MV Dona Marilyn Case Study

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 52

SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC.

PHILIPPINES 2022

INTRODUCTION

Background of the Study

The MV Doña Marilyn was a Japanese built ship designed by Onomichi Zosen for

Ryukyu Kainun KK ( the RKK Line) in 1966. It was originally known in Japan as

Otohime Maru and was employed on the Okinawa route. The ship was first sold to

Eusebio Shipping Lines, Cebu in the Philippines in 1976 and was renamed Doña

Ana. However, it was purchased again in 1980 by Sulpicio Lines Inc., Cebu and

was again renamed as Doña Marilyn.

The vessel's striking design emanated an image of bustling activity, drawing

passengers from all walks of life onto its decks. The MV Doña Marilyn, being

roughly 97 meters in length and weighing around 2,215 tons, had a large capacity

to accommodate hundreds of passengers and staff members on each voyage.

The vessel epitomized the spirit of maritime travel, providing passengers with a

comfortable and convenient way of transit between Manila and places in the

Visayas and Mindanao. Its interiors were built to provide a blend of utility and luxury,

with spacious passenger cabins, eating rooms, and lounges where passengers

could relax and unwind throughout their trip.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


1
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

On October 24, 1988, the vessel set off on a routine journey from Manila to

Tacloban City, despite the approaching danger of Typhoon Unsang. Unfortunately,

the voyage became a nightmare when the typhoon released its full power on the

vessel.

The MV Doña Marilyn was caught in a storm with winds over 100 km/h and waves

reaching astounding heights. Despite efforts to manage the storm, the ship

eventually sank off the shore of Leyte island. The accident killed hundreds of

passengers and crew members, leaving a trail of devastation and sorrow.

Investigations were conducted to determine the cause of the disaster and the

events that ultimately caused the ship to sink. Reports of overloading, poor

maintenance, and disregard for safety procedures surfaced, indicating that the ship

was functioning under questionable conditions

The sinking of the MV Doña Marilyn sent shockwaves through the maritime industry

and prompted widespread calls for reform. It brought to light how crucial it is for a

marine transportation to prioritize safety and regulatory compliance in maritime

transportation particularly in adverse weather conditions.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


2
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Figure 1. MV Doña Marilyn

Figure 2. Wrecked MV Doña Marilyn

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


3
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

DETAILS OF MV DOÑA MARILYN

SPECIFICATIONS

Name MV Doña Marilyn

Owner Suplicio Lines Inc.

Operator Suplicio Lines Inc.

Completed 1966

GENERAL CHARACTERISTICS

Type Cargo/Passenger Ship

Height 97.6 m (320 ft 2.52 in)

Length 13.7 m (44 ft 11.37 in)

Beam 8.1 m (26 ft 6.89 in)

Tonnage 2855 GRT

Propulsion motor vessel

Speed 19.5 knots (36.11 kph)

Table 1. Ship’s Particular

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


4
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

BODY

Incident Description

In the early morning exactly 10 am of October 23, 1988, the ship MV Dona Marilyn

– a Philippine passenger ferry operated by Sulpicio Lines, a prominent shipping

company in the Philippines. The vessel was built in 1963 and primarily served

routes between various islands in the Philippines, providing transportation for

passengers and cargo, it was a relatively large ferry, capable of accommodating a

significant number of passengers and vehicles. It played a crucial role in facilitating

travel and commerce between different regions of the Philippines. It left the Manila

and heading or sailing towards Tacloban City having at least 511 people on board

including the ship’s crew and with Captain Eliodoro Salgado Jr.

It sailed from Manila, the capital of the Philippines, on October 23, 1988. Manila is a

significant transportation center in the country, with multiple ports that facilitate the

passage of people and goods between the different islands that make up the

archipelago. It was intended to sail from Manila to Tacloban City, which is situated

on the Island of Leyte's eastern coast.

As MV Dona Marilyn traversing the ocean of Sibuyan Sea in the Central Philippines

on 23rd of October, 1988, 2am, they encountered a huge and powerful waves due

to Typhoon Unsang and also Sibuyan Sea is also known which is prone to rough

seas and affected by tropical storms and typhoons. As they experience the whip of

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


5
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Typhoon Unsang they immediately sent a message on the coastal station of

Sulpicio Lines at Manila updating about their condition during the travel and

deciding to slow down the engine in order to cope on the tyranny of waves.

At 1:30 pm, the Doña Marilyn radioed a distress signal off Tanguingui Island, also

known as Manoc-Manoc Island, near Masbate. According to military officials, this

was the last signal from the ferry received by the station. Typhoon Ruby, locally

known as Typhoon Unsang, caused strong winds and giant waves, causing the

ship to capsize around 2 pm.

Figure 3: TYPHOON UNSANG MAP PLOTTING THE STORM'S TRACK AND

INTENSITY, ACCORDING TO THE SAFFIR–SIMPSON SCALE

Along the way, Typhoon Unsang—locally known as Typhoon Ruby in the

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


6
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Philippines—a tropical storm that formed in the Western Pacific Ocean, was

making the weather worse in the Manila area and the surrounding waterways. As it

got closer to the Philippines, it brought with it bitter cold, a lot of rain, and choppy

waves.

The Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration,

or PAGASA, claims that it has alerted vessels to the impending typhoon by issuing

warnings and advisories, possibly changing their course to avoid the worst of the

storm. The MV Dona Marilyn chose to persist with its voyage from the port of

Manila to Tacloban City in defiance of all of PAGASA's warnings. This choice

ultimately resulted in the terrible and tragic sinking of the ferry.

Figure 4: TYPHOON UNSANG AT PEAK INTENSITY ON OCTOBER 24, 1988

The crew on board the MV Dona Marilyn responds to Typhoon Unsang's approach

and the worsening weather conditions before the ship sinks. But not every action

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


7
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

the staff takes is thoroughly documented. The crew made sure all safety measures

were taken in case of choppy seas, large waves, and unfavorable weather. This

include tying up loose objects on the deck, inspecting life-saving gear, and

educating passengers on what to do in an emergency. The MV Dona Marilyn's

officers and captain have been in contact with the company's headquarters and

maritime authorities to get updates on the situation and any advisories or warnings

that have been issued for other vessels in the vicinity. Additionally, the staff gave

passengers safety briefings during which they explained emergency protocols,

where life-saving supplies are kept, and evacuation routes in case of an emergency.

It is noteworthy that the MV Dona Marilyn tragically sank during her voyage in spite

of these measures, underscoring the difficulties and dangers of traveling in severe

weather, particularly in the context of tropical cyclones like Typhoon Unsang.

A tragic moment in maritime history, the sinking of the MV Dona Marilyn symbolizes

the ongoing search for responsibility and maritime safety. On October 24, 1988, in

the midst of the stormy waters of the central Philippines, the boat came under the

full force of Typhoon Unsang, also named Typhoon Ruby. This tragic event took

place.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


8
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Figure 5: MV DONA MARILYN SHIP PHOTO

Sulpicio Lines' passenger ferry, the MV Dona Marilyn, sailed from the Philippines'

capital city of Manila, a busy port, on its disastrous journey. Packed with

passengers and goods, the ship headed for Tacloban City, an important center on

the eastern side of the island of Leyte. But those on board were unaware that

Typhoon Unsang, with its fierce gusts and pouring rain, was about to threaten to

scuttle their journey.

The MV Dona Marilyn faced more and more choppy circumstances as it traveled

through the Sibuyan Sea. The vessel was pushed to the verge of disaster as the

unrelenting onslaught of wind and waves tried its strength and stability. The crew

did everything they could to keep things under control and make sure everyone on

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


9
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

board was safe, but the power of nature was simply too much.

As time went on, things on the MV Dona Marilyn became more and more desperate.

The boat listed dangerously in the middle of the churning waves as they pounded it

with their powerful surges. As the crew and passengers came to terms with the fact

that they were dependent on the weather, confusion and panic broke out.

In a terrifying finale, Typhoon Unsang's overpowering might claimed the MV Dona

Marilyn. The ship, which was once a representation of trade and marine

connectedness, capsized in the turbulent waves and fell into the abyss below.

Hundreds of souls were devoured by the ocean's unrelenting grip, and the sound of

their shouts and pleas resounded across the water.

A frantic battle for survival took place in the wreckage-filled waters in the wake of

the catastrophe. In a desperate attempt to save as many survivors as possible,

heroic people risked their lives in the rescue operation.

A grim reckoning started as the debris fell and the true scope of the disaster

emerged. There were many unanswered questions concerning the choices made

before the tragic journey, the ship's ability to withstand the storm, and the actions

taken in the crucial seconds before the catastrophe happened. The goal of the

investigations was to disentangle the complex network of events that had resulted

in such a devastating death toll.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


10
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Repercussions from the MV Dona Marilyn's sinking rippled throughout the maritime

industry, provoking introspection and calls for change. It exposed the weaknesses

in the Philippine maritime sector and emphasized the necessity of strict safety

regulations and close supervision. Although tributes were given, memorials built,

and lessons learnt, the tragedy's wounds would always remain as a somber

reminder of how fleeting human existence is in the face of nature's wrath.

The MV Dona Marilyn's sinking is a somber tribute to the human spirit's persistent

endurance following unfathomable catastrophe in the annals of nautical history. It

acts as a sobering reminder of the sea's limitless capacity to bring people together

as well as drive them apart, to nurture and destroy. Above all, it forces us to take

historical lessons into consideration as we set out to create a more secure and safe

future for the world's oceans.

So aftermath the hearing of Senate about into the disaster, some evidences are

presented such as logbook of the Sulpicio Lines. Senator John Osmeña contended

that the shipping line and the Coast Guard ought to have been able to warn

Captain Salgado to divert from its intended course before the hurricane reached

Signal No. 3, given that they were aware of a typhoon approaching Tacloban

through PAGASA.

On October 31, Corazon Alma de Leon of the Department of Social Welfare and

Development (DSWD) declared that Sulpicio Lines has promised to donate

₱50,000 to each of the departed family members. Two days later, Secretary of

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


11
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Transportation and Communications Rainerio Reyes met with President Corazon

Aquino. Reyes said after the conference that all Sulpicio Lines ferries would be

prohibited from leaving their respective ports. Sulpicio Lines ignored the directive

and continued operating the ferry as usual, asking to be given a formal order before

they shut down. In the end, an interagency committee was formed on November 5

to investigate all Philippine commercial vessels. In order to inspect the MV

Cotabato Princesa ferry operated by Sulpicio Lines, the committee grounded all of

its ships on the same day.

Shortly after the committee's formation, the National Telecommunications

Commission (NTC) raised the bar for seafaring vessels following the Doña Marilyn

incident, suspending 14 more cargo and passenger ships after examining 216 of

them nationwide for broken navigational and communication systems.

When diving at Manoc-manoc Island, also known as La Manok Island, on

November 10, a fisherman by the name of Bonifacio Rodrigo apparently saw the

sunken vessel, which turned out to be the wreck of the Doña Marilyn.

Father of Capt. Salgado, Eliodoro Salgado Sr., offered three weeks after the ship

sank to assist Ramon Barrot of the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) in

locating his son, who was allegedly hiding in Maripipi Island in the province of

Biliran at the time. Some survivors, including Alex Moron Jr., claimed to have seen

him board a life raft after he abandoned ship.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


12
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

A reward of ₱50,000 was set for anyone who could find Capt. Salgado, and shortly

after, NBI senior agent Zosimo Pebrero confirmed his presence in Barangay Ol-og,

Maripipi. Speaker Pro Tempore Antonio Cuenco, who was in charge of the search

for Salgado, claimed that barangay officials would not cooperate with NBI officials

upon their arrival on the island and that he might be forced to ask for their arrests if

needed.

The precise number of disaster survivors was the subject of conflicting accounts;

Reuters stated that at least 205 people survived, while Martinia Mercado of the

DSWD stated that just 181 people did. Vice President of Sulpicio Lines Vicente

Gambito estimated the number at 197.

Lynette Ordoñez of the Manila Standard claimed that at least 101 of the survivors

were not listed on the ship's manifest, but Gambito claimed that 46 of them were.

After the tragedy, Alex Moron Jr. became president of the Doña Marilyn Survivors

Association.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


13
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Figure 6: CURRENT SITUATION OF MV DONA MARILYN

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


14
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

ANALYSIS

In the wake of the tragedy, amid Typhoon Unsang's rage, the state of the MV Dona

Marilyn prior to its terrible sinking has been the focus of examination and research.

This maritime calamity is still incredibly painful and somber. The ship's

maintenance has been closely examined to determine whether it was subjected to

routine inspections, repairs, and maintenance processes in accordance with

industry norms and maritime laws. Any breakdowns or inadequacies in the

maintenance procedures may have jeopardized the ship's seaworthiness and

weather-withstanding capacity.

The classification societies regularly conduct surveys and inspections to verify that

ships meet safety and technical standards, helping to confirm the seaworthiness of

vessels. Details on the MV Dona Marilyns classification status and inspection

reports could provide valuable information on the ships condition and compliance

with regulations.

Having knowledge of the ships history, such as incidents, accidents, or near misses,

can offer important context for evaluating its performance and ability to handle

challenging conditions. Older ships may undergo upgrades or modifications to

improve their efficiency, safety, or adherence to rules. Assessing the effectiveness

of the retrofitting of the MV Dona Marilyn would be crucial in determining its

adequacy.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


15
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

The availability, condition, and functionality of emergency equipment such as

lifeboats, life rafts, life jackets, and emergency communication systems are crucial

for ensuring the safety of passengers and crew during emergencies. Evaluating the

adequacy and effectiveness of emergency equipment and procedures aboard the

MV Dona Marilyn would have been essential in assessing the vessel’s readiness to

respond to adverse conditions.

One of the most important components of the analysis is the decision-making

process that led to the disastrous expedition. Despite the threat of Typhoon

Unsang, the decision was taken to continue the voyage from Manila to Tacloban

City. This choice implies possible errors in risk assessment and judgment on the

severity of the weather conditions and their potential influence on the voyage's

safety.

Typhoon Unsang showcased its strength highlighting the dangers of navigating

through weather conditions, at sea when the MV Dona Marilyn narrowly avoided its

wrath. Despite the Philippines experiencing typhoons questions were raised about

the ships and crews capability to handle circumstances. Worries emerged

regarding the ships stability, structural integrity and safety measures during

weather conditions.

The incident led to investigations into the management system overseeing the

Philippines' ocean operations and assessing compliance with safety guidelines,

contracts, and emergency response strategies, aiming to identify deficiencies in

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


16
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

administrative controls. Effective communication and coordination between vessel

crew, maritime authorities, and other parties is crucial during emergencies.

Analysis of protocols and processes identifies areas for improvement.

The incident underscored the significance of emergency preparedness and

response in addressing maritime disasters, revealing areas for improvement in

emergency equipment, evacuation procedures, and crew training to improve

passenger and crew survival during emergencies.

The MV Dona Marilyn disaster highlighted the significant impact of human factors

on the vessel's sinking, including crew ability, training, and adherence to operating

procedures. The incident led to a thorough examination of marine safety

procedures, legislation, and industry standards in the Philippines and other

countries, influencing measures to increase safety standards, improve regulatory

monitoring, and promote a safety culture to prevent future tragedies.

Improve weather monitoring and forecasting skills, especially in tropical storm and

typhoon-prone areas. Implement strong processes for analyzing weather-related

hazards and making educated decisions about trip planning, route selection, and

potential delays or cancellations under poor weather conditions.

Strengthen rules and monitoring procedures to guarantee that vessels are

seaworthy, including frequent inspections, maintenance, and adherence to safety

requirements. Implement actions to address age-related degradation, modify older

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


17
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

boats, and invest in modernization and safety enhancements to increase the

marine fleet's resilience.

Enforce compliance with current safety legislation and industry standards that

regulate marine operations, such as vessel stability, lifesaving equipment,

emergency procedures, and crew training. Implement actions to improve

accountability and enforcement mechanisms in order to discourage noncompliance

and guarantee adherence to safety rules.

Improve communication and collaboration among marine stakeholders, such as

vessel operators, maritime authorities, meteorological services, and search and

rescue groups. Improve standards for communicating timely weather warnings,

emergency alerts, and operational updates to support informed decision-making.

Situational parameters played an important role in the sinking of the MV Dona

Marilyn and subsequent impacts on maritime activities. The analysis presented

here closely examines all the environmental factors related to the incident.

The major natural disaster linked to the calamity was Typhoon Unsang. This

destructive tropical cyclone had massive effects on the area in the form of harsh

climate conditions such as strong winds, very heavy rainfall, and rough seas. The

intensity of the typhoon subjected the MV Dona Marilyn to unimaginable strain,

resulting in its sinking. The characteristics, speed, and path of Typhoon Unsang

were important environmental factors that determined the level of difficulty maritime

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


18
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

conditions would pose to any vessel at a given time.

One of the crucial determining factors of the readiness and response of a ship and

its crew is the level of accuracy of weather forecasting and timely availability of

weather information. When there is a likelihood that a hazard is coming through,

strong weather monitoring systems with accurate forecasts are essential in alerting

the stakeholders in the maritime sector about upcoming hazards to enable

informed decision-making on voyage planning, route adjustments, safety measures,

among others.

Given that the tragedy was also impacted by the area's distinctive geographical and

oceanographic features, it is reasonable to predict that these factors will alter the

environmental setting. The Sibuyan Sea is located in central Philippines, between

the islands of Luzon and Visayas, which are frequently affected by tropical storms

and typhoons due to their location in the Typhoon Belt. In particular, undersea

topography, currents, and bathymetry in the Sibuyan Sea may have rendered sea

conditions even more perilous for the MV Dona Marilyn.

Although the individual incident was not related to climate change itself, the overall

climate changes that occur around can, however, not be disregarded as climate

change is said to affect the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events.

Weather patterns, for example, those associated with tropical cyclones, might be

increased by climate change, thus more intense and dangerous maritime hazards

can result from these. Recognizing the potential consequences of climate change

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


19
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

on marine safety must come as part of the larger initiative of adapting to changing

environmental conditions while minimizing future risks.

The sinking of the MV Dona Marilyn was accompanied by environmental impacts

that went far beyond human fatalities and property loss. The spillage of fuel, oil,

and other dangerous substances by the ship was a menace to marine life and

people who lived along the coast. It is evident from this environmental impact that

an accident prevention plan should include an effective response strategy and

other steps for early pollution control to curtail further harm to ecology in case of

maritime accidents.

In summary, environmental factors played a crucial role in causing the sinking of

the MV Dona Marilyn and its aftermath. Understanding the complex interplay

between environmental variables, maritime operations and security aspects is

critical to improving resilience, preparedness and sustainability in the face of

maritime threats. Continued efforts to mitigate environmental risks, improve

forecasting capabilities and promote sustainable marine practices are critical to

protecting lives, livelihoods and the marine environment into the future.

The state of the sea and the waves in the Sibuyan Sea must be taken into account

by the ship’s captain and crew because they will have a significant influence on

their stability and navigability. Vessels must understand how certain variables, such

as wave height, period, and direction, can affect their ability to steer out of harm’s

way and susceptibility to capsizing or submersion in high waves. It is highly

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


20
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

important to analyze changes in the local wave climate to estimate risks related to

offshore activities here.

Severe weather conditions also play a role, with visibility and atmospheric

situations influencing maritime safety. During heavy rain, fog, or very low visibility,

navigation becomes complicated, increasing the possibility of ship collisions or

groundings; likewise, this will hinder an emergency search and rescue mission.

Therefore, it is important that visibility and atmospheric conditions are monitored to

ensure the safety of ships at sea.

The complex topography of the shoreline and oceanic threats within the pathway of

MV Dona Marilyn might be factors that add more environmental risks to its

navigation. Low-lying shoals, coral reefs, as well as sunken vessels can increase

the possibilities of running aground or collisions, particularly if visibility is poor or in

stormy weather. In the assessment of these hazards and mitigation measures, it is

imperative to appreciate local coastal geomorphology and bathymetry.

The discharge of pollutants into the marine environment can cause profound

damage to nearby ecosystems and local biodiversity. Pollution may have adversely

affected coastal ecosystems, fish resources, and marine species, leading to

continuous ecological threats and socio-economic consequences for coastal

populations. Determining the sensitivity and resilience of marine systems towards

anthropogenic impacts is important when planning recovery measures in response

to marine accidents.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


21
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Environmental concerns must be considered while developing emergency

response and environmental contingency plans for marine catastrophes. To reduce

the impact of maritime accidents on natural resources, reaction measures must be

integrated into a strategy that includes protocols for oil spill cleaning, hazardous

waste removal, and habitat restoration. Collaboration among government agencies,

environmental groups, and corporate sector participants is critical to ensuring an

ecologically sound response and recovery strategy.

Preventing climate risks is critical in the context of extreme weather and other

natural catastrophes to meet the growing concerns posed by these problems.

While ensuring that disaster risk reduction activities are well-coordinated and

implemented in accordance with gender equality, incorporating climate resilience

considerations into maritime infrastructure development, coastal zone management,

and disaster risk reduction activities can help to limit the effects of climate-related

threats on maritime safety and environmental sustainability.

The Doña Marilyn MV disaster had an impact beyond the boat thus leaving behind

a sad aftermath of loss, grief and trauma. At the core of this tragedy is profound

human suffering characterized by loss of life and injuries suffered by passengers

and crew.

Chiefly, the incident claimed too many lives with hundreds of individuals dying in

the ferry capsizing and sinking. The number of deaths may depend on different

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


22
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

accounts and sources but the extent of the tragedy cannot be denied. As news

about the calamity spread, families were torn apart, communities shattered and a

nation thrown into mourning. Each death represented a unique story, a beloved

one lost, an end to tomorrow’s dreams leaving gaps that can never be filled.

Besides loss of life, other survivors sustained minor injuries such as cuts or more

serious trauma like bodily injury.

Falling objects, falling debris, and cold water might have exposed them to

numerous dangers among others. The survivors would have suffered various

injuries that needed urgent medical attention as well as continuing support which

will further destabilize already overwhelmed emergency departments.

Beyond the immediate physical damage, the psychological implications of this

event are almost impossible to exaggerate. People who survived such a thing

might be tormented by their own terrifying memories of disaster; in addition, they

had been facing feelings of blame and fear as well as survivor’s guilt. For example,

many people who experience traumatic events in their lives like MV Doña Marilyn

tend to develop Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), anxiety and depression

which require specialized support and mental health services for rehabilitation.

The death and injuries that characterized the MV Doña Marilyn incident were felt all

over the Philippines, touching families, communities and then country at large. This

catastrophe was a vivid reminder of how fragile life is and how unpredictable sea

journeys could be, thus prompting a call for more safety measures, responsibility as

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


23
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

well as control in the maritime industry.

The MV Doña Marilyn accident while best known as one with tragic loss of lives

and injuries, also had severe effects on its environment. The ferry’s capsizing and

sinking caused environmental harm, which affected not only the immediate area

but also spread further to marine ecosystems, coastal habitats plus communities

relying on natural resources for their livelihoods. In this essay we explore the

environmental consequences of the MV Doña Marilyn incident by examining

damage done to marine environments with efforts to redress it considered.

Oil Spills and Pollution. The most immediate and visible environmental impact of

the MV Doña Marilyn would be the oil and other pollutants released into the sea.

The ferry was carrying fuel oil, lubricants, and other hazardous materials in its fuel

tanks and machinery. The sinking would result in fuel dispersion, jeopardizing

water quality, marine life, and ecosystems of the coastal areas. Oil spills are highly

destructive to the marine environment; they create a film on the water surface and

suffocate marine life, including fish, sea birds, and marine mammals. The toxic

elements of oil damage the respiratory, digestive, and reproductive systems of

marine animals, resulting in massive death as well as long-term ecological

devastation.

Finally, oil spills can result in contamination of coastal habitats such as beaches,

mangroves, and coral reefs, limiting the capability of these ecosystems to support

biodiversity and offer valuable ecosystem services. Cleaning and remediation

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


24
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

processes to remediate oil spills can be relatively complicated, expensive, and

time-consuming.

They necessitate the use of special technologies and machinery as well as trained

workers and cooperation among government agencies and other relevant

organizations. Habitat Destruction and Loss of Biodiversity, following the sinking of

the MV Doña Marilyn, the incident may have caused physical harm to marine

habitats and ecosystems around the location. Artifacts such as the wreckage of the

ferry, its cargo, and other items may have been strewn on the seafloor, disrupting

benthic environments and coral ecosystems.

Furthermore, the commotion instigated by the ferry plummeting and following

retrieval endeavors might have rattled frail ecosystems, like underwater grasslands,

swamp woodlands, and stony coasts. Such territories furnish critical spawning

locales, munching zones, and juvenile shelters for an expansive assortment of sea

life forms comprising economically vital fish plus invertebrates. The ruin or

impairment of aquatic terrains can trigger avalanches in biodiversity which leads to

dwindling piscine populations, alterations in creature assortments, and

perturbations in ecological operations. The safeguarding plus restoration of water

domains impacted by the accident involving MV Doña Marilyn prove paramount for

upholding the durability plus yield of seaside ecologies while endorsing enduring

fisheries plus touristic deeds.

Further down line concerning Sea Path Dangers also Naval Preservation; debris

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


25
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

from MV Doña Marilyn alongside detritus from said calamity could've represented

seafaring risks to additional crafts sailing nearby thus elevating hazards linked with

maritime mishaps also smashes. Submerged crafts dormant obstacles along

floating remnants pose potential stumbling blocks within navigational passages

blocking transit ways besides jeopardizing aquatic voyaging safety measures

consequently post-disaster efforts towards pinpoint mark furthermore clean sea

route dangers turned crucial keeping vessel movements across this locale under

secure conditions likewise salvage undertakings aimed at hauling rubbish sinking

wreckage off sea bottom seen hampered via limited sight harsh tides moreover

tough subsurface circumstances Tackling seaway threats born out MV Doña

Marilyn event insists upon tight cooperation amongst naval authorities harbor

overseers wreck lifting entities together eco divisions. By identifying and mitigating

potential risks to navigation, stakeholders can enhance maritime safety and prevent

further environmental damage in the affected area.

Economic Impact on Fisheries and Tourism, the environmental damage caused by

the MV Doña Marilyn incident can have far-reaching economic consequences for

coastal communities dependent on fisheries and tourism. Oil spills, habitat

destruction, and loss of biodiversity can disrupt commercial fishing activities,

reduce fish stocks, and undermine the livelihoods of fishers and seafood

processors. Additionally, the negative publicity surrounding the incident and its

environmental consequences can deter tourists from visiting affected areas,

leading to declines in tourism revenues, hotel bookings, and recreational activities.

Coastal communities reliant on tourism income may suffer economic losses as a

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


26
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

result of reduced visitor numbers and negative perceptions of destination safety

and environmental quality. Addressing the economic impacts of the MV Doña

Marilyn incident requires targeted interventions to support affected communities,

restore ecosystem services, and promote sustainable resource management

practices. Investing in fisheries rehabilitation, habitat restoration, and ecotourism

development can help mitigate the long-term economic consequences of

environmental damage and promote the resilience and recovery of coastal

economies.

Legal and Regulatory Responses, in response to the environmental damage

caused by the MV Doña Marilyn incident, government agencies and regulatory

authorities may have implemented measures to enforce environmental laws,

impose penalties on responsible parties, and prevent future incidents.

Environmental regulations governing maritime operations, oil pollution prevention,

and marine conservation may be strengthened or revised to address gaps and

shortcomings revealed by the incident. Additionally, legal actions, such as lawsuits,

compensation claims, and enforcement actions, may be pursued against the

owners, operators, and insurers of the MV Doña Marilyn to hold them accountable

for the environmental damage and economic losses incurred.

Civil and criminal liability for pollution incidents may result in fines, penalties, and

restitution payments to affected parties, contributing to the funding of cleanup and

restoration efforts.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


27
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

The MV Doña Marilyn incident had far-reaching consequences beyond the loss of

human lives and environmental damage; it also inflicted significant property

damage. In this essay, we will explore the various aspects of property damage

resulting from the incident, including the destruction of the ferry itself, loss of cargo

and vehicles, and economic ramifications for stakeholders.

Loss of Vessel, the most obvious form of property damage resulting from the MV

Doña Marilyn incident was the total loss of the ferry itself. The vessel, which

represented a significant investment for its owner, Sulpicio Lines, was rendered

irreparably damaged and ultimately sank beneath the waters, becoming a

permanent fixture of the ocean floor.

The loss of the MV Doña Marilyn had significant financial implications for its owner,

including the cost of the vessel's construction, maintenance, and insurance

coverage. The value of the ferry, along with its equipment, machinery, and onboard

amenities, would have amounted to millions of dollars, representing a substantial

financial loss for the company.

Moreover, the loss of the ferry had operational consequences for Sulpicio Lines,

including disruptions to its maritime transportation services, loss of revenue, and

reputational damage. The company's ability to fulfill contractual obligations, service

routes, and maintain customer confidence may have been compromised in the

aftermath of the incident, further exacerbating its financial woes. Cargo and Vehicle

Loss, in addition to the loss of the vessel itself, the MV Doña Marilyn incident

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


28
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

resulted in the destruction or loss of cargo, vehicles, and personal belongings

onboard. The ferry was likely carrying a variety of goods, merchandise, and

supplies destined for delivery to various ports of call, as well as vehicles belonging

to passengers and crew members. The destruction of cargo and vehicles onboard

the MV Doña Marilyn represented a significant financial loss for shippers, importers,

and exporters, who may have incurred damages or lost revenue as a result of the

incident. The value of the lost cargo, including perishable goods, consumer

products, and commercial merchandise, would have amounted to substantial sums,

further compounding the economic impact of the tragedy.

Additionally, the loss of personal belongings belonging to passengers and crew

members onboard the ferry would have had emotional and financial consequences

for those affected. Valuable items such as clothing, electronics, documents, and

sentimental belongings may have been destroyed or lost in the chaos of the

capsizing and sinking, leaving individuals without essential possessions and

mementos of their past.

Economic Ramifications for Stakeholders, the property damage resulting from the

MV Doña Marilyn incident had broader economic ramifications for stakeholders

across the maritime industry and local economies dependent on maritime trade and

transportation. The loss of the ferry and its cargo disrupted supply chains, logistics

networks, and commercial activities, leading to financial losses for businesses,

suppliers, and service providers. Shipping companies, freight forwarders, and

logistics providers involved in the transport of goods and commodities may have

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


29
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

incurred additional costs associated with rerouting shipments, arranging alternative

transportation, and addressing delays in delivery schedules.

The ripple effects of the incident would have been felt by a wide range of industries,

including manufacturing, retail, agriculture, and tourism. Furthermore, the

reputational damage inflicted by the MV Doña Marilyn incident on Sulpicio Lines

and the broader maritime industry in the Philippines had long-term consequences

for investor confidence, market competitiveness, and regulatory oversight.

Stakeholders, including investors, shareholders, and creditors, may have

reassessed their relationships with the company and the industry, leading to

changes in investment strategies and risk management practices.

The MV Doña Marilyn incident had a profound and multifaceted economic impact

on the maritime industry, local economies, and society. Direct costs included

search and rescue operations, emergency response efforts, salvage operations,

and cleanup activities to recover survivors, mitigate environmental damage, and

restore maritime assets. These costs included fuel, equipment, logistical support,

medical care, humanitarian aid, and crisis management. Salvage operations aimed

at recovering the wreckage and removing navigation hazards also incurred

substantial costs. Cleanup activities to mitigate environmental damage also

required financial resources and technical expertise.

Indirect losses resulted from the incident, including disruptions to maritime

transportation services, loss of revenue for businesses, and reputational damage to

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


30
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

the tourism sector. The suspension of maritime operations by Sulpicio Lines led to

lost revenue for the company, its suppliers, and affiliated businesses. The negative

publicity surrounding the incident may have deterred passengers from using ferry

services operated by Sulpicio Lines, further impacting the company's financial

viability.

The MV Doña Marilyn incident had broader implications for the tourism sector,

particularly in regions reliant on maritime transportation for tourism activities. The

loss of confidence in ferry travel and negative perception of destination safety and

environmental quality may have led to declines in tourist arrivals, hotel bookings,

and recreational activities. Indirect losses also extended to businesses dependent

on maritime trade and transportation, such as importers, exporters, and

manufacturers.

Long-term consequences of the MV Doña Marilyn incident included legal liabilities,

regulatory reforms, and changes in industry practices. Legal liabilities, such as

compensation claims, lawsuits, and enforcement actions, imposed financial

burdens on responsible parties, such as Sulpicio Lines and its insurers. Regulatory

reforms and changes in industry practices emerged to enhance safety standards,

improve emergency preparedness, and strengthen oversight of maritime operations.

The incident served as a catalyst for broader discussions on maritime safety,

environmental protection, and corporate accountability within the maritime industry

and regulatory agencies.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


31
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Figure 7: WHO’S SALVAGING MV DONA MARILYN

The supporters of the environment and scuba diving were disturbed because an

untracked shipping company had allegedly conducted a salvage activity on the

ruins of the MV Doña Marilyn, which has now become a well-known dive site in

Malapascua Island in Daanbantayan.

A reason they raised was that disposing of the remains of the ship could cause a

negative effect on the environment and economy of Northern Cebu, which is

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


32
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

famous among scuba divers.

With the matter reaching Daanbantayan Mayor Vicente Loot’s ear, he was quick to

denounce the salvaging of MV Doña Marilyn, noting how it had taken place

unbeknownst to the town officials.

One of the cases which DENR 7 is investigating is to determine the suspects

responsible for the illegal salvage operations.

To ensure that their operations are within the boundaries of the law, the Philippine

Coast Guard (PCG) Cebu Station is also verifying if the salvage ship obtained a

permit from them prior to conducting their operations.

V Doña Marilyn, a passenger ship owned by the former Sulpicio Lines Inc., sank in

1988 while on a voyage from Manila to Tacloban under Typhoon Unsang.

The sinking resulted in the death of over three hundred individuals, while one

hundred and forty-seven others were able to escape alive.

While the ship had a history of tragedy, divers have begun to consider it a treasure

trove.

This place is also rich in biodiversity, as many types of corals and marine life reside

here.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


33
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Oposa announced to SunStar Cebu yesterday that "Inasmuch as it has sunk, the

shipwreck has now transformed into an artificial reef and begun to harbor marine

life."

It is, on the other hand, one of the four shipwrecks divers get to see in Malapascua.

The enterprise tried to salvage the boat before, Oposa mentioned.

In 2004, there was an attempt by a metal company to remove the wreckage from

the area; however, it was stopped after the Philippine Tourism Authority (PTA)

ordered them not to do so.

The present PTA executive and senator Robert Dean Barbers fought the salvage

because it was about to destroy the tourism sector.

During an interview with SunStar Cebu, Gideon Esmero, who works in the

Conservation and Development Division of the DENR 7, said that this ship is a

successful artificial coral area because it hosts diverse flora and fauna like black

corals, which are also endangered.

The remains of the wreck also served as habitats for many other sea creatures like

the marble electric ray, blue spotted rays, bow and eagle rays, devil rays, and white

tip sharks.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


34
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

According to Esmero, despite the limited number of studies on biodiversity within

the MV Doña Marilyn, the presence of these plant and animal species indicates

that coral recruitment in the wreckage has been successful.

In response to the needs and demands of the diving fraternity, Esmero noted that

one of their findings is that sand tends to dominate as the primary substrate or bed

in most parts of the area, making it hard for coral colonies to be successful.

"These fragments have become a matrix that promotes coral growth in the area,"

he said.

Esmero said if the debris was removed from the area, it would cause a significant

loss to the area's biodiversity.

In a separate interview, Vince Hinches of Greenpeace Philippines said clearing the

wreck would also have an economic impact, especially for Malapascua residents

whose livelihoods depend on tourists.

"For a community that relies heavily on diving for income, closing dive sites is likely

to shorten the time divers spend on the island and concentrate the pressure on a

few locations," he said.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


35
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Mayor Lott condemned the restoration of the MV Doña Marilyn in a statement,

saying it would have a negative impact on the city's tourism industry.

“No natural or legal person may carry out shipwreck salvage or similar activities

within the area of ​ ​ responsibility of Daanbantayan without the necessary

authorization from the mayor, which unfortunately we will never approve as they

are harmful to the environment and the growing city tourism is destructive," he said.

(JKV)

Figure 8: MV DONA MARILYN AS DIVING SPOT

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


36
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

Sunken ships, despite their terrible histories, regularly resurface as famous diving

spots. The MV Dona Marilyn, sitting beneath the seas of the central Philippines,

has become a popular diving destination. Although it may sound counterintuitive,

these destinations entice divers with their unique underwater landscape, rich

marine fauna, and historical significance.

The appeal of the MV Dona Marilyn's wreckage entices divers, allowing them to

explore its depths. The ship's ruins rest on the seabed, creating a stunning

underwater scene that invites brave divers to delve within and closely investigate

the debris.

As time passes, submerged ships such as the MV Dona Marilyn transform into

man-made coral reefs, drawing in a wide range of marine creatures. The wreckage

becomes a thriving environment, with corals, sponges, and fish taking up residence,

resulting in vibrant ecosystems that divers can venture into. This sunken vessel

potentially provides a home for numerous species.

Despite the past that ended with tragedy, Dona Marilyn still stands as a relic of

maritime history. Those who are keen on studying shipwrecks and maritime

traditions might find the remnants an interesting material for investigation and

uncovering the details of the catastrophe. The place is seen to be able to provide a

visualized form of memories about the perils that mariners have gone through, as

well as emphasizing the need for safety precautions in their sailing escapades.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


37
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

One of the most enjoyable and yet challenging diving experiences is found in wreck

sites such as MV Dona Marilyn. Moving through debris, controlling buoyancy, and

penetrating narrow spaces are definitely not for amateurs; those skills require

practice and make it possible to enjoy the adventure of wreck diving, which is often

unique and extraordinary.

The existence of a prominent diving destination can lead to the growth of the

tourism industry and economy in this area. Dive centers, hotels, restaurants, and

other organizations can generate more income from visitors coming to that place

specifically because of a sunken ship dive site.

A renowned wreck site can be a vital source of foreign currency and generate local

tourism, which directly results in economic development. The diving operation,

hotels, restaurants, and other businesses could benefit from the increased number

of divers and tourists who come to this location due to its popularity as a wreck

diving spot. Scuba diving tourism has the potential for job creation and helping to

stimulate the local economy for coastal areas.

Please note that even though it is an exciting and enlightening experience, wreck

diving should not be taken lightly. In order to ensure the safety of those diving in

wrecks, divers must possess proper qualifications, knowledge, as well as

necessary equipment. Moreover, the protection of wreck sites as cultural and

ecological resources necessitates responsible diving methods and efforts at

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


38
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

conservation aimed at minimizing harm to the underwater flora and fauna.

Figure 9: DIVING THE DONA MARILYN WRECK

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


39
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

This ship is presently sat at roughly 30m on its starboard side and is remarkably

well preserved, giving it an ideal diving location without having to travel far. We

often offer tours to examine this strange wreck, which is home to some incredible

life. With spectacular growth on the top of the wreck at roughly 18m and great life

on it ranging from Scorpion fish to Nudibranchs and, on sometimes, a variety of the

ray family drifting by, all of this leads to an amazing dive.

This wreck is home to frogfish, sea snakes, nudibranchs, huge cuttlefish, and

flatworms. Batfish and large porcupine fish are both regular visits. White tip sharks,

huge moray eels, marble rays, blue-spotted rays, eagle rays, and devil rays have

all been observed there. Several types of sweetlips grow larger here than at other

diving locations. Divers may also see numerous of the stunning purple fire sea

urchins, together with their resident zebra crabs and Coleman's shrimps. For those

completing their Advanced Open Water (AOW) course or those who already

possess this certification and just want to undertake enjoyable dives, the dive itself

is ideal. Since the ruin is completely penetrated, it is also suitable for anyone doing

their PADI ruin Diver Specialty or even TDI Advanced Wreck course. Frogfish, sea

snakes, nudibranchs, big cuttlefish, and flatworms can all be found living on this

wreck. Along with batfish, large porcupine fish are frequent visitors. There are

occasionally observed white tip sharks, huge moray eels, marble rays, blue-spotted

rays, eagle rays, and devil rays. This diving spot has larger types of sweetlips than

any other. Divers can also see a large number of the stunning purple fire sea

urchins, along with the zebra crabs and Coleman's shrimp that live there.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


40
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

SUMMARY

The tragedy of the MV Dona Marilyn is among the most terrible maritime mishaps

in Philippine history. On October 24, 1988, the Sulpicio Lines ship MV Dona

Marilyn was traveling from Manila to Tacloban City as usual. This route was chosen

by travelers from Metro Manila who were traveling to various locations in the

Visayas. Regretfully, the trip that was supposed to be routine turned into a terrible

nightmare when they encountered Typhoon Unsang, a strong tropical storm that

quickly formed over the Philippine Sea.

The ship had several difficulties when the cyclone stirred up the waters. First of all,

the ferry's construction was unable to withstand the gusts of wind and the wave that

was cresting higher than the homes. Second, there was probably an overloading

issue because it is highly likely that even in this sad incident—which is just one of

many tragic accidents that frequently occur as a result of disregarding safety

regulations—the Ferry MV Dona Marilyn would have been carrying more

passengers and cargo than her capacity would have permitted under rules

designed to prevent such tragedies in the maritime transportation industry, which is

beset by safety issues that are routinely ignored in favor of profit maximization.

The ship's structural fragility combined with the unfavorable weather conditions

resulted in a calamity. Despite their greatest attempts to fight through the storm, the

MV Dona Marilyn was overwhelmed by the elements and began to fill with water.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


41
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

When passengers and crew members realized they were about to die, chaos broke

out on board, creating a terrifying spectacle.

Following the MV Dona Marilyn disaster, inquiries were conducted to determine the

underlying reasons of the sinking and to bring charges against those responsible

for the crew's and passengers' safety. The main points of contention were whether

or not the ship was seaworthy, how trustworthy the safety measures were, and

what the crew did in response to the incident.

The tragedy of the MV Dona Marilyn serves as a stark reminder of the risks

associated with shipping, particularly in areas where typhoons and tropical storms

are common. It also highlights the need for strict safety regulations, rules, and

oversight to prevent such tragedies from happening in the future. Years have gone

by since then, but the memory of those who perished in the sinking of the MV Dona

Marilyn endures, serving as a constant reminder of how susceptible humans are to

natural calamities.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


42
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, the sad loss of the MV Dona Marilyn serves as a stark warning of the

terrible outcomes that may happen when marine safety is jeopardized in severe

weather. During Typhoon Unsan on October 24, 1988, an incident happened that

resulted in hundreds of deaths and had a lasting influence on marine safety laws

and procedures in the Philippines and other countries.

The MV Dona Marilyn event analysis highlights the intricate interactions between

environmental elements, human factors, ship preparedness, and decision-making

processes that resulted in the catastrophe. The decision to proceed with the

voyage from Manila to Tacloban City in spite of warnings of an impending typhoon

eventually left the ship and its occupants vulnerable to the full intensity of the storm.

The event was influenced by a number of environmental factors, including the

strength of Typhoon Unsang, the state of the water, and the geology of the shore.

Due to the Sibuyan Sea's notorious susceptibility to tropical storms, the MV Dona

Marilyn has additional difficulties when navigating choppy waters and unfavorable

weather.

In order to avert future catastrophes of this kind, a thorough examination of industry

standards, legal frameworks, and marine safety procedures has been prompted by

the aftermath of the MS Dona Marilyn. There are suggestions for strengthening

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


43
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

oversight, enhancing ship preparedness, enhancing weather monitoring capabilities,

and fostering a safety culture in the maritime sector. There have been initiatives to

memorialize the victims of the MV Dona Marilyn disaster and guarantee that their

legacy is honored in the years after this terrible incident. Remembrance events,

memorials, and rituals serve as a symbol of respect for the departed and provide

solace to the surviving who are still here. These deeds also serve as a reminder of

the immense sorrow that occurs when people are involved in maritime tragedies.

They also serve as a catalyst for the idea that people should never forget the lives

that are lost at sea. Apart from the aforementioned alterations in perspectives

about maritime safety, the disaster led to significant revisions in the legislative and

regulatory structure overseeing marine safety in the Philippines.

Maritime collaboration and knowledge exchange among stakeholders took off after

the MV Dona Marilyn incident at national, regional, and international levels. Other

countries and organizations benefited from these lessons learned, leading to the

sharing of best practices, guidelines, and standards that were created to enhance

maritime safety and resilience worldwide. This collaborative response illustrates

how much global cooperation matters in addressing maritime threats that endanger

our collective security, as well as ensuring the successful conduct of maritime

operations in peacetime or wartime. However long ago it was when the MV Dona

Marilyn incident occurred, its teachings still remain pertinent at present.

It is also essential that all maritime stakeholders stay alert, proactive, and be

prepared to face ever-changing risks and threats that may arise in the maritime

environment. Moreover, these kinds of training, drills, and exercises serve as a way

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


44
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

to maintain readiness and keep track of what has been learned from previous

events for better application in the future.

In the midst of the MV Dona Marilyn sinking, there emerged tales of resilience,

heroism, and survival. The courage and resolve shown by survivors, responders,

and the affected areas demonstrate how strong the human spirit can be when

confronted with challenges. Such narratives provide hope for others and underline

solidarity, empathy, and assistance during testing situations.

Sunk since then, the MV Dona Marilyn has turned into a diving destination, a sober

symbol of the lives lost and wisdom acquired through disaster while its message

still stands as a testament to the need for adherence to safety, preparedness, and

resilience in marine operations. By adopting effective mitigation strategies based

on lessons from history and applying proactive approaches to reduce risks,

stakeholders are likely to forge the way forward towards a safer and more

environmentally friendly future for the maritime industry.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


45
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

ANALYSIS

The MV Dona Marilyn disaster highlights some of the major issues that continue to

affect maritime security in the Philippines and throughout the world based on its

aftermath.

Safety Guidelines and Adherence

One crucial lesson to be learned from the accident is the necessity of strong and

efficient safety regulations that can regulate the activities of the maritime industry.

However, overcrowding, which was common on Philippine ferries in those years,

seriously jeopardizes ship stability and increases risks during inclement weather.

Being Weather Ready

Typhoon Unsang's impact on the MV Dona Marilyn highlights the need of accurate

weather forecasts and preparedness strategies for seafaring ships. This makes it

abundantly evident that regulations like proper training and procedures for sailing in

severe weather are crucial for lowering the hazards to sailors and passengers alike.

Handling Crises and Reaction

The failure of a disaster preparedness system that had no crisis management plans,

and crew training indicates the value and practical use of comprehensive crisis

management plans and crew training. Successful completion of all other measures

such as good communication, cooperation with rescue teams, and maintenance of

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


46
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

order in the evacuation are extremely imp ortant to improve chances for

survival in an emergency situation.

Responsibility and Supervision

Following the disaster, an investigation into the sinking brought up questions about

accountability and oversight of the maritime sector. One crucial way to prevent

future tragedies of this kind is to hold accountable individuals who are negligent or

violate safety regulations.

Takeaways Acquired

For those in the same industry, the maritime authorities, operators, and regulators

involved in the MV Dona Marilyn catastrophe offer insightful insights. They highlight

the significance of constantly raising safety standards, maintaining and updating

ships, providing crew training, and having emergency response procedures in

place to save the lives of passengers and crew members while they are at sea.

In general, the MV Dona Marilyn accident highlights the related issues of ocean

security, such as regulatory compliance, readiness against weather conditions,

disaster management, accountability, and efforts aimed at constant improvement to

avoid more victims.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


47
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

RECCOMENDATIONS

In light of the MV Dona Marilyn event study, the following suggestions may be

made to improve marine safety and lessen the likelihood of future disasters of a

similar nature:

Better Decision-Making and Weather Monitoring

Improve the possibilities of surveillance and predictions in relation to weather

conditions, especially in areas prone to tropical storms and typhoons. Develop

efficient systems for weather-based risk assessment as well as rational

determinations about navigation schedules, route choices, potential delays, or flight

cancellations during adverse weather conditions.

Improved Ship Maintenance and Readiness

Ensure the safety of ships by introducing more regulations and proper oversight

systems. Inspections, maintenance, and verification should be done periodically,

and funding should be provided to establish programs for fleet modernization, such

as retrofitting older vessels and investing in state-of-the-art technology.

Strict Compliance with Safety Guidelines

To ensure adherence to the already existing safety regulations and industry

requirements for marine activities, these include ships' stability, life-saving

appliances, emergency preparedness, and crew training standards. They may also

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


48
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

entail efforts geared towards increasing accountability and establishing deterrents

against non-compliance, such as enforcement mechanisms.

Coordination and Communication That Works

Efforts should be made to enhance communication and coordination between

vessel operators, maritime authorities, meteorological agencies, and search and

rescue organizations. Develop more efficient procedures for the transmission of

weather reports, emergency alerts, as well as operational updates to facilitate

appropriate decision-making in time when facing marine emergencies.

Investing in Human Resources and Training

Improve and strengthen training programs in emergency response procedures,

crisis management, and decision-making in high-pressure situations by placing top

priority on competency building for maritime personnel, particularly the crew

members, officers, and shore-based staff. Develop the safety culture within the

maritime sector to reduce human error and enhance the overall performance of

safety.

Constant Observation and Assessment

Develop arrangements for regular surveillance, monitoring, and audit of maritime

safety enforcement practices as well as data on accidents to unveil new risk factors,

trends, and scope of improvements. Study complex, multi-causal investigations and

the post-incident analysis techniques to establish what they reveal in terms of deep

causes, systemic problems, and useful lessons for the development of policy,

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


49
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

regulatory reforms, and industry best practices.

Global Collaboration & Cooperation

Collaboration is essential in any joint effort such as this, and it involves all those

interested or involved in the maritime sector within a country, regionally, or globally

to address common challenges, share best practices, and promote standardization

of rules and regulations. We should participate in capacity-building programs like

technical assistance programs as well as combined military exercises to enhance

the effectiveness of maritime safety and security along borders.

Improved Responsiveness to Emergencies

Invest in the evolution of strong and efficient emergency response capabilities,

such as constructing maritime search and rescue bases, pre-placing emergency

equipment at critical positions, and training staff on advanced rescue methods and

medical aid. Encourage harmonious action between various institutions engaged in

addressing a maritime situation to guarantee timely and effective aid to ships in

distress.

Making Use of Innovation and Technology

To enhance safety and efficiency at sea, consider the use of cutting-edge

technologies such as satellite-based navigation systems, real-time weather

monitoring instruments, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), and autonomous

vessels to foster a high level of situational awareness and accurate route planning,

in addition to providing immediate early warning. Invest in research and

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


50
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

development projects that will result in advanced solutions to increase the stability

of vessels, make them more weather-resistant, and improve safety performance.

Public Awareness and Community Involvement

In order to increase community involvement and raise public awareness of maritime

issues, an integrated program that equips key stakeholders—such as coastal

residents, travelers, and anyone involved in marine activity—with the knowledge

and abilities to respond appropriately in the event of a maritime emergency should

be developed. Engage in a range of educational initiatives, outreach programs, and

simulation exercises to improve comprehension and consciousness of emergency

preparedness, maritime safety protocols, and the need of reporting risks and

accidents at sea.

Protection of the Environment and Sustainable Development

It is important to explore how marine laws, rules, and practices incorporate

environmental protection and sustainable development concepts. Additionally, it

would be beneficial if steps were taken to reduce emissions, prevent marine

pollution, and preserve marine biodiversity in order to lessen the negative effects of

shipping operations on the ecosystem. Encourage the use of ecosystem-based

strategies, efficient coastal zone management, and sustainable fishing methods to

preserve the long-term resilience and health of the marine environment.

Provide training courses in ship handling, navigation, emergency protocols, and

crisis management for members of the maritime crew. These programs must be

founded on ideas that are proven to provide crew members the abilities, know-how,

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


51
SOUTHWESTERN COLLEGE OF MARITIME, BUSINESS AND TECHNOLOGY INC. PHILIPPINES 2022

and skills they need to carry out their duties in a variety of operational

environments. Make sure to employ simulation-based training facilities so that crew

members may practice emergency response methods in a hands-on environment

and realistic scenarios can be produced. By exposing them to challenging

scenarios such as inclement weather, engine malfunctions, or collisions, simulators

may help the crew develop crucial decision-making abilities and a sense of

collaboration. Provide specialized instruction to seafarers regarding what to do in

the event of typical maritime crises, such as medical emergencies, firefighting, man

overboard, and ship abandonment.

Working together towards promoting the resilience, preparedness, and safety

culture within the maritime sector will be possible through implementing these

recommendations, thereby decreasing chances of any more such events in the

future.

SINGLING PF MV DONA MARILYN ACCIDENT DUE TO TYPHOON UNSANG 1988


52

You might also like