J,.:J
Fd~. ~· ~ ~ f:._. \p I C• - 'v r o- . r-=1
~ f "·l flb 1: l.1;'° ;
~· r(; ;..... ~ 0 /:.·
·t l.- '.f, r t
t· ~ I ~~ . y iL 4.p
~,. ~~"(."'(Ell 1~ ·:t
• Ci • ... l, ' ~
- ~ · o... o N ...... ~ rl:'
~•t' ~· l r- t,, Ci.- t•· .r, t .e.
tr
'[, [, ~ ..- I:!. ~
E1 • b.!
1• ~·r ::s
en ~ 1·[ r··-··.:.·; ·'
- 'I:!. '-' A . l'.J
'\. I f>-" I C. (,'f - ~• 0 I l':j
rt=1;~- {.t·~.. ·&·~· {~ ~ I- f {~' i• Cc,.- i :r~.. ·r ~ t- tt
., ' ~ 1,-• t - r. .C f> - [i: C. t.•-.~
r 1. e; & ~. l.. . ~ [a• ·!j.. b 1,· \_ ~ l ~· : ';!. ~ - ,._ h Ii
r· 1- .~ 1·-
I X . '-'
~r r '1» & - r-· ·- \ ; b.! r;: r:1
'f! ~ i •i. f. _q· i: i
l._ ~I·~. Lt-~~ }yt
- rs: [ Cr ~ Cr ~ - ,I:" ·be! - fr. T" (,'f "r ~ f;i
~~ 1'-t g \ b.! ~ G. I F.. l F.. ~ i t_~r-'f
·t ~ :f;. ;
~ .r f ~
J { [• : I &' ' . ·~ ~ :~ J= t' (J
&.~ &.S~ ~·
~· C•
\ - 'i:P !ii~·i
I 'k ~- ·"" I - ~!
[i t-.f ~ & ff ~ - p:" t ~~t!.f If p
~ ~ 1 f> '~ G' ~ • r-'f , N r:l
!i l,
E
t J 1 'Ci ~ E ~- -1- j_,. E: c . .c- ~
Cr ' . t! ~.. - C· .c;
~
1[
• ~
l,' ~ ~
_b, ~ P-'
i:;.l
h E:
•
Ci. r . ·.. · \ \I> F.. • ~ .. ,
~I I ~I~ I, C· I E.:. ~ A L !:. : E:
i; (·f ~· t r~ t.. ~. ~ t. f> £
r <i,, - c:;.• - •- '[ I • \ - t' .V b.! r:~:;J -
b.! };
?
l
1' ~ 1 tr ~ It ~· t C r '1!.. ~ !t t~ f
I '
r:-.. ~ ~
~•t, x' . l:! ~ l ,
~ I '1»· ·r; E: . ,. ; ~ ·1::.~ 1: ~ f ·~ ~ g ~· - t· - - f- -:t'b~~~- 1.:.:l
n -
~...»-iJ.)Ji'! <.>-4 ~1~i J~l .J---'bJ ~~j ~c.!.Jl....i.AJ
111(.)-"~
Counterproductive ~ I ~ I l.!l_,-l-u, Wli <.>":.':l..a..o (Spector et al, 2006)

~ oJ.:!S'~ ccjAL..:JI ;;~Lu,}» ~~~..,Work Behavior Checklist (CWB-C)
,, ..
:.-'cll~ ~1 ~~1 . (Berry et al., 2007) u ~ I <.>-4 'i~ .l~)U ~_,.I.I .._gl..rtU'il
~1~ ?JI <.>":.':'-4.tl ~ i 0-J...»-i y ~ ~ <>4 ~ I ~ ~'jl -U: ~.:UI ~_,JI~
09-: 0i ~ 'i cL.._jj ~! ,~..)lS'~I J4:J.I ~ '-:? Q.!t:, ;;ti a..;.bl_,-1.1 c.!.J_,.LuJ ~Lal
lS_;.;..~I y)lhll ul;.6'_,.Lu, 0fiJ ~.., .u~~I ~ t~I 1~ ..1.;?-yl [~J--4-i.11
~ ~
t.~ -~ · ~)G..-:iil L~L ,. · - ~,1 ill.ti~~ ,a..u)lhll u ~ I . "c.!.JI - :. 'ilS'
~J - - . ~ '-T"' -· - . '-r 1..)-'-'-'J
~ ci'1' u~)WJ ~ J JAi~ ,~_,~ al),WI ul~ d.£.44,JI ~~ ~ y)lhll
~ t~f'4 ~..>: ~1 ~ ~'jl 0i ~ ~ L,rg~ <>4 ~_y.JI ~J . ~
~ E:_)4'j1 ~ ~~I _;.b\..:,c:J.I 0i Fl_,JI <.>-4 0i 'i! ,whistleblowing u~\..:,c:J.1
~ uWWI ~ t~f'I ~ ~~I _;.bWI <>4 ~ ~i ~I~~ uW~I
~
- 1 (.)-""""'
_:._:.q ulo·' --' -1.:u1 r"'::.--
.. ~~ ..... ~~ti .J.AJ ~ .:.UI ~-ti · J · i .~WI
'.r ~ ~ •
~... r .
LJ;.i11,o ~J ;;.).lw ~I~ y)lhll ul..:.~ 0i 'i! ,distribution 1=J~1 ~_,:;
.Ct>surrogate measure~~<>"~~
.. • , L..c..ul.)J.1.J a...t.;;
~ • - .fl b.1:i
, ,111!:J·~ • ·i~
(.) , -·- :.. ,LJlit.1
.. ~w,
.. ·
(.)--A
a l«eQ;.JI 4.!cO;. e~,11 ~~ 0:--:' Lo L:9),WI ~ longitudinal ~j..11

~ ~ ~ I ul;.6'j-L,J ~Ll.o ~_,Lu, u~J ,Big Five Personality Factors
~ .)~I~1.?. <>4J . ~ I ~1 l.!lj-L,J '-:? Q.!t;, ;;11 a..;.bl_,-1.1 c.!.Jj-L,J rlf.1.1 cll~
~ I ~1 ul;.6'j-L,~ \.A..)~I .JAlS_;.;..~1 uL.ul.).JJI <>4..#JJ:i Ll.).JJI o.:U
a.!\!;;,«ell 1!:J~I ~ 0i ~ -rlf.1.1 ~1-li ~i ~ I ~1 ~ .)~'ii 0-4 ~~
,,
~c.!.J~0lS' 1~1., .4#.,_LuJI '-:!ly.ilJul;.6'_,.LuJI ~ ~~.,-o~l..a..oj~?}
~~tw• ~ ·."..r
t i ~1-~'1 ·
• :;-:w ~~~u ,... - .< -~": · i ~ Q,t;, jjJI a..;.blr· 'I l.!J.l..t
.... '-:?.. ~ ~'"" ~
,,
, ~ I ~1 ul;.6'.,LJ ~ ~bj ~ c.!.Jl.i.A 0lS' 1~1 ,J'J.4J -~~_,.ti ~ I
.~ . . 'I
.. y..ay. u-a-'
L - ,,
~
~l:u.J. a..b.u. 'I ~I 'I
. '..r • :;-:w
A~ . ,... . .< - ~-: . i ~
~ ~ ~ (.) •• -
:S..,.,C~~•C:1;'>',.~·-~-~;:,:.-.>"3......,_.,•. ';'.~:,,..+=;~x•·;..·,1~· - • ...,.t ,._...,.-,.;.,::.-",-.,..>;:;:::.;,,-.,.-.•"\:~ l! - - - ~ ~ ~ 7~¥.;·~~7-"l',l,,'l.~,r:,,t• ...,.,.q."C"c~o._r,.-i,;;·.,,.,-..-.1•..1,l.·-.:..~.~,.•.i..,r.,~~.l,th.:M..:;,,.'C.,;•.,.:,v.:.,Q~ ;:.,;:,,;;._ .•~:
\Y'~ ~~ild~'-:f.'..Ltll..oJi!l~faU. :u~l'?9~~1J'2.4J~I

,·.·-:·.-·.:,j
w,-k . ~ I u ':l/~ ~ ~ ~ I ~1 c.!J_,k,J '=7"q.! t:, iill a.lb 1_,J. I c.!J_,Lu, u¥,
~ JA~ ~ t ~_,JI ul ~~1 i!J~I u~l '5.:UI ~_,JI w,-9 ,Jut.I~
- ,1$ - -
,~cJ4 .a.!,o~I d.hu,I~ \# ~ ~1 c.!J_,k, 0i ':lll , ~ 1 ~1 c.!J~

~ J~~ j....A~ ~L-JI c.!J~»,µ ~ I u~.)t ~~ b-....UI.) c.!Jl.i.A
c.!J~ ~~I dLAi c.J-4J .(Hunter and Hunter, 1984) e<y':oi ,cell c.!l.,.L-J4
-.: ~-~ti .1. . I t ~ - q u)LJWI -: . L c.!Jl.i.A ~ L -'I ul& ., .... L ~~" - L-JI
~ J c.!J~ - ~ . ~ . ~ -~~~
~l.:UI ~ I uw~J (Gatewood, Field, and Barrick, 2007) .).)~1 0,.4
u,,>_;.>,iJ ulJ~ ~ ul ~yl ~ .(Shaffer, Saunders, and Owens, 1986)
~ olj.ll1J ~_,JI ul.)~I ~ i c.;,-11 IJ.)~i (Kish-Gephart et al., 2010)
y:-JI ~l._>ll ¥_,1.uJI u~I r'~'
~ l ~ i ~i ':lll ,((~w1 rLl:JI»~.,=;
~ I c.!J~ al~I ul~ uL.u1.)...u1 ~ ..llJ .L1.)...u1 o~ ~ ~! J..>.b:tll ~
LA~I ~ r\.lo:ij':lJ\S' c.!lµ ~~_,J.1 ul~jll Ji ¥_,1.uJI ~WI 0,.4 ~ I
u~~IJ ~~I ~1~1J 0.)~1 o.)\.;g U ~ j ..9:~I &~i O.)l..:c..u,I ~ J
u~_,.L-JI 0-A u¥, w,-9 ~ 1 ul c.;,-11 ~l.)...ul D~ ~ b : , ~ -~~':l/1
~~':l/1 ~...ul u~.,Lu, u~ a.!t:;;,,,ll ~~1 ~t~! ~ ~ ~ ~L-JI
·¥>b~1~u~~IJ
r - - . G / 1 1 : 1 , T ~ ' t ' S " Y T ~ - ~ ~ . - - . - - . . . . . : . ~ - . - . # I L " ~ ~ -~ ~ - --=---~-r.·.:r.,-l'r#:'.r~---.~:::-=~.-A·A:::1.-.-......~,1;'\.~~r.r~~.C.
~~ 4W ~ '-:f ~I Lo..9 o ~ ljU : u ~ I ~ ~l.wwil!J '4-,~I \t •

;:l
- .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 1 . 1-r ·-:
! .,.
i .,. >
-< -,
- -'• -'
< >
-< >
.,. <
> >
- 0
> <
-, <
_., 0o -
_.,' -
>' -
-,' 0_., I t '. l,i
'l ..e·
I'~
I C· ~- ~ H
-hC • - ft
r- ~ ~~ 't
~ i fi_
j oe•1
\D
-ct [-,
6
+:I
, f
t rt-<f
•
t
- I S n~
F' f'~ 1-
r~· t[ ll
r r . :E: ~ {" " &· ~ f:
1i 1 1-·
- t
I
1 . : ~ ~ .r:
l t '
b ft~ t.c ~ -
r 1:.,
~
"; t C·
l ;i ' .... t
c, '1! - ·~ 'l V ·L 'j, .U

E f C. t . -:; m C·
tl- 1 r ~ -·
~v k .· f ~ t f E
.r . -.
t 1 r .c .t .t .!e.: ·l,. _; r.: :~ ,i [ t. ~
fr 1:r;.. r - !.. •-.! f.<
~ ~ • • - (!_ r;; r;; , ~ ~ iC· ~ ~ ·1 .r··: s~
I t - t . . --, -, 'j, - r - c: ..
f! ,c.; ,c.; {' " C· 1,· -
,:: ~ ~ . ' '
'e. s ., .
: I -
I• -.! I:; I:; . ~ . C· I • ~i I
C·
~·~ .1I f.-. 1'°- .·t·-. !t- ~V t~- r- r-
i::
r. i~· [· •f.~ '\f'. 1~· ~ 'j,l 'j,.f. i ,t.t•t i~;.t-
.c.; - '\. . {' ... • " - !)
i !,
t(' .t -. - . f -. -.
-I · ~ c, - ':
E ~ . \. t.~ · e:: e:: ..
.: \. . . .
\.
£ ~ ; t
'\. l - V C ~ V V t t f f L _, .[" '-· .c -• .
t .~ f l l
[I '!.. T ~ - .~ \ ~ ~ ~ 'r ~ 'i, f ·L 1.. I ~ ·L 1. f t.
. i 1 ) " [1 r:f r:f i -· - - f t: '\, - f t . [. - f
t-
11 ~ : ~ ·~ _: t ·~ t ~ ~ f;: r 1.· t c; ~
l ·~- l l · tt
11 t t t f ~ ~ 't 't ·-c ~ <g _ ~ ~ } fi f t F f i I
~Wl~I
L.c~..:._.:._, . · ~ - . ,.· .. ,•.·.,.~•.'.'. •,;··~··········.,.,,·....•. ·.,,·.J·•·...·.:.,.··.~··.•;,_-......~.·.·.•·•.····.,·..·..- . ? ' . \ / ~ : . ~ - ~ : : : : i
'"3a~~t ~l:Ul - 4 ..c..: 1uJt J4att ul:!,S~

~t;. ~fa. ~ I '"bi ..1.4.U
. 'o, _)\.~?JI ~1 ~l>- j~J ~J ~ ~ I '"bl~ '"~?JI ..1.4.U
• '0 I\ u ~ I W~ ...L4,Lj
l'°:'~~t - 4 .! : t Cu.tt J4att Ul:!,$~

• IO"\ 0~10J-l jA...ll _;~I ~ ...,_;..b.JI
• '"\A ..ill~ u.uJ ~iJ ~JA cl>~ J~IJ J_µll ~ '"~I
~ ..ill r~~ aL_,b 4>-~I j,;.j
·, tA
aal~t - AA ..s.:I cccrt J4att ul:!,S~

• IO"\ ~ I y.:,..Ld ~ .l..,..:; lA '"~ al>'""
. '" ..ill~ 0~1 ~ J ~ l 0J-l Jj..i.411 ul..u.A Ji u l ~ .:G..l
l.fl~ ~ ~ uld.'"" ~~LA~~ ~lb.ti

0~l 0J~ ~ I y.:,..b 1)-4 JI.JAi j,;.f
~ I ~...,_;..T ~ ~ jy:; '"~ al>'""
r,.~~Yll"Y.-.,.,.,.~-·~,,,..._._.,,,.;,11;:•.s,i-~-~~-9#--"'1'111.-."n"._,.._....~--s:rc-~ ...~ ' ) : ; f ~. . . . . ~ _ , ~ . . . . _ ~ ~ . ~ ~
~~ 4.1.d ~ ~~I '-4j i!,...L>,j ,~u : u ~ I ~ .)~lj 4.4.l~I 't y

'.! ~~lS~t .:,l:!S~!J it.! ·o~I rt~l:t ~ I .:.Lil~ ~ I
~.W.l:T~~?l:'J:·c>',•~irn'.';~1''1&,.id,,~,;t:~~71.~..~im!.'-T'~J}t:t~;:.:;;:];--;>;n'.~Z:J.W~m:~il
,~...,.:wtu~~
0A ~.)4)~1 a..ll_p.JI 04 -lJ-4,11 -l~I <.)1 cc<r-.;L;.JI ~lj.S'.>-4»~ (\)
l.5.J.A ~ ((locus of control ~lj.S'.>-4»rlbcoo Loi -~.;G..1.5~~
0AJ: ,Jl:J.1 ~ c_:,k. •'U~ ~ ~..ll_p.JI y4--u,i ~ .:G4 ..lJ-4,11 ..l~I
I..S~ F 0A ~4 ~ I 0AJ: ~ '?'9 ~ i F 0A (.:d~l 04 ~ I
1.j,,4) r~' 0A JJi Julian Rotter ->3J.J wl:J.?. ~ I f1Lc. 0lS ...1SJ -~.;G..
•..:. __ ti •.. '.:.ti - I · · · ... .:.~tl_..1,.. • -lt..., .... tl
·u,,J~ ~ ~.!'.!1«14,'.>-~~ ~-~c---
Rotter, J. (1966). Generalized expectancies for internal versus external
control of reinforcements. Psychological Monographs, 80, Whole No. 609.
~1~1 ~ 0i c_:,k. 0J-'-"...UJA>~J ~~ ~~' '?'9 a.ow, ~ 1 r~ (")

<i'1l 1.5..u.l o~I ~ I .;l:i'5!1 ~ ~WI» 0i .j,AJ J.>IJ~ '?'9 ~.;;,~,;
.r- ~ Jl:J.I U':.'-'""
A__& '- · -~'" ~ ~ '" ~~- ul~:.t:.s' ~ I~ "~I ~~- 0-4
· ~ ·-
..lJ-l.;5 ~WI Ji~~~, a~.!!tl 0A ~ ~I Ji ul.;...Gd.1 ~L..J ~ JL,JI
-lJ-4,11 r~~ .,c~! •.. y,,-~l '-9y-hll 4-l~ '-9~1 ~ ~Jj.11 J.>i ~
r ~ l wJ..l«the immediate pleasure» ~~I d.ul.1 w,k- ~ 0~ L....i..41
:~I -~~ 1.5..u.l o~I .Jl:i~4
The Generality of Deviance. Ed.Travis Hirschi & Michael R.
Gottfredson. (1994: 1-2), Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick, NJ.
~>Lo~~ <i'1' u l ~ I ~ latent variables ~ls:JI u l ~ I (1)

[l:u:u.ul ~ J . observable variables ~~I u l ~ l 0Lli _j,A ~ o~Lt-o
r.J;.i 110~i~~LlAJ~~[~~J)l;..0A~ls:Jlul~l ..l~J
ul..>=4A LJAJ .hidden variables a .!,;~II ul~I ~ J 4..LAls:JI ul.; .!;;4\J
..ll..lei ~ ~ ~ uLl~l 1.5~ ~ 4..LAls:JI u ~ I rl...1;.; ,ul
~ ~i 0A cl.LA~ ~Li.o ~ [~~ ~~ a.lopJ.1.1 u l ~ l 0A o ~
.ulo.,WI
http:!/en. wikipedia.org/wiki/Latent_variable :.;~I
ulo~ c_:,k. J ~ I ~l '-9-4: u-"~ _j,A surrogate measure J:!~1 u-"~1 (t)
~WI -.Lt: ,Jl:J.1 ~ c_:,k. •;;~4-o ~ cL..c,l.j! ~Ji~~ u.c
~ ~ ~u-"-
-
"'1- t!..: aJ .J..JI ~1 :. Li4l WLl. "'L..l~I "'L-L......a.o ml· .:.1t GDP t ~ ~I '- ti
- - 'J-""'-' ':T ... ~
~G-bh "~' c.:,.,.t c.:,~ .is ~ o.,;--Lu'+4 d.A.>fa. ..)~~, o_;g <>"~ ~~
.yW\ ~ r~ lS..lA ~ J...u o~~J-!:C. ~,~JA c->~~1
http://www.conservapedia.com/Surrogate_measure :J~I
Ht
~t,J't~t
c')~ ;,µ.,_.i, ullJ-"' ~ tta:Jt JJ~
Edward C. Tomlinson ~ _ , J ·4>" .)J~.)! s.)1~!
II II
~l.&A ~ UjA bW ,(~I I~)~~ o~ J ~ ,~WI .l~~I ~LA:

II .. ..
ul~J o.J..4AA u.,sJ lA L.Jli. <>"~~I I~ y~i ui ~ ~jjl ~_,JI ~J ·J~ ~

~~~~i ~1 ~ 1 JAl_,£11 ~i ui JA 4..LA t_jJ-4llJ-A~1 u~ ,o.l.J.Li.A ~Ji
1. _:ti - t~··I) .... t..q 1 A,.:tiJ ~,1 J~~I ~ ~ I
u-"-4 \.,;JI ~~c-~-~ t' .. ~· uL.u~ WI ~
((ul~,1.:1~.l~~IL~l~~l lA~;;~lul:~..,.Jl~J .(~11~0-A
~ ,u~~I ~\S' jl4j?J ~ 0-AJ ~ o~ u\S'~ ~l4j1 ._g~ ~~ .J-t):.
~~ ~ l ~ I ~ JI.JA~I ~ ~ q,jj ._gLl.:iS'I ~ ~jJ ~ ~! LWI ~
~l..9~~.lJ~~I (J-1.J:..U.I U ~ . ) ~ ~.l~ ,Jl:'J.I ~~ ,~Ll.4.)-t):.
~~u~l~~LJ~l"~~~,~~~1~~1 .a4,..;.,0J1
jl~~I" I~ ul • .ll:.ljl ~ ~_,.1.1 ul:9..>-'-" ui J~ {~_;L.t...;. u ~ ~i Ji)
~Jiy•o~lf4A1~~~_,J.IJ;90Aa5~1u~~~L~I.HJ:.
~~ ~~~~~.;Jib dJ u\S' (Greenberg, 1995, p. 154) «u-i..?i ~1
o_;~I ~J.>JI ul->=.JZJI ~ ~ J ,Jl:'J.I ~ ~ . ~ I .l~~l 0-AJ
.(AFCE,2008) ~..;-4i_;~J.l()-*4 C\'U _;1~;;~1 u~~..,.JI ~ ~ I
.)oWI ~10-A~IJ ~ I .l_;ly.l u~~ ~ ~l~l .;~i ~WI ~_,JI ~ J
~.l~~I .l.,....S-_;l.J ~~\S' u\S'~I 0A ~L.u.>- ulA~ ~~ ;;~lj:J.1
~ J (Friedman, 2009; Koster, 2009; Needleman, 2008; Roberts, 2009)
~ ~.l~~I <>"l.:w~4J ul qt:,;JI 0-A~ ~~ ll~~t i~..L&J d..J~ u~
. ._glhJ.I ~~
.~ -:t-~ • ~ a.zJI
·d . rti ul:9~~
!t!. &
.. .)J .l .)J..H
· ..ul
-~ · .. ,~11.!lb.l
.. LL.a.J.I ~
U'!
. J
'\
._g.~~
· -~1t - ~ u~
• ..u-~
· jjl ~..
· ~ I 0---l->:
· ..u.1 r..:-'-'~r
. ~ · ·· :t!.. · t\ ~~-
.. :. ... t l~Ll
~
LJ'-4.o ~i ~ j u~_,.1.1 ~ ~j.A u~ .ill ,"5~1 ul.;,>-..iA ~ a.JJ~ ~~
..14w ~ I y ~ i J;g 0A ~_,.1.1 ~l..>-4 ~_;.l u~ ~~ .ul~l~?JI ~ ~
,(Dunn and Schweitzer, 2005 ,JLJ.l.l ~~~I),~ a.zJI ~_;.l ~
u~ L.JI _;LJ i , ~ 4 . ~_,.1.1 ul:9..)---'-':I ~jA .;Ui ~ y....:;~ I.LAJ
~~~~~~ ...~'-...·.t:i...: M.....,..,,..m . . - " " - . . ~ vw•~·•;•;:"""*:ir~M~W-A"~~,;)z,n,,.Jc-~'loUl"'L-'L'·~->.... ~- .. "..7.:..,~.r.~1~x..:.:..r.<r-~w"'!gl(''*"C4'11U":•~•·•~•-.:•v,a•1
\to "4,7t~4.las~~.:.L!ILAJ&.:1~faU. : u ~ l ~ J ~ l j ~ ~ I
&!.>Jl~I
r··.~-··s:"'.-·=·.··~~-- -~-~~~_....._!~:,·~~ts·~- :.·<~C:L·~-~-=-~-~-~r-~-~·J· . ~ & ~ ~ - J
,(Cressey, 1953; Litsky, Eddleston, and Kidder, 2006, Niehoff and Paul, 2000)
Abcede, 1994; Balmer, 2009; Banks, 2007; JL...:J.I ~ ~ ) <.JJ-'-".JWl..9
~~LA..o o-4 u l ~ J)l.;. u:-JI r'b,oo (Davies, 2003; Sennewald, 1986
J)l.;. ~LLi ~I ;i.)~I ~ ~.)~'ii u4~1 u~f W' .~_,J.I u ~
~ u:-JI I.SJi Ill~ a.'s)k ul~ 0fi:j ..l9 ~.,.ti ull..)--'-' ui ;;µ 0A ~\1i'il DLA
c.J..9l.zi w,:JI ul::,.)}U ~L&JI ~ I 0.A ~..,JI~ ,~~I c4 .~ji.11 ull)k
u:-JI a.'s~ ~ L ~ - t~ •. . - ..L.:i--~ 'i 4-li 'il u ~ I ~
a..:,..,JL...o u· ~I ~ . ___j\ ~ I
i.:r11 t~>14 ;;_;-i:JI . , ~ ~ ~ I I ~ ~ , l.:U .~.,.ti ull..>--'-' t~~
I~ ~ J .a.s~4 u:-JI i.b..iy ~I ull~I r~ ~~J a:;~IJ 4WI ~ I
,a.! 4.!to iitl a :;~IJ . :u4 ~~ [~~ ~IJ-A (,) ~ 4tJI ~1~ ~I 0fi:j ~_,,_ ,~.lfll
~.,.ti ull..J-'-C' a..ul.J.JJ 4WI u4)~.tl .Jlbl ~ u:-JI ~.)_p ~.:UI .JJ.J.11 ~J (Y)
y~iJ ~.,.t.1 i.S.JJ u:-JI a.s)k Jol+i.;I a.!a§ r.# u:-JI [~~ _;i ,;.,..,.; , ,I('"')
. ~ I I~ o-4 ~ u ~ u.c~I (t )J ~_,J.I ull...>-'-"-! ~ I
auLot,; c.Jt y,la U:J't ~

a.ubl - J'·~
-· ·- uw~ t< :._"': ~,1 ~ I a!WI» ti u:-JI
.-.:q a\.o?:A ~ '-r - c.::r~ f'~~
· :.
~ ~.)~i ~ ~ J .(Rousseau et al.1998: p.395) «~I ~.,L.u Ji ~ljl!
-l~;;~ulA~I u:-JI t::'b,oo~l~ ,(Deutsch, 1998) -LA~ ~ o - 4 ~t
~ C:JI) ;;~ ~~ u:-JI r'~ ~_;I W' .a.!4.!loiitl ~WJ4 ~_p,J.I ~~
~b~~) u~_,l.uJl..9 (~4.!t;, iitl ~ 'i_,-JIJ ~.,JI ~L.:::,..,.J~) ~.)~I u~~'il i.S~
J;...JJ~) ~ I i.S~ ~ a.!1.!; ,~,;11 u-":!:Ul.l i.:r11 (a.! 4.!t;, iiJI d.l.bly.lJ ~.,JI
i~ .(Lewicki, Tomlinson, and Gillespie, 2006 ~I cll~ ~IJ,1) ,(~4.J~IJ
~l·~t\ t .... ~
. .:r:w ~ <..r- - - t'J-'
\ ~ l• ~ ~ ' i L l "WILll-t\
~ - '.j,J • 'J-' ~ -
- . : . L ~ J..-J.l
r'
~ ~~ d...a.J_)o u:-JI r..L-.4i (Arrow, 1973; Parkhe, 1998) ~ I ~Lo:&JI
.Jo.ii. ~,1 I.
.'J-'"' ~ J
A • • "':
a.!4.!to ;;11 a :;~,,~~I uLA.)~J ~.)J->=LA[~~~~11~ ~~_,,_

uWI Jol+i.)'ii ~ ~ ~ i 0--4 (Mayer, Davis, and Schoorman, 1995)
u:-JI ~~I a....ui.o- - ~L~I [ ~·~ - ~,1 ~~
· ·d :t~.q ull!.>-'-"J u:-JI U'::'
. ~..,... · .,.)~J
¥l:'JI i.S1>JI 0A ...u->4:1 ~ - J a:;~IJ 4tJI ~tu.JI ~J L&J ~LuJI J.ol_,_.JI ~
-
.?~I ~_;Jo.JI~ ~ I .J...:i , ~ I D ~ ~ J .ll.J.11 D~~ ~~ - " D.).,_b:i.J.l..9
~ . =-~ ...,-~..~~....... ~ -~....-t':IL":.~...,,,...,,,,,..:,,:JOC'.~~=,.,___..,
~~ 4.Las ~ ($.'..Lll l..o.9 Q ~ ljU : u ~ I c;,S J~~ ~~I \ t"\
~.,.tt uli>"' ~ ~IJ.9.l
[~'"'W=c-::x,~~;:_~~~;:3;:.t:'.li":.C"m~~ZJ;.Uc""~~n['~~:ii"Zi-:,~m:~:~"!l-~mlt."CZ',3V&m
.. :., • fl
4.J. <..9Yr .. j 1-u\:i
a..JA .. ~ tfUStOr D~• .. :.1 • t\ propensity ~ •. ~ j · ·· (' -": ~
c..,---, ~ ,.>J J c..>-- ...
~a;~,, a.c.j.i.JI r~ Loi . trustworthiness a;~,, ~i wfi.: wi ~ trustee
uJ.>=
• ..l>. · · ~I ~ ~~I~.. ~ .:.UI .J I.J.41.1 ~.. ~
. f-8-'·j u~ ... ~ .... ~ t.;r'~ti
~4:,JI y_;~I r.J..aJ wi ~ '<.>F"i J..csl~ ~ 0-4J .(Rotter, 1967) ~4
t~/JI ~ ~l ~.J...1.:' ~I I.JA ~ ~ uL.ljtll lLlt SJ. o..u:.l:g oJ_;Lt,ll
. ~ I ILlt ~ - ~~ ~· cl.J• <.,9.j--J..,....
- :..• q 1. 4 •
~ (>A
a;~u ~~,
-
,~
.. A u..,.-.
• .• <-:
~
-:tt
'"')o...La.11 c..:r--
~ '.)
,... ~.:.ti,;.~.!'-
~
-<-:.o
~ '-='J-'---'-',IA ~ ~ & ~
· ..:.l·'lu~-='--:.~
.~ - ~
~J~I ¥.J-'1 ~i) benevolence ~I'-:-'>- ~J ( ~ JLhj ~ ~Lull
-:.1.f\.l'..1.Ja..J
&~ '-='
- .. t:-:t'}[\.d)integrity4.....Al::t\
~~r'J-W '-? 1.... ,o • - :.l·t\oL..,.:i
'J-"" r..:r--J ~~~ .
J.,:;.,.tl ~ 0-4 «aJl...wl .;~I» ~ oJ.J..LLA . ; ~ ~ olj.i.JI ~ ~ .(o~
¥ ~ ~.:.UI ~.,JI~ .(Mayer, Davis, and Schoorman, 1995, p. 719) cl.....:>
(Greenberg, 1990, 1993, 2002; ~ 4 ~.,.ti ul:g.J-U'-:' aJl...wl a:e)L:. a.ul_;J
Greenberg and Scott, 1996; Greenberg and Tomlinson, 2004; Tomlinson
~ ~Lu, ~ I M f1 J ~ I I.JA ~ .:L..,jj '}fl and Greenberg, 2005, 2007)
a;~1t Jjl.,JI ~_;.:, a.h-1-"=' ~I _;\J.a.A J ~ ,J~ ~i ~J ·[~J-4lll <.S.»-i ~I.?.
~>'' ~ ¥>'' oJ~ ~I .;IJ.a.A wi ~i ,d.! J.,:;.,.t1 ~i ~~~,Jo~
.. :.. • - " 4-4..l.41.I .)-J
• 4.J• <.9Y~ :.tJI a..LUJ
....
~J-'I ~i ,~I wi ~ (Mayer and his colleagues, 1995) ~~.JJ ..>:Lo ~.J
o_rbWI rLoJ .:G..i ~ ~ I <.?.,WI ~I~ alcaai~ ,__,jtJI ~~ ~J-'I ~
·(<<~>WI ~o_rb~I))~ ~~~~.J4S~ Ls:J1 IJ.)U.i ~I ~J) a ~l.;JI
~! ~b.J. IJ ~J-'I ~ , ~.,.t I u\:g..>--'-" J.J->- ~WI J ~ 1..:-'--'-"W.1 <.JAJ
_;~ ul:g>WI ~ o_rbWI ~ ~ I .>;Pb wi ~ .~)WI ~ o_rbWI wl~
u'}[~I»~! o.;,1,WI ~ ¥~LJ:L4~J~ ~_,:al o_rbWI ~.J...1.:'
«d..! J.,:;.,.tl c-4 ~>WI~ <?11 ul-A~'}[I J\.hj [.JL;. ~ ~ I J '"':-'--'-"~I
~1 uLij)-411 o ~ ~~µ .(Mayer, Davis, and Schoorman, 1995, p. 726)
~ ·~ I··-1.0-'-~.d·
I,.:, ~
·--'}f,.!-:~1·t._A
~
'~I:··
u r..::,-i_:,-IJ ~~)L,
.)'!~
.. - ~.) -
-
~.J...1.:t.?-i J.)-9~J:i:wi J~~ ,L;,l:i .o_rbWl~o4,JI ~ ~ ~ J - ' I
.. - - ..
. o_rbWI w-4 ~le. ~.)J ~..?.Y ~l_;J'j I~ o.;,1,WI ~ Jgi ~ cLlSJJ 0 ~
~~~ ,~rt ~~l ~~ ,;.IJ--'-" ,o_rbWI a~~ J~'}[4J J>:P""t
~..,.ti 0-4J ·d.! J.,:;.,.tl ~ rJWI ~Ll:ill -b l ~ I ~4 ~~I~
~
aLd.~Jo.j'}[I
~!.,Jl~I
. (Tomlinson and Mayer, 2009) u ~ I ~~ i~ ul_,b.;JI "~ pb:i ui

~.t!.:tlu1'-(P."~ ~IJaL:i
• ~
I.~
A-
. . . . c.)
.. ·~~ ,l~~I [ ~~c.:r-
·~I ~ · 1... J~~L.~
.~_,.I.I ull~ y~t u~ ~WI
s~,_Jt uli->"' J~...,.w ulf.?.J

. :. Li
c.).j-'>- • ~ ~ _ )
.At.:.. ..Li 1<':.. . . . . -:ti ;; ..~.-::q~·'lull
~ J-4-U ~ J '..r----" .. :r '..)-'-'J
~Ju:;~
... J
µ l u ~ J ' <,~i,oi~..J .4i_;.A~lo~a........ulJ..u~~u~0-4 ·
~ u~~'il_, ~~I ~.,::JI ~1 ~_,.I.I ull.J---4"" y~iJ ~ ~ d~li.JI
(Greenberg, 1997a; Gross-Schaefer ~~~I u~.,::JIJ ":!Jyi.11 u~.,::JI
et al. 2000; Kidder, 2005; Niehoff and Paul, 2000, 2009a; Tomlinson and
. Greenberg, 2005, 2007)
aJL.ua.A lfji ~ ~_,.1.1 ull.J---4"" ~1 security orientation '?"'4~' ~~, ~

ui uJJ <.ill~ 1 ~ ui ~\k:u.u4 ui u J ~ LA~ Jl_;g~, ~ 0-4 <Y°~1 <Y°~1
.(Greenberg, 1997a; Tomlinson and Greenberg, 2005, 2007) -l>i ~8 ,; .~,;<.?
• I .1-:-:tl I... ~~I · 4->ll·'I ~\ · ~ I<'_:._, ol.i...u.J, r.:UI c:\.:,...-:tl I~ ~('
( > A ~ c.:r-~ (>A .. ~ ~~J~ ... ~ -~ ~.):
ull~ I ~LluS'I uwl<Aljj..Li<i'3I ~_,l~IJul~ I.?.?JI J ~ 0-4~_,.I.I ull~
u~~J¥1..,-llul_HAlS'Ju4~1~1->-1,~J.Zll~~IJl:J.l~~~J
.security clearance policies (Sennewald, 1996) (i)~~I ~l->-1,1 ul~l.?.u
.... L .
l,j,l~~~r
.d :t~.q ull'..)-'-'J(>A~
. 1.1-:-:tt Lllti
..
~ I .. \ ,... 1...J·' . -~II~,,..
.. ... fJ-'-'-"~c.:r- - ~ ~~
..
~ -~-.,1 J ~.. LA~J ,;(g.'..r-'""'"'
···'1 aJj b i.:r>- .. (>A
· ~
.. · ':r
I~· ~ ~ (>A · ~I·j---J~ · ..
.~ .. b ~ ~,, .1,.. ~.'..>--'
--:tt;;~ ,-o::-
· · .<' u~~I ~l..i.A c..>~
• ~ ;(g.~
-··'I l,j,l.J-6=
.... t_ ~ •
ui ,.;~ individual differences orientation ~J~I uLl~ 'ii ~jj LAi

Jl:J.I ~ ~ .~I y ~ l 0-4 uJl.J-1-'1: ~.:UI ~ ~~ b ~ l ~l..i.A
~ ~..Li ~ l...-4 ul..r4~\ _,t ulb~ ~ <.>"JW _,i tl..Gdl ~ ~..u ~.:UI
. (Greenberg, 1997a; Tomlinson and Greenberg, 2005, 2007) ;(g~\ ul~l~l
~~ ~ · a...,d.~I u ~ I ~
··'-~ '- i LJ-4 ·· ~~J ~·~'I~~
~ L~ .. ".ill.:U ~
dl<.J • ..
. J.,~I r-Ull ~ ~JA I ~ ui 0-4 ~ ljl~ ui ~ I <Y°~~ u ~

~I ~LA~IJ olj..iJI ulJ~'i __v.<:J.1 r-lJ;.; rc,'il ~ ~~I ~JWI "~ ,bl cc,i
.(Buss, 1993) u ~ I ~l..r4J (Sackett, 1994) ~j£l1 ~
.,~--..~~-l':rl.-~~-~--·-~---~---
W'~"'ll.f.:tl"~.......~ . · . = s r ~ - r . " ; L " - ~ ' : : - . . , - - - l W ' ~ ~ ~ . . , c i . ~ = c : a . , u.....
~~ ~ ~ c,i~l lAJ ~~ l~U :u~l~.:il.w.4l1J4.4.J~I \tA

~,11 uli-'""" ~ &1.4itl.JJ->
1:.::.·.•;.,?::ml:11\·e··,. ·,,zci.&~'.,~::::,szmTff.mT..1!:,;,"'\d&t:fu'""'.Erza:r~~..Jd~~;~~~~im:s:<mm:u
'1ll.i.A, ~ . r'I ull~

·~ !t!... · -.. t 4..>~uL
- - .IJ la.A (.)· ~l..a..&JI
• · Us.IJ l4.ll ~~
(.) ,~ --: . e.:Uk:..cl·'.:J"ti.i..:,-'\
~ - -
~r..5.:.UI social orientation~~~, ~~4~~~1~J ~a:;1..b-_;si ~J
.(G~eenberg, 1997a, 1997b; Tomlinson and Gre~nb~rg, 2005, 2007) i~j.A
4.A~.J.A Ji oJ~ ~ I ull->-'"" 0t ~l .;:. .~.; ~I ~~I~ ~Jl4.ll ".J.A ~
~ -
~! I.SJ.Li ~ I J ~ ~ ~~1 ui ~i .~~~I ~1~4 Jl~~I ~ i ~
~ .l~~4J .(Greenberg, 1997b,p.88) < ( ~ ~ ~ , ~IJ...ul <.>A a\.6 .~.;))
j,;..~I ~1 ~.lj:i <?31 ~l~I ~ Jlk~ (Blau, 1964) ~~~I J.ll.+lJI ~
~~4 ~L..c,0~ltJI rll ,~TJi W)_# ~~~1.l_;l.,.tl J~~~lk£11J
J.lWI ~ j.AlA:tll ~ u~~~I WJ ~~ ~.,.ti 0w..1: ~.l~ ~~
(Greenberg,1997a, 1997b; Greenberg and Scott, 1996; ~~~I .>::!WIJ
. (Tomlinson and Greenberg, 2005, 2007
(Greenberg and Tomlinson, 2004) ~.,JI ~~I~ a.zJI r'b·M~ ~
Jl...:J.1 ~ w,---k ~ I ) ~.,.ti i.S..W ~~I u~~ a ;\.;ti
~~I J..-..;g 0---4 ~....>:..l.4ll ~.l~J?JI ~~I ~ J (Gressey, 1953
,..1:~4 ·LJ:--'""JWI u l J ~ ~J (Litsky, Eddleston, and Kidder, 2006)
(') :4tJlu~sJl0-4~~I y~iJ~y.l~a.zJI i.S~~..>:
, l.:U .Lll -'I ~b.ll
. i_rJ . · ~
0-4 - a..JWI
.. a..o:JI r
". I~~-~.is, ~ -~. c i ~ ~
· ~14.::i-·~'L ..'\
.(Gressey, 1953 :Jl...:J.I ~ ~ ~ l ) u l l ~ l 6J..l.>J 4>-JJ~I ~
<.)A ~I~~ ·~.l~I u~sJI wr---9 uLl)b;..~4 ~~ wr---9J (Y)
4..,:»- ~ a..a:JI u-
1 ... j ~
·
-~. u..Jo.~,1 - . i..:,-JA ~
- '.r ul.Jb. .:....~.,cil J)l;. ()A
· ull'·J---'I
-
-
Jlitl ~~~I) t i ~-~ ~i fA ~.:.UI ~ ~ I ul~...u J~.,JI -
a..o:JI ...\.Li ·~~~I u~jA.34 ~ ~ ("') .(Sackett and Wanek, 1996
~ (Blau, 1964) ~ I y~lJ~y.l0::tci.l~~~4~1 i.lJ~
~ ~ I ) ~.,.ti ul:9->-'"" J ~ ~JoT~T ~_;,b ~ LJ..U-4 ~_;,b ~~ ~~
. (Litsky, Eddleston, and Kidder, 2006 :Jlitl ~
ull.J--'-"J a..a:JI ~ ul:9}\..AJI JljJLA , ~ I ~l..l:' <.>A ~yl ~J ,..ill~ ~ J
~JJ ~..l:' ~J>b..o uLl~ 0~ 0i L>-4 ~..l:' ~'"'"b "' ul4b .l~ ~.,11
~ .l~ ~4 .integrity testing d........Al_µJI J ~ I c.!.U~ <.>A'-' t;; • ,::., ,c.J:Al~I
Kramer, 1999; Lewicki,~l ,c.ill~ ~1.;-1) lAJ#J a..o:JI J~ a 4,...;. ·oll u~.l~I
~ ~~ .l.?.J u~?J 4.Aj~l i.SjJ ~~~(Tomlinson, and Gillespie, 2006
~-A!lt."~,._~('.•.~~~-'V,.,....._,...-_-;:_..:,.-.~N~..,.,,,,_..__~~~~~~~~-~' Q < . ' 1 < : . • . , . . , . : , _ . ; . . , . _ , , M ~ 1 1 . ~ ~ $ ' i i , I '
\t~ ~~ 4.La..e ~ ':F.Jll l.4.9 !!I~ ljU : u ~ l '?9 .>~~ 4.J~I

~!>ll~I
L·. ·.·-· .·... · . _ · : · ~ · : X .. ~··'.:vh ~~ - - ~ ~ - ·. ·.-··.··1.' .. ··d:»+;s:--;.::;v·;;.:, ·.·.· _,::;r.,.: .,,/·~::.:::::::<::.,::;.:.~
0 ~ I.JA..9 .a_;,IJ:.,ll ~~ ~~I o...u:.WI ~JJ ~.,.ll ull..>--'-"J a.a:..11

.~tJI ~~It~-"°
,~
•. ·:at:.
,.. .. -.tt ull!>'"'~ A.a:tJt ~
· U~t
~ I y ~ l 0,.4 ~ 0~ ~I~ ~I ~I~ ,a ii~IJ ~Ll:LJI ~ I ~1 _µ4..9
~~ 0\S' I~! I.JA) ~I~~~ )...1.44 0 ~ ul)i9 0~1~ ~.,.ll..9
~_,_, ,(Mayer et al., 1995) 0J.?-IJ.Hl..o o...u:.i ~.:.UI [~~\ ~l>-4:'J .(6..~
.y..9lul4 ~fa JS" ~ J w,k 0'511 ~ i
'f"+:! ;,t;.JA (}I ~ t ":'~i 4 a·\

a ii~IJ JAl ~i w,k ~.,.ll ~1 ~ I y ~ i ~ ,~.,.ll ull~ J~ ~
":b ~ ~>11 ~.l.l 0fi.: 0i..9 U.;----uJI ~ tl.u.4~1 ~ OJ~4 ~ d.J6. ~
a.!.;.!t;_,JI ~~Jj.ua.A ~b~ a.:,Lo~ 0~~ ~iJ ( ~ I ~ ) ~I~~ 0y.oJ
~ f1 U.;----uJI ~ w,k ~_,J.I oJ~ 0l u~GJI ~l ~ ~~ .(c1.......Alj.lll)
~.;-1.1 yl~~I [~lA,j ~ ~ ul~\1u.......ul .)_?.-J w,.o ~>11 w,k ~1 JJ..b=JI
- ,,
, ~ Lo ~~J (Greenberg, 1997a; Tomlinson and Greenberg, 2005 ~I)
.(Tomlinson, 2009b) u~WI ~ ~ 0~WJ rl->°'I ~.l.10:--,A~I o~ c.;;::,,.
....
~:r. '-·'11....J~t
!t!.Aq~ ~ . ~ ~ . -~ a.a:.Jl,• ~~I
.:.J .) ~ - u~Llo:,I
• :.~- ,J6. 1.)->
j-Jj-J
t<' <..:,--J
t ...
~~l..9 ~~~I u~jLJI ~ 0~1...ul r~ ,ul~I...P.-?JI o.JA w,.o ~yl w,k..9

• ~\..j ... ,~t;.. ••:. ~ ...U -:t.~, u • ..LJj cl..J-~ LL.ALA cl,.J_)Ll, 1 "'L.oj
~ - u-- ,er::--'J,4:1 ~ • :.) • '-"""""'= ~ ~
A
A~ • -
- (>JY- ..
,-...---- ~ a.a:..11 r...u:.ul'J-'-"rre---

.cu2.d..l:i~ :._~t-,.~l:..--)l.o·~·-·!t!.AtLU:JI
u ~.r. t ... •
<.:,--(>JY-
..ul ~ :.-
.(Litsky, Eddleston, and Kidder, 2005; Murphy, 1993) U.;----uJI ~~l
-H.:i.:,..:; ~
,15F"'i ~\..j 0-AJ .U.;----uJl..9 a.a:..11 LJ::1 a.! ,11<,JI U)WI ~11.JA~
~J~I ~.,-Jl c1..,..o->4'I ~iq.! "' ~~ 01~ 0,.4 -~_,_;.. o~I a.a:..11 & 0,.4 ~Y-..ul
a..,,_,b.,~I
... ·-~
U)WI 1.:r~t\ I.JA ~:. . ~ -
~Lb~ J)L;.. 0-4
I ,-... · a.1i
-~ \S' JI ~· t L9·w1~0-4
·
-~J~ J<J ~Lillo~ .J..>-!-4 ~l..A.A..9 .U~IJ U:JI LJ::I
... ~.,.ll c4 jAl...:JI)) ~ I y ~ i w,k 0~ ~ll ~I~ y~I ~ ~b

~ w,.o ~ 0t ~~I w,.o 0i ofo w,k i.)~I (Taylor, 1986, p.24) « ~
,_-.-~,:,;·~i:--.o:~!t-'\-..._.R._......,.~,.-;..:irvrr#fl,•1"'V.~~~...n4i.-.,._--.-..nr,.~~u,.-·-.~-~-....._-"11:,1.a,111,L,;:..~..----.v::...~r.~~..-.T;.."V'&~~~.........-..:.....,._~_..~.~"".-.,y.,.__,, •.a•
Lfj~ 4.1.aa ~ 1$~1 LAJ ~..b,j faU : u ~ l '="9 ~lw.il!., ~~t \ o•

~.,tt ul!..>-"' ~ d.aitt-"~
~m:fil:·£2.7~~~;;;.·J~;:zg~-&~-~:"{~3&:-s;;-1i:lf::·G.I~'U~~:..U:."T"'~~2uLR?-:.?~.~-~~r§:7:.zt¥~::.L.:X£it.,E£3:;L:.J.(~;iii~~n
~ iill~ ~Ll..4 ~ W'j . ~ a.!cO?: I~' ~)L:_ ~~ ~ ~_J r~4 ~~

. I ..":'\~I ,_ .~~
. iill~ '-'~ - ",,;t;. . " L -'I ~6-.w::,i -:. LA~ ' - WI ~~~ti
~~ c.;-- ~ J A '-:T ~ • ~ ~ J-:""
~~1 .(a:iLA~ ~I) ol~ 0~.J ,oi.! , ,. ~i..9 .;l:?-i ~.,.LI~ ~j.A 0~ ~.J-tl
- ~ ,J$ -
(Serva, Fuller, Jll4 a.l.l~ o~J.A ~~I l.l.;JA ~ ~I J~l ,iill~ ~1

cl-;t Jy_,ll ~.J..l: LA~ d_j~ ~J <>"b .JS'i ~ .and Mayer, 2005; Zand, 1972)
1...9~ ~~J.A 0~ 0"1 ~ d_j~ cl-;t ~I~ i~ .)o~ ~ cl-;t &J 0A 0~
,1...9UoJ.I ~~ ~J .(Das, and Teng, 1998, p. 503) «~4 I..>:~~ y_jl.u,~
o'.) L....J
. . •~'-I:,-
··t\ ~ r W Jb...'-:T
- ..~J · · -'I a.t.a.,. a..JWI
J:, ull'J-'"'-' - ~I Jc:,LJ
• '.) I~-~'
L_J..,..... I L..)A
·
.aa~tt J)4.! ~LLA '~.»- t
Dunn and Schweizer, JL....ill ~ ~) ~411 ~ c:--1-t , ~ I ~
~_,Le-JI ~l£A ~ J ...L....c..oyl..9 ~...cJI 0L:i (2005; Kruglanski, 1970
·.·: ,1111.,-A l.u..9~_,ll ~~~~I r~uLA>L:.o-o ...L...J~_,ll t..:,-k
r~ '-:?.l~ (Gross-Schaefer et al., 2000). ~.,.LI ull..>---'-" ~l.;..9 ~>11
w LllA?J4 ~ . J ~ J (Murphy, 1993) ~.,.LI ~~I ~l lL4> ~ I
r~~11...9..L....f:1 cll~.., l...91~~10--4.»-i t~ '-:?t y~.;I ..,t ~~ ~..1:
~ J ,a a.!;;.... • (Kruglanski, 1970; Litsky, Eddleston, and Kidder, 2006)
~~I ~l 0_,..;.lo.,.LI ~ ~ t.s:;I~ ~ o~~ ~1 o.;l.l?}t a.a:; r..l&. '-:?.l~ , ~
(Litsky, Eddleston, (..,,)self-fulfilling prophecy ~ I Y.J ~ 0\S' W' ~
~
rJ&. 0 ~ ~ I ~L.o ~__µ, ,-..,~!. ..w ,cl.J~ ~.J.>- l~l .and Kidder, 2006)
.~t,.1.1.., ~>110--4 ..u_j.A ~1 ~I~,~~ .l~ ~ aa~IJ r si.!'"'i
u.;~i clljS' . (Strickland, 1958) ~)WI ~ o.;,b~I 0-4 J:.J..a:ifl '~.? i o.J4-t-:t
r.··oi cc,s,~o.)o~ .:G.l ~~l~I ~1.;,b~I~ LA~ d_jj~l ~~I
• .. .. 'JI - ~ •
cl.J~ a.b~ ~ ~I~ l.;~I Jsi..9 ILU:i ~I~ \S'I.J.l! Jgi ~ J~_,ll i...91.)o"ll
.(Malhotra, 2004) aa~U jAi ~i ~ y_jl.u,~ 1...9~4
,o,
_., ~-"'""""·'Nt~'!,eo,.3~,•f"..o.._-.•.a;~~,.~---.-'.,~......1'."l.'l,1',."l'l#A',;:••!W4~2~<..#,t,&V..:1.-'",
~~c!..Ld~'i~' Lo_,o~ ,~u

.•.. \~··"l;,a,.•)l;.•,'¥ol.W',• ..·_.-,,.,.,~.._.JW,'>..l.•-'lf.._~
:ul.J:a.al~ ~~!.94.4.J~t
..V \ , . ' ~ V ~
~t,Jl~I
.. .°.>°-,·., · •- · .... ,-·. ·- -, ··. ·... ·.. ·· .- . ,. ,·.-.7C .. · ..···.Cc:;.·· C -· c . 7 ,·._<";.7"./7;7+7 ..... ·.,,.-.,.·::J
1 ~ - ~--:
t ....
~ ~
O.l~
- lJI · ~ti
- ,.... ~IS ':T"' · ---'I
~,1 U '..r---""" (..:T'..
,, ('"+!
•. .): ...1>-• ~• .l~· 1 ."'.Lljl ~
~ "
r~i 0-4 o...L.>.IJ c-'i...1>- ,a ;.!;>.11 ~ .(Christopher, 2003; Cressey, 1953)
U~J ybS' u..)-1-" .-. j4 .;.,.; ~ ~.J..4ll ~ .l.:'l.&A ~ a.l.7= 111' U_;--uJI u'}/6.. I
ulA~'}/1 "~ ~ cJljlA .(Peet, 1924) a i.!4115.;,>-i ~~iJ ~Ju~~

~ a;,o"C4..H);. ~_,JI ..H);.J ~...ul u ~ I ul ~ I I.SY-~ r-*11 ~4
0:.:UI) ~~WI~ '&·:
,u; ~I ~WI a..a:JI ~.;...u I~ ~_,J.I ull~ -
~ ~ll..,JI O ••o '.«: «11.'J (~.llA '1,l4A ~ Uj \.o:-~ "}/ u~~ ~~ f-A
C
~1 ii""':~~ u"}/~ ~ uJ---"".;WI ~..>-'3 ..1.4l ,4"L:iJ4 .(Balmer, 2009)

,, 0-4~i ~ u~ <J:.:UI '~-"4 y~.;'}/ ~~I~ ~.i>-4 ulA..1.&.o
,~..H);.
~ ~ . (Koster, 2009; Needleman, 2008; Roberts, 2009) a'.!; ,~. ull~
tJ.A ..uj.:iJ ~-"4 J..-,;g tJ.A U ~ ~..>-'3 u"}/~I 0-4 ~ I y ~ i a........a:JI

. (Abcede, 1994) ~ ll ~ l.!.LI~ 0-4 uJ..iSl~ LJ:>- a.:iL:,.;J I tJ.A owW Iy:. ~
~1 uJ~ ~ ~ I ",41 ~.;,>JI c.;r-W.4 ''U~~»~_,J.I ~ ,~I ~~J
~ J ~4 J~I Ji (Abcede, 1994) L&:iJ...1>- J~IS u ~ u\ bb'"t4 ~J
~ ~ I y ~ i ~ ~ ~.ll.,,JI l.!.lti ~ ui F'~' 0---4 . (Balmer, 2009)
~ U_;--uJI ~~,_;;~ ~ ,l.!.U~~l ~~1 .(Christopher,2003) ~-"4
~ Ji ~4 ~_,J.I ~ i ~ culd-f.b:,I Ji ~I ~1 ~ I ~L.o J.*4 ~
.(U~I ~ ~.;~ ~_,J.I ~ ~ ~ ulJ ~ ) . ~ 0-J...r4\'I
~ U_;--uJI u~ ~.J.>JI 4=-.... ,1111 ~~I~ o.l.;l~I ulA..,WI u~i .J..4l
· i ·· ... q ...1>-i ...1>-.J .~lJ. ~
ur.,............. ·-· !t~
.r ·'1 a..J.AL
- -~~~-=t-~-: -=t~tt o :. ul~~l u ~ I
¥~1~as'~luw~uji!J~~J---""~~ l~i~-::i ,11110-41. o\

~~i ~ .(Cyber-Ark,2008) a.Jb'i ~ua,JUJ~~~ I ~ 1~1
:~ lA r .,,. ·Ar~~ua,J 1..,s-..,:; 0:.:u1 ~.,.t.1 ~ c.!:.i:...1>- ..»-i
-~ua,J IJ.J.l~ lA~ a.,->-'"" uw~ i.:,1:. f41~ ~ 7 i,utl tJ.A 1. oC\ ~i -
.uw~I ~ i.:,1:. J ~ I 0-4 ~ as'~I uL.u~ u~ 1. V • ~i -
'"&'
Lll
• I .t - ,,( -
- ~ ~: ~ u ~ j (\$'.'J-""""'
f""C""".J-l l.4
~
-~-1\ • j
L)
II 1. '0 Ll,j - (..:T'.. .)
• L - " - ,,( - t. 4 t
u-- ~.J-l ~ ~ ~ A.
,- f.f:) d,...i.Q \.,;JI ~ wl..a.J'
4 - - t
- - . . . - 0.~ l L). t,• 1. A°' .)Ll, i -
-· (.>-)~
~ ~..,:; ~ as-~, a<: .~.t J.?...ul ~l.b:&.-.u4 JIJlA d.,jj ~11. n .)~i -
. (Ponemon Institute, 2009) . ~
~I c, .~· t c, ~: ,: t· re ·~. i. t i.
}c & f:; ,._ ~I
1~ ~·;( t• '\ ~ b tl ~ f ~ C)I
·1 1r;;c, ·1 ~
I~ •~ ~I r~' ~' , J ~. (.• r(; p.t ~ ~ t(; I ,('• C,
1~~ ~1·r:: i <i..7~.. {!:~:.f.
't! a::. I ·~ I - it ~· •t. I:! C· L• • [
·E
~l ~ ~
1
' C-' c- &° f C· } f-: - [: C· C.. ~ ,$.·. •.•,· ii

·• .. i. ... fil i. Et .. i;- - i
~~ .._, ·f ,tf _Ft .l(' ~r" :c f t r~r, ,E· ~~ E:~ ·~ (. ~
EC): V>.
t·· ·t·' f • 4..,. ,C· .( . ' .~ ~..- I :. fl . C· ~:.,· ''b.
't:,. ' ~' ~( _,. '-' - (; , - I - \ i,: I
I ~0 }_: .r ~~· ·f' f l· ~:. ~~
~ I I - I I I (1 I I ' 1D I • l,' I • I _c I
g . · r ~- '· b ~· i ~- ~. :-- ,.· ~ ·l! i· 1: ·t:. 8 t ~- t l rt (r I·.::.: fil

cl fe
-r.1 1f ,t: 'I: f ~ c:· ·[ ~ f: E ~ l ( E· 1, ~ f! } l l t c.. l .(i_
tl r~ [.~ ·<,..t
1
E -~
·c, ~ ~ ·<,.. ~ J: ;f ~ f 1 f'k l! ~ ~ : t }>f ,,.i.:. 1,.·
l .- u
.Flt ~~ 1 li- fj..=~d:
w , _, r .~
,, C-
Ir. I I
..
'"O :c- I I
C_,. -.. (1j
C·
\ • ~ I
A•
•l.
~~ :-1
J
-~ - tr;; ~. ·~. ~;: ~ lc t·s i~ ·1,t• ~~ -: ltt-; o~ 7 !1:. .t.~ .1..1· f ;l· . ·t!: 1~ t[
-. . I b ,. Cl.> I l; C - :
•L 1~ t ~" l f'6' t• ~.
~ r. Is' 1-. -:- ,;- ,~• "• ,t' 0 • f '.:
~ ~ t, b ~ r,: E· -.. ·,
't - ·1 · , [ -~ l r 2'" ·l ~· · ~ r rt Ii- ~
(:•\ •~ _;
(J!. !) r; :,·!·:·.:.1·.
r.- lit; ,(; I:; - J- .~ - ~ E! t, I:. p )! ' r.. w J..• .f ~ - r- ~¥ 8: lit; ~

l> .1\ C· '~.
l_ ~ ,._ ~· - ,t.' ~ i
iir '1; ' \ ·t l L~ ~ •fJ,s·. t ~, •t~ l fi ·~: f~ J'- '1IH~'-' i ~ .t r t 'f ~ ~ ~ ~ e. . :'( - ,7-· t
i;~j
~ ~ i ~ ] f." l ~ C); ·~. G.. ~ p E } ~l ~.. ,~"~; ~ r·~: ·i. g· '°6' & { ~ n 1
J:; l [•
- b> <i.. ~. p:
1 ~ ~ r: ,._ t·· I ,L r;; '-" l, ~ w
·c· g$ ~ . ~· 1 - 'C: r. (• ~ ,C· <i_ 'l. ~ 't.. 'r [, ['. ;- ~· li
• 1\ 'c, - . s- L r- V\ lit; I> l~
r.V\ P&ti"" r.--~' ·~e:e-: (i_- c=-<i_- l;.t·[, 'b~-- ee-;. C·-&'
1 1
\ ~· f:; ~· f ..! 1r. 1
i£1 - E: '>! - c· c
r:r !!- ,r:-"
i , [~ li> f ~& i· li>'- ~, ~.. •
I • • • I) . I.. I I I -;
I- r;; ~ f:: (1 • - is- ~
t .t:- rr . ~· l.. 1~1 '"''er 't~·:: ·r: ~ ~. .rr.-1 1. ~, ~ ~ i· ~ Et c ·£.'
e-: •• ~ !( y ~ t, \ 1'
t·k1
j;, 'f.1- .!<: t'.',.:.:
C>• 1,
~- t ·t - :- { l
[ c· 1:! 1 ,£• -~ ·rc~r ~~- l,. t:: ~ f~}· J?; f~ .- J ·t t t~ t &'~ ·- ~;I!
fu 't}· f--~·1.
-~ ~ c . c· c.:. ,r,: t ~~
l :£, 1 ~. t~. ~· 'i: I .r:- (r Ys:: I.:··.,
.•··
l,
~£'
~
~~ ,/)-'t. ~l .. 1. ~ c· lo } • ·f
} l . C: ~ :. "~ ~ toe! ~· ~· -
.t ·. tl,· ·t-;
·~ )!. ~ : Ii ,
l c
,i;: f;
r.t- ·~r Ci;-[,. 'tt· ~t sr i ~'.
- ~ J:. """A :,•
:. ~[ tY· ;e.·t ~r:- ~; ~'r;; ir ~~
V> lo - :::: c.. I:; Ii\ - .,
·t- .r:- - - l, g- ' ~- - -~ ·~. ~ ..r:-~. -l.= V>~
~!.,Jl~I
,·.:·.-:.~-7if.=~-T~R~~=:'.,,·, . . :··,~::···::~
ox-~~~..-~~~.n&.»---~~~Tm~~~~ - - · - ~
~~A.Las~ <i.:ill LoJ ~~ ,~u : u ~ I ~ J~!J 44.J~I , ot

~.Jl t uli..,-., ~ 'U.ill ...1.9~
P~~;..·,:-···-~ .....?, . . .-~~~·~t;& ~ , . · ~ t ; - : · . ·:-··:.c :;;;/·Y·••Y&~~~-....:_..:,~~¥"~.t?":i: ·.·:·<.;::·~~~:=:~~~.- --:. . · -:-z:·~J--::~·-~.:::~·;.:..;·:,;···.~~;...::~:f,:<.)£:-~-.:.~=-7-~
.).¥!'"J l>4 ~ "i i.ill~ 0 i ~ . a:;~ ll JA l ~ ~.:U I ulo.,11 L!.L.J ~ •t;. =-~ 0 i 0J.)
c.;rl! ~.)~ Le.A ulo_,J.I iill~ ¥ ~ 0i C::Jbi '".! "i ~.:UIJ wlAfa.l.l rl..lo:, ~ ;;~
Davis~.)JMayer ..HLA [~~ ~J . a ~ wfa. wlAfa.l.l ~~~I
o_fa\..;J.l l>4 ~ I ~i l>4 ww~I ~J 0h "ii~ Schoorman 0LAJ~J
•ulo.,11 iill~ ~ ~ I..w w,k. 4-4>L:, .).¥!'"J Ji .)..1=t:.4 ulo.JA ~ ~ I IJ.L1 I w,k. ~ Ll:t r
w,k. .)~"ii r~ 4.Ab.ll ~I~ 0 i ~ ;;~¥->1:> o_fa~ .)..P.'"J ~ ~J
;;~w ..1:?-J ~Jbl ~.JA .)..P.""fiofal.;J.4 ~ J I ~ ~~I~ U>..b,.j ~ I
4.:co~ uLA~ ~~ uw~ ;;~tg .)..P.'"J Jb. ~ ,J\ill ~ w,k. .wLA.,W.I
·~~ ~~ ~ 0 ~~ r~ 0i ~ ~IJ ~.,11 ~"iT ~
,J..att ~1.wa ~~,..it-. aA,
oJbl ~ ~LiS'i I.JAblA a.......zll jAi ~ j w,k. ~ I y ~ i c.,:rll 0 ~ . , l l ~
~Lal 4:~I ~ ..i9 ~IJ ,a qt;.,;ll ~bl:, ..bLfiJ"il wl~ ~l~I ~
~ ) ~.,11 w4"~ rW-A"ilJ 4:lall J~!J (oJ~I) ~ I .)JI.JAJ wl~...u.
:..,. ,
~j,J er- . ~ j~ I(":. . • (01-:.~t1)
'J"*'
~
-
I· . _'\,'+'
J-:1?'- ~ .·.~ ~ti \-=-
-- '-?"'"' -·~'I ~· j j (·
~
..:.._q
Le.A ~ I ~ ~ ~ UUo.11 ~.,11 ~ ~ ~4 ~~I <).C, wL:. 4Jo.j"ii "L-4>
~A·L~I.
- ,_,....
i.:. LJI .
U ~ . ~L..;-
.~, ~ . ~ ~~tu~ - ti" ...lJ,t".).,
L__JJ,Jc.,-'~ '.)j • ~ ~
.(Murphy; 1993; Niehoff and Paul, 2000) ~J.l U~I u~~ ~.>3
~"iJAJ~0i~_;J.ll>40~~1y~i~;;~l~0~.,llF.lA~
~ -
J:'Ul.l ~ ~ J:i~ 0i ~ ~.;JI ~J.10~ 0iJ ~..,.kJI 0:! ~~ 0~.,11
. (Davies, 2003; Serva et al., 2005; Zand, 1972) ~~..,JI l>4 ...u_j..q.l.J ~~ w
Ponemon Institute 0~~ ~ "l..r?"i ~.:UI ~I~ ~~I ww~ o.)~4J
1~1 lA ~J.=t::AJ f"'~I jAWI 0i ~ 0..1:?-ylJ a.::- ,~.ti d..:P~)'I ~ I 0~ ..w
~ . "i ri ~j.j~JAr&iqJ;.,ioc.;rll ~~0.i9~0~LuJI 0~.,ll 0~
ol_).j <).C, ~~1 ~ ~.JJ ~~ lA~ l.,s~ ~i ~ ~.1.:-?i11,ll l>41.,r ~~
,,
. (Ponemon Institute, 2009) ~~ ":.J.l c:,~ I~~ ~.:UI ~ I ~ b
. ~ .... t1._'\d...u:, .~("j• ·,A(" •... , •. ,·-lt '--tl~~i• "• .. ! t ! . A ' I ~ . -~
'..r-"'-' ~ • 'JJ-"- uJ-J~ ~ ~ . ~ ~r <.>°_;.a., J
~¥.;JI oJl:i! c.;rll ~I~~ J;g l>4 ~I L!l~"i J~.).¥!'"J ~.)~ ..i9, ~..1=t::A.l4J
.(Litsky, Eddleston, and Kidder, 2006) ~l~"il L!l_,1.uJI ~1 ~~4 rl.Z:,"il
\00
~~ .oJ..14ll ~ u~~~4 J,>J <.j.:.UI ~ I JA a.t:JI ~ ~ u~ .Jl_,
~.,_c~ w ~,~~~~?JI~ OJb?JI OJ~ ~;ll u~l r~ ,JLJJ.I
~~~~1Jt:.~«ff.41.Jli~~_i!.,J4»~~w~~~~
~ I y:,,-b y:,,- ~ ~...Gl.l t.~~I ~~ ..WJ . (Ponemon Institute, 2009)
r~~, ~1 (~_.,J.I J ~ I d.bL..JI
~.J+., r'~' ~~ ,J\:J.1 ~ ~) ~
ufi:3 .Jl ,c.ill~ c..,--11 ~~1 .(Greenberg and Scott, 1996) ul:9..)---'-U oJ ~ ~
~I~ ~)G..t ~ ~~ J ~ ~ 4.4~ ~...Gl.l 4.41tµ)I ~ ul...c.~~I
~l~)G.~l~~l~al~.l_?.J~~~1~1~,~~i~
-
4-;t r4l:s ~fi~ ~ .(IOMA, 2002) ~_.,J.I ~...u al~I o.l~J - IF-JA ~..1>
~I ~Jbl ~ (.)jOO\:~;ll o--4~ 1.t.C\ 0i Watson WyattU:IJ u~IJ
~~I ~~~1.,:u ~fa.0~~0-J...>::J.l.lJ4S° 0~ u.,_lAJ:~ :t.oo 0 t_,
. (Watson Wyatt, 2007)
u'-4~ ~UA ,~~ a;~1t ~ I yb:..w,l ~ i ~ ~..,.LI u~~I ~~J
~ WI 1.... c.:.uA9 .Jl o··.<'ti LJUI i:.~I ~ I · i ,. . J...L..J
.(4 (.)-" ~~I
'~ ~ - ~ .) (.)~
oA 1.1 Y ui i~ Y • ~ ..,1~~1 ~ ~ ~J ...l4l .4.4~ ~ ~~ ~_,J.I
~~_,JI~ 0~ ~ a_jJL4A 0'511 ~~_>1u ~ Jgi ~ ~...u 0~ um ~7=i«,tl
Business Week ~~~I J'-4.c. ~I~ Jli4 ~J • (Edelman, 2009) c_i,L..u r~
J~I pi~~~ <.j.:.UI ~ti.JI ~I~ "'~u'511 ~ ~ <.jl ~ ~ JA,, ul~
:0~ Enron u~l ~~
I(' .'-.-: I ~L- lA.A J~ \JI Jb . 4\ \ · .r..< o a.~ \..1:,,.• ~ ~' ~ l.!Jl.....iA
c.,--ww ~ • I . : ~ ~J,Aj
~,..,.i,
Jui J..,~ ... Lz\S'..,..!, ~~ ct..d)1_µ11.., ~Li\11 u~ Lzl..14iLl a.o~
J\.bj ~ .l~I JA I.J.A ul ~ ;;..1:,,.IJ ;;~ as'~ J~I ~UI ~J~I o.J.A
. (Nussbaum, 2002, p. 30) ~,..,
LA~ c.ill~J ~ upb .Jl ~I _pu .ll_~~I oA ~ ac.;:, 0~ I~~~ .Jl

. -~~_.,J.1
~ .. ~i.5...
~..>J~(.) .. ~ I ·<)AJ . ..1>1JJ lb} ~i.L.U~JS
,., • t -~i - ~·. -
.Jl o~I L.a:&JI 01 ~ U>la.JI ~ l..-,j_,~ ~I _.,.lot;J.I ~ ~ I ~ b
-1_;1_~J -l.;l_.>-4 ~_.,J. I ul:9 - -
.)-J-1' ul:!·P t c.::-i.A..H .J.4l . al~I v".>-9 ~ ~ ~_,~
' -
J . ? . ) U ~ J A ~ ~ ~ ~ w o ~ ~.....,,oluL-~~lu ' t r~~J
-- ~
~..i:J ~_JAJ a /~I ~WI oA r~ ((t_l..L..>.ll ~t ~ 41~ ~1 J ~ ~
- ~
~ b ~ ~WI a.t:JI ..,_,.;:; ..L....lJ .(Ditton, 1977; Mars, 1973) J.?.~I ~~
,o,
~.,S.t uli>"' ~ 'CU:'Jt.»~
I -:U.- :"-.f··.: . ::_.:=•..=:· . . s.~:··t §4-·=~--~·. J.~# ht.fr g.......J . ·.: y::-.:.···--'"::':h:'. --~·:-···: :,··.=·· =--.~·-c·-,e1i,h -~?'· ;, .l!i\~"¢ : "......ya.~ ~>.f;.·:·. . :..:,·-...·#
.rY 1· '• -,:':-7'.'"cy."~~..:':"''."'".•~7':...~··1atr:Dd'--·<'1.-:,.>- A,;_h·=: -.$.hJ
~J ·«ti~»~~, <JJ.l (JAIJ,Ltll ~ d.L.oU.o >-°i .;,k~ J~ ~1 ulo_,.t.l JA.A.11

LA ulo-"4 ~ .a ,a.JL~.H ".lA ~ . ¥ ~I ->-1,~4 ;;_;.k~I ".lA ~ _;;t,jj ..1-..9
"'= ,r.:.UI ~
W- '-.:. L-tl ~L.o 0A
· c..:,J:>o
- ~ -~('f ~
-
I.; u· L. ,Jul.I ~
'-· ··· ~
I,.., 1°4j;;.L~
(.)-' ~ . •
- ,,c.!lli.A wfi: LA~,~

<)A L..!J~ - -~WI ~.l~':ill yl~':ill o~ J)l;.. I~ -
.3.:\:aicceQ \ : ; ~ ~ ~J o.JS'j.A..H):. ~ ' ~~,~':ill ".lA .~.,.ti~~
I~ az14 w~~, w~.,.t.1 ~ wf ~ ' <JA '<->F""i oJlJ Jb. ~i ~ J

~ w~ ~':il~I i.!J\.1.4) wi ¥ J~ ':il i.S.:.UI ~_,JI ~J .Jb. i.Si ~ ,U~I ~
~' ~ ~L:t ~~i ~.:.u, ~' y>-b "4,.:i~ '~~<)~.,.ti ~':ilJA
- - ,, -
".lA t~.) I.SJ.A.)~ ':ill~ c.J:~T ~t&. ~IJ,j wfi:J 0 i ~ ,~..uA ~.)~ ~
. (Tomlinson and Mayer, 2009) ~ ,
,4:!.).....:Jt ull~ ~ t ~ t ~~ ~bJt f':! ..14,;tt

[~J y~lJ ~ 0 ~ ~.;l-~IJ ~WI ~l~l&..l':ill 1).4 ~..wl JI;~
.(Tomlinson, 2009a) ~~a.:...L:J.I ~l..1.:!,11 a..!.l~I (.!.!;;;~l<JAw~~.,.t.l ~tg>""
3a.:s.l~~~I.Rl~.,.t.l~tg>""J~l~U)Wl 0 ~;;.l..U:Ul~l~ull~~
~ I ol-¥1 <)A ~_;JI ~J .~l~l&..l':ill db ~ j j J i ~ Ji ~...u ~lJ~l ~..LZJ
a;;~IJ ~~4 ~.J.>JI <~>meta-analyses ~ I ~~I~~ ,~I ~':il
.(Berry, Ones, and Sackett, 2007; Lau,Au, amd Ho, 2003) a......z.lJ ~~I Ji
~·~ !t~.,1., ~I · U)WI
r. O::' FJJ· - o'..>~ :. • ;;..1:,,.IJ ~- · --
a..J.J.:...:i L.ul.J.l i.!J\.1.4) ~
0 f ~J ~ (Colquitt, Scott, and Lepine, 2007) a.::'
c.!J\.1.4)
. ,,
,cell ~~~IJ
,,
~~~I ,-,l4j ,~., ~ J rr-~.)~ acorrected corre1at1on ~.... coi LbAiJ I
~~ ps'l ~~ Ji y~IJ F"bllS JAi_~ ~ ~L.ul.J...ul 1).4 ~ ~ ~ I

LI.J.l~~J ~ - ~ ~ I ~J~~.,.t.l ~tg..>--'-" ~~~JL..!l~)U
~ ~~-\J. ~1 i.!l.,kJI ~ ~.,.t.1 ~Lc.~1 0 t w~lJJ ~.,.JJ ~.) ~ ru
-
.r.J.JI)
~ J Y! -
qeloiill~I
~
)\JLLA -... ~.A ~
7 ·-)l.Alc.c.:....u.J~.·
~.?. L~ - - v_~.)-I.A4 -
0
- - -
.ll_;s~I ~ ~~l~)U ~.?. ~ )Gk. ~lS Ls,ji ~_;JI~ (U~I ~
~lc.4,bjl ~ LA ~tg)Wl ..,_t;..lll ~ •(Dineen, Lewicki and Tomlinson, 2006)
l.A.l.?.J a.:\:ai11,Q ~~ ,-,:~i ~.)~~.,.ti ~tg..>--'-"J ~IJ ~4 ~~I~
. (Tomlinson, 2009a) ~.,.ti utg>""J olj.tll .Jl;o-1 ~ U)WI l.!.U~ <JA ~ _ J
<JA wl ,(Gressey, 1953) ~...u <i'11 ~.,JI aLl~I jAt:i ~J l.!.U;') 1).4 ~->-11 ~J
\OV
~(Greenberg and Tomlinson, 2004) a.:'.:l~I Lb...,.I.I~ r..i.ZJI ~4U ~ I
-c.S..L4 c.jl ~L, ~_,.I.I ~ll...>-"":l ~.>3 ~ ~I ~lS' lA 1~1 .J:~ ~i c.JA cll~_,
.. ...
'" d..c uLa..c..· h;
~I W::' ~ll~I .;.: ,ceai1 ao.:9-lJ ~ ~~_,b ¥ ~~ c.j~I ~_,JI~
~,.)~~ ~ ~>1 .:l,.:lll .,.J.A ~ i 01 J_,.;.tl ).;--SJ~ ,~.,11 ~llJ-'-"J
,-,qs ,ul ~ J ~ I ~~-li ~J~~4J.J~~I ~ I.J.A ~t ~J .~1..1:,11
~I.J~~I ~.;-cl L-9-"'"" 'c.>.J>~I ~~l::_d.l ~ ai.:a~11 a._;g\:JI c.Sl>-11 ~~w~l .,.J.A
.'"7:Jll~I ~ jAL.:JI ~ 0-J->:...L4l.1 ~WI ~ I o..:il,g! ~ ~bll
iallA~t f'lvi! ....a:i J,J_,.b ~ UiU' ~~t fl:! ..141.tt

u~ u~ cl-! J~.,.tl ~~ ·'' q.:.:;;_, ~~ ~~ ~, )i9 ..:i~ ,JI ;2 w-
~.JA ~ u~~ "1 ~~1 0~- ~, ~~Lo~~., c.JA ~-1.! - ~4 -,~~
~_,l I ~ ll..>-"" J_p, ~ I I.J.A j.S'.): ,J l::_d. I I.J.A ~ •'=' IO?: ~. JI c.S~ I c.:,k
~ J ~_,.I.I ~l_).j f .:.:oi.i ~\,;. ~~ rWA~I 0--->.J:..UI c.:,k ~ ~t ~
~~I u- t4 f ~Lo. '..J 1..b-• J-"-
-~('~I u~
· · :.t.:....q •i~
• .(' · u
r u..,-; . . _Ll ~~tt a\.o,-,t I.~
_ 1"'&"" ~J . ~
· .~tt
~lj.,Jl '"7:JIJ~I a. . .-:lld o..:i_?._,ll ~ I '"7:J4..l~I ~JJ .Jb.. c.jl ~ c l ! ~
(Tomlinson, 2009a) u~~ ~i ~->-1,1 c.JA ~~I ~~..,.U 6:4.JZLI ~
\OA
~.,tt ul!>"" ~ 'Ulll .JJ~
in~"~::U'mP..:Er&::"""-rn~:r:1~m -,,--,-A,'1:i2.fil--il?f1?Zill'::L~~,,p;s,;7.;,_~~wr..:;z;;,·,.,;r:w-af»¥11
a..t:JI f' ~ ~ ; ;'.J l:il uJ . 'ii "~ ~

· .l ul.) L:&;.. - l:s.~t_ ~Ll.A u· i l.:r'tl ~i- ..)-:!:---'-'I-
:.-J
I.S..>->-~I ;;.)l...:i.:tJ.I ul.)~'il LAi .(Tomlinson and Greenberg, Y· ·Y LJ.)Li)
~
.:UI ~.t\ ~ ~
. .J\ .~.tt ~
..1.ZJI 01·· - • .<-: ..w uw.t;JI
r
1.>J - .. ~~t ~Ll..4 w.,.-. .. ~I·-<.~ ,-=-- .
~)U .l~I U)WI J.o~ ~~ wlA.).,_.1uJJ..i:bJ..>:lA[~.J4>~~1 ~ ~~
JWI ~ ct........&..ul;e ~ 'i ~.:UIJ (Mayer and Davis, Schoorman, 1995) ~4
~ r'-4:lA 'ii ~ ~,~ ~LlA 0fi.: ..ll ~J ,~..,.i, ~
~
r~' J ~ ~ 'il
~~'ii ~ ' ul~ u~.,kJ4 .:t..J ~ ~ a.!;.!t;.,.U r..JZil ~..\.4i ~.).l ~J
l.!il.JS'J ol__µJI ~.!.! ;;; ~i ~ I 0--4 0fi.: ...L.lJ • (Brief and Motowidlo,1986)
.(Murphy, 1993 Jul.I~ ~ ~ I ) ~y.11 ul:9~ J ~ ~ I ~
,·. . ~t:.. ...... tt2.At··

~,.... !.JJ.J...r--- . ~ ..u
.:-.tt~ &
~ I ~~~6.:i~~~~J~I ~ I y~i ~~
d..i.b1_,.1.1 J.? ~ ' u~.l)U ~~, ~ ~JJ .~_,.1.1 LJ:;I ~ J olJ.ltlJ
~ ~ a_;sl:tll 1.SJJ.ll 0-4 ...u.J.A ~ J ~ I ~i 0-4 (Organ, 1998) a.!ci.!Joiill
c....c.J ..all ·i6·-·'lu-At!..L~1~:tL -='-~·~ . '--tl~L..o"b:i~·-tt .. .:._q
.~ L) ~ ~ '..}-'-'.~ -~ 0 - - . . ~~
(Izzo, Langford, and ~..,JI .)J.>A c4 ~~ ~I ~.J-&,ll .).,k:'JI Ji.A: J ~ ~I~

I.S-li ,..L#l:J4 . Vitell, 2006; Loe and Weeks, 2002; Penn and Collier, 1985)
~1 ~LI~ ..b-ls° ~}t;.. ~I ~..J..all ~ ~.:UIJ J}t;.. ~I~ J.o~ ~LI..H ~..l4i
~ 0i ~>11 ~ (Greenberg, 2002) 4LA ulA...G.. aS'->1u ~ U~I 0-4 J:.J.Zll
~J ,Luil.)...ul ~ (-=>)~.Jy.}I a.Jl..1.C ~~I J.o't:i) a_;,~ ~.)-?.i ~\S' ~.)~I
- ~
<.)1 J}t;..~I ~LI.>:' ~.lY- .is .(~lj.al ~ I ~L..o .)~I d...J~ ~ ,J~ ~
L:&;..1 (.)· i (.;r'tl;;'.) Ll.1" ~Ll.A.., •~,~
.) •
· · \-0--
- ,,~L.l£A ~
-- ,-
... t uu
• L c..;r'>-
- ··· ~r!..." 01l_;-J
~..,... · · _J-J.J-A-1
· · ..
~ ~ J 0fi.: 0i ~ ~_,..JJ periodic integrity-testing 1.§.)J...ul ~lj.lll
o~I ulA.~'il r.,._.,J. ~ W' (Murphy, 1993) ~..,JI .)J..>A c4 J.oWI 1.L.,l
.~·- ~~
I t .. :...ti~
• <.>" ~
..
\o'\ ~~4.1.as~'-i~ILoJQ~faU :u~,~~~,.,~~t

~ : ; t " , t , J r , ; ~ ~... ~ ~ ~ , ; ; , 1 1 , • Y ~ ~ J : . ~ ~ . : . : : , , - ' . A > W ~ - · ~ Q ' T . ~ U - ~ " o " C . ~ . ~ . 1 , . . V A " . l . , ..... : , , . , ~ , t , i , 1 , . ~ ~ ~ j , 1 W l / l l , < . N ; ~ ~ - , . o ~ ~
4.J6::c........-'i1
. . J 4.Jl.i....,
.. . a.zJL. ~ 'Y"'I a.J.Ai
- - .. ~,.
• '..rt ul~
L.:. j\.,;ul •.1....ollJL• 0---1~
. ..u.1
,,
A
~ o£;1j.J1 ~tg..,JI ~ .is .ul~l~?/11.!.lhl l.dJ ~Lal a.zJI i.SJi '"~ ~.:U
ul!J?/ a.;,..(j,,4 ~~ f"6:..u 0 ~ ~ ~_j,4:> ~1 ~ b ~ J_,.b:i LJA .J.>JI
~4~~ ~iJL>.~~ '~J .(Strickland, 1958) ~4( si.:\&t
~ 0Jlj:JI ~ w,-k ~~;11 ~ , LJA 01 ie~.:u ~ ~, .l_?.JJ) o ~ I
~~;II ~Lal LJA '1.>Y"'l DJ~ .(Dunn and Schweitzer, 2005) ~L!ylJ a.zJI
0t ~ I J .(Banks,2007) Jl_p,~1 ~~ ~tg..,JI LJA~l.i..oi.S~~
Jtg ~J . ~ I u~J.A ~ Job.ti ~I~ ~~I y~~ 0J-i:!~ 0--J~..Ll.l
a _ , ~ ~ ~I» 01 ~~I LJA ~tg.,.U ~j.A ~ ~~I <J,J~..Ll.l ~t
~LLA0~ ~ l J~ ~J .(Koster,2009,p.13 ~~j~1~1)«L~ ~ t
,~ 0.,-a..,.; "'.! ~.:u, ~--'1' ~ a ;11J ~ y ~ t ~LLA ~~J 1;9~t 41.J
UI ..,. - -
~j 01 ~ ~tg..,JI tl..,~l LJA tis t.it 0.J.l I.A.& ~I~~ 'i ' ~ J .J~'il
Lll
• !..>-4 ul.JT,JL...ill
.. 1.. --- 1,... .Ll.t::.tl
~~
Ll--•La..b..a:i·t\
.. ~ LJ-"" Y'-' • • '.r [ j~I ~ ~
' .:.:.~
,. . i · ·.<' i :.t:; o'.)-J.r
~ ~ ~
:.,:qJ ul.a:i~~I
.. -: : · .t_-:
~ J 4.J:.r---'
· ···'I J~'il ~-L:..._c-
~
ul.a:!~~1
..
~ .(Greenberg, 2002; Murphy, 1993; Trevino, 1986) ~>b~I ~_,L-11
Ll~l f"6: ..u ~
· .:UI ~ ~~L• ~~ ~I .... 11 ~1- ..:....q • :. ,~ I
.. ~(.;r' ~ ~~ ..
o..,.bWI .l_?._,Ji~ ~l ~~ ~IJ-4:> ~jJ ul!~ ~WI~~ c,;o..,_.:JI

. (Koster, 2009; Roberts, 2009) 4WI
iU:Jt ~.J ~~u...Jt ~~ a:i~t ut~ 4-:'ll.;tt u~

,o·L~ I --'l~b~...u'i...1..-li--:..<'~ ..:.-',,..LJlu.1:,-t\
.. ~Y- '"'='
..
,, ~ ~ . L- .. 'J":"- .. ' r c..::,----0-
I~ o~ ~_#1..,.bl.:dl 0 ~ LA~ d.JjJ ,~L!ylJ ~bl.I LJA ~~

,
r\Jo..j '-it.;.:'~'.! 'i .is ,0L.:WI I~~ . (Mayer, Davis, and Schoorman, 1995)
~ ~ I ~ b ~ ~ ~1 o.J~4 (..,.bWI LJA ~I~~) ~tg_;lJ
- - -
0t ~..,JI~) ¥.#1 ..,.bWI ~ \;91J ~J.l d.lo~ ~ .is ~ J .~_jll
~.:UI ~_jll ~ 0 ~ .is .(o.j.i>: 'i .is _,t ~ I " ~ o.j.i>: .Jl ~_jll
~ 0J.ll:w ( ulA.,_i.J_jlS:11_, ~JLA.l~) ~ I y4) LJ-4 ~ ~ljsl ~~ 0 ~
a;11J L1~1 ~ ~t w,-k ~1_µ ~~, J!l ~J t"-'-"IJ Jlkj ~ ~tg..,Jt
oJb?/ ~ o~ d.lo~ ~.i>: .is ~1 ~ ':? ,o;. ,~,JI i.S~I ~ ~
~ ~tg..,Jt F• a.:i·oi~ .(Kidwell and Kidwell, 1997) cl........;!,lWl_,_....bWI
~I c,.·. ~· t;·
I f
.r:,: ~ ~f I • I
'c... l-· '°·~~· •(t- ~-~ ·~•...~ lr •~1-~ bt ft
t,. ~ ·i t' .~ . J:. .r ~ t - L C· ~ i } ~ 'b .i 1..; C· ". C... C•
f.~. ~ r-
t~ t'°·b~~ - .. ,
t t l~ rf t ~t t~ rt ~ rtr1:
c, ·~· ~ ·<t.. ~ e-: ~ ~ r ~· - ~t ~· -: ~. ;f
~ ~ ~· e.. I..;
E: ~ l, [• t - •(i:..
·t.If ~lf~ ~t:t 1i·~ ~ ~ ·t ~- t ! .? lj,' E· ~ ~\= ~f ~. ~ ~.t C·

t I ;~ I
I~
;
~ '( · , E·fl; fi en -:- - ff t· -~ 't. Pi f t \.-cf 1t. · ~ l ,i ·!;, -: 1~
£. l ~ ~ 1.
r.
'i:- :~c: ~- ~t'( -~ =r... -· ~ ~t: ~~ ~rte~ }~: - 1-~ -~[• • t- ~~ t. ·t~ ~ '°:
C>I
l te 1-· }-
~i
,lr I> (:_ - - ,. Y, I, C>f
!t t -~ ~~ F.. = '° t't!: ~I [ • I _ ...
f 1 € •f: ~ 1 tr Ix • { ~ - ~ ~ t' I
t : fl \ t'( i ~ t· 'L~ t - ~ - - e-: ·~ f: .,. ~ . &· ~ i· r r
•L 1>- ~·~ .~ ~e-· i ·~r. ~c... L i 't ~ E' J; . /l-l - U, tC A.I ,
C• 1> - •L •
:i r ~ .~ r .Ii" ~~cf ~ '(. ·~ ~>r 't '\ E; ~ 9' ~ ~ ~
·C...
1(,.. \ • I> I
~·tf~p t fi~ ,tit r • ~- .~: G...l,<t- ,f: ~.~ r-r, l-t. ~ ,f~ ~ ~ ,t' t~ ~
~ - ~ n ,s·. ~· .~ ~: .r ~ p ~';. { <;: i;:;
f , .r · .~ ~D\
fr
r~ le. [• E ~~ 1• ~f"' - L~ ~t ~I- ,:, 'i:f .c
C·
i ~ .f. 't. lcj t <c::'1r - f s s· ~ ·c;; r. i ~ .~ ~ ,t; \- '(,. ~ ·i· i .s·. V\ f - -~ ~-. r.
t
,S: r ~t ~I •L
r-
t_ J' r:;: ~ c-° ~ .f- f -~ e,-: • t - C•, (1) C> 1:- -~A.I
. ~. 1;· ~--'>
-:- . ~ l C· C>. IL .[-"
~ ~ ~ 1 ~ .. r; ~ f f:. - ~. .~
-:v~ t' [ • [•
i: f:.! t' - C 5;- J- ,. { ~· [.
[ [ l'.i:.:.:.·
I, l.n
e: s~ ,,,. ·~ _J c: f ~ [ ·t' 0\ tr
<;,. ~. C-
·~: ~- 'i. rt' '-o \ t '( f ,':
'1-t ~· ~. · f ·~ ~ i -;t ~c 1-~ ~ ---h ·
- - ,._ ' C· ' I:. I
[• EIE~· i: ~~ ~ • - - - - [1 ("{) ~ •
E F'i.· ~ l c;
s t 'i- _: ::- -
l ~ ~ -.. ~ b l ~ .f t :~•' •.; IC -; 'i: ~·\.
'\. c-
J:.. ~· - C.·
l:. I')
• C· f:.. ~ C• s 5 Ii. c;_.
r ~ J- r(i:.. - ~· [, i, I • _,. ~ C tC ~ t' V\ .E ~ ~. .~. ~
1~ ~~ t •t l~ r. ~~ -~ ~ 1s. ~ i tf~- r,- l 'l ~ '1!~ f- ~- .t
~ t' I • e.! l:: r }- r c...
~ ~ ~ ~
: i· - ·~ [, I . . ci f'li ,r .~ s i ~ '\. ~ ~'t '°· i r. .~: ~ f 't 't.
,c; v= c.. ~~ le~
j.-• C.· C· [ So .r I ,. • z.~. I ·E .~ .r
,:. I 1'P ,:.
·t- t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L - I •
~ - \ .._, -
----'° --.. -~-I') .r - - - s f;: _ _ c ·-
t ;- :r ·~ L. r 1~'t · r. t ·\. 1 t~ t.F 1~ t i f r: l f' ~ r l "[; t
cf. I • F' ,t: ~ <i.. c... ~ ~ [• r::
.r- r l ~ t ~ r- I ~! j, c::
t- ~
It• t· C-'
r- i~ r·Y\ -f. 1-°e-: i ~0 <i..!<. ·~~·
;~ !<. 1: [ ~ ~· g l ~- ~ ·~
't lc... F,' ~- ~:,r' ~- <r·~ I:. :8. Ci~f ~c,
£" ~ ·N
~. ~ C/) • r;;
[.. ~· Pf ~
1 - [,~ 1 ~
f: C)I t"' . t· t 'L ·~' s(') ge-: t.
[a st . ~ - ~: C O C... ~
Fl ~ ~ ~ ':-' ·~ ~ ~ a1 [•
(1 f-1 1-1 ~ ~: ~ § t -; r,: C)I
Ir.
~ ·~r... ,r E ~· ,r r.
"°1- ~
I I \C)
E
.- ~
t: ~ .&
I::~ ·~. ~
'!
-t ,. :. . ' . ~ [•· ·~.
I!.. -
~• Ci • ~' ~I :-'t
c.. ,l
p r' ~ r,: b [~• ~ l t,C)I C
[ . •c. .. Ir _J:.;.. ' - •
o~ it- - (,)l
I ~'I> I
-
\D
'i - . I ~J- !:: '° C 1,. l; •
r :.. ~ ·t ~ c, ... • t ~ -:· r-: ~. :r
i r;; .l-. ~- \ '.:· -
~ .. t· ·~ r1:
,c- &..
r1.· ~ ~ r.
·i,.~· ~;~ 1krt~ li-l. l ~.~ ~•r- tt·E; 1-ge-:
·i ~ ~ r.,! Ir . Pf ~ ls>· Pf ~· 1>
·~ i Co[·l)~L.t~:l
·~
~ 1.~c."e,···E'_._~ l ~ 1- ~-·'1 :·. ' _, {l
.~'rA.
f. ~ [I ~- 1-°.~ .. , ;.··:.·~
~ t' I 'I • :'
_ i.
,. , - .1 I I • P, 'i
..c '-' - "<. - L,• r> - ,t ,. ,
"'- ~E,: ~f ·f 'l· ·~r;; .r::. . r~ ·[ ~t [.t·~ i.. f t~ r~
~,ti uli_,...., ~ ~I.JJ.l
1,M.f¥¥4&tii.§~~ fr4"-SrP:%#%#~%¥· Sfr¥i~G?:~i%W·ffe&1,.fWf&iP?tf§!, #'t·f'M,'fi%bW'-it?S1£··~·o/S?-&hc~;fi;.fiff.1.~...4
1
,~..,i.tt uU»-~
c.)1 security clearance policies «~~l ~l,J-ll aL.i.ul:!-,» ~ ~ (i)
~ ct:...u ~ rJ lj} ~ alA.,W.l L>-4 J.Jl ~i ~ Ji ulo.,tl ~ ~l..>-4
c.)1 JJ>-...ul J i ~ al.A~~ t_)lb'}!4 dJ r~' Ji9 clJjJ ~ , c.;s
.~~ii9l-"4
Ji ~ ~ ~ LA..>-4l c!JJ~ c.)1 self-fulfilling prophecyf'-*4A~ (y)
~~clJjJa=i.:iWl~c.)l~pi culjc.;si9j£Jl0i~~J..>-4~1 l~ lb;..
y~c.;so..>-4JJi~l l~~ . ..)~~la~.,k,JalA4,.:il~i9j£Jl~
Social Theory and Social Structure«~~'}!l ~ ~lJ ~ ~ '}!l ~ l »
J ~ l Jlil.1 ~ .Robert Merton uji.HA a..HJJ ~.J-A~l t~'}Jl rJW
~l~ c.;s ~_,ll ul.Ajj c.;s a;~!~ rJ ,oJ~l "~ ~_;J Jl:!-, c.;s ~1
l.fl l_jl~~~l.Ajf ~ ~ ~l ciJb)'l ~L.ui •.·: '"!aJ.H ~J..>-4~l
- - .clJj ~ Ji f'~'}!l ~~ -l=,.'}l
~ J..wl ~ 4J_µl «distributivejustice»t-t.Jj£Jl a.JI~ r'b·oQ ~ (a)
-~J~4~,~~t
J.t--...u~I ~ l c!J~I f'J;.; ,crl «meta-analysis»~l ~ l ~(c!J)
~ l . ~ ~ Jlj.u ~ ~4-'}!l ~~ ~b.tll ~l..>-4J ~ ~ ' } ! LA~
·'-:-'bS:Jl L>-4 JJ'}!l ~ 1 c.;s «a» ~J ~~l ~)Lo
~~t~t
~ ~ra ;,ac ~ ;i _...112,it as La:J't->-c.)ti
Amy Guerber..>J~ ~i i ~•~!
Aparna Rajagoplan ~~~~!) UJL:,1
Vikas Anand ..uU1 ~~.J
~._rtl ~ ,~.J.:>JI J~ ~I u ~ <JA ..y..all ~ . l ~ I Ji1..J )~ l.t..ll_;.l?J

u l ~ ~,~I~ .J~I I~~ ~.;JI.;~ ~I <).>-9Ll&. ~ ~~ wi
~ o ~ I ofi'I.JJI ~ WorldComrfi ...ll.;JJJ Enron w~l ~~u..-.::,oi a1.!1s
~~~~l~IJ .J~~IJ~~~WIJ.?~~l.;~~lji
~~I~~ I ~ .ll~l ~ w,-4 J ~ ~I u~b.. 1...9\~I ~ d..J:i o.l...u:al
-
J)l;.~IJJ~~l ~ ,l.:U .o..)WI ~ ~)l;.i w~w_, ~~i-~~i ~ J
~~I~~ ?JIJ ~~I J ~ ~ .lL.will u~Jk, ~ ~ . J ~ .ll~~I <JA
~ '-:?.l.J-4ll lS~I ~ o.l~ ul_;~l:, i~ <i'11 .lL-o..11 uL.u_;k.o wi ~ c.illj
·I ...
Uc <:.-:.,..j ·,4..)4..u..u
~ 1 . : : J u...,
.. .... IJ.) a.a.s-'--~uUo~~
~
~ \.....• u·i ~
·<-·Jl4.C.~lu~
.normalization ~ 4 ~ wi ~ aQ' ..,~ 41_µ1_, .lL-o..11 ~bul_,.b.;..
:~tJI CJ)WI lSJ-Oll .lL-o..11 ~ ~--':!
.,t ul..v-tll J)t;.l l,fl)l;. <JA ~ <i'11 ul_,.b;JI ~J rationalization a ila·JI -\
. ~~1 a.a.,~ .lL-o..11 uL.u_;k.o .J-l~ _,t ~ '-9.J+.I _;I~ ~I
f:'..\.oJ lfl)\.;. 0--4 ~ <i'1' ul_,.b.;.. ~ J socialization ~~~I a~ ,:.,;;JI -Y
.o.l._P.-.,11 .lL-o..11 uL.u_;~w~~J .l~I ~~~I
~ b ~)l;. 0--4 ~ <i'11 ul.,._.b;.JI ~ J institutionalization <.>":-'-"'bll -r
. (Ashforth and Anand, 2003) a.! Q.!t;.. ;;JI uL.u_;WI ~ JL-o..11 uL.u.;k.o
-
J)l;. ~I~~ l.l~ . l ~ I ~ ~)l;. <JA ~I ul_,.b;JI CJ~
-
_,i~.;~l0-4o~~J~L.:;~l~11~»4\S'0i ~ .~Jo~
-
--'A-w,tiQl~-W..C.. "ft ~~!).X' . . . . . . JIS ~ ~ ~ · - - - -
\,V ~~ 4la9 ~ ~.:.L11 LA_,~~ ,~u :u~1 ~ J~!J 4.4..1~1

' ..... ,·· ··.. ·.,.•{->·· .,=.,··.y::·i. ,,ir:pj :·:-.,j:~···~=-~ ~I"· .. : (,.-; .. ,r , · . . 1·· . .·:.i.1·--::-. · .... ·-... ~·,·,. f:{ J::-);,' .. ·•.1':.(··.'.:;-••:: .. (i .:· -~-::·=.. ~~ ...--;·.=~i-· ,··:.- '·: .·. ·.. •··.•,,· .. ·.} )'v'. f·.,•,.)J''·.-:·.· .. .J·<.'. ,. ···.::i'".•'-~'((·J'"·f,1}cJ-~-:;: ·: .. ;:··}··'"-~'fciJ+'("·,=.?.§•,15 ..d-; '.'.:rd
~~lA;;~~;;~~.l~J~l~«.lLd»~L)~J~'
~, ~,p ~ ~ ' ~1.,_b;J ~.;-11 wfi:.1.1 wl -~~ ~' ~ ' ~w
c.:,k &U>JI ~1 o-4 .lLuuill ~la~~~~ o.ll....c.l» .ll~)U ~ ~ I
0 1 ·.: '"!J .(AshforthandAnand,2003,p.16) <,;;~,, ~~I ,,
LJA
L -~ :.- -:ti I -I ··ti '6..d ... ,,q · · LI c.lLuuiJI • .. l...i · _j.\ ~ I .l ~
~ J-l~ ':r"' u-- .,-, \--v-- f""O""' (>A u ~ c:_::-:-- ':'""" .. ~ JJ
. (Anand, Ashforth, and Joshi, 2004)
~L.ui.
• - (>A
~ ~LA:a ~
[ 'J <;-- ••. l...i Jl.? 44Jl-.ull
,,.. ..)~, c:_::-:-- . c.!:J·-
~
.q ~~<
'..}'-.)
~~~I
- ~
· ~LS'·' ... tt l~~I "'-~1 J t J-l~
- ~.)
·· .-:t ..)·'J-'
.:.ti l.All..u.,
. -
~ -:ti ~ I
':r"'
~LuJI ~_,JI c.!:J~I c.:,k ~ I I.J.A ~ • (Ashforth and Anand, 2003)
a..u)U.-.ll~I
.. , ..-:q ~
IJ-l~ · ~ '-··-.:.": y:,c..J· u~ . . ~~I ~
· ·'--·.ll~ '·~"=.is ':r"' -:ti '-""'
'-l··tl~~l.J
.,-, L: •
~ I l&l~«:.>-4PJ:i ~J<i'11J.,.hll· a,~,<;, ,·.i_g.,._,..L;!~4J --»-~1~10J.l

0 t ~L.ulJ..ul ~~t .isJ -l&l-*9Jl ~~I «:.>-4<i'11 ~ I [~~~¥l.a:&JI
'-r·w1 ~~'u• c.!:Jl.,1:,..)U ,16.41
~ j ~...J ,16..41
._ • .<
.J.:.":~
'=- ·~ ... tWI Jl.?~ ~~I
· .:..< :.tu ,-
'- i~J-l
. (Hofstede, 1980; Schwartz, 1994) ¥ ~ I ~ ~ . ? «:.>-4 f1WI ~

.. .:.t:..q
u~ r LILl...u.J -:ti a..a.a...JI t'~·t.4-r'
... '7""' -~ 4-L.i.b·'I
.. .,.
~la:'JI ..>-':.~- . t L-:_ q .
~ u u--- 0-0
J.o~~la:'JI .y~~l<J-A .l~illl~J .lLua.a.ll~la~d..n~ ~ ,~Jl

a.J~~J
.. • f a...J~.. L".f I,.. .l· .:.q I ··'1 . I!.~. -:ti ~\..6'-1 ... ti ..1.1~ •
~ <;-- 'jMJ ~ ~'-?""' .. ~ - t..rf-4.4
iJJ.l ~la:'JI ~.lj....J ,~l:i .(Licht, Goldschmidt, and Schwartz, 2007)
.. ,,
~l.fi_,!.-.JI o-4 .l.J.Al a.J~ L....,jl c.:,k,, ~1 ~ ~I
.. ~l.ir.J.I ~~ ~
.. ~
. t!..~.
~'-i"""~
~b;JIJ\""':"""9~~
.... :;ti 1.< _:._": - ,l:JlL(Cullen ' Parboteeah ' and Hoegl ' 2004)
-:11
~... '?""'
-:ti 4Sl.Zll c.,J~
... · '- ~ · L~ -~u •~ · ti ~~~11
· .r .. . ~......+. •
:.:r- (>A ~'..r':"
• L:f I,.. .l·
~ <;-- .:.ti I.·'!
'..rw ~
.(Mosquera, Manstead, and Fischer, 2002; Schwartz, 2006) .l~I I.J.A ~1
a ;1;.11 ~ 1..-9~1 l.!lUA w~ wl ~ 1 0--A wl ,y~~I " ~
I
~
~- .
uJ---AA~
. •
~
-:ti a......aslliJI
-
... .:;ti
~ <;---
,,.. i.l~I JI~
.. '\~I LI~
... ~
-:t\
1..-9.,.._ . (Gollan, and Witte, 2008; Licht, Goldschmidt, and Schwartz, 2007)
l&l~ o-4 ~' ~1.,bJJJ '-' 4.!t;.. ii JI .ll-.u..i.U ~ o-4 ~la~ 'ii "~ ~ .»-9:!
.. .. t.., ,, ,,
~ I l~~~wl J.41,j~ .a.!4.!t:,;;JI alo c~ci:il «:.>-4 l:!.l~ 1~~ .lLua.a.11 ~
0'4 ~ J:,,..G-,o ~ l.>~~I JAIJ-&llJ dJ1la:'JI ~l~b L ) ~ a.:\:oi 1114 c!.,~
-~~I·(>A ~ti~·
.. '..r':" ~ u·L.l~
. ~ -:11~1.t-.:.._q
-- '-?""' .,-
u
~ a.u:,L:,.. .)~I c.:,k .AP i ~ I 0A <i'11 ¥la:al JAIJ-L!I ~ ~ i c.!lLlA
~~I LJ::' J.l\+tl,I .)~ ~I o.)l:u ~l 1..Pf a.t.J-L!I FL.:i ui ~ l.!.U~J ~WI ~.,JI
~6:-.J~ ~~I 0-Aul .c.!l~I ~ I J..9---"~~JuWolil ~ J
a.! q.! J;, ;; JI o~ I 0A -1~J.:!,. lsJ)l;.. 0A .)~I ~ <i'11 u- 1.,-b>J I c.:,k ~L.a:a I..>-Pt:;
u ~ 0A ~WI ~w <i'11 ~..;...Gll ~l>t11 {4.!q ,,.,;! ulS~ ~ l.!.U~ u"l
ui ~ • ls:Jl u J ~ .Jl <i'11 o.l~I ~ I ~~J c.!ll.J.l! c.:,k o.)...\.......:ic. ~~
~t:;~c_:,k ~~ui ~l.!.Uju~ J~~I ~W&J ~J;i>JI l~~c!J~I
-~~ .)~I ~ 1!.(ti·')l;.. <)A(;-'
· ~,lul·t-.:._tL~lli.>.~~. - '-1·-'1
4:\~.t!..tl
i.:r- - ~ ~~
~.
- •
-
. ~ u ~ ~ liAj..o
-
L&:J! JJ.b:lll ~ <i'11 ~ I ~ I ~~J L ~ ..J1..9---" , a. .d-411 ~ IJ.:!,. ~I ~
<i'11 ~~I ~IJ..111 u-uLul c.:,k ~l.u,_,JI
~ .).,_bjJ ~~I ul:.,.l~I ~
D~
~ ..J1J-U1 J>:?-i .~,.) .JUo! ~J ~La:JI ~1 .)~~ ~ J r~J ~ r~

u~ u~ji r~J ~ , u ~ 0A I;,.!;.,.,; JS'~ tJ-4:! ~I u~,~~,
· ·J.)L~--·~1-
.LA~ u I t..·-.:.~.~l~la:alu~)b;.~I
~ -·- '.>-'-'-"~~ -
.)L...d u~~ .J .! •",;;t .)~I ~l ~ ~ uK .!-,<3 ~ a ;, ;.JI

«a...oWI a .!q.!aJI .J........dj-411..J1~ ~~, .;l~i ~ Ji 0.).)---tA ••• » ~
, ;,.!bliJI I.P.'-i 0A ~ I .ll_.,_s~I r...,;.; .. ,2 .(Ashforth and Anand, 2003, p. 16)
~ c.:,k . .)~I u~~ ~ ~.JL_jJ,4 J:,~.;I
- LsJ ufi.: ...ll .Jl&. ~J lG i 0A
, -
u! ~~ ~~~ ~~J.>-'-4A u4~ ~ 0_,...J4.! 0:.:UI .ll_.,.s~I ~ ...ll ,Jul.I
~ J
·j i .~---~,, 1"··'~1~~1
~ """-8-' -· - r ~~~1.. . ·- ·-'u~---~,1~
J-'4,J U" '.r--'
~6. ~ l.·-Aj ~·L• lA.lLl..o ~ ti •• I._, :. . • 'ii ~~- ··j . . La., .Jl
• ... c..r~ u ~ ~ (>J.u,:>- ~ ~ ~ u.j,J.J ...
• C')~j ~.)~ ~4~ u~~ u~~ ,-,q;.,;.,; 0:.:UI 0A fA~ 0A
-~~I c!J~I ~ lA..1:~ ~ <i'11 ~ I ~ I ~Lu...9 0A .)~ c.!lLlAJ
\s,o.!;.~ l-"4~J ...L,WiJ c!J.J~i LsJ ~ <?ll ~ I ~Lu,J c.:,k LlA..JS'.>1 ~
~ J ( o-,) JJ~ ~ ~1.J.)1 ~ ~~_,JI D.J.A • (Ashforth and Anand, 2003)
.DW.)i ~ j i
cf. I ;t ~ .r ;. l, ~. t ·~. ~ ,1
_ I- t~ ,. 1-
.F ii ~ r.. ;. ~
i't. ·~ t..i;
> E.. ~ -~ t= [,'i ~ U>I I "' - - &,
? -
~.
I a.CI'
L, . - ;. l,' ~ ,C:-
E .r I I •
1 ~
I .::
r:: c·
1
Jt•i1 ~ :.- p ~- ~ t. :- .t: 'Lv r. ·~ r. .... ~ .
p• 1,· 17 H - 1 )-" -
I I y f.. ·Y ,i: L. ~ C: ~ ,t ~
·i- if -f> IE 1 ,e - r. '1::. . t.t
f ~ I • - ~ ·~ • - 'i· l, C· r.: - •• f
c-i ~;~\~ ~ !:Jtr '#' fill ~ t<g~lrh~<gl !,~
t;. &· G-. • <t1; t;. <t [.
l,· l,·
i::
~ II ;>._ . 't.~. LH' ·f c •
l
•
<t~ •c, ~
t .c- ~ ~ E: \'
. ':"' r e. 11·
. ~ fit. :[ .c-
1
e·. :[ ~ l ~.fij:.·:,
• • :, l ~ f - C• ~ If \ l, E ~1 C• ~ • ~ (r _ 11 (' • C• • [• ~ ··~
E 1.•, 1
r-. C· lA _, C• •
- ~
-11 ~:r .t-G~. t-i 1- l f §; - r, -
. i1 ~ ~ ~ k~ :r- ~r t.f:~ f ·~ 1-L- lr. ·i ·i l P:~ t ~ t i· t~ r. h G I:: r. [ f,
'\.i [
I, ! :r
[ ij ~ •G-. t· ~ 1,----;- f~ 'E ,. r: i.... 1 I: ]- (; - (. r ,-.. ~.''.·
- Q. iL 0
"E -~ [· \- 1ip- -~- f- '1U>· ~ tt: '\ p't f. r!
"'· I~ ~ I::- ~ -L .f, . r- .f. f!- . \. . . .E~. : .L.. ~ - • ' • le . • ~ - • • ....: .~·- .:; iij::,·:·
e: ~· r. ·~ l,
~ I'
•t ~ ~
'e e; IP I~· - ~ r.l t:.J ~r. if:
-E N
n 8
~ ~~ r-:. ~·r C· ~
'e, i:
~!_;
1
r II .. ·£.·~[~ I I_ ·r-~f ~~-t~ I I ~ f-., -
~! 1
I I_ Lr_ ~t I·f:L~ I It"·,.:' E
JL.."'4lt lllac ~ ~ - " ' asW.11 ~l:i
@:C:~~..;,~-ra;:;..J.!1Z..t-iJrrX~,,.,q~~...!W.&'.::ffiT~~~77idl1%'iR'ffi'."'~
al..>-'~I ~J~.)LJ:?'"~~~1 ~ I tl~i, O.!i,oi~ 'r~~

. (Scott and Lyman, 1968; Shaw, Wild, and Colquitt, 2003) JI~ ~IJ
" II II lt
~ J I ~Lo.!~ ~~1 ~.lj:i ~~I a.J~al_;l.~. n l.A_;I~ ~IJal..>-'~I
.(Scott and Lyman, 1968, p. 46) ~ Ji L4A..l:,,..i ~ ,1 \§ .~.;JI ~ LA~ ~tr,
rJJ..• «111 ui ~ ~J al.:.UI r..w.:3 al.J4c, ~ o.)~ JI~ ~IJ al.>--J~l 4'.LA
~.)~ L..!l->--1o~ ~ ~ L o . ! ~ ~ Ji .>--J_;,;J Ji ~l...ul ~ ~ ) L I
~.:U. 6:! ~.;JI JJ L411J . (Eisbach, 1994; Goodrick and Salanick, 1996)
fi..i:i~JlAL..!~~4J~4L..!l~":Jl~al..>-'~luiJA~ a.!i,oiJI
~L..!~IJ.,_;s.Jl~~l~,~W.IL..!~l~J .L..!~l 14J~l~~I
. (Scott and Lyman, 1968) cll~ .J~l Ji "-i.c. llA~I 4 JJ.uJ-1 _µ ~J ~~ c.1,jj
lt " "
~~":Jl.)l~~IJAJJ~I, a.!i,oill ._;l~)U~~J..:!4H~l l.j,A)~
."-i.c. Ji~j...~
-It a...u:.~":JI ahJI ~I
.. •
.
. . . . ~~c...r-
,... .:GUJL
~- .ltl I .tq '"
J~~<.:r- ~ -:ti
~ rr
~ JAi.¥- ~i ,0-J_;.=i,.~1 r-'1 ~ ~I ~~I .;!~~I ~ ~l:JI, o.!i,aiJI LAi
.L..!~I ~ JJJ.uJ-1 ~ ~ ~ji o.ll.Jl ~i ~
u::,t,.t.J-iJt
1.:u. oJ..:.t.A .o.)L.:::» Ji a:Jo~ ~ i u~ ~ ~~~ ua~~l .v-t: LA~
0A ("S ,11;,;i i5...u ~.)y.a J ~ ~ ~~ u~ ~L1ll 0i a..a.a...JI 0A t~'
Lo.!~ cl.91~1 ~L1ll .»-!: LA~ .J---A ->-'~I l.:U. ti..~ i ..l:,,.. i . ~ ~ i ~! ~.J.A
.~i L..!..1.A ~ Ji i-'"4-'-".;,ot ~)l;.i a ~ ~ JoLi.:d.l ~ J e,tjf ~ . l ~ I Q ..
~! ~~I wi ~_;.11 <)A .~i alhl.u, ~1 ~~I ~ I 0-4 t~I l.j,A) ~ ~

-~~I Ji .ll~~I i5...u ol)4-JI ~)l;.~I tp~IJ~I ~ ~ ~ albL.u
(.....U..'-",JL.tl ~
. . . r ~Li. i...r- . ~ .. _. I , . . ~ .l·
... .. ~.)c...r- ..
.:.ti 1...J.A.J.. ..ii ,Jl:J.I ~
'J- .
I.. ...
<.:r-
, ....
0.A ~i ~j.U u a ~ ?JI ui JA llA ~ I ~l~":JIJ .J--:AjJI 141 ~)l;.!

.~~IJ ~L.ul,JI c4 ~l.~I
,C(~l .l.P.-J.)l£s1»~al..>-'~1 • a.!i,oi~i.S-.,P-~I ~ , ~'>'-'-"1 LAi
~~ ":J ~~ J ~ . l ~ I Lo.!~ 0l.:' al.:.UI t~! ~ I J~?J ~~I 0 '.! Q ,;.,..
~b.JI
•
.:G..i ~.. I.?""
, ~ u.Jo~ .»-t: ..,w ,Jl:J.I ~
I.. 1.... L !ti clj~ ,
<.:r- ~
• ..
()A~
4Ul~1..PUl4'Hti~.J.l0~ .l~IJJ~ ~ ~ 4 U l 0 i J bi~

.. .- I ~ ~
_ _ _ _:'ll.._la#"""'"-".a.1.:#,.,;,,.1V-~.".-.."'-~...._..~._ ... _ . ~ - . _ ' ( V ~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~ ~ - , . . ; c · . . - . 1 0 o " ' . ' _ . . , . . J A ' > ~ Y ~ : \ Z I L ' l r - ' " ' S : : ) . . ' > , , ) : O ~ - , C . . , S . 1 , o Q ; t " ~ • . - . A ~ ~ J
w, ~~ 41d ~ 1$~1 LA..9 Q ~ 1:,u : u ~ I ~ J~lj 4.4,J~I

.),~~, ~ ~ .a:!.d. 4'.~.. ~, .),~~, ~ ~ , ~L..u~ ~\:JI C OJi«oiJI
~ -~.)l;JI JAl.,..JI ~ ~.).?JI Jl ~ ' .J~l ~~ I s;•.!.,b.' r-'"'
~ J o ~ ~ ! o.)Ll,)'4 c.ill~J .)l~)U 0J~ Lo~ ~_,L.u ~ ~ .l~~I
i.b~.ll._~~,.)~~ -~~_,Lw,~~w,~.-L,Qs cuiJi«··:: cc·~'
•4.s.A .::<t ~
.. ~~ -·
'--9~
•. t:.
()A~
• • .. Jo . . 'I ~~1 4..&c~
~i.:r.. - •
~I ~
·'" LA!.) ~
ahJI
-· J a...u:.W:,..~I ... u· ~ ~
d!u.JI .. ' ·J~11
- .) l~~IJ a...u:.W>.~I
. .) l~~I ()::'
· ~ - ·· ~
· ·
1
- . -
_;l~j~~~~l.)I.J. . ~~I . .ll._~~,~~L.b~«.·: ccsi~~..,.tJI
4.:PI.J.ll u~~I al~ ~1 _µ4 Ji ...,.;.T ~;. ,~. ~1 r.,lll JJ~ 4 ~ u~4,.
~ r.,lll ~Wl 4 ~ u~4,. .;l~l ~ ~..,.tJI )~~I Loi ·0-J...»-511 u~~ e:4
-~UI Y.J~J ul....u~IJ u~)U\S i.S...»i ~ JAi~
~ ~Jj...-uJ.I Jo~ '--91~~1 .ll~~I ~..>: ~~~I )~)LI ~~I~
.),~~, fa.>3 .a. . . =c.t.~'11 ~ ~ JAi~ ~ ~LJJh, c.ill~J ~~~ r-'"'
u~_,L.u ~ Jol~~4 Jc.WI .JI~~ ~ i ~I ~ I JAi~ ~~~~I
I.JA ~ w ~ I 0.,kWI ~..>: ,jALlJI ~4J • ~ ~ 43.JJ.i ~J .lL..wiJI
~~~I i.S..ll ~I ¥)G..~I J~IJ ~1.J5IIJ ul~I ~~ ~ I LJ.A tJ1ll
.Jl~)U 0J~ 0:?.:.UI 0.,kWI ~ . (Ashforth and Kreiner, 2002) 0--J.....»511
0~..>: ~t Ji 0--J...»-511 e:4 a:,.Jw, JJo ~ ~~! o_;Jo:, rs '"'. .~ ~~~,
. o ~ I ~l.;,k~I J ~ '--91~~1
wblA -~~I .Jl~i Lg.;l ~ lsci.!i,oi ~ a ila-\t w~l_;.L,.ul '1lllA
·~ 1-Li.11 ~·~' ~ .Lu:.~~I a:,·l·'IJ ~ I -
~ !}-";'-' - • !.)..,... - i.,>-.) \£sl" Lo.A·u ~
-· I - ~I
.. IJ-'--'-" ..
LJ.A I ~ wi Ji ~~I~ r.,.U4 I~ wi lo! f+9 ~ ~ ? J I ~LA i.SJ.>.?J
~ ' ~ .Jl£>1 ~ 0i ~ ·iY_;.>-511 ~~~, D:kLi.11 J i ~ ' cGLol
~ ~J.> ~ WYJ~ ~~ i_;Jo:,~~ Lo (JJ-0,-?:; 'di.! l:~I 0~ .)~~, ~
(A~ 0L:u .Jib~~ l-s=;I~ ¥)G..~I J~I ~ wfi~ '1 ~~I wi Jl
~~~I a:,jl_,-11 ~ 0i ~ ~ .(Anand,Ashforth, and Joshi, 2004)
A~~,
ul.o 1~ ~w1 u· l...u.l cGl.ll". ~
. .... . o~ 4..&c~I
.. . a:,!.) ~ ~,~ L i . 1..ul a,jb\.J
... J u ,.
a,jJl-"4 o~I ~~~I a:,.JWI ~ J . ~ I ~ ~ ,~·iJI Jl ~I~ ·''f'
..dbo.Ai_,.,..,.,ti~.! c~·JdJi~...,.;.i~;. ,~,u~~~4f-"J.>lu~~
-~""1 ... :.ii• 4Wllln:::s;::r~ ......... ,.,,._..,,.,ac:ce.... ~::n-s-·-----"
~~ ~ ~ ~.J.Jt l.oJ ~..b.l faU : u ~ t ~ Jl.w.Al!_g 4.o.J~t \VY
C· •G -., .,
< ~ •[' ¢ F '\ f:.. ~· -' -' 1~. ''-·
-' ~ {X I:! {- [
-1 • ~ t ~ f; '6' ~: f: f r2 [ c~
1·. :r(• (• ~ C· '\!~ -:-f ~~·1'
i
t ~. -[, " ~
r 1) - • ~ ~" t.. r
i;i _,, r. - • r r •£. p ~
·vb 1·Fi"" 1-r.- .--.,
c" I>,_ r l. I!;
L.
~, J..• • ~ ~ ~
l ~ ~ C·
~· ' ;:- ,;;: } - t=r... .c- , /lo' !f! , 'f\C:
r;; .f!'
fre·
- • & • h c:_ C· v (;..
I!'.
- ·· -; r;;
·L.f.ff.._:l ~gi'r_c.·it~·~'r fl f".'t°~['[l
4-r. r(;,. • p. I, 'i ~· fi:- ,~ · ~ P C. &- e-, l [ 1) -1· r ~. • -
·~ I:: { h t:; !t , ~ " ~: •£ ~ C t· ~ <i: [:= (• ~. if ji
I ·~. t: ~ r; [ fi \ ~; .r;- •t ~:Sf ~- •; f,c;;. ~
r (• p - t, ls>· . ~·
i •<i_ t -
{_~ ~ 4i.. -
1 ('1:: ~.t •(;..f t_ ,-,..~- ~ (;. ~ ~ ~ t •
~· C· ; ~·
f.1 E - "£ 1r;; <[. . ·~. \ :r (• ~~ ? ~· ~ .~:
.1:.· ,<;,. I, (• .~ ·~
- { ~~ ~ ~t,C' "',F" ,t"
C. [ ~
'i~. ~ C· .i:- ~
t ~ 1- ;: ~
~ r r ~ [ ~: t ~· ~~ C, c:_ 'f: l ~
,.
i.L 1-_,, ~{ st: •f P · ~
r ;'· 'i; ~l i;=_,, •(;...C: ,r' ~. _,, b i I 'fu i;; ~
R:. E ·t
-i" C· Ci
:i ·vt c· } ~£ f ~ t~ I"' ~t
·~ )' l r;; _,. ~' C• ~y -
l: i( l~. ·t:[ ~ ~ ~'t! [~ "[ 1- ~ t }
'r.f ~
~ ·h •ff.'. t t- i ~. l t .~ ~; t; .- _: ~ r : !r:.1 . i-~ ,
'1 I, I:: lo - ll-'
'° e-· ~ _,, f?r ~ ,(; [ [ ~ ~· ( ~- ~ t:
t ~~ t t.t: ~' ·f~ }._ .i··'i_
~ J ·~ J: i :, t,C' ls>· - ~ ~~ { f 'i~ w fl t ,--:- ~· ,t:

l, le, ~ [ b t: }_,. (•f c:_~· ~.·
1
~ 1 c:_ f ~ 1- _,. t c; ·L
g( G. (;! r • ~ t ~ c' r r;- f l ~ i- .~ t r
ti r.(• r~ >
r·~ t~- t-t
· l r- ~ z Pf t,· f- ~ f: ~ - c;.. t.. t E - i;;
t &- c· r I_ Lg ,
C· _:: ,. •G ' . ~. 1~1' ~ 'i r· l t) t " ..
u r."'. h
h
.c- c," • _,, ~. • .,
C•'~ ~· [• ·~~1' ~., •t. [;· "'
~ ~ ~s
f rt,, - - 1, I I I, '>f 1) I - I,
E 1"' t' 'li.i • ~
·<CI w·
&r "° .r, ~ ·f W'k f. { { [ .r:- ~ ~ . ~ l -C t .e .f: £ irt
II,I ~ f; ~ 't oC r ~. . ~ [ r ~- t· _: ~- f; ~- ·[ f;, p B :f '1- t t i' (•}
I':,
Jo
I t· r. ~ 1 1: c· ·1= ~ -
si £ t(
' l ,(; • e:
~r - ls> C l> - , 1, ls> - -
r "fl l
14 __JIWJ't ~t~t
~~t·..)-:!-AU- '-:""'
~,1J ~
i'!-lt4........u:.~l~··t\»
- . . ~
1 ~:L~~l'-4.-J
....__., . -. ~--
-!)-LJ ~
.(Hofstede,2001,p.9) ((~~ ~ ~ ~ i , a .:i«oiJj ~ a. . . d.-4~..

¥~I ~ I L-.al.J..il ~ I ~ ~I <>--° i..)~ uJ ,;1,.:.v, u~4 .J.,_Jo ..1....-4l
.)~~I L..i.ArJ;., ,u·· .(Hofstede, 1980; Inglehart, 1997; Schwartz. 1994)
~µ1 .Jlb)11 _r1_,.b:i ~ .J..41 •y ~~I 0,.4 ..)..al ~~J Schwartz jJ.JI~ ¥lZll
u~I.J..ill J~ 0,.4 ~ 0,.4 ~ I ~J ~)lA ~~ ~ '-""~l ~ J:i.JI~
~~ . u ~ I oA ~ ..)~ ~ o.:U~~IJ y>lbll 0,.4 u ~ ~..,JI ~ I
~
-
-,~~jJ.)1~~µ1_;\.b)ll ~
lsi4cci.:<i'1' ~~l~I ..)~,,-, Q.4~
-~.>4'.R ~ ~ ef-~1 ~ J I ~ -~J.A ~ ~ u~ ~ Ja< ,114
~_µI .Jlb)ll 0,.4 ~..J ~ I ..)~~I ~~I~ J;.l~I _;l..1.a.4 0,.4 ~ l~J
,D~ ~J -41~ _jJ_;l_,..!J
u ~• I .tl bl:; ~~t1 ~
t ~
'"(t:' •
-: . '-t\.~~ u- , A'b.JL. ~~I
- .... ::;q ..)~i
,--:--- ·- I~:. .).:,-
. .r'.) ·'-
a..t.Lu, ~I D~JJl .(Schwartz, 1994) L..>4'.R ~~Ji~t~ ~4-~
«~~IJ ..)..)----41\ ~ ..)J..J.>JI Ji a.....:a)WI ~ » t 4,.iz,.J.I ~ ~ ..)~
0 1u~» ~ ~ ~uJI ~ ~ ' i i Jlj-.cJIJ .(Schwartz. 2006, p. 140)
&.UI .J~ I ) (( ef- ~'ii-
.(- .... :t\ ~ aJJ~ ~ c\.4.i·
. e:.-=--- L. ·.~
~u~~~
- l..;.__c!,~\
Dj~t Jo~ 0 t ~ 1 ~ 4.l~ 0-4 ~.:.u,
r~I ~~i (\.4.i~ , ~ ..)~
~.:.UI ~uJI ~~'ii Jl_;.........JI Loi -~~I ~l.ai 0,.4 ~JJ ~ J~l ~
~I~~~~~ '-""Llll l.!l.J~ '-4» ~ ~hA u\ , 4f~tl ~ ~ ~
.(Schwarz, 2006, 2006, p. 141) <'~~'ii ~WIJ
~<&'W~-·~.,. . ~~-'7~--~. - ----------.,.,.,.,..

~~ 4.1.a.b ~ '-:?.:.Lll Lo.91!1~ tjU :ul.J:a.i.11 ~ ~l.w.iUI., A.4J~I Wt
. < - . a..J~)U
~ ..
. .l . . . .. I :. . ..Lal • a.c.b.11
~ ~~j-J.)~j-:A •
I .4 • 'I . .<
A - -~-
~L,)A.).,.........J~
:.-~,1
c..:,,11.;.:,~·.?~.JJIJ~WI J~~I .JAJJ~I .(r· ·1,, C\'\t) ~I~ w..H~
~ ~ .. ~I .) .J..4j ~
1
.:.'-WI J'ft,A.I.C.&I ~,1 u ~• I .'-:?"'"·" .a..ubJ
... • .. ~l.J:.
.. • ~~
I...J
• -
~ ···'Ia.,:.?
?~I t.,_i.11 Lii .d..c..J-LLAJ ;;~ ol:?, ~ r..iZJI ~ D.)J.4.UJ .)~~~I~~
~~~~I c..:,,1!~ ~.JJIJ ~~I J~~I ~ J ~ ~ l 0,A
.) ...143.~,i~.r-<.:.tlJ~~L
I.:~ · .... ~
• .)-:-4-U ~'lu~I
•
Lii .a..J~Lj·.:.tl
.. • 'J-"' .)
~j
.(Schwartz, 2006) tl...1.:t?/IJ ~~I ~ J ~~I
~u,o~i c..:,,1! ~~~.JJI ..\>JI c..:,,l!t~.;JI~ ,,.;?~I ~liJI 0-AJ
~ - ~ ~ ) U ~Lal ~ I ~J '~~I ~~I o~_,JI ~ u~J..i.A ~i
~ (>A ~Lw.. - " 4..a.A.Ai ~Ll..41 •
JoL:i
• ~
~I J'_JL:>.
1
•
.. • ~I ull'
1
JULU .. C::J---'-"·...)-'· tl.J. ~
· .... '?""'
~,1 ulsla:;.JI
1~ - .as' .. :. ~I...Ld)i -:
u-- ~ ·-=--~,rl...AJIJ ol.L:i.JI
~ .. I...J·'
.~ ·. j.'-:?"'""as'.)~ IJ L.d....,JL
..
~ I J a.c. \..bj IJ 0-A ~IJ J .......~ll.d::JI r I ~ IJ <r ~ ~I r' Uo.lll .)..1...-43 ulsl.a:JI D ~
. (Schwartz, 2006)
· r~ ~ · ~, C::J---'
~ • -"··ti
...)-' .J.£J• 'r• "I·~ ... ulw ~~,1 .) l..bs~I
· .< ~ "
'r· ,Jlill ~
1 · · · · 1,...
c..:r-
c..:,,11 ~ ~~~~l~Wlu~~.J~'.«: '"!~~~ic.,:,k jl~)U
~~ ·t ,. . a..J~~I .J.£J·'r~...
~c..:r-.. • I··.< Lu....d, c.c_J\.j
- ts
~'I l..bs~I
'-?""'.)
"
· -ll~· lt
'r ~1
• ~J,LiJ ~.)4,-:i ~ 1..; ~
i<t74..)4tt ~~~ ;;~~t

w·'-··
~ ~ ..~-tl-ll~"i~
~ ~...
~ ... ~ '?"·l:JIJI=:J-"""'"'
··~-.:1-~q ·-·ti·~ a..,b,.)U
• • " iJ
~ ol..~ ~LllJ ~l:JI ~I~ ~I~ u ~ l uµ ' ~ J dJJ~

olJWI ~ ·i.S?~l 4;!\..s..tll ~ <:?"4..>fll [.J...LJl:i ~..J ~l.;,b~I ~t ~ olJLuJ.I
u~~..J .. uJJ ~ ~·t c..:r-
· ..< .. :. ~>G..i· t ... ~~--'I ~ · a.i4~iJ u-o ~~I ,.,,..'!·h-~tl
~
,olJWI ~ 41.1 ~ I ,~L.-:al u ~ I ~ . ~ ~L.u~I ~bl.I~

.(Schwartz, 2006) a:,..1~1 ,o...Lc.WI '~J_µI ,~~~I dJIJJJI
~ .JIJ-l~I ¥ u§J ~.JJI ~ I c..:,,11 ':7'4~1 [.J...LJI ~,,.;?~I ~LlJI 0-A

<r~~I ~Li..tll ~ .JJ_µI ~_,1...-uJI u~ ~i 0-41.!.U~J ascribe;;~ Ji
c.,:,1c. ~~~1 a~,~, c; ~ LAS' • -l)j,1.IJ .;IJ~~IJ ,a..biuJJ J ~ ~ L....i.JJJ <..:r-4~1
ts -
f.:,··- ·. ,; :~;-::::,:-,:~ :=:::.= ..,,··.:::-..~: ' )=~·:=·:·-.~~ . ·:-::·.:·,, . \ ·::·· .:-:· ..·2 ,:·,: }.-·'=< :·::) ,..... -~·~:-:-~:=.-::-:-:,.-::,::,,;:..-,,·-..·:::;-:_=:(=.:.-:::.=:.=·::, ·-~==·=·-~-.:::; :._.;_.. ,: .;·:::' <=:;-. ..·.::_: :::<: 1' i
<:r4.>fll ~I~ ~ I ~I_, ·fA)JJi ~~ c.i'11 ul.Alj:J~I_, ~~I J ~

. (Shwartz, 2006) ~1_;11_, ~l__,:JI_, ~ I _ , ~ ~ ~I ::,~I t..:rA
- -
t •. A_t;..~.
~~~
~t\~-'-'IJ
~ J \.ru.e.LJlcJGJI
-"'? i.r- Lu>.~IJI~
. ... fl· Lb.>l.J
.,-.-w ~ .. ~
J.¥1 <J-4 ~I u ~ I ~ ,42·2:btl_, ~~ ~I a~2:H c4 ~ll~ o,o~~I
. • i 4...&.:>.\.j •
:. ..i...:i~ ~~L -:t.~q cJGJI
r.~~I ~~ t"
-
D. L .. q 4-.&>.\.j •
0-4 ~ . . , .. 0-4f". ·'-"'""""""
..,t D_; 22 ;; a.1_,b 0..,J ~ ~ ~w, ~ [LA..G~I U"'w1 ~ J..,~ t.§.:u1 .J.>JI ~1
~Le~ ~ I ~I ufi:i r"~~I ~ ~_,J ~..u <i'11 u ~ I ~ .d..J~I
.(Schwarz, 2006) a~.!:JI ~~.., ~ I c4 J6.:i~1.., r>LJI DJ~
~~~t.§.LJI .J.>JI ~1 D_;b.! ,11JI ~~ ,LA~~WI ~4JI ~ J -

.~~~l..,~lc.:.,~luJI;; '".!JU~J,J..J~l~fA~o,o~~I
r~IJ r_,..Jo.11 ~ ~ I ~I 0~ o ~ I ~ ~_,J ~..u <i'11 u ~ I ~J
.o~~IJD~IJ
J~~ ~.J-A ~~ (Shwartz, 2006) j.:iJI~<>° J~I_, ( o-,) ~ r~

t('. ~ A..&~\ ..w o J ~ ... ,;;t Llla:JI ... ,;;ti
0-4 ~ ,-=-J - ,~
1 ·- .~fl ·
.LllZ..11
- ~
.. .. I u ~.,.... .J,J- ~I.:,~
1. -·--. ·
~ 0-4 I...J. Llla:JI
-:tl.J t ·- -·-
.'J-*". ~ . . , ~ ~
-
~
- ~,1
.. -
·- .~fl u· i a.b)\A ~
I u'"'(P..,.... . ·- LS
~ •~ -· ~ - a,.a..,l.kt.o
• ..w Llc ~• ~ .. D ~ .. I.., <:r°,~I [J .J:tll ~ ~ .I
, .• t\ .J:tl~ ._ .. ti L .•-- .t ~la.A I .. _._ - ~ti ~ I ul~.,.... t ~ .-:
·- .~ti c..r----
'-?'4..}"ttJ [J ~ ~ ~.., ~ ~ - -
- ,;;\t d...&..U -
~ ·-~t
4i•dl
. ~ • - .a..asl.ZJI...
- \-::W
,;;t\ JLu~
.
~l.u.A
-
•.. .L°A DI L.uJIJJ
~ ..,
y..>1:-JJJ~ ,Jlill ~ ~ .J~~I ~t ~ ..b.a.9 ~ J <J-4 ~..lo:' ~\..a:"JI
<)-4 yjA1l:, ~IJ DIJl-J.IJ ~ I ~~~4 ~4""i_, ~~J J.J_,__uJ~ 4JJf
¥~I ut:gl.ZJI ~ ~WI ~4,JI ~J .~ll_;JI_, r"~~I ~yJ <i'11 ~ I
·t~.;-11.., <:r4.>-&ll [J.J:tll <J-4 ~ ~ <i'11J J~.., 40.., ~fi ~~
-...-_"a,Qfl,'lr.a-;:~~~ A ~ ~ ~ ~ . . . _ ,...- . _ , _ , . , . ~ ~ ~ · - " ' - · _ , _ _ ,
_~~~
_
\.dl~ AW~ ~~I LAJ ~~ faU : u ~ I ~ ~Lw.iJIJ 4..,~I w,

. : . ~ I ~ ~ ~,114laWJl~l:i
1:4·---·,.,·.,-:-:,,-, ~':':•:,· •. ·.,v_.,,~ :- ·.~-:~~;:,.~,t~··, ':~·.··:'-"_·..~ ·.~:, ;~·=•:•."·~ · •r.":":t.iJ:"":i~.•-'. ~:":-:.).- ·.:~•'·.:·· ,..~. · .,f'...c:-il·. · .- ":.": ,.: :_.. ~ · •. =· · ·.• -~y:''fli:···· :r.~'" ·,.-:-.-.:· r.-·:-·-~Bl...Zit2i?::s>..::..JZ>•··=·:~S:=~-=·--.-·L<:, ·"r+..:-i
.=
~wrl ~ I ( 0-\) ~JJU,
.3·
~
5'
J"-
.; J
..,
1
...,
~
.,.,
~
J
~. ·~ ~
:~
~
i.• •
~
~
u.
~
J
. 1
j. • ~
00 • ~
• 1
"')
5'
.;
~
J t
j
,.;J'
~
• JC)
•
1
H
"-
•
,.
3 ~
:=i ·~.
'"!>, 3
~
•
•
J 00
l· j • • • • ,J
·L •
• L ,j~ ::j
"')
•
.:J •
5'
•
].
! ~
~;J•
5'
:,
~
tJ :=i
1· • ;j,
j
[U Ji• • ,.;JI
]. \
• •
'
.)..]
IQ
].
1IQ ·~. ;i
1
~
J
""'.)
• ~ } ~
• j
] 7'·
J 1.
u.
J • ·l
·i•
~
~ ,j.
IC>
• i).J
J
•
l.,. ~
•.?1 • J J• J
j ;i
_!) tJ
], ;~ 1
_j •
IQ
1 1 ""'.)
J
00
'1•
1
IC)
(I
j • '1•
•
. (Schwartz, 2006) :.)~,
-,w 1""0-,~~~.......-.-.-......... -. I'll.
\+a~ "-1.d ~ ':?.:Lll l.4.9 o..l>,j faU : u ~ I ~ .:.1-.dl~ 4.w..,r?JI
Jll:\";:ICl.Ci)-l"fXS·:,,.,.-..vw,.~~--.---~------
cf.
I (i' ·~. b ·~ f .i· f' t ~- .~ 1:, t. t { ~ ~" rt rt~ -rt Er t'P:' c, &_ i;; 13
f:•.•:.••.·1
.F 'r.. f ~! ~· G:.. t ~ - ft ! f;, 'G.. [ tC ~ ~ - 8~ 5r:: t.
1
t. .ir;-• \_,.- C•f::
f. ~ 'k ,.
~ E! 1.' ~ <i:.
t }. [• f;. t.•.".i.;:
r,:,
.
;~
'
r. .c b ·~
' .l - ~
-
1"r[•
•
.~. •
~r:~t~ib~r~ . ' ~ J- ~ 11
·f 1! ~~.,f..
~rr,-
~ i:, r . - 1
i I - ~ ~-·~ i'~ t f
I •_,. ~. ":- ,
t i: 'f 2q ; (P= £ r 1' 'l 1
11
hi r:: ·~ ~ - ~· [ [• ~ ~ . C - -
't ·Cj.. -.· [ ~: ( !'£: ·~ '.f <i:.
c, ~ ~ f [• \- g Ci.
tl ~ f. • ~ ".' ~ \ 1 - · t v· ·~ - .E
tr;.if
r. t- 1r. r-~
lp~c_[•~n, .
,'!.. · -; IL t c, t ·.,
ii ~~tr~r1e.l ~v l-.'.1.:.1
{:
ti c;.- ,. f 'v'"f. ,c;~ 'r- ;
rt l:-~ t~ '[~ ~r:: t~ Ci_F\ ~~· ~ ,, [• ~·· ls>· ~ 1. •.
re .,. .
~ il: J·I:! i~ i ~H·
e. ~ .r ~- E f. ~ r 1 t:
EI ! C· - - _, ;J> - - '
C• f.: 1.° ~- i. 'Cj.. IT ·~
. [
-,.t. b ' ~j
L.
,~\r rf~'t-~.e-. ~- -
~~
~ ~
f: ,~
1'1' ' t f .t";:- ii- i;; -~- ~ . ti
•L I • I ~.·
~ 'S 'S [• ~ P" -;
·~-: 1~· ·~.~r~·r:
~ C· G' ( fl f. :r\ ~ ·_: .. e· ·r. _,. IT l_,. - L
b Fi'" I
t' ~:= ~ ~ lf"' "
~ s-· ;[ i 1~ ~ :.·
~ · ~%= f.f 1, ~ ~ C• r • ·1
ti ~lc-f i.[~'1: 1 1r:t\ttJ .r.t. f.~ ·~t.'· f~ '[~ t~ ~.£ ,-;,t. !rl
I !E-Jrf.~~ff.~ Ir ~ ~ t:~.k}i r ~ r-
l ~ l v [· r'i.. !'- c, <c. t <t ~.. ,t - - ~ .,. ·r 't ~ 't· b li Ii
r
c, , f. r 1 Fi'" <i:- !.D ·E :.:·:··I
i
li- .~ ~ ~ 8 ~ r r ~ r:: tV\ rfu· ·[•~ rt "'&\.. l. ~E ,.'· ~t
I . ~ ~. ~ r:- ~ I J ~
~ ,a & ""
I.
i ,t. . ~ ' i ..
G .f, .
~: .~ t ~ ~ '[ i' ~ £
''"O - c.. i. 1· r:: f. 11~~ ~ ~ t! ;':.·• ~
rt .~
i;; ~- r - " s- &_ ~i
c· [" ~.. • \~~Cl:~·~· i!l: t f i, \·.. ~ 1· I::
n, ~ 1!
~ ~.;··'':.: tl
~ I r:: ~ r:: t ~ .[ ~· - 1 ~ f f ~. ~- t· ti - Er~ 'b - - ~ - . -
~i 0-4 ~~ ..:.i~~I "lA c.:,l O"'L-,j ~ .l~I ..:.i~~ ~ ~ . ) ~
0-4~1 c.:,i ~ ~~J ~u, ~ t.,:i.,_a....,.;, '.! ul.o...G.. ~~~,Ji ~~L:. ~ b
- - -
..:.i~~I ~ .ll~~I Loi •..:.i~~I l.!l.l:i ~ ~ ¥ ..1.Li ..:.il.o.J.>JI J.l~J ~WI
;::- ..- t.:rtl ".-1tl.J
... .:< '~ ~ •
.l~I ..:.i~~·.~as'
"': J LlJ.I uJ~
· ~ DI L,.,J.L · ·- ~ti
J . .)-:!-4-'J ':'"'
.~~~I a.JI.J.AllJ "~.,JI
!.. tt .
i ..
~ ~
A 4-J' .. ~
•
.. ,.,,.,._.,,.
...... tt ..) lS:lt~
~ ~ ..:.il:_Ji t-4 ~ ' ~ ~ J ~ ' .)~1 UJ_;-1:, ~ c.:,i ~ il~i

~ ~~ c.:,~ .ll~~I c.:,i ~.J~I 0-4 , ~ I ~I~ . ~ ..:.i~~
.l.J'.JA l&!...u ~ ' c.:,l:i ~ ' ~ JJJ..uJI ~ ...ilJ
. ~ , ~ uJ"oai4 ~i
~~ cL>l:i~I ~ u:JJj.-110-4t_,.i.l1 l l A ~ ...ilJ 41 [ ~ ~~i
~ .ll~\11 ~ ~ ·(S ,.,a·,l:, .lJl_,14 t ~ ~ 4 ~I Ji ~I~ J ~ I
·0J?~I JJ-4> ~ IJ~ ~ ~i Ulb ~ ~i I~~ ~l:i ~ I ~ I
~ I -l).JA ~ ~ ~ c.:,l:, ~t,JI ~I~ .ll~\11 ~ ...il ''->?i ~w 0-4J
J~I c.:,~ Lo~ 6.~J jai <•~ ~ Lo,~ •• ~ y,, Lo))~ J.JWI c.:,\J !~~I Ji
- -
·~"~~4
Jts:j!J ~i ..:.i~ ~1 "~' WJ ~ ~ J ..:.il.>J~I ~ ,j~b,

~~ D.lL:.! ~I~ u:JJ_;.-..Jl ~ ..:.il_.>-'~I c.:,i ~ J . ~ I ~ 4..9j.-l.l
,J
r' l ~ I ~u,
'.! · t_ • ~ ,c...JI.J.>. •
. . ~~ ..:.i~~
··-~ti ".J.A ~ · L · 4J.lW~I
· .. t~~ ~~ • ' ~-~~•
.ll~\11 ~ ~J-«-" ,a.lb..~ ~J .~~ ~ ~ ~ c.:,~ ~J-«-" ..:.il.>J~l "lA
~,.>J~I ".J.A r'~ c.:,i ~i 0-4 ~~~~~I ~I~ .)~I ~ ufa.J_;J.I
·~~~
.. .
i~~'1t ..) t~\tt
i4 ....,..~, ~ J~!
.;lS::>1 c..:,A ~~ ~I .;121.c. ~I~~ w-4' 0.1 i, oiJI l.u ~ ~ I ~L-,J JJl
0~ ~ l tl.fgl ~ o.;..1.a.11 ~.,.ti o.u 0-"'°.G:; '"- ~.:UI A~)U . ~ I J.>
lS..b.l ~ . ~ I ~ .;\S:J'j ~ . ; ~ c.!ll.i.41_, .cl.J c.!:J~ Lo J......i '"- ~ I
- --
~.l~ l..otzjl ~ ~.... ,;.,IJ c.!:J~ Lo 0l ~I~ JJj-uJI ~ JS .;~I .,;a
0~~1 ~JJj-J.I ~ JS 'l>J->-f o.;~~J .~..... ;.,IJ~L.u~~J-&Ai~
~\.;JI 0~1 ~ ~l.,:JI ~.;b;.I ~i ~ l+J c.!:J..b. Lo JS'~ a..J_,~ ~ I
.) \£,I~L-~
~,.•1.i .-~.
L~
.r-~ -
- . ) \S:j~~ cG.!Gll o'.).r-
~I ~ ··-ti Lol ·'-'-'-"Lal
. ~. c.l·tl.
~ ~J -~
.;~ltl~t#lo.;~lo:U~ .i:~~)b.~IJ~~l~J_,_µ1
-
~ I ~ JJ~I ~~~~?JI w-4 ~ ~ I ~ ' . ' . ' "'! ~ I J.>
. (Bandura, 1999)
~~~I 0i c..:rA ~ ~fi ~ I J>- .;lS::tl .;~ ~ ~l.;J ~l~~I 01

-
-Lol~1Jsio.u~l~J0fi:j0i~ .~~l:u0J-4-....; " ' - ~ I
~~~I a..JI.J.a.JI ~Lu r=4 ~1~~1 l.u r'.lL.o:i '.·: '"! ol_,LuJI ~ ~
.;lS::>1 0F-: 0i ~ ,dl~ 1...S~J .~~\~~ls~ l.4..;..l.4i ~IJ ol_,LuJI_,
a.b.luJJ ol.b.11 ~- , '-'-&.A..U.J
.. .~ -:. -'-•I
[.)..L£JI ~
-
- '"=' -
. ~ Lol~I J--
-~('i ~
-
,~
-
. ~ ~ ' a.b.luJJ_, ~~~,
l~~~t.u·t·
.. • u~ . . tt
-~~- 4..1..d ~ ci~I Lo..91!1.bJ

-
fall : u ~ I ~ ~~!J 4.4J~I
~ ~ 1· l 1· t. f ~ C· -: f . . 8- C· C.. ;_ l>- , .,
->P, L ~ ~f. 2: t! Ci- :t· f: ~ .f J.
- .r 1, P C• t'> .~ C•
f~ ,.;.1- }.g .f·~ 1:~. .f·~ ' ,._ h »! :c
·~t. trt.
C h §O. , '
I fr_· r-· - F ;... ,f, E . £ .. I
lf' . r- ~ ~f [f.
I; ... .V\ Ci
r!~~t~
f. ~ .r
~ • t!
r,-
'l!- t!
C•
l- t- :c:t . ,t•~ . . Cip l{ f>'
~ 1 -
e-; ~ e-~ i. :
t l~ f g> t· ~
I r.! (• ~ 1(; !\.I J.- &C y • - Ir & • 0 ~
~· : C· !:.: y C· • , ~ I •
I
• 1·
(r;;• -C: ~
t- . -~ 1· 1 =·~r •
e-: • .. . ~- ~ _ .1: J..·
fr_·
•
c-
&C E r. ~
Ci..
\I) .... • ·~ ~:
·rs.
--=: ·[; ffe-~ ~- ~
I ,Ei,I~.~~[ 1
f. t i. l! ~. ~. fi . ..~ ~· i· ~ :. a .r.:.... ~
- t• 1;.n ):...,. -,.,..1;. 5=:t> .~ T _: (i'
/l- •C' f>
.Ff ~ c, t•. 1· ·~. · ·Y
~ r .r
.h \I) 't!. I
1~ • t! t:: l-
t ,c- •t• -(• .c- '-' . ~ ~ !:~
t1 ~ _f.
1. ·r -~ $ ~- i [ :i. £ g .f 'F .e: t
C• t. } Ci
- r-l 'tt·i.
h &C
'G~
!• .~G: ~[
.,
r 'f ~
E!: ~! ~. k ~ 1 - O _,.
;i i~r::_f-.~ 1
I~
I:; -,.,
·~.~~r;B ,._ -. - · • , •• ·~ .r, i ·i· f. -r ~ {. ; l.
~; I;, ~· '~. C -1
t_!.
~-1 l 1r ~~: > h·r~ ~ ~ ~"' .f, ~ ~ 1
i r ;~ ~· f ~·
f' ,, . L , . , ::s .r .p- , ·b ·Y ~ ~
[, f, .e ·~- 'i. f
g [! -c-. ..
b. .. . 1... E'.
,,, r,"
C)f I
~. · i- 1 t l ·~ ~ fu, I:; L• ",..,.. • - ~ • 1'
~~ 1 ~ r b ~ ";t t:E ·~ ·r· ~ E i.L. ~ re PC..
~. fr:
t ;:- C· t! ~ &C ~ ! ~ ~ - ~ c.. - .f: - (• - I
••
[, j~ ,f:. . ,
t c-
,._ lp
·Y
~ 1~ ~ ~ c! ~ f- t ~ J..•
r> ,r; } ~ !i [! r.. f [
1· c... , ~ C· ~· Ci ::\. ,t c;.· - r;; ~ ~ ~ ~ ,fl-' t•
£1
f tt
·~ "°, t~ 1· (• 1· .~· p ~.. ~ ET 1-· l ~ ~t .f t> c.
~ 1 r·. N· B
1! ~ } . l: -;" ~ ~ f. ~ i l ~ f, .f •(i t' E5
'\. I ~ h;
~ ·t: r- 1 c- .
;. ..C· E'. C·~ .. t;~! ( I; p
I, ['"" - ~ \I)
~ -,., ~.['"
f' t~ ; c- c ~ L. cf.
• ..... [ '· - 0 • ..1 - I)· l..p
1 1 -c· ~ ~. ~· ..
t
t ...
lrt. c, .t'-
• '
E!:
• - ~· t' ::r - ,;
~
C:rn
t
l,
PC..f.'
~ ' •
- t
- ,
C:
C
, c· ~
&
-
~ -
~· • • \I) 'b ]
.c-~ ~- . 'r e-'.
[ (· ·r. ,-: t ~· t
~ ~ b t' ~ c·
.r ~. - _:!; - I:;
{- }~ ~:t. r~- - i- </~. i~ . lf'~ t ~r~ tl' ~8 f-c !: itt t-c~ l-": '\.ft! 1 {'~. t't' 'l'·~,E £f'• •t.~
i~~tJt~~t
~ al~, ,.:Jl.#.,1.-w,.;..s~ ~ ' ~ ~ , n.=iroitl tli,i 0A t_,.;.ll ,~~ C
""-~~IJr \..t:-.i.ll J t 4.J~

· ----=tiJ ~
- - I Jo~
• .:. -~'L. .)~
•• -~·'L.IJ b- .'.) L;JI c...e·'u--,'
· h.q r.,.,-:
.1. Lo
~UI J~i .)1 ,;.,,.; ,111 J-AJ ¥~I .)l~)U ~ i [j~ c.!lll41J -~~~I
~ i ui ~1 ~4J . al~,~ aS'.)LlJ.I .>J~ ~w, .)Jal o.;1..~,., o~I
~l ~ ~ ~1 alyill ~ ~I ul:sl.Zll 0A all~~I u~ ,~_;1.,;. ul.;..s~I "~
- ~
~ I ~J - ~ '->t ul.;..s~I c.illJ j:.A uy~ ~cu~~~~ L o ~ ~
~ ~ i ~~ ~.)L;JI ~,-J~~,.,
uy~ ~~, all~~' u~ ,l.!Ll~ 0A ~w,
-~~~I .)l~~I ~ ~I.) uJ~
t)~t~~~tJISl!
~ ·4Jj.-J.l.)LS:,jl~¥~1.;l~~lc o .=i«oi~~~JJJi
.)~ ~..u u""="' 4.....,jl.:i ("S ,,;;t l~l ~l Ji ~_,JI "-41 UJ~ ~.J.JI all~~' C
all~~I ~ ,c.!.lJj 0A ~~ .al~I c.!l~ ~ aS'.)LlJ.I r~ Ji aS'.)LlJ.I u~Y"'i

c...e·-'~.~
~ ~
. . ~..1.A (',S,J.. l:s~.. (.)·La..J ! ... q .) ts:,jl.J~l~lll.i..c.u·'
• .. IJ~ ~· .. ':J"' (· . .!-1.
)j~ ~ • .J.JI
~~~I Js,:.,;, ·.: .(Anand,Ashforth, and Joshi, 2004) ~~ ~ ~.)t,;.

L.Wlo
..
b~IJo~
'.) ~
.<-:Lo~al~I-'-:'"~as-'.) ~ L
. . .(.)..,..... •
~.~,, r,,,,
~ l ~ I .()A ,._.r -,,,:
.c...el.JA~I ~ 4~ ~
u""="' alyi.JI ui J-A ~ ~fi ~ ' ~ 4_,_;.-J.1 .)LS:,jl ~,.)J ~,~~, ul
~ . ~.) ,-.r1~
-<--: ....
t,;. ~< ~ l ~ . ,':J"', "~ i.h..:i
-~
... cul:s~ i ...: r,-... o~
-'-- - cu..u
..
t5Y"'i JAi~ Ji ¥.#1 J-A~' ui ofo J ~ ~ ' ~ 4Jj.-J.I .)LS:,jl ~~
.)ts:,jl ~l.)J ~ c;JI u~l~~I ui ~_rll 0AJ . alyill ul:s~ ~ j i ~ L.J~
~.<-~'I '-'-'-',,u.J • - • 'L · -- ~~ ~
~J-W • • • r-'"'""..)-' . J-:!-4-U - • I .r..u a.I~ .. -~'I ~
· .•<-: ..J..)-"*'
- w..,_.... · a..J .! ... q
- J~
r---~
I,.:,
c.illJ ~'-:'"..
·~ J..Jla:"JI r~
A •I .. I ~
-~
.. IJ ~Lb.JI ~.. !Jef- ~. ~, r\..t:-.i.ll ~ . ~ ,...

.4~~4~~lul:s~I ~'tJ---'-"..,..U~UJ.lc...e~l~J . u ~ I
- ..
I~~ a.I~~ ufi:J 4Jj.-J.l .)lS::,! ~1.)J ~ c;JI u~l~~I uf ~_rll 0A
-
j.,#~I ~ 1.j~I J~~I l.S~ tLl3.)4 ~ c;JI ul:s~I ~ all~~I t5..u
~ a;: rr,11 ~ I ...u.J:i ,c.!.lJj ~1 ~~1 ·l.j~I r~~IJ tl~~IJ ~I~
u~~, 0A ~..)-8,ll [.)J.l14~ c;JI ul:sl.Zll ~ ab! , ,JI_, ef-~~, jyilll
.ul:sl.Zll c.illJ ~ ~ I ~ 4JJ.uJI .)lS::,l J~J rl~I
..~--~.,.,.-...... . _...._ 11>.,.~....,~,....__,___,_, ___.r-...:'.A~--...::-.,_ ~-,1V111=,11"1_,._~~.1"::"'~-~-~,....------~·~~
~~Llaa~'?~ll.oJl!l~l~U :u~l~J~~~~I "'y
sUflwJ't ~U...J~l
ul.o·'
-~
... ~ Ll· t!..tl 1.J.c.~I ~
.. 'J--'.)
1... .J.4a.J .r.:UI
-~ I.?"·~1 a..a.a..JI ~·'
.~~
... f · · -
~ •~~ ':J .J:..14i ~t ~ .,t u_i,WI c4 &I~ ~_,kJI uf o,uL..ui ~ .)L..u.a.JI
~ •~ I ~ ~_,_µI .;~l 0-4 .)~ t_i, d.,j i ~ I.J.&21 a..a.a..JI y _,L.u i ~! _µ1
a.J_,~ ~ ~ I <-9~1 r'jl ~I~ ~Jj.uJ.l .;~l ~ ~.:UI ~jll
r~4 U>WI ulj <-9~1 ~ u_i,WI cuiJG:..A .;~! fa..>: ,.)~I ul.9~ ~
~I~ JJj.uJ.I ~ , ~ ~fi u_i,WI d.AIG:..A .;~'/ s:.~I ~_, .~_i,WI
. .)L..u.a.JI ul.9~.. -~' Ll~
.. ulJ>tA Il.(t-1
a·.j ~,... c.r~~, r ~I.-~ Lil· 'I ~,.~ri '!
'-?""" -· 'J-' • .,-,;w '-7"'
uL...1u u-4 L)~ ~l~'il ~ u_i,WI Wb _;\S:jl c..-,-k ~y ~I ~ I ~

~Jj.uJ.1.;l£>10Lli c:GL!, • tb;Jt JA lAJ yl~I JA lA ~~ uiJ .))-A: ui J>-i .)~
uJ.) u~sJIJ a...Joj~I J~ ~ .)~I ~.r.' u_i,WI Wb _;\S:j} ~~,~I~
Wb ~ <.::.4blA ~lj .)~I ul.9~ ~ ~.J.Ai Uifa. ~ I Ji.,,.!< .~,;tt ~WI
· -- ~tt ul.9\.Zll ~ I.J..L:,..
~~ ... ~~-· I - ~ ~.. . (~uJ-J -
' · ·w1 Wb J \S:jlu . u_j-l
· .l.4.U -
c4 f's:,~ ~ . d.d.bJIJ <JA}l.JJ ~~':JI f'&.a.J ul.9\.Zll O.JAI J:...1..aJ ~ b---'-"..,J4
-~.>&11 [.;..cil ulj ul.9\.Zll ~ a.bLJIJ ~~ 'ii j~I ~ ~ I &JI
l~~tJ_J~ :iJLa1&.ut
~WI JJ.) o.;l.uuil ~ ~~I _;I.J.c.~I, ;,.!i«oi ~ ~ ~J.?-i lAt
· L.)~
~ '-'. · :.11 .)~I o.J......A ~ I a.L......u.
.. • -- .uLLui.:,.JI
j• ~ • a.:,I .I) ~ <-9~c.,;,..wJ
- ~ti
.~u1 ~ .;1~~ .,~ ~ .,t ~L..u ~~ c:G~ .)L..u.a.Jt Jwi L.;l. 4,A ~ ~1
e:9.JA ~ ~jll .;...L-.A u~.,J.I ~ lA~ ~"~~I ~ J ~ J ~ J
~ u~ s:.k-.)':14 ~ I s:.l.&ji ~'ii'=' ,o;.~I ~J..JY. ~l...>-4 Ji Facebook <LJ~
.~Uo_, ~ "~ l.:?.:UI ~IJ ~.,JI~ lillj ~ ~ I
ui j1 ~ u'--9~1 ~ uJJ.¥b ~ W I JJ.)o.;~I s:.IJJ<Y°l~')/1 wl
~JJ ul->=11 <-9l->-1oi 0-4 ..b-lJ 1..9..,.._..b ~ ~ J ~ ((~~?II)) u'--9~1
JJ~ ~ a.!.'' cert\ ul.9~1 ~bl.A_, ·.?-'ii 1.....9~1 ~ 11a.!:I ccrtl)) ul.9~1
ul.9~ ~ts'J.;~I ~.;l~'il ~I~ J J ~ ~ ~~?/I ul.9~1
~ I ~1 ~.JA'-:-'-'-"Wl.;J.)o.;~I u~ ~. ~Luc.1.W U 41~Ji~)l;.i
- .. - ti
.;;1_,WI ~ WWI u ~ I ~ ;;t_,WIJ d..:,c~'il a.11...wl c,.:,k. ~ I

~·,r,...~.'C::~~cwc.~.'l~•····•..s::•~~----~~:".·.~~Y~'!."~""""",r~~'Wlllw;r;.:a."f.•~'llt'.,'l.':1~,·.c.-;;;;,,'.t-l',,tt;,~:...'l.1!...,...:n~c.•"'-,.~~"n,,,)~"'!,7,.>'>'"°"'~r"C:ilJIIIU
\AY' \+,~ 4.1.d ~ c,io:.Lll l.oJ ~~ faU : u ~ I ~ ~~!J 4-4.J~I

j ~. I . ,_!:,, ,•;, ,··:!/ (/""·';'"'r ,, '/'"· -~r:~::= ( . :···.':··· :'./.":.Lfy'-{·•· ·..,: \ ,:1y-f r;-:-~1:-:::::,., .......... _. .. , ·, :.. :-;,·)//,,• ~· i··~.I )..-=,=)/ ·,' ·=·b. /J. ;;..(·;= ...... ·.. ··. ·._. ·... j· ',' 1 • g; . .~ . -.: .:~ .;,:,.,· ·'"J.' ·:,, .( ,:/ .. /·:/··: ·.. '/.: I "i ~ .. ·\ ~. :· ... ;· ·.. ::-. u;-:,· ::-'"' ...:=,1 · ,~:-- ... '·:,: ,,,··:·:. ,'.: ·.1 · ',: 1
,a..JL.;...
¥~, ~, P.P ~)G.. oA <?1' J;-.b.ll ~ ~.J+A :;_p ~ , l.il r...L..l
..1.4l • ~ . i ) ~ <?11 ~L.will 4.!.t~ ~ ~ A~~I \+,o..G:i "'.! <?11 ~L.u_,ll ~
:;~~1 Jl ~ ~l oA ~1~~' LA\ i:i.! <?1' ~ I oA ~ ~.,_:,l c.JO.!'"M-~ w
''=L.u'J ' ;. -,i,oi•.
l.!11:i ~ , V" w ..1.4l .a.....bl
•. . ... -L-=---
.. ,...-:t 4.J~~'il
- " ~-Lg~- a.a.~
-
. :~~ ~)Ci o-11
~ 0J~~J aJ~UI ~.JA 1..-9~1 ~ ~Jj.uJ.l:, 1....9l~'il ~J ~l..>-'..>PJI -,
·'4 ~..,.11 ~.,.ti ~ly.JI
~l~~l.:.UI d_jJ~~J~IJ~lJ~I J~~Jd..:C~'il)~~l-r
·0-'.Y-~' ~ l j j oA ~4'=:1 ~i
·~Jl>. JAi~ ~ ~Jj.uJ.I ~WlJ~I J~ ~J ¥~I )~~I-,
~ I JAly.JI ~iJ - ~ ~ [j~ ~ ~ p_p ~ ~ 'i JAi~ 4.!.!UA
· - , •.~., ,t"· ·~~,,
..)-'j,,.....,., ' - : ~ j
·~l-LUJ a..u.b·''
· - W ~~, a..........,1j ..uJ .~
lb'il ~ - ~ ~~, ~
~~'l'IJr..,-"""".;JI ~~J ~~i~)l:;~J~~J~~.;, ,02'-§.J....JIJ
,, "
uO.!'Ui! w 'l~IJ .~t9.;JIJ r ~ ' i l ~J :;IJL......-.1.IJ ~.J-&ll [J.J:JI ~ J
· tI · ~,1 Ll~I .... ~ti ~LlA ~ aL.......u, U"'
~.r (>A '-?""' -
I(' ~1
jj
~ ~tt ~~I -· 'ii
'-?""' ~ ,-=- '-' - '-'
u' l ~.r · t\ <>4u.
. 'l., Lld~• ..1.4l ,J\ill ~~
I.· · ·· I.... • ~
_ a.h......u,
_ ~~~ • .<'-: • j
" •• L~ u.,..-,u
<.SjL..uall ~lj ~~I~ ps'l ~ ~fi «0j,WI d.41~ J~l» ~ ~

;s - -
~..,.11 ~ l g ~ 0i ~ u=o~ ~_,JI Doil 0i ', ·: '"! t~.;JI J ~ ~ o,lWI
"<:r.""JL;JI f3WI LA~~
TT :nmr: ....-:
Lf:,~ ~ ~ ti~t Lo_g o...b,,j tjU :ul.Jaat '=1'9 ->~!., ~~, \At
,~..,i.J't u~~
~I~ w,ul-ii ~ ~~I ~...G ~I 4UI ul,g~I ~ LlA u_,..;.lj.l.l ~~ (,)
.ulo_,.t.l ~~ 4Lo ut,g_# ..9i
~ .JAJ ((metaphor of the ledger» _,-..A ~~I ~I~ .)_;J ~l.11 ~ I ( " )
~ ~>'ll rt,;.; «ol ~J .<1~tl...-«.~I ~ . ) » ..9l <1u4L.....i..:.JI ~.)» o_;~I
cl!4?1 u_,..;.lj.l.l ~ ~l.11 ~ I r=4 ~lb:i..9 ci.,.,_J (('-:-'-'-"WI _JJ.) o_;~I»
-~_;l.~.U
ul:9)WI ~ J::i_,JI ~~I ~1 ((embeddednes t.,.._..,yl» r~ ~ (Y')
~~1.r?-l.!l_;Lot~~1~1..c.r~1 ~.., -¥~1..,~.)~~1..,~~~1
ul:9)Wl~J>.I..Ltllu q,oi.:~r \b,oll l~MarkGranobetter
:~I • ~_;L;...9 uLJo..UI J;.b ~.)~~l..9 ~~~I
Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem ofEmbeddedness»,
American Journal of Sociology 91 (3): 481-510, November 1985.
~ ~ I a ,o,o'%tl J~I c.r-"' ascribed rights olb.l.l ..9i a;_, • ,ti J~I (t)
~~l0-4~J~~J ~~~ ~JJ ..u..9cG!~ ~o.)1_;1 ~i .)~
J.,~ .;J-'o"}U ~.)~~I JS..,_J.l..9 (~l ..,t ulS' lfi~) t.,lll..9 o-uJl..9 a:;J.J_,.t.l
~l..9 ~ll.11 ".)~ .)yill ~~~I a:11,i<'JI J~I ~ I J~I
-~~~..9~l..9~I~
\AO
Canan c. Albrecht,... :~1 ""~U.,S 1 ~•~!
Matthew L. Sanders.1,6'U'""' .J ~IA
Daniel V. Holland 6oUY~ .UI J:!l•~
Chad Albrecht,.., ,t,~1 ~L:,
~ I J ~ I J ~..; q';; 11 ~ o..o Jo~ r~4 J~~I t.,..:0.jA ~

JS' (5..u a Q..;..;,JI 4:!lUI a~~~I aw~ c:,lS' ..L....sJ .4.4WIJ a 4 ~ 1 ~1>4J
Xerox ~J>J_jJ WorldCom rlS'..>.JJJ Enron c:,~TJ Satyam r~L.r, alS'~ o..o
Cendant c..,jl~J HealthSouth ~JL.u ~ J 'fyco ~l:iJ Qwest ~.fiJ
'ilJJ HIH ~ i 'ii ~iJ Harris Scarfe ~.J~ v.&&J..;LAJ Parmalat ~LA.J4J
c:,I.J.d ~ ~ ~b Vivendi ' i ~ J .Livedoor Co .JJ~~J YGX ~1 if':"
..>6.. ~~, ~ ,•,qs 111l ~ .(Carson, 2004) J~\'I t~ 4-Aljj ~ ~ ,
c..:,11 o~IJ o.J:!~I J'-4&. \JI a ~ a..>l ~ .rJWI ~6:jf ~ ~\rt Jt..,-~t ~
()? t,iS wJ>t1 as'~ ~ . , b i . ~ alS'~I (5..u J~~I a\bb.:..,, o..o o..>.J..Ll.o J~T
~ J ·rlS'..>_;J as'~ (5..U i,w.aL:u 'i.:U\S'~~~I J~~I a\hhM a ~ I
~~1 ~~-.H ~L.r,J o_;-""° ~ ~~ 'i.:UI J ~ ~4 J:!S]I ~ ''i..>yi.11 '5~1
'°'
a.:,o;.~I al.A.,.WI ~ J~~IJ(t ~J ~aJL.u_;Jl:&11 ~~)
~I al....r,~IJ «c..,j~},, ~WI a<: Ml~ J~~I al..>lj...oJ phishing scams
.~t} ·.•. -:<'t~I ...L.J· ·'I J b .__j\J~~I ..... c.:r·--u~ a..,~
J L&:,..b:s~I ... tl U·~\,.:,
... t ,l'..>""~..
c_- c.r.u--',.
.. ~ . ~
.. - ..
- ..
r..l.4'JI ~ , ~ I &..o t ~ ~ t~?. WI.> 0\S' ..>~IJ J ~ ~I 0T ~.;JI~
...
a~~ c.:,-- '- ~

·~L~- 'I L~I
.. · ~,
cJA ... ..>~ r=4 V""""
.. l)-'A '--t·~'Lw-J~
~ • .. .L~<"-:tt
~.,..~
·(.}'A 4..1 ~ rJ ( . > ~ ~ J c ) ~ ~
iJ~~t~_,li
JJ\JI -~.,:Sll~ 4.a.Jfa. ..>yi.JI ~,~..l.A ~ ~~~ ( j ~ J 0Lc.j, 1.!.Jl.lA
,c..:,1J\JI aJWI ~ .d.&...bJI J.,_,Jo ~ ~u11_, ~, «u::--JI ;;~ ~~4 cC«s.J-'-" ~
·t'~ J4d,I '¥-..H ..>yi.JI ~ ~ult ~J 4.&-4 ¥_; <JJ..> cu~..l.A ~ ..>yi.JI ~
W\
Jl ~ I J tl.,.;.J4 co ,oi,: 0.,:SWl u l ~ ~~~~LAA t-'""Jf ~ J~~I
.(CERN, 2009) ~ ~ c,ll o.l~ ~-l.S:! ~J ~I ~~4
<.j.J-Abll <.§~~ ,b b:u ~ a.6.! cu)\S° ~ ' J~~, a~L>. ~~1

~..Jb.JI Jl.,_b <.j.J-Abll <.jY~ ,b bv r ,.;.; «111 <.j.:UI c.:.«l_,JI ~ .Poonzi scheme
a\.!;.!.« cciJI ~1...1:' ~ ,,Charles» jJJ~ ~J Carlo -'1J~ " ~ .lj,t: ' ~ 0J.l
-
~ I ~ «..,jl~» ~IJ\'I 0,J_; Q~; cccaU ~bll <,§Y~ a\bb:M i.:.c.A..19 ~
,
rJ-11' J-41~, '<.§.J-4bll ~ , ,~~J-~ ~0,J_;Q~; ccc"0A ~ ' ~
~J -0-J~I 0A o~ i.ll.uJ ~ 4mt.l c u ~ 0A ~~ ~ 0i ~
.cuJl-ll 4.a..o ~ ~ ~ rJ-11' J-41 ~ ~ , J\..ajl ,~lhll ~\..aj
-~.l\..;J.I ~ F~ ~~ lt
J~)U -, ~ '~l:a.o <.j.J-Al:tll
-
<,§Y~ ,bb;... ~
..,jl~I a~4,. ~ ~ ~ al_;~I 0A a....lll ..,jl~l 04 0-J~I ~Jl ..La.l
~ ~Jj..--J-10A ~ ~..U F l ~ ~ . .)~\ 0,J_; Q~; cc«Jl 0A .l..U:. JIJAI 0A
J->P-t .~~ ~ J.,laA ~~ ~ J ~ I ~ ~ I ~ J ~ ~~IJ ~ I
r.is ..La.J -~' ~ ~ J~~, tl.,:St ~\S' 0t l§.J-Abll l§Y~ ,bb:u ~~
<,§Y~ ebb;... f:1..14i ~ J .a;~IJ ~i d_j4 I~~ ~IJAt 0.1) Q~; cull
-4Jl.d ,~ c.:.«lJ ~ ..,jl~ '->.J-4l:tll
c....a:;ljJI _;~I«.«: «u: 0.1) Q~ ,cell y ~ LA -
'
~i LA 4JL:. ,J\!i.ll ~ ~ ·'->J-"bll ~I~ JJµI alJ.is 0 ~ ~4
- -
-
~J 'LA~~ J)b.1.t. a:
-i: .Jj~ f:1..14i ~l..b:a........u4 0t 0,J_; Q~; cul I '->y~
CCC
~t 0~-':!0A~01,~l~J .(SEC,2009) .l~I <.jl ~~l..o ~~

•~ 4 i.ill~ 0_,.,,~ ~~ «llil..o» ala.i...o 0JA..ld:!
,
J~l{r)Ja~l~~~~Y-J~l{')~l~J~~lc o.!i•oi~
~I ~'--'a~I ~
· -
a.A.uJ~~l......s::;'.
- - .~(.)'°
~~IJ a ~ I ~._s::;
-~
0A ~ d..w1 ~lhll ~\..aj ~ lj.l~ ~J ·t-91_,ll ~ ~ ~ w ~6. ~ t ~
rl:Pl-i d.J6. ~ I~ ~..b- .isJ . ~ I ~..ul ~ Jg~I ~ , ~ 4 ~~_;I w
~~LAIJ .y ~..,JI FJi . ~I~ J~I d.J6. ~ t ~J ~I~ Satyam
as~,~~
.,;s-t J.J..ij 0\S' J~~I yl~:i_JI 04 B. Ramalinga Raju ~IJ
~rWIY-..ul ~J wt ~ t f-'» .J~\'I J~~ ~~j.Jj.s:ilJ~lri
«a Q..;..;,;11 ~l:ull y ~ ~ l:JLA~ f-'J as~,
0AJ~J.lJh..b-lJ ~JJ
~ o.l~ ~~10~ a ~ I ~ ~~ <.j.:UI J~~I ~ J .(Raju, 2009)
a.c.4,11.., u~.,.ll ~ r~ ~I ~~I J)l;. 0°4 cl.:10.;. .~. ~UA ~ JJ 10:>JI
~J.:.:·; ~..)~ ~~~~I ".L.4i ~ ·'5.>="-\71 ~l..>,b\71 o-4 ~~ Ji s:.~IJ
~~I~ ~I.) ti~ ~~I~~~ J~~I ~ ~ ~ ~t,_;....u.1
("\-\) JJ~ .~J.;4,JI J~~I tl..~i o-4 ..l..1.e. c.!lLl.A ,~a.:i,oill ~~ ~ J . ~
ts
. ~ ...l>.IJ ~ ~Jr'~
J ~-JI ~.Jli (i-') ~J J.t~
u~~ ~I ~J~t J~-.tt •
- fJ-1
a.:c.:lo.,JI ~jSl..,..l 0~.,.i.1 ~ ~l~L.o ~~~ uL....)l.....i....;.I
~ d_p...L.A ~ JJ 10 .,....!J ~ wal:,_,J.I
~t ~J • "4,L~ Jl ~ I ~L.o
.L:.~ J~~, tl_iil
t:)4,o .;b~ uw~ ~4JI r~ ~ ~'
.l.l.&ll a.L11, t ~.l "~ i ~
- 4.fo.ill 4.fo..il a..c. 4J I ~- -
"l..JI u~l.u:,..I
- J -!.J~ .J - ~~1~4JllsJ ~
- ~ JLi:i~I ~I.A~~ .u'-4.,.;JI ..9l
J:WI 0~~ ~1 ..9l i:~1 ~~ ~ ~ c;JI 4.fo..il I ~j:~ ~lu~~I

(JA ~ ' ~ ( J ~ ~l ..9l i~ j:~ I.A
. tl.,.;J I J.,_,>k 0£. 4.fo..il I
~UI uLl4+,lL:i o.;b?/1 ~)l:u ~~' l.!l)L...o 1.S..L.>} o.;bl 1.§.;b?/I J ~ ~I

w ~6. ~ t J.J.il as-~, ~ · · "1.J.JI
~ Jl/J ulS'~I ~J~~I)
~J~~l<J.At_,.;.JI I~-~~ -~'J (~Uluw~I
.J~)ll ~ U\S::i~I
~ o.J....i\ J~~I tl~f ~~ L,)j) Q

:.I -
I I II OS:- w;-lJ ~ I t' ;JI
( u..:,..,..:u1)) 4:J.WI
~J
a.a:;~ J ~ I ~ J ~
~' wfoWI ~J~~,
-~l_iil
L_.;I
(JA
Q ~ i
I.SJ> t t'~ l..9

~I
~'~' .)~~ ~..u ~~~, i:~ltl..G..

.LsJa~~d&.~~
~ a.a:; i:..,..ll ~ ~ c.J,..91.§t -ti~~,~ - tl_ii~I~ (JA I.SJ-,>- t tl-.,_j l

. ~I..G.. ..9l 4\&.l.,.;J J>i '-49_,.l.l ~ ~ ~ I Q i • .! J~~,
U:S_,J.1
. Albrecht, Albrecht, and Albrcht (2006) :. ; ~ I
,~,
r [ N. ':'..:. p.• • P.' ~ ~ ~ ~ {
'C• : 'tL 't. (, 't.. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ •
=-: ,c;b, •<t,r'- 1 'E!.~·
s::"' I l': ~. I, I, I, l, [.,' r:-
,Er • L- \ (;i V\ J::
- - -< -1 C C _,. y
t ~~
t ~ .s l ·· .;; f.:. 'ii D ~ : : : t ~- ~ r
;~ ~ l· f ..: ~ f ·t f ~ ·f ·t· ·:: (• 't t
t ~~·~I: \'L <t: ~I ii~ l ~·\
.f 1 f '&, •f [ \ f
n. ~ C• ~ 1) D
~ h: s- -.r (· <r: t.. .
~ q ~~f ~1•
t t ~~ l E
~'>I i~•
~ -
a,• C \p_ l, - l, I I f~
r.t' [. ti r. E: t' ~
J:: ., l V, \i;., I - - • • 1• 't:
i:!. •
·- ..
t '°.
[• 1r I t• • • l, I> - ~• -:- (:_ ~
f
£ • -~.'\ t s r. E· i r:_ f f,
I I • L'
c ,r;- "'"1 -
•C Ir f" •
t.r 1\ t ;-f, 'f~
P' £-~ a=
"&• • • ,-.. I C C • t I ~ ~ •
; ~ ·f ·i ~ l· ~ r, ,g. rt,•
~ ~ G-. a- c, ~..
f •
~c;'
r~ !J ;:~ ~ 'b .-..
t "°~ 1e.. .f-}-f-. -t 1 1(11·
E (
C IC -
i~
•t ~
~ l.f,. 'J- -:'~£; ; ff. ~J;"
- • (:_ I • I l, ~ I
if . ,- §~ Lfl~
,-.. • I:! ....._,, \o
t,-.
~
- '.:., }. '.; .;_ £ D. f fl: ,c t' •£;
1 f t° 1;._.. (; •~
G_ - ~~ C• ,P.' - (r ~ ~ ~ f ·E: 1,. c..
-f~ 11111 i r
- 4t.. ~ ~ t. C• .r, c_ ~: l, - ~ ,r; •t=:" Ci:- ti(
~ E]: c' •I=; ' ~ b C ~ ·~ ~·\\ f r -;
. 'l l': • t! C.
• '~\ -~ tf ~ ~- l
_: c 1. !
l ~ ~ ~~ C•~ C:- C
~G !~ ~ I"'•.: 1.
c\\ - . ~- c_
, 1" r.'. [ J . ~ - f'~ • c... £ ~ 1'} ,f ~: ~
'.i:. • -t ~ ·~· t'. .f ·t'. f- : ·~ 'f, :r ~ I;, l, :.; r
; I E'\ ~ ! [. ! E t i ~ E' l ~ I~ }
:;
- Ii .<;- it:
~. r..., l,
f. bo!" 1)r- C·
V\ t"'
-1 I
(.
f: t~
- X ~ E
I ·~ [• l,
i. :r '1 ~. f ', C· -
c-
}fr.~:
c..tl:.f: -
~
I t· 'l! -..
........... 'f, ._:_ ,E S' 't
I ~ f ~: • 'k ~ :~- :
1 ~ ~ ~· f !W ·~ . t .[ ~ ~ 'fs
~'1 ~· ~
X
I t~tt\~~! X
. t
·~ i c...- .
lt
- :t)·
[fee_.
1; ~ .:_· ·'6f
I - ~ l, ,.
r i 1r 'f, i ~ ~ ,f :' -
fl V I;" ~
:f's t~- 'it~ V-S ;i-: ~.~ 'r~~ L
f'
_c [• C· ~ t To ~. - t· ~" '.: ~
.Fl r;, \ l ~ J f ~- ·~. '° loo! - I. ~ t' ~· :; t
C'~
~
t· \·· [-,
.t1 1· . f J- ~ ~ J• ~ l,
- .l• • '} i;
'·1· t- -
c,- r . ~- ~iET
C: 'v" b' r r"
1f 'l:r "bo! I 'c
~
.:~~ ~ 1_ 1: t 1· i i fl
,._ C .- (. :-.
,P
I:; ·~" _,. { ti 9' ·~ •
- > - - . -[{ [-[• .bo! t,
.~ ~_,., ~.
[• C-
-.. 1·t .!c-.
·C" -
{; tt[·:r (;,·i·r[ ~ 'r' ~· cf
Jd rc l· ~I ' •~. 1 bo! ,~.:. :.!
~ f) - \
l, I ~. bo! -
. . i·c' ,c;1 te.~
- E!r;. !::;;;ill
~ ~~
- < lo V .ls>·
I,'
i:;~
f C~ t,
-<
t;-
t- '-.D r>~· 0;::::.. - I
-
t
:[
•• ii • • ·E t·
~ L X _
C• ·Y
<:.- •• C- o-~ . - l tfJ.'1. j
[• (.'f
£f _,. • r[." ~ - C• L• V.
f; ~ <i.' • f l, • b ~ f)I c-£ ~ ~f:lr.
~1 _,,_ ~ 11!
l, ,. [1
I ~ ; ~I i- bo! ~• I~ ~ ~- c...
- I• C:
\. I 't ;E <;- :E-
t~ ~
fc_ ~ . f. f c... :t ![
~ ~ ~~ ~ ~
-< ~. -1 q L .f 'f,
r~ II l ~ ·~.h ·t
[• [•
~, c.. > ~ ~ _i c 1 1 t~
~ 1 ~
f). 1-C·
Ff lo·
F it ~c-
J... I L I•
t1 'f,bo! ·.• t t 1'' 1 s·~ l 1 s ~ ·~
•& •
't.- - • &
cf. !, ~ C· :_ \' C· f"' 1 1· { C• ;_ C• ~ t' C• J; ·~ c.. !J
r:" ~ ~. 1• f>I C- C (1)
~ "
,f>· ..... L
L, 6 C -
I:: ~.
~ ,,
d I
,l' ~ tC I _,. ,.1:. . p I, .... 1
;i - •
11.t' {~ l;f; 1i, ~• ,t:r (/\
r:. C· I I •I ti.!
,C- I [' l)
r-
I
·r r .e-• ;_> 1·f: v ,!""' I I Sf ~ C>I f t
_f, • I '-, i
~ • ~ I I • t::. ~ C· \.S> - • c... ,C
~ ~ '° "r • N ,I:.. C· £' ~• ~ t. ;.·J
O ::r L-. 1,
"[
:~ ! i,. C, - .:· 11C, ~ • '!.. - 0 . - ,c;
.1 -E: I C· - ibl'
11-t
''
,l t
't,
:·
~:~
r-·
b- C: ~
t r- i c· - ,[ I:"
~ ·fu,
fu'·
.f " f- ~
~ r e.. . C·V\
e· •t: . ,
~ _:. E· -=; :[ i:l t t' ,t O -
1t. ,c;
LI
_:
~ c..
l r
(;, .
~ ·(j.. ~-·r- '.::j
fc'1
E ,J:; s- ·~- "ti.! <v- :·:···l

I, I~ I '·I
~
~~ i - 9°
r:
L• e,,! ~
l ·~ L. 11
r~ f. 1·tL, I ,C-
F>"" c·
J-
- I
L
C:..
-
_
·t € .
t~ i f f~
- • .•
.,,
[,. f I ti,,! C:.. " ~ t! ~ • - • 1 I
}
~· I, ,c; £, L. 'I I ~.:·····11

,,
rl. cf ~ 'li ~ f. ~
C· C...
"r;; le. I,[ f1 ,C- ('f
,C- h
ti
a,•/,
tl .b- l:ti, "'r I
<'(. ,C-
~~
•f;
t: Cj
~ ~~ t - . ~i .. ~ ~ C· ~. ~:.:
J:::; I - I • uc;. - [ • ,(; - •L C• t') -1 .1
•• ~, ~" (_ ,C- 1\ V•
p '.- c.. ,C- .., r> P.'
,C
"l i . ~·~~ [.1-E;:- 1;"~·
\D ~· ~ 1 . c.. ,
~ ~ tf>I [ - I, C· ~·.. ,f; F.:.l
[1 ~ f.' [ flo,!t I ::r t ~ •, C ~: ~ ~
r -
'f, ~.~.
1- I ~• ;; • I
~ f) • ' c_ -
~,.
- [, ti.! v· .t:- ~ 9" E!
~ r
~ - .1.. ~ llo,!t - _ ~
h c.. · ~ ~ ·i;, V f?.!
E ·r ,J:;r · - c I ·[
'\,. !, [ t ,r- t_t 1-fI-:- [, [, C
1J· 1. ~c.. h'
- 'I> I I I I ,,!
tr;~.~-f
·~-I 'f _: ( f ~ t"b t: [ t· c.. £ 02 c.. 'f v f' [',. . \D f, LJ
r r • ti.! C• ~· C ~ 't f \0 '-, r-" i ~ 'f
~ ~ [" i [ ~·~ p : l,. ; s i
~t . r 1:;; ~. J· .cc.. c, t t 1.1.,_.1
t. [ [• V G,. [ [! '!...
ErIr .(j..[ 1~-~ :tE ~ ir ~r {f ·~-~ r [I
l£' ~ ~c.. ,i!..D C·- ~- ~F ~V .~·~ . ~c.. ·~ ~i=' ~9" Ci~ I
~ !t~ -:
~ - f>I ·E
- _
i. ~ ~ _: ;:- _,. I, , tr· I C•
to4' '\, -; r,
t '1:! t-.::j.:.-.·.'
r ·t-
.-~.: 'f ~ 1
c, 'f c -:.. ti.! t; 6~1 •~ I {X~I' ::J
'. ti.! \.S> ·~ ·~ [ ti.! (r C•
I -
t r~. 1··E t ·~.
- ~ f>'
I .~
I [, ~ ~
I:: c::-
b e-. 1 ~ '\.. } -~ ~ f [ ·i f ~ r. E ~U~ 1° ~ - ~ ~
I t-r·-~~ 't Ec-:bc·~.
t ~· ~D\ ·~ - 'ti t !..
t F_ 1
"[ ;- ·t' f' ,"' t ~ ::; t '\ ~ l ~ .. ,l ~ !::
l f
Ci C• } ,C· c-; _ ~.:?·.11
~ ti.! [•· '> • 'l.. ~ f.. Ci" '1 [
- ,c;
!~ ~ ~ 1_ ~ ~.l ~ f 1f -[, _: f t -.£ ~-ft t,r· r.; f vc, e..g .f· 1, 'k "t r
~· P !C b
c.. r: ~ t C· '.J. -
I I ,. llo,!t
r~ t=i ,L ·~.
[•ti.! c·- E ,t'>• c;.· .'.'
! ' . { 1:: '~ l 1:: ~ ' l: f le• ~- & 1t t
l
::I ~ i ~ ~ ~ l l: b ~h 'i' ~ i. :c- t; ~ ~· ~ t .t: ·\. 1: ·1:: ~ 1: - H
:I b b ·. ~ 1· E IX
C
.c 'i. '£ t - !:: 'ttt{~t-t\'F

E c_ . t\. C• .fl
t L ~- ~ ·P~ .t
rE
l 'f, • .. ' . E b ~ f, '1/r
•t' 'f, l { t : ~ '& b •Ii_ --; C& .e I
~ ~ • 'b lo
It
,:;: I ,._ \.,
1· ~ (f:. c'
.,. \· } "' c_ E
-~ t 1;f i-~
~ -· f• .c _ 1
i f~ t
• t .- 'l
' ~t
~1- -~..\ . .cb 1
rL
l r V ~ ~ "°. ;- 1 ~\\ ~; c 't • • ~~
.~€j . ~e;.~. ·~.·t. · f 'fe ( f, '\. 1:. Ir- :-; ·L ~
1 ~~
t ··-r~~c_ I( -1_~ "'"'[ ~ lE!
i ('i. ~ ~ r· E IX .. • - ~. r ttl . - ·~. • ij-
rj
I:;
~ •
f. -
.r~1[·t~ l,' .
f. r· ·\rr~r·Er
ft . I..., ;; ~ I
--c
i. ,..,. .;- 1- . ~
~- - '\ I,
'
o,!i" •
q• -·
·~r;
~ a.. ·\. t .r· ! ~ •~
C (r ~ c,~C:b• •
ic, ,cf-S[~c li I
- C j:. • _,, 0 1
(-_ II '\I,
~
I! 1 l i , '\(_• [ 1,°. <i...f ~. ~...: ;'~
i:: ·1 ~r'5>1
.t. . f$b£.;-~ (. I
[, t 1· .·· E ~ ·
- - ~ C· · tt1'ff k~'ft- I
E l .1: r [ ~· -r
~ ~· tC
IX .t' l 'f b '\. bi ~ i
·i: ~- ~ l• ; l 1.° .-c_ ·ii
• I C7 -
t l · t!
~ I ...' ~
11(_ q·t .f ~ ·rsc.s I -;e '
I
t~
'bft1$t
~r·~t~ . 11 ~t-P! ~li ~! ~ ~
~~ ~ E:: ~ ,
{- ;i}f't!l f ~. r.. . ~ t_,. ~"' t ~v !i". fi r t- I
·, "::,~\.. -: -:-:-.=~ ~::· ·.. ·, ..: ::: .:·.=:::~::,:,;. ·;:::. ~-·:. ·. ··::·:·:=::-::::-::-·,.:._:: ·:·-::-,:.:=..-..::_::,_,::.~:. -:~:: :~~:=:·::.. ==-~ •::=,;
aUJ~t~~t
y~_;'i ~..u <jJI 4S_;.J.l.l Jo~I LJ-A ~~ J~'il ~ w_,l_,_µ1~
w_pjbi ,11.: 'i w~4JU) .aj4j0'>· Jo~,"~, wfiJ wl ~1 ~6. 'i .J~'il
. ; ~ wfi.: J.S .J~>LI u4-;. .~,JI~~ l& ~ , wfi.: '4 ~ y1w1 ~
~i~ · » T ~ ~ \ & ~ o S 1 J ~ ~ ~ l ~ \ & ~ I
- - ,
~
-- .).,'..H1""'14>.WI
bi j.J_)-4J • L_L_-:.l" • i~lb · · <.!l~ .("t a..JLA4>.6.Jo . .:..~q
~ i.;Y:,- ~ ,._,-.,J - . ~
LA l.>4-;. ,~. ~ ~ I J ,<'>r~I ~ ~ ~~IJ ,~I WA Jo~ ?JIJ ,~~

.~UI ~..111 ~.?.J ~ <jJI ~1~>11 WA ~..u:.J ,~I ~
as~~~ ~I Susan Jones~.?. wl.;J----'-" ~1 ~ , J u l . I ~ ~
- ~ ,
a:J~I w-,--u, ~J . WhA ,1 1§ .~,i\J ~y:, ~LAl ~ ~ . LAk rr LJ--4_;-ot o..\>.IJ
~~I ~ .«~~ ~...LA» ~1 c.J~ ; ; ~ ~ 1-!.U~ ~J ;;~ u.."t.scoi ~ I J
~...LA ~ i u...... :,ol LAS' - ~ ~ ~ b l ~ ~""'=Fwl tjbi ,11; ~~~
~l_,.;....JI J)l;..J .Home Shopping Network ~j.UI JJ~I ~ WA ~l..,__ill

"\ 0 • t • • •LJ--4 ..,=cS"i ~ I ~ b WA wljJ----'-" ~.>-'-" ~J.C. Lo:; ,- 4: <?' ~)WI C 111
~ c.Jb.i LAS' • ..\>.IJ rW ~4 ~ ~ J ~~I~ J.SJ -~JAt _;'iJ~

~ . ~ ~J-A-" LA ~l..1.u, a.J_,l,J. J:!WI ~ I ~ b c)l ~J.JJ ~ ~ ~~
t • · , · · • y_;~ LA .JAJ ~1)-:!-~J ~..u:.l.ZJI '-f.}1-"4lJ ~j.AA ~ I ~ b l ~.ig
~..11 ~_,..:; ~ ~ ~ I J LAS' •~->-'-" ~j_JI _;'i_,~ "\ o • , • • • ~ w---4 _;'iJ~
~lfa ~~ r..u:. ·.·: ·11!J -~ ~..u uJljLA ~j_JI .;'iJ~ ro ·, · • • .JAJ ~ t JUI
w~ «J~'il» LJ-A L..,l;.-~ ~ ~j_JI .;'iJ~ ro · , · · · ~ - ' ~ I ~ ~ J..-3..~
~ ~lfa ~~ ~lb:i Internal Revenue Service ~..111 ~lfa a,.,, o 4
. (Albrecht, Albrecht, and Albrecht, 2006) ~ I 0A ~J»- ~
~l_;~IJ_;~I ~ wLA~?JI ~ Jo~I 0A ~..all <.!l~ ~~ ,t:-#4
._;-ot Jl-"4i ~..11 ~j_JI ()J~~I ol_;~ a.J_,b ~ .,t a;,w~,., ~,., _;~IJ
\ 4\'\
~ 1· ~· f; £:. t· .e· ~ ,c:;...
t. e-· ·~. i !r~ r. ~ ·£; t·
-!
:: £ ,c:;.. -
<r-, . 1 'l.~}.Lc_~ ~c-~~~ lf;,~~,e-; e· ~ ~t- ·t.
E.. ~ • ~· - ' 1l\ ~· l> - ~ c.. - !.., P" .1: ~· \o J.. ~ c..
~
r ~- [ .c f":n b·
- ~: ~ ~ h •
c: ·l ·~. .c ·f-~ ·L 'f-:: r:'f~ -c~ ·\..·
.f" C- ~' ·<t. ~- ? ;
~
. ' - !i ' c.. .1·.-.:
t· - ' . . - { ·~ <t! '\
·r~
<r: t .L~ 'f- .!,
lc, t· i [t "~~: ~. ~- ~ f. ~ .~ ~ ·.,:· !
- •• \D. [ } b £_ ;- ·~
t C•· r·~· }~· ~-c I;, ro, ~
£. f~ ,c;~• .t' - - l)S Cf.l I> - l_, to,! b ~ I - C.. - rr: ~·~
.f. ~! • r;. C (• I
1~.~ 9o f: •-. . ,r,- J; ·b
l' :{· t-
~ t' ~ .b to,! ( [ N -
l~ ·~l.: I p~' e-·ti p- ~
1::1:'..·:_·.
r. I I!. e-; 1 t ~ 2 fl· ~ Cr· • to,! "i.;.r- ;f:{f
.t .- '. tg
'E. - •I=:" N 1
( "° [ t 1' l £
i 1- r--- ~"rr.: Ci Cif> c'Cir..,•
:l -; - . 1° ~ ~ .t' D ~ .. I •• -: ~ f> t! f> ~. 1· .r. t
t ·P 1.. ~ :r-· c- e f _: ~ ~ 1:. {. l- ~- ~ ,r. [ to
~ e-· 1 ·f ~ ·6' - ~ L 1>- ~s ~ ~1 ;" ~ r· ~ J. t itf { i
i ~- ~- t [, l .t' r .. ¥. l ·:: t 'r. r- ": .t· - ,,

~ .e $ -~ ~ ~ ~ e 1. l ~1·~·~.t
,:: 1)1
;t.: 1 t<r-1:- ~=c'.- ~.f .c-rr ·f~ ~ i"'~ cg'e.. ~~
1- :t \o L;
~Ii>· -r~ <t f-'ti J'I' r ~ r f" ~ t
[ J.. - ~·
l t
· ,( £ i .t -c· : ~ )· . - ;; [ to,!
c, t ~ f ~ · E· '1 · -t· r
~ qt~ ~ .r f
E
- t. ~ ~ ~ ·t f
f ~ 1· t'. . (• i=:t E . 1: c· ~li- -: ~t.. c.. le. - . '
~ <i" ·k t ~ II\
-f.1· [sf~
·[ ~. [• ~ i
1. ~ [lv"°~
·t' C· Ci • \o l; Ci • " - to,! p c.. '- to,! C -
·[~ }r ~~ ~.~ 1:Ft ~; ~ l~ 1 I :r: ~ E~ f ~ ~L f i t
~ . l G.. ' r;. f> - ~ f> • I:. ' ~ . - ;.( f~I h I;, .b
1 1
t t1. r ~it~ tr~ r l£ tI &!tlr:r t 't <£ \ \- ~·
~ ~ y ~ _,i lS~I c.)J.) ulA...G....9 u ~ ~..14i ..9i ~~ ~ J~i
.. .. .,
~I c,)J.) ~~bi c.:,l ~ ~ ¥~1 J~I ~bl J~l c.:,_,!AWI t.!b; "'.! - ~ ~
.... t • ,.t~ t• .,, ..
~ ~'-"(fl ~ 0 _).)Ut.A ~ ( ~
I•. :. '--1t f"'...O,,t'"_?.)
• LJ-::'
I.. .. ..
CC l ' ~
•
LJJ *.!
t...-I C 11.! J .., ~ ......
)~ ".-ti
~ ~ .is..9 . ~ I c.),A ~J.»' J.:.:= 11,iJ lS..?-j o.J-A o.)~I ~ ~ 4 al~ ell
~..14iJi y_jlhll ~ ~ l S ~ ~ 1 ~ ~bt.>JJ-ij a.J~I c.),A c.:,i ~~~I
'}}~ ~J ~LAi r~ IJ.ljj ~ U..i): '}} ~ i ·.·: I'! ~i O.)_?. ulj ulA...G....9 u ~
- ~ ail~ ~ j c.),A
.. *
. '..)-',, ~
d..9~ ~• ~LA~IJ a.,l:g. ,,.. ~
... ~ . Jl...u>.
.. '}}I ~.)-A
..
.<~ ~.)lJ.
• ..
" I ~-!'I :. ..
l.:r ~ y~
..
~ ~~ I ~ '· 4 LAL=. 0:--'
· :.~ ~Li.Ai Jl...u>. .. '}}I ~· .<~j - A ~ .,... .:UI ~·'I
.. ~ . J\ • as'·~
~ '-:""" -~- 'I
~J .~j ~ o~~ L!l.,LuJI I~ c.)J.)Jl-: ~ ~WI c.:,i ~ ,J..9~1 J~>Ll
.:1 ~.. J l) ~l..A
.. LA...G.. ~''"(to' .... '}} ~:. Jl...u>.'}11
f-&.I .. .)k"~I ~ ~~ .r.J.ll ~·'I
~
~ d.,jj ~ J~'}}l ""1~ '}

\-V-.-
~i ~ a QJ;.,ill
~ \-V..- •
C.:,J.»-~I ~ , ( ~
~
J ~ '}}I u '}16. t:4 JA~I ~ ~.;,3 ~I ulS~ I c.),A ..1:..aJI L!ll.lA c.:, i \.& . o~
""!
~
J-'""" ~ ~ i <fa,~I c.),AJ ~ I ~~?11 ~ I c.),A 1...9_,;.JI ·.,: '"! ~J~

J~'}}I c.),A _wj.J.I ~ ~jtll l.JA ~ , ~ I ~..,_JJ ·lS..?-i ~ ~tw Ji JUI
-~l~UJ_.,
~Li.A .w- ~J ~ ulA.,W.I ""1 J~_,ll ~ (J-'..J.)WI ~ ~~I c.:,~

.c.:,_,l~l l.AI~ c.:,f ~ ~I lS~I oJ~I ~ ~ oJJ.AJI ~..u ~ ~J ~~
i..# ~ t .,~ ~ ' ~ ,,t_)\-b'}}I o_,;b» ~ ~.:,.u ¥~' .)_?.Jr~~
~ ,~~I j.a.:,,JI ~J . .)l~~I J ~ 4 ~ . ) ~ ~ . . J ~l_,JI ~.,-Aw
~ J ~ I ~ . . J ~Lc. uLA.,W.I ~ ~J WL.lu ~ I ~ ! um..u.1
~1~1 ~Lc. ~ J -~~I ~ ~~J ~WI a<:
.~,JI ~l_;.l .)~1 ~i c.),A
• ~.) ~ .is..9 a.! cceiJI ~ tki.. ~~ «<fa,j4ill J)l;. c.),A 0--4~1» ofo ~~,
Q
.:..<f ~ ti 'I .. < ,-:.. ti ...

O.)":._H l.i.u.)JJ""'- ~ U J ct:
.. I . ,It· I.... .., .. ''I ,II- ... ~~~.'I
~~ ~'..)-1--'-"f ~ to/ ,";,• ' ~ ~
.
~~l~L.u~l..9¥Li-...!JIJ~c.),AJl.ullc.),A~I~~ - ~ ~ l l S ~
.a.J~I ~~l~I..Li.11 c.),A .)~J ~Lal c.:,IJ~l..9~1 ~~I a~.... ,oJl..9
f' ~ I .'-:"""~~,~~I
.. .. ~l.a..,}1...9,,,,LlLi-...!JI
. -r. .. · ~I ,~JI·~'!
<)A ,,.. J
_,.,.... <..,--
r
• ~1-" '-:"""~.
1- - '
*L. ~-~ ~ r ~ I., L~L
.. . .)~.. -.
I ·'}}l~l.Jlc. ~·
~ J ci.J.A\S ¥ ~ u)\.A~I ~ c <, «~«<JI ~ ul.cJo.al..9 .)l~~I ~ c.:,i ~
:; ; ~' C· C· C.. ,1· fr.' 1· s-: r• ,t' ~ 6- [, ,[ l, ~ ~ ~. ft.' ~ ~ l...~ [1
.,0 I. !. L f> L· f>
~
~i -~ r~ ~ .r,-
• ~·
, .,. ~~· ~.. c:.. V -
• b/..t ~ ·~ cf ,<;' ~ 1· . ;
11 ~
•: .r
rE f> ~
~ f>
C-
1 c.. ·Yr-
.. ~
ijr,i
ffl ~
E•
~ } ~ · I:! c.· ~ ,- tr. r...
;-r,- • ~~ ,c-[
1
c...f,
I - I - ,._ ' I _., '-D I I I
r,r_' 1J> r Isl• t: ,, ·,cD'
1(1
J-· ~ f· P.· .~ h ~ -.: ~- r.1· c:..
Q I ·~ t
$t. 1E: s i~ B-. ~ ~t. r 1~ 1~ ~ ~ ~ ·E" ~ t ~ ~~ ·r
C.· §- - 1:. t' f;: ~! '. s__
·r~c, .-r.:FA .~1:-,~ ·~. f.;. ~
lo oC -~ ~- .;,:,t [• I:. f. J· . ,t' • • ; '
b=l~· l . ·i.. r.~ .t Ci~.. ~ r· - ~~ ~ ir i" ~
~ -.!' [ .§ 1
_ ~ ~ E C· (i l[ ,t tr.. 1= i f.;·: 1
cf. r_ • • t - !, C.· 0 ,. f> . C.. ::r' -
t
I ;;;-V. c
-
t ,r,-c...
.i S[. '
if- (.• r I> I r
f: !~. \0
~- E J,[ ' ~. .-,.
r?.f.l [t
s- , • \S)I ' '-" • '- I '""1 {t
.F I:: .~· ~~ -.! § ~t

1r r v r: r . . . r r t ~- _: i ~ " .1 ~
.t~. ~ i-[ •[:" bC p.• ii,; g
E.:. I I I L• · ~ .~. [• y· V - Isl·
1· ·t. lb ~. t_,. f:~ f:. ~ ·~ 1 [ 'tt 't, ~ ~~ 11 ~·J!- ~~ ~ ~=-· ~
• - • • "" C:.. I I I c.. W ~ - - -~ 0 .
· ~· -" ~
\- . . - ~ 1- - t _: ~ ~ - "b/.. _., ~. = ~ 1- = I
·<i_. ·1! i.··i
lt~ C.· • P.' C· ".?A
ir: ~ ~. }l
1 r.
~ i t J·~ 1::r [ t ~ f, Et:·1 t!"'L J,. . w~ :f~ -t i;r:-
~ C ~ l C· f . . ·~ 't! . ,. f; 't.. I ~ ·~ - ~· L. • I:! h
t
~
'f.~ ~bC s;r~·
t· - . ,.
b/..1
r ~. t F~
-
• ~
E ci --·~
. ·~· : \., e~ ,. -" . \-
rt t ,;. ; \ _., -
1· l.f .__: [ t;J
~ t- c, ~ I ~.
'h -:.r ~- '· ~:
'Ii>.
- b/..
t
.9.f
~ c·
~ ~
r rt
~
~ ~: 'k ~ ~ .f-1 t ~ -~ 1-£ ft ~ ~ .~ ~ i h ~ t ~ l ~ . f I

E 't· ·f r. ~· • c- t r {. ~ f ·g f ~ ~ ~ l ~ 1 i '.t' t ~ l 1 ~ il
''b. ,c- e.r~ ft· - ~-:·1,:
1
a, [
1' l } ~ t ~l 1- l,.. p.t> \., I 'f> -
L...
~ t~
:S
-· (.• I
~ ~~· ,t ~ ~. , · t ·~· Ic.. i c,
J-
r-- f I
Li J l, ~ ,(""" L•
c:_ ~l, I )·'
-""(
(JQ _,, C· .. -
[ , ~ ~ - i ,i:- [, ~
f,' •
t1• i7-
~ ~.. ~ · •t ti;.,
lD 1, " - , 't, ,~ t,• ~ · _., I [• b/.. !:: :_" ,C- C• t
8- f,• f -· ~.. ;
f: I
b/_. I s(; , L L ii),
[ -E·f;: f
•t
re·• } !
Jt ]r;; ~~~ l~ fl!_ ~-.) ~i. ~f 1i t~ ir.~ lb. ~ ft·,t t { t~ 1 ~ ~ ·~ bC ,L 'f_ b/_.
r~
- ~ - I • - • - '-' • ~ I - - U> Cl - - C.. V\ - - !:i
.F
~ t. • \A) - I ~ • ~I
·~ ~I !··.::::·:·.:.·
\
)- I 'l> ~ • •,_
r. - •' ··1•,:
f ·i- F- J,-. . ~_,. 1·~·r 11f 1f }_,. r. '\..~ .t ~'~. •,. ~,e
. i:.. ~... I I [, (• I
~- !
1· ~.C . . V\- -b C. i
t
:( f 'ti; ; i.. i;; .1:-· t
l EI 1,. t t·:·:··
C· > t· C· ,. C:.. Ii>; 1> k

h ::r \A)< -- I I -•
,l~
~ fi~ $t· [o 1 _,.
~ rf
I 8 :+ I i> (1 I I ·[~ • \o
e-· ~• } C: ~
f- iI;,~ f l
- ~ t. I(.. f>"" (;i - - > C:.. c;.: ~ C •
> t.
11b e~~:
~~ !:
~. ·i ~ [ ~.. f ·~. f: ~ 1 11- 'f ~ ~
,r,- o ~ I!-' t ~' It t. - ~ ~ J:""" Y·
~.~ 'f-1 ~·~
l, t I
¥ ). -~ - • ~· ~ t. ft• ·~ ):" .- 't tC ,t ~ ~ E I
~I J ~ ':!! i= f
(• C t. [~ - l, ~,.
.re-·
"°
~8.> ·l· i ~ l l ·st ~ ~· ~b % t ~t
£ f_ ~ S: ·~ C· ~. t•· fr ~ l ~
t' f>. ~ ~ •L c... (1) L. I I ~
r. ~.t 1 t
'LE: : S F ~~· ·L e.:
I; ¥,,[•t:t ~·~ ~~s.
·~ I .:1. i ~ ¥ f l f ·i f f ! i:: :\· r. [
H I - I l, ~ l, -' ~ • (1) I ~. •
E· I
~ ·~ I }c
[, !' ~ •
[I
~ '( P ~ f : <r. ~- . G,
cb - c;.: t . _, , _,. .• X • ·f. - I>(;,. I • rls>· t:
r;: -
.t! \A) y
t t ~. f "°.
l, I • _p (1) • - - - -
l
I ~tl-'
1 ;
~
r. . . t 1 t r;; Pf .~
~ ~ ·<,..
l t- ~ \·.!- Sti 1f 'f..,. ·(~ 1
'e. -: { <c. . •
~
1-.
- •1 • ~ _p 1> ~ C:.. ,, •L ~ b ~ C:.. (!, h .y
1 \ r ~. . : 1 t~ · c;- J·
b '~. lo '~ ~ ~ c_ ~! > f>"" n' C"°'" (1 V ~
(1) I - I - C· • - -
- l,o•
l '-, "' £. . - . - t - ~ •
'f fi 'f r J.: l1>
~ l,
- · ~ [ : i>
> ,c;~•
F>"" • ~ ~ ' ~
c·
h
,.
r'Ci .I
e-. B
C
I ~· G_ i;; ·~ ":
! r _:._ ··..1 t ~ t, 1z ~ ·i. {· L~ r ~. h - ~ 1· .~· '°.r ~. ~ .~
i:,• <o ·i;. t'. ~· C.
I• I~• < r• I
"t
~ . , 't-- , l, < , c· . r . r ts>· h _,. f;! ~
I ~•[• r. I $~ i l~ J.. ~ 1- le;'~ lfl~ -t 1~ s.f 1 t t· lr- L~ 1 1~i '[• 'b~-~ t_,. t~·. .. Ell· r
I I .. • It.
p
1(;. l ~_,. t <i... < E: ~
ls>·
J- I~
V\
r;.:. s I s - . V\ .
,. ~I [
•L
~
t•
- - l..o
l
~• a '(- 11:~ 1..o~ ~- ~ < - ~. -
1I I I I I I - ~ ::::
(.)'°~IJ as'.;..u.l Jo~I :~J J ~'ii c..LA ~ cG>illl ~LWJ o~~ l.!JL....i.A
~'-:~u· t uLJo..al ~ ~
t,.. . ·- .JL.u:,..'l'I
- (.)'° ~~I~
• ~ l~U-,,;t
,...,,- ~ IJ as''.) ..u.l
~ ~ ~.:.UI ~_,JI~ . ~ I ~t,-bt 0A ~.,,-b JS' ~W ~ J ~ LA JS'

.~IJ(.)'°~l & 4 ~ ~ 1 J.._g~ .:t.:,l 'i! ,Jo~I ~~tJI ul qt;,;JI
15_;-;. t J>-6 illl~ l.!ll.i.4.J ~~ I 0-4 ~ .)l:c.a.11 y ..,L..u,~I a.J~I ~ll_;JI ~
a.,.)L..aJI
- - o~
··~tiJ a.kW! '-',J I J~ c.)-4
.:.)..i:JI ~'..H · ~ I c...,gl -, ,,-:0 ...-1-·-~~
- · .illl~ ~·
. tone at the top ~l_,JI
i~.,:at ~ J~ 'it
l.!ll.i.4. ~J J~'l'I ~ .)l~~I Jo.;ji ~ ~ ~ J~'l'I c..LA o~~ ~
(.)'°~~I ~ u-4 ~_;JI~ .ul.c~I ~ ~>' <i'11 u'l'~'l'I u-4 J:.J.Lll
Ji .)l~~I o-..o .)...u:. ~ 0i ~ I 0-4 ~ ,~ ,o;. ,~. Ji L>'°'-.:.. ,~. a:iLAi r.J.LJ
J~'l'I ~~ r~ ,~ 0~ J~)U r~4 illl~J ~~~ ~ u l ~
ab\ I - ~ ~jtll ~
sJI rlbcOQ J~ 0-4 illl~J ~~I 6'lAi U~..,L..u, ( ) A
a.bkJJ [~~ a u,.,;., ~ i;~I ~~I ,bl «si .(French and Raven, 1959)
:_;-;,i .)~~.)~I ~.)~ ..1l ci'11
~ tl.r91 ~ J ~'ii~ JJj..ull o.;..ll ~J reward power ole~I a.bL..u -\
Ji J~'}JI .)l..>:1 &4 ~ Ji u~~IS ~Ll.4 ~ ~ c...,gJ---'-" c:tj~ ~
. -~
- j ul...l -
_!.)-l
t~l ~ J~'l'I ~ JJ~I o.;..ll ~J coercive power ~ I ab\ '"" -r

.u'l'~'l'I ~ as'.;LlJ.I ~ l~I~ f11~1 .)l~~I ~ ~~I
~..?-~I tLal ~ J ~'ii~ JJj..ull o.;..ll ~J expert power ~ I a.bL..u -,
c:tjj ~ ~l~'l'I l.!l~I ~ ..1l ~.:.UI ~_,JI~ . ~ I ~J-LO ct:...u 0~
.l..!.lJjS' ~ c:tj~ ~-?-~I tlal t_.!b; ..._ ,J~I
15...u J-4~1 a.bL..u Ji a.!;;.!;;:>JI a..bL..iJI ~J legitimate power ~~I a..bL..iJI -i
LA'-'""J.i)-4 0-4 y1k: ..1l ~.:.UI ..>:J.1.1 ~ &4 '-'"".; W ..1l ~J •J ~'ii ~ JJj..ul I
.«~~~.)J:»c:tjf a.Jo~U""J1>!1~ ..llJ ·rllo..al4~I ~~J_,;....ul
Jo~.;'}JI ~ J~'l'I ~ JJj..ull o.;..ll ~J referent power ~.;..1.1 a.hl.uJI -o
·(.)'°~~I ~ ~tJIJ ~..?-~4
f. ~~ ,c;~' '~
r-" 'l! ~. I - '\_. § :~ ·~ f ;-; \. t' \' . r-'"'~ ~. . ~ •(. ~: F
1
•I- ~·
f ~·.i:- .·~
I I - - I (_
r.~j
t" t. lC· ,r.b C· I - i; E f ,f-' f, J. c:.. t t '-: r;; ·, E ~. c:_ ~I 1:i·:·l·
·; ~ - .. ~ t ! [ ' --
}> ~ ~ ~ 'P ~ ~
~ [, C· l_ .c- & !_
'l -c, r ~- •h~' 'f r - I
r<' :'I
~•
-~ - }> 1 - ~ ~ c:.. l I C ,c; .-1
E'f, 6;,
;~ ! C• !... '.fl ~· ~ .~ fl
.t, ~t 1·t hs g ft'~ ~ 't:f.'~ f
~ .f- 't t f ,I:' ~i . <i: 'f, ~ ,t. i: ~.. [, ~ 1)
1-' ~! -?.
,• I f) ("{) L.
·~.~ ~. t-:- ~ r- t> ~ 1, - 1C· ~._,.
i;= ! • •I !: . ~ ~ ~ h ~I f;"" 1( C• ~; [' ~ i [ ~ [ f .f' i 1_
~ I
i ir;; E·. 1• ~:1:
1·,
t,
E ~ 1· ~ ~ ~ E C·
{h ~~. E.ci ,c;.· r, [:~
~ fj:- f;, b ~ ~ ~ •E. L: - ,I
i; ~ .f: t· i .f c-· i- f '\: :r .~. t'
f 'f- 1·~ "-:- -
,_,-- ~v Pf Li l,· i.'
C· I ·~
&,• •.· }> (i: 1[: I I I Ci ·~.
J:~ ~ ~ I• 'I• I
t I 'l ~ ~ E: 1. ·[ ;, [. tr •h
c.. r;, ~ c:_r- ~·r. t- ·~.f'' .e-·~ rt ·[· ~ l:
.. ~ ~ •. ,r,- ~I
f 'i ~; •h f V\ l - - 1' (_ I I I
r;i c-r: ~ fI
C• ·, -~ c. ~• · .~ ~ t:I
r l- 'L· - E~ t;
t 'i..- ltlJ
r, - ~ • - - (p, -!t ~ r ~ f 'l! r (;" -
I l, - 1(; ~I
£~ ~. ~ ~ ~ ~ .h ): 'Ii>· - - • t- c,
\. ,c;~· c, ,r.-r c;.:: ~ ~ . ['"' u
f.;:, ~ G.. r;; ~ .. ~ ~ l, 'I· S' &. . t! s:.. [• ,c ~ f ~ C~ I • i}. f':
~'I l,
" tI C· 1- t.C ~· .... l, !f. ~i f
(~ ·~ t"' '( ~ ~-:- t ~I/• ·~f' ~~ ;= I
• ~I • l..o - - L•
[ ·.i .c- G.. _: b ;.
1~·1:\·J E~l t
£ \ ~ ~- ~ c, ,r.- .rl- t'
~:f.'lf
~ ~
f
~ C· • I
_,. c:.. •
t. -~ 'I
f<j
I ~ u ~ _,. ~. ~ \) re:: I
.~ l, V l... t.C'
~t-' 'i. '5>c;.: t~
_...
t =~.. t ,._
~
- ~ -
~
.... ~I I _,.. 't> (r ~ I
r.~ - (1 I . ~I •
f c;.:
.~ ,r.-r ~ r. !
r·,
,I- .r 't C• f' J• r
.f. " ~ ~ C· U
i!
J; .~ li
r~~ .'
_,. Ci ~ ·l ~ ~ 'fu ~ t
~- ~
l ~ C. \..a>
·~ r- 't ,.
t·· I •• 1·.:.!
1··,
i !i... ,!: ? ·r. f ~ ~ ri ~ r rr_' \. '[
ti t lt lw i~ ~t t -t~ l~ '~ ~" (r .& - c:.. .t • ~ ~ .6 t' ~
:L~ ~.~ I c:_
sfs~" • -
- ,c; I>
ti '-
r-
-~
I
~~ - - <i_- C-'I' ~'t>. "Z: IL
1~.
1li, . C·_,, ~ ;- E <i.. ~,, ,r.- ~. ~· ~ ~. ·~ -r ~ \. ,r,- I( •
t Et s
uti
\·l
ij l, 't:. ~ ,._ g ~- . ~· c r;; l ,e. r - n
I ,· .•.. '
t..
': <i_
f ,r,- I
'<i.. f:! r.l, ~-
,[:
E.
. ~ 't
I
1'
C I ttCi
Ci-~ C: u ~ 1 ·r l i~ ~·iX r·
~ tr I I~ _,. • ( 1 - t.C' - 1 h ~- ~S
~ ,._ ~ ~ If, l \• ~ I~ I ·t,, ~ ~ ~ ::. ~~ ~ ~
Er- tl"
• , c. _ C· ~I .. ~ ~ C:.. \' - ,t' sL ·E"' n [
!l~ f' - .. l~ r: ~ }
.- ~
.... 1f y ~· 'l f ~' [
Ji - G.. ,- ~ •
~i r c; <e..
1 r
~ ~
•L ~
•
~ (1.t-
·l
;-j _:.
..c \ _,. tr - t .l f!r I -
L 'bl \-.::. - -;- t l 1 f !. E E~ f'~ i f ~· £ t
,~~~~~~_g:at -Y
~~~l~hs~ .~llA~l~.,11~~ ~0,.4~..u Lo~J~I
~GA a..a.,_>1o ..)~J r-.u.. 0,.4 ~yl ~ -~~I ul~l~l L)-.4 ~~ ~~
ps-~IJ ~L.u~I ~...GJI 0~ ,~~ ~11.!J~I ~ lA ..)~ l.!l_;~ JA a.s_;..J.
-~~~~~I.P."!J~w,-4~~~~1~~.,.tl J:?~a .!;;b;4
~y>-i ulb~ Ji J ~ ~I~ ~Lu, l.!J_;~ ..ig ..)~I 01.S' I~! lA, ;, .~,i<J wi JJ6.
c:,SJJ ..)l~~I ~..u cGlA~I ~~ ~.!.!oil a.! cc,.;;JI ulJJ~I ~...Guuil .igJ -~~
~ ~I . ~w ~J.A 0~ ~ ~_;~ ~b:J -~~ ~....P.'-1' ~I ~~I u~I~
Facebook l.!l~ ~~ ~I_; .~WI ~ I rl...Gt::'u.u4 ~ I ~.,.ti ~~J.A
~~* wfi:! ..(g~i ~ljj ~i,;, ,:.,..,<IJ ~IS'_;~ i~IJ MySpace ~ ~lAJ
.~WI ~I~ ~ I ~_,11
,·
~.• :.t.!. -tt~Lsa.....u
, ,..._ ... :J ..Li t
!A!>:',,. t~t-l"
-0:4~l~J LJ:-4~1 ~µI LJ'::' ~ I w~_,11 ~ 0i ~l..rtll <.!.Lb 0,.4 ~~IJ

i.ill~ 01.S' l~lJ .J4'>-~I .)o~J 0Wi ~ t,s:;~ a.s~ o)J?}l 0~ J-5b
~ ~ fl
~4 ~ I ~.»-~I e,_gl..,Jo~l 0,.4 ~~J ~~IJ ~4Jl '-:-'--'.._;..i;, ~ ,~llA

... ~ ...GJI ~~
a..u., I· .It L:.r
. ." i~:.t; 1.!JUA u. i ~
. At:.. ~ • . . ) ~ ,J tl..G.JI ~'"' ~~ l...A
.J~~I u~_,k,0,.4 ~
,~UJ~ ~,;.a• ul ...! ....a:i -t
JY"" ~~ ~ w~_,llJ w.1>:J..l.l L&l~ r"~ ~I ul~Wtl ~Lc..H ~

~llyl ~~J ~~ ..)l~~I ~~J.A toll .a ,oi:,c.ll ~~~~~I ~~I
-~LlAJ~IS'~ll->-11 ~L.uJ~IS' 1~1 LAf.!.!;;i!~~ ,o..)~_;lb.i ~w ~Lal
-~b ~ ~~J uL.u~IJ ~l:iylJ ~llylJ.)oUt:.1.1 u\ Q.!.!;;; ~I_;
«.·,-··- ,:...-r·~.-.:::-·.J X..).""'· .,.-.....r.,:x~~-·"'""~-~+·.~
R:·T'~-- ·--: . - . { ~ · -:s~.--- · v : r - , ~,, . . . '<Y".-.'X"·~-~·,·-.;.··_ .• .•. ,_,~_i,:.- ::,,; •••.t
•l.t.'l':>.T-'J"'t•... ~ ,l'··t~··t,.'l.ct..~··--·.y·~~-N- .. ~ t
Y•Y' lfj~ ..\.W ~ '?.'.lll l.4.9 ~~ faU : u ~ I ~ JlMM2llJ 4\.4..S~I

c~1.·._~J ...~· .,...• ,, . _.._~!.-~-~,).·., --~.-/="-::---::.1·-:·._.·.-;.·..·.·=-=~ ... ~ · : ~ : · · ....,.:,. r·. -.~·.. ~·.-·.-:· )'· 1 ,·,..:,.,.,I 1 ..-·; ',.'.· 1:·.i ·~'.~·-.: ;:.. ·~'."1\~'/:,·., ,'-'):;•··~ '".".",':··:.·t ;,, .. , i
.aa.,u.i~ ~"' -0
_ps-~1 ~_,J~ whistleblowing ~Wl.=t:.11 ~ t.>4~ Jw r~ ~~1 ~
,
~ ,Jl:J.I ~ ~ . ~ I ~li.>411 &..;-k ~ ~ J~~I ~~ ~~
~li.>411 J~ 0-4J~~I ~~~ ~ 0-41.,, ~Lla:ol ~ ,o~I ~\S~l '->..1>1
~J .J~~1~~~0-41.,A~4L-:.Jl~IJA«;.. c~ei<l~jjl~_,Jl~~I
1.n ~Lla:iIJ 4.L..........u ~ J~I a.J~ ' ' ••• L>-4 _ps-L:.~IJ '->..,_;.i as'~
~.;~ Lo~ .i:.~IJ ~.,.ti 0-4 '->J~IJ ~ I ~li.>411 J>l,;. 0-4 \..s,.i.A
J ~ ~4 "~~I~~ ~j.lo~J ~ d..4.1_;,lo ~~j '->...u 0i 0~.,.tl
JlLj,f ~Li.A -~~I ~ ~~~I <r9 as'.;l-.A~ _p$'i 0~~ ~~ ,~~._>J
~l.&l ~.; ~ o.;~ aJo~ 0fi:i ..l9 ~J ~ww, ~ t>l:i?l' ~~ o~...\-.LLA
~ St oi cc·4 0~ 0lJ ~li.>411 ~..\Al ~ I r~I ~~ 0t y:, ~IJ .~~
.~.,.ti J;s 0-4 u l ~ I ~..J ~ I
aJ~~,~ ~ uL:,~t ~..Li~~~~, iJ.)~t-i

,
·t .. ,, ,. .
(.) ~J- ~
-~~L ~L,~~·1,).4 ~J.J• .Jl.u>o~I~
• • .) • -
.At!.. -
~~~
.t!.-:~~~
_ps-~10...1.:?.,JI ~_,JI JI_µ Lo whistleblowing lines ~ww1 ~ f:.>4?]1 Jo.P

0-4~ r~ ,~Lla:i<IJ J~~I ~ ~Wc..UI '-6,Al~I t:.!bicc,i ~IJ d..:_Jw
.~J..&,11 I~~ ~LAJWI ~ o~I ~\.!iciJI ~WI ~_,JI <r9 ~Wc..UI
a.sJ..>-Lll J~~1 Jowi ~ ~w~I ~l_ig J~ 0-4 ~ 1 o~w1 ~ l.!.LI~ ~
.~l~j.11 0-4 ~~J ~~I .>A? Loj
,aa.,u.J~ 4AJ~t ul.4...~ t -V

~~I~ ~~~10t 0fi.;~ ~.,.ti~ c,;JI ~ I o~l.a.1.1 ~L..u~ 01
- ,,
~ ~Lui:JI M wJ ~~ 0J.)
c\..a..4 0-4 ~1~~1 0lJ LA.,k~ ~la: ~J-'-" as-~,
~ J ~1~40fi:i o~La.1.l 0i ~.;-11 w,k .J~~I 0-4 ..wl ~~L.ut 0-4
lt
~ ~ 1 w,k r~?JI ~~Jc-:= ,~.; ~i ~.;-11 w,kJ0l:P-~' ~ i ~ ..\.A~,
,, C
,. . ~I~ '_:. :.t\ • i ~I ~ I

'-> ..u.1 ~ -
· ak.~ ~
- 1,).4 I - I ..1.£.J o~l.a.1.1 1.7"""
- • -
. 4\ ~ (.) ~C
,,
-
- C
C
~_..,.;.~I ~.,..Jl o~l.a.1.1 ••• j"?'"j~~ ,J.,_,.b..11 '->..u.1 w,k Loi •~.) .!cocJI
~.;-l ~~ i:.~ i.J-'-"i 0~ o.)oWI J......i . ,2 J ~ ~, y~.;l 0t ~~Li.A a.J~.;
. ~ I L>-4 ~~, y:,
a.•<.r,•a:..__., ,--.:..~--:;.-..:;c~~».=Jo;.~~~·--_..; .• ,-r>,1.·1"-~~,, ----1~-Vl,.,n..'_,,:;--·,-s_,_,.. ~..- _,,.~-=--~.~.:-...,.t>-,l't.-.,..~;-•...,..•_.:,.,...,..,~..,._..-,..........•..,,_-•••,--~~'"°"'<IUlo"'l-'-*!,;~S.::.:~::o'.O::r."""""'"-~z:
~~4.la.9~~.:.Llll.4.9~...u,,,jl~U : u ~ l ~ J ~ ! J ~ ~ I Y•t
u~l~J~~~,u~l:ut
~~~'.",f.J~~.c~::r.zJ::~:s-rn1~~=;;.:--?~Y:::mi~4::2lli1::f;1r22]r:~:::2~~=~~~~~[]
i4 ..c.i~ ~t 4 ..c.t-..:Jt ~ ~.,-.l

¥>l,;.~1 a .!4iiII [~~ J)L..;.~1 J ~ ~ ~~1 U ~.?-i J....4.1
The Ethics Development Model (EDM) (Albrecht, Hil, and Albrecht, 2006)
~.)~ [~~1 w,:o.J-J: . .)l~)U a.!,o;. ,:.,ll J>l,;.~1.)..,-b:i u ~ ~ ~ J
.("\-,) ~ ~ ~."4 ~J .)_,k:'J1 c.>-4 ~.).GA u ~
~~~1~,~~~(i-Y')~..)JU,
4.zco?:.!JI ~~)\.;.~I~
0-J~~Ir'~' ,~\jj\ ulj..i.11 ,~bj)'I , \k;.Jlj yl~I
. Albrecht, Hil, and Albrecht (2006) :J...u.o.1.1
~ ~ ,J)l;.)U '=' IO?L~1 ~_;-ti~ [~~I c.>-4 ~~~I ~~1 ~

0-J..»-~4 ~La.JI ~J ~~hi j..ola:'JI ~ J yl~IJ t.b.;JI 0::t uli~I ~JL4
olj.lll ~~~1 i:s.)4-l1J 0,J..;->->U ~..>---11 ~ ~.:.UI r-1~~1_, ~ WL.....bla:'JIJ
I~~ Karl G. Maeser ~LA - ~ J.)lS' c.>-4 '-'""~I~~ .a a.!a:>JIJ
~ '=' co~~I ~~I~~~ LA~ ..ill~_, ~~~1 ~)l;.~1 '5~1
~~ .)~i c.>-4 ~llJ ~WI ~ 1 wl.)~ ~ ~ .\LU JjsL..u» Jli
JW>-1 ~LiA'5.?-i _,i ~ J .w,:o.)~I ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~1 ~_,..:;~1J i~
~IJ~.?c.>-4~4hJ4o~l.)~.)I ~~~I~ ~i ~ I ~J ·<:r.~
~i oJ . ~ ,o~Lul JJ4,.:i C::.!b; ,,,i ~ .~1 JJ4,.:ii ~4 ~_;---j, ~ ~ i
.(Burton, 1953 ~ ..ill~ ~1 o.)~?JI ~) ,.~_,i u."4i c:,i ~ i ~1 lLilb d-1~
(:A ~1..ill~ ~ ~ o~I ~1..?. ~lS' ~ .).J-4lJ a.!''°~~1 J>l,;.~I d_jJ..l.4 ~
.d..:_u~I u~~IJ , ~ I ~~J ,~1 u)\AL.:i ~l.>=?-1 ,0-Jy-.~I
,.-....__......._... ~-----c.... . ....-.i:::~~-.-· ·.._.-~.......,....•-y;o.•.11. '- . ..-.-.,yp.._._. ..,. .... -, o~ -'-~"'·U',-;.l,.,;:,.• .o:,.~~ ,:.,,.zr....,.,...~~=-."o:~......._ pr.:, . ,...;~ ~~z,-· -..· - ... ,,_..._ .•• ~. :.•..;:~_ "1:1,;.,...;; ••~~:.. O.!¥,,.;.~-· -.0"--~----~
Y• O ~L!r.:i ..ua.9 ~ ~.JJI loj 0 ~ ,~u : u ~ I ~ J~~ 4-4,J~I

tr:]~;;~~~ ·"h(=:·::,··:•:::::·'.·.·:·.·: ... z:=:.~~-:::=:::x:::<··:.·····. ·;;;;;:;;·· ·.",·. .·.. P ~ · ···:::s···.·.~·,t~·:,~ .'.··.··;·:::.·:.=.··::· ........·.=··.::::.:::rn
1.SJ.l ~.:Ul~~~I ~ I ~(Jq ,;.,;.!s¥~~1 ~ I [~~~\ill 1.S~I LAi

ti ti
~~ - ~ Wb~~I I.J.A~ . ~ I a.!.;.!t;._,JI q3l,bLla:,~~l~->11

~llJ..L.o~llJ illWI ~ ~w J ~ ~ ~ u~~i Jl~~I 1.S..U (J~ ~ ,JLlll
~~lu\,biii11,ll~~~IJi~J~lP~~(J~"}l~J
ti ..
· ~ ~ ' Ji ~~i .)-!):. lS'~ ~ dl~ (Ji~ Jt (.)""Llll 0~ ~ ~~

~ I ul~I J ~ ~UI ulS'~"}ll ~ lfi.)~ ~.:UI ~~~I ( . ) A ~ ~
~ ~L;JI ul.)~"}1\ l~I ~ J .(J~~iJ ~UAi ~i ~ ~~ ~UI
ul:S'.,.LJI ~ Ji <<u~l:, ~)\:JI» u4llo o_H~ ( . ) ~ ul_;l..,.:S ~1-'"4
a.:,o;.~I ~~~I~~~ ~J-UI ~s·o;;; ~lS' ..l..4l . ~ ~ I ~ I
~_.;J:ill ~\ill ~_;JI ~~I 0~ ui ~ ~\ill 1.S~I I.J.AJ . ~ I u ~
.J~~I o.)bl u ~ ~
~· -..Ll~~I
. ~~
. 1 -'i"'""""·
~Ll~~I ~
.. I [ ~~l.!:JliJl1.S·~
~ ... q LAi
tLAJi ~ ~UA U , ~ ~~ ~l_;JI ~Ll.4JIJ o~I ¥~~I ~~I
ti ~
~ l.).ll9 (J~ ~J J~)U I..> ,o;. .~,ti ~ I ~->111.S..U (J~ ~ . ~ l.!.1~

LA~ LA ~-'"4 ~L;w"}l ~~I 4:!..u 0~ "}! ~ ~J ~ I u ~ ~ I I.J.A ~
~-'"4 ~ ~~I a.!q;; ~ o~WI u ~ I ~...!bi«ss; .dl~ o.)~I ~
.oJ~l 1.SJ.l ~ I o~IJ ~l_,ll uL.ul:-JIJ ~ I J '-:-'-3_.;..l:ill J ~ L>'°
~ ·¥~~1~,[~~~u~l~i~~~loJ~l~J
U"".>£-J ~ ~~j tLAJi ~ ~ ~.:UI 0-J.J>}U oJ~I ~...LiiJ ~~~I o.l~I
1.!.1~1 (.),A ~_;JI [~~I I.LA~ . ~ I ~)GJ ~ a_;g~~I ~~I
~4'=:?JI ul:S'~I ~~ J ~ (.),A 0-J...»-~I ~ ul ~.:.. .~,JI (.),A ~~~I
l.!.11..A.A uLJo.al ~ i ~ .o~I D.)b?JIJ t~?JIJ [~~,J a.!.'' ... JI_, I.>~,
l.,.J.,JJ~IJa.!,o;. ,~.I.!.}~ ~ljg~..u~.:Ul~,jll ( . ) , A o ~ ~ ~
""'LA (j&M.I
.r- t.:t~~I• ~
..udl~. u--
'--'lu~ -· t.:r'lLl~~l-,~tl.,.J.A
.. ~
1-:.·.~
U"""' .. ..
~~l.!.11..A.AJ ·~_j-ALA(J~y.l~"}l~~Jl_p,-~l~i~ .yl~
-*(J~~~ID.J.A -~~ly•o;. ·~eJll.!.1~1 ~l~~D~I.S.»-i
~IJ<<~)it.l ~4-Jl»~~I ~~I LAi .dl~ ~~J~i~~i
~ J;..aJI ~~I D.J.A ~~ -¥~I ul#~~I y ~ i 0---4 Jl~i (.),A 0.P
-
4..i.ut.A ull~ i · J J~ ~I ,- c.r
- t'-':, ~'l Ll~- 1-:.: ~
~I ~- U"""' .. .. J 1-J\ •. -'IJ L..b.;JI
. .,.,.-.,
~ ~ -~-t\ • !. ~~,, ~
• ~ ~~ ~ J .I-JI
. < - . "}! .ig '. <t
- LA ~
• ~ . rA& '- !t ~6:..!JI
. ~
..u ~
. -·~":
~ ... -'l--~A.n.-=-.~'r.-~_,:-._:..,g-_-...:....._1,.....w;~_,=-:,,rr.i:.;....A-.v.--.,.._;w,,._.-cr...,:.,_.,..=-:v.o.-.,r.~."l'c,«.-"'-".........,~~~~~--•·,.._;rn~u~,;.~-~VQ.<A<lim.
~~4.1.d~"?.:illLoJo~faU : u ~ l ~ ~ ~ l j 4 J ~ I Y•i
LJ"">yi.ll t_)c.J l&:, 0 ~ ~ I Jo~I t_)c. ~)G.. ~I ~I.J~ ~ J u-91•02
. ~ I ~laj ic~ ~y_;; ...l9j ~..)L9 k ~ I o.:U.c_fwL..9J-'-" ,LA~ .~LJI
~)G..i o..)l.;9J ~ <.LJ_Ji.... a..:i.9..1.AJ o..)~1 lS..i.J ~4=:!t, ~ o~ <.LJ\..i..e 0~ La..w:..9
L?..)Y- . ~L..:,JI w l)~I o~I k ~ I o.:U...,_JWI ~ ~L..9J----'-" ~~I~
~_,ll 0-4 ~ ~ ~L.......J Jl.......Jl c.;,-1! ~ I J ~4=:!)'I w~~ o..)WI ~.J.>-J
.~L..:,JI wl)~I :ik..:il t_)c. L)-I_J..)L9J ic L.i.., i
:J~~l~~I
($..LIJ ,wlS'~I <i9 J~ ~I~ ~ I ..::,lbl,,:;..:, ~ J~ ~I L..9~1 ~
k.,_;:J.I ~L..}il 0-4 o~ ~ ..ill:i ~ -d.tlUI wLl~IJ wLaµI ~J ..)l_;-9~1
.~ J5 <i9 w ~ I o.:U. t_)c. t)Lbl ~ i ~..i.J 0:!.:UI .!.tJ.9i ~~ l&J ~ c;JI
J~ ~I ~ l : 9 ~ w~J Report to Lhe Nation (2008) ~)ll ~_,lly~I <i9
..::,~~ ~I ui The A ssoc iation of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) 0:!~I
~J .c:.,.,~IJ ~lw~>l:JIJJ>~ ~ I J ~ ~ I tlyi_;siuA~~I
.('\-~) ~ <i9 FY' JA> La J~~I L..9~1 ~L....i ~ ,~ I 0~
cr>J~":i{l~w.:iSIJ:il....iJ~Uu(i-t)~.)~
(I) 4::y..uJI ..:...L:.)411
( 'I') ~
.. J WI ;;~
· '- · · I\
(i) ~....Lc.o.ll,,
(!.) ~IJJI ~WI
. AFCE (2008) :J...1...L4.1.I
T•V
~ G { ·1· I,
r_-,_;l!
I
f.12~~ [ c...
rJ:";" ~ ~ 1,,C)I 1 le
c, 1
r ~f, ·cL ~ I
I 'l[ be· ~~.
I I • I , I
'[1 f>-1[
c, '\; ~I• ,
f ire· i~: 1t· ·f' , !-.,
,f,r ~ -: ~ • [ ' r..!! •f ~ ~ ,. C: ~ . ~ I • to 11
=: - [ ~- ~• - - - - [1 - f;-"' t-1
t.-- 1~ f,~ ~ ~
[.f ~ - f;: ,. ·~ e! l;-
t1 .~. 1· c... r- C· " u c... ~. - - Y· - ~ t! G {;' c... E [• ~ [·'l
,cC)I ~
'f, ~ t l;- c,· 1;- b ~t .~ f. 'f, t . 8 ~ f>- 't,, ·:_:.:_::_1
:r ~ .~. . f ·[ 1~
·~~ £ L. C.· b (.• ·~
c, f ,r,-r - ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~- ~ - \. C· - ·E c... :
E:; ,; ·~ ~ ~ f;: I, ~ ,.
t..
I I) I f) I..• ' I) :·
E... ~ ,c;I:! ~... :~ t ~ c, ,tF: .t ~~ ~ 'f~r ,_ :'_
i! ~~ r c... ; ·~. 'E l· l •~
fr I • .~
,l :rrr.c: l 1·-~·
~ ~~ r -• c..
G... ~ }e ,C~' ~l,. 'l ~ 7 - --: e- ~ 1. r ~- -r::r· t ~ - f'!
b ~- . ~ _ t· !:.
~~ ,r,- t, . ~ 9' I ·L E 1 ·t=:" C· C.· C·. ~ :i_-_,
a,• I ~ p ( -~ ·C ~· ,L ~ .c ~· :_- :_
~~
r~ ~ 't, .~ -· -
'° E;
:r ~ ~. ~ c, ~ r ~
I
r t I
l r-
I)
r ~· ·~ b ~~ I - •
l.c- , C·~.~ .r
" '°_ ~-
- ~· ~ - ~I ,r'• 11..~· _ -:I
C, I j=;: ~ { l ,c
' ~ ~. it''. t t ,(. (.•
-~ b ~' ~ C)I - ~ ' \ ~ r., c.. C· 'r.. - ,£ ·l -
E
.r -rt i. ·_. . .[·· i~- ;. :_ ~ -~ ~ tr·1; ~·.r r ·t tr ,II
'\, i f-1 lC)I f: l. f-' 1(; [r
'E ·~ r t' I:!
! i«>• 'E: '.!! -; . '.:-_I
r- J~
~-(_I
'-o
1
:~L
- tI,
-
,
•
\
I
1 ,
'°
['(I•
,t
I I'
·~~ t",~- ~~ f~ t- t- ~~ ~·-~ t~· f. .f![ (- '°t f~ ~f 't i ~
c... ~, c. - re, '° .t - :vFA "
r . ~..
~ ~Y' /l-' - c· ~ ,t' ,c;-· -
I~ I -, l, -
£l ··, ~ ~ L t " e: e; : ~ ~ I, - - ,.
~!
I I I
·t t.. 'I:,,
t!- ~' .~·
- I g IT ·
:vC) ,c-IC ~ t-'
e r-
I ~ ?f' ~ ~ 1;-_:f; ~ i l l ·~ i ~- t ~. ~
i_'..•_·_:._-1·
t [, ~ ' \ '(.~ \
J' [ ~ ~ h (i 'f r_ ,,!
~ 1 ~ f ,Lr f J ~ft• ~..r-, ~ ·l 1·~ ~ .r 1~ 1l
! f;-" [, ~ ~. f;: 1
t. ·[' f~ l-~.c... ,r:C.
<t· ·~ .'to .e_- f ~ t -.- 1 ~- \- ~ ~ _: i "' .. · ""
t· ~ ~. 'f, f C·
~. 1,- ~ ~- l ~ r ~; '°. ~ ~ ~ 1,- '°. f t -E ·:;-_,• •G_.
'f~ t(
I' l ft ! c...f
f' . 't.. C 't 'ii -
t .~ u r; ,s·. 1 ,c c.. ·[ p C· I;, t ,._ p• - - II\ - ~-- t 1,- l t 1l ~ ~ ~ 1t. ~ -r: l ,t 'r.. ~I ' \
~ ~
1 '\. t c· ~ t ~ ~ ~ f;, ·~ :: l ~ r rt t, v· ~ !} ~
c... b r<' t- t t tj:.'.
)! C· .
~p.~ 1C· ~.[ .y
sC· ~(. rt.
1t· :t
•
.1: G".. ·t·. lF l. t{X 'l! ·E ~. ..-
~~ . r . _~~ 1~ _ ~
~ ~· .. ~ ~ ~ }(' ; ! ~ ; - ~.. ~ - }. I, i ~ c- !:: ~ 't>· t;! -
£. j 1 1 i t' 'i[
f ( __, ~ 1r. ~ ·~ E· tf." .
I I I I - - • f> I -~
f.,, ;- c.. - .[ t'f. ~ ~:r~ [1. \ ::S~
.~ I t· ~ ,t b f g' C,
~ ) 1-· ,f. !e• Ci. . • \,. '"
It,•! I; I - E- . ft & ,:. -
~ f,~ ·~~ C·1 .i: ~,._[ ~ i;:: .E ·i c;.... Ci.
·[·~ t· ~. i:: ·~ C:: ~ ~ ·i. t' F>' ~. 'c: c' •. ¥,. ~ ~ c, ~~ I!, L
t re [ : t
0..1 . ·~ ~f
:l 1 • . . :h -- . IC ·~ • r 1 1t· _ .~ E: '\t I> .i;- i ~ .. ,£ 't ,
1 1 '\,. ~:.·ij···
C· - IC ·L 1·
g• I, S:[·
~[· l:·L r~ '11 r:Er E 1.. . [, v- ':- tl
r . -r i t- ~. f } r1-~ ~r- .f ·~r t-r ~ f. t·
i. I ~ .f i::
'.t· J f ~ l>' 1· ,t: l" '1:: l = 1,· .~ 't' 'E.
f "' " 't: . : :~ ·~ ~. .
C.r. g g. '(!. ~' ~>{ t• . 1C· ~?- ;: ; ' } ~. ~'>• ~:
r"' • \.., r.: '>I " .- ' . - C'. C· C·
~ l~
.-. r-
t ,!n.s I \J> y• I, ~ I
LI I
~ :!~ ;:~ '- {_c( ~1: l• t~ ~t
~_,. ·t;. ls> . . I t> - I
'..,
c, \ ,L [ if· f .!<: ~.:i

4-e · t> , •
t f. ·~ ~~ r--£ t C·
f.·' - · -[,
~ f;, f:.. ~ ~ h ·~ ~
- ~ ; ~ .- lo I r F/ ~ _-:- . _-:- ht ~. c- I ['fl I - r I '
t ~ .;- 1"° \- ,-.~ r,: ~ r: -r c· '.i-f ;: --~ f
.': L' °t~. l, I...J> f:.. 'f>, [ ~ f.
! iE t ~ ~: .t; f .c· 1 ~ E
:i f l i . t -E [ f ·t ~ g. ~· i. tf C, tr c, t ~J ·i. I f. L ~·
{I ~ '\,. ~ ~ t ~: t ~ [ ~ t } 1f 1; { rl ~ f' lr f. ·~ ~ 5:: } g~ I
.»-~ ui .;.lllll ~ .J~'}!I ~JA 4Jlc. 18 .~'.!'..! ci'11 b~4JI D~I ~~j -
~Lc.i ~ J~'}!I ui c.)1 _~lll-!J .~J-'-" LA Ji 4l.J-'-" LA J~'}!I ~JA
- LA "~J-A ~ ,(~UI ~ I D.l~) L A ~ -~_igJ.A u~ JI~~I
"~J-'-"
~ ~.,.ti 0i ~ .b~4 ~~L;' ~ 1 ~ uJJ~ ~i Ji D~J D~ ~

- -
~j J~ D.)~ D.l~ Ji 4lc. wl_)-A~ Ji Dj>-~ LJ""':'~ ~ ~ D~ uJj~
.~IJ.A c4 ~I~'}]
~ ..>i:.! ci'11 ~ I wl_;-,~I ~ .J~'}!I ~JA J;g ~ ~_;-ill ~~I -
~ I ~J ~ I wl:_o~I ~ ~Y-4 ~ a;u~ u~.;~ ~ i.ll~~I
Ji wlJ4-1 ~l ~ Who u~ '}!J ~I~ d.L_,b w~L..v u~ ~ ~i Ji
•.;1_,b~I ~I~~~ ~J ~.? ~ <:?~ ~ ~ ~i
~ ' '
'}!~I ~llA ul w ~ I .l.?.J ~ '}] ,J~'}!I ~ l ~ I ~~ ~ ~ J
a:;1.)J '~ '-'~
.< · ~ b~lJI
A·· ...
. Dl.a..:,JI
•
.. , _! tl.J. w..l.d u..,.-.
J~ -~o~· t~ • D' . ) ~tl.J.
· .<-: ~ i>l A. • ._
al>LJI·.·: ,ss!~4Ji0:t-4~~...u~w~jj~~u~~J .JUI

~
•~.~wL. aS'~ ·-~-'I~}_)-).. c.r

-:fl ~\.;JI
~~ .~_;ll uo.:;. .~.; c4 ~ I J..ol.t:i: LJ:i.A w ~ I c4 J..ol.ull ~

~~~I~~ . ~ ~ f1i ~~~I D.l~ f'~ b->-4 ui
~ i D_H-> ~...u ~.J.11 ~ I LAi .D..LAA ~~ ~...u Ji ~...u ul.;i JWI ~~_,J.I
~~1 wb~ ~ ~_,J.I Ji ~_,J.I ~~I~ c.)! ~ .;1~1 ~ Ct.J~
~ ~ '}] ,Ji.1.4J .~~ ~IJ-Ai .l~IJ ~..,.LI.;~~~ ~ i C~..J
-
~,I.LU~~'}]~ .D-1>-IJ ~~~ ~J.:S'~I J~'}!I ~~I
.-=.-:.--:ti
~J.). Lu;..'}11J ~ ~ I ·0A ..u:twl :.~ 1.·.j
:r 1..)-'-"JA ~ ~
1.... w1..:.1t.t!.~tl-"'·''"'
~ J - - ' ro:-
J~'}!I ~~I ~~J~i ~ ~ I wlc.~I ui ~ ~ I .ll~! ~

~L..vJ r1~1 J~ ~ u,,,_;jA~ ~ 1 0 i c.)1 aJo~ .l~ ~~J k~
~~ .ww~I ~ D~I ~~'}II D.;.l4l,I ~~L;i ~ ~ ~G... '~J->-j
~ J~~ J>.IJA C-c..&.U ~ u~IJ ww~I ~ ~ I J ~'}II ~~I y_,l.u,i
~.,.ti~ J>.l..,_J.I "~ .J~'}II .l.?..};> ~ J+u uJ.l a 4-.:.. ,oJI wLA_,LJ.I ...u:.I~
. (Albrecht, Albrecht, and Dunn, 2001) ow.li
r ~ x ~ = - ~ = - " " · =~~ . ~,.-A..,.._.,.,.__..,....~"":"Y'l,~ ,.,__. .
~,-_.r~,,,,-,..·~--.:-:,;..1,-:-~~ _._...,~·-,r.~-:,.~~-.....-..~.r-~"'f"-,,...,,~::-._n=·
· _,,.•..._
Lfj~ 4J.d ~ 1$~1 l.o.J ~..b,j faU : u ~ l '?9 ~L."4ltg 4.4.J~I Y, •
u ~ I ~J~.)U ~ I u~bJI
l~~~~Y.~:9:'f&l7~.™f;Jt~7~@~~~3'§1%@~~~f.~:fii11~-™~
sJ4att 4 ·-~.~ ~ - <.:,1_J~t a.b.._,.Jt

tl_~i ~ ~ r~ ~ J ~ J~-:il ~~I wl~l?.1 ~ ~ 'i
* ~ ~
~J~'ilw-4'i~ ·'s 11,.i',~l~~wl.J>.J~~JIJ~~I
J ~ I ~I~~ LWI w'ij~I Ji J~'il ~~'i LWI ~L.....u_,11
~ J ~ I ~ . Ls:;1~1?.1 ~ ~.;-.:tllJ ~ JS' <JA yl~'i4 ~.)WI~
~~~ .J~'il~,;. ,~,<U~l~?Jlw~l~l.)J~~
~...LL.4) ;;J~l ~bi .J.lc. ~ "-41<.ll wlb~I ;;.J>.J ~i J i ~ ~i ~ u ~ I
.J~}Uu~I
:Lo~ 0~ ul.o.,WI F. ~ I J->1,JI <JA J~ ~ ~

·Fl Ji ~ 1 Ji ~1 ~b a.i~ r~1 -
.~Lal u ~ w,k ~~I -
.·~...,..
s:;.tl~·tla.L~-
.. :r .
.<.Sp-~ I u Lo_jh.l lJ 4U I w L:, L:.J I J:-6.:i -
•1..9:!-'
- :.,.~ti
-.,.w
w- ~ ~•I1.)-A -
.w-4~1 ~.JAJ w4~1 ~I.J-A ~ ~ I -

·~l+o <)JJ~ ~J ~..,.ti ¥1.J-A -
i ~_,J ~i ~ ~t 4A L~~.tt u'I~ 'It ~..bi.J - ~Utt aL.._,.Jt

a.b._;..tt 0fi:i , ~ ~ J i ~ u~ ~1 J~' i i ~ i.;~ u~ LA.J.lc.
~L.;JI dJWI c;s ~ji ~Ji;;J~_JAw-:i~I u.H.A.A>ulS' l~l Lo J:~~J~l:JI
- t_,..
;;J~t JL.u:,..'il ... . r~
1 ·j ~ --~ ~
. er~ti ~
. LUd.l ~ ···1 .L9-_.;;
-- a.b.'.J-A 1"(+-I .. ......
?-.:ill
.....
J~'il J:~ w ~ i~ . ~~ ~ I ~l~~I ~ l.oJ ~~ ~ J
~~I wl.J>._,llJJ~~I ~ i a.lo~ .4:!J~I ~U:,J~l ~ I D.J>.J~
*
~ . .J>.IJ~J~ ~ ~ l j - f i _ ; J ~ ~ ~ l~~~J;;~ w
~ ~ I w ~ w,kj-fi..,:JI w,k ~~4:!J~~U:,J~l ~ I ~ u i clt~
~
· ~
~ Ji~
· <.:,--
t,..:,(".~ttLA....
~J-""
.. ~,Jl:&.111. ... I,.. .JL:"o.'il
~ ..).)-0,: ~ <.:,-- ..
-~~l~JJirW~I
..-A,>.ff'.~:.,-.t,.·A~~,z.~....._$-t'b~.).'r.'\,:'~1;;,.Jo<.:"t>-W-.,~-·-:<..J....,_-\,1:;Q'".,::."~.V':.'\.'"'S'-.-;..'..'l;.n.~~~A,""';',.~~~~.W~·~~",;.n;e_nwc..A;.:..~~~",/'il.>i°':1>:;h,,;::,y·.v>r.;:,J,'lo.Y~~.,_•r.•.t"e~~~.p,.*~"lff.,X:.\'"~"•'°•;t~~~
Y,, Lfj~ t.\.La.9 ~ '?'~11.o., ~~ ,~u :u~1 ~ ~~!J 4.4.J~I

r ij
l:, il
;.
' - 11='
C..7 C·
_,. );- C-
11:.. •GI:! •GI:! I~,. ! C..
11='7 L,;rr 1\~ ,r.- ~ 1· p
t1l
~,1 ,J:7 f
.e. ~ f ~
~
-:.. r L,
~ i' ~· b
-
~ .~
-
t ~· 1:-
r .re.. f
l·: .;. ~
•- ~
c.. C ~ I I
I::
]
Al ~I - ,r: f.·.··.• 1
t.:; ~ - 2 '-' f;,° !b 'c. ~ ~ •L b IL l ~. ~
9" f,
f ,r,- ~ I• I~
'[ t ~ l. ,r,- c.. - - ~ ' ~ £ £:..
~ ,t c, ~ .
'[~.f~~-cf c..lJ ll-' •
•(i.. • •l •L C.. ~· e-
:d~ b~~ r~ ,r,-9" t
~~ I ' ~..
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t 'f, I r.:.••.
1 - C
~~ [• 'L $ ~ lr,-
~ ~ l.. ..
~ ~ ~ ~ti _,. 6
L,• J
r ~ {J
I
·~.~r -~ -~ [·(
~f, - ~I 1,.:;1
f. ~• • I' 1(; I
~; '
r, [• I I
[. ~ r 1~ t;, a.:
"° b 1·~. - r· t f ~ [,
·t ·t' ~. 1~ ~ .~~ Cf V. • [ I •
~(»• ~I lJ>• • ~ )
~ 1> \D I - C ~
f;. - t' f1 - _,, ' - I I I c
t.; ·f," ,. £ r- ~
v~ l - 1·· f r- f. [' { t ~ r f : . ~- U: - ~. 1
t J- t.C'
~\:: d ,Cf
f "~ ; Affes -;:- '1 I - ~ \p I~·
(• I L'
·f -
('( ) - _, , ~
.r • C· - f') I _ , y c:.:. :V\ I~.;
~ i
~
~
t)I I
fr ~ i r'b ~. .c..
C. i L,
C.
r - ••
1-.- t.b. r-s.. l.[ .~.- .t... ~- :
I
C.
I
I~ I
c• ~ • • - C .
E
-1 ·~ fr; vE' 11:. J.· I;, ~d: f- ~ r, _i
c; { t. ~ ~ 1>" l i ~ c: f. E '
•!j..j 'e... •:
•f ~ I:,, ;c
f. 1,° ft~f C
~ lrc: 1;,~_Ef ~ti • [• ~! t,(
f ~ fl b [ r.•·:.
·L ,._ C [• fr_·. fr_·. I:; ~: ~, fr_· t.C'
LI ~ • ~ 1::; 1::; - 1:-,
§ ~ .t-:: 1c· fr 'b ·r,· v· c· c.. r ,-
~!1 E: , •L..
f ,L 1~ i~ c.l . c.. ,. I;,
~
r~ 1" • · E... • 4; t) - - ~· ~ h ,. "
r~~.1l ·f t
., . [• ,. c.. fi b
•r.' ~- F ~ r, }. fi f ~ .c .'·_•:.·
tr -
.1:··
-~' f, ~- C..
~t. ~t. ~ ~ ~ ·~ [" ~ ;
')! - - I:. ll-' c.' - ·r. f:,·:.-.:.:..
t)I I
~ ~ ~ ~ f-1
~ C.. ~ ~.. ,f ~
t·t ,~ ~f r~
-! r ~ ~ I 1• : • (::; e• ~ ·~,.. I - - C.. ~· ~ ~ . C f') 1 C.. ~- [
t~-t= f ·i. ·n. ·i. gi ri 'f, -.•- '1! ~
; - t)I [• I [' } E c.. ~. c.. b - b ·E I
' L, C " - ~ • a ~y -. t' t' ~.r. •GI:! •GI:! - IfI=:" 1I [·::.·,.:
~ .[ ~ J-, C7 L, _,. ' 1 ' ~ ~- ,r; ~ I
• "° e.! ~ ~ 1\ • n- ~ 9" t' ~· -E ·E i :- :- i\ ~ ~ 't ~
1 Et"1· "°t -
: [ C· [, ~
~ C:
~ [, t.Ii\ ~._,. 'f~ ~... ~ b' .
' . -· t,t:' - - - .I! !j, r~ r r r ~ ~ l> i i 1:- Iii
I i. [ 1>° !j, f _: .c-; I., ~_.} P:!
t
t{r- ~ f ~..
I - 1· \. 1 '\ •!j_ f' l . .~· C· ~
~I t f ~ ~ .r ~. :r g r i ~ i [i;i~.
r~ ·r r t t i i r~ : r.f 1~ I I
·l
I I I I I IS ~t
u ~ I ~J~~ ~ ' u~\:at
1~<·J·J·:,.·,.;.··:-·;:,, ..;-::,-.·r~··.·.··~::•:-~~.:;;~·'·"i.::,_·.,·:~..~~..···,:--·;·~.{{.·.~~~~~ •. 7-".'.:'·~fjzi~:".r:;r~.- •. :.,·,t·( •. ,; .•. ~ .• ~·.,;:_.~::::z.~-~~i~~~:-~n
. J ~' i i ~ ~ u ~ I y_,.L,1=, u ~ ~ I ~l..>-4 .J-t=WL.4 ~ ~ j j ~

ab....>-4 c..:)1 J ~ 'ii~ ui ~ u ~ I o.:U, ~ ~"i ~ ~ I u~~I LAT
dJ6. ~ J:t~J .~~~~I ~.lJ.,>3 JI O.lJ.,>3 ~~~~I t4ll 0i
-" .,
t_)4?JI ~ "i ~i Ji J~I u"i6. ~ ILIUA ~.J ~ t.~?JI i.>:?'i ~ J~I
. ~ ~ I Ji
:...c.~.-'Z\L:L..u"il
v-- ~ • J i ~-1- ~1'-l.t.
1.)-'-'-""
.. ~1 ~
• ,.,--
- d.b..-'lo.:U,
"..r - ~i~"i
~
~ ~ 4.4~ c..:,lJ~I ~>Ll.11 u l ~ ~ . ~ I ~ I .JL..b?JI~ J ~ 'ii

t.., - - " - -
tli,~ )\AL:,~ y~'l'l l.:U, ~ .~~ ~..\>.J ~i J i ~ ~i ~ lsa.!:b;
.d.J:.~ Jkci uL>~ ~ ~jj ..ll <?' o.l..l>J.I J~"il
l(,JQ~~, ~ uLo.,.t.a...tt ~ ~~~ , ~'-~-""", - ~t,.tt a.1.,.....>Jt
~ ,o.l~J~I u"i~ lsb~.JI J:~JJ~"il ~l~i ~~ L.....o~
0-4 ~.;JI~ ·l.S.»-~I JJ~IJ as'~I uLA~ ..u:.ljg 0-4 u ~ I ~~I
~~ WI JLu.:..."il ~
-- .r..,u u· i "i!, ~y.L~<'~tl
-
· .. .:.._ti ~
.,.,..-w .r::--w · 'I o.:U, ~
0-4 a.6.."..r
l. 4 ·
I,.:, -
~~.)WI~~~ . ..u:.l~I l.!.lt.l ~I~ .!t:, iit\ a.!.;§ J~ a .!I~,
. ~ I o~~I ~ ~.,.t~I ~ I j4':. ~j'J J~"il
a~~t ~ - ~u.Jt ll,.....)4!'1

. [ ~WIJ uw·~'L I A~·. ~ -- • i t.·-.:.. ~Lal uL>WI t6. -
..,..., . '"(t-'-i.) f-'"' u ~ . -· - ~I ~ - LA~
~'ii-0-4 oJ~ 0.P <?I o~I ul.....o.,WI ..u:.ljg J:.6,.:i c..:)1 -4J~ ~~' '.·: "'!J
~~ ~Jj:i ~I 4...9--'-"WI ~1~1 rl.J;.i I 111 ~ ~~I ~~I u ~ ~ ,
~ J u ~ I 4.~I uLA_,.t:,..al o.:U, ~ .« l.!~_ulA_,JJi» ~~ J;...u <.JJ.l
u"iWI» Ji ~Lal~ u~j'JIJ ~-1)-Lll~ ~IJJl.=,JI u"i6. ~ ~~I
-~4-4 ~ ~~oh·~~~~ <?I «~~LlJI
1(,JQ~~t ~ - ~.,~, ll,.....>Jt

,J~)U ul~j.A lfji w~I J~_J J_l;JI u"i6. ~ i;~I ,b.:I I , ; ~
1'.
1 .·7t!.'~,L
~ . j.~ y•~ ~<~- uLui ul~ J i 4.J...ul4i
L u __ ~
~ · L r l ~ L...
LAI '~~~
• -~ -= · -:_ ~tt -
~ ~ r~' ~ ,~w ~~I ~ I y_,L,i ~~ YA <.r...9--'-"WI ~ I wi
,e.,_o,,.~'!l'~...~•.--,~,;..,4!ftr-'J1. 0•-.,•..-J".,.-.; -·~·,,:.~.~-~-;:. .... '0.-9''-'~;,;.......t"XF"'--!o~ll'.IPA._.......,,...t '"'O' ....._.,... --'>-"- , ....,.. >.-r.---•...-.•,.~.-_.::c.,..•.,.·•Y• .,.;:•,,r~o,..__ N..,....__ _,,':":'-1..c.r.
Y,r l.fj~~~'=?.:Llll.oJQ~l~U :u~l~~~IJ4.w~I

'---- • - ,· .-:...~.-~.....i... ~ • -.~ t .. '. ·1.· & ,~-7:". - ·- ·. , " • ·.- .·_ :: _J •• _ • ... _ _ _ • • ..~ d ' . : : C : : ; .. · · - · -·. ·• · ·, • ~ • . ~ ~ ~ · · · · · ~ - ~
J~~l.)\:iT~~I~~ .y~WlrlJ;.; «114~\:u.JI~~

~ lA o.l~ ·.; qi ,.,ti J:.bull J)l;.. 0,-A l A ~ ~ ~ <i'3I Jl>JI w~6.. ~
UY~ ~1 .Jl=.JJ y~i -':!~ 0,-A~I ~.JAJ w4~1 ~L,..o ~I~
~ ' r~ -~.;\>- .ll~i ~ u_,l.u,lju....9 &l:i_,.JI U~..J ~ I ~~j ~
lAA w~jL.c:Jl..9 w4~1 ~ ~ o~~ i.)~i J~ ~I ~IJJ=- ~ ~~I
~ <.:r'-'-4 wl~ ~tu.JI ~..l.4iJ ~ W I ~ o~I ~~~I .>J_,bJ ~1 ~JJ:
. ~,>'-4
-W IJ l.!ll.i.A u~ ~.,...,, . w ~ I ~ o ~ I w ~ I 0-A J~l..9 J~~I

~ ' wl_;-,~I U-"4~..J ~~, ~~' U~..J Jo~ Uj-Q' ccsi111J Jl~i
~ L.:,..&L~<~,, J b . ~ a:"u..1.>JI wl .L~'I Cc.A~ ..1.4l .a..Jl.u::i-.~I
4,...J -~ · --~•
.I.) j •. ~,...-... . ~ - .).,...., - - ~ ~
~~ -~~~~l~WIJ~~l~~~..9w~~l~>G..9~WI
o.)_,b:'J.I w\.:iait\..9 0,-AjJI .)~I wj..94,.:i <i'3I ~L.u~I D:! ~..ul w~l..9 Jl~~I
. ..)~, J_?.J ~ ~l..9 J~~l 0,-A ~b.l}
.;~10--A uL.Ll.tJI ~ J uLqt;,;tl J~l..9 J~~I ~ ,o~ c'~ 0--A

~ .~_,.Jl~~~~l..9J~~l0,.A~ll_,.J1~ -~l[G:,._:;~~I
~~ J~ ~I u~ ~lJ "~ rJ6.. ~.JA :'.)\..:c:il Jl~~l..9 wLJo..al..9 w ~ I ~
~yl ~ . -I~ o~ ~~ ~ l ~ I ~ ~I ~ I lA.l.;1.JA ~ ~
~ J ~ ~, ~ ui
- ui
~1 ~ ~L.u -L.o~..9 o~~- wl..9Ji J ~ ~1 ~..>-4 ~..u
«c.c:i~J» ¥WI ~I~ wl.A.,W.1 ~lji ~ .o-':!~ J..>..b..9 wl..9.lt ~..u ~~
a"'"lsa4 ~ ~ a........:..tJ.I ~_;~1 o»::Jl..9 d..:lW1 w4--,6:..U ~~I o~l..9
~~I ~J ~ .ll~~l..9 wl qt;,;tl..9 ul~ ~Lal ~_,JI JA u~l..9 . ~ I
·".)~ 0,-A tl.J.>JI J~~ ~~I ¥~~I oJ~I ~~
• . -..."\;,....:---..,_,__,._ . . .1 ..E,,£.._.:z_...,..... ,.._._·m~-- ·"""-"-ti,.~--.~-~- . . _.,_,._~.r.-r .:.~.,__._,_- w • .,....r.~.·--·•·.,.-,,1,1.c•.L " - . ' . · - - - ' " ~ Z . : . _ . w ~ - .-....~~-.-11,;Nr~.r1:a....-_.t..,
Lfj~ ~ ~ "?.:.Lll Lo.9 i:,...L=o,j faU : u ~ l '="9 .,~~ 4.1~1 Y, t

i~~,u~~
~ w5JJ ~IJA~I ~ «beat the system rl..Io..al ~~'-:?~Ii,~(')

-~~I t\+i4 D.l~
ufi.: ~J .wl_,b;.~Jfi:.UI ~<(wl~~»~l~~I ~l~(Y)
~~ J~ ?JI ~LluS'l J:..IJAJ wl~I . , ~ ~ ~ I t.b>.ll I~ ;.IJJ ~ I
. ~ I I~~~"}! F~ .JA ~ J:..L>-4 u.A-11 ~J ,ww~I ~
{ $ lt
J.!s ...jJ~~l~u-·H=·~J.lt~J .~'l'l~l~o.l.?.JA~tLiJ~l('r)
-~~1~11 8 ;Q,;.,;2 ~1ww~ID;.l_;g
-~-t'l::l'!",-_,.~ -,_,i:;*.· '"-";.....-.o.-.· •i,;,.-~. ~ • ..- •• .-,:-,• ..i.,.-,_ •~_:.--' • •"·'-'•"-', .. _y,.. _.- ,=;."'• ..• , ••·.-.- .• , •., ,..,._..._,...---~--..-~...-.~-\A·· ~ ·•....-.~'::""'-~'-- .-":".", ",• .• ~.,s.....•·-.,._.• 2>.·, ~-,-: .. ~- •.'.-, .•'C7,•1t..-.r11r-" ,.,.~,-.~~.:-.~•z-.• ~."I:
Y\O '-6l~ 4.1.a.9 ~ ($.:a.JI l.oj 6...L>.l 1:,u :uLJ:..al ~ .)'"""4J~ 4.J~I
~~~t~t.JA~":'L~cui~t~~l~~to~~l
~'-"J'·~·
'->"J ta.\..4J"t ~ 2 ..t.4-& t; C:Jt
Zehava Rosenblatt u~JJ., lal+.!j a~•~i
Orly Shapira-Lishchinsky ~i:. ~i ~ ..1' ~~~.J!t
~ _,,-.< Ll&..o ~
- f""C'"""".J c4 ~
-
·~LJo'J ~
-
~.,.i.,
-
j:.l.a..,. '->i
-
''-'~'ii
.
~LoAL .. ..1.aJ
- ..,........
~F>"'-" . o ~ ~ ~ l .l_;l.,11 o_;bl ~lju,..o (Kaplanetal.,2009) ,~I
~J ~~ ~I u,..o ~IJ ~~ ~ u,..o ~~I ~ly:.i a.:;~~ ~ I I.JA
~ly:. ~I o.JA u,..o ...1>,.IJ JS'~~ . ~ I ~.>3 ~J yl:iJIJ ~I~ r~'il r.J.&.
lateness ~I~ r~'il r.J.&. ~ LA 41~ . ~ I ~I~ u,..o ~ ~~ - -
. (Koslowsky, 2000) ~Ir~ j:.ls=ul ~ o_;.lW.IJ ~ . ; ~ I ~ ..»-bll c..:,-11
~ I ILl.>3 ajiJ ,(Johns, 2003) rj---:11 Jl_,Jo ~ I ~.>3 ~ absence y~I wt
~ ~ I ILl->--3 ~ ~.,.ti Ji ~yJ.J ~_,.b.fl ~_;JI _j---A intent to leave
. (Carmeli, 2005)
., ~
~.JA y~'il ~ly:.i ~~ 1~1 ~ JIJ--..u.;l:i: lAA a.:i>Gll ~l~'l'I ~.J,!J

~Jl_µl l,41~1~..l41 .«~~»~aQloiioUJ~~I ~t-4-
(Johns, 2003; Koslowsky, 2000; Koslowsky et al., 1997) ~L.ul_;..ul u,..o .l.J.&.
lS...1>,.1 .~ll)l.all ~l..ul j:.l.i..tJI ~ u,..o y~'il ~lj,C, i 0~4JI ~ JJlri <i'11
i:.~ ~.>3 ~ y~'il ~ly:.i 0i .JA> c.!:J~I u,..o tJlll l.JA ~ a ,se.!u.JI _;~~I
..... t~·. lbLa:,Lu-'iLo-<'.:.tl.,.JA
i.:J-"--1.) ~· • ~ ~ • l.)A ~ lAA c..r-
t.:,c....9~ .~li:.L;..'..H a.b...:i t,..
~~ 1~1 LA~~ c....9_,-, .~l~J~_;~a.!4.!loiiJIJ}U..~l~jS~

- tS
_:., 1..JWJI
a...u . - .., ~ . _'\ r~'ii r.J.&.) ~i I""(t:o'.tl .; L!.J.I a=;>l:JI '-'~'ii
I - -ti ~ A
•
. I i
u,Q~
c4 llil~ J.ol~I clb ~~ 1~1 w~J ,a.!4.!t;,;;JI J)l;.~4 ~.>3 (~I ~->--3
o.JA ~ o_;~I ~ ~.:UI ~~I [~~I LAt .y~'il ~lj,C, ~ ~_µI _;lb ?/I
~ ~i ~ y~'il ~l#.,L.cJ ~ ~.J.JI ~J '[_;...LUI [~~I ~ a........u.l_;..ul
JJL:tu c....9_,-, 'l>°~i o_;\+t:i .(Koslowsky et al., 1997) Li: , ,o .l~ ~ ~
~l#~ 6::t LA ~~I ~_;...LUI ~\l)l&ll ~ ~.J.JI y ~ ' i l [~~ ~~
.a.!4.!loiiJI J)l;.~IJ ~ ~~I
=-=------~·
YW
now;~ ~49'.&~..c':i:tnnzftJIW r..-•
'-6l~ 4.las ~ "?.:a.ti LAJ ~..b.l l~U
..,..ur::trmt:nmrrs; .- rz~~-~~~ .-...oi -~
: u ~ I ~ .:il-u.4J!.g a...,~1
y~l0l~.)~ll>'4 -~~y~'ilul#_.,L.uLl.)..)~ijJ~~'i
l>'4 0~4-A ~ Ji o~l+4 a..a.,fa. Ji.a: ul#~ I l.!.11:i j:iA ~-Ll 0:.:.UI ~_,J.I
~ I ~l:ul l>'41.!.LI~Jla: 0i ~ I0-AJ . (Kaplan et al., 2009) ~I~ ~..)..w.-
. (Shaw, Gupta, and Delery, 2005) a.!q.!t;,;;JI ~l.....ill ~ rlAi ~ ~ . . J
.~)l;. ~I~ ~ I ~_.,L.u ~ ...l9 ~ y~'il U:OI~ ~ ~#I JAWI ~ J
.a.!q.!t;,;;JI u~)l;.~I ~ ~ J 0A ~\.)..) ~W.1 l>'4 ~ I l~J
a.! q.!t;, iill J)l;. ~IJ y~'il ul#..,L.u ~ull~I ~~ Ll.)..ul "~~
a.! q.! lo jj 11 u ~)l;. ~ I L l.)..U '-:-'--'-"Li.A ~~ <.>"J l..u I 0 i ~ . <.>".) I..u. I ~ cJ.::i
~.)~~Li.A l.!.U.:.U -WJJ .(Starrat, 1991) ¥)l;.i ~ ~ - ·.·:
~fi '"!
~ ~~iJy)lb.U ~)l;..~I ~~I ~ j ~j#..,:JI ~J L.)..u.1 aJL.,.,,._r1
-~ ·- · · -- ~ti -
_j-1-J ~ '-7"" j u.r.u-J ..lill o~I ~
-
- t!. ~1L.j l.!.U~ (.:r'•1 a_gW,1 .u.r.u-J ..i:JI
-• I (.:r'ti ~ C
o..)...l.LLA -~W>Ji - y ~ ct.!•.!:bll l.!.11:i 0µ r~IJ LG~IJ 0-AjJIJ ~_,JI ..)J~ ~

C )I C -
o..)~ o.:DL.,.,,'l'I wr-11~ .(Maanen, 1995) ¥)l;.'l'I u ~ I ~~ ~

01 . (Delattre and Russell, 1993) a.......«.uJ..U.I ~ ~ 0~)l;. i 0.,k ~ ~ t ~
~_,11 ~ y>lbll u.r.u-J~ l..9-4~ 0iJ LG~[~~ , ~ 0t ~ ~j'J.1 0A
.)lb?JI I~ ~Ll: .(Starrat, 1991) ~~'ilJ ~..).J-4ll F-1 ¥ 0 ~ ~.:.UI
·<.>"Jl..u.1 ~ ~ <::r.~'il ~_,1.uJI ~~ ~.)~ ~)l;.~I
u~i ·IY°~I ~J ~ y~'il ul#..,L.u ~~~~I ~J

~ ~ ..)J..).) ~ lA ltJL.c. y ~ ' i l ul#_,1--.u 0i ~ ~ J uL.,.,,1.)..ul
tliAJ ~-LllJ 01..~~I ull~J aJ..)~I ~l.:.UI ull~4 ~.;J ~J ~ I tW>J~
LG~ I 0J..) ~ t,_W>Ji 0i,Lt: 0:.:.U I 0_,.j.t.l I w i . (Kwantes, 2003) a.......«.u.)..U. I
~L.,.,,~ ~ , 0A y~>Ll ~1-L11 ~ ~ 0i ~j'J.I l>'4 0§.: ~ ~~'
, ~ I t-4-,~~ ~ J Lzu..,,\.)-Ll ~yaS o,u)..L4ll w.)~'i J ~ I I~ LG..)i

. y ~ ' i l ul#_,1--.uJ 4.!q.!loiiJI ul;g)l;.~I LJ::I ~~I~ ~ I ~~ci..J~J
-)l;.~I ul~
l.9 ·~ll~ ~
·- 1"---(to' -· j ~. ~ ' i i IY° · Ilj,&- ~ L~ o~
-t!. ~ · j...L&,j
• ~~
. '··'-JA·--'I -
()A~ ~ ~ ~
~tt~I
- • ~
~l:ul.J ~ J ,. J-,~ ~ - ~~ j .a -sqsloiiJI -
.)~'i aJJb ~ l.!.U~J 4.!q.!loiit\ J)l;.~IJ y~'il U:Ol~i ~ uL.,.,,I.)..) ~)l:;
-~~ u!,~ F ~ ·[.)~, [~~,
V"Jl'°'11 ~ C,J oJt;.;;tt J~~t ~1-"4 ~ ~~~I va~l ~.fo:JI ~~~J
r::~:.:£B&llia:::12:r,.~il-i-:&-:.:&1'l25ID;:i~~~:;s~;.:::7iwai,.'iu;'mmr.w-~~~r:.:;rs:J.::~f.:?:'7(>:~:e;;em1&:i;7i!&.t.,.rt::IJ
~ l-6,l>G. 0-4 ~I a~_,L.u.110-4 al§,~,; t..r.'~")11 ~~I~

.. a.!Q.!t:.,;;JI
,, ..
~i ~ ~ ~1 ~ WkA ufiJ~ ")} ~i Ji y_,!htl J.>JI 0-4 Jg~ u~.,.t.1
. (Kaplan et al., 2009; Vardi and Weitz, 2004) ~_,J.I c..:-JIJJ JJ~ ~ l_,Jljl.A
~ , I <)A ~ I ~ 0-4 ~IJ
.. ~ .. a~_j,LuJI ~ 0-4 c1..t.........ulJ ~~ c.!lUA
J~ -~4 ~ I c.!lyJ ~ I c.!ly a_;,J y~IJ ~ I c,;s r"~")}I f"~J ~ I
~J ~ j as'~ ~L;.. ~ c.!l.;i·~·i ~~ ~j ~ u~_j,LuJI o~ ~1 11~~))
a..u~I
... ulo·'-··
.. ~ c.i.>\.:i ~ ~< . ~~ . ~ I ~
'"' l..iA ~y '"' l,.4)~:.t; l....>'°~J
· . l,.4)~•
. ~ I c.!ly a.;,J y~IJ ~ I c.;s r~")}I r~ ~J

[~IJ ~ J ~ I ~?tJI ~~~I~ r~")}I r~ ul#_,lu, ~ j j
rJ.J,1 Jt aisl ~1 ~ <>"JI..Ll.l ~J
_. . (Koslowsky, 2000) ~ I r ~ ~~1 J.-.;g
~I~ r~")}I r~ ~ ' ~ -~l.;JJI ~ I ~1 J~_,JI ~ ~..ill
r~ ~ ·~ ~ ")} ~jJIJ ~ ~ ~.LJIJ <)Aj.ll ~ .)~i Ll.>\.:i ~!
~~
.. ~I ~
.... .. I ~ I Ly ~'.j ~ a..,b::L.......c,I
•• • i~
~1 JI_j,> ~I ~ · 0-f.l r' ~")}I
.. ~
~ ~ , ~ 0-4J.ll r~")}I r~ ~ ~1 ~w.1 J.ol~I LAi . 0~_,1.1
~jjl r"~")}I r"~ c.i~ .~_,JI ~~->-11 ~ J Y! Q.!t:., ;;JI rlJ=J")ll ~ ,JG.ti
~i ~~i ~_,1.1 ~JJ 0~ LA~(.;;; , ., 1~JJJJI r~")}, r~) ~~
4>-L,JI ciJ LJ::1 ~Wl.! -~Lal ci_,JI ~~I~! J~_,JI <)A ~ i Ji
~ ~jJI r"~")}I r"~ ~ ~~ J.ol.,_c. ~ illWIJ ~ I LJ::I tljlllJ ~JJIJ
~.,11~j...l90-4 ~i J.ol.,.c. ~1 ~ ~ ")} ~jJI r~")}I r~ .)~..J . ~
c.i.lly,JIJ ~->---1,IJ ~ I Jb. ~~J u~l_,J.I JS'~~ D_; b.! .,,JI~
cl.! Q.!J:., ;;JI a.Jl...u.l4 ~ ~ ' r~' r~ y'-:---,i ~i ~ i . (Blau, 1995)
. (Shapira-Lishchinsky, 2007) ~.;...l.411
~
,,.. ~Ll.J- ~• k.1...
~~
.. '1.,jl_g L-tl, -" ~")}I ~ ~~i.
~ u-- ~r-
.
~~ ~ J r .. t~~,, ..
.(Koslowsky,2000)~bj?]IJo..>:!:!lAAJ~lt~lc4~J~~f-1WI~~
~)WI ~~?J ~L:. a .!Q.!t:.,;; ~.,-6, ~ ~1.;JJI ~ i?GA.;J ,;.»Jl.!
~ 0..,_,.;..b.1.1 u~I ~~ ~' <>"J.;.J....Jl.!
~ i u.,s::;.; Q; ,114 ,~.i4 ·ct'·
u ~ a.slS'~ ~_,JI uJ~ ")} .i9~1 ~")}j.....Aui ·.·: "'!J . .)tw.l <)A
(S 11,a·,4 ~ LA~~ ofi~ ~ y~~ ,~lf1JI ~l_;~)U ~_,lhll o.)UI
LA 4Jlc ~ ~ 0-J_p-b.ll ~ I 0 i ~ . (Shapira-Lishchinsky, 2007)
~la:u'11 ~ L4.A 4>-1~'11 J~ v"-'...J...Gl4 .)~I ci_,JI ~ ~~I o.,JJ~
-~1 Lt.A ~6. ~Li.A ~.:UI 4>-1~'11 ciJ i.>A
~Li.A 0~ LA~ Jo~I ~."4 ~ -l : ~ ~I)) jA...11 ~ y ~ I ~
<r-"l-.i. ~ LS •(Harrison and Prince, 2003) <«olLll l.!ll~ ~ ~l..,:tl4 t--l.,=i
o.)~ ~~ 1.S.:UI ~.,WI y~I WJ y~I i.>A ~ . J ~_,j o.::i (Sagie, 1998)
jA...11 J-""'6 ~ ~\S' a.!«o;....:a, .J."4~ ~ ~ f ' ~ J 0~4.ll u.lo_,J.I oJl_;h,
~ '1 y~~ O.)~ ~~ ~.:UI ~~I y~lj .aAeaicceQ ~ j ~1.)~ ~
.~')JI u.lo_,J.I o ~
jA...11 J o ~ ~ ~ I y ~ ~l_;J ~ .., .! I ai JI Y4--u~I 0---AJ

. (Gaziel, 2004) 4-wi_;.J.l.l ~.JJ. o~I ~l#.,kJIJ (Myburgh and Poggenpoel, 2002)
~..>A~ y~I ~ l_p-j.o ~_;...L&.o ~I ~"='J)U ~ I ~~GJ.I ~F.J ~J
·L.uJ1j
'-'..
a,.. Q ,t;, ;;JI aie.JL
.. ... •
-~t
- ~ j 'J-*'
-
· <, .) . .:.u ~, ~
.. ~.J-4:
-_.. ,
.J.JI ~~L• ~ ~
~J .(Felfe and Schyns, 2004; Martocchio and Jimeno, 2003) ~~'11
_;~I ~la.A i.>A 0~ ;u~ ~~ ~ I y ~ 0t ,·./; ,a.!q.!l.;JI ~~I
L_;.JJ.I ~.JJ. ~1.J.JI oJ~I y.,L.s,4J (Myburgh and Poggenpoel, 2002)
~~ 0.*:-7=; ..,.? ~ I 0 t ~L.ul_;..1.ll "~ ~ .(Scott-Norton, 1998)
-
o~J .~I ~ I~ ~~41.!.U~J ~ ~ J~ ~ o.J..p,.ll >.!f:. ~~'11
L-:-fl.·.rt'l:\,4-l..__ ...'Z\ l~··-~1 i. ~1-.1L...JI ·\S'l~l ~ -•~~ 11 · · a...uutl
u---" v-- :.r--J - ~ ~ ·- . - u ~ ~j -
'--'~ 11 -:. •
. - ~ LS •~b:i'11
... . _'l:\ • lili c.:r'1 ~
~ "::"u :. ct:,~ a,- -,t;, ;;JI a..Jw.JL
Q
- • i~~· -=-" ct:,i
y~I y~ i.>A ..1..1~ ~ .*9 ,l.:U .L_;.J..41.J _ ; ~ y~I ~ b i.>A ~ I
~ ,.;:o'l o~~ 4..4.l~J l.!lJjS' .(Imants and Van Zoelen, 1995) ~ l
'?""" l_;.J.J I ( sI.! I O ~ i.)A J14i d..:!A-'='11 y)lbJ I (YIj.)..\ ~ ~ ~ lJo.a.j '11 0 t ~ L.u l_;.J.J'
0-AJ .(Miller, Murnane, and Willett, 2008; Woods, and Montagno, 1997)
~~1
- o'J-'-"i.LA
• u..J\S'.:i
- c.:r'1 ~tu.u~I '--'~ • - J~ - u· l ~·-< ~· a.bL-u . -~ a.JUI
- ~WI
..
(Rosenblatt and Shirom, 2003) f'~J ~~.JJ.J _;~ .L_;.J.1.1 o_;bl JAlS' ~
~1~'11 LWI <Y'l_;J..1.1 ~ ~'1--4,ll ~ I ~ ~ I ~~ ~ I t ~ I
Y.J~ ~ ~ ) ~...)Al - - -
- 1_;'1j..\ H 'rAo 'VH -! J:pl.>-'-"1 ~ a..b...uj£.llj
.('1·,···
V"Jl..ill ~ d.z 4.zlaii!I J~~I ~1.j-4 ~ !.:'~~I Vo~t ~~I o~lcj
J·.·:·.rH'. . ..:J·{j}J, .. ;:z.\·, .ft'§·~p.· .. J~ •• .-;u· •,,. .·,"'-:i--<§1 ~>eA§eAf.ti-Yf%P.tf.&#htnt' 1·:!Y ~ -'· r·.,'~·r~.~--(·····/\~-f:r!e:T,:?7~-~·····:rmw:.-+: . .-<j£,kl
y~ ~ ~ ~ l~jA ~ ~.:UIJ ,~11.!ly ~ ~ ,'11.1~ w,,ll ~~1

ti - -
(Carmeli, 2005; Lambert and Hogan, 2009) , ~ I 0--4 t.S->l.;f'I ~.,.ti

_A a.!A~ a.La~ o.._~.)
~w1Jc.J-U.J 1..u.1.~ ~ ~ ~Ju
·~-:.-~Ario ~ 1...~ w~I
. ~ '.J b)U
~ ~
- -
l.!l_;i ~ ~.J.l ~.:UI ~ I c.:,i ~.;ll 0,-4 .(Smylie and Miretzky, 2004) ~
~ rJ.-.11 ~ ~l.;J ~~I·.·: :c,JIJ .~I~~->~ 0,-4 c.:,~ ~.;l...1.4
Jgi ~ ~ '-4 c.:,4 ulo_,J.I t~I -1:!~4J ,~1.;JI , . s ~ ~ ~ I o.;.lliA
~I~ ~IJ.J , . s ~ ~ ~.:UI o.:UL.u~4 ~ ~ J .y_,lkll ..\>JI 0--4
~jA ~..G.t.l ~l.;JI ~ (Grissmer and Kirby, 1997) a.....d . L.,~IJ J~ ~I~
. (Liu ~d Meyer, 2005 Jl:al ~~~I) y6:..-.j~I c.,:ol~ ~ ~ . ? . ~
~b «=Jl:9)WI ~~ 4\•~ <r"_,bll yl:iJI ~l.;J o ~ I ,.s..,_;.~1 y~~IJ
.(Ingersoll, 2001) ~ I t~JiJ ~l.;.J.ll «=J~WI
~c.:,~~l«=J~.l~I~ :~Ji .a.uJ , .. ~__;;«=Jl~b~ll.!ly"-:!,llJ
-
'-4 4J~ .(Ladebo, 2005) 4ld ~ I o.;.>l.U LJ~ ~jA JJJ., ~ I l.!l~ - - -
~l£.4 c.,:o~ L4.4 )4Abps-~I ~ ~11.!l.iJ ~ ~.J.l 0--:.:UI c.:,~I c.:,~
~ I ~-.,.j c.:,i,. ·: "'.', ~l:i • (Ingersoll, 2001).; b:,c..U L......,.;..u.l ~ (.)-"---J~...u.JI
~ I o.;.lliA ~ ~IJ ~11.!ly ~J o~I ~ ,.s..,.;.i j....AI~ ~ ~
~~~l~<r"~'l'l~l>'1IJL......,.;..u.la•4 w.i I~~ w 4id
ti -
0,-4 ,~..,11 0,-4 ~~ c.:,~ ~~ . (Ingersoll, 2004) L......,.;..u.l ~1..9 ~~
~'~\.tit~.)~ 0,-4 c.:,foa:! ~..9-'-" ~ ' l.!ly ~ ~.J.l ~.:u, ~' c.:,i ~.;ll
~ b ~ p~ .isJ ~bjf'I 0,-4 D.JJ..l.! ~ ~ (Maertz and Campion, 1998)
.(Albion et al., 2008) ~.l~J ~I~~.)
«=Jl#_,.611 ~ 1..111 «=Jl:!)W4 ~. ) ~ yb..-j'ii C..,:01~ i J..? l!J~ ' ~ ,
~.:UI u=ol..~'l'IJ .(Johns, 2003; Koslowsky et al., 1997) c.,:ol~~I D ~ ~fill
0,-4 ~'~ a~~~~~ y~~1 «=Jl#_,.L..uc.:,iybr~~, 1~ ~1.;J~
0-AJ . ~ ~ a . L u i ~ «=Jlb~.;14.l ((~~))- -lS'_,.L..u ~ ~ J «=Jl.9~1
«=J~~I ~IJ y ~ ~ I «=Jl#_,.L..u ~ ~l...ul «=Jll)WI ~ ~I [~WI
t:t~ ~ l!J~ y~'l'I JA~ c.:,i [~.J-4-i.ll I.J.A z:~ ·[.;...Ltl.l [~.J-4-i.ll ~
. (Koslowsky et al., 1997) yl:iJI_, ~11.!l.iJ ~ ~ ot.bJ ~~I ..>-"~4 ysiiiJ
\..sji ~ c.:,~..,11 l.s:!Jl ~ <i'11 t~J~IJ a.!ci.:t:, ;;ti ol..L,,..~I [.;...ull l.J.A ~ ~
,~LUI~) 1!:JI..L,,..~I ~ a..1:&.Al c.JAJ .a.!;.J;_,JI ~~ ~-.,.jJi ~j:,L;..J .)~
Jwi .lJ.lJ ~1 .)~ ~ ~ (~' '">lA.; ~ ~ll>WI '"~ '~Jl.l?JI ~..1.11 01~
~Lil
• -
1._-: - •-.:.~ ___-: :. '--'I·
~ ~ ~ ~ < . > - - ' ~'-'-
-~r l '·- b.llS'J..LLAA~·'--··
· b~I ~·' i : _ ~
i...1.U•
~~ -~4 ~ ' ~..,:; l.>:P-tJ ~ ' ~..,:; ~ ~1 r~u ~ ~ ' ~ 4.lA\S' rl:!i
.a.:Q.:loiill J)l.;.~4 t...l.t: ~ ~J..GJI r..14Lll ,~ 0i ~ llA ~
~J ,4:lWI a..ulJ..ul ~~~~~a.: Q.:t:, iiJI J)l.;.}U ~~ ~)Ci ~llA

J:l.lJ ,organizational justice a.: Q.:t:, iill aJI.J.AllJ ,ethical climate ~)l.;. ~I tl.i..11
. tendency to misbehave ~~I ;;t:-L.u?J
~ ~)l.;.l 15~ ~ <:i'11 ~IJl~IJ ~_,l.uJI ~la.A ~)l.;. ~I tl.i..11 ~

~)l.;.~I t~ ufi.: ~ <>"Jl..u.l ~ .(Victor and Cullen, 1988) ~_,1.1 Lj;
.J..a.A~
- Ll)l.;.~'I
- ~- •I c.;--
'" ~:.~ .. ~!j , ~
- I u-LL.:;~·' ·-·i c.;--
. ,_,_......... '" '-:~
.r .. & .P.- j-:J:.t:;
. (Robinson and Bennett, 1995)
tL4ll wl.j 4~~ (Victor and Cullen, 1988) ~FJ .)~ r~'
4-u\:,~I
- . ____& -)l.;.}U ~
~JcJ -~ ~LJ-~ ~ ~~ 4Jjl I ~- .
• .P.- ...1.-...>-i ~ ..
~
_l)l.;. ~'
~~I ~bLJ_j) u~?/IJ ( ~ ...1.-...>- ~ i ~! a.:,o.;. «~«JI a ..,.Loll ;;.lLJ_j)
~_J .p...~)l.;.~1 ~P4J.4r'_µ.1~,)~p4,1.1..,c~ ~~i ~1 as-~,
.~WI _;Uo?JIJ ~ 1 Jl.Jo?/IJ .lyill ~ J J:6::JI ~~ ~l:i.JI ~~I
J\:'J.I ~ ~ ) ~J-4" ~~I L ~ I ;;~~ ~L...ul_;.l ~~I ..L..a.J
Appelbaum,Deguire,andLay,2005;KellyandDorsch, 1991 ;Peterson,2002;
(Upchurch and Ruhland, 1996; Vardi, 2001; Wimbush and Shepard, 1994
~...,:J.I ~)l.;.~I J-Al_~I c.:.J_,L.z;~I ~L...ulJ..ul 0-4 ~.J.All ~~ui ~
~J ~~.JJJ .l...1.-...>- J:.wl..)-""1 ~ ~~i ~IJ.l ~ ·[~~I I.J....A c.;,-L:.
;;J~ ~IJ ~ t ~~I ~i ~ 1.iJ.:t ~ l e . (Rosenblatt and Peled, 2002)
u\+uillA ~t ~.., .«~>11».., <•~lc.>11» ~.., ~.;...ul ~4--~ J+ul' ~
• Lu....ulJ.l ~ ~.., ~~.)JJ ~~ ~ ~~ '~'->-""?!' ~ , rl..Jo..al
J;..b ~I~~~ J.l~I ~_,1.1 r~4 ~lc..;JI tl..i..o I i, coi1
~~I y~l ~ r~~I ~ I J;..b ~lc..;JI tli.A ~ . ~ I [JL....;..J
~L>J...LAJ ~ I ~ i ~ jS'~ ~.;JI a~.::ll LAi . ~ I ~ <'>stakeholders
YTT
V"Jl""11 ~ Ci.z 4.!t..;tt J~\tt ~IJA ~ ~~~I u,o~i ~.folll o.)l&.J
mt,..~,sr;<:7~:rt~m.~2@:.~~~::If£..::.;;r:m:1ti1~~}:::tr:.r~:::;,::1.rui1im;?;;.;::i::I1!a\'i'.ii~».:~t.::'?z.;;:~;~t;:;7;,uzr!lr~~~
a\uJI o.JA j:LA ~ ~_,.1.l 0-4 c'9..,:Ul 0-4 . ~l~I ~ ~:= .~,iJIJ ~11.!l~l
'.·: '"!J -~~WI ~l.,lJIJ~l l.!J_,1...-Jl~wJ~f"l_µJ~IJ~I ~ltL+il
,~~I wl~l?.1 ~J .l)yJ.1 J-lWl ~_)_,:JI~ ~>11 ~~~I tl.i.ll .l~I
Jig 0.AJ ;;Jb?JI Jig 0-4 d.1.oWI ;;~~10-4 ~.,.11 ~.:Gt~ 41 _;Jo.lll p.
t!.·.~.L ...u~li . -~~~I· Lal~·· 1. ·
~
'---= ~,~~~..,...
A.t\ •.• !l!. .t\.~ ~ - -~~ r - :.}Ju ()--J_r)-· ~I
.(Peterson, 2002) ~ I J;.b ~_,.1.l l.!l~ ~ I ~ I 0-4
i_gb?JI ~~.:UIJ a.! 4.!t;.. ii JI aJl...wl ~ a.! 4.!t;.. ii JI J~)U..»-~I r.'b oJ I lAi I
~is,J~l J:~ ~ a.!4.!t;,;;JI aJl...wl ~.;J .(Greenberg, 1995) ~I~~

c.i~wj5J ...l.41 .a.!4.!t;, iill w4,.~I ~~l&..4,bj~I o.JAyjJ'°4JaJl..wl~_,.l.l
,, -
distributive justice ~_)_,:JI a.JI~, ~Ji : WJ ~ ~4-, ~ a.!4.!t;, ;;JI aJl...wl
~
,lul:i.(Adams1965)ulo·t\d...i.k'---·
- ' 'r -
~ti ~b.l.JI.J.\~b~I
~ '?""' ~ ~
tl :.- ~tt
~ (.:r' ~ '?""' J
d.AJ;.i «ull wls;l..r?""?JI ~ b l ~ ~IJ procedural justice ~l?.?JI Lll...wl
~ ~~ . (Pillai, Williams, and Tan, 2001) a.! 4.!t;, ;;JI w4~1 J : ~
; ; ~ ~J.l 0~ 0 ~ lA~ ~ ~i ~ ~ I wls;l?.1 ~l 0~.,.11
01S s;I~ -~ Ul.ull a.!4.!t;.. iiJI wl)~I ;;Jb!J &..bJ ~ ~I w~I ~
0.,..:S~ ~_,.1.1 0i ~ ~L.ulJJ.l~ ~I?. ?JI aJl...wl Ji ~_)_,:JI a.JI~~ ~.;,:tll
~ p~ ~b?JI ILLI~ ~ ~l&..4,bjlJ (Greenberg, 1995) ~I~ ~~?JI
~ ~l&..4,bj)U ~Jt.u JJ~ l.!Jl..i.A ,ILLI.:U -WJ -~l#.,6 ~J ~I~ - ~LA~I
.· .. !t!..t\ , __ ~tu., -='-~-k&.Sa,q,t;,;;JlaJl...wt
~ r u--~ . ~ - - -
~ISJ...L4 ~ ~J ~~I ;;~L..u?J J=-1,1 ~ a.! 4.!t;, iiJI J~)U c.Jl:JI ~4,JI lAi
..i4Li Jl:J.I ~~I.LU~ <JAJ ~ wl#.,6 ~ ~J~I J~ 0 ~ ~.,.11
JI -
~~I~ i_g~\ os;~! i_g~ ·(~J~~I yl:,i.JIJ ~I~ rLt:..::u"il r"~
~~ ~~"ii ~WIJ ~IJ a.!4.!t:,;;t\ ~l~I l.!1~4 ~J~I ~~ .:Gi
i_g~\ ;;s;L.u! u-"L.;9 ~ ,~11.JA ~ .(Vardi and Wiener, 1996) ~l.i.11
~ .:Gi ~ ~~ ~.,.11~ ~J~ ~~4J ulo.,.tl ~LJ:.4,bjl ~...>1o ~
s;-'"'"" W::' J:=iJ Jo~) l.!Jl..i.A '<:rq.!t;,;;JI 1.!J~I wl::,~l ~J . ~ I ~ I ~l#~
workplace deviance ~I.J-4A ~ ~l~"il)) : ~ 0-4 wb-lb,ooJ ~~I
counterproductive behavior ~ I l.!l~l»J <1(Diefendorff and Mehta, 2007)
;;~ ~ s:iJ 'ii 4.!t;, iiJI ~~I s;_j-1-AJ ~ , ~ ~ ~U .(((Miles et al., 2002)
. ~ I s;~i \+9~ 0i ~ I 0-4 <?JI ~ I ~ I ~l#.,1.u, tl~i 0-4
*~--~~~•v~-..-..·_1.:.oe""71.,.:«c?·.~-"'4;.-;" ·. ~..;,...,.·.·.r~-- ..,,,,.,,.,..... ~,.•..., •·.••.'.A"l.'s.'.P'I,-,, •·.:,..-c."'-·-_.,.",.,?"J.· ·.:-.1fl'Q'l"-;.':.""""·.v...:..~--- •.-:;~.-•.'.-,;,,.\ , ' .. '.....-.s,. _g,.,~:,.-,..._•.:. ~:,· .,~.,·.o.;,·: · c.~~~A; ;,;,;;,~ .,:.,,v.
Y'fY' ~~ LLa.9 ~ ($~I LAJ o~ faU : u ~ I ~ Jl.w.aJ!_g 4-w.J-?.ll

C···--·~, ..:/r·-.·.. ~-··. ·,1·i· ,:.,, ..- ... /.fa-=-:-:,· 1'. '·.' ... ,_. :.1 .=.·. ,·· ·=;._:.-,,•.';"'>'"§..:.-·,, .. .,'.,:·i.,: ·=~. ·. ··~ .... ··:., .. '"I(=·-:-':(' :.=·r ··..-.,::.·-.. .. ··( ::y..-.,·.- 1\. ,.....· ..-.~-.. /· .. ..:··,.-.. j·,;:-'·==.-1··.'~·.:· ~·(· ...... · ··.,, C ,.. ,. _.. ·,. ·. >·=·-//:.~/=· ··'.:'1·::..•. '.:."f ·.;.:=·. .:·-: .~.--.-:.i,:? ··ti j
U,:'~~t U~~ ~ ~~\tt J.4\att

L,ji L.IJ..ul o.J.A ~ ,-, ,~,,; ~I y~'l'I ~I~ f.:J as'~I u ~ I LG..1.>!
~»Jo . :1~ LoJ..i.c. ~_., o~ u 'l'6.. ~ d ...alo_.,. 1.1 o.; b.! , ""·~·JWI ~ t ,;,=-=.j
,( t.:.L
c..>""'-' ,y::,J-A ~
•
. • . J\:ill ~
I. .... I ... ) '--t\.
c.:r-- . DJI.~
v--' ~ ..r>-
-~ ~
..<.:.~It•~..,...
.. !t!...q 4-L> \,,;..
- •'.)
J\:ill ~~)~I c.!l.;J ..9l (a.!«o;.2&i ~ «.,: '"! J\:ill ~ ~ ) y~l..9
JI_~ J14i 0l ~ ~.,U ~W.I oJb?Jl 0~ ,(~J.>,11 ..9i [J.)-JI JI.Zjl «.,: '".'
y~'l'l 0l ~ J .(Blau, 1994) ~ I ~~\J c:,..o ..9l o.J.A y~'l'I u~_,1.u,
* * - *
~ J IJJ.l a.!Q.!J:,ijJI J~~;)/1 J_µ 0~ '~~ I~ .l~ y~'l'I r~ _.,t
~ ~~f.:JI J..oWI ~ ~ ~~ ~~ .~1 c:,..o y~'l'I ul)~ ~ ~
.~j c.:r--
1.... • - J ~ Li ..ul
~j,J '.) ~ c.:r-- ~J-""' • -·
· I~ l ~>Ci
-'- - ,... ~ .< .-:tl.J a.u~I ,y::,
~ , c.!J_.,_; ~_., Y' .! ; u_., ~ , ~ r' t;, ; ·,'l'I r~ .;-.:i..h!

~.J..w ~~ J....S ~ J....Al...Lll J----:,,JI ~ ~Lll y ~ I ~
. (Shapira-Lishchinsky, 2007; Shapira-Lishchinsky and Rosenblatt, 2009, 2010)
*
J6.. ~_., • 4Jtc. ~_,a:; ~ 'l' ~ ' ~ r~'l'I r..1&. ~ .:1_,ull ~.,.i1 01
o.:1WI ~~Li.A~ fA~.:UI ~'l'~I ~4~.,.tl ~~_,..:;.JI~ ,~I y~
<.)!J.:1~~.:u1~10~,~lc.!Jy:;~~ ~_., .~1~1~a.!b;;1t
0.i)Q~isu.!111~l~.;,ll~~l~fA~IJJ0,.4~yl~J:p..ylJ~j~~jf
"-:11 0.?.~ ~.:UI ~_,JI ..9i ~l..ul ~..G ~ ~ I ~ ~b~ c:,..o ~ I
~ PJ:i ~~ o.J.A y~'l'I u~_,1.u, 0i ~.;,11 c:,..o ·d.l:...Y ~ J ~ ~
.(Rosemnblatt, Shapira-Lishchinsk and Shirom, 2010) y)lb.11 ~ ~
-~~'l'l~a.!,o~l~~,~~y)lb.11~~~_.,..:;~.:u
• .....J.lo.,
<JA
* ..
_ ~"~.'J ~~'J c.:r--
• _ • L..o.,1
*
, ... l.J.,..,
• u • • ·~ · · -'-'I .;->~
· . ..Ull u.,....--
. .:.~qJ uJ.»- :. ~ ~
~Ld • u.w::u- - w IY-..r>-
· · t:J.I ~"~·'J ~ c.:r--t ... ~I1..)-1-",.
,, :.'l'I ~.tl.J · .~-:1t1 ._. -'-'I
._,.,. LJ:A..J"'""""' ~
~·.,\h.!, ,L.JJ.ll~~~lj&ll~lc:,1 -~IJ~~o.:1bMl~~i<.)!

- - *
r~'l'I r..1&. ~~I~~.) _;l:,.j ~ J 0-AJ -~WI jl:u.uf.:JI ~ ~_,..:;.JI 4Jlc.
0Jl.,:J4 ~ 0i ~__., (Comer, 1995) ~~ ~~I \5_,L.u y~l..9 ~1 ~
c:,1.J.A ..u~ ~ .(Adams, 1965) '=7"'""JJ.ll f9lbll ~~i u~~J u~..1A ~
~ ~ ~bl J~ .:1~'/ L.J..ul oJbl ol:tl...A c:,..o 0l::,~'l'I 0~_,bll
~..9..9 L.J...LJl 0..:1..9~1 .:1).,_l.l yL.u.:,.. ~ ~~J ~l..9 ~ ~ ~ I
* * -
L.J..ul ~LLA ~ ~ l~b yl:!,ill..9 ~ I ~ r~'l'I r..u.l 01 ~ .oJb?JI
. -
Lfj~ ~ ~ 1$.:.ill Lo..9 o...b,,j
·-- ,~u ~-.---=----~---------
: u ~ t ~ ->l.i..ilt.9 4.4..'~t
nt
~Jl""1.1 ~ C,.! o.!loii!I J$~1 ~l..9-4 ~ 1-:'~~I ~!).ct ~~I o.>~1
f=-::=,. ·:-:·.:::.,,,.-,:.::·> .,:;·· \i7(••:f\j7f· S:f ·.-····>·::."""{ '.•,·:.·· .. ; ~--.,f.': ,I·--.~·.'.·:'.··.·.,·..._,. iz,:..•:.·.(ljJ:-3·:·,, ..:!. .:·v ·,: .,· .:" -·;:·: : .:-:'i'i;··r,,/tf{'.;.. ,·•-.. ..·,-.·.;.}:3"-::=:·~·.."..-, - ~ J : ,......~"""'"t.:-_.,,.,.,.. .. '£,.,,,.,.%<"""
.. __. ;..,.._...,.,..,., 1-·i'._,...,...,
:·-,.,-,:<·-":'~,,..,,.,..··~:.'-:-.',=·::{fu.,.,,.,..:.~4
~ i I.S..u <:r4-'=1I ~ I o.l~ o.lk. ~I"~~ ._;~I ~l#~ ~ ~

w~IJ0.,_,.;..t:a1 wyJ.a.1.1 ..ll .~1~~r~1.,w_iJWI ~~J~.,11 r~
·"-'-"_;-\ll 'T-~ o.::i ~~'ilJ ~~I t.J>i <i'1'-' ~ I ~I Ju.JI~
~~~Ju.JI c.!J~ a.;i -la: ,y~IJ ~I~ r~'il r.J.....&. c..S~J
~~ 'ii a.....-=bl;JI ~ ~JJ ~J . ,:,LAW l:c-~ lS.,L.u ~.,1, J.-.u.14 - - -
~ ~ ..ll (Montes and Zweig, 2009) social exchange theory .
. -'-'c..Sl·L'il
I.:" ~ ~ u· ia....d.4~'ilLl.lL:i..Jla..s·t~~,,
. .. . ~ W"°.>-'4J · ...... .. ~
~l.6'·'---'1
.. ~ a...s~~, ·
~I"~~ .a:s)WI d b ~ c..9bj?JIJ wjl.,:-Jl w~ ~~I al)lc. '5i
~ ..
w~fo..J .l..J-411J ~ I <JA ~ ~ c.!J_;~ <:i'11J y ,11,;;11 J~'il f-*4A o~tg
. (Robinson and Rousseau, 1994; Rousseau, 1995) ~ I ~ <JA ~tu
a.!o.!t:,iill ~Lal_, aJ~I Ju.JI tL..:o_,t_, ~Lal ~~.;ll J:,~ (ljj ~ I c"9j:i:J
~
~ f1 1~1 o_;.lW.1 ~ rj.£11 ul,s, l.:U.a_;s~.,11_, ~ 'i_,JI u.,.;.lo.,11 ~ ul ~.:.. ,uJI

... .:~,, ..lll..:ill c.!J 1"ff-'-'
·~~ •- 4.Jl
.~·.1 (ljf c.:r- .. ~ -•~ ~,1 ~
· < - .d , ~ .. I a.,~ b'il a.!AWI ~ ...
..
~
.yl~ t ~ lS_,1- -la: c.ill.:U Y'J

- ,ul;.,11 ~4-
~ y~~ d.J:._,e..1..4
y~'il ~l:P_,l-ufiJ ..ll '5.:UI ~_,JI~ ,_;~4
.. ..
~~~~ ~ c.!J.;i,~,i ~ t.s:,i 'il ,~4 Jo~_;I ~I~ _,t a.!,o:,c.j, ~\S ~1_,_,
-
~~lal)Wl~~.:UI LA :~y-fbl1Jlj.ull '-4i . ~ l ~ ~ a ; e ~ i ~
y o.:t:, Ci JI c.!J_,!-JI ~l::,.lf ~ ~~ ~a.! 4.!t;.. Citl J ~ ~IJ y ~ ' i l ~~_,L.u o.::i
lS..U Ju.JI~~µ~~~~ JA~ y o.!lo ;;JI rl~'il ~ ~ <:i'11J ~~I
~ ~ i u~ ..ll y-o.!t;, ;;ti rl..).:tl'il u~ ~ ,(Cohen, 2003) ~.,11 r~
.~JI~~~ ,1.:U .a.!o.:loiiJI J~~4
- - lt
y~'il ~l$.,.t-a:s~
i4 .."o...c1i.i-t.tl a~\t~ ":'~~I u~Jl.u ~ ~.J JALaS ~~c1i.Ull ~!j.:a~I

.; 4i ,ullJ ~ I J ~WI :~_, y-o.!lo;iJI rl~)U [~~ a=i)\j w,li_,~'-4 .l..J.>.
c..:,Jl affective commitment ~WI rl..>=J'il ~ . (Meyer and Allen, 1997)
• :. .L.d ... ,.~(' ~ L .... "~1.-: ~ L .:.f-Wl~·tlJoLu I
f_j,&44~..J ~f""C""""'.J ~"tt:',~J -~ - '.r .!.)
Ju.JI ~ _;I~ 'i4 r1~'i4 _;~I ~1 normative commitment ~ I rl..>=J'il

~:;~I y~~I c..:,J! commitment continuous ~ I rl..>=J'il .J.!'~':!j .a 4Jo Co\t
• Ls:;_;.ll.u ~ ~.>=J.I ~\S ~I~~~ ~.,11 ~.u <:i'11
~ - - ~...,..or--.si."'IJ.C~~?_..~~......,.-,....._,.........,,~~A,,Q~~,N!,a·"""~~,:J)r>,.~-.,r:,g.7.,.."l,"~":11.l:?.lif~•~.o.u, "'1s.4.00.: ..._,.~:,;1::4llll
no lfj~ ~~ii~' LAJ ~~ fall :ul.J:a.al '?9 ->~IJ d.4.J~I
~l.,.Jl~I
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ · - : : : . • , , , · •:,:~---~~~-.-,·~::,~;.·,.z.rn:::~~~~~~~~-.z~~·::.,.,1··.d··.':·;J'·•::.·,;.:··,·~.:J.:.::~Gr:J
~Ll~4J~I ~~~~~.)~'"¥.>:!~I r'J=J~I c:,i ~ r~ ~ljic.!.Jl.i.A

. (Kwantes, 2003; Luchak and Gellatly, 2007; Meyer et al., 2002) ~_,JI
~~ a...o~ ~ I ~4--~J 'i'q.!t:,;;JI rlJ:&J~I ~ a:s>WI 0~ ':1 ~ ,l.!.U~~J
~ I r'J:&J~IJ ~WI rlJ:&J':11 c:,i c.:.il..ul.)..ul ~ J i ...la.l "'=7"q.!J;., iiTI rlJ:&J':11 tl~i
0:> ~ ,y~~, c.:.i~_,.L, l.!.U~ ~~~I c.:.i4,.~ ~ -~~1 -l~b 01..A~
.:...q~~~- ~ ~':Jl.Jo J.>. ~ ~c.:.i~~ •-~.•'I 1:~,~, ~
· At!.j
c.:.,6,..-.~ . <-rt .~ . ~ J - ~r'..J-""'
.(Luchak and Gallatky, 2007; Mathieu and Zajac 1990; Meyer et al., 2002)
c.!.J~I c.:.i~Ji 0i ~1 J~i 1.j.:UI (Cohen, 2003) <J:AF c.:.i4,.b.u...........u~I o~ .uS
~~J - ~ ' rlJ:&J':14 ~.)~ ~_;oi ~IJ~WI r'J:&J~l 0~'=7"q.!t;,;;JI
~ ab.! "'J JAi~ ~ I J ~WI rl.):tl':11 ~ ~ w~I , ~ I 0~ ~
• l.zu.ul.)J [~~
-
~~~LA~ ~ y~~I c.:.i~~J 'i'q.!t;.,;;11 rlJ:&J':11 ~ a:s~I w!
. ~Lu 4J ~I~ ~I social exchange theory~~ ~I JJ~I ~ JJ..;,b
l.!.U~.U.}t"
atJluo....\...i>,d.AJ·'-· Ll.uilA',j , .... -LJo.;J.. &.t!..: •• .:UI •.,!t!.a'l '1
·- -· ~~U--- '"&" ~~ u~0: ~ r u
0:.:UI w~..,ll ..1.,->: wi ~->-1,10-4 0~ I~ ~ J . ~ ~~?JI ~~4,b.jl oJ~
(Kickul , 2001) 1~ A:- L.J.,.,,J\
-· ~
-~l...Jo.j\
. · ... JJ~, ... L...A ~ ~~
l>-4,-o-- - - ~ u. •L u· ~ :.
ILLI~J ~-'4-..,.; "'.! ~i 0 ~ ~I ~l.i.11 ~ J ~ J)o J~?} 0 ~ ~J ;s
.(Turnley et al. 2004) l.!l:ai,114 ~l....A o~L.ul 0-4 ~ i 4:~ ~~
a.! q.! t:, ;;11 c.:.i)l;....u I J.>. i ~a.! q.!t:, ;;JI J)l;.. ~' 0~ ~ ~ ' o~ ~&'¥.,
o..i1u>1,I ~ ' d.!q.!t:,;;tt J)l;..~I ~ -w~I 41·.«.!7i««12~I ~~':JI JJ~
~ &lji ~ ~~ 0~..,.tl ~ ':J LA~J .(Schein, 1990) ~ I c.:.i~_,1.uJ
..u q .J;., jjJI t ':'..J-""'~1':JI.,..~~
~ 'i' -
- ~
. .. l.!.U~ U.}t"
. tJlu ·t_g - ~ L ' . ~ ~11 .... ~ti
·- ~ , ~ '"&" • <:r"" \-=-
&
_;> b.LJ ~l5 ~I~~ c.:.i~~J c.:.il.A4,.:il J1:.. ~1 J.,W.1 ~ 1.jJJ:! 1.j.:UIJ
.(Kwantes, 2003; Lo andAryee, 2003) ~ I ~.>lJ~I y~IJ ~I~
-)l;..',:11·
"'
'
U::'
~ - ~,,c.:.i~~,.
.1.)-J <:r""
-
~Uo........a..i,-
'?"" ~ -~
Ll' ;s~~ q,t:,;;JI
-
'i' -
\:~1':JI
f' '..J-""' CJ--='
'~H
.y~':11 c.:.i~.,.L,J ~J..ul a.!q.!t;,;;JI
i.:.,-,,_••,._:. -='---~".ID""..'\~ ,;1111;...,.'"'II-'-~ ~ .• ,,"h~-··-:w., __ .:.,r_.• .. 1 -~-·--.,;;.K""~j·....-,,·..>.~-·- _._,...o~:._...,__ •• ~•. ·,,••• ; . ~ , ' 1 ; . - ~ - ~ - - ' · ~ ~ .~""::C-..t·-:A~'6:- -.:...=--·~.-'I
~~A.id~ ti.J.ll lAJ ~~ faU : u ~ I ~ ~Lw.iJ!.9 4-4.J~I n''\

~ I ,e-: ,;. c, ,;. ·f. ·~. ~ ~: ~: t' ~ 1 {. {: ~·· l i [ J, :• f .[ ~ •C !··. ,.· ~
X ,C- -
J I l 1 ~ t- ~[• t .· t' ,C- c_ ~, £;:
~~ : •t '&: . - i l ~ .[ ~ '(, 't f w. ~
>'-' -<'-' ( 17\ Ii\ t' c_ ~- r l. ,.'" i.
(1 l~I I I
~c·:.ir 1,. vc··~.~e-·L r. c..f. l ~,c:• li>ip i> ~ ti( .:
'e-! {te-• • 1: 1I;. \a
·1;. C
~ 1· t' :1... [- _: ·re; ·t ~- te. L I ..: ~
~~ i
-P I~
r·.; r-f{- ~I I
~ t ~ :i t €. .. Ci ! .r; t,. - •~ Ii\
_r- ,Jc I~• I~: £ ~: ~ f I f I,\ ·. · (i.1
< E:: _,s> I - - •
.l:
r p~ • •(;
€
~• ~
f.>g,. .-+ [•
r=-
-
lt f' ~i
J;t.!c..·"~c r
• t., C ,:,.
t f 1 . ~• ('f[• sr ,. r-~
,. , : h , I - - I:! S ._ I('
~ t: s::: ~\ ~ r E:: I f') -;- ~ ~ '°. f -.• ( ~- q. ~ \ f i ~
G,, :.._ _, - \- t.
ca I
.f. \- ·~ f 'e: c· ~ ~ ;~ . . . p 'f
't be! ~ ~ t c. .~
fl ·t ~ f E I-~ ~ - • .~
l)
[. 1. 'E: .r CE P -C l ft l.
r [:7'
,, -
h -
~
· \>· ·Y t· ~ 'e.. ~
1 ,c t' . ~ - '\. - rr
C·
t>
!:;; _.
c, ~
S .
;~ :f.: :f' t [ l ~ _f 1: 't i 'l! \ : G,, ·t ~: ~ ;;; r ~- i. ·&; 1:; r.1. -c

I~ It r.., r;; 'J: - 1(;P
I - I :C • I., ~•
I;; 't t f; ~ ~. - f. Ir ¥ E l! ~ ~ ~ ~ , f
'f :[~
~ \». ~. t~ ·t. ,;. :f tC ·r.- • . .r i {;! ~. h ~, b .:{ ~
1Ftr tr ~.r
~ - £ _ ()t• LI J-
'J:.. .r C-; - ; • C·
~ ~ •LP L,
''I.,
~
- J ' l· - L'
; !:[ ? •
(i, I ~ tr J I> '"o S •I:°" r - ~. .t es.. i r p.· • rt
F: -r,_._~ y tC
1~ to
[· • ~ ~ t b
.. ~s. t. _,
l, t > £' "'[ k t ,-._ - .._, f:'' . t> C ~ \>· I
V\ c-
t F. f • a,• I I I -
.1. -:-
r ~ p..r ,C C)I
- - ~ I I ;
E · ~ 'F ~ .
f . ~ c.. 'F -{ f 1· t ~
r£' E. ·V •L - ~ 1> • t= • w. I
;. ~•
1
[, £ ~ to 1_ ~ v- ·F; ~ t
.- 'i;
tr- ~ ,I I
C•
r;; ~ p.t ' G.* .....
~ ,r.- tj C>I
,-:; r, .
,-:;x~ E. ,_._ . c- ~
rt·f1o r· . · <i~ •f"\. l ~ ~ 'EI ~ f'[~ 1~ ~
E ~ t ~ -,t E - t· - X C• f:. 1> ,f ~ t· L G., • ™~
,r;-
'b -f '~
.,s><.:, ~
-( C·
}> r._
C. I
- -
..-J
f; . < l> -
C
.,·
r ·f ~: '(, ~.
~- \.,.1 t·~-1.
~ ft'~. - .r
'f.i>
.
f·~ ;- r~· t ~
-~"
~.
t l(qt
- ~
1·-
'r. ~
..-JD\ I•
(1 -
be! -I:: W ,- , · t;· ,-:- ~. Hl1i
. 'f. 1> ,c - ~"~ -· ~ ,_._ - . ~. C .'
f.; t· t· - . f .~ f. i' .t' ..::J • - I , ~ I , I '1 - '~
'!'.: '!'.: -.,i I ~ ) ~- la '[ ,E:.'
~· • C C,• ,.
1 ]>f. t }. ff 1
r1 f !f f ti }.rt12kl ·r f
f i f r. tq :f'} lo ·f .':
p~
Ci_,. 5_ ~ ~
.~ ~ ;£'
~
'ti.· ~t _: l, _:. ~ b ~ ~
,~. ·;;-· ~L,,-. .;,1 ·.. ~-·@:,·.f·t r,..:-y;<.r;·,·\F·· ..:i .'f.""""". ·:::-~;=;··, .. ·:_._y Y{;'',' -:~/(" :' ('..-•!!.·::-:,. ;./7.i.\.",-,:",.,f-·:::.} •,, ,/:":_:=y h"' ,· .ry) ."'/.=~··:., ;.l""i'"·'.:.,.,...;) (:.:!"ii'···.-·'··~. I: :<..;:::.~, ····r·'t·:. ;··.-J.Mx§'.(' ··~· ·:)' ·. •. •::.,ffi:.t·-:·· I ··s·:...cr· ific,0~[",."" 'ff'/" ·A··(l,\1111
-~w..r~ u!>:!i; .it

~ ~ ' ~ r~'il r~ '->"~ ~ :Lateness J.,.4alt ~ rLl=ul~t r~
'->"..r?°' t.>9 ~ ~t _,t ~\:a.)~ ~I ~~~I al->-1,1 .l~ ~ .J.>.IJ
~JJ (Blau, 1994) J~~ I.J..-A~~ ~ .~UI -LAY-~~I ~ a ,o...JI
r'~'il r'~ ~ ~~ LoY-~~I o..1AJ~I LAt .(Niealetal., 1993) ~?TJ
~j.ll o~I ~ ~ I Jlj-, ,-L.L4 ,;.,; cr>pilot study~~ d.walJ.l ~ ~~ ~
-1:!~ ~,JJ Jhill LAt - ~ ' ~ r~'il r~ o,Alll ~ ~LUI LA~~~'
o~I "~ wt ~WI aL.,,IJ..ul Jl,lol •. : , r:'9 ~t .,t ~La.)~ r~'il r~
c.ill~ ':'""""
. _j\ ~
•
~ I a'"4.MI <),A
· .l~ '.='_j\
""" ~
- -I ~WI
- ·
0--4 a.J~- ~• LalA ~ t\
- 'J-'
·'->"JI..Ll.l
~~r~t ..)~~~IJIJ...-.u~ ~ :WorkabsenceJ,.4.aJt~~~,
~ ~u.o JS'~~~ ~L-11 a ,114:.J\ ~~'~~JS'~~'~
· z-,.-.q o~LuJ. a\.jl....:L....,,'il
(.):'~ • ~ · a~~L9
~~ - ~
-- -~ L l...i49 ~ •~
1. _.:.~.
~6•
. yl:!,ill fij:j ~
J)L;.. ~I y~ al.J-4 .l~ '?t (o~I ~J) Jlfi:JI ~ r ' ~ I '->"~I LAt
yl:!,ill Jlfi.:i wl.:t r'~ ..)~, l.!lllA . O.l~I r'~~' ..)~ ~ _µ, ~ OJfi.J.l.1 o~I
(o..)·~.:.t\
~ r'- . - o-..;--~
L~I .l.J.c.)1...Jl..c.iJI . ~ ...<--: Wu... ~J-l.u>'il 1...JW.U
• - ~ l.·- 4 t
'->"- ~ ,j-A
l:;~I 4~
~ <J:AY- ~1 f'Y- y~ wl aL.,,IJ..ul a~t ~ ·t?~I yl:!,ill
Jfi.J.l.l ·.,: crcJI ~µ, ~ ~ ~r'~~' ~J_,.bl o..1Ay~ ~ 4~
.(Blau, Tatum, and Ward-Cook, 2004; Gellaty, 1995; Sagie, 1998) y ~
. ll>Ull ~. .r-
'-':! ,.1,,. ·- 4(,f ~
u (j \:JI \.j~ ,... 1...JL.i.ll
. - J '.<-: lj ... ' ~
'J-- !.)-'>-
~J.A. ~ I
~ ~IJ ~ ~~'ii u'i.l~I J~ ~ yl:iJIJ ~)L;..~I a~~'il
YYA
~JI.A.I~ i1~ o~Y:iill J~~I ~1,-o ~ l.:'~~I Vo~t ~..,.J.a.UI 0.)~1
l·vs<<JfWv.YAAr· ·tAsf&· ·}&=---~-v-~K···.-h·<:-;''::.J · <, ~w-·-~~--+~--". · . ·~,x£:;-....!m}fr,-~ . . .·.ffl>:uL·r%%::·\.v+--:.~ -:v..w(-:~..Yt( X'···.,T: \··-::~. )?"':'·~·,:;._;---:.~>-> ..-.-fr:c .,. ·,t;);i- ··~~-····=-~a i'".f¥4f··tJ
;;~ J~I ~ l.!.U.JS' -(~_,.bll yl:iJI) J ~ I r~ Jl ~ J ~ ~IJ~I

~ ;;j1ci.JI o~ wl ~ ~I y~ ~ U_,j-'"4 ;;J~ J~l c..9..1.f:t ~~I ~~I
~..u wl ~jj J.,.a.a.ll 0A wi ~ J {..1>.IJ ~ ) ~I.J-""1 ~ ~IJ..ul ~I~
.(Johns, 1994) ;;j1ci.JI ~ J)l;.. ~~ _;5jJ ~ ;;J..1411 ~ I
ct.!i:i ~ ..l!J - ~ ~y:J ~I~ U"'~I I~~ : ~ I ~..,_J~

~.)JJ ~J ~ .(Walsh,Ashford and Hill, 1985) ~J .lJ~iJ o!JiJ 0A
~~IJ.l ~ U"'"=-4ll I~ LA~I wl.:illl (Roseenblatt and lnball, 1999) J~u
. ,°' . =a~ ~_,j_,J.I ~J.l ~1->-'-"til ~I~
J~l~.,kJl'4,AlAw~~l~~~l~I I~~ :~$\tttLal
.-.< .d u,""='4'°
.).,.,,-.:::- I - I. • -
U.A.J,: I I 11
' .... t
.,.\.4J •
Ll'-1
• ~
~ ~I I':! '~
• -•1 .• ~ f "!.,I ~t
I·' •ti ~ ~
r=4 LJoHut.&.I J L:,!2~
(Victor and Cullen, 1988) i ~ rv 0-Awfi.l.lJ~)l;..~I ~'il~fiJ t~
. (Rosenblatt and Peled, 2002) ~ J ~~.)JJ ~ I a.ill ~~ r~ i.j.LllJ
(~..,JI ~~IJ 4=!~..,.SI ~~ l.4.AJ) ~ o:!~ ~ 4~~ .l~I ·.·: «cr!J
~~'ii ~Llfi.ll J--:6.:i) factor analysis cr1-4w1 ~ I ~t~ht ~
~ I a.;. ,cr;lt (Varimax rotation ..L....A\..:al J--JJ...ullJ principal components
r=4 0~1-* ~ u'iJ':/1 ulii'ilJ ,J-A~ a:L..u ~ ~ ~J .~La.I.I c.>---A
((4=!~..,.SI» tliA (i) :~ JAl~I o~ .a-.lJ..ul ~~ J;9 WJ~I ~ ():!:ill! o:!~I
.l~l r=4 JslM ~J) d..uJ...U.I ~~t l9lS' uJ~ ~ I tl..UI ct,j~ ~~ ~ i.jlllJ
0,-A \o,AV ~ l.A~~J ·U"'~l~«~~'il~Jj.-.J.l>~«Ul~I»
~IJ~~'il ~wJ..1.4.1.JJ~'il tllA~J«~..,.Jl»tl..UI (y) . ~ I U:4'JI
,<1~1~1..r?-f'IJ ~~I» ~I.?. 0A JS' r=4 JsljAJ '?"'J) ~J..u.l ~IJl.;,lJ ~';/J
..l!J ·(o:!4'JI 0A , o, "\A~ ~J ~~I U"'~ «~WJl»J c1r~IJ u-.,jWl»J
c.)1 "\,Ao~~ LA~ t+,':/ ~ ) ~ i ~,~.-. '".!t>"°l.WI ~ wf ,·./;
. (~4'11 0A °' '"\'
u'-4.;_j-4 ~ -I ~ n w,A wfi.ll U"'~I ,~ ~ :d .!4.!Hti-tJla..JI..WI
.(Rosenblatt and Hijazi, 2004) ~J~J a~JJJ ~ ~..,J JSJ (Moorman, 1991)
~~~I ~wfi.ll J--:6.:i) factor analysis cr1-4w1 ~ I ~ ~
~>"°~a:;~ (Varimax rotation ..L....A\..:al ..>-J.J...ullJ principal components
<i'1'J (~l..r?-?/1 a.JLu.llJ ~_jj'JI a.JI~) a.! I 11/!)-II a.Jl..wl tl-.,jl ls.AA c.)J'il ~)UJI
oJ...Lwtlj,i ~~~?JI ct.!q.!Joiitl a.Jl...wl JJL....ui .~WI L.....ul.).ill lA.)~I ~
~ I ~ J ~ I JJ~J ~l»JI l . S ~ ~~ ~ ~ L.....u.)J.11 u4-,~ 0-4
ul.)li9 J ~ I ~.)J ~I..P."-?JI a.Jl...wl ~ ~ -(~\+JI 0-4 1.r · ,rr ~ )
~ ~ I ~ . ) ~ J o ~ ~J a ;.!;J ulA_,b ~ J ~ I u'-:}i ~ ~ I
·(~\+JI 0-4 rv, ·A~)~~~, ~ J L.)J.11 wJ_µ
~L.o..9~1 ~ <i'11 <.>"~I I.JA u ~ J ~ I ~ : ~ ~ I o~L.utf J:11

(Robinson and Bennett, 1995) ,-,.!;;.!.'J ~ j j , l ~L«..u ~~ 0-4 ~_,LuJI
~ ..l.c.J •(Vardi, 2001) ~J.)~J (Fimbel and Burstein, 1990) ~~.i>-:'J ~ J
~ I ul#_,kJI 0-4 oJ...Lw tlj,t ~ ~IJA l.SJ.A (.!.!;;J ~ ~ i ~ j i
J ~ l 0-4 ~ . , - ~ .)~ wJ~ Y~,
.,t w~l wJ~ ~ ' ~ r~~, r~
wlS' 1~1 ~ o.JJ~~I JI~~~ social desirability «~~I y~->1,1»~1
~..u wlS' 1~1 ~ ~lj...«, ~ ~J ~ I ul#.,L.«JI J ~ rs ssui",i ¥,yl ~..u
~~ ~ i ~ J .(Vardi, 2001) w-iy-)U ~ I ul#.,LuJI J ~ ¥,yl
.~..u a.J~ (+-«')J.A ~ ~ I ul#_,kJI ~ c.:,,.j\S' 1~1 lA w~
D:--Jl.., ~u ~~' LJ:--«-«'~1 ~ ~ ~ :'r4.zt;;;11 rt;..:J~'

affective commitment ~WI rt;-~~, J..9~ . (Meyer and Allen, 1997)
~J rlj:&J~I !Ai ·(+-1'.)IJ.A ~~~I~~.) y~i J~ ~ I u~~I
f'8-4j..\J <i'11 y4---u,~I ~ ~ I u u ~ I J J ~ normative commitment
·(+-«')J.A ~ ~~4
~~1J.,..A1~10-4~~r'.J;.i ,114~~ =~~,u~1

y ~ ~ I u l # ~ Ls~ ul~ l...s,ji ~->1,10--4 ~~I u ~ ~
t_,ll\S' a.!,o~I ul~I ".JA ~ .(Rosenblatt and Shirom, 2005, 2006)
o)..w ~.)~ ~1~4 L~ t t ~l , 0-4) ~-1l~1.., (~L«.-tlt = ,.., J4-->11 = ·)
~~lu~~a.!q.!loiitlul~l~J .~IJ~.)bl~~J(A,tA
.(yl:iJI., ~ , ~ r~~, r~ ~ ~) Ls:i~~.., a..u.)J.11 ~ 0-4 ~ -
,uU~t~
Ll.)..ul ~ ~ I l.S~ :Multi-level analysis u ~ I J...u:J.1 ~ I
~.)~J~I u ~ ~ I ~ J ~ I ~l ~~ ~l.JI ~J~I l.S~I J--ib
LJ-11.JI.Jl.1 ~c,~ q~t:,iitl J~~I ~IJ-4~L:'~~l l.)4~1 ~_,J:a.UI 4i~~J
mfil:~~m-l'm~wzm:-rn~irk~~~~P~\!farn~1:.i::$Ti-!i!·::.CQi;;z.~~r.::r.,~-,,.w:.1'l
~ I ~ ~ - ' .~.J..ul w~~i JL.p._, ~.J..ul I.Lt_;;~ Jl.p. ~llll

w~ .ll:L-Lll t~"il 6-4 (~_;I..L4 ~ ~ w~I ~ ) wwl&J ~.;+JI
~--:ttwlj:.I~ ..I ~
[r.r- "! •. L ~ . w ~ .-: .. L~lt Ll:g
~(.)'! ~
• wlb>ll.l~lS'a.J~I
..
wl~l~[~~l~~.li .ig-' .SASmixed-model~l~~)'I

~ [~~I w,1.c (a......i..u.J..ul) ~~I Jl.;..ll ~-' ~.l~I LG~I w,1.c ~lS' <?I
~ (Chan, 1998) wLlJ ~4.ll t 4 )'I [~J4l c4 &ljil4J . ~ I ~ ~b 4,jj
t4?/I LG~w,1.c (<.>"_;l..ul) ~~ ~WI lSJi "'~ ~~b .l_?.J~~
.( .ll~~I) wl..1;,,...,.U C,,:,.l~I
l~l l..a.J~I u-11 ('')mediation analysis ~_,JI J:-6::JI ~...l.f:! :~_,JI J:-6::JI
rl~"il~t:i~ ~.?. a.~.,:il.:,y~"il wl:!S'_,b_, a.! 4.!t;.. ;;JI J ~ ~I w:1-:1 U)WI ~lS'
~~I [.J..cJI ~Y! i:i.i ~~..)-411 "~.J~"i_, .~_,jAL.S'Y?q.!t;..;;JI
~LlJI wlj:.I..P.-?/1 _;&'l 6-4 ~-' (Kenny, Kashy and Bolger, 1998) J-4l-'-:'J ~lS'_,
.(MacKinnon, Lockwood, and Williams, 2004) ~_,JI ~tJI .J~"i
s~liat
[~~I w,1.c ~..J ~~I_, ~fil4 ~ ~~ [~J4l r1J;.; , ,,L ~ ~
wl~· .:.~,1 ~lS'JG...lL ... W ~~"ii • wl~0.AJ-:!:L'A~
... · ... l<'t . ~ I ~~ ~1 "ii
..
~
_(' _-: .~Li..1.1
• a..b.J~I
• wl · .:.~11
~ c..:r..
,, ~~I a
.. .. .. ,t;..;;}I ..
~
~~L• ~ I W>ll.1 IQ
~
~ I J-:!:L'A... ~l<'t
'?"
'fill '-:T~~
•. :ti [ ~-'.r--'
- :ti tl:i.JI j:. ':.~'I . ~ I •• _ •
'?" ~ I.: ~...)-LI-"" Yr" ~
-:q ~blll
~ I ~lj)'I wli;l~lJ stepwise regression ~...;..cJI .Jl~"il r1J;.; 11,4_,
. backward deletion procedures
~ ' ~ rlt:..:u"il r...L....C. ~..H :d.! o . 1 t t f i l l J $ ~ ! 9 ~ l ~ r ~ ~ , r~

.. ti ti
aJl...uJI J:~4 .,..._AJ a.!4.!t;..;;JI J~~I wl~jA 6-4~~ ~.?. l.bl+i.;I
rl~>Ll~t:i .l~-' 6-4 ~>11 w,1.c ~_,~'ti w,1.c .)µ1 ~ f-1-' .a .1q.:t;..;;t1
~ rlt:..:u"il r...L....C. ~ U)WI ~~_,:ill~_, ~I~ ~q.!t;.. jjJI ~WI
\ 6-4)~WI rl~)U ~ I w ~ I rl~I ~ .igJ ·c1..J_,:ill a..Jl...u:._,~I
~WI rt~::J"il LG~ wi (V-\) ~ ~\:J.JI w~i ~ J:-6::JI ~ ( o u-11
.l_?.J c4-' .a.::' ,.. ~lS' ~1 ~ .. r~"il r...u:.-' c1..Jjill a..Jl...u:. ~ U>Wlj ~.;-1.1
~
-l.?..J-!J .fi~ .l~ "i U)WI ~~I wlS' ~WI rlj:il"il 6-4 ~..GA w ~
:;.,-.~· ·\"o""J....-i,<;,:,•~:.<...;~'..-,l."""""~~,i..•."1-~':..=.·.·~-..~.~,.::;...,<,.•.•...-..-.;.. • ·-.,.•..,. .,,...,._.,,.,;.;.~ •. ~.:>¥"'"~ ·~~~~°"'" ,._..N>.r..·~-· .,-. .,.. . ...,.,...._? . . . . ; .,......:,.:..,-...-.,.>~., ,m ..._.J',/y.A...:,. .,.-.~·.r.,.,.,.,~._-.,,._-.,: ·.-.-;
.... .,.,,..•••
YY', ~ ~ A i d ~ 'i~I LAJ o~ faU :ul4,.t:,.lll ~ J~~ '-4J~I

, --) --=-=~.:=:---_-,.-,.-,~:-,-:_.:;(--_ -~-'.-~ ,.-- -/_-,,-s----L::)
a.JI~~ ~~1 L.JA.?. 49~ ~UA wlS' ~WI rlJ:J'il oA 0~ 1 5 ~

4~ ~~ .l.?.J Jb.. ~ ~ ,15 ..»-t DJ~ .~1 ~ r~'il r~J ~_j..,:JI
~ ~_j..,:JI a.JI~~ t.4-b.i'il ~ ~ u~ ~UA ~WI '=7"1.!t;.. ;;JI rlJ:il'il LJA
''-:? 1.!t;., ;;JI ~WI rlJ:J)U ~~ ~~ .:i.?.~J ·..»-tJl ~I ~J a...........i,J.J..tl
I.H:'Ll. 15..u ps-t ~~ ~UA] 4.djL.o ~a.a.,~~ U)WI olA c.:.-e: ,oi
a-,1J..ul ~ ~tu.JI olA ~...u .[ (Shapira-Lishchinsky, 2007) 0 «cei.!«~sc\:l
~ a.!1.!t;.,;;JI J~\J1J~1 ~ r ~ ' i l r~ ~ ~~ u~ .l.?.Jw~
.~w1 rlJ:J'il ~J".:i a.:UL..,,\11 15..u
'-:?'4-'""YI ~~\JI tlal wl ~ :4 .! o.zt:.,ii)tJ~~~J-o.alt ~~4,alt

J,A
.~
- '-' JA~ (~ .:.t-WI) rlj:J'il.J. .>J,.b.1.1J "-JWJl.J
. • .Jo..u->-1,1
. ~_,JI.
- .. :.~tt
~~\JI ~
"?""
,(Shapira-Lishchinsky and Rosenblatt, 2010 ~ ~~I oA .J.J_j.A ~ )
. u--
'--'I.<J'Z- "-JWJl.J~I
• - • ~
~\:u.Jl(V-Y) ~
I<.~. __ .:...I.~
U---0:
~,-ai,~~~u.:a,~\:i(v-,)~JjS::,
,.w.:u~t ,.~ ~ ~Lalt ,.t;.:a~~
t---~~~~~~~~~------------------- l~WI~~
- r ffi
r,o-+------------------------------~--~-----~~
0
c.>".JI-Lll~di,:o,:lo;;tlJ.$\'t~IJ-4~":'~~l~!J.&.l~~lo~~J
, · · ··- ---· ·· -~-.............<·-'-:·>>\:--~·'.·:-: ..;.::·.,.-~=·= .· .... ···.-:,ii·.'"·.~~-~--.-·. -~...:~~•. ·~ ~ -..;:;·-:it : ..:.:.:.:.-.=::~2:-:_.,.... ,. . -=~~·-'.-!)=.-.~---~·,.) ··-·;:, -:···-1····-'.··f·-:.- -·.::-~- · · - - · ·, . , .-.·:. - - -~·~7:'~...~w~~?I£7::t:fc.~·~~
*- .092 = \ [~.J4'
- .037 =(~WI rlJ:J"il r:4) r [~.J4'
*** 505 **- .115
~.;JI ~~~I · l.i.J.t ~

- - r -
.(GENMOD procedure ~ I [~_JA,l}I ;.1~1)

N = 1.016; * p < 0.05; ** p < 0.01; *** p < 0.001.
. Shapira-Lishchinsky and Rosenblatt (2010) :.J..L.&..::J.I
~ I ~_>3 ~LJ::I ~.?. ~~ ~UA :4.! o.zt;.;iflJ~\'t,J.4,JL)l~..,_J~

ct.J~. 'L L-'I ~~.. a...u ~~. ,ti\ .a:;)W1 a ,o ,t;,;;JI .. ~~1 ~, ...
.. 'J-'.V- .. c.r- .... "' ~~J
~j ~~ u~ ~ I J ~WI
r~~I ui ~ j (~..,JI ~~..,JI~)
~I?. ?JI d.Jl..wl:, ~I~_;;~ a__g~ ~J . ~)WI~~ -\> ~ i ~1
rl.µl~I ~ al>WI ~ ~?. ul.PJJ.I 0~_,Jl 0)LoWI wlS' (c'.Jyll a.JI~ ~J)
~J ~~I D;.L..u?J J:!.14 ~ I ~.;J ~ ~~ ~J .~l~?JI d..11..wlJ ~WI
.. - ..
·( - ."!ti ,-.~,~, .... t ) ~ 1-~ :.L.WI ,~~,~Li Ll· D :.L:c.A~)WI .,~ · l
~ f'.r' ~J .. ~~ ~ f'.r' ... u-:?'" ~ (.)
.(Shapira-Lishchinsky and Rosenblatt, 2009) ~I~>' .!'oaiJI iJ.A ...u.J-lJ)
.(V-Y') ~~~tu.JI.,~~ ~UAJ
~Lwlt~t
m:.=:--~£..:. :=::-~•l..s••;,~. . ,·~."i• !.•.•, o"'.•" :~~• ,.'• ~ - , ~.. ·,.~ •-y.-; . ~"•.'",.•'. 7~. 0 , :T•;._. •;'=.,•" "..& / "•'. O. ,·:.:.•'"/•' ,,.• ;::••: ";'";.••.•. 0 ·~~~-~~~-~~ ,r: • ,;~·,•.~;l.::J
~WI l_µl~I
- r
- .35 ***
.25 ***
t t t
.N = 1,016; * p < 0.05; ** p < 0.01; *** p < 0.001 ( ~ I ~t~?JI)

. (Shapira-Lishchinsky and Rosenblatt, 2009) :.)~I
~I m.:
..:.i ~
i ,f fh C· - tC /l-' lj
t ~· 1 t ·~.<i- ~~ ~~ &·~ l~ 1- ·~.f:: ~~~ ~~ f;~: ~[.: r"f .~r~ }. ~r ·t.l £ f~,c, f.·~. :f. ~
f ~.· !c <>•
'~. E. 1 1I 1~! t 't ,r t,• •L ,("; { b - [, c ~· ; , ~l.1'\.
I if.: l>-' - ~ - ~ lJ>• - tt} 1
I I:: ~
·~,.
.e• . I> ·~. • ~ [• ~ •L G>, '::ij I
.r r· t, f:: f. ~\\ ~-[• -(r - ~s { ~:
f. ~f 1 [ ft t> 1 l •L ~ •L ' ~ r; ~ ~.:'•:~.1
i r.,! L, c:.. h l"t
t-E Ir. t! ~- ~ ~ CI:. _' ~-V P ~ ~ ~ ~t> ,. ~.
.r:fil
j ; I ;; ;:- I>- ~ ~~ .~· I
~ ~ 'I,' !E, ·~. ~- <i- F L, .f ti.:i
r~ ~~ !: t.E! '~~, f i
f • ~· - r.,! ~ ''C.- I . L1- { • (> • - ,l
1 ti wf(I:: E.. l ,i::
f., '\ II r.-"' c~
'f\ I (>J .1~ ~· L,
_r • ' ~f i
~
~ ~ t •l: ~ r>
r- I [ ·f E t.• r ~~ ~[ - -~ "<. I I
t!
I·'' .,
..._ •
~
,:. ~ ~ - [ • I> • • '- • ~ "' - ~
~ t· ~ r ,t'p L- c t -Cf. ~:··: -
.Fi :E"' . .'.

l -i f, ~ Ii:-- :·f
I ~ 6--t,! o.! '.f},. Ci,, - rt, -,.
If •~~ ~ Fi- t c, -/ 'tt 'e,~• <.; Y r; 1. 'r... · lr;.. tr, ,
'E... J I, ~
tr. ;v,t'
11 ·u- i: tl ft.& ~.~· J- f I~ ~·l.; ~,·.{
·o.! ID ·C
.t1:i I ·L~ Ci.. t~ ~ ·~. frv ~·f
·~ ,E· ~ f ~ ·• r -~ ~ t ,r · 'r ·1. ..,.- ... ~ ~
~t ~t : ~f ~ 1.·.~.•
r-" C· . i 'El fl
tr; I~ f- ;:~ Yb! r~ it.~ I~ 1·· ~·E; ~.;E- 1:: Jt: f.~ L
~
& <i-· { ~ 1~: ~t , •(;l %: ~
:.1 [~
~ ~ [• r..! - t') P v .~ , · Hc
1
~ •• , , - ~ I
.i . . ' . t. ) 1 . E_- ,r-t: ~I:.!. '"'t t1-~· ;· ~.& I.D• r..!- t> Ii ,.
t ! i_. i. ·~. 1. l t f.
f . E1. / i ~ . . ·Ci.,. .• ~ r· ~ -; ~ c.. • 1;: ~1
~ 1 rt ~ oe ) I c· J; l. 1 ·fi.. t. f. .i J;" ·,,! h.~.:i,\.
~i t ~ I { •r.,! • I .~ ' •~ Jr• I> 'fu• J;; ,~r p r ~I '
'f. 'r ~ {·· ..,. ~ r c~ ~ t:~ ~ E
l;- i: -E ft ~ b m~
(1~ C r fi' i b '[' o,! [. C· ~- C• lo L] [;
t.. .:.~ le.~ -.:.1·'.·
I • I "'I • • I [ .._ • - L,• - ·-:< C.-
~ t" I r •
f>' •
.I I 1• • r, l,
~;•. t'
ht ll
'f .[ ·r.· f..~ r. ~; . · l ~~ r~· - i>E 'r::· -~,. ·~ t~ 1- ·~. tr· 1.f:: r·
,V\ ~ U<..,, • • ~ i..., .__
E('.
- r
~t }.c- ==L ~_: , . l " r •-
'fj.. ! _ ,. C• &", c,° ( • 'f 'C.. --;- . : tr 'f:. ~ ,~ ~ 'i : 't: E'E ~ ' I:. f;!
t 1. .}. ~- i.;·'~: r.r. h..

1
~, ~ [ r 1 ~ ~
[i t
r t r r g ~ g{
t\ ~ {! {
C tC -
Ii:--
~r ·~ I:.!.
~
l· '~-.~.(i { ' r ' t h~ ,[fl i
'i;; i ~· f' i . : 'b ~· ~ i ~-.: t ~ L
l
t ~
~.
t,
- ~". ~i ~ h t!
f...
.c•·
! I [=;
ff
t r..! G,. L 1£ ,c , c_ L,· r- ' - r..! •
·t c· r-;- ~
i i;E E.. ~ E..
1:, \.D - p - - - -
- t ~- - ~- - r.,! c:.. - - - V\ -~ ~ ~
r~l
~ Ci.-1 ~ ~
0 r:: ~ ~! r·
L, • .. ,e' vr:: c__ IA , ~ lp.-
£.r.~I ~f... .t·c-- ·~[· ~' ~ 1t· r. Nb·
E. $! _,. a l,'
t ,
.1:.· r> J:.! V\ ·L. &
rt[ ·[ ~ i"°~· ~.'
'c" 'c.. \ •t. ·~ - to .c- t' 1.o \ -
I .
E 1.· ,'f c,
r . . .
rt· ~ ~: r.
- f \ . 1 · • •~. a~ ,~ t!
1· ~. ~ ·~ .~· ~, 1_ ~ t f § }. fr. ~ r .c- ! ·
:~ I .I !.- i C· 1 V ~. 1 ,t: -: 'c.. &• f;. ( ;:- } .c c:l- • I ~· ~- I ~ B1~.. f: to i.l!. ~-k
·~~ !i :<~ t
~. .r -
.~~. f.~ r~ f~ (t t
t t [ \- l· fie- 1 fvt: :f i i t} 1: n-~ c__ i...
t• I O !:: I :• .._, • (s>I • - 0 (1 "' i f) •
~ ! G.. I:: ;. . t.~, - .v- ~- ~ ~· ~ ~ ~ g - ~ . E e ft· ·t ~ ~• ~
[ji, 'i,. -~. §:
f- G°
·[ C: - 0 (i \0 C 1> C
I~ l,• ~ ·~ C'r· rt ~t: £ '<i..If E ~- f r1:E :'.. ~L ·f; ~·- .f. ~· l. - ,r.t> b ~~
~ j ~ ~ f; ~ ~ EI) - Ci_ "iw! II) ,C- \0 - J t..! f. ' t..! 1... • Y·
t l, ~ f
trt· .v :E· ~
1:: 1 E ~ ~ r ~ l ~ [• r;- •t: . ..;- ~- 1 c- -c !-!' 'Ii,.. ~ ·~ .:: .t' '&' h ~-c r;
.. j ~ .V\ ·E, ~ ~ G. - 1' \0
l '[ ~ L .c f" - ·~ ·~ C· - ·V :v C· ,f C·
'i:,
t t \ ~ {. ~ 'b ~ - ~ f [ r:. ~ t J t r. i i f
-c, h ./:!
EI..:! l~ i,i: ·f-~·.ct ~~. ·t·-~ 1~ E}.
•C
"b• ij ~ -/:! • • • !,.o
• 'c... C· i• - b . . ' . t "'(/) - I [ I -
t! I:•· C· £
_,. a> v~
i ~ 1
:f ~ t·<t-. j, •il f: ~ i c- 1= rs·~.f' ~: ·f' ~ ~
Ci_ E c $c:
I '[ E•. [• I:! /:! t..! - L. e• /
r~ ~ l , ~ 1; ...: ~ ·1 l ·(; · -: r.°t -: ,._ <i-E. r- ~rs i-· f. t - ~~ r l yI:! e-· ·,.'.·
1
i.:i 1:: ·• 1:. -;-
J 'l.. a> ·- .~
$~ , ·G. ·f·.,. · ~ F~·~ _: - ~ ~ t ·ic.~ Ci·h -i ~- ~ t-; ~ ·r ~~ ~~ £ -r. t i- '.; ' ,[ E: r. b II) -· ,[ G" c.. .._, ft t-f
G" . I;. ·~ ·G_1' ,[ ~. 1·~·:'.:·
I • • _,. '
~ I I - - I • -· ' ~ I • q ,C- .
·~ ~ ~ . c- .E J. fi ~,. - ~. . ~ ~E. ~ t· ~ ;. ·i:: ·~. .~ .( ~ t l R~ r· .:
"~ L
ra- rl,' ~· $·
r. .,.
~· r. ~ ~ "iw! Lt.
L, • C· - ..C·
~ ' ~· C· ~ ~ Ci- r;. ~·
h • L•
r:.. • .'•.·.·:.
~ 'L
:=:. [. ~· ~ ~ t) ~ ~· I ~ I t. ~ ' ~ ~
''f. _,P ' ~E. ~- ,t' 't _[ l~ ~ -Ee- E ~. E.. 1~ ~- 'g ( -:-
1 ·~ ,t: .~ c r. ~ f { t r.· t -c ... f' E 2- ,r f . . 1 ~ c- .f,' ·Y £ ·.: '~·. e! - _;
[c, 1··=.::i·. {t
Ii 1 f:! 1> V· ~ _,. ~ o '[ ,L ~ C C ~
.f . -
1
r ·~ c- } t:f. _,. ·1.. t r· tt r: t l l· :-f 11 ¥ 1
1 • •
:1
~~ -:
... ~~ __ .__ ~ ~, v- .E .c _ ,~. ·~- , ,C-
.c \ · 1::; 0
-- _ , -: _ -t t- C·_,,
~:.. 1::: I, _. 1
V"Jl..ill ~ Ct.: 4.!t;,CC!I J~~I ~l_ya ~ '":'~~I u,a~l ~~I o.)~1
~~.~~~~;.-~~~~1Pr~~w-~:1E~~-2 ..~;:s~!i~;s12;:~-~~~~~~~~?raa~~.:~::0~7~.7-iu~
~ ru ci'11 y ~ ~ I ~l~i ~ ~l_,JI ull~I .l.?.J o-4 ~_;JI~

~ I ~bill ~JJI ~ I ~ i ~tull ~ c l ! ~ ~ ~J ,L..i.lJJJI o~ ~
·)L;.\JI LJ::IJ
<J · L~ ..
'-8-'::1
~u.>\..£ll
-
- luA~.l~J d...&.ulJ .J.1Ja:;~1a.1,1..,.-Jl~l·~'L
L9-'-" -- . .:,-:w •
~J o-4 J)lb?/1 ~ ~~I cl_,k, '5jgi ~ I cl.;J ~ c,.jlS' ..Lal .a.!q.!t;.,;;JI
:4:!.§:i;ll ul~j.A a:;~I) a.!q.!t;.,;;tt J)L;.~4 ~ ~J...l!~Y~J ~I~
o-4 JS' l.4>~ ~ {Wl~I o~L.u?J j:11,~l.?.-?/I a.Jl..u.JI ,~)L;.~I ~~.;JI tLlA
~tJI ojg ~ L>-4 ILU~ 0 ~.J.ll c l ~ I LAi . ~ I rlj:i.J~IJ ~WI rlj:i.J~I
rlj:J~I ~I.?. 0--A ..l>-IJ ~4- J)L;. o-4 ~.;JI tlll4 ~..>: JAJ y~I ~
~I~ r~~I r~~~tJI ojg ~ o-41.!l_jL.u~iJ ·(~WI) y;q.!t;.,;;JI
~WI rlj:J~I Jt=, ~ ~-j~I a.JI~ ~J ..l>,IJ ~)l;..i r~ ~ ~) ~jJIJ
U~ ui _;L&,1oh, [_;...Gll [~~ ~JJI ~ ~tull o~ r..J..aJ ~ · ~ J j.A~
cl_,L, ~ LA~ ojg_J6'i ufi:J ~ ~ a.!q.!t;.,;;JI J)l;..~4 y~~, u~_,L,
.ojg_J6'i y~~I
t~-:t~l o ~ ~~
rJ'"""' • ,,..jjl ,,.-.-:
~~'-'~~
... q · i ·At~., i:.l:u.JI ~~ ~',j a.ill.J.l ~L;ol..
~LA~~~ a.!q.!J;,;;JI J)L;.~'IJ y ~ ~ I ul$_jL.u~ <L9~1 y;q.!t;.,;;tl
o~(~l~rl.J;..:u~lr~~i)ojg~~lcl~I LAi .ojg_J6'iy~~lcl_,L,
rlj:JI ~JJ ~jJI ~ I JL> ~ ~ cil~J) ~ i ~J...l! Y!"q.!t;.,;;tl rl.j-:&J~I
~
~ (~I cl.;J ~ ~I) <:r.'~I cl_,L.u lSjgi ui ~,~~_,JI~ .~~

rlj:J~IJ ~WI rlj:J~I 0--A JS'~) Y! q.!t;., ;;JI rlj:J~I ~_;.b ~ ~ ~J...l!
J:!IJ ~l.?.-?JI a.Jl..u.JI ~J ~)l;..i 0-J~j.AJ jA...11 cl.;J ~ ~ <L9~1 ~ I
.(~~.;JI t4 U)WI ~WI rlJ:J~I ~ . J - Wl~I o~L.u?I
,~.;-I.I ~ I y ~ o-4 4~ ...l,ij ul.;.! «uaiJI o.JA ui ~ ~.J.ll ~_,JI~
a:;~I y ~ ~ I u~~ ~IJJI ~~I J ~ ~~I o-4 ..1-J_j..l._,.c...w ~
4-41>"° _;6'i ~ J..>.--b r'J;.j ,,.4 ~~ ~J .a.!q.!t:,;;11 J)l;.~1 J.,LAA ~
~ ·~~~, ~~ '5.?~I a.!q.!J;,ijJI ul~~I J.,lo.A [_;J:J.I [~~I ~
·.·.!:::=i "'.! 0i ~.;-I.I o-4 0i spillover model ~WI [~~I ~~ ,Jlitl ~
l.!l_,L, o-4 ~...l! y ~ ~ I ul,fi_jL.u o-4 ac.~ ~L&.&JI j.Al~I ~ .ll~~I
~w o--4 .(Beehr and Gupta, 1978; Koslowsky et all., 1997) ~ ..1-...>IJ
n.r-~ ....- ; . : . - ~ . . . - - - , , _ ~ . _... --..,._..,.~,r. .-.J!',.,_ . .-.,v...... ,,::_ •.,.,,,-,._,_•. -- ~,~oVJQ..-...--.~--.;,?"',~~.,::.:~i Vt~~'\"':"X=_.,.-'f"":'~, :",,!;...I" ._._,.._...._~-7.•. ...__.._._..#, ..-.r..,:,.-•,1,-,.,p.·~\.·....-,,,r,l',-,V~·.,.-..--,c.:,._,·~~
YY'V ~~ 4.1.aS ~ '?~I l.4..9 o~ faU : u ~ I ~ .)l-.al!.9 44.1~1

~ ~ c· c·. } C• C• E.• { i [' ~ 1> fl
' 'P
£. ~~ I ,-:-"" I[ l,•
-
f:!h. G...
~- I ,._
_:, ~ tl
I ' I ' f ·~ C t. C- l;j'
t ii ,. l 1C -
E: . · f::"' ·i f · .~1 rtt
l - • - - I
.F \!:a - - f.
,t ' I lp ..-, I • -
'v ·.·1
t
t f5.:~-p
'l:s· p.• 1> f) [, l, ,._
·~ I· .,i ~:
:l \. f ~ t \. ~ G., ·t t
rr<r [·~1:.
~ 'l!- ;.,,_ f ·tv !!:!hr.
c_ 1'~ ,. - I - I~ I:! -
0
~ ::r J.. ~· I
.I i . ·~
~- C·- ~I c; ·1 ~ - ·~ t .r ;· · IJ
'" I • .l> \) • - E; ~ 1• ~ I _....[•
I I ,. _ _ _
<i.. [~ ~ ~
tL~ 1• . [;;-V~t ·1
~i ·~· i 1 ~ r &-c ";' t 's - J ~'Y (,'f ~ •
l,• l, l,
('i• \-
• 'Ii>· .t•· rt 1 l::. ~· (") .:
- ~ ~" 1. t' l;- i ·.!
.rc·· 1i ~t: -~ ~. ,c-- 1£.G. a"' ,Lt>· I : It'r E ~ !::t·
f; ·~ ~ "·.~•
l,'
(,'f ,,_ J·.
: J:rt 'el- <i.. ~g 1:·:•.
I ~ l~j• • I •
- t { ~ f> '
t ; I:. [, Ci f c~,. en~ r-~ •t.~ rt- "',t"• ~.C· •[;- t' ~; ~ '\ I;t' ~ ~~\\ f
;- G.. C· (
~· ~· t> - • ~
- 'l
I ~ ~• C)I C) I O .!
~. c: r . 'Ii>~· 4-;:~ _,,
~ - t,
t .;
N - ' ~· _,. l, ~· ~ .-. 1
~[• lI r. <e
,._ ~. ~ F f~ ~ E4i..f>"" '.-~ [•r
e • [." _,. .'v • I r;; I> I·
1>. i: [. \ ~· 1
t ., Otp
·; •~: I ft - I • 1!1 -
E ~ 8 f r £. r:
I~
,r; C
£ ~-•.f.
~ [, Cr • '-5 L. • er .•·.·.l
-1 ~ ri •~ U) :f C "
1
f t '? d. C.• - ~· I:. C f>"" • c, ~s;. I • J.· . .
' ts.. ! ~ ,
r;; }r_ - [ t ~ [ (i ~ C_,. J).S l .r, j bl; t ~ I !I
·f ·t-~ 'f ~
I, ~ ~ ~I' [1 ~. 11• ~ 1' "1 p ~ ~ ~ I G-. ·~ - E r;;
1• l,
h ~I:. ·~~ f. I 11
[ 1· ~· _,, I_:•, ....: - • I~ I• • ·.•.·.·.,
~ L ~. ~· f. ~ ~ ~ ·t ~,, t El r "'" [. ~
, i_. F\. ,. t fil Ci
t.:. -
- - '>S
11
~1' I f:.,
~£,'~ ,r:s-. : -;IA GFi"' c_f. Ne:..• l:~-C· • 1 ~J:.-
~e ~ r- 1_ c.· o ,r' - - <;:- ~ ., Ci b' Cll - Pi '
i; !:= ,._ i= ~ f:. l,• 1.:.··.··.1!
\(_- t~ t~-~·tl·~}. : .[~• t' f- i{~;' } zg-· [_: t~ ;
·~ ! c;, ·~ •I;., ~ • ~ ~ s ~ ,t: 1 ~ ~ r. 1- [ 0. ::, !,
g l;- ~ ~ - .t £ t I '< § t,!
o. - :- r,
r...
t: ::.· 0
i !>f ~ ~ l ff.:E, l t l 'f 'f t t f ~. r ~ •f~. ·~r .ge.c l • t ~. [1 ~ ~ 0
(.~ [1 ::t. Q.
C (
I 1i: ii: [
f i ~ f ~\- {b ~~ ~• .r:.~.~ \ t. i: ~ ~ } ~;
Cr
{,c .r~ tlr ~[ V'~~ :t~ tt
. i., 1.- '[:! .b.
r 1.. • · t • '· ~~ t rr· <i'g : i-r· rL~~ 'l .rt-1. ! i
I E:~b ~~ _:. ~ ,C'" ~• .._, - - t _
~1 ~\-l.'~ 1: !l (ti~ ~tf ~it 1i{
OMJl~I ~ft.: 4.!t;.illl J~\tt ~l_j-4 ~ ~l..:,,,..wj~l u-o!J.cl ~~I D~~J
rr~:&~~~~E~~H'l°·tt-·-,dk:~~-.$.::2::::.~1=t1z.;~~~-:~;~:.R~.z:1:~~!!~£2mrnrsr;;:~;~~::..~~~:E:~~:;;r~~~1;:rn
~~ ~ self-reported study ~l.:.UI .i~?/1 ~ ~ I L.....ul.J...ul <>"~ 01

al.i~'l'L
. . . ~-1.:.u1 .J...r-~ ,... o ~ I ~~tu.JI _J-J;.tu~~ .cul~ ~
1.__°"'l'I ~ .. --~ti .) ~
~ . ~ ~b..i.ll « ~ » ~~ lAA social desirability "<-:,d.~.. '11 y~_,J.I»
ofil.:.UI ~ ~ o...u1., ~l..\.,~.u~ J~ ? J I"~ ~ "~~ - "1µ ~ll.4> 0i
~~~I~ (Blau et al. 2005; Nicholson and Payne, 1987) ~ I ~ I J
a.:\:ai111ll al-u.l.J...ul ~ 0~ ~jJ ~ .y~I., ~I~ r'Uo:u'l'I r'~ ~
~l.i.A..9 -~1.:.UI.Jl.;-!?}1~ ~'5?~1 ~~I ~-ui ~~'11 y~_,J.1 <>"~
~~\:Jl<>".Jl..1..ll~~l~~I~ .~tu.JI~ .!4''!~p-,i~
a 11,/u,JI ~tr, 0ic- •.,1~..9 .LI.J..ill ~.Jt.;.JI J~I ~_;~ ~ l~..9~1>'-"!
y~'l'I w ~ ~ J ~.J...u.1 J~ ~4 ~ I ~I aL.c.ul.J...ul c4 W1l_iL.o '5..»
(Ingersoll, 2001, 2004; Rosenblatt and Peled, 2002; Koslowsky, 2000)
~J J:PI.J--1 ~ '5?i a~~~ 0i ~j:J y abi11<J-40§.: ~ ~ J
a_~_,..1:tll ~ 4 U)WI al~ ~l::i.lll d........,.ul.J.l ~ 0~ ~jJ ~ J.J-:!>i . \A~
a.:1.,;, ..,11 aL.ul.J...ul ~ a.o1J-LA:1 a.:Q.:t:,;;JI J~~1., y~'l'I a~~ all)WJ
~1_,,.d 0-4 ..)~ al~ ~~_,JI ~<>".J...G~I ~b>?JI ~Lal r'l...t?:i «ul..9
. ~ a.:Q.:t:,;;JI a4,.~4 y~'l'I
, . ~ ~ ~ " ' - · " " . , . , , , , _ . . , ......._...__...,....--.:,_.,_-....w·.-~.-;;,,<lf:.;1~----..v:~~~,r;...,,.,."(-,,.'. '!;lllr~'l,!.4"~·~-.-~>~CC~4oC-~
Yr~ ~~ 4.1.d ~ c.fJ.ll lAJ c.:,~ faU : i : i ~ I ~ ~~!J 4J~I

i~_;1..tt u~~
~ a.... t.oA ":..LI cJA ~~stakeholders«~~\ y6:..w,l» f".J4-"-4 J--lb: (')
.Jlll\ ~ ~ ~~, ~t l.!l~ ~4
0-4 ~ ~~ ~ Lua\J..u\ ~~pilot study~~\ 4-'-'1\J..u\ f"J-4l ('1')

~1_~1 a..o~~I.G""-4 ~~ ~~J..>-#l ~~ 184.!oiJ;e"-'""\J..u\ ~
.~t Jl.b:,~
W::> ~ \ U~\ pt; 15..J-A J~\ JA effect mediation ~_,l\ ~t; ~ ('f')
:~\ .cJ\:ijA~~JU:'\:;~
MacKinnon, D. P. (2008). Introduction to Statistical Mediation
Analysis. New York, NY.
lll'A,t".c#'",;-•:._-~~ 1,.~,.c,1;:,._,,.,,,. _ _.;,_~---,,n,,"'l;:'.-•e..11....,_,_.._T"..-....::i.·.:-~~~~-~----::~•....-...:C~----.-,~---~---'S.~~--= •;ii:
l.fj~ 4..1.as ~ 1$.:.Lll Lo.9 ~...L>al fa\l : u ~ I ~ ~L.w.i&llj '4..a~I Yt •

~UJ't~t
c,~ ..'-4aJ~LS~t uW~t->.t ,,, a;
Alison L. Antesj.!;;1.J ~ i s~t~J
Michael D.Mumford ~.JJ,44.9-4·~~LA
<>4->:P"'~I ~~I J)l;. ~I~ ..:1~1., J~'il uo ,as o.;-:JJ u~ljJ

~ I 0-4 JJ~I ...L-...4.JI J)l;. l&.Jb. ~ ~ . ; ~ o.;-:JJ u ~ I J ,~UI ~ I
~:1ol Jl_, \ . j ~ ~ ~ l u W ~ u j ~ l ,I.JJ -0-l~IJlpWI
bJ>.J~~I JA uLoµt_, u\S'~I ..:1W 0i ~ .uLli~l 0-4 ...1:..wl k~-"4
~ I u l ~ I ~ .~I~~ J.la.U o~ ~~I uW\1d.l ~ ~ J
~ ~4J ~ 0J-W: ~.JJI ..:11~~1 <.Si ,~..:1\S'~I uW~ cJ\.j ,~UI
-
~~I o.;~I u'1WI 0-4 -:1...u:.
' -
JlJ . I~ Lo~I ,~WI ~ I .J.Al£A w.t - -
~~I~ ,~lj:al f'~~I d..Jj ~l.;J l~\S' 0:.JJI ~L.J.aJIJ ~..:1~}U ~ I
~-'"4-"JJ ~1J-A ~..w_., ~~I l:!)fi 0-4 ~4 ~ u~WI ~ ~...\>.1 ~J •-~~
~ J ~~I ~~ ti ,";;, .,I y_;l.~.:; 0-4 ~tuJJ uLll::, Hwang Woo-Suk
a:;,.:1Wl D.JA~~ ~ .(Cyranoski, 2006) a ~a\•JI u~1 ~ i ~ ~tu
.o~ · ·-~ a..JLA;
.. C.tLA oi_; ~ '-r· b.. ~\S'J a..u:..:.wt
.. . L)l;JI
- Jb . '-r· ~
~:. ·ti f' ..i.a:JI
~tu~ Eric Poehlman ul.JA-":' ~Y-1 ~...r4~1 ~4ll ok,i '~?i a.Jb. ~ J
~J-tA4 ul.A_,b ~ ; ~ '-'""'-:!,JI <Y-" ~ ~ L...ui..iJ1 ~...u uLl-"4_;.&JI J I ~ ~ ~~
a1010;...11 ~)LI.I--':~ ~1 a.JWI ".JA u..:1i Jl_, .(Daltoon, 2005) 4IS'
' - fl
~~)LI
~ JoJo;.. ~ ~~1 ul..o_,b ..:1IY-l ~ rl.J:. o...u. uWA-":' ~ ~ ,-·:: • .;.,
• d.:-:1 L:...:i~ I d..A~ d...4...\.4.4
lfjl J~ ,~..:1\S'~I uLil'1d.4 ~ I ul.;~ '11 ".JA ~I~ 0A ~ Lo J~J

J~\S' o ~ I u\S'~~I ulY-.J.4j 0l 0A ~_;JI~ - ~ 0A ~ ~ ~
~
· - ~ ~t ~1,(~l..cJ£lt (>A
· 1.r c.:rt11., ~
• L- ~--) ~
.. ...u., ~ , ~l.:ill1 ~\S'
- .. • ~
~)L;..~1~W10.A~~~~1~~10i~,W~f'I.J:.~
. (Fanelli, 2009; Marshall, 2000; Resnik, 2003; Steneck, 2007) ~l..tc:i.,_,I ~
<....a.Jj.4.U o.;L..c!.f'I o.;.,.b>, ~~I uW'1d.1 [~W ~~I~ Jl:J.I ~ ~
t .o.L:,..:i ~ -*
l.J-M1 • ~
• 4..4J~· L · a..wwt
.. · . ~1 J~f cl.A>.1
IY..? . lj-AJ a........-u~
• -*. 4..4J~
·L ·
r~'t~'--·~ -.,.,.......,,_..o.•..,_..v,w.,-.,;,N,..~-A,1;,••.w.._,,_,~_.~<(¥.H~~.~--;,,,,,r~w_;.r,v."' ,..,,...:,,.~.""'~-.-.. '",~Y"'~-.-~,,._,...,...,~...,...,.~,-~~'!'~
Ytr ~~~~Ii~' LoJ !!I~ fall :ul.J:.ltt ~ ~LWMillJ 4-w~t

£.1.: ·~. \. ~ t •.:.·.1.;
1·· 1 ~ ~ t~
t.
Fs fil ~ ~ .... f::
i- ~v I>c, 'l~· lJ ·iE rl rE Ec·. ~v Ec·. '} .c·~ i- ~f i.... ,~.
l r11.• c, ~ ., ~-
·~i ,,e 1·.::·:•:::•.
, i h ,~ • C- L L ' :.,
I
1·• [ t :[J ~. ·[ 1· '.V\,._ . _, 1;' -;-
• C·
b E-.. C)S ... ~ , • \
i, [~ f [ 1.-E" [ [E' ·1· '"~ fJ ~f ,~- ~ c' l.
t.c! c:.. ,. [, N ,L ~ , ~ "
1
.l I.. 1~· .f" ·d: ,L !:·,··(·.,:·
1:-; :i ;~
~ 'f: I:: C)S C· • L• ,c; I -- - 0 .,... I::
-
~ ·\. t t :[V\ _f-;9 cr-
t
I - t.C •
I -~ E
~ c:.. I°)
d' ~ f-Eli7 ['~. l• § ~ f·t: re.;e-• ~-::s .f. I C· C !,
c· - I • • ti i;; t:·.
r- ~~
'D i
. . ·~
, I I:: I
e:: c,
f C" . I:.
f' 1 t,t - f C·
f ~•L .t··r
1. . c· - i' .
- N lr=- c... B ~ ~ ..
>::s ~. I • f!i
1
f; l C• ' '. !i. 'j, :.•:. ·.:.
['j. ~- [ 1(; 1-1 ~- 1r. r,J
l:,.
~~
,~.
,t ~
~
,f if '<t:i.. ~ h -
t.c!"' V
~ ~f 6· I
•
I
I::
- I
!I:
'.E! - 1-p
'bl- 'l~
!$II V\
~~
~::s .ft. f ~J.~ ~~ ~' •(j_'I::. u7~ [ ~ •t 11
-1 ,. . ~ .~ ~· (D 0
... 6 t ~ 0 - .'i
J:; f. ~ - ' ~ I I:: h J.C I '" (_ -" r,J - ~ ::S • ,;I
t... ~ .c- > 1 r b ("('_f ._ I~. (1 ~. r.,.:·:·1.
i - C)J ' r1$1• ,. o

w t ::s
0.. • ,L
V\ - ~ -~ ;.i:~
~ [,E 1~ ~c. &-. '°r: [Ei" ~r • i~: c..._:_ ~~· '°~ t' '1 ~' i' t! ~ ~b- §o. \::::;-
• • I t.,!• • O .,. IJ>• , • ·1
d.~' -
~ 'I:.. ... " - ,.,_
;;! t,C ...: ·.•·.'..·.1·
'\ H C· [ S- V\ o ,r' -
1
t-, t [ . . t 'i.~ ft ~ f1- 1~ i.l g- ·l~ c-_,. .r-_,. t tf. r· ·., ~r-· c: ..~ t (l,· 1'° ~~ 'r.,_,.
I°) : • t.C ~I ~· ' '•. -•.•.l
[ 1 i. !!' j1
.,· i ~·1· F · "s..· ~--;- 1-.- c·!.. Ci:-E.. : c- 1~· V\,.~ b l=t ·i~ 'Crb <£~. ·[ -c~ ?§ e..c· t ~. . ~ · t=ti ~. '°f;,
\ ; :., ~ ~- -. ·:.::·····•j
g [• (',
L - - C· ,(; • - S- ... 1-. VI I.J
~ ~ 1. . t- l i; ~ C, ~ 1
5- r.-'r-'r.~ 8 ·r·
~ ~ . V\ L' • "r. -- - 1 1c; ~ c: ~ - ::i 1 1 r> ··,1
.;.!£ ·1! l:~ ~r. :t~ 1 ·~i f~·. ~~· ~<E
; J.C j 'f\ & C... ~, I:! , I °t, 1 lo I • l.. "'
1l !( , £. r ~v S' i· ~·~. -~. i _.
1
-1 (.f. r- c· 1I, i;d ·. E .c,f- c, ·~'. t l - \- ~ r § ·._ p [~· ~·l-- - t ~ f·,:··.:. •.
1
l
;1 : ·:.
-b. ~ . \D ~ & ~ E:: ~ ,._ ~ c. o ~
I ·~. }· ~. ·~ . ~ ·~. P' fr= ~ ·i ~ ,f, f. 't- ~ 1 li--" r,~: r;.~ f tv ~ t~ ·ie' f:; \- re; 'tv
0
r .:'··.:i .
I [; • li7 t· ~·· C· 1-n \

II .c-~ 1 ·~~ t ~ l. f5 1- ~.·t> f• ~ t· ic'. ~c ~t . .,L~· f.f' ~r lf' wr {_~ ~-.~ -(• c·.~ '&~ ~ Jr C
I [, Cb ' t, ~· E: ~ l:' .~ , ~, ..c ~ J,. c;· t ~· f; . ;.:1 g
1 \D r. . s..· l- , I~ J.- ij- , -•.'.1.
=~:e _~·. ~r-· ~ . . f_,. ~
V C)f isl' :;:1
·ft;, ~• ~ & L ,, - ~ 1 -. ~ ('!I_ ~
~t> c_ e: b. ~~ ls>•
_,. -..c
:: I ·lj.. Ei E E·lj.. ~t '1, [ [ ·lj.. 1, l !2- E ~ r. ~ f '.L [ ; ~ £ ~- ~ t ;t
.. • - (;I c_ e-1 l, r I c_ G" c_ ~ (; ~ ~~ Ci- 1··.
: i~ r ~ ~ t ~c· :f! ~ L, I .1: . f;"'" E C C C I , ;' :te-r
1
1 1
r
! ~.
O t:1
j;) I)'
,._ l, 1f!
l, l, • C - f[I t L
f~ - li>
,,-... t>° V\
lJ>; [ \D
1C \D
,I: - I • li>
.. •
"DC.. - 1·c IV\
~
f ~.. tf .u e.. l :. ·r:- 1 J:. 1 1 f 1t- :. f E..
c6' ~ C)I • ri\ ~ ~ C)I ~ ~ ·~. ,r .r 1 1 ~ _,. _ • 1 ~.. ;- - :< ~·
1
le.. e. ~= :r ·· ~J f. ttC
.r'f,l.. £' le' ft f 1 f ~ ) c;,.- Cj; h
, o ..... r. . I f> t 1 l, ~ 1E ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ rl b,
! ~ ~ l ~r i 1
~ ~ i- .~ . z. ¥- ~ h ·~ ·~ . l,· ! I ._ [· ~· ~ f> .~
6:.1.
1
1s ,... .. _1 i ~ ~ ~ •
- .~-:r~ f.. ~ - c e>1 ~ c_ 1 t .r r :J
I le.. NI
1· _,. ~I I ·V c_ l, - , ·E1 ·. . 17\ I C· I • I :t: ~· • fi I
r.' j,·'·_.
£. !
r;-_
@l . . l
f . . ._ ~ ._
~.
-~ '-
-c; t ~ r "'. t :£
l '- J r - "' q.
r E [ l
!t•
1
·. i;- "f.
£t f
E E;
't. ·E ~-
c, f,. !e 't: [• I"'
!e·
c.. tl C· I
l
Ci;. 1.i
00 l, t· r.: !t l,
ii~ ; tr . . ~ Ci-~ .~~. r~ 1!'. -e:t· ~--~ -~ t ·fc, «t.1:. it·t 'l ~r $ rr:~ r 'r,~· ~ ·~~ ;i~ fi:-g ~ I ;f.l· .f.· ti
i. i ~ i E.. 1 ~ ~ ~ f> ·~ r, E! ~ ~ G. [ ~. i ~ [ c... t' l r ~ 11: C·
F;] c_ 1 li>'
1.·.1. .
,c;; N ,!"1 I ~(1· C)I • c_ - ;~ •L Ii
l II .t,t t8 { {- tt' ;~~ [ l~ ·t· l ·"1~· {'t. )·\ 1 rI;; ~·~ •.i ~~· ~-~ ~i· i;-r !f l \- t i 1 ~-
.!, 1' . ! tl, ,l, I··,.·.:·:.
t" to.!: h \0 ·~ - c_ I V O V\ >

~ I ~ c-~ ~ ;1 1(1· ~ ·_,. . ' I~ ;v~ ~~" ~£1 ~,V '[- ic· i- ~t, ~_:_ j~ ~ ~ 1.l I.f"' fl
~ . - I f> t>
. - I 1 ~ '£;" l, I ~ ~ V e-1 °LI }r: . ~ t> ~ tC O I I tC ;:
E.~.i.;.·
L#' . C>I C - 1• 'f!.. • l.. • _e.. - ;1

tI~ t·c.. ;~~ .L· ,rlk !. ~~ ~[ { fl 'j._\. ~-l ~~_. r€ E- i l1t~ f:·..f it' t;• i~ i>J t ~ ! t ..
~ i~ ·.r, ·~t E. h
~ - ~
· ; ~
N
·1 ~ ·r
h .r i l _: t - l · 't ~ [ !t >\ i £ ~; 'r ~- 1
~~ ~ I
c, ~ ,t. .t,· t
•., I.- C>• - ! - . ~. .. - ! I •
E! ~. - ~· t t -: \- s r . " 1. 1 ir- [, J [ i ~ G. e-: ·f _ g; ,~: r .... ,. ~ C· ,,'.'..l

1 1
-; ' t ,f: t· ~ ii: 1t• l (.- ~ r- ~ 't ~ N '[ t 1 - 1 .I; L .~ Ii\ •j;, . • •ot; ("f
. ~ t i f ~ · 1= \ f;:
'! ·~. i- ~ ! •
·~· ~ f k 1:. ( 1 ~ ~ I;;; g ~ { ~.- •L tC
i
~ - E ~ Ci- c· r. .i:- , ~: 1\ - - 1>
·~·r i 1 c, ~- , E.. '° r- <t_ 1
~ l • (1 [i ~ ,r\ I
l _ I• [ .; Ir •I ~ l,' I E.. ~ I [1
1 '-'.._ , ~ - • - t1
li> (1 C • I _,. t [, r=- _,. •

~II ~tr ,. ·tf t. r -1 I .IA I I I I
!·ti
-~
.r: L li) - '
l- ft \-~ Lt It
l,' I
.
~-[ ·~ :i ~ :.f.
_,_ - ~
~ -~ ·~~ tf (t~ 1.~· l~ !- ·fl~:,:····,'l
t't [ x-J: r; ~:~ ~
- - - - 'I ~ ~ \, -1 ~ ~• - ,:
~ i_gl~} ~ ~.)~ D.ll.c. ~ ~~l..1-;t ~ ~I~ C:.,~-llS'~I ~ , l.:U
,, ,, ,, - ,,
l.:r4=-llS'~I J4'J.I ~~~..>A 4.)...u I~ ~~I[~~~ .J4'J.I ~
,-D~ ~~?/4; .~.llS'~I ~ i.S..»-i 4:J.?A ~ ~..J D~I c..:,k ;.~
~ .. bij L~
- - u~ - ' 1 - -'lS' ~l.J1:u11 - .:..< .J..d.Ll.l 1 - -'I . ~ ·~~I~
; . lS'~ ~ .llS''l'I u---' . ~J u---' '-T.). ' . ..
.(Hunter and Schmidt, 1996; Steele et al., 2000) a.:,o;....,1
LLAJ ~~I i.S..»-i JAi~ ,~IJ ...l1uy.l ~ U)WI ~ ,l.!.U~~l ~~!

~ ~J ~Ji .c:.,l...,l~I ~~I.J-AJ yll.bJIJ ~l:u.u~I ~ ~ll)WIJ C:.,Jl..:JI ~ ~J
~Jl..:JI ~I~ .(Dunbar, 1995) C:.,Jl..:JI D-ll.c. ~-llS'~I ~I~,~~
~,.:aiiJ ~LlJ.I J>- i_g...14:1 <YY"-~I -l)-'"°J ~l.)~J ~.)l.&A 0-4 D.lLl:i.-"}/4 ~Le.~
~ , l.:U . (Bordons and Gomez, 2000; Gibson, 2001) aS'~ a.a.,~ ~ I
,l.!.U~ ~1 ~~1 ·~~~~~I ~ clkt! ~ ~ll)lc. J-lfa ~-llS'~I ~
0 ~ LA~ <Y~I y)lbJI ~ ~ll)lc. J§ «~«i! 0~-llS'~I f'~ c:.,i ~y.l 0-4
• (Janssen and Van Yoeren, 2004) ~l.)..ul ~Le.WI ~~..>£A~!
r'~ ~ ~ I - l ~ ~I ~J ~-llS'~I ~ '?'~I ~~ l.!J~J

~~~I"~~ 0J? '}ii ~LJ..JI ~ •peer review c:.,l->--9~1 ~I.J-A
~Jia .:'..>=JlJi ~LA~.l~
.. J ~ ri~~~c:.,lS' ~1..9-'-",, , ~ 1
~~I ~.l4ll ~i c..:,k ~ I c..:,k <YY"-)U ~~.,.ti r'~)U ~ .~l~I
~ Jl.)Ji ~ ~ I c:.,i ~i .(Crigger, 1998; Wenneras and Wold, 1997)
clrara.,JI~
- -
,... ;L.&..,·
- c.:,-,-
..<.·L-~~
• (.)~ (.) • •- • J i~bi J i~lcC'c..b;..
.. • J i ~J-' I·~~,,
~~I llA ~ ~~ ,-,/i ~J . ~ I Ji 4.:co;. ,~,JI ~~I 0,-4 ~...L..:'
a~.(Pronin,2007)~1~Wb~~~l~lc:.,i~~~I
~~~4 a:s)WI ~,~ ~~I 0-4 -l..u:. ~1 c:.,l...,l~I ~~I.J-A ~~ ~-ljJ ,l.!.U.:U
.~~~IJ~Lal
-l~?/4 ~ l.!.U.:UJ ,4WI Jo~IJ ~~ ~-llS'~I ~I~ ,i.>:?-i

0fi.: ~ D.lJ..L....>J 1.l).,.ti ~~ Jlo ~ l.!.U~ ~ CJ...L.:t:: rLc. ~ .~>1-'
-:ti ~ L
'-:?"""J .. -~ - - ~. ~iJ J~iJ J:.,_
,.,....-J.) ~l~
·- r. b.lllJ u.-:11
-'.r'"'I.Y'
L.ui
0~0iJ~~~J~l~l~<Y.J>-~1~1~4~c:.,i~
LA~,l.:U .~1_,.i--u,Ji~i~l-l~~I l l A ~ -~0-4~~.J-A
c:.,~l.!.U~c:.,i ~J-ll ~<Y.J>-~1 rl~IJi_gl~I c..:,k ~JJI ~ ~ "}!
~ D.ll.c. ,J4'J.I I~ ~J . (Schweitzer, Ordnez, and Douma, 2004) ll~l
~L:.., .4.l.a.9 ~ .L".'..LJt Lo. ~-L,,,j faU

. . --~ ~
:uLJ:..a~"
'T
JlwMilt 4.4J·-'1
!J =r:-
=-------- --T!i
Ji w-t?\tt wl;i.)'-4AJ .)~i.., w ~ ~.) ~,.., ~.)\5~1 ~ ' ~ r~'
~)l;. w,k. ~~,.., ~.)\5~1 ~ .ig ~4-Jt 1.J.A 0 i F1_,J10-AJ • ~ , 11.:< ,~,;11
~
1-=~~'.,l.i.1&,\..aj· ""U c..9"~I
<.)A ~ .. I('_:._-: ~tt~I"'
~ ~ .. ~J ....... t" '' ·\ft c4
\-o-'~ <,r (>J...;,::.
.~.)\5~1 WG:..11 ~U 0\tl
J)l;. ~)l;. ~IJ ~ I t.!l.,L.-uJI wWJ...lA ~l...A t.!l~I ~.)\5~1 WG:..11 ~

~ I wlb~L;i ~ I t.!l.,L.-uJI ~~ ~..D t.!l~ o.)k. . ~ I ~ I ).:,;;;
JJi ~~,~I~ .~UI .J~~I ~ J ~ ~ I ~t...;JI ·.·: '"! cll~J
,~W.ll
L-
.LL;J.I a:i·1
• ~ ~-"°J ~ , .~ ~.)
. '-:T' •.. < L.c:W.I cl..J~
.. ,Ll)l;.~I
.. ~
LuJJ ~
'! .. L-:
t.!l~ ,~.)\5~1 wWLld.l ~Li.A ~J .~.)\5~1 a.:a.::b;t\ ~~I J~ ~

~..,_JI_, <...a..U_µ}IJ J)t;..~I ~ ~J o.)F wWG:..11 ~i ._u:j w~~ cd>G
WG:..11 o.)k. ~J-Li ~JL:...:i~I wku~IJ w ~ I wkul:-, 0i ~ I J . ~ I
J i ~ ., ~ cJ"L....u
.. <r ... t\ J i "-4.LJ~~tt
· ~-'..)-'-'*' ")t;..~I L·-t.,
~ J i cJ 4..L.4.,.)\5~1 J i ~
L.8-1 • .. .. .. ,
.
• cLL:oy:. Ji ~1.)-AJ "j~l
~1 ~.)~ ~jjlJ -~J\5~1 ~ I o~ll ~D ~1 ~.JWI w,k. J ~ I ~.)~

~~t...;JIJ wwL.JI .. · I .~ri) cJ")t;.. ~I .r-
... t_l~ A A ~ · -t\ -<'I ..
"J- rl_)-J~r · ....LZJI wl,--.
-'-.:. J ~ I
~~l.?.Ji ww~I ~~..,i~~i)"-4.U_µJl_,(~l.a>. ~i w,k. ~Y:.J
,cll~ ~1 ~~1 . (Gerber, 2006; Sox and Rennie, 2006) (~ I J>1o _,t ~~
.)~)U ~ ~J-LA 0JJ ~~t ~ Lo~ J.)1.,11 .J~ ~! w~~I ".J.A ~.)j:i
~~~I ~i) ~ I ~~I 0i 0-4~.;JI w,k. ·0:J>}U ~~~I J~~I w,k.
~.)j:i ~(~.)~I ~i uJJ 0-J?\tl wl.)4':, Ji ~l:i:sJ wW~J wl~l~l., .)~i ~
~F Lo~cll~_, , ~ I ~IU:OJZ ~ J ,~J-Ll.l J)t;..~I ~lo->-1u~
w-t?~I ww~ ~..>-'-" ~ .~t...;JI_, ~~~IJ .J~~I J.)~ ~ i .J~~I
-~~I ~ J~~IJ ;u:-JI ~_,-a:; ~1 ~ I
o~w~~r~~~~l~..,-JIJ"-4.U_µ}l_,J)t;..~10i0-4~.;Jlw,k.
cGi w,k. (J.lb~ ~.)\5~1 wW~ ~ I ~..,_JI_, "-4.U_µJI_, J)t;..~I [~J4> ui ~1
,,
0-4 ~~JS'.1:J:' , ~ I ·,.:aii~->-1o.J~~l~[~~I I.J.A~ ~ -~~
0-4 • (Mumford,Antes, Beeler, and Caughron, 2009) ~ I w4-,~ w,k. cll~
e:4 ~.)~' Jd~ ~ Jfill ~ ~ ) ~.)~' ~ ' ~'.:aii ~ 0t F'-'1'
·¥)l.;.~IJ~la~_,L..JJ~l.?.~(~)Loj.JIJ~IJa..u.lJ..1.ll~~)~~I
e:4 ~'-:JJ ~~~ J,...AL..:tll ~ ~ ¥)l.;.~' ~.)4,11 <)---4 J¥ JS'_JJ , ~bJ4
~ I ~~IJ WUJ_j:tllJ J)t;. ~I~ nill~ ~1 ~W,1 . ~ I ~ ~ J ~ I
I('_:._. ~ I ~, I J)l.;. L-u...uli.l.11.!l-'--'I L ~ j-l.j,J
h- • . '\ -L:;· tiLA~I
~~ ~ • ~. • ~ - LJ:>" "T -~
. (De Vries Anderson, Martinson, 2006; Resnik, 2003) ~.)lS'~I ~ ~
~~I a~W\.:i a.:sJ'-4..o ,o.ll:i.Lll ~.)lS'~I aW~I a~6. ~l..)J JI.~ u~, l.:U
-:1.:...-: .igl.!.LJ~ .~.)~I.)· A~tl 4-AI··
~ -- ~
I,.. j ...<'j.L:. I(' :.-: LL_.
~~~~~~
,o' J.L.:..
~
ui ~...,.11 <>4J ,oJ~ ...L.-1ui a~6. ¥ _;.s:.:; kLlA ~.)lS'~I aW~I a~L....:,..
~ .i9 ~~I ~4JIJ ~.)~I ~ o-4 ~.)\S'~I aUJLld.l L.b)Lo
.~At~i.
r""O"' ()A
o.)l:l...A '-WI ,:.__ -:, .·.j ,,.. , ••.• '!.L. , .-. . -
• ..?. c.,---, '+' ~ '+'~ - J '"(f-'~
~ I ~~IJ WUJ_j:tllJ J)t;. ~I[~~~ J ~ I (:A J..olA.:ill aJJb ~J

~11.!l~I awJ.J.A (Helton-Fauth et al. 2003) u~iJ ~.,Ls u~ w,uJ.l
~.r.r-w
I.. _;.~tL .. -~-~, l.!.J-1 ·-·'' aw .J.A A -~-'I a ~ I
~ !J ~ - • ~. - .~~
~ '- J~- " .T'\
~Jls u~ ~IJ .~~~~I ~bi J)l.;. d..J~I ~J d..J~I a~_,1-JI
4:d.~~~I r#IJ ~ I J ~~~' ~ ~ l.!l_,1.uJI aWJ.J.A ~ Us~ u~IJ
ti ti
~ FJA .Jib ~J . a w ~ ~WI ¥ ~ 1 ~I~ ) L o ~ ~ IJJfoJ

ti ti
~ <?11 J ~ I ~ aW~ lS'~ ~4- , V~ IJ I co> ,(A-,) JJ~
,l.!l_,bll Lu,IJ.l ,4:ub?/I aw~I ~ J ~le. ~I.?. ~,;i Jl.bl ~ \so.:i«oi
.J~~I aL..u).-4.AJ ~ I aL.uJWI
~~LS~IJ,...u~~~t~t~t· i,.!jcai(A-,)~.JJ.J~
~..,.;zr·~~· . w,~~·
. ~ I J J~'}ll ,uw~4 ~~I uw~I o.Jbl
.(uujll ~..L,.jJOJ~I ul:i~I~ ,J~I ~~)~I uL.).4A
.~~jll ~l_;-ll ~~ uL.J'-4.o LIJJ.ll \:oii

- ~ ~ I J ~~I ~1,-o
.~I
-~~I r=4 jALA:iJI
.y J 4:=JI u w1-':P'" r=4 jALA:iJ I
.(A-\) ~.J c.b~ - ~u
~.,M·~~· .J4.&l1 r-.:.: ;;; ~ ~~_,.I.I

flaJl~~I
~ I ~L.u.;WI
.o~4~~'l'I
-~la.µll~~
. ~ I ~1~4 rl_µt'l'I
.~1.,a...ow1~1~~
.~ ~ _,t ~Jl..:J.I _,t j4&ll ~lb J ~ I
.~Uly.;W:u J~~I ~L.u.;LA..o
• .al..:ill ~L.,,.; LA..o J l ~~I ~ t_l .,.;JI
.~..)UI .l.;l.,.Jl "'='""'LUI ..HJ:, rl~'l'I
-~W.I ..HJ:. ~1.;-!,til ~L.u.;WI _,t ~W.I ..HJ:. o.;btil
.Helton-Fauth et al. (2003) :.;~I
~\.jJJ.A 0J»-iJ 6_,ls u~ ~IJ ,c a.!i,oiJI I~ ~l..l.r.o.4 ~ a.loll ~..J.4JJ

~ , ~l:S'.,WI 0-4 :I.Ar~ I <,.!i,oiJI ul ,.,~..,.., ~ , . ~ ~ I ~.,WI
~, O.!; I oiJI ~~<)-,A \ si.!b;; ~ rJ <i'1' ~l:S'_,1...-uJI Loi .~w..,..u.l ~ ~
~,,...4.L9L.:::,1
. Lhi ~ ...1.a:i f-l.. ~ .D~
.. .(' ct>. ...u, ~~ ·-. ~ ..
.J. ~ ~~
· .. ~\S' ~
l,)J»'ij~j <..:r""Y-Loj ,.. ,.!~ ~ rll a..ul.).l ~_,.b ~' 4.!icoiJI ,~ ¥1..l.r.o.4
~, <,.!i,oiJI ~ i.S.J.-A l_,__,J.l ~ (Kligyte, Marcy, Sevier, et al., 2008)
~WI y_,L..,i rl~4.., . ~ I .l~.;~I ~ j y_,__,WI r.,k.J L.J.411 J~i
~rJ~l;.!;,oiJ1~0i0-4~yl~~i0~j.ll ~_,,J~I ~~~I~
~~I 0-4 :I.°'• 0-4 ~i ~ .i9 ~l~I ~ u~ ~Gl~I 0-4 JAL..:JlS' ~Li.A
.J~I ~ ~ ¥)l;.~I
~ JIJL.o ,(Stenmark et al.)
uJ»-iJ ~J~ ~ rll ~~ ~ ~1_~1 ~J
c a.!i•oiJI I~~~ c'""jlll a;,~} ~.J-AA ~ ~~I w,11 ~~ jAj ,~l..,.ll
J~J (~I_, ~_,tJI Jlill ~ ~ ) a.;,~?}1 r#I ~ ~W&JI J~i ~

-(~_j,llJ~ylJ~ylJ~IJlill~~)~lu~IJ~b~I
~ rJ a_;,1~1_, ~ I 6~~4 ~L;JI ~l~I ~ uf 0-4 ~yl ~
o~ ~ ~L..u~I ¥~~I ~~I~ ~l~l o~ ui IJ~J ~i '}]} J~b
r#I ~ ~ ~ ~l~I o:U ~ a.!10,0.:...:J\ a.!'.!.ebtl ul .u\ ,o,o:=c::JI
~~J(~l..9u~~l~~~,J\:'Jl~~)~~I~
~J~~l~l.?.~lS',~I~ -~~J~~l~a.! "'.!;_;J\~l~I
ulS' ,J~I ~ ~ . ~ i ~ ojJ4 ,~b~I u~I ~G....., , J ~ I dJ:i
~ ~4- 4.9~} ~~4J , ~ I Lt..u.)~ LWI ~l~I ~ o..)~ ~Li.A
~
-=•-~ · W- J,,
~
,LlJ.I Ll)l;..
-
~I l.,~I
-
,... - .,.~tt I,.. ··.<'ti ~ .<. ~,1 ...< - ., .• ~
~J~-=-- ~~ ~...J-W ~~~
.~11:U~~
y~)U ~~J , ~ ..)~~4 u ~ ~I ~l~..9 1 o.!i,oill I.J.fl ~ i ~UA
~~' u~>ltJl..9u~l.)l.;u:.~I ~ula.!i,oill - o~F ,~..,i
- :~Ull
~4- ~ W' -~.llS'~I jA.t.U J~~I ~4- c.:)14.9~1 ~..)\S~I ~ I ls:k
ula.!i,oitl o:U ~ -~.llS'~I jA.t.U ~ I .>::!WI .)l.;u:.~1 ~ a~;stl u ~ I
J~~I [~~ a_j.)UA~.llS'~I ~ ¥)l;..~I ~I~ ~~~i i.)Uol r~~
~I.?.~ LG.:UI y_,L.u~I 14} ~ i ~t ~UA . ~ I U~l..9 '-4.iJ_µJl..9
-
ul~ Wl.l ~- ~..)lS'~I uWL;J.I ~~ ui c.:,ll ~ ,(J~ ~..)lS'~I uWL;J.I
'-4.iJ_µJI Jgi ~.).lc.:)lJ ~ I al~l..9J~~I ui u,A~yl ~ .~l..9 ..)J~
~.!.!;;; ~ ~~_,.1.1 ~ Jo~lS' ~..?-t ~~.,.Lu ui ~1,~1.., ~~~ ...u.:;
o:Uul ~I~ .~i ~.)..1.:t~La.a.l ~ll ...u.:; ~b?JI ~L..u.)WI L~)\.A..9~1
,,. - - C. ti ~ C. C.
~ ~ L...uLl.A
• lS'·' · ·· J I ~~I
y---,,- - • .< · (.)· I ~
(.)~ • c · LAiJ l.!J.I
~ · .It Ll~
- 'ii ~I --'I
. :;-:-
. ~ I J~IJ ~~IJ uld,4~1..9 ..)\__,-g~I ~~4
'-4.iJ_µJl..9 J~~ ~ J ~l..9 ~..)lS'~I uWWI ._;.___,~ u,A ~.;JI~

~ -
<.iafa.J LWI ul........u~I d.J:.~ ~I~ "i ~l.i...o ufi.: ~ L f l l al~l..9
~..)lS'~I ~w~ j ~ .lJ..L>..1.1 ~~I ui ,-,_.:., ~Uoll ~~ ~ ,ul ;;.!;;.,...::JI
~ ~ I U~IJ ~,.., J~~lS' ; ; ~ I ~ww1 ~lS' 1~1 - ~ ~
~~~~I ~~I u,A ~..Lt.JI ~~ ,~..)lS'i uW~ Ls:k Jllo: ~ ~I
J.}>' ~~~I LJ::1 ~..)6.~I J.l~ ~ J ~_.;..D..9 ~..)lS°~I uWl..id.l Ll.).l ~
uJ.J->-i..9j..,_.;Ll:..)JL.....u LA~ ,(Jj~ ab>LJJ..>tJ.l..9 .~I ~J;..b~~_,L.u
l..9.)Ll.i ,LA~ u,A~i ~ <i'1' ~~I~~ ~WAll (De Vries et al., 2006)
~w~ ~ I .).l~I ~ ~..i>JI ~J .u4.....:..)LA.;JI» d..41o..al ~~ ~i ~!
. ~~ -~..,,~ <..ia~ ~J-'-" ,~.llS'°'il ~
,1' _c.~~IS\tt uWu...Jt ~l:il
ul~ ulS'~I uLilbJ ~4-JI uLill.;J.I l~U LA~ w,.11 ~1_,.JI 0-4 wfa- ~
J~I ,~~JS'~J ~Ji ~~J\S'~I uLill.;J.4r~')Jl l~U~J - ~ P i
a.owl J)_,.1.10--4 ul.)')JJ..ul ~~ rJ;.; , ,i i!.i~I J ~ ~ ~\,;. ~J\S'~I
a...Jo.j~I ~J ~ ,~~ w,.11 a..._gW:,J • (Nova, 2009; Pear, 2009) ~\.;JIJ
J.)l..,.llJ JI.JA~I 0-4 i~ i)...L44 uLill.;J.I u')J6. ~ ~ I J ul:J~IJ ~~j.1.1
~tuJI ,~4 . J.)l..,.llJ JUI ~J\S'~I uLill.;J.I JJ..83 a.b~ •(Steneck, 2000)
LA~;;~ ~tu~~ ,Jul.I ~w,k. ·..1:?-.,.JI r~')JI ~·-, '".!t ~UI
'~l-u.·tl
V'
a..u.b.JI ul.)'..}-""-'
'Y J -·
I- ':ti ~l.;.,jlJ u6u..al
. .. L~t "'I ~!)-A a..u....tl
.)---J~ ·-
i!.i·- -ti · .<'-:
~ (.)~
~ I ul~l~'jl ~'-&:ul ~J~ ~ ,u')JWI i.,-,i ~J .a...oWI a..u4-JI Ji a.!4.!l.;tl
~J .;;t,g_,.JI ~ J (.}.I~ .., 111=:JI ~ I w,.11 ~ I u~W.IJ ~ I u ~ I J
; ; ~ ~ ~ I a ~ ~ J i!.i~IJ ~I~ a...oWI ~ jl~I .J qi '".! ~l&lJI
~ ~~ . (Haerlin and Parr, 1999; Friedmna, 2002) ~J\S'~I uLil~
i...11u..>-4 wfiJ 0i 0-4 ~~ Jl..?~1 y1&.i ~ yl~')JIJ ~ , ~ oL:...LA i!.i~I
.<>"WI ul)~
- ·
j-4.A~
· ~ - J~
i:.b,j (.:r't1 ~J\S'~I
- -
"- ,a...oWI ~i:.l:u.JI ~.J..41 (.:r',ti ~Ll:t!
uLill.;J.I,":'e J~
~~ ~"l:u.Jl.e...1.LJ,uLill.;J.I.~~
I,.;, I..:?"""" ~ J ic:U.&...J
- .~ ·:.Jo··~
LA~ t.:,-1> - •u--'--t\
y ~ ~J .(Biaggio,Duffy,andStaffelbach, 1998) ~~I u.U:iJi~I
0~;;~~,~~~ w4.4lL;..JJ~~·.·: '"!~w~i Jl~i
~IJJ ~ J -~4 ~J\S'~I uLill.;J.I u')J6. ~ ~
.J6. JS' w,k. Jyl a.!af
~~~ '--u~ -)l;..~I · ~At\ • ~.1. .. t1 -.:1.:....., i:.tu.tl~.J..41
• -· 0--, -·'r ~J~~ ~ ~ ~
. (Schminke, Arnaud, and Kuenzi, 2007) ~ I ~ I J ~I r~J J~')JI
.~b,j':lll · .J-'U
- . , '-"'° --J ,...,,.--
-"''""' ~ ..iJ rL:. ~
· '-"'° ~~luLill.;J.I~~-a.1oL..sa..u t<'_:._.
J
- .L.:. 'I
;;~ uWl..;..qjj .) ~~'I (· ...~.:.1.
)~~ • .:UI JI:.r-
.._~~I <.r-
'- ~ -j Ll
.~- a...ot.A ~"l:aj ~l.i.AiJ
~i ')11 ~k>J iJ~ ~ uLJolll uL.u~ wl 0A ~.,.>-11 ~ . whistleblowers
~~ t>AJ-
• ·::<"t J l u~l.;..lL. ~ .. ~~, ~..,.._,J
·~ - A~' I JI~ · - ..La.J. a........a..,~
- oJL:. u~~
· · -
~.:UI ~IJJ~ ~ I t 4; 7 tlJ ~ I 04-J Jl-a:i ,-1:~4J .(Miethe, 1999)
~ '-4S' .~l~L:.JI ~~ a.bi f:~ ~l.b:iJ fA.J..£.O~J ~Wl..;..qlJ J~~I w~
' i ~~~~
.ci.!1:oi·u4~J~~l ..w:.~~w~IJ-1.JJS'LliAyb.o1~
.J ~ ~ - ~ ~ - - - - -
YO\ '-dl~ ~ ~ ii~• UJ o..b,j ljU : u ~ I ~ Jl.w.il~ 44,J~·

uk~I .l\_;..g~I ~ LG..U ~~I 0A 0 ~ ~ cGl 0A ~->11 ~ ,i~t
~ ~ ~1 opjA .ll~~I ~ '1jA ~~~ ~I~ 01 '1l ,~L...4l~I ~J-4 r:--4
o..>-'~ t-9IJ.l c.!ll.i.A 0~ 01 .;.lWI o-4 ,t9l_,ll ~ .(Oding-Smee et al., 2007)
~.,.-J Jo~J LG_p,l t-9IJ.l c.!ll.i.A ,c.ill~ o-4 ~~ -~.l\S\11 ~w~ ~l.;J ~~
~~ ,o.>J:o ~'16. ~ .t9.,:UI.H):. c.!l..,.LuJJ ~.lj:i ~I ~J ,~l.,.uf ~~
(s':ai,11°-' ~~~, a,Q ,110fi:J lb:.. ~t .l_?.J r~ ~ .,t ~L:d.l ~ ~~'
Jlj.uJI ~ , ~ I D.JA .llJ:!hsJ . (McCook, 2009) ~~I ~1 ~~ ~ ~ I
~~.l\S\11 ~WL:d.l ~ ~.JJI LA :~->11
,~~lSYt uWu.....ttJ~l...A i,.c ,. . ~ t

-~~~I c.!l_,1.""11~ ~~I ~cil11 ~'-4µ1 o-4 .l~l.!.lllA~IY-""1.SJ.A~
~1 moral development theory ¥)I.;. ~I ~ I ~ ~ ,JUll ~ ~
oY-~~IJ-4 ~ l~~J~)l;.~I c.!l..,.LuJJ o~ll~~)l;.~I J.bll.10t
Ll)l;.
- l ~ 4.J~)U
• • •
~
•..~, ~ ~'-4.
'--9~- .>J...;:-w I!.~ al>
,,__. 'J-4 ~ r
I(' ~
A
~1 moral identity theory ~)l;.~I ~ I ~~J .(Kohlberg, 1969)

0t ~>1' 0A 0~ ,~)l;.t ~ J_p, ~,.,~ ~ ~_j) ~~~, ~ ~ 4-,.j1
[~~fa.>i ~ .(Reynolds and Geranic, 2007) ~)l;.l c.!l~ ~ 1_,s'.;~
a.!~.!:JI J.ol_,-allJ (Haidt, 2001) ~~'11 \"' .!.!;;JI J...j.A 0A J.ol~ ~ LG~l
U"'.J........:,JIJ (Brown and Trevino, 2006) o.l~IJ (Hegrty and Sims, 1979)
~LL.ut~~ID.J.Ar~ .~)l;.~lc.!l.,kJl~c.ill~J(Reynolds,2006)
sense making model J.,.a.J.I ~~ [~~ ~J ~)l;.~I c.!l~I ~I.?.~
~.lts°"}U ~)l;.~I c.!l~l ls;Q ,;.,;.! ~ I ~l:!,J~I ~J:! 4-,.j1 ~ ~.JJI J--A
,~~4J .(Mumford, Connelly et al., 2008; 2008; Sonenshein, 2007)
¥)1.;.~l~~l~~..)~~~J~I~~[~~~
~ 0fi:J '}] ~ ~.JJI ~ I ~J ,..1.ul.lJ ~~I~ J~ ~ \.s,LA 0~J~J
.aJ
~
~ IJ Ll)l;.~l~~I
- -·
,J~ ia.J't 4CU..Jl.b!

(Mumford, Connelly and Colleagues, 2008) fAJ)\.AjJ ~fi'J .l.J~-"4 ,.;:,~
,~~ ~)l;.~I ~,.;1~ sense-making model J ~ I ~~ [~~
'1'0'1'
~
.. -
~IJ a.!,o;. .~.JI y_;~I.; 4i «·; '[~~I I.J..s.J LdJ .(A-\) JL.:u~I
a..u.uw., ~A"
~
:l . fr .lL.ll '- - ,, ~ll ~ H.ill~ '1 o~l . '- -,, ~ll ,... j-:Jr.b.JI
• ~ I,.;, • v- ~ ~ f.:r' v - ~ ~ c..:r--
.~..L&,JI ~ ~~J a.!,u.!1yl ~1.a~IJ ~l.,.ll ~':: ,114 w~ ~~4.b:s'}!IJ
~ ~~ aJ< MIJ ~~ (.!.!;;JI Ji framing.;-:bb.JI JAl~I "~~ ,~.;J..1.:IJ
~ w,k ~pt 0-4~1 ~l:..al .lyi.}l~_;~J .~Jll ~.JJ t§.:UI ~ I [~~I
o-4 .l...w ~tuJI t9ji ~ .l~I f~ '".JJ..1.:IJ .~~I~ lA.;~ c)J_,.;..~1 w,k.J
,... c...r..l.:UI .)_y-w
- · -~'IJ U!l...&JI ._,
. ~ b:tll
. J ~1.a)U c...r.. 1.:UI ~ ~ LAS' •~~~
'-b.JI J-l:.~ · · -~'I
c..:r--
~-'I ~ ~ ~ r. .
.
... .)·:.,, L.a.., ~ .... ~,,J:-":-tla.d..i.~1!.s..1.:tuVA~,,.---9
'-r-' ,,_... .:a.~,,,~
.. .. '+"" ~J '-_J..,...
c-r' "~ .~_,.t.l t:4 JAL.:tll ( j ~ ~ u-11 J~_,11 ~ <.J,AJ "~~ ~ Jo.......J_;Jlj
. -~~ ~~1 ~J -l_;l.>9 F '=""1' J~I ~~
~~Ytut,t,.att ~u..:aY J,aatt~U.ot~~{A-\)~.J~
~11...Sl.a~I
a,:,o:e "Jl..9
~Ul1~1
............~ . . . . _ . . . . . . . ....... ,;i..._·· .. ·. :·=:·~.:-:···:·:,=.. ·,:;,,.:~-. .:. : ·.·:. ·:::&:::L:J
w-4 .u~ ~..)l5~1 ~..w ~~ ~I wl.;l~I ~L;u'i [~~I I.L.A ~~

w~l ,b.! '"!;~1 ~..)j:i0l ~..;..I.I w-4<i'1I ~ I ~~'11 w~l_~f'I
J.,~1 w~l~?Jl o.L.A ~ -~~'ii .;l~I jLJ-::il J,J~ ~ 0--AJ
~~.;J ..).J-'4-4JA r'1:g • L..&Jl~~I w ~ ~ j.obJI_., ~~ ..)~\ ,b .~,;JI
~ .Jl a.!.".!~.J w~l..~1 ~~~(Mumford and Colleagues, 2006)
~l.;..)1 ~ ~J -~~i wl.;l..,....:S ~1 ~..)~ '-4.A J~I d..c~ w ~ '"'.J-'
,c....akl~I ~ J.o~l ,~\:JJI r=9J:l ''"~ <iil.J.JI .;l~I ~.!.!;; ,;;~UI ~ ,~~I
ps'i ~ wLi..i.J-Li (A-r) JJ~ r'~ -0-J..;,:.~I ;;~\.J-4-' ,~1.J.JI ~l_,.JJI ~
.w~\..~?Jlo~
J~l4Cll.o·!o.!111!iu~~!{A-T),JJJJ~
1.,,4.o,tt J~tkU&ou~~!
d.A4ll ~I-U>~4J al~I ~J~ .ll~~4J ~LUI i:PltJ.4 ~_,JI ._g»tJI ~l.;.l}
- ~ ~.)j.ll Ci.! /~I y~~4J
~~_µ, .l.;1.,11 ~ ~,.., ,~~.,.i.1 .lyill <JA o~w, ylb o~Wlylb

.~Ll..o t~..,t ~ Wj>,>-~I ~ ¥ _µ1_, okl.J-4J
w~ .i9 ~ , ~1.;1~1..,t ~ ~->11 ~ w~ ~ J.otill ~.;-cJJ ~l.:UI .;l~I ('.!.!ai

.~l>. ~~l~I ~ lfjl _,to~ =~
-·.., o~I
- ~"l:uJI ..ill~~
i>..1.iA..JI - L4J. ,~jLJ.I d».~I~
- J.obll ~l:uJI ~~
. ~J..tll ~ I ~I.; I.J-41J '5 ..u I
u-~ I.)· l ~- ~I.., ~ ~WI

- ~Li6::a...u~I
• • ~
- ~~-- u.bl_,...JI o.;b}
- -~~_,..Jl ~~
._gl-U>~IJ ~I ~J ~ I ~ I ~,~ ~l..,..ul ~ J.obll a.!,o;....!JI ~l..,...ul ~

- - -
- J l~I ~li::il ~ ..ill~ JS' _J.J~
.c...d.,J.I ~ ,. ~ I.)· l ~- WLO
- ..,
d~~ ~bl_, w,,,_p,~1 d.A~IJ ~k~~ ~IJ ~l.;.l)'I w,,,_y,,-~I okl.J-4

·o-J-?-~I~ ~_;-ti
yot
llA~ -IJ~lj;+i~lu~l~~l.)~~J[~~I llA~~~a..bi~~J
(Mumford and Colleagues, 2006) ~~.JJ ~.J.¥2-4-'"4 ~Ji rll , ~ 1 ~ y_jl.u,~I
I~~ . ~ \ ~ ~ cLbi ~..LAiJ ~>l,;.~I ul)J-4ll ~G:J~ ~JA..>->~
~ ~.W.-IJ: ui ~ I 0A <i'11 ~ D ~ t~J~ ~.)~I ~~I c.>"~I
_ A, ..
,~~t:°.
,,
'--'--'-'tLl:i.J- ~ -~J ''\" c.>"-~I I.LA.~I..)~.)
~ •. &(' ~ I JJ Ll:i • ~
' - -'I
alALlJI LL.o~I
- t~J ~I"~ (· ) A· ~ Jt<'~ ~-- Ll~i
-
u ~ CJ)l:i t:° ~ - I
"~ .-,,4; ,~., .~>l,;.i ais ,~.4 r"\ ~ ' t~' ~ ~ ' ~ ~ . i i <i'1'
0J»-iJ CJ~J 0 ~ ~ rll <i'11 D ~ ~ I , o.!i«oitl ~I.P.- ~ u ~ I
~4'" ~ JS'~ CJ~ w,-11 ~-$ .~,o ~.P.-~ i.ill~J ,(Helton-Fauth et al., 2003)
ul~ ~~ ~>l,;.~I u ~ I "~ c.;,11 ~ i ..\SJ .• o.!i•oitl ~I.P.- 0A ~~
. Ci>demand characteristics L..:i~>1,1 ~~I ~ a.! iiii11 u ~ 4 al~
.Ll~i~
-
t<ta..,~lS' ~
1..)--1 • •
-~1.·_!_ •
()-1_) -
w..~~~ ~·...<) ~ J I~
.. ~ - .. .iiJ
- .J,Jf-l
4WIJ ~SJ.IJ a_;i...LJ,I ~~ ~I u ~ I ~ ul.J~ a_;iW ~J.Ai ~ ~

ub~J)'IJ~WI ~ i:.~ ~ I ~I~ i:-1~1 ~ J <i'1' u'-:-,.J.ill WJ -
~ ~~~I ul.)~I 0A .)~I ~ ~>1,1 J>l,;. ~I u'-:-,.)~ ~ J . ~Lal
~>l,;.~1 c.!l_,L.,JI ~I.?. 0A ~4-, ~ ~ I a..\L.u)U ~~I ~SJ.I ~~1
~ J ~ I ~ ,~~4J ·~.J~l)J-4ll jLlc:il u4--.J~~c.>"~l~i~.J~I
uL.u.)WIJ ,4.a.ul.)JJI .J.:aiiJ uw~I D)~ht ~ ~ ~>l,;.i .)'~ ~G:31 ~ ~.)~
.J~~I uL.u.JL4.AJ ~ I
uL~~I
• •
1,..
~ i:.Ll.lJ'&~-ll
• ~
a..c.Ll.L.ou~I - 1
- • - 1..)-1----'-U <..)-":!:
L4A c.>" ~I
- I~·~·-
~~~l~j-Lllu4J~4D..H>-~J.Ju~rll ~ ·wfi'.JLlJ.I ~&IJ<i'11
- ~ ub...'.) ~ I~ ·J ..L4l .a..,~~I
.) W.. • • ul~..
lu:.-1 ~-- ~>l,;.~I
.. .) IJ-4ll ~G:JL.J
u ~ ~ ) ' I &-4 ~1~1 ~ u4~~1 ,.S...L4 ~ i:.~ ~~~I wlJ~I 0A
u4'°.J~~J~I~~ .(A-'\")JJ~~~_,-tlJ~l~~~I
~ l~IJ <i'1' ~~>LI u'-:-,.)JJI Jo.up ~~ht~.)~\ u ~ l ~ l
. u ~ I ~ ~ I ulb..u_,:J.I ~~ht~~~ u~
ul.;IJ-4ll ~~I i:-1.JJ u~ ~ J~I ~Ll.L.o ui ~ ~..ltA a. . . bi f=~J
W::' 4,g)W\ (Mumford and Colleagues, 2006) "j)LoJJ ~J.¥2-4-'"4 c.>".J~ ,~>l,;. ~I
LWI
-
uL.ul.) JJI 1...J' 1 '·
• ...,n.JQ r
ll ..L4l •.I.::" 1 ~ ~I \.~,,~~I J· &
~'.JL,>. .) 'J-"'
~-t\ ~Ll.L.o u -~
J .,-.-. .. 1
. -I1.)-'-'-'J
.J'->4JI ~~, c.>"~ i:.l..r?-1 L>-4 i:.~~4 a;i~)'I r#IJ ~ , J , i : , ~~' r.,k. ~
i ·: ,·_...-. <t:; '· •··: §f:,,,..-..: . :, ,·/_.;:.-,; =· ._....'.=~,-:-:,~·>·.-=: :··=·\ ' ·· ,. ·--~-·:,~;·:..'.=~-~::_.:.,, .. ':.=;~;-.~~'.~:··-..~· · ,,. · · ,, ...=~-;,~==~·=·:·:=:::,::-~·-~_.;._:; ,::=.=,;~...-,~. -~:-:-:,: .=.~·~,.-.-.,u.-, ... :•~.:·~; ·· · ' ~:,=.-.::--.-,~,-~=i~:.~.==,=:-::·,.-:.:t=~:::.:.:.:.'.-:,·:~·. .-::,:--.--.::·,-:.:,~ '.::~=.=· --~: -~=.=.-,'.:-:-~---= ~=.-:=.j.=.~J -~.. ,;.,;•·: :;:.jJ.:=·; ~ .."- ·•. ~--.::·:·. ·.=: .. ·-=·· .::,j
_;l~I ~l:c:i4 u~ ~,j J.,.WI a.d.l~ ~~1~10t ~ ~ ~J .~)G.. ~I

J~~I ~L..a._;WJ , ~ I ~L..a._;WIJ ,Ll_;..ul j.!OOJ ,~w~I o_;Lll ~ c.,l)G..~I
,, - -
~~l~?Jl lAt . '-4~ ·,toJ ·, ro ~ '-4 ~~1 Jo~) u~ .)_?._,l '1.1.JjJ
~j:JJ ,1.-9~11.!ll_;.)1 ~ ~)G.. ~I _;l~I jl.....;::;4 '5i9~1 U~I ~lj c!J~I
Le$ • •, o Y ~1 •,to ~ '-4 Jo~_; ~I J..-,Al....A t:Jl..>J ~ 0,-J_y-~I o~ 1.JAJ ,~b.i.JI
j\.:c:i~ J.,.WI ~~ [j~ ¥1~ ~ al~.ill ¥~1 dJ.)t ~ JJ ·o:>.11 ~
~pLli_;l ('tAW~ LL.ail J.,.WI ~~ _;llol ~~, ~L..a.l_;.) 0-4 ~~~I )~I
r'~ . (Kligyte, Marcy, Waples, et al., 2008; Mumford, Connelly, et al., 2008)
J:,WI ~__;.."11 a:i).4.4:'J .~1 ~~1~?}1 ~ ll.s~ D;?_;LluJJ ('tAw~I -
~~, - ~11..!.LI:i ,... '-U ..cil • t •At:.,. ~)\.;. ~' 1• -:.ti j\.:c:il ~ ,... W )UL,
- • - '..>-'-'-". <.,-- • :.) u ~ ~ .J'J-' c.>" - <.,--~ •
•<.#.>A.?. ~ ~ l.l~' _;fo ~

c.(gt,g.JJ .)_;..,...._.ci.AJA Jl-.u [j~I I.LA ¥1~ ~ ~~ a_bi .).,..._:::.~J
, ~ I ~,~'b..11 J~ a.JL..u~I 0-4 i.)~ (Mumford and Colleagues, 2006)
,~1 ~J /"')field socialization ~l~I ~~~I a~ ,~.;;JI ~,~t:i ~L;..
c!J~ a, ,01,,, ~'..r?""bi '1.1.JjJ ,J.,.WI ~~ ~ a.!'0;. MIJ ~~, r .:'·iJIJ
(Antes et al., 2007; Mumford et al., 2007, Mumford, ~IJ--:!:ib.ll o.:U. . J ~~
c!J~l o.:U. ~.:,_;,t .Connelly, et al., 2009; Mumford, Waples, et al., 2009)
D:!.:u,J ~~~1 rfa.l'J ~ , J ~~~' r.,k ~ ~ ' ~L..a.l_;..ul y)lb <>° ~
~ a.: ,,,.;;JI U"":!:L.allJ ~)l;.~I _;!_~I j\.:c:il _;~ c.>"~ ~t~l 0-4 l ~ I
.c!J~I l.!.U:i 0-4 ~.l>-:1 <?11 a.:,.,/~I ~b.i.JI ~La J.,._,;;,,,s o~I lAi .a,.\rol4
~ (Mumford, Connelly, et al. 2009) wJ..>-->-TJ ~~J .).J_j--44JA Jl-.u

~1_;1~1 jl.....;::;I ~ ~Ll)t;..)U a_;,l~I ~~~Ia~ ,~.;;JI~ _;I..L.....4.o
~~~4_;L4Arl.Jh:i , , , 4 ~ ~ ~ ~ J ~ ~ L . : i .~)l;.~I
~~I ~Lt:sfaJIJ ~~ ~I ~Ll:al JoWt .>JfaJ ~~Io.LA a a\i:tha
.)_;..,...._.ci.AJA ~j:J , 1Ll . (Feldman, 1999; Morrison, 1993; Simonton, 2005)
a~ ,~.;;ll 0t (Mumford, Connelly, and Colleagues, 2009) ~j~JJ c.:,-l~fiJ
i I ·tr, ,r~ {r ,r[ ,t:~ f. t· '[ ,t:~ t',. ~ ~ c:
c, ~ ~ cfe, E·L,
t".' f
L r:
~ ~ .
s tJ L
e-· "t :r
',.' .,
~ .f E . ~· .. - ~· ' g .f .~ e. . - c, ·\· ·C .f ~ :' ~-
1;. ~ t' c· ie • , 1> ~ - • ~ t. c.. : . Q . ~ -; . . re· '&· f::t' . c:
"l· f ·ii' !' r·.: ·\. g, E ·v f,
·'-. c;.. ~ 1: [, 'K .i; .:" r I:: i f E
I-. 1:; l ~ ~ ~ 1;.. - ~ ~ t ~ ~. f
·r- l,l [, ~ 1 ic,· r·.. ~· .~.l° {~~ p.Q ·[·. '-(,r. ~f. f r·. ·t.r. c..
. f
1:: ,,. - • ,,. - ':!! tC t, 1
! 'e..c. <it.
'<i"· ~ 1f ·[·. ~ ~ { V.r.. ,,~ 'f cf:· <e.}· f. q~ ~t ·~!:: i-: .fE: ~r f.·c: 1'e:: ·i~ r~-·t' .t
r i 'C,.. ,,) - f; E· - t: ~ [• r,
1:, ~ ~ c, ~ "°1: t' ~ [: 1> 'f. c.. .. ' '\
~~ ~ ~. .E•,P ~··f:: "rC" Pl= - •(;~. t':~ ~- ~ 'f ~ ·~ ,t;t ~~.
~.
-r ~ 1 1s ir r:·c: [ - . i ' f'~· ~ ~- .{. .r, tf:: \ . ~ P· 'f J .n:t C.. ~ "c.:•
~ i r~ ~
' , ~ L,. ti" \. tC '-(, ~ f, ~ ~ ~ C
·~ · .f. tf· tfJ 1r- t: :-f 11_. ·[ 1: t'f [ -~ t ·r f 1·. t: ·~- ~· r I ~~ 11 i

L·
.:;;.. ..~ I - I c;. . ~ ~ ~ ·E ~· c.. N I 1-D - ~ c.. 'fl
1 l ·t··Ft .~1~·
- """ - ,e E:..
. . 1;· 1> o ~ . - , ~ •. '.'t
-r-- c, iE, , . .p-r.-ft~C-~~9J!,(;
c:- § fl. ~~ ~; t - I E~ ~ ,br ,.·
1
to r. ,c .F> ~ ~ r. p ; "t- .. i;-f, ~· '\. ti
('I) - - ,_
l ~
t ~t•t.. ~ •
f?; ·\. \..
• l,' • ~ t. . ~ . t' J;,.
t~ I -~ -rE: "c:c: fl 1; tr i~ '&t•.\.r ~[~t ~ ·~ t .l !r:
i i;__ Ii-
~ ·~ ·;. rf. IT _:_ ~ _: •t. ft.. t ·t [ t .!. t .'-; C ~ f, ' f ! f· ~ ~ ·L,.
L, t, [, "' ft_ t;· {

=3 "e • 1(; - L,• !c- c.. - J).I J).I 1 r. b [ [ (p, c..
[,£ ~ l E: ~ ff ~ e: ~t --;r; ~ -~r ~r ~ .t. l· b. rt ~ ' r. ' : i ~~ e:
i :. °' ~ Ci ~·
~ E. ~ ~.. ~. ~~ · ~ : ~. 'f>. l ~. ~. t: ~.
<;- c... J; .r:- L" •t,. r. .r
-~ n n ~ f 1 € :[ '\ 1 'E- [~ !f.
~ t ~ • . - •t ~ ~
~'fl (• - -;
I f~. t
'\, I ~ g ·~ t' g .L L . - c;~ ·\. ·~ ~ : ~ 'f. ~ f> (• . ·~
c.. c'
.. =:, tC tC
t ? lt {"' Ii-l 'ei..r t- f 't'8 t(" "t· fc· l- !r,r. if :~ !r,r. ·t.'. 1 i .f,~ gc· ['= .c~ 1. ·f 1'n.w· f.r. ·~(':
1
{ ~tti}(c(}-tt fti~}if?.~~E ~'.till--f~E
A\.t\ ,-:_ t\. J\ ..,d..
~ ~ ~
a. 4~~,
• :.t:JI
L~- t\ .)-.!:J
a~c~siiJt ~ '- Ll..L&.A
(.;r>-.. •
a.bl~,.)..uL,~
"~ ;;~~ ul:,Ji I.S.»-i ul-ual.;J ~ wi ~ ,¥~~I ul.;l~I ~L.;u1 ~
·I.S.»-i J~ ~ u~)t;..~I
~
Jyill ~)l;..'l'1 ~.,_L.uJ1 ~ l~u ~I~~ u ~ I : ~ 1 ~
C, - ..
. (Agarwal and Malloy, 1999; Barnett and Vaicys, 2000; Gelman and Gibelman, 2002)
(Mumford, Connelly, and colleagues, 2009) ~j~jJ w,l_i,fiJ JJ¥-4JA JL, 1.:.U
1~ ~ -¥~~, u1.;1_J,Ail ~~L.;u1 c.;,k. ~W£J1 ~ ~ PJJ wi ~ "4
.. C, SI, C,
~ ~'l' 1~ c..:,lJ'l'I ~1 ~ l:hJI uL.u1.;..ul y ~ c_;,k. a...u1.;J ~1~1 ~ , ~ I

'-'""~ ~1..r?--1 c)A l:hJI uL.u1.;..ul y ~ ~ I .a.!\!!11 tL.:::>J~4 j_;;t; ~i 0_iJ~
.. .,
J~I ~ t~~I dl~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~~~1 ~.!a.! ~.:.U1 ~ I ~
u~4hi1 ~ - ~ ~1 rl..;.:'1~1_, ~.,.SI ~Li:tll_, a!,o:'t.,!JI u~)l.>1.JIJ
~WI l>..u~~1 ul.4i4,J~IJ ~_,L.ull J:,lA:,~1 c_;,k. ~ ~~ <>°Gclu~1
.a~!:11 ~ ~
~J-'4-4JA r~1 'f 814,.C. ~ ~ ~ ' uL........-1.;..ul y ~ w~~1 c...:,11 ~L.:::>1

;;~~ a!~.!! YJ~ ~.)jJ 0i ~..,_I.I 0--4 0i (Mumford et al. 2007) wJ.>-->-iJ
~~~&'A' · .. ~t1 oJLL.a.11
_r-"(;-'(J'°J.£"':t.rJ .. J ~... , tA , ;, ..,<iJ1J ~ ~~,
. '-Ll:i.JL. -.:,.~.~
u- ~ ..
~i 0~ ~ c.!LJ~ wl J., ,¥~~1 wl.;1~ ~~L.;ul ~ ~b.l1 ~1 y>Lb11
,, .. - ,, ..
'-'""~ ~1~1 c)A ~ , wfi.;~I ~ ' , 1.:.u - ~ ~ ~ ~~~, c)A 1~0
oJLL.a.lL
... ~
-='-~· ~..
o.)~ ~.!.) 6:::J
•
· - 1..Lo.l ~
~~.) -
1...r
~.'Lo:
~~
.:.u1 ~
--·
, ~.!.) 6:::JI
•
~.,:JI ~J-'-UJ oJJ.J.:i.J.I ~LzJ1 ~~IJ ,w~~I rl~IJ , ~ I ~ J , ~ I

-~1
,~)l;..~I .;1~1 ~L.;u1_, a~.!:ll ~ w~~~I ~ "-:,Jo\+i.;~I ~)WI ~1~1 ~
~ .;1~1 u~~iJ a.!coi:..c!JI w~>l,;JI ~ u~~"il ~~~)WI ~\S'
,J.,WI ~ .(r = ·, H-)J~~I wL.u.;wJ(r = ·, n-) ~ I w~.;W4~
- - .,_,..tt aS'.) ~ L. ~ ~
~ ~
t
-· u• L. wLd..L1:u~I '-'::'
t\ A - · a..ub}
... . - ~)WI c,.......j\S'
wL....-.;W4 ~ ~ ~)l;.. ~I .;l~I ~l.;ul ~ J occupational engagement
~ 4 r-1._µt~I ~ w~~~I ~ <:r.'~1 '1,\+i.;1 ~Ll.A ulS'J .(r = ·, n) ~ I
~ ,.) ..ul ~
- .~-.:1.~t\.~~)l;..~I .)~
\. ':t\ ~\..;ul ~J
· L.. ~ti :l
~.'J-"t\ I~u---=~ ~ ~
t\. -~
A• A-
.(r = • , H)
- 1 .... ,. _ .. .. " 1 .. '!I-~.
d!: • ·~.,...n.. .)~J~ O . ) ~ ~ Y . ) ~ ~
1
~~LW
._ l't-·t1 ·< ,lt·.e-
,•,a• cicl.!.u~
(r = • , 'rV-) uw~I o_;bh, J1u: ~~~\JI _;!~I j~I., ~I~ 0::t
0 i~,l.:.U .(r= • ,r·-)J~\JluL...u.;l4.4...9(r= • ,'r·-)~luL...u.;Wl...9
. ~ ul_;I~ ~~'i -bl~I ~ I" ( ' - " ~ ~ c4 ~ 0~~ ~~I .)l~~I "
0 ~ ~.:.UI l:WI ul-ui_;IJJI y>lb a~! · ,ti ul.;l~I ~ ~ ,~j ~1 ~~1

-
ul.;l~l~~lr:4~~~~1~1~01~~~1~1,;, " •co!
.(r = ·, Y'1) ~ I ul-ui.;WL:,., (r = ·, r,-) uw~I o_;bh, J1u: ~ ¥~\JI
~ ~ 0.)...9~ I ~l.i..tl:, . ; ~ I 0::t ~~1 a.'.e)k ~LAA U:SlS' '1.>.»' i ~w 0-4J
~~
.. \ft .) '->4JI ~~L• a..ai..:-J.1 ~l~I
. • ~ ~
.. Ll~
.. \JI ul'.) l~I LJ::'J
· ~I
uL..,,.;Wl...9 r = ·, n ~l.;JJI °'!.;;;_, r = ·,, ~ uw~I o.;bl , J u l i ~ ~ )
.(r = ·, n J~\11 uL..,,.;L4AJJ r = ·, n ~ I
~ ~I .; I·
..' -lr'1~ -:tt ~~I
'J-M-1 ~ ' - -t\
1... <..>--'"' d!.u :.t; t..:r't1 ~
... ..H:J :.- ~"tu.JI"~ u· i F · 1-t\
~ ()A·
~ I ~ _ , ~l~I r,l..,L.jl...9 ,~Ll:tll Jo~IJ ,tlj1ll 0i JA ~ ~.:.UI 0 i
~b.i.ll o~ u.)ll . ~ I ¥~~I ul.;l~I ~ ~ o~~~ ~ ~ ~
(Mumford,Antes,Beeler, and Caughron, 2009) 0~lS'J~J~iJ .)J.¥-4-"4
· .Jr--=-tt
()A ~ a.c.b ubul .. ..I ~
..... 1.)-1-'-'J -.: .. t_-: ~ t ... ul~
· ..:.~tt "~ .HJ:.t; ~
· J"Luull
'-' tj
(..;r'
u ..... .. 1
~ I1.)-1-'-'J~...
a.uiu, U~• u.hu I ~tt , ...__"I-~ t\ I.J.e.jl ~~L. t(,j J-!:"""
-~'-r"'-'~~r · -~t I
uld..Jo.l'ilc.h.,.->3~a.'.e)k~llA~(r= • ,Y'A-~~)J~la......c.b
~·~.. ~iJ .J·--=..q
.,-.-. a.c.Lu.o u~I .. 1rl ~ L. ~I'--)
.. • .. 1.)-1-'-'J . ... .~ ~I
. ., \,;l..r>-
.r • \ft ~.....I
~1 ~.)_j.J_., J~I a.c.b u ~ ~ l rt..,;.; ,.,I 0-4 ~I~ ~~l~I r,l..,L.jl
~ J ~ ~l.i..tl ul-ui.;WI ~ J:b:ill '.·: ,.,! ¥ ~ l ~ ul.;I~ ~~I
~t ... o :. LA · d..4J.
'.)--'-'J • ~ ~ L · >:J,.t:JI (..;r''1 1,.;Y,,-
.r • ~I Ua..JI
.. ... ul~ .I'".)" .. ~
· -=-~tt '-: ~ ~I-~
!J • ~ :r-'ti
~I~ J.w ~ , J u l i ~ ~ -¥~i ~ ul)_;g ~ J~I a.....c.b

~_,L..uJI uLil~ ul..>-J_,.;JI J}t;..4 ¥ ~ i J-=C- ul.;I~ [~1 ~ 0~~1 ~
. (Mumford, Antes, Beeler, and Caughron, 2009)
~-'-·-t\ ·-. "~ld!.u.
:.,..-w ~ '?""
"'--)• ~ b:ill~f~l~L
-· '?"" . - " .IJ :~~• 1 , 1.·a1
.....~
(Mumford, Waples, et al., 2009) 0J..>-->i...9 ~,_,., .)J.¥-4-"4 JL- ,~~ ~I
d!.u.~Ll~~I
-· '-r - ~ · uL...u~ ~ ~ ··--~tt
J--W _HJ
:.b.J~l~I .. -
· ..u~L.
()-C, ..
~ I ul-ui.;W c.,:o..,...:JI 0 t JA ~jtll 0lS' -¥~\JI ul.;l~I ~~I~ ~ I
•· ·-~.:; ,=.:.:.;:·,,dv ::~ .. ·:.''if>!" ,=·~::.fr.=4 yf:::.-::;.~·=, .. .q::k.:=.=y~·>.=::..:·'.:sn:, :}.':·=1::·:·:·:=t-~:,,·:. ·;·-,-.::.:,,-ii{·::.::,:··.:==,~=="};'·.:·'. :~·:::.,J :·· =i?·:::·:==-.:: . ::JUl<'=~===:-:-:=:::::.(u:,.:.\":"::~>+·::v ·=:,y .y.,·:.c:~=;:·:.1.v;Af·~::/.•::,tt·,htdfu)3fj(·=tr=· -<·<Fw~-~c,
~'r~':J, ~Jj4....tl ~~u~~~, ~ ~iPJ:! ..\S~~':JI.J-tJ;.

~_)-Li JI .J.41. ~.;L...:&J. l u\ 4.!.! ;;; ~J ~ , I.J.l . ~~ ~I .)-t);. ul....i..,.;WI J ~
u~l+b,j~I ~1 ~~1 ''?9~ ':JI .;l~l ~WI u~.;..) tA ~~':JI .)-t);. ul....i..,.;W
~l.;..) '5?.- -~~':JI.)-!);. uL.u.;Wl J ~ ~ I r~~IJ a.!4.!t;.;;JI a~.!:Jl ~
t$
&.!.J.ll y ~ ~ 4 l:!..)~I ~I.;..) ~.:lS'J o~I u ~ ~ u\:!)Wl "~

~
· uL.u~ ~ ~.r--'
· ..•~,1 >:J:.t:; ~)t;..I J~L. L_Jj,J .t I.,~·.
~ - ..)~.,.. ~ ~
o. ..:...11 LJ~
• ~
..u
.o~I ' 5 ~ ~~4 ~~~I
¥~~I.)-!);. uL.u.;~ ~~I~~ U)lc. ..).?.J ~1 ~\:ull u.;~l
Jo~.;I u\:!)lc. ..).?._,l I~ {r = ·, Y·- ~ ~J14:,) ~~':JI ul.;l~I ~WIJ
~ I y)lbl4dj.;~(r= •, YA-t---4~~)0.J-?Ji':JI y)lbll (5..U~~t
~~, ~ l:!l.ua:il JilJ oj! Jsi U)WI ~~ ~ .(r = . '' Y- ~~~)OJ-?
uL.u.;WI J ~ a.;a.:u1 r~ ~IJ a~.!.eJl ~ u~~~IJ ¥~':JI.)-!);. uL.u.;~
ul-.u.;W~~I u l ~ ,I.J.l -¥~':JI ul.;l~I jl:t:J4 dj.J~ ~~':Jl.)-t);.
i~
·,~: J·.-:..q
,.,.,..._ ~~ u-~J ~
'.l -~At\ o·~..:...,1 .).,--
-'--: <.:r-
,. . J-l:.,~ a...s~~I
- • ' -·'I
~ u--,aw
"~ wl ~ .j4....tl ~b':J 4-4..,.,.UI ~ ' ~t ~~~~I.)-!);. uL.u.;WI ~

~bl~ ~""'11 u l ~ I ~J~ 0-4 y)lbll l.!.11.;..))l ~\,;. ~ t ulj u ~ I
~ 1.!.1~ ~j~ u~6.. ~~ ~I .)-t);. ul....i..,.;WI r..l.4i ..l9 ~.:lS' . ~ I
t$
~J .(Kolodner, 1997) ~ I 4-9.;la..o 0-4 ,~~ ~~ ~ ~J ,..)..,_.ill~

· ..•~,, . -"~~I
~.r-w ~
.... t.-:q · · - ..1i~ r:"\:9.,.,.t\ (>A
~ r,:-- c.)-4-LA'::!
~ t\ J .. -..1
• ...u~ - ~~ 4.J.
-er-:- JA ~ -~•L
~ -~
~~~IJ~LJ..).?.J~l.;J~l~~,I.J.l .~j~~~lu~W
.Jsl u ~ ~..u &.!.J.ll Jl._>-9':ll (5..U ul.;l.~I jl:t:J\ ~ uLiJ~
uLiJ~I~ ~..)..,_.ill u~I ui ~->-1,10-4 ,a.!~.!:JI JAl.,...U ~~1 :4J·o~I
JJ~ .;~I ~J .(Ones, Viswesvaran, and Schmidt, 1993; Murphy, 2000)
~ t o,u.;..) ,(Myers, 2007) 1.!J~IJ.;~lJ~I J>1o u'-4...-...u ~t ,a.!,a~I
..)..,_.i.JI ~ ~ ~PJ:i <i'1' a.!,a;. ,:.,ll u'-4...-...u (Antes et al., 2007) wJPiJ
~ I j4....tl "-=' ~ ~.J.ll uncertainty ~ I rJ.L ~1 _µ4J ·w-t..»SA.lJ ~
~tnarcissism ~u~I 0t wJPiJ~i ~~ '~JL.:tll ~ I ,~~~1_µ4J
~IJ (Penney and Spector, 2002) ~j ~ cl.il4f.lJ ul.J.ll ~ t~~I ~.;. ,;,;
l,&l ul ,-,_.~~ .1S (Kanter and Mirvis, 1989) w-t..»SA.l ~ 1 o~I ~i cynicism
y,.
cll>L:, u~iJ~f V"J.) W' .a.;a~~I cl.;I~ "~I j~I ~ ~~ ~ i
y l ~'l'IJ ,extroversion ~ I Jo~'l'I clJj ~ ~a.!, o;. ,7,IJ LWI ckuJI
conscientiousness ~l_.,JI ~ I J ,openness rl:urs'l'IJ ,neuroticism '=' 111aill
~~ .)LZ:.I .).?.Y clJjJ agreeableness (John and Srivastava, 1999) Jsl.,:JIJ
.(Barrick and Mount, 1991) ~I~~ 1.!J~I ~ c l ~ l o.J.A__,j~
cl.;1.;,,all j~I c--4 clti a.!«o;. Ml c ~ 6::t ~~.;'11 U)WI V"~ ~J

r= ·, ,,-~~~o-k arrogance ~.;-bill ~~~l:s~I~ ,~~'ii
cll>L:. ~J r = ·, H- ~ ~ji.4 ~ (.::.>entitlement ~'i4 .;~I ~ J
; 1 . ~'J-'-4:'
c=-: - ~ ... <..~ti ~ JL:.iJlclJ.JS° .r
.. A J ,Ll~~lcll·~•lj~L~~-
- .) ~ . -. . !.>J
~ f JL ,~~~I ).;-all j~4 cll~I ,,,:u. JoLti.;I ~1 _µ4J .r = ·, '1-
a! ,o;.~I ck.....- C&,j\S' ljl '-4.c. c.LlJj ~ ,(Antes and colleagues 2007) oj~jJ
.:.~•1 ~r
• ..l4J ~Jr. ~.q a.c.~ c ~ I - 1 -.: . -•--= ,.... :.~ i.!11:i
.. ~~
t....A..u..u • • •..•
- . i.,-- ~ ~c.:r--.>J_j,J
-·-
ck.....- U>L:, IJ---1-"J.) clJ~ ~J -~~ ~I .;l.;,,all j~'l' c ~ I clti ~J,4i

.J~I a.c,L.w:, c~l>"'-"1 ~ ~1.;Lla.11 a.!«o~I
~.JJ ~J ,entitlement ~'i4.;~ ~.JJ ~w'il .)~'ii 0t ~1 _µ4J

~w~IJo~.;I ~~~~ ,ab, ,ull ~~>11 ~.JJJc>J..?"~I ~ ~ L . : i
~ -~
-
., ... JoL:; 11.!JUA b l .Jr.~.q ~L.w:,c~I - 1~\S' -.: .. L~. ~ lbl..u I
- i.,-- -·- ~ ~
-...
- -~
_µ1 0 i .JA~ ':?.:.UIJ .J~I Lc.l..w:, c~l_~l rlwG:i ,,.IJ ~ I 6::t

cl.;1.;,,all j~IJ J~I a.c,L.w:, ~~ ~w~I ~IJ~ u~~..LA ~i ~ o-J..?"}U
~~'ii
.. l.!.l.,.l-11 ~~'11.>J~1
.. ~ ~ ~ clJ~ wi •. ,: , ·:~.;~~'ii ~
LWI c ~ I cpl~ .(Tyson, 1990) cl.LJI 4:!b ~ ~>11 c-:= ,7,1 .i9J
U>L:, 1.!JllA ,Jlitl ~ ~ ~ --
t.. · , ..... J:.~.q a.c,L.w:, c ~ I u.......l
. ,...,--, ~ -- -
,.... )LJs a110:e ,7,IJ
' ·lullJ ~
i..r- ... .:. ~ti
'-,JI·'-·
. ~ ·-'11 ~
· a....J...u
... U>L:.J ~~b.i.JI ~_J_j,J
J .. U::'-'
· r tui:J'l'I ~
· d_.ubl
......
j~IJa.!10;.,7.IJLWlcl~l~~cll)L:. .)_?.J~~~J .u.blJAll~
Ulutl ~b.i.JI o.J.A ~~ ~ J_p::tll j;aJ -~4!1 lS..1......1 ~~~I cl.;l~I
~U:,_.,JIJ ~WI Jo~I ~ ~411 .)'~~' 0t ~1 o.;Ll.)/1 ~I w,,o ,a.!10%/:Jl;t
W' (Wallace and Baumeister, 2002) ~.;~I~ 0_,;,tsi ~ ~WI cwlSll clj
0_iJ~ ..19 ~1J.,'c>J..?"-~40J ca<si4J 0J---«-"~ ~ u~WI "~I ui ~J
~b~jAl..ull~~~~il.!.IUA,l.:.U .(Feist,1998)~~~1ti ,110
1>4Ull~I
..,........,,.,-,,.,
__ ..,,,,., ....:,'cs,.·· ,.,, ..,.,.::::::::J
.., ...,,.,.,,.,
' ,,
~ ~"'4A a.bi oj>lo.)J ..).JJ-44JA ~ lA~I c.i'11 ~tu.JI o~ r.J.4i ,LA~
~I~ ' ul)~I j~I ~ ,,4-u,Ll..4 -4,j~ wfi:i ~ J#I ad;.~ wt
¥~':JI
J.o1~4 ~ I ~~I W..l~I ~ w.JJ.>-IJ ..l.)J,44JA ~ r~ ~ -~..)\S'~I
~J -¥~~I ul.Jl~I jL;:JIJ J~I ~~ ~ jij:i ~I ~..)~IJ ~ I
'5.;->-i u~jAJ ~~ ~ ~i ~~~ r~4 ~tu.JI o~ J\..bj t=---ii ~
~~ .u\l)WI o ~ ~I.JJ y~~I ~ ~ I ~1 ~~1,o~ ~i ~ J
..)· ~IJ J:.-:.q
i.r-
a.....c.Lu..:J ..1>-IJ U"" L.u
.. ~t .... Ll..41 1 ··'1 ~tt ~"tu.JI u ~ I
:.j ":T"'
~ ' ..>-!:--'-"
¥~L>"~'-4A a.!':oi «cell~~, rJ?:i C(f; wi ~ 'l.:U ·¥~~, ul.)l~I
JJ~ Ll..41 ~ J ~ ~.:UI ~ I wi c..,--11 ~ ,~4 . ~~J ~Lalo~
c.!lU.41 w§.! "'(¥~~I ul.;l_~I jL;:JIJ J~I ~~ ~i) ~ I c.!l~ I
C
ul)_,l j~IJ J~I ~~ ~ U)WI ~ a.bl r..l4i c.i'1' ~~ a.....::,t;.. ~ i

u)l.d.4i ..l_?.J ~._>-LI w---,o wl ~j ~! ~~ -~1 ~ ~ o..)~ u~_,Lu,J
Ll~~I
.. ul.o·'--·'1
.. ,.,......... J ul.) 1'jM"' -~ b j-J:.,J,J.. '.r-'
· -:q."T" ~,, a,'...;..)·'..;--'.:.tiJ ~
.. .. I '-1··'1
. u-"' · o..1.4.t.A
:y- CJ:;>
~l...ul ~ ~J .(Trevino, 1986; Trevino, Weaver, and Reynolds, 2006)

a.!~.!.'JI J.ol~I ~ J ~..)\S'~I uL.;J\..;..4" J~I ~Lu..:J [j~ P::, yJj..L...JIJ
~l:9 ulj u~.JJ y_,k:; ~ I I~ l.iJ ~ ,uWLldl o~ ~ oji_;.tl ~..l~IJ
~ ~ -¥~~1 t.s:;bl-1u.)1~JaQloiQULWI ~~, ~ul~\S'~l
.~..)\S'~I uWLldl ~ ~ LWI ~L.u}U ~WI ~~I JJ\.jjj ~~
,4 ..c.~~~~t 4 ..c.l~~t uWu..Jt ~ , . ,t;-J't

J.ol..:ill ~ ~l.:UI ~ll..,JI wi JAJ ul~I <JA .)& ..l...W ~L.u ~ c.!lU.41 wlS'
u~b.. .)~ '.'.' '"! '-:?~ o~I o~ ~_;-..:; ~J .~..)\S'~I ~ I ol_J.j c-4
~• .. .o'j-J.,...
~~ti ~bl.,
• .IJ o'.) ~ L. ~.,.. :.) c..:r'1 ~~1 a..6'-t
·'I o..)L· .. ~ ... ti uW\..;.ll ()A
·
uW\.;.J.I ~ jAL.:ill <~>~.JL;Jl ..uli5ll <JA \..)~ ~..)~I ~I~ ,~.:U
c.!l_,bil~I uwJ..u.l a.!"'.!~..,Jlu~~l,·,;q,:..,; -r~~l 1,41~~1 ~~I
w~ ubLl'.J! ~ ~ ,o.>:>~I ~J~I ~J .~l~?IIJ ~~j.11 uL-.u~IJ
~ I ~l~I d..&.o\.;.. ,~4-:..)\S'~I ~ I J~}U a.JJj.uJIJ ¥~~I u ~ ~ I
-~'(.)A
~O:l~lS-:it uU&Ju...tt~
n~x£.1u~e.£:..qfr'T'Zuw2.Y~~1m=.-s2T~~iiilk~:!!'i~~~~rJ71'$2ili'.i:?i"f.if.~tE.imi~;z}i.U~£Zi:.~~
,,
-:l-""..~cij~
~ .. ~ ,~~.~
~ ..... - 1.-;,.. a..o~ ...u.1~·'---'lwLs
J~~0-A ~ ~ ..\Al--:..<~
~
jAL..:i4~~~lwwJ...\A~~ ~~l~L.tA0f W' ,~jiJ ~ J LAI~

. (Iverson, Frankel, and Siang, 2003; Lere and Gaumnitz, 2003) wW~I c4
~f ~ wwj°JIJ ~ Y I ..>-:!:WI ~j"J a.k~ ~ J ~~I wWJ...\A 0f ~
~d..Al.Aw~~F-'<,;t~ •. ·: «·:o.lJ~~~J .J~l<J.AJ.a>.
wl~tr?-f'I J~ ~ wbLlc.;f'I <JA J:.WI t..l.4i ~ , l.:U . w ~ '-8,l~l, ~ I
~.; c..!l~I wWJ.J.A r..l.4i ,..ill~ ~1 ~~1 ·'=:T4~I ~ I ~'.!oii c4 ~Lu:; ~I
~ J ,~IJ-tllJ ~l~IJ 0 ~f'~ d..A~ ~P~ ~ JS'..>3 ~ ~ l..-=1~
. ~ I ~ a.!:;.!:;,.. ~~ wl.;I~ ~~I 0~ wbLlc.;1 t..l.4i ":1
~~jl.lJ ~.,JIJ ~WI w ~ I ~ w~IJ w":1LS.,JI ~~! r~ LaS'

,, ,,
d.>.~ I ~~I e-1.;iJ wl.......u~I ww~I " ~ J.--+b:i . ~.;\.;. Lh:,~
~)l;.~IJ aJJj....uJ.I w ~ ~ I ~ ~..ul t..l.4iJ wW~I ~l_j.A ~ ,:., ~~J
~ ~ j . l l ~l_,J.1 ~~ ~ ,JL.itl ~ ~ -~.llS~I ~I~
~IJA 04-JJ ([bwl~4 r~":11 w~j.AJ institutional review boards
~I ~_,.bll ~~~IJ ~~I ~ I ~~f ¥1.JAJ ~~I~ wlAIJ;.; , ,":11
;;J..=tu.11 wL":1 · ' I• ~ 4.:,...~-J ~~
.. .!J" :. La$' • '·
~-Au·I·-~ ~ aS''.) ~ ~
~ Jti u· ~":JI • • --
wlb~I ~ The US Office of Research Integrity (ORI) a .!~~I d.Al_µ\J
~ I wlA...GJI J;g <JA "-4_,c....Ll.l ~_,.bll ~~IJ ~~I ~I~~ ~ I
0A ~..,JI w,,-k . Public Health Service (Pascal, 2000; Stenek, 2007) ~WI
~
~.)~~ ..
-
l< _:._. -:L"".~ ~ I
• ~I~ ~It ;;J..=tu.11 wL":J·tl
'J-"""' .. .!J" ~
•
wl~I'..r!"'!J .. u· i
I wl.....ulu.u
,, ,,
~~ ~.,JI i . S ~ ~.; ~ I ~ l.;J.l ~ I 1-4] 0i ":11 ,;;~I w~~4
~ I J U:...Lc!i_,J.I 0::t wl:s~IJ ~ I wL..u.;~ ~~I ~ I wlbLl..lll o..)~
,,
d..AWI wl.....u4-uJIJ c..!l~I wwJ...Ll. ,LA~ .w":1~1 ..ill:i ~ '-:-U_.;...cJIJ 0Jl..:JIJ
w4,..ll£A w~~l ,,.JA r-..l.4i ~J ~.llS~I wW~I ~~I~ .;J.l ~1-.>-·~f'IJ
-~~~beer
i~~~,~~11
wW~lc4j_A~a.! ·u/b~J0.H~~~l .l~.;f'l[l__~I~ ~
~..1>£-4~ .l~.;f'I y~~ a.kWI ~L...u.,JI Jlj.....:j LA ' ~ J .~..)LS~I
~ ... -t:"'--;-,.·•. - --.....-.....,;,--.. : ••.,,, ...""""~-'1.fr..l ..C.~~;,,, .•·~--•••• v.:~- •.. ••• "• ~~.~-.-.-;,.-_ • ... -~·.-.-,.v.:.•,:.,;,.••,1..-.:,,.;,.1::~· ---v
···~v.w~..lr,,~~yn:~ ... .~.nv~.... ~·-·---·.A·-·-.~-·---+·~ .•.,:_J._.•._ ........ __ .... ~.-..-.:. -~-· ... -.~,;,,,..:.~ .O:::.::,>;i,;',;
Y'f ~~4.ld~lj~ILA..9~~fall :u~l~~l.i.cc..iJlj4.w~I

...L-ilJ:uJ (Antes et al., 2009; Kalichman, 2007; Steneck and Bulger, 2007)
->-"°~ oA -wj&-4 ,I ~ ~ i ~)l;. lt~, JL:ii_;?JI wi ~ -I # ~ I "lA ~ i
. (Basken, 2009; Dalton, 2000) ~l...ul ~~, ~j4i ~ ~JIS\tl '-:-U_;...cJI
:_jAIJ rlA Jlj.- ~ J.obll ~Ji~ ,~)l;.":11 JLli_;?JI ~~J ~llA ~ ~~I JigJ
Y.?.J Jlj.uJI llA ~ ~4,-?JI ~ ~~IJ ~)l;.":11 ~_,1.uJI JLli_;?JI ~-':! JA
•_;~ -.ii ~ JoWJI w-4 J.J.C. ~ i
~ W:.:UI ~~':JI ~J)l;.~I U " ' ~ ~ J~_;?}I wi ~y.l ~ '~Ji

ifi.: ~ 1~1.J--:!:ibll ~.J.C. J~_;?/1 w~ JS ,~Ci .(Chen, 2003) J ~ l ~...u
wi oA ~.;JI~ ,a.J~I ~La..Jl ~ J ~~ ~l...ul Jg":11 ~ Jl~":1115..L....l
.(Tannenbaum et al., 1991) ~~I ~1..1.ll oA ~JJ~ JS ~4 JLliJ?/1
~JL...,j,_;?}1 ~4,-..,..;J.I ~l.;Jo-A J ~ I ~ ~)l;.":11 Jl......!,_;?JI ~~ ~ ,l-:il\:i
wl ~l_,ll ~ J .(Alliger et al., 1997; Kraiger, Ford, and Salas, 1993)
~ , • __& ·)l;.":11 u.,..-
· ·· <~ Lo~ c':"~~ >LI a....k~
I - . ~)l;. ":11 JL...,j,!.). J~ J ~ . ) - l-
~
•- ~,.J
LLutlJ Ll)l;.":11
- w~, - _,,;t ~,.) Ltt
r-,,- '+"' J
w,
'--9!.) ,. .
~ ~J-"" • !.)
-
~ .< -~•L ~ la.A a......:s-~11
,.,.-
~ ~j wi ~ ~)l;.":11 ~.,L-11 JLli_;?}I ~-':!JAJI_;..-,~ ~4,-?JIJ . ~

- - -
oA ~ L@_;~IJ ~l_;\+1.IJ ~_;WI .>Jfa _jAI ~J.fll w~ Lo~ -~J.fll ~
Wjlo ~ ,~j ~J ·<<lA:,_;» \.;.~_;ps'":11 ~4,-?JI ~ ,~1..1.JIJ J)l;.":111.§Jj
• JL:ii!.)- . i- i- ~ ,•M ;:;.~-" ~ Lo~ '1
• • u• Lla.,. """----:;-- ..,..- t.7'
~~~)\.;.':II JLl,_;?/1 ~4.;la.A ~~ :o~~jlt UU..)\.4.U <c>~t ~ t

- -
~ ~l.§2Lll JL:ii_;?JI .;lkl ~~, 1.)m~":11 w~ JSJ .~IJ15~I ~o,A
-
,_ j~~ a,a·cr',;Jla.,.,~~tt
u--[ - ~lj -
·-'-~•, [ j~~~L~~~,~
Ll)l;.":11 .)-l~ • - -·
·Jul.I~~ . ~ JL:ii.;! ~4.;la.A ~ I .;lo":11 "lA r_.,..;o-"! f'.J.4i •~~I
u~l~[j~~,JJ-4.Ao-A~J_,.bi~l~¥)l;.~l.>J_,.b:Jl[j~~JS
. (Bebeau and Thoma, 1994; Duckett et al., 1997; Gawthrop and Uhlemann, 1992)
~_;la.A ~_,l ~J JLli_;?JI ~! ~~I ~~I~ ~L-.ui ~ JS .~2LJ a.eL:o!
~L-.u~,ps-~J~-'1'~~~j~ .~w,a<: Ml~Jg":11~LuJ4
a.JJb ~J .15~IJ J ~ I ~ oA ~~~I ~~I~ ~w ~J~_;?/1
ubLli_;~ i.:·.: ~ ~ wJ» iJ~ i I.SY':" t wLlJI llA ~ ~bLli_;?JI~~~
Q
.(Antes et al., 2009) r#I ~ ¥)l;.~I

. <).?.;LlJ.1 ~~ ~4-w,.Jl '4:!,Jl-. lJ .lLl..;?JI u ~ ~t; w~iJ J..:?u t u,u.;.l
(t)Cohen 's d ~->:->:.t; u· lS' ...1.4l • ~
.. ~~c:.blll ~LS', .) L:u:. . -~ ~
. 'ii ~ ... 1~~J
• - . ·-
~ .lLl.,;?JI 4w ~ ,wS'..JJ • .lLl..;~ ~J.:?-JI 4Lu11 w,.Jl .;.! ,~,2 w · , tr~

u~~ ~ ~IJ • ,A• ~ J • ,o• 0-4 ~~ f"~~I~~ j.ol_,..JI 0-4 .l...u:.
• o.l..1.uA ~.lLl..;!
~ 4wj;A~I .ll...1u,;?Jl wl Ltibj.A a~ w,.11 o~I f"~~I ~t; ~ 1.Pi

.. .lLl.,;?/1 4l.ull ~ 0-4 ~ ,¥.J-Lll u ~ I J>-y~i ~ JS~ '5.:.UI
'5.:.UI .. .,
u ~ I ~ 0-AJ .~~~I u ~ I r=4 ~~'ii j.c.Li:JI Joi~ ~fa.J:
~ I ~ I ul~IJ ~~ ~4 ~w__;(~I .lLl..;?JI ~.;I ,o.l..l>..11 ~.lLl..;?JI
~lu~l~lu.li,~jw,.Jl~~! . J ~ 4 ~ ~ 1 J i ~ ~ l ~ l S '
~_iJJ .;~'ii~ 0-J_p-~I _;Joj u ~J r:fofi covering thinking strategies ~li_,JI
ti ~~1 .a..Jw
(.;r., ..
.~C'j .lLl.~ l (.;r.,
J-A- ti ,u'~ 1"':. 'I J' 1 • •
~0-4 ••C' !"'.'I
~ ~~J - "'..ti ,~c:.Ui.JI
.
~I~r~~ · Jl.ull .lLl,~ 'ii ~.
. - t!. ·, t.rc:.li~
• ti ~ . ~I~~ ~IJ u ~
· .C' .:.-:tl.J .....Ii..>-'-'-".,
.. 'ii
~li_,JI ~1~1 f"..l.43 ~.;~I~ . uLl~I ~ as'.;LlJIJ ~ I J .J.,j,.;J.I U::' U}WI
.. ~~\.r
(.,9
-
lo:'~
~~LL-iLl)\..>.~lulA~'il
.. ..
· ' i.....
~ " ""'.ti
" ' JL-'La..a.la:UI
~.
~~1 "~.b ,~,;; LA,;J..1.:'J -~~~1,;1~1 ~~I ~~I ~ I ~L..o..a..JIJ
.; \.:tlj~I··
~ ~ ~ • u ~ I r=4 ~ '-l.:tllu~I .. 1r b:i <..T'-4
.. . .. I.J-'--'-" - J J:.:-'l~b
i.,....-.
.(Gick and Holyoak, 1983; Mumford, Connelly, et al., 2008) ~~~I

o.lLi:L.ul (Antes and colleagues. 2009) cd)LsjJ~~ ~ I ~I~ i L&
~ ~L:,.. ~Li.A wfi: ..1l . ~~ 0-4 }:Ai .lLli.;?JI 0-4 ~ I . ; ~ 0-4 <).?.;~ I
~ I Ll~~I
. . . .L~I ~ · o.J..4.Ll.l ul.A·,,,.-. ~--
1-'1 "~ ~~! i _-;.. a..ul..LJ.I ~ Lui
~
.J.! , ,,;1JI ~ ~ . . J .(Oakey, 1999; Ercsson and Chamess, 1994) ~ 4
~ o.ll.g?JI ~ ~ u'iL:,.. ~ [~W ~i ~ I f"..l.43 ~.;J .~.JS ~1.JJI
.l~.;?/lwi~l~l~Y-'~'~ .(VanLehn,1998)~\J~
~L..u4 a_j.;L4..o 4w ):Ai aJWI J:..6.:iJ u'iWI rL.i;.; , ,,4
~ .lLl..;?/lS' i.S~i
;;~~I ul,;l&J.IJ ~ . ; W I ~ ~ u'iWI J:..6,.:i ...u:.~ .ul~WI J,J_,.k
u ~ I J>-~ ~o.l~'il ~~I ~J ,Lss~~[jWI ~ QI.;~ f"..Lis..J
0 ~ u'iWI ~ ~ I .lLli.;?/1 ~ ~.JS .(Kolodner et al., 2003) 1.!1!;;, ,o
ul~
· · :q u,-
· ..C'-: , ••1..ol~JL
- • -.)A Jl:,...~
. . U"":.~L• cl>.· -~('," ,,Ld-4~1
-~ ~~~ ,J-A- ..
,, -~(',"
• J ~Ll:i y--
-
. .lJ..l>..11 ~~ 'ii j.c.Li:JI ul~ ~1..l)-4,l4 a_j.;L4..o ~t_g _;-oi
-
~Ll:i j;A~I
ul..).)-4l4 a:,.Jl4A 4w~i uUb.JI ~ ~\ D ~ I ul~\ ~\S' ,\~i
~Ll:i~ul~u~ui~}D~lul~\~~ .J..,..._b~la .!1,oaJI
iJw.y5iD~lul~lu~I ~uiuW10-4~J .d~WI~ ~ J
D···-':.t\ul··":.f\
~ ·.<-:~~ ...
.»-- u.,.-, ':.f\aJ.c.~··
..)..J- .. .)>A: I.J.A~ ,... ,,:q 1..9.. \..bj [.) L;..L':j'--'-Lu&J
e:.-a- '"tt-' • • •
\.j ..... ul , At\ .• t_-: , .... :..('j ~< - ~L.ui ~ b . . -- , A·.~ a..u~6. -~('j
..)j,4J .)'"ft-' ..>J~ ~ ~ J->..>JJ .. '.) ~ '"tt-' ... • J-'-1
Jgi ~jJI D.J.l\S' .)~.)?JI u ~ ~ J~ ~ .a...otA a..b.c:, ~1 u~)UI i,.J.A

u4-~~ rtA~b ~..>-4~'
~~ ~JI.SJ>-~' uk-uJ4a:,.)L4A ~ j
dti ~ I J:-6:=JI ~tu~~, L~ .(Goldstein and Ford, 2002) ~ I
~ J~I ..)L,j,.J?}I D..)\i, ul ~ ~ Jy'W.I ~l.u.o ~ j ~ ~~1 a.bi
• \.s,aA jAWJI ~ ~J ¥~ ~I u ~ I t.Sjl:,c.A 1.!JI.J..)1 ..)~\ ~
• • j • -·~
(>JJ>J~ ~
• -~t\
~
I -'-~t\ ~ .
~
At.:.j
~
~,,
~
~l:u.J, u• j ~ ,1 .... ,,q
ft.A,...,,.. .
(>--A
~ yfb ub.J.>.11 db~\~ ~t .ub~ uJ~ ,... "'.!' (Antes et al., 2009)
..)J.J.>.11 ~I~~..)~ 0 i ~ . ..)Lli.J?JI ~.:.:;;; uL.u.Jb 0-4 i..)J..u:A i..)..u:. ~ '
J:6.j ~ J effect size estimates~t:JI ~ ul..>:~ u~ ~ LJA~ 0 i <.)!
~~! ulSA?}4 ~ ~ . ..)~4 ~ I ..)~.J?JI u4-~ t . S ~ ~ u~'b.tl
..)Ll,.)?}\ u~ w~ ~ u ~ .)~ ~ ~ ' ~ uL.ul.)J.110-4 ~
f' -
.).#..,.:al 0J...»-1Jj..;ul 4b)UI i,.J.A u..)\:9 . l.J.A ~ Ji ~~?JI u).I .!b-~I Ji

~ ~ l ,4'b.t4 .a.:1_.;;; 11,ll f.!.!:;;JI . . ) ~ ~ ~ I al.ill ~WI~
~ ~)UI ~t:JI ~ uLl~I ~ I ~~I ~WIJ a.!Q.!.!;;;ll ul-uil.J..ul
- ,- , ..
..1.J~ ~ , , ... lb . b~I i,')t.A· . -·, ~~ ..1.>~L . ·-~'I I .,-~,,
- .) . ~ ~ j '.)JJ-!:-U .. • ~ ~
.(Rest, 1976) ..)\_j,.J?JI u4-~ c.>"~ Defining Issues Test (DIT) L:~1
,<.r.. )l;..~I ~
-='-~'I ~I ·
. ~~~.).- ~~I I.J.A ~··u· l a..J~I
.. · · · 'I <.,r-'-
0A~..r ,...
~ y~..,J.I Ji a 1Q.;.,.,tl ..)L,j,J?}I u4-~ ~\S' ~ ui ~_rl.l ~ u--4 ui ~!
. (Kraiger and Jung, 1996)
~j>lA.)J~fiJ ..).J_j4AJA~~.LJ\~\ ~ :J~14...e.~ut~U.JJ

~~ J~I ~l.u.o .Jlbl J..? (Mumford, Connelly and Colleagues, 2008)
..)..U:. ~ ~ 6..~ ~»-4-4 ~IJ ~ .Dpj.o ~j ~ I J:-6:=JI ~ j D ~

. l:hJI uL.ul.JJ.11 y>l,b ~ ~ u~.;ll ufi.JL!J.I u\S' ~I ~..)\S'~I J~I 0-4
~WJ ~_,J -~J ~..)Lli.Jl ~L.u 'r
YJ~ LA\- iQ ,oio ~-'= J~ ~ I I.J.A ~~
:·q.· ~ (, ~,. r. ~ { [, 1· Ci C.. '~. Ci G. [, Ci -;e ~.·::.:i.i ,t'
< i;,
~
9~ ~~- (,ti.! 1c P 'f: P P t·1.:i ,t"
~ •("' ,r-
1s1, c;,. f, ~ •Ci_ ( (,'() ,._, .2. ,
c: , - . ~ E ""E; f;,· ~,e'' &' C[·,. "'f;' e,s-
1 -.:! f. i a cf (i • •.1.::'! ~-
r ~ f - . ~ 1 ~- - r ~ ·~ t: r r; .r
t ;f.. J
1.· t' t,C
t-, r- ~ [ ·i. ,f;"" ~ ' ·~ J).' ~ h p 1-.:Jl g
I l..o b I .
'. c- ~ b 0.
~- ·i. ~ ~-;-
6
-c ~ t'. ~ [- ~, ' C· f - c;
I I:. ~ r,r- ! ~ t[ f •t: J' I .r. " ·~ ~ ~ '·:'i f
i.; .~: C:· ,c;_ i \ i .l ji ~l 1>-f: h f.. ·.i \
~j ~
~; :c'
tf !. V ; lf 'E(•
I Ii-
-
,._ "~
0 !__
rt 1 ~..
[1 {;
-
I> I
f. ' I • (s
-[
~[,'. f.. i t :!-
f
~ "°t 't.
[ fr r~•I
[
~ j;"--~ 1C- (;
t I>
~·
'fur
P.f
.h
Li •
r; I
-:' [ \ }~· [ ··.1.

t.:. .
C ,._ c:.. • ' h
cf.r:"~! • 'f. f·' ~ f.c, tC , ·t..
C· - ' , ·~. ' c_ J).' • , f.fj
.t· ~ j C '
t~. f 1:r_,. ·[·•• , ·
bd- f-s t,• rl -,. .f \ e,s-,
1: - 1 \ ·( - ~
!1 h L• - ~ b t'
t~ ~·~ ~ ~ 1:t fs.-·=
J. '-' • ' I I • I , - C"" - I ' I ' ~. - & K'i
.[! '.·.':.• l·I·'.
t.. G - b [•
C: ti.! - i,l ·r. c;: C· ,r;~·
. ti.! • E: h ~ t)· ~ ~.. t> t> ~ ~· --.i
'.i[.~i\ ![(• f-:- ~.·~ ,c : ~'c &·~kc·~I> c::..1-: [•~ "°~ !r .l,l
~h=- ;::~; tr:- g l ~ ~s-, E ,·[' t' 1_.,
I f'. 1 _ ~• i• h - E; ,e "~ ~ 6 ,[. - (:_ - ,.~ • I ~ ~Ii\ fl
!~ }. -~ c: ti.!
lr- I~ ~, .e-~ lc:.. :t·r, ~e-, \.: -cf
t· (Fl t~. <r:"' "°{ [-: ·~c f. <r:r. * l 1'"i J... ~~ {- Et· · . 1,- ~c· Ir.i.~:.
\o ' '- _r I I). I> - ~1 • - ':> ;·
c... c... ~· p.I'>• ~
C•·
~ ~ l - l 'c -= . . ~ );- -r ~ t ·~ -. ~- '°'l c:..- 't.. ~ { f, ~- ~ ij [! ~, IA
~.:··:.1
i:; ,[. ~ r, t \: P.' \i,, f;:.:i

i1.'~ .t· _ l:s ~ "'l·..[t: 1'\t. ,i:,~ :~·~- f·. -: l-[• ,(;.1:. E·i ¥- ~- i_ :~ l- te. 1t ~~ 1~ f .,t. J1! ·t~-
.. ~ f, . f, [ C" !::. ~, fu, l,' •i;, C's,, I:! d
I~ • I , { ~I ' I - I I ,
(i ~ ~ IC l;- '[ t . ~ 'l 1
u \e_. , - l.,o ~ [s -
l..' L• "" 1 C• - );- , [ } ~,. [ !·.)
L. -( - - - , • L, ' f:
1 (;: t ~ £' r., _ 'f. 'rt' h P.' ,. ~· L.
11 • - • • , • I) ·
~; e; - 1! "~ f' ~ ~ 1- - ~,. ~
r... 'i;, tC • - ,• r;
I I - I~ ,-. I I -
E - i _2. (j ~ c... •Ci_ ' • - ,r;-" •f: m Ii _2.
~.·,j.
1
·~·/ e. ~ G~ f~ ~- t t
1 .,e ,._, .,. c_ l, Ct
r '1! :s 1 ~ .,. - l;.E7 ~~ 't:£ .f ~ -
·d~ ! g tc- l f..~ f:; f°~ f~ "'•t. 'f
Ji I i ~ :~ '.[ .~· r ~- e: ~.. :c ·t· -~ E· t t 'fu g c, J ~ c, r ~ = ~ " ·(j.. " ~j
1,- -C ~~ f<c- ~
J· t. ~
[!
r)·
f~ E.I f.·
' i~.1
t,C e. ,r; ,r; t,C ..
~ s- 1 !f. ~·· u
f·t, ~~ 1s,.rs- c,~~ i ~i-~ {, E t i f.~ ~k ~r: ·i. lft. ~k -~~ ~t ~~E f'~ 1J t r~
- - ~- V\ - ~• ~• - - • I - _:._ _2. - - ~ - ~I ,._ e! I - lj
._,,. ,,.,,. ~·,,,.-,.,,,.=,:~, . .:,~s~\===-:·. _,_,.,:\ .... , ·,=·~=:, _-;~·.:;;f==:;=,:·:,,::::~_::"":;,=·:,:=.=.=:,. . .,·:'.'::·:·:-:-:'::=.=~:::-.=>~:;.-:.;_-~:"\.=,,.~.1
·.>& c_.)l i.b..u,~ 0,-4 r_JI..~ (. 't °') J ~ ~I uL..ai.)lA...oj (.

''"\') ~ I uL..ai.)w1..,
u~l..~l r l ~ I ( j ~ J>~I.., J:,UI .)~'ii~ 0 , ,,-.::JI .)1...1.dA 0l5 ~..,
( · , At) o"'-'UI y.\klJ (, , rt)~~ I ~I.J.l)' <Jl5 ~~ti~ J ~ I a.c. l.u..o
~tu.JI t9.,:tlJ ( • , °' ·) ~1.,.-JI ~ J.ol..:illJ (, , YV) ~.;--JJ ~l.:Ul .;l~I ~ J
(.:.:aitl ~~.., ·(. 'to) 0,-)_;,>,~I o~ly.J (' ',"\) ~l.:UI ~l..,...ul ~ . . , (. 'VY)
~ ~J .ulJijJ.1 "~~~_,JI J.o~ ~b r,"'-' .)& ~ ~ '.J~ a:L-.u ~
~ I .lb}JIJ ~~I "':-'--'-"bJI r~ y)U:J ~ i ~.l~.J)'I ~Ll~I I~ ('3=.J..a:i
o..Hfi ~\5:.A ~tu.JI u~t . (Kligyte, Marcy, Waples, et al., 2008) L..1l&JIJ
~"i LI.J.l ~..liJ u~l_~?JI rl~IJ ~~~I ul.J'->4JI ~~\ J ~ ~
. (Brock et al., 2008) ~_,JI .JJ.J-A ~ ulpjll "~ ~ ~WI ~ c_µ°'i.l
~I J~\ ~Lu..o 0i ,-,:~; ~ aJ.ll ~ ' 1-&J< '~'! uLuil.)...u\ "~ r..l.4i
~ jS~ ~.:UI J-1b llA .l~.J)'IJ .~~ ~, .lLl..J~ l"'-'IJ -4 ~ i ~ .l~.J?/4 lt -
~ 1 -'--: , ... "'-'Lua:; -:q uL.:ii:..ul -

o~\ Ll~ - ~I u ~ I ,--v-1J~~ ~ -·- ~ 'ii .. (= J..aJ
.AL-:t )le.Lg j ;.b ~ \ -
~~ ~ -·- ~'ii
. ~r~~
I... - .r.:U\ c...&.J ..QJ . • t:.. J.41 .~\.ill
.:.) ~ ..,
~~ ~l-1.:t)'I J_,bJl5 ~J-L4 i.l~ '.' lb;; o..l4a.4 ~.»i r~ ~ ~b~\
~.:UI J~I a.c.Lu..o .JL..bl ~Y- ~ .(Scott, Leritz, and Mumford, 2004)
Jo~ .J...6wlL
-
AA Ll' 1 : ~\ ul I. ~t\
. .r- - JL,;>. .) 'J-'
~~I
u· i l..:rti.. u----'
1. _.:.q \~. _A dJ -: . L-:t1 -
":: ~ ~
o~ I ;;J-41 U:J I "~ j..,~ ~ J-1b "':-'--'-"li..t I 01 , I.:U . ~J ~ I .l..l.Li..4J ..l4a.4 ~J-L4
-
.~..,~, .l..l.Li.Aj ~ bLl..Jl ~- ,~..,
-
o~ ~~\ y_,l..u~I J-1b .l~.J)'I 0t ~ :~~~I ~UJ.)U ~~I ~~I
~.ll5~1 ~ . . i l l ~ ~ 0~ ~.., ~~ ~IJ ~ I uLl~I ~ J..-,Ala:ill
I AI~ - I ~, _. I< .;,,~J
""8-!rU:24-.,,.J.l~UJ·'
• • - • (' t
-~ ~ ~ ~- u I.. l- ~ ,. i ,-, o ~
ti - - - c
. ..t .I...
JI~~
.... I.":, It I
..r.Pb L-1.J...ul "~ cJ..,Lu .~l~"il I~~ (Antes et al., 2010) 0.i»T..,~i
uw4-JI <J.A .l"'-' ~ ~~I ~ I y)lbl ~ I ul~I ~ JJj-..-11 ~_,LJI
._r.PL:i .J~"i ~ ~ ~.:UI y_,l..u~I wl5 .igJ .~\.J...ul ~ I J~ ~JA~I
( j ~ 0,-).j>Tj .l.J~Y. J>)LJI.., J:,~I <>"~I (j-A a.;. 11,i a~:-; J-'b ul~I "~
. (Mumford et al., 2006) ~~ ~I .;l~I ~~,
.lLl..J)'I ~ ~~ ..,t ~~~~~I ul.;l~I 0i L~ ~ ~ t u . J I ~

.J~~I uL..ai.J~ ~ I ul.;1~4~ ~J~~I ~.Jl~I ~UA<Jl5 ~J
- - - ~ ....~ : w . e w
~~ 4las ~ ij.:.Lll LoJ ~..boil tjU : u ~ I ~ Jl-.411J 44J~I
---- ~~-- - ~ -===----·----:.=....,.~
~
1-
.. aJlj ~ ul~
.ll-...&:u~ )U · ..< ~ I
:.t;.)~J (.)~.) 'A., . . .:"IJ '-?""'~t1 Jo'
~ 1.7'" L4J
. A•~~
·~1 ~
.J-&.Ol.Wl ~.;LlJI u ~ ~~~Li.A wlS' ...La.J .Jj-4,Lll ~~ u~l_~l
~ )~I ~Li.A wlS' ~ J ,ul~IJ a!"';. .~.JI ~IJ..ill ~~.>A ~J a!.;s.,.tl
" -
<Jl~!~b.tll~,~41 -
.a!«o?: .~.Jl4J~~J<.).J_;.:..~4~WAI
.o_;~ .;l:il- 4.1 wfi.: J.S ~ I ~ J I ~ o.;~4 ~ .)L!i,_;?JI -
~ I u l ~ I ~~1 (Antes and colleagues,2010) oj~JJ~i.;Llii
wi J-A ~ I wfi.: J.S - ~ .;l:ii lj Jf pys.;-:c .ll-...&:u_;?JI ~ ~.JJI '.·: ,cell ~1.;J
_4 o~lilL a..ul.:i.JI cu~I uLS'·' · ..
,... -:. .< .~,,.~
~b.tll ~~.rw
~ . .. .. .. ~~ .J.J-<.r'")l;..~1 .)L..j,~ ~I
.
~ ~'I Jh.a.11 JoLl.u.ll 0-4
.>Jr · ~ I .1-:~tl ti .)L!i,~..~I."=r.)"~ , 1.:i.J . Ll)l;..
'7'c .. ~I uLi.ll?:.4" 4.LJ.uJI
...
~ a.k_;-o.J.I ~I wfi.:i ..isJ .a.:,o;. .~.JI 4 J ~ I ~ ~ ~..J ~->~•.'~I~
~
~
.r •i :< · -:1:.- l..Joj 1.·.j I..... ~)lj ul · · -:q ·
"=.¥1=: u ~~ r J6.. " ~ I
'"(to' ~'"' ~ ~~ i.r .-
~..,:JI I.JA>~ .)~ ~ .~)l;..~I ~~I~ J ~ o.)...l>J.I ~.;L...ll 0---4
. ~ ~ I ~.;WI~ r~ J)l;..~I ~.l>-44<>4 ~~~I wi ual~}U y)Li:JI
0-4, o.:a.:...:illJ .i~ 4iJ a_.....,.b a.:\:;;;,cetl u)IS' c~eQ\t ~~~I wfi:i J.S, l.:i.J
Ill
~ o_;~ ~)l;..~I ul)~I jl.;.JI wi ~ c_:,k .lLli_;?JI t=:= «~«.? wi ~ ,~11:a

~ Ji ul.:i.JI j..,_j.Ju w,k .lL1u_;t'I c:= /·,2 J.SJ - ~ 4 ~Jo_; qi 111Q u~
~ ~L;.. 4-A_;~ d.t.4~ ~.;W4 t9j"J.I ~~ y>lbll ~ ljl ~)l;.. ~I ~~I
wfi.: .is ,J:,WI ~ .(Brown et al., in press~ cl.4.1_,.k ~) ~~~I J4:,ll
~
·<>'..»-~I ~ ~ts~ ul~i:JJ ~l.,..Jl Jlwll J .:'....:ill ~~I J91 y)LI:JI
- "' ., C.
u l ~ I ~1~1 r..1-&. ~1 (Antes etal. 2010) wJ.?-iJ~i J..-u,ji ,~~1

·cl:t F.>Ai ~i ~ ~-l4iJ JWJI ~).G..~I .)Lli_;?JI ~ ~ d.L.ob.1.1
~~----'l;l:. . __. ..-.,41.o:,17'~-:~,,,,.>.?'-~·•VV...3o,,._.'W'.-C:i;:"l.;.s,,;.:;.'\.~ W":;l:::::"c:1'.,.~ ~~.--.:OVY:'"~:>>fl,l~J'.V.·.,~~.,•~-.~-~'l.1'ill''?C'OIA•..-:.r-.,._,:fl:;,,!,,,;~7
Ti'\ ~~~~($~I Lo..9 l!,..b,j ,~u : u ~ I ~ ~l.w.iJIJ 41~1

'-4-4 ~Wl..9 o..1.4.Ll.l ~l_,J.I 0~ J_j4UI ~~ u ~ .:1.Jl_,J.I J~ ~ I r~J
, l.:U .(Fiedler and Garcia, 1987) ~~ j:iSi ~~~I ul.JIJ-4ll ~L;ul ~
~ J ~ u~yJI ul~I.P.'U u ~ ~ ~ ~ I J all.all~ ~cJI 0~
.l.!l_,1.uJI J,J..,b:i ~! ~.:1J: '-4-4 ulb~I d\:i ~~~I~~~ ..lS .:1)_,J.I
J ~ I uwji ~~ o--4 £Lill ~.:1~1 ~I~~ cll~ c.:,-L:. Jl:i.ci..9
u~\Sll ~ i ~ ~ ,cll~ ~1 a._g~1 .o.)~I ~ I u~\5 ~yJI ~
ul~ ~~yl uL..u..)W\5 ~.:1\5~1 ~ l>~l ~I~ o~~ ~.:1\5~1 J~I ~
-~'
4..c;.o\.;.u~Ij .~At\ J:.-:.~q
'.A
~ ~ ~
· · -- .i9 '?""' .r ·~I~ IJ')/1 ~ I -
~,, ~..)> :.) C - • - ~C
')/1J
~,. :. ~ Lll
· ·'I ul~_j-4 · t ul~I~1 ~
. i..r -= _,_-: · i ~ ,a.Jl.c. · '-l.:t:.o
u . ·- - ~ ,.... '-~ _:._-: ~tt d\:i
o---~'?""'
l.!L!Jl..9 ~~_,J.l..9 '--9~?/I ~ ul.c.L_a.bj')Jl..9 tlJ.lll..9 ~Lalo~ ~ ~ I J ~ I
.(Martinson et al., 2006; Mumford, Antes, Beeler, and Caughron, 2009)
~...w. 4..L.4J.:1\5~1
- - uW~ ~:.) ~I
. 1.-)Li.u,~I
. . c4 a.J~
- LL.:aJ ~~-
. u- . ~'I ~ i ~-
a~,~,;;1\u~¥1..,-.o~W' -~~ll.!l_,kJl~J~~u4'-~lc4J.ol..:JI~
.a.JWI
- · '-Lld.l ul~ J'·";.~t\.
~ ,_,-- ~ ~ a......aL;. 43~1 ~
A .~A"
a~ :.,jilt u ~
- • -I'J-'-1-"c
- I j-J_,.-.J
.. ,_-:J
as'.JLlJ.I ~ peer mentoring 0l.>9~I d..:'~.J ~1 ~~I~ ,J\:J.I ~ ~
J,J..,b:i ~l 0l.>9~I d..:'~.J u~~ ~ ..lSJ . ~ I r ~ ~ J:.lull..9 ulA.,W.I ~
ul.~.H..90.:1~_,J.la_:4_:loiiJluL.u~l~~,clJ~~!a._g~l -~J.,lall0..9l..:JI
l.!l.,kJJ ~.:1_;11 a~.!:" ~lAl+-uh, ~ ~ ~~__µ, ~1_;.11 ~~ '--91~)'1
.(DeVries et al., 2006; Franzen, Rodder, and Weingart, 2007) ~~~I
. .'".:tt. ~~ • 1(.:,6~
! ~ ~~~ . tt
. ~ -:.· Lr,j ')/!' G}U .,t...~·, lA~. . - t . ..< L .... J • . t\ ,. .
~c.,,-u r c-- .
~ \ - ~ u - - - ~..,0-'°~..J-' ~
a.!"'.!~yl ul_,b.;JI ~i ~t 0\5 ,~w..l4 -~.:1\5~1 uWLld.l ~t14,.:i4 Lui~
t~J 0-4 ~yl c.:,-L:. - ~ I J ~.:1\5~1 ul_j}Lld.l ~ lA ~~ o.:1l.c.1 .J-A
.~<~\ d..a.A
j'-"-
• .q 1 - • t\ L
- '-'=" u - - - ' - ~ r u1 :.t:Jl ~
~ .J-f:J _ u· t ')11 ,o~
_ .., u· -:ill UJ..u -·.< uL..a.l~
C. ,. 4, -
~.:1\5'}/\ uW~ o.Hfi ~.)~ ~ I J ' i ~ j:iS'}i\ ~ I I . a ~ • Le.~

.o.)~LJ:g~~..9.:1\~~\a._g\5~a .!'00Jlt1.a<)ia o.!o>~~~\
~~)Lo.JJ wrllifiJ J.)~_j-4 ~.:1\5~1 uWLld.l a........c.~ uJ~ ,4.!.U~ ~1 ~l.,.;::,l
(• (• " C... • C· .~ '~. (•· 3 J;, G' C· C.. ~.:,. • ,t"'
tC ('D • -
3i' ~ ,[ ":c;:- ['()1• •f' • 't:
~ .-. ~
~· .'[ rt,, ~~ en _.., l , , l ::s
1·. l Lf,, •G'..t, •
t ,P.:~ ·f
t>"" \.,• C, , •
t·~. i l : , v,.- 1 ,t"
I s.., ·~ Q 1 s..· ,c. ~ .c l- ~ c"' r.·.'.·.-;ll ~.
§ VJ •
C: ~ c..
9~ ~f~ ..f~ tr.:- ·_ & ~ ~~ \~ c..;.
__s t .c- '
[, ~ ·1· - · , -/l-'
C- ,· -
I I ' ;:> I ~ - Y' ::r I (• ... ~.. I:! . [, ~ ~ ·V ~ I') f:: [1
i -t! 1~ ,c 1· '
1.•.
l, 1S:- I:. ~• [DI 1!• t,C l-, ,t I Er l,' ~ I~ .h C: t1 -

{~ I -.s> • I" .. - [D •~:I l, 'I> • • b, •~·I" 'fur V\ f') ' '
~- p.1 ~.. r
:t: -~f ('
t ~ ~ tJ ·~ f 1· \ J. ~ : ·(· t.f. ffr E~ f ·~ t 1'f r ~ f i. f 1.H
,. ' • • DC;.. c... , DC;.. 't! c . o c; c· DC;.. t c.. I:. - -1)-- ;: ,
: [r t;· -
f. Vt i ~ g .;- l t .f - ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 t :1 l [r c-' - c_ " ·\.
<;:- t t.1.
,tr ~ - C)I C· & L ~ - ~ t! ~ L - c_ ~ - ~ >ef> - ,[ .~ r... (:7 /l-' ~ ' H
f ;. 1 t r.~ ~ ~ ~ E-t { i .(n t _: 17 .~ t ~ 1 t' 1 tt(· ·
b l, - C)I (1• h l,• I') I i.:J
[. : ~ t, _,. t 11 r . ~ 'fi 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ t: 6• ~•
.1: .c;
d, c· ~ · g ~ ~ f ~ 9 ~. ()f • [ 0 t:.l
• , l- e-· ~· ~ ·L C) • - ("') c.. ~ ~ .. ,
I I - •
c_ · h I - I -
.i· i fi ~ ~..r
I I.D• 'f) C· '< C:
l~ r t 1;- rv- i~ ~ ~f r.l, '-" ~ C/.) t>"" ~ -(• .~ V
' ~ , i
...;:
.
~ f, •r"'r(; l- ~ c.. - g, ~..' I S-• .I: [1 fD" 2, (1 r:, fl,
I:; ' • ~· & 0 C I:! V\ 0 :1
- l
1' • l(r kl r- 1t f:
[• I
1t l ,. ' ~ I
' l, I
• ,. • •
~ •
•11 ""'..... ' i-, .L,• t 'tc- tC ""'I q
.r i - .~ t '£. - ,£ p. 1 .i::.~,.1
& ;,s" Q ;i
fl t f .-:- r.- [. .t· . _: ·\. It 1 ~ { ~ t[• IiI> 3- 'E. : •. (..f t·_:
! . . ·~ l \ c· = - 1. -~ -~ ,I: r.' r ,£ f_ - .t• f
r. ~[ n_ !·,.J
,:: C>. - { Ii>, .~ (:7 ~· f':1
tl.·~ [ ~ i .,-:f 1~· it; E ;:- .r ~ ~· 1- r:· t· ~ t~ rt,~. _i.f~
\ .f~ [ c.. ~- ·t ~ ; ~ ~~ ~ e-· (•· Cf s- . ~ '<
c. ! ~ 1 T ;~ r.' [r .~
t· F ~ -1, ~ .. -f 6 t r. ~ ~ f ,r ·t 1 .e·. • f § z:
£;.;
t: : i. ·"' t! ,
I ,
._ -
~. t ~, r: 1 J·t f :~-·~" i;c· .·~. g- · < .t~ r:_,. r· , s~· .;. r-6 .rr.- 1r. :t" ~..~ ~o :-.-.·':·.; ::s I:! i;;: I:!
I
,(. ~ l- }c F g- ~ I I
8 ( t, ~· ~ t ~ c.. (r ~'I> ' I -. '(, ,. .,, 1 ~ t·, I ~ !:: [, ~ n
"", ~
i'j
.c;~· ~·
t·~ ~ fc· 't ~ l.1· [,~ ~ ~ •r <r :,: tt· ! 1-1rr fj l ~ t f· 'f r~ 1 \p
&
!~
'te-. ""-I:! C· E.
- r;:
5: '<
::s c.. ' , '
t.. c.'
·~
[•.
r;: ,c;-~· VJ
--
t.:·;.!
1
n.·.·
E'- i I • • ~ p - \.D .f Al -· ~ ~ • C .r - I N [,J
- L~ ~ ~ lo
~'I>
~ - ~ ·( c l ·=·.- ~ f. ·~~ i
t ~ . ~ & ,t' t: Lf> D. , . I> , - :t: C:.. • , - • 0 ,.:
1
i 1 t f. E: ~ .r ~ ,h tt f a G hl ·\. ~ 'L ~ 1. · . t ~ t ~ g ,£ Ii
£. i ,C- ~ • [, • 'l C· C· Ci:- l c.. 1 ~ c;:. :-_ lt> ~ c..
~1>
g
~:. 'G-~ ~c, ~ I;~ g
'.1:·J•.·
I I - :.:.:I
~· r. '
~t. ·f .
~s;.
G
,
•.
-
::;.
"'~ ~, ~ c ol"1 " ~· r.-c, rr6· (!_
~· r
• -• t,) p. t: (;i ·r lo
~~
-
~1> "
•fil ~
. -.~1
·c
;~1 lfl ~lit.~
~t ~ 1 C.. 0 . _,. l, [ ~ \.o ,,::- ()I ~· • tr"
1
\ i · ,t~ ::!. C· f ·~· C- I
0 •L c;- - •
~ ~~ ~ ~
• ~· ·~.
It,, . •l
1 ~~ ~ t ~ ,'l ~ ,. . , . -. s \.o ~ c... ~ 0. •L ;v - .. ·[ I
ff f ~ ~ ~ \.o - ~ ~
't-1~
£" ij • - [,
1l t 1 'f>. C·
c,. ~
,£" t> .f ~ I~ I - _:_ •• I - :
fil ~·!i,·:1@ 1 t~~:~r.- [r{~
.e-·
Ii,. r- g - ~ f. [' n E ·f E e: t - ~
Ii,. ~- I I l,,.0
g. t.C-.Jp.1~ ~ - • I ~~c :-
-.._,() - ,,C: r. ,, ~
~ s • _ l, I' , ::S I ! (1Q 1 I
I I I• tC -~. l..o
J: ~
n' • - -
t.,.I, \t.-11,- [- f. l. 1~ -t;t l· \
f 1 •L' '::
c. I.f ~ l ~ )( E [ 1 t .r ·, 1
1, "'t::I C~ . ~
er ..::S • f;.. r;
c·. ~ -[• .••.·~•.·.-.·
"""' " - L C: • ~ I c... [I' "~ [1 :
,.~ ~~ [. t'lf g r 1· a t~; ' , b~ :f (.f
E ~ ~ 1.. r- t. - g· .t: 1 r:: {
- ~ - l' . ~ -( '1 t ~
~- I:; }e 1
1 i.•.
0
~ ! '[~I [ I• '\.- ;~ I [t
I,/ • • t,C\.o. '1 § ,<;.. ,L ~r § :1
l Ji ~ ~· 't: F ~·t r~ a.~ - fi:-g <c·~ {e· f~ t~ '\.1:
,,
f -
r ~·' -~• ~' f 1
,c-' {~ I ~ I I
- r l, ~ !» } I l, f:::•:. ·.:· ·:· .,·
0 ~
E ~ t .~ t ~ ·1' t~ 3 '[~ l 1 t '\.· ·~,t [. I < . I • l,
11 ~c~ ta f'~ ·t L.· r. t> ~ b• i"(n
N • § ~I' _:P
, 0 -
• C·I •_ ~.:.· ·
•t O cJll -..J ,c; -· C r .•:;.
c; 0 ~! :r ·~ I ls>• ~ t ,.!
r L (r., 'tr .t,f' .._,~ t r. l p'ct,•~ .-~ ~L ,
t ~;~(i?~~c:.flf-i ti.,t'l,· .
. r.- & ~ ~ ~ ,f: r
y I I> - ~ ~ •~,. •
·r = t; -[1 t>orl',f"°~r i~-- ~,t-1!
fi §.~l ~!::)7- tr ~ ~ ~~"~ I l,
0. I'> C t 1:•. _,. i;- [,: " .b r. ~ "°. i
~p ~ ,C· ,._ [\ p~ b ~ &. \J·p .,.:. C.·
M
I I • - C· I.
e. ~, ~ ~g ;: ~ J. ~ ,:
N I;, C... ~j p~' f)' f ,(' - I
ia.. •·1: -
'! ·Ii,. - 0 . ; .
I!. C[.
-
c... -r~! -fi ~-
}(· "
~ r· ·.•· . E: •:'
II ~. <t c;: .. Ci V\
f·& 1~ tt t:f [.f 1·t.t t.111-r. r;E ""' t .; t t ( - 1~ ~ t
l r; rr t,
31 re tr" ~. !,, ..: 1:: i r.
:e ~ i _: r~· !· _ ..c ~ F 't 't ·Ii,. 1: t i ~ ~t
s~.;.Jtu~~
~~.~J
.<.:..tL · · •u--w
'-- 111~-~I-<
'-T ~.) L!,·~ .:.UI~~~, --'l;Jll:,-<.:._.
'..J-'U""""' ~("
~(')
Ryan Brown uJI.H ~IJJ Cheryl Beeler k J..,~J Jay Caughron 0~~
~ J Lynn Devenport ~JJ:i.!'i.!.l ul:JJ Shane Connelly ~fi ~L-!.J
...L..lJ . Cheryle Stenmark 1.!J) ;.!; "' J..,~J Stephen Murphy ~.J-:A Q
~1..aWl~L>--°~~~..)~~l l~~r"...\.411~1~
~ I . l ) ~ ~.,JI J--S->-1-IJ National Institutes of Health ~.,JI
~~I 6L~/ill fa..>-4 ~ J National Center for Research Resource
~ . , (#MOl RR-14467) ~.H General Clinical Research Center rL-All
(#5R01-NS049535-02) 6 ~ 1 ol_j.j ~ J ~ I ~.,JI ~ I (>A
Michael D. Mumford .l.J-'4-4JA .~..) ~lAJ Office of Research Integrity
·~.)~~
Ii:' '°"'~ .>l~C.·_..,,...,>...Jl'l,1,..._~~"'?::.'lo.._-.'W,l,~.:lr...,,,~"<:. ~ ,,.,,-- ~ ~ t o l i i i > - . o z . . - + ~ ~ .....,._,_ . .._~~ .....· . • . . . n Y : : , . ~ - . . ~ ~ , 4 : , . - ~
YVY' '-6=a~ Ll.a.9 ~ 1$~1 Lo.9 c,~ faU a:,~1 ~ ~~~ "'4J~I
,~...,i.J't u~~
~ <J.?JL_jJI 0-J..§J ~ demand characteristics~ y~->-1,1 ~~I (i)
- J ~· a.a.,.
~I t-. -Lo.t...
~~ - ,.,.....~J
·- d...ul.) JJI ~·A'~~~
~ - oi::.1'J-'
· -=t cdl
.
u~J-'4 ~ I ~ 0:?J~ I ui illl~ a.JiA i 0AJ •oi::. I..J-4ll l.!.Lb c4 r'i;.~

u.r- - ~'j J j ~
· .!tb.J - l.!tl ... ,,<.l ... ·
~.,..........~
~ l.u:.~I
-
L.':&1-l'
. ~ .~J-A
"---4.t·'-·
~
.~l'.JJ.11 ¥ 1 ~ 0-4 ~ c.!:.&>.4JI u ~
. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demand_characteristics :~I
y~I ~1 field socialization ~1..Ltl,1 ~~~, a~ .~,;;JI r~~ (y)
y~lul_pu-4~Ji::.~~J~1~4~1~WIJ~I
. ~ I ~la:i
., " .I ,
ul~J l:9~J.."'"i 2 cGL:i
,11 ..)yiJI .)~I _JAent1t ement ~':214'.J~I (u)
.4.1 ~~ ri ~~WI r~I c4 llil~ ~lS' i;.IJ-1-"
u ~ I ['.J~ u ~ w-4 l>"'.JWI ~ I ~1 ((~).;.JI ultf~I n ~ ~ ( ~)
.~..)\S'~I
. ~ I Y'.J4c=JI ~ 4-4~1 uwl~I J-A .)~I([)
~ , ~ ((U» ~.) ~~, ~~ ~1 Cr)
.y~1 0-4 JJ~,
.,
~,~~I~ LA~~~~ JJLlJI ~! Cohen's d ~~ti~ (t)
:d..:ltJI a.bW4 ~~I~ LA J-AJ ,uw~ ~.)~I
x, - .x2
d s
.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effect_size#Cohen.27s_d :~I
~l:at~t
4.:!).J_,..J't u'-4_,.l&Jt ~L.j iJWt. 4:g~~t
z4A-\44
e.r:1..,:-U->:> 0J---=!" ~l~~I ~4,11 _;S~ ~.)~I a. . . . d ..i.~ ulS'~ ~ 'l:ito' ~
~.)~I ulS'~ ~J.A~I ~~I 0-'...>:..ul <.J---A ~ I ul John Braithwaite
~ J.1_;.......uJI <.>":P_;JI ~w» ~ y l ~ I 0 ~ u~'-4A ~ ~~l 0=lllJ
~~I ~I~ _jl ,~~l ;;.)~ .(Braithwaite, 1984) ''U-'?= ..,It yl.Alll
<.>-'?° ccr\JyUlJ\~~~(jllO?: .~.Jl(jl~~~~,#~lw,k
~ u .LA~
_ u· l.:illl
•. - .. It • I~~
- .·.~
~i ~ I ~ . . ) ui ~ 6 ~ f1 lA~ 0,,1~IJ ~I~ ~ J

<)-cs
~JAJ ulS'~I ~ u ~ o..).lL&A u'ib.. l.!l~ ulS' ~J , ~ ~ I LJ-1....>:..UI

J.l.J~ ~~ u~l r'l'· •V r'~ ~ ;;.)~ ; ; ~ ~ ~...L.2JJ .~WI ~
~~ ~ ~ ~ll4 ~~I ~->:...Lo <)-cs '°~J Purdue Pharma LA.)t:g
.~~I u ~ ..b,.i ~ <Jlo.lf'I .)ol:.:A u~ ~JllJ ~4-b~I ~ •.«: «er!
cd)WI 0-'...>:..ul w,k ~jiJ ~J.Al .J'iJ.l 0 ~ 1 · · t-44 ~~I ~.)-Li .JlJ
~ - ru
~ i ~ .(Meier, 2007) ~J.At .J'iJ.l u~ n, o ~ ~ . . ) ~ ~ I
~ ~J.Ai.J'iJ.l<J~ tr· t-44~..)J~ll4u~i.,Pfizer ~~~~
.- ·J.)~
()'U · · ~11 ~ IJ ...u. ~ I ~...,...........
- · · · ..~11 ul-,~ ~ab.a:;·
. . '.rt\ Ll..ul
- J LlLl..:,,JI
- . uLot.~'il
~
rWI ~..ul ~.) ~ . (Harris, 2004) (Gabapentin ~44-) <'>Neurontin

~ ~~ ~~ ...l.&.a ~~..) J~'i\ccr11 4:~ l.!J.)J-'~ 4:'iy
<),cs ~('18j
~ ul.......&..ul.J..u ~ ~l:u ~ ~ ~ GlaxoSmithKline 0--:>l5

i~ ~ ;;~ .L..i.AJ .Paxil (parxetine) (Bass, 2008) L..;>~ ..)\..«.;:J.\ [)WI
~~lt-44J~~uL:,~~J.Ai.J'iJ.l0~, ,r ~.).):~~~~..)
~J ~.)~I <)-cs ..)..lJ:. J.i~ ~ a_;,...Lo ulolfa ~J.Aj .J'iJ..) 0 ~ ~
.(Harris,2009)<")Bextra(valdecoxib)(,.,.! 11,<~..u~) IJi ,.,<_iu~
£. ~ [• ,P l [, y Cj:- ,~ C· p,.1 [• ()t (') J.:.. ,~· C· l, ·~ JJ.I
I fs>1 r') IJ>I I
'-' V\ '°-~ l . . h
CI) 0 ~ t'.'..- [ ~( 1-- '° t~' -.• ~J
I V\ =E . I')~ ,. 'l
.F1 ~ i {r f. t t ,i
t 'Cj.. ~- !:, C•. ·~
'j, 'i, r;:- -· .r (s;.' ,I
l, l,'
~: . - ~ c, c, t 't:,
[ ~ f 1_ l f t ~- [~ g· ~ c._:. \._ r-~ '\t.. 1:: Ec, ~~
,r\ c· .c- ~ V\ . ,c' c;- ~ 1-- ~
:~ ~ l -r .r. ·~ c-1. ~ ~ r'c ~= ~ ~e. . ~ c' b l-: ,I! . & (•
1 ,. l, ~ (s;. tC l, ~· ~· b
yl,, -
~. : [1 I 1[ . 1 C· , ~· ,. 0 - 1 1 t, • ,C-
~
E:; , "" e
•r\\ !:::c- c 1z ~·L ~-
.[• t ]
c[ l
l
• l,' • {;- 0.. ' C· I
, .;.1·
~ :; le-~: <ir-~r,:~ i.
J· ~ ] ~ 1E1· [ e..·fr ~-:- '°~ t. ~ 1t ~
- t' t ~ t,• f-' - pi .~· ':
t. t' I
~ G: ", _. 1· 'r- 1\ r ; .f. ,
J::; I •
¢ , c, b r e-· 1 - u~ r [?;
~ ~ - ~ I!. .[." r·
l. ~I~ ¥.
t ·h..l· ; t ~v ~· f ra ·l!c, ~ ~d)-
,C ~1 ·[ L• ' 0° 6
,~ ~ • t,•
}- ·~ I ~- l, -~ c:.. ::,
L Ct ~ cf. 0
~f. ~ { ~~ ~
c, I ·~ [ tl !:; • ,;;__ 1!, I:: . t' r .c <t i.:;- n -. ~ ~ ,c-f. t' v ~ c, ~--
-
t ·~ - ,;r 1 I l, - I ::,
- ""1~ . ~
t I - 1V\ I .
tC tC . [ tt- ::-:
-· nm-i.
~ - -·
ti ·_ '& £; c·· ,. .
J
·t. c,. : ~ a '- f: g ~: t ·i - ~
f·s f~}~ ~· ~ 't"· .r ,t: I:E .~, ~c, . ~t·~ rt>""
I i- p,.· o
r') ]· • •
1 ~ ct
V\ ~: .r; l I EL • _l: \ ~ · .t·
e-· c..b s-·&
~ tX ,E• r 1' C ~ f O
o.. t, ,I!.,.. ' ' '
• I I~ - , - I I I
~
1 ~
~tC° ~
,. •
<t
J,£'~.1 r.et~~ ',c~'( •(;Jt •~·[i 1-f;-E,.).-t' !t~ [t-, f'~ ·r· 1
l t>"°
lt' t, ~ ~ ~ C· tt' [• ~- ·t .~ { ht· f.. t' ~- ~.
r. " C7 l, l,
E . l>- -~ 1t E· ·~I:: ~
'° ..r r ~ r
- 'E: t; . .. ' " ~ ~ t f"' - ... V\ f J~- ~", .c IA
-1 ~:
~ ·~ ~- t 1 6r;-
[r ~· { (• (
I .~ ~ l· .e
t
l t· t· er
~ ~: ~: f~· :· E ~ t' £ E ~ ~
f. 't· [ '~ ·t· ", r.., ~ f:7 ~· {:' ~ i · <e: <j.c
t, [•
~
~ 'c' ~ - .,'.·
~· g. i r· .r .f b f t·· ·~. 117:'·.·'.
-:
I~ t- Yl,, le- C• •l,. ~ . . , . !
~ -1I ,t
~~ ~•s:: ·r ~
( ft 6~ ~ ~ ~~ [r~ ~[r ft' t;.1 r t· ~e-· f;. ~ ~( I' I~ (}t
~ l, I::~~~~~ -0I t>L,: - [• ~- ~ .- • :,t
1'
E l c.. ~ t 'L v- ~ 1. r. --= 1:. £ -i ~ t .i>· t ~ t: ·: ;. g
~ Cl) c... ~ ,._
C· fl.. .[ <:i . Er t,.• ' • -h ~-"'·;·'
0
~,. r' l g" - t• t ~ ~,. ~ fu t
g c ft f" - ·f: C·. Cf C• [ r ;
Jfl 1lf.tf i· ~ ~ ~ 1- t
1; :~ ~ ~ ~ f I!, - L. -~ ~ '.'· - , ~ '° '° ,C" r. ~ 'h1/\- b - ,C- · -
~~I ~L~/il ~ ulS'..,_.!JI c.ill:i u l s ~ 0-4 ~~I ~~1 ~~ .isJ ,o~l
~~~I ~ l ~..)~I cu:.Lu.o ulS'~ u ~ ~J.>,lll ~ LAl . (Moses et al., 2005)
~ 1 ~~1 u~~~ a.!·ss/!)I ~ I ~?JI u4dJI ~_;gi <i'11 ~~I
rY· •r ~Jr'O..O..t 0-40~1 J ~ J .(Hole, Winther,andStraume,2001)
~~I ~ l ~ I YJ~I ~ ~ ..)\8 ·~·i,u'il ~ <i'11 ~~I ~ l u ~ I
cu:.Lu.o ul.S'~ 0-4 ~LA~..)~~ <i'11J <t>randomized controlled trials
<i'11 OJ~I YJ~l 0-4 rr 0-4 ,A~ .l..ull l.jA .ll.) ~_,ll .)j)A ~J .~..)~I
~ ,
~ UJ..) ~..)~I ulS'~ Ji! 0-4 ~LA d.A~J.A r' 0.. 0.. 0.. rk ~ ~ ..)18 ,~,i 11'il ~ I
. (Patsopoulos, Ioannidis, and Analatos, 2006)
~~ ,~~I ~~~I J.,J4l ~ ~.l~I ~Lu.o ulS'~ o ~ ~4,. ~1

o.>tfi ~ ~.)..l.;> ~..)_jj ulS'..,_.!JI Ji! 0-4 d..A~J.11 ~~I ul FY ~I~ a.bl
~~l ..LSJ ·.;,>-i . ) ~ ~l 0-4 d..A~J.11 ~~~4 a,j.)'-4A ~4::1 ~~ ~1
rkJ rr • •r rk 0::' u ~ a..-lJ.l , v ~I.JA ¥~qualitative research c.r-_iJ
ulS'~ ~L:.J ul ~i ,\LU~~ ~ j ~ ~IJ.l .l..?.J ~ ,o~l "~ Y• •"\
.(Sismondo, 2008) _psi ~4::1 ~~ ~1 a ot;.,iio wfa. .l_jj rJ ~..)~I ~Lu.o
u\icili~o u~1J.l ~ uJl...4i ~.:UI ~_,JI c..:,--lc. '":"'-.... 11,i; ~ I ~J..) ui ~
~ ~ antipsychotic uLA.:ill o..)~1 ~\:ill ~ I ~..)i ~_iJ ~
~
~l.;JI ~~1 Ji! 0-4 F l ~1J~, ~ "~ ~ J~l ~1J~1 0 t ~ ~
-
J~0-4~~~11.jAa~u~ ..LSJ .(Heres et al., 2006) L..u1J..ill
~ I u ~ I J)L.;. 0-4 \LU~~ ~J clinical trails ~~I YJ~I
Ll~I u~..)~IJ (Yank, Rennie, and Bero, 2007) <0 >meta-analyses
. <1 )pharmacoeconomics
~~ .a =:=.!iiJI c.ill:i F...,:tl LI.ll~l ~ <i'11 ul.;.: 11,ciiJI 0-4 ..)JJ:. ~L...i.A
ulS'J .a,j_;\•.a.1.1 ~..)~I~~~~ L..u1J~I ~ <i'11 uL:.~I c,.jLS' u'iWI
~1J.l~ LA.A ~1.;JI ~~4 <->'°L.;.Jl ~ ~i uL:.~ "jlb:.1 ~ ~.:UI ~IJ..l.....Jl
Jl.;o-1 ~ '~.»-i ullJl ~J .(Rochon et al., 1994) 4.:lw_;si (\.jf ~ ~~1
i.:.,LAl,.,;.i , ,'ii ui ~ .(Johansen and Gotzsche, 1999) ~..LIA ~ J ~~ ~IJ.l
~IJ~l ufi.: LA~ ~jl~l ~ <i'11 uL.u.;1~1 ~i ,J.,~I ~ LA uL.u.;1~ o..l:lj.:al
i__#ul .~~~IJy-,~lS.»-i~Jr..l4i,(Dembner,2002)J~I~
~~~~~-~~ ........,.,.,- - - " " ' " " ~....~--==--.or. C I O G o ' " ~..... -.,.,,._-;v71..._.Al'.,,~~--.""'l!"r-·.-,._...,___,.~-
YW ~~ 41d ~ ~~, Lo_, o..bJ ,~u : u ~ 1 ~ ~l.wwil!., 4..1~1
~l:i.Jl~I
r=-;r·.· . ·.... ··· . ..r.:......._, . ,·. - ~ ' ; ; \ · .·. ~ J : : : / . J~=:= -+·= . . .r- .... -~ ::::·· ~ -.. · ·.. ,._, .···.·,· i-.... /-; . . . . · , , ; ..... ,···;_~· .• :·.·.(. 1· .. , ... ,. ~· .. '. .... ·.·:_.l~/.lJ
Y'J ~ J ~~ '-&J ,«~i» Y.J~ \+,i ~ '-s:Jl .)~ <i'1' Y.J~I "~ 0---A
~ ' ~ J w-4 i~~ ~,J...ul ~ ~..l-&:' F' rt.J;.i
"'' ~ uJJ~ ~4b~' ~
ADVANTAGE~i d..:t~c.j\S'c.:.u...?.'i <i'11 ~~I y.;~l_;oi 0-4 .o.)b...11
Vioxx ~~ .;~ r l ~ I t="-7" ,~,il Merck ~>=-4 as'~ l&:i Cc.All a.........ul.;.l ~J
.J-l-l~IJ ~.;\-~IJ ~l...ul w~l..,.11 ~ ~Ll:t .cv>(rofecoxib ·.c.! 11,<HJ.;)
:cGl:, Dj)\.AJJ J:.A ~Ji '~.>=-4 as'~ ~JZJI w:oJ_J,£llJ
• -
~_j-AJJ,J
-~~ as~~"'"'_,........,~~()A~
~
'.:.~--:tl.!J
a..~ - ....-:11~ i....
~
a.,.--:q ~ f o - l-
~~1., ~1 ~w4tJI &4 JS' r::4 l.!.l.>=A as~ JJ~I ~ J.ow JAJ
~ •...-:q 4-LLJ::JI I.!.!
- ~ -·
as a. ~ t ~ .~
~ 'J-'-"
· -~-~tiJ ~ ..... -111..!ll~.~"LA.J•
t.t_-:tlJc:-;---
~~j.J.I ~l_;J.I ~ ~~t_, ~4}1 ~4Jo~IJ ~.;L!..1.1 ~ L ~
.(Hill et al., 2008. p. 251)
· 4-J- La.,• o'.) ~ cLl...u:.

,, "
~1..,,
~ .• ..r'I ~-0 - 4 - ~ - • 4-J:J .) ~ I .) Lu;.
t,... ~ LlJ• Ll..La.A . I~-
.i.ill~ r~ w-4 ~.)~' ..ill:i ~w J:~ ~ ~ a.t~ ~LiA u~ ~ ~~
wL:.~ ~ ~~I w ~ ui ~ ~IJ...ul <.JJo)i.: <.J:.:UI ~..,.11 ~.lJ~ <.)SJJ
~ ~ o~I wl/1_,JI ~ .d.4J~ ~ ~1 ~~ ~ ~J-'-" ~..,.110-4 ~.?i
~~4 a..b..u..>A ~J~ ~ J ~ I ~ o.J:~ ~-li o ~ J< 0-4 J.>.IJ ~IJ-l
~, I.J..i< ~J .(Lasser et al., 2002) o_)ol:t:.A «.·: ,er! ~IJ...ul ~ ..>:~ w:o~ Ji
U\.w y~~ wlj,L-'-" ~ o~ J~ oj4t:ll ~.l~I 0-4 ~ ) ~1 a:;)C; ~..,. •.,
. (Lexchin, 2009) ~~4
~ lA o~I J~ cGi ~.l~I wl<~ ~ 0-4 a.u.~1 J.i~I w ~ ~

wb::u.111.!.l.l::J
. · ~~
U"' Lill ~ · L ~ ~~IJ 4.l:J.l)U '-T'"..LJ.I
· ..)-Ll- lA~ - .. . --~'I
. ~_,_........
wl~I ~ . Vioxx ~~ ~IJ.l d..J~ ~ i 0---AJ .(Friedman et al., 1999)
<.JlS'J ~IJ...ul W~J ~ u~ r. ~ '~..).A~' J~I ~ ~IJ...ul ~l.,::J ~ '
~tJI ~ I W:0~ Ul.LtA _)ol.;J. ¥~1 a.lb.. t ·, · • ·J AA,·•• <J:-:1 lA ~LiA
~ I .l.J..t.ll ~ ,i.illj< . (Graham et al., 2005) 1.t i ~! ~ J o~J J ~
~ <i"1' w~I ~J , ~ w ~ ~1 w~I "~ 1_,JJlzi <.J:.:UI ~ ~ ) U
.o~
...< ~
-
. '-l:t:.A .)J..H
J--
. _'\ .J-l:.tu u. i
Jb...~
.. ~..,., ·&- ~. ··-,.----,,v_·-;,,..~.'1V,,·=--.n,.r,;"" \, ,_. .....,,.,--~·- ~ ~ - ' ' ~ - ·.-. - .... . _ .....y ... .,__,.· - ·%-.........."'!...•..; ~"'""'ii ...~ ~ W Y " - ' ' 7 1 J ; .... ~---::all'J't""--C.,!U\'\,~
lfj~ Lla.9 ~ ~.:ill Lo..9 ~~ ,~u : u ~ I ~ ~l.""'4llj 4.4.J~I YVA

~ } i i ~ wlS'~ ~lji ~ ~ ~ ~ wL.ul.)..) ":?i l.!Jl.i.A ~~ ~
w~Jb~~bw~b..l.!Jl.i.A~J .L)l.uJI ~~L.>~~..))lj~lt-4
0-4 ~ I ~i 0-4 Js~I ~ w~WI ~ ~ L)luJI wLA~ wlS'~I ~~
.~.)~I ...dl:i ~ rl:i) ~ ~b.UJ ~.)~I L>L.i, 0~ c....9J~I
Halcion (triazolam) r'}!Ji:1~ 0~1A ~I~~~ ui4 r' \\• rk ~

~IJ LA~J • Upjohn ~ i as~ ~ I ~kyl w ~ ~410---4 1.r •
,.5y,. i ~ 1..J-C iJ ~ I J ~ I..ullJ o_;.S'I .JJ I ~ ~..>-4 0~1A .J laJ:. 0 L:i y...;~ as'~ I
i~,- .~. ~· - ~ u· bi» ·, am~ 1~.)-""~
.. u.. .~~ :. • as.'..)--"""
_:._ti ~.wa:;~ ~ b ,a..u,jb..
.. . . ~-
0~1A wiJ '-="'"'-"Ll..o ~..u ":?.JJI ~I 0i ~ ~ ~I..G ~ J .~_;-I.I ~ J;g
~
w,11 o.J~?JI ~ ) « ~ I ~ c.i'-1' ~jtl.J -ldJ r--';.; "'.! LA~ JwJ <)Ai .JlaJ:.
u\!i.iiJI y ~ JJ~ ~J .(Abrahman and Sheppard, 1999, p.110 :~ <.LtJj
Food and Drug Administration (FDA) ~IJ..l...JIJ ~I.L.i.11 ~ 4-! ~ll ":?Lll
u·bja.5'
. . '..)--""" - !.) a-.u1.)..)l.!.!LlA u·P~-Atl~
..: . .-t ~ "'-':tt" :J i ...1..a..l . ~ ~ .~
L • •ti
c'"° .r
«~Ll..o~fa.ww~I I c.1i1oi~ l,._..)i.g ~ ) ) , .. •i41oi~IJ..1ll L~L)~
0 ~ 0.,=i~I ~_;.S'j c.i'-11 l.!:J..)\~I ~41~ r~ (0~i as'~) ~k..)I)) 0iJ
~i.5y,.~I tll.J~IJc.!:J..)\~1~410i , ~ I ~ -~-~~~1..J-Ci
,,
~IJ..lllJ ~I.J.ill ~y~.)-4"'-"IJ .«Lt-,~ 1.'r• a: «ui:y_;-a:-JI ~ ·.·: '".'.J.!;;;
~1J..u1 r l ~ ~ ~1_,.1.1 ~ J ~ I ~Jb.. (0~i) ":?i as~, 0i» ~ j i ~
,.5J.l.l ~ 41.AIJ;.i ,ul o.).,_b.;.. w,1! ~ a.bi ~ji 0-4 ~..,JI~ ~ I ,.5J.l.l ~
:~ <.Ltlj w,-ll o.J~?JI ~) ,,~I ~Llll <JA ~ t_\.g..ll\ ~ '}[ <.Ltlj 0iJ ,J.,_,.bJI
.(Abrahman and Sheppard, 1999, p. 109
c.i'-1' Wyeth ~IJ as~ w~~ ".J~ (A);;.;-AL12JI "~ w~ ~l:'JI Jl:i.l.lJ
w.)~i . Redux (dexfenfluramine) ~J..J..i_.; ~ I ~l_;si ~ t_\.g..ll\ c.::i....JJb..
°'. •0-4 Y.J~ ~ ~ ~ c....9J---'-" ~J..J..i_.; .)l..aJ:. w ~ 0i w,-ll ~~I c.:JF4
~ ~i ~ ~IJ..UIJ ~I.J.ill ~~i ~ ..isJ \\Ark ~~...)-Ai .)~J..)L)~ ·r'
:.- ~,1 a..ul.ua.JI
c.::rti.. ~~ ... ·~ t\ u. Llu. ..>-'~
~,J ..ul .) oL. ~ I c.:J..)Iy-w · · :~, LA a$'1.)-""~
:. :1-: Jb..
~I.J.ill ~
.. <.::r ..>-'~ '1 ·.
... ~- ~
:~q c:\..o. • • .. ~Lg
" ,«o.~
·'-.:. 1 .:j 1.... ~ » a..u_jb,. • I
~ 1,7'- . . . . ~~
i
~ ~~ o.)_,.b.;JI ~»y_.;l.a:'JI JL.u.J! ~ '~J • LA~~ - a ,uQ> J)l;. ~IJ..lllJ
LJA.PS'i ~,j-C,~\ ,-,iQ toi \j1 ,<.LtJj w,-ll ;(g~l •~ 1.;?.)J..) ~ l(~i I C.!icoi
1>.~n,-...1,~~;e,-,...,:,t. .,... _ __,,..,..,- -.~<('....,._ ... -., -•,"=',,;,.-;,,.~,.. -.o•: .. ~• ,.,»,.:·HA'· 1~.":"..-:.~.~ . •~ , . , , . , ...,-r.-,t.,......-....,._~.~..,..:o,c-~~~-··•r .,',1{<·"'""•7~·--·..,.,,w •.~ .... ,..,.••,...-.--·~ 1-~,j>. r,L'<";.~~-..•r,,,•·
YV'\ l.fj~ ~ ~ '=?~, LAJ o...L>J fall : u ~ I ~ .:i~IJ 44.)~I

-.>J~ ~1_,..u1_, ~1.J.iJI a~.:"' ~IJ-4 ~ ..)~ ~_,t Jfi.lll c.:,~ .J>.IJ ~4,. ~~
primary pulmonary hypertension ~~..,JI r.J....11 ~ ~J-LA ~l.iA c.:,lS' ..L..-41
rJ ~ ~ 4d~ ~J_c.J~.>J_;la:tll ~lS' ,I~ -~JJ.J_; ~1_,..u ~4,. ~~
I~ c.:,~ J,J_;la:tll c.:,~ I~ ~ I r ~ ~1_,..ul ~ ~~I ~ I ~J>AA ~
a..uiuJI ~ 1j ..ul .) \jL ~ 1 as.~
MO 0
-~-'I _}-J_) la:tl (..):-""-'
, -'--: ~. A'!.i . 4d!j-1,A
- ~· ~·w1 .)-!:J:.w1
0
~1 r~~1.., ~..,t ~~..,JI r..ul .b ;.:.,~J.>J->la:tll c.!.lti~ 1~ c.:,i

c_,k ,iill~ ~1 ~~1 . ~.J>. a.; ,:.,;<JI o ~ I at< Ml c.J.A ~ I ~i c.J.A ~\:;
a~WI ..)..u::. ~b ~ ..w ,t5~..,.JI r..ul ~ ~J.J>. u~~I ~.J-LA c.J.----A ~..,JI
I~ c.:,~ ~.JJ~l .>J_;\..a:tll, a,:i,oil I~ ~1_,...L..J1_, ~t.J.iJI ~ 1+-, ~~I ~ I
M -
~': · A'I cLlti ~ a.6..~ ~ · '-- 1 A··L.!u '- -1.-:,1 - ... t ~ ,,~i» 1 A··t ,... · •'I
~ • ~ "-8-' • ~ :J"'"' ~ ~- -· • "-8-' c.:r- ~~
.(Mundy, 2001)
~ ~)4-. as~ c.:,i (Lurie and Wolfe, 2005) wJ_,_, ~.;.,J JL.c:ul i.ill.JS
~IJ..) 4..4~ c.:,~ ~1_,..u1_, ~1.:w1 ~ ~ c.:.J_,6. GlaxoSmithKline ~)lS'
~ . Serevent (salmeterol) J~L.u ,-. i.:".>:!-'-" ~ I J,Jyl [)W J~I j.Jjlo
~..>-4 y ,csoiit\ .)~~ ~ U~j ~ o..)l:0 u~W.:...IJ;i ~-'r'C\C\"\ r~
~~ y).~~ c.).A ~~ ~ J ~IJ..) ,-.;Q ,:,; YJ~ ~ as~I ai~ ,~l..9..ul I.J+.i
--
uw~I as~I ,-,qi .,, l.A~..9 -~.,JI I~ LIJ..u ~Y.---'-"i "<Ao~ o.;b.: ,cslt
LIJ..ul o~ ~ ~ ~ al.A_,l.a..o ~ c.:,lS' ~1_,..ul..9 ~l.:WI ~~~'-&,al
~~ c.:,i C.:,J..) ~)UI ~l~~I ~ al.A_,l.a..o ~J ,kY.---'-"t "<A ~lS' <?I
.>J~I ~ uw~I c.J.A ~_,.;JI~~ ~J Jfg ..J..aJ . ~ I o.J..&:i ~1..9..ul_, ~I.Lill
i.ill~ c.:,i ~ I c.J.AJ Serevent ~.>:!-'-" [>L:. r'~4 ~.;J.1.J-A~l .;,b.:,JI c.J.A
~ ~1_,..ul..9 ~1.J.iJI ~ ~_, ~J-4J ~~I_, ~1..9..ul c.:,~ ~~I J:~I ~ i
.-~;tL \.;JI ~ ~--~
-=·-"I
JJ-Hi ~~Merck ~.>:!A as->1u ~~ <?' ~l..ul aw~I a~l si..r.P"i
a~.,Jlt~~o~o..)l:) Vioxx~J:~~1_,..u~~~ ~~r"<· • \ r~
~ LA~ iill~J ,<'>placebo a. . . .ld.-411 ~ ~~I a u ~ I l.,J..9Lu ~ Ll.;'-4A
Alzheimer <1..>-4=l.&jJI» ~~I ~..>-4 ~ ~...>--YJ~ ~ ~t..9..ul rlJ;.; crrl
~'=-A'a~·'L~la)LkuJlc.!.lti
~ M,,., O M
- ... t» -~~~~! ~ ..u ~
f= .J.....4i ~~- M
· ~I J i
~J;.j scrl ,i.!lJ~ c.).A -~~ .<1'-:-'-'-"Lll.\ ci.,JI ~ 4.AWJ ~ ~ rJJ ~l..9..Ulj ~\.:WI
~ J=6,.:i ~ r "< • ·' ~J: ~ ~ ~1_,..ul..9 ~1.J.iJI ~ c.:....J....u ~I ul.A.,WI
_.~~ ~ ~- =~ ......,=---llill,'W'".~~
,_,,:;,& _ _ _ _ _ _ _
lfj~ 4LL9 ~ ':f~I Lo.9 o~ faU :uwl=a.al ~ l~IJ 4.w~I

lA~ r't'· ·, r ~ ~ J ~ ~ » J .ols_,!J..,.Jo~ ~i.).,.,Jo <J-4 ~ ' ~1 \.Pf
teu
\. '='"-:ti -· u· ~. L)L_JL. ~ ~ l ~1J ...ulJ ~lliJI ai.LA
"" L)l_JI u~l..u - u '..) l3i
«.·· .S:.:a»J a.kW!~ ~~I u~~I ~bj w~cl.>:!-4 as'~ ~4,.l ,\sq.:' 11,;
~Jb c4 ..b,. ~ i ~1 ~l_,:u a '.:~·o ~~ uls~I u ~ i rofecoxib
.((chance fluctuations (Psaty and Kronmal, 2008, p. 1815) d'.i~~I
a~tf ~l.4.1l'lt~t
<).4 o~ ~J..L! ~4-b~I ~1 ~4JI ~~t <J-4 ~ I u'---4.,WI ~
,~L..,~I ~~~I ~4Jo~I t~ ~ lA~ ~ . ~ I u ~ I ~~I J)l;.
Jqi ,11JI ~I~ wJ·qi 11,.ui ~tJ.J-110~ u~l->-1,1 w J ~ ~~
LWI ~~I C:p4J.I 0.'"4-';..; "'.! Ji Continuing Medical Education (CME)
~~ ,~IJ...ul ~ ~ I L....ilJ...uls -~~I ~ I .,-A~ LAJ~ ~IJ
<::r.~l~LJ L&l0~0i~,~~bul~a .:qlc ~~~ci'1ld_l:;
. ~ . c.r ~'='"""
~)l.:,..jL .: a..b..o • u :. · -:t\ ('·)VIGOR .)~ls J6.. c.r· .ul....u.1.1
-· c.:r-~
,... · · .<
L)Lu. oJ.:!.A J ~ ~~JI u.Jl.i.A wlS' New England Journal of Medicine ~
~.:UI JA~I u4l,:tl)U oJ~I ~~I ~J~4 a:sJLA.o Vioxx ~J:ls ~IJ...u LALA
~4-b~I ~ ~.JjiJ Jl.a.J.I (J-4 a.;.. 111°' '\ •• ' ••• ~,~ cl.>:4 as'~ rl.jg ~l 1.Pi
. (Smith, 2006)
i ..L4l .o'..)y--w-
..~.~ti uluJ~I. t.:::" · ..< •<:.·-:·--:ti I.~.;;\ tl a.b~I :.-
~ -· ' J~
:...~ J~~~.) <.:T' ~
'='"-:t\
"" ~~b.l.JI ..J..>,tJJ
· - 1lo(:f:• ·...u ~ I
~~
· ·J J J~- cl.J~ J~I ulS'~:.u· i ~ IJ
· ~b.l.JI ~:.u
(Melander et al., 2003) 0__v.;..iJ J~~ wJll .oJ~ ~ ulJ~ ~ ~
l)~~} ~b~_; <).l_;ji..):--'-U d.....t_JJj ~ Y J ~ b ~ ~ ~
a~.:& \sq.:\.,;~ uL.ulJ.l.11 .,~ 0-4 ~ c4 serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRs)
FJi .Swedish regulatory authority (Melander et al., 2003) ~..u~I ~ I
. _'\ o·~< · LA~~
' : '..)-'-"-!
••• t a..u6ul
:. · - cl.J~ J~I o~ -· ••
· .,~~ -:ti uL.i.ulJ ...ul u· i u.,-.y.
ul~:.t3 ~'='""" · · :.w I
c.:JA.6..:i~
•
.cl.JLA • ~bju-
:;-I~~~
.t!..j -:t\ul....u'. ) l...uLa:s
~ '='""" . '. ) l..a..A~~ul
- :..
.)J-'-"-'A
~ uJLlifJ u ~ I c4 JAL.t:tll ~ at;,..; .....11.1 ~b.l.JI ~ I ulJ~I 0-41.#
1.1_-:tl.J a ;\.;JI ~ .~<~t
. <"~er
·p protocol analyses '--J
. '..) b:ill
. c.:r'\ill ~ . J - J""- ~
~tu.1.1
~ ~ J!~I ~ ~ <).l_;~ ~ Ll.;J t Y J,..oi 0-4 LIJJ n ~L.u ~
YA\
~~ ;;.r.P""~I ~ I u~J ~J . ~ ulJ~ ~ ~ uL.ulJ.l «!.>>l!i ~L.uJ
(Huston and Moher, 1996) ~-"4J u~J-AJ (' \A\) G0zsche ~j~ ~..u
a;,-"4.;-&JI .H):. u b ~ ~ I YJ~I 0 ~ ~ I ulj_~I ui IJ~J 0:.:.UI
risperidone 0JJ.J~..J ;.IJ.lJ non-steroidal anti-inflammatories ul...:il&=J)U
.0>4 0,A ~ j ~ ~ ~j '.«.!°l):J4
~ ~J.ill a .!~ ....-+11 ~ I ~Jl.:9 oJ:...u=. u ~ .-.;/;i ,~~I ;;~1 ~ J

J ~ ~ ~jj <i'1' ~blll ~~I ~I~ \8<1.!' ,cc;~ <i'14 ;.IJ.JJIJ ;.l.:WI
~ a........u.lJ.l Vt ~t ~ .(Melander et al., 2008) c.illj~~jjJ u»>-iJ
0-4 a........u.,J..) rv ~ ~ ,ylzo)U ..)~ ;.IJ..) '.,,-:> ~ j ;.IJ..Ulj ;.l.:WI ~ ~..L.J
,
a........u.lJ.l ~ f1 LJ? ~ ~ I ~ ~ I <i'1'J 'Y:'~f'I ~blll ulj ul.....&..ulJ..ul
~ . (Turner et al., 2008, p. 252) 'Y:'~}'1 ~blll ulj ul.....&..ulJ..ul c.ill:i 0-4 0...1>,IJ
~LlA·f.At~~4.4J-'-• 1A~----~~-< -~-A4ta.u.L.u ~~ulja........u.,..),, :.• -
u ~ ~~ ~ ~J -· ~ J _)---J-'J,J f"
;l.\t J d...ubuf ~~ ~LlA · i · A,~.,;; - -~-~,, 4...i..4WI ul.u.l}\J ~ .d...ubuf ~~
-· ·- ~ u ~ '.).,...-.-- - -· ~ -· ·- ~
~~ ;.IJ.JJIJ ;.l.:WI ~ u ~ ~ '~Jl414J . ~jl?-1 ~ <i'11 YJ~I c:>-4
~ I ~ ~La:w~I "~ JI~ J1.a.1l ~IJ (Turner et al., 2008). ;t.o, J 'Y:'~1
;.IJ.l~~~l~;;J~lyJ~l~~~l~~bui~J,A~I
;.l.:WI ~-
A.,, u ~ Llii '-7""'
,~~ ~,, a.i~,
~--'I
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ;1.rr ; t . . ~ -
C"":':
..('j · IS
~~ u
~i ~ ~ I u4..)~I 0J~ 0:.:.UI ;.4b}U ~.)~I J ~ c.illj ~ .;.IJ..L.JIJ
~~ ~~!~~l._g..>-""° Wyeth~IJ~~cJJ6.. ~J .~i~wulj
;.lc...)~4 (venlafaxine ~~~) effexor J ~ l ;.IJ..) ~ ~i.!:' ,,, ~IJ.l
ufij ,c.illj ~! a_g~l .J~ .H):. ;.IJ..ul 0L:> ~I~ ~I 0-4 ~~ «llil:! uL.ulJ.l» ~~
·<~I~~ ~~I~ ~ I ~ I ~Li....1u ;;~ J.Jj:i» ~L:> ~IJ ~~
J::iJ»Y ~~ 1.!.LJj ~ o.lJ ~ J .(Ninan, Poole, and Stiles, 2008, p.252)
~~~~,~~,~~~lnui(TurnerandTell,2008.p. 2181)
• ~t&:t 41 JJJJ Lo~ ;.Ll:i a..,1J..ul ~ ~ Jb~ .l..P."-J r...u:. ~ ~ «~~I
wL.ulJ.J.11 0~ (Turner et al., 2008) oj~jJ »..>3 '-s:l! ~jj <i'1' ~~I 01
LIJ.l ~ ·~.»-i wL.ulJ.l ~ ~ i ~ l e . ~ ~ ~KU 4i.lbtl ~}ii~
~!r"· ·, l)A;;~IJ)L;.;.IJ.JJIJ;.l.:.WI ~ 's<l.!i.u;~~ ,·u 4:,lw~a;,1:;
. <"')New Drug Application~~, ;. IJ...ul u ~~I y J4,.:i !)Arr ~..cJ rr · · Y
,R
~t,...ul..9 ~llill a~.!& ~I.JA c.)A uljl.u, ~ ~ "}11 Y.J~l l..!.lJ:j c . ) A _ # ~ rJ..9
- ~ ,R
c.)A .~~?JI ~b.al I ~ ~ · - iq•ois~w,:JI Y.J~I LAi •.)lall ~
- ,R
o.J..& c.)A ". ~ ~ rJJ ~ l..9...ul a.! ce/u,JI ~tu c.)A tr ~ rJ ~ '"\ t JI
I
statistical significance ~~?JI ~~I al)WI ~ ru ~ .a~ tr JI

~tu t ~l.J ~.q ~1J ...ul ~
'-·- 4 ..1l~ ,1..4»~:.· ~ d.J .. n JI ~tu~ ·
~ r;j.) ··<.r- -~ ~ -·'T
~ ~I · 45' .. :. ~ I\ I\ ~ll.& · lS' . 1..4» ... .. ~ ti · ·· - .:. _ ti ~b.lJI ·
.'.). LJ::I ~ • .. u J ~~~ u - ~ ()--A
~b.lJI c.)A~J.!.!•;ru ..ll..9 . ~ I ul.J~l..9 ~~I ~1..9...ul u"}/~4 ~ I

~
~ ~tu ~lS'..9 ~ I ~ I ~ ~~I ~l..9...ul u"}/1 ui ,I Y.J~ ~ I «
.(Rising, Bacchetti, and Bero, 2008) as'~I u ~ ~
\.'10§.: 0i ~ ~"'i ~ ~.llS'i ~ ~ I ~I~ ~\.Zj"}ll ~ "}I

~bJ-:.U...) ~ii~ ~.)t rlh-i ,114 ~~1 r~ c.)A ~.;,11 ~ . ~...)--'-" ~tu
Jl..a.b "'11 lS...u y~I ~W serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRs) .).)~~1
~ I J:.6::al .).!'~'.? -~.;J.I c.)A uk~l o~ i_# ~ j i ~j "}/1,~1.;J.l..9
. ~.)\JI ~ ~ ~I c.)A J:rs .)..?.J ~1;;.J~I ~ I u~.))U met-analysis
~ • .. , ~lS' . ~
• - ~ ti ~ . -~- ~'I ~· uL.ul.) ...ul a.s~1 ~ a.bWI ~LJ-'-'J
'-'-~It;;'.).,............ ..... · <t
~Ltu.u,4 ~l..4ll .)ol.=t:..ll jJ~ ~ -l...A ;;.J.,._.!J.ll..9 ;;.J~I ~ uL....u.l.J...ul ('tA.l ~
.(Whittington et al., 2004) (Fkuxetine ~ f o ) Prozac ~ljJ.>:1 [ ~
~ ~ I as'~I J;9 c.)A j£:.l.s .JI~ ~ll.& ulS' J9"'il ~ u"}JWI ~ c.:,-9..9
GlaxoSmithKline as'~ 1.-sJ..r?-i w,:JI rrt\ a.ul.J.l ~J .~I ~ ~ I ~w~I
u~i .JL.a.b"'ll~~~4(P~oxetine~..9)~)Paxil~4~1_.,..)~L..s~
. placebo a.k.Lill ~ .J~"}/1 uk..r?-LJ-4 ~~ ~ ~ 4 ~IJ.l 0i a 7=.!;;JI
~i.)A"'ll ~ ~ ~lS'a.1:.Lill~ ~~I uk~l 0i a;,o d.J~ U~JJ
uw~l~»~jtll~as'~lul...b-Jc.)A;;...b-J\,-sJ~i~~J~J .~w
~.)..9\JI ~I)~~ ~.:UI ~uu1 ~ ~ ~ ~ rrt\ cl.&.Ul.).l c.)A ~~?JI
'-:-'-'-"LUI ..HJ;. LJ-4 0i»..9 ((Neuropsychopharmacology ( ~ I ~ I ~..)"ii~
~_j-'-" l.!.U~ 0\J i_;Joj lsJ~l ~ rJ 1~1 ~Lill~ ;;.J~ ~ ~~I ~WI LJ-4
1.S...U wlS' ..141 .(Kondro and Sibbald, 2004, p. 783) cc().?J.J~I ~IJ.l ~ ~~
,R
I~ ~ J ~ 4 ~IJ-l uL..ail.J.l \.'1 ~ j i c.i'11 a.!:I ,cell ~b.lJ4 cl.+'.J-AA ~~I

. (Garland, 2004) ~b.lJI ~~Ir~ iloJ.>1u ~ 0 ~ ~ 0~ ?JI c.)A
-------------------~>;<~A,Ma._.i:x:;~-
YAY' 'i~' ~~ 4W ~
~~IJ a...,~, LoJf.!I~ 1::iu : u ~ t ~
~
s ~ , i t ":'~t
~WI [~~I ~_,ll ybS:11 ~ y a..-i.;w ..L.J~~I ~J ~
~ ~tu.JI ~bS' ~ o~l-""11 ~4JI ~ ul . ~ I ~l,j~ ~ j .!".:ill
~ I ail 4J~
~J) ~?II a..lll uJ~ "i 0:.:UI ~ ~ ) U ~b. ~~
~ ~~I ~4JI ~l.;\+o 0 t •. : '"! _,t ~J~I ~ .-, '".!J ~\' i~ -(~I
y~I ·'5F""t a 0 ~ «o~l-""11» ' 5 ~ ulo~ ~_,JI 4.;i~I LAT .o~
~~I y.;~I ~w~ ~ J ~ ( sa.!loy ~ ~~J J~.; ~ u~_,ll
~.:.. Ml Ji ~IJ..ill ~ I as'~I ~ .~1_,..ul ~ wfa. ~"i~I ~bS'J
(:4 4.;i~I ~ ~1_,.JJ . ; ~ ~ _,t ~.llS'i ~y ~ ~ 4 ~ ~.:UI
~_,JI 4.;i~I ~ ~l...:\S::,.JI oA -1:!...u.ll .l.?.J oA ~._>ll ~ .u.......JjJ.I q,jf ~L,j;..}
0 i ~1 ~ a.b~I 0 ~ (Dunbar and Tallman, 2009; Fugh - Berman, 2005)
. ~ U>fa.J a ~ ~.;WI"~
(:4~...>Al.;"iJ.l ,A•,••• ~i~ Wyeth~IJas'..,_.!,,-,,i_,r",C\C\t r"~~

~..r':"~ ~"iJ ~~~as'..,_.!, ~J Excerpta Medica lS'..1:-4 l:i~l as'..,_.!,
~J..J..J_.; ~4 ~\.,;JI ~IJ.l ~ ~~1 ~ ~~.li ~,..,,.; ,,,I ~t oA ..ill~J
~JS'~ ~"iu..o ~ a.J_,~ ~ ~~ l:i~l as~ ~\:9 .Redux
._:;\S'
. LA~t.s ~"iWI LAt . ~ . ) ~
~t L~ I(" cl.I>. - - d.,Ll.t., ~ a.JL.u
~(.)- &
•. JJfJJ - .
A A A
- ~
.;"iJ.l, , o • • t4,,o J-'"4.>A c.c.>4J as'~I ~.) ~ ~yt .;"iJ.l o, • • • aci.!o! ~ J

.~1~4·oco'=.ll ~"iWI ~ ~IJf cl4.uil ~JJ ~lj-4~"4.o~yi
u~ ~.)~1 ~jll uf ~~,.,as"..,..!,~ 6:lJJ...-uJ.l .;1.~1 oA ~->11 ~
~"iWI ~~ i__# I~~ as~, <:r'J~ ul "il ,~"iWI ~ ~L,.i.JI ~1.,11
~ ~ <itll ~1.,,-t.l ....a~ _,t ~J..J..J_.; ~IJ.l ~ ~ "i <itl' ~l.;~I .)~4
•'->F°' t ~.)i
~l JUll u-,A ~L- ~ c.'.:lJL..!.l ,Jlill ~ ~ c.::J~Ull 15..1:,,.J ~
~~ ~ ~ , ~ o.lW:J.I L_,.l~I r'~'
wl c.'.:l~JD 4..1:,,. L-,J.l
~~_,JI r..ul ..b.i.c.:::, ..,_Jo~
o.l'=>:, ~.>:! dexfenfluramine ~LoJfo ~ . )
<:?"4..1;.; a 15..u ~ I , ; . ~ .ll.l_)jfa~ ~ J .pulmonary hypertension
~ ~ , a ; . ;11~1.,as~~,.J-A~J .«~..,w1 15..L...1.1~<::~'

aL_,Joo~cl.ol~lfaWJ~lAJfo~.l.dJ.l~l~~.:Ul~.,>-1.1
. (Kauffman and Julien, 2000, p. A I)
YAt
u~ Y~ ci'1' l.,:;~ ~ t~..ill ~_,JI y ~ ~ i ~IJ as-~ u4,.3 ~
u~ ~JPrempro~...HJPremarinuJ~...Ht.jJ~~ ~~->-4tJ'iJ~
Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) ~--411 ~-"4->fll ~L....Jl as'~
. Women's Health Initiative (WHI) ol~I ~ oJ~4A~ ~J J;i ~~J
~--411 ~-'"4->fll ~WI u ~ ul ~ ~ ol,.J.I ~ oJ~4A ,-. ,...I.QJt J.41
.a c:,SJJ ,y~?JI i.J-'-" 0jJ4,.:i c.iil.,.UI '"~I ~..u ~l~IJ yWI ~~,.,_,.. ~ ~
'"~I ~~~Io.a ~..u yWI ~I~ ~l.>Ai o~l:) ~1 ~I.J;.; ,ul ,..PJ:
iJJ~ I~ ~_,JI yl...kJI ui ~ I ~\jJ u ~ i .(Writing Group, 2002)
~--411 ~-"4->fll ~WI rl.J;.; ,ul ~..u ~
- ~ UJJ r\ ~bS' ~ -~ J
~ ci'1' u 'iL..a..t. L,.a u JSJ . rr · · o rLe.J r, °' \A rL....c. D:.s Lo u ~ ci'1 'J
o~'i.,JIJ '"~' ~l..,.A'i ~->-4'il ~ts' a.! , '.!1J ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~
~~ ~ ~J t9La I ~ American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology
I.a'"~~ ~IJ as'~~ e-.oll t.j.:UI JJ..111 ~!~ ~J .uw-"4->fll rl.J;.; , ,I

.(Singer, 2009) aj~ t9~J ~ I
(Healy and Cattel, 2003)J:ilS'J~~,~~~Wlul'"l~?Jla.6..>AJ~

a..u.b.11
-·
u 1~.,....
A·- A~tl
~
..u ~~,1 a...ubll
-·
ul..oA'·"
..,.._
as'1..)--'-":. as''.) ~ ~· _j,J- U...1 ,...
- !j ~
~ a........c.u,J~ Ao -1 ~,~ ?JI ~ (CMD) Current Medical Directions a..._;,~I
ytzs')U o~~,
~~'ii~ JAJ ,(Sertraline) ~1.>i.>:!-1-" Zoloft ~_,JJj '"'J~
. Pfizer ~~ as'~ J;i ~ r: i, o t IJ selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors
..iiJ J~I u'ilS'J ~..u L,JJ-&-Ot ~jj ci'1' Fl~~~ ~.?.J ~1 ~_,JI uJLl.i
~4J .«~'i~~~.,.-»~jll'"~tulu'iW.l~~J':IIFI~~
00 JI ~J .u'iW.1 o.a~ ~ J~ Lo J:ilS'J ~ ~J , ~ I u4.~':/I ~
~ I u~jtll as-~ u~ L,J ~ - -

~~ , r 0t J~ la:k Jµ1 ~ ci'1' 'i~ --
~ ci'1' u'iW.1 r:--4 as'~I o.iA ~ c.:.S'JL.c:u ci'11 u'iW.1 a:tJ~ ~J -~~I
~~~'ii~ ~J':/1 u'iW.1 ui~ ~_,lJJ '"'J~ u~ a1;;,114 a..a..i~ LA~
WWI
-·
1. · ·- !.~
~ ( . . ; r ' . ~ .!J
· .<"j ~
ti - t~ ~,L .~ -
~ ul~ ~ u),b..o . ~ u :. · ·~<"i
- . I.?"" ~J~
u~~'il ~41 ul..:t ~ J~I ~~ ,~_,JJj '-IJ..u u'iW.1 o.iA ~ 4..4:,..Lc.:J\
·".>J~ ~ LAA ~t '"IJ..ul ~4'::!1 ~ o ~ ~J ~~ ci'1' ~ I
YAO
t'"'~'~'
.,.,,··;•.•.•;,:,···"'""",,.,..,-,.,..,,:·,..,,,.-F,;,,..,,.,,•,,.,-,.,.,..,-:c;".,.,,,""7'"•.·:cr.;,·"."···e.•.·.'···:.::·• .. )
~'-"'""~.>:Aas~~~~~~~~, ~ljJ r\J;.j cul~ .J.41

-· . - D~~.)• I~1c.:r-
a..u~} 1,.. ..LSbll ~ I J~'.¥1 ~IS :. as ~ t ~ ct..4J · t_ ·
- -· 1..)-'-" '.) • J ~
: Vioxx ~~ ~IJJ ~
~ I ~ I wlS'~ ~ uJL.ul4 Jl a1;; o ~ l.!.!.J-:!A _,.;.Jo.JA ~ ..141
~.llS'l wU:,4iJl 1.SJ~ ~J~ ~ 4 U:..~ (1_,.;.JoJ) ~ a~I ~ .llJ&.)'
.~bll c;\:i11 Jl J~':/1 Y---:.U>'11 ~ ~ j ~ Lo 4J~J . 4J ~j.o t,. . ..;.H
IJJ_,Jo~.:i.JI l.!.!.J-:!A as'~~JJ~I ~.JA~~UJw,kJµI ~ ~
~ J y ~ w,k J ~ ~ I ~ I wlS'~ 1.,b:ilJ ~ I l.!1l:i.J ~ I
u.!J~J, ~ ~j.o l~.H ~.llS'l wLI,4iJI ~J~ ~J~ ~ 4 1_,.;.JoJJ ~
l.!.!~u~~ji~~.:i.JI ~j.l.l &oJ . ~ 1 ~1_;-1.1 Jl.;Jt~~..1.-+.'
•
(.)Aj .- . )~ ~
~,.-:< - .,~·.....
f""C"" - ~~
,,t c,..•A.:il f::' ..l.4i ~_., t<'t ..i.:,..Ij I...AI~ ~':/1.~"
~ •
YJ~I w~l..a.o &o (H &o H ~l) 1.\ YI.!.!~ ulS' ~ 4+---Lal ~l..o..o \ 1 -JI
~ 1.!.!llA ulS'J ,l.!.!>.!-4 as'~ ~UI ~..LJI ~ ~ j i w ~ ci'11 ~_,_..JI
Jl l.!.!>.!-4 as'~ ~L:.J ~ ~ f-1 ci'11 ~l_;-1.1 w~L'i.A &o (VY u-o n) 1.o •
~ .,t as'~I &o ~Lo ~JU w,k ~ .w I...Alj.1.1 ulS' 1~1 Lo Fji f-1 4 t
.(Ross et al., 2008, p. 1800)
~ f1 ~LA~ i:9~ ~~J ,~_,JI ~~IL>"° ..i.a.!t ~.>:A as~~~ .J.SJ

~~ ~ [b:,1 ~i L>"° ~~J , ~ I ~ Elsevier ~ 1 as..;-!J ~ ~
~ ~a.6:.AD:. ~~~LlA·IS).Wt· __gL-.·- - ~ ~
- 'J - • ~ u J - I..>-'---'-"' j ~ ~_.)j,J ~ - 'J -
~ ~J~~~,.)~~~~>4'J.l~.J.A~ ·(~_,Jl.)_,b~
~ ~ J ~ w,ll ~ f1 ~J '~..>:-4 as~~~~~ ~IJ.li .r4~I ~IJ
.(Grant, 2009; Laidlaw, 2009) as~,~ L>"°
i~~~u~L4a8-'-"'~~~;,u~t
- a...o~I J ..L..JI. ~~IS- .:..tt u
'- i. ~ I .... ~ ~...1)-L!
~ 0.4 '"(to' • J ~ ~ -~'ll ~
~~J~l~~'.¥6..~J .a qt:,it\ab\ ,,Jl~~ljj~IJ.l~'.¥\ui ,ul
D_; b.! , ,,11 ~L>- ~1~ Y.J~ L>"° a...w a.bi .l>+i c.:,i ~IS~t ~ c.:,i d..Jj
c.:,SJJ . J.J.>.11 rlJ;.; «·)Lt J~J 0-4i ~IJ..ul c.:,i ,-,:~i randomized controlled trials
~r~~ ~'i~'i ~~~,J,,:ill ~.l~I ~I.J-:4A ~LlAc.:,~~I ~~
~IJ..ill ""'=~ J ~ I ~~1 wrll L-9~ ~I ~~I Y.J4=:ill ~ • uses off-label
I.J.A~~~~4 .ul.)'iJ..ul 0-4~)UI u~w,ll J.&.::Li~ ~ I ~4c.:,fi:;c.:,l
0-4 ~J.lc u~ ~ ~~;;~F' ti.fol ;;~t..H.;~~ a.!a:ill ;;...u.1 ufi:i lAJ.lc
-~~1 ulAl~I ~ ui u~l a.J_,L:,..J. Jlll J~l as'~I a"'"\.oo
~Ji~~~., Eli Lilly~ o-11 as'.;-iuc.:.,~ .J>.i Zyprexa ~l_r.a:lj ~IJ.l
- - -
<.S...U.I j.J_,Jo_,~~[~ ~6.. cl.Al~4r~~Jr' C\C\"\ f'~ ;;~I c.:.,~~_,JI ~
a.b.0J.I u ~ I J Schizophrenia r~t.,
bipolar I disorder [IJ-..11 yl~~
, l.:.U -~_µ1 ~~J ~ 4 ~l_r.a:lj ~IJ.l rl~I ~.J ~ ~J .u~WI "~
.~Li.A ~i ~ '-'-'.) ~.;-1.1 [>Wl ~Lat..)-:!):. rl~~, ~ ui ~
,Fl I.J.A c.:.,~ u---4 ;;~ c.:.,wJJ ~JJ u\S' ~ as-~ ui 0-4 ~>1' ~
~4b~I ~ 0-4 ~ J ~ ~ b ~ r~I_, [lj.ll yl~I u~b.. ui ~1
-
rWI ~ ~..J-Ai .;~J.l u~
-,, - ,o ·
Y.J~ - -
~~1 ll.,_, as'~I c.:.,i.; ~J . ~ I
&l:i.,J ta_,_,
,'-9..lfll l.J.A ~ J ·[)WI u ~ ~J~l 4:l.aJI ~4Jof ,-. '·==- 1~1
~ ~ r ~ ' ..>-t:C- ~1..9JJ1 c.:.,lAIJ;.; ... ~~~~as-~, c.:.,.;.,Jo ~ ,
~J~l 4:LaJI ~~i 0-4 ~..)-:!):.J general practitioners (GPs) <J:-4W1 ~L,t.b~I
c.:.,4~~l»..9 ~ I J~~I ~ ~ I ~l~)U ~l..9J.ll I ~ ui u-,-J..?'511
;;.;.J..411 ~ J ~...G.ll .).....:!S'..,:Jl..9~1 ~ y ~ ~ I ••. ~ ~ I a :•·oJI
Olanzapine 0::>IJ:,~}il ~IJ.lJ.,~ ~ ~., .l.!.11.;.l?}I rl~IJ r~~l .;I...L'"°l ~
~~I ~ » y_,l.u,~ ul.!.l~IJ~IJ [lj.ll ~ c.:.,41~1» ~i 0-4 ..1:~4
ts -
<(;;.l.J.>J.I ~~J.ll 0-4 ~~c.:.,~~IJ~l~~I J..? cYJl..a.lll J~~i~c·~~IJ
~ I J~>Ll J.,~I ~ ~ as'.;-iu c.:.,J4'-"I ~J . (Spielmans, 2009, p.17)
cl.Al~~ ~1_,JJl..9 ~1.:w1 a~.!" ~,_j-4 ~ J ~ ~~.,b '-9~10-4 ~>11 ~
c.:., Lu, l.;.l &---'-" as'~ I I.> J.l u\S' ~_.) tJ I I.J.A J ~ . r '1' •• r r ~ ~._>,il I i.ill.:.U
0-4 <.S..»-i tl~iJ Alzheimer «->-4=\AjJI» _,i '-9~1 ~_,-l ~1_,J.11 ~~ r.J.&. ~
.(Fisk, Lopatto, and Feeley, 2009) ~ I J~~I
c.:.,fai w~ ~ 0 ~ &a., .l_?._,11 J.::,J ~.,i ~ lAJ.lc_, r"· ., r~ ~.,
Zyprexa LuaS'l_r.a:lj ~,.,.) J.,~ ~ as'~I t~ ~ as'~ f-'""4 ;a~1
lAJ.lc r'1' • • C\ rL....c. J~J . (Berenson, 2006) L+.i r ~ ..)-:!):. ulAIJ ;.; ••~
~ 4lA ~ ~..J-Ai .;~J.l u-*4' , t' o ~ ~.) ~ as'~I ~I_,
>'=~~ 0.?. ~~I ~.;JI fi~,, ~..J-Ai .;~J.l 0~ o, o F. ~~ Lesly:.
~l.b.~I ~ ; ; ~ "-4.......c.&I~ \.lj~» ~ ul::i ~ ~ a s ' ~ John Lechleiter
.(Spielmans, 2009, p. 14) <•~ 4..4JL.;..J.l <.S~.l ~ ~I ~Lll
YAV~=-~- ~M=H,.,~ ··- -~·" , ~~ ~·~~.:LJI Lo_,~~ fall :~w, ~· .)~~~_;:;,
Pfizer.»:?~ as'.>1u c.:.c.d.) , ~ I I.a d.A...La..o ~ j~~ c.ill~ ~I~~., "°'1
6uJJ~' .)la.al l+a-s~ ~.J-A t.)'1.,.) u~ t, · ~)...La.A LAI~ rr · · t rw:.
,,.. ~~I
.- •JJ.J:I• .J La..c. c..r--
DU - -'I~ ..L....a.J .a..u
llil~ - ~·t:9 ~• ~~· •- · Neurontin
c.:..,41~'110-4 o.)..l=t:.A t_l~~ «¥~?Jl»c.:.,'JI u; ,o'll .J.:,..t ~.J~4 r' C\C\t rw:.
.)~ u-'1J~~ 'r'°'°'A rt&.~ t.'~'11 ;;~1>.J ~t..,:u1 ~1µ4., ~., . ~ ,
4,jf (.»:?~ as'~ 0-4 i~..?. 0 ~1 c..... :,ol c;JIJ) Park-Davis~.) l.!l.J4 as'~~
~~' c.:.,l.ol...1;.; sc,)U ~1.,..u1., ~1.:w1 a~.!4> llil_j-4 ~ J ~ ~~ ciJ ~~ '1
~.J as'.;-!JI lS..U ~ rJ ,~ ci_,JI ~J . (Lenzer, 2003, p.620) 6uJJ~ .Jla.al
-
:Boston Globe y~ ~~ ~"'" ,ot -l.dJ . J ~ I uJ.l ~t.,..ul JIJ-'""t l.!l..,J ~
~~as~1~.,LA~r'"-'trkw b ,ci~~4:!l~l~ts ....
~ as'.;Lls.JJ ,~Ll-4 d~~ ~yJJ u~ &,!.:UI ~_,T LJA ~l> ,~4b~I
~ ~WI ~_,J.I ..b-T ~I .,igJ -ciuJJ~ .;~ u~ ~ ~ ~k~I ~
1 ~ J ~ I "?~ ~IJ.JS'du.i>~~J~ ~4b~I ~'?' ,'-,i: a5~1~.l~J4
~~a..;..~4~~..Hf'~"c>'->' '"; Q<»~JUl~~l.!l.J~_,,4.;ir~~
. (Kowalczyk, 2002) ~ I ~4
~- i I . ~(" t •- •
~J DUJJ.J:I .)
la.al 'T.J,J. WI ~. l.9->_,....-w
• -. & .J.:,.. ~ J..>:
• --~" . ~ as'1..)--'-'J:. u.aJ \..J
.... tJ
~..i:; «;JI c.:.,w.,.WI .J..1..&4A ~~J -~1 ~ 4:).J~I Y.J~I ~bj ~~
: ~ I ~\:iJ w-o 4.!ll:i .»:?~ c.:.,l-.Jw

,
o.l...i.:,J.I a.!, ,/~I a~, ~ts ~fi~ ~' o ~ ~":JI y.;~I LJA 0 W ~
~ ~l!i.ll ~ ' ~ ~ J ~ ~ ' cl.J:i ~ ~ . ) ~ ' j-1~' ~
fij ~ rJ ·· · ~Y." J-t:C- ~ t j ~Y:. ~I y.;~I ~ J . •• . the protocol
'---~--·-~
~~ - -'JJ
-.,1~-'l~I ·- ~f ·-J-J l4.J·---'la.k.;...
~
~o··- 'l~LA·'·'PA'
":r' - ~
...
':,--"' --~
OJ~'YJ~~~,LJ.A~~a.! A,-Jl~I.J.!.!;;~.1.4l .~la.k.;..
~ w,-11 ~.l~ ~ ~~I ~~)'I i.P":J..ul ~ d~)b;.I ~l.ub 0 lS ~
~~I ~_>11 ~~I LJ.Ac>'~JLS..b-! LJ.AJ .Gabapentin ~4~ ~IJ.l
c.9·)l_b":JI
• ~~
1- "tj
~.) l '-'"'11-:.1..-.11 - ... to- .'-.~'14....Jl.::i.::i.JI~
~ ~ , '.),-.-.- -~. c,r~J
·1 • .:. __
~ • •.
•- (>J~ J ~
_:._.I, ·~, • I .•.f
l.)AJ .4.J~•1,j ~'°\jj "6"' 1-
~ ~
'-tj t 110 I ,.,,, •
(:1.) '-'"' '.)L.....JJJf fJJ
o~~ a?[u o~~' ~~1 ~o.;~IJ-1->~' ~ ~J~~I ~ J
.(Vedula et al., 2009., p. 1963)
d.AI~ rY· •'\ rl&. ~~.).»:?~as'~ u~ '~~, d.Al..,_i.JI 0-4 ~..,JI~

'~.)La.al "-!r~'~&~l c.·: '".'~.J-At.)'lj.l(J~ y ,, -u..14i~l
·lS~i _J-isla..c. a=i)C;J Bextra
YM
~ a.;,~WI ~ uL..u.;WI ".J.A c.:,k. ~..)~I ulS'~~ wl ~.,rll o,.o wl
~ ~I t:4.J ~I .;1...1.4.4 IJ--A '-:-'-J~ i . S ~ ~J ~ ~ "1 ul.ol..,...JI .;I..L....aA wl
~as-~~rr· ·Ar~-'rr· • • r~~ ~ ·¥1->1 1~..)~'".J.Ao,.o ~
r~ ~.., .Zyprexa L,.,.Sl~IJ.;~ ~ J:i,..JS' ~...>Al .;"1J.l w~ r1 c.:,k. Lilly
o,.o ~...>At.;"1..,..) w-*4 r , rv t4-4 c.:,k. ml.a
as-~ ~ r r · •r r~ ~ ~ t ..1>, ,..,
r~~ u ~ ·.·: '"! ~11.J.A o,.o 1.,. wlS'J Neurontin 6uJJ~I .;~ ~
I.; j .,<.:! .;'-4Al l&:,
C r~' ~ u~I ~ r.,, ..Ar~.., r.,, .. ' rw:. ~.., . ~
.(Evans, 2009) ~...>At .;"1JJ w-*4 n ,A i.S.»l ~~ ~)t:;..,
~~~' u~.,:a!,..,..:C ~u .rt ~,~,4S~ ~_,al

o,.o ~~I ~~I ul.o.,WI c.:,k. ~4Jo~I ~ '1~L..u c.ill~ ~l u~l ~
..,t Continuing Medical Education (CME) ~ I ~ I ~ I ul.J.>-4A J)l;.
ulS'~J .Clinical Guidelines ~~I uL..u.;~ ~WI u~jlll J)l;. o,.o
ul:!"1.,JI ~ ·0:!.J.A uLA.,WI ~J~ J.,J4i J~ ~~_;.::;ti ~J~I L.d. L.o
~IJ 'J qi ,ull ~ I ~ I ul.J.>-4A 0A.J.>-4A, • ·, • • • <.)A~l c.!lllA o~I
r~ ~ u I.J.>A,11 c..tl.t ~\.<:i o,.o 1.o • o,.o .;!aS'l ~..)~I ~ ~ ulS'~ 41 ~..i:s
Y • • <)A ~f Ll.;..1.:t Nature ~ I ~ c.:.r.A~ .J.41 » • (ACCME, 2009) r Y • • A
o..L.:tull ul:!"1_,11 JSJ-4 ~ ~l~J ~ ~,.., rJWI ~but~ ~WI u~jlll IJ--A
1., • JI o,.oJ cn·>«US National Guideline Clearinghouse ~ I J~.;¥J ~_,JI
o.)b...o ,-, ,11.:J 1.n c.!lllA wlS' ... ~j.ll ~~ YJ~ ~ ~Li:i ~~» ~ '
. (Taylor and Giles, 2005, p. 1070) «~J~I ~~ ulS'_A.
.)
~ - - · L:i...,• Wyeth
~_,.,..., c.)
c.ul- .., as-I.)-'-":. 1~.~..r?'" t i.r~•1 ~
- .-'I r:--
- .,.~ti ~ c.:.,.jl$'
~ ~)U L...1.4.4 ~Lo u~_,i1.J.A <.>A 0§:z, wj_,JI u<>.:a;..:ll Redux ~J..U...J as'~I
.(Elliott,2004)~1~1u~~;. ·u~J4>-~4ul~j.oJ~J~I
~IJ as'~ ul_,!,jf ,yuJI ul.o~ ~)t;b, ~J..U...J ~IJ.l Jo~.;I ~ L-4~..,
~..9-4.,rll o.JJL..u~I o.;l:u ~t:,..>-! f-""'4 0-.,s~ ~ ~)t:; <.>AL~~~
Jl..>-!1 ~~ 4} ..:.JS"..,t ~j.JIJ Visiting Important Professor Program (VIPP)
~ J~I» ~ ~w~ r~"11 ~l..A ~lS'J .~1..,..ul ~ ~~1 aJL..u.;
as-~) i.SJ.J -I.;~ ufi.: wtJ ~Lal aJL..,,..,Jt J41 ~:!b; "'.? w'J~ ,~.., ~,~1
. (Mundy, 2001, p. 123) (( ~..)~4 [)L....aJI o~..) o,.o.., a.ji~..9-4 ,~ wfi.: wt.., i(~,..,
s:-4}o~I ~~ ~ ~ ~ c.:.,IJ~J..ul ~ ~_,.J~I c.:.,I~ ..l>:~ as'~ udJ .J.SJ
~ ~ r~ ~ ~~ c.:.,~L:,.J 6uJJ~I J ~ ~ J ~ ~ 0 ~ 0-t...»-~I
.FDA (Petersen, 2003) s:-IJJ.llJ s:-1.:WI
W:J-R~JJJ) Xigris <>"~IJJ'-4...J s:-IJ..ulJ s:-1.:WI a~.:"' ~.J-"'° 'f' r · ·, rk ~

c.:.,~WI) [ ~ Eli Lilly~ ~1 as'~ ~ l ~.:.UI (drotrecogin alfa L....4Jt
~ '<>"~l.)J~ ~ as'..,_..!JI c.:.,~ oJ~J .sepsis r..ul ~.,-b ~ (o~I
as-~ ~J Belsito and Company ~~J . f.: '".!'! as-~ r r · · r rk as'..,_..!JI
~ J.,~ ~l>'--'-"1 ~ ~ o~LuJ.IJ..>-'fo LP.-i ~ c.illjJ ,4.Ak c.:.,\l~
~ ~ •.• <'-:. & ~ , - 'l'I clt.J L' ·t\
. Ll=.:..A..)J. LWI ..1.>.i •.)J b cG)\:i
~
-
(),J-.,-..~ - · - ~~
, '"tt-' ~
~ I ".J.A ~..LSJ , ~ as'..,_..!J l.dJ . Surviving Sepsis Campaign r..ul ~_,_JJ
jAL.uU ~bJJ LWI c.:.,bLliJ?Jl ..>-'foJ r..ul ~.,-b oJ~ ~_,JI i.S~ (:::9J c.)1
rr · · r rk ~~ ~ ~ 0-*1k s:-1..J+> F--1 ,~..1.fll l.J.A ~ J ·<>°>11 e:-.o
1-C\ • ~ ps-t as'...,_!JI t.:.4.J.S .J.SJ . ~ I ~.'94 ~ 4-4WI c.:., IJL&:i,J ?JI ~ ~_,.J
~ .as'~I c-4 4lA~J 4lAc.:.,\l~ ~JLlJ.I ~~ i.SJ.l ulSJ ~lS:tll ~
c.)! i.SJi LA J-AJ <>"~I.) Jl..ul ~~l-->--1ol=c..l.l u~ji ~~ J_?.J ~ p..,.ll
c.)1 oJLlil ~l t.!lLl.A ~ ~ 4(,f ~} ,s:-IJ..ul L ~ 0~ s:-IJJ.llJ s:-1.:WI ~ ~Y-.k.:i
~ ~ ~ ·r..ul ~.,-b _;,bl=.:..A .)J~ ~ c.:.,IJL&:i,J?JI ~ ~ YJ~I ".J.A
~ J c.)1 oJLli?}\ ~.Jo>- ~J <>"~I.) J~ ~ ~j..&JI oJ_,.b. 45.J.A ~ c.:.,IJLl,J?JI
Infectious Diseases Society of America ~J.L\I <>°1.J-A>LI ~.JA~I ~ I
J..r.P-t -l+i~ <?11 ~I~ c.:.,~~~I J.>.t ~ 4-4WI c.:.,IJLl,J?JI ~ ~§JI
.)J~ ~ ~w..H ~ , , ~i L>"° d.b~I ~ ~I ~_.)ji ~ ~ a s ' ~ c.:.,l~
c.:.,~_,:; ~ '"~ s:-bi r..»- '"~1 J-A ~w-->+11 ~.J.& 0\S' ..l.4l .((r..ul ~.,t .;Job
~ I ~ I J l ~ I ~~..,JI~» .a \ o·.ll 4.AWI c.:.,IJL&:i,J)/1 L>"° oJ~
... y o.:.,bill a Ia .,JI J:,lJ ui ~1 (<>"~I.) J~) ~WJ L ~ ~ y--:JI
<1~WI s:-IJJ.llJ s:-1.:WI a~.:& c.:.,IY-.J.>.:j c.)1 Ji (~i.::I 11,ll ~.._r.e:JI) c.)1 ( ~ ~)
.(Eichacker, Natanson, and Danner, 2006, p. 1642)
a~i..14.1.1..J't u~! 43'.J~

<>°~M .~,j~.... ·oic.:J~J~~~JFl~J~ut<>°~,~
• ~ J Ji ~Lb.11 ~~ ~ l&J-*9 ~ ~~ oJklJ lA~J c.:.,~~I Ji ~ I
--- .ww--« ~~~- C .._ ~~
Lfj~ ~ ~ 'i~' Lo.9 c.~ ,~u : u ~ t '="9 ~l.wallJ 4.4.J~t

1+~.);f:..:. . ' ':'""'·' . '.···-::v .,I" f:!'? . tJ,l·1-a-cf>,.· .' ·. ,·.--:.:;··.·,·.·.·· .· · .··~ith·c··-.~...-i,··r··~·..:,-:-.·,~- ·.YE:=.,_:, '~ . . . . . :::,-: -,. J· .. ·.. 7'\.'"'·" •.,···-.. ~ ~ ~ - : : : : ~ - - - . ~ ·,·.·.·.•', . /' . ·/.~ .. ·t,·i·;·~-itl
. ~ I uLA~ ~I y~'il_, "?~I u!,L.alll ~ .~.; J-A u ~ I .,~ JAY:-

~-' ~ I L>-4 ~ ~ . ? . - ~ ~ ~ I ufi:i J.d u!,L.alll L>-4 ~.?.- ~ ~_,
~.J.l . c.ill~ L>-4 i.,.._, l J-A LAJ ~Jl I ~ ~11.LU~ "?j~ .Jl ~ I r.,....WI ~
~_,Lcj i:9~ ...l:!~4 ~~ u~l aJ_,b ~ j.J_,1, ~_,l:i ~}ii~~ ulS'~
~~ ulS'~ ~ u.A 'i "?.:UI ~.,.ti~ -~l.ui!)J ~IA ..,i ~~ ~j,ll
t'-'-4 ~11.?j;; ui ~ ~l#.,L.u 0t 'il JJJhll ~...u.1 ~ L21~ ~ ~~ ~j~1
. ~ I ~ J.4.i.14 ~I~ 0:!jj~ ~~~I~ ~_,;JI L>-4
~ -~~ub~'ilu~lMerckc.!JJ-=AaS'~cJ_,6..u'iWIL>-4j~~
<i'1' (..4..... 'otl ~...1.:,,.1 ~_jjj ~~'i ~~, rl.Iolll cJ_,6.. ,ul.! i.!• jfl ~.., r'~' I ..
~ I ~ I a..b..u.lJ-:1 (aledronate ,-•.!;JJ.J.ll) Fosamax ~LAl.uiJ-! ~1_,j u~I

Norwegian Medicines Control Authority (Hemminki, Hailey, ~j~I ¥1>1
~ ~j,ll ~ c.!l.J-:A aS'~ ~ J ,~'i ~ ~-' .and Koivusalo, 1999)
~I u4,.~l_,~U£11 ~ D~ ~ JW "..>-J~ ~ 04---ui'jl a.Jj~I ...1.:,,.j
. -~ ~ .)U£1 a.....uw1
~J: .... ~~ · 1 ~1 0 1 -1-=~ 11.J 1 ~r:Lcj'i VIGOR
· -4 ~. ~ .)~ · ~ ~ ,.) j 1~ ~ -~
~'i~l lo4J~J~wlS'J .(Bosch,2004)~~.J.ll ~..,~,~ Vioxx

b~ ufi.: ui Dr Joan-Ramon LaPorte c.;r-J.;Y.'i w.JAJI.; uly,:. .;~.J.ll ~,..,
r"· ·
- ti
u~l.ui "?.:.u1.., i rlc 04---ui'jl 0:4~1 ~ . ) ~ "?~~jA ~ ~ . )

LA~_, .~_,tJI 1,41 ~WI ~~I ul~I J~ 4~ ~ Merck c.!lJ-=A aS'~
~ '.!:.i:..l>.14 ':?.;J,:1'1 .;~..ill r~' r~ c.!l.J-:A as-~ y1Jo ~.;11 ~ ~.)
.(Mathews and Martinez, 2004) ~UI ~ j '.c.."'" ...! aS'~I ~ll ,~j.11
·~J:l:g .;~ ~ I ~ 0:!.:UI ~.JA~I ~jlS'~I c.!l.J-:A aS'~ 1 1 ~ » ~
j.;~b..u 4.t.A4,. ~ ~ "?.:UI Dr Gurkirpal Singh ~ ~.;lS'Jy,:. .;~.J.ll ulS'
~J .c.!l.J-:A aS'~ ~~ ~~~ .;~ ~ ulfab:.A ("...La: Stanford University
~ aS'~I r~ rJ [>l-.11 L>lu, u~ ~~1 uLA~ aS'~I L>-4 y1b LA~
~.JA ...1.:,,.i rll ~ ' i D~ ~ .~Ll.c!JI ~.:ufab~J.>.:ii ,l.:U .uLA.,.W.I
~ .)~.J.ll ulfab ui L>-4 ~fi...ill j.;~b..u 4.t.A4'- ~ J~'i4 c.!l.J-:A as-~
•••• '~~l:g .;lal ~..,l.i..o ...l:!~4 ~.., aJ_,~ ~ d..4.ifa. c.!lJ-=A as-~~,))
~ .;~.J.ll ~~ c.ill~ .;l~I J6.. ~ cG4 c.!l.>=A aS'~ ~.JA .;~i ~
~l:i ~b..ui ~i ~~ ~ .u.;J,!l.u.u 4-tA4,. ~ ••• ~I~ c.!Jl.i.A w~J , ~ ,
~ I ~4,JI ~I~ ~I University of Minnesota l:iJ •".!;.! a 4-lA4,. L>-4 ~ - '
- - - - - " " " " " " ' - - ~ ~ ~;fUICllfa;Q':CI :t:iCP iAAZa£ ~~~.....-~~~~
1..fj~ ~ ~ ( $ ~ I Lo..9 ~~ faU : u ~ t '?'9 ~Lw..aJ~ w ~ I

("., I' ,I/("-.:: •.. , ·;·;::.:' ,.! ( 'S. ,·. ·."·./.: ,:,:,-:_..: ;;:··;._ ......::-.-... "[ ·.-·. :, .,f?· ·:··-::.; c~ ... '. ,..:·. ;,:.~~,:·_j .-..-·. ,.-·.=;: .. 'I? ( ,' ' .. -i"::·:::7 ,:··.· ·:··. ~,,;I ·+~ /' ·r ~tc ·-~ :·),'" .,fi.'• ,I/.·< .."·':·.',."."( .. ':'".,('):··:·:·;,-..'···/'/ .. T' Pi ;_ ·., !/ :·.,:· ·:', .. / !"1 t"'··. 'J ;p.u · ...-·:: ;·:.'jl :.,•v=::--:-»·,r~·Q-".",'(;":~.>/ I
o~~ a!iJb ~ a.)b .J.4111 -~.)-:!A c....a.lo_t.4 ~ w,A J~l 0~4'-J~~~.)laJ

wfi:i wl ~ , ~ ~ J ~I ~~ ~\S' .J.41 ... ~JJ \.,j~ ~ i wl ~ ":J
- -.(Math~ws and Martinez, 2004, p.1) «'J~ lA 0 ~ i.J~
.,t~,~~4Jl~a\S'~la":J_,b~ji~la":JWl~iwfi:i.igJ
~~Ji ~wJ Betty Dong ~JJ ~ a":16.. ~ 4-A)luJI l...9J~ 6~ CA:..1>JI
.J~ F <i'1' Flint Laboratories,-, ;.!Is al.; :i" c......Al:9 .Nancy Olivieri
hypothyroidism ¥.JJ.ll o.lill ~ .J~I ~..>-1 [>k-'""J Synthroid ..u~
~~I ~JWI ~1_,..ul a ~ w,k J~ I s:r=i.i.A 0 l ~jtl ~JJ o.;jAS'..ul ~~
~.:is-.,,~ 1...9~ lAJ ~JJ L..ul.)J ~ w,k ~ a l ~ ~ , . , • I ~ -
w,k a ~ ~ I ~I Boots Laboratories~~ a l ~ ~ ":J ~~ w,k ~,.,
. ~ J~ ~~-":J ~}ii~ of~~~' - ~t.s:rsl ~., . ~ a l ~
'-&.o~ ~ a l ~ r::4 ~ l.s:!..u olS' <fi.JJ , ~ I ~ w,k ~JJ :i.Jj"o..ul ~
~I :. • 1.t - •f
• ~ " + ' ~ < . J ~~
- al~ -· ~~ .awWI :.· 1.... llil·t\
-· ~c.:r- ~
.:G..L.
I..S~J r:9-H ~~ al.; :iv ~J.J.A . , ~ ~ ~ ~JJ o.JjAS'..ul ~ lA~J
oJ Jl .J~ w,k ~ a..r?-l <i'1' ~~.,t o.JjAS'..ul lAl • (Rennie, 1997) a.._;;~
0~~ ~.:UI ~..>-111..SJ.l iron-overload ..1:..1>JI ~l->3 [)l.J r ~ ~ -'""-' Ll
. ~ I ~ -~~l:9 -I~ I..S.»-";/1lt
~ c.::.i.d~ thalassemia ~I.J_,11 r..ul .;,d 6--A
~JWI ~J)U ~~ ~~ ~J ,Apotex u-4~i ~~ ~I I~~~
~L,jl ~ r~ o...u. ~ I aLl~ ~ F l ~ ~ I ,~J~I ~ J~ ~
~ I <JJ Jl .)~ 4-A~ 6~ l...9J~ ~~Ji o.Jj"o...ul u.:ib:sl lA~J . ~ I
Ls:!..u LA w,k ~I~~ ~.,,-11 ut,b":J ~6.. ~ ~t ~~J u-4Jl ~~
(J~ l.41~~u-4~i~~~ -.;~I 4.A)L.u<)~oJ::=iccs41...9J~W,..O
- -
Jb. ~ UI...L&.Q ~~l:9 al~l~l ~G::34 l,JJ.J.AJ ~ ~.;J aw~l 4-A)L....u,
. (Downie, Baird, and Thompson, 2002) )UI w,k ~.,~ ~ ~>kl
-b~ 0 Q «oii ":J I..S..,_..;..1~ a":J~ ~L..l..A ,a":JL>..11 ~ ~1 Ll~?JL:,
~ u~ ~ a ; : ,cs a u~
J~J ~ Ji L...;-e--JI (.j-£- ~~u
~ I ~..,_J~ ( .!.! ai J ~~I J .! "' ii ti«.· i< a ..1.......d .a...............JJ\JI
Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health (CCOHTA)
~ I a ~..,_J.,_;...<..JJ L.JJ)U ~J...i..<.JI a.J~_,JI 0 ~1 '4,L:. ~ <.SLllJ
0~
-
LQ.!.!;; Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health -
----------===·~-··
~ ':f
" " ~ 41d
-~~-=-=--------=-----
o...L>,j ,~u :ul.J:Ml. ~ ~~!J .:Lll LA..9
=-·
t ~.._r?Jt
~1.J->~' ~ .J~fill ~ r ~ <i'1'-' statin ~l:L.u ~.li ~~
.~LUI ~ LJA~~ ~ llil.S::lA~_,JI clJj~ ~b.J.I ~l:L.u~.lT ~ uT
.;~ u ~ I Bristol-Myers-Squibb '-:'-J~ ~LA Jju.i,J-! as'~ UA.9.; clJj ~
~I~~~~ c.S.¥-.l (Pravastatin ~l:L.ul.91.>!) Pravachol JJ-Al.91..H
.• ~Q • • · ,, ,.... • •. ~~,, :.• <...,d '-9.l,11 ~ , L:,..t.~("-: - .. ::-:t ,.,.~,
v-J.) (.)A ~j J c.;r"- J-lJ-'"' ~ ~ ~ - • 'Y~ r-=-- ~
o..U.J->~I ~J.:R.l:i~! LS.li clJj ui "l'} ,~l.a.U ~l&lll i9c.::.LJ LA~ LS_¥....UI
cG..ul· · 1.\, ~ I L:,..t.~<'-= - .. ::-:t .e~I -.: .... ~,, ~ u.lS' w '-\S' Le.
- ~(.)A --'-"'~r-=--~ ~ . u- r
.(Hemrninki, Hailey, and Koivusalo, 1999) LJ:-46:..4" yWiS ~.l ~ I
LJA Dr Anne Holbrook l.!lJ.HlJ-A ~ i o.;_,:o'..ul _,.,..Jb:!Ji "-4~ ~ . , J.)--:P"-i
. ~ I j~I ~.li ~ J->..J-4i ~~ University McMaster ~~ ~~
Losee ~_,J ~ I AstraZeneca ~_jl.>A-'-"i as'~.;~ ul ~l l.A..>-J..J-4i ~ j i
.~1_,...ult~~oAJ~JJ:s~l~ILJA~~~(OmeprazoleJJjl~)
. ·- ~-, - las'1..)--'-'J:. ~
~ - V '.>'-'-"
·~-- '-:T..,.»·ll~a.JL.u
• ,. . ~ l , A )l..>-JJ-'"'
~ c.;r"-
--~~,~ •-
i9» d_jfJ ~~I ~.l~'°l'I u~l.a.U UJ~ w~J->_;-a:ill lA~ Jb. i9 (t.j~ ~lc..l'°l'I
'-9~ ~., u~ ~~ ui ~ ~ ~~, llA LJA ~>1' ~ l.!l).J-4W'I Jb.
~i LJA ~LUI ~~WI ul~l~)'I i9 ~~I~ <i'1' ~LUI ul_,.b;JI ~
.(Shuchman, 1999, p. Al) «u~Wl '4~'°l'I ~ J ~~ ~ ~6J.I
l+LJ a.JL-.i-JI ul ~..lA l.!lJ.HlJ-A o.;.,:.S.ill L..J~ u.;~I ~~T as-~ ul ~
.(«Talking points», 2002) «_,.s..Jb:!Ji a..oµ ~~ 0T ~ 0\S' ~iJ ~4
ia..liJ-
~"l'J-:Aoli~~' .l~'°l'l~Lc.~"l' ,o.;~~~4-l.;J~
:ui Alan Maynard
a..l.l~I ;;~tg .lW} ~ ~ ~J--"'"" ~~I 0l:, 4:!.l~'JI ~ I 4z:i
.e..Lf
.,;, 4..6\.J. ":J-""'
.e--~'I ~ •.. <-: \.4...w,c.J .44..J~
(.)..,..... - • · .('f ~~ L
()A~
~l.i..o
-
•.• <-:
u..,..... ~
-
_;~'ii wl ~_,J.I IJAJ .a.J.l~I ;;~tg .l~Jl..bjtL...:il ~ j J ~ ~ I
~~I J~ ~ 4:!.l~'ilJ ~~I ~Lal IJA ; ; ~ a..l.l~I ;;~tg ~
~.,:UI IJA 01 -~.:.:ci11 d~~ ~l_p,, ~ ~ )\..o~J ~ 0~ ~J--"'""
y\..b;..J ~ I yl.b;.JI ~~ u:i~ WS' ~~.,...,_;~'ii~~ Sui wi
~I ~4J ~~~I~~ L4A~J ~ 4AWI ~~I
. (Maynard, 2001, n. p.)
f ,t' I?: [• [• ~
f. ~ £ (:-· V\ 1 ::t> t· ~ f % 1· r 1· ~ :r l·· ~ i 1° r t·
.f I f i.{'ta ~\DE\~ ry ~i t'n f£~ f
t· l= '\.. ·[· t ~ ~ E: - -g. t' 5.: g -: ~. t;. r;: ~ € ~ ~ c, l,.
~ ·~ ·~ C, c- !t- '\.. ~ t ~ f ~!
f t t £ [:;..... ~ -: t•'\,. IA
:L I
r~: . ~~ c, I f- f~ ~ ~ er t; le er il .. • -
1 ; ; l, loot (;"' ~l
~I
·~· E C- ii : 1V\ f• I I "' •~
-~~ t. ··t· ·V O l, •
~ • S- ~ - '1L . r-•~ •- ,c;~ 1
e-· ~ l, -.. -- 0 ,. - ·V N .& I I I - ....
f[ . 'ii, ~ c- ~ [• ~
cfl, f {t:il,
1,° ,c ~ ,C· [' t 'k ' 'l! le 8 ~ f£. f ~ :
t 'f\10~ ~ -II,!~- l, [,C l, [•
~
i:; l ir[f!i1~ •~ I> •
•i' •i. ~ r 1V\ ~: c;.: ~ r; ~ ~ ,f lk
.C·i.cE:gc,. ~fo
C: I ::S I
{JQI •- t• I• l.; -
I Cl) l, .. I ;
[•;
.. ' c[ ,<;.. ~
'i 1
\0 ~ [•
I~ [
l ): .~ ~ ~rE•·
::=: V\ I I ~• s- ,C- t~I
1 • ~ "fl,! 1• ~I
'f I:; ~ •E.. ~ ~ IA (I) ~· [• I ,. : ~" ,C- C·
E1 ~ 1V\ ~ r. ~. [• 1 it .,·
E•• • t>
c ,. § c_ '[
't" V\ ~ .It
c:;:l.. ft ~ ~ ~ .~' "c'. ' C·
1 t ' I'
[• (1 •i ~ 'I. I:. t•• ~ !:: t;
t I
1.-- 1
·~[~·I 1: (l, cf,. ''k l~· .~ 1:·~
''k . .: . ~ ~ ·f,'Ei '( c.' t· ~! t. ~. " ;.- £ r [r
}e § I I V\ ~. •t,. f. - r;;
~,
£' u ~: i b ~ t .c' lo"" t
-
r,
a I1
tfi(l)CT I· ' - •·i.
~
·t
;
~ ~r- [,
Ct
Fi""
~
·t'
t
l
rr it· ~ ._
-[,sL V~
r:.
(7
1:: ~ V'l· ~ J ·r.· £ -~ • ~[s fl,! I &
• I
ti --E fl,! ~kl?:
t\.'<i: -"'·t; E:. (;, iC• N f; ). • 1,• ~~ 1,° ~ l ~ l 1.o f£.
l.o
t: I,' r r-: t; ·r- f [r . l,
I
~ ~. { <t: i • V\ 00 - "C1, l, ,.
~ E t ~ t
- 't ~ t t' f; ~. ~ ~=a J:. ~.·· lb
I
r·t-:_ ~·~ -
_:
81 .r·;-
~ .. ~
'& ii; £ ~ ~ ,i;:; .f c:: c::
(JQ ~-
t ,._ ,[ b lf E -f.
~ ~ t ~ t;! ~ ~· " ~ 1r ~- . ~ t ~·
·L ::T ~
., ,p:.
g- 'r V• - G. f. ~ ~ V l l, ~ ~ ~
1[, . .1~[, t[• ~l 'J- f. ,c ':< y, ~· :, c-
~r f- ~: f; ,._ r-· ~ ~ ~ ·i. .f y v
rrg
NN-N ~ • ~ ~ 'l, t''t-:
..,c 8 8 r 8 - 1> ~~ f f ~ <r.· is:. ~. t y· le ~ r
_,
> i~[il1ti ~ ~ ~ ~i s l. <.e. ~ f ~ I:. 't L ~ ~
,~~tu~~
~ i ~ t~I IJ&'..>A [)W '-""'--~1 ~ Neurontin 6uJ.JJ:-i.ll .J~ r..,.;.; .,1 (')
:~I .a!:«oaJI IJ&'I.J-4~10-4 J..w ~~I r'i~I, ;,!,;.:...:J ~'i rhi "'.!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gabapentin
. ) ~ Bextra (valdecoxib ) (·. '! . .,<fi:!JJ~) I.J; , ,<JJ [ ~ r..1...:..; "'.! ('1')
:~I . ~1_,JJI 1,41 ~~ IJ&'l_~i J_?.y r:?.o .ii_, ~WI c.:J4\+JlS' c.:J4\+J)U
http://en.wikipedia.org/wikiNaldecoxib
~ ~j.lll ~~IJ yW~I c.:JlS'~ _;+!,i 0-4 blockbuster .;:,.,..u~ ~~ as'~ (r)
·rr ·' · r~ '-""~~ IJ&'J-LU wt~ ~y~I ;;~1 c.:J~'i.,JI
Y.J4t=:JI ~ randomized controlled trials ~~I a..;;1~1 Y.J~I (t)
t~l ~ ~ ~'~ l.A.ll~i .;~I ~ wt&&.~ ~ wfi:! <i'11 a ~ cJ.JI
~~ ~i ~~ ~~ lS..>->~I ~~lJ ~ I c.:Jlyj.l.l c.;r!J~I ~~I
-~litll d.,j.)'-4.4
.y~I 0-4 JJ~I ~I~ ((c.:J» ~.; ~~I ~~ ~ I ( o)

uo • o:o:.3 ~~ J...-..a>- pharmacoeconomics LJ~I c.:J~J~I (1)
~JaiJ ._;.>,i t:4 <r-~ Ji ~IJJ ~ d.,j.J'-4.4 ~ f'~..J ~ I c.:J~J~I
: . t!.. ·.1 .o.l..LL&A ' "='-- tL.uL i:ul :.t;
.,J- I.Joi !J • • ~ t:4 "T"IJ JJI c.:..-
-~:t I 0-4-l
· :. a.J~I
- c.:JLJ~I
-
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pharmacoeconomics
~~~ ~1Jc.:J4\+J)U .l~[~.JArofecoxib ·.·J ,.,<~J.).J~ (V)

0-4 ~~r'""" r~ 1~Lo0-4~~, ~..;~ ~~' ~,., ..1.t1., ~1.:.w1 ~
".;l~i ~ Y • • t f'~ ~ 0-4 ~)\:JI~_.;~ ~>=-4 as'~~ 0-4 J;-uJI
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rofecoxib : ~ I .yWI w,k. ".).)-'A ~ J
.~l_,JJI L ~ UL.:al c.:Jlo.,W.4 ~)\:JI .JA <<;;~Lt:JI,, ~ J ~ I (A)
~~ ..illj ~ .,t ~l_;li ~ ;;.J~ placebo a.k.WI .>t):. ~ I <.:J~~I ('\)
I.>"-
L...o.J 4...i.4WI
-
'-,J ~ ,
-~.
.
~
4\ a.b.,~I ~ .. -- _It L - ~ .
• ~~~J ~
~ t\ ~ I .J-1.l
_A
J
• ' : . ':
.~IJ ..ul J·.-.:.t

'Y-.
.:u~ J ~"-&'U~
. i .t •.•< . .ii ~~tt ~
-
I ~l·~tl
• ~
r ,.,anc:;·~...- ~»a~~~,.'t"·~~~~-x.,eaa =.w:Al'Cl•._~.,,......._ , , , , . _ . _ . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Y4\0 Lfj~ .4.1.a.9 ~ '=?.7.\ll LoJ &!,~ faU : u ~ I ~ .,)lw,,4l!J 4.4.J~I
JUa.U ~ I ~tu.ti ~1 VIGOR <IJ~ls,, ~"li9 ~ <?I .)_jA..,.11 ~ ( \ ·)
Vioxx Gastrointestinal Outcomes Research
~ I YJ~I ~1 per protocol analysis cr-1\ill ~ I r ~ ~ (, , )

a..J\ill
..
Jo~
... -~-•, ,
... 0 '! .L ~ . .:UI ~ L.!J.I
".,~: - ~~ .. '.)
,,.. L~
c.:r-- -~ as' L.!J.I
'.) ...... ~,,
~~
~W.li;..,~~a:,J~YJ4':uJ10--At_,.tll l ~ ~ J .~lyJ4:aJ
~ I J •~~ ~ ~ wfiJLlJ.I ~..,.LI F <?' treatment group
~ I ~i;..,l_,b ~ ~.:UI y~I ~ I J-A protocol~ ~\ill
~I.Ji "'~ti ~ 4S':wJ ~~, a.:,..01 J-A c.t.lJj ~ ~ •.14.11., •\so.::b; i;..,l"l~l.,
:~I .~tu.tla.j91~~~\sa.!:bio.l~1~0-J?~l"w.JI~~
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analysis_of_clinical_trials
http://www.ncbi.n1m.nih.gov/pmc/artic1es/PMC3071397
~_jll ~ New Drug Application ..1.-:~I '-IJ..L...ll d'il 4,; «:rl (' Y)
'-IJ...L.JI_, "l~I ~ ~l.>-11 _,t ~ I a.5~1 L,s.J~ 0-4 ,.. ,:~; ~ I
:~I .J~J o-,oi '-IJ..L.11 c:,tFood and Drug Administration ~.J-4~1
u=o~ l.!.l.Jj al!JtlJ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Drug_Application
v - al'-1~~'ii ~
-·~ · ~ 4:rJ
.. 0-4 . ~•1 1 ~-: t ~,1 w b::JI ~j:,\:ij as·'..;-a-,'
~ ~~ ~ -~ .
_.& ~': • -~-'I
-
. ~ ~ I J oJ~I YJ4':uJI
~ I Jl-.c:uJ~ ~.,_JI oJ .,. i JI aL:'i~I j...S_;--o ~~ {\l')

~ ~~J "4Jo~I ...uJJJ ~1 US National Guideline Clearinghouse
J~ ,.;s ~J.!ai,ccJIJ ~bb;.JI_, ~ I ~\.WI '?'4~J <J:9~1 ~ I
LA~ ~ <?I i;..,lA.,W.I ~ LA~J ~ I ~_;-JI a~..,:a.J4 ~ I
http://guideline.gov/about/index.aspx :~I . L.,Al~IJ
...,..:,wt~t
iJ~~tuL4t;t.A~ ~~ti;A ~t4' ..~4.S
1+..~ ~~~ ulS~" ..cl~~t allll:c.tt-->-'~
Mark S. SchwartzjJJt.,..:i ·'1>" ~JlA a ~•~1
iA.A..\44
..L:.i J ~ I 04 JJ~ 0i ~~~~I ~lji ~I l:!~I ~~ ~.;UA
~ ~ t ~ c.:Jl_,JI ~ ~ .JAJ , ~ I ~ ~ I o.Jo:.L1~ ~ ~ ~ i
~ 0~1 Jo..s~ ~.LJI c.:Jl_,JI ~ .~Lal ~_;.kl4 d.£.4 ~ I JAW~
~~_,!- ~ ~i ~ ~_;-aJ ~ 4i.J:.u. '5..?l ~I.Jo~ ~Li.A> ;;~...,JIJ J ~ I
jlj.:&:i~IJ ~~~IJ "4J~J a.!l ,.,iJI ~L-JJ i:?l..\.fll ~..l.4i ~ ~J ,JL...will
JJ~IJ 'r'WI JUI (.)oAl~IJ a..bL..iJI J ~ I ~J-'-"J ~J 11:>..tlJ y)l~I ;;4bJ
C
r'l~~IJ Jl_ys~I ~ J ,~~~I ~~IJ ~~I ylj>}U <i'..,:SWI ~

<'>improper use of insider information ~l..ul ~LA~ ~ L a l ~
~~~J.1.1 ~ J ~~, Y.J~J (Y)intermediaries ~Lb-.u_,JI r'\J;.i csrlJ
.(Arhamdiia, 2005 ~I) {T>tipping ~~lfi)'I ~ Ji facilitating payments
~bA ~ tl.-~I,, ~ . J ~~.:Gt~ J ~ I Wt.J_;-a3 ~Jll J.al 1~1
J~~\S)tS..?i ~l..r!'-1 ~~~~~.JS'~ (Encarta, 2009) «a.!,o~
~..r1,1 ~ 4.,lbA ~ ~~, ~J .(aggressive accounting ~l..u.11 ~WI Ji
~~ ~ J~IJ ~~I~ ;;~I ~~I tS-->-=1 ;;~I ~l~I ~_µ1
._. ~,!. 11 ... A~~ 11 ~~ ,~, .1.., 1 =-w, ,
~rJw->....,..........
& • ••,... ~~, i..ill:i u . ".J i J~ ~'
- ~ J-t,:J J ~ ~w~L
A~-
as'~J Enron 0~1 as'~~~ J\:al ~ ~) d..A~ ~ ~ I J ~~IJ

~ as'~J Hollinger ~.JA as'~J Tyco ~t; as'~J WorldCom r'\S' J_;JJ
~,.;~I as'~J Ciemens ~ as'~J Parmalat ~~LA.;4 as'~J Livent Inc
. Madoff Investment "-9JJlA
~J ~ JLwill ~ JAl.ull ~ J_,b.. ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~.:.UI c.:Jl_,JI ~

JJ~(HessandDunfee,2002,2003)JJ\:al~w,k.~l)J~~I~~~
~l <>4(¥\S'~ ~tc)-4~...,.ll c..,1:. )<1as°..,..ill¥~i~~)) J.P.-J4i.;~0~1
_,..:,Wt~I
J ul.I ~~~
1. · --· t ... · •~··I) Ll~~I
- ~.J t a..u
-~·w1 ~. ul.bLl...ill J t ..)~I c
· . )1.1~~,1
A~
.(Ferrel and Gresham, 1985; Trevino, 1986; Brass, Butterfield, and Skaggs, 1998
••. » '-8,ji ~ ~1 ~I~ a.: q.:J;, iitl ~~ ~ J o..L...:~ uLl..,_J-Li l.!.!Ll.4>
~I~...>:? ~.:UI ~~ ~I ~ I ~J as'~I ubla:i.c. ~IJ ~IJ uL.:ol~~I
~ I ~t:tll .;1~ Lot . (Trevino, and Nelson, 2007: p. 257) < ( ~ ~ ~
~ ~ .~~ J-Ai ~ <J-lY-...UIJ ~_,.I.I~~~ as'~ «~)b. ~I»~~
.(Brooks and Dunn, 2010: p. 256~1)<<'1'·-"\·-Y· »o~t:g~~l ,J\:J.1
d.:P_,:it:g cl.4.s_,.b:i ~~~ yl~I ~ ~J-'-" d.!.ol.c. ,.,sjs ~t <)A 1.Y • ,,.,s?i oJ~
~~~~...S?t:I.Y•J . ~ ~ J f ~ ~ 1 ~ _ µ 1 ~ ~ ) b . i J i
~~, ~u~,J~w, ~~, ..)~J ~ ~)Ll,..i~Jd.:P_,:it:g~ wfa. Wb
~ l.!.!JLl.:i ~ ~ d.!.oWI ...s~I <)A 1."\ • ~ Loi . ~ ~ d.:P.J:tl.1 ~~IJ
. ~ ~~ cl.1~ ~ ~ l.!JJLl.:i ~ JlJ ~)Ll,..i~J d.:P_,:it:g~ u~.,L.u
r~l lA~~ <i'1' uu~1., wl~~I Jo~J 4=.;b~I Jo~I ,Jul.I~~
~~~J..)~~w~wi~u=o~1~t:tl1 Loi ·"?i~l
<)A":a,1."\·
,1.:U .as'~ ~)Ll,..~1 ~\.ZJI Jl.bl ~ ~~JA ~ Lo~ cll~J ,yl~I j.d ~l
. ~ ~ l " : U , ~ ~ l l:U,j.:P_;J<)~
i.!ll.i.A wi ~ I 0-49~_,J.I yl&.i u~~~ ~ I ~~bJ6.. ~

as'·~ .~.It Ll)Ll,..~1 ~\.ZJI ._L-: 4.........ui..o-A~I L . ...u ~, qJ;,jqlt LJL.c. ~ i
- j-J~ - - ,-,,- ~Y- ,J - -
~ ~ .l>IJ J-->- ~~ ~ ~.:UI ~_,JI~ .J>--1JI ~~ ~ ~L,J.1_,
wi ~1,(Trevifio and Nelson, 2007: p. 257 ~I) Jw:.~1 u ~ tL.:oJt ~
oi ~ o..)~ a.:cce.:1J JAl_,c. i.!ll.i.A wt lo~ u=o~ wi t;.:bisu. ~_;-ll wf ~j.1.1 <)A
~)Ll,.. ~I ~\.ZJI .>J_,b:J ~~ ~ t ~ J ~ I ~.;-ll ..)1) 1~1 ~..)t ~ ~I~
0i ~ Un dJ..oL....j, Wt:g ~11:.u, r~ wf <)A~~ • ~ ~WIJ as'_;--ill
~~ ul.c.~ _,t 4Au.~~ a!i~ i.!ll.i.A wf ~ ~l~I r~ , u ~ I < ( ~
...S?~I ul.bLl...illJ ..)Luuu\_, ~~I <)A .J.>JI J:?,.t <)A o..)~..9-4 wfi:i wl ~ a.:· ·.:1J
~)Ll,..~I ~\.ZJI .>J_,b:i J ~ <)A cll~J , u ~ I ~ ~)Ll,..~1 ~J d.:P_,:,Ull ~
:~~)Wl~LWIJ .~~WIJas'~
I~-:~
"oft-' - J l~-:L.a,bJ)b..
"oft-' - c.)A
~ l , ·- ·a_, Ll)b.j ~• ~~ ..)i.P."J -\
• [..>-'4l ~~ -
. ~L.u}-4..4J
,.. ..
~ C.· [,
~ J. \ \ l ~. f fr 1· 1· ~ t: ~· ~; f, 1, ~; • }:. ,-. 0;:.. t f •
- U>' ::s
<i. t - - r;- f- ,c;
'f ~ .~ ,c; ~ '= ~ I , ('l) - I
.E h ~ t' t, - ~· 'c.. t' 1 ~· ~ , fL- ;- ~

l ,rE. 1.
lt~~ '[ f.
t' ~ l. f. l l·~t~&.if~;t(i~f f~ ~Cj;; F ~ ii i.
!:. o ..
JC•
f- Cr
,, C ~ ~ ~' ~
'6.
I
l f :£ 1. l ft l ·t: £ ·!j..j_ ~: I d. I: ~ t.~ .. • C-' f. 'i~
e:. ·[' :[ ~r- r- f, .c~ ~ r· {.. f( ~. ~. } ~
C· b - X ,._ r;; ~· L r.... ,I'-'
i t f.~ ~ 1·~ rf c-=-" ~ 1·~ ~ 1· ~·
r:
'P- ~_,. C....
.. 0 [,• , I ~_,, L.
1 - . - -·1 ~· a.::.
r:- '· ~
- ~c-; '"
't - [, .F
,t- t>, ~ ,t' t
tr ,c-
f. <e:. ~ f ~ g • I!
t 1= l q if·'1. b e. · · £~ ,, f. t,. ~ l, ..
.c·~
~I• ~ ~ I~ ~ ~
1 1
'L [, ~· ~ I:!'. !:. e.! J:!'. I::
,~ ~. J> X 1, 0 ~: - • 1 'fi.,
t. :~ •t:~ ._: ~ tl t 1~ 1! 11- ~ ~ t ~ tJ- '[ ~ 7
,r. C- - 1,bl A I ::S l;.1 ~ 1(; , ~
I 9' • • f ,: ' .. ~ I ~I • e.!
, f ...c•,_ 1-- t ~t_:
V\ - •
·~. · -;e E I li- G.
n ~ c.- ·[' 8. ·~. ~ r- ~ I : l ·~
; ~-~tr:-i
-t. lD ~"'
l~ I
s~ ·~ -~ - c· · ,
_,_ I ('l)
~ f ~·t ~ g; f. t' a 1: ti'" I 'fo ~ ..c ,.
c.... · ~
-}r.~ f . -t;· c-~. '-; C ,en_,. "~ } ..
C..
~ -!!.. c. .f· ':< C· x
-F. l. ~ o ~ f ~ ~ ,. G" .. ~ f
[" ,2. lp I • ~ (t ~ -<::; f - ~ ~·
f tV\~· V\ --1 ·~
a c.b ·V N lD f - ~v , ::n e.! o 1. It {j;; ,C· •t, J· •<i. ~·
~ g fi le_ ,. ,C- §~ s: G. ~·
~ p ~· 8. ( fE- ~ t : ·~. ~ t· :c
(• i f. - [
}r.. '[ ~ ~'7
t' ,f E. C
;:: O t. '-' ~. f ~ ~ f ~ C ,. E!: r> _,.
~1 , _,. -1 1- .... r,,C • 1 •
.. 3 b C~ - S.. l f i ~ ~
[1 ~ ~· ·~ } G. \ I> ~ C- ~ -• 0 [• (j Ci C. isr. . . ~· r
('l)
= c,- -~~ .~ 1:7t>.' -t.:. [ •• I
Ul
~ .c;~ · ::r
0 I
_,.
ti'" G. - I I,
E ~ i t E ~~ f ~ I
t ..c f. ·~.
= }e.v ~'.t•_c.._
t
~ ~ ~ 1~ ~ [ •(, ! " t. - ,c;.._ ~- 1.,. t;. "e [
'\. I ~· ti'" lt> I I \0 - 0 .
- [,t; ,fr. :r.~ ; s c. ~ ,tE ._ , : .:.. ~ ~
· b t> -•
,en - ....J C· .. ,. ~~· C: ~ t c-; -
" - ,en. ~ l . i-. [, l:; C·
I:; ,C' C:- f r-" - ~ \C) ~
[
~ '1t - t ':' }~I- f r,~ - I \~ _,. ~,.
- J> [' J• •I- I I
-1 f ~ 1~· 1l p
r;,.
00 }. ti(•
l
....! ·t
r r:: ·t: · . 1. . .• ·~- .·. t :._ ·t: : .c. ·t: . - 1
•L ; ~. I '~
t ~ {. t ~ 1l g l t ~ ~ t ~ t t • t - [ ·~. ~ L - t f;•. -'I( ~
,~.;~"ii ~ ~I ~ I a_;g~~I F-1 c)-4 .l~ .l_?.J c)A ~_;JI~
. d..:lWI ~ I ul~ a_;g~ ~I ~ I -1:?.1>J JJb: i:,i ~ ~Jll 0~ J~I ~
,. . ~ ~ .• .)l ~-L;;~ILl~~1
t,.:r>- • '.) -
.... : . t 1 ~
r=- u ·i
. ~ ·t;;~
. -,i.S..» '.) ..
~ ~ .t....9~IJc)AjJIJ~...ulJ~lZll~ul.9~"ilo-4~.;JI~ \ si.!4&i
..
~ u~~IJ .ll~~I ~ ;;_;-&_, ~~ ~~ ~ ~ "i~ F-1 ~ i:,i
-
,~I 1,4., .uL.u~IJ u ~ ~ I ~.!.!;;; _,t ~ ~ ~L.ui ~ i ~ lfji
IA!.- ~ti«~ t• -'I
~J~ ~ >:!=
Wl».J~L,
•~ ...':. L:f , .... a..J.WI Ll' 1 ~ ~I .... :It -•~~,1 ·<A.
'+1 t,.:r>- - - ~ r-:-~ ~
a_;e~~I ~I)) L..+s~ (Donaldson and Dynfee, 1999) ~J.lJ i:,~...uWJ.l
.(p.44) ((4.!0cee\oJIJ ~~1., ~...ul .)~~I ~)ti ••• ) ) ~ ~I (p.27) ((~I
- - ,,
1....94 lfji F. I~ ~L.ui» lfji ~ ~1 ~ < ? I ~ ~ I >:!=WI LAi
..
~1 ~(~~_,JI~) ~.l~I ·.«.!;~I ul~ F-1 ~.!.!;;; ~1 '-4J_;..a:JI I~~
.(p.44) ((~l.u&:,?}1 ~t 0A ~~i yb i.Aj-&_?.
a=i>W w.;'-4.o ~ ~t~l ~ (Schwartz, 2005) ;J.;I~ ~L- d........c.ul.;.l ~
.d..:lWl¥~~1F-lc)A~~~J~l~ic)A~.;.l~
, .. ,;Q«oi
,J~)U d..:lWI uLlJ..ul (Y) ,u\S'~I i5...u J~~I uWJJ.A (,) .;.lL.o.1.1 ".J.-..A
¥}l;.~I F-1 c>4 ~~ -1:?.1>J yb 1....9~1 i:,\S' .J~~I u~}l;.i u~.ll ('r)J
ul~ lfjt ~ \so.!i,oi ~ c.!lJjJ ~J ' ~ ~ J .;.lL.o.1.1 c)-4 .l..U:. ~ 1)-iJ ~I
~ul~~
... .. ~~t1u~~1
.. .... :tl...u.1>J
r=- .. yb t....9'A'l·\S'
~ u J .~a..J.~a....uk
- -·
·F-1 c)A ~1., Jlkj ~ ~~ lfji ~.)...U a.lALl, ~ . , ' ~ ~~ ~.ll+i
:~L.u~I ¥~~I F-10,.44tJI ~~I Ll.;...ul a\.o:u ~\S'
.(~"i.,JI ,¥~I ,~lj..tll ,4-llA~I ~..J) ~l.9.,JI -,
r
(i:,l.u&:,11 J_,;i>. ~La..o ~_.,) 1~"ii - r
·(0-JJ>-~I f'Y r~ ,~Lk>.~4 t....9l~"il ,a.J~WI) 4JJ.-J.I -,
.(·(>J...)>-
• ~L.t• ~ . ).~ti
,L · ... ~,, -w1 ~
~ ~~ c.9 • • ~ La..o ~ • •J-- ) t....9b'l'I
• -t.
•(c.\l ~b "i ~jjl ~ I JWl ~ ~..J) r~"il -o
.(a~.!:11 ~lA>.J ~l~I ~lbl ~Li..o ~ J ) a..tlol_,11 -"\
F-1 "~ ~.l JJ~ i:,i ~ J~ ~I ~Ww ~ i:,t ~ ~ I JJ---'-" ~
~~~~i:,i ~)G.~~o.J:..u:.J)o~l.u\., .~~~~L.u~I ~)G.~I
. .,w.ll ~~~Li.A~ t....9~J .uL.u.;WI ([) u ~ I (y) uL.u~I (i) t.r'J
:; I ·i r.:. :-' .fl f. ·~ f. .~ ~ ~ r:: ~ C's>· r· ,:.
·1-.1 ·t'. '1! •f:
[· [:.,. [·~ ·t·
•t 1· ~., £-~ f;, ~ \. r- ; :f-~
{ ~ ;i f [r [ 1.° ~ e; f: c.' ~ p ~ •~ ~ ~ n . f
.e-· c:_r- J C[:\ ,.o-: [• t ~ ·C' ,E
&• f. loC· ~ (e~
-[ ~f,·-.~··'-rt E..1tf: . </.. } r <r.'t, J:ttr 1 £1\ f"'E!• ·[..e .!·"-~ '[-
b Cr
. • • -~ - 'l.. '.•-~
bl ~
·= ~ L..~.,.
= I> ~- ~ r···- - - • c:_
l ' ~
li' f. .f. t ~ - rt- - i. ~ ·<t •-..·
IC·~- ';;· .c: V t -r .:- ~ r: i r- -~ [• - - ~· ~ . 1 Ii ~ I. </.. ' 1
<i_ !_ I - \ J - f
-l,
.,. t.C • \o -~
~;.....l.i.. ~ ••• t-
f r· ~c,i . r .[7 ·f- i ~ t t. t ~:t .[ f t f
-~ ~ - - ·~ • L
E '. ~·
-:e - t Nl e-. Et ·~ t 1· ~
'·t~
.e.r -i;; 'D < f>.
f.: ~ c;-L «r.-· <c..
r .r- ~f. lJ· ~ ; r1l ·r:- .·t• 1 ~ -:- ~-l -..' <j,...: ~.; - ~- ~ ,e '. ~-
l ~ f <j, E: '} ~ ~ ( ~ ~ i: r ~i •
p.• f;, ~. C ~. IC i ~ c." 1.' ,t ~· ·t ~~ 1:f. ·t: :~
bl 6 .,. lo lo 0.. b
·[·r f, ~ tr ~: , ~l = t· - lr-
~- ~ l, { - ,£: ~ ·i ~ h')' f it
IA 1:.
- f1 )· ,e -
t ·i. -..· ~q_ ·c;..f 1~ r-1.° ,£: §"~ r tr
.c fi: t ,e O
< C·
B ~ I:! IiP f..r .fbl 1·. t· r: tlC
.V\ =;: -•[,
·t f.,
·-,' C· •
-- •
/i: ..
c..
C;! C· ~ ~ ' ~ - C· ' · - - &
J) '§ "e, f;! fi l ~ r 'e: ;~ q_ .· ~
{l ft fr,t t 1..~ ~.c fi l~ f f,8 ·~ fi t~. ~
t( : c,
~ le• - bf
J~ t~ 1·-;- 1)
-~ § "; ~ ;l :r .~ ~.
[• - . i 'I- ,c;, r.. 'f ' "' ~ c:.. ~ 'r . "' ~ ,l ... c:..
i. l- -. 't- •I;.,t· ~r,· f~ :-t 'f
C• ~- (. :( r- [ c- .'f ~ ~ C· \o~
~~.·(;·1 r ·r~ 1-~ ~P.·~r'~f :.
Ir. .~ - c, r; t. ':"" t) • V f:; - - ~ I:! •t.c! \.
~~f
4..o ~ j:.; - p.•
E J-r-'*'' l -,= . ~
·~ _€1 r~:·.·t ft'i: . . t ( i
t .~ ~ ~ 1- r ;t
• ~, I '
1
~Jl,, J~ .r-~ t~ ti·
f;, ~·1 1
1
~ (;, t ,f:r i: "r:
~ r.... C· • [r .I -· [• t!. ~
• t:; ~ • ... • - f" .
t
[ ~- r- ·t ~· ~r· 5 f .r ,e f: t 1- ts c 1i. C ~q. ·t: 1 t -~ t;; ·~ r
't [ l J ~ ~ 'f. c- t! t f"' ~... *[ ~ .ft (;! le_
t iJ ~ t t ! ff t E%t · _ t __ h ~ fi r r 1 r: E _ ·~ IC ~·
~Wl~I
u)LW.L
. . 3-j'.) ~ ) L&hJI
.. uL-~···t\
~ ~
~..,:JI
- u.·ifi.:.. lA..llc. ul'.) lj-ltl a.c.~ ~
-
ulA~)) JIY.'! J,.asl w~ ..il u ~ I 4.Lll:i w~ i~ (..1>-IJ ~ ,~. ~~ ci'11
.(Schwarz, 2009 ~I) ~>b-~I ~Ll.11 ~ C<_;ll:>'jl
I~?. &JI w~ wi ~ u,w.ll \si «~«SUA ~ ci'11 J>b-~13.jJ..1.Ac.,ll o~l

~.l~J ~I~ J41 ~,, :<i9>b-~I ~...;..cJ\S' ~ j i u ~ ~t c:,...-o
~ I ... ~ji <i9>b-~I L:-«J...;..cJI ~~J -~.J,ll ~l.rtll J>b- ~ a .!S.!~Jlll
..llc..;~'i1~~_,~a.;s>b-~1~1~1wt.,<i9>b-~1~~1~t
1.§~ 0t ~ ~ •(Trevino and Nelson, 2007: p. 276) ((ul.;l~I ~~
~» :a.;s>b-~I &J4 ~ ~ ~_jll ul:!S'.,L.«, oL:.l..>-4 ~ ~b~I u\ 4.!.!iii
j,AJ ¥>b-~I o~I .J-1-0~ ~ -~ . )* I ~ ~b~I lt ..
~.!.!;;t Jl.ull 1.§.;b'jl rl.tull
«LA.;~J>b-'jl ~Ji ~>b-~I ol.Zll.;~~.... ,oi~ ~l-ii *l_;J.l~
lt *
~~ i:,~t ~ wfi.: 1.§.:,..tl ~_,JI~ .(Trevino and Nelson, 2007: p. 277)

aJ~ ~l.lA ,Ll>b-~I .. \..b:al ~ .I · .. ti
... ,;:q ~&. .. , r.:,JI ~b~I ~~~ .... -~ · .<j
.. r-=- ~ ~~
~
u· i ~
. ·- ~
,--=-
.... .:ti 4.LU:i ~
· .< --: 'i '?""' ··· !t!..• ti uLl~- J..J~.
~•1 ~.,... - ~~
_'\ · -b-~I
1... ~li.J ··· !t!..q Ll - · ·
- .... :ti 1... u.~tl ul.) I~
\-=- c.:,-- - 'J-
..________l
as-~1 w~t~'il ,~>b-~1 &JI~~ c.,ll ~jbt c.:,S.H 0t wJ.l~~u1

L:. J q;.,..Q
0~1 <.;,--
,.....
~
:.t; YL.b:,'il 1·,~
.)-1:J L .
~t -~>b-~1- .:u ~ i
J .. \ ~ .. ' r•_j-J- 'i
~.J.A ~ ~'-':I a.Jll'jl ~ _,t ~.lb.JI ul.;l_,l w§J wi ~ \..& .as'~ ~>b-~I
t\b; «ccll.;~~~as'~lwiJA~lp(~lwl~.;~IJ ·&J4rl>'1'il
~>b-~I &JI~ &l.*l ,u~~I ~~ ~ ~ ,uulSll r~ .;~ ~ wl
.(Trevino and Nelson, 2007) as'~
u:,l.uJL...l't
~ d.! ~>bi~ a........c.~ as'~l l5..W 0\S' 1~1 ~L:. d 0«0.'
CCC.!~.)
<<JJ,4i LA J.L4i» wi ~ 1.§i L+.> r~ ~t ~ as-~ o ~ I w~ wi

~ ,rWI t~'il l.j,A wJ~J . (Messmer, 2003: p. 13; Gibbs, 2003: p. 41)
ul-.u.;WI ~ a.c.~ ~llA l.j,A ~J..1> tllJ ·lSJ~I ~~ ~>b ~I ~ I
wts:.A'il .;~ ~ ,d.AL:. ~ . , .as-~,~ <JA 1~?. r~~ ~ wi ~ ci'11
&JI~ ~'-':I ~Uo_,JI_, u ~ I o\S' ~ ul:!S'~IJ ul_;lj-ltl a.c.~ w~ wi
~ ~Wt, ulS~ ~~~• lilZll..>J..JW :Jl.o.c~t u ~ ~ ~~• vA ..L:IJt ~
J$@J&4i%4ti,.&.~.g~~¥-M¥WW,,*@M%&~iJ=1<-<fk?Y.frW.jXC~~&@M§iii~A+i··v§·b#&A&~-~w®i tl~"h•••v--i·:ik3i¥~-fK$ v·=s+S:.-hv~aw-~1@~=~$b+'1ir§A§rl
4 1
,~~_,.l.lJ0-J~~IJ~~I 0-J~~l "i c.ill~~ .as'..,_.:ill a.j9)l;.~I

c.ill.JS' .(Schwartz,Dunfee,andKline,2005 ~ I ) ~ i o.;b)'I ~~J
~ I ~bi J ~ ~ ~~IJ ~~ ~.... 11111 wl....ulJ...ul ~ wf ~
->.w.JIJ wl~WJI ~ ~ 0i ~ LoS" .~)l;.~I ~ 4 ~ ~ ~)w:.J
~I ~1 (<>--1~~1 J~ yW.. ~h;..) ~lk;.JI wLJs:llJ ~~ )'I a .::.u..L&ll
LAA a.: «u/?J,,11 ¥)\.;.~I ~I <.J..4 wl.s~l o.:U. JS' J.>..--...:i .a.! 111/uJI a.j9)l;.~I
.as-.~ -
-~-'t u)l;.~I .... :;t1 · · .. L .. ...u:.L..&a.J
..)-l...)-*-J <..r- - ,-=-
~ I «~I» J)Ll.. <.J.A a.j9)l;.. ~I ~ I o-uy:. c.r'J lSF--i L4.,_>1o t.!lllAJ
~ » : ~ ~ I 0-J~~I .;~ Ji <>--1~~1J ~.,.ti ul.;l~J uLl~4
«l.AUAA ~~, , , ~ ~ ~ I c.r'J 4.! 4.!t;, ii JI ~~, d.! 4.!t;.. ii JI ~ I J .;,:JoL.u~I
<.J.A ~I ~~)'I ~ I c.ill~ C.:,-4 ,;.,;2 .(Trevino and Nelson, 2007: p. 287)
.. ,
r..:-r-=- I - L ~ I ~ ~I ~J~~
~,1 .... :;1t~~.)~.~- .. ,. ~IJ u1;.,1~ :r
.. 1.t)l;.
~1.(t-1
~lc.ill.JS'J«~~G:A~fa.~~~~10-4~..,_JI~ \ si4,;.,;;
:. ~I JJ l.i:C.JC.!:,c..i>-
~...\.u:. o-u - - 'I~ • - . "!. '~ ~ 1"il . _'\as'. _:._ ,, '.:.. !~ I .t)l;. .
r~ ~ ~ (.,)-WWW 1.(t-1 (>Ar..:,-~ti a..uluJI ...
•~I~~ ~ ~ J ~lk3,..~I ~~ l~U
i(;'4-"'Jlt a~~t ~U..Ji:'

o...u:.~ ~ J J JAL«:u ~~f ~w..H ->.,P.-J o.;~ ~~~I ~I~
~ o~I wl Qt;,;Jt ~h;.. ,l+,~J as'..,_.:ill ~~i ~~ ~~1 ~
~w~I ~ ~1 o~I ~~, w->i i.:·'slJ ,a a.:a..JI ~ ·<Y°J co;.JI ~ J
, , lt
~i <.J.A c.ill~J ,4....4WI w~j.11 Ji o~I wlS'..,_.:ill ~~ll ~ ~)l;. ;yl
~ ,Jl::J.I ~ ~ •t--il.,JI >:?- ~ ~l~I I.LL1:i J:iA ~...u 0 t 0-4 ..1....S'b.tl
w~I ~ r'~~I JI~)' ~.lb.:i"il ~~I a...oµ1 w~ji ~
~IJ the US Federal Sentencing Guidelines for Organizations (FSGs)
US Sentencing Commission rlL>.~I .;I~)' o~I w~"i_,JI ~ '-s:iJ~i
w~"i.,.U ~.>b.:i"il 0~WI ~L:-:.1 w~I ~ LAlS:>.i o~I .;~ l-4...Li.c.
w~I ~ rlS:>.~l .;I~)' 4=.>b.:i"il ~y~l a...ofi>JI w~ji c.......- 111 .o~I Q
~w..H)) ~...u wl wL.;1 J6.. ~ l.s:!,k ~jJ,41. I w'-41...,_ill 0-4 ~ 4 ulS'..,_.:ill

~ c.r'J r"·. tr'~~ w~fall ~'.)A~ JlJ .«Jl.ull Jl:u.o)U ~)l;.f
~w.>:rn ~~I ~..u i:.,i J~I Jig ¥)l;.~I «a.!o.:IoiiJI ~l.Zll» oJ~ ~1 i:.,'il
. ,, i
~J i:.,yWl ~G:.11 ul,fo'_,L.uJI t-i-J. 4 o.:o ,oi ~ ~.JJIJ «Jlull Jl:uA)U ~)l;.
Jl~?J ~..)6.:i'il ~JA~I LµI u~ji 0---A Ab'\',, o..)U\ ~ ·¥)l;.~I
~)l;.t ~w..HJ JWJI Jo~'il ~ J ~ » ~\:.JI~ u ~ I ~ r~~\
r\..µl'ilJ ~)l;.~I ~_,L.ull ~..u <i'1' a.:o.:Ioiil\ ~\.Zll ~-:: .~,i ~I~~
~..u u ~ I ~..)i u~j&.11 u..)..1> ~ .(oJ4-tJI ~u ~) «i:.,yLiU tJ ,;,;.J4
'-:-'->..J..i:tllJJ)l;.i d_jJ~~~J,c~w,, ~w..H ~..u wiJ~I ~~ ~~I
- -
r~J (J)l;.~I JJ~ ~i) J)l;.~I ~w..H ~ J J ~ ~;. ,~• ..).?.JJ ~)l;.~I
u\.fi..,LuJ4 ~ I ~J (whistleblowing uWG:.11 ~ ~?JI . b ~i) u~~
~ J i ~JL..u o~\ u~'i_,JI i:.,yl:91.!.U~ rJJi ,d..4J_,.kjl ~ J .~Lill ~
~~ .l.?.J 0---A .J....Sl:J4 ulS'~I US Sarbanes-Oxley Act (2002) (SOX)
1.... J···--t\ LWI ~ ~ I · ~ u.}J
· ·w1~ ... t •.~
-"9)l;.j ~ t:,~
.. t ~
<.:r- ~ L)A • -,- -
l&io ,oii i:.,i ~ <i'1' l;,..ul u ~ I ~1 JL.....!,j i:.,S:JJ ,(J)l;.i Ji) ~_,1- d_jJ~
uWL;J.I ~~~~Li.A ul_,tg i:.~h, u ~ I rJ.li ~.JJI ci_,JI ~ d_jJJ.l.l
. whistleblowing
~ ~ ,,
o..)~ u~ji ~JA~I ~ µ 1 ~';/\ l:,16.. r..14i ~.JJI ci_,JI ~, I.J....J
a.:o.!J;,;;t\ ~\.Zll ~ ~ ~w..H ~i) J~ ~)l;.i ~w..H i:.~l a.!,;.!'~
.aL..o~I ~ '---=-~tl.J W·~.t\ ~ ~ ~.}Jr'+'
. ~~Ll.A~ . ~.~ • - ... t L".f 'il ,(Ll)l;.~I
-
J_,lo JI.J.4.o Lo 'il+i~ ..1:~4 ~ Lo ,J)l;. ~I d_jJ~ ~ t (JA ~_,JI~
a.::' ,"J i..1:~ ps-i .,t ~., ~~1 ~ d_j.,J.J.1 ;;~ wfi:i i:.,i ~ JA ,d_jJJ.J.1
~ <i'1' [~Lull Lo 'io~ i:.,l ~ (JA 'i~)l;. ~I Y.,..J..i:tll w~ l~Lo 'io~I
'iuWl:.J.I ~ ~~ i:.,.;.L..JI Jo;J\ ~ ~ i:.,i ~ ~.:UI Lo '>r...1.;.; 111i i:.,t
Jb..~yu...14~..1:~~.,.LIJ~l~JA 'i~..14i~~luwl.o..,.;:JI Lo
-
,~~I clb ~ Jlo:il ..).?.Jt~ ~1_µ4., 'iuWl:.J.I ~ ~?}\ ~ ~Li>-1
-
a;;~~ ~~ ~..14i ~ <i'1' a.: er·/~\ ~~j&.11 4\:.JI ~1~ ~I ~l.>3 ~~
u ~ I ~ r~~\ Jl~?J ~..)6.:i'il ~JA~I Lfi.:,JI u~ji ,~Ji :J..)~
the US Federal Sentencing Guidelines for Organizations (US Sentencing
,, t, ,,
,ull:i ·¥)l;.~I u\ oioillJ w~..)lS'~I w~4ll ,l....;sl:i .Commission,1991)
,~~I J...1..LA.l4 ~ ~ J .(Schwartz, 2004) ~jll lAl~t ci'1' ~~~I
u ~ t:t) ~ J)l;.~I ~ J ~ J ~Y-~J ~JA e::4 ~~ ov ~jll ~~i
,...,
~ ~W.!J ulS~ ~~\Pl lil.airl.>J..Jl:u :JL4.c\PI u ~ '="9 J ~ I u-4 ..bJI ~
r .- . ··v-··~-~-=··.-/i,·~-~<··· ... ···A·,:.i;;-.,_;.-·::Y· ...........
~~ ..?·.,·.-.t:-:~··: · .. .-..,.1:r&ftl<·;_;..;.:'.··i····-·B <-~,.v ~~-----:~-:-A·I!··,;)4'<li:--(··)~(~--,..·}: ·'·-d
.l~<i'11L~l~l.WIJ.?~l.;i~'i~tJ~~o~J~t
~ a.1:iAt5 .-,w.lt ~~1 <.:JI.;~~ .ll~l ~ ~-"'"" .Jlu..11 J~~1 ~w~
.JWJI ~-~~I ~ w·~ .u ~ I y..,::, \..WL,•
~~)~~~I ~1->+1] [~WllJ <.:J~I w,-4 .l~ ¥ ~.:UI c.:.il_j-11 ~

'"->1,1~Li:! J.d ,(Pine, 1994 .;--Jo.jl ,~lj..tll _,t 0L....:.~~ ld_, 0fiJ <?' ,Jl....ill
,J\:i.11 ~ w,k) ~~ t ~w..H .>Jfa (') ~ '"Ll:i Jlu..11 ~~ ~I ~w.r.JI
·(~~~I ~_.;~1,J\:i.11 ~~) ~~i ~W..H ~ (") .(J~i a:,_,.J.A
~ I .. l-.cJI ·-1 ~ti Jo........;.JI ,J\:i.11 I.. . . , .... ) -~t ~ Lj1..)-! O'.) bl (Y-)iJ
(»- ~ t..:,---"- ~
~"'(f-1
~I) (<.:J4~1 ~1..>-4 ~~ ,J~~I J J ~ ,~L&JI J..i_)o ~ o~L-J.I

~ I a 2 ,c:/v-fl <.:J~_,::JI ~~ ~-'"'""~ ~ .(Schwartz, 2001, 2004
.a.,~_,.-..,.,
·-t-~tl <.)-"'"
'-l·tldl:i
'.r 1.... '"l.uLl)l;..~I
c.:r-- . - .. t\ ..>-3~
('tA l.j~ ·-•-~.
w,A .JS"'l:JI ~~)l;..~I ~w~I ~ ~I..L;JI ~ 01 :J}U\'1u.,~~_,.b3

~ .c.!l.,.LuJI a:,_,.J.A _,t J)l;..~I a:,_,.J.A f-'""4 ~~ ~.JJ alcoai4 ~J .l_?.J
LA~b 0~ ~ 6 . ~ LA ...1.:i,. ~! <.:JWJ..i..ll ~ <.:Jl-.ul.;..lll 0i ~ ~.:UI c.:.:i_j-11
jJ.; I~ a..u l.;.l <.:J~J ,(Kapstein and Schwartz, 2008 ~I) ~_,.I.I c.!l_,L.u w,k
~~~I c.!l.,L.cJI w,k.~'+4~b o.;~4 l&l 0~ 'i ~ cGi (Schwartz, 2001)
-
a:,iJ..u.l '-'.,....,
.. _("-: ,J\:i.11 ~
I.. . .. ,.... • 0
c.:r-- :. LA
'.J--'-" • ~J
-=. ,_. :. c- LA l.J~ I :j 'ii
. O.l...u:iA ~ YJJ . ~ ~
- 6
0~ 0JL.:tll _,i 0-J...?-~I .ll..,:S~I ~ .;JLl.:al ~_,.1.4 ~..D <1~.l~.;l L)lc.11 :(f)
-
~.:UI 11t.;..lll11 a:,_,..i..t.l ~ :(y) • ~llA LA i.!l_,l.u 0lS' ljl LA .J:~ <.:Jl-.u~I
1. ... '-) t.·-':c.ja..a_,.t-.u~~I
~ c.:r-- U"""--' ~ - ~
· <.:JLJ.bJIL
• '-'
~'-' ·'"~
'-:
··· ~,~-- 11
• LJ:=..,._., ~
I ;. ,~.;<
.)J.l a:,_,..i..t.l ~.lj:i :([) •(0-J~..U.I ~ J '"~1., ~.l.;_,.1.1 <.:J41k ,Jl....ill
0))
.~Lal~ ~U)~0~fA~.;lj,jlJtl.r91 aJ_,W ~_,.I.I~...\: w,10t:;....1JI

~Lal a.b.1.uJ4 Jb:i>Ll ~_,.I.It=-=:= ,~.;J «~l»JI, ;, .~.;< o» .;J.l a:,_,.JJ.1 ~.lj:i ( .l)
~ ,-
LA~ .<.:JW~I ~ ~,µ_, (J~ ~~I J J ~ Jb:i'il ,J\:i.11 ~ ~ )
.~)l;..i ~w>:' ~t L.>A l:.J~
i'"J.:?,. J~~I <.:JWJ.J.A .;~I
~ ,.,)lc.t ~ l.!.LJj ~llA ~ ~ a:,_,..u,I ,.s~ ~ ~ :4l.9~1 ~~
,l.!.LJj~l a:e~1 .as-~ a2 , ,/v-JI ¥)l;..~I ~1 ~1 r~~ a:,_,..i..t.1~ 0l
uf ~1 (t·"\.s ,r· •r) Sarbanes-Oxey Act~.,t~.;L..u0i,ll~ ~6.
~ ~ * C. -
:~ J ~ t a:,_,.J.A ~I ~o·oii 01 o.;~4 ~ <?IJ r~~I L>-4 b~

- - - - - - - - - - - ~ ~ ..,.,.,,, - ~ ~ ~ r n &::a:-~~
~~~~"?~I Lo.9 !!I~ fall :ul.Ja.al '="9 J~!.g 4J...,r?JI

' ·.. ,..,.: ···: /~ .. ·. :::= '·f -'=\··.! ;;·' . . ,-~==.-:·;-·, ··.: :. ·.... _./ r=... : ;' .... :.::. ll 1:, ..'" ~..1; .;_ 1·· ,; (),:.. ·, )~ ... .' . . .)'·, ·.... ,~-~···I'' .. )'·.·.:,,.,::.... ('/'/·.:','(-· -~ 1:·· .. ,·,:, / r~·=·, ( .· . <·....,.,,, -0, ,' I )J/i·Q.v<•~/, ·,,• ·.. I";-.::· i.X.,.; ·:·.\.~( .:· i:rf~···, -&+~·':'<;:. 0.f'·.J I{!"',' .7/( .::i /"1··:·.),i. ·I
..9l ~ I ~Lall tlJ-ll ~)l;.~I j_.Alull ~l..9 ~)l;.~l..9 4=j.i.ll ~.,L-JI -,

.~l..9 a.!'ozr:iJI c.:.,\l)WI <J::i P'
·&l:i.,JIJ ..>-'..Jla:al a:iii.,llJ a"t:.:-..,. ,oJl..9 ~l..9 Lb.JI ¥Li..!JI -'1'
.u..b.ll
• "1-ltl ~~IJ(J:J~
~,....., · ·1-~u Jl:u.A~I -,
dti .;-:i:. ~p,-l ~~! c.:.,~~JA r~..9-:' c.:.,Ll..9..ul J..9l.w ul ~ r.,_,.;o..9-:1..9

~4JI ~ .l~ Ll_;.l ~~.;JI~ · ~ J t ~_;L..u u~ll '-f:ll _;Lj,l <i'11
~ 0t ~1,d.,jJ...l41J a+u,t.al c.:.,~I 0 ~ c.:.,~jtlt )..iJ.olJ c.:.,w..9...u.l c.:.,~
~ rll <i'11J ~WI c.:.,lS'..,_!JI ~ c.:.,w..9...L4il a.!'".!~.;-11 Ll_;..lll ~ ~ o~I ~I.J.tll
c.:.,~~..ul/o~.;JI :~b.ll c.:.,~I ~~~ .l.J.>. .(Berenbeim, 1999) ~~~
J ~ I V°' '1') c.:.,lA.,W.I ~ c):\AL:i ,(1.°' ") ~~, YJ~ ,(1.°' Y) a+u,Lal ~
a~.!:ll ,(1.At) l:IJ.f.11 ~~ ,(1.A"\) ~~I u-0yill/al~I ,(1.°'·) l:I~ ~
jA..JI ~ ~ L)L..JI ,(1.V"\) J ~ ~, ~~ ,(1.VA) y 111 i::-JI u!,~ ' ,(1.VA)
c.:.,lA.,W.I ~ ,(1.1Y) a.!•oi::rll c.:.,\l)WI ,(1.V') ~~I c.:.,~~I ,(1.V,)
~ ~?JI ,(1.tA) ~_,.ti~~ ,(1.0 •) u~?l' J ~ ,(1.0Y) a.!«0;. ,~,JI
yJll~I 046:..o ,(1.t '1')~~1 rl~I ~.,-..,, i(1.t1) whistleblowing c.:.,Wlzll
. (1., o) JLib ~I a.n. 4~ i(1.YA)
~ J)l;. ~I c.:.,wJ...lA L.ul_;..1.:t ~ I ~\S' ~ =~~ o~~, ~ aJ~t
(Ethics Resource ab ,11:o~lL..4~t ~~~ ~bS'y~J
Center, 1990: p. 111-1; Raibom and Payne, 1990: p.883; Brooks, 1989:
~I~ Lo.!o ,o; f" G:i ,11; ul..9 p. 124; Pitt and Groskaufmanis, 1990: p. 25)
.(Ethics Resource Center, 1990: p.111-2; Moore and Dittenhofer, 1996: p. 29)
~ 41 ~ LA..l.U:. J-AJ d.,j..9...u.l ~J ;'"4:' ~p,-i uL....a!. ~Ll.A ,c.ill~ ~1 ~~1
~.., ~ ~~ ~ w (eb:..o ~~ rll ~t) i~ ;;~ ~J..1.:t ~~ll 4-.it
.(Gibbs, 2003: p. 40; Sanderson and Varner, 1984: pp. 28-32) c.ill~ ·.,: "'!
'-;,-U_J...Lill J)l;. ~~' ~ ..9l l<l•I d.,j..9..ul ~ J ~ u-0~1 Ll:'&..ot ..1.-:i l.!Ll~ 's I
u-0~ ~~~_,.ti o~l.w.o !sib «rel..9-:1 ~ I~ L~ ~L..u..9 d.,j..9..ul ~

--
. (Gidds, 2003: p. 40; Murphy, 1995: p. 731) 1....9lbJ.I ~l,j ~ ~~J a,j..9...u.l
&l:i.,.tl wfi:Jul ~~_,.ti~ ~.J.A ~.>=iJ: wl ~ ~.:Ul~~IJ «oi•tl..9
.(Trevino and Nelson, 1995: p. 246) ~j;,I~ i~ l:a..9 ~ w 1~ a.L_,k
-~.)-A J-Jl:ifi r.J;.i lfj~ i~ aa.!,~ ~w.,..ul 0..,_sJ 0i ~ ")I ~ j
sui
ul ~ ~w.,..ul 0 i ..l.....:!..1.~Jl-:1..9 a .!4'·" ~4~~, c--A ~,~ •. , \bill t.J..-A.,

t"jtll ~.,LuJI u~ ~~I ~jlfl f::'.JZJ ~lS' a.!\.!cocii ~Lo_,1.-..o u 4,;.,i;
.(Pitt and Groskaufmanis, 1990: p. 1638; Laczniak and Murphy, 1991: p. 269)
~,~~~w.,..ul ~~..,.i.1~LAL&J")!t_;.b;..i ..b-i : ~ , ; ; ~ , ~

~~ ")!»0-4 a, ,,.\,,,~i ,~;;~~1~0fi:i LA 4JL:. lfji~ ~l.;..l!
(Austin, 1961; ~~, J-4~1 ~ ~_,.!.I r~t' 0..GA ~ b f.:?"bJ r n ~ ul
Harris, 1978: p. 315; Ethics Resource Center, 1990: p. 111-2; Raiborn and
~ 4,:tll.; ;;l.)f ~i ~J..l! Ll_,..ul r..G:i ,ui ~ I l~..9 .Payne, 1990: p. 883)
. ~..GA ~.,LuJI ~ '=7'='4=:?/1 ~ b 0~ .i9 <-.9lht.l ~~ ~J ~ ) U ~ ~I
~~ ~ ~.,..ut ~~ rJ <i'1' ~UoLlJ.U u~..,.i.1 ~ .i9 ,I.LU~ ~1 as~1
.i9..9 .(Harris, 1978: pp.314-315; Murphy, 1995: p.730) ~~ Ls:,i ~
~..9..ul ail~ ~4'::f'I ;;~I rl..G:i ,ul ~ ~Jl-"4 ~1 J~.,.U ~6.1.!.ll.lA u~
~~I ..b-T.;Ll.i ,Juli~~ .~i~.;J.,:t~I ;;~I J:?~6::'J ~~
~wjLJI r..14i ~ ;;..r.U-:' 4,:t~I ~..9..ul ul.:t (Schwartz, 2004) __µ.;I_,..!, a..u.t.;~ ~
:a.u~, 4.AJ- L. ~-~<'t\ ~ ..uL ~ ~ L. . -~<j 4..4.J. L.
-· --~ ~ .,Y--, ~ • !.) ~j~ ~
o~i LAl~J -~Jt~~~.>~..ill~.:,~ ••• ~.:,~.:,l~."i

.:,..o ~ ~l.l.,2) .:,~ ~ ... ~.>LAJ ~~ ~l.l.,2) .:,lS' I~! -~~IJ .>J--1-"~I ~
.Ju:; "i _,t ..ill~ ~I, "i _,t ~ ... ~ ~ "i L,j} .:,.,J~ ~.:UI u-o~~I ~
C~J~l.l.,2).:,lS'l~L:,~J··· ~1~.,....,.:,..o~~~.;,.c. .is~l ~ l
~) "i ~t "i ... i~ ~,., .:,~ .:,t ~ ii-:,1:1~! ri ~ ..ill~ .:,lS' ~,.,...., ~.).,
.(Schwartz, 2004: p. 329, ~,.)~I~~) Ulb 4.l~l ~l ..ill~~
~lS'~I ~lS' I~! LA~..9 r~)U~.?-i.J-Ai ~LlA :~Lt, ~UA~~~l

•
c'"°-"4 . '\,e.,& • .:ui ·-~ !t~ •• ,t4..J...uLal~UoLlu.Jt
"T '~ ~ ~.,....... . e:4 u,,"I ~,,~w
'-l..-:c:i ~ ~
..u.l,~•..!,!._.,
,... r
..i4i
.(Pitt and Groskaufmanis, 1990: p. 1639; Brandl and Maguire, 2002) r~")!I
:~ll.(J.:J:0:.-.q
~
..b-i c.,--
-::1 ...
~~' ~~ ~ ~ ~6. ~ .:,S'l f1 ~~ d..lJ..U4 t~

~l f1 ljf 4bl4
· .)J..u- L
..ill~ (>A . u ~ . L:'i
J-:!:C- '"ft-' ~~~I
-
' l.a.bu:;~l-1.-:c.jf
~ u- . r- .Lu~I
-
•(Schwarz, 2004: p. 330) $11
~Wlj.w:wl
......... ,. . ,~,.,, ?TT)
~ a,jJ..u,I ~ ~J.A .¥b U ~J ~~I \ S.!cil;J.A <>-4 u~~I ~ j i 1~1

..w ~ ~ '1 Ji ~IJ~ d..li ~ ~_,1.uJI l.!.U.J.l w~.,ll ~ ~.J.ll c.:.,l_,JI
(Murphy, 1988: p.909; Ethics Resource Center, 1990, ~~ a,jJ..l.1.1 ..l.44i
. pp.V-1; Harris, 1978: p.312)
uw..,..u.1 wl ~ w ~ ~ ' wi J~ :4.Ai.,:..tt u~~~ ul:5~t ~

fl ~ ~
-:ti ul..S'·'
...u3 1.7""" · .ti ~.-:q ~.I ... tl_i "= ,_-:-: o.)~ Llb I • • .... ·I
..
.. ~J~__J.,- ~-~ J ~( .) .~...
fl
. (Raibom and Payne, 1990: p. 884;) ~ W I ~ u4~1J a_jJ.J.41J ~~I

~ ~ u4~ LlJ..u.l ~ wi Y.?.J ~1 ~J-:!.AJ ~l.i,j..-.u'-1.;~i l.!.U~
w§J wi ~ '"->..»-i o.;~ .(Laczniak and Murphy, 1991: p. 269) t sa.!:bi
~fi~ ~ .(Murphy, 1988: p. 909) uWWI w~ a.!~IJJ ~IJ uwJ..u.1
wl.:t cl.!JI ~~ 'ii a,jJ..l.1.1 ;;~I~ .J.ic. ~_,.1.1 ~ ~ » d..JL:i <>"wls:....u.ir?"J
.(1990: p. 1649) <<~I JW>.IJ ~.)t:aJ ulo_,.t.l ~~ ~-"'"" \+A~i Wl=t:.A
u~~;;
.. .. :.la.A~_,.1.1
'..)-'-'J • .. aS'.) Ll-A~• ~J ~1;;'.) Ll.'11
~ f-l.. ~ :~.,ttas
- !) L:i.4
~ ~ l.!.LI~ ~1 o.;Ll.?JI y~t ..1>i •(Messmer, 2003, p.14) a,jJ..u,I ~~1

(EthicsResourceCenter ' LlJ ..u.t;;·~ ·.. !,~.q
'.) .. . ~ :. ··~--:t~l~I
r .)~.J-l...r- .. . ..
1990, pp.11-3; Montoya and Richard, 1994: p. 714; Arndt, 1990; Sweeney
~ '1 ~.J.ll ~.,JI~ .and Siers, 1990: p. 34; Molander, 1987: p. 628)
\.fl~ <>-4 o.;~4 ..u~ ~-"'"" d.,j..,..u, ~~1 ~ ~.;Ll-A wl:i ~~' ~~
a_...llJJ ~Ll.A cJ~ d.,jJ..ul u ~ wi !Y°.>9 <>-4 ..u.JJ ~J-""" ~ . ) ~ wi '11
. (Schwartz, 2004)
~l.9 ~ oJij.11 JAl_~I ..1>i :o.;btft ~ J l:,Wt o.;t~tft ~~ ~ J ~ t

~ ~~ ~_,.1.1 ~J-&A o.;~ ~ ~ I u~.)~I ~1 u.;Ll.l ~IJ a,jJ..u,I
(Montoya and Richard, 1994: p. 714; Ethics Resource~~ a,jJ..u o.;b?JI
Center, 1990: pp. 11-1; Brand and Maguire, 2002; Trevino and Nelson,
\.fl~ <>-4 ~ ~ fAi» cJ~ cJ.).)_P.- <>-4~ ,J\:i.1.1 ~ ~ .1995: p. 252)
'='"'""~IJ JA~I ~..ul ~ J ~ I ~ ~wJ akl.9 ~~ ljJ..l.4 .)_P.-J w~
..lS'i ~ .(Jordan, 1995: p. 305) «l....:WI ~.;bu aS'~I o.;bl ~ ~ w---4
~~I~ ,.. ,;Q ,;.,; • l:,WI o.;b?JI ~.) ~,.).)! ~ i jJ.;I~ c1.......&..ul.;.) ~ w_,:i~I
~ c:,.,->=.J.41J _µ,..,
d.,j..,..u.1 ~ b ~ o.;b?JI t~ 0~.,11 ~1.;Lj,f <i'11
~ ~W!JulS~ 4=,i$~1a.sWJ1.;-J_,Jo.3 :J~~, u~~ ~Lwl.4ll &A~,~
IZ.¥£2M"14•i@,"''N·kifW•>r;fil-E£,.>i~ilSSiffiil'am'mi!!M'rE:!Q!E~'w.Bl:E::mm~.~~-,$h.:fi'!~
,Jlill ~ ~ • ~~_j a:,_,..ul ~ 0 ~ 0-J-H..ul 0i ~J-AAJ ' 5 ~ [ j ~

ofo .J..:i as~ ~~I ~_;JI 0-4 a.Jlu,j ~ J ~ I 0~ ~~I~ c)A~
~~I ~ J .•• oµI "~ c)Aji wi ~ J~_j .a:,_,..Lll ~ .(,j ... » :o~
. (Schwartz, 2004: p. 332) «~S: cS::>J c.;JI
~~~I~~ lsa.:.,b;~a.L:,~a:,J.J.A~J~l~lc)A : ~ I
(Benson, 1989: p. 318). ~i ~_;JI ~~I y ~ i l.!.LJj ~ ~ as'~I ~
~IJJ c)A 1.-S~I ~Jj....J ~>l,;.~I ~L....:,_,..ul 0~ .>A-'-"~ fij jLlt.l ~ Jc_
~~ ':ii ~i 't .:~I ~~WI~ c.rAJ o..,\.:,..IJ a.lb.~ UJ._?.J
~IY- ,l.!.LJj ~1 ~~1 .(Hosmer, 1991: p. 25) i.G.:, .:aiill '5~1 ~ ~.,.ti
~
clJJ..Ulc),44:,- e r r • ~ 1~01~~_,J.1~0~ ~~ (.~
-· .. • • C. • • .. - .... .. • •
~_,:J~ i~ ~ I ~.J: ~ .(Pitt and Groskaufmanis, 1990: p. 25)

0:JJ.,11J ~~IJ ~~I ~~IJ ~_,:JI ~':its'_,_, ~~I y ~ i JJ ·o=--~
.(Webley, 1988: p. 15) a,jJ..Lll 0-4 ~ ~
0t .j-AJ a .!41.11 ~~J~I ~ r~

J~I l.!l~ :u44aJl:tJl,-itft
c)A l.!.LJjJ ,~~ )~1 '4>-~ 0t ~ a.kW! ~L....:,_,..ul ~ JJ ,o:>JI
l..A I~ - ~ .le" t Ll .41.J J~':il i I • - .4 I .~~, .. •.. !t!..q 1.-SI
J ~ J ~ J '-8-1 ~ ~ . . , . . . ~
.. I J ~
.(Gibbs, 2003: p. 41; Pitt and Groskaufmanis, 1990: p. 24; Lane, 1991: p. 31)
~_,.1.1 ~b~I ~~' ".LAJ../:u 0i J ~ I 0-4 0 ~ i 1.-S~ ~ . ,
~I.JJ ~ ~~I 0-4 J~ .JL.1ui ...(gJ . (Trevino and Nelson, 1995: p. 247)
.(Schwartz, 2004) Jl~?/1 ~1~1~1 ~ llil_,.1.4 ~ I 1.-S..9~1 ~ ~1 _µJ~
,ti9.,:JI r~J~I ~4\..a.j~~(Y) JA~ JJ..,:at (i) : ~ 1.-S.,~, ~~
.as~! ((~)) ~1 ~ (A )J ,~I rl..U:.l l.!.LJj ~ ( J) o..LiWI rl..U:.I (d
:~~I ~ j .)Ll,j ,cc~I» ~ ~ ~ J
r=9~ ~ u~ ~ t 'i ~ J ••• Y--~ ~ ' t-4 JAL.:lll u~ ~ t ...
•~ I L.>-4 ~ ~~ ~ u~ o~l ~.:,JI ••• ~ ~ ~ &9.,:Jl '-"°~~I
~'i.o~o·
. . -
<;.
- • '..r-" v°
~~I 1... c....c..uS:J1
c.r- . - ·-·l~t ~··i ~·.,,
~..)JJ (.)
1...
J-' <..r--
~1.;4aJI ~u ~) ... ~ l ~ I ~~ ~tg ~~ ~ &9.,:JI ... ~
.(Schwartz, 2004: p. 333,
ofo ..l.:ia,jJ..Lll ~ )j!f'4 ~.,.ti~~ 0i ~10»>-i 0.,_j~ ~i LS

.)Ll,f .J.41 -ls:i~l.;-4l~~J~Jc)A ..u_J:i ~i~J~.J'.'! rrr)l.!.U~.,,o~
.a"3', 4- :zcs--.w ... fti:mwcil. J0431.Zi,'.~~--- ~
~~ '1..LL9 ~ '-if.:All Lo.Jc.~ ,~u :u~1 ~ ~Lwl.4ll.J a.w~,

~~µ,~.,:a,~~~ ~_j),:!J.A~ 0t ~' cJA 0t ~1 ~~' cJA .l..LC
.~~ lA~4 ~ i ~ 1.)-4~ 0i ~i cJA c.ill~j ,djj...u.l
I~~Yt '-:':f.J.Qt
~ r~~, .;1~)1 Li.lb.:i'il ~_;-A~' 4-4µ1 u ~ j j ~ ~ ~ j
the US Federal Sentencing Guidelines for Organizations (FSGs) ul..cJo.UI
(US Sentencing Commission, 2004)r~~11.;l~?Jo~l~~'i.,JI ~ ~.;~i<jJIJ
I :'bi A ~)l;.~I ~_;..i:JIJ JU:&.o'il ~ ~ (t.) ABY,, o.lUI (.)A--U»
~)\.;. ~I ~_;..i:JI J ~ ~ o-A r:---JJ ~ ~ I ~ ~ I u'=.,i , , Q.\J
~I u ~ \ ~J~o-A~.,.llJ L_;b?JI ab! ,cell ~~Ll.4,.,tb;~
J~~~4JI~~ .c,~~JJa Qt;.,;t\~-'"4~~1~~1
~~I~ o_,jj.A .>--t):. uLlJ...u.1 ~ ~\S:.J\ ~_;..i:JI 0J~ 4Li4 LlJ...u.l
(Pitt and Groskaufmanis, 1990: p. 24; Gellerman, 1989: p. 77; Lane, 1991,
p. 131; Benson, 1989: p. 318;Gibbs, 2003: p. 40; Messmer, 2003: p. 13).
,u\~ · \.:..J\ ~
· t ~,, ~L.,,~I
• --. r .- · ~~ ul..cJo.UI r ~ ,J~I ~~
(.)A
t. · · ·· 1-
¥)\.;.~\u~lj~~'r'~,,~w,~ta..a..i_;Jo~~_;..i:Jl,)J.l~'~
~ .(Ethics Resource Centre, 1990; Trevino and Nelson, 2007) u'iWI Ji
04 0JP"~\ r~ ~_;..i:JI c.illj ~ ~ i ~ .,1< ,\: ~ I Jljl.o ~.JJI ~_,JI
1
~ ~~)11 uld~kj'i\ ... ,, c)A J.J_j.ll ~1 ~.l.H J~ ~I u~)\.;. i ~ ~_;..i:JI

~ ••• »d_jf Jf(Valentine and Fleischman, 2004: p. 386)((a.!Q.!loiit\u~)l;.~I
.(Weber, 2007: p. 61) «~I~~ ~)l;.\'I ~_,J..uJI ~ ~~1.>i~
~)l;.\'I ~_;..i:JI IY'JJ cJA c...9.J.fll ,(Gellerman, 1989, p. 77) 0Lo~ ~ J
0 ~ (.)'°~~I ~L...c!aA o.;l:il _j,A c.ill~ c)A ~~I ~J ~.l4ll .;tp ~ ~
0lSA?JI .;~J .o.>:4-4 .>--t):.J ~ ~.l4ll IL1.ti ~ ~ 0~ ~ <?I t~J~I
o~I c)A 0~ 0t ~ <?I u'iWI ~ ~ ~~ ~_;..i:JI 0 ~ 0i ~
~ w:?.;~I (.)'°~~I y.;4,J ~ ~ 0i _j,A c.ill~ c)A ~~IJ ~ ,a.!,el_,.11
~I u'iWI cJA ~~~ ~1 (Lane, 1991, p. 31) ~'i .;~i ~ -~_;..i:JI IY'JJ
~~ ~ 4-4~ ulAy_;ll....u JJ~I t..,_al ~ -~_;..i:JI J)l;. \.,a..Al~I ~
~_,J ~ I J>.l.l ~ ct Q.!Q «oi ~ ~l:-JI t_,111 Loi ·<J.l~...u.l ~ljj ~)l;.i
~ ~~I ~ f ~ ~.LJI ~_,JI~ .J~)U ~~I t~J\'I ~ ~~...u.l
•·· -:.t~,.q
~..,...
~
•
l~
· •~~- ..1a ,(Schwartz ' 2004) a..ubl ;;. •~:
... ·- ~
L..U
-~
Jj1J ... I
.)-J.)~
:. LI.)..)
~.;-2, c...a~J ~1 c.i..)~ ..1a w JUIJ c.:,l.,U J-1.A ,tj t ~ ~...)..Li.JI ~ a._jj4,.Jl
·d_jJJ.ll
~ I Lt.-t r~ ~...)..Li.JI ul.)j...Uls -~...)..LJI ~ i ~~I cJA ..)~ ~~

~I ~)U ~~~I~ Ji d_jJJ.ll ;;_,j~ ~;LI ~J ;;..)'-!) ~i cJA y_,!hll
:d_jJJ.ll ~ as'~I ~
.y~ ~.l J~~ cll~j ... ~ ~,., ( ~ ~ , ~IJJ.>.ll) ~ u#
~..U (,)• f c:::--u--JJ
• .t..~ ...": •.<'t .o-~
..C' ~~I
.. .. -~1 "(to'
.J\:6' 4.J\:6'
H ..
• •
• r. ,,-f ebi
~~ t- ..
II
01··
!.)-1 Li.,.JJ
.. ,~u,., , ..:. as-~,~·
~ '.) • • ~ ~~, r..14i LA~ a.....,~,
... o'.)J.JJL•
:!.)
I-~ -
~
.a;c-:- ~'I) as'.' J-'"·'I.~
l."i '?""" - r.r
l.!.l:i~~.. JJ~ .. J cll.:U o~
'"- 4-4.0 ··.<'ti 4...i..4.A~I. __,,, LA
.. '-:T" lj
.(Schwartz, 2004: p. 333, ~IJlta.!I 4b ~) (~IJ~J.JJI ~~
ui ~ cJA .Jt~ ~t; ~Ll..4> u~ ..1a ,tjf ~J UWJ..UI LI.)~ ~I~ ~i
.(Trevino and Nelson, 1995, pp. 249-150) d_jJ..1.41J ~;LI~ a.!1;.6 ~ Y.J-':!
as-~1 J>.bcJAu~ul ~~...).J.jjl u~JJ.JIJ1u LIJ->~~411 ~t ~
~...JI .~,i«uJI Jt:9 cJA "~'.!oii: d_j.J~ (J~~I ~J~ Jl ~~..ul ah-,1_,:, <.it)
t. ·-af ~~
u--- · L • (• . ) ~• f.fJ• l <..;r-
I,.. (>J~
• · •~ ~ · ,Juli ~
..l..4ll ~ ~ . ) l;JI
1- • •
I.· · ·· <..;r-
· · .<"f ~~
0-4..J-:- 1.~-: '- - - · ~ . ~ Jj1J
.L..U -~<"i ~
~- t ; ~ ... "'·-·~as.
• -~-•L ~\.;.JI ctsl..a1tl
'..r-'.
~ ;;..)...l.LiA y~i ~ll..t. J.,u.t.1 ~J -~~..ul ~ cJA ~...J.J.jjl ~ LA~ ~;LI
'->...u u~ ~ ..1a -~.)\.;.JI) .~,i.,,11 J;9 cJA ~...J.J.jjl ~,.!.;;; y~J ~i o-4 ~~
~...J.J.jjl ~ ~~I ~...u ~ Jl d_jJJ.ll ~ ~...J.J.jjl ~ ;;J..1411 ~~..ul ~
4>bA» ~...J.J.jjl ul.JJ..L......ll ufi:i ~ ..1a ,c.ill~ ~1 Ls~J .J)l;..)U ".J~I,. ·: •u:
-~..;.J.jjl j.!.;,; ~ ~ u~..1..o ~.)Ll. 1~1 « ~
ulb)UIJ rW ~I u~ ~ IJ ul..,..:;ull J)l;.. cJA j.Jj.a:Jl;;.JLl,~I~ ..141 :~_j.a:Ut
d_jJJ.ll~Ls~i.JJ->~~iu~~~l~J~luWS'Jl~jj:,SJ~l..u~IJ
.(Pitt and Groskaufmanis, 1990: p. 24; Trevino and Nelson, 2007: pp. 248-253)
~ I j.J_j.a:a.JI uJ~ ,tjf ~1 IJ.JLl.f 0;!jjl J:i.JIJ1u LIJ-> ~ u_,:i~I c.ill~ JS'l ..1aJ
- ..
·.~.~,, ·t ~ .b ...L::t:A ·~'!.t~.q~ .. I. .. 1-d_j ..ul
•.• '!.t~ ... lt
~.,.......~.>J-.r-w u J ... ~ ~ . r ~<..:r- ~ ..>-:J:.t; u •, . C' ~
... 4
~ c.ill~ uJ~J -~J..1.41l J~)U ~~ ~ji ~I ~~IJ ~~I IJS'.J-':! u~

:..>#f ~.J~ '-41A4,.:i ~..J ~T Jgt d_jJJ.ll
0J~J ... l.!l.,L..JIJ ~IJ ~l.a:i.ll ~ i:.,l ~_,J ~ 'iJ -~J .l~ ~l
o.lL:.?/J~I ~ ~6.~~t -~Jo,4~l ~ ~_,JI ,15~l.;J-4l
..... t:..~:,. I... 4..4,J~ JC&J.11.!.\J.:LJ o~~ ~Ll., ~)LI ~.-:II .... ,l.~tl
L..i..,f c.:r-
~ 4.>" - J .J J - ,.....J r--=--
. (Schwartz, 2004: p. 334, ~l.;4-,ll ~ ~) ~ ~ J c:..,.b lAl
~-lb.:i~I ~->-4~\ a......oµ1 a~y 0---4 AB'1',' ojll.\ r-J-b :'iJl~J ~

~ ~ as'~\ the US Federal Sentencing Guidelines r~ ~I 1 1...LI..::)'j
as'->1Wl~~~.,i~~l~_,..i:i~» :~~~I ~w.r.1~JJ~
~ .,,~~~I ~w~IJ J~~I u~ ~~\ a.:'.:· ,~,;JI al:JJj-uJ.I ~i ~
((J~ ~' JJ~» ~i ~ O.l~ ~ I llA ~1 J ~ ,o~I ~_;-A~' a~,
J)l;.. ~I~~ ~.,11 ~ ~Uo ~ ~~ ~ ':?.:UI_, «J~~I JJ~n Ji
~
J)l;..'it~w.r.1~~ - ~
~.,~~....~.11 t1A0fi:01~ .as-~,~
u~ ~~\ ~)LI Jg~\~ ~IJ J~I ~J ~.,11 i.S-Ll 0~ ui ~_..,
uJ~Y.J ~)l;..~I ~w~I J ~ ~ ~411 ~..ill~~"°'= .Ll..,...u.1 a ~
~lhll 4:~ ~ J~ ~I ~Wj-;1 ~ ~~ o_;b?JI ~ ufi: 0t ~1 ~WI
.(Pitt and Groskaufmanis, 1990: p. 1642)
~i ~~ ~)l;.. ~I ~w~\ a.ut.;~ ~ ' ~ ~~ :u~~ ~· ~.J

(Ethics Resource Center, 1990: pp.VII-I; Pitt a ~ ~ , J..-.+g ~ aLl>4,l.J
a ;;.:; ..JI~ .andGroskaufmanis, 1990,p.1645; Gellerman, 1989: p.78)
r~~l _;I...Ll..::)?J ~-lb.:i~I ~->-4~1 c!.Aµl u~y ~ AB'1',, oJU.I u'5!1 rJ.--.':i
:~ a ~ I The US Federal Sentencing Guidelines
c;JI ~l;J~I ~ .Jl ~.:UI .r4~I J---AJ ,,;\J ~L:...ulJ rllo.j ~ J ~ I •..
•• t..~ .... '·')l.;.. -:11 , ~ •• -.:.._q ~~~I .• 1.:.. ..1.U
~ I ~JA • .:.1.:.. c=---= "'fr' (>A '-:T"" J - :,--- J .)~r . ~
-
r~'ll 0-4 ~_,.;. 0J.l ~ I Jl ~ I ~I?. )II ~l#.,.UI ~ ~)II ~~J

.l.!.\J~ ~ ¥ .lLli.;)11 ~ J ~ I Jl
J.;Ji .~)l;.. ~I ~w~I d.......&.ul_;~ ~ \ 0,.4 ~ \ ~ I llA ~ l ~"°'=

~~I J~~I ~_F» ul ~J uL:.>4,1.J ~i ~J J ~ o.;~ ~}\A 0J.;.P.-
~ J-i:,S ~~ c4 llil~ ufiJ ~ ~~I_,<< ~ I ~l:s.;JI » al_;_~ _;-J:;J ~LuJ\
W'.::' ...u~IJ «ub..l~~I JJ~» ~ as'~l i . S ~ ~ ~l-¥1J .u~~I
~~I ~Li. LAi .(Jordan, 1995: 312) u~~?JI ...u~I ~ i ..,t ~lS:.1.1
·-·
~~ 41d ~ 'i?~t Lo..9 ~~ tjU : u ~ I ~ Jl.w.iltJ 4-4.J~t
----------- 1"\ t
~ 4latW!J ulS_,..:i.u ~~ \tt ~~t ..,.a__,b.:i :J~\tt u ~ ~ ~Lw.ilt ~ ~ t ~
c:;;r;;::r;:;;::1m7~,.r.p;;i,S.adL&rnJ:.:4et.. -..-..-·. :,,,.H\i·""i:l··~ri+Lt:.:P@-'S-.:-;-:·.rn~~:nr;::-~~Ycilf.:;~~
1
~ .~l.uJI ik;J\ ~l 0-4 ~J "?.:.UI ~...\.fll ~~ 0.¥-4~ ..P;I.~ LI.J.l ~

~l~.•:}11 ~ ~.J.>JI ~ c:l:i->-° i.Llj~ ~ "}! 0l:P-~I ~ ~ ... ,, :Jul.I~
~_;JI ~...u uSJ f1 I~1 (~WL:.J. I ~ ) ~ ~J---'-" ~ Li.A c.illJ>- fA 0:.:.UI
•. .
. (Schwartz, 2004: p. 336) <<5..!l..>:..l.4 c.:,11 ~.J.>JI ~
c.ill.JS'J) ~JJ.4ll.) 4j cut\ ~ I <Jj c.:,--11 ~ \ ~ _# J ~ j :J..!!hCJI
(Pitt and Groskaufmanis, 1990: LlJ..Lll ~ W f'S-4 (\so.::bi 0 ~ ju,ljtll
p. 25; Sweeney and Siers, 1990: p. 39, Gibbs, 2003, p. 40; Messmer,
,Jul.I~~) d..JIJ..LJI ~ t~"}!l 0i c.:,11 oJ~?JI ~ ~ ~. 2003: p. 14)
~1--lt~L:.J.l~l.6'·'
• '..J--- - ~ _'\o'.)-'-'J:.LAw-'--
... q.~ •
:.~ ·i ·<-·(Ll~ ..u.l ~
~ j-J~ u ~
·.<c "
..r-
~U.OJ d..l.lL:. 0~ 0i ~ a ;;:bll ~~I LAi .(Trevino, 1992: p.647)
.i!J .(Raibom and Payne, 1990: p. 888; Molander, 1987: p. 630) Wl.:t:...Jj
l>.j:i "}/j ~ I ~~I ~ I <)J~ cGiyjl~ L....ul.).l~<)_,:i~I FJi
. (Schartz, 2004) 4:!~ ~J..ll.l
,~t. -tt - - A.LJ't ~ t~

.~~~ ..... tt ~.
o.lUI l:-.n.~ ~ ~ L4 _j-/bJ ~Ll~I 4ku ~..w ~ J~i
f'LS::,..~I .Jl~?J ~.ll....,.:;"}!I ~->-4~1 L ~ I ~~.,_:; u--4 Abr,,
: the US Federal Sentencing Guidelines (US Sentencing Commission, 2004)
t l.ul
. J ~ I 4.J~I
. . · JS't:ill (l) ~
(.>A -
~t-•-:.
~
~\..;ul ~ I ~,... ~
• ·-
·<:r4l~?Jl l.!l_,l...JI ~ ~ I J ~..LillJ ¥1Jll ~~ ~ . . J ,~)l;.~I ~w~I

... ~)l;.~I ~W_HJ ~ I Jl:c:i.AI ~Lil ~_,;....JI r.:.:aiJI (y) (J)
a:,~ ..u.l.J. ~
•_, !t!..q
: r r" 1-:.-:t\ ___ ;.t ~, •.~.• ti ... t:.•.-::fl .Atl..G.JI r" l ~ I u. .l~..¥?- u
'..;-w ~ ~ ,....-- J ~ i.;r:-
..1:.'-Z\\.j
~..,.Jl Fl r,1~1 c.:,11 JL:ui ~ .(Jordan, 1995: p. 312) ~~.;~IJ
0-4 .l~ ~Ji~ .J~~I a_jJ..l.4.>J_,.b:iJ ~ I ~Lo:i .J:~J 4lull ~l..,..t.
(Murphy, 1988: p. 909; Pitt and~ a:,J..U.I ~~ ~w.,..u.l LI.)~ ~ I
.Groskaufmanis, 1990: p. 25; Driscoll, Hoffman, and Petry, 1996, p: 156)
4:!~ ~J .~~ ~I ~w_;-tll JlullJ jALlJI ..>-1JkJI 0-4 ~.?.- ~I..G.11 ,,:u, JS'
~ . } l u=JI a.: 111.:~.;JI ¥~~I F-1 ~ ~~ ~\.j~I wfi.: 0i ~ "-~L...ht.l
.~~ , .~L.ub. "~l:&A ~ Ll~l ~ '··...u -:q as'- .:..q. ('f .,,~j
,'"&" .. J '"&" .. ~ - .. ~ - '""~ ~ '-:?"'"' 'J-""*' u--1J
w~~~ A ~1,,;i~-,-... ~~ :c.-., Jill'I, a *2V :.,-..w-,._.._...,.,
1"\0 "6l~ A.1.a.9 ~ '?~I LoJ ~..L.=-l fall : u ~ t ~ ~l.w..:Ll!J w~I
.l.P.-J LAl .~l.;J JALl. ~)l;..l ~lj.J-H ~.l ~ 01., ~\S' 0fi:i "j ..is \+iL.u.;~J
·0~1 ~~ ~LlA F- ~ o.;~ ~ t ~ a.j9)l;..\JI o.l~I
,JALl. ~)\.;. t ~lj..H j-J_,.b:;J ~ , ~ LlA ~ ~ a.j9)\.;. 'ii ~ I 0"->1:- ~ l.;J

~ji 0i ~ ,as'..,_.!Jl a.j9)l;..\'I ~~I~ J ~ I ~t &.o ~L:t ~ a.l.;J
tone at the top (Schwartz, Dunfee, and Kline, ~ I o.;b~ 4:!.l~I o~I»
0~1 .;Ll.T ~I~ •2005, Sheeder, 2005; Weaver and Trevino, 1999)
o~I ~ ~ .•. 11 :a.j9)\.;.'ii o.l~I ~ ~ a s ' ~ a.j9)\.;. ~I ~~I 0l ~1
L~u.,..- w, '- --· ...
· ., .. ~ L.J.tll;;
- . t_ 1.·- 4 L ~ , . ___j\u)l;..\JI
b"il - .. t_ • ~~u-=r.
~ • i.J,J~~ ~ -
~~1 .(James, 2000: p. 54) <1~L.ul, ~ LA o..lA~ a.j9)l;.. ~I a~j.ll ~
u)l;..~l~I
- .. t-~t ~..)"'
-· j-J_,.-., ":.ti ··-~·'I
..r---- ~·t ~'-o.llall C.~ .,~~~,,,'1l.l~ (.;r--'1
· J-! ~
Dfi~ U ~J .(Trevin~, 1990: p. 203) <1l....s:k, ~WIJ ~~~~I
~)\.;. ~I ~_,:al ~..,JI .;~I o.lWI 0~ 0t ~)) 0J--'-"J-:!AJ ~Li.J_;JJ 0JI..H
~l .;Ll.t ~~ 01 J., Brown, Trevino, and Harrison, 2005: p. 117 ,,~_,..JJ
~~JJJ.lJ)\.;.)U» : ~ I ~~I .l.P.-JJ~)l;..\11 o.lWI 6:!al~ .l.P.-J
.(Northouse, 2001: p. 255) <1~1 ~ ~ b ~ o.lWI ~b ~ o.l~I
U -~~ .~)l;..~I - ~ al)WJ ~t
t., ~., ---ti Ll)l;..~I
t., o.l~I · -
- ~J - • I ~- ~
- ~
a ~ I ~ .llj-S)U ~)l;..\11 ~~I 0l..:t ~ I aL.u_;IJ.11 ~bj~ji»~ DP~
0l..:t ~.,.ti al&.~I ~~.?. ~p_;:; .(Hitt, 1990: p. 3) «o.lW4 i~p~
a.j9)l;..\JI ~~I~~ ~J0~~~Ja.! '".!~.;a.j9)l;..l ~~...>:J.A~.u
, ·, • • • &.o.J:iS~ ~~ ~~~\S' ~IJ~..»-iJ~~ Ll.;.u ~J .as'~
:o~I a~"i_,.JI ~ ~.,.ti 6-4
~, ... ~
_t;.-:~
~ .. a
I('
. ! :~
·'"··. .· .. "· -~-'I '7"'1
- I .(>J~ ..LllJ v._,..r- .. .:.t:....q
l.)~y, ~
. ,~~. G ~
u~ LA.)~ ~IJ J~ \14 U~J ~~ ~J.:G..~ J~ \14 u~ ~t

•• <' ... 4,jf ~~
I.)~
• ·'"')4.J.Jb} -'"-<'l • .('-:~~~"tu.JI ~ I . )·Ls,LlL~,1~
-· - - ~ w.,...... ,
1
."ft""'~.
'L
Ll~\11
- L~L
- - ..<' c.r-JJ c.r.J-J
.~ • 'WI ·
~J ~ c.r
-~\II ~· l.!J.1...11 · I.)P..i:; l.!l~ c.r
~-~ -"-'I u--
I.:. I.)·
(.)A
~-
I .:G..\I 1.).,....,...,...
· . .:.t:....q l.:d.,~
. - ~~.) \II ~1...J Lu
-~'WIJ
~WGJ.I ~ ~f'IJ ;;JI.)~ ~ I J4:i-- \II J~l ~ ~ J J:Sl ui,,~ ~.,_...,J
.(Trevino et al., 1999: p.142) (~4 LAJ:i.ll ;:st 0 jJ~ ~.,....,J ¥~\II
~ ~W!J u\S..,.:JJ ¥~\'14.iWll..>J..Job:i :J~\'t ul.Ja.i..o ~ JlwMilt ~ ~ , ~
k#Skh1...fajS£{ ...t.jp.·.:-\J~+?M@?-f<.13'j{i i:}~··l!$:f .·.~.\d-np§ffi·/WN·#itk #i§\\-·.'4@¥ Af@&~-~·+& ~···¥1£N,. ·6?§~%§&-o· r•·WH£¥6y$-.:jf;f1.,wN-1·!Ai-N£¥>t'lr~·~wr:a
1
0t~,Jw:.~IJ~~~~~lo.l~l~~~l~~l<)A~yl~
y~4', ~ ~J ,Jlill ~ ~ .o.l~-'"4~ o.l~I ~ ~ 0~ k~I ~Ll.A
0~o~la~~.,.tl ~ ~ I . J ~ \, • • • <)A~i<)A~ 1.'r· 0~Gallup
~.)~» a.;s~t~la..o ~..UJ 0.HJY ~t ~ <J:-:~' Jw:.~I ~.>:.J.A ~1
al)-:-uJI ~~ ~Wl ~~l...A <)A Jgi I.J.AJ .«4lc. ~.J.l»J «i~ 4lc.
Jr r · · °' rl.c. ~ ~ t ~ . (Gallup, 2004) (1.lr) 0_,.,_µtJI ~IJAJ (1.n)
<)A 1.'W 0t Harvard Business Review J~)U .l~.J~ ~ ~1...,.:a 0---4 \ , • n
~-•~~.a:,~ la.Ao~law~·'I.
ffJ~ -~ l.JA.Jlo
.. .,.. ~ .. '.) b~I.
• ~ _Aa..a,j...G..oa..a:;
.. ~
..u.D:J~
:.,.-.q
a.& ~IA ~· alS'~I ~
.. : . ) - l.JA.JI
.. • • ~t ~ ~ ..u 1.o, J
o'.) b~L ,4.4.,LuJI
. ~I~
-
J ~ ~ ~~~I o.l~I ~ ~...uS:.11 a~4Jojl ~lS'J .(Podolny, 2009)
(lpsos-Reid, 2003) ..u...J <>"~1 ~ ~J -~..JA~I ~1}, ~~ Jw:. ~I
0~..u.l~ .«-;~0~<)-4~''1.J:!~1.;Jl~~~l<).4 \, • •V JI~~
~~ ~ ~~ ~.J~ ~t ~ ~J ,~~I ~l.;T <)A 1.n ~ 0..9:!~I
~..9:! ~J (1.l\) 0:46J.IJ (1.,,) ~.... ,oJIJ ,(1.,,) ~ I ~ <J:!.:UI al.J~I
6~1 o.J.AJ.!'~.; .(1.°') ~_,JI a........u.LuJIJ (1.\ ·) al.J~I ~4 <)A~i ~
.Jw:.~I o.lUl ~~ ~I ~I~ ~ I alc.~I <)A ~..,..U >tfi ~ .l~J ~1
-;a_;s~ ~I o.l~ i . S ~ ~ 0..9:!~I 0~..U.IJ 0~..u.l 0~ u#, I.LJ
~ w 0,J~..u.1 .J~ c-°~'+4 J~I ~.,.ll 15..u ~ ,a~WI ~ i ~
aL&.ul.J.l~Jl.iJ ..ill - ~ ~~i <i•q ,,,a.!Q;; as'~I o.lle ~~ '1.....,.jf
wW.J~ <>"~J 0Jl...>-~J 0~~.J~l .a,Q •.,JI o ~ <i.:Q;; ~ o.l..1......L&A
o.l~ 0:!~ ~L...lA 0i ~1 (Trevino, Brown, and Pincus-Hartman, 2003)
u4-.;. .~.JI~~ .((J_,.L;JI .>:..u.1,, ~J «J_,.L;JI (.)'°--.;. ~.>l,;.~~11 .~.JI»~~.,
~~ .... · j I,.. {: ..u.1,~rf) '-'..,............
... · I.:.. ti
~u ~ .. J J ~ ~~
J~h, ~ JA~ ~~~4 LA~I ~..J yly.o.JI ~)) d.,jj ~ .):..14.U _Hill
15~ 1 ~ ~.>l,;.t ol:?- ~ 0i., ~ J~~ ~ 0 ~ 0t., r'~'-'
pb;9~.>l,;.~l.>:..u.l ~ lAi .(Trevino and Nelson, 2007: p. 265) <<y·o;...1&JI
~.,.,., C'° F ' J r.,:UU' J~~4 <f'.,.t.uJI ~~~, <r~~, .)J.l .)~h, ... ,, ~
<<~l.t...Jl ~ J .l~~aJ~LuJ.a~~I r'~rlJ;.; 11·4JF-IJJ~~I 0 ~
. (Trevino and Nelson, 2007: p. 266)
f\V
~\.;:J\ 0i <.JA ~l:JI ~~~~I o.l~I J~'j ~w ~l.u._,JI j:,5l 0i ~ I<.JA
illl~ ~ . ("~ f illl~ ~LlA ~ ~) ~~ ~I F-1 c4 ~1_,:i: ul)~I ~\S'
ul.) I·~,, 1~- • ~
l.!.ll:i u-- ·t ,,.. · ~ I (>JJ: · ,~~. LA~ l.:,..~
· ..L41J ~ · j J-'-
-~('j
'J-- (.)j - ~ <..r- ~ -
0 i ~ 0i ~ ,15~i;;J~ .~UI ~WI <.JA as~I ~ illl~y~ LA~~
.~LiA
• ~ · ~~~j - t 15..r>-
· ~1-tL.oJ.I
C"' ~ - •• a:,~ ~ a..,.t
~j
~I Ll~~I
-
.... :It
r::-
d ~ <>""'""j.l.l Arthur Andersen 0_,_,J.,1jj yJi ~ J .Y' ;;J~I a.LA~I ..1,:,•.i_,
illl~ 0\S' ~ ~~..b.ll ~ I ~~ c4 rLA ~ u ~ ~ ~l_,J.\ ~WI
~l(j"'~l ~~J~l;;J~illl~Cl~~lS'J .LAk. " YA"~0\S'LA~
~l._).j ~ J_,:i_,JI ~ "~ ~ <.JJ--'-".).,1j ~Ip.) -I d. Q I II u ~ J>-"i ~j ~
;;~J.C. ul_,l.uJ as~~~ t ;;...,_;, )~11.JA 0~ . (Toffler and Reingold, 2003)
c4J~J .4+-WI ul.bL:uj ~ ~ "~l..>-4 "~"i ~0_,_,J.,1jiyJi ~ ~
illl~J '<.J.¥-"J.,1jj yJi as_;.,c!, ~~;;~~~~I ~_,!-JI illl~~ ~ u....c,~\
....~
\ :ti <..r-
1,.. a.,:.) ~'ii '.-:Lu,
lo(tol ~ ~• ~ I ..>=J -1~. .:.tt ul~k. ~~ '-9~ - ·-- ui~. LA~
as_;.,c!, ~sl.:~ ~~~~lo> ,~WI ~J~I ~~ ~jll ~~~I
.Enron (Trevino and Nelson, 2007: pp. 292-293) 0J»l
'-:?~\ ..>:..u.l James Burke~~~~ ~ , ' J ~ ~i Jli4 ~ J
~ d~ ;;~~Johnson and Johnson 0~..?.J 0~..?. as..,._.:W
~t <JA~J r'°'AY rk. Tylenol J~~~)bll 4Aji 4AJ~~i <.JA ~
;;~ Jl_,lo illl~ as~I ~ J.41 • ~"i ulJ-'---'-" ~ Wb ~l.Li ;;.J-:!-4 ~
ulJ~"il ~ 4A~I ~ J <?llJ ~~~I~~ -l~"i4 ~~ o.l~
~<JA~.;JI~ .l~I ~~)~\S'<.JA ~as..,._.:Wl~~I ~ .~UI
lfi.ll as~ J:,WI ~~1..>:..u.l ~ I ~4J .(Trevino and Nelson, 2007)
~jl.JIJ~L.o.1.1 ;;J~illl~).li J.41 . ~ ~ L ~ u ~ l ~ ~ A l c o a
JUI JL;jl ~ ~ ~iJ L ~ I J~'4;J ~I.J-:!-4 ~Li.A 0~ ~ ~~ ~yJJ
"'4ilA~J~t ~l ~ .illl~~~_fo.;JI ~ L)LJI ~~ t.Gi r~'!
;;Jl:.).J ~W\ Jy,, "l.:«o;....c:u ~JJ , L ~ I u ~ ~ t_>4~ ~~ - c.,:r1j.lll
.(Trevino and Nelson, 2007: pp. 266-267) u~L.o'j l~J-Li 0--:.:UI ~.'"4
t.jJ~l t.j~I ~~I 4J ~.)-Li <?ll ~~I <11 .. L,! ~ ,~'ii Jl:&.11 LAi
as~ ~4JJI ul~ ~~ ~J) the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce
..>:..u.1 ~ ..1.....4l ·(0-'..; Q~i .. ,JI c4 t.j...LAS' J"iJ.l 0 ~ Y, t ~ J Enron 0~!
~t; c..:rll u.ll <?llJ u~-.,.u]I ~ ~lfo J~I ~~ ~~I ~j .:oiill
____,,____'"""""""'_______.-=-----== = ·- -
1..fj~ 4.1..d ~ 'i?.'..1.tl Loj Q ~ l~ll : ~ ~ I ~ ~~!J Lw~I r,A

~ ~Wt, ulS~ ¥~\'1 lil..di!l.,r1_,l::a.:i :J~\'t u ~ ~ ~1-.iz.tl ~ ..L:,JI ~
eiYiw~·iFi 1(1f:i@jff}i?i::@'.IT,mg;,,,~r*1'2/t'.Yffijjf'efflitt:da,tH1-i?·,,,Ni§d1ru3!"~ts·r:~r,.'"'.9ifl)ih'i+ *W·f·,1
a_;,ts:..obi -~ ~ ~ ,~IJ Jl.b:, c.:,k ~ i c.:,k J ~ I ul.;~ c\l\..a...,.; 1111

c.:,k u~~ I &.LU:i J:.J. p l ~ . (CNW, 2005) ~J p~ q3bJ_,..:; L:-'-... • ,.
~~I ..>:J.1.1 ~ t~I ~.§Jc.)! ~.lJ:!
.. - w ~~ ~I ~ 4 LAl.,µ11 ~ ~ i
·~~i ..dll ~i c.:,k
~.l~lo~l»~~~u~~ I.fl~ "}!d£tAi~~u.t.A,~lf=AJ~J
&.LU:i ~~ ~1 cll~ i,S.li ul:P- ~I~ ~J 0 ~ ~L.o..a.J ,.Pi w ( ~I o_;b~
"'8:i.;b! ~ u~~ ~~ ui ~ ,J\ill ~ c.:,k . (Gini, 2004) u~~I
~~I ~-..>:...lA 0,AJ ~y~I u~~I &.LU:i 0,AJ .~Lal ~.l~I o.;-.u!J ~I
~~ &.WI ~~I lA..>:...lAJ) WorldCom r~ .l.JJ J u l i ~ c.:,k ~LuJI
LA~...lAJ Tyco International Jl.i_j,l,j~1 fi:b as'~J {Bernie Ebbers ~1
Adelphia ~.lf as'~J ,Dennis Kozlowski ~yjfi U"":!-i:.l &.WI ~~I
as-~ ~~I u~~I U"4J .John Rigas <>"4u-J UY.- &.LuJI ~~I l.A~...lAJ
as'~J ,Conrad Black ~)l;, .ll~fi &.WI ~~I lA~...lAJ Hollinger~~
,Garth Drabinsky y< ,., ;11_;.l l!J.;4,. &.LuJI ~~I l.Al~...lAJ Livent ,.. , i.!'i.!1
~J,jb ~~ ~~I lA~...lAJ Parmalat u'l'LA.;4 as-~ 4~?JI u~~I 0,AJ
Ji Jl:u.o)U JALl. ~w.>:' ~...u u~ ~IJ Enron u~i as-~ u! J:, .Calisto Tanzi
LAI~ ...lA t.S ...u 4..Lu.W.I
• ~
. o.lL.a.11
.. 0~ . . ~ti ~ 14 ~1
• • • (.)-' ,... .. ~ .)~
c..:r- w·
I~ .. , ~i "}!! -~~I
'"'
~ I ~bj c_.,k faJ ~.:.UIJ Jeffrey Skilling J ii§ , "~.>4:P:- &.LuJI ~~I
.(Watkins,2003)~~~1~1~J.:.6'..>=J4~J~resultsbottomline~\+tJI
Enron uwl as-~ ~JJ &.LuJI 1.G~I ~J.1.1 Kenneth Lay 1.G'i ,:.,.! if LA!
rlJ?:i ss,I u~! as-~ ~~...lA u,,4ylb .. LA~ ~~~I o.l~I ~ ~...u~~ -
u,,4 ylb .isJ .(Thottam, 2002) 4=1J...ul ~)6.J LP.'"f u,,4 ~~ a:,..~1 a.J~yl
~~ as'~ J:,WI ~~I ~>11 ~J Harry Stonecipher Y2:~~ ~.;LAI
u~ .isJ .~j.!,;;; o~..LA f=A ~~ u~ ":...u ui ~LluS'I ~ a.J~'l'I Boeing
o_;.l4,l.lJ 4UI ~l.iJI u,,4 as'~I 04,.:il ~ u,,4 JS'~ ~J_ycA JJ.lY2:~~
-~~I ~~ ...lA J~ 0-4~~
'"'
· · as-~~~
:. . ~. °Z\~~I ~.t..tl
~ ~~~~
1,.. ~<"~ .. ~tt o..u.J..=-JI
...
(Y2:L.u:s~) ui ~ ~i» as'~I ~~~'.!,;;;~~..LA o~~ U ~J .a.J...u.11
~ I t~J~I, ;,,~.<;ss,·, US' ~.:.UI ~_,JI~ o.l.}o ~~I~~~ u~
'°~ o_;.is u ~ i ... ~I ~...\ZJI ~_j---1-A' ~~ ~ ~~ ui ~~ cll~
. (Merle, 2005: p. AOl) 11rLA'l'I ~ ~.l~I
~ ~ ~ - - - ' : , ( ~ . ~ ~ ~&IICA:llloll----~ Al'6iul.- ~ - - ~ - - -
,..,~ i+,~4.Ld~':f~IL.oJQ~faU :u~,~~~t,w~1

r~J ~ J JJ~J "-9~J 0:4lJ a;~lt JAl ~)b..~I ~WI ,t,Sp,l OJ~
~0,J_p,,~1~~,y~lJas~,~~FJOl~"-9~J' <, •oi4J
~WI c.::Jls~ J)b.. <JA~ c:,l ~ c.ill~ JS' .a.:«o;. ,~,JI ~J.oo Ji G.--Loc,
~_,J.I ~~i kµ CJ~I ~~~I~) 4:iWS' J)b.. <JA ~ ~ J
C:,J~ .(c.ill.:U ~ J "-9~ rJJ ~)b..~I c.t.J~i ~ t ~ J....jUJI c!:J~ 1~1
-
4.9~1 ~ b l ~ CJ~W>.1 c.t.JUA ~ I ~I ~\S'. _'\ Ll)b..~I o.l~1
-~ ~-
~)b..~l 4.9\ZlJ l.@lA b~ ~1 o.l~I ~>> : l.s:!1.c ~6.LIJ as~ ~)b..~1
-
~ ~ ~~1 ~ ~ , <JA ~ (olJ.lll rl..uul Ji) LA.IJ.lll c:,~ ,a qt;,;~
<(~..,JI o.l~I )J.lf c:,~ ~.:UI ~ ~ ci'11 ~~I <JA CJl~j.t.l c:,~_,J.I
.(Trevino and Nelson, 2007: p. 264)
.a..:;~
~~,~~~4J ....
".-fl~)WI .>---"'° llill.LJ.::' u-
" ~.u-- '-1..i:&ll('·-,) u---'-"
I(' :. -- .:...I.
~
. ~ ~6..tlJ as~I J>b ~)b..~I
4S..,.:.U2.ii~YI allWU~)Utl ~..,r,Ji'°u.r, ( \ . - \)~.)JU,
¥~'::II o.ll:o,JI
~~,
as~ ~'.)l.;.'::/1
""1
-c c_ ·[
r i-·~. 1· e-i L, ·~. ~ c, c.. ~- i- c.. c, 1'>· .·. ~~ r :r
- f ~ "' I:: ! ~ ~ 't:. .t E. g C' ._, g g_ • ~ 'L' . ~ ·~
~ . ·~ . £ ~ l r:. E '). ~ fi:- ~ 1\ r: f
t
L, C• .r G 1· ~ "· ·~ r r:. r ~ !E ~ ! ·[. lo. ~ i . ¢ t t ~· ~· I ·~ i
c.:.1\
~ ti"" 1. t C·- I _L, - [ -~ ,-...1 J) -
~ ~ !::
~
[
·V f" t t ' '.V
~ .r;-f \. ,..... i - r );- ~ A );- l f. - • ~- G, [,
<;.. ~ § [ f -? 2 ; c, ~- c;; . . ., - ~ •,e-; ,£: l ~ {:
~ ~ ~ ~ l ,[: (p, ' - ' . .r ~. E, (r C·.. E
i '\. ~t . ~ ~ ·l ~ cf:
t. . . E: .. . V\ I> ·~ .6 ft· b l,' . . ~· .(" ·£:
f. - ,c
.F l, • C:
~ ·£. f 1I: i-c- t ~ 1 'i. ~ -:: 'k . ·- - ,.~ ,.~ (_ \o
I~ (_ t c- I.;r,, ;~t•. I
~ 1· -
~
~'
e! for - f! A , f! - C•
\D • C• J) \o -
t
~~ f.,.~ f1~~ t=:~ . ~c: '1 r,~~ 1 f ~. 1 \•. -.·• ~· G. - ~ Jc· - · . ~ .r - .: t'.
~ t i 1= .~ •t' ·t' f Y ff- f £ ff- "' ·- ~ . •n ~ r:. : ~
·J~~ t ~ ~: ~. [ ·~ ~ i r
~ ·i S: 1.· ~ ~· ~
~ ~ l .f.l ·~· J'i~ ~· f t:E ;· . i
.c
r \- l . · g ~ \ t i •i " c.. \- •
r
f[ . ·t: <i: E! C· t: 1~ I;! f "· ~ . . ., ·~ c- r
Ei- 'l. ·r. - ~ c. j
1
{ l 1= ·~ JV~- t· :r [ ' i.: ~ 1 ;. ~.
C• .. t· g ; ~ C• , c, ~ •!;, .~ - .t ·~. fl-'
tv r ~~ i.~ [~ 1~ ~g :=.~ ~·~ &i_:
,: . ~ Ci. ). r fi:- -( ~ 'r. 1\ - -c ~ ~ ~ 'l. f. 't .1: 1 ~ .,, E i
[1 f .E'. .c !t t !t { ~ ~ ~ 1f 1; f! 2- [ ,c ~ t e ~ f. q:
E if. t ~ F"
I!, ~C fl-' - :~ ti"" J) r.: - ~· t.. hr
~E r~ ~-r: f" 1-: l
''I», • ,,!g ~ E; ic· 'i.,
,£' • ' . . .- ---; l· t: r- E ". ![. - ~- ' g ~
r [ 11-cf ~£ ,(;f fF.rL i. ; :·~r
~
[ . ~ ~ ~ f }. t t 1. f. ·</.. f t 1i fr Fl '°·. ~ i .[ .··~· f E l
~ r1 e ~· -t { f. - l [ l fr r· r ~ - 1,d - ,,! (
£' -
t f;
1_i r! ~ r ·ti '°. .:cl t t 1-: \ t 1.-~} 1: ~ t · :t
..,..:,wt~I
s~...,i..tt u~~
a .: I ;.l..wl uLA..9 I • Q I t y......u,Li...J.1 ~ rl-' ;. ; cc,'il...:t -' ,o ;; 2 (')
ulo_,.JJ ~jD ~I ulA_,w. I J ~ I improper use of insider information

,Jl:'J.I ~ ~ .a.:,o;....,!, ~ls:.A ~ J ~ I ~t 0-4 4iQt;.;a ~ ~
~t 0-4 f-"~ wJ~ ulS'~I ...L=,,.t ~_tl ~¥ ~I ulA.,W.I rl~I

-~~I J~ ~ ;;?.tJ.4 ~lA ~ls:.A ~ J ~ I
~~~'ii ~ I JAJ . ~~,~intermediaries s:-lb........a.u_,JI .)J~ JA ~~I (Y)
c.:,.,~IJ~4JI ~L.u:~.JJI Jl c.:,.,~ ~I;;~~)' 0:-l.)_jll 0-4~J;,~,2~.JJI
:~I . u ~ I s:-1?.lJ s:-lo:J'il ~
Spulber, Daniel F. 1996 ..Market Microstructure and Intermediation.
The Journal of Economic Perspectives, IO (3): 135.152.
j o: cc,a ~ I 4.c.~..LA ~..G.. J.,la.A ~lA o~ls:.A ~...l4i ~ tipping u~\..~)'I (Y')
.«u~'.!'~.;.-tll» ~ ~WI 4:->y.ll u ~ I ~ ~ ~ 1A JAJ
t~l 0-4 £~I ~ "'=11 JS'_jll o,o-.:.. ,:.,JI JA ethics officer J)l;..~I J J ~ (i)
~ I ,uLJalll ~ (l.Q\..s.,a J ~ ..u_j.cJJJ ·¥)\..;..~l~lt.Jl ~ I s:-~i
.y~l 0-4 JJ~I ~I~«~»~.) ~~I ~)Lo
~b)'I ul.)l~I ~~I s:-1.)J ~ I yjl~I ~ bottom line ~'-&,i.JI a\co...,tl (o)
.J~~I uLJo..i...o ~~~IJ r4.)~4 ~_;; ~J
~ '-i~L:.Jt ~ t
~~~ a,~ i~!j..at J.J3t.,.. ij.t_,.b ~ ~~t ~t.,..
Wesley Cragg ~t,.S' ~ a ~t~J
Uwafiokun Idemudia ~~~~! u,$,Jlst..J:!J
Bronwyn Best~ ~t..fl_!>JJ
i4Aa.\u
~~ ull>.:i ~J, Transparency International 4 J.JJI ¥ ~ I ~ ~~
~-'"""» ~L:i ~.JA ~..)~\,.)~I~
.«~G.. a.-..1.,.,t a.JS'_,J.\ a..bL.JI J ~ \
~~ ,.)~I J~ ~ 0J..Pj.t.l ~411 ..b.i J-AJ ,Joh.; Noonan uw~ <J.P."- Lot
~I d.AWI ~_,JI ~bi~ ~Li.4~ ~p~ ~1~1)) ls,ji ~ ;;~_,JI
- -
I~ ~l.;J 0A ~l..1.A~I ~ J .(Noonan, 1984: p. xi) ((w~ o,u.;~ ui..:i ~
~ -
~ tl..r9t1
~w ..H):. Ji ~w aJJb ~i ls,ji ~ ;;~_,..u ~ ~-"'"" ,u!,Ulll
a..b.u ·ti;;
. " r '..)
I ~
.
ct..a..Jl:t:A ~ i ~
,... ~.~ti i I .. ~~'}! Ll
.. Y"' J .) l.)-9
.~ ... q c9- .JA '-r· Lo
.. J.:r----,
..»-i '->'°'-.:.. M Ji cul.JJ L,l~ ~I ul.J.:4ll Ji a..,.1,,.,11 ~ ~ .l.?.J (:A aJW4
~ '}!_,JI Ji ~.,:JI Ji ~l.,JIJ '-' ,o;.-1.JI rl_µJ'}JI
J..,,.)o ~ L&:, al~ c:tJ ~~ Ji
-
~i ~ '}/~~~I wu_,..:i.JI ,~ 0_;+4 ul -~~ ~'}!.,_JI Ji ~IJ ~.)~I
-
~'}1_,JIJ Ul~I ~ ~J ..)~IJ ;;~_,..u ~..u ~ I J ul.;~I l.!JLlA. uL:i~
~ ..
. t!.. ~. ~,1 a.uL.u.-~t I - .~ti i ~'-4.,JI ~ ...... aJ:jWI ubl ~bi ,a.fjl...JJ
J--:~J .. 'r ,~ J . ,---~J .. J J
. ~LtJ4 ii_H~ .i.l~ ls,ji ~ ~ \ d..:P-l.tll <J.A Ji L,:i\~ ~ ~1
o.:LoWl~JtJ~~l~~~~..)~\J;;~_,Jlu~,illl~wu~~~J
~ ~ -~..ill I~~ - ,~J
,..)~4 0~4A ~.)-AA ~ I 15...us ' ~
~ ;;_µ1 O~J .f-1W\ JJ..) <J.A ~..wl ~ ~4J ls,ji..:i ;;~_,JI 4..,.JJI ¥ ~ I
ulS'_;.J.A~j.A~J ,u\~j.A ~~ u ~ ~~ c c r Q ~ ~ a=i)G~~ ~..)
Bribe Payers Index ;;~_,JI ~b~j.AJ Corruption Perceptions Index..)~\
o~ ~ JS'j:i .<'>.)~I~~~ uf ~_,J.I <J.A ~I J~~\ u~~~j.AJ
.rJWI J.? ~l.;J ; ; ~ ~ ~ i ..)~IJ o~_,JI ui ul-1.;.JJI
0 ~ ~~ t71 -
u! LJ.R 'iJWI J,A I~ ,~u
J,A cl:,,.._;,lo~ ~.JJ\ JIJ..---uJIJ
tJA ;;~_,..u lAJ.l.J.JAJ ulS~I ~ .i9 .;;~_,..u ii.l..lLi.4 ulol~I .l.?.J •.«! "'!
______.....,.....________
_........,~~Jl.4 Mi .. :-cw.~
..........- - - - - - -
~
~
l"Yl" ~~ ilaa ~ tio:1l1 LA_j &!,...L>,J i:~u :u~I ~ ~~!.9 4-4.J...)-?lll
1-:-: .,::.-::,:-:·. ··, .!·." ···.,.-.-.::.-._:,::·.-:· .:.:_~.:~ ·::.'.'.·: ·: -:::.::V,:::·:::":":"::i::\.:~~:::::,·j:":"i;._:·.-t -/"v j:::.,~; .. ·3;··,,·::)::{}··:·.=.1 . ·;:D:···: :. : /.'.'.'.·j:-~. \'·:':.=.:.=.:~y·· ... '
-· J a..o~,J ~ , ~ t ~
"1.JLl.A -~' -.. ,_.~ wullS::tll.
. . c.,J~ -
'- t
l.l'!~t, I.P."
0-4 ~
~J ~JJ ~ ~_,=i~ a:;.;lS' ~ \.!"'.!~.; i.;J.l~ .l~I o-4 t~I l.lA w~ ~l~lc..ll
~ ~.:UI .;iA..111 ~J ~.;'ii ~l.).fll Ji!~ ,II.! ru<tlj L#.;J ~ ~4ll .;~I
~4w1 a.Jljl., ~L:tWI ~ ~J c.>"l.;J..1.lA ~ Hurricane Mitch~ .;~1
lA.ll~1~~
- ~ti a.LWI
- d.L-4~1 o:U,~ • L......-T
- J ~~I
- - ~-!)-0 l · a...u "ll ~~
· -: · '-- er -~
~~~1~1~1.;1..,l~~bl1~;;~>1'r~LS - ~ o A ~ ~
wfi: ~J . 1..1.AS' ~ Wal-Mart ~.;LA JJJ~ -l_;.;.jA c.ill~, a «~riS'I LS ..L.....J_.;jtll
~ ~lc.~I J)l;. o-4 a..o_,w1 ~L..u~ ~ ~t:JJ ~lS'~I o-4 ~'iJb "1.JLl.A
Watergate ~.;JIJ a,..!'"' wfiJ ~J -~~I y~~J ~~ a.;,_,=iw1
~1.,11 oA wl ~.; . l ~ , oA t~' 1:u, F~ ~~ ~ t ;;~1 ~L:!'i.,JI ~
~lc.~4~1~\.c..l'ilJ~LAL,:i'il -~t ~Ll.AJ .a.JJ..111 o~~~~ cGl -
'->..11 ~J ,~.;11,tl .l~I .>J_.;l.Z r..iAi LS ,L;,Ul ~ ~~ y ~ a_;,_,=iw1 ~
-~~1 ~~.!·ojid.L-41 ~ J ~J.,ljlJ ~-"5JJ.l~LJ::4.,WI ~Jj-«-1.1
~ ~ a+,_).j~ ~,~L.....c..)I ,-,;q ,;.,;, cr>1..1.AS" ~ Bre-X ~t ~~ a .... .!'"' LAl
~~t ~ rl~IJ ~J.,ljl ~ ~.:UI o-4 ~ ~~ .;CiT .l.?.--"! ~lc..l'-i4
~ o-4 c.ill~J ,Suharto ji.;lA~ a..o~ '->..11 ~J41 ~ J ~ ~~ ;;->--""t
~ d..l t J+fo ~ .>J~ f.? ~ J ~ a..,_jl..u.J.' ~lS'~ ' o-4 .l..U:. <i'1' ~.:u,
~,.;1..,l ~J J~~1 ~L..u.;w ~ .l~I PJ:! wi ~ c.4 c.!.U~ F~ . .l_?.,JA
~1~Lc.ll w~ Barings Bank~_.;4 ~~ a,..!'"'~ ,~i -.;~'-ii
d..li i..»-JA ~..b- cil11 ~UI 4.oj~IJ hedge funds c.b_,....:tll J:.lb ~ ~)WI
. .l~I ~a;,o::-:.4~4Ul~~j.t.l~
Fd ..b-l» cG~ ~L.u.; < ) ~ ~ . ) ~ I ~j..UI ¥ ~ I ~ c i, •oi
~J . .l~l~ti~~~, l.lAo.;P~ .<,~Wlf1Wl~~L:!~I
:~l~fi~
(:I_)~'"~ ~1 ~~j.JJ a.ow, uL..,~I D~J o~I a..o~, ~~, ~~
-u-a~I ~J~ '"'~Lu-~ «Gt "'4S' DJ~Ju,0L.;.J1 t ~ 4 ~ J ~J1.,_.1.1
r~ Jl.bl ~ ~UI ybu.ol o.o 4.Lu,IJ ~~ wJ~ ~ ~ ~l:s->11 ~..J
.u,0l,;.JI t~'J ~...u.l ~ I J aJJ.111 ~ D~~ fAt ~ ~.:,JI ~lj..i.ll
.(Tl, 1997) LALA i.)J~ ~J.111 d ..,.""""j.ll yaJ:i "'4S'
.~l.c.l'il l:U, U&.a>o ~

· ..~'-·
-:
.elJI - ~~
· I-ti JU!.I L~~
· 1::_-:
Y'Yt
ib!j.atl~~~.,-.l l~~t4.!,b..4
~ I <J:,J...,:;....-ll ~ .)~I o..o ~ ulJ.)f.JI <>--4 ~ I ..>-J_,kJ ~ ~
c.tlJj a.li4i <JAJ -~~I JJ...ul a;,yWI ~L...u_,JI ~ ulJ.)\'l o.J..41 <JAJ '~J...ulJ
.,J~t ~.:UI Foreign Corrupt Practices Act <::r."JL;JI .)~I uL...uJw 0ytl
c,,jlS' ;;..1:!~ u l ~ -~.;JIJ a,..!,;,,~ .)fir' C\VC\ rk. ~...>At.JI <>"~fill
J-1:o ~ ~J <JAJ -t_,.tll I.J..41 o..o 0yll l&!...u ~I ;;~_,JI a.JJ...ul ;;~I u~"}l_,JI
~JA ~ ulS'~l o.J..41 ~J t_,.tll l.J..41 o..o <)yll .).?.J ~ ~~I ulS'...,..:;JI 0..0
ulS'...,_.:;JI Jo~ u.)l .JlJ -~...>At.JI ~ ulS'~I J.,U.O ~ i~ ~<.:r'-" ~\..Zi
ti - .. ..
'-k. '7"'1 ~t 1 ~";t ~ • · ·w, ·- '7"'1 ~

- )tJI ..L4All J)l;.. a..aS:..a
=-~ u-
..>JJA - ,.=d ...., u.JJ ~ - ~ t.i1
~» c.:rll ~~~~->-°~I c t ~ I «JJ..J..u» _,..J ~->-°~I 4A_µI ~ o..o

·~J...ul Jl..,._f.JI ~ ~->-°toil ulS'...,_.!;JI rLAi «~I ul~
a :-:'«oQ ~ "}] ~...J.Af.JI 0~WJ a .!\,all a '?"fill 0L:, J.,_.aJI wi
~ J .(CraggandWoof,2002)~)l;..a .!«os~~f.JlulS'~I
, -
~ I J ~.)~"}ll 0Jl-t:tll a Qt,.;Q l.>--:P"'t ~ , ~ ,c!J..1:a,,. ~ J c.!Lfj 0t
the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)
~..,JI ~J~I ;;..,.._.:uJ ~~ ~Li:il c.:rll r'C\C\V rk. ~ ..s.)i w ~~ 0i
the OECD Convention on Combating Bribery of Foreign Public ~4- \JI
~ c.!lllA 0lS' ~_,JI c.ill~ .JlAJ . Officials (OECD Anti-Bribery Convention)
01..u,tll ~ L,l.oJ ~J...ul u ~ I o..o a\.6 ,~,i ~ ~I ~J...ul ulj4ij11 o..o
. United Nations ;;~I f-4\'IJ Organization of American States ~\JI
,Publish What You Pay~ ~..Li LA~I a...Jo..i.A ,-,b;,o ;;.>:P'-\11 a:,J~I ~J
~ ~.;.Ai 0 i l?.' i ~ ~_,JI ulAfo-JI ~ ,~fo,.. .)-t):. ~J.) a...Jo..i.A ~J
JJ...ul ulAfi>J ulJLilJ ~lfa ~~.)LA~ .)Jl.,..Jl at;; ,retl ulS'~I
~,
-· ~
· - "}lluk.~Ll~I;;
-
.)LA.__Ac.ill.:U4.J~"}]I
'.) . ~ . .
.L.A '--~ ~,,
J ~u-r-''-:*'
~fo,.. o.)~ ;;J.)Lt,o L+>l .Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative
r~~ Jl.bl ~_,J ,~WI ~WI JJ.) ~ ~t.;. ,uLAµI tL.al c.)1 ~~
.c.ill~ ~ ~..,>1u ~ I 4A_µIJ ,ubl..,i?llJ uk.~..\.4.ll ~WI ~...GllJ
Transparency International ~J...ul ¥ ~ I a QloiA ,b .~.;; c.!LJ.:is-
<::r.""JL;JI .)~I uL.uJw 0Ytg JJ..J..Li ; ; ~ .)~ ~ J .jbJI I.L.A ~
_# ci ~Wt J.a.a..iJ I
""'"""""'--·- I
<J:l..9~1 o~.J ~~ a_;su:;1 ~1 u..)l <?llJ Foreign Corrupt Practices Act

f1WI J_p- ul~I ~ aJ..9...ul ..)~ ~ ul Q.!.!;; u ~ ..il..9 .~~~I ~_;JI
~j.AJ Corruption Perceptions Index . l ~ I ulS'.J..l.A ~j.A ,-, iq ,;.,; <?llJ
~ ~.:.UI ~J,ll ..l:~ ~ ~~ <?llJ Bribe Payers Index o~_;JI ~ b
o~~ ~ ul..9.l~ ~6.. .l.P.-Y. ~~I ~1 _µ4.., .~l ~ .l~I ~
4..9..ul ¥ ~ I ~~~I ,~_µ1 u~t..:JI ~..)~I~ ~~I~
-
. Integrity Pact d.AI:'..)-*'~t\ "-li....A --
• ~i
' .. t-*4-4 ..
Integrity Pact Tool ol__µll J ~ obi ~..9..ul ¥ ~ I ~ u ~ i ..1.4'
~~..u.l~l..9J~~l..9ul..A~lo~w~..))4llu\.!i.!• ,,ill• ocoii4~
~ ui,WI ~ LAi .a..oWI ul.Jlt..:JI Jh ~ .l~I ~~ ~i 0-4 l.&A ~ I
~ o.)~ ol__µll J ~ ul..9.li ui ~ ,~~ J.il..i.o ~ .Jd .l.J ~ o.)~ ~~I~
~ .6~lA~yLallt~1~~..,..)~lt,UaQQ«04¥~1u~
0-4 ~~.., ,uLlaj LA~ ol__µll J ~ obl:i •,1.!< .~.;t4 y ~ I '-:-':?-~I 0-4 ~_;JI
r ~ olj.lll ~IJA ui "l'l World Bank ~..9...ul ~lS' 4..9...ul u~j.J.I ~
~L.u..9 0-4 ~ u~~ ~ f1WI ~~t ~ 4..9..ul ¥~I~~ 0-4 u~I
t~ ~.., ..1.4' .ul..A_jl....ll ~ J j.J~IJ ul..A..G.Jl..9 u~IJ,ll ~1 u"l'L&.o:i"l'I
l..u..4.L<. 1<. _'\ '! .. L~,1 y • ...~ 01: ~•1 -li..A obi a.J ...ul L l ~ I ~
... ~,.. ()A ~ '-T ~ L.~JA '-T 'J'*' "' .. .. J ..
. o_# d..l:'uii 0-4 ~ u"l'b.. ~J ·0~4J l:Jfi Y~J ~~U
W::' JLl:il ..)~?1 u ~ ~ o.J~ Integrity Pact Tool LAl__µll J ~ obi
o.Jlj_,.JI ..9i ( ~ I ~~I~ ..9i ~_,JI ..9i ~..)L,..:i"l'I ~~I~) a..o_µ1
~ 0-4 ~ ~ J ~ ~li..t.l uA~ a..o~I ~l.;-b~I ~lS' W::'J ~~I
..,t (.)A~ ~UA ufi: "l'i ~ ~l.;-b~I ~ JLl:il J~I ~ ·r~' tl...k..a.JI
~.:UI ...1..4£ll ~ J ~ ~li..t.l IJA~ ~ ~..9Ll..;-lJ J~ ..9i u~~..l.A ..,t u'-tlJo
~•-1 .":ti
~ .,- :r-' r . a..ow1 ~,1 r1: ":ti
..l.a.J :l · - ·liJ.1
'J'*' '-' ..
~
• ..
~ . LAI:'J'*'~, 1"'-li..A
..
d...&L:.
..
'!
~
. L ~.
..,t olj..tll J ~ ~ <?l' .l_,.a..}I ..,t J.4LJI ~ J ~ I uLdsl.i..o ~ ~Lzal

J.~
· · --" uLdsli..t.l.'-T
_:g ~\.Z.ll
.. '- ~
i.:r- . .- ~ .4>.J..&.4.Li
- J i J.4LJL. .)~ '- t (.)-4
· · :.11 1.,)-!'" ·
~~ ~ 0-4 ~..) <?11 4.&:tLlJI u~I ..9i u"l'~I ~ ~ r~?JI J.4LJI c.:rk
~J ~ JLl:i"l'l..9 ol__µll J ~ ~ u4~ ..l:~ ~ ..il..9 . J.4LJ4 c(g~ d.J ~.;-b
.J~uWb .l.P.-JJ6..~~
_,..,........_ .....r>?z:o.,r •:n.•·.a.a1ti.....,._. • • • ~""'1:1:::C"~<-=·' - " ' ~ - - - - ~=-= = - - - . w ~ - ~
~~ ~ ~ ci~l l.A.J ~.J.>.J faU : u ~ t ~ J~!.9 ~~t
· ·.< · LA~ ~l.ul.l II.) W..
:~Li.A (.)~ -
~I:'J-'"':q ~
- :.1JA ...L.:i -
DLla.i.o ~ Ji Lµt 0-4 ~ Ji ciilj J ~ I ~lj J i ~ Ji ~J-4 Lfi.=... -
. ~l.ul.l r~ t ~ 4:?..u ~.:UIJ (principal ~>'I J..9_µ1) a.JJ..ill a5~
~ I (bidders ~W.1 ~ J ~ <JJ-4~1) o-ot.;JI t ~ I ~lS'~ -

.i,~ t... .. • .:UI l .J.4A.JI t ... J:a.-~tL
·-Le. ~t'2=~
- ~ J ~ '.r--'.
~ Ji ~~IJ ~~ji.JIJ ~ .!~ coiJIJ "b.!b:ic::JI ct.......4>lj..ill J~ ~

~ y l JJ_µI 1.)1..l.c..olJ ~bY.-.,.tl <.JO.!IO;..J_, ~ y l JJ_µI Jig <JA ~bY.-.,.tl
a.!;;;JI ~LA...l.>JIJ ~11.JUi:L.u~I ~LA~ ~1..,11 ~LA...l.>JIJ ~lj~~l..9 ~l_,:Jl
¥ ~ 1 ~4--1.J.:1 ~ i ~1 J~.,.t, .Jib ~..l.&1' 0t ~J .~).:1f'I ~..u,., ~u,.,
..1..4LJL. ~ I ~Lb~I ~ u---": t _ :._.~I: :t\ ·l:u..o · 1.:9, -
'J-'"' <J .. u..
~ c.tlJj · lS' ~
(.)
.. , ..
a..J.a..a.JI t I ~W.1 t ... J· -· --tt ,.... . .. aL.u.tl lu.;..I t .4 LA ~Lbl .. L
-
a..b..
'J-"' J ~ ~ \.I__ I.) .. l..J7- '.J-'---1-U • t~...u•
:.
~ 01 ~ J.!; .~,;JI_, J~~IJ ~ 4 ~~I J)L;.. c.tlJjJ, .i!~IJ ~ll..J.J
. .:1~1 ~.,I-J L _;g r.J..aJ ~ 1_,b;J, 4'.J.A
:w ~,, :q <J·l:c..J... (.). ..
~ 'J-'"'
~
- ~
. 1.:9.u ~Li.A
(.)
:wL:i ~l~u ~.J..aJ J.,..)o ~ D~yl ~ 0-4 ~lS'~I ~ -,

• D'j-'-'J
:... lt ~--lt\ .
J-"' ~ ~ L
ylz.A~L. ,:-:I~ L..o..,1.. ~Ll.A -
. (.)JAJ-""""' .. \--v.;--
-
L _):aA ~ l ~ I I.Jl..l.c..ohi Ji uo.!,a~IJ ~~I ~~4 ~ I D~~I -
~ ~L.:i.JIJ ~ ~JJ--uJ-1 ~ 1.J.:1~1 Jl>':'~I c.tlJj ~ ~ .:1L.will ~
.~LLl, ~,j:.1_~1 ( J ~ ~i
~WI ~ I 0-4 ~ \ <)A (w~I ~Wo..i.A ~ c.tlJj ~-..9) ~LA~ I ~ -'r
Ji <.JO.! ,a;..::JIJ LWI ~~4 ~.;-1\ .:l~I ~ c.::j~ ~.:UI ~'-4J~IJ
.(Tl, 2002: p. 4) ~ l ~ I )..l.c..ol
l'..t•'··~·-·~)~ .. ••~- .... •·z~-. ·. •v.;..,.v-.-~.,.~;-•.~;.·:t.--·1'-~- .':-t,,-__ ...,..,..,:,c.,,., ~--~~,_.,._,._...:.,.w ..<..-J)-..,.:1,o..&,1"..;:J,.~•':.' u-..--,...-....v . . . . ,... •-· ._.7.-..•-· • ..s-.t:.·JI .-11,.•,,•, _,,. .:,.,,.. L
l"YV ~~ 4.W ~ ':?~I Lo.9 ,.:,~ fall : u ~ I ~ ~Lw..ial!., ~~I

cf. ~ '\t' l- f"' '(~ n 1· ~ J• ~ ~~ l- & t
.F Jr i, ~ [. .~ .. \ , iC·
P.' 1:· lc... F 1~ r,1 e>r
I I I,
I> I:: .fr, -~
.c- c·I') '-'
I:; ,c· [ ~
E .r lc... ~
- ,
- I , ::::
t ~• -
C>
I> C• ~ I> \o ~• <t:.•
,t ~ [,- <r:• fr
"'iL
I I,
C• ~
- • ' \ t! "' tr '-' C- t ~ C
~. t ~ Cj. .c- ~ • C... r.. 1:· 't. 1C· .. ~ [,
·~:~ I~ ~ - l..o ~ l ~ I ~ ~ r;,
~ l • ,C- " - C· ::t. - ,
'l· .. fr, 5 i' -
f[ .. l -~ ·~ <'(' { ~f ' f
• ~. l..o - 1, •C C•
t--• ~ "'
i 1; E: '1f - 'r.f.• f>. c. '-' e_
~ ~- ftt', ~-
t I 1• e; -: ' ] ~• I') '[.. ~ iL • I, I - [1
't• 3 f
~
i:: f'' -;,, C· '-!.' f 'Cj.. ,~ {
&\ •fr.. ""'l>
(, oo liC>'
J.~ ·t: 1 ,d . . 7;~: t1C>•
,c· .._.,c ~ ~
t 1t_ i,I: •.
t , - \o .,.. , 't. · - c· r '
- N . - ~ !.o
~
- ,.
1, ~ l L.. '"' -
•C •• ~ , r,
t P, ~ _f V\ •fr.. \o C - L•
~• "'O I " • I.,: st I ~ • - fr.. - 'i_ c... ~ •
E
'\. r \D
I~ I _.IS> I,'~ • -
''i,C: :
J. ~c- ~
~r
f tr 1· t.F .;-h t ·t ~ ~~ f:: ~ ·tl,t fr.. - ~
Cr.· I,' -: I:: IC Ct ,I: 11-: I,' •
1-D • I> - e;
t 'l!- ~c... c... ~
~
r 1 ~~ E' r. t~ ~ t. 1 ~ t·[• ..::; c...~. ~s
t' t' .e-' E: ~ E t \o.
' IC - - Is>· L
·[' f t 'l! i.r-· rt·· ~ l ~ .c- ~
lc... . ~ c...
f - :c:.. "'r 11~.. ·Cc;:.
c" - <;... ~ r. A .. ~ c__ - ~· ' • ' r.- ,C- • ~
L.. ·i;,0 ~ ~ V\
c,- ~ IS>' - y -
<; ~ I;; !~· {.
i ~. l: <'( t. c'~ .ft, . . -;- ~ If [: 'b- ~ ·Cj.. ! l . 1, t
r. ~ .1, ~ C -"° c£ F - ·!.. ~- c... E C· I:: P.' - - - r.<' - •fr..
s ·~. l ~ ·~· ~ "°t. fr: 1· ~ I:: [• ""'l> 't,. (;.. [ V\ I:; .
,P.'
.. Ci. ~. . . [ • E r, ~
{~ qi\ ~·,'l! 1, f..:.. l": I r.: t i
l 1,. . _t·., •t' r, ~t"
t.. - ,t, ~· ·~ ~I - C 1:1) {;,
Ci C·
'i- ..E. " - if"' "'°. ~· -~ .'t C: . 1 ~ ~ ~~· l )A [• ,t: 1· r· I
[, ·r ~ ~ - [ ;: I I I
h I;:, •lj
1. ~ f ri l f. \: ~ If [ · '. ~ f "· f t · ~ ~ f. f (. ~ ~ ~
j n,
·V ~' - I
-
.c- -I
~ c -~ ~_ !:. _ , rI_ E cI
_ ~. r- ·~
.c· -
- ·i. _ ., ~
E g E.. ·v E: 1
, _ _ _ \o
,t ~-
I
t-.
> C: I I I I I I - -
r ~~I-'--r
ULWI ~~Io..)~ ~I~.<
~~
_:._ti '- ol~'J-*''-'-~
~,1 ·L:i..i.4 · - -
,~l..,Jo~I ~ u41JJJ~ U""-"~ cGi «.·: '"! ~ '5i ~ ~.Jll.:JI ~_,:,WI
dJ_,l:J.I ul~I...P.-?JI w,11 ~~I wJ..) w~ ~i ~ ~ ~ J~I r~ wi ~i
.~- I ():J
. ·1.-:tt
.,-. ~·- ~ IJ o..)~IJ
~ ol__µJI ~I~ - ~ i,S_i.,..,AA ~ j ~ L ~ o..)\_;l ~ b l ~6. ~UA -
. a....ib.
-
ti i ~~,
'.Y J - - ~
~L. ~ ... t L a,,j '-4A ~ I ~LA~ ... ti
~. ~ - ~ ~~ ~
1- ..<f I(' :. . ..1,:,,. IA~ It
. .,.....
-
¥1..>-4J ol__µJI J ~ ~ JA~I ~l~?JI ~ lA~ -l.)J..) <:?..u.l ~I~ -
'5..)~ I.J.AJ .alai «rrll ~.)L;JI ¥1..>-11 J)l;. w-.o i.ill~J ,a~ a.a.,~~
-
a_,~ ~I~ ti .e_)~ w r WI .) 1'J-'
-· (.T ~ "-: ~
· -:ti ~l.::t::il uL4.c..
-
~~~I;;~
c.r ti -
(.T ~
LA~
.:r-
. rWI ~ I ~..ul o..)l:.) wrllJ 4.4~)\A ~i
.<:r.ll..,JI .)J..ul i.ill~ J=t.o ~ ~ I tQi'?uU laJlA~ ~ ~ JJ..ul ~ ~
:4-4_µ1 ~ ~ ,...dWI ~~I J-A I.J.A wfi.: LA~
tl..b.a.JI 0-4 ~~~i <<~L;JI tl..b.a.JI 0-4Jai ,114 ':T4~ ~»-:' a,,j~~I -\
Ji ,~l.i.11 o~I 4:..u ..)~ Ji ~L;JI
~l.i.ll 4AWI ulA.,W.I ~~ ~ JA~ r~l ~~ 's ·..;;
4.4_µ1 rP -r
1sa-·,,b; .-"~; ~ti
• (;"" dJ..)~L ..... ~~ti l-'-4J
.iJ r-=-- ~ .IJ - ,~LzJI · ....
~»-- ~ -t\ -- ~ IJ
Wll ~ J.4LJ.IJ :,~ •. IJA ..14i I..?""'
~ti .) b~L.IJ ~lz.1.L
- •
Wll ~ ..l.4u.IJ , '-""'
L~ I('_:._.
~
~~I~ ~ I ~.;Jy~i i.ill:,SJ '~.)y~iJ~J.>,C,~.)~.:U4
. (Tl, 2002) t ~ I d..a.1S::J 4.4_µ\ ->=..14i c° o_jjWI
ti ti
t~~I ~~ ~~J ,u~l_,.tl ~~ ~ ~ ~ l.)J..) ~~?JI~ .JlJ
. ~i opjA 4AWI
uLl.l4, ~
,_ ~ ll.,ol~
•
~,, -~
' j - ' '-' - [
~ .. ~ul~J a..J
~c.,r - J ..ulLlLLlJl~u
- ·'-..w
~,...
a.:Qn~~J WorldBankw,lJ..ul~~~J..ulu~IJ~lAfi.>Jl~a ,;.,.:.;;, ,4
~ '->-*""~' ~->-'~1.1_, Int~r-American Development Bank ~..J-4~1 wl""'-411
J.,~1 a~.:"J UNDR ~W?JI ;;~I f-4~1 ~l)Y.J Asian Development Bank
;;.)~I ~.;-il ~ _:<.,..::JI a Q<?:AJ International Finance Corporation ~..9..ul
. Court of Arbitration of International Chamber of Commerce ~J..UI
~ ~J>AJ-A ~l~JA~ol__µJl~IJA~~~..,JI.; ,oi•llwl

~ alo~I [~WI rlJ;.; ,I~ .J.41 . ~ ~_,:all u~ c° ~ J J .::biJI
n\------~-~~. 'i~,..~_;-1!1~1~ :ui7Y..~il~-;~::,r~ 4.4,.1_;:.;1
£.; ~ ~
.r c, f .,: t! li- ts! .r ~ t, ,E"~: ~ ~ ~ ~ G>t, Ci .t' l· ~ p!
1(; b ~.. _,. <;- 'I\ ·t ~ t ~ 'r f
.Fl j .~ f 1 ,t: 1 .r t' 't 'E~- [ ~ c,
.t ~ ·L ·fu, ~ ~ · f.: ~· 6 r:1
J
t f>" J Pf r ,t ,c- J ~ - r:: •":, ll-' e:: E: !.., r- l, ,._ -: ·t· c, e.
'i - ' ~ 1'
- ~ f ,t. , f' pti
11 -~ ~ .~ { c: U. ~ le-· i f 1 C '<i,.. [.~ 'e.
t ; ,f: t
. . . '° t ~ c.· ,.,.
;tfu 1c· ~-r 't1~
~ I ,E· • . !t·
r c.·- t ; r;:
t: Ci" • ~;
1· 't..
• (j,• c;;. \i.. t· =-- c. 1 !:. 1, ..- - r1
·~ ~ r- ~. r· r
-t '-!> I I
~1>
~-
t~
I -
f:!
~
t .r f
·~. ,~ :: .~. ,, b· e; ~ •E: l ~ t, tA
f•
~
b I ~ l .•C. , '
[ .. ~ i::- e:! ~ r,: b
•I'°~
rt r I:. '° l, ,t' -
l [~ ~. 1
't_ C·
~~ ~ '°t e:.. l, '° ~ [ - :i;- [ t - C.· rt ~ Y rl
f. i r. I 'r . fi - t·. f- ·~ t e-. f
l, ! ; _ I:; .f C· ·~" Ci f !t'
rfu', t-
-: ~ 0 V\ p• ~ ~ fu', ~. .. fp, .. ti ~.~ ·L [?; ~ 'f ~ C ,c !.J
l:: I ..:
t f t ,(;, 't J -i ,c ,i;.. C _;- .P.· e-' £i l,· P::!. ti'>
b
fur
[• ~. (p I b
,r,E.,.
- -1 - , , 'b· , !:.t. :!
r·r r . 1'~ ~, t'~ r., t - f E I
El~C:e:\ {lffF~f'f~ ~ : ~ f. t ~ (. ~ ~· r:: -; f!
.- ! r-i ' [ V\ l, C· [ , . t'S>· v ~ :-. .·-.i
f. .rl ~-c: ~
1> IP'
~ ~ ~t ~ ~ l.. ~ ~ I
~ ,f.,_ '
t!...•• rE,.
IA ~
C.r' I
• ,r' '
-~ ~~ I
c· u
11
\. I b· .- - l, ~ r- s- - f;, '[ -:- ~*
" I ~ -:t. r ~ c. .~ e- ~ c '[ ~- I:: b c.' . • I,\
b ~· '[; : ~ f. Lj
-P - -P 1> f" c ,c l 1
~§; ~ I:!: r ~ r ~
[~ ~ ,~! 'r;; ~·. ~ ~ b ·~1' ~ • •~ . : ;
I..D ! ~ c....
b· [' r,: ~ {;!.
v G_ [, f"'
l • f>" - J' ~ .f; f ~· l·I
~·~ ~ g ri ~; ~ c-~
~ ~· , ~. ~
t l ~.. - t.'. V\ . ~ '· 't Pf !::: "" i t1
·t - t- i. r .f ~ :; l 17 r: ~ € ~ ~ r ~ ~
\ I }6 Ii- ~ c.. ~ 1d ·<j,,. f. C- 1.° 1: : E C· • .
.t ~ ~ J· J t ·~ 't f," ~-
!" [ lj
~ ~ l ·~ f: I:; 1- .f ~ r ,t: r(;.. ..
r;. ~ ~ [ ,£, t~ e:! &· ( 'r ~ t, 1, 'Ci D ~j
'I:.
I ~ \- t· L·<p. ·i _.. r L r l
l y ~
('f :
r::: -
~· ·~.
f. '°
, . ~..
f . ~ '°,. ~·· ~· l ,c;
~ ~
~ .~
~. f. h r;; .'I
> ~ ~ t,. ,r f, .~ C· •
1 f . ~ -; 'e. ~ e-· .• r c, t .- ·f l, • - t 1 i))
l, , V\ , .
..f. ~ :cr:"' L. ·. . ~· ,. "" _! ~ ·t ·:I.' .
r f £ i;- '° ~ re; .1:- ~ 1: r ~ ti~
C· ~ ,r. . '~; t ~ c, - ~ ~ · Ht
il e·~ t i ~~ ~, ~t - ·tt ~.f. /f. 1
l f-; t. ,['.·~..
~ - I I .i;- V\ , (r l> L · rL ~' - Pf , i,: -
't - [• f C~ ~. y
l ~ ..%.
p~
~I. i t;. ;~ .~·
'I~ 't ~· 1. ~ t~ ~ ~ ~r ~f ~ ~ ~~ 1 I:. t>
:g "' ~[ f t-:B.c;t,· E~ .t,.t: .E,r. t.f- s ~ ~ ~
t!d~~
~ ~ J~I u-4 "-4>->lJI LAk ~~ i.S...L.o ~ ~~I J~'}/1 J.,~ w,-11 -
W::' ~ ,J\:i.11 ~ ~ . ~ I ~ ~L.ui ~ ~ J~I wrll ~l_ij.11
~>-' w~ 1 • • L>-4 ~i ~1 ~ D.J-tfi DJ\i> ~ , [L...:ul A) r, "vrJ r, "1 •
"\1 L>-4 cl.Afi.:,JL Jl->=1 JIJ ~iJ ~~ ~...H ~~ o u-4~l i.LU~ J;g w~ wi ~
r-'""· r,k~D~~~ ,. u-4~":l~r-'"v· r k ~ o ~ w ~
wi ~1 ~I~ ~ I dJJ..ill ~_;JI dJWlj.A~r,~1 LAi .(Watts,2007)
.cl.Afi.>JI wbl..Hl u-41.AY'J wlJJLAll u-41.C\oJ ~~1 J;...ul u-41.t • ~ ~ I
. . .~
wl-.ul.a-, . "l4A c,r· ~
I..>! .. 'r· ~ ~J~JJ
.. :,-· t\ a....-L.a.uJI • - ti ..ul ..u:. l-.u L.&
W::' LA ,~J~I w l ~ J .« J)_,J.1 ~ » J jAlS:JI j~I ~ ~ I J;g LA
- .. ,, ,s .. -
-~...r4I IJ'}/JJ nr wrll ~...r4I IJ'}/JJ Yo• u-4Jj-4llJ_;.J~,r"··tJr'"\O
~...r4i J'}/JJ ~ w ~ ~jjl ~~":JI J...u:. Jlj r,Y• ·"Jr' C\V• <J::1 ~ J
~ I YJ~ LA wrll w~ 'C\ u-4 ~i 1.V. u-4 ~i wrll 1.Y'"\ 0-4 Jgi Ji r~ JS'
,s
.l)JA u-4 1.C\ • J_p::J I_~ J;...ul c'...Jji JJA...Li ~ • (Watts, 2007) ~;. ,~. w~
W::' LA~ w~ i.!.U~ wrl! wrll ~ I ~~lJ ~ ~.,JI ~J wlL.uJI u-41.'
J).,.t.l J..lAJ J ~ , , . '! , 11! ~...r4i J '}IJJ w~ r A· ")..L.....4A LA r, C\" °'Jr," 1 •
JJ.A Ji U>"" ~ r,Y· ·Y' r,k ~ ~i wrll ~IJJLll ~ ,4'LL14 .(HRW, 2007)
«. '.!-~ w~ ,(r r · · C\) J'-411 1:a ~~ r,k ~J . (Watts, 2007) ~ I D..,P u-4 1.v •
'-r'"~'}/I
" D~I f'"° ":11 ~ ll·~.ta.,.~ _:._.q ~.. , >""JA r..:r- dJJ J '"" ()A
· L~· H , ... '°"
dJJ..ul ~ I D~I ul..? ~~I ~WI 0-AJ . UNDRP (UNDP, 2009)
<t>. primitive accumulation ~l..1.;1 ~fa. DJpll F. a.Jw Dbi ~1 L ~ I
~ji~J.llJ DJbl.1 ~ I w4~'}/1J ":;>' cs,•JI w4~'}!1 ~~ ,dJjj a ~
,,
rk ~ LAk ~~ i.S...L.o ~ ~~~WI ~fi.:,JI [~~I~~< ,11•11
~ '-!.JJIJ Babangida 1~44 DJb! w~ ,J\:i.11 ~ ~ ·")b LAJ r' C\1·
-b~I L!lllA <)I.. l..& ,~...r4I.. J'}/JJ w~ H 'y ~~, r' C\C\Y' ~Jr' C\Ao W::' LA
-~.JAi J'}/JJ ~~ a:;~ wrll WJ,&,:) W::' LA Abacha Ll4i Jl~I r~ '-""'~4
jyi.U ~fi ((~yi.11 wl;.Ji» r ' ~ ' r' C\C\C\ rk ~1..)-4.4=..ul rJ.ig ~ ~
>4":JIJ . ~ I JIJAi ~ a......:iG_;JI ~i u-4 cibl ,11JI ~ J ~ I J w4~'}!1 ~
, ~ I bb~~ ~.JJIJ~I ~ i (\.1.Q[..>-.:,.; ,1111 ~?JI w":1 i_;Jo.j i~~~i
~IJ wl.;;;; ... J I ~ ~ ~I ~ll":11 .r.6'i u-4 L~IJ ~ ,(, ,_,) JL1u_;Jo.jl
obJA JAJ ·Jl+,":JIJ jlJ,A":JIJ ,D~I ~UI JJl..i....::,JIJ ~ 1 wl~4 j.!Q..u
-~...,,.:.~~::i,ir;:,;:;c-;:,o;~·- .v··.• ..•·•,;.•.._••_,.• .,,__ ~--~".':. ..:.,.~..............,,'lol\,~...-.t_.,,..•.,.,._._--.&:,·..y-~-~ ,7Zlr;-:,:r.:f ·.:.~.:,:.'<;'l!.. ......., ~ ~ y...~.,,. .....r...,:;.·-..,, ... ....,.,.._... .:.•.,:..:;.·.·......... --~~ ....... ..,,.,. ·.:-_>'Y'~~-~.... ~ - ~
rr, l,6l~ Lld ~ 'i~I Lo_,..:,~ faU :u~I ~->~!.,~~I

,. · · ")..l1iA l.....oufi:i~I ~ I 9~\w~~\0-4~~ t· u--,c~~
<lllb.:iJI w ~ 0i LS ~ I .J~..cJl..9~\ ~)'I~ ..1~...9 ;,.;i~ ~~
. (NDDC,2004) <I..!~ ~_,JI ..b.......y1 I J_,.;:i ~
Li
~~. · - .~t, Lil..lJ'A:IA<"tt~L.i~Att
,_,_ - ~ ( \\-\) r_.1~v-,-
~ . I<".-;,.
(.)-'..,-'J .
:;,.,,} ~ I
~.,i
yl
..>-9yi ':J ~..JJ---bliA~~I tJ . 1 0~0-4 '/.V· ~ ,cill:.i~J L:9~1

.. Li~l..9 o~I Jyhll..9 ~j..i.1.1.,~I.I wl<_. ,~.< ~L...~I ~4':JI ~l_,J.I ~
~ 1 .. 1_;;.Jl~jj~ ~w~L::i..l\ .,.i.....A,..::.,..1i ..l9j .4 2::e•cll wlj 2s~..::Jl..9
..6.;JI ;(g..>--'-"c:.,';J~ - ~ I l:A..b~0-4j.1.I .. I....L.JI c...-.,_.,ci ~I w~lj..JI ~1
~ J w~~I J..._.;..l..1 ww.ll..9 ~~';}\ u........i..a..l..9 "-::>..l,g ~ JJ ,c?-...ll wJc..;.Jlj
tJ..1 ~ 4\( .~.11..9 'rr · · · r~ ~ 1 .J..>. i .)L..:;.i L..S..9 ·r~ J< L;u_;-a3 ..::i~ ~
SU:! iJ ..::i~~ ~c......,!,ai 4!( .~.ti ~..9ww.ll ..::i..9.J..>. ~jj~ ..u:i~~I
. (Ibeanu , 2000; Idemudia, 2009a)
a.J_.,..ut ~t.?.t~...>:~.J.ll~l~I ~i ~ l ~ t ,i.ill~0-4~_;Jt~_.,
~j.JI ~ I .l~'ilJ ~ I ul...dL:. ~.>-4 «·r...... a i.u .J.41 ·.»-~I ~ I r::4 ~
.l...u:.ac.Uo~l~~.lL:...:i'ita...aµtjS'.>-4~~~lu~l~~'ic!J~ "
~..ul ~~I y~I ~ ~->-1,1 a...a_µt ~lk:i-.1, I.J.l . ~ µ I ~l:!'i_,110-4
~~I ~l~I 0-4 ~ ~_;.l ~~ 0-4 (' \ '\ V • ~J r' \ '\ "\ V LJ::I lA c.:1i~ <i'-11
.a.! '".!~..> ~ ~ ' D~I a~ i.ill~ uts' .i9_., , ~ , ~~' .lL:...:i'it ~
.l_;l.,.ll a..i.Al ~~~I u ~ I r::4 jA\.Llll ul.l~ ujS'_; a...aL:. ~ J
".J.A0-4JJ~lt_,l11 ~~ .D..l:!~I uL.c..uj.1.l0-4~~J-4>~Llaj1~ ~~
~ .l)-'"4 ~ fo. i.ill~J , ~ I b.b ulS:.uJ D.l..i:,J. I rJ~ I r::4 jA La:al u L.c...uj.1. I
~ IJu. .ll..J.J ~ . I~
-='-li.1.1 4-1.4,.U
• ~ rr I~ 4L.4i ~
- uL.c..u!t ' - ;.-:
J ....
~~ ·'°".>ll j-!-1
..('j
Oil Mineral Producing Area Development Commission (OMPADEC)
~ ' ~.) a.! q;; a~.! ,,._., r.'°'°'" r~ ~j~1 ~ ~ '
rr · · · rL:. l.AjLlajl ~ ~I_, Niger Delta Development Commission (NDDC)
~_., .r r · · A rL:. l.AjLlajl ~ <i'-1' Ministry of the Niger Delta ~ I b.J.l D).;JJ
obi ~L. ~ IJu· .ll..J.J ~ . I Jbli.l.l ~ - ~ • <>" Li,~ u...o'-'.
~.J.ll ci_,JI
~ 'iji-'"4Ji .JS'~ ,(Frynas, 2000) ~ , .l..>JA u~ j~J a...awt ull~
. (Omotola, 2007) ~ I b.J.l ~ ~
. . l ~ I ~ls:.!.,-.~ .~.·.i ~ I uLi.iu..uj..1.1 ~ a_;,\:JI ~~I u~J
~I~_, . l ~ I uLi.u_;W al;; cull ~I~ oj_;~I Ll:&..o~I u q·oii
Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related a._:g)WI ul~ ~I ,.S.»-
~.)~'ii ~~I ~ . , r r · · · rL.c. ~ Offences Commission (ICPC)
~ Economic and Financial Crime Commission (EFCC) 4 U. 1_.,
L...,~ ~ l ~ ' i l uL.c.~ ¥ ~ I D_;.l~J r'r• •'1' r'Lc.
~.), .i9J .Nigeria Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (NEITI)
~ A'r 0-4 _;6'i ~ ~\.:, ,.SJL:..l ~..> ~l:i 4U.I_., ~.)~'ii 4..4.i~I ~
0,4 ~_)Ai _)'iJ.) LJ.:_\:)4 d > 0,4 _;oi u.)l.t:i......i.ul ~ i_., J~ 'ii_, .)L..a..ll} ~ ~
I 14
.(HRW,2007) U~I Jl-'"4~1
,~~?JI ~l:tlll ~ 1.+J 0 \S' ~I_, .lL.w;JI ~_;W ub~I ~ 0-4 ~_;JI~
JIJLA .)L.w;Jt ut., u~I ~ 1.).,~ uts' r~'
ul u~?l' J~ ¥1->-° a~.!"'~ 'i
,.~jl;~-
.. ~ ....~~~~.......,,., ~'2'0:-.V.0,'r.lt<'l:":,'l_""'Xl"~.,._T.,.•.... - " ' , . . , . . . _ ~ ~ W i 4 1 ~ ~ ~
n," ~~ 41d ~ c.i.'..L.tl Lo..9 o~ fall :ul.J:..al ~ ~Lw..il!J W~I

[~;;...:...i;· ,·:.-.;./.··· ,.;.,.i:, ..:•.-;·.'·' ,. ·,<:~ '··1-····:·.'.'.•·./·: .,_,·,··:·,,'.,' ·,
~'.·.!1>JJI.JlA~6.J .(HRW,2007)~~1~~,~~~ - -
Corruption Perceptions Index .l~I ~\S'J..1.A ~j.A ~ aJJ.l \A· W:! lA H' • Y'
~ .Transparency International (Tl, 2009) 4J.JI ~LL...jJI ~ c-3\:i.JI
a;,~ll ~ t ~ ~ ,... , .~., ~ ' a..oµ, 0i ~ i .!~~ "'1l~ J.j---J:,
~ld..uAil ~LL...jJI oJ.l4-o ~ ~ a.!A~I as-J ~ I 0A L, iS: Q; sci ~\S' 4.4\.A
~IJ Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) ~1~'}11
~~ .~Ll........c:u~i~~l~\S'~L~l~le~J.t=::i ... ~\S'
~J~I u~ll t ~ ~ a..oµt ~ f1 Ju.ti l.:U ~~ ~J J ~ ,J\::J.I
~LL...jJIJ d.Al_µI ~J ~ 1 ~JA ~ o~~ .>::ti.Lit';.,.! 0\S' ~.J.JIJ 4UI
,.:a~
SCI
.l-"*: . ~ ~ , ~\S' ~ a..oµ, ~l,g~J a;,1.i-:!,11 J~i -1.:?-jiJ

a.JJ.JI ~ ~ ~l~J ~~J ~~ J ~ ~1.?. ~1 L~I ~ 0A ~1~1
~ .l~I ~ ~ jAw.11 .l.t: ,"'1l.J.J a~ . (ldemudia, 2009b) L ~ I
~.. I ~JA ~-= ·~-~,
i.: .rJ ~• l.l.All .. -" o...Li>o
.. ' ~J ,. ~ L~~ ~t L
... L·<- ·
:-!)~
- -
.~.l\ ~ 1 \:i.J.l ~! ~ Ll..u...cJ.1
u--,.-:,: _...at i:a ~ "_..6-n" ~c.:.~.J a..u.at ~t!lt.JA

~'}]l<)JWI ' - • -
...... ' - J~ .. · - " Lf:Ll_o~L
~J""&" :J-L'-" 1~JA
.. , a..J
.. J ..u1~~1~.J.4Li
-
o~~ ~L.u~_;-,_,b:JJ rWI J ~ r..l4i 0A ".JI..»-!~ lA ~1.;,1 a Qt;,;Qu r~'
y~~~, rW~~~~ .L.lWI ~~~ .ll~?JJ ·r'°'°'°'
a..J.Wl~~I~
.. .. ,,_,_~ u L-~.l~..1.4-
.1~-
- ~ -"~.rjj\.r.~ ... t\ j-4J~~q~.._"j
"': "':.,........., y. .. :.r- A • • •
.~
· - .~,1 \:i.J.l.~
~ d.AI' ~j -~'I .. l:'u.A • l ~ I ~Ll.o ~r.J--
' '-' .. rJ-&AAr
'- ~ -'I 0:
· .i9k. ~ WJ 1~.
~\S' .J.41 .1~ ~J.JI ~~I~ 0J.l4"o ~1.)J y4,.....ui o~ l.!lLl.A u\S'
Jt\~ ~ ..lSJ .~1 \:i.J.l oA ~1 ~1~1 ~ i.b~ ~ ~~I ~\S'~I
~ ~l......iA~\ ~ ~ .lL...uill ~~ J ~ ~ ~.l~I ~\S'~I c.S~l
~I~~ .J.41 .Nexen~ as'~~ as'~l ".:UJ ~~1 ~LL...jJI
JI~~< cc•JI ~ji~.ul ~ ~ ~.l~I lAJJ.U '}]IJ O.l~I 0--4 ~
I r'~
<').lbJ':lll ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.l~l l.AJ_,.J_, c:l£A 0.,w.11 ~>1 Lc:u~i
~ ~ "4JJ ,b ciilJ ~ a.JJ.l 1.J........AS' ~\S' .J.41 -~~..ul o.l~I ~
..
J-4.:L.J -
':ll~i 1~ ).) .i9J . ..)L...uill oA lA~ 4WIJ &Li.JI ~\S'~I J ~
~ J:,L.u Jt~J ~ 4J.JI ~~I~ ~ J Y'J Ashola Williams
~~~~,t'.'..Llll.o
• • • - "=' !.9 ~...L>iJl;;\i :u~l~~l.wi.All
.. ~
~~I
• . .,. ~t
~ ~u.;JI ~J • ~ ~ J ~ 0:~I ..l1ui <JAJ ~ I a.,., cull wl~I
..HJ;. w~I ~ as'l~4 4-A~I ~ 'i~i ~ I ~ 4_,...ul ~~I~
.~..GS'JI ~~I
..HJ;. JLl:il ..l4C. ~ ~ i~ o..u:.IJ Durban ~.JJJ ~ ~..l.:,1.1 uLl,u.;JI ~LS'~

J~I L~ - ' - ~ L~ J
~ (.)-"'
_'\ ~~I
· I~."::""" - ~
~
as'I~
- .:..tt ~ . )
.as'l~I ~ .J_,.b:"J ~ J ~ ~ J .l.!.U.:i.J «b.:b:ic::JI i..1-:tJ , ~ I tJJ ~
'--9~ .oj.J4JI wlJ.:,cJ.I 0A IJ..u:. t ~ 0i c..:,k JLl:il ~UA 0LS' ~l~I .J.l4
'--9-1,&ll wlS' . t~ t ~ I I~ i~ '--9J-'-" J ~ I ~~ wl.JJ4A 0-4 "":..u.ll
~J Niger Delta Development Commission ~ I tJJ a.: 4;; ~ c:.,..,.fi:i _j---Jb
~ , J~JA I I~ ~,,~,JI
.~::..1:,,-j '-:"" - L L-
JA. ~..ill c\.J·
~
·- .~ti L·<
~ ~
- ,, I .~Lla:,j ~~
..
'--9.l,8Jl~rJJ .~J~'il ~ I ~·~,;J~I tJ...u cGfi..ll w~~lS?ioJ-A
J ~ I ~~ ~ '! . • • tf
. 1-t~·.
.J ~
1 ~·· 1' ,r...1l~I
~"""':-8-'-'"=' f" \Jo.ill r ~Io -
. '.J JW\
•
a.b;. <.)A
·
,~~I <JA.J~I ~c..:,kJ ~l:J4J . .J ,:aiiJI ~..HJ:..J~I I~~ L4.A

.;;..>-!fi ~.J..1-:t J~, <JA ~L;.. ..(g w <>"=-'""t:i c..:,k ;;.)..LW r w~ Y ~ ~'1A 0 LS'
~~~I~ ~I J~l 0-4 ~ J ~ ~~t ~ J:~I .J~l wlS'
.0..1:i- c..:,k d..16. JS' c..:,k~..,:J4 d.J~J tJ...ul ~ ~ I w~~ 0,J->-4i w~u
...1.4£ll 0~ ~ 0:.igla:i.l.lJ ~ J ~ I w k ~ w~)'I .JA ~ i .PS'~IJ JJ~I
o.)~I .>Jfa ~ ~~1.JA ~\:JI '--9~1J .~I~~ J ~ l w..o ~\,;.JI
~IJA c>->~ w~l.H-'-" 0:.:i.JI u.o~~I ~_;..Li 01 -~~I ~IJA ¥1.J-A c..:,k
;$
•o.>A JS' ~ ..1:i- I_, ..l4C. c..:,k ~..>=J4 i.ill ~J lA.A LJ:9.l,8l I ~ ~_,JI .JA o lj..U I
f-1 LA ~I~ r~' ~ ~ 01 O.)J4ll ul c..:,k 4.dlJA \.LJUA uLS' ~'~' .J.l4J
wLS'~I w4~1 w..o I~ [?i .o~b .)J~ 0A ~UI ~...ul ~ ~
rW~IJ w ~ I ~ J Shell Oil~ J,:u as'~ tJ...ul ~~~I o~I
~~'--9.;,1,~itlal~lw..owl .~l~~I tJJc1,:4iia~.:"'J~~I
LAi -.JJ~I ~ 0-4 ~i <JA l.\L~ J.JIJA w~4-, 1~1 J ~ I w..o ~L;.. t ~ I 0~
~ I o .~r~: ~ . i:\ c:LJI
· · L~· i.:,- -t~ ~. • <·
- " ~ u-':! \ -
c\.J..GS'JI
-
L-< - 'I · tUI ~ ...ul
~ <.)A c.:r'
-'4
4_,...ul ~ I aJLS'_, WJ ~...ul .JJ~ <JA c:.,..,__;J..c.Al. -~~ y4JI I~~ -~- -
~..GS'JI ~IJ Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) ~..GS'JI
~)LIi wl~I ~J .Canadian High Commission in Nigeria~ 4,WI
~~ ~r"'t-~·.a....,..,>c>:t·y't;l41:Y.!-4$'# V , ~ 1 1 l ' l ' O $ ~ . , . J i 1 . f f " ~ ~ - c , ; r n ~ ~ " ' m . T ~ t l - . ~ . . : : : r . l , J J -~~-~~'4fC.~.·~-'"Y;<•,~·--.~~.a·:,,e,':":~9'~
Y,"O ~~ 4.1.as ~ t:f.71ll Lo.9 Q ~ fall :ul.J::a.al ~ .i'"'-iJ!_g 4-.w-.)-?.ll

cf. i £, ·1· ~ ~ !· ~ C• ']. ~: c_. ~· ;, ~ tX tX
.r-1 'e.. ~ '.:. • -~ [ t
E: , • • 0 !:- - - n ri:-
~1 ~ t
rt 'Ii.'t ,f~ ri.'&~· fl..[- re. ~rt 'G't-t. ~[t ~,£"'t 1·l, 1.-.~· l ·~ ,tEt t r:~
:t· ,{ ~ ·: ·: ~ F [', ~· \. [ } i c, _: .c- ~ . .,. t Tl,.{' t' ~: ~ ~·
l; ~ fl.. . . - t ~ ~ - t t tf, C> i ·~. \ ~· -,c; f tX ;~ ~
4...1 c.' [ ~~ ,t ~ E! { - ,- L~- ~ ~ Ii.. ri 't' " ·~ t' 1. •lj.: 't.·
~t l'.i\ - r, r, f ~ f f:!. ~ - r:- - E "° ~· ~ ~ E i ,c; , t
.E .E 'Ci.. :
fl'·~ { ~ Lr
i'__: rrJ·; ~~ ·r...r ~ t,C~ J; 'S", :~ & ~
[.. I : ·r.., .; ~. 'l, ~ f:!. '\. ~ t' ,t" '[ (/) C i;:
t . l:: I,t • fC-'• fC-'• 1s:: ~ . •(i't• 'D):... !?:e-: ~ I " l, C>I I f"' ~ , ~• ~ [; • s
i
~ l~ ~1: -; :; ~ 11. • g,
J: . _. I), \ J (1) - I~ I & ~ ~
z 1:. 1-,e, c:: •E, e<> 'ts-• 'l tc;: ~· t ~-t' 1£: ~ ~ 'l~ i'.= r:t ,t!t.
le.. l l •
f t-
[1 ~ ~ ~ I' 8 ~ -;e t"• (1 r ~ ~ - f"~ ~ , I - ~ ; ,~ ~ l, ,t° &- ,t° [
101:.:.->= _V\-,, I C.,~ ! -• I ,.,
I 1
f JJ t 1 f ~- l ~ ~ ;- £ ~ t~ . 5; f ~ ~ ·.:~. ri. .'
·cC ~ ~ e. ~- 1:- •.:·•·.
·1.-. ,r. 'f. J c.. <t, ~ ·t ~- ,t
f. i{ ~· 't~: $.~ 'it r t t:~ 1.l ,d ~ l ~.l
... - . . s~r ~. f.~ • ., .... t, t<: 'l.e~1,~t r-- r-;f 11
j ,1 l· 'k ,L 1;, :f: .'t ~; 1 ,; l l f ~ ·[ g l ft l ~ 'Ii.: i r'. ~ . r.-o }- { °,
e-· 1- C>. rs· 1:. \. !fA ~ ·,, ~· q rt ·~ l'.i\ c·
t .k c.b' ~
t- I~ - f"' ~ ~ I
't, l::
i. ,{; E~1
cf. U>' -
t
~~ t_,. ~("" · 1
'l! \ !
~- ,fr:-' • I
l. e: .; (, E ;t ., C· \t. c- 1 ~ t . 1 f :F. ..- 'Ii.=

I> & t> fu. ,i;.. I:: C· <- !::
,r· cf ·t't. , fu ~ 1 "
~ ~f t- t - l -: z
·. f i. le_. ~ i_ I '\ C· ~·· '\. ~· !
.l l'..- ~t.,: ~'lE ~~ 1·t i~.
Isl• I L I • I - \) I C D\ t"' L
~ C· !... 1>- ~t~ ~
~~ t~ ~. fr' J .·~~ ·\ ~- 1
V\ V\ _ • 1[. - l, 'I> I I I~ • _. C:..
'tP.' • fl.. i.;.I!_. -[ 'r~
I ~ "°~
-
t- ~t' ~•- 1I; P· l .~ ~
~
re, t E ~ t1
lt>
·~ ..
I:.
~ ·f. u- ( ·1: 'r 1:1: ~ ~ t }-c. !
~•
~ ~ ~I l I I I - _, - • - I,
,L
l r ~ ~' .[' }. ~ !, l ~· ~ ~ •t 1 f ,t• { 'lj_. l! 1 -:- -i ( i t' 1,° ' ; ~ I ('i
:t' ·~: r;; ·t. t. r { ~· rt i. t.J: ~ .~ -~ -t; <t [it(,!:. !i t ~ 1: t ·~ i :r.

..if ~ V\
Ii\ _ ~ ~ ~ !E "" ~ f) _ t> c 1> ""
v- - e. t- t> "" lD _ \o -
- • .) ~~I ~
Ll..w.l · ~L----~•a..b.
~ ~ l~a..J
• _!J . J .- J l ~ ~ I ~ ~
-~
~ ~ J ' r " · · ' r1..c.~~~~J -~jllr~'iJ~~IJJ~~,
, ~ 4J.J.ll ¥LLlJI ~ ~ ~ <.j.:UI Shade Lawal JIJ'i l.j~L..j, ct4,oj
4-Y.t ~..1AJ '-""y,:.'i ~..1A ~ ~_;JI ~lw:J.1 y ~ t ~~ Jl_;g.;~.J.ll rll
lshola Williams ~ J 'i~t ~I.; ...(gJ ,u.;fi.;LA u.;~ ~..1A ~ >---:P"-fJ
w,k~I,-, Lo,. .i9J . ~ I bb~~~<J:lJJ..--uJ.41~1~
Shell Nigeria ~ J.-j, aS'~ &.o ~ J;! &.o .;.b.J4 y ~ <;r-4'=:1 ~..,:;
Nigerian Anti-Corruption Commission ~ I ~Lc.wiJI ~~ ~ J
~jiaJ~I ~ ~ ~6..1.1 aS°..»-J J~I ~ J ~ I u ~ I &.o ~..1..-e.J
w,k ~ I J ~ .Movement for the Survival of Ogoni People (MOSOP)
w,k Niger Delta Development Commission ~ I L~.b a.! Q;; ~ ;;~1
w,k ~~I ~i &.o ;;~L.-JJ ~6. ~I~~~ 0-,).J:!..UI .;~ tl.zal &.o ~_;JI
- \.!•11cc
. .d.! • :.-ti ~~
-I I - • I • ti
~ ~'-'-'t..l:IJ
,JJ~I ~j4.U ,b.!b:ic::JI t~ ,a..b,;.JI w,k ~_;JI ~~I y ~ t ~IJ-4:'J

~~ ~..1.Ai ~i &.o ~~J Statoil JJJi;.!;'" .JA JJ~I ·0-J..;-:i-,i ~~ ~ ~ ~
¥~1~.JA~~IJ -~.JAi.;'iJ~ \ •, • • • ~t~4~~1~LA
- t ~ I ~ aS'.;~I ;;~tg ~ j i ~~TI-Norway ~J.>ll4 ~J.J.ll
rLA~,~~~~~,_iia~i~~~_;-11~~iFl~Ju--S1J
-¥~1 ul_,.L.,, ~)l:; ~jll ~ rJL.u,I
~jll ~Ju~l~.:i:i i>:>-i~ ,~~I a.b._;-11 ~~&4ul~~~ ~J

tl.b.aJIJ L~I &.o ~ ~1-"4 w,k J ~ I J ~lj.lll ~IJA r~ W1J~ JJ~I
0-J_.>-~a.JIJ t:t~I ~ 4-Y. t ~ ~jll ~ ...(gJ ~_,Jo:"JI uw. l.b.aJIJ <>°L....;JI
u~ ~ V O ~ ~jll ~ ...(gj ·rr .. t J:LA ~ L>-4 0-J~IJ &.o~IJ
_(O)~ or
Oby Ezekweseli ~fi..Hl <;:r.Ji 4i.;~.J.ll 4i~I ~~'ii a ,,,l~l '-""i.; ...(gJ
,b.!b;..:JIJ ~IJ.:11 a_;gl..>A 4i~J ~ . ; ~J ,~.;ll ~\.;.JI ~~LuJI ;;~
ul.d.l.a.::Jl ~~I
.. • ~~
4i'.) ~l...o •....·L.tl-tlw:J.1
, . . c_- ~~j
• '-- ~~ ~~
u-
~ ...(gJ . Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) ~ I ~'ii
...dWI Chief Olusegun Obsanjo-GCFR.,_-:-; ,:., ,114Ji 0~_,JJi ~_;Jl~jll ~
------•·:...-
•-~~-~"1.1'.l'Xle.'i!V :jt ~ 0 : : f l = N T . " " ' t . ' I K t . ~ ~......w~~~A·~~.~~~~11
n'V ~~ 4.1.&9 ~ <$~I LAJ ~~ faU : u ~ l '="9 J~~ 4.4.J~I

u\.!«o~IJ~LJ-4..»-i J..u:.i.!lllAw~J . ~ I ~J\..:...:i~I ~~I ~JJ~~I
~Joy:...) ~~'}JI ~ I ~ J ~4,.:i C-4.u,~I ~ .~..l=t:.ll ~Y:,..) ~ 0:.:UI
Niger Delta Development Commission (NDDC)~I ~ba.:a ;;a~.:"'~
b.b a.:o;; ~ tJA ~ J ~ I oJ.ll.i.A ~l 1.Pl ~.:UI t.h;.J\ .JAJ , ~ u ~ ~L.41':J
- ~ ~ ~IJyl ~1 t ~ I ..)~i.,~I
Jl..~~_;11 ..)~, 0~ J ~ ~.,:, ~1 uw:.~_j,1.1,-, iocoiJ
~1~'}/1 u~~I ~ ¥ ~ 1 DJ.l4,l r~'}/4 L,~1 ~fi.:,J1
yW~1J ~l~I ~ ua~J Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative
, ~ 0A ~1~1 ~ ~ ~1 ~1 ulS'.;---...!. J;g 0-4 ~~ ~~..u.1
ul:~1 wJ •oi=:-..11 ~w ~ .Joi cceO ~_)-)_jl.o:lJ1 o.J..& LIJl..>~J ~'..>4:'
J~IJ ~~1_, Lfi..=,J1 ~1ji ~1J jW1J ~1 t\..b:g ~ .)~I lAJL:ii ~I
"..>-1~ ~ll ~.:U1 ¥~1 J ~ r-*1-4 f:>~ ~ ~ -~fi.>J1 ~ u'-4M1J
. ~ 1 ((;~ ~li..o_, Transparency International ~_,..u1 ¥~1 ~
~J .JA J~)'I ~ f-"'~1., . L~ ~1., ~L"ill.J a.:cc·.:~.;JI ~1~1 ua~ ~ W'

a.6..~ J~'}/1 ~ 0,1 (\.jj ~l oJ.l4,l.1 ~_;-bJ ~ ~ _ , - a ~ «J~'}/1 r~» i--4A
i..Lt,l1 1.J..& ~~ wi ~ i l l l_jl 1 ~ t ~ W' . I.LU~ ~ ~_;11 llil_,-o t)J.l ~l:&11
·t~1 J>-1.;-o ~lS' ~
~
. I & Uo·b~I
(.) - ~· " T
-~~i~\..uib~·~ILU~
- - (.) -.,,..:u1 (.)-":.LA.tlllAi
~":?
t~1., ~~,~~fa ~w ~~ ~~1 ~ -,~ ~ . , rt,:;'}11_, -':!~1
· <t • ~
~., - I ~-'"°
· I.?""~
. 4' . - · ~,1 l:i.l..) I.?""
. ~ o1i..;--
~ ~t\ -l:u_o
<J - r.J-8,4A
•
~ . , r~ c.r,.-.-.
• ~ 1~ · ·· • .< - t\
o.J..& ~ uw~! J~ ~ J~IJ d5.J~I I.S~ o..)l:_j .JA _µ ~ I
~y:...)~0:.:u1~~~l:&llr~1~., .~ir.~Y-~1 l:i.l..)~0µ1
l:i.l..) a.:aii ~ ~ ~1 o.Jb?JI I.LU~ 0-4 ~ - - ' u~lll.1 ~ Jo~ 1fiJLl,J
.(NDDC}~1
:~l:i.ll u~~_j,1.1 u ~ 1 ~ wfi.JLlJ.1 JJLD 'f"~~i~ ~ ~ ~J

.a.:cc«/~I ul:~1-
.J~I ~ ~lS'~1 -
Ll1-~fl -
• "= • · L~t1
~J.
~ l.!11~ \si ,~.,llA ~ ~I J_,6,JI c.>-4 J~ i.S?i DJ-A wk~I wJk ~
c.P,lli.tl ~ !.!.U~J ~~I J,J..)o ~ wl.;l.>9 a=u.u ~ ~ .isJ . 4.Ak ~to. ~
:.;l~IJ
¥l.a....1WI ~ J ~ d..o~ ~ J Integrity Pact oljlll Jl\.L~ ~ Lli _,
!.!.U~ &:-T M ~ d.,jf..9 ~ µ I w~l.UI ~~ ~ ~~I ~ ~~IJ
JI ~ ~ ,,
.~
-· ~
I"..-:t'il ~
r'J-""' · .,~~u· I.~
·- wl.o·< - ti · I Ll..L.i.A o.l'..)-'-''"'
~ u..9 - .
". :ti - ~ '- .:~I ~·'I u· j -'1'
- ~l.:r-..9u-"':P..J-'
.&~ wl.o~ ufi:i ~ olj.lll ~'~
Transparency International Nigeria (TIN)~ ~_,..ul ~lLlJI ~ 0::' ~ ~~ -r
t~ ~~ ~ "-"lj.ill J:!Jlyi ~ ~ ~i i>A '5~~1 ~J..ul_, ~ I ~LJ~~.i.J.IJ
.jWl_,~I
!.!.U~ c.r• Li..s). a..J-..9...ul Ll~I
- _J..JI Ll~I
a...J - ~ ~ 1- -t ~..9 ~~·
~~I ~ I wl.J..u ~~ ~ j.fi..>=JI (i.S~~I wLllA~l..9 ~WI w~I
. ~ ¥-al --':~4J a:s}WI wl~ ~~I w~4 r~'il..9 ~~I
oljlll ~1-'"4 ~ ~y ~I 4i •.1......d.all ~ wl.o.jl....ll ~ JJ ,o:>JI ~ -o
wl': .. q c4 u-"-'
'-":8-' '--'l~~
.. - . : ' I
.. L l ~ I ~ ~'-~,,.,
• .- . • ,11lll'•·'
~..9 .a..J~I
.wl.o.jl....ll ~ J~I ~ uyll &'-" ~~ d..4&-1...ul..9 J_?._jll

.
~j
&. c1..w.4:L-
.. ~
'~I: :tt.;u....cs ~
'J-'"" l,,;I
'! .. L~L.JtJ. '-- a1u
- v-, 'jj
<- · ~'.jLJ-'-"
~ .~ y
•
i.~
-~~-'\
....
. Niger Delta Development Commission ~ I b.b a~ Q..U ~ --':~4
~>lll w l ~ ,b~b;..:JI ~J..;J ~l.all iS".J~~ ~ ) ~..i.:,..:; ~ !.!.U~ ~
JI
~l.alll ~ .is~ ..~
-.:ti tJJ~~wl..isW
- - ~
'- 01::11
'..)-'-' "-' ~ · - .,b;t
- r~~~- ......
:~..9 ~tJI r-'=11 ~ yb~b~i.ll
~w ,~._rll f"'J (TIN) ~ 4J...UI ¥l.a....1WI ~ ~L.o.ci c.>-4 a 1114"> -
._;-iij.11 F..9 D.)l~'i' ~ ~L.o.ci c.>-4 01~ ,~._rll
~ I J ~.;Jl..9 (Tl-Canada) ~~I 4..9...ul ¥l.a....1WI ~ c.>A u l ~ -
.National Coordinator ~_,JI
~_,JI .>:!~I ~J (Tl-Norway) ~~14_.,...ul ¥ ~ I ~ LJ.A ~ -
. National Director
~~~~~™~;~~::.. : : ; : . - , . , _ . . , . . . x , : , x ~ ~ _ . , . , ; ~ - · ~ ~ s . i r , , . . _ ' \ ! l t M ) t 1 ' . ~ - ... ~·~:!'.-~-~-,~·~-y_,.~...--.·,•-~
n'~ ~~ 4.1.a.9 ~ ':f.:.Lll Lo_g ~~ faU :ul.J:Li.11 ~ ..)\.wwil!., 4 , ~ t
11·0· ~ . . ~-- .-· . , ..........,·< ,. -<··:.r g.. ·1,.~ 1·... ,. . _.. . if:... ·x' .-.·-t,, .-.-=·,).'cl'., . . . /1· ·r::,~~··:·=· =· ==..-·== ·... .-·::..::=: . !l ·.; . . ... .: .!.,}·· .........._1 • : ... ,~ .I. ... ,rr· ·. u .,. =...J', ·. c . . . . , .,. . . . . ·-6 >v ....... ·v:. ,·, ... L:,'.-1 t =-::.1 >: /·--K ·.~·:.,fa}·::. AA ·.". +r ,h-<· -,,y·.-·. . ,-.,._; ¥:'i'I
(TI-S) ~.,..w1 ~ , a .~, 11 a ., t;, ; ., a.......,_,u~ 0-4 ., .;,. c -

LL.a.JI~,~, • ; llJ LAIJ--i--11 &-:--11~ ~ L l ~ ..>-:..l-4 .,.._AJ
. Integrity Pacts and Public Contracting Programme Manager
.Statoil j.J-.,t ~ as~ <JA ~ -
bl...u ~~I~~, ., t;, i ~' t ~1_, ~ t-ll.H ~ ~ ) -
~.,_l}il ~ ~ ~L:.J.I a....S'_p,J_, ,Niger Delta NGOs ~ I
w" '?' r_, ,(MOSOP) Movement for the Survival of Ogoni People
~I ~ ~ I W..:1 ~ . , Ijan Youth Council u~i y ~
Niger Delta for Professional Development
.~lal.JI ~~~OJ:!~~~J>j ~ -
:~b.11 ~ ~lal.ll ~ a b ; . ~ ~.,
.~)UI ~ l ~ I ~ j i J "":?~ _,
.~~., r..:1WI ~lal.ll ~J.A J:?~ -r
Niger Delta Development ~ I l_,jlJ ~ ~ ~~ 4:t~~I -r
. Commission (NDDC)
.~~ ~ JLl:i~IJ t ~ I <)A~ U j.J_.,.ii J.l~ "?~ -t
•u--
'- -11 a.b;. . :1~· ~ <.:,->-
,.... '-'-u:;1 ~ - )UI ~lal.ll
· t.? ·
"TJ
:~b.J~ 0~ i:,t ~ ~~I ~,~1 "":?~ ~ _,
.J.!oii i>fo ~y.l ·b.!b~I ~ t~IJ "?~I ~..,JI a..a1JA ~ Y..?.J -
b.1..:1 a.!a i i ~ ~ti~~~~~~~., ,~lhll ~~ ~ ~~ J~
.~I
a...u~,
..
w.,s:.J.b b.:..:.J, .1.., ~
~ - -
-:.~,L
.
01:'J-*':11 c..9-l:u.A
- a..._,.jt&.JI
.. u-- a....._j,'.)J ~ - L_,,
~J~IJ~<.)l~...LiJ~I ut..:1a.!.,;;~~..:1~~ 1 sa.!:b;
.olJ-i11 J~ r~
~ I # ~JfiJUI ~.)_j,! ~.J.A ~ ~ <i'11 ~\:&.JI ~ I ~JJ ~ i:,i ~ -
c...J.b::&.,
• -
I~,., .4..&1:.
-
4.Jll· t\ •
.'..}"'(>--4
£uJIJ ol:
~ :ti '-tu.A
-'- L~t ebb;.,,~~~
'= •.~ ~
•~ I.) ..l.411 ~ Li:,
-~'..>-'-"c..9
:. .. tu.A
.. f' ,~L, -.. -~ ~ ..:11.u..1 c..:r-
,. . Ll' ~~'I ;;.L:..
.. "tt-'"' ~~.;-Ju
'I :~ - . i ~
....
-
fl /$
u~ u' ~ -
C
• ~ . ; i.e.J.A ~l.;...l.4ll ~~
1... ~ .< ·--:tt.,
~~J-W.
4.AI'..}-'-
~ ~ti -
~~:.1 r ' IJ-.f , 111 ~.. lb:, ~ y.. Ll~!
.. · " · t~ ~,1 ~
'-TJ-1='*' .... -
·IS?~I IS.,J:i ~'iJ
C fl C
.t9l.,JI <>°.JI~ ~ ~jj c;JI J~'il ~ ~~I ~I (>4 -
oA . ; ~ u~ ~6.. c.!.Jl.i.A , ~ I tJ.l ~ ~ ~ ~ ,P.;J ~ ~ -

.o.l~ ~bj a;,l:JI ~ I ~.JJ
·lo~~
•.i..;,Y,,-
r ·- .~ti tJ.l ~
.. ~
.. 1...J.:i..:..J
• • ~6,..
• c.!.Jl.i.A _
:~.J ~\.:tll ~ I ~.;.,J ~I.J.A~I oA .l~ ~.J ~,_;~'ii~ ..ill~ .:G.-1=,J
.o~I ~ (>4 ~ ~ I J olJ1.ll J~ r~ ~JJ -

.~l:!.;JI ~ ~...;...L4.fl ~ ~~I -
~fi.=,Jl~~~,~~.;Jl~Jj.-.1.IJ~l~~~l~~-
.~j-i.4.1.1 .l~4 U~ ~ c.J:.JJIJ~I tJ.l a.icio a~.!"J
~ ~• L U L..-.~tttJ.l~~
~ - -
,~~t, -l:u...o '! .. L-: , ... ~ .<.--:t _
~ 0 'J-W ~ .. ~ ~ ~ J - W 1
.i~iJ~IJi~Jik~
..1.w uiJ Js~I ~ c):u~ ~ ' ~ . ; J ~ ul ~ ~t m1~1 ~ '"4S'
..1.w ui ~ ('f • • t, \ t-\Y') ..H~j ~ J Ji (Y' ·-Y\) ~~ ~~ ~
~I.J.A~I ~ ~ J..-.:?,. i oAJ ,..ill~ t:,11 a_g~l .~.;.,._5.;lA ~_;~ ~...\.A ~
-.. :.~t --·~tt tJ.l ~
~~ - ~ .. ~ · ~L.IJ(>JJ,>- • o
· · Tl,..jl.......:,..
• · ~
'.)~ ~ ~
1... llil·'I
~ ufi_;L:;..ll o~i ~.:UIJ olj1.ll J~ r~ J~IJ ~Ll:JI oA IS~I

•<'>-':!LA~ (>4 rA t:,11 rv oA ~ ~.:u1 ..)4ij.ll
~ u ~ l ~ .bl;.. ~~~I b.ba.:qii~ l : ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ - ,
u .Jfi.)l.4' U.)~ ~ ~~ ~ W ~ 4.411.).lll J ~ r~ -'-4~1 ~ I bl.) a.: q.,U
- --
~., .J4iJll~as.)~ ~~-"..) ~dJ::i.,,r"· ., ~ . . ) ~ ~
~ I bl.) 4.:qii ~ ~.J.J..)l.c. ,~I.J..)j~ d.i.41....A ~i ~ ~\.J..)1 ~ '-4 ~
.J4iJll ~ ~ ' as.)~~~' dl~., ,~~ ~~ J.,t J)L;. J4iJll
~--('i..u:i
~
:.~laJ\.1J--·~
U"' J ~
1\bl..)~~o..)~I~\-
- .. .. .. . .. '..>-'--'-"1·~,l.:U
u ..
-rJoii 0i D.J..)~ ~ 1::i1 ~
0--A ~ i .J-A l....AJ ~uJI ~ I a....1u.JJ J..-,~ ~~ ~ ~J -t
~ I 4...--:~I ~ I ~ . J ~ 0--A r ~ l l.!l~ 0~ ...L....41 .d...J::i
~JJJI ~ I Ll~J t~ ~-"4 ~ 0--AJ Canadian High Commission
~ Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) 4...--:~I
~ yllo ~.14i Y-'-"Lal 0-4 0i ~ Jl.aJ~I ~ ...L....41 - t ~ I ~..) ~l.,.t.

~~
-.('. -~-' J..ul.:i
- 1-!l~ u• ~iJ .u.J\S:JI - · ~ (NDDC) ~
~ ..
· - .:tt bl.)~ ..
~J-'-"J 4. J_,:i_,ll ~ ~IJ ~i ~ Statoil J.i..Ji ~ J Nexen~
~i 0-4 ast~I JJ.J..u..o J:~ ~ .igJ .Ji~ 1.S.»-i .J..)~ ~~I~
~JJ.ll ¥L;.jJI ~ t:tbll Partnership for Transparency Fund ¥L;.jJI
c4 J.i~I .J..)~ ~_,_;:; ~ i ~ Jl.aJI 1-!l~ 0~J .Ji~ '=,\:oi,114.J~
~ J t.~ 10-4 ~~, ~ ~ dJ::i 0~ i~ u~~4 r ~ ' r.u:.
~ a..J 1,.. -1..aJ~I .. J · j .4..&.9
- J JJI LlL;.jJI
a..J .. .. J JJI ast'J-"""""
· -~-t\ u· i (..:r""'- 1..9 f.l 1.)-:> •.,e LlJ.1
.. ~ . )
TI-Norway ~.J.)-"' .•. :tl.JLlL;.jJ\~
• .. iJ - T l l. ~ .. L l ~ I ~iJ L~ ·
·r'-4~1 ~ D.J..)414 ~..ill~ o.u:.l:9 ~
~~ o..)~b, F'J ~LaJ ~~~a ... J::-JI r::9.J ~ ..)~1 ~ ~~~, ~.,
--.&,·i~
r~~I c..:r'2+l i..r-., ..r1"" ~ ": U'F
:..,..jt.i.NDDC--.:t\bl..)~~
~ .. - c4
a..._:g~\
TIN L~• a..J .. J JJI Ll~I
- ~ r~u -- · i (..:r""'-1..9
,,.. ·LaJ~I f.l.. , l.:.U .-c-- 1t I . .('~I
~
o..)~>lJ
.. ~·- .:q bl.)~ .. :i -: ... t L.WI o b~\
~- '.J .. c4 ~w aJ J.:>J
J. ~ I ..)·"~t\
~
~~
.
~l.aJ ~ a1u.JJ ~ ~~'i ~ I J ~>Lll ul_,b;.JI ~laj_;-.ii_;ll 0 ~
JI
~fa-1>:! ~Ji .J.¢'.JJI 0-4 •.,lb.: ··:j • "4=il::i~I bl.) 4.:au ~ o.Jbl c-4
.;l~>Ll ~ I L...:J..) ~ ~ ~..>-! J~~4 Dr Obey Ezekwesili
JI
l:,WI ~~I ~ I ~.J 0-4 ~ ~~ ~ -r~~I ~l..>-4 ~ 4.lA~

~ I bl.) a.:Q ;; ~ ~.J c4 ~w ~ 0~ Canadian High Commission
rtu.s'l' J..9~1 ~WJ1 ~ U.Jfi.JLA U.J~ ~ LA~ ~ t ~ ~Li.l
.~j..t.l ~ o-4 t~i ~ ~ I a.!1,oiatl
~>11 Jig l>-4 LJ:*A~I tJ..) a.!4 n a~.!4) ~.J 0i l>-4 fG->11 ~J W1.u,~1 c4J
~ ~ 1 ~ d,.jf 'l'1 ((as.)~1 ~ ¥1.J ~ » ~10~ FJt d,.jf..91.§.J .!~1
Howard Strauss U"'I~ .).;I~ L:,WI ~J..iS'.JI ~ I ~.J 0::' ~"'i ~w ~ ;;.J4--JI
a.b.->-1,1 J~1 ul_,_b;. ;;..)~ ~1 '-Pi '-4.A~I ta.) aJ4-U a~.!4) ;;.Jb! ~ ~.JJ
~ ,,
•~~I o-4 b..u:. ~ I.J.,.U ~ l:'J I
~..9..ul ¥~I~~~, LA~~tJI.J.L4 111_?..)~~~f3..9

4...&4J-t\~--.:tlta..)~~
.. ~ .. ~ .. ... '..)-'-' <.)A TINL~·
.. ..H J.A c4 ~w~~-~tl·
...L......41 .NDDC Director of Rural and Community Development a .!' q.:i~l..9
•01i..r- ': :q "".. G.L.4
..
'--U .. ;; -< 4
• ~ ~ c.:r- .. .
-
,,.. Ll..L&A ~,., L, :l'=. ·'I w..1 .. ,,Lubl ~WJ1 u· lS'
.:J"" • ""-":&' .) • ~ ruJ ... . ..
. r ..
~~
I,..
c.:r- ~
... c.!lLl.A · j I,.. l,
u c.:r- ~ .. J ...ul L
· a..J .. l ~ I ~ t>Lbl ru.. u--J
· <"tJ
~
~ ~ ~ ~>LIi uLliW.11 ~ ~..>"J~ ~ , l.:U . ~l.ti~l 1.!.L.ti ~ ;;.)~I

.aJ,4-~l..9 ~_;-11 ~~1 tJ..)a.!w ~ ""'=~ ;;.Jb!
- l ~ I ~ u '..)-J
.. ..9..ul L
a..J -<'~ ...u...1.>,. · ·· 1- • •
. . . ~ ~ . > - ' '-T
.. :.i. "~i a~isi a.JL-u')'-:T..9 . "
~~..LJ.1 1-:~t'l'La,.q-~I
• {''..r- • .. . ..9 ~.. ~ - ' I.. ~ ·~ -.:qbJ..)~~- .. ~ ···'-·L~ ·
t. )L"'i ~ Li:i ~ ~ .. a..u\5:.A! ...s J.A ~
q - •• -~ ..
• c.J~ ~:j ol-: ~ 'I .. G...i.A ;; .)LA L.J~
'..r'"' "" .. '.) • • •
. Lll:'Jla..6..-f\.
.. '--fl~
-.r ~ 4.Y-1'-' ')J ~ ~.)
. L"".<'~<..-c..lb .. G.J.l~..1.A)~·
. J "" ..
:l': .• q
.. . ~ ""-":&'
Sam Edem ~-':1 r,L.u ~ I ~.J y ~ I r' r · · o r,k ~Y- ~ 0-A rA ~J
~.. ~ ; ·· 1-
.. ;'.) b! ~ . ~• a..J
c· 4 ~Li:i~L,
.. .. J ...ulLl~I~
.. ~ ..):j
~J.A ~ {' r .. 0 r,k 4Y- 't ~...)~ NDDC a.!' ~~ll..9 ~_;JI~ ~ I tJ..)
•j;..a.J...J ~ 'l'J,! u .JF.) LA u .JJ-!
i:,lS' LA~ w...\.iJ ~ Wesley Cragg ~lfi ~.,1 r~I ~WJI ~t;,i ub..9 ...l.41..9
~~ Jy-...) ;;~tJ ~ J ~ I tlb:uul ~..9 ,l:)~ ~ j.4-C ~.J-'1 cl.4J_,.b ~
TIN L,~• .. ..9 ...ul Ll~I
a..J .. ~ <.)A
· cd~·~ ~I'..r
- t L,~ · ·-~
.:t ~ )iA
· -·'I .'-
·:. < ·
.~Ll:i.JI
- ~.I .J.:r--""'"'
•. :-~t
~..9..ul ~~I a qloio <J--A ~..9 ~..9 ~Y- ~ <J--A , t ~ J

~ l ~ ' l ' I ukLl..i.oll ~~, ;;.J..)Lt-o a qt;,;q.JJ ~ d :?:•O,? w~
Cragg ~lfi .J.,:-S..ul ~I~ Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative
~~ ~J .a.!aqi::=,ilJ ~ _ , J I ~ ~ I bl.l a.!4;; a~.!"' ~~i r_ .!4"!"~
~J H. Assisi Asobie ~J--'-"i Y! CCI.! crrl •...& .)jlS'...UIJ ~lfi .)jlS'...ul r.i! ~
:a..Jbll
.. .~:q L~
~6..~ • a..J
.. J ...ul ~L:Ll.JI
.. ~ ~.) ~
.~1~'}11~k~¥~1o.J.)4-o~~0-4~luljlll~1-"°~~
ulJ.,al J~ ~ y ~ •~.l~ i.JJ.l ~ ¥ ~ ~ t Jlkj ~ ~:, c:,S:JJ
~ 0JI.Li:i as'I~~ a.o~IJJ~~I ~~J 4:-4~1~ ~W:ul.l ~_,b
.u1~~11 -li.i.o
'J-"""' ~ '(''Ll~l.!lllA
- 1.)-'-' - 'J .l.!.l~ -=--=---'l...A u-""'J
- :. ~.J.A ~ L.-: ~ ~t-'-~'
t ~ I ~I.J-Au-4 o.)~ d.b.>4 ~ 4A~.>J..J~ ~l_jj J~ ~ ~ LoS
~ J~tll ~ u.pj j~l 0-4 ~ l.Aj ~ljlll J~ ~ l g '5.J.A ~
~kl.b.a.JI ~ "\S'~I 4.A~ J-o~ .>J.J-4i ~ ul~ J~ ~ ~ . J .~_;ti
.ulj.111 J~ t~ ~WI 4:!~I 0~ ~_,b:&11
~ ~JJ.-...u.11 [l..»-1 Jl .)L.u..ill ~ JA ulj..ill ~'-"° &o ~J.411 u---:t

~ 0~ rWI tl.b.a.JI ~~I"~ ""1 ~~ ~ J .~\.,;,JI Ji rWI t~'
-: .-:_-., ~ a.oWI a.JUI.)!) 1-'I
~ r - · t · - b.JI a.J
.,.,.. u (.):AA
! ·-·'1>J U~L
- >J.,...- - •~- 4.41~
-'-·
• .)~I 0-4 ~_J ~ l g j M.a~ a.o411 a.ow, ~I.J.A~I
:~~~~l~I~~
.4:!.)b:i1,'}/I ~I~~ «;JI ~k~I ~ ~t;.. ;~tg ul_µJI ~I~
~~,
• ~l j ~ ..u- ~ LA~ 1~
t:._-: ~--- 1-Lg
[J i.'-:?"""
-" 4.J.l~'}/14........L.4.ull
- - · · ('-:
c.J_,_-.,J
~lb.J.la.!4ii~~~J . t + , i ~ ~ ~ l ~ ~ l ~ I
~ ~ I J a.......,,a~t 1.!.LJ:, ~ Niger Delta Development Commission
~~I~ ~ I ~_,k:JI t~IJ ~ I ~\S'~J .)_,u-11 y~lJ ~ I
~ I bl.)~ ~1_µ11 J~~ ofo ~~ W ~J .4:-4~1 ~
0-4 ~bl.I ~~lJ J ~ ~I ~~J 4-Al,&ll ~_,b:i.JI ~kl.b.a.JI &o ~ ~
4.J~ f-1- 6.. ~ t 4..AJJ.A. -, - .t:..~. W
- '-:?"""~ .)-AU-"° r-=--=- ~
· UI WI '-r· J . '-?'°~
r _(' _ti t Lb.a.JI
. __ ('_., ~~~I.T"J,J
u~u •-.l'A..°Z\.:"t-1.!lllA·\S' "'.!t\4.Jt.·.. ~ .u1:~t1
cJ .)-AU_,.,. -"'(j-l~J ~ ~
·l....!uAo·('"'
- "J-"-~~
·
.~§.JlA ~.J~ ~J.A ~ ~ UJJ ~ ~ t ~ ~l!i db.>41.!.JUA
~ 4 ulj.111 J~ ofo ~y:. ~ ~l!Lll ~1 ~.JJ 0-4 ~J.411 ~
U.JJ ~.J.A 0 ~ •JJ~l .)4ijll ~ ~_,JI 0\S' ~J . ~ I b.J.l ~ ~~~
- ~!J-'-"
a.1:i.A~I ~l.i...oiJ ~- ~ - J .ul·-~~'I ~-li.i.o '-- ~
- v-- - :. JA <>--'
- - C.J----'-U '-·'I
~ ' 5 J ~ ~l.i...o ~~ ~ ~ .ulj.111 ~ I - " ° ~ ~ ~ I ~l.,JI
~ t ~ l .).P.-JJ6.~J . ~ I b.J.)~4:!.)~'}/l~ll'_:J...;~~o~I
~
-
~l -
l i lJ,A c:--
•. t..tL·
.~ ·- I~'J .;.('.:.11 ··'--:'~''.)l.;.·()A ~
~ _),J_,-.. "-&'
-:fl~I
• • - '?"" - -
· t ~ ' &o a:J\!Lll ab.~ JZri ~~ .~, b.J.l
rWI U"":P.;-11 ~ ~ 1 bb a.1Q;; a~.1"' o.Jl.ll ~ f-""4 ~4-- ~.:u1 oJ.) ~J
L~ -· 'LlJ
JJI LlLi..a!JI
-
~ P:~ TimiAlaibe
~
A .. tt
'.r-:'~-- ~ I a_,lj~l.,
.... ~ ~r: .• tt
)~1 ~ JkJ jA\S'JI ~ j f.igJ ~.JJ4,A ~ -TI I~ ~~I ~ J TIN

c-r~
• ·- .~ti \:JJ -~ ~
- cllI.)--'-"..
:.1 ~b..o
• ~t ... L
~ · a.J
_j
JJI Ll~I
-
~
~ I ~.:UIJ Edem 0-A~l ~ I o.Jb?JI ~ '51, ciL.u.J ~ .;fi .igJ - t ~ I

.Ottawa IJl:iJi ~.J.A ~ <:?"4WI ~ 0:0~ ~ I~ I~ I~~~ cGi
,,
u4~1 u..L-.aL ~ .ul~I &.o J..W o~ J~Jj-&d..J~ ~c.!:J..b LAJ
0-A ~~ Umaru Yar' Adua IJJi I.J~ .i.>LAJl ~~I ~.;JI J_,b.. ~ ,-,,;.,:w:..~
.Chief Olusegun Obsanjo ~4Ji 0~_,JJl U"":PYI
c.:,,11 a..sJ1~1 ~~?JI c.:.i)L.u1>1,1 U.)Llil ,rr · · Ark.~JJ~..,:,~~~J

i.)1~1 _;.s-l ~~~~I ~_,JI ~ i ~ ·t~I ~ o~I ~ oJk.1
~~I o.)J4,A o ~ ui~J~I b.b a.!Q;; ~ ~~ ~ J..,~ clll& ulS'J
. Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) ~ I ~~I c.:.ik. Ll..&AU
c.:,:tllJ u.Jfi)..& U.J~ ~.J.A ~ ..,a-i "' c.:,:tll ~ I ~.JY ~ ab ~J ~ .igJ
- - -
~ ~lfatl oJk.1 ~J t ~ ' 0-A ~l:tll ab..Jll 0-A ~l:tll ~~1 ~~ 0~1 ~~
- ,,
. Niger Delta Development Commission (NDDC) ~ I b.b a.! Q;; a~.!,,.
J)l;..J .o.J-tfi~~~.).JA~lc.:.ii~r"··v rk....H~iJ~~~~J

l.,~ _ j JJI ~~I~
• Ll - lj· -~.~ti \:JJ ~
- a.ta.4H.:.~
- -..;- .._._,_,..,.°Z\ a..u.o·
..-~11 o-..r.:-- - '.) o-..;-
..~i:\
~..r-ll o.:ui ~ uS1J .u.Jfi.JLA u.)~ ~~y YAJ rt 0::t ~ I ~.)J .J.AC.
~lb1a.ul r ..al -I~
- t!.·. L~· a.J -
-'-' JJI ~Li.......!JI
- ~ as' ~
'.) · t:;. __j\ o··.<'ti
..>:? Ii'""" ~
~i 0-A ~Lal ~_,JI~ J.?JJI o~l:i ~ J ~ I Cragg ~lfi .J~JJI
.~I ~.JJ ~ as').!J.I
rto
r•-\A ~1~1 tJ.l d.!4ji a~.!"' t-4 ~ 4 ~ I L...:u.;J a.JJ~ O.l~l ~ l.:U
r ~ ~ I ~4:J.;J~y!utl ~o_;J.l o.J........&~J ·r"· •\ f"~J:~~~
:~ ~l..1.Ai a:i)\:; l,fl ulS'J . lfj ,bb:u J.Jb ~ U.;_,ll u..1.4CJ
~~J olj.iJI HIJA -l.?.~ a..a.o~ ~bll y~t., '->"'Ull 4.A~ ~JJ _,
. .l~I ~ts:l
.~ti tJ.l ~ ~ <)U .~ ... q LS'~ -'r
.. l:°u.A
<.9 .. ~ -~ -= . . L-:
.. ~-.~
d,...._L4.0 • ~ . -
.... u
-J~.). -
~ ~ J i g ~~ Ji t ~ r.~ .l~4 a..a.ol.;JI ~~ olj.iJI
. t""" IJ J \.bj
~ LG...U ~l.ull ~~ ~ ~lj.iJI J~ ~ ~J J ~ J J.,.lo .ll~1 -,
. ~ I tJ.l 4.!4i'
• ·--.1.""..:..-;.,,1•
!U4101r= ~ U A Cl.4,J
- - -:.ti_,_
'-:T'"' ···'I' f
~~~_r LAI
• d..& lj.iJ I Jl41. 4A ~ 4.AJ.4.4 -

.l.!.lJj ~ u.fiJ lsa.!:bi ~ 0:i ~t - olj.iJI Jl41. o~I uL..u.;WI -
. 01-:. ~,, -l:u..A -= .. '-"".'~Li.JI
'..r""'<..9-~ • a.a.,.'-
~I.,:
ti . et - 01-:.'..r""'<.9
~,, -l:u..A
.. ~'- - . wa..0
.. -
· - .~fl tJ.l
•~ ~ ~
....
.l~<..,-"-
.. I,.. OI-:. ~ti .. l:°u.A
'..r""'<.9 .. ~
"! • .L-: -
.olj.iJI J~ u ~ -
.uW\..;:.ll ~ u4~1 -
, .~oo:tl d..JL!
...,=---J . 'JJ· ti uL...l.:>J
- J L~
- -
tJ.l ~ ~ "ts'.;~"\• YJ~ lA as'.;~ l.!.lJjJ, -I~ . ; ~ I ulS' ..L.--41

.l~ ~L.!ll..i.AulS' ~ -~..u.1~1 u~Jig~.;-_&~1.l..u.ll r-4,.J . ~ I
.~lj~I tJ.la.!4ii~~J-& J.,~J ~14..A_µI ~<J§.;Ll.J.I ~J-&
~ c4 ~Ll:il ~1 J~.,.tl ~ i ~J ~l..1.Ai ~ ~ I L...:u.;J ~ ...l4l

4..&..4-u.ll
.. ~...) Ll.J. :c~
~
· ·'I ul~W.I.?""~ ol-:. ~,, ~JA{'"
'..r""' - :.1 1~1 d..J.
~~
--:.t . - -~•1 tJ.l ~
..
...u......uJI
.. · - .~ti tJ.l ~
~ .. ~ '- -'I L...:u~Jr ~I.-"
.. ~.; ~...l.:>J u-- ~J .d..J.l~'il
.. i:.
olj.iJI ~~ ~ .HfaU ~WI~ OJ& ~~h, Timi Alaibe ~ i ~

~'='-~~.Jl ~ I t-4~.;~ r.'-41 l.!11..i.AulS' ~J . ~ I tJ.l a.!4;; ~~
~i ~ l.!.lJjJ ~ I ~JJ r.~1 ~ cLa.A r.LA.l ~ '1.J~ ~ ~J~I ~l~'il
·~~-~~'S,,fl.~Vlr.:,,,,:;;-_v,_,~"",:--::,,;~1,,'F.i.~J.t~.'-'A.ii,..J!lll'Jl'ftK'4-~K--.:"-~-,.<-..o._'...._____,._.;r,;.~~~a- • . f l l . : . , r . " - - . , l - 1 i . i ~ - ~ C . " - - - ~ ; w . D C
lf,l~ 41..La.9 ~ ~~, Lo.91!1...1,.:,,,j ,~u :u4la..al ~ ~Lw..i&llJ ~~, rt,

I,.. .. tf~l-~'-',4..194
..~
-.:tfti.J.l~~.)~ 1,..4-Af~:t\ -:., o: •. L~
~~ - I..T"".J J - - '..:,--~ ~ ~_j-4~
-~lj
~ J~ . ~. , ~'J l.J~. ~~,
,_ ~}lb':J ~
-
~ .
(>A
~
Jt-4~ ~ ,
. ~ ~ a..ol,8-11 ,b.!h=-i:JI
4-Alj..tll J~ r'~ ~ I.SJ~ ~w. ~~ .)~ J..u.ll ~JJ ~..19

~ ~..UJ ~.;~I 0,A ..1>.IJ JS' J.l~ ..1..4l . ~ I Gl.l a.!Q..u ~ ~l.i9l..:i ~
~ I Gl.l a.!4 ;; ~ ~ w:u-1b?/I 0-A .)~ ,.!.LJ:l ~ ~ f ' ~ ~ ~L.ui
• \.A.)~I Jl.,Jo ~.;.,JI ~ lfi.;Ll. ~.:UIJ
,~J l.J~. ~Ll.....,;;.JI~.
- 0 - 4. ~ ~J ~ ' ' -~ - ' I ~'JJ ~'A"'."..IJ6..
~ J
GJ.)a.!Q;;~JobJ~ i~ L.u~ulS' ..19J .~~~i ~1c4~w
-:.1_ j -'! 4
~ .. L"'.tL.J
~ • a..J ..ulLlLl.....,;;.JI~
~ _., - L-ltDl.JI
t-4<->-- __j,J"JL&>
- J.-.:ti
~
~bi~~» ul~ a.b;J ~ J ~ ~.,JI ti,bl .i9J . ~ I ~l..19W ~ ~lj..tll
.((a,!'11.!\,JI ~1.)~I ~~., ~l...l.A~I :NDDC~I Gl.) a,!QO ~~ ~lS'.;--!JI
• -,, t At i ·- .:tf Gl.) ~ -:1r:.At ~ , - 1 ~l...l.Ai a:&........u, u...1A'I ~ ..1..4l
~ j - J '+'J ~ - ~ - . - 1..)-1---'-U - ~ J
D~\..;:Jt ~ ~.:u,
':T'""L.u~I Juli ulS'J .~b ~4 («a.i~w,., ¥LL!J1., 4-Alj..tll
-\:u.l.
"' - ~
b.U a..J ..ul LlLl.....,;;.JI ~ as'I :. . ..<~)) ..
-J
- t-4 1..)--'-'J 0-l.J->-' .r- -'-8-' ~
&~.A,, ,~
"! ."!--:t
·r-~1 .)l.»-1 ~ o ~ as'l~I ui ~1 a..b;.JI ~ J ~.;Ll.i .Jl_, .«4-Alj..tll

Alex M. Sharta ti.;Lj, ·f' u,4i ~ I FJi ,~Wll ~ ~)LIi ~ ~J
L.Jl:i.11
. ~w ~J~
. -'·\ ,--,1 ~'JJ~ -- . A LJ
· D'.)-J~~ ~ • a..J
_., ..111 ~La1W1
- ~~ - ·
: a..JGJI
- ~I.).
la.JI ~ · - ·:ti ti.l.) ~
- ~
- t-4
~ ~~ ~ Jjla:tll lAjLs ; ; ~ a b ~ ~ I L!..;J ~I~
.~~w.4 ~\.,;.JI '-&-a~. h.1 :., iiJ ~ I l:J.3 a.! 11;; 4 ~ ulj.i.JI J ~
~ IAJ1fi::i J.o\.:j_j wi ~ ol_)..j ;;..)-1~ ~ ' l:J.l a.! 11;; ~ I.J.A ~ ~~
. ~ ~b:it ~ ~ 15~l 4:Afi>. ~~
~.. tj ~- ..L.&..-uJI
- J l.J~ · a..J_., ..ul LlLl.....,;;.JI
- ~ LJ.::I&->-
· - ':ii J~I ~ . J"
LlLl.....,;;.JI ~ 4-AI ~ :t\ -li&A · .~ · '6..&i ,,.. ~ .< · -:11 .. Timi Alaibe
- ti
~"' - f'J44A~~,- ~ ~ J - W ~
,~L.a.a..::,l_,J.1.)1~10-A 1~..l.:' a.b.....r4JS' ~ ..19t..:tll ~~ ~ I ~l:9..,-11 J-AJ ,4_,..ul
.~~I ~Wl..>-J..J-4i .)1~1 ~ .J.41JI ~ J ~ I .;~I_, ~l~l.k.a.JI ~ ~W.IJ
~ ~ll..,-11 ~ JJ~I ~.."4i~illl~ui ~1.>:..l4iJ9i ~., ~.,io.;Ll.?/1 ~ ..1..4l
,, ti ~
'l.:U . Loti ':il~I ~ j.J~I u~ ulJ '<.r§.:>.. ~ .)...u.Q.A 0-A ~J.tll .)~I
£. st; ~ ·t ,t:
r ~
.f ~~ g~.[f
[. 1.. E·11 f n~ ~ { ~ ~ t t t -~ H. i ~ ·1:.
;~ t .,:- . ,'i, ·Cj.. 1:, ,f'
-~ ¥,q~ t ~ t{ -~t ~·- .~
c;- I, i:. l, !::: &· C: [ C• t ~I ·~ I t' C• t)
f~ G:.. ~
i ~f ·t !, ~
~ ~'L ~ ~ .,:-'Cj.. 'L
-i, C·
·~!: t' ll> l 1
J" ~ ;' t' 11 t 't f! 1
t~ &- °l,~ • ,~
i;: -: e,! ri\ - ~
t: l 11' f. ·~t t:~ ~ L~ ~ ;•i ,I=l {h ~~ ~~ •n, '1!' i
[•
e»,
f°f1c, t ~ar
II - t t> ,r' I Er
CH·
I,
t l
.;°c..'"c:tE,t~}_:_.;-r~
- . r 'b -» ~ • C•
..£:.
~
~. 'f_;.
i:: ,ri f . . ~ ~ t~tr. r~~ rl1f~ffg~, I"~~
[, i i t· - , .t • .r:- &- l.o - , (p,
(• ~ ~ ili rt ~~. ~'& {- ~,. _[b' ,., t '& ~ 1 t ~ ~ ,f'£1 r:r.J.~ . ~. 1-1 'f t;t
,i,., .t' \. ~· ,P: P.'
t.. I - 'fu• b - E! t> ~ C· r;; ,L I, 't..
f ~T,, f t t fi _: r _: {,
'\.
l . · ~ ~. rtr. e: l 1 ~ ,e-:t. l ~ t
·~. ·t t ~ 'f:: ~ :~ "' ,t; .• t; 'lj..
t t t c·
~ f;' ~ f t 1 } fl ·f: ~· EI ,£:
f. ,t'
~ ~i , ,c E::; e-,· ~
,l 1 r ~ .~ ~ $' ~ ~ c."f. f 1· ~ ·[ t'
- t
£:.
0
t'° .f. ct :t. l: ,.~ '•t.f :F. 't ~·~ .~-. 'L g
£'
~ ·t." ~.. t;; ~
i ·,\
r .", ~f l·-,1.r .t· t: e-., c·- • -< •1:..P.' ,c~· t.-
~ .{1J 1• \ f. .h t _: ~ \- ~ i· ~ ~ Ii
e.! _: I, l.o l.o .~ •
i f~ ~ •t.
'?t h [ ~ ·r- i~ t
:t·t !E ~. Lr r € " C, ~ - ,I;. G. .[i f 'l r
11-·
~.- ~~ <t~ <tt 1 [ i ~ ~ l cll { 11-· ,, ·V -
2-' .~ ~ ~.
·V ,. ~
·~· ~ '.t, -i .~ •f: :-: \. g !~ fu1 <rE: EI lfi:-
·b . <t ~ ~· ,. t C· (1Q I,
(1Q • • •
. c, . o o ·v ·v • v- ;, i= .r .r:- .r . . . . ~ -:- p J:. ·r ~ &- • . .. r·,
1 .[.
I,\ ~ [
~'b ~e. ~~ "t,~ 'i. .J-<i.. t tE.. .v- }·,:- .r~ ·H F ~ ~ f
C·
b
~ ~ ~ I l, ~·
·t'· t !·r ,r:. \. tr r:r~ fi!, l;t. ~t 1-- t> h -
f
C
'l·
·~
E r:. e. \o
~ T T - -; \ - 1· · · E 't ." · ~ ~ c··~ e! [ J;\ II\ " " .,
". f t ~ .. .. .'. l=" ~ . -~ ..;;- ... ~ ~ \- I, I, ~
-~ ~ i ~[?- f t
~, "ti ~l. L~ t
~
16W.I - .
..-~-l4l u..-
t - ~1·1-1-"'t
~l:Uft ulb~t ~.,tt
~ l...o.u ~I~ JW~I 0:0.>-1 ~~l cl.i:!.J..o~~.,~j.o ~ '4.6._,.J.I

cl.i:!.J..o ~ ~ 1 ~ a._,!,.)., .~lj.i.JI J ~ r~
. Port Harcourt ~JfiJlA ~J~
u.J., ~ a5JLl.J.1 ~ JW~I ~ I W.) ~~~~~I (i) r 4.6._,.J.I

~.)~ ~ ~b.ll y~~ ~ Niger Delta Development Commissi
-~JfiJLA .o.J.l~ <.:1UI ~..ul <J:Abl on
Jl..a:&j~I ~ ~~I JW~I cl.i:!..1..o ~ ~1 ~ u.)., ~w ~ (y) Y 4.6._,.J.I

.a:J~l 4.6.~ -~Jfi.;LA ~.J~
t!4-'J -lA-11, ~I~ r~ JLl:il i.:llJ ~ ~ l....:WI o.Jb?/1 ~l--4l ([) r 4.6._,.J.I
-~~ab;.
-~'
-~~~~rJ J ~ ~ ~ ~-4,-LI .)~ J ~ I r 4.6._,.J.I
.~1_,.J.I YJ...>..i:iJ ~lj.i.JI
-~~~~rJ ~ ulj..lll J~ ~~I ~ I t 4.6._,.J.I

~ . ) ~ o-,A . ) ~ a.!;~ .,t 0:!~
- ~ ' tJ.) 4,:qii
J~~, uWa.1.oJ ~fi..=.Jl 0'::> ~,~, ~ olj.lll J .:11-"4.J.:S'~«.·: "'!J
~.i! wu~~, c.!.Lti0'::> U7Jl~J~4~ l,:,~~..ul c 4i 7 llJ
a:ib.A
y1b:u ",>L:.t ~ I ~l.).JJI a..JWI FY ~ j ~ j . J ~ I ~ls:A_J,,:.tl..U
~ d.AL.i> ul.;.:.:·i aJ..i>- ~~ ~ J ~ I aA? 0-4 ~ d.A~I ul~I
blJ ~~~I u ~ I oJ..wll ~ I ulS'~J d.Afi..=,JI ;;J\l l.!l_,L.u ..k~t
~,..illj~l~~l .Is .. ,.;·,~t blJ4.:4ii4~.:"'J~~lt~IJ~I
~Ll.o u• ~ j~
~- ·I!.·. ;iJ.d..d.ll . r ..
I , ; ~ c.:,--
I,.. ul · · ..:.~tt
~ c.:,--
I,.. ol: :tt .. :.I I _:._ 4 f ~
'J-'-' ~ -"4 ~ J r .
_;s't l.s,.iA 0 J ~ I u.o~~I ~ ~ J~I uL.u.)w ~ J ~ I 0-4 ~ I

~·~_._,, ~ ~ . - .:fl blJ ~ :l~ .• , ot: :,1 .. l:u.o;; Jl.....A
~ 'J-'-' c..9 .. '.) • ~f'.'
• .... ..l.a.l .-6...& • •
..
-
~ , 0 t _jA ~ , o~ 0-4 F,.,.i, ~ J .ctJ ,.)~' 0fi:i ~ J ~.,:Jt ,~ ~
..
\___J~(>-4
. ~owl.Au~ 0fi.: 0t ~ ~ I ~~,~~Li.JI
.htt://www.transparency.org ~-"4 ~ ;;~~ u l ~ ~b.A ul~Jll o~ (')
. Calgary, Canada I~ ~.;4,. ~\S' ~ U).>4A ~ 4:~ ~~ ~_.,_.!, Bre-X ~I->='(")

r~ ~ Busang, Indonesia ~J..i.jh> ~L.u~ ~ ~-"4 as'~I o~ u~I
4..a>.>Lll ul~lw-4 J~J)l;.~~as'~I ~ f t-°3.;l ..l.a.l ·r\'\'\,
~.,.i.1 ~ u¥ ~ J~'}lt w,~I ~ ..illjJ r' '\W r~ U.)t,:,t ~ ..ill.:u
~I a:-:.:,;., all o~ ~l.&.I.J . ¥ ~.:Ut w,~4 ul~..J..dJ l.!ll..A.A c:,\S' ~.:UI
. (Canadian Encyclopedia, 2009) ~.J..AS:.Jt ~-"'""yJJ
http://www. ~-"4 ~ otj.llt ~1-'"4:' a ;;t,;t I ul..A.,.Wt 0---4 ...u_).A ~.,:u ("')
a:it~t ~-"4 ~ d...l.:iS'J transparency.org/integrity_pact/index.html
w,.o ...L:,,JI ~ J J ~ I ~ls:A ulJJi ~~ wl~ CD-ROM ~..LA
The Corruption Fighter's Tool Kit, and the LWI u~l.&.1.1 c.;s J ~ I
. Handbook of Curbing Corruption in Public Procurement
u~l..~1 rtJ;.; ,.,I <«primitive accumulation ~l~I ~I»~~ (t)

~Lal
• ~_)J.l'i""""~j • • c~-:~tt
· ... -~ : --~,, rent-seeking J~'}ltj ~>lJ.ll.l. --.)~ I
.~l.:UI ;;\..i>4,tt ~i w,.o ..)L..wi.ll ..ill.:iS'J patronage ~fi>JI
Y"O•
..)6.:il y~ ,ljan Youth Council 0~i y~ ~ u ~ I .,l..A L)A (o)
~..) LA ~ I ,Bayesha State Youths Federation J.!«\!'.4 ~~J
ulA...G.JI jS.J-A ,Publish What You Pay (Nigeria) ~~ ~
,Centre for Voluntary and Community Services ~ I J ~~I
,TIN 4.H-7 .!;., a.+JJ...ul ~~I a,,t;,;,, ,Statoil ~ . . J ~ ~~
~ y • .! : b JI jLLllJ ~ I J4-o ~ ~.,_I.I .;4,S a.!. ,, ::,-
,Petroleum and Natural Gas Senior Staff Association of Nigeria (PENGASSAN)
~..)6.:i~I .J:..)l.;JI aS'~ ,Exam Ethics Project J)l;..~I ul.;~I t~
d.:lJ...ul ~ I ,Federal (FRCN) Radio Corporation of Nigeria ~
Jntemational Automotive Technicians Network (IATN) ul.;~I ~
;;_;..)4-o ,Center for Responsive Politics ~l:-JI ~~~I jS.J-A
J~ ~t:,J-:' ,Niger Delta for Development ~ ~ I tJ..)
4lb_,JI ~ I ,Women's Right to Education ~I~ ;;t.,r11
~~I ~ I ula.:o~ d.:lJJ.11 ~ I ,National Assembly
~WI aS'...r"" Jnternational Association of Forensic Nurses (IAFN)
,(MOSOP) Movement for the Survival of Ogoni People ~JlJ~I ~ ~
~...L...1.1 t ,, ; =r t I a .! ,, ; ; J---S..J----" , Shell J---1u a............S'~
~ I ~~I ~ I ,Centre for the Development of Civil Society
~ ~ I jWIJ ~ I J~ ..)6.:il ,British High Commission
,Nigeria Union of Petroleum and Natural Gas Workers (NUPENG)
y ~I ~?JI ;;...1 "'" « 11 f-4~1 [ ,,, !)>--.....
..)_;_µi ~ ,(UNPD) United Nations Program for Development

,(Oxfam) Oxford Committee for Famine Relief ~\..=r-ll ~~
~' ·,?JI~~' " JIJ 0' ·,?JI JJ " >- ...1 s • ,,
CCI SCI
,Institute of Human Rights and Humanitarian Law

~..)' ,o ; "~'J a .! ~ .! : JI wt.., • , , a .! ; ~~1 a < : ,~, JI
,African Network for Environment and Economic Justice
,Petroleum Resources Ministry of a .! b " 11 ..)_;\_.,.._J.I ;;_;ljJ
U>WI ul~ i.SJ--->-~I ~l..~IJ ..)~I uL.u.;~ a\;;'" ll ~ I
Jndependent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission (ICPC)
~ ~ ~ . - A f . ( l n , l • ~ , " ? " t ; · ~ • : , . ' - 1 - \ v - ; . . , ; , _ , . , . ~ , , > ~ : : , i . - . . , 4 S i ; · . . . - , . 1 ' ! " . n r . ~ ' . r - 1 : . ~ ~ ~ X ~ . > l ~ \ l ~ ~ - C : . ~ + ~ ' T , : t . ~ · ••..------.,:,.,l..~~~..:q-'-,!;4~.4~.'°""'~•..,.....
ro, ~~~~':?.:.Ltl l..oJQ~ faU :~\.J:LJ.I~ ~~lj4.4.J~I

1·. ,..,,;.;·' . :.. :.=,. -, -:==.=.:"::.1\·-:L·=~"\t&::~·. ,:·G:::-:-~,/F.:.,>\faf·,v==;:t==y' .,==~==Y='<<j=.-:-f·,>h&·#;:.,,.:.=. L=+:~0 .+===k+==:.Z·,:-:24w~0:r=, 1=...J<:-:fr:::-::::F"k1:·:·:· '.· .::fifrk>+ .. -0.·e!-~=-~·-1:§L== /:,}i'.-/.'·.yl.?}·x· . :·<=k•· :£JW¥Nx:+¥i§.--.:-.:gfl
~..1..0JI ~_,..111 ~ I a.n~., ,House of Representatives yl.,_;.JI ~

~l__S'.; ,Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA)
,~.
,Global Rights Partners for Justice aJl..wl ~t 0-4 ~WI J ~ I

;;µ ~ I ~Ll.H ,Norwegian Embassy ~J.>-,Lll ;;.;~I
l:!,W I ~ ..1..0J I ~ I ,Women's Environmental Program
l : ~ ~ I 0-4 , o.:a;...::J I ..1.8-L4 ,Canadian High Commission
~\.;..JI_, 4AWI J.,.a:,JI ¥1..)A ,Poverty Alleviation Institute of Nigeria
a..i.,..111 .>4A ,Business Day J~ ~I r~ ,Public and Private Rights Watch
,State House Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC)
a..ub·'I
- ..,.. ~ 4J: ) ~~I;;'.) b~I
.. ~LA~I ,4J·
~ ·-·~'I a..ub·'I
- ..,.. i.bi.11 ~1..)-'-"
:.
,National Petroleum Investment Management Services (NAPIMS)
~ I jWl ~ ~.>1u ,Media Right Agenda ~~ ?II J.,.a:,JI J_,~
uJol.,11 ~~b:il ,(NLNG) Nigeria Liquefied Natural Gas ~WI
,Ijan National Congress 0 ~i yl~ ~ ,Citizen Communications
L;,.;~~ ~ ,Africa Leadership Forum Community ~~~ ;;.l~I ($...ui.A
California Western School of Law (CWSL) Action For 0~U.U 4=,J..;-ill
.ll:..:il ,~~ ~, ~.;Lla.ll ~t 0-4 ~ I ,Popular Participation (CAPP)
,NGO Coalition for Environment a~.::11 ~t 0-4 ~µ1 ~ ~~,
,Ministry of Commerce ;;.;~I ;;.;ljJ ,Ministry of Finance ~UI ;;.;ljJ
,Niger Delta for Professional Development ~ I ~ ~ I bl.l a~.:.,.
,TI-Norway ~_v-w.
... ~,L Ll~I
-
~ ,TI-Canada I ~ LlLLlJI ~
• -
. TI Secretariat ~~I ~ ~ti~
i~...,i.t• uU»..~
JJ...ut ~ of Nations Commonwealth «c........L...,_i.A~I» Jl .lL,..:i'i4 ~ (l)
Jl:J.I ~ ~ \+iAJ a_;,lh,..HI ~_,kl.;+4~1 .)Loi sc,'i ~G... ~\S' ~I
• LA~J ~ J ~lAJ ..14JIJ l~J 4Jl~t
~~.J;:Z:SA~~~~~~ c.t:"-'1..-'t".l'J'ri;..,...... ~~......_-..:r.v.A"#:'._ Y«.-X.c«.~V~..~-r-.c.·~.-....,s..~y«:":• _:.:.,,a;._~,·.,fr.•.•o3:'l,•·:!f...•~~
,-o,- ~Wi.:i ~ ~ c;~t Lo..9 ~~ t~U : u ~ t ~ ~L..u.4!!.9 4.4.J~t

L. S. (Al) Rosen um (Ji) •l.J" .J •~l~f
iZ9~t
JI.JJi ~~ ~ i c.:.iS'J c!JJ>- ljl ~~I y~I Jkll.o ~ i J>-i I ~
ul.AJ,J_;~IJulA.,.W.l[I.J.l?IJ:.ll~4ll~~ -~~l~~UIJW:L..u-:11
~ ~)11 ~ r..l.4i 1..1..iS' ul ·.·: 1111 o.l..1.LA.ll ul.tltll ~Ju.ti ~L.u.lJ..u ~~,
~ -~UI .JWL..u-:11 JIJJi ~~ L>.>'44 u~~ ~i ak.~J al.A~ a ~lqc
«~p4J.I ~ .l~-:14» 4:~I a~.!:ll ~..)~,~LU ~l:l.o ~l ul ,Jlill ~
~ •J ~l.i..o
• • • .<-: ~~~
~u..,.-, " .lWI
. Ji~• I LJ:J:;-, · ola:u..o ~
· ·1 • -:q 0A .. . L ~ ...u.1
~ o.l~ ~~I f-5W1 ~ ' J ~ 4 c.!L.Jj ~jLJJ • L--8,1 ~ -:I Ji Lk.~
ul·l.>:4-4 ""· 1 .~WI ."r.3W\
~ •
a.a.lb u- . c.:r'1
1... t.:,..:; • ·1.-:1t
1._-:J LJ:J
v::--i .,........ ~\.ti
'.r
uLil~I
~ a........u,1.J..ul ~ i u,.4 LLLU 4>-l:al 4:~I ulS'~I ~I...P." ~ ~ I ul ;;.! ;;,-.:lll
.(')a.!4.!t;,;;JI c!J~I ~ u~~ ~~ J.1c. ~..ul ~µ, ~ ' J.....-i CIC; L,jl
~\.j • I .·.f I,.. j I IJ..iS'.~_i:\ cl.L.u.ll · -~~ · ··t\ 4.Jb u ~ - .t~-: • - -t\ I,..
. ~ '+' c.:r- .)!.)-4 • ~ - - ~r~ c.:r-J
~~I~ <.i'1' Jts::e~IJ ~l.)-4ll u,.4 ~ I c.!J~J .yl+u,~I ~ .l...W l.!!JjJ

~µ)11 <JA~.l~l ...l.>JI ~~J 1..1..iS' ~ o ~ I a .!4.!t;,;;JI ~lb.~I u---4
JIJJi JJ----U' ~ .l~I ~l:&j ~ t .lyJ ~ . <'>deregulation w:ul~I .;-,~ .,t
.~ w:?~I ~ ~ u,.4 ~ b JAi~ ~14:~I ~UI J~-:11
~4:~I ulS'~I uw~ c4 l.,_\AW ~~I ~JJ.ll ~4ll u,.4 ~ ~J .ieJ

~ b lli...u.l LWI uLl~I IJA~I ~t 1.!!Jj~ . 18 , .. .;; o~I ~lb.~I
~..u:iuJ~J - ~ ~ uLl~I ..ill:i ~ ulS'~I <JA ~ ~)ti <JA ~j-11 ~
~4-J alo~ ~ I~ ,WL.!JI u-:l~-:11 o~l.;-1 ulJ-:IJJ.ll rll.J~ ~4ll
- .. -
. .) .. . . ":' ~""
~ ~ ul.:,..~I . rj - .. .. • i ~ L · < - · ,l.!JJ~ l.d . a..J.ull - ~l.kll
. -~ ~ .. ~
J:~ J-AJ 0-3~1 L~ <JA cGJ...u~ LA u~ ~UI JWL..u-:11 JIJJi ~~
- ~ 1 J-A ~ I ui ~ ~ 4:~I .l_?.-J
-------------------~~~
Y'OO ~~ ~ ~ 1.i~l lA.9 ~..L,.j faU : u ~ I '?9~
..,_,,,.,,,~~.... .
~'-431J 4.4.J~I
P,·. <t '!¥··~· .. ··>,··ti."} :?•.ii:'"/ ··i _v, . ."'·'( ... ,.·'" ,.. ·.. Ji,·.: .-..:~?ff./·.'.::.1,1 :-,:= ..:;:-A"~•i -r=·-~,;;--?i··.: ··. ·.g•.,:,~ ·....,.J.-.::,....... ,~·:ii' ····'.f:, .-.-; "t=::,~10=. :~·w·v/··vs'"'<" /~·il~Y:·•·:,.pxe,+.··r-·:=:: .j I' :t,·,.:,·-lkVi•; ,., &'·$1
~ ~1.JJIJ c.:,..a~I tl..bJ 4UI ..>J_;~I ~ WLlJI 4:lUI J::,JI .l>'"" ~

~ aJJb ~ ~~ l.!ll.i.A JJ.iJ ..l9J · t ~ ~ ~ ~..la:i ~_.,~I~' I~
.)~~I Jl_;Jl JJ-'-" ¥ _.,~I ~.JJI rWI ~J 'r' °' rC\ r'-':. .J.i.A ~ , ~ ~ L A
~ cliJ4ll ~ J.4JJ - ~ ~l ~ _.,~ ~ ~Li_,JI ~ ~ ~l ~1,~UI
i~~ ~ ~~ ulS'J "-9_;b.llS' ~~I alS'~I ~ ~ ~ ~.l_;J o_;~ JI.>.>!
-~~ al_,i..&.u ~ "-9tkll ~~ ~ t9l_,ll ~ .;-&lo LA~ c.:,. a. .; q~i , ,JI ~L.o. ~
:'?"tbJI ~. . .... a.,~1
.. ~Li ti . l ~)U.L-~ ~.
~ ._,.. u
A
-~_,ll '->~I ~ 4UI Jl_;J)U ~ Ji ~ J ~~ r~ .l_?.J r~ _,

u.ll .i9J .a,jb?JIJ ~I~ oJ.A4-J a!A~ alA_,.\.LA ~~ ~ ".ill.JJ a~
. -LA~ ~lj t~I ~ ~WI w,11 ~ I J ~liJIJ ~bl.I al~~?JI
~
ul w,11 IJ.;~l LA~ I~~ rWI ~W:..l~I ~ ~ ~ .l~ L..k;.j ...L...lJ

~J .<'"">white-collar crime LJ::!-4_µ1 ~.,.ti ~I~~~ 4~ .l~I
ujj~ ·.·: ,11ll l.4JJ '~~~ ~_,JI ui 4UI Jl_;J)U 0¥-J..UI u_,l~I ~
4:l~~I ~.>J~ a\ bbttJ 4=.)Abll ~\bb:to ~ ~ alJ-i--.uJ I~
~ ~ t_>4?11 ~ f1 <i41I al-.u)to.~I ~~I l.!ll.i.AJ (.:.>Ponzi frauds
~_., J.41 ·(S,;,,:, .;\-&~1 ~ ~_.,~~I j.J~I ~~J.A ~_., r~ •.,: "'!
.~ I .J-'-">'J ~\j'ii
• I~ c.:,--
t- d.JUI
.. r ~.~ __j\ t.b>o ~
.... J ..ul ~~I -- -r
("4J.. Li~_., ~ I
.. · '--9~
~
~.l~ w ~ l Jl.o.....j, ~ ,bbtt ~ ~.JS' ~_;-o'il c_.,k UY~ ~l

;;~I al:?~_,ll ~ a~.;-*11J 4:lUI JI.JJ\11 ~ ~ ~ ~~J ~1
a~L:iJ.I ~ l al.lo:' J.41 .Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
~Ji ~_;-o\11 al.hl.uJI '--9~4 ~~I ~UI _;~~I Jl_;Ji J ~ ~ ~
Jl_;J\11 ~ a ~ r~ .i9J .<J:I~I ~ b J ~~I~ a)IS: ,~,o\t
ui ~.;JI c_.,k d...l~Jw ~ .i9J ,~~I al~l~?JI ~~ ~~I ~UI
-
.<J:I~I ~ b ~~~;;~I al:?~_,ll
~j:il~~~whJ.l~Ul_.,~~IJl.;Jl~J~~la~~~i-r
I.At . J ~ I JUI~ t4-~~ '--9..1.83 <i411 civil court ~...LI.I p6:..JJ
_.,~~I Jl.;Ji ~ J~~I a~~ ~ I class action ~~I '->Jw:.J.ll
0-4J:rg J~ J.P.-J0-4~->11 c.:,k c..,lJ~I ~ ~ ~ J l j J ~ IJ.iS' ~~UI
~~~1 ~..1.4.Ll ~6.. ~~ oJL.c , ~ I ~ •~WI ~~1 ~Ww1
~J .o~~ ul_,.i-uJ .;l~)U ~ ~IJ ,a_;,..u.l ~~I lSJlc..ul ~..u
0 J ~ I o_;L-;. ~ L4.A ~~ ~i ~~ "}] a_;,..u.l ~~I lSJlc..ul y~
-~UI _;~"}]I Jl_;Jl ~~ ojy- ~ ~~ ~ ~Lo.:,J
~ ~ o~I u~~_,JI ~ SEC uL.o_;J-tllJ ~UI Jl_;J~I ~ r ~ ui -t
. IJ.iS' ~ ~..u.1 u~~ 4.&:i~ ul~tr?-1 r ~ ~~~~I u~L:..JI
o.J-tfi ~ ~u1 _;~"}]I JbJi ~~ lS..U ui ~ J~ rLA ~jA 1.:u.J
~UI _;~"}]I Jl_;Ji ~ ~l_;Jjl ~J~ ~ . IJ.iS' ~ ~lbb;.,, ~
• :L .. Llu.J.I a..Jl.u::..
'""'O':' .. .. 'J-'-' (.:rt! ~
"}]I f-&J-t hh~o J 1.<-: · Li.JI ~· ~
· ~I
F-LillJ ~IJ-0-ll ~~ rt:9 ,o~I ~Ll.&411 JJ..ul ~ t ~ ~J.:>- '-41.-9~ -o
J.4-Li u ~ I~~ u 4 ~ 1 ~IJAJ ~UI t.>4?JIJ ~ W 4 a ;t.;t I
~
..:o:<~--~4.JI
~ • ~ '-:
.... t,l.:U .a.JUI
· ..... t~~ c..,-u--::,' .. f.lj:,1.-:tt
,,..., ~ IU-0 ~~
JJlc c.:,k t4i ~ I ulAl~~I 0-4 ~..rbJI "~ ~ i ~J ,~l~I 0--4
~?JIJ ulS'~I J~I c)C. ~ I c.ill~ a.Ji.al ~ J .u4~1 ~IJ-4
c..9_;WI ~ ~UI u~~I .,t (.!.>self-dealings a.! ,o;.~I ~UI u~~I c)C.
u~?14 ulS' ,Jlill ~ c.:,k •k>related party transactions ~ ~LuJI
0J->:..1.4ll r ~ l c.·: '".' o_;b?}l 0-4 o~I u ~ ~ l 0-4 ..uj.1.1 c.:,k J ~ I
<i'1' ~t;JI ~lS'~ ~ <dpublic company 4.AWI ulS'~ ~~I
- ~ ~ I ulS'.;-!JI ~ ~J>&A ~ ~ u~W ~WI~ ~..u
~JJ 1.4..Jg~I
.. , )lJa...... " ll~I
.. u ..~~
• .:.-lt 4.Lll:cll
. '= .-:-~ti
~ . ' j 'ti u ~
J d..Jl:9. ..
y """A JI ·-1A-"\
,._.u- U.J
~ ~1 1-"'°.ia ~.:UI ~WI u4~1 ~IJ-4 0-4 J-tfi J~ ~jJ ~UI
u~Wl~~~~,u~.iaJ .o~IJ4-4Wl~WlulS'~o-4~J
J-*9 ~ J ~WI ~)l.oj.ll ~ l$..U.I a.L_,hll ul~ "}]_,JI~ oJ~ ~~I
.~WI a.!,o.;..~I y_;~I J.P.-_,J I~ ~~I ~WI -
u~ ~~_,JI Ji ca.bWI lS~J c.;J\..:..J~I
.. lS~I ~ u~)l;JI i.SJj:i ~ -v
- ..
r~~ c..,ll ~UI J~~I Jl.;Ji ~l..AJ ~~~~I u ~ I ~l-..o
~~4 ~ I a.!1.!;.~.;tl ul~l~?JIJ ~~~I u~ ~ ~J: ~ ~ .J-tfi
J~ c.:,k ~tu c..,ll ~J~ L4.A ~6:A 1.-9..\+.J ~ ~ I Ji ~~I ~UI
u~ ~ ~ ~..u _;g_;a:; "}] ~ ~ 1 0 t _j,AJJ-tfi ~ ~~J ·t--"""'J
,a• nc ~-~~"U..~ ~ !al
rov "6l~ 4.La.i ~ ':f~I Lo..9 l!I~ fall : u ~ I ~ J~IJ 44.J~I

11;-~~--··~e-W&1 1w+J=PF,J,,t~~wY''·#&&··f1f&·~j@r3W~@fb:4g,...4tf&dili§@ef@f&ktfus'ill·+&NixP&·!@@~ ·h=-~1w*;.~,A. ·-N)_l/@t?i·~~i&@z: -j&t-4%iJ101Y41@·%·["·d+:W..Brfil1&@!®4&k·WMt~@,!~J
1
. deregulation LJ:ll~I ..>-J~ ~ Ul.ul.~ u~4~1 ~IJ-4 ,.;o~ ;;_;I~ -

. '~~
.. .< '. ~ , .J.>LJ- l.:U - --
i.;t.>9 r' \C\V r~ Supreme Court of Canada ~~Il:!,WI a q<:>J.I a_;.J.,..ol -A
~1-~t1
~:r-6 ~
· ~ · · · -~~---t\ .,L:..:;
- (>J_,_........... •
aL~I
•
I aLAl-:.~tL
~~
-=•-~. Ll..A..1.A
'..J-"". ~
-
~J~.l i:9.; LA~ 0J; q~i •.,ti t_.!bi ·re.: "'i · ~ I ~ .a4l ... ,-.1J ~lf.tll
a4~1 ~IJ-4 J-1..Jl.a:i ~ ~l_,J. a4~1 ~IJ-4 ~ ~ l . j ~~
al~a~~ ~ I ~UI ~l~I ~~~LA aLA_,h.o ~ ~ I
J-=-1§~ al.;b} a.JW ~..ul ;;~ .;l:ii .l~J 0-4 ~.;JI~ .4.4WI a"'iJl~I
Ji 1..1.iS' ~ OJ.>L4 .>-t):. a.JWI .,~ 0i "'11 ,(\ \\V) Hercules Managements
al~~.l"'il a l ~ ~ t1-4 c..:,31~~ a.Jb.. a.ll ..1.-.lJ ._;-;.i 0~ ~i ~
r'°'°'v r~ .J.lA ,l.:U .~LAaW~f"&A~"'i a4~1 ~IJ-4 ~~_;-;.~I
-
~1~4 Ul.ul.l ~~I a l ~ ~ ? J I ~ ~ c.!lLlA 0§.:-0i ~ I..L...d.~
l.!1.ti a~i ,igJ .~UI .;~'ii Jl.;Jl ~ J~"'il al~~.)4 Ji ~ I ~UI
- -- *
a~ .~u, . ; ~ ' i i Jl.;Jl ;;J4,.:i ~ ~.)t;.. '-'-4i ;;~_,11 a;,.,:,w, uw,
.l~J 0-4 ~.;JI~ ~ I t:-~.l"'il ~J~.l 0-4 ...1:J.AJI ~...L....a:i .Jo.!:~;~ ,~.:U
.a~~ ~UI (j"'>U?/1 ~ ~_;,:; &'-4>.
a.JWI .,lA ~ . l:!,WI ~ I Jl.>9 0-4 ~I~~~~ Jb.. c.!lLlA -\
prospectus yl:uS"'il ;;~ 0-4 It:-~ ~ J -~ b ~IJ-4 ~ ~LA ~I~ -
.J.a.l .d..4~ a5~ ~ Lo»=9 Jj ;;...l.-:~ ~ j 0,J_; q~j ,cell~ ,.J,o~ <?11
a_;,lb~I ~_,Jfid..&bl.a.A~ Appeal Court1...S~"'il ~ . - , •«<>J
y~I ;;~ ~ 4UI ~ 0i ~ ~~ i.;~ British Columbia ~,~i
~~a.Jb..~ -~~"'il~l.;l_,.all~rJ;.i ,u10t~ ~ir~-"!~
i~ ~4~, ~'J-4 ~ a;,_,.;w, ~J_µ, t:-Wl ~ (Kripps, 1997) ;;j.;4JI
- -
r~?JI» ~ ),jA~, 0-4 b..u:. ~ <?1' ~~ 'ii ~Lt.J.J ~~,J-4 r..L....t.l
J;gu-41...S~>lJt~"'il ~~I l:!,WI ~ I ~ . ; ..La.l .«J.lWIJrb.11
0i ~ llAJ ,(Deloitte~~.)) 4.4WI ~6:..cJJ Big Four J~ ~ a5~
~~ .;l_,.al ~ I .;l:i~I i~ Cc..ib ..La.l .«a.!,u).;JI a.JWI» u..~:·oi ~~
;;_;4,.:i 0-41.\o Y.J~ w -~~ .;li9 pi~ ~t:-4- <i'1' r::9Lal c.,k. Hercules
. <")«secondary marketn ~\:&JI J~I ~ ~~ 1..1.iS' ~ ~UI J~"'il., JIJJi
ulo~ . prospectus contracts yl:uS"'il a l ~ al.i!l.J .ul.b:, 0-4 [ ~ llAJ
·-
~~~~"?~I l..oJ o~ l~U :ul.cJo.al ~ Jl.i..ii..a.t~ "'4J~I
,,_.__ .._ __________
,-==- [
a..w,L;J1 .... :;~ti j~
'r• Lb
... lli..J.1 a.,.~
~ ..
... ti a.JUI fJ:,- ·~IL '1 ~t
~,.~,1 ~ .
·oJ..J 4~i«u4U ~J\S' ~\:i.j alo.,.tUI ~UI ~l~I ~ 0 l a.J.,.,_JI 0-4 ,I.JJ -~
~IJA~~~Wl~..9l.....c...ul~~l~~uJ;4~i 11,llt.!L; «u.:'l'~..9
~ I \+ols) ~ ~l..,.ll ~ 'l'jA Jsl..9 <:?11 ~UI t14ll .lb>'--"''l' c.:.a4~1
u~ ~ I J~ as..>-1'-4 ~..110-4 ~ , ljj • l-.+w_j.j ~ lfiJL.,j, ~J ..9l
J~l..9 . ) ~ l:~ -~~'l'jA 0~ ..is..9,~Jlkl~Herculesj#~ -
~UI c.:.als~?ll L>--4~ .l..L&.1 u~~I uJ; 4~; ,,JI u=o~ ..L....4l .c.:.a\S'~I
-oJ~l..9 ...\>.l_,JI ~ I 0-4 Jlil ~ I J ~ ~LUI
~UI J~'l'I Jl.;..9l ~ ~6::JI c.:.a\ LL;.,,~ I..L&S' ~ ~L....:'JI ~ ..L...4J -\ •
-
~-
· I..L&S' ~
(>A .. •
~
•
•U---- -
t ~\11
u,-"-
- ..
t ... Lale. A• o..u. j • .:.~,1 ~~, I.~·
,_,-- • VF (.)--A
~~ JJ~ (~..u:Jl..9 JLi.Jl..9 ..bi.tll a..w,L;.) a.!'.!:LJI J.;l.,.Jl -l.;..L....&.o.A l.,jfi
..u.J:! &4A ~~~II.a~ o§JL.!JI ~i..9 .oJ.,.bll c.:.a\S'~I c.:.alkLj.j
JIJ..9}U ~fijl.9 J.,.- j6. ~ -~.,:..11 ~I~ ~..11 o~~l ._s~ ~
- #
~ c.:.a\.! ;.! •• ,;JI ~1 c.:.a..i:&.ol 4.:!,llc. ~ Vancouver Stock Exchange ~UI

~ ~ J ~ ~ I c.:.a\S'~I 0-4 a1 •.,t.,, J)4jl ~~J .<J:I~ ll.oi lj)Lo
# -
~UA '->~~ ..9i ~ J - ~ o~I c.:.al#~I u ~ ~ I JA~ ~WI

J,.-,.i c:,.: ~UI J~'l'I Jl.;..9i J ~ J,.A.J..)lS' ~-1: 0-4 ui .JAJ ,~..11 ~l.):asl
~~~a ,;.!,.;,JI c.:.a'l'..96..ll L>--4 .)...U:, ~UA ulS' ~ J - ~ oA o ~ w
w,uLa.:,.JI rWI ~lc..l'l'I ~ J 0~ 1 ..l.4S ~ J .~!.,.a.JI J .!:L;t J.! «uiiJI
~w, 1.JJ -~Lal a.!,.!* ,:..;JI JIJA\'l..9 oJ4,JI 4:----l:!-JI O.)~l y~ Jl:t ~
# -
J:!JJ~ as~ .)~\S' o~I ~UI c.:.al.)~'l'I t--A ~~ I..L&S' ~ UJ.) 4~j •.,JI
4-4~..u.l J~~I c.:.alj L:!JUI JIJ..9\'I as~..9 Nortel Networks c.:.a'l'Lc.o:i)U
-~~~as~ ~J Asset-Backed Commercial Paper (ABCP)
~~ ,~l~I 0-4_# ~ oJ..J 4~i·uG,IJ a.J~I ~La.:,.JI y~ Jl:t ~ ,j~h,

ljf I.a ,~~I c.:.a\S'~I ~ ~IJAi efoJ ~ oJ..J 4~; ,.,11 Jl~I '.·: ,.,_, ~Jll
~WI c.:.a\S'~I J.4-Li -~WI~~ ~ J ~ I ~ ¥>31 ~j0-4 ~ I
o~ ~LA c.:.aL..u.....uj..o ~liA..9 ,jWl..9 ~l..9 <>.!..u:J\S' a.!·.::LJI .lJIJll ~ ~ -4,J~
# -
-1:..L&JI J~ o J ~ I y~ LA~ ~l.b:.....-ul ~w..9 ~ ~~ c.:.a\S'~..9
~l~..9 c.:.a\.:i.!",WJI' o•oiiA J ~ ~..1>- c.:.a6.~I o,41 c.:.al~t.tu.u'l'l..9 .c.:.al~I 0-4
•~UI c.:.aL..u.....ujll 0-4 J...u:. JL,jl LA~ c.:.a\.: i.:•, .,;JI
cf. I 1, c· fr: f!! rt if l' c, £f ~ ~ ·~ '\ 1
f l.. t t t· l~ t·
_f.~ f, r. f ~'. r- 7 C f:: f ~ i ~•. fr: r ~ g; ~
[. ~ '° r ~ '\.· [, cf e, C: ·~ '1:: ·~ ~ e. t~: f-'
t t~- 1..r t b~• gg: ~·•t t-·f~ t'l.·~.r-
r/l ~,.. • . -
-11 ,oc;. • I)
p~ -r
·~
. •E·. r 'fs' ,. t' ' ·~ ' ,. 6 r.'."
-l, \o Ii\ y-
.. (; -e:. ...r ~. ~ tV\ [• ' • ~.. ' '.
C ' l, ~' ,. i;: w t.. • .. A•
•Ci; I .b· Ci-. - - IP' (;i •L
J f'~ l t '\., ~ ft• 8_ 't,f"! ' c.. 1. ~'°' . ~ 't ~ · \c-- I:: tY·
: C,J::" - ,rt Ir-c -C• •(; ~ - '°'~ r g. C,
~
C•
b~•
t! C·
l bC• ~ •-
f
t rl}
. ~ e. -
r-~~~I ~ 'E.
~ 1·· ·~ - .r' t "' .F> I:! ~. r.<' Ii\ -
~ \
t't - c.. - •
c.. i
r.. I:: .t· i: 'r~ c.. ..:.
c.. ,c; C· I:. ('D f.'()· ,c;
tI ~ ~ r,
~ ire: ie- <i;kIu re; ~ t· JJ e...~ <tt ~ f ~- r.c t·' 1iI r- r .e-·~ ~ t
gf ,c; • f •l !~
r t . f! ~- ~ c' ~: Q c.. ~ '\.· '\.· &- l is.·
I\,! 1.. •(; - - •· 't. C· • ~. ,(' ~ 1[• ~ r, I:. ,.
;t- ·~.~ ~ ~~ . ~~ l
- l> C· \ ~· S ltC • C: I> f.'()• • a.: t· t'
..C• !~ ~ ,f ~
£ l,f.c,:l:i
V & h I> C 0 1'1\,! - • - }:!: -

s
~ t :r E; f }· f ~ ~.r
1'
'FA :b
1~· . ~- f{ -r~ f• i \ ~- :~ .f1 { ~~ i~ '?. 1r ~ -;
-'i..... - - ::s-• -
.,P- • • ~--..· l, •
\.1I .
"'. c- .• -• • f-l.
• .. r ·
ri C· <j;;r ~· ~! f:!
I f:: ls.· - £' - • - t:,.
~ ~ h fr:
1. ~- G...~ ~ f. fj;~ ·L '[ }, <i.. nfa~-. l'.-} ~~. 1~. t 1 '° ~ &E l
~ 'f ·e ~r
~" ~ ~ ~ - :_ ; _: •. c, r c.. r;- -- r .,. ~· '\.· ~ - ·c. ~ ,t <t ~ ~· e-·
rl r l ·L ~ 'f°_ t- ! ·. - ~ -t ·r, ~- q_ If :c ~- [ ~ c, '; '!~ s:: " .f ~ E
11
\j ~ ~ \ ,t (i.· \\ f. b ~ (, ~ ~ ~ ~- -;- ft- c, t. '[\ ~ Vt. f.t i c,
i [ <c. C•
E -°1: ~ ~ t-C :[ ,t t·. Ji['~ ,Et f' °f -::l· ~· ~ i 1tri\ ~t ~·
I e.. - le [• [• ~ ~. f ·r r c.. "' [ ~ y l.. y· f:: C· "' n• .1:•
l r_.
1
E e·, f "' :~ ·. .~ .
fu c..
, • r.
,t'
l ~ ~ 1 ~ • 'r ~c. -
~ ,., ,r,- ~ _:. <t ~. ~ ~. ~ r .~
r .
t_ /ti b ~ §. [,
l,
-r»•
t r ' b .::.
f. •L C·,
fc: t ~ ·£,
a.:
)~ e! '\,.
~ '""* - it.
C- I:;
• ,
.r ~ -: I - [ ~· ~. ~· Q. p p
,. ~ \.· - - -~,. C <t.. • <t.. I' '
~ ~ ,l• - t f , [• F· r;-, ~ ~ ~ 5' f ~. r- tl~: 't· i:, 'CE!i.. t
1
:1 l :·~· 1 t ·~ 1 t •t {' ['-· ~ £:f { t £:f
. i
~ t> _ _
r _ _ _~ r- ~ _ ~- ~ _ _ ~ ~~ i~ & 1 't.t.1_ ;~ ~ lt t( ~- l
~ ! fi- e· t ~ J· t· t· rt [. l ~ { ~ 'L •G_ 'L [• C· ~. C• [, G., ~ ~· fr. c;. ~
~.~ f.. [ ,I!~ b . ~El' l, ~· ~ e,, I:. J:: f ~. f:: -~ rr f Ii\ ~ ~ { ~ ~ \ c .h T
Ir- ~ _,. - c- !::: ~~ i-, ~ 1 F.-; c__ El' ~. ·~ t-'
c_ [• ~ 'G. [• - iL
~ r_. L /),,.I ,, .~ , t• - f V\ - C J:!,.I t
- L• • ·~ ~· ,
•L
f ~ c:.. ft• l; - .-
f: '°
.. ~·
't.. ~ .
C, ~· t>- •• t CI ~
V\ •L
C l~
~·
'P· 1 ~:f ~ f: r .~: •L[• ,.
~ £:.
r ). f:: 'L ·~ ·~ (• ~ ·L: ,[
I f:: I
I.e.: ~ - ,•
·t • [•
[ l,.
~
~ :t ~·
.-1 ·~ ~ ~ ~-· E: fi ·~. [ , \·· \ r;: . (;i - i,.. ·t- .r. ,c;. ~ :.... . ,i:- j ~
c:..
C· G., == ::s - Cf!,
1,./J-1
- - • J..
!n k fi_ 'c. [ ~ ~ E ~ f:• ,- Ii>· C
11> h o ~ - ~
,._ - , c_ - (,"(' 0 c_ ~
~ ,(; c_ ~ .
Jr. ;-
•,_ '°
•L ' ~ ~· ' 'f l
, f:: - 'l.. r:t> - o V\ .. ~ ~ [• t 1. [-;- 3 ,;.._ ·;:
f. ! ~- ·1·: v ~~ f:: ~·
FJ • f '1> E'· • ~ C. ~- t :er ,t; t r ,e: '[ I i I t ~ It
·;1 i rt ~- } f fr ic_ (•1> l.l!-£.-. --f, £C<
t ~ l't.r1.~ lc.' l>'f
.l·~ l b b' - ; l ~ c_ i ~ .c; . ~ ~
c ·~ t.1 ')! ·1:.. 11>
.r-i ·(
· .... _,. !:::
J;-
-~ I - - 1 · ~ -:- r 1. ff,,r- 1 r· ~r ;. c£~· e..ir r,:r v-~ i-
1:: e· .~ 'i ~- ~ c· f:: c r~ ~· ~ c·
I t> - C t:
'°f ~ ~ f:! C
f '1!- ~ G., ~ ;&\ \)
1.t> C·f
l, (; • • ,
.~~ 1 F.~ -;{,;:c ~ ,. t,·
f
p-1 U>
't
'>I
J:. .
r- -
I)
~tc
c_
I
.. '
C·
'C I> ~ Ct. ~
•Y
· {Er fi· f, i '\. ~ ~ ' ..
t· f' 1-,
V\ b . •
~ £ 1. 'E. f t P ~
t
E ~·
r
;t:
C
\.:o
b
~ •
C, [•~ ,~L ,c;11>· Ii\
fr
.b l, I;;" lo •
~i~-~~f-•t ft: - t l ~- i - - 1. ( . { );- '\ ~
}:; C. 11>• f;- I G
l '>• "O ..
ti! ~ ~~ .rt ,(; . ~,l, ·~. G.. 'f lr );- ~· '[ ~. l fr f ,c: f: t ~ ~--1 );- • .j [ S r
.. ~ t- f" t, '< 11 .,
l :~ rt ;:- 'L -~
~ t~ ~ u e -:. ~ . . l ] i f ~ t [
~ ~ 1:-. !l :><
l,' - - l, L -~ C.· • \
-
El~ 1
f~ rt r·" ·f 1· l ~ ~ •L 00 11 ~~
r r:: [ f, [ '° i- ~ ~ ·[· r· t :. -:- Q. ~
C §!. ~
•C~ i-.,,i O-< ~
ls>• ~ • \JJ I ::r' • •I. g ~ ·\. '& ~ 1, i r ·t· ~. . - i -~ s· ·\. , ·<j_. C" [I; si
.,! . 1·- 0 I- 0 •
[i ~ 1 ~~~ ..~. ~~ [i ri. r<i.- ft -~ :t i ~ ~ t l ~ r r[ 5 ~ j:.
~ I [, ·~ .1: ~ 'L Cl,. f;- 'r.._ 1-.·.:.
i. c ·~ £_ 1> t
~· g- E{ fl
f.. r::1- -c· ~t ~ 1.: l Jr f.~ J~ ~~ .f' l .ff.
lr r y·E· .~ [~ ~£,E\ :-,
~~ ~~ f: ~- ~. ·~ ~~ ~ r- ~ g~ b i ~ ~ ·'.
{- I :t· 1 f~--
!:i.Jlli::Z:U--·.-·,··F·./ ,,. . ,,,·O. .,,,,_,, ,: J··. ·r--''J·.J ,,,v.... ,;r,•., i'''~~""">....,.,.-··:,.....,....,
..., _., ,., · ,.,·""""-.,,......
,,aq.=·
.. ,r..,.,,.·.
··J,=,···.,-,,,.,..,.,
...•~"""",
~~UJ·~·
.1 '"""'·,r··''"r""tti..,,.'(~'-"".Jl,2-=--,_,v,,....,,,.0.,.,..,.,,u.""T']i'J,,.,,'jji;£;iJJ
r..w i~ rWI ~~J~I ~ U"'lA.:,.. ~ ~ OJ...1u4 y4---u,~ ~6:..Jl ~~I

. ~ 0-4 ~...u Lo~ ..9i ~l:!-JI r~I
J~ r"· -1.,
r"· · · r~ 0::' Lo ~J-&ll ~..r4bl1 ~ 1 :;~ y4--u,i ..1>.t 0 1
~4~1 ~1..r4., ~u1 . ; ~ ~ , Jl.;Ji J:J~ ~~J.AJ ~~, ~~
~..>3 .~.,JI ~~~I ~l...dWI .;4>,i} ,~.;·,1 ~ c.illjJ ,~l~I 0-4 ~.J..all
~ I ~Ll~'ii J)b 0-4 as'~ J;....ul ~~ ~bj «~_;» ~ ~L..u~I ~ I
, l.:.U .«~.Jjill ":..14l t34-4» ~ ~ 1.'r • • o • 0-4 ~ ~i ~..r.' clll~IJ ""1
.;~JJ ~~ a:;)l:; ~ ~..,.:o .;~JJ 0~ ~ i.j.:.UI J;....ul ~~~)\:JI~
a ~ i.j.J.:o .;~JJ 0~ i.jl) 1.t ".Jl..l.44 i.j.:.UI J;....ul Loi ·~.Jjill i.j~ ~ i.jJ:S
.;~JJ ~~ a:;)l:; i.jl) 1., r~b:&14 ~ 0l ~ (i.jJ:S .;~JJ 0~ ro .;~I
·(i.j.J.:o .;~JJ 0~ ro .;~I a ~ i.j.J.:o
,, ,, - -
J.41 • I~ 41~ l:.,~I l...d~ 1., 'r ~ J..J...iJ o...dLiJI ~ ~ ~ ~J
0 t~~~1., .c.ill.:.u~ 1~..,~1.;~.,0-t~..u10-4~F'~'
J..W ~~, ~ i.j.J.:o .)~JJ ~~ a:;~1 ~.) i.jJ:S _;'i..9J 0~ <JA J~'il ""l
· ~ I., ~I
u.o . ~.. ·- tlS' u.JI.S::i.JI
- ·
w--4 ..u..wl
- J~l ru- Jl~ . t .J..=iJI <JAtJ-'-'AJ~
· - · · .~
.c.illj '4Lli l.oj 0~...ul ~~J ~ I ~
-
~b.U I~ c.5.J.:o .;~JJ ~~ a:;~1 ~ ~ ~l>J.11.!l:ai«,4 ~ ~ ~
,,
-
-LoljJ 0 lS' 1.," JI J;.J aJLA ~ Jo~.., <JSJJ .J~~1 ~ J~I rlJ;.; ,,,~
~ J!bi cyli J)b (>4 c.illjJ) r~ ~ (J.J...) 4~ic114\t i.j.J.:o .)~JJ ~~ a:;)\.:; ~.Jji
.(<dncome trust J;....ul ~JJ»
Jl..9-4~10-4 ..u.J.11 ~ r~ ~ ~ o,u~'i' ~ ~J.,JI .,t as-~4 '-:?taJ.,

i.jj:J~ ,bb=---o ~ ~ , l.:.U .~l..1>..,JI Jl ~~I 0-4 ..u_j.11 ~ Ji ~l..,-..l'i4
~~It# .,t J~ ~ 0-4 ~l~'il ~ ~.;~I Ponzi Scheme""~ ~I
-
. ~ ~ l.,_J~I ~.:.UI ~J...Gc.ll (J.J~I ~~ ~ ~l..1>.yl..9
- -
~IJJ 0-4 ~~LY u.."":«oi (jWI_, ~ I Ji .;~4 Ll_;\..oA) J~~I J ~ ~
J..l.C. .;l+,I ..ll..9 ·"S: ,~,lt -~JA ,0..1>...9 ml j J ~ ~J income trusts J_.;....ul -
.)'iJJ 0-*1:i "0
0-4 ./J5~ (J.J...) 4~i t I ;;. ) ~ ,.Pt ~ ~)\.:;.., i ~ ~ ~ C II ""l
0-4 ~ i J y~I ~ allJ o_;~IJ ~l.,JI ~,~~, 0-4 ~->-11 ~ ·i.jJ:S
c.illJ..9i 0-4 '-:?~ 1...9_)-'Ai i.jl .;~ rJ ,forensic accountants ~~I ~WI
J ~ ' i l JIJJl ~ ~J ,~~'ii c.::.,lbb;.41J ~ I ~L:. ~ ~ ~.:UI
~I rl:\11 ~ t 0A
- o~, .,~
~lS' .Jl..9 -~4-,..Jl..9 c.::.,4~1 ~'.)AJ ~UI
-. .))411 ~,., -
J)l;. a.:;;.:;;.,..JI ~ ~t...a.ot o~ ~1 ~ tl~ ~ ' c.::.tlS'->1WI ~ ..L4l
I(" :. • d...u.t.A c.::.,b::u.A ~I c..9.,...-
- t uJ-LA • • ~, :. ~ \.!ll~ ' I.:. ...ul '"b ~
~ ·- • ~
& •••
~ - iJ u-- ~ iJ •
ru
<...a....,.,oJI 0A ~l~i uo.:co:..:J ~ .a ·o.:t:11 J::,,JI 0-A~I rl..1;.; ,,,4~
o(U~,":~lS~4)) ci~4 «ui ~ ~ ~ <?' ~J,J~I ~,~, LJ.4 a.L_,b c.::.,l&.,l....a,J
.\.!ll.:u a~ ~..,t; ~tr?-1 ~t ~ ~ <JS:JJ
c.::.,~ ~-' I.:.~ '-',J.ul..al ~-~,, · I ~ ,\.!ll.JS' I..LiS' •..("-: · l ·.~ ~'I .
- 'Y (.)-" • .. ,.,.... u.. - u..,..... u ur- u,AJ
~..,Jr'~)U o..,_µI ~~I 0A d.L.uL..,,c.!lliA ,l.:U -~J~I oJ.lw~I J~'il
o.ll.£, c,;s o~..1.C. ~t,Joi ,·,4s ,,,i ..L4l .«~c.::.t'i~'il .,~ ~.,..b,..; 4; ,cs2 ,~u» ~
ci.>.I - ~,1 ~
. J-lc,r - ·.. ''J-I ~ I ~ · ·· -::~---'I i.!.WJ i."?"'~~
· <"tJ • [ ~I (>J-r--- -~ · '"lu&.;JI ~
.a 4.!4.,..JI c.::.ttll~IJ c.::.,LilbuJI J4c. ~~~I w,,i~I
jA J-¥- ~.LJl..9 • I..LiS' ~~is~~ (j-1...) 41i «1 I ~...u ~ ,~L.ui ~

C
~.,~1., w,,i_,...!,WI ~~ ~ ~.;Jl~f"S--').)/1 ~~ a ~;.,;.,JI c.::.,w~?II c:,i

~~~WI olSJ ~f y l ~ 4 c:,~L:uJi ~~ ,J.,La.1.1 c,;s ·J4>-~I~
LA~~~ JS' JA :~ll c.::.,Wol.41J ~UI JIJJ~I JJ:!..l.AJ c.::.t4~1 ~I.JA
c.::.tl:'i_,ll c,;s c.::.,b.)~,., ~UI JIJJ~I a~.:&~ a~.:& y~ JJo c,;s ' J ~ 4 ·rl...>:!
c:,~4-,..JI J ~ Securities and Exchange Commission (US SEC) o~I
O.)~ ~ LA , ~~4 -~WI r\..lalll 4.A~)\..A ~.J.A ~ . , JS'~I ~~~WI
~0-':!-'-" ~ I ~J:i: <? I ~~?/I
J>-...ul ~l.)J J ~ i ~ c.::.tlJ-'-'-1' ~ ~1 ~ I a.....b...JA ~ J ~
0A l:~I ~t c:,lS' - ~ J ~ L,ji ~ I ~ business income trusts
~,u..-.v~l~J -~l:P,.~ IJJ>-.ll LAJS'~~l .w~.:Ul~IJ4S'
~~ ~ 0-AJ o..b,.l_,JI ~I otbi ~ J>-...ul ~bJ c.::.t'-4S'b c.::.t'ib. .l..1.e. y ~
-~..LI.I l:~I c.::.t'ib.
~_;.>-~I ~t:JI ~j:J_j,! c.::.,lbb;... 0A c.::.,l~l c.!ll.iA c:,lS' ,Is (Cf.;; o~I J)l;...9
JJJ ..\.al .Quebec c.!l4fiJJ Alberta b~i c.::.,\.a.blaA i;s ~ J ~ c.c:i..b,. <?'-'
[JL;J U~I Jl-'"4~1 JJ~ ~~_,JI c,;s l-'"4llJ~tJJI ~c:,..,~..u.10.A~
·::::.:.:.·::·;:,~;-:.~:::-;=·.:-::-:: ·. ,-.::-.;:,._ . _.·:-.:-.,~:·.. :.·:'} t
c.:,11 rr · · \, rr · · A ~k ':?..)~~,,,w!i~~, '"pi .is_, . ~Li;..1 L-9..L+.i ..)~1

a\ bb:u oA ~ .J~I illl~ a7= ...:UJ . I~~ 6:,Jb:,...1.1 ~ ~ I ~ ~
. ..)~~I oA JIJA~I y ~ ~ ~t:JI ':?.>J~
u,A 4-4.lUll ~yJJ 0 ~ , ~ 01 - ~ ' ~ lA J,Aj ..)-""1' ~ ' ~..J

W::!-'~I ~l:tul r~ ~ ~>fll ~t:JI a\ bb=-c.!IJ ~t:Jl ':?.>J~ a\ bb:u
. ~.... coiJI ul~I ~)U - - ...;-. C.
s~;..Jtu~~t
a4L..u:,.. ~.J.A,, ~ lAJ aWoWI ~ c.:,lUI .J~~I Jl.JJi ~ ~l_j:!
,, .. ,, .. -
. ~t ~.Jlw ~~ ~ j i ci'1' a41.,Jl ~ Ji alAl_µJ~I ~ al:~ ,,~WI
~ ..
1~
... ,.-:;.t:..
j ( . ) . ':?"'
.. , t ~
· L tUI .) ~~I "9.)j &-,~~ .. ..1Z...J, .. ~ - · ... L ~1
.. f8J ~ ( > A ~
, • «.!1..>J u=;~, l.:U .JUI oA ..u_j..A ~ ~->3 ~I aw~ ~~I ~l~I ~ c..,A
- - C. - - -
J.!:i.Jii as'...,.._.j, ~
(.r."j~IJ j.A.:.UI Jlil.lJ .WWI ~j ~ 0.1) Q~i •.,ti
~I
,, - -
I~~ a: .";! ~ l~~alAl..,.ill u=o~ 01 .Nortel Networks a~~)U
,~ ____ -:-:~o~laL~&tl.~ab
.. ~ I.:" ··t\ a.JUI
'.)_r.-, j ..
.. I ~I~~
"'jj .. ~
·-l4JLl
. '.)
la.A
o_µl 0i J~, l.:U .alAl..,_lli ~~ ~ a.!L.;:J.I ~UI t_)4f'l .>J...Jl..a:i ~ al~k.l)\J
01 ~ ,~ul4J ·t~.,14 ~~ ~ ~ ~i oA ~_;g I~~ ~...J Q~i ·114\t
,, -
-~._;~ ~ ~~ aW:u_,..:; ~ I ~
~~.,11 ~l~I ~~ ':?jjl u4~1 ~l_;l ~.JwUI .JJ..iJI ~I~~

u4~ &.J.A '4k 0~ 0i do~ ':?.:UI lA ':?i) ~Ul .J~~I JIJJ~J a~~
LJ-AJ -~l:JJJ~ a4lua.:.JI ~IJ-4 ~~ ci'1' ~.;JI o~I ~ ,(~...J Q~; • ,11
~~ ci'1' Hercules Management j.....#.J-:!-A al.Jb! Llb. ~ ~..ill ~ I
~J ~~Supreme Court of Canada ~~I L:,LJI ~I~ ~
lliwLl.l ~Ul .>J...Jl.a:Jl Jl~l u~ l~_,t al:,lua.:.JI ~IJ-4 <:r4b 0l r' °'°'1 rk
->~J.\_, -~~~I ~.Jli9 ~w,
~ ~~I ~)LA o~~ c.:,11 L-9~ ~ ~ b
oA ~.;JI~ ~bJ.I ~..,i ~ ~ I ~ I o ~ ~~J-A ~~
-~UI .J~~l Jl.;__,i_, a~~ o.l..i>J.I ~l~I ~ illl~ L-9~1
a~~I al.Jbf' a 4 ~ 1 ~l..r4 a.!·:;~ illl.:U ~ I a 7=.!;;t~, ILl
~LuJI 4UI aWL:dl ~J o.Jbf'I ~ ~1_~1 f9l.b J~J r~ c.:,11 '-pi~
....-~:re: 11.'"=8=::r,1:;1:.~..,.., ..
Lfj~ 41a.9 ~ 'i?~I LAJ Q..L>IJ tjU : u ~ t ~ Jl.""4l!_g 44.J_r?JI

iI ~ i :!' c· fi.. ,t' 1> e.. <t C:• rfi ~ e. I l\ ~• :• C)S .~.;· . ~
\ ~: :r, c.· £• •ft_J::
t• 1,. ~ ~ ., 'i. ,t ~-~ \o i T
~f E: t- ,.;- c. t . t>""
~ ~ "L' s-. [, '.·\. t'
1> t.. : {
'\ t -; ~.
'r. ,t - ~ f"' r: V\ ~
~--~ ;t' ~~ .~[, ~t' ~r. ~·~ ~.t ·~- ~·. ~ 1.r •ft_1:. 1;f-' ,P.'
'f ~ t· c- ~ ~ ·~. l .~· <t ~ •r;; ,t' ;~ 1 J:: -~ ~ ~.•. :.·;· c.:
'J:.. t>"" ~ ~ -~ ~ '~. ~I <; :· :t
1~ 'fu:" ~ f' ~E~ -~ ~· ~
C· •C' • fl: 1> i :·M·. ~.
1· Ci -; ~· ~. ~ f t- -
E lo~ ~ t
•
I:.
~ t> ~ E: I:; ~
~
c... ~
>! -~ fl
L :·.t i~ ~
~ tS f! P ·~ r 1·
~ l\ ,E•
E ·~ C)S ~ 1
l ;~ f z i.~.:.1 -
- , ~ ~ ~ r· ~
iJ:: tl~ e:I:. '[ .. l.c ).~ f.t :[ '~Fe ·~.fi f't
£. ~: ,t'
·i· 7 ~ t ~· J ~ - ~ - i- 1= a .f t ~· f:4.':
.F" C·
~ .es- 9' , ~--< ~ f"
l..
l..~ 1
I C·
r'\t. ·,r,-1~ t i. ., ftl ~ =I r E: ~,. e-· l ~· a~. =r ij
_r. ~ f . ~ •; -:- [, -:- , .! [ r ·~: !' c.' I:. t· ~ ~.~.:t.
.r c
~ Er~ ~fl .-~ ~[ ~c, c}. O~- .r:-
. 'I: 9' , ,_ ~
;~
~
1 ~
r-~ e.,. 1••
1,· .., I,
C)S ::!, !: ,
l 1. 1
C... 1:' -
1,, = ~t'' r;. H.•
I;; ~ ~ " 8 1> ~- ~ tC C·
~ C· ·Y ,;;., 5· ;- ~ ~· - ~ , V\
s-. • • ·r, - ~ - ., ..14
'° , r.,.
r.[ ;r·- 1: (-t~i>
· ·- f ·ri:;; e..t ~~ r~1f= ~= i~·1t·~ ·:,'
,ll-' ,c;, [, •
(t, •
1 ~~ ~
1,
_;_
,
-
C· f;
f:?..>
,f-' (')
0 C)S
'[ , ~ ,
t ~. ·~. ·t · [, t,
- ,C-
~ ~. f {" 'L ,~ ~ ~ ~ ~. a ,C- ~
6. [, - . ~ ?
~.f l\
't. ~ c...
~ '<i. . ~ r: t- - ~ . ~ r ~ [ . I·,·'
,j (I) •
- - C· c_
t ·[ '[ ~ f! 't: 'ftg. ~- f'C- ~-i 1;.~. -
~ C... C ..
, ft - . ~ [• . , !t f.
•C' r11>· 'C. - li>l "' 1> ' b. ~ (C)'
-
c ~· r. t ,c. · · i . r- ~C. • t:r~ ~Q - !t ~·. r.:•:1.•• k :]
,t:,· ::t.• ,
l
·1· 1 ~ I . ~: [, . }
I ,s
l\
J:. ,r }
\I\
C· ...
c...
,r
V'\l~ , r
:v'\
r i, I•
S
· - ~ e,.
• -
·-
1[,
f, £;r J,r. ,' ~c-- iRt· ,• C•.c -
,c _ - = \.,•
,. l;- A
,_
~ ... ()'Q • -
r.,.·:.:~·.
E
C
1
, h ·[ I:; .~· ~. C: . .~ \.
1_
•:-_" C· .~·
.~ !f.
{- <t- re·C· <t- 1,t:. ~ J::. .,.r:: en ~ -~· , \ t
b• 1, , r C)I I •
C ·~ f! ~
- ~ tC ~ t>"° ~ t>"° ~
s- I>c-
= t .,.
., ',_
J:: ·E'
f>: -. £
• ~ - •
t -Y •- tC
v ~, [s- ~·C _: ~ ·::1
\.·.1'
C .: <r; ,c.- t 'l, 'l,
!t' 1$ ~ ~~. 1~';: ~ ~ :~-~ [
ft• 1>~ - 5=: ·~ ,. ~.6· r:. b ~fl: e. -[, -~ ~· y'~ r::. _,
f.:fr-i ~
k.[ { •ff
tt~·~i I (r~i~bcf,
tC _ Ci }c ~. ~. lo I,'
i- ~- .r~! i.r ~., 1 - ~
'- ~fr[,<tI, !,I;, tr- ~l rt- • 1~~ f ~ I:. ~ ~ ~ J
10-'-"'Wt..>.!J1.a.1J't
~~~1 L>~~J..9.J.ll o-4_#<.i-90,J_; Q~j cull L)~~~J~I ~l_lA
~UI ~?11 ~~ 0-4 [~~ J..9..ul 0-4 ..1:..uJI e·, ;:; ~ ·r..\WI ~ I J ~ o~
~ ~ ci°'11J International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) ~..9..ul
a.! "'.!~>31 c~l~'.)11 .J>.l .c.cl_,JI ~ <.i-9 ~ ~ J ~~L.,, 4Lo c~l~I
a.!1.!; ,~sill ~~ ~ 0 ~ as'~ ~i ~~J.A 0t J-A ~..9..ul ~UI t_)411 ~w
.cG~ Lo Jli91 <.i-9 ~ I ~..u 0~ 0t ~ 'l.:U -~~ 0-4 ~ i
~.JZJ ~~ b~ ~Li.A wi 0,J~J..l.l 0-4 cl4>.~I ~WI '5~ I ~ a.J..9.l <.i-9J

~ tU\ • • ,i,• ti C..,11.41.LU
,t _I •ti • I• J"-i ~-1 ••lt • • •
~ cl.!,o" ~~UA ~ J ( S ,,,o•'Jf~C1--.:11..0
j ~, ....
~l....4 c ~ t I.LU~ c4J .o~l '5..J.A ~~>31 ~~~I self-dealings

.abj4LI ~?11 J:> ~ ~ I ..\~l..9 cl.;_~1 ~ ~..9..ul ~UI ~?11
~?11 ~~ <.i-9 ~~I ~l~I 0-J~..Ll.l 0-4 _# ~ wl ~_;-ll 0-4, l.:U
<.i-9 ~~ ~\.:&j ~l.i.A..9 .a.!,o~I ~~J.>-',A4 o.l\i)..9~1..b.;.i ~W..?1 ~..9..ul ~UI
:'·~- . "~
'+"""'~~ - ~ , ~ J ~ L• ~J~.) ~ I
.~j-4,ll ~ I ~~J cl.,_;.-~ ~1 ~)~~I~~-""" -

<.i-9 ,Jut.I~~ . LAjW..l ~ ~J.l ~l i~ ~lb.;.~\(;.,;.,;;~.,......, -
I . ' ~ a..u lit I a..;_,_,J I ~\.:&j IU-.:.. I;.,i '}1 J ~ I J ~ I . bu.JI .
U'! • - ~ ~ ~ - U:! w-4 a..u
.. \ill a..;_,_,J\
J~I ~ ~l..9 0~ ljl ,I.LU.:U a~ -~J~I ~ I c'}l~I ~W..l <.i-9J Qicc,.!"'
1 ·- ~W..1 c.cl-'I
a..;_,_,JI ~ . , 1., o l.r'l '· ~
··.. J\
,.,.. ~ ~ • . a..a...WI
• ~ \ ll~ t .)J r
· L>.:i
.
.~t ~ ~ d..4.lll ~ ~ 0~ ,~WI
~ 0t.¥'~~1 <.i-91.LUj~.., ·rll.)~' ~~r~ <.i-9~U1 J.b..11 i ~ -
~~?JI ~ I ea ,~S.J: .c,j.b.al "-41~ oJfi.J.11 rllJ~I ~ o.l~I cLI>WI
o..u. J~'.)11 ~..,~ ~~l '5.»-t cl Q.!.!;;~ W' ,a..a.,._).A c ~ ~..,~
.I.LU~~ ..9l cl.,_;.-~
0i..9o~C~0,J~lc4L.u:,..~J.A~ Loe Oc~ciS'.J.wlJ.lWlo-4..9

~ i ~ i ~ ofo 0-J..; Q~; ,.,ti~ ~.:UI JA~I Y'J ,cla.J\.;..Jl J~~I \ ~
.cl ois..a!I
,..,,
~~I l.G..9~..ul t ~ ~.ljJ wi ~~I~ LA as'~ c.:.,~ i~ LA.J.lc
o.l~ .ol~ L&J~io.JIJ1~~1~.;JI ~~~_;1..t~~~ljJ_,,.:i~! ~ I
as'~I ~~~I o.J~I a.!«u/v-JI J.:?JI 6A F. as'~l l.G..u w~ .i9
~~ ~I Nortel Networks c.:.,':Jl.'4i)U ~.J~ as'~~ ~J.>. ~.., .~Li.JI
~ ~J l.G~j o..>A ~ o.l~l ~ ~LA ~ljg &) as'_;-:WI u.J..1.&.oi ''-"")lg~

~ wJJ Q~; , 111\..9 0~1..u1 LAi . ~ b aa..i..t.1 ~Lu.JI ~ll.;i ~~ o.l~hi
JA4,.:i ~ 'i, l.:.U ·l.G~i OJA ~UI ~l_,l!I ~~ o.l~l .J.lc wjg~ 6A I~~
.c.:.,':Jl.'4i)U J:!:i.J~ as'~ '-"")l91 ~~~I ~~I
. J ~'ii J I.JJ i <.:r-4.>=!=A 6A ..u.J.1.1 y.,->..u .JA c.:.,~jAJI "21.A 6A ~J.&ll ~

a.: '".!~.;,31~~~1".:ui6.4~4JIY-~.JA~~..Lfll~..,,~1~u1
~ ,~~ ~ b ~ . . , . ast .~.IJ o.J-1:i-o l.G~l ~ ~1 ~ .i9 ~I
-
.J~I .JA L;;~ ~ lA ~ ·".J.lbo ~ ..9i ~ J~I ~ ~ 4,1~ ~ 'i
- ~
ts "' "' ~
.I.LU~ ~I.JJ ~ 'ilJAI 1.!Jl..&.A wlJ , ~ I .JJA':ltl ~ ~ _;i ,ceilJ ~UI t.)4)'1
- ~ti a.JUI
f"'~ · .• .:.ti ~. L·.~ LA al..u. .l~ ~~ ,~
- ~:,-' ___& -~ ...~ti ~~I J.£J-~
- ~ ..}-!):. ~ « ~l..A11
t# C C
:~LA~~ ~ I tl~I ~I 6AJ

~UI fa_;J.I ~ l l ~ ~.Jl,&l:,hi J_,-c..oi <.)1 al.J-'W ".:'.:; .~.; ~~ j....J_,,.:i -,
WW ..,t r4},u ~~16-4 ~~ ~UI ~_,JI 0L:., ~ ..,t balance sheet
·r4.J~I ~~I .JA opi w~ I.LU~~ r~ Jb.. ~J ,~UI J>...ul
6A ~ I ,JUl.l ~ ~ . reducing liabilities c.:.,LAlj:J'il 0--4 ~ I -r
L+,i ~ \s\.:'?°"';! warranty repairs r~t'I c.:.,l:,~ ~ ~ I ul:!J..9j-J.I
.Jl,&l:,! .JA ~..1.&11 ,l5~i oJA .~I c.:.,IJIY-1 ~ o.ll:.) ..9i c.:.,~~I ~ ~
.J>...ul ~ ..,t r4)ll ~ o.ll:.)
o-4 ~w a.:\:ai cr,o ul.olj:J\S' 's'.:? cc,i JLi.c.h, u~~IJ ul.olj:J'il ~~1-r
rt.;JI .)\yJJ w,--:...u::i as'~~~ cll~ J~J . ~ I a.:\.:; .~.;JI ulb~I
4J~I
. . · ~I r ~1~ c.,--
<>°J 1... a,.a:;.-:ttul.ol~-:t'}ll'- ..": ~4~..U -:tj
. 'J- '.J-""' ~ r J - i.r
.c.:.,,j\S' ~l a.:~.::ll ~l~I u41k:J.
U.'?'" ,1111 o.)l:.).JI « ~ » ~.>JJ.}J ~ cll~ a~J) J~~I ~.J.a:i ~ a........;.J4ll -t
c.:.,,j\S' ~ ~ •.~ll-:1J .~1~1.....u~1o,4a..c~r'~4cll~J(~~
International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) ~J.J.11 ~UI ~?JI.>:!:!~
o-4 4lo ~~'ii~ ~I r.:.:aiJI ~L.ut 0-4~1 .)..?..,.t ~_; q~i,11qlJ a~.: ,110
• ~ ... t a.JL:.
,4-4.)\l ul~ • ; tWI J ~I - - ~Lill · •~
·-: · ..-:tt ~
'- t
- 1~"TC'.
.-: - .A
~ ~. <.rJ
4-:1~ rJ.l:i 'i <::1J.J.11 <::1Ut t.)4?1' .>:!:!t...o ~ ~ ~ ' tP4l' 0 t ~ cll~J
-~~ ~~ ~ o.;~ ~ u ~ l l.!1.1:i
u'ilo:&>.I ~1~ wi ~ o_# lS.>="-t ~~ c.!lLl.A ,o~ifi~ Lo~!~~!

:~J <::1UI J ~ 'ii ~J.J>.
ul.olj:J'il .)~J~ Enron w~l as'~.;~I ~l.;J~->11 •.,: ,eell 0\S'-\
,as'~I .;~I .J.lAJ .Off-balance-sheet liabilities ~l~I Jl....b:, [JL.;..
A.A Lu ·wt ul.
· .:.-:q -;,~Li.JI J..1.a.A ~ Lo .rJ :.~ti · . .~<t\ -:: 1;. -
~ -~ 'J--"" 0 - 4 ~ ~~
~ w~ ~ ~~ J~ Lo ~ J • (VIEs) variable interest entity
asset securitizations ~_.;.,:JI J~lJ pension obligations ~~I ul.olj:JI
~bt o~LiS' ~ ~L;JI uL:.~'ilJ .hybrid liabilities abt;;.tt uLolj:J'ilJ
~
-~_;q~i•csqlJ ~i w~_r.aS't ~.J.110§.: Lo~~~ as-~, ~ t

at;; cc·Il..)-:!-C, u)\.Al..:JIJ self-dealings a,:,o;. ,~,'I ~UI ~>L.ol..:JI ~ -r
~I u\S'~~ . I~~ o ~ alS' ,~,o c:i>non-arms length transactions
-·
ul...&.J.I ~ J.AO) a.,~ 6::JI
. 1~.":)\.AL.:; (.).,_....
· · <"": (.)• t ~ -
· < - · (.)~
· ~ I (·. ) ~ ..ul 1~
.('t~ • ·
~ 4 w~~I wJJ--:!..111 ~ r~ ~I LAWI u\S'~I ~ ( ulA..bJI Ji

.;l..L-ii wfiJ ~J .~L-..iJ.1 ~ 4-:1~ L~ ~J.)~ ~ ~ J 'L>Jb?JI
-
~ ..ill~J , I ~ ~J-4 a.!,o;. ,~,JI 4UI u)lol..:JI o.;~ ~ ~IJ ~1~1
-
~ l ~ l ~ i ~ i ~ ~ · ; , •,oc.!lLl.A,i.LU~~J -~~lw--s-H..ul
~ ul:,~I ~~J a.!,o;.~I 4UI ~)lol..:Jl:, ~ I ~ W 4 ~ I
~~I .;b~I r l ~ I ~ 1...9\~'il uM ~ r~?JI J4>-~I t.!b; cc,i 'i
riA
~J..ul ~UI t.)4?11.>:!:'-'-4 0t J.A..&i ~ J.WI ~ 1.§jjlJ . J ~ a.bWI
..&l ~ ~ International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS)
-
':T• La.,~
. ~~ - u· lS' ~. cG~ L4A ~)LJI
• -'I cLik - . J~
-· W I u:u
· ·1.,-.
-~'I u':ib
. ':T·
t_)4?Jl .>:!:W L>..,.;_.i JJ.3 rl~I Jb. ~ 0,,t~I J ~ I ..lbY- ~ • I.LAS'
[~~ International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) ~J..ul ~UI
·L>~
4UI u~l..:JI ~4':-:, c.J:-:~1 u-i~..ul a~~ L>J-->'i ~~ ~Ll.4.-r
~.J.jj .~_,.LuJI [~~J o.;b?JI u~~j ~ oJ~ W t..1.4i ~J ,a.!,o;. ,~.JI
u~~ .;~J 4UI u4&JI J)L..;.. 0-4 ~~I 0,,t~..1.4.U ~~ ?JI uLl~I
0J..1.:1 Ji a,o~:-L4 ~I~ ~JJ-4l1J ~ I ~411 ul.9~1 u4~J 'f'8-'-"~I
,~I d.J:.~..ul ~~?JI ulj4"?JIJ ,o.3.J,.:,c.A J:..t..-3 ul~ -l.P."-J r~ c4 ~I~
uw~4 ~>1,1 ~l»JI JJI~ 0--A J:..ull ~ 0,,t~..ul ~ ':J~ ~'-4......uii -l.P."-JJ
1.§jjl .;Ua.U d.J:.~..ul o~I 0.:-41:JI U~J as'~I ~_.;~15 ;(g)WI ul~
~
~bl.JI ~ · -Llb. .. ~ · . LA~J . ..1--1-:. : rti ~LlA'J~
: rtiJ ..u-:. .r ~ .. I ~ ..ul ct S'\i4J..
\.!!.ti u--
1:: - -
c4 1-'..)-:!:-'-1
.::~ 0'.) b':JI . ··'- - ~ L
~ ~
L : . ~• ' ~I:. ..ul a..u . t ... a...:;. "':.f I
- ~ c.;-- • 'J-'""
" - "
~~ll~1.:tcG~':J4 lb~0,,t~..ul 0-4~1 <>"J~ ~ .ulb~I

..
,,
.4'.u..ul u~\S:.l.l 0-4 d.J:.~ ~ J ~ o.;b?JI ~
.-~
v - ~ I c.;--
~.. I (,>J~
t ... •
~· ..ul ~- '?""" • ·1-~'1
"':ti u:u .,-. (( 1-'..)-:!:-'-1
.::~ (>A
· ,J-' -
-:. 'I .)J
· l,..:;11
. ..1.41-t
0~..ul ~u\5_;-j, -l.P."-Jl.§-l~ -~~I u~~.J~J~~~J~IJ.;
-~WI L>..u ~J.>L4 ..H);. L!ll~ uS'JJ ~~ u~~ ~~ ~10J:~1
~ ~ 1.:.uiJ ~WI ~bjj ~ i ~ ~ll.;JI ~ ubl~?JI ~ [..,.;_. ~ -o
.>:!:'-'-4 ~ ~_,_,J .(liabilities uJ:..ul/uLAlj:J':il) 0-4 ~WI ubl~?JI ~
International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) ~J...ul ~UI t.)4?11
;tWI
C"' • ~ '··--"= u--
,::_ (>A
· L~
.. u-~~~~i~
. ~ . . . .::~tu~l.,.:.ui
.J---'-" ~
,,
I .. . ,t
"
-, . . -, ': ·' - ": , ti • • ~ .. .. tI
• L..'2> 4 ~'":"'-" _;,:> ~ ~L...UZ)J oCl.4...,. f I I"
..H);. Ji i~ ~ note disclosure ~b;JI y ~ I ~ ufi.: 0i <J'-4,ll 0-4 -1

0t a.J~I 0-4 ,o~ ~~, i, ,~.<JI ~ <i'1' ul.;4--}1 ~ 0J..1.:1J - ~
0-4~ r..1.4i ,LL:. o~LaS'J .~l,&lll 4UI ~1~ c::,Jo~I .;.! , ,,;;JI~~
~ij:oiu~jj~~JLLA..H);. ~~~a.L_,Joul.9~ul5~1
~b;JI y ~ I ~ ~~ ul:P-~l 0-4~ ~J .UhA u)IS' ,~·4! ~
Y'"\~ .. ~~ 4-La.9 ~ 1$~L4J ~..bJ ljU :ul.JUI ~ .:il.wUIJ 4-a~I

cf. 0'. ~: ~ la' ~ [· ~ i 1· ~ <; ~ ~ .~· [· :[ r tJ
.. f;. r J;. ~ g .f" 'i.~ ~ ~ p.• -· ~ ~ ~ r- 1 _ Ii.· t.il·,.
r:t ·~. ,c E, 8_ t> 1 .c-r.- ·~1::..~~
,f.r I: ~ r O - ~ ~ '6' - 't.. ls.· ~ t' 1° ~ l, ii ~. c... ' I.., f' [!
I
.t E: t ~ ~ ·( t ! ~ ~ v- 1.:.:.~.::
rr: -~
~ .r I I.., <; lo • • - .. ,~.'_.
en - N 't:. ' c ·V n • .. - •
J,l ' ~ ~ t P ,. r.
f. ~--· ·c:-l l~ frl ~ . : ; 'Cj.. ·[r .c-~- ~~ ·t[• ft:
Ci ~. !- .. lo. ~.
I:; en & c- .,e · < _,. l, p.• _, - ~. V ~t , &:" !e ,
~. f ~ ~ ~ ~ t. \. f ·t~ ! :.,:·•'-
- : n, 1s>• , , : , , ~.
•(,. l~ ~t,, tI?: s1, ·.t> ~ ~ 'E l ,l - ~ ' ~rr
f lo .b l,' I t'· ' ~
... ~ ~ gv .v ~ -~ c - le. 'Csi.. :.·
-~
l} S ~ ~ 6 ~
c, r C· (!
[ t ~' '~ ~ { ~ fi. [ l i ~ - '
('<>•
t '°b '}I:. ~~ E ·Ei, 'b .f,rj f; -~ i -r:: •t'.-f:
t· I! ' .~. r t 'f {: f .E ~ ~ .~.
lr '.l
~ ix : ;~ i. F' ~ .f' [ f ..q; f $ _ 8 e· r: r. -~ -'- ~ t J'l! :~ ,{'
C· ~ err r l. ~
r~ c..
~ 1.1· i [· i { 'f: ~ '1= t ·i· r { ., ~- t· i
,t· ·~ ~ ~ [' l ~ t;- ·~ f.:.j:.
n, - . -~ - \.
- 'r t> y ..
f, .~: ~· t 1 ·r· c: ~· ~~ ~ ~l c·- Ct-~· t> ·[ t E ~ f"
~ f. f.~ [ ~·Ir ~:,
'\. Er . ~ : C· ~ ,C-' ,J.. -• • ·( t, • ! ~ n i;- c;- C· ;~ lC... t•· 1 -[ 1' f> ~.·:.
I, <; ~ 1> :.. '- ,t ~· ·~ t - C. ..c I:: I is. ~ - t' ~ . ' ,._ i,'l
[ t> - e.. l, [ ri -f. 0 {' - ' 'l.. ('f ~· 5. £ 0 l, ~0 t 'i: ~ ~0 1· L"·
~ c... ·~. Q. C: E. ~: . 1 f. ~ f ,. Ci.. ~,

i g:
£ f" fi:- - ~ 1(; ~ ~ ~ - ::s t,C l, G. _,. - ,._ b ~ .1::
l . i~,·. ~. -' 1ii' l ~ ~{ ·i· ~i· ~f 'f,~ 1.
i . ~, -; ·~. ~ ¥. r ~ 1,. 1:; t. ·1:. ·~. ·~. ~ ~ 1· ' Vt ~ ~! ~· : · 1· ~ rr.·
- E;
l,' '
~ &fi ~ ,.
. ' ~ c-_,.
.r ~ <;t
~ .P.·t~ ~t;' ~t r ~ E
t ..1::t ~·V t- it~ Ef c...g C·h 1- I & •
t [· r - •
i - 1~ 1r ; 1 ~ ~ I , , , ~ - • ' ~ft~ -;;-r::f{f,' •·f C.. ~
.1
J, t :t; 'r~ t. .~ i l i ,t t ~ 1:· tr ~ r. r~· i\
,.E ·~ t., ~ t• ~ (;, ,r' Ii;; Cj_. (, t, , [• e_ - ,L
; ~- f.[: ·f~ tr r t ~: ~ r~ e· t }·.l! ~ t "i.
, ' y L. f;, ll-' · t' v i;- &7 G. , ' . ri
k- -,.~ ;f 1 •'
· • • Ii>~ .1:: ·~ I')
r-• -~ ,;.' [• ~ 1 ·Es ~y,. c... , .r , t> i· C _ c· ~ ~ _
i:: ~- i~...
! i.:;;- ' .~ t,C
~• II I f-~ tt>· "'··.
I;\ l!,
r r.:~ ~f-,. f.~ [I:. ~ 1~" 1~· ;:- t e·C- ik. ! l!,r tC -it '
r t>
f. '.L 'rl
- -• - , y· tC - - '-" t•• "" - ~. - - - _,. •
r-:. ~f ~-• r -
~ l.:U.Jl.Gy-.ias~w,k ~1~'}11 ~ LAas~~?IJ-1...;~c.!ll.lA_,
o~_,-.....; cullulS'~l~~JAJ«.;l.~'}11~.)~l~c.:,.,n~~w,
~J '~.)~I ~~I ~ ~.J+.t ; ; ~ ~L;.. ulS'~ ~1~ consolidators
.,t ~~ J~i ulS'~ ~\S' ~1J---«-" ~l:ul J:g~l ulS'~l .ll..1C.i c.)-4~ ~~
lP~ LA~JAJ ~1~'}11 ~1.)J~c.!lllAc.:,l:P,.~l~~J .o~ulS'~
- * -
~-
~ ... t ~I~• '}II J-1...J Ll..a..--,
.. • LA I·.:...<·
• ..>L'::!
LJ-0 ~ ~ <tJ -~~I.
.. "~
r..;,- .. ·"J-1• (.Tt} -lJ.a.9
.. ~~
J -
<Y~J C.:,~J-L«-":' ~I.;.. ulS'~ ~1~ a.:;;.:;;.,..JI a.b;JI ~ LA~ J~'}!l
- ~ ~J a.ci.c~ r4).~ C.:,..,...)-4:iluJ.l LW ~bl..>:! _,i ~4) ~
ulS'.~.~.ti •
<)A
__ t -l.J~
4J:.·~ .. ..
. t!.. ~ti • < - .. Lh,Jl
.,J---W ~ ~
..
D.:U. ~
... <.ti.
u -.: .. L-: ~
....
~ ) Y.)L.;;:; ~J.J-4ll ~ c.:,f w,k ~.,.ti ~J ulS'~ Ji ~J~I ulS'~ (.,)~L.;JI

~~J.wJL~~as_,LJ.lulS'~l~J -~~1~1~4.;f~~l
;;~ ~~I ~ I ~4) ~~l ~~ ~ ~ ulS'~I dti ~ J ~
~ ~ , l.:U -~~I J.l~ JJ---«-" ~ ~ ((L~» ulS'~ t+,i \+&A :y4--u,i
~...ul ~~~I ~4) ~~i ~) ~ ~L.;JI ulS'~I w,k ~1~'}11
.,.:u,_, , ~ I ~4) ~~i ~w ~ ~ LWI as~, c.:,~l ~1 ~
-
• ~L;;.lj 1.:J~ as~l «ct 4-:.~» ~ ~~I a.ci.c~I
r4.)~I ~ _ ; ; ~ ~ C.:,..,..; 4~i «ull L~ ~JA<J:l~l l.G...u ~.:Ul~IJ

.~l..:u.A l.G»l u~~ _,t ul:!J~ JI ~.li u ~ [LA...LII ~~~~I
w,k <<~~i ~~I» ~.J.,:J Jl..lLL-c..u'l'I w,k ~bJI ~ l.G?~l ~ I ;;..,_.b;.JIJ
~~I» ~I?~ ~6:.4" ~6. c.!lllA c.:,~ ~J---«-"J .J~I ~ C.:,..,..; 4~j 111' I
u~JJ~~J.,_;.b~;;~~lulS'~lc.)-4~4J:.~~«~~l
-~J-1_j..4tll ul~WllJ ~J6.~I c.)-4 ~..u.JI ~l~lJ ~lll ~I~ ~IJ.ill
«ct ,cea>.» Ji«~),,~ LWI as~I ~ c.:,l ~ I c.)-4 c.:,! ,~1_,JI ~
;-st,... . ,.:1 LWI as~,., . i.,# _;.:·ii f1 ~4) c.:,~ i~ ~J.A.J l:jfi ~~i
f1 ~L.;JI u~I c.:,i ..r4~I ~ J .(j)~L.u ~L.;JI ulS'~I c.)-4 4J:.~ c.)-4
l. · · 1- .ublal · ~- .t ~ ~ , . --9 ••• c.!JUA • .< • Jl · <t , I .-:L,bLl,,j ...
~ ~ . ~ .. ~ ~ (.)~ (.)--'J "(to' ..)-!:A-J
4~\ Ji ~J~I ~~~I ~ I ul_; ,;., ....; « ·4 ~~ J.;;:; Jl ,Jl:al

~ ~~I c.)-4 LA~J.)~?JI ct4.:"J.)Y."~I ~~J , ~ 4 ~1~1 ~
•_;.:.:·i C.:,JJ l&J6.
.
rv,
. .VCJll.,I', · - ~ ~.. ~,)Cllll,,---
Lf:,~ 4.1..a.9 '":-'-?': '?.:iii Lo.9 ~~ faU : u ~ t ~ ~~~ 4-t~t
Li.A w~I ~. . . ~.J.a.lll .~ ~
- r L.I.)~1 ~ • A~· ...L9 , lA~ J
o.)L~· l.!l~ u~
o~~,~w
1.1-:.-: c.....u.&.,,U
-
~~ ,~u ~., ·~~1 J~ ~ as-~1 ~ i ~ t:9J ~1 ~.)~

~J4c=J1 JoLlu.11 ..,.k~ 0t ~ ~ ~~i ~1 ~Ji 0A r4J~1 .,, jb\11
'.,
-t
rle. ..b~ 1..7'tl ~l,;JI.'-:!.) 6::JI
•
..b~I J"'~- ..La.l ,, Alb. c.,--
I"
- . c.:.JI·.) Lo
'"' ~L,
'"(t"
-
. c.ill~ ..)-!):. I__# ~~
,wl~I u,-4 .)~ i.S.J.A ~ ~WI ~J~I ..bLla.i.JI ~1~ w ~ ~~ Lo~J

~~1)) (Jl ( J j ~ ~ (_)J..) Q~j 'It 1tl..G. ~ ~i ~~ <.J:1~1 i.$..U ( J ~
C
as'.;-c:iJI 01:, .)~ ~, J.)w «~~l ~~I» ,~l:., wlJ~J .a.!;b; Q ((~~t
a..J~'}ll~WI~
- - • - ·<- . . ~WI
- ~~J - - - ,... ~l.i.i1.H~o~A-~
l9~c.,-- • • ~
... q
. ~l..,_;JI "~ Fo..,:J
~ ~ <i'1' wlS'~ D~'}/1 ~411., (_)J..) Q~j I cl 1~ ~ ' J ~ 4

t~J~I ~ .)_?.J u,-4 ~..,JI~ .bl.;JI wlS'_;-c:iJI ~1~ J ~ ~ ~ J
~1 ~~ '}I t~J~I ~le.~ ~L.u~I ak.;JI ul '}l} ,J~l 1~ ~ a.;__;-c:iJI
~ i ~..u ~.:UI 0-J..; Q~; •.,JI~ J~'}ll J-A~..l.fll ~J ,~~1 ~~_,:JI
Lo~_, • ~~I ~i ,<1~)» u,-4 -~~ ~~i c1~W» t:9...u o~~I as'~I ~ -
l,~~1 ulti ~ ~J-'-" ~.:UI u,-4 ~ ~~1 uJ»-...u.1 ~_;i,~,2
wlS'_;.>J 1u~b.>J 1~ , ~ .l....A i ~ w~ <i'1' [ ~~, c..!.L.J:j ~
~l~ly~ ~ .~1J4f1 y ~ ~ J c1i:p4J.I ~ ~»<i'11 ~~1
0t ~1.;-fo..i.J4J .~L.u~I ~ ~ 1 ~ r~ ~ t(J~ LJ:--A~ L:.JA
-
~ili ,¥}G..~1 «i:P~4» Who~..)-!):. ~UI J~'}/1 JIJJi ~~ -
~J...ul ~UI ~ ? J I ~ ~ ~UI ~?JI~.)~ wl._l7 i ,uo ~ ~,., ~
J-A c.ill~ <.J--A ~.JAJ . International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS)
wlc.~_,11., aa.!•coll a .!l:,o\tl wlc.~I ~J ~ wfi-uJ.1 wlPI ~ ~ 1
~ J:w:tl.1 '::T""L.u~I ~Llu.J i.S?-l OJ-A o.)_,...l\ U...99.!bi 111_? ~ .c.ill~ .PUJ ~w,
·[~, tl..G.
iJ-A.J.A (.)§.: ...L9 Lo aJ_,.) ~ ~w 0§.: ...L9 ~.:u1.,
.~41J o..# aJ.)i ,~ r..l.4i
J~)U ~~I wL.u.)WIJJ~~1.,~l.Z.ll .)_,..:;a.!.".!';.)y\+ui~ i.S?-i JJ.)~ i~
(.)L:, (.)J:~I ()~~I .;,,A~ .c.ill~ d..:t~ Lo_, \sii.!.,bi r-1..U:,I Ji <J..ulJ4f1 ~ J
.~.)~ ~~4,- Ll~ I~ ~ i , l.:U ·(.)J.).)w ~UI .)~'}11 Jl.)Jl ~~
~ I w~I _;~ ~J JUI <>"i_; o_;J..l ~J ~..ul ~..>J~ ~ [IJ_; l.!ll.LA
~_,.J~ ~w w l ~ J>b .4UI w ~ I ~I~ ~J r4}il ~J wbl..>:?/4
~ '"~ w\S~I wl ".!.!;; c.j\S ,u-,~IJ ~l_,.JI ~ I 4:I~ ~ (V""bw_,h.1.1
,I.JJ ·r4) 4:i ~..u ~ ~ ~ i 0L.«: «II! alo~ c.ill~J '~~ wbl..>:?JI
o A 0 ~ ~ 1 ~ i ~ ~ .~".!.!;;t~T..r4~cG~~l~lw,-k0ts
yJ-i: ~4 multiple of sales revenue o..l..Lull w~I wbl..>:?J ~~I '-="'-'""Lal
.«a.!\:oicc,11 r4}~/I» ~
o..l..Lull w~I wbl..>:1 r-~) ~ ;;..l:!IJJ.I l_,.c~IJ ~->-""'=' 0_,.c..lWI '4,Li ~J

~l..r4 ~l~J ~ W I ~I~~ I ~ ~ b ~ . . L i ~ ~IJ - - -
~ ,4l:J.I ~Ll.JI oA .0L.u~I oA ._# ~ l.!ll.:WT ~ji ~ts <?JIJ w4~1
~ ~l..,_1.1 ~ J ,as'~ 4UI ~l~I ~ wl.o...1->JI Ji w~I ~ J.:.:= IC(;
(>"Lui l.!ll.LAJ wl.o...1->JI Jl w~I ~ " : ? ~ I ~ ,t*11 _;l.t........c..ulJ ~I[~~
J i J.4A.l.J ~ [ ~L~.lL..... .u::i .-:q (.). ~"l'L
- 'J-W .... It . - _< ...\..a.l.JI ~
~ .!..9 c:::- ~
'"' Ji~
--It . ~ ,
(.) A.
f=
~ ~ I.
r'~ ~ ,Jl:J.I I.· - ··
~~
I... • Lll:J.I ."e..lWI
- '-' . ~(.)=!
· 1 ...u:; ~
•
-:fl ,LlL:u~I
'-?"'"'J -
~J~ J6. ~J .a.l.AWI 1.:?..J:"il _;_?.iJ ~ I u:l~ ~ wl_j-L&-U ~ 0 ~
ol.clJl c,!d t:-,__;b 0---4 ~ l ..J:~ ~"ii oA 0ts I~! Lo 0 ~ JIJ.--uJI ~ ,c.ill~
~~ l.!ll.LA0i Fl_,.JI oAJ • warranty repairs r~?JI c , l j ~ ~~b.JI
~ ~~ lfj <?JlS ,.,;_;,>-i "=.)~ wlk L..!u.J ~ji ~ <?JI ~~ I oA i..S..»- i
.wl~L:u.j?JI J ~ ~ ,.,;..ul
~ o_;b?JI <->">9 .J.Jy wbLl._;}'IJ D:il~IJ ~ W I i:p4J.I ~ JA~I _;~J

u-,-..>:..ul ,.,;..u wl_;4>- ":?i ~ o..l\.i, ~ as'~I ~ i _;bi o..l~ r'~_; "i4 ~~I
..1.d • bartering ~~ .. a\S~ · -~-ti ~ . ~~ ,Jl:J.I ~~
• 6.ti • ~
1. · - 1... • (): .. I
~
.A,~.~ .. e L,..,j • .. -t ... t;...:,. a)WI .r~~
"'='_) • <.>"..J-"'- r--"J . '-' :.lj • ~~l.!ll.LA · .• <.
~ ..>--'-" ~ - (.)~
":?_;4c=JI '->°__,...I.I~~ tfi l.!ll.LA 0~J ":?_;~I '->°~I ~~I~ 0)Lc.!
J..ll;JI oA t_,.al I~~ ~J .":?~ J..l'-:u ~~~LA.A . ~ I wlSl~I ~
'i~..ill ~.:,. ,oi ri c:H ":?_;~I
o..l..Lull w~I wbl..>:1 ~ ~~ 0.,_..tbJ.I ~ <?JI w\S~I 0i ~_;"ii oA

~ t:,k. o_;J.All w~I ~ _ ; " i i ~ ~ ~ ~ multiple of sales revenue
....: ' l • • - - . ~ ~ ~ _ . r 1/tc\~~~••,1·"'· .#,.,..•. SXL-....'-0'.~" r-.;...-..-.,._.- ----y-y,"(.-.£-·.'6"'"-____. _ , . . . . . . . _ _ , . . _ ~ ~ - · ~ •• .IUJ',,.o; --·x·- •"'-?"-·~ • , ·->-<•',' ;-,,_:,--°'",':~~·">~YY"l;'"_.._..,.,11,,_..",.-• .._.,.,,,... w-....-.a:
Y'VY' ~L:..:, 4Ua.9 ~ &$~1 Lo.9 ~..b,j faU :ul.J::&.al ~ ~l..w.4ll.9 4.4.J~I
A A.I ,r. (.'i [• [• :::h c_ c_ ,(; C)I ll L L f;-:~ A.I
,:, IL1... 1 - 1V\~· ::S j:: 'f, ~· I, I I ~ 1(. t'' •t I
r:"
,lr
hj::
~ C ~
,~I,
V }( I'
~
~ L
- I ~
,._
f;'°
• - -
•-1:- t
~ l~' •\, [ C• I , I
r
~ 1 ()t .. -· ~.. ~ , • 1.r') r:: a
.,. < ~1> ,c-" ~• - , - .t>
i.
·~ ,C-
fr,. ,
'
~ n-
'~.•!,
a c
a ~' ·~ b C• P.f
1· rr.l''
t; ._., O [, ~ • f; t°. <i. 'l
1:.:. "'O r.,· 1> • ~.,. c· ::s c· .~·
~.ks· ·Lhb ~
i;-- ·f • o C"i 1>
·• , re· ~ • ~ ~
t ~ ~ V\
9, ~... r, .E
c· ~
·<r. I:! t> t· c: "° ~
I;; fp, - •· }· . ' 3 - [, \~ C·
~• ~"' ~ ~ :i'~ C-;~ S:.. , n .c- '~_,. Ci·'
·f
f;. '\. I:! 1.,. V• 1 OQ • !:: br ! · . ~
f- fr_· t;_,._ -!:::21::. r.. V o<·
t
~ - . t: ~ . 0 ,. ' ' •
.,. ii ~· ~ _ -
I,. 00 [• i:.. ('f C C: I,
[J.~ ~c- r-}...-t Tb
[• (;
~~ ,c;i. ~ ~~ ;fr.
~ Cik"- t~ ~ ': ~ i- r.- ' c.. ~
[, ~· b C/.l"('i• I -
"°b c- t.' s= 'E C'"" ~·
16 }( tC .
gl r~ .( l r\ 't. ·L _:
t ::- ~ ~ f ·{ )t ~- i ~ :r. !,L .c
C· t I f .i 1 -~ \ i ·t: t c. ; . t. r t. t·
,. r· '--
~ ~ . _ ~·r.,._ • L.
9-- ·[ ' I • I-
.~ I, •
ii ' f. t'-
L ·E. I,
-
E 'br s ·r t~ \' 'f' T.£:
S:: - C· . - l ' . '-o - ('f - "
C· V\ ·~. . • ,C- •
- W"° 1::. - ' • ~ 1· c: - - _,. §i ~ - n'i;
h •
·~. ,' ~ - 0'· _,. . ~ ~ tC .y - c -
1·
f C, 'lj.. -~ b C. I, - .. n" •L
00 b '- 1c; 00 _,. 1
~ "° . ~ - ~Ii- ·~~ 'f.,., ~[. 'rt:. 1 r c-'\ ~f 1,° •~_ t-c '~[ V:1::.
• ::_ -
~r £ }
~ 1, I, - ' -
O • - - 'l_ - L r') ' ~ ~ 't> [r ~
t-' 1 G-.
l s l .. ~ <
0
~
·t.
Il ~
r~ ~f
I
1· l c... .~ ,c;- ·1· 'f. , ~6 I ii ~• ' '-o 0
~
f i,.
'-DI C.. c.. .
I
. g
_,_
~ ~I:! ~ ·~.I:: t [. i.~' , e·c-
C: _ I ~ • tC:- _, ~.
- C· ( C- [• f, ~ •G._ G"'" '\.,. ,r' 1:- t f,. r. l o f: ~.. .. ~ ,f:: t. ~ l
~ ir, b ~ S:: f- ·,~ t" £ [ [• ' C· f!'
~~ ~" cf. · . ~ ~
}e.. ,c;. ~ r.. c \; C c· f'.' ~· c.' ~· ,t' ~ :i 'e. '1- l. 1~ ·~ '
IS>'1 C 'J'
[• ~ P ~ ~ ,c; f\ f ~
·r · ,[
• \., ~ •l.: c .
t. • ~ 1' ·. 4! - ·~ ·c·. b .- ~ .~ r-·
.c- - e-• c-" ~ ~· ~. . r
~·V\ ~P t;,c-[• ·_'['
L. 6 \ • I J- .[." - C I [•
I:!. - C· [ 0 - •L
f C· [! C·
C- Ci_.
t r-~ r-~ ~.. 1~r. .[I: ~ f }(!c. r,·. 11 r.·.. l,: ~~ tI:. [~• ."t, _).
t1
- c.. ,r' - l, ' ('p, t> ~ t , ~ E
~ •Ls= ~· ·f ~~ ~- t- t t -('p, • :c- • { · [• · =" [•
l h s 'it t er ~ } e. } - '(.
f l t ~: ~ l ~ f ·f. ·1. c: , ~ e ·fi ·[
~ a 't
,... ff ~
~;&\ -~ :r,~ ~~ rb ,~~ ,c;~. l!- ';t ';tI - [. t - '1:! ~
I I I I - -
'i.
'° 1-! t
::S
- . - ,c;~. s· r. r~ ~· l-
- Er Lt -
~ ,t: 1· fl,, {i P: {i ~ c;: {i [• :t (r [• ·t... cf," ~ [• I;.: ~
0 I," I
I [• .r;- ~- '
·i. •<i_J:: f;"" ' f;"" f;"" ~ 1.. V .r;- ' r;- ~ ~
?.y T
I - I : I I I
.e-('
l l l ·t .~ l,r f f ~ 1\ ~ ~
· [ ~ fr·\
ft· ·L . \ tX [ t'' 't· .,. r.·
.f. t~ ~ .c -~~ ~..: l·~, -r: ~ ~ ·i..cl. rr; "r . ~. ·~[ ·[_ 1} ~.t 1·I r·~- N•.' {.
!. r 1.·,.!
i - {i _,. er f- ,f-' t,. . .. 1\ tX );
·t~ I tr,: t- l[ ~ ~ ~~ i· t 1.[ 1.{ <-~ tJ ~-~ f f'!:-l't ~~. ~~ ~~ t. ~· i
; :~ c, &\ ~ f;""
~t. .r, ,t-' f- 6 ~ ~ iA b • ~ ~ .f .c- rc: ['
i , V - I ·f ~ fl ·V ~ .r;- ' .. ~ t•· •<i_ & tX '
t. ,. er - t- II
81· E f" b 'e. {. i:: ~1.:
e f. Ci. l, - tX ,I: C: J-- - ';t '[c· '[c· [V\ m
f.J ;~ti. t ·r· l r;· { ~ i ·c,.. l, (~; r- \~ irr ~r (."();
·e.1 ~.,· · : •E'
r ·e.. a ~. [• -;t t ri: · i ·f - ~ ~ ! · ·_ C· C· ~. V· C ~ ~
c .. (· ~.
~ t { b c;-
,C- • - - 1r:- ' c_ • )• : . C· C· p
.·~~·~ ~·r .}! r· t. ~ 1"· ·i . J·~ :tc l t r~ ~. lt· t'( e.;•f ~..~ {' Ii
• ; ' ·i ,. '. t'~. ' r 1- ·~ -~ ' c· ~ G. ce, .'
·i .rt [ r €. Fi· 1. rc·.h t 0 t ~ 'r.- c. tr ft. -:
~ ; L~ fr: t;. le·
.r 1- ·Ii_. -
.c· r·\ :: l r s t r. !c 1 t r ~ Ci; ~- fl- C, ·c, r<' <; •• - 't. C, ;~
[ f E l 'k ,t ;~· ~- f; · -c~ ~ ~ - ~ { f t 1: f f: :-; ;~ (;: . f. ,t'. I c-
?. ·~ 1 C: \- i;- I-
i:; b, • ~ ~ C)I (• • ~ ~ '
~ Ii ..
1
l, .r,,~· n· T:.t- 1. ~r> 1 [
- " "t:I~ 0 1\
t - -~ .rE ·~ ~ .~ t-r, ",.
f{;"" c..,,=:- f' ~~·'L.,.,._
t: i \- I.. r> ~
r. ,. C·
q J-.~ J ~- }• ~), s: E; ~- 1 ,f, J• ( { } t: [ Ci. l t ~.! -( :c, ~.r. ~ I!, ,C·
l,· I r;. 'f; fil.
L· ,. • Q - "C)I \or, C) 1/\ ~ ~ ; • "' •
-~ • C:.. - I I r;- ~ b J-.; I e! '- _,. • ~ i/~.'
·lj.. ,
tIi [ -[ :_• ,.,.~ 1 t c.~f;, 0~ ~C· , • C·f
~ ' - 'i- r.t . L•
c. "{ ::, . • 'e. • ,c
C·
l,
,,.. C:
1· :
r l~. ft.E!: ~ '..if t -r.-~ _.Et l..c" _ ·f ~·g ·f :t~~ ~- ;r.l-_,. I:.: ... •
I-
f) } • . L '} ('I -
L
·~
~- ,c
!~ ~ ~ ·E . t ~ c~.. ~ ~ ~· Ci.} ·r . ~ ~ ·i. ~ :tr C· 1-:.

p.• - ~· n o.. ;E.. ;~ t>• 11 (' {
c-:. r \.t I~ lfi:- J ·[ ~- ·i. · ·:
,i:- V\ - !!!. -· - \D l, - (• [r '
'°[.' ·~-·~~ ,c;~·~ ~ t tX ..E , &' .
{ 1 ~ ·=-= . i t-~- 1 [ ~
- f;"" ·~. (D (l) "'· b - fil
{ (, t~ f ~ {~ 'f~: '°t i ~~ i ~. <rl,. ·c,.. •~•1.- f.~ I ~ ~ ~ ~
°E- \- - .1: ~ -
(S ,110°•l:,l~ul~_;Q~i ,11ll~~,~~lc4 .cGIJJ<J,.AJ....jlk'i'-:?.LJI
w~~I ~ ;;~\ ~ wlJ'-4:u-,'i~ ~_;-a.JI J.JA)U I ~ ufJ w4~ ~I~
.;;~\
~~I wblu'i
- 'J-'
bWI
•
:LA ~'i \s,;.,,.;~~wlu.J.IJbi ~;..;.,;~~
.....,-- C,- \ -· - - \....•
'5.;>i ~l..1.Ai ~ Ji ~l..ul .l~ J~'ilJ w~~I ii.ll:JJ 4WI ~I~

..,.;.i t!J <J.A \sQ ,o;., ~ ~ ~y wblY-f'I ~~1 ~,~I~ .'5..u.l ; ; ~
~~ ~~ '-:?.:UI ~ I J~ <J.A ;;J~ ~..i>JI "~~,Ill ·'5.;>l ~ Ji
. lA~.JA J_,b. ~ wblY-f'I ~ ~J
4tJI ;;~I <J.A 'i~ 4WI ;;~I ~ w~I wblY-1 ~ ~ w~ ~ -

~.ll..l.LL....u'il~i~lj,~ui~_;q~j crrll~~ .iiJ:~wl~llo
• I .r:l.b.;..i \A j;.lua,;., ~ j bb... _'\as'.~-~-'I u~
..<I.~ t!..fl ti •j
~ J !J-l .. J f::-'-".a-:lt
~ . ~ ~J
-
'.u---' .}J
~&.
~ I J -u~':/1 J ~ 4:tl~ J~ 4UI ~1~1 ~~ ~ Jl~~I "~ ~

~ ~ l ~ I ~ ~I wblY-f'I <J.A ~ J..1! ~i ~~~~I
~ . ~.,.t.b.11 wlo..G.JI <J.A _# ~bl r~ u-4 ~..,JI ~ b ta I .l.,..-WI <J.A J.>-.-bll
, 0 'il ~ ~4 ~ a_. «rriJ ~ ~.ljJ 'i lAjl~ <i'11 w~'il ul ,JULI~ ru
~ ,cil.:U a~ . lAj\..~1 ~ ~I a.:;;;;JI wl~I u-4 .l~ .l_?.J ~1 a.e~l
Ji wlo..G.JI ~bl ~\5::i ~ cil; ~J ,wblY-f'I ~ 0..D ~.l'-411 wl~I ~
.. - ..
. ww~I ~ ~~ ~ ~~ '-:?i ~bi
J~'il ~ JAl~I <J.A .l...L...C. ~J ~ 4UI ~ I ~ i c4 JWI ~ ~ J
j.u,lSJJ w4~1 ~l..>-4 wl~l~l, ~Li.A~ l.!.1.Jj ()AJ ,~I.) qj «rri ~
~UI ;;J~'il JIJJi ~ r~I r~J ~l~I r~ Ji w4~1 ~l.>A
~L....u,J ~liJJ wlJbf'I ~~J ~~I ii'i4,,o'iJ ~ W I ~l~I ~ J
ls-6- W~JbJ w ~ I ~J..l:>- L.'::' ;;~I J_,b:i Lo .)~J .l.!.1.Jj ~Ll, LoJ r)lc.f'I
.J_,b,JI .)~1 4:t~ ..ujJ
JIJJi ~ ~ wlJ-L'-" llo UJ-:!-'"U~I JbLi: '5lll ~_,JI~ ,JULI~~
~ ~ ~~ .l..?.J~J - ~ ..l:~~_,Jlu-41..u_j.A~UIJ~'il
.. --
~_,;...u ciJj ~ ~ Jil ~~ .l_?.JJ ~ ~w d...Jj <>° Jsl ~.>9J ~
~ ~~...) Q~j , • t 1~ J~ ~4 J.iJ.U j.lL.o..o .)~1 L>-4 ~ '-:?.:UI w , ~ I
~I~~ ,.. ,1 Qi .~,I ~I ~UI J ~ ~ I JIJJi ~~ ~ r~i u'il ~ J ~
~ , / ·a-·.-"?;7.,..'"3.,A:~·A,=o,;:;.,:,.- -,., .•,.. • ..,.:;;..t..-s-.. .4::"'.-.nvt"J. _,~..,.;:.-~~:,r~..,. .._ . -~ ......_.-,,;"ff'l.:_,,n,-.::::.:;:~~-.i..=.__.',t~+--·.,....._-;iA".;1111-"""~..-.";;W'."~·~--=-,R-.,¥.~~-e:;:,.~u--.,_.w:,d..._~ .v·• ·,
l.f:,~ 41.d ~ ~.:.JI LoJ i.:,..l>,j t::a\l : u ~ I ~ .:il.w.i.llJ 44.1~1 l"V"\

u'1b~JA . I ~ ~ LA~w,,,~0-4ps'i~~)ul.)'1J.J.....JI~~
.c;~1 r'Uc..iJI j.;p'-4..) J;..b ~ JljJ lA ~ ~jS' J-A~I ~ '1 <~~a.......1;~
J.ul4 ~~ lA ~ '1 ~I ~~I ul~~~ ~ I ~4JI ~ ~ , I.LJ
-~Wl~_,JI~
,~Wt2.c~t
~IJ 4UI uL..o..l>JI ~~ J ~ ~~~~I u'1WI 0-4 ..).J.....c. ~~
~J~Ul.)~'1IJl.)Ji~l~o~LiS'~..u_,~_µ1;;.)b?Jlc; •·,Q0 4,;,;;
.'iJJ& 4lA ul.)~I ~! '5..)l ~ ~ f".J.....c. _,t u4~1 ~IJ-4 ~ j i ~
ul.S'~ cPJ ~IJ ~l->--1u?JI _,t ¥1yJ.1 ~~I u~~I 0l -;,~I ~LUI 0-AJ
~b ~~..)~I Ji Jw?JI ~~~I~ D.)..)ll ~ f1 ~ I u ~ J
~L.uJ.)~I ~-;,~I 4Ul__;~1 w,,,_; 4~i,114U~ .ieJ .L~j..ll~I
. ~J-tAA ~~ ~~ ~~ ~ i ~J ''->~t ~l..~i r-~ r~ i~ ~~,
aI< .~. Q J-4&. ~)Le, r'~ ~ .)J..) ~l ~ , 111 I ubl.;:?JI J.p.. ~ ...L..a.J
0-4 ~~.)~I~~ .4UI ul-.-.uj.ll ~r'~ ~lll y.-u,Ll.1.1.;-t:i:. ~l~?JI
~ I L&J~~ ~ I u~j.ll ~J>9 ~ d.£14,ll ~l 0-4 .,~j ~.,.ti J.:>JI
0-4 ~_,JI ~J ~ I ~J • L+.t ~L;JI -;,~WI ubl.J--:!hiJ receivable assets
-
JS' 0i 'l'l 4UI u~j.ll ~ r'~ ~I J~}U -L-L.ui LA.)~4 ..)_,.ii.ll ~ i
-
u ~ ~ ~J: ..)~'14 ~~J ~ J ~ I ~ w4 ~~ ~ ~ ~jA
~\..,;.; 11,I D..)~! ~ '-".>J.J..Li ~ ~I ..)_,.ii.ll 0-4 ~ ~ ~~ .<'-'"'>pennies
.4lA ~jA JS'~ JUI 0-4 ~ ~ ..)~~ t~I r':'~ f"J: JS'~~
~li91 ~~I~ J ~ 4 <<J-Alllo:"JI)) ~~I~ ~ 1 ~ 1 Loi
0-4 ~~ ..lAl ~i r-~1 ~ ~i '.·: "'! ~J .w,,,y-,i ~~ ~~
f11=w
•w,Jy--1 ~~ ~!_;gl ~ ..lAl ~l.iA ~ ,0:...ul LJA ~~ .)_;--.1 J:,l- ~~
. c"'°
. :I"
.ti ~l.aj'i
~
~ 1 ~6..lL
• •
a.:»~'11 ~
·.< - . ~
- ~ c.r-
-::1-:.1t b '1 l..iAiJ
~ i 0 ~ u4~ ~IJ-AJ 0 ~ ~l.iA r-blA ~w tl...GJI 0~ ~-'"'""

lA ~..l:'J «~w» ~ I ; ,o; .~.J.4.i.JI ul..a..a.lJl..9..>:Pl~I ~IJ-4 0--4 '°1..l:' J.>--.bJI -
.)~I 01 .ul~l 0-4 ~ Jl_,l:, 0..)..1.LLA u'1b ~ 1...GS' ~ ~ ~ ~~
-.1...GS"~,~~w~~
--
~ ~ ~ . - . . i , , . ~.Y~";ll'<llo;N':t.'O.".".:h;.".,,-..,,~ ~ . - . . .~v.-..,..~'V;";t,'.:..:,v.-.~ ~n,t.J»,..... N~"9·~'"\", ,.'A' ................,,,,.,,-~·.,.,;.".;V~-!-C-Wt"... -,~··.. ····A••~-~.!l...
z.,(
Y'VV Lfj~ ~~!.?~I Loj ~..u,,,j l~U. :u\.J:a.al ~ .ll.w...illj 4.4.J~I

,#~Wl~I
t h-·/~ -~·· ; ;.:-: . • { P ~ ~ - -.~ ,','.I r:·.~r- . .~~d-a:z:11ilt·.tr., ,· ',lj~r:-,-'~~~:l!:0-,,:~ .,./., ~--.-, ·,, ./• '.:?A 1~•j;,.....r·:'E-::~~;17''~~i~}j.·:;l"li;i.;~ )}(1:!h"..:-~);,-{,.:..--.f·:,..q-fi'),'.j.-::q.~fl
(«J:!J..&.::J» iillj 0fi..}. ~) t.§~ ~.>9 ~~ ~ .J~'}JI ~ UJ_>1o Dl-AJ

1.. ··· , ... ,l..u...A~ · .. ~-:.q~ <"t
J t t.§.J L>.:i -.<"
. ..;-.)-A J t "'-..ll9 J i <.::r'-!-4
· J\:J.I ~ wr-- - - ~~ -~
~~I w,k ;;~WI t"-9-l ~ t w-4 ~ts:JI «JUI» ~..L...4i ~ ~~ • iillj ~~ Lo
~ t.§.:.UI ~~?11 «JUI» I.JA ,Jl_p-~1 ~ i ~ .~)l:; ..9i ~ ~LI.I ~j.4.U
,,~ ~ ~J ~~ ~UI ~~I .,t ~~\ ~~ WkA .;.l~ '}I ~1~1
~ ~ t.§.:.Ul..9 ~~?JI~~~~ '}I o.l~ .;;~WI ~.l ~l~I ~ ~~
Cc:~~ ,iill.:.U a=r_.:u .~LI.I ~?11 ~1..ui~ «deferred revenue ~jll A~?ll»
o.l'-:JJ «~jll .ll->:?11» uo.:ci;.~ ;;~WI ul.ol_µJ4 ~ ~ ~~ .,t ~ ~~I
~..ul Wll .,t r4.;~I Wll ~ .ll->:1 ~i w,k ;;~WI ~ ,11i ~ LS .«~..ul»
.>J-..9..G ~ ~J .jul4 ~.l>, iillj ~ . I~
- ~
~w ~t w,k ~LI.I ~ j l l ~ J
-~.l c.)l ~jll .ll->:?14 rl_µJ'}JI J.,~ .l_?.-_,l.l ..Hf!- JUI
ul.ol-.~t'}JL
'..r;' • ~-.:1.~q. _____AA·t\ ~I·
~.r w~~I ~ I ~~4
()A -
,... o'.) ...1.411 wt
· I ~I wr-- 4 -
(.)j-A ~ - ~l.°4 (J-4 ~ .:... ... ti":.~

t"'lt\ -- I,. J'··-~t\ I,.. • -· • ~I •It• \ •• t\
~ w,,-- ' . r - - w,,-- ~ DJ.JL4l.J ,;!.!!0'111
. ) ~ ~ , Jl.;Ji ~ .)J.l ,iillj ~ -0~ ~ ~ .lj)_,ll I.SJ: J:!~ ~ w-4 .,t

.c.'}JcLJiLS .a.,.u_q
~
-~l:i-"~l;;~\-:tl.J
- ~ ~ ,y-, -
..1.Ji · - · · - . .:.UI '?"tlJ.1
'J-" . ~ - ~_,., u ~ W:!
J->:P-i • L&Jb. w,k ~La.a.JI «·1.:a! \jl ~.:.. ,11ll u~l~'}Jl..9 u~l.uJI ~ ~ I
0 ~ ~~ ii.J-?-t.§j ~..u ~ 0:.:.UI u4~1 ~I.J-A .l_?._,l o.;~ i.!J~
. ..J.Ai.JI y ~ ab~ 0J ·.: b; cc1. '}I ~ ~J .l.l_;3 0J.l ~ I rll.Jl~
J~~4~_,:iJ6. ~ ~~~J ~L.u~I ~ o.lJ.LLA i.;y.o i.!ll.i.Aui LS

~LI.I .)~'}JI Jl.;..9i ~r~' r~
.,t J-,~.,0)-1.1 ~ I iillj<.J,AJ ~~I
~ ~1~?11 ~ J u4~1 ~1.J-A i.S..11 ~ ' } J I ~ rl.,ujlJ ~.;~I _,t
~ J ulS'~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ,Jl:"J.I ~ ~ -~~I o.;bl ~ i.S~
.~..111 ;;..,_;..u.o ~,~ ~..u ~Lu~~ ~ll.l ~ ..J.Ai.JI J.,~ lA.;J~ r~ ~.,
Jy.o~4 ~ I ~~I~ J~'}JI u'}Jb. ~ l ~ d.li:i~ o.l'-:) i.!J~
4UI ~l~I ..9l r4.;~I Ji ~...ul ~ljg ~ ubl->=?11 ..di~ J.:-7= ·rriJ i~ ~ I
d.:o.:o> ~,t · ... :It~ lt"'t,~~-t, .)J~~.,-A~J
- - - JI~~~~~ •t - • I 1.:._tl (_ I ( ' - \ •
·ri..:.u-d.:.:· ·-,,
sire
~ j i ~ Li.A_, ·c.>")u?ll ~~ ,~l.b.1.1 ~~ ~ ..14.tll ~ Lo~., - ~

~ 0J; q~i 1111 I~ J 0Lo~I u ~ c.:.J.b.a:; ...1.41 ·c.>"WI w-4 ;;~ ~~ rJlll
-~~
~~..:uu ecnm_.:..m~~....,.....---=---=~:o:,._~...,_---
~~ 4.1.d ~ t$~1 l.oJ i!I~ ljU : u ~ I ~ ~l.w.altg 4.4.1~1 Y'VA
~ ("() • , t1 p ,C·
t. ~.. •G , [r ~ f"' •Ci_ ~ .- ~. ~ <t 1· [• ~
>
F
l
•t" f.
I,•
<t,
~
'C; E c,
V\
~ V 'b
f -
r.I•
EI ~ 'f>. '!»·
- E:. I~ [1
t
•
Ji.
t'
tr
'f\ 1 l,•
IA ,T
I
~i• [ ~ b [1 C.• ,t' I~ i:: •r.: t lfr.' •~ ,f, ~ }cl' df

r -t :t
' •· -; ~ ' l, ~ ~ r;, J:: · "~ ' ,. ' . ~·
r[•· k- '<C·i.• ,. "~ ,c~ {t
i '\ i.. ~ - ~ .~ H 'c.. ~ ':t ~ f ' •f;; ~· v ~ ~·
-~\\ ~· ~ ~· £:_
~ "r. 1.-, ~ ·l.! '. ~
~. A' i
J.. ~ f.., • C
·tJ:: ''( ~ l !
·Y {:! (1) ' •L
t= . -
~ ~I:!, "'O
Ij t; ~V
r; :~ 1· fb"[ t-; ~ ;· Et·
I .~· l· _._ ~· \~. ~ ·r. Q_ 't 'L. §. 'l.! lE
r ., ._ ~i - - "
£.i [. \ 't ,t ~ b,t ~ ·i. e: g . [ f - ~ fj,- 1 <e:. ~ 1 t t.
.Fl c· E, ,t' 1
't. ~· ti "'O fi:- (1) I!' E:. ~
' r,.! '1· f §" r.r,.!' ' C• -:- ~
r.~ i f l(r- 'i g g
c...1 t• t ,en' ~l!' ~ t
.1 ·~ -• cn - ..... ,. _,. ' C b C
11' '1!r,.! ~~ -
r.1 C • I ' ' -
~ "<. • • ' r., _ •1 0-·
' I . _,. • - I....· - C·
11 rrr t r c: t er: [ · ~ .r.11 1· 1 .[:". :[ i
•~ I C· ~.
.~ •I:.
r· -:. t ..tr
~ " ' ti ' ~ ~ · . _t
E:; f
,r' i:: -:- r; - 1bi~1 i C
c" - 1 E:; !Ef-' -~ { C... C· (• '~ f.., - - r V\ t - b J
~~ 1. 1: fi l ~tr fj,- -t I ~ r J· ~
t.
~. (' . [. ' •f:. r..! (") I,'
t= ,. f 'G, I,
'"' • ...
[
ii' ..
• E..
f i 1 · . l·_: ..t' ·ft>t. t-: r.f. ~ ~= 1 ~- [~ ~f- t f r. ~t f'V'. .e-i I!.
.~ [ ·t ~ .r c <t ('D .11 - 1 ·t.. .
f - I • \\ ~ tr - C. [s
1 - ~ 1'· £. .. "'Cj • ( . t r ~• b ('i '
11c, I
YE·· [ ·G.. I
.I
lt f
- c;' (;: {:! :,I
l_!! ·~.r... ·~i:: ~r.· tV\ r~ . a.= i:: 1 t ! J,.~ •. if. ·i.~· rl 1e;t· ir;.·_,.
t.C t.C - - (IQ ' "<.
1, ( - ~ "'t= ~·- . -,. lr ~ ,en · - ' t £ ~ fg.t
t t t Cl)
r1
'\. t t~ V. 'f . =t !! l I .
.,.
.f"' i- 'J· ~ -q ~ E:. V\ r - - -· ~" i~ ..: I;c, l ~·f;. \t I,tr ~ -r.~ '<j.. , ~
t
~
~ l:: f' ; , .r! C· _ j:"" t' lE ~ 1,° , ·~ ~ fj,- ;tr t &_ l '° f\. 1- \,. f. 1
0
1
$' I
·t 1 - lo
_t
t'
,
,.
r·•[ f= 1'· ,tr 1c' 1-C·.c-" ,~·t: 'f!~ f . . C·,.f lrt.6C ·1 ~f:: .r·[ --~ ~r· i=~ 1 [ .1- ri~ c ~~ nt
tS' ,c t ~ ,
r:. • " ,c
r..! ,t' ~· I
1:.
r E .6· ..c
C
., ~·
Cl)
'-" - -
lo
:
f ~
t
- ~
~ ~~I J,w:wll
r.'7~~.-~ .. ~ . ~::i::::c:c:::s::z:::r=:::~~:"'".-~~.:r:~ ' .· ~ ~ ~ ~ ; \ ; ; : > L - A · I ' · \ · · . ! ' , ( ·-:v . · ·' ·.~-~-..·::'. -;,''.;",ii:'./~ ...1·,q
,~;..it ut.w.~
.(Rosen and Rosen, 2010) ~ I ~~I d..:lUI i.:..,l.)~~4 Wl:9 ~ t_>lb)U (')
[J.J> Jl J_p,,..) ~ ')] 1.§.L.ll ¥' «secondary securities» 1.§.,._:,t:JI J ~ I (Y)
~ uJ.r?-l:alJ .<.)UI .Jw:L.u')]I JI.JJi ~~I~~ ~WL-~1 Jlys~I
.. - ,,. .. C.
,~l.Zll ~Ll,l.A ~..)\..u.o o..)~ fA ~ o.J.lL.c:JI ~UI JI.JJ)U ":?j,\:JI J_,_JI

. .ll>9~IJ I.Ll~I .Jw:L.u')]I ~..)\..u.o
,~_,:wt ull»-~
~L.;Jl..9 rWI u,;c.~I ~ ~l~I ~ deregulation ~l~l ..>J~ ~ Ci)
<>'°~I~~ ~l~l..>J~J . ~ I ~~..90~~0.)~~1 ~.)~ ~
~~l.l.4>..9 .~l~f.:Ja qt;,;Jl~~<i'1l~l.,.Ul..9~f.:Jl..9~l~I
:~I .d..:!-4_µ1 ~l~I <>'° ~L.;JI t~I ~ JAJ ~l_j,411..>J~ ~ i
'-41j.l l..9 . http://wordnetweb .princeton .edu/perl/webwn ?s=deregulation
y~f.:JI J>.iJ,A~l~l..>J~<>'°t~I I.JAwi~!~ ~Lfi~~
wl~I ~ 4:-lWI 4UI Jl.,......._f.:J4 ,-.:.,oc <i'11 4UI d.Ajf.:JI ~l.;..9 0~4.ll
.~Ul~I
J..91.:JI ~ I <),Acci»~.)~µ1 ~_,.I.I ~l.?.'~~~I ah)U~I CY)
.y~I <>'°
w\bb;.o ~ a ;\.;11..9 ~l:'JI ~I~ ccr» ~ J uuj.l.l ah}lo~I Cw)
.Ponzi frauds 4~'il ..9i ~WI ~_j:J~
~ ~ I J ~ I ~1 self dealing a.: ,o~I 4UI u}lol.:JI ~ ~ C6)
~ ~ . ; ~ 41 ~Ji ~.:iJI ..>:..u.1 ..9l ulo_,.J.I ~ <>'° 4UI w~l.:JI
-
<>'° 'i~ ~ I 4UI a.:,o;. .~.JI cL,,J~ ~l.;..9 -~ c:WJA J ~ 4 rllJ
t~.,.11 I.JA J.?- ..u_J..J.1..9 . ~ tLl...u4 r'j.:i.11 <i'11 ~I~~ r'~'il
. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-dealing ~I
related party transactions \.fl ~~I ~.;WI c4 4UI u}lol.:J4 ~ Cd
".JA ~ ~ \ , ; . a l ~ ~-->3 ~ j ..9i ~fa LJ::' ~ ~~ .)_?.J _j---A
a_;i_,:,WI d..:P-WI <>'° Jo.d ~ 0JAJlo ~L;JI ~)WI ".JA ybu.oi..9 .~)WI
~~I y~f.:J ~>WI~~ (~)/4 ~>l,;..f.:JI '4>-WI <>'° ~i ~
.4UI w)\Al.:JI dJl~..9 ~~ 0~
~.)~ ~I w~~I publicly-owned companies d.AWI w~~4 ~ Cd
~WI ..9i ~L;JI ~~I~~ ~~J o,c,WI d..4~ '&qs ,ui ~ ~
. ~I \.,s:i.;bl ~ 0~-..9 0 ~ .)l_;gl ..9l .).>9 ~ <i'11
ua-.:,. .~. d.1..9~ i~ ~i,ll ~ J.e.c, JA pyramid trickery <:?"4.)411 J ~ 'ii Ct)
0i ~ LJ:L4 F Ji 4.£.L..u ~1~ fA~ tL.a! ~~f.:JI <>'° .)J~ .)~ .,t
~ ~ ; ' ! ; " t ; e _ ~ ,...~.-;Jt~ •...,..'1--";~.-.....-..y"-"~"-'_,..,'·~w,,-.,,_._.•• ~~~~.-A/CAi>~~~V.t/Y_._~,..,.y,-~...,~~-~"-'~ -~"'"•"•·_. .. . _ ..,..,.,., •...•";;u;.v..-:.°""'Uo'"-"•··~"W'-.-._,N1$T~
Y'A, ~~A.I.as~ 'i?~I l.oJ ~~ fall. : u ~ t '?9 ~L..a.illJ 1-w~I

~~UJl~I
~~~~-~r72:@i·=.;ie;~·r·t ..),~.~:~·'.."-:-,:-·,=.-.'.:;, .. ···ttt·Y-~""=iA . ~-·-J..= . :,: 1~ ~ - - i i + \ 1 . , ... _.,.~.~..x.r:.l.-,).!-hJ,,··:"fv~( .. 1@J~1t. . ·!
.)~ .)\~ 0t ~1 u'i~ J.,UA j:.1~4 ~~t ~1>1oi tlish, ~i j:.'ij.A r~

u ~ u.lbjl WS'J ·r>fll ~ ~ j:.~IJ ~I u ~ ~ <).?_;~I
u'i~~r>fll~i~0fi~l~J~~'0.At_,l.ll l.J.A~~l~'il
~ j o_;~ ~IJ j:.l~I u ~ ~ jA\5 _;~I ~lJ-4~1 ~ ~ ~i
:~I I.ill~ Jy,- ..u_j..4.1.1 -~l._9.A~ j:.~I
http://wordnetweb.princeton.edu/perl/webwn ?s=pyramid%20scheme.
_;~I J~>ll ~i ~~pyramid schemes ~J-&11 ~bll u\ bb;. ti (.))
.(·) - ~WI
r ~J •
~>Lll ':T. cl.Ji
-
~1 «non-arms length transactions alai ,1111 ~ u)Lo~I» ~~ (~)
l.il.J~J ,J~I ~ ~ ~~~i Ji~.;!,~ j:.l~IJ ~I u ~
~ u)Lol..:tll d..l:&.Ai <JAJ .l.il.J~~Jl ¥~Ji ~~I Ji a.!,o~ul_;~'i
http://~! .J~I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ cJ:i.A _;l4..l ~.J.ll.,_JI ~ ~ I
y4--i ~t 0~ JlJ .en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arm's_length_principle
. L ~ o.J-tfi ~I~ t:9.l ~ J-A J~I ~~~~~I
~ u)l:;lJ::. Jl .ll~i ~ <i'1' ~ ~L.;J\ ul5~10i ~1 Ll.A ulj.11 .).!'~'- {_;)
• 'A~·-·
~
u)l:;lJ::. J i (..)"° ~ t <.;--
,... 1 A-:
"'&'.)
bl~J i I A~.<'L
~~
--- 'i LL.JI ul5·~
_:._t\
J~IJ crlA__w'il ~ ~ ul5~1 ~l <( ~L-«, ~L.;JI ul5~4» .)~I (j)

.4UI Jl_;J~I J-'"'"" ~ JJl-"1.J b ~ LlJ::. ul5~
Ji «dot com rt5 ul.J.ll» ~ ~1 J ~ ~I~ ulAfa-1.1 ~.,J~ ~\.d (u-1')
u ~ I J.i~ ~I"~~ .)~'ii a.b.J-4~J ~~I ~ I ~\.d
~» ~t.w, ~1~ ~\5 ...LIJ ·r4.;~I ~ 0 ~ ~ , J ~.) ~~1 0_;.)
<i'11J ClLl,WI t-1..)~I <JA o~ .ll~i o~ u ~ LA~ ul.!i.!• «11ill ul:~
er~~ business model ~..;JI~~~~ ~ I J o_;~ ~1~ L&#,i 0\5
~Lj.JI ~.J.l 0 ~ ~~ o_;~ ~ J ~ I J,A L+o~I ~ 0l5J J~~,
~ i ~.;1,J 0->~I 0.A~l__,.:a'i4 t-1..)LlJ.1 ~ ~ll ·¥..9-'-" ~ J
~\5 <i'11 t-1..)~I ~~ 01 ~ -~~ ~)UI (-.;;;;.,.._g rWI y~>l}
~.t-"~1
~
.. t11A• ~
t:-t...,.. -- '-:?'*'~,1~-'-"'A-
'"(:t:' ~ J.A ~ - .'.) 6.~
,-,~~
•<' .... • ~- ~
-
"(P."
;$ -
a.,.._L.?: ,oll ul-._;WI 0 ~ 1 ~JJ -~J.A ~1 ul_;l:)JI .)~ ~ ..u.J.: ~I

-l:~-J ~-'"'""-'"4 :_;...Li.All .((~ ~)Lo l ~ J -~4,. t-1..)LlJ.I ~ -
-·----A-~-----
~~~~1$~1L4J~..L:lillfaU :u~l~.:.~IJ'-4J~I
------ _.. ,_ _ __.. 1"A'f
'46., ~ f1 w'i6.. _,i ~I.?. cold cases a.Jo~l l:~I Ji w'iWI ~ (~)
wlo-i _1-,-- - ..•) ~
t!. J6... ~ ~Ll.>JI " ! . ' ! - ~ I t ~
~~ • ~
" -~ ~
. ~ 'Lu
~~J ~~ ~ ~
a ;;~
•. L.
·t~.,11 Jy,- ~.?-j a.l.li ~ Ji w ~ I ~l.>A Ji .l~I J.,_>1o ~ ;;-'::?~
. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_case ~ I
.'-:?..1.ASJI .J'iJ...ul 0---4 (' • •;, ) a:J.10-4 ~,., '-:?..1.ASJI penny ~ I '-:?J~ (~)
J LA .JA ;;.) 4--JI 0-4 ..).,.,~41.IJ . 1..P~ Jl:J , , '"\ ~_,.;;:; I.SJ~ 1.G..l..iSJI .)'iJ...U IJ
- - ....
.,~~
~
~ ~ ' l l , ; ~ ! l . - - . l ( " ~ ~ ~ . ~ " " " - - - a l l l l L - . . . W..... -~-.#......,...__,,""""',·-.'9illlll~Wc·•--.~·~ot-~ft"W\-->1#'¥,C.._"6'#9_~•.·.--·,A·~~,~
Y'A'(' l.f:J~ 4.1..as ~ '?.:i.tl Lo.9 Q ~ ljU ;ul.Ja:ill ~ ~~l.9 41~1

.~lb.JI ~1-"4 w,-o ,~l.ia_,JI cilll ~ cY. ~ cY. cilll ~ • .) -
,;a ..d~~ ;a.! 4 l,tt u~}4rt

-~JLl.11 '=' Q.!t:, jjJI t~ -:11 ~ ~b.w,j -
-~.JA~I o~I c.:.i~-:1_,JL:, ~_j,:I L..o4,. w,-o '=7Q.:loiiJI t~-:11 ~ ~ olJjAS'.) -
.a...s:..,
.. -!)A
~I o~I c.:.il.J';a'.tl.,
.. .!J".[~
.. a....o6..0A
· ~
.... I Ly~':a'1
. - _'\~..~ LA-
... 1....
r
-~~4 .)~ dill au~ ~~~n aL.ulJ..ul ~ oA t~~, ~ ~ o,u_,.a...)y~ -
,;a ..s..J,t~ ;a ..d.-l't u ~ t
~_;JI .}5..,.14 4.AWI oJb?JI ~ .;-t~ ~JJ i!J~I jS'..,.1 lA~ IJ:!.!-4 ~ -
.4.AWI oJb?JI ~
.~ a;~,;11
• a..J..JI
.. ~• , ~.)J
~ a.ow,;;'.) b-:11 . h' _,.t, ~
• ~~ . -'-tt ~
· -
.LWI ;;Jb?JI ~ i!J~I ~ ~ J -
.4.AWI oJbf'I ~ ~ I J.>:9J w~I w,-o ~..LA.JI ~ J a......,~J ~ ~JLl, -
-~.JA-:11 ;;~I c.:.i~-:1_,JI ~J ~ I J>b ~ I c.:.iUb.JI w,-o .)..u:, ~ ~JLl, -
"" "' A '

i4 ~.tt:a.!~·ttu~~t
. "'il~U1 ~.<- 1
~ ~I~ ii j_JI
.. ..,---, 1;;· w :L..Jol .. "'"· .. tf'
.. ~~ '-l~
· ~.J-l.. -
..A, HA 4-AWI ;;Jb?}I .J.SAA ,i!J~I J5JA c.:.ilj_~ ·w~J ~ . .). i ~ti
~J..ul ~j..JJ L..1.4.4 ~ ;(gJJ. "as.;-J_I ;;JbU ~l~~I" wl~ ~ ~ i - -
.A,
tr· ;;~1 J~ ,,-,r ~l:u-J' ,~bf'I ~
OJb?JI .l.fLA ,LWI ;;Jbf'I ~J.) ,"wJ...u;.IY.I ~.)~,~ti wl~ ~ ..u:.l- -
·rY·, ·~,A, tr, Jl_,1u :t:tl_;-11 .)..LA.JI ,0~1 ~ ' .4.AWI
~ ~ < i ~ J ~ ~ L A :~l_;.l~l~IJJw"ul_~~~i- -
Beyond Weberian Bureaucracy: Max .(L~f'I L.ill4) . ~,_;g~I
L..o4,. ,~~ -:11 r.,_w, .
~ Weber on Bureaucracy and his Critics
·rY·' • ,r .)..LA.JI ,rA ~ I .~_fill
Y"AO
~6. a.kA. "a.Joi~~
. . -
-,£ · • ·t\ . · -~LA 4.J~
<r~i..>-
. · h. •. a..:.b · I · -~. ..1J:.i -
- D.lL:.I"" u~
J..9~1 .l..u.11 , ~ 0,AG!I _;\.J..&..o?Jl .~~?JI r.,Wl..9 yb~I :j.J_j.All~ d..J.1.1
....A, tn
:wl~ .l~I ~ (~'}]\ a.iU4) ~ a:s.;..9 ("~ -
Corruption and Self-Conflict: A Sociological Approach.
2012 International Conference on Government, Law and Culture.
Hong Kong, January 5-7, 2012.
-~'~~,()A l.l..lJ:. c>:-'.Jj ~.>3 -
fl
s~t~_;..J't
·r' C\A y r~ '11Jy~ ~'iJ LA4,. ,"-.AWi ~L.u~I J:.6.:i ~ "IJ_,:-6'.) -
s~loJt~t
,~b?JI r.,_J...JIJ .)~'ii ~ ,'11J-O~I ~4,. ,LWI oJb?JI ~ ~~t -
. 0.)J ~ I "ld
.~t-1
.(r' C\Ao ,~.,JI .)b ,~.)) ob~I ~ ~ I J:bujl ~L.ut _,
:~b?JI r~ ~..;--JI ~ I :0~) ~~I ,~IJ!;WI J:.6.:i :~_.)LlJ.I r.!.!iii -Y
·(r' C\A1 ,~L.ulJ...UIJ ~~I oJbf
~)L.u?JI <::r..;---11 c.sl~l..9o~W.I ~~I o-4 ~_jAJ~..,>-t,ll OJb?Jl~o.)~1-'f'
·(r, C\AV ~L.ul.).JJIJ ~~I OJbl ,~b':11 r~ ~..,>-t,11 ~ I :0~)
~~I oJLll ,~b?JI ~ ~..,>-t,11 ~ I :o.JAWI) ~->~I ~.!.!oi..9 oJbl -t
·(rY• •'f' ,~L.ulJ...UIJ
,~)L.u?JI ~ I LWI oJl.:i':11,~l:i.JI ~ I ,~)L.u?JI ~..,>-t,11 oJl.:i?JI ~""'""_j-4-0
·r"· •t ,~b?JI ~ ~J-Lfl ~ I

~.
.~ . . -.tt-u
~ I ,oJb~ ~ I ~ I ,o~I J~~I tlld! ~~~~I .)J.) _,

• ' ' C\-C\ C\ ~ ~ 'f' C\Ao ~J ,~l:i.JI .).J.AJI 't-'tJI
~ ' ,oJb~ ~..,>-t,11 ~ I ,oJb?/1 ~ ~ ' J:bujl J:iii c4J ~~ -Y I
. T'A-, • ~ ~ 't'°'-A1 ~~ ,J..9~1 .)..all ,y.,:uWI
't'AV
QjJ ;, ·,·, 1·. ~ ,,.) ·,! 1 :: 1:;:r·,; '..=;·,,.,:..-........ !.I ,,. ...~·-:·.~ 1.:--;:·.~: '.,·;.-:·., .·, ..) ·;:-==-·~h·; ·-'·l ( 1·~_,.-.,-; ;,~·=i•t:,,, . . . =;.;_.,- ~··· =.•. .-~ .,( ,:; (\1:-~.·-.1 ·,,i' =:, ; =. ··. , ~--· 1 ( ,_. , ... ,.: • ··., (: ,·.-•.-~, ?,:, ·, '·.J ::=.... ~ ::.~ :,· ·: :-·· :. ~-;,~;-.•·:,: ~--~~·:,}-:-::- 1.1; ·i.:· ' .;:·.-~ .,....- ·,· ~: 1 Y·.J "i; '· ·. '.,:.'..- J·1 ·:; ~-~·· ·~·:·/.'~ ,. · ='· ;=.=/ '.\··'.; = 12@
,~~?11 a.J..9..ul ~ ~\.,;JI t~I ~ i ~ J ,b.!b;..J ~ LµI J;...13 -r

.l~I ,~l:&JI ~ I ,~~"il..9 ~~?JI r#I ~ ,i.!l-'"4~1 i!:J~i ~
. \ "\A-\ U ~ ~ 'r' \ \AV J_,'il
~I ~4- ~ ,o~WI ~w~I c)A cuS-'"4J ~6:.U (?4~?11 .J.~I -t
·(r'°'A°' /-AH·\) \·-"\Y ~~('<+') ~l.l?JI r#' ,, r ,.l~
"the Islamic External Critics of Public Administration The American. -o
Journal Oflslamic Social Sciences, Vol. 2. 1, July 1985, PP. 105-114.
"Human Nature and Motivation In Islam," The Islamic Quarterly, Vol, -"\
XXZX, No. 3. Third Quarter, 1985, PP. 148-164.
~ I ,O"\ .l~I ,~WI oJb?ll , ~ I .lJl_,.1.1 o.Jb?l (?4~?11 J ~ I -V
• \\•-\"\\ ~~ 'r'\\AV ~ . l ,-A\ t•Ay,,-'il ~J ,0~l..9 ~WI
r#I ~ ,u.l-'"4~1 i!:J~i ~ '':?Jb?JI ~ I i:P4l (?4~?11 JµI -A
.\o-"\\ ~ ~ 'r'\C\AA ,Y .l..wl ,t ~ I ,~~"il..9 ~~?JI
'':?Jb?ll ' ~ ~ I ~ ~~~I u.J_,L.u ~ ~_,L.ut : ~ ~ , ~4!.l -C\
. wt-,rv ~~ 't'°'Av ~~ ,n-r· .l..wl ,a.....a.,,ttl1 ~ I
~ I ,~~?JI a.J..9..ul ~ ~ I o.Jb?Jl..9 ~.JS.;J.I o.Jb?ll ~ a.....,:g)WI -\ •
•V•-t C\ ~ ~ 't \ C\AA ~J ,~l:&11 .l~I , ~ ~l:&JI ~ I ,o.Jb~ ~~I
,a...........:,Jla.4"-'-ulJ.l :4....--AWI o.Jb?JI ~ ~l:!__,.ll ~_,.Jl..9~~?11.JµI-\ \
\Ao-, to~~(') a...._____,...Jl.l?ll r#I r f" , . l ~ ~, La..o4,. a \7=4
·(r' °' °' ' I -AH " )

.l..WI ,4=A~?ll ~4,JI '<:?"°~?JI ':?Jb?Jl~I ~ LWI ~UI o.Jb! ~ -\Y
. A1-1 r ~ °' °'. -AH, • , rr r,
~~jll ~Uo_, ~ ~ I ~ I Ulb.JI ~ o.ll:.} a ,114,u, ~~ -,r
:c.Jl:&11 .l..wl , ~ b4,. ,.l~"il..9 o.Jb?JI a .!'' , ~ I ~ I ,4.._,4WI
. , r -C\ r ~ ~ 't, °' °' r -A, t, r
~fi.>JI tl.Wll ~ a..LoWI l.GJ-411 ~ ~~ l$..LAJ ~ I oi.;J.1 JJ.l -\ t
t:tl->11 .l..wl , ~ La..o4,. ,.l~"il..9 o.;l.l?JI a .!IS' , ~ I ~ I ' ' : ? ~ '
. YAt-YY\ ~ ~ 'F"' °'°''"'I-AH H
Y'M
u~~'jl ~ ~ . ? ,~a....____JJ.)~ ~I;;_.,!.)~ y_,b~~.J.411 ~~1-, o
. t w-rA' ~ u.o 'r"' 0..0..o ',A .)..WI'~ 4-LA4', '~~~I r#IJ
~ ~I ;;_.,b'jl ~yi lS...U ~~I ~j..tll L..ul_.,.) : J ~ ~ 4 ;;_.,b'jl _,,
~~'jl r#I a\ ,ulru ,c.ilyi.;,:Jl l!J~l w.))11 '~..>! ~ b 'f"WI tlW.11
.tr-0.. ~u.o 't'0..0..1 ,t .).,wl ,H ~1,~~~IJ
..<- ti LylW.J1.r..:r-
'-?"4~ -~ ~U;.tl .. L-:-:.)~ ~~bj ~
._,.. ~ -- :~U;.tl ... L - -W
._,.. ~..,.,
~ ~ 'f", 0.. O..o J}il .).J.AJ1 , ~ o>L..,JI ~ I ,;;_.,b~ ~_yJI ~ I ,~~1
• , 0..A-HO..
~~1 .)~1..>.)la..:J.~b'jl ~4,bt ~1_.,~ ~~1 a-.ul_.,.) :~I.)~! -'A
,(~b'jl r#I ) .)~ c.ill.J.I 4.a.44', ~ '0.).) \JI JW u ~ b u\.!,; .~.j 4 C Cl
~ ) .rrr-r·, u.o~(r'o..o..v / ...AHW )~~I ,~l:'J1 .).J.AJI ,o.. ~1

-(~i~c.il~
~~.J.A ~1_.,~ ~1..l:!A a-.u1_.,.) : u ~ 1 J>. ~ <.J,J~.J..Jl a.! ,.,,;;ti c.bLu\11 _, o..
, r .).J.AJ1 ,rv ~1,;yw1 ;;_.,b'jl ,0 .)_.,\11,~_.,1 ~ b ~ d..:!,Afi>..11 ul_.,b'jl
·(..»-i ~ c.il~ ~ ) • roo..-nv ~ ~ (r'°'o..v / -AH ,A) u=o~I
~ J..,~ ~ I u ~ ~JJ lS.J.A J.,=,- <.J,J~.J.11 ~b~ ~I~ a..u1_.,.) :J..,~1 ~~ -r •
.)..WI ,rA ~ I LWI ;;_.,b'j1 ,0 .)_.,\11 ~ J~1 u~L::.J. d..:!,Afi>JI ;;~\11
.(~i ~ c.il~ ~ ) .rv,-rro ~ ~ (r'O..O..A / .A' UO..) ~~1,r
L..ul_.,.) :~.)_.,\11 ~fi.=,JI ;;~\11 ~~1 J..,~_.,_,bJJ>.1.JA~lS...L....4-n
c.ill.J.1 4.a.44', ~ , J ~ I ~1 u ~ b ~ ()..UAW1 <.J,J~...u.1 w,k. ~1~
·(r r • • o.. /.A, tr·) , rA-Ao o.o ~, 't n r ,;;_.,b'j1J .)~~, :j.J_j.&31 ~
-(~i ~ c.il~ ~ )
Nairn Nusaie, The Impact of Transformational Leadership style on - n
Innovation As Perceived By Public Employees in Jordan, International
Journal of Commerce and Management, volume 22 issue 3, 2012.
-~~~~-~ .. , . , : - : q - r ~~
~~ L\a.9 ~ ':f~I Lo..91!1~ fall : u ~ l '?9 ~LwM1llJ LQ.J~I

.)~ ':11_, d..AWI ;;.)bf'I ~ ~~ ~IJ ~ I J~
C:.,J..) ;;.)~ ~l.:t ~ o..)~1 _,f ybS:.11 I.J.Ai <J-4 t:-~ <>"~I
~ I <>"~':JI c.:.i ':116. ~ ':11! ~ I <J-4 ~l:iS' a.al.J-4
-.)~I fij Y.P."J f::AJ , ~ I J J.4.i.JI ~~
,'
I
·"
u~
~ 4JoJ [. I_,.;..
-A' t'r1 - lAWI D.Jbtll ~ ~ I J ~4,bll lAWI D.Jb?ll
IHIIIIHllllllll~I III
* 9 9 6 0 1 4 2 3 5 3 *

الجريمة والفساد في المنظمات لماذا تحدث وما الذي يجب فعله بشأنها♦

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

الجريمة والفساد في المنظمات لماذا تحدث وما الذي يجب فعله بشأنها♦

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

..

. [ .JJ \.jJ.) '~.>=:'

w.JA~IJ ~~I -Y ~.;btll .l~I -\

Why It Occurs and What To Do

© Ronald J. Burke, Edward C. Tomlinson and Cary L. Cooper 2011

C\ ............................................................................................................................ JJl~L:, Wti

yy .............................................................................................................................. ~.;.:..LI a.o~

:ul4laltl '='9 .:.'""'4ltg '""4.J~I -JJ'il ~ I

C\, ................................................... ul.JUI '='9 .:.~t, '""4.J~I ~~t :~WI ~~I

:JU.t ~Jl - ~WI ~ I

u~J,L.Jt, '.! 10.;...:Jt "'~4 J,4.alt uLU~ ~ ' - ~WI~'

:~~I~~ ~.,JI li~l~\:i- ~UJI ~ I

Amy Guerber .>J...H?:- ~t : .ll~l

,Av .......................................... u ~ I ~ J~~t, ~~, ~~ :~WI ~J..:?JI

: u ~ I ~ J~.W ~ I u~t:u, - V"~l.JI ~ '

J~~I ~IJ-4 ~ 1.:-'~~I '-"°!.,,cl ~~I o~~J - ~l.JI ~ I

Zehava Rosenblatt ~~jJ.J U1\.s.,_j : .ll~l

rt, .................................................................................. ~IJ~l~~~l-~t,Jl~J..:?JI

:dj 4J~IS~t u~u...t,~ - ~w, ~ '

:4Jy~I ul.4.Jl.all ~L....i.9 :JUt, ~~~I - ~till ~ I

,;-a...,w :J~~I u ~ ~ -ll.u..ill vA -WI 4=¥ - ~Lall ~ I

4.tb. :a..!j.UI ~IJ-4 J,J_,Jo ~ .ll.w.ill ~ l.9-4 - ~ ($-lWI ~ I

: ~ ~JS W-':!~1- ~ ~WI ~ I

\V• ................................................................... ~ J ~ J : ~ I ~L.u_, o-\ JJ~

\ C\ \ .......................................................................................................... J~~I tl_,:,i "\-\ JJ~

, a.. r ........................................................................................................... ~..1.11 ~wL::i 1-r J..,~

rtA ......................................... ~.)~~I~ ~)l;.~I ~l~I, o.:i«oi A-\ JJ~

rot ......................................................... J~I ~~ ~ ~~1~1 A-Y JJ~

rto.. ...................................... ~~1~1~1.,olJ.lllJ~~~ \\-\JJ~

,Ronald J. Broke~~ t ..Ull.JJ

.¥JJ.;fo. l.!l.;~ LA~ J~)U ~~ ~ ~ <::'"Q}o ii JI l.!l_,l.uJI ~ .;_;:,S~ ~ti.....u i

~ , . , ':YQ.!t:,. ;;ti ~I~~ Distinguished Professor~ JjjS~ ~ti....ui

aEdward C. Tomlinson ~.JJ ·4"' ~..Jlg~!

J~}U YJ-:1 ~ Mulwich Scholar ~_,J-"'° ~4_, ;;J.l?JI ~ l.!1.)~ ~~i

aChad Albrecht .-'-"'t,~1 ~t..:,

w,k. c.G~fa_;.:i • Utah State University l:i~ 4:'}!_, 4.a.44,. ~ ~~ jl.:i--uj

,, ~~ 4.ls!I ~ ':f~I LAJ c,~ faU : u ~ I ~ ~lwt.AlL9 4-w~I

•Vikas Anand ..uU1 "'1'~

Arizona State University~µ, L>Jj..J..Ji~4'-0-40IJ.¢.J.llo.l~~~

a.Jl ••u.HJ ~~I r.,WI ~ ~ a . : Q.:t;., ;;JI ;;.l~I J~ ~ .u.l-A :,~i

,Bronwyn Best~ ~t.Jl.!H

~~I ~j.1.1 c4 ~ '~..Jbll I~ J;9J . \ C\W f'~ ~~~ ~

·r r~ ~ o_;l.l?JI J ~ ~ 1Jl_;~.l ~lb ->--'.J-t?:- ~ i ~

,Boland Daniel V ..u~~.t..iJ:!ll~

~fi,>JI b..9: ~~ Entrepreneurship 4:;~I o.l~I J~~ ..1.e.~ ::i~i

al. M. ,Jim» JawaharJ~~'-?-«tu.""» .,. .i

~~I LAJ,A%Ji L..A4,. 0--4 "11.,....:0..ul ;;J~ c.,---k ~6..

,Joel Lexchin ~~ JJ~

University of Toronto .¥JJJj°J 4.aA4,. L>-4 J~~I DJbl ~Lo~~

. ~ u~,j,;> ~..)-'Ai ~1 ":J.)t11 ~

~ls') 4-...AA~ J~)U 0_,-:Jl..9 ·r r~ ~~.,,.;~..)~lb

~l.k.J...;-t,11 ~yfi 4.....AA4" ~ ~4'Jl o..)~l c.:,--k. ~

W ~~ ~ ~ '?~t LAJ ~...L:,,,ij l~U :u~t '?'9 ~~~ 4.4..a~I

,Zehava Rosenblatt u~jJJ Ull.s:!j

~~~JA ~ I._# ~~J '=""Q.!t;.,iit\ ~.,L-Jl..9 ~ I .lJl_j,1.1 o.;b! ~ a,o,o~

,Matthew L. Sanders.i)..u~ .J ~Lo

.;..w~ J.ll.;.,.._J..,...._< LL-44 0--4 Dl.)~..L...JI O . l ~ c.:,-L.c. ~ L , . .

,Mark S. SchwartzjJJI~ ·4"' l!l'.)Lo

0~t ~ J~ ~1., 0.,:,w,., ~LS"~I w~ ~~~ ~ ~~ ~b........u,f

~L:i.:a 4.1.as ~ ~.:Lll l.4_, 1!1~ ljU

:ul.o.l:wl ~ ~L.w.ill ~ '-4J~I

c.:,~! .;L:, L.aA~ cl .!4.!\•ill ;;.;b)ll ~ ~ ~_)..D ~ ~

,Thomas H. Stone~.~ ""'Lo.,:i

:I ~.,JI li~l~\:i- ~UJI ~ I

,Av .......................................... u ~ I ~ Jt, , ~~ :~WI ~J..:?JI

J~~I ~IJ-4 ~ 1.:-'I '-"°!.,,cl I o~~J - ~l.JI ~ I

I .ll;JI 0-4~ ~JA\rl ~J,All ~ J ,r• •'\ r W ~ . l ~ ~ J

.gift cards l:l~I ~LI~~ ~UI ~ ~~ IJAll ~ I I

l.!U~J '~...>At~~;;~YJ~ l..o~I alJ-'-" ~ ,Y• •Ar

as'..,_j,a.>9l r'°' • •\ r,l.c.~ . ~ I ~l.c...,.JI J~~ l.i.ljlAJ

~J ·r' \A"\ r'~ jJ~i~o-4 <)-l~IJU"'.ll-uJI ~~ ~I

, ~~~ J~ a, J~ ~w, utswitjiW ulf.?,.,

o, ... · ~~~~~~IL4Jo~faU :u'4Y,iil~!JI

(Mazar,Amir, andAriely, 2008)~..JtJ..>:AiJJIJLAfij 5.;-:i;.\11 ljU