Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Module 5 (Design of Normal Concrete Mixes)
Module 5 (Design of Normal Concrete Mixes)
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
• To achieve the workable concrete mix • Concrete mixes can be designed by using any of the
• To obtain a cohesive mix which offsets the possibility of following methods
bleeding, segregation and honey combing.
• British D.O.E. Method of Mix design
• To achieve durability for particular site conditions and • American Concrete Institute’s mix design procedure
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
• British D.O.E. Method of Mix design • British D.O.E. Method of Mix design
• The British method of concrete mix design, popularly STEP NO. 1 Determination of Target Mean Strength
referred to as DoE method, is used in UK and other parts • M= k x s
of world. • Where, k = a value appropriate to the % age defectives
permitted below the characteristic strength
• Originates from the Road Note No 4, published in Great • s = the standard deviation
Britain in 1950.
• The value of k is taken as :
• In 1975, the note was replaced by the Design of Normal • k for 10% defective = 1.28
• k for 5% defective = 1.64
Concrete Mixes, published by the British Department of • k for 2.5% defective = 1.96
Environment. • k for 1% defective = 2.33
Figure: Normal Distribution of concrete strength
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
• British D.O.E. Method of Mix design • British D.O.E. Method of Mix design
Example of Calculation of Standard Deviation
STEP NO. 1 Determination of Target Mean Strength
• Mean strength:
• Because of the variability of concrete strength during
production, the mix must be designed to have a • This is the average strength obtained by dividing the sum
considerably higher strength than the specified of strength of all the cubes by the number of cubes.
characteristic strength.
• where
• This is done by an amount termed as margin, which is • x = mean strength
obtained by using the relation: • Σx = sum of the strength of cubes
• n = number of cubes.
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
• British D.O.E. Method of Mix design • British D.O.E. Method of Mix design
Example of Calculation of Standard Deviation
STEP NO. 1 Determination of Target Mean Strength
• Standard Deviation:
• fm = fc + M
• This is the root mean square deviation of all the results.
• Where, fm = the target mean strength This is denoted by s or σ.
• fc = the specified characteristic strength
• where
• M = the margin • σ = Standard deviation,
• n = number of observations
• The value of the margin (M) can be derived from the
• x = particular value of observations
calculation: • x- = arithmetic mean
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
• British D.O.E. Method of Mix design • British D.O.E. Method of Mix design
Example of Calculation of Standard Deviation STEP NO. 2 Determination of water cement ratio
• British D.O.E. Method of Mix design • British D.O.E. Method of Mix design
STEP NO. 2 Determination of water cement ratio STEP NO. 3 Determination of water content
• From Table 1 corresponding to the type of cement, type of • Table 2 corresponding to the maximum size of coarse
coarse agg. and specified age, the appropriate value of
strength (at w/c ratio of 0.5) is obtained. aggregate and specified slump, the value of water content
is obtained.
• From Fig. 2, a point corresponding to this strength at a w/c
ratio of 0.5 is marked.
• Through this point, a curve ‘parallel’ to the neighboring
curves is drawn. Using this new curve, the w/c ratio
corresponding to the specified target mean strength is
obtained.
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
• British D.O.E. Method of Mix design • British D.O.E. Method of Mix design
STEP NO. 2 Determination of water cement ratio STEP NO. 3 Determination of water content
Table: 1 Approximate compressive strengths (N/mm2) of concrete mixes Table: 2 Approximate free water contents required to give various levels of workability
made with free w/c ratio of 0.5
Slump (mm) 0-10 10-30 30-60 60-180
Compressive Strengths (N/mm2)
Type of Coarse Vebe Time (s) > 12 6 -12 3–6 0-3
Type of Cement
Aggregate
Age (days) • Maximum Size of Type of
3 7 28 91
Aggregate (mm) Aggregate
Ordinary Uncrushed 22 30 42 49
Uncrushed 150 180 205 225
Portland Cement 10
Crushed 180 205 230 250
or Sulphate
Crushed 27 36 49 56 Uncrushed 135 160 180 195
Resisting 20
Portland Cement Crushed 170 190 210 225
Rapid Hardening Uncrushed 29 37 48 54 Uncrushed 115 140 160 175
40
Portland Cement Crushed 34 43 55 61 Crushed 155 175 190 205
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
• British D.O.E. Method of Mix design • British D.O.E. Method of Mix design
STEP NO. 3 Determination of water content STEP NO. 5 Determination of Total aggregate content
• Note: When coarse and fine aggregate of different types • Knowing the water content and cement content, the total
are used, the free-water content is estimated by the aggregate content is determined by using the relation:
expression:
• Total aggregate content = D – Wc - WFW
• 2/3 Wf + 1/3 Wc
• Where:
• Where: • D = the wet density of concrete (kg/m3)
• Wf = water content appropriate to type of fine agg. • Wc = the cement content (kg/m3)
• Wc = water content appropriate to type of coarse agg. • WFW = the free-water content (kg/m3)
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
• British D.O.E. Method of Mix design • British D.O.E. Method of Mix design
STEP NO. 4 Determination of cement content STEP NO. 6 Determination of Fine & Coarse aggregate content
• Cement is determined by dividing the water content • This step involves deciding how much of the total
obtained in Step (3) with the w/c ratio obtained in Step (2). aggregate should consist of material smaller than 5 mm, i.e
• The value obtained should be checked against any fine aggregate content.
maximum or minimum cement contents that may have • The F.A content of concrete is estimated by reference to
been specified. Fig. 4, which relates the amount of F.A as a %ge of the
• If the cement content as calculated above is below a total aggregate content to the w/c ratio for different values
specified minimum, this minimum must be used. of workability, max. size of aggregate and grading of F.A.
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
• British D.O.E. Method of Mix design • British D.O.E. Method of Mix design
STEP NO. 4 Determination of cement content STEP NO. 6 Determination of Fine & Coarse aggregate content
• On the other hand, if the calculated cement content is • The coarse aggregate content is then simply obtained by
higher than a specified maximum, then the specified subtracting the fine aggregate content from the total
strength and workability cannot simultaneously be met aggregate content.
with the selected materials.
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
DOE MIX DESIGN PROCEDURE
Example:
• British D.O.E. Method of Mix design
STEP NO. 6 Determination of Fine & Coarse aggregate content • Using the D.O.E method of mix design, compute the batch
quantities required for a cubic meter of concrete to suit the
following data:
• Characteristic cube strength is 30 MPa at 28 days with 5%
defective rate.
• Type of cement: Ordinary Portland Cement
• Coarse aggregate: Crushed of max. size 20 mm
• Fine aggregate: Natural river sand (uncrushed) confirming to
grading zone II
• Desirable slump: 50-75 mm
• Standard deviation = 6 N/mm2
Fig: 4 (a) Recommended proportion of fine aggregate according to percentage passing
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
600µm sieve
30 28
5
6
1.64 1.64 6 9.84
30 9.84 39.84
30 28
5
6
1.64 1.64 6 9.84
30 9.84 39.84
crushed
uncrushed
STEP NO. 2 Determination of water cement ratio STEP NO. 5 Determination of total aggregate content
As,
Total aggregate content = D – Wc - WFW
30 28
Where:
5
D = the wet density of concrete (kg/m3)
6
Wc = the cement content (kg/m3)
1.64 1.64 6 9.84
WFW = the free-water content (kg/m3)
30 9.84 39.84
Therefore,
crushed
Total aggregate content
uncrushed
= 2400 – 205 – 360
0.57 Use this value
= 1835 Kg/m3
-
STEP NO. 3 Determination of Free water content STEP NO. 6 Determination of fine and coarse
aggregate content
Table 3. Approximate Free-Water Contents (kg/m3) required to
give Various Levels of Workability
Slump (mm) 0-10 10-30 30-60 60-180 Free-water content Fine aggregate content = Total
Vebe Time (s) > 12 6 -12 3–6 0-3 = 2/3(195) + 1/3(225)
Maximum Size of Type of
aggregate content x proportions of
= 130 + 75 fines
Aggregate (mm) Aggregate
Uncrushed 150 180 205 225 = 205 kg/m3
10
Crushed 180 205 230 250
And,
Uncrushed 135 160 180 195 Coarse aggregate content = Total
20
Crushed 170 190 210 225
Uncrushed 115 140 160 175
aggregate content – fine aggregate
40 content
Crushed 155 175 190 205
Note: When coarse and fine aggregate of different types are used, then free-water content is
estimated by the expression
2/3 Wf + 1/3 Wc
Figure 6. Recommended Proportions of Fine Aggregate
Where: Wf = free-water content appropriate to type of fine aggregate
According to Percentage Passing 600 m sieve
Wc = free-water content appropriate to type of coarse aggregate
DOE MIX DESIGN PROCEDURE
STEP NO. 6 Determination of fine and coarse ACI Method of Mix Design
aggregate content
Data to be required for the design of the mix
2 Before starting the mix design process, the following
37% - 44% use 40.5%
material properties should be determined:
0.405 1835 743
1835 743 1092 Specific gravity of cement
Fineness modulus of selected Fine Aggregate
Unit weight of dry rodded coarse aggregate
Sp. gravity of coarse and fine aggregates in SSD condition
Absorption characteristics of both coarse & fine aggregates
Assuming a trial mix of 0.05 m3 to be used using aggregate with ACI Method of Mix Design
saturated surface dry condition for this example
The ACI mix design procedure can be divided into the
The required amount for each material for this volume is listed in following steps:
the final line of this mix design form.
Choice of slump
Maximum aggregate size selection
Mixing water and air content estimation
Determination of Water-cement ratio
Determination of Cement content
360 205 743 1092 Determination of Coarse aggregate content
0.05 18 10.25 37.15 54.6 Determination of Fine aggregate content
Adjustment for aggregate moisture
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
This method of mix design, widely used in the USA, Step 1: Choice of Slump
was first published in 1944 by ACI committee 613
Select the slump of concrete depending on the type of
In 1954 the method was revised to include, among other construction and the degree of workability
modifications, the use of entrained air
If slump is not specified, a value appropriate for the
In 1970, the method became the responsibility of ACI work can be selected from Table 1
committee 211 As a general rule, the lowest slump that will permit
adequate placement, should be selected
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
ACI Method of Mix Design ACI Method of Mix Design
Step 1: Choice of Slump Step 3: Estimation of Mixing water and Air content
Table 1. Recommended Slumps for Various Types of Construction
Determine the amount of mixing water required for air
entrained or non-air entrained concrete for the selected
slump and maximum size of coarse aggregate from
Table 2.
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
Step 2: Selection of Maximum Aggregate size Step 4: Determination of water cement ratio
These restrictions limit maximum aggregate size to 40 Find the minimum water-cement ratio based on the
mm (1.5 inches), except in mass applications dual criterion of durability and strength using Tables 3
and 4.
Generally for RCC work 20 mm and prestressed
concrete 10 mm size are used
Note: Aggregate larger than these dimensions may be
difficult to consolidate & compact resulting in a honey-
combed structure or large air pockets.
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
ACI Method of Mix Design ACI Method of Mix Design
Table 3. Maximum Permissible W/C Ratios for Different Types of Structures and Degrees of Exposure
Step 6: Determination of Coarse aggregate content
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
Once the water content and w/c ratio is determined Determine the amount of fine aggregate.
from steps 3 and 4, the amount of cement per unit
If the weight of concrete per unit volume is assumed,
volume of the concrete is found by dividing the
the required weight of fine aggregate is simply the
estimated water content by the w/c ratio.
difference b/w the weight of fresh concrete and the
i.e. Cement content = Water content / Water cement ratio total weight of all other ingredients.
This cement content should not be less than the cement
An estimate of weight of fresh concrete can be made
content required based on durability or some other
criterion. either by using the following Equation (1) or Table 6
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
ACI Method of Mix Design ACI Method of Mix Design
ρ = 10 γa (100 - A) + C (1 – γa / γ ) – W (γa - 1) … 1(a) (kg/m3) Example: Using the ACI method, design a concrete mix
ρ = 16.85 γa (100 - A) + C (1 – γa / γ ) – W (γa - 1) … 1(b) (lb/ft3) for construction of internal columns of a building. The
where, specified strength of concrete is 30 MPa at 28 days
ρ = density (unit weight) of fresh concrete, kg/m3(lb/ft3) measured on standard cylinders. The size of the column
γa = weighted av. specific gravity of combined fine & coarse agg. sections and the spacing of the reinforcement require a
A = air content, percent slump of 50 mm (2 in.) and a maximum size of aggregate
C = cement content, kg/m3(lb/ft3) of 20 mm (3/4 in.). The specific gravity of Fine &
γ = specific gravity of cement ( generally 3.15) Coarse aggregates are 2.65 and 2.70 respectively. The
W = mixing water requirement, kg/m3 (lb/ft3)
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
Adjust the mixing water quantity and proportions of Select the slump of concrete depending on the type of
fine and coarse aggregate based on the surface construction and degree of workability. If not given, an
moisture and absorption capacity in the aggregate. appropriate value may be chosen from Table 1
Check the calculated mix proportions by means of trial The slump of 50 mm (2 inch) is given, which is
batches and make some adjustments in the mix consistent with Table 1.
proportions, if necessary.
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
ACI Method of Mix Design ACI Method of Mix Design
Step 1: Choice of Slump Step 3: Estimation of Mixing water and Air content
Table 1. Recommended Slumps for Various Types of Construction
From Table 2, the mixing water content for non air-
entrained concrete with a slump of 50 mm (2 in.), and
a maximum size of aggregate of 20 mm (3/4 in.) is
190 kg/m3 (315 lb/yd3)
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
Step 3: Estimation of Mixing water and Air content Step 4: Determination of water cement ratio
Determine the amount of mixing water required for air Find the water-cement ratio based on the dual criterion of
entrained or non-air entrained concrete for the selected durability and strength using Tables 3 and 4.
slump and maximum size of coarse aggregate from Table Adopt the lower value out of strength and durability
2. consideration.
Since there are no special exposure conditions,
From Table 3, based on the exposure/durability
Ordinary Portland cement will be used without air
conditions, the estimated w/c ratio is 0.5
entrainment.
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
ACI Method of Mix Design ACI Method of Mix Design
From Table 4, for non air-entrained concrete, the Find the amount of cement per unit volume of the
concrete by dividing the estimated water content by the
estimated w/c ratio is 0.55 for an average strength of
w/c ratio.
30 N/mm2
Thus, Cement content = 190 / 0.5
Therefore, adopt w/c ratio of 0.5
= 380 kg/m3
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
Step 6: Determination of Coarse aggregate content Step 7: Determination of Fine aggregate content
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
Step 7: Determination of Fine aggregate content Step 7: Determination of Fine aggregate content
Determine the amount of fine aggregate. Thus,
If the weight of concrete per unit volume is known, the the weight of fine aggregate = 2355 – 190 – 380 – 992
required weight of fine aggregate is simply the difference
= 793 kg/m3
b/w the weight of fresh concrete and the total weight of all
other ingredients. Alternatively, the weight of fine aggregate can also be
An estimate of weight of fresh concrete can be made found out by absolute volume method which is more
either by using Table 6 or using the Equation (1). accurate and is given by,
Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon Prepared By: Prof. Dr. Fareed Ahmed Memon
Thus,
the absolute volume of fine aggregate = 1000 – 698.04
= 301.96
Therefore,
the weight of fine aggregate = 301.96 x 2.65
= 800.19 say 800 kg/m3