Professional Documents
Culture Documents
UNIT 2 and 3
UNIT 2 and 3
Introduction
The Building and Other Constructions Workers (Regulation of Employment and
Conditions of Service) Act, 1996 hereinafter referred to as the “BOCW Act” is a
social welfare statute enacted by the Indian government to provide a safe and
healthy working environment for the workers engaged in construction activities. This act
watchdog the employment and working conditions of the building and other
constructions for workers and it aims to provide welfare measures for the
construction workers. The ambit of BOCW Act in India is wide because countries
like India where the construction sector rises with a pace, there are many
workers engaged in this sector and to safeguard their interest the presence of
this legislation is a must.
Act
In India, more than 80 crore workers, whether skilled or unskilled are engaged
in the construction sector. The construction industry is majorly labour-intensive,
and most of the workers are unskilled, unorganized and generally work in
inhuman and miserable conditions. These construction workers are part of the
vulnerable segments of the unorganized sector in India. In order to address
these inhumane working conditions, ill-treatment, poor facilities, poor health,
and necessary safety measures in the construction sector, the government
enacted the Building and Other Construction Workers (Regulation of Employment
and Conditions ,of Service) Act, 1996.
Giving construction workers their due
Most of the construction workers are educated, unskilled, migrants,
socially backward, and have low bargaining power, so the employer usually
looted them by giving fewer wages for the work they did. Also, construction
workers tend to work with uncertain working hours with an inherent risk of
life. Section 45 of BOCW Act, 1996 deals with the responsibility of the employer
for the payment of wages and compensation to each construction worker
employed by him and if the employer, in any case fails to comply with this
section, then he is liable to pay compensation to the workers employed by him
in full or the unpaid balance which is due in accordance with Section 8 of the
Workmen Compensation Act, 1923.
Is it mandatory to take registration under BOCW
Section 7 of the BOCW Act, 1996 talks about the registration of an
establishment. Before explaining the provision mentioned in this section, we
have to know something about establishments. Section 2(1)(j) of BOCW Act,
1996 defines ‘establishments’ as, an establishment belongs to any firm or
organization or body of corporations or individuals or associations or
government, who employs construction workers for any construction site, is said
to be an establishment, but those constructions whose value or cost of such
construction is less than 10 Lakhs rupees would not become under this
definition. -Now, Section 7 of the BOCW Act, 1996 deals with the provisions
related to the registration of establishments. It says that every employer of the
construction work shall make an application to the registering officer for
registration of such establishment. The applicant shall make an application for
registration:
Section 8 of the BOCW Act, 1996 deals with the revocation of registration. It
says that if the registering officer is satisfied by the reference made to him in
this regard or if any employer of an establishment obtained a certificate of
registration by misrepresenting the material facts or an establishment has not
complied with any provisions mentioned under this legislation, a registering
officer after giving a fair opportunity to the employer to represent his case may
revoke the registration.
Different states in India have their welfare schemes for the workers having
BOCW cards. Section 13 of the BOCW Act, 1996 talks about identity card issues
to the beneficiaries i.e. workers working in a building or at any construction site
by the board. Every state offers various facilities or initiates multiple welfare
schemes for the workers having BOCW cards or working in the construction
sector. Some of the welfare schemes or benefits offered by different State
Governments are as follow:
o Ministry of Labour and Employment: They enacted schemes
on life and disability cover, skill development, health and
maternity cover, education, pension, housing, awareness
programs.
o Punjab government: Stipend Scheme, LTC Scheme, Funeral
Assistance Scheme, Ex-gratia Scheme, Maternity Benefit
Scheme, General Surgery Scheme, Denture, Cycle Scheme for
Construction Workers as well as for Children, Spectacles &
Hearing Aid Scheme, Shagun Scheme, Reimbursement of
expenditure for Dangerous Ailments, Tool Kit Scheme, Bhagat
Puran Singh Sehat Bima Yojna (BPSSBY), Pension Scheme, Balri
Birth Gift Scheme, Skill upgradation & Vocational Education
Scheme, Mobile Lab Scheme.
o Assam government: Death benefit, cash award, general
pension, disability pension, advance for purchase or construction
of house, education institution, marriage assistance, family
pension, educational assistance, medical assistance, funeral
assistance, health check up, maternity benefit, loan for the
purchase of tools, coverage under Pradhan Mantri Jeevan Jyoti
Bima Yojana (PMJJBY) & Pradhan Mantri Suraksha Bima Yojana
(PMSBY).
For example, if the total cost for construction of a building is Rs. 1 Crore then
the total amount of cess is one percent of 1 Crore i.e. Rs. 1 Lakh.
State legislations
As already mentioned in this article, every state offers various facilities or
initiates multiple welfare schemes for the workers working in the construction
sector. Also Section 4 of the BOCW Act, 1996 empowers the State Government
to constitute a State Advisory Committee which is called as ‘State Building and
Other Construction Workers’ Advisory Committee to advise the State
Government on the matters related to the administration of this act.
Now, what the government of the states and Union Territories can do is to utilise
the remaining cess funds for the welfare of construction workers during the
pandemic and also by implementing those unutilised funds for the upliftment of
corona warriors like doctors, medical staff, police, etc.
Scope of improvement
In 2013, the Ministry of Labour and Employment presented The Building and
Other Construction Workers Related Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2013 before Rajya
Sabha to amend the grey areas present in the BOCW Act, 1996. This bill has
presented the scope of improvement in this legislation. The salient features of
this bill are:
Also, there is already a large gap between the registered construction workers
with the welfare boards and the estimated number of construction workers
engaged in the construction sector. If we talk about the data, less than 50% of
estimated construction workers are registered with such welfare boards. This
New Labour Code will lead to the shutdown of 29 State and 8 Union Territories’
BOCW boards and the construction workers will have to again register
themselves with the respective state welfare boards. These newly formed state
welfare boards will also take other unorganised sector workers under its ambit
and all these workers would be listed in the same place. Also, the cess funds
which have been collected for the construction workers would be merged with
the social assistance fund.
If the new Labour Code is enacted, it would be beneficial for the construction
workers because the scope of welfare measures would be increased in the
construction sector, and also it would provide the overall benefit to the labour
class engaged in the labour sector of the Republic of India.
Conclusion
It is commendable that the Indian government has made social welfare
arrangements for the long-neglected construction workers, but there have been
some grey areas left in the statute which requires clarification and enforcement
until the judiciary has stepped in to resolve the matter. Section 2(1) (i) of the
BOCW Act defines ‘employer’ and includes both contractor and owner of the
construction site under its ambit. Hence, the contractor and owner start shifting
their liability and responsibility to one another. Also, the State Governments
have to be accountable for the unutilized cess collected fund and must
implement the remaining funds for the welfare of construction workers.
The persistence of Covid-19 pandemic has expedited the misery of India's working
population. It came to light that more than 90% of the Indian population is employed
in the unorganised sector and they neither have access to social security nor
minimum wages despite them contributing an approximate of 60% to the Indian
GDP.
Salient Features:
The Act mentions about constitution of a National Social Security board and
State Social Security Board which will give recommendation for formulation of
suitable schemes which later shall be monitored and reviewed.
The UWSS Act has laid down provisions wherein it registers and issues a
smart identity card with a unique number to the unorganised sector worker.
The Record Keeping function will be performed by the District Administration.
The Workers Facilitation Centres will disseminate the available data on the
social security schemes, facilitate the filing-processing and forwarding of the
registration application with the assistance of the district administrator.
The act in its Schedule I has laid down a list of the Social Security Schemes
to ensure that the workers of the unorganised sector meet their basic needs
and that they have a decent standard of living.
In India, the social security laws have derived their basis from Part IV of the Directive
Principles of State Policy (DPSP). The Social security and Labour Laws form a part
of the concurrent list therefore both, the Central and the State Governments are
approved to make laws for the same. It is the obligation of the state to lay down
provisions which grant social security to organised as well as unorganised sector
workers.
Another purpose of the act is to ensure that the needs of the workers employed in
the unorganised sector are addressed as it contributes to the sustainable economic
growth in the country. Apart from Social security the needs include availability of
credit, upskilling, use of modern technology, infrastructure and the requirement of a
contractual obligation between the employer and employee.
Several schemes under the Act depend on State-level nodal agencies for functioning
of its Schemes and in times like the national health crisis these labour laws and
policies not only provide social security for the workers but help the economy from
deteriorating. Recently, the state of Uttar Pradesh promulgated Uttar Pradesh
Temporary Exemption from Certain Labour Laws Ordinance, 2020 which shall
suspend a majority of the acts and schemes under UWSS for a period of three
years.
The Covid-19 pandemic has highlighted the need for additional legal safeguards and
welfare measures for the unorganised workers especially the migrant workers and
domestic workers as they are in dire need of social security more than ever.
Critical Analysis
The UWSS Act is a significant initiative taken by the government to address and
provide remedy to the plight of the workers engaged in unorganised sector for the
first time, the act has also enlisted several welfare schemes which can be availed by
the workers.
There are certain inadequacies in the act which complicates the implementation
process at the same time infringes rights of the unorganised workers. The scope of
the definition of unorganised workers is narrow and excludes forest and fish
workers, domestic workers, cross-border provisional workers, and aanganwadi
workers etc.
It is important to note that, the act has not defined the term social security and
hence it is not justiciable. The act has laid down several social security schemes but
has not included them within the body of the act.
The act places the unorganised workers in an odd position as, if they fail to make the
deposits in time, they are disentitled from the benefits without considering the
contingencies that come along which renders the process of contribution
complicated.
Recommendations:
Conclusion
Social security is an important part of the development at all the levels of the existent
society and leads it towards a better social and economic growth. To enable these
workers to gain maximum benefit from the schemes an effort must be to make them
aware of their rights.
Gig Workers
They have a non-standard work arrangement with their employers and share
a non-traditional employer-employee relationship.
The work is usually temporary and completed within a stipulated time.
The Code on Social Security, 2020 [Section 2(35)] defines a gig worker
as ‘a person who performs work or participates in a work arrangement
and earns from such activities outside of traditional employer-employee
relationships.’
Freelancers, contingent workers, independent contractors, etc. can come
under the umbrella of gig workers. Even a part-time professor can be
classified as a gig worker.
Platform Workers
INTRODUCTION
Registration is the process of recording a document with a recognized officer and
to safeguard its original copies (See Here). Any document whether binding or
non-binding shall be registered in a required manner. Registration of every
document is not necessary but doing so affirms the authenticity and helps in
avoiding legal process. Many people are not familiar with the concept of
registration and hence, do not understand its importance in eyes of law. It is
crucial to be familiarized with registration and what it includes to avoid disputes.
There are two kinds of registration according to The Registration Act, 1908
namely “Mandatory Registration” and “Optional Registration” which have been
explained below. Apart from them, a person going for registration should also
know the following:-
MANDATORY REGISTRATION
Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act, 1908 provides for mandatory
registration of certain documents. Those are as follows:-
OPTIONAL REGISTRATION
But not all documents have to be registered. Section 18 provides for optional
registration of some documents such as:- (See here)
1. Adoption Deed
2. Instrument relating to shares in joint stock company
3. Debentures issued by joint stock company
4. Will
5. Lease of immovable property not exceeding 1 year
6. Document of a past transaction
7. Power of Attorney with respect to movable property
8. Decree or order of court comprising an immovable property valued
below Rs. 100
9. Certificate of Sale granted
10. Agreement of Mortgage
11. Promissory note
12. Instrument of partition by Revenue Officer
13. Grant of immovable property by Government
Application for such a step has to be made to Sub-Registrar who will forward
such application to the Registrar to whom he is a subordinate (Section 25 of The
Registration Act, 1908). If a document is executed outside India by any or all of
the parties and is presented after expiry 4 months then it will be accepted for
registration provided that it was executed and presented for registration within 4
months after its arrival to India (Section 26 of The Registration Act, 1908).
WHERE TO REGISTER?
In case of documents regarding immovable property, it shall be presented for
registration in the office of Sub-Registrar within whose district the property or
part of it is located (Section 28 of The Registration Act, 1908). In case of all
1. some person executing or claiming under the same, or, in the case of a
copy of a decree or order, claiming under the decree or order, or
2. the representative or assignee of such a person, or
3. the agent of such a person, representative or assign, duly authorized
by power-of-attorney executed and authenticated in the manner
hereinafter mentioned.
Every person presenting a document for registration shall affix his passport size
photograph along with fingerprints to the document. In a case where a
document is related to transfer of ownership of immovable property, passport
size photographs and fingerprints of all the buyers and sellers mentioned in the
document shall be affixed (Section 32A of The Registration Act, 1908).
In case of a will or authority to adopt, the testator or after his death any
executor may or a donor or after his death the donee or adoptive son may
present it to the Registrar or Sub-Registrar for registration respectively (Section
40 and Section 41 of The Registration Act, 1908). It shall be registered if it is
satisfied that:-
CASE LAWS
In Narinder Singh Rao v. Air Vice Marshal Mahinder Singh Rao (2013) settled by
Supreme Court, the Appellant’s father wrote on a piece of paper that his wife
would inherit the property on his death. It was signed by a single witness and
was not registered. After the father’s death, his widow executed a will,
transferring the entire property to only one of her nine children. The aggrieved
siblings challenged the mother’s will in court, stating that she had not inherited
the entire property because the father’s will was invalid. The argument was
accepted, stating that for a will to be valid, it must be attested by two witnesses.
Besides, it could not be held as a valid transfer of property as it was not
registered under the Indian Registration Act, 1908.
So, the Supreme Court held that the rule of succession would apply in dividing
the property as the father’s will was invalid. This case recapitulated two rules
which have been clearly set out in legislation. They are: (See Here)
For this case, an application was moved by a man before the Sub-Registrar
(Registration) to cancel the registration of extinguishment deed executed by the
Society cancelling an allocation of the plot. Persecuted by the rejection of his
application, on the ground that Sub Registrar has no domain to cancel the
enrollment of a registered document being referred to, he moved toward
Inspector General (Registration) which was in vain.
The High Court, on its writ petition, held that, since the Registering Officer
selected the deed acquainted with him for registration, his ability is exhausted
and he would then advance towards becoming functus officio (an officer or
agency whose mandate has expired either because of the arrival of an expiry
date or because an agency has accomplished the purpose for which it was
created. When used in relation to a court, it may also mean whose duty or
authority has come to an end) and no vitality to appropriate the report under
Section 33 of the Act. This decision by the High Court was condemned in the
Supreme Court.
The appeal in Part XII especially under Section 72 limits just to the refusal of
Registering Officer to register a document. It was similarly held that power given
to Registrar under Section 68 can’t be used to cross out registration of a
registered document.
Moreover, the court observed that there is no express course of action in the
Registration Act or Rules bound by the State of Madhya Pradesh nor any circular
issued by the competent authority of the State of Madhya Pradesh with the goal
that the extinguishment deed should bear the characteristics of both the vendor
and the buyer and both must be accessible before the Registering Officer when
the document is presented for registration. (See Here)
CONCLUSION
Therefore, it can be seen that registration of a document is of utmost importance
and must be done as soon as possible otherwise it would lead to long years of
legal battle which is costly and time consuming.
3.2 ‘Employers obligation towards Employee
Every employee, labour or workman at the workplace has been granted
many rights and privileges by different statutes under law, the same rights
result in corresponding duties for the respective employers, thus along with
rights to employees, law has also assigned certain duties to the employers in
order to ensure a harmonious relationship between the employers and
employees and increase the efficiency of work at the respective workplace.
An important point that must be noted is that this Act shall cover only that
establishments which have employed 20 or more contract labourers in any
day of the preceding 12 months.
MISCELLANEOUS DUTIES
The employer also has the duty to keep a check on the contractor and his
operations and his history, he also has the duty to check if the contractor
possesses a valid licence or registration under the act.
Section 19 of the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention) Act 2013 lays down the
duties of the Employer to ensure protection of his or her women employees –
The Section lays down the basic obligations which the employers need to
follow to ensure the safety of the female workforce, these obligations include
INDUSTRIES.
The employer in case of a COAL MINE shall have the following duties –
Medical Aid
Railway Facilities
Declaration of the process of filling vacancies
Declaration of the process of transfers
Production of Service Certificate
CONCLUSION
In addition to all the above duties and obligations the employer cannot
escape from the basic duty of protecting the rights of the employees, be it
permanent or contractual. Fulfilling and protecting the rights of the
employees and the workmen who contribute towards the interests of the
employer.
3.3 Occupational and Health Law
Ensuring the safety and health of employees in the workplace is a priority for many businesses.
Occupational Safety and Health (OSH) law helps to ensure that employers are providing safe
working conditions for their employees. In this article, we will explore OSH law and what it means
for businesses and their workers.
This includes providing adequate protection against hazards such as dangerous chemicals, toxic
substances, extreme temperatures, hazardous machinery, electrical shocks, slips and falls. OSH
laws also require employers to take measures that will help prevent workplace accidents and
ensure prompt medical treatment if an accident does occur.
The main purpose of OSH law is to reduce the risk of workplace injuries or illnesses by
implementing various safety procedures in order to create a safe work environment. By doing so,
it helps businesses avoid costly lawsuits while ensuring the health and well-being of their
employees at the same time.
As such, it's important for employers in each jurisdiction where they operate understand which
specific regulations they must comply with. Generally speaking,however, OSH applies equally
across all business sectors regardless of size or industry. All employers have a duty under OSH
law to provide a safe working environment free from recognized hazards likely cause death or
serious physical harm.
Ensuring that all workers wear personal protective equipment when necessary; this could
be anything from hard hats on construction sites through respirators when dealing with
hazardous materials
Establishing emergency plans should any type of incident occur; this could involve having
clear evacuation routes marked out within buildings, providing fire extinguishers etc
Making sure appropriate training has been given before any new piece of equipment is
introduced into the workplace
Providing regular medical check-ups if required
Reporting any incidents which result in employee injury or death
Keeping accurate records related to employee injuries/illnesses
Implementing hazard identification processes
Conclusion
Occupational Safety & Health laws are designed protect both employees' business owners alike;
these regulations help ensure safe working conditions while at same time reducing risk
expensive lawsuits. It's essential for businesses understand what their obligations are under
relevant legislation; failing adhere such requirements can lead hefty fines even prison sentences.
To avoid this happening, employers must create comprehensive safety plans audit effectiveness
thereof on regular basis. Doing so will not only help keep staff members safe but also
demonstrate commitment towards creating healthy work environment - something sure pay
dividends future!
3.4-Constitutional Values And Labour Welfare
It was the Factories Act of 1881 which paved the way for the foundation of
series of labour laws with the objective of bringing improvements in the
working conditions of labours. The International Labour Organization (ILO) in
its founding year, in 1919, recognised the importance of labour in the
economic and social reconstruction of the world and suggested some changes
in labour welfare schemes operating in India. The then government of the
day, subsequently, enacted the Factories Act of 1922, which provided for the
cap of 60 hours a week and 11 hours a day for both men and woman. The
minimum age for child worker was set at 12.
Article 39, 39A, 41, 42, 43 and 43A collectively can be termed “Magna Carta
of working class in India.”
Article 14 commands State to treat any person equally before the law.
Article (19) (1) (c) grants citizens the right to form association or unions.
Article 39(a) provides that the State shall secure to its citizens equal right to
an adequate means of livelihood.
Article 39A provides that the State shall secure the equal opportunities for
access to justice to its citizens and ensure that such opportunities are not
denied by reason of economic or other disabilities.
Article 41 provides that within the limits of its economic capacity the State
shall secure for the Right to work and education.
Article 42 instructs State to make provisions for securing just and humane
conditions of work and for maternity relief.
Article 43 orders the State to secure a living wage, decent condition of work
and social and cultural opportunities to all workers through legislation or
economic organisation. And
The principle of ‘equal pay for equal work’, which meant equal pay for
everyone irrespective of sex, was deducible from preamble and Articles
14,16 and 39(d) of the Constitution. The principle of equal pay for equal
work w as held to be applicable to cases of unequal scales of pay, based on
classification or irrational classification, though both sets of
employees(engaged on temporary and regular basis, respectively) performed
identical duties and responsibilities.
Article 38(1) enjoins the State to strive to promote the welfare of the people
by securing and protecting as effective as it may a social order in which
justice- social, economic and political shall inform all institutions of the
national life. In particular, the State shall strive to minimise the inequalities
in income and endeavour to eliminate inequalities in status, facilities and
opportunities.Art.39 (d) enjoins a duty to see that there is equal pay for
equal work for both men and women and this directive should be understood
and interpreted in the light of the judgement of this court in Randhir Singh
v.Union of India (1982).
The jurisprudence developed through these two case laws was recently
applied by the Apex Court in the case of State of Punjab v.Jagjit
Singh6 (2016) where it held that temporarily engaged employees(daily
wage employees, ad‐hoc appointed on casual basis , contractual employees
and the like),are entitled to minimum of the regular pay scale, along with
dearness allowance(as revised from time to time )on account of their
performing same duties, which are discharged by those engaged on regular
basis, against sanctioned posts.