Professional Documents
Culture Documents
International 3 - 5
International 3 - 5
International 3 - 5
com FOLLOW US
May 3, 2024 https://newsth.live/fb
https://newsth.live/whatsapp
INTERNATIONAL https://newsth.live/x
EDITION https://newsth.live/ig
20 Pages
Vol. 2 앫 No. 106
Chennai » Coimbatore » Bengaluru » Hyderabad » Madurai » Noida » Visakhapatnam » Thiruvananthapuram » Kochi » Vijayawada » Mangaluru » Tiruchirapalli » Kolkata » Hubballi » Mohali » Malappuram » Mumbai » Tirupati » Lucknow » Cuttack » Patna
PARLEY
COLOMBO RALLIES
INSIDE
쑽 Prajwal booked for rape; lookout circular issued
Karnataka govt. asks PM to cancel diplomatic State Home Minister says govt. will not protect Prajwal’s father, also named in the cases, skips
passport issued to the absconding Hassan MP accused, appeals to all victims to come forward the SIT summons and seeks anticipatory bail
The Hindu Bureau that she was “coerced to Rahul demands self before the SIT.
BENGALURU/KALABURGI/ have sexual relationship” External Affairs Ministry
Bengal Governor NEW DELHI with him. Based on the apology from spokesperson A. Randhir
complaint, Section 376 of PM over Prajwal Jaiswal said that they were
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
accused of sexual he Karnataka Pol- the Indian Penal Code, that not approached for “politi-
harassment
KOLKATA
T ice booked Hassan
MP Prajwal Revan-
na on rape charges on
deals with rape, has been
invoked against the MP.
He has previously been
SHIVAMOGGA/RAICHUR
Calling Hassan MP Prajwal
Revanna, a “mass rapist”,
cal clearance”; nor did the
Ministry issue any clea-
rance for enabling foreign
An employee at the Raj Bhavan Thursday, and issued a loo- booked for sexual harass- Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, travel by Mr. Prajwal.
in Kolkata on Thursday alleged kout circular against the ment on the basis of anoth- speaking at election rallies in
that she was sexually harassed “absconding” MP a day af- er woman’s complaint on Karnataka, demanded that ‘No clearance sought’
by West Bengal Governor ter he failed to appear be- April 28. His father is also Prime Minister Narendra Modi “No political clearance was
C.V. Ananda Bose. The woman fore the Special Investiga- named in the first case. In a apologise to the nation for either sought from or is-
lodged a complaint at the tion Team (SIT) that is new FIR filed on Thursday campaigning for such a sued by the MEA in respect
Hare Street police station probing his alleged sexual evening, Mr. Revanna was candidate. » PAGE 3 of the travel of the said MP
in Kolkata. » PAGE 4 crimes. also booked for kidnap for Burning issue: A Congress protest in Bengaluru against Prajwal Revanna. SPECIAL ARRANGEMENT to Germany. Obviously, no
His father and former allegedly playing a role in visa note was issued either.
Minister H.D. Revanna, abducting one of the vic- featured in explicit videos be conducted on the basis polls. He is now believed to detained as soon as he re- No visa is required for di-
Manipur violence who also skipped the SIT tims of Mr. Prajwal. which are being circulated of evidence collected be in Germany. ports at any of the immi- plomatic passport holders
FIRs reduced to summons, moved a court Earlier in the day, Kar- through social media, to through the fact findings,” Chief Minister Siddara- gration points at airports, to travel to Germany. The
seeking anticipatory bail. nataka Home Minister G. come forward and make the Minister said. maiah has already urged sea ports, or at border Ministry has not issued vi-
3,000 on review Parameshwara said a se- statements before the SIT. The MP is believed to Prime Minister Narendra checkposts. SIT sources sa note for any other coun-
Second complaint cond victim had come for- He said the government have left the country using Modi to cancel his diplo- said his return ticket has try,” he said.
NEW DELHI The charges against the ward and lodged a com- would ensure their safety his diplomatic passport on matic passport and bring been booked for May 15. The Hassan MP has now
A year after ethnic violence grandson of former Prime plaint against Mr. Prajwal. and protect their identity. April 27, a day after the him back to “face the full An advocate claiming to re- been suspended by the Ja-
erupted in Manipur, the Minister H.D. Deve Gowda The Minister also appealed “The government will Hassan constituency force of law.” present the Hassan MP had nata Dal (Secular), which
clean-up of records has were filed after a second to other victims, especially not protect the accused where he was seeking ree- In view of the lookout sought seven days’ time for he represents in Parlia-
brought down the total woman filed a complaint those who were allegedly and the investigation will lection from went to the circular, Mr. Prajwal will be his client to present him- ment.
number of violence-related
FIRs from over 11,000 to
around 3,000, a government
source said. » PAGE 6
Water slog India protests
Chinese road
Law and order a
Centre to train
police on new construction State subject, says
criminal laws
CHENNAI
in PoK valley SC on Bengal’s suit
The Union government has Dinakar Peri
rolled out an intensive training NEW DELHI Krishnadas Rajagopal
strategy for police and prison NEW DELHI
department personnel across India has registered its
the country on the new protest with Beijing against The Supreme Court on
criminal laws and to sensitise China’s “illegal attempts” Thursday categorically
them to the transition from the to “alter facts on the said law and order is a
colonial legacies. » PAGE 6 ground” in the Shaksgam State subject, after West
valley of Pakistan-occu- Bengal complained that
pied Kashmir, which faces the Central Bureau of In-
Rebuilding Gaza the Siachen glacier, the Mi- vestigation (CBI) claims
after the war will nistry of External Affairs “unilateral right” to inves-
said on Thursday. MEA tigate offences committed
cost $40 bn: UN spokesperson Randhir Jais- by Central employees with-
wal was responding to in State jurisdiction.
GAZA STRIP questions on Chinese road “Law and order is a sent. Mr. Sibal said the
The United Nations said on construction in the valley. State subject. Suppose a State had withdrawn prior
Thursday that the post-war “The Shaksgam valley is Central employee commits consent under Section 6 of
reconstruction of Gaza would a part of the territory of In- dacoity, will the case be in- the Delhi Police Special Es-
require an international dia. We have never accept- vestigated by the CBI on- tablishment Act to CBI in-
effort unseen since the ed the so-called China Pa- ly?” Justice B.R. Gavai que- vestigations within its terri-
aftermath of Second World kistan Boundary ried. Justice Sandeep tory on November 16, 2018.
War, estimating it could cost up Agreement of 1963 through Mehta, also on the two-
to $40 billion. » PAGE 14 Red zone: A resident collects drinking water from a pond in Sivaganga district of Tamil Nadu on Wednesday. G. MOORTHY which Pakistan unlawfully judge Bench, said when Ar- ‘No unilateral claim’
attempted to cede the area my personnel commit of- “It is not our case that
to China, and have consis- fences even within their there should be no investi-
tently conveyed our rejec- camp, officers hand over gation in these cases. But
Police make arrests, dismantle barricades at UCLA tion of the same,” Mr. Jais-
wal said at a briefing.
“We have registered our
the culprits to the local pol-
ice. Senior advocate Kapil
Sibal, for West Bengal, said
you cannot claim I have a
unilateral right to investi-
gate them by giving the
after clashes with students protesting war in Gaza protest with the Chinese
side against illegal at-
tempts to alter facts on the
“their intent is to get in
through the CBI, then use
the Directorate of Enforce-
Code of Criminal Proce-
dure a go-by. You cannot
say that the offences relat-
ground. We further reserve ment [ED] and then do ing to Central government
Associated Press officers spent hours threa- The protest group Occu- the right to take necessary whatever is to be done… employees will be investi-
LOS ANGELES tening arrests over loud- py Yale said campus police measures to safeguard our This has far-reaching gated only by a Central
speakers if people did not were violent during the ar- interests,” he added. repercussions”. agency,” Mr. Sibal submit-
The police arrested pro- disperse. A crowd of more rests and did not issue The Shaksgam Valley is Another SC Bench is ted. Solicitor-General
Palestinian protesters on than 1,000 had gathered warnings beforehand. The part of Pakistan-occupied tackling a similar question Tushar Mehta, for the Un-
college campuses across on campus, both inside a group posted a video on In- Kashmir, and was ceded by of law related to Tamil Na- ion government, said the
the U.S. overnight, notably barricaded tent encamp- stagram showing officers Pakistan to China in 1963, a du in the case of Ankit Ti- original suit of the State
at the University of Califor- ment and outside it, in sup- taking one person to the year after the India-China wari, an ED officer against was not maintainable and
nia, Los Angeles (UCLA), port. Protesters and the ground and pinning anoth- war. Recent satellite pic- whom the T.N. Directorate should be dismissed. He
where chaotic scenes police shoved and scuffled. er to a sidewalk. tures indicate that China is of Vigilance and Anti-Cor- raised the preliminary ob-
played out early on Thurs- Protesters chanted, In Oregon, the police building a road into the ruption had launched a cri- jection that disputes in ori-
day as officers in riot gear “Where were you last have started working to lower Shaksgam valley. minal prosecution for brib- ginal suits filed under Arti-
surged against a crowd of night?” at the officers, in clear demonstrators out of This has also been con- ery. cle 131 directly in the apex
demonstrators and made reference to Tuesday a library at Portland State firmed by official sources. The ED had approached court exclusively involve
arrests. night, when counterprot- Reining in: Protesters being detained by the police at the University University. The protesters The Siachen glacier is a the top court claiming the the Union and the States.
The police removed bar- esters attacked the en- of California, Los Angeles, on Thursday. REUTERS have been occupying the piece of Indian territory case be transferred to it as He said the Union had
ricades and began disman- campment and the UCLA Millar Library since Mon- wedged between China Mr. Tiwari was a Central not registered any cases in
tling demonstrators’ forti- administration and cam- student movement unlike sident’s home and to the day. and Pakistan. The 2020 government employee. West Bengal. He said the
fied encampment at UCLA pus police took hours to any other this century. The campus police depart- The protests at UCLA standoff between Indian The hearing before Justice Union was not involved
after hundreds of protes- respond. ensuing police crackdowns ment, school officials said. appeared to be getting the and Chinese troops in east- Gavai’s Bench was based and the CBI cannot be
ters defied orders to leave, echoed actions decades Protesters ignored re- most attention. Iranian ern Ladakh has made the on an original suit filed by made a defendant in the
some of them forming hu- ‘Unlike other protests’ ago against a much larger peated warnings that they state television carried live control of Siachen even West Bengal under Article suit. “It is the CBI which
man chains as police fired Tent encampments of prot- protest movement against were violating policy by oc- images of the police action, more critical for India. Chi- 131 of the Constitution has registered the cases in
flash-bangs to break up the esters calling on universi- the Vietnam War. cupying parts of campus as did Qatar’s pan-Arab Al na has undertaken a mas- against the Union govern- question. But the CBI is not
crowds. ties to stop doing business Yale University Police without permission, Jazeera satellite network. sive build-up and deploy- ment. The State alleged a defendant in this suit,
Numerous protesters with Israel or companies arrested four persons on school officials said in a Live images of Los Angeles ment along the Line of that CBI was probing sever- and it cannot be made one,
were arrested, their hands they say support the war in Wednesday night after statement Thursday. Two also played across Israeli Actual Control threatening al cases and registering as the CBI is not a ‘state’
bound with zip ties. Gaza have spread across around 200 demonstrators of those arrested were stu- television networks, as Indian positions in Dep- FIRs within its jurisdiction under Article 131,” Mr.
The action came after campuses nationwide in a marched to the school pre- dents, Yale said well. sang and Daulat Beg Oldie. without taking prior con- Mehta contended.
CM A IN-X
YK
THE HINDU
2 Friday, May 3, 2024
States Chennai
INBRIEF
쑽 Modi says Pakistan eager BJP fields Brij
to see Rahul Gandhi as PM Bhushan’s son
In four back-to-back rallies in his home State ahead of the May 7 election in Gujarat, Modi claims
from Kaiserganj
‘Congress is dying and Pakistan is crying’, takes a dig at ‘vote jihad’ remark by SP leader The Hindu Bureau
LUCKNOW
The Hindu Bureau gress veteran from Gujarat,
AHMEDABAD the CM of the State. The Bharatiya Janata Party
Cong. wants Karnataka quota rime Minister Na-
In Junagadh, the PM said
if Sardar Patel was not pre-
(BJP) on Thursday an-
nounced the candidature
model for the country: Dhami
Uttarakhand Chief Minister Pushkar Singh Dhami
P rendra Modi on
Thursday said Pa-
kistan was eager to see Con-
sent, Junagadh would have
gone to Pakistan, bringing
up the issue of the then Ju-
of Karan Bhushan Singh,
son of six-term MP Brij
Bhushan Sharan Singh,
on Thursday accused the Congress of aiming to gress leader Rahul Gandhi nagadh Nawab’s assertion from Kaiserganj Lok Sabha
replicate the Karnataka reservation model become the Prime Minister to make it a part of Pakistan seat and U.P. Minister Di- Karan Bhushan Singh
nationwide and claimed that a specific of India. “The enemies of during Independence. nesh Pratap Singh from
community in the southern State was added to the nation, including Pakis- Mr. Modi also took a dig Rae Bareli. The move drew choice, accusing the ruling
the OBC list overnight. Addressing an election tan, want a weak govern- at the “vote jihad” remark criticism from Opposition party of rewarding Mr. Brij
rally in ranchi in support of BJP nominee for the ment in India. They want a Prime Minister Narendra Modi during an election rally in by Congress leader Salman parties. Bhushan. “Just when we
seat, Mr. Dhami urged people to vote for the BJP corrupt government which Surendranagar, Gujarat, on Thursday. VIJAY SONEJI Khurshid’s niece and Sa- While the ruling party thought that the Prajwal
to protect the country from corruption, was there before 2014. Mo- majwadi Party leader Maria denied the ticket to Mr. Brij Revanna scandal [in Karna-
appeasement and dynastic politics. “At a time di’s strong government ised sections”. conspire” against Mr. Modi. Alam during a recent rally Bhushan, the former Wres- taka] had exposed the
when the country is moving towards the Uniform does not bow down to The Congress’s manifes- In central Gujarat’s in Uttar Pradesh. He said tling Federation of India depths of the BJP’s deprav-
Civil Code, the Congress says it will implement anyone,” Mr. Modi said in to for the Lok Sabha poll Anand, the Prime Minister that the country had heard chief accused of sexually ity, they show that there
Muslim Personal Law,” he said. PTI Gujarat, where voting will does not talk about reli- said the Congress was “dy- of “love jihad” but now a harassing women wres- are always new lows for
take place on May 7. gion-based reservations for ing and Pakistan was cry- Congress leader has talked tlers, sources said he was them to fall to,” Congress
The Prime Minister’s any community. ing”. “You all might have about “vote jihad” to defeat consulted about his leader Jairam Ramesh
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
statement comes a day after “When Congress re- known by now that Pakista- Lord Ram. replacement. posted on X.
‘Did not require bulldozers to former Pakistan Minister
Ch. Fawad Hussain shared a
leased its manifesto, I alert-
ed the country... I could see
ni leaders are praying for
the Congress’s victory... to Kshatriya anger
Mr. Karan Bhushan’s el-
der brother Prateek Bhush-
“The BJP’s slogans of
Nari Shakti, Nari Samman
maintain U.P. law and order’ video featuring Mr. Gandhi the image of the Muslim make the Shehzada [refer- In Jamnagar, the PM called an Singh is a BJP MLA. His and Beti Bachao are all hol-
on X (formerly Twitter) League in their manifesto,” ring to Rahul Gandhi] of on the former royal family mother Ketki Devi Singh is low, shallow, meaningless
Taking a dig at her political opponents over law with the captioned, “Rahul he said in his address in Congress the PM of India.” member Shatrusalyasinhji a former MP from Gonda. and bogus,” said Trina-
and order in Uttar Pradesh, BSP supremo Gandhi on fire”. Jamnagar. Bringing up of Mr. Modi, who has also Jadeja. The meeting was The family is influential in mool Rajya Sabha MP Saga-
Mayawati Thursday claimed she did not require a Addressing election ral- Pakistan in poll campaign served as the Chief Minister seen as a bid to pacify the Gonda and nearby dis- rika Ghose.
bulldozer like the present BJP government to lies in four different Lok and equating the Opposi- of the State for 13 years, had Kshatriya community, tricts. The BJP’s pick will Mr. Dinesh Pratap, a lo-
maintain rule of law in the State when she was in Sabha seats — Anand, Su- tion party with the neigh- in past elections as well eq- which is on warpath with contest against Narendra cal Rajput leader who con-
power. “When the BSP was in power in Uttar rendranagar, Junagadh and bouring country was remi- uated the Opposition party the ruling party over the Pandey of the Bahujan Sa- tested unsuccessfully
Pradesh, we did not allow Hindu-Muslim riots to Jamnagar — in his home niscent of similar with the neighbouring controversial remarks by maj Party; the Samajwadi against Congress leader So-
take place. Respect was given to all religious State, the Prime Minister sentiments during the run- country and accused it of the BJP’s Rajkot candidate Party is yet to declare its nia Gandhi in the 2019 par-
groups, their lives, properties and religious reiterated his claim that the up to the 2017 Assembly doing “appeasement polit- and Union Minister Par- candidate for Kaiserganj. liamentary polls, was re-
beliefs. “Have you heard of riots taking place Congress intends to create poll in Gujarat, when he ics”. In 2012 and 2017 As- shottam Rupala about The Congress, Trina- peated again by the BJP
during my governments in U.P. Whichever party reservations for Muslims in had accused former PM sembly polls, Mr. Modi had former princely families mool Congress and Shiv even as the Opposition par-
was in power here, be it the Samajwadi Party, the government jobs and edu- Manmohan Singh of “hold- said that if voted to power, and their alliances with the Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb ty is yet to announce its
Congress or the present BJP, riots have taken cation “by snatching away ing a secret meeting with the Congress would make British during colonial Thackeray) criticised the candidate for Rae Bareli.
place,” the BSP chief said. PTI the rights of the marginal- diplomats of Pakistan to Ahmed Patel, former Con- times. BJP for its Kaiserganj (With inputs from PTI)
Man arrested
for ‘sharing’
Priyanka promises reforms for tribals in Ajmer booth goes for repoll
fake video of biodiversity-rich areas of Chhattisgarh after presiding officer
Adityanath
The Hindu Bureau
The Hindu Bureau
RAIPUR/BHOPAL
elephant attacks [man-ani-
mal conflict] have been
more frequent. Your envi-
hi did not inherit wealth
but the sense of martyr-
dom from his mother and
misplaces register of voters
LUCKNOW Making a pitch for tribal ronment is being des- ex-PM Indira Gandhi. "Mo-
votes in Chhattisgarh, se- troyed. Which ever big in- diji cannot understand the The Hindi Bureau
The Special Task Force nior Congress leader Pri- dustrialist is coming here is sense of martyrdom," she JAIPUR
(STF) of Uttar Pradesh pol- yanka Gandhi Vadra on getting whatever he needs, said as she refuted the
ice on Thursday arrested a Thursday alleged that at- be it land or mines, but you Prime Minister’s allega- Repolling was held at a
person for allegedly post- tempts were being made to do not get it,” she added. tions that Rajiv Gandhi had booth at Nandsi village in
ing an Artificial Intelli- muzzle the anti-mining In her speech, Ms. Vadra axed the inheritance law Rajasthan’s Ajmer Lok Sab-
gence-generated “deep- movement in the Hasdeo also highlighted the Con- when he became PM to ha constituency on Thurs-
fake” of U.P. Chief Minister Aranya region, even as she gress “guarantees” for the avoid paying tax. day following the Election
Yogi Adityanath. promised reforms for tri- welfare and empowerment Morena is part of the Commission’s declaration
The Additional Director bals if her party returned Congress leader Priyanka of the tribal communities. Gwalior-Chambal region in of the April 26 polling as
General of Police and head to power at the Centre. Gandhi Vadra in Korba on “We want to implement M.P. that sees many youth void. The repolling was or-
of U.P. STF Amitabh Yash Mining and related de- Thursday. the Forest Rights Act joining the forces. dered at the booth, situat- An elderly voter arrives to cast his vote during repolling at Nandsi in
said the fake video was forestation has been a con- (FRA), this is our guaran- “How do I explain (to ed in the Nandsi’s Govern- Ajmer parliamentary constituency on Thursday. ANI
used to spread misleading tentious issue in the biodi- dustrlaists in Hasdeo but tee. There will be a specific myself ) when Modiji calls ment Senior Secondary
facts and strengthening an- versity-rich areas in the tribals were getting budget and plan setting my father a traitor, when School, because of the pre- mission. A total of 395 p.m. and webcasting of the
ti-national elements. tribal-dominant Chhattis- nothing. aside money for work that Modiji says that my father siding officer having mis- voters had exercised their booth was also done.
“On May 1, an AI-gener- garh. Resumption of min- “Today, your protest site can be done for you. The changed some law to get placed the 17-A register of franchise at the polling The Election Depart-
ated deepfake video of the ing in recent months have is being burnt,” she said, amendments that these pe- the inheritance from her voters. booth on April 26. ment has suspended three
U.P. Chief Minster went vi- resulted in protests, and referring to a recent case of ople have made in the land mother? Modiji will not un- The voters’ turnout dur- The repolling witnessed members of the polling
ral after it was posted on X triggered a political blame arson in which unidenti- acquisition law, which are derstand that my father ing the repolling was re- some tense moments when party for dereliction of du-
from a handle. The video game between the ruling fied individuals allegedly mostly weakening you, we did not get money and corded at 68.66%, as 517 of a few villagers tried to forci- ty while taking a serious
was used to spread mis- Bharatiya Janata Party and set the protest site of the will remove those amend- wealth but shahadat ki the 753 registered voters bly enter the booth while view of the loss of impor-
leading facts,” Mr. Yash the Congress. Hasdeo Aranya Jungle Ba- ments,” she said. bhavna (feeling of martyr- turned up to cast their bal- protesting against the ab- tant papers on April 26.
added. Speaking at a rally in the chao Andolan in Surguja dom) as inheritance. You lot. Chief Electoral Officer sence of their names in the A total of 14 candidates,
The accused, Shyam mining town of Chirmiri, a ablaze. Rally in M.P.’s Morena can understand this as you Praveen Gupta said the re- voters’ list. Police brought including BJP's sitting MP
Kishor Gupta, was arrested part of the Korba Lok Sab- “Your trees are being Later addressing a rally in have sent your sons to the polling was conducted the situation under control Bhagirath Choudhary and
and further legal action is ha constituency, Ms. Vadra cut, more than 15,000 Morena, Madhya Pradesh, border and they attain amid tight security arran- and sent the villagers back Congress's Ram Chandra
being initiated according to alleged that resources were trees have been cut. Be- Ms. Vadra said, her father martyrdom for this coun- gements as per the instruc- to their homes. The voting Choudhary, are in the fray
the law, Mr. Yash said. being handed over to in- cause trees are being cut, and former PM Rajiv Gand- try,” Ms. Vadra said. tions of the Election Com- was held from 7 a.m. to 5 in Ajmer seat.
‘Strong desire for change in Odisha, lack of performance has fuelled discontentment’
BJD run by group of bureaucrats, heavily dependent on imports from Congress, lacks strong leadership and grassroots support, says the Union Minister, who is the BJP candidate for the Sambalpur seat
campaigning in Sambal- the reins of Odisha. Be- migrations of labour in the seats. We are going to form Assembly constituency re- lack of strong leadership
INTERVIEW pur, he spoke about how coming a people’s repre- country. This is also a mat- the next government. presented by the CM, has and grassroots support.
the BJD is putting Odia cul- sentative is altogether a dif- ter of Odia Asmita. become the focal point of The party seems to be rely-
Dharmendra ture in jeopardy, the lack of ferent issue. Today, who is Where does this distress migration. Indivi- ing heavily on imports
basic facilities in villages, the No. 1 star campaigner The BJP is facing confidence stem from? duals from Ganjam, the from the Congress, with
Pradhan and rising unemployment of the BJD? A non-Odia. criticism for not home district of Mr. Pat- few remnants of the iconic
levels causing large-scale Whose photographs figure mentioning Odia pride Our interactions with peo- naik, can be seen across Biju Patnaik era within its
Satyasundar Barik migration from the State. in all its campaign posters? and refraining from ple across the State re- various industrial areas in ranks. The BJD is run by a
Edited excerpts: That of a non-Odia. criticising the BJD vealed a strong desire for the country, often under- group of bureaucrats and
nion Education Mi- during alliance talks. change. Despite being in taking low-paying jobs. there is massive resent-
Published by Nirmala Lakshman at Kasturi Buildings, 859-860, Anna Salai, Chennai 600002 on behalf of THG PUBLISHING PVT.LTD. Editor: Suresh Nambath (Responsible for selection of news under the PRB Act). ISSN 0971 - 751X
CM A IN-X
YK
THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 3
Chennai
States
Nationalist Congress Party The Hindu Bureau light between 11 a.m. and 3 cy is also considering a ‘hot The Karnataka State Natu-
(SP) chief Sharad Pawar on THIRUVANANTHAPURAM p.m. Those working under day’ alert for the State after ral Disaster Management
Thursday accused Prime the sun like construction temperatures soared to un- Centre (KSNDMC) district-
Minister Narendra Modi of ith tempera- workers, farmers, and precedented levels. wise minimum and maxi-
not basing his speeches on
facts and reality. Talking to
reporters in Kolhapur, Mr.
W ture staying un-
usually high in
the State, a meeting
hawkers should resche-
dule their work timings.
Workplaces roofed with as-
V.K. Mini, Director in-
charge, IMD, Kerala, says
normally warm night is de-
mum temperatures record-
ed from 8.30 a.m. on Wed-
nesday to 8.30 a.m. on
Pawar said, “I have never Sharad Pawar chaired by Kerala Chief Mi- bestos and tin sheets clared when the maximum Thursday showed that Ben-
seen such degradation of nister Pinarayi Vijayan on should be closed during temperature remains galuru Urban recorded a
the stature of the PM’s why Maharashtra was vot- Thursday decided to sus- the day. Workers living in equal to or above 40 de- maximum of 41.1 degrees
post. I feel Mr. Modi is a cri- ing in five phases in the pend classes in all educa- these types of roofed hous- grees Celsius and the mini- Celsius.
sis for the country.” current Lok Sabha elec- tional institutions, includ- es should be shifted, said mum temperature departs Many parts of Bengalu-
Rebutting Mr. Pawar’s tion, he said, “It is because ing professional colleges, Mr. Vijayan. from the normal by 4.5 to ru received rain on Thurs-
allegation, Deputy Chief Mr. Modi can campaign till May 6. The online meet- Scorching heat: A man uses a cardboard box to shield himself from 6.4 degrees Celsius. day evening after a
Minister and BJP leader De- here as much as possible... ing of the State Disaster the sun, in Kochi on Thursday. THULASI KAKKAT ‘Warm night’ Meanwhile, one more parched five months and
vendra Fadnavis said in Those in power are wor- Management Authority, With daytime tempera- person died due to sun- seven days. The IMD fore-
Mumbai the Prime Minis- ried.” which was also attended liday classes from 11 a.m. to Meteorological Depart- tures remaining unusually stroke in the State. Vijeesh, cast for Bengaluru City is-
ter is not a “crisis” for the He alleged that PM Mo- by Collectors, assessed the 3 p.m. Daytime parades ment (IMD) continuing to high and giving the people a native of Kozhikode, suf- sued on Thursday states
country, but definitely for di’s frequent remark that if possibilities of heatwaves and drills should also be issue a yellow alert for a harrowing time, the India fered sunstroke on Satur- that for the next 36 hours,
Mr. Pawar and his party. voted to power, the INDIA in the State and issued in- avoided at training centres heatwaves for Alappuzha, Meteorological Depart- day, and died at Kozhikode the maximum and mini-
“After Mr. Modi came to bloc would bring reserva- structions to mitigate the of the Police, Fire Force, Palakkad, Thrissur, and ment (IMD) has issued a Medical College Hospital mum temperatures very
power, what happened to tion based on religion, was impact of the heat. other forces, National Ca- Kozhikode districts, Mr. Vi- ‘warm night’ forecast on Thursday. Two indivi- likely will be around 39 de-
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
his party? Now the NCP is an attempt to create social The meeting instructed det Corps, Student Police jayan urged residents to along with a heatwave al- duals succumbed to heat grees Celsius and 25 de-
with us... I feel Mr. Modi is tension. schoolchildren to avoid ho- Cadets etc. With the India keep away from direct sun- ert for the State. The agen- stroke in the State earlier. grees Celsius, respectively.
definitely a challenge be- “We have never said
fore him. But the country this. This is Mr. Modi’s
loves Mr. Modi, and people creation,” Mr. Pawar said.
will respond to this criti-
cism through votes,” Mr.
Fadnavis said.
Mr. Modi has also been
speaking about redistribu-
tion of wealth and inheri-
Railways deletes reference to loco pilots watching cricket
tance tax, which does not
‘PM’s culture’ have any mention in the S. Vijay Kumar accident “happened be- After The Hindu pu- the use of Bluetooth devic- risk,” the circular said.
The BJP leader also said Congress manifesto, the CHENNAI cause both the loco pilot blished the report “Loco es of headphones. “This But with no evidence
that the PM used to call up veteran politician added. and co-pilot were distract- pilots were not watching blatant disregard for safety forthcoming later in the
Rashmi Thackeray to en- While campaigning in The Railway Ministry has ed by the cricket match cricket at time of crash” protocols is utterly unac- mobile data usage analysis
quire about the health of the State, Mr. Modi target- deleted the reference which was going on.” based on the final inquiry ceptable and places count- to substantiate the allega-
Uddhav Thackeray when ed Mr. Pawar, saying, made to loco pilots “en- He was referring to the report of the Commission- less loves at grave risk,” it tion that the loco pilots
he was in hospital. “There is a bhatakti atma grossed in watching a rear-end collision between er of Railway Safety (CRS) said in a circular. were watching cricket and
“It is the culture of the (wandering soul) in Maha- cricket match on their mo- Train No. 08504 Visakha- on Saturday, the Minister In a similar circular the the final investigation re-
PM to enquire about a per- rashtra. If it does not man- bile phones” in the Vizia- patnam-Rayagada Passen- clarified that the findings South East Central Railway port of the Commissioner
son’s well-being. You may age success it spoils others’ nagaram train accident in ger with Train No. 08532 of the CRS would be final. said, “Disturbingly, it was of Railway Safety not mak-
be in different political par- good work. Maharashtra safety circulars issued later Visakhapatnam-Palasa Pas- There was tentative initial The spot of the rail accident in revealed that the crew ing any mention about the
ties, but helping a person has been a victim of it.” Mr. which banned the crew senger between Kantaka- possibility that the loco pi- A.P.’s Kantakapalli. members were distracted same, the Railways have
caught in a medical situa- Pawar’s NCP (SP) is con- from using Bluetooth palle and Alamanda rail- lots may have been dis- by watching a cricket recalled the safety circu-
tion is our culture, and Mr. testing 10 out of 48 Lok headsets, official sources way stations in Waltair tracted at the time of the on duty. In a circular, the match on their mobile lars, the sources said.
Modi always follows it,” Mr. Sabha seats in Maharashtra said on Wednesday. Division of East Coast Rail- accident, he said. Southern Railway ex- phones, facilitated by the The railways have with-
Fadnavis said. as part of the Maha Vikas The issue pertains to way in Andhra Pradesh on Soon after Mr. Vaish- pressed shock that the use of Bluetooth devices or drawn the circular and is-
Mr. Pawar had also said, Aghadi (MVA) alliance with Union Railway Minister October 29, 2023, which naw’s statement, the Rail- crew members were en- headphones. This egre- sued a fresh circular after
“The PM is satisfied with Shiv Sena (UBT), which is Ashwini Vaishnaw’s state- left 17 people, including ways issued circulars ban- grossed in watching a gious disregard for safety deleting the portions refer-
targeting me and Uddhav fighting on 21 seats and ment made in New Delhi the loco pilot and his assis- ning the crew from using cricket match on their mo- protocols is unacceptable ring to the loco pilots
Thackeray.” Wondering Congress 17 seats. on March 3, 2024, that the tant, dead and 34 injured. Bluetooth headsets while bile phones, facilitated by and puts countless lives at watching cricket.
IN BRIEF
쑽
Sea voyage PM should apologise
for seeking votes for
‘mass rapist’: Rahul
The Hindu Bureau
SHIVAMOGGA/RAICHUR
News Chennai
The prizewinning explainer page dated September 3, 2023. W the last day for
filing nomina-
tions for the Amethi and
West Bengal Governor C.V.
Ananda Bose. The woman
lodged a complaint at the
night, a woman was alleg-
edly molested by the Go-
vernor under the false pre-
Rae Bareli seats in Uttar Hare Street police station text of a job,” the party
The Hindu wins top Pradesh that go to the polls
on May 20, sources said
in Kolkata.
The allegation came
posted on X from its official
handle.
awards at international Congress president Malli-
karjun Kharge had a meet-
hours before Prime Minis-
ter Narendra Modi was
The party has also
sought that “justice must
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
blished on September 3, organised on a simple grid seat he lost in 2019 to Un- shift to Rae Bareli, which is won Rae Bareli 17 times dra’s name has also been election benefits by ma- She alleged that she was
2023, has won three around world-class illustra- ion Minister and BJP leader deemed to be a “safer since the first general elec- doing the rounds for one of ligning me, God bless asked to appear before the
awards at the 6th Interna- tions” and every part of Smriti Irani. seat”. His mother and tion. The seat was first re- the two seats. On Friday, them. But they cannot stop Governor on April 24 when
tional Newspaper Design this page informs and en- Mr. Gandhi had won the former Congress president presented by Feroze Gand- Ms. Vadra is scheduled to my fight against corruption she suffered sexual harass-
Competition organised by gages readers. They went seat in 2004, 2009, and Sonia Gandhi represented hi and later on three address a roadshow in Fa- and violence in Bengal,” ment. The woman said she
newspaperdesign.in. on to add that the pages 2014. In 2019, he contested the seat from 2004. She occasions by Indira Gand- tehpur Sikri, some 500 km the Raj Bhavan said in a faced a similar situation on
were a “great balance of from Wayanad in addition opted out of the Lok Sabha hi. In 1977, Janata Party away from both Amethi statement, quoting the Thursday following which
‘Standout sports page’ strong visuals, detailed ex- to Amethi. This time too, election race this year, leader Raj Narain famously and Rae Bareli. Governor. she approached the police.
The Hindu won the ‘Best of plainers and well-edited he is in the fray from choosing to enter Parlia- defeated Indira Gandhi Sources, however, The ruling Trinamool Article 361 of the Consti-
show’ award; ‘Gold’ in the narrative text that com- Wayanad. ment through the Rajya here. claimed that she remains Congress said the “sanctity tution grants immunity to
‘Best of Sports Page’ cate- bined to deliver a medal- There is also specula- Sabha instead. Congress general secre- reluctant to make her elec- of Raj Bhavan has been tar- the Governor against any
gory; and an award of ex- winning experience”. tion that Mr. Gandhi could The Congress has tary Priyanka Gandhi Va- toral debut. nished”.“Appalling and un- criminal proceedings.
ELECTIONS 2024
Naveen Patnaik, closer to three Lok Sabha Baramulla fight simple choice on May 20. Congress fields
seats — Balangir, Kalahandi Whether they want to vote for
Pradhan file and Bargarh — which are BJP is against Delhi’s a local representative in Tsering Namgyal
nominations strongholds. might, RSS: NC Parliament or send a Delhi’s from Ladakh
The day saw heavyweights representative to Parliament.
쑽 filing nomination for the Lok 쑽 We have a direct contest with 쑽
Sabha poll. Union Minister Delhi’s might and Nagpur’s
Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik Dharmendra Pradhan and National Conference RSS. They have fielded their J.P. Nadda has The Congress on Thursday A majority of
on Thursday filed nomination former Minister Jual Oram vice-president Omar Abdullah, men against the NC and the become Jhooth fielded Tsering Namgyal from the leaders of
for the Kantabanji Assembly filed papers from Sambalpur who filed his nomination INDIA bloc candidates on all the Ladakh Lok Sabha seat.
Prachar Nadda... He said the INDIA bloc, including
seat in Balangir district, the and Sundargarh, respectively. papers from the Baramulla seats in Kashmir,” Mr. The Congress’s central
Cong.’s thinking on election committee has those of the Congress
second seat after his BJP spokesperson Aparajita seat on Thursday, said he was Abdullah said. “We will fight
traditional Hinjili constituency Sarangi filed papers from “up against Delhi’s might and for the snatched rights. I will economic inequalities is approved the name of Tsering and RJD, are either in jail
for the Odisha Assembly Bhubaneswar while BJD the Rashtriya Swayamsevak ensure I take the struggle to Maoist in nature. There Namgyal as the candidate to or out on bail. RJD
election. His selection of leader and former Mumbai Naveen Patnaik filing papers Sangh (RSS)”. Parliament and work hard, cannot be a bigger lie contest the poll from Ladakh, means corruption
Kantabanji as the second seat Police Commissioner Arup for the Kantabanji seat on “Voters in the Baramulla even though the opponent is JAIRAM RAMESH an official communication J.P. NADDA
assumes significance as it is Patnaik filed papers from Puri. Thursday. BISWARANJAN ROUT constituency have to make a very shrewd,” he said. Congress leader from the party said. PTI BJP president
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
Hindutva ideology believes that India’s growth is because of nationalism and not in spite of it; under the ideology, the Ram
temple is not seen as a distraction from, or barrier to, India’s development, but as an essential foundation and catalyst for it
News Chennai
INBRIEF
쑽 Manipur violence: a year Year since conflict,
kin of missing Meiteis
on, number of FIRs brought in Delhi seek closure
down from 11,000 to 3,000 Abhinay Lakshman
NEW DELHI
#Justice4MissingMeeteis”.
In the one year of the
conflict between the val-
The number of cases had shot up owing to overlap, several duplicate FIRs for the same incident Nearly six months after her ley-based Meitei people
19-year-old son Anthony and the hills-based Kuki-Zo
and thousands of zero FIRs, says official; Biren Singh appeals to people to surrender weapons
ED gets custody of Haryana went missing upon cross-
ing the buffer zone, Prem-
tribals, over 220 people
have been killed, thou-
Congress MLA’s son till May 6 lata Ningthoujam keeps a sands of others have been
Vijaita Singh violence stood at 150, plate out for him even to- injured, and tens of thou-
The Enforcement Directorate (ED) has taken the NEW DELHI while subsequently 71 had day while they eat their sands of people have been
custody of Sikandar Singh Chhoker, son of been killed, bringing the daily meals. A tradition in internally displaced. Amid
Congress MLA Dharam Singh Chhoker, in the year after ethnic death toll to 221. As many Meitei communities, the this, while the Meitei com-
case of Sai Aaina Farms Private Limited and
others for allegedly siphoning off hundreds of
crores of homebuyers’ money related to multiple
A violence erupted in
Manipur, the clean-
up of records has brought
as 15 members of the Kuki-
Zo community and 32
members of the Meitei
practice is something fami-
lies follow in the hopes that
their loved ones will re-
munity has said that there
was no news of 31 of their
people still missing, the
projects in Gurugram, the agency said on down the total number of community have been mis- turn. “Every time we clear Kuki-Zo people have said 15
Thursday. It is alleged that Mr. Sikandar had been violence-related first infor- sing for a year. the untouched plate, our of theirs were still unac-
absconding for the past four months and was mation reports (FIRs) from Mr. Singh said in a post hearts break all over counted for.
traced to Haridwar in Uttarakhand on April 30. A over 11,000 to around on X that the first phase of again,” Ms. Ningthoujam
court had issued non-bailable arrest warrants 3,000, a government deportation of “illegal im- said. Ex-journalist missing
against him. After arresting him, the probe source told The Hindu. migrants” from Myanmar She was among dozens In the national capital for
agency produced him before a special court, The number of cases was completed on Thurs- of people who arrived in the gathering, 47-year-old
which sent him to ED custody till May 6. had shot up owing to over- day as 38 immigrants left Delhi on Thursday in a bid Kabita Atom said: “I last
lap, several duplicate FIRs The first phase of deportation of “illegal immigrants” from Myanmar Manipur for Myanmar to make an appeal to find saw my husband on May 6
for the same incident and has been completed, the Manipur government said. @NBIRENSINGH/X through the Moreh border their loved ones — people last year. That afternoon,
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
thousands of zero FIRs, the check post. “Without any who were reported to have he was visiting a friend and
SC advocates’ association official said. Zero FIRs are
filed irrespective of juris-
ice armouries after ethnic
violence erupted in the
place in a village, several
FIRs were registered for
discrimination, we have
completed the first phase
gone missing in the course
of the ethnic conflict in Ma-
he told me on the phone
that he would be back
elects new office-bearers diction and are later trans- State on May 3, 2023. Till the same crime, a team of deportation of illegal im- nipur, which began one soon. We never saw him af-
ferred to the police station now, around 1,800 wea- was constituted that migrants from Myanmar year ago on May 3, 2023. ter that.” A former journal-
The powerful Supreme Court Advocate-on where the crime took pons have been recovered cleaned up the records,” with 38 more immigrants A group of Meitei civil ist, Atom Samarendra,
-Record Association (SCAORA), which place. or surrendered by the civi- said the source. leaving Manipur today society organisations had along with his friend Y. Ki-
spearheaded the case against the National Chief Minister N. Biren lians. The conflict is bet- According to a status re- through Moreh. A total of brought the families to- ran Kumar, had gone mis-
Judicial Appointments Commission, elected a Singh said that the people ween the tribal Kuki-Zo pe- port filed by the State go- 77 illegal immigrants have gether for a press meet at sing that day.
change of guard in polls held recently. Advocate should be united and there ople and the majority vernment on August 1 last been deported in the first the Press Club of India in “If he is alive, then we
Vipin Nair was elected president of SCAORA in should be no attempts to Meitei community. year, 4,766 regular FIRs phase. One Indian national New Delhi, stating that request that he be released
the election held on April 29. Mr. Nair, a former divide society. “Those who The government source were registered till July 30 was also brought back there was still no news of 31 and if not, at least his re-
secretary of SCAORA, has been a part of several have committed the crimes said that thousands were the same year. Out of 11,414 from Myanmar during the people from the communi- mains should be sent back
public interest litigation pleas, including those in should be prosecuted le- displaced and due to the zero FIRs, as many as 6,621 handover ceremony. The ty who had gone missing to us for the last rites,” she
the NJAC and the right to privacy writ involving gally. I appeal to the people prevailing law and order FIRs were converted to reg- State government is conti- during the conflict. As the said, adding that while the
Aadhaar. Advocate Amit Sharma, who represents from both sides to surren- situation, they registered ular FIRs, the report said, nuing the identification of families addressed the Manipur police registered
the Election Commission in the top court, was der weapons,” Mr. Singh FIRs at places convenient adding that “there is an illegal immigrants and at press, a poster behind a First Information Report
also elected vice-president. Advocates Nikhil Jain told The Hindu. to them, which also includ- overlap of offences”. the same time biometric them had pictures of those that very day, they had not
and Aljo Joseph were elected secretary and More than 4,500 wea- ed neighbouring States. The death toll in the in- data are being recorded,” missing, with the phrase: got in touch with them
treasurer, respectively. pons were looted from pol- “If an arson has taken itial three months of the he said. “Let them Rest in Peace, since about the probe.
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
It so happens that an unsolved problem in visuals of adults spewing white smoke
computer science, simply called the P from their mouth and nose. What the
versus NP problem, could hold the key to child said was garbled but it was soon
these modern-day conundra. While it may apparent the child had consumed a food
sound like a cryptic puzzle reserved for item infused with liquid nitrogen.
computer science mavens, its Television channels and online media
implications stretch beyond algorithms took up the issue. The Tamil Nadu
and data structures, rippling through government issued an advisory banning
diverse fields including healthcare. But the use of liquid nitrogen in food and
what exactly is this puzzle, and how could warned of stringent action against
its resolution unlock a new era in medical violators.
science? In 1991, The Hindu reported that a
Let’s start with a simple arithmetic London-based company developed a
example. Say you’re asked to multiply 17 system to improve the quality and shelf
with 19. With some time, you’d arrive at life of food by introducing droplets of
the answer: 323. This is a ‘P’ problem: you liquid nitrogen in the packaging. When
can solve it reasonably quickly. (‘P’ stands nitrogen evaporates, it displaces oxygen
for polynomial time.) Suppose you’re in the food pack, preventing microbial
presented with 323 and asked to identify action and preserving freshness.
the two prime numbers multiplied to get Healthcare is filled with complex issues like assigning doctors and nurses to shifts, booking operating theatres for surgeries, and organising patient The technique was useful in packing
this. In this case, you will have to take the appointments. GETTY IMAGES/ISTOCKPHOTO coffee, potato crisps, peanuts and peanut
trial and error route until you arrive at 17 butter, milk products, cheese, and dried
and 19. This is an ‘NP’ problem: it takes emerging diseases. Of course, patients’ and algorithms rely on problems that are potatoes, the article said.
longer to solve, but once you have the adherence will still matter. currently hard to solve, believed to be in As with every novelty, some chefs also
solution, you can verify it quickly. (‘NP’ Cancer is a complex disease with the set of ‘NP’, not ‘P’ problems. That is, experimented with liquid nitrogen to
here is nondeterministic polynomial myriad mutations. Deciding the best If P equals NP, we may have a way to these schemes protect secrets by hiding make food more interesting. In 2016, a
time.) treatment plan is an NP problem because quickly analyse bacterial genomes and them behind a problem that is very hard few upmarket restaurants and eateries in
Healthcare is filled with complex it involves considering all possible predict their resistance patterns, to solve but easy to verify. If P equals NP, Chennai and elsewhere used it to entice
issues. Consider scheduling in a hospital: combinations of drugs and therapies. If P these problems will become easy to solve, customers.
helping doctors prescribe the most
assigning doctors and nurses to shifts, equals NP, we may have an opportunity to rendering these encryption schemes But in August 2017, the then Union
booking operating theatres for surgeries, swiftly identify the optimal treatment for effective antibiotics. This would vulnerable to attacks and compromising Environment Minister Harsh Vardhan said
and organising patient appointments. It is each individual cancer patient and improve patient outcomes and combat digital security. in Rajya Sabha the government would
an intricate puzzle that requires potentially save many lives. The catch antibiotic resistance This said, healthcare isn’t the sole investigate the addition of liquid nitrogen
considering various factors — staff here is that we will still need a large beneficiary of this problem-solving. The
availability, urgency of medical cases, etc. volume of data. barrier that the P vs NP problem stands The Tamil Nadu Food Safety
— and potential changes such as Insurance companies grapple with NP of which they have unearthed for encompasses every field where the Department has issued a circular
emergency cases and cancellations. problems when they have to determine improvements to algorithms and new solution to a problem is blocked by the on the use of liquid nitrogen
The P vs NP question is this: could premiums and packages based on approaches to dealing with complex availability of significant computational
saying the substance can only be
there be a shortcut to solve ‘NP’ problems considering numerous variables like age, problems. resources. So these fields include
as quickly as ‘P’ problems? Because the health status, lifestyle, and medical Throughout history, there have been logistics, finance, and even climate used to preserve packaged food
implication is that if P equals NP, we could history. Having a shortcut to crack the P many instances of seemingly modelling, all of which could experience
quickly find the optimal solution to these vs NP problem could help these insurmountable problems being paradigm shifts if the P vs NP problem is in food and drinks served in some
scheduling problems, thus significantly companies optimise their overcome with innovative thinking. solved in favour of the P = NP outcome. restaurants.
improving patient care. decision-making and pave the way to Before the discovery of electricity, for The Clay Mathematics Institute in Six months ago, in Tiruchirappalli, a
The implications of resolving this fairer and more accurate premiums and example, candlemakers lit our world. Yet Colorado continues to offer a million vendor’s shop was sealed after authorities
question are profound and wide-reaching, conditions. Further, government most of them may never have foreseen dollars to anyone who can definitively found liquid nitrogen in food, the city’s
including for healthcare. spending on healthcare can also be the revolutionary consequences of solve the P vs NP problem. But for anyone designated food safety officer said.
utilised with minimal leakage while Thomas Edison’s incandescent bulb, who does, a million dollars will pale in “Liquid nitrogen, an inert, colourless,
Implications for healthcare programmes like Ayushman Bharat can which brought light to more people and comparison to the rewards they stand to odourless cryogenic fluid has traditionally
The P vs NP question is a problem in contribute more effectively to achieving for longer hours. collect by revolutionising various human been used in the management of many
mathematics and computer science, but universal health coverage. Similarly, following the invention of enterprises, potentially driving human benign pre-cancers and cancers since the
that does not mean it will be confined By solving these complex problems calculus and expanding the binomial progress in unimaginable ways. 1960s,” Arvind Krishnamurthy, professor
there. If an existing problem can be given more efficiently, we could potentially theorem to negative integers and As we look to the future, let us and head of surgical oncology at the
a faithful mathematical representation dramatically reduce resource constraints fractions, Isaac Newton considerably remember that problems that seem Adyar Cancer Institute, said. “This form
and is found to be an ‘NP’ problem, the and improve health outcomes. improved our understanding of the insurmountable today might not be so of treatment is generally used to manage
shortcut in question could help by irrational number pi. Why, the technology tomorrow. As with the candlemakers, the cancers wherein conventional surgery is
turning it into a ‘P’ problem. Surprising sources of progress giant Apple has been transforming our watchmakers, and even Anton van not possible or can be used as an adjunct
For example, antibiotic resistance is a While the P vs NP problem is a topic of expectations of what a watch can be Leeuwenhoek, the solution often comes to conventional surgery.”
significant global health concern. If P ongoing study in computer science, the expected to do in ways that Swiss from where we least expect it. Today’s The procedure involves using the
equals NP, we may have a way to quickly consensus among most experts is that P watchmakers may never have anticipated. brightest minds grappling with the P vs element at a frosty -196 degrees C to
analyse bacterial genomes and predict probably does not equal NP, implying that NP problem may be on the brink of a freeze and destroy cancer cells. “The
their resistance patterns, helping doctors some problems will remain very difficult Not all will be winners breakthrough that could redefine treatment is scientifically described as
prescribe the most effective antibiotics. to crack, even if a solution — once it is This said, one potential drawback of P healthcare as we know it. cryotherapy. It can also be used to obtain
This would improve patient outcomes found — will be easier to verify. But this being equal to NP, if ever that outcome (Dr C. Aravinda is a public health biopsies from cancer tissues for further
and help combat antibiotic resistance, has not deterred researchers from comes to pass, lies in the realm of physician and student at IIT Madras molecular analysis. Another application is
including new antibiotics discoveries for exploring this question, and in the pursuit cryptography. Many encryption schemes pursuing a BS degree in data science.) to use it as cryo-adhesion to remove
foreign bodies,” he explained.
Cryotherapy has been attempted to
treat many cancers, including those of
skin, bone, breast, cervical, eye, kidney,
Please send in your answers to liver, lung, and prostate.
THE SCIENCE QUIZ science@thehindu.co.in “Liquid nitrogen should be handled by
trained professionals with proper
protective gear, preferably in a controlled
lab or industry, as improper handling or
Revisiting malaria and its unique challenges consumption of liquid nitrogen can cause
severe damage to the skin, mucous
membranes, and internal organs,” the
Saumya Kalia speed up malaria Answers to May 1 quiz: surgeon said.
transmission. Identify the 1. Line beyond which human A day after the viral video, the Tamil
X cheapest and most-used activity is astronautic – Ans: Nadu Food Safety Department cited the
QUESTION 1 antimalarial drug to which Karman line Food Safety and Standards Regulations,
Malaria is caused by parasites mosquitoes have become 2. Line above which exposed and the Drug Administration department
transmitted through the bite resistant over time. water boils away – Ans: issued a circular on the use of liquid
of this category of emale X Armstrong line nitrogen saying the substance can only be
mosquito, discovered in 1897 QUESTION 4 3. Conditions in which water used to preserve packaged food.
by a British doctor. Name the vapour bubbles accumulate The department also warned of
This country made history in
mosquito and the doctor. in body’s fluids – Ans: stringent action, including fines and legal
2024 by launching the world’s
X
Ebullism proceedings, if it is used for other
first malaria vaccine as part
QUESTION 2 purposes.
of its immunisation 4. Entity of which around 1%
Which country contributes to (sujatha.r@thehindu.co.in)
programme. Name the is lost in every month in
more than half of the malaria
country and the vaccine. space – Ans: Bone
cases in the World Health
Organisation’s administrative X 5. Terrestrial counterpart of
Southeast Asia region? QUESTION 5 space adaptation syndrome –
X Which vaccine manufacturer Ans: Motion sickness For feedback and suggestions
QUESTION 3 has currently established Visual: Gemini 11 for ‘Science’, please write to
Global warming, population production capacity for the First contact: Vijayram X science@thehindu.co.in with the
displacement, and insecticide second malaria vaccine, Ganasala | ViswanadhaRao Visual: This chemist in 1939 identified the insecticidal properties of DDT, an achievement subject ‘Daily page’
resistance are expected to called R21/Matrix M? Batchu | Shiva Nigam that later won him a Nobel Prize. Name him. PUBLIC DOMAIN
CM A IN-X
YK
THE HINDU
8 Friday, May 3, 2024
Editorial Chennai
R
evenues from the Goods and Services
Tax (GST) crossed the ₹2 lakh crore mark phones. So far, the issues of regulating SEPs have is the co-author of The Indian response to the issue has been crores of rupees, before trial, are unprecedented
for the first time in April. The month of been left to the judiciary, which, as an institution, ‘Create, Copy, Disrupt: characterised by both judicial lethargy and in the history of commercial law for the simple
April has usually delivered the highest GST kitty has mostly missed the ball. India’s Intellectual judicial activism at the Delhi High Court. This reason that there is no provision in the law
as it involves taxes paid for activity undertaken in To begin with, it is important to understand Property Dilemmas’ may seem contradictory but a few facts will help granting judges such powers. In addition to being
March, when taxpayers close their books for the the importance of SEPs. These are patents that (2017) explain how India landed in this situation. unprecedented, these orders are also unfair to
year, scurry to meet tax filing deadlines, and cover technologies which are adopted by the In 2013, the Competition Commission of India defendants because they deprive them of
make adjustments to square off dues sought by industry as “standards”. For example, (CCI), acting on a complaint by Micromax began working capital (which is very expensive in India)
the revenue department owing to oversights or technologies such as CDMA, GSM, LTE are all an investigation under the Competition Act into for the entire duration of the trial (which can take
interpretation differences. With slightly over ₹2.1 industry standards in the telecom sector. Such the issue of whether Ericsson abused its up to eight years).
lakh crore of gross revenues, last month’s GST technological standards are especially important dominant position by demanding extortionate Yet, such judicial activism has been justified by
collection was 12.4% higher than the April 2023 to ensure interoperability of different brands of royalties for its SEPs. Ericsson challenged the the Delhi High Court by invoking its “inherent
tally of ₹1.87 lakh crore, which marked the high- cellular phones manufactured by different power of the CCI to do so, before the Delhi High powers to do justice”. Such similar logic has been
est monthly intake prior to the latest data set. Mi- companies. For example, once GSM was adopted Court, on the grounds that the Patents Act vested used in the past by the judiciary to justify activist
nus the year-end effect, revenues in subsequent as a standard, all manufacturers had to ensure the power to remedy an abuse of patents only measures such as “public interest litigation”. That
months will moderate so the ₹2 lakh crore figure that the handsets that they manufactured were with the Patent Office. the same argument has been used to justify
may not be the new normal for monthly GST col- compatible with GSM. Otherwise there would be The first round of litigation was resolved in activism in the name of the oppressed and also in
lections just yet. However, assuming the present no demand for their phones. favour of the CCI by a single judge on March 30, the name of multinational corporations
momentum of the economy continues and GST 2016. Ericsson then challenged this decision demonstrates how specious an argument it was in
revenue growth persists in last year’s 11%-12% Opaque model before the Division Bench of the Delhi High the first place.
range, last April’s high of ₹1.87 lakh crore could The process of setting standards in the Court, where it remained pending for an This judicial activism combined with judicial
well be this year’s monthly average. Bear in mind technology sector is largely privatised and astounding seven years until a judgment was delays will have a negative impact on the
dominated by “standard setting organisations” delivered against the CCI on July 13, 2023. The government’s attempt to attract more investment
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
that the average monthly revenues last year were
₹1.68 lakh crore, and before the year began, the (SSOs) run largely by private technology CCI has appealed against this decision to the in the manufacturing sector. These measures, by
highest monthly collection was seen in April companies. Countries such as India with little Supreme Court of India, where the matter government, have included payouts to
2022, at ₹1,67,540 crore. innovation in the telecom sector, have very little remains pending. As a result, India is the only manufacturers under the “production linked
Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman has influence over how standards are set or how SEPs major economy to not yet investigate the incentives” scheme for manufacturing in India. It
termed last month’s ₹2 lakh crore-plus GST reve- are licensed. potentially abusive licensing practices of is worth questioning the rationale of putting
nues a “landmark”, attributing them to a strong Theoretically, the companies which own the technology companies that own SEPs. money in the pockets of manufacturers, while
economy and efficient collections. This should SEPs, gain enormously because every While the competition law issues remained turning a Nelson’s eye to the manner and the
put to rest the Centre’s concerns from a few years manufacturer of cellular phones has to licence mired in litigation, the Delhi High Court amount of money that is being removed from the
ago that returns from the GST regime, now 82 the technological standards in question in order proceeded to hear lawsuits filed by Ericsson and same pockets by the owners of SEPs. More
months old, had been underwhelming. No to survive in the market. The lack of alternatives other SEPs owners against manufacturers of pertinently, unlike manufacturers who are
doubt, sustained action against frauds, such as also means that owners of SEPs can demand cellular phones on the question of whether the investing in India to create jobs, the owners of
fake invoicing, and stricter compliance norms extortionary royalties or licensing terms from The latter were infringing SEPs owned by the former SEPs are only taking their money out of the
have helped shore up revenues. With central GST manufacturers that block competition. In government and whether damages were payable. Ideally the country.
revenues overshooting last year’s targets, meet- economics, this is called the “patent holdup” infringement lawsuits should have been stayed
must put in
ing the goals set in the interim Budget for 2024-25 problem. In theory, the SSOs are supposed to until the competition law issues were resolved. The case of Europe
prevent such a scenario by requiring the owners place measures The ordinary course of such litigation in most It is time for the Indian government to intervene
now requires less than 10% revenue growth. For
of SEPs to licence their technologies at a fair, to regulate countries is for the courts to conduct a trial on and put in place measures to regulate SEPs before
the next government, the easy part would be to
upgrade revenue targets in the full Budget. The reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND) rate. standard the validity of the patents, whether there has the judiciary causes further damage to India’s
more critical imperative is to plan and execute In practice, this model of self-regulation by the essential been infringement and, if so, the damages manufacturing dreams. India will not be an
the expansion of the GST net, and expedite the technology industry has been marked with patents before payable. These trials are complex and can take outlier if it intervenes. The European Parliament
long-awaited reboot of its complex rate structure opacity and has failed rather spectacularly, as the judiciary time. For example, one of the early lawsuits filed has already enacted one such set of measures to
to make it a truly simple tax for consumers and evidenced by the record fines that some of these by Ericsson against Lava International took eight regulate SEPs. India, arguably, has a much
causes further
investors, now that revenue worries are relatively SEP owners have had to cough up across the years to be decided in a remarkable judgment, stronger case to push for similar, if not stronger
world for engaging in anti-competitive practices. damage to running into 500 pages, and delivered by Justice regulatory measures, since it has no say in how
muted. Incidentally, the BJP’s election manifesto,
The largest of these SEP owners, Qualcomm, has India’s Amit Bansal of the Delhi High Court, recently. SEPs are selected by SSOs, while also being
which takes credit for ringing in GST, only pro-
mises to make its portal simpler for small busi- been fined $975 million by China (2015), $873 manufacturing The problem, however, is the manner in which compelled by international agreements to enforce
nesses to use. The Congress has assured a switch million by South Korea (2017), $774 million by dreams Delhi High Court has granted “interim” remedies patents of foreign technology companies.
to a single, moderate tax rate with few excep-
tions, no levies on farm inputs, and sharing of re-
venues with panchayats and municipalities.
Smart GST reforms, informed by stakeholder
consultations, need to be at the forefront of the
Recognise ‘this leave’ as a woman’s right
agenda of whoever comes into office, to correct
anomalies that hold consumption back and set
S
ometimes, elections throw up an Tharoor, Congress MP from Kerala, introducing a legislation. For instance, Japan introduced
the foundations for the next virtuous cycle of in-
acceptance of and solutions to deeply similar Bill named The Women’s Sexual, menstrual leave in 1947, Indonesia in 1948, and
vestment and growth.
institutionalised gender biases and Reproductive and Menstrual Rights Bill, 2018. South Korea. Taiwan and Vietnam have also
discrimination against women. In the run-up to Hibi Eden, Congress MP from Kerala, also implemented paid leave. In relation to the Asian
Eastern front the general election 2024, the election manifesto
of the ruling political party in Tamil Nadu, the
introduced a private member Bill titled The Right
to Women to Menstrual Leave and Free Access to
countries, the progress made by the western
world, except in Sweden and Spain, is still
Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK), has made a Rehnamol Menstrual Health Products Bill, 2022. abysmal. Several international organisations have
Polarisation of votes in West Bengal is Raveendran
promise (under the topic “Women’s welfare”) The Supreme Court of India, early in 2023, promoted menstrual leave as a women’s right.
edging out the Left and the Congress that the “DMK will insist that the Union refused to entertain a public interest litigation in For instance, an International Labour
teaches political
government enact a law providing menstrual Shailendra Mani Tripathi vs Union of India which Organisation report, in 2003, asked nations to
T
he Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) nurtures science at the
high hopes in West Bengal, where it won leave to women, emphasizing the journey University of sought direction to the state on menstrual leave; recognise menstrual leave. The World Health
18 of the 42 seats, and 40% vote share in towards gender equality.” This promise has been Allahabad it was of the opinion that it is in the policy Organization recognised a non-governmental
2019. This dramatic rise from two seats in 2014 made after a debate in the 17th Lok Sabha, in domain of the government. By December 2023, organisation driven World Menstrual Hygiene Day
gave the party the confidence to present itself as December 2023, on menstrual leave, but with no the central government refused to agree on such on May 28 from 2014. However, India’s new code
the principal opposition in the 2021 Assembly outcome. a policy, and the Bharatiya Janata Party manifesto on Social Security, 2020, passed by Parliament,
polls, but the Mamata Banerjee-led All India Tri- for the general election 2024, the ‘Sankalp Patra which consolidated existing labour laws (yet to be
namool Congress (TMC) stormed back to power Legislators and Bills 2024’, has made no mention of it. The Congress notified), has not included the aspect of
for a third term. With 77 of the 294 Assembly In December 2021, S. Jothimani, Congress party’s manifesto for the general election 2024, menstrual leave in its code.
seats, and a 38.1% vote share, the BJP came a dis- Member of Parliament (MP) from Tamil Nadu, the ‘Nyaya Patra’ has also not mentioned Women labourers in the sugarcane fields of
tant second. This year, the polling in the State is had introduced a Private Member Bill named, menstrual leave, but under the subject of Maharashtra and agricultural labourers in
spread across all seven phases of the general elec- ‘Right to Menstrual Hygiene and Paid Leave Bill, “Health” has promised that “all employers shall Telangana have been documented to have
tion, and the BJP is pulling out all stops in the 2019’, which sought to bring menstrual leave into mandatorily grant paid maternity leave for their hysterectomies as menstrual-related absences
hope it could improve its tally which could also the ambit of the rights of a woman, and a refusal employees”. could endanger their livelihoods. It is time the
compensate for any electoral loss elsewhere. The of such leave into the domain of The Sexual Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment
BJP is keeping the TMC on the defensive with alle- Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Progressive Indian States, Asian nations Guarantee Act and laws governing industrial
gations of corruption, the land grab and sexual Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013. It also History shows us that some States were ahead of labour and other establishments recognise
assault at Sandeshkhali, and the school recruit- sought to impose a penalty for refusal. the times. For instance, the Kerala Sahitya menstrual leave like the way progressive gig
ment scam. The Calcutta High Court terminated The Bill that envisaged menstrual rights for Academy published work, Kerala in 19th Century, worker platforms such as Swiggy and Zomato
about 25,000 teacher appointments which is a women stipulates that every woman shall be mentions that Kerala was the first (in then Cochin have.
shot in the arm for the BJP. The TMC’s campaign entitled to the right to self-perception of her State) to recognise the need for “ period leave”
against the BJP is centred on New Delhi’s stop- menstruation, including but not limited to for students and allowed it during examinations Greater gender sensitivity needed
page of funds to the State under central schemes menarche (first menstruation), menopause, in 1912. In a recent progressive attempt, Kerala Policy solutions to gender inequalities that are
and the Citizenship (Amendment) Act. It is also menstrual cycle, primary or secondary has encouraged the use of other menstrual defined by differentiated gender experiences of
banking on its cash transfer schemes such as dysmenorrhea (menstrual pain). The Bill sought hygiene products and made them available for women owing to socio-cultural and biological
remedies in the form of: rights, including paid A more students. Bihar, in 1992, allowed government reasons will not only ensure equity but also bring
Lakshmir Bhandar for women. Highlighting the
issue of women’s safety, the BJP has fielded a wo- leave for three days; right to leave or absence for pronounced employees two-day menstrual leave. Kerala, in new social change. The instrumentality of public
man from Sandeshkhali, the constituency that three days for students above class eight; right to stand by January 2023, introduced menstrual and policy and discussions on menstruation also lies
saw reports of assault on women. 30 minutes rest twice a day during the menstrual political parties maternity leave to all students above the age of in shattering taboos and creating a
The BJP hopes to perform better in the dis- period for employees/workers, and right to on the issue of 18. Other States must be reminded that the gender-sensitive world that is open to issues
tricts of north Bengal, where it had won seven menstrual hygiene management facilities and existing laws are not a hindrance for State which are hitherto considered to be clandestine
menstrual leave
out of eight seats in 2019, while the Trinamool’s equity for all women. governments to go ahead and notify the right to by conservative-gendered social standards. In the
Ninong Ering, who was a Congress MP from will boost menstrual leave. political domain, recognition of the issue by
focus is more in the southern districts with a high
Arunachal Pradesh, introduced a private member women’s rights On the other hand, many other Asian political parties this election season will be a
proportion of Muslim voters. For this, the TMC is
also battling the Left-Congress coalition. The al- Bill on menstrual leave in 2017 (the Menstruation and gender countries have ended the prejudices and major step to promote women’s rights and
liance may turn out to be a factor in certain seats Benefit Bill, 2017). This was followed by Shashi equality stereotypes around menstruation using gender equality.
in the minority-dominated districts of Malda and
Murshidabad, and the decision of the Indian Sec-
ular Front to walk out of the alliance is likely to LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
work to the advantage of the TMC. The BJP is
bringing up Ram Mandir, violence during Ram Hill stations, summer rush could board and alight at many of the reservoirs in Local people will be put to her popular singer husband melodies ever. Once while
Navami processions and the illegal movement of There is no doubt that their will after ensuring that the Nilgiris are cause for hardship if curbs are A.V. Ramanan, and star at a bus stop opposite a tea
people across the India-Bangladesh border. Po- many of the hill stations in these buses operate to all worry. The district has had imposed on vehicular composer Ilaiyaraja, which kiosk, her song, “Aagaya
larisation of voters on religious lines had helped India, especially in the tourist locations every five cloudless blue skies for movement. This must be catapulted her to Vennilavae”, began to play
the BJP in the 2019 Lok Sabha election and the South, are facing grave minutes. All private cars long. It is also a fact that thought of in any move to nationwide stardom. Her on the radio in the shop. It
Trinamool in the 2021 Assembly polls, edging out environmental pressures should be left in specific the residents of the Nilgiris impose a cap on the unique voice earned her a was one time when I wished
the Left and Congress from the field. The Trina- caused by the massive parking spaces and not will be thought of last when number of vehicles into the special place in the hearts that the bus would reach
mool is also harping on the Bengali identity by influx of tourists. In allowed to operate to these it comes to the rationing of district. of music lovers. It is late as I wanted to listen to
presenting itself as its custodian and portraying connection with the e-pass points. Chaotic parking of water as the priority is to N.R. Ramachandran, unfortunate that her great the song in full. Her songs
the BJP as an interloper and being insensitive to plans for Kodaikanal and vehicles is a very common meet the needs of Udhagamandalam, The Nilgiris potential was not utilised by will live forever.
the interests of the State. For the BJP, West Bengal the Nilgiris, having issue in the hills. The hills commercial establishments. many music composers. T.S. Karthik,
is not merely about winning more seats but is al- battery-operated mini buses deserve better. J.W. Prabakar, Uma Ramanan R. Sivakumar, Chennai
so about expanding its foothold into a region that to all the important tourist T. Murali, Udhagamandalam, The Nilgiris The passing of playback Chennai Letters emailed to
claims exceptionalism. Some of the earliest argu- spots in these hill stations, Madurai singer Uma Ramanan is letters@thehindu.co.in
ments for a Hindu polity had originated in Ben- and at a fixed charge, can The peak summer season in deeply saddening (May 2). It Uma Ramanan sang some must carry the full postal
gal, and this gives the BJP hope. be thought of. Tourists The water storage levels in the Nilgiris is only in May. was her collaboration with of the most soul-stirring address and the full name.
CM A IN-X
YK
THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 9
Chennai
Opinion
A
yushman Bharat, the government’s To deliver PMJAY will be difficult until the trying to provide some form of universal
flagship programme to achieve public sector is strengthened. This is because healthcare. India is ranked 67th out of 189
universal health coverage (UHC), was patients will choose to go to an already countries in terms of out-of-pocket expenditure.
Nachiket launched in 2018. The scheme has Also, the Union government is meant to allocate
Mor overburdened private player.
two inter-related components: health and 60% of PMJAY funds, but the amount [it is]
wellness centres and the Pradhan Mantri Jan AVANI KAPUR actually spending is less than this. In some ways,
is Visiting
Scientist, Arogya Yojana (PMJAY) that aims to provide a PMJAY was designed to take care of [healthcare
Banyan health cover of ₹5 lakh per family per year for cost] shocks, as inpatient treatments can cost a
Academy of secondary and tertiary care hospitalisation to coverage, some have been quite low compared lot relative to outpatient treatments. But we
Leadership in over 12 crore families that form the bottom 40% to others, and even within States, the dispersion need to think about it in its entirety rather than
Mental Health of the population. PM-JAY has issued 34.27 crore of hospitals is skewed. Governance processes looking at it as bits and pieces.
cards. About 6.5 crore have received treatment make a big difference. In terms of claim
and there are over 30,000 empanelled payments, some States saw a delay of more than The government said this was a step towards
hospitals. However, over the past year, hospitals 45 days, while others paid the claims faster. providing UHC. Would you argue that the
in some States have reported they are owed What is also interesting is that there is a insurance model is not correct for India’s
hundreds of crores in dues, and some are concentration of claims in Andhra Pradesh, path towards achieving UHC? Has any other
reportedly turning away or taking in fewer Arunachal Pradesh, Rajasthan, Karnataka, country been able to achieve it through an
PMJAY patients. Does PMJAY need a design Maharashtra, and Tamil Nadu. More research is insurance model?
change? Avani Kapur and Nachiket Mor discuss The Rajiv Gandhi Institute for Chest Diseases in Bengaluru. THE HINDU needed to understand why this is the case.
Avani Kapur the question in a conversation moderated by NM: The insurance model, if defined narrowly
Zubeda Hamid. Edited excerpts: while 43% are private, the rest are government. NM: The issue of delays [in payments] should as separating the money from the provider, and
is Senior There is a belief that a private hospital delivers not have anything to do with poor or rich States; not giving budget-based allocations but saying to
Visiting Fellow,
Does PMJAY’s design need to be changed to better services and so people choose to go to a these are technology-enabled platforms. The the provider that if you perform, then you get
Centre for
Policy Research make the scheme more sustainable? private hospital even when they have a public fact is, in Shravasti district in U.P., for example, paid — in India, my own belief is that the
and Founder- hospital close to them. It’s possible that this is there isn’t enough hospital capacity. This is the insurance model, if restricted exclusively to the
Director, Nachiket Mor: PMJAY was required as there was not just an assumption: in most places, the driver of these differences. In most jurisdictions public sector, could have a big impact on its
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
Foundation for a belief that while the public sector exists and is chances of getting better quality care in a private around the world, there is an obligation for the performance, particularly in the poorer States.
Responsive supposed to offer universal healthcare for free, hospital could be higher than in a public insurer to have network adequacy. This means It’s almost become the only way many countries
Governance there were deficiencies in what it could do. hospital. We have not done enough to increase you can’t offer an insurance scheme unless you have delivered UHC, such as Thailand, Turkey,
Therefore, there was a need to allow patients to belief in the public health system. have hospitals nearby. That restriction is not Vietnam, and Uruguay. India’s current model is
access the private sector. I don’t think this Why would the private sector turn away there in India, so you can offer a card to no longer the dominant model. That is what is
scheme was ever designed to deal with patients? One, capacity. In many States, the somebody even though there is no way for him exciting to me about the NHA/SHA — we have
comprehensive universal health coverage or number of people per empanelled healthcare to go and claim it. And that is a key deficiency in the capacity to implement something like this.
comprehensive healthcare costs — it is currently provider (EHCP) is really high. In Bihar, it was much of the northern and north-eastern States. But it wouldn’t be in the way you’re thinking
at under 2.5% of total health expenditure. Our over 10,000 families per EHCP. So, you don’t And that’s where we need to pay attention. The about insurance perhaps, which is indemnity: I
research suggests that if you pool government necessarily have an adequate number of beds private sector is unlikely to go to Bastar and file a claim, I get refunded. Those approaches
departmental expenditure with PM-JAY and facilities to be able to cater to that demand. build a hospital. It would have to be led by the are a pathway to bad outcomes. This is the error
expenditure in many States, government health Two, the delays in claim payments despite the public sector for the foreseeable future. Medicare/Medicaid made in the U.S. in 1965 – it
expenditure may be enough to offer universal guidelines being clear about turnaround time. led to massive inflation in healthcare prices. But
health coverage, including drugs and Three, there are claim rejections too, which India’s out-of-pocket expenditure for health with the purchaser-provider split, I would say it
diagnostics. The reason we see high means a hospital takes in a patient, does the has decreased, but it still hovers around the is the only idea that can take us forward, but if
out-of-pocket expenditure in Kerala, for surgery, and then the insurance company rejects 47-50% mark, which is much higher than we restrict it only to the public sector and bring
example, is that the public sector, despite being that claim because of documentation errors or a global average. Do we need to look at a all the multiple pools of money together.
well funded, is unable to deliver universal technicality. Four, the Union government has system where outpatient care, diagnostics
healthcare. Its primary care is underutilised and put a cap on the amount you can charge for and drugs can also be covered? AK: I agree. I don’t think in its current design,
there is enormous waste and inefficiency. I different treatments. That doesn’t always work insurance is going to yield what we want it to
worry that if schemes are layered on top of a well for private providers. NM: We are making an error in equating PMJAY yield, which is not just reducing out-of-pocket
hospital-centric design, it exacerbates To deliver PMJAY will be difficult until the and health and wellness centres with expenditure, but also ensuring quality care. A
misallocation of government resources. In fact, public sector is strengthened. This is because government efforts on the healthcare side. The recent paper on low- and middle-income
there are distortions now: even a government patients will choose to go to an already largest component of healthcare expenditures countries and health insurance said the issue is
hospital that is supposed to give you free care is overburdened private player. Of course, private are government expenditures through the State not just whether government subsidy should be
now checking whether you’re authorised to hospitals charge more and may do unnecessary and Centre and they are multiples higher than channelled through health insurance or direct
receive PMJAY. Why? Have we created a barrier procedures, but what is often not spoken about what these two schemes are doing. These are subsidies to public facilities, but how do you
now? Because, while a high-income family can enough is that there is a burden on them supposed to include outpatient (OP) care: in reach a system where you have specific payment
handle a claim rejection or delay, a low-income because the public sector either isn’t performing fact, the bulk of the expenditure is on drugs and structures and non price mechanisms that can
family cannot. How can you deliver better or people don’t trust the sector to perform. OP care. Are there governments (in the world) actually change both provider behaviour and
healthcare to people to eliminate out-of-pocket that have a separate government-financed public also patient choice? In its current form, I don’t
expenditure? Where can the National Health How wide is the performance disparity sector and then added an insurance layer on top think PM-JAY is going to get us there unless we
Authority (NHA) and the State Health Authority among States under PMJAY? of it? I have not seen [this] because it adds to the focus a lot more on the public health system.
(SHA), with their ability to purchase care in an fragmentation of the overall health landscape.
organised, high quality manner, help you? I AK: Not only do hospitals not exist [in many And that is something we need to address to
think that’s the question we should pursue. parts], but even empanelled hospitals haven’t solve the problem of out-of-pocket expenditure.
been active. In Uttar Pradesh, for instance, 39% To listen to the full interview
Avani Kapur: Nachiket spoke about the supply have been inactive since empanellment, and AK: In the current design and given the fiscal Scan the code or go to the link
side, and I wanted to bring in the demand side. only 50% have been active in the last six cost, it may be too much to expect the current www.thehindu.com
It’s interesting that of empanelled hospitals, months. The States’ [performances] vary. In model of PMJAY to cover everything. But there
E
very time I have travelled to rural that his party had its ear to the ground or
areas in India during elections, I whether he was merely amplifying pro-
have run into astute voters who paganda that had already been running.
are aware of every aspect of the candi- This election, in Churu, Rajasthan, I
dates in the fray, including how many found that people feared that reservation
times they have switched parties, and would be scrapped. This time, I asked for
well-versed with the caste equations of the source. Why did they think reserva-
the constituency. This hyper awareness is tion would go? Pat came the reply: they
helpful for a reporter. It makes our lives had heard an election speech of BJP can-
easier when we meet a respondent who didate Jyoti Mirdha, who was contesting
is knowledgeable, eager to engage, and from the Naguar Lok Sabha seat, on
does not need to be persuaded to speak. WhatsApp. Building a case for voting the
However, the penetration of the Inter- BJP and its allies to at least 400 seats, she
net and mobile phone has also meant a spoke of “tough decisions” that needed
surge in disinformation. The challenge to be taken in the “country’s interest”
then is to separate the voter’s own perso- and that needed constitutional amend-
nal experience or opinion from propa- ments. However, neither her speech nor
ganda. Establishing this distinction is es- the reactions to it from the Opposition,
sential to understanding the impact of which has run a consistent campaign
various election campaigns and what against the BJP saying the “Constitution is
may influence voter choices. in danger”, mentioned any scrapping of
In the run-up to the 2017 Uttar Pradesh reservation. I was puzzled.
elections, while touring the western part Then, miles away in Chhattisgarh, I
of the State, I heard a common complaint heard people voicing this fear again. It
among people belonging to upper castes was clearly not Ms. Mirdha’s words that
and non-Yadav backward communities had prompted this reaction in Chhattis- X
against the incumbent government led by garh. When I probed further, the voters Women draw water from a well on a hot day in Kasara, a town in Thane district in Maharashtra. Maharashtra has registered 25 deaths from heat stroke since late March, the
Akhilesh Yadav of the Samajwadi Party. said they had been hearing about reser- highest toll in the past five years. Scientists have linked the early onset of an intense summer to climate change. REUTERS
They lamented that the government had vation for the last three or four months.
been building boundary walls for gra- One of them mentioned Mr. Modi saying
veyards, even as it took away land from in a speech in November 2023 that
cremation grounds. Nearly a week later, among all the “caste groups”, he consi- FR OM THE ARCH IVES A HUNDRED YEARS AGO MAY 3, 1924
Prime Minister Narendra Modi said at an dered four the biggest — “the poor, the
election rally, “If you create a kabristaan youth, women, and farmers.” Mr. Modi’s FIFTY YEARS AGO MAY 3, 1974 adjournment motion to censure the Plaintiff in the box
(graveyard) in a village, then a shamshaan remarks were a counter to the Congress’s Government on the arrest of Mr. George
(cremation ground) should also be creat- demand for a caste census. But the voters Fernandes and other important Railway London, May 2: Sir Michael O’ Dwyer was in the
ed. If electricity is given uninterrupted in believed, not without a nudge from the Talks if Ry. strike notice is labour leaders early this morning after a box all Thursday. In cross-examination he
Ramzan, then it should be given in Diwali principal Opposition party, the Congress, stormy debate. Mr. L.N. Mishra, Railway denied he had been guilty of tyranny, but was
without a break.” In hindsight, I feel I that if the reality of caste is ignored, then withdrawn: Mishra Minister, vigorously defended the action of the attacked for his opinions by the members of the
should have asked the people whether so will reservation. Government and said this was done because would-be oligarchy. Sir Sankaran Nair’s book
their opinion was based on their own ex- New Delhi, May 2: By an overwhelming Mr. Fernandes was working for a strike even as was translated and circulated in the vernacular
periences or whether they had heard this sobhanak.nair@thehindu.co.in majority, the Lok Sabha to-day rejected an negotiations were going on. by most provincial Governments.
CM A IN-X
YK
Chennai www.thehindu.com Friday, May 3, 2024
● ●
10
Text&Context 0
NEWS IN NUMBERS
The homes destroyed The aid pledged to The Myanmar The forest land in the Highest single-day
in Gaza, expected to Lebanon by the refugees deported Garhwal division migrant arrivals in the
be rebuilt by 2040 European Union amid border tensions affected by fires U.K. in 2024
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
Why have countries such as Singapore, Hong Kong and the U.S. announced an investigation into possible contamination of spice mixes sold by MDH and
Everest? How has the Spices Board of India responded? What has the U.S. FDA said?
A
t least five countries — checks of curry powders and spices to (Madras curry powder,
including Singapore, Hong detect and control the use of EtO in food Sambhar masala and Curry
Kong and the U.S. — have products and ensure proper powder masala) and Everest
announced an investigation implementation of regulatory norms. A Fish curry masala.
into possible contamination of spice recent CUTS report also recommended
mixes sold by Indian brands, MDH and updating food safety standards to align 쑽
Everest. The complaints cite the presence with global practices, and improving MDH and Everest’s spice mixes
of ethylene oxide (EtO), a toxic chemical information flow to food industries so that allegedly contain high levels of
used as a food stabiliser, beyond they better comply with regulations. EtO, a prohibited pesticide. EtO
permissible limits. The Spices Board of is a colourless, flammable gas
India in response has initiated mandatory Is food safety in India lacking? that was originally intended for
testing of products shipped abroad and is Simi T.B., who works with CUTS sterilising medical devices.
reportedly working with exporters to International, a global advocacy group for 쑽
identify the root cause of contamination. consumer welfare told The Hindu,
notwithstanding stringent food laws in GTRI assessed that if regulators
Which countries have flagged safety place, that the recent controversies in China follow their peers in
Hong Kong, Indian exports
of Indian spices? “collectively underscore the persistent
could see a “dramatic
The domino first shook on April 5, when nature of food safety challenges across
downturn”. This could affect
Hong Kong’s Centre for Food Safety various sectors of the food industry”. exports valued at $2.17 billion
suspended the sale of three MDH spice One challenge is operational — India’s — about 51.1% of the country’s
blends (Madras curry powder, Sambhar diverse food landscape, the lack of global spice exports.
masala and Curry powder masala) and standardised record-keeping and
Everest Fish curry masala. The spice intentional food fraud may prevent
mixes had high levels of ethylene oxide, manufacturers from tracing ingredients
the regulator said, and advised and assessing potential risks which
consumers against purchasing these compromise the safety of the entire food
products. Days later, Singapore ordered a supply chain. Traceability is particularly
recall of the Everest spice mix, stating that challenging for small and medium sized
it is unfit for human consumption. businesses with limited resources.
MDH has called allegations over EtO Some are logistic barriers. At least 10
contamination “baseless and States/Union Territories lack government
unsubstantiated”. “We reassure our or private notified food testing labs, as
buyers and consumers that we do not use mandated under the Food Safety and
ethylene oxide at any stage of storing, Standards Act 2006. These labs are
processing, or packing our spices,” the distributed unevenly across regions; have
company said in a statement. It added insufficient number of food safety
that neither the Spices Board nor the officers; and were found to operate
Food Safety and Standards Authority of ineffectively due to resource constraints,
India (FSSAI) have received showed the FSSAI Annual Report of
communication or test reports from 2021-22. FSSAI’s operations often lack
Singapore or Hong Kong authorities. transparency, which “hinders efforts to
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration meet safety standards”, build
(FDA), which had previously rejected food accountability and trust, adds Ms. Simi.
and spice imports from India, told Reuters
that it is “aware of the reports and is What next?
gathering additional information about Delhi-based think tank Global Trade
the situation”. Regulatory bodies in Research Initiative (GTRI) in a recent note
Maldives, New Zealand, Bangladesh and held, “With nearly $700 million worth of
Australia have announced similar plans. exports to critical markets at stake, and
potential losses soaring to over half of
What are the health concerns? India’s total spice exports due to
MDH and Everest’s spice mixes allegedly cascading regulatory actions in many
contain high levels of EtO, a prohibited countries, the integrity and future of
pesticide. EtO is a colourless, flammable India’s spice trade hang in delicate
gas that was originally intended for balance.” According to the think tank, the
sterilising medical devices. It is used as a issue demands urgent attention to uphold
chemical in industrial settings, the reputation of the entire ecosystem.
agriculture, and as a sterilising agent in Vijoo Krishnan, General Secretary of
food products, including spices, dried ISTOCKPHOTO the All-India Kisan Sabha explained that
vegetables and other commodities. The the chain of events could put other small
chemical lends life to the spice industry — food-borne illness. Other than this, there pathogen-related violations. With 5,115 companies or co-operatives’ exports
it reduces microbial contamination, and have been at least 11 counts of products refusals — the figure represented 22.9% of under a cloud of suspicion. Importantly,
in turn, extends products’ shelf life. being rejected because of misbranding, overall import refusals for pathogen/toxin Mr Krishnan explained that in the event
However, this process is not always adulteration, artificial colouring or related violations. of potential losses, farmers of such crops
airtight. The improper and excessive use incorrect labelling. The two causes have too could find themselves at the receiving
of EtO may leave behind residues, causing existed in combination as well. The report How has India responded? end. “We have instances where
toxic and even carcinogenic compounds tabulates Ramdev Food Products to have On April 25, the Spice Board in India companies have not paid appropriate
to form, thus contaminating the product. had the maximum rejections in 2023 announced a slew of corrective measures prices to farmers even when they were
One such compound is ethylene glycol, an (about 30), followed by MDH (about 19), including initiating mandatory testing of making profits,” he stated, adding,
ingredient which was found in MTR (7), Everest (5), makers of Catch: DS consignments shipped to Singapore and “Should the companies make losses now,
Indian-made cough syrups that were Group (2) and Badshah (1). Hong Kong and gathering technical details it could be used as a pretext to reduce
linked to the deaths of more than 300 In fact, in September 2019, a recall of and analytical reports from the relevant prices, thus, burdening the farmer.”
children in Cameroon, Gambia, Indonesia MDH’s Sambhar Masala was initiated in food and drug agencies. It also sought to GTRI also assessed that if regulators in
and Uzbekistan. Long-term exposure to the U.S. after FDA discovered the product propose corrective measures to the China follow their peers in Hong Kong,
ethylene oxide is associated with cancers was contaminated with salmonella. The concerned exporters and initiate and ASEAN based on that by Singapore,
including lymphoma and leukaemia, recall terminated in December 2021. inspections to ensure adherence to Indian exports could see a “dramatic
some evidence shows. Another such recall involved Everest’s relevant standards. A circular dated April downturn”. This could affect exports
Garam Masala and Sambhar Masala, and 30 contains guidelines to exporters on valued at $2.17 billion — about 51.1% of the
Is there a history of rejections in U.S.? Maggi’s Masala-ae-Magic in June last year. preventing EtO contamination. The country’s global spice exports. The
A scrutiny of FDA’s import refusal report, The U.S. Dept of Agriculture had in guidelines prescribe norms for testing at paradigm could further worsen if the EU,
for the calendar year 2023, cites at least February 2022 stated that India and raw and final stages, storage of EtO which it states, “regularly rejects Indian
30 instances wherein entry was refused Mexico were the top sources of treated products and use of alternate spice consignments over quality issues”,
because the products appeared to contain pathogen-based food import refusals. methods curtailing the use of the follows suit. The impact could be an
salmonella. These are agents known to Their study, from 2002-19, held Indian chemical compounds. The Spices Board additional $2.5 billion, bringing potential
cause salmonellosis — a common bacterial imports had the maximum number of issued a similar advisory in September losses to 58.8% of India’s global exports.
CM A IN-X
YK
THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 11
Chennai
Text&Context
FROM THE ARCHIVES
Know your
English
K. Subrahmanian
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
with the distinction between the forms
thus: “Distinction between the forms is
On May 3, 1715, a total solar eclipse occurred over Europe. A quiz on the event 12, 1991.
Vasudevan Mukunth parliament of Great Britain to pass Questions and Answers to the previous
the Longitude Act in 1714. It day’s daily quiz: 1. This British football
X promised rewards for anyone who legend was the runner up for the Ballon
QUESTION 1 devised a simple method to estimate D’Or in 1999. Ans: David Beckham
The English astronomer X is famous a ship’s longitude while at sea. Name 2. The party to which Tony Blair belonged
for, among other things, predicting the Y. to. Ans: Labour party. He was the U.K.
onset of the eclipse with an accuracy X Prime Minister for three terms
of four minutes. As a result, the event QUESTION 4 3. Identify this novel that won the Pulitzer
is also known as “X’s eclipse”. Name X. While X (in Q1) had predicted the Prize for Fiction in 1932. Ans: The Good
X eclipse to within four minutes, he’d Earth by Pearl. S. Buck
QUESTION 2 got the path of the eclipse wrong by 4. This movie based on a popular comic
At the time the eclipse occurred, the around 30 km. X later realised he’d book saga was released in 2008. Ans: Iron
date was April 22 and not May 3 (the used the wrong lunar _________ (a Man
year was 1715 in either case). The table that describes the path of the 5. This song by Pink Floyd was banned in
reason for this is that Great Britain moon). Fill in the blank. South Africa. Ans: ‘Another Brick in Wall
would adopt the _________ ________ X (Part II)’
only 37 years later. Fill in the blanks. QUESTION 5 Visual: The reason why May 2 is celebrated
X In 1686, X (in Q1) coined the name as International Harry Potter day. Ans: It is
QUESTION 3 ‘_____’ to refer to a period of about the day the battle of Hogwarts was
Before the eclipse occurred, the 6,585.3 days, which could be used to X fought and Lord Voldemort was For feedback and suggestions for
English cartographer John Senex had predict the occurrence of solar and Visual question: defeated Text & Context, please write to
published maps of the eclipse’s path lunar eclipses. X said he was inspired Name the man whose bust is depicted here. X (in Q1) succeeded to his Early Birds: Vasumann Yadav| Neha letters@thehindu.co.in
created by both X (in Q1) and Y in by a term in an 11th century title in 1720, and his work helped Y (in Q3) prepare the eclipse map. PUBLIC Vaddiparti| ViswanadhaRao Batchu| M. with the subject ‘Text & Context’
March. Y is famous for pushing the Byzantine book. Fill in the blank. DOMAIN Suresh Kumar
CM A IN-X
YK
THE HINDU
12 Friday, May 3, 2024
Business Chennai
INBRIEF
쑽 April PMI signals second-best gain in MARKETS
쑽
MARKET WATCH
New orders increased at the second-fastest pace in almost 40 months with domestic demand outpacing export orders, the
PMI survey showed; manufacturers ramped up hiring at a moderate pace, which was still the quickest since last September NIFTY 50
PRICE CHANGE
Adani Enter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 3039.60. . . . . . . . -15.10
Vikas Dhoot employees at a moderate- nium, paper, plastics and Adani Ports. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1338.80. . . . . . . . . . 13.90
Apollo Hosp. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 5958.55. . . . . . . . . . 11.45
NEW DELHI pace, which was still the steel, and producers last Asian Paints. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2975.40. . . . . . . . . . 99.50
quickest since September. month raised selling prices Axis Bank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1149.85. . . . . . . . -16.05
I
Bajaj Auto . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 9110.65. . . . . . . . 207.00
NPCI’s global arm to develop ndia’s manufacturing
activity eased in April
However, pressure on ca-
pacities remained mild.
at the fastest pace in three
months, noting that labour
Bajaj Finserv . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1615.45. . . . . . . . . . . . 0.45
Bajaj Finance . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 6882.70. . . . . . . . -40.85
UPI-like system for Namibia but still signalled the Even though input costs costs had also gone up. Bharti Airtel . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1304.05. . . . . . . . -18.25
BPCL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 634.65. . . . . . . . . . 27.30
second-best improvement rose, producers took input “Higher costs of raw ma- Britannia Ind . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 4759.65. . . . . . . . -16.30
NPCI International Payments Ltd. (NIPL), the in three-and-a-half years, purchases to the highest le- terials and labour led to a Cipla . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1420.05. . . . . . . . . . 20.05
Coal India . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 453.90. . . . . . . . . . -0.40
international arm of the National Payments as per the seasonally ad- vel since June, and expan- modest uptick in input Divis Lab . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 3964.65. . . . . . . . -37.75
Corporation of India (NPCI), has signed an justed HSBC India Manu- sion of stock inventories costs, but inflation remains Dr Reddys Lab . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 6287.50. . . . . . . . . . 83.20
agreement with the Bank of Namibia to support facturing Purchasing Man- was the third-strongest below the historical aver- Eicher Motors . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 4602.40. . . . . . . . . . . . 5.00
Grasim Ind . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2437.35. . . . . . . . . . 25.70
the institution in developing an instant payment agers’ Index (PMI), which since early 2005, when the age.” said HSBC’s chief In- HCL Tech . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1360.70. . . . . . . . . . -5.90
system like the Unified Payment Interface (UPI) slid to 58.8 from March’s PMI data collection began. dia economist Pranjul HDFC Bank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1532.25. . . . . . . . . . 12.15
HDFC Life . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 576.35. . . . . . . . . . -7.30
for Namibia. “By leveraging technology and 16-year high of 59.1. Expectations that demand Bhandari. “However, firms Hero MotoCorp . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 4561.50. . . . . . . . . . 18.45
experiences from India’s UPI, the partnership New orders rose at the conditions will remain con- passed these increases on- Hindalco . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 641.45. . . . . . . . . . -2.95
Hind Unilever . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2226.30. . . . . . . . . . -4.15
seeks to help Namibia modernise its financial second-strongest pace in Output growth slowed but demand, manufacturers ducive to growth support- to consumers through ICICI Bank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1139.45. . . . . . . . -10.95
ecosystem,” NIPL said in a statement. almost 40 months, with was still the second-fastest reported higher confi- ed inventory-building in- higher output charges, as IndusInd Bank. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1505.20. . . . . . . . -10.50
domestic demand rising in 42 months. dence levels with expecta- itiatives, HSBC said. demand remained resi- Infosys . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1414.45. . . . . . . . . . -6.10
ITC . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 439.00. . . . . . . . . . . . 3.35
faster than export orders, Bolstered by current tions of higher output a Price gains were report- lient, resulting in improved JSW Steel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 890.35. . . . . . . . . . . . 8.15
the PMI survey suggested. and anticipated upticks in year ahead. Firms added ed for materials like alumi- margins,” she added. Kotak Bank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 1575.65. . . . . . . . -48.30
L&T . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 3599.50. . . . . . . . . . . . 5.20
Aadhar Housing Finance LTIMindtree Ltd. . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 4692.70. . . . . . . . -13.70
M&M . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2185.15. . . . . . . . . . 28.80
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
NestleIndia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . 2512.30. . . . . . . . . . . . 4.90
million contract with FORVIA, a French global come (NII) grew 15% to The company, viewed as High volumes the area and therefore we freight rates were boosted CURRENCY TT BUY TT SELL
automotive supplier, to offer engineering ₹2,195.11 crore. a barometer of world “The container volumes can see that not only by a pandemic-related US Dollar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 83.27. . . . . . . . . . 83.59
Euro. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 89.11. . . . . . . . . . 89.46
development services to the latter’s Clean The Board recommend- trade, said that shipping we see today are quite high Maersk but all shipping boost to demand. British Pound . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . 104.20. . . . . . . . 104.60
Mobility division. As part of the five-year ed a dividend of ₹1.2 per disruptions caused by compared to GDP growth lines have adjusted their Still, Maersk posted a Japanese Yen (100) . . . . . . .. . . . . 53.63. . . . . . . . . . 53.84
Chinese Yuan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 11.50. . . . . . . . . . 11.54
partnership, about 300 engineers from FORVIA’s equity share with a face va- Houthi militants’ attacks in the world economy,” networks more or less per- third straight quarterly loss Swiss Franc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 91.28. . . . . . . . . . 91.63
Augsburg and Bengaluru sites had been lue of ₹2 for FY24. on vessels in the Red Sea said CEO Vincent Clerc. “At manently,” Mr. Clerc said. in its ocean container ship- Singapore Dollar . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 61.23. . . . . . . . . . 61.48
Canadian Dollar . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 60.67. . . . . . . . . . 60.91
transferred to LTTS. This represents a 95% In FY24, the bank’s total were expected to last at one point or another, we Maersk now expects ping division, mainly ow- Malaysian Ringitt . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 17.51. . . . . . . . . . 17.58
transfer success rate in securing the skills of business grew 19.1% YoY to least until the end of the will see a normalisation of full-year underlying EBIT- ing to higher costs related Australian Dollar . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 54.32. . . . . . . . . . 54.53
these teams, the company said in a statement. ₹4,61,937.36 crore. year, adding that growth in volumes,” he added. DA between $4 billion and to the Red Sea disruptions. Source:Indian Bank
Adani Enterprises Q4 Outlook for venture capital, private NMDC output slid 1%,
net profit slides 37% equity has improved: TVS Capital sales rose 3% in April
Press Trust of India The Hindu Bureau
NEW DELHI Mini Tejaswi ing,” she added. economic uncertainty. HYDERABAD
BENGALURU “However, India by itself
Adani Enterprises Ltd., the ‘Return to normalcy’ is an attractive market, and State-owned NMDC report-
flagship incubator of billio- The outlook for India’s Ms. Ramachandran ob- we do attract capital in the ed iron-ore production for
naire Gautam Adani’s con- private equity and venture served a lot of ‘normalisa- early stage investments. April slid almost 1% while
glomerate, on Thursday re- capital market appears tion’ had happened among But in terms of return on sales increased almost 3%.
ported a 37% drop in positive this year, com- investors and entrepre- capital, our funding mar- Production stood at 3.48
March quarter net profit, pared with last year, as neurs and conversations kets are yet to gain maturi- million tonne (mt) (3.51 mt)
bogged down by one-time ‘normalcy’ has returned in were now getting better ty,” she observed. and sales 3.53 mt (3.43 mt),
past airport dues and com- the lives of investors, said with realistic expectations NMDC said in a filing on Amitava Mukherjee
mercial-mining losses. While incubating busi- Anuradha Ramachandran, from both sides. ‘Credit averse’ the provisional numbers.
Consolidated net profit nesses like new energy and Managing Partner, TVS Anuradha Ramachandran “This scenario will On lending to women, she India’s largest iron-ore dia’s iron-ore output and
of ₹450.58 crore in the airports showed strong Capital Funds. boost the growth of the said, women were credit producer has been report- demand,” CMD (additional
fourth quarter of FY24 momentum, it suffered a they required digital edu- domestic funding market. averse and were very res- ing a year-on-year decline charge) Amitava Mukher-
compares with a net profit loss of ₹201.83 crore in ‘Excess funding’ cation, while consumer We hope, from now on, ponsible, yet opportunities in output since February. jee said in a statement.
of ₹722.48 crore in the commercial mining, while Ms. Ramachandran said, goods had to be mostly things are going to be ea- available for them could be In March, production and
same period last year and pre-tax earnings from the there had been excess bought online and there- sier for both parties,” she fewer, and that could also sales fell. For the year end- ‘Promising start’
₹1,888.45 crore earnings in road business plummeted funding during 2020 and fore B2C ventures did well. commented. be one of the reasons why ed March, it had reported a “All our mining complexes
the preceding quarter, ac- 84% to ₹222.03 crore. 2021 as both investors and “Now, the question is Funding winter, set in a a lesser number of women 10% increase in production have delivered a promising
cording to a filing. Also, its unit Mumbai In- business owners had got how do you sustain growth couple of years ago after became entrepreneurs. to a record 45.1 mt and 16% start and are geared up to
The firm reported an 8% ternational Airport Ltd. carried away. The pandem- when structural disadvan- many global funds dialed However, “it is encou- higher sales at 44.48 mt. harmonise with the new
decline in EBITDA (earn- (MIAL) recognised a one- ic had brought about struc- tages no longer exist. That down their investments in raging to see some start- “We are targeting north mining technologies, navi-
ings before interest, taxes, time exceptional expense tural changes. Edtech is the conundrum both in- India because of a lack of ups having women co- of 10% growth in our vol- gate sectoral challenges
depreciation, and amorti- of ₹627 crore to make up boomed because students vestors and businesses al- private fund availability, founders,” Ms. Ramachan- umes in FY25 attuned to and achieve 50 million
sation) at ₹3,646 crore. for past payments. could not go to school and ways faced and are still fac- coupled with the global dran added. the growth trajectory of In- tonne,” he added.
‘Shriram Finance to focus on ‘April palm-oil imports Reliance starts trading U.S. oil
small-ticket loans, used vehicles’ swell to 3-month high’ setting Brent oil benchmark
N. Anand FY25 as the government Reuters Reuters line last month, trade
CHENNAI machinery was involved in MUMBAI LONDON sources said.
the elections during April More players have be-
Shriram Finance Ltd. (SFL) and May. India’s palm-oil imports India’s Reliance has made come involved in trading
will focus on building its “There is likely to be jumped by 41% in April its first foray into trading a crude that can set the
bottom line in a granular some slowdown in the ca- from the previous month type of U.S. crude oil that Brent price in the Platts
manner by offering small- pex activity of the govern- to reach the highest level in underpins the global Brent window since Platts added
ticket loans and high-yield- ment and infrastructure three months, as easing benchmark in a process WTI to the benchmark last
ing products during the projects,” he said. prices prompted refiners run by oil-index publisher year.
current fiscal year, said ex- Mr. Revankar said to increase purchases, five S&P Global Commodity In- U.S. WTI Midland is one
ecutive vice chairman though the growth may be dealers told Reuters. sights, the publisher said. of six crude-oil grades as-
Umesh G. Revankar. Umesh G. Revankar a little slow in Q1, SFL ex- Higher palm-oil pur- rection that eliminated its RIL, operator of the sessed by Platts that can set
“We will be focusing on pects good demand from chases by India, the premium over soybean world’s biggest refining ters request for comment. the value of dated Brent,
our niche area of small- emphasis would be to raise rural areas in Q2 with the world’s biggest importer of and sunflower oil, said Ra- complex, on Wednesday India, the world’s third- part of the wider Brent
ticket lending and used efficiency and profitability, IMD’s prediction on the vegetable oils, could sup- jesh Patel, managing partn- offered a cargo of WTI Mi- biggest oil importer and complex used to price
vehicle portfolio, where and not unduly focus on monsoon being a positive. port the benchmark Malay- er at GGN Research. dland in the Platts Market consumer, is looking to di- more than three-quarters
high-yielding assets will be the top line growth. Talking about the FY25 sian palm oil futures that Crude palm-oil imports on Close process, known versify its oil supplies as of the world’s traded oil.
given a little higher weight- In FY24, SFL’s standa- guidance for return on are trading near their low- are offered at about $920 a as the Platts window. fresh U.S. sanctions on The price of dated Brent
age,” Mr. Revankar said lone net profit rose 20% equity, he said: “We are al- est level in three months. metric tonne, including It was Reliance’s first Moscow threaten to dent is set by the cheapest of the
during an interaction. YoY to ₹7,190 crore, while ready at 16.4% and we Palm oil imports in April cost, insurance and time offering WTI in the Russian oil sales to India, six crudes and Midland, by
Asserting that the com- total income increased by should be able to cross jumped to 6,82,000 metric freight, in India for June window, Platts spokesper- the biggest buyer of Rus- far the largest of the six
pany’s growth would be ca- 17% to ₹34,998 crore. 17%. By FY26, we will be at tonne, dealers estimate. delivery, while soyoil and son Kathleen Tanzy told sian seaborne crude. crude streams, often plays
librated and SFL would be According to him, the 18%”. “Assets under man- Palm oil has become sunflower oil are offered at Reuters. A Reliance spo- Reliance made its first a role in setting its value.
focusing on improving the industry might expect agement will grow at 15% more attractive to buyers about $920 and $945 a kesperson did not imme- oil purchase from Canada’s The other five are North
bottom line, he said the slower growth in Q1 of for FY25,” he added. due to a recent price cor- tonne, respectively. diately respond to a Reu- new Trans Mountain pipe- Sea crudes.
CM A IN-X
YK
THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 13
Chennai
Business
W
hen Ademola founder of Metro Africa gy technology, with less
Adesina found- Xpress, which makes elec- funding coming in for
ed a start-up to tric two- and three-wheel- more diverse initiatives,
provide solar and battery- ers and electric vehicle in- said Sandy Okoth, a capital
Meeting point: The two sought to collaborate in based power subscription frastructure in Nigeria and market specialist for green
pharmaceuticals and medical devices. AP packages to individuals has raised just under $100 finance at FSD Africa, one
and businesses in Nigeria million since it was found- of the commissioners of
in 2015, it was a lot harder ed in 2015. the CPI study.
Amiti Sen to raise money than it is Mr. Adetayo said ven- “The private sector feels
NEW DELHI today. ture capitalists “are play- this (renewable energy
Climate tech was new in ing a catalytic role that is technology) is a more ma-
India and New Zealand are likely to set up Africa, the continent was a extremely essential.” ture space,” he said. “They
working groups in sectors such as agriculture, fledgling destination for “We all know that in or- understand the funding
food processing, storage and transportation, venture capital money, der to really decarbonise models.”
forestry and pharmaceuticals to facilitate ongoing there were fewer funders our economies, invest- Investors are also start-
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
Giant share: Climate start-ups raised over a third of all funds raised by start-ups in Africa in 2023. AFP
collaboration on key trade and economic issues, to approach and less mo- ments have to be made. ing to understand the eco-
per an official statement. ney was available, he said. African countries need to added. And it’s not trivial invest- nomic benefits of adapting
In a series of bilateral meetings in New Zealand It took him a year of address risks like currency The money raised by cli- ment,” he said. to climate change and solu-
on April 26-27, the two countries also sought to “running around and instability that they say re- mate tech start-ups last Besides venture capital, tions as they have returns
collaborate in area of pharmaceuticals and scouring” his networks to duce investor appetite, We all know that in year was more than a third other investments by priv- on investment, said Hetal
medical devices sector, including adoption of raise his first amount — just while investors need to ex- order to really of all funds raised by start- ate equity firms, syndi- Patel, Nairobi-based direc-
fast-tracking of regulatory process and quality under $1 million — from VC pand their scope of inter- ups in Africa in 2023, plac- cates, venture builders, tor of investments at Mercy
assessment of manufacturing facilities using, as firms and other sources. est to more climate sectors
decarbonize our ing climate tech second on- and other financial institu- Corps Ventures, an early-
appropriate, the inspection reports of “Everything was a learning like flood protection, disas- economies, investments ly to fintech, a more ma- tions are actively financing stage VC fund.
comparable overseas regulators. experience,” he said. ter management and heat have to be made. And it’s ture sector. climate initiatives on the “We’re starting to build
“Greater sourcing of medicines from India and But the ecosystem has management, and to use not trivial investment continent. a very strong business case
cooperation in medical device sector was also since changed, and Mr. diverse funding methods. ADETAYO BAMIDURO ‘Risk takers’ But private sector fi- for adaptation investors
discussed,” according to a statement issued by Adesina’s Rensource Ener- Still, the investment co-founder, Metro Africa Xpress Venture capital is typically nancing in general lags far and make sure that private
the Commerce Department on Thursday. gy has raised about $30 numbers for the climate given to businesses with behind that of public fi- capital flows start coming
Commerce Secretary Sunil Barthwal, who million over the years, tech sector — which in- despite a decline in the substantial risk but great nancing, which includes in,” he said.
headed the Indian delegation, met Minister for mostly from VC firms. cludes businesses in re- amount of money raised long-term growth poten- funds from governments, Maëlis Carraro, manag-
Trade of New Zealand Todd McClay and Acting Funding for climate tech newable energy, carbon re- by all start-ups in total on tial. Start-ups use it to ex- multilaterals and develop- ing partner at Catalyst
Chief Executive and Secretary of Foreign Affairs start-ups in Africa from the moval, land restoration the continent last year. pand into new markets ment finance institutions. Fund, a Nairobi-based VC
and Trade of New Zealand Brook Barrington. He private sector is growing, and water and waste man- That matters because and to get products and From 2019 to 2020, priv- fund, urged more diverse
participated in the India-New Zealand Business with businesses raising agement — are compelling: climate tech requires expe- services on the market. ate sector financing repre- funding, such as that which
Council (INZBC) and the 11th India-New Zealand more than $3.4 billion last year, climate tech start- rimentation, and VC firms Venture capitalists “can sented only 14% of all of blends private and public
Joint Trade Committee ( JTC) meeting. since 2019. But there’s still ups on the continent that provide money to nas- take risks that other people Africa’s climate finance, ac- sector funding. The role of
Discussions included cooperation in a long way to go, with the raised $1.04 billion, a 9% cent businesses are playing cannot take, because our cording to a report by the public financing, she said,
horticulture, including kiwi-fruit sector to continent requiring $277 increase from the previous an essential role by giving business model is designed Climate Policy Initiative, should be to de-risk the
address issues of quality and productivity, proper billion annually to meet its year and triple what they climate tech start-ups risk to have failures,” said Brian much lower than in re- private sector and attract
storage in pack houses and suitable climate goals for 2030. raised in 2019, according to capital, said Mr. Adesina. Odhiambo, a Lagos-based gions such as East Asia and more private sector capital
transportation and the dairy sector. Experts say to unlock fi- the funding database Afri- “In the climate space, a lot partner at Novastar Ven- Pacific at 39%, and Latin into financing climate
(The writer is with The Hindu businessline) nancing and fill this gap, ca: The Big Deal. That was of things are uncertain,” he tures, an Africa-focused in- America and the Carib- initiatives.
Fed’s dilemma
Steel exports to Europe increase
65% to touch 5-year high in FY24
Abhishek Law Indian steel mills have
NEW DELHI held back HRC export off-
ers to Europe this week,
India’s steel exports to Eu- market participants said.
rope hit a five-year high in The indicative prices are
FY24 with outbound ship- about $625- 635/t.
ments hovering at 3.3 mil- “Supported by re-stock-
lion tonne (mt), up 65% y- ing and a weak dollar,
o-y and almost doubling domestic prices in the EU
over a five-year period rose after the Euro to U.S.
(from FY20). dollar exchange rate
However, the country changed. Buyers also held
suffered a setback when it off on overseas purchases
came to exports to the due to long lead times.
UAE, which hit a five-year- Steely foes: Competition from Chinese exports have seriously This ended the downward
low. Exports to South East dented Indian mills’ prospects in the UAE and Vietnam. REUTERS trend in European prices
Asia also slipped, Steel Mi- that had been in place
nistry reports accessed by stood at 7.5 mt, up 11% y- Spain, it surged 133%. since January. Despite li-
businessline show. o-y, buoyed primarily by In FY23, exports to the mited demand, mills are
Competition from Chi- rise in shipments to the EU. EU were at 2 mt while in expected to raise prices
nese exports have serious- Over the five-year pe- FY22, it was 3 mt. In FY21, soon due to the lack of im-
ly dented Indian mills’ riod, Italy saw exports rise when CIOVID curbs were port competition,” consul-
Tight market: The number of Americans filing new claims for unemployment benefits held steady at a low level last week, pointing to a prospects in the UAE and 112%; exports to Belgium being lifted globally, it was tancy firm BigMint said.
still fairly tight labour market that should continue to underpin the economy in the second quarter. Initial claims for State unemployment Vietnam. more than doubled from 2 mt. In FY20, the COVID (The writer is with The
benefits were unchanged at a seasonally adjusted 2,08,000 for the week ended April 27. REUTERS India’s steel exports 0.4 mt; and in the case of year, exports were 1.5 mt. Hindu businesline)
World Chennai
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
This is a mission that the global community has not dealt with since the Second World War, it says; Meera Srinivasan Leader of Opposition Sajith
presence of large quantities of unexploded ordnance in the debris to make rebuilding difficult COLOMBO Premadasa, pledged to im-
plement the 13th Amend-
With a presidential elec- ment to the Sri Lankan
Agence France-Presse “72% of all residential tion expected later this constitution, which pro-
GAZA STRIP buildings have been com- year, the May Day rallies of mises a measure of power
pletely or partially all main political parties in devolution to the provinc-
Sri Lanka seemed a pre- es. Further, he proposed a
T
he United Nations destroyed”.
said on Thursday lude to their poll cam- “national wealth fund” to
that the post-war Continuous explosions paigns. Leaders of various ensure prosperity of future
reconstruction of Gaza Reconstruction is made political camps made a di- generations.
would require an interna- more difficult by the pre- rect pitch to the people in The JVP-led National Pe-
tional effort unseen since sence of large quantities of their respective public ople’s Power coalition put
the aftermath of Second unexploded ordnance in events, seeking their sup- up a big show in capital Co-
World War, estimating it the debris that Gaza’s Civil port in what would be the Show of strength: The May Day rally held by the centre-left lombo, with scores of
could cost up to $40 Defence agency says trig- first election since the is- Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna in Colombo. MEERA SRINIVASAN members and supporters
billion. gers “more than 10 explo- land nation’s debilitating marching across the city,
It came as Hamas chief sions every week”. economic crisis in 2022. gress in Kotagala in the lombo rally organised by chanting “we want a go-
Ismail Haniyeh struck an The war started with A year into the Interna- Central Province, where his United National Party vernment”. The party and
optimistic tone over a pos- Shards of memories: A Palestinian boy inspects a damaged house Hamas’s October 7 attack tional Monetary Fund’s many Malaiyaha Tamils, in- (UNP), Mr. Wickremes- its now-popular leader An-
sible truce and hostage re- in Rafah in the southern Gaza Strip on Wednesday. REUTERS on Israel that resulted in programme, that brought cluding estate workers re- inghe said his government ura Kumara Dissanayake
lease deal for Gaza, after the deaths of 1,170 people, with it tough austerity side and work, announced took “difficult decisions” told supporters gathered
weeks of largely stalled the militant group’s Qatar- $30 billion and $40 billion. mostly civilians. measures, many Sri Lan- an increase in the daily for economic recovery near Colombo’s Town Hall:
negotiations. based political bureau, “The scale of the des- Israel estimates that 129 kans are reeling under the wage of plantation sector while challenging the main “We should create Sri Lan-
said in calls to Egyptian truction is huge and unpre- captives seized by militants impact of steep tax hikes, workers, to LKR 1700 Opposition party Samagi ka’s biggest people’s move-
Truce possibilities and Qatari mediators that cedented... this is a mis- during their attack remain and higher fuel and energy (roughly ₹ 477). Underscor- Jana Balawegaya (SJB or ment, in order to bring in a
There have been reports of Hamas was studying the sion that the global in Gaza. The military says prices, amid high living ing his government’s “dili- United People’s Force) and new era.”
sticking points between latest proposal with a “pos- community has not dealt 34 of them are dead. costs. gent efforts” to stabilise the the centre-left Janatha Vi- Tamil parties from the
the militant group and Is- itive spirit”. with since World War II,” Israel’s retaliatory offen- country’s economy, he mukthi Peramuna ( JVP or island’s north and east
rael nearly seven months Much of Gaza has been UN assistant secretary-gen- sive against Hamas has Increase in daily wage further pledged to convert People’s Liberation Front) held May Day events high-
into the war that has devas- reduced to a grey land- eral Abdallah al-Dardari killed at least 34,596 peo- President Ranil Wickre- workers’ colonial-era line on what their response had lighting pending concerns
tated the Palestinian scape of rubble and the UN told a briefing in the Jorda- ple in Gaza, mostly women mesinghe, who participat- room accommodation to been. over accountability, power
territory. estimated the cost of re- nian capital Amman. and children, according to ed at the May Day event of “villages”. Addressing the SJB’s devolution, and ongoing
But Haniyeh, head of construction at between The UN official said the Health Ministry. the Ceylon Workers’ Con- Speaking later at a Co- May Day rally in Colombo, land grabs in the region.
Crime and cost of living left, Delhi-born candidate Japan and India struggling
right and centre as London Ghulati in the fray in economically because they
citizens vote for a Mayor London Mayor polls are xenophobic, says Biden
Sriram Lakshman
Sriram Lakshman general election later this LONDON Agence France-Presse U.S. President our economy is growing is
LONDON year. Ms. Hall, a London WASHINGTON lumped the allies because of you and many
Assembly member, has As London goes to the with rivals China and others. Why? Because we
Voters in England and said that she will increase polls on Thursday to elect Japan and India are strug- welcome immigrants,” the
Wales are going to the polls the number of police offic- a Mayor, Delhi-born Tarun
Russia as countries
gling economically be- president said.
on Thursday, to elect a ers and introduce Bo- Ghulati is among the 13 cause they are “xenophob- rejecting immigrants While China and Russia
number of local govern- rough-based policing to candidates for voters to ic,” U.S. President Joe are considered U.S. rivals,
ment officials, but the tackle crime (i.e., more lo- choose from. Mr. Ghulati, Biden told a campaign Mr. Biden’s remarks on Ja-
most-watched race is in calised police forces). an investment banker and event, lumping the Ameri- tion against Republican riv- pan and India came as a
London, where the incum- She has also said she will strategic advisor, is run- can allies in with rivals Chi- al Donald Trump in the surprise.
bent mayor, the Labour end the expanded Ultra ning as an independent to na and Russia as countries November presidential The White House sought
Party’s Sadiq Khan, is seek- Low Emissions Zone “encourage the free flow of Tarun Ghulati rejecting immigrants. vote, made the remarks at to downplay the Presi-
ing a third term as he runs Sadiq Khan (ULEZ) on day 1. The ex- ideas and policies without “Why is China stalling a campaign fundraising dent’s remarks on
against 12 other panded zone, which im- party ideology and bias”. sion for London and have so badly economically? event in Washington mark- Thursday.
candidates. the scheme permanent. He poses congestion charges “People don’t know failed London, “ Mr. Ghula- Why is Japan in trouble? ing the start of Asian Amer- “The broader point the
The three other conten- has also pledged to in- on certain vehicles, was whether to heat or eat,” ti said, when asked if Lon- Why is Russia in trouble? ican, Native Hawaiian, and president was making, and
ders dominating the air crease policing and is in created by Mr. Khan in Au- Mr. Ghulati told The Hindu don was read for a foreign- And India? Because they’re Pacific Islanders Heritage I think people all around
waves are Conservative competition with Ms. Hall gust last year. The mayor on the eve of the election, born Mayor. xenophobic. They don’t Month. the world recognise this, is
candidate Susan Hall, Lib- over how many new police has defended the expan- describing the cost of living “I speak several lan- want immigrants,” Biden Such events are neither that the United States is a
eral Democrat (Lib Dem) offers they will deploy. sion of the zone and has crisis. He hopes to bring guages and and under- said on Wednesday, with a filmed nor recorded, but a nation of immigrants, and
Rob Blackie and the Green linked it to better health his finance background to stand the cultural sensitivi- transcript not made public small number of journal- it’s in our DNA,” National
Party’s Zoë Garbett. Also Opinion poll and environmental out- create funds for London. ty of people,” Mr. Ghulati until Thursday. ists attend and provide a Security Council spokes-
running is independent The incumbent’s other comes for Londoners. As part of his plan, Mr. said adding that his Indian The 81-year-old Demo- written account. man John Kirby told
candidate, Delhi-born Ta- priorities include afforda- Ms. Hall has previously Ghulati said he would want upbringing taught him to crat, who is seeking reelec- “One of the reasons why reporters.
run Ghulati. ble housing and transport courted controversy for more “bobbies (police) on believe in the notion of the
Crime and safety have — but with Londoners reel- her comments on crime in the beat” . “But of the right world as one family, which
been at the top of the list ing from higher costs of liv- the black community and kind,” he adds, meaning he described as ‘Vasudhai-
for voters as has the related
topic of confidence in the
Met (Metropolitan Police).
ing than when he assumed
office, Mr. Khan has the ad-
ded task of defending his
for her social media style —
where she ‘liked’ racist
posts, including some in-
they should come from di-
verse backgrounds to un-
derstand the cultural
va Kutumbakam’, a San-
skrit phrase also used by
the Modi government in its
U.S. misidentified target, killed
On Tuesday, a sword-
wielding man killed a 14-
year-old child and injured
record so far. A YouGov
poll report released on
Wednesday said 47% of po-
volving Mr. Khan, who is
Muslim.
nuances of the communi-
ties they police.
Not unlike the Conser-
foreign policy references.
Emphasizing that he
was committed to all cul-
civilian in Syria strike last year
several other people in tential voters planned to LibDem candidate vative candidate Susan tures and communities,
London, where blade relat- vote for Mr. Khan while Reforming the Met is the Hall, he wants more local- Mr. Ghulati voiced his sup- Agence France-Presse gation the following fense and CENTCOM poli-
ed crimes are high relative 25% planned to vote for main priority for the Lib ised policing, by increasing port for civilians in Gaza WASHINGTON month. cies,” the statement said.
to other cities. The cost of Ms. Hall (1,192 adults sur- Dem candidate, Mr. Black- the number of police during his call with The “The investigation de- Hours after the strike
living, especially as it im- veyed between April 24- ie, who was the victim of a booths in the city. Hindu, describing the A U.S. strike in Syria last termined U.S. forces mis- killed Lotfi Hassan Masto,
pacts housing and tran- 30). violent mugging some Like other candidates, bombarding of Gaza as year killed a civilian who identified the intended al- his brother said his relative
sport costs is another cru- Nevertheless, respon- years ago. “One night I was Mr. Ghulati’s formula for “carnage and genocide”. was misidentified as an al- Qaeda target and that a ci- had no al-Qaeda ties and
cial manifesto issue for dents were split on his re- attacked while walking making housing more af- “I’ve been asking the Qaeda leader, the military vilian... was struck and was “tending to his sheep
candidates. cord to date, with 41% ap- home from work. My neck fordable in London in- leaders to go off to the Ra- command responsible for killed instead,” CENTCOM in the mountain when the
proving and 46% saying he was broken, and I was cludes rent-control laws in fah crossing or Gaza and the region said on said in a statement, saying aircraft targeted him.”
School meals has done a bad job. lucky to live,” he said on areas undergoing gentrifi- see the bodies and the Thursday. it “regrets the civilian harm The conflict in Syria has
Mr. Khan’s main pledge is One of the messages of his campaign page. cation and changing land- mass graves, just as they The strike was carried that resulted.” killed more than half a mil-
free primary school meals. the Khan campaign has Ms. Garbett, who re- use regulations. He also went to Ukraine,” he said. out on May 3, 2023, but in- lion people since it began
He introduced these at the been that he will be able to minds voters repeatedly wants to reduce the The Israel-Palestine issue dications quickly emerged ‘Complied to all laws’ in 2011 with a brutal crack-
start of the 2023 school achieve much more than in that she is a home renter amount of congestion has become a point of ten- that the man it killed was “The investigation con- down on anti-government
year as an emergency mea- the last few years if there is (and not owner), is focused charges paid by car drivers sion in London, with near- not a senior militant, and cluded the strike was con- protests, spiraling into a
sure to help parents with a Labour Chancelor of the on transport fare reform using London roads. weekly protests and coun- Central Command (CENT- ducted in compliance with complex battlefield involv-
the cost of living crisis. He Exchequer and govern- and rent control and regu- “You don’t need politi- ter-protests, as in many COM) chief General Erik the law of armed conflict as ing foreign armies, militias
is now proposing making ment following the U.K.’s lation in the city. cians who blurred the vi- other world capitals. Kurilla ordered an investi- well as Department of De- and jihadists.
CM A IN-X
YK
THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 15
Chennai
World
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
Ground zero: A student journalist shows off a sign while covering the events at Hamilton Hall at
the ground next to a train station, is a key part of They are immersed in the Columbia University in New York City on Tuesday. GETTY IMAGES am season. “We are still protests about investments
efforts to clean up the river Seine, which is set to story in ways journalists students at the end of the in Israel.
host swimming events during the Paris Games in for major media organisa- She checked out of a hospi- were listening to an audio side journalists. day,” Ms. Patel said. Lantern staff members
July and August. tions often cannot be. And tal on Wednesday after stream, and its announcers The Daily Spectator has are having meetings about
“It’s a real cathedral. It’s something exception- they face dual challenges — learning that injuries to recommended people been on the story every ‘Part of history’ balancing the experiences
al,” Paris Mayor Anne Hidalgo said on Thursday as as members of the media her arms and chest were tune in to FM radio step of the way and has not At Columbia, whose jour- of pro-Palestinian protes-
she walked on the bottom of the vast cylinder- and students at the institu- bruises. instead. hesitated to confront Co- nalism school is consi- ters and Jewish students or
shaped construction that has taken more than tions they are covering. Even though he wore a lumbia University’s leader- dered one of the country’s counter-protesters, Ms.
three years to complete. Deputy Paris mayor An- Across the country from ‘Familiar ground’ badge identifying him as a ship in print. In an edito- finest, Dean Jelani Cobb Smith said. They debate
toine Guillou has compared the project in western UCLA on Tuesday, a stu- “While it was terrifying member of the press, the rial late last month, the wrote a memo on Wednes- whether to publish the
Paris, near the Austerlitz transport hub, to Notre dent-run radio station and, honestly, will take a police ordered Chris Man- students sharply con- day to the population of names of students who
Dame, which is under reconstruction after a de- broadcast live as the police lot of mental processing, dell and other reporters demned university Presi- budding journalists who face discipline, compare
vastating fire in 2019. cleared a building taken by the experience confirmed for the Columbia Daily dent Minouche Shafik and are his students: “You are a language choices to other
Notre Dame will not be ready in time for the Pa- the protesters on the Co- for me the importance of Spectator into a dormitory. said administrators have part of history now. Your news organisations and re-
ris Games, as promised by President Emmanuel lumbia University campus, student journalists be- When he tried to open the been uncommunicative ex- perseverance during a con- flect on what viewpoints
Macron immediately after the inferno that tore while other student jour- cause we know our cam- door, Mr. Mandell said he cept for “ominous late- fusing and challenging mo- are missing from stories.
through the 850-year-old masterpiece. nalists were confined to pus better than any outside was told he would be ar- night emails.” ment cannot be understat- Editors instruct reporters
Fortunately for Olympic open-water swim- dorms and threatened reporter would,” Ms. Ha- rested if he did it again. “This is your legacy,” ed. You told the stories the to keep opinions to
mers, the stormwater facility is set to enter service with arrests. milton said. “It has not de- Mr. Mandell has been the Spectator wrote — “a global public deserved to themselves.
in June after tests later this month. Its role will be Ms. Hamilton’s attackers terred me from wanting to covering the demonstra- president more focused on hear. You helped the As national news outlets
to store rainwater in the event of a heavy down- wore masks. But she recog- continue this coverage.” tions and the planning for the brand of your universi- school to meet its mission.” descend on campuses na-
pour, reducing the chances of the capital’s sewer- nised the voice of one as a Fear and anger were ob- months. While he consid- ty than the safety of your The protest movement tionwide, student journal-
age system needing to discharge its pathogen-rich counter-demonstrator vious in the voices of stu- ers it a learning expe- students and their de- has become a training ists say their connection to
contents directly into the Seine. Paris’s sanitation sympathetic to Israel’s dents narrating the action rience, he said “it has been mands for justice.” ground for students grap- their campuses is their
system is under immense scrutiny following cause because of prior re- on Columbia’s WKCR radio breaking my heart” to see At campuses across the pling with complicated ed- greatest asset. They have
pledges from Olympic organisers to use the Seine porting when some of on Tuesday. The station’s the police presence on country, around-the-clock itorial decisions for some built relationships with stu-
for the marathon swimming and triathlon during them filmed her working website briefly went down campus and how the story reporting from protests of the first times in their ca- dent groups, faculty and
the Games, which begin on July 26. and harassed her by name. because so many people has been covered by out- and student disciplinary reers. They confront the administrators.
Nordic Europe’s culture of saunas spawns amazing new variations and locations
Agence France-Presse 1968 before reopening in nothing that disturbs you home to 3.3 million the Stockholm archipelago firm and he wanted a truly
BORLÄNGE 2022, redesigned to wel- from enjoying the sauna.” saunas. is making waves — sailing extraordinary sauna that
come visitors looking for a “You don’t have mobile Traditionally consi- on the waters of the capital he hadn’t seen before,” ar-
Deep underground in a dis- unique — and sweaty — ex- phones, you don’t have the dered a sacred space in city. chitect Johan Strandlund
used iron mine and under perience, Daniel Karlsson, sun, you don’t have the Finland, ‘a church of na- The “Big Branzino”, a said. “So we came up with
the bluish glow of a flash- the head of Adventure wind,” he said. ture’, the Finnish sauna luxury floating sauna mea- this shape in order to really
light, a small crowd emerg- Mine, said. Saunas are enjoyed culture was named a UN- suring 30 square metre, maximise the intimacy
es from a sauna, steam ris- “If you look at saunas to- around the world as a ESCO Intangible Cultural was designed and built in with its surroundings, and
ing off their bodies as they day, it’s more like a luxury method of relaxation, Heritage of Humanity in 2022 at the request of a we also wanted a truly
plunge into a crystal clear experience,” he said. claimed by some to pro- 2020. private person. breathtaking presence on
turquoise lake. vide health benefits. Saunas originated in The structure resembles the horizon,” he said.
In Sweden and Finland, ‘Experience of nature’ Having a sauna has been Finland and Estonia, typi- a square wooden cabin, Mr. Strandlund said the
some unusual saunas have But “down here it’s not just a social and hygiene tradi- cally built as small wooden featuring floor-to-ceiling floating sauna appealed to
been built in recent years, a sauna. It’s also the expe- tion for more than 2,000 cabins where dry heat up glass windows and an nature- and sauna-loving
offering truly singular ex- rience that you get with na- years. Now, sauna enthu- Unique experience: Interior of the ‘Big Branzino’, a luxury floating to 100°C with very low hu- open-air wheelhouse on Swedes.
periences. ture,” he said, clad in a siasts who want to expand sauna in the waters of the Swedish capital of Stockholm. AFP midity is produced from a the deck. “I think it’s the way that
Nestled in the snowy thick red parka to protect their horizons can reach stove or hot rocks. Inside, a custom-made we really like to enjoy the
forests of Bergslagen in from the cold and a helmet new heights in Helsinki. wallet though, costing bet- few people in here, four or wood stove with hot rocks beautiful nature that we
central Sweden, hidden with a headlamp. In the Finnish capital, a ween €240 and €350. five. Also the views are Different types is surrounded by wooden have around here in
90m below ground in this The space offers visitors giant ferris wheel overlook- “You can get a pretty more fun when you’re in Saunas in the Nordic coun- benches and chairs, while Stockholm.”
region known for its a moment of respite from ing the city offers a sauna good steam and heat here the sauna.” tries are typically small outside, a rooftop terrace And “even when you’re
mines, lies this very special the busy, connected world in one of its specially-built if you really want to,” shift Saunas are an integral wooden cabins located features a large table and not using the sauna, the
sauna. above. pods. manager Viivi Makelainen part of daily life for most near the shore, deep in the seating area to take in the fire is a great source of
The old iron mine in the “Because the sauna is The sweat session could said. “Although it’s pretty Finns. The country of 5.5 forest or in a home. view. heat, for example for cold
town of Borlange closed in down in the mine, there is easily burn a hole in one’s small, you can fit quite a million inhabitants is But one special sauna in “A client came to the summer nights.”
CM A IN-X
YK
THE HINDU
16 Friday, May 3, 2024
Sport Chennai
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
Bhuvneshwar bowls a brilliant final over to complement his first; Jaiswal and Parag’s fantastic stand to no avail; Nitish sizzles for the host
SCOREBOARD
쑽
SUNRISERS HYDERABAD Bhuvneshwar 27 (15b, 3x4, 1x6),
Travis Head b Avesh 58 (44b, 6x4, Dhruv Jurel c Abhishek b Cummins
3x6), Abhishek Sharma c Jurel b 1 (3b), R. Ashwin (not out) 2 (2b);
Avesh 12 (10b, 1x6), Anmolpreet Extras (nb-2, w-11): 13; Total (for
Singh c Jaiswal b Sandeep 5 (5b, seven wkts. in 20 overs): 200.
1x4), Nitish Reddy (not out) 76 FALL OF WICKETS
(42b, 3x4, 8x6), Heinrich Klaasen 1-1 (Buttler, 0.2), 2-1 (Samson,
(not out) 42 (19b, 3x4, 3x6); Extras Engrossing: Salt’s pyrotechnics have lit up this edition.
0.5), 3-135 (Jaiswal, 13.3), 4-159
(w-8): 8; Total (for three wkts. in 20 EMMANUAL YOGINI
(Parag, 15.5), 5-181 (Hetmyer,
overs): 201. 17.4), 6-182 (Jurel, 18.1), 7-200
FALL OF WICKETS (Powell, 19.6). Amol Karhadkar
1-25 (Abhishek, 4.1 overs), 2-35 SUNRISERS BOWLING MUMBAI
(Anmolpreet, 5.1), 3-131 (Head, Bhuvneshwar 4-0-41-3, Jansen
14.4). 4-0-44-0, Cummins 4-0-34-2, For long, facing Kolkata
ROYALS BOWLING Natarajan 4-0-35-2, Unadkat Knight Riders used to be
Boult 4-0-33-0, Ashwin 4-0-36-0, (Impact Player in place of like a walk in the park for
Avesh 4-0-39-2, Sandeep 4-0-31-1, Anmolpreet) 2-0-23-0, Nitish
Chahal 4-0-62-0. Mumbai Indians, and its
1-0-12-0, Shahbaz 1-0-11-0.
RAJASTHAN ROYALS Toss: SRH; PoM: Bhuvneshwar.
batting mainstay Rohit
Yashasvi Jaiswal b Natarajan 67 SRH won by one run. Sharma.
(40b, 7x4, 2x6), Jos Buttler But even the bogey team
(Impact Player in place of has turned the reputation
Chahal) c Jansen b Bhuvneshwar around in the last few
0 (1b), Sanju Samson b years.
Bhuvneshwar 0 (3b), Riyan Parag c Add to it the form this
Jansen b Cummins 77 (49b, 8x4, season and it puts the
4x6), Shimron Hetmyer c Jansen b
home under severe pres-
Natarajan 13 (9b, 1x4, 1x6),
Rovman Powell lbw b sure come Friday night at
the Wankhede Stadium.
Another loss will put Mum- With the Knight Riders’
bai Indians’ – placed at the bowling unit having fal-
ninth place in a table of 10 – tered at home, the Mumbai
Home heroes: Nitish put on attacking masterclass, while the wily Bhuvneshwar struck when it mattered most. B. JOTHI RAMALINGAM mathematical hopes of Indians batters will be hop-
making the Indian Premier ing to make merry, for a
came down to two runs off put on 134 off 82 balls by attack. Travis Head, who League Playoffs up in the change. The onus will be
IPL-17 the last ball. He trapped treating the bowlers with scored 18 runs off 17 balls in air. on veteran Rohit Sharma
the big-hitting Rovman Po- contempt and playing the first six overs, was The Knight Riders – on to set the tone against
V.V. Subrahmanyam well leg-before to trigger strokes all over the park. lucky to survive when a the other hand – will look Mitchell Starc.
HYDERABAD celebrations in the stands SRH skipper Pat Cum- slash off the first ball of the to solidify its position as a Despite Starc succumb-
and in the team’s dug out. mins’ third and fourth ov- innings from Trent Boult clear second-placed team ing to the price-tag pres-
Bhuvneshwar Kumar Earlier, Bhuvneshwar ers, during which he just flew past Parag at back- with its seventh win of the sure, Rohit’s woes against
turned out to be the hero, produced a dream first ov- picked up the wickets of ward point. season. left-arm pace have come to
striking the big blows er, sending back Impact Parag and Dhruv Jurel Soon the left-hander The only solace that the fore repeatedly this
when it mattered most, to Player Jos Buttler and San- without being expensive, switched gears, and in the Hardik Pandya and Co. will season.
help Sunrisers Hyderabad ju Samson for ducks to put the home team back in company of the free-strok- have is the Knight Riders’ Rohit and Ishan Kishan
pull off a sensational one- make an early dent to the hunt. ing Nitish Kumar Reddy (76 poor record while bowling will have to come out all
run win over table-topper Royals’ hopes, who were Earlier, the in-form not out, 42b, 3x4, 8x6), at its den. The conditions guns blazing to match the
Rajasthan Royals, in an IPL chasing 202 for a win. opener Abhishek Sharma pulled and lofted leggie then one over extra-cover for the third wicket and an at the Wankhede and Eden onslaught of their Knight
match at the Rajiv Gandhi But the visitors stayed in and Anmolpreet Singh fell Yuzvendra Chahal for two off pacer Sandeep Sharma unbeaten 70 with Heinrich Gardens are quite similar, Riders counterparts – Sunil
Stadium here on Thursday. the hunt when the young cheaply as the home team sixes in the ninth over. to show his class. Klaasen (42 not out, 19b, with flat decks, short boun- Narine and Phil Salt – who
With 13 runs needed off guns Yashasvi Jaiswal (67, scored just 37 for two in Later, Nitish hit two Nitish’s two crucial 3x4, 3x6) — saw Sunrisers daries and dew making life have been taking virtually
the last over bowled by 40b, 7x4, 2x6) and Riyan the PowerPlay against a huge sixes and a four in stands — 96 (57 balls) with come back strongly and miserable for bowlers with every opposition attack to
Bhuvneshwar, the match Parag (77, 49b, 8x4, 4x6) disciplined Royals bowling Chahal’s third over and Head (58, 44b, 6x4, 3x6) breach the 200-run mark. every passing over. pieces.
We were muddled and inaccurate Super Kings, blowing hot and cold,
with bat and ball, says Fleming face a steep climb to the playoffs
S. Dipak Ragav batting order reflected the
CHENNAI confused thinking. After
losing Shivam Dube in the
At the core of Chennai Sup- ninth over, the team pro-
er Kings’ metronomic con- moted Ravindra Jadeja to
sistency in the IPL has been four despite having Moeen
its ability to have a clear Ali, who can be aggressive
game-plan and stick to it, against pace and spin. Jade-
even in the face of adversi- ja also struggled at number
ty, and not be reactive. But four in the home match
the team’s journey in 2024 against LSG, coming ahead
has been anything but that. of Dube. The all-rounder
CSK has blown hot and has often been more effec-
cold, unable to string to- In hot water: CSK has deviated from its philosophy and struggled. tive when coming lower
gether a series of good re- S.R. RAGHUNATHAN down toward the final
sults. When it wins, it dom- phase of the innings. Mitch-
inates the tie from start to er to qualifying when they dited for reviving Shivam ell, who finally found form
finish. But at the same had three successive Dube’s career by providing at number three in the pre-
Dube. S.R. RAGHUNATHAN time, it has meekly surren- matches at home. Howev- clarity on his role, the same vious game, was shunted
dered in defeats and ap- er, the five-time winner lost cannot be said for some down.
Sankar Narayanan E.H. Punjab Kings. turn the ball.” much over. We have an as- peared to be behind the the plot with two defeats others this year. It has The team has also unde-
CHENNAI “They got good pur- He also backed Ajinkya sessment period which we eight-ball throughout, and will need to get its act struggled to get its combi- rutilised Moeen, wasting an
chase and we just got sti- Rahane’s timid approach want those two (openers) showing it has been out- together in the remaining nation right, from bench- overseas slot on a player
Chennai Super Kings fled through the middle in the PowerPlay. to do. So, we’re fine with played. After its fifth defeat four fixtures. ing Rachin Ravindra after a who is not getting a chance
coach Stephen Fleming overs… we were muddled “I thought he was good. the role Rahane plays,” of the campaign — and the For a team famed for its few quiet outings to persist- to make a mark with bat or
said the pitch getting ea- and inaccurate with bat He was probably too ag- Fleming added. fifth straight reverse philosophy of consistency ing with an underperform- ball. Going forward, CSK
sier to bat in the second in- and ball,” Fleming said on gressive in terms of what PBKS batter Rilee Ros- against Punjab Kings — on in selection and playing to ing Ajinkya Rahane. can ill-afford to waste re-
nings and the rival spin- Wednesday. he was trying to do. We souw lauded skipper Sam Wednesday, the defending its strengths, it has deviat- The outfit has also been sources and need to quick-
ners winning the “Every match we played have to pause to see what a Curran’s brave call to give champion faces a steep ed from this philosophy unable to identify the right ly identify its core group if
middle-overs battle in the has been wet. Our spin- good score is. the penultimate over to climb to make the playoffs. and struggled to nail its slots for Daryl Mitchell and it hopes to get its title de-
first essay proved crucial ners have had no impact “If you’re three for 30 leg-spinner Rahul Chahar Super Kings had a gol- combination. Moeen Ali. fence campaign back on
in his side’s heavy loss to because they could not then the game is pretty with M.S. Dhoni on strike. den chance of getting clos- While CSK has been cre- Against PBKS, the team’s track.
CM A IN-X
YK
THE HINDU
Friday, May 3, 2024 17
Chennai
Sport
Good, but...Though proving his worth as a ‘designated’ finisher, T20 WORLD CUP
Rinku does not find a place in the World Cup squad. FILE PHOTO India captain Rohit Shar-
Amol Karhadkar ma has revealed that
MUMBAI Washington Sundar and R.
O
the last slot of a fourth
fining aspects of spinner before zeroing in
nothing wrong’ India’s squad for
the T20 World Cup is the
inclusion of four spinners
on Axar Patel’s all-round
skills.
“We discussed it a lot,
Amol Karhadkar est thing that we had to dis- and just three specialist whether to have an off-
MUMBAI cuss, frankly. He has done pacers. India captain Rohit spinner or not. Unfortu- Samson. PTI
nothing wrong, nor has Sharma has owned up to nately Washi hasn’t played
His family was ready to Shubman Gill, for that mat- the change in strategy, a lot of cricket lately, thanks to his consistent
burst firecrackers. But, it ter. It’s the combinations. stressing that he sought hasn’t been getting an op- outing in the IPL.
was not to be. We are not quite sure what four spinners to the selec- portunity and it was then Chief selector Ajit Agar-
Instead of celebrating conditions we’ll get, so we tors, anticipating slower between Ash and Axar,” kar has explained the ra-
their son’s selection for the wanted to try and have conditions in the West In- Rohit said here on tionale behind preferring
T20 World Cup, Rinku enough options,” Agarkar dies and the USA. Thursday. Samson as the second
Singh’s parents were sur- said here on Thursday. “I definitely wanted four wicketkeeper in place of
prised at his omission from “There are a couple of spinners. We have played a Axar bowling well K.L. Rahul. According to
India’s provisional squad. spinners (Chahal and Kul- lot of cricket there. We “Ashwin hasn’t played the
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
Agarkar, Rahul’s prefe-
Since his debut for India deep) that were included in know what the conditions format (T20Is) lately as rence to bat as an opener
in the shortest format in the squad to give Rohit are like. The match starts Inside view: Rohit and Agarkar reveal the thinking behind selecting the squad for the marquee event. well for a long time. Axar went against him.
August last year, Rinku, a more options. It’s just un- at probably 10-10.30 in the EMMANUAL YOGINI was in real good form “KL is a terrific player.
‘designated finisher’, has fortunate. I don’t think it’s morning, so there is a little since 50-over World Cup We were looking at some-
been dismissed only four anything to do with Rinku bit of technical aspect in- can bat — Axar (Patel) and the T20Is since India’s was a bit of challenge to when he played that five- one who bats in the mid-
times in the 11 innings he Singh.” volved in this. I wanted Jaddu (Ravindra Jadeja) — semifinal exit from the not get swayed by indivi- match series against Aus- dle. At the moment, he is
has batted in the National “It’s not his fault that he four spinners for sure, and and then the two attacking 2022 edition, the think- dual performances in the tralia. He was the player of batting at the top,” Agar-
blues. Despite emerging as has missed out. It’s the 15 — three seamers and Hardik spinners, Kuldeep (Yadav) tank preferred to include IPL while finalising the the series, so he has been kar said.
a reliable finisher, Rinku with two keepers who are (Pandya) being the fourth and (Yuzvendra) Chahal, three specialist pacers in combination. bowling well.
has been overlooked with both terrific batters and an one,” Rohit said, with chief give you a little bit of ba- the XI. “We had a fair idea of “He has been bowling Batting down the order
the selectors preferring to extra batter sitting out, selector Ajit Agarkar seat- lance in your spin depart- “Based on the opposi- what we were looking for. well in the format and has “Sanju, we like to believe,
add all-rounders Axar Patel whoever doesn’t play — that ed next to him, in a media ment as well.” tion composition and con- In IPL, you keep track of done well for India. We has the ability to come
and Shivam Dube. As a re- gives us the best balance. interaction at the BCCI Ever since the ploy of ditions, we can decide who fitness levels of players, considered all of it and down the order, if need
sult, the left-hander has to We thought another bow- headquarters here on going in with four spinners to play. There is a good but if you start getting that left-handed option, if be. Rishabh (Pant) is bat-
be content as a travelling ling option might be handy Thursday. failed miserably during the chance Kuldeep and Cha- swayed by three-four we have to send someone ting down the order for
reserve. going forward in the tour- T20 World Cup in 2021, In- hal can play together. weeks of cricket, there is in the middle to do so- Delhi Capitals.
Ajit Agarkar, the chair- nament. He is still one of Getting the balance dia has relied on playing There is a good chance something wrong in your mething different.” It’s about the slots we
man of the national selec- the travelling subs. That’s “You get that balance of three specialist pacers both left-arm spinners can thinking. Besides Axar’s addition needed. We felt these two
tion panel, admitted it was how close he was. It’s a lit- seamers as well, and then, along with Hardik, the all- play along with Kuldeep or “All performances are as the fourth spin-bowling are better and have spent
a harsh call without the tle bit tough on him, but at you know, the spinners as rounder, in a majority of Chahal, so all sorts of noticed and it will help us option, the selectors final- more time down the order
player’s fault. the end of the day, you can well. Obviously, two spin- T20Is. Even when Hardik things are possible.” in the future anyway,” ly gave Sanju Samson the which might be needed at
“It’s probably the tough- only pick 15.” Agarkar said. ners being all-rounders was the captain for most of Agarkar admitted that it Agarkar said. nod for a World event, the World Cup.”
South Africa women Feisty Dortmund outmuscles PSG in the first leg
to tour India CHAMPIONS LEAGUE
day, when the French
champion will need to
hardest early in the second
half, when Mbappe hit the
Lavanya L South Africa’s third ever. overturn the result if it’s go- right post before Achraf
Associated Press
CHENNAI The T20Is are likely to be ing to capture Europe’s big- Hakimi struck the left post.
DORTMUND
staged on July 5, 7 and 9. gest prize before Kylian Gregor Kobel saved
The Indian women’s team Niclas Fullkrug scored and Mbappe leaves the club. Mbappe’s next effort and
An official confirmation Borussia Dortmund earned PSG is under pressure to
will host the Laura Wol- of the tour is awaited from Dortmund survived the
vaardt-led South African a 1-0 win over Paris Saint- finally win to the Cham- pressure.
the Board of Control for Germain in the first leg of pions League to justify
team in a multi-format se- Cricket in India (BCCI). Fullkrug went on to miss
ries in June-July 2024. their Champions League more than a decade of further good chances for
semifinal on Wednesday. huge investment from its the German team, while
The ODI leg of the se- Second women’s Test Qatari owners.
Dortmund defender Ni- Marquinhos made a crucial
ries will be held in Benga- Chennai will be hosting a co Schlotterbeck sent a Dortmund’s win en- block to deny Julian Brandt
luru at the M. Chinnaswa- women’s Test for the se- long pass over the top for sured it qualified for the late on.
my Stadium while cond time after November Fullkrug to control bril- tournament next season
Chennai’s M.A. Chidamba- 1976 when India took on Ousmane Dembele
liantly with his first touch and it gives the Bundesliga
ram Stadium will be the the West Indies. The should have scored on his
before firing it past PSG five teams in the expanded
venue for the one-off Test match ended in a draw. return to Dortmund when
goalkeeper Gianluigi Don- tournament. Dortmund is
and three T20Is. he blazed a shot over late,
After the South Africa narumma with his next in assured of finishing at least
The Test has reportedly series, India will head to the 36th minute. fifth. then Vitinha flashed a shot
been scheduled from June the Asia Cup in Sri Lanka It gives Dortmund a nar- wide of the left post.
Defender Lucas Hernan-
28. and the T20 World Cup in row advantage before the dez went off injured after The result: Semifinal, first leg:
It will be India’s third Bangladesh in September- teams play again in the se- trying to stop Fullkrug Borussia Dortmund 1 (Fullkrug
Test in six months and October. Slick finish: Fullkrug gives Dortmund a slight advantage with this strike against PSG. REUTERS cond leg in Paris next Tues- from scoring. PSG pushed 36) bt Paris Saint-Germain 0.
Sport Chennai
e6fcf1ba-47bb-4e5e-a12b-0876de505fce
SHASHI SHEKHAR KASHYAP & GETTY IMAGES
Y.B. Sarangi and I wanted to make a comeback as 2024 myself. I have been trying to avoid the mistakes I THE GIST
was an important year because of the “My fitness level is much better now, made in the past.
hree more years of experience, Olympics. I stayed positive, I thought if the my body is in good shape. After coming “I can feel the difference. My strength