Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Harees Project
Harees Project
Project management leadership is a process by which a project manager can direct, guide,
and influence the behavior and work of the project team towards accomplishing the project
objectives (Burke & Baron, 2014). So for every IT project to be successfully executed the
project manager has a key role to play as he has to guide and influence the team members.
The idea of effective IT project management has been discussed by academicians and
practitioners since 1978 (Alter & Ginzberg, 1978) as they say that considerable hopes in
improving the performance in software development have been placed in techniques and
guidelines that identify, analyze and tackle software risks by the project managers skills.
Software risks are incidents that endanger a successful development process leading to
hard and soft skills, he needs to have technical skills or competence in order to be able to
solve a problem that may be facing his team and that will also enable him to be able to solve
a problem that may be facing his team and that will also enable him to be able to delegate
task as he will know what functions in the project that various team members are most
1
that has greatly been contemplated on (Delone & McLean 1992: Jetu & Riedl 2012).
Regardless of the fact that there has been a lot of attention given to this theme, the failure of
et al. 2006). From 2003 to 2012, in large software projects 52% were over budget, late and
or had unsatisfactory implementation; 42% were either cancelled prior to completion or not
used after being implemented, and only 6% were implemented and deemed successful,
implemented on time, within budget and had satisfactory results (The Standish Group, 2014)
yet there has been no measurable improvements with regards to successful execution of IT
projects. A study carried out by the Standish Group (2013) comes out with the findings that
43% of IT projects that were carried out were failures and recommends that leaders ought to
plays a key role in regards to influencing project success, hence the project leaders ought to
lead their teams in incorporating various project management methodologies to in order that
Sub-Saharan Africa and other parts of Asia have carried out extensive studies on the issue of
Information Technology projects at Fintech Kenya, and the study sought to find out what
performance of IT projects. And brought out a good number of leadership aspects that are
projects. Karuiki (2014) carried a study on the influence of leadership skills on the success
2
of IT projects within the banking sector in Kenya. And he was able to establish on the fact
that the skills set that a leader possesses are very instrumental to the success rate of IT
projects for banking institutions as without those skills they cannot succeed with their
projects.
Lategan (2015) carried out a research to assess the impact of leadership styles on project
success in telecommunication companies in South Africa and from his study he established
that for projects to be successful the leader should be able to use a wide range of methods
whilst he draws on political and interpersonal skills, they ought to be innovative, have
respect for team members and make efforts beyond their ability in order for an organization
to be effective in executing their projects. Roque & Carvalho (2013) carried out a study to
Brazilian IT firms and from his research he was able to establish that risk assessment has a
significant impact on the success of their projects. This moreover did not indicate whether
portfolio project risk management influence the execution of projects on time and within the
given budget and due to the high failure rates of that are linked with projects, and a Chinese
manage the risks so that projects can be delivered successfully (Han & Huang, 2007).
To show that IT is big and influential in the city of Buea it has been captioned with the name
‘’Silicon Mountain’’ with IT professionals increasing by the days and carrying out complex
and demanding projects that are required of them. Recently BBC said that Buea is on the
way of being Africa’s next tech hub (Afro Vision Group, 2019, para 1). Further IT firms are
being created rampantly all to which they seek to carry out IT projects like the building of
3
Vision Group is a market leading IT outsourcing company in Buea offshoring world class IT
solutions and support services to small, medium and large scale enterprises worldwide and
they have grown despite all odds to an incredible height of excellence in engineering and
Putting into account the case of Makonjo Media one of the top IT medium enterprises in
Buea we did carry out a survey with them to know how instrumental the skill set of a project
manager is having an impact on the success of a project manager and they were able to give
us information about the issue of contempt that for any project to be successfully executed
the project manager has to be very skillful and not only possess leadership traits but also he
needs to have absolute knowledge and mastery in the domain of information technology
because most often IT projects fail due to the fact that the administrators are not very well
versed with the software developing knowledge and how to apply it as most often the project
team members are stocked when they are implementing a project and they need the
assistance of the leader to solve the problem, and often workers can be in disagreement as to
who is to carry out a task and if the leader is not good at task delegating he won’t know who
to appoint to carry out the task, and they further brought out that for a leader to be good in
software development he needs to have passion for the field and that makes him stand out.
In the field of information technology there are particular products and services that IT
Systems (IS) services. And medium enterprises information systems project failures are
4
common (Wenk, 2005) despite with the continuous advancement in technology in our world
of today. According to a survey (Bonnie, 2015) carried out in 2015 says only 64% of all
projects succeeded in meeting their original goals or business objective, and this as a result
of the fact that the leadership skills needed for the implementation of projects successfully
was lacking. After carrying out a pilot study with 10 IT firms we discovered that 3 out of 5
projects were successfully executed, 3 thereby stating that 40% of all projects carried out by
the medium enterprises failed the findings ties with what the survey postulates, despite them
this is in line with what we have seen in the field and that to us is a problem that Information
The Standish Group International (2009) indicated that 44 percent of software projects for
medium enterprises were unable to be delivered on schedule, within budget, or with the
required functions, and that 24 percent of all software projects were cancelled hence 68
percent of the ICT medium enterprises projects have failed to achieve their target functions,
this can be largely attributed to the limited ability of the project leaders on how to
appropriate aspects of leadership which includes hard and soft skills. Still in line with the
pilot study the researcher confirms these findings to be true and are being faced by medium
enterprises in Buea.
the hard and soft skills to influence the execution of their projects. With the advancement in
technology in this 21st century that has brought more sophisticated equipment’s one can see
it as a paradox with yet all these there still has not been an increase with the successful
execution of IT projects. The study seeks to find out what seems to be the challenges with
5
the successful execution of projects by IT enterprises and how the project management
ii. To what extent does task familiarity influence the execution of Information
iii. What is the influence of problem solving ability on the execution of Information
The main objective of the study is to determine the influence of Project Management
iii. To ascertain the influence of problem solving ability on the execution of Information
6
1.6 Hypothesis of the Study
Municipality.
H02: Task familiarity has no significant influence on the execution of IT projects in Buea
Municipality.
H03: Problem solving ability has no significant influence on the execution of IT projects in
Buea Municipality.
The findings of this research will be of great importance to Information Technology project
managers that and those who are involved in IT as a whole, as they will have more profound
knowledge on how leadership skills will influence the successful execution of Information
Technology projects. As this research will be able to let them know what type of leadership
skills they are to have in order to be successful in implementing their projects and how they
It will also be of importance to the enterprises from which we shall collect data from as it
will help them to know what skills the leaders have to possess for their project to be
executed. As some of them might not know on what leadership skills they are to develop as
they might be focusing on their technical knowledge and ability not knowing that they also
need a perfect blend of skills that will be key for them to improve on their success.
Furthermore, they shall have access to analyzed data and from there they will be able to
know where they went wrong and what caused their projects to fail.
7
This research will also provide a lot of educational knowledge to the society since every
member of society is involved in IT one way or the other. And it will be some sort of an
additional knowledge because they are the end users of the services that are being provided
by the IT sector and they don’t have a clear knowledge of what goes on as far as the
developing of these services or products are concerned, the challenges they face, the skills
that the IT personnel’s are supposed to have so that those aspiring to become IT project
Future scholars and researchers that will carry out studies in this domain are going to gain
from this study because it will serve as a basis for prospective research’s that will be carried
out and provide literature material for future research. Any future researcher that will be
interested to carry out work in this domain of IT which the researcher have carried out will
find this work to be of relevance to him as it will enable him to know how to go about his
research and all the literature materials that are embodies in this work will help them to
It will add to the body of knowledge on the influence of leadership skills on the execution of
materials that relates to IT projects and Leadership the research will go in to add more flesh
or ideas to this concept as IT is a very wide field as a whole, so being able to write on how
project management leadership skills influence the execution of IT projects has significantly
8
1.8 Scope/Delimitations of the Study
This study focuses mainly on IT firms that are of a medium size scale with employees of 10
and above and that are formally registered entities, With Project management leaders and
team members that have been part of projects that have been carried out in by their
organization within the Buea area. The focus here is on how the leadership skills of project
considered in the context of the project being completed on time, within the allocated budget
Chapter one provides background information, the problem statement, the purpose of the
study, research questions, and objectives of the study, hypotheses, significance of the study,
and scope and delimitations of the study. Chapter two provides on the conceptual
framework, empirical review, research gaps and theoretical review, Chapter three clearly
outlines the research methodology that the study will employ bringing out the area of study,
the research design, the target population, the sample size and technique, the instrument of
9
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATAURE REVIEW
The best project managers are outstanding leaders. They motivate, bring people together,
and accomplish great things, they are the pillars of any organization. They are the ones that
succeed. Leadership competence is not an optional project management skill, but a key part
of being a successful and respected project manager (Retfavi, 2013). Given the importance
of thriving in a project-driven world, the people who lead projects, who turn visions into
tangible products and services stand out. But it has been proven that project managers alone
can’t carry the burden alone of creating mature organizations whose project management
capability produces a strategic advantage. In fact as the pace of change continues to increase
leaders at every level must be able to speak the language of project management (Verzuh,
2016). There are essential leadership skills which every project manager must possess, and
Leadership skill is defined as an ability and capacity acquired through deliberate, systematic,
and sustained effort arising through talent, training or practice to smoothly and adaptively
carryout complex activities or job functions involving ideas (cognitive skills), things
(technical skills), and/or people (human skills). (Zenger & Folkman, 2012). Skills can be
classified to be hard and soft, hard skills are considered to be abilities that are gotten from
10
being taught and are easily quantified and nobody is born with them. Soft skills on the other
hand are subjective abilities that are more difficult to be quantified as it concerns mainly
with the way you relate and interact with people and it is more of who you are and they can
be learned. We shall be analyzing the components of these skills that are used in this study
2.1.1.1 Experience in IT
It is important that every leader is well acquainted with the activities that are concerned with
an IT projects as due to the fact that he has been around the milieu of software projects for
quite a period of time it enables him to be able to achieve every single task with ease, and
also be able to step in to correct team members were they are wrong, and clients turn to be
more comfortable when they know that he knows what he is doing (Westerveld, 2003)
Is of the fact that his continuous doing of a process or activities should help the team to be
more efficient, as a more familiar leader should be able to identify the appropriate technical
tasks that must be completed, estimate how long the tasks will take to complete, determine
the sequence of the tasks and effectively monitor completion of the tasks. This skill is
necessary for every leader as he knows what tasks to hold importance to its completion for a
project to be done within the desired time. And what amount of time will it take for the task
to be done and place the tasks according to their precedencies and is able to monitor and
evaluate the performance of the team towards completing the tasks. (Banker et al., 1991)
11
2.1.1.3 Problem Solving Ability
Is the project manager skilled at problem analysis and identification, in facilitating the
emergence of creative solutions, and in arriving at optimal solutions? When, under severe
time constraints, optimizing must give away to satisfying decision-making, can the project
manager just as effectively formulate, correct and acceptable decisions? Often the adhocracy
must quickly improvise a solution but cannot strictly ‘‘go by the book’’ and employ
established and standardized bureaucratic procedures. The willingness to take risk and
attempt innovative approaches can mean the difference between success and failure in
determining the best tradeoffs between quality, cost and time. The personal decisions you
make as a project manager have a direct impact on the success of a project and ultimately
the success of the business itself. At times, however, it is inevitable that mistakes will be
made. After all, it is impossible to make the best decisions all of the time. If and when the
wrong decision is made, an excellent leader will be able to put their hands up, be
accountable, and take responsibility rather than pointing a finger. (Einsiedel, 1983)
This is one of the processes that are involved in the project management process and it is the
dependent variable of this study. Traditionally, project execution is defined as meeting user
requirements within the budget and time specified (Atkinson 1999: Jha & Iyer 2007).
Although many authors have argued that these aspects do not represent reality. (Shenhar &
Dvir, 2007) emphasizes that project managers are supposed to pay a lot of attention to the
Increases efficiency (2) Brings positive impact to customers (3) Produces business success,
12
(4) Prepare the organization for future endeavors and (5) Affects the project team positively
between success criteria and success factors (Baccarini, 1999). Criteria are used to measure
success whilst factors facilitate the achievement of success. Project success criteria consist
Project Management Success – This focuses upon the project process and has three criteria:
Meeting time, cost and quality objectives, Quality of the project management process
Satisfy stakeholders during project management process (primarily sponsor and project
team).
For a project to be deemed as successfully executed it has to meet up with the above stated
criteria’s and all has to be met as the attaining of one or two of them does not seems to be a
genuine aspect through which we can measure the project’s success. As the project has to
meet up with the scheduled time of completion, at the same time not compromising cost and
the quality that is required of him to deliver. Product Success – This deals with the effect of
the project’s final product and has three criteria: Meeting the project owner’s strategic
organizational objectives (goal), Satisfy users’ needs (purpose), Satisfy stakeholders where
13
Independent Variables Dependent Variable
Experience in IT
Execution of IT Projects
Task familiarity
This theory is the oldest leadership theory that states that leaders are born not made as was
instigated by Thomas Caryle in the early 1900s (he states that leadership is mainly innate,
rather than being developed through learning) Bateman & Zeithanel (1993) further
emphasized that the trait approach assumes the existence of leadership personality and that
leaders are born and not made, the theory assumes that leaders are born and due to this belief
those that possess the right qualities and traits are most suitable for leadership. And the traits
they have a solely responsible to indicate if the person will be successful as a leader or not.
The characteristics of the trait theory of leadership is based on the fact that various leaders
have their own abilities both successful and unsuccessful leaders and their skills is a
predictor of leadership effectiveness, the resulting lists of traits are then compared to those
of potential leaders to assess their likelihood of success or failures, the underlying idea
14
behind the theory is that natural leaders can be nurtured to become great leaders. Some of
the common leadership traits are; Good cognitive skills and capable of using good judgment
and decisions, flexibility, creativity, charisma, emotional, intelligence, driven and motivated
to succeed, confidence, honesty and integrity. Achievement drive: high level of effort, high
levels of ambition, energy and initiative, Leadership motivation: an intense desire to lead
others to reach shared goals, Honesty and integrity: trustworthy, reliable and open,
This theory is relevant to this study in that it gives us constructive information about
leadership as from this theory we can have considerable knowledge on leadership, It can be
information on this theory to assess how their relevance in their organization can be made
stronger, It can enable project managers to have an idea of their strength and weaknesses
then they can make amends on how they can improve on their leadership qualities, The
theory brings out a good number of skills that leaders need to have and the once which they
Here are some of the merits of the theory; It is a naturally pleasing theory, It is valid as a lot
of research has validated the foundation and basis of the theory, It serves as a yardstick
against which the leadership traits of an individual can be assessed, It gives a detailed
knowledge and understanding of the leader element in the leadership process. Without
withstanding it also has a good number of demerits; there is bound to be some subjective
possible trends tends to be very long as more than 100 different traits of successful leaders
in various leadership positions have been identified. The descriptions are mere generalities,
15
there is also disagreement over which traits are the most significant for an effective leader.
The model tries to relate physical traits such as; height and weight to effective leadership
whereas most of them are more of situational factors. For example, a minimum weight and
height might be necessary to perform the tasks in a military leadership position, but in
There are also criticisms against this theory as it gives right to questions whether leaders are
born or made, and whether leadership is an art or science. Although they are not mutually
application of special skills and techniques. Even if there are certain inborn qualities that
make one a good leader these natural talents need encouragement and development. Another
criticism is that a person is not born with self-confidence it is developed, honesty and
integrity are a matter of personal choice, motivation to lead comes within the individual, and
the knowledge of business can be acquired, while cognitive ability has its origin partly in
genes, it still needs to be developed as none of the above stated ingredients can be acquired
The goal-setting theory was developed by Edward Locke and Gary Latham in the year 1990.
The theory states that people who have more specific, difficult but attainable goals perform
better than those with less difficult and general goals (Locke, 1990). The Goal setting theory
states that specific and challenging goals along with appropriate feedback contribute to
higher and better task performance. Goals indicate and give direction to an employee about
what needs to be done and how much efforts are required to be put in. ‘‘ The theory states
16
that goal setting is essentially linked to task performance’’. In the goal setting theory, goals
must be based on five principles in order to motivate they must have these.
The five principles are Clarity, Challenge, Commitment, Feedback, and Task complexity
which we are going to be analyzing beginning with Clarity; as it states that clear goals are
measurable and unambiguous. When a goal is clear and specific, with a definite time set for
its completion, there is less misunderstanding about what behaviors will be rewarded. So the
theory states that goals are supposed to be made clear enough so as to be easily understood
and they should avoid ambiguity when setting goals, as a goal is supposed to be direct to the
The next here will be the Challenge; one of the most important principle of goals is the level
of challenge. People are often motivated by achievement and they will judge a goal based on
the significance of the anticipated accomplishment. Rewards typically increase for more
difficult goals. As if you believe you will be well compensated or otherwise rewarded for
achieving a challenging goal that will boost your enthusiasm and your drive to get it done
Commitment: Goals must be understood and agreed upon if they are to be effective.
Employees are more likely to ‘‘buy into’’ a goal if they were part of creating that goal. The
notion of participative management rests on the idea of involving employees in setting goals
Feedback: In addition to selecting the right type of goal, an effective program must also
17
difficulty, and gain recognition. It is important to provide benchmark opportunities or
targets, so individuals can determine for themselves how they are doing.
Task Complexity: The last principle in goal setting theory introduces two more requirements
for success of goals or assignments that are highly complex, take special care to ensure that
the work doesn’t become too overwhelming. Goal setting theory has certain eventualities
confidence and faith that he has potential in performing the task. The higher the level of self-
efficiency will lead to a greater effort put in by the individual when they face challenging
tasks. While the lower level of self-efficiency, lesser will be the efforts put in by the
The Goal setting theory assumes that; the individual is committed to the goal and will not
leave the goal. And the goal commitment is dependent on the following aspects:
Goals are made open, known and broadcasted, Goals should be set, Goals should be set by
individuals rather than designated individuals, Set goals should be consistent with the
The willingness to work towards the attainment of the goal is the main source of job
motivation. Clear, particular and difficult goals are greater motivating factors than easy,
general and vague goals. Specific and clear goals lead to greater output and better
completion avoids misunderstanding. Goals should be realistic and challenging. The more
challenging the goal the greater is the reward generally and the more is the passion for
18
achieving it. Better and appropriate feedback of results directs the employee behavior and
Employee’s participation in goal is not always desirable. Participation in setting the goal,
however, makes the goal more acceptable and leads to more involvement. The researcher
choose to make use of this theory as it is applicable in the field of this study and it is found
to be of relevance within the study as every IT firm when they get into implementing a
project one of the major objectives is to meet up with the satisfaction of the beneficiary and
this is one of the dependent variable of this study; So in order to achieve the goal of the
stakeholders they can break it down to smaller goals and go progressively and track their
IT projects is all about delegating tasks to team members, so with the use of this theory it
applies to the field of study, as it entails to give directions to team members on what needs
to be done, the efforts needed of them to put in so as to accomplish a task that has been
assigned to them, And one of the independent variable in this research is Task familiarity as
it entails that the leader is supposed to be well versed in every task within the
implementation of an IT project so the more familiar the leader is versed with the tasks the
more he can assign, give directions and step in to make corrections to an assignment that he
Due to how clear the goal is made it enables the workers not to go out of track, and they
know the limit were they are to end and it enables them to be time conscious, hence making
them to work using a time frame and that will enable them to be time conscious, hence
19
making them to work using a time frame and that will enable the project to be executed
It also relates with the field of study as one of the soft skills that we will be making use of in
this study is Teamwork. As according to this theory, it states that employees are to ‘‘buy
into’’ a goal if they were part of creating that goal. So, IT leaders need to get their team
members involved during the planning phase of the project to also assist in shaping their
goals. So with these it makes the employees to know the goals better and understand what it
requires as they were part of creating the goal with that they become more effective and
leads to the end product meeting with the satisfaction of the end users.
With feedback it allows or creates an avenue for the desired expectations of the stakeholders
to be given to the leaders, also with the availability of information sharing it becomes
possible that complex and difficult goals can be re-adjusted. So IT leaders need to make use
of this aspect of the theory as after the execution of a project they should be ready to receive
stakeholders as they can only determine if the product was a success after it has gotten to the
market, and while they are implementing the project there need to be a means of
Here are some of the advantages or benefits of the goal setting theory; it’s a technique used
to raise incentives for employees to complete work quickly and effectively. So this theory
when applied makes employees to work faster than their normal rate and at the same time
being effective.
20
Goal setting leads to better performance by increasing motivation and efforts, but also
through increasing and improving the feedback quality. With the use of this theory it leads
to an increase with the performance through the motivation and efforts it places by the
Without withstanding the theory also has some limitations as at times some of the
organizational goals conflict with the managerial goals, as goal conflicts has a detrimental
effect on the performance if it motivates incompatible action drift. At times goals do differ
within the level of the organization and the management and as a result of that it has a
negative result with the performance as both level levels are not in line with one another.
Another limitation here is that very difficult and complex goals stimulate riskier behavior, so
the more complex a goal leads to actions which can be risky to the organization.
Furthermore, if the employee lacks skills and competencies to perform actions essential for a
goal, then the goal setting can fail and lead to an undermining of performance.
And lastly, there is no evidence to prove that goal-setting improves job satisfaction, as you
cannot determine if the employees are satisfied with the job done by them achieving a goal
as they may be working under duress to meet up with the goal and not satisfying themselves
The author of the theory is Eliyahu M. Goldratt (1990) with the publication of the Goal. He
focused his theory with another book ‘’Critical Chain’’ which was published in
1997.Basically the theory of constraints states that a small number of constraints prevents
21
any management system from achieving more of its goals. There is always at least one
constrain, and it is relevant in this work as during the process of implementing an IT project
it is of necessity for the project manager to be able to identify that constraint which can act
as a limiting factor and slow down or hamper the project from being carried out successfully
and the theory of constraints uses what is called a focusing process to identify the
constraints, with the focusing process which is all about identifying the constraints that can
productivity, and that has to begin with identifying the constraint as only an improvement at
the constraint makes a difference so it has to be identified first before efforts can be made to
improve on it then they go further to optimize the constraint as before adding capacity they
need to first of all use the capacity which they have in hand for example if they need
machines with a higher capacity to develop a software they have to first use that which is
ready and available before adding others, so to optimize will mean they do everything
possible to use the constraint to its fullest capacity, and all the non-constraints are to
subordinate their decisions to the constraint’s needs in the sense that much attention is to be
paid the constraint and with that there is a higher performance of the IT systems that have
been put in place, and the other principle is to find that link between the project achieving its
goals and the constraints that can hinder it and then lessen its vulnerability. So when you
have identified the constraint you then make improvements at the constraint that is going to
reduce how vulnerable it will affect the project by adding capacity so that will enable the
project to achieve its goals as the chances of completing the project successfully will be
higher had it being the constraint had not been known only for it to affect the project during
22
implementation. The theory has key assumptions which is called Throughput, which is the
rate at which the system generates ‘’goal units’’ or revenue through sales. The aim of every
IT firm is to ensure that the developed software meets to the appeal of the clients and when
that is achieved then a lot of revenue will be gotten from it like ‘‘WhatsApp’’ which is a
popular software used all around the world today is generating millions of dollars annually
due to its high demand from its users all over the world. The other assumption is Operational
expense which is money spent when generating goal units and Investments, All money that
is invested in the system (inventory, machinery) as in order for any software to be developed
the organization must incur some costs when they procure computer hardware’s and other
equipment’s that are needed so they ought to ensure that they generate a lot of
‘‘Throughput’’ which is sales to cover their costs. This theory is applicable in my field of
study as every organization dealing with IT has set of goals to achieve and there will be
constraints that can stand against them not reaching their objective, which could be to
complete the developing of a software within the allocated budget, time and desired quality
therefore identifying and optimizing the constraint is an important aspect for every project
The theory of constraints has quite a good number of merits that can be of benefit of PM
leaders carrying out IT in Buea as it enables them to be able to identify constraints that will
hinder the execution of projects, Gives alternative measures to alleviate the constraints,
Cause project managers to be oriented towards achieving their goals and also to increase
their sales and generate more money to their organization. One of the demerits is that it
doesn’t put into consideration time that is being used to alleviate or optimize the constraints
which can be a factor that will increase the execution time of the project, It also gives as a
23
remedy to a constraint to increase resources and in this case it will lead to an increase in cost
Source: www.projectmanager.com
Lee et al (1995) their objective was to investigate changes of the skills and knowledge
designed for data collection on computing trends and changing knowledge and skills
requirements. They came up with the findings that IT professionals who are well versed with
the knowledge and skill needed in technology, well versed with management of the
24
organization along with the personnel’s that enables them to be effective in leading the
Kirsch (2000) has highlighted that successful project management requires both hard and
soft skills. The objective of his research was to address the practical difficulties that plagued
most Information Technology projects that organizations were implementing at the time, To
provide a broad overview and assessment of past and current research on the implementation
of IT projects, and to provide suggestions for future research that will help in addressing
some of the challenges IT currently face. The research design he adopted was a descriptive
research and the method of data collection was by interviews. He came out with the findings
that for IT projects to be successfully implemented there is need for the combination of both
Thite (1999) His objective was to seek a three-dimensional (self, subordinate and superior)
survey on Australian organizations that had carried out projects that were either completed
or more than halfway through the deadline. The sample consisted of Project managers and
their subordinates who described the leadership behaviors of managers and their perceived
effectiveness. After carrying out the study the researcher was able to came out with the
findings that every leader of an IT project ought to have technical ability in order for them to
successfully execute a project and also they ought to adopt transformational leadership
rather than transactional which aims at getting compliance from subordinates by telling them
rewards and benefits they will get at the end and withhold it till they do what is required.
25
Karuiki (2014) did a study on the influence of leadership skills on the success of IT projects
within the banking sector. The objective of the study was to establish how leadership skills
influence the success of IT projects in Banks, Descriptive research design was used and the
sample size was 50 Banks. The study concluded that project manager leading characteristics
influence the success of the project positively, and it can be achieved through never ending
training and learning. And from his findings he made mention of the fact that there are seven
leadership skills that a good project manager possesses; communication skills, problem
solving and decision making skills, team building skills, conflict resolution skills, planning
and goal setting skills, sense of responsibility and time management skills. The researcher
recommends that every leader of an IT project needs to possess these seven skills mentioned
According to Wateridge (1996) within the IS domain there has been little research and
testing of project and the study seeks to investigate the key criteria on which the success is
judged, and the factor that are important in influencing the success or failure of IT projects.
PMs and collecting data from their executed projects, then he goes to the users and conduct
from the study shows that PM focus on achieving time scales and budget limits, Success
criteria and his research pointed out that there is a vast difference between the perceptions of
users and those of project managers on the factors that contribute to success of IT projects,
The conclusion is that for IT projects to be successful in the future, the criteria for success
need to be defined clearly, agreed by all parties at the start of the project, and reviewed as
the project progresses. After his study he recommended that PM should be concentrating on
26
success criteria relating to users and sponsors, and consequently the factors to deliver the
success criteria
Fintech Kenya. The study was to add to the existing body of project management leadership
the study identified four aspects of leadership which included; skills, experience, control and
style and investigated their influence at Fintech Kenya. The study explored a descriptive
survey design and a combination of both quantitative and qualitative methods. The targeted
population comprised of 100 full time employees at Fintech Kenya that included senior
managers, project managers, project team members and consultants. Data was collected by
the use of questionnaires. The study found that 68.11% of the respondents indicated that
leadership skills influenced performance of IT projects to a very great extent. 57.9% of the
Roque & Carvalho (2013) carried out a study on understanding the impact of project risk
The objective of the study was to comprehend the impact of risk assessment on IT project
performance and to investigate the degree of diffusion of project risk assessment in Brazilian
different companies in Brazil. The results demonstrate that adopting risk assessment and
planning has a significant positive impact on project success as project staff were able to
identify and take on measures to mitigate the occurrence of risks to greater extent. The study
came out with the findings that assessing uncertainties during the project, making use of the
risk management strategies and deeply understand the business environment are critical
27
success factors and they had a significant impact on project performance (P<0.05,
r=0.002,b=0.413). The results demonstrated that the impact of project risk assessment and
Jun, Quizhen & Qingguo (2010) investigated the effect of project risk planning on IT
projects performance focusing on a case of China vendor firms. The study sought to test the
hypothesis, Project Risk planning and control makes a greater significant positive
contribution to project performance at low levels of inherent uncertainty than at high levels.
The study made use of questionnaire to collect data from 181 sample of software project
managers and other key informants from software houses in Hangzhou City, China, by mail
and email. The respondents were required to provide information with respect to one or
more recently completed outsourced IS development projects. From the finding the study
found that there existed a significant positive relationship between project risk planning and
project performance (P<0.05, r=0.015, b=0.813). The results indicated that project risk
planning and control improve project performance making project complete within time
Addison & Vallabh, (2002) carried out a study on impact of project risk identification on the
research design. Data collection was achieved through the use of a structured questionnaire,
which asked respondents questions aimed at achieving the study objective. A total of 70
project managers from IT enterprises were sampled the method of sample selection that was
returned. The study found that software project risks identification of unclear or
28
knowledge/skills and lack of effective project management methodology and
mitigation measures influencing software projects completion within time and increase
profitability. The study further found that as management involvement increases, the risk of
performance. The p-value showed a relationship between project risk identification and
Julianne & Alexander (2013) carried out a study to determine how portfolio risk
objective of the study was establish whether portfolio risk management influences IT project
performance. Data was collected by the use of questionnaires, a cross industry sampling was
adopted to derive a sample of 176 firms. The results showed that portfolio risk management
shows a significant positive relationship with project performance (b=0.16, p<0.05). The
study concluded that IT project portfolio risk management, portfolio risk identification, risk
prevention, risk monitoring, integration of risk information into the project portfolio
project perfforrmance.
Research Gap
Some of the studies reviewed identify and laid emphasis mostly on the knowledge and skills
needed in technology and the acquaintance of the leader with the personnel’s and failed to
mention other aspects like leadership skills and styles. Some studies focus mainly on the
29
hard and soft skills and ignored other aspects that can have an impact on the success of the
project. Some studies focus mainly on one variable leadership skills and did not encompass
on other aspects of leadership like communication and interpersonal skills are some of the
required skills in software development projects. So to that effect there is need to adopt and
insignificant amount of work have been done in the less developed and developing
economies to examine the influence of leadership skills. To that effect this study seeks to fill
the existing research gap by investigating how project management leadership skills and its
30
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
Buea originally spelled ‘’Gbea’’ was founded by a hunter which came from the Bomboko
area. Coming from the Bomboko side of the mountain, they named the newfound land in
the Bakweri (whose headquarter is Buea) was Chief Kuva Likenye. Buea was the colonial
capital of German Kamerun from 1901 to 1919, the capital of the Southern Cameroons from
1949 up till 1961 and the capital of the West Cameroon until 1972, it has an area size of 870
sq.km with 67 villages. The German administration in Buea was temporarily suspended
during the eruption of Mt. Cameroon from 28 April until June 1909. Originally, Buea’s
population consisted mainly of the Bakweri people. However, owing to its status as a
University town and the original capital, there are significant numbers of other ethnic
groups. Buea has a population of about 131,325 inhabitants according to the 2005 census,
with an elevation of 1000 meters (including the villages of Bokwango, Muea, Bomaka and
other surrounding villages. And with such a thriving increase of population which has
brought about the creation of many enterprises the people of Buea have turn to be in high
need of information technology which is one of the trademarks of the city and also due to its
31
3.2 Research Design.
The research adopted a survey research design, as we intend to gather information not
available from other sources, it has an unbiased representation of interest, and the same
information is collected from every respondent, and we are going to use survey data to
complement existing data from secondary sources (Babbie, 1998). This research design was
making use of the design the researcher was able to find answers to questions by analyzing
specific variable related to project execution, By making sure that a multiple regression
model was applied to establish the influence of hard and soft skills on the execution of IT
projects in Buea.
Quantitative data was collected using a questionnaire developed for the present study, with
each section of the questionnaire taken on one independent variable and how it influences
the dependent variable. Each section of the questionnaire is to be answered on a five point
Likert Scale from ‘’strongly disagree’’ to ‘’strongly agree’’, each leadership skill was
members who have taken part in IT projects that have been carried out within the medium
enterprise. As this study did sought to provide explanations and personal insights from the
participants, open ended questions were preferred in order to allow them to express their
opinions about their knowledge which they have from past projects.
32
3.3 Population, Sample Size and Sampling Technique
The study had a population 32 IT enterprises in Buea according to the records of the
managers, who are directly involved in the projects of the IT enterprises within the areas of
study. This was because they are all responsible in the implementation and management of
projects in the enterprises and understand what leadership skills entails. This study made use
of all the population as the sample size for this study. Thus the sample size for this study
was 32 IT managers.
This study made use of the primary source of data collection. Primary data was collected
featured structured questions that provided quantitative data for statistical analysis. The
questionnaire design followed the objectives of the research, with the first part capturing the
hard skills and its independent variables on how it influences IT project execution, part two
capture the project leadership skills. Part three on other aspects which were not mentioned
and they are allowed to chip in other facts. Owen (2002) did recommend the use of
questionnaires for its potential in reaching out to respondents within a short time by going to
the enterprises in person and handing them in person and after a certain period of time return
to collect the filled questionnaires; ability to accord respondents’ adequate time to respond
33
3.5 Validiaty and Reliability of Instruments/Variables
Validity is defined as the degree to which a test measures what it purports to measure
(Collins & Hussey, 2003). Each item in the instruments was reviewed by the supervisor who
noted how each of the specified study objectives and research questions were captured in the
instrument. The researcher made use of content validity in order to see how it covered the
area of knowledge that it was designed to measure and how it did enable us realize the
objective of the study, By determining whether the content that the instruments contained
was an adequate sample of the domain of the content they are supposed to represent. Also
we made use of construct validity so as to adequately measure the psychological traits of the
study by being able to adequately capture information on the variables in the research and its
applicability in real life situations. And lastly, the researcher will make use of face validity
reader in relation to the grammar and diction, sequencing of the independent variables in
3.5.2 Reliability
Joppe (2000), defines reliability as the extent to which results are consistent over time and
an accurate representation of the total population under study, and if the results of a study
could be reproduced under a similar methodology, then the research instrument was
considered reliable. In order to strengthen the reliability of the instruments the mixed
quantitative and qualitative data gathering employed was helpful, and via a pre-testing of the
instruments with two experienced project managers and four experienced project team
34
members. Reliability was also enforced by correlating the scores of each questionnaire for
each variable. Pearson product moment correlation coefficient (r) was used to test reliability
of the questionnaire. The correlation coefficient of the halves was correlated by the
Spearman Brown Prophesy formula. The questionnaire was considered reliable if the value
for R was closer to 1.0 getting consistent responses when the same question was posed to the
same respondent more than once. And for secondary data we had to correctly interpret the
The study also employed an empirical model which was formulated to establish the
Buea region in order to best explain the relationship in the study. The multiple linear
Π = a0 + a1 X1 + a2 X2 + a3 X 3 + U … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … 3.2
X1= Experience in IT
35
X2= Task familiarity
While a1, a2 and a3 are coefficients of X1, X2 and X3 variables, and the aim here is to show
distinctively how each variable influences project execution, and U is the error term.
The study applied both quantitative and qualitative approaches for data analysis. The
collected data was well examined and evaluated by the researcher for completeness and
comprehensibility. For qualitative data, which was gathered mainly through by the use of
open-ended questions a qualitative data checklist was developed. The checklist was then
clustered along with main themes of the research to facilitate consolidation of information
and interpretation and it was then analyzed by content analysis. Content analysis is
order to measure the variables qualitatively. The data was then summarized, coded, and
tabulated, Data presentation was done by the use of pie charts, bar charts and graphs,
percentages and frequency tables. The data was then analyzed using descriptive which
included frequency, percentages, means and standard deviations. The data analysis
technique used was the Ordinary least square because it measures how well the observed
data fits with the distribution that is expected if the variables are independent, It tests the
hypothesis that the variables are independent, The tests compares the observed data to a
model that distributes the data according to the expectation that the variables are
independent. Wherever the observed data doesn’t fit the model, the likelihood that the
variables are dependent becomes stronger, thus proving the null hypothesis to be incorrect.
36
REFERENCES
Addison, W. & Vallabh, P. (2002) Impact of project risk identification performance of
software projects in IT enterprises in China. Journal of Project Risk Management
8(1) pp 17-27, November, 2002
Afro Vision Group (n.d) The evolution of information technology in Buea.
www.afrovisiongroup.com
Atkinson, R. (1999). Project management: cost, time and quality, two best guesses and a
phenomenon, its time to accept other success criteria. International Journal of Project
Management, 17(6), 337-342. doi:10.1016/S6263-7863(98)00069-6
Alhawari, S., Karadsheh, Talet A.N. & Mansour, E. (2012). Knowledge based Risk
management framework for information technology projects. International Journal of
Information Management 32(4), 50-65
Alter, S., Ginzberg, M. (1978) Managing uncertainty in MIS implementation. MIT Sloan
Management Review 20(1), 23-28
Babbie, E.R. (1998) The practice of social research (8th ed., pp. 301-310) Belmont,
California: Wadsworth Publishing Company
Baccarini, D., (1999) The logical framework method for defining project success. Project
Management Journal 15(2), 25-32
Bateman, T,S,. & Zeithanel. M.C. (1993) The proactive component of organizational
behavior: A measure and correlates. Journal of Organizational Behavior 14(2), 44-
61, doi:10.1002/job.4030140202
Baldwin C., & Von Hippel, E. (2011) Modeling a paradigm shift: From producer innovation
to user and open collaborative innovation. Organizational Science. 1(3), 38-49,
doi:10.1287/osrc.1100.0618
Banker, R.D., Chang, H.S., & Cooper, W.W. (1991). Equivalence and implementation of
alternative methods for determining returns to scale in data envelopment analysis.
European Journal Operational Research, 8(19), 473-481
Boehm, B.W. (1991) Software risk management: principles and practices. IEEE Software
13(4), 35-44
Bonnie, E. (2015) Complete collection of project management statistics
Byrd, T.A., & Turner, D.E. (2001) An exploratory analysis of the value of the skills of IT
personnel: Their relationship to IS infrastructure and competitive advantage.
Decision Sciences 32(1). Retrieved from http://www.jscript.org/journal/32-1/3324/
37
Burke, R. & Barron, S. (2014) Project Management Leadership (2nd ed). Southern Gale,
United Kingdom
Caupin, G., Knoepfel, H., Koch, C., Pannenbacker, K., Perez-Polo,F. & Seabury, C. (2006).
ICP-IPMA Competence baseline. International Journal of Project Management
3(15). Retrieved from http://www.jscript.org/journal/3-15/2133/
Carmel, E. (1999) Global and Organizational discourse about information technology (1st
ed., pp. 32-45 ). Springer, London, Britain
Chapman, C.B. & Ward, S. (1997) Project risk management: Processes, techniques and
insights (1st ed., pp. 54-68). Wiley, New York
Collins, J. & Hussey, R. (2003) Essays, UK(November, 2019). Qualitative and Quantitative
research methods. Retrieved from
hhtps://www.ukessays.com/essays/psychology/adopting-qualitative-and-quantitative-
psychology-essay.phpvref=1
Delone, W.H. & Mclean, E.R. (1992) Information systems success: The quest for the
dependent variable. Information Systems Research. 3(1), pp 60-95 doi:10.1287?
isre.3.1.60
Duncan, W.R. (2013) A Guide to Project Management body of knowledge. Project
Management Institute (4th ed., pp 25-48). Newton Square, PA
Einsiedel, N.P. (1993) What do we know about the effective project manager. International
Journal of Project Management, 9(2) pp 99-104 DOI/10.1016/0263-7863 (91)90068-
7
Faraj, S. & Sproull, L. (2000) Coordinating expertise in software development teams.
Management Science, 6(1) pp 54-68 doi/10.1287/mnsc/46.12.1554.12072
Glorefeld, K. (1994) Information Technology: Measures of Success and Impact. Project
Management Journal 3(3) pp 45-57, May 1994
Goldratt, E.M. (1997) Critical chain. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 150(2) PP
925-930 doi/10.1016/j.sbspro.2014.09.103
Gibbs, G. (2014) Analyzing Qualitative Data (U.Flick, Ed.) SAGE Publications, Inc
Han, R. & Huang, G. (2007) An empirical analysis of risk assessment and performance on
software projects. Project Management Journal. 37(2) pp 35-50 April, 2007
Leavitt, T & Whistler,H,J. (1958) Management in the 1980s, From the 1958 Issue, Harvard
Business Review 11(1). November 1958
Jetu, F.T. & Riedl, R. (2012) Determinants of Information Systems and Information
technology project team success:A literataure review and a conceptual model.
Communications of the Association for Information Systems 30(2) pp 44-57
38
Jha, K,N. & Iyer, K,C. (2007) Commitment, coordination, competence and the iron triangle.
International Journal of Project Management. 25(5) pp 527-540
doi:10.1016/j.iiproman.2006.11.009
Jun, G., Qiuzhen, R. & Qingguo, E. (2010) Effects of project risk planing on IT project
performance focusing on a case of China vendor firms. Project Management Journal
31(1) pp 32-43, May 2010
Juliane, S. & Alexander, K. (2013) Influence portfolio risk management influences IT
project portfolio success in IT enterprises in UK. International Journal of Project
Management, 26(2) pp 73-79, August 2013
Joppe, M. (2000) The research process. The Quantitative Report Journal. 8(4) pp 597-607.
Available from http://www.nova.edu/SSSS/QR/QR8-4/golafshani.pdf
Karuiki, T. (2014) Influence of leadership skills on the success of IT projects:A case of
Banks in Kenya
Kiioh, S. (2015) Influence of Project management leadership on performance of information
technology projects:A case of Fintech Kenya
Kerzner. H. (2001) Project management metrics KPIs and dashboards-A guide to measuring
and monitoring project performance. John Wiley & Sons Inc, Haboken, New Jersey
Kirsch, L.J. (1996) The management of complex tasks in organizations:Controlling the
systems development process. Organization Sciences 7(1)
Kirsch, L.J. (2000) Software project management:An integrated perspective for an emerging
paradigm. R.W. Zmud (Ed), Framing the domains of IT Management:Projecting the
future-through the past pp 285-304
Kloppenborg, T., Shriberg, A., Venkatraman, J. (2003) Project Leadership. Vienna, Austria
Kraut, R.E. & Streeter, L.A. (1995) Coordinating in software developments-
Communications of the ACM. International Journal of Information Management
7(2) doi:10.1145/203330.203345
Krishnan, M.S. (1998) The role of team factors in software cost and quality:An empirical
analysis. Information Technology & People 3(1) pp 20-35 June 1998
Lategan, V. (2015) The impact of leadership styles on project success in telecommunication
companies. South African Business Review 2(1) pp 97-110 January 2015
Lamb, L.F (2009) "IT", A Dictionary of Physics, Oxford University Press
Lapp, J. (2009) New Models of Leadership. Executive Excellence, 16(6) pp 20-27
Locke, E.A & Latham, G.P. (1990) A theory of goal setting and task performance. Academy
of Management. 16(2) pp 480-485 doi:10.2307/258875
39
Lord, J., & Hall, R. (2015) Matching the project manager's leadership style to project type.
International Journal of Project Management, 25(1) pp 21-32 doi:10.1016?
Mann, E.M. & Rutherford, S. (2002) Climate reconstruction using 'pseudoproxies'.
Geophysical Research Letters 29(10) pp 25-26 doi:10.1029/2001GLO14554
Mehta. A. (2011) Communicating in project management. International Journal of Project
Management 120(20) pp 23-32 doi:10.1029/2011JD016637
Mumford, M.D., Zaccaro, S.J., Johnson, J.F., Diana, M., Goldbert, J.A. & Threlfall, K.V.
(2010) Patterns of Leader Characteristics:Implications for performance and
development. Leadership Quarterly 11(1) pp 115-134
Odusami, K.T. (2002) Perceptions of IT professionals concerning important skills of
effective project leaders, Journal of Management in Engineering, 18(2) pp 61-67
Owens, L,K. (2002) Introduction to survey research design. SRL Fall 2002 Seminar Series.
Retrieved from http://www.srl.uic/edu/seminars/intro/aintrosm.pdf
Peslak, A.R. (2012) Information technology project management and project success.
International Journal of Information Technology Project Management, 3(3) pp 55-
68. December 2012
Pinto, J.K. & Slevin, D.P. (1988) Critical success factors across the project life cycle.
Project Management Journal 19(5) pp 67-75, June 1988
Sayles, L.R. (1979) Managerial behavior and a journey through time. The Leadership
Quarterly 10(1) pp 7-13
Retfalvi, A. (2013) Fixture and Setup planning and fixture configuration system. Science
Direct 12(1) pp 34-43. August 2013
Taylor,H., Woelfer, J.P., & Artman, E. (2012) Information technology governance in
practice:A project management office's use of early risk management as relational
mechanism. International Journal of Information Technology Project Management
3(3) pp 14-30, August 2012
Roque, R & de Carvalho, Y. (2013) Impact of Project risk management assessments of risks
on project performance in Brazilian vendor companies. International Journal of
Project Management 21(2) pp 97-110. May 2013
Shenhar, J. & Dvir, D. (2007) Reinventing Project Management:The Diamond Approach to
successful growth and innovation. Project Management Journal 5(1) pp 25-32
Sumner, M., Bock, D. & Giamartino, G. (2006) Exploring the linkage between the
characteristics of IT project leaders and success. Information Systems Management
23(4) pp 21-33
Standish Group. CHAOS. (2013). Retrieved from
http://versionone.com/assets/img/files/ChaosManifesto2013.pdf
40
Wagner, R.K., Sternberg, R.J. (1985) Practical Intelligence in real-world pursuits:The role
of tacit knowledge. Journal of Personality and social psychology 49(2) pp 436-4458
Wenk, D. (2015) Risk management and business continuity, overview and perspective.
Journal of Chartered Insurance Institute 3(3) pp 234-246
Westeerveld, E. (2003) The project excellence model:Linking success criteria and critical
success factors, International Journal of Project Management 8(2), February 2008, pp
411-421
Yang, R. (2011) The association among project manager's leadership style, team work and
project success. International Journal of Project Management (29)3 pp 35-40.
September 2011
Zenger.H & Folkman. R. (2012) The New Extra Ordinary Leader (3rd. ed) British
Columbia, Canada
41