Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Glotodidaktika
Glotodidaktika
On Glotodidactics
What is applied linguistics?
o Applied linguistics – someone with a degree in linguistics who was unable to get a job in a
linguistics department (?)
TASK
o Read the definitions of applied linguistics (A. Burns, J. Richards, Z Dorney, R Hudson)
o Find the topics/expressions all the definitions have in common
o Based on these topics /expressions „build“ your own definition
o Discussion
o Burns
Application of language theory irl
Problems of language in different real-life contexts → solutions
o Richards
at first – theory of language teachin
later – various disciplines dealing with practical language issues
teaching has its own methods (SLA, pedagogical grammar etc.)
in the past – language teaching = applied linguistics
nowadays – language teachin = TESOL – teaching and practice of teaching
English to speakers of other languages
language teaching ≠ applied linguistics
conclusion: term irrelevant and old
o Dorney
How language is acquired
o Hudson
Interdisciplinary
Solution to language problems
Real-world language problems
David Crystal, A Dictionary of Linguistics and Phonetics
o AL -a branch of linguistics where the primary concern is the application of linguistic
theories, methods, findings to the elucidation of language problems which have arisen in
other areas of experience
o The most well dveloped branch: teaching and learning foreign languages
o Medical linguistics - treating language disabilities (dislexia, disgraphy)
o Phorensic linguistics – language analysis in legal documents
Glottodidactics
o Glottad (from Greek) – language, speech, dialect
o Didaskein – to teach
o The study of foreign language learning and teaching
o The study of teaching metods and procedure sin language teaching
Mihaljević Djigunovič – Interdisciplinarna istraživanja u području obrazovanja na primjeru
glotodidaktike
Methods
o Meta – by means of
o Hodos – way
o The actual techniques and procedures of the class wordk
o An overall plan of the orderly presentation of language material
o Skills/content/order
o The grammar-translation method
o The direct method
o Audiolingual method
o TPR
o The silent way
o Community language learning
o Suggestopedia
o Communicative language teaching
Approach
o Theories about the nature of language and language learning that serve as the source
of practices and principles in language teaching
o A set of assumptions dealing with the nature of language teaching and learning
o Methods developed on the basis of various approaches
o Reform movement = approach
o Direct approach = one of the methods
Listening
Key terms
o Listening comprehension
o Processes involved in listening
How important is listening in FL learning and tteaching?
o 40s to 60s
Listening neglected
“passive” skill
Listener as tape recorder – audiolingual method
Listening as primary skill, but the practice was very restricted
In every-day life
45% - listening
30% speaking
Reading 16%
9% writing
In reality listening is used the most in everyday life
o 70s
Recognized as core component od 2nd language acquisition
We internalize linguistic information through listening
Speaking is NOT communication
Speaking + listening comprehension = communication
Teaching the comprehension of spoken speech – of primary importance!
TPR
Natural approach
o How do we listen? One-way or two way?
One-way (non-interactive) – not interacting with the speaker to facilitate
comprehension (movie, lecture)
Two-way (face-to-face interaction) – able to interact with the speaker
o Listen carefully!
Which problems did you have while listening?
Which information would have been helpful?
o Interactive model of listening comprehension
Clark and Clark
Listening is an interactive processes (8 processes)
1. Processing raw speech and holds an image of it in short term
memory
2. The hearer determines the type of speech event
a discussion
3. Determining the objective of the speaker
speakers wants to share their ideas
4. The hearer recalls background info
What do I know about?
5. Literal meaning to the utterance
6. Assigning an intended meaning to the utterance
7. The hearer determines whether info should be stored in short term
or long term
short tern
8. Hearer deletes the form in which the message was received
o What makes listening difficult?
Speed
Most common observation by L2 learners: fluent speakers (NSs) seem to
speak very fast
The ability to follow natural speech in a second language is a skill that
takes a long time to master
The exposure to English for L2 learners?
To what extent do they reflect natural speech
Unplanned nature of spoken discourse
Two-way spoken discourse is usually unpredictable and reflect the
processes of construction
Hesitation, reduced form, filler, false, starts and repeats
Jack C. Richards on listening comprehension
o 1. What are the two strands of listening comprehension?
Bottom up processing
work through language
understanding language, and analyze it, then
coming to the meaning
Top down processing
start from meaning, then work towards language
bypass some bottom processing by using
background knowledge
o 2. What is a schema?
The body of knowledge about a topic
Used to process language
Filling in information gaps in communication
o 3. What is the implication of this theory of language teaching?
Bottom-up processing
o Wunifthifirstthingsimgunnadownigetometoniteischeckmyemailm
esagis
o Input is the basis for understanding language
o We use our knowledge of language and our ability to process
acoustic signals to make sense of the sounds
o We segment speech into identifiable sounds and impose a
structure on these in terms of words, phrases…
o Tasks for students:
List of content words and aske them to make sentences
A list of content words and ask them to listen toa text and
number the words as the occur in the text
Words deleted – fill in the gaps
Time reference on a chart
Sentences with a grammatical feature and students tick
the intended meaning
Set of sentences with a particular grammatical feature
Top-down processing
o Use of background knowledge in understanding the meaning of
the message
o Inside the head information
o Schematic knowledge
Formal schemata – knowledge we have of the structure of
some speech events (Once upon a time…)
Content schemata – general world knowledge
o Higher level processes (top-down)
o Lower level processes (bottom-up)
Both processes simultaneously
Teaching listening
o Teaching listening: Gist and Detail
Listening for gist?
To get general idea - skimming
What is listening for detail?
To get details - scanning
Where is the listening text from? What do you think
about the text
How many times did students listen to the text?
3
Did the students get specific tasks before listening?
Just listen to the text
Listen again and put the activities in correct order
Why did the teacher walk around the classroom
Checking answers
What are some other activities that are mentioned in the
video
Is there anything the teacher could have done differently?
Pre-Listening stage
o Contextualize the text
While-listening activity
o Help them focus on the text
o Listening for gist – focus on main idea
o Listening for specific information – scanning; students should
focus on details
Post-listening
o Integration with other skills
o Listening + reading/writing
o Homework, discussion, chart completion,commenting…
Accents
Teaching reading
Task 1: The White Mountains
o Read the text paying attention to the underlined words
o Guess their meaning – what helped you understand them?
Stram – tower
Marret - upholder
Jurrip - castle
Barlim - barman
Taddle - waste
Barl - farm
Fastam - fixation
Wol - strap
Prad -
Dimp
o Syntactic knowledge
A barlim, a wol – nouns
Can taddle – verb
o Morphological knowledge
Barl – barlim (barl + im =barlim, farm – farmer etc.)
o Linguistic (systematic) knowledge
Good lreaders decode quickly and accurately the maning
o Sociocultural
o General world knowledge
o Genre knowledge
o Schematic knowledge
Reading: knowledge areas/skills
o Vještina čitanja na stranom jeziku: teorijska ishodišta
o Automatic recognition skills
Unconscious: recognizing the text for what it is
o Vocabulary and structural knowledge
Understanding of language structure
Large recognition vocabulary
o Formal discourse structure knowledge
Understanding how texts are organized and how information is put together
o Content/world background knowledge
Prior knowledge of text related info
A shared understanding of cultural information
o Synthesis and evaluation skills/strategies
The ability to read and compare info from multiple sources
The ability to think critically about what you read
o Metacognitive knowledge
Defining reading
o Complex ability to extract, or build, meaning from a text – too simple
o Usually divided into multiple abilities
Key skills
Recognizing words
Large recognition vocabulary
Strategic processes
Background knowledge
Interpreting and evaluating texts
Proceessing texts fluently over extended period of time
o How does fluent reading work?
Lower level processing and higher level processing
Lower
Word recognition
Lexico-syntactic processing
Semantic processing
Beginner reader?
o Need to establish a strong link between ortographic forms and
sounds of language
o L1 research – training in phonological awareness and letter-sound
correspondences
o What is phonological awareness?
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=K0G6teawxls&t=222s&ab_channel=Understood)
Awareness that the words which we speak can be taken
apart
Strongly linked to early reading and spelling success
through its association with phonics
Teaching literacy
o Recognizing phonological patterns such
as rhyme an alliteration
o Awareness of syllables and phonemes
within words
o Hearing multiple phonemes within words
o Phonemic awareness is a critical subset of phonological
awareness
o Phonemic awareness includes the following skills
Onset-rime identification, initial and final sound
segmenting, blending, segmenting, and manipulating
sounds
o The automatization of letter-sound relations is the foundation
of all alphabetic reading and supports syllabic reading
Higher
Forming main idea meanings
Thematic info
Using background knowledge and inferencing
L1 and L2 reading differences
o Smaller L2 linguistic knowledge
o Less L2 experience
o Involves two language systems
o Different background knowledge between L1 and L2
o Foreign social and cultural assumptions for L2
General principles for teaching reading
Interesting and accessible reading resources
Some degree of student choice in selecting reading sources
Lessons – pre- during, and post reading
o These activities should be varied from one major reading to the
next
Opportunities for students to experience comprehension success while
reading
Word recognition skills
o Important for reading
o Happens in less than 100 ms
o Accuracy + speed of meaning
o Visual decoding of letters
o Semantic resources
o Mental lexicon
o Reading skills developed before school – parents singing with
you
Reading fluency
o the ability to read accurately, smoothly with expression
o automatic recognition of words
o RF provides a bridge between word recognition and reading
comprehension
o Can focus on the meaning of the text
Working with text: general framework
o Pre-reading activities
Access background info
Video: Using Visual Images to Pre-teach Vocabulary
What is the teacher’s advice on the use of visual
images?
o Don’t write – pictures are more
stimulating
o Just use a computer – alternatively print
them out
o Activate students prior knowledge
How does the teacher elicit unknown
vocabulary?
o Asking questions about the pictures
Comment on the amount of the linguistic input,
teacher feedback and student’s reaction to the
activity
o During-reading activities
o Post-reading activities
Styles of reading
o Oral reading
At the beginning and intermediate levels: serves as an
evaluate check on bottom-up processing skills
Pronunciation check
Extra student participation – if you want to highlight a
certain passage
Not authentic activity
o Intensive reading
Focusing on linguistic or semantic details
Surface structures
o Extensive reading
Larger texts outside of the classroom
Longer text
o Skimming
Reading for gist
Getting a global impression
Top-down
o Scanning
Reading for detail
Predavanje: Writing
How is writing like swimming?
o Somebody has to teach you
o Once you learn it you never forget it
Why is writing a difficult skill for learners?
o Has to be learned unlike speech
o We do it rarely
o Absent audience
o Linguistic difficulties
Conventions of genre
Grammar/vocabulary
Organizing and sequencing ideas
Differences between written and spoken discourse
o permanence
written is fixed and stable, time, speed, and level depend on an individual
spoken discourse moves on in real time
o explicit
written text is explicit
spoken discourse – some info can be assumed, context and situation
o density
content is much more condensed in writing
o detachment
written detached in time and space
speaking – interaction and feedback
o organization
written – organized and carefully formulated: grammar and vocabulary
spoken – improbisation, stream of consviousness kind of language
o standard
written – standard variety of language
speech – dialect
o a learnt skill
writing – taught and learned deliberately
speaking – acquired
main objective of teaching writing
o students to be able to produce the same texts as an educated person
o ESL/EFL – context, writing, like other language, according to level
o Mechanical aspects of writing
o Focus on accuracy and content of the message
o Communicative perspective
Early writing taskts: coping with the mechanics
o Basic mechanics
Letter/word recognition
Letter discrimination
Word recognition
Rules of spelling
Punctuation and capitalization
Students tend to look for one to one letter sound correspondence
Not in English
How do we teach mechanics
o Enhance letter recognition
o Reactive sound-spelling correspondence
o Move from letters to sentences
More advanced writing
o Focus on accuracy and content of the message
o Lists (“things to do” – “things completed”)
o Notes and messages
o Letters to friends
Jack C. Richards, Writing in a second language
o what is the audiolingual approach to writing?
Focused on control of sentence patterns and grammar through oral practice and
drill
Basis for writing
Dicto-comp
Reading a paragraph and repeating details
o What is the paragraph-pattern approach? (topic sentences, thesis sentence)
Focus on organizational patterns (narration, description…)
Developing a paragraph on modes and patterns
Logic of paragraphs
Writing sentences for paragraphs
Topic sentence - the topic sentence helps organize the paragraph by summarizing
the information in the paragraph.
Thesis sentence – tells the reader how to inrerpret the information
o What s the process-oriented view of writing?
Emphasis on the writer and writing strategies
Not on end result – but process
Writing as a creative process
Planning, drafting, revising, editing
Criticism:
more suited for advanced learners
more advanced texts are needed
o What are the features of the discourse-genre approach
How language Is used for particular purposed
How is it used in particular contexts (school, job….)
Genres have certain features
Factors:
Cultural conventions
Audience
Formal or informal
…
Creating texts that are context appropriate
Depends on cultures
Awareness of contexts of texts
Škola za život – grade 8 – writing a mini-saga
o what are the outcomes?
Writing a mini-saga on the word travelling
o What is an outcome? Why are outcomes important for L2 learning?
Things students can do after a lesson, not what they learned
o What are the stages?
Posing a general question about stories
Introducing the elements of a story
Reading an example
Analyzing it
Pin-pointing different
o What’s a mini-saga?
Very short story
All the elements, but few words
o What are the elements of the process view of writing the lesson
Product view of writing
o Focus on final product of writing (essay, report etc.)
o Supposed to
Meet standards of rhetorical style
Grammatically correct
Conventionally organized
o Emulating model compositions
o Measuring student compositions against real ones
Process view of writing
o Focus on process to a finished result
o Help understand composing process
o Learn about strategies such as prewriting, drafting, and rewriting
o Give student time to write or rewrite
o Focus on revision
o Find the topic
o Giving feedback and encourage it
o Individual conferences between teacher and student
o Taking advantage of nature of written code
Two step process
Figure out the meaning
Putting it into words
o Writing is a process of “cooking a message”
Components of a writing course
o Content
Depends on the type of writing students are learning
Not always chosen by the teacher
o System
Grammar
What areas of grammar will be useful to the
Linked to simple paragraph-writing
Sentence-combining – pairs of sentence
Expanding
Combining
Extending
Copleting
Paralleling
Rewriting
o Process
Rehearsing
Drafting
Ideas to words
Time focused
Elaboration
Reduction
Jumbled paragraph
Revising
Peer feedback, group correction, rewriting exercise, teacher feedback,
checklist
o Genre and text
Modelling – analyze model with students
Joint construction
Independent construction
Teaching grammar
Why teach grammar?
o 2 views
“There is no doubt that a knowledge – implicit or explicit – of grammatical
rules is essential for the mastery of a language”
“The effects of grammar teaching appear to be peripheral and fragile.”
o Grammar debate
o For and against teaching grammar
The case for grammar
o Sentence-machine argument
Part of the process of language learning is item-learning
Memorization of individual items
There comes a point where new need to learn some patterns and rules to
enable us to generate new sentences
A knowledge of regularities in language provides the learner with the means
to generate original sentences
Grammar – a sentence-making machine
o The fine-tuning argument
The purpose of grammar is to allow for greater subtlety of meaning that a
merely lexical system can cater for
Teaching of grammar serves as a corrective
o Fossilization argument
Learners often reach a kind of plateau beyond which it is difficult to progress
Their linguistic competence fossilizes
Learners who receive no instruction seem to be at risk of fossilizing sooner
than those who receive instruction
o Advance organizer argument
Weak interface hypothesis
Grammar instruction might have a delayed effect
R. Schmidt, Developing basic conversational ability in a second language: A
case study of an adult learner of Portuguese (1986)
Studied Portuguese in Brazil
Left classes to travel
While speaking noticed grammatical structures in talk with natives
Noticing: a prerequisite for acquisition
Grammar teaching – insufficient for fluency – a preparation for noticing
Grammar as a kind of advance organizer for later acquisition
o Discrete-item argument
Grammar consists of an apparently finite set of rules
Reduces the enormity of the learning task
A discrete item – any unit of the grammar system that is sufficiently narrowly
defined to form the focus of the lesson or an exercise
o Rule-of-law argument
Since grammar is a system of learnable rules, it lends itself to a view of
learning and teaching known as transmission
Education as a transfer of a body of knowledge
Very simplistic view of education
o The learner expectations argument
Many language learners come to the language classes with fairly fixd
expectations as to what they will do there
Previous classroom or out-of-classroom
Case against grammar
o Knowledge-how argument
Language is a skill – experiential learning
Learnt in praxis – not by sitting down
o The communication argument
More to it than grammar
Do you drink?
Present simple
Offer
Communicative approach – communicative language teaching
Grammatical knowledge is merely one component of communicative
competence
Communicative competenece – usage of grammar and covaculary of the
language to achieve the communivatie goal and knowing how to do this in a
socially appropriate way
o Acquisition argument
Learning/acquisition
Acquisition occurs when the learner is exposed to the right input in stress-free
environment
Learning – formal instruction; of limited use
Learning – monitoring the acquisition of language
o The natural order argument
There is a natural order of acquisition of grammatical items
Universal grammar
Similarities in developmental order in L1 and L2 acquisition
A textbook grammar is not nor can ever be a mental grammar
What is the status of grammar now?
o 2 types of approaches to language teaching: distinctive pattern in the history of
methods
o Focus on analyzing the language and focus on using the language
o GM – DM
o ALM – CA
Task-based and content-based approaches, CLIL, CA- speaking and writing Accurately is
Teachers who focus student’s attention on linguistic form during communicative interactions
are more effective than those who do so in decontextualized grammar lessons.
Focus-on-form
o Draw student’s attention to linguistic form while they are primarily focused on
meaning
Balance between fgramar and commnicatio nencouraged
First step is to come to a broader understanding of rammar
Grammar=form
Te teaching of gramaar = the teaching of explicit linguistic rules
Jack C. Richards – Grammar as a communicative resource
o „we have to go beyond looking at how grammar is used to shape sentences and focus
on how it can be linked to real contexts for the use of language, for the real
communication“
What is grammar?
o Grammar is not
A discrete set of meaningless decontextualized or static structures
Prescriptive rules about linguistic form
o What is grammar
3D grammar framework
Form/structure – how is it formed
Meaning/semantics – what does it mean
Use/pragmatics – when and why is it used
Grammar structures have morphosyntactic form; hey are also used to express
meaning (semantics) in context-appropriate use (pragmatics)
Three dimensions are wedges of a single pie chart
Not present all dimensions at once
The scope and multidimensionality of the structure
Learning challenges
What does CEFR say?
o Grammatical competence – knowledge of, and ability to use, the grammatical
resources of a language
o Grammatical competence – the ability to understand and express meaning by
producing and recognizing well-formed phrases and sentences in accordance with the
principles of language (as opposed to memorizing and reproducing them as fixed
formulae)
Presenting grammar
o Degrees of explicitness
1. Deductive approach
- Reasoning, analyzing, and comparing
- Presentation of an example
- Explanation
- Students practice with given prompts
- Disadvantages
Grammar is taught in an isolated way
Little attention to meaning
Practice is mechanical
- Advantages
Very successful with selected and motivated students
Explaining complex grammar
Time-saving
accuracy
2. Inductive approach
- Induces the learners to realise grammar rules without any
forms of explicit explanation
- The rules will become evident through practice
- Possible tasks
Timelines
Games
Oral exercises: repetition, substitution, translation
exercises
Multiple choice exercises
- Teaching grammar in context
Do children learn EFL grammar differently from adults?
o CNES: Croatian National Educational Standard (2006)
o Kurikulum nastavnog predmeta Engleski Jezik (2019)
o Grades 1 5 8
o Conclusions
o What does HNOS say about the grammar learning process?
Grade 1:
Various activities
Dynamic class structure, tasks 5 min
Visual learning
Games
Group tasks
I+1
Code Switching to explain tasks
Reproduction mechanical
Grade 5:
Explicit lessons
Implicit grammar knowledge
Games
Problem and research
More simple grammatical structures taught implicitly
Contrastive analysis if needed
I+1
Code switching if needed
Dynamic activities in class, duration 15 min
Pupil centered
Grade 8
Contrastive analysis
Certain structures taught explicitly metagramatically
Multimedial
Codeswitching if needed
Repetition
Asking questions
o Theories about how young children learn are not ifferent from theories about how
teenagers and adults learn language and grammar
o There are secial considerations regarding how children learn anything
o Children absorb new information
o Best by playing and practically
o Children interpret meaning without necessarily understanding the individual words
Unable to grammatically analize
o Children learn hrough their sense
o An ECLECIC approach to teaching YLs has been suggested
o Processes:
Noticing
Structuring
Proceduralization
Automatic use
o Where is the difference?
Learning process (Hedge, 2000
1. Noticing
Students must notice items of language in order to interpret the
relationship between form and meaning.
Language teacher has to be noticeable
Items become part of intake
2. Reasoning and hypothesizing
For adults
Analyzing language
See patterns in language, create hypotheses about the rules and
gradually revise them
3. Structuring
New rules have to be integrated within their interlanguage
Evidence: errors
Errors are systematic
4. Automatizing
Form without thinking
Basic principles for teaching grammar
o There is a convincing case for a role for grammar
o Teaching grammar includes teaching form, meaning and use
o Basic rules for grammar teaching – the criteria for evaluating the examples
o E – factor
Efficiency
Teacher as efficient as possible
How efficient is it?
Economy, ease, and efficacy
When presenting grammar, the sound rule of thumb is the shorter, the beter
A little prior teahing seems to be more effective than a lot
Economical in term of planning and resources
Ease – painstaking preparation is not always possible
Generally speaking, the easier the activity is going to be setu up, the
better it is
Efficacy: will the activity work
If teachers cant’ directly cause learning, they can at least provide optimal
conditions for it
Attention, understanding, memory and motivation
The efficacy of a grammar activity can partly be measured by the degree of
attention
Motivation: materials relevant,
o A – factor
Appropriacy
No class of students is the same
Not everything is hoing to work for another group
Task 1: A sample lesson
Aim of step 1?
- Establish basic terminology
Aim of step 2?
- Minimal grammar pairs
- Contrast between two forms
- Think about the difference, don’t verbalise it
Step 3: explain grammar point: the T uses the board to provide a
visual reinforcement
Step 4 : designed to test the learner’s grasp of the rule
Step 5: the students have a chance o personalize the language point
E-factor
- Efficiency depends on the rule being explained and on the
teacher monitoring the learner’s degree of comprehension
- Economic – rules Is simple
- Very easy and no preparation
A factor
- Appropriate for teens and adults
- Analytical and reflective approach to language teaching
- Not appropriate for young learners.
Task 2: Teaching grammar in context
1. What advice is given about grammar teaching in the introductory part of
the video?
2. Which grammatical structure is in the focus of the lesson?
- Past simple
3. Does the teacher provide any explicit explanation regarding the structure?
- no
4. Which activities does he use to contextualize grammar?
- Important dates/years
- Pair-work
5. Does the teacher provide feedback? If yes, how?
- T correct the mistakes himself
- T prompts the students to correct the mistakes (asks
questions)
- T repeats the students utterances
6. In your opinion, was this lesson (or part of the lesson) successful? Why?
7. A and E criteria?
Community learning
Whole person learning
o Taking into account not only intellect, but also emotions, will etc.
o Adults feel threatened by a new learning situation
o Teacher understands the struggle students face when trying to learn a new language
Counselling-learning approach
Why does the teacher give careful instructions at the beginning of the lesson?
o To not include anxiety if explained later on
o Explains in L1
o Their first lesson ever
Why are students invited to talk about the experience?
o Sharing feelings
o Creating a community and friendly atmosphere
The use of L1?
o Translation
Background
o Charles A. Curran
o Counseling-Learning
Application of psycholofical counseling techniques to learning
Counseling
One person giving advice,
Teacher – counselor
Students – clients
View of language – interactional
Interactions between learners
Interactions between learners and knowers
Class – a community of learners
Interaction between learners and knowers:
Dependent
o Students are dependent on the teacher
o Teacher translates student’s sentences
o Feelings of security and belonging
Self-assertive
o Ss gradually learn the phrases
o Atmosphere: warm and accepting
Resentful and indignant
o Ss speak independently and may need to assert their identity
o Ss reject unasked-for advice
Tolerant
o Ss use FL freely
o T provides idioms and more complex hrammar items
o Ss are secure enough to take criticism
Independent
o Improving style and knowledge of linguistic appropriateness
o Ss know everything
Based on child development psychology
Theory of learning
Learning is persons
Convalidation
o Essential to the learning process
o Key element of CLL classroom procedures
o Understanding and positive evaluation of others pesrons
worth develop between the teacher and the earner
Learning is achieved collaboratively